Agenda 03/23/1999 R
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
~
AGENDA
Tuesday, March 23, 1999
9:00 a.m.
NOTICE: ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON ANY AGENDA ITEM MUST REGISTER
PRIOR TO SPEAKING. SPEAKERS MUST REGISTER WITH THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
PRIOR TO THE PRESENTATION OF THE AGENDA ITEM TO BE ADDRESSED.
REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON SUBJECTS WHICH ARE NOT ON THIS AGENDA
MUST BE SUBMITTED IN WRITING WITH EXPLANATION TO THE COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR AT LEAST 13 DAYS PRIOR TO THE DATE OF THE MEETING AND WILL
BE HEARD UNDER "PUBLIC PETITIONS".
ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A
RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO
ENSURE THAT A VERBA TIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD
INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED.
-
ALL REGISTERED PUBLIC SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO FIVE (5) MINUTES UNLESS
PERMISSION FOR ADDITIONAL TIME IS GRANTED BY THE CHAIRWOMAN.
ASSISTED L1STEI\ING DEVICES FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABLE IN THE
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' OFFICE.
LUNCH RECESS SCHEDULED FOR 12:00 NOON TO 1:00 P.M.
1. INVOCATION - Reverend George Locldwrt, First Baptist Church of Golden Gate
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
3. APPROVAL OF AGENDAS
A. APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA.
B. APPROVAL OF SUMMARY AGENDA.
c. APPROVAL OF REGULAR AGENDA.
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Febmary 23,1999 - Regular meeting.
5. PROCLAMATIONS AND SERVICE AWARDS
A. PROCLAMA TIONS
I
March 23. J 999
-
1) Proclamation p.-oclaiming weel,; of March 28 - AIU'il 3, 1999 be designated as
Diversity Week. To be accepted by Ms. Hope BrOI)h~', Chair of Naples Branch of
the Amel'ican Association of Universit~' Women's Dh'ersity Committee
2) Pl'oclamation proclaiming weel. of March 21-27, 1999 be designated as Master
Gardener Appreciation Wee I. in Collier Count~'. To be accepted b~' Ms. Naida
Eisenbud, Mr. Earl Garrett, Mr. Elmer Hahn and Mr. Tom Porter, Master
GardenCJ's, Colliel' Count~/Uniycrsit~ of Florida Extension
3) Proclamation proclaiming the month of April as Focus on Education Month. To be
accepted b~' Ms. Carol Conwa~, Co-Chair of EDC Economic Foundations
Committee. Also, present are representatiYCs from the collier Count~' Public
Schools, Naples Area Chamber of Commerce, Collier County Education Foundation
and Junior Achieycment
B. SERVICE AWARDS
1) Diane Day-Deoss, DOR - 10 ~ears
2) Scott Conley, Water - S ~ears
3) Isaac Dennis, Road and Bridge - S years
4) John Drur~', Aiqwli Authorit~ - S years
5) John Jones, Libnu'y - S years
6) B:lIi Sanders, Water - S ~ears
7) Saint Saintil, Road and Bridge - S ~ears
c. PRESENTATIONS
6. APPROVAL OF CLERK'S REPORT
A. ANALYSIS OF CHANGES TO RESERVES FOR CONTINGENCIES.
1) To present the Celiificate of Achieycment for Excellence in Financial
Repoliing to the BO:lrd of Count~' Commissioners for the Fiscal Year ended
Septemher 30,1997.
2) To presl.'nt to the Board of County Commissioners the Comprehensh'e Annual
Financi:ll RepOl't for the Fiscal Year ended September 30,1998.
7. PUBLIC PETITIONS
A. Jo~' Lelonel., Executiyc Director of the United A\is Council of Collier County requesting
financial suppOli.
B. Request to :ldopt a Resolution declaring a need for an educational facilities authorit,y to
function in Collie\' County, Flol'id:l; :lUthorizing the authorit~, to transact business and
exercise powers under the act; designating and approving the members thereof; providing
an effectiyc date.
,-
8. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT
2
March 23. 1999
A. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
1) Connie D. Stegall-Fullmer, representing Goodland Civic Association,
requesting a waiver of Tempor:lr~' Use Permit fee for an event held on March 6
and 7,1999, on Goodland, Collier County, Florida.
B. PUBLIC WORKS
C. PUBLIC SERVICES
D. SUPPORT SERVICES
E. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
1) Presentation of Impl'O\'ed and Expanded "Collier Serves" Program Initiati"e.
2) QU:lIierl~' capital project status l'epOli.
F. AIRPORT AUTHORITY
9. COUNTY ATTORNEY'S REPORT
A. Recommendation for the Boal'd of Count~' Commissioners to settle the case of Eve~lm
Field v. Collier COUI1(l', C;lse No. 98-3183-CA-01, now pending in the Circuit Court for
the Twentieth Judicial Circuit, Collier County, Florida for S39,750.00 Illus payment of
Mediator's fees in an approximate amount of S300.00.
10. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
A. Discussion regarding Sheriff's Office operations/administration facilities
(Commissioner Constantine).
B. Appointment of memhers to the Hispanic Affairs Ad\'isory Board.
C. Appointment of memhe\'S to the Immokalee Enteqlrise Zone Development Agenc~'.
D. Appointment of memhers to the Tourist Development Council.
E. Apllointment of member to the Radio RO:ld Beautification Advisor~' Committee.
F. Recommendation to declare a vacancy on the Golden Gate Beautification Adyisory
Committee.
G. AJlpointment of members to the Count~ Go\'Crnment Productiyit~ Committee.
H. AJlJlointment of membel's to the Cont ractors Licensing Board.
11. OTHER ITEMS
A. OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
1)
Request tr:lIlsfer of S2,982,100 from General Fund Resen'es to the Resen'es of the
She\'iff's Office.
~-
B. PUBLIC COMMENT ON GENERAL TOPICS
,
,)
March 23, 1999
PUBLIC HEARINGS WILL BE HEARD IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING STAFF ITEMS
12. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS - BCC
A. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENTS
B. ZONING AMENDMENTS
1) CONTINUED FROM THE MEETING OF FEBRUARY 23, 1999. Petition
PUD-82-16(l) Karen Bishop of PMS, Inc. of Naples, rcprescnting Henry
Krehling, to I'ezone lands no,," zoned PU D to a new PUD to comply with the
sunsctting 11I'o\isions of thc Land Dewlopment Code, lmd to add commercial
and light industrial uses to the list of authorized uses and to update the PUD
Document and Master Plan to CUITent land de\clopmcnt code rcquirements,
for propel1y generally located southeast of the interscction of U.S. 41 and Old
U.S. 41, 'h milc east of U.S. 41 at the eastern terminus of Wiggins Pass Road, in
Section IS, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
2) CONTINUED (NO DATE) - ORIGINALLY CONTINUED FROM THE
MEETING OF FEBRUARY 23, 1999. Pctition PUD-98-13, R. Bmcc Andcrson
of Young, \':1Il Assendcrp & Varnadoe, P.A., representing Collier Development
Corporation, requesting a rezone for lands zoned "A" Rural Agriculture and
"PU D" Planned lJ nit Dnclopment "PU D" to "PUD" for a ncw "PUD" Planned
Unit Dewlopment to be known as Collier Tract 21, formel'l~' Beachway PUD,
for a golf course and acccssor~ and incidental facilities including a clubhouse,
SO,OOO square feet of C-3 commcrcial uses and/or a hotel on prope\iy locatcd
between U.S. 41 on the east and Vanderhilt Drive on the west, I~'ing north of
Ill") A \enue and south of thc Cocohatchee River, in Scction 21, Township 48
South, Range 25 East, Collier COllnt~, Florida consisting of 267.44 +
C. OTHER
1) Din'ct staff to amend an Ordinance as it relates to the Parl.s and Recrcation
Ad\isol'y Board.
13. BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
A. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
B. OTHER
14. STAFF'S COMMUNICATIONS
15. BOARD OF COllNTY COMMISSIONERS' COMMUNICATIONS
16, CONSENT AGENDA - All matters listed under this item are considered to be routine and
action will be tal.cn by one motion without separate discussion of each item. If discussion is
desired by a member of the Board, that item(s) will be removcd from the Conscnt Agenda and
considercd separately.
A. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
-+
March 23. 1999
1) Resolution opposing House Bill 11925 and Scmlte Bill 13S2, relating to
ratemaking 11I'o\'isions of ill\'estOl'-owned watcl' and wastcwatcr utilit~, s~'stems,
heforc the 1999 I'egular session of the Flol'ida Lcgislature.
2) Request to grant final acceptance of the I'oadwa~', drainage, watcr and sewer
impro\'ements for the final plat of "Quail West Phasc III, Block K. Lot 97"
3) Request to appro\'(' 1'01' recording the final plat of "Creekside Commcrce Park
West - Unit Two" and appro\'al of the performance securit~,.
4) This item has been deleted.
5) Authorization to award Bid #99-2912 "White Lakc COfJlOrate ParI.
Infrastl"Ucture ImprO\ements" ano authorize staff to initiate an agreement with
Harper Bros., Inc., of Ft. M~ers, Florida.
6) Re<}uest to approve for rccording the final plat of Pebblebl'ool.c Lakes Phase 3
and approval of the peri'ormance security.
7) Lien Rcsolutions - Code Enforcement Case Nos. 80720-120 - Tropicana Homes
at Marco Inc.; 80722-057 - Luis Alfredo & Patricia Ann Can'ajal; 80813-047-
Flora Acosta; 809(1)-01)8 - Daniel Liy
B. PUBLIC WORKS
1) Re<luest appl'o\'al to use funds from Waste Tire Grant to pl'O\'ide safety pla~'
sUlface at Everglades City Puhlic Pla~gl'Ound.
2) This item has hcen deleted.
3) Approve Budget Amcndment recognizing carry fonnlrd amounts from FY 98
for road projects in funds 313,331,333,334,336,338,339 & 340.
4) Appro\'(' an Agreemcnt with Immokalee Disposal, Inc, to continue providing
I'ecycling sel'vice for multi-famil~' residential units and authorize the
Chain\'oman to sign the Agreement.
5) Award Bid #98-2880 for B"c1d'low Sen'ices.
6) Ohtain Board apprO\al to amend the Collier County' Rcclaimed Water S)'stcm
Ordin:mce.
7) Approve the dclction of the Backdoor Service Olltion from the Automated Solid
Waste Curhside Collcction Program with the cxception of cases of mcdical
necessit~.
8) Award a Contract to Lightlll'r Contracting, Inc. for Bid No. 99-2915, Bcach
Maintenance Acth,ities.
9) Adopt a Resolution re\'ising thc eligihility for memhershil) on the Naples Beach
Renou rishment/M aintenance Comm ittee.
10)
Authorize usc of the Charlotte Count~ Trenchlcss Pipc Rchabilitation Bid No.
97-254.
_.
5
March 23, 1999
11) Rescind the Award of a Contract to Allied Trucldng of Flodda, Inc./C.B.E.
Trucking Company, Inc. for Bid No. 98-2900 and Amll'd a Contract to Douglas
N. Higgins, Inc. for the Transp0l1 and Placement of Bench Fill Matcrial.
12) Appro\'al to administratin.'ly adjust the non-ad \':lIorem assessment for Parccl
Number 11 in the Naples Production Park M.S.T.U.
13) Appro\'e Amendment 7 to Professional Sel\'ices Agrcemcnt with Hole, Montes
& Associates, Inc. for engineering ser\'ices relatcd to Impro\'emcnts at the
South Count~ Watel' Reclamation Facility, RFP 93-2121, Projcct 73916.
H) Approw pa\'ing thc limerock pOliion of POJ1Cr Street in rcsponse to citizens'
request.
C. PUBLIC SERVICES
1) This item has been deleted.
2) Appro\'al to fund thc .t1h of July Festh'al and Firewol".s Show.
3) Appro\'e the purchase of pla~ground equipment for Eagle Lakes Communit)'
Park.
4) ApprO\al of two (2) Interlocal Fund Sharing Agreements with the Cit), of
Naples and thc City of Ewrglades.
5) Apprmal of budget amendmcnt recogni/,ing an additional S.t8,C.37 in State Aid
to Lihraries in FY 91).
D. SUPPORT SERVICES
1) Add Asset #9.t0024, a Ford Aerostar Van, to the March 27, 1999 Auction List.
2) Award Bid 9S-2903 for Laboratory' Chemicals nnd Supplies.
3) Appro\'al of a Contract hetwecn Collier County and Communit~, Health
Panners.
.t) Appro\'al of a Budget Amcndmcnt to Propeliy & Cnsualty Insur:lnce Prognlm
Fund.
5) Recommend to Award Bid #99-2913 for Contract Pdnting.
E. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR
1) Budget Amendment Repol.t - #99-171 & #99-182
F. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
G. MISCELLANOUES CORRESPONDENCE
1) Miscellaneous items to file for rccord with action as dirccted.
H. OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFlCERS
()
March 2], 1999
1) Request fOl' appro\'al for the purchase of replacement desktop computer
s~'stems for the Collier County Sheriff's Office from Dell Comlluters under the
terms and conditions of State of Florida Contract #250-040-99-1.
L COUNTY ATTORNEY
J. AIRPORT AUTHORITY
17. SUMMARY AGENDA - THIS SECTION IS FOR ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS AND
MUST MEET THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA: 1) A RECOMMENDATION FOR APPROVAL
FROM STAFF; 2) UNANIMOUS RECOMMENDATION FOR APPROVAL BY THE COLLIER
COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION OR OTHER AUTHORIZING AGENCIES OF ALL
MEMBERS PRESENT AND VOTING; 3) NO WRITTEN OR ORAL OBJECTIONS TO THE ITEM
RECEIVED BY STAFF, THE COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION, OTHER
AUTHORIZING AGENCIES OR THE BOARD, PRIOR TO THE COMMENCEMENT OF THE BCC
MEETING ON WHICH THE ITEMS ARE SCHEDULED TO BE HEARD; AND 4) NO
INDIVIDUALS ARE REGISTERED TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE ITEM.
A. Petition OSP-98-1, Da\'e Sneed of Kuhlman Engineering, repl'esenting Azar GalleD',
requesting appro\'al for 20 off-site parking spaces on Lot 26, and the west half of Lot
25, Blocl. B, Naples Villas to se!'\'e an existing commel'cial facilit~' on Lot 1, Block B,
Naples Villas and which is located on th(.' northeast comer of AirJlOli-Pulling Road
(CR-3l) and Poinsettia Avenue, in Section 1, Township SO South, Range 25 East.
B. Petition V-99-1, Richard D. YO\anO\ich representing Coastal Beverages LTD.
requesting a 17.8 foot \'al'iance from thc required SO foot front ~ard to 32.2 feet for the
proposed expansion of a warehouse complcx apprO\'ed in 1992. The subject property is
located at 4747 Progress Aycnue in Scction 30, Township 49 South, Range 25 East,
Collier County, Florida.
C. Petition VAC 99-004 to \'acate the 25' wide drainage easement on Lot 4, the 25' wide
drainage easement on Lot 5 and the remaining 12' wide drainage easement on Tract A,
according to the Plat of "Quail Creek Plaza Phase 1" as recorded in Plat Book 15, Page
73, Public Records of Collier COllnty, located in Section 20, Township 48 South, Range
26 East.
D. Amend the Pari. Impact Fee OnJinance to eliminate the collection of Communit~' Park
Impact Fees in the Marco Island District.
18. ADJOURN
INQUIRIES CONCERNING CHANGES TO THE BOARD'S AGENDA SHOULD BE MADE TO THE
COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE AT 774-8383.
7
March 23, 199')
~
".--
,----.
...
PROCLAMA rrON
WHEREAS. amidst the. beauty and bountiful notural resources of Collier
County, the community's MOST important resource is its people;
and,
WHEREAS, the population of Collier County is made up of a rich, diverse
mixture of people from many different racial, ethnic, and
cultural backgrounds; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County is committed
to the development and execution of public policies that ensure
the health, safety, and welfare and enhance the quality of life
of AU residents and visitors; and,
WHEREAS, the Board supports and applauds efforts in the community to
break down barriers and build bridges of understanding among
people of different facia!; <Ilthnic, and cultural backgrounds; and,
>::;.;:"
,.
WHEREAS,
, ." -. '. -. ',....' ."., ""-'." ., ,
.........-....................... ,- ......-....--... ......................
.. ... ".. _. ..0. .....".
, '".'.,',-,. ...-....,. .,' , ','.'",- ',"',".' ',',","
....... -....',......-. -'-.--' -'... .
..-.... . ........... ... .. ... .."_.......
on Tuesd4.....a..y.. '.... M.......o. 11. 'C. It......l.. 0)1999.. '..............t.."'... e...~......'o. ""'. "d4.o........Hi. umanities Counct'l and
the Naples . Branch of the ..Ame"ita~1$so~/ation of l/niversity
W~Ten~ill co-sponso~o.. "()lalo!fUe..()n.~i.;f.c~ity" program at the
CdUnty'sMain Librpr>:at850Central;AVf!.nHl!{nNaples from 7:00
t~~:$()p. m.
;.::::>:::::.-..>:;-',,:::.'::,;: 0"':'::' -.:: ,:r :::,_.:," .::,: ':"',:::.. ':::.:'::\." ,,::.:~:'}' -::':-,::".:'... ,...-)p \::;;:":,}I:::::::':.?::;::::.::.;,,:
NOW THERE0~RE,ibe it procloim~(l bythe~oard#f cJif{{fjrqmmiSsioners of
;~~II/~,.County.Florida,th(JtMQr~~Z8 thr~iJ5Ih :l!pril 3, 1999 be
'i:I~$IgHated as .'. " .....,.
:~. .
{:.
........................."....................................................."'...... .................. . ...... ...................'.......................................................................
...... ....... n_ .,.. ...... .. ... . ..
in Cdllie;r.Co~~ty;+t1nd. r~s,ktept$,o~~~ryef!t~lupport and attend
the ..()(QJogu~ol7/)l~ersity!~pr;~firE~ri/
, . -.,......-..- ....... .... ,..." . -'.- .,........--,... ,,""'"''
..;,;.:-.-.....-....-...... -'.-"',-" ..,..---- '-','. ',....... .-,...,..,.",....-...-.,..,..-.- "".-..,-".,.--
::::';':;,,"':<, :::,.::::: -;::,,''<<\; ':';';;::,' .:;:;:;':;:;:.. -"'.;:;>", :",:.:<';::.:;'./::;; '-:,:;:;~:;::::-;:;-;<:;:
--- .,-,,'. .'".'.. '. .". ,...".... ...-----.,...... .'" ....-....."..,. .'- -
::,.---'. ."','-".'.;- -"'--.."., ':.;;...:......,".-,....,.....,..., '.;,.,....-'---.'.;-...;.-.:-. .-:.':
.:",'.';":.:. ,..,..-.-....,. .,-.-........,."-....-,;..,...,:.-.., .-.,:,..::'.';.'....-....... '.'
/)ONE AN/) OR/)ERE/) THIS Z3rd Day"~ Mq,-c!7 J 999.
BOAR/) OF COl/NTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COl/NTY, FLORIDA
PAMELA S. MACKIE. CHAIRWOMAN
ATTEST:
/)WIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
AGENDA ITEM
No. 5;q /
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. /
. _.~.~___..._--_._---_____'""__...~-_w____w~.
PROCLAMA rrON
WHEREAS, Master Gardener volunteers are an integral part of Collier County
Government; and,
WHEREAS, the Collier County Master Gardener Program offers opportunities for
citizens who wish to volunteer in a diversity of different ways;
including plant clinics, garden workshops, recycling garden demon-
strations, authoring articles for the newspaper's garden pages; and,
WHEREAS, Master Gardener volunteerism results in the resolution of over 6,000
problems for citizens of the community; and,
WHEREAS, last year Master Gardener volunteers contributed in excess of 2,170
hours of service in the plant clinic alone, or the equivalent of more than
one full- time employee; and,
WHEREAS, last year Master Gardener volunteers contributed over $26,000 in
services to Collier County GoVernment; and,
-', -..;..............,. ",-,-:-,,',.,:
..,..:_ .:. ",:.".:"" ..::.'--.',;,.," ::;..::(": {:'T;.'-'.:..\:.' ./:? ....... .
WHEREAS, our communl'ty has as one of its major a, . :ltes the lushness of its
horticulture; and, .. .
;' ,
WHEREAS, wi~~6Ut ~6Iuhteerservice~9fh1aster1!ar;ai!lfe,:s;fhe quality of our
coh7munity would be greatly.reduced. ...
.---
.. '. ..- "'. ...... . .....-. ".
. . . '. ..... . ..
, -... ",' - '",. ',', ,.... ,_....
,...'-....,.'_..::':...::',:::.:'. .;.... -'.. ",' "'- ,'.- ,",",".'.. ... ....., :,.:-: ,,-",.:;.,-:.:,,:.:",
. . ,. .
NOW THEREFORE-be it prof'a,,"edbythiBoafdorCJunty~()mit;'fsioners of Collier
~ounty,Florida,thatMarch2t-27,:1999 be d,!signpted as
"" _._ ..___ . , . ,__',. _C' ,'_ '. .... .
.> .... "'.' .......'... .. ..- -' -' . -." . '. .. . ". .. ' ...
':' :_,':,' ...... ..' ,'.,'. :" .' - ":'C"':. ,..'....'..
MASTER GARDENER APPRECIATION. WEEK IN CottIER COUNTY
withi~xfrel11egrat<fi}deand appreciation.~~ef}d~d to all the Master
Gardener volunteers who fir~ olth~i~tif17e and energies to Collier
County G9vernment. We't~~.B~ard of~ollierCounty Commissioners,
do affirm our commitment to the Master Gardener Program and value
our partnership with the. University of Florida in bringing these special
opportunities to our residentsi:1nd visitors.
DONE AND ORDERED THIS 23rd Day of March, 1999.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
PAMELA S. MACKIE, CHAIRWOMAN
ATTEST:
AGENDAA-ITEM
No. S 2)
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
".....-
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I
PROCLAMA rrON
---...........
WHEREAS, the Economic Development Council of Collier County, through the
Public/Private Partnership with the Collier County Board of County
Commissioners, strives to provide economic opportunities for our youth
through specific efforts to retain and recruit businesses which create
high-wage job opportunities: and,
WHEREAS, a quality labor force and a diversified economy are needed to ensure
the economic stability of our local community: and,
'WHEREAS, a good education and inspiration is essential for our youth to value free
enterprise, business and economics to improve the quality of their lives:
and,
WHEREAS, the current and future success of our students is dependent on the
cooperative relationship of the entire community: and,
WHEREAS, the EDC recognizes the importance of providing linkages between the
business community and AU levels of an integrated educational
delivery system: and, ...
"', ;.:.:...., .., .'>:: :,."., ,::.-'-,:' ,'",.. ,-,
WHEREAS, the tteerJ~of thiJ busiflesstommuf1/tylsforaw.ell-educated workforce
and citizenry: and, ,', .......
WHEREAS,
"':':'- ..:.,..,.:<:':....:... . .'. "-:"": ...' . -,:,:' " ."" ,/ -':,:: \,){,o::"":::,:,),::::,,,
th~follter County~o(1r;d of County Commissiprl~rsand the Economic
Development CouncilofCollier Cou1tyreciJgniz~th~.efforts and
partnerships with the Collier CkuntyPublic Sc~~ols,.c.o//ier County
Education Foundation, Naples Area Chamber of;.Coinmerce, and Junior
Achievement. iT ";/ r' ..
~
.... "
..'. ::
, " ,-- ,. ,-, . . -', -. ~: ,,',' "-"
NOW THEREFO/{E,beit p~ocla(medb0'fhe.~()ard of CounrKCommissioners of Collter
Coun.. ty,Florida, that.. th.e..' month of April be...Ot. .....e$.. ...~.;gna fed as
" .. .. . ..'...... ..
. . ,- .. .
~ ;.
FOCUS'ON EDl/CATIONMONTH
........................ ........................ ................ ....'...................'............................................................... .........................
'-',. ......- ,-_.. -, .....--.... ....... .......-,. ........ ... ,.. .. ..
'.. ........ '....... '-.......
and urge everypnet.o r~cogni.z7t~e/I11Portance of preparing our youth
with the ability to obtain meaflingful.employment upon graduation of
high school, vocationolschool,cofTlITlUnity college or a four-year
institution.
DONE AND ORDERED THIS 23rd Day of March, 1999.
BOARD OF COl/NTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
PAMELA S. MACKIE, CHAIRWOMAN
ATTEST:
AGENDA A~
No. ...5
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
".,.--
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. /
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
TO PRESENT THE CERTIFICATE OF ACHIEVEMENT FOR EXCELLENCE IN
FINANCIAL REPORTING TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS FOR THE
FISCAL YEAR ENDED SEPTEMBER 30, 1997
OBJECTIVE: To inform and present to the Board of County Commissioners the Government
Finance Officers Association Certificate of Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting
for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1997.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Clerk of the Circuit Court serving in the capacity as Ex-Officio Clerk
to the Board of County Commissioners is responsible for coordination of the annual independent
audit along with the production of the comprehensive annual financial report.
In this role, the Clerk participates in the Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA)
Certificate of Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting program. This award program
was established by the GFOA in 1945 to encourage government units to prepare and publish an
easily readable and understandable comprehensive annual financial report covering all
transactions of the government during the fiscal year.
,-
The GFOA, along with the Clerk of the Circuit Court, believes that governments have a special
responsibility to provide the public with a fair presentation of their financial affairs, The
comprehensive annual financial reports prepared by and for Collier County go beyond the
requirements of generally accepted accounting principles by providing the many users of our
financial statements a wide variety of information with which to evaluate the financial condition
of this County.
Collier County has received this prestigious award for eleven consecutive years, and it is with
great pride that we inform and present to the Board the award for the twelfth consecutive year for
the comprehensive annual financial report that was prepared for the year ended September 30,
1997,
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
FISCAL IMPACT: NOlle.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners accept the Government
Finance Officers Association Certificate of Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting
for the comprehensive annual financial report for the period ended September 30, 1997.
Prepared By: /
James L. Mitchell, CIA, CFE, CBA
Dire,et-ornfFinance and Accounting
Date: 3/z./, j'
I ,
....--.
Reviewed By:
Date:
MAR 2 j 1999
Pg...J
r
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PRESENT TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS THE CO"~fPREHENSIVE
ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORT FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED SEPTEMBER 30,
1998.
OBJECTIVE: To present to the Board of County Commissioners the comprehensive annual
financial report for the year ended September 30, 1998,
CONSIDERATIONS: The Clerk of the Circuit Court serving in the capacity as Ex-Officio Clerk
to the Board of County Commissioners is responsible for the coordination of the annual
independent audit along with the production of the comprehensive annual financial report.
In this role, the Clerk is pleased to present to the Board the comprehensive annual financial report
for the fiscal year ended September 30, 1998, The comprehensive annual financial report
represents a significant investment of effort by the Finance and Accounting Department along
with those involved County employees, We would like to express our appreciation to KPMG
LLP, this Board, the other Constitutional Officers, the County Administrator, the Division
Administrators and the Department Directors, not only for their assistance with the CAFR, but for
their assistance throughout the year in matters pertaining to the financial affairs of Collier
County.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None,
FISCAL IMPACT: None.
_.
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Collier County Board of County Commissioners accepts the
comprehensive annual financial report for the period ended September 30, 1998.
Prepared By: Y
James L. Mitchell, CIA, CFE, CBA
Director of Finance and Accounting
Date: 3/~/'7'
Reviewed By:
Date' 2 ~ ~rc:
. ~ ./.'J /. /
N~~E~~~T~~
".--
MAR 2 3 1999
pg.---L-
..,
~_. COLLIER COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE
March 15, 1999
3301 E, TAMIA,MI TRAIL
NAPLES, FL 34112
(941) 774-8383
FAX (941) 774-4010
Ms, Joy Lelonek
Executive Director
United Arts Council of Collier County
1051 5lh Avenue South
Naples, Florida 34102
A CERTIFIED BLUE CHIP COMMUNITY
Re: Request for Public Petition - Request for Financial Support
Dear Ms. Lelonek:
Please be advised that you arc scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of Commissioners at
the meeting of March 23, 1999 reg:uding the abo\e referenced su bject.
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners "ill be limited to ten minutes, Please be advised that
the Board will takc no action on your petition at this meeting, Howcver, your petition may be pbced on a
future agcnda for consideration at the Board's discretion, Therefore, your petition to the Board should be
to advise them of your concern and thc necd for action by the Board at a future meeting,
,-
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a,m, in the Board's Chambers on the Tlmd Floor of the Administration
Building (Building .oF") of the government compkx, Please arrange to be present at this meeting and to
respond to inquiries by Board members,
If you require any further infonnation or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this office,
Very truly yours,
,.' ~
- ;../,,~ .. ~.
a~/ "0...4 rt?
Robert F. Fernandez ..
County Administrator
RFFlbp
cc: County Attorney
Office of Management and Budget
AGENO~ JTlM
No. I(,,~l ,
/
".-..
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. {
~~n~
UNITED ARTS COUNCIL
.,.~"-~-
of Collier County
"All the Arts for All the People"
COlmTY ADMINISTRATOR ROUTING
DATE"
ACTION: \-.".'. ..;. ;- ;';"'.-1 ~
March 8, 1999
;" /~ f./'I 1-: ~~ ~ ,:.J
INFO:
Mr, Robert Fernandez
County Administrator
3301 E, Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
FILE:
STAFF FILE:
IH: fL.;' " ~ ..{,,,
,
..----~
Dear Mr. Fernandez:
We are requesting to be placed on the agenda under the Public Petition section of the March 23,
1998 meeting of the Board of Commissioners of Collier County, We will be petitioning the Board
of Commissioners to provide financial support to the United Arts Council.
"
The United Arts Council has been named the official representative of Collier County for
purposes of performing the functions of the county fine arts council as described in Chapter 265,
Florida Statutes, and by resolution #84-81, adopted by the Board of County Commissioners on
April 24, 1984.
It is our responsibility to survey and assess the needs of the arts, stimulate greater governmental
and public appreciation of the importance of the arts to people and the economy in Florida, and
encourage opportunities in the arts. In addition, we promote the development of Collier County
artists, art institutions, and community organizations as well as sponsor arts activities.
With county support, we will be better able to fulfill our role as the county local arts agency and
not compete for art dollars meant to support our member organizations. Thank you for your
consideration of this request.
Sincerely,
-'i~ ~~
Joy Lelonek
Executive Director
JL:jp
N~~EN_~~,~)EM
MAR 2 3 1999
,~
The State Designared Local Arts Agency for Collier COllnty
1051 5th Avcnuc Smith. Naples. Florida 34102
941/263-R242. Fax 941/263-3R30. e-mail # analive@naplcs.nct
Pg.
.1..
-~, ,
.:..-:. ;C~:JI""""'..\
' ;~ '-'::~.~'),
,'.'>:~
~~"J COLLIER COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE
.J
~
3301 E. TAMIAMI TRAIL
NAPLES, FL 34112
(941) 774-8383
FAX (941) 774-4010
March 17, 1999
A CERTIFIED BLCE CHIP C01L'\lCNITY
Donald Pickworth, Esquire
5811 Pelican Bay Blvd" Suite 210
Naples, Florida 34108
Re: Request for Public Petition - International College - Educational Facilities Authority
Dear Mr. Pickworth:
Please be advised that you are scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of
Commissioners at the meeting of March 23, 1999 regarding the above referenced subject.
.".--..
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners will be limited to ten minutes, Please be
advised that the Board will take no action on your petition at this meeting, However, your
petition may be placed on a future agenda for consideration at the Board's discretion, Therefore,
your petition to the Board should be to advise them of your concern and the need for action by
the Board at a future meeting,
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a,m. in the Board's Chambers on the Third Floor of the
Administration Building (Building "F") of the government complex, Please arrange to be present
at this meeting and to respond to inquiries by Board members,
If you require any further information or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this office.
Very truly yours,
~~
County Administrator
RFFlbp
cc: County Attorney
Office of Management and Budget
/~A~-E)OA ITEM
MAR 2 3 1999
.,.-.....
P9.---1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to adopt a resolution authorizing the Collier County Educational Facilities
Authority to function.
OBJECTIVE:
To adopt a resolution authorizing the Collier County Educational Facilities Authority to
function and exercise powers under the Florida Higher Educational Facilities Authorities Law.
CONSIDERATIONS:
International College has requested the Collier County Industrial Development Authority,
("IDA") to assist it with tax";exempt financing of its now administrative/classroom facilities planned
for the site that International College is acquiring in Northbrook Village PUD. While the IDA can
finance classroom and administration facilities for private non-profit secondary schools, it is not
authorized to finance such facilities for post secondary private institutions. The power to finance
post secondary administration buildings and classroom facilities is given to an Educational Facilities
Authority, which the Florida Legislature has created in each county.
An Educational Facilities Authority ("EF A") functions almost identically to an Industrial
Development Authority, except that an EF A is limited only to financing projects on behalf of
private, nonprofit, post secondary educational facilities. Therefore, in order to provide tax-exempt
financing for International College, it will be necessary to authorize the EF A to function in Collier
County,
The most administratively simple way of accomplishing this is to activate the Educational
Facilities Authority by resolution, and name the members of the Industrial Development Authority
as the members of the EF A. This would take advantage of the existing administrative support
structure that the IDA has, and would, in effect, simply authorize the IDA to act as an EF A.
The Florida Statutes provide that before the EF A may function in any county, the County
Commission must adopt a resolution declaring the need for the Authority to function, and naming
the initial members. A resolution which accomplishes this is attached. It names the existing
members of the IDA as the members of the EFA.
FISCAL IMP ACT: Tax-exempt bonds of the EF A, like all private-activity tax-exempt bonds
issued by the various County financing authorities, do not pledge or obligate any revenues of the
County, the State, or any other governmental entity. The bonds are payable solely from the funds
ofthe borrower. The bonds are not liabilities or obligations ofthe County and will state on their face
~~~JfAd5M. ~
M/~~ 2 3 1999
'')...
Pg. -
that neither the County nor any officer, employee or agent thereof is liable on the bonds.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMP ACT: The activation ofthe Educational Facilities Authority will
assist the County in providing for the post-secondary educational needs of Collier County students.
The Board is aware of the need ofInternational College to expand its facilities, having considered'
a petition for a relocation of the college into a residential area several months ago. The proposed site
does not create an issue of incompatibility. Like all projects financed in this manner, the resolution
approving the bonds will expressly provide that the facilities are subject to all growth management
and land development regulations.
RECOMMENDA TION:
That the Board of County Commissioners adopt the attached resolution.
Prepared by:
-2-
~g~~~j
M;'~ Z ~1999
Pg.
Resolution 99-
A RESOLUTION DECLARING A NEED FOR AN EDUCATIONAL
FACILITIES AUTHORITY TO FUNCTION IN COLLIER COUNTY
FLORIDA; AUTHORIZING THE AUTHORITY TO TRANSACT
BUSINESS AND EXERCISE POWERS UNDER THE ACT; DESIGNATING
AND APPOINTING THE MEMBERS THEREOF; PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS, pursuant to Sections 243.18 through 243.40, inclusive, Florida Statutes,
(designated as the "Higher Educational Facilities Authorities Law" and referred to herein as the
"Act") there has been created by the Florida Legislature a body corporate and politic to be known
as the "Collier County Educational Facilities Authority" (hereinafter, the "Authority"); and
WHEREAS, the Authority, under the terms of the Act, may not transact any business or
exercise any power under the Act unless the Board of County CU:l1missioners of Collier County
(the "Board") shall declare that there is a need for the Authority to function within Collier
County; and
WHEREAS, the Board by this resolution hereby determines there is a need for the
Authority to function,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY that:
1. The Board hereby finds that there is a shortage of educational facilities at
institutions for higher education (as defined in the Act) in Collier County, and there exists a need
for an Educational Facilities Authority to function in Collier County, Florida. Accordingly, the
Collier County Educational Facilities is hereby authorized and empowered to transact any and all
business and to exercise any and all powers authorized by the Act for an educational facilities
authority as set forth in the Act.
2. The following persons, each of whom are residents and electors of Collier County,
and at least one of whom is a trustee director, officer, or employee of an institution for higher
education as defined in the Act, are hereby appointed to serve as members of the Authority for
the terms set forth beside their names, and this resolution shall constitute a certificate of
appointment for such members:
For a term of five years:
For a term of four years:
For a term of three years:
For a term of two years
For a term of one year
J.R. Humphrey
Barbara Rosenberg
Alice Carlson
Ross Obley
John Agnelli
AGEN~ r~~
NO. ~
M:i~ 2 3 1999
Pg. !I-
3. This Resolution shall take effect immediately upon its adoption.
PASSED and Adopted this _ day of March, 1999.
ATTEST:
Dwight E. Brock, Clerk
By:
Deputy Clerk
[SEAL]
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
.~
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BY
ITS BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS
Pamela S. Mac'Kie
Chairwoman
~~9tn,~ -
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ~
03/10/99 WED 16:-18 FAX
i4J 002
, '
TREISER, KOBZA & VOLPE, CItTD.
ATTORNEYS AT L.AW
Lisa H. Barnett
_ nomas A. Collins. 11 a
FilzseruJd A. Fnurr .0
CaLl,erine E, Kilian
Kim P:lml:k KobL'! 0
Stanley J, Lieberfarb
C. Ril:hacd Mancini
Andrew H. Reiss
Richard M. Treiser
Christopher T. VemoD
Michael J. Volpe +
The Northern Trust Building
4001 Tamiami Trail North
.- Suite 330
Naples. Florida 34103
Telephcine (941)649-4900
Fax (941) 649-0823
Internet Address:
www.tkvnaples.com
Richard Shapllc~ ot
or Coun~.1
o Also ~dmill.d in Michigan
. Alia ;,dmiu<:d in New York
a Also admi[Jl!d in ~oruclcy
~ Also odmi~ in New Jmey
1 Board CDtified TlIJ: AtlOl1ley
M. J. Volpe direcr Internet address:
mjvolpc@tkvnapJes.com
March 10, 1999
VIA TELEFAX
'8-1161
Donald Pickworth, Esquire-
5811 Pelican Bay Boulevard, Suite 210
Naples, FL 34108
RE: International College - Educational Facilities Authority
Dear Don:
As you know, I am the attorney for the rIl.temational College who will be representing its interest in
olUlection with the acquisition and development of its new campus which is to be located here in Collier
County. To assist Intemational CoJlege in lheacquisition financing and construction of its first campus
building which will contain approximately 40,000 square feet, we have requested your assistance in
obtaining [Tom the Board of Commissioners of Collier County, the proper Ordinance or Resolution declaring
there is a need for an Educational Facilities Authority to function. here in Collier County.
In that regard, I understand the enabling statUte requires at least one of the members of the
Educational Authority be a Trustee, Director, Officer or employee of an institution for higher education
located in Collier County. In this instance, l.R.(Jack) Humphrey, who as you know, currently serves as a
member of the Collier County Industrial DevelopmentAuthority, is and has been, since its inception a
member of the Board of Trustees of the International College which is a non-profit educational institution
here in Collier County providing a program of educalion~eyond the high school level.
I trust this information will be of assistance to YOll in making your presentation to the Collier Comity
Board of Commissioners. if there is anything additionalyou require from me at this time, just let me know.
Thank you for your assistance.
, ,-
, .....
Very truly y:~urs,
" ,"
Qtilf.+ZA & VOLPE, Chtd.
MiC~ae(JjolPe
AGENDA m:-u .
NO. ~ ('8'1
~~-)
M~l~ 2 3 1999
Pg. h
-WV:mjw
cc:
Terry P. McMahan.. President (via relefax:774-4593)
International College
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
CONNIE D. STEGALL-FULLMER, REPRESENTING
GOODLAND CIVIC ASSOCIATION, REQUESTING A
WAIVER OF TEMPORARY USE PERMIT FEE FOR AN
EVENT HELD ON MARCH 6 AND 7, 1999, ON
GOODLAND, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
OBJECTIVE:
The Petitioner requests a waiver of the required application fee for a Temporary Use
Permit. The permit is for Goodland's 50th Birthday Celebration, a fund raiser sponsored
by the Goodland Civic Association, held on March 6 and 7, 1999, at designated
business locations throughout Goodland.
CONSIDERATIONS:
~
The Goodland Civic Association, a non-profit organization, will use the proceeds from
this fund raiser event to go into their building fund to cover costs of insurance, repairs,
maintenance and improvements related to their community building.
The required application fee for a temporary use permit is $75. The Petitioner requests
to waive the fee for this event.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Revenues for Fund 113 (Community Development Fund) are generated from fees
established in the Schedule of Development Review and Building Permit Fees. It is a
Board policy that requests for waiver of such fees be granted only by the Board. The
term waiver is a bit of a misnomer in that, should a waiver be granted, it is necessary to
transfer the funds from the General Fund Reserves (001) to the Community
Development Fund (113).
Based on staff research, the average annual fiscal impact resulting from these types of
fee waivers is $2,200.00.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
A policy decision made by the Board with respect to Temporary Use Permit fee waivers
will have no impact on the Collier County Growth Management Plan.
~
AGENDA 'TEML
No. 't { A'L
MAR 2 3 1999
L
Pi.
RECOMMENDATION:
Fee waiver applications may only be approved by the Collier County Board of County
Commissioners, Since fee waivers are requested by a wide variety of individuals and
organizations, for various reasons, it is necessary for the Board to evaluate the
conditions and reasons which underlie the fee waiver application on a case by case
basis. Therefore staff can only recommend denial for fee waiver requests.
PREPARED BY:
~Yl~
CHERYL L, ' TER
PLANNER I
3-1- 99
DATE
,
REVIEWED BY: \
, ,
\ '
\
'~~
--''-''
~/.
..: \ '"
~~ C . C, c~
L.-~.J '
DATE
RONALD F. NINO, AICP
CURRENT PLANNING MANAGER
"'t...r;
r~_ ~ "
.5'- ) -, 1
DATE
ROBERT J. MULHERE, AICP
PLANNING SERVICES DIRECTOR
APPROVED BY:
Jf;Ji7 ~ '
VINCENT A. CAUTERO, AICP
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL
SERVICES ADMINISTRATOR
L-.
3--1 ~ ftr
DATE
EXECUTIVE SUMMARYI FEE WAIVER
-
AGENDA ITEM
No.~(A) L
MAR 2 3 1999
PI. ~
2
/ .
\.
qC.A
GOODLAND CIVIC ASSOCIATION
P. O. BOX 571
GOODLAND. FLORIDA 33t1S8- 34 I ,,~{
January] 9. ] 999
fo"'t. ,,-' ,-, t - - ..~.
:~,~ ~::~.~:, ~"' .~~ r -:.~_~ : - ... ~~
Ron Nino. A1CP. Director
Planning Services Department
Community Dewlopment & Environmental Services Div.
2800 North Horseshoe Dr.
Naples. Fl. 34] 04
If,.., 'j (l i:-, ':-'C;
~,.. _ L 1...;...,;,-,"
\:OJ,_,: ,14",- SC.~"'I'Ct'::
Sir:
Enclosed please find a letter from the Collier County Sheriffs Office. Application for
T cmporary Use Permit with maps. and a check in the amount of $75.00 for the pemlit.
The Goodland Civic Association has organized and wishes to hold a Goodland 50th
Birthday Celebration on March 6 & 7. 1999, The event is a fund raiser for the civic
association. a non profit organization, The monies raised will go into our building fund
and used for insurance. repairs and maintenance and improvements to the building. The
building is our only community gathering place and is used for community meetings and
community social events.
Since the event is a fund raiser. we are requesting a waiver of the permit fee 01'$75.00.
We are anxious to receive our pemlit and the waiver.
1 look forward to hearing from you.
Thank vou,
Sincere]v,
/', '~I- <"'0,..-\ ~(C :).,,-q .
I ....---'t....~,.-, .. \ J'-.l..,_,.,,- - ~.0,,_'\"'I.L,
,~-~ ~ . "-
Connie 0, Stegall-Fullmer '-
Member. Birthday Celebration Committee
AGENOA ITEM
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
3
,
r
~
;
cc: John Carter. GCA President
(' \", ~ \ '.. \\~
"- \\\ ~
\, )
Pi.
.
,
_;n:->t
/
, II'!
..-, 'L Y /-H: L . '. ()Ll....
~ " . ~./ ~
389 - 6:/~ ~ c
_ Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
':;DPR1103 - Official Receipt
Trans Number Date Post Date i Payment Slip Nbr
-f130i4~-------- - --0112271999 -1 :32_:J~P_~___~ /22/!.99~________~~_~ 7859_________==~--~=
GOODLAND CIVIC ASSOC" INC.
GOOD LAND
Payor: GOODLAND CIVIC ASSOC
Fee Information
F_~~~-goai --~icri~)tlO~-==~~-=_-=--=--=-~~===GCAccount _-===-==-=--=- Amounf-walved---
11 "'l.J~E ___~E~I~_L E'{~_N_T~I~~OR!-.B]'_l.J_SJ~._1_~ 13890034394000000_________ -$7s:-00----------
Total $75.00
Payments
_F'?y!!'l~~!~od~
CHECK
Account/Check Number
----.- -----_...._-~-_._~~---'-----
636
Amount
$75,00
----. --.~~--~_._~-~----_..
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
$0.00
$75.00
Total Paid
$75.00
Memo:
TEMP, USE#99-39
Cashier/location: FROLOFF _E / 1
User: FRONT_DESK
AGENDA ITEM
No. cgCAI
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 'f
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:01/22/1999 1 :32:45 PM
"
COlliER COUNTY
TEMPORARY USE PERMIT
TU-
990038
SPECIAL EVENT
o Temporary Sales
m-emporary Sports, Religious. or Community Event
o Sign Only
o Temporary Seasonal Sales: DChristmas Trees; 0 Fireworks; 0 Pumpkins
Shopping Center:
Business Name: ~cC)dLf-11l,cj r-.UI ~ Ilc:;.r::;oc.
Event Address: GC9or/LIO.NrJ - vA/2.(oU~ (,oC,AT70;->$ /,..) Goo"!:>LAA-
see;
Event Dates: This permit is effective from 3 1~/.Jj to 3 1::1) q Cf. MA f'
Property Owner:
Name:
Address:
Phone:
Applicant: _
Name: tf((t{jl,j~ J. ~///'ne~
Address: ~~~1~1t, ~Y/~O
Phone: 9~/- 3COQ- D2SS-
AGENDA I~EM
No. ~{A.J I
MAR 2 3 1999
p,. S
.-1
Attach a site plan which depicts:
. property boundaries I
. external roads /
. access points -../
. parking (improved & unimprovec;l to be used by vehicles during event) v
. buildings '.j/
. proposed sign locations
SITE INFORMATION
Zoning: ftfuc..nCt..e 2o__/,..;c ">1'5r;e.rC.,-5
Present Use:
~ndeveloped
ifdeveloped; type of business
Parking:
o undeveloped; site plan indicates designated parking areas
0developed; site plan indicates a maximum of 10% of the parking area
occupied by the special event
Banner or Sign:
Collier County Land Development Code Section 2.6.33.6.2 allows one temporary sign or
banner in conjunction with a temporary use permit (2 signs are allowed for properties
with more than 1 street frontage). MAXIMUM SIZE = 32 square feet. WIND SIGNS
(includina balloons. streamers. rota tin a devices and unofficial "aas) ARE
PROHIBITED.
Traffic Safety:
Authorization from the Collier County Sheriffs office may be required for certain events.
o undeveloped: proposed access points are shown on the site plan
r::rdeveloped; access points existing
Exterior Lightin~
8' existing
o additional lighting indicated on site plan
Noise:
o no music or noise proposed
G2f music/noise is anticipated from 51- tl ~i s
Alcoholic Beverpges:
rz alcoholic beverages will not be sold or consumed A~~I~ I
o a copy of the Florida Beverage Commission permit is at ~chEtQ.~
2
MAR 2 3 1999
p,. In
JAN-25-99 MON 05:06 PM GOODTIMES PROP~RTIES INC 1 941 389 0925
P.01
Q1/2&/99 18:00 FAX 941~436968
--...----. .'
._ffi,lliILCO COmflTNITY DE'- ~002
I\- \-L ~ (' k-QA lj l
~
,,"
Restrooms: ,.
e( ~isting facilities will be available
~ portable facilities are shown on the site plan
Security Guard:
o ~urity will be provided
ua'security will not be provided
Other Requirem:ants:
By acceptance I)f this pennit, the applicant agreeS to defend, hold harmless and
il"1demnify Collier County and its agents from any and all liability which may arise as a
result of the issuance of this permit and agrees to conform with applicable provisIons of
the Collier Coun~' Land Development Code. /':
I, ~~ :5"/.~~II-f:;I/ttJ~ property owner or prope~~r of the
sUbject property permlt' to use the property 9S
described herein during the time period Indicated. I understand that Collier County Land
Development Co:1e S&ction 2.6.33.6.2 permits a total of 28 c;lays per calendar year (up
to 14 consecutiw! days) for special event~ on this property.
~ '"-,
Date
.....'\ S.
Property Ownel'/llI1anager
ApEroval: ~ J.
p~M: w:19~
This permit doe.:. not constitute approvals which may also be necassary under other
local, state and federal regulatIons, including, but not limited to right-of-way permit,
buHdlng permit. =AA, FCC, fire district, & DEP. This TU permit is issued pursuant to
information provided by the applicant
TU permIt fee: $75
Checks payable to: Board of County Commissioners
COLLI~R COU;-.TY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
NaptQS,I='L 34104
941-403~2400
~g(S.)!
3
MAR 2 3 1999
Pt. 7
~Iycriff ~01t ~u1ttcr
Collier County Govt. Complex Bldg. - J
3301 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, FL 33962
Telephone (AC 941) 774-4434
Jatll:k1ry 18, 1999
Ron Nino" J\ICP, Director
Pla.ll!ling Services Department
Community Development & Envir('IIlnlental Services Div.
2800 North Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, H~ 34104
Sir,
I have reviewed the documentation concerning the 50th Birthday Celebration planned by
the Goodland Civic Association for the \o\'eekend of March 6th and 7th, 1999. There are no
anti~ipated problems with the events, and it does not appear there will be a serious
adverse affect on the traffic flow through Goodland.
Please feel free to contact me at the :Marco Island Substation ( 394-5129) should you
have any prob I ems or concerns in this matter.
Sincerely,
#1tL-~)~
Sgt William E. McDonald
Collier County Sheriff s Office
Marco Island Substation
AGENOA ~
No. 'it I
MAR 2 3 1999
~
Pi.
-
(
(
I .j,
(-- ~'
. ....~
rr
(. .r
~
~
"
~,-~
<}o~1J
J'
t..;.,e,';
~~tt'~. _..,(
. -:-'-::t_ .._,~
:~;~.~.y~:
: ," . -~ ,;
:.. :-..:~i:'-f::/-'
.:. :-..~~'
\.D.
~
~
---to
'\:l)
....~
...
,j,' ' ,-I(
" u
,P
1-- ~
(
-(
~
. r
c. )
-l t
ry'i)
~ "J tJ 3
~ -i ~Jt
-~ -' '0 V ~ rr- <s
~\ ~ \.I T iiI <.
'-'\ ..r () J -. .: I q:
-6 ~ "'.J) <r~~ ?:~
-:: ~::f g ~ ~ g l)o) ~-j
j -f - ."'-r:;t~
c!1- ~ -i \J
( ,
.;.~O
--
~ I).
~
i
i'-~
""
..,
2
~
<;I
-t
~
\
'U
J'
.'
. ~;
'~'. .'
/!!i~::
/D
i
(
, ....
I J, ' '
,..-;' "'"
(~ ~
~
U
1
. ....r
( ,
-r
J.
C1.
r= ).11. _ ~ ~.
LT. .. .. ,. ....
IEJ ~ to ..
r ~. I ~ ;....~.
~ i~iiL~ · : ~ ~"~'~~"~',,, ~ ' ..:
-:':' ~ ~, ;::,:~ El:: - ~, f\:~' Hi
~':t' f-:- 1-- ,iT _ r-f)f I:i: ? ~ I..q.
) )'h,. :1,:.1--'- - ~ ~ ,Ill" lL r.: ~
. I',:.r - >-, :s.. .,.... ~ ., 0
7)~ ,:: "I:?--:::: :: "ot 'f ~ ~
~~ 'I -lJ1f!2{Blc. f ~ .:J; Ii
- ~ - ~:,J~ .~: 1::: iF" jr:i ~ '7
L-l/~ ff"i~~"-=-~~"l'_ lJE<~' r~
J~~ . 1- ~~ .u J" I ~ -~:i
I~ cr ~ ~ · I Ii", ~ ' &; L" ;
.. > L:t ~I-...,
~- -' · I : I . f- I....:.. _
I ~..;:.. .. ~. (
~--"~~""....:1 :: :: r!.~ tk. '}g
~=~ 1 ~ -"- · 'or ..... ~I i I
r:-.... .,1 :i: : ~ ~: it ~ ~j: i~" __
\ ~-1?--. '. ~>;- .!......!.. ., ~ ,-,' '.
. ,tn.., <? ~7' ~~ Ii..., .;!. i~ ~-..l"1r ;;-...... . ~:" . J"'
!1~iJ~~'M~~.~"8111;:; ~+~~ ~~ ,'. ..
t' \ ~.. - - .. ...!- ~ -;- i\;~ CJ. ' !(/..'~.,.__ - ,_ .
- - ". .. .. ,-1- ~ ,,' ,,' ;;;;". If "'--^:, ~.'
..... ". 9. ~ CI) · ~I ..'""~:'
:.-', l:- :......., :OJ ~ I :.. · ~..! ~ ~ a ~ ,!ieC":, .
~.. .."'l", ."c~ .i-.~ I:" i~ '. ~. ~' ." f,< '.
~i.':;?~~~"~_,-, II"':... ~h:;..! ~'a''i;, -.~~ ',__ f,
1 ~~ I 'E ~ .. h~~ ~IJr':. ~~t ~,':} ~~~ ~ ( -'f,,~
~ f.;:: ~MU1SHnSl:: all ',' II ""Il ,. ~ ,_'\ '7 ,
;~ .T. .T..r. .r'.',i~c~~;,) "- ~~!. \ · .:~' U.l199!l
~~.. '.'~-~~~Sll .... - . ...... .....;: 11'1
:_j.~, ' ~-
I . '-_ .s :2 tt
......,.
9-1'
,
""
"
-;; ~<5,'
, . ~J^ B:.:,; .
(
J
,t (
j ~
i'-~__
,
'" lf2 - <lB;
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
FINAL ACCEPTANCE OF WATER FACILITIES ACCEPTANCE FOR
951 MINI STORAGE
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to
accept the conveyance of the water facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of 951 Mini Storage, has constructed the water
facilities within dedicated easements to serve this development.
See attached location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance was approved by the Community
Development and Environmental Services staff on March 23, 1998, in
accordance with Ordinance 97-17.
3) Staff has recorded all appropriate legal documentation which
had been reviewed by the County Attorney's office for legal
sufficiency.
4) The water facilities have been operated and maintained by the
Collier County Water-Sewer District during the one (1) year
warranty period.
5) A final inspection to examine for any defects in materials
and workmanship was conducted by the Community Development and
Environmental Services Division staff and found to be
satisfactory.
6) The Utilities Performance Security (UPS), in the form a Cash
Bond in the amount of $2,197.00, will be released to the Project
Engineer or the Developer's designated agent upon the Boards
approval.
FISCAL IMPACT: The water facilities were constructed without cost
to the Collier County Water-Sewer District. The cost of operating
and maintaining the water facilities will be paid by monthly user
revenues.
AGENDA ITEM
No. <?(jj) t2
MAR 2 3 1999
PI. /
Executive Summary
951 Mini storage
Page Two
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: This project has been connected to the
County Regional Water Treatment Plant. Capacity presently exists
to serve this project.
RECOMMENDATION: The Community Development and Environmental
Services Division Administrator recommends that the Board of
County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of the
Collier County Water-Sewer District, accept the water facilities
for 951 Mini Storage, and release the UPS to the Project Engineer
or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY:
s~~ E~~ng Technician II
Engineer' g Review Services
__~~//9P
Date
REVIEWED BY:
~~~ p iU
Thomas E. Kuck, P.E.
Engineering Review Services Manager
3,,/7- 99
Date
Robert Mulhere, AICP
Planning Services Department Director
Date
AP~Oy6 B.Y:U. ~
~ Cautero, AICP Administrator
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
]-/)-CZ,
Date
AGENDA ITEM
No. qC#)~
MAR 2 3 1999
~~
~--f':'-." ... ,_....:':-;"'";.-'
~ - .. ..-' .....-...,. -;
'- -. .
~_. . --c...:'~. ~. ,. .._ __..
- '-""-'~~"~' -;..._~~-..,
.. .' ~'..'
~"""~~~?~'~"?""2~.~~~:~~~_ ~_"?_~.~~~~..._....,_. l""'Ia ._~.~.,~-.::-~:~_ __4:_"'~."'''-'~"'':7~~~~~a;~~~~'''''''~'~.~'''''~~'''~'l
. . ....
,';_~;.'_-.,...<:__r".;,-:~":'~~~"::::'_":~'"_.".;_,::,,,>;,:_;,_.:'",::~"".,.~..:,: ;' .'<___'__.' . ~i_,.__. . :-'.'~"',:, ;', _.,.____. .'_~_"" _. '_'_~'_.
-- ---.- .._. ...~._-_........~.--,._-- --~ - -..... .- ~ ......--.- -........" -- :. - .'-. -- -,... -, ~ - -- - -.
. . _:- : ~.~:~~~.:!":,:c ~:l~:: -: '"":r,-;::.~ i-^2,"::; :,~~;;:~-::?'":_~:::~:;~:;,~,-s;~-~~?f~~~~,:,'?47~:.~~~-:~&.,~li~~~:~ - ';;;'::0~~':-:^;.;~~~~T;';';;;I.;;:.;;~~~;i~~i
, d
--
..,
~:. .
~ ~
.. I
it
4- -4-- ---
~ lQ
tQlllfIt ....
~
.... -- ~
--- ~
\I) +
I I ~
.,. i=
-.. .,1fo- O.
" ~
7 :- ....- -4t-
.... ~ 0
.... ~
~
~
:
C) ~
0 ~
to-
\I) ~ ~
~ ~ \-
;
\n ~
~
5 <C(
{b@CC~ lj~@lNl ~~~
-.-----.---.----------..----.-
~ ~ ~
~ ~ \!
Ci " ,
. ....
AGEtt)A ITEM
No. >?'~ 2..
MAR 2 3 1999
pt. -3
JF~rJ~HOUSAND
ONE HUNDREL> NINETY :.:;E'v'EN AND 'X>/10(lUUUUU~UhUUUUt.uU
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK OF FLORIDA
~
J
~
Dollars ~
~
JYA~r~-<<h-.~, ~
FEB O"j, 1 ::!)rr:~
. ". $
BGARI> OF COLLIER COUNTY CONMISSIONER~.::*UhH*~UUU**U
UUUtH2r
1 ';l7 . 00
. .---.
.. . -.
;1uwtil?~i>..,.n.r"Sy-... loe. E~,'cO.'
. .,.ll<JM1 "'~~BIIi<llIllo<1'M.~.Jo-_~~.
I: ~o 20000 ~al:8
~ 0 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 B U; ~ ~ ~ b 3111
"',..".,..."'........"'...,,.....,.."'...,:."'....a."...Ol.'...'A."!".""''''............,..,....''..11.,.....,'''......" 10:0.."....".,...,...'""....,,,......,.......:......,"'.. :'.....,:~~=~.~..-'-.~....,. ..,,,,.,,.. ~"Ol.
;II r ') ....., ~?, .'~
-- ~- ,:-:c:-,,~"""!'''''7''-'''''~-~-- ~. ~_,.:.:-:>l~~_.. ..~ -_.- ...,,~_
~.~-='~:'::~~~~'-~~,:.-::::'~~.~~:,~-.;;~~~-:~;:;~~~;;=-:":-;~~~=~~:~=;~-; - . - - "'--.',_ ",,-,,_'"'::,_~~.j;, 'c._" _ ::__'
- . ,--.,...,\.O:.--~... .....'.~..:-,.::~ Q"" ,.-~...,t.i~,~.;=Q~~=_::=.~::::~~:~....,.:-~-_.~~:-.;-~
~.f-:-~~-i.~~..,.:-r~~~-J.'!.~b~.~~~~~~_-.;.-=~:.-~-;:t__ "'''
'-'-..--:""'"':"-.-". --
4 . .. ....,.."" .-- _.,.. ~ ,,". ~ ;:-__-..., '~'.W. .,__.... .;L -.. ;:. '._ . __~~~...:~~:."..:-L. [--Co _~_ . __ ~~..~_, .;,';' __ '"_._ '_~"
-;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,JZ2:.~.~~~-;,~~;::::~~~;;;~~
~~t=~~Ji-~l~~~::~;::;;iE:Zi;E=~~Zi::;;;;t~~sa~j~~::~~~~~.~~il~~l
.J.l!"
_al! '._.'":..___ :"~~~"-::!"'~::;'.'.,...._.
__~:::__~.-.~..~~-:.~""'.'J.....:.....__. _"'_'_.~
~........~
-i"'....~~
,~_. " .,.."\~"'_ .4._.J..:-~:._ :?.._:-_r.'_~.~_ __~~....~~.:...~....':~~.~~._~..... :,~
. - .-.-' . io..i... .~;"...,'~:" ~ :--:.-'~
.,~..~:r-~~;l~,.~..::;..::L=~;:~~,'~~..:::.:;;~~:.~~~~F~~~~~~~~~"'~..~~~y::~
.~-:..--
, .
-...
-.-~
-;:-:..
...". -
_ .... ~~J~~.-v--._ --;:__""-:--:-'.17
~.
-~ -
.-"'-:""':_:..:..,;...:....~;;:----.:..... ....".;.. a':::.
~-:...~(.~~~~~~:..~~:;.'i.-.:~~~~..~~~:~:;~~~~~~~~-.~7~-'.:..i--..._';=":~..~~.:.;.;r~.. ---._-
~
~...~~-~~~~.~~~...~-~~:.y:r r~_
~- -
.. ."
.-' -~- '---',
..
-,
:....,-:<"
_.~....J--;~... _~'::r_T.~.'
..,:::'.
-
,-
'-.- -,--- ..
;~.i~:-~~~~.:~~~~~~~~-'~:;..:<.:.-s.::O;-.;;;.,~~f'.4~~._~,~.;.~;~,r.,;.~~.,.f~.;::-.:<";- "~.;:;.~""::"
-:..:~
A.
--"
. ..A. ~
....... DIIld_" '-!44.. --"'"' Il(I"
-.
-'- ..
~~
-~-~
-' . " - -"-"'~..-....:
~-'--- ~.-:-~~-,
~
~ ..
....
e _._..:"J... -_l""'! F, .".,..,,~....--.-~
.lo.............
~ -
. '_" 4....---,: .____
-~ .....~.:---
-.... .--~ _~-._..1 :.-.-.. ~'~ :'-A. ".l~
~~a ~ '::~.
.-----",.
.~_.~~::~____'~'~-:--_-":':~-::::",:,:_.~-:-a";;'.";:_--=-'_..--:,,:" ....~..~~.......;...~.~~:~~___,.~
..t -:-":;"'.
'. ....~_4J..-.. ~
~ ~lolIIotC1
~n "'- . _ L'~
.~ ~.;"::;"..:.~_:
; ...'......... ~,;....
.'.. ~~_.__:"..;".~_.. 'v.
'.-. .. -~. . ~
. '_ ...:._,. _ ~z:
'-::-:c-:~ .
u..'._.~~,-:'.o.::....:..
-~~..r....."..~._~.
~...-..~:..-.:.....~.. ~.
O'.7"_::-.u'.-~' _-"".,~__..' ~"""'.'.-
. .-.:-:.:_..;~. ~.:~ ._....~ ~'..
... 41:-"': . 1.." -:
,4_.._, _
. _r-.
'!,J_., .~....., ..,.
._ "'""' _. -... ..",... - ~""Io. ", ::'~..-;--
~ ~
.'
w......-:-
~
.. ~..-..
..~.-, ~-
.~..
........':,.
'. - ,.:.-::~.~i..:-.:~~'-,'_~~.~.:......-...........'..,'..; "'lJ"'~ ~:...,.-;i;',.".-- :n.,,:;:', ..;..,b~,...c,.."""":...~'"ZbI .~."'" """,~w:;.:.'-,'),-."...."" ...;~:;;.,,~,-''''..;.-:'"~: :J:;."""',:"7-.__.,.-
'~'-"~
.'~-
"~
_.
, .J
,-
Tf.....
,~. .
r:- -
~ ~
."~
9~.
... ~. ~ - ~
"~
'~:.,..: "",~~,..:iJ:i;<" ...,.n~.;~~~-::-'!,.._...........:;~i.=.::;-..-:..'O'... .~.....o:"~-"'~~":;-,''-'-'o..,,.,,',-.,.;.,"-,,~.-,,,..~~~...-.,
--~....
~
'--~'
...
.----;.:.....
,.,..'t'-'" -.: - .. --
. _ '.~_ _!-~<~"""- ,'~~;-';';---.iJ~~~~--..?-=:.~~-~~-:=-.;:;-: :-:'.~' .-....:;.__.~
~
-:;.
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
Trans Number
59158
Date
2/9/98 2:56:55 PM
Post Date
2/9/98
Payment Slip Nbr
MS 31304
CLIFTON ENTERPRISES
951 MINI STORAGE
Payor: CLIFTON ENT
Fee Information
Fee Code Description _~_ GL Account
1~BON!2_ DEPOSITS-COMM DEV (CASH BOND) 67000000022011300000
Total
Amount' Waived
$2197,00 I
$2197,00.
Payments
Payment Code
CHECK
AccounUCheck Number
081611463
Amount
$2197.00
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
$0.00 i
$2197.00 i
$2197.00 I
Total Paid
Memo:
Cashier/location: TERILLA_J / 1
User: NIX_S
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:
lIAR :[.J ,1QQQ
/98 2:57:36\JPfi'~
-6
"-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST TO APPROVE FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF LONGSHORE LAKE
UNIT FOUR AND APPROVAL THE PERFORMANCE SECURITY
OBJECTIVE:
To approve for recording the final plat of Longshore Lake Unit
Four.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The Board of County Commissioners on October 28, 1997 approved
the final plat of Longshore Lake Unit Four with the stipulation
that the plat not be recorded until security was provided to
ensure completion of the required subdivision improvements.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The fiscal impact to the County is listed below. The
project cost is $103,551.25, to be borne by the developer.
The security amount, equal to 100% of the cost to complete the
remaining improvements and 10% of the total cost of the project, is
$9,500.62. The developer has provided a Letter of Credit as the
required security. The County will realize revenues as follows:
Fund: Community Development Fund 113
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138900 - Development Services
Revenue generated by this project:
Total: $2331.12
Fees are based on a construction estimate of $103,551.25 and were
paid in August, 1997 and are reflected in the Executive Summary of
October 28, 1997.
A~ITEM
No. 8tfJJJ
MAR 2 3 1999
PI- /
'*
Executive Summary
Longshore Lake Unit Four
Page 2
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the final plat of
"Longshore Lake Unit Four II , with the following stipulations:
1) Accept the Letter of Credit as security to guarantee
completion of the Subdivision improvements.
2) Authorize the recording of the final plat of "Longshore
Lake Uni t Four II .
3) Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached
Construction and Maintenance Agreement.
4) That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the
required improvements have received preliminary
acceptance.
PREPARED BY:
)~ \~ ~\~...w ~
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
~.\t...qq
Date
REVIEWED BY:
ThO~,8.E~
Engineering Review Manager
5-/1- 99
Date
a6~ICP
Planning Services Department Director
APPROVED BY/1~ ~ ,
Lf;wf /I. ~~~
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
'] -/?rll
Date
3//?~?
Date
Community Dev. and Environmental Sves. DIVISION
AGENDA ITEM
No. 9(jt3
MAR 2 3 1999
PIL r1..
~:.
~~
~
"~~
. . c.a. ....
--;:.
~ - ,. f . '-.':" ."""" " 1 -- ~.-~_..
- _ ,': -:'.,..~0.;. I .~'.-
.. r --_.."
: ,.~ .--'.' ._.p, I
. ~ J
lft ~ - . - 1
:i I '-I " -
, ., .1
:1 .
) 4 .1
- ., . -,
" I . .,
"- .\1 -' , I
"" -
~ c ' .L ~.t. &.IT r .
c ...~~ -~-~... - -...--
.. I. "
I
..... . I -
:> .
z :, -
- .. ..
c :, . .
- . .
U. 2 . ~l .. ..
..1 -. c . E ,
... :, c
~ ., -
c::t J "
. ...e IttM c ....
-
l
. . '
-L.
I
I
I ..
1 I.
I I
- J ' ,
.' I ,I
~V~".C ....., J . ,..... C _.h:::.::' ·
~~~:;~---~::"i '~:1 '0S~K~
.. . ,c_'\ . .
_ ." '\ c
-., .
.& ,;
vI \-
I - . '
I
,"
-J~
E).
-,
1. [ C 'OUWTT
. .
COL.LltR CWWTT'
. ....-.J
~
...
--_.-. .
< ___ .." r,
. ..
. ,
:<:;:\t:Zi~i.t:.;;,rs, PRO J E C T '~
~~::~::~,~l-. '.,S.L'L'O. '''c': A~-'-T':-=lc~O">:;':N-- ~'~~ '.
.~_-: ;.:-:_ .:. :~":"_.:' ~,._ "0
-.-:.~ 4.~.~:~-;:7_~-:"~::~' ". " .. .- -. -: ~_:.- .' .-
.,...>;: -::--:';'
.. .
;:. -:,.,,<- i
,.:..
n:
.. '~.
.
'<II
.~
"
~~',tI!~C' · "'M.I4C1 IIW'T.',
..... .
]'~"'{:-, ;.3~'.-:..:;._i;.';...[~ .
:~ _ .. - . 'r .- ~:
-
..
-
..
.
~_.....-.._..-_...
-~. .
.. -'. -.-
.
.
.
.
..
-
..
..
..
"
La. ...
.........._---~~..
..
.
-
-
-
-
.
.
It e Z 0 D. P. tit i 011 It - a ,.- % C
~
LONGSHORE
LAKE
P.Uc o.
-
.
T. ac.&u
- ,
: "4'~-;.
.
LOCATION
MAP
NlBGAmM '
~-'
., -. .,
"~E'--::: "...-.' ....
.~
. :. .. . ..: c~~~;~:, :;;~~ ~:':""~~T:;;";;;~;~".;;:~"'~ ,,-:. . -
'".."_.' ,_.~,~,. ",.~~~~.,_~J:.
" -"~t:;::~,~7i:t~~~~.-; '~~:.~'" .~;:?~:.-:-~~:. '.:-:- ..
...........;.-'"':'-..-
'='
CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMEl\1' FOR SUBDIVISION
IMPROVEMENTS
THIS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION
IMPROVEMENTS entered into this day of , 1999 between
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P., a Delaware Limited Partnership, hereinafter referred to as
"Developer", and the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereinafter
referred to as the "Board".
RECITALS
A. Developer has, simultaneously with the delivery of this Agreement, applied for the
approval by the Board of a certain plat of a subdivision to be known as:
"Longshore Lake, Unit 4 "
B. Division 3.2 of the Collier County Land Development Code requires the Developer to
post appropriate guarantees for the construction of the improvements required by said
subdivision regulations, said guarantees to be incorporated in a bonded agreement for the
construction of the required improvements.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants
hereinafter set forth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows:
1. Developer will cause to be constructed: water, sewer, roadway, drainage,
and street lighting within 36 months from the date of approval said subdivision plat, said
improvements hereinafter referred to as the required improvements.
2. Developer herewith tenders its subdivision performance security (attached
hereto as Exhibit "A" and by reference made a part hereof) in the amount of $9,500.62 which
amount represents 10% of the total contract cost to complete construction plus 100% of the
estimated cost to complete the required improvements at the date of this Agreement.
3. In the event of default by the Developer or failure of the Developer to
complete such improvements within the time required by the Land Development Code, Collier
County may call upon the subdivision performance security to insure satisfactory completion of
the required improvements.
4. The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a
statement of substantial completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records
have been furnished to be reviewed and approved: by the Development Services Director for
compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code.
AGENDA ITEM
No. <;?{#)3
MAR 2 3 1999
,." 1../
\\Hma_naples\ WP\1986\1986029\WTC\cmasiUnit4.doc
--- ----.~ ...-. ..-----.-.-----.---".---...
. of
5. The Development Services Director shall, within sixty (60) days of receipt
of the statement of substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of his
preliminary approval of the improvements; or b) notify the Developer in writing of his refusal to
approve improvements, therewith specifying those conditions which the Developer must fulfill in
order to obtain the Director's approval of the improvements. However, in no event shall the
Deveiopment Services Director refuse preliminary approval of the improvements if they are in
fact constructed and submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this
Agreement.
6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum
period of one year after preliminary approval by the Development Services Director. After the
one year maintenance period by the Developer has terminated, the Developer shall petition the
Development Services Director to inspect the required improvements. The Development
Services Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found to be still in
compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by final approval by
the Board, the Board shall release the remaining 10% of the subdivision performance security.
The Developer's responsibility for maintenance of the required improvements shall continue
unless or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for and by the County.
7. Six (6) months after the execution of this Agreement and once within
every six (6) months thereafter the Developer may request the Development Services Director to
reduce the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security on the basis of work complete.
Each request for a reduction in the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security shall
be accompanied by a statement of substantial completion by the Developer's engineer together
with the project records necessary for review by the Development Services Director. The
Development Services Director may grant the request for a reduction in the amount of the
subdivision performance security for the improvements completed as of the date of the request.
8. In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to fulfill its obligations
under this Agreement, upon certification of such failure, the County Administrator may call upon
the subdivision performance security to secure satisfactory completion, repair and maintenance
of the required improvements. The Board shall have the right to construct and maintain, or cause
to be constructed or maintained, pursuant to public advertisement and receipt and acceptance of
bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision.
performance security, shall be liable to pay and to indemnify the Board, upon completion of such
construction, the final total cost to the Board thereof, including, but not limited to, engineering,
legal and contingent costs, together with any damages, either direct or consequential, which the
Board may sustain on account of the failure of the Developer to fulfill all of the provisions of this
Agreement.
All of the terms, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon
the Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer.
AGENDA ITEM
No. l? {fJV
MAR 2 3 1999
PlL6
W:\l 986\1 986029\WTOcmasiUnit4.doe
~
TN WlTN'"FSS VlHRRF.OF. the 'Rowand 'Oeveloper have c~n~ thi~.Agreement to be exe...."UteO
by their duly authorized representative this _ day of . 1999.
Signed, Sealed and Delivered
in the presence of:
~~Lu.
~
~l("~ C""'lLVb~~
~.!~T~)l>ed,N~_~u. .
/ , <<-
( -- ' ,
~ 0.1~ LiW: ,1n/(-L
. ed or T)-pe Nam.e)
A.ttest:
Dwight E. Brock. Cle:tk
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legal
s-ufficiency:
'd c.. Weigel.
Collier County Attomey
\\Hna_mpb\WP\1916\1~~. ~I i1B0517.doG
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P.
a DeIa.ware LiIMecl Partnership
doing bl1Siness in the State of Florida
as Long.omnre Lake Homes, Limited
I-artncrsbip
By: LLH General Partna, Inc.
a Delaware C.otp<'l1'aticm.
its General Partner
By:
A;.'. en, as taIy* AA ...LFt.--
with n power and authority to bind VVr7'-'-
the partneJ:sbip
and Vice President
Board of County Commissioners
of Collier County. Florida
By:
Pamela S. Mac'Kie
Chairwoman
AGENDA ITEM
No. Pi /l).:1
MAR 2 3 1999
PI. b
,.-
--
. E!~~T NATIONAL BANK
PO, Box 413043
Naples, Florida 34101-3043
Phone: (941) 262-7600
Fax: (941) 262-6267
IRREVOCABLE STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT NO. 12-98-0173
ISSUER:
First National Bank of Naples (hereinafter "Issuer").
900 Goodlette Road North
Naples, Florida 34102
PLACE AND DATE OF ISSUE:
900 Goodlette Road North
Naples, Florida 34102
December 22, 1998
PLACE OF EXPIRY:
At Issuer's counters.
DATE OF EXPIRY: This Credit shall be valid until December 22, 1999 and
shall thereafter be automatically renewed for successive one-year periods on
the anniversary of its issue unless at least sixty (60) days prior to any
such anniversary date, the Issuer notifies the Beneficiary in writing by
registered mail that the Issu~r elects not to so renew this Credit.
APPLICANT:
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P., a Delaware Limited Partnership.
BENEFICIARY: The Board of County Commissioners, Collier County,
(hereinafter llBeneficiary") Collier County Courthouse Complex,
Florida 34112.
Florida
Naples,
AMOUNT :
$9,500.62 (U.S.) up to an aggregate thereof.
CREDIT AVAILABLE WITH: Issuer.
BY: Payment against documents detailed herein and Beneficiary's drafts at
sight drawn on the Issuer.
DOCUMENTS REQUIRED: AVAILABLE BY BENEFICIARY'S DRAFT(S) AT SIGHT DRAWN ON
THE ISSUER AND ACCOMPANIED BY BENEFICIARY'S STATEMENT PURPORTEDLY SIGNED BY
THE COUNTY MANAGER, CERTIFYING THAT: "Longshore Lake Homes, L. P., a Delaware
Limited Partnership has failed to construct and/or maintain the required
improvements as shown on the plans for the subdivision known as Longshore
Lake Unit 4, or a final inspection satisfactory to Collier County, has not
been performed prior to the date of expiry, and satisfactory alternative
performance security has not been provided to and formally accepted by the
Beneficiary."
DRAFT (S) DRAWN UNDER THIS LETTER OF CREDIT MOST BE MARKED:
First National Bank of Naples' Credit No. 12-98-0173, dated
1998.11 The original letter of credit and all amendments, if
presented for proper endorsement.
"Where little things make a BIG difference."
"Drawn under
December 2 2 ,
an must be
AGENDA ITEM
No. f? (1)..1
MAR 2 3 1999
.... 1
.,.,
. E~~T NATIONAL BANK
PO, Box 413043
Naples, Florida 34101-3043
Phr~e: (941) 26~-7600
Fax: (941) 262-6267
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P.
Letter of Credit #12-98-0173
Page 2
This Letter of Credit sets forth in full the terms of the Issuer's
undertaking and such undertaking shall not in any way be modified, amended,
or amplified by reference to any documents, instrument, or agreement
referenced to herein or in which this letter of credit relates, and any such
reference shall not be deemed to incorporate herein by reference any
document, instrument or agreement.
Issuer hereby engages with Beneficiary that draft(s) drawn under and in
compliance with the terms of this credit will be duly honored by Issuer if
presented within the validity of this credit.
This credit is
Documentary Credits
publication No. 500.
subject to the
(1993 Revision)
Uniform CUstoms and
International Chamber
Practice for
of Commerce
FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF NAPLES
By:
Cn:
Vice President
AGENDA ITEM
No. &' GA).3
MAR 2 3 1999
~..
PI-
"Where little things make a BIG difference."
. -------.. .........- ","-
.... ---.. '"-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST TO APPROVE FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF LONGSHORE LAKE
UNIT 5-D AND APPROVAL THE PERFORMANCE SECURITY
OBJECTIVE:
To approve for recording the final plat of Longshore Lake Unit 5-
D.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The Board of County Commissioners on October 21, 1997 approved
the final plat of Longshore Lake Unit 5-D with the stipulation
that the plat not be recorded until security was provided to
ensure completion of the required subdivision improvements.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The fiscal impact to the County is listed below. The
project cost is $126,284., to be borne by the developer.
The security amount, equal to 100% of the cost to complete the
remaining improvements and 10% of the total cost of the project, is
$13,342.25. The developer has provided a Letter of Credit as the
required security. The County will realize revenues as follows:
Fund: Community Development Fund 113
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138900 - Development Services
Revenue generated by this project:
Total: $2750.00
Fees are based on a construction estimate of $126,284.20 and were
paid in August 1997, and are reflected in the Executive Summary of
October 21, 1997.
AGENDA ITEM
......./'Cf'I \ ~
......
MAR 2 3 1999
~ /
Executive Summary
Longshore Lake Unit 5-D
Page 2
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the final plat of
IILongshore Lake Unit 5-DII, with the following stipulations:
1) Accept the Letter of Credit as security to guarantee
completion of the Subdivision improvements.
2) Authorize the recording of the final plat of IILongshore
Lake Unit 5-DII.
3) Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached
Construction and Maintenance Agreement.
4) That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the
required improvements have received preliminary
acceptance.
PREPARED BY:
Jo~~ ~\cl.~,"~~~
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
!,. lib' qq
Date
REVIEWED BY:
~0~
Thomas E. Kuck, P.E.
Engineering Review Manager
s.. /1-- 9~
Date
~
~obert Mulhere, AICP
Planning Services Department Director
? '/;:Z <;- f
Date
APPROVED B~
VJ'~ -a-
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
~
3'7/f7
Date
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs. DIVISION
AGEJtI)A fTEM
No. ~(Ij) Lf
MAR 2 3 1999
.... ~
~:,
L::'.~l
~
'~
I . c..a. ....
- t t
... f .... .~ .:::..-.;-. I '.' --..
- .' -" 1
--~-... . . ~ I
.. - I
:S I .- r . -
, .1 .1
:1 .
J .. ..I
., . -,
- . &1
.c. ,
. ''-. ~ oJ I J
-
~ c . .,L ~u. "Tt: .
C ~-- -~_-... - ...---
... , ','
J
'.. ' I -
::> - lit
2 ~I .
- .. ..
c :, .. .
- . .
u.. 2 .. :, . ~.
..J -. c ~ ; ,
.. :, .. -
=' ., J
..' .. C) J
, ....c .,.., ....
....
l
..
L.
t
I
r
1
I
S
t
, I
~:-~...~:-..~~~:, ~
.-., ,~'.
I
, I
...;'!>,~-~'=-~
..
_I:
.,
.l
v.
I
I
.-..-.,
, pvtuaC
......
~-..w..~..~
;= -:~:~:_;'-7: ~r.~-j:.
__" ,~:::~~.:~'~~:3'"
:...._~ .
"
~.
..
.
". .c~U
-.
". --
,LEe CouffTT
I" -
I
,
I
I
...J
:,;,,1
--:'1
':1
" \
. \
\
"
'\
\
. '
.
. .
. eO\.Lltlt aNMTY
:"-'. .:. .' -
~.. "
..
....
---:.~:.:-: "
.
-
_o~~~,=~.-:,>:",' -PROJECT:.
-:r~f:0I~2LOCAti6N'
- ~'=--".-::- ~~'.-:::;-' "~.-: ~ ~ -..:
:-:-~~~;':'/'_., '.',.
:~.;f:.:';' ~-~ ~:.]- ::"~.'
- -.".<
., '.,-"::,.,
~:c <, '~~'!T a
'.
c
...
...
z
-
1m.
'-.
:'.:~~:;i;',P-:=:--~.~'~':"'~' "
r -.." _ .,- ."."- -:;-.
-
.
.
,;
"
- ...-.~.-. ....... - -...
~ :. ..
.
..
.
.
c.a. ...
-
'.
.
.
y
-~~.-_-_...._..
..... .
-:;:.
I
r
1
I
.. I
I
'.. J
"1
~.
.
~
.
: -
.'
>
-
J
-
-
"
-. .:";'
'" '
.'
Resoc.
Petitioc
R-'7.-2C
.;.
LONGSHORE
LAKE
P. U. D.
.
LOCATION
M
A.GDGA IlEM
NA.?~) LJ
. MARc 1.3, ,1999
-.... .'"
;;~-;. .-
~.-..;~" "-
"f~'<._tf % :e~X,:r:' 1
::- - .. ..... - -' -. ~ ::......-., -.. .
': '~iti~';o1'ijiti~:~,!~_~~i~;E: . - ,~~",-'-- c'J.
,..,-.;..." ."-,--~--,""-""""_.
::
CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION
IMPROVEMENTS
THIS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION
IMPROVEMENTS entered into this day of , 1999 between
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P., a Delaware Limited Partnership, hereinafter referred to as
"Developer", and the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereinafter
referred to as the "Board".
RECITALS
A. Developer has, simultaneously with the delivery of this Agreement, applied for the
approval by the Board of a certain plat of a subdivision to be known as:
"Longshore Lake, Unit 5D"
B. Division 3.2 of the Collier County Land Development Code requires the Developer to
post appropriate guarantees for the construction of the improvements required by said
subdivision regulations, said guarantees to be incorporated in a bonded agreement for the
construction of the required improvements.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants
hereinafter set forth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows:
1. Developer will cause to be constructed: water, sewer, roadway, drainage,
and street lighting within 36 months from the date of approval said subdivision plat, said
improvements hereinafter referred to as the required improvements.
2. Developer herewith tenders its subdivision performance security (attached
hereto as Exhibit "A" and by reference made a part hereof) in the amount of $13,342.25 which
amount represents 10% of the total contract cost to complete construction plus 100% of the
estimated cost to complete the required improvements at the date of this Agreement.
3. In the event of default by the Developer or failure of the Developer to
complete such improvements within the time required by the Land Development Code, Collier
County may call upon the subdivision performance security to insure satisfactory completion of
the required improvements.
4. The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a
statement of substantial completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records
have been furnished to be reviewed and approved by the Development Services Director for
compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code.
AGENDA ITEM
No. ?(t/) "I
MAR 2 3 1999
W:\ 1986\1986029\WTC\cmasiUnitSD.doc
PI. i..f
...
5. The Development Services Director shall, within sixty (60) days of receipt
of the statement of substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of his
preliminary approval of the improvements; or b) notify the Developer in writing of his refusal to
approve improvements, therewith specifying those conditions which the Developer must fulfill in
order to obtain the Director's approval of the improvements. However, in no event shall the
Development Services Director refuse preliminary approval of the improvements if they are in
fact constructed and submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this
Agreement.
6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum
period of one year after preliminary approval by the Development Services Director. After the
one year maintenance period by the Developer has terminated, the Developer shall petition the
Development Services Director to inspect the required improvements. The Development
Services Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found to be still in
compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by fmal approval by
the Board, the Board shall release the remaining 10% of the subdivision performance security.
The Developer's responsibility for maintenance of the required improvements shall continue
unless or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for and by the County.
7. Six (6) months after the execution of this Agreement and once within
every six (6) months thereafter the Developer may request the Development Services Director to
reduce the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security on the basis of work complete.
Each request for a reduction in the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security shall
be accompanied by a statement of substantial completion by the Developer's engineer together
with the project records necessary for review by the Development Services Director. The
Development Services Director may grant the request for a reduction in the amount of the
subdivision performance security for the improvements completed as of the date of the request.
8. In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to fulfill its obligations
under this Agreement, upon certification of such failure, the County Administrator may call upon
the subdivision performance security to secure satisfactory completion, repair and maintenance
of the required improvements. The Board shall have the right to construct and maintain, or cause
to be constructed or maintained, pursuant to public advertisement and receipt and acceptance of
bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision
performance security, shall be liable to pay and to indemnify the Board, upon completion of such
construction, the final total cost to the Board thereof, including, but not limited to, engineering,
legal and contingent costs, together with any damages, either direct or consequential, which the
Board may sustain on account of the failure of the Developer to fulfill all of the provisions of this
Agreement.
All of the terms, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon
the Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer.
AGEN)A ITEM
No. r<V/) 1./
MAR 2 3 1~g9
S'
PI,
\ \Hna_ napIes\ WP\1986\1986029\ WTC\cmuiUnitSD.doc
IN '\V1TNESS WHEREOF~ the Board and ~.eloper have C3ll.~ th~~ Agr.eeme.nt to be executed
by their duly authorized representative rhis _ day of , 1999.
Signed, Sealed and Delivered
ill th~ p~ce of:
JifJ ~ II
VJ.&~,- ~~\)~
(Printed or Typed Name)
Atrest::
Dwight E. Brock, elm
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form 3lld legal
sufficiency:
~)ML
&Vlii . Weigel
COllier County Attorney
\iHua_
. DS061l.dcc
-
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P.
a Delaware Limited Partnership
doing business in the State of Florida
as Longshore Lake Homes) Limited
Parmership
By: LLH General Partner. Inc.
a Delaware Corporation.
its Galc:ral Partner
Hy:
I
* AAL::J:/- .
A. , en, as SeCf w "'V~LL./'
\vith full pO\Vel' and. aulhotity to bind
the partnership
and Vice President
Board. of County Commissioners
of Collier County, Florida
By:
Pamela S. Mac'Kie
Chairwoman
AGENDA ITEM
No. R(8)4
MAR 2 3 1999
b
pc.
. f!~~T NATIONAL BANK
EO, Box 413043
Naples, Florida 34101-3043
Phone: (941) 262-7600
Fax: (941) 262-6267
IRREVOCABLE STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT NO. 12-98-0175
ISSUER:
First National Bank of Naples (hereinafter "Issuer").
900 Goodlette Road North
Naples, Florida 34102
PLACE AND DATE OF ISSUE:
900 Goodlette Road North
Naples, Florida 34102
December 22, 1998
PLACE OF EXPIRY:
At Issuer's counters.
DATE OF EXPIRY: This Credit shall be valid until December 22, 1999 and
shall thereafter be automatically renewed for successive one-year periods on
the anniversary of its issue unless at least sixty (60) days prior to any
such anniversary date, the Issuer notifies the Beneficiary in writing by
registered mail that the Issuer elects not to so renew this Credit.
APPLICANT:
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P., a Delaware Limited Partnership.
BENEFICIARY: The Board of County Commissioners, Collier County,
(hereinafter "Beneficiary") Collier County Courthouse Complex,
Florida 34112.
Florida
Naples,
AMOUNT :
$13,342.25 (U.S.) up to an aggregate thereof.
CREDIT AVAILABLE WITH: Issuer.
BY: Payment against documents detailed herein and Beneficiary's drafts at
sight drawn on the Issuer.
DOCUMENTS REQUIRED: AVAILABLE BY BENEFICIARY'S DRAFT(S) AT SIGHT DRAWN ON
THE ISSUER AND ACCOMPANIED BY BENEFICIARY'S STATEMENT PURPORTEDLY SIGNED BY
THE COUNTY MANAGER, CERTIFYING THAT: "Longshore Lake Homes, L. P., a Delaware
Limited Partnership has failed to construct and/or maintain the required
improvements as shown on the plans for the subdivision known as Longshore
Lake Unit 5D or a final inspection satisfactory to Collier County, has not
been performed prior to the date of expiry, and satisfactory alternative
performance security has not been provided to and formally accepted by the
Beneficiary."
DRAFT(S) DRAWN UNDER THIS LETTER OF CREDIT MUST BE MARKED:
First National Bank of Naples' Credit No. 12-98-0175, dated
1998." The original letter of credit and all amendments, i
presented for proper endorsement.
"Drawn under
December 22,
"Where little things make a BIG difference."
PI. 1
-=.-
. E!~~T NATIONAL BANK
P.O. Box 413043
Naples, Florida 34101-3043
Phone: (941) 262-7600
Fax: (941) 262-6267
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P.
Letter of Credit #12-98-0175
Page 2
This Letter of Credit sets forth in full the terms of the Issuer's
undertaking and such undertaking shall not in any way be modified, amended,
or amplified by reference to any documents, instrument, or agreement
referenced to herein or in which this letter of credit relates, and any such
reference shall not be deemed to incorporate herein by reference any
document, instrument or agreement.
Issuer hereby engages with Beneficiary that draft(s) drawn under and in
compliance with the terms of this credit will be duly honored by Issuer if
presented within the validity of this credit.
This credit is
Documentary Credits
Publication No. 500.
subject to the
(1993 Revision)
Uniform CUstoms and
International Chamber
Practice for
of Commerce
FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF NAPLES
Vice President
~fu
MAR 2 3 1929
"Where little things make a BIG difference,"
pt.
~
:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST TO APPROVE FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF LONGSHORE LAKE
UNIT 5-C AND APPROVAL THE PERFORMANCE SECURITY
OBJECTIVE:
To approve for recording the final plat of Longshore Lake Unit 5-
C.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The Board of County Commissioners on October 21, 1997 approved
the final plat of Longshore Lake Unit 5-C with the stipulation
that the plat not be recorded until security was provided to
ensure completion of the required subdivision improvements.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The fiscal impact to the County is listed below. The
project cost is $330,321.87, to be borne by the developer.
The security amount, equal to 100% of the cost to complete the
remaining improvements and 10% of the total cost of the project, is
$37,397.12. The developer has provided a Letter of Credit as the
required security. The County will realize revenues as follows:
Fund: Community Development Fund 113
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138900 - Development Services
Revenue generated by this project:
Total: $5490.00
Fees are based on a construction estimate of $330,321.87 and were
paid in August, 1997 and are reflected in the Executive Summary of
October 21, 1997.
4GENDA ITEM
No. ffjJ6
MAR 2 3 1999
PI. I
:-
Executive Summary
Longshore Lake Unit 5-C
Page 2
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the final plat of
"Longshore Lake Unit 5-C", with the following stipulations:
1) Accept the Letter of Credit as security to guarantee
completion of the Subdivision improvements.
2) Authorize the recording of the final plat of "Longshore
Lake Unit 5-C".
3) Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached
Construction and Maintenance Agreement.
4) That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the
required improvements have received preliminary
acceptance.
PREPARED BY:
J 0 l~...\ ~~ ~ \.tJ\p \.l...
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
'3.. I Ca ' q~
Date
REVIEWED BY:
~~iJ-
Thomas E. Kuck, P.E.
Engineering Review Manager
~~/l- r;9
Date
~
R~ert Mulhere, AICP
Planning Services Department Director
AP'/t7 BY: --/'_
v~~~~ero~, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
? ....y ,? ?9
Date
~:~
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs. DIVISION
AGENDA ITEM
No. ~)6
MAR 2 3 1999
PI.~
.~>
p~
',/-..:.....
~
l
.
L.
t
I
I
i
I
J
I
. J
. ,)
- -, ..' .
I
p,.
. ,,,,,,ec
..6.8
. ~. '- -'
-.-".--- .-.
.
"
_I'-
-I
.1
vi
I
I
. "
- 1
.- J
.. ~ J
:i I
.r
:1 :1 .
;) ..
., .
- .
.c. .J I
',,- ~ - I
~ c .L ...... c:.
.... c ....... -.~-...-
t- I. "
I
'.. . I
~ :I :,
..
c ... .
- -, .
p.. :I :, ..
..J -. c .
.. :, -
c
=' .,
0 J :
,"-' .
. ....c
.'
'.
E)"
-
..
, .
T. aC4\U
i.
I
,I
I
I ·
_ J -. ,.~-_:~~~'-=":-":'''~~:
~ ~.I :......-i.-;,.. ".. ,::' :~~~::..--'
,."~-"I
,t
\
\
"
"
,
\
. .
.. ..,
C:." . ,'c,", ~
, ,'C
. ",...
.-
c
--
...
z
-
c..a. ....
UTI'
------
....c
.
I
,
I
a
.... I
I
'.. J
'.,
'.
.,
1
q I
,
. J
.. I . '
.1
..I
..
-,
I
..
.
..
-
.
-.
-
:.
-
-
. LtC COUNTT ,. ,..
. .
COLLIER C'OUMTT'
.-
...
_.;'~.~~.,,; ':"'~'-'PROJECT'o
~-;~:1-.1't;i.oc At ION
.-::..:-~~~.~--'.-. ':
"-::,,,".i
:.
.. :
- .
"
",
.~
': ,I!~C' - ...M.t4n
:'~~~-;:5_~-..:::. "..~,~'._/-
1rrT.
.l"..... .
-~
,
-
-
-
.
.
v
~~_...-.._~----
.
<<I
.
.
ee....
C." ...
-
'.
..
.
y
-~....~_..-.----.
..
.
'.
..
..
-
-
-. ......~.
. .
.
It e z 0 D . P. lit i 0 D It - a 7.- 2. C
LAKE
P. u. o.
,;
LONGSHORE
.
LOCATION
MAP
AGEJ<<JA ITEM
No. .8" rd)~
.:';~1.17~~ll9_'
~~1~~:";~""
EXHX:eXT. :1.
,"::"~,.~::;;::j~.;~~.:;;tli:r~\.~~~~ki~~~~T.b,:t~~~;~J~~'
..' .-_. . ...--.''':'.... - .^"=
--
CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION
IMPROVEMENTS
THIS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDMSION
IMPROVEMENTS entered into this day of , 1999 between
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P., a Delaware Limited Partnership, hereinafter referred to as
"Developer", and the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida. hereinafter
referred to as the "Board".
RECITALS
A. Developer has, simultaneously with the delivery of this Agreement, applied for the
approval by the Board of a certain plat of a subdivision to be known as:
"Longshore Lake, Unit 5C"
B. Division 3.2 of the Collier County Land Development Code requires the Developer to
post appropriate guarantees for the construction of the improvements required by said
subdivision regulations, said guarantees to be incorporated in a bonded agreement for the
construction of the required improvements.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants
hereinafter set forth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows:
1. Developer will cause to be constructed: water, sewer, roadway, drainage,
and street lighting within 36 months from the date of approval said subdivision plat, said
improvements hereinafter referred to as the required improvements.
2. Developer herewith tenders its subdivision performance security (attached
hereto as Exhibit "A" and by reference made a part hereof) in the amount of $37,397.12 which
amount represents 10% of the total contract cost to complete construction plus 100% of the
estimated cost to complete the required improvements at the date of this Agreement.
3. In the event of default by the Developer or failure of the Developer to
complete such improvements within the time required by the Land Development Code, Collier
County may call upon the subdivision performance security to insure satisfactory completion of
the required improvements.
4. The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a
statement of substantial completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records
have been furnished to be reviewed and approved by the Development Services Director for
compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code.
AGENDA rrEM
No. R (A),s"
MAR 2 3 1999
W:\l 986\1 986029\WTC\cmasiUnitSC.doc
~ II
5. The Development Services Director shall, wi thin sixty (60) days of receipt
of the statement of substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of his
preliminary approval of the improvements; or b) notify the Developer in writing of his refusal to
approve improvements, therewith specifying those conditions which the Developer must fulfill in
order to obtain the Director's approval of the improvements. However, in no event shall the
Development Sv'rvices Director refuse preliminary approval of the improvements if they are in
fact constructed and submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this
Agreement.
6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum
period of one year after preliminary approval by the Development Services Director. After the
one year maintenance period by the Developer has terminated, the Developer shall petition the
Development Services Director to inspect the required improvements. The Development
Services Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found to be still in
compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by final approval by
the Board, the Board shall release the remaining 10% of the subdivision performance security.
The Developer's responsibility for maintenance of the required improvements shall continue
unless or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for and by the County.
7. Six (6) months after the execution of this Agreement and once within
every six (6) months thereafter the Developer may request the Development Services Director to
reduce the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security on the basis of work complete.
Each request for a reduction in the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security shall
be accompanied by a statement of substantial completion by the Developer's engineer together
with the project records necessary for review by the Development Services Director. The
Development Services Director may grant the request for a reduction in the amount of the
subdivision performance security for the improvements completed as of the date of the request.
8. In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to fulfill its obligations
under this Agreement, upon certification of such failure, the County Administrator may call upon
the subdivision performance security to secure satisfactory completion, repair and maintenance
of the required improvements. The Board shall have the right to construct and maintain, or cause
to be constructed or maintained, pursuant to public advertisement and receipt and acceptance of
bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision
performance security, shall be liable to pay and to indemnify the Board, upon completion of such
construction, the final total cost to the Board thereof, including, but not limited to, engineering,
legal and contingent costs, together with any damages, either direct or consequential, which the
Board may sustain on account of the failure of the Developer to fulfill all of the provisions of this
Agreement.
All of the terms, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon
the Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer.
AGEN>A ITEM
No. f? Cfl ) 6/
MAR 2 3 1999
~-S
W:\l 986\1 986029\WTC\cmasiUnitSC,doc
IN WITNESS WHEREOF. the Boord and neve~'(" have ~used ~ A.greement to be ~ecuf:ed
by thei.r duly authorized representative this _ day of . 199 9.
Sigced, Sealed 8Dd Delivered.
in the presence of:
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P.
a Delaware LiDUted Partnership
doing business in the State of Florida
as Longshore Lake Homes, Limited.
PartncrWp
By: LLH Genecal Partner, Inc.
a Delaware C':nfl\nr.:rtiou
it; General Partner
~ ..
--Ws ~ QLL
By:
A. . ~asS e ~ C?fd'~
with full power and authority to bind tiP c....c.....
the partnership
and Vice President
~ ~~ ~~~b'-"""""
(Printed. or Typed Name)
Attest:
Dwight 1=:. l3rock, Clerk
Board of County Commissioners
oreoDier County, Florida
By:
Deputy Clak
Pamela S. Mac'Kie
Chairwoman
Appro'lt:U. ~ to tunn antlleg-oll
sufficiency:
@
David C. Weigel
Collier CountY Attomey
AGENDA ITEM
No. ~ fA) S
MAR 2 3 1999
W'!t.l9S6\: 986O:!9\W'l'C'ltmIpi5C8105UJ.toe
PI. h
~-~-------- -...
'.:0.
: . a~?sT NATIONAL BANK
ro, Box 413043
Naples, Florida 34101-3043
Phone: (941) 262-7600
Fax: (941) 262-6267
IRREVOCABLE STANDBY LETTER OF CREDIT NO. 12-98-0176
ISSUER:
First National Bank of Naples (hereinafter llIssuerll).
900 Goodlette Road North
Naples, Florida 34102
PLACE AND DATE OF ISSUE:
900 Goodlette Road North
Naples, Florida 34102
December 22, 1998
PLACE OF EXPIRY:
At Issuer's counters.
DATE OF EXPIRY: This Credit shall be valid until December 22, 1999 and
shall thereafter be automatically renewed for successive one-year periods on
che anniversary of its issue unless at least sixty (60) days prior to any
such anniversary date, the Issuer notifies the Beneficiary in writing by
registered mail that the Issuer elects not to so renew this Credit.
APPLICANT:
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P., a Delaware Limited Partnership.
BENEFICIARY: The Board of County Commissioners, Collier County, Florida
(hereinafter "Beneficiary") Collier County Courthouse Complex, Naples,
Florida 34112.
.:;MOUNT :
$37,397.12 (U.S.) up to an aggregate thereof.
CREDIT AVAILABLE WITH: Issuer.
BY: Payment against documents detailed herein and Beneficiary's drafts at
sight drawn on the Issuer.
DOCUMENTS REQUIRED: AVAILABLE BY BENEFICIARY'S DRAFT(S) AT SIGHT DRAWN ON
THE ISSUER AND ACCOMPANIED BY BENEFICIARY'S STATEMENT PURPORTEDLY SIGNED BY
THE COUNTY MANAGER, CERTIFYING THAT: "Longshore Lake Homes, L.P., a Delaware
Limited Partnership, has failed to construct and/or maintain the required
improvements as shown on the plans for the subdivision known as Longshore
Lake Unit SC or a final inspection satisfactory to Collier County, has not
been performed prior to the 'date of expiry, and satisfactory alternative
performance security has not been provided to and formally accepted by the
Beneficiary."
DRAFT (S) DRAWN UNDER THIS LETTER OF CREDIT MUST BE MARKED: "Drawn under
First National Bank of Naples' Credit No. 12-98-0176, dated December 22,
1998." The original letter of credit and all amendments, if any, must be
presented for proper endorsement.
AGENDA ITEM
No. <is' (J1~ s:
MAR 2 3 1999
"Where little things make a BIG difference."
-. -- ~- '-;-..:~ -~__""'I"o:.: -........L!:"'~......,;....~~~ ..~__ ..
-Jtf. 1/
.
"
. f!~~T NATIONAL BANK
PO. Box 413043
Naples, Florida 34101.3043
Phone: (941) 26'7600
Fax: (941) 262.6267
Longshore Lake Homes, L.P.
Letter of Credit #12-98-0176
Page 2
This Letter of Credit sets forth in full the terms of the Issuer's
undertaking and such undertaking shall not in any way be modified, amended,
or amplified by reference to any documents, instrument, or agreement
referenced to herein or in which this letter of credit relates, and any such
reference shall not be deemed to incorporate herein by reference any
document, instrument or agreement.
Issuer hereby engages with Beneficiary that draft(s) drawn under and in
compliance with the terms of this credit will be duly honored by Issuer if
presented within the validity of this credit.
This credit is
Documentary Credits
publication No. 500.
subject to the
(1993 Revision)
Uniform Customs and
International Chamber
Practice for
of Commerce
FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF NAPLES
. Sammons, Vice President
AGENDA ITEM
No. f? (IJ) ({
MAR 2 3 \999
f'
~
"Where little things make a BIG difference,"
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST TO APPROVE THE FINAL PLAT OF "CANDLEWOOD THREE"
OBJECTIVE:
To approve the final plat of
lands located in Section 24,
Collier County, Florida.
"Candlewood Three",
Township 48 South,
a subdivision of
Range 25 East,
CONSIDERATION:
Engineering Review Section has completed the review of the
construction drawings, specifications, and final plat of "Candlewood
Three" . These documents are in compliance with the County Land
Development Code and Florida State Statute No. 177. All fees have
been paid. It is the intent of the developer to construct the
improvements for this project prior to recording of the plat or to
furnish the required amount of approved security for recording
purposes at a later date. This procedure would be in conformance
with Division 3.2 of the Collier County Land Development Code.
Engineering Review Section recommends that the final plat of
"Candlewood Three" be approved with the stipulation that the final
plat not be recorded until the required improvements have been
constructed and accepted or until the approved security is received
to guarantee completion of the required improvements.
FISCAL IMPACT: The fiscal impact to the County is as follows.
The project cost is $66,728.15, to be borne by the
developer.
The cost breakdown is as follows:
a) Water & Sewer - $35,863.00
b) Drainage,
Paving & Grading - $30,865.15
The County will realize revenues as follows:
Fund: Community Development Fund 113
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138900 - Development Services
Revenue generated by this project:
Total: $1,686.96
Fees are based on a co~st:uction estimatE ofA~~)~
$66,728.15 and were pa~d ~n December, 19c8, ~n ~n~~
March, 1999.
MAR 2 3 1999
I
PI.
Executive Summary
Candlewood Three
Page 2
The breakdown is as follows:
a) Plat Review Fee
($425.00 + $ 4./ac)
- $445.00
b) Construction Drawing Review Fee
Water &
Sewer (.50% const. est.) - $179.31
Drainage,
Paving, Grading (.425% const. est.)- $131.17
c) Construction Inspection Fee
Water &
Sewer (1.5% const. est.) - $537.95
Drainage,
Paving & Grading (1.275% const. est- $393.53
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
The Concurrency Waiver and Release relating to conditional
approval has been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's
Office for the project.
