Petition CP-2008-4 & CP-2009-1
11.( III1IIIIIIIII111111111111
.' .. "<,- ........ ?'.",-:' ->",: ./,-, ......: ',,<'. .'.".c., 'j"-,- :",-,::-,: -,.-,",: c"'>. '.:.,.-.; .:....:- :.'<", <_, ,:".:' ..-..-:::.. :'-:: :,':.: ,':C',: ".._ ...... .."
COLLIERCOUNTY
Growth Management Plan Amendments
2007.. 2008
Combined Cycle
&
Petition CP..2009..1
TRANSMITTAL HEARINGS
BCC: January 19, 2010
CO.'EII'S:
P.~i~ions CP.2008.4 l CP.200'.1
APPLICATION FOR A REQUEST TO AMEND
THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN
PETITION NUMBER CP-2co~-4_ DA TE RECEIVED-A!2~Of)
PRE-APPLICATION CONFERENCE DATE 4/:2-1/0'0
DATE SUFFICIENT r/ 1 ,") / nq I
PLANNER ASSIGNED: '0n~hl' ~JniY\;ritl AI0.P
COMMISSION DISTRICT: 5, - J rO~tt:()
[ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF]
This application, with all required supplemental data and information, must be completed and
accompanied by the appropriate fee, and returned to the Comprehensive Planning Section,
2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida 34104. Phone: (941 )403-2300; Fax: (941 )643-
6869.
The application must be reviewed by staff for sufficiency within 30 calendar days following the
filing deadline before it will be processed and advert ised for public hearing. The applicant will
be notified, in writing, of the sufficiency determ ination. If insufficient, the applicant w ill have 30
days to remedy the deficiencies. For additional information on the processing of the application,
see Resolution 97-431 (attached). If you have any questions, please contact the
Comprehensive Planning Section at 941-403-2300.
SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS
t GENERAL INFORMATION
A. Name of Applicant(s) John & Teresa Fillmore
Company
Fillmore LLC
Mailing Address 2250 Washburn Avenue
City: Naples
State: Florida Zip Code: 34117
Phone Number: 239-352-7888 Fax Number: 239-352-4649
B. Name of Agent" Dwicht Nadeau
"THIS WILL BE THE PERSON CONTACTED FOR ALL BUSINESS RELATED
TO THE PETITION.
Company/Firm RWA. Inc.
Mailing Address 6610 Willow Park Drive
City: Naples State: Florida Zip Code 34109
Phone Number: 239-597-0575 Fax Number: 239-597-0578
Email Address:dhn(ci)consult-rwa.com
5:\2008\080073.00.00 YahlMukhing GMPA\0003 CPA Application 5u1'1'ort\2009-9-3 GMP Amendment Application Form.doc
APPLICATION FOR A REQUEST TO AMEND
THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN
PETITION NUMBER
DA TE RECEIVED
PRE-APPLICATION CONFERENCE DATE
DATE SUFFICIENT
PLANNER ASSIGNED:
COMMISSION DISTRICT:
[ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF]
This application, with ali required supplemental data and information, must be completed and
accompanied by the appropriate fee, and returned to the Comprehensive Planning Section,
2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida 34104. Phone: (941 )403-2300; Fax: (941 )643-
6869.
The application must be reviewed by staff for sufficiency within 30 calendar days following the
filing deadline before it will be processed and advertised for public hearing. The applicant will
be notified, in writing, of the sufficiency determination. If insufficient, the applicant w ill have 30
days to remedy the deficiencies. For additional information on the processing of the application,
see Resolution 97-431 (attached). If you have any questions, please contact the
Comprehensive Planning Section at 941-403-2300.
SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS
t GENERAL INFORMATION
A. Name of Applicant(s) John & Teresa Fillmore
Company
Fillmore LLC
Mailing Address 2250 Washburn Avenue
City: Naples
State: Florida Zip Code: 34117
Phone Number: 239-352-7888 Fax Number: 239-352-4649
B. Name of Agent" Dwiaht Nadeau
"THIS WILL BE THE PERSON CONTACTED FOR ALL BUSINESS RELATED
TO THE PETITION.
Company/Firm RWA. Inc.
Mailing Address 6610 Willow Park Drive
City: Naples State: Florida Zip Code 34109
Phone Number: 239-597-0575 Fax Number: 239-597-0578
Email Address:dhnla>consult-rwa.com
S:\2008\080073.00.00 Yahl Mulching GMPA\OO03 CPA Application Support\2009-9-3 GMP Amendment Application Form.doc
C. Name of Owner(s) of Record: Fillmore LLC.
Mailing Address: 2250 Washburn Avenue
City: Naples State: Florida Zip Code: 34117
Phone Number: 239-352-7888 Fax Number: 239-352-4649
D. Name, Address and Qualifications of additional planner, architects, engineers,
environmental consultants and other professionals providing information
contained in this application.
Dwight Nadeau, Planning Manager
RWA, inc.
6610 Willow Park Drive
Naples, FL 34109
Reed K. Jarvi,
Omega Consulting Group
3365 Woods Edge Circle
Unit 102
Bonita Springs, FL 34134
Michael R. Ramsey,
Ramsey Inc.
2631 4th St. NW
Naples, FL 34120
II DISCLOSURE OF INTEREST INFORMATION:
A. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety,
tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership interest as
well as the percentage of such interest. (Use additional sheets if necessary).
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
S:\2008\080073.00.00 Yahl J\lulching GMPA \0003 CPA Application SUppOfl\2009-9.3 GMP Amendment Application I-'orm.doc
2
B. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders
and the percentage of stock owned by each, and provide one copy of the Articles
of Incorporation, or other documentation, to verify the signer of this petition has
the authority to do so.
Name and Address, and Office
Percentage of Stock
C. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with
the percentage of interest.
Name and Address
Percentage of I nteres t
D. If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list
the name of the general and/or limited partners. See Attachment N
Name and Address
John Fillmore
Percentage of Ownership
50 %
Teresa Fillmore
50%
E. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a
Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contact purchasers
below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners, and provide
one copy of the executed contr act.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
F. If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all
individuals or officers, if a corporation, partnership or trust.
Name and Address
S:\2008\OB0073.00.00 Yahl Mulching GMPA\0003 CPA Application Support\2009-9-3 GMP Amendment Application Form.doc
3
G. Date subject property acquired (April 10, 2003) leased ( ):_
Terms of lease_yrs/mos.
If Petitioner has option to buy, indicate date of option:_ and date
option terminates: , or anti cipated closing date
H. NOTE: Shouid any changes of ow nership or changes in contracts for purchase
occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final
public hearing, it is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to
submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form.
III. DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY
A. Legal Description: A PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN SECTION 31. TOWNSHIP 49
SOUTH. RANGE 27 EAST. COLLIER. COUNTY, FLORIDA. BEING MORE
PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
COMMENCING AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE SOUTHWEST
QUARTER OF SECTION 31. TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH. RANGE 27 EAST.
THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE SOUTHWEST QUARTER OF
SAID SECTION 31. NORTH 89'58'41" EAST. A DISTANCE OF 343.00 FEET
TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF THE PARCEL OF LAND HEREIN
DESCRIBED: THENCE CONTINUING ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF THE
SOUTHWEST QUARTER OF THE SOUTHWEST QUARTER OF SAID
SECTION 31. SOUTH 89'59"49" EAST. A DISTANCE OF 1029.30 FEET:
THENCE SOUTH 02'04'30" EAST. A DISTANCE OF 658.93 FEET: THENCE
NORTH 89'58'14" WEST. A DISTANCE OF 342.85 FEET: THENCE SOUTH
02'05'32" EAST. A DISTANCE OF 558.99 FEET: THENCE NORTH 89'57'41"
WEST. A DISTANCE OF 1029.48 FEET: THENCE NORTH 02'07'49" WEST. A
DISTANCE OF 558.60 FEET: THENCE SOUTH 89'58'27" EAST. A DISTANCE
OF 343.20 FEET: THENCE NORTH 02'03'36" WEST. A DISTANCE OF 658.67
FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
CONTAINING 1.252.915 SQUARE FEET. OR 28.763 ACRES. MORE OR LESS.
SURVEY INFORMATION PROVIDED BY RHODES AND RHODES LAND
SURVEYING. INC.
B.
Section: ~ Township: 49 South
Range: 27 East
C. Tax I.D. Number (Folio #) 00341920409 (Previous Folio combined on Mav 18.
2006 #'s 00337520004.00338600004.00341360001,00341920409.
00341920302.0037040005.00341040004).
D. General Location N of 1-75 E of 951 Located on White Lake Blvd
E.
Planning Community Rural Estates
F. TAZ 228
G.
Size in Acres
District.
28.76
H. Zoning A. Aaricultural
S:\2008\080073.00,OO Yahl Mulching GI\1PA\0003 CPA Application Suppon\2009-9-3 GMP Amendment Application Form.doc
4
I. Present Future Land Use Map Designation (s) AQricultural/Rural Desianation;
Rural Frinae Mixed Use District: Sendina Lands
IV. TYPE OF REQUEST
A. Growth Management Plan Element(s) OR Sub-Element(s) to be amended:
x
Future Land Use
Immokalee Area Master Plan
Transportation
Coastal & Conservation
Intergovernmental Coord.
Sanitary Sewer
Drainage
Golden Gate Area Master Plan
__ Capital Improvement
Housing
Recreation & Open Space
Potable Water
Solid Waste
Natural Groundwater Aquifer
B. Amend Page(s) 94, Overlavs and Special Features.125. Future Land Use Map,
and North Belle Mead Overlav Map of the Future Land Use Element As
Follows: ( Use Cress tFiretJllRs to identify language to be deleted; Use Underline
to identify language to be added). Attach additional pages if
necessary: Please see Attachment B. B-1 and Attachment B-2
C. Amend Future Land Use Map(s) designation,
FROM: Aaricultural/Rural Desianation. Rural Frinae Mixed Use District - Sendina
Lands
TO:
Lands
Aaricultural/Rural Desianation. Rural Frinae Mixed Use District - Neutral
Please See Attachment A. Narrative Statement
[If new District and/or Sub-district proposed, include Future Land Use Map with
legend depicti ng it].
D. Amend other Map(s) and Exhibits as follows: (Name & Page #)
Paae 125. Future Land Use Map. and North Belle Mead Overlav Map Please see
Attachment B and B-1.
E. Describe additional changes requested:
V. REQUIRED INFORMATION
Note: All Aerials must be at a scale of no smaller than 1" = 400', At least one copy
reduced to 8 'j, x 11 shall be provided of all aerials and/or maps.
A. LAND USE
1. Attachment C Provided general location map showing surrounding
developments (PUD, DRI'S, existing zoning) with subject property outlined.
2. Attachment 0 Provide most recent aerial of site showing subject boundaries,
source, and date.
S:\2008\080073.00,00 Yahl Mulching GMPA\0003 CPA Application Support\2009-9-3 GMP Amendment Application Form.doc
5
3. Attachment E Provide a map and summary table of existing land use and
zoning within a radius of 500 feet from boundar ies of subject property.
B. FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION
1. Attachment F Provide map of existing Future Land Use Designation(s) of
Subject property and adjacent lands, with acreage totals for each
land use designation on the subject property.
C. ENVIRONMENTAL
1. Attachment G Provide most recent aerial and summary table of acreage of
Native habitats and soils occurring on site.
HABITAT IDENTIFICATION
MUST BE CONSISTENT WITH THE FOOT-FLORIDA LAND USE,
COVER AND FORMS CLASSIFICATION SYSTEMM (FLUCCS
CODE). NOTE: THIS MAY BE INDICATED ON SAME AERIAL AS
THE LAND USE AEIRAL IN "A" ABOVE.
2. Attachment G Provide a summary table of Federal (US Fish & Wildlife Service)
and State (Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission)
iisted plant and anim al species known to occur on the site and/or
known to inhabit biological communities similar to the site (e.g.
panther or black bear range, avian rookery, bird migratory route,
etc.).
3. Attachment 0 Identify historic and lor archaeological sites on the subject
property. Provide copy of County's Historical/Archaeological
Probability Map and correspondence from Florida Department of
State.
D. GROWTH MANAGMENT
Reference 9J-11.006, F .A.C. and Collier County's Capital Improvement
Element Policy 1.1.2 (Copies attached). INSERT "Y" FOR YES OR "N" FOR
NO IN RESPONSE TO THE FOLLOWING:
1. N
2. N
3. N
4. N
5. Y
is the proposed am endment located in an Area of Critical State
Concern? (Reference 9J-11.006(1 )(a)7.a, FAC.) If so, identify
area iocated in ACSC.
Is the proposed am endment directly related to a proposed
Development of Regional Impact pursuant to Chapter 380, F .S.?
Is the proposed am endment directly related tot a proposed Small
Scale Deveiopment Activity pursuant to Subsection
163.3187(1)(c), F.S.? (Reference 9J-11.006(1)(a)7.b, FAC.)
Does the pr oposed amendment create a significant impact in
population which is defined as a potential increase in County
wide population by m ore than 5% of population pr ojections?
(Reference Capital Improvement Element Policy 1.1.2). If yes,
indicate mitigation measures being proposed in conjunction with
the proposed am endment.
Does the proposed land use cause an increase in density and/or
intensity to the uses permitted in a specific land use designation
S:\2008\080073.00.00 Yahl Mulching GMPA\OO03 CPA Application SUppoI"t\2009-9-3 GMP L\mendmcnt Application Form.doc
6
and district/subdistrict identified (commercial, industrial, etc.), or
is the proposed la nd use a new land use designation or
district/subdistrict? (Reference Rule 9J-5.006(5) FAC.). If
so, provide data and analysis to support the suitability of land for
the proposed use, and com patibility of use with surrounding
land uses, and as it concer ns protection of environmentally
sensitive land, ground water and natural resources. (Reference
Rule 9J-1.007, FAC.).
E. PUBLIC FACILITIES
1. Attachment H Provide the existing adopted Level of Service Standard (LOS,
and document the impact the proposed change will have on
that Standard, for each of the following public facilities:
a) x Potable Water
b) x Sanitary Sewer
c) Attachment J Arterial & Collector Roads: Name of specific road and
LOS
d)
e)
f)
Dr ainage
Solid Waste
Parks: Community and Regional
If the proposed amendment involves an increase in residential density,
or an increase in intensity for commercial and/or industrial development
that would cause the LOS for public facilities to fall below the adopted
LOS, indicate mitigation measures being proposed in conjunction with
the proposed amendment. (Reference Capital Improvement Element
Policy 1.1.2 and 1.1.5).
2. Attachment I Provide a map showing the location of exisli ng services and
public facilities that will serve the subject property (I.e. water,
sewer, fire protection, police protection, schools and
emergency medical services).
3. Attachments H & A Document proposed services and public facilities, identify
provider, and describe the effect the proposed change will
have on schools fire protection and emergency medical
services.
F. OTHER
Identify the following areas relating to the subject property:
1. Attachment K Flood zone based on Flood Insurance Rate Map data (FIRM).
2. NA Location of well fields and cones of influence, if appli cable. (Identified on
Collier County Zoning Maps).
3. NA Traffic Congestion Boundary, if applicable
4. NA Coastal Management Boundary, if applicable
S:\2008\ORlKl73.0000 Yahl Mulching GMPA\OO03 CPA Application Support\2009-9-3 GMP Amendment Application Form.doc
7
5. NA
High Noise Contours (65 LDN or higher) surrounding the Naples Airport,
if applicable (Identified on Collier County Zoning Maps).
G. SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION
1. x $16,700.00 non-refundable filing fee, made payable to the Board of
County Commissioners, due at time of submittal.
2. NA
$9,000.00 non-refundable filing fee for a Small Scale Amendment,
made payable to the Board of County Commissioners, due at time of
submittal.
3. x Plus Legal Advertisement Costs (Your portion determined by number of
petitions and divided accordingly)
4. Attachment M Proof of ownership (Copy of deed).
5. Attachment L Notarized Letter of Authorization if Agent is not the Owner (see
attached form).
6. x 1 Original and 5 complete, signed applications with all attachments,
including maps, at time of submittal. After sufficiency is completed, 15
copies of the complete application will be required. Additional copies
may be required.
" Maps, aerials, sketches shall include: North arrow; name and location of principal roadways;
shall be at scale of 1" = 400' or at a scale as determined during the pre-application meeting;
identification of the subject site; legend or key, if applicable. All oversized documents and
attachments must be folded so as to fit into a legal-size folder. For all oversized exhibits, at
least one copy must be submitted at 8-1/2 x 11 inches. Ail exhibits and attachments to the
petition must include a title and exhibit # or letter, and must be referenced in the petition.
S:\200!:\\080U73_00.(]() Yahl Mulching GMP.A\0003 CPA Appliclltion Support\2009-9-3 GMP .Amendment Application Form_doc
8
Amendment to the Collier County Growth Management Plan
Fillmore Recycling
Collier County, FL
Attachment A
Narrative Statement
for
Fillmore Recycling GMP Amendment
The subject property consists of +/- 28.7 acres and is located on Washburn Avenue and White
Lake Boulevard, in Section 31, Township 49, Range 27, Collier County, Florida (See
Attachment C "General Location Map"). The subject property is zoned "A", Rural
Agricultural District and is partially cleared and improved with the existing Yahl Mulching and
Recycling facilities. (See Attachment D "Aerial FLUCFCS Map"). The adjacent properties
include agricultural land uses (i.e.: single family homes, plant nursery and truck barn) to the
north and east, Collier County and State right-of-way to the south, and Collier County Land Fill
facility to the west, (See Attachment E "Existing Zoning and Land Use"). The property is in
the AgriculturallRural Designation; Rural Fringe Mixed Use District (RFMUD); North Belle
Meade Overlay (NBMO) - Non Natural Resource Protection Area (Non-NRPA) Sending Lands
of the Collier County Growth Management Plan (GMP) Future Land Use Map (FLUM) (See
Attachment F "Future Land Use Map").
Agricultural:
The purpose of the "A", Rural Agricultural District Land Use Designation is to provide lands for
agricultural, pastoral, and rural land uses by accommodating traditional agricultural, agricultural
related activities and facilities, support facilities related to agricultural needs, and conservation
uses. Uses that are generally considered compatible to agricultural uses that would not endanger
or damage the agricultural, environmental, potable water, or wildlife resources of the County are
permissible as conditional uses in the "A" District.
Rural Fringe Mixed Use District (RFMUD):
The challenges and goals of the RFMUD are to provide transition between the Urban and Estates
designated lands, and between the Urban and AgriculturallRural and Conservation designated
lands. The RFMUD employs a balanced approach, including both regulations and incentives, to
protect natural resources and private property rights, providing for large areas of open space, and
allowing, in designated areas, appropriate types, density and intensity of development. The
RFMUD allows for a mixture of urban and rural levels of service, including limited extension of
central water and sewer, schools, recreational facilities, commercial uses and essential services
deemed necessary to serve the residents of the District.
While not proposed in this petition, the RFMUD allows the Transfer of Development Rights
(TDR) process that provides an equitable method of protecting and conserving the most valuable
environmental lands, including large connected wetland systems and significant areas of habitat
for listed species, while allowing property owners of such lands to recoup lost value and
development potentiaL Within the RFMUD, residential density may be transferred from lands
5:\2001\080073,00.00 YUlI Mulching GMPA\OOOl CPA Appliulion\2009-S-14_Numive,doc
- 1 -
D\XT ^ '" ::'.t'._
.i(~~rr_,~"''l =1
Amendment to the Collier County Growth Management Plan
Fillmore Recycling
Collier County, FL
designated as Sending Lands to lands designated as Receiving Lands on the Future Land Use
Map. Residential density may not be transferred either from or into areas designated as Neutral
Lands through the TDR process. Sending Lands designation are those lands that have the highest
degree of environmental value and sensitivity, and generally include significant wetland,
uplands, and habitat for listed species.
North Belle Meade Overlav (NBMO):
The North Belle Meade area is surrounded by Golden Gate Estates to the north, east, and west
and 1-75 to the south. The NBMO area is unique to the RFMUD because it is surrounded by
areas that are vested for development on three sides. Because the area is largely undeveloped
and includes substantial vegetated areas, the Sending Lands can and do provide valuable habitat
for wildlife, including endangered and threatened species. The Overlay area are also areas the
have been previously impacted by canal construction and past clearing and agricultural practices
which have altered the natural hydroperiod. The challenge of the NBMO area is to achieve a
balance of both preservation and opportunities for future development that takes into account
resource protection and the relationship between this area and the Estates.
Sendinl! Lands:
Sending Lands consist ofNRPA lands and non-NRPA lands in which residential development is
discouraged. Further, Sending lands are those areas that have the highest degree of
environmental value and sensitivity, and generally include significant wetlands, uplands, and
habitat for listed species. Endangered and threatened species located in these areas include
colonies of Red Cockaded Woodpeckers. Therefore, the protection of endangered and
threatened species including the protection of habitat, are primary planning considerations in this
area.
Neutral Lands:
Neutral Lands are neither Sending nor Receiving areas. They have been identified for limited
semi-rural residential development. Available data indicates that Neutral Lands have a higher
ratio of native vegetation, and thus higher habitat values than lands designated as Receiving
Lands, but these values do not approach those of Sending Lands. Therefore, these lands are
appropriate for limited development if such development is directed away from existing native
vegetation and habitat. As set forth in the Collier County Conservation and Coastal Management
Element of the GMP, Neutral lands shall preserve a minimum of 60% of the native vegetation
present, not to exceed 45% ofthe total site area.
S:\2008\080073,OO,OO Yahl MllkhinB GMPA\QOO2 CPA App1i~lliDn\2009.S.l4_N&ITlIti,,~.doe
- 2-
D'lT^"~,:.::~_
,~n"~"\"'l"',; F..........
.L ...., U.. .L ~"'''rAl
Amendment to the Collier County Growth Management Plan
Fillmore Recycling
Collier County, FL
Proposed Growth Manaeement Plan Amendment:
The proposed Growth Management Plan Amendment provides for the modification of the
subject property designation from Sending Lands to Neutral Lands on the Future Land Use Map.
See Attachment B "Proposed Future Land Use Map"
The proposed Neutral Lands designation will allow for the introduction of an additional intended
use of the property which is "facilities for the collection, transfer, processing and reduction of
solid waste" as described in the Neutral Lands provisions oflbe FLUE. The facility will support
receiving, crushing, sorting, and storing of construction and demolition (C&D) materials as well
as materials transfer; no actual recycling processing will occur on-site. Examples of such C&D
materials include dry wall, wood, concrete, brick, metals, PVC pipe, screen, asphalt and other
related materials. Construction and demolition waste may include packaging material and land
clearing debris. No hazardous waste or materials will be accepted o05ite. The Florida Statute
403.703 defines C&D as lbe following: ",..discarded materials generally considered to be not
water soluble and nonhazardous in nature, including but not limited to, steel, glass, brick,
asphalt roofing material, pipe, gypsum wallboard, and lumber, from the construction or
destruction of a structure as part of a construction or demolition project or from the
renovation of a structure, and including rocks, soils, tree remains, trees, and other vegetative
matter that normally results from land clearing or land development operations...",
The proposed operations will support the recycling of waste generated from construction
projects. It is estimated that C&D materials account for as much as 15% of all materials used in
a construction project. Further, it is estimated that residential construction generates upwards of
7 Ibs. of waste per square foot of construction. C&D debris accounts for 33% of solid waste
collected in lbe State of Florida each year anu only a small percentage, 20%, of this C&D waste
is currently recycled (FDEP, 2001). Recycling C&D has become important as it is cheaper than
putting C&D materials in landfills since lbe cost of using landfills has risen. A recycling facility
reduces lbe likelihood that the recyclable material will end up at the landfill and conserves the
space. Further, recycling reduces the impact of producing new materials.
Currently, there is an existing horticulture recycling operation onsite which has been in operation
since 1998. The current Conditional Use CU-2000-22, approved on June 11 th, 2002, allows for
lbe disposal and recycling of horticulture waste. Horticulture recycling operations are open to
the public and include receiving, sorting, crushing, storing and transfer of horticulture materials.
Onsite equipment includes crushers, grinders, front end loaders, backhoes, transfer equipment
and trucks. Operations occur Monday through Saturday during nonnal business hours. Two
existing homes are utilized for office and storage, however they will be demolished to
accommodate the facility expansion. The expansion of operations will allow for the continuation
of lbe existing horticulture, as well as the proposed construction and demolition recycling
operations. Further, the addition of the proposed facility will be approximately 20,000 square
feet with approximately 10 additional employees. This construction and demolition recycling
facility will utilize the same equipment and conduct similar operations as those which already
5:\2008\080073.00.00 YliIl Mulching GMPA\O(102 CPA ApplieIILon\2009-5-14_Narralivt doc:
~ 3 -
D:tT T^~~""
'\1\IJ ,',...........
cn"Sl'l.1"INc' fil>J_i'II
.........l'''...s~
Amendment to the Collier County Growth Management Plan
Fillmore Recycling
Collier County, FL
exist on site. The GMP A will provide for the future land use designation change from Sending
Lands to Neutral Lands to allow for the recycling operations of C&D materials in addition to the
existing mulching operation.
Based on the language adopted to define the Sending Lands, compared with the disturbed nature
of lands on the subject property, it is both reasonable and logical to propose the change to
Neutral Lands. Further, the subject property is located adjacent to the Collier County Landfill
located on White Lake Boulevard. The neighboring landfill property is greatly disturbed and
could have significant impacts to surrounding properties. It should be noted that the landfill is
proposed for expansion to add additional capacity over the next five to ten years. By definition,
Sending Lands are "those areas that have the highest degree of environmental value and
sensitivity". Clearly, these lands do not fall under this description considering the existing
improvements and operations on the site, in addition to the neighboring public operation of the
landfill on adjacent lands. This request is more than appropriate given the neighboring land uses.
The proposed recycling facility will maintain compatibility with surrounding land uses and
promote recycling of solid waste in an area adjacent to the Collier County LandfilL
Further, with respect to the TDR program of the Rural Fringe Mixed Use District, the existing
property owner has withheld the right to generate TDR credits from the subject property, thereby
removing 22.96 credits from the potential TDR pooL The current land use ,of the subject
property, combined with the existing 12.0 +/- acre conservation easement, effectively eliminates
the opportunity to sever TDRs for transfer. Further, as provided through the proposed Growth
Management Plan Amendment to change the subject property designation to Neutral Lands,
there will be no transfer of development rights into or out of the subject property. Therefore,
there will be no significant effect on the development potential allowed by the existing TDR
program.
Compatibility with surroundinl! land uses:
The subject property has direct access to Washburn A venue and White Lake Boulevard. The
adjacent properties consist of permitted and conditionally permitted agricultural land uses on
large parcels. The proposed expansion of recycling use on the subject property will be
compatible with the existing Collier County Landfill operations located west of the subject
property. The existing recycling operation provides adequate buffering provisions as set forth in
the County's Land Development Code, and as was required in the prior Conditional Use and Site
Development Plan approvals. Further, separation distances from surrounding properties, and the
proposed location of the new C&D sorting and transfer facilities within the 28.7 +/- acre subject
property will mitigate potential noise impacts from future facility operations onto neighboring
properties. The current recycling facility has maintained a positive relationship with neighboring
property owners and no complaints in regards to on-site operations, noise, dust, odor, or the like
have been received. Preservation and open space areas will also act as a buffer between
residential uses on surrounding lands adjacent to, or neighboring, the subject property.
S:\200I\OBOO73 0000 Valli Mulching GMPA\OOO2 CPA AppliCltion\200~S.l._N.rntived(le
- 4 -
D'XT^"=~.
,'()"'\'\.11~,' ~~.~
.... __, IJ.. Jl. ~""''''f
Amendment to the Collier County Growth Management Plan
Fillmore Recycling
Collier County, FL
Public Facilities and Services: With respect to Public facilities, Attachment H "Public
Facilities Impact Analysis", is a spreadsheet which sets forth the impacts on public facilities
under the existing and proposed scenarios. Public facilities within the area of the subject
property are depicted on Attachment I "Public Facilities Exhibit". Impacts on Washburn
A venue and White Lake Boulevard are addressed in Attachment J "Traffic Impact
Statement" prepared by Omega Consulting Group.
With respect to Potable Water, Sanitary Sewer, Stormwater Drainage, Solid Waste, and Arterial
& Collector Roads within the vicinity of the proj ect, the proposed Amendment will not result in
any of these facilities falling below the adopted level of service established by and in accordance
with the Collier County Growth Management Plan and Section 6.02.0 I of the LDC. It should be
noted that while Attachment H examines the impacts of the proposed Plan amendment on public
water and sewer facilities, the existing mulching operation is utilizing a well and septic system,
so there are actually no impacts to those public facilities. For the reviewer's information, the
SFWMD issued General Water Use Permit I 1-0264- W for industrial, irrigation and public water
supply from the Water Table Aquifer using two withdrawal sources. The water use is limited to
23,458,300 gallons per year, not to exceed a maximum monthly withdrawal of 404,800 gallons.
The proposed future land use change and resulting land uses will not require additional water
demand.
The Collier County Sheriffs Department will provide police protection/law enforcement
services. There is a Sheriffs substation located on Golden Gate Parkway, which is a shared
facility housing Collier County EMS. The subject property lies within the service area of the
Golden Gate Fire Control and Rescue District, with Station 72 being located just east of Collier
Boulevard, on the south side of Beck Boulevard, well within the 8 minute response period LOS
standard. Finally, given that there will be no residential dwelling units associated with this
amendment or future land use, there will be no impact to public schools or regional/community
parks.
Environmental, Historical & Archeological Considerations: A detailed envirorunental
assessment has been prepared by Ramsey, Inc. (See Attachment G "Environmental
Assessment"). Over nine years of investigations have been included in the updated assessment
and associated appendices and no listed species have been observed on site. There is presence of
jurisdictional wetlands on the subject property which has been dermed and permitted with South
Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) Permit No. 11-02649-P, and US Army Corps of
Engineers Pennit SAJ-2007-605.
A letter has been received from the State of Florida Division of Historic Resources with regard to
historic, archaeological, or cultural resources that may be present on the site and is provided as
Attachment 0, No historical and/or archaeological sites will be impacted by development
proposed on this site,
S:\200ll'\0800n.OO 00 Yalll Mu1chin8 GMPA\OOO2 CPA Applicalion\20lJ9.5-14_Narl'llivedDc
- 5 -
DUTK:~:i;}._
,~O"l'l'l:llN,' MI''''''''''
.JL'-' U.. ....""""'$..1
Amendment to the Collier County Growth Management Plan
Fillmore Recycling
Collier Counly, FL
Conclusion: The property is proximate to adequate existing or planned public facilities. Based
upon the Public Facilities Analysis, future development resulting from the proposed GMP
amendment will not result in any degradation of any public facility. Extensive environmental
studies and permitting have occurred on the subject property and it has been demonstrated that
no listed or endangered species have been observed over a nine year investigation period. The
subject property is does not have the "highest degree of environmental value and sensitivity" as
would be the case with undisturbed lands. The subject property does not have the significant
wetlands, uplands, and habitat for listed species as has been determined by both the SFWMD and
the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers as is evidenced in the permits that have been issued. The
environmental evidence supports the appropriateness of the proposed FLUM change to Neutral
Lands,
Approval of this proposed amendment will provide for the continuation of the existing recycling
operations and expansion for construction and demolition recycling operations on lands adjacent
to existing landfill operation for Collier County. The use is comparable and compatible with
surrounding land uses and should be found to be consistent with the provisions of the Rural
Fringe Mixed Use District based on the immediate proximity of the public land fill facilities to
the west. TDR credits are prohibited from being generated from government owned lands, and
the Sending Lands provisions of the FLUE include special provisions to allow publicly operated
solid waste and resource recovery facilities through the conditional use procedure.
The Collier County Solid Waste Department is currently pursuing such a conditional use for their
proposed Resource Recovery Park that is anticipated to be approved by the time this Petition is
considered for transmittal and adoption. An argument can be supported that the special
allowances for government facilities in the Sending Lands combined with the prohibition of
generating TDR credits from government lands makes the County's lands in Sections 25 and 36,
Township 49 South, Range 26 East less like Sending Lands and more similar to Neutral Lands.
Therefore, based on the similarity of land uses with the County, the subject property should more
appropriately be designated as Neutral Lands to allow similar land uses as the County's land fill
and anticipated Resource Recovery Park. The reduction of available Sending Lands that would
result in the adoption ofthe requested FLUM change is insignificant (28.7 acres) when compared
to the County's 655;, acres in land fill and Resource Recovery Park lands that have been
effectively removed from the Sending Lands designation. Therefore, the proposed adjustment to
the Sending Lands to change the subject property to a Neutral Lands designation will not
adversely affect the TDR program.
s:uocalOaoon,oo.oo Ylhl Mul~hi"8 GMJ'A\OOOJ CPA APpli~atiOl\UOO9-S.14_Nm.li,,~.diX
- 6 -
D'XT.^~
1"1..''"1
'\";""'..,...
d,"I~l'l:IIN,l liII-.
.&....., 'L .&. _,.~
on~
>o~
;;!~n
..~~ ~:z COLLIER BOULEVARD (C.R. 951)
N~1'Tl
~:(o
g~~ .
~;.;
r~
::J~~ ~ ~ ~ ; = ~
~~~ " ~ ~
. -; ~ -;
~~ ~ ~ ~
~~~ 0 '" ~
foo ~
On;;! ~ c
;';Zn
~<z
>~Z ~ ~
-<in
I~~
~~~ R26
,>~
"r~
M~ . R27
l..:S;l'l
b~n ~
~"~ ;;; ; ~ ~
g~
<
~
~ Z
):,. 0
r-
r- ~ "
~ "- ;:; ~
~ -t
-; :I:
~~ :::0 OJ
):,. m
r- .
0::, _~ . r- '" r-
~z ~ 111 r-
2~ 0 -< m
z> z r
n n m
Gl "0 s:
m G)
z ~
0 ~ ;:0 " 0 m
V;~ r-
Q:) CJ )>
:Lj ~ rn C
~ z m
n
R c ~
;; ~ ~ 0
z
n '" :: n:1
<
m
;:0
r-
z ;;; )>
0 -<
... R27
m
?H' R28 s:
au; ; )>
"r m
E'~ ~ !O ~ BOULE 'ARD ~ "'tJ
a
On
~~
,,~ '2'
;l~
nn n:1 ,.
~ a " ~
n- O
~~ ~
:::0 '" " ~ m
C/) ~ ;;t
~~ ~ ,. " J!
:c-I !2' r
n~ '" '" '"
a z z "
g~ n:1 '" a a i!'
_0........1'Tl_l'Tl Z
Z g.. ~9 ~9 '" ..
:<i!i 111
~;l . ~ ~~ ~o ~c.. '" '" .
~ " '" ,. 'I)
og ~ t-.)~ N~ NZ '" '"
~; 9 g~ g~ 0 0
0
?~ 1ffi I'~ '" 111 ;'
0 ~
rn X:;tl ca:::IJ - ;i\ ~
... ;' )( -- OlN '0
H ~ -N ...............y. " :0
,. > 0 '" ,. ., S;
'" '"
~y; '" 0 0 ~
~ ~ 0 0 0 '" -<
'i@ . <5 ~ ~ 8 ~ "
'"
~fo; I "
~n ~
r=i ~
~;.;
. '"
A TT A TCHMENT B-1
V. OVERLAYS AND SPECIAL FEATURES
B. North Belle Meade Overlay
4. SENDING AREAS [page 94]
Within the NBM Overiay are :!: 4,a984.569 acres of land that are identified as Sending Areas for
the transfer of development rights that are located in the western, eastern and southern portion
of the study area. The Sending Areas consist of the NRPA lands and:!:5 and % sections west
of the NRPA. The sending areas are locations where residential development is discouraged.
Endangered and threatened species are located within the Sendi ng Areas, including colonies
of Red Cockaded Woodpeck ers. Therefore, the protection of endangered and threatened
species including the protection of habitat are primary planning considerations in this area.
Planning Considerations
a. TDRs
"Strongly encourage the transfer of development rights from the NBM Sending Areas to other
locations within the Rural Fringe or NBM Overlay outside the boundary of the NRPA, or to the
Urban Area.
b. Habitat Protection
" The Goals, Objectives and Policies of the Conservation and Coastal Management Element
for wildlife habitat protection shall apply to NB M Sending Lands.
c. Public Acquisition
"The County should support the public acquisition of Sending Lands in the NBM Overlay,
particularly in locations where endangered or threatened species are iocated.
5. NEUTRAL LANDS
Within the NBM Overlay there are:!: ~1 ,309 acres of land that are identified as Neutral
Areas. The Neutral Areas consist of two Y, sections located at the northeast corner of this
Overlay aR6-~Section 24 located in the northwest portion of this Overlay. and approximatelv 29
acres located in Section 31. The preservation standards for Neutral Lands shail be those
contained in CCM E Policy 6.1.2 for Neutral Lands. The County has performed an RCW study
for Section 24 and, if the results of the study warrant, the Plan will be amended.
Attachment B-2
RWA.ll"iCprOYloeslhlsO.l;lforyl)Ul'peraonal~'ar;is. Thts
informatlOfliSdtfiYe<lfrommulliple5Oll"Ctl$wt1lehrn;ay.irlperl.nol
be current, and be oulli<le \he eonlOI of RWA Inc_ The afln
deplc\e(1bylhismaotreappro1.im8te,8r1d,fenOlneces.s.l'lly
acwrale 10 SlfNeying or engin8lll'11'\g starldafd$ RWA.II'tc- 8S5Umes
no legal r_ponsibllty For lh. mfOfmal1Ol'l eonla,,,.d on lhl$ map
o
,
1,000 2,000
4,000
6,000
,Feet
D\XTA'"
("ONSl-l.n"lu
..&.. '"' '.L JL
'Pb/lnillt'VlfllhL'hM
.eml b1g.,l>O!'ting 'S""'.Y;"~ &: M:wi.,
Attachment B
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Proposed Future Land Use Map
N
A
Prep;IIe<lBy JrnlOf1es
PrlnbngDal"~nl30,2009
File TlPtotectl\2008\080Q7)OOOO_Y'hl_UutChln9
GMPAlPloposad_FLU ...~(l
V. OVERLAYS AND SPECIAL FEATURES
B, North Belle Meade Overlay
4. SENDING AREAS [page 94]
Within the NBM Overlay are:!: 4,5984.569 acres of land that are identified as Sending Areas for
the transfer of development rights that are located in the western, eastern and southern portion
of the study area. The Sending Areas consist of the NRPA lands and :!:5 and'/.. sections west
of the NRPA. The sending areas are locations where residential development is discouraged.
Endangered and threatened species are located within the Sending Areas, including colonies
of Red Cockaded Woodpeckers. Therefore, the protection of endangered and threatened
species including the protection of habitat are primary planning considerations in this area.
Planning Considerations
a. TDRs
"Strongly encourage the transfer of development rights from the NBM Sending Areas to other
locations within the Rural Fringe or NBM Overlay outside the boundary of the NRPA, or to the
Urban Area.
b. Habitat Protection
"The Goals, Objectives and Policies of the Conservation and Coastal Management Element
for wildlife habitat protection shall apply to NB M Sending Lands.
c. Public Acquisition
"The County should support the public acquisition of Sending Lands in the NBM Overlay,
particularly in locations where endangered or threatened species are located.
5. NEUTRAL LANDS
Within the NBM Overlay there are :!: ~1,309 acres of land that are identified as Neutral
Areas. The Neutral Areas consist of two Yo sections located at the northeast corner of this
Overlay aRG-~Section 24 located in the northwest portion of this Overlay. and approximatelv 29
acres located in Section 31. The preservation standards for Neutral Lands shall be those -
contained in CCM E Policy 6.1.2 for Neutral Lands. The County has performed an RCW study
for Section 24 and, if the results of the study warrant, the Plan will be amended.
Attachment B-2
GOLDEN
GATE PKY
10
I::;
"'
II:
IW
I~
i
GOlOENGAT~li ~I _ JI
COMMERCE I
PA_RK ruo ,L_ CITY
. - GATE PUD
COLLIER BlVD
-~: ~I- __ ,
~- I ~ WHITE'LAKE
I ... INDUSTRIAL
~ CORP PARK PuD \
TOll ~
GATE PUD
B~
~'~ >0]1'
r -J~_~'i.o
OfoJ:~ I ~
~~ "
~"
WESTPORT-I
COMMERCE
CEtllTER PUD :
PUD
fOREST
GLENN OF
NAPLES PUD
-_.---;
CEDAR [
I9o~CKG& ,6
CCLUBf'U'} -i l
'-,
~
NAPLES-HERITAG
GOLF AND COUNT U
CLUB PUD
NAPlES
~Tl GOLF
CLUB PUD
I SA"
MARINO
PUD
lr
i-
tl nTl~~NA ~
I ~(~
~
HOMeS OF
~;::; t~--L_- II
""'~ ~~" I 1-?
Attachment C
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
General Location Map
o
,
3,000
1,500
I
,
\
I
I
6,000
N
A
SUBJECT
PROPERTY
Legend
c:J Subject Property
CJ Collier County Land Fill
Collier Street CtrLines
- Collier County Major Roads
,- I PUD_0807
OISClf.lMER
RW" In, pfO..o;" ~'<6 jallllur yo.... pe'llONIll.I'e "91 I. - lh~
,nwma!JO<1"; de""~d lrom muq.pIe source, """I,h ma~ of] pal1 flOl
oewr'e,,1 and I)eOHI!1de me C(.ofllOl ofRWA. I..... lh~ areM
dePOClildbylhlSmal!areapprtl~"nal",_andarenolflfl("_Usl/'l~
acc,"ate \tl ~ur\11Y'fl(l or e<l9''llIe''ro;IsllII'dllrd$ RWA lor; n_,es
I\'Jlegalr/!slX>naLb,ht~lorllle,",ormatJont.o""l"'>e<:I<)n~mll1l
9,000
, Feet
D'XTA'"<
("O"-<;l L1J"-/(;
..L....., lA.. ....
. ~:""nmg . V..~,llI.""'"
.(i>;tl:tl,"'..nnf .S~",~},n~ &. lo1~pjIrn:e
Prepared By \l]pellegnno
PnntlngOote ~"t7,200S
F,le T'.PrOjects\2008\080(J73 00 00
Yaht_Mu1ching_GMPA Locall00 m~(
FLUCFCS CODE
'"
'"
6241743
52'
'"
62418146
'"
""
'"
6241742
52'
8145
8145
OES RIPTl
Sin Ie Famil Residllnt'ai
TimberPraceSsin
PinelC rlIss/PalmiS oil Piles
Cress
PinelC fess/Palm
PinelC rlIssiPalmllm ctedB ROadClearin
Pine/C ress/Palm
Hardwood Conifer
Pine/C resslPalm
Pine I Cress / Palm 11m cted 6 Borrow Pit E~cava\lOn
Cress
Gradlldl Drainlld Road
Graded I Drained Road
TOTAL ACRE
ACRES
2'
J2
0.5
L5
7.0
0.8
"
03
"
"
"
05
07
28.8
~A.'nc,prov'deslnl>d"'afOlyourperson;lIu>e"a~,s,- ThiS
information IS derwec lrom mulliple sources wh',ch may, ,n pan, nol
becurrenf,and be"ut",det~econlolotRWA Inc, Tneareas
dep'cled l'ythl5 map are approximale, and arll nof necessaflly
accura'etos",veY"'gorllnglneenng staO<lard., RWA,lnc assume~
0<1 legal resprmsobillfyfor t~e Infc.-m~ti(Jtl confalned onlhlS map
o 150
,
300
600
Attachment D
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
FLUCFCS Map (Aerial Flown Date: Jan 2008)
N
A
900
, Feet
D\XTA'NC
CONSULTING
..a......, ,~ ..a.
'Planning 'V~,,,,"lil'llil)ll
'Civil Eng.;lleering'Surveying &. M~pping
Prinling Date: April 10,2008
F'le:T:\Projects\2008\0800730000
Ya hl_ M ulching_ GM PA\FL UCCS m~d
E
[:;'U
I
'~',~'-
f)
U
CITY
GATE PUD
WHITELAKE
INDUSTRIAL
CORP. PARK PUD
TOlL
GATE PUD
FOREST
GLENN OF
NAPLES PUD
CEDAR
HAMMOCK G &
C CLue PUD
",....."....,'~
NAPLES HERITA
GOLF AND COUN
CLUB PUD
NAPLES
NAT'L GOlF
CLUB puo
o
u
,.
~
I'
L...... '\
Subject Property , l
c:J 500' Buff., I
II::J AGRICULTURE i
_ COMMERCIAL I
:' '-1 ESTATES
_ GOlF COURSE
D PLANNED UNIT PEVE LOPMENT
_ RESIDENTIAL MULTI,FAMILY
D RESIPENTIAL SINGLE-FAM~L Y
- Collier County Major Roads
SAN
MARINO
PUD
HOMES OF
ISLANDIA
PUD
LASt? CONSV.
AREA PUD
NAPLES LAKES
C.C, PUD
RWA Ill<; 1lI000000......dlUlo.\IOUIClel__...."'I$. T.....
nIonn..,.., 16 ditrIv$:I Worn ..... -.._ whi<;h ""'Y. in p8It rot
bee..... an<Ibe<lUtli.ld&llwQOrCololRWA Itle TIle.,_
~byl_InajI8r.lCJpfOlIlIllll\elNld.....not"""'''f''''
~,*Io"""""V\llgorerow-mg"""dIIds rfNA Inc an""e.
>ll;IlegIII~blhot""otn\alIon_d...thlmllP
o
Attachment E ,
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Existing Zoning and Land Use
1 ,500 3,000
6,000
9,000
'Feet
D\XTA'"
CO'\lSl'1 TI"lO
.A....., ,... ...
.~..........llull(WI
'CmIE~_""l:'Slfl"<'Cyint"M:rppin:
N
A
Prtll)ltlBd By 'Jone~
Pn"~l)g OJit. ,4onl30. 2009
File T\Ploteds\20CJe1D80073,OO.OO~YahU~'UJCl1m9
GUPA\Land U~ aod ZOI1U'1g rnxd
o
,
1,000 2,000
4,000
Attachment F
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Future Land Use Map
N
A
RWA..lnc.ptO~deslhisdalaloryourpel'Sonl'lUU'IlSIS' Thu;
Inlormatior1 is derIVed from multiple $OUrU$ whlct\ may III part. ~l
be current. and De oulslde the conlOl of RWA. In!; The areas
depiCted b~ 1M rnaJl are appl'OIUtnale. and ara not neceswdy
accurate to surveying Of er'Igllleenng $laMatOs RWA. Ine assumes
rKllegal respon$lbllily for lhe ,nfommion eontamed (1'11,,", map
6,000
. Feet
D'lTA'"
vo:"-!')\ L"IINl.i
.&.'tro., u....
