Recap 05/28/1991 RNOTICE:
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA
Tuesday, May 28, 1991
9300 a.m.
ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON ANY
REGISTER PRIOR TO SPEAKING.
AGENDA ITEM MUST
REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON SUBJECTS WHICH ARE NOT
ON THIS AGENDA MUST BE SUBMITTED IN WRITING WITH
EXPLANATION TO THE COUNTY MANAGER AT LEAST 13 DAYS PRIOR
TO THE DATE OF THE MEETING AND WILL BE HEARD UNDER
"PUBLIC PETITIONS" IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING THE ADVERTISED
PUBLIC HEARINGS. ~
ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS
BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING
THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A
VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD
INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE
APPEAL IS TO BE BASED.
1. INVOCATION
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANC~
3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA AND CONSENT AGENDA
A. Approval of consent agenda.
.~ ~ B. Approval of Clerk's Report.
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
April
9, 1991 - regular meeting.
Approved w/changes.
Approved and/or adopt.
5/0
Approved. 5/0
Approved. 5/0
PROCLAMATIONS AND SERVICE AWARDS
A. $erv$ce Awards
Byron "Skip" Camp - Facilities Management - 10 years
Presented.
Be
roc a~___~
1. The Year of Cultural Encounters.
Nancy Olson and Tina Osceola.
To be accepted by
2. National Safe Boating Week. To be accepted by
Captain Alan Marsden, Florida Marine Patrol.
Adopted. 5/0
Adopted. 5/0
1
May 28, 1991
6. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS - BCC
A. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENTS
B. ZONING AMENDMENTS
(1)~ Petition R-90-37, George L. Varnadoe, Young, Van Ord. 991-42 adopted a~
/ Assenderp, Varnadoe & Benton, P.A., representing amended and with con-
Point Marco Development Corporation (Jack Antaramian, dition.~ 4/1 (Cmsr Vo~
President) requesting a rezone from RT to PUD and to ·
amend the PUD currently referenced as Point Marco, opposed.)
PUD Ordinance No. 81-25, as amended by Ordinance
No.'s 81-98 and 90-42 providing for 734 dwelling ~
units and related club uses in Parcel I and a parking
facility on Parcel II for pr6perty located on both
sides of Collier Boulevard at the southern tip
of Marco Island in Secs. 19 and 20, T52S, R26E,
consisting of 33.04 acres. (Continued from the
meeting of 5/21/91).
Petition PDA-89-16, Barbara Henderson Cawley of
Wilson, Miller, Barton and Peek, Inc., representing
Amnon Golan, Trustee for Orangetree Associates,
requesting amendments to the Orangetree PUD located
on the east side of CR 846, Immokalee Road and north
and south of Oil Well Road in Secs. 11, 12, 13, 14,
22, 23, 24, 25, 26, and 27, T48S, R27E.
Ord. 991-43 adopted
subject to Agreement
Sheet. 5/0
(3) Petition R-90-34 (reconsideration), Linda Lawson
representing Andi Pearson and Carol Irving,
requesting a rezone from the C-6 Commercial Infill
District to the C-3, Commercial Intermediate District
for property located on Marco Island on the east side
of South Collier Boulevard, approximately 400 feet
south of Spruce Avenue.
(4) Pg~ition R-90-6, Carl Reich of Smally, Wellford and
~alven, Inc., representing James E. Williams, Jr.,
/and Diane Williams, requesting a rezone from A-1MH
/ and A-2MH to PUD to be known as Arrowhead PUD for 900
\/ residential units and 15 acres of commercial uses for
property located in the southwest quadrant of the
intersection of Lake Trafford Road and the planned
extension of Carson Road in Sec. 31, T46S, R29E, and
Sec. 6, T47S, R29E, consisting of 307~ acres in
Immokalee, Florida.
2
May 28, 1991
Motion for approval
denied due to lack of
4/1 vote. 3/2 (Com-
missioners Volpe and
Hasse opposed)
Ord. #91-44 adopted
subject to Agreement
Sheet. 5/0
C. OTHER
(1) Petition AV 90-007, WinsCo Builders, Inc., as owner,' Res.
requesting vacation of a portion of a five foot (5~) 5/0
drainage easement located on a portion of lots 34 and
35 of the plat of Kelly Plaza as recorded in Pl~t
Book 3, Page 95, of the Public Records of Collier
County, Florida. ,
91-423 adopted.