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the final plat of
"Candlewood Three" with the following stipulations:
1) That the final plat not be recorded until the required
improvements have been constructed and accepted or until
approved security is received for the uncompleted
improvements and that construction shall be completed within
36 months of the date of this approval.
2) Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached Construction
and Maintenance Agreement.
3) That no building permits be issued until the final plat is
recorded.
4) That any outstanding issues with the construction plans and
plat are resolved prior to the pre-construction meeting.
AGEN>? ~)Z
No.i
MAR 2 3 1999
~
pc.
Executive Summary
Candlewood Three
Page 3
PREPARED BY:
~~-\. ~d~\N~
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
REVIEWED BY:
~ 21U
Thomas E. Kuck, P.E.
Engineering Review Manager
R6~ AICP
Planning Services Department Director
APP~Y'
~d-
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
~
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs. DIVISION
jrh
~'/8"9q
Date
3//~/9f
Da t e .
{1~;:
S-y9-9?
Date
A~~
No.-1..l6.)!e...
MAR 2 3 1999
PI. 3
,.. ~..... · !/1
- _.~A-~
1_ -.: ~ - ~\ OJ!'! -=
-.-.\/....-.- .
--- fI -'-
." CJl_ .., " _
I .,~
i =?~l-=
_~ i ~D -:.~ _ .:.....
~ - +=ITl ~~ _II = --
. - \ r u,-.J, L
~ ,.,. _ fc.A. ~ , /'......lll._
l "\ ~. _..- ~
\,~ ~ ~-~c~ ~~ ...:..
~r-~~~
U- ~r -..;0; ~
.
~
, t
~:fii:. ..
U PROJECT
LOCATIOf\
~
l
. I
"
H
.
i = I
! '
TT II: ] J I I 0.:--
-- .:-. I ~
--:I~
"-,All
"'II.I:llOf
..
~ .... \.~ 1 l!i'-
...- I' '::1~ r~ .:.
1_-
_ ~I __we
~ \ _~ ~P\I)
\ \
~ ~ i \ '
-: !:'" 1 . \ .:.
_I.M<< - I -
'IUAI 5 ~
, ~_ 5
... - ::IIF~' -..ao - C)lJ.
~ I' I ~ '\
; ~- --- ---
~ -- ....,..,
.:: ~:---- .r ~
· J , II ~mL
II I I, ~~-' ... YU,
-- [::i' l5U&o n,;; ,
I -.-u, r-MQIlIl I'"
: -= --~ I
--
1MB
--
. ~ .
l~~~
I
"\
\..
~
~.
I~
g
,
.- .
~ :_~ ~~. ~ '"rJi\
r!:.'!D<< [f' ,.J I .. ~- - jllillr[[~ ~ P-'C/l'
=- I: ~ l...J' 1-'. a ~
I. i:D N = a-. .
,__ r-+- ~... .., D
I-~
::: ~
~
u
~-
I
l:5
LOCATION MAP
AGEN>A Il9'
NO. 'X'/~)"
MAR 2 3 1999
PI, 1-
, Ill" It TIll f\ I
~-,
~::..,~
CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT
FOR SUBDIVISION IMPROVEMENTS
PRIOR TO RECORDING OF f>LA T
THIS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION IMPROVEMENTS
PRIOR TO RECORDING OF PLAT AGREEMENT entered into this _ day of . 19 between
Peek-BenderJnc. . (hereinafter referred to as "Developer"), and the Board of County Commissioners
of Collier County, Florida, (hereinafter referred to as the "Board").
RECITALS:
1. Developer has, simultaneously with the delivery of this Agreement, applied for the approval by
the Board of a certain plat of a subdivision to be known as: Candlewood Three
2. Division 3,2 of the Collier County Land Development Code allows the Developer to construct
the improvements required by said subdivision regulations prior to recording the final plat.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants hereinafter set
forth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows:
1. Developer will cause to be constructed:
within ~ months from the date of approval of said subdivision plat, said improvements hereinafter referred to
as the required improvements.
2. Developer herewith agrees to construct said improvements prior to recording said subdivision
plat and the Board of County Commissioners shall not approve the plat for recording until said improvements
have been completed.
3. Upon completion of said improvements, the Developer shall tender its subdivision performance
security in the amount of $ 6.632.05 which represents 10% of the total contract cost to complete construction.
Upon receipt of said subdivision performance security by the Development Services Director, the Developer may
request the Board of County Commissioners to approve the subdivision plat for recording and grant preliminary
approval of said plat.
4. The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a statement of substantial
completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records have been furnished to be reviewed and
approved by the Development Services Director for compliance with the Collier County Land Development
Code.
5. The Development Services Director shall, within sixty days of receipt of the statement of
substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of his preliminary approval of the improvements;
or b) notify the Developer in writing of his refusal to approve the improvements, therewith specifying those
conditions which the Developer must fulfill in order to obtain the Director's approval of the improvements,
However, in no event shall the Development Services Director refuse preliminary approval of the improvements
if they are in fact constructed and submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this Agreement.
~A~
No. B (fl)Cp
MAR 2 3 1999
Pf..~
2117~9I53 Ver 02!-AMCINTOS
n.Li....LC~I,.
03117..QOO..OOI-ECOR-21932
.
.
6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum period of one year after
preliminary approval by the Development Services Director, After the one year maintenance period by the
Developer has tenninated, the Developer sildll petition lhe Development Services Director to inspect the required
improvements. The Development Services Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found
to be still in compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by final approval by the
Board, the Board shall release the 10% subdivisionperfonnance security. The Developer's responsibility for
maintenance of the required improvements shall continue unless or until the Board accepts maintenance
responsibility for the County.
7. In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to fulfill its obligations under this Agreement,
upon certification of such failure, the County Administrator may call upon the subdivision perfonnance security
to secure satisfactory completion, repair and maintenance of the required improvements. The Board shall have
the right to construct and maintain, or cause to be constructed and maintained, pursuant to public advertisement
and receipt of acceptance of bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the
subdivision perfonnance security, shall be liable to pay and to indemnify the Board, upon completion of such
construction, the final total cost to the Board thereof, including, but not limited to, engineering, legal and
contingent costs, together with any damages, either director or consequential, which the Board may sustain on
account of the failure of the Developer to fulfill all of the provisions of this Agreement.
8. All of the tenns, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon the
Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Board and the Developer have caused this Agreement to be executed by their
duly authorized representative this _ day of . 19_.
Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of:
Witnesses to (Developer Name):
.s~
Step~A.Meansfl h _ ~
C~.....t!.- r h ~ <- ~ /
Anne P. McIntosh
PE
Devel e
By: .>
Robert P. Bender, Vice President
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
Pamela S. Mac'kie, Chairwoman
Approved as to fonn and
IJ:L~C1J J~
David C. Weigel, County Attorney
~
A~!'.tIDj
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
~
pt.
2117199-4915] Vor: 021.AMCINTOS
........LC~
03117.QOO.OOI-ECOIl-%I91%
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST TO APPROVE FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF "ASHLEY GROVE"
OBJECTIVE:
To approve for recording the final plat of Ashley Grove, a
subdivision of lands located in Section 13, Township 49 South, Range
25 East, Collier County, Florida.
CONSIDERATION:
Engineering Review Section has completed the review of the final plat
of "Ashley Grove". This document is in compliance with the County
Land Development Code and Florida State Statute No. 177. All fees
have been paid. There are no subdivision related improvements
associated with this plat.
Engineering Review Section recommends that the final plat of "Ashley
Grove" be approved for recording.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The County will realize revenues as follows:
Fund: Community Development Fund 113
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138900 - Development Services
Revenue generated by this project:
Total: $450.00 Plat Review Fees
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
The Concurrency Waiver and Release relating to conditional approval
has been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's Office for
the project.
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the Final Plat of
"Ashley Grove" with the following stipulations:
1. Authorize the recording of the Final plat of "Ashley
"
AGENDA ~
No. ~(JJ)1
MAR 2 3 1999
pt. /
Executive Summary
Ashley Grove
Page 2
PREPARED BY:
-bt\~ V\.\~~~\i
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
REVIEWED BY:
~~~
Thomas E. Kuck, P.E.
Engineering Review Manager
R6b~, AICP
Planning Services Department Director
APPRO~
~t4-
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP Administrator
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs.
4
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs. DIVISION
~. I 2> .. ere;
Date
';?-/$-?j
Date
"1:/7- ?5-
Date
Date
AGENDA ITEM
No. ~(A)1
MAR 2 3 1999
d
PI.
~.
t
I
Ii! 4TH A
W E ~ 7
i
::J
~
S ~
~
~
...
~
l~ ]f~M"D~~
· J 11
2HO A'o'E. Sow.
18
1If
i
(!
~
1 nT~ 1 TWOn1 Ir.W ~ nC" 01 n('v un" "C" VC'~'<:"""f"T""" 0 A nv ...."......~
t
~
r
23
24
LOCATION MAP
NOT TO SCALE
DESCRIPTION OF' LANDS PLATTEO
14TH A, SW,
ll1TH AI/ s.w,
0-
Il>
-<
...
>-
-<
.
20TH AI/ s.w,
~
UNO AI/ SW
24TH AIi SW
~tl~
No. fA
MAR 2 3 1999
PI. 3
--
RECOMMENDATION FOR THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS TO SETTLE THE CASE OF EVELYN FIELD Jt:
COLLIER COUNTY, CASE NO. 98-3183-CA-Ol, NOW PENDING IN THE
CIRCUIT COURT FOR THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA FOR $39,750 PLUS PAYMENT OF
MEDIATOR'S FEES IN AN APPROXIMATE AMOUNT OF $300.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain Board approval of a settlement reached in mediation in the case
of Evelyn Field v. Collier County, Case No. 983183-CA-01, now pending in the Circuit Court for
the Twentieth Judicial Circuit for Collier County, Florida in the amount of$39,750 plus payment
of mediator's fees in an approximate amount of$300.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Field case arises out of a collision between a vehicle driven by
Mrs. Evelyn Field, the plaintiff, and a parked County truck that occurred on December 23, 1996.
~ Mrs. Field alleges the truck was parked at the side of the roadway in a negligent manner and in
violation of Section 316.194, Fla. Stat. Mrs. Field also claims that she suffered soft tissue
injuries to her cervical spine area as well as carpal tunnel syndrome due to the accident. In
addition, Mrs. Field claims. that she injured her knee in the accident and that this will require
arthroscopic surgery in the future. To date, Mrs. Field has incurred approximately $11,229 in
medical bills and anticipates incurring an additional $10,000 in medical bills and rehabilitation
services as a result of the proposed arthroscopic surgery.
This case was sent to Court ordered mediation, which was held on March 4, 1999. As a result of
the mediation, the Office of the County Attorney and the Risk Management Department agree
and recommend to the Board a settlement with the following principal terms:
1. The County would pay Mrs. Field $39,750 in settlement of all of her claims as
well as any claims of loss of consortium by her husband.
2. The County would pay Mrs. Field's portion of the mediator's fee, which is
estimated to be approximately $300.
3. The County would receive an appropriate release and Mrs. Field would dismiss
the lawsuit with prejudice.
AGENDA ~M
No. q_
.} -i 'ICQ9
.",.J..i', (.... .,.I'fJ
~
4.
Neither party would admit any fault or liability.
1
Pg.
/
The case is set for trial beginning on the April 1, 1999 trial docket.
FISCAL IMPACT: If the settlement is approved, the cost to the County will be
$39,750 plus the cost of Mrs. Field's mediation fees. In addition, the County will bear its own
costs in this action, which to date are estimated to be in the range of $3,000. Payment of the
settlement sum will be from the County's Property and Casualty Fund No. 516-121650. Should
the County decide to rej ect the proposed settlement, it is estimated that it will cost the County at
least an additional $8,000 to prepare and try the case. In addition, should the County be found
liable to Mrs. Field, it would have exposure to damages up to its sovereign immunity cap of
$100,000 although the more likely estimated damages Mrs. Field could recover should she be
fully successful at trial would be in the neighborhood of$65,000.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
RECOMMENDATION: To approve the settlement reached at mediation in Field v. Collier
County, and authorize the Chairwoman to execute the appropriate settlement documents.
~ ,,-.-.
PREPARED BY: ~!l#
Michael W. Pettit
Assistant County Attorney
Date:
J'JIS/99
, ,
REVIEWED BY:~~
e Walker, Director
Risk Management Department
Date: ..i')~~
APPROVED BY: ~(! H.
David C. Weigel
County Attorney
Date: ..J /Is / f1
h:Lit\Field-ExSum-Settlement
AGENDA ITEM
No. 1" It-
h;'l~ 2 3 1999
Pg. ,~
r-
2
,',
MEMORANDUM
DATE: March 12,1999
TO: Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Timothy 1. Constantine, Vice Chairman
Commissioner, District 3
RE: Sheriffs Department - Building A
Recently the Board of County Commissioners spent a great deal of time searching for
the most appropriate \'lay to handle the Sheriffs Department's Building A and space
dilemma, The stated desire from the Sheriff s agency and from the Board of County
Commissioners had several parts.
The most important of those parts included moving the Building A employees as soon as
possible from what is perceived to be an unhealthy situation. A further point \...ould be
to minimize the expense and maximize efficiency of such a move, and finally, to
minimize the number of times the individuals would have to move.
I believe I have a solution that meets each of the above and takes advantage of the one
year leasing decision already made.
The Sheriff s employees are scheduled to move out in the next couple of weeks to
temporarily leased quarters. Unfortunately, our current plan also calls for those same
employees to move at least two and possibly three more times.
It seems a more logical solution would be to move ahead and build the administrative
space the Sheriffs Department needs llillY. It is scheduled to begin construction in 18 -
24 months anyway.
We already have a design/build team in place and if we act reasonably quickly they can
have permanent space available in one year when the new temporary leases expire.
The result would be only one more move for the employees, a permanent solution 18 -
24 months ahead of schedule, saved ta'{payer money and dramatically improved
efficiency.
POTENTIAL CONCERNS AND RESPONSES
1. DR! must be completed prior to building on the campus.
Response: The net result of closing Building "A" and adding space in "]" is zero
impact.
2. The campus needs additional parking.
Response: Provide temporary and overflow parking on vacant land until a
parking structure is developed.
3. Stormwater impacts need to be addressed.
Response: The impacts from the new building will be addressed during design.
Campus-wide deficiencies will be addressed during the DRl over the
next two years.
4. The central plant capacity may not be adequate to handle the additional loads.
Response: By vacating "A" for newer, more efficient space at Building "1", the
impacts would be minimized and could be met with additional ice
storage.
5. Project costs are unbudgeted,
Response: The Commission can borrow short term and address the issue more
completely in the upcoming ,budget cycle.
SPACE ALTERNATIVES
Recent events have focused considerable attention on the County's immediate and long
term space needs to,address its expanding operational requirements, In anticipation of
the County's growing needs, the Departm~nt of Facilities Management commissioned a
Master Space Plan Study which projected agency growth through the year 2017. This
comprehensive work was phased in order to balance needs with budgets, addressing the
most pressing needs in Phase 1.
Several elements of Phase I (to be completed by 2002) of the approved County Master
Plan included the demolition of Building "A" and multiple additions to Building "J".
The Building "J" additions, labeled J-l, J-2 and J-3, would add 34,509 square feet for
Sheriff administration as J-l and 59,810 square feet for Sheriff operations as J-2.
Additionally J-3 was for Jail housing and support and total 93,640 square feet.
To alleviate the immediate problem with Building "A" and ccntinue to pursue the goals
of the Master Plan, the County has two reasonable options. See attached excerpts from
the Master Plan, Either option would require moving the current occupants of Building
"A" to lease space on a temporary basis.
Option 1
Build the 34,509 square foot J-l addition and upon completion move staff from rental
space into the new building. The net impact to the campus infrastructure is minimal since
Building "A" would be abandoned.
Option 2
Build the 59,810 square foot J-2 addition and upon completion, move staff from rental
space into one floor of the new building. Following completion of the DR! process,
move the Sheriff into the remaining space to fulfill his space needs in accordance with
the Master Plan.
Campus infrastructure impacts from Option 2 would need to be closely coordinated to
ensure adequate central plant capacity and parking.
Schedule
Design
Construction
3 - 4 months
8 -10 months
Total
11 - 14 months
Budget
Option 1
34,509 square feet J--l
Building Cost, Site Cost, AlE Fees, Contingencies
Option 2
59,810 square feet J-2 with Half Shell Space
Building Cost, Site Cost, AlE Fees, Contingencies
.d' ))
~S -'
$4,774,000
f} '')(7
$6,305,000
.' ,-' - '~'-"
C::'t:l(')ctl't:l"O
. . . 0 - ll.l 03 ~, 5' ffi
oOJ(')=.:~ ~nVl
. rn ." g ctl S ~ -:;:, ~ 't:l _. is' ctl
. OJ x, o"o:-"iS..5__
. 0 0 '0 ~. ~ 0 = '" '" _ _ 0
W -N_ -mnn_
. . ci OJ ~& ! ~ I ~ ~IR~I~Ogg;
., OJ ~ ~ o:~ -. W ~_s~"._~~~~
~c.- c:: E E ,"no ~o _ ~A::lR' ~'t:lOctl:::r:::r_~
.0Q 0: ~ - -&0_ BOJ~ .000_
n 3 "'...< ""tll.nz-<,,,",,,OJOOoo~o,~,.
~i_ ~ ~ 6!O~O.aoOJOJ .=~~~-~--oon"
-, ctl - ~o 0 0 '" -< mo. 0 0 -" 0 ~ " . 0 9' ! OJ Q. . < ~ ;:. 0'-
is = O' I -. W -<.. 0 - m n m _. 0. _ . 0 _ _ , 0 0. _ ~ = "
< =, ::l .J\) ""l 0 ,~';r - 0 1? < · 0 < en. 0: _. 0 . _." 0 s. "'0 __. ctl Vl-
< · - - - - < a , - - 0 '" - , _ 0 -. _ 0 _ . _ '" 0
Q g " ~ 0 ~ L "' ". ~ ;;. !!. 0 0 - m 0, '" ~ 3 ' ~ _ 90 '0- 0 = 0 , ,
T -'0_, -0:--T_.~-3~"'~.crOJ' -=N .."o=on
~ o'w.-~"50 QO-~--~~6~"'_ n-ox.o
"~=:"'-o"<Com_ m.o, -00'll>(J'1 OCJ~'t:l_3
O (.J'I 0 ll.l to c.o c.o ..... -< C. n :::- ~ ~ - c. _ C, A to c::::l _, ll.l :::r
,o"!"'2L."o,,,, 0;;;3:::900 5:::"'03", -0='0,,-
" " 0. '1" .:. '0 iU , - 0 ;;;'" 0 .. ~ '" 5' . co _ '" ~ ':;. :g. 1:. !'.
::lowo -R~mo= =:~Owgn ~~~~O ",om'o.m
n 0 wm-_1B Q;;;!~!!.!!. ""'="'OVl 5~~0~_:::r
"'Z'O~ ~."..- . .0 m --_ _ 9'0--0
I!i- ~. ':'.ng !!.~~~~~ ~~B~~ 'tll~;~~
- -L <0 -00, '2o"~oo oOn_", "'0< -0
p~ ~ · ~o,_ oo._~ocr ~Qo 0 .~-O:tll,
o - <0 ~ " ,. g 0 n. ~ . _ " "' 0 is = s. ~
a - ~--~ .5Po~n 0 5 - ~~..o:~
'" · <0 ~ ~ n 2',. 0 - 0 , 0 0 ffi _" _ 0
o "'offim ~o,,~ 0 0 0 '2 oo!!.,~
- c..=., ~::l - T"O :::r Ul,~ 0- '0 C. Ul tCo _,
- .00_ o=~o 0 0 =-_o~
'.. 0 '0 '! , 0 0 0 15. "0 0 o' .,
'" , ;; - - .. 0 · · 0 · 0 "., _ 0
N " N '" = - - 0 0 - a:, _. 0 0 ,,_
· -'00 ~,,-o. n. '0_ 5
- . OQ.. - "'0'0 m <C. 0
=0 =~~Q. 0 ~o ffi
'.0.0.. @ =
Vl _)( g
c::
iii'
(f)
. ..... ..". :-I.1:~.,~':~~,~.~.....::_:",.""" .r
~ 0
2. ~
'0 '
~
o
8 ~
::l !l:l
@ ....
~ ~
+
<..~
l.O
a,
o
'"
,Q
....
(Jl
o
+
~
o
""
"....
o
o
o
+
'"
c:
.- .c
o '"
-l l.O
:> <..~
,
~ +
o ""
C .::.
..... <..~
C1 :E
:>
;::;
:>
C1 .
m l.O
(Jl ""
c: "~
, 0
c;
C1
(Jl
'- .:.
:;>0 "...
'- (Jl
"" '"
(Jl
c
c:
(Jl Q
-l
:>
-l
6
z
(Jl
~ 0
o
(")
J:
r=
r-
m
;::; c
"'C
,
:>
z
-l
01 -
o "0
~ l.O
l.O 0
(Jl <.0
o 0
l.O
,':;.a...
(Jl (Jl ~ ~ ~ C1 C1 C1 ~ ~ ~ ~
gg~~~~~~~~.g:.g:
~ ~ ~ (Jl ~ ~ ~ ] z ~ ~ '
~ l>
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
^ ^ '- '- '- '- J: C1 ~ m 0 (") (")
~ ~ ~ N N ...
Q c:
~ ~
~ Q
~ :>
~ ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 ~
(Jl .... ~ '" ~
o .... (Jl a,
m l.O
....
.:.
o
C,.l
.....
o
o
+
'"
01
l.O
"",
<0
(Jl
~ .... I\> 0 0 0 0
'0 C,.l <0
(Jl .... ~
o ....
m
I\> 0 <0
m U,
<0 I\>
~ <J1
<0
<J1
o~:~~~~::e.~~~
~~~5:~~~~~~~0
o <0 0 <0 0 0 ~ I\>
Q .c.. : c
:
c.c ... -.. ..... Q
to !.J <0 _
<N ... (." N
<J1 <0 0 ~
I\> 0
o <J1 0 0 0
"C'l
CD
<J1
..
-
'....
<J1
I\>
~ CD <J1 CD
~ !-.J '"en U'1
?' to I\> '<0
-. 0 U'1 ...
0.... I\>
C
+
(Jl
<0
a,
...
c
+
(...l
....
(Jl
o
<0
+
<0
(...l
"en
....
o
CJ"tO--..~r\J
~~~~~~
<J1 <0 0 Q (Jl
I\> 0 0
N "tl
Q ::l:
Q - l>
.!::! CIl
m
:g~~ "T\CI'J
jijOlO'O.o
",2::.~~
Q ::l 0 ~ ii>
- <0 l':l
O~~N~
-g~C:c~O:
~=o~c....
o' en a" N
~ :- ~
,:"
?'
....
<..~
o
o.:::~~~N~_
~ '.... !!!.
?' :: ~ ~, ~
",. '" l':l l>
:-~
6:QoO[
~5~5C:
o'~o_.,
:::oc:Ol':l~
~ ~ ~
-
is ~
0.('1
~" g
~
0. l':l I\>
iii' ~ ~
!2-~
o' is
::: '"
~
~c;
o l':l
So <
l':l e.
< 0
=:'0
c..
CD I\>
....01
0<0
"'~
'0 IC
Ol <J1
a ~
<J1C1Cl
'" =: s,
sa-.gE
is' Q
~ ...
~ :_~
~r
:> (...l - c:
c.. .... I\> 50,
9: r..."1 ~ E
:=:00
o l.O ::, '-
= tit (':) -
E::... CII
~~::l~
o.="enE
Cf):r....
c: 0 0 '-
'0 c: '" to;
'8 s. :-
:.~
.~ ~ ~
l::j:2.g-
~
c.-~
c..!!!.E
=. 0
g -< ~
6'
~'"
-'0
o 01
.3.Q
(") o~
~c~~
c:: ::: IV
;J o."C
(jig ~c
~1Il 2:
Q o.
~~
_ 5'
~ iii'
~~
S.
:i"
i:~~~
g;-<~c;::
3 Iii,
0" 01-
-< ::lO
c."'
iil6:~ ~~~~
CDa.S=.~~:;' (D
:2. '0 ~=.:::
g. [ ~ ~~
~o~
Q.l 2. c
g; ~ ~
-QQ
a
~
~4~riff ~(ln ~untcr
RECE1VED
Collier County Sheriff's Office
3301 Tamiami Trail East
Building "J"
Naples, FL 34112
Telephone (AC 941) .774-44'34
March 5, 1999
v!A;~ fi ;1 !('{'~('
. ,,\.~ :...;.')' j
~ ( ~ ,i ;... , :
;;:Iln',:
,~:,:/"'ri~ ':.~ ~ ;:'n-2:'
Commissioner Timothy Constantine
Collier County Board of Commissioners
Administration Building
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
RE: Space Alternatives
Dear Commissioner Constantine:
Reference our meeting on March 4, 1999, I have reviewed the space alternatives you presented. I
believe that Option 2 best addresses our needs. specifically a single building with one completed floor
and one shelled-out floor, This would reduce, to a minimum, the disruption caused by the site
development phase of construction, and should allow some economies since it \vill require less
foundation (total area) be built. This building could fit on the south side of Building "J," generally
facing U.S, 41,
I, and the Agency, appreciate the extra and innovative efforts you have contributed to the solving of
this problem. If[ can be of any assistance. please don't hesitate to call on me,
Sincerely.
r:::
1--""............
D1I:GY:mc
CC:Filc:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO THE HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD
--- OBJECTIVE: To appoint two members to fulfill the remainder ofyacant terms expiring on
June 25,2001 and June 25, 2002, on the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board.
CONSIDERATIONS: This 9 member board identifies and evaluates problems unique to the
Hispanic Community, reviews and recommends ways to ensure open communication between
the minorities and Collier County Government and provides periodic reports to the Board of
County Commissioners. Terms are 4 years. A list of the current membership is included in the
backup.
A press release was issued and resumes were received from the following 2 interested citizens:
APPLICANT
CA TEGORY
DIST
ELECTOR ADV. COMM.
Faye D. Reddick
n/a
4
yes none
Maria Grimaldo
n/a
5
yes none
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
Faye D, Reddick,. expiring on June 25, 2001
rvIaria Grimaldo, expiring on June 25, 2002
nSCALIMPACT: NONE
,.,.,..--
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment and appoint two members to the Hispanic Affairs Advisory
Board and direct the County Attorney to prepare a resolution confirming the appointments.
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Date: MARCH 23,1999
.\~G.E.NDA J.TEM
,~u. Lo...P-
~
~
~
j
~
~
MAr< 2 3 1999
,
~_.~,----~ ."
Pg ,_
I
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
Name Work Pholle Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 21ldExpDate 21ld Term
declared vacant 1/26/99 08/26/97 06/25/01 4 Years
Naples, FL 34104
District: 3
Category:
Kate L. Warner 12/16/97 06/25/01 4 Years
1717 Camelia Lane 435-4577
Naples, FL 34105
District: 1
Category:
Dora S. Vidaurri 658-2082 08/05/97 06/25/01 4 Years
611 Nassau Street Apt. #3
Immokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category:
Pete Cade, Jr. 657-1763 08/05/97 06/25/01 4 Years
1903 Leed A venue
Immokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category:
Eva 11/14/95 06/25/98 3 Years
, ! ~ I f/) ;;;--
4521 353-0070 i./'~ v
David Correa
11257 Longshore Way West
Naples, FL 34119
District: 5
Category:
06106/95
10/20/98
06/25/98
06/25/02
3 Years
4 Years
Frank G. Loney
131 Tahiti Street
Naples, FL 34113
District: 1
Category:
08/01/95
06/25/99
4 Years
^-
Wednesday, January 27, 1999
Page 1 012
N~~~~X
MAF? 2 3 1999
Pg. :z-
~.""""'.......:m
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp. Date
211dExpDate
Term
2nd Term
reS 16""e&'
Sandra Buxton I' ;;N-4't
7816 Gardner Drive, #203
Naples, FL 34109
District: 3
Category:
04/28/98
06/:5/99
1 Year
514-2371
Frank Florencio Rodriguez
P.O. Box 990244
Naples, FL 34101
District: 3
Category:
08/01/95
06/25:'99
4 Years
434-1975
This 9 member committee was created by Ord, No, 91-37, amended by Ord, No, 91-78) to
identify and evaluate problems unique to the Hispanic community, review and recommend ways
to ensure open communication between minorities and Collier County govemment and provide
periodic reports to the Board of County Commissioners, Terms are 4 years,
FL STA T:
Staff: Ramiro Manalich, Assistant County Attorney: 774-8400
Wedllesday, Jalluary 27, /999
Page 2 of 2
r ~I~G_IO ?JM
,
n
r:
.
~
MAFl 2 3 1999
Pg.
3
RECEIVED
M E M 0 RAN DUM \J..\R [) 2 1999
i\:~:'~ ,y;' l:c~unt~;, Ccrr:?;1-: -::.'":. -: ':,:~.
TO:
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of ty Commissioners
afialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney
FROM:
DATE:
March 2, 1999
RE:
Applicants Seeking Appointment to the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
At its regular meeting held February 25, 1999, the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
(HAAB) considered the following applicants for appointmc.
Fay D. Reddick
Maria Grimaldo
HAAB voted unanimously that the above applicants be recommended for appointment by
the Board of County Commissioners. The next HAAB meeting is scheduled to be held on March
25, 1999. Please have the Board of County Commissioners consider the above applicants for
appointment to HAAB.
Thank you for your assistance in this regard. If you have any questions, please do not
hesitate to contact me.
RMlkn
attachments
cc: David C. Weigel, County Attorney
HAAB Members
-
N~~_7j;_Z-
MAR 2 3 1999
,- 9, ----L
j
MEMORANDUM
[:! -=f<'.~.-"~'j Il~n...-.
" . '..... '~r '\...:. j I'J .::: t,
..... ,- : :-, :.~ j',
'~""--,
, .,'.
DATE:
February 22, 1999
TO:
Vinell Hills, Elections Office /+
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant-<T;, I
Board of County Commissioners '
FROM:
RE:
V oter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also, please list the commi~sion district in which each applicant resides.
HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD
COMMISSION DISTRICT
Faye D. Reddick
4031 Gulf Shore Boulevard North
Naples, FL 34103
~
1
Thank you for your help.
N~~~bl!M
MAP 2 3 1999
Pg. ~
MEMORANDUM
tJ~,r'FfVFr~
l j,...... .",,)'.~.. ~ --....., ....
. '01',0
, .' ~.;
. ..... ~ "-"" ...
DATE: January 29, 1999
'i.'_,-,', '
TO: Vinell Hills, Elections Office
FROM: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioner
RE: Voter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also, please list the commission district in which each applicant resides.
HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVSIORY BOARD
COMMISSION DISTRICT
Maria Grimaldo
203 N. 8th Street
Immokalee, FL 34142
r
t
Thank you for your help.
N~~_ENDJO-rn
MAR 2 3 1999
Ctl
Pg -
:~-_..--
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
February 22, 1999
TO:
Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant COmA,rto~ey
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistan~ ' :;r
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for
consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review as follows:
Faye D. Reddick
4031 Gulf Shore Boulevard North
Naples, FL 34103
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions,
please call me at 774-8097,
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Attachments
N~~_7t>~
MAR 2 3 1999
1
Pg.
j
""""--'""",,,"''"!I'''~
Feb-10-99 01:32P Group Seven. Inc.
FAX NUMBER TRANSMITTED TO: 77._1- 3(PO~
Stie; r/V5IJN
, ,thye t<:eP/J/C/<-
.
2-, /0,11,
To:
Of:
From:
ChentJM:attcr:
Date:
, .
, , t
COMMENTS:
941 430 2719
Group Seven, Inc.
456 10Lh Ave. South
Naples, Florida 34102
941-430-2708
Fax: 941-430-2719
FAX COVER SHEET
~
"'~'... ,..-.
~ .-",' '. '.. .
..: ~ - -".....
! .
~:h'fl'.' ,
." '".',:~,'.! IJ",
.' ....~..,....,.,._ri;r;,
P.01
~ we /JtJa/G.'eo eN~.5"l9,t; IS ~y tel7EJf'--
/tNI? f<J!%"t./Mt::? ~f!<c:%~/1{b. MY /N1?5~r IN
5e;z.vIN~ eN ~ aJU1~ c~t./-IIty ,lffS"f'A-NfC-
APFAlf?S A/)YISOIlY(t:)MM1r lee'
MAR 2 J ' 1999
~
Feb-10-99 01:32P Group Seven, Inc.
941 430 2719
P.02
FAYE D. REDDICK
4031 GULF SHORE BOULEVARD NORTH
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34103
94] -434-9475
February 10. 1998
Ms, Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board or County Commissioners
3301 Tumiami Trail East
Naples, Florida 34112
Dear Ms, I:ilson:
As a full rime resident of Collier County I am inl~rested in s~rving as a member of the Hispanic
Af1~irs Advisory Committee,
Prior to coming to Florida my family lived in Arizona for over' 00 years, Growing up in onc of
the oldest llispanic populations in America has given me a unique sensitivity and concern Il)r the
important and ever growing role of the Latino community.
Although I have nOl served in this capacity 1x:fore, I would welcome the opportunity, enclosed,
please tind my resume,
Sincerdv,
'- /o~.~c_Q--~,..Jj"'0
FaYVCddlCk
,
N~~=1blr-
t~AR 2 3 1999
<1
Pg.
Feb-10-99 01:32P Group Seven, Inc.
941 430 2719
P.03
FAYE D. REDDICK
4031 GULF SHORE BOULEVARD NORTH
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34103
94) -434-9475
Resume
Personal:
Married. Two children.
Education:
University uf Arizona, Tucson
Loma Linda University, Southern California
lJ n ivenity of Colorado, Colorado ~ 0 rin~s
,",'ork Experience:
~rctary, Dean of the Graduate School of Business
lJniversity of California, Berkeley
Secretaryrrreasurcr, Pbillips Brandt Redllick, Inc.
Architecture, Planning and [)~velopment
Denver, Colorado
Owner, Reddick Develol)mcnt Group,
Community Developer - Naples
Owner, Group Seven. Inc.
Construction and Development - Naples
Volunteer Work:
Denver Street Beat. Denver, Colorado organization to fced and
clotbe the homeless.
Dougla!! County Colorado Eleetion Judge
Franktown SDA School, Grades 1-8. Franktown. Colorado
Scbool Board Member
Literacy Volunteer - Naples,I'lorida
.-
Guardian Ad Litem - Naples, ."Iorids
N.pl.. CommuDity Hospit.1 - Co-Chuirrn.. of VOlontT'" N~~E ~~
r MAR 2 3 1999
,
~ Pg.
':...r~__
/0
I
_t
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
January 29, 1999
TO:
Ramiro Mafialich, Chief ASSistant:;}fount ttomey
Sue Filson, Administrative Assist .:>
Board of County Commissioners ~
FROM:
RE:
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for
consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review as follows:
Maria Grimaldo
203 N. 8th Street
Immokalee, FL 34142
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions,
please call me at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Attachments
AGENO~I"W"
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. / /
-----. .
Maria Grimaldo
Volunteer Parent
203 N, 8th Street t\
Immokalee, FL ,34142
(941) 657.7754
.t,~ ........ .._o".,"~'f-'
f~E~;,t>~ \ c.~~)
.'J,L\i\~
.} ,.~ .: ,,",,;"1 \.~
'~'.rl~'(i :):" ".'"
:t.(.;"-.....; ~_; ;<:!t'~ .
January 24,1999
Government Complex
Administrator Assistant
ATT: Sue Filson
3301 East Tamiami Trial
Naples, FL 34112-4902 (941) 774-0225
Dear Mrs. Filson:
Please, accept my application for an appointment as a member for the Hispanic
Affairs Advisory Board.
First, I am going to give you brief background information. I am a Hispanic that has
lived in Immokalee since 1972. I am a proud mother of three children. Two of my
children are in college. and the youngest is in the eleventh grade. I have been
working as a tutor for about nine years for Collier County Public Schools. In addition,
I am a volunteer Parent for my community. Also, I am a member of the Immokalee
High School Advisory Committee, and a member of the Immokalee Advisory Council
on Domestic Violence.
If you have any questions or need additional information, please feel free to call me
at home (941) 657-7754 after 3 p.m. or at work (941) 657-4469 between 7 a.m. - 3
p.m.
I would be honored if you gave me the opportunity to serve my community as an
Advisory Board Member. Thank you for taking the time to review my letter.
ri n aldo
N~~.Eio~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. j:L
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
~
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO THE IMMOKALEE ENTERPRISE ZONE
DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
OBJECTIVE: To appoint seven members to serve 4 year terms. expiring on April 4, 2003, on
the lmmokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency,
CONSIDERA TIONS: The Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency has 7 terms
expiring on April 4, 1999. This 13 member committee was created on March 28, 1995, by
Ordinance 95-22 to induce private investment into distressed areas to create economic
opportunities and sustainable economic development for designated areas, To permit Collier
County to participate in this program, the Board of County Commissioners nominated the
lmmokalee Community to be considered by the Florida Department of Commerce for Enterprise
Zone designation in Resolution No. 95-248, approved March 28, 1995. As part of the formal
application for an Enterprise Zone, the State required that a committee consisting of a broad base
of citizens be established. The committee has representation from the Chamber of Commerce,
financial or insurance entities, businesses operating within the nominated area, residents living
within the nominated area, nonprofit community-based organizations operating \vithin the
nominated area, local private industry council, local code enforcement agency, and local law
enforcement agency. A list of the current membership is included in the backup.
A press release was issued and resumes were received from the following 7 interested citizens:
APPLICANT
CA TEGORY
Maria De La Luz V, Ortiz (re-appt)
John Kirchner (re-appt)
Ira Malamut (new appt)
Floyd Crews (re-appt)
Jim Penczykowski (re-appt)
Jerry Hubbart (new appt)
Al Neuman (re-appt)
Non-profit Organization
Chamber Representative
Non-profit Organization
Business Operating in the Zone
Non-profit Organization
Business Operating in the Zone
Private Industry Council
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
All applicants be appointed to 4 year terms.
FISCAL IMP ACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment and appoint 7 members to the lmmokalee Enterprise Zone
Development Agency and direct the County Attorney to prepare a resolution confirming the
appointments,
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
N~~~ I~
Agenda Date: MARCH 23,1999
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. /
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp. Date
21ldExpDate
Term
21ld Term
Garv Dantini 643-8445 09/93/96
2800 1'-,:orth Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34112
District:
Category: Local Code Enforcement
John Kirchner 352-8575 07/28/98
3311 Golden Gate Boulevard, E.
Naples, FL 34120
District: 5
Category: Immokalee Chamber of Commerce
Robert Asbel. Jr.
112 South 1 st Street
Immokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category: Local La\v Enforcement
657-6168 02/03/98
James L. Penczykowski
1108 Monroe Street
Immokalee. FL 34142
District: 5
Category: Non Profit Organization
04/01197
657 -2999
Joseph Lozano
403 North 15th Street
Immokalee. FL 34142
District: 5
Category: ~on Profit Organization
657-2742 04/04/95
Alan W , Neuman
1653 South Fountainhead Road
Ft. Myers. FL 33919
District: 5
Category: Private Industry Council
481-8020 08/05/97
Floyd Crews
5214 Lake lane
Immokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category: ResidenUbusiness
657 -2429 11124/98
-
04/04/99
04/04/99
04/04/02
04/04/99
04/04/99
04/04/99
04/04/01
3 Years V
Months
~
4 Years
2 Years
,//
4 Years
,/
2 Years
./'
2 Years
Wednesday, i....Ol'ember 25. /998
Page J 0[3
N~~:2i> IltM
MAR 2 3 1999
SL...
Pg.
--:..,~., I
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
W. Herman Spooner 657-2569 08/05/97 04/04/98 1 Year
806 K 15th Street 3/14/98 04/04/02 4 Years
lmmokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category: Business Ovmer & Resident
Raymond T. Holland 657-3171 04/01/97 04'28.'01 4 Years
7380 Trafford Oaks, #12 657 -4568
Immokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category: Finanical Entity
Edgardo T enreiro 262-3636 04/04/95 04/04/99 4 Years /'
v/
1065 5th Avenue North 657 -5542
Naples, FL 34102
District: 5
Category: Business in Zone
Jerry Primus 657-3671 04/04/95 04'04/99 4 Years /
701 lmmoblee Drive
Immokalee. FL 34142
District: 5
Category: Business in Zone
Lucy Ortiz 262-4404 04/04/95 04/0499 4 Years /'
606 Robens .-\ venue 657-5617
Immokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category: :.ion Profit Organization
Denise BlQI1ton 657 -3306 12/09/97 00/00100 limited
14700 Immoblee Road
Immokalee, FL 34120
District: 5
Category: non-voting ex-officio member
Fred N, Thomas, Jr. 657-3649 04/04/95 04/04/96 1 Year
1800 Farm Worker Way 9/3/96 04/04/00 4 Years
Immoka1ee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category: Non Profit Organization
AGE/!> It!:
I MAR 2 3 1999
LC9._l.__- 1
. ._~_..-",:,.-"....,----..
Wednesday, ,\'ovember 25,1998
Page 2 of 3
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp. Date
2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
This 13 member committee was created on April 4, 1995, by Ord, No 95-22 to induce private
investment into distressed areas to create economic opportunities and sustainable economic
development for designated areas, Initial members were appointed by Resolution No. 95-249,
To permit Collier County to participate in this program, the Board of County Commissioners
nominated the Immokalee Community to be considered by the FL Dept. of Commerce for
Enterprise Zone designation in Reso. No 95-248, approved March 28, 1995, As part of the
formal app for an EZ, the State required that a committee consisting of a broad base of citizens
be established, The committee has representation from the Chamber of Commerce, financial or
insurance entities, businesses operating within the nominated area, residents, nonprofit
community-based organizations, local private industry council, local code enforcement agency,
FL STAT: 190,00] - 290,01
6
Staff" Greg Mihalic, HUI Director: 403-2330
Wednesday, ^'ovemher 25, /998
Page 3 of 3
A~.~~_
MAR 2 3 1999
I Pg .__~:-.::.~
MEMORAi""DUM
RECEIVED
FROM:
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
Helene Caseltine ~ :" ^ ..;'
Economic Development Manager, Housing & Urban Improvement
V:\;:' :'1') 'coQ
.,1:1 . .... }-..Jo..J.....'
TO:
_ _~ d :'1::
:~m'~~'0'\~ '
DATE:
March 1. 1999
RE:
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency (EZDA)
The Board of County Commissioners nominated the Immokalee community to be considered by the
Florida Department of Commerce for Enterprise Zone designation in Resolution No, 95-248, which was
approved March 28, 1995. As part of the formal application for an Enterprise Zone, the State required
that a committee consisting of a broad base of citizens be established, This Board has representation
from the Chamber of Commerce, financial or insurance entities, businesses operating \vithin the
nominated area, residents living within the nominated area, nonprofit community-based organizations
operating within the nominated area, local private industry council, local code enforcement agency, and
local law enforcement agency,
The Committee was created through Ordinance 95-22 as the Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development
Agency (EZDA), In addition, the County Commission appointed members to the EZDA under
Resolution 95-249,
Due to term expirations. we are recommending the following people for Board approval:
1. Maria De La Luz V, Ortiz, from the Shelter for Abused Women. representing a non-profit
orgamzation established in the Zone. (re-appointment)
2, John Kirchner, Airport Manager for the Immokalee Regional Airport and Vice President of the
Immokalee Chamber of Commerce, This position must be filled with a Chamber representatlve. and
Mr. Kirchner meets this requirement. (re-appointment)
3, Ira Malamut of the Redlands Christian Migrant Association (RCMA), representing a non-profit
organization in the Zone, (new appointment)
4, Floyd Crews, of SW Florida Service & Supply, representing a business operating in the Zone, (re-
appointment)
5, Jim Penczykowski, ofImmokalee Non-Profit Housing, Inc., representing a non-profit organization in
the Zone, (re-appointment)
6, Jerry Hubbart, of the Immokalee State Farmers' Market, representing a business operating in the
Zone, (new appointment)
7, Al Neuman, of the Workforce Council ofSW Florida. Inc, This position must be filled with a
representative of the Private Industry Council, and Mr. Neuman meets this requirement. (re-
appointment)
Please prepare an Executive Summary for the Board's consideration of the recommendations and let me
know if any further information or assistance is needed to initiate the process. Thank you for your help,
c: Fred Thomas, EZDA Chairman AGENDA ~~
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator, Community Development & EnVironmt. tal Senric_e;ZU~
Greg Mihalic, Director, Housing and Urban Improvement
i MAR .2 3 1999
i 0
I ~:,:,-- --- -
~.-~,-...-..-...... _.._,..,..--,.~.-:-
MEMORANDUM
R-CEIV '-,
. E ~__. EL
F:r::~l ? 5 13S9
DATE: February 22, 1999
. ~ ;:.-' ,~ .'~:\!;rr:~ L
TO:
Vinell Hills. Elections Office J
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistanr;r-f '
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
V oter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also, please list the commission district in which each applicant resides.
IMMOKA.LEE EZDA
Maria De La Luz V. Ortiz
606 Roberts A venue
Immokalee, FL 34142
~~
COMMISSION DISTRlCT
~
!J
John W, Kirchner
3311 Golden Gate Blvd., E.
Naples, FL 34120
5;...j'::-'; CJ;l++S S+,
f\1~? (LS" /:= v
I
Ira J. Malamut
11990 \Vedge Drive IV 0
Ft. Myers, FL 33913
Floyd Crews
5214 Lake Lane NV
Immokalee, FL 34141
James Penczykowski
1108 Monore Street
Immokalee, FL 34142
vr
NU
j--
Jerry Hubbart
P.O, Box 267
Felda, FL 33930
AG.ENDA 1Tlt
No. /tJ ...
r
[ :~R:;;:99 _.
Al Neuman
3830 Evans Avenue, Suite 3-A ~V
Fort Myers. FL 33901
Thank you for your help.
AGE7dTrr~
No,_
MAR 2 3 1999
7
Pg.
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
February 22, 1999
TO:
Greg Mihalic, HUI Director _ ry/
Sue Filson, Administrative Assista0'i" ·
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
lmmokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for
consideration, I have attached the resumes received for your review as follows:
Maria De La Luz V. Ortiz
606 Roberts A venue
Immokalee, FL 34142
John W. Kirchner
3311 Golden Gate Blvd., E.
Naples, FL 34120
Ira J. Malamut
11990 Wedge Drive
Ft. Myers, FL 33913
Floyd Crews
5214 Lake Lane
Immokalee, FL 34141
James Penczykowski
1108 Monore Street
Immokalee, FL 34142
Jerry Hubbart
P.O. Box 267
Felda, FL 33930
Al Neuman
3830 Evans Avenue, Suite 3-A
Fort Myers. FL 33901
AGEN9~ I~EM
No. -L.t'"L c..
MAR 2 3 1999
t _. ,;y
f r'g,___~_ i
~_.--,.a;_......-__.....~..'"",
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions,
please call me at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Anachments
AGENQ~ I~
No . _Ltit__...-
MAR 2 3 1999
r-g, __~_._ _
~ --1- ~
"""__I:'.r"""-,.,."..,......___~..-~"~.~ ~~.L
02/19/1999 08:16
9415575776
1MMOKALEE SAW OFFICE
PAGE 01
Shelter
Ibmen.
PO. Box JOJ02.NapIcs,FL ~lOJ
~ECEIV~(>
February 17, 1999
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, FI 34112-4977
i=EB i 9 1999
, f" "tl' "'~;~~ione"'~
boal'Q (l ",OUII, \..""". .,
Re: Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Dear Ms. Filson:
I received your letter date February 1, 1999 regarding my term on the Immokalee
Enterprise Zone Development Agency.
Enclosed please find an updated resume. I hereby request consideration for
reappointment to the Irnmokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency. I would like to
be considered under the "non-profit" category, as I am working for The Shelter for
Abused Women (SAW), a 501 0 (3) organization. 1 provide services at the SAW
ImmokaIee Outreach Office at 123 North 4111 Street, ImmokaJee. They are in support of
my continuing on the EZDA board
It has been an interesting and exciting term and I look forward to additional happenings
in Immokalee for the future.
If you have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me at
the ImmokaJee Outreach Office1 941-657.5700.
S i.ncerely.
~ j(~J-f!$J
Maria (Lucy) CSW
Immokalee Outreach Advocate
cc: Robin Postill, MSW
AGENDA IT.EM
No. --L!J ~
MAR 2 3 1999
L_.:.~~O_:..~,
11lc:.hdter lor AbuJedWoolcll~ snttt:ful for ~ from lJntta1Wl1y at (..oilier (.outlEy.
Dcpmmrnt uf ~ and famlI)' SC!'\'\cefj (Dn~ VIolence: 'lru,t Fund) otncl pm'att contnbut(Jl"S,
02/19/1999 08:16
9415575776
1MMOKALEE SAW OFFICE
PAGE 02
CURRICULUM VITAE
MARIA DE LA LUZ V. ORTIZ, ACSW, LCSW
606 Roberts Avenue
lmmokalee, Florida 34142
941-657-5617
Personal Data: DOB: August 7, 1946 POB: San Antonio, Texas
Marital Status: Married to NefWi Ortiz. since August 14, 1964
2 Children, 2 Grandchildren, 2 Great-grandchildren
Other. Fluent in English and Spanish, also some Creole and German
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
08/18/97 to Present: The Shelter for Abuse Women of Collier County,
Licensed Clinical Social Worker (Immoka1ee Outreach Advocate)
P.O. Box 10102 !P. O. Box 397
Naples, FL, 34101 IImmokalee, FL 34143
07/20/97 to Present Let's Talk IHablamos, Private Practice (sole propriator)
P.Q, Box 3134
Immoklalee, F1 34143
02124/97 to 08/15/97 Medical Social Worker, Community Home Services, Inc., Immokalee Off
851 5th Avenue North, Suite 201
Naples, F1 34102
09/13/93 to 02121197 Medical Social Worker, Hospice of Naples, Inc.
1095 Whippoorwill Lane
Naples, Fl 33999
10/94 to 04/30/97
Adult Outpatient Counselor, Clinician n
David Lawrence Center, lmmokalee Office
425 First Street North
Immokalee, Fl 34142
01192-05/93
Lead Organizer, Collier United for Rights and Equality,Inc.
2900 CR. 951, Unit 10
Naples, F1 33999
04/87 to 02192
Director, Immokalee Immigration Project
Catholic Charities, lnc.( Diocese of Venice)
209 South 9th Street
Immokalee, F1 34142
02/19/1999 08:16
9415575776
1MMOKALEE SAW OFFICE
PAGE 03
PSBe2
08/64 to 2/66
Assistant Cashier, First Bank ofImmokalee
1400 North 15th Street
lmmolcalee, Fl34142
Migrant Farm Worker
02/66 to 12/86
EDUCATION
09/93 MSW (Masters in Social Work) Barry University, Miami)1orida
04/90 BA in Psychology, University of South Florida, Ft.Myers Campus
04/88 Edison Community CoDege, Ft Myers, AA
04/87 Edison Community CoUege, Ft Myers, AS in Banking &. Finance
08/83 Graduate, F10rida School of Banking, UP, Gainesville, Fl.
LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATIONS
07110/97 Certified Assessor, Florida Dept. of Corrections. BIP
03/04/97 Continuing Education Unit Provider: CM-693-Exp.1I2001
11/26/96 Florida DPR, Licensed Clinical Social Worker, No. SW0004496
11/04/96 Academy of Certified Social Workers
02192 Certified Paralegal-Immigration, Miami,Florida
1980~to Present -Notary Public, State of Florida
PROFESSIONAL ORGANlZA.TlONS
National Network of Battered Immigrant Women, April., 1998
National Association of Social Workers, since Sept. 1992
Academv of Certified Social Workers, since Nov. 1996
Association for the Advancement of Social Worker Wrth Groups, Ine since April, 1991
Association of Death Education and Counseling,Inc. SW F1 ,1992
CURRENT ACTlV1TES
Commissioned Board Member, lnunobJee Water and Sewer District, 01199
Village Oaks Elementry School Advisory Member, 01/98
Immokalee Advisory Council on Domestic Violence (developer), 09/97
Vice-Chairwoman, Enterprise Zone Development Agency, 4/97
National Coordinator, Las Hermanas-USA, 10/95-10/98
Board of Trustees, Treasurer, The Guadalupe Center, since Oct. 1994
Personal references available upon request.
N~.G?~~~_ .
MAR 2 3 1999
L~ r
,...: r ~
"L' ':j,- --- t
~...~ .......,..":>..;-~.---------...~"....".~
02/19/1999 08:15
9415575775
lMMDKALEE SAW OFFICE
PAGE 03
page 2
08/64 to 2/66
Assistant Cashier, First Bank of Immokalee
1400 North 15th Street
Immok:alee, Fl34142
Migrant Farm Worker
02166 to 12/86
EDUCATION
09/93 MSW (Masters in Social Work) Barry University, Miami,Florida
04/90 BA in Psychology, University of South Florida, Ft.Myers Campus
04/88 Edison Community College, Ft Myers, AA
04/87 Edison Community College, Ft Myers, AS in Banking & Finance
08/83 Graduate, Florida School of Banking, UF, Gainesville, F1.
LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATIONS
07/10/97 Certified Assessor , Florida Dept. of Corrections, BIP
03/04/97 Continuing Education Unit Provider: CM-693-Exp 1/2001
11/26/96 Florida DPR, Licensed Clinical Social Worker, No. SWOOO4496
11/04/96 Academy of Certified Social Workers
02192 Certified Paralegal-Immigration, Miam4FJorida
1980.to Present -Notary Public, State of Florida
PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
National Network of Battered Immigrant Women, April, 1998
National Association of Social Workers, since Sept, 1992
Academy of Certified Social Workers, since Nov. 1996
Association for the Advancement of Social Worker Wrth Groups, Ine since April, 1991
Association of Death Education and Counseling,Inc. SW Fl.1992
CURRENT ACT1VlTES
Commissioned Board Member, Immokalee Water and Sewer District, 01199
Village Oaks Elementry School Advisory Member, 01/98
Immokalee Advisory Council on Domestic Violence (developer), 09/97
Vice-Chairwom8l\ Enterprise Zone Development Agency, 4/97
National Coordinator, Las Hermanas-USA, 10/95-10/98
Board of Trustees, Treasurer, The Guadalupe Center, since 0et.1994
Personal references available upon request.
~~~~E:M
i
I
t
,
~
~
MAR 2 3 1999
~CJ.n-.--
-"~"-.~'.~"""'.
FEB-19-99 10:07 AM IMMOKALEE AIRPORT
941 6579191
P.01
RECEIVED
FEB 1 9 1999
I\,~I'.Q \\1 County C_ i 50S 1 oners
r>t '
Mel110
To: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
From: John W. Kirchner, Airport Supervisor
CC: Mr. John H, Drury, A.A E Executive Director
Date: February 19. 1999
Re: Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Heno Sue:
I am very interested in continuing my participation with the Immokalee Enterprise Zone Advisory
Committee, It IS very important for me as the airport manager and vice-president of the chamber to
stay involved with community issues, Please place my name on the list for consideration,
Many thanks
c:-~~'L)L"--.~ . '--c___
John W, Kirchner
Airport Supervisor
~GENDVIT~
t\J,' I
" ..- ,.-:....-
--,
. Page 1
i
I
;
;
l
~
~ ~.g..l~--. ;
~~,..,~r....-r::.::..~~_._~""""'-"--'--l"""""'"
MAR 2 3 1999
FEB-19-99 10:08 AM IMMOKALEE AIRPORT
941 6579191
P.02
JOHN W. KIRCHNER
3311 Golden Gate Blvd., E.
Naples, FL 34120
(941)352-8575
PROFESSIONAL OBJECTIVE
My immediate goal is to provide leadership and direction to the community and to take each
opportunity to gain the confidence of the general public_
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Z/98 - Pr~ent Airport Managt>r
CoUier County Airport Authority, Immokalee Regional Airport
4/97 - 2/98 Purchasing Technidan
Collier County Purchasing Department. Naples. FL
3/93 - 4/97 Assistant ManagerfRemodel Team Managtr
Eckerd Drug Company, Naples, FL
6.'94 - 9/98 Accountant
KirchnerlLash Accounting Service, Naples, FL
1992-1993 General Manager
Del's Wholesale, Naples, FL
1991-1992 General Manager
Uttle Caesar's Tnc" Garden Grove. CA
1989-1991 Relief Managerl Automation Clerk
U.S.PS, Salt Lake City, UT
1981-1984 Security Guard
Tooele Army Depot. Tooele, UT
1978-1981 Deputy Sheriff
Collier/Lee County Sheriffs Office, NaplesIFt. Myers, FL
1971-1978
Staff Sergeant
U.S. Marine Corps
Honorable Discharge
Vietnam Veteran
,AGEN9hIT~
No /(7 ~.
MAR 2 3 1999
~ F'g. IS-
'---
FEB-19-99 10:08 AM IMMOKALEE AIRPORT
941 6579191
EDUCA TION/SPECIAL TRAINING
Embry-Riddle Aeronautiul Univenity
Professional Aeronautics
Utah Technical College
Business Management! A. A. S. Degree
Accounting/Certificate of Graduation
Data Processing/Certificate of Graduation
Las ABides Community CoUege
Criminal Investigations
Private Pilot Training
OTHER POSITIONS
1998-1999
Vice-President. ImmokaJee Chamber of Commerce
1998.1999
Board Member. Enterprise Zone Committee
P.03
...~.~--
\ ,~r;F" Nl?~ IJ.EM
/6!-,-_~
~~AR 2:~ 1999
":~ / -k-.--
-. ........-...,.-,.~.c:>>-...."__..."'._,_."...,......~__
elle,"I\', ~h i',':- ,-\'-
RECEIVED
"rl~<~:
~ (J Co .... 0 ,~:. . ~'" , " - C ':M'it~ ~ S s i (} r! ~ :"'" ~
\._~',-'~: 4:~ \\"!:_.;~ '\1':',1', S"T~::.E-, h<,\<\.Y~-\!..E!:.. F;. ". 'ql~:.:;\n)
',IJ~: ,\,'::---. ~~~:. 5',"(' '\' J~..;, ~56:. F~.\ l u1116~:---_~) ~ I
February 12, 1999
Board of County Commissioners
clo Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
3301 E Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112-4977
Gentlemen.
The Intent of this letter is to express my interest in serving on the Board of Directors of the
Enterprise ZO:le Development Agency, representing the Redlands Christian Migrant Association,
I understand there is a vacancy on the Board left by Joseph Lozano,
Rediands Christian Migrant Association is a non-profit, non-sectarian voluntary organization
committed to the provision of quality child care services for young children and to the advocacy of
Issues relevant to the lives of migrant and seasonal farm workers and the rural poor in general,
RCMA, with its state headquarters at the Rollason Center in Immokalee, serves in excess of
5,000 children In approximately 75 childcare centers and programs in 21 counties in Florida, We
employ over 150 people in Collier County,
I have enclosed a copy of my resume, Thank you for your consideration in this matter,
Sincerely,
~.~.~
i \
Ira J);),alamut
Senior Fiscal Officer
119";0 we..f:Jc Dr.
f f. ([11 e(?, .3 '3 '1 J3
enclosure
cc. Barbara Malnster, Executive Director
.-\\, E~\_ \~ ~l;F\\;;'~\:-;; E\'.;~:"~lF. tL:<'tr' 1\ r_~,F-T r:~
\
i
~
i. !4
' t' g. --_ .~- .'
III ."
'..----
,
X
~
H1LL:-f'..,)\(\11.~,H "::,'l 'T'l
M~R /. 3 1999
N~.~n/S~- ,
diP
~~
tail" @r ,
~: o,tilL'pim.. I ECI\1HSP I
&. FAMILIES '
e
EXPERIENCE
1994 to
Present
Mr, Ira J. Malamut
Addendum to Resume
SENIOR FISCAL OFFICER
REDLANDS CHRISTIAN MIGRANT ASSOCIATION
IMMOKALEE, FLORIDA 34142
Responsible for accounting and financial operations of the agency.
Advise Executive Director on fiscal matters. Present financial state-
ments to the Board of Directors. Duties include preparation of financial
reports, analysis of monthly financial statements for all funding sources,
budget preparation, monitoring of compliance with appropriate govern-
ment fiscal regulations as well as with internal accounting policies and
procedures, preparation of reports required by regulatory and funding
sources, assurance of adequate cost rate agreements. Other responsi-
bilitiesinclude management of computer operations and supervision of a
twenty person Fiscal Department, including direct supervision of the
Director of Accounting. Contracts Manager, Fleet Manager, Network
Administrator and Computer Technicians.
r AGEN~~ lJiM
i No. ./1;)~
MAR 23 1999
It
~ ~'J ~
-~
EXPERIE~CE
1985
to
1993
1984
to
1985
1983
to
1984
1971
to
1983
EDUCArIO~
Hr. Ira J. ~alamut
ASSISTA~T AD~I~[STRATOR FOR FISCAL AFFAIRS
WOODBI~E Nu]SI~G & CO~~ALESCE~T CE~TER
ALEXANDRIA, VIRGI~IA 22302
Chief financial officer/ controller for 307 bed skilled proprietary nursing facility.
Responsible for accounting and financial operations of the nursing home. ~ember of
management committee having overall responsibility for the operatinns of the facility.
Duties included cash management; financial analyses; preparation of hudgets, financial
statements and reports; management of computer operations; supervision of the accounting
department. Selected, implemented and upgraded computerized accounting system. Member
of Virginia Health Care Association state Payment for Services Committee dealing ~ith
state.ide reimburs~ent issues,
SE~10R ACCOUNTA~T
~E~DELSOS & ~E~DELSOS
CERTIFIED P~BLIC ACCOU\TA\TS
~ASH[SGTO~, D.C, 20036
Performed audits, co:pilations and reviews for clients in a variety of businesses and
industries, Prepared indi.idual and corporate tax returns, Analyzed and designed
accounting syste~s. Prepared personal financial statements,
ASSISTA~T AD~INIST~ATOR FOR FISCAL AFFAIRS
SOUTH SHORE HOSPITAL ASD ~EDICAL CESTER
~IA~I BEACH, FLORIDA 33139
Finance cirector for 178 bed private non-profit hospital. Responsible for the financial
operations of the hospital. Duties included supervision of tbe accounting, billing and
data processing departments; design and implementation of accounting controls and proce-
dures for physicians' private offices in new ten story medical building; assessment of
the effects of nev Medicare reimbursement regulations (DRG's) on the hospital; budgeting;
preparation of financial projections.
SE~IOR ACCOU~TA~T
REGARDIE, BROOKS & LE~IS, CHARTERED
CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOU~TA~TS
BETHESDA, ~~YLA~D 20814
Responsible for all aspects of financial audit engagements. Duties included scheduling
required personnel for audits; supervising and revie~ing the ~ork or other staff account-
ants; performing analytical revie.s of operations; drafting financial statements; pre-
paring state and federal tax returns. Other responsibilies included corporate and indi-
vidual tax planning, and manage~ent advisory services.
A,B.A" 1971, Benjamin Franklin University, Washington, D.C.
Various seminars for continuing prOfessional education,
N~~_~1tl Il!~
MAR 2 3 1999
:~g .
11--
,
. .......-~''-L.-c:.....".__~.....--...--..._'-~
~ECF;\fE[,:
,-"C', ' ... 1n(Jf'
~ t:r.j , tl .~j;:):'
Southwest Florida Service &
Supply
Post Office Box 610 . Immokalee. Florida 34143 . (941 )657 -2429 . Fax: (941) 657 -3511
hhruary 12. 1999
1\ls Sue rilsoll
Collier County t\dministratioI1 Office
3301 East TamiamJ Tr<lil
1':3r1es, FL 34112
DC;lI/'lls Filson
J Zl111 respo11l11l1g to a letter fro\11 YOll reganhng my re-appointment to the
lmrnok alee Enterprise Zone Development Agency Board. I ''''au ld like to serve
,mother 4-ycar tt:rrn on this Boan!.
1 am a Business Panner ill Southwest FloriJa Service and Supply, a company
loc;lted within the Immokalec Enterprise Zone, \Ve helve heen in business in
Immoblce since 1972
If you have any questions, or need more infon113tion, please call me at 657-2429.
Thank yo~f< r your time and consi eration.
C Si"t5/f,1 ~.q~ L~
// t ~ ~
FI(lyd ('rn.,s. . .
P.S, Pkase he sure to mall Llny and all correspondence to the post office hnx
~iddrcss at my place ofhusincss
~. ,.-rEM
^(, r :,1, t I-' l! 1"1
'" ,~,h.. ,...
v.;r' IJ)-~-
~A.P.
,...., ~,
{ :>
1999
\
;2-Q. ,~
- ~'_:';_ ~_;.~';;:.-';'____,-~ ...w~.-....,."
FEB-16-1999 09:36 AM IMMOK. NON-PRFT. HSNG. INC. 941 657 8335
Sander.
Pines
P. 01
Immokafee Non-Profit Housing, Inc. Rt:~C:1 t' ~i.:'
(j1
2449 Bandera Pine. Circle '-~B ; 6 1999 Timber
Ridge
ImmokaiIM, Florida 341~clrc; 0'-' ;- , r ,
(941)857-8333' ...oun',1 ...00JrI1SSlone~'~
FAX (~1) 657-8335
February 16, 1999
Sue Filson
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
330] E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112-4977
via facsimile: 774-3602
Dear Ms Filson:
1 currently serve on the Board oftbe EnteIln;se Zone Development Agency for
Immokalee, My tenn expires soon and I would like to be con!\idered for another term on
this board.
My qualifications as an elector in Collier County, as an employer within the "zoneH, and as
a representative of a not.for-protit organization are the same as during my first term. My
resume follows.
Respectfully.
2:::c~
Executive Director,
Thi'PH,Ine,
cc Helene Caseltine
N;GEle.:~_
MAR 2 3 1999
rY'h~i__
,
i,_........~...""~..,....- _
~~..-
FEB-16-1999 09: 36 AM I MMOK, NON- PRFT. HSNG. I NC, 841 657 8335
James Penczykowski
1108 Monroe Street
Immokalee, FL 34J42
EDUCATION:
EXPERIENCE:
COMMUNITY
ACTMTY:
P. 02
RESUME
(94]) 657-2999 = home
(941) 657-8333 = work
(941) 657.8335'" fax
B.A, St. Francis de Sales College, Milwaukee, ~ 1971,
n.M., St. Francis Seminary, Milwaukee, WI, 1975,
1996 to present. Executive Director, Immokalee Non-Profit
Housing, Jne" Jmmokalee, Florida.
1992-1996, Self-employed Consultant. Immokalee. Florida,
1986-1992. Manager of the Menter Hospital. NewStart Residential
Center, Madison, Wisconsin.
1981-1986, Therapist and Clinical Supervisor of Ingalls Memorial
Hospital, Addiction TreaIment Center,
Board of Directors, Immokalee Developmental Services.
Board Member, Rural Health Network.
Participant, Empowerment Zone Application Process.
\
~
\:
f
N~~E~.~d_~~
MAR 2 3 1999
1-' 9 . _ ;2.:2-:::
,...-.,..,..-,_..-,-'
"'.............~...~...,.-~--
FEB-16-1999 09:36 AM IMMOK, NON-PRFT. HSNG. INC, 941 657 8335
James Penczykowski
1108 Monroe Street
Immokalee, FL 34142
EDUCATiON:
EXPERIENCE:
COMMUNITY
ACTIVITY :
P. 02
RESUME
(941) 657-2999 == home
(941) 657.8333 = work
(941)657-8335= fax
B.A, St. Francis de Sales College, Milwaukee, WI, 1971 ,
Th.M., St. Francis Seminary, Milwaukee, WI, 1975,
1996 to present, Executive Director, Immokalee Non-Profit
Housing, Inc" Immokalee, Florida.
1992-1996, Self-employed Consultant, Immokalee. Florida.
1986-1992, Manager of the Meriter Hospital, NewStart Residential
Center. Madison, Wisconsin,
1981-1986, Therapist and Clinical Supervisor of lngalls Memorial
Hospital, Addiction Treatment Center.
Board of Directors, Immokalee Developmental Services.
Board Member, Rural Health Network.
Participant, Empowerment Zone Application Process,
AGENp~ ITEM
No. .~S!....-_
MAR 2 3 1999
P9._;<.3
IMMOKALEE ST, FRM, MKT TEL:9416583508
Feb 15,99 12:10 No.002 P.Ol
,<,"'-
RECEIVED
FEB 1, 6 1999
Fio!'idJ Dl.:pal'lmClil of A&d,cultul'c & Consumer Sel'vices
DOB CitA WFOltD I Gpmmis:iiQJ1cl' Boarci 'of Count.~ com j ss loner
l'lclll'lll\c"L!~llCcl 'j'".
lm'tlOKalee State F~ l "MCU:ko.t
424 New MZ1rket Road
Imrokalee, Florida 34142
941/658-3505
FAX 'I'aANSMITI:AL COVER SHI:E'I'
t>>a'E :
02/15
19~
'rIME :
AMRi
'1'0:
11;, Sue Pi1scn
FAX ii ('1m) 774-?ffJ2
FFa1 :
Jerry Hublm't
. FAX ~ (941) GS6-3508 '
NiJMaI::R OF SHEErS: 03
(Incl~ 'l'rMSlt\ittal, Sheet)
---
sun-n:-/"'fTl,. 1" d
~ """.. .Ptt pr or :i ntpIest an 1"'F'cQ!lIP. ,
~.' '"-~ '-
""""''''~.,n...;/ I nRnK you,
','
.'
.:- -----.-.-------
1 JlGENDA ITEM
: ,,~. }~ n .
:- \(-~,..~-
MAR 2 3 1999
THB CAllrrOI. . "AU^lr"C:~lm '" ......- .
'~9, ;;t!f.~_1
~.'J:~_'._'_"""""-~ ,
IMMOKRLEE ST. FRM. MKT TEL:9416583508
Feb 15,99
12:10 No.002 P.02
Jerry Hubbart
P.O. Box 267
Felda, Florida 33930
02-15-99
Subject: lmmokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency Advisory Board
Dear Ms. Filson.
It bas come to my attention that there will be an opening on the Advisory Board of the
lmmokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency, I am submitting this letter of interest along
with a short resume.
Please consider my interest in serving on the Board at the next applicable meeting and infonn
me of the outcome. I can be reached at 941/658-3505 (B) or 941/675.3747 (H). Thank you.
, Sincerely,
~~
Jerry Hubbart
AGEN}~ ITEM
No. .?U-J:..-.
JHJ1k
,
MAR 2 3 1999
~
i
~...Jlo.__
pg.~L ~
_.-.c-~
,c.>!..."
'-., ~.~ r ......~,,'...w::.....~H!', '-."'" "'~I '+-1
-.-,T.'
I
'...
IMMOKHLEE ST. FRM. MKT TEL:9416583508
Feb 15,99
12:11 No,002 P,03
R
E
s
u
M
E
Name:
Jerry Hubbart
Date of Birth:
02.2()..SO
Educational Background:
B,8, in Agronomy received from Kansas State University
in 1912,
Current Employer:
State of Florida, Department of Agriculture and Consumer
Services, Division of Marketing and Developmen~
ImmokaJee State Farmers' Market.
Job Title:
Senior Market Manager
Date of Employment:
04/88 through current.
Previous Experience:
Cane Contractors, Lake Harbor, PI. as sugar cane harvesting
foreman from 1986 through 1988.
Clewiston Drainage District, Clewiston, FI. as Assistant
Manager from 1984 through 1986.
A, Duda and Sons, CJewisto~ Fl. as Crop Supervisor from
1973 through 1984.
Personal Data:
Divorced with 8 Daughter, Lori, who is 28 years of age.
Lori is a Physicians Assistant in West Pahn Beach.
"
r N~GE~~T~
!
; MAR 2 3 1999
f fJg._~(Q
--"~"-~"""",".'I:'~--'
--...::._-
.......,
."'''''''-,----....-..,'..~~'........~~' I", ',. -~t
~ -r.akt'!'~t .':1.~; --""l..~._....."~ ,-,
Workforce Council
of Southwest Florida~q\nc,
,.\1 Neuman. EXCCU11\'e Dlrc'ctor
Lee County/ Administrative Office FEB j 0 1999
3R30 hans Avenue. Fort Myers. Florida 3.NOl
9~1.939-~9~9. FAX9~1-~t%'44~?'-: :CJiJr..:.' :,):7rr o:,~IiC:~;
February 9, 1999
Sue Filson. Administrative Assistant
Board of Collier County Commissioners
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 3~331-4977
Dear 1\1s. Filson:
Attached is an updated Resume as requested in your letter dated February 1. 1999.
I feel the Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency is an extremely important committee
and has positive impact on activities within the community. I am still interested in continuing to
serve on this committee and hope that I can make a worthwhile contribution.
If you need additioml information. please contact me as soon as possible.
Sincerely/'
/J/// /
><~~
Al Neuman
A1'\ : bcp
AG?pe ITEM
No '. ~_
MAR 2 3 1999
~g.~L
~ -~~...'."..-=-::)a.....-.
Charlotte County
3 12 '>:esbit Street
Punt:.! Gord:.!. FL 33950
TeI941.637.1311
Fax: 041.639.2149
Hendry !Glades Counties
923 W Sugarland Highway
PO, Box 596. Cle\\iston. FL 33440
Tel: 941.983.6138
Fa,x: 941.983.71 18
Collier County
46 Tenth Street South
'>:apks, FL 34102
Tel: 941.::;61-055?-
Fax: 9-\].261.5969
~
ALAN W. NEUMAN
3830 Evans Avenue, Suite 3-A, Fort Myers, FL 33901
941-939-4949 FAX 941-939.0465
SUMMARY:
Provides administrative leadership and carries out the directives of the Workforce Council of
Southwest Florida, Inc. for employment and training activities in the administration of the Job
Training Partnership Act (JTPA) and other approved employment and training activities.
HIGHLIGHTS OF QUALIFICATIONS:
-Extensive knowledge of employment and training planning principals, practices,
statistical and other research techniques, program management and fiscal reporting.
- Working knowledge of employment and training program planning, evaluation and
operations.
-Thorough knowledge of existing employment and training legislation at the federal,
state and localleve/.
-Ability to analyze facts and figures and to exercise sound judgment in arriving at
conclusions.
-Ability to express oneself clearly and concisely, bvoth orally and in writing and to public
groups.
-Ability to establish and maintain effective working relationships with staff, program
directors, board members, elected officials and other agencies.
-Ability to exercise mature judgment, initiative and tact.
EMPLOYMENT HISTORY:
Aprif 1997 to Present:
Executive Director:
Workforce Council of SW FL, Inc.
Fort Myers, FL
April 1985-1996
Executive Director
Lee County Private Industry Council, Inc.
Fort Myers, FL
Lee Co. Dept. of Employment & Training
January 1970.March 1985
Director and Ass't Director of Employment and Training
Lee County Board of Commissioners, Fort Myers, FL
Apri/1987.present
Community Involvement
-Appointed to the initial Jobs and Education Partnership (JEP) workgroup (Oct. 1995)
-Currently serving on the JEPlvVorkforce Council One-Stop Proposal Committee
-Instrumental in the formation of the five (5) county workforce Council of SW FL, Inc.
.Currently Board Member of the Mayor's Alliance for person with disabilities.
-Past Vice President of the Association of Provider Organization
.Past Chairman of the Dunbar Enterprise Zone Commission
.Past Member of the Edison Community College (ECC) Business Advisory Board.
-Past Member of the Economic Development Committee, SW Regional Planning Council.
EDUCA TlON:
BS, Budiness Administration, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH
N~G7~ I~
-
! MAR 2 3 1999
n
i
~ I~g,.~-
.----::-
;;"EXECUTIVEStTMIVIARY
,... - ~ ..". iL:, ..<~., ':, n
, , ~ r~ " ;1 ,'.., '. ' " ' '
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) fO r;r~ TOURlST DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL
--
OBJECTIVE: To appoint 2 members (1 representing the owner/operator category and 1
representing the non-owner/operator category) to serve 4 year terms, expiring on April 21, 2003,
on the Tourist Development Council.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Tourist Development Council has 2 terms expiring on April 21,
1999. this 9 member council was established by Ordinance No. 92-18 as an advisory committee
to make recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners regarding a proposed plan of
uses for tourist development tax revenues, for the effective operation of the special projects or
uses of the tourist development tax revenues, and to review all expenditures of revenues from the
tourist development trust fund. This council consists of the Chairman or designated
representative of the Board of County Commissioners, 2 elected municipal officials, 3 owners or
operators of motels, hotels, recreational vehicle parks, or other tourist accommodations in the
county and subject to the tourist tax, 3 individuals involved in the tourist industry who have
demonstrated an interest in tourist development, but who are not owners or operators of motels,
hotels or other tourist accommodations. The council shall meet;1: least once each quarter.
Terms are 4 years. A list of the current membership is included in the backup.
A press release was issued and resumes were received from the following 6 interested citizens:
APPLICANT
CATEGORY
Joy Lelonek
Louise J. Thaell
Eric J. Vasquez
Gene Vaccaro (re-appt)
Jeny Thirion (re-appt)
Gene O. Luciano
non-owner/operator
non-owner/operator
non-owner/operator
non-owner/operator
owner/operator
non-owner/operator
DlST ELECTOR ADV. COMM.
2 yes none
4 yes none
2 yes none
5 yes TOC
2 yes TOC
4 yes none
,.,.-...
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
q uarterl y.
No Recommendation because meetings are
FISCAL IMP ACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the requests for
appointment, appoint 2 members to serve 4 year terms, commencing on April 21, 1999 and
expiring on April 21, 2003, and direct the County Attorney to prepare a resolution confirming the
appointments.
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
N~~E"~ j5M
MAR 2 3 1999
/
Pg.
Agenda Date: March 23,1999
RECE~VED
Phone (94'IV403~:dsdi9S9
FAX (941) 403-233 I
HOUSING AND URBAN IMPROVEME~9fd of County COIM1issioners
MEMORANDUM
DATE: March 4,1999
TO: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Greg Mihalic, Director
Housing and Urban Improvemen
SUBJECT: Tourist Development Council Vacancies
Currently there are two vacancies on the Tourist Development Council - one to be filled by an
owner/operator and one as a non-owner/operator. Considering that the TDC will not meet again
until April 19, 1999, well past the 41 day time-frame requirement, I am forwarding the attached
grid sheet describing the candidates who applied for the vacancies.
Please prepare an executive summary for the Board's consideration in appointing members to fill
these vacancies.
Thank you for your attention to this matter and if you have any questions, please call me at 403-
2330.
GMlhc
Attachment
j ~H~ (~:~ _1b rw
I
~
~ Mt:,.~ L 3 1999
t
Pg,.- ~
_:!.+~",.."...,..,~.~
C)
C)
C)
.,-
I
...J
-
U
Z
::J
o
U
....
Z
W
~
D-
O
...J
W
>
W
C
....
(/)
0=:
::J
o
....
W
:I:
....
0=:
o
u.
(/)
w
....
<(
c
c
z
<(
u
0::: .
00:::0
I-~co
<0'-
o:::-Q)
W 0::: g.
o-w~
Q~~
0::: 0 :::
w 0
z I I
:: 5 5
ozC:
I-
Z
W
9
U)
w
0:::
0:::1-
wZ
aJW
:E:E
wI-
:E~
1-0
ZO-
wO-
0:::<
0:::::
:::lw
Uz
:::
Q)
c:
:::
Q)
c:
C/)
Q)
"g'E
- ('0
~:::
Q)-o
JJ .~
UiS:
L..'4-
:l 0
o '-
I- 0
>--
Q) ~ C/)
=Q)'-
o n. ('0
.:: ..e ~
'-
Ul Q) -.;:-
Q) c: ..-
0..:::L..
('000
z r:.: -.-
-.- 0) 'co
o en :::
o .,..... co
ti ~ J:
Q) .~ oS
.= VJ
o Ul ~
c::n c: :l
c: 0 0
~ .~ I-
.::t:.:l'O
Co ~ ~
2W~
'-
o
co
L..
Q)
n.
..e
L..
Q)
c:
:::
o
,
c:
o
c:
C/)
L..
('0
Q)
>-
l.()
......
:::
Q)
c::
'4- C/)
o Q)
C:o..
o ('0
'Vi z
.;; -.- .c
o 0 U
- ('0
C/) c:: 0
L.. Q) U
~~
::: C/) ro
(1J~.o
....Jo.<ll
en..1.. rJ')
c::UlJg
:l 8: Q)
o :l
>- c:: c::n
-
o g ~
~.!'2 a;
(1JU_
<i3~~
'- C/)
a5<{.o
U),-.2
.. (1J U
:::CD=
(1J >. (1J
-l-.o
, c:_
C? 6 8
>. U w...
Q) L.. >.
E .~ .0
0= c::n
_ 0 :l
<{uo::
'-
o
co
'-
Q)
n.
o
~
Q)
c:
3:
o
I
c:
o
c:
Ul
'-
(1J
Q)
>-
C!:I
-
co
0)
-
ct2
Q)"-
L.. ..-
'-
:l:O
Ua..
n.
~
. _ co
I'- '-
0) 0
0)'4-
..- .::t:.
'-
Q) (1J
go.
'Vi ~
C/) 0
c: n.
Q)U)
'E (1J
(1J'O
(j .~
c: 0
.2 u::
~~
.0 '-
Q) 0
Q3ti
U ~
00
-
'- Q)
o .~
u-S
~ U
o ~
C/)W
c: >.
.QCii
<5 6 C/)
E .;; L..
o Q) ro
'- L.. Q)
CL n. >.
'-
o
co
L..
Q)
n.
o
--
'-
Q)
c:
:::
o
C:
o
c:
C/)
'-
(1J
Q)
>-
o
......
-
l.()
0)
Ci3
C..-
0>--
L.. -.;:-
L..
:l:O
Ua..
n.
~
'-
Q)
c: c::n
(1J (1J
c::nC:
0> (1J -.-
.020
t ro ~
OC/) a; E
Q) c: L..
o::O>~
~ (j U
_ Ul
Ul (1J .c
'en en as
0> co Q) en
o::~co~
~ .~ $ g;;
I- Q) en
-.- n. a. ..-
o 0 ....: c:
oUC/).Q
C3 <i3 .f; co
~ <5 t:: '(3
oJ:g55
c::n~o>~
.~ Vi ex::
0l(1J 'en Co Q3
c: Q) C/) <5
ro 0:: Q) ~
2Q)UQ)
--a. .c c: -
I- 0 0
>.cOJ:
.....: .~ ~ -1
C/) ::: 0 w...
'-
o
co
'-
Q)
a.
..e
L..
Q)
c:
3:
o
Ul
'-
(1J
Q)
>.
C!:I
is c:
c: .2
-.. ro
Q) .-
.~ g
.c Ul
~~
:l C/)
C/) c:
Q) .2
Zin
:l (1J
o L..
0::::
--<{
:::: (1J
~ '0
CD .~
>...2
'Ow...
Sv;
-.- Q)
o 3:
,-.c
Q) '5
c: 0
3:C/)
0_
:;::, 0
c: '-
0> (I)
~.o
Ul E
(I) (I)
ct E
'-
o
co
L..
Q)
a.
o
--
L..
(I)
c:
:::
o
C:
o
c:
Ul
L..
(1J
(I)
>.
0)
..-
3:
Q)
c:
... c
(1J
'-
:l
(1J
en
~-
.. co
-.;:-1'-
1'-'
O)~
......en
(1)"-
u-
,~ ~
Ul (1J
~(I)
- >.
~l.()
-0 0
.~ -
(I)-g
~-ffi
.~
(1J 0
E ~
.c (1J
.- 2
3: c:
as 0
> a;
'0 c:
> :::
c: 0
0'>
0)
--
(f)
C/)
0>
10
'0
'6
c:
(1J
U
U
o
I-
0
Q3 N c:
<ll 0 (1J
(1J :::l "- c: '(3
.::t:. .c 0' (1J AGE~~ .ITEM
Q) l- (/) u 0 :::l
c: (1J U '~ -l N
0 -; > (1J E o. roo
W Q3 <ll > I- 0
:E ....J .!!l -; <ll ~ Q)
>. ::J u c: c: MAR 23 1999
< .~ <ll '- Q)
0 0 <ll
Z -, ....J UJ (j -, (9
Pg. .3
W
()
Z
W
~
W
0-
X
W
I-
Z
~
W
..J
W
0:::
>.
C
:l Ul
ot::
U (1J
'-C!:I
.Q:? (f)
'0'0
U c:
'0.2
(5
'(3 E a;
c: 0 c::n
:l L.. (1J
o..e-c:
U c: (1J
.!!1 ,2 E
~coro
'0 .~ U
..., ~ r~o.
~o-
:58~
_ (/) S;
00>....
'- (I) UO
o Ul
_ L.. "-
as ~ .Q:?
.= 0 0
Or:.:U
.~ 85 .~
:5 ~ en
uQ)n.
<ll u :l
X c: 2
W 'Vi c::n
Ul
'-
(1J
(I)
>.
en
Tourist Development Council
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Liana M. Buysse 261-6522 04/21/92 04/21/94 2 Years
989 Aqua Circle 2/24/98 04/21/02 4 Years
Naples, FL 34102
District: 4
Category: Non-Owner/Operator
William A. Hall 598-3300 02/24/98 04/21/02 4 Years
348 Flamingo Drive
Naples, FL 34108
District: 2
Category: O\V1ler/Operator
Rhona E. Saunders 11/24/98 04/21/00 2 Years
3770 Parkview Way 434-9230
Naples, FL 34103
District: 4
Category: Non-O\\ner/Operator
Gene Vaccaro 11103/98 04/21/99 6 months ~
4939 Rattlesnake Hammock Rd, Suite 774-0000
Naples, FL 34113
District: 5
Category: non-O\vner/Operator
Jerry Thirion 597-3232 04/18/95 04121/99 4 Years /
475 Seagate Drive
Naples, FL 34103
District: 2
Category: O\\11er/Operator
John 1. Dougherty 394-5000 03/12/96 04/21/00 4 Years
560 South Collier Blvd. 642-7091
Marco Island, FL 34145
District: 1
Category: O\V1ler/Operator
Karen Louwsma 695-3781 02/24/98 04/21100 3 Years
P.O. Box 110
Everglades City, FL 34139
District: 5
Category: Municipal Official
i\GENO~IT.~
No. __./.Jd. I:J~
..-
Thursday, February 25,1999
Page 1 of 2
i
I
MAi~ 2 3 1999
Pg., Y
~.or._.."..r.-~,,.:,.,,,,,,,,,
Tourist Development Council
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Bill Barnett 434-4601 02/21/96 04/21/00 4 Years
735 Eighth Street South
Naples, FL 34102
District: 4
Category: Municipal Officer
Pamela S. Mac'Kie 77 4-8392 01/12/99 01/04/00 1 Year
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
District: 4
Category: BCC Chairwoman
H. Kent Stanner 02/23/99 04/21/03 4 Years
515 Wildwood Lane 649-5098
Naples, FL 34104
District: 4
Category: Ad Hoc Advisor
This 9 member council was created on March 23,1992 by Ord. No. 92-18 to make
recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners regarding a proposed plan of uses for
tourist development tax revenues, for the effective operation of the special projects or uses of the
tourist development tax revenues. and to review all expenditures of revenues from the tourist
development trust fund. Membership consist of the Chairman of the BCC, 3 owner/operators, 3
non-owner/operators and 2 elected municipal officials, Terms are 4 years,
FL STAT: 125.0104
Staff: Greg Mihalic. HUI Director: 403-2330
AGENCLA Iff'
. to
MAR 2 3 1999
Lpg. S-
I
Thursday, February 25, 1999
Page 2 of 2
MEMORANDUM
i~} ~~ .,_~~.~.1":./ [:, ~"~',
~ Co I.: c.
DATE:
February 22, 1999
TO:
Vinell Hills, Elections Office at
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistan0 1'\ J
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
V oter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also, please list the commission district in which each applican~:'..~sides.
TOURIST DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL
COMMISSION DISTRICT
Joy Lelonek
7024 Pelican Bay Boulevard #501
Naples, FL 34108
?f
~
;]v
Louise 1. Thaell
730 9th Avenue South
Naples, FL 34102
L{-
Eric J. Vasquez
341 Burning Tree Drive
Naples, FL 34105
~
~
Gene Vaccaro
700 7th Street, S.W.
Naples, FL 34117
.0 3;2.3)
:::::l-erOv-e, 1'. .5'C(1~ 1'6
t~ Jerry Thirion J :::Jr. t &;5 k:
~ 475 Seagate Drive f'-1 j)
r:r.....o Naples, FL 34103
rr~
jtb
,..,..,..-
~
75;;'1.( 5aY' ;r1l8vel \.J~
~
Gene D. Luciano
10 5th Street North
Naples, FL
u
~
N~~E'b~M
Thank you for your help.
I MAR 2 3 1999
f
~ Pg. lo
L~.........;r.,.",..~.-
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
February 22, 1999
TO:
Greg Mihalic, HUI Director ~ JJ
Sue Filson, Administrative Assist~:J I ..
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
Tourist Development Council
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for
consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review as follows:
Joy Lelonek
7024 Pelican Bay Boulevard #501
Naples, FL 34108
Louise J. Thaell
730 9th Avenue South
Naples, FL 34102
Eric J. Vasquez
341 Burning Tree Drive
Naples, FL 34105
Gene Vaccaro
700 7th Street, S.W.
Naples, FL 34117
Jerry Thirion
475 Seagate Drive
Naples, FL 34103
Gene D. Luciano
10 5th Street North
Naples, FL
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions,
please call me at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
N~~ry6 ~~
MAR 23 1999
I
SF
Attachments
Pg.
~~II~
UNITED ARTS COUNCIL
....)" ~
~ ~ " .:.L.
FEB 1 9 1999
olCollier COIIJl~)'
"All the Arts for All the People"
board of ~ountJ Corm:lssioner
February 18, 1999
Collier County Board of Commissioners
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
Dear Commissioners;
By directive of the Board of Directors of the United Ar ;mncil of Collier County. I
have been instructed to apply for one of the vacant seats on the Tourist Development
Council representing all the arts in Collier County.
The United Arts Council. the state and county designated local art agency. serves as the
umbrella organization for 36 cultural groups \vithin the county. These groups provide
almost one thousand performances throughout the year, creating a significant economic
impact upon this county. Studies are showing cultural tourism is on the rise nationally.
In Collier County the arts are enjoyed by a large percentage of the tourist trade resulting
in healthy economic grov,th for supporting services.
I am poised to provide a significant service to the Council by coordinating and filtering
the many requests from arts organizations into a more efficient and orderly system and to
encourage more collaborative efforts to minimize requests. I also anxious to partner with
the tourism industry to maximize their ability to promote this beautiful environment.
As you can see from my resume I not only have experience in the arts but have a vast
background in business and marketing management. I have been trained to make critical
decisions in a professional, businesslike manner.
I appreciate your consideration of my request and am available to answer any questions
you may have concerning this matter.
Sincerely,
()" (\
~~
N~~7-b IBM
MAR 2 3 1999
t
Pg.
-
Joy Lelonek
Executive Director
The State Designated Local Arts Agencyfor Collier COllnty
I OS I 5th .-\\enue South. Naples. Florida 34102
9-+1/263-82..+2. Fax 9-+]/263-3830. e-mail # analive@'naples,net
JOY LELONEK
7024 PELICAN BAY BLVD #501
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34108
1-941-598-3586
SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS
Proven ability to plan, develop and manage internal and external operations,
achieving broad-scale image enhancement and community awareness. Strong
organizational ability; excellent communication and speaking skills; experienced
with coordinating and directing efforts of staff and volunteer groups in a variety of
environments focusing on organizational goals.
1997-
1990-1997
1986-1989
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
UNIT.EP ARTS COUNCIL OF COLLIER COUNTY, NAPLES, FL
Executive Director
Responsible for the day to day operations of a state and county local
arts agency. Oversees the coordination and promotion of thirty six
Arts groups involving over one thousand members, Determines
public relations and marketing strategies to enhance exposure of the
arts in Collier County. Responsible for fiscal management including
endowment management, regranting and membership development.
Supervise staff, contract staff and volunteers.
INVENTORY DATA SPECIALISTS, INC., Naples, FI- Columbus, 0
CoOwner/Marketing Coordinator
Design and implement marketing strategies to enhance position in
Florida market. Organize systematic approaches to growth and
expansion. Develop public relations program to create visibility and
broaden customer base. Identify areas targeted for future growth.
Plan and develop personnel training incentive program and
communication network to assure quality control in field reporting.
DIRECTIONS FOR YOUTH, Columbus,
Director of Marketing, Development
Responsible for planning and implementing a planned giving and
corporate fund-raising plan including direct mail, corporate giving,
foundation funding and special e\'ent fund-raising. Develop and
promote public relations campaign to improve agency's image and
support fund-raising strategy. Plan and develop marking strategies to
support program expansion and broaden volunteer and donor base.
N~~EN'b YJM
,
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg '_
1985-1989
CENTRTAL OHIO DIABETES ASSOCIATION, Columbus, 0
Chapter Development Coordinator
Managed chapter programs for education, detection and fund-raising.
Developed public relations package; build communication network
with area medical personnel; organized and conducted meetings.
1978-1986
ASSOCIATION FOR THE DEVELOPMENTALLY DISABLE,
Columbus, 0
Resource Development Coordinator
Managed resource development functions including public relations,
fund-raising, volunteer coordination and recruitment. Supervised 60
volunteers and 40 student interns yearly.
EDUCATION
The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
Bachelor of Arts, Psychology - 1977
AFFILIATIONS
Board of Directors, Calais at Pelican Bay (former)
Board of Directors, Friends of TECH (former)
Member Friends of TECH (current)
Board of Directors TECH Foundation (current)
Member Naples 'Vomen's Club (current)
PRSA
N~~~O IBM
MAR 23 1999
Pg.
/0
r
~1I~
UNITED ARTS COUNCIL
~
-..,; ..
".
January 25,1999
of Collier County
"All the Arts for All the People"
Pam MacKie
Chairman, Collier County Commission
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
Dear Pam,
Great to hear that you have been elected Chair of the Collier County Commission to
succeed Barbara Berry. Surely, you desenre that honor.
Speaking of Barbara Berry - at a meeting last week of the Forum Group of the
United Arts Council where she was an invited speaker, Barbara discussed the
changes taking place in the structure of the T.D.C. We suggested to her that it
seemed clear that time had come for a representative of the United Arts Council, the
state's designated local arts agency, to be represented as a permanent member of
the Council. It has become a known fact that the "Arts" are an important economic
attraction in Southwest Florida. With ever increasing request for TDC funding
from many arts and cultural groups, it becomes obvious that choosing the desenring
ones with positive track records in operations and community service becomes
paramount. The organization best suited to senre this role should be the United
Arts Council, since their primary mission is to senre all the arts agencies .for
community betterment. We can benefit the TDC by serving as a filter for tbe many
requests while we also senre the 36 agencies that are represented within our
umbrella framework.
Needless to say, Barbara Berry agreed that this seemed to be an obvious solution to
the TDC revision dilemma. A place should be secured for the UAC - the
organization that has been commissioned by our county commission to represent all
the arts in the area.
Let's get together soon to discuss this. The time is right.
Sincerely,
~QJ\~~n \'Y\. Bf\eu:YY\
N~GE~ I
::R~/99 I
-a;''''~~'' ~~~.."'_..
Marilyn Brown
President, UAC Board of Directors
f
~
l
,
1
The State Designated Local Arts Agency for Collier County
1051 5th Avenue South' Naples, Florida 34102
94[/263-8242' Fax 941/263-3830' e-mail # artalive@naples.net
~eD-~~-~Y ~2:35 Naples Trol ley Tours
941-262 6967
P.Ol
RECEIVED
TRM & ASSOCIATES, INC. C"
730 9TH A VENUE SOUTH / Ho~ i 9 1999
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34102Soar-d of Count.r COtmtiss;oner~
941-434-0032
February 19, 1999
Ms. Sue Filson
Fax #774-3602
Hello Sue,
Please accept this fax as application to apply for one of the V8.CalL seats on the Tourism
Development Council. I have been a resident of Collier County since January of 1969 - with the
exception of 1 S years spent living and working in Kona, Hawaii in the tour business,
--
Presently I am owner operator of"TRM" & Associates, Inc. (Tourism Related Marketing.
established January of 1997.) I am currently the Marketing director of Naples Trolley Tours,
Everglades Excursions,
I am very committed to the tourism industry in Southwest Florida and would welcome the
opportunity to serve on the TDC Committee. References and resume available upon request,
Thank you,
Sincerely,
~< <-~.;.~-, 9 :7kt-L.
Louise 1. Thaell
-
~AGENQA .IT.t;.M
No .j(2:IL--
MAR 2 3 1999
\ pg.~
~--
f))tl'J~ J,3r.f. Oe.).'] ~
'~oll~y 10(-<1":5 a6~- 7.>>0
'--&/1 flbl1e - ??~O ~ 011 S-
Feb-19-99 13:33 Naples Trolley Tours
941-262 6967
P.01
,
NAPLES TROLLEY TOURS
TO: 6~ -:;~,0 nOM DATE:d/-11-tfc;
Louise TbaeU Number or pagel
Oirc:ctor of Sales cl Advertising b1ctadiDg cover.
,Phone: 941-262-7300
FAXN 171-.3&01 Fax: 941~262-6967
JJ- C/o/-
r du.('a.r~A<-/- ~'l.!.~4!-f; N~~~-ur - ~ /QL4U~ .
IJ~ OI~JIc'SI o!t1kAe.ciJ',yU.<A:)'YU-~: ~csJi~
1)(>/1;',') II< 'L6~ 'fa..u<U.D€V /~(P9
S~ ;/ ff. (ji-LfJ ~ 17 l:A
[!put). ~ /'YU.a~ a.ta-ttcUot. - /'7'}:< - 17'1(',
~~yY)r;c
~cM-U>94-. I
Odtb-cll'~ 0w~
if ' ') I I I. ) ~ ~ d.u.J:u. cZ....J!.da./ "
/1?-% -- /99 L ('Y ~u.-~ &f/;.(~A./ ~../'-'.,
~~" 1!~a.... - (CP><-') f~L
/911-19fJ. tPL~'--' y~~ ~"
19?J.,- ;(2f..1fX'a-u"-:IiA,eiY.<k 7Mf-t~' (~~....;:r~ ~d
~ lEI-{ f- ~)&~~rue.- p~AL~d ffC~,
_ JL!~-(.I:u.~~CJ ~c-~: ~t4/ jA.~/~ t.
t!:? o.t. /1 ~ ./ I))-V') (, '71ruJle . _ ~J
~~~~'lJ:LV"Z/f-~ . "-/-' No. loP
/~r
fJ~'I.M<C.f.~: tJd,e./J,:u.n.dt: MAR 2 3 1999
)?a1t $ltJiD{ Pg.
IF FOR ANY REASON YOU DO NOT RECEIVE TIllS TRANSMISSION IN ITS ENTIRETY
PLEASE CONTACT THE ABOVE PERSON ·
SEDANS · LUXlJRV LIMOUSINES · EXECUTIVE VANS" MIN-BUSES .. COACHES" TROLLEYS
1100 6TH Avenue South. Suite 221A" Naples, Florida 34102. 941.262-7300. 800/592-0848. fax 941/262-6967
www.naples-transportation.com · www. n~l~s-trolley. com · www.everglades-excursionscom
02/19/99 11:45 FAX 9416420137
1:...1. \'h;:'IaIL'J:..f.. en.
RECEIVED
'Law Offices of
FEB 1 g 1999
ERIC J. V ASQUoE~~C_i"ioners
,~
~~~;.
"h.d'b:t\",~
~.t-:;~~~~
'';';'';~.,.", ;If...
......Je..:..~:.~ .!1.
,......~l'rw~~
...._~'I,..,I'~.
~:" ~':"~frB:..
. -.~ \~ >' ''';:..:~ ~ ~:;~~.
:-;~:: ..~~~~;~,
993 North Collier BlvcL
Marco Island, Florida 34145
Reply to Marco Island
649 Fifth Avenue South
Naples, Florida 34102
Tel: 941-642-8111
941-430-0999
Fax: '41-642-0137
FAX Transmittal
". ..-. Is ~ fat 1M laM ~ tbI ~ or enuty to wNdt It " ICIcIrested ..cI "'" cantlltlI IllIfuI"~ .....
Ia "".~ .......1Woc.ltW IrllOl Uiempt from dl~ uncler llPOIICIII* IIW. . Cl'lt I'NOef Of UlIl mtNaIIt II I'OC ""
MC.nMd ncIpWIl. or ttle ~ qf tIgeI'It ~ for cMOwfmg lht IMCSI9' to "" ~ ~ )IOU ..
MnIt7y naaned fMt .try ~ dtstr1budon or copy Qf UIt ~1lI(;IQQn \$ IU1CUy pt'OMlItd. If Y9" """
~ WI ~ In emw. ,.... notify &It lnNne.~ '" ~ Md r-.m tile ortgtnaI message to us .
!he MeW!!~. via the U.s. P'OstII8erYIca. 'Il\antt)lOU,
From: Eric
Date: 2119199
Fax No.: 941-714-3602
v r
Notes:
3VI ;:3ur-r1/~v~ Tye-r-L)r
~ L(/D~-
Original to follow by U.S. Mall.
AGENPA IbM
No. _L-I.l
MAR 2 3 1999
L pg...-{i
02/19/99 11:45 FAX 94164201J7
.t.~. "l\.,;;,r.:cL'.L..LI, .&...~
Law Offices of
Eric J . Vasquez
Attorney at Law
Also Adm1tted I.a Massatbuseas
The Royal Palm Mall
993 N. ~ Boulevard
Marro Island, FlorirlA 3.4145
649 ylith Avenue S.
Suite 220
N8ples, Florida 34102
Phone (941) 642-8111
Fo: (941) 642-0137
PhoD~ (941) 43O..Q999
Please Reply to
Marco Island
February 19, 1999
Ms. Sue Filson
AdTTlinistrative Assistant,
Board of County Conimissioners
3301 Tamiami Trail, East
Naples, FL 34112
Re: Tourist Development Council
Dear Ms. Filson:
I am enthusiastic and confident to submit this correspondence and my resume as
application for one of the two positions becoming available with the Collier County
Tourist Development Council. I am enthusiastic because it is through the Tourist
Development Council that I can concentrate my efforts to better our community. I am
confident because my education,. skills and experience will benefit the Tourist
Development Council in the next two years.
I have been a resident of Collier County for nearly six (6) years. I have been
travcling to Collier County for nearly ten (10) years. CWTently, I reside with my wife
and two young daughters in the north end of Naples. I have two offices from which I
operate my law practice. The principal office is in Marco Island and the satellite office,
where I generally meet clients. is in downtown Naples. Therefore, I have the opportunity
to be in several different areas of the County on a day-to-day basis.
In addition to being a business owner in Collier County, I am active with the
Collier County Bar Association. and I am currently the Secretaly of the Y oung La~ers
Division. I have spoken to high school classes on the law, judged the annual high school
F'\EIlIC'CalRES~cm
AGENDA ITEM
No. /0 0
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg._ IS
02/19/99 11:45 FAX 941642013i
E.J. VASQtmZ. fA
~V"
Ms. Sue Filson
Febnwy 19. 1999
PaSt 2
mock trial competition. and have coached little league baseball. In addition to the
numerous professional associations of which I am an active member, I am also past
president of the Naples Rugby Football Club. The Naples Rugby Football Club is a
social and athletic organization with over SO members, Each year the Rugby Club
sponsors a tournament in August which attracts rugby teams from around the state. In the
last three years attendance bas tripled. Last year over 350 people from outside the COWlty
were in attendance. Over two thirds of the attendants made accommodations to spend the
evening somewhere in Collier County. A portion of the proceeds from the tournament go
to charity. The Rugby Club also holds a food drive for the homeless every holiday
season.
As one can see. I am deeply TOoted in the Collier County Community. This is my
home, and it will be for many. many years to come. My civic activity also demonstrates
that I am an active member of this community and not just a passive observer. All this
explains my desire to become more active in shaping our community. Tourism is a large
part of the social and economic structure of Collier County. Tourism needs to be
embraced and prompted to better the lives of all who live and visit Collier County, It is
through the Tourist Development Council that I can further concentrate my efforts to
promote the betterment of our community.
If you. any County Commissioners, members of the Tourist Development Council,
or otherwise, have questions concerning my qualifications or desire, please feel free to
call. Otherwise. I look forward to working with you, all the County Commissioners and
the Tourist Development Council in the near future.
FJV/
AGEjo I~M
No. -/,L-
F:~_
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg .LiP
U~/l~/~~ ll:~~ t.~ ~~~O~~V~vl
EDUCATION:
CURRENT
EMPLOYMENT:
EMPWYMENT
HISTORY:
PROFESSIONAL
MEMBERSHIPS:
~."'. "/'\.....;...'-.l.....~, 01...
ERIC JOHN VASQUEZ
Law Offices of Eric 1. Vasquez
993 North Collier Boulevard
Marco Island. Florida 34145
(941) 642 - 8111
New England School of Law, Boston, Massachutetts
Juris Doctor, May 1991
Academic Standing: Top 25% of Class
Dean's List: Academic Years 1989, 1990 and 1991
UpsaJa CoUege. East Orange, New Jersey
Baehelor of Arts, History, May 1988
Bachelor of Am, Political Science, May 1988
Dean's List: Academic Years 1986, 1987 and 1988
Phi Alpha 1beta. National Honor Sotiety for History
Law OfficeJ of Eric J. Vuque'Z, Marco Island and Naples, Florida
President, April, 1998 to Present
Practicing in state and federal coutts in the areas of civil and crimina1law including
misdemeanors and felonies, personal injury. produas liability, medical malpractice,
wrongful death, premises liability, consuuction law, contract litigation, civil rights,
emplOyIDeIlt law and real estate transactions.
McDonnell Trial Lawyers, Naples, Florida
Associate, May J 993 to Marcb 1998
N'U1Cty percent of practice in litigation, including commercial, constrUCtion, personal
injwy, wrongful death, federal civil rights violations, criminal, medical malpractice,
professional malpractice, appellate practice and family law. Responsible for all aspects
of case management including discovery, settlement negotiations, appcarnnce for
motions. trial and appeals. I have appeared as lead counsel and secondary counsel for
jury and bench trials. I have prncticed in the trial COuJU of F1orida. the appellare courts
ofAorida, the Middle District Court of Florida, and the Eleventh Cfrcuit Court of
Appeals. Very well versed in federal trial practice and procedure. Managed and
supervised secretarial and paralegal staff. Well versed with computers including word
processing, case management, calendar management, accounting. CD Rom, West1aw,
LEXlS and Windows 98.