-P1>llllfll,.\I1-<1l11iuuoo
-(',,",j En;iloetrin,'S1l1'rC:.\IJ1~& MiplU'lJi
PtepattdBy mlJ0ne5
p"rlhng Dale. Apnl 30 2009
~.Ie, TIProJecl!\2008\080073000C
nIlU.l~chon{LGMPA'FlU mxd
Attachment G
Environmental Assessment with
Protected Species Survey
Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Ramse Inc. LEP, eWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP
'_', ., ,,,-.,,"....,. '. -';'-'11' ",-,. ",...,. ',,_.'~.', ..".--...._..-- ,....-
E-mail: Ramse)..Inc@ernbarqmail.com
Office: 239.564.1660. FIIX: 866.334.1496
26314. Sl. NW, Naples, FL 34120
www.ramsevinc.net
LEP - Licensed Environmental Professional
CWB . Certified Wildlife Biologist
CFEA . Certified Florida Environmental Assessor
REPA - Registered Environmental Properly Assessor
CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional
RE-DESIGNATION EVALUATION OF FILLMORE IYAHL MULCHING PROJECT
FROM RFUMD SENDING TO NEUTRAL LANDS
GMP AMENDMENT CP-2008-4
Project: Yahl Mulching and Recycling, Inc.
Owner: Fillmore LLC
Folio #: 00341920409
Acres: 28.8
Location: Naples, Florida; Collier County
By: Michael R. Ramsey, Ramsey Inc.
Date: 01 October 2008
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Yahl Mulching and Recycling (Yahl) Project is located on a 29 acre site on the west
side of the North Belle Meade Sending Area and adjacent to the south east corner of the
Collier County Landfill. Both are located north of 1-75 near the west I- 75 toll gate. The
property the Yahl Project is on is owned by Fillmore LLC and the folio identification is
#00341920409. The principals of the Yahl Project and Fillmore LLC are the sarne: John
and Teresa Fillmore.
The Yahl Project provides an essential service to both the Collier County Government
Solid Waste Department and to the residents of Collier County by preventing horticultural
debris from going into the Collier County Landfill and taking up valuable space. The Yahl
Project "intercepts" the horticultural waste debris grinds it up and processes it into a soil
compost amendment that is used in agriculture and landscaping businesses. Technically
this is both a resource recovery operation and a renewable energy operation.
The owners of the Yahl Project believe that their property was incorrectly classified as
Sending Lands under the Rural Fringe Mixed Use District (RFMUD) as described in the
Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the Growth Management Plan (GMP). This report
examines detailed site specific information collected from the property over the last 8 years.
Based on the criteria listed in the FLUE of the GMP, Sending Lands are those lands having
"the highest degree of environmental value and sensitivity and generally include significant
wetlands, uplands, and habitat for listed species." Collier County Community Development
and Environmental Services Review (CDESR) initially classified the property based on
offsite Florida Natural Areas Inventory (FNAI) extrapolated information about habitat and
listed species. CDESR never visited the site to collect actual data.
Site specific data collected from the property over the last 8 years and closer examination
of the property indicates the Yahl ProjecVFillmore parcel does not meet that criteria listed in
the GMP for Sending Lands. Additionally, the property had existing agriculture and
recycling uses on it prior to implementation of the RFMUD in 2002. Collection of more
accurate site specific data indicates the classification should be Neutral Lands.
Page 1
Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Ramse Inc. LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP
.. ~,.... _.'" ,":__ ,.. ,- _...'0 '.. _, ,_, _ ""..c....,.
LEP - Licensed Envirollmental Professional
CWB ~ Certified Wildlife Biologist
CFEA. Certified Florida Environmental Assessor
REPA . Registered Environmental Property Assessor
CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional
E-mail: Ramsey.lnc@embarqmail.com
Office: 239.564.1660, Fax: 866.334.1496
26314" Sl. NW. Nnples, FL 34120
www.ramsevinc.net
RE-DESIGNATlON EVALUATION OF FILLMORE /VAHL MULCHING PROJECT
FROM RFUMD SENDING TO NEUTRAL LANDS
GMP AMENDMENT CP"200B-4
Project: Yahl Mulching and Recycling, Inc.
Owner: Fillmore LLC
Folio #: 00341920409
Acres: 28.8
Location: Naples, Florida; Collier County
By: Michael R. Ramsey, Ramsey Inc.
Date: 01 October 2008
INTRODUCTION
The Yahl Mulching and Recycling, Inc. (Yahl) operation is a 29 acre parcel located in
Collier County at 2250 Washburn Ave., Naples, Florida (Figure 1 and 2) owned by Fillmore
LLC. This report examines detailed site specific information collected from the property
over the last 8 years to determine if the initial designation of Sending Lands was correct
under the Rural Fringe Mixed User District (RFMUD) as described in the Future Land Use
Element (FLUE) of the Collier County Growth Management Plan (GMP).
SITE DESCRIPTION
The Yahl Project is 29 acres located approximately 2 miles east of CR 951, north of 1-75.
The owner of the property the Yahl Project is located on is Fillmore LLC, folio #
00341920409. The principals of the Yahl Project and Fillmore LLC are the same: John
and Teresa Fillmore.
The Yahl Project takes in vegetative and horticultural debris, grinds it into mulch, and then
composts the mulch into an organic soil amendment. The Yahl projects assists the Collier
County Landfill operations by intercepting vegetative waste debris that would occupy
valuable space in the landfill and recycles into other uses. The mulch and composted
material is utilized for landscaping and agriculturai soil amendment purposes. The Yahl
Project provides and essential service to the Collier County Sold Waste Department and
the residents of Collier County
On the west side it borders the Collier County Landfill. On the south side it borders the
right-ol-way line of 1-75. On the north and east sides it borders 5 acres parcels agriculture
zoned with single family residences (Figure 1). The Yahl project and the general area have
been in recycling and agricultural activities since 1990, The Yahl Project was initially set up
here because of its proximity to the Collier County Landfill, the remoteness, iow density and
zoned for agriculture. The Collier County Landfill has been here since 1975-76.
Page 2
RFMUD Re-desiQI1a1ion Evalualion of Folio 00341920409
From Sending 10 Neutral Lands
GMP Amendment CP-2008-4
01 October 2008
Page 3
FLORIDA NATURAL AREAS INVENTORY - FNAI
The staff of Collier County Community Development and Environmental Services Review
(CDESR) indicated in numerous public meetings that the procedure for determining the
classification of a piece oi land in the RFMUD was the use of the Fiorida Natural Areas
Inventory (FNAI). The FNAI is a classiiication system that government organizations use to
predict habitat and protected species without visiting a property.
FNAI attempts to predict the type of vegetation that would occur on property based on the
soil type classification done in each county by the Natural Resource Conservation Service
(NRGS). FNAI does surveys for vegetation and wildlife on properties that they are allowed
to access and are done all over the state of Florida,
First the vegetation is surveyed and projected as to the type of habitat it is classified as.
Second, all wildlife is surveyed. Third, the vegetation and wildlife is matched to the NRCS
soil type it occurred on. From this matching of habitat to soil type, listed species can also
be speculated. Therefore, the Sending Land classification that the Landfill and Yahl Project
was based on soil type extrapolation from the FNAI surveys. No actual site surveys or
detailed site data was collected to make the determination.
Problems with FNAI:
1. NRCS soil classifications have an average 25-50% error based on comparison of soii
maps to actual property data.
2. Extrapolations of habitat and listed species based on NRCS soil types have an inherit
20-50% error.
3. No actual site data or surveys are conducted. When no actual site specific data is
collected the error in the FNAI extrapolation is not corrected.
The Board of County Commissioners (BOCC) have made it clear in many pUblic hearings
that decisions on land ciassification should be made with the best available data. If more
accurate site specific data becomes available after an initial decision is made, then the new
data should re-evaluated and changes made if warranted.
The information presented below describes more accurate, detailed, site specific data
collected from the 29 acre Yahl Project over a period of 8 years. The more site specific
data indicates that there was error in the FNAI extrapolation and the property should not
have been classified as Sending Lands. The site specific data indicates the more accurate
classification based on the guidelines would be Neutral Lands.
OVERLAYS, HABITATS, WETLANDS,JUXTAPOSTION
OVERLAYS. In reviewing the information available from Collier County the first indicator
that the Yahl Project and Landfill area Is not "lands that have the highest degree of
environmental value and sensitivity and generally include significant wetlands, uplands, and
habitat for listed species" is that the areas were not initially classified as Natural Resource
Protection Areas (NRPA's) as demonstrated in Figure 3.
NRPA's as defined and described in the FLUE as follows: "The purpose of the Natural
Resource Protection Area (NRPA) Overlay designation is to protect endangered or
p01entially endangered species and to identify large connected intact and relatively
unfragmented habitats, which may be important for these listed species. NRPA's may
Page 3
RFMUD Re-designaHon Evalualion 01 Folio 00341920409
From Sending to Neutral Lands
GMP Amendment Cp.200B,4
01 October 200B
Page 4
include major wetland systems and regional flow-ways. These lands generally should be
the focus of any federal, state, County or private acquisition efforts;" according to the FLUE.
Since Collier County chose not to declare the area of the Landfill and the Yahl Project as
part of the NRPA, then it was decided that the area
. "was not" needed to protect potentially endangered species,
. "was not" part of an intact and relatively unfragmented habitat area, and
. "was not" Important to listed species.
The reasoning behind not classifying the Landfill-Yahl Project area as a NRPA
appears to be due to:
. The high intensity use of the area due to the landfill.
I The high amount of truck traffic to the land fiil.
I The current and past agricultural use of the general area.
I The proximity to the fenced Right of Way of 1-75 which effectively severs and
segments:
o Any movement of ground animals
o Continuity of any habitat or vegetation used by ground wildlife
I High infestation of exotic plants
I Presence of native vegetation not significant.
I Lack of any regional or significant wetland systems
I Lack of any significant habitat.
Overall, the Landfill- Yahl Project area does not exemplify the characteristics listed for
Sending Lands, However, it does better fit the Neutral Lands definition of:
"Neutral Lands have been identified for limited semi-rural residential development.
Available data indicates that Neutral Lands have a higher ratio of native vegetation, and
thus higher habitat values, than lands designated as Receiving Lands, but these values
do not approach those of Sending Lands, Therefore, these lands are appropriate for
limited development, if such development is directed away from existing native vegetation
and habitat (FLUE)."
HABIT ATS, WETLANDS. The FLUE states that Sending Lands will have "the highest
degree of environmental value and sensitivity and generally include significant wetlands,
uplands, and habitat for listed species." Also, stated in the FLUE the intent of RFMUD
designations is to "protecting and conserving the most valuable environmental lands,
including large connected wetland systems and significant areas of habitat for listed
species..."
Figure 4 shows a compilation of Collier County habitat and wetlands data from the Rural
Lands Stewardship (RLSA) program, the RFMUD, the FLUE, Dep1. of Environmental
Protection (DEP) and the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD). As shown
in Figure 4 there are "no large connected wetland systems" in or around the Landfill or Yahl
Project Area.
JUXTAPOSITION. The Landfill and Yahl Project area are situated in a iocation such that
1he properties can not be utilized effectively by listed species, The proximity to the White
Lake industrial area to the west, 1-75 to south, single family residential and agriculture to
the immediate east and north effectively has isolated the Landfill and the Yahl Project
Page 4
RFMUD Re-designalion Evaluation of Folio 00341920409
From Sending to Neutral lands
GMP Amendment CP-200B.4
01 October 2008
PageS
habitat use by wide ranging ground species, 1-75 in particular provides a long term barrier
to any movement for wildlife to or from the south.
PROTECTED SPECIES
The Yahl Project site was surveyed and evaluated for listed species in the 2008 Spring,
2007 Fall, 2006 and 2000. In all surveys the property indicated little to no value as habitat
for utilization by listed species. It is anticipated that construction of a surface water
mana~ement system required by the SFWMD for horticultural recycling will improve
conditions primarily for wading birds. These reports are attached in the Appendix. The
conclusions of the 4 reports were that the area is utilized little to none by listed species and
by general wildlife. The area in fact showed very little use except by Passerines (son~
birds). This is generally concluded to be a result of the juxtaposition of the property With
the other limiting features of the area (especially 1-75) and by the human activity
encountered at the landfill.
Panthers- Habitat Qualitv. The Landfill and the Yahl Project is located on the western edge
of what is considered by the US Fish & Wildlife Service (FWS) to be classified as panther
primary zone (Figures 5,6,7). During the processing of the US Army Corps 01 Engineers
(USACOE) permitting for this project and the required coordination with the FWS, it was
communicated to the Yahl Project that the FWS would be requiring the applicant to rnitigate
for all 29 acres of the project even though a 12 acre preserve site was going to be
maintained on site through Conservation Easements. According to the FWS (B. Reick,
personal communicaton) the FWS considers habitat on the edge or perimeter of the
primary or secondary zone to be unusable to the panther and requires mitigation for the
entire site. The reasoning is that areas on the "edge" have so much activity going on
around them that the panther won't use it. Therefore, the animal would be better off if
mitigation assisted in putting together protected properties toward the center of the core
areas. The conclusion being that the quality of the habitat is low to "zero" and that the
presence of 1-75 will forever prevent utilization from the south.
Figures 5, 6 and 7 indicate the utilization of Collier County property by panthers as
indicated by telemetry data collected by the Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation
Commission (FWC), This telemetry data is broken into 3 time periods Figure 51981-1996,
Figure 61997-2003 and Figure 7 2004-2007. This data collected by FWC shows that the
panther is not utilizing the general area of the Landfill and Yahl Project area. In fact it is
showing a trend toward less and less utilization, that trend appears to be continuing today.
This trend appears to validate the assertion by the FWS that the habitat on the edge of the
primary zone is not usable.
Red Cockaded Woodpeckers (RCW). RCW's are of particular interest in the area around
the Landfill and the Yahl Project. After 4 surveys over 8 years over the entire area of the
Yahl Project no nest trees were found, and no utilization of the area was observed.
Generally, the Yahl Project does not have the preferred habitat type for RCW's due to a
heavy exotic infestation of Brazilian Pepper and Melaleuca at the canopy and sub-canopy
levels. Again this conclusion from this evaluation is that this is a low quality habitat area for
wildlife with very little utilization.
Black Bear. Figures 8 and 9 are telemetry data for black bear obtained from the FWC from
1983-2006. Figure 8 indicates that the pnmary utilization area is to the east of the Landfill
and Yahl Project and to the south near Royal Palm Hammock on US 41. Although this is
limited data it indicates that the primary areas of utilization are far to the east of the Yahl
Project in the Camp Keais and Picayune Strand State Forest (PSSF). Figure 9 is nuisance
Page 5
RFMUD Re-designalion Evaluation of Folio 00341920409
From Sending to Neutral Lands
GMP Amendment CP.200B-4
01 October 2008
Page 6
telemetry data which also shows a trend of bear movement not in the area of the Landfill /
Yahl Project area.
Bald Eaale. Figure 10 indicates the closest bald eagle nest to the Yahl Project. This nest
is considered somewhat unusual since it is so far inland. Most nests are closer to the
coast. This nest is in the PSSF management area south of 1-75. Again the Yahl Project
area is not utilized because of its proximity to 1-75 and lack of quality habitat for this animal.
CONCLUSION
The classification of the Yahl Project does not meet the criteria that have been listed in the
FLUE for the selection of properties as Sending Lands because of the utilization of FNAI
extrapolated data. The collec1ion of accurate site specific data on the Yahl Project/Fillmore
site indicates:
. The area has had agriculture use on it since 1990, before the implementation of the
RFMUD land classifications
. it was never initially considered to be a NRPA
. it is not part of a regional wetland flow way system,
. it is not considered to be significant habitat,
. it has little to no listed species use,
. it has a juxtaposition with 1-75 that will prevent it from being fully utilized as functional
habitat for listed species
. it is on the edge of primary panther habitat and is considered not usable by FWS
Based on the site specific data collected, the most accurate land classification based on the
RFMUD guidelines is Neutral.
Page 6
PROJECT LOCATION MAP
LANDFI
------.
.....~-_....
.. .. -. ~;.. 0
'---r-'-~- .
. - . '.. .
-. --
~ .
"
_.~.- .
---," --...... .
.- -_......
,-~ .....:~- .
\l
I
~
5
,
o
5
10
15 Miles
N
Figure 1. Project Location Map In Callier County;
PRO.JECT: FILLMORE I YAHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC' GMP AMENDMENT CP.2008-4
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples.FL 34120
239,564,1660
Vahl Mulching EXl!anslon Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn lI9, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
PROJECT LOCATION DETAIL MAP
I I 1 I
IT
L
lE
~1i0",
11.1. ~
040
YAHL MULCHING &
RECYCLING, IHC
...
It)
0'>
~
U
175
Figure 2. Project Location Detail Map In Collier County;
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING & RECYCLING, INC
GMP AMENDMENT CP.2008-4
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples.FL 34120
239.564.1660
N
W+E
S
Yahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn lI9, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
LOCATION OF NRPA AND NUETRAL
LANDS MAP
o Collier County Boundary
N Roads
_ RFMUD Nautral Lands
E::a RFMUD Sending Lands
_ NRPA AREAS
D Collier County Landliil
_ Yahl Project
+
Figure 3. Location of NRPA and Nuetral Lands in Collier County In
relation to the Yahl Project and the Collier County Landfill.
((_
PROJECT: FILLMORE I YAHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC' GMP AMENDMENT CP-2008-4
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples, FL 34120
239,56...1660
Yahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn "9, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28,8 acres.
LOCATION OF MAJOR WETLAND, HABITAT
AND NRPA LANDS MAP
D Collier County Boundary
7\l Roads
_ RFMUO Neutral Lands
I:S] NRPA AREAS
II RLSA FSH OKALACOOCHIE
RLSA FSA CAMP KEAIS
IlIllII FLUE MAP CONSERVATION ZON
_ CORKCREW MARSH, CAMP KEAI
E23 RFMUO Sending Lands
i.! J Collier County Landfill
_ Yahl Project
FIgure 4. Location of m!"ior wetland, hablltat & NRPA Lands In
Collier County.n relatIon 10 the Vahl Project and the
Collier Co.un~L.ndflll.
Yahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 1I9, Rge 27, t~otaling approximately 2B.8 acres.
-4
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th 5t. NW
Naplej,FL 34120
239.5_.1660
+
PANTHER TELEMETRY 1981.1996
. 1 996 pantber ielem.'lY
. 1995 p.nther telemetry
. 1.994 p.nlker telem.try
. 1993 p.nther telemetry
. 1992 panther telemetry
. 1991 penther telemelry
. 1990 penther telemetry
. 1989 penther telemetry
. 1988 panther telemetry
. 1987 panther telemetry
. 198,6 panther telemetry
. 1985 p.ather 18lemetry
. 1884 no panther telemetry
. 1983 panther telemetry
. 1982 panther telemetry
. 1981 panther telemetry
. Vehl Project
7\i _.
12:3 North beth! m..de1 ..ndlng erea
~ Corkscrew sWllmp ._neldal")'
r:21 CorlcscrltW .....i0n81 ecosystem watershed
m Florid. panther natloRIII wlldlKe refuge
rs:i Picayune strand e...e torelt & . aelle Meed
~~ Foehatch.. strand preserve slate park
.~::::::=:::::n. ~
PROJECT: FILLMORE I Y AHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC. GMP AMENDMENT CP.2008-4
+
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples.FL 34120
239.564.1660
Figure 5. Panther telemetry 1981-1996;
Yahl Mulching & Recyclln9, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
PANTHER TELEMETRY 1997.2003
+
. 2003 pantber telemetry
. 2002 p;lnther telemetry
. 2001 pint her telemetry
. 2000 panlher telemetry
. 1999 panther telemetry
. 1998 panther telemetry
. 1897 panther telemetry
.. Yahl Project
7\7 Roads
E.2I North belle me.de sending area
I:Z22 Corkscrew awamp sanctuary
D Corkscrew reglanal ecosystem watershod
m Florida panther naUDnal wildlife r.fuge
J:5J Plc:ayune at,.nd atate forest & S Belle Mu'
f!;] Fakahatchee ioU-lid pr...rve atahl park
W Panther secondary zone
~ Padther primary ZDne
~
PROJECT: FILLMORE I YAHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC. GMP AMENDMENT CP.2008-4
Yahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn '49, Rge 27, totalln9 approximately 2a.8 acres.
~~r!!ll~~ !!S:ing
2631 4th st. NW
Naples. FL 34120
239.56...1860
Figure 6 Panther telemetry 1997-2003;
PANTHER TELEMETRY 2004.2007
. 2007 panther telemetry
. 2006 panther telemetry
. 2005 panther telemetry
. 2004 panther telemetry
~ Y.hl Project
7\l Roads
~ North belle meade sending anta
m3 Corllaorow swamp ..nctuary
CJ Codwcrew regional ecosystem watersh
ID Florida panth.' national wildlife refule
E:! Picayune strand state farest & S Belle
t:J Fakahatchee shnd pre.erve state park
ij :::::;;::::~_:::ft. '\ ~
PROJECT: FILLMORE I YAHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC- GMP AMENDMENT CP-2008-4
+
Ramsev Inc.
Envlronmentil Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Neple!,~ FL 34120
239.5_.1660
Figure 7. Panther telemetry 2004-2007;
Yahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washbum Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn "9, Rge 27, rotaling approximately 28.8 acres.
BEAR TELEMETRY 1983.2000
. Black bear telem fl1983 2000
. Vahl Project
N Roads
.
.
.
1--.
.
.
..
. .
. ,
..... .\ .
. I. ....
.'t. .~,. ,~.
:. "
.
Figure 8. Black Bear Telemetry 1983-2000; source FL Fish & W1ldlllfe
Conservation Comm.
PROJECT: FILLMORE I Y AHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC' GMP AMENDMENT CP.2008.4
~!},!!'~~r. !~~ting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples, FL 34120
239.564.1660
+
Vahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn '49, Rge 27, ~otallng approximately 28.8 acres.
Black Bear Nusionace Locations 1980-2006
, v
. Bear_nuisance_1980-2006
.. Yahl Project
7'\l Roads
.
.
PROJECT: FILLMORE I YAHL MULCHING +
& RECYCLING INC. GMP AMENDMENT CP.2008-4 '
Vahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washbum Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn '19, Rge 27, fotaling approximately 28.8 acres.
~~~~~~ c~~S:ing
2631 4th St. NW
Naple!"FL 34120
239.5_.1660
Figure 9. Black Bear Nuslonace Locations 1980.2006.
BA~D EA~E, NEST LO~A~~O~ MA~ 1m
I 1- ,
_ 1
I I
f-
r
f--
n
I 0
r ~ NEST LOI:ATION
f--
I
...LH
,~ .....
.
"
:-
~~
Hi+1H I Hrl -r- 1-1
..~~".....
I p. JIP;
':':,.
1
,
-
~
~
~
~,~ \
IV.
~
s
I
f--
I~ 4~1)
LI
= -n
I-
u~
-
-
II
I
--'
I
-
=
'rt'
I s
-.
-
I I f---J
~
~
-
-
=
=-
_ 0
-
-
I
b:1 f--
-!
I i
- T I
- I 1
P- I
-.
I I-
'I , I ~
~E
S
1=
:r
PROJECT: FILLMORE I YAHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING. INC: GMP AMENDMENT CP-2008-4
Figure 10. Bald Eagle Location Map; source FWC. Ramsey' Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples.FL 34120
239.564.1680
Yahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn lI9, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
RFMUD Re-designallon Evaluation ot Folio 00341920409
From Sending 10 Neulrallands
GMP Amendment CP.200B.4
01 October 2008
Page 7
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A. 2001 0115 LISTED SPECIES SURVEY REPORT
APPENDIX B. 20061229 LISTED SPECIES SURVEY REPORT
APPENDIX C. 20080130 YAHL FALL 2007 PROTECED SPECIES REPORT
APPENDIX D. 20080615 YAHL SPRING 2008 PROTECED SPECIES REPORT
Page 7
Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING
LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP
LEP . Licensed Environmental Professional
CWB . Certified Wildlife Biologist
CFEA . Cenified Florida Environmental Assessor
REPA . Registered Environmental Property Assessor
CEHP - Certified Environmental Heal.th Professional
OSHA S - Hazardous Materials Incident Commander
E.mail: Ramsey.Inc@embarqrnail.com
Office: 239.564.1660, Fax: 866.334.1496
26314"SI. NW, Naples, FL 34120
www.ramseyinc.net
PROTECTED SPECIES WILDLIFE SURVEY REPORT- SPRING 2009
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING SDPA AR 7633
DATE: 05.01.09
BY: Michael R. Ramsey
Ramsey Inc.
INTRODUCTION
Owner: Fillmore U.C (Yahl Mulching)
County: Collier
City: Naples
Size: 28.8 acres
Legal Descriptions: PID 00341920409
2250 Washburn A ve; the SW 'A or the SW 'A
Section 31; Township 49, Range 27
The applicant Yahl Mulching has applied to the Collier Co. Government, the South Florida Water Management District
(SFWMD) and US Army Corps of Engineers (USACOE) to expand its existing operation of mulching and recycling of
vegetative malerial in Collier Co. (Figure 1). The following protected species/wildlife survey report was done 10 meet
the submission requirements for each agency.
This report evaluates if the above described project property is utilized by any protected species listed by the
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). A
protected species/wildlife evaluation for this property was conducted in 2000. 2006, 2007 and 2008, this report
follows up on those 4 previous reports.
METHODS
First, the project properties were surveyed and a map prepared of the habitat types on site. Second, the official lists
of protected species were obtained from each of the agencies (FWC & FWS). The FWC list all species classified
as protected by the slate of Florida government. The FWS list all species that are classified as protected in the Slale
of Florida by the United States government. Third, each species on each list was researched as to county of
occurrence and'required habitat in the literature. Last, all species that were indicated as being found in Collier Co.
and having a habitat type that occurred on the project properties were searched for by surveys on the project
properties.
RESULTS
Stt. '~J D4l~.. This property was initially evaluated for the presence of protected species in 2000. Collier Co.
Government Natural Resources Division concluded there was no issue with protected species on this site and issued
approval to move ahead with a site development plan in the Conditional Use Permit proceedings. The area was
resurveyed in 2006 for the presence of protected species for the SFWMD and USACOE. The SFWMD found no issues
with protected species and issued their permit #11.02649-P on 15 March 2007. The USACOE is still evaluating their
permit application at this time. The project properties were visited on: October 14, December 30 in the year 2000:
and resurveyed on lhe dates: 09115,09/23,09/30, 10/05, 10/12, 11/05, 11/26, 12109 and 12/17 in 2006. In 2007 the
project area was visited on 09/23-24, 09/29, 10/06. 10/20, 10/28, 11111 and 11/13. In 2008 the property was visited on
04102,04/04,04/06,04/26,05/14,05/18 and OS/25. For this 2009 survey period the property was visited on 04.1]2, 04/14
and 04116. The surveys were done in the morning (AM) 2-3 hours afler sunrise and in the evening (PM) 2-3 hours before
sunset. Survey routes are shown in Figure 2.
YahlMulcbing
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Proleclcd Species Report
01 May 2009
Pllge2
Habitat. The Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classilication System (FLUCFCS) was utilized to
produce the habitat maps for the project properties. The habitat or FLUCFCS maps are depicted in Figure
2 for the Yahl Mulching project. Table 1 below indicates the acres for each habitat type.
Table 1. FLUCFCS acres for the Yahl Mulching and Recycling property.
ID# Acres FLUCCS # Habitat TVDe
I 2.6 III Single Family Residence
2 3.2 152 Timber Processing
3 05 624n43 Pine/CypresslPalmlspoi1 piles
4 1.6 621 Cypress
5 7.0 624 Pine/CypressIPalm
6 0.8 624/8146 Pine/CypresslPalm impacted by road clearing
7 1.1 624 Pine/CypresslPalm
8 0.3 434 Hardwood Conifer
9 4.7 624 Pine/CypresslPalm
10 3.4 624n42 Pine/Cypress/Palm impacted by borrow pit excavation
II 2.4 621 Cypress
12 0.5 8145 GradedlDrained Road
13 0.7 8145 GradedIDrained Road
The Yahl property has been impacted by road construction on the north, south and west sides of the property.
This construction has effectively cut off sheet flow across the property, except for unusually high rainfall events.
Impacted hydrology appears to be the cause of the pine trees being present with present in cypress transition areas
in the 624 habitats. It is also the reason for the heavy melaleuca infestation in the 624 areas to be preserved. This
area has been slowly drying out over time. In the site development plan the applicant will be impacting 6.37 acres
of weuands at the northwest corner of the properly (adjacentlo the road, Figure 3) and preserve approximately
11.73 acres to the south of the operations area that will be rehydrated and enhanced (Figure 3). Rehydration is
anticipated to greatly improve the vegetative conditions and make it more attractive to wetland wildlife.
All permits for this projecl have been issued by CoJlier County Government, SFWMD and USACOE as of the
writing of this report to proceed with the modification and expansion of this area for vegetative recycling and
composting.
StatelFederal Protected Soccies Listed. The FWC list was published in May 2008 and lists 117 itnimals as
protected in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix A. Based on general habitat requirements, historic
distributions and actual sightings, the FWC lists 51 animal species that may occur in Collier County. There are 50
species that are vertebrates and I invertebrate. The 51 species are listed in Figure 4.
The FWS list is updated daily on lheir website. The May 2009 list totals 113 animal and plant 'pecies as protected
in the State of Aorida and is attached as Appendix B. Based on general habitat requirements, historic distributions and
actual sightings, the FWS lists 24 species (24 animals and no plants) that may occur in Collier County. Species for
Collier Co. are listed in Figure 4 also.
Site Survev Results. Figure 5 indicates the cumulative total of all species observed over 6 survey events. Daily field
sheets are located in Appendix C. Overall, 20 species were noted, 16 bird species, 3 mammals and 1 reptile. The most
frequent bird species observed was mourning dove with 19 observations and for manunals . gray squirrel with 3
observations. The area also has received its second treatment for exotic nuisance plant removal as required by issued
pennits. The habitat is much more open than in previous years.
YaM Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Protected Species Report
01 May 2009
Page 3
Soecies Results.
Gopher Frog/Rana capilO: Prefers dry sandy, upland habitats adjacent to wetland areas. This type habitat is nol
present onsite. or adjacent properties and no individuals were observed on site. Changes in the project property
will have no effect on this species.
Cape Sable seaside sparrow/Ammodromus maritimus mirabilis: Currently inhabits se....onally inundated freshwater
interior marshes within Everglades National Park and Big Cypress National Preserve in Monroe and Dade County. Last
documented in Collier Co. in 1979. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property.
Florida Grasshopper sparrow/Ammodramus savannarum floridonus: Prefers large areas of frequently burned dry prairie
habitat, with patchy open areas sufficient for foraging. This habitat type is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the property. In addition, this species h.... not been observed since 1955 in Collier Co. Changes in the
project property will have no effect on this species.
Florida scrub jay/ Aphelocoma coerulescens: Prefers low growing scrub oak plants. This habitat is not present
onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in the project property will have no effect on
this species.
Limpkin/Arumus guarauna: Inhabits mangroves, freshwater marshes, swamps, springs and spring runs, and pond
and river margins. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida burrowing owllAlhene cuniculariafloridana: Prefers habitats of high, sparsely vegetated, sandy ground.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Cuban-/snowy plover, Charadrius alexandrinus: Prefers dry, sandy beaches, where they nest in shallow
depressions, usually near some vegetat.ion or debris. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Piping plover/Charadrius melodus: Prefers open, sandy benches and on tidal mudflats and
sandflats along the coasts. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Kirtland's warbler /Dendraicn klrtlandil; Nests in nearly homogeneous stands of usually 30 ha or more of dense
scrubby jack pine. Florida maybe a migration SlOp between Michigan and the Bahamas. Individuals may flay
straight through. This habitat is nol present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes
in this property will have no effect on this species.
Little blue heronlEgrelta caerulea: Feeds in shallow freshwater, brackish, and saltwater habitats. Nesting colonies
usually occur in coastal areas, but prefers foraging in freshwater lakes, marshes, swamps, and streams. Nests in a
variety of woody vegetation types, including cypress, willow, maple, black mangrove, and cabbage palm. Usually
breeds in mixed-species colonies in flooded vegetation or on islands. Nesting habitat is present onsite, but no
other nesting of other wading bird species has been observed. No individuals or nests were observed on the
property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately
12 aCres of forested wetlands in a preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Reddish egret/Egrella ruJeseens: Typically prefers coastal mangrove islands, or in Brazilian pepper on manmade
dredge spoil islands, near suitable foraging habitat. Generally forages in shallow water of variable salinity. Broad,
open, marine lidal flats and shorelines with little vegetation are ideal feeding areas. Alsn importanlare salt
YahlMulching
SDPA AR 7633
SprinS 2009 Protected Species Report
01 Mlly2009
Page 4
evaporation pools and lagoons, often located inside mangrove keys or just inside shoreline on mainland. This
habilal is not presenl onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have no effecI on this species.
Snowy egrellEgrelta Ihula: Nesls both inland and in coastal wetlands with nesls placed in many Iypes of woody
shrubs, especially mangroves and willows; usually over shallow waters. Almosl all nesting is over shallow waters
or on islands that are separated from shoreline by extensive open water. Feeds in many types of pennanently and
seasonally flooded wetlands, streams, lakes, and swamps, and in manmade impoundments and ditches. Breeding
.uccess is tied to water-level fluctuations. Preferred nesling habitat is not present onsite. There are no
pennanently inundated areas on site. Seasonally flooded areas are very short in duration. No individuals or
nesting were observed on the properties. Changes in Ihis property will have no effect on Ihis species. It is
planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of foresled wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in
habitat conditions may encourage use.
Tricolored heron/Egre/ro Iricolor: Most nesting colonies occur on mangrove islands or in willow Ihickets in fresh
water, but nesting sites include olher woody thickets on islands or over standing water. Prefers coaslal
environments. Feeds in a variely of permanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, mangrove swamps, tidal
creeks, dilches, and edges of ponds and lakes. Preferred nesting and feeding habitat is not present onsite and no
individuais were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on tltis species. It is
planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in
habitat conditions may encourage use.
White ibis/Eudocimus albus: Found in a wide variely of habitats, including freshwater and brackish marshes, salt
flats and .alt marsh meadow., many type. of forested wetlands, wel prairie., swales, seasonally inundated fields,
and man,made ditches. The foreSled wetland habitat is present onsite and targeted to be preserved and enhanced.
No individuals or nests were observed in the property. Changes in tltis property will have no effect on this
species. It is planned to rehydrale approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This
improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Peregrine falcon/Fa/co peregrinas: The Peregrine Falcon frequents open areas like marshes, fields, swamps, and
tidal areas. Since its reintroduction inlo the eastern United States, however, the Peregrine Falcon has colonized
many urban areas because of increased nesling sites (and nesting ledges being created on buildings). This species
i. considered 10 be recovered and i. wailing for delisting. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on the properties. Changes in this properly will have no effect on this species.
Southeaslem American kestrel/Fa/co sparverius paulus: Found in open pine habitats, woodland edges, prairies,
and pastures throughout much of Florida Nest sites are tall dead tree. or utility poles generally with an
unobstructed view of surroundings. Kestrels are not known 10 nest in Collier CounlY. Most individuals are
migrants from the north. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have little to no effect on this species.
Florida sandhill crane/Grus canadensis pra/ensis: Habitat: Prairies, freshwater marshes, and pasture lands.
A voids forests and deep marshes but uses transition zones and edges between these and prairies or pasture lands.
This habilat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
American oystercatcherlHaemalopus palliales: Habitat: Coastal waters. This habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properlies. Changes in this property will have no effecI on this species.
Wood stork/Mycleria Americana: Nests colonially in a variety of inundated forested wetlands, including cypress
strands and domes, mixed hardwood swamps, sloughs, and mangroves. Forages in 6-15 inches of surface water.
The preferred nesting habital is presenl on site, but the surface water does not get very deep on Ihe property during
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Protected Species Report
01 May 2009
Page 5
the year due 10 the impacts of road building changing the hydrology. No individuals or nests were observed on the
properlies. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately
12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habilat conditions may encourage use.
Brown pelican/Pelecanu. ocddemalis: Habitat: Mainly coastal, feeding in shallow estuarine waters, and (less
often) far offshore. . This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Red-cockaded woodpecker/Picoides borealis: Habitat: Inhabits open, mature pine woodlands Ihat have a
diversity of grass, forb, and shrub species. Prefers mature slash pine trees that are generally larger than 12 inches
in diameter, a wide spacing of trees, no subcanopy and relatively dry conditions. The preferred habital is not
present onsile. No individuals were observed on the property. Again for Ihis survey all pine trees were inspected
for nest cavities or start holes and none were found. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Roseate spoonbill/Plala/ea ajaja (Ajaia ajaja): Habitat: Primarily nesls in mixed-species colonies on coastal
mangrove islands or in Brazilian pepper on man-made dredge spoil islands near suitable foraging habitat. Does
feed in forested wetland habitats with slow moving waler. Although forested wetland type habitat present,
hydrology has been so impacted it is very low quality. No individuals or indications of this species were observed
on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effecl on this species. It is planned to rehydrate
approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may
encourage use.
Crested caracara/Po/yborus p/ancus audubonii (earacam cheriway): Open country, including dry prairie and
pasture lands wilh cabbage palm, cabbage palm/live oak hammocks, and shallow ponds and sloughs. Preferred
nest trees are cabbage palms, followed by live oaks. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Everglades snail IUIe/Rosrrhamus sociabilis plumbeus: Habitat: Large open freshwater marshes and lakes with
shallow water. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Black skimmer/Rynchops niger: Habitat: Coastal waters, including beaches, bays, estuaries, sandbars, tidal creeks
(foraging), and also inland waters of large lakes, phosphale pits, and flooded agricultural fields. This habitat is not
present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this properly will have no effect on
this species.
Least tern/S/emn an/illarum: Habitnl: Coastal areas throughout Florida, including beaches, lagoons, bays and
estuaries. Increasingly use artificial nesting sites, including gravel rooftops, dredge spoil islands or other dredged
malerial deposits, construction sites, causeways, and mining lands. This habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this properly will have no effect on this species.
Roseate lern/S/ema dougalli (S/erna dougallii dougallii): Habilat: Nest sites include bare limestone, shell-sand
beaches, newly deposited rock and marl fill, dredge material, and heaps of broken coral deposited by slorms. This
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have no effect on this species.
Bachman's warbler/Vermivora bachmanii: Historic records indicate the Bachman's warbler nested in low, wet
forested areas containing variable amounts of water, but usually with some waler that was permanent. This
species is considered extinct in Florida. This preferred habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
YablMulching
SDPA AR 1633
Spring 2009 Protc:clrd Species Rc:porl
o I May 2009
Pll~e6
Smalltooth sawfish/Pristis pectina/a: Habitat: Shallow coastal, estuarine, and fresh waters; often in brackish
water near river mouths and large embayments, in deeper holes on bottoms of mud or muddy sand. This habitat is
not present onsite and no individuals were observed 00 the properties. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
Rivulus (mangrove rivulus)/Rivltlus marmoratus: Habitat; coastal, appears to prefer red mangrove (Rhizophora
mangle). This habitat is lIOl presenl onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Sei whale/Balaenoplera borealis: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Generally, in deep water; along edge of continental
shelf and in open ocean. This babitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Fin whale (finhack whale)/BaJaenoptera physalus: Habitat; Pelagic, marine. Usually found in largest numbers
25 miles or more from shore. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
North Atlantic right whale/Eubalaena gwcialis (Balaena glacialis [inel. auslralis/): Habitat: Inhabits near shore
and offshore waters. Mainly coastal in the North Atlantic. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
Florida mastiff baliEumops glaucinus floridanus: Habitat: Roosts in palms and hollow trees and in buildings.
Forages high in air over natural as well as human-altered landscapes. Minimal preferred roosting habitat is
presenlonsite. No individuals were observed on the properties or surrounding areas during surveys. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Humpback wtJale/Megaplera novaeangliae: Habitat: Pelagic and coastal waters, sometimes frequenting inshore
areas such as bay.. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in lhi. property will have no effect on this species.
Caribbean monk sealfMonachus Iropicalis: Habitat; Marine areas. Shallow lagoons and reefs, sandy beaches, and
permanent islets or beaches above high tide. Mainly west coast of Florida and Caribbean. This habitat is not
present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on
this species.
Everglades mink/Mus/ek! vison evergladensis: Habitat: A variety of wetland communities, incIoding salt marsh,
freshwater marsh, cypress swamp, and hardwood swamp. There is very Iiltle of the preferred habitat is onsite.
However, no individuals were observed or, indicators of the presence was noted on the property. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands
in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Spenn whale1Physeler macrocephalus: Habitat: Pelagic. prefers deep water, sometimes around islands or in
shallow shelf waters. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida panther/Puma (Pelis) concolor coryi: Habitat: Reqoires extensive bJocks of mostly forested communities.
The FWC panther telemetry database form 198 I -2008 indicates no utilization of this property (Figure 6). The
forested habitat panthers utilize is present onsite. No individuals or indicators were observed on the property.
Planned changes in this property will have no effect on this species. However, this property is considered to be in
the area of the Primary Panther Habitat Zones articulated by FWS (Figure 7). This issue is currently heing
evaluated by USACOE and FWS for proposed mitigation. FWS has indicated that this area has little value to the
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Protected Species Repon
01 May 2009
Page 7
panther since it is on the edge of the Primary Habitat Zone and bordered by 1-75. Proposed changes to the
property are expected to have liltle to no effect on this species.
Big Cypress fox squirrel/Sciurus niger avicennia: Habitat: Sandhills (high pine), pine flatwoods, and pastures and
other open, ruderal habitats with scattered pines and oaks. Depends on a variety of oak trees for seasonal food and
nest material. Longleaf pine cones and seeds are important foods. This habitat type is present onsite, bUI very few
oak trees. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on lhis
species. Crealion of the preserve area may encourage ulilization.
FloridalWest Indian manatee/Trichechus manatus latirastris (Trichechus manatus): Habilat: Coastal walers, bays,
rivers, and (occasionally) lakes. Requires warm-waler refugia such as springs or cooling effluent during cold
weather. Sheltered coves are important for feeding, resting, and calving. This habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida black bearlUrsus americanus floridanl": Habitat: A wide variety of forested communities is needed lo
support the varied seasonal diet of black bears. Forested wetlands are particularly important for diurnal cover.
This habilat is present on site. However this area is bordered on the south by 1-75 which greatly delers access. No
individuals or indices were observed on the properties. Figure 8 indicates black bear lelemetry locations form
1983-2000 as collected by the FWC. The closest bear location was 3600 feet from the property however it is
south of 1-75 and excluded from the property. North of 1-75 the closette]emetry location was approximately 5900
square feet. Figure 9 indicates the locations of nuisance issues from 1980-2006 according to the FWC. Generally,
there has been no telemetry or nuisance issues on or immediately around the project property. Personal
communication with the Naples FWC office revealed that only 3-4 nuisance complaints for black bears had been
lodged for this general area since 1991 and they were in the last 3 years. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species. Creation of the preserve area may encourage utilization, but is not expe<oted to.
Loggerhead seaturtle/Care/la caretra: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Green seaturtle//Chelonia mydas: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nesl on coastal sand beaches. This
habital is Dot present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Chang", in this property will
have no effect on lhis species.
American crocodile//Crocodylus acutus: Habitat: Coaslal estuarine marshes, tidal swamps, and creeks along
edg'" of mainland and islands. Usualiy associated with mangroves. Nests on beaches, stream banks:and levees.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Leatherback seaturtlelDennochelys coriacea: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Eastern indigo snake/lDrymarchon corais couperi: Habitat: Broad range of habilats, from scrub and sandhill 10
wet prairies and mangrove swamps. ]n northern part of range, oflen winters in gopher tortoise burrows in sandy
uplands but forages in more hydric habitats. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed
on the plOperty. Also, no gopher tortoise burrows were discovered. Changes in this property will have no effect
on this species. It is expected that the planned rehydration of this area will further discourage possible utilization.
Hawksbill seaturtle//Erelmochelys imbricata: Habital: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Yahl Muktiing
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Protccted Species Rcpon
OJ May 2009
Page 8
Gopher tortoiseJGopherus polyphemus: Habitat: Typically found in dry upland habitats, including sandhills,
scrub, xeric oak hammock, and dry pine flatwoods; also commonly uses disturbed habitats such as pastures, old
fields, and road shoulders. Typical habitat not present onsite. No burrows or individuals observed on site.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is expected that the planned rehydration of this area
will further discourage possible utilization
Kemp's ridley seaturtle//Lepidochelys kempii: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Florida tree snaiV/Uguus fascialus: Habitat: Tropical hardwood hammock (rockland hammock). This species
prefers smooth-barked !rees. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properti.es.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
CONCLUSIONS
The majority of habitat present on site is 624 pine, cypress, palm. This habitat type appears to be the resull of a
hydrology impacts over a long period of time, which dried the area out and allowed slash pine to invade in cypress
transition areas in the dry years. There was no indication of utilization of the 6.37 acres of 624 to be cleared by
protected species. The approximate 11.73 acres that will be preserved and to be rehydrated has a great potential to
improve the conditions of the area and increase wildlife utilization. Creation of the preservation area also insures
that there will be a conneclion to the 1-75 drainage for "community flow way" to the north of this project. In
addition, the preserve area will be protected by a pennanent conservation easement with tbe SFWMD. The
preserve area will also be managed for restoration of a natural association of vegetalion and function. The
preserve area has received 2 !realments for the removal on nuisance exotic plants and the habilal is much more
open. Overall, changes in this property will have little to no effect on protected species detected. Implementation
of the preserve area, enbancement and rehydration of it will increase wildlife utilization and habitat quality on the
property, especially for wetland oriented species; and provide a pennanent flow way for lhe natural flow of water
form the nOM. This area is not expected to have a high increase in wildlife utilization due to the proximity to I.
75. Agaln.this area would be consider extremely marginal for wildlife use because of its proximity 10 1-75.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR. 1633
Spring 2009 Protecttd S~cic:s Report
01 May 2009
Page 9
REFERENCES
Ashton, R. E., Jr., and P. S. Ashton. 1988a. Handbook of reptiles and amphibian. of Florida, part 3: The amphibians.
Windward Publ., Inc., Miami, Florida
_' 1988b. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 1: The snakes, 2nd ed. Windward Publ., Inc.,
Miami, Florida.
_' 1991. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 2: Lizards, turtles & crocodilians, 2nd ed. Windward
Pub!., Inc., Miami, Florida.
Barbour, D. B., and S. R. Humphrey. 1982. Status and habilat of the Key Largo wondra! and cOlton mouse (Neotoma
floridana .malli and Peromyscus gos.ypinus allapaticola). J Manunal. 63:144.148.