(2~Petition AV 91-001, C. Perry Peeples as agent for Res. 91-424 adopted.
owner, Donald Hamilton, requesting vacation of a 5/0
portion of the ten foot (10') drainage and utility
easement located on a portion of Tract D of the plat
of Lakeside of Naples at Citrus Gardens as recorded
in Plat Book 15, Pages 83-88 of the Public Records of
Collier County, Florida.
Petition SMP-89-28, Steven Sodemann of Hole, Montes
and Associates, Inc., representing Radio Road Joint
Venture, requesting subdivision master plan approval
for Collier County Production Park, Phase 2 for
property located 200 feet west of Commercial
Boulevard and 1/4± mile north of Radio Road (CR 856)
in Sec. 36, T49S, R25E.
Res. 91-425 adopted
5/0 Subject to stip
Petition SMP-90-34, Dwight Nadeau representing Res. 91-426 adopted.
Highway Pavers, Inc., requesting subdivision master 5/0 Subject to s~ips.
plan approval for Kathleen Court located on the
south side of Seward Avenue between Shirle~ Street
and Yahl Street in'Sec. 11, T49S, R2~E, consisting of
7.07 acres.
(5) Petition CCSL-91-4, Harry Huber, Office of Capital Res. 91-427 adopted.
Projects, representing the Collier County Board of 5/0 Subject to stiDs.
/County Commissioners, requesting a coastal
/construction setback line variance for time extension
/of Resolution No. 90-580 approving re-nourishment,
I/ re-vegetation, and construction of dune walkovers,
~T52S, R26E, Marco Island, Florida.
Petition SMP-90-38, Jeff Purse of Evers and Purse, Res. 91-428 adopted
Inc., representing Dev-Tech Corporation, requesting with additional stips.
3 5/0
May 28, 1991
subdivision master plan approval for "Imperiai
Square" for property located adjacent to and east of
U.S. 41 north of Imperial Golf Course Boulevard in
the southwest 1/4 of Sec. 15, T48S, R25E, Collier
County, Florida, consisting of 12.36 acre¥.
(Continued from the meeting of 5/14/91)
7. BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
A. ADVERTISED PUBLIC ~ARING$
(1) Petition FDPO-91-1, Robert Jocelyne N. and Bonnie Variance request
/Jean DeLestang request~ing a variance from the minimum denied 2/3 (Commsrs.
~base flood elevation as required by Flood Damage Hasse, Shanahan and
~revent~i~n Ordinance (FDPO) Number 87-80 on property
d~scribed as 1281 Belair Court, Lot 61, Gulf Harbor~ Volpe opposed.
as'- recorded in /~t ~ook 4, Page 31, of the Public Res. 91-429 for
Records Of Collier County, _Florida. nonconform~lng use
adopted 3/2 (Commsrs.
Volp~ and Goodnight
.~ opposed~
(2) Petition
A-91-4, Karen A. Ornowski representing
William and Lottie Tedio, requesting an
administrative appeal of the Planning/Zoning
Director's decision that the existing parking to
support a 40 seat restaurant is insufficient, that
the business ceased to operate for a p~riod in excess
of 90 days and further use must conform to the
current zoning standards of the ColIier County Zoning
Ordinance.
Decision upheld with
modification for
35 seat restaurant.
5/0
END OF ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
PROVISIONAL USE
Petition PU-89-26, Bryan L. Weber of SCA Development,
Inc., requesting extension of Provisional Use "b" of
the RMF-12 District for a child care center for
property located on the east side of Airport-Pulling
Road (CR 31) 3/4 mile north of Pine Ridge Road (CR
896) located in the northwest 1/4 of Sec. 12, T49S,
R25E. (Continued from the meeting of 5/21/91)
Res. 91-430 adopted
5/0
(2) Petition
PU-90-2, Richard A. Kennedy of Butler
Engineering, Inc., representing Immokalee Habitat for
Humanity, Inc., requesting an extension of
Provisional Use "d" of the RMF-6 Zoning District for
property located on the east side of 9th Street North
and bordered by Jefferson Avenue and Hendry Street in
4
May 28, 1991
Reso. 91-422 adopted
5/O
Sec. 33, T46S, R29E, Immokalee, Florida.