Curtin-Sullivan and Sullivan, Brockton, Massachusetts
A!sociate December 1991 to April 1993; Law Oerk 1990 to 1991
Eighty percent of practice wa.!; in litigation with a primary emphasis on personal injury
and c:riminallaw. Responsible for all aspects of case management including ctient
contaet. discovery, settlement negotiations, appearance on motions and trial. Second
seat in aver ten trials in two years. Managed all estate matte~ including estate planning
and administnUioa Coordinated and developed a workmen's compensation practice for
the firm. Managed and supervised ~ and paralegal sra1f. Developed a
computer system 10 better access information and service clients.
Massachusetts Bar Assodation, Florida Bar Association, Ameriow Bar .Association,
Collier County Bar Association. Florida Academy of Trial Attorneys, Middle District of
Florida, Eleventh Circuit Coun of Appc:als, and American Inns of Court.
REFERENCES A V AILABLE UPON REQUEST
N~~E1o If5M
~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. / 1
~ECE'VED
;:~Q \ '1 '~~9
1 I_(.~ I '.' I.........
~Odrd of County Commissioners
2/8/99
Board of Collier County Commissioners
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112-4977
Dear Commissioners:
Please consider this letter indicating my desire to continue to serve
the citizens of Collier County as a member of the Tourist Development
Council. I am currently serving in the non-ovvner/operator category
My term exrpires April 21, .1999,
As part of my occupational responsibility, tourism development and
promotion in Collier County has been a focus for me for the past 10 years.
Thank you for your consideration,
Sincer~ ~
Gene~~
700 7th Street S,W
Naples, Florida 34117
(941) 354-0100
(Resume Enclosed)
AGEN'O IJ;;M
No. J
*
MAR 2 3 1999
L_ pg.--4-
j
~L:LlL:
I l
1
700 7th Street S.W, Naples. Rorida 34117. Home ( 941) 354-0100. Office ( 941) 774-0000. Cell (941) 777-0833
Llull(l~
Advertising, Event Planning, Promotions, Conceptualizing.
Building exceptional loyalty and enthusiasm among fellow employees,
A proven ability to create public awareness, excitement and
support for a new product, service, or special event.
~lULlr
Creative copy writing and graphic design, understanding
of all print and electronic media, publicity and public
relations, proficiency in Corel Draw PC Graphics program.
ljl~Ll\1Ll((t
Nov. 1997 - Current Promotions Director, Celebration Gardens, Naples, FL
(70 acre entertainment and special event venue)
1989 - 1997 txecutive Director, Florida Sports Park, Naples
( 130 acre sports and special event venue)
1985 - 1989 Owner, Vaccaro & Associates Advertising, Knoxville, TN
1976 - 1985 Art Director, Keith press & Associates, Knoxville, TN
1971 - 1976 Creative Director, GSA, Knoxville, TN
l~t!l1~L ll!ll
1966 - 1969 Florida State University
AGENPA lTEM
No. 10 0
MAR 2 3 1999
pg .-j.:b-J
~~~~~~
L "\- \.-.... -
\mw,eo\a\e.
Jerry Thirion, CHA
SenIOr \',ce PreSIdent I Managing Director
/.'>t:::.
, L,,- t' . ,,- "
'-,......./ \/10..,
..... , /- "',
......
February 4, 1999
r ' .
Ms. Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
Board of Collier County Commissioners
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112-4977
>'. .
.'},t,.r,.
Dear Sue:
Please be advised that I wish to be considered for another term on the Tourist
Development Council. I understand that my present term does expire on April 21, 1999 and
by means of this communication, I am definitely expressing my interest to participate in
another term. I have certainly enjoyed this first term and I am looking forward to having the
opportunity to participate in the future with the other members of the Tourist Development
Council.
As requested, please find enclosed a recent resume, Should you have any further
questions or if there is anything else that I should do, please advise.
7i~~
U Thirion, CHA
Senior Vice President/Managing Director
JT:lp
N~~7b IJ5M
MAR 2 3 1999
pg>~ Q--
.r:, SC:lpatt: Dn\ l' ,\':ir/c,. Fhlrida .'./W3 (9./ I ) 5'r-323':
.." .. " ' ."
'. . .',. .'." .,' . .
, ',. . . " 0":",.' . ... . . '" .
JERRY THIRION
BIOGRAPHY
Jerry Thirion began his hospitality career in 1970 at the Colony Beach and Tennis Resort on
Longboat Key, Florida. In 1982, he resigned from the Colony as President to join the Stouffer
Hotel Company and oversee management of Stouffer properties on Lake Lanier Islands, Georgia
and in Atlanta, Georgia. Later. Thirion joined the Melrose Club Resort on Daufuski Island off
Hilton Head Island as its general manager.
In 1989, Thirion joined The Registry Hotel Corporation as General Manager of the world
famous Don CeSar, a Registry Resort on St. Petersburg Beach, Florida. Then in 1993, Thirion
was named the Vice President/Managing Director of The Registry Resort in Naples, Florida.
Presently, he is the Seniol'- V ice President/Managing Director.
Jerry Thirion is a Certified Hotel Administrator (CHA) and is actively involved with the following
local, state and national organizations:
Board of Directors of:
.
Florida Hotel & Motel Association - Chairman 1998 - 1999
The Conservancy
Naples Visitors Bureau
Southern Innkeepers Association
Vice President - Florida -1996 -1997
Past President -1986 -1988
Chaine des Rotisseurs
United Way
.
.
.
.
.
Thirion also serves on:
.
The Tourist Development Council (T.D.C.)
The Resort Committee of the American Hotel & Motel Association
.
N~~_~~Lb!K
MAR 2 3 1999
i
L Pg,~-1__
. ~~'''''''~~~""",,,,'~.--.
J
"
!
Fishing Vessels
Sightseeing/Sunset Vessels
RECEIVED
FEB 0 8 1999
Sue Filson-Admin. Asst.
Board of County Commissioners
3301 Tamiami Trail East
Naples, FL. 34112
BOird of County ComRiss1oner$
February 4,1999
SirlMadam:
Enclosed is my resume in support of my application for the Tourist Development Council
Advisory Committee position opening as advertised in the February, 1999 edition of the
Naples Daily News.
Thank you for your consideration.
Yours, ~
{1j J1 ~
~tJU.
Gene D. Luciano
President/Owner
Lady BrettIDouble Sunshine, Inc.
AGE~o.e. ~M
No.J.U__~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg._~~--
L _~~_1(,"',.,___.....~,-,~,....._.~_~.__,..,
Docked at TIM CITY
Lady Brett, Inc, · 1200 5th Ave, S. · Naples, Florida 34102 · (941) 263-4949 . Fax (941) 263-3853
Gene D. Luciano
10 5th Street North,
Naples, Florida
941-263-4949
Objective
ExPerience
Summary: During My Professional Carreer, I have held
responsible supervisory & management positions in the
Hospitality & Tourism Industry. In addition, I have been
the President and business owner of both Charter
Fishing/Diving and a major Sightseeing attraction in the
greater Collier County area. I am a major supporter and
active participant in the various tourism related issues
surrounding my industry.
1971-1973 Marco Beach Hotel
Clubs Manager
. Staff Management and Recruiting
. Increased Sales Volume
. Implemented Plans to Increase Efficiency of Operations
1973-1978
Restaurant Owner
Marco Island, FL
Restaurateur
. Established and Managed 185-Seat Restaurant.
. Designed & SupeNised Renovations Of Facility
. Implemented training course for new employees.
. Established Advertising Program to Increase Revenues. -
. Full P&L Responsibility.
1974-Present
Maritime Business
Marco & Naples
Charter Fishing, Diving, Sightseeing Operator
. Currently Own & Operate three (3) Commercial Vessels On Naples Bay
. SupeNised Design & Manufacture of six Commercial Vessels.
. Financial Management & Operations.
. Expanded Sales Objectives Through Tourism Related Markets.
. Established Maintenance Programs to insure compliance with U.S. Coast
Guard Regulations.
. Recruit, Hire and Train All Professional Staff.
. Established Network Referral Program With Various S.W. Florida
Attractions.
N~~Ef6 If?
MAR 2 3 1999
p 9 . --23---
-_e..~:r~-..:::<-"'--~ .....,... "''':'$-~"..
Personnel:
Collier County Resident Since 1970,
Member of South West Florida Attractions.
Collier County Marine Trades Association.
Naples Fishing Club,
Former Rotarian and Kawanis Member.
Annual Sponsor of local Police Athletic League Events.
Member Collier County Education Foundation.
Sponsor of Hispanic Heritage Celebration.
Sponsor Naples Youth Basketball.
Lorenzo Walker Vocational Steering Committee.
Sponsor Collier Parks & Recreation Youth Program.
AGENDA,IJJM
No,-l.O-4J-
MAf? 2 3 1999
p 9 . ~~:'~~:w~__j
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
-~
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO RADIO ROAD BEAUTIFICA nON ADVISORY
COlvfMITTEE
OBJECTIVE: To appoint one member to serve the remainder of a vacant term, expiring on
March 3. 2001. on the Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee aids and assists
the Board of County Commissioners in carrying out the purposes of providing curbing, watering
facilities, plantings and maintenance of the median areas as set forth in Ordinance No. 96-84.
This 5 member committee shall recommend work programs and priorities to the County
Administrator or his designee. Members shall be permanent residents within the MSTU. After
initial staggered terms, terms will be 4 years.
A list of the current membership is included in the backup.
A press release was issued and resumes \vere received from the following interested citizens:
APPLICANT
CATEGORY
DIST
ELECTOR ADV. COMM.
Susan Saum
n/a
3
yes none
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
Susan Saum
~
FISCAL IMPACT: NONE
GRO\\TH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMME:\DATION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment and appoint one member to fulfill the remainder of the vacant
term. and direct the County Attorney to prepare a resolution confirming the appointment
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Date: MARCH 23, 1999
,-...
AGEND;riT~
No. _.~V..-&-
MAR 2 3 1999
/
Pg.
MEMORANDUM
DATE: March 9, 1999
TO: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Daniel DeCesare, Engineer II -p)-N
-
Transportation Services Department
SUBJECT: Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee
Susan Saum Application
On March 9. 1999, the Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee met with a three-member
quorum necessary to take formal action. The three members requested that the Board give
consideration to Susan Saum's application, which 1 received by FAX from you on February 22,
1999.
Susan is a registered voter and lives within the Radio Road MSTU. Susan's area of expertise seems
to be business management.
If you need any more infon11ation, please do not hesitate to contact me. 1\'ly telephone number is
77 4-8494.
cc: Edward 1. Kant, P.E., Transportation Services Director
File: Radio Road MSTU
N~G~7~ ;!~_
MAR 2 3 1999
., -, t
/",'9 . ---~-- _..i
.---~...-..-.-
Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Pholle DateRe-appt 21ldExpDate 21ld Term
Wolfgang B.P. Schulz 09/01/98 03/03/02 - '-<I .,.,:J~. ,r'~
260 Lambton Lane 455-7909 ' . .1..1 '"
Naples, FL 34104
District: 3
Category: Foxfire
Wilfred Jaeger 09/01/98 03/03/01 - , I~ ".::
-
139 Artic \A/ay 643-5029
Naples, FL 34104
District: 3
Category: F oxfire
Crystal K. Kinzel 03/03/98 03/03/00 2 Years
498 Henle\' Drive 353-5477
Naples, FL 34105
District: 3
Category: Berkshire Lakes
Kathryn Godfrey-Irwin 03/03/98 03/03/00 2 Ye:J.rs
5021 Brixton Court 435-9074
0iJples. FL 34104
District: 3
Category: Bri~lfwood ,
. .' "v
/"\ . ~
Leona P. Hyland '" ~ I1r~C\ 03 0398 03/03/01 ~ "'"
2..+2 St. James Way //1 455-3061
'\:aples. FL 34104
District: 3
Category: Countryside
ThiS 5 member committee was created on October 21, 1997, by Ordinance No 97-52 to cC c"d
assist the Board of County Commissioners in carrying out the purposes of providing curbing
watenng facilities, plantings and maintenance of the median areas as set forth In Ordinance No,
96-84 The committee shall recommend work programs and priorities to the County
Administrator or his designee Members shall be permanent residents within the MSTU Terms
are 4 years,
FL ST.4T: ]25.01
Staff: Russ Muller, Engineer II: 774-8494
- ,,~~~.~.b~~
MAR ~'3 1999
Pg,_J_ ~_
~o;;ober I rlT;;;.~'---
-
Page I of I
.~:I'''r1t;......-,-- ..------ r "t.
=------~-----
MEMORANDUM
?~ ro... ~~\,..<..:~
- -----
L.. ....~
DATE: February 22, 1999
TO: Vinell Hills, Elections Office
FROM: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant M,
Board of County Commissioners d:' '7
RE: V oter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also. please list the commission district in which each applicant resides.
RADIO ROAD BEAU ADVISORY COMM
COMMISSION DISTRlCT
Susan Sauro
5060 Coldstream Lane
Naples, FL 34104
r
3
Thank you for your help.
AGEN9~ IJ.iM
N0, J V&--
MAR t 3 1999
Pg i
------ J.
----
"'JO:It"",.., --.---
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
February 22, 1999
TO:
Dan DeCesare. En2.ineer Il r /1
Sue Filson, Admin:strative ASSiSUmrir '
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for
consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review as follows:
Susan Saum
5060 Coldstream Lane
Naples, FL 34104
Please let me know, in \-\'Titing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions,
please call me at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Attachments
N~~EN7DI~ .
MAR ? 3 1999
Pg. ,,$._--
-....-.~----'---..,....
. ,--..,~_._.._,.__.,---,-,-_.-
qc r.:.:: f \1 t:'.l
5060 Coldstream Lane
Naples, Florida 34104-4736
February 17, 1999
", '\'"'
/,'t
'.'i,,"
Ms. Sue Filson
Board of County Commissioners
Collier County Government Complex
3301 East T amiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
Dear Ms. Filson:
Please consider my application for a position on the Radio Road Beautification
Committee.
I relocated to Collier County from Illinois in 1970 and have resided in Briarwoodl off
Radio Road, for the past five years.
My husband and I are business O'WTlers in Collier County. Additionally, I am
employed as an accountant and have several years experience the in accounting
and customer service fields. My educational background includes an associate's
degree from Edison Community College. I have recently completed the course
work and will receive a Bachelors Degree in Business and Management from Barry
University next month.
Should you require additional information, you may call me \Neekdays at 793-9358 or
evenings at 263-4030. I appreciate your consideration and look forward to hearing
from you.
N~~El!; I~
MAR ',1 3 1999
~g,._~ --
;;>onL":P"UI~_..--,.....:;"
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
~
RECOMMENDATION TO DECLARE A VACANCY ON THE GOLDEN GATE
BEAUTIFICATION MSTU ADVISORY COMMITTEE
OBJECTIVE: To declare a vacancy on the Golden Gate Beautification MSTU Advisory Comminee
and to direct staff to issue a press release soliciting resumes in an effort to fill the vacant position.
CONSIDERATIONS: Ordinance No. 92-42, Section 4, reads as follows: "It is the intent and strong
desire of the Commission that there be full attendance of advisory Board members at all meetings of
the Boards, recognizing, however, that it may be necessary for Board members to be absent from a
meeting due to unusual or emergency circumstances. Nevertheless, full attendance at Board meetings
is encouraged and necessary for the proper operation of the Boards and in furtherance thereof the
following requirements are established: A. Any Board member who is absent for more than one-half
of the Board's meetings in a given fiscal year shall be deemed to have tendered his or her resignation
for such Board. The Commission shall, as soon as practicable after such resignation, declare the
position to be vacant and shall promptly fill same pursuant to the provisions of Section Six herein.
The Board member shall not serve at any meetings after his or her position is declared vacant by the
Commission. B. In the event that any Board member is absent from two consecutive Board meetings
without a satisfactory excuse acceptable to the Board chairman, the Board chairman shall state such
fact at the next regularly scheduled Board meeting and shall thereafter notify, in wTiting, the
Administrative Assistant to the Commission of the Board member's failure to anend without
~ satisfactory excuse, The Commission shall review the Board Chairman's notification at a
Commission meeting and shall declare the Board member's position to be vacant if the Commission
concurs that the Board member was absent from two consecutive Board meetings without a
satisfactory excuse and shall promptly fill same pursuant to the provisions of Section Six herein. The
Board member shall not serve at any meetings after his or her position is declared vacant. C. A
member of a Board shall be deemed absent from a meeting when he or she is not present during at
least 75% of the meetings.
Mr. Mark Houghton has missed more than six (6) consecutive meetings, unexcused.
Attached is a letter from the Chairman of the committee requesting that the Board of County
Commissioners declare a vacancy on the committee and direct staff to advertise to fill the vacancy.
FISCAL IMP ACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMP ACT: NONE
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the recommendation to
declare a vacancy on the Golden Gate Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee and direct staffto
issue a press release soliciting new members. It is also recommended that the Board of County
Commissioners direct the County Attorney to prepare a resolution declaring the position vacant.
N~~Er'b I?
--
Prepared By:
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
MAR 2 3 1999
/
.
Pg.
Date:
MARCH 23,1999
__ _w_____.-._.____.___..__..".. .._ ..."'__;......''''''__,,_,_~..,,____,_
Golden Gate Beautification Advisory Committee
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Cheryle L. Newman 11107/95 10/06/97 2 Years
5101 31st Avenue, S.W. 353-7969 12/16/97 1 0/06/0 1 4 Years
Naples, FL 34116
District: 3
Category: Precinct 626
Mark \V. Houghton 434-5090 07/22/97 10/06/97 2 Mas
1748 46th Street, S.W. 353-4021 7/22/97 10/06/0 1 4 Years
Naples, FL 34116
District: 3
Category: Precinct 624
Sabina Musci 10/04/94 10/06/98 4 Years
4470 32nd Avenue, S.W. 2/9/99 lO/06/02 4 Years
Naples, FL 34116
District: 3 .L ,
Category: Precinct 627
Bonner G. Bacon 11107/95 10/06/98 3 Years
2570 47th Terrace, S.W. 455-4373 2/9/99 10/06/02 4 Years
Naples,FL 34116
District: 3
Category: Precinct 623/626
Charles McMahon 999-3498 OS/27/97 10/06/99 2 + Years
4433 20th Avenue, S.W. 353-2055
Naples, FL 34116
District: 3
Category: Precinct 625
This 5 member committee was created by Ord. No. 87-78 to advise and recommend as to the
beautification and maintenance of landscape improvements within the road right of way as
described by ordinance boundaries. The committee shall prepare an itemized budget of the
amount of money required to carry out the business of the committee for the next fiscal year.
Amended on September 3.1996, by Ord. No. 96-50 and 96-51. Precincts are 623.624,625,626,
627, and part of 622
FL STAT: 125.01
Staff: Dan DeCesare, Engineer II: 774-8494
Friday, February Il, 1999
Page 1 of 1
No, 78E,=-
MAR 2 3 1999
M
f Pr~~
--.............
"'-, - ,'~
--- . --~';.,
. ' '.-,
Golden Gate Beautification M.S.T.U. Advisory Committee
March 10, 1999
Ms. Sue Filson
Administrative Assistant
Board of Collier County Commissioners
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
RE: ADVISORY BOARD MEMBER NON-PARTICIPATION
Dear Ms. Filson,
The above advisory board meet on March 9, 1999 and appointed me as representative, to address
the following concern.
Mr. Mark Houghton, a member of this appointed advisory board, has missed more than six (6)
consecutive meetings, unexcused. Monday, March 8, 1999 his files were delivered to me, without
explanation or resignation letter affixed. May we assume he is a volunteer quit')') Has he provided
you with his letter of resignation??
This advisory board would ask your assistance in providing a replacement for his position. Would
you please advertise this opening at your earliest convenience, as we have been operating without
his attendance for six (6) months.
Thank you in advance for your cooperation,
If you have any questions regarding this request, please feel free to contact me at 353-7969.
Sincerely,
~d/)h~d~-
~(~~~n
Co-Chairman
c.c: AIl members
Dan DeCesare- Engineer II
Russ Muller. Engineer II
N~~E/O ~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. .3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO COUNTY GOVERNMENT PRODUCTIVITY
COMMlTTEE
--
OBJECTIVE: To appoint/reappoint five members to serve 2 year terms expiring on February 4,
2001, to the County Govemment Productivity Committee.
CONSIDERATIONS: The County Government Productivity Committee has 5 vacancies; the
terms expired on February 4, 1999. This committee is composed of 13 members, one of whom is
the vice chair of the Board of County Commissioners. The remaining twelve members are
appointed by resolution of the Board of County Commissioners for a two year term and must be
permanent residents and electors of Collier County. Committee members are required to possess
special expertise and experience related to managing large organizations, and must be balanced
in representing the views of the community. The committee reviews the efficiency of
departments of County Government under the jurisdiction of the Board of County
Commissioners. The committee may analyze and review existing structure, organization,
staffing, management, functions, business practices. and procedures of any or all parts of county
government and make recommendations for increased efficiency and cost-effectiveness. The
committee may also assist in the implementation of those recommendations.
A list of the current membership is included in the backup.
~ Two press releases were issued and resumes were received from the follO\ving 5 interested
citizens:
APPLlCA]\T CA TEGORY DIST ELECTOR ADV. COMM.
Edward T, Ferguson (reappt) Bs Mgmt & Ed 3 yes CGPC
William E, Ebben (reappt) Corporate Executive :2 yes CGPC
Charles E. Getler (reappt) Bs Mgmt :2 yes GCPC
Sharon Hanlon Attorney 5 yes none
Donald Campbell Corporate Mgmt :2 yes none
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
Edward 1. Ferguson - re-appointment
William E. Ebben - re-appointment
Charles E. Getler - re-appointment
Sharon Hanlon - new appointment
Donald Campbell - new appointment
NOTE: Section Seven (b.) (1) of Ordinance 86-41 states "Terms of office for Board members
shall be limited to two consecutive terms of service on anyone Board. . ." Under (3) of the same
section, it is noted that "By a unanimous vote of the Commission, the limitations set forth in
subsection (b) (1) above may be waived". According to available records, Edward T. Ferguson
has served two full terms. Should the Board wish to re-appoint Mr. Ferguson, the limitations on
__ two consecutive terms will need to be waived. N~~~/P~
FISCAL IMPACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
MAR 2 3 1999
I
Pg.
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment and appoint five members to serve two year terms, and direct
the County Attorney to prepare a resolution confirming the appointments.
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Date: MARCH 23, 1999
N~.~:~b~~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ::L
RECEIVED
MAR
( 10:g
)(-1('" l' '~lJi:- ,:>m's~..:;[1e
Memorandum
To:
Sue Filson. Administrative Assistant
Board ofCountv Commissioners )' J
Gary Vincent Senior Budget & Management Analyst Il
Staff Liaison to the Productivity Comminee ./
March 12, 1999
From:
Date:
Re:
Recommendation for Filling Two Vacant Posinons on the Comminee
The Collier County Govemment Productivity Comminee has re\'iewed five applications for the five vacant
positions on the comminee, The applicants were evaluated based on their potential contribution to the committee.
The Producti\'ity Comminee has recommended the follo\ving three applicants for reappointment to the
comminee. Edward Ferguson's reappointment requires a waiver because he has already served t\vo consecutive
tem1S on the commmee,
I\ame
Area of Expertise
Edward 1. Ferguson
215 Silverado Drive
I\aples. FL 34119
Employee benefits and college level teaching
William E. Ebben
12254 Collier's Reser;e Drive
:'\aples. FL 34110
Real estate management cost reduction. purchasing,
training and operations
Charles E. Geller
6855 San :-13000 Dri\'e 1\0. 209
:'\apks. FL 34 I OS
Cost reduction. efficiency. purchasing. fmanciaI analysis
The following two applIcants are reconm1ended by the Producti\'ity Comminee to fill the remammg t\vo
vacanCies.
:\'ame
Area of Expertise
Sharon Hanlon
4555 SheaT\vater Lane
Naples. FL 34119
Trial Anomey, Plaintiffs Personal Injury Litigation
Managing Partner
Donald Campbell
6849 Grenadier Boulevard, # 11 0 1
:\' aples, FL 34108
Corporate management, operations
All applications are on file in the Office of Management and Budget. Please call 774-8810 ifyou~Wre~
additional information r ~ ';E~.~EM
,
C":::> h
,._.::'-:~'--_.-J
"'!t ') "."'po
''''i-~i-' t.. j
1999
County Government Productivity Committee
Name Work Pho1le Appt'd Exp, Date Term
Home Pho1le DateRe-appt 21ldExpDate 21ld Term
Charlie Moss 07/28/98 02/04/99 6 Mos.
990 Cape Marco Drive, Unit 607 389-0131
Marco Island, FL 34145
District: 1
Category: Mgmt & Marketing
Wolfgang B.P. Schulz 07/28/98 02/04/00 1.5 Years
260 Lambton Lane 455-7909
Naples, FL 34104
District: 3
Category: Exec Mgmt & Financial
Bill L. Neal 11/07/95 02/04/96 3Mo.
3839 Clipper Lane 774-6325 2/1 7/98 02/04/00 2 Years
Naples. FL 34112
District: 4
Category: Retired Businessman
John E. Stockton 11/07/95 02/04/96 2 Mo.
2230 Royal Lane 774-0902 2/17/98 02/04/00 2 Years
Naples. FL 34112
District: 1
Category: Retired Businessman
Judith E. McCaffrey 514-2800 01/12/99 02/04/99 1 mo.
225 5th Street. S. 1/12/99 02/04/01 2 Yrs.
l\'aples. FL 3410':
District: 4
Category: Attorney
Robert 1\1. Calmers 07/28/98 02/04/00 1 .5 Y rs
4535 Liuhthouse Lane 793-4574
Naples. FL 34112
District: 4
Category: Property Mgmt & Bs Publishing
Janev Vasev 01/12/99 02/04/00 1 Year
. .
4398 Lon2:shore Way North 598-4378
Naples, FL 34119 -
District: 5
Category: Financial
~
.^""::;TU~''';;::C';'~-:'~''>;';'~7;_,.~~ :"-"~__~'<.j"'^~.:'.C";;.~,c;.:--:!",~",._..#;..r.o>4';W-~~~~.;~~~~-:,;~~_;:;;"
Frtda}" March 12, 1999 Page I of3
,,,tm:NpA UEM
!'Ie lElbd~"
\ t-\AR 2 '3 \999
\ Po. '-1--- ,.)
~ ' -' --::1:-----
~...-......--.'-
County Government Productivity Committee
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp, Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Edward T. F enmson 02/28/95 02/04/97 2 Years
215 Silverado Drive 1/7/97 02/04/99 2 Years
Naples, FL 34119
District: 3
Category: Business MgmuEducation
Karl 1. Otto 11107/95 02/04/96 3 Mo.
901 Collier Court, No. 5-201 642-3798 2/17/98 02/04/00 2 Years
Marco Island, FL 34145
District: 2
Category: Retired Engineer
Robert D. Laird 07/16/96 02/04/97 1 Year
1765 Courtyard Way. #205.C 793-0933 1/7 /97 02/04/99 2 Years
Naples, FL 34112
District: 1
Category: Real Estate/Insurance
\VilIiam E. Ebben 12/09/97 02/04/99 1 Year
12254 Colliers Reserve Drive 592-1158
Naples. FL 34110
District: 2
Category: Corporate Executive
James D. Carter 77 4-8097 01/12/99 01/11/00 1 Year
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
1\aples, FL 34112
District: -+
Category: BCC Vice Chairman Designee
Charles E. Getler 07/16/96 02/04/97 1 Year
6855 San Marino Drive 598-1860 1/7/97 02/04/99 2 Years
Naples. FL 34108
District: 2
Category: Business Management
Fridaj\)t;;;;hii.;'l999=='''''''''''''''~-''--''-'''-'''''''''~- ,~., j>age];fr'=c.--~' .b...-t~;"r;ELb ~
M:R ~~ 1999 I
-,...:=........,..~.....~~
County Government Productivity Committee
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp, Date
2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
This 13 member committee was created on 01/20/91 by Ord, No, 91-10 (amended by Ord. No.
93-13 & 96-10), The committee is composed of 13 members, one of whom is the vice chair of
the BCC. Committee members are required to possess special expertise and experience related
to managing large organizations. and must be balanced in representing the views of the
community The committee reviews the efficiency of departments of County Government under
the jurisdiction of the BCC, The committee may analyze and review existing structure,
organization, staffing, management, functions, business practices, and procedures of any or all
parts of county government and make recommendations for increased efficiency and cost-
effectiveness. They may also assist in the implementation of those recommendations, Terms
are 2 years,
FL STAT:
Staff" Gary Vincent, Budget Analyst II: 774-8810
'...~'kh:"""""'-:..'""~- -. . .y__ .._. ~,"!!,,",_-'_{J;.~~;' ''''':;'-~~~':''::'.''''-.'''~'.>:.:;..'
Friday, March 12, 1999
"''''''''''"*'''''""p;g;30/]=''''"--''=-=='' ..m'N~~jf) ,$: M
MAR 2. 3 1999
F9.-iR--
...-r :I.
MEMORANDUM
~C'c,-,~ .--
,"" ~ C, Ii t: L.
_; >~. N i~ ~~-::
DATE: January 11, 1999
-. -"\ ~ ... ":' " . ~
FROM:
Vinell Hills. Elections Office
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistan#'
Board of County Commissioners
TO:
RE:
V oter Registration. Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory comminees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also, please list the commission district in which each applicant resides.
COUNTY GOVERNMENT PRODUCTIVITY COMM COMMISSION DISTRICT
Donald Campbell
6849 Grenadier Boulevard, #1101
Naples. FL 34108
lr
~
~
Sharon 1\1. Hanlon
4555 Shcarwater Lane
Naples. FL 34119
...........
j
Edv,'ard T. Ferguson
215 Silverado Drive
Naples. FL 34119
t~
I
3
v
William E. Ebben
12254 Collier's Reserve Drive
Naples, FL 34110
~
J-
Charles E. Getler
6855 San Marino Drive No. 209
Naples, FL 34108
ip
f)--
Thank you for your help.
~GENJtr~-
" ~AR 'L 3 1S99
\ pg. J~:::---.
~=---...-
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
January 11, 1999
TO:
Garv Vincent. Budl!et Analvst II ~
sue- Filson, Admin:strative ~ssistan~ '
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
County Government Productivity Committee
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for
consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review as follows:
Donald Campbell
6849 Grenadier Boulevard, # 11 0 1
Naples, FL 34108
Sharon M. Hanlon
4555 Shearwater Lane
Naples, FL 34119
Edward T. Ferguson
215 Silverado Drive
Naples. FL 34119
William E. Ebben
12254 Collier's Reserve Drive
Naples, FL 34110
Charles E. Getler
6855 San Marino Drive No. 209
Naples, FL 34108
Please let me know, in \VTiting, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions,
please call me at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
AGE N D/,. I ']:E.M
No ._./J2~
SF
Attachments
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.,g
01/08/1999 15:24
9415921335
ST LAURENT
PAGE 01
RECEIVED
:AN' 0'" '19QC
~ ,0 I ........
6849 Grena:3.ier Blvd., #1101
Naples, FL 34108
';~~r~ i).... ::0un'~/ C~mi S:) i1n{~:")
January 7, 1999
Mrs. Sue Filson, Mninistrative Assistant
Collier County Board of County Cal1missioners
\; , A (.--A)( ~'f - 3L.o ~
Dear Mrs. Filson:
I am writing again to P!'Op:)se myself as a can::lidate for the County
Goverrrrnent Prcrluctivity Carmittee. Naturally, I can provide whatever
personal background you may need. Hc:J'V.BVer, this thunb nail sketch should
help to get startErl.
1. My wife, Ruth, and I are rrost-of-the-year residents arrl registered
voters in Collier County.
2 . I em a retired Corp:>rate V. P. of Procter arrl Gamble. I joined
P & G after tiE u. s. Army and after college, ani I served 38
years 1:efore retiring in 1996. Sixteen years were outside the
U.S. I rrost recently and inrnediately before retiring, as I<egional
vice President in Latin Jllrerica arrl ChailInan of prcct:er & Gamble
M2Xico .
3. I have served as a director or trustee of several oollege arrl
rusiness organizations. Jioong these, Wi1Jnington College, Th::!
Ohio Fourrlation of looepen:ient Colleges, The Greater Cincinnati
YM:A, The krerican Chambers of Q::mrerce in Mexiro an:i in France.
4. In the mid-80 I s I was a member of the Ohio (State Coverrrnent)
Operations Improvement Task Force.
r appreciate your oonsidering my carrlidacy carefully.
s~rell'l1
( J{# lL..1.---k ~ ~
f
Donald Campl:ell
941-598-3426
AGEN9~ IXM
NO,._~~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 1
.. .. :'"
LAW OFFICES
YEGA, STANLEY, ZELMAN & HANLON, P. A.
Ge::O~GE: VE~":'. ..lP.
.JOHN F, STANL.E:Y .
THECDCR( ZL../'.A.AN
S~.A.~ON M. HANLCN .
.. AlSC L;CENSC::::: ~'" "-'I
~ ,
t 50th "
\ Jlnniversary I
~~~ ~
~
1948 1998
266::; AIR"ORT RCAD SOUTH
NAPLES. FL::R;CA 3~1 ~2 4899
THOMAS _ WCCD --
..JCHN G. VEG~
C:::JNS7ANCE M eUPKE
TE~E~~C~E (9L.. i 774.3333
TE~E::CPIE~ IS-":'~i 77"::::'.642C
<t AlSC ,-,CENSC:: .... ~Y
-+-+ A:-SC- ...ICENSC:; IN C.C.. KY, NC &. VA
CF C::'-..'....SL....
THOMAS ~. BROWN
E:JWARD E. WOLL~":"N 5. ~S3:::CIA7"ES, F. A,
October 20, 1998
!v1rs. Sue Fi!son
Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
3301 Tamiami Trail East
Naples FL 34111
RE: County Government Productivity Comminee
Dear Mrs. Filson:
I am interested in applying fo, one of the two vacan:;ies fi)r the above commince. I have
enclosed my reSU:11e.
I believe my past experience as manJging partner for this law firm. founding President of
the Collier County Women's Bar Association and current President and long time member of the
Women's Politic:l] C<lUCUS enables me to meet the requirements for the above position.
Please contact me at the above numher if you need additional information.
Thank v1u.
/~~~---
Sharon M. Hanlon
LjSSS Shear-waT-e:r
"3\.{I\C{
Lo-IL- e
c~
SMH:jma
I N~G~~~
I MAR 2 3 1999
i~g._/()
f
SHARON M. HANLON
Vega, Stanley, Zelman & Hanlon
2660 Airport Road South
Naples FL 34112
(941) 774-3333
PERSONAL DATA:
Marital:
Children:
Place of Birth:
David B. Rawlings, Ph.D.
three- 2 daughters and a son
Minnesota
EDUCATION:
College of St. Catherine - St. Paul, Minnesota, B.A.
Central Michigan University- Mt. Pleasant, Michigan, M.A.
Thomas M. Cooley Law School - Lansing, Michigan, J.D.
LEGAL EMPLOYMENT:
Vega, Stanley, Zelman & Hanlon, P.A.
2660 Airport Road South
Naples, FL 34116
1992 to present
Practice: Plaintiffs personal injury litigation, trial attorney
William G. Reamon Law Office
Grand Rapids, MI 49503
1982-1992
Practice: Plaintiffs personal injury litigations
LEGAL ORGANIZATIONS:
Florida Bar Association
Michigan Bar Association
American Bar Association
The Academy of Florida Trial Lawyers
Collier County Women's Bar Association, Founding President 1993-1995
Collier County Trial Lawyer's Section, member and Treasurer 1997-1998
Quality of Life/Stress Management - Florida Bar Association 1995-1997
Inns of Court, Collier County, Florida 1997-1999
OTHER ORGANIZATIONS:
Women's Political Caucus Collier County, Board Member 1995-1 7 ,AGENpA ITEM ,
President 1998 . ~o. --/-0- (;
MAR 2:3 1999
k
~ pg.-'-I--
~~-~"".""""
Executive Board, Fort Myers/Naples Town Hall Series 1997-1999
Gulf Coast High School Advisory Committee 1997-1998
Citizen's Advisory Committee for N. Naples Fire Control and Rescue District 1997
Emergency Medical Services Advisory Committee, Collier County
Board Member 1995-1997
Economic Development Corporation-Economic Foundation Committee 1997-1998
Collier County Guardian ad Litem Advisory Committee, 1995.1996
Women and Children's Steering Committee, Naples Community Hospital 1996
The Florida Head Injury Association 1995-1998
The Naples Press Club 1998
N~~=/1J-2C-
MAR 2 3 1999
pg,D--
215 Silverado Dr.
Naples, FL 34119
January 7, 1999
Ms. Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of Collier Commissioners
3301 Tamiami Trail E.
Naples, FL 34112-4977
'~E. ,...-:.\ i'.~'~,
'"' . '_'!::\ J ','-!
""" r"
,'~ j"i ': -- ~~Jr~
Dear Ms, Filson:
3oa~'(! ,',,' ';0iJn~., ,.;/;':'E1;~.
'. ': .:,. . ~
This letter is to state that I wish to be considered for another
term on the County Government Productivity Committee.
I am attaching a copy of my resume and a short biographical sketch.
I wish to thank the commissioners for again being able to serve the
county on this most important committee,
Sincerely yours,
~~//}cl~?~
Edward T. Ferguson, Ph.D.
N~~~~
! MAR 2 3 1999 J
~~j3 I
RESU11E
EDWARD T, FERGUSON
SUM11ARY
Areas of Professional Specialty:
Business Administration, Professional
Development, Human Resource
Management, Educatio~ Curriculum Design
and Development
Background and Expenise in:
Administration, Teaching, Research,
Evaluation, Project Management
Highest Degree:
PhD
Foreign Language:
Spanish
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENC=~
Director of Personnel. Management and Career Development Counselor: Collier
County Sheriff's Office. Naples FL 1989-present
Adjunct Professor, Manage::nent Development Program: Barry University, Naples
Center, Naples FL 198i-present
Adjunct Professor, Business Management and Adolescent Psychology: Edison
Community College, Collier ~nter, Naples FL 1988-1990
Contract Consultant: University ofMarvland. International Business and Management
. .. -
Institute, Tokyo Japan 1985-1986
Visiting Pr~fessor, Ime.rr:ational ~anagement Program: Institute for Infern~~~......U:~~
StudIes and Trammg, Boeki Kenshu Center Japan 1986 I.J_~
, MAR 2 3 1999
~
L~~~~~ V
FERG US ON -- p, 2
Senior Lecturer, Departments of Management, Education, and Graduate Counseling
and Guidance Program: University of Maryland, European and Asian Divisions
Visiting Professor, Department of Business and Economics: University of North
Carolina at Greensboro
Senior Lecturer, Department of Business: Columbus International College, Sevilla
Spain
Research Fellow, Fulbright Fellowship, Council for International Exchange of
Sr.hnl::l.r~: Ministries of Culture and Labor, Germany
Senior Research Specialist and Director of Professional Development and Industrial
Training: Center on Education and Training for Employment, OJlumbus OH
Professor, College of Education Graduate School Faculty: The Ohio State University,
Columbus OH
Sabbatical, Research and Professionai Writing: Spain
Teacher Educator, College of Erlucation, Instructor, College of Business: Michigan
State University, East Lansing Ml
Assistant Professor, Department of Education and College of Business: Virginia
Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg VA
EDUCATION
BS Business Administration, State University of New Yor~ Albany
Major: Business Administration
Minor: Social Science
MS Business Administration, State University of New York, Albany
Major: Marketing
N~G_:_LO I~M
PhD Education, rvfichigan State University
Major: Business and Marketing Education
~or: Business Administration
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg ,j..s-
-FERGUSON .- p,3
BIOGRAPHICAL LISTINGS
Leaders in Education, Fourth ed" Jacques Cattell Press, Tempe AZ
Men of Achievement
Melrose Press Ltd., Cambridge England
Dictionarv ofInternationa] Bio~raphy. International Biographical Centre, Cambridge
England
\\Tho's Who in the South and Southwest. 22nd ed., Marquis, MacMillan Directory
Division, Wilmette IL 1995
ME~1BERSHIPS
Pi Delta Kappa
Delta Pi Epsilon
Society for Human Resources Management
Personnel Testing CDuncil of SOuth Flerida
Personnel Association or Collier County
PUBLICATIONS
A listing of over fifty books, professional articles, and research papers is available
upon request.
~GE!jo.e-.G!EM
N"..&..
MAR 2 3 1999
pg.lh
-
3IGGRAPHICAL SKETCH
\.:..:lwa rd i
F2rgu3on l5 Senior Training Coordina~or and Crisis
Intervention Team ~emcer at t~e Collier County (F~orica;
<::'--_:"::";:'-
...,1 lei ..:. I J .:::.
0" l'':5.
j~e
_ _ i ...J,-.
: l'-'............i.:=.
a
;;:i . ~ .
and i"1._
a-=~ree
In business
.. ,
a em l. ill S t T a [. .:.. c. il
7' ,-: in
~ca~3 UniV9r3i~y OT New YorK
at .~i.ban~.'
aTiC a :=h.O
.....;1 ::'U'=::IJc3S 31i.':: SCLi.::ar..:.orl TTcm Miclligan Stat.?
''; ;; 1 '-.i -= r 3':" :. ....
~-I ,-=1 :;L30rl '.".as 5 u;:.::.....Ier2.:...:..,~. ~r-..:.,ess0r r..-?2C.il.j";g T-:>1'" ';'v'2, 2lJ
',.Iea,:=:
:n
:':le
72..::.....~L.125 '':'f
::. '-I -= U i1 i 'v' a r sit 'j
':>, ,'1ary ':'21:-::.
0:-; ~ c;
. - -. - -
~'--=~....-=
.,....~~ l"i~;- S.i -: ';"
.'--'--"'"
..;., '_. I _ '",::"c .1
.~ r...3 L. a
'J ill 'v'er.2:' t. ....- .
ai1G 'j:,. r-;i 1'1i3
?0.;. ',r-:. ~c:in:..:
:::1C
-----
_l-"='_=
..,. II _ .-;:::'"
..'\ia3
.:';1-.
3,':' ;~G":' _
- - - - - - .-
_='::'L.:==I
, -,
.::. - >~
....-=-= j- .=.
.=':
-'
:. c.
; c' i 7l':"
.j.....
:. .-: Co
'- - - ~ .-
"':-1 Ie' I _ .
,,'
- ;-1
~':'6'::
1-1-=
AicS
'i)Ci ria ,;eiT;-::::"
---- ----
___)1.::::.1..-_............:.;::.-
-- - ~ - . - --.".-
-:.;..... -:;:'_ _ =. ~ _ _ _ : J -~
"::..;- :;ar;.:.=~~.- =,'~
ane
- ---------
Il;.:;:'I.-::.....'::;'I:J-:::';::..-
.:Je\i-2 ~ '':"~'I-r;C il ~ _
-~- ;-:05 ~ee:-; :'~le .tec.:';";;'.i.-=T"I~ .,)7 a :'~...C"I-:'::Jrl:' ;7~~~Cws;-.i~"
'--
":2- j- i1i":; j;"'1"
~ ji':: :"'.iA S
,,/ - ~ ~ '-..;., ,'~
;:.:- : -;" ~3.'SC';-
. '"",'J
:. '-12
Jc~'-?jj..::~-= ,'1~ lll'=::"l-'f'
------- ---"
-.ll~=: ::c::::___~.........H:::~
; ";- ace 2 r:c
~:-:'':~3:''l'J .::\....
':iie:i
I.:lS~'::":"""::'=
1 .....;j
_ :i:' = . - -; a ~ _ ......' I I::: _ ..:; -:. ..... .=..:.. .? 3 a;-. '..:
,:-..=~:-i~ I." _.1 1-.-:.....~-;G;7:.:.../3~ .~2..:a:.
CT
7
- ,
::U '=::'11
~ -...::.,,-:='-
_ : I
";,-,C'
:3
'.I\II-;C
__~D_._ ~ ;-IE"
'.;~_i....L~ ."}
a :1(:
-..- - ---
_ '-'-: _. . :""J -:::'..::. "-
------
--' - -
-~--"-'.~
_--= '_ ':'.3 ;: ...
.:i..'; .~ ~ ~ ~,": ~ ::. = :-;:...
.::'1:'_
-,7'"""'=' ",- .
- .- - '-" ,.-,
, . - - ...-
._ - - '-J . . _ _
.:::....:
ii~;7:c- 'r ..:;..,.2
--------
:::..:;.C-=.l ___,I
- . ". --
------.....
..:: ,1\....;
:='r :.~ =s.:: _ ':' -;-~6..;..
; ..:. w j- :-..5 ...
,57iC
:112':;':=:" ~e
=:l: ',- - - ,- __
-. -----........
:,", ,l ~ 3
- .
- '-' - - ..
------
..-... -.
..--..- --'
_ -H..1 ;o.=; :;
.~ ~sc;~ ;'=-3:::
~S2C'C.:.=t__G,n
-......- ,.--
L~2~ .~2S0LT:S ~~3~aqam2~~.
1_______
- -' -.,.. ,-
. -' -.....'.,.--
- - - -
-.:o;:::'~=........____.i~ ____'L.,.:;'___
-,
. . - ,.,-
....-. ----
~.l-=: :i::.sr7i2L.'::"C'i1.5..;.. .~'~r3C'7::ie_
. 1ft .= ~.:: '; -2: iil e :-. :.
,,---- -- --
-'-=''''':'''_'-- ...".:: '-_ __'1..
:. ;-. =
-.= .....:.:,
- - '
....- -- -"
'_ ... '.....I: . 1'- _
~fi:-= ';~
....-...::..
-_. _._-
I .:;...... .;..:.. .:'
-"- ------
_' -= '. -= .-. '.- ,;-. III 0::' I : L- ..
--.-_. ---
..:;,-.~ _; ,we..::.__
_.:;.~r .:.. ''::2:
.- '- -- - - - .-
'_. IQj.....' l-C I
-'
:-1":"lL..
.3 Ti.":
-_. ----
~;I'__'-o~II:'-
~~~2SS ~a~a0affi~~~
~~__~a~- C~~~~-~. ~~6~ ~c.
1-,...- ;--?j;U.s"'::i~.5 3_~0 =il ""'1~)LTiC~ ~1='Te:::30; ':'1 ':'LiS,j,,:l-&SZ an.:: i~UDi.':'C
a..em i 7i ~ 2: 'C r .3 L ~ ,.:] ~:
'" '-
':::c:-"'
:Jjj ~ .....2 r.=::.. ~ .~-
anG a
~r,~re53:':
.ili
~;.e
~~"~_2:0~ ~T ~~~~_~a..:.. ~~S~_C2 a~
_c~~ca Gu~7' ,-cas~ ~n~veTSl~/
AGEN[}A ~
No..-tE2 .
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.
J?
,f
~r":''''-'''-~V:=f''
~~~"J'C~.', -1 :_.~..
... ......
\ "
,,:~ - '
January 5, ] 999
3(~ ,-,':'
Ms, Sue Filson
Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
RE: County Government Productivity Committee
Dear Ms. Filson:
In response to your December] 8, ] 998 letter, I am interested in being reappointed
to another term on the Productivity Committee, Accordingly, attached is an updated
resume.
Thank you.
k_ ~S
/~/~U ~~
"------t ~ ' / --.....
w iU1am E. Eb,ben '
12254 Collier's Reserve Drive
Naples, FL 34110
941-513-0936
N~~,7-e,.~~
MAP 2 3 1999
" F'g. ,1t-
--..-,,-.. ._- -..
William E. Ebben
12254 Collier's Reserve Drive
Naples, FL 34110
Phone: 941-513-0936
Fax: 941-513-7935
l\lember, Collier County Goyernment
Productivity Committee
1/98 - Present
Corporate Executive Vice President
AT&T
Basking Ridge, New Jersey
11/82 - 12/96
Three large team operating leadership positions for world-wide
field seIYice of Business communicatinu de'vices, for all Real
'- '
Estate matters, and for all Procurement matters,
Executive Vice President - Operations
Pacific l\'orthwest Bell Telephone Company
Seattle. \Yashington
9/78 -11/82
Chief Operating Officer of the this then-AT&T subsidiary, re-
sponsible for all service and financial results of this company,
Vice President and General Manager
IVlichigan Bell Telephone Company
Detroit, lVlichigan
3/77 - 10/82
Chief Operating Officer for the two million customers in the
Detroit area, Assumed this position after a series of manag-
erial assignments as:
Vice President - Engineering and Network Services
Vice President - Operations Staff and Engineering
Chief Engineer
5/76-3/77
3/73-4/76
12/70 - 3/73
AGENDA I~
Nc "--/!2--~
MAR 2 3 1999
l___!g. /1
I
Page 2
Various Supervisory/Managerial Positions
l\-lichigan Bell Telephone Company
Detroit, l\lichigan
9/58 -3/73
Held various supervisory and managerial positions in the
engineering, accoW1ting, and plant departments.
Education:
University of Detroit, Detroit, MI: BSME, 1958; 1v1BA, 1966.
Northwestern University, Evanston, IL: Mgmt. Development Program, 1960.
Carleton College, North field, MN: Mgmt. Development Advanced Program, 1969.
l\lilitary:
Captain, U, S. Anny Infantry. Active service 1959-60; Reserve duty 1960-66.
Personal:
Married 40 years to Diane; Father ofLynn (Alexy), William, Brad, and Greg and
Grandfather of three (Claire, Caroline and William),
References available upon request.
N~~E1D ~M _
MAR 2 3 1999
pg.~O
--
CHARLES EDWARD GETLER
6855 San Marino Drive No, 209
Naples, FL 34108
~ ~ - ',-1 V...., .
n~~.Jtt.' t:.,~.
January 3. 1 999
" .,... ;"'f"
!.~,N :' -
Ms Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
~,.,,,..,:
~)] '.3
..."",.....
I' ,.,(2 :",
, .... ~:'~, i
'I':::
Dear Ms Filson:
This is in reference to your letter of December 18 offering me the opportunity to reapply
for another term on the County Government Committee starting February 4, 1999.
I \-vould like to be considered for another term and have attached an updated resume
which includes some of the projects in which I participated as a member of the Committee,
I hope that the Board of Commissioners will consider my request favorably and I look
fOf\.vard to your response,
Thank you for your consideration,
..,
,. / Si~erelXv ///1 .-/JJ
/-' L^lt~~/l- t.l/~
Charles E. Getler
AG~ ~M 1
No.
-'-
MAR 2 3 1999 I
Pg, c:J/
_.I
Resume
Charles E. Getler
6855 San !\'!larino Dr.
Naples, FL 34108
Telephone: (941) 598-1860
Birth Date June 29, 1926
Present Occupation: Retired
Permanent Resident of Naples since 1993
EDUCATION
1948 A B. Princeton University
1951 tvIBA Cniversity of Michigan
WORK EXPERIENCE
1951-1991 Ford Motor Company
Analytical, Supervisory and Managerial Positions in the follO\ving areas:
Purchasing
Personnel
Financial Analysis
Organization
Advance Product Planning
Product Engineering (Administration)
Developed and implemented cost reduction! efficiency improvement
programs
POST -RETIREME;\JT EXPERIENCE
August, 1996-Present
Board Member, San Marino Condominium Association
President, Board of Directors, San Marino
Condominium Association
Member, Collier County Productivity Committee
Principal Projects in which I participated directly
include:
-Procurement Study: 20 recommendations adopted by
the Commission.
-Review of County Airport authority's business plan
-Human Resources Data Systems Project
-Economic Development Review (prese
underway)
AGENfj~ r~M
No. Lli----._...._
February, 1995 - February, 1997
February, 1995 - February, 1996
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.,<;2-
_:a.-'. T
. (~ r:.:':/'t',.:'vt)"
j; ',:'\"-:?~~TC?~1,~ X." .',:"':", "~:y_:;}~'~~~t:'"-:>^:'::'-',,,t .,' ,.
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO TI!EC()NTRAC.tO~t~~EN~IH~:{BQABl?_
"C" " '0: , '~r; ~,
'-C' ".<'.:"':','"'
;v ___.;..' " '~
OBJECTIVE: To appoint two (2) consumer members to the Contractors Licensing Board.
CONSIDERA TIONS: This 9 member board determines the qualifications of applicants for the
various categories of the Contractors' Certificates of Competency. They also hold hearings to
determine if the holder of a certificate of competency of any contractor, master or journeyman
should be disciplined. A minimum 3 members shall be in the category of "Consumer", The
consumer representatives may be any resident of the local jurisdiction that is not, and has never
been, a member or practitioner of a profession regulated by the board or a member of any closely
related profession. Members are required to file a Form 1 Statement of Financial Interests each
year with the Supervisor of Elections. Terms are 3 years.
,~
On October 6, 1998, the Board discussed the statutory requirement relating to the Contractors
Licensing Board Ordinance. At that time the Board directed staff to make a request of current
sitting board members for those who wish to volunteer to end their terms at the time of
appointment of the mandated positions. Letters were sent to the members on October 26, 1998
advising of the amended FL Statute. One of the three required Consumer positions was appointed
on February 9, 1999 to fill a seat that was declared vacant. The Board indicated that if
individuals did not volunteer to step dOVvTI that a recommendation based on attendance be made
to eliminate the positions at the time of appointment to consumer positions, as mandated by the
State Statute. One member (Mr. William T. Lewis) voluntarily resigned his position on
November 12, 1998, leaving a need for one additional vacancy. Staff has indicated that we do
not currently have an absenteeism problem. An alternative would be to appoint the consumer
member to the term that is due to expire on June 30, 1999 that is currently filled by Mr. Humbert
Gressani. Mr. Gressani has served 2 full terms and in order to be eligible for another term, the
Board would be required to waive Section 7(B)(1) of Ordinance No. 86-41.
A list of the current membership is included in the backup.
A press release was issued and resumes were received from the following 2 interested citizens:
APPLICANT
CATEGORY
DlST
ELECTOR ADV. COMM.
Robert D. Laird
Consumer
yes
EMSAC
Garrett C. Bock
Consumer
2
yes
none
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Quasi-Judicial. no recommendations permitted.
One member to serve as a Consumer Member with the term expiring on June 30, 2001, and
...--'
One member to serve as a Consumer Member with the term expiring on June 30, 1999, plus an
additional 3 year term expiring on June 30,2002.
N~~E'b 11M
MAR 2 3 1999
I
Pg.____
_~_-'""'--""_""'~_""'^"~-..--.,--..,.~ ....,LIIII... ...._~ __~.,,~.
FISCAL IMPACT: NONE
GRO\VTH MANAGEMENT IMP ACT: NONE
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment and appoint two consumer members to the Contractors
Licensing Board and direct the County Attorney to prepare a resolution confirming the
appointments.
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Date: March 23, 1999
AGEN2 I~M
No.. ()
MAR 2 3 1999
,;t
Pg.
Contractors Licensing Board
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Les Dickson 643-1616 06/11/96 06/30/99 3 Years
202 Monterey Drive
Naples, FL 34119
District: 3
Category: Roofing Contractor
Carol Pahl 02/09/99 06/30/00 1 Year
2501 Sailors Way 597 -3759
Naples, FL 34109
District: 3
Category: Consumer Representative
Humbert Gressani 01/04/94 06/30/96 3 Years
3225 Duchess Drive 775-5881 6/11/96 06/30/99 3 Years
Naples, FL 34112
District: 1
Category: General Contractor
Richard E. Joslin, Jr. 455-5000 06/11/96 06/30/97 1 Year
595 13th Street, N. W. 7/22/97 06/30/00 4 Years
Naples, FL 34117
District: 5
Category: Licensed Commercial Pool/Spa Contr
Raben P. Meister 04/18/95 06/30/97 2 Years
22 4th A venue South 262-8565 7/22/97 06/30/00 4 Years
Naples. FL 34102
District: 4
Category: General Contractor
Daniel Gonzalez 434-8696 11107/95 06/30/98 3 Years
809 Walkerbilt Rd., Ste 3 6/16/98 06/30/0 I 3 Years
Naples, FL 34110
District: 4
Category: Residential Contractor
Arthur F. Schoenfuss 597-7544 06/13/95 06/30/98 3 Years
6506 Ilex Circle 596-3388 6/16/98 06/30/01 3 Years
Naples, FL 34109
District: 4
Category: Engineer
N~GE~{/Y-J
Wednesday, February 10, 1999
Page I of2
MAR 2 3 1999
pr 3
'=J'____,
Contractors Licensing Board
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp, Date
2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
Gary F. Hayes 643-2431
1475 Curlew Avenue
Naples, FL 34102
District: 2
Category: Specialty ContractorlPlurnbing.
\' , 'If'-,r:l'c-c/
b~ \ -/ - ~
William T. Lewis \/{; ( , ?/ '1 ~ 732-8700
3416 Caloosa Street J)' I 732-8700
Naples, FL 34112
District: 4
Category: General Contractor
09/26/95
6/11/96
06/30/96
06/30/99
-1 Year
3 Years
06/16/98
06/30/01
3 Years
This 9 member board was created by Ord. No, 78-2, 85-42, 90-105, 92-61 to determine the
qualifications of applicants for the various categories of the Contractors' Certificates of
Competency, They also hold hearings to determine if a certificate of competency of any
contractor, master or journeyman should be revoked, A minimum of 2 members shall reside
within the corporate city limits of Naples or shall be recommended to the BCC by the Naples City
Council. Members are required to file a Form 1 Statement of Financial Interest each year with
the Supervisor of Elections. Terms are 3 years, This is a Quasi Judicial Board, Amended by
Ordinance No, 97-68
FL STAT: 489
Staff: Ed Perico, Building Review & Permitting Director:: 403-2400
. -;
,., .."" J-' ~
l' .;
c..
- >'11 C'
~ I'
. : r'" of' y'
t.C (1 ~....
-t-,r: 1-' \)..-:,...:,
"",' '*. ~ _" .. \ I ~ f ..... /"
y-r ~ ( .- ~... I 0 ~ -/ -/ ''5
Wednesday, February 10, /999
Page 2 of 2
No.
fl
70
MAR 2 3 1999
- tf
r' 9 " _.____--~
"""'....--.....-_~. ..-..:.r.....:T..:"....,,...oF .~..'
RFCEIVEG
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES b'rVISION.., .)
BUILDING REVIEW AND PERMITTING DEP~t~N,T,._
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
February 24,1999
FROM:
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
Ed Perico, Director ~
Building Review & Permitting Department
TO:
RE:
Contractors Licensing Board
I have re\iev"ed the applicants for the Contractors Licensing Board vacancies and they
both meet the criteria for the Consumer Member.
I f I can be of further assistance please do not hesitate to contact me at 403-2442.
N~~E/b IJ;M
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ..,s--
'r....~-=-...,....~.,...:."_...~..... ,,_'
MEMORANDUM
'-,'- .....,
1;-.;"-_;
DATE:
February 22, 1999
Vinell Hills, Elections Office /'/
Sue Filson, Administrative AssistanJ / /
Board of County Commissioners
TO:
FROM:
RE:
V oter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also, please list the commission district in which each applicant resides.
CONTRACTORS LICEI\'SING BOARD
COMMISSION DISTRICT
Robert D. Laird
1765 Courtyard Way
Naples. FL 34112
r
I
Garrett C. Bock
2434 Indian Pipe Way
Naples. FL 34105
~
~1V;
Thank you for your help.
,-'~
AGENJA If!
No. ()
r ..
MAR 2 3 1999 \
- ,ft,.
r-g, ____ ___
-".........,....-.-...'.""'":;"
MEMORANDUM
DATE: February 22,1999
TO: Ed Perico, Building Review & Permitting Director
FROM: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
RE: Contractors Licensing Board
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for
consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review as follows:
Robert D. Laird
1765 Courtyard Way
Naples, FL 34112
Garrett C. Bock
2434 Indian Pipe Way
Naples, FL 34105
Please let me know, in \\'Titing within the 41 day time-frame, if the applicants are qualified to
serve as members on the board, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any
questions, please call me at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Attachments
AGEN~ I;Y
No. 0
p
I MAR ~ 3 1999
~~:r:==-~.- .....
RECEfV~r-.
",',. .
ROBERT D. LAIRD
r-r--
r- c:H :;
,..j~; ~i
1765 COURTYARD WAY
;j>~,\,~ 'J:" :.'...../:"~ ,
NAPLES, FLORIDA'34112. 'T
941/793-0933
February 18, 1999
Mrs. Sue Filson. Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112-4977
RE: Collier County Contractors Licensing Board
Dear Mrs. Filson:
As we discussed in your office on Tuesday, I am interested in being appointed to
the Contractors Licensing Board as the "Consumer" member.
At the present time. I am serving as the "Consumer" member of the State of Florida
Construction Industry Licensing Board (CILB) and I feel the two memberships would
compliment each other.
I am enclosing a brief resume and I would also like to point out that I have owned
property in Collier County for the past twenty years and have been a full time resident for
fifteen years.
Sincerely,
(;~ 0rb. G~~L
Robert D. Laird
RDL/dk
Ene.
AGENDA-..I~
No._-,l'V
MAR ? 3 1999
8*
f"'9. ____ _
ROBERT D. LAIRD
1765 Courtyard Way, # 205-C
Naples, Florida 34112
941/793-0933
OCCUPA TION/EMPLOYMENT
· I am retired from the Underwriters Adjusting Co.lContinental Insurance
Company as Regional Director of Personnel and Training. Our home offices
was located at 1111 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio, 43215.
· I am self employed as a part time Insurance Consultant, handling
malpractice claims.
· I have held Florida Real Estate License # SL-0443153 for the past sixteen
years.
· I am also self employed as a part time massage therapist and instructor,
holding Florida License No. MA 0016291.
EOUCA TlON
. Graduated from Jackson High School, Jackson, Ohio.
. Graduated from Ohio University, Athens, Ohio. Received a BS degree.
. Attended Ohio State University Graduate School, Columbus, Ohio; received
MBA degree.
MILITARY SERVICE
. Lt. Commander, United States Naval Reserve, three years active duty.
Served as CO of Naval Training Center.
BUSINESSICIVIC ORGANIZATIONS
.
Member and Chairman (EMSAC) Emergency Medical Service Advisory
Council
Member and Board of Directors, Naples Sunset Rotary Club
President of Courtyard Condominium Association
Vice President, Kings Lake Homeowners Association
Member of Board Tiger Bay Association
Member Collier County Sheriff's Citizens Commission
Member Collier County 100 Club
Member Collier County Forum Club
Member Naples Area Board of Realtors
Past member Collier County Productivity Committee
N~~~/I~
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
MAR 2 3 1999
?9. l'
.
~
~ -
.
References and past business and government organizations available upon request.
...=-... '.-,. "..
:,...; .- ,
::-; -;': ,/ --= '-'~
.~. " :--'~
Garrett C. Bock
2434 Jndian Pipe Way
Naples, Florida 34105
Telephone: (941) 430-1785
Fax: (941) 430-1783
February 9, 1999
Ms. Sue Filson
Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
3301 Tamiami Trail East
Naples, Florida 34112
Re: Contractors Licensing Board
Dear Ms. Filson:
I would like to apply for a position on the Contractors Licensing Board based on my
experience as reflected in the enclosed resume.
Please call me if you have any questions.
Your~y, ~
V7~J*,(/
Garrett C. Bock
I Enclosure
r
N~~E/t>~M .
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg, /P
~'._.'__-r=",,,._r
J
I
I
i
GARRETT C. BOCK
2434 INDIAN PIPE WAY
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34105
EDUCA TION
University of Buffalo. B.S degree. 1961, Business Administration,
U.S. Army Command and General Staff College, 1970,
Artillery Officer Career Course, 1969.
Air Defense Electronic Warfare Course, 1968.
USARADCOM CBR Officer Course, 1967
Nike Hercules Officer Electronic Warfare c'ourse, 1964,
U,S, Army Airborne Course, 1964,
Nike Universal Officer Course, 1963,
U,S. Army Officer Candidate School, 1963,
EXPERIENCE
United States Army 1961-1971 with rank of Major; Operations Officer
in a Nike Hercules air defense missile battalion,
President, Bock Enterprises, Inc 1972-1998, a Buffalo, New York
builder, land developer, and real estate corporation, Developed 9
single family subdivisions and two condominium projects, Built and
sold over 600 custom single-family homes and 89 condominium units
MEMBERSHIP
National Association of Home Builders (Director 1982).
National Association of Realtors.
New York State Builders Association (Director 1978-1981)
New York State Realtors Association
Niagara Frontier Builders Association (President 1979),
Greater Buffalo Association of Realtors
LICENSES
Real Estate Broker, 1972.Present.
Notary Public, 1973-Present.
AWARDS
American Wood Coune!1 Des!gn Fer Better Living Award, 1977,
PERSONAL
Born in Poughkeepsie, New York May 29. 1940, Married in 1968 to
Norma L. Bock, a vocational rehabilitation counselor for New York
State; no children. Interests: classical music, art. travel. scuba diving,
computers. Retired in 1998 and moved to Naples, Florida as a full-
time resident living in the Grey Oaks Country Club.
N~~_EN~r}H
MAR ? 3 1999
P9,_ //_
.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST TRANSFER OF $2,982,100 FROM GENERAL FUND RESERVES TO THE
RESERVES OF THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE.
OBJECTIVE: To transfer the amount of $2,982,100 from General Fund Reserves to the
reserves of the Sheriff's Office,
CONSIDERATIONS: In the FY 1999 budget, the Board of County Commissioners
appropriated 5% of the Sheriff's operating budget as reserves for contingency for
Constitutional Officers in the General Fund. During the course of 1999, the Sheriff's Office
may have needs that exceed the current appropriation, Reserve funds are required to meet
these needs. Needs may include emergency equipment, salary adjustments as required per
pay surveys or other emergency items deemed necessary by the Sheriff, Any funds not
required during the fiscal year will be returned to the Board of County Commissioners as
excess fees,
FISCAL IMPACT: None, This is a transfer from reserves to reserves, Monies are available
from:
..-
TRANSFER FROM:
Fund: 001
Cost Center: 919010
Reserves: 991000
Project: 0
TRANSFER TO:
Fund: 040
Cost Center: 611010
Reserves: 991000
Project: 0
GROWTH IMPACT: None.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners transfer $2,982,100 from
General Fund reserves to the reserves of the Sheriff.
REQUESTED BY:
/"
D
APPROVED BY:
DATE:
March 5, 1999
5.1a-exsum\exresrvl\dv
N~~A)t)
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. J
-
,"-
,-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PETITION NO. PUD-82-16(1) KAREN BISHOP OF PMS, INC. OF NAPLES, REPRESENTING
HENRY KREHLING, TO REZONE LANDS NOW ZONED PUD TO A NEW PUD TO COMPLY
WITH THE SUNSETTING PROVISIONS OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, AND TO ADD
COMMERCIAL AND LIGHT INDUSTRIAL USES TO THE LIST OF AUTHORIZED USES AND TO
UPDATE THE PUD DOCUMENT AND MASTER PLAN TO CURRENT LAND DEVELOPMENT
CODE REQUIREMENTS, FOR PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED SOUTHEAST OF THE
INTERSECTION OF U.S. 41 AND OLD U.S. 41, Y2 MILE EAST OF U.S. 41 AT THE EASTERN
TERMINUS OF WIGGINS PASS ROAD, IN SECTION 15, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26
EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
OBJECTIVE:
This petition purports to rezone the site from PUD to PUD, in effect bringing the presently approved
document up to current Land Development Code (LDC) requirements and reducing the number of
development tracts from three (3) to two (2). The size of the subject property is not planned to change.
The Collier County Land Development Code, in Section 2.7.3.4. requires that the project developer
submit an annual report on the progress of development, commencing on the fifth anniversary of the PUD
approval by the Board of County Commissioners. For PUDs which were approved prior to the adoption
date ofthe LDC, the Board directed that the five year approval period commence on October 30, 1991, the
date of adoption of the LDC. The purpose of this report will be to evaluate whether or not the project has
commenced in earnest in accordance with the criteria set forth in Section 2.7.3.4. of the LDC.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The original Krehling PUD was adopted in 1982 prior to the adoption date of the LDC. At original
submittal of the required PUD monitoring report, the subject PUD was given a one (1) year extension to
either comply substantially with the provisions of the sun setting requirements in the LDC or to submit an
amended PUD. Submittal of this PUD amendment gives staff the opportunity to review the proposed
PUD for its consistency with the Growth Management Plan and Land Development Code. Subsequent
approval of this petition will establish the project's consistency with the existing Growth Management
Plan and bring the presently approved PUD up to the current requirements of the Land Development
Code. The site is located on the south side of Wiggins Pass Road at its eastern terminus. Access to the
site is provided by two (2) driveways located off of Wiggins Pass Road. Wiggins Pass Road from U.S. 41
also provides access to the existing concrete plant to the west of the subject site, as well as residential
development on properties zoned for Mobile Home (MH) and Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle
Campground (TTRVC), on the north and south sides of Wiggins Pass Road, east of U.S. 41. The subject
site and the abutting industrial site are presently under common ownership. The western portion of the site
is currently used for outdoor storage of finished concrete products in association with the adjacent
concrete plant on industrial zoned property to the west. The PUD Master Plan indicates a total of two (2)
land use tracts. Similar to the previously approved PUD, the +/.11.96 acre Tract A is planned for future
commercial and light industrial type of development. The +/- 3.3 acre Tract B is shown on the PUD
Master Plan as a Cypress Preserve Area and stormwater retention area. The land uses permitted by this
PUD can generally be described as light industrial uses permitted in the Industrial zoning district like light
manufacturing and assembling, and industrial warehousing, wholesale, storage or distri
as part of the current business operations ofKrehling Industries, Inc., some of the indus ial ~~l Itles I a (8)/
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. I
as part of the current business operations of Krehling Industries, Inc., some of the industrial facilities
proposed for the subject site will also be used to develop concrete specialty products, stockpile and store
finished concrete products. The PUD also allows commercial uses which will generally consist of
warehousing, office (retail or professional), building supplies and enclosed storage. The proposed uses are
similar in type and intensity to the uses approved in the original PUD. In general, this +/- 15 acre
development proposal essentially retains the same type of land uses originally approved, to be developed
in two (2) rather then three (3) development tracts.
Traffic Circulation Element -
The ITE Trip Generation Manual indicates that the proposed amendment will generate approximately 250
to 300 additional trips more than the amount of trips that could be generated by the currently approved
PUD, The additional trips probably result from a clarification of uses through the addition of Standard
Industrial Code (SIC) references to the PUD document, as well as changes in the ITE Trip Generation
Manual since the PUD was originally adopted. Nevertheless, the site generated traffic will not exceed this
significant test standard (5 percent of the LOS "C" design volume) on U.S. 41 or on any County road.
The total site generated trips is estimated to be 1,248 weekday trips at build out in 2002.
The Traffic Circulation Elements lists U.S. 41 as a 4-lane arterial road. The current traffic count for the
segment from the Lee County~ine to Wiggins Pass Road is 24,364 AADT and is operating at LOS "A". It
should be noted that this segment is not projected to be deficient at the buildout of this project in 2002.
However, the segment of U.S. 41 from Wiggins Pass Road to Immokalee Road is currently deficient.
Therefore, this road segment is required to be improved to 6-lanes for concurrency purposes. The 5-year
work program indicates that this segment is scheduled to be improved by the year 2000.
FISCAL IMPACT:
At buildout, a commercial project will generate the following amount of impact fees:
Current PUD Zoning District
Proposed PUD Zoning District
15.26 acres-1.64 preserve = 13.62 15.26 acres - 3.33 acres preserve = 11.93
developable acres assuming 10,000 sf developable acres assuming 10,000 sf
floor area per acre = 132,600 sf floor area per acre = 119,300 sf
F.A.ll,OOO x $5,000 (road) = $663,000.00 F,A.ll,OOO x $5,000 (road) = $596,500.00
F.A. x 0.30 (fire) = $39,780,00 F.A. x 0.30 (fire) = $35,790.00
F.A. x 0.005 (radon gas) = $663.00 F.A. x 0.005 (radon gas) = $596.50
F.A. x 0.005 (bldg code) = $663.00 F.A. x 0.005 (bldg code) = $596.50
F.A./l,OOO x $250.00 (EMS) = F.A./l,OOO x $250.00 (EMS) = $29,825,00
$33,150.00
Total 132,600 sq ft comm = $737,256.00 Total 162,500 sq ft comm = $663,308.00
"G~( ~L
No,
MAR 2 3 1999
~
Pi,
Development ofthe site for a commercial use, should the site be rezoned to commercial and developed
with 119,300 square feet of commercial floor area, will generate approximately $73,948.00 less in impact
fees than if the site was developed for commercial uses as presently zoned. This is due largely to the
increase of 1.69 acres in preserve area, taking that land additional area out of eligibility for development
and converting it to preservation.
Because impact fees vary by housing type and type of commercial development, and because this
appraisal does not provide this level of specificity as to the actual type of use, the total impact fees quoted
are at best raw estimates. Additionally, it should be recognized that there is no guarantee that the project
and buildout will have maximized their authorized level of development. In addition to the impact fees
described there are building permit review fees and utility fees associated with connecting to the. County's
sewer and water system. Building permit fees have traditionally offset the cost of administering the
Community Development review costs, whereas utility fees are based on their proportionate share of
impact to the County system. Impact fees are currently under review to determine if adjustments are
required to more accurately reflect the impact of a particular development on County provided services,
Also, additional revenue is generated by application of the ad valorem tax rate. The revenue that will be
generated by the ad valorem tax depends on the value of the improvements. Presently, staff has not
developed a method to arrive at a reasonable estimate of tax revenues based on the ad valorem tax rate.
A fiscal impact analysis is incomplete without an estimate of costs that will be generated by a particular
land use development project. Presently, staffhas not developed a model by which to estimate the costs of
a particular land use development project. Such a model, in staffs opinion, would be misleading because
there is no certain way, particularly with respect to housing projects, to determine their value and
likelihood that not all ofthe authorized development will occur.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
The subject site is designated Urban Residential on the Future Land Use Map ofthe Growth Management
Plan. The proposed uses of land (industrial/commercial) are not consistent with the locational criteria for
these uses provided for in the Future Land Use Element (FLUE). However, because an exemption was
granted for this PUD through the Zoning Reevaluation Program (ZRO) the existing PUD zoning can be
considered consistent with the FLUE via policy, specifically Policy 5.10 of the FLUE. Policy 5.10
provides that exemptions based on vested rights or compatibility determinations that are granted as
provided for in the Collier County Zoning Re-evaluation ordinance shall be considered consistent with the
Future Land Use Element. In this regard, the subject petition is consistent with the Future Land Use
Element of the Growth Management Plan. However, the exemption granted for the subject PUD although
it precluded Collier County from rezoning the property via the authorization provided by the Zoning
Reevaluation Ordinance and FLUE Policy 3.1(k), does not protect the property from a zoning change
initiated by Collier County as may be authorized by other ordinance or statutory provisions, Section
2,1.16. of the LDC notwithstanding. Section 2.1.16 allows any use or structure that has been granted a
compatibility exception, an exemption, or vested rights pursuant to the Collier County Zoning
Reevaluation ordinance, to be a permitted use in the zoning district in which it is located to the extent of
its approved maximum density or intensity of use and to the extent that is remains effective. In effect, the
exemption granted under the ZRO does not protect the property's zoning under the LDC sunsetting
provision. The subject petition is for a commercial and industrial mixed use land development for uses
similar in intensity to what was originally approved at the initial rezoning to PUD in 19
does,nothing to impact the Growth Management Plan.
A ~~ 1lR",
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
~
Pi,
HISTORIC/ARCHAEOLOGICAL IMPACT:
Staffs analysis indicates that the petitioner's property is located outside an area of historical and
archaeological probability as referenced on the official Collier County Probability Map. Therefore, no
Historical! Archaeological Survey and Assessment is required.
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
This petition was not eligible to be placed on the summary agenda due to the receipt ofletters of
opposition.
The Collier County Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval ofPUD-82-16(1)
with the following stipulations to which the petitioner agreed to on the record:
1, Prior to the issuance of any other development order, the developer shall complete an intersection
analysis of the U.S. 41 and Wiggins Pass Road intersection. This intersection analysis shall be
submitted to the State Department of Transportation for review, comment and approval. Any required
improvements shall be the responsibility of the developer. The timing for any required
improvement(s) shall be such that it is in place prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy for
a structure in association with a use which triggers the required improvements.
2. The landscape buffering along the northern property boundary shall consist of a twenty (20) foot wide
buffer area planted with trees spaced no more than 25 feet on center, and a hedge of at least 24 inches
in height and attaining a minimum of three feet in height within one year shall be required. Should the
property north of the site's northern property boundary be approved by the Board of County
Commissioner's for any use other than for residential, this additional landscape buffer requirement
shall no longer apply and landscaping shall be installed consistent with the requirements of the Land
Development Code at the time of Site Development Plan approval.
3. Development within fifty (50) feet from the required setback of the northern property boundary ofthe
site shall be limited to commercial type of land uses. Any type of outdoor storage shall not be
permitted within fifty (50) feet from the required setback of the northern property boundary or in
association with a structure or use within fifty (50) feet from the required setback of the northern
property boundary. Should the property north ofthe site's northern property boundary be approved by
the Board of County Commissioner's for any use other than for residential, this setback and outdoor
storage limitation as it applies to structures adjacent to the northern property boundary shall no longer
apply,
4. The maximum height of structures located adjacent to the northern property boundary shall be limited
to thirty-five (35) feet, a minimum of fifty (50) feet from the required setback from the northern
property boundary, Should the property boundary north of the site's northern property boundary be
approved by the Board of County Commissioner's for any use other than for residential, this height
limitation as it applies to structures adjacent to the northern property boundary shall no longer apply,
5. The petitioner shall submit the required FLUCCS map for the Planning Services Environmental staffs
review and approval. Should staff determine that the preserve area indicated on the UD ~ PIiM.
to be insufficient, the PUD Master Plan shall be revised, three (3) weeks prior to tht healift~
I~ & I
MAR 2 3 999
Pe. L/
Board of County Commissioners, to accurately reflect the required preserve area as recommended and
approved by Collier County Environmental staff.
After the Planning Commission hearing, the petitioner provided the required FLUCCS map as noted
above. The FLUCCS map was reviewed by the Planning Services Environmental staff. Upon review, the
Environmental staff recommends approval of the PUD amendment with the following stipulations:
1. The PUD document shall be revised as folJows:
(a) Section V, 5.6. B, the following language shalJ be added: "An approved structural boundary shall
be constructed along the entire western edge of the preserve, to provide the required buffer. The
construction of this buffer shalJ be completed no later than 180 days from the approval of PUD
amendment number PUD-82-16(1)."
(b) Section V, 5.6.D. shall be revised to read as follows: Replace ". . . approval prior to Final Site
Plan/Construction Plan approval" with the following language: "within 90 days of approval of this
PUD amendment." Also, add the following language to the end of the paragraph, "Initial exotic
removal shall be completed no later than 180 days from the approval of PUD amendment number
PUD-82-16(1)."
(c) Replace Section V, 5,6,F" with the folJowing language, "A conservation easement shall be placed
over the jurisdictional wetland em site, providing protective covenants per Florida Statues 704.06,
within 180 days of approval of this PUD amendment number PUD-82-16( I).
(d) Revise Section 2.4 D. TRACT "B" - Cypress Preserve shall read +/- 3.33 acres.
(e) Revise the PUD Master Plan to show the Tract B - Cypress Preserve to read +/-3.33 acres.
Between the Planning Commission hearing and the scheduled hearing before the Board, staff met with
neighboring homeowner's associations concerning the proposed PUD amendment(s). Discussion at these
meetings has centered around the existing Krehling Plant located on the Industrial zoned property west of
the subject site, which is not under the consideration of this petition. The citizen's concerns are related to
what they perceive as excessive noise associated with the operation of the plant. Since the PUD as
originalJy approved in 1982, and as presented for amendment, wilJ alJow uses similar to the existing
Krehling Plant. staff has since taken under consideration the need to provide a limitation on the operating
hours ofthat type of business. The Land Development Code does not contain limitations on hours of
operation associated with uses in the Industrial zoning district and restricts noise levels to specific decibel
readings. However, the PUD amendment process and PUD zoning process provides an
opportunity to impose conditions such as a limitation on the hours of operation. It is staffs opinion that
the Board of County Commissioners should consider imposing a limitation on the hours of operation
associated with some of the heavier types of industrial uses permitted by the PUD document and/or
eliminating those uses from the PUD. Should the Board wish to consider either ofthose options, staff has
the following recommendations:
1. The hours of operation associated with the following uses shalJ be limited to 6:30 a.m. to 7:00 p,m.
Monday through Saturday; no work is permitted on Sundays and the following holidays: New Year's
Day, Memorial Day, 4th of July, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Day:
A) Bulk storage, not including bulk storage of flammable liquids, and stockpiling, hard
stockpiling activities (Groups 1411, 1422, 1429, 1442, 1446,3273).
B) Concrete specialty products (Groups 1411, 1422-1446, 1771,3273).
~~
MAR 2 3 1999
S-
pe.
C) Any other heavier industrial type of use that the Planning Services Director determines to be
comparable in nature to the foregoing uses.
Andlor
Eliminate the following Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) codes from the PUD document:
Groups 1411, 1422, 1429, 1442-1446,1711,3273.
This petition has been continued from the February 23, 1999 BCC meeting. The above referenced groups
have been removed from the PUD document's list of permitted uses. All other staff conditions have been
met.
PREPARED BY:
~-J ~7
~USANMURRAy,AICP
CHIEF PLANNER
I
, ~ '
~~::~~\~,
RONALD F. NINO, AICP, MANAGER
CURRENT PLANNING SECTION
, l-z-----------
ROBERT J. MULHERE, AICP, DIRECTOR
PLANNING SERVICES /
APPROVEDBy/J/ J 4 /~
V;;~#. ~' J--/,J -1/
VINCENT A, CAUTERO, AICP, ADMINISTRATOR DATE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SVCS.
Petition Number: PUD-82-16(1) Krehling Industries PUD
This petition has been tentatively scheduled for the March 23, 1999 Board of County
Commissioners Public Hearing.
3- 3 -99
DATE
j "~Z,
_f _
DATE
\- d
I -
-~
}
-; ~;, '1
DATE
.-
AGENOA ITEM
No, J~l~1
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. (p
.:c,GENDA ITEM j-F
MEiHOR-\.NDUM
TO:
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM:
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
DIVISION
DATE:
"\JOVEMBER 18. 1998
RE: ,
. ?FTlTION NO:
PlTD-8/-1hCL) KRFHf TNG i''.ilJl T~TR!F"
O'VNERJ AGENT:
Agent:
Karen Bishop
PMS, Inc. of Naples
2335 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 408
Naples, FL 34103
Owner:
Henry W. Krehling
1425 E. Wiggins Pass Road
Naples, FL 34110
REQUESTED ACTION:
The petitioner seeks to have land described herein rezoned from its current zoning designation of PUD to
PUD pursuant to Section 2.7.3.4. of the Land Development Code, sunsetting provisions.
GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION:
The +/- 15.26 acre subject site is located in Section 15, Township 48 South, Range 25 East at the eastern
terminus of Wiggins Pass Road. The square shaped parcel abuts Industrial zoned property to the west
which is currently developed with the Krehling Concrete Plant.
PURPOSE/DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:
The original Krehling PUD was adopted in 1982. This petition purports to rezone the site from PUD to
PUD, in effect bringing the presently approved document up to current Land Development Code
requirements and reducing the number of development tracts from three (3) to two (2). The size of the
subject property is not planned to change. The Collier County Land Development Code, in Section
2.7.3.4. requires that the project developer submit an annual report on the progress of development,
commencing on the [fth anniversary of the PUD approval by the Board of County Commissioners. For
PUDs which were approved prior to the adoption date of the Land Development Code, the Board directed
that the five year approval period commence on October 30, 1991, the date of adoption of the LDC. The
purpose of this report will be to evaluate whether or not the project has commenced in e est~RENOA iA;J
No. I~
MAR 2 3 1999
7
Pi.
l-a
,m
l~
i~
~~
It
c
I
CZI
N
I
IS
..-
-
,
o
(")
J>:
~"-'i
1-
o
Z
II ,:.:.
(~.. "S"n} p'~
-r
'i
1\ ~
:\ :;
~
"'~2
~~ ;~~
.... - :: -<
\. -.J.... ~ -.::,
~~-:::y:-;~
- gi~('~: ; ~
'::i3:l: Q~ n
-<;~ ~; () 0
, "
,
. ,- I.--' -
~
I "," ~ I
.c
. -(~
i
~--
f ,,'~ ~
!!!I :;1...,
I ~~
~
,,~
0cQ
cz~
a3~2
I' ~
'\ >-
\1'"
~(;. i\!
" I ~
~, s:
~I~
3:
l>
""0
c
~~
';~ t::,l
r" ~ ~~
>: Vl~ _~
2
I~!
J:I Q'f'Ol:i ~...mr.d - !.dOdl:H'f
,,~ill (I< .."'l
~S! 1iI~
:;:~ ..
~i <,1
s '"
-~ ~
~ g
,.... av~ NCllSOH~n
\ PDJCAH w~ _
;3~~
~"" fir,.
'" ~
~ c;il
.. ~c
'j>~
~ -
___ / NOT 10 oc.ou
==
- -
- -
-
-
-
- -
- -
=~=
-1'-
\
)~ll = li W / ~~>I!.;z-~::\..I;""
@~ = ~r= ffiE~~ g ~ ~~~ - ~
o = 1'== --1 f- -I~~?j E:
.===jr -::!:r~= ~~B'~~
~C I I' ~ ~ '<"T'v-
L- ~ '--' 'F' /- {J. b = I
r- = , p i J=. '\ ,-<;y r<Jl\ t:1 >-
~ ' I I EI~a 'lAC! :=t,- I
_i I ~ "0 -
tlffiffilffiEff ~! %f- I T If V' ~
~~ I " 11 TT III1 IT II'
I Ii
en
-
--t
IT1
~~J~~ r n
g.~~,\J~
i~~ {ifi
t= ""11l i ~ ~\; I
~ =Q~ =1 J E t=
-= =:=J ~~
~5 ,~~ ( ~ ~
~(r\ 'I "'-, ~ ~
~,\I\j 'PLOW,
~ ~ ~ }1-rUT r-
_'-.\II r \Y ~ ~
Bi'r 1\1 "(\~
o \@ II:
I
AGENO
( No. /-
i
',,-- 7 MAR 2
I,
I
I
i
3:
l>
1""0
, .'
........ ClClAS1lN: """"""""
,
V'
) II
I ;
~\\
~
~.
Dd
ii
..
:l
I
~J
999
Y
accordance with the criteria set forth in Section 2.1.3.4. lhe above reterenced PUD is a project which was
~pproved prior to the adoption date of the LDC. At oligillal :suumitlal UI lht: ft:yuireu repon, the subject
PUD was given a one (1) year extension to either comply substantially with the provisions of the
sunsetting requirements in the LDC or to submit <In amended Pl m. S::nmin;:;l of this PUD ame)lcli11f:l'~
......:,,-.:.,:. 'I;,;:"'f':lr~'''''fl''lt,rl';jv-l') lr-"\l:r-""i t~I"'-I"II'll"""f-"'~ -;...--;~, '-'llr- ;''-' ,., \"'10.'11..'1 '-Ar"",, \"~In r......o..-r"'.,.,....... .,/.......-..................-"="-t
~ .".;/' . .".11" "'.--'-.) .'-'."- -.a.--r--r---- --_.._.............-_.............~...-......-.J .....Io......."'......._vv,.~LJ.l.l........uJ.J.u6""'.l..1J.""J..1
Plan and Land Development Code. Subseqllent ~rpnwr!i ()f this pf'tlTioTl. will est?)]!ish the prcJest'~
consistency with the existing Growth Management Plan and bring the presently approved PUD up to the
current requirements of the Land Development Code.
ApproximareiY seventy-five (75) percent oftne subject site is cieared. lhe western portIOn of the site is
curremiy uc;eri for (mtnonr "tnr~sf' r.ffini~hf'rl r;C)T\.':'!"~!~ pro':!'.JCts iT\. ::~:':'si2.!~C'~:' 'Nith the adjace:lt c:J:lcrete
plant on industrial zoned property to the west. The proposed development scheme as illustrated by the
PUD Master Plan indicates a total of two (2) land use tracts. Similar to the previously approved PUD, the
+/-13.62 acre Tract A is planned for future commercial and light industrial type of development. The +/-
1.64 acre Tract B is shown on the PUD Master Plan as a Cypress Preserve Area and stormwater retention
area. The site is located on the south side of Wiggins Pass Road at its eastern terminus. Access to the site
is provided by two (2) driveways located off of Wiggins Pass Road. Wiggins Pass Road from U.S. 41 also
provides access to the existing concrete plant to the west of the subj ect site, as well as residential
development on properties zoned for Mobile Home (MH) and Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle
Campground (TTRVC), on the north and south sides of Wiggins Pass Road, just east of U.S. 41. The
subject site and the abutting industrial site are presently under common ownership. There is an existing
railroad spur which runs along the western property boundary between the two properties. The land uses
permitted by this PUD can generally be described as light industrial uses permitted in the Industrial
zoning district like light manufacturing and assembling, and industrial warehousing, wholesale, storage or
distributing. As part of the current business operations of Krehling Industries, Inc., the light industrial
facilities proposed for the subject site will also be used to support concrete specialty products, stockpile
and storage of finished concrete products. Also, in association with the industrial uses, the permitted
commercial uses will generally consist of warehousing, office (retail or professional), building supplies
and enclosed storage. The proposed uses are similar in type and intensity to the uses approved in the
original PUD. In general, this +/- 35 acre development proposal essentially retains the same type ofland
uses originally approved, to be developea in two (2) rather then three (3) development tracts.
SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING:
Existing: The subject property is vacant and presently has a PUD zoning designation approved for
commercial and light industrial type of land uses.
Zoning
Land Use
Surrounding: North - Agriculture (A)
Vacant
South - Golf Course (GC)
Golf Course
East - Golf Course (GC)
Golf Course
AGENDA ITEM
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 9
West- Industrial (1)
Concrete Plan
2
GRO\'/TH ~'L\NAGE:ME~T I'LAN CONS1STENCY:
fhe land \vhich is the subject of this petition is designated Urban Residential an the Future Land Use Map
\-';~~~I,", :-::I"l<"~~' ~":..11.H\S(~Ht~rl~ r:f1IL T~..., 1.i"f.II''''l~li q~r~ t.f!~I,,,": '~;'_":'_~"'I.!~:-e_~"I~-I~'~~~I_!~,::"~"_.~~!: ~!.':" ~~'~'~ I~'...\~~~i~~~!~~
with the loeationa1 criteria for these uses provided fOT in the FIJI lire Lan,ri \ !se Fiemenll,F LlTF) l-1nwever,
because an exemption was granted for this PUD through the Zoning Reevaluation Program (ZRO) the
existing pun zoning can be considered consistent with the FT UE via policy, specifically Policy 5.10 of
the FLUE. Policy 5.10 providf'stht cypmnf;nTI" nr>Sf'0 Of1 ....."::t?r~ ,,:r.t<: or rr)Ti1p.1tibility determi!l:;.~i0ns
thai al~ granieu a~ provided for in (he Collier County Zoning ke-evaiuation ordinance shall be considered
consislem with {he Future Lanrt Use Flem.ent. In this rl"~~rd. thr' <::llhjprt f'ptitio!' i~ consistent \,'.r~!!: !~e
Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management Plan. However, the exemption granted for the
subject PUD although it precluded Collier County from rezoning the property via the authorization
provided by the Zoning Reevaluation Ordinance and FLUE Policy 3.1 (k), does not protect the property
from a zoning change initiated by Collier County as may be authorized by other ordinance or statutory
provisions, Section 2.1.16. of the LDC notwithstanding. Section 2.1.16 allows any use or structure that
has been granted a compatibility exception, an exemption, or vested rights pursuant to the Collier County
Zoning Reevaluation ordinance, to be a permitted use in the zoning district in which it is located to the
extent of its approved maximum density or intensity of use and to the extent that is remains effective. In
effect, the exemption granted under the ZRO does not protect the property's zoning under the LDC
sunsetting provision. The subject petition is for a commercial and industrial mixed use land development
for uses similar in intensity to what was originally approved at the initial rezoning to PUD in 1982. There
are no significant changes in permitted land uses from what was initially approved.
Consistency with other applicable elements of the Growth Management Plan (GMP) is as
follows:
Traffic Circulation Element -
The ITE Trip Generation Manual indicates that the proposed amendment will generate approximately 250
to 300 additional trips more than the amount of trips that could be generated by the currently approved
PUD. Therefore, the site generated traffic will not exceed this significant test standard (5 percent of the
LOS "C" design volume) on U.S. 41 or on any County road. The total site generated trips is estimated to
be 1,248 weekday trips at build out in 2002.
The Traffic Circulation Elements lists U.S. 41 as a 4-1ane arterial road. The current traffic count for the
segment from the Lee County line to Wiggins Pass Road is 24,364 AADT and is operating at LOS "A". It
should be noted that this segment is not projected to be deficient at the bui1dout of this project in 2002.
However, the segment of U.S. 41 from Wiggins Pass Road to Immokalee Road is currently deficient.
Therefore, this road segment is required to be improved to 6-lanes for concurrency purposes. The 5-year
work program indicates that this segment is scheduled to be improved by the year 2000.
Other Applicable Element (s) -
Other applicable elements are those typically evaluated at the time of subsequent devel
approvals, and generally deal with infrastructure. To the extent that improvements to
AGENDA ITEM
No,~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi, }O
3
inrraslruclUlt andJor tne extension or avaiiabie public utilities IS required. these will be mandated
at the time of approval of the required site deielopment plan <uh.lJor subdividing if necessary.
RISTO RI C! AR~_HA~.QLQGICAI,. .,!J~1.~ ,~&J:I~
Staff's analysis indicates that the petitioner's property is lor:ated olllside;'ln ;:[rt"'a ofl1i,torir::l.l ::l!ld
archaeological probability as referenced on the official Collier County Probability Map.
Therefore, no HistoricaV Archaeological Survey and Assessment is r~ql)i!'ed.
KVALUATION FOR E~ViRONlVr~:lirAL~IRA[i~.rORIAJJ(J.N A~D INfRASTkUCrlfRE:
The subject petition has been reviewed by the appropriate staff responsible for the above referenced areas
of critical concern. This primarily includes a review by the Community Development environmental and
engineering staff, and the Transportation Services Division staff.
Jurisdictional reviews have resulted in the formulation of development commitments necessary to ensure
compliance with the development regulations of Collier County. These development commitments have
all been included in the PUD document and/or have been reflected on the P1JD Master Plan.
ANALYSIS:
Staff completed a comprehensive evaluation of this land use petition and the criteria on which a favorable
determination must be based. This evaluation is intended to provide an objective, comprehensive
overview of the impact of the proposed land use change, be they positive or negative, culminating in a
staff recommendation based on that comprehensive overview. The listed criteria are specifically noted in
Section 2.7.2.5 and Section 2.7.3.2.5 of the Land Development Code thus requiring staff evaluation and
comment, and shall be used as the basis for a recommendation of approval or denial by the Planning
Commission to the Board of County Commissioners. Each of the potential impacts or considerations
identified during the staff review are listed under each of the criterion noted and are categorized as either
pro or con, whichever the case may be, in the opinion of staff. Staff review of each of the criterion is
followed by a summary conclusion culminating in a determination of compliance, non-compliance, or
compliance with mitigation. These evaluations are completed as separate documents and are attached to
the staff report.
Appropriate evaluation of petitions for rezoning should establish a factual bases for supportive action by
appointed and elected decision makers. The evaluation by professional staff should typically include an
analysis of the petition's relationship to the community's future land use plan, and whether or not a
rezoning action would be consistent with the Collier County Growth Management Plan in all of its related
elements. Other evaluation considerations should include an assessment of adequacy of transportation
infrastructure, other infrastructure, and compatibility with adjacent land uses, a consideration usually dealt
with as a facet of analyzing the relationship of the rezoning action to the long range plan for future land
uses.
Notwithstanding the above, staff in reviewing the determinants for adequate findings to support a
rezoning action advise as follows:
AGENDA ITEM
No. /;>.. ( !;) I
MAR 2 3 1999
4
Pi. II
Relationship to Future and Existing Land L::;cs:
A discussion of this relationship, as it applies specifically to Collier CO'Jntv's legal basis for land use
~.JtJlI_":Hl~._ j..,;"L~3 tv l1JL j".,L-lli'-'I,S".:11 1)_; j:H-- C'III~"_I""r-:-(; _~I_I~~~~~~ ~~,_.~~,_,~~ 1-'_' ~~~':" Fl!~~~l~ Lan.d L\~e =:le:~lellt oflhe
......:;> ,J. ... _
Coiiier County Growth Management Plan.
The subject property is located within the Urban Designated Mixed Use future land use classification as
depicted on the Future Land Use Man of the Collier CCIlmtv Gn'.vth l\1~n~~?f"ment P!:m. Th~ ~itt:' is 1.:~~:lted
at tIll;; t:aSlem terminus uf Wiggins Pass Road. less than 12 mile east of the U.S. 41 - Wiggins Pass Road
imersection. Tile Pl IT) c1or.urr.~nt inf;ir:1t~<:: thp. proP0<::('(t rlPv{'!f"\~rr'~,=!n ~l,m to!" the site is? mixed use
commerciaVlight industrial type of development on +/- 13.62 acres. Approximately 1.64 acres along the
eastern property boundary is comprised of a Cypress Preserve tract. The western boundary of the site
abuts a parcel ofland zoned and developed for Industrial uses (concrete batch plant). The southern and
eastern boundaries abut property zoned and developed with an existing golf course. The northern property
boundary abuts the sixty (60) foot wide Wiggins Pass Road right-of-way, then, further north, properties
zoned Agriculture (A). The proposed building setbacks required in the PUD, and the Wiggins Pass Road
right-of-way minimizes the location of light industrial and commercial land uses adj acent to agriculturally
zoned land uses to the north. The PUD Master Plan shows the proposed location of future commercial
and industrial development encompassing the entire site with the exception of the 1.64 acres along the
eastern boundary dedicated to the Cypress Preserve, as well as required landscape buffers, water
management areas and internal right-of-way.
-- The site abuts an existing golf course to the south and east as part of an existing residential development
(Imperial Lakes PUD). Additionally, the eastern and southern boundaries are also heavily buffered with
vegetative buffer. The property to the north is also heavily vegetated and is currently undeveloped.
Although currently zoned Agricultural, it is not unlikely that future development of this property will
include residential land uses. The existing developed Industrial property to the west creates truck traffic,
noise and dust in association with its use. Future development of the subject site for a light
industriaVcommercial type of land use may have the affect of exacerbating truck traffic through the area
however, more than likely not to the extent at to which it is associated with the existing concrete plant.
Given the nature of the development on the adjacent property to the west, and the golf course zoned
properties to the east and south, light industrial and commercial land uses could be viewed as having little
impact on the existing developme'lt on these properties. It is likely that properties to the north, however,
may be developed for future residential uses and should be sufficiently buffered. The project's proposed
open space, ingress/egress, landscape buffers, and other applicable development standards comply with
the requirements of the Collier County Land Development Code. With respect to compatibility issues,
staff is of the opinion that the subject petition is consistent with the Collier County Growth Management
Plan by policy.
Traffic:
The ITE Trip Generation Manual indicates that the proposed amendment -w-ill generate approximately 250
to 300 additional trips more than the amount of trips that could be generated by the currently approved
"-, PUD. Therefore. the site generated traffic will not exceed this significant test standard (5 pe
~~ .).~
No,~
5
MAR 2 3 1999
pc, /~
LOS. C" design volume) on U.S. 41 or on any County road. lhe total SIte generated trips is estimated to
oe 1248 -,,,-c;ekday trips at uuild out in 2002.
The Traffic Circulation Elements lists U.S. 41 as a 4-1ar.e arterial road. The current traffic (l')unt for the
.....r-t.il("-...I~ l-....."rn (';11-" T pe '-'(lllIIIV j;r11'-" ~n '\"J~l'(.r'-'J.'tl<'~ ~'a~'c .......t\.l,l 'S 1'1 04""/i 1'1\.1' I n"-"j"1 1c;' i"\_Clo....,.."T......~......T If -..... ..",(,'" It
.~_.;;;;_......;.__~.. ....__.... .....~'~.",.. ----...~.l ..l..........<..J I ~o....,J.... ......J..IL........lo-."J.. _.~-"....,.....L.A-....-..A. -......._...o.J-.t-'......a.~.......l...6""'~'--'....J 4-1..
should he noted that this segment is not pr0jerted to hf' df'f!rl.~l'!t ~.t th,=, bmldm!t of this project in 2002.
However, the segment of U.S. 41 from Wiggins Pass Road to Immokalee Road is currently deficient.
Therefore, this road segment is required to be improved to 6-lanes for concurrency purposes. The 5-year
work pro~;:l'11 indic?tes th;:;t this sP~'ent is: 5ch~dt!!e.J ~,_) be ;rf':"'0"erl b\! the vear :WOO. A ~tb~lwn th-~---, -
submitted TIS indicates potential traffic impacts resulting from develo!"ment of the suhject site\ it cioes not
~n::l !Y7P, th~ potential il11r~~ts on t~Ifl1't1g I!'J)V~!!'.'?TI!S ?.!:.'2 !r?.i!!-: !e'.'e!~ ~! t~e inter$ect~ O~ c f ~.S. 41 and
Wiggins Pass Road. Prior to the issuance of additional development orders, a detailed intersection
analysis should be provided in order to examine the potential impacts to this intersection.
From a planning and traffic safety standpoint, due to the clear sight distance of the existing
ingress and egress easement, the proposed access should operate adequately subject to any required
engineering modifications and the Collier County Access Management Plan. The final geometry and
design of the access will be reviewed at the time of Preliminary , Development Plan (SDP) and/or
Preliminary Subdivision Plat (PSP) review.
The GMP consistency review indicates that approval of this petition is consistent with policies of the
TCE.
Utility Infrastructure:
Both a public sanitary sewer and municipal water supply is available to the property. All development
must comply with surface water management requirements invoked at the time of site development plan
approval.
SummarY:
Based on the above analysis, the following conclusions can be reached from the staff report:
1. The proposed rezoning of the subject property from the Cl!rrent zoning designation of PUD to PUD
and the PUD development strategy for mixed use commercial and light industrial development is
consistent with the FLUE of the GMP by policy.
2. The proposed light industrial and commercial uses are similar to those uses approved at the original
adoption of the PUD and are not proposed to increase in intensity from what was originally approved.
The proposed uses can be considered compatible with the Industrial zoning district to the west, and
when properly buffered, the agricultural property to the north. Existing buffers in the form of a golf
course and heavy vegetation sufficiently buffer the subject site from the land uses on the south and
east sides.
3. Although the submitted TIS indicates potential traffic impacts resulting from develo
subject site, it does not analyze the potential impacts on turning movements and traf c le~~
MAR 2 3 1999
6
Pi. /3
illlt.:IsectioI1 oIu.5. -+ i ami '..Viggins ?ass Road. Prior to the issuance of additional development orders.
a detailed intersection uilul)::;is should be pro\'ided in order to examine the poteniial impacts LV ihis
- intersection.
~T ~ ~~ :;~,~:-:~.,:~_~.';:"7';~4.~.::~;c
Staff recommends that Collier County Planning Commission forward a recommendation for approval of
Petition PUD-82-16( I), Krehling PUD to the Board of County COITlJTIissioners, pursuant to the Ordinance
of Adontion and Exhibits attacne0 thereto with the fC\l1nwif1g stipphtiop'S:
1. Prior to the issuance of :my other development orc1p.r, the developf>f sh?!l c0!1'.~lete ?P- in!er~ection
analysis of the U.S. 41 and Wiggins Pass Road intersection. This intersection analysis shall be
submitted to the State Department of Transportation for review, comment and approval. Any required
improvements shall be the responsibility of the developer. The timing for any required
improvement(s) shall be such that it is in place prior to the issuance to any certificate of occupancy for
a structure in association with a use which triggers the required improvement(s).
") The Landscape buffering along the northern property boundary shall be provided which is at least
twenty (20) feet in width,.trees spaced no more than 25 feet on center, and a hedge of at least 24
inches in height and attaining a minimum of three feet in height within one year shall be required.
3. Development adjacent to the northern boundary of the site shall be limited to the permitted
commercial type of land uses. Any type of outdoor storage shall not be permitted adjacent to the
northern property boundary or in association with a structure or use adjacent to the northern property
boundary .
4. The maximum height of structures located adjacent the northern property shall be limited to thirty-five
(35) feet.
.--,
AG~~~
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. / L/
7
PREPARED BY:
-- .'~
'.. ;"...
'.-0.
SUSAN MURRAY. AICP
. CHIEF PI.ANNER
DATE
JU:VIE\VED BY:
\
(/ \
RoNArD F~-NiNO:-~ICP
"".
CURRENT PLANNING MANAGER
\ \ ~ ~ ~.
\ . \ '- \ . ~ \ .'
DATE
/ ...-;
/"t-/~
/ROHE:RT J. MULHERE, AICP
PLANNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR
1'/ - Co -/6
DATE
t:1" ~~ )/- ~3 -7?
VINCENT A. CAUTERO, AICP, ADMINISTRATOR DATE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SVCS.
Petition Number: PUD-82-16(1), Krehling Pun
Staff Report for December 3, 1998 CCPC Meeting
NOTE: This Petition has been tentatively advertised for the January 12, 1999 BCC meeting.
COLLIER ~UNTY PLANNING COMMISSION:
~~~
MIC~ J. BRUET, CHAIRPERSON
A~Ar~L
No. ~
8
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. /~
REZONE FINDINGS FOR PETITION PL'D # 98-16
Section 2.7.2.5. of the Collier County Land Development Code requires that the report and
recommendations oftne Plannin~ Commission to the Board of County Commissioners shall show that the
Planning commission has stuil\ ",rI, :md com:iderp,-'j th~ iil-nf\I);;;pd chrmge in relation to tl~S' foIl0'''!!'.?', where
applicable:
1. Whether the proposed change will be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies and
Future Land Use map and the elements of the Growth Management Plan.
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summarv Findim:!:s: The proposed development is in compliance with the Future Land Use Element of
the Growth Management Plan by policy for Collier County, and all other elements. their objectives and
policies.
2. The existing land use pattern;
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Summary Findin2s:
Existing: The majority of the subject property is vacant and a portion of it is cleared. The western portion
of the site is currently being used for outdoor storage of concrete products made in association with the
concrete plant to the west.