Barnwell, M. E., P. A. Meylan, and T. Walsh. 1997. The sponed turtle (Clemmys gunata) in central Florida. Chelonian
Cons. BioI. 2:405-408.
Bartlett, R. D., and P. P. Bartlett. 1999. A field guide to Florida reptile. and amphibians. GulfPubl. Co., Houston,
Texas.
Berner, L., and M. L. Pescador. 1988. The mayGie. of Florida. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Birkenholz., D. E. 1963. A study of the life history and ecology of the round-lailed muskrat (Neofiber alieni). Ecolog.
Monogr.33:225-280.
Bortone, S. A. 1989. Notropis melanostomus, a new species of cyprinid fish from the Blackwater.Yellow River drainage
of northwest Florida. Copeia 3:737-741.story, habitat asse.sment, and systematics of the blackmouth shiner
(Notropis sp.), Blackwater
River drainage. Final Rep. Nongame Wildl. Prog., F10ridn Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Bouchard, R. W. 1978. Taxonomy, ecology and phylogeny of the subgenus Depressicambarus, with the description of a
new species from Florida and redescription. of Cambarus graysoni, Cambarus lalimnnus, and Cambarus shiatu.
(Decapoda: Cambaridae). Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat Hist. 3:27-60.
Bowen, P. J. 2000. Demographic, distribution, and melapopulation analyses of the burrowing owl (Alhene cunicularia)
in Florida. M.S. thesis, Univ. Central Florida, Orlando.
Brady, J. T., T. H. Kunz., M. D. Tuttle, and D. E. Wilson. 1982. Gray bat recovery plan. U.S. Fi.h Wildl. Serv., Denver,
Colorado.
Brim Box, J., and J. D. Williams. 2000. Unionid mollusks of the Apalachicola Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia.
Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 21:1-143.
Brody, R. W. 1990. Status of habilat and populations of Procambarus pictus in the North Fork of Black Creek, Clay
County, Florida. St. Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida.
Brown, L. N. 1997. A guide to the mammals of the southeastern United Slates. Univ. Tennessee Press, Knoxville.
Brown, W. S. 1993. Biology, slalus, and management of the timber rattlesnake (Crotalus horridus): a guide for
conservation. Soc. Stud. Ampbib. Rept. Herp. Circ. 22.
Carle, F. L., and M. L. May. 1987. Gomphus (Phanogomphus) westfalli spec. novo from the Gulf coast of Florida
(Anisoptera: Gomphidae). Odonatologica 16:67.75.
Chace, F. A., Jr. 1954. Two subterranean shrimps (Decapoda: Caridea) from Rorida and the West Indies, with a revised
key to Ihe American species. J. Washington Acad. Sci. 44:318-324.
Chafin, L. 2000. Field guide 10 the rare plants of Florida, Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Chase, C. A., and J. A. Gore. 1989. Snowy plover breeding distribution. Unpubl. final rept., Florida Fish and
Wild1.Conserv. Comm., Tallahassee.
Choate, P. M. 1984. A new species of Cicindela Unnaeus (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae) from Florida, and elevation of C.
abdominalis scabrosa Schaupp to species level. Entomol. News 95:73-82.
Conant, R., and J. T. Collins. 1991. A field guide to reptiles and amphibians: eastern and central North America, 3rd ed.
Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Cox, J., D. Inkley, and R. Kautz. 1987. Ecology and habitat protection needs of gopher tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus)
populations found on lands slated for large-seale development in Florida. Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep.
no. 4, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Crance, J. H. 1986. Habitat suitability index models and instream flow suitability curves: shortnose sturgeon. U. S. Fish
WildL Servo BioI. Rep. 82(10.129).
Deitz, D. c., and T. C. Hines. 1980. Alligator nesting in north-central Florida. Copeia 1980:249-258.
Delany, M. F., and C. L Abercrombie. 1986. American alligator food habits in north-central Florida. J. Wildl. Manag.
50:348-353.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Protected SpcCle5 Report
01 May 2009
Page 10
Delany, M. F.. P.B. Walsh, B. Pranty, and D.W. Perkins. 1999. A previously unknown population of Florida
grasshopper sparrow on Avon Park Air Force Range. Florida Field Nat. 27(2):52-56.
Deyrup, M., and R. Franz (eds.). 1994. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. IV: Invertebrates. Univ. Press of
Florida, Gainesville.
Dodd, C. K., Jr. 1988. Synopsis of the hiological data on the loggerhead sea turtle Carella carena (Linnaeus 1758). U.S.
Fish Wildl. Servo BioI. Rep.88(l4).
Duggins, C. F., Jr., A. A. Karlin, K. Relyea, and R. W. Yerger. ]986. Systematics of the key silverside, Menidia
conchorum, with comments on other Menidia species (Pisces: Atherinidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot. 25(2): 133-
150.
Dunkle, S. W. 1989. Dragonflies of the Florida Peninsula, Bermuda and the Bahamas. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville,
Florida.
_.2000. Dragonflies through binoculars: A field guide to the dragonflies of North America. Oxford Univ. Press,
New York.
Dunn, J. 1999. National Geographic Society field guide to the birds of North America. 3rd ed. National Geographic
Soc., Washington, D.C.
Emmel, T. c., and M. C. Minno. 1988. Habitat requirements and status of the endemic Schaus swallowtail in the Florida
Keys. Final report, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Enge, K. M., M. M. Bentzien, and F. Percival. 1986. Florida scrub lizard status survey. Tech. Rept. No. 26 to U.S. Fish
Wild!. Serv., Jacksonville End. Sp. Office, Florida.
Ernst, C. H., and R. W. Barbour. 1989. Snakes of eastern North America. George Mason Univ. Press, Fairfax, Virginia.
Ernst, C. H., J. E. Llvich, and R. W. Barbour. 1994. Turtles of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Inst. Press,
Washington, D.C.
Ewert, M. A., and D. R. Jackson. 1994. Nesting ecology of the alligator snapping turtle (Macroclemys temminckii)
along the lower Apalachicola River, Florida. Final Rep. NG89-020, Nongame Wildlife Prog. Florida Game and
Fresh Water FIsh Comm., Tallahassee.
FItzpatrick, J. W., G. E. Woolfenden, and M. T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related habitat requirements
of the Florida scrub jay (Aphelocoma coemlescens coerulescens). Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 8,
Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Florida FIsh & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003. Management Plan Red-Cockaded Woodpecker Picoides
borealis. TaUahassee, FI. 78 pp.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003, October 8. Florida's Waterbird Colony Locator.
htlp://www.myfwc.comlwaders.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2006. Eagle nest locator. hllp://wld,fwc.state.tl.usleagleleaglenests.
Florida Natural Areas Inventory. 1990. Guide to the natuml communities of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory
and Florida Depl. Natural Resources, Tallahassee.
Franz, R. 1986. The Florida gopher frog and the Florida pine snake as burrow associates of the gopher tortoise in
northern Florida. Pp. 16.20 in D. R. Jackson and R. J. Bryant (eds.). The gophe. tortoise and its community.
Proc. 5 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council, Gainesville, Florida.
Franz, R., and L. M. Franz. 1979. Distribution, habitat preference and status of populations of the Black Creek crayfish,
Procambarus (Ortmannicus) pictus (Decapoda: Cambaridae). Florida Sci. 42: 13-17.
Franz, R., and L. L. Smith. 1999. Distribution and status of the striped newt and Florida gopher frog in peninsular
Florida. Final Rep. Florida Fish and Wildt. Cons. Comm., Tallahassee.
Gaby, R., M. P. McMahon, F. J. Mazzotti, W. N. Gillies, andJ. R. Wilcox. 1985. Ecology and status of a population of
Crocodylus acutus (Reptilia; Crocodilidae) at a power plant site in Florida. J. Herpetol. 19:189-198.
Georgia Department of Natural Resources. 1999. Protected animals of Georgia. Nongame - Endangered Wildlife
Program, Wildlife Res. Div., Georgia Dept. Nat. Res., Social Circle.
Gilbert, C. R. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. 4: Fishes. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesvi1le.
_(ed). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. II: FIshes. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Glassberg, J., M. C. Minno, and J. V. Calhoun. 2000. Butterflies through binoculars: a field, finding, and gardening
guide to butterflies in Florida. Oxford Univ. Press, New York.
Gordon, M. E., and W. R. Hoeh. 1993. Anodonta heardi,a new species of freshwater mussel (Bivalvia:Unionidae) from
the Apalachicola River system of the southeastern United States. Walkerana 7:265-273.
Gore, J. A., and M. J. Kinnison. 1991. Hatching success in roof and ground colonies of least terns. The Condor 93;759-
762.
Yahl Mulching
SOPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Protected Species Repon
01 May 2009
Page I I
Guillory, V. 1979. Lake Eustis pupfish investigations. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission 1977-1979 Final
Report: Sludy I-N. Tallahassee.
Guillory, V., and W. E. Johnson. 1986. Habitat, conservation status, and zoogeography ofthe cyprinodont fish,
Cyprinodon variegatus hubbsi (Carr). The Southwestern Nat 31 (1):95-100.
Hall, E. R. 1981. Manunals of North America. 2 nd ed, John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Harvey, M. J. 1992. Bats of the eastern United States. Arkansas Game and Fish Comm., Little Rock.
Hersh, S.L. 1981. Ecology of the Key Largo woodmt (Neostoma floridana smalli). J. Mammal. 62:201-206.
Hipes, D., D. R. Jackson, K. NeSmith, D. Printiss and K. Brandt. 200 I. Field guide 10 lhe rare animals of Florida
Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Hirth, H. F. 1971. Synopsis of lhe biological data on the green tunle Chelonia mydas (Lionaeus) 1758. FAO Fish.
Synopsis 85.
Hobbs, H. H., Jr. 1942. The crayfishes of Florida. Univ. Florida Publ., BioI. Sci. Ser. 3(2):H79.
Hoehn, T. S. 1998. Rare and imperiled fish species of Florida: a watershed perspective. Office Envir. Serv., Florida
Game and Fresh Water Fish Corom., Tallahassee.
Hovis, J. A., and M. S. Robson, 1989. Breeding slatus and distribution of the least tern in the Florida Keys. Florida Field
Nat 17(3):61-66.
Humphrey, S. R. (ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. I: Mammals. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville
Humphrey, S. R. 1988. Density estimates of Ihc endangered Key Largo woodrat and cotton mouse (Neotoma floridana
smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus aIlapaticola) using the nesled-grid approach. J. Manunal. 69(3):524-531.
Humphrey, S. R., and H. W. Setzer. 1989. Geographic varialion and taxonomic revision of mink (Mustela vison) in
Florida. J. ManunaI. 17:382-392.
Hurst, H. N., G. Bass, and C. Hubbs. 1975. The biology of Ihe Guadalupe, Suwannee, and redeye basses. 1'1'.47-53 in
R. H. Stroud and H. Clepper (eds.).
Black bass biology and management. Sport Fishing 1nstitule,Washington, D.C. Jackson, D. R., and R. Franz. 1999.
Survey for the fire-back crayfish in the Apalachicola ravine system, northern Florida. Final report 10 The Nature
Conservancy. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee,
Jackson, D. R., and E. G. Milstrey. 1989. The fauna of gopher tortoise burrows. PI'. 86-98 in J. E. Diemer, D. R.
Jackson, 1. L. Landers, J. N. Layne, and D. A. Wood, eds. Gopher Tortoise Relocation Symposium
Proceedings. Nongame Wildl. Program Tech. Rep. no. 5. Florida Game and Fresh Waler Fish Corom..
Tallahassee.
Jackson, D. R., and R. N. Walker. 1997. Reproduction in Ihe Suwannee cooter, Pscudemys coneinna suwanniensis.
Bull. Florida Mus. Nat Hist 41 :69-167.
Jackson, J. F. 1973. Distribution and population phenetics of the Florida scrub lizard, Sceloporus wood;' Copeia
1973:746-761.
Jackson, J. F., and S. R. Telford. 1974. Reproductive ecology of Ihe Florida scrub lizard, Sceloporus wood;' Copeia
1974:689-694.
James, F. C. 1991. Signs of trouble ir the largesl remaining population of red-cockaded woodpeckers. Auk 108:419-
423.
Johnson, S. A. 2001. Autecology of lhe stri.ped newt (Notophthalmus perstriatus): life-history, upland-habitat use,
paedomoIl>hosis. and conservation genetics. Ph.D. di.s., Univ. Florida, Gainesville.
Kale, H. W., II. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. 2. Birds. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Kale, H. W.. II., B. Pranty, B. Stith, and W. Biggs. 1992. An atlas of Florida's breeding birds. Final Rep.
Nongame Wildlife Prog., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Keppner, E. J., and L A. Keppner. 2000. A preliminary search for Ihe Panama Cily crayfish, Procambams
(Leconticambarus) econfinae, Hobbs, 1942, in Bay County, Florida. Report to U.s. Fish Wildl. Serv., Panama
City, Florida.
Knisley, C. B., and 1. M. Hill. 1994. Studies of the Florida Highlands liger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: distribution,
abundance, habitat characteristics and biology. Report 10 U.S. Fish WildL Serv., Jacksonville, Florida.
_' 1996. The Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: habital requirements, remaining mnge, life
history, and management. Final Rep. Florida Nongame Wildlife Prog. NG91-012, Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Conun., Tallahassee.
Kulhavey, D. L., R. G. Hooper, and R. Costa (eds.). 1995. Red-cockaded woodpecker: recovery, ecology, and
management. Center for Applied Studies in Forests, College of Forestry, Stephen F. Austin State Univ.,
Nacogdoches, Texas.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Prol:ccted Species Report
01 May 2009
Page 12
Kushlan, J. A. 1974. Observations on the role of the American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) in the southern
Florida wetlands. Copeia 1974:993-996.
_, and F. J. Mazzotti. 1989. Population biology of the American crocodile. J. Herpelol. 23:7-21.
Lazell, J. D., Jr. 1989. Wildlife oflhe Florida Keys: a natural history. Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Layne, 1. N. 1990. The Florida mouse. Pp. 1-21 in C. K. Dodd, Jr., R. E. Ashton, Jr., R. Franz, and E. Wesler (eds.).
Burrow Associates of the Gopher Tonoise. Proc. 8 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council. Florida Mus. Nat.
Hist., Gainesville.
Loftin, R. W. 1992. Vse of nest boxes by the Florida kestrel. Florida Field Nat. 20(3):57-64.
McMillian, M. 2001. Florida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomination fonn -Lake Istokpoga, Audubon of Florida,
Tampa Bay Sanctuanes.
McNair, D. B., and J. A. Gore. 1999. Recent breeding status of royal and sandwich terns in nonhwest Florida. Florida
Field Nat. 27(3):117-120.
Maehr, D. S. 1987. Florida panther movements, social organization, and habitat utilization. E-1. 11 annual performance
report. Florida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm., Tallahassee.
Martin, W. H., and D. B. Means. 1998. Distribution and habitat relationships of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake
(Crotalus adamanteus). Herpetological Nat. Hist. 7:9-34.
Means, D. B. 1975. Compelitive exclusion along a habitat gradient between two species of salamanders (Desmognathus)
in western Florida. J. Biogeog. 2:253. 263.
Means, D. B., and A. A. Karlan. 1989. A new species of Desmognathus from the eastern Gulf Coastal Plain.
Herpetologica 45:37-46.
Means, D. B., and C. J. Longden. ] 970. Observations on the occurrence of Desmognathus monticola in Florida.
Herpetologica 26:396-399.
_' 1976. Aspects of the biology and zoogeography of the pine barrens treefrog, Hyla andersonii, in oonhern
Florida. Herpetologica 32:117-130.
Means, D. B., and P. E. Moler. 1979. The pine barrens treefrog: fue, seepage bogs, and management implications. Pp.
77-83 in R. R. adorn and L. Landers (eds.). Proc. rare and endangered wildlife symposium. Georgia Dept. Nal.
Res., Game and Fish Div. Tech. Bull. WrA.
Meylan, A. B. 1999. Slatus of the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region. Chelonian Cons.
BioI. 3:177-184.
_, and M. Donnelly. 1999. Status justification for listing the hawksbill tunle (Eretmochelys imbricata) as Critically
Endangered on the 1996 IVCN Red List of Threatened Animals. Chelonian Cons. BioI. 3:200-224.
Mettee, M. E, P. E. O'Neil, and 1. M. Pierson. 1996. Fishes of Alabama and the Mobile Basin. Oxmoor House, Inc.,
Birmingham, Alabama.
Minno, M. c., and D. Pierce. 1999. Florida butterfly gardening: A complete guide to attracting, identifying, and
enjoying butterflies of the lower south. Vniv. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Mitchell, 1. C. 1977. Geographic variation of Elaphe guttata (Reptilia: Serpentes) in the Atlantic coastal plain. Copeia
1977:33-41.
Moler, P. E. 1981. Notes on Hyla andersonii in Florida and Alabama. J. Herpetol. 15:441-444.
_' 1985. A new species of frog (Ranidae: Rana) from northwestern Florida. Copeia 1985:379-383.
_(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. Ill: Amphibians and reptiles. Vniv. Press of Florida,
Gainesville.
_' 1996. Alligator snapping turtle: distribution and relative abundance. Final report 7544. Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Mount, R. H. 1975. The reptiles and amphibians of Alabama. Auburn Univ. Agric. Exp. Station, Auburn, Alabama.
Myers, R. L., and J J. Ewel (eds.) 1990. Ecosystems of Florida. Vniv. Central Florida Press, Orlando.
NatureServe. 2006. NatureServe Explorer: An online eneyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 5.0. NatureServe,
Arlington, Virginia. http://www.natureserve.orgiexplorer.
Neill, W. T. 1971. The last of the ruling reptiles: alligators, crocodiles, and their kin. Columhia Univ. Press, New York.
Page, L. M., and B. M. Burr. 1998. A field guide to freshwater fishes: North America north of Mexico, 2nd ed.
Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Paul, R. T. 1991. Status reporr - Egrella rufescens (Gmelin) reddish egret. V.S. Fish Wild\. Serv., Houston, Texas.
_' and A. F. SchnapC. 2000. Florida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomina-tion fonn - Passage Key National
Wildlife Refuge, Audubon of Florida, Tampa Bay Sanctuaries.
Pennak, R. W. 1978. Fresh-water invertebrates of the United States. 2nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
YahlMulching
SOPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Protected Species Report
01 May 2009
Page 13
Peterson, RT. 1998. Peterson field guide to easlern birds. 41h ed. Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Petranka, J. W. 1998. Salamanders of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian lnst. Press, Washington, D.C.
Pilsbry, H. A. 1946. Land Mollusca of North America, Vol. 2, part 1. Monograph of the Academy of Nalural Sciences,
Philadelphia.
Pimm, S. (ed). 2000. The 2000 Cape Sable sparrow annual report. Accessed 2001 May 8.
Poole, A., and F. Gill (eds.). 1992-2000. The birds of North America. The Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia,
and The American Ornithologists' Union, Washington, D.C.
Pos!. W., and J. S. Greenlaw. 2000. The present and future of the Cape Sable seaside sparrow. Rorida Field Nat.
28(3):93-110.
Pranty, B. 1996. A birder's guide to Florida. American Birding Association, Inc., Colorado Springs, Colorado.
Printiss, D. J., and D. L. Hipes. 1999. Rare amphibian and reptile survey of Eglin Air Force Base, Florida. Final report
10 U.S. Dept. of Defense. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Pritchard, P. C. H. 1989. The alligator snapping turtle: biology and conservation. Milwaukee Publ. Mus., Milwaukee,
Wisconsin.
Quay, T. L., J. B. Funderburg, Jr., D. S. Lee, E. F. Potter, and C. S. Robbins (eds.). 1983. The seaside sparrow, its
biology and management. Occ. Papers, Nonh arolina BioI. Surv. North Carolina Slate Mus. Nat. Hist., Raleigh.
Relyea, K., and B. Sutton. 1975. A new troglobitic crayfish of the genus Procambarus from Rorida. (Decapoda:
Aslacidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot. 19(1-2):8.16.
Rice, D. W. 1957. Life history and ecology of Myotis austroriparius in Florida. J. Mammal. 38:15-32.
Robbins, C. S., B. Bruun, and H. S. Zim. 2001. Birds of Nonh America: a guide 10 field identification. St. Martin's
Press, New York.
Rndgers, J. A., and H. T. Smith. 1995. Set-back distances to protect nesting bird colonies from human disturbance in
Florida. Conserv. BioI. 9:89-99.
Rodgers, J. A., Jr., H. W. Kale 11, and H. 1. Smith (eds.). 1996. Rare and endangered biola of Rorida, vol. V: Birds.
Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Robertson, W. B" Jr, and G. E. Woolfenden. 1992. Florida bird species: an annotated list. P10rida Omithol. Soc. Spec.
Pub. no. 6: ix + 260.
Roosenburg, W. M. 2000. Impact of a bycalch reduction device on diamondback terrapin and blue crab caplure in crab
pots. Ecol. Applic. 10:882-889.
Ross, J. P" S. Beavers, D. Mundell, and M. Ainh-Kindree. 1989. The status of Kemp's ridley. Center Marine Cooserv.,
Washington, D.C.
Runde, D., J. Gore, 1. Hovis, M. Robson, and P. Southall. 1991. Rorida atlas of breeding sites for herons and their
allies: update 1986 - 1989. Nongame Wildlife Program Tech. Rep. no. 10. Rorida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm., Tallahassee.
Semlitsch, R. D. 1983. Structure and dynamics of lwo breeding populations of the eastern tiger salamander, Ambysroma
tigrinum. Copeia 1983:608-616.
Shealy, R. M. 1976. The natural history of lhe Alabama map turtle" Graptemys pulchra BaUI, in Alabama. Bull. Rorida
State Mus., BioI. Sci. 21:47-11.
Shriver, G. W., P. D. Vickery, and S. A. Hedges. 1996. Effects of summer bums on Florida grasshopper sparrows.
Florida Field Nat. 24(3):68-73.
Sibley. D. A. 2000. The Sibley guide to birds. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
Spotila, J. R., A. E. Dunham, A. J. Leslie, A. C. Sleyermark, P. T. Plotkin, and F. V. Paladino. 1996. Worldwide
population decline of Dcrmochelys coriacea: arc leatherback tunles going extinct? Chelonian Cons. BioI.
2:209-222.
Sprandel, G. L., J. A. Gore, and D. T. Cobb. 1997. Winter shorebird survey. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm.
Final Perf. Rep. Tallahassee.
Stevenson, H. M. 1970. Occurrence of the carpenler frog in Rorida. Quart. J. Florida Acad. Sci. 32:233-235.
_' and B. H. Anderson. 1994. The birdlife ofFJorida. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville. Slys, B. 1993. Ecology
and habitat protection needs of the southeastern American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) on large-scale
developmenl sites in Florida. Nongame Wildl. Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 13. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm., Tallahassee.
Telford, S. R. 1959. A study of the sand skink, Neoseps reynoldsl. Copeia 1959: J 00- 119.
Tenant. A. 1997. A field guide 10 snakes of Florida. GulfPubl. Co., Houston, Texas.
Yahl Mulcbing
SOPA AR 7633
Spring 2009 Prolected Species Report
o I May 2009
Page 14
Timmerman, W. W. \989. Home range, habitat use and behavior of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake. M, S. thesis,
Univ. Florida, Gainesville.
Thaxton, J. E., and T. M. Hingtgen, \996. Effects of suburbanization and habitat fragmentation on Florida scrub-jay
dispersal. Florida Field Nat 24(2):25-37.
Toland, B. ] 999a. Nesting success and productivity of Florida sandhill cranes on natural and developed sites in
southeastern Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(1):\0- 13.
_' 1999b. Nesl site characteristics, breeding phenology, and nesting success of American oystercatchers in Indian
River County, Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(3):\ ]2-] 16.
Tuberville, T D" J. R. Bodie, J. B. Jensen, L. LaClaire, and 1. W. Gibbons. 2000. Apparent decline of the soulhem hog-
nosed snake, Heterodon simus. J. Elisha Mitchell Soc. 116:19-40.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife. Service. 1982. Stock Island tree snail recovery plan. U.s. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_' 1984. American crocodile recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_' 1987. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; proposed threatened status for two Florida lizards. Ped.
Reg. 52(13):2242-2246,
_' 1998a. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; 90-day finding for a petition to delist the Squirrel
Chimney cave shrimp. Fed. Reg. 63:67618-676\9.
_' 1998b. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; determination of endangered status for five freshwater
mussels and threatened status for two freshwater mussels from the eastern Gulf Slope drainages of Alabama,
Florida, and Georgia. Fed. Reg. 63(50):12664-12687.
_' 1998c. Okaloosa darter lEtheostoma okaloosae) recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Servo Atlanta, Georgia.
_. \999. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; final rule to list the !1atwoods salamander as a threatened
species. Fed. Reg. 64:]569\.15704.
_. 1999. South Florida Muhi-Species Recovery Plan U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. 2172 pp.
_. 2000. Candidate and listing priority assignment form: Cicindela highlandensis,
_.2006. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service The Endangered Species Program (web application]. US Fish & Wildlife
Service. Washington, D.C. htlp://www.fws.gov/endangercd
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Gulf States Marine Fisheries Commission. \995.Gulf Sturgeon Recovery Plan.
Atlanta, Georgia.
Walls, J. G. 1976. Fishes of the northern Gulf of Mexico. 1. F. H. Publications, Inc., Ud., Hong Kong.
Whitaker, J. 0.1996. National Aodubon Society field guide to North American mammals. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
Williams, J. D., and G. H. Burgess. 1999. A new species of bass, Micropterus cataractae (Teleostei: Centrarchidae),
from the Apalachicola River basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Bull. Florida Mus. Nat. Hist. 42(2):81-
114.
Witzell, W. N. 1983, Synopsis of Ihe biological data on the hawksbill tunle Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus, ] 766).
FAO Fish. Synopsis 137.
Wood, P. B., M. L. Hoffman, M. W. Collopy, and J. M. Schaefer. 1988. Southeastern American kestrel (FalC<l
sparveri~s paulus) natural history, life requirements, and habitat protectior.'guidelines. Final report to Office of
Envir. Services, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Corron., Tallahassee.
Woods, C, A., W. Post, and C. W. Kilpatrick. 1982. Microtus pennsylvanicus (Rodentia; Muridae) in Florida: a
Pleistocene relict in a coastal saltmarsh. Bull. Florida State Mus. BioI. Sci, 28:25-52.
Wooley, C. M., and E. J. Crateau. 1985, Movement, microhabilal, exploitation, and management of Gulf of Mexico
sturgeon, Apalachicola River, Florida. North American J. Fisheries Manag. 5:590-605.
Wunderlin, R.P. 1998. Guide to the vascular plants of Florida. University Presses of
Florida, Gainesville, Florida
Zambrano, R., M. S. Robson, D. Y. Chametzky, and H. T. Smith. 1997. Distribution and status of least tern nesting
colonies in southeast Florida, Florida Field Nat 25(3):85-91.
Zambrano, R., R., H. T. Smilh, and M. Robson. 2000. Summary of breeding roseate terns in the Florida Keys: 1974-
1998. Florida Field Nat. 28(2):64-68.
P e 15 43
PROJECT LOCATION MAP
:f "
\.
5
,
o
5
10
15 Miles
,
Yahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27, totalin9 approximately 28.7 acres.
YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE, NAPLES, FL
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th 5l.
Naple!!, FL 34120
239.5.....1660
N
W+E
PRO.JECT:
Figure 1. Project Location Map in Collier County;
Pa e16/43
FLUCCSIVEGETATION MAP; SURVEY ROUTES
It!5
0.7AC
!'AC
1JA18148
r.a AC
~E
S
~
~ ~ SURVEY ROUTE
ID. AC FLUCRrI
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
100
,
o
100 200 Feet
Figure 2. FLUCFC81 Vegetation Mep; 8urvey Routes.
Vahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28,7 acres.
Ramsey Inc.
EnvIronmental Consulting
2831 4th 8t. NW
NaPkl!. FL 34120
239.5_.1880
Pa e17/43
PRESERVE AREA MAP
PRESERVE AREA
PARCELID
#4 621
#5 624
#6 624/8146
#9 624
#11 821
1.57 AC
2.82 AC
0.24 AC
4.70 AC
2.40 AC
TOTAL
11.73 AC
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
N
w+.
Yahl MJllchinlLExpnslon Pa~el 2250 Wllshbltm AVfI.
Sec. 31, Twn'l9, Kge 27, totaling approXimately 2B.71ocres.
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples,FL 34120
239.56...1860
Figure 3. Preserve Area Map.
Page 18/43
LIST OF USFWS AND FWC PROTECTED SPECIES
FOR COLLIER CO., FL. AS OF 04/14/09
ICOIIIKI....A..II! .K.tII!NTInC MA"II! ...I...AnD DTATVS
- -
ro, ....
AMPRJllANS
JOPbedllll RIlNlCQpiID 55C(I,2)
IIllDS
Crp;:Sabk:sc:uioklpU'lll.... ,t-.lntm'd _rill''''~~ ",.robilis E E
F1orid1~1plI'fOW ,tllllllr'.HliallUlllll'OlWlQ'Il"'p.,ndtuud E E
FIoridol/;l\lhjay ApkhKomlJ n>t'llltKtM T T
'''''''" ,j'Il/IlUlliHl'lIl/1lll SSC{ll
Mh.... ntlliMllriD (,tIlMM
AoridlIbwrowiqll...J <1ItrK,n",jQ;jTonJw,,,) SSC(1l
i'^"Y-bllalWO<Jdpt:cm CfStflJUplliJwl'rVlCiplSll~ E
Cllbu./_1,lllYU ClHvll4ri",altMNI.;"U' T
piplalPhWtT CIuJ/fnMIUWIIliHhls T T
Kirlbncl'l~tr D."fI<lAA....~irrlDnt!ii E
lillkbloehtroa CI't"" C..M.. SSC(1.4)
RllldilhtJI'CI Elnlf/ln4uuns SSC(l,41
....,"'" E,W/fJUIIIW SSC(ll
lritelandhcrOCl EI"'/fJutce/o, SSC(I.41
'tJhUiblll E~"'lQlllbuf SK(2)
ptrqVjDe',bo" Fttk",.",rilllU E
SolnhcaltmAmqiQ/IkCilliCl FQkolf'/l,,'''IIi.pruJus T
FlorilD~llnant GIWCottadtaJ'I'",,.,,,1r T
Amaian ~ClI:4Icbt< 1l4l_optUpt>/Jllmu 55e(I,2)
......M M.rt1trill_ritllftll , E
l>>owIIpelican I't/H(nuuDC't"iJr"w!i. sse (I)
rM~~'lt1 1>iNtJdtlbtm'flllJ sse .
'_~"ilJ "u"1l1u~(A.)oirltIJ,*,/ 55C(1,4)
I't'J/tbo,,,,pI..,wuauJuboltii
e:J<<icd.arx.... (Cilnl<'u",cAt"..C)'j T T
E.~....i1-';le ~rftMrMsllK'klb/lilpl"",,,.UJ E E
blldlki"""!'r RplrilfJpl~I,.r sseOl
"",~ .!iltt....""'i/kt11f1rl T
S,..'"".w..,IIJ/JISt",".Joq/lIli/
,-- ~rJ1Il/1 T T
81<'........I..uiIl.~ V~""il'fl.Qkcl\m.:lnj' E
nsn
,nulllolld1....,r,lb I'mli'I',C1;/lfl'C E
"...Ju.r.(-.ro~rivu"') Ilil'~llfl_ml'''lIlul SSC(I)
MAMJIIALS
"'.... BlllultOpU-rQkrhl'lr E
til "ak (fallbtd...halt} BcfuN>J*'r/lpll)'JIl/Ii' . E
Eubol"lIl1,lodoll'I~Qlotml
NotdoA1'-6i:Jit.h.l,,'ll* ,ltmullt {lnrt...""./fsJl E E
FIorilllI-urbG [;u/'llopI,lll/fClrwrplIriddtt..s ,
~whal~ M.tfIP""il",,-.lillt E e
eaibtntl moot IGIlJ MaudUIJ.,."u-IIJI. .
~lIIifIk M""'rlcW6OA~"r.Ia4t,q1.< T
.....- I'hyulorMlJt'MtYpAa/n E
fk'mdlJlUllh<' I'U/Wll{F,JiI)Nlflt'O/M('1I'}' E ,
Bi.c,pm.sllll~ .kt~N:lKIf"1I.1ct/l"'Q T
Trldl<<llsu_IlfIIoU,,,"n..
f~CIIIIolliM"'..ait<l (TrJr1u(#;..-._Illf) , ,
F'klridlIblIld:beu UJJltJ_r/r""~'fioriIh~1lS T,
IlEI'QWI
........ricanliiilltOf /JJ"ol<lr",;ulmppl""rl~ SSC(lJl
-"""', Cotrmrro,..lIa T T
Jm:'ftltllt\-'k ClltitM...",ydoJ e E..AT.
A<IlCN:anf;'JQClIdiilc CtoMCl~<<u,.., E ,
Il'lllbtbdowunJc lHntIndv/yr."r/fScra e ,
Eu1m>UldIp -u. Dr;.M4l,dllillNlr/lI'COllptri T T
~....bbjllawllr\lt Ef1'lmorlI,I;pIir!h,;rllla , E
-""". OtJf'lwlfllpDIyplrnnJlr T
KtftlJI'lridlly""..1>Ilk: l.ipjdtKIttIYJ~'"1'11 , ,
""""""lUTES
MOLLUSKS
Rondl ll'c:c ,"iiI U,~u'falC'l<IllLl sse(l)
PLAN11l
(NONEi
Proiect: Y AHL MULCHING SDP A AR 7633
Figure 4. List of USFWS and FWC protected species for Collier Co., FL Ramsey Inc.
EnllironmcDlfll Conlldling
YahI Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave., 26314"SI,NW
Naples. FL ~4120
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.7 acres. 239,*,.1660
Page 19 , 43
PROTECTED SPECIES/WILDLIFE FIELD SURVEY SHEET
CUMLA TIVE TOTALS
APPENDIX C.
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
DATE:
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIlME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
Y AHL MULCHING
COLLIER
04112- 16/2009 ALL SURVEYS
AM & PM TOTAL COUNT
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0645 AM
2030 PM
0-15
63-80 F
NONE
0-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
GREAT EGRET
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MALLARD DUCK
MEADOW LARK
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus floridanu6)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
REPTILE
BLACK RATE SNAKE
TOTAL
COUNT
7
7
9
2
4
o
11
19
1
o
9
17
1
3
2
2
o
2
1
3
Project: Y AHL MULCHING: Sorine 2009
Figure 5. Cumulative totals for Protected Species / Wildlife Survey.
Daily field sheets in Appendix C.
Yahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.7 acres.
Ramsey Inc.
Envlronmemal Consulting
2631 41~ Sl. NW
Naples, FL 34120
239.564.1660
P 20/43
PANTHER TELEMETRY 1981.2008
Yahl Mulching ExPansion Parcel, 2250 W....bum Ave.,
Sec:. 31, Twn 'lg, Rge 27, totaling .pproxlmataly 28.8 .cres.
& RECYCLING INC
Ramsev Inc.
Envlronmandl Consulting
2831 4th St. NW
Narl..!. FL 34120
23 .5-.1680
+
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING
Figure 8. Panther telemetry 1981.2008;
P 21 4
PANTHER PRIMARY/SECONDARY
HABITAT MAP
400 0 400 800 Feet
,
SECONDARY.
HABITAT
PRIMARY
HABITAT
D
~
N
W*,
S
PRO.JECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
Figure 7. Panther PrImary/Secondary Habitat Map;
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
PO Box 1261
Immokal"!..FL 34143
239.564.1....0
Vahl MJlI!;.hinlLE!xD8nsllln Par..el 2250 W1l8hbltl1l Av..
Se... 31, TWn"'9, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.7I1er...
Pa 822/43
BEAR TELEMETRY 1983-2000
.
.
.
.
.
..
. .
. ,
..... -\ .
. a. ....
.'t · ..,.... ':-.
l "
.
PROJECT: FILLMORE I YAHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC. GMP AMENDMENT
+
Ramsev Inc.
Envlronmentil Consulting
2831 4th at. NW
Nepl~. FL 34120
239.5_.1880
Figure 8. Bleck B..r T.I.mBtry 1983-2000; source FL Fish & Wlldlllfe
Cons.."Btlon Comm.
Vahl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. Parcel, 2250 Washbum Ave.,
8ec. 31, Twn ..g, RlJe 27, '-otallng approxlmBtely 28.7 acres.
Pa 023/43
Black Bear Nusionace Locations 1980-2006
/'
.
PRO,JECT: FILLMORE I Y AHL MULCHING
& RECYCLING INC. GMP AMENDMENT
f'
V.hl Mulching & Recycling, Inc. P.rcel, 2250 Washbum Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn '49, Rg. 27, ~otelln8 .pproxl....t.ly 28.7 .c....
Ramsey Inc.
Envlronm.nta. Consulting
2831 4th St. NW
N!lple!.FL 34120
239.5.....1880
Figure 9. Bisek B_r Nuslonec. Locations 1980-2006.
Page 24/43
APPENDIX B
FLORIDA'S ENDANGERED SPECIES,
THREATENED SPECIES, AND SPECIES
OF SPECIAL CONCERN
May 2008
FLORIDA FISH AND WILDLIFE CONSERVATION COMMISSION
Page 25/ 43
APPENDIX B
CONTENTS
PREFACE.......................................................................................................................... ii
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA
AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN .... 1
OFFICIAL LISTS ...................................................................................................... I
FISH ................ ................ ........ ........ .......... ................ ................... .................................. 2
AMPHIBIANS...... ........ .............. .......... ..... .............. ........................ ... .............. ............. 2
REPTILES... ..... ............ .... ......... ............... .......... ...... ............ .... ........ ..... .... ............. ....... 2
BIRDS ...... ... ........ ......... ....... ...... ........ .... ........... ........ ... ...... .... ......................................... 3
MAMMALS................................................................................................................... 4
INVERTEBRATES........... ........ ................. .... ........... .......... ........... ..... ......................... 6
CORALS....................................................................................................................6
CRUSTACEANS....................................................................................................... 6
INSECTS ..... ..................... ...... .............. .... .......... ................. ........ ........ .......... ............ 6
MOLLUSKS ..............................................................................................................6
KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATIONS........................................................ 7
Page 26 I 43
APPENDIX B
PREFACE
This document consolidates the official state of Florida list of endangered species, threatened
species, and species of special concern. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission (FWC) maintains the state list of animals designated as endangered, threatened, or
species of special concern, in accordance with Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and 68A-27.00S,
respectively, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.), httos:/Iwww.flrules.onIDefaultasn. The
state lists of plants, which are designated endangered, threatened, and commercially exploited,
are administered and maintained by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer
Services (DOACS) via Chapter 5B-40, F.A.C. This list ofpJants can be obtained at
htto://wwwJI-dof.oomlforest manal!ementlnlant conserve lisLhtml. The federal agencies that
share the authority to list species as Endangered and Threatened are the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration-National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA-NMFS) and U. S. Fish
and Wildlife Service (USFWS). The NOAA-NMFS is responsible for listing most marine
species. The federal list of animals and plants is administered by the USFWS, and this list is
published in 50 CFR 17 (animals) and 50 CFR23 (plants). Additional infonnation regarding
federal listings can be located at the following websites;
NOAA-NMFS - httn:/Iwww.nmfil.noaa.l!OV and
USFWS - http://endllIll!ercd.fwuovlwildlife.html#Soecies.
Please note that while the FWC has published a consolidated list of state and federally listed
species in the past, we now only publish a list of species listed within the state of Florida. This
list will be maintained and available at our agency website: htlD:/Iwww.mvfwc.oom. Lists of
federally listed species can still be viewed at the USFWS and NOAA-NMFS websites mentioned
above. It is our intent by providing the list in this manner that we will be able to maintain a
current list that is more readily available to the public.
. Common and scientific names listed first are as tbey appear in the Florida Adminlstratiye Code, Title
68A. Common andlor scientiDe nam.. following tbis aDd located wltbln parentbes.. () contain names .s
used by USFWS, or other commonly used names.
Bradley J. Gruver, Ph. D
Listed Species Coordinator
Species Conservation Planning Section
Divisioo of Habitat and Species Conservation
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Cover Photos by FWC StatT: Key Largo Woodrat, Burrowing Owls, Okaloosa Darter, Schaus' swallowtail bunertly,
Sbort-tailed Snake.
11
Page 27 I 43
APPENDIX B
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE ST ATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED,
THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN
STATUS
DESIGNATION FISH AMPHmlANS REPTILES BIRDS MAMMALS INVERTEBRATES TOTAL
E 3 0 6 8 20 4 41
T 2 0 11 9 4 0 26
SSC 10 5 7 18 6 4 50
TOTAL 15 5 24 35 30 8 117
Page 28! 43
APPENDIX B
OFFICIAL LISTS
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
-,_._~
FISH
Atlantic sturgeon A cipenser oxyrinchus SSC(I)
(Gulfsturlleon) IAcinenser oxvrinchus desotoj)
shortnose sturgeon AciDenser brevirostrum E
shoal bass MicroD/erus ca/araelae sse (1,2)
Suwannee bass Microoterus notius sse (I)
rivulus Rivulus marmoratus SSe(l)
(mangrove rivulus)
Lake Eustis pupfish CVDrinodon varief!atus hubbsi sse (!)
blackmouth shiner No/roDis melanostomus E
bluenose shiner Pteronotroois welaka sse (1,2)
saltmarsh loOnllnnow Fundulus ienkinsi sse (I)
key silverside Menidia eonehorum T
crystal darter Crvstallaria aSDrella T
- sse (I)
harlequin darter E/heos/oma his/rio
okaloosa darter E/heos/oma okalossae E
Southern tesse-llated darter Etheos/oma olmstedi sse (1)
(tessellated iohnnv darter)~_ maculaticeDs
key blennv Starksia slarcki sse (I)
AMPHIBIANS
tlatwoods salamander Ambvstoma cinvulatum sse
Geonia blind salamander Haideotriton wallaeei sse (J 2)
pine barrens treefrol1. Hvla andersonii sse (I)
Florida bog frOg Rana okaloosae sse (2)
gopher frOg Rana caDito sse (J,2)
REPTILES
American alligator Alligator mississippiensis sse (1,3)
American crocodile Crocodvlus aculus E
key riD!!Ileck snake DiadoDhis Dunetatus acricus T
Eastern. indillo snake Drvmarchon corais couveri T
red rat snake Elaphe gutta/a sse] (J\
Atlantic salt marsh water snake Nerodia clarkii taenia/a T
(Atlantic salt marsh snake)
2
Page 29/43
Common Name
Scientific Name
AQPENDIX B
Florida pine snake Piluophis melanoleueus SSC (2)
mUJlitus
short -tailed snake Stilosoma extenuatum T
Florida brown snake Storeria dekay; vie/a TI
rim rock crowned snake Tantil/a oolitiea T
Florida ribbon snake Thamnophis sauritus saekeni T'
bluetail mole skink Eumeees eJlreJlius liyidus T
Florida Kev mole skink Eumeees eJl7'el!;US eRreRius SSC (J)
sand skink Neoseps revnoldsi T
gopher tortoise Gopherus polyphemus T
Barbour's map turtle Graptemvs barbouri SSC (! ,2)
alligator snapping turtle Maeroclemys temminekii SSC (I )
striped mud turtle Kinosternon baurii E'
Suwannee cooter Pseudemys eoncinna SSC (1,2)
suwanniens ;s
loggerhead seaturtle Caretta earetta T
(loltlterhead sea turtle)
green seaturtle Chelonia mydas E
(green sea turtle)
leatherback sea turtle Dermoehelys eoriaeea E
lleatherback sea turtle)
hawksbill seaturtle Ere/moehelys imbrieata E
(hawksbill sea turtle)
Kemp's ridley seaturtle Lepidochelys kempii E
(Kemp's ridlev sea turtle)
BIRDS
pipiDlz plover Charadrius melodus T
snowy plover Charadrius alexandrinus T
(Cuban snowy plover)
American ovstercatcher Haematopus palliatus ' sse (! ,2)
brown oelican Peleeanus oecidentalis SSC (J)
black skimmer Rynehops niRer sse (I)
least tem Sterna antil/arum T
roseate tem Sterna dougal/i T
(Sterna douJlaJ/ii douJla/liil
limpkin Aramus Jluarauna SSC (I )
reddish elrret El!retta rufeseens SSC (1,4)
snowy egret ERretta /hula sse (J)
little blue heron ERretta caerulea sse (1,4)
tricolored heron Ewetta tricolor sse (1,4)
3
Page 30 I 43
Common Name
Scientific Name
~PENDIX B
white ibis Eudocimus albus SSC (2)
Florida sandhill crane Grus canadensis pratensis T
whoooine crane Grus americana SSC (5)
~
wood stork Mvcteria americana E
roseate spoonbill Plalalea aiaia SSC (1,4)
burrowing ow I Athene cunicularia SSC (I)
(Florida burrowing owl) (Athene cuniculariafloridana)
crested caracara Caracara cheriway T
(Audubon's crested caracara) (Polvborus plancus audubonii)
perel!rlne falcon Falco /JereJ!rinus E
Southeastern American kestrel Falco s/Jarverius paulus T
osprey Pandion hallaetus SSC2 (I 2)
snail kite Rostrhamus sociabilis E
(Even!lades snail kite) plumbeus
Florida scrub jay Aphelocoma coerulescens T
Cape Sable seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus E
mirabilis
Florida grasshopper sparrow Ammodramus savannarum E
floridanus
Scott's seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus SSC(I)
peninsulae
Wakulla seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus SSC(I)
;uncicolus
white-crowned pigeon Columba leucocevhala T
Kirtland's warbler Dendroica kirtlandii E
Bachman's warbler Vermivora bachmanii E
ivory-billed woodpecker Campephilus principalls E
red-cockaded woodpecker Picoides borealis SSC
Marian's marsh wren Cistothorus Dalustris marianae SSC (J)
Worthington's marsh wren Cistothoros palustris wiseus SSC (J)
,
MAMMALS
Florida panther Puma con color coryi E
(Puma r~Fellsl concolorcorv'l
Florida black bear Ursus americanus floridanus TJ
Everglades mink Mustela vison everrdadensis T
key deer Odocoileus virginianus E
clavium
4
Page 31/43
APPENDIX 8
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
Lower Kevs marsh rabbit SvlvilailUs palustris hefneri E
Bill CY\lress fox squirrel Sciurus nil!er avicennia T
Shennan's fox squirrel Sciurus niJ!er shermani SSC II 2)
Eastern chiomunk Tamias striatus sse (J)
Sanibel Island rice rat Orvzomvs palustris sanibeli SSC 0,2)
silver rice rat Oryzomys argentatus E
(rice rat,lower FL Keys) (Qrvzomvs palustris nata/or)
Kev Larl!;o woodrat Neotoma {[oridOJla smalli E
Key Largo Cotton Mouse Peromyscus gossypinus E
al/avaticola
Choctawhatchee beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
al/ophrvs
~---~--
Southeastern beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus T
niveiventris
Anastasia Island beach mouse Peromyscus polionotlls E
phasma
St. Andrews beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
peninsularis
Perdido Key beach mouse Peromyscus polionotlls E
trissvl/epsis
Florida mouse Podomvs {[oridanus sse (J)
Florida mastiff bat ElImops J!laucinus floridanus E
l!rav bat Mvotis J!risescens E
Indiana bat Myotis sodalis E
Florida saltmarsh vole Microtus pennsylvanicus E
dukecampbelli
(Florida salt marsh vole)
Sherman's short-tailed shrew B/arina carolonensis SSC (2)
r =brevicauda 1 shermani
f[omosassa shrew Sorex lonJ!irostris eionis SSC (2)
sei whale Balaenovtera borealis E
fin whale Balaenoptera physalus E
(fmback whale)
North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena glacialis E
(right whale) (Balaena glacia/is (incl.
australis 1)
humDback whale MeJ!aPtera novaeanl!liae E
sperm whale Phvseter macroceohalus E
Florida manatee Trichechus manatus latirostris E
(West Indian manatee) (Trichechus manatus)
5
Page 32/43
Common Name
Scientific Name
ARPENDIX B
INVERTEBRATES
CORALS
nillar coral DendroJ!Vra cvlindrus E
CRUSTACEANS
Panama eity crayfish Procambarus econfinae sse (1)
(econfina crayfish)
sims sink crayfish Procambarus erythrops sse (1)
(Santa Fe cave cravfish)
black creek crayfish Procambarus victus sse (J)
INSECTS
Miami blue butterfly eyclargus [~Hermiargus] E
thomasi bethunebakeri
Schaus' swallowtail butterfly Heraclides aristodemus E
ponceanus
--
MOLLUSKS
Florida tree snail LiJlUUS fasciatus ssem
Stock Island tree snail Orthalicus reses E
Ortha/icus reses [not incl.
nesodrvas 1
6
Page 33/43
APPENDIX B
KEY TO ABBREVIA nONS AND NOT A nONS
List Abbreviations
FWC =
E=
T=
SSC=
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Endangered
Threatened
Species of Special Concern
Reasons for sse listings prior to January 1,2001 are indicated by the number in parenthesis under
the following criteria:
(I) has a significant vulnerability to habitat modification, environmental alteration, human
disturbance, or human exploitation which, in the foreseeable future, may result in its
becoming a threatened species unless appropriate protective or management techniques are
initiated or maintained;
(2) may already meet certain criteria for designation as a threatened species but for which
conclusive data are limited or lacking;
(3) may occupy such an unusually vital or essential ecological niche that should it decline
significantly in numbers or distribution other species would be adversely affected to a
significant degree;
(4) has not sufficiently recovered from past population depletion, and
(5) occurs as a population either intentionally introduced or being experimentally managed to
attain specific objectives, and the species of special concern prohibitions in Rule 68A-
27.002, FAC., shall not apply to species so designated, provided that the intentional killing,
attempting to kill, possession or sale of such species is prohibited.