3) Petition PU-90-7, George F. Archibald of Res. 91-431 adopted
Transportation Services representing the Board of 5/0
County Commissioners, requesting extension of
Provisional Use "b" of the "I" District.
8. PUBLIC PETITIONS
9. COUNTY MANAGER'S REPORT
A. COMMUNITy DEVELOPMENT
(1) Budget Amendment request to establish the Continued to 6/4
/~'.~ Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) Grant for
Grant Year 1991-92. ~
Community Development Division requesting an Res. 91-432 adopted
amendment to Exhibit "B" of Resolution 91-136 to 5/0
correct a scrivener's error in the legal description ~ ·
for property owned by Southern States Utilities
located in Tract "G", Marco Beach Unit Twenty-Five,
containing 7.68± acres.
B. TRANSPORTATION
MOVED ~( 16(B) (
F M 2)
.1) Recommendation to approve an agreement with Liebig Approved w/changes
Investments for roadway and site improvements at the 5/0
Regency Autohaus and Chrysler-Plymouth dealerships on
Airport-Pulling Road.
C. ~UBLIC SERVICES
D. UTILITIES
Agreement between the Orangetree Development, its
successor utility and Collier County.
May 28, 1991
Approved. 5/0
E. ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES
MOVED FROM ~
16(E) (1)
(1) Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
authorize the Chairman to execute a work order under
the annual contract for architectural services wi~h
Victor J. Latavish, Architect, for the design of a
' fire suppression system in Building F.
Continued to 6/4
F. EMERGENCY SERVICES
G. ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
~/ (1) Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
adopt a Resolution to certify a Supplemental
Assessment Roll for mandatory garbage collection fees
for the 1991 service year.
Continued to 6./4
H. COUNTY MANAGER
...... ~ (1) Recommendation that the Board adopt staffs plan of Accepted staff's
action regarding the Wiggins Pass dredge project. recommendations in
executive summary. 5/~
(2) County Government Productivity Committee Sub-committee Repor~ accepted & Cou]
Reports. Mgr to report back on
their imDlementati~on.
5/0
1~/(3) Discussion regarding status of Palmer Cablevision Continued to 6/4
agreement.
) Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
not enter into the proposed lease agreement for leased Continued to 6/4
Growth Management Department office space with the
Collier Development Corporation.
(5) Recommendation for road maintenance program cost
6
May 28, 1991
Continued to 6/4
,/~eductions involving reduction in employees, County
policy revisions for operations, and deferral of
improvements.
MOVED FROM
16(H)(2)(~. Recommendation to approve the vacation on an existing
access easement within Pelican Bay and to accept a
~/ revised grant of easement.
Continued to 6/4
10. COUNTY ATTORNEy'S REPORT
A. Request for Board approval of
Lester horses.
the proposed sale of the
MOVED FROM
16(L) (1)
Recommendation that the Board approve an Amendment to the
Agreement Between Henderson, Young & Company, Inc. and
Collier County for the preparation of Emergency Medical
Services Impact Fee Study and an Amendment to the
Agreement between Henderson, Young & Company, Inc. and
Collier County for the preparation of Parks and
Recreation Impact Fee Study.
Material breach of
Settlement Agreement
Mr. Lester; Cty. Atty~
office to return in 2
weeks with amended Ag~
to include regular in~
pections of horses fo~
12 months after trans~
and County to receive
money for expenses upc
execution of amended
Agree. 5/0
Continued to 6/4
11. CLERK TO THE BOARD'S REPORT
Budget Amendments
(1) Regarding matters not previously discussed: 5
(2) Regarding matters previously discussed: 4
(3) Budget Amendment Resolution No.: NONE
B.A.'S 91-188; 9t-193
and 91-198/199 adopte
5/0
BA's 91-187; 91-192 a
91-195/196 adopted. 5
B. Tabulation of Contracts and Documents (as of noon
previous Tuesday).
Co
Analysis of Changes to Reserves for Contingencies
(1) General Fund (001)
7
May 28, 1991
(2)
(3)
Facilities Construction Fund (301)
Community Development Fund (113)
12. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
A. Appointment of members to the Environmental Policy Res. 91-433 for an
Technical Advisory Board (EPTAB). 1I-member Board. adopte(
5/0
Appointment of members to the
Committee.