Zoning Land Use
Surrounding: North - Agriculture (A) Vacant
South - Golf Course (GC) Golf Course
East - Golf Course (GC) Golf Course
West- Industrial (I) Concrete Plant
.-
AGENOA I~
No. J ;) (B) I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. / 10
9
3. The pus~ioiiilY 4.:realijlg of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts:
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
~~;;.;-u~;--.P =--:~.al~~.;;..... ~~j~ .~,:~~ :s (j,dj.q-:~:i-,i t() ;~n l,~.-i"'~J\g: gC,Jf C"llf~e ~uL1l;! (1Plj ': ~~l.
1 . 1., .
-:1!~1__ \. :-'I_-~!-.!.~ ~gl-!..'2.l_!!.~..':.~l~!
land to the north. Property adjacent to the site on the west. across Wiggins Pass Road. is undeveloped _
property zoned for Agricultural use. The availability of adequate infrastructure and the proximity to
adjacent developments justify a rezoning action to PUD.
4. \Vhetlter eXI5illllg distrid boundaries are iilogicaHy drawn in reiation to existing conditions
on the property pru!,>used rO.r change.
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summarv Findines: The district boundaries are logically drawn. The site is similar in area and shape to
the Industrial zoned property to the west.
5. \Vhether changed or changing conditions make the passa~e of the proposed amendment
necessary.
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summarv Findin~s: The proposed change is appropriately based on the existing conditions of the
property and because it is consistent with the Future Land Use Element by policy of the Growth
Management Plan.
6. Whether the proposed change will adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood;
Pro: (i) The zoning designation of the adjacent property to the west is Industrial and it is currently
developed with a concrete plant.
(ii) The subject site has been zoned for a mixed commercial and light industrial PUD since 1982. This
rezoning does not propose to increase the intensity of those uses originally approved in 1982, nor
does it propose to change the project's boundaries.
(iii) Adjacent properties to the south and east have been developed with significant open space and buffer
areas thus mitigating the impacts of any future development.
Con: The conversion ofraw land to urban development may be viewed by the neighboring property
owner's to the west as an infringement on their existing quality of environment. However, by law, the
County cannot deny a property owner reasonable use of hislher land, consistent with the Comprehensive
Plan, without fair compensation.
Summary Findim!s: The proposed zoning amendment will not adversely affect living conditions in the
neighborhood because the recommended development standards and other conditions for ap' roval have
been developed and designed to ensure the least amount of adverse impact on adjacent dev lopm~Hrr~1
No. ~
10
MAR 2 3 1999
/1
pc.
project has been zonet.! fur I..0wmerciai and light industrial lanu uses since 1982. It appears that in
response to the site's existing zoning, properties to the south and east have provided suffi(ient buffers
between the site and nearby residential land uses. Those buffers have taken the form of significant open
spaccin the form of a golf course. and heavy ve~etative buffering adjacent to the subject site's south and
,--;~.~t ~)i\j~I(;i"iJ' ;-'~:'J;llll.:"'11 ;"....
7. \Vhether the proposed change will create or excessively increase traffic congestion or create
types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses, became (If peak volumes or
projected types of vehicular traffic. includinp activitv during constnlctil'\n ph~t;;es Ilf the
ut:velupmeut. or otherwise affect public safety.
Pro: (i) The proposed development of the subject property is consistent with the provisions of the
Traffic Element of the Growth Management Plan, therefore the additional traffic generated by the
proposed development should not adversely affect the comfort and safety of existing users on adjacent
public roads.
Con: As urban intensification increases. there is some loss of comfort and ease of travel to motorists
using the adjacent roadways. However, by law, this degree of discomfort is regulated by concurrency
requirements. Development of the site may increase truck traffic to the area however, not unlike similar
types of commercial and light industrial development but not to the extent that the neighboring concrete
plant generates.
Summary Findines: Evaluation ofthis project took into account the requirement for consistency with
Policy 5.1 of the Traffic Element of the GMP and was found consistent. Staff s recommendations include
the requirement for an intersection analysis to be performed prior to the approval of further development
orders. Improvements required by that intersection analysis shall be the responsibility of the developer.
8. \Vhether the proposed change will create a drainage problem;
Pro: Water management improvements to accommodate site development are designed to
accommodate the normal drainage requirement.
Con: Urban intensification always poses a threat for area-wide flooding under the most severe rainfall
event, unless countYNide drainage improvements are made commensurate with urban intensification.
Summary Findin~s: Every project approved in Collier County involving the utilization of land for some
land use activity is scrutinized and required to mitigate all sub-surface drainage generated by
developmental activities as a condition of approval. This project was reviewed for drainage relationships
and design and construction plans are required to meet County standards as a condition of approval. In
the event area-wide deficiencies develop, which deficiencies would be further exacerbated by developing
vacant land, the County is required to react through its Concurrency Management system.
--
AGj;~):
No.
11
MAR 2 3 1999
Jeg
.
Pt.
Y. W-hether the proposed change wilJ seriously reduce light and air to ad,jacent areas:
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
:;!.Hnrnarv Fil!~.HI1~S; "~il proj~cts in CoE!~~ (e~!!IY ~~:: ~~L~~~I ~~, ~!lt;: ~~'.'::!~~:;.:::::t s::':'rldards Ihat are
unique to the zoning district in which iT is Inc;(lt~n These d~velopment "t~nrl~rd<;; <'Inri 0ther apply
generally and equally to all zoning districts (i.e. open space requirement, corridor management provisions,
etc.) were designed to ensure that light pen,=,tration and circulation of air does not adversely affect adjacent
~re8S.
10. \Vhether the I'rl}r(\~ed chang"." wi!! atj"er~"-"!y ~!'fert property val!!e~ !!! t!le2djacent area;
Pro: Urban intensification typically increases the value of adjacent vacant or underutilized land.
Con: None.
Summarv Findin2s: This is a subjective determination based upon anticipated results which may be
internal or external to the subject property that can affect proper'llues. Property valuation is affected
by many factors including zoning, however zoning by itself ma) may not affect values, since value
determination by law is driven by market value. The mere fact that a property is given a new zoning
designation mayor may not affect value.
11. Whether the proposed change will be a deterrent to the improvement or development of
adjacent property in accordance with existing regulations;
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summarv Findin2s: Application of the development standards found in the Land Development Code
combined with the administrative site development plan approval process, should give reasonable
assurance that the proposed change in zoning will not deter the future improvement or development of
adjacent property. Additional development standards as recommended by staff should help to alleviate to
buffer agricultural areas to the north.
12. Whether the proposed change will cons~itute a grant of special privilege to an individual
owner as contrasting with the public welfare;
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summary Findines: Since consistency with the Future Land Use Element of the County's Growth
Management Plan is deemed to be in the public's interest, and because the proposed rezoning action and
subsequent development complies with the Growth Management Plan, then the proposal can be deemed
not to constitute a special privilege and in the public interest.
AGENDA ITH'
No. f;)"{ A)I
MAR 2 3 1989
Pi. J 9
12
1-'. \Vhetner there are substantial reasons why the property cannot be used in accordance with
existing zoning;
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summarv Findinps: The subject property's current pun zoning rlesignation ,,1l0W llses of the same ~ype
and intensity as it presently permitted under the current zoning designation. Surrounding properties to the
south and east of the site are already developed wi~h lJses deemed compatible to the requested zoning
designation. Pronertlps to the west areZOl1f>r1 to allow for more inteme IndEstrial type of land uses.
14. \Vhethl'f the dU1Pge suggested is out of sc~le with the ne~ds Qfthe !H~ighbQ!'hood or the
CountY"
. ,
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summarv Findin2s: The proposed development complies with the Growth Management Plan, a policy
statement which has evaluated the scale, density and intensity of land uses deemed to be acceptable for
this site.
15. Whether it is impossible to find other adequate sites in the County for the proposed use in
districts already permitting such use.
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summary Findin~s: This petition will allow similar types ofland uses which were originally approved
in 1982. The result of this rezoning will not establish a zoning district different from what presently exists
in terms of permitted uses.
16. The physical characteristics of the property and the degree of site alteration which would be
required to make the property usable for any of the range of potential uses under the proposed
zoning classification.
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
Summarv Findin2s: The extent of site alteration will be determined as a function of obtaining Site
Development Plan approval which will be necessary to execute the PUD's development strategy. The
existing environmentally sensitive areas on site will be preserved.
17. The impact of development on the availability of adequate public facilities and services
consistent with the levels of service adopted in the Collier County Growth management Plan as
defined and implemented through the Collier County Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance, as
amended.
Pro/Con:
Application not applicable.
AGENDA ITEM
No.--J;t L ~ L
MAR 2 3 1999
~O
P&.O<
13
Summarv FiIldin1!s; Sanitary sewers and municipal water utilities are avaIlable to serve the
development. Revievv' by jurisdictional staff for consistency evaluation with G\lP required levels of
service advise that there is no deficiency.
A~LIr);
No. 8
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. e:? I
14
FIND11~GS FOR PC 0
PCD-97-1
Sccti0i\ 2.'7.3.2.3. ,_,f [lie Collier Cc'~'nty L1!Hi l)':\'':'~'J~!"!!ent C/~\~-= ,~:;.~!~:-~~ lne .::'larming Commis:;ion to
make a finding as to the PUD Master Phm's compli:mre with the followifl3 cri~ena:
1. The suitability of the area f(lr the type and pattern of development proposed in relation to
pt!'vsical characteristics ofthe lanrl3 sllrrnunding areas, traffk ~l1d ac~e~", dr~!n~weo ~ewer,
water, and other utilities.
Pro: (i)
The subject site is located adjacent to an existing golf course on the south and east sides
and heavy industrial uses on the west side.
(ii) Intensifying land development patterns produces economies of scale relative to
public utilities, facilities and services, which are currently available in this area.
Con: (i) Nearby residential communities may perceive development of light industrial and
commercial type of land uses in their area as contributing factors to inconveniencing movements to and
from their place of residence although the current PUD zoning designation has been in place since 1982.
Findine:
Jurisdictional reviews by County staff support the manner and pattern of
development proposed for the subject property. Development conditions
contained in the Pun document give assurance that all infrastructure will be
developed and be consistent with County regulations. Any inadequacies which
require supplementing the PUD document will be recommended to the Board of
County Commissioners as conditions of approval by staff and the CCPC.
2. Adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of any proposed agreements,
contract, or other instruments, or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as
they may relate to arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing
operation and maintenance of such areas and facilities that are not to be provided
or maintained at public expense.
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applIcable.
Findine::
Documents submitted with the application provide evidence of unified
control. The PUD document makes appropriate provisions for continuing
operation and maintenance of Common areas.
3. Conformity of the proposed Planned Unit Development with the goals, objectives and
policies of the Growth Management Plan.
Pro/Con:
Findine:
Evaluation not applicable.
The subject petition has been found consistent with the goals, ob ~ctiv~~t~
15
MAR 2 3 1999
d~
P&.
and policies of the Growth Management Plan. The subject property is designated
Crban Nlixed-Use - Urban Residential on the FLUE to lhe G:YIP. As such it does
not authorizes zoning actions aimed at allo\ving the land to be used for industrial
and commercial purposes. however. the has b~p-n found consic::teT1t with the FLUE
oy policy.
4. The internal and external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions may include
restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and buffering and screening
rem!!rements,
Pro/Con:
Findinl.?:
Evaluation not applicable.
The Pun Master Plan has been designed to optimize internal land use
relationships through the use of various forms of open space separation
(i.e., preserves, landscape buffers etc.). External relationships are regulated by the
Land Development Code to help assure harmonious relationships between
projects.
5. The adequacy of usable open.space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the
development.
Pro/Con:
Findinl.?:
Evaluation not applicable.
The amount of open space set aside by this project is consistent with the
provisions of the Land Development Code.
6. The timing or sequence of development for the purpose of assuring the adequacy of available
improvements and facilities, both public and private.
Pro/Con:
Findine:
Evaluation not applicable.
Timing or sequence of development in light of concurrency requirements
automatically triggers the mechanism for ensuring that future LOS
degradation is not allowed or the LOS deficiency is corrected.
See Finding No.1, also applicable for this finding.
16
AGENDA '~
No. 1;1. { (j) I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. ~3
..
I.
The abllity of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate expansion.
Pro/Con:
Evaluation not applicable.
.,..... 1.
r 'n.J!~II_~:
A~';;;tY, as '"'.fJ~.iieJ in this contt;:xt, imp~ies supporting infrastructure such as
wastewater ciisposal systems, potable water supplies. characteristics of the
property relative to hazards, and capacity of roads. is supportive of
conditions emanating from urban development. This assessment is
described at ]pngth in the staff report. Development of the snbjert pr0p~rty
is timely, because supporting infrastructure is available and deemed to be
adequate.
8. Conformity with PUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of such regulations in the
particular case, based on determination that such modifications are justified as meeting public
purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such regulations.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Finding: This finding essentially requires an evaluation of the extent to which
development standards proposed for this PUD depart from development
standards that would be required for the most similar conventional zoning
district. The development standards in this PUD are similar to those
standards used for particular housing structures and associated area
requirements.
-
A~(I~
No. a 13
17
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. cxt.f
-~--~,-,~.,.....~ ,.....---
- .... -
-.. ~ ~. -
-~,,--~.---
--~::.....,
-~.-.-.._-.....
. . ; , ..;. '- . . - - . '- - .... ~. - .......
-.. -.~.A1'""',,....,-.._~...... -"-
.'--~-~ - -
-............ .-..-..-.-...... -
=-=~~=~:~ :;,:::::;:":-::".=-,-=-=:::.3 :::; -=-;-.:::: ~:':I:'~C~<?',~>:::,.=-.:-:==
-~ ,...,.--..----~
- - -
- - ",",,"""---.
.... ...... ~,,:..... ','
~ '"' .... ;.~ . - ,
_T ,.....T""'.-......-.
::: -'..../;\~ ;""..--.."
- . ~-... -. - ..,......
.-.~.~:".. -- -~, '...;'
=::;=~:~ ;:'~::';'.S >~.:..:;
::.~:'~~::=;:::= : ::::~ ~',:' =:-:.::'.:~G=~:~ ::-:~ =::'.1:::::~
=:''':'4SS::::=.=;.:;~==~: ::- :;-.:::: :":::?~~:J ~~c::.--:?:~:::=
~_:...r..:.....
~'?~;?==P:": ??c:.~ II ?_~=If -=-: fI?fJ;:;" ?LAiJNEC ~_'~,~:~
=::..4:::"',:.r.:':'"r~;l"I' ~~::'~ /,'t~ .:".S :'-;.St1_,:::G =::~,r...~S:?,:::~::3
~'~~, ::CR ?RC?:?7Y ::C~:=J SOCTHEAST :?
-'~"":""'C'=-c::;:,rrT"-""""i -:- .. ::
_..__."..,.J..............____.. __ _......
-: -0. ~:.~:-.JI:::' CLS' :J.::3.
-: -,
~
:-:::..::: =:.:'.ST2:: '_'. ~.
.-::...r-: r:-~E EASTEEN
~~?:.1::::~:CS ::: :.;: ~~:::::S ?::..3S ?,O.~D, ::1 SE:::::-::,J
:8WNSH:? ~3 5:JT~, ~ANGE :6 EAS:,
~::..:..:::::=? C2:'::';:'.:.',
-- .--..~ -.-,...
: _v:'.1._....;."
=2:JSET::iG:: =-
:S.2E+ ACRES; ??CV==I~:G :-:R ~~E ?SPE~:" -
=:;.: :::~J;".~':C~ :::~~:.~=:::::, : '-
:JFt.~E:~
~:?~~::~G ::::~:~~:?,:::~S
::: . ~..., .
- ....~.,
.:'.~~D 3Y ??C\...===:~~
.:..:~ ::?:::::C':':~.~::: =.:....:-::.
~HE?E~S, :.are~ 3ishop 2~ ?~S,
~f Naples, ~epresentl~g Eenry
~rehlir:.g, ~e'=2-::is:Jed tl':e Bsarj ::= 2::unt:y Commissl:::;;:ers :::; ::::--.ange :::-:e
:on~ng c~ass~~~~a~icn of :~e ~e~ein described ~eal ~rcper~y;
NOW ~~ERE::;~ 3E
CRC;'.::~EJ BY
':':-iE
30APD
0~
"r
C~ 0~J~'f
28MMISSIONERS C-
COL~:ER C8U~T~, :~=RI~A;
SECTION ONE:
~he ZO~~~~ C:assi:i~a:~:~
:~e herein Gescr~bea ~ea~ proper~y
_~ca:e8 :~ ~ec~:~~
, c
- ~,
~~wns~:~ ~3 Scut~,
?ange :6 ::a.5:',
_:;.:-.Ller C:::;unty,
:lc-:-ic.a,
::"3 '=:--.a:-:':'ea f::cm "?'_~:11 :: "?r.....S" ?.2..anned '__~,.~,- =e~]e':",J-pment
::..~,......'""' -,..-,.-.;:;~~::-::.
. ------..-- ....._..'-~
.~....... ........::::..---
- ---"-" -...,-.. -,
=.::::.a::::-:eci ;:e:re:::::
::~{:--.:::.:. -:
II'" "
.~. ,
',.;:--.ich
~s l~c~rpora~ea herein and ~~. ~eference made part te:-eo:.
The Official
Zonlng ~t: ,5 Ma? ~umbered 8S:SS, as described in Ordl~ance ~umber 9:-102,
:he '=o~lier :~U~LY Land 8eve:2;~en~ Code, lS jereDY amended accordi~gly.
SECTION T'.vO:
Crdlnance iiuI:\Cer 82-:'::::::, :.;:nown as the Krenling :ndustries POD,
adopted en December 28, 1982 ~v ::~e Eoard of County Corrmissioners of
Collier County, is hereby repealed in its entirety.
SECTION T:-iREE:
This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the
Department of State.
AGENDA ITEM
No. /J (~
MAR 2 3 1999
0lS-
Pi.
" ~ ~ ~~ -
.~;:;:- ~ -: ._-=::
:':,r~ ::::-.::
=-2<;0_ _ ~:::..-=:..'=~.=':
~'1
I: (1 /..... ,,~..ol L- -, )~1 ~ Ld...L.d
. ;::< ..- - ._".- ~ -
..--....._,vJ--'= H' ..::::"..:aer-l"":.
.=-.5 S :.. 52 ~ 3.:--. ::. _ 'J '--.. _ .=-. ':. :: :: .:::-. e
..,.-.~
- ~ "'" ,- ~. ~
-.----..- -
-.<"/-::::--"--~
:::..; [\ = ;-. ;,.-.
= ::"':-.:-.':' ,
_:-.a.:2:::-.al~
AG~A)~
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi.
~Io
PET::::TION N1J:13ER
0;'. TE
. '.
;'.PPLIG..TION FOR PU6LIC ED_'UNG
FOR
PUD 1-.J1ENDMENT / DO l>-,'1E~mMENT
COMMU~ITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION
PL\NNING SERVICES
.;l\;~-
1. Na~e of Applicant(s) Henry W. Krehling, Krehling Industries, Inc.
Applicant's Mailing Address
1425 ~. Wiggins Pass Rd.
city
r:aple s
State
?L
Applicant's Telephone NUGber: Res.:
N/A
Zip ]h110
Bus.: 941-597-3162
Is the applicant the owner of the subject property?
x Yes 110
(a) If applicant is a land tr~st, so indicate and name
beneficiaries below.
x
(b) If applicant is corporation other than a public
corporation, so indicate and nane officers and najor
stockholders below.
(c) If applicant is a partnership, limited partnership
or other business entity, so indicate and name
principals below.
(d) If applicant is an owner, indicate exactly as
recorded, and list all other owners, if any.
(e) If applicant is a lessee, attach copy of lease, and
indicate actual owners if not indicated on the lease.
(f) If applicant is a contract purchaser, attach copy of
cO'ltract, and indicate actual o'....-ner (s) nane and address
be 10'.....' .
Henry W. Krehling, President (only stockholder)
(If space lS inadequate, attach on separate page.)
2 .
Na::'.e of 1-.gent
Karen Bishop
Firw P~s, Inc. of Naples
Agents Mailing Address 2335 Tamiarri Trail North, Ste 408
City Naples
Telephone Number-:~ Re~. :
State
PT, Zip
Bus.: 041_4
34103
1\r/A
,/ / __ ~ n'EM
No.lfl(~1
MAR 2 3 1999
~1
Pi.
peD ORDINA.l;CE E.~~'~E ;'.110 NUMBER:
~:rehling =ndust~ies, =~c.
DETAILED LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF TEE PROPERTY COVERED BY THE
LICATION (If space is inadequate, attach on separate page. If
_ ~uest involves change to more than one zoning district, include
separate legal description for property involved in each district.
If property is odd-shaped, submit five (5) copies cf survey (1'1 to
400 I scale).
.
-
TEE APPLICANT IS RESPONSIBLE FOR SUPPLYING THE CO~~ECT LEGAL
DESCRIPTION. IF QUESTIOnS ARISE CONCERNING THE LEGAL DESCRIPTION,
~~ ENGINEERIS CERTIFICATION SHALL BE REQUIRED.
SECTION
15
TO'riNSHIP
48 South
RANGE 2 S ~asL;
See attacted legal desc~iption
5. Address or location of subject property 1425 Wiggins Pass Rd. E.
Naples. FL
eA. Does property m..;ne:::- o......n contiguous property to the subj ect
property? If so, give complete legal description of entire
contiguous property. (If space is inadequate, attach on
separate page) . See attached legal description.
7 . TYPE OF A!-~ENDMENT:
x A. PUD Docutent Language fu~endnent
x B. PUD ~1aster Plan l-J!'.er.d:ne:1t
C. Develop:nent O:::-der Language fu~endment
8.
DOES ?_~END:.rENT CO~rPLY WITH THE CO:.fPREHENSIVE PLA."l\l':
No If no, explain:
x
Yes
9. P-~S A PUBLIC HE.~..RING BEEN HELD ON THIS PROPERTY WITHIN THE
LAST YEAR? IF SO, IN wnOSE Nl-_"'fl:..? No
PETITION #:
:JjA
DF.TE:
N/A
AGENDA ITEM
No. /~{~)I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pt. ~ 8'
Fe-?
SOLD ;'.~;D / O?
TEE ;.. R E.:'.. SOLD
:"0.
::.:-"'S .:'..~r:t.' PORTIO~: OF TEE PC=:J 3EE~;
DEVELOPED? ARE ~~Y CHANGES P?O?OSEJ
DE~.'ELO?ED?
Yes.
.~.DDITIG~L.;L SHEE:TS I? ~~ECES5;'.::Y).
;'.liD / O?.
z:
~;o .
YES, DESC?I3E:
(.:'..-=-TACH
.,. .........----D'....-:""!'"I
l-.::':" .......-'-1
~e, Krehling Industries, Inc. being fi~s~ duly s~orn,
depose and say that ~e are the o~ners of the property described
herein and ~hich is the subject ~atter of the proposed hearing;
that all the answers to the questions in ~his application, and all
sketches, data, and other supple~ent~ry L~tter attached to and
~ade a part of this application, are honest and true to the best
of our knowledge and belief. ~e understand this application Dust
be conpleted and accurate before a hearing can be advertised. We
further perr.it the undersigned to act as our representative in any
~atters regarding this Pe~i~ion.
!'~.SD.:'.:=-OR-.:.' .
State of Flo~ida
20unty of Collier
S
'--
The fo~egoing _.
27M day of ///'47"
is cersonally kno~n ~o ~e
ii"v~~/J/: i?~
ta}:e an oath.
this
, '..;ho
(did not)
!;OT ;..~y :P:J3LI C
co:-:-.:-:-.ission ;::
!.;y CO::1:-:-.ission
Expires:
OFFiCIAr.. 1':c:T::n SF..!,Ci
!NOT AF;'{ :~~~tt. F'~_>;"~ ::'~'~;_';' ':r,:,-".l
lj ::':":.. . . -. ; :.. c'.::. ,.:,'~ : ;
!\fY C:.J!\r.. U~~~....~_:~-~..:.:..L\~~-~' ~ '2:~~J
PUD\DO APPLICATION/sd/4128
AGENDA ITEM
No. la [fiJ!
MAR 2 3 1999
atj
Pi.
.5
PROPERTY OWNERSHIP & LEGAL DESCRIPTION
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
The subject property is described as:
All that part of Section 15, Township 48 South, Ran;:;e 25 East, Collier County,
Florida, being described as follows:
All that part of the north ;'2 of the northwest v.. of t:le southeast v.. of said Section 15
and all that parr of the north 280.0 feet of the south Y'2 of the northwest:;" of the
southeast /.. of said Section 15 lying east of the west right-of-way line of the former
Seaboard Coast Line Railroad right-of-way; said parcel being also described as
follows:
Commencing at the center of said Section 15; thence along the east and west v.. line
of said Section 15, South 890-54'-18" East, 561.94 feet to the west line of the former
Seaboard Coast Line Railroad right-of-way and the POINT OF BEGINNING of the
parcel herein described;
thence continuing along said east and west v.. line, South 890-54'-18" East
706.49 feet to the northeast corner of the northwest v.. of the southeast v.. of said
Section 15;
thence along the east line of the northwest Y. of the southeast :,~ of said Section
15, South 00-40'-39" East 951.13 feet to the southeast corner of the North
280.00 feet of the south Y'2 of the northwest Y. of the southeast Y. of said Section
15;
thence along the south line of the North 280.00 feet of the south ;/2 of the
northwest % of the southeast % of said Section 15, North 890-55'-31" West
684.19 feet to the west right-of-way line of the former Seaboard Coast Line
Railroad right-of-way;
thence along said west right-of-way line, northerly 952.02 feet along the arc of a
nontangential circular curve o ,'1 cave to the east, having a radius of 22,983.3 feet,
subtended by a chord which bears North 20-01 '-11" West 951.93 feet;
being a part of the northwest 1 /4 of Section 15, Township 48 South, Range 25 East,
Collier County, Florida; subject to easements and restrictions of record; containing
15.26 acres more or less; bearings are assumed north based on the north and
south 1/4 line of Section 15, being North 0'-44'-02" West.
'-.
AGiA{~1
No. a
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 3D
[!:{[~iE[1JfsjC0@ [fP~~~~[~u~;J u ~ ;~({J~7J[FJ
[f8~fJJ~ fP~({JJ[fP~~uW ~~~~ffBO[fPuO(Q)fM
ALL OF THE WEST HALF (W 1/2) OF THE NORTHEAST QUARTER (NE 1/4) OF
SECTION 15. TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH. RANGE 25 EAST. COLLIER COUNTY, LYING
EAST OF THE ATLANTIC COAST LINE RAILROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY, EXCEPTING
THE NORTH 2.337 FEET THEREOF AND SUBJECT TO A 30 FOOT ROAD EASEMENT
ON THE SOUTH AND EAST THEREOF.
AGENDA ITEM
No.J;;! L e')t
MAR 2 3 1999
Pt..~
,,"-
~(!'fiI r~ il!7;7 f1 ;70ll~ .(3 /G;,n /rg /;: /0) 0\"1 11:1' 'frli itNli'l1JL/f; 1r;1d1 fifW/ ;;;.@err
_' '...:..:...' :..J' ~u UL!:::=UL./ \~j ~ Lr- UU ~u L:=JLII] i.../!...." w ~ U \:.} ~ I ~ 0 LJL' tj:; LSC9) U
~~~~~~~~~~TrW@~~~~~~~~
THE WEST 1/2 OF THE NORTHEAST 1/4 OF SECTION 15, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH,
RANGE 25 EAST, LYING WEST OF ATLANTIC COAST LINE RIGHT-OF-WAY, LESS
THE NORTH 2,030 FEET, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
~
AGENDA ITEM
No. jJ. (13) I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 3~
;/7!@,'Sr 7(1 J7,GVl/8 '9!if%Y'FisFS@;r\f '-;/?T; !JM!/l(S@CJ?
_('\~ u u,l '- u L; Lb u U \..J \.Sj '.-' L J '2/ u --'= ULJ U L udJ b i!J is ~ U
/R? r:~ /;?\i /7
U u is 0cJ L'::=J
~~~~~~uW~~~~~~~@~
THE NORTH 1/2 OF THE NORTHWEST 1/4 OF THE SOUTHEAST
1/4 OF SECTION 15, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
AND
THE NORTHERLY 280.00 FEET OF THE SOUTH 1/2 OF THE
NORTHWEST 1/4 OF THE SOUTHEAST 1/4 OF SECTION 15,
TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA.
AGENDA ITEM
No. );). L ty 1
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 33
..,
'=':?CINP.~N~=::::
4
5
.;N O?DINANCE JI.['lENDING CFDINp.:KE :::":;HBEF
9~-l02, THE C8LL=ER C8UKTY L~ND =EVELO?MS~JT
CODE, WHICH INCL0DES THS CCH~FEHENSIVE
ZONING REGULATIONS FOR iHE: UENCCRPORATED
AREA OF COLLISR COUKT:, F:ORISA, ~y
AMENDING TnE OFFICIAL ZONING ATLAS MAP
NUMBERED 8515S BY CHANGING ~HE ZONING
CLASSIFICATION OF THS HEREIN DESCRIBED REAL
PROPERTY FROt--l "PUD" TO "PUD" PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENT KNOWN AS KREnLING INDUSTRIES
PUD, FOR PROPERTY LOCATED SOUTHEAST OF THE
INTERSECTION OF U.S. 41 AND OLD U.S. ~1, ~
MILE EAST OF U.S. 41 AT THE EASTERN
TERMINUS OF WIGGINS PASS ROAD, IN SECTION
15, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONSISTING OF
15.26+ ACRES; PROVIDING FOR THE REPEA~ OF
ORDINANCE NUMBER 82-120, THE FORMER
KREHLING INDUSTRIES PUD; AND BY PROVIDING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27 WHEREAS, Karen Bishop 0: PMS, Inc., of Naples, representing Henry
28 Krehling, petitioned the Board of County Commissioners to change the
29 zoning classification of ~he herein described real property;
30 NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
31 COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA;
32 SECTION ONE:
33 The Zoning Classification of the hereln described real property
34 located in Section 15, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County,
35 Florlda, is Changed from "PUD" to "PUD" Planned Unit Development in
36 accoraance wlth the PUD Document, attached hereto a~ Exhibit "A", which
37 is incorporated herein and by reference made par~ hereof. The Official
38 Zoning Atlas Map numbered 85155, as (=scribed in Ordinance Number 91-102,
39 the Collier County Land Development Code, lS hereby amended accordingly.
40 SECTION TWO:
41 Ordinance Number 82-120, known as the Krehling Industries PUD,
42. adopted on December 28, 1982 by the Board of County Commissioners of
43 Collier County, is hereby repealed in its entirety.
I
44 SECTION THREE:
45 This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the
~,
46 Department of State.
A~A}~ I
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
p&.34
-1-
=~8IT,~ssic~e~s 8f
"' :=c:ll:..er ::::::cunty, :-=..cr:.ci2., th:..s
;~S22D ~~= __~_ ~=~F~E: =".- -~Q =~~~~
::2Y -""'-=
:":.998.
3
4 }'..TTEST:
5 DWIGHT ~. BROe?, =le~k
6
7
8
9
10
II
12 .A.pproved as ~o ro:-m and
13 Legal Sufficiency
14
15
16){\~~" J/1 ~lu~
17 Mar] c e 1-1. Stuaem:
18 Assistant County Attorney
]9
20
21 ~,FeD-8:-lE
22
23
SCARe OF CJUNTY COMMISSIONERS
=~~~=~~ C8~NTY, :LORIDA
:::; \' .
3ARBARA ~. S~RRY, Chairman
AGENDA I~ .....,
No. 1J.[8
MAR 2 3 1999
-2 -
Pi. 3S-
DATE REVIEWED BY CCPC 12-03-98
DATE APPROVED BY BCC
ORDINANCE NUMBER
AMENDMENTS AND REPEAL
KREHLING INDUSTRIES
A
PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT
REGULATIONS AND SUPPORTING MASTER PLAN
GOVERNING THE KREHLlNG INDUSTRIES A PLANNED
UNIT DEVELOPMENT PURSUANT TO PROVISIONS OF
THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
-
PREPARED FOR:
HENRY W. KREHLlNG
PREPARED BY:
VANASSE & DAYLOR
8270 COLLEGE PARKWAY, SUITE 205
FT. MYERS FLORIDA 33919
~\EC~~V\ED
~~1 ' 'i ~9~~
---------------
IY -. '-t
P ~ D 8 2 - : "'~ /
Exhibit A
AGENDA ITEM
No. la /fi,) L
MAR 2 3 1999
pc. 3 (p
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
LIST OF EXHIBITS
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE 1
SECTION I PROPERTY OWNERSHIP AND LEGA' '"'ESCRIPTION 3
SECTION II PROJECT DEVELOPMENT REQUIREMENTS 5
SECTION III INDUSTRIAL / COMMERCIAL DISTRICT 8
SECTION IV PRESERVE DISTRICT 13
SECTION V GENERAL DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS 15
AGENDA I~
No. la if) I
MAR 2 3 1999
P,. "7
EXHIBIT A
EXHIBIT B
EXHIBIT C
.", ;
"--.
.'-"
LIST OF EXHIBITS
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
LOCATION MAP
PUD MASTER PLAN
AGENOA.I~
No. I;;"{ 1
MAR 2 3 1999
pc. 3g
EXHIBIT A
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
The subject property is approximately 15.26 acres, and is located in Section 15,
Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. The development of this
property as a Planned Unit Development, known as Krehling Industries Inc., will be in
compliance with the planning goals and objectives of Collier County as set forth in the
Growth Management Plan. The commercial and light industrial development will be
consistent with the growth policies, land development regulations, and applicable
comprehensive planning objective or each of the elements of the Growth Management
Plan for the following reasons:
1. The subject property is within the Urban Residential Land Use designation as
identified on the Future Land Use Map as required in Objective 1, Policy 5.1 and
Policy 5.3 of the Future Land Use Element.
2. All improvements will be in compliance with all applicable regulations.
3. The project development will result in an efficient and economical extension of
community facilities and services, as required in Policies 3.1.H and L of the
Future Land Use Element.
4. The commercial and industrial facilities shall be designed to be compatible and
compliment to existing and future surrounding land uses as required in Policy
5.4 of the Future Land Use Element..
5. A complete range of services and utilities as approved by the County will serve
the project.
6. Because an exemption was granted to Kreh1ing PUD through the Zoning
Reevaluation Program, the PUD is deemed consistent with the Future Land Use
Element Policy 5.10.
7. Policies 5.1, 5.9, 5.10 and 5.11 of the Future Land Use Element address non-
conforming zonings (non-conforming existing zonings are defined as those not
being consistent with the locational or density criteria identified by the FLUE).
Krehling PUD Final Draft
Policy 5.1 allows certain PUDs to be modified without being consistent with the
locational or density criteria of the Future Land Use Element. Under this policy,
a PUD is not allowed to increase the approved density or intensity of use. The
Krehling PUD is consistent based on the fact that it was granted an ex ~~A)~~
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
pc. 3t
- 1 -
through the Zoning Reevaluation Program under this policy and is not increasing
intensity previously approved in the zoning.
Policy 5.9 allows non-conforming uses to further develop or redevelop in
accordance with the zoning on the property at the time of the development or
redevelopment. The Board of County Commissioners has clearly acknowledged
this situation in previous zoning cases such as the Krehling PUD.
Policies 5.10 and 5.11 acknowledge properties that are granted an Exemption or
a Compatibility Exemption through the Zoning Reevaluation Ordinance and are
thereby deemed consistent with the Future Land Use Element due to these
exemptions. Both of these policies relate back to Policy 5.1. These policies do
not require that non-conforming zonings be eliminated, but allow them to
develop under their existing approvals.
8. An Exemption has been granted for the Krehling PUD which precluded the
County from rezoning the property via the authorization provided by the Zoning
Reevaluation Ordinance and the Future Land Use Element Policy 3.1 k.
--
AGEN>A ITEM
No. 1<<'(6)'
MAR 2 3 199~
Pi. L/ ()
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 2 -
SECTION I
PROPERTY OWNERSHIP & LEGAL DESCRIPTION
1.1. PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to set forth the location and ownership of the
property, and to describe the existing conditions of the property proposed for
development under the name of Krehling Industries, Inc.
1.2. LEGAL DESCRIPTION
A parcel of land located in Section 15, Township 48 South, Range 25 East
Collier County, Florida, being more particularly described as follows:
All that part of the north "Yz of the northwest % of the southeast % of said
Section 15 and all that part of the north 280.0 feet of the south "Yz of the
northwest % of the southeast % of said Section 'i 5 lying east of the west right-
of-way line of the former Seaboard Coast Line Railroad right-of-way; said
parcel being also described as follows:
Commencing at the center of said Section 15; thence along the east and west
% line of said Section 15, South 890_54'_18" East, 561.94 feet to the west line
of the former Seaboard Coast Line Railroad right-of-way and the POINT OF
BEGINNING of the parcel herein described;
thence continuing along said east and west % line, South 890-54'-18"
East 706.49 feet to the northeast corner of the northwest % of the
southeast % of said Section 15; thence along the east line of the
northwest % of the southeast % of said Section 15, South 00-40'-39" East
951.13 teet to the southeast corner of the North 280.00 feet of the south
"Yz of the northwest % of the southeast % of said Section 15; thence along
the south line of the North 280.00 feet of the south "Yz of the northwest %
of the ~Joutheast % of said Section 15, North 890-55'-31" West 684.19 feet
to the west right-of-way line of the former Seaboard Coast Line Railroad
right-of-way;
thence along said west right-of-way line, northerly 952.02 feet along the
arc of a nontangential circular curve oncave to the east, having a radius
of 22,983.3 feet, subtended by a chord which bears North 20_01'_11"
West 951.93 feet; being a part of the northwest 1/4 of Section 15,
Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; subject to
easements and restrictions of record; containing 15.26 acres more or
less; bearings are assumed north based on the north and south 1/4 line of
Section 15, being North 00-44'-02" West
AGENDA I~
No. IA (t3) I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. J../ I
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 3 -
.-
1.3. PROPERTY OWNERSHIP
The subject property is currently under the ownership of Henry W. Krehling
of Krehling Industries, 1425 East Wiggins Pass Road, Naples, Florida.
1.4. GENERAL PROPERTY DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY AREA
A. The property is located in the north % of the northwest ~ of the
southeast ~ of Section 15 and all of the 280 feet of the south % of the
northwest ~ of the southeast ~ of Section 15 lying east of the west
right-of-way line of the former Seaboard Coast Line Railroad right-of-
way. The property is generally located south and east of the
intersection of new US 41 and old US 41, approximately % mile east of
new US 41 at the eastern terminus of Wiggins Pass Road.
B. The subject property is currently vacant but it is sometimes used for
temporary storeage of some minor amounts of finished concrete
products. The existing zoning classification of the property is PUD.
1.5. PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION
The site is located at the east terminus of Wiggins Pass Road and is
surrounded by existing development: Imperial Golf Club to the east and
south; the Krehling Concrete Batch Plant to the west; and disturbed
agricultural/and to the north. The site itself is disturbed.
Elevations within the site range from 7.5 t015.3 feet above mean sea level.
Most of the site, however, falls within the 10.0 to 12.0 feet elevation
category. The entire site is located within Flood Zone AE according to
FIRM Map 120067 0191 D.
1.6. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The Krehling PUD will be a specialized light-industrial development in
association with commercial! retail. As a part of the current business
operations of Krehling Industries, Inc., the light-industrial facilities will be
used to support concrete specialty products, stockpiling, and storage of
finished products. In association with the industrial uses, ttle principal
commercial facilities will generally consist of warehousing, office (retail or
professional), building supplies and enclosed storage.
1.7. SHORT TITLE
Krehling PUD Final Draft
This Ordinance shall be known and cited as the "Krehling Industri I~ . ITEM
Unit Development Ordinance." No. IDi{~)1
MAR 2 3 1999
p,. J../ ~
- 4 -
,,--.
SECTION II
PROJECT DEVELOPMENT REQUIREMENTS
2.1. PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to delineate and describe the project plan of
development, relationships to applicable County ordinances, the respective
land uses of the tracts included in the project, as well as other project
relationships.
This planned unit of development shall be limited to specific industrial uses
which are compatible and inter-related to the business operations of
Krehling's concrete division for concrete specialty products as well as
office/retail services. Therefore, it is the inte'")f the developer to use the
industrial areas of the site to stockpile and S',; finished concrete materials
on-site along with the storage of the finished products of the adjacent
concrete plant.
2.2. GENERAL
A Regulations for development of the Krehling PUD shall be in accordance
with the contents of this document, PUD-Planned Unit Development
District and other applicable sections and parts of the Collier County Land
Development Code and Growth Management Plan in effect at the time of
building permit application. Where these regulations fail to provide
development standards then the provisions of the most similar district in
the County Land Development Code shall apply.
B. Unless otherwise noted, the definitions of all terms shall be the same as
the definitions set forth in the Collier County Land Development Code in
effect at the time of building permit application.
C. Development permitted by the approval of this petition will be subject to a
concurrency review under the provisions of Division 3.15 Adequate Public
Facilities at the earliest or next to occur of either final SOP, final plat
approval, or building permit issuance applicable to this development.
2.3. DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT PLAN AND PROPOSED LAND USES
A The project Master Plan is illustrated graphically on Exhibit "2", PUD
Master Development Plan.
B. Minor modifications to Exhibit "2" may be permitted at the time of ~ ~GENOAIIDI
Development Plan approval, subject to the provisions of Section .7.~ of I~lf>),
- 5 -
MAR 2 3 1999
~
PI.
Krehling PUD Final Draft
.-
2.4.
--..
the Collier County Land Development Code or as otherwise permitted by
this PUD document.
LAND USE
A. Exhibit "A", PUD Master Plan, constitutes the required PUD
Development Plan. Except as otherwise provided within this PUD
document, any division of the property and the development of the land
shall be in compliance with the Land Development Code and the
platting laws of the State of Florida.
8. The provisions of Division 3.3, Site Development Plans of the Land
Development Code, when applicable, shall apply to the development of
all platted tracts, or parcels of land as provided in said Division 3.3 prior
to the issuance of a building permit or other development order.
C. Appropriate instruments will be provided at the time of infrastructure
improvements regarding any dedications and the methodology for
providiri"g'perpetual maintenance of common facilities.
D. The following land uses and acreage amounts are proposed for the
project and are illustrated on Exhibit "A" the Master Development Plan:
LAND USE TYPE
ACREAGE
TRACT "A" - Industrial/Commercial... .., ... ... ... ... ... ... +/- 12.26 Acres
TRACT "8"- Cypress Preserve............... ............... +/- 3.00 Acres
TOTAL +/- 15.26 Acres
(Exact acreages to be determined during permitting)
2.5. AMENDMENTS TO PUD DOCUMENTS OR MASTER PLAN
Arr.andments may be made to the PUD as provided in Section 2.7.3.5 of the
Collier County Land Development Code.
2.6. LIMITATIONS OF PUD APPROVAL
This PUD is subject to the sunsetting provisions as provided for within
Section 2.7.3.4 of the Collier County Land Development Code.
2.7. PUD MONITORING
An annual Monitoring report shall be submitted pursuant to Section
the Collier County Land Development Code.
A ITEM
No. I~ l ii::) I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. t..J 4
Kreh/ing PUD Final Draft
- 6 -
2.8 OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS
A minimum of thirty percent (30%) of the project's gross area shall be
devoted to open space, pursuant to Section 2.6.32 of the Collier County Land
Development Code. The total project is 15.26 +/- acres requiring a minimum
of 4.58 acres to be retained as open space throughout the Krehling
Industries PUD.
~G~2~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 4S-
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 7 -
SECTION III
INDUSTRIAL I COMMERCIAL DISTRICT
.u. PURPOSE
The purpose of this section is to identify permitted uses and development
standards for areas within the Krehling PUD designated on Exhibit "A", PUD
Master Plan as Tract "A" - Industrial/Commercial.
3.2 GENERAL DESCRIPTION
A. Areas designated as "Industrial/Commercial" on the PUD Master Plan
are designed to accommodate light manufacturing, assembling,
processing, packaging, storage, warehousing, retailing and distribution of
concrete specialty products, office / retail, aluminum fabricators, cabinet
shops. dry good stores, freight movers, hardware stores, lawn
maintenance shops, paint and wallpaper stores, radio / television stations,
warehousing, tile sales and other similar uses.
8. Actual acreage of all development tracts will be provided at the time of
Site Development Plan approval in accordance with Division 3.3 of the
Land Development Code.
3.3. TRACT "A": COMMERCIAL I LIGHT INDUSTRIAL
A. Permitted Uses and Structures:
No building or structures, or part thereof, shall be erected, altered or used,
or land or water used, in whole or part, for other then the following:
1. Permitted Principal Uses and Structures:
a) Wholesale Trade (Groups 5039 and 5051).
b) Concrete Work (Groups 1771).
-
c) Hardware stores (Groups 5072, 5251).
AGENDA I~
No. I~LB
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. '-I to
Krehling PUD Final DraftA.doc
- 8 -
d) Light manufacturing or processing (Groups 3411 - 3479,3491 -
3499); packing or fabricating in completely enclosed building
(Groups 4783, 3491 - 3499).
e) Industrial warehousing; wholesale, storage, or distributing
establishments and similar uses (Group 4225).
f) Material and equipment storage yards, storage for finished
concrete products, outdoor storage yards and lots, provided such
outdoor yard shall not be closer than twenty-five (25) feet to any
public street (Group 4226 except oil. gasoline and petroleum
products ).
g) Miscellaneous uses such as truck or other transportation terminal
and related uses (Groups 4214 -4215).
h) Office/retail, professional, general (Groups 7311 - 7389).
i) Radio and television stations and transmitters (Groups 4832 -
4833).
j) Repairs for heavy machinery and equipment (Groups 3569, 3568,
3537.3531), and similar uses.
k) Tile sales - ceramic tile (Groups 1743, 5211).
I) Any other Industrial/Commercial use or professional service which
is comparable in nature with the foregoing uses and which the
Current Planning Manager determines to be compatible in the
district.
2. Permitted Accessory Uses and Structures:
a) Any accessory uses and/or structures, which are incidental to and
customarily associated with uses permitted in this section.
b) Caretaker's residence.
AGENDA I~
No. Ii. [8)/
MAR 2 3 1999
P&. J-f.1
Krehling PUD Final DraftA.doc
- 9 -
3. Permitted Conditional Uses:
a) Detached residence in conjunction with business - one (1) per
business.
B. Minimum Lot Area: Seven thousand-five hundred (7,500) square feet.
C. Minimum Lot Width: Seventy-five (75) feet.
D. Minimum Property Perimeter Setbacks:
1. North: Thirty (30) feet
2. South: Fifty (50) feet.
3. East: Twenty (20) feet
4. West: Zero (0) feet
E. Minimum Internal Property Setbacks (if subdivided):
1. Front Yard Twenty-five (25) feet
2. Side Yard Ten (10) feet
3. Rear Yard Fifteen (15) feet
4. Waterfront Twent-five (25) feet
5. Railroad ROW No setback required
6. Yard Abutting
Residential Parcel Fifty (50) feet
F. Limitations and Setbacks for Development Adjacent to the Northern
Property Boundary
Development within fifty (50) feet of the required setback of the northern
property boundary of the site shall be limited to commercial type of land
uses. Any type of outdoor storage shall not be permitted with fifty (50) feet
from the required setback of the northern property boundary or in
association with a structure or use within fifty (50) feet from the required
setback of the northern property boundary. Should the property north of the
site's northern property boundary be approved by the Board of County
Commissioners for any use other than for residential, this setback and
outdoor storage limitation as it applies to structures adjacent to the northern
property boundary shall no longer apply.
G. Maximum Height of Structures: Fifty (50) feet. The maximum height of
structures located adjacent to the northern property boundary shall be
limited to thirty-five (35) feet, a minimum of fifty (50) feet from the required
setback from the northern property boundary. Should the property north of
the site's northern property boundary be approved by the Board of County
Commissioners for any use other than for residential, this height ,. I . A ITEM
~~
- 10-
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 4g
Krehling PUD Final Draft
as it applies to structures adjacent to the northern property boundary shall
no longer apply.
H. Minimum Floor Area of Principal Structure: Eight hundred (800) square
feet.
I. Internal Setbacks:
1. Building separation:
2. Service drive:
Ten (10) feet or ~ sum of the heights,
whichever is greater
Five (5) feet
J. Minimum Off-Street Parking and Off-Street Loading: As required by
Division 2.3 of the Land Development Code in effect at time of application
for building permit.
K. Minimum Residential Setbacks: There sr' be a minimum of 50-foot
building setback from any residentially usee.. zoned land.
AGENDA I~
No. fa (enl
MAR 2 3 1999
IJ9
Pi.
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 11 -
SECTION IV
PRESERVE DISTRICT
4.1. PURPOSE
The purpose of this section is to identify permitted uses and development
standards for areas within the Krehling PUD designated on Exhibit "A", PUD
Master Plan as TRACT UB" - Cypress Preserve.
4.2. GENERAL DESCRIPTION
Areas designated Preserve on the PUD Master Plan are designed to
accommodate a full range of conservation and preservation functions. The
primary purpose of this District is to retain viable naturally functioning wetland
systems, to allow for the restoration and enhancement of impacted or degraded
wetland systems,'& and cleansing and to provide open space for the
development. The exact acreage of the perserve shall be determined during the
pemitting of the site.
4.3. TRACT liB" PRESERVE
A. Permitted Uses and Structures:
No building or structure, or part thereof, shall be erected, altered or used, or
land or water used, in whole or part, for other than the following:
1. Permitted Uses and Structures:
Boardwalks, viewing platforms, stormwater management structures
necessary for the establishment of an appropriate hydroperiod for the
conservation area and the like.
B. Treatment I General Use:
The treatment of this area shall be for the preservation and conservation of
the native flora and fauna found within the subject area. Retention of the
vegetation shall meet the requirements shown in Section 3.9.5.5 of the LDC
and shall be preserved in its entirety with all trees, understory and ground
cover left intact and undisturbed, except for prohibited exotic species
removal.
AGMtfl
No.
- 12 -
MAR 2 3 1999
So
pc.
Krehling PUD Final Draft
C. Maintenance and Monitoring
An exotic vegetation removal, monitoring and maintenance (exotic-free) plan
for the site, with emphasis on the conservation I preservation area, shall be
submitted to the Current Planning Environmental Staff for review and
approval prior to Final Site Plan I Construction Plan approvals.
4.4. PRESERVE DISTRICT CONSERVATION EASEMENT
A non-exclusive conservation easement or tract is required by the Collier County
Land Development Code, Section 3.2.8.4.7.3 for preservation lands included in
the Preserve District. In addition to Collier County, a conservation easement
may also be required by other regulatory agencies with jurisdiction over
Preserve District lands. Furthermore, in addition to complying with provisions of
the Collier County Land Development Code, easements shall be provided in
accordance with the terms set forth in the applicable permit granted by the
permitting agencies. Krehling Industries, Inc. shall be responsible for control
and maintenance of the lands within the Preserve District.
A~ll~
No. 8
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. S/
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 13 -
SECTION V
GENERAL DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS
5.1. PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to set forth the development commitments for the
development of the project.
5.2. GENERAL
All facilities shall be constructed in strict accordance with Final Site
Development Plans, Final Subdivision Plats and all applicable State and local
laws, codes, and regulations applicable to this PUD. Except where specifically
noted or stated otherwise, the standards and specifications of the Land
Development Code of Division 3.2 shall apply to this project even if the land
within the PUD is not to be platted. The developer, his successors and assigns,
shall be responsible for the commitments outlined in this document.
5.3. PUD MASTER PLAN
A Exhibit "A", the PUD Master Plan, illustrates the proposed development and
is conceptual in nature. Proposed tract, lot or land use boundaries or special
land use boundaries shall not be construed to be final and may be varied at
any subsequent approval phase such as final platting or site development
plan application. Subject to the provisions of Section 2.7.3.5 of the Land
Development Code, amendments may be made from time to time.
8. All necessary easements, dedications, or other instruments shall be granted
to insure the continued operation and maintenance of all service utilities and
all common areas.
C. Minor design changes shall be permitted subject to staff approval.
D. Overall site design shall be harmonious in terms of landscaping, enclosure of
structures, locations of all improved facilities, and location and treatment of
buffer areas.
E. To protect the integrity of the Planned Unit Development, the only access
road shall be the private roads as shown on the Master Plan.
-...
AG~A !l!{' .
No.~
. 14.
MAR 2 3 1999
~~
Pl.
Krehling PUD Final Draft
5.4. UTILITIES
Water distribution, sewage collection and transmission facilities to serve the
project are to be designed, constructed, conveyed, owned and maintained in
accordance with Collier County Ordinance 97-17, as amended, and other
applicable County rules and regulations.
5.5. ENGINEERING
A. Except as otherwise provided within this PUD document, this project shall be
required to meet all County Ordinances in effect at the time final construction
documents are submitted for development approval.
B. If the property is subdivided into three (3) or more parcels, a plat shall be
required.
5.6. ENVIRONMENTAL
A. Environmental permitting shall be in accordance with the State of Florida
Environmental Resource Permit Rules and be subject to review and approval
by Current Planning Environmental Staff.
B. Buffers shall be provided around wetlands, extending at least fifteen (15) feet
landward from the edge of wetland preserves in all places and averaging
twenty-five (25) feet from the landward edge of wetlands. Where natural
buffers are not possible, structural buffers shall be provided in accordance
with the State of Florida Environmental Resources Permit Rules and be
subject to review and approved by Current Planning Environmental Staff. An
approved structural buffer shall be constructed along the entire western edge
of the preserve, to provide a required buffer from the impacts of the site. This
may be modified as appropriate during the environmental permitting process
(ERP). That construction shall be completed no later than 180 days from the
approval of PUD-82-16 (1).
C. No protected wildlife species are anticipated on-site. However, if protected
species are observed on site, a Habitat Management Plan for those
protected species shall be submitted to Current Planning Environmental Staff
for review and approval prior to Final Site Plan/Construction Plan approval.
D. An exotic vegetation removal, monitoring, and maintenance (exotic-free) plan
for the site, with emphasis on the conservation/preservation areas, shall be
submitted to Current Planning Environmental Staff for review within 90 days
of approval of this PUD amendment. The plan shall contain appropriate
scheduling commitments for the initial exotic removal activities a A~AJ~
No.~
- 15 -
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 63
Krehling PUD Final Draft
removal shall be completed no later than 180 days from approval of PUD-82-
16(1).
E. The project shall comply with the environmental sections of the LDC and the
Growth Management Plan in effect at the time of final development order
approval.
F. A conservation easement shall be placed over the jurisdictional wetland on
the site, providing protective covenants per or similar to Florida Statutes
704.06, within 180 days of approval of PUD-82-16 (1). This may be modified
as appropriate during the environmental permitting process (ERP).
5.7. WATER MANAGEMENT
A. Excavation permits will be required for any proposed lakes in accordance
with Division 3.5 of the Collier County Land Development Code, as amended.
B. Excavated material from the property is intended to be used within the project
site.
C. Detailed paving, grading and site drainage plans shall be submitted to
Engineering Review Services for review.
D. No construction permits shall be issued unless and until approval of the
proposed construction in accordance with the submitted plans is granted by
Engineering Review Services and the South Florida Water Management
District.
E. In accordance with the Rules of the South Florida Water Management
District (SFWMD), Chapters 40E-4 and 40E-40, this project shall be
designed for a storm event of 3-day duration and 25-year frequency.
F. The storm'.v'ater management system shall also include a positive drainage
outfall.
G. Design and construction of all improvements shall be subject to compliance
with the appropriate provisions of Divisions 3.2 of the Collier County Land
Development Code
5.8. TRANSPORTATION
A. The developer shall pay appropriate impact fees in accordance with the
schedule in effect at the time the building permits are acquired.
.-
AGENDA I~ .
No. I~ ~
MAR 2 3 1999
pt. 51
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 16 -
B. FOOT Driveway Permits will be submitted. as appropriate. with Site Plan
submittals.
C. Prior to the issuance of any other development order, the developer shall
complete an intersection analysis of the U.S. 41 and Wiggins Pass Road
intersection. This intersection analysis shall be submitted to the State
Department of Transportation for review, comment and approval. Any
required improvements shall be the responsibility of the developer. The
timing for any required improvement(s) shall be such that it is in place prior to
the issuance of any certificate of occupancy for a structure in association with
a use which triggers the required improvement.
5.9. INTERNAL ROADWAY/SERVICE DRIVE CONSTRUCTION
All internal roadways within the limits of the PUfl shall be private roadways and
shall be maintained by the owner. However, ~ roadways shall be constructed
to meet County standards.
5.10. LANDSCAPE / BUFFER AREAS
Prior to the issuance of any project certificates of occupancy, the developer
shall:
A. Comply with all applicable Land Development Code regulations for
required landscaping;
B. Construct a concrete wall up to 10 feet in height or construct a berm and
plant appropriate native vegetation on the berm. In either event the wall
or berm (or combination of the the two) shall be located on the southern
property line and is intended to serve as a visual buffer from adjacent
residential uses.
C. The landscape buffering along the northern property boundary shall
consist of a twenty (20) foot wirle buffer area planted with trees spaced no
more than 25 feet on center, c-nd a hedge of at least 24 inches in height
and attaining a minimum height of three feet in height within one year
shall be required. Should the property north of the site's northern
property boundary be approved by the Board of County Commissioners
for any use other than for residential, this additional landscape buffer
requirement shall no longer apply and landscaping shall be consistent
with the requirements of the Land Development Code in effect at the time
of Site Development Plan approval.
5.11. HISTORIC PRESERVATION REVIEW
AGENDA ITEM
No. J~ (EJ!-
MAR 2 3 1999
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 17 -
--
Pi. 5:';)
Pursuant to Section 2.2.25.8.1. of the LDC. if, during the course of site clearing,
excavation or other construction activity, an histroric or archaeological artifact is
found, all development within the minimum area necessary to protect the
discovery shall be immediately stopped and the Collier County Code
Enforcement Department contacted.
..". ;
_.
AGENDA ~
No. fiX (fJ)/
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 6 tp
Krehling PUD Final Draft
- 18 -
I
\
I
,
I
I
":--,
'-'''''''' ""<',''''
" ,,' "
, ""', '" ',~
"", ',''-::",
" '" " ""', <...
",,',. ,,'. ,"'.; '. .~.
',,, ',. '" <~ -", ~
, ""'". < '.' "', < .',....
, "" ~', "" '" ,'. '.., ....,....
" '" ", ~'(I)" "., , ' ,', " ", . ....
".'" '" ,"-'''-_,',-,' - ~- 't
',' ' ~ '" '''.'",' ".' , 'cD ,.....,
'.." , ' L.", '.. ,,'..'.0'0)'
; OJ ~ ~ ,"0).. c' ~,s C'" "~
..~,', ~':: ""~, ;(6 '::..2 "'~'.. ~-a. .~\
, ""W' "..:> '..~ ,,~,,~~ '
''''0' ~~' "-' ~~'.. '.., -1
".",,<tS~ ~~.' ,~< '~E ~ "'<:}
" ~ "f/'J . "CD '..co ~t:-, "'" '.f
. '~. ,',~,. "" 0 ''4'V "".";';"'" +:!'t,CI) " ,
. ....'" ~ .u... ',,""" 'U'-4>>" 0.', '1
:" , ' '.""CP' .J.!},' .,' ',", ,CO..... ',,','
"....,"'" ,L..., ~', '. ',', " 'X'G)",;
~' ,'" ., '.., "W 'C
, ',~. ~" ",.". '-. .'-~ '.;
. "~" '. .,', .
,.', '" ''0 '. < '" ,'. -,,~.,
<"'< ",":/~
..,... - ~.'....- .....~~
I
I
I
I
\
I
\
I
\
I
:JA A
: ~<<@0 ~
I ~ [J 0
(~\ Li--D?..9n9~OG:E~~~~m-:-
; ~'
- '
~ ~ ,
Ii'
.
r-
l' f
- ,---l
~ ti
~ ~
G II
en (/)
b b
ci ci
IN III
N
....,
.,-j
.0
.~
.c
:><:
w
iii
E
III
::l
'Q
.E
CO
E
E
~
en
CD
U)
:::>
"0
c:
co
....J
1:
g.
o::! u
.,C
C1..!.
I! +
0"
- I'C
f!2 .
_I'C
Ill....
-e;.:..
~C
E t;
8E.
-,
-
:. _"",.s...~.. ...
:~~c.~~'-~~~:;;~~ .:s.~'..:c;~c:; ~~:;~~~~~.;~ ~
-- ~ --
....:: ......1~. :..-.;...... ---.-.------
.=-.,: ..,;-:;:; 7... w --:::E:.:-~:~"'1,r . '. ~
r~-..~_,".~... ~--,' ~. .. ~ '"
_~N~~"'-'~ ~r
....."'l_
~...~~ t."""_
';.i,;:y
...----
~~::=::.. -::::
___... ie': f
c -
o ~
~g~ \
- II E ...
~5l'& "
~
... !! 0
j:l .g \ "
"-
E 1j ::l ~
.s~~ ~ !
en......c ~ 8~ i
.0 . g . co .--
Cl~" .. c%.. \
~~c; ., ~: .
i+'Q I'C
'"'.! .,; a. .
... 0 ' i
11..;.:.. ~ I
111I
et; 1 :;
o.t! r7
~t:. II
... a::
-----....
...-..-..- - -
--
...
,
d~
~l~ ~
i ~
en ....,,'
b ;'
o ~.,
Lj~~
~j
......:,
~:
-'
<C
16
"~
CD
E
E
8
ro
"C:
Q)(;)
C):J
ro"'C
L., c:
.9
en
-0
~ ["
en ::: I
'Q ::,.,
,g 3::5
&! ~i t
2' :1, e ":
!LJ~:)D- ,~
:-5 :E: I
~"~- ~:
:.;- ~ t---
~,I.c "I,~\
:.}.
~l
.......
(.)
~
r-
....
.c:
0)
::i
::.1
'~
-:.t.
~
-.
'J~"l1<'I;":',,,,,,,,
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
DIRECT STAFF TO AMEND AN ORDINANCE AS IT RELATES TO THE PARKS AND
RECREA TION ADVISORY BOARD.
Objective: That the Board of County Commissioners direct staff to amend the ordinance as it relates to the
Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (P ARAB).
Consideration: On November 24, 1998, staff presented a draft of an amended Parks and Recreation Advisory
Board Ordinance that removed the specific representation of a Marco Island resident in favor of an additional "at-
large" representative which is attached and shown as option 1. The Commission reviewed the ordinance and
requested that the staff consider and have the Parks Board look at inclusion of representation from each
incorporated City instead. This option is also included and is attached as option #2. The Parks and Recreation
Advisory Board was presented with the structure which would include specific representation from each City and
voted to continue to recommend that the County Commission adopt an ordinance that removes the specific City
representation.
The original staff recommendation and the recommendation of the Parks Board was precipitated by several
factors. From a historical perspective, the original PARAB positions were created in conjunction with the three
community park impact fee district boundaries: Marco Island, Immokalee, and Naples Urban boundary. With the
Marco Island incorporation, there is no longer a Marco Island Impact Fee District nor is there a need for a specific
representative as the community parks on the island have been deeded to the City and the associated community
park impact fees are no longer assessed to their residents.
Secondly, P ARAB is designed to provide the BCC with recommendations on the major policy issues and new
projects that are facing the County's Parks Department. Specific representation is unnecessary from the City of
Naples or Marco where the only County Parks are built out with no plans for expansion and no plans for new
--.,rojects. The County has no parks in Everglades City, nor are there any plans to construct parks within that City's
}oundaries which again makes representation on the County's board incongruous. Since the Advisory Board does
not deal with daily administrative issues there is no benefit operationally from having specific City representation
either. Coordination of these administrative issues is done at a staff level, which has historically worked
extremely well. In fact attempts were made on several occasions to have the City of Naples Parks Board meet with
the County's Parks Board on some regular schedule; but there were so few common issues that these meetings
were not continued.
Lastly, getting representatives for the Parks Board and most other boards is difficult even for County wide seats.
Limiting representation to smaller populations will make filling seats even more difficult. The ordinance as
proposed still affords the Board the ability to choose a candidate from an incorporated area but simply does not
require it. "At-large" representation encompasses both residents from within incorporated and unincorporated
areas; thus, the Commission has a greater list of candidates to choose from and an increased opportunity to
generate qualified applicants. The process has generally provided a cross section of community representation
and in fact a resident of the City of Naples currently fills one of the board's "at-large" positions.
Although the Board expressed an interest in including specific representation from all of the County's
incorporated City's it is still the staff and the current Parks and Recreation Advisory Board's recommendation that
the ordinance be amended to eliminate the language specific to a Marco Island representative in favor of adding an
"at large" position. There is nothing in the amended ordinance that would preclude the current Marco
representative from fulfilling his term which by ordinance would be his last in any case. On the other hand,
should the Board want to adopt an ordinance that does provide for specific City representation, such an ordinance
has been prepared, is attached and can be adopted.
----;rowth Management: There is no impact on the comprehensive plan associated with this item.
Agt~~l~~i,
No. .
MAR 2 3 1999
I
Pg.
-
Fiscal Impact: There is no additional fiscal impact regardless of the ordinance amendment selected. The cost of
the staff time to support the Parks Board is built into the Parks Department's general fund budget and costs
approximately $100 per monthly meeting for the staff time, material preparation and copying, postage, meeting
advertisement, and the generation of minutes.
t continues to be the recommendation of the staff and the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board that: an
amendment to Ordinance 93-81 based on option # 1 be adopted.
:'\_0 , ~ Q
PREPARED BY:~ L/~~JvL0..._ J-
6 John Dunnuck, OperatIOns Coordmator
Department of Parks and Recreation
.A"l ~ //
REVIEWED BY '111iWfIt tCa4'(~
. Marla Ramsey, Director
Department of Parks and Recreation
DATE: 2./r2./cr)
DATE: 2~/2 ;9}1
Thomas W. Olliff, Adm ator
Division of Public ServI es
DA TE: 3.ct. ~
APPROVED BY:
<-
AgendJ ~J'
No. ;~_ ~ )
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. d....
- -
I ORDINANCE NO. 99-
2
3 A1\ ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO.
4 93-81, THE COUNTY'S PARKS AND
5 RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD ORDINANCE,
6 BY DESIGNATING THAT ONE SEAT BE FROM
7 WITHIN THE CITY OF MARCO ISLAND, ONE (1)
8 SEA T BE FROM WITHIN THE CITY OF NAPLES,
9 AND THAT ONE SEAT BE FROM WITHIN THE
10 CITY OF EVERGLADES; PROVIDING FOR
11 COl\;FLJCT AND SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING
12 AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
13
14 WHEREAS, Collier County Ordinance No. 93-81 provides for a
15 seven (7) member Parks and Recreation Advisory Board; and
16 WH EREAS, County's Parks and Recreation Advisory Board has
17 requested that the total number of seats on the Advisory Board remain at
18 seven (7) members, but that the seat now designated from within the Marco
19 Island Community Park District be re-designated to be "from within the City
20 of Marco Island": also that one (1) existing seat be designated from "within
21 the City of1\apks" and that one (1) existing seat be designated from "within
22 the City of Everglades"; and
23 WH EREAS, the Board of County Commissioners accepts the
24 recommendations of the Advisory Board.
25 1\OW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF
26 COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
27 that:
28 SECTIO!\' ONE. Amendment to Paragraph A of Section TWO of
29 Ordinance 1\0. 93-81. Paragraph A of Section TWO of Collier County
30 Ordinance f\o. 93-81, is hereby amended to read as follows:
31 "A. The Board shall be composed of seven (7) members consisting of
32 one (l) member from the Immokalee Community Park District, one (1)
33 member from \\ithin the City of Marco Island Community Park District, one
Ao_no&. J ~~
No,$~
MAR (, J i~~~
pg. ~
-
(1) member from within the City ofNapJes. one (I) member from within the
2 City of Even2.Jades. and three ill five (5) members from within the Naples
3 and Urban Area Community Park District."
4
5 SECTION TWO.
Conflict and Severability.
6 In the event that this Ordinance conflicts with any other ordinance of
7 Collier County or other applicable Jaw, the more restrictive shall apply. If
8 any phrase or portion or this Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by
9 any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate,
10 distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the
11 validity of the remaining portions.
12
13 SECTION THREE.
Effective Date.
14 This Ordinance shall be effective upon filing with the Department of
15 State.
16
17
A TrEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
By:
PAMELA S. MAC'KIE, CHAIRWOMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
/o~ V~[~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
b:/lCp/amendlllg Ord. 93-8 J
Words underlined are added; Words struck through are deleted.
2
AoeJj C ~,.
No . ~) r
MAR 2 3 l~sg
p~. if
.J
,I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
ORDINANCE NO. 99-
A:\ ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO.
93-81 TO CHANGE THE COMPOSITION OF THE
COL1\:TY'S PARKS AND RECREATION
ADVISORY BOARD BY DELETING THE SEAT
FRO\1 WITHIN THE MARCO ISLAND PARK
DISTRICT AND INCREASING FROM FIVE (5) TO
SIX (6) THE 1\:UMBER OF SEATS WITHIN THE
NAPLES AND URBAN AREA PARK DISTRICT;
PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT AND
SEVER-\BILITY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
WHEREAS, Collier County Ordinance No. 93-81 requires that one
(1) member of the seven (7) member Parks and Recreation Advisory Board
17 be appointed from within the geographic area of the Marco Island
18 Community Park District: and
19 WHEREAS, because of the incorporation of the City of Marco
20 Island, public pZlrks in the geographic area of the Marco Island Community
21 Park District are no longer under the advisory review jurisdiction of the
22 County's Parks Zlnd Recreation Advisory Board and it is unnecessary that
23 said Board ha\ e a mem bel' Zlppointed from within the City of Marco Island.
24 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF
25 COUNTY COl\1!\lISSJONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
26 that:
27 SECTION 01'\E. Amendment to Paragraph A of Section TWO of
28 Ordinance No. 93-81. Paragraph A of Section TWO of Collier County
29 Ordinance 1\0. 93-81, is hereby amended to read as follows:
30 "A. The Board shall be composed of seven (7) members consisting of
31 one (1) member from the Immokalee Community Park District, one (l)
32 member from the \larco Island Community Park District and ~ six (6)
33 members from the l\;aples and Urban Area Community Park District."
Ag.n,d~ f ~,
HO.~ I
MAR 2 3 ~99
P9. ~
-
.'
13
14
-15
2
3 SECTlO!\' TWO.
Conflict and Severability.
4 In the event that this Ordinance conflicts with any other ordinance of
5 Collier County or other applicable Jaw, the more restrictive shall apply. If
6 any phrase or portion of this Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by
7 any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate,
8 distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the
9 validity of the remaining portions.
10 SEeTIO\' THREE.
Effective Date.
II This Ordinance shall be effective upon filing with the Department of
12 State.
A TrEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
By:
PAMELA S. MAC'KIE, CHAIRWOMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Ie (0
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
h:/t.cp/amcndwg Ord. ~3-X I
Words underlined are added; Words struck through are deleted.
2
Ag.nd.. J ~'"
No .~.;j; 1
MAR 2 3 i~:19
Pg. b --
- -
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
BOARD ADOPT RESOLUTION OPPOSING HOUSE BILL 0925 AND SENATE
BILL 1352, RELATING TO RATEMAKING PROVISIONS OF INVESTOR-
OWNED WATER AND WASTEWATER UTILITY SYSTEMS, BEFORE THE
1999 REGULAR SESSION OF THE FLORIDA LEGISLATURE.
OBJECTIVE: To garner support of other counties and the local Legislative Delegation
in opposing proposed legislation initiated by investor-owned water and wastewater utility
interests, which will materially affect the future rates of customers of regulated water
and/or wastewater utilities in Collier County and other Florida Counties.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Board adopted similar resolutions during the 1997 and 1998
Legislative Sessions, joining with other counties in opposing similar bills which
contained statutory revisions related to "margin reserve" and "environmental compliance
cost recovery" for regulated private water and/or wastewater utilities. During the 1997
and 1998 Legislative Sessions, identical legislation passed the House, but was narrowly
defeated in the Senate on both occasions due in large part to Collier County's lobbying
efforts.
,"-
During the Florida Association of Counties (F AC) 1999 Legislative Conference in
November 1998, staff addressed the FAC Growth Management & Environmental
Planning Committee regarding opposition to such legislation. There was overwhelming
support from other counties which led the F AC to adopt a Policy Statement in opposition
to this legislation during the 1999 Legislative Session. At the time the F AC Policy
Statement was adopted, no specific bills had been filed. House Bill No. 0925 and Senate
Bill No. 1352 were filed in February 1999.
The proposed legislation will revise current Florida Public Service Commission (FPSC)
utility ratemaking policy and defeat aspects of case law victories obtained by local
regulators and consumers, compelling regulators to increase rates.
The bills have three major, controversial provisions, each of which are unnecessary and
potentially devastating to utility consumers. Both bills are on file with the Utility and
Franchise Regulation Department.
1. Changes are applicable to utilities regulated by both the FPSC and counties that
regulate rates of investor-owned water and/or wastewater utilities.
The changes will not only be applicable to FPSC-regulated water and/or wastewater
utilities, but those regulated by counties that left FPSC jurisdiction after January 1, 1980,
._ such as Collier, Hernando, and Flagler Counties.
AGENDA '~
No. 1~6 I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pc.
I
2. Unjustified increases in "future use" rate base paid for by current customers.
Staffs position is that current customers should be required to pay only those costs
associated with providing them with water and/or wastewater service, while any extra or
"excess" utility plant or facilities built in cost-effective increments should accrue
reasonable interest and be collected from the future customers when, and if, they take
servIce.
The FPSC present policy is to allow current customers to pay for expected customer
growth for only the next 12 months (of test year) for the collection and distribution
systems, and out into the future 18 months of investment for water and sewer treatment
plant necessary to serve future customers. Staff contends that this level of "margin
reserve" is adequate; but the proposed legislation to increase rate base from 12 and 18
months out to 5 years or more, is arbitrary and capricious.
3. Expanded recovery of "environmental compliance" costs,
The bills state "the commission shall approve rates for service that allow a utility to
recover from customers the full amount of environmental costs." This provision
mandates full recovery of all environmental costs without regard for whether the
environmental equipment is used and useful to serve current customers. Staff contends
that this concept is flawed from a ratemaking perspective. The unacceptable definition of
"environmental compliance costs" is subject to abuse by utilities. Before long, every cost
imaginable may be cited as an "environmental compliance cost."
Should the proposed legislation become law, ratemaking authorities would lose vast
discretionary prerogatives now afforded in the rate application review process.
Upon adoption, the resolution will be forwarded to the FAC and the local
Legislative Delegation.
FISCAL IMPACT: None.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
RECOMMENDATION: Board adopt the accompanying resolution opposing House
Bill 0925 and sena~~
PREPARED BY: DATE: 3-1z,.9'1
D. E. :13leu" Wallace, Di..rector, Utility & Franchise Regulation
-/
1 ~-...L // v ~ .::? /r-- Oq
APPROVED BY: j .If" _ - < ~/-::'..6/L- DATE: ..../........- J - c /
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
AI~ I
No. If, {!tJ.l
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi.
~
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
RESOLUTION NO. 99-
A RESOLUTION OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, OPPOSING ENACTMENT INTO LAW
OF PROPOSED FlORIDA HOUSE BILL NUMBER
0925 AND PROPOSED FLORIDA SENATE BILL
NUMBER 1352, WHICH BILLS INTEND TO
ARBITRARIL Y REQUIRE THAT CUSTOMERS OF
MANY INVESTOR OWNED WATER AND
W ASTEW A TER UTILITIES WILL HAVE TO PAY
COSTS OF CAPIT AL IMPROVEMENTS THAT
SHOULD BE PAID FOR BY THE UTILITY'S
FUTURE CUSTOMERS, AND WHICH BILLS WILL
OVER TIME REQUIRE THAT UTILITY
CUSTOMERS MUST PAY FOR MANY
GOVERNMENT AL AND PERMITTING
COMPLIANCE COSTS THAT SHOULD BE
CHARGED TO THE UTILITY'S STOCKHOLDERS
OR FUTURE CUSTOMERS.
'''HEREAS, House Bill Number 0925 (HB 0925) and Senate Bill Number 1352
(SB 1352) have been proposed recently for enactment into law by action of the Florida
Legislature; and
WHEREAS, proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352 apply to the Florida Public Service
Commission and to all Florida counties that now regulate, or hereafter will regulate, the
rates of investor owned water and wastewater utilities; and
WHEREAS, a primary purpose of proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352 is to have
"considered" for inclusion into a utility's rate base as "used and useful in the public
service" utility property, including land acquired or facilities constructed or to be
constructed if such property is needed to serve customers five (5) years after the expected
date of the final order issued in the respective rate increase application proceeding; and
WHEREAS, another primary purpose of proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352 is to
charge the utility's customers the full amount of "environmental compliance costs" which
costs include, but are not limited to, all reasonable expenses and fair return on any
prudent investment incurred by the utility in complying with the requirements or
conditions contained in any permitting, enforcement, or similar decisions of any federal,
state, or local governmental agency with environmental compliance jurisdiction; and
A/C ~T)1
No. ,
MAR 2 3 1999
...3
PI.
.,-
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
WHEREAS, proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352 unnecessarily and arbitrarily
restricts each county's now existing discretion to consider the merits of approving or
disapproving the utility's appropriate "margin reserve" and in determining what
"compliance costs" should be paid by the utility's current customers and which should be
charged to the utility's stockholders or future customers.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida opposes
passage of proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352.
2. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County County, Florida,
requests that its local Legislative Delegation actively oppose enactment into
law of proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352.
3. The Florida Association of Counties may utilize this Resolution as it deems
appropriate to oppose enactment into law of proposed HB 0925, SB 1352, and
any substantially similar House and Senate bills.
THIS RESOLUTION ADOPTED after motion, second and majority vote in
favor of adoption this day of , 1999.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
Deputy Clerk
Pamela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
Approved as to form
and legal sufficiency:
~/-- ---:> [
\ t, v\\. \ W~.------'
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
AGENDA ITEM
No. /ltJ(A) (
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 1-
1 RESOLUTION NO. 99-
2
3 A RESOLUTION OF COLLIER COUNTY,
4 FLORIDA, OPPOSING ENACTMENT INTO LAW
5 OF PROPOSED FLORIDA HOUSE BILL NUMBER
6 0925 AND PROPOSED FLORIDA SENATE BILL
7 NUMBER 1352, TO INCLUDE SENATE
8 COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE BILL WITH
9 AMENDMENT, ADOPTED MARCH 17, 1999,
10 WHICH BILLS INTEND TO ARBITRARILY
11 REQUIRE THAT CUSTOMERS OF MANY
12 INVESTOR OWNED WATER AND WASTEWATER
13 UTILITIES WILL HAVE TO PAY COSTS OF
14 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS THAT SHOULD BE
15 PAID FOR BY THE UTILITY'S FUTURE
16 CUSTOMERS, AND WHICH BILLS WILL OVER
17 TIME REQUIRE THAT UTILITY CUSTOMERS
18 MUST PAY FOR MANY GOVERNMENTAL AND
19 PERMITTING COMPLIANCE COSTS THAT
20 SHOULD BE CHARGED TO THE UTILITY'S
21 STOCKHOLDERS OR FUTURE CUSTOMERS.
22
23 WHEREAS, House Bill Number 0925 (BB 0925) and Senate Bill Number 1352
24 (SB 1352), with Senate Committee Substitute Bill and amendment adopted on March 17,
25 1999, have been proposed recently for enactment into law by action of the Florida
26 Legislature; and
27
28 WHEREAS, proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352, with Senate Committee Substitute
29 Bill and amendment, apply to the Florida Public Service Commission and to all Florida
30 counties that now regulate, or hereafter will regulate, the rates of investor owned water
31 and wastewater utilities; and
32
33 WHEREAS, a primary purpose of proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352, with Senate
34 Committee Substitute Bill and amendment, is to have "considered" for inclusion into a
35 utility's rate base as "used and useful in the public service" utility property, including
36 land acquired or facilities constructed or to be constructed if such property is needed to
37 serve customers five (5) years after the expected date ofthe final order issued in the
38 respective rate increase application proceeding; and
39
40 WHEREAS, another primary purpose of proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352, with
41 Senate Committee Substitute Bill and amendment, is to charge the utility's customers the
42 full amount of "environmental compliance costs" which costs include, but are not limited
43 to, all reasonable expenses and fair return on any prudent investment incurred by the
44 utility in complying with the requirements or conditions contained in any permitting,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
enforcement, or similar decisions of any federal, state, or local governmental agency with
environmental compliance jurisdiction; and
WHEREAS, proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352, with Senate Committee Substitute
Bill and amendment, unnecessarily and arbitrarily restricts each county's now existing
discretion to consider the merits of approving or disapproving the utility's appropriate
"margin reserve" and in determining what "compliance costs" should be paid by the
utility's current customers and which should be charged to the utility's stockholders or
future customers.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida opposes
passage of proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352, with Senate Committee
Substitute Bill and amendment adopted March 17, 1999.
2. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, requests that
its local Legislative Delegation actively oppose enactment into law of
proposed HB 0925 and SB 1352, with Senate Committee Substitute Bill and
amendment adopted March 17, 1999.
3. The Florida Association of Counties may utilize this Resolution as it deems
appropriate to oppose enactment into law of proposed HB 0925, SB 1352 with
Senate Committee Substitute Bill and amendment adopted March 17, 1999,
and any substantially similar House and Senate bills.
THIS RESOLUTION ADOPTED after motion, second and majority vote in
favor of adoption this day of , 1999.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
Deputy Clerk
Pamela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
Approved as to form
and legal sufficiency:
\6~ \{~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
EQUEST TO GRANT FINAL ACCEPTANCE OF THE ROADWAY, DRAINAGE, WATER AND
SEWER IMPROVEMENTS FOR THE FINAL PLAT OF "QUAIL WEST PHASE III, BLOCK
K, LOT 97"
OBJECTIVE:
To grant final acceptance of "Quail West Phase III, Block K, Lot 97"
CONSIDERATION:
1. On February 1, 1996, the Board of County Commissioners granted
preliminary acceptance of the roadway, drainage, water and
sewer improvements in "Quail West Phase III, Block K, Lot 97".
2. The roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements not
required by the plat to be maintained by the project's
homeowners association will be maintained by the County.
3.
The required improvements have been constructed in accordance
with the Land Development Code. The County Development
Services has inspected the improvements and is recommending
final acceptance of the improvements.
."..".,-.....
4. A resolution for final acceptance has been prepared and
approved by the County Attorney's Office. A copy of the
document is attached.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The roadway, drainage water and sewer improvements not required to
be maintained by the project's homeowners association will be
maintained by the County Transportation Department and the County
Utility Divisions. Funds for the routine maintenance and upkeep
will come from the Operations and Maintenance budgets of the
Transportation Services and Utility Divisions.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
,-
AGENDA ITEM
No..J t. {Al"
MA~ 2 J 'i~S9
Pg. I
Executive Summary
Quail West Phase III, Block K, Lot 97
Page 2
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners grant final acceptance of
the roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements in "Quail West
Phase III, Block K, Lot 97" and release the maintenance security.
1. Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached resolution
authorizing final acceptance.
2. Authorize the release of the maintenance security.
PREPARED BY:
J()~J. \1..-\ . ~ '- \>..!\-, ~
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
~.~.q~
Date
REVIEWED BY:
~Q.1U
Thomas E. Kuck, P.E.
Engineering Review Manager
3- 11)- J9
Date
,/Z//) L
/
Robert Mulhere, AICP
Planning Services Department Director
/'
APPRO'0u /~
!"/Hpr k'.
Vincent A. Cau ero, AICP, Administrator
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs.
>-J;~l
Date
~
~-
~/J -'7 t-
Date
jrh
-
AGENDA rtEM
No. I~ (A)~
MAR 2 3 'tSSg
Pg.
01
\~~
! <)
\2-0 ~
N~S
l . I. .
Ity ot
Nap\es
\
\
\
\
I .
~'
\~\
,
"
\
,
,
LEE dTl'
r ~I
.
\ \ \
\ SITE \ \
\
\
\
I
i
\
\
T4C6
1495
\
\
\
\
UJ'
.J
(J)'
Plt'-E
lOCAJ"ION 'c. MAP ,,,.;./, . .M.A~ Z 31S89
_ ." . ",.,..~...-:_.- :.:~.,~-~~':-; ,". .'-' ',~. :<;.....:r:: . '. :';:L . 3:
.-,.......~..._~_...,-~,_-.._-~.,..........~. .
-.~-~ ~~',' . . q.-'-"- ,.---'
..A-'~~C,~~_"""-~k""_-~-~"'';' ."'.......~.._~
...,.--..:-----..-.----"....- ~
----.- .,.......
L'f ~..".,_.............
._.:::.:'\~~._-~~' -~.-:.
..~_--"""..'...~---~....'.,--'-..!'--~-,:!r...,..-
.~ ,.....,. - --.'.
~~........~~~~,-:
,:::__,,_'..~"'..~-~.'>o7;~..........~--;i2I.~..~~.~~,~.~''::>>'ld>
. 11-, ~ ...
.;. ~. ~-..~. ..:,--;..,-~~........"jj;~
.~--
.,--............______-_~._.~__-...~_'!__:_.;r
'."'" .~,~....:...~......--"'-,--_-_:_....-,-..,-.'1'>
-:,-:":;"";:7::':".-.>.:. ,..._~-.
--.-,..-...-;:.F'
...-._-.....-....-.~
~~- -
....,...._~-""'!"'~~..........-"~
_~~~.r.._i._':;......;.;..-~'_.
-,"""
~,~;;~.-:.;:.-=---~-..-:2.~..;:::.:~..:-;::-~..~
----~--,.~.~..-
'. 7
-.~~-~~~_.....__...
-;- . :- "":""' ..- .... -, ~~'- ~
r ~ _,-,--.<.-._~' ..,~~.,.... '__:._'-'- ......___...---~
--~----_..._--~.._.- .-.
.'#.' ........--,,~_..,'<....,-----,...~.....---~~-
~~
.-.,.
~ ,-...,..... .
~-~..- - ~- ~",,~~;::. :>-'- ~ :.-..--..-
. ..~.....---:~_>:.''"_~ _~.r,..,
,.. ..-._----_'l.~--:---
,_~. ~.~:~'."'M'-.'""'-,.~"..~~..; -.)-:-";..~ ;.olO.-r--::,YA ," ~" - ,-.:.;. :--.-:-:'"t
_~~1
.,.-~
___............,.~.._.:.'.. ~.,.:,_'C'_.-...
. :::-, '-or ....y. ~
.,-..----
........-.,--.. ..~-~~'----_'l..-..,~...... --:;r-----~~.......
// -
--:::---1.~..,.._~_..~......-:or-'I-....:.~~''"r,_,,-''''''''~_7''''-'
_'"'_"~_'~::~:"~'-~-~~i
. . ~':. ..
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59.
60
RESOLUTION NO. 99-_
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING FINAL
ACCEPTANCE OF THOSE ROADWAY,
DRAINAGE, WATER AND SEWER
IMPROVEMENTS IN QUAIL WEST PHASE III,
BLOCK K, LOT 97, RELEASE OF THE
MAINTENANCE SECURITY, AND ACCEPTING
THE MAThITENANCE RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE
ROADWAY, DRAINAGE, WATER AND SEWER
IMPROVEMENTS THAT ARE NOT REQUIRED TO
BE MATh'T AINED BY THE HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION.
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, on
January 2,1996 approved the plat of Quail West Phase III, Block K, Lot 97 for
recording; and
\VHEREAS, the developer has constructed and maintained the roadway, drainage,
water and sewer improvements in accordance with the approved plans and specifications
and as required by the Land Development Code (Collier County Ordinance No. 91-102,
as amended); and the Utilities Standards and Procedures Ordinance (Collier County
Ordinance No. 97-17), and
WHEREAS, the developer has now requested final acceptance of the roadway,
drainage, water and sewer improvements and release of his maintenance security; and
WHEREAS, the Compliance Services Section of the Development Services
Department has inspected the roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements and is
recommending acceptance of said facilities.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COM.,\1ISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that final acceptance be
granted for those roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements in Quail West Phase
III, Block K, Lot 97, and authorize the Clerk to release the maintenance security.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED AND ORDERED that the County accept the
future maintenance and other attendant costs for the roadway, drainage, water and sewer
improvements that are not required to be maintained by the homeowners association.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote favoring same.
DATE:
ATTEST:
D\\<1GHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIOJ'..'ERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
PAMELA S. MACKIE, CHAIRWOMAN
Approved as to form and legal
';tnJ1 d:Ai 11/"-
Heidi F. Ashton
Assistant Collier County Attorney
AGEKJA ,I~ ...
No. 1~{Ir~
MAP. 2 3 '1~~'9
o___....._,..__..".......--~-.......-- __ -....._h.__,,,.._..-;.._____~_,7.____~ .
-i:/.
~""F'c....;
- -. -P(I.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
,...",--.
REQUEST TO APPROVE
COMMERCE PARK WEST
SECURITY
FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF "CREEKSIDE
- UNIT TWO", AND APPROVAL OF THE PERFORMANCE
OBJECTIVE:
To approve for recording the final plat of "Creekside Commerce Park
West Unit Two", a subdivision of lands located in Section 27,
Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida.
CONSIDERATION:
Engineering Review Section has completed the review of the
construction drawings, specifications, and final plat of "Creekside
Commerce Park West - Unit Two". These documents are in compliance
with the County Land Development Code and Florida State Statute No.
177. All fees have been paid. It is the intent of the developer to
record the plat prior to construction of the improvements. The
securi ty in the amount of 110% of the total cost of the required
improvements is being covered by construction and maintenance
agreement and a Performance Bond. This would be in conformance with
the County Land Development Code - Division 3.2.9.
.'-""
Engineering Review Section recommends that the final plat of
"Creekside Commerce Park West - Unit Two" be approved for recording.
FISCAL IMPACT: The fiscal impact to the County is as follows.
The project cost is $1,054,475.41, to be borne
by the developer.
The cost breakdown is as follows:
a)
b)
Water & Sewer
Drainage,
Paving, Grading
- $260,226.00
- $794,299.41
The Security amount is $1,375,399.00
The County will realize revenues as follows:
'.~""'.....,
Fund: Community Development Fund 113
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138900 - Development Services
Revenue generated by this project:
Total: $19,510.99
Fees are based on a construction estirn te A~A{~~
$1,054,475.41 and were paid in October, 19(8. ~
MAR 2 3 19:9
Pg. I
. Executive Summary
Creekside Commerce Park West - Unit Two
Page 2
The breakdown is as follows:
a} Plat Review Fee ($425.00 + $4./ac)-$ 804.26
b) Construction Drawing Review Fee
Water &
Sewer (.50% const. est.) -$ 1301.13
Drainage,
Paving, Grading (.425% const. est.)$ 3375.56
c) Construction Inspection Fee
Water &
Sewer (1.5% const. est.) - $ 3903.37
Drainage,
Paving, Grading (1.275% const. est.) - $10126.67
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
The Concurrency Waiver and Release relating to conditional
approval has been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's
Office for the proj~ct.
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the Final Plat of
"Creekside Commerce Park West Unit Two II with the following
stipulations:
1. Accept the Performance Bond as security to guarantee
completion of the subdivision improvements.
2. Authorize the recording of the Final Plat of "Creekside
Commerce Park West - Unit Twoll.
3.
Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached construction
and maintenance agreement.
4.
That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the
required improvements have received preliminary acceptance.
.-
~l~
No. .3
MAR 2 3 1SSg
~
Pi.
Executive Summary
Creekside Commerce Park West - Unit Two
Page 3
PREPARED BY:
-1i..l.\.l LL\.~\sv..","~
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
REVIEWED BY:
Thoma~, ?E~
Engineering Review Manager
}("o~e, AICP ---
Planning Services Department Director
APP~' k
. ~ C;::;.
Vinc nt A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs. DIVISION
JRH/ew
~.R.~~:1
Date
i3 ~/() - 99
Date
:;;-1'1) J.7~
Date ("
:s -/-Y --/ (
Date
',~'""
AGENDA ITLM
No. I~ ~
MAR 2 3 'I~U:J
!>g.
a
~
i \
t
NAPLES; FLORIDA
=-==
L
Vanderbilt Beach Ro(
AGENDA ITEM
No. /l.tfA 3
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 4
NOTES: .
1 THF" RAe
CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEl\1ENT
FOR SUBDIVISION IMPROVEMENTS
I
i
THIS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION
IMPROVEMENTS entered into this day of , 1999, between
CREEKSIDE WEST, INC., a Florida corporation, hereinafter referred to as "Developer", and the Board of
County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereinafter referred to as the "Board".
RECITALS:
A. Developer has, simultaneously with the delivery of this Agreement, applied for the approval by
the Board of certain plat ofa subdivision to be known as: Creekside Commerce Park West, unit Two.
B. Division 3.2 of the Collier County Land Development Code requires the Developer to post
appropriate guarantees for the construction of the improvements required by said subdivision regulations, said
~uarantees to be incorporated in a bonded agreement for the construction of the required improvements.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants hereinafter set
"orth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows:
1. Developer will cause to be constructed: The paving, landscaping, drainage, potable water,
irrigation water, sanitary sewer, and street lighting improvements for Creekside Commerce
Park 'Vest, unit Two, within twenty-four (24) months from the date of approval of said
subdivision plat, said improvements hereafter referred to as the "required improvements".
2. Developer herewith tenders its subdivision performance security (attached hereto as Exhibit "A"
and by reference made a part hereof) in the amount of$1.375,399.00 which amount represents
10% of the total contract cost to complete construction plus 100% of the estimate cost to
complete the required improvements at the date of this Agreement.
3. In the event of default by the Developer or failure of the Developer to complete such
improvements within the time required be the Land Development Code, Collier County, may call
upon the subdivision performance security to insure satisfactory completion of the required
improvements.
4. The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a statement of substantial
completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records have been fhrnished to
be reviewed and approved by the Development Services Director for compliance with the Collier
County Land Development Code.
AGENDA ITEM
No. J~ '- ~ 3
MAR 2 3 '1~99
5"
Pi.
- 1 -
5. The Development Services Director shall, within sixty (60) days of receipt of the statement of
substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of his preliminary approval of
the improvements; or b) notify the Developer in writing of his refusal to approve improvements,
therewith specifying those conditions which the Developer must fulfill in order to obtain the
Director's approval of the improvements. However, in no event shall the Development Services
Director refuse preliminary approval of the improvements if they are in fact constructed and
submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this Agreement.
6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum period of one year after
preliminary approval by the Development Services Director. After the one-year maintenance
period by the Developer has terminated, the Developer shall petition the Development Services
Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, iffound to be still in compliance
with the Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by final approval by the Board, the
Board shall release the remaining 10% of the subdivision performance security. The
Developer's responsibility for maintenance of the required improvements shall continue unless
or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for and by the County.
7. Six (6) months after the execution of this Agreement and once within every six (6) months
thereafter the Developer may request the Development Services Director to reduce the dollar
amount of the subdivision performance security on the basis of work complete. Each request for
reduction in the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security shall be accompanied by
a statement of substantial completion by the Developer's engineer together with the project
records necessary for review by the Development Services Director. The Development Services
Director may grant the request for reduction in the amount of the subdivision performance
security for the improvements competed as of the date of the request.
8. In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to fulfill its obligations under this Agreement,
upon certification of such failure the County Administrator may call upon the subdivision
performance security to secure satisfactory completion, repair and maintenance of the required
improvements. The Board shall have the right to construct and maintain, or cause to be
constructed or maintained, pursuant to public advertisement and receipt and acceptance of bids,
the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision
performance security, shall be liable to pay and to indemnify the Board thereof, including but not
limited to engineering, legal and other contingent costs, together with any damages, either direct
or consequential, which the Board may sustain on account of the failure of the Developer to
fulfill all of the provisions of this Agreement.
9. All of the terms, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon the
Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer.
AGENDA ITEM
No. )t. (JJc')3
MAR 2 3 1~89
- 2 -
PS.
te
~_t~
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Board and the Developer have caused this Agreement to be executed by their
duly authorized representative this 'i't-r.- day of V).1 (1/' cl\.. , , 1999.
I ,
I
b
:TEST:
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
WIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
By:
Pamela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
~puty Clerk
..David C. Weigel
County Attorney
AGENDA ITEM
No. If. LA13
MAR 2 3 lS~3 j
~ 7
~..~-,-"
'"'
- -' -
BOND #12800141
COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
PERFORl'\fANCE BOND
KNOW ALL PERSONS BY THESE PRESENTS, that Creekside West, Inc., a Florida corporation,
located at 2640 Golden Gate Parkway, Suite 115, Nap]es, F]orida 34105, (hereinafter referred to as "Owner")
and Amwest Suretv Insurance Companv (hereinafter referred to as "Surety") are held and finnly bound
unto Collier County, Florida, (hereinafter referred to as "County") in the tot a] aggregate sum ofSOne
million, three hundred sevent.... five thousand, three hundred ninetv nine Dollars ($1,375,399.00) in
lawful money of the United States, for the payment of which sum well and truly to be made, we bind
ourselves, our heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, jointly and severally, finnly by these
presents. Owner and Surety are used for singular or plural, as the context requires.
--
THE CONDITION OF THIS OBLlGA nON is such that whereas, the Owner has submitted for approval
by the board a certain subdivision plat named Creekside Commerce Park West, unit Two, and that certain
subdivision shall include specific improvements which are required by Collier County Ordinances and
Resolutions (hereinafter "Land Development Regulations'). This obligation of the SurelY shall commence on
the date this Bond is executed and shall continue until the date of final acceptance bv the Board of Count\'
Commissioners of the specific improvements described in the Land Development Regulations (hereinafter
the "Guarantv Period").
NOW, THEREFORE, if the Owner shall well, truly and faithfully perform its obligations and duties in
accordance with the Land Development Regulations during the Guaranty Period established by the County,
and the Owner shall satisfy all claims and demands incurred and shall fully indemnify and save hann]ess the
County from and against all costs and damages which it may suffer by reason of Owner's failure to do so,
and shall reimburse and repay the County all outlay and expense which the County may incur in making
good any default, then this obligation shall be void, otherwise to remain in full force and effect.
PROVIDE, FURTHER, that the said Surety, for value received hereby, stipulates and agrees that no
change, extension of time, alteration, addition or deletion to the proposed specific improvements shall in any
way affect its obligation on this Bond, and it does hereby waive notice of any such change, extension of time,
alteration, addition or deletion to the proposed specific improvements.
PROVIDED FURTHER, that it is expressly agreed that the Bond shall be deemed amended automatically
and immediately, without formal and separate amendments hereto, so as to bind the Owner and the Surety to
the full and faithful performance in accordance with the Land Deve]opment Regulations. The tenn
"Amendment", wherever used in this Bond, and whether referring to this Bond, or other documents, shall
include any alteration, addition or modification of any character whatsoever.
Page I of2
r-
AGENDA ITEM
No. I~{A\~
MAR 2 3 1S~'9
~ ~
KKI"'".:da..m<diImao<.../da........ICmplal..........~doc
LIMITED POWER OF ATTORNEY
Amwest Surety Insurance Company
Ex iration Date:
11/11/00
POWER NUYlBER 0000947931
This document is printed on white paper containing the artificial watermarked logo (A ) of Amwest Surety Insurance Company on the front and brown security pape
on the back. Only unaltered originals of the Limited Power of Attorney ("PO A") are valid. This POA may not be used in conjunction ....ith any other POA.
representations or warranties regarding this POA may be made by any person. This POA is governed by the laws of the State of Nebraska and is only valid until,
expiration date. Amwest Surety Insurance Company (the "Company") shall not be liable on any limited POA which is fraudulently produced, forged or otherwise
distributed without the permission of the Company. Any party concerned about the validity of this POA or an accompanying Company bond should call your local Amwest
branch office at (liB) 787-1"\76
KNOW ALL BY THESE PRESENT, that Amwest Surety Insurance Company, a Nebraska corporation, does hereby make, constitute and appoint:
Karen A. Keller
Ron Kasarda
Mark Benson
Piper Kelly Hunt
Paula A. Murdock
As Employees of Sedgwick of Florida, Inc.
its true and lawful Attorney-in-fact, with limited power and authority for and on behalf of the Company as surety to execute, deliver and affix the seal of the company thereto
jf a seal is required on bonds, undeltlkings, recognizances, reinsurance agreement for a MIller Act or other perforrr.:mce bond or other \\Tinen obligations in the nature thereof
as follows:
Bid Bonds up to S500,000.00
Contract Bonds up to $1,000,000.00
License and Permit Bonds up to SIOO,OOO.OO
Miscellaneous Bonds Op To SIOO,OOO.OO
and to bind the company thereby. This appointment is made under and by authority of the By-Laws of the Company, which are now in full force and effect.
I. the undersigned secretary of Amwest Surety Insurance Company, a Nebraska corporation, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that this Power of Attorney remains in full force and
eflect and has not been revoked and furthermore, that the resolutions of the Board of Directors of Amwest Surety In,urance Company set forth on this Power of Attorney, and
that the relevant provisions of the By-laws of each company, are now in full force and effect.
.''''No. J~gOOfli-1 Si,,'dholod,hi, /1 d'yor F'ebr,'ary 19CJCL ~p ~
~ren G. Cohen, Secrel4'"
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * RESOLt:TIO:\S OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * . * · · * * * * *
This POA is signed and sealed by facsimile under and by the authority of the follo\\ing resolutions adopted by the Board of Directors of Amwest Surety Insurance Cor.
at a meeting duly held on December 15, 1975:
RESOL VED, that the President or any Vice President, in conjunction \\ith the Secretary or any Assist;Jnt Secretary, may appoint attorneys-in-fact or agents with
authority as defined or limited in the instrument evidencing the appointment in each case, for and on behal f of the Company, to execute and deliver and affix the seal of the
Company to bonds, undertakings, recognizances, and suretyship obligations of all kinds; and said ofllcers may remove any such attorney-in-fact or agent and revoke any POA
previously granted to such person.
RESOL VED FURTHER, that any bond, undeltlking, recognizance, or suretyship obligation shall be valid and bind upon the Company:
(i) when signed by the President or an)i Vice President and attested and sealed (if a seal be required) by any Secretary or Assistant Secretary; or
(ii) when signed by the President or any Vice President or Secretary or Assistant Secret;Jry, and countersigned and sealed (if a seal be required) by a duly
authorized attorney-in-fact or agent; or
(iii) when duly executed and sealed (if a seal be required) by one or more attorneys-in-fact or agents pursuant to and within the limits of the authority
evidenced by the power of attorney issued by the Company to such person or persons.
RESOLVED FURTHER, that the signature of any authorized ofticer and the seal of the Company may be affixed by facsimile to any POA or certification thereof
authorizing the execution and delivery of any bond, undertaking, recognizance, or other suretyship obligations of the Company; and such signature and seal when so used shan
have the same force and effect as though manually aftixed.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Amwest Surety Insurance Company has caused these present to be signed by its proper otticers, and its corporate seals to be hereunto affixed this
25'" day of September, 1998. 9~ E: ~~ '-L P ~
/' John E. Savage, presid7 ~ Karen G. Cohen, Secretary
State of California
County of Los Angeles
On September 25,1998 before me, Peggy B. Lofton Notary Public, personally appeared John E. Savage and Karen G. Cohen. personally known to me (or proved to me
on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the \\ithin instrument and acknowledged to me an that he/shelthey executed the
same in hislher/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted
executed the instrument. WITNESS mY~d and official seal '@_.................:_:v....a..:.-ON........l
,....."':\:',,\,,.N'U'S""~.;"""',.. fl.. '-f' , ,.,:~ ~1"""'- .
""'~~"?-p'6X1'11:'" S'gnature ~I-\, I,,). ~~ (sea,)i -". ~P\bIc:'~.
l'J;4P -1 ~.:t\ ~ P...,B 1 . ~y u " . Lot Mg".~, 1~
~ CI) ~ DEC.14. j () ~ . ,
;\-\ 1995 iOf
":.d)\ '1-. ~! E
\f;>~,! R {>.s.~<'f/
.,.'1 i<t ............ ~\~ -,'
''''''''1", tr' * ,,~;"\\....
"""1"111\11'\
No.
5230 Las Virgencs Road Calabasas, CA 91302
TEL 818 871-20 0
".'
oj
Pa---.!l.-_
~
I
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
AUTHORIZATION TO AWARD BID # 99-2912 "WHITE LAKE CORPORATE PARK
.-'" INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS" AND TO AUTHORIZE STAFF TO INITIATE AN
AGREEMENT WITH HARPER BROS., INC. OF FT. MYERS, FLORIDA.
OBJECTIVE: Board of County Commissioner's authorization of the award of Bid # 99-2912 (White Lake
Corporate Park Infrastructure Improvements) to Harper Bros., Inc. a licensed and bonded construction
company of Ft. Myers, Florida, and authorizing staff to contract with the same for the purpose of
constructing an asphalt concrete street with appurtenances, in a Planned Urban Development known as
White Lake Corporate Park.
CONSIDERA TIONS: On November 23, 1998, Collier County was awarded an Economic Development
Block Grant by the Department of Community Affairs (DCA), for the construction of a street with
appurtenances for a development known as White Lake Corporate Park, located in Activity Center-9
(Interstate 75/CR 951). Engineering plans, specifications, and bid documents were completed and an
advertisement for bids was made on February 10, 1999. Bids were opened on March 11, 1999.
Harper Bros., Inc. was the apparent low bidder with a total construction price of $690,000. After review of
the five (5) separate bid documents by our Purchasing Department, RW A, Inc. (the project engineering firm)
completed a review of Harper Bros., Inc. references and bid tabulation. No discrepancies in the bid
tabulation were found, and the reference review did not turn up any inadequacies of the company. County
Staff and the Project Engineer RW A, Inc. (Civil Engineers) are recommending that the Board of County
CommiSSioners award Bid # 99-2912 to Harper Bros., Inc. ofFt. Myers, Florida.
./"'--.,
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
FISCAL IMPACT: This contract has been budgeted for in the applicable CDBG Block Grants fund. The
total amount funded by the CDBG Grant is $750,000. Less Administration costs ($60,000), the total amount
available for construction is $690,000.
RECOMMENDA nONS:
That the Board of County Commissioners award Bid # 99-2912 "White Lake Corporate Park
Infrastructure Improvements" to Harper Bros., Inc. of Ft. Myers, Florida and to authorize staff to initiate a
contract for the construction of the 1998 CDBG Econ ic Development Project.
8.
PREP ARED BY:
Date:
.3 /.:J. -Ff'
APPROVED BY:
Donalr;l .. Blalock, Jr., Ma r
Housing and Urban Improvement
//
~. .-/? /~L.