List Notations
Lower keys population only.
2
Monroe County population only.
Other than those found in Baker and Columbia Counties or in Apalachicola National Forest.
7
Species listed in Florida based on published population data
Page I of 4
Page 34 143
APPENDIX B.
Species Reports
Environmental Conservation Online System
Species listed in Florida based on published population data
Notes:
. This report shows the species listed in this state according to the Federal Register listing description.
. This list does not include experimental populations and similarity of appearance listings.
. This list includes species or populations under the sole jurisdiction of the National Marine Fisheries
Service .
. Click on the highlighted scientific names below to view a Species Profile for each listing.
LIsted species (based on published population data) .. 114 listings
Animals - 59 listings
Slllli!I Species/Listing Name
T Bankclimber, purple (mussel) (EJI/moldeus sloallanus)
E Bat, gray (Ifrolls arlseSCens)
E Beetle, American burying (Nlcrophorus amer/canusl
E Butterfly, Schaus swallowtail (f/mrClldes sr/slodemus ponceenus)
T Caracara, Audubon's crested FL pop. (Polvborus o/sncus sudubonll)
T Coral, elkhorn (AcfODOl1l palmele)
T Coral, stag horn (Acroporll cerv/cornls)
T Crocodile, American FL pop. (Crocodylus eeU/us)
E Curlew, ~skimo (Numen/us borealle)
E Darter, Okaloosa (Elhaos/oms okelooses)
E Deer, key (Odoco//eus v/ra/nlanus clsv/um)
E Kite, Everglade snail FL pop. (Roslrhamus soc/abllls plumbeus)
E Manatee, West Indian (Tr/chachus menslus)
E Moccasinshell, Gun (Med/on/dus oanicl/Islus)
E Moccasinshell, Ochlockonee (Mad/on/dus slmpson/snwll)
E Mouse, Anastasia Island beach (Peromyscus DOI/onolus phss"",)
E Mouse, Choctawhatchee beach (Paromvscus ool/onotus el/oohtys)
E Mouse, Key Largo cotton (eM12!nvscus aossvolnus al/a08l1cola)
E Mouse, Perdido Key beach (peromyscus pol/onolus tr/ssvlleps/s)
T Mouse, southeastern beach (P.aromvscus ool/onotus n/ve/vanlris)
htlp://ecos. fws.gov /tess_public/pub/stateListinglndi vidual.j sp ?state=FL&status=listed
4/1412009
Species listed in Florida based on published population data
Page 2 of 4
Page 35/43
APPENDIX B.
10 Mouse, :;1. IInorew Peacn l"eromvscus oOl/ono/us DemnsU/anSI
E Panther, Florida (Puma (=FellsJ concolor COTV/)
E Pelican, brown except U.S. Atlantic coast, FL, AL (Pelecanus occldentalls)
E Pigtoe, oval (P/eurobema pyrlforme\
T Plover, piping except Great Lakes watershed (Charadriu~ melodusl
E Pocketbook, shinyrayed (Lamps/lis subanaulata)
E Rabbit, Lower Keys marsh (SylvilapU8 ps/U$tris helnerll
E Rice rallower FL Keys (Orvzomvs paJustris !lBtatlHl
T Salamander, frosted flatwoods (Ambvs/oma c/naulatum)
E Sawfish, smalltooth (Prlsffs pectlnslll)
T scrub-jay, Florida IAphe/oCDma coeruIeacena)
E Sea turtle, green FL, Mexico nesting pops. (Che/on/e mydas)
T Sea lurtle, green except where endangered (ChelonIa mvdas)
E Sea turtle, hawksbill (Eretmochelys Imbrica/a)
E Sea turtle, Kemp's ridley (Lep/dochelys /cemo/(J
E Sea turtle, leatherback (DemJoche/ys carlaCBS)
T Sea turtle, loggerhead (Caretta care"s)
E Seal, Caribbean monk (Monschus IrOD/calls\
T Shrimp, Squirrel Chimney Cave (PsJftmonetes cummlna(J
T Sklnk, bluetail mole (Eumeces egre'a/us Hv/dus\
T Skink, sand (~UJ!XI!!l!M!)
T Slabshell, Chipola (Ell(ptlo chlDolsenals)
T Snail, Stock Island tree (Orths/Icus reus {not /ncl. nesodfVllsJl
T Snake, Atlantic salt marsh (Neradls clarldl taen/SI.)
T Snake, eastern indigo (Dl}'msrchon corals cauDell)
E Sparrow, Cape Sable seaside (AmmodnJmua marit/mua m/rablll$)
E Sperrow, Florida grasshopper (Ammodramua S8vsnnBI'Um florldanusl
E Stork, wood AL, FL, GA, SC (Arvcteria americana)
T Sturgeon, gulf (Aelpenser oxyrinchus desoto(J
E Sturgeon, short nose (Ac/penser brevirMtrum)
T Tern, roseate Westem Hemisphere except NE U.S. (Sterna douaallll douaalll(J
E Three-ridge, fat (mussel) (Amblema nelsleri/)
E Vole, Florida sail marsh (MIcrotus oennavlvsn/cua dukecampbellil
E Whale, flnback (Balaenopters ohvsalua)
E Whale, humpback (Meaaotera novaeanptlae)
E Whale, right (Ba/uns alae/alia (Incl. australlal)
E Wolf, gray Lower 48 States, except where delisted and where EXPN. Mexico. (CanIs lupus\
E Woodpecker, red-cockaded (Pico/des borealla)
E Woodrat, Key Largo (~/oma florldans small/)
http://ecos.fws.gov/tess_pu blic/pub/stateListi nglndividual.j sp ?state=FL&sta tus=listed
4/1412009
Species listed in Florida based on published population data
Plants - 55 listings
Status Species/Listing Name
E Aster, Florida golden (ChlVse>pBis flofldana)
E Beargrass, Britton's (Nollns brlltonhma)
E Beauty, Harpefs {HafDe1OC8INs flaval
E Bellflower, Brooksville (Campllnula robIns_)
T Birds-in-a-nest, white (Macbrldea a/ba,)
E Blazingstar, scrub (LlaITls ohlln~
T Bonamia, Florida (Bonsmla orand/tlora)
T Buckwheat, scrub (Ertogonum lonattOllum tflIT. onaDhallfollum\
T Butterwort, Godfrey's (Pinou/cu/a Ionanlhal
E Cactus, Key tree {PUosocereus rob/nIfJ
E Campion, fringed (Sllene oolvDe/atal
E Chaffseed, American (Schwalbes amerlcans)
E Cladonia, Florida perlorate (C/adonla perlot:ata)
E Fringe-tree, pygmy (Chlonanlhus Dvamaeus)
T Gooseberry, Miccosukee (Rlbes echlnellWf/J
E Gourd, Okeechobee (Cucurbila oIceechobeensIs AlP, oIceechobeensls)
E Harebells, Avon Park (Croralana a\lO_la)
E Hypericum, highlands scrub (Hypericum cumullCDIa)
E Jacquemontia, beach (Jacauemonlia recIInaIa)
E Leadil1ant, Crenulate (AnIOIJlha Mlmlliara)
E Lupine, scrub ((uplnus aridorom)
E Meadowrue, Cooley's (ThBltctrum oooleyO
E Milkpea, Small's (Galac/Is amsJl1II
E Mint, Garrett's (Dlcerandra chris_Ii)
E Mint, Lakela's (DlcerandralmmsculBta)
E Mint, longspurred (Dlcerandra comu/Isslms)
E Mint, scrub (Dlcerand,. frolescens)
E Mustard, Cartefs (Walll/l carter!)
E Pawpaw, beautiful (Deerinoolhamnus pulchellua)
E Pawpaw, lour-petal (Aslmlna Ie/raffle,.)
E Pawpaw, Rugel's (Deerln!,o/hamnuB ruae/1Ii
T Pigeon wings (Clltoria f18Drans)
E Pinkroot, gentian (Soloella oenllanolde$)
E Plum, scrub (Prunua oenlculalB)
E Polygala, Lewton's (POIVOBla lew/anm
E Polygala, tiny (Polvoala smalll!)
E Pondberry {(Indara mellaaltolla)
Page 3 of 4
Page 36143
APPENDIX B.
http://ecos.fws.gov /tess_public/pub/stateListinglndi viduaLjsp ?state=FL&status=li sted
4/14/2009
Species listed in Florida based on published population data
Page 4 of 4
Page 37 143
APPENDIX B.
E Prickly-apple, fragrant (Cereus arioohorus var. fragrans)
E Rhododendron, Chapman (Fllr_ododandron cheDmBnlf)
E Rosemary, Apalachicola (Conradlna alabral
E Rosemary, Etonia (Conradlna atonia)
E Rosemary, short-leaved (Conradlna brevlfolla)
E Sandlace (Po/rgonet/a mvrlophvlla)
T Seagrass, Johnson's (Halophlla lohnsonif)
T Skullcap, Florida (Scutatlarm nor/dana)
E Snakeroot (ErvrnJlum cunalfolium)
E Spurge, deltoid (Chamaesyce deltoldeB ssp. deltoidell)
T Spurge, Garber's (Chamaesrce garberll
T Spurge, telephus (Euphorbia telephlaldes)
E Torreya, Florida (Torreva taKlfolla)
E Warea, wide-leaf (Wares amo/aKltolla)
E Water-willow, Cooley's (Justlcla coolavll
T Whrtlow-wort, papery (Paronvchla chattaceal
E Wireweed (Po/vaonf1i/a baslram/a)
E Ziziphus, Florida (Ziz/ohus celaoo
Last updated: May 14, 2009
ECOS Home I ConI8Ct Us
http://ecos.fws .gov /tess_public/pub/stateListi ngl ndi v idual.jsp ?slate=FL&status=listed
4/14/2009
Erological, Environmental, Hazardous Materials, Agricultural Land I A P PEN 0 I X A
CONSULTING & TRAINING Michael R. Ramsey
"..-~ .--.- =-=
CWB, CFEA, REPA
--- - - --
- ..
--~~-
.
CWB . Certified Wildlife Biologist
CFEA ~ Certified Florida Environmental Assessor
REPA - Registered Environmental Property Assessor
E-mail: nfnOI840@naples.neet
Phone: 941-564-1660,OfficelFax: 941-657- 2601
PO Box 1261, lmmokalee, FL 34143
PROTECTED SPECIES REPORT 2000
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCIDNG
DATE: 01lI5nOOl
BY: Michael R. Ramsey
Ramsey Inc.
Owner: Fillmore Yahl Mulching
County: Collier
City: Naples
Size: 28.8 acres
Legal Descriptions: PID 00341920409
2250 Washbum Ave; the SW 'A or the SW 'A
Section3l; Township 49. Range 27
INTRODUCTION
Tbe applicant Yahl Mulching has applied to the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) and US Army
Corps of Engineers (USACOE) to expand its existing operation of mulching and recycling of vegetative material in
Collier Co. (Figure 1). The following protected species repon was done to meet the submission requirements for each
agency. This report evaluates if the above described project property is utilized by any protected species listed by the
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS).
METHODS
Information concerning locations, densities, status, listings and changes from the Florida Fish & Wildlfie Conservation
Commission (FWC) and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) were reviewed along with other related publications.
Last, on site surveys or investigations wert conducted on the proposed project site.
On site surveys were conducted OClober ]4 through December 30, 2000, Surveys were conducted in the early morning
hours or in the late afternoon.
RESULTS
Plants
Beautiful oawoaw. This species was not observed on the site. This low shrub species is usually found in association with
pine flatwoods. However, its distribution is limited to those areas in western Lee Co. The proposed development should
have little or DO impact on this species.
Small's milkDea. This species was not observed on the sileo Wunderlin (1996, 1998) listed this species as being in
Collier Co, The habital requirements of solution holes in limerock would favor conditions in lower southeast Collier Co..
closer to Dade Co. The proposed project should have little \0 no impact on this species.
Animals
American Al1i~ator. Alligators (Alliutor mississiDDiensis) were not observed on the site. This species prefers open
water year round. which does not ex'ist on the site. The proposed project should have liule to no impact on this species.
Eastern IndiRO Snake. No evidence of the Eastern indigo snake (Drvrnarchon ~ couoen) was observed on the site.
Habitat requirements for these species are not well known, but generally prefer high., dry we]] drained soils. In addition
prey base species were limited. The pTOpOSed activity should have little or no impact on this species.
GaDher Tonoise. No sightings or burrows of this species were observed on site The proposed project should have little
or no impacl on this species.
Protected Species Survey
YahlProject
OlIlSnOOJ
APPENDIX A
2
Florida eanther. This species was not observed on the site or detected by indices. Ie addition FL Fish & Wildlife
Conservation Commission panther telemetry records since 1981 has never recorded a panther using this sileo The
proposed project should have little to no effect on this species.
Bil:! Cvnress fox SQuirrel. During surveys no fox squirrels (Sciurus niger avicennia) were observed. The proposed
project should have little to no effect on this species.
Arctic Peremne Falcon. This species was not observed on the area. In 1998 it was reconunended by the USFWS to
delist this species, due to its population numbers increasing. Since this species' breeding habitat is in the Northern US
and Canada and winters in the southern US and South America, it is a seasonal migrant to Florida. ]n addition to being a
seasonal migrant, it is more likely to utilize coastal areas. The proposed project should bave little to no effect on this
species.
Bachman's Warbler. No evidence of this species was noted on the area. In addition, no sightings of this species has been
recorded since 1977 and is thought to be extinct. The proposed project should have little or no effect on this species.
Bald Eule. No evidence of this species was noted 8S to its presence on the area and no documented evidence indicates
any nesting activity. The prnposed activities should have linle or no effect on this species.
Crested Caracara. No indications of this species were noted as to existence or utilization on the project site. This species
is more dependent on open areas like wet prairies and pastures with scattered saba! palm trees. This type habitat does
not exist on the area. The proposed project should have little to no effecl on this species.
Even:1ades Mink. This species was Dot observed or detected on the area. The preferred habitat of marsh and open water
areas do not exist on lhe project because of the hydroperiod alteratinn to the wetland. The proposed development should
have little to no effect on this species.
Florida Black Bear. No black bears were observed. nnr indices delected on the area. Although suitable habitat exist, it
is not large enough 10 support an individual bear. Surrounding human residential activity also deters any bear utilization.
The proposed development should have little to no impacts on this species.
F1nrida Burrowin. Owl. This species was not observed on the area. The preferred habit.t of this species also does not
exist on the site. The proposed development should have little to no effect on this species.
Florida GrasshoDoer SnarTOw. This species was not observed on the sile during surveys. Available records indicate that
this species is more likely to occur north of this area, from northern Hendry Co. into south central Florida. In addition,
this species is more likely to utilize an area of stunted saw palmetto with sparse grasses in between clumps. This type
habitat does not exist on the site. The proposed project should have little to no effect on this species.
Florida Sandhill Crane. This species was not seen on the during the surveys. However, areas typically used are wetland
marshes, prairies and pasture areas. This habit8f type exist on the property. The proposed project should bave little to no
effect on lhis species.
Florida Scrub Jav, No indication ofmis species presence was noted during surveys. In addition. the scrub oak habitat
required fnr this species, does not exist on the area. The proposed project should have little to no impact nn this species.
~. This species, nor indications of this species were observed on the area. The preferred habitat for this species
has abundant emergent and submergent vegetation with adequate Pomacea oaludosa. No pomacea paludosa remains
were observed while on the area. Creation of detention areas has been observed tn help provide better quality nesting and
feeding babitat for this species. Little or not effects are expected for this species from the proposed development, and
may benefit from detention area constrUction..
Little blue and tri-colored heron. These two herons were not observed on or utilizing the area. The altered hydroperiad
of the onsite wetland does not allow water to stand for very long in the wetland. The property does have a borrow pit on
the area with standing water, but it is too deep for a preferred feeding area. The proposed project should have little to no
effect on this species.
Protected Species Survey
YaM Project
OJIll1200J
APPENDIX A
3
~. Although the osprey is listed as a species of special concern by the FWC it is applicable only to Monroe County.
The proposed development should have little to no effect on this species.
Red-cockaded woodoeckers. No evidence of th],s species was noted on the site. No birds were seen or heard on the area,
and no evidence of nest tree..~ was observed. Some of the areas in the pine tracts did appear to be appropriate for feeding
areas, but no individuals were observed or heard while on site. The proposed project should have little to no impact on
this species.
Round.Ta;led Muskrat. This species was not ohserved or detected on the area. The preferred hahitat of dense stands of
pickerel weed (Pontederia cordata) and maidcncane (panicum hemitomon) do not exist on tbe area and no marsh habitat
exists. The planned development should have little to no impact on this species.
Shennan's Fox SQuirrel. This species was not observed, nor were any indications noted on the area, This species is more
typically found from the mid panhandle to Tampa to Lake Okeechohee. The preferred habitat for this species is very dry
pine-oak stands, which do not exist on the area. The proposed g development shoukl have little to no effect on this
species.
Snail Kite.. This species was not observed on the area. Pomacea naludosa also was not observed while on the area. Also,
preferred habitat of sloughs and flats vegetated by sawgnss rQadium iamaiccme) and spikerushes with scaltered shrubs
and tree islands do not exist on the area. The proposed development should have little to no effect on this species.
Snowv Eeret. This species was not observed on the area. Since standing water is not available on the property, Snowy
egrets have nn place to feed. The proposed project should have little to no impacts on this species. The propeny does
have a borrow pit OD the area with standing water, but it is too deep for a preferred feeding area. The restoration of a
hydroperiod to the wetland area will provide more suitable feeding habitat.
Southeastern Kestrel. This species was Dot observed on the area. Preferred habitat for Southeastern Kestrels {Falco
soarverius ~ requires the presence of snags and mature pine forests La provide nesting areas. These specific types
of habitat association was not observed on the area. The proposed project should have little to no impact on this species.
West. Indian Manatee. This species was not observed on the area, nor does suitable habitat exist. The proposed
development should have little or no effect on this species
Wood stork.. Wood storks were not observed flying over or utilizing the site. The property does not currently support
any areas of s\8.nding shallow water that Wood storks prefer for feeding. The property does have a borrow pit on the area
with standing water, but it is too deep for a preferred feeding area. The proposed project should have little to nO impact
on this species.
CONCLUSIONS
The proposed project water management structures should have little to no effect on listed species. If the applicant is
allowed to construct dikes and impound the wetland area multiple benefllS are possible. Habitat Utililed by wading bird
species would be created. A hydroperiod more conducive to normal wetland functions and plant associations would be
created
PrOlected Species Survey
Yahl Project
01llSnOOl
APPENDIX A
4
REFERENCES
Brown, L.N. 1978. Mangrovefoxsquirrel. Pages 5.6, in Rare and Endangered Biota of Florida: Vol. I, Mammals.
IN. Layne, ed. University Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Conner, R.N. and BA Locke. 1982. Fungi and red-cockaded woodpecker cavity treeS. Wilson Bull. 94:64-70.
Cox, I., D. Inkley, and R. Kautz. 1987.Ecology and habitat protection needs of gopher tortoise (GonheNs nolVDhemus)
populations found on lands slated for large.scale development in Florida. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Commission, Nongame Wildlife Program Technical Report No.4. Tallahassee, FL. 75pp.
Duever, M.l., J.E. Carlson, J.P. Meeder, L.C. Duever, L.H. Gunderson, LA Riopelle, T.R. Alexander, R.F. Myers and
D.P. Spangler. 1986. The Big Cypress National Preserve. National Audubon Society Research Report No.8,
National Audubon Society, New York, NY. 444.pp.
Fitzpatric, JW., G.E. Woolfenden and M.T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related babitat requirements of
the Florida scrub jay (Aohelocoma coerulescens coerulesceDs). Florida Game and Presh Water Fish
Commission, Nongame Wildlife Program Technical Report No.8. Tallahassee, FL. 49 pp.
Hooper, R.G., A.F. Robinson, Jr., and JA Jackson. 1980. The red-cockaded woodpecker: notes on life history and
management. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Atlanta, GA 8pp.
Jackson, JA 1977. Red-cockaded woodpeckers and pine red heart disease. Auk. 94:160-163.
Jackson, J .A. 1977. Determination of the slatus of red-cockaded woodpecker colonies. J. Wild!. manage. 41 :448-452.
Johnson, K.G., D. Lane!, ane! MA Lou. 1996. Annual Performance Report: Plorida Panlher Genetic Restoration and
Management. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission. Tallahassee, FL.
Johnson, K.G., D. Land, and MA Lotz. 1997. Annual Performance Report: Florida Panlher Genetic Resloration and
Management. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission. Tallahassee, FL.
Henry, V.G. 1989. Guidelines for Preparation of Biological Assessments and Evaluations for the Red-Cockadee!
Wooe!pecker. US Fish & Wile!life Service. 13pp.
Hillestad, H.O., R.W. Whitesie!e, J J. Mayer, J.T. Vermont, J.R. Fue!ge, IV, AW. Conger, and B.L Carter. 1989.
Wildlife Assessment for Citrus Grove Conversion. Final Report. South Florida Water Management District.
West Palm Beach, FL.
Hoffman, Mark L.; Collopy, Michael W. 1988. Historical status of Ihe American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) in
Florida. Wilson Bulletin. 100(1): 91.107.
Howell, Arthur H. 1932. Florie!a bire!life. Tallahassee, FL: Florie!a Department of Game and Fresh Water Fish. 579 p.
Kale, HW. n. 1978. Rare ane! Ene!angered Biota of Plorida. Vol. 2. Birds. University Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Land. D. 1994. Southwest Florida Black Bear Habitat Use. Distribution Movements. and Conservation Strategy. Final
Report. Florie!a Game ane! Freshwater Fish Commission. Tallahassee, Florie!a.
Land, D., and S.K. Taylor. 1998. Annual Report: Florida Panther Genetic Restoration and Management. Florida Game
and Fresh Water Fish Conunission. Tallahassee, FL.
Lane!, D., D. Shine!le, D. Singler. ane! S.K. Tayior. 1999. Annual Report: Florida Panlher Genetic Restoration and
Management, Stue!y No.7508. Florie!a Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission. Tallahassee, FL.
Liudahl, K., DJ. Belz. L.Carey, RW. Drew, S. Fisher, ane! R. Pate. 1998. Soil Survey of Collier County, Florie!a.
Natural Resource Conservation Service, U.S. Dept. of Agriculture. 152 pp.
Protected Species Survey
Y ahl Projtct
OJ/llnOOI
APPENDIX A
5
Mazzotti, FJ., LA Brandt, LG. Pearlstine, W.M. Kitchens, T.A. Obreza, F.C. Depkin, N.E. Morris, and C.E. Arnold.
1992. An evaluation of the regional effects of new citrus development on the ecological integrity of wildlife
resources in southwest Florida, Final Report. South Florida Water Management District. West Palm Beach. FL
188 pp.
Stevenson, H.M. 1978. Bachman's warbler. pp.13-14. In Rare and endangered biota of Florida: Vol. 2, Birds. HW.
Kale II. ed. University Presses of Florida. Gainesville.
Thompson, R. L and W. W. Baker. 1971. A survey of red-cockaded woodpecker nesting habitat requirements. Pp 170-
186. Ecol. and mgmL red.cockaded woodpecker (R.L. Thompson, ed.), Bur. of Sport Fish. and Wild1. and Tall
Timbers Res. Srn., Tallahassee.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1998. Multi-species recovery plan for the threatened and endangered species of South
Florida, Volume 1 of 2, The Ecosystem. TechnicallAgency Draft; Atlanta, GeuIEia.
u.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1995. Second Revision Florida panther (Felis concolor ~ recovery plan. Prepared by
the Florida Panther Interagency Comminee for the USFWS, Atlanta, Georgia 75 pp.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1986. Florida Panther (Felis concolor coryl) Recovery Plan. Prepared by- the Florida
Panther interagency Committee for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Atlanta, GA 88 pp.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1986. Florida Snail Kite (Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus. Ridgeway) Revised Recovery
Plan. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Atlanta, Georgia. 48 pp.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1986. Recovery plan for 'the U.S. breeding population ofthe wood stork. U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, Atlanta. GA 28 pp.
U.s. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1985. Red.cockaded woodpecker recovery plan. U.s.Fish and Wildlife Service,
Atlanta, GA. 88 pp.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1982. Eastern indigo snake recovery plan. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Atlanta, GA.
23 pp.
Wunderlin, R, P. 1998, Guide 10 the Vascular Planu of Florida. University Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Wunderlin, R.P. B.F. Hansen. and E.L. Bridges. 1996. Atlas of Florida Vascular Plants. Florida Depl. of State.
Tallabassee. 34143
APPENDIX A
,..,....:.....'..'......:.:
;~i;.;.,:...:..i:;i;.......
"
"
.
II
,'!!......
:cn
--.ir'
:-.-1".
:
i 1....
.. ---
::. u -
a
~
_ _ 1.
--
"
.' ,.;~:.r.~:;: .=#~'i:-:.~:'~
'"
l'~".
..1,.
";,
"
WtE 31 I:
c.II.,tt, tl
~ TIW :
(\
.
[.IMIpIir;
-
-
I"
.::::i::::'T11
t -\"1 It
:':::1
::51
:-wJNG SOUTH
~"'--. AIRPARK
R.tt~~~ f'~T$' )
.......... ~::;~
-.-
--~
--
~n Dr."
11
"
11
"
..
--~
;.:U=:
---
.--.-
-~-
::;"-:)t:-
--'"--
----
~--
-"'--
;
....~ ii:: .~.~~.:~.~.:::l~~~~~ '
11 n ':::.:'
~.
;.::
-
If
H
"
-
--
:::. ,
,
....
= ;:::
-h-- -:.21
-~=
_ -"- -
-.
-.:
I' ,I
II
""
",'" .
Figure 1. Location map or the Yabl Project in the SW 1/4 or Section 31,
Township 49, Range 27; Collier Co.
FLUCFCS CODE
'"
'"
624n43
621
62'
6241B146
62.
,J<
'"
624/142
'21
B145
B145
o 150
,
300
600
Attachment G - Appendix A
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
FLUCFCS Map (Aerial Flown Date. Jan 2008)
N
A
DESCRIPTION
Sin Ie Famil Residential
TimberPlocessin
PinelC 'ess/PalmIS o;iPiles
C 'ess
PinelC ress/Palm
Pine / C less 1 Palm 11m acled BRoad Clea'in
PinelC esslPalm
Haldwood Coniler
Pine/C ,ess/Palm
Pine / C ,ess / Palm .11m cled B Barlow Pil ExcavatiOl'l
Crass
G,aded IO'ained Roao
Graded J D'aineCl Road
TOT At ACRES
ACRES
"
2'
05
1.'
'.0
08
"
02
..,
2'
'A
0.5
0.7
28.8
RWA. I"", rlro.ides Ihi~ data fo' your p~monal u~e "as'" ThIS
in<ormalion '" de6.ed f'om mullip'~ sources which may. In pa1. nol
bccurrenl,and beOuISlde\heoonlololRWA, Inc. lhe~reas
depir.llld by Ihis ma~ i1'€ i1~pro,imate, and a,e ~o' rrecessar'ly
acturaletowrvey'n!lo'engi~eerirl9slao<iards. RWA,lnc assumes
""1"g.aI.reSpO'1.,t>;;"ytorlhe,~lorrnaho~oonlai'ledo"'h',_p
900
'Feet
D'lTA'"
CONSULTING
~....., ,.L....
.Planning'\li>oaliZlllio"
. C,.il En~inetrin~ . Sor..y'n~ &. M.,>ping
Pnnt"'g Date Apn110, 200B
File: TlProjecls\2008\080073.0000
Yahl~MLJlching_ GMPA\FLUCCS,mxd
8145
#13
APPENDIX A
HABITAT LEGEND
Acres FLUCCS Code Type
UP1.AJID HABITAT TYPES
...!! '" .R~._,~'n
3.3 152 TIMBER PROCESSING
12.2 419 OTHER 'PllfE
0.3 _ 434 . HARDWOOD COI'/lFER NlX&t
3.3 ~ 742 BORROW AR.EA
0.5 ~ 743 SPOIL AREA
1.0 IIIIlJ] 8145 GRAnitO AllD DRAJIIED ROA:
0.9 _ 8146 WOODS ROAD
24.1 ToTAL UPLAJlD HABITAT
nTLAIlD HABITAT TYPES
3.9 E:ZJ 621 CYPR&88
3.9 TOTAL WETLAllD HABITAT
~ 28.0 TOTAL PROJECT ACREAGE
Figure 3. CONTINUED; Habitat map for the Yahl project.
APPENDIX A
Figure 4. Soils map ofYahl Project in Comer Co. Source: US Dept.
of Agriculture, 1990, Soll Survey oreamer Co.
APPENDIX A
~
~
~
f!1
$
~
~
~
(IJ
!3
o
(H)
HOLOPAW
#
~
~O...~
~O ~T
Figure 4. CONTINUED; Soils map for the Yahl project.
.~
I II ti
i I
----
.t.
0000000
I I DrDDDD
I I
I I I
. P i
PI I
.
I I I I
Iii i
. I I 11111111111111111111111
-----
.1"11111111111111111111
I
I
Ii
I
p
I
I
~
If
I
YAK. IU..CIta ClCIII:IIJIl:IW \IE"
t UK......... JIG IEIO'IQ.IrQ II:.
- COIIlll1OIW.. lIfE I'I.DT PLAN
D.4Y1l1SON 8N/1/NIIlII1lfc, INC. -
CTVZL BN~ --
..~al__&_..... -
-..,....... -....... ' ;..
APPENDIX A
,
.
.
~*2
~
II
I
I
I
,
I
I
'1
'8
I
,
I
in
,
I
,
I
I ~
I.
I! .
I
.
I
I
I~
;II I'I'IIII~I ~
I III Ill' Ii
" ~ c; F ~ F
I . I I I
Figure 5. Yahl Mulching & Recycling Site Plan for expansion CUP 2000 22
Prot.ected Species Survey
Yahl projecl
OllJSnOOI
APPENDIX A
4
REFERENCES
Brown, L.N. 1978. Mangrove fox squirrel. Pages 5-6, in Rare and Endangered Biota of Florida: Vol. 1, Mammals.
IN. Layne, ed. University Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Conner, R.N. and B.A. Locke. 1982. Fungi and red-cockaded woodpecker cavity trees. Wilson Bull. 94:64-70.
Cox. 1., D. Inkley, and R. KaUll. 1987.Ecology and habitat protection needs of gopher tortoi,e (Gooherus Dolvohemu,)
populations found on lands slated for large.scale development in Florida. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Commi,sion, Nongame Wildlife Program Technical Report No.4. Tallahassee, FL. 75pp.
Duever, M.l.,1.E. Carlson, J.F. Meeder, L.C. Duever, L.1l. Gunderson, L.A. Riopelle, T.R. Alexander, R.F. Myers and
D.P. Spangler. 1986 The Big Cypress National Preserve. National Audubon Society Research Report No.8,
National Audubon Society, New York, NY. 444.pp.
FilIpatric, JW.. G.E Woolfenden and M.T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related habitat requirements of
the Florida scrub jay (Aohelocoma coerulescens coerulescens). Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Commission, Nongame Wildlife Program Technical Report No.8. Tallahassee, FL. 49 pp.
Hooper, R.G., A.F. Robinson, Jr., and LA. Jackson. 1980. The red-cockaded woodpeck.er: notes on life history and
management. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Atlanta, GA 8pp.
Jackson, JA 1977. Red-cockaded woodpeckers and pine red hean disease. Auk. 94: 160.163.
Jackson, J A 1977 Determination of the status of red-cockaded woodpecker colonies. 1. Wildl. manage. 41 :448-452
Johnson. K.G.. D. Land, and M.A. Lotz. 1996. AnnualPenonnance Report: Florida Panther Genetic Restoration and
Management. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission Tallahass~, FL.
lohnson, KG., D. Land, and M.A. Lotz. 1997. Annual Performance Report: Florida Panther Genetic Restoration and
Management. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission. Tallahassee, FL
Henry, V.G. 1989. Guidelines for Preparation of Biological Assessments and Evaluations for the Red-Cockaded
Woodpecker. US Fisli & Wildlife Service. \3pp.
HilleSlad, B.O., R.W. Whiteside, J.l. Mayer, J.T. Vennont, J.R. Fudge, IV, AW. Conger. and B.LCarter 1989.
Wildlife Assessment for Citrus Grove Conversion. Final Report. South Florida Water Management District.
West Palm Beach, FL.
Hoffman. Mark L.; Collopy, Michael W. 1988. Historical statuS of the American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) in
Florida. Wilson Bulletin. 100(1): 91-107.
Howell, Arthur H. 1932. Florida bird life. Tallahassee, FL: Florida Department of Game and Fresh Water Fish. 579 p.
Kale, H.W. II 1978. Rare and Endangered Biou of Florida. Vol. 2. Birds. University Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Land, D. 1994. Southwest Florida Black Bear Habitat Use, Distribution Movements, and Conservation Strategy. Final
Report. Florida Game and Freshwater Fish Commission. Tallahassee, Florida.
Land, D., and S.K. Taylor. 1998. Annual Report: Florida Panther Genetic Restoration and Management. Florida Game
and Fresh Water Fish Corrunission. Tallahassee, FL.
Land, D., D. Shindle, D. Singler, and S.K. Taylor. 1999. Annual Report: Florida Panther Genetic Restoration and
Management, Study No.7508. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Conunission. Tallahassee, FL.
Liudahl. K., DJ. Belz, LCarey, RW. Drew. S. Fisher, and R Pate. 1998. Soil Survey of Collier County. Florida.
Natural Resource Conservation Service, U.S. Depl. of Agriculture, 152 pp.
Protected Species Survey
Yahl Project
OlIlSnOOI
APPENDIX A
2
Florida canther. This species was not observed on the site or detected by indices. In addition FL Fish & Wildlife
Conservation Commission panther telemetry records since 1981 has never recorded a panther using this site, The
proposed project should have little to no effect on this species.
Bil:! Cvnress fox sQuirreL During surveys no fox squirrels (Sciwus niger avicennia) were observed. The proposed
project should have little to no effect on this species.
Arctic Perel!rint. Falcon. This species was nol observed on the area. In 1998 it was reconunended by the USFWS to
delist this species, due to its population numbers increasing. Since this species' breeding habitat is in the Northern US
and Canada and winters in the southern US and South America, it is a seasonal migrant to Florida. In addition to being a
seasonal migrant, it is more likely to utilize coastal areas. The proposed project should bave little to no effect on this
species.
Bachman's Warbler. No evidence of this species was noted on the area. In addition, no sightings of this species has been
recorded since 1977 and is thougbtto be extincl. The proposed project should have little or no effect on this species.
Bald Eule. No evidence of this species was noted as to its presence on the area and no documented evidence indicates
any nesting a,clivil)'. The proposed activities should have linle or no effect on this species.
Crested Caracara. No indications of this species were noted as to existence or utiliz.ation on the project site. This species
is more dependent on open areas like wet prairies and pastures with scattered saba! palm trees. This type habitat does
not exist on the area. The proposed project should have little to no effect on this species.
Evenlades Mink, This species was not observed or detected on the area. The preferred habitat of marsh and open water
artas do not. exist on the project because of the hydroperiod alteration to the wetland. The proposed development should
have little to nO effect on this species.
Florida Black Bear. No black bears were observed, nor indices detected on the area. Although suitable habitat exisl, it
is not large enough to support an Individual bear. Surrounding human residential activity also deters any bear utilization.
The proposed development should have little to no impacts on tms species.
Florida Burrowin. Owl. This species was not observed on the area. The preferred habitat of this species also does not
exist on the site. The proposed development should have little to no effect on this species.
Florida GrasshoDDer Soarrow. This species was nO( observed on the site during surveys. Available records indicate that
this species is more likely to occur north of this area, from northern Hendry Co. into south central Florida. In addition,
this species is more likely to utilize an area of stunted saw palmetto with sparse grasses in between clumps. This type
habitat does not exist on the site. The proposed project should have little to no effect on this species.
Florida Sandhill Crane. This species was not seen on the during the surveys. However, areas typically used are wetland
marshes, prairies and pasture areas, This habitat type exist on the propeny. The proposed project should have little to no
effect on this species.
Florida Scrub Jav. No indication afthis species presence was noted during surveys. In addition, the scrub oak habitat
required for this species, does not exist on the area. The proposed project should have little to no impact on this species
LimDkin. This species, nor indications of this species were observed on the area. The preferred habitat for this species
has abundant emergent and submergent vegetation with adequate Pomacea Daludosa. No Pomacea paludosa remains
were observed while on the area. Creation of detention areas has been observed to help provide better quality nesting and
feeding habitat for this species. Little or not effects are expected for lhis species from the proposed development, and
may benefit from detention area construction..
Little blue and tri.colored heron. These two herons were not observed on or utilizing the area. The altered hydroperiod
of the onsite wetland does not aHow water to stand for very long in the wetland. The property does have a borrow pit on
the area with standing water, but it is too deep for a preferred feeding area. The proposed project should have little to no
effecl on this species.
CONSULTING
E<ological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Managemer A P PEN 0 I X B
Ram. Inc. .
;:s.;; - - -
."..-......~~-........-:_.
.
CWB - Cer1ified Wiidlife Biologist
CFEA - Certified Florida Enviromnentol Assessor
REP A - Registered Enviromnental Property Assessor
DATE: 12.29.06
BY: Michael R. Ramsey
Ramsey Inc.
INTRODUCTION
E-mail: Ramsey.Inc@car1hIink.net
Phone: 239.564.166O,OfliceIFax: 866334.1496
2631 4 rn Street, N""I.., FL 34120
PROTECTED SPECIES REPORT
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING
Owner: Fillmore LLC (Yahl Mulching)
County: Collier
City: Naples
Size: 28.8 acres
Legal Descriptions: PID 00341920409
2250 Washburn Ave; the SW Yo or the SW Yo
Section 31; Township 49, Range 27
The applicant Yahl Mulching has applied to the Collier Co. Govemment, the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD)
and US Army Corps of Engineers (USACOE) to expand its existing operation of mulching and recycling of vegetative material in
Collier Co. (Figure 1). The following protected species report was done to meet the submission requirements for each agency.
This report evaluates if the above described project property is utilized by any protected Species listed by the Florida
Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). A protected species
evaluation for this property was conducted in 2000 this report is a updated follow up on that report.
METIlODS
First, the project properties were surveyed and a map prepared of the habitat types on site. Second, Ibe official lists of
protected species were obtained from each of the agencies (FWC & FWS). The FWC list all species classified as
protected by the state of Florida government The FWS list all species tllat are classifIed as protected in tlle stale of
Florida by the United States government TIrird, each species on each list was researched as to county of occurrence and
required habitat in the literature. Last, all species that were indicated as being fouod in Collier Co. and having a habitat
type that occurred on the project properties were searched for by surveys on the project properties.
RESULTS
Survev Dates. This property was initially evaluated for the presence of protected species in 2000. Collier Co. Government
Natural Resources Division concluded there was no issue with protected species on this site and issued approval to move
ahead with a site development plan. The area was resurveyed in 2006 for the presence of protected species. The project
properties were visited for surveys on: October 14 - December 30 in the year 2000; and resurveyed on the dates: 09/15,
09/23,09/30,10/05, 10112, 11/05, 11126, 12/09 snd 12/17 in 2006.
Habitat The Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS) was utilized to produce the habitat
maps for the project properties. The habitat or FLUCFCS maps are depicted in Figure 2 for the Yahl Mulching project.
Table I below indicates the acres for each habitat type.
Table I. FLUCFCS acres fOT the Yahl Mulching and Recycling property.
10# Acres FLUCCS #I
1
2
3
<
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Hlbital Tvoe
2.6
3.2
0.5
1.6
7.0
0.8
1.1
OJ
<.7
3.<
2.<
0.5
0.7
111 Singel Family Residence
152 Timber Processing
624/743 PinelCypresslPalmlspoil piles
621 Cypress
624 PinelCypressIPalm
624/8146 Pine/CypressIPalm impacted by road clearing
624 Pinc/CypressIPalm
434 Hardword Conifer
624 PinelCypressIPalm
624/742 PinelCypresslPalm impacted by borrow pitexcav81ion
621 Cypress
8145 GnldedlDrained Road
8145 GradcdlDrained Road
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Pase 2
APPENDIX B
The Yahl property has been impacted by road construction on the north, south and west sides of the property. This
construction bas effectively cut off sheet flow across the property, except for unusually high rainfall events. Impacted
hydrology appears to be the cause of the pine trees being present with present in cypress transition areas in the 624
habitats. It is also the reason for the heavy melaleuca infestation in the 624 areas to be preserved. This area has been
slowly drying out over time. In the site development plan the applicant will be impacting 6.37 acres of wetlands at the
northwest comer of the property (adjacent to the road, Figure 4) and preserve approximately 11.73 acres to the south of
the operatioos area that will be rehydrated and enhanced (Figure 4). Rehydration is anticipated to greatly improve the
vegetative conditions and make it more attractive to wetland wildlife.
State/Federal Protected Soecies Listed. The FWC lists was published in June 2006 and lists 118 animals as protected
in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix A Based on general habitat requirements, historic distributions and
actual sightings, the FWC lists 50 animal species that may occur in Collier County, 49 species are vertebrates, I is an
invertebrate. The 50 species are listed in Figure 3.
The FWS list is updated daily on their website. The August 2006 lists III animal and plant species as protected in the
State of Florida and is attached as Appendix B. Based on general habitat requirements, historic distributions and actual
sightings, the FWS lists 24 species (23 animals and 1 plant) that may occur in Collier County. Species are listed in
Figure 3 also.
Species Results
Gopher Frog/Rana capito: Prefers dry sandy, upland habitats adjacent to wetland areas. This type habitat is oot present
onsite, or adjacent properties and no individna1s were observed on site. Changes in the project property will have no
effect on this species.
Florida scrub jay/ Aphelocoma coerulescens: Prefers low growing scrub oak plants. This habitat is not present onsite
and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in the project property will have no effect on this species.
Limpkin/A ramus guarauna: Inhabits mangroves, freshwater marshes, swamps, springs and spring runs, and pond and
river margins. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Florida burrowing owVAthene cunicuJarioj/oridana: Prefers habitats oflrigh, sparsely vegetated, sandy ground This
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
Ivory-billed woodpecker/ Campephilus prine/palls: This species is considered to be extinct but is still listed. Known
to prefer swampy forests, especially large bottomland river swamps of coastal plain aod Mississippi Delta and cypress
swamps of Florida. This habitat is present onsite, but no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have nO effect on this species.
Cuban-/snowy plover, Charadrius alexandrinus: Prefers dry, sandy beaches, where they nest in shallow depressions,
usually near some vegetation or debris. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Piping ploverfCharadrius melodus: Prerers open, sandy beaches and on tidal mudflats and
sandflats along the coasts. l1ris habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Kirtland's warbler /Dendroica kirtlandii: Nests in nearly homogeneous stands of usually 30 ha or more of dense
scrubby jack pine. Florida maybe a migration stop between Michigan and the Bahamas. Individuals may flay straight
through. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341921)409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
t2.29.2006
Page 3
APPENDIX B
Little blue heronlEgrelta caerulea: Feeds in shallow freshwater, brackish, and saltwater habitats. Nesting colonies
usually occur in coastal areas, but prefers foraging in freshwater lakes, marshes, swamps, and streams. Nests in a
variety of woody vegetation types, including cypress, willow, maple, black mangrove, and cabbage palm. Usually breeds
in mixed-species colonies in flooded vegetation or on islands. Nesting habitat is present onsite, but no other nesting of other
wading bird species has been observed. No individuals or nests were observed on 1he properties. Changes in this
property will have no eflect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in a
preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Reddish egret/Egre/ta rufescens: Typically prefers coastal mangrove islands, or in Brazilian pepper on manmade
dredge spoil islands, near suitable foraging habitat Generally forages in shallow water of variable salinity. Broad, open,
marine tidal flats and shorelines with little vegetation are ideal feeding areas. Also important are salt evaporation pools
and lagoons, often located inside mangrove keys or just inside shoreline on mainland. This habitat is not present onsite
and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effuct on this species,
Snowy egret/Egre/fa (hula: Nests both inland and in coastal wetlands with nests placed in many types of woody shrubs,
especially mangroves and willows; usually over shallow walers. Ahnost all nesting is over shallow waters or on islands
that are separated from shoreline by extensive open water. Feeds in many types of permanently and seasonally flooded
wetlands, streams, lakes, and swamps, and in manmade impoundments and ditches. Breeding success is tied to water-
level fluctuations. Preferred nesting habitat is not present onsite. There are no permanently inundated areas on site.