Homeless Advisory
Continued to 6/4
Discussion regarding support for resolution re
acquisition of Fi$ch property. (Commissioner Goodnight)
13. OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
14. BOARD 0F COUNTy COMMISSIONERS' COMMUNICATIONS
Continued to 6/4
15. STAFF COM/4UNICATIONS
CONSENT AGENDA
All matters listed under this item are considered to be
routine and action will be taken by one motion without
separate discussion of each item. If discussion is desired
by a member of the Board, that item(s) will be removed from
the Consent Agenda and considered separately.
A. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
(1) Water facilities acceptance for Cracker Barrel Old
Country Store.
8
May 28, 1991
Approved and/or Adopt~
5/0:
w/stips
(2) Recommendation to approve for recording the final
plat of "Caxambas Estates - Replat".
(3) Recommendation to approve for recording the fin41
plat of "Bass Point".
~)Recommendation to approve a Resolution for
/declaration of a common nuisance, Compliance Services
/Case No. 91-03-03397. Owners of record - Helen
V Weinfield Co., Trs., and Lester and Mary E. Persky.
Res. 991-389
(5) Recommendation to approve Lien
following:
Resolutions for the
(a) Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00939.
of record -Blanca M. Adorno.
Owner
(b) Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00525.
Owners of record - Robert Ralph Atkins and
Carolyn A. Atkins.
Res. 991-390
Res. ,~91-391
/ (c) Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00183. Owner
of record - Jay A. Craven.
~(d) Compliance Services Case No. 90-12-14935. Owners
of record - Erva Mae Graham and Pansy Mae Graham.
~(e) Compliance Services Case No. 90-12-14938. Owners
of record - Monroe Graham and Erva Jennings.
Res. #91-392
Res. #91-393
Res. %91-394
~/~f) Compliance Services Case No. 90-12-14827. Owner
of record - Marco Media Enterprises.
..... ~~~(g) Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00474. Owners
of record - Don Hutchison and Karen Hutchison.
9
May 28, 1991
Res. ~91-395
Res. #91-396
~ ~h) Compliance Services Case No. 90-12-14583. Owners
of record - Edward J. Pelc and Laverda L. Pelc. ~
ompliance Services Case No. 91-01-00709. Owner
~/ of record - W. D. Roberts.
Res. %91-397
Res. ~91-398
('~Compliance Services Cas~ No. Z89-11175 and
Z89-11176. Owners of record - Frances G. Tukes,
a life estate, with remainder in Gloria J.
Andrews Canty.
ompliance services case No.
f record -Blanca M. Adorno.
91-02-01190. Owner
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00789.
of record - Silas Bacon.
Owner
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00806.
of record - Robin Riley Burch.
Owner
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00920.
of record - Robin Riley Burch.
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00810.
of record - Alphonso Campbell.
Owner
Owner
Res. %91-399
Res. %91-400
Res. ~, 91-401
Res. #91-402
Res. %91-403
Res. %91-404
/) Compliance Services No. 91-01-00406. Owners of
record - Valentin Campos, Jr., and Irma Campos.
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00877.
of record - Elizabeth Chambers.
Owner
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00816.
of record - Victory Claridy.
Owner
10
May 28, 1991
Res. %91-405
Res. %91-406
Res. a91-407
Compliance Services Case No. 91-02-01647. Owner
of record - William D. Collins, III, Trustee f~r
Florida Sunbelt Properties Trust. ~'
Res. ~91-408
/~(t) Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00903. Owner
of record - Community Corp.
)
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00925.
of record - Community Corp.
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00839.
of record - Ismael Cruz and Nidia Cruz.
)
Compliance Services Case No. 90-11-13115.
of record - Herman F. Groeger.
Owner
Owners
Owner
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00820.
Owners of record - James and Clara M. Gadsden.
Res. #91-409
Res. ~91-410
Res. #91-411
Res. ~91-412
Res. 991-413
~/~(y) Compliance Services Case No. 91-02-01723. Owner
of record - A. B. Grassi.
Res,. ~91-414
Compliance Services Case No. 90-09-08610. Owner
of record - Quality Construction Group of Naples,
Inc.
Res. #91-415
Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00798.
of record - O. L. Snyder and Lucile Snyder.