_.,~ ./~ ~.-../ - -----...
Greg MihaN,c, Director
Housing and1Jrban Improvement
/",
C L' ('. /'
~ ';.:;L {'~ - ---':
Steve Carnell, Director
Purch ng Departmen~ ._
t. ~
V ncent A. Cautero AICP, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
-( I'"')
Date:"""> - / t.... '-
"f'c;
REVIEWED BY:
REVIEWED BY:
Date:
J "./ ~
)' .....( .. - f! 1
":' -\ vi
Date: ]-/ S- -9 9
AGEJ'<<)A ITEM
No.~
MAR 2 3 1999
p,. I
.-
Ul
-
C
G)
E
G)
>
e
Q.
.5
G)
..
:::s
-
u
:::s
..
-
...lA-.
oX
..
l'll
Q.
G)
-
l'll
..
o
Q.
..
o
o
G)
.oX
III
...J
G)
:::
.l:
==
~
i
"C
iXi
IX!
~
-
lrl
~
:::
Q)
rzl
tIl
Q)
'c
'5
0-
:::
-
to)
Q)
ex::
tIl
Q)
0[)
(0;:1
..::.:::
to)
(0;:1
0..
i..:
0[)
:.:E
~
~
o
-;
==
=
o
Q
~
to)
Q)
'0'
I-
0..
~
..
=
-
~
=
..
...
III
~
~
c
-
~
..
C':l
=-.
Q.l
-
C':l
..
o
Q.
..
o
U
Q.l
~
~
..J
Q.l
.-::
III
...
c
~
e ~
~ M ~
e ;; ~
Q. M ~
S s c:J.., ~
~-=,,-
~
~
j;::
~
CO
I- U
c.8 "E
c: 0
.~ gf
::l :::
..c Q)
(0;:1 0..
f-O
~
to)
Q)
'0'
I-
0..
~
~.
I:)
ez: .l.<
...5
.~
.....
....
.~.
~
l.<
C
-
u
=
~
:
'Cl
~ C
~ ~
"'-t
Eii
:~
... ~
~ ilJ
Q.,C
... ....
~ =
:: ...
cc
...
c
-
. .'!,
.ilJ
.C
;:;
Q
cc
I~
1<I!l
z 1$
o I;
1= 1:1
i:l.. 1;-
C2 :::
U I;;;
"'- '~
~..
Q i;t
l~
i::
i=
~
~
I-
-
.',... ..' ~8.
..... ....;;) .'...~
.'. M .~.
t- .r--:
'0 .00
t:;J\ .~
. . ~
.....' ... .... ...
" ..'
V)
V)
0\
N
"'<t
IJ")
t-
I'--
b'>
$..,.t::.
r-lo\
',' ~ .~
Vi ~
V) .00
.00 ~
<>'7
V)
0'>
-.0
I'--
O.
IJ")
o
\0
b'>
o
....
.-
o
o
r:r;
0'>
\0
b'>
[;oil
I.:i
<
Z
-
<
IX
Q
Q
Z
<
I.:i
z
-
Q
~
I.:i
I.:i
Z
-
~
<
i:l..
...:
o
M
..0
Q'I
\0
iI';
V)
-
~
.....
IJ")
~
"'<t
t-
\0
o
00
b'> -
o
IJ")
o
00
o
o
0'>
b'>
-
'"
~
00
0..,
I'--
~
=:
\;Jil
I-
<
~
Z
o
-
I-
U
~
I-
o
~
-
~
=:
-
""
Q
Z
<
[;oil
oJ
cc
<
E-
O
i:l..
...:
-
V)
N
r-l
00
\0
00
00
b'>
.""
"1
"'<t
-
0'>
M
iI';
-
b'>
o
~
t-
O'>
I'--
0\
"'<t
b'>
''<''j
-
o
CJ..
~
....
[Zl
o
"'<t
oci
0\
0\
\0
IZ;;
00
I'--
I'--
cr-.
-
N
M
li.-i
IJ")
I'--
00
o
V)
I~
o
0.
.~
\0
.N
'.~
o
IJ")
M
N
\0
t-
Z;;
Ii') ...,.
00 ~..
.r-) N
M 00
"'<t 00
00 N'.
. r-- .\0
.;; IIN
.
IJ")
N
0\
IJ")
N
-
~
~ SS ... ~
s: ..~ .' &j
"} '~ '<t
00 ....., 'M'"
V)N ... ~ ....
E;'t .~ '.' M '...
... ...... '.'
.... "
C
N
0\
o
N
I'--
~
N
0.
-
M
o
o
\0
b'>
I'--
-
00
"'<t
\0
\0
o
N
00
....
\0
V)
M
o
lr)
.....
,..,
~.' g,,' ~,"'.~ '.'. ~,..., ......" ....[ ....
,...; r-,: ,'. oci ',' N" ,...;1
:"t 0 M Q'I'... "t..'.. ....i.
t-.l.t") -," .', .M,', ..' ,0-..,.' .' .... ,'.
.t- _ .... V)" 00'
N ','v) ,. \0 ... ,.;; '... f'- .'..
l&oi' .E>"] .',.0 . . > I..
'.' !;;; I
" ..' ..,'. ... ,...
=:
[;oil
~
\;Jil
rjJ
~
<
E-
-
Z
<
rjJ
...:
-
-
\;Jil
z
<
oJ
~
~
E-
-;;.
-
rjJ
~
~
~
~
..
~
=:
E-
z
[;oil
b
'z
<
\;Jil
i:l..
<
U
rJ)
E2
<
::
-;;.
;;;;;
0'1 C
01 f")
M r-)
1'--1"'-'
C t-'
'IJ") .' N
..., C
.~"'<t
.. :.;;:
..
M
'"'l
N
00
0'>
N
IJ")
b'>
V)
~
00
"'<t
N
I'--
;;;;;
M
\0
M
IJ")
0\
I'--
I'--
:~
I~
::;;
!~
I.:i
z
-
i:l..
<
U
rjJ
Q
Z
<
oJ
z
o
-
E-
<
I.:i
~
-
...:
~
...:
-
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
....
~
c:
..
Q
I"
~
~
~
=-:
11:I1$;2' .01 .... g > ~
:,Q\ 0. . ',0, '. ',' . . '-
00 ...;.; ii"l9
1E;A~ ',N .ai. ... .;t
t:7",~ ...... '..: '<t ::"'''.:
:ti"'" ....N.'" ~
M ......._....
.~ .. ..._.......<i'l
'.' .:. ..... .', :...
o C C
o C C
000
C C 0
000
N C IJ")
fF. ~ I~
.
CC
MOl
!~g
o
00
I'--
~
'b:;'.c: ....:q g. I~
.,.;.~ :.,;.; ....."j. ';
i~ .Ocr-. "r<) I~
N,.. .\I:l....r<),..,,,,
.,~, ' .~.. I'-- .1'--. .
.~, ~......... I.....
:~ I""
"
...
IJ")01
00 0
IZ;; g
o
M
~
o
o
o
-
N
t-
ct
... ...
..
C
C
C
c
~
IJ")
o
o
IJ")
I'--
I'--
;;;;
~$ :., 8.1 g, . ..... ~, '
"'" ....:. . 0.. "'<t
I~ .'~ ..':~ ~ ..... .~
,~":::I,i(J,:, < g
:~l>'3II."':"".....'~
"1< .....,...
~
'i:
~
~
o
~
.:l:
...
I:)
~
J::
....
...
~
I;Iil
<l)
"C
U5
..c
....
~
o
CIl
~
C
<':l
CO
<lJ>-
~U
.....l ....
~ ~
l::
.;::: ~
~'C
-5i~
<lJ <lJ
~....
- ~
'"
.- '" >-
.....<lJU
J.oj~O
"'~O
t::eC
?-f-<~
.....I~ ~
2~<";;'
.- Cl:$ QJ
~.....l u
..... ....
0.........
O~
~
<lJ
~
::l
CIl
"C
l::
""
'"
.~
<l)
~
.5
....
'"
""
a
<l)
....
rzi
6
.;!l
....
.t:J
<l)
o
E
::l
co
2
E
2
:;::
~G~
No.
f7':
.,.....
.,.....
-
o
Cll
Ol
CI:l
CL
2
v.;
i:t:
o
'"
]
<l)
o
<l)
'"
~
'"
i5
N
2
""
E
2
:;::
"ITEM
f(P/A)5
: 3 1999
MM
pc.
~
\() 0, .\()O .... .0
.~ .or"t.o. .0.
oo.~ I.;! .~ .;q
I""' OV)
.fo:' \0 1E.'i
.;;
8 8 8 ,~r8
o d '..IJri .r::iv;
~N .,'...... ,...;1:'-
0-. N ..' 0
.~~ ".~
.'~ ,.1""
". '. . ..
.. ..
00 0
00 0
66 6
00 0
00 0
MO\ "'I"
'Vi Z;; 1C!
:2'8
.ri:d
Ib<ii~
I~
:.t,.;;
\().O
r<j.V')
.0\ .'
.~ "
i6
~g
o.~
..-0\
1(;<l'1"-
E.
o
o
o
l"-
I"-
I~
00
<')0
I~~
V)
~
'\()O
Nlo.
....10
-- .'0
.'. l'
o
\.Q
.~
';;' .
..-e
~
Q .y
.~.. =
lo. ....
4/'
....... .
..."..
..4/
=
~~
Vl
.
',',
.
00
<no
-6
loI'lO
o
IS:;
00
\C 0
I~g
<n
\C
~
o
o
6
o
I~
00
\Co
~~
00
00
~g
<n
o
~
<nO
I"- <n
i~~
\C
~
00
00
I~~
I"-
o
;;;;
o
o
6
o
<n
[;!
<nO
1"-0
I~g
\0
I"-
C!
00
00
I~g
o
"'I"
IC!
<no
000
~g
N
00
~
00
~o.
1~8
"'I"
~
~
=
-
r,j
:t
\;5l
o
~
l;;1$~lg> '(2 ·
...0"'1" ~ 0>.00
I'~,""" loI'l.~ .....,
-0', .'.
'~',
f.... ,,~ .,~.. .....~ g.', .... ..~,'
.~8 .... i~.~ .... .~
... .,.. .~ ....1> .~ >>rl;;
.t> .- .[>
'"
0; ~$,8 .~
I~o (3', \C I:'-
0-. .;:;: '<t '"
f-,-",.O
0..- '"'"
I~ z; .;;;;
p~
10,"'1"
i~1"-
'""
.~
~5
[~~
.,..,
~
vo
~r
I~
;,-
.~
o
\()
~
00
....,
<n
;;
M 0\
.~ -~
.'1;' ~.~
'~.<nr-
a..,. _~~
~i(,'j~
Ii =
~
41
......
..~
t,;. .
~
"
. .
.
,'. .. .,
<no 00
-0 \Co
I~~ ;;;g
0\ \C
0\ I~
,~ l~
'"
<n 0
\C \()
-N
It'lM
o
~
00
'<l:o.
-0
""\()
"'I"
~
00
'<l:o.
-0
1 b'l 0\
;;;.,
\()O
I"- \()
-N
I"" \C
I"-
;;:;
o
0.
o
\()
-
00
0;0.
I~~
l/")
M
~
00
00
~g
00
00
~
\()O
t'-;\()
l;;~
o
~
00
"'1"0
I~~
"'I"
0\
;;
c
c
C
N
<r:
00 0
00 0.
66 0
I. ~ 00 0
41 41 00"'1" <n
E-;,~\C 0\
I'll 0 ""'~ I:::
::z: = ~ ,~
en
-
c:
CI1
E
CI1
>
o
...
c.
.5
CI1
...
;::,
-
(.)
;::,
...
-
en
C'lS
...
-
c:
.:.:.
...
C'lS
C.
CI1
-
E
o
Q.
...
o
(.)
CI1
.:.:.
C'lS
..J
CI1
-
:c
3:
""
;;;;
....,.,. c:;
1Oe:
..0'
..rio
MO
,~o
,. 6Fl \.Q
\0
Vi
.;;
o 0 0 0\ 00 .~
..~ 00> 0 r- VJ ~ 0.
~ ~~* .~g .~~
~ N M V) ..... 0 .....0
~ ,~Z;;I~ .... ..... ~ ;;
~ ..... .,...,.1.'. >>.... <
o
0.
0'1
.-
-:t
'~
~g
ll'i~
10 \0
<X:
-<:t
~
~$
~l~
.00 .
o
I~
~Ig
'~ci
'0\
IS
.",
~s
i~ t:
~
.~.~
I~ ~.
::
V'
~',:s
.00 '0;
N
.z,j
o
0.
o
N
I~
.....
.....
--
o
N
Cl)
Ol
co
0..
, ',' .
'.
'.'
;>-
u:l
~
'"
.~
....
~
U
<r::
...
~
'"
(.)
'C
~
~
:s
I'll
I.
"
~
~
'S;:
I'll
l:l..
>-
u:l
~
'"
u
'C
~
z
o
~
l:l..
=:2
u
rr.
l.:i
Q
M
>-
u:l
...
~
'"
u
'C
Q.
"';>-
~u:l
I!lo
o
~oo
g"'l"
... ....
S<2
.- '"
~ (.)
'C
oo~
.....
~
...
~
~
u
'C
~
.........
~~
:::lo
O~
~M
- ...
"C;<2
> '"
- (.)
0'-
....
N~
.....
~
~
Q)
(.)
'C
~
.....
U~
0~
",I"-
"C;-
~ ...
u:l<2
E ~
cO~
.....
~
....
1S
'"
(.)
'C
~
.....
::r::~
'0
::r::<n
<1)-
"C;N
~ ...
u:l<2
E 13
Cl)'i:
I!l~
-
~
g
<I)
(.)
'C
~
.....
E~
<1)0
I!lCl
~::
8<2
~ 13
o.t::
r-~
.-
-
-
J:,
,~
r-
.::l;>-
~u:l
gg
000
u"'I"
.~ .....
;;<2
...t:: <I)
~.~
<r::c':::
.....
~
....
~
Q)
.~
...
~
..........
I~
.....0
~V)
"''-0
~ ...
u:l<2
E 13
Q) .-
I!lc':::
.....
....l
...
~
<I)
(.)
'C .....
~~
.!:JO
""I"-
:::IN
U ...
.....<2
~.~
~c':::
'"
"0
~
'"0
C
'"
i3iu
'<r::
qM
~-
gj 8
.- <.::;
... ~
~.~
Dc':::
~
...
o
~
...t::
t
'"
'-LJ
~
~
'-
o
]
~
<I)
'"0
<<l
...
~;>-
:::lu:l
u:lo
'"00
~o
;"=\0
;.c ""
"'<2
r/)<I)
(.)
N't::
~
.....
~
""
1S.....
<I)......
.~o
"'0
~\C
"'.....
~ ...
"C;<2
~ Q)
~ (.)
'"0 .-
.- ...
u:l~
~
:B
'"
::E
a<3
~
'S
.~
u:l
<I)
(.)
c
~
8
'S:
c
~
<II
-
c:
ell
E
ell
>
e
Q.
.5
Cll
...
:2
-
l.,)
:2
...
-
~.
.x:
...
ca
0..
Cll
-
ca
...
o
Q.
...
o
(.)
ell
.x:
ca
..J
.Sl
:c
~
.-nl.
en
-
'tl
iXi
r;;
.-e'
.ell
Q
~ .~
.Jo. _
41' .
....-_.
..... .
A.l
::=
~I~.
.f:II; ~
00
I~
:0 ,...
o
:u:.'
o
N
I~
o
o
o
o
v-.
I;;;;
08 .0 r~ 001~
~, "-d ..:. .'~I",""'. . 0,-0:>>. !:.. ';3,';"r-
o M ::..01 I,~f'-., \I) ..ol~
.>QI.P 0 I~ (") "t10"
-:Q\ I~ it; :Z! I;;;~I~
.
00
00
trio
r- v-.
v-. '<t
I;;;'~
~ 8 g ", 'f? g ~
'C.. .' ','
:~= . ~ ~ g >, ~ 8 >;
,~ .. ._, r- ~ '" '" >', ;1
~t ~ 1;;;>1;; s: '.'. ""
fi ''i .' ..'.. I .~. ...
~ '... .> ...
...
=
-
00
~o
~g
r-
Z;'
U
::c
(;I;l
.. \:
cu cu
Cl..c
.. -
= =
::c=
00
'<to
r;1*
~
.....
=
-
~
.~
c
=
'Q
:=
00 0
MOq
v1 0 :0-,
~oo 0
~ ~'.
.~ ":~
. .
','
'.
:J
g
u
u
.:::
t::..
z
o
1=
=-
Q2
u
'J)
~
Q
t2
v
'iQ
u
o
-l
.~
ti
~
'"
:E
.c
-
.~
~
.:; l.t..
]-l
00
UO
..0
.f. a
,- :-
- ll)
;:) u
. 't:
..o:l...
:;
~
!-
-
o
o
o
v-.
~
I;;;
"0
'"
o
"
f
s::
~
'-
o
Co)
"0
Vi
.c
:;
o
C/.l
'"
s::
'"
-
(/)
'"
U..l
.f.
....
U5
'"
o
C/.l
'"
:.a
'"
CD
Vi
00
00
"';0
r- v-.
'<t 00
I;;;~
00
00
<rid
.00 ""'""
"<T'o-.
!;;;.~
~
=
=
.;
..
Q
.c
u
'"
U..l
Co)
.~
....
Q..
~
~\O
I: ....
,?<2
ll) ll)
::::: u
"'.-
>d:
g
o
v-.
o
I;;
00
00
00
r-'<t
""'" '"
I;; ~
'.,oM
I;';;"","
I.... N
,~g
I~~
o
o
v-.
M
~
00 0
00 ~
"';0 v-.
\O~ \0
Mv-. M
I;; ~ I;;;
o
~
v-.
r-
v-.
gg
00
~ \0
-M
;;;I~
1~8 'S;;:
I~'g'
t'''t
,;. '":'l '....1'1;
>: I > ..
I!) 1/
g
o
o
~
o
o
.-0
,:~
r<t
o
o
o
o
N
~
00
00
00
..oM
N v-.
I;;;!~
'01:0
RII:C:;,.~.'
......
N-(:'.
00
~\O
-or-:
l~~
~
r-
:'b
~.~
o,-:f.
S!,~
.,...,
:...
I;;;;
IN
IS
I;;;
.~I~
00
~13'
I;;
0'" MICl
-.t .1'-0
.r-: '.' "";'';';
~ .' ;:$:~
N I~'....t
. .
o 00
o 00
o trio
v-. r- v-.
- ""'" '"
~ I~I~
o
o
o
""'"
~
00
<r"!~
- 00
I~ :::
;;
00
00
00
r-"'<t
0-
;;;;~
18 8. IS. 21 g .... .~ 11~.~21 .'. 52 ... .~".~
I~,.,.'.\O Ii "''''''",' .~ > "!:l'".. .00 10" ..'.:~ ,O\g
.l=:i;:?; IN ',' '::: N :'.' .~$ .,.~ 1;;;;:0
~MI~-~S t:M ~
{,.j '. ...... . .... .. '.1 : >, ',., .'. ....
I " ..:.. ....r >. <
o
~
00
"'<t
~
.c
u
'"
U..l
ll)
u
E
.S
(/)
'"
.0
.c
u
-
'"
u
u
J
r-
"'~I
-::,
i:1
,~
8~
0<2
~ 8
~J::
c:
'c;;
'"
.0
.c
u
-
'"
u
U..l
J
r-
.c
u
'"
U..l
ll)
.~
....
Q..
(/)
IV
><
o
CDN
c: ....
0<2
',= OJ
U u
1:._
;:l ....
......Q..
~
.2
u
E
'J)
'0
J:l
I:
o
U
.c
u
'"
W
v
.::!
....
Q..
"8
U..l
'"
~M
ll) ....
.~ c.8
:E ll)
\c .~
~Q..
"0
c:
U..l
'"
ll)
....
~
~
l.t..
..J
....
~
ll)l.t..
,~ ..J
....N
t:l..v-.
t:l.. ....
u<2
" ll)
.l::l
v-. ....
-Q..
0,1,<=
;:;:I"~
.~.r-;.
:Eii': .
v-. 0
v-. \0
I~ gg
I~
o ,..0 0
~1>1i'i':~,
.g: .l,~'~
i~:~!I;
; I> I ,'.
....' ...11 '...
&r) v-. v-. v-.
..or- &r)~
,.,..; -.6 I~ ~r-
~ c; I~
~ !:;
~ ~
~I~ .' ~.~.
I~I;;; .~.:::'
IN' '~N
I~ ."'!
00
-M
~;:j
I;};
"'<to
M.M
.t-,:.v-)
,~ 0>
v-.
.~
gg
000
~~
..0
~
00
- V'l
:~~
""'"
c
loP.
.li-il~ ,.'. '~lrlli-i.V"i
\I) &r) .... \I) 'N
. ! '"..~... .'....~,..
.0'< ."r'-' CI,=
.~ ."" N. L> ,;:;0, ''0
"t 'l>!3r- ,<m
'~T >cr...~
.,I! ,..>....!<....
.....
.....
.....
o
C'?
Q)
C>
ro
c..
l.t..
..J
....
~~
II.) v-.
.~ 0'\
....N
t:l.._
Q.. ....
U...:::
0:: v
~.~
Nt:l..
l.t..
..J
....
~
ll)
.~
....
Q..
g~
''';::: '!'
(/)0'\
~M
c:::l-
Q.. ....
u<2
0:: ll)
u
~ 'C
Nt:l..
~
M
l.t..
-l
....
~
ll)
u
'i:
t:l..
~ .
't; ~
""
-N
CD v-.
t:l.. ....
u<2
" v
u
in 'C
-Q..
ITEM
Mo. l'-IA)s
MlA.f ~ 3 1999
Pi. 4
II)
-
r:
Gl
E
Gl
>
o
~
a.
.E
Gl
~
::l
-
U
::l
~
-
II)
l!
-
.=
.:.::
~
C'Cl
Q.
CIl
-
E
o
a.
~
o
o
CIl
.:.::
C'Cl
-'
CIl
=:
~
~
N
....
(l)
N
.
(l)
~
"C
en
. 'JO" :QO
.:~ 0.0
~. I~ .;:i
:~::.~ :~.~
lo. _ .~
.~ -]7;";
....
.1IJ
:=
y
==
-
00
~~
- r-
I~:;:;
o
,;:;'
00
i'i':c;::>
-010;
~''''-'
'0
,&;;
Vl Vl
Vl~
I~~
..".
tV;
88
<>ON
3:'^
V7:0\
.'"
I;;:;
Vl 0
~...,
-N
~~
0\
I;;:;
~g
~.~
'M
N
.~
VlO
Vl r-
~~
o
~
.. ~ ~....;;; ~ ~ g: -;;;.~
1IJ ~ oo..r> ~ 1.0 '... ~ H t""
.~ 6i51~ ~ .",.~"" .\O~..~ ,."'.~
ti5 l- N ...,;:;;" ',' N ,~
1IJ , ;:: ',', " ,::;;!""'
g, ~ "" I" .,.. r--'
~. I
U
::
~
00
V:Vl
'" NN
~ ~ I~ ~
E-.s ...,
= 0 :::
:: lo. ""
=
00
- r-
,~;:;;
o
I~
Vl 0
~-;
Vl ...,
~~
..".
I~
'y:
. .C
-
~.
II
=
c:
o
'...=
00 >0,' "'.V) :-9 ..".
-N,....,,....,_OO
. ro-'.' . ''01::''
r~ ~ t..-: ~ .'. ~ S;
r'" 00'. ..". ..-..".
0'1". ... N l-'-
'.;;;"..., I~
z
o
1=
~
C2
\.,.)
00
~
Q
""-
-l
...
g,,"-
II) ,
u-<
.- r-
Q::q
Q.. ...
u<.2
0::: II)
u
O'C
r". Q..
::it
~
~
-
. .
.
"
:J
g
II)
u
'C
e..
~""-
--l
'"
0<Ir-
-V)
o:lN
e.. ...
u<.2
0::: II)
u
o 'C
...,e..
""-
-l
...
gLo.
tl-l
'C ~
e.....,
e.. ...
u<.2
0::: II)
u
::.0 .t:
,...,e..
00
-~
~g;
o
I~
I;;;;'
I
.~~
t.",
V")
f~
Lo.
-l
...
~
II)
.~
...
e..
~Lo.
'; ..J
'"
""..".
2i~
e.. ...
u<.2
0::: II)
u
\0 'C
,...,e..
.~~
r- ..".
..,..;....M
:- N
.t;.~
00
00
""0
V") -
-...,
. v;: ~
',~ N '-
,-(' ":t '\5
t~ ~ I~'
v;: I;
00
00
00
00
00
,v;: ~
gg
Ii: ~
",", .-n
-N
,v: <r
..c
()
""
r.I.l
II)
u
'C
e..
-;;
~N
"0 ...
e<.2
::c II)
~ .~
Ne..
o
I:~
i8:;
I;;;;
o
o
o
o
-
I~
o
~
Vl
...,
00
IV;:
'g
1.-::'
I~
I~
-;;
~
"0
""
II)
::c
\0
...,
o 00 :0
01: 00..".
.~ .:: :~r-) I";';
o ..,,...,N <rl
.0'0 .'1,0 :....
'.", r--
:i;<l ~
'.' I~
'. ". ','
o
o
o
o
o
~
00
VlV:
~~
...,
~
-
l-'-
,....,
>0
-
~ 0'1
0000
tri.~
:v; r-
d\
.~
..~
o
o
o
o
00
Vl V)
-~
-..".
".;r-
~
IV;:
o
c:
Vl tr\
~-
<;;)
... Vl
ibi'!OO
00
~
-
0\
.V)
I;'
~
:::
.~
~
o
"'0
...
o
u
II)
0:::
Lo.
..J
...
g
II)
()
'i:
e..
~
.5
~
~Lo.
e..-l
~r-
(1)"'"
~o;::
<;<.2
C5 ~
:: .-
.- ...
-le..
< :::. o:c; I :0
..:: '.": ',:;; :,..".... .'~,'
....:.~~.~ .~
.~ ..~
.....". .... .....
, ..
Vl
Vl
0;
N
..".
Vl
r-
I~
!~
[~
..".
V)
<rl
Vl
I~
. .'.
:
V)
~
1.0
r-
o
Vl
o
I~
V) Vl
r- N
.,.;r...:
-...,
V'l0
1.0
~
M'\'c
:ION
b~
00
V) Vl
00",)
- r-
V'l0
..".
I~
.Vl
l""j
.
0:000:: 00
-C;~ 0.0. -C;~
\0 0-'<"": .r--.oo
l-'- 00 "";'M g'N
~I~" a~. ~E
:. .... ::'
::
o
o
o
00
00
,~
00
00
00
V) V)
ON
~2
1V'l
00
~~
V) V)
V) 1.0
-..".
V;I~
00
:0\ l-'-
~I~
S'OO
N
00
00
00
\0 00
0-
V;:I~
00
00
00
0'11.0
e;-
I~
MN
-Vl
oO.N
v)....,
~\O
I~
00
O~
VlO
NO
~~
~
-
I~
<"'1
'0-
:~
r- ".0 00 00'... ~ 0
0';1' .... 0 000 0.... <;;0
101' .t"i .... ~ 0,.' '''00...r; ('0;100,
,'. .~I~ '.'. ,0\.. r--,',.r- ..' ,O.l'l.... ...".1.0
.~ 00 .,' -'00 .:. 0 0 r- 0-
0' ''0,'' NO..'..,;...M ~N
-.:t..f><. If>': .,....Ii;<
.'
f........'
o
-
=
~
00
~
~
<(
z
~
Q
Q
Z
<(
~
z
-
Q
~
~
~
z
....
~
<(
c..
Is
I~
~
~
<d:
~
~
~
Lo.
-l
...
g
II)
u
'C
Q..,
c
.~ Lo.
E-l
(1)",",
-N
0<10'1
:SN
U ...
><.2
e.. II)
o'~
-e..
lri
t"-
OO
. lop
. or)
. Ii')
,.f>':
00
":to
r..:.r-::
V) 00
ON
NO
".;....
o
o
o
....
-
00
00
00
1.00
N,...,
I~ :::
I".;
~
. .
fa
r-<
..c
u
""
II)
II)
u
'C
Q..,
~
J::>
E
<I)
'"
'"
<(V)
- ...
~<.2
... II)
1=! .~
::t~
-
o
:I:
o
N
><
o
-
.:::
u
""
r.I.l
II)
.~
...
e..
II)
~
<;
>M
II) ...
~<.2
011)
u
o "C
-0..
.:::
u
~
r.I.l
II)
.~
...
e..
II)
~
<;..".
> ...
2<.2
13 ~
~ "t:
ooe..
.....
.....
-
o
-.:t
<!)
OJ
ctl
0..
A~E ~~ rt~~ ~_
No 1)~/A)5
--.-
f~AR ? b 1999
Pe. 5
I
CIl
-
C
Cll
E
Cll
>
e
c.
.5
e
::s
-
u
::s
..
,.-.
~
..
ca
Q.
Cll
-
ca
..
o
c.
..
o
o
Cll
~
ca
...J
Cll
-
:c
~
...,
i
"0
i:ii
~ 1~18.1. 8.8-
_.. .. r-.- I.... '0.
Q ......11:\ t-C'l
~ '1;1 .,.. ~ ~~ Q'I
· t": ;;;,'IC? .~
....
....
.~.
:=
88
C;I 00
C Vi<rl
- 0.-
U ;;;;IZ!
::e
~
'00'00
....... ..-.:t
~l ~$
.G<l 101 00 '<t
~i ~I~
S:.. =
;;I
I. ~
Cl.I Cl.I
Q.,:::
.. ....
III Q
::eels
co.
co.
vi vi
0.-
g::r--
~~
C;I
C
-
.~
.'"
'Coil
=
C
Q
~
00
co.
N..o
...."..l"'l
~l"'l
.~
:z
o
~
~
;:
U
r.n
~
Q
-=
u
C':l
W
v
u
.;::
c..
'"
-
c
.0
Q..
~
1
E
<<I
\/Jr""l
;;; ...
'C <.E
~ 0
u U
<<1'-
coQ:::
~
~
f-
-
co.
oo~
~~
~
I~I .~ ~11~.1
I.... C'I t- .
J~ .r--- .~
[~ .:; t-
f;iI'
..' .... ...
'..
.
0. co.
0. 00
o 00
o r-- 00
Vi '<t 00
I~ ;;;;~
<rl
~
'<t
r--
'"
o
~
M 0....01....". ','.0 ,I.r'-, .'.
-,~ . V'J "t.r-: .',.- .,.,
i;;:"~'" d $ {:: .~ ....
I{;<: 0.... r--.I - '-C I"-
~ '.'l~ ,;;;;.~ ..~
...
co
00
vio
~~
~
MO
t- N
Na\
.;:::0
..,..,.~
-=
U
<<I
W
V
U
.;::
Q..
c
.~
o
~o
~'<t
...
U<2
> 0
Q.. u
. 'C
ooc..
,
o
o
o
o
Vi
I~
00
00
vio
1"-0
l"'l-
;;;;~
g
-'
.~
I~
00
00
d:?,,'
I"'j ,~
.:::;; .;...,.
~
-=
U
<<I
W
V
U
.;::
Q..
~
c
.~
<<I
...
Cl
"0
...
o
u
o
p:::
"0
C
<<I
.g
'"
<:)
f-<
...
o
~
u
o
.....l
~
:::E:
"0
C
<':l
>:
o
00
;S
.~
o'<t
.~ '""'
,<2
o 0
[/) u
'C
00Q..
o
V')
d
00
o
o
,~
Iv:
g
~
ct
~
f-
<
~
z
o
-
f-
U
~
f-~
0<
~f-
~o
~;
_;;I
\;li,r.n
Q
Z
<
~
~
~
fo-
o
~
: ..8.I:~
~I~
I~
I~
'. ..
...
V') V')
"1~
00 V')
~~
Mlv-:
001'::"':
NI;
~~
I~
00
"1"1
..... l"'l
~~
I~
0.0.0.0. 0.:0. VlC
.1"1 :", '. ."l .... ."'l:"1 .. "'t.."'T,
:~ ."'t .00 'r"! '" .0\ Vi .t:'>l
vc,:~ I;;,' ~T."':n ,;;,'.~
I~ I~IJI~ ..".,{;;;
....c-..t!."... ....1
. .'...... I'" ...1
00. ViVi
"'0. "1~
,..)..; I~ ~
I~~ .....
00
;;;;
I;;;;
V') Vi
"1l"!
~8
r""l
I~
~s .',~~
'~..o .~ Vi
.f...l~..'I~~
M V')
Ii.<: '..'.:::
'. ... ,V':
..'
'.;r 0
.M....
19~
-
'<t
co
00
I~~
V')
:S
,~
~~
00r--:
~~
00
I;;;;
','
00
co
~~
M
~
V') Vi
r-- t-
oo l")
~;::!l
'"
;;;;
Vic
."'t''<t
N'..o
.,~~
. V')
.' I~
00
00
";00
~~
'"
I;;;;
~Itrc i Vi ""I 0\ on--c Viir1 ... ~~
l"""! V::f .Vi ~I'~,~ .... ."11':: .""!.
.;gle:<< .~ G, . I .~.~ I~ ~," ,hi ,~" "
':'_ r""l0'<1 ,..,.., r-- I M .....0
I~ <r;r .....:~ '.....~... .;::
,', ..,I " '.' .... ,....'..~. .... .... ~
.": "<I '.'.' [ .'.'
I~
I~
I~
I~
I';
....
.....l
...
~
o
u
'I:
Q..
-
;:3
u
00
I
\0
...
0....
~.....l
J5~
.f. ~
~<2
c:s~
_ "t::
OOQ..
....
.....l
...
~
o
.~
...
c..
;;
U
00
I
\0
.5
-
'"
<':l
Eri
...
oi-t..
~.....l
J5~
I.f. ~
~<2
c:s ~
_ 'C
00Q..
....
.....l
~
o
u
.;::
c..
18
o
-
I
00
...
0....
~.....l
GJV)
\/J",
.~ ~
~<2
c:s ~
.;::
ooc..
i-t..
.....l
...
~
Il)
u
';::
c..
;;
u
o
-
I
00
.~
on
C':l
Eri
...
oi-t..
~.....l
GJV)
tIl\O
:,f. ~
~<2
... 0
o .~
- ...
ooc..
....
.....l
...
g
o
u
.;::
c..
<3
N
.....
I
o
-
...
0....
~.....l
Ol"'l
[/)r--
.f. ~
~<2
... 0
o u
_ 'c
oo~
V'J.O
NQ
~N
...;,.."'t'
~~....
00
.~.
lrI 0.
lrI '"
.~::::
'"
;j
fll:1C
.'<:t;.C1C1
1;;- ~
r::" \0
r" .r-:-
.1")
,&I
I~~
0'''''';
I~~
l"'l
;;;;
1<:;0.
I~\O
1.~':00
'''';'',0\
I~:
I:UI"
ViO
lrI l"'l
I~~
r""l
I;;;;
,'<:tOO 1-' -<t'<t'-O
~."t '~"<t: " I~O\
r- ~ t- 0 ,..If-' 0
.~ .~ Iz;)Cl l~ ~
.M -.: O'i 1>-
.fiii '.' .'... [10'3
,..1' r
: ".,.
'.' ....1 ,..,1
co ViO lrIC
-l"'l l"'l0 Cl"'l
~~ ,f3~ I~~
00 ,""'~' 0;
~ ~ ~
~.~<[::t~ :;;.~
. ., ..,1:::::,< ", ."
,~t"<I;:;J;;;; ~'~
:;;; ifAN ...'M
.~ ','.~ ,r.;;l
.,','
'., ... ..... ..'.
i-t..
.....l
...
g
o
.~
....
Q..
;;
U
N
-
I
o
-
.~
on
o::l
a:l
...
oi-t..
~.....l
Ol"'l
tIlr--
.f. ~
~<2
c:s~
_ 'c
ooc..
t.t.,
.....l
...
~
o
u
'1:
~
=
u
~
-
I
N
-
...
GJt.t.,
~.....l
O"'t'
tIl'<t
I.f. ~
~<2
.... 0
o u
_ 'C
00Q..
I .
.' .'
......
......
....
o
l!)
il)
OJ
co
0..
t.t.,
.....l
...
g
o
.~
...
Q..
...-
::l
U
~
-
I
N
.....
.s
...-
on
o::l
Eri
...
0....
~.....l
V'<t
\/J'<t
.f. ~
~.,8
l; 8
_ ';:
ooc..
~G!tNI A. ITEM
INc IJl,li\S
~) R 2 3 1999
PI. it:>
N
....
01
N
,
01
~
"
in
en
-
C
G)
E
G)
>
o
...
0.
E
G)
...
::J
-
CJ
::J
...
-
en
ea
...
-
E:
~
...
ea
0..
G)
-
ea
...
o
0.
...
o
o
G)
~
ea
..J
G)
:!::
~
~
>(i;
"0' .
,~
Q
=:..~
,J..;,..,
41
.... .
....
41
::C.'
co
CO
"';00
N'~
.\0 N
;t;IZl
I.l
=
-
U
::c
l;o;i
1010
1010
00
1010
r-v
;;IZl
\ON
~:M
~ -g. 0\00
..... .. 10-
.~ O/J M \0
.,~ .~. ;;I~
ri =
.~
t ~
Q. Il.l
lo. ::
ell 0
::c ..
=
1010
1010
00
V 00
V 00
;;I~
'"(,;1
=
-
..;;
",.
1l;l,
=
=
'0
~.
co
~o.
"'" 00
~~
'-M
..-;IEti
z
o
-
E-
~
;
U
rJ:;
l;o;i
Q
.=
u
t':I
W
<I.l
U
'c;
Q...
'5
u
00
,
::0
OJ)
<I.l
"0
.=
=
t':I
~N
~2
t':I
.-::: C,)
;~
[/)Q...
:;
l;o;i
E-
-
,1010
C1o.
N'<t
1010
."" 00
.~.~
~'fI';
1010
1010
00
-N
-N
~~
<n.O
~o:
~oo
0\00
~.O\
V;.~
1010
1010
00
V 00
\0 N
;;;;;
1010
1010
0\00
10.......
0\00
;;;;;
.=
u
t':I
W
<I.l
U
'c;
Q...
'5
u
o
-;'
00
'"
<I.l
"0
.=
=
t':I
~N
~2
t':I
.-::: lU
;.~
[/)Q...
g 8 ...I~ 8~ ...8.... g .~ 8 gg
,.-;' ....: .. .... ".. . .... -:..
"~~ !~ ~.~ ...~ ~Q\- ~g
...., r<) \00 ..' r<) 10 .... 00.. .'... ~ ~ ""
'~.~ f~ ~ ~ t~<~I~~
.', '... ... .... :J~..< < <
1010 10 1010 10 10 1010 1010
1010 10 1010 10 10 '<t\O 1010
00 ~ 00 ~ ~ ~~ 00
00\0 \0 r-N N r- ~r<) r<)\Q
~- N ~o v,~ N ~N
~~ !~ -'I~ ~ ,_. I~ _.~
00:\0 .' '0\ .'. 00
0\ 0: ". ,,' '1"'-:
,0\,' 0'1 'I~v". \Q
,.... ~' "'00
.r;... ~ ... r<)
.~.~
010
1010
~o
~-
0-.0\
~~
gg
'~;.,r
N.~
Nv
z;:i~
.=
u
0:
W
<I.l
U
'C;
Q...
'5
u
N
-
,
o
OJ)
<I.l
"0
.=
=
0:
~N
~2
t':I
.~ Q,)
c.~
t':I ....
[/)Q...
.
10
10
o
~
v
i~
'...~ ~...,'r::
.... 00.... -..0 ..... .ci;
I r-....o::::;
c'. .'<t'. V'l _
00
.~
1010
1010
~o
N~
:'!~
-'I~
10
10
o
~
r-
~
10
10
o
or;
I~
~~
~t;
- r<)
- \Q
;.o<lr<)
N
I~
r- M~
M .,.,N..~
N..,..V~
~....~~
.,.;.. '{;<l"
-
1010
1010
~o
~-
~-
vi_
v;
ig. g;:: 'g 8 .~ ~8 8
:~ ~ ~ gj' ri .~ ~ .cil ~
<:J-. ' .~.... lr) N.,.. .~ "':
i~ I~.:O iV;.... ....I~-. ;;;
.'.' ... "I'.~ '...:.. < <:// ....
, .' I.... ..'.
'5
u
"'r
-
,
N
-
OJ)
<I.l
"0
.=
=
0:
~
E
'S
t':I
[/)
.=
u
t':I
W
Q)
.~
....
Q...
;:::
.g
C<i
ri)
~
......l
E
'2
t':I
[/)
OJ)
Q)
u
'E
Q)
[/)\Q
.... ....
~<2
<I.l <I.l
[/) u
_ "C
\OQ...
.5
.....
OJ)
~
co
=
.g
C<i
ci5
a::
;J
E
'2
t':I
[/)
.....
......l
....
~
Q)
.~
....
Q...
.5.....
t':I..J
60\
d)o-.
~c
0_
..... ....
u<2
> Q)
Q... .~
- ....
VQ...
..r:::
u
t':I
W
<I.l
.~
....
Q...
<I.l
;>
(;iN
> ....
~<2
E:: 13
_ 'C
VQ...
.0 10.....0
0. .... R .... .rrj
.:c.....~ ....~
.r-- .... '?II" ~
....... .... 'r<) .:g
<.i ;;
10 10
10 10
~ 0
r- -
or; r<)
~ IZl
.:\0.. . t<) .~
.N .M ..
. .', "" -
00."., NV
~ .~ ~
N .~ ~
"'" IVJ .v:e
-
10 10
0. 10
~ 0
"'I -
V -
~ I~
~
~
"'I
00
\Q
00
00
;;;
10
V
r--:
0-.
r-
0-.
'<t
;;;
gg .~
.1;;, . ..g .~
r- ".,M .'""! ....
N/e~....
.... ....1.',. ,.,' ,'. ,...
fi3
F-
e
:t
'<t
X
"'r
Ql
;:::
.~
0:
....
o
"0
....
o
u
d)
et::
"0
=
0:
....
<I.l
~
Il)
;;
....
d)
~
(I)
en
"0
;:::
0:
.~
'"
(I)
1-<
~
E-
o
E-
=
;,
rJ:;
~
l;o;i
~
l;o;i
r:rJ
~
~
E-
~
r:rJ
....0
o
o
,10
.Q\
'.~
!tq:lq
'<Or-
:~N
.",
g
o
10
10
~
1010
r<) 0\
~~
~
190
\n.V)
6\.r'<)
;.;,~
r<)
r-
,QI'l
..
..
1010
V) ~
.~~
~
~
N co .-.0 00
V; ,'. 'O:l'-: :0.oq
..-. ,~o,' roc ..\0
.~ 'v:' ~ ...~~......
.", ..... .\0
.l;;i ...~ .~
~
..
~
~
10
o
o
10
lJ)
~
010
'<t "'I
~g
r-
~
o
.0
.r-::
"'I
.r-
.~
w:~
cr-
,)0 ~
~ .~
.~
>-
CIl
....
~
<I.l
U
.;::
Q...
r<)
-
-
-
I
rJ:;
-
~
"0
;:::
<<l
.:.:
....
o
~
'€
<<l
UJ
,~
1-<
(I)
~>-
grJ:;
Or<)
ur-
.~ ::
~~
..r::: (I)
~.~
<rt
.
~ <n
r<) or,
j~
l"":
,.,.,
v;
:q
'~ .M
_ ."'1
r-
.~
"...
"...
.....
o
to
m
OJ
ro
a.
>-
CIl
.....
~
4,)
u
.;::
Q...
<I.l
~>-
CO[/)
.:.:r<)
ur-
or-
.... ....
6<2
.- <I.l
......l.~
- ....
00Q...
~ ~ ~ A ~~
Nc In J~ 5
...
_I.. "' 9
'\f J\ L J 1;;1;;1;
Pi. 7
f r1 ~
I; ~
8. Iq'" .~I.~8. '...f; .~
'0 "0 .'.'0 'lr.)'V'J ) V"l
."'." I 'Co rZl.r--; 01\,'
.\0 .. ,.ee'~ .I,Q
i.O I IS- .~
..... . I~
I~.~
."'t :S.
I;:~
I. ~
I~
'1"-
I~
I~
o ... OI>."V"l
C;:t;;... ....dl....
g lj)' ..... .~
:r2 ~ :;:;:;
....
0'0
f"-.Q'I
~oO
:f:oo'!\O
o
'f".!
I Eo"
'0
o
l.....
00
'0
l3
qO- .'
.'l;l. .
:It
~ .~
- .....
4,/
....
.....
'4,/
.=
:""':'"
.'.
'.'(
'0 '0
'0 '0
o 0
'0 '0
'0 N
~ I~
, >
'0
~
00
0\
0\
'-0
~
gg
00
O\N
;;~
Ib';
o
V"l
r<)
N
\0
I"-
I~
'0'0
'0'0
00
O'I~
-'0
b';~
'0
'0
o
o
-
o
o
o
o
V"l
o
;;
00
V"l V"l
I~M
I"""~
~
co
CO
~~
'0
~
'0
o
o
o
V"l
I~
o
q
o
o
o
V"l
I;;;;
o
o
o
o
~
(,l
=
....
U
::c
[;ol
I~
'.. ~I .::' ~
....<:.'.~.
t'-.liJG ["-
())CO'O>,
:-:tl;; .0:
...... 'i,;.i
I.~.M "l"'"l ~'.,;...j ir.l
I t"-I- r- 'N \0 V"l '00
I~,~ gg,'.' ~ I~:g zi
'.,lioC ,:Q,' .,"",V"l N1 "<t
'0\ ."" I"-t- m ,00
S '8;
.. 1t;9
:< ....r .....',..' ........ .... .'..
o 0
o 0
o 0
V"l r-
r<) r-
~ l~
o
r-
r-
r<1
.-,
~ ~ ,,~ ~ ~
'C ."f r<) - .~ 0
.~. = ."'<;0\ 00 ..... \0
~t N .... V)! ~ I~
.~'.; V"l ,'N :"11"
''C ..''''"
G:;<cl.. "
Q ..',
.
.
N
.~
..
",I '.
.
0'0
qq
C!~
.".
~
gg
"';0
r<1 00
;;::
Ib';
00
00
OC
00 oc:
- oc:
b';~
~
o
o
o
V"l
r-
'-0
I;;;;
o
o
o
V"l
r-
o
;;;;
o
o
o
0\
V"l V"l
r- N
l~~
\0
C!
V"l
N
0..:
V"l
N
o
q
'0
V"l
00
o
c:
N
<rl
.".
~
V"l
r-:
00
'0
V"l
ell
-
C
CD
E
CD
>
e
Q.
.5
e
::::J
-
U
::::J
...
-
-...
~ :
Q.~
- -
I'll =
::::: -
=
I~
-
IS
-
~
I;;;;
'. ..',. '.lgl g 1XI( 8 gg
.... .'",.~I,,....; ..'. f~ .>:t,' .... .,:..;.,....;
... '0\ .'..M .~ >>IEi"l'(;j\. ...
V"l, .trl,OO IT .Z: ....
- I'" .\0 .'. '-c:..
.~.".; .'.' .-:r.
.,...,
o
.~
o
'V"l
~
I~
:C:;:O$?
~o.o.-.
.. .~.~ ~.~
>, ,,',.. .;:;,- "'I .t;t.o;
..> ....1...,- ;;;;1.... ~
I> ..., .... < ...
,~oo "0 0
""''"'" '.''0 0.
,~ 00 .0, : N
,,,,,,.'0 0 V"l
r<1 V) "<t
. .,.~ ...I~ ,~
....1 ..' .,..
... ,.,1.
'0
o
..0
00
M
N
...,
""
.~
.-
"t
r-
'r-
.Cl
~
.=
-
~.
"'"
'Q;l
c
=
Q
~
~
~
.....
o
r--
<l.)
OJ
co
a..
".
.'
.
~
...
III
0..
CD
-
E
o
Q.
...
o
(.)
CD
~
III
...I
CD
-
1:
3:
16
....
~
~
u
'r::
Q..
1.-
~
cd
5:
"1:l
:::
cd
f
::l
I~
...:..:
....
~
51~
Q:l-
- 0\
Sr<1
I:: ....
e..9
cd ~
E.~
o~
.,
~
:
I~
~
~
~
I~
I~
I~
I~
I'
: ::I
rJ:J
~
;,.;J
~
~
~
~
~~
E-E-<
~o
QE-<
~~
~
llo.
<
~
~
<
==
~
::l
o
U
....
~
:::
.e
";j
l3
:.0
<d
v.;
....
~
"0
:;
.2$
r/) c:
.~ E
~ ~
co '5
'5 g
r./'J~
..;l
<
E-
O
E-
=
~
r/'1
[;ol
Z
<
..;l
'Z
cz::
~
. ~
~
~
~
..
'Z
o
~
Q..
;:
U
rJ'J
~
Q
>-
r/)
....
~
~
.~
....
Q..
""
Q;l
Q;l
-
E-
..c:
u
cd
~
Q,)
u
'r::
Q..
<d
I::
<d
~
<d
:000
<d ....
'S ..9
:E ~
::l U
&3g:
f
::l
r/)
u
'.E
U
~
m
o
-
tl
Q,)
I::
I::
o
U
..c:
U
<d
~
~
C,)
I~
(1)\0
.5 ~
'" ....
~.El
U Q)
~.~
::::Q..
u
"1:l
<d
E>-
::lr/)
r./'Jr-
"1:l-
~N
~-
.- ....
~..9
-
CI.l ~
U
N'r::
-Q..
u
I.;:;
<+-<
cd
....
f-
'-
o
u
U
I::
<d
c:
~
C
';;j
~
~
~
<d
::2
~
l~
.~
Ci3
-
";j
~
j
"E
<d
D
I::
.~
r/)
~~
~
-f
;i
.[
r/)
::;
~
E-
-
.o.L-
,~IGlNll'h
,
O'l
-
"0
iii
I"~' \~ 2 3 1999
8'
Pi.
II)
-
c:
Q)
E
Q)
>
e
Q.
.5
!
::I
-
U
::I
...
-
II)
IV
...
....
.E
~
...
IV
C.
Q)
-
E
o
Q.
...
o
U
Q)
~
IV
..J
Q)
:::
.c:
~
N
-
0)
N
I
0)
0)
'*I:
'tJ
CD
.'~ ~.~ .... 8. 8. .... ~ ~
.'t:\' .' M "t 0000 .... t""'- r--
~ . ~.g: ;:'~ ~ ~
:s li.'l~ I~.::, ~.....
Z - '''''' I;;;
::= '
~ ...
" .
00
00
00
r-- -
1:-: 0'
U 1'Tl;2
::
""
C"I
"
-
00
00
00
00 00
-0
I""'i;;'
00
00
00
00 00
I~ r--
I~
~
~
t--
;;;
o
~
o
0'
~
00
:::>0
~~
~oo
.~
00
00
00
N 00
;;;0
I~
00
C!.~
00
-N
c::
00
00
\ON
-M
~I~
00 .. IS? 0
:~$ I'~":'@
;,o'N -
~~.;:;; .~
'..
00
00
00
r--"t
~~
coo ~o 00 ~ 00 M;,o:~O
.'C 0 M ~ ~,.. V) \(") ~ ..... V'> '01" "'! t".J ". N.:lJ')
~ " c..:N'" NM "to'\ ~ -00 .N\(") M.'O
... l. ;,0 "t . 00 g 1;9 0' ... .... N;,o -.N \ON
.;! ef ~ ~ .' :;;; - ,~ ~ .':: ;::: ~,~ ~I~
~~ ~ ."~ ".~..I< '~
Ii ".. ~: ..,.
.~ ..,1 ... < I
00 00 00 0
00 00 00 ~
00 "'0 00 '"
!::~OO M- "'''' M
~ ~ ~I ~ ;;; ~ I ~; I ~
::c~
. '(J.
C
-
~
'"
CII
C
"
'0
.::Q
00
00
Nd
NO
;;;I~
z
o
1=
~
C2
u
rJ)
""
Q
.:::
u
<'<l
V
V
u
.;:
Q.
<'<l
...
~
.- M
tiN
u ...
e<.2
.- V
~ .~
:E~
:;
""
Eo-
-
00
00
..f-<i
MO
;:>0
."".~
-
U
<'<l
W
V
U
.;:
Q.
V
'(;j
...
o
:E\O
Ec8
;:l
.- <l)
"0 u
'r;; .~
Q.Q.
g8.
.'<t '<t
!R~
WO
,;j
-
U
o:l
W
V
.~
...
Q.
<'<l
"
o:l
'2
'E _
.;;: M
'" ...
S<.2
... V
V u
le~
o
o
I;}:
I'":'
I"'"
o:l
V
::
~
o:l
.~
;:l
..c
u
..c
<'<l
f-
00
~~
'" '"
I~~
~
00
~~
Mr--
M'<t
I;;; 00
;;
....
. ,'.
'"
5
-;
ll.
.:::
u
<'<l
W
V
U
'C
Q.
o
t:
VO'
E",
~ ...
...<.2
'(;j 8
~.t::
Cl)Q.
00
00
.no
M r--
I;;;I~
00
00
0\00
!T) .......
r~l~
.:::
u
o:l
W
V
U
'C
Q.
s
V"J
;:l
..c
o
...
o:l
'2
ON
e:i ...
.5 <.2
.::: V
(/l U
CIl ._
~Q:;
00
00
00
'" 0
~I~
I" g .8.t8. .~
I" I 09 oo:c:;i
.3;' ~ \l!lv
'-.
00
00
.no
-M
I~~
VlO
l"--\(")
Ir-;,', ,l"-
100
~.~
00
00
.no
\0 M
~I~
. .
.
.... ,.'
gg
N\O
~M
~I~
00
00
00
t;'"
_. ~
.~:~g8
oo.~ :o{:."'
'(?!.~ .ii:~
..... .,.~i.. .'.i.
,.".:.1..
I.. ;..: I
"., ".,
"'!<:
~~
I~
00
-<:
~G
".,
I~
~I~ ...00,... \0.:""', ',..c tS,', ,'0
""".0 . 00 - 'I"lj .\1.; ....0
.....I~,. ' "0,' : .~, ......Ir-;, ~ .M, . ~ >..0
S"ti 'S; V'1 11~Z1 .~.:.~
:.. ..... ....... "E;
..
.. '.. .'.'
... .':' .,.,... ....
'..1
00
00
c..:.n
~M
-'I~
00
00
N\O
I!"::: r--
I~,~
gg ggg8
... .. ..:.,. -
<:> 0 s;a; .... M~
~I~ .~ '<t ..' .:..I~:~
I '.. ...1, <I',....
,.. .... ....
.:::
u
CIl
W
u
.~
...
Q..
o:l
-
VJ
::l
..c
o
...
o:l
'2
ON
~ 5
.- <.;::.
.::: 0
~ .~
::J:~
.:::
u
o:l
W
o
,~
...
Q.
.lS
VJ
::l
..c
o
...
o:l
'2
ON
~ 5
.- "'"
.::: 0
'" u
o:l._
::J:~
'"
-
c
CII
(J.
(J.
<:
..c
u
o:l
W
o
,~
...
Q.
-...
o
~
.'"
VJ
"
o
eoo
...
o:l ...
0<.2
5 8
~ 't::
Cl)Q.
O'I~'
o
6
00
1b'!IS
..c
u
o:l
W
o
u
.;:::
Q.
<'<l
o
u
CIl
...
<E",
<2 ...
CIl<.2
's 8
~J::
"., ".,
<:\0
I~~
~
"., '"
NN
I~g
'"":
"'"
v,,,., oo't
\t)."<t '.' ~....o
10-- N 100...0
IV. r-- IlOo'l M
, r:: \0
'.''''' "';J
.
'"
.Q
=
l.
.J:
TJ'.J
..c
u
~
W
o
.~
...
Q.
~
CIl
o
:=0'
,- M
6 ...
"- <.E
~ 0
::l U
0'-
r:o~
..c
u
CIl
W
o
U
'C
Q.,
~
.~
SM
CIlO'\
's ...
0<.2
..:;: 0
..:. U
0:'-
ejQ:;
.....
.....
"'-
o
co
Q)
C)
ctl
CL
AaEfKl .!~
&0. u_ 1...:1)..s
HAI?? 1999
Pe. '1
III
-
c:
Q)
E
Q)
>
e
c..
.5
Q)
~
::l
-
U
::l
~
--
~
~
ca
a.
Q)
-
~
o
c..
~
o
to)
Q)
~
ca
..J
Q)
-
:E
3=
\"I.
i
~
iD
~
"C).
=' '.
~'.~
loO":
4/' .
-
_.
. 4/ .
=
'~
.....
=
.~
rn
!i
00 0 0 <:;; 0 0> 0
~ "t; ~.~ "'.R IIZ:. "l
r-.. \C 15:;;""" t"">N., If'- J.T)
I~ ~ ,t\~: '.t.>I'~~II(,I; ~
" ' ",., .;;
... !< ....
I.. ...
'.. "
CoI
C
-
V) <ro
00 -
!Cl ;g
;;:1
rJ
::c
~
t-- .......
M>:r
"C). .
= r92 ,v)
l. I~ \0
~;;:1
4/ "
'e
=
;;:I
V) V)
N r-
'" ,S; N
... ...,v~OO
~~ ~
l. _
" =
::c l.
==
Noo
CoI "'t'.......
.s .~ gj
i' ,~
~
2 ..
.=
~
,
:z:
o
E=
~
C2
U
rJJ
~
Q
..J::
u
<':l
l.l.l
'l.l
u
.-=
Q..
b
20'\
. .......
~c2
<':l Q)
8,~
~Q:
~
f;I;l
1-
-
V) V)
00 0'\
I~~
1;;:1
t"">0'\
MM
I~ 0,
I"" "1'
I~
.
V) v",
N r-
I~~
I~
1..f"':l.V'.
.0'\ '..0
r---:r'"i
l~ r-
~
..J::
u
<':l
;.;.l
Q)
.~
....
Q..
E
::l
Il.l
U
<':l
V
cJl
E!:::
::l ~
- ....
~..;::
.2 do)
c::.~
Q) ....
c..c..
V)O
00 <ro
Cl~
I~
t-- 0
MO:
'~~
.~
V) 0
N V)
~~
;:;;
~~
~8i
.~
..J::
U
<':l
i.I.l
v
.~
....
Q..
S
::l
..9
'ii
'"
=
00
-tir-
= ....
~..;::
o Il.l
:-:: u
..J:: .-=
Q..Q..
V) <ro
00 .......
,c; :.::
00
1~8
0:-.0
I';" \0
,~ ('l
~ Io"i
~
V) 0
'<1" .......
o;N
I::;' r-
I""':~
.~~~I~
r: M. .&1.00
or. M '>0
-'~~IJt I~
[.1.... ....
J< ....<1
.~o
',,:,:.-.:1; ..
t~81
I~
<roo
NO
,zj ~
I~
I~ g ,...p: ~l" ,<'~'~"".lJ;;;t
Ii la $i~:'r~>:~la
.. ,........f ... .... .... ....
00 V)V) V)V) VOlO
VOlO Nr- r-r- r-o
S ~ c; ~ Icj &5 d. ~
I~I;; N ....... I~
I~ ,~
f"-r-;
IS.- ;
ct
VOl V)
N r-
Cl~
\0
~
l':!:l" . VOl . Ie .1;0
1'-':'<1:... 0
.~ ~ "I~ 'g:i
; .;;
..
..J::
u
'"
l.l.l
Il.l
U
.-=
Q..
<':l
.~
"'0
.5 _
.~ ~
'l.l ....
0";::
:..a v
] .~
~~
..J::
u
<':l
l.l.l
v
.~
....
Q..
Cl1
=
.~
11)'<1"
....-
<':l ....
'B c.8
;.::: CI)
Q) U
J:l'-=
r/)Q..
<ro VOl
0<1~
~~
~
,~
00
000
I~~
0'\
,~
.ire, or,
~"'11
r- 0,.
~~
'<1"
N
f&'l
000 0000
". ..... Oi ...,-:N.
I~ lr\ .' ~'<r!
.~..,. '"",~
..... I~
...~
...
.... ....
.
..J::
u
<':l
U.l
Il.l
U
.-=
Q..
<':l
....
~
~
u
<':lr-
"'00
EM
::J ....
~..;::
~ 8
'C 'C
!-Q..
'"
...
41
;.
=
CoI
'C
=
=
=
...
'"
'2
o
'"
....
<':l
fl..
'"
.~ V)
=0
~VOl
.- ....
..J::..;::
U 11)
C .~
.:;~
..J::
v
<':l
U.l
II)
.~
....
Q..
..J::
u
<':l
l.l.l
II)
u
'C
Q..
<':l
Il.l
<':l
u
<':l
o
.;;: \0
<'1'"
.- ....
~..;::
<':l V
::S u
~J:
18: ~8.n 8r IR:~ :f6
o~ .1<:1.;.;.......r-;.
:tiO\ ~ I.,..'
.~.>;o 1':'-.<r)
'...:..,. ti-l I~
,..,.. ;...-; I~
.
\0 ~
N 00
Is.'$
VOl
VOl
~
oO.~ 0
'.'N<r! .,.,
ci~ N
I~.~.,.... .0
'.'\0 .. .....
,.'.~ [~
..
','
.'.
00 N
N VOl
g~
r-
\0
~
.
o
o
o
VOl
I~
r- M
-M
sr::
M
~
,'~~
IgE
V'l
N
..""
o
c:
V)
~
I~
~\O
....... \0
s.~
r-
~
~.' oc::;...'. 0.,..'..... f.;.
.... "':N. ~.(s. .~
I.~'~ ~ .~ ~
: 1 .... 0\;;: N
.' ....'..
.,1....2 .... ...' ~
'.. .,: ......... '...[.. ..
.... .... ..... .,.' .,..
'"
=
=
41
=
.!'!
'ii
\ol
'"
~
I{
~
'C
v
;;-
.8
....
.8
u
~
=
o
I S:1 .....
-0 r/)
o '<1"
r/) 00
'l.l 00
c.....'"
',,= rJ) lr)
'" .... ....
~~..;::
::l v v
.(.~ .~
- .... ..
r/)Q..Q..
=
.~
r/)
"'0
=
:..a
Il.l
Cl:l
o:l
V
....
.(
.....
r/)
~
v
.~
....
Q..
I~
Il.l
Il)
o
I~
1'- .....
..J::r/)
~'"
=S~
~'"
~:.::
<':l ....
~..;::
'l.l V
=.~
.- ....
Q..~
~
.a
<':l
z
=
<'1
V
[)
"'0
=
<Il
::t
N
~
....
M
o
o
I~
..;r:
~
N
'00
.00
N
I~
M
M
N
00
0'\
N
I~
....,..;
'1"'1
00
..,
.....
I~
~
1-
o
1-
==
;;:I
rn
f;I;l
~
<
U
rJJ
Q
~
~
..-
..-
.....
o
en
C1l
Ol
CO
a..
~ A ITEM.
~ '''fAllS
J 10 ? 3 1999
Pi.
/0
I
III
-
C
41
E
41
>
e
Q.
.5
f
;:,
-
~
;:,
~
-
III
lU
.;
.E
~
~
lU
c..
G>
-
lU
~
o
Q.
~
o
o
G>
~
lU
..J
G>
;t::
~
~
N
"""
en
N
.
en
en
'Jt
"0
in
~.
....
. .ac
.....
VI
zi.
~
"C
.llS
~. C;I .'
lo.':
-0,1'
_.
.-.
~..
~..'
C.l
C
-
U
:c
~
'. QO
"C ... QO
E 00
ClII '.. -
.J..
.<11
'tI'
C
;;l
J.. ",
<II J..
c.<II
"'.::
C'; <=
:c '"
=
'C,j
.:c
-
.~..
.~
c
c.
=
~
z
o
E:
Q.
C2
U
VI
~
Q
~
\;Iil
Eo-<
-
00
.. .c::o.
',N N
.;..: .. N
... ,V; ... PO
- .M
.~ 'loP.
"
..' .,.. .',
o 0
0. 0
'" 0
00 0
'" '<t
;; ~
...,
.
, .
o
0.
'"
\0
\0
1;;;7
o . 0 ,;::.0,
00. ,-..,.,
-'-' r-- ('.l
M ,.,' >.0 ','....
v), ',:I~
I;;;;,""
.'
~
<
~
~
r
.
~
~
;;
c
.S
-
<<l
u:i
E
;::I
Q..,
c
,9
c;
.!:!
....
...::
'"
r--
00
>.0
\0
M
j;;:
o
0.
V')
\0
\0
;;;;
i
;::I
V"J
u
'5
u
v
W
.8
t)
Il)
c
c
o
U
~
'"
.00
g8
,.:.)Q
.\0
~
(,F.
o
o
o
o
~
00
-0.
~:;::
00
;;;;
'-0
0\
--
.~
"'"
';! ~
",,0:-
e;
.""
"'"
o
o
o
o
l~
"'0
M '"
.~~
'"
~
0'\ '0
",.;:;:
I;;; ::
Vl
~
....
Il)
:>
o
U
c
.S
c;
C/5
E
::I
Q..,
e
.S
c;
.!:!
E
.....
..J
g
Il)
u
.;::
Q..,
Il)
e
:J
e
.;
::?2t.l..
e..J
00
~N
.S8 M
t:: ....
.....<.8
Mil)
-.... U
-'C
MQ..,
8.~
cON
I~;:,]
to'ii
'" 0
"1' 00
O\r--
I~M
'''''~
02~
0[;
'>.0 ~
-.;
00
00
"'0
I:'! co
''''';;;;
~..::=
~I~
~i~
.e
u
<<l
U..l
Il)
u
.;::
Q..,
'"
-;:
'0
Q..,
..:.:
u
Il)
.e
U
Il)
...
::I
Vl
Vl
~
Q..,
V "1'
.5 b
..J~
e v
.- U
<<l._
~o':
8~
I~~
00
N 00
"1'\0
15'2 M
I.....,:~
:=:'~
0;0
I~I~
00
00.
....."1'
I~ "1'
I~I~
~I~
. r-: ci
1;:1;1~
I~
.e
u
<<l
U..l
V
.S!
....
Q..,
Vl
V
...
c;
>
Il)
c;
o
c;
::I
;"1'
~ ....
<.8
Nil)
:::::; .~
....
NQ..,
8.1~
"1'lu.'.I
;;I~
V') '"
"1'-
000\
'" 0
1;;;;1;
\ON
~I~
,;;;;1";'"
I;;
00
'" '"
N r--
..... 00
I;;;;I~
N"1'
01"";'
,.:.)1-
'lr1 'r-
I ""I.;,'
.e
u
<<l
U..l
Il)
u
.;::
Q..,
Vl
V
:>
c;
>
...
V
e
::Ir-
o ....
U<.8
~V
.- u
::I .-
16 0':
o
<:;>
,.:.)
.0\
'r--
'i,.<j
.00 iQ'OO 0
:<:;.0. .'. I~<::; .f;';, '0
"..,:.N I:";N !Ir.)
b\lS i\CO\ ,'.:' 00
;;;,~ " I~ .~ ..,.
o
0.
V')
.....
~
00
00
00
00
.~~
~
M
..;;
....
~
""'N
'-.:I' .r--
.\O.~
,~QO
Ilr.~
o
q
V')
'"
~
00
00
00
"1'\0
I;;;;~
o
o
o
.M
.~
00
00
r~"N
I~:r<)
I;; ~
....
o
Vl
e
ClJ
Vl
e
.;
~
-S
.~
...
~
e
-;:
18
e
.S
c;
.!:!
t::
.....
.e
u
<<l
U..l
V
U
';::
Q..,
Vl
ClJ
;>
c;
>
'0
.t:l
e
o
U
ClJ"1'
8~
N ClJ
u
V") 'C
-Q..,
00
00
00
r--
I;;;;;~
..
~,~
r---:......;
~r-
-'I~
s;
~.
.;::
QO ',,0.0
.~ <::; 0.0.
;~ ~.~
~ l:":- ~.r-
-0,.. .... ::.. ...e,.
...
00
'" 0
0\0
~~
~
00
lJ"'\0
-.:r,.:.)
~\O
""I~
o
N
'"
o
N
r-
~
:>:t .,1"; N ....,$ 0 .... .... 00.... g
.~ .... ~QO,'~ ~........ .,;-:-.': ~.{ ;.:~ ~"....
<:;> ',' 00 V) NI ~. '" r--
~ f~~I~! I I~ ~
..."....}I Ii....
<tl<, <1< ....
00
00
00
N '-0
I;;;;;,~
lJ"'\ '"
M'<t
0000
,.:1 ....
1~1z;'
00
~~
'" lJ"'\
z;'~
IJ
00
00
0"\0
~'<t
-'I~
.,.,
"":
oc
'<t
M
r...:
~
I~o g '~;;::I ~I N .0\..'.. ~
" ee.' I~~, M,ool ~'~,': ~
- M I~ -.:f d\ '~N.;:r.
IJ]~.t : ~
'...[> t.... ....
....If , I
.e
u
<<l
U..l
Il)
.S!
....
Q..,
C/)
ClJ
:>
c;
>
'0
.t:l
e
o
U
vM
l:: ....
0<.8
Nv
: u
~ '0
-Q....
.e
u
<<l
U..l
V
.S!
...
Q..,
C/)
V
e
;:i
c;
....
V
c;
.....l
"0
e
<<l
C/)
....
o
-
o
~
g
g
Q..,r-
.e ...
~~ <.8
::z:: ClJ
r..>
N"t:
-Q..,
.e
u
<<l
U..l
V
.S!
....
Q..,
Vl
V
e
:J
c;
....
V
~
..J
"0
e
<<l
Vl
...
o
-
o
~
5
60
Q..,:!
"0 ....
~<.8
] ~
5"c
VlQ..,
c;
....
Q)
-
<<l
..J
'"0
e
<<l
Vl
....
ClJ
Vl
i:2
u
>
Q..,
o
00
.J:l
u
Vl
C
o
Vl
0... .e
- u
o <<l
~U..l
~,~ :!
.- '-t ~
~Q..,<E
..0] ~ ~
e ._
.- ....
Vl..JQ..,
~
.....
'-
o
o
~
(!)
OJ
co
Q..
~
Eo-<
o
Eo-<
=
;;l
Vl
~
o
-
Eo-<
<(
C,;I
~
...
~G~)Af~
N Ilpl-A. \S
.. --,
M. ~~ 2 3 1999
Pi. i{
~.
,'C.
:10
Q
"
Jo,;,
Qi
.-
_.
'Qi
'~
C,I
=:
-
III
- '"
r:: .. ..
Gl Q,I III
E Q.,C
.. -
Gl l'll =
> ::: ..
e Q:I
Co
.5
Gl C,I
~ C
::::l - ~
- ~ ~
u .....
::::l ~" 0
Ja. c ~
.c'
'.=- ~
:=: (J)
OJ
CO
.:.: a..
~
C'll
Q.
Gl
-
C'll
~
0
Co
~
0
0
Gl Z
.:.:
C'll 0
.J -
Gl ~
- Q.
:c ;
~ U
r./')
Io;:l
Q
en
en
=It
'tS
as
:;
\;I;J
~
-
AGENDA r~
No. jlt>(A. 5
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi.~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
~._..
REQUEST TO APPROVE FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF PEBBLEBROOKE
LAKES PHASE 3 AND APPROVAL THE PERFORMANCE SECURITY
OBJECTIVE:
To approve for recording the final plat of Pebblebrooke Lakes
Phase 3.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The Board of County Commissioners on January 12, 1999 approved
the final plat of pebblebrooke Lakes Phase 3 with the stipulation
that the plat not be recorded until security was provlded to
ensure completion ~f the required subdivision improvements.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The fiscal impact to the County is listed below. The
project cost is $453,510.00, to be borne by the developer.
.H........."
The security amount, equal to 100% of the cost to complete the
remaining improvements and 10% of the total cost of the project, is
$498,861.00. The developer has provided a Performance Bond as the
required security. The County will realize revenues as follows:
Fund: Community Development Fund 113
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138900 - Development Services
Revenue generated by this project:
Total: $9070.80
Fees are based on a construction estimate of $453,510.00 and were
paid in August, 1998 and are reflected in the Executive Summary of
January 12, 1999.
AGitoA ti:)'
No.
MAR 2 3 1999
/
Pg.
r"'.....'.._,
Executive Summary
Pebblebrooke Lakes Phase ~
Page 2
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the final plat of
"Pebblebrooke Lakes Phase 3", with the following stipulations:
1) Accept the Performance Bond as security to guarantee
completion of the Subdivision improvements.
2) Authorize the recorcl.lng of the final plat of II Pebblebrooke
Lakes Phase 3".
3) Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached
Construction and Maintenance Agreement.
4) That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the
required improvements have received preliminary
acceptance.
~
PREPARED BY:
Jc~..l l~ d,~~'t ~
John R. Houldsworth, Senior Engineer
Engineering Review
(. - l~ .po.q
Date
REVIEWED BY:
jo l~J
rN"lV Tomas E. Kuck, P. E.
[- n neering Review Manager
o
"1 ~ /'S :- qq
Date
:; 1~' Sl
Date
Director
APPR~?D BY:
1fTh1 t7 ~
~-
~/~-~
Date
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
Community Dev. and Environmental Svcs. DIVISION
--
jrh
AGi('~
No.~,4\a
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. O?
\1
r/
I'C"' J
~ .~
t' (~
01
~
PLAT
SHEET
BOOK
1
PAGE
OF 4
LAUREL OAK ~
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 23 ~
22
27
OAK RIDGE -'
MIDDLE SCHOOL ~
~
<t
o
~
r 35
g LOCATION MAP
8 N. T.5.
33
34
MORTGAGEE'S CONSENT
5
tl.IAT1f"\"IAI Ql1t1.IV 6. "'t,Tl('\"'~' D "''''11/'''''1''' . ,.....-"',-... -''-''
ROAD <C.R, 846)
PEBBLEBROOKE
LAKES
26
~
AGENDA n'EM
No. / It> ( IJ.) tc
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. 3
Mar-03-99 04:16P
P.02
COLLIER COU~TY LA.l\D DEVELOPMENT CODE
COl\STRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEME~T FOR St:BDIVfSIO~
IMPROVEMENTS
THIS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTE'ANCE AGREEME1\T FOR SUBDIVISIOr.;
IMPROVEMENTS entered into this ________ day of ___~_ 19 between
Kenco De\'elopment [nc., hereinafter referred to as "Developer," and the Board of County
Commissioners of Collier County, Florida. hereinafter referred to as the "Board".
RECIT ALS:
A. Developer has. simultaneously with the delivel}' of this Agreement. applied for the approval by the Board
of a certain plat of a subdivision to be known as Pebblebrooke Lakes Phase 3:
8. Division 3,2 of the Collier County Land Development Code requires the Developer (0 post appropriate
guarantees for the construction of the improvements required by said subdivision regulations. said guarantees to be
incorporated in a bonded agreement for the construction of the required improvements.
'OW THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants hereinafter set forth.
Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows:
). Developer will cause to be constructed the Required Improvements within ] 2 months from the
date of approval said subdivision plat, said infrastructure (water, sewer. drainage and roadway)
improvements hereinafter referred to as the Required Improvements.
2. Developer herewith tenders its subdivision performance security (attached hereto as Exhibit
.. A" and by reference made a part of hereoO in the amount of S 94,192.14 which represents
10% of the tocal contract cost of completed construction plus $ 578,146.75 which represents
100% of the estimated costs to complete the Required Improvements at the date of this
Agreement for a total of $ 672,338.89.
3. In the event of default by the Developer or failure of the Developer to complete such
improvements within the time required by the Land Development Code, Collier County. may
call upon the subdivision performance security to lOsure satisfactory completion of the
required improvements.
4. The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a statement of substantial
completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records have been furnished
to be reviewed and approved by the Development Services Director for compliance with the
Collier County Land Development Code.
5. The Development Services Director shall, within sixty (60) days of receipt of the statement of
substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of his preliminary approval of
--
AGENDA ITEM
No. Ib fA) fp
MAR 2 3 1999
'-I
Pi.
Mar-03-99 04:17P
P.03
the improvements; or b) notify the Developer in "'Titing of his refusal to approve
improvements, therewith specitying those conditions WhlCh the Developer must fulfill in order
to obtain the Director's approv'al of the improvements. However in no event shall the
Development Services Director refuse preliminary approval of the improvements if they are in
fact constructed and submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this
Agreement.
6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum period of one year
after preliminary approval by the Development Services Director. After the one year
maintenance period by the Developer has terminated. the Developer shall petition the
Development Services Director to inspect the required improvements. The Development
Services Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found to still be in
compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code as retlected by final approval by
the Board, the Board shall release the remaining ]0% of the subdivision performance security.
The Developer's responsibility for maintenance of the required improvements shall continue
unless or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for and by the County.
I. Six (6) months afterthe execution of this Agreeme:" j once within every six (6) months
thereafter the Developer may request the Devdopm; ...ervices Director to reduce the dollar
amount of the subdivision performance security on the basis of work complete. Each request
for a reduction in the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security shall be
accompanied by a statement of substantial completion by the Developer's engine~r together
with the project records necessary for review by the Development Services Director.
The Development Services Director may grant the request for a reduction in the amount of the
subdivision perfonnance security for the improvements completed as ot the date of the request.
8. In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to fulfill its obligations under this Agreement.
upon certification of such failure, the County Administrator may call upon the subdivision
performance security to secure satisfactory completion. repair and maintenance of the required
improvements, The Board shall have the right to construct and maintain. or cause to be
constructed or maintained, pursuant to public advertisement and receipt and acceptance of
bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision
performance security, shall be liable to pay and to indemnify the Board. upon completion of
such construction. the final total cost to the Board thereo[ including. but not limited to.
engineering, legal and contingent costs, together with any damages. either direct or
consequential. which the Board may sustain on account of the failure of the Developer to
fulfill all of the provisions of this Agreement.
9. All of the terms. covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon the
Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Board and the Developer have caused this Agreement to be executed by their
duly authorized representatives this __ day of ___, 19_.
2
AGEND" ITEM-
No. /f;(A)~
MAR 2 3 1999
~
Pg.
SIGNED. SEALED AND DELIVERED
Mar-03-99 04:17P
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
A ?~Wl
If- . Ie. () r1c:
\: Itness
~ b,s~-p
( Print name)
ATTEST:
Dwight E. Brock, Clerk
P.04
By: KE]\'"CO Development. Inc..
BOARD OF COlfl'J"TY CO\1MISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency
Pamela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
Assistant Cour.lY Attorney
.~
(!)
3
AGENDA ITEM J
No. 1(P (Ir) ~
MAR 2 3 1999
b
Pi.
:...,,, - .;~ .\1
}~ "1 ~'f+-,.:..:yt
'~'d"'" .
.c.
-~ - -. '.. .
. - - "; .,..;.. -
_ ~'l ~
- .. . ... .
! , - H...: ;
- ~
.. ~
.~ -,\,'; 1 _-
-. ,'-,...
,,,-,,,-,'-'''''--''---
;: -..
- 'T
_ i. ~
.~ :.IE',y = --:::. -.;
..:.. .:..
"
_l"; L':":':"
-----
- .-
,';'.i:lY
E. DC:-:
.-..~----.....-,._... -",.,..-., ......~~.....,
.....l.. '::':r.:.-.r':... _."i.;'~1 .t:.=-
'.____ _.. ___'i~=::.~?: _....~
- -- .-. ,. --.~.
-. - ...-
....~,~-~....-,-.
. - - = - .:.. '.:=
~Ei'-iLF=
. ~. - - ...........-,
. 7 ~.:.. _.~:,.:
.....-,...... ~.""-- -,.-.
~..t..I...:.~:: ~=-~.~L
..,.. "', .-.
- - - - --
I." ,-',""'"
"
- --:..'!'..-:"
-....--:..:..; :..
-~'~r--
------
-~. ~~,_':.:._.. -
.- ~.,. "= ;-, ~ -::;.' 1-:-;:(
. - - - -" - -..., "-'
- po.. - - ',' - - -,... --. -
- . . . - ~
'-<0'- _...".
.-' ~ '.......... "
- ......~., -
- _...,.--........ - -....
- -' ...'-, ...... .:.: ~ -..-I.. .-, ..'. ...
.:.. ..i.l-o
". ,...........
- . ,.. ,.,...
-' -..- , ~ ..... .....
.~..- ,- -.... -....--.-
~. [I: 1': "':.:-.:: .... ,_: i',.l':" _--, :'
_. -.,. - -.,....,-
'- '-' - -- .... .;...... ....,.
-.. .- -,.,. -. ..
:: .;... '..:' r"~ ~ :-1 ~.
.----_..., ----
._ ~ -..':" .:...1,-:. = -....
. -= ~ -....r '":" -= - -. -
- -. - _. - "','" ~ ..- - - -,,".-
:... _' ~ J,'. =- i:- r'. ......' \..;r
:=_ E '\' :: E. '.~.:
: ~ -. - . ,-, "7.7
- -'- ... - -.., .
,-,
:-1i:'R~E2:E,:.::
-
.~ - -: -- ~
34~:::~1
.: .- "",", .-.
:~ ;'-' :,j.. - -
-_.,-,~'...' -1-'-'-
c' :-;
- .... -
.. --'.. ..........-......
- ..., ....
.. '."-, ............~ ~,' - ..... rT'\"T
..: _ ...,: ;..' :: C i.... j, ~-; ~ n J.
::. _ 0;:
,:'.I',.ID
w _
:_: : I ! T E ~:
:' 'T .1:.. "'I' E '::
=,::.! L.... ......::'"-.-
:::.
. ....., ,-..,-..,....,.-.-.
.-. ...: -=:": ~ -.- ,~. -
'T"I U r:-, 'C"",'- ':"'
,- i ..-
.---.......---
. . "":'" -. ~ T
;.... .. - - -,.:T ~
.'~_ r'~ _ _: ~-. .-, .....
....; :-. .:.'~ .'
:.: ;.~. .,t !'LS ~ .. -:
~G;::-iET 20CU~~~~::3
-. - -. . - . -'.~.
_~_o~l......:........
~ E ? E :: ~.;
\;ir
::: :- "_T H ":;" .... :-- ..... :. ":;. -;:
-;.....:.._- ....__.~...-
:'E.!..FT':'
. ~
,-. ~
-, ~ ~ :.!;~,I
-----
- - -". ...
;F-=-==~: .
~ .;'11;( .
.: : :. ._'I-,1:S:.-~ ~
-,-_.,--:,,~
_-. z:.. '...:.t' u ~:. r:.....-'
fo. '0' .-, _ ;... :-.~::.: ~!:.
B::':~'~LF: ::,'.:.-:':
- -." -.-
_ :t..r.": __
:
:,p A,\tJN
'-:.:}.! T~1E
:~E
,::. ~:.' :. :f ~~ F .l.. ~,I : E: - : E l-T E:.? = _ _. ..'._
7' !.. -:-::: '1::: i' 1
_ . . _ .- ._. _ '""M....... __, ~ ~-
- :...:~::-- i._'~~ ~ ,:...... ~_
:. _-= ~'l t. ~ ~ 1.
.'- :. ;': : : -:: : ':' R Ale R
-. --..... ~ ... _..,........--,
- - -
..: :~.TC .:; :'E~7S: ~ ,:,F ;'1E1':1 ~ : lor C
~ '.: F ~: ...,. s >~ E !-,~:- ~ ;: s :. :: C :: ~ :- ;: ::
C' ..-'.:. -. _~....
::J!'.~SI2:_'\_",
.-..i"4W
~T1 ..... I 1,1 T .:. : (i THE
- ~-,
.... _ .""'i
:":~:.;I~J :-L.;.<.~
',-' ....
.:J i_' z: ~ : "'.- : -:: I -:' l:: r~ 1": Ci ~it IT
Ae,
- --'-,,!, ~_.'l""",,_,_,-
- _ -= .;: _ ..:.. ~ :---. l.... '_ :'. .:..
~ .~ :': t: '':
? ~,;::.Z
~= ]T A L
I ~..j E: FEC:- : .J !,r
.,.. ~ -:- -:-:- ~, ,-. ~- 7"", .,..-
~ ~ ,- ~ ~. ',' ~ '
..J .. _ _ ..' _ ., '_ .. '- -. -
:: ~:' ~ LIE ~
nM~'
~_..... __"\'f'
=,1:.. t... .:."~
:: E R FeR ;.'. ::: :
_. _. _,... T"'".
:-:".":" \-' .......
.....,... ......,...
:. -' . ,.
:F
_~"....., - T"'" ......
=-_'...r- ~!'"... J. .
~,r~ D
_, .. --.. ... ,.. .,..... . .-, ~.'""l."'-'''~
':: .'-. ""' _ :. ~ .u. '_ .;. '-,' r: .:..
- - -. " - -
. - .... .....-..... - -
:: :: r.? c<r:: H A l~ '.2 2.
,-.- ..... -~ ,..-. ..~
-:t.-_:.Jrr.l..;._
< ,-', 'T'
:-"- ...
BEC:N
....... ,_, __......,. - ~ r-
:-':",".'-': - ....: ~:....-
~?l [i
- - -." ~
-: -_, rt !"1 :.:.. ~ .i... i.
1. ,- .- ....... T"'I -.,... ,.-
t".1..... '_'':'';: i. .:.. L
:- HE 3 Z l.r 2 F :: C :: A R :" ...
.... .'. c"-.?:-
:: ~ A ~..J t.!
L l,r :.1 E ? -= i-! : :;
.. ._--:-1'--.
..... .:.. .i. ~ =- tr.
j. -,
,_, .i.
'_ r..c...... j,. .I.
>i ;";S:-
~ -
~~
.'-i ..... r.... f'.. i::.:...~
.; : rt? ~/]lr
OJ i E:' E R
?I;(;-
'."''7 - --1..-: ',-'.- ~ -...- ,: - -." -....,,!'
_.' ..:.._ 4'. .;.~ .'-'" .1 i. :_'.:.. ,.... ~ :J~. .'~ r..
'-' - -
-.......... ... --'.
- - ...... _ -""""' ,\T-\
--' r......c:. ._) _..;. ..''/ L. .
:::1;40';E3~;1;
- '" .......--.
.!...'?.:...::. _.'
.i......
THE
-'-,'" ,-. .......,..-
_ :".. _ :~ ,j" ..~ i-\ i...
i..ZTTER CF
cr;~E:.I:
,. ..T-.
.... J.'~ >.!
. . 1
ML...
A !~~ E :'7 [, H E l! T .:
IF
I:':"" j.'; .l ~
~IU2: EE ?RE5ENTED FOR
~~CFER ~:JDCRSEMEI1T.
- - ': T l., N I:' ~ ': T_ S T '" :: ? n ]:I C ~. S D : T .: rn = S' iJ R T H ::: H F U L L -=-:-: E ~ t: ;:;: ~-: s " -:' H E I S SUE R ':
-' '-' '..... ,~
. . \ - - - - -..., , ;' ;- :",";.-
_: .:. ~ .:,... .:.,. .-_ .. .:........ :-. .;.. .j. 't ,~
-";" 1-.,.....
.... ;,~
,...;...;..,j .i.
...Jr-_ .:..
~......
l'.:;:,:':F--:-:-
.;.;.. H El'lD E:i
: 1=:
-----_.._.--
_ ..... ~~, __ .~ ~\ ;.. r;,.:
.::~.W"l....:.A _~'......
,._~...-.... .... T""'I"'~""
-,.'.:~.i.r .:..~~
~ 1. ? E FER E T.; C E
;U7 :~CUM2tlT. I!{S7RUMEN:~ 2R AG?EE~':E
--: =: ?~ E I ~,r :,_, rt
~ ... ~
"... - -..
'..~ ~ ~ '--, n.
'"""\ 'i ","",...
~:ANLBY L~!TER ~ C~E~:: EE:~:SS
_L.,l-?IJ
~ -". - ffEM- W .
i,! Y , ::, ;j C H ~ (1,<<1..,:'\. . (
':' N4,.. _,~L .'f),
-.:.. ,-'.:..'~.i. _...JI..i.Ji.......'...
MAR 2 3 1999
.=..::: E'" ~:' Fr.!.: E
"':' t"'~ 0'\ L :...
,..:-,.....
.....~ U 4
=~EHE::
:: ~~ ':. C R F '::' Ft ~::... T E
H E E E : :-.; =, 1
--.........,-..........,.
... ~ ... -! - - ,,'
............ -.;.,........'
=~:.;;-=-:.~HE:N-=-
.=-. :; :; E ::: :"~ E 1-,~ .-;
=2~JZ? ~:E~3~ El~G~GES ..~-u
- .....,..-.........-.... .
- ~ '.! .... - -, '---:--
.....-.-...--..--....... -
. ~. .-. ...
='R.;:'.F~
,..., - "' ,-...,.
. .....;.:.. ......'
,..!"W
--.,---1....--
___ .. , :- .:... .i. ..... f'~ '-, .to
. ~ - ~~.
., ' . .....
.. ..... - "
~ t,.'1.
:- :: R ~.-! S
-' -.' ...~. .... '-'
.. _.- - -----
,i. _ ~"-1 ~-,' .:~ ~ _
pe.: GEE
~:7
-:.: ~ :::'~-=-=:-
.' - -1'.... ....
. - ~ ......" -..-
~...,~L::-:-:-:
.- '0..... r
_ :1 l. ~
- - ,!,,",,-, -,..,...
_ .i........... _ ..;.
"
.,.....il!:""\
.~, ~ "'.. . :,~ "I(
:.- " !'-
.. /) -
.. /
.'
4itJ@t{tlj!
-- --:- ..:..--...
. - -,;,- - - -
-
-
. .-,. .-..
- \-~ 7" -=
"
::
Pi.
s.- """, ~--~..
:;~ ~~~.
- -,--- -".--~
~ _ " ' ..; f"'l
- -~. - - .-:.., .........
.... ..';
- ... ... -'
- .,... - --.
,.-'- ....
-
. ~ '"- ..' - . . ...... ~.
-f.7---
=.: .: Ul,T....,...
_ .........~. _ _ .'"".
-.---'-,- ~--
=-.. -~ - -' .:: .:.. :'. - - ~
~~ E . ,-c ~ == ._:
.. -. .- - -
- !-.;
'-~ = :. .:' ~ ~ ~. ;.~, :E
______ _ __....._T"".
..,. - - - _.., I'"
_~__..__-....... ____..._..10
-,-,-
-: '....' ,r:
~. __'_ ,_; i'., 1
;-. .:.. ,r~ '_' "-
S:.~T~~~1ENT
.:-iEFE
.,-, - . .-. --.
..-~::' ......, ~'-:,
,... --- '...! t;'!;:
- - -. -- ...-.
::-~Rl-!S
.:.. i-.,r D C :-=, t! S I ':::' I C N ~- E Z ?1 .~ I N
JRIGINAL CREDIT INSTRUMENT.
- -----
....c...._.t..Z'.
--',.... ,.
.._.0....:
.,,, - -,... -
- :. -, -' -- .. ,-'
...~---- ',.
_..~ ~ ;':-' ::".:":
r .-'1 "J;:;:
- -:::' .: rr'
'.1, .. '!..S "':'"
.. - ....-
...... . ,. __ _, ..... ._, ,-. T"''' .,""'" ~ r";"" ~ ,--
..:.. ...:-n..c..'::.-:,.i....l .:...i.i~l.':"~
- . -. -.
- ...... , ......... '- ..
~ ;~. - !-l
:_;1.1 i: ;1 ,~. ~>:; ~ u
_-..- 'r"O...,......
r:.:.::"..~ ~ ~'J
:_' ::
': D H H E E ': ~
~' ; .; = ': : C E .s .. - :.- J C i: U :"~ ;: : ; -: .
__,......._,:...T:
- _' ;-, I
- _....;.....;.... ...
- ,~. r-.:~'
:...:Li Fi..
:; ',~ ,'. ",: ;:" :-.~,...,...
......-. -.. -"'-'-
:. - -~'
=: ~T T
~ ;',"f :.-
"
.....u
- . ~ .... '-
- -..,.....-, --..
......;f"\.cLJ.. ...
--.-T" - -;-"
_'::_ L~J.l. ..i. ~
~ -, '..J' .
...........;.. .:.,i-.,::t.::-",!--
l:";, I!
: c.. ~
-;HIJ"7S~~:'~
'.-' .:-..
THE
-- -- -.....
~ :....'::' - .:.. '..... ~ ........
_ :: ... j ~ E ":..- :: SID l'~} ~
AGENDA ITEM
No. I (p (jP/LJ
MAR 2 3 1999
q
Pg.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
LIEN RESOLUTIONS - CODE ENFORCEMENT CASE NO'S.
80720-120rrropicana Homes At Marco Inc. & Jose A Perez, 80722-0S7/Luis Alfredo
& Patricia Ann Carvajal, 80813-047/FJora Acosta & 80909-098/Daniel Liy
OBJECTIVE
Board to accept report and adopt separate Resolutions assessing a lien against the parcels
identified in the Resolutions in order to recover public funds expended to affect the
abatement of public nuisances at these locations, all as provided for in Ordinance 91-47,
the Collier County Weed, Litter and Plant Control Ordinance.
CONSIDERATION
As required by Ordinance 91~47, a Legal Notice of Assessment and copy of the
Resolution will be mailed to the respective property owners, and the Clerk to the Board
will record the resolution thirty days after mailing of the resolution.
Case No. Owner of Record Case Summary Lien Amount
80720-120 Tropicana Homes At a. Violation determination 08/03/98 $ 245.00
Marco Inc b. Notice of Violation served 08/08/98
. c. Verification of unabated nuisance 08/28/98
--.
d. Nuisance abated with public funds 09/03/98
e. Owner invoiced for costs 09/11198
80722-057 Luis Alfredo & a. Violation determination 07/20/98 245.00
Patricia Ann Carvajal b. Notice of Violation served Undeliverable
c. Verification of unabated nuisance 08/12/98
, d. Nuisance abated with public funds 08/21/98
e. Owner invoiced for costs 09/04/98
80813-047 Flora Acosta a. Violation determination 08/12/98 245.00
b. Notice of Violation served Undeliverable
c. Verification of unabated nuisance 09/16/98
d. Nuisance abated with public funds 10/05/98
e. Owner invoiced for costs 10/09/98
80909-098 Daniel Liy a. Violation determination 09/03/98 245.00
b. Notice of Violation served Undeliverable
c. Verification of unabated nuisance 09/29/98
d. Nuisance abated with public funds 10/14/98
e. Owner invoiced for costs 10/23/98
FISCAL IMP ACT
A total reimbursement of $ 980.00 may be anticipated by voluntary action or foreclosure.
The only cost to be incurred by the County is the cost of recording the Lien, which is
estimated to be approximately $ 28.00, and can be paid from Code Enforce"' F'ont
. 4GENDAI~
#111-138911. No. 1f,IA) 1
MAR 2 3 1999
pt. I
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT Not applicable.
RECOMMENDATION
That the Board of County Commissioners adopt the attached Resolutions.
PREP ARED BY:
JJ\' )~, .
{ ~ t l { (Ii. I [) 'u [~!f' III 01 \.. DATE:
Melo y Bridgem\m, Customer Service Representative
Code Enforcement
"1.#'\ ~ ~c::;
C>J.. t:.( '0....> .' I 1
REVIEWED BY:
DATE:
0}3/'1'1
Belanger, Senior Custome
Enforcement
REVIEWED BY:
i/i~vwi L-
Michelle Edwards Arnold, Director
Code Enforcement
h
L
"'\
DATE:
J~S-1(
A~BY~ ~
Vincent A. Cautero, AICP, Administrator
Community Dev. & Environmental Svcs.
DATE: 3- /S'- 7(
CSce 8 - 6/91
AGENDA ITEM
No. )t, fA) 7
MAR 2 3 1999
Pt. ~
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
LEGAL NOTICE OF ASSESSMENT OF LIEN
DATE:
Tropicana Homes At Marco Inc
% Jose A Perez
6317 SW _11th St
Miami, FL 33144
REFERENCE 80720-120 #56855720000
LIEN NUMBER:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
Lot 17, Block 79 of MARCO BEACH UNIT THREE, a Subdivision according to the Plat
thereof, recorded in Plat Book 6, Pages 17-24 of the Public Records of Collier
County, Florida.
You, as the owner of the property above described, as recorded in the records
maintained by the office of the Property Appraiser, are hereby advised that the
Compliance Services Manager, did on 8/5/98, order the abatement of a certain nuisance
existing on the above property prohibited by Ordinance 91-47, serving notice thereof
upon you, such nuisance being:
Prohibited accumulation of non-protected mowable vegetation in excess of 18" in
height in a subdivision other than Golden Gate Estates.
Weeds over 18".
You falled to abate such nuisance; whereupon, it was abated by the expenditure of
public funds at a dlrect cost of $ 45.00 and administrative cost of $200.00 for a total
of $ 245.00. Such costs, by Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier
County, Florida, have been assessed against the above property on
and shall become a lien on the property thirty (30) days after such assessment.
You may request a hearing before the Board of County Commissioners to show cause, if
any, why the expenses and charges incurred by the County under this Ordinance are
unwarranted or excessive or why such expenses should not constitute a lien against the
property. Such request for hearing must be made to the Clerk of the Board of County
Commissioners, Government Center, Naples, Florida 34112 in writing within
CLERK, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
thirty (30)
AGENDA ITEM
No. Iw(ft) 1
MAR 2 3 1999
..3
p,.
days from the date of this assessment to be valid.
CSce 9- 1/93
3(
3]
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57 APPROVED AS TO FORM
~8~~DILEG~L SfFFIf~~N~Y:
6l t J (t. < >i;l \.,./ ~.
6] j\~VIDWEIGEL
62 ~ COUNTY ATTORNEY
63
64 CSce 11 - 1/1/99
j
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
I I
12
13
14
15
]6
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29-
1-
RESOLUTION NO. 99-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
PROVIDING FOR ASSESSMENT OF LIEN, FOR THE COST OF
THE ABATEMENT OF PUBLIC NUISANCE, IN ACCORDANCE
WITH ORDINANCE 91-47.
WHEREAS, as provided in Ordinance 91-47, the direct costs of abatement of certain
nuisances, including prescribed administrative cost incurred by the County, shall be assessed
against such property; and
WHEREAS, the cost thereof to the Cou;-ty as to each parcel shall be calculated and
reported to the Board of County Commissioners, together with a description of said parcel; and
WHEREAS, such assessment shall be a legal, valid and binding obligation upon the
property against which made until paid; and
WHEREAS, the assessment shall become due and payable thirty (3D) days after the mailing
of Notice of Assessment after which interest shall accrue at a rate of twelve percent (12.0%)
per annum on any unpaid portion thereof.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, that the property described as follows, and having been abated of a public nuisance
after due and proper notice thereof to the owner of said property, is hereby assessed the
following costs of such abatement, to wit:
NAME:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
~
tropicana Homes At Marco Inc
% Jose A Perez
6317 SW _11th St
Miami, FL 33144
Lot 17, Block 79 of MARCO
BEACH UNIT THREE, a Subdivision
accord~ng to the Plat thereof,
recorded in Plat Book 6, Pages
17-24 of the Public Records of
Collier County, Florida.
$245.00
REFERENCE:
80720-120 #56855720000
The Clerk of the Board shall mail a notice of assessment of lien to the owner or
owners of the above described property, and if such owner fails to pay such assessment
within th~rty (3D) days hereof, a certified copy of this Resolution shall be recorded in
official records of Collier County, to constitute a lien against such property according
law, unless such direction is stayed by this Board upon appeal of the assessment of the
owner.
the
to
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote.
DATED:
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY:
Pamela S Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
AGENO~ ITEM
No. It, (A) 7
MAR 2 3 1999
pt.
4/
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
LEGAL NOTICE OF ASSESSMENT OF LIEN
DATE:
Luis Alfredo & Patricia Ann Carvajal
5205 McCarty St
Naples, FL 34113
Norman & Cleda Hedrich
10911 Bonita Beach Rd
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
REFERENCE 80722-057 #62046200006
LIEN NUMBER:
LEGAL DESCRI?TION:
Lot 24, Block 10, Unit 1, Naples Manor, according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat
Book 3, Page 57, Public Records, Collier County, Florida.
You, as the owner of the property above described, as recorded in the records maintained by
the office of the Property Appraiser, are hereby advised that the Compliance Services
Manager, did on 7/22/98, order the abatement of a certain nuisance existing on the above
property prohlbi~ed by Ordinance 91-47, serving notice thereof upon you, such nuisance being:
Prohibited accumulation of non-protected mowable vegetation in excess of 18" in height
in a subdiv~sion other than Golden Gate Estates.
Weeds over 18".
You failec ~c abate such nuisance; whereupon, it was abated by the expenditure of public
funds at a dlrect cost of $ 45.00 and administrative cost of $200.00 for a total of $ 245.00.
Such costs, by Resolutlon 0: the Board of County Co~~issioners of Collier County, Florida,
have been assessed against the above property on
and shall become a lien on the property thirty (30) days after such assessment.
You may request a hearing before the Board of County Commissioners to show cause, if any, why
the expenses and charges lncurred by the County under this Ordinance are unwarranted or
excesslve or why such expenses should not constitute a lien against the property.
Such
request for hearing must be made to the Clerk of the Board of County Commissioners,
Government Center, Naples, Florida 34112 in writing within thirty (30) days from the date of
this assessment to be valid.
AGENDA ITEM
No. j(p(A-)1
MAR 2 3 1999
S-
PI.
CLERK, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
CSee 9- 1/93
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31-
3'
3::-
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
6?-
(
f>.
65
66
1_
RESOLUTION NO. 99-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
PROVIDING FOR ASSESSMENT OF LIEN. FOR THE COST OF
THE ABATEMENT OF PUBLIC NUISANCE, IN ACCORDANCE
WITH ORDINANCE 91-47.
WHEREAS, as provided in Ordinance 91-47, the direct costs of abatement of certain nuisances.
lncluding prescribed administrative cost incurred by the County, shall be assessed against such
property; and
WHEREAS, the cost th0reof '0 the County as to each parcel shall be calculated and reported
to the Board of County Commission~rs, together with a description of said parcel; and
WHEREAS, such assessment shall be a legal, valid and binding obligation upon the property
against which made until paid; and
WHEREAS, the assessment shall become due and payable thirty (30) days after the mailing of
Notice of Assessment after which interest shall accrue at a rate of twelve percent (12.0%) per
annum on any unpald portion thereof.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, that the property described as follows, and having been abated of a public nuisance after
due and proper notice thereof to the owner of said property, is hereby assessed the following costs
of such abatement, to wit:
NAME:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
~
uis Alfredo & Patricia
Ann Carvajal
5205 McCarty St
Naples, FL 34113
Lot 24, Block 10, Unit 1,
Naples Manor, according to the
plat thereof recorded in Plat
Book 3,page 57, Public Records,
Collier County, Florida.
$ 245.00
Norman & Cleda Hedrich
10911 Bonita Beach Rd
Bonita Spr~ngs, FL 34134
REFERENCE:
80727-057 #62046200006
The Clerk of the Board shall mail a notice of assessment of lien to the owner or owners
of the above described property. and if such owner fails to pay such assessment within thirty
(30) days hereof, a certified copy of this Resolutic: shall be recorded in the official records
of Collier County, to constitute a lien against suc!, rroperty according to law, unless such
direction is stayed by thlS Board upon appeal of the assessment of the owner.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote.
DATED:
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY:
Pamela S Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
APPROVED AS TO FORM
AND ~EGAL SUFFICIENCY:
ti~J:i&j Afl ,1 /'---
COUNTY ATTORNEY
AGENDA ITEM
Mo. J 4 (A) 1
MAR 2 3 1999
CSce 11 - 1/1/99
pt.
to
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
LEGAL NOTICE OF ASSESSMENT OF LIEN
DATE:
Flora Acosta
35 Colonial Dr
Naples, FL 34112
REFERENCE 80807-008 #22623480001
LIEN NUMBER:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
Lot 4, Block 5, Unit No: 1, Avalon Estates, a subdivision according to the Plat
thereof as recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, at Plat Book 3,
Page 62 and recorded in O.R. 686 at Page 457.
You, as the owner of the property above described, as recorded in the records maintained by
the office of the Property Appraiser, are hereby advised that the Compliance Services
Manager, did on 8/14/98, order the abatement of a certain nuisance existing on the above
property prohibited by Ordinance 91-47, serving notice thereof upon you, such nuisance being:
OVERGROWTH
(URBAN) :
Prohibited accumulation of non-protected mowable vegetation in excess of 18"
in height in a subdivision other than Golden Gate Estates.
Weeds over 18".
You failed to abate such nJisance; whereupon, it was abated by the expenditure of public
funds at a dlrect cost of $ 45.00 and administrative cost of $200.00 for a total of $ 245.00.
Such costs, by Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida,
have been assessed against the above property on
and shall
become a llen o~ the property ~nirty (30) days after such assessment.
You may request a hearing before the Board of County Commissioners to show cause, if any, why
the expenses and charges incurred by the County under this Ordinance are unwarranted or
excessive or why such expenses should not constitute a lien against the property.
Such
request for hearing must be made to the Clerk of the Board of County Commissioners,
Government Center, Naples, Florida 34112 in writing within thirty (30) days from the date of
this assessment to be valid.
AGENDA ITEM
No. lID (A-) 7
MAR 2 3 1999
CLERK, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
CSce 9- 1/93
PI. 7
RESOLUTION NO. 99-
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
3
3~
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59 APPROVED AS TO FORM
60 AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
61 . (~
6~~OA~-~ (lJ..J.rJ.Q/l/ ~~
{ ~A VIp WEJ,GSL ... U
6. COUNTy ATTORNEY
65
66
THE
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
PROVIDING FOR ASSESSMENT OF LIEN, FOR THE COST OF
ABATEMENT OF PUBLIC NUISANCE, IN ACCORDANCE
WITH ORDINANCE 91-47.
WHEREAS, as provided in Ordinance 91-47, the direct costs
including prescribed administrative cost incurred by the County,
property; and
of abatement of certain nuisances,
shall be assessed against such
WHEREAS, the cost thereof to the County as to each parcel shall be calculated and reported
to the Board of County Commissioners, together with a description of said parcel, and
WHEREAS, such assessment shall be a legal, valid and binding obligation upon the property
against which made until paid, and
WHEREAS, the assessment shall become due and payable thirty (30) days after the mailing of
Notice of Assessment after which interest shall accrue at a rate of twelve percent (12.0%) per
annum on any unpaid portion thereof.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, that the property described as follows, and having been abated of a public nuisance after
due and proper notlce thereof to the owner of said property, is hereby assessed the following costs
of such abatement, to wit:
LEGAL D!:'}:,.J(IPTION:
~
NAME:
- "'"lora Acosta
5 Colonial Dr
Aaples, FL 34112
Lot 4, Block 5, Unit No: 1,
Avalon Estates, a subdivision
according to the Plat thereof
as recorded in the Public
Record~ ~~ Collier County,
Florid; 'Plat Book 3, Page
62 and rL20rded in O.R. 686 at
Page 457.