Seasonally flooded areas are very short in duration. No individuals or nesting were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of
forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat cooditions may encourage use.
Tricolored heronlEgretta tricolor. Most nesting colonies occur on mangrove islands or in willow thickets in fresh water,
but nesting sites include other woody thickets on islands or over standing water. Prefers coastal environments. Feeds in
a variety of permanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, mangrove swamps, tidal creeks, ditches, and edges of ponds
and lakes. Preferred nesting and feeding habitat is not present onsite aod no individuals were observed on tlle
properties. Changes in this property will have no effuct on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12
acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
White ibis/Eudocimus albus: Found in a wide variety of habitats, including freshwater and brackish marshes, salt flats
and salt marsh meadows, many types of forested wetlands, wet prairies, swales, seasonally inundated fields, and man-
made ditches. The forested wetland habitat is present onsite and targeted to be preserved and enhanced. No individuals
or nests were observed in the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to
rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may
encourage use.
Peregrine falcon/Falco peregrinus: The Peregrine Falcon frequents open areas like marshes, fields, swamps, and tidal
areas. Since its reintroduction into the eastern Uniled States, however, the Peregrine Falcon has colonized many urban
areas because of increased nesting sites (and nesting ledges being created on buildings). This species is considered to
be recovered and is waiting for delisting. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Southeastern American kestrel/Falco sparverius paulus: Found in open pine habitats, woodland edges, prairies, and
pastures throughout much of Florida. Nest sites are tall dead trees or utility poles generally with an unobstructed view
of surroundings. Kestrels are notlmown to Dest in Collier County. Most individuals are migrants from the north No
individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have little to no effect on this
species.
Florida sandhill crane/Grus canadensis pratensis: Habitat: Prairies, freshwater marshes, and pasture lands. Avoids
forests and deep marshes but uses transition zones and edges between these and prairies or pasture lands. This habitat
is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect
on this species.
Yahl Mulching
PlD: 00341920409; Collier Co,
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Page 4
APPENDIX B
American oystercatcher/Haema/opus palliales: Habitat: Coastal waters. This habitat is not present OllSite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Bald eagle/Haliaeelus leucocephalus: According to the FWC eagle website, only 1 nest is within 1 mile of this project
A map of this nest location is presented in Figure 5. The location of this nest was field verified and it is active. It is
approximately 4,270 feet form the project. It is within the South Belle Meade Boundary, but it is in private ownership.
FWC records indicate that it has been active since the year 2000. The Yahl Recycling project has been in operation
prior to 2000. Highway 1-75 is also between the Yahl project and the designated eagles nest The proposed project is
not in the primary zone, but it is in the secondary zone. No individuals or nests were observed on or utilizing the
property. The distance of the nests from the project, coupled with the fact that activity form I -75 has not presented any
problems indicates that proposed changes in this property will have little to no effect on this species. On a larger scale
tlle FWS has started the process to delist the Bald Eagle.
Wood stork/Mycleria Amerioona: Nests colonially in a variety of inundated forested wetlands, including cypress
strands and domes, mixed hardwood swamps, sloughs, and mangroves. Forages in 6-15 inches of surface water, Tj.,
preferred nesting habitat is present onsite, but the surface water does not get very deep on the property during the year
due to the impacts of road building changing the hydrology. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species, It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of
forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Brown pelican/Pelecanus occidenlalis: Habitat: Mainly coastal, feeding in shallow estuarine waters, and (less
often) far offshore. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Red-cockaded woodpecker/Picoides borealis: Habitat: Inhabits open, mature pine woodlands that have a diversity of
grass, forb, and shrub species. Prefers mature slash pine trees that are generally larger than 12 inches in diameter, a
wide spacing of trees, no subcanopy and relatively dry conditions. Tj., preferred habitat is not present onsite. No
individuals were observed on the property. All trees were inspected for nest cavities or start holes and none were
found. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Roseate spoonbilVPlatalea qjaja (Ajaia ajaja): Habitat: Primarily nests in mixed-species colonies on coastal mangrove
islands or in Brazilian pepper on man-made dredge spoil islands near suitable foraging habitat Does feed in forested
wetland habitats with slow moving water. Although forested wetland type habitat present, hydrology has been so
impacted it is very low quality. No individuals or indications of this species were observed on the properties. Changes
in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres offorested
wetlands in the preserve area This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Crested caracara/Polyborus plancus audubonii (earacara cheriway): Open country, including dry prairie and pasture
lands with cabbage palm, cabbage pa1mllive oak hammocks, and shallow ponds and sloughs. Preferred nest trees are
cabbage palms, followed by live oaks. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Everglades snail kite/Ros/rhamus sociabtlis plumbeus: Habitat: Large open freshwater marshes and lakes wilb shallow
water. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on tlle properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Black skimmer/Rynchops niger: Habitat: Coastal waters, including beaches, bays, estuaries, sandbars, tidal creeks
(foraging), and also inland waters oflarge lakes, phosphate pits, and flooded agricultural fields. This habitat is not
present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this
species.
Least temlS/erna an/iI/arum: Habitat: Coastal areas throughout Florida, including beaches, lagoons, bays and
estuaries. Increasingly use artificial nesting sites, including gravel rooftops, dredge spoil islands or other dredged
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Page 5
APPENDIX B
material deposits, construction sites, causeways, and mining lands. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Roseate tern/Sterna dougalli (Sterna dougallii dougal/ii): Habitat: Nest sites include bare limestone, shell-sand
beaches, newly deposited rock and marl fill, dredge material, and heaps of broken coral deposited by storms. This
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
Bachman's warblerlVennivora baehmanii: Historic records indicate the Bachman's warbler nested in low, wet forested
areas containing variable amounts of water, but usually with some water that was permanent. This species is considered
extinct in Florida. This preferred habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Smalltooth sawfish! Pristis peetiMla: Habitat: Shallow coastal, estuarine, and fresh waters; often in brackish water near
river mouths and large embayments, in deeper holes on bottoms of mud or muddy sand. This habitat is not present
onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Rivulus (mangrove rivulus)/Rivulus marmora/us: Habitat: coastal, appears to prefer red mangrove (Rhizophora
mangle). This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Sei whale/Balaenoptera borealis: Habitat Pelagic, marine. Generally, in deep water; along edge of continental shelf
and in open oceau. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Fin whale (finback whale)/Balaenoptera physaJus: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Usually found in largest nwnbers 25
miles or more from shore. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effeet on this species
North Atlantic right whale/Eubalaena glacialis (Balaena glacialis [ine/. aus/ralis]): Habitat: Inhabits near shore and
offshore waters. Mainly coastal in the North Atlantic. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
Florida mastiffbat/Eumaps glaucinusfloridanus: Habitat: Roosts in palms and hollow trees and in buildings. Forages
high in air over natural as well as hwnan--altered landscapes. Minimal preferred roosting habitat is present onsite. No
individuals were observed on the properties or surrounding areas during surveys. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
Humphack whale/Megaptera novaeangliae: Habitat: Pelagic and coastal waters, sometimes frequenting inshore areas
such as bays. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Caribbean monk seallMonachus tropicalis: Habitat: Marine areas. Shallow lagoons and reefs, sandy beaches, and
permanent islets or beaches above high tide. Mainly west coast of Florida and Caribbean This habitat is not present
onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Everglades miITK/Mus/ela vison evergladensis: Habitat: A variety of wetland communities, including salt marsh,
freshwater marsh, cypress swamp, and hardwood swamp. There is very little of the preferred habitat is onsite.
However, no individuals were observed or, indicators of the presence was noted on the property. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in
the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Yahl Mulching
pm: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protecled Species Report
12.29.2006
Page 6
APPENDIX B
Sperm wbale/Physe/er macrocephalus: Habitat: Pelagic, prefers deep water, sometimes around islands or in shallow
shelf waters. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed OD the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Florida panther/Puma (Felis) concolor coryi: Habitat: Requires extensive blocks of mostly forested communities. The
FWC panther telemetry database form 1981-2005 indicates no utilization of this property. The forested Illbitat panthers
utilize is present onsite. No individuals or indicators were observed on the property. Planned changes in this property
will have no effect on this species. However, this property is considered to be Figure 6 shows the location of the
property within the areas considered to be Primary or Secondary Panther Habitat Zones. This project is within the zone
considered to be a Primary Habitat Zone. Proposed changes to the property are expected to have little to no effect on
this species. A more detailed discussion concerning this species is in the Proposed Mitigation section of accompanying
this report.
Big Cypress fox squirrel/Sciurus niger avicennia: Habitat: Sandhills (high pine), pine flatwoods, and pastures and other
open, ruderal habitats with scattered pines and oaks. Depends on a variety of oak trees for seasonal food and nest
material. Longleafpine CODes and seeds are important foods. This habitat type is present onsite, but very few oak trees.
No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
FloridalWest Indian manateelTrichechus manatus la/iros/ris (Trichechus mana/us): Habitat: Coastal waters, bays,
rivers, and (occasionally) lakes. Requires wann-water refugia such as springs or cooling effluent during cold weather.
Sheltered coves are important for feeding, resting, and calving. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida black hearlUrsus americanus floridanus: Habitat: A wide variety of forested communities is needed to support
the varied seasonal diet of black bears. Forested wetlands are particularly important for diurnal cover. This habitat is
present onsite. No individuals or indices were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect
on lhis species.
American alligator/Alliga/or mississippiensis: Habitat: Most permanent bodies of fresh water, including marshes,
swamps, lakes, and rivers. Oc<:asionally wanders into brackish and salt water but rarely remains there. Protected
classification is primarily due to similarity of appearance with the American Crocodile. This Species is considered
recovered in Florida. Habitat is not present onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Loggerhead seaturtlelCarella caret/a: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on tlle properties. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
Green seatw'llel/Chelonia mydas: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
American crocodile//Crocodylus aculus: Habitat: Coastal estuarine marshes, tidal swamps, and creeks along edges of
mainland and islands. Usually associated with mangroves. Nests on beaches, stream banks, and levees. This habitat is
not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on
this species.
Leatherback seaturtlelDennochelys coriacea: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have no effect on this species.
Eastern indigo snakel/Drymarchon corais couper!: Habitat: Broad range of habitats, from scrub and sandhill to wet
prairies and mangrove swamps. In northern part of range, often winters in gopher tortoise burrows in sandy uplands but
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Page?
APPENDIX B
forages in more hydric habitats. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property.
Also, no gopher tortoise burrows were discovered. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Hawksbill seaturtlel/Erelmoche/ys imbricala: Habitat Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Gopher tortoiselGopheTlL' polyphemus: Habitat: Typically found in dry upland habitats, including sandhills, scrub,
xeric oak hammock, and dry pine flatwoods; also commonly uses disturbed habitats such as pastures, old fields, and
road shoulders. Typical habitat not present onsite. No burrows or individuals observed on site. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Kemp's ridley seaturtle//Lepidochelys kempii: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Florida tree snaill/Liguus fascialus: Hahitat: Tropical hardwood hammock (rock land hammock). This species prefers
smooth-barked trees. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species
Milkpea, Small's/IGalaclia smalli: Habitat: The results of a study oftlle abundance, distribution, and habitat
preferences of Galactia species appears to be in Miami-Dade County pine. This species may occur in the extreme SE
comer of Collier County with similar habitat characteristics. This habitat is not prescot onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
CONCLUSIONS
The majority of habitat on site is 624 pine, cypress, palm. This habitat type appears to be the result of hydrology
impacts over a long period of time, which dried the area out and allowed slash pine to invade in cypress transition areas
in tlle dry years. There was no indication of utilization of the 6.37 acres of 624 to be cleared by protected species. The
approximate 11.73 acres that will be preserved and to be rehydrated has a great potential to improve the conditions of
the area and increase wildlife utilization. Creation oftlle preservation area also insures that there will be a connection to
the 1-75 drainage for a "community flow way" to the north of this project In additon, the preserve area will be protected
by a permanent conservation easement with the SFWMD. Overall, changes in this property will have little to no effect
on protected species detected. Implementation of the preserve area, enhancement and rehydration of it will increase
wildlife utilization and habitat quality on the property, especially for wetland oriented species; and provide a permanent
flow way for the natural flow of water form the north.
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Page 8
APPENDIX B
REFERENCES
Ashton, R. E., Jr., and P. S. Ashton. 1 988a. Handbook of reptiles and amplnbians of Florida, part 3: The amphibians.
Windward Pub!., Inc., Miami, Florida.
_' 1988b. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 1: The snakes, 2nd ed. Windward Publ., Inc.,
Miami, Florida.
_' 1991. Handbook ofreptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 2: Lizards, turtles & crocodilians, 2nd ed. Windward
Publ., Inc., Miami, Florida.
Barbour, D. B., and S. R Hwnphrey. 1982. Status and habitat of the Key Largo woodrat and cotton mouse (Neotoma
floridana sma1li and Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola). J Marnma1. 63:144-148.
Barnwell, M. E., P. A. Meylan, and T. Walsh. 1997. The spotted turtle (Clemmys guttata) in central Florida. Chelonian
Cons. BioI. 2:405-408.
Bartlett, R. D., and P. P. Bartlett. 1999. A field guide to Florida reptiles and amphibians. GulfPubl. Co., Houston,
Texas.
Bemer, 1., and M. 1. Pescador. 1988. The mayflies of Florida. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Birkenholz, D. E. 1963. A study of the life history and ecology of the round-tailed muskrat (Neofiber alieni). Ecolog.
Monogr. 33:225-280.
Bortone, S. A. 1989. Notropis melanostomus, a new species of cyprinid fish from the Blackwater-Yellow River drainage
of northwest Florida. Copeia 3:73 7-74I.story, habitat assessment, and systematics of the blackmouth shiner
(Notropis sp.), Blackwater
River drainage. Final Rep. Nongame Wildl. Prog., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Bouchard, R. W. 1978. Taxonomy, ecology and phylogeny of the subgenus Depressicambarns, with the description of a
new species from Florida and redescriptions of Carnbarus graysoni, Carnbarus latimanus, and Carnbarns striatus
(Decapoda: Cambaridae). Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 3:27-60.
Bowen, P. J. 2000. Demographic, disbibution, and metapopulation analyses of the bwrowing owl (Athene cunicularia) in
Florida. M.S. thesis, Univ. Central Florida, Orlando.
Brady, J. T., T. H. Kunz, M. D. Tuttle, and D. E. Wilson. 1982. Gray bat recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Denver,
Colorado.
Brim Box, J., and J. D. Williams. 2000. Unionid mollusks of the Apalachicola Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia.
Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. His!. 21:1-143.
Brody, R. W.. 1990. Status of habitat and populations of Procambarus pictus in the North Fork of Black Creek, Clay
County, Florida. St Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida.
Brown, 1. N. 1997. A guide to the mammals oftbe southeastern United States. Univ. Tennessee Press, Knoxville.
Brown, W. S. 1993. Biology, status, and management of the timber rattlesnake (Crotalus borridus): a guide for
conservation. Soc. Stud. Amphib. Rept. Herp. Circ_ 22.
Carle, F. 1., and M. 1. May. 1987. Gomphus (phanogomphus) westfalli spec. novo from the Gulf coast of Florida
(Anisoptera: Gomphidae). Odonatologica 16:67- 75.
Chace, F. A, Jr. 1954. Two subterranean shrimps (Decapoda: Caridea) from Florida and the West Indies, with a revised
key to !be American species. J. Washington Acad. ScL 44:318-324.
Chafin, 1. 2000. Field guide to the rare plants of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Chase, C A., and J. A. Gore. 1989. Snowy plover breeding disbibution. Unpubl. final rept, Florida Fish and
Wildl.Conserv. Comm., Tallahassee.
Choate, P. M. 1984. A new species ofCicindela Linnaeus (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae) from Florida, and elevation ofC.
abdominalis scabrosa Schaupp to species level. Entomol. News 95:73-82.
Conant, R., and J. T. Collins. 1991. A field guide to reptiles and amplnbians: eastem and central North America, 3rd cd.
Houghton Miffiin, Boston.
Cox, J., D. Inkley, and R. Kautz. 1987. Ecology and habitat protection needs of gopher tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus)
populations found on lands slated for large-scale development in Florida. Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep.
no. 4, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Crance, J. H. 1986. Habitat suitability index models and instrearn flow suitability curves: shortnose sturgeon. U. S. Fish
Wildl. Servo BioI. Rep. 82(10.129).
Deitz, D. c., and T. CHines. 1980. Alligator nesting in north-central Florida. Copeia 1980:249-258.
Delany, M. F., and C 1. Abercrombie. 1986. American alligator food habits in north-central Florida. I. Wildl. Manag.
50:348-353.
YaW Mulching
PlD: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Page 9
APPENDIX B
Delany, M. F., P.B. Walsh, B. Pranty, and DW. Perkins. 1999. A previously unknown population of Florida
grasshopper sparrow on Avon Park All Force Range. Florida Field Nat. 27(2):52-56.
Deyrup, M., and R. Franz (cds.). 1994. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. N: Invertebrates. Univ. Press of
Florida, Gainesville.
Dodd, C. K., Jr. 1988. Synopsis of the biological data on the loggemead sea turtle Caretta carella (Linn_eus 1758). U.S.
Fish Wildl. Serv. BioI. Rep.88(14).
Duggins, C. F., Jr., A. A. Karlin, K. Relyea, and R. W. Yerger. 1986. Systematics of the key silverside, Menidia
conchorum, with comments on other Menidia species (pisces: Atherinidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot. 25(2):133-
150.
Dunkle, S. W. 1989. Dragonflies of the Florida Peninsula, Bermuda and the Bahamas. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville,
Florida.
_.2000. Dragonflies through binoculars: A field guide to the dragonflies of North America. Oxford Univ. Press,
New York.
Dunn, J. 1999. National Geographic Society field guide to the birds of North America. 3rd ed. National Geographic
Soc., Washington, D.C.
Emmel, T. C., and M. C. Minno. 1988. Habitat requirements and status of the endemic Schaus swallowtail in the Florida
Keys. Final report, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Enge, K M., M. M. Bentzien, and F. Percival. 1986. Florida scrub lizard status survey. Tech. Rept. No. 26 to U.S. Fish
Wildl. Serv., Jacksonville End. Sp. Office, Florida.
Emst, C. H., and R. W. Barbour. 1989. Snalces of eastern North America. George Mason Univ. Press, Fairfax, Virginia.
Emst, C. H., J. E. Lovich, and R W. Barbour. 1994. Turtles of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Inst. Press,
Washington,D.C.
Ewert, M. A., and D. R. Jackson. 1994. Nesting ecology of the alligator snapping turtle (Macroclemys temminckii)
along the lower Apalachicola River, Florida. Final Rep. NG89-020, Nongame Wildlife Prog. Florida Game and
Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Fillpatrick, J. W., G. E. Woolfenden, and M. T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related habitat requirements
of the Florida scrub jay (Apbelocoma coerulcsccns coerulescens). Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 8,
Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003. Management Plan Red-Cockaded Woodpecker Picoide.s
borealis. Tallahassee, FL 78 pp.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003, October 8. Florida's Waterbird Colony Locator.
http://www.rnyfwc.comlwaders.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2006. Eagle nest locator. http://wld.fwc.state.fl.us/eagleleaglenests.
Florida Natural Areas Inventory. 1990. Guide to the natural communities of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory
and Florida Dept. Natural Resources, Tallahassee.
Franz, R. 1986. The Florida gopher frog and the Florida pine snake as burrow associates of the gopher tortoise in
northern Florida. pp. 16-20 in D. R. Jackson and R. J. Bryant (eds.). The gopher tortoise and its community.
Proc. 5 tl1 Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council, Gainesville, Florida.
Franz, R., and 1. M. Franz. 1979. Distribution, habitat preference and status of populations of the Black Creek crayfish,
Procambaros (Ortmannicus) pictus (Decapoda: Cambaridae). Florida Sci. 42:13-17.
Franz, R., and 1. 1. Smith. 1999. Distribution and status of the striped newt and Florida gopher frog in peninsular
Florida. Final Rep. Florida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm., Tallahassee.
Gaby, R., M. P. McMahon, F. 1. Mazzotti, W. N. Gillies, and J. R. Wilcox. 1985. Ecology and status of a population of
Crocodylus acutus (Reptilia: Crocodilidae) at a power plant site in Florida. J. Herpetol. 19: 189-198.
Georgia Department of Natural Resources. 1999. Protected animals of Georgia. Nongame - Endangered Wildlife
Program, Wildlife Res. Div., Georgia Dept. Nat. Res., Social Circle.
Gilbert, C. R. (cd.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. 4: Fishes. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
_(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. II: Fishes. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Glassberg, J., M. C. Minno, and J. V. Calhoun. 2000. Butterflies through binoculars: a field, finding, and gardening
guide to butterflies in Florida. Oxford Univ. Press, New York.
Gordon, M. E., and W. R. Hoeh. 1993. Anodonta heardi,a new species of freshwater mussel (Bivalvia:Unionidae) from
the Apalachicola River system of the southeastern United States. Walkerana 7:265-273.
Gore, J. A., and M. J. Kinnison. 1991. Hatching success in roof and ground colonies ofleast terns. The Condor 93:759-
762.
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29J006
Page 10
APPENDIX B
Guillory, V. 1979. Lake Eustis pupfish investigations. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission 1977-1979
Final Report: Study I-N. Tallahassee.
Guillory, V., and W. E. Johnson. 1986. Habitat, conservation status, and zoogeography of the cyprinodont fish,
Cyprinodon variegatus hubbsi (Carr). The Southwestern Nal31(1):95-100.
Hall, E. R. 1981. Mammals of North America. 2 nd ell. John Wiley and Sons, New YOlk.
Harvey, M. J. 1992. Bats of the eastern United States. Arkansas Game and Fish Comro., Little Rock.
Hersh, S.L. 1981. Ecology of the Key Largo woodrat (Ncostoma floridana sma11i). J. Mammal. 62:201-206.
Hipes, D., D. R. Jackson, K. NeSmith, D. Printiss and K. Brandt. 2001. Field guide to tlle rare animals of Florida.
Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Hirth, H. F. 1971. Synopsis of the biological data on the green turtle Chelonia mydas (Linnaens) 1758. FAO Fish.
Synopsis 85.
Hobbs, H. H., Jr. 1942. The cmyfishes of Florida. Univ. Florida Pub\., Bio\. ScL Ser. 3(2):1-179.
Hoehn, T. S. 1998. Rare and imperiled fish species of Florida: a watershed perspective. Office Envir. Serv., Florida
Game and Fresh Water Fish Comro., Tallahassee.
Hovis, J. A., and M. S. Robson. 1989. Breeding status and distribution of the least tern in the Florida Keys. Florida
FieldNal17(3):61-66.
Humpbrey, S. R. (ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. I: Mammals. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville
Humphrey, S. R. 1988. Density estimates of the endangered Key Largo woodratand colton mouse (Neotoma floridana
smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola) using the nested-grid approach. J. Mammal. 69(3):524-531.
Humphrey, S. R, and H. W. Setzer. 1989. Geographic variation and taxonomic revision of mink (Muste!a vison) in
Florida. J. Mammal. 17:382-392.
Hurst, H. N., G. Bass, and C. Hubbs. 1975. The biology of the Guadalupe, Snwannee, and redeye basses. Pp. 47-53 in
R. H. Strood and H. Clepper (eds.).
Black bass biology and management Sport Fishing lnstilUte,Wasbinglon, D.C. Jackson, D. R., and R. Franz. 1999.
Survey for the fire-back crayfish in the Apalachicola ravine system, northern Florida. Final report to The Nature
Conservancy. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Jackson, D. R., and E. G. Milsirey. 1989. The fauna of gopher tortoise burrows. pp. 86-98 in J. E. Diemer, D. R.
Jackson, J. L. Landers, J. N. Layne, and D. A. Wood, eds. Gopher Tortoise Relocation Symposium
Proceedings. Nongame Wildl. Program Tech. Rep. no. 5. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm.,
Ta1lahassee.
Jackson, D. R., and R. N. Walker. 1997. Reproduction in the Suwannee cooler, Pseudemys concinua suwanniensis. Bull.
Florida Mus. Nat. Hist. 41:69-167.
Jackson, J. F. 1973. Distnbution and population phenetics of the Florida scrub lizard, Sceloporus woodi. Copeia
1973:746-761.
Jackson, J. F., and S. R. Telford. 1974. Reproductive ecology of the Florida scrub lizard, ScelopoTUS woodi. Copeia
1974:689-694.
James, F. C. 1991. Signs of trouble in the largest remaining population of red-cockaded woodpeckers. Auk 108:419-
423.
Johnson, S. A. 2001. Autecology of the striped newt (Nolophthalmus perstrialus): life-history, upland-habitat use,
paedomorphosis, and conservation genetics. Ph.D. diss., Univ. Florida, Gainesville.
Kale, H. W., n. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vo\. 2. Birds. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Kale, H W., Il., B. Pranty, B. Stith, and W. Biggs. 1992. An aUas of Florida's breeding birds. Final Rep.
Nongame Wildlife Prog., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comro., Tallahassee.
Keppner. E. J., and L. A. Keppner. 2000. A preliminary search for the Panama City crayfish, ProcambaTUS
(Leconticambarus) econfinae, Hobbs, 1942, in Bay County, Florida. Report to V.S. Fish Wild\. Serv., Panama
City, Florida.
Knisley, C. B., and J. M. Hill. 1994. Studies of the Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: distribution,
abundance, habitat characteristics and biology. Report to V.s. Fish Wildl. Serv., Jacksonville, Florida.
_. 1996. The Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: habitat requirements, remaining range, life
history, and management. Final Rep. Florida Nongame Wildlife Prog. NG91-012, Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Kulhavey, D. L., R. G. Hooper, and R. Costa (eds.). 1995. Red-cockaded woodpecker. recovery, ecology, and
management. Center for Applied Studies in Forests, College of Forestry, Stephen F. Austin State Vniv.,
Nacogdoches, Texas.
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Pa8,lI
APPENDIX B
Kushlan, J. A. 1974. Observations on the role of the American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) in the southem
Florida wetlands. Copeia 1974:993-996.
_' and F. 1. Mazzotti. 1989. Population biology of the American crocodile. J. HerpetoL 23:7-21.
Lazell, J. D., Jr. 1989. Wildlife of the Florida Keys: a natural history. Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Layne, J. N. 1990. The Florida mouse. pp. 1-21 in C. K. Dodd, Jr., R. E. Ashton, Jr., R. Franz, and E. Wester (eds}
Burrow Associates of the Gopher Tortoise. Proc. 8 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council. Florida Mus. Nat.
His!., Gainesville.
Loftin, R. W. 1992. Use of nest boxes by the Florida kestrel. Florida Field Nal 20(3):57-64.
McMillian, M. 2001. Florida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomination form -Lake lstokpoga, Audubon of Florida,
Tampa Bay Sanctuaries.
McNair, D. B., and 1. A. Gore. 1999. Recent breeding status of royal and sandwich terns in northwest Florida. Florida
Field Nal27(3):117-120.
Maehr, D. S. 1987. Florida panther movements, social organization, and habitat utilization. &1-11 annual performance
report. Florida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm., Tallahassee.
Martin, W. H., and D. B. Means. 1998. Distribution and habitat relationships of the eastem diamondback rattlesnake
(Crotalus adarnanteos). Herpetological Nat. Hist. 7:9-34.
Means, D. B. 1975. Competitive exclusion along a habitat gradient hetween two species of sahunanders (Desmognathus)
in western Florida. J. Biogeog. 2:253- 263.
Means, D. B., and A. A. Karlan. 1989. A new species ofDesmognathus from the eastem Gulf Coastal Plain.
Herpetologica 45:37-46.
Means, D. B., and C. J. Longden. 1970. Observations on the occurrence of Desmognathos monticola in Florida.
Herpetologica 26:396-399.
_. 1976. Aspects oflhe biology and zoogeography of the pine barrens 1reefrog, Hyla andersonii, in northem Florida.
Herpetologica 32: 117-130.
Means, D. B., and P. E. Moler. 1979. The pine barrens treefrog: fire, seepage bogs, and management implications. pp.
77-83 in R. R. Odorn and L Landers (cds.). Proc. rare and endangered wildlife symposium. Georgia Dept. Nat.
Res., Game and Fish Div. Tech. Bull. WL-4.
Meylan, A. B. 1999. Status of the hawksbill turtle (Erebnochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region. Chelonian Cons.
BioI. 3:177-184.
_, and M. Donnelly. 1999. Status justification for listing the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) as Critically
Endangered on the 1996 ruCN Red List of Threatened Animals. Chelonian Coos. Bio!' 3:200-224.
Mettee, M. F., P. E. O'Neil, and 1. M. Pierson. 1996. Fishes of Alabama and the Mobile Basin. Oxmoor House, Inc.,
Birmingham, Alabama.
Minno, M. C., and D. Pierce. 1999. Florida butterfly gardening: A complete guide to attmcting, identifying, and enjoying
butterflies of the lower south. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Mitchell. J. C. 1977. Geographic variation ofElaphe gutlata (Reptilia: Serpentes) in the Atlantic coastal plain. Copeia
1977:33-41.
Moler, P. E. 1981. Notes on Hyla andersonii in Florida and Alabama. 1. Herpeto!. 15:441-444.
_.1985. A new species of frog (Ranidae: Rana) from northwestern Florida. Copeia 1985:379-383.
~(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. III: Amphibians and reptiles. Univ. Press of Florida,
Gainesville.
_. 1996. Alligator snapping turtle: distribution and relative abundance. Final report 7544. Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Cmnm., Tallahassee.
Mount, R. H. 1975. The reptiles andarophibians of Alabama. Auburn Univ. Agric. Exp. Station, Auburn, Alabama.
Myers, R L, and J. J. Ewel (eds.) 1990. Ecosystems of Florida. Univ. Central Florida Press, Orlando.
NatureServe. 2006. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 5.0. NatureServe,
Arlington, Virginia. http://www.natureserve.orglexplorer.
Neill, W. T. 1971. The last of the ruling reptiles: alligators, crocodiles, and their kin. Columbia Univ. Press, New York.
Page, L M., and B. M Burr. 1998. A field guide to freshwater fishes: North America north of Mexico, 2nd ed.
Houghton MifI1in, Boston.
Paul, R. T. 1991. Status report - Egretla rufescens (Gmelin) reddish egret U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Houston, Texas.
--' and A. F. Schnapf. 2000. Florida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomina-tion form - Passage Key National
Wildlife Refuge, Audubon of Florida, Tampa Bay Sanctuaries.
pennak, R. W. 1978. Fresh-water invertebrates of the United States. 2nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Yahl Mulching
PID: 00341920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Page 12
APPENDIX B
Peterson, R.T. 1998. Peterson field guide to eastern birds. 4th ell. Houghton Mifilin, Boston.
Petranka, J. W. 1998. Salamanders of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Inst. Press, Washington, D.C.
Pilsbry, H. A. 1946. Land Mollusca of North America, Vol. 2, part 1. Monograph of the Academy of Natural Sciences,
Philadelphia.
Pimm, S. (ed.). 2000. The 2000 Cape Sable sparrow annual report. Accessed 2001 May 8.
Poole, A, and F. Gill (cds.). 1992.2000. The birds of North America. The Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia.
and The American Ornithologists' Union, Washington, D.C.
Post, W., and J. S. Greenlaw. 2000. The present and future of the Cape Sable seaside sparrow. Florida Field Nat.
28(3):93-110.
Pranty, B. 1996. A birder's guide to Florida. American Birding Association, Inc., Colorado Springs, Colorado.
Printiss, D. J., and D. 1. Hipes. 1999. Rare amphibian and reptile survey of Eglin Air Force Base, Florida. Final report
to U.S. Dept of Defense. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Pritchard, P. C. H. 1989. The alligator snapping turtle: biology and conservation. Milwaukee Publ. Mus., Milwaukee,
Wisconsin.
Quay, T. 1., J. B. Funderburg, Jr., D. S. Lee, E. F. Polter, and C. S. Robbins (eds.). 1983. The seaside sparrow, its
biology and managemenl Occ. Papers, North arolina BioI. Surv. North Carolina State Mus. Nal Hist., Raleigh.
Relyea, K., and B. Sutton. 1975. A new troglobitic crayfish of the genus Procarnbarus from Florida. (Decapoda:
Astacidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot. 19(1-2):8-16.
Rice, D. W. 1957. Life history and ecology of Myotis austroriparius in Florida. J. Mammal. 38:15-32.
Robbins, C. S., B. Bruun, and H. S. Zim. 2001. Birds of North America: a guide to field identification. St. Martin's
Press, New York.
Rodgers, J. A., and H. T. Smith. 1995. Set-back distances to protect nesting bird colonies from human disturbance in
Florida. Conserv. BioI. 9:89-99.
Rodgers, J. A., Jr., H. W. Kale Il, and H. T. Smith (eds.). 1996. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. V: Birds.
Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Robertson, W. B., Jr., and G. E. Woolfenden. 1992. Florida bird species: an annotated list. Florida Ornithol. Soc. Spec.
Pub. no. 6: ix + 260.
Roosenburg, W. M. 2000. Impact of a bycalch reduction device on diamondback terrapin and blue crab capture in crab
pots. Ecol. Applic. 10:882-889.
Ross, J. P., S. Beavers, D. Mundell, and M. Airth-Kindree. 1989. The status of Kemp's ridley. Center Marine Conserv.,
Washington, D.G.
Runde, D., J. Gore, J. Hovis, M. Robson, and P. Southall. 1991. Florida atlas of breeding sites for herons and their
allies: update 1986 - 1989. Nongarne.Wildlife Program Tech. Rep. no. 10. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm., Tallahassee.
Semlitsch, R. D. 1983. Structure and dynamics of two breeding populations of the eastern tiger salamander, Ambystorna
tigrinum. Copeia 1983:608-616.
Shealy, R. M. 1976. The natural history of the Alabama map turtle, Graptemys pulchra Baur, in Alabama. Bull. Florida
State Mus., BioI. Sci. 21:47-11.
Shriver, G. W., P. D. Vickery, and S. A Hedges. 1996. Effects of summer burns on Florida grasshopper sparrows.
Florida Field Nat. 24(3):68-73.
Sibley, D. A 2000. The Sibley guide to birds. Alfred A Knopf, New York.
Spotila, J. R., A. E. Dunham, A. J. Leslie, A. C. Steyermark, P. T. Plotkin, and F. V. Paladino. 1996. Worldwide
population decline of Dermochelys coriace.: are leatherback turtles going extinct? Chelonian Cons. BioI.
2:209-222.
Sprandel, G. L., J. A Gore, and D. T. Cobb. 1997. Winter shorebird survey. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm. Final Perf. Rep. Tallahassee.
Stevenson, H. M. 1970. Occurrence of the carpenter frog in Florida. Quart. J. Florida Acad. Sci. 32:233-235.
, and B. H. Anderson. 1994. The birdlife of Florida. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville. Stys, B. 1993. Ecology
- and habitat protection needs of the southeastem American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) on large-scale
development sites in Florida. Nongame Wildl. Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 13. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm., Tallahassee.
Telford, S. R. 1959. A study of the sand skink, Neoseps reynoldsi. Copeia 1959:100- 119.
Tenant, A. 1997. A field guide to snakes of Florida. Gulf Publ. Co., Houston, Texas.
Yahl Mulching
PID: 0034 t 920409; Collier Co.
Protected Species Report
12.29.2006
Page 13
APPENDIX B
Tinunerrnan, W. W. 1989. Horne range, habitat use and behavior of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake. M. S. thesis,
Univ. Florida, Gainesville.
Thaxtort, J. E., and T. M. Hingtgen. 1996. Effects of suburbanizatioo and habitat fragmentation on Florida scrub-jay
dispetllal. Florida Field Nat 24(2):25-37.
Toland, B. 1999a. Nesting success and productivity of Florida sandhill cranes on natural and developed sites in
southeastern Florida. Florida Field Nat 27(1):10- 13.
_' 1999b. Nest site characteristics, breeding phenology, and nesting success of American oystercatchers in Indian
River County, Florida. Florida Field Nat 27(3):112-116.
Tuberville, TO., J. R Bodie, J. B. Jensert, 1. LaClaire, and J. W. Gibbons. 2000. Apparent decline of the southern hog-
nosed snake, Heterodon simus. J. Elisha Mitchell Soc. 116:19-40.
U.s. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1982. Stock Island tree snail recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_. 1984. American crocodile recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_.1987. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; proposed threatened status for two Florida lizards. Fed.
Reg. 52(13):2242-2246.
_' 1998a. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; 90-day finding for a petition 10 delist the Squirrel
Chimney cave shrimp. Fed. Reg. 63:67618-67619.
_' 1998b. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; determination of endangered status for five freshwater
mussels and threatened status for two freshwater mussels from the eastern Gulf Slope drainages of Alabama,
Florida, and Georgia. Fed. Reg. 63(50):12664-12687.
_' 1998c. Okaloosa darter (Etheostoma okaloosae) recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv. Atlanta,
Georgia.
_' 1999. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; final rule to list the f1atwoods salamander as a threateoed
species. Fed. Reg. 64:15691-15704.
_. 1999. South Florida Multi-Species Recovery Plan U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. 2172 pp.
_' 2000. Candidate and listing priority assignment form: Cicindela higblandeosis.
_. 2006. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service The Endangered Species Program [web application). US Fish & Wildlife
Service. Washington, D.C. hllp:/Iwww.fws.gov/eodangered
U.s. Fish and Wildlife Service and Gulf States Marine Fisheries Commission. 1995.GulfSturgeon Recovery Plan.
Atlanta, Georgia.
Walls, J. G. 1976. Fishes oftbe northern Gulf of Mexico. T. F. H. Publications, Inc., Ltd., Hong Kong.
Whitaker, J. O. 1996. National Audubon Society field guide to North American mammals. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
Williams, J. D., and G. H. Burgess. 1999. A new species of bass, Micropterus cataractae (Teleostei: Ceotrarchidae),
from the Apalachicola River basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Bull. Florida Mus. Nal Hist. 42(2):81-
114.
Witzell, W. N. 1983. Synopsis of the biological data on the hawksbill turtle Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus, 1766).
FAO Fish. Synopsis 137.
Wood, P. B., M. 1. Hoffroart, M. W. Collopy, and J. M. Schaefer. 1988. Southeastern American kestrel (Falco
sparverius paulus) natural history, life requirements, and habitat protection guidelines. Final report to Office of
Envir. Services, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Woods, C. A., W. Post, and C W. Kilpatrick 1982. Microtus pennsylvanicus (Rodentia; Muridae) in Florida: a
Pleistocene relict in a coastal saltmarsh. Bull. Florida State Mus. BioI. Sci. 28:25-52.
Wooley, eM., and E. J. Crateau. 1985. Movement, microhabitat. exploitation, and management of Gulf of Mexico
sturgeon, Apalachicola River, Florida. North American J. Fisheries Manag. 5:590-605.
Wunderlin, R.P. 1998. Guide to the vascular plants of Florida. University Presses of
Florida, Gainesville, Florida
Zambrano, R., M. S. Robson, D. Y. Charnetzky, and H. T. Smith. 1997. Distribution and status ofleast tern nesting
colonies in southeast Florida. Florida Field Nat. 25(3):85-91.
Zambrano, R., R., H. T. Smith, and M. Robson. 2000. Summary of breeding roseate terns in the Florida Keys: 1974-
1998. Florida Field Nat. 28(2):64--68.
PROJECT LOCATIOIAPPENDIX B
5
,
o
5
10
15 Miles
,
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE, NAPLES, FL
Figure 1. Project Location Map In Collier County; UPDATED 12.29.06 Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
Vahl MulchIng Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave., 2631 4th St.
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres. ~r'.'lI"~\634120
N
W+E
APPENDIX B
Iv~c
N
W*E
S
ID " AC FWCFCS
TOTAL ACRES 28.8
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
100
,
o
100 200 Feet
,
Figure 2. FLUCFCS/ Vegetation Map; UPDATED 12.29.06
Ramsey Inc.
environmental Consulting
2831 4th St. NW
Naple~. FL 34120
239.5.....1880
Vahl MJllchlna.Exll8nslo.n Parl;;el 2250 Washbllm AVfl.
sec. 31, 'TWn-.9, Kge 27, totalinll approXimately 28.1IIocres.
PROTECTED SPECIES LISTED BY FW( APPEN 0 IX B
FOR COLLIER CO.
-
CO_ON NAIll
.ClaNTJPtc NAIll
......An. nATUI
"" ....
.... ....
AMPHIBIANS
-""
a,ons
F1orid.tlU\lbjly
,""'*'"
florid.ib.lJTowiT\&owl
ivory4)JlledwoodpctkCl
Cuball-/SllOW)'p\oYtT
piJqplover
Klrtlmd'. watbkl
Iiltkbluehmln
leMIsh*,d
mlWr')'rpcl
tic;dcn:dhmln
whilCibis
paqrincrakoo
SlllliM;utcmAmc:ricankelln:1
rklrilla.JIndblllCftllC
NlIericlPoytIuCalchc
"""....
....-
browIIpe1ican
ml-coc:kackdwoodpecktl
fosaltspoonbtl!
.......~
E~Iit:s*nlnkile
blIek.1c:inmu
.,,,"'"
''''''''''''
Badunan'swubkr
I1SH
II!IlIllOOthuwfish
ril'll1us(mIllgrovcrivlllll$)
MAMMALS
$ti 'IIbII~
fin whall: (fiTll:..u whalr)
NGrtII Atl&rllic n,hl whale
FloridllllUSrifl"bIt
hlll1pbackwhlk
CaibbcanmODkiW
EW:lJladcsllrillk
~whalc
Ftoricb-pvolht:r
Bit Cypress to>: iqUirrd
FkllidalWnllndianlllllllkt
Florida b1a* btar
REPTILES
AlMricanik1hptor
100000000.ahDIlc
.....-
AJncriClllc:rocodilc
~klelturt~
EastcmblditD_kc
tll>NbbllllCllllt\lt
FJPbcrlm10ilC
Kcmp'sridleyseGllltlt
INVERUBRATES
MOLLUSKS
1'Iori41~cl;l\lll
.LANni
Millcpu,SnWI'l
Jhl~lI ClIP//(} sse (I))
Ap/tc/octHNl tomll~wu T
A'1"4IIl~porlllUlll SSe (1)
A/4cuCIIlllnol"'U1(.fIlIr/lc
CUIcN/oriIlJl".i4DMl) SSC(I)
CIlIllp4MUWprlllc/p;l1U ,
CM1JUIr"" lllUDrulrinlU r
CM..unf'llltdtHIUJ T
DvtdrO/C'IlAln/Gndll E
EpltlClc11du SSC(I,~)
E,nnllntjeuclJJ sse (J,~)
Errcnllfhlll SSC(1)
qraUltrlclIllIr SSC(I,4}
ElJocilJlwllibJls SSC(2)
Fll/aJpt~1G E
FnJu.IJHlrwrlWplJUiJD T
GrJiJCII",rklullpr"~JI, T
HtJrlfUIllIpwpalllQtIlJ SSC(I,1)
HtilioutUll'lKOCtpAQ/ul T
Mycfmo,MUlurllq E
pt/<<tJllwo<</dD!/Q/is SSC(I)
P;roidQbortlillb sse
PI41alfillljofll(~~qJqjo} SSC(l,4}
PII/ybortupllUttOUnd/;boll"i
(Ct'l7fttl1'fld1.lr1-r) T
,""Irl!,PrlWS'lKWblllspl.u"bt". E
Rl"dt'lpl.',.,r SSC(ll
Sfulfll'IIdlltrn;nl T
Sft""(l~IIi(SttFfllldotIK,,lII,
dOIlpIIU) T
JI".I1ll_t1bf1cJr"'o~1i ,
Pri"iljJetli""a
Ri~"/IU/ll/lr,,",fllfw SSC(T)
BIl/UIIllpItfllbarUJIJJ E
Bfl11UII~rllp1QiJIlIWJ ,
E..bcltItM6/atIll/Ji(JliIlliIl'IlII
r1Ildt'llUlllltI.'IQ/f/l1is)1 E
UIMp1,ltllJdllUSJl,.,;dtzll'" E
M"'Pfl:rJ/MWlI:Il,,,liae E
MOflfJUtlUfropiC,/l.
Mw/tliJlIfl:llllrltrihJdtllS;, T
P"yrtlu,,",croctpl!,w E
PIU!IIl(FtliJ}~ltII"coryI ,
ScillflU"lter/IVtnlfll/(J T
TrldtUlIIS",OIlflIIlS/,I;ro,trj]
(T,ldtt:dw m4111,IIfJ) E
Unl/l ''''U/tlIlWS floridtUlIH T.
Alu,IltcJ,.",inlulppfl1l11s S$C(I.:l)
Cllrrllllnft//Q T
CItt:I611IIl"l)'ll/U E
Crocody/"" "1I11U E
IN,IIl<</rt./ftrorilltu E
D""",ttboIlCllfQ;,n".ptr; T
LnlIfII<<"t./ftlMbrltlllll E
GllpAt(W~UflIl.I SSC"{l,1,J}
up;dt:ltlltlyl!ttrtp/i E
T
T
T
E
E
T
S
T
,
E
E
,
E
11""
T
~U
E
E
T
E
E
Liguw f01(/"'",
SSC(I)
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING AND RECYCLING
G.!aetiatmami
E
Figure 3. 2006 Protected species list for Collier Count, FL for the Florida
Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish
and Wildlife Service (FWS)
Yahl Mulching Parcels; 2250 Washburn Road, Pill 00341920409, 28.8 ac;
the SW Y. or the SW 'f., Section 31; Township 49, Range 27.
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Con.rulting
263141hSt.NW
Nlples, FL 34120
239.564.1660
CONSERVATION/PRIAPPENDIX B
AREA MAP
I~c
~ Conservation/Preserve Area 11.73 Acres
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
N
W+E
s
Igure 4. Conservation/Preserve Area Map; UPDATED 12.29.06
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th It. NW
Nalll.s, FL 34120
239.564.1660
Vahl MJdl<hlnR.ExDllnslon Pa~el 2250 WlUlhblU11 AVl"L
Sec. 31. Twn~9 Ka 7:1. totalln a OXlmatalV 28.8 acres.