Owners
~ (/~bb) Compliance Services Case No. 91-01-00801. Owners
'~~_cord - O. L. Snyder and Lucile Snyder.
Tomszay.
11
May 28, 1991
Res. ~91-416
Res. #91-417
Res. #91-418
(dd)/C~pliance Services Case No. 91-02-01480. Owners
record - Alex Weisenbacher, Patricia R~
Mikelson, and Robert Richter, Trustee. ~
Recommendation to accept the security for Excavation
Permit No. 59.420 "Pelican Bay System V" located in
Sec. 33, T48S, R25E.
B. TRANSPORTATION
(1) This item has been deleted.
MOVED TO
9(B) (1)
(2) Recommendation to approve an agreement with Liebig
Investments for roadway and site improvements at the
Regency Autohaus and Chrysler-Plymouth dealerships on
Airport-Pulling Road.
Res. #91-419
Deleted.
Moved to 9(B)(1)
C. PUBLIC SERVICES
(1) Request that the Board of County Commissioners
approve the cooperative effort to Master Plan
Barefoot Beach Park (Collier) and Bonita Beach Park
(Lee), approve the Conceptual Master Plan, authorize
staff to enter into an Interlocal Agreement with Lee
County, and approve Consultant Engineers for this
project.
D. UTILITIES
WITHDRAWN:
(1) Award Contract for Construction of Water, Sewer and
Effluent Lines on Immokalee Road, Bid #91-1674
2/Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
/ approve and authorize the Chairman to execute the
/ Resolution and the Utility Easement to the Collier
V County Water-Sewer District as necessary to provide a
utility effluent line to the Pelican Bay'area.
Withdrawn
Res. %91-420
(3)/~A~solution designating the Assistant Utilities
Administrator as signee, during the absence of the
Utilities Administrator, for the Collier County
Water-Sewer District, the Marco Water and Sewer
District and the Goodland Water district for
12
May 28, 1991
Res. %91-421
execution of permits, grant applications and othe~
miscellaneous documents related to Utilities matters
E. ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES
MOVED TO
9(E) (1)
(1) Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
authorize the Chairman to execute a work order under
the annual contract for architectural services with
Victor J. Latavish, Architect, for the design of a
fire suppression system in Building F.
Moved to 9(E)(1)
(2) Recommendation to approve and execute an agreement
for sale of motor vehicle fuels with the Collier
County School Board.
F. EMERGENCY SERVIC$$
.G. ENVIRONM~NTAL SERVICES
(1) Recommendation to approve mid-year adjustments to
~. ~ Water Management operation budget (Fund 110).
(2) Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
approve Certificates of Correction to the Mandatory
Solid Waste Collection Special Assessments Roll and
authorize the Chairman to sign the Certificates on
behalf of the Board of County commissioners.
H. COUNTY MANAGER
\
(1) Recommendation to execute and accept a subordination
// of Utility interests from Florida Power and Light
Company of Florida concerning the Naples Production
Park Municipal Services Taxing Unit.
MOVED TO
9 (H) (6)
(2) Recommendation to approve the vacation on an existing
access easement within Pelican Bay and to accept a
revised grant of easement.
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
approve and accept the Amendment to the Grant of
Easement to provide access to and from water
management facilities located in Pelican Bay Nit 2
13
May 28, 1991
Moved to 9(H)(6)
consisting of a portion of parcels M, N & O as well
as a portion of Pelican Bay Unit 12 parcel G-C within
the Pelican Bay development in accordance with the
Pelican Planned Unit development Ordinance 77-18, as
amended by Ordinance 8296. ~
BOARD OF ~OUNTY COMmISSIONeRS
MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE
Certificate for Correction: NEED MOTION authorizing
the Chairman to sign CertifiCate for Correction to
the tax rolls as presented by the Property
Appraiser's Office. RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
K. OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
L. COUNTY ATTORNEY
MOVED TO
lO(~)
(1) Recommendation that the Board approve an
Amendment to the Agreement Between Henderson, Young &
Company, Inc. and Collier County for the preparation
of Emergency Medical Services Impact Fee Study and an
Amendment to the Agreement between Henderson, Young &
Company, Inc. and Collier County for the preparation
of Parks and Recreation Impact Fee Study.
Moved to 10 (B)
17. ADJOURN
14
May 28, 1991