$245.00
REFERENCE:
80807-008
#22623480001
The Clerk of the Board shall rr.ail a notice of assessment of lien to the owner or owners
of the above described property, and ~f such owner fails to pay such assessment within thirty
(30) days hereof, a certified copy c: this Resolution shall be recorded in the official records
of Collier County, to constitute a } .en against such property according to law, unless such
directlon is stayed by this Board up~~ appeal of the assessment of the owner.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote.
DATED:
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Pamela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
AGENDA ITEM
No. lip (A) 1
MAR 2 3 1999
CSce 11 - 1/1/99
Pc. Z
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
LEGAL NOTICE OF ASSESSMENT OF LIEN
DATE:
Daniel Liy
5102 NW_7th St #614W
Miami, FL 33126
REFERENCE 80909-098 #36315560005
LIEN NUMBER:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
LOT 20, BLOCK 198, GOLDEN GATE, UNIT NO.6, ACCORDING TO PLAT IN PLAT BOOK 5, PAGES
124 THROUGH 134, INCLUSIVE OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
You, as the owner of the property above described, as recorded in the records maintained by
the office of the Property Appraiser, are hereby advised that the Compliance Services
Manager, did on 9/9/98, order the abatement of a certain nuisance existing on the above
property prohibited by Ordlnance 91-47, serving
thereof upon you, such nuisance being:
OVERGROWTH
(URBAN) :
Prohibited accumulation of non-protected mowable vegetation in excess of 18"
in height in a subdivision other than Golden Gate Estates.
Weeds over 18".
You failed to abate such nuisance; whereupon, it was abated by the expenditure of public
funds at a direct cost of $ 45.00 and administrative cost of $200.00 for a total of $ 245.00.
Such costs, by Reso~ution of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida,
have been assessed agains~ the above property on
and shall
become a lien on the p~operty thirty (30) days after such assessment.
You may request a hearing before the Board of County Commissioners to show cause, if any, why
the expenses and cha~ges incurred by the County under this Ordinance are unwarranted or
excessive or why such expenses should not constitute a lien against the property. Such
request for hearing must be made to the Clerk of the Board of County Commissioners,
Government Center, Naples, Florida 34112 in writing within thirty (30) days from the date of
this assessment to be valid.
CLERK, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA ITEM
No./~t A-)[
MAR 2 3 1S99
CSce 9- 1/93
Pi. CJ
~f'I"Il""'~
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
3'
3.
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58 APPROVED AS TO FORM
59 AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
60 \ A~ . "-/l,.,.{nA:
~1_ :i:I;J~~CJE:'CUu-v\-( ~.~
l COUNTY ATTORNEY
64
65
)-
RESOLUTION NO. 99-
THE
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOAR:
PROVIDING FOR ASSESSMEN:
ABATEMENT OF PUBLIC NUISANCE,
WITH ORDINANCE 91-47.
~OUNTY COMMISSIONERS
_ 'N, FOR THE COST OF
.::CORDANCE
WHEREAS, as provided in Ordinance 91-47, the direct costs of abatement of certain nuisances,
including prescribed administrative cost incurred by the County, shall be assessed against such
property; and
WHEREAS, the cost thereof to the County as to each parcel shall be calculated and reported
to the Board of County Commissioners, together with a description of said parcel; and
WHEREAS, such assessment shall be a legal, valid and binding obligation upon the property
against which made until paid; and
WHEREAS, the assessment shall become due and payable thirty (30) days after the mailing of
Notice of Assessment after which interest shall accrue at a rate of twelve percent (12.0%) per
annum on any unpaid portion thereof.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, that the property described as follows, and having been abated of a public nuisance after
due and proper notice chereof to the owner of said property, is hereby assessed the following costs
of such abatement, to w~t:
NAME:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
gQll
'aniel Liy
,102 NW_7th St #614W
Miami, FL 33126
LOT 20, BLOCK 198, GOLDEN
GATE, UNIT NO.6, ACCORDING
TO PLAT IN PLAT BOOK 5,
PAGES 124 THROUGH 134,
INCLUSIVE OF THE PUBLIC
RECORDS OF COLLIER
COUNTY, FLORIDA.
$245.00
REFERENCE:
80909-098
#36315560005
The Clerk of the Board shall mail a notice of assessment of lien to the owner or owners
of the above described property, and if such 0~~8! : ..s to pay such assessment within thirty
(30) days hereof, a cert~fied copy of this Reso:~' ~nall be recorded in the official records
of Collier County, to constitute a lien against su~;, property according to law, unless such
direction is stayed by this Board upon appeal of the assessment of the owner.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote.
DATED:
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY:
Yamela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman
CSce 11 - 1/1/99
AGENDA ITEM
No. J~{A-)1
MAR 2 3 1999
10
pc.
~,.....-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST APPROVAL TO USE FUNDS FROM WASTE TIRE GRANT TO
PROVIDE SAFETY PLAY SURFACE AT EVERGLADES CITY PUBLIC
PLAYGROUND
OBJECTIVE: To obtain approval from the Board of County Commissioners to use
State Waste Tire Grant funds to replace current surface for a recycled tire overlay safety
surface for the public access Everglades City playground,
CONSIDERATION: This project will provide a safety surface for an existing play
structure by using waste tires collected and recycled in Florida. The Waste Tire Grant
allows counties to buy materials made from recycled tires in order to promote the benefits
of recycling and to "close the loop" by buying recycled products.
.~-
The project will include a sign noting the sponsor of the project, and the grant that made it
possible as well as the unique safety material used. This daily visible reminder of sponsors
and the identification of recycled materials used for this project reinforces the mission of
the Solid Waste Department to educate the public on the resulting benefits of community
participation in recycling. The need for a safe surface for children to play on was a major
consideration in selecting this project using Waste Tire Grant money.
The project is expected to be completed by May 1999. This project is consistent with the
use of Waste Tire Grant funds as outlined in the Board's acceptance of the Recycling &
Education, Waste Tire and Litter Control Grants on 10/06/98, agenda item 16B( 1).
FISCAL IMPACT: Funds are available in the 1998-99 Solid Waste Tire Grant.
The cost of the project will not exceed $23,000.00. Work includes a 4" concrete slab with
a recycled tire and synthetic rubber overlay. Preliminary preparation and excavation work
as well as project management of site will be performed by Everglades City personnel.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
,..~-'''''''
NO. Ajt"( a;f:E I )
MAR 2 3 1999
PG. I
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners approve using State
Waste Tire Grant funds for a recycled tire safety surface at Everglades City public
playground.
SUBMITTED BY
D vid W. Russell, Director, Solid
Waste Department
Date: ~./ S - 7 '9
REVIEWEDBY ~~, Gd't'1" Date J~'-f-q1
Stephen Y. Ca . ell, Director, Purchasing
Department
APPROVEDB~ Date: :3 ~5 -'1 '7
Ed Ilschrier, Public Works Administrator
--..
AGENOA )T~H)
NO. n. (8 II
- -
MAR 2 3 1999
PG. ~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPROVE BUDGET AMENDMENTS RECOGNIZING CARRY FORWARD AMOUNTS FROM
FY 98 FOR ROAD PROJECTS IN FUNDS 313, 331, 333, 334, 336, 338,339 & 340
OBJECTIVE: To obtain BCC approval of budget amendments that will allow unexpended funds
budgeted for Road projects to be carried forward and re-appropriated in the FY 99 budget.
CONSIDERATIONS: Funds were appropriated in FY 98 for multiple road projects. Staff was unable to
encumber all the appropriated funds before the end of the fiscal year. These funds are still required to
complete the approved projects. This is typically the case with transportation capital funding since
roadway projects generally span several fiscal years. Also, some projects are shifting funding sources
between gas taxes and impact fees, as outlined below.
FISCAL IMPACT: Increases in appropriated carry forward revenue are as follows:
Fund:
Road Construction Gas Tax (313)
Road Impact Fee District 1 (331)
Road Impact Fee District 3 (333)
Road Impact Fee District 4 (334)
Road Impact Fee District 6 (336)
Road Impact Fee District 8 (338)
Road Impact Fee District 9 (339)
Road Impact Fee District 10 (340)
Total:
Amount
$ 3,902,739
$ 2,236,517
$ 404,580
$ 503
$ 791,530
$ 575,770
$ 20,221
$ 1,932
$ 7,933,792
Increases in expense appropriations funded by increased carry forward revenue, and changes to project
funding sources (gas taxes and impact fees) are indicated below:
In crease/ In crease/ In crease/
Decrease New Decrease Decrease Increase/
1m Project Funding Gas Tax Impact Fee Decrease
Fund Carry Fwd Requests Funding Funding Reserves Total
313 1,493,301 500,000 (500,000) 0 2,409,438 3,902,739
331 1,679,935 -0 0 500,000 56,582 2,236,517
333 1,021,263 0 0 0 (616,683) 404,580
334 17,320 0 0 0 (16,817) 503
336 0 0 0 0 791,530 791,530
338 258,914 0 0 0 316,856 575,770
339 0 0 0 0 20,221 20,221
340 0 0 0 0 1,932 1,932
Total 4,470,733 500,000 (500,000) 500,000 2,963,059 7,933,792
--
Fund 313 - New Funding: (61009) - $500,000 US41 Sidewalks approved by BCC on 2/23/99. Fund 333
- Carry Forward - (60101) County Barn Road and (65031) Radio Road - funding is needed forR-G-\~6:';:;- M
Fund 334 - Carry Forward - (60134) Goodlette Road - Design, (69031) Golden Gate Parkway - N(-,._L~{e/x:..3)
Monitoring of Wetlands by Natural Resources. : t'iAF~ 2 3 1999
( I
.;; ""..-
. f.,;.
h_,...~"\t,
FY99 Fuodin~ Chaof!es
Increase! Increase! In crease/ In crease/ Increase! Net
Project Project Decrease Decrease Decrease Decrease Decrease Increase!
Number Name Fund 313 Fund 331 Fund 333 Fund 336 Reserves Decrease
65041 NN MSTU (500,000) 500,000 0 0 0 0
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMP ACT: Impact fee funded projects are included in the Growth
Management Plan.
RECOMMENDATIONS: That the BCC approve/authorize the necessary budget amendments to (1)
carry forward FY 98 unexpended funds into FY 99, (2) authorize new and revised funding for the above
listed projects in Roads Capital Funds 313, 331, 333, 334, 336, 338, 339 & 340.
PREPARED BY:
\
\ \
'I , i. I J' "".:J "_
, ,I '- --'1.._\. '.. ,~' \ ..\, '-, 'J -
\,' ',' .
DATE:
; \ } I,'."!
~- ,J _' I.....
.,., 0 -= /.9 c
DATE: 0<-/0....5,/ 'I '1
I ("l /:
3- -/(7
DATE:
.3 -- 9'- 91
DATE:
cc: Rich Hellriegel, Senior Project Manager, PWED
"GlkU{ I) 9'\.. )
NO. J" b I...-='
~ ."
MAR 2 3 1999
I
~
J PG..;s. i
"'~"~~w..f.t""'~J
PRJ
# DESCRIPTION
60013 Naples Streetscape
60031 I11th Avenue
60061 Livingston Rd Radio/GG
60071 Livingston Rd
60101 County Barn Road
60141 Cnty Wide Mangrove
60172 Multi PIj Transportation
60173 Multi Prj Transportation
60174 Traffic Signal
61005 Master Mitigation
61008 Tamiami Trail North
62031 Airport Rd
62041 Bald Eagle Dr
62061 Livingston Rd
63041 GG Blvd
65021 Rattlesnake Hammock
65032 Radio Rd
65041 NN MSTU Rd
66043 Immokalee Road
66061 CR951
66065 Turnlane
66066 Bridge Structure
66067 Airport Road Bridge
66076 Neighborhood Traffic
67021 Vanderbilt Bch
67033 Sabal Palm Rd
69021 Westclox
69031 Golden Gate Pkwy
69071 Multi PIj Environment
69072 Multi PIj Environment
69081 Bike Pathways
69115 CR9 51 Monitoring
Miller Blvd
Hunters Road
Naples Airport Auth
Non Project
Transfer Debt service
Reserves
REVENUE
Gas Tax
Impact Fees
Interest
Transfers/Loans
Grants/Contributions
Carry Forward
Total Revenue
Variance
CF Project 66067
Remaining Balance to
FY98
Amended
F
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORWARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 313
Preliminary
Amount
YTD Available for
b E F
E
ore cast ncum xpenses arry orward
1,039,000 117,041 414,532 507,426
134,000 - 2,442 131,558
537,000 28,672 714,743 (206,416)
22,400 . 144 22,256
500 . - 500
5,000 . - 5,000
656,100 139,503 460,951 55,646
752,800 94,515 497,911 160,374
275,000 . - 275,000
53,000 . 12,325 40,675
300,000 . 300,000
9,500 4,873 14,266 (9,638)
57,500 57,517 (17)
10,000 - 10,000
12,100 163,812 51,631 (203,343)
846,900 - 519,463 327,437
1,400 1,351 49
1,213,400 36,592 53,041 1,123,767
1,000 991 7 2
9,500 - 3,951 5,549
211,400 37,234 79,980 94,186
250,000 219,967 25,615 4,419
977,100 14,890 162.681 799,529
100,000 - 8,931 91,069
272,500 29,952 241,953 595
1,300 500 800
3,000 - 3,000
233,500 46,174 187,326
5,000 4,446 554
4,700 4,666 34
427,400 19,733 356,132 51,534
12,000 2,907 9,093
5,000 - - 5,000
7,000 - . 7,000
20,000 - . 20,000
334,000 - 354,123 (20,123)
1,239,200 - 1,239,200 -
-
10,039,200 912,441 5,326,916 3,799,843
12,908,600 13,398,259 489,659
-
400,000 753,465 353,465
181,600 181,600 -
150,000 209,301 59,301
10,274,700 10,274,700 -
23,914,900 24,817,325 - 902,425
I I I 4,702,267
(799,528)
Carry Forward 3,902,739
If NO. it,N~~
, MAR 2 3 1999
LpG.
-3
-
60013
60021
60061
60071
60111
60134
62031
62041
62061
62071
65041
65042
65061
65071
66043
66041
66067
66076
67021
69061
69101
.-c.Q 111
DESCRIPTION
Naples Streets cape
BBch Rd 31
Livingston Rd Radio/GG
Livingston Rd
Pine Ridge Road
Goodlette Rd
Airport Rd
Bald Eagle Dr
Livingston Rd
Livingston Rd
NN MSTU Rd
NN MSTU Rd
CR951
Vanderbilt Bch
Immokalee Road
Immokalee Road
AilJlort Road Bridge
Neighborhood Traffic
Vanderbilt Bch
Vanderbilt Bch
ImmokaIee Road
Airport Rd Extension
Non Project
REVENUE
Other
Impact Fees
Interest
Transfers/Loans
Grants/Contributions
Carry Forward
Total Revenue
Variance
CF Project 66067
Remaining Balance to
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORWARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 331
Fund
331
YTD
Preliminary
Amount
Available for
F d
E
b
E
ncum xpenses arry orwar
-
293,400 13,875 19,547 259,978
500 577 (77)
55,000 18,435 36,566
475,200 334,163 53,342 87,695
-
440,400 6,885 666,037 (232,522)
-
7,000 9,401 (2,401)
37,400 6,792 30,608
834,200 437,782 19,369 377,049
4,800 4,773 27
-
67,000 12.000 1,579 53,422
100 100
- 1,201 (1,201)
150.000 9,480 140,520
-
466,700 19,920 445,980 800
52,000 3,036 48,964
1,425,400 207,105 264,762 953,533
1,000 - 639 361
117,000 97,985 19,015
4,427, I 00 1,036,502 1,618,161 1,772,437
15,886 15,886
3,900,000 4,167,168 267,168
325,000 556,567 231,567
.
201,600 201,600 -
8,023,900 8,023,900 -
12,450,500 12.965,121 514,621
I I I 2,287,058
(50.541)
Carry Forward 2,236,517
NO. Ail:18X3J
MAR 2 3 1999
pc. .1.
~ ,
!t........._~.......-.
PRJ
#
60061
60071
60091
60101
62081
65021
65031
65032
65033
66061
DESCRIPTION
Livingston Rd Radio/GG
Livingston Rd
Santa Barbara Blvd
County Barn Road
Santa Barbara
Rattlesnake Hammock
Radio Rd
Radio Rd
Radio Rd
CR951
Non Project
REVENUE
Impact Fees
Interest
Carry FOlWard
Total Revenue
Variance
Fund
333
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORW ARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 333
Preliminary
Amount
Available for
F d
E
b
YTD
E
ncum xpenses arry olWar
219,000 15,765 1,122,293 (919,057)
9,000 4,500 4,500 -
431,800 301,099 69,253 61,448
453,400 4,220 89,647 359,533
79,000 3,725 45,708 29,567
254,000 3,803 118,084 132,112
597,500 - 28,413 569,087
700 723 (23)
16,900 7,261 8,012 1,628
36,600 1,254 35,346
75,000 2 74,998
2,172,900 340,373 1,487,889 344,638
2,000,000 2,007,956 7,956
237,100 289,086 51,986
5,498,000 5,498,000 -
7,735,100 7,795,042 59,942
5,562,200 I
404,580 I
r~w~
Mt\K 2 3 lS~j9
~i: ...~
It
60134
69031
DESCRIPTION
Goodlette Rd
Golden Gate Pkwy
Non Project
REVENUE
Impact Fees
Interest
Carry Forward
Total Revenue
Variance
Fund
334
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORWARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 334
Preliminary
Amount
Available for
F d
E
b
YTD
E
ncum xpenses arry orwar
698,200 497,250 197,417 3,533
21,000 7,213 13,787
1,000 1,000
720,200 497,250 204.630 18,320
100,000 63,698 (36,302)
81,000 99,585 18,585
1,802,100 1,802,000 (100)
1,983,100 1,965,283 (17,817)
1,262,900 I
503 I
---
NO. AGfl:t~J(J)
MAH 2 3 1599
PG.~~ 4
414. .I;!
PRJ
#
60101
62041
65021
66061
DESCRIPTION
County Barn Road
Bald Eagle Dr
Rattlesnake Hanunock
CR951
Non Project
REVENUE
Impact Fees
Interest
Carry Forward
Total Revenue
Variance
Fund
336
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORWARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 336
Preliminary
Amount
YTD Available for
E b E F d
ncum xpenses arry orwar
20,500 948 19,534 18
600 296 305
50,000 . - 50,000
436,400 . 126,529 309,871
1,000 468 532
508,500 948 146,826 360,726
1,000,000 1,340,217 340,217
105,000 195,587 90,587
2,959,200 2,959,200 .
4,064,200 4,495,004 430,804
3,555,700 I
791,530 I
NO. 7~G-.J
..~ t. "l 2 3 4,ce;Q
nHr\ oJ....
pc. 7
DESCRIPTION
63031 CR95J GGPKWYDav
63041 GO Blvd
65021 Rattlesnake Hanunock
65061 CR951
66061 CR951
Non Project
REVENUE
Impact Fees
Interest
Carry Forward
Total Revenue
Variance
Fund
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORWARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 338
Preliminary
Amount
YTD Available for
338 Encumb Expenses arrv Forward
6,000 520 5,480
574,000 32,135 302,889 238,976
328.000 156,996 171,004
15,700 1,242 14,458
15,800 8 15,792
1,000 165 835
940,500 32,135 461,821 446,545
1,000,000 1,094,908 94,908
60,000 94,318 34,318
1,364,000 1,364,000 .
2,424,000 2,553,226 129,226
575.770 I
1,483,500 I
~AGfl~tA~
I ~lAF~ 2 3 1999
8"
PG.
PRJ
#
DESCRIPTION
Non Project
REVENUE
Impact Fees
Interest
Carry Forward
Total Revenue
Variance
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORW ARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 339
Preliminary
Amount
Available for
ar Forward
Encumb
65,000 72,635 7,635
25,000 32,587 7,587
538,700 538,700 -
628.700 643,921 15,221
623,700 I
20,221 I
i
1
NO.~~
MAR 2 3 lS99
pc. Cj
I _ i~~ .
PRELIMINARY CARRY FORWARD ESTIMATES
ROADS FUND 340
63041
DESCRIPTION
GO Blvd
REVENUE
Interest
Transfers/Loans
Carry Forward
Total Revenue
Variance
Encumb
Preliminary
Amount
Available for
arry Forward
3,100 5,032 1,932
-
89,700 89,700 -
92,800 94,732 1,932
42,800 I
1,932 I
r--
A~i'f_A /lItr:l )
N,r, -LJ.fJ-J.LJ~
. ;j'AR 2 3 1S99
~:~
-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPROVE AN AGREEMENT WITH IMMOKALEE DISPOSAL, INe. TO
CONTINUE PROVIDING RECYCLING SERVICE FOR MULTI-FAMILY
RESIDENTIAL UNITS AND AUTHORIZE THE CHAIRWOMAN TO SIGN THE
AGREEMENT.
OBJECTIVE: To provide an agreement for the continuation of the multi-family
recycling service for the remainder of the franchise solid waste collection agreement
period for Service Area Number Two, ending September 30,2001.
CONSIDERATION: The initial multi-family recycling collection service agreement
between the County and Immokalee Disposal, Inc. was initiated April 9, 1996.
The agreement approved recycling collection service for mulit-family units at a rate of
$.95 cents per unit per month. The multi-family units are billed for the recycling service
directly by the franchisee.
-
It is necessary to provide an agreement for the continuation of the recycling service to
coincide with the September 30,2001 ending date of the franchise collection agreement.
Immokalee Disposal, Inc. has agreed to maintain the original price to the end of the
agreement period. The agreement document is available for review at the offices of the
County Administrator, Board of County Commissioners, County Attorney and Minutes
and Records.
This service provided by the lmmokalee area franchisee is consistent with the same service
provided by Waste Management in Service Area Number One.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approximately 2700 units at $.95 cents per unit per month for a
total annual amount of $30,780 billed directly to customers by the franchisee.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
-----
RECOMMENDA TION: Approve an agreement with Immokalee Disposal, Inc. to
provide recycling service for multi-family residential units and authorize the Chairwoman
to sign the agreement.
SUBMITTEDBY ,~#~ Date 5/ //-9/
David W. Russell, Director, Solid
Waste Management Department
APPROVEDB~~ ~
Ed IIscliner, Public Works Administrator
Date: 3 -t 1. -.&;~
"'G(ND~ Il;.Ef". n
NO. 114 r.81~:;...
MAR 2 3 1999
PG. ,
AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into on this day of
,19---. by and between Immokalee Disposal, Inc., hereinafter
called the "Contractor" and Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida,
Collier County, Naples, hereinafter called the "County":
WIT N E SSE T H:
1. COMMENCEMENT.
. The Contractor shall commence the work the first day of the month following the
execution of this agreement. The contract shall terminate on September 30, 2001. The
County Administrator may, at his discretion, extend this Agreement under all of the terms
and conditions contained in this Agreement for up to two (2) additional one (1) year
periods. The County Administrator shall give the Contractor written notice of the
County's intention to extend the Agreement term not less than ninety (90) days prior to
the end of the Agreement term then in effect.
2. STATEMENT OF WORK.
The Contractor shall provide multi-family recycling service on a mandatory basis in
accordance with the terms and conditions of the specifications of the Contractor's
proposal dated March 11, 1994, hereto attached and made an integral part of this
Agreement and any applicable provisions of the 1990 Solid Waste Collection Service
Agreement between County and Contractor incorporated herein by reference, as amended.
3. THE CONTRACT SUM.
Through the Contractor's commercial billing system, the Contractor shall collect the per
unit price as indicated in the Contractor's proposal for the performance of this Agreement
($.95 per month, or $11.40 annually for approximately 2,686 units in Immokalee, Florida).
4. NOTICES
All notices from the County to the Contractor shall be deemed duly served if mailed by
registered or certified mail to the Contractor at the following address:
lmmokalee Disposal, Inc.
120 W. Jefferson Avenue
Immokalee, Florida 34142
All notices from the Contractor to the County shall be deemed duly served if mailed
1
~p~/Jj
~?B7/
by registered or certified mail to the County to:
Collier County Solid Waste Department
Collier County Government Center
Health/Community Services Bldg.
3301 Tarniami Trail East
Naples, Florida 34112
The Contractor and the County may change the above mailing address at any time upon
giving the other party written notification. All notices under this Service Agreement must
be in writing.
5. NO PARTNERSHIP.
Nothing herein contained shall create or be construed as creating a partnership between
the County and the Contractor or to constitute the Contractor as an agent of the County.
6. PERMITS: LICENSES: TAXES.
The Contractor agrees to obtain and pay for all permits and licenses necessary for the
conduct of business and agrees to comply with all laws governing the responsibility of an
employer with respect to persons employed by the Contractor. The Contractor shall also
be solely responsible for payment of any and all taxes levied on the Contractor. In
addition, the Contractor shall comply with all rules, regulations and laws of Collier
County, the State of Florida, or the U.S. Government now in force or hereafter adopted.
7. EMPLOYEES
The Contractor shall employ people to work at County facilities who are neat, clean, well-
groomed and courteous.
8. NO IMPROPER USE.
The Contractor will not use, nor suffer or permit any person to use in any manner
whatsoever, County facilities for any improper, immoral or offensive purpose, or for any
purpose in violation of any federal, state, county or municipal ordinance, rule, order or
regulation, or of any governmental rule or regulation now in effect or hereafter enacted or
adopted. In the event of such violation by the Contractor of if the County or its
authorized representative shall deem any conduct on the part of the Contractor to be
objectionable or improper, the County shall have the right to suspend the contract of the
Contractor. Should the Contractor fail to correct any such violation, conduct, or practice
to the satisfaction of the County within twenty-four (24) hours after receiving notice of
such violation, conduct, or practice, such suspension to continue until the violation is
2
cured. The Contractor further agrees not to commence operation during the suspension
period until the violation has been corrected to the satisfaction of the County.
9. TERMINATION.
Should the Contractor be found to have failed to perform his services in a manner
satisfactory to the County as per Specifications, the County may terminate this Agreement
immediately for cause. The County shall be sole judge of non-performance. The County
may also terminate this Agreement for convenience with a thirty (30) day written notice.
10. NO DISCRlMINA nON.
The Contractor agrees that there shall be no discrimination as to race, sex, color, creed or
national origin.
11. INSURANCE.
The Contractor shall provide insurance as follows;
A. Comprehensive General Liabilitv: Coverage shall have minimum limits of
$1,000;000 Per OGcurrence, Combined Single Limit for Bodily Injury Liability and
Property Damage Liability. This shall include Premises and Operations;
Independent Contractors; Products and Completed Operations and Contractual
Liability.
B. Business Auto Liabilitv: Coverage shall have minimum limits of$I,OOO,OOO Per
Occurrence, Combined Single Limit for Bodily Injury Liability and Property
Damage Liability. This shall include; Owned Vehicles, Hired and Non-Owned
Vehicles and Employee Non-Ownership.
c. Worker's Compensation: Insurance covering all employees meeting Statutory
Limits in compliance with the applicable state and federal laws.
Special Reauirements: Collier County shall be included as an Additional
Insured on both the Comprehensive General Liability and Business Auto Liability
Policies.
Current, valid insurance policies meeting the requirement herein identified shall be
maintained by Contractor during the duration of this Agreement. Renewal
certificates shall be sent to the County thirty (30) days prior to any expiration date.
There shall be a thirty (30) day notification to the County in the event of
cancellation or modification of any stipulated insurance coverage.
3
Contractor shall insure that all subcontractors comply with the same insurance
requirements that he is required to meet. The same Contractor shall provide
County with certificates of insurance meeting the required insurance provisions.
12. INDEMNIFICATION.
The ContractorNendor, in consideration ofTen Dollars ($10.00), the receipt and
sufficiency of which is accepted through the signing of this document, shall hold harmless
and defend Collier County and its agents and employees from all suits and actions,
including attorneys' fees and all costs of litigation and judgments of any name and
description arising out of or incidental to the performance of this contract or work
performed thereunder. This provision shall also pertain to any claims brought against the
County by any employee of the named ContractorNendor, any Subcontractor, or anyone
directory or indirectly employed by any of them. The ContractorN endor' s obligation
under this provision shall not be limited in any way by the agreed upon contract price as
shown in this Contract or the Contractor/Vendor's limit of, or lack of, sufficient insurance
protection. The first Ten Dollars ($10.00) of money received on the contract price is
considered as payment of this obligation by the County.
This section does not pertain to any incident arising from the sole negligence of Collier
County .
13. THIS AGREEMENT shall be administered on behalf of the County by the Solid
Waste Department.
14. COMPONENT PARTS OF THIS CONTRACT.
This Contract consists of this Agreement and the attached and/or referenced component
parts, all of which are as fully a part of the contract as if herein set out verbatim.
Contractor's Proposal dated March 11, 1994, Insurance Certificate, Performance Bond,
and any applicable provisions of the 1990 Solid Waste Collection Service Agreement
between County and Contractor incorporated herein by reference, as amended.
15. IT IS FURTHER UNDERSTOOD AND AGREED, by and between the parties
herein that the within contract is subject to annual appropriation by the Board of County
Commissioners.
4
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Contractor and the County have each, respectively, by
an authorized person or agent, hereunder set their hands and seals on the date and year
first above written.
DATED:
ATTEST:
BOARD OF COUNTY CO:MMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
PAMELA S. MAC'KIE, Chairwoman
(SEAL)
~dA/;(/ /7l~
~~irst Witness
177&1(' r:;:.. f91e e T J- t (Y) {Jaw'j
Type/print witne~ name
1..:2 0 UJ. J ,,<--f=(~r ~ C IV J'1\J e ,
0; '-{I - ~~7-~ 1c.:J 9
Address and Telephone
Immokalee Disposal, Inc.
Contractor
By:~7- CdtG
Signature
Larry L. Collins: Vice President
G.LL-,,-?(., ~4a./
Second WItness
E/LetpA/ ,Jfe'Dr;~S
.JYJ'7~P~j, ~'!pess name
cb~.:;:/,h ~3'9.?c'
/~/ ~~
Address d Telephone
3&;9- C:, 7-~?
CORPORATE SEAL
(corporations only)
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
. ....~.
5
::'~::. <.:!t>~?:~_:i~'~:~; ~~~> .
t: !" . ~~..
'.
DATE:
.March 11, 1994
TO:
. Dave :;Russell
.Solid _;Waste Management
.BuildingH
3301 ..:Tamiami ":~ail
. Naples, ':Florida.33962
Director
'-:FROM: >-
~La.:cry .-Collins, ..President
::J:mmokalee .:::Disposal....Inc .
'.
.~IDDERS -:PROPOSAL
".!!rOIlfi:=:F..AMILY::RECYCLING :EROGRAM.
---
PERFORMANCE BOND AND .INSURANCE
To my understanding, all bond and insurance
requirements should be covered under our current
franchise.
POTENTIAL -RECYCLABLES
Newspaper
Plastic containers
~lear and colored glass
Aluminum and tin cans
RECYCLING CONTAINERS
All recycle bins and containers will pe provided by
Immokalee Disposal.
i
~~~ ~:--~..~:..~....,
,..,.... . .
ii !":~, ' _ _ _ .
$.~.\I ,_.__..... _'.._..,
~~l ::~~':~: ~ i-~- \--
~-- l
SOl~D V';,~TE DEPT. .
'---. .
.. . :~:74,!~.:::.~~~:'~'~-=~::';~~~.i:~~:~' .~ ~- ~~.. ...~~.::..,
. -
.. ,-
MULTI.;FAMILY:RECYCLING':'COST
(1 - 5 YEARS)
CONTRACT LENGTE
5 years recommended
STARTING DATE
August 1, 1994
BILLING
Immokalee Disposal will be responsible for all billing
and collection of payments.
.~
.' . ,:~.. '.";'
.
,.
. ,.',
..
:,
i
TITLE OF -RECYCLABLES
..All,:.recyclables 'and .:revenues ::col.lected 'are :the
:property' of .Immokalee ~.Disposal..'
COMMENTS '..
'* :. ])ue','.:to .::the ...high _tw:n:.over.::.:in:.isome.;:z:en.taL::units,
::rmmoka.'lee :.J)i.sposal.::expects ~::to::repl.ace..25 :percent
of-:.:the:.:recycle .:bins ::each:year~
"J. -". ~'.
. --.-...... .
'"* .:~..:Because,amm.oka.leeds ::a -:::sma 11 '+own,;::::mandatory
'" :participation ::with.::no.:::exi:epti.on~.:..esseTl+;"" l-=Eor, ,
'-:the -:success .rof :::multii=:family :-=recycling ~:',',;Word=spJ:eads
very -;:fast ',.:if _:anyone '-;::is .~exempt';.:;which :~wi.1..J..:.....undeDI1ine
,the "whole -pro.gram. :' .
-
Sincerely,
~
Larry Collins, President
tJAJ~
EXECllTIVE Slll\-1MARY
AWARD BID #98-2880 FOR BACKFLO\V SERVICES
OB.n:'<"'''TIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Oftkio, the
Governing Board of the Conier County \Vater-Sewer District, award Bid #98-2880 for backtlow
services to Severn Trent Environmental Services, Inc,
CONSIDERA TIONS:
1. The Water Department per Ordinance No. 97-33 and Florida Administrative Code 62-
555.360, has been assigned to oversee the retrofitting of all service connections within the
Collier County Water District, posing a known hazard to the Water District's potable water
supply, with a cross-connection control device.
2. This Bid provides for the retrotltting services for the 3;4" to 2" service connections with cross
connection control devices and the repair of large meter backtlow devices.
3, Bid 98-2880 for backtlow services was posted on November 18,1998, Eighty-four inquiries
were sent to vendors with five bidders responding.
4, Staff has reviewed the bids received. The Bid is divided into three tasks, with Task One
divided into nine sections, Severn Trent Environmental Services, Inc, was the low bidder for
all Tasks of this bid.
-
FISCAL IMPACT: Task One for services for retrofitting eXlstmg service connections will
result in expenditures of$371,312.50. Task Two for retrofitting services for newly found hazard
connections will result in no tiscal impact to the Collier County Water District, as customers
receiving devices under this scenario will be invoiced for cost incurred. The tlscal impact of Task
Three for repair of large meter assembly backflow devices is estimated at $5,000 per year. Funds
are budgeted for Task One - Two in the Collier County Water-Sewer District, Water Distribution
Cost Center. Funds are budgeted for Task Three in the Water Sewer District Capital Fund.
GRWOTH l\IANAGEl\IENT Il\IPACT: None
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Ofticio, the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, award Bid #98-2880, for backflow
services, Task One, Two and Three to Severn Trent Environmental Services, Inc.
n '1 /}//"
Submitted By: '- /C"C..J!f\ -1'~
Pamela Libby, F~ pervisor
(/l J. "
Reviewed By: / 1..;.\i11;;7t~ t'C--
I 1 I
Paul Mattausch, Water Director
i.l
C I~ , t.' { /
'I / , .." / /.
Reviewed By: -,.-:~':~rrtJ,'\ Lrl. ~?I,Lj;'
Stephen Carnell, Purchasing Director
.-
~
/--/ /:
Approved B , .- __ / ~~_.~..>,c:___.
d IIschner, Public Works Administrator
.3//f-~ f
r:;:7.J?:(bjW
~
k iv' ~ '.:1 ') '3 1" Q Cl
~ I!I-\I\ t.. :;J.;;....
L-=.~:..~...~ ---
00 ... c. g - I~ c ~ c ,II
C' ;;1'" .... ~
C' ~ . <r; ;r, I~ or. Vi
~ c '"" .~ C M
'" r- .J;; IC; r-- .l;; J;;
oC .tI': fA fA
~ ...
.'C i ..
- = '.'
-,;. ~ i" '.' ". ... ...
E- .' .'.
..,. e . .
Z . . .' .
00
~ g c ~ "' g ;r. ~I 8
- V', V', - ~
c - - - - - -
...
... or. ~ ~ ~-- ~ i~ ~ r
E- fA '~ .t<)
c ~ i"'
... (f:' -...
...
... .:.. 1.0
...
00
- '..) <:.J g - c - g =1
C <:.J C; .'" :, . C, ~ O. ~ C -Sf
~ 0::- c v-i or. g l~'~ V'. lrJ s:"
r./:; C "S! . .. """ -VI
r- rr r- Iel v".
v:. v:. ~ .:.f "" V; i;,' I;:;; IV; ;;;~
<:.J <:.J
'C ~ ,.... . ... ,., ~......
c: ,.... i ...
~ .:.s:. E:i ::
g- '..) c.. ::
<':l . I
C- O
c c - - := - t-
o C ~ C ::
...; -. a
~ ;r, c oc C lrJ [:::: C -
r- :x:
.;&. ...., I:;! r;; ;;; ,..., r;; ir;; ;:;::.\ ..-
-.:; ... fA fA I"': al
~ ~ OJ
c;; co
::;; a.
0 - c .'. c c c 0
-.: .. lrJ ~. I~I\; vc vc I.' co II')
~ ;;.. @ ..,f- ... '.' -t .. or; """ -t V') '"
~ '" .. ...... 0'-. ~ ..,. '.' .~ I~- '7 ..,. y;
~ .~ <A i :; I~ ~ :;! ~
;:;l .~ "
u .;. ""
- ,... ... ....
<:.J :: .... ~ I'l" ~
..... 00 .....
'c' - ~ ...s
.... ~
c- ~ '. .
-
-
.S:
-
CJ
~
C
-
o
U
I
'"
'"
e
l- =:
U ,.. 00
__ C 00
::: c: N
el-'
c: I;J) 00
~ e C'I
~~~
= ~
~
f=
-
(,)
~
'0'
....
c-
C
Q
'';:
c.
'i:
...
'"
~
Q
~.....
q~~
.....~;z.
~~C
U ~~
<00
c:::~'-
~==
--c,
E-~_
r!:~C:::
~~
....
<.2
c
.S
-
C':l
::;
.J:;
~
r-
""
;z.
e 0
~ ~
- 00
<
f-
t:
.S
ti
Q)
c
c-
O'"
ur-
13~
'E -E
Q) t:
<J) ce
~o
("f')~.r.
iEroo
2 ,S ~
u1r.=
c;r::u.;;:J
c
.S
ti
Q)
c
coc
c
~i
u..;:;
.- c
, g
_'do
;"""'0-
Q) v:
- _ C
t.:= ~ ~ '
OEv
~ .~ ~
~u.;;:J
.s
ti
Q)
C
t:
C
ur-
u-
u
-E i
'1) "=
v: ~
.... ;:;:
Sic
_'"0-
~ (J';
.;: 0: UO
o :::
L- .:
t) v; ::
~u.;;:J
c
~
E-
..,~
-aq
~=
I~=
c:::
c
_S
ti
Q)
c"""
c",
8 V')
8 ;;
-E -E
u c
<J) :s
~c
M"-
t1) r.r.
- - 0
'-gEu
... .-
'Uv;=
~>l..l;:J
c
.S
U
Q)
cr-
t:-
C
~ i
u -;::
'E ~
Q)I ;?
cr.1 '-
N~:;;
.;: C;; c
Oeu
... --
~V;C:
~>l..l;:J
c
s:
ti
~
cV')
o
u "
Q) ~
u '';::
-;;: c
... c::
_~Ic
=--~r.r;
- - 0
~gu
a.... .=
Q) v; t::
~>l..l;::'
t:
.S
U
u
;::
C
UM
Q)-
U
'E i
u '':::;
'Z. C
- '"
N2
::::c
-~rJ:.
- _ 0
~~U
.:: -,2
0,) V'J =
,"",... """""'
......-..;~
.~
"5
u
t: rr.
c-
o
U ..
U z:
.~ .~
t c:;
Q) ::
_"'Ie
- -
("-I aJ '=;
~ ~,.~
o:=~
l- .=
t):;.
~~-
~G M;', ~Lf;J.f)
MAR 2 3 1999
L~.:~~ 01
QO
0\
0\
-
~
-
-.;
..,. 0
CO :z:
- u ClJ
c: ClJ -
~~o
en ~ OJ)
ClJ OJ) c:
.!:: C':l 'c
::l ~ ClJ
a- U c..
.=ci:o
-.: ~
OJ).c
~.c
...... 1
U -
.~ E
2 ~
c:...=-
=
o
::::
CJ
ClJ
=
=
o
U
I
fI.l
fI.l
o
I- =
~ E gg
=: ~ N
o I- I
I;: ~ co
~ E 0\
~=-"O
~ i:i5
~
-
E=
-
U
ClJ
'0'
'-
0..
i:.i
<l.I
'"
'"
ClI
:c
,c
'ClI
E-
-
C
<l.I
l-
E-
c
I-
<l.I
..
<l.I
rJJ
.'"
'.'c.
'[€
:;.:
.~:.
:i
Q
c<l
'iit:
~~
:;
~-;~~
....
;:l :~;:;
o.'~
....'rJJ
-
,.... .
~
~
IQ:'
f I~
~ 1=
I~
'-
..8
c:
o
'';;:
C':l
...
.0
C':l
f-
E
~
-
~
tr:
-i
I~ '.
I '.. '.
..:: ....: :.'.
...1....
.
c:
.2
U
II)
C:O
C:"<t
8",
8.2-'
'E 'E
II) c:
Vl '"
~Ic
M"'O-
II) Vl
<.;::c;;c
E:E'::.
ti Vl, E
0::: r.ul;::
o
c
C
C
r-..
~
. , '
~
c
S
oc
c
I;:;;
c
c
C
lr>
N
(,A
"- g
, or
r-:
""I
C:
oS:
::;
~
c:cc
8 ;.:
11)-
u..;:;
,- c:
c: '"
_~Ic
=--gcn
tEc;;8
E E
ii r.r. Oc
C:::~~
,0 :::: 011.'
:<::;1< ::.: ~ I
o 0
lI) 0
t- : .00
-
1\:
c
~
M
I~
.~
\I"'J
t-
I;:;;
c
o
C
r-..
I:;;!
Ie
~ ".
I~
c:
.2
U
II)
c:
c:
C
UM
11)-
U
,- ;.:
c: -
QJ "';:
'" c:
'"
~c
::]~
~~U
... c:
OJ 00 "r::
c:::r.u~
e
V"'.
o 0
V"', -0
~
I ~ I')
I '" :i
....
e c 9
;1< :<. ::.: 2 >,
.~ .': IE.~
.'
. < .
':' ::
.'
o
e,
o
cc
:;;!
o
e
C
e
I~
o
e
lI)
"<t
:;;!
00
;;c :
~I~
I... .--l
t--'
.,..
,2 I~
u I~
II) I~
C:M
c:-
~ ~ 1=
'E ~ I::
~Ic Ie:
N~V;
<.;::c;;C
OEU
~ .~.~
o:::r.u~
Ic-,"
<<i
t: .'.
o
lI"1
.... i
. .'
c:
.2
U
'"
c:'"
C:CC
8",
8 ;.:
'E ::
II) c:
'" '"
- I-='
~I'-
M"'Ev;
<.;::c;;o
E:EU
Q3 r.n c
c:::r.u~
e
e
o
o
r--.
~
c
~
~
~
~:
::;; :
I : .
<".
~
~
c
'v,
IZ::
.
o
lI)
~
8 '. '.< ..
~ - .. ...
;; r .~ "f
.... <' :<
...1
c
o
C
~
c
o
C
lr>
N
(,A
'.'
i::
.S:
U
'"
c:
c:cc
c
~ i
u _
"t ;
11)1":;:
"'1'-
] rr.
tE C;;I(
E: E
t) 'tr..E
c::: r.ul;::
0,
V"',
"<t
I;:;
.
"
I:;"
c:
C
U
II)
c:
c:
o
U"<t
,11)-
U
'E i
'" '';::
'" c:
'"
~IC
-~v;
<.;:: C;; 0
E:EU
03 Cj;'c
c:::r.u:::J
o
~
o
cc
:;;!
r--
-
o
a..
o
c;
lI)
'<t
r~'
I
L~.Rf~(:~~9
.... .3
,..".
~~-
..,.
co
= (.) ~
11) 11) ce
r:/JQ:::o
rJJ ~ OIl
.g :.0 t::
._ ce t::
::l ~ 11)
0" (.) c..
.=0:0
i..: ~
:.0..
~=
u-
.~ E
e eo:
j:l..c..
c
.:=
-
C.I
II)
C
C
Q
U
I
rIl
rIl
Q
I- =>
~ 5 gg
~ eo: N
Q ~ ob
C Q ="
~ I-
~c.."'O
~ 05
11)
-=
E=
....
(.)
11)
'0'
~
j:l..
co
="
0\
-
aO
-
.,;
Q
:z
~
c.2
t::
o
.+:;
ce
"5
.D
ce
t-
C.l
C.l
<I>
'"
0:1
.C
C
'0:1.
E--.
==
C.l
1-
E--
::
1-
C.l
..
C.l
trJ
.<1>
.=
'Ell
...~
....;,;:
:>~
.z
Q
o(l
1i~
.c 0:1
y -
;::trJ
~
~.~
5~~
o .~
~.trJ
-.
....
C
Q
<:::
Q.
.;:
y
<I>
C.l
Q
e
C.l
-
-
c
,.,'R...
.'. ...g ..
... oc
.~... ....
....;
.... .... ...
....
~
~
~
S; to-.....
.:.:~
oc
g;~
'""'
~,.c
;,.;,
... "~..
e
,g
u
o
e~
c-
o
~i
U'';:
.- =
C: Ol
o,=:
'" i '-'
~"O-
o '"
tECii8
o E
~.~ c
IXUJ~
c
c
C
c
:;;
.~('
.oj
." ,,'
...
~i'
c
V'.
.,f
.S;
, ..
:~
I~
i ;:
I~
=
,!2
t)
o
E;'g
8-a
82:
'E .E
o =
rr. ~
~'O
:;13tn
u::~o
2E~
t)'~'c
IXUJ~
c
~
c
C
r-
{,'7
. .
c
o
0--
I~
o
.~
V'l
,..-.,
I;;;;
o
o
C
or)
~
-
,
e
.2
t)
o
e
=r-
C
~ i
u_
'E ~
ol~
"'[ '-'
13t;
tECii8
e,5,~
G:)'Ci;C
IXUJ~
c
.~
'V)
'N
If;:;
o
c:
0--
~
c
R
or)
r-
;;;;
c
.'. c
c.
.0
('.j
.. . iii
. ... .'
.
...
o
o
C
r-
~
c
or)
-i
S;
. c.'
. c
. . ~
('1
I~
.
.
i::
,2
t)
o
=
=
o
u<')
0-
u
'E i
o
'" e
_ Ol
N':::
;:::;c::;
-~1n
tECii8
2 ,5.~
'QJt;c
IXUJ~
~" I .... ~ .... g
g... '. .'. g..............~
C>C .. . r- .r-
10 .. ..~ .i,.o,
..
...
..
c
c
C
\I")
C;
o
or)
c
or)~
~i
t'-
--
01-
~
~
c.,
:c ~'l
c,'
'nV;
~o
ot'~
'"
o
o
C
oc
I~
c
o
C
o
:;;
~'~ ...
:g'i
~';A
.....,
e
.2
t)
o
e<')
e -
C
~i
u '';::
.- =
t Ol
_~Ic
~13V)
c-;o
oEU
~.~ .~
IXUJ~
c
\I")
.... -i
S;
I~
lri:
I~
I;:
Ie
1=
=
,!2
t)
o
=
e-
c-a
uor)
82:
'E 'E
o e
'" ell
~Io
<')"0-
-~~
t::OlU
2,5 .~
t)t;;c:
IXUJ~
o
O.
0-.
~
c
~
oc
C
;;;;
o
o
C
or)
~
-
<
e
oS:
t)
o
e
=-a
o
~i
u 'Z
.- =
C: Ol
o ::l
"'0
"0-
o '"
- - 0
l.;:OlU
g.g .~
OJ ~ c
IXUJ;::J
c
. I~
. I~
:t;
c
c
c:..
~
o
or)
I~
c
c:
.,..,
r-
;;;;
Ig
lsi
I~
o
o
C
r-
~
c
c
C
oc
I~
c
lr,
'.,:f
S
I~
Ie
~
,~
t)
o
=
=
c
u_
0-
u
'E i
iU'';::
'" e
_ ell
S'o
_"0-
.., '"
tECiiO
2EU
....'- .-
/U r:;; c:
IXUJ~
r
;
l'-
-
o
C')
Q)
Cl
I1l
0..
i
\
-, AftLi~
MAR 2 3 1999
PG . t.J-
..,.
QC
;..;
c: u
~ ~
rJjC::::
o
.....
C':l
o
~ ~ eIJ
'c eIJ c:
:J ~ c:
cr u 0
c: C':l c..
_e...O
-.:
~ ~.
~:c
..... ,
u -
.~ E
2 C':l
e...c..
=
.S
-
tJ
tJ
-
-
=
Q
U
I
'"
'"
Q
L. =
~ E gg
... tl: N
Q L. I
C ~ 00
~ e Q'-.
~c..'"O
~ as
~
E=
.....
u
o
'0'
....
e...
00
Q'-.
Q'-.
-
~
,;
Q
:z:
....
cE
c:
.~
.....
C':l
"3
.!:J
C':l
r-
..
'C,I
'<Ii
'<Ii
'"
:c
c
",.
!-
-
c:
C,I
...
!-
c:
...
C,I
~
C,I
en
". .
'.
'.
'0
~~
or,llio:
:;;'1..-
.... t~ ....:
N
'"
c:
,'Ei;
ell
:t;:
:-.....
'"f'
:2:
"Q
:
o<J
0;1:
.c: ..
~V5
~
.~
;:l
o
.~.
-
I~(~
:E" :->:~
t .'. ....i;,;...~
en . '\f
c:
c:
;:
c.
'i:
(.j
<Ii
C,I
=:l
e
,~
13
<l.l
eN
c-
o
~i
U_
'E ;
.., ='
"'C
N~C;;
!.;: <C;IC
E E_
ii .~ 'c:
~~::I
E
~
-
9
~
~("
....: C
~
I~
lit- .....
r()
o
o
C
o
;;;
i~
~
17
~
I~
CC
~
i
i::
.~
13
<l.l
CN
C",
8lr)
8 ;,;
'E ::
<l.l e
rJ; ~
~6
("'j13v-
.E<c;8
e .~ .~
tit;c
~~::I
o
o
g
l"-
""
o
C;
I~
Ig
Ioc'
o
o
C;
o
lr)
I~
"---
10
'lr)
'.;,r
Ie;
C
.~
13
<l.l
C
er-
e
~i
u';;
.- e
, '"
_~lc
=]~
!.;: '" 0
OEU
\.....- ......
t)~s::
~~::I
o
C;
V")
N
Ir;;
o
o
I~
~
,;C>
I;;;':
o
S
r:::.
~
o
or,
.,r
~
.'.
C
o
13
..,
C
C
o
UN
..,-
U
'E i
~ 'Z
'" C
- '"
Sic
--gel:
- _ 0
!.;:"'u
e,~ .~
tiv;=
~~::I
c
o
C
V")
1;;
o
lr)
~
c
o
C
o
~
o
o
C
oc
~
o
o
.,.;
.",.
~
~
,2
13
..,
CN
e -
o
~i
u_
'E ;
~c
N~v:
.E<c;8
e E ...
l).~'c:
~,"",::I
5 . -.'
c
I~
0",
lr'; ,~
I~~
If.
~-
cr..
o'~ .' '.'
c"..:l "
V\ __ .'
I~"'" '.'
'l./) '. '.'
'::l ,..
:--.. '.' '.'
~
c
c
o
I;;;
~rg .' '
~ ..... .:.
I~; '::'.
.~ .
'X~.
"
.
o
c
g
.r-
<A
.
o
o
. . V")
I~
. ,
I[
~
I~
I~
-'
,=
::
=
e
.~
13
..,
~8
8..0
8 ;,:
.~ ::
~ ;
_ :"::::u::l
::!.
:;]~
!.;: '" 0
eEU
~'~.c
~~~
C
r-:
I~
o
o
C
V")
~
-
o
or.
..",.
S
~
.2
13
..,
C
Clr)
o
~i
u ...
.- C
, '"
~Ic
"'0
<l.l '"
ct;O
oEU
I- ._ .",=
!) tr. c:
~,"",::I
c
o
lr)
N
~
.
. "
..,:: i :
r-:
~
0.:
C;.
'" .'
r-'
;;;; .,:
.'
. .'
.
c
C
r-
~
~
v.. ..-
~
~
.
: :
C
,2
13
<l.l
e
C
o
UM
..,-
U
.~ i
tU '';::
'" C
- '"
Sic
_"'0"-
<l.l '"
.E<c;8
g.S .~
l1) ti.i c::
~~~
c
s=;
Ci
o
lI")
~
.15
.<-0
15
.~
o
o
C
oc
~
r--
"-
f"".
a:
~ :).
A Icn:7~'t,)
, -J
MAR 2 3 1999
pc. 5
.-
00
="
="
-
~
-
...,.
QQ
-.;
e
:z
.;.; u cu
t: (l) -
~~8
00 ~ en
.~ ~ t:
.!:: (o::l 'c
::l .:.:: (l)
v u c..
Eg:O
~ ....
en ,..
~:c
...... .,
u -
.~ =
e c:
~~
=
e
:;:
(,j
~
=
=
e
U
I
'"
'"
e
I- =
~=~
~ c: M
e 6'sJ ob
co: e Q\
~ I-
~~-i::i
~ as
~
-
E=
-
u
(l)
'0'
....
~
'"
=
.&
.' ,:!,
....
. ... . -:'.'
i
Q
. I
o(l
..'t
.: Cll
.~ in
:;
....
..8
t:
.S2
-
CIS
:i
..0
CIS
~
q;
'1lJ
.'"
',,"
'0:
'I:
I:
0:
I-
.. . .22
c/
.~
-
I:
IlJ
..
l-
I:
..
IlJ
..
IlJ
Vl
c
"'~
~I~
s:'
g~ .'
. c:; ()
"''0;
. .~~
~....
~
c
c
C
c
;;;
(5
c
C
t-
....,
. .' ..'
..'; .'
... ..,<
'-
r",
I~
g
'. .-:
.
;;;;;
~:~
'= ~
:J.':;:
o .~
~~
.~ ~ v=.
I~i: .... ~ .'
I&'.~ '.' .... "/'.
"" .'
"':...!l '.' .
,
=
.S:
C.
.;:
u
'"
IlJ
Q
I:
.S!
t)
IlJ
c-.r
c-
o
~i
u_
.- c
Co '"
1lJ~
"'I,..
N""O-
_ B ~
'-="'u
e .5 .';::
--c
~JJ:::J
e
IlJ
-
-
~
i~
~,
I:E
c:
~
c
.S!
t)
IlJ
CN
coc
8'"
~ ?
'E .E
IlJ C
'" ~
~c
("1")"0-
11) '"
tE~o
o E U
~.~ .~
~u.l:::J
c
c;
'"
N
::;;
....
c
C:
'"
r-
I;;;;;
c
c
C
V".
~
-
,
I
c
,5:
t)
~
C'"
o
~i
U '=
.- c
Co '"
.';], C
=-~cr.
tEE8
2. ::-
Qj'~'c
~~:::J
c
c
C
'"
I::;;
.'
I
c
c;
<'\
~
c
c.
c
r-
I~
c
.V".
-<i
~.
c
c
\ri
-.r .
. N
c
.S!
t)
IlJ
C
C
o
UN
1lJ-
U
'E i
11) '=
ell C
_ '"
!:::lIC
-"'21;;
- - 0
'-="'U
g.5,,;::
Q) t:; c
~~:::J
...
c
c
0..
C .'
00.
....
c
~
~, 8
I~~
~
If'l.....
'--<'
~
c
C
o
c
:;;:
8 (,
c~
v.......
~~
..~
".
. ...~
..
c
c
C
c
;;;
c
c
C
00
~
I
c
,S!
t)
11)
c-.r
c-
o
~i
u_
,- c
Co '"
';],6
N"'O-
IlJ '"
tE~O
OEU
~.~.~
~~:::J
c') ...
C:{)
<rl .
~,~
N.S:;
.....'
I~
Vl
~
-
,
EQ
~
~
!-Vl
-Vl
~<
~~
!- 0 -
~ ~ N
cx:&:o
~~!-
~ u_
.,..<-.r
o<-C:::;':;
o
~
!-
~
Vl
<
!-
,
.
.
.'.
I
c
c,
c
c
iZi
I
~
;:;.;
2:
.!:;
E
IlJ
'"
tIlc
<'"
I1)N
..
ca.2:
>.';::
....c;
u~
11)1,..
.r::--:l
Ua;~
11) - c
:C~U
_ c _
o'~ E
o~-,
c
c
:=:
t:::
...,
~"
E
c
'"
~
c
'"
..c
~
c
S
;r.
~
[ .
c
c
C
v",
I~
c
C;
t:::
I~
.....
-
o
LO
<ll
OJ
ro
0..
I-
-
~ .'
~
~. .l
..; .'
~.
.
.' .
2:
"E
11)
'"
tIl
<c
11)-
..
caZ:;
>.=
.... ~
~c
U---:l-
IlJ '"
IlJ - 0
~Ev
c ';: 'c
oJJ:::J
~ _ bd.
11 . ~G'I'L l~
Mh;< .... 3 lQqq
, ..r'\i ~ L ......:~...,
foG. 1.,
~
QO
- U <I)
~ <I) "'C;;
J.lcGo
~~eJl
'1: eJl ~
.~ ~ ~
;: ~ <I)
a- U c..
.Ec:.o
~ ....
eJl.Q
:2::
- ,
U -
.~ E
2 c:
p..~
=
10
0';::
C,J
~
=
=
10
U
.
'"
'"
10
- Q
usgg
~ c: N
10 - I
C eJi QO
~ E f.:/'I
~=-'"
~ Ci5
2
-
E=
-
U
II)
'[
p..
QO
f.:/'I
f.:/'I
~
....
.,;
Q
;Z
....
<2
~
.S
-
~
:;
.s:.
~
E-
0:>
0:>
'"
'"
~
.C
=
~
ro-
-
C
0:>
...
r0-
c
...
0:>
;.
0:>
rJ:J
_~ ... -c: .'.
._ . ....c:: .'.
:~ .' .....~
.;:: .' '.'
..... '-. ", ,.-
i
Q
-
.
c
c
C
:x:
l~
~
~~
- ~
~Vl
~
iE..~
0:>
- ...
~ .';;
c ~
~oo
-
12
,v
!t
C:!
c
c
:=
C-
't:
...
'"
<:.I
Q
>
:c
E
Q)
'"
..(0
Q)-
>
0:; ;;
> ,<;:
~~
&$6
01ltii
~~8
.g E
8~~
5
0:>
-
-
I~
:9
t
c
c,
V)
M
~
o
o
o
o
~
-
c
c:
V)
M
~
.'
.....~ ~
:-:: ~.< :8
IS; ... ;;i
..
...: .... .... ....
N
2:
.c
E
Q)
'"
..(0
Q)-
>
0:; ;;
>-
-'" ~
u';::
Q)v
.c-o
U <u '"
<u - 0
:SEu
(5 en c:
C\.l.l:J
c
o
C
c
~
o
c:
V')
"<1"
c:
~
~
:n
E
Q)
'"
..(0
Q)II")
eN
o
N ;;
Q)-
.... -
:3 e
'" ~
~o
c..-o_
"E2~
gE~
-0 --
~~:5
::5
C
o
r--
"'"
c
c:c
r-
I~
o
c
C
or.
c:
-
s; · .
..,.;
~
.
.
... .....!
2:
.c
E
Q)
'"
'"
<
<uC
c-
O
N.2:
Q) -
... -
_ c
'J; ~
~O
p..-o-
-0 <u '"
Q) - 0
u~U
::: E_
-0 .-
Q) '" s::
O:::UJ::)
o
c:
or)
.N
:;
f
C
C
r--:
~
C
c:
V)
l-
i;;;;;
g
C
r-
I~
~ ..
.'
<:t '.' .
.~
~
>
:c
E
Q)
'"
'"
<
Q)O
c-
o
N ;;
Q) -
... -
::l C
cr;, ~
~,.=:
....u
c..-o_
-0 Q) '"
Q)-o
u~U
:3 E _
-0 ,- ,-
Cl)~S::
O:::~:J
.g
,c
or;
I::;;
g
c
C
I~
-
l
..
c.
II")
C
~
C
C
.r:
C
I~
.gJ
-I
Ig
.~
g
;r,
~
o
C
C
:x:
~
g
c
C
l;:
.::;< ....
.~ '.
"<1"
.~ .
C
C
~
"<1"
~
I
I .
I' .
~
E
<u
or.
or.
<
<uC
c-
o
Ni
Q).-
.... -
e
or. ~
~C
p..-o
"'0 l\) rJ':.
<u - 0
uceU
::: E_
-0 --
Cl) cr..E
O:::\.l.l...!
..
.'
'.'
.'
'.'
.
'.'
.' .'
... '.
'.'
'.. ....
,...
....
Q
u..
.-;( "J!~~
MAR 2 3 1999 ,
PG. 7
--~--~
,,-
~
co
- u ~
t: Q) _
Q) "'" t':l
CIJ.....O
Vl ..."
~ U c-
.- eIJ._
.:: j t:
::: U Q)
g-~O
-~
i..: >.
CJ),Q
~=
- ,
U -
.S; E
2 eo:
~Q..
C
Q
'.0
<:.I
~
C
C
Q
U
I
III
III
Q
I-
U
......
~
Q
c::
~
CJ
eo:
CQ
Q
E~
E ~
CJ)CO
Q ="
I- ..
Q..:;2
co
~ . .. .... 0 8, ...
0
.. ... r:i Ir.
e . .. 0 I~
:'Ei: C", <:i X
el: '. ....
:i: OJ ,> .....~I.., ':. '.'
i t ~
c X >-
Q .V"> x
-
c. 0
0_
0 0
~ 0 0 x
.... ~ :;! I;;;;: <:i x
0:; ...
.::: 0: OJ X
~ - ... X
rrJ ~ '"
x <II
~ '" x >-
N
co
0\
="
-
':15
.:.
Q
z:
.... g .~
'. '. ..:c
'.:..... ~. i~
....["'\. .'.
.' .... t
.. .'.
.'~. .
.~
. -..
-OIl
0:
1
1-.
-
e
~
...
E-
I:
...
<II
;.
~
rrJ
'.'
0
'- o.
0 IS
,J.
I
I
. .
.
t:i
:.)
... .
:.)
.; ... '.
C",
x
x
~: I'
X". .: 31..
X">
. :.
I : .,.
f
c
u
~
OJ X
.;, X
- X
+ v:
~ X <II
C X >-
u
.
-
'.
.
I
. ;
.
to-
-
o
to-
O)
OJ
ell
a.
I
,
:E~:
-.;: .~
;;:l~~
oa;
MrrJ
....
~ >.
...
'~.1; I
.~ . ~ .~~II .... ~
- 1.,"_;:) X.
~ Ie u .. X .
i2 I~. ~ 0 '. x
. .-
e
.!:
-
c-
.t:
u
'"
<lI
~
>
u
:z:
Ii<::
c.;
c:::
Ii<::
~
Ii<::
rrJ
0. Ii<::
:z:u
-(-
o.~
Ii<::'-l
";:rrJ
~c::::
0._
Ii<::"l:
....1:;.,
-Ii<::
~c:::
I
:;.
c
U
c
,2
~
.~
:E
c
~
-
u
ll)
"'-
;:;
>
r:
r-
"0
ll)
'"
-.:
OJ)
'Il)
>-
I
. .
'..
,.... '.. I...
... .. ..
. L....
\~'--
"f.' ':\
I'"
",
I
I
1.'-'
ll)
(;
~
2-
!::
~
-
E
.:;;:
...
C':
~
'-
c
I~
-;
-c:
ll)
~
~
"C
C
'"
OJ)
t::
co
Cl..
Ie
~ <~
;, ,
---
'-::
'"
.I~
'. ~
-.
'0
ll)
.;
ll)
~
o
c
.:.::
u
co
'"
"0
C
<II
"C
"0
<:
I"::r<
t"
<Ii
E
ll)
E-
E
u
~
'"
Cl..
r
E .,
o ~ 0 ..
o:>-z;f
~
~
.... '-l
~ c.8 Ii<:: <Ii
t: c:::: '" I -
- s ... ;.; ll)
E= 0 1= I ~ E A' . ~;7~ Il$J[J)
.~ <II I
- 5 ~
- - ~ I
u ~ I o::l r\.I_. __
Q) rrJ I
'0' .D -( .L J L....J 3 1999
t':l E- , Mt\R 2
.... E-
~
I PG. 8___
~-.....
.........~~-, ---
-~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
OBTAIN BOARD APPROVAL TO AMEND THE COLLIER
COUNTY RECLAIMED WATER SYSTEM ORDINANCE
OBJECTIVE: Obtain Board approval to amend the Collier County Reclaimed Water
System Ordinance No, 97-37 to add submetering language and allow for allocating cost
to internal users.
CONSIDERATIONS: Collier County provides bulk reclaimed irrigation service to
several communities. Many of these customers submeter irrigation service to internal
customers. The reclaimed water system ordinance is silent on the matter of submetering
and charging the internal customers for service. Accordingly, no protections are
provided to internal users regarding cost allocations or ability to request an explanation of
the basis of charges.
/""""'
In recent months this issue has been brought to the attention of staff. In an effort to deal
with the concerns of internal users staff has developed the following language and
proposes to add said language to Ordinance No. 97-37:
"Customer may apportion the monthly charge for Collier County Water/Sewer District
(CCWSD) reclaimed irrigation service among its internal users either by equal
apportionment, installation of submeters, or otherwise based on reasonable allocation
methods provided that such allocation of cost is restricted to recovery of the customers
actual cost for District reclaimed irrigation service and directly related to administrative
or capital expenses incurred in recovering that cost. Upon the internal users written
request, Customer shall provide to the internal users documentation for the customers
actual cost for District reclaimed irrigation service as well as documentation and a written
explanation of the basis for any costs charged to the member for reclaimed irrigation
service. Such documentation and written explanation shall be provided within five (5)
business days from receipt of written request. The provision of irrigation service as
described in this subsection is deemed not to constitute the sale or disposition of
reclaimed irrigation service."
FISCAL IMPACT: None.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
,~'
NO. Ajl:te)(t,)
MAR 2 3 1999
PG. I
~
,"--
r--
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District of Collier County, Florida,
authorize staff to advertise and bring back Ordinance No. 97-37 with the amendment as
discussed herein.
/7 j; ~ i' r
, , """? c;; Coo
PREPARED BY::"" X---h /7,;''-1..-<_L/ /~""-~ //-t!i/ Date: ~ - /' --- 7 (
Ann Marie Saylor, Adm1 strative Assistant II
-7
Date:
erations & Interim Wastewater
REVIEWED BY./t!f::~-7~
Ed Ilschner, Public Works Administrator
Date:3//p/9 '9
/
Consent Agenda
--7- ...,
NO. ':It'( SfW-
~AR 13 1S9~_1
.(...",.
r--
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPROVE THE DELETION OF THE BACKDOOR SERVICE OPTION FROM
THE AUTOMATED SOLID WASTE CURBSIDE COLLECTION PROGRAM
WITH THE EXCEPTION OF CASES OF MEDICAL NECESSITY.
OBJECTIVE: To offer solid waste curbside collection service consistent with the new
automated cart system provided in Service Area Number One,
CONSIDERA TION: The automated cart system was implemented during 1998 with the
conversion to a system using a single operator on specialized trucks The speed and
efficiency of the system depends on the single operator remaining in the truck as much as
possible, The current fee schedule offers backdoor service at an additional fee paid directly
by the customer to the franchisee, This backdoor option is not consistent with the
automated system Currently there are 129 backdoor accounts out of the total of60,000
units in the service area. The franchisee proposes to give these 129 customers 30 days
notice and revert to curbside service for these units effective May 1, 1999,
The franchise agreement provides for backdoor service for handicapped residents when no
able-bodied person resides in the household, This special service will be maintained,
,"'-'" FISCAL IMPACT: None,
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None,
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners approve the
deletion of backdoor residential service with the exception of cases of medical need and
authorize the Chairwoman to sign the necessary franchisee agreement modification to
follow _
. " f, /;' / /
/, ,// /I
SUBMITTED BY: <#'/;~__;~~~'/I'~"/l/./~./' "
David W, Russell, Director, Solid
Waste Management Department
Date:
.~ -/ ('/,
:c /" - / /
APPROVED BY:~~~~ Date 3 - 1/- Cj 7
-~ Ed I1schner, Public Works Administrator
r.
No.~G1'~(8~O)
MA' f'. ... 3 '''''n
1\ L b~~:1
PG:d.-:- .
r--
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
AWARD A CONTRACT TO LIGHTNER CONTRACTING, INC. FOR
BID NO. 99-2915, BEACH MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES.
OBJECTIVE: To award an annual contract to perform beach maintenance
activities on the Naples, Marco Island and Collier County beaches.
,~
CONSIDERA TIONS: Certain maintenance activities have been found to be
necessary to adequately maintain the restored beaches in Collier County, the
City of Naples and the City of Marco. The maintenance activities associated
with this contract will include but not be limited to escarpment removal,
beach tilling, debris removal and beach grading, It was considered necessary
to establish an annual contract to enable these activities to be performed in
an efficient and timely manner. Therefore, an advertisement for bids was
sent to twenty-six (26) vendors and bids were opened on March 3, 1999.
This was a unit cost bid to provide labor and equipment for performing the
described maintenance activities. These unit costs will be used in
determining the basis for issuance of a purchase order when the scope of
work for each maintenance project has been established.
A proposal from Lightner Contracting, Inc. was the only one received for
this bid, Based upon a review by the staff of the unit costs contained in the
proposal and the qualifications of the vendor, it is recommended that Bid
No, 99-2915 be awarded to Lightner Contracting, Inc, This contract is a
one year agreement with the option to renew for an additional year.
:1\,\' '
FISCAL IMPACT: The cost for performing the activities associated with
this contract were included in the TDC Funding Application for Beach
Maintenance Activities which was approved by the Board of County
Commissioners on February 9, 1999 [Agenda Item (16)(B)(6)]. Funds in the
amount of $243,700,00 have been appropriated as a result of said approval.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDA TIONS: That the Board of County Commissioners:
1. Award a contract for Bid No. 99-2915 to Lightner Contracting, Inc.
2, Authorize purchase orders to be issued for beach maintenance projects
based upon the unit costs in the bid proposal.
r-
Executive Summary
r~;';~:~){ji)(ii'
'-1 . ," 'J . ,-- ...,.., I
' Ij ....., ,".,' ~ ; .
( .r ~!\ /~ -J r:..:...;.;
P' I J
~;..m..~.~~-=~:~~~~~
~
Executive Summary
Contract To Lightner Contracting, Inc.
Page Two
PREPARED BY:
// A' -~- ,-
.../ ~~
9- L- ~ e::.-C''-<-. /~~ -<--
~
Harold E. Huber, Project Manager III
Public Works Engineering Department
REVIEWED BY:
. ~', I r '\ ..
.mr~\ '11 . 19v-iJ:L
Steve Carnell ,I
Purchasing Director
DA TE:
') '" ("', r
;> I I I
-1 \ Cj
DATE: -~- \- ILl
REVIEWED BY:
Y./i'Jr/~
r--
ff Bibby, P ,E" Director
Public Works Engineering Department
APPROVEDBY:~
Ed 11 schner
Public Works Administrator
attachment
cc: Beach Renourishment/Maintenance Committee
Lightner Contracting, Inc.
r--
7)/h11:-'
DA TE:
DA TE: ~//2,,/9q
{ '
f NO. ~'~Jtli3tv_ '1
I MAi.i 'i 3 i"J-., l
~~:~~~._:~_1
.,.--..
~
Ct>
::l
- S'
--3 t](:;
~ 0
~ ~ Pol
....
CO Ct>
....
::l :::
Ct> '<
CIl Ct>
~ :: IJCi ~ Ct> Q. ~ 0' ~ (..,l N Q. ~ C" ~ ....
:::0 to ""0 C. n r-' 0 CO 0 0 w ;N "'I'j ~ tc ~ Z n < ~ (..,l
0 ::r '""I 0 ~. Ct> 0 7t ::: tl: 0 '""I .c Ct> Pol - $::.l I
0 CIl 0 Pol $::.l 0 ~
::l 0 3 .... "0 ::l X 3 (") $::.l ::l = ~ d "0 3 ::l 0'
::l 0 n' 0 (p co :::0 7;'" Q.. ,- -6' ~ (D Q.. ~
"'0 Q.. '"0 -, -, '""I 0 '"0 ::r 0 =- 0 CIl Ct> = ~
'""I Pol .... CIl e:... - .... 0 tTJ a "'0 '""I .... I
(p -3 t'I1 tl: Pol --3 - Pol [ N
"'t1 0 '""I Ct> '""I ::l CIl \C
(") \/) ::r -, .0 r Q.. Q.. ::: Pol Q.. Ct> = p.) CIl ~ \C
::: ::l ~ '""I ,... tl: Ct> (") '"0 Q.. = CIl .... ....
"0 r 0 - -- ....
!:?. (p ~. cr 7;'" ::1. Ct> l" .... .... ::l "'t1 co 0
3 (p (S. ~ '"0 ::: '""I 0 = Q.. =
::1. 3 -- (") ~ IJCi Pol Ct>
(p -- 0 ..... ..... Ct> Pol = '""I --.
::l w ::l ..... Ct> (") 00 "0 Q.. 7;'" Pol ='
g '""I '"0 '"0 ::1. Q. "CI 0
.... '-" CIl Ct> Ct> ::r Ct> 0
Ct> -3 (") Ct> (") '""I ~ \/)
-3 ;N CIl .... '"0 '"0 '< '""I Ct> t"" .... ::r a ~
0 Ct> >- ::1. Ct> '""I '-" ~ ~ ~ 0
::l (t> >- (") '""I ::: ::r '"0 -- 0' Ct> '""I 0 \/)
-< (") '"0 0 (1) ;N 0' ("')
:::: '""I .... =. Ct> ::r 7;'" ::: '""I 0 "CI (1) ....
.... 0 '""I 0 ~
CIl g r:; '"0 '""I ~ Ct> -
(") - ,... -- (") ::r 0 ~ ;r
..... $::.l (1) ;:; w -
(") ::r Ct> 0 .... ~ -=
cr '""I 0 ::: ~
Ct> Ct> - '"0 :::0 .... --3
CIl Q.. 0 :::r (") -; ~ o'
0 Ct> $::.l ~
>- ." '< -; -
0' 7;'" Ct> = 0
::: '-" - Ct>
.... -; .....
;;;- -; 0 -- Z
'"0 Ct>
Q.. C -. ::: "0 ~
CIl (S' -; -; ~
(? (1) (1) (S. =-
Q.. >- "0 Ct> r=;
....;; "0
.... (1)
.... -; 0 0
tl: ::r ..., ....
(") ::r '-"
:::r 0
0 ::: 0
0.. ..., :::
....;; ...,
z -< -< -< .
s 0 Ct> Ct> 'l) t""
CIl CIl CIl
.... .. o .....
(1) =1JCi
. '.' f;/'J f;/'J '€A f;/'J f;/'J ....=-
.~ .~ .~ ~ ~ t:A t:A N .- - .- - ~ ....
N 00 >D +>- -..J VI 0- - -..J -..J -..J -..J ~ ::l
? v, .- VI 0 VI 5=' 9 '.' VI IJ\ Y' IJ\ ~ Ct>
..... :- (:> :"'" ~
0 c 0 0 0 c 0 c 0 0 c
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .. 0 0 0 0>
..:' . ... .'. . < :
'. '.' :'. '. <
.:... .
- '. .'
.. .i
. ..' ....: ...:..
.' .' '.' > .:
. '.'
<
.! . ..... .> I :
. . > _: . . > - '. .
.:. .: . >. . ..~. .' .... .'
:.. < .'. .
. . : '.
> .>
. :. .'.:.' .
. .... >.. . .' .: ..: _.
'. .
> :... .. N
'. .' . ... '.
\J
Q)
.r--
~
r-
-3"'t1
Pol -;
cr..2
::: Ct>'
[Q.
s' ~.
..... ....
~rr
0'
...,
co
0..
\Ctc
\CCt>
I =
N l":I
~:r
U1~
~
s'
....
Ct>
=
=
=
~
Ct>
>
~
....
...'
<
....
....
....
Ct>
II>
::c"'O
= -;
~ .2,
~ (1)
'-< s:..
::c~
C t](:;
0' '""I
Ct> .,
~
~s
o .0
7;'" :::
$::.l ::j'
~ (D'
CIl CIl
;Nr:./)
Ct> (1)
o a
N
-Q-.
tD
0:
co
co
~
co
....
CJl
tD
Cl)
AI
('l
':1'
s:
AI
S'
....
Cl)
~
AI
~
('l
Cl)
)>
('l
....
<'
;::;:
(D'
(II
~f~i~r8)
MAR ':' 3'. 1Q;iq
p: L !..........-
i PG. 3
~"~~~~.,.;;.;--".--
.----
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
ADOPT A RESOLUTION REVISING THE ELIGIBILITY FOR MEMBERSHIP
ON THE NAPLES BEACH RENOURISHMENT/MAINTENANCE COMMITTEE.
OBJECTIVE: To adopt a resolution whereby applicants residing within the
unincorporated area of Collier County or within any municipality in Collier
County will be eligible for appointment by the Board of County
Commissioners to the Naples Beach RenourishmentlMaintenance Committee,
CONSIDERATIONS: On December 9, 1992, the Board of County
Commissioners adopted Resolution No. 92-656 recognizing the City of Naples
Beach RenourishmentlMaintenance Committee as a technical advisory
committee to formally advise the Board of County Commissioners as well as
the Naples City Council. This resolution provided for the selection of five (5)
members to be appointed by the Board of County Commissioners from the
unincorporated area of Collier County.
Prior to its incorporation, residents from Marco Island were eligible for
appointment by the Board of County Commissioners to the Naples Beach
....--. Renouri shment/Mai n tenance Committee. Recent appl ication s from residen ts of
the City of Marco were declared invalid based upon the provision in Resolution
No. 92-656. Therefore, the attached resolution has been prepared for
consideration whereby the Board of County Commissioners will be able to
appoint members to the committee from any municipality in Collier County as
well as from the unincorporated area.
I',", FISCAL IMPACT: None
"
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDA TIONS: That the Board of County Commissioners:
1. Adopt the attached Resolution revising the eligibility for membership on
the Naples Beach Renourishment/Maintenance Committee.
2. Authorize the Chairwoman to execute the Resolution.
".---.
r~w,,~-~.~~---,
I NO. ~t~rdjCV. -. I
MA':t 'i 3 1C;CfQ ~
"t. ' .. .' " t
l PG. J ___.__. I
. ~ ~~-.', k-~~~~.;;._~;.T___..,,""~..'"'"'.._..
~.
Executive Summary
Adopt A Resolution/Naples Beach Renourishment
Page Two
PREPARED BY: /~/~ DATE: ,s./(.C)Cj
Harold E. Huber, Project Manager III
Public \Vorks Engineering Department
REVIEWED BY:
:7 /i.~J~
DATE:
J~//17
f Bibby, P.E., Director
Public Works Engineering Department
,"--"
APPROVEDBY:~
Ed Ilschner
Public Works Administrator
DATE: 8/12j9'?
I
attachment
cc: Beach Renourishment/Maintenance Committee
r-
r-----:.="~:~"~--~
l N0. ~'7i: (8}liJ- I
LMA.... 3 1"-'1" 1
I ~ 'j ~ ~.~ '_~ ~
1\ t.. ! -' ,. -~ t
,
I
PG.,;;J t
... .,-- ~
· ~_.............."..=~n'~'"'- '_'-_~"'_
.----
.----
,/"'""'"'
RESOLUTION NO. 99-
2
3 RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
4 COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
5 REVISING THE ELIGIBILITY FOR MEMBERSHIP ON THE
6 NAPLES BEACH RENOURISHMENT/MAINTENANCE
7 COMMITTEE.
8
9
10 WHEREAS, the Naples Beach Renourishment/Maintenancc Committee consists
11 of eleven (II) voting members, and
12 WHEREAS, five (5) members of the Naples Beach Renourishment/Maintenance
13 Committee are appointed by the Board of County Commissioners; and
]4 WHEREAS, the current County resolution requires the five (5) members
15 appointed by the Board of County Commissioners to be from the unincorporated area
16 of Collier County; and
17 WHEREAS, prior to its incorporation, residents from Marco Island were
18 eligible for appointment to the Beach Renourishment/Maintenance Committee; and
19 WHEREAS, the County desires to have representation from the City of Marco
20 on the Committee_
21 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
22 COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA, that
23 I. It is hereby declared that applicants residing within the unincorporated
24 area of Collier County or within any municipality in Collier County shall be eligible
25 for appointment by the Board of County Commissioners to the Naples Beach
26 Renourishment/Maintenance Committee.
27 2, This Resolution shall supersede Collier Coullty Resolution No, 92-656,
28 3, ThIS Resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
29 This Resolution adopted thIS day of , 1999, after
30 motion, second and majority vote favoring same.
31
32
33
34
35
36 ATTEST
37 Dwight E. Brock, Clerk
38
39 By.
40 Deputy Clerk
41
42 Approved as to form and
:~ ~~e1YA~
46 Heidi F. Ashton
47 Assistant County Attorney
48
49 H EH .Ih 3,1. 99
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By.
Pamela S. Mac 'Kie, Chairwoman
t~-_$._:-r..~~,",:,. -~'--/.
,t "'. .~~lfdi,J.C.~J i
MAR'" 3 ,...--, "
~ L !::~;:j f
i PG .~______. ·
c~......_.>#.....~-.._~....~.,.,. ....n;.__J
,.-.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
AUTHORIZE USE OF THE CHARLOTTE COUNTY TRENCHLESS PIPE
REHABILITATION BID NO. 97-254.
Objective: That the Board of County Commissioners, as the ex-officio Board of the Collier
County Water-Sewer District (CCWSD), authorize staff to utilize the Charlotte County
Trenchless Pipe Rehabilitation Bid No. 97-254 for CCWSD pipe line rehabilitation.
Consideration: As part of the 1998-1999 Adopted Budget, the Board of County Commissioners
authorized staff to complete certain CCWSD pipe line rehabilitation projects,
The Board's Purchasing Policy provides for cooperative buying under the Southwest Florida
Purchasing Consortium Program. Charlotte County Bid No. 97-254 provides for cured in place
and U-liner trenchless pipe lining, unit pricing, warrantee TV surveys and warrantees. The
current bid is valid through September 1999.
Growth ~lanagement: None
r-
Fiscal Impact: Funds in the amount of $1,385,000 have been budgeted for sanitary sewer
system pipe line rehabilitation. Funds are available in the sewer capital fund (414) under project
number 73050 Sewer Line Rehab. Funds in the amount of $991,500 have been budgeted for
water distribution system pipe line rehabilitation. Funds are available in the water capital fund
(412) not presently under a project number. Please note that these budgets are for overall
rehabilitation efforts not solely trenchless rehabilitation.
Recommendation: That the Board of County Commissioners authOllze the use of the Charlotte
County Trenchless Pipe RehabilitationB, No. 9)-254 for
" ,/
PREPARED BY: /' /
/' ......
Edward N. FimI;O~ons/lnte .
WSD pipe line r7bili
,/"-:>
('
REVIEWED BY:
l,/ / '-----
~J;{.. (,;A~U", j/
,
Steve Carnell, Purchasing Director
~ III II -:1 )(.0 OJ
",",' I ~ \ -/
, .
Date
REVIEWEDBY:-~~
Ed Ilschner, Public Works Administrator
;3.&2/99
, 4[
Date
~
~~(or.~~l
Mt,..! ! J, ~''';''-;'J'
. .,..~ t \ .::.. .,J ! "'" '..' ,.1
PG. f .
r--
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
RESCIND THE A WARn OF A CONTRACT TO ALLIED TRUCKING OF
FLORIDA, INC./C.B.E. TRUCKING COMPANY, INC. FOR BID NO. 98-
2900 AND AWARD A CONTRACT TO DOUGLAS N. HIGGINS, INC. FOR
THE TRANSPORT AND PLACEMENT OF BEACH FILL MA TERIAL.
OBJECTIVE: To rescind the award of a contract to Allied Trucking of Florida,
Inc.lC.B.E. Trucking Company, Inc. for Bid No. 98-2900 as granted on February
9, 1999 and award a contract for same to the next low bidder, D. N. Higgins, Inc.
CONSIDERA TION: On February 9, 1999, the Board of County Commissioners
awarded a contract for Bid No. 98-2900 to the partnership of Allied Trucking of
Florida, Inc.lC.B .E. Trucking Company, Inc. [Agenda Item 16(B)( 4)]. The
awardee, however, has failed to execute a Contract in accordance with the
Proposal and upon the terms and conditions setforth therein. Therefore, it is
recommended that such award be rescinded and that a contract for Bid No. 98-
2900 be re-awarded to the next low bidder, Douglas N. Higgins, Inc. in the
amount of$417,857.14,
~\... FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of a budget amendment is necessary to account for
, the additional funds in the amount of $55,357.14 required for this award.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners:
1. Rescind the award of a contract for Bid No. 98-2900 to Allied Trucking of
Florida, Inc.lC.B,E. Trucking Company, Inc, as granted on February 9, 1999
[Agenda Item 16(B)(4)].
2. Re-award a contract for Bid No. 98-2900 to the next low bidder, Douglas N.
Higgins, Inc. in the amount of $417,857.14.
3. Authorize the staff to file a claim against the bid bond provided by Allied
Trucking of Florida, inc, for failure to comply with the bidding requirements.
4. Approve the necessary budget amendment.
5. Authorize the Chairwoman to execute the contract.
r
:..~"":'-.~--,
i,...5J;.,(~J.ti11 I
~
~ ; " ',(i ,-. !
. I I...
~ :....,.... .
L, _ ._.. -:::-.-:':: ",:=-:--::-=,-":::,-:-.!
Page Two
/.--,
SUBMITTED BY: _~~ --
Harry Huber, Project Manager III
Public Works Engineering Department
/' ~ I . -
\. '7 . . J /
REVIEWED BY: -<:~(//., "\ - -...-({~). / (
Steve Carnell, Director
Purchasing Department
~/f Jr/-
REVIEWED BY:
eff Bibby, P .E., Director
Public Works Engineering Department
,~
APPROVED BY:-~.....w~
Ed Ilschner, Administrator
Public Works Division
attachments
cc: Allied Trucking of Florida, Inc.
Douglas N. Higgins, Inc.
,r-.
DATE:
DATE:
cS.(~.'7~
"l I !
~~~ \ 11 Cl {oj
I 1
DATE: 3/'509
DATE: d-/J-t:j?
("-"""--"::";:~,'-;~ '-~,--:'~""-"~
; ~,:..,j1(8)~L)-_ ~
I M t.;{ ", j" " ,',' ~
;: r1n L t~.~-' ,,1 ~
L~~~~~,:,_..;..j
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPROVAL TO ADMINISTRA TIVEL Y ADJUST THE NON-AD VALOREM
ASSESSMENT FOR PARCEL NUMBER 11 IN THE NAPLES PRODUCTION
r-- PARK M.S.T.U.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain authorization to administratively adjust a non-ad valorem
assessment for the Naples Production Park M.S.T.U.
CONSIDERA TIONS: Subsequent to adoption of the final assessment roll for the
Naples Production Park M,S.T.U., the need for adjustment to a certain assessment
(Parcel No, II) has been discovered. This adjustment is necessary due to the
determination that the property owner, the Board of Trustees of the Internal
Improvement Trust Fund (State of Florida) is not subject to taxes or special
assessments. This adjustment will result in a $24,683.17 deficit in the total amount to
be recovered via assessments. Since the public hearing has now been concluded, the
cost of this deficit cannot be redistributed among the other properties in the project
unless the public hearing is reopened for this purpose. Therefore, it is recommended
that this deficit be funded from project reserves in Fund 341.
FISCAL IMPACT: Sufficient funds are not available for this purpose in the budget
for the Naples Production Park M.S.T.U. (Fund 138) during FY 98/99. Approval of a
budget amendment is requested whereby funds for this obligation would be borrowed
from the reserves in the budget for Road Assessments Receivable (Fund 341) with the
condition that reimbursement from the Naples Production Park M.S.T.U. be provided
during FY 99/00.
/-
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDA TIONS: That the Board of County Commissioners:
1. Authorize administrative adjustment of the non-ad valorem assessment for Parcel
No. 11 in the Naples Production Park M.S.T.U. in the amount of $24,683.17.
2. Authorize payment in this regard as follows:
(a) Collier County Department of Revenue - $10,537.00
(b) Collier County Tax Collector - $14,146.17
3. Approve the necessary budget amendment.
PREPARED BY:
~~
Harold E, Huber, Project Manager III
Public Works Engineering Department
DATE:
3"'1.9~
REVIEWED BY:
~/?',J/
" ~ / j ....A,.L
eff Bibby, P.E., Director
Public Works Engineering Department
DATE: s/;-;/11
r-
~
APPROVED BY: !qll..::-l~JU-L,/ ~ ..;;;'
Ed Ilschner /
Public Works Administrator
DA TE:,!/I~f i,.
~. .~ '." I \"~'-~".---'
"~ f.. /(, " 11 )( ;',) ; t'
I ' ..--'-.10<:4 -/- !
i APE; 3 ::j I
l
r.,.,;; .__.--,,__....__ ~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
,~
APPROVE AMENDMENT 7 TO PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH
HOLE, MONTES & ASSOCIATES, INC., FOR ENGINEERING SERVICES RELATED
TO IMPROVEMENTS AT THE SOUTH COUNTY WATER RECLAMATION
FACILITY, RFP 93-2121, PROJECT 73916
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners, as the Ex-Officio Governing
Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, approve an amendment to a professional
services agreement to provide services related to rerating the permitted treatment capacity of
the facility.
CONSIDERATIONS:
Consistent with the 1999 Annual Update Inventory Report, it is proposed to re-rate the
permitted capacity of our 8-mgd South County Water Reclamation Facility (SCWRF). An
Amendment to a Professional Services Agreement has been prepared for services to re-
evaluate the treatment capacity of the existing facility as needed to re-rate the facility.
Services to be provided are consistent with our existing March 15, 1994 agreement with
Hole, Montes & Associates, Inc. for professional services pursuant to RFP 93-2121.
~ The consultant proposes to make adjustments to the hourly rate schedule contained in the
1994 agreement. Total consultant fees associated with Amendment 7 are $116,000. A
summary of total fees approved and proposed are as follows:
Fees
Scope of Services
Original Agreement
Amendment 1
Amendment 2
Amendment 3
Amendment 4
Amendment 5
Amendment 6
Amendment 7 (proposed)
247,000 Preliminary Report, Conditional Use
322,700 Design Report, Disinfection Design
582,000 Deep Injection Well
218,000 Reuse Master Plan, Lakewood Design
2,016,000 WWTF design, permits, bid and construct
60,000 SRF Coordination and Administration
41,388 Post-construction SRF Administration
116,000 Re-Rate Permitted Capacity
Total
$3,605,396
r-
Staff has negotiated the proposed scope and compensation as provided in Amendment 7 to
Professional Services Agreement, copies of which are available for viewing at the Clerk's
Office of Minutes and Records, the Board of County Commissioners' Office, and the County
Administrator's Office.
AGENDA ITEM
.C'. FISCAL IMPACT: Funds in the amount of $116,000 are available in c ~o~S&"'~" r~pital
Projects. The source of funds is user fees. I (j 6 13
- MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I
Executive Summary
Approve Amendment 7, RFP 93-2121
Page 2
r-
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMP ACT: In accordance with the Ninth Annual Update and
Inventory Report on Public Facilities approved by the BCC on January 12, 1999, additional
capacity is to be achieved by "re-rating" the plant in 1999 as opposed to construction of
added capacity
RECOMMENDATIONS: That the Board of County Commissioners, as the Ex-Officio
governing board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, approve and authorize
Chairwoman to execute Amendment 7 to Professional Services Agreement with Hole,
Montes & Associates, Inc., related to planning and preliminary design services to re-rate the
treatment capacity of our SCWRF.
J1
SUBMITTED BY: I(;.'-f:.>-,-,-",/~ ,9-- Date: :r/z/r1
Karl W. Boyer, P.E., PWED Senior Project Manager
,"'--'
REVIEWED BY:
,....--, 'J
7/(' ,,;
'""Y 0 _J;-- (, ' ---J
fBibby, P.E., PWED DIrector
Date:
-..1..... ~ ,~
)//-;,/9 ~/
REVIEWED BY:
( Ed
'7'..... -. ....;'
REVIEWED BY:,.--, ,,~. 'J, "'-'~/~
Stephen Y. Carnell, Purchasing Director
"-
Date: ..
APPROVEDBY~
Ed Ilschner, ublic Works Administrator
Date: a/it7 it? q
/ /
~
',..c..-.. "'tl2)' "'.'
~0.~Ji.Ji) "3 ,
MA~' ,., 3 .""Q
K L I:~;_.
PG. _~~__~.:J
EXECUTIVE SUM.MARY
/---
APPROVE PAVING THE LIMEROCK PORTION OF PORTER STREET IN
RESPONSE TO CITIZENS' REQUEST.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain Board approval of a plan for paving a portion of Porter Street
subject to funding from benefiting property owners.
CONSIDERA TIONS: The County maintains the road base on a number of limerock
roads. The Transportation Services Department has received inquiries over the years as to the
possibility of improving the limerock roads with an asphalt paved surface. There have been
three typical scenarios to accomplish these improvements:
1. Creation of an MSTU;
2. Prepayment of funds to the County; or
3. Completion of improvements by the adjacentlbenefiting property owners.
The cost of road maintenance is reduced because maintenance costs for paved roadways is
typically one-fourth that for limerock road maintenance. Accordingly, the cost to maintain the
limerock portion of Porter Street as shown on Attachment 1 is about $1,500 annually.
~
A cost estimate of $20,638.27 (Attachment 2) has been prepared based on grading the existing
limerock base, applying an asphalt prime coat with lean mix, followed by application of a one-
inch thick asphalt wearing surface. The improvements will be restricted to a width of
approximately 20 feet and designed for a relatively low volume of local traffic with a
hammerhead or "T" turn-around at the dead end. The property owners continue to remain
responsible for reconstruction/paving of private driveways.
One of the property owners on Porter Street, Mr. Frank Roberto, acting on behalf of the
residents, volunteered to pursue the donation method (Option 2 above). Mr. Roberto devised
the methodology of a front footage cost per property and sent letters to all benefiting property
owners stating their proportionate share. Mr. Roberto has collected $13,309.39. He has
received commitments from other property owners for $4,412.03 upon completion of the paving
project. Mr. Roberto is requesting that the Board accept the $13,309.39, the promise of
$4,412.03, and participate with the property owners to the extent of the remaining $2,916.85 to
accommodate the paving. Staff and Mr. Roberto will continue to pursue the outstanding funds.
Based on the above information, staff, in concert with Mr. Roberto, has developed the following
options:
1. Accept the $13,309.39 already collected with County participation for the estimated
remaining $7,328.88.
r,.,.,.~+:~1LL0
< .-.a.,.,
~ W
I .
l
~ i~?\f>; 2 3 1999
,.
~ FG, I
il.~-.u~'-,('~~,,'.~.~ ,
~
2. Accept the $13,309.39 already collected and have the property owners accept the liability
"...--- for collecting the $4,412.03 promised for a total of $17,721.42. The County's participation
is estimated at $2,916.85.
3. Require the benefiting property owners to subsidize the entire estimated cost of $20,638.27.
4. Require the benefiting property owners to petition the Board for a Municipal Service Benefit
Unit (MSBU).
Based upon the public benefit derived from reduced maintenance costs, staff recommends the
Board approve Option #2.
FISCAL IMPACT: The total cost for improvements is estimated at $20,638.27. The
benefiting property owners will provide $17,721.42 pursuant to Option #2. The remaining
$2,916.85 is available in MSTD Road District 3.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approve Option #2 as outlined above, and direct
staff to implement the project subject to receiving $17,721.42 from the benefiting property
owners.
DATE: Z-~ LA ~7 5"
REVIEWED BY:
Ed~~~.dJ.........~K......"....,~t....~..0.......~. '., /T. r.anspo.rtation Services Director
G./ (/ , ) -~_~
APPROVED ~~:<__'~~~~~~~_
Ed Ilschller, Public Works Administrator
DATE: 'L'W'))
DATE:J 3-02 - f't/f
Attachments
".~__",.~~...1 k13.(!~'f)"";
'I' . AGCIf-iI' _OOJ v::.. "\ !
.' ~.. :.' .. \
I ~~rd::: '! 3- 1[~'~
~ I'll-'ll' l.. ...~..
~ PC. ;;l" . ~
~~n~."".""""'.....l
ATTACHMENT 1
======>-2-<
(
'.
~
. I"L)
"E)
t
-.:-\
\
,,~"_ 1../'" I"
~ ' _~m,,~, ,fP.J:J..!.-j ~
if,;". ,>",-c.,,": v~r:::-:?
t . .-/
I ~J. ,', ;"
; nf\i\ 2 3 1999-
L.!.o;; . ..3
................- ".....~
I
.
~
~
""
"-
~
- ''';...,,,.!'
A'ITACHMENT 2
PRELIMINARY ESTIMATED IMPROVEMENT COSTS
FOR PORTER STREET
September 30, 1998
GENERAL
Mobilization
Traffic Maintenance
Lump Sum
Lump Sum
$5,000.00
$ 500.00
PAVING
Fill
Limerock Base
Prime and Lean
1 ~" Type II Asphaltic Concrete Paving Tons
75 S.Y.
56 S.Y.
2,824 S.Y.
375 Tons
$ 480.96
$ 476.56
$1,412.00
$9,768.75
DRAINAGE
CMP
CMP
60' X 24"
40' X 18"
$2,000.00
$1,000.00
TOTAL
$20,638.27
r..-'c~'a,.,~. -- /(, 1/1'1_'0'"
: .' ......~, ,
~. f4 ...1
~.. - / - ~
:; r: " :', ,,-- -- ~
~, ',i .' ,'" >f': 3 -\1-_'"' .,
i It..', ;~ .~ / : ;; ..~ '< /
:~ -, ....,. li
W p: t.L ~
" "" .........._-J.::..;.,,--~,-_.._.---... t
~:wro.;".--"~_........:;.,,,,~:...........ll<,;J
.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
--
APPROVAL TO FUND THE 4th OF JUL Y FESTIVAL AND FIREWORKS
SHOW.
Objective: That the Board of County Commissioners approve a budget amendment in
the amount of $25,000 to fund the 2nd annual 4th of July festival and fireworks show at
Sugden Regional Park.
Consideration: Parks and Recreation staff is once again partnering with the
Naples Junior Chamber (NJC) to host a 4th of July Festival at Sugden Regional Park. The
one-day festival will include a$25,000 fireworks show, live entertainment, patriotic
music, games for children and adults alike, and affordable food and beverages. Last year
(the event's first year), staff estimated that 5,000 people turned out for the event. This
year staff anticipates a much larger crowd, as Sugden Park has established itself in the
community, publicity will begin much earlier this year, and the entertainment will
address everyone in the family. This event affords residents a viable alternative to other
fireworks shows.
Growth Management: None
Fiscal Impact: The fireworks will cost the County $25,000 and will be transferred
-----, by budget amendment from general fund reserves into the Recreation Programs budget.
Recommendation: That the Board approve a budget amendment to fund the 4th of July
festival.
Prepared by: ~ '" l~ilA1 ~
ohn Dunnuck, OperatlOns Coordmator
Department of Parks and Recreation
Reviewed an~ ~ /J
Approved by. /.~.) G "L~y."-L..
Marla Ramsey, Director
Department of Parks and Recreation
Date:
3IrZ/'f1
Date: 3 -/2-fy
Reviewed and I ~
Approved by: \ y~~
Thomas W. Olliff, Adm ator
Division of Public Services
Date: 3. \5 .q~
~
~g~n1m'~~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I
. .u_..."__m..''''_~,_""",,,'_''''''"''_''<'
....__.__.."'....__""'..,..,...._"..dol..''''~',.....-._'''".,,;._. ,_..'~ ~
..
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
~.~""--
APPROVE THE PURCHASE OF PLAYGROUND EQUIPMENT FOR EAGLE
LAKES COMMUNITY PARK.
Objective: To award the purchase and installation of playground equipment for Eagle
Lakes Community Park to Dominica Recreation Products, Inc. / Gametime utilizing an
annual state contract.
Consideration: The parks and recreation department has specifically budgeted
funds in Fiscal 98/99 to purchase and install playground equipment at Eagle Lakes
Community Park. Dominica Recreation Products Inc., a supplier of many other Collier
County park playground structures, is currently on state contract (#650875, 650876) and
would be able to install said playground for $75,000. Collier County Purchasing policy
stipulates that departments must gain Board approval for annual state contract purchases
over $25,000.
Growth Management: None
Fiscal Impact: The cost of the project is $75,000. Funds are budgeted in the
Community Park Fund, Eagle Lakes Community Park Project.
/..-...
Recommendation: That the Board award the purchase of playground equipment to
Dominica Recreation,Produc Inc. for Eagle Lakes Community Park.
Date: .3 - //-f7
Prepared by:
Mur 0 Smith, Recreation Manager
Department of Parks and Recreation
Reviewed amL,fi
Approved by: j/J'~ Y11~
arIa Ramsey, Director
Department of Parks and Recreation
Date: 5-/! - 7'7
Reviewed and ~ /:... II
Approved by: A ~ ~ ~'\1
Steve ell, Dl tor
Department of Purchasing
'/ 1 ~-i-
Date: :J- t 1
Reviewed an~ ~
Approved by: Q^ ~
Thomas W. Olliff, inistrator
Division of Public Services
Date: 3. ~ 0::; oCf?t
,---
Agenda It~'"
No. IfJ(~ ~
.
MAR 2 3/1999
pg.
-
,-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPROVAL OF TWO (2) INTERLOCAL FUND SHARING AGREEMENTS WITH THE
CITY OF NAPLES AND THE CITY OF EVERGLADES
Objective: That the Board of County Commissioners enter into a fund sharing agreement with
the City of Naples for various park improvements projects~ and that the Board of County
Commissioners enter into a separate fund sharing agreement with the City of Everglades to
renovate their recreational community center.
Consideration: The Board previously approved and budgeted in FY99 funds to support
both interlocal agreements. The agreement with the City of Naples provides funding for three
projects: Phase II of Beach Access Improvements, Phase III of the Naples Landing renovation,
and the Edge Skate Park Improvements Project. The first two are tied to the interlocal beach
access agreement as well. Below is a brief description of each project.
Beach Access Improvements: Phase II entails the renovation of fourteen (14) beach access
points to include landscaping upgrades, brick pavers, and customer service amenities such as
drinking fountains and bicycle racks. The County will remit 50% of project cost not to exceed
$25,000,
...-- Naples Landing Improvements: Phase III includes the addition of picnic facilities and shade
structures, renovation of the parking area, improved landscaping, additional lighting, and a new
area to view the bay. The County will remit up to $25,000 for said project.
Edge Skate Facility: The County will remit up to $15,000 for expansion of the City facility to
accommodate City and County residents alike. In exchange, the City will not charge an additional
fee to unincorporated residents within the lifetime of the project without the consent of the Board,
described as "authorized County Representative" in section 4 of the Agreement.
Everglades Community Center: The County Summer Camp program has utilized this facility
in the past. Renovation includes repair and replacement or building infrastructure and parking lot
improvements. The County will fund $50,000 of renovation cost,
Growth Management: These facilities are operated by their respective City municipalities
and therefore are not included in the County Comprehensive plan.
Fiscal Impact:
listed below:
Funds are budgeted and available in the Park Improvement Fund (306) as
~
Naples Landing (306-156314-881400-80074)
Beach Ends Project (306- 1/1/3t..c ,7('51t.'..' .kt.,
Edge Skate Park Project (306-156314-881400)
Everglades City Skate Rink (306-llb3bo-S""~''to,,)
$25,000
$25,000
$15,000
$50,000
Agend. J ,em
No. /(C(S4 Cf
MAR 2 3 1999
PQ. ,
-
Recommendation: That the Board authorize the Chairwoman to sIgn the interlocal
agreements with the City of Everglades and the Cny of Naples.
~.~ n
Prepared By: ~
ohn Dunnuck, OperatIons Coordmator
Department of Parks and Recreation
Reviewed and AI ~ /" /
Approved By: . It//.A'p~
Marla Ramsey, Direct
Department of Parks and Recreatlon
Date: '3 ire... / ~9
Date: :5- (2..7:9
Reviewed and
Approved By:
Thomas W. Olliff, Pub i e ices Administrator
Division of Public Services
Date: 3'\5'~
AQendh ~~e~
No. ! -lC.) r
MAR 2 3 \9S9
p~. ~
-
INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT FOR FUND SHARING:
NAPLES BEACH ACCESS IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT
NAPLES LANDING PARK IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT,
AND EDGE SKATE PARK IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT
THIS INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT, BY AND BETWEEN Collier
County, ("County"); and the City of Naples, ("City");
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners for Collier County
has approved funding assistance to the City of Naples for the Naples Beach
Access Improvements Project; and
\VHEREAS, this funding was approved in the 1999 fiscal budget for
Collier County;
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the covenants contained
herein, the County and the City hereby agree as follows:
Section 1. The County shall pay fifty percent (50%) funding of the
costs of the Naples Beach Access Improvements Phase II Project, payable as
reimbursement to the City not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars
($25,000). The City shall submit invoices for this Project to the County not
later than September 30, 1999.
Section 2. In the event that the current Beach Parking Interlocal
Agreement between the City and the County, dated November 5, 1997,
should not for any reason have an effective duration of a full ten (lID years
following the completion of the Naples Beach Access Improvements Phase II
Project), the City shall refund to the County the County's proportionate share
of the useful life remainder value of the Naples Beach Access Improvements
Phase II Project. Improvements to the Naples Beach Access Improvements
Phase II Project are deemed to have a useful life often (10) years. The
subject refund shall be based on the County's funding contribution reduced
by ten (10) year straight line deprociation of the beach access improvements
with no residual value.
Section 3. The County will pay up to twenty-five thousand dollars
($25,000) for phase III refurbishment of [he Naples Landing Park, payable as
reimbursements to the City. The City shall submit the invoices to the County
for said project not later then September 30, 1999.