-
lit- ~I'~D~~GE NESr LOCA'API~ENDIIXIB
. NEST LO ATlON
~
-
h
'J;;..f\
ygz
~,
.-
u-
/ ~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~i-;~/.~~
v/, ./ ~ ~~~00~~VW~0~/; ;/:; ~~'~~:~
'/ //,/ // :0 '//// '/~~ //// / '/1/ / // ///
/, //17///. '//v'~//yx:22'/M '/N/ / // /~
~;~/ ~~~ ~~~/~./ :/:~~,/- // .~ ,J// ~~;
/~ /:-.4 %%~/// ~:///~ / i/ '/'"7 /j-'/j;
) ~~~~ ~ ~ ~t;l~.r: ~i~~
~~A/ -% 0 / / ~ '////t/.:'//
/l;~///;0w /0~~I 7W/~ }~~~~
/~///~:/~~/'/;r;:;~~~~;;Y////// <<~<<~~
///~//0'//~ '/ :/~///,,0 / / //'/; '//LL Z '//
'-- @/~/~//ffi'/;//'l/~ ~~//~~~~~~;j~~
~~;/ ~/1/ ;/~ ~ /~i7;~~;:: '~i>>~~
~~ <<~>>~000~0 ~~~~~~
-//1//1/ /X/A' //.// '/ '/:: ,/:~ij -:% x// '/
////'//1//1/ 'J"'/I' 7///.///////////, '/////////////./0/
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION W~E
WASHBURN AVE. NAPLES. FL T
Figure 5. Bald Eagle Location Map; UPDATED 12.29.06
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples.FL 34120
239.564.1660
Yahl MJllchlnlLExll8nsl1lJ1 P.rcel 2250 W/lShb"m AVfI.
Sec. 31, TWn"'9, Rge 27, total In.. approximately 26.B acres.
PANTHER PRIMARY/SEAPPENDIX B
HABITAT MAP '~
~
PANTHER \
CONSULTATION
LINE
SECONDARY I'~~Y I
HABITAT ",-",
~'1tN D
400 0 400 800 Feet
,
N
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION W.........E
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL T
Figure 6. Panther Primary/Secondary Habitat Map; UPDATED 12.29.06 Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th st. NW
I:~~ rf.I~~\I~Ili~Ir. fo'~r~. ~~o~r.::=r~A~hcres. ~1!':l~'i&~4120
APPEAPPENDIX B
FLORIDA'S ENDANGERED SPECIES,
THREATENED SPECIES, AND SPECIES
OF SPECIAL CONCERN
June 2006
FLORIDA FISH AND WILDLIFE CONSERVATION COMMISSION
APPEAPPENDIX B
CONTENTS
PREFACE.......................................................................................................................... ii
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA
AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN .... I
OFFICIAL LISTS ....................................................................................................... I
FISH ............................................................. ................ .................................................. 2
AMPHIBIANS...............................................................................................................2
REPTILES.. ................................................................................................................... 2
BIRDS ............................................................................................................................ 3
MAMMALS.................................................................................................................,.4
INVERTEBRATES ......................................................................................................6
CORALS ....................................................................................................................6
CRUSTACEANS.......................................................................................................6
INSECTS ..................................... ............ ............................ .............................. ........ 6
MOLLUSKS ..............................................................................................................6
KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATIONS........................................................ 7
APPEAPPENDIX B
PREFACE
This document consolidates the official state of Florida list of endangered species, threatened
species, and species of special concern. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission (FWC) maintains the state list of animals designated as endangered, threatened, or
species of special concern, in accordance with Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and 68A-27.005,
respectively, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.) hrtp:llfac.dos_state_fl_us/. The state lists of
plants, which are designated endangered, threatened, and commercially exploited, are
administered and maintained by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
(DOACS) via Chapter 5B-40, F .A.C. This list of plants can be obtained at hlto:/Iwww.fl-
dof.com/form manat!ement/plant conserve list_html. The federal agencies that share the
authority to list species as Endangered and Threatened are the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration-National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA-NMFS) and U. S. Fish
and Wildlife Service (USFWS). The NOAA-NMFS is responsible for listing most marine
species. The federal list of animals and plants is administered by the USFWS, and this list is
published in 50 CFR 17 (animals) and 50 CFR 23 (plants). Additional information regarding
federal listings can be located at the following websites; NOAA-NMFS
http://www.nmfs.noaa_l!.ovandUSFWS-hlto:/Iendanl!.ered.fwu:ov/wildlife.html#Species.
Please note that while the FWC has published a consolidated list of state and federally listed
species in the past, we now only publish a list of species listed within the state of Florida. This
list will be maintained and available at our agency website: \tttp:l!www.mvfwc.com. Lists of
federally listed species can still be viewed at the USFWS and NOAA-NMFS websites mentioned
above. It is our intent by providing the list in this manner that we will be able to maintain a
current list that is more readily available to the public. I would like to thank the following
people who assisted in revising this list; Tom Logan, Jeff Gore, Paul Vincent, Paul Moler,
George Wallace, Jim Rodgers, Karl Miller, Ted Hoehn, Darrell Scovell, Gray Bass, Kelly
Donnelly, Elsa Haubold, Kipp Frohlich, Bill Brooks and the USFWS staff. Special appreciation
is expressed to Ms. Angela T. Williams, Ms. Christine Yannett and Ms. Kat Diersen for their
assistance with preparation of this document.
. Common and scienUfic names listed first ore as they appear in tbe FWC "Florida Wildlife Code Title
68A" (F.A.G). Common and/or scientific names following this and located within parentheses () contain
names as used by USFWS, or other commonly used Mme!.
J. Daniel Sullivan Jr.
Endangered Species Coordinator
Species Conservation Planning Section
Cover Photos by FWC Staff: Key Largo Woodrat, Burrowing Owls, Okaloosa Darter, Schaus'
swallowtail butterfly, Short-tailed Snake.
ii
APPEAPPENDIX B
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED,
THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN
STATUS
DESIGNATION FISH AMPHIBIANS REPTILES BIRDS MAMMALS INVERTEBRATES TOTAL
E 3 0 6 8 20 4 41
T 2 0 10 10 4 0 26
sse 10 5 8 18 6 4 51
TOTAL 15 5 24 36 30 8 118
APPEAPPENDIX B
OFFICIAL LISTS
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
FISH
Atlantic sturgeon Acipenser oxyrinchus sse (1)
(Gulf sturj(eon) (Acinenser oxvrinchus desotofl
shortnose sturgeon Aci/Jenser brevirostrum E
shoal bass MicroDterus cataractae SSC (l,2)
Suwannee bass Micronterus notius SSC (l)
rivulus Rivulus marmoratus sse (1)
(man01'oye riyulus)
Lake Eustis puplish CV/Jrinodon varieI!alUs hubbsi sse (1)
blackmouth shiner Notroois melanostomus E
bluenose shiner Pteronotropis welaka SSC (1,2)
saltmarsh topminnow Fundulus ienkinsi SSC (])
key silyerside Menidia conchorum T
crystal darter Crystal/aria asprel/a T
harleouin darter Etheostoma histrio sse (1)
okaloosa darter Etheostoma okalossae E
Southern tessellated darter Etheostoma olmstedi sse (I)
(tessellated iohnny darter) maculaticeps sse 6Y-
key blenny Starksia starcki
AMPHIBIANS
flatwoods salamander Ambvstoma ciDlrnlalUm sse
Georuia blind salamander Haideotriton wallacei sse (1,2)
pine barrens treefrol! Hvla andersonii sse (])
Florida bog frOg Rana okaloosae SSC (2)
gopher frog Rona ca/Jito sse (1 2)
REPTILES
American allil!ator Alligotor mississippiensis sse (1,3)
American crocodile Crocodvlus acutus E
key ringneck snake Diadoohis /Junc/alUs acricus T
Eastern indigo snake Drvmarchon corais couneri T
red rat snake Elaphe gut/ata SSC1(l)
Atlantic salt marsh water snake Nerodia clarkii taeniata T
(Atlantic salt marsh snake)
2
Common Name
scientificNa~PPEAPPENDIX B
Florida pine snake Pituophis melanoleueus SSC (2)
mUllilus
short-tailed snake Sti/osoma extenuatum T
Florida brown snake Storeria dekayi vieta T1
rim rock crowned snake T antilla oolitiea T
Florida ribbon snake Thamnophis sauritus sac/reni T1
bluetail mole skink Eumeees ell/"ellius lividus T
Florida Kev mole skink Eumeees ell/"ellius ell/"ellius sse (\)
sand skink NeoseDs revnoldsi T
gopher tortoise GODherus [JOlvvhemus sse (1,2,3)
Barbour's maD turtle GraDtemvs barbouri sse (1,2)
alliRator snapping turtle Maeroc/emvs temminekii SSC ())
striped mud turtle Kinosternon baurii E1
Suwannee cooter Pseudemys eoncinna sse (1,2)
suwanniensis
loggerhead seaturtle Caretta earetta T
(lolUlerhead sea turtle)
green seaturtle Chelonia mydas E
(green sea turtle)
leatherback seaturtle Dermoehelys eoriacea E
(Ieatherhack sea turtle)
hawksbill seaturtle Eretmoehelys imbrieata E
(hawksbill sea turtle)
Kemp's ridley seaturtle Lepidoehelys kempii E
(Kemp's ridlev sea turtle)
BIRDS
piping plover Charadrius melodus T
snowy plover Charadrius alexandrinus T
(Cuban snowy Dlover)
American ovstercatcher HaematoDus Dal/iatus sse (1 2)
brown pelican Peleeanus oeeidentalis sse 1)\
black skimmer RvnehoDs niller SSC (\)
least tern Sterna antillarum T
roseate tern Sterna dougalli T
(Sterna doullallii doullalliil
limpkin Aramus f!Uarauna sse I))
reddish egret Ell/"etta rufeseens SSC (1 4)
snoWY egret Ell/"ella thula SSC (J)
little blue heron Ewetta caerulea SSC (1,4)
tricolored heron Ell/"etta tricolor SSC (I 4)
3
Common Name
seientifieNa~PPEAPPENDIX B
white ibis Eudocimus albus sse (2)
Florida sandhill crane Grus canadensis oratensis T
whooping crane Grus americana sse (5)
wood stork Mvcteria americana E
roseate sooonbill Platalea aiaia SSC (J ,4)
burrowing owl Athene cunicularia sse (I)
(Florida burrowing own (Athene cunicularia tloridana)
crested caracara Caracara cheriway T
(Audubon's crested caracara) (Polvborus olancus auduboniil
oerel!rine falcon Falco perewinus E
Southeastern American kestrel Falco sparverius paulus T
bald eagle Haliaeetus leucoceohalus T
osprey Pandion haliaetus sse2 (j ,2)
snail kite Rostrhamus sociabilis E
(EverJ,lades snail kite) plumbeus
Florida scrub iav Aohelocoma coerulescens T
eape Sable seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus E
mirabilis
Florida grasshopper sparrow Ammodramus savannarum E
lIoridanus
Scott's seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (I)
oeninsulae
Wakulla seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (I)
iuncicolus
white-crowned oil!eon Columba leucoceohala T
Kirtland's warbler Dendroica kirtlandii E
Bachman's warbler Vermivora bachmanii E
ivorv-billed woodoecker Camoeohi/us orincioalis E
red-cockaded woodoecker Picoides borealis sse
Marian's marsh wren Cistothorus oalustris marianae ssem
Worthington's marsh wren Cistothorus oalustris I!riseus sse (1)
MAMMALS
Florida panther Puma concolor coryi E
(Puma r =Fe/isl concolor coro;)
Florida black bear Ursus americanus j10ridanus T3
Everlllades mink Mustela vison everlliadensis T
key deer Odocoi/eus virginianus E
elavium
4
APPEAPPENDIX B
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
Lower Keys marsh rabbit Sv/vila1!.Us pa/ustris hefneri E
Bill Cvnress fox squirrel Sciurus niJ!er avicennia T
Sherman's fox squirrel Sciurus niJ!er shermani sse 0,2)
Eastern chiomunk Tamias striatus SSC (1)
Sanibel Island rice rat Orvzomys pa/ustris sanibeli sse (\ ,2)
silver rice rat Oryzomys argentatus E
(rice rat, lower FL Kevs) (Orvzomvs pa/ustris nalator)
Key Largo woodrat Neotoma f/oridana smalli E
Key Largo Cotton Mouse Peromyscus gossypinus E
allaoatico/a
Choctawhatchee beach mouse Peromyscus polionolus E
alloohrvs
Southeastern beach mOuse Peromyscus polionotus T
nivelventris
Anastasia Island beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
Dhasma
St. Andrews beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
oeninsu/aris
Perdido Key beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
trissvlleosis
Florida mouse Podomvs floridanus sse (1)
Florida mastiff hat Eumops j!/aucinus floridanus E
gray bat Mvotis JQ'isescens E
Indiana bat Mvotis sodalis E
Florida saltmarsh vole Microtus pennsy/vanicus E
(Florida salt marsh vole) dukecampbelli
Sherman's short-tailed shrew Blarina car%nensis sse (2)
r =brevicauda 1 shermani
Homosassa shrew Sorex lonj!irostris eionis sse (2)
sei whale BalaenoPtera borealis E
fin whale Ba/aenopreraphysarus E
(finback whale)
North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena g/aclalis E
(right whale) (Balaena glacialis line/.
australis n
humpback whale Mevaolera novaeanJ!liae E
sperm whale Phvseter macroceohalus E
Caribbean monk seal Monachus tronicalis
Florida manatee Trichechus manatus /alirostris E
(West Indian manatee) (Trichechus manatus)
5
Common Name
scientificNa~PPEAPPENDIX B
INVERTEBRATES
CODAl _l;:
nillar coral Dendrol!V1'a evlindrus E
CRUSTACEANS
Panama eity crayfish Proeambarus eeonjinae sse (I)
(econfinacravfish)
sims sink crayfish Proeambarus erythrops sse (1)
(Santa Fe cave crayfish)
black creek crayfish Procambarus nietus sse (j)
INSECTS
Miami blue butterfly eyclargus [=Hermiargus] E
thomasi bethunebakeri
Schaus' swallowtail butterfly Heraclides aristodemus E
/Joneeanus
MOLLUSKS
Florida tree snail Li21JUS fasciatus sse !l)
Stock Island tree snail Orthalieus reses E
Orthalieus reses [not incl,
nesodrvas 1
6
APPEAPPENDIX B
KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATlUNS
List Abbreviations
FWC =
E=
T=
SSC=
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Endangered
Threatened
Species of Special Concern
Reasons for SSC listings prior to January 1,2001 are indicated by the number in parenthesis under the
following criteria:
(I) has a significant vulnerability to habitat modification, environmental alteration, human disturbance,
or human exploitation which, in the foreseeable future, may result in its becoming a threatened
species unless appropriate protective or management techniques are initiated or maintained;
(2) may already meet certain criteria for designation as a threatened species but for which conclusive data
are limited or lacking;
(3) may occupy such an unusually vital or essential ecological niche that should it decline significantly in
numbers or distribution other species would be adversely affected to a significant degree;
(4) has not sufficiently recovered from past population depletion, and
(5) occurs as a population eitller intentionally introduced or being experimentally managed to attain
specific objectives, and the species of special concern prohibitions in Rule 68A-27.002, F.A.C., shall
not apply to species so designated, provided that the intentional killing, attempting to kill, possession
or sale of such species is prohibited.
(FWC\
I Lower keys population only.
Monroe County population only.
Other than those found in Baker and Columbia Counties or in Apalachicola National Forest.
7
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
~';I"'. ,"". ..... ,.,,,,,
....01 .
... ~~ ;:::hrealened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENOIX B
I
Contact ECOS
Notes:
. This reporl shows the species listed in this state according to Ihe Federal Register
listing descriplion.
. This list does not include experimental populations and similarity of appearance
listings.
. This list includes species or populations under the sole jurisdiction of the National
Marine Fisheries Service.
. Click on Ihe highlighted scientific names below to view a Species Profile for each
listing.
Florida listed specie. (baaed on publhihed population datal --112 listing.
Status Spec/es/Llsllng Name
tHfIOTE: The"..n... lUItl.1s Usttd 2 timts undf/I
.tJinIII. Sf fife .dU,' IlIINt' Bsflcf Js. 56 AnImals 0
w1t1THlL
Animals - 57
T Bankclimber. purple (mussel) (E/llptold.us sloa/lanus)
E Bat, gray (MyoIlSgrisescens)
E Beelle, American burying (Nkrophorus americ8nus)
E Bullerfly, Schaus swallowtail (_Ides aris/odemus ponceanus)
T Caracara, Audubon'. crested FL pop. (PoI)II>orus phmcus audubon;,]
E Crocodile. American (Croc:O<l,ws acutus)
E Curlew, Eskimo {Numen;us boteaIis}
E Darter, Okalaasa (E/heos/ome oke/nosee)
E o.ar, key (OdocoReus vityln/enus clavium)
T Eagle, bald lower 48 State. (ila/ilIea/us leucocephalus)
T Jay, Florida scrub (Aph6locoma coerulescens)
E Kite, Everglade snail Fl pop. (Roslthamus sociabflis p'vmbeus)
E Manatee, West Indian (Trichechus manatus)
E Moccaslnshell, Gulf (Medionldus penlclllatus)
E Moccasinshell, Ochlockonee (Medionidus slmpsonJanus)
E Mouse, Anaslasia Island beach (Peromyscu6 polJonalus phasma)
E Mouse, Choclawhalchee beach (Peromyscus polionotus e/lophrys)
E Mouse, Key largo cotton (peromyscus gossyplnus aflapaticola)
http://ecos.fws.gov/tess''public/StateListing.do ?state= FL&status=listed
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX B
E Mouse, Perdido Key beach (peromyscus po//onoIus lrissyflepsis)
T Mouse, southeastern beach (Peromyscus poHonotus "iveiventris)
E Mouse, St. Andrew beach (Peromyscus poIionotus peninsularis)
E Panther. Florida (Puma (=FeJ.s) concolorocl}'!)
E Pigtoe, oval (Pleurobema pyrifonr>e)
T Plover, piping except Greal Lakes watershed (Charadrius melodus)
E Pocketbook, shinyrayed (LampsJlis suhengutala)
E Rabbit, Lower Keys marsh (SyivUagus paluslris hefnerf)
E Rice rat lowar Fl Keys (Ol)'Zomys paluslJis n8l8lOf)
T Salamander, flatwoods (Amby&oma clngulalum)
E Sawfish, smalllooth (Prislis pectlnala)
E Sea lurtle, green Fl, Mexico nesting pops. (Chelonia mydas)
T Sea turtle, green except where endangered (Chelonia mydas)
E Sea turtle. hawksbill (Eielmochelys imbt1c8la)
E Sea turtla. Kemp's rid ley (lB(lidoche/ys kempil)
E Sea turtle, leatherback (Oannochelys coriecea)
T Sea turtle, loggerhead (Camlla caflllla)
E Seal, Cerlbbean monk (MonachusllOpIca/is)
T Shrimp. Squirrel Chimney Cave (Po/aarnone"'s cumming~
T Skink, bluetail mole (Eumeces egregius INidus)
T Skink, sand (N80sepS reynolds~
T Slabshell, Chipola (Elliptio chipolsensls)
T Snail, Stock Island tree (Orthalicus reses (not me/. nesodryas))
T Snake, Atlantic sail marsh (Nerodia clarkiit8eniala)
T Snake, eastern indigo (Drymarchon oorals coupen)
E Sparrow, Cape Sable seaside (Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis)
E Sparrow, Florida grasshopper (Ammodramus $8vannarum florldanus)
E Stork. wood AL, FL, GA, SC (Myeleria americans)
T Sturgeon, gulf (Acipenser oxyrlnchus desotoi)
E Sturgeon, shortnose (Acipenser brev/rosuum)
T Tern, roseate Western Hemisphere except NE U.S. (Sterna dougallii dougallli)
bttp://ecos.fws.gov/tess "public/StateListing.do ?state=FL&status=listed
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX B
E Three.ridge, fat (mussel) (Ambleme neislotit)
E Vole, Florida salt marsh {Microtus pennsylvanicus duJ<ecampbelJij
E Whale, finback (Balaenoplera physalus)
E Whale, humpback (Megaplera novaeangliae)
E Whale, right (Balaena glacia/is (incl. ausfraNs))
E Wolf, gray lower 48 States, except MN and where XN; Mexico (Canis lupus)
E Woodpecker, red-cockaded (Picoides borealis)
E Woodrat, Key Largo (Neotoma floridana smalll)
Plants - 55
Status Species/Listing Name
E Aster, Florida goldon (Chrysopsis fforidana)
E Beargrass, Britton's {NaNna blfttoniana}
E Beauty. Harpers (HarpeTrlCSnis naval
E Bellflower, Brooksville (Campanula IObinslae)
T Birds-in-a-nesl, white (Macbridea 81ba)
E Blazingslar, scrub (Lialris ohRngerae)
T Bonamia, Florida (Bonamla grandillora)
T Buckwheat, scrub (EriOgOnum Iongifolium VaT. gnap/lalifolium)
T Bullerwort, Godfrey's (Pinguicula ionanfha)
E Cactus. Key lree (Pilosocereus robln;~
E Campion. fringed (Silene polypefala)
E Chaffseed, American (Schwa/bea americana)
E Cladonia, Florida perforale (ClarIoni. perlorofa)
E Fringe-tree, pygmy (Chlon.nthus pYl/m.eus)
T Gooseberry, Miccosukee (Rib8s echioslJum)
E Gourd, Okeechobee (Cucurbita okeechobeensis ssp. okeecnobeensis)
E Harebells, Avon Park (Crotalarla avonensls)
E Hypericum, highlands scrub (Hypericum cumuJico/a)
E Jacquemonlia, beach (Jacquemontia recllnata)
E Lead-plant. Crenulale (Amorpha erenulala)
http://ecos.fws.gov/tess-!,ublic/StateListing.do ?state=FL&status=listed
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX B
E Lupine, scrub (Lupinus al/dcrum)
E Meadowrue, Cooley's (Thallctrum cooleyi)
E Mllkpea, Small's (Golactle smollil)
E Mint, Garretrs (Dlcerandra chl/stmanin
E Mint, lakela's (Dicerandra immacul8ta)
E Mint, longs purred (Dicerandra comutlsslma)
E Mint, scrub (Dicerandra frutescens)
E Mustard, Car!e(s (Waroa carteri)
E Pawpaw, beautiful (Deerlngolhomnus pulchellus)
E Pawpaw, four-petal (Asim/na tetramera)
E Pawpaw, Rugel's (Deeringothamnus rugelil)
T Pigeon wings (CHlorta fragmns)
E Pinkroot, genlien (Splge/ia genl/ano/des)
E Plum, scrub (PI'l1IlUS genlculol.)
E Polygala, Lewton's (Po/nIala lew/onh)
E Polygala, liny (PoIWala smonil)
E Pond berry (Lindem mellssifo/is)
E Prickly-apple, fragrant (Ceraus eriophorus var. /ragmns)
E Rhododendron. Chapman (Rhododendron chapmanil)
E Rosemory, Apalachicola (Conl8dino g/obm)
E Rosemary. Etonia (Conradlna elonla)
E Rosemary. shari-leaved (Conradlna bmv/fo/ia)
E Sandlaco (Polygoneno myriophyl/a)
T Seagrass. Johnson'. (Ha/ophilo johnsonln
T Skullcap, Florida (Sculellario Rorideno)
E Snakeroot (Eryngium cuneifolium)
E Spurge, delloid (Chamaesyce delloideo ssp. deltoidea)
T Spurge, Garber's (Chamaesyce garbenl
T Spurge, lelephus (Euphorbie telephloldes)
E Tarreya, Florida (TotTeys taxlfo/ia)
E Wares, wide-leaf (Wares ampfexifolia)
h ltp://ecos. fws.gov /tess yublic/StateListing.do ?state=FL&status=listed
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX B
E Waler-willow, Cooley's (Justieia eooley~
T Whitlow-wort, papery (Paronychia ehartaeea)
E Wireweed (Po/ygonella bas;ramia)
E Z,ziphus, Florida (liz/phus eelata)
TESS I ECOS I USFWS Home I Privacy
http://ecos.fws.gov/tessyublic/StateListing.do ?state=FL&status=listed
E<ological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Pennitl AP PEN 0 I X C
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING >< Ra. Inc. L _
E-mail: R.amsey.Inc@embarqmai1.com
Office: 239.564.1660, Fax: 866.334.1496
2631 4~ SL NW, Naples. FL 34120
www.ramseyinc.oel
'.
LEP ~ Licensed Environmental Professional
CWB - Certified Wildlife Biolosist
eFEA - Certified Florida Environmental Assessor
REPA - Registered Environmental Property Assessor
CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional
OSHA S - Hazardous Materials Incident Commander
PROTECTED SPECIES WILDLIFE SURVEY REPORT-FALL 2007
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCIUNG SDP A AR 7633
DATE: 01.30.08
BY: Michael R. Ramsey
Ramsey Inc.
Owner: Fillmore LLC (Yahl Mulching)
County: Collier
City: Naples
Size: 28.8 acres
Legal Descriptions: PID 00341920409
2250 Washburn Ave; the SW '" or the SW '"
Section 31; Township 49, Range 27
INTRODUCTION
The applicant Yahl Mulching has applied to the Collier Co. Government, the South Florida Water Management District
(SFWMD) and US Army Corps of Engineers (USACOE) to expand ils existing operation of mulching and recycling of
vegelative material in Collier Co. (Figure 1). The following protected species/wildlife survey report was done to meet
the submission requirements for each agency.
This report evaluates if the above described project property is utilized by any protected species listed by the
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). A
protected species/wildlife evaluation for this property was conducled in 2000 and 2006, this report follows up on
those 2 previous reporls.
METHODS
First, the project properties were surveyed and a map prepared of the habitat types on site. Second, the official lists
of protected species were obtained from each of the agencies (FWC & FWS). The FWC list all species classified
as protected by the state of Florida government. The FWS list all species that are classified as protected in the state
of Florida by the United States government. Third, each species on each list was researched as to couoty of
occurrence and required habitat in the literature. Last, all species that were indicated as being found in Collier Co.
and having a habitat type thai occurred on the project properties were searched for by surveys on tlle project
properties.
RESULTS
Survev Dates. This property was initially evaluated for the presence of protected species in 2000. Collier Co.
Government Natural Resources Division concluded there was no issue with protected species on this site and issued
approval to move ahead with a site development plan in the Conditional Use Permit proceedings. The area was
resurveyed in 2006 for the presence of protected species for the SFWMD and USACOE. The SFWMD found no issues
with protected species and issued their permit #11.02649-P on 15 March 2007. The USACOE is still evaluating their
permil application at this time. The project properties were visited on: October 14 - December 30 in the year 2000;
and resurveyed on the dates: 09/15,09/23,09/30,10/05, 10/12, 11/05, 11/26, 12/09 and 12/17 in 2006. For this
evaluation the properties were visited on 09/23-24, 09/29, 10/06, 10/20, 10/28, 11/11 and 11/13 in 2007. Surveys were
done in the moming (AM) 2-3 hours after sunrise and in the evening (PM) 2-3 hours before sunset. Survey routes are
shown in Figure 2.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
PAlL 2007 PCOI.ccled Species Report
30 January 2008
Pagc2
APPENDIX C
Habitat. The Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS) was utilized to
produce the habitat maps for the projecl properties. The habitat or FLUCFCS maps are depicted in Figure
2 for the Yahl Mulching project. Table I below indicates the acres for each habitat type.
Table 1. FLUCFCS acres for the YahI Mulching and Recycling property.
ID# Acres FLUCCS #
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1l
12
13
2.6
3.2
0.5
1.6
7.0
0.8
1.1
0.3
4.7
3.4
2.4
0.5
0.7
III
152
624n43
621
624
624/8146
624
434
624
624n42
621
8145
8145
Habitat Tvoe
Single Family Residence
Timber Processing
PineiCypresslPalmlspoil piles
Cypress
Pine/CypresslPalm
PineiCypresslPalm impacted by road clearing
PineiCypresslPalm
Hardwood Conifer
Pine/CypresslPalm
PineiCypressIPalm impacted by borrow pit excavation
Cypress
GradedlDrained Road
GradedIDrained Road
The Yahl property has been impacted by road construction on the north, south and west sides of the property.
This construction has effectively cut off sheet flow across the property, except for unusually high rainfall events.
Impacted hydrology appears to be the cause of the pine trees being present with present in cypress transition areas
in the 624 habitats. It is also the reason for the heavy melaleuca infestation in the 624 areas to be preserved. This
area has been slowly drying out over time. In the site development plan the applicant will be impacting 6.37 acres
of wetlands at the northwest comer of the property (adjacent to the road, Figure 3) and preserve approximately
11.73 acres to the south of the operations area that will be rehydraled and enhanced (Figure 3). Rehydration is
anticipated to greatly improve the vegetative conditions and make it more attractive to wetland wildlife.
StatelFederal Protected Soecies Listed. The FWC list was published in November 2007 and lists 118 animals as
protected in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix A. Based on general habitat requirements, historic
distributions and actual sightillgs, the FWC lists 52 animal species that may occnrin Collier County. There are 51
species that are vertebrates and 1 invertebrate. The 52 species are listed in Figure 4.
The FWS list is updated daily on their website. The January 2008 list totals J 12 anirna1and plant species as protected
in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix B. Based on general habitat requirements, historic distributions and
actual sigbtings, the FWS lists 26 species (26 animals and no plants) thaI may occur in Collier County. Species for
Collier Co. are listed in Figure 4 also.
Site Survev Results. Figure 5 indicates the cumulative total of aU species observed over 10 survey events. Daily field
sheets are located in Appendix C. Overall, 18 species were noted, 15 bird species and 3 nuunmals. The most frequent
bird species observed was cattle egret with 85 observations and for mamma1s . gray squirrel with 8 observations.
Soecies Results.
Gopher Frog/Rana capito: Prefers dry sandy, upland habitats adjacent to wetland areas. This type habitat is not
present onsite. or adjacent properties and no individuals were observed on site. Changes in the project property
will have no effect on this species.
YahIMuJching
SOPA AR 1633
FAlL 2007 Protected Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 3
APPENDIX C
Cape Sahle seaside sparrow/Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis: Currently inhabits seasonally inundated freshwater
interior marshes within Everglades National Park and Big Cypress National Preserve in Monroe and Dade County. Last
documented in Collier Co. in 1979. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property.
Florida Grasshopper sparrow/Ammodramus savannarumjloridanus: Prefers large areas of frequently burned dry prairie
habitat, with patchy open areas sufficient for foraging. This habitat type is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the property. In addition, this species has not been observed since] 955 in Collier Co. Changes in the
project property will have no effect on this species.
Florida scrub jay/ Apheloeoma eoeruleseens: Prefers low growing scrub oak plants. This habitat is not present
onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in the project property will have no effect on
this species.
Limpkin/Aromus guarauna: Inhabits mangroves, freshwater marshes, swamps, springs and spring runs, and pond
and river margins. This habitat is not present onsile and no individuals were observed on tlle properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida burrowing owl/Athene cunieulariaj/oridana: Prefers habitats of high, sparsely vegetated, sandy ground.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Ivory-billed woodpecker/ Campephilus principalis: This species is considered to be extinct but is still listed.
Known to prefer swampy forests, especially large bottomland river swamps of coastal plain and Mississippi Delta
and cypress swamps of Florida. This habitat is present onsite, but no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on lhis species.
Cuban-/snowy plover, Charadrius alexandrinus: Prefers dry, sandy beaches, where they nest in shallow
depressions, usually near some vegetation or debris. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Piping plover/C/l(Jradrius melodus: Prefers open, sandy beaches and on tidal mudflats and
sandflats along tlle coasts. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in lhis property will have no effecl on this species.
Kirtland's warbler /Dendroiea kirtlandil: Nests in nearly homogeneous stands of usually 30 ha or more of dense
scrubby jack pine. Florida maybe a migration stop between Michigan and the Bahamas. Individuals may flay
straight through. This habitat is not present onsile and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes
in this property will have no effect on this species.
Little blue heron/Egretta eaerulea: Feeds in shallow freshwater, brackish, and saltwater habitats. Nestiog colonies
usually occur jn coastal areas, but prefers foraging in freshwater lakes, marshes, swamps, and streams. Nests in a
variety of woody vegetation types, including cypress, willow, maple, black mangrove, and cabbage palm. Usually
breeds in mixed-species colonies in flooded vegetation or on islands. Nesting habitat is present onsite, but no
other nesting of other wading bird species has been observed. No individuals or nests were observed on the
property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately
12 acres of forested wetlands in a preserve area. This improvemenl in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Reddish egreliEgretta rufeseens: Typically prefers coastal mangrove islands, or in Brazilian pepper on manmade
dredge spoil islands, near suitable foraging habitat. Generally forages in shallow water of variable salinity. Broad,
open, marine tidal flats and shorelines with little vegetation are ideal feeding areas. Also important are salt
evaporation pools aod lagoons, often located inside mangrove keys or just inside shoreline on mainland. This
Yahl Mulching
SOPA AR 7633
PAlL 2007 Proc:ected Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 4
APPENDIX C
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have no effect on this species.
Snowy egretlEgretta thula: Nests both inland and in coastal wetlands with nests placed in many types of woody
shrubs, especially mangroves and willows; usually over shallow waters. Almost all nesting is over shallow waters
or on islands that are separated from shoreline by extensive open water. Feeds in many types of permanently aod
seasonally flooded wetlands, streams, lakes, and swamps, and in manmade impoundments and ditches. Breeding
success is tied to water-level fluctuations. Preferred nesting habitat is not present onsite. There are no
permanently inundated areas on site. Seasonally flooded areas are very short in duration. No individuals or
nesting were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is
planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in
habitat conditions may encourage use.
Tricolored heron/Egretla tricolor. Most nesting colonies occur on mangrove islands or in willow thickets in fresh
water, but nesting sites include other woody thickets on islands or over standing water. Prefers coastal
environments. Feeds in a variety of pennanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, mangrove swamps, tidal
creeks, ditches, and edges of ponds and lakes. Preferred nesting and feeding habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is
planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in tlle preserve area. This improvemeut in
habitat conditions may encourage use.
White ibislEudocimus albus: Found in a wide variety of habitats, including freshwater and brackish marshes, salt
flats and salt marsh meadows, many types of forested wetlands, wet prairies, swales, seasonally inundated fields,
and man-made ditches. The forested wetland habitat is present onsite and targeted to be preserved and enhanced.
No individuals or nests were observed in the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this
species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This
improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Peregrine falcon/Falco peregrinus: The Peregrine Falcon frequents open areas like marshes, fields, swamps, and
tidal areas. Since its reintroduction into the eastern United States, however, the Peregrine Falcon has colonized
many urban areas hecause of increased nesting sites (and nesting ledges being erealed on buildings). This species
is considered to be recovered and is waiting for deli sting. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Southeastern American kestreVFalco sparverius paulus: Found in open pine habitats, woodland edges, prairies,
and pastures throughout much of Florida. Nest sites are tall dead trees or utility poles generally with an
unobstructed view of surroundings. Kestrels are not known to nest in Collier County. Most individuals are
migrants from the north. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have little to no effect on this species.
Florida sandhill crane/Grus canadensis pratensis: Habitat Prairies, freshwater marshes, and pasture lands.
A voids forests and deep marshes but uses transition zones and edges between these and prairies or paslure lands.
This habitat is not present onsi\e and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
American oystercatcherlHaematopus palliates: Habitat: Coastal waters. This habitat is not presenl onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Bald eaglelHaliaeerus leucacephalus: According to the FWC eagle website, only] nest (CO 015) is within 1 mile
of this project. A map of this nest location is presented in Figure 6. The location of this nest was field verified
and it is active. It is approximately 4,270 feet form tlle project. It is within Ihe South Belle Meade Boundary, but
it is in private ownership. FWC records indicate that it has been active since the year 2000. The Yahl Recycling
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
FAlL 2007 Protected Species Repor1
30 January 2008
PageS
APPENDIX C
project has been in operation prior to 2000. Highway 1-75 is also between the YahI project and the designated
eagles nest. The proposed project is not in the primary zone, but it is in the secondary zone. No individuals or
nests were observed on or utilizing the property. The distance of the nests from the project, coupled with the fact
that activity form I -75 has not presented any problems indicates that proposed changes in this property will have
little to no effect on this species. On a larger scale the FWS has started the process to delist tlle Bald Eagle.
Wood stork/Mycterla Americana: Nests colonially in a variety of inundated forested wetlands, inCluding cypress
strands and domes, mixed hardwood swamps, sloughs, and mangroves. Forages in 6-15 inches of surface water.
The preferred nesting habitat is present onsite, but the surface water does not gel very deep on the property during
the year due to the impacts of road building changing tlle hydrology. No individuals or nests were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately
12 acres of forested wetlands in tlle preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage Use.
Brown pelican/Pelecanus occldental/s: Habitat: Mainly coastal, feeding in shallow estuarine waters, and (less
often) far offshore. . This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Red-cockaded woodpecker! Picoldes boreal/s: Habitat: Inhabits open, mature pine woodlands that have a
diversity of grass, forb, and shrub species. Prefers mature slash pine trees that are generally larger than 12 inches
in diameter, a wide spacing of trees, no subcanopy and relatively dry conditions. The preferred habitat is not
present onsite. Nn individuals were observed on the property. All pine trees were inspected for nest cavities or
start holes and none were found. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Roseate spoonbilVPlaralea ajaja (Ajala ajaja); Habitat: Primarily nests in mixed-species colonies on coastal
mangrove islands or in Brazilian pepper on man-made dredge spoil islands near suitable foraging habitat. Does
feed in forested wetland habitats with SlOW moving water. Although forested wetland type habitat present,
hydrology has been so impacted it is very low quality. No individuals or indications of this species were observed
on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate
approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may
encollfage use.
Crested caracaralPolyborus plancus audubonii (Caracara cheriway): Open country, including dry prairie and
pasture lands with cabbage palm, cabbage palmllive oak hammocks, and shallow ponds and sloughs. Preferred
nest trees are cabbage palms, followed by live oaks. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Everglades snail kite/Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus: Habitat: Large open freshwater marshes and lakes with
shallow water. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Black skirnmer/Rynchops niger: Habitat: Coastal waters, inclUding beaches, bays, estuaries, sandbars, tidal creeks
(foraging), and also inland waters of large lakes, phosphate pits, and flooded agricultural fields. This habitat is not
present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on
this species.
LeaslternlSterna antillarum: Habitat: Coastal areas throughout Florida, including beaches, lagoons, bays and
estuaries. Increasingly use artificial nesting sites, including gravel rooftops, dredge spoil islands or other dredged
material deposits, construction sites, causeways, and miniog lands. This habilat is not presenl onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Roseate tern/Sterna dougalli (Sterna dougalli/ dougallii): Habitat: Nest sites include bare limestone, shell-sand
beaches, newly deposited rock and marl fill, dredge material, and heaps of broken coral deposited by storms. This
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
FAlL 2007 Protected Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 6
APPENDIX C
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on tlle properties. Changes in this property will
have no effect on this species.
Bachman's warbler/Vennivora bachmanii: Historic records indicate the Bachman's warbler nested in low, wet
forested areas containing variable amounts of water, but usually witll some water that was permanent. This
species is considered extinct in Florida. This preferred habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Smalltooth sawfish/Pristis pectinata: Habitat: Shallow coastal, estuarine, and fresh waters; often in brackish
water near river mouths and large embayments, in deeper holes on bottoms of mud or muddy sand. This habitat is
not present onsite and no individuals w...e observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
Rivulus (mangrove rivulus)/Rivulus mannoratus: Habitat: coastal, appears to prefer red mangrove (Rhizophora
mangle). This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
properly will have no effect on this species.
Sei whale/Balaenoptera borealis: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Generally, in deep water; along edge of continental
shelf and in open ocean. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effeCI on tllis species.
Fin whale (finback whale)/Balaenoptera physalus: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Usually found in largest numbers
25 miles or more from shore. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have nn effect on this species
North Atlantic right whale/Eubalaena glacialis (BaloeM glacialis [incl. australis)): Habitat: Inhabits near shore
and offshore waters. Mainly coastal in the North Atlantic. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on tbe properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
Florida mastiff baVEumops glaucinus floridanus: Habitat: Roosts in palms and hollow trees and in buildings.
Forages high in air over natural as well as human-altered landscapes. Minimal preferred roosting habitat is
present onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties or surrounding areas duriug surveys. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Humpback whale/Megaptera novaeangliae: Habilat: Pelagic and coaslal waters, sometimes frequenting inshore
areas such as bays. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Caribbean monk seaVMonachus tropicalis: Habitat: Marine areas. Shallow lagoons and reefs, sandy beaches, and
permanent islets or beaches above high tide. Mainly west coast of Florida and Caribbean. This habitat is not
present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in tllis property will have no effect on
this species.
Everglades minklMustelo vison evergladensis: Habitat: A variety of wetland communities, including salt marsh,
freshwater marsh, cypress swamp, and hardwood swamp. There is very litlle of the preferred habitat is onsite.
However, no individuals were observed or, indicators oftlle presence was noted on the property. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands
in the preserve area. This improvemenl in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Sperm whale/Physeter macrocephall/s: Habitat: Pelagic, prefers deep water, sometimes around islands or in
shallow shelf waters. This habitat is not present onsile and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
PALL 2007 Prolectcd Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 7
APPENDIX C
Florida panther/Puma (Felis) conca/or coryi: Habitat: Requires extensive blocks of mostly forested communities.
The FWC panther telemetry database form 1981-2007 indicates no utilization of this property (Figure 7). The
forested habitat panthers utilize is present onsite. No individuals or indicators were observed on the property.
Planned changes in this property will have no effect on this species. However, this property is considered to be in
the area of the Primary Panther Habitat Zones articulated by FWS (Figure 8). This issue is currently being
evaluated by USACOE and FWS for proposed mitigation. FWS has indicaled that this area has little value to the
panther since it is on the edge of the Primary Habitat Zone and bordered by 1-75. Proposed cbanges to the
property are expected to bave little to DO effect on this species.
Big Cypress fox squirrellSciu1'U.\' niger avieennia; Habitat: Sandhills (high pine), pine tlatwoods, and pastures and
other open, ruderal habitats with scaUered pines and oaks. Depends on a variety of oak trees for seasonal food and
nest material. Longleaf pine cones and seeds are important foods. This habitat type is present onsite, but very few
oak trees. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this
species. Creation of the preserve area may encourage utilization.
FloridalWest Indian manateelTrieheehus manalus laliroslris (Trieheehus manalus): Habitat: Coastal waters, bays,
rivers, and (occasionally) lakes. Requires Warm-water refugia such as springs or cooling effluent during cold
weather. Sheltered coves are important for feeding, resting, and calving. This habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida black bear/Vrsus amerieanusflaridanus: Habitat: A wide variety offorested communities is needed to
support the varied seasonal diet of black bears. Forested wetlands are particularly important for diurnal cover.
This habitat is present onsite. However this area is bordered on the south by 1-75 which greatly delers access. No
individuals or indices were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this
species. Creation of the preserve area may encourage utilizatioo, but is not expected to.
American alligator/AlIigalor mississippiensis: Habitat Most permanent bodies of fresh water, including marshes,
swamps, lakes, aod rivers. Occasionally wanders into brackish and salt water but rarely remains there. Protected
classification is primarily due to similarity of appearance with the American Crocodile. This Species is
considered recovered in Florida. Habitat is not presenl onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Loggerhead seaturtlelCarella carella: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on tllis species.
Green sealUrtlel/Che/ania mydas: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have no effect on this species.
\
American crocodilel/Crocodylus oculus: Habitat: Coastal estuarine marshes, tidal swamps, and creeks along
edges of mainland and islands. Usually associated witll mangroves. Nests on beaches, stream banks, and levees.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Leatherback seaturtlelDermochelys cariacea: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic walers; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Eastern indigo snakellDrymarchon corais couperi: Habitat: Broad range of habitats, from scrub and sandhill to
wet prairies and mangrove swamps. In northern part of range, often winters in gopher tortoise burrows in sandy
Yahl Mulching
SOPA AR 7633
FAll.. 2007 Prolectr.rl Species Rt:port
30 January 2008
Pagt:8
APPENDIX C
uplands but forages in more hydric habitats. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed
on the property. Also, no gopher tortoise burrows were discovered. Changes in this property will have no effect
on this species. It is expected that the planned rehydration of this area will furtller discourage possible utilization.
Hawksbill seaturtle//Eretmochelys imbricata: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Gopher tortoise/Gopherus polyphemus: Habitat: Typically found in dry upland habitats, including sandhills,
scrub, xeric oak hammock, and dry pine flatwoods; also commonly uses disturbed habitats such as pastures. old
fields, and road shoulders. Typical habitat not present onsite. No burrows or individuals observed on site.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is expected that the planned rehydration of this area
will further discourage possible utilization
Kemp's ridley seaturtleJ/Lepidochely.1 kempii: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This hahitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on tllis species.
florida tree snaiUlLiguusfasciatus: Habilat: Tropical hardwood hammock (rockland hammock). This species
prefers smooth-barked trees. This habitat is not present onsite and nO individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
CONCLUSIONS
The majority of habitat on site is 624 pine, cypress, palm. This habitat type appears to be the result of a hydrology
impacts over a long period of time, which dried the area out and allowed slash pine to invade in cypress transition
areas in the dry years. There was no indication of utilization of the 6.37 acres of 624 to be cleared by protected
species. The approximate 11.73 acres that will be preserved and to be rehydrated has a great potential to improve
the conditions of the area and increase wildlife utilization. Creation of the preservation area also insures that there
will be a connection to the 1-75 drainage for "community flow way"to the north of this project. In addition,the
preserve area will be protected by a permanent conservation easement with tlle SFWMD. Overall, changes in this
property will have little to no effect on protected species detected. Implementation of the preserve area,
enhancement and rehydration of it will increase wildlife utilization and habitat quality on the property, especially
for wetland oriented species; and provide a permanent flow way for the natural flow of water form the north.
YahlMulctung
SDPA AR 7633
FAU. 2007 Protected. Species RepOlt
30 January 2008
Page 9
APPENDIX C
REFERENCES
Ashton, R. E., Jr., and P. S. Ashton. 1988.. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Aorida, part 3: The amphibians.
Windward Publ., Inc., Miami, Aorida.
-. 1988b. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Aorida, part 1: The snakes, 2nd ed. Windward Publ., Inc.,
Miami, Aorida.
-' 1991. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Aorida, part 2: Lizards, turtles & crocodilians, 2nd ed. Windward
PubL, Inc., Miami, Aorida.
Barbour, D. B., and S. R. Humphrey. 1982. Status and habitat of the Key Largo woodrat and COlTon mouse (Neotoma
floridana smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola). J Mammal. 63:144-148.