Section 4. The City shall not assess an additional admission fee,
user fee, etc., to residents of Collier County during the life of the project
without prior written approval by an authorized County representative. In
Agen/~. ~ tem
No. /I {c. I{
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ~
the event that this stipulation is violated, the City shall refund to the County
the County's proportionate share of the useful life remainder value of the
Naples Landing Park improvements. Improvements to the Naples Landing
Park are deemed to have a useful life of twenty (20) years. This refund shall
be based on twenty (20) year straight line depreciation of the Naples Landing
improvements with no residual value.
Section 5. The County shall pay up to fifteen thousand dollars
($15,000) for improvements to the Edge Skate facility at Fleischmann Park,
payable as reimbursements to the City. The City shall submit the invoices to
the County for said project not later than September 30, 1999. The City shall
not assess any additional admission fee, user fee, etc.;'fu residents of
unincorporated Collier County during the life of the project, without prior
written approval by an authorized County representative. In the event that
this stipulation is violated, the City shall refund to the County the County's
proportionate share of the useful life remainder value of the skate park's
improvements. Improvements to the Edge Skate facility are deemed to have
a useful life of ten (10) years. This refund shall be based on ten (10) year
straight line depreciation of the skate facility improvements with no residual
value.
Section 6. This Agreement may be signed in counterparts by the
parties hereto. This Agreement shall take effect on the last day of execution
by the last party to execute same.
Section 7. This Agreement shall be recorded by the County in the
Official Records of Collier County within thirty (30) days after this
Agreement is fully executed.
DATE:
ATTEST
D\VIGHT E. BROCK,
By:
BOARD OF COUNTY
COM1vIISSIONERS OF COLLIER
COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
PAMELA S. MAC'KIE, CHAIRWOMAN
Approved as to form and
Legal sufficiency:
11~ ?~
~
Thomas C. Palmer
Agenda dJtem
NO. ((1( ~
MAR 2 3 1999
pg. 1- -
- -
Assistant County Attorney
ATTEST:
TARA NORIvlA.N,
CITY CLERK
~ r::11~
BY:
DATE:~~~ ~.~~
Approved as to form and
Le;;;::;;~-ftL
Kenneth B. Cuyler
City Attorney
/ gen/ agree/in ter localagreepar k
Agendl !~'r
No.-.lb(CJ..:;;.
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. eS
-
INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT FOR FUND SHARING
EVERGLADES CITY COMMIJNITY CENTER IMPROVEMENTS
THIS Il\TERLOCAL AGREEMENT, BY AND BETWEEN Collier County,
("County"): and the City of Everglades, a Florida Municipal Corporation ("City");
\VHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners for Collier County has
approved funding assistance to the City of Everglades for the Everglades Community
Center Improvements Project; and
\VHERE.i\.S, this funding was approved in the 1999 fiscal budget for Collier
County.
:\O\\', THEREFORE, in consideratiOn of the covenants contained herein, the
County and the City hereby agrees as follr
Section 1. The County shall pay up to fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) for
refurbishment of the Everglades City Community Center, payable as reimbursement to
the City. The City shall submit invoices to the County for the project not later than
September 30, 1999.
Section 2. The City shall not assess an additional admission fee, user fee,
etc., to residents of Collier County during the life of the project. The City shall make
said Community Center available for the County's summer youth camp program. These
improvements are deemed to have a useful life of fifteen (15) years and if this stipulation
is violated, the City shall refund to the County the useful life remainder value of the
skate park's improvements calculated on fifteen (15) year straight line depreciation with
no residual value.
Section 3: This Agreement may be signed in counterparts by the parties
hereto, This Agreement shall take effect on the last day of execution by the party that
last executed this agreement.
Section 4: This Agreement shar ,';': recorded by the County in the Official
Records of Coli jer County within thirty (30) days after this Agreement is fully executed.
DATE:
ATTEST
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY:
BY:
PA1v1ELA S. MAC'KIE, CHAIRWOMAN
~~;nO/kc~~tv
MAR 2 3 1999
f'g. ~_
Approved as to [01111 and
Legal sufficiency:
0uv1 r~
Thodas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
ATTEST
\JAR THA DA?\IELS, CITY CLERK
CITY OF EVERGLADES, A FLORIDA
MUNIIPAL CORPORATION
\ ~ ~ -fun UlLJ 'BY~a~/t5~'.---
~~ SAMMY HAM LTON JR., MAYOR
Appro\'cd as to [01111 and
Legal suffic'
DATE:
P. Pires, Jr.
~~~n~& ({'jei
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 7
,
... --t
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
( PPROV AL OF BUDGET AMENDMENT RECOGNIZING AN ADDITIONAL $48,637 IN
6T A TE AID TO LIBRARIES IN FY99.
OBJECTIVE: To recognize and budget additional funds that the Collier County Public
Library System is authorized to receive in State Aid for FY 1998.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Board approved submission of the Application for State Aid on
September 22,1998. Florida Statutes stipulate the maImer in which these funds may be
expended.
State Aid to Libraries is, by legislative intent, provided to improve library services within
the State and is to supplement, rather than replace, local efforts towards that end. The Collier
County Public Library has qualified for State Aid to Libraries since the program inception in
1964. State Aid was included as anticipated revenue ($300,000) in the FY 1999 Collier County
General Fund Budget. The actual amount of State Aid received depends on the number of
Florida Counties qualifying and the amount of funds appropriated by the Florida Legislature.
This program was funded by the Legislature at a level which will provide $348,637 to Collier
County. This figure is $15,225 higher than State Aid received in FY 1998, and $48,637 higher
than anticipated in the FY98 Budget. As local governmental support for the Library increases,
~o does the amount returned to Collier County in State Aid.
These funds can be used for any Library expense except fixed capital purchases such as
construction or equipment purchased as part of a construction project, and cannot replace
local funds. Library staff is recommending that funds be used to upgrade Library computer
which runs the public catalog, circulation, cataloging and acquisitions functions.
FISCAL IMPACT: The Library General Fund Budget for FY 1999 will increase from
$3,325,100 to $3,373,737.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends Board approval of accompanying budget amend-
ment which recognizes additional State Aid and places the funds in appropriate expenditure
accounts.
Preparedby: ~ fit~
ari yn M es, ASSIstant Dlfector
DATE: 3/1 2-/ lJ 9
.
Reviewed and
Approved by:
J
DATE: 3/ J5'I'fi
~
~viewed and
Approved by:
Thomas W. Olliff,
DATE:
blic Services Administrator
~g~n1~t~
MAR 2 3 )999
Pg.
.
",.,
r--
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
ADD ASSET #940024, A 1994 FORD AEROSTAR V AN, TO THE MARCH 27, 1999,
AUCTION LIST.
OBJECTIVE: Obtain Board of County Commissioners approval to add Asset #940024, a
1994 Ford Aerostar van, to the March 27, 1999, auction list.
CONSIDERATION: The Board approved the March 27, 1999, auction list on March 9,
1999. Since the original auction list was published, the scheduled replacement for Asset
#940024 was received. The replacement was not expected until the end of March. If the
replaced vehicle is not sold at this auction, it will receive very limited use, due to mileage and
condition, for the next six months to a year until the next auction. Waiting for the next
auction will result in the vehicle losing value; thus the County is best served to auction the
vehicle now.
FISCAL IMPACT: Revenue from sale of this vehicle is estimated at $3500-$4000 if sold at
the March 27, 1999 auction. If sold at the following auction, revenue would decrease an
estimated $500 - $1000.
~
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
RECOMMENDATION: Add Asset #940024 to the March 27, 1999, auction list.
SUBMITTED BY:
Date:
3/t199
/ /
REVIEWED BY:
~ '<11 0~
Steve Carnell, Purchasing Director
? /0 )e1' G('
Date: ::I
REVIEWED BY:
, ~~ Date: *-/79
Skip Camp, Facilities Management Director
REVIEWED BY:
Date:
rt Services Administrator
'_~/7!9/
I
~.
:O~EHOAJ le,T67
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
AWARD OF BID NO. 98-2903 FOR LABORATORY CHEMICALS AND SUPPLIES.
CONSIDERATIONS: On January 4, 1999 the Purchasing Department published and distributed bid
packages to eighteen (18) vendors for laboratory chemicals and supplies for the Pollution Control,
Collier County Water Reclamation, and Collier County Water Department Laboratories. A bid
opening was held on January 27, 1999, with three (3) bidders submitting. See attached bid
tabulation sheet.
Vendors were asked to give a "percentage off' price for Classes I through V (various chemicals and
supplies). These percentages were applied to a list of items to determine the lowest, responsive
bidder. This bid will be available for use by all County Departments.
Staff recommends award to VWR Scientific as the lowest, qualified and responsive bidder.
FISCAL IMPACT: It is estimated that approximately $200,000 will be spent for laboratory chemicals
and supplies this fiscal year. Funds are available within the various County Departments.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT: None.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners award Bid No. 98-2903, Laboratory
~Shemicals & Supplies to VWR Scientific.
SUBMITTED BY:~\-Y'\'Y~,-' ,:fr,), ((.('
Rhonda L. Snell, Buyer I '
DATE: .J) C~ ,C{'\
,,~. -
~") "
REVIEWED BY: ..Y'-'?c-~'C/'!.--, ,;' l~"'
Stephen Y. Carnell, Director
Purchasing/General Services
REVIEWED ByQ J/tn!/W,., ,./
Paul MiAkl1sCh, Water Director
.---,
DATE:
) ,
,-
,. .,. J
--_- .......4
\ i
/0/:'<)
DATE: .5. j /J
REVIEWED BY: c:::::::::::::;.......- 2~ DATE: ~ - ,.,
G. George Yilmaz, Pollution Control Director
REVIEWED BY' ~--~" ~;':(~i (.l~~ DATE'
. _"', L ( (l, ./J I ...... J { .
Leo E. Ochs, Support 'Services Administrator
~!/" .".
/'
7.,)/"") IF,;'
, ,/
~
...C,iE:HO.... IDEM
No. /(,,.' V
MAR 2 3 1999
I
Pg.
co ~
...
...... u
s:: <l)
~p::
U'J ~
Il) en
:E coo
::J ~
V U
s:: c:l
...-c..
C
,.,
....
III -
.~ ~
c.. :-
c. 50--=
:::::l ~:
(fJ .... lo.
III U e':
iU u ...
'0' ",.
u c
E '- -
c.. -
Q)
.L:
U
~
0
-
r:l
...
0
..0
r:l '"
..J <:.I
C.
C.
-
rJJ
~
'"
e':
.~
~
Q;;
-
-
U
~
lo. ~
0
...... ~ ~
e': I
lo. <:: C
0 ~ e':
,., ~ ..,
- I I
~ QO ~
,
- ~ ~
"'0
c:o
"- Qj
~ t2 ......
M co:
...... s:: Cl
0 E= .2
en en
N ...... ...... s::
. U <:':
co ll) - c
en .~ ..0 Il)
~ "- <:': c..
as o..E- 0
<>: .. .-.- . ..... .: : . ....... :: :..
:::: -
-. ....: ..::. '.' .'.
::- : : " '. ..
..' .- . : .:... -
.- ..
:-.' .-. ,-
- - . .' ..' >
':.: I. . .... ....... ... ....
. ..
".:" ..': .:... .: .:... ......: ....
.... '.'
. . ~ ....... > ..\ ...... .- ~ '.- .... ~ :
> c
'(J V"1. ) > V"I. .... . . ..... V") ::..
..lo. == ("") ..:... ..... ....:. ..... :..
.'C; .'. .... > <: 1< / < > < ...... <
--. ..:. 1\ '..
..;c:. :c' .:....
.",. .... :. . :': .
~ . 4,). .' .... ) 1<
<:i ... ... :. <
... 00: .: . .....:
. :. '.'
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
<:: c c 0 0 0 c c C
t.l V") ..... c V") N N V") N ,-. C C
~ = \.C M '<T N N N N N ~ '<T '<T '<T
~ -
C
:> .::! ,[
t.l
00 <(
G-- ---
Z
t.l ...
t;: - ...
;. ....
C
ll). .
..-~_. .
V'J -<( -< -< -< -<( -< <( <( -< <( <( .-< -<
~. -
--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
~ Z Z Z Z . Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z ;z:
-
"0:
Ci
~ ~:
lo.i lo.i
Z .:!:I e':i ~I
0 .~ c:. J
- ~I
I- lo.l
~ .5 ~I
- .c'
Q:: C 'E
u C ~ ~
00 ,
-
~ ~ .~
~ -, -
lo. .:I '"
0 ~
.c ...... ~ ~
~ "'0 rill rJl
, 0 ~ '""" W I
- "- u ......
I ~ ~ Il) -
- u 'E '-1 Il) s:: - en Il) <l)
.= ~ .... 2 - ... s:: s::
"- ell ::0
'" ll) ell :0 ....:l 0 :.a ..c '" (5 .- ll)
'" '""" w <.2 .~ '" J::? E E en
co: Vi w ~ "'0 a c:o ll) u ~ ~
0 02 ~ II) ':1 ...... ~ c C':l ~ ct: 0 ~
~ cG c:o 0 J:.I.J ....... ~ u Z
- .....
~
~
Eo- GU o~(.I6Et
- N<
M, R 2 3 1999
Pg. ;;;.-
("')
-
o
~
Q.l
0)
ell
0..
en
III
0.
0.
....
(/)
en
I'a
u
E
III
J:
U
~
o
-
I'a
....
o
.0
I'a
..J
... . .....
..' .... ... .'.
'. ( ..'
.' .....
..
'.' ->
.'.
.' -. < ... ...
.... >. . . .. -
~ ..... ~ ..... . > .
C
If) . .'. .
[r ('oj ~ ..' ... ....
..... .'
... .> . . >
'.
'. .... .
~ ~ ~ ~ :::S:' :::S:' ~ ~ ~ ~ :::S:' ~ ,,:;; ~ ,,= "c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
:;; ~ r-1 c C' ~ ~
t.I - ~ - '- - tr, - lr) lr) lr) - ;;r - '- lr) lr) '- -
,.", !;: "<:t "'T "'T lr) "'T ~ !",", !"'". !",", C'1 ~ ~ "'T "<:t ~ "'T !",", "<:t !",", !",", ~
- .-
a: ....
c
~ eJ
t.I
rr. -<
---
Z
"" ~
!;:
'- --
- C'l
-
C,i
t.I
'lJ ,..,..,
.-~ -< -< <( -< -< --< -< -< -< -< -< -< -< < < -< -< -< -< <( < <
--- -- -- --- --- --- ---- ---- ---- ---- --- ---- --- ---- ---- --- --- --- --- --- ---- ----
- Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z
-
0,
CIJ
" a...
..."
=:.
-,
-,
~I
'::1
-,
.~.
Z ...,
-,
~ ~i
"" =:.
-
- ~I
:.. ~I
- :Ill
=' -,
U Coil =i
-, C,i,
iJJ ~l =:
~ ..., e':l
:: ...., ]i >.
~I .....
;1)1 ::5
-, .....
.WI C ~ u
~I (':l ..... ......
:;1 U C 2 Q)
0
I C U '"0 C) ~ .....
..... t: ...:..:: (:;
~ ~ > >< (':l ~ ..... (5 0 ~ ..... ~ ....
-, C) 0 u - C) ~ ~ 0 ..... E
x 0 ..... E .9 t:
<1:1 .- .D C':l '" t: 'C ~ .- c .... .- CIl .D .,... ~ C) (5 ..... c..> .... ....
:Ill ..... '" 0 c..> "E .... ..... ..... E CIl E .... .- EJ t:: (5 CIJ c= c..>
C':I C C E C': u E t: u t: :;:l - (:; ~ .... ~ ...- ...c:
0 c t u ce C':l C':l C'J C':l 0 'C iJJ
Oi U -< k2 2 ~ ~ ce 0
U ~ ~ -< u u u.J 0 ::r: ::r: ..,... z z 0 iJJ >-
......
;;;;
~
Eo- Tb'"
-
No /.. z-
~A R 3 1999
Pg. 3
M
o
O'l
N
.
00
O'l
~
aJ
VI
ell
c..
C.
~
en
VI
III
52
E
ell
.r:.
()
>.
~
o
-
(ll
~
o
..Q
(ll
..J
r
'-
.-.
.
.
.'. .....
Q'
...~. !::
"a.>.::;:::' '0
~z. ,g
ii:.. otj . . 0;. . ..
'--()'j 0 ....
'2 .'.
o
Q c;
~!:: ~
-~
~ c
> ~
r.tJ
u
'.~....,
'0':. '. ..'
zg
. -.r; '. 'C
.' <J1' .. t:..
...t;;;,.. 0
= ..z
. ..
... .' ....
- ..
.' . -..
.
....1
.
.
-'
. ..
.
. 'i ....
'"
-
0
"'0
l-
I:':
N
I:':
.:
z: I-
0 ..s:
- E ,:,. VJ
~ t:.l r.tJ ..., C'-. C)
l:- .-:: l:- C) "'0 -
- en :;I) Q) C-
" a.> :J r- -::; "'0 C-
.: r- U ;::
U I:': r:: [/)
o- Il) ~
r.tJ ... u
~ l- f- 0 ::: :-:;
a.> "C - ::: - u
Q Q. t:.l ::: ..;;.:: VJ .-
a.> Q. Q) u ~ - "0
Co l= < 0 u u
~ .- ;;:, c; = =- ~
..c r- U
~ '" (\:l ::: (;l [/) -
0.. :-:; u
c ~ U l- E
0 - ..., "0 c..
Oi: c.. r- Il) r- r-
..: U <5 r- ::
E Il) <5
.- ClJ ..., l- r- ..-
"'0 - E r- C2 e:::: [/)
"'0 I:': <: ~
-< E 0.. ~ iIi VJ
Q) VJ "0
;::.., Q) CO
=
;:: -
C!:i 0
>- Z
.-
.
..-
u
~
l-
-
:::
o
U
V Q) .... .... ....
.~ ~..~ ..i. '.'
Q)
'0
Q) z
::: VJ Q) VJ
Q)
0 u Q) >-
Z >- r.tJ
.. ..... C")
'. .. -
.... '. 0
'::; C")
ill
::: (/1 en
0 ':) 0 ro
Z >- Z 0..
- ~
M ~
0 ~
Cl -
~
IX) I
Cl I
"C
iil
.Gum.. h'~
No . I ~ ;)-
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.
.r-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPROVAL OF A CONTRACT BETWEEN COLLIER COUNTY AND
COMMUNITY HEALTH PARTNERS.
OBJECTIVE: To seek approval of a contract between Collier County and Community
Health Partners, Inc., for group health managed care network fees and services.
CONSIDERATION: In 1994, the Board entered into a contract with SunHealth for
group health managed care fees and services. Sun Health was a statewide provider
network, which had under contract many of the local physicians and other healthcare
providers in the Collier County area. At that time, no locally based network existed,
Subsequent to this time, Naples Community Hospital along with local physicians in
Collier County created what is now known as Community Health Partners, Inc., which is
commonly referred to as a Physician Hospital Organization or "PHO". Community
Health Partners entered into an agreement with SunHealth to provide specialized
healthcare services not available in Collier County.
r-'
After establishing Community Health Partners, the PHO approached Collier County to
discuss a contractual arrangement directly with Community Health Partners. In 1996,
staff received approval from the Board to proceed with the exploration of this direct
contract arrangement, however, this was delayed due to problems with the County's third
party administrator at that time, First Health. First Health did not posess the ability to
administer certain portions of the program and in general did not perform to the
expectations of the County. The contract with First Health was subsequently terminated
and Florida 1 st was hired to perform third party administration services on January 1,
1998. Negotiation of a contract with Community Health Partners began in 1998 and the
final agreement is presented at this time. Community Health Partners, in good faith,
agreed to allow Florida 1 st to utilize this reduced fee schedule prior to finalizing this
contract
The advantage to Collier County of this arrangement is that the county will receive a 10%
reduction in hospital related fees that would not have been available under the SunHealth
contract Generally, hospital fees comprise approximately 50% of total healthcare costs_
In FY 98, the County incurred approximately $4,700,000 in claims expenses, Utilizing
this formula, a 10% fee' reduction would result in approximate savings of $235,000.
Physician's fees remain the same under the Community Health Partners agreement as
they were under the SunHealth agreement
There is a PHO access fee under the contract of $2.25 per employee per month, which
totals approximately $37,800 per year.
r---.
AGENO~ ITEM
No. /(>D:3
~~~ ? 1999
~
The term of the contract is from January 1, 1998 through December 31, 1999. It
automatically renews annually thereafter unless notification of the intent to non-renew is
given by either party 90 days prior to renewal. The contract also contains a 60-day
termination for convenience provision,
FISCAL IMPACT: The PHO access fee to enter into this contract is approximately
$37,800 per year dependent on actual enrollment. Funds would be payable from the
Group Health and Life Fund,
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
RECOMMENDA TION: It is recommended that the Board approve a contract between
Collier County and Community Health Partners, Inc, for group health managed care
services and fees, authorizing staff to prepare those budget amendments necessary to
fund the contract. The contract and details of the health plan are on file in the Board of
Commissioners office,
SUBMITTED BY~~ Date :;4/0/1
Walker, CPCU, ARM
Director, Risk Management
r-
REVIEWED BY:
,.
~ (.,'. '- ~I
. 'l '~, ~ I... / Date:
f
Leo E Ochs, k..
Support Services Administrator
7Ii-:;j~; '7
,', I <
~
N~~:Jt g~M
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ;.;z
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPROVAL OF A BUDGET AMENDMENT TO PROPERTY & CASUALTY
(",-. INSURANCE PROGRAM FUND
OBJECTIVE: To seek approval from the Board of County Commissioners ofa budget
amendment to fund the Property & Casualty insurance claims and settlements for the
remainder of fiscal year 1999.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Board of County Commissioners operates a self-insured
property and casualty insurance program to fund property and casualty claims. A budget
amendment is sought to provide sufficient funding for the payment of claims through the
remainder of Fiscal Year 1999.
The primary reason for requesting this budget amendment is due to the payment of auto
losses, property losses, settlements, judgments, and their related litigation expenses
which have occurred in FY 99. To date, there have been eleven major cases where
settlement payment became due in FY 99. These cases totaled $308,325 in settlement
and judgment costs. In addition, it has been necessary to retain outside counsel in several
cases due to conflict of interest and administrative reasons which has increased defense
costs. The total paid for expenses including attorney fees to outside counsel as of
December 1998, was $217,171. Currently pending are outside attorney fees in the
amount of approximately $190,000 through end of FY99. On-going processing of third
party loss payments, BCC property and auto physical damage claims have totaled
r-- $62,583. Total paid losses for FY 99 have been $279,754.
Currently, $350,000 is budgeted in the Property & Casualty Insurance Program Fund for
the payment of claims expenses. It is recommended that a budget amendment of $450,000
be approved through the transfer of funds from Reinsurance Premiums and Reserves to the
Property & Casualty Insurance Program Fund. This amount will cover the settlements
approved by the Board and cover claims expenses for the remainder of the year.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMP ACT:
None.
FISCAL IMP ACT: The Board of County Commissioners appropriates reserves
expressly for the payment of claims and settlement costs. Funds are available from
Reinsurance Premiums and Reserves.
r--
RECOMMENDA TION: It is recommended that the Board of County Commissioners
approve a budget amendment to the Property & Casualty Insurance Program Fund.
PREPARED BY: .~/~tl(- ,j};c ~ ,c,.J.- Date: .J /,1 /9f
\....... , -
Lynn Uvans, S"enior Risk Analyst
REVIEWED BY~ Date: $/rl/j'j
ef alker, CPCU, ARM, Risk Management Director
REVIEWED BY: -. ( - ~- l -t/.~.'.( l. ' /./) Date:"> I).);"
Leo E. Ochs, Jr., Support' Services Administrator
N~~E rIDir/ bElJ
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.
..--
I
~.
.~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
RECOMMENDATION TO AWARD BID #99-2913 FOR CONTRACT
PRINTING
OBJECTIVE: To award a two-year term agreement for contract printing for use
by all County Departments.
CONSIDERATIONS: Throughout the year, the Purchasing Department has the
need to contact firms for the printing of a wide variety of documents for various
County departments. Many of the document print jobs are routine in nature, and
therefore lend themselves to standard specifications.
On February 12, 1999, formal bid invitations were distributed to 36 firms providing
printing services. Bid specifications requested pricing for 47 different proposals for
various types of 'flat forms, single/multi-part forms, business cards, continuous feed
forms, and envelopes used by various County Departments. On March 3, 1999, bids
were received and opened from 7 printing firms. After careful analysis of all proposals,
staff recommends award of this bid on a proposal by proposal basis as listed on
Attachment "A" and in accordance with the tabulation sheets. The bid tabulation sheets
are available for review in the Purchasing Department. In order to provide the best
possible service to the County, the proposals will be awarded to the apparent low bidders
on a primary, secondary and tertiary basis in order to facilitate timely delivery and turn-
around requirements and to ensure a quality product.
Due to a pattern of long lead times and late deliveries throughout the previous printing
contract period, a 10% penalty for late deliveries has been instituted, with
possible termination for excessive late deliveries. For this reason, staff is
requesting entire bid offerings of the bidders listed herein be accepted as additional
suppliers to be utilized in the event of inability or termination of the lowest bidder
to furnish product as needed. In such a situation, the next lowest bidder would be
contacted until the needed product could be obtained.
FISCAL IMPACT: It is estimated that approximately $35,000 will be expended
annually from funds appropriated in the operating budgets of the respective using
agencies.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACE: None
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners award Bid
#99-2913 for contract printing as shown in the enclosed Attachment "A".
"GEHO~ n.E~'/ I
Mo. Ie. f).=2
,
t-\AR 2 3 1999
po- ,
-
PREP ARED BY:
REVIEWED BY:
REVIEWED BY:
//:
'-~/ ;. \ ,..~
, " ~-
../
-.....
,
Kelsey Ward, Buyer II
Purchasing' Department
~/~'- '^ / .'
/ I. . . - . ./
- --";R"~" Vl. Ve "" (.
St~ph~ Carnell, 'CSM, Director
Purchasing/General Services Department
. ~_.I~C(' /': //~,( ( c_~'1
,/
Leo E. Ochs, Jr. Administrator
Support Services Division
DATE: 03/11/99
DATE: ':) (j"L/cr f
DATE:
'-~.r' ./;-_.';;, i
. ....' 0-" -
.- !. ;;_ /"C
. I
N~~ENQ'(.rIJ:r
MAR 2 3 1999
d-
P9.
Proposal #
Flat Forms
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16a
16b
Carbonless Forms
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
Primary Awardee
PRIDE
Advanced Nationwide
PRIDE
Advanced Nationwide
Advanced Nationwide
Pederson Printing
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
PRIDE
PRIDE
New York Press
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
New York Press
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
Tractor Feed Forms
32
33
A-I Printing
A-I Printing
ATTACHMENT' A'
AWARDEE LIST
Secondary Awardee Tertiary Awardee
Pederson Printing
PRIDE
Pederson Printing
PRIDE
PRIDE
Advanced Nationwide
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
PRIDE
PRIDE
PRIDE
New York Press
New York Press
PRIDE
New York Press
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
Advanced Nationwide
Advanced Nationwide
Pederson Printing
New York Press
PRIDE
Pederson Printing
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
Pederson Printing
New York Press
New York Press
Pederson Printing
New York Press
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
Pederson Printing
Advanced Nationwide
A-I Printing
Pederson Printing
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
New York Press
Pederson Printing
New York Press
A- 1 Printing
Pederson Printing
Advanced Nationwide
A-I Printing
A-I Printing
Advanced Nationwide
Pederson Printing
Pederson Printing
New York Press
Pederson Printing
Daniel Printing Advanced Nationwide
Advanced Nationwide * no other bidders
N~~EN' (,ITtr~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. -3
, \
Executive Summary Attachment "A"
Title: Recommendation to Award Bid #99- 2913 for Contract Printing
Page 2
Proposal # Primary Awardee Secondary Awardee Tertiary Awardee
Envelopes
34 Pederson Printing Advanced Nationwide PRIDE
35 Pederson Printing A-I Printing PRIDE
36 PRIDE Pederson Printing New York Press
37 Advanced Nationwide New York Press Pederson Printing
38 PRIDE Advanced Nationwide Pederson Printing
39 PRIDE Pederson Printing New York Press
40a,b Advanced Nationwide New York Press A-I Printing
40c Advanced Nationwide A-I Printing New York Press
40d Advanced Nationwide A-I Printing Sir Speedy
Business Cards
41,42 Pederson Printing PRIDE Advanced Nationwide
43 Pederson Pringing PRIDE Sir Speedy
44 PRIDE Pederson Printing Sir Speedy
45 Pederson Printing PRIDE Advanced Nationwide
46 Pederson Printing PRIDE Sir Speedy
Airport Authority Package
47 PRIDE Advanced Nationwide Sir Speedy
':'~ENO}GT~ r
99
Pg.
/r'-
r'-
r-"
APPROVAL OF BUDGET AMENDMENTS
BCC Agenda of
March 23, 1999
General (Fund 001)
Budget Amendment #99-171
Public Defender
Telephone System
Reserves
Reserves for Contingencies
Total:
Explanation: To fund the purchase of phones compatible with voice mail.
$3,700
(3,700)
-0-
General (Fund 001)
Budget Amendment #99-181
Maintenance Service
Reserves
Reserves for Contingencies
Total:
$8,500
(8,500)
-0-
Explanation: Funds to be transferred into the Department to fund an Indoor Air Quality Preventive
Management Plan, which includes policy, operating procedures, forms and training program.
Capital Projects (Fund 301)
Budget Amendment #99-183
Building Improvements
Building F Renovations
Total:
$4,800
(4,800)
-0-
Explanation: Funds to be transferred to complete carpeting of C-I, Tax Collector's Building.
Park Improvements (Fund 306)
Budget Amendment #99-185
Capital
Improvements
Reserves
Reserves for Capital Outlay
Total:
Explanation: Funds to repair gazebo.
$1,600
(1,600)
AGENDA ITEM
NO.1" ell)
-0-
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I
r'-
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE
MARCH 23,1999
FOR BOARD ACTION:
1. MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS TO FILE FOR RECORD WITH ACTION AS DIRECTED:
2. Clerk of Courts: Submitted for public record, pursuant to Florida Statutes, Chapter
136.06(1), the disbursements for the Board of County Commissioners for the period:
A. February 22 - 26, 1999
B. March 1 - 5, 1999
3. Districts:
A. Collier County Housing Authority - Annual Financial Report FYE 9/30/98,
Approved Budget FY 1998-1999, Registered Office and Agent, Schedule of
Regular Meetings 1998-1999, Description of Outstanding Bonds FYE 9/30/98,
Public Facilities Report, and Audit and Management Letter FYE 9/30/98
r---.
B. Collier Mosquito Control District - Public Facilities Report and District Map
C. Port of the Islands Community Improvement District - Notice of meeting of
February 18, 1999 and minutes of meetings held August 6, October 15 and
November 19,1998 and January 21,1999
D. South Florida Water Management District - Comprehensive Annual Financial
Report FYE 9/30/98, Management Letter FYE 9/30/98, Schedule of Governing
Board Meetings for 1998-1999, District Map
4. Minutes:
A. Affordable Housing Commission - Minutes of meetings of October 22, 1998 and
December 17,1998 and January 21,1999
B. Airport Authority - Minutes of Mee-ting of January 11, 1999 and agenda of
February 8, 1999
C. Code Enforcement Board (South) - Minutes of meeting of January 8, 1999
D.
Collier County Planning Commission - Agenda of February 18, 1999 and
AGEND't, rtM
No . I I
,"'--"
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.
r'.
,r'
~
minutes of meeting of January 21, 1999
E. Golden Gate Beautification Advisory Committee - Agenda of March 9, 1999 and
minutes of meeting of February 9, 1999
F. Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - Agenda of February 24, 1999 and minutes
of meeting of January 27, 1999
G. Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee - Agenda of March 8, 1999 and
minutes of meeting of February 8, 1999
AGE NOt ITEM
No. / ,(:..., I
,
t
.,
'--
MAR 2 3 1999
Z-
Pg.
.,
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REQUEST APPROV AL FOR THE PURCHASE OF REPLACEMENT DESKTOP COMPUTER
SYSTEMS FOR THE COLLIER COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE FROM DELL COMPUTERS
UNDER THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF STATE OF FLORIDA CONTRACT
#250-040-99-1.
r--
OBJECTIVE: To purchase replacement desktop computer systems from Dell Computers under the
terms and conditions of State of Florida Contract #250-040-99- I.
CONSIDERATIONS: Currently, the Collier County Sheriff's Office has numerous 286- and 386-
processor level computers that are obsolete for running the necessary applications on the current
operating system. Funding for replacement computers was approved for the FY 1999 budget year
under 301 Fund guidelines.
While several different desktop computer systems have been reviewed, the P6400 Pentium II mid-
tower desktop computer from Dell Computers represents the least expensive total cost of ownership,
current technology system available under the State of Florida Contract #250-040-99-1.
FISCAL IMPACT: The cost to purchase the replacement computers will be $100,600.00 and are
available in:
r--
Fund:
Cost Center:
Object:
Project:
301
611010
764990
OlGll
Facilities Mgmt., Countywide CIP
Law Enforcement - Pd. by Sheriff
Other Machinery & Equipment
PC Modernization
GROWTH IMPACT: There are no recurring costs for subsequent years.
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners authoriz.e the purchase of
replacement computers described above from Dell Computers under State of Florida Contract
#250-040-99-1.
REVIEWED BY:
DATE:
wpd51\expcx2\dv
AGENDA ITEM
No. f r f H \
r'.
I':,~. ~ 2 3 1999
Pg.
i~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PETITION NO. OSP-98-1 , DAVE SNEED OF KUHLMAN ENGINEERING, REPRESENTING
AZAR GALLERY, REQUESTING APPROVAL FOR 20 OFF-SITE PARKING SPACES ON LOT
26, AND THE WEST HALF OF LOT 25, BLOCK B, NAPLES VILLAS TO SERVE AN EXISTING
COMMERCIAL FACILITY ON LOT 1, BLOCK B, NAPLES VILLAS AND WHICH IS LOCATED
ON THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF AIRPORT-PULLING ROAD (CR-31) AND POINSETTIA
AVENUE, IN SECTION 1, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST.
OBJECTIVE:
The applicant is requesting approval of 20 off-site parking spaces on Lot 26 and the west half of Lot
25, Block B, Naples Villas which is zoned "RMF-6". The objective is to rectify a preexisting parking
deficiency on Lot 1, Block B, Naples Villas which contains an existing 3,650 square foot commercial
building and is zoned C-4.
r'
CONSIDERATIONS:
The applicant is requesting approval of 20 off-site parking spaces on the above referenced residential
lot which is presently undeveloped. The additional parking is in support of an existing commercial
building that has been in existence since 1973. Consequently, the site improvements made at that time
were either inconsistent with development standards or built to older development standards that do not
meet current requirements. Based on these circumstances, the site's eight (8) existing parking spaces
are less than the 15 parking spaces required for retail land uses for the existing building. It should be
noted that the parking calculation for the petitioner's carpet store is only 1 space per 600 square feet of
floor area which results in a requirement of 6 parking spaces. However. the 8 existinji parkinli spaces
on-site are confiiured in such a manner as to require direct access to each space from a public street
which is no lonier permitted. In addition. the petitioner claims that the eight parkin~ spaces are
insufficient durini their busiest work hours.
Since this commercial site cannot provide the needed off-street parking on-site during the peak hours,
the additional parking spaces must be provided off-site. In order to provide parking to meet the demand
and to improve safety and aesthetics, the petitioner is proposing to locate 20 additional parking spaces
on an adjacent lot to the east. The additional parking will also meet the retail parking requirements for
the subject structure. Lastly, this lot will be landscaped and buffered from the adjacent residential
properties consistent with the Land Development Code.
r--,
AGENDA ITEM
No. / 'I If
MAR 2 3 1999
J
Pg.
1
The Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) reviewed this petition during their public hearing of
March 4, 1999, The cepc unanimously recommended by a 9 to 0 vote to forward petition OSP-98-1
to the Board of Zoning Appeals with a recommendation of approval. In addition, staff has not received
any letters in opposition to this petition and no one spoke against this petition during the public
hearing. As a result, this petition has been placed on the Summary Agenda.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The CommerciallIndustrial impact fees for retail land uses include the following categories: (I) Roads;
(2) Fire; (3) EMS; and (4) Surcharges that include: a) Radon Gas; b) Building Code Administration;
and c) Micro Film. These impact fees are based on the total square footage of any new commercial
structure or addition thereof. However, since this petition only provides off-street parking for the
existing land use and is not expanding or increasing the square footage of the retail or storage areas
within this commercial building, the above referenced impact fees can't be applied to the proposed
parking lot.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
The off-site parking spaces can only be requested on residentially zoned parcels which meet the
locational requirements for commercial uses as noted in Section 2.3.4.11 of the Land Development
Code. This section states that where off-site parking is proposed for commercial uses, all of the lots
proposed for off-site parking must meet the Locational requirements for commercial uses as identified
in the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the Growth Management Plan (GMP) or be designed to
serve water-dependent and/or water-related uses described in the GMP. Since the subject parcel is not
located within an Activity Center, nor will the proposed off-site parking be in support of a water-
dependent and/or water-related use, the subject lot must meet the criteria for Transitional C-l/T
Zoning. Since the residential lot abuts a commercial C-4 lot and a parking lot is also a permitted use in
the C-lIT zoning district, staff is of the opinion that this petition for off-site parking is consistent with
the Locational requirements for commercial uses as identified in the FLUE of the GMP.
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) approve petition OSP-98-1 subject to the conditions of
approval as described in the Resolution of Adoption and Exhibits made a part of this executive
summary.
--,
AGENDA-ITEM
No. /1,4-
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ~
2
PREPARED BY:
/
/ /
/ ? , / I <', " / , _
RA YBELLOWS, PRINCIPAL PLANNER
CURRENT PLANNING SECTION
RE:VIEWEJ;:> By:":
1\ .' ,\ ,
.. i \
\ l ,-.~ t.. : \ /
RONALD F. NINO, AICP, MANAGER
CURRENT PLANNING SECTION
<
~. .~_._------_._-------
ROBERT 1. MULHERE, AICP, DIRECTOR
PLANNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT
~.
APPROVEIFBY:
/'),/ I
- f7!il ~l <
VINCENT A. CAUTERO, AICP, ADMINISTRATOR
COMMUNITY DEY. AND ENVIRONMENTAL SVCS.
OSP-98-11 EX SUMMARY/RYB/rb
3
-:> r :0
--.) '- \ / /
DATE
-3.; 1 c1
DATE
"'1
I ,', ~.'
) 6 . '/
DATE
~/ /J-cz7
DATE
AGENOA ITEM
No. 17 A
MAR 2 3 1999
3
Pg.
\lE:\;IORANDUM
AGENDA ITEM 7-G
TO:
COLLIER COUNTY PL-\~~ING COMMISSION
FRO\1:
CO:v1ML'NITY DEVELOP:vlENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
DATE:
FEBRCARY 8. 1999
RE:
PETITION NO: OSP.98-1. AlAR RUG GALLERY. INC.
O\VNERJAGENT:
Agent:
Mr. David Sneed
Kuhlman Engineering. Inc.
2647 Davis Boulevard
Naples. Florida 34104
Owner:
Mr, Ahmad Mirziai
Azar Gallery. Inc.
989 Airport Road South
Naples. Florida 34104
REOCESTED ACTION:
The applicant is requesting approval of 20 off'-site parking spaces on Lot 26 and the west half of
Lot 25. Block B. Naples Villas. to rectify a preexisting parking deficiency on Lot 1. Block B.
Naples Villas which contains an existing 3.650 square foot commercial building,
GEOGR.\PHIC LOCATION:
The subject property proposed for off-site parking is located on the north side of Poinsettia
Avenue and approximately 149 feet east of Airport Road. (See illustration on following page).
PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF AMMENDM.ENT:
The petitioner owns a commercial building that was constructed in 1973 prior to the site
development plan (SDP) process. As a result. there was no comprehensive site review prior to
construction. Consequently, the site improvements were either inconsistent with development
standards or built to older development standards that do not meet current requirements. Based
on these circumstances. the site's eight (8) parking spaces are less than the number of parking
spaces for retail land uses on the subject site. A retail store would require a total of 15 parking
spaces on-site as listed in Section 2.3.14 of the LDC. It should be noted that the parking
calculation for the petitioner' s existing carpet store is only 1 space per 600 square feet of floor
area which results in a requirement of 6 parking spaces. However, the 8 existing parking spaces
on-site are configured in such a manner as to require direct access to each space from a ublic
street which is no longer permitted. In addition. the petitioner claims that the ight ~fEM
spaces are insufficient during their busiest work hours. Since this commercial site c ~r(wicip /1 A-
I
MA~ 2 3 1999
i<
~
~
pa.
4
\
.~.
--.
- = >----
-'-'~
- ::r--.
'2
Oi
z
o I---- ;""dC --v.t....N3::
w-
~t\~. c
- - '"
~ ~)-. ; ~-.
'-" z -- i,f) _ ,....., r----o
-=: S?-~'---'3 v
~ - V) I
'""""--::; CD
~'~~::.~ =-
~~~)--;/) ~
-~,
l
I
I
I
"
z
'c
I~
I?
I=-
:>.
12
3
;;~ - ::""L~"i.""
8
"
'"
~
~~~
if~ ~
"
'>
~..;...l.-i-
.r =:"J
C'tOo 8\1r~,"ic-lbCdd.lV'
,~---:.:\--
,~~r-
o .
~v
"
Q,i i i
"'-./, : I
,,~
"",
..:''\---
:/\.'1
S3t\331S
z
0;;
"
'=!
Z,
5,
<:
_" -'='13
.,.
...-- ~'~,
~,6'~'
'~~
\ ~
..... /' ~w
: - "'. i < \ / ~- ~- i ~
V; ,,~ "' ~~ ::k::'
~- - \'-15
~ --;~ /~, ~
~- \.) \
3""r:l5 OJ)OH /
-
-.-
>
S
7'
i
- I
//
~ ' /
t~
"'/'
l/I~B
"b~
~~d ~
-~"'
~5~
~ ~"'~
I.......--a~
CYO~ ~8 AJ "'f'lOO
I 'h >~'"
~~o
,-,:Ii u,~
~"' ~'I! /
.r=-:~~V: / :;~
--e:::;:::::::3;!..,~ ~~^ il ::~
>gS:; <'....!
. ~ :;;~g : #
~! ~
--;1 d
'~,
w
--I' z
:I! i~
iir' s::
0' ~~
~,\ /~-
tr :1 S3H1e rGm'f'1
OOCJG" 04V'1t ~ll
8~1!
~ - ---J ,
Q\(~ IC1JS:>NJ/ln I~ ~
i ~ ~::t:
o~ II ~~ ~
~~ II t'~ >-:g m
'" ty ~~
I "'~
(I~ lt~)
"""" ONmr.r,,,,,,,,,.... /i1
~
Ii
il ~
'...;.--
~I;
i,l:
l ~ ~
I, 0 0<<
ii ~ r
I
~
~
~
s~
~~
.1'
."1
0'1
:61
'"
~
::l
~
- ''';;/1(
~~ :i~
~~~ 1'1 ~
~,~ ,I ;.1(J
, i!~ jll~ "'~
~ ~ LL!~
H~
,-
S"l'Oil "fl!s::>"'~n
~
~
'"
.
0;,
,c
g
I' ~'"
,18\3
I ,,5
'" ' i "'~~ ;Xl
" . I~~~
. : : go $ ~
0;, i!!
,0 z ~ '"
ii ~o ~
~~ if,
~'"
~ 3I:OI-6.l."'S
SS3"lOO11M
I ,to 'S'~) ~""l:lJ 1"""'1"",..1
\;; (I, rr=::./ ~~ 0
r--\
v
<Xl
'"
~
a..
<(
~
o
'"
<:
>
'"
5
'"
Vl
5
..
o
UJ
I-
-
en
I
CD.
0.,
I'
Q..,
~I
,.'
%'
~!
1-'
1-'
w,
Q..
~
'"
w
~
a..
<(
~
z
o
-
I-
<(
U
o
-J
s
~
7!!-
...
~
!:?
='. '..
'.
.-.oE WAAEHOuSE
~
~. t.,'+
~
t
i
.....9
....1--.-_ _~..;...-:::
,~. 'J"
1T'J" --
'..r --- W~ ---- 17'0"
~
~
,--~=
;;
!"X'I~n...c.
'="'T~l.:~E
_--1._
~
9
--------.- -
9101 I NC,.
STI1UC'lIJJ::E
':
;.
?
l'l
"
~.-.-.~
".... ',.. t_.r .
: =-. -{"-
--.1._____
b
...
l.AH08CAP'E
-.-- RE~ ~1lJ~~.. 'f& 1"9T"t l . 4,""'~^..-e:
""'f"
CJort...l5rETT1.A...
"""'E_
SITE PL,A,N 1"=20'
Os
Po
8....<
EXHIBIT "A"
l'
~
~'m-site during the peak hours. the additional parking spaces must be provided otf-site. In order to
provide parking to meet the demand and to improve safety and aesthetics. the petitioner is
proposing to locate 20 additional parking spaces on an adjacent lot to the east. The additional
parking \\-ill also meet the retail parking requirements for the subject structure. Lastly. this lot
will be landscaped and buffered from the adjacent residential properties.
srRROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING:
Existing Conditions:
The property proposed for off-site parking is currently vacant (See
Photograph No. I) and is zoned RMF -6.
Surrounding:
?\iorth - Single-family residential and zoned R.t\1F-6. To the northwest is an
existing commercial building that is zoned "C-4"
East - Single-family residential (See Photo No.2) and zoned RMF-6.
South - Poinsettia Avenue and single-family residential: zoned RMF -6, To
the southwest is a commercial building that is zoned C-4.
West - Azar Gallery and Airport Road; Zoned C-4.
1. View of adjacent property looking northeast. 2. View of adjacent property looking east.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN CONSISTENCY:
Section 2.3.4.11 Locational Restrictions, states that where off-site parking is proposed for
commercial uses. all of the lots proposed for off-site parking must meet the Locational
requirements for commercial uses as identified in the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the
Gro\vth Management Plan (GMP) or be designed to serve water-dependent andlor water-related
uses described in the GMP. Approval of this petition does not constitute a rezone, but rather will
only permit the off-site parking as depicted on the attached site plan labeled Exhibit "A", or any
use which is permitted in the RMF-6 zoning district, should the off-site parking agreement be
rescinded at any time in the future.
'-
It should be noted that the subject parcel is not located within an Activity Center. ITEM
proposed off-site parking be in support of a water-dependent andlor water-related u e. h~'ever. 11 A
:;
L,:.R 2 3 ;99
the subject lot does meet the criteria for Transitional C-l T Zoning. Since a parking lot is also a
permitted use in the C -1 T zoning district. staff is of the opinion that this petition for off-site
parking is consistent with the Locational requirements for commercial uses as identified in the
FLUE of the GMP.
EV ALUA TION FOR
INFRASTRUCTURE:
ENVIRONMENT AL.
TRANSPORTATION
AND
This petition has been re\'iewed by all of the appropriate County agencies assigned jurisdictional
oversight. none of which have offered any objection to this approval.
HISTORIC/ARCHAEOLOGICAL IMPACT:
Staff's analysis indicates that the petitioner's property is located outside an area of historical and
archaeological probability as referenced on the official Collier County Probability Map,
Therefore. no Historical/Archaeological Survey and Assessment is required. However, pursuant
to Section 2.2.25.8.1 of the Land Development Code, if. during the course of site clearing,
excavation or other construction activity an historic or archaeological artifact is found, all
development within the minimum area necessary to protect the discovery shall be immediately
stopped and the Collier County Code Enforcement Department contacted.
ANAL YSIS:
There are six requirements which must be satisfied in order to be granted approval of off-site
parking. These requirements are as follow:
a . All of the lots are under the same ownership:
All lots are under the ownership of Ahmad Mirziai.
c. :-:0 off-site parking space is located further than three hundred feet (300') from the building
or use they are intended to serve. measured by the shortest feasible walking distance, unless
special circumstances exist under Section 2.3.4.11.5;
The furthermost off-site parking space is within approximat dy 110 feet of the existing
commercial building.
The lots are not separated by an arterial roadway as designated in the Traffic Circulation
Element of the Grow1h Management Plan;
The lots are not separated by an arterial roadway.
d. At least sixty-seven percent (67%) of the required parking for the development is located
on the lot with the principal structure unless special circumstances exist under Section
2,3.4.11.5:
The site plan indicates that there are presently eight (8) parking spaces th t seAr~ Iff A
existing 3,650 square foot carpet store. Based on the parking calculation s p~idt;d
MAR 2 3 1999
'8
3
Pi.
for in Section 2.3.16 of the LDC, one (1) space per 600 square feet of floor area is
required for the subject carpet store. This results in a total of 6 required parking
spaces. Therefore, the existing parking exceeds the requirement to provide over sixty-
seven (67) percent of the required parking on the commercial lot with the principal
structure. Howeyer, the 8 existing on-site parking spaces are configured in such a
manner as to require direct access to each space from a public street which is no
longer permitted. In addition, the petitioner claims that the eight parking spaces are
insufficient during their busiest work hours. Since this commercial site cannot
provide the needed off-street parking during the peak work periods, the additional
parking spaces must be provided off-site. Furthermore, if the existing carpet store
were converted to a retail store, the parking calculations would require a total of 15
parking spaces based on the calculation of 1 space per 250 square feet of floor area. In
this case, the retail use of the site would provide only 54 percent of the required
parking on-site. It should be noted that this requirement has previously been waived
by the Board of County Commissioners for similar off-site parking petitions.
e. The off-site parking will serve an existing structure or land use; and.
The off-site parking will serve an existing commercial building.
f. All of the lots proposed for off-site parking meet the locational requirements for
commercial uses as identified in the Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management
Plan as described in the Crban Residential Subdistrict of the Future Land Use Element of
the Grow1h Management Plan.
As noted above, this petition is consistent with the locational requirements as
designated in the FLUE of the Growth Management Plan.
g. The off-site parking facility shall be designed to mitigate any negative effects of this
parking facility on neighboring residentially zoned property. Mitigation shall include.
unless specifically detennined by the Board of Zoning Appeals not to be necessary:
1. :";0 vehicular egress shall occur on local streets opposite of residential homes or within
the building lines of unimproved single-family residentially zoned property.
~o access wi)) occur on a purely residential street and no access will be within the
building lines of the adjacent properties.
2. Lighting shall be shielded. pointing downward. and not over 20 feet in height so as to
prevent glare upon all neighboring properties,
This requirement has been incorporated into the resolution.
3. A 15 foot wide landscape buffer strip shall be provided around the entire perimeter
\vhere it directly abuts residentially zoned property. A six foot high fence, wall
(architecturally finished), hedge or benn combination and 10 foot tall shade
no more than 20 feet apart on center shall be required.
AGENDA ITEM
No. /7 A
MAR 2 3 1999
4
Pg. 9
The conceptual site plan indicates that the petitioner has designed the parking lot
in accordance with those requirements.
REVIEW CRITERIA:
Staff s recommendation to the Planning Board. as well as the Planning Board' s recommendation
to the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be based on the following review criteria set forth in
Section 2.3.4.11.6 of land Development Code:
The proposed off-site parking facility, including the mgress and egress IS safe and
convenient for motorists and pedestrians;
The currently approved parking along the south side of the structure is arranged so
that vehicles are forced to back into the right-of-way of Poinsettia Avenue (see
photograph). The proposed parking lot will provide a driveway connection onto
Poinsettia Avenue which safely directs ingressing and egressing traffic onto the
adjacent public street.
~
~. .
The proposed off-site parking facility does not adversely impact the character and quality
of the neighborhood nor will hinder the future development of surrounding properties:
Where off-site parking is proposed adjacent to residentially zoned property, enhanced
buffering and landscaping are required pursuant to Section 2.3.4.11.4(g) of the Land
Development Code. In t"~ opinion of staff, this enhanced landscape buffer will
provide an adequate buffer between the proposed off-site parking facility and the
residentially zoned properties adjacent to the said parking facility.
Approval of the petition will not create parking problems for any neighboring propeny;
Approval of this request will do nothing to create parking problems and should even
reduce the parking problems for the neighboring properties due to the provision of
additional off-street parking. The additional off-street parking as proposed will
reduce the amount of vehicles currently parking along the right-of-way of Poinsettia
A,'enue.
AGENDA ITEM
No. 17 tL
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. /0
..., Other more viable parking solutions are not available to the petitioner.
5
There are no other more viable parking solutions available within the neighborhood
to provide adequate parking for this building. There is also an existing commercial
building to the north.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
That the Collier County Plarming Commission (CCPC) fOf\vard Petition OSP-98-1 to the Board
of Zoning Appeals with a recommendation of approval subject to the stipulations listed on the
Resolution of adoption and Restrictive Covenant.
PREPARED BY:
2.'~'9~
DATE
RA Y LLOWS. PRINCIPAL PLA~NER
CURRE?\iT PLANNJ1\'G SECTIOi\
,
REVIE\VED, :
;' ,'. \\ I c;- ';
, :n,
RPNALDT.---1 .' ICP. \1ANAGER
CURRENT PLANNING SECTIO}\;
).. \L),r\L'!
DATE
2-1/~f
DATE
APPROV~d. ~.
\T'-JCENT A. CAUTERO. AICP. ADMINISTRATOR
COMMUNITY DEV. AND ENVIRONMENTAL SVCS.
a. -(~ -9,,/
DATE
Staff Report for the March 4. 1999 CCPC meeting.
OMMISSION:
OSP-98-liSTAFF REPORTIRVB/rb
AGENOA ITEM
No. 11~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 1/
6
OFF-SITE PARKING APPLICATION (OSP)
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS DETERMINATICU,
PETITION NO.
(ASSIGNED BY STAFF) DAT.E
SDP NO.
(ASSIGNED BY STAFF)
TO BE SERVED BY OFF-SITE PARKING
NAME AND ADDRESS OF BUSINESS
A ZA~ c;A '-I- ~ rL.1
crRC, A I.frorZ,
tv A r '-2<:> J
I
~Ad?
Ft..-
~.,)~
c1A-/O_4-
I BLOCK If ~ 'I
UNIT
LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF BUSINESS LOT
~ A P L ~ ') V \ \-LA 5
SEC TWP RANGE
..... "
U ~ wEST 112. 01- z. ~
LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF OFF-SITE LOT BLOck 118~. UNIT
PARKING LOT SEe TWP - - RANGE -"-
PETITIONER'S NAME A 2A{L ({A /..-f- ~a...-'I I ~ C.
PETITIONER'S ADDRESS 7r7 4IL"~~ ~A-P "'S;-.;~
_~ A to L-~? F L. 34-1 ~ TELEPHONE
I
AGENT'S NAME VAPID 5j)~ / ~~'-W1AU F"c)~ rLJee4I"-""t
AGENT'S ADDRESS 2(,4-7 'PAYI" ~'-o/O
t..J A-~ (... ~ , F L- TELEPHONE 774- . S-s <7 4-
I
ZONING ON PROPOSED OFF-SITE PARKING LOT
12..1Y\f=4:>
ZONING/LAND USE ON PROPERTY ADJACENT TO PROPOSED OFF ,SITE
PARKING LOT.
ZONING
N. ---F-d1 ~(,
S ~4-
E ~f'l1 F lo
w C+
LAND USES
-1-
_.A
~ AGENOA ITEM
No. I1A
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I~
ZONING OF ,LOT THE OFF-SITE PARKING IS PROPOSED TO SERVE
TYPE OF LAND USE THAT OFF-SITE PARKING IS PROPOSED TO SERVE
(EXAMPLE: MEDICAL OF~ICE, RES!.(iURANT, ETC.)
Oe,~~ I't.>C< 6<'Al-L-CIZ--7
PARKING FORMULA REQUIRED FOR ABOVE REFERENCED USE (I.E. 1
SPACE PER 250 SQ. FT.) PURSUANT TO SECTION 2.3.14 OF COLLIER
COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
~:.c ')D /2 .::;b
f
TOTAL NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES REQUIRED FOR ABOVE USE
'"
r
-,
/)
TOTAL NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES LOCATED ON SITE
% OF 'TOTAL REQUIRED 53
s
TOTAL NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES PROPOSED OFF-SITE
((
DISTANCE OF PROPOSED OFF-SITE PARKING LOT TO SUBJECT BUSINESS
lcrol
(MEASURED BY SHORTEST
FEASIBLE WALKING DISTANCT)
BRIEF NARRATIVE SUMMARY OF WHAT YOU ARE PROPOSING:
"P~vIO,.)L.t \'i -oAJet::/Ut. c::5f"~ 0,.)
l- ~I~ -4 O...J-A;r A_~ \0 CZ V I ~ .,../ ~'"
~-.;cs.//\/~~ ~~~
-2-
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1A
MAR 2 3 1999
/3
Pg.
-- BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS DETEP~INATION OF OFF-SITE PARKING PETITION
YOU MUST MEET ALL 6 OF THE REQUIREMENTS BELOW:
(a) All of the lots are under the same ownership;
(b) No off-site parking space is located further than three
hundred (300) feet from the building or use they are intended
to serve, measured by the shortest feasible walking distance,
unless special circumstances exist under section 2.3.4.11.5;*
(c) The lots are not separated by an arterial roadway as
designated in the Traffic Element of the Growth Management
Plan;
(d) At least sixty-seven (67) percent of the required parking for
the development is located on the lot with the principal
structure unless special circumstances exist under Section
2.3.4.11.5;*
(e) The off-site parking will serve an existing structure or land
use; and
(f) All of the lots proposed for off-site parking meet the
locational requirements for commercial uses as identified in
the Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management Plan or
are designed to serve water-dependent an~/or water-related
uses as described in the Urban Residential Subdistrict of the
Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management Plan.
*Where the following special circumstances exist the Board of
Zoning Appeals may reduce the requirements of "b" and/or "d"
above. If so, check the item(s) below that still allow you to
submit the petition and turn in this page with your application.
These special circumstances shall include, but shall not be
limited to:
( a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
_(e)
Where the proposed off-site parking will serv~ water-
dependent and/or wa~er-related uses;
Where the proposed off-site parking will serve
Temporary Parking for Sports Events, Religious Events,
or Community Events as described in Section 8.23;
Where the proposed off-site parking will serve uses
within the Immokalee Central Business District as
described in Section 2.3.3.4;
Where the proposed off-site parking spaces will only
be for valet parking; or
Where the proposed off-site parkin~ spaces will onl
be for employees (limited to a max~mum of fiftee (ll~ENOAITEM
percent of the project's total parking requireme t)~ 17 A
-3-
MAR 2 3 1999
/J./
Pg.
REVIEW CRITERIA FOR BOARD OF ZONING AP?EALS DETERMINATION
The Board of Zoning Appeals shall base their determination of
requests for off-site parking on the following review criteria:
The petitioner is encouraged to provide comments relating to each
of the below listed criteria.
(a) The proposed off-site parking facility, including its ingress
and egress, is safe and convenient for motorists and
pedestrians;
Petitioner's Comments:
-,-- r
c i-f..-c::;
..p ~I J"-
~
IH~
~~.
Cv~/V)
!s ~>V~ ~ (JCC-HIC~
~t,)i~ ~ ~~ /~ID
;2 (~ 14'1 - (),c ,. ~It-J' CJ i= -PO I OS F-' I
--rF-l~ P~Q5 ~ ?A-1e~/ML.. ~T
P ~~ i.t:J .c 'SA-~ ~It /1::::" P-/C
IIA
~/'-'-
C!4A;,,~/;;V,
-
(b)
The proposed off-site parking facility does not adversely
impact the character and quality of the neighborhood nor will
hinder the proper future development of surrounding
properties;
OJ,)
U
)Jr; ,J&",-~/~ /fr7,4Ac~
IJGIC rJ'cf)a~ , ~""'IC <?A-Pt;77
/h?/~I
SUNL...o
Petitioner's Comments:
AGENDA ITEM
No. 17A-
MAR 2 3 1999
IS-
-4-
,LPg.
(c) Approval of the petition will not create parking problems for
any neighboring property;
Petitioner's Comments:
ro~
/It <k...I u 4
I,.ea,~f
(d) other ,more viable parking solutions are not available to the
petitioner.
/~
<-
Ow~a:ro
/Jc;; O~UffI.
_fJL Av~/t-I1d4 ' AA./ ~
Z K 1-5'71/1/4 ~S~..u (!?-S
.
rdPP?tZtZi ;'
Petitioner's Comments:
-r-.
/C;
7#G"
OSP BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS DETERMINATION/rod
AGENDA ITEM
No. 17A
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. J to
-5-
':.olo""~AC~Q~ or """OIllTC'..'C(
',..ll.~t').....,ltw;'.'"
.....;m \0 ..-c'~' ....mcI,......, .1..... .,.,......)
'-
~** 20523:7 ~R: :179 PG: 0405 ~xx
~jCOI~~li :J ,U:W,l. :!COnDS of COL;:U :QUlI'l'T, I~
:5rO&lH H :: :m CW:GH! ! mer, ::m
mm ,;~
,l,xr....
^",EIl RiCORDING 1\!~WI'\N ~o
-AW OFO'CE QF
::UUW....li ~, H"'NI\.IN
"'OaRINae ~ROFESS'ONA~ ev'LO."G
23351.1.1011.1.".[ TRAIL NORTH SUITE:ice
I'IAPLES, FL 339'0
.il
Ii
!
i
l
I
Retn:
~COGLAS L ?.AJfm
:m !AKUX: ~F. R me
mm f1 J3!IO
~:
Tr I ,"''''rum.". P,..ect "y.
This Instrum.nt "'Ia crepared by:
.""'... Douglll L. Rlnotn
Attornev II llw
Moonng, Prof.sslonl' Building
2335 Tam'amJ Tr'lI North Sull. 30t
Nap..., FL 33UO
0,0".".. ~I"'_ "_1__ (FOIDl_WI.):
~3;00350009 ~ ~3~01160004
SPACE A80Vf Tl<I5 ""Ii FOOl PROCE5$I"G CATA
"'ACE AIIOV! T>tS lIfo1l FO" RECOAaNG DJlTA
~ttfi5farlion of ~ngt
~ttr J\ll 4Ln ~q 'mqrl!le JTruerch5: Thai
r
(1.w.)
;3vid J. Henry, a married ~an,
, the owner and holder of a cerra", frlOrrgage deed e:recuted by A h marl "11 r z i ai, 3 "1 a r r i e d man,
i to
Savin C. Yenry, a "1arr;erl ~an,
I
I
I
I
~anngdatuhe 3Dth day of Seotember ,A.D,J994recordedinOfflcja/R<<:ordsBooIc :990 'I
FUl5e S J G 1 . III tile ujJir.:e uf the Clert ur tire Cirr:uit CUUlt oj C 0 I 1 i e r CoIUll)'. I
Slale of r lor; Ii a ,JeCSmll' t ~ 3 b:1'IQrllllO~ Iflthe PrillClr IWIrt of ')ne Yundre~ T~ i rty-t:; gh~
?"jusal1d ~iMe Yun~r!>r: 'ii"ety-T~ree and 611100 rS138,993.61 ..' i
Dullcm, aM CCl'illill P'ONlifiUj a1ii1 GtJli~liil(jM oCi fonll ill ouill mongage gtrMi, _jXHl hI ;".".r1)' lUl/,ur In 11l1;1 ~rarr .:rId (;'ft'l'Y I
i I descnbed as follows. to-wit:
i
~ARCEL 1: lot 1, Block 3, ~APlES VILLAS, accordlng to the plat ln Plat Book-
~, Cage 7, Public Records of Colller County, Flor;1a; and P~RCEL 11: lot 25
3nd the ~est one-half (:/2) Of lot 25, Bloc~ S, NAPLES VILLAS, according to
t~c ~lJt i" D1Jt oDO~ 1, ~Jgc 7, ~ublie qceJrd~ of Collier County, ~lori~~.
:1
I,
I
.! Mretiy ack1law/e/1gr ~ [wit fJ/TftMnlll1ld saii,sfacrion of satd 1IlJt4 n man gag, i"i, Qntt l'JrrrIWm rh' 11lm' Ql 'Q/l""'4,
rInd hereby direct 5 lhe Clerk of the :sard Circuit Colin to cQ7ICe/ lhe )Qme afn:cord.
;3lIImw.. my lIond and s~al ,Ih/s
SignuJ. uQ/.d QIU/ d.liv.lYd in I~ pru.n:;. of:
-~~ --==~
W..!I.pIIIIIftC"1o ~,
~ouolas L. Qankin
-Ja.~ ~7T'A
::; ., '-""
\ ~enn1fe Na1fe~ "
"-
2nd
day of
May
, A TJ /9 95
%lt~--c
....... N_
254 Dine valley Circle
II
I
Ii "'-"-~."(""""",,_.""')
1\__
IlijW_Il_lOOwc.-..-,lt.,1
_N_
il STATE OF FLORIDA ) Ibenbyc..utyl!l.lcatbiaday,befon-._om-dlA/y.udlonzad
COUNTY OF COLLIER.. ) lC~oadIIllldlak..ctDow\clc1p- ~yappeand
II r)avirl J. Henry, a married 'Tl1an,
10>0... 10 .... to be 1lIe ~ delcribed ift """ wtlo .......-.IlIlo r-.-, __.... wbo .C~ befon _IlIaC ~ e aocawd tile
II .--.,...,....... - -.....
I Cbect ..... _ tIsa.d penaa(1) ill... penonaIly blowIIlo .....
II ( .) 0 Said porIOII(l) provided the rollowiaa type of~..:atiaa:
\'
II
I I
I,
.... ""'- .....-.-
~aples, Fl. 319~2
"~~1_4"'- It.,
_N_
_ 0lII00_
TEM
IIId s~ aforlS&l4 J '11
1996
1999 .
/11
NOTARY AlJUE/llT_ .....
"'__illY band IIId omclal Mal ill dIt CoWl
lbiI 2nli 1.4 a
i
A DOUGLAS L RANKIN
No"" ~ SlIlt CIl FIDIllII
I "., ConwlI. ... -, 20. ,.
/010. CC IClO1S7
I - !lMllI<! ~ IIIlIoIoI ........
'" ..
-,~
~ouQlas l. qankin
--
?.ESOL',-:-IO'\ 99-
RELATf\'G TO PETITlO'\ '\1..~1BER OSp.98-i
FOR OFF.SITE P_\R.Kf.\:G O~ PROPERTY
HEREf.':A.FTER DESCRIBED I'\ COLLIER
COL~T\"_ FLORIDA_
\\ "HERE AS. the LegIslature oi the Stale oi Florida In Chapter I ~5. Florida Statutes. has
~onjerred on ail counl1es In Flonda the power to establish. coorainate ana enforce zoning and
such bUSIness regulations as are necessary ior the prOleC110n of the public. and
\\"HEREAS. the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code
I Ordinance '\0. 91-1 O~) which establishes regulations for the zomng oi particular geographic
JiVlslons oithe County. among which is the allowance oioff-sHe parking. and
-.\"HEREA.S. the Board oi loning Appeals. being the duiy elected constituted board tor
Collier County which includes the area hereby atTected. has held a public heanng after nollce and
has considered the advisability of off-site parking as shown on the attached plot plan, Exhibit
",\". m an R.T\1F -6 zone for the propeny heremafter descnbed. and has found as a matter of fact
that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters
required by said regulations and in accordance with SubsectIOn 2_3_5.3. Section 2.7.5 and
DiVIsion 3_3 at the Collier County Land Development Code. for the unincorporated area of
Collier County. and
\\"HEREAS. all interested partIes have been gIven opponumty to be heard by this Board
in a public meellng and the Board having conSIdered all matters presented.
'\OW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF lO'\lNG APPEALS at
CollIer County. Flonda. that the petition filed by David Sneed of Kuhlman Engineering. Inc.
representing Ahmad Mirziai with respect to the property hereinafter described as:
Lot 26 and the west ':, of Lot 25. Block B. ~aples Villas. as recorded in
Plat Book 4. Page i. of the Public Records of Collier County. Florida.
be and the same hereby is approved for off-site parking as ShOV,11 on the attached plot plan.
Exhibit "Au. of the RMF -6 zoning district wherein said property is located. subject to the
following conditions:
a) Prior to fmal site development Plan (SDP) approval. an Off-site Parking Agreement
shall be approved by the Board of County Commissioners and the applicant shall bear
the cost of recording the restrictive covenant and off-site parking agreement in the
Public Records of Collier County, and shall provide the document when submitting
the final SDP for approval.
AGENDA ITEM
No. /7 A_
MAR 2 3 1999
Pr.;.
/1
J I LightIng shall be designed to shield streets and aH adjacent oroperties from dlrect
;iare. excessIve light. :md hazardous Interterence W1lh aUlOmOllve and pedestnan
:raffi c.
C I The petitIOner shall submIt a final site development plan in accordance with Division
:.3 olthe Land Development Code (LDC),
'"') The proposed parkmg lot shall be surtaced \\1lh asphalt or concrete and striped
accordingly.
e I :\ 15 foot landscape buffer smp shaH be provlded along the resIdentIally zoned
property, This IS to include a fence or berm as required in Section 2.3.4.11 A,I g) of
the Land Development Code.
: I ,",0 access shall be provlded from the off-site parking Lot 26 and the west " of Lot 25
:0 any adJacent resIdentIal street. The access shall be as shown on the attached plot
plan. ExhibIt ",\",
BE IT RESOL \"ED that this Resolution relating to Petition ,",umber OSP-98-] be
recorded in the mmutes at this Board,
This ResolutIon adopted after motion. second and maJonty vote.
day of
.1999,
Done thIS
0\ TTEST:
D\\lGHT E BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF ZONING _.I.JlPEALS
COLLIER COLl"TY. FLORIDA
BY:
P,-\..\1EL.-\ S. \lACKlE. CHAlRWOMA~
,\pproved as to Form and Legal Sufficienc":
'\ "
J)~ 1 ~ I J) . p;Q.1.d..P d-
Marjo' M. Student
Assistant County Attorney
OSP-9i,1 RESOLLT10S
AGENDA ITEM
No. I1A
MAR 2 3 1999
/9
P~.
-2-
-: :\ r -= ::J 1 -:' "~"
N ~'
~
!l b
~
g) _.--
a - - - i
IHOE WAAEHOUSE 11
t --,
17' 0- -
\49
.....1..-._~.;..--=:::-__.
18'1" - wtr -- 1,.0- 1~' rr
o
;;.
~
T
_...l.- '
E;xtS"I'INb
~T"uCTtJli.'E'
!'l(t~nNG
STIltLJC1'URE
..
9
--.--
I
~
It
'X
,.
-'----
~~
=
b
~
L.AH08CAPE
-- IrE~ IJl.,,$~M""'> f& I'-!ST....l ~ '"''''lqt>cA'''E
....E'
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1 A_
MAR 2 3 1999
"OIN~." "'-\/'E,
SITE o~,A,N 1"=20'
Pg. 01 0
RESTRlCTI\'E COVDiA.."iT
-\;-"1) OFT.SITE P-\RKDG .-\GREE:-'lE~l
ThIS ,-\gree:nenr ]5 made and entered Into thIS
-::ay or"
'999, by and between
-'\.hmaci :-'llrZlal., ~;:c the CoilIer County Board or County lommlSSlOners !the "Board"].
RECITALS
\\ liEREAS, Pelllloner IS the O,^l1er or 989 AIrport Road South, \'aples. Flonda I heremarter the
",ublect propem'''i, :TIore panlcularlv descnbed as: Lot I Block B. \'aoles Villas. as recorded m PIat
Book... Page ;, or the PublIc Records of CollIer County. flonda: and
\VHEREAS. the PetllJOner WIshes to operate ori-slle parkmg racIlllles on land more particularly
Jescnoeo as: Lot 26 and the west ,or Lot 25, \'aoies Villas. recorded m Plat book ... Page -; or the
Pubilc Records ore oIlier County. flonda compnsed or RMF-6 zOning: and which pelllloner also 0....."5:
and
WHEREAS, the proposed otT-sire parkmg does not adversely Impact the character and qualav or
the neighborhood nor hmder the proper future developmenr of surroundmg propemes: and
WHEREAS the proposed of i-site parkmg IS In conformance W1lh all of the cntena set forth m
Secllon 2.3....] 1.6 of the Land DevelopmenrCode: and
\'vliEREAS. the proposed off-slle parkmg \\1111 prOVIde twenty (20) new parkmg spaces which
'xiii serve to proVIde the necessary parkmg ror the subject property: and
\\liEREAS. the Board of Zomng Appeals has passed ResoiutlOn No. 99-
attached hereto
:is Exhlba ".-\ ", relaung to Peullon OSP-98-1, approving the proposed off-sae parkmg,
:-iOW. THEREFORE. m conslderatlOn thereof. the PetItIoner agrees In hIS capacIty as the O\VTleT
or the subject property as well as the owner of the property whIch wIll prOVIde the off-sae parlang:
), That the above recnals are true and correct and mcorporated herem by reierence.
2, That the proposed off-Site parking areas shall never be encroached upon. used. sold. leased.
or conveyed for any purpose except for the use m conJunclJon .....'th the subject property and used so long
as the off-site parkmg faCIlitates are reqUIred and that thIS Agreement consl1lutes a restrictIve covenant.
That the pelllJoner shall bear the expense of recordmg the Agreement in the OffiCIal
Records of Collier County whIch shall bind the property owner. his heIrs. successors and assigns.
AGENO~ ITEM
No. 17A
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.
~J
. '.3I
;";:t:u..:)r;I?~ ~;~~O~ :~"
--.....:: COnOnlOnS "':':--.0. :-::::n":lJ.tJOnS ucS~nOeG ::- :;:C'
.1,~soiulJon :"0. -,'1-
..:1a b\' the :-i1!e 1':3:1 nOlea 3S ExhlDn ..\.. Jllachec :.ereta ana mcornor31ec D\
.::e:-er.ce :--,e~e1l1
:-":..1! :::..~ 0; :;:e :--caUlrements tor J. Bo:.ua or' ZunIng .-\ppeal5 (ktermlnatlOn for or(-:-Ite
"3r~ml! re:erer;cea l~. Pe:ltJon uSP.Q'-l :'.l\e heer, rr:el and aDprO\ea :,\ plannmg :-itaff
:"at ::-::'\~'Teement ,uDerseaes ana ,,",oOllles an\' pnor Parkmg .-\greement whIch :na\'
~ave heen executed [-etween the Board ana Ihe then or :urrent O\\ller of tr,e sub1ect oroperr\' 3no the
"~ODert': "'nlch \\'111 ,ei\e 35 me otf-me parKmg area.
Tnat thls-\~'Teement ,nail remam ITI :''Jil force and effect '.miess and unlll termmatec h\'
:ne Boaro,
1:1at t:11S ,-\",'Teement snail be vOlded b\' the Board :f other olt'-sne parkmg faClill1es are
--'o\'lded :n accordance \\1!h Ihe reaUIrements of 01\'\SI0n 2.:, vf t:-,e L:md Oeveiopmem Code,
1:1at upon faIlure to conform ta an\' at the provtSlons of :hlS ,-\greement or the anached
\greement Sheet. thIS Resmcllve Covenant and Off-Sne Parkmg Agreement shall become \'old and of
::0 effect ;;nd the Pet1tloner ;;hali be requIred to conform ta ail zOnIng reguiatlOns as comamed m the
CollIer CounN Land Development Code.
['i \\Tr~'ESS \\"HEREOF :he pames hereto have set theIr hands and seals the day and year first
.Joove \\T1nen.
.-\ TTEST
O\\'IGHT E. BROCK, C;erK
BOARD OF COL~"ll- COMMISSI01'<'ERS
COLLIER COL")'"ll', FLORIDA
PAMELA S, MACKlE. ChaIrwoman
\\" 1 messes:
PETITIONER A.l\ffi O\\~R OF LA.."ID CPO~
\VHlCH OFF-SITE P:\RKING FACILITIES
ARE TO BE LOCATED:
Ahmad MlfZlal
,-\pproved as to Form and Legal SufficIency:
mr~^- In. ~
\la!)one. . Student
ASSIstant County Attorney
AGENDA ItEM
No. /7 ~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.
da
-L.-
--
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PETITION NO. V-99-1, RICHARD D. YOVANOVICH REPRESENTING COASTAL
BEVERAGES LTD. REQUESTING A 17.8 FOOT VARIANCE FROM THE REQUIRED
50 FOOT FRONT YARD TO 32.2 FEET FOR THE PROPOSED EXPANSION OF A
WAREHOUSE COMPLEX APPROVED IN 1992. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS
LOCATED AT 4747 PROGRESS AVENUE IN SECTION 36, TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH,
RANGE 25 EAST COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
OBJECTIVE:
The petitioner is requesting the above described variance for an existing warehousing
facility.
CONSIDERATIONS:
---
The County is in the process of acquiring Right of Way for the future Livingston Road.
This property which was developed in 1993 is one of the properties affected by this
acquisition. This development was for a warehouse type use and the approved plans
showed a future expansion. By the virtue of this taking the existing yard will be reduced
by 20 feet, and furthermore, the existing side yard will become a front yard. The
combined side yard setbacks in the industrial district is 20 percent of the lot width with a
maximum of 50 feet, whereas, the front setback is 50 feet. This variance will not confer
any privilege on the applicant. It only will allow the construction of the structures as
previously were approved by the Site Development Plan (SDP-92-27 -C).
The Collier County Planning Commission reviewed this petition on March 4, 1999 and
by a vote of 9-0 recommended approval of the variance. Staff has not received any
letters in opposition to the granting of this request. This petition does qualify to be
placed on the Summary Agenda.
FISCAL IMPACT:
None.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
None.
HISTORIC/ARCHAEOLOGICAL IMPACT:
--...
Staff's analysis indicates that the petitioner's property is located outside an area of
historical and archaeological probability as referenced on the official Col ~I ITEM
No.---11....CL
MAR 2 3 1999
/
1
pc.
Probability Map. Therefore, no Historical/Archaeological Survey and Assessment is
required.
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of Zoning Appeals approve V-99-1.
PREPARED BY:
chJ,~~ ~~---
CHAHRAM BADAMTCHIAN, Ph.D., AICP
PRINCIPAL PLANNER
't/4-/"l"
DATE
R~VIEWEiD BY:
\ i
,': ~ " ;,,', ?;~-
RONALD F.'NfNO, AICP. MANAGER
CURRENT PLANNING SECTION
, 1 ~.
/) lL., C, .7
. .) I.
DATE
?
,/ (;/~,;?--------~ --~-- - ".-
ROBERT J. MULHERE, AICP, DIRECTOR
PLANNING SERVICES
? - { 'Y9'
'"
DATE
APPR/D BY:
'l/Wt it. J -(J- 7 r
VINCENT A. CAUTERO. AICP, ADMINISTRATOR DATE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
AGeI>A ITEM
No. 11 B
MAR 2 3 1999
~
pc.
2
c..GEND.; ITEM 7-H
MEMORANDUM
TO:
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM:
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION
DATE:
Fl3bruary 1 rJ. 1999
RE:
::'ETITION V 99-',
AGENT/APPLICANT:
Owner:
Coastal Beverages L TO.
4747 Progress Avenue
Naples. FL. 34104
Agent:
Richard D. Yovanovich. Esq.
Goodlette, Coleman & Johnson, P.A.
4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300
Naples, FL. 34103
REQUESTED ACTION:
The petitioner is requesting a 17.8 foot variance from the required 50 foot front yard to
32.2 feet for the proposed expansion of a warehouse complex approved in 1992.
GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION:
The subject property is located at 4747 Progress Avenue in Section 36, Township 49
South, Range 25 East Collier County, Florida (See attached for cOn1olete legal descriotion).
PURPOSE/DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:
The County is in the process of acquiring Right of Way for the future Livingston Road.
This property which was developed in 1993 is one of the r:operties affected by this
acquisition. This development was for a warehouse type use and the approved plans
showed a future expansion. By the virtue of this taking the existing yard will be reduced
by 20 feet, and furthermore, the existing side yard will become a front yard. The
combined side yard setbacks in the industrial district is 20 percent of the iot width with a
maximum of 50 feet, whereas, the front setback is 50 feet. This variance will not confer
any privilege on the applicant. It only will allow the construction of the structures as
previously were approved by the Site Development Plan (SDP-92-27 -C).
SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING:
Existing:
- Warehouse, zoned Industrial
AGENe'" ITEM
No. /7 13
MAR 2 3 1999
3
Pi.
-1-
o
~
-------
~~ -----~ ~ ~; " .
//, ""I, '" ~
~'-" ''',,/ '~r ~- . I /,' "
-~, ~~~/\. ";,
c-- ~D · ~,i(:~ ',. .0, ','~~
i w 21~\ V~-'<=0'#'~(~ r--"-- ~"~
":'~r <;~~ / ~N, ~at=,
~1\~2 V~,:/// '___.~.!~~.~,~I
" """ / "~'.' ,
' ~ ':'" I" 'ii', ,
~
,------,
=~..~
- -€~
-2>......
'--
'-'
"
-
-
I
Q..:
41
2:.
lJJl
!::I
(/)1
Q
~e\
~i
-
~
~;
:"-----i '.
, ,
,~i
~
~"
:1 I
I
'i I
1 I
. '
~I
-~.
:~~
Iii
I i
~,
I~I
-J~I
I~
I
I
'!
, \
Ti
0>:
~I
~I
I
""""OIlClN / ~
-
%,
01
i=i
-,
1-1
Wi
Q..I
~
~
~~
~ j ~
~
g
~
N
1
61.1
!'
;;
~
;;
Surrounding: North - Vacant, zoned Industrial
East - Livingston Road R.O.W.
South - United parcel Services, zoned industrial
West - Automobile repair storage yard, zoned industrial
HISTORIC/ARCHAEOLOGICAL IMPACT:
Staff's analysis indicates that the petitioner's property is located outside an area of
historical and archaeological probability as referenced on the official Collier County
Probability Map. Therefore, :10 Historical/Archaeological Survey and Assessment is
required.
EVALUATION FOR ENVIRONMENTAL. TRANSPORTATION AND
INFRASTRUCTURE:
Approval of this variance request will have no effect on infrastructure, transportation or
required environment relationships.
ANAL YSIS:
Section 2.7.5 of the Land Development Code grants the authority to the Board of
Zoning Appeals to grant variances. The Planning Commission is advisory to the BZA
and utilizes the provisions of Subsection(6)(a) through (h) which are general guidelines
to be used to assist the Commission in making a determination. Responses to items (a)
through (h) of Subsection (6) are as follows:
a. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing which are peculiar
to the location, size and characteristics of the land, structure, or building
involved?
Yes, this development was approved meeting the requirements of the LDC. The
County's eminent domain action will have the effect of reducing the amount of
land available to satisfy a setback requirement that will now effect the planned
expansion unless the variance is granted.
b. Are there special condi'jons and circumstances which do not result from the
action of the applicant such as pre-existing conditions relative to the
property which is the subject of the variance request?
Yes, when the applicant planned and obtained permits for their development, the
County did not request this 20 foot strip be sold to the County for ROW purposes.
This development cannot be expanded to the extent planned without a variance.
c. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this Land Development Code
work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant?
Yes, the applicant will not be able to go forward with the planne eX~I1lTEM
without an approved variance, nevertheless, it should be apprecia ed ~t the /1./!>
-2-
MAR 2 3 1999
0-
Pi.
owner of the land was compensated for the value or the taking wnich presumably
should have accounted for the effect this would have on the expansion
opportunities.
d. Will the variance, if granted, be the minimum variance that will mak(~
possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure and which
promote standards of health, safety and welfare?
Yes, the requested 17.8 foot variance is the minimum variance necessary to
enable the applicant to expand the building, as previously approved.
e. Will granting the variance requested confer on the petitioner any special
privilege that is denied by these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings,
or structures in the same zoning district?
No, granting of this variance will not confer on the applicant any privilege. It only
enable them to construct the expansion as previously approved. Had it not been
for this prior approval it would be our opinion that the granting of the variance
would confer a special privilege.
f. Will granting the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose
of this Land Development Code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood,
or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare?
No, this variance, if approved, will reduce the front yard requirements on
Livingston Road. However, a multitude of other buildings along this stretch of the
Livingston road will have non-conforming front setbacks, however, it should not be
injurious to the neighborhood, or detrimental to the public welfare in terms of the
function that setbacks serve.
g. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that
ameliorate the goals and objectives of the regulation such as natural
preserves, lakes, golf courses, etc.?
No.
h. Will granting the variance be consistent with the Growth Management Plan.
The granting of this variance will not change the requirements of the Growth
Management Plan.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
-3-
r ^ AGOI)'" ITEM
B.r. rto~tn a 17 e,
MAR 2 3 1999
to
Pg.
Staff recommends that the CCPC forward Petition V 99-1 to the
recommendation for approval.
PREPARED BY:
,. /~.} ~4 J.
~V~h-WM . Ir~.....,
CHAHRAM BADAMTCHIAN, Ph.D., AICP
PPIN:IP.A,L P~ANNER
2//{.,..-"'I/
DATE
'\
REVIEWED BY~
~ . \ i
, \
,\ '
\~..
"\ .-...A. x ~, \/\~
I _
RONALD F. NINO, AICP, MANAGER
CURRENT PLANNING SECTION
-r
~'Ie '\ -1,
DATE
~MULHERE, A~P, DIRECTOR
PLANNING SERVICES
'2-11--~7
DATE
APPROVED BY:
~ /'~
. ./ ,/ /'
~..~ //(. (h1A ~ .,--.. q
/ / v?'Q c-' ~ 0.---- ~ D< -.. / - q 0
V'NCENT A. CAUTERO. AICP, ADMINISTRATOR DATE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
Petition Number: V-99-1
Staff report for March 4, 1999 CCPC meeting.
This Petition has tentatively been scheduled for March 23,1999 BZA Public Hearing.
Collier County Planning Commission:
\ /---;?
\
AGENOA ITEM
No. /1 ~
MAR 2 3 1999
7
P&.
I
-4-
.~
.,
" ~:'!'~
-
,",
-...s,io
-
~"_ :~_ -'r-~-':.;'
RESOLL1IO:-: :-:0,99-
RELUD:G TO PETITIO:\' l\l.TMBER \'-99-1. FOR
A \"A.RL~'\;CE ON PROPERTY HEREr\AFTER
DESCRIBED f.\i COLLIER COUNTY. FLORID.-\..
\\rIEREAS. the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has
conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such
business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public: and
WHEREAS. the County pursuant thereto has :.:dopred a Land Development Code (Ordinance
:\0, 91-102) which establishes regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the
County, among which is the granting of variances: and
\\ 11EREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals, being the duly elected constituted Board of the
area hereby affected. has held a public hearing after norice as in said regulatIOns made and provided.
and has considered the advisability of a 17.8-foot variance from the required front yard setback of
50 feet lO 32.2 feet as shown on the attached plot plan. Exhibit "A". in an Industrial Zone for the
property hereinafter described, and has found as a matter of fact that satisfactory provision and
arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in
accordance with Section 2.7,5 of the Zoning Regulations of said Land Development Code for the
un;ncorporateLi area of Collier County; and
\VHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in
public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered all matters presented;
:\O\V THEREFORE BE IT RESOLYED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEAl.S of
Collier County, Florida. that:
T~e Petition V-99-1 filed by Mr. Richard D. Yovanovich of Goodlette Coleman & Johnson,
P.A.. re;Jresenting Coastal Beverage. Ltd,. with respect to the property heremafter described as:
Exhibit "B"
be ar.d the same hereby is approved for a 17,8-foot variance from the required front yard setback of
50 feetlO 32,2 feet as shov."TI on the attached plot plan, Exhibit "A", of the Industrial Zoning District
wherein said property is located, subject to the following conditions:
This variance shall only apply to the structures identified on the attached plat
plan (Exhibit "A").
-1-
AGENO'" ITEM
No. 17 t:>
MAR 2 3 1999
. ._~-'.: -..,. -~-
".~.
~
,-..~-
~'!...;;~~)'::~...,;-;...~~:.~~~= ~~;>"" -:.: -.:.. ~~.:: '::-.~ :..-~: -~.
-;;;;;.
bE IT RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to PetltlOn ~umDer \' -99-1 be recorded in
the minutes of this Board.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote.
Done this
day of
,1999,
.-\ TTEST:
D\\lGHT E, BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF ZOC\'DiG APPE.-\LS
COLLIER COl..-:HY. FLORIDA
P.~'v1ELA S. i\LA.C'KlE. CHAIRWo\1A'"
Approved as to Form and Legal Sufficiency:
,/.' !(~'-i\~ (I.. ~I/I ........-c.<:cc{LT
\L;:iorie \! Sl'..:dent
Assistant County Attorney
:--";3)().1 RESOLLTIOS
-2-
AGENO'" ITEM
No. /7/3
MAR 2 3 1999
~.
e;o-. .
9
:':':~~':,!~~-:;.",..., ~H_''OI ..", ~,_ ...
-.-. ,,_ 00. ..., ,'.... ..,. _'1_" ..... ........11.
~..1't ,.M ~. ". _..~.... ~.._. .1 ""., ~I(', ,..,U.' I.
~~::'l~--=;'--::':' ill,'. ~ ~,ll'. -.- d'~ _ 'IM. c:.UI., ,_.U
-,-. "_ ... _,. li...1 .... ~ ~ "..Jl.....J. ..'"
.~:~.::7' .1 ,.... 1Ol:)1" I:)t ..,..... tl ._ ....., "'e,"
:'"';: ;::~:-._ .1_ ..,.. _" 11_ ...... 1".11
.. ""0' a...... ..... _It I, \; ~...,
-.-. _.. ....Il'...'....n J~_" I.."
-.._ .n. '\',:"-I\'''n lt~,.) '....
-_. _'13 "-.II"ll' ~., J....I. (...
.-..., _....'......1'. ....., 1Il.l! .... ...... ........r
-,-._ e. p.. ..,...I...........n.......
....'.e. " ...._... u.. "" ..<..... t:_ .",. _...<"._
, ,.... ~.." !. l' I,.. ". ..,r ,
,....,. ,.....-........"...."'rf,_...._..''1.
.......,. ....1 ,__,,"c ....,
.:.~;;,. ... .~. .... II.., -' ..,'1 ....".. Ii ".'''' -..,'"
;.
'~E~.'=-2\'1
"
"
-::::=- :_~, ~:2, PSS 6:9-660
~~/
~~. RC:": ~;"~~\,.4::~~"7"
-: .:.;~~c~- =:::.:-
:;;
'-
i.;; ,.... "I' .r I..,. -_<<.au.' '.1 .t "'-<tl_ 11. !:1'WO'\.I'lI.,. It ~t...
...... :, t...,. l;4111.1. ,-..,. ,;...,.1<1o?i. boll... _,. o."la".,rO'l'
_...u.... I. '.11_.
-c__I... " ,_ _I.....' ~t' 01 "IC 1...,1.. l'.
- ........ ... .... !J" e.( loll. ...U.. l' -'-0. .O'......~U. t...1l
~... f..... ,. ... ...~ ... "-I~~ .r '" ..re.4 "",Ue
"...........,
~_o _1M"!", .1.,.. '-- _., 11_ .r ..1. I'Ctt.. )t "'t.
,........". ,... I""." ,_ '0 '!I' _..I....' eo'..... .t t!l.,
;.,..1 _'_1"1-.1 1a .._ ,_..... 101 0.1. ...,. 1111 ....... IH"
.... : "I. '.111.... "-Ilt' ""'10 ..._......
1*--. .j,.... ... __ 1l_ .t ..l. ___ ",tA ,,'..n ....,.. _.,
I'.... 1_1I
.",._ ..n..a .........". "u l"." t..t I
~...... "n. ....lJ.....I. LIl' B.O' ","
:.... ..n.s ........11. .... ",." r.,,,
tlW., "rI' ........-l.. ....., I1S.f10 t... r. ~". "Ifill ..
......1... I' ,., .....1 ""'0 ._""I~'
........co. t, '__11." 'w ..... .............. .J.... Cll. .011'''.1., )'.'11
f....'''.....,..... ...,_. t... _._'" ."" ",..Illt" p"r.... .:.o'lQ
~M _..u....t, lI.'4 1__ ., ,". ...I."t" I~'.'O ,..t ...d ..._, to
.. ",_., tor ~"I'"" ..tl~lt1.. .".. hll., .ttlil .1.... ''''.
...t'''I, 10.01 ,... '''.r.orr
~'''''l''IOWlI ~.ll IliLt...1 1..,.4 1E,..r 1_..
:..rl""Q' In ~.." _ ,... ..., l~.. of ',id hcotl.1 U "I... .....Ul
". .,It. ~ U' t..,.
;; CHAiN LL"K ,?:'iCE ~
" :i':~':!J.~ <~.ac
:J-...
'c
!"
'"
"'0
00
f'o
0"',
O""'XI
'"
'"
'"
'"
~
V1
"
~
~
"
-.::
UTilITY EASEMENT ~
>
C'.E S7CF-....
=_iL::~,G
:- ':5~ FL:C:;
:.;..:.I :: I:,:;
....:.
z
z
~,
"
::1
; i
. :,...
-": .
~
, I
. I
:-1
~
~i
I
I
I
r. ~+-,-
10,'\ .
0.'
k
i:
-.%'
,
-, c....'.'G ---QY ..........c;;~-=
~':..I...ljl. I':'.,,). ...._',~._.
. .::: "'ro( ':.~::;1 ,-- F=
...-............ . -... - -
r- - - - - - - r - - - - _.
- - - - r-
?RC?CCE:
WAnE,-':"...S::
~j.?":'.'JS,:~. "
..a;'2~'C::?~
G CHA.N L:!';!< ~E'iCE-..
~..
..::'+
.':-' ,.,:~.\::
-= :;.".~.
I
, \
~1L
-.'~' ~'
...--:.. ...
~
206~
c,.
.:.~:
'",'
"
-:
<:-
""l
'"
"""'c:l
= ('J
;:Er0
~vi
c::;?
.-J-
"'<7
<\.;I
0<::'
c::: -,
o c:::,
U)O
i ~. \
:0 I
r---
OJ':.;.
0,'
:::.
, '
,-::..",~ ":~.....
,,', "''''\. 0, I
i"
\ ~ ~,
\'~ 1,
n'" ,
o "I
" \
I
_ ,:::. -.+,..":J" "",,'::l.
'0," 0,: -~, q, - . 'Of
~\ \
-"': ..
"
~.
;:::)
..
- FOUND CONe.
YONUMENT
_0,62 NORT~O.cO
s. 1;'2\'02
~\..
q'
....J
W
U
,'"'
<
"
~
~'
5.77 ACRES:
~..
::;..
')..:.
,,-:0-
'"
'0.
')..:. .
-::;'^RrEli.
I t'"' '-" 1,
o ^ RC~i ~URV~V~'i f\ ND
' ,........, \ '--_ ,....., ~ 1 ~-' ,.....
I DESC~En 't)EREON
:::::""'" . 7'::::'-:1, 'CR~"". -f'~.,
U ~ il~'co'/ ,;" ~ A rO:~,;:)lA_V<
- '.-J -~ V~-i LC I '.. .~
u< '
:::::::?.--:J // PINE~ a PALMET"TOS 6 i
~ (~. I ~
[' 2,';.
,c.. ,..... """.3' \. J50' 24 J .uS 5
,/ I q. 0,'-'.. 0,'
J ~:
O.R. 1464, PGS, 328-334
J 30~A~ EASEMENT
'1>....
Cb' ~...:
, ,
z
<
~,
,
'-jV.-
~
~....
'1>'
'1>.
......
'1>'
."'''0
,....
c,'
I"l~ -., ~',t.,..
P.O.E,------ 'I'
PROGRESS AVE.
60' R /W
sv' ,04
".21' 02''''
'\~. 'I>
0,' ~ ~
"I". ASPHALT'
\' PAVEMENT
"I'..."'.
".
"I....
'1>'
,".
~.
LANDS RECORDED IN O.R.
PAGES i207-1208
BOOK
1278
EXHIBIT "A"
-'
J[::-
: / /". '
"
r
"
:::
~I
',.
':J.~.
c..
-
0::
'~
_o,~(f) c,.
c:: I !
~ - _c;!44~~- t i-
~
"'"
~
,.....
~
~
-:.
<:;;<:;;
<:j'
".
.....
I.:::
-8,-
-
'"
!;
(.'.
, 'I
:=:1
LW
<.:)
-<
;Z
-
~
~:' .,.
...":l+
------6.-.
,...,
-
I k~
I c.r l()' 0 '
';. I'? I
:/ ou ~ _~_:...
'u ~'
1
i
J'
'/1"
,
:::::;
::<:
~
=
:<-:
,,'
,\<:l.
'\.
,.":J1
;a"
'I>~
'1>'
/
/'
:
AGENDA IlEM .., ...
No. /181 o,.c, la
I 4 CORNtR ~
C NC. tlt~'r 1~ ~
cb
':!
Pg.
:-eecrip-:'ion vf t:.:!.rce!. locate:l i:. part 0: ~he nor-:.r-.eas:.
of Section 36, Tcwnehip 49 SouLh, Range 25 East,
Collier County, Florida
(Naples Production Park, not recorded)
- (For ~d McNamara)
(Parcel 1)
(Revised 3-20-91)
, " ~
":",' ,
.:1 ~hat part Q! ~he ~ortheast 1/4 of Section 36, Township 49 Sc~th,
{ange 25 East, Collier County, Florida, being more particularly
iescribed as follows;
:ommencing at "the northeast corner of said Section 36;
:hence along the east :ine of said Section 36 Soutn 00"-00'-36" East
730.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of the parcel herein
::.escr ibed;
thence cor.tinuing along the east line of said Section 36 South
00"-00'-36" East 570.29 feet to the northeast corner of that
parcel described in deed recorded in O.R. Book 1278, page 1207
and 1208, Collier County Public Records;
thence along the north line of said deed South S9"-21'-02" "est
591.04 feet;
t~ence North 00"-~l'-50. West 1.92 feet;
thence South 89"-21'-02" West 30.00 feet;
t~ence Ncrth 05"-21'-05" West 231.63 feet;
~~ence Horth 89"-21'-02" East 231.59 feet;
~ence Horth 00"-00'-21" West 136.20 feet;
~ence Horth 89"-e6'-30' East 425.00 feet to the Foint of
-~ginning of the parcel herein described;
sue ":. to easements for road purposes along the westerly and
sou ,rly 30.00 feet thereof, and subject to an easement for utility
pur: 3es along the northerly 10.00 feet of the northerly 425.00 feet
and ,ubject to an easement for drainage, utilitie~ and buffer st=ip
alo~~ the easterly 30.00 feet thereof;
=ontaining 7.43 acres af land more or less;
bear~ngs are based on the east line cf said Section 36 being South
00.-00'-36" East.
WILSON, MILLER, BARTON, SOLL & PEEK, INC.
Reg. engineers and Land Surveyors
EX~I3J:T
'In II
1_
AGENDA ITEM
No. J1 8
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 1/
VARIANCE PETITION
(VARIANCE FROM SETBACK{S)
REQUIRED FOR A PARTICULAR ZONING DISTRICT)
i
,
~~/~'~
)1."'"' . '-.. ' ,'-
; J ~,c~ ~'~::- ..~-
., -':';' , ,,-<
PETITION NO. ~ 'V 99- 0 1
DATE PETITION R CErvBD
, .;"
PROJECT PLANNER
G' Yv, Yv1 V"L
(ABOVE TO BE FILLED IN BY STAFF)
-------
--------
PETITIONER'S NAME Coastal Beverage, Ltd.
PETITIONER'S ADDRESS 4747 Progress Avenue, Naples, Florid 34104
TELEPHONE 941-643-4343
AGENT'S ADDRESS Richard D. Yovanovich, Goodlette, Coleman &
Johnson, P.A., 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300, Naples,
Florida 34103
TELEPHONE 941-435-3535
LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: LOT{S) BLOCK{S)
SUBDIVISION SECTION 36 TWP. 495 RANGE 25E
(If legal description is lengthy, i.e. metes & bounds
description, attach additional page) See Exhibit "An attached
hereto and incorporated herein.
CURRENT ZONING OF SUBJECT PROPERTY Industrial
EXISTING LAND USE ON SUBJECT PROPERTY Distributorship and
Warehouse
ADJACENT ZONING & LAND USE
N
S
E
W
ZONING
FPL Easement/Industrial
Progress Ave/Industrial
Livingston Road
Commercial Blvd/Industrial
LAND USE
Undeveloped
United Parcel Service
Right-of-way
Tamiami Ford
MINIMUM YARD REQUIREMENTS FOR SUBJECT PROPERTY
FRONT: 50 I
CORNER LOT: Yes
SIDE: Total for all
sides is 20% of lot, max 50'
REAR IS'
WATERFRONT LOT: No
AGENOA ITEM
No. 17 8
MAR 2 3 1999
pg.--'.L-
NATURE OF PETITION
Provide a detailed explanation of the request including what
structures are existing and what is proposed; the amount of
encroachment proposed using number, i.e. reduce front setback
from 251 to 181; when property owner purchased property; when
existing principal structure was built (include building per.mit
number if possible); why encroachment is necessary; how existing
encroachment came to be; etc.
The subject site is located on the Northwest corner of the
intersection of Progress Avenue and the future Livingston Road.
The existing facilities include a distributorship and warehouse
building and a parking lot. Coastal Beverage, Ltd. has owned the
property since August 2, 1991. The existing structure was
constructed on the property in February I, 1993.
A 17.8' variance is necessary to address a governmental taking
along the Eastern boundary of the site for additional right-of-
way and easements for the purpose of constructing Livingston
Road. The variance is necessary to accommodate future
construction on the site which was approved in SDP-92-27-C
A variance is requested from the currently required front yard
requirement along Future Livingston Road of 50 feet to be reduced
to 32.2 feet. The encroachment of the future construction came
about due to Collier County taking a portion of the subject site
for the construction of Livingston Road. The encroachment is not
due to any action of the applicant.
Please note that staff and the Collier County Planning Commission
shall be guided in their recommendation to the Board of Zoning
Appeals, and that the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be guided in
its deter.mination to approve or deny a variance petition by the
below listed criteria (1-6). (Please address this criteria using
additional pages if necessary.)
1. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing
which are peculiar to the location, size and characteristics
of the land, structure, or building involved.
At the time SDP-92-27-C was approved, it met all Collier
County set back requirements. However, due to the County's
eminent domain actions, the proposed development will not
conform with County setback requirements for that portion of
the site adjacent to Livingston Road. Accordingly, a
variance is needed.
AGENOA ITEM
No. /1 b
MAR 2 3 1999
Pt;;. J.3
2. Are there special conditions and circumstances which do not
result from the action of the applicant such as pre-existing
conditions relative to the property which is the subject of
the variance request.
In the event the variance is not granted, the subject site
will not accommodate the proposed future expansion on this
property and a new location for the distributorship and
warehouse must be obtained. The applicant will suffer
significant business damages and relocation expenses if the
variance is not granted.
3. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this
zoning code work unnecessary and undue hardship or create
practical difficulties on the applicant.
Absent the proposed taking initiated by Collier County,
there would be no need for the property owner to obtain the
variance and if the variance is not granted, relocate the
existing distributorship and warehouse to alternative
location.
4. Will the variance, if granted, be the minimum variance that
will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building
or structure and which promote standards of health, safety
or welfare.
The request for a variance is the minimum variance necessary
to enable the future expansions to be conforming structures.
The proposed variance does not expand upon the existing
approved improvements identified on SDP-92-27-C
5. Will granting the variance requested confer on the
petitioner any special privilege that is denied by these
zoning regulations to other lands, buildings, or structures
in the same zoning district.
Granting of this variance will not confer on the applicant
any special privileges, and will match other buildings and
structures in this same zoning district. Granting of this
variance will enable the applicant to continue to construct
approved improvements identified in SDP-92-27-C
AGENDA ITEM
No. 17 f:>
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. /4
6. Will granting the variance be in har.mony with the intent and
purpose of this zoning code, and not be injurious to the
neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public
welfare.
Granting of variance will be in harmony with the general
intent and purpose of the LDC and will not be injurious to
the neighborhood or detrimental to the public welfare.
Approval of this request will enable the distributorship and
warehouse to continue in operation in a manner contemplated
in SDP-92-27-C.
7. Are there natural conditions or physically induced
conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives of the
regulation such as natural preserves, lakes, golf course,
etc.
The variance request became necessary due to the County's
actions in regard to the construction of Livingston Road.
Accordingly, the setback requirements cannot be met.
8. Will granting the variance be consistent with the growth
management plan.
The subject property is designated industrial on the future
land use map of Collier County's growth management plan.
Distributorships and warehouses are permitted uses in this
land use designation; therefore, granting this request will
be consistent with the Growth management plan.
MaENDA ITEM
No. /1 f3
MAR 2 3 1999
Pi. IS
AFFIDAVIT
I, Ed McNamara, being first duly sworn, depose and say that I am
the owner of the property described herein and which is the
subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to
the questions in this application, and all sketches, data, and
other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this
application are honest and true to the best of my knowledge and
belief. I understand this application must be completed and
accurate before a hearing can be advertised. I further permit
Richard D. Yovanovich, Esq. to act as my representative in any
matters regarding this Petition.. ,~
fi/; /), ". '
~-:c~-,,;-;r /~-- ~~~Z;,-:C-<c'(
SIGNATURE OF OWNER
State of Florida
County of Collier
The foregoing Agreement ~eet was
J.ls+ day of Nov{~I!I~If'1 'g by Ed
known to me or who has produced
and who did (did not) take an oath.
t~.9 ~
(Sig ature of Notary
acknowledged before me this
McNamara, who is personally
as identification
Public)
#''j.:..:.... Betty Jo Brown
... ~... My ComrTll$$iOn CC700701
\'" ,:,,1 EXpires January 22, 2002
JeH<! J; ~l61LJAJ
NOTARY PUBLIC
Commission # efl.. 7M76)
My Commission Expires: 1-~~-~2..
-1~L -" \'0 () ~
SIGNATURE OF AGENT
State of Florida
County of Collier
The foregoing A~reemen~_Sheet was acknowledged before
~Nf) ,,",C~r;j;'"l L'-\"\
~ day of NOvem ~r; 1998 by Richard D. Yovanovich,
is personally known to me or who has produced
identification and who did (did ot) take an 0
me this
Esq., who
as
Public)
\\\,,11 II 1/IIIIIl
~\\\\\ 'i;\.. C, FRI. IIII~
~~r:.Y' ........ s...y....~
~.. -. <:~ ~
~ .- ",!,\SSION Cl,... ~
~ . ~~. 8 -'t..z .. ~
::: : c..; ~'-~ ,79,9, ~ \ ~
i ;~"S ~ cP~*E
=*: ... :<:
~~~ ICC473102 :~~
~~... J; 8cna""'~'~ ",."~i
:i'- '...n . ro ~ ~~. /'V ....