Barnwell, M. E., P. A. Meylan, and T. Walsh. 1997. The spotted turtle (Clemmys guttata) in central Aorida. Chelonian
Cons. BioI. 2:405-408.
Bartlett, R. D., and P. P. Bartlett. 1999. A field guide to Florida reptiles and amphibians. GuIfPubl. Co., Houston,
Texas.
Berner, L, and M. L Pescador. 1988. The mayflies of Aorida. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Birkenholz, D. E. 1963. A study of the life history and ecology of the round-tailed muskrat (Neofiber alIeni). Ecolog.
Monogr.33:225-280.
Bortone, S. A. 1989. Notropis melanostomus, a new species of cyprinid fish from Ibe Blackwater. Yellow River drainage
of northwest Aorida. Copeia 3:737-74I.story, habitat assessment, and systematics of Ibe blackmoulb shiner
(Notropis sp.), Blackwater
River drainage. Final Rep. Nongame Wild!. Prog., Aorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Bouchard, R. W. 1978. Taxonomy, ecology and phylogeny oflbe subgenus Depressicambarus, wilb the description of a
new species from Aorida and redescriptions of Cambarus graysoni, Cambarus latimanus, and Carnbarus slriatus
(Decapoda: Cambaridae). Bull. Alabama Mus. Nal Hist. 3:27-60.
Bowen, P. J. 2000. Demographic, distribution, and metapopulation analyses of the burrowing owl (Albene cunicularia)
in Aorida. M.s. thesis, Univ. Central Aorida, Orlando.
Brady, J. T., T. H. Kunz, M. D. Tuttle, and D. E. Wilson. 1982. Gray bat recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Denver,
Colorado.
Brim Box, J, and J D. Williams. 2000. Unionid mollusks of the Apa1achicola Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia
Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 21:1-143.
Brody, R. W. ] 990. Status of habitat and populations of Procarnbarus pictus in the North Fork of Black Creek, Clay
County, Florida. St Johns River Water Management District. Palatka, Aorida.
Brown, L N. 1997. A guide to the mammals of the southeastern United States. Univ. Tennessee Press, Knoxville.
Brown, W. S. 1993. Biology, status, and management of the timber rattlesnake (Crotalus horridus): a guide for
conservation. Soc. Stud. Amphib. Rept. Herp. Circ. 22.
Carle, F. L, and M. 1. May. 1987. Gornphus (pbanogomphus) weslfalli spec. novo from the Gulf coast of Aorida
(Anisoptera: Gomphidae). Odonatologica 16:67- 75.
Chace, F. A., Jr. 1954. Two subterranean shrimps (Decapoda: Caridea) from Florida and the West Indies, with a revised
key to the American species. J Washinglon Acad. Sci. 44:318-324.
Chafin, 1. 2000. Field guide to the rare plants of Aorida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Chase, C. A, and J A. Gore. 1989. Snowy plover breeding distribution. Unpubl. final rept., Aorida Fish and
Wildl.Conserv. Comrn., Tallahassee.
Choate, P. M. 1984. A new species of Cicindela Linnaeus (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae) from Aorida, and elevation of C.
abdominalis scabrosa Schaupp to species level. Emomol. News 95:73-82.
Conant, R., and J. T. Collins. 1991. A field guide to reptiles aod amphibians: eastern and central North America, 3rd ed.
Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Cox, J., D. Inkley, and R. Kautz. 1987. Ecology and babitat protection needs of gopher tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus)
populations found on lands slated for large-scale development in Aorida. Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep.
no. 4, Aorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comrn., Tallahassee.
Crance, J. H. 1986. Habitat suitability index models and instrearn flow suitability curves: shortnose sturgeon. U. S. Fish
Wildl. Servo BioI. Rep. 82(10.129).
Deitz, D. C., and T. C. Hines. 1980. Alligator nesting in north-central Aorida. Copeia 1980:249.258.
Delany, M. P., and C. L Abercrombie. 1986. American alligator food habits in north-central Aorida. J. Wildl. Manag.
50:348-353.
Yahl Mulching
SOPA AR 1633
FAll 2007 Proteclcd Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 10
APPENDIX C
Delany, M. F., P.B. Walsh, B. Pranty, and D.W. Perkins. 1999. A previously unknown population of Florida
grasshopper sparrow on Avon Park Air Force Range. Florida Field Nal. 27(2):52-56.
Deyrup, M., and R. Franz (cds.). 1994. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. IV: Invertebrates. Univ. Press of
Florida, Gainesville.
Dodd, C. K., Jr. 1988. Synopsis of the biological data on the loggerhead sea turtle Carella caretta (Linnaeus 1758). U.S.
Fish WildL Servo BioL Rep.88(14).
Duggins, C. F., Jr., A. A. Karlin, K. Relyea, and R. W. Yerger. 1986. Systematics of the key silverside, Menidia
conchorum, with comments on other Menidia species (Pisces: Atherinidae). Tulane Stud. ZooL Bot. 25(2):133-
150.
Dunkle, S. W. 1989. Dragonflies of the Florida Peninsula, Bennuda and the Bahamas. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville,
Florida.
_.2000. Dragonflies through binoculars: A field guide to the dragonflies of North America Oxford Univ. Press,
New York.
Dunn, J. 1999. National Geographic Society field guide to the birds of North America 3rd ed. National Geographic
Soc., Washington, D.C.
Emmel, T. c., and M. C. Minno. 1988. Habitat requirements and status of the endemic Schaus swallowtail in the Florida
Keys. Fmal report, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Enge, K. M., M. M. Bentzien, and F. Percival. 1986. Florida scrub lizard status survey. Tech. Repl. No. 26 to U.S. Fish
WildL Serv., Jacksonville End. Sp. Office, Florida.
Ernst, C. H., and R. W. Barbour. 1989. Snakes of eastern North America. George Mason Univ. Press, Fairfax, Virginia.
Ernst, C. H., J. E. Lovich, and R. W. Barbour. 1994. Turtles of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Inst Press,
Washington, D.C.
Ewert, M. A., and D. R. Jackson. 1994. Nesting ecology of the alligator snapping turtle (Macroclemys temminckii)
along the lower Apalachicola River, Florida. Final Rep. NG89-020, Nongame Wildlife Prog. Florida Game and
Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Fitzpatrick, J. W., G. E. Woolfenden, and M. T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related habitat requirements
of the Florida scrub jay (Aphelocoma coeruJescens coerulescens). Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 8,
Florida Game and Fresh Water Fisb Cornm., Tallahassee.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003. Management Plan Red-Cockaded Woodpecker Picoides
borealis. Tallabassee, Fl. 78 pp.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003, October 8. Florida's Waterbird Colony Locator.
http://www.myfwc.comlwaders.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2006. Eagle nest locator. http://wld.fwc.state.fl.usleagle/eaglenests.
Florida Natural Areas Inventory. 1990. Guide to the natural communities of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory
and Florida Depl. Natural Resources, Tallahassee.
Franz, R. 1986. The Florida gopher frog and the Florida pine snake as burrow associates of the gopher tortoise in
northern Florida. Pp. 16-20 in D. R. Jackson and R. J. Bryant (cds.). The gopher toooise and its community.
Proc. 5 th Ann. Mtg. Gopber Tortoise Council, Gainesville, Florida.
Franz, R, and L. M. Franz. 1979. Distribution, habitat preference and status of populations of the Black Creek crayfish,
Procambarus (Ortmannicus) pictus (Decapoda: Carnbaridae). Florida ScL 42:13-17.
Franz, R, and L. L. Smith. 1999. Distribution and status of the striped newt and Florida gopher frog in peninsular
Florida. Final Rep. Florida Fish and Wtldl. Cons. Comm., Tallahassee.
Gaby, R., M. P. McMahon, F. J. Mazzotti, W. N. Gillies, and J. R. Wilcox. 1985. Ecology and status of a population of
Crocodylus acutus (Reptilia: Crocodilidae) at a power plant site in Florida. J. HerpetoL 19:189-198.
Georgia Department of Natural Resources. 1999. Protected animals of Georgia. Nongame - Endangered Wildlife
Program, Wildlife Res. Div., Georgia Depl. Nal. Res., Social Circlc.
Gilbert, C. R. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. 4: Fishes. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
_< ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. ll: Fishes. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Glassberg, J., M. C. Minno, and J. V. Calhoun. 2000. Butterflies through binoculars: a field, finding, and gardening
guide to butterflies in Florida. Oxford Univ. Press, New York.
Gordon, M. E., and W. R. Hoeh. 1993. Anodonta heardi.a new species of freshwater mussel (Bivalvia:Unionidae) from
the Apalachicola River system of the southeastern United Stales. Walkerana 7:265-273.
Gore, J. A., and M. 1. Kinnison. 1991. Hatching success in roof and ground colonies of least terns. The Condor 93:759-
762.
Yalll Mulcrong
SOPA AR 7633
FALl. 2007 Protecled Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 1l
APPENDIX C
Guillory, V. 1979. Lake Eustis pupfish investigations. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission 1977.1979 Fma!
Report: Study l-N. Tallahassee.
Guillory, V., and W. E. Johnson. 1986. Habitat, conservation status, and wogeography of the cyprinodont fish,
Cyprinodon variegatus hnbbsi (Carr). The Southwestern Nat. 31(1):95.100.
Hall, E. R. 1981. Mammals ofNortb America. 2 od ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Harvey, M. J. 1992. Bats ofthe eastern United States. Arkansas Game and Fish Comm., Uttle Rock.
Hersh, SL 1981. Ecology of the Key Largo woodrat (Neostoma floridana smalli). J. Mammal. 62:201-206.
Hipes, D., D. R. Jackson, K. NeSmith, D. Printiss and K. Brandt. 200]. Field guide to the rare animals of Florida.
Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Hirth, H. F. 1971. Synopsis of the biological data on the green turtle Chelonia mydas (Linnaeus) 1758. FAO Fish.
Synopsis 85.
Hobbs, H. H., Jr. 1942. The crayfishes of Florida. Unlv. Florida Publ., Bioi. Sci. Ser. 3(2):1-179.
Hoehn, T. S. 1998. Rare and imperiled fish species of Florida: a watershed perspective. Office Envir. Serv., Florida
Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Hovis, J. A., and M. S. Robson. 1989. Breeding status and distribution of the least tern in the Florida Keys. Florida Field
Nat. 17(3):61-66.
Humphrey, S. R. (ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. I: Mammals. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville
Humphrey, S. R. 1988. Density estimates of the endangered Key Largo woodral and colton mouse (Neotoma floridana
smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus aUapaticola) using the nested-grid approach. J. Mammal. 69(3):524-531.
Humphrey, S. R., and H. W. Setzer. 1989. Geographic variation and taxonomic revision of mink (Mustela vison) in
Florida. J. Mammal. 17:382.392.
Hurst, H. N., G. Bass, and C. Hubbs. 1975. The biology of the Guadalupe, Suwannee, and redeye basses. pp. 47-53 in
R. H Stroud and H. Clepper (eds.).
Black bass biology and management. Sport Fishing Institute,Washington, D.C Jackson, D. R., and R. Franz. 1999.
Survey for the fire.back crayfish in the Apalachicola ravine system, northern Florida. Final report to The Nature
Conservancy. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Jackson, D. R., and E. G. Milstrey. 1989. The fauna of gopher tortoise burrows. Pp. 86-98 in J. E. Diemer, D. R.
Jackson, J. 1. Landers, J. N. Layne, and D. A. Wood, eds. Gopher Tortoise Relocation Symposium
Proceedings. Nongame Wildl. Program Tech. Rep. no. 5, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Corom.,
Tallahassee.
Jackson, D. R, and R. N. Walker. 1997. Reproduction in the Suwannee cooter, Pseudemys cond... suwanniensis.
BulL Florida Mus, Nat. Hist. 41:69.167.
Jackson, J. F. 1973. Distribution and population phenetics of the Florida scrub lizard, Sceloporus woodi. Copeia
1973:746-761.
Jackson, J. F., and S. R. Telford. 1974. Reproductive ecology of the Florida scrub lizard, Sceloporus woodi. Copeia
1974:689-694.
James, F. C. 1991. Signs of trouble in the largeslremaining population ofred-cockaded woodpeckers. Auk 108:419-
423.
Johnson, S. A. 2001. Autecology of the striped newt (Notophthalmus perstriatus): life-history, upland-habitat use,
paedomorphosis, and conservation genetics. Ph.D. diss., Univ. Florida, Gainesville.
Kale, H W" n. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. 2. Birds. Univ. Presses of Florida. Gainesville.
Kale, H. W., IL, B. Pranty, B. Stith, and W. Biggs. 1992. An atlas of Florida's breeding birds. Final Rep.
Nongame Wildlife Prog., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Keppner, E. J., and 1. A. Keppner. 2000. A preliminary search for the Panama City crayfish, Procarnbarus
(Leconticambarus) econfmae, Hobbs, 1942, in Bay County, Florida. Report to U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Panama
City, Florida.
Knisley, C. B., and J. M. Hill. 1994. Studies of the Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: distribution,
abundance, habitat characteristics and biology. Report to U.s. Fish WildL Serv., Jacksonville, Florida.
_' 1996. The Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: habitat requirements, remaining range, life
history, and management. Fmal Rep. Florida Nongame Wildlife Prog. NG9l-Ol2, Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Conon., Tallahassee.
Kulhavey, D. 1., R. G. Hooper, and R. Costa (eds.). 1995. Red-cockaded woodpecker: recovery, ecology, and
management. Center for Applied Studies in Forests, College of Forestry, Stephen F. Austin State Univ.,
Nacogdoches, Texas.
Yahl MulchiD&
SDPA AR 7633
PAlL 2007 Protected Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 12
APPENDIX C
Kushlan, J. A. 1974. Observations on the role of the American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) in the southern
Florida wetlands. Copeia 1974:993-996.
_, and P. J. Mazzotti. 1989. Population biology of the American crocodile. J. Herpetol. 23:7-21.
Lazell, J. D., Jr. 1989. Wildlife of the Florida Keys: a natural history. Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Layne, 1. N. 1990. The Florida mouse. pp. 1-21 in C. K. Dodd, Jr., R. E. Ashton, Jr., R. Franz, and E. Wester (cds.).
Burrow Associates of the Gopher Tortoise. Proc. 8 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council. Florida Mus. NaL
HiSL, Gainesville.
Loftin, R. W. 1992. Use of nest boxes by the Florida kestrel. Florida field Nat 20(3):57-64.
McMillian, M. 2001. Florida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomination form -Lake Istokpoga, Audubon of Florida,
Tampa Bay Sanctuaries.
McNair, D. B., and J. A. Gore. 1999. Recent breeding status of royal and sandwich terns in northwest Florida. Florida
Field Nat. 27(3):117-120.
Maehr, D. S. 1987. Florida panther movements, social organization, and habitat utilization. E-I-1I annual performance
report. Florida Fish and WildL Cons. Corum., Tallahassee.
Martin, W. H., and D. B. Means. 1998. Distribution and habitat relationships of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake
(Crotalus adamanteus). Herpetological Nal. Hist. 7:9-34.
Means, D. B. 1975. Competitive exclusion along a habitat gradient between two species of salamanders (Desmognathus)
in westem Florida. J. Biogeog. 2:253- 263.
Means, D. B., and A A. Karlan. 1989. A new species of Desmognathus from the eastern Gulf Coastal Plain.
Herpetologica 45:37-46.
Means, D. B., and C. J. Longden. 1970. Observations on the occurrence of Desmognathus monticola in Florida.
Herpetologica 26:396-399.
_' 1976. Aspects of the biology and zoogeography of the pine barrens treefrog, Hyla andersonii, in northern
Florida. Herpetologica 32: 117-130.
Means, D. B., and P. E. Moler. 1979. The pine barrens treefrog: ftre, seepage bogs, and managemeot implications. pp.
77-83 in R. R. Odom and L. Landers (eds.). Proc. rare and endangered wildlife symposium. Georgia Dept. Nal.
Res., Game and Fish Div. Tech. Bull. WlA.
Meylan, A. B. 1999. Status of the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region. Chelonian Cons.
BioI. 3:177-184.
_' and M. Donnelly. 1999. Status justification for listing the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) as Critically
Endangered on the 1996 IUCN Red ust of Threatened Animals. Chelonian Cons. BioI. 3:200-224.
Menee, M. F., P. E. O'Neil, and 1. M. Pierson. 1996. Fishes of Alabama and the Mobile Basin. Oxmoor House, Inc.,
Birmingham, Alabama.
Minno, M. c., and D. Pierce. 1999. Florida bunerfly gardening: A complete guide to attracting, identifying, and
enjoying bunerflies of the lower south. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Mitchell, J. C. 1977. Geographic variation of Elaphe guttata (Reptilia: Serpentes) in the Atlantic coastal plain. Copeia
1977:33-41.
Moler, P. E. 1981. Notes on Hyla andersonii in Florida and Alabama. 1. Herpelol. 15:441-444.
_' 1985. A new species of frog (Ranidae: Rana) from northweslem Florida. Copeia 1985:379.383.
_(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. ill: Amphibians and reptiles. Univ. Press of Florida,
Gainesville.
_' 1996. Alligator snapping turtle: distribution and relative abuodance. Final report 7544. Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Mount, R. H. 1975. The reptiles and amphibians of Alabama. Auburn Univ. Agric. Exp. Station, Auburn, Alabama.
Myers, R. L., and J. J. Ewel (eds.) 1990. Ecosystems of Florida. Univ. Central Florida Press, Orlando.
NatureServe. 2006. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 5.0. NatureServe,
Arlington, Virginia. http://www.natureserve.orglexplorer.
Neill, W. T. 1971. The last of the roling reptiles: alligators, crocodiles, and their kin. Columbia Univ. Press, New York.
Page, L. M., and B. M. BUrr. 1998. A fteld guide to freshwater fishes: North America north of Mexico, 2nd ed.
Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Paul, R. T. 1991. Status report - Egrena rufescens (Gmelin) reddish egret. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Houston, Texas.
_, and A. F. Schnapf. 2000. Floridalmportant Bird Areas Program, site nomina-tion form - Passage Key National
Wildlife Refuge, Audubon of Florida, Tampa Bay Sanctuaries.
pennak, R. W. 1978. Fresh-water invertebrates of the United States. 2nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Yahl MulcbiDE
SDPA AR 7633
FAlL 2007 Protected Species Report
30 January 2008
Page 13
APPENDIX C
Peterson, R.T. 1998. Peterson field guide to eastern birds. 4th cd. Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Petranka, J. W.1998. Salamanders of the United States and Canada. Srnithsonian lnst Press, Washington, D.C.
Pilsbry, H. A. 1946. Land Mollusca of Norlh America, VoL 2, part 1. Monograph of Ibe Academy of Natural Sciences,
Philadelphia.
Pimm. S. (ed.). 2000. The 2000 Cape Sable sparrow annual repon. Accessed 2001 May 8.
Poole, A., and F. Gill (cds.). 1992-2000. The birds of Norlh America. The Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia,
and The American Ornithologists' Union, Washington, D.C.
Post, W., and J. S. Greenlaw. 2000. The present and future of the Cape Sable seaside sparrow. Florida Field Nal
28(3):93-110.
Pranty, B. 1996. A birder's guide to Florida. American Birding Association, Inc., Colorado Springs, Colorado.
Printiss, D. J., and D. L. Hipes. 1999. Rare amphibian and reptile survey of Eglin Air Force Base, Florida. Final report
to U.S. Dept of Defense. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Pritchard, P. C. H. 1989. The alligator snapping turtle: biology and conservation. Milwaukee Publ. Mus., Milwaukee,
Wisconsin.
Quay, T. L.. J. B. Funderburg, Jr., D. S. Lee, E. F. Potter, and C. S. Robbins (eds.). 1983. The seaside sparrow, its
biology and management. Dec. Papers, Norlh arolina BioI. Surv. Norlh Carolina State Mus. Nat. Hist., Raleigh.
Relyea, K., and B. Sutton. 1975. A new troglobitic crayfish of the genus Procambarus from Florida. (Decapoda:
Astacidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot 19(1-2):8-16.
Rice, D. W. 1957. Life history and ecology of Myotis aUSlroriparius in Florida. J. Mammal. 38: 15-32.
Robbins, C. S., B. Bruun, and H. S. Zim. 2001. Birds ofNorlh America: a guide to field identification. St. Martin's
Press, New York.
Rodgers, J. A, and H. T. Smith. 1995. Set-back distances to protect nesting bird colonies from human disturbance in
Florida. Conserv. BioI. 9:89-99.
Rodgers, J. A, Jr., H. W. Kale n, and H. T. Smith (eds.). 1996. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. V: Birds.
Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Robertson, W. B., Jr., and G. E. Woolfenden. 1992. Florida bird species: an annotated list. Florida Ornithol. Soc. Spec.
Pub. no. 6: ix + 260.
Roosenburg, W. M. 2000. Impact of a bycatch reduction device on diamondback terrapin and blue crab capture in crab
pots. Bcol. Applic. 10:882-889.
Ross, J. P., S. Beavers, D. Mundell, and M. Airth-Kindree. 1989. The status of Kemp's ridley. Center Marine Conserv.,
WaslUngton, D.C.
Runde, D., 1. Gore, J. Hovis, M. Robson, and P. Southall. 1991. Florida atlas of breeding sites for herons and their
allies: update 1986 - 1989. Nongame Wildlife Program Tech. Rep. no. 10. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm., Tallahassee.
SemlilSch, R D. 1983. Structure and dynamics of two breeding populations of the eastern tiger salamander, Ambystoma
tigrinum. Copeia 1983:608-616.
Shealy, R. M. 1976. The natural history of the Alabama map turtle, Graptemys pulchra Baur, in Alabama. Bull. Florida
State Mus., BioI. Sci. 21:47-11.
Shriver, G. W., P. D. Vickery, and S. A Hedges. 1996. Effects of summer burns on Florida grasshopper sparrows.
Florida Field Nat. 24(3):68-73.
Sibley, D. A 2000. The Sibley guide to birds. Alfred A Knopf, New York.
SpotHa, J. R., A. E. Dunham, A J. Leslie, A. C. Steyermark, P. T. Plotkin, and F. V. Paladino. 1996. Worldwide
population decline of Dermochelys coriacea: are leatllerback turtles going extinct? Chelonian Cons. BioI.
2:209-222.
Sprandel, G. L., 1. A Gore, and D. T. Cobb. J 997. Winter shorebird survey. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Corum.
Final Perf. Rep. Tallahassee.
Stevenson, H. M. 1970. Occurrence of the carpenter frog in Florida. Quart. J. Florida Acad. Sci. 32:233-235.
_, and B. H. Anderson. 1994. The birdlife of Florida. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville. Stys, B. 1993. Ecology
and habitat protection needs of the southeastern American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) on large-scale
development sites in Florida. Nongame Wildl. Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 13. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm., Tallahassee.
Telford, S. R. 1959. A study of the sand skink, Neoseps reynoldsi. Copeia 1959:100-119.
Tenant, A 1997. A field guide to snakes of Florida. GulfPubl. Co., Houston, Texas.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
FAll. 2007 Protected Species RepDrt
30 JanulU)' 2008
Page 14
APPENDIX C
Timmerman, W. W. 1989. Home range, habitat use and bebavior of the eastern diamondhack rattlesnake. M. S. thesis,
Univ. Florida, Gainesville.
Thaxton, 1. E., and T. M. Hingtgen. 1996. Effects of suburbanization and habitat fragmentation on Florida scrub-jay
dispersal. Florida Field NaL 24(2):25-37.
Toland, B. 1999a. Nesting success and productivity of Florida sandhill cranes aD natural and developed sites in
southeastern Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(1):10- 13.
_. 1999b. Nest site characteristics, breeding phenology, and nesting success of American oystercatcbers in Indian
River County, Florida. Florida Field NaL 27(3): 112-116.
Tuberville, TO., J. R. Bodie, J. B. Jensen, 1. LaClaire, and J. W. Gibbons. 2000. AppareDt decline of Ibe southern hog-
nosed snake, Heterodon simus. J. Elisha Mitchell Soc. 116:19-40.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1982. Stock Island tree snail recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_. 1984. American crocodile recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_' 1987. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; proposed threatened slatus fDr two Florida lizards. Fed.
Reg. 52(13):2242-2246.
_' 1998a. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants: 9O-day finding for a petition to delist the Squirrel
Chimney cave shrimp. Fed. Reg. 63:67618-67619.
_. 1998b. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; determination of endangered status for five freshwater
mnssels and threatened status for two freshwater mussels from the eastern Gulf Slope drninages of Alabama,
Florida, and Georgia. Fed. Reg. 63(50):12664-12687.
_' 1998c. Okaloosa darter (Etheostoma okaloosae) recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Servo Atlanta, Georgia.
_. 1999. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; final rule to list the flatwoods salamander as a threatened
species. Fed. Reg. 64:15691-15704.
_. 1999. South Florid. Multi-Species Recovery Plan U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. 2172 pp.
_. 2000. Candidate and listing priority assignment form: Cicindela highlandensis.
_.2006. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service The Endangered Species Program [web application]. US Fish & Wildlife
Service. Washington, D.C. http://www.fws.gov/endangered
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Gulf States Marine Fisheries Conunission. 1995.Gulf Sturgeon Recovery Plan.
Atlanta, Georgia.
Walls, J. G. 1976. FIShes of the northern GnU of Mexico. T. F. H. Publications.1nc., LId" Hong Kong.
Whitaker, J. 0.1996. National Audubon Society field guide to North American manunals. Alfred A Knopf, New York.
Williams, 1. D., and G. H. Burgess. 1999. A new species of bass, Micropterus cataractae (feleostei: Cenlrarchidae),
from the Apalachicola River basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Bull. Florida Mus. Nat. Hist. 42(2):81-
114.
Willell, W. N. 1983. Synopsis of the biOlogical data on the hawksbill turtle Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus, 1766).
FAO Fish. Synopsis 137.
Wood, P. B., M. 1. Hoffman, M. W. Collopy, and J. M. Schaefer. 1988. Southeastern American kestrel (Falco
sparverius paulus) natural history, life requirements, and habitat protection guidelines. Final report to Office of
Envir. Services, Florida Game and Fresb Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Woods, C. A., W. Post, and C. W. Kilpatrick. 1982. Microtus pennsylvanicus (Rodentia; Mnridae) in Florida: a
Pleistocene relict in a coastal saltmarsh. Bull. Florida State Mus. BioI. ScL 28:25-52.
Wooley, C. M., and E. J. Crateau. 1985. Movement, microhabitat, exploitation, and management of Gulf of Mexico
sturgeon, ApaIachicola River, Florida. North American J. Fisheries Manag. 5:590-605.
Wunderlin, R.P. 1998. Guide to the vascular plants of Florida. University Presses of
Florida, Gainesville, Florida
Zambrano, R., M. S. Robson, D. Y. Chametzky, and H. T. Smith. 1997. Distribution and status of least tern nesting
colonies in southeast Florida. Florida Field Nat. 25(3):85-91.
Zambrano, R., R., H. T. Smith, and M. Robson. 2000, Sununary of breeding roseate tems in the Florida Keys: 1974-
1998. Florida Field Nat. 28(2):64-68.
PROJECT LOCATIOIAPPENDIX C
5
,
o
5
10
15 Miles
,
Vahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49. Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE, NAPLES, FL
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consultin9
2631 4th St.
Naples, FL 34120
238.564.1660
N
W+E
S
PRO') ECT:
Figure 1. Project Location Map In Collier County; UPDATED 12.28.06
FLUCCSIVEGETATION MAP; SUAPPENDIX C :5
p
1rn'148
.IAC
+E
5
~
~ ~ SURVEY ROUTE
10' 4C PLUCf'CI
TOTAL ac...:ILI
PRO~ECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION 1~0
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
o
100 200 Feet
Vahl Mulchlna_ExDalUllqn Pa~' 2250 Wr,ahbl4.m AVl!.
Sec. 31, Twn'l8, Kge 27, totalln.epprox matal)' 28.alocre..
Ramsey Inc.
EnvIronmental Consulting
2831 4th St. NW
Nap'e!, FL 34120
238.5_.1880
Figure 2. FLUCFCSI Vegetetlon Map; Surve,. Route..
PRESERVE AREA M.APPENDIX C
PRESERVE AREA
PARCELID
#4 621
#S 624
#6 624/8146
#9 624
#11 621
1.57 AC
2.82 AC
0.24 AC
4.70 AC
2.40 AC
TOTAL
11.73 AC
PRO.JECT: Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
N
w+.
Figure 2. Preserve Area Map.
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th SL NW
N!lPI.... FL 34120
239.56...1660
Yahl MjllchlnlLExDllnslon P..-eel 2250 W".hbu.mAvp.
Sec. 31, Twn'iJ9, Kge 27, totaling approximately 28.BLeres.
LIST OFUSFWS AND FWC PROTECTlAPPENDIX C
FOR COLLIER CO., FL. AS OF 01130/08
co..aN NAMI!
.CIIiNTlfIC NA..
-
DPIONATED STATUS
._ 1.00.
'WII: ..we
AMl'III81ANS
IOPlacclro,
BIaDS
Cape Sable .culde lp1lml....
f'lodda.....olIoppc:rlparro....
FloricUu:rubjay
IImpkln
F'Iorkiabanowing.",..1
ivory-bilkd woodpecler
Cubu:l-/SI'lDWYplovu
plplncPIoYff
KlrtJan4',waroler
tirllebloebero..
............
snoW)' Cpl
trievloralhcl;U1>
........
,..~pi:a", Wcon
Sow!l~ Ameritln knUt:!'
Fiorida....dMnc.."e
Ameri;M.oy~crcatcbcr
b..ld~
woodJtodi:
brown'~IiC'a'"
Ifti-cockaded ...oo4pecur
ro_IClrpoonblR
..-rated.,...,...
Everp.deslnlloillo...,
w.ck Uimme~
....,=
ro_ctem
BbChtftan'.wQl'b}e1
FISH
1mdr.1X>lih _r.b
riwlul(m"'Jf'Ovc""",bJl)
MAMMALS
-.ci.mll1e
&~,(finbad;,",hr.k)
Nom. At_tic, ....I ....h.1cI
JIl&rida -.mff b1l
humpblw;k....bde
Carihbcanlllonklul
Ewrpde, mink
.perm.wbtlk
FIorid.,..dier
11IIC)'prts.I(o.~imll
Aorirdll/'Westllld~nP'l""le",
Aoridilb~1<bcur
REI"TlLES
Arnenc.n .1;"'101
lo"~uatunie
.....-
Amerieaa croc:odik
ka~ksel.l.""
EaIllUJ'liJIdiJolEUlM
luiurbbiD liaNnk
Jl'pbu11l:lftci..,
KC""P'.ridk)/IUlunle
INVERlEBJtA1ES
MOLLUliIUi
Fklrldilm:e..IllI;\
PLA"""
(NONE)
RsultJUlpilo
"'",,,wd_.f""'rlli~mjr,,bllis
A",.,."d_llls"w.nnD,j"../L'rld,"'''1
Aph.ekwolf'l,a C'DCnUuUI'lS
1I.n:1I""",llGraUM
ArMnlcunlcr,"ri" {Atl",.....
cMnlc:dIlrl,,/IorldflnQ)
C"mp.philul prin.:lptJlb
ChCI,IllI"u,at..;fanJrlnu
Chll.nUi,/u,lIWltuJ"s
CH1Ul,.,ir:aunkur.dtl
E,NTUl caf'n11ul
E,rdlQ",/ucrBI
E,rrTUlfhulu
E,r"U1l"iCf>lo,
Etodoc/mmll/h1U
FakD~",g"i,,,u
F(lfcD ,p(U1lf'ri.., po..lm
OnlJc4UItuil!lUbpN3fuuls
HGUI11lI(lp'"pGUiat"J
HGliattllultllcocf'phl"UI
M).C1UiGllmf'rlcofl"
P~t:"nus"cx/dmrGlIs
PIC:Dtdu bolf'ali'
P/alGIlGl!JajQ(AJGllllljaJa)
PotJbonu p1oll.:", GJldub<!n/i
(CIIIIICQI"G "".,I_,)
l(o'''luJmlU'or:iob/bsplu'''b......
R>",clwps 111,.,
S'~Q/lIiu..,....m
SUf'FlQ do..,alU (SIUIW d,m'IlUII
mm#aHli)
Vtrm{vo,.,bGcllm""1I
P';IIIJpf'crIQalO
R,,,,,lu.sm",,"OYllllU
8aklUlopu.mborf'Qli.J
BtlHWl6P'I!rrI plllWIU
EubaJe,tlUl,lt1.clllliJ (Balaf'n"
,hltloll,(ltlcl.oUllrtlliJ})
f'.wnDpJ ,fuut:itlUlflo'ldwt'lJ
MI!Illptf""nOWlf'Dll.fli,,",
M"IW.:luut,."pl<aU,
MlUulD ~lJan n>f'f'lIDcU7u'.'
Ph)'If'lfI'_CIlJ/:f'pltl/lu,
"u"III(Fdil)r:oncolurcoryi
$<;/11'", nl,"o~j<;rnIlIG
r"th<<J"umancr'IUU,liro",i,
(TrJe~d"J""",,"..Jl
U"lUalOKrl<;(1Jf,,,J1crldanrlJ
AIJJ,<u,,' miulnlppl.n,is
CfT1TfUIC<I'f'111l
CMlonlamyrJ(U
CO'O<;OtfJl'UIIC"'US
Cknnoclttt,J co,ittefo
D/?",olch""r:"....',N1up..".
E1Tlmodod).,/",llTltll,I/
Gopltf'rul polypll",._s
lAp/de><lw!1yl ulflPli
ur,nujQJet",1U
sse 0,2)
E
E
T
SSC(1)
SSC(I)
B
T
T
E
SSC(l.4)
SSC(l,4)
SSC(1)
SSC(1,4)
sse (2)
E
T
T
SSC(I,2)
T
E
SSC(l)
sse
sse (J.4)
T
E
SSe(l)
T
T
E
SSC(1)
E
E
E
E
E
T
E
E
T
E
"
sse 0.3)
T
E
E
E
T
E
T
E
SSC(ll
Proiect: YAHL MULCHING SDPA AR 7633
Figure 4. List of USFWS and FWC protected species for Collier Co., Fl.
YalJI Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49. Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
E
E
T
E
T
E
E
E
T
E
T
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
TSJA
T
e....T.
E
E
T
E
E
Ramsey Inc.
En\oironmc:D1a1 CODSuhint.
'26314"St.NW
NaplCI.FL 34120
239.364.1660
PROTECTED SPECIES/WILDLIFE FIELD ~APPEN 0 IX C -
CUMLA TIVE TOTALS
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
DATE:
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
09/23/07-11113/07 ALL SURVEYS
AM & PM TOTAL COUNT
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0610 AM
2000 PM
0-15
59-90 F
NONE
0-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus f1oridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
Project: Y AHL MULCHING; Fall 2007
TOTAL
COUNT
6
10
18
2
22
2
85
28
2
6
22
55
13
18
18
6
1
8
Figure 5. Cumulative totals for Protected Species I Wildlife Survey.
Daily field sheets in Appendix C.
Yahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27. totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
Ramseylnc.
Fnviromnental Cons\tting
26314"St.NW
Naples. FL 3412D
239.S64.1660
-
III- ~~~D ~~GE NES[T LOCA'API~ENDI\~l C
. NEST LO AnON
r- ---,
- I-
$ ~ .- 1
~ -
.....[
/
~ ~ ;W~~/~ ;%;;;11 ,,%
/ /. ///// ~ ~ ~/ /. /. //1%
7, -:/, //// '0/ /VJ0t/y >>0/, // / // /:
, v/~/ ~ ~ 0"/'~~~~
/ / '/ //~ v/ 'l': -/;
j ~~i4~ ~ all 1 ~~ii
~~ /lI /r/ ~ ~I; / 'i <<:~
- f:1~ //;~ ~;;r;;:; 0W~;; -*'/ -0 ~ ~~ ~1i3
V // -/j~ ~r0~~ [7/Y / /1/ / / ~ '/ ~/ ~/
- ~ / /~~'l;r;~;;W~r@~~ ~~r ~;-
~~~~~~~~~J7d~~~~~~
::0 // 1//::0 7 '/0:// ~~>>'ij0~
/, ~//IY.Y ~0 '/ 'i/// 'i:0//.~//~/v0
////.~ ~/// /): 7/ 0 '//;'///////// '/////////(,/
N
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION w+.
WASHBURN AVE. NAPLES. FL
s
Figure 6. Bald Eagle Location Map; Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
I:hl rf.l~n\lxcns!,n lc~r~e' 2250 Wr.::hr.~mAv" Nrr.1es,k.FL 34120
c. . n . 98 ,0 a In9 approx ma e., . l.cres. 23 .56 1660
PANTHER TELEMETRY 1!APPENDIX C
,
PRO.JECT: Y AHL MULCHING
Vahl Mulching ~an.lon Parcel, 2250 Wa.hburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn lI9, Kge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 ac....
& RECYCLING INC
\!!om~StJJ!S.
2831 4th St. NW
Naple.!. FL 34120
239.5_1860
Flgu.. 7. Panther telemetry 1981.2007;
PANTHER PRIMARY/SEAPPENDIX C
HABITAT MAP
N
W*E
,
~l\1{'AT'O\
UNE
~iYrAQ{'RY .
PRIMARY r<:-"I
HABITAT _.:~::;::
400 0 400 800 Feet
. '
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
Figure 8. Panther PrImary/Secondary Habitat Map;
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
PO Box 1261
Immokai8!J.!L 34143
239.564.100\1
Vahl MJllchlnlLEXlI8nslonf.llrcel 2250 Washbltm Ave.
Sec. 31, Twn'3l9, Kge 27, otallng approXimately 28.6 locres.
APPENDIX C
FLORIDA'S ENDANGERED SPECIES,
THREATENED SPECIES, AND SPECIES
OF SPECIAL CONCERN
November 2007
FLORIDA FISH AND WILDLIFE CONSERVATION COMMISSION
APPENDIX C
CONTENTS
PREFACE.......................................................................................................................... ii
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA
AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN .... I
OFFICIAL LISTS ....................................................................................................... I
FISH ............. ........ ................. .... ... .................................... ............. ............ .... ................. 2
AMPHIBIANS................ ...... .... ... .............. ............................ ...... ................ .............. .... 2
REPTILES ........... ................. ................................................. ..................... .............. ..... 2
BIRDS ....... ....... .......... ........... ....... ................................... ... .......... ................ .................. 3
MAMMALS...................................................................................................................4
INVERTEBRATES ......................................................................................................6
CORALS....................................................................................................................6
CRUSTACEANS.......................................................................................................6
INSECTS ..... .... ....... .......... ....... .......... ........... ............................. ........... ..... .......... ...... 6
MOLLUSKS..............................................................................................................6
KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATIONS........................................................ 7
APPENDIX C
PREFACE
This document consolidates the official state of Florida list of endangered species, threatened
species, and species of special concern. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission (FWC) maintains the state list of animals designated as endangered, threatened, or
species of special concern, in accordance with Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and 68A-27.005,
respectively, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.) httD://fac.dos.state.fl.us/. The state lists of
plants, which are designated endangered, threatened, and commercially exploited, are
administered and maintained by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
(DOACS) via Chapter 5B-40, F.A.C. This list of plants can be obtained at hllP://www.fl-
dof.com/forest manalrementlplant conserve Iisthtml. The federal agencies that share the
authority to list species as Endangered and 1ltreatened are the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration-National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA-NMFS) and U. S. Fish
and Wildlife Service (USFWS). The NOAA-NMFS is responsible for listing most marine
species. The federal list of animals and plants is administered by the USFWS, and this list is
published in 50 CFR 17 (animals) and 50 CFR 23 (plants). Additional infonnation regarding
federal listings can be located at the following websites; NOAA-NMFS
httD:/Iwww.nmfs.noaa.lrovandUSFWS-httr>://endanl!ered.fws.l!ov/wildlife.htm1#Soecies.
Please note that while the FWC has published a consolidated list of state and federally listed
species in the past, we now only publish a list of species listed within the state of Florida. This
list will be maintained and available at our agency website: hlltJ://www.mvfwc.com. Lists of
federally listed species can still be viewed at the USFWS and NOAA-NMFS websites mentioned
above. It is our intent by providing the list in this manner that we will be able to maintain a
current list that is more readily available to the public. I would like to thank the following
people who assisted in revising this list; Tom Logan, Jeff Gore, Paul Vincent, Paul Moler,
George Wallace, Jim Rodgers, Karl Miller, Ted Hoehn, Darrell Scovell, Gray Bass, Kelly
Donnelly, Elsa Haubold, Kipp Frohlich, Bill Brooks and the USFWS staff. Special appreciation
is expressed to Ms. Angela T. Williams, Ms. Christine Yannell and Ms. Kat Diersen for their
assistance with preparation of this document.
. Common and scientific names listed first are as tbey appear In tbe FWC "Florida Wildlife Code Title
6llA" (F,A.C). Common and/or scientific names following thls and located wltbin parentbeses ( ) contain
names as used by USFWS, or other commonly used names,
Bradley J. Gruver, Ph. D
Endangered Species Coordinator
Species Conservation Planning Section
Cover Photos by FWC Staff: Key Largo Woodrat, Burrowing Owls, Okaloosa Darter, Schaus'
swallowtail butterfly, Short-tailed Snake.
ii
APPENDIX C
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED,
THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN
STATUS
DESIGNATION FISH AMPHIBIANS REPTILES BIRDS MAMMALS INVERTEBRATES TOTAL
E 3 0 6 8 20 4 41
T 2 0 11 10 4 0 27
sse 10 5 7 18 6 4 SO
TOTAL 15 5 24 36 30 8 118
APPENDIX C
OFFICIAL LISTS
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
FISH
Atlantic sturgeon Acipenser oxyrinchus SSC (1)
(Gulf sturl!eon) (Acipenser oxvrinchus desotoi)
shortnose sturl!eon Acioenser brevirostrum E
shoal bass Micropterus cataractae sse (1,2)
Suwannee bass Microp/erus no/ius sse (1)
rivulus Rivulus marmoratus sse (I)
(manl!rove rivulus)
Lake Eustis nuofish . Cvvrinodon varie1!,atus hubbsi sse (])
blackmouth shiner Notropis melanostomus E
bluenose shiner P/eronolropis welaka sse (1,2)
saltmarsh tonminnow Fundulus ienkinsi SSC (I)
key silverside Menidia conchorum T
crvstal darter Crvstallaria asprella T
harlequin darter Etheosloma histrio SSC (1)
okaloosa darter Etheostoma okalossae E
Southern tessellated darter Etheostomo olmstedi sse (1)
(tessellated johnny darter) maculaticeps
key blenny Starlcsia starcki sse (J)
AMPHIBIANS
f1atwoods salamander Ambystoma cin1!.Ulatum sse
Georl(ia blind salamander Haideotriton wallacei sse (1,2)
nine barrens treefrog Hvla andersonii SSC (])
Florida bog frog Rana okaloosae SSC(2)
gopher frog Rana capito sse (I 2)
ILES
American aIlil!ator Alliga/or mississippiensis sse (] 3)
American crocodile Crocodylus aculus E
key rinj(l1eck snake Diadophis puncta/us acricus T
Eastern indil!o snake Drvmarchon corais couveri T
red rat snake Elaphe gut/ala SSe'(1)
Atlantic salt marsh water snake Nerodia clarkii taeniata T
(Atlantic salt marsh snake)
2
Common Name
Scientific Name
APPENDIX C
Florida pine snake Piluophis melanoleucus sse (2)
muf!itus
short-tailed snake Stilosoma extenuatum T
Florida brown snake Storeria dekayi victa TI
rim rock crowned snake Tanlilla oolitica T
Florida ribbon snake Thamnophis sauritus sackeni TI
bluetail mole skink Eumeces ellref!ius lividus T
Florida Kev mole skink Eumeces ellref!ius ellrelrius sse7f)
sand skink NeoselJs revnoldsi T
gopher tortoise GOlJherus polyphemus T
Barbour's man turtle Graptemvs barbouri SSC () .2)
allilZlltor snaoninl! turtle Macroclemvs temminckii sse ())
striped mud turtle Kinosternon baurii E1
Suwannee cooter Pseudemys concinna SSC (1,2)
suwanniensis
loggerhead seaturtle Carella carella T
(loggerhead sea turtle)
green seaturtle Chelonia mydas E
(green sea turtle)
leatherback seaturtle Dermochelys coriacea E
(leatherback sea turtle)
hawksbill seaturtle Eretmochelys imbricata E
(hawksbill sea turtle)
Kemp's ridley seaturtle Lepidochelys kempii E
(Kemp's ridlev sea turtle)
BIRDS
I nining nlover Charadrius melodus T
snowy plover Charadrius alexandrinus T
(Cuban snowy olover)
American ovstercatcber HaematolJus pal/iatus sse71 2\
brown pelican Pelecanus occidentalis SSC (I)
black skimmer RvnchoDs niller SSC ())
least tern Sterna antil/arum T
roseate tern Sterna dougal/i T
i (Sterna douJ!allii dou"a/lii)
limnkin Aramus J!Uarauna sscm
reddish elrret Ewella rufescens SSCi1.4)
snowy egret Ewella thula SSC '\)
little blue heron Ewella caerulea SSC ( 1,4)
tricolored heron Ewella tricolor sscr 1,4)
3
Common Name
Scientific Name
APPENDIX C
white ibis Eudocimus albus sse (2)
Florida sandhiJI crane Grus canadensis Dratensis T
whooping crane Grus amer/cana SSC (5)
wood stork Mvcteria americana E
roseate spoonbill Platalea aiaia sse (1 4)
burrowing owl Athene cunicularia SSC (1)
i (Florida burrowing owl) I (Athene cunicularia floridana)
crested caracara Caracara cheriway T
I (Audubon's crested caracara) (Polvborus Dlancus audubonii)
I perel!rine falcon Falco neref!7'inus E
Southeastern American kestrel Falco snarverius naulus T
bald eagle Haliaeetus leucoceDhalus T
osprey Pandion haliaetus ssc2 (1,2)
snail kite Rostrhamus sociabilis E
(Everglades snail kite) plumbeus
Florida scrub iav Anhelocoma coerulescens T
Cape Sable seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus E
mirabills
Florida grasshopper sparrow Ammodramus savannarum E
floridanus
Scott's seaside sparrow Ammodramus mar/timus sse (1)
neninsulae
Wakulla seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (1)
iuncicolus
white-crowned pigeon Columba leucoceDhala T
Kirtland's warbler Dendroica kirtlandii E
Bachman's warbler Vermivora bachmanii E
ivory-billed woodpecker ComDeDhilus Drincinalls E
red-cockaded woodpecker Picoides borealis SSC
Marian's marsh wren Cistothorus Dalustris marianae SSC (I)
WortbiDltton's marsh wren Cistothorus nalustris flriseus SSC (1)
MAMMALS
Florida panther Puma concolor coryi E
(Puma r~Felisl concolor corvi)
Florida black bear Ursus americanus floridanus r
Everglades mink Mustela vlson ever$!ladensis T
key deer Odocoileus virginianus E
elavium
4
APPENDIX C
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
Lower Kevs marsh rabbit Svlvilarms nalustris hefneri E
Biu Cvnress fox sauirrel Sciurus niller avicennia T
Shennan's fox sauirrel Sciurus niller shermani sse (J 2)
Eastern chiomunk Tamias striatus SSC (J)
Sanibel Island rice rat Orvzomvs nalustris sanibeli sse (J 2)
silver rice rat Oryzomys argentatus E
I (rice rat. lower FL Kevs) (Orvzomvs lJalustris natator)
Kev Lanzo woodrat Neotoma floridana smalli E
Key Largo Cotton Mouse Peromyscus gossypinus E
allanaticola
Choctawhatchee beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
allonhrvs
Southeastern beach mouse Peromyscuspoliono~ T
niveiventris
Anastasia Island beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
lJhasma
St. Andrews beach mouse Peromyscus poliono~ E
oeninsularis
Perdido Key beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
trissvllensis
Florida mouse Podomvs floridanus sse (1)
Florida mastifTbat Eumoos lllaucinus floridanus E
!ITaV bat Mvotis llrisescens E
Indiana bat Mvotis sodalis E
Florida saltmarsh vole Microtus pennsylvanicus E
(Florida salt marsh vole) dukecampbelli
Sherman's short-tailed shrew Blarina carolonensis sse (2)
r =brevicauda 1 shermani
Homosassa shrew Sorex lonllirostris eionis sse (2)
sei whale Balaenootera borealis E
fin whale Balaenoptera physalus E
(tinback whale)
North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena glacialis E
(right whale) (Balaena glacialis [inel.
aus/ralis 1)
humoback whale Mellantera novaeanvliae E
soerm whale Phvseter macroceDhalus E
Florida manatee Trichechus manatus latirostris E
(West Indian manatee) (Trichechus manatus)
5
Common Name
Scientific Name
APPENDIX C
INVERTEBRATES
CORALS
oillar coral Dendrogyra cylindrus E
CRUSTACEANS
Panama eity crayfish Procambarus econfinae sse (1)
(econfina crayfish)
sims sink crayfish Procambarus erythrops SSC (I)
(Santa Fe cave crayfish)
black creek crayfish Procambarus pictus sse 0)
INSECTS
Miami blue butterfly eyclargus [=Henniargus] E
thomasi bethunebakeri
Schaus' swallowtail butterfly Heraclides aristodemus E
ponceanus
MOLLUSKS
Florida tree snail ~i~us fasciatus sse 0)
Stock Island tree snail Orthalicus reses E
Orthalicus reses [not incl.
nesodrvas]
6
APPENDIX C
KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATiONS
List Abbreviations
FWC =
E=
T=
ssc=
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Endangered
Threatened
Species of Special Concern
Reasons for SSC listings prior to January 1, 2001 are indicated by the number in parenthesis under tlle
following criteria:
(1) has a significant vulnerability to habitat modification, environmental alteration, hurnan disturbance,
or human exploitation which, in tlle foreseeable future, may result in its becoming a threatened
species unless appropriate protective or management techniques are initiated or maintained;
(2) may already meet certain criteria for designation as a threatened species but for which conclusive data
are limited or lacking;
(3) may occupy such an unusually vital or essential ecological niche that should it decline significantly in
nurnbers or distribution other species would be adverscly affected to a significant degree;
(4) has not sufficiently recovered from past population depletion, and
(5) occurs as a population either intentionally introduced or being experimentally managed to attain
specific objectives, and the species of special concern prohibitions in Rule 68A-27.002, F.A.C., shall
not apply to species so designated, provided that the intentional killing, attempting to kill, possession
or sale of such species is prohibited.
(FWC)
1 Lower keys population only.
Monroe County population only.
Other tbau those found in Baker and Columbia Counties or in Apalachicola National Forest.
7
USFWS 1l1reatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
~.S. Fish & Wildlife Service
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
6ESS
APPIAPPENDIX C
I
Contact ECOS
Florida
Notes:
. This report shows the species listed in this state according to the Federal Register listing
description.
. This list does not include experimental populations and similarity of appearance listings.
. This I/st includes species or populations under the sole jurisdiction of the National Marine
Fisheries Service.
. Click on the highlighted scientific nemes below to view a Species Profile for each listing.
Listed species (based on published population data) - 114 listings
Animals - 59
Status Species/Listing Name
-NOTE: TIle ftetfl'N IurCft is &ttd 2 limes undtr [
1II1m.1I. $(I the ,,11II1 number Hstm 1$. 51 Aftlm8ls 0
.nd 111 To"l.
T Bankclimber, purple (mussel) (Elliptoideus sloat/anus)
E Bat. gray (Myot;s grisescens)
E Beetle, American burying (Nicrophorus americanuS)
E Butterfly, Schaus swallowtail (Heme/ides aristodemus ponceanus)
T Caracara, Audubon's crested FL pop. (Polyborus plancus audUbon/i)
T Coral, elkhom (Acropora palmata)
T Coral, staghorn (Acropora cervicornis)
T Crocodile, American FL pop. (Crocodylus acutus)
E Curlew, Eskimo (Numanius borealis)
E Darter, Okaloosa (Etheoslome oka/nosee)
E Deer, key (Odooolleus virgin/anus clavium)
T Jay. Florida scrub (Aphelocome coerolascans)
E Kite, Everglade snail FL pop. (Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbaus)
E Manatee. West Indian (Trichechus manetus)
E MOCC8sinshell, Gulf (Medionidus penicillatus)
E Moccasinshell, Ochlockonee (Medionidus simpson/anus)
E Mouse, Anastasia Island beach (Paromyscus po/ionolus phesme)
http://ecos.fws.gov/tess_public/StateListing.do ?status=] isted&state= FL
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX C
E Mouse, Choctawhatchee beach (Peromyscus polionotus allophrys)
E Mouse, Key Largo cotton (Paromyscus gossypinlls al/apa/ieo/a)
E Mouse, Perdido Key beach (peromyscus polionotus trlssyllepsis)
T Mouse, southeastern beach (Paromyscus polionotus nivelven/ris)
E Mousa, SI. Andrew beach (Paromyscus poliollotus peninsu/arls)
E Panther, Florida (Puma (=FeJ/s) concotor caryl)
E Pelican, brown except U.S. Atlantic coast, FL, AL (Pe/eeanus occ/dentalis)
E Plgtoe, oval (P/eurobema pyriforme)
T Plover, piping except Great Lakes watershed (Charadrius me/odus)
E Pocketbook, shinyrayed (Lamps/lis subangulata)
E Rabbit. Lower Keys marsh (Sylvl/aglls paluslris hefnan)
E Rice rat lower FL Keys (Oryzomys palusitis natator)
T Salamander, flatwoods (Ambystoma cingulatum)
E Sawfish, smalltooth (Prlstls pectinata)
E Sea turtle, green FL, Mexico nesting pops. (Che/on/a mydas)
T Sea turtle, green except where endangered (Ch9lonla mydas)
E Sea turtle, hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata)
E Sea turtle, Kemp's ridley (Lapidochelys kempil)
E Sea turtle, leatherback (Darmoche/ys cotiacea)
T Sea turtle, loggarhead (Caret/a caretta)
E Seal, Caribbean monk (Monachus tropica/is)
T Shrimp, Squirrel Chimney Cave (Palaemone/es cumming~
T Skink, bluetail mole (Eumacas agregius lividus)
T Sklnk, sand (Necseps reynolds/)
T Slabshell, Chipola (Elliptio Cllipo/aensls)
T Snail, Stock Island tree (Or/I'alicus reses (not incl. nesodryas))
T Snake, Atlantic sail marsh (Nerodia clarkii taeniata)
T Snake. eastern indigo (Drymarchon corais couperl)
E Sparrow, Cape Sable seaside (Ammodramus marltimus mirabi/ls)
http://ecos.fws.gov!lessyublic/StateListing.do ?slatus=l isted&state= FL
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX C
E Sparrow. Florida grasshopper (Ammodramus savannarum noridanus)
E Stork, wood AL, FL, GA, SC (Mycteria americana)
T Sturgeon, gulf (Aclpenser oxyrinchus desolo/)
E Sturgeon, shortnose (Adpenser brovirostrum)
T Tern, roseate Westem Hemisphere except NE U.S. (Slema dougallH dougal/Ii)
E Three-ridge, fat (mussel) (Amb/ema neislarH)
E Vole, Florida salt marsh (Microtus pennsylvan/cus dukecampbelll)
E Whale. finback (Balaenoptera physalus)
E Whale, humpback (Megaptera novaeangllae)
E Whale, right (Balaena gladalis (incl. australis})
E Wolf, gray Lower 48 States, except where de listed; where XN; and Mexico. (Canis
lupus)
E Woodpecker, red-cockaded (Picoides borealis)
E Wood rat, Key Largo (Neotama noridana smalh)
Plants - 55
Slalus Spec/esILlstlng Name
E Aster, Florida golden (Chrysopsis Roridana)
E Beargrass, Britton's (NOOna britJoniana)
E Beauty, Harper's (Harperoca/ljs naval
E Bellflower, Brooksville (Campanula roblnslae)
T Birds-in-a-nest, white (Macbridea alba)
E Blazingstar, scrub (Uatris ohlingerae)
T Bonamia, Florida (Sonamia grandfflora)
T Buckwheat, scrub (Eriogonum longifolium var. gnaphalifolium)
T Bullerwort, Godfrey's (Pinguicula ionantha)
E Cactus, Key tree (Pilosocereus robinli)
E Campion, fringed (Silene polypstala)
E Chaffseed, American (Schwalbea americana)
E Cladonia, Florida perforate (eladon!a perforata)
http://ecos.fws.gov/tessyublic/StateListing.do ?status=listed&state=FL
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX C
E Fringe-tree, pygmy (Ch/onanthus pygmaeus)
T Gooseberry, Miccosukee (Ribes echlnellum)
E Gourd, Okeechobee (Cucurbita okeechobeensls ssp. okeechobeensis)
E Harebells, Avon Park (Crota/aria avonens/s)
E Hypericum, highlands acrub (Hypericum cumulico/a)
E Jacquemontia, beach (Jacquemonba reclinata)
E Lead-plant, Crenulate (Amotpha crenulata)
E Lupine, scrub (Luplnus ar/dorum)
E Meadowrue, Cooley's (Thaliclrum cooley~
E Milkpea, Small's (Ga/aclia sma/1m
E Mint, Garrett's (DlOOrandra christmanil)
E Mint, Lakela's (Dicerandm immaculata)
E Mint, longspurred (Dicemndra comubssima)
E Mint, scrub (Dicerandra frulescens)
E Mustard, Carter's (Warea catler~
E Pawpaw, beautiful (Deeringothamnus pulche//us)
E Pawpaw, four-petal (Asimina tetmmem)
E Pawpaw, Rugel's (Deeringolhamnus ruge/il)
T Pigeon wings (C/itotia fmgrans)
E Pinkroot, gentian (Spige//a gen6anoldes)
E Plum, scrub (Prunus geniculafa)
E Polygala, Lewton's (Po/ygala lew/onil)
E Polygala, tiny (Po/yga/a smaUii)
E Pondberry (Undem melissi/oIia)
E Prickly-apple, fragrant (Cereus eriopholUs var. fmgrans)
E Rhododendron, Chapman (Rhododendron c/lapmani~
E Rosemary, Apalachicola (Conradlna g/abra)
E Rosemary, Etonia (Conradine elonie)
E Rosemary, short-leaved (Conradine brev/folie)
http://ecos.fws,gov/tess''public/StateListing.do ?status=listed&state= FL
USFWS Threatened and Endangered Species System (TESS)
APPIAPPENDIX C
E Sandlace (Pofygonal/a myr/ophyl/a)
T Seagrass. Johnson's (Halophila johnsonJ~
T Skullcap, Florida (Scu/al/aria flor/dana)
E Snakeroot (Erynglum cuna/folium)
E Spurge, deltoid (Chamaasyce delto/dea ssp. delto/daa)
T Spurge, Garber's (Chamaesyce garber~
T Spurge, telephus (Euphorbia la/aphioidas)
E Torreya. Florida (Torreya taxifolia)
E Warea, wide-leaf (WaTBa amp/exifolia)
E Water-willow, Cooiey's (Juslicia coo/aYI)
T WhiUow-wort, papery (Paronychia chal1acea)
E Wlreweed (Polygonel/a basiram/a)
E Ziziphus, Florida (Zlziphus ce/ala)
TESS I ECOS I U_S. FWS Home I Privacy
http://ecos.fws.gov/tess "publiclStateListing.do ?status=listed&state= FL
APPENDIX C.
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
09/23/07-11/13/07 ALL SURVEYS
AM & PM TOTAL COUNT
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0610 AM
2000 PM
0-15
59-90 F
NONE
0-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
DATE:
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus lIoridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
TOTAL
COUNT
6
10
18
2
22
2
85
28
2
6
22
55
13
18
18
6
1
8
APPENDIX C
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
09.23..07
AM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0700 AM
1000 AM
0-5 N
76 F
NONE
10%
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus floridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
COUNT
1
1
1
10
2
3
5
4
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
09.24.07
PM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
1700 PM
2000 PM
5-15NE
85 F
NONE
10-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJA Y
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus Iloridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
COUNT
1
2
2
1
3
8
3
1
3
11
1
3
4
2
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
DATE:
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
09.29.07
AM
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0710 AM
0945 AM
5.10NE
74 F
NONE
10 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VUL lURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus floridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
COUNT
1
2
6
1
3
2
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
09.29.07
PM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
1650 PM
1000 PM
5.15 E
87 F
NONE
10-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJA Y
CARDINAL
PILEA TED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
COUNT
3
15
4
2
6
11
2
1
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sytvilagus f1oridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
2
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATILE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
DATE:
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
10..06..07
PM
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
1645 PM
2000 PM
5-10 NE
90 F
NONE
30-Jan %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
COUNT
3
3
2
1
14
3
1
4
8
2
1
2
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus floridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
2
2
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
10.20.07
AM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0700 AM
1000 AM
0-5S
74 F
NONE
10-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvllagus f1oridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
COUNT
1
4
2
7
4
1
3
6
2
1
2
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
10.20.07
PM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
1700 PM
1850 AM
0-5 VARIABLE
80 F
RAINED EARLIER
30-40 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
COUNT
2
8
5
1
,
2
7
2
6
2
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus floridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
10.28.07
AM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0700 AM
1015 AM
5-10 N
73 F
NONE
10-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(SylvUagus f1oridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
COUNT
1
1
4
2
1
2
2
1
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
11.11.07
AM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0610 AM
0945 AM
5.10NE
56 F
NONE
0%
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
COUNT
2
2
4
2
2
1
2
2
1
2
1
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus lIoridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
APPENDIX C
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
DATE:
11.13.07
PM
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
1530 PM
1830 PM
5-10 E NE
75 F
NONE
30-40 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJA Y
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
WHITE IBIS
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sy1vilagus floridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
COUNT
1
1
3
4
11
2
1
2
2
1
E<ological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, PennitU A P PEN 0 I X 0
~NVIRONMENTAL CONS~LT!~~r Ra. Inc. LE
LEP - Licensed Environmental Professional E-mail: Ramsey.Inc@embarqrnail.com
CWB - Certified Wildlife Biologist Office: 239.564.1660, Fax: 866.334.1496
CFEA. Certified Florida Environmental Assessor 2631 4tb St. NW, Naples, FL 34120
REPA. Registered Environmental Property Assessor www.ramseyinc.net
CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional
OSHA 5 - Hazardous Mar:erials Incident Commander
-~~
-~~_::.....
PROTECTED SPECIES WILDLIFE SURVEY REPORT. SPRING 2008
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING SDP A AR 7633
DATE: 06.15.08
BY: Michael R Ramsey
Ramsey Inc.
Owner: Fillmore LLC (Yahl Mulching)
County: Collier
City: Naples
Size: 28.8 acres
Legal Descriptions: PID 00341920409
2250 Washburn Ave; the SW 'A or the SW 'A
Section 31; Township 49, Range 27
INTRODUCTION
The applicant Yahl Mulching has applied to the Collier Co. Government, tbe South Florida Water Management District
(SFWMD) and US Army Corps of Engineers (USACOE) to expand its existing operation of mulching and recycling of
vegetative material in Collier Co. (Figure I). The following protected species/wildlife survey report was done to meet
the submission requirements for each agency.
This report evaluates if the above described project property is utilized by any protected species listed by the
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). A
protected species/wildlife evaluation for this property was conducted in 2000, 2006 and Fall 2007, this report
follows up on those 3 previous reports.
METHODS
First, the project properties were surveyed and a map prepared of the habitat types on site. Second, the official lists
of protected species were obtained from each of the agencies (FWC & FWS). The FWC list all species classified
as protected by the state of Florida government. The FWS list all species that are classified as protected in the state
of Florida by the United States government. Third, each species on each list was researched as to county of
occurrence and required habitat in the literature. Last, all species that were indicated as being found in Collier Co.
and having a habitat type that occurred on the project properties were searched for by surveys on the project
properties.
RESULTS
Survev Dates. This property was initially evaluated for the presence of protected species in 2000. Collier Co.
Government Natural Resources Division concluded there was no issue with protected species on this site and issued
approval to move ahead with a site development plan in the Conditional Use Permit proceedings. The area was
resurveyed in 2006 for the presence of protected species for tlle SFWMD and USACOE. The SFWMD found no issues
with protected species and issued their permit #11 .02649-P on 15 March 2007. The USACOE is still evaluating their
permit application at Ibis time. The project properties were visited on: October 14 - December 30 in the year 2000;
and resurveyed on the dates: 09/15,09/23,09/30,10/05, 10/12, 11/05, 11/26, 12/09 and 12/17 in 2006. ln 2007 the
project area was visited on 09/23-24, 09/29, 10/06, 10/20, 10/28, 11/11 and 1 ]/13. For this survey period Spring 2008
the property was visited on 04/02, 04/04, 04/06, 04/26, 05/14, 05/18 and OS/25. Surveys were done in the moming (AM)
2-3 hours after sunrise and in the evening (PM) 2-3 hours before sunset. Survey routes are shown in Figure 2.
YablMulching
SDPA AR 1633
Spring 2008 PrOlttled Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 2
APPENDIX 0
Habitat. The Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS) was utilized to
produce the habitat maps for the project properties. The habitat or FLUCFCS maps are depicted in Figure
2 for the Yabl Mulching project. Table I below indicates the acres for each habitat type.
Table 1. FLUCFCS acres for the Yahl Mulching and Recycling property.
ID# Acres FLUCCS #
I
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
2.6
3.2
0.5
1.6
7.0
0.8
1.1
0.3
4.7
3.4
2.4
0.5
0.7
111
152
624n43
621
624
624/8146
624
434
624
624/742
621
8145
8145
Habitat Tvue
Single Family Residence
Timber Processing
Pine/CypresslPalmispoil piles
Cypress
Pine/CypresslPalm
Pine/CypresslPalm impacted by road clearing
Pine/CypresslPalm
Hardwood Conifer
Pine/CypresslPalm
Pine/CypresslPalm impacted by borrow pit excavation
Cypress
GradediDrained Road
GradediDrained Road
The Yahl property has been impacted by road construction on the north, south and west sides of the property.
This construction has effectively cut off sheet flow across the property, except for unusually high rainfall events.
Impacted hydrology appears to be the cause of the pine trees being present with present in cypress transition areas
in the 624 habitats. It is also the reason for the heavy melaleuca infestation in the 624 areas to be preserved. This
area has been slowly drying out over time. In the site development plan the applicant will be impacting 6.37 acres
of wetlands at the northwest corner of the property (adjacent to the road, Figure 3) and preserve approximately
11.73 acres to the south of the operations area that will be rehydrated and enhanced (Figure 3). Rehydration is
anticipated to greatly improve the vegetative conditions and make it more attractive to wetland wildlife.
State!Federal Protected Suecies Listed. The FWC list was published in November 2007 and lists 118 anlmals as
protected in the Slate of Florida and is attached as Appendix A. Based on general habitat requirements, historic
distributions and actual sightings, the FWC lists 52 animal species that may occur in Collier County. There are 51
species that are vertebrates and 1 invertebrate. The 52 species are listed in Figure 4.
The FWS list is updated daily on their website. The May 2008 list totals 112 animal and plant species as protected
in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix B. Based on general habitat requirements, historic distributions and
actual sightings, the FWS lists 26 species (26 animals and no plants) that may occur in Collier County. Species for
Collier Co. are listed in Figure 4 also.
Site Survev Results. Figure 5 indicates the cumulative total of all species observed over 10 survey events. Daily field
sheets are located in Appendix C. Overall, 21 species were noted. 17 bird species, 3 mammals and 1 reptile. The most
frequent bird species observed was mourning dove with 67 observations and for manunals - gray squirrel with 15
observations.
Snecies Results.
Gopher Frog/Rana capilO: Prefers dry sandy, upland habitats adjacent to wetland areas. This type habitat is not
present onsite, or adjacent properties and no individuals were observed on site. Changes in the project property
will have no effect on this species.
Yah1 Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Prolecled Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 3
APPENDIX 0
Cape Sable seaside sparrow/Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis: Currently inhabits seasonally inundated freshwater
interior marshes within Everglades National Park and Big Cypress National Preserve in Monroe and Dade County. Last
documented in Collier Co. in 1979. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property.
Florida Grasshopper sparrow!Ammodramus savannarum floridanus: Prefers large areas of frequently burned dry prairie
habitat, with patchy open areas sufficient for foraging. This habitat type is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the property. In addition, this species has not been observed since 1955 in Collier Co. Changes in the
project property will have no effect on this species.
Florida scrub jay! Apheloeama caerulescens: Prefers low growing scrub oak plants. This habitat is not present
onsite and nO individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in the project property will have no effect on
this species.
Limpkin/Aramus guarauna: Inhabits mangroves, freshwater marshes, swamps, springs and spring runs, and pond
and river margins. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida burrowing owl/Alhene eUfliculariaflaridana: Prefers habitats of high, sparsely vegetated, sandy ground.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Ivory-billed woodpecker/ Campephilus principalis: This species is considered to be extinct but is still listed.
Known to prefer swampy forests, especially large bottomland river swamps of coastal plain and Mississippi Delta
and cypress swamps of Florida. This habitat is present onsite, but no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Cuban-/snowy plover, Charadrius alexandrinus: Prefers dry, sandy beaches, where they nest in shallow
depressions, usually near some vegetation or debris. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Piping plover/Charadrius me/adus: Prefers open, sandy beaches and on tidal mudflats and
sandflats along the coasts. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have nO effect on this species.
Kirtland's warbler !Dendraica kirtlandii: Nests in nearly homogeneous stands of usually 30 ha or more of dense
scrubby jack pine. Florida maybe a mlgration stop between Michigan and the Bahamas. Individuals may flay
straight through. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes
in this property will have no effect on this species.
Little blue heron/Egrella caerulea: Feeds in shallow freshwater, brackish, and saltwater habitats. Nesting colonies
usually occur in coastal areas, but prefers foraging in freshwater lakes, marshes, swamps, and streams. Nests in a
variety of woody vegetation types, including cypress, willow, maple, black mangrove, and cabbage palm. Usually
breeds in mixed-species colonies in flooded vegetation or on islands. Nesting habitat is present onsite, but no
other nesting of other wading bird species has been observed. No individuals or nests were observed on the
property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately
12 acres of forested wetlands in a preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Reddish egretlEgretla rufeseens: Typically prefers coastal mangrove islands, or in Brazilian pepper on manmade
dredge spoil islands, near suitable foraging habitat. Generally forages in shallow water of variable salinity. Broad,
open, marine tidal flats and shorelines with little vegetation are ideal feeding areas. Also important are salt
evaporation pools and lagoons, often located inside mangrove keys or just inside shoreline on mainland. This
Yah] Mulching
SOPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 4
APPENDIX 0
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
have no effect on this species.
Changes in this property will
Snowy egretJEgretla thula: Nests both inland and in coastal wetlands with nests placed in many types of woody
shrubs, especially mangroves and willows; usually over shallow waters. Almost all nesting is over shallow waters
or on islands that are separated from shoreline by extensive open water. Feeds in many types of permanently and
seasonally flooded wetlands, streams, lakes, and swamps, and in manmade impoundments and ditches. Breeding
success is tied to water-level fluctuations. Preferred nesting habitat is not present onsite. There are no
permanently inundated areas on site. Seasonally flooded areaS are very short in duration. No individuals or
nesting were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is
planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in
habitat conditions may encourage use.
Tricolored heron/Egretta Iricolor: Most nesting colonies occur on mangrove islands or in willow thickets in fresq
water, but nesting sites include other woody thickets on islands or over standing water. Prefers coastal
environments. Feeds in a variety of permanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, mangrove swamps, tidal
creeks, ditches, and edges of ponds and lakes. Preferred nesting and feeding habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is
planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in
habitat conditions may encourage use.
White ibislEudocimus albus: Found in a wide variety of habitats, including freshwater and brackish marshes, salt
flats and salt marsh meadows, many types offorested wetlands, wet prairies, swales, seasonally inundated fields,
and man-made ditches. The forested wetland habitat is present onsite and targeted to be preserved and enhanced.
No individuals or nests were observed in the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this
species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands in the preserve area. This
improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Peregrine falcon/Falco peregrinus: The Peregrine Falcon frequents open areas like marshes, fields, swamps, and
tidal areas. Since its reintroduction into the eastern United States, however, the Peregrine Falcon has colonized
many urban areas because of increased nesting sites (and nesting ledges being created on buildings). This species
is considered to be recovered and is waiting for deli sting. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Southeastern American kestrel/Falco sparverlus paulus: Found in open pine habitats, woodland edges, prairies,
and pastures throughout much of Florida. Nest sites are tall dead trees or utility poles generally with an
unobstructed view of surroundings. Kestrels are not known to nest in Collier County. Most individuals are
migrants from the north. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have little to no effect on this species.
Florida sandhill crane!Grus canadensis pralensis: Habitat: Prairies, freshwater marshes, and pasture lands.
Avoids forests and deep marshes but uses transition zones and edges between these and prairies or pasture lands.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
American oystercatcher/Haemalopus palliates: Habitat: Coastal waters. This habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Bald eagle/Haliaeetus leucocephalus: According to tlle FWC eagle website, only 1 nest (CO 015) is within 1 mile
of this project. A map of this nesllocation is presented in Figure 6. The location of this nest was field verified
and it is active. It is approximately 4,270 feet form the project. It is within the South Belle Meade Boundary, but
it is in private ownership. FWC records indicate that it has been active since the year 2000. The Yahl Recycling
Yahl Mulching
SOfA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Prol.etted Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 5
APPENDIX D
project has been in operation prior to 2000. Highway 1-75 is also between the Yahl project and the designated
eagles nest. The proposed project is not in the primary zone, but it is in the secondary Zone. No individuals or
nests were observed on or utilizing the property. The distance of the nests from tlle project, coupled with the fact
that activity form I -75 has not presented any problems indicates that proposed changes in this property will have
little to no effect on this species. On a larger scale the FWS has delisted the Bald Eagle.
Wood stork/Mycleria Americana: Nests colonially in a variety of inundated forested wetlands, including cypress
strands and domes, mixed hardwood swamps, sloughs, and mangroves. Forages in 6-15 inches of surface water.
The preferred nesting habitat is present onsite, but the surface water does not get very deep on the property during
the year due to the impacts of road building changing the hydrology. No individuals or nests were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately
12 acres of forested wetlands iu the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Brown pelican/Pelecanus occidenlalis: Habitat: Mainly coastal, feeding in shallow estuarine waters, and (less
often) far offshore. . This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Red-cockaded woodpecker/Picoides borealis: Habitat: Inhabits open, mature pine woodlands that have a
diversity of grass, forb, and shrub species. Prefers mature slash pine trees that are generally larger than 12 inches
in diameter, a wide spacing of trees, no subcanopy and relatively dry conditions. The preferred habitat is not
present onsite. No individuals were observed on the property. Again for this survey all pine trees were inspected
for nest cavities or start holes and none were found. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Roseate spoonbill/Platalea ajaja (Ajaia ajaja): Habitat: Primarily nests in mixed-species colonies on coastal
mangrove islands or in Brazilian pepper on man-made dredge spoil islands near suitable foraging hahitat. Does
feed in forested wetland habitats with slow moving water. Although forested wetland type habitat present,
hydrology has been so impacted it is very low quality. No individuals or indications of this species were observed
on the properties. Changes in this propeny will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate
approximately 12 acres offorested wetlands in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may
encourage use.
Crested caracara/Polyborus plancus audubonii (Caracara cheriway): Open country, including dry prairie and
pasture lands with cabbage palm, cabbage palmllive oak hammocks, and shallow ponds and sloughs. Preferred
nest trees are cabbage palms, followed by live oaks. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Everglades snail kitelRostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus: Habitat: Large open freshwater marshes and lakes with
shallow water. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Black skimmerlRynchops niger: Habitat: Coastal waters, including beaches, bays, estuaries, sandbars, tidal creeks
(foraging), and also inland waters of large lakes, phosphate pits, and flooded agricultural fields. This habitat is not
present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on
this species.
Leas1 tern/Sterna antil/arum: Habitat: Coastal areas throughout Florida, including beaches, lagoons, bays and
estuaries. Increasingly use artificial nesting sites, including gravel rooftops, dredge spoil islands or other dredged
material deposits, construction sites, causeways, and mining lands. This habitat is not present onsile and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Roseate tern/Slerna dougalli (Sterna dougallii dougallii): Habitat: Nest sites include bare limestone, shell-sand
beaches, newly deposited rock and marl fill, dredge material, and heaps of broken coral deposited by storms. This
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Prolected Species Report
15 June 2008
Page6
APPENDIX D
habitat is not presen1 on site and no individuals were observed on the properties.
have no effect on this species.
Changes in this property will
Bachman's warbler/Vermivora bachmanii: Historic records indicate the Bachman's warbler nested in low, wet
forested areas containing variable amounts of water, but usually with some water that was permanent. This
species is considered extinct in Florida. This preferred habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were
observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Smalltooth sawfish/Pristis pectinata: Habitat: Shallow coastal, estuarine, and fresh waters; often in brackish
water near river mouths and large embayments, in deeper holes on bottnms of mud or muddy sand. This habitat is
not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species.
Rivulus (mangrove rivulus)/Rivulus marmoratus: Habitat: coastal, appears to prefer red mangrove (Rhizophora
mangle). This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Sei whale/Balaenoptera borealis: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Generally, in deep water; along edge of continental
shelf and in open ocean. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Fin whale (finback whale)/Balaenoptera physalus: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Usually found in largest numbers
25 miles or more from shore. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the
properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
North Atlantic right whale/Eubalaena glacialis (Balaena glacialis fincl. australis)): Habitat: Inhabits near shore
and offshore waters. Mainly coastal in the North Atlantic. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals
were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
Florida mastiff batlEumops glaucinus floridanus: Habitat: Roosts in palms and hollow trees and in buildings.
Forages high in air over natural as well as human-altered landscapes. Minimal preferred roosting habitat is
present onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties or surrounding areas during surveys. Changes in
this property will have no effect on this species.
Humpback whale/Megaptera novaeangliae: Habitat: Pelagic and coastal waters, sometimes frequenting inshore
areas such as bays. This habitat is not present onsile and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Caribbean monk seal/Monachlls tropicalis: Habitat: Marine areas. Shallow lagoons and reefs, sandy beaches, and
permanent islets or beaches above high tide. Mainly west coast of Florida and Caribbean. This habitat is not
present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on
this species.
Everglades mink/Mustela vison evergladensis: Habitat: A variety of wetland communities, including salt marsh,
freshwater marsh, cypress swamp, and hardwood swamp. There is very little of the preferred habitat is onsite.
However, no individuals were observed or, indicators of the presence was noted on the properly. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species. It is planned to rehydrate approximately 12 acres of forested wetlands
in the preserve area. This improvement in habitat conditions may encourage use.
Sperm whale/Physeter macrocephalus: Habitat: Pelagic, prefers deep water, sometimes around islands or in
shallow shelf waters. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Report
]S June 2008
Page 7
APPENDIX 0
Florida panther/Puma (Felis) concolor coryi: Habitat: Requires extensive blocks of mostly forested communities.
The FWC panther telemetry database form 1981-2007 indicates no utilization of this property (Figure 7). The
forested habitat panthers utilize is present onsite. No individuals or indicators were observed on the property.
Planned changes in this property will have no effect on this species. However, this property is considered to be in
the area of the Primary Panther Habitat Zones articulated by FWS (Figure 8). This issue is currently being
evaluated by USACOE and FWS for proposed mitigation. FWS has indicated that this area has little value to the
panther since it is on the edge of the Primary Habitat Zone and bordered by 1-75. Proposed changes to the
property are expected to have little to no effect on this species.
Big Cypress fox squirrel/Sciurus niger avicennia: Habitat: Sandhills (high pine), pine f1atwoods, and pastures and
other open, ruderal habitats with scattered pines and oaks. Depends on a variety of oak trees for seasonal food and
nest material. Longleaf pine cones and seeds are important foods. This habitat type is present onsite, but very few
oak trees. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this
species. Creation of the preserve area may encourage utilization.
FloridalWest Indian manateelTrichechus manatus latirostris (Trichechus manatus): Habitat: Coastal waters, bays,
rivers, and (occasionally) lakes. Requires warm-water refugia such as springs or cooling effluent during cold
weather. Sheltered coves are important for feeding, resting, and calving. This habitat is not present onsite and no
individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Florida black bear/Ursus americanus florjdanus: Habitat: A wide variety of forested cornmunities is needed to
support the varied seasonal diet of black bears. Forested wetlands are particularly important for diuroal cover.
This habitat is present onsite. However this area is bordered on the south by 1-75 which greatly deters access. No
individuals or indices were observed on the properties. Figure 9 indicates black bear telemetry locations form
1983-2000 as collected by the FWC. The closest bear location was 3600 feet from the property however it is
south of 1-75 and excluded from the property. North ofI-75 the closet telemetry location was approximately 5900
square feet. Figure 10 indicates the locations of nuisance issues from 1980-2006 according to the FWC.
Generally, there has been no telemetry or nuisance issues on or immediately around the project property. Personal
communication with the Naples FWC office revealed that only 2-3 nuisance complaints for black bears had been
lodged for this general area since 1991 and they were in the last 2 years. Changes in this property will have no
effect on this species. Creation of tlle preserve area may encourage utilization, but is not expected to.
American alligator/AlUgator mississippiensis: Habitat: Most permanent bodies of fresh water, including marshes,
swamps, lakes, and rivers. Occasionally wanders into brackish and salt water but rarely remains there. Protected
classification is primarily due to similarity of appearance with the American Crocodile. This Species is
considered recovered in Florida. Habitat is not present onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species.
Loggerhead seaturtle/Caretta caretta: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches.
This hahitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Green seaturtlel/Chelonia mydas: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This
habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will
have no effect on this species.
American crocodilel/Crocodylus acutus: Habitat: Coastal estuarine marshes, tidal swamps, and creeks along
edges of mainland and islands. Usually associated with mangroves. Nests on beaches, stream banks, and levees.
This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property
will have no effect on this species.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR ,633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Report
] 5 June 2008
Page 8
APPENDIX 0
Leatherback seaturtle/Dennochelys coriacea: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Eastern indigo snake//Drymarchon corais couperi: Habitat: Broad range of habitats, from scrub and sandhill to
wet prairies and mangrove swamps. In northern part of range, often winters in gopher tortoise burrows in sandy
uplands bnt forages in more hydric habitats. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were observed
on the property. Also, no gopher tortoise burrows were discovered. Changes in this property will have no effect
on this species. It is expected that the planned rehydration of this area will further discourage possible utilization.
Hawksbill seaturtle//Eretmochelys imbricata: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Gopher tortoise/Gopherus polyphemus: Habitat: Typically found in dry upland habitats, including sandhills,
scrub, xeric oak hammock, and dry pine flatwoods; also commonly uses disturbed habitats such as pastures, old
fields, and road shoulders. Typical habitat not present onsite. No burrows or individuals observed on site.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. It is expected that the planned rehydration of this area
will further discourage possible utilization
Kemp's ridiey seaturtle//Lepidochelys kempii: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand
beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this
property will have no effect on this species.
Florida tree snaiU/Liguus fasciatus: Habitat: Tropical hardwood hammock (rockland hammock). This species
prefers smooth-barked trees. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties.
Changes in this property will have no effect on this species
CONCLUSIONS
The majority of habitat on site is 624 pine, cypress, palm. This habitat type appears to be the result of a hydrology
impacts over a long period of time, which dried the area out and allowed slash pine to invade in cypress transition
areas in the dry years. There was no indication of utilization of the 6.37 acres of 624 to be cleared by protected
species. The approximate 11.73 acres that will be preserved and to be rehydrated has a great potential to improve
the conditions of the area and increase wildlife utilization. Creation of the preservation area also insures that there
will be a connection to the 1-75 drainage for "community flow way" to the north of this project. In addition, the
preserve area will be protected by a permanent conservation easement with the SFWMD. The preserve area will
also be managed for restoration of a natural association of vegetation and function. Overall, changes in this
property will have lillle to no effect on protected species detected. Implementation of the preserve area,
enhancement and rehydration of it will increase wildlife utilization and habitat quality on the property, especially
for wetland nriented species; and provide a permanent flow way for the natural flow of water form the north. This
area is not expected to have a high increase in wildlife utilization due to the proximity to 1-75.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Repon
15 June 2008
Page 9
APPENDIX 0
REFERENCES
Ashton, R. E., Jr., and P. S. Ashton. 1988a. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 3: The amphibians.
Windward Pub!., Inc., Miami, Florida.
_. 1988b. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 1: The snakes, 2nd ed. Windward Pub!., Inc.,
Miami, Florida,
_' 1991. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 2: lizards, turtles & crocodilians, 2nd ed. Windward
Publ., Inc., Miami, Florida.
Barbour, D. 8., and S. R. Humphrey. 1982. Status and habitat of the Key Largo wondrat and colton mouse (Neotoma
floridana smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus allapatico1a). J Mammal. 63:144-148,
Barnwell, M. E., P. A. Meylan, and T. Walsh, 1997. The spotted turtle (Clenunys guttata) in central Florida. Chelonian
Cons. BioI. 2:405-408.
Bartlett, R, D., and P. P. Bartlett. 1999. A field guide to Florida reptiles and amphibians. Gulf Pub!. Co., Houston,
Texas.
Berner, 1., and M. 1. Pescador. 1988. The mayflies of Florida. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Birkenholz, D. E. 1963. A study of the life history and ecology of the round-tailed muskrat (Neofiber alleni). Ecolog.
Monogr.33:225-280.
Bortone, S. A. 1989. Notropis melanostomus, a new species of cyprinid fish from the Blackwater-Yellow River drainage
of northwest Florida. Copeia 3:737-74Lstory, habitat assessment, and systematics of the blackmouth shiner
(Notropis sp.), Blackwater
River drainage. Final Rep. Nongame Wildl. Prog., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Bouchard, R, W, 1978. Taxonomy, ecology and phylogeny ofthe subgeuus Depressicambarus, with the description of a
new species from Florida and redescriptions of Cambarus graysoni, Carnbarus latimanus, and Carnbarus striatus
(Decapoda: Cambaridae). Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 3:27-60.
Bowen, P. J. 2000. Demographic, distribution, and metapopulation analyses of the burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia)
in Florida. M.S. thesis, Univ. Central Florida, Orlando.
Brady, J. T., T. H. Kunz, M. D. Tunle, and D. E. Wilson. 1982. Gray bat recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Denver,
Colorado.
Brim Box, J., and J. D, Williams. 2000. Unionid mollusks of the Apalachicola Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia.
Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 21:1-143.
Brody, R. W. 1990. Status of habitat and populations of Procarnbarus pictus in the Nonh Fork of Black Creek, Clay
County, Florida. St. Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida.
Brown, 1. N. 1997. A guide to the mammals of the southeastern United States. Univ. Tennessee Press, Knoxville.
Brown, W. S. 1993. Biology, status, and management of the timber rattlesnake (Crotalus horridus): a guide for
conservation. Soc. Stud. Amphib. Rept. Herp. Circ, 22.
Carle, F. 1., and M. 1. May. 1987. Gomphus (Phanogomphus) westfa1li spec. novo from the Gulf coast of Florida
(Anisoptera: Gomphidae). Odonatologica 16:67- 75.
Chace, F. A., Jr. 1954. Two subterranean shrimps (Decapoda: Caridea) from Florida and the West Indies, with a revised
key to the American species. J. Washington Acad. Sci. 44:318-324.
Chafiu, 1. 2000. Fleld guide to the rare plants of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Chase, C. A., and J. A. Gore. 1989. Snowy plover breeding distribution. Unpubl. final rept., Florida Fish and
Wildl.Conserv. Comm., Tallahassee.
Choate, P. M. 1984. A new species of Cicindela Unnaeus (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae) from Florida, and elevation of C.
abdominalis scabrosa Schaupp to species level. Entomol. News 95:73-82.
Conant, R., and J. T. Collins. 1991. A field guide to reptiles and amphibians: eastern and central North America, 3rd ed.
Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Cox, J., D. Inkley, and R. Kautz. 1987. Ecology and habitat protection needs of gopher tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus)ppopulations found on lands slated for large-scale development in Florida. Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep.
no. 4, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Crance, J. H. 1986. Habitat suitability index models and instream flow suitability curves: shortnose sturgeon. U. S. Fish
WildL Servo BioI. Rep. 82(10.129).
Deitz, D. c., and T. C. Hines. 1980. Alligator nesting in nonh-central Florida. Copeia 1980:249-258.
Delany, M. F., and C. 1. Abercrombie. 1986. American alligator food habits in north-central Florida. J. Wild!. Manag.
50:348-353,
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Report
lS June 2008
Page 10
APPENDIX 0
Delany, M. F., P.B. Walsh, B. Pranty, and D.W. Perkins. 1999. A previously unknown population of Florida
grasshopper sparrow on Avon Park Air Force Range. Florida Field Nat. 27(2):52-56.
Deyrup, M., and R. Franz (eds.). 1994. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. IV: lnvertebrates. Univ. Press of
Florida, Gainesville.
Dodd, C. K., Jr. 1988. Synopsis of the biological data on the loggerhead sea turtle Carella carella (Unnaeus 1758). U.S.
Fish WildL Serv. BioI. Rep.88(l4).
Duggins, C. F., Jr., A. A. Karlin, K. Relyea, andR. W. Yerger. 1986. Systematics of the key silverside, Menidia
conchorum, with comments on other Menidia species (pisces: Atherinidae). Tulane Stud. ZooL Bot. 25(2):133-
150.
Dunkle, S. W. 1989. Dragonflies of the Florida Peninsula, Bermuda and the Bahamas. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville,
Florida.
_.2000. Dragonflies through binoculars: A field guide to the dragonflies of North America. Oxford Univ. Press,
New York.
Dunn, J. 1999. National Geographic Society field guide to the birds of North America. 3rd ed. National Geographic
Soc., Washington, D.C.
Emmel, T. C., and M. C. Minno. 1988. Habitat requirements and status of the endemic Schaus swallowtail in the Florida
Keys. Final report, Florida Game and Fresb Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Enge, K. M., M. M. Bentzien, and F. Percival. 1986. Florida scrub lizard status survey. Tech. Rept. No. 26 to U.S. Fish
WildL Serv., Jacksonville End. Sp. Office, Florida.
Ernst, C. H., and R. W. Barbour. 1989. Snakes of eastern North America. George Mason Univ. Press, Fairfax, Virginia.
Ernst, C. H., J. E. Lovich, and R. W. Barbour. 1994. Turtles of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian lnst. Press,
Washington, D.C.
Ewert, M. A., and D. R. Jackson. 1994. Nesting ecology of the alligator snapping turtle (Macroclernys temminckii)
along the lower Apalachicola River, Florida. Final Rep. NG89-020, Nongame Wildlife Prog. Florida Game and
Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Fitzpatrick, J. W., G. E. W oolfenden, and M. T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related habitat requirements
of the Florida scrub jay (Aphelocorna coerulescens coerulescens). Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 8,
Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003. Management Plan Red-Cockaded Woodpecker Picoides
borealis. Tallahassee, FL 78 pp.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003, October 8. Florida's Waterbird Colony Locator.
http://www.myfwc.comlwaders.
Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2006. Eagle nest locator. http://wld.fwc.state.fl.usieagle/eaglenests.
Florida Natural Areas lnventory. 1990. Guide to the natural communities of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory
and Florida Dept. Natural Resources, Tallahassee.
Franz, R. 1986. The Florida gopher frog and the Florida pine snake as burrow associates of the gopher tortoise in
northem Florida. Pp. 16-20 in D. R Jackson and R. J. Bryant (eds.). The gopher tortoise and its community.
Proc. 5 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council, Gainesville, Florida.
Franz, R., and L. M. Franz. 1979. Distribution, habitat preference and status of populations of the Black Creek crayfish,
Procanlbarus (Ortmannicus) piClUS (Decapoda: Cambaridae). Florida Sci. 42:13-17.
Franz, R, and L. L. Smith. 1999. Distribution and status of the striped newt and Florida gopher frog in peninsular
Florida. Final Rep. Florida Fish and WildL Cons. Comm., Tallahassee.
Gaby, R., M. P. McMahon, F. J. Mazzotti, W. N. Gillies, and J. R. Wilcox. J 985. Ecology and status of a population of
Crocodylus acutus (Reptilia: Crocodilidae) at a power plant site in Florida. J. HerpetoL 19:189- J 98.
Georgia Department of Natural Resources. 1999. Protected animals of Georgia. Nongame - Endangered Wildlife
Program, Wildlife Res. Div., Georgia Dept. NaL Res., Social Circle.
Gilbert, C. R (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. 4: Fishes. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
_(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, voL n: Fisbes. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Glassberg, J., M. C. Minuo, and J. V. Calhoun. 2000. Butterflies through binoculars: a field, finding, and gardening
guide to butterflies in Florida. Oxford Univ. Press, New York.
Gordon, M. E., and W. R Hoeh. 1993. Anodonta heardi,a new species of freshwater mussel (Bivalvia:Unionidae) from
the Apalachicola River system of the southeastern United Stares. Walkerana 7:265-273.
Gore, J. A., and M. J. Kinnison. 1991. Hatching success in roof and ground colonies ofleast terns. The Condor 93:759-
762.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 11
APPENDIX 0
Guillory, V. 1979. Lake Eustis pupfish investigations. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fisb