~; TrA'..'Y f.m.\r.li'V .'~'X"-"'~
,..~ 'I, ........ ~ '" ~....
'/II,<JBOC s,p."\... \\\,'\:
"'IIII"!t!t\\\"~
RACHEL C. FRISHE
NOTARY PUBLIC
Commission #
My Commission
AGENDA ITEM
E:x bire~: J1~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
,-.-
PETITION V AC 99-004 TO VACATE THE 25' WIDE DRAINAGE EASEMENT ON LOT 4,
THE 25' WIDE DRAINAGE EASEMENT ON LOT 5 AND THE REMAINING 12' WIDE
DRAINAGE EASEMENT ON TRACT A, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT OF "QUAIL CREEK
PLAZA PHASE 1" AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK IS, PAGE 73, PUBLIC RECORDS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, LOCATED IN SECTION 20, TOWNSIDP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST.
OBJECTIVE: To adopt a Resolution to vacate the above described Drainage Easements.
CONSIDERA TIONS: Petition V AC 99.004 has been received by Planning Services from Robert S.
Hardy, as agent for the petitioners, Joseph D']amoos and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A., requesting the
vacation of the above-described Drainage Easements to accommodate future construction improvements. AIl
of the platted Drainage Easement on Tract A (except for the abovementioned 12' wide portion) has been
previously vacated by Resolution 91-782 Letters of no objection have been received from all pertinent users
and agencies. Zoning is P.U,D.
FISCAL IMPACT: Planning Services has collected a $1,000 "Petition to Vacate" fee from the
petitioners, which will be deposited in Fund 113-13890.03291. This fee covers advertising, recording and
other processing costs, -
,,-
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners:
1. Adopt the Resolution for Petition V AC 99-004 for the vacation of the above-described Drainage
Easements, and
2. Authorize the execution of the Resolution by its Chainnan and direct the Clerk to the Board to record a
certified copy of the Resolution in the Official Records; and
3, Request the Clerk to the Board to make appropriate marginal notes on the recorded plat.
.-
PREPARED BY: J-;:-:"', ~~. ,/ c~~'~/('--"';"'L::-7'"
Rick Grigg, P.S,M.
Planning Services
REVIEWED BY: ~A. ~ ~
Thomas E. Kuck, P.E.
Engineering Review Manager
REVIEWED BY: ...//::-:- ______
f Robert Mulhere, AICP
Planninfl,services Department Director
~~
APPROVED BY:' - 0 -
ncent A. Cautero, AICP, Clministrator
Community Development & Environmental Services
DATE: ~~-..J -9--7
DATE: ,3-2- 9Cf
DATE: J - -; --7" f"
DATE:
AGENDA ITEM
/1C-
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. I
.-
1 RESOLUTION NO. 99-_
')
...
3 PETITION VAC 99-004 TO VACATE THE 25' WIDE DRAINAGE EASEMENT ON LOT 4,
4 THE 25' WIDE DRAINAGE EASEMEJ\1T ON LOT 5 AND THE REMAINING 12' WIDE
5 DRAINAGE EASEMENT ON TRACT A. ACCORDING TO THE PLAT OF "QUAIL
6 CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1" AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 15, PAGE 73. PUBLIC
7 RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, LOCATED IN SECTION 20, TOWNSHIP 48
8 SOlITH, RANGE 26 EAST.
9
10
11 WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 177,10 I, Florida Statutes, Robert S, Hardy, as agent for the petitioners, Joseph D'Jamoos
12 and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A., does hereby request the vacation of the 25' wide Drainage Easement on Lot 4, the 25' wide
13 drainage easement on Lot 5 and the remaining 12' wide Drainage Easement on Tract A, according to the plat of "Quail Creek Plaza
14 Phase 1" as recorded in Plat Book 15, Page 73. Public Records of Collier Countv, located in Section 20. Township 48 South, Range
15 26 East and
16
1 7 WHEREAS, the Board has this day held a public hearing to consider vacating said Drainage Easements as more fully
18 described below, and notice of said public hearing to vacate was given as required by law; and
WHEREAS, the granting of the vacation will not adversely atfect the o\\-nership or right of convenient access of other
_ J property OMlers.
21 NOW, TIIEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY TIIE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER
22 COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the follo'Wing be and is hereby vacated:
23 See Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein.
24 BE IT FURTIIER RESOLVED, that the Clerk to the Board is hereby directed to record a certified copy of this
2S Resolution in the Official Records of Collier County, Florida, and to make proper notation of this vacation on the recorded plat as
26 referenced above.
27 This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote favoring same.
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
.-18
DATED:
AITEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY:
PAMELA S, MAC'KIE, Chairwoman
Approved as to form and legal
sufficiency:
"'"\
o
0\. .
AGENDA ITEM
No. I 7 c..
MAR 2 3 1999
~
Pg.
Heidi F, Ashton
Assistant County Attorney
, ,wll i
Ir8!81'
- "'I'"
VONN
6, I
wi,.
~ ~ Co <01
OJ ~ ~- ....
<(u(J')'cn
...... l.U po.
W ~ <Xl'" 0,1'
~o <Xl
~ Zvo
, !
I~ ~I~!
I
1
o
'"
W
-l
<l: 0
l) '"
rJ}
l) 0
...
:r:
0...
<l:
e::
()
o
'"
z
w
CO
<(
w eLl""")
::: r--
a: <(
QU':;:e>
wt--Ja...
> UQ "
~~ U"l
::>0::"'-
v..-w
~ ~ro
w uCl
ti
io)
r..
!
-
tX::J)..'.
;:;'
6
=:'-
"0 ~l
- 0 ",----1
.....J
, i
'"
.-
l-
Ll
<l:<l:
0::
I-
1
j",...,
o
,10'>
o
'"
,
'<t
l"g,
gl
I-
o
.....J
i'" ,
I~ :
\ \
\ \
\ ~
\\.o'~ -
\..,~ 0 ...~.
\'f.."~-..J
...
, \
\ \
, \
\ '
2
~
:::
-'>
00 o.z: ~ .:O,l;oO.,O S
3 "Zt,O<;.OO S
,OO'OLZ
,OO"OLl
M ,,It,O<;.OO N
OOOl(: M ..Z;.,o<;.oo N
00 Cl: M ~':~.C~.;)\) N
00 Ol~ '" .~'.O."OO N
<;6\:9' M .~'.O<;"OO N
",,", :r:.
<.
il::(:~
c(-JW
Nil.
5~?J
~8~
~~~
"'OU
U~~
;ia::!d
a8~
."."5c..
g:~
a~~
~....~
~ ~~t5.
E 8i?~~
5 ~~~~
~ ......c.l.-
o ~~~>'
;i wt:~z
~ ~~~8
'31
'"
.,.
~
I I':
'0
10 i
r
V"
...
>
e;
~
'"
~
~,
".,
..
'" .
2~
....u
u'"
10]'"
~~
V>."
>-z
_0
"''''
w'"'
~iX
"'~
a..~,'
VI '"
~5
!:' 1
'"'~
0~
<:::l '
~~ ~I~
.."I fi _
~c .n::
.,.~ ~I::l
0::: ~:<
; ; -l!~
~w ~ ~
e:<_t;~
:s.~ .::s1....
~;;. .~'I
........... >-
ru Ol
*
>-
w
>
0::
::)
I (/)
\ I 4:
1
I l-
I 0
I"", Z
<<l
'" *
R
,
"'"
~'I
~I
'"
~l
I- l/"i I
Zw
:i'~!
~ CL I
<( "
Wl"'ll,
w:2 I
c;-
~:.: I
.;;' C;; I
:Las
,.J c
~ .~O:: i
.;:s - c ,
. I
H
:::
-
l~
a
::1
" .
181
gl
i -~
; ~l
I ~
I i
:-' i
;"81\
p".,
"''"'
"' ,
z
<(
"'~
,,~
~::s
~'"
V>~
a.'"
N -
0 C."
<.D iii
CO "'
en
z
o
f-
a..
0::
()
(()
w
o
--l
<:
<..:>
w
--l
<:
u....
o
:z:
u
f-
W
~
(()
~~~~!
~.c=<i52~ .
~!:~~~
3~~.oc;i
~~~~~i
-1.0./ ~~...
~~~~~
(/)
W
f-
~
U
o
(/)
(/)
4:
~
~:
lQ~-
~~:
,",VI
~~~
"'~-
U"li~
Ig~
.I{S::QI~
~v.:
z:3~
if) :5~f
~ ~~;
Z '~~
o gz"'" ~
:::!:~q
~(/):
'-''"''
z-'';
L..l~~
z!
z
W
--l
o
~1
:1C
-~
ZW
_"'-lCli
:z~<
w.....w
2 V">
w"tw (0
~w~ ;~~~
wt)~ o:::'o~
;>-<(w
!~~~~ r; ~
'" . ~~~~~
W Wl.&..J <::Jl; (;:,......1
-J)=-~ ~ ~ ~
Exhibit "A"
Sheet I of 3
V AC 99-004
~
o
AGENDA ITEM
No. /7C.
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ..3
o
..
t::l
.....
<t 0
U ..,
if)
u 0
-
......
.....
0..
<t
IY
......
o
o
..
z
f-
01,{)
--1
.
:3\
i8i
l:g .
i i
+
I
...J
U1
<<
'> ~
ii <{ lo,..,i f-
oU~l) IC <..>
<! <!
w- ~ i8' c::
>u;:;-'
.= ~ ...... -. " f-
::>O::~-
'"-} -......
x ~c:: ':;C
'-' - I'ro
4 i';; I
is [PI
,0>
'<0,
iV'll
. I
1
!-
c.:I
c.:I
to.
~
:::
00
II
r
0'\7
-
~.:.:.
I i
~ ,,~..... 7(;,0: ;::
.00 0 ~;:
'"
~
~
3 ..W..t>O.~O S G,
,OO'O~Z
.OO'O~Z
M "W,vO. ~o N
C<:', o~::-
.~t" c;.CC) s
." ..,
0: co
::s ~
0...:;:(5 cO 00__
Z N"-
<:......(".) Q >D
",Cl Ul~
::zc ...0
<{
':"'-l./l > :;:E' ~
c::
fS~~ w Vl""
Vl ClVl
~~O w
5o~ 0: t
~x vi N
-'W .....
<a:~ .....
z ~~
"'''--- w
OOID ...
"'''' ;;:;
~5a. '" t.ri
..,
~I'" '" . ~~
o~a: Co
-'~ =.3 "';:::
uoO.
,,-",,"- ON
0--0 VlO:
Q. :..)':::!
'" '....- VlO j!
~~r--. ~~ ""=
z ...-'" 0:; - :::l;
0 oo~q:' VI,/) z<<
;::: <{
Q. 0-0...9 rZ "- :::l;
0: "')o-B _0 r;o Vl
" ;:::
U ("\,jz<C........J wu ;:~ ~
Vl _6 ....... co.- ~~
'" l/'lct:..o . o:;!: 0<<
0 !iEo_r I>:Vl :1 c'
-' t;~z co...., ;;:
<< Vll>: W.=
<.:> ~<85 --I>:
w II>: OW ,..
---mu _0 =u tD
l~
81
""
"I
i
~
I~i
i"'i I I
i~,.oi.c, b
1<( 0 0,
~ U"lU"l Z
Vl",,,-,
I 16 *
, I , ,
i I jWI~
wlzr'l,
_,O,aJ a)
m:-'>-!-
<( I c'I' 0",. 0CO",
:i~ ~I~l
~ I o! rol CO!
i 2: (fl'
~ ,
C
". :
"-' ,
-
" ~I
"-'
~ U1 6!
~
:::; << :"
, ^
< ~ ?;
- ~ ,
...J '"' OJI
CJ - '0-'
<<
~ '" I "'I
0 I I C'
. ,
<< 0 , '::1"1;
~ CD IX)
::; c:: ,(.,-;
'"
;;: - '-
~
I~ =!~I
1-' \. .
: !
o
Ul
r,
:::
!- -
-r-
1
z
w
~::;
Zw
~w(fl
Z::!<<
:.....;ww
~~W
l./lwU
<< Z
w...J<<
CJz
"'<<w
~Z~
~'02~. ~
Z::JO::;
t::IWWW
..J::JO::;
N
o
<.0
CO
0'>
u
"'
~
Exhibit "A"
Z Sheet 2 of 3
o V AC 99..()()4
f-
a..
Cl:::
U
(/)
L..J
Cl
*
:;iS~~
g.~5:l;a:
~~~S~....
Jt~"",""~8:
C4::cVl~
~~~~~Q
....,o.....x~
~~!~~
~
w
>
a::
:::J
V1
<
(/):
wi 0
f-' "'::
~ I~~-
U I~~:
0"''''
V1' ~ 'I( =
V1i~~~
<II g~
c1d!~I~
i~~ ~
(/)I~~!
Wio:'~ ~
f- . .
Z I ~ ~
Ol~"- ::
:::E:::; I!!'
~t/)~
L'>WX
... Z -I ';
~ I~~;
o :
~'
:Ie
w O'l I.oJ (To
.... C\ - 0>
00(,<........
ONOr\o
.
'"
~ ~
'" "
25
o
z
~ L'>
~ Z
- ;;
"
'"
"
-l
<:
<..?
w
-l
<:
u...
o
:I:
U
f-
W
~
(/)
AGENO'" ITEM
No. /7 c.
MAR 2 3 1999
Pli. Lf
~~~:J~
0
'"
W
.....J
<t: 0
() '"
rn
() 0
....
::c
p.,
<t:
0::
()
0
'"
z
w
1I1
<<
w ctf"'i
> '"
C2 <::
DU~<..J
wl--.-lo...
:> U CL. .
;::::<. ..r1
=:>lr"'-
U....UJ
~ ~~
UJ Un.
f-o
l>l
c.l
10.
~
-
~
<i <<
vi ::;@U
l/) 3: U ~O!;
ooi_>-"O << @
~~~~ g; ::.::..... ~.
8,..:~ :DO
<,......0..... 0 "'~
~~Ulfi <' tO~, ""-
V1 z- 0,
..,.J,...,,..,....<( lr6,;,j ~8
::.~~O :5 OUZ ::;w
::::.::~....JL...J za:2
~gso~ ..... VI....
w -~O:::: <<
~uuu w co-'<< ,,--
U~u...Vl "- N VI
~c5cn '"
::::lJ)o(5 N ....
~<~>- N g~~ U;.
O~~~ ~ u O~' ';co t
W..,.-.J
=> a:: r-...~ -'
L&..wu5 0 viz
oa::w~ l/) Vl:r . ;:'0
c(WO::.u <{~;:
:c - w Z~~ <(;::
.....U.... ;: U":
..... -0:: c.,O -J
U""",,.....Je{ ;:::$~ 0'::'
<l:<l:<Da. "- VI", ~Ii
0::-'::> 0 u-.;.: VlO
t-Q..Q..W 5N~ <l::r
z ,0:: ..... oS *I~
t....I.iJI"")O w ~~o
0 o~r--.~ w :i""
;::: "- ON""
::; 0.. ~Ot5D e:: ....
N -.JV\<< L10
C2 e{~<~ <<we.. 'u Ji
":! U a..c.:>o..~ lOlOw -UJ
l/) ..... w<l:O:: Z....
w ....Z ' -'0..0.. 0<<
CO <( _ Ul a 0:: :::;>2
0 :rO-<( 0
...J ~~~~ Z ....
-U) <l: w yji=
'-' ...JUOO W ..... -'Cl<
N W ...JUO-l ~ 0 Ow >-
-' <[<(COl4 'z :CU ell
I -0 ~...,---1 - -
r-' 1 \
I ....J
000\: t::l "O..C n:
,.,
'",
'0
C
,
".
*
>-
W
>
0:::
~, ;:)
~ U'1
N ~\
N 4:
0
"'("l
N.-J .-J I-
-Cfl 0
Zw
Wo '", Z
::;<::
trio.. OJ
'" *
<( , ~
UJ"-' I
..-,
W'"'
0-
~ ,*.
<;:6
::; 2?5aJ
~ it:
:::0
.::
c
~
U
<(<(
a::
~
I
<i
<5
.,
0,
Ig :
I
.....
Z
w
....::;
zw
....wll1
z::;<<
~u...lW
:E v'"';
w<(w
lI1WU
<< Z
wt5~
>-<w
....z....
~..2.~~
z::>O::;
"'WuJW
.-J::>o::;
=
c
L
I
~
i
'0 I ~
~l 0
-l
---..---
000.: "" .:'..os.oo N
\~\
\ '
\~
\ '
'.'o't> .....
\""'B 0 ,...,
\~'o _'
\ ....%-
\ \\
000\': M.i: ~ .O~.QC t~
0'
01
~l
, I
I~:
I
I
,
~ I
." ,
- 0'
'~~I'
",...
'"
z I
I '
I I
,OOO~l No. ~l,.o~.OO N
<;& ,9, '" _,..0..00 N
N
o
tJ)
00
O'l
z
a
~
0..
0::
U
(/)
w
Cl
-l
<l:
<.::l
w
-l
<l:
L..-
a
:c
u
~
w
~
Vl
s~~a~
~";CCiC.ai
~~::~~~
~~~4I:~:I
~~~:S~i
_ -'"",4
i~~~~
(/)i
W
~ t/l~
<l:1t/l~:
u l'~~;
a wt/l
(/) ~:::::
U'1 t/l,,:
-< 19;;
~lQd
~~;
U1i~~i
l.U o:~~
)- """" ~
Z I ~i
o lQ"':::
~ i I ~
-"'.
..! ~~ ~
~!~~ ;
o ;
~'
~c
WIOl...JlO
~~<~
o ~ 0;::'
~
.,
i ~
. "
'"
a
~ 0
., z
:> "
a i
..
'"
c
z
Exhibit "An
Sheet 3 of 3
V AC 99-004
AGENDA ITEM
No. 17C.
MAR 2 3 1999
S-
Pg.
'IO.":'~',~;
16Al
(i)
Attachment "B"
PETITION FORM FOR VACATION OF PLATS OR PORTIONS
OF PLATS OF SUBDIVIDED LAND
Date Received: FE?'). /8 ,qqq
,
Petition #: \/ AC :-lq - 00+
Petitioner:
,Ioint" Pp.t";t"innp.T'!': -- SAA At.t.Rchment "1"
Address:
City/State:
Telephone:
Zip Code:
Agent:
Address:
City/State:
Robert S. Hardy
10641 Airport Road North, Suite 32
Naples, FL
Telephone: 593-3883
Zip Code: 34109
Address of Subject Propqty:Quail Creek Plaza Phase I (N. Side of 1mmokalee Rd I E of 1-75)
Location: Section 20 Township 48S Range 26# SubdivisionQuail Creek Plaza Phase I
Legal Description: Lot 4,5 Block N/ A Unit N/ A Plat Book 15 Page(s) 73
e easement no Ion
ralnage easemen a u lng
Does this affect density?
due to vacation of a
Current Zoning:
I hereby authorize Agent above to represent me for this petition: 0 Yes 0 No
Joint Petitioners -- See Attachment
Signature of Petitioner
c
~
.-
Date
(Title)
I'
H-
e
w.
>-t
C;
Print Name
Please see "Policy and Procedure for the Vacation and Annulment of Plats or Portions of Plats of
Subdivided Land" for the list of supportive materials which must accompany this petition, and deliver or
mail to:
t'-.
C
c:
..c::
Community Development & Environmental Services Division
Planning Services Department
2800 North Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, Florida 34104
(1)
(2)
Attachment "B"
Page 4 of 4
If applicant is a land trust, indicate the name of beneficiaries.
If applicant is a corporation other than a public corporation, indicate the name of officers and
major stockholders.
If applicant is a partnership, limited partnership or other business entity, indicate the name of
principals. AGENDA ITEM
List all other owners. No. / 1 c..
MAR 2 3 1999
~
Pg.
..--
(3)
(4)
ATTACHMENT "1" TO ATTACHMENT "B"
VRC '1'9-004
PETITION FORM FOR VACATION OF PLATS
OR PORTIONS OF PLATS OF SUBDIVIDED LAND
Petitioner:
Address:
City/State:
Joseph D'Jamoos
13356 Rosewood Lane
Naples, FL
Telephone: 290-7900
Zip Code: 34119
Petitioner:
Address:
City/State:
First Anesthesia Associates, P.A.
860 l11th Avenue North
Naples, FL
Telephone:
Zip Code: 34108
Signatures of Petitioners:
~
4(Obert S. Hardy as Agen and
Attorney-In-Fact for
Joseph D'Jamoos, Owner
U
Date
I 7/ t~
I /
~SSOCIATES' PA
, ~
Robert S. Hardy as Agent an
Attorney-in-Fact for
J.M. Campoamor, President
U 7/'1'
Date
"'GENOA ITEM
No. /1 C
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 1
QBNAP\173247,l
Ii'
\!{J
16AI
Attachment "C"
PETITION FORM FOR THE EXTINGUISHMENT OF PUBLIC
DEDICA TED EASEMENTS RECORDED BY SEP ARA TE INSTRUMENT IN
THE PUBLIC RECORDS (OTHER THAN ON A SUBDIVISION PLAT) ON PLATTED
OR UNPLA TIED LAND, EXCEPT FOR PUBLIC ROADS
Date Received: 1= E F.""). ! f3 ,
J9q.'?
Petition #: V He
,., .'-J ~
.... /. - /') 1")4-
Petitioner (Owner):
Address:
City/State:
,lnint: PRt:it:ioners -- See Attachment "1"
Telephone:
Zip Code:
Agent:
Address:
City/State:
RobRrt: S. H<'lrdy
10641 Airport Road North, Suite 32
NnplR!,;, FL
Telephone: 593-3883
Zip Code: 34109
Location of Subject Property: Quail Creek Plaza Phase I, Tract A
Township 48S
Range 26E
Location: Section 20
Official Record Book 1633 Page (s) 2402 Current Zoning: PUD Does this affect density? No
Legal Description: North 12 feet of the South 22 feet of Tract A of Quail Creek Plaza
Phase I, Plat Book 15, Page 32, Collier County, Florida
Reason for Request:Dr&lim'lge e&l5e~ent no lonCJE'r n€rp<:;C::::lry nr IIc::pflll hp.r::lIIC::p. ::lhllt:t:i no r1 ::ltte(
t=1::1c:t=lm,:::3nr \I~r:::1t:prl
I hereby authorize Agent above to represent me for this petition: 0 Yes 0 No
Joint Petitioners -- See Attachment
Signature of Petitioner Date
Print Name (Title)
Please see "Policy and Procedure for the Extinguishment of Public Easements by Separate Instrument" for
the list of supportive materials which must accompany this petition, and deliver or mail to:
Community Development & Environmental Services Division
Planning Services Department
2800 North Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, Florida 34104
(1) If applicant is a land trust, indicate the name of beneficiaries.
(2) If applicant is a corporation other than a public corporation, indicate the name of officers and
major stockholders.
.--. (3) If applicant is a partnership, limited partnership or other business entity, ind ate ~EiM
principals. No. /7 C.
(4) List all other owners.
MAR 2 3 1999
Attachment "e"
Page 4 of 4
Pg.
~
ATTACHMENT "1" TO ATTACHMENT "C"
V4C ,q';/-OQ~1-
PETITION FORM FOR THE EXTINGUISHMENT OF PUBLIC DEDICATED
EASEMENTS RECORDED BY SEPARATE INSTRUMENT IN THE PUBLIC
RECORDS (OTHER THAN ON A SUBDIVISION PLAT) ON PLATTED
OR UNPLATTED LAND, EXCEPT FOR PUBLIC ROADS
Petitioner:
Address:
City/State:
Joseph O'Jamoos
13356 Rosewood Lane
Naples, FL
Telephone: 290-7900
Zip Code: 34119
Petitioner:
Address:
City/State:
First Anesthesia Associates, P.A.
860 111th Avenue North
Naples, FL
Telephone:
Zip Code: 34108
Robert S. Hardy as Ag t and
Attorney-In-Fact for
Joseph O'Jamoos, Owner
k ~'/f'
Date (
FIRST ANESTHESIA ASSOCIATES, P.A.
~/I/?f
Date / '
Robert S. Hardy as Agen and
Attorney-in-Fact for
J.M. Campoamor, President
.,..-~
QBNAP\173247.2
AGENDA ITEM
No. I 7 ~
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. q
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
Trans Number
117341
Date Post Date
02/19/199912:01:15 PM 02/19/1999
Nbr
NAPLES ROAD BUILDING CORPORATION
New or Exist: N
Payor: NAPALES RD BUILDING CORP
Fee Information
GL Account
11313890032910000000
Total
Amount Waived
$1000.00
$1000.00
Payments
Pa ment Code
CHECK
Account/Check Number
0006156
Total Paid
Amount
$1000.00
$0.00 I
$1000.00
$1000.00 I
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
Memo:
V AC 99-004
CK #6156
Cashierllocation: TERILLA_J 1 1
User: KIRK_D
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1 C
MAR 2 3 1999
/0
Pg.
Printed:02l19/1999 12:01 :52 PM
'.;!":
BLE
'j'.'
.,<:
{; '\0
'f~:.
..J3:.'."
Ii.
.!.iA
E,!4~SW. ?~,
},';t"&\~;~'
OPERTY ID '"
""UDESCYi: UAIL CREEK PLAZA
.wu. . .,.., T SE CNR LOT 4, S
fT, N 71FT TO POB,
CONTINUED (PER TAX
".
';!..
'~:
i t
',~._f, "...../ .1"I1?~
.' V H:::' ere; - ~O..~
~- ~ ----.--.,..- -~--_..--- ---'-.' n-.---""-'-.---~._---___nU...Ll.tAlt.
199~ C6LLIER COUNTY NOTICE Of AD VALOREM TAXES AND NON-AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
COUNT EA~NED 4% IN NOV 3% IN DEe 2% 1~ JAN-- ~% IN FEB 0% IN MAR
OUNT>:DUE 1,180.10 1,192.39 //1,204.68 ~ 1,216.96 1,,229~
i',i. ,-" VAlUE MILL RATE AMOUNT AUTHORITY # _~- PAY IN U.S. fUNDS TO:'
SSED 3 . 5923 '30 0 A.D.lI~OREM TAXES 5
U ~ COLLIER COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR "
5 . 9 0 4 0 4 9 3 . 1 4 COUNTY 1
2 . 6060 21 -? 6 ( SCHOOL - STATE 1 COURTHOUSE COMPLEX. BUILDING C-1
. , SCHOOL . LOCAL NAPLES, FLORIDA 34112.4997 "
CITY "
. 8082 6 7 . 5 n DEPENDENT 23 MILL CODE 96 ESCROW CODE
.5620 46.94 WATERMGT,
1 . 1953 9 c1 . 8 \.1 INDfP, SPECIAL 3
.0495 Y.13 0 Y
14 . 7173 1 .. 229 . 27 V TER APPR. DfBT. 19
'."
.' ..,,'., ~.:,.:~
QUAIL PL.AZA INC
4500 EXECUTIVE DR
NAPLES FL 34119-8939
RATE
PER
NON,AO VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
ROADS
WATER/SEWER
COMM, IMPROVE.
GARBAGE
:r.,229;.2?
......
8t.1DEG W 18
S &9DEG W
ROLL-PAGE
COMBINED TO'
-,;: , ,;.,:. L\,.j't I.
1.:.' ~ !..,t :~g,>~i ~;(((i j ~.i~
~. !.)' '~:,:i:Jj "l,g (~t-'~ i'l
b I i-O.l, f):A/ N.t! l
9500)
Gt).. L.. Ctlf..; '1(1;1
!.:.:::~.....J i';. ~';)I,q.'!J)
p,.{~~ (..I) ·
'~-~':)," .\ "
r /"" (;,~u.I::l)'l'l)li
" _l'{ -,
...
sseD
000006&815031154 0000122927 0000000000 00000
)." ,'.....~ _.1
SEt RIYIBSE -2!!lEfDR~~~nON - - - -- -- --~- -- -... -- ,,- - __11lISAREA ~ll!rE~~'~T ;]-,
,,.-' ---~-------- .---.----- -.-, ,,- ------......-L.----IJ'Ui..t:::rtp,I'~ ~...
199 a'; CO L LIE Reo U N T Y NOT ICE 0 FAD V t\ LOR E "I T A ',: E SAN 1) ~i 0 r! - A D V A LOR E MAS S E SSM E N T S
COUNT EARNED 4% IN NOV 3% IN tEe 2% IN JAN 1% IN fES 0% IN MAR
, ../
aUNT DUE 1,928.57 1,948.66 1,Q68.75) 1,988.642,008~
, VALUE MILL RATE AMOUNT AUTHORITY . # ../
3. 5923 1190AD~~OREMTAXES '----s--/
5 9 U 4 0 e; n c : ~ ~ COUNTY 1
2 : 606 OJ S 5 . -i l~: ~~~~~~ : ~~~~~ 1.
~ CITY
.8082 110.jr' OEPENOENT
.5620 7b. 72 WATERMGT.
1.195:= 16 '3. 1b INOEP. SPECIAL
. 0495 b . 7 b VOTER APPR. DEBT,
14.7173 2,008.93
BLE
136,500
COLLIER COUNTY TAX COLLECTOR
COURTHOUSE COMPLEX . BUILDING C.1
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34112-4997
::1 MILL CODE 98 ESCROW CODE .
2
3 HARDY, ROBERT S
4 6289 BURNHAM RD
19 NAPLES FL 34119-8407
RATE PER
NON.AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
ROAOS
WATER/SEWER
COMM. IMPROVE,
2 , 0 D t\ . 9 '1 GARBAGE COMBINED TOTAL
._,),::'~i,': :,., i'l l,~.rl ~\ ....\
!I' ~.. !~;' /,!,:, l'..n:{ ';. -HHJ
~i,~"G /5 CK r p~n-X-~0
'~, >
UAIL CREEK PLAZA
OT 5 OR 1651 PG 2103
: I I l~. ' . ...., Ii.; _ :' "" i\~
",:.t,. :.: ~,','kn; .Ii'.' (:','LI.~(n(lR
0000068815031400 UD002GlJ f:, 'I:, UO LJ lJ lJ 0 O(] (] u
.SEE ~~ERg SIDE. FOR!..URT~ER INF~TIO~____ __ __ _
[j-' , ' ,.' '" [J AGENDA ITEM
.J..lt~ 11 C
THIS AREA FOR TAX COLLECTOR'S OF ICE usrttm' ., .'. - ,- .'
---!'..J...!..!J..' ""'''...A.!'I!.c::.-.-
- -- --. n_ - --;~ - -. - MAR-2? 1999
pg. ~/
02/09/1999 11:24
9414340953
STERLING TITLE
PAGE 04
,?~c, ''1C>~'"
. . ,
~ ....~' D
I ~.' ~ ..._
, ,
This instrument prepared by and
after recording retum to:
2421793 OR: 2502 PG: 3230
IJCORDKD in OFFICIAL RlcalDS of COLLIJR COUN1Y, 'L
01/15/99 at 04:58PR DWIGH' I. BROCI, CLiRK
eOls 2391'0.00
RJC FIB 10.50
DOC-,10 1614.40
leo'. Salvatori, Esquire
Quarles & Brady LLP
4501 Tamiami Trat! Norrh
Suite 300
Naples. Florida 34 1 03
RetD:
STIRLING TI7L1
5121 CASTILLO DR 13
KAPLIS lL HI03
'-I ;:.;c. qj - CCJ4-
WARRANTY DEED
This Indenture, made this t -r,1 day of January, 1999, between, ROBERT S. HARDY,
GRANTOR, and JOSEPH D'JAMOOS, whose social security number is
, and whose post office address is 13356 Rosewood
Lane, Naples, FL~3-4l19 , GRANTEE.
Witnesseth that said Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN DOLLARS,
and other good and valuable consideration, to said Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee, the
receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bargained and sold to the said Grantee
and Grantee's heirs and assigns forever, the following described land, situate, lying and being
in Collier County, Florida.
The easterly 58 feet of Tract A, and aU of Lot 5, Quail Creek Plaza, Phase I,
according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 15, page 73, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida.
Subject to easements and restrictions common to the subdivision; oil, gas and
mineral rights of record; and real estate taxes for the year 1999, and all
subsequent years, being a portion of the property bearing Property Identification
Numbers 68815031400 (Lot 5) and 68815000509 (Tract A).
Grantor warrants by execution hereof that the subject properties are vacant land and do not
constitute his homestead property, nor are they contiguous thereto.
and said Grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same
against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever.
AGENDA ITEM
No. 17C.
QBNAP\USlUSl .1
MAR 2 3 1999
/~
Pg.
FEE 139 1999 113:25
94143413953
PAGE. 134
02/09/1999 11:24
9414340953
STERLING TITLE
PAGE 05
t** OR: 2502 PG: 3231 ***
In Witness Whereof, the Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day and
year first above written.
Pri nted Name
(tZ~ t?~
~ness ~
TR V A. $Mtnt
Printed name
~~
10641 Airport Pulling Road N., #32
Naples, Fl 34109
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF COLLIER
~ The foregoing instrument was acknowledged b re me this ~ o--~ay of'-ro..w..o."'~ '
1996, by Robert S. Hardy, who is personally kno n t e. '
Name of Notary, Printed, Typed or Stamped
My Commission Expires:
G), LEO J. 8Al..VATOAI
. "" wv CXltMISSlON I cc 5lIOll64
- DCPIN8; ~ 28. 2000 .
. ., ~ '""" MolIry I'IMll LRIINrIIllI
AGENDA ITEM
No. 11 C.
MAR 2 3 1~~9
Pg. /3
QBNAP\lUU9.1
FEE 09 1999 10:25
9414340953 PRGE.05
02/09/1999 11:24
9414340953
STERLING TITLE PAGE 02
2421794 OR: 2502 PG: 3232
RJCORDJD in OPP1C1AL R!CORDS of COLL1!R COUITY, 'L
01/15/99 at 04:58PK DWIGHT B. BRoCt, CtlRl
COMS 506250.00
KIC !II 10.50
DOC-.10 3544.10
I'
S-c (,..{ ~.'(' ..'
. .
" ~:'",I'; /,"
-' ~"'D
/c-
This instrument prepared by and
after recording return to:
Leo). Salvatori. Esquire
Quarles & Brady llP
4501 Tamiami Trail North
Suile 300
Naples, Florida 34103
Retn:
S'lIRLIIIG 'ITLI
5121 CAS!ILLO DR t3
RAPLIS PL Hi03
WARRANTY DEED
This Indenture, made this 5th day of January, 1999, between ROBERT S. Hardy,
GRANTOR, and FIRST ANESTHESIA ASSOCIATES, P.A., a Florida Professional Association,
whose tax identjfication number is , and whose post office address
is 860 111th Avenue North, #3, Naples, FL 34108, GRANTEE.
Witnesseth that said Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN DOLLARS,
and other good and valuable consideration, to said Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee. the
receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bargained and sold to the said Grantee
and Grantee's heirs and assigns forever, the following described land, situate, lying and being
in Collier County, Florida.
Lot 4, QUAIL CREEK PlAZA, PHASE I, according to the plat thereof recorded
in Plat Book 15, page 73, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, less
and excepting the Westerly 42 feet thereof; and Tract A, QUAtl CREEK
PLAZA, PHASE I, according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Bonk 15,
page 73, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, less and excepting
the Easterly 58 feet thereof.
Subject to easements and restrictions common to the subdivision; oil, gas and
mineral rights of record; and real estate taxes for the year 1999, and all
subsequent years, being a portion of the property bearing Property Identification
Number 68815031154 (Lot 4) and 68815000509 (Tract A).
Grantor warrants by execution hereof that the subject properties are vacant land and do not
constitute his homestead property, nor are they contiguous thereto.
and said Grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same
against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever.
AGENO'" rtEM
No. /7 C
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. /1
QB.NAP\155176.1
FEE 09 1999 10:25
9414340953
PAGE. 02
02/09/1999 11:24
9C.14340953
STERLING TITLE
PAGE 03
.'
*** OR: 2502 PG: 3233 ttt
In Witness Whereof, the Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day and
year first above written.
Printed Name
~h?~~
Itness #
TRUDY A. SMITH
Printed name
~~
- ROBERT S. HARDY .
10641 Airport Pulling Road N., Ste. 32
Naples, Florida 34109
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF COLLIER
5"
:i The foregoing instrument was acknowledged b ore me this ~ day O"f1CL~Ct "y I
19W, by ROBERT S. HARDY, who is personally 0 n
Name of Notary, Printed, Typed or Stamped
My Commission Expires:
,~:r.t~'>. LEO J. 6Al..VA.TORl
I~W" ..~~ t.lY~'CC~
~; : ; EXPlPDl: NlMlmlIIt~. 2lXXl
\~ ~1l'I\l.........NJI)~
, "
AGEND~ ITEM
No. J 1C-
.
QBNA.P\155)"'.4
MAR 2 3 1999
/~
Pg.
FEE 09 1959 10:26
9414340953
PAGE. 03
LIST OF ABUTTING AND OTHER PROPERTY OWNERS
WITHIN 250 FEET OF PROPOSED VACATION V~C (jCf- Q;:)-I-
Name:
Address:
Zip Code:
Parcel Number:
Name:
Address:
Zip Code:
Parcel Number:
QBNAP\173256.1
Quail Plaza, Inc.
4500 Executive Drive, Suite 110
Naples, FL
34119
Lots 1, 2, 3 and the West 42 feet of Lot 4,
Quai I Plaza, Phase I
Robert S. Hardy & Quail II Limited Partnership
do David Budd, Esq.
3033 Riviera Drive
Naples, FL
34103
All Remaining Property
Quail Plaza, Phase I
AGENO'" ITEM
No. /7c.
MAR 2 3 1999
I~
Pg.
.-'
~~\\\'{
~\..\~~ ~~~"s
\.~ \j '0 \_ \ c; c.\ ~ \\
\ \:,\ \1, ~' ~\\ 7:' '-\ \
Quotfe{Bt1lty III
4501 T ami ami Trail North
Suite 300
Naples, Florida 34103.3060
941/262.5959
FAX 941/434.4999
http://www.quarles.com
Attorneys at law in
Milwaukee and Madison, Wisconsin
West Palm Beach and Naples, Florida
Phoenix, Arizona
january 21, 1999
John H. Boldt, P.S.M., P.E.
Director
Collier County Stormwater Management
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
Dear Mr. Boldt:
Naples Attornevs
James T, Demarest
Robert E. Doyle, Jr.
Timotl1y G, Hains
Samara S, Holland
John 0, Humphreville
Kimberly l. Johnson
Edmond E, Koester
Susan 8, Kubar
Lisa C,Lottes
Thomas E. Maloney
F, Joseph McMackin, 111
Mart H. Muller
David L Petersen
Leo J. Salvatori
C,lane Wood
Please be advised that our firm represents the authorized agent for Joseph D'jamoos
and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A., property owners Of , lands described in the attached
Exhibit "A". We have been engaged by Mr. D'jamoos anL. r irst Anesthesia Associates for the
purpose of petitioning Collier County in connection with the vacation of drainage easements
currently existing on their lands. These easements are described in the attached Exhibit "B"
and graphically depicted in the attached Exhibit "B-1". All lands and easements referred to
herein are located within the plat of Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1.
As part of the formal procedure to vacate the drainage easements, Collier County
requires that certain utilities and users of the easements acknowledge this "Letter of No
Objection." Please indicate your consent to the vacation of the easements by means of
signature below and return the same to us. We have enclosed a postage-paid envelope for
your convenience. Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you should have any
questions. We thank you in advance for your prompt attention to this matter.
The t1lldt::1 ~;g~cd docf b~reb'l agree to hsvQ RS abiection to the propo~ed iflcatioll.
~ . Ab-
BY:~~ Ah.~-(J, ~'~JL~ -of
Print ame -..::7t ff.,.J B--o '-P r ;' i- . J:"-:- r_ - - '" r;;' ~~
Title~~ JAr ~D\ ~~' ~ SF~J:)
, 10-;.- IF -~~ ~ t/u-
~p~.
Respectfully,
QUARLES & BRADY LLP
e.
C. Lane Wood
CLW:jch
--
QBNAP\171485.1
AGENOA ITEM
No. 17G
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. /1
... _ ll...
4501 TamiamiTrail North
Suite 300
Naples, Aorida 34103-3060
9411262-5959
FAX 941/434-4999
http://www.quarles.com
Attorneys at law in
Milwaukee and Madison, Wisconsin
West Palm Beach and Naples, Aarida
Phoenix, Arizona
Qjun{efl Bnuly UP
January 21, 1999
Mr. John R. Houldswoth
Senior Engineer
Collier County Engineering Review Services
2800 Horseshoe Drive North
Naples, Florida 34104
RECEIVED
JAN 2 2 1999
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
PlANNING SE~ICES
Dear Mr. Houldsworth:
Naples Attorneys
James T, Demarest
Robert E. Doyle, Jr.
Timothy G. Hains
Samara S, Holland
John 0, Humphreville
Kimberly L Johnson
Edmond E, Koester
Susan B, Kubar
usa C, Lottes
Thomas E, Maloney
f. Joseph McMackin, III
Mark H Muller
David L Petersen
Leo J Salvatori
C. Lane Wood
Please be advised that our fj rm represents the authorized agent for Joseph D'Jamoos
and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A., property owners of the lands described in the attached
Exhibit "A". We have been engaged by Mr. D'Jamoos and First Anesthesia Associates for the
purpose of petitioning Collier County in connection with the vacation of drainage easements
currently existing on their lands. These easements are described in the attached Exhibit "B"
and graphically depicted in the attached Exhibit "B-1". All lands and easements referred to
herein are located within the plat of Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1.
As part of the formal procedureto vacate the drainage easements, Collier County
requires that certain utilities and users of the easements acknowledge this "Letter of No
Objection." Please indicate your consent to the vacation of the easements by means of
signature below and return the same to us. We have enclosed a postage-paid envelope for
your convenience. Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you should have any
questions. We thank you in advance for your prompt attention to this matter.
Respectfully,
QUARLES & BRADY LLP
(! ~tJ~
c
C. Lane Wood
CL W:jch
,,..,-.
The undersigned does hereby agree to have no obiection to the proposed vacation.
By:~l
Print Name .j~ I"~ ~\':!.u\q~~o\r~
Title ~~U.\C5V' ~.....~\...eoQlf"
\
~tl fA.c.\L\ T\E:-b ~ '\t~ IlJ
'G,A~E:.lM.~/\!"T 1\ V-b A -
QBNAP\171479.1
:~
AGENOA ITEM
No. /1 C
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. Jg
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
PUBLIC WORKS DIVISION
January 26,1998
3301 E, TAMIAMlTRAIL
NAPLES. FL 34112
(941) 732-2575
FAX: (941) 732-2526
Mr. C. Lane Wood
Quarles & Brady LLP
4501 Tamiami Trial North
Suite 300
Naples, FL 34103-5959
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements - Quail Creek Plaza, Lot 4 & Lot 5
Dear Mr. Wood:
This office has reviewed your request to vacate the above-referenced drainage easements.
The Collier County Water-Sewer District has no facilities in the area and we, therefore, have no
objection to the vacation of the Utility Easement.
Should you have any further questions, please feel free to contact me.
Sincerely,
C-1jY'~O----;Y; t.~
Cindy M. Erb
Public Works Senior Engineering Technician
cc: Edward N. Finn, Public Works Opcrations/lnlerim Wastewater Director
Paul Mattausch, Water Director
Rick Grigg, Land Surveyor, Community Development
~
AGENO'" ,Tal
No. /1 C
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. 19
4501 Tamiami Trail North
Suite 300
Naples, Florida 34103.3060
941/262-5959
fAX 9411434-4999
http://www.Quarles.com
Attorneys at law in
Milwaukee and Madison, Wisconsin
West Palm Beach and Naples, Florida
Phoenix, Arizona
Naples Attorneys
James T. Demarest
Robert E, Doyle, Jr,
Timothy G, Hains
Samara S, Holland
John D, Humphreville
Kimberly L Johnson
Edmond E, Koester
Susan B. Kubar
Usa C, lottes
Thomas E. Maloney
F. Joseph McMackin, III
Mark H. Muller
David L Petersen
leo J. Salvatori
C. lane Wood
Qumfesl Bmdy LU
January 21, 1999
Mr. Rick Grigg
Collier County Community Development
and Environmental Services Division
2800 Horseshoe Drive North
Naples, Florida 34104
'REC'EIVED
JAN 2 2 1999
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
PlANNING saNlCES
Dear Mr. Grigg:
'.<:... J' .... .,...,...,of~ ~~........ -f" 'P'I."_~-_" . . .-.-~....
Please be advised that our firm represents the authorized agent for Joseph D'Jamoos
and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A., property owners of the lands described in the attached
Exhibit "A". We have been engaged by Mr. D'Jamoos and First Anesthesia Associates for the
purpose of petitioning Collier County in connection with the vacation of drainage easements
currently existing on their lands. These easements are described in the attached Exhibit UB"
and graphically depicted in the attached Exhibit "B-1". All lands and easements referred to
herein are located within the plat of Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1.
As part of the formal procedure to vacate the drainage easements, Collier County
requires that certain utilities and users of the easements acknowledge this "Letter of No
Objection." Please indicate your consent to the vacation of the easements by means of
signature below and return the same to us. We have enclosed a postage-paid envelope for
your convenience. Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you should have any
questions. We thank you in advance for your prompt attention to this matter.
Respectfu Ily,
QUARLES & BRADY LLP
e.~~
C. Lane Wood
CLW:jch
..,,-_.
The undersigned does hereby agree to have no obiection to the proposed vacation.
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1 C
MAR 2 3 1999
By: ~_J/ 6 Z2!'/ .&#ut:;-
Print Name ~....-~ ~I?"/~
QBNAP\171472.1 F"~. 3/ /99r
Pg.
~o
lJ
UHTY
Oi4 SVC
4501 Tamiami Trail North
Suite 300
Naples, Florida 34103-3060
941/262-5959
FAX 941/434.4999
http://www.cuarles.com
Attorneys at Law in
Milwaukee and Madison, Wisconsin
West Palm Beach and Naples, Rorida
Phoenix, Arizona
Naples Attorneys
. - '""\
James T. Demarest
Robert E. Doyle, Jr.
Timothy G, Hains
Samara S. Holland
John D. Humphreville
Kimberly L. Johnson
Edmond E. Koester
Susan B. Kubar
Lisa C. Lottes
Thomas E. Maloney
F. Joseph McMackin, III
Mark H. Muller
David L. Petersen
Leo J Salvatori
C. Lane Wood
Quorles!/3Wdy;;;' PI1 2: I ^,
January 21, 1999
Ed Kant, P.E., Director
Transportation Department
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
Dear Ms. Kant:
L~___.
,
.._----- i
---.-..--. - I
._---....J
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
Please be advised that our firm represents the authorized agent for Joseph D'Jamoos
and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A., property owners of the lands described in the attached
Exhibit "A". We have been engaged by Mr. D'Jamoos and First Anesthesia Associates for the
purpose of petitioning Collier County in connection with the vacation of drainage easements
currently existing on their lands. These easements are described in the attached Exhibit "B"
and graphically depicted in the attached Exhibit "B-1". All lands and easements referred to
herein are located within the plat of Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1,
As part of the formal procedure to vacate the drainage easements, Collier County
requires that certain utilities and users of the easements acknowledge this "Letter of No
Objection." Please indicate your consent to the vacation of the easements by means of
signature below and return the same to us, We have enclosed a postage-paid envelope for
your convenience. Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you should have any
questions. We thank you in advance for your prompt attention to this matter.
Respectfully,
QUARLES & BRADY UP
(I. LW~
C. Lane Wood
CLW:jch
agree to have no obiection to the proposed vacation.
-
AGENDA ITEM
No. 11 c..
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ~ I
QBNAP\171495.1
45011amiami Trail North
Suite 300
Naples, Florida 34103-3060
941/262.5959
FAX 941/434-4999
httpJ/www.quarles.com
Attorneys at Law in
Milwaukee and Madison, Wisconsin
West Palm Beach and Naples, Flonda
Phoenix, Arizona
Quorles/Bmdy UP
January 21, 1999
Ms. Janet Kelly
President
Quail Creek Plaza Property Owners Association, Inc.
do Naples Road Building Corporation
4500 Executive Drive
Naples, Florida 34119
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
Dear Ms. Kelly:
NaD;es Attorneys
James T Demarest
RObe:: E Doyle, Jr
T'~c:" i G. HainS
Sa'-", S Holland
Jor" ~ rlumDnreville
K,rTice- i ~. Johnson
Edm,": E Koester
Sus:' B Kubar
Lisa C Lottes
Tho'"" = Maloney
F Jcse;' McMackln,ll;
Mar,~. ~11uller
Da'!!: L Petersen
Leo J S,lvaton
C. La~:Nood
Please be advised that our firm represents the authorized agent for Joseph O'Jamoos
and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A, property owners of the lands described in the attached
Exhibit "A", We have been engaged by Mr. O'Jamoos and First Anesthesia Associates for the
purpose of petitioning Collier County in connection with the vacation of drainage easements
currently existing on their lands. These easements are described in the attached Exhibit "B"
and graphically depicted in the attached Exhibit "B-1". All lands and easements referred to
herein are located within the plat of Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1.
As part of the formal procedure to vacate the drainage easements, Collier County
requires that certain utilities and users of the easements acknowledge this "Letter of No
Objection." Please indicate your consent to the vacation of the easements by means of
signature below and return the same to us. We have enclosed a postage-paid envelope for
your convenience. Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you should have any
questions. We thank you in advance for your prompt attention to this matter.
Respectfully,
QUARLES & BRADY LLP
(~~
C. Lane Wood
CL W:jch
The undersigned does hereby agree to have no obiection to the proposed vacation.
By: /!?~/?(~
Print NU;e 'Jcf (1('1
. ,.~ .'1' ,
Title , \ -'" :"\'; I.,j-r
Pc~-: +- V~ I~ ~~ '
^~ ('" .,, ,;/.)",
v~Y'u{1 j... ~ .t-~ 'l..L--
r>/ " ~ .1,
f i':'(..j', r_
'i .
~I .' ,1'
.li'('~ '.)~..,.." fJ I'd'\,
QBNAP\171474.1
AGENOA ITEM
No. J1C_
"jJMAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ;} ~
02/10 '99 11 :58
-. ',-
\. L- - .~
. - .
ID:BIG CYPRESS BASIN
FAX:941-597-4987
PAGE
3
4SOlllmilmi TI~~ Nonh
Su~e 300
Naples, Florid. 311033060
941/262-5959
FAX 941/43H9~S
hl\pJIwwv< quailescom
Anorney, .,Law in
Mllwau~e! ~lId Madison, Wisconsin
Wesl Palm Rf.ach Hod Naplls, Florid.
PhocOll. Arllcna
Naples Anornavs
QUI/TitSI R,ru!y Uf'
February 2, 1999
James!. Demarest
Roben E. Doyle, Jr.
Timothy G. Hains
Samara S Holland
John U. Humphreville
Kimberly l John5on
~dmond t Koester
Suun B. KubJl
LIsa Clone'
lhumBs E M~lullav
t. Jmph McMilckin.1I1
Mark II. Muliel
Omd L Pelersan
leo J Salva lor,
C, tHlle Wood
Mr, C1tlrence Tears
Big Cypress Basin
6089 Jane~ lane
Naples, Florida 34109
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
Dear Mr. 'ears:
PIp.tlsC! be advised that our firm represents the authorized agent for Joseph D'Jamoos
and First Anesthesia Associntcs, P.A., property owners of th. 'nds described in the attached
Exhibit "AN. We have been engaged by Mr. D/Jamnos and i Anesthesia Associates for the
purpo5e of petitioning Collier County in connection with the> vilcation of druinilge casements
currently existing on their lands. lhese p.ct~p.rrH!f)ts are described in ttu~ attClched Fxhibit "B"
rllld graphically depicted in the attached Exhibit "B-1". Alllanns and easements referred to
herein are located within the plat of Quail Creek PlaLi..I, Phase 1.
As part of the formal procedure to va(:C\h~ the drainage easements, Collier County
requires that certain utilities and users of the eClSem(:nts acknowledge this "Letter of No
Objection." Please indicate your consent to the v<lciltion of the ellsements by means of
signature below and return the same to us. We hflv(~ enclosed a postage-paid envelope for
your COl1v(!nienc(!, Plof1se do !lol h(!sitate to contact our ()ffjn~ it you should have any
questions. We! thank you in adv,mC(~ (or your prompt \lttentiun to this rnatter.
R(~spectflllly /
QUARLES & BRADY LLP /J'
c. ~tJ/~_...
C lane Wood
CLW:jch
By:
Plln Clarence
Tlllc._.. .... _~~r~ctor, Big ~ypress ~~in
y agre. 0 haw' no obiection to the proposed vacation.
AGENDA ITEM
No. J1C-
MA:i 2 '3 1999
RECE\VEO
FE 8 0 2 1999
ale .: ': , '.;H BABIN
Sr'IJ'VMU. NAPl.ES
QBNAI'\ 172'i2A.l
Pg. d~
.
I=PL
4105 15th Avenue S.W.
Naples, FL. 34116
FAX 353-6082
January 25, 1999
Quarles & Brady LLP
Mr. C. Lane Wood
4501 Tamiami Trail North
Naples. Florida 34103-3060
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
Dear Mr. Wood;
In reply to your recent request, FPL Company has no objection to the vacation of the
existing drainage easements as described:
1. The north 12 feet of the south 22 feet of Tract A of Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1,
according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 15, page 73. of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida.
2. The east 25 feet of Lot 4, (Not Including the North Ten Feet that abuts Tract C),
Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1, according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 15,
Page 73, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida.
3. The West 25 feet of Lot 5, (Not Including the North Ten Feet that abuts Tract C),
Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1. according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 15,
Page 73. of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida.
FPL will retain our rights to utilize the North Ten Feet that abuts Tract C, for the
installation of new or upgraded electric facilities, both overhead and underground.
If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me at 941-353-6025.
Sincerely,
Jim Merriam
Construction Services
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1C-
MAR 2 3 1999
!>g. ;l4
cc:file
an FPL Group Company
4501 Tamiami Trail North
Suite 300
Naples, Aorida 34103.3060
941/262.5959
FAX 941/434.4999
http://www.quarles.com
Attorneys at law in
Milwaukee end Madison, Wisconsin
West Palm Beach and Naples, Rorida
Phoenix, Arizona
Quur!es/Bmdy LU
Janua
Joyce F. Goddard
Network Engineer 1 - E&C
Sprint
Box 2477
Naples, Florida 34116
Re: Vacation of Drainage Easements
Dear Ms. Goddard:
Naples Attorneys
James T. Demarest
Robert E. Doyle, Jr, /
Timothy G. Hains
Samara S, Holland
John D. Humphreville
Kimberly L Johnson
Edmond E. Koester
Susan B. Kubar
Lisa C. Lottes
Thomas E. Maloney
F, Joseph McMackin, 11\
Mark H, Muller
David L Petersen
leo J, Salvatori
C. Lane Wood
Please be advised that our firm represents the authorized agent for Joseph D'Jamoos
and First Anesthesia Associates, P.A., property owners of the lands described in the attached
Exhibit "A". We have been engaged by Mr. D'Jamoos and First Anesthesia Associates for the
purpose of petitioning Collier County in connection with the vacation of drainage easements
currently existing on their lands. These easements are described in the attached Exhibit "B"
and graphically depicted in the attached Exhibit "B-1". All lands and easements referred to
herein are located within the plat of Quail Creek Plaza, Phase 1. ._
As part of the formal procedure to vacate the drainage easements, Collier County
requires that certain utilities and users of the easements acknowledge this "Letter of No
Objection." Please indicate your consent to the vacation of the easements by means of
signature below and return the same to us. We have enclosed a postage-paid envelope for
your convenience. Please do not hesitate to contact our office if you should have any
questions. We thank you in advance for your prompt attention to this matter.
e to have no obiection to the proposed vacation.
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1 C.
MAR 2 3 '999
Pg. ,15
Respectfully,
QUARLES & BRADY LLP
~~
C,
C. Lane Wood
CLW:jch
QBNAP\171448.1
II} "
Il'in
185 lJ
I~; CJ
If) ()Q
,,1.(1(1
I ~
,'i(
I 63
I
I 62
I 61
I
I ~ 60
I~
I 3 Ii 59
I 58
I
I ~ 57
,2
I 56
I
I
I
I
I 10 ~
G2
L~~
~IRAD. ON [HE GREENS
ONE COHOO PH j
\
r'Aril:El_ G
~
,_1..;
.'?'in
~
CD
~
'"
.~
lot
]
...
...
@ 1\ @ :5 @ .. @ tl @
~
~: ~ ;;,; .,
"" ..
1 ~ 13 12 11
Ill.. '" 13 ,1IIi .'J JO 'I l1Dto
1I~ to
EXECUTIV DRIVE
1\ 00
1525.'
~
:(j) ,,,
~ I
"to
~. ~
30 4
" to lto to
2
(9) ~
CD (5) CD \!:
(2) G} 4
TRACT ^
5 6 7 "ooB
?fJ116 100 00 7'l1J'J
1Vttv1liuth
1/~ Une
130 00
Ll
1100 J9
S,R, 846
IVISION P,B. PG. NO. SUBDIVISION
_AlA PHASE 2 18 71 ~2. LONGSHORE LAKE UNIT 5B2
~SE TWO 21 42-43 ~,3 , QUAIL WALK PHASE TH E AGENDA ITEM
E UNIT 5A 21 49-50 ',4, HUNTINGTON LAKES UN TWIe. 17C-
24 75-76 MA~ 2 3 iS~9
KES ~,dT ONE 24 93-96
E UNIT 581 25 48-49 Pg. ;}Io
VAC qq- 004
4~?E~MlENf MRP
i
= - .
~ ~a
;!! lOf'GSHORE I..Al<LS !.NT OOE
! ".
~ -.
\- ~~
, . ers.rsr I! .cuxr
'tca1fl'IUIl~~"""CI'<<
PLAT BOOK 15
SlUET lor
PAGe: 7
I
PLAZA
QUAIL CREEK
PHASE 1
A SUBDIVISION
OF
DESCRIPTION OF LAND PLATTED
i
CCft'OI:\.., lHE """" 1/4 ~ a1 RetIa. 10. TO\MSW1' .. PI'''.
.......'4 u..sl. I"IAlllC Ilfcar::x. CoQ.llUl Q).", I\CltIO...
1~ It.cat II<< aclIlT" ~o saur. lit U": tlf' S..U Sl::lItJ11 2'0. _'M
01-....-01. weST 101).00 fUl 10 IlI€ lIOIlI" \'11l( 0If flUl IDC 'lX:r
c..uJ.N. U"",'-(J6-...u AS DUU11(.1 ,. 0... U. "".;( ,.,. P"IAllC tt~
aI CQ..~\(I w..-n. nQllHa MQ ltolE P'Ol" r:I IUII..I.. Of tIC. ItAjlllC(I,.
....1. Cl($OIll(Dt
'O~ ....~ u.n aollIh. L1. ....'M ...........,... ""1 Ie"..
liLI lC rill(. WI Ll-t rJif UlOOXl ...,,( AlIIICMI 011 ,.. l'I.d "
"'4H Cl'llU \11.11 -.. p... lJ. ".foGIU ,....:N. 1OCIl.1IU co...n.
ftOllHI...
nua ...__ no( ....,. lASt L'II( .",. 'AI...DID:>> _It'[ .. ,.. '"LOIil'''
Illl.Il (.. IIIl.SCaIUD c:o.II5(..S. .
u -'1. 00..10......'.. ..., ......~ faT.
;II ~,~,...o ~II'LUIUtl' e4J-t:! ,al ...... fill[ ~ 01 A
.....,...$0".... Cl1tCU..M CUl"r( 1;:CItC.A'r( 10 '.. SDl.ilto€A$1
....".. .. IADI'" OF ..10.00 n(f r..Cl.lI>I , c,un.... u~1l: Of
&J'-."-~. ....0 II(lac; _toO(.!) " .. QC)ItO .1CM KNl,
_,. P'.,'""," 051 ....'.n fU1 1(; "1'0111 01 T~"
t =::J.:;~;-~ ~~~,'~~~I,.ur..~ 'M[,tItC. A
''''OUI1.!,L I:ltclA.AlIl ~( co.c...U: '0 f1~ 1IOlt1Mif(1I IUUII5 "
LiI01US Of" iW)'S.QO nu lMUJI.'gI ., c::(Jl1Ul.. MQ.I 01
:;j~l;;1D~~i.!f=J;.:,~~rtl; 'o~gl:;lf: ~~
,....a: U..U\..~ ""I) u.sl UK...o S...ID QJIt1"t SOIol'" OI'-04'~"
OJ! l~.. 'Ut .!,LaM '"I; lIlCst L11I( Of" It.a;SI<lItf \,,vn
.. I ..... l"l"" 100I 14. 'AO:I(.S eJ-~. ,,*,lC <<C/iIIIDI Oft
C:CU1Ul ~", nClllO.....
~..IlI;~;.!:..~~ ~~a::[~1O ~ UIU
fa 1M( os, \.Ill( 01 he. ~I M rut ., IJC 1t'lr.~1 1/. 01
"".~ KeU_ J'Or
I~":% Iolo.. UID WI L 1.. -.". ".........o;r. VAl U..CI)
It: f TIl ,.... "'111 I.IIl! rJI Lilli ,....Jot. .'Gloo'~."""l
rv.-a. Al.ca5 ...:0 at'IlI" Ida( saul. ....-0..-... lIIE.U M.OO '0.1
10 rl4f. P'CIII or t(~I.'IU 0'" I,. 'UQ]. ~~j' O(\.CJlllU1..
....,... IIfIll 'or.$Ul .. hC. ~I.. ...0 UUllt II. CCMtIU lh( ", ....10
"...cTl~ l'O. I(lU I-OAtJII 01........-42.. Io(:S1&
1Ioa..I(CT '0 ~" M4 IIUJIICUOIIS 01 M.CCIJIG.
ACK~OWLEDGEMENT AS TO MOBTGAGEE
.r"'IlflIf"lIllTU
00MT1 (4 ::o:a.ltOl
, KnC1' Q;llln r_r CII twlS 0<101 wYocr: PI[ ... lW"~ M. 1
~i,~;<<~~~~"'~~~.~I~
~f:~h:JA~~:'~r\t.r ":;'~,.t~[f~.l~:=~'''''
D.LCl,JIII:; ,..1: '....\,orIU"1LT~.)(JI .....'~I" t'lA.f H::;l(:;! UI fll"
" "'10 '..:JO-o,ll.lrlo. 01,10 ,,...r tl1l: :;:(J.l ...;'-ll'.:l 'I'IU1:ra U IIC llnL
CDI:1':JIU,11. 5l.Al OE SI:D COAI'ClRA!I~.u.i..f ~;,
~:=:~:'11~ NIIJ.s;,;; ~ :y~ ~..:'::~..
.. """,co,.. 01'10'" ~ik4iljl~$ft
~ICT "'...~ - -,
EAST LINE Of WEST 60'
Of SCUTHEAST 1/4 Of SECTIGK 20
0'
,C.U.[
~POI~T OF BEG1HKING OF LAND PLATTED
iL
' ~ "''''' " ro""<<~,
SOOTH 1/~ CM'~:ER SEcn ell 20.
10lP.!SHIP 48 SCUW. R'JlGli': ;2i; UST.
COlUER COO:CTT. fl3RIOA
PART
OF SECTION 20.
COLLIER COUNTY.
TOWNSHIP
FLORIDA
48
SOUTH.
26
EAST.
DEDI CAlI ON
t1..." .1\.,.1"
__n"CIlUlU
uov,u.:. "'h I' fl.. l'tI(SlJ"1 '_I ...., I. ~.. H1[ ~ .
(ME l..,..ol; IlUUtlt.O I<<Jl'(I>> ..... c.ALISL-D "'" "'AI bllTlU
IlJAll CIlUI ~.av.. P'IU$( I III lit MDt MoD ~, QUlIU.IU ,... 'CIlL""l'"
1. 10 ~.ll I'\Alt. "a""Ul1 ~U" .IoSSOClAlIc. t.c.. T.... ..... MID
1111;10I1':# ,...,.... ~.... 01111<<. ......,.u ..1....'r c' oUIO It<<
.$I"OIII~'IIL1" 'JI 1'!;J1,f'{llJA.l I\Al.T{IOJIQ: f1I1 1.ylI(.
I. TO Ou.:l il'\U... H:O"t1l11 O'\tIoU'S ass.or.UT''', tac.. ....l c-..I"-: 1t/CJ""""0aA.<l
u.~oot...~....>.., U:'lC:.fo'U 011 lill r\"" Ml) .lr'C*Ilell.lff
f1Il'"t....,.!:l\l.tLl'I..llIfUl"~:tClf~.
,. III au IV C~1J W-IIVl-I("IU "'sr..'"
ITS '......;;roIILl. Ad 1,0( .""'flI1 Il.ll'\.U O-r
I1Slll1tt ,. -.c.:..::n t..uU€-Jr '0 ....L ,..IJleus ~ 011 ,." n.1ll
'OIl IfIE: S':U ~ f1I1 H.ll:f'ltrl" ~ ....0 IunCl[ HJt,a.U
lD"'I.~UICI~AI\'U.t.
4. 'II nOllI=.'O'olIEJ.u:) ll~' ~".,. ....11al rn~ ~M1'
,ur, .... e~1\.( In(lIS1111l ".".041';( c.:ar.AII" . .1>>r-(la.lAIY[
UTlllf1 (.o...:;.(""Ll1 W.(.I ,I.S I.OICA11L.) 0.. IIC l'\.AI fe.. ,.... ~S
rJI t.Ol'u....cnc.. '''UllAIJOII ""'..'U....CI. Uti 0l'1J1:~11Q1l . U(Ulltc.
In~ Jo.II& CA8l.t T(\[1II.IQa 'o!oGllIl1U MO 1.(UICl.. .a
COU111\.1:IH'-. IUIAl\,AIIOJI. ~llIlr(.U.JIC( -..0 "t.Ullo.r 01
..., c.oa.t HlO1Slo. f",.eIUIlU IUlD ILUTe( WtL IlltJllv..
111",1"1( n(el111C!lIt t(1~[ tAC'LlflU IUIO UJlflct.. I.
TIIII( OUT A111 Col.IU: rnOlS100ll t.lr"Nl"1 a.......lIo(. 10< ,AoCllUIU
f1I ....c:r<.a "-Ie \In\.I'', If '""'-1. . iCllt.Lr 1t(1"'QU11L( ,0.
-",t11 IM,-.....1(f_
S. loll V.fUl .lJI~ ~ VTILIIIU COl.Uln.CllD "'t.,. "'11 "-Uf(llI
MOo Sou.l.~ __ MOlc..un 10' he. fOQ.L1U1 c........" ltlAtLl-iol...... Ilnttlcr.
IIol.l 1IIIt#....:L IASlft.IlTS AS &IC)lIIll 011 hU' n.t to "'LIlA ~lf
'011 loft: ~~ rJI ~11Al::t VlTIf.a ltu.onl.1LlIT ,0. ,,",UTUAaC(.
,. M.L~"'OIft UIlL1TIU (\j..TO 4 &lWLtJ IKAlL . ICUlUf1~
,. c.w.I. ~n ..,nlll ~U
J. 'IJ1111CS .vt(7. .owe., &. ltNIICI1. ~ tAUSlO IIlI[a: P'IlUUTI
:.-..,:;~; ~,:r~~r::J:d~I~M(.~~ .~.)1O.01l0A;-
. ...W~ u..~. ..1..
........... Jf.~JL~ Ii . /1
4}j"l// " W'~5.:..j~{~
....1 ..~. "';;-7'
PERSONAL
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
RANGE
COUNTY APPROVALS
.... -..",
IN" "l.t ~u .,. r..: CGLL1U ICIDIaTr OrIUUJI '1111 2~ ~
GAr OT c~u~..- ...,. 4.0.
~ _ d....2JJ.jJ
.CJIII'Q( ,. ....t1I1~T. P.~. 1301_
ca.l.tU CIlI.IIl n. ILC.I<<U
~" .... hi .:7"""""
h.~S.J'-~ll~Ul~~ OCUI~:-~~O~:: ~~ ;:"
~Ul ...'u U:J .~.
~ r
lMl'ltT 1_'. c:.--... .~""'....e:- ..
OII:l(CIOII OF 01'1~'" U11111UJ1"_
c:altn ., f-.cT ~
BOI pur ~u,,'~ c:eU1U..." ..U...." .." $-
0.., 0( A"M.r-L 1..... ....a.
~d.'-..L .
1.1:"1: I.. .. GUTl;;;r----
Cl1lLlUl~".lI~'
_n .,un _",n_
1t.1I I'\.t ~UI fOIl "~1_ n ,.. CCIl.L1Ul __n "lIun
aUl'l~ '"'' ."'" ....__ &.. ...... A.'.
4."tI-....l......,~.J
~:,~~ IIl_ct.. ..J
WllLllt III"....
..." -.0.,. ~..
'''" 1'\.111 ""~U1 Hili IIlCtlltOI.. ,_ .. II"tA fII(IU.' ,. re ~ '3f OIodIn
C:ON'IlCSIOMJt. OF CD..LIU w..rl. nan'A ,... )1... on. ..._..va.,.
I",". ....0. "",,1C'Ut 1.....1 lto( ,.,..,1 11 f"ltCi.
'I ,,~ 1If'f"lt( IIf' 'M: C:lAClIIf CI:UII _ ~11U1 COtaIl....f\.OIlI~..
ii/_____.....-r-.,.::.-C.. I?-H.-{~t'
..IolJ"1:$ C. tllU _r It.UIlOVII. cau.,-..
Q.[ltaOlCIJlCUlfClll.aI ~WCCUll"CP'fo;Q-.(~
ClLLld: ....1'. nfa1Dol
~
SURVEYOR"S CERTIFICATE-
If " ..., co.nnu ,...., till" ..." "... ".U....(D #~ M ..-;:.
IU"(' fIT It<< ~11 " ,. :. 1...0(.1 '" Sl"II'f.'UIc. ,.. ~1:ll
" N..I 21__. fL~a'A ~1111""'f"lt c;.arx #olD ~fUl U2 " r
IU.llU1 ,"'fUIU..
11 l' ""'I~ c:unnc ,...., ALL ~" ..,..., Io€flV1I Iol:r'.:Au1
0111 III "1ll unl ,..,. ,. It(e(lItDl.' ., IK "",."1t1'1~.
MID 11<1(1. 1111. UXATtDll. '1"( ..., N.IUlllol ~ .;.>'Ucn, ~
'" P'1l;CI,.OUl II tiC Cl"IRa(,tI LOin.. . Clt.AIIU 11" rII II<< I'lCIIl.I....
,UIU:U.
(Vll.t.l1f"r':.l.1tA. ..t.fIl1CM. ..... .. f'UJ[. IIC.
.~f'e:!:~".. ,.(:,/M
"-----
FILING RECORD
1 lCJtUl c::t.ar:" ,...., hilI 1'\41 .....s _LI U""'1IL!l '" lit[ .... 1_1
IT ~IU I. ,000ft lJ1'W 1"Of "ttlIJlt:tlt".r. (lP" C"""I. '''. lA'" cr
1M( 1.1~'( f6 ,\,CWlIOA. 1.1..-1.... ct.atlft ,...., ItC:S n....1 .... 'I~
,,. lIU:QIIIO ,,' ,.OJ "". 11'11 12 'II on 01 "'''''IL
I.... ....0. .0 1ILIl.1 ..~ I' ""AI..... II ."-"'W; n
CII h€ na.IC ~ " caLltfl ~". nGlIllN..
tdl~l~~:So G.J".::....J J"')'~'.
Q,ur. tJI f'4l ClaQIU ~r I'
... ,. CIIlI.1.1U ~1'. n..aatOA
pE~~Bt,...l, _~.qJ.~S..,,_" ,...-.
J. ""-1. DII'I.UIc:.1 . c:.r.'7U ~ Me UNI" WlL.lSI era fll~..
~~ :....~~~'";"-i~~~ ~?... -0- . oc.- LUll'" -~.. . DI1.U
....t lUll ~.. . rx.:--:'I KAJl:I..
.u.ln~ ~ &AStD ~ 1M( ....,. ... ...,. .,. UM . IItctUIII
2'0. J~~" ... lWI"-. ..... iii (.MI. JiLMt.. _'" t1.~'-e=l'"
"'91[..1 ~". n::aI~A.
.. 1.01c..TU '.0_........, .,(~ ~1.
t. 1.:>lC...,U ~1 CIl:.'-' N,a. &P.C..".I 1_" III.~.-
""It ,unu c.,t#.
.. &.1.'0( lilli L1...,j;.......,.. -.na .'U .,...,..
,. a.l. l&.)tCoAIU c.lA:a,loQ( U~,.
I. U-t.. IWOIU:U IIll1lfl U..UC.llI.
t. ... srall' Ol' L""-' 1.' m:.. II IJC ,.., ... .... " &l UII II
_1ll.E.' ~5l[JI'1'Ul .. .. /,11:U" IIoIIMJIr 10'.'. to L.. ..1.1.
.Y.:I c..alr.L 'UUI$ICII ,*,-1.
'HE CLllUll.'~ t1I '''''L''C..11 _-.:t1 '. nt'''''''' ..... A 1._ .
14.SC I~ ".I~ af '..U I'UI ClCSI_ "-IUIS. 1M( ",0.....
C.OIUIC. 1& ~1"",1(l.f I)., ~IDI II ....,UII-.fol t.:<'l.U.CI. TlC. l'"
11 _11"1. nClCCl' lClIIt 1:... f'UI nc::c:e .~u: u;( """ c:arn..,"
~...o. aIoftIU 1:-:raw..." SD ..Uut ...,..... IiLL G.CUtl_ ".
ac:u .. lUna.... ......a;II(I1C WbIt1C1l1. OAf'UIl.
n. RUI.IC11on.. ..C'IUU.,...' .... "'.ICla(~' ..-:
.CIIIl:Dt:D I. .....I~I.. It(~ ~ 141. . P'..wtl to.
f1iCIIDI.ol;lM I~l' . ,.....IC ~ CII CQ.1.IO C:::::I.Mft. A_Ie.&..
12. al ~ ..,.. ..... ... '~1 C a.nc:urnll: _1.0
II<< ~1 P[!lIC:.'ub .. IK "'~'::"Ie .0 ... "'''A'(.
.,_ "I&tcf acc:.~ "'_1.ll'n I t~_ . 1.c:I.~.g...
Irn:JI:.U ~ ~l It( 1'IIP'f,"lld.
... ~. ........,----:-";Y~_..."_'O,.,.....",..~
d. ~~....:.: ~.,::;;-: POll nIE.....-eM ('# ~....
II..AoQ "....nul ~ ~ .........u,not.
THI S lOSTRUl'LH
JOIfl< Eo 8Wrlo'!:l
WllSOM. "!llER.
ftEGtSTEPED ENt;l
.J8J AIRPORT RO
'AnES. c:ll.lItR
tulIO'. l~
E:~rD LAND SUR__ETC, c....:.
n~'n. I
11A.IIOlF\0II10'"
, ..,
CP-art tJI 2I.L101
1 ~ COIn" I~r 011 "'III 0.'. t(!1IlIt(~. ..,. tlr'flCU 0IA.1
....'....I;Ul l~ r-.( '~"ow.te;.L"':.'l H.JllQII"'-l' .....!.M'{O
ft::k,,, I. ""'-;:f. ('Y'lI~1l ...s O(Ole...r,* 0. 1"-1[ 'Cl'IlC.:Jh8 ,,-"I
,lIlQ M( "CUJ~(!'GU OIClJII.. lME ~ ':a....UlIllI 1.JIlQU:
.w.IfllClll" ""'-I ".IUl U .,.,,,.
W11.n '" IIUo.c ..0 Clf"flcUl ..... ,. flC CCUlTr IUlO S"'It
:=~::I;~O"'I 01 In:;! rn ~,. ....0.
..:TIAA' "'" lC
W,"'1
MORTGAGEE"S CONSENT
ataPo AICl JiCllTr<<" UTOUl. .... " ~
hIE ~1-.D CIlUr ~1lf"'U Jl( II tIC to.M. ",. t-<<:
_,..... lit. 011 0'""' ucu..r....O( OA'I!) ...owl..... t\,I_'"
,., Oll.' ,,~o I. OHIC14 "-~~ pe"')lr. I),.. ,....:U .'1. .ao.
"'*.IG Kt.:{A';$ Of e=UI(t: c.ou.l'. flCllI';A".O:ol1 ..O[lr
co.~1 TO ,101( tl"tlC.lItl:' Dr TN( \,......'S DU'JlIIUI i. '14: DUltU.TlOll
-":'0 I( 111: e....{1 1~1l:(1:If lUJl:l """-t( t"~f ,..: ....C:"lf1...'C 'Ull'~.
1.1U '" 01~.""r;;( ~ .. ~lulU) 10 I~ 1'\1.1 M.fI 'ME
"'1""'1101 L..:o/r.
..--~' ~.~.L-
.AJI:lIC.TT......,.
-.:t P'fIUOD(f - ~ ~
Q'TIlPOA.oc>~~..,..~t\.CICIA
t4OO,.,. I'TII[r't
/UIf ............. ~
TITLE CERTIFICATION
.un. "-.1;....
_n .. IZU.IU
I. ..ftIOI ,. ""'1'. .. ....., U~ ...lIi:W'1(' I. tIC 'tAn: cr
P\~1;;.A. oc .......t"--I' ClJ'''' 1_1 , ",",-Il U.....I-..1I IHE l'ltt :0 M
......lIIllllll(J.Ca;~,rlI PT:If'l.Alt ..., ''''''' t,. lI'a ia h'l: K"'~' QltSC;a,tD>
~rt IS lUlU! I_ ~"'-OI .. 1IlMCl1. r."1 !:'!,: ..;:..;:toi.T I~ "',,:..~
,,"". .. n.u :.c. ft:ClrU1I t. nu. f;I ~.""'I u.::u>t A:I fcuan.
I. """'-t C'!rT...~"'. f'1IWCIl or"'~ 111-"', ....
~::n.:"", IS .... -..x ':t... ,...... '.1 - tH. .......lC ~ .
1lIlU.1!..JI CD.IIU. n.0II'....
... ,. 11-.0
An"..., .I' \..loll'
ll~ 18~"
MAR 2 3 1999
-.:... --
f"lM-'__'-
------.....
- -;;- ~WA47--
1 ~~ 35
tt., ~7"i.~IAL COII[a f"\.lir. JHT I - 1iWZL~ ~ tal ~~ _~ 6:i
VAC
qq - 004-
}ll ~t
· so
;!! ~ LAXE5 !.NT ONE
f -.
. is
.~1!4O.OO"
p.lT)(~~l.McDI,.WTCN:
COLl.Ell WlHTl'
!ITE LOCAT'1CIN
!
~fU).
:.
i
f:::j
I
o 50 100
P""b......_
SCALE IN
200
,
fEET
NOT PLATTED
'"
zo
-
..J
.
....
TRACT 8
%0
-'"
~
cz
"'0
..~
'"
%W
...'"
a::
c""
zoo
'"
>
a::
c
c
c
~
'"
..J
<
>
,.7..
. ........ '.""
.. . ".001'"'' J
; ~ v~.., to' cI
~;}~....,.. i . ...... ---:t -.-}.:. ~.~.!
. ""'1.""".0 546." ell TRACT C -- -C!.~ '.1'.. ~ I ..,
. .r." 11'- _ ~.,.._.~.. 'I oooll
DRIVE ~ut. ~O' R/W(~~.aDoo_~" ~I" "'.l. ,
. ~~:;,,'w_'41'= 100.00 -1$.. _. :::::.~.:..~~]?~..- ~
I 1l7" - 1..q $
~ ., ~ ,. )
lO'\a I ~...:;; ;:
r ", .:;;
7 ;: Lor . I ~o"
~ I
I
I
-".00
~
-nucT A _
~NC)~.a
~ :.
.....
....
<>
2 ;, LOr J ; LOt 4,
I
I
I
.
~
8 ~
~
~~ s
;; I
I
I
-,.....,
IGlJ..
o
A SUBDIVISION
DESCRIPT ION OF LAND Pi
s
~
CGI'f'O.:l. .10' fl'l[ ""',. 1/. CClIIbIOl OF ReU. 20. ,~,
IIMfIl '" OST. 1'Uk.1C II(~ 01 CGlLlU C;OI.n. nOlI l tI....
r~ ..(at IN[ ~TI' ..,.0 10.1111 ". u.-t: Of SAHl Kcn... :I
............1.11($1 1000.GO fUI 10 1M(. ~,.. lll( or h..., 100
c.MAl IIIIIH-(lJ-"., AS Dtsc..tl.ul 'I 0.'. 4.3. ,"'" H1. P\oell
", CCI.",U co..-u. nc:.U'lA MD ,~ f'Ollr Of 1U1..1" ., '"
_II D(1Ca I I(.b.
, OC( N.OIIG ....1" &C*fll 1111( ICUUI .........U. ~If .e
'1.,(1 '0 fl< lAlI L tIC( tIIf Ulao:to .1ft; .... ~ OIl r~
1u41L 0IItU \all 11II(. f'... .,. 'NfIU l~ H. CQ.llUl c:a
nQll:I~.
ruAoC( ..... '10( IATD 011 UK fJI "~L1ICXI IInl ,. ,
'U,Il 141 Of5CAll.Ol ta..-Sl..S.
II _1101 OO'~JO'-U. .." .....;re '"til.
Z _r~'.-.D &aIlf........rulu M).U I"Uf...... It<<
__1M<<.Il1AL CIIlCU.NI CUII1I[ co-eATt: ro 1101( sout...
aUTN .. L\D1Ul OF "G.OCl rut '~III .. CUU:Al It.
""."l'~"'. "'0 1(1., _'OlllED " .. CICIRO ""I"" .
-,... ",..."..,,- OS1 ...,.... nu '" It. "'1.1. I
II _,~ 1.'","'-1.- u.sl .".';0 'Uf.
&! _f~tOll' ~ ~lto<<.Jll' .u.1tO fUI ..o.s tIC
IAMlUu.:. CUtCl..._ ClAn!! co-cnl Ig he .oltlllftl(lU
IlAlltvt etr ~~.GC "UI U<<lJLOCOlll .. CUUl.... MC\[ Of
:;i~]"~~i.t€ill,sam~~i\:r~ tD~gl:;l~ t
'MOle( Lf..nIU ....I~ tlt.$I 1.1. Me '.UO (:UII'[ $.OI,l'" 01'
tAU II,J." "f..(l "lION tM( W;SI lalll. 01 l(;lo;~ lU'(
".1 ...:. f"L.U ~ U. f'lIoQ(S IU-~. PUkIC ctClllltDti or
CClL1U c::a..n. nallD....
~..-=~;.!:.~; ~~~(~IO l~ LMU
U: 1M[ USI UN Of r"'ll: ~, 60 f'Ul . fie 1t'\l:'fC.A$1 .
""", Jl[CIIOI le'
r~..;( .....1*. UID ~r Lt.. Nut.. DI'-o".02- LU,r 11.
n:' to I.... .0000Tlllll( 01 UIO c..uAL .1""'.."....,.
rw'.Ia. Alr..c ":D ~l" L 1-.1: """,.. ...~O...I.. ItII:.st 10
10 fl'lf 1"'C1IT . .{ioU_lac OF rl<< "....cn t<<:~{i' Dn,(;1l11"!
IIUWIII'" -. .1.5Ul G'; 'l<< .,.1", ....0 SWIll I...ot COIlIUl Lllll 01
"...cnOll 1'0. klU lrJJ1r.. DI'--o.'~02" IliLU'
....." 10 ilASlJo€.JIlJ MD 1U'11C110IS (JIT ~.
ACK~OWLEDGEMENT AS TO
'Uft: 01 'l_T....
ClMff (r ;aL 110
1 fOVlII(' ct.al1n 'MAr I>> "',. Dot., WYOItt K M DrrTeat CIA. ,
~~~~~:~~"J~~
J'OII.f("'-"''u''tJt&~'~:''''h I"LA1 1.1I:; I......r".-: ~cu;C".\~~::
m:CUIII; u.."l. 'a.\.III.utllf lM:JUl ALllfIOlItlU t'lA., HUG! U fll
If ~IC '~~T1C11 uo ,....., tME ~ .,n.....~ rJ<<,Jtuo 11 ft<<
c;ctI:I"Ol.tl.5(.AI.. II' ""':0 ~!I~.Uoi.f ~
::~I:'f I~ MO..w~ ~ ::'f~ ~":frt.
"'CI:IJ't'YIU1.orlRU. ~~.~
,,-.aT ".." t
EAST LTNE Of WEST 60'
Of SCUTHEAST 1/4 Of SECTION 20
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1C-
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg.
dg
.-
I
1 100'
/_-
/HI'10KAlEE ROAD 1100'
CDUIHT ROAD 846
....l~.~~
~POI~' OF BEGl~NlNG OF LAND PI
;1(00 '.
--~"'''' ~ ro~m.."
SllUm 1/( C<l;-,t:ER s.ECilCN 20.
lO~SllIP 48 ~UTlI. R'-'I(;E 25 u.sr.
COU.IER COU:ln. fL3RlD...
CANAl R/W. DEED BOOK 43.
/
R/W'/
SOUlH LII<E s.ECTlOll 20
V Fie 9'7-cx:J4-
1?35
v ~ c q:;-cx:J 4-
~56
~"".,..:..'.~~....:...:.-.;:,,;:-.~-:::';:';.;~~'.... ,~:,' >.~. -,.-~--_. ~'~-:'-~.....'.,__---'--- -,;,:.. "..:.... .'... ';T~, -~'. '_' "~, . _,' _,,' _, _ .
'':'- ~""'i~~8i2' ., ~ ".~~"f"'", "'<< t~ ~,;.;;~,{'i,.- ~~;;...~~~*~~~~~,
~~:..<...._.~"-- f~ . ~ ,..,,_.~r? m~~~~$~~~~
~~
~1
~!~
.~~-4 O! 500306 In n.. 23 ~ 1;:29 no 1'633- 002%02
~i RECtHJED OR BOOK
r,.l...~,:, COWER COUHTY PA.GE
- ," ~~.liA.G.L..Eh$~~~
"~}l:,~?~ ;~ P.OEERT s. ::~~~ ~^::"'~::~t~:~n::d t:i:o:.2 OF d::Ul::~' J~~~I~::~l~Z:~
li~:,.",...}"e_~ OF CCJ!..L!ER CC,n;TY, "LaPID", as the Govcrni:1<:; c'C'dy of Collier COU:1ty
.-:;:/ a~d o.S C:.: o:'ficio the Go'..rerning Board of the Collier county
"';.,-."oj
--"'::-'
,.2:..~'~
t~~
~:'1,;
'~f~~~
~~
.f0~
r~~~,
i~
.:~~f;~~
~,,~"'.i../:"'~
~'~.>::?)
"~ ~'":.-.~'
r~
~tfz~
~~~~
~.,. \
jtl ~
'~~:;~j ~
E-<
'"
~
Wat2~/Sewcr Dis~rict, i~5 sUcc~ssors a~d a~signs, ~~ Grantee.
~'ITNE55ErH :
That the G~~ntcr, for and in consideration of the sum or
Te~ and 00/100 Dollars ($10.00) and 0thcr v~luable consideration
p;J.id by the Grantee, receipt of which is hereby i\ckno\oiledged,
he~cby conv"'?ys and g'!:"arts unto the Grantc ts ::;u.ccessors. ~r.d
assigns, a perpetual, €>:clusive drainage eas - on the fcllOl..-ing-
describ~d l~nds being lccated in Collier. Co~n~~', Florida, to-wit:
See Ex:' 3... ,i t '1A" attachcG hc!:'ct.o and ;-nadc a pa.::-t
he=-ccf.
to hand and to hold the :;ame unto the GrClntce together .....ith a right
to enter upon said :;: :-,d, excavate and ~a}:~ li',at.eri~ls for the
purposes of ccnstructi~g, operating and maintainins drain~ge
facilities thereon.
IN W!'l'NESS ;:rrEr:r:OF, Gra!1tor h2S saus8d this Drainag(~
Easement to be executed the day and year first above written.
~ffi~
ROBERT S, HARDY /
John .t.
~
Re~~cca Jane M~Kav
STATE OF FLORInA .
COUNTY OF COLLIER, 55.
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer
duly authorized in the state aforesaid and in the county aLoresaid
to take ackncwledge~ent5, personally appeared ROBERT S. HARDr, to
me known to be the person described in and who executed the.
foregoing instrument aTld acknowledged before me that he executed"
the same for the purpcEe therein expressed.
WITNESS my hand and official sea
aforesaid this ~ c.ay of July, 1991.
'.. :i
;jJ
,.,
Notary
fo:G,~,"f N~i 1: ~~.'~< (' ,; My COllU 'ssion Expires:
1:"1 C1ll!MISSIO:l [::'. ~w~. ;;,' , John" S t 1
&millJ) THI', "OE::::r:I,l, If;:'. ".-". ' . . an ey
No.
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. cJ9
;~-~~~~~~"
]
5
.<;
.~
..,
;~
..
..,
~
WILSON, I\HLLER, BARTON & PEEK, INC.
En;;i= p~ Surveyon. '..arodoca::o:: Arch.il<:CU, Envi,onnxnu.! CDruulwlu &:. Constr.xti<>n MI.lUi'="
"'.loon ~lc...:..,. s,.;,.:;no. :2!:lllloil<y u... '" Air.'<-' Rood. N<;>I<s. F1on<!.a )3942. 1!131 ~ Fu 111J)f>''\.I''~
~
'...~
.~
Deacript10n of part of Quail Creek Pl~~a Phase I
PInt Book 15, rags 73, Collier CQunty, Florid~
r1rainaqe Eal!arnent
-(;
~
... ~
"L.~
.~
.....
.~
^ll t~~~ p~rt of Tr~c~ A of Qu~il Cre~k Plaza Ph~8e I ~ccording
the plet ther~of ae r9co~ded in Plat Boo~ 15, p~geB 73, Public
Recore:! of Collier Cotmt:/. Florida, being morc particularly
d06cribed dB fo1Io~~;
the north 12 feet of the south 22 feet of 3a:.d Tract A.
:~
'~,4
.~;
WILSON, MILLP.~,' BARTON " PEEK, INC.
Roq. Engineer~ and ~nd Surveyors
BY ~~ DATE
\~ E. Eo~t"''ell, P.L.S. t!3934
~(~7/""1
~l.,t valid unlel!6 e::lOOBSOO with the Professional's se51.
W.O.
Ref:
Datel
10185.2
r.B. 15, pace 73
June 27, i991
(JEB:kjd phase 1 qu~i1 creek plaza deec)
lecei.,ed $
"leceived ~
.\n()
\..II A-
i1r,cun"l'l"ol;t,\' ::rafll;' 1 cD,
ClilSC: "C" 111:"I",o':IL If!
Per",0rtdl ~r0~'~'f:\' T.lX
-::'"-c 0_,' 'i~
a :::> l
;:0 =
::n CT. ;
a II:.
a c.....:> "
;y; ':..r.) t
to t
.,
r
\
,
~
C")
ro,
=
=
N)
.",..
=
'-'-'
:OlLlER COUNTY CLERK or CCUR,S
AY 1 Q...,.,..., ~'1c.Jrr..."-.I\~. ::>c.
0~ft-
:..:.:-:.-----
RH(lt'O('(J'''od'i'''lftfld
'"~IC'...ft~cts....1
ClllllEA COUNT'r, rLORIO'>'
JAMtS C CILi!'S. CLlR.
~ 'ri. _. P.E.. "'_ L _ P.E.._ L..... P.L. P.LS.. w_ ".~J,_P,L.S..CIiIIoN H._,PL. """ D.a.,-. A.LCP.
..... D. ....... A.LCP.. o.r, L 0-. CPA. .... A. Di.u. P.E.. )oM E. ___ F.LS. . Tloo;o5Il. NG;lo. P.L . _ J. -. C"C
..... H. 0.0... P.LS. . _ L _ P.L. PlLD.. !..... A. _ P.E. . .._ C Lo...... P.LS, . T..,. r. -. r.l. . __ L...... P.E.
: ::::;~. ..,~ ,.; (~.:",.> ,,: ":...~,: '.; '.:<~.~ "'~"':::";' .:?:~':~.: ;,~.:fi :~~~~~.:r~. ~
: :'''~ ";"'~..\f i.(\,.(.'i;.lt....i"). "'. ..n~i ?:( ..~~':r..;o;.?;:.,::~,:...:. ~'","-:~'" ~r.;" ~;,:;:i ..,':, ~... ~ ......
857
AGENDA ITEM
No. 11 C
MAR 2 3 1999
3D
Pg.
;~f;~2:;0;;f~1~i~~~It~~.{.
RESOL~TION ~O. 91---132-
(.:,:~-
[': je.d:
t;r;;..:_
.. ,
;~:O.( 5Q..Y
RESOLUTI0N FOR PETITION AV 91-014 TO VhCATE A
PORTION Of A DHAIrIAGE AIm l"u\H.TENANCE E,'-SE!1c:..T
!"oCATED ON THE PLAT OF Ql'AIL CREEK PLAZA PIlAS;O:
J: AS :<ECORCED IN I'Ll,T ROClK 15, PAG~: 73 OF TilE
PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER C0UNTY, FLORIDA.
=
0-,
'->.0
WHEREAS, pUrS1.l37\t to sectior. i77.101, r::"crida S~(jt.ute~, Fermin
L~ ~. Di~z as ~gent 10r Q~nec, Rob2rt S. H~~dy, Qv~S he~cbi rcq~cst
'"
,~).:
the v~cation of a portion of T~act IIAII, a drain~ge and rnaintcn~ncc
::,
easement
1 oC<:'.tr>c. on
plat of Quail
::>
C1
Creek Pl~z~
portion o~ the
a
'.-' Ph;,::e 1 ,,:; rcc-crd"d in Plat Doo~, 15, page 7 J, of the Pub), ic Records
", ~
~ l)
fl.
of Collic~ c~u~ty, Florida; a~d
,
."
3
j
~
..,
;,
~HEREAS, the Board has this day }lcld a public h~aring to
consider vacating a portion of s~id plat as ~ore fully d~scribed
1
;1
:.:;
...
.~
~
-~
~
'.oj
~~
:;;.
~
~
'~
"'-..,'
,~i;---
~i'
!}
,,;1
,~
i
,~
Ie
'"
..
belc.;..'r
said public hearing
to vacate '..as
given as
and r.otice
or
= >-
('-...; ;:-
~ .-
(--..; (.-~
C") '-
v-; ..
= -
required by law; and
vacatio:l .....ill
granting
net
adversely
of
vniEp.EAS r
the
the
right
acc~ss
of
other
o~'r,ership
con-;en:c-nt
affect
t::e
cf
or
property owners.
80A".D
OF
COUIlTY
!~O;...~ I
TP.EREFORE,
BE
IT
R~SC!..V:::D
B':O
TP.E
COY:~ISSI0!rERS
FLORIDA,
that
th('
following
OF
COLLIER
COUNTY.
portio~ of said plat be and is herehy v~catcd;
See Exhibit "An,
incorporated herein
atta-:hed
hereto
and
BE
IT FeRnIER RES0L'l'20, that tl::e Clerk
is hereby directed to
this ResC'luti.cn
in
the Public R~ccrds
of C~llier County,
record
Florida and to make proper r.0tation~ of this vacation on said plat.
after motion,
sf.::cond arid
majority vote
This
Resclucicn
adopted
favoring S3:ne.
..
'0
Cl
~ ,.
IS;;, DATED: /.;/.2--/1.<
\ ATTEST:
~ J_AI-lES C. GILES,:Cl€:rk
~ 1f:~~-r-~ ,~__1~C~
~ APp;oved as to form and legal
~ st:fficienc~-:
U-..<) ~,~_,-_.~
Richard D. y~ anovich
Assistant County Attorney
BO~D OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUN Y, FLORIDA
BY " 'l.A~
P~TRICIA GOOD IGHT, hairman
-v
f\
"
2344
,~c, ..'
'," __i.
",
~~~~~ ...~w>...~~'-.~;,;:.:;~:J, ~J~:t:~';:/~'.iSs'/:~c~;t. :j.L~Z~:~" !',!.,',:t...) :~','. ".
t., 1
-"!.-....~.~.~~~:nr.,l't..~.~,..,..,....~
---~."'~,~~~
.... ".". ~ ,-"" ....: "" . .. ... \. '... "'< ,... '... ..... ,~ .';.. ;.-.";.a"
r
f
r:
!
I
~
t
~
~S3
\)1=1 c q9-00~J..
AGEND'" ITEM
No. 17 C
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. ~I
.,
JAN 12 1999 12:28 FR QUARLES - BRADY LLP
941 4344998 TO 96436968
,..~:!.'l!~:J:012~:;'}\~f!~f~!~gL..'
-0-
I
EXl'IIBI't -A-
WILSON~ MILLER. BARTON & PEEK. INC.
----- -----."'.- --
1!!\~i"C"!'f"'lI:. rl"nncf"!l:, SurW'~r.u. t "mf~:'Ir-: ~'ml~1~C'1C'. f.",';rfll'll"rnl.,t C""-'IIIi1nt( /.1 l.'nn'trtJC1iOf1 M,10_r.t,...
W;"'~II't"f.,.........~1 (4""kt. :~'IC'~, :\~;).~.'lII:"t' i...... M ...."ro.n n..,'\oi. '''ar''''. IIIH"l:a '~l~.. 1'lI1'1/"'lI..vw't' "'. ""1 M'."i7r..
Delll;:rlption ot p<lrt ot 0\1(111 C(f,!~1c: Pta:!il
Phase 1, P_B. 15, page 73,
Colli~r County. Yloridd
Tract "A" (to b~ vDcnLPd)
.1\11 Qf 'tract -A" of Quail Creek plaza phQI3~ 1 acc':'lrdin'] 1;0 I:hQ plat
thereof as recorded in P.B. 15, page 73, Public Reco=ds of COlll~~
County. Florida;
RETnINING the~ein
tho existillg plattp.d 10 foot utility OlllJementll ~n th::: nQ~th and.
8Q~th of said Tr4ct "A"
AND I<.ES~nV:lN~ 'I'1I!:l\f:'1'O
th~ no~th 12 f.QRt of th~ 8o~th ~2 fCQt. o! T(~c~ "A" for drainage
Q~sement purpQ'e~.
WILSON. M!LLRR, S~TON , PE~K, INC.
Reg. EnqlnGOrS and Land surveyors
~' 1
BY I ,-, '~.dLl OAT& ~~f:t7 /99/
oh' 8.: ,B,IOl\at",!,~i.~1p.t.-:rr:t:l934 "
~!~ ". -:,"'1'. .
Not val!:a ~.nl~ss', embolllled with the Proflilu j,on~l' I SQ,'l.
. .. "'..
904'0' "':1
4L-B41 (JEBlkjd
~uqL..t :27, 1991
W.O.
RQf!
Datel
quail cre~~ p!~~~ t~.et a vacated)
.......,_.."'-l_.11i'1
......... --......~
tl'Y:uHIt 1)..~..'~\'1. htJllfl\l.
Ji.~~c,c. (ou.I.\ t;\Polijl
1II.1\~1 \\' "IUf', I' f.' W~......I.IbR"'1 r,T.. , "'"..., Jt rtr\, r,r., r.1 :" . Wllm. ", \"I"I\II~...lr, l" 1 :" .. (l~lh..1f It "c!'l-r.'ttIln, ''.1',. .'\1." n .r,m.",l'I 1.(",1"
",.....!l .........1.. ,(' 1" . l"oJI'> I p,..n, ('".r.A .. '.n.... All...," r , lotll. r "n.n....'". r 1 !Ii . ,,.,<<Lol., !lt~.., r, ,~lru..1 r.lI.....~ f" A t'"
rrul fl. '''''''''.I',r.~ .. J~~ t to.4..""",.II.I'. to.. h . :ro."I"......... 'h_.. ".f I ...j,....rl ~ ,...........1-1 " . 1..,"11.. t" h..."..... ,..... .. n........1 r ._........ F
5~
O-C"l
;;;r. w
-
"1J '-
>-
C;
m =
.'
-~~
I
---..-.... ....;,
.'. ..... ~, ..:'...,; ".. .:.~.;t'..,..'~.:.:',:~,: ,',::,-...... . '.,;.:. "..";' ~. '.:..
'. . , .' . , . ,'.., ':~.~.'.' .'~{ \' '
';';':~,/'~:'::",>": ,." . ., '~'
.".. .. ",. :.' _~.'. :~.'~~)):~'j'.' .r. "
.~,. ..'...~..',~..~..::,:I,:..":;.'C.,~,,.,;:','.,:...::~.,.",.:"":..~,,. :..~. ~ . ..i:~. ..' I.".
- . <\,!:i::/~~)\)~~::,;:'~": '~':'; .; :':;'
, ... \.. .. \ .. ;"':~' '.
. \~.
.:'.:;
.i.".
." ,'.....
,- ~ I,.
. .....::.;;
.:
. , '. ' . . ~.
-' ;'..
~, '.:
.:..,.....
",
\. ....'.'
... ,~
.....,.
,~,:. ;-~;,1~~':~! :.
, ';-;, ~..... ~.:..."
. ~ ., ~'.
, '
P.02/02
~S4
~
AGENDA ITEM
No. /1 c....
MAR 2 3 t999
Pg. 3~
** TOTAL PAGE.02 **
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
/.....-' .
AMEND THE PARK IMPACT FEE ORDINANCE TO ELIMINATE THE
COLLECTION OF COMMUNITY PARK IMPACT FEES IN THE MARCO
ISLAND DISTRICT.
Objective: That the Board of County Commissioners amend the Park Impact Fee
Ordinance, 88-96 as amended, to remove the community park impact fee in Marco
Island.
Consideration: The City of Marco Island began issuing their own building pennits
and collecting community park impact fees effective October 1, 1998, the same day that
the County deeded all community and neighborhood parks located in Marco Island to the
City. The enclosed amendment cleans up the County Parks and Recreational Facilities
Impact Fee Ordinance, 88-96 as amended, to reflect that the County no longer collects
community park impact fees within the City of Marco Island.
Growth Management: None
..--
Fiscal Impact: Both revenues and estimated expenses will be reduced by an
estimated $172,000 annually. The County will no longer collect the estimated $172,000
annual revenue for community park impact fees generated in Marco Island~ subsequently,
the County will no longer expense said dollar amount on any community park projects
within the City,
Recommendation: That the Board amend the current park impact fee ordinance to
reflect that community park impact fees will no longer be collected.
Prepared by:
Date: Z/2.2-/9C?
John Dunnuck, Operations Coordinator
Department of Parks and Recreation
Reviewed and
Approved by: ' ~ ,,41.1-
Milrla Ramsey, Director
Department of Parks and Recreation
Date: -z.. ZZ .91
Reviewed and
Approved by:
Thomas W, Olliff, Ad ator
Division of Public Servi es
Date: :3 ,q4ar
,-.
Agenda ~m
No ..J.7
. I
MAR 2 3 1999
Pg. / -
- -
1 ORDII\'ANCE NO. 99-_
2
_~ AN ORDIl'ANCE AMENDING COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE
I\'O. 811-96. AS AMEI\'DED, RELATING TO THE COLLIER
COVl'ITY PARKS AI'\D RECREATIONAL FACILITIES IMPACT
6 FEE ORDINANCE; A.l\1ENDlNG APPENDIX A, IMPACT FEE
7 RATES, TO REMOVE A COMMUNITY PARK IMPACT FEE IN
8 MARCO ISLAND; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT AND
9 SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN THE CODE
10 OF LAWS AI'\D ORDINANCES; AND BY PROVIDING FOR AN
11 EFFECTIVE DATE.
12
13
14 WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners finds that there is no longer a need in
15 Marco Island for additional Community Parks; and
16 WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners desires to remove the community park
17 impact fee in the Marco Island :lrea,
18 NOW, THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
19 COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA thai:
20
SECTION ONE:
/u\1ENDMENT TO APPENDIX.
21 Appendix A of Collier County Ordinance No. 88-96, as amended, shall be amended as
follows:
APPENDIX A
24
IMPACT FEE RATES
25
A.
All Parks and Recreational Facilities Impact ConstIuctioI1 within the
26 unincorporated area and within the boundaries of all municipalities shall pay the following
27 Regional Park Impact Fee:
28
Upon Effective Date of this Ordinance $179/Dwelling Unit
29
B,
All Parks and Recreational Facilities Impact Construction occurring within the
30 Immokalee Community Park District gllii the Naples and Urban Collier County Community Park
31 District and the Marco Communit)' Parl~ Distriot shall pay the following Community Park Impact
32 Fee:
33
Upon Effective Date of this Ordinance $399/Dwelling Unit
34
c.
All Parks and Recreational Facilities Impact Constnlction occurrin~ within the
35 Marco Community Park District shall pay no Community Park Impact Fee subiect to the
~lo.:cd.s
, ". ,
~nce-= _'::-'.~:J.
--.-
6::e ,.dci::.:::;ns,
""-Jords
.:Jtruol( throu~ are deletions.
Agendl 13'.
No . 1"'7 '?
MAR 2 3 1999
PQ. ex.
-
- -
subsequent reviews orthe Ordjn~rl Impact Fee Study pursuant to Section 4 09
1
SECTION TWO:
CONFLICT Al'\'D SEVERABILITY.
2 In the event this OnJinance conflicts with any other ordinance of Col1i~r County or other
applicable law, the more restnctivc shall apply. If any phrase or portion of the ordinance is held
4 invalid or unconstitutional by any co un of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a
5 separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the
6 remaining ponion.
7
8
SECTION THREE
INCLt.:SION IN THE CODE OF LAWS AND
ORDI;-..;ANCES,
9 The provision of this Ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Laws
10 and Ordinances of Collier County. Florida. The sections of the Ordinance may be renumbered or
II relettered to accomplish such, and the work "ordinance" may be changed to "section", "article",
12 or any other appropriate word.
13
SECTION FOt.:R:
EFFECTIVE DATE.
14 This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the Department of State.
15 PASSED Al'\TI DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier
16 County, Florida, this _ day of __, 1999.
17
18 ATTEST:
19 DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
PAMELA S, MAC' KIE, .Chait"Woman
Approved as to fonn and
legal sufficiency:
fb ;; 1'<
dL Jilt (/'-
Hei 1 F, Ashton
Assistant County Attorney
h:hglhfa/ordlI999iAmenc Ord So. 88-96 Marco I,). Parks & Rec Fac.
Words C~8er"O~e8 6re e880~08~S, words ~thre~~fl are deletions,
2
Agenda ~m
No. I?
- . I
MAR 2 3 1999
PQ. ;}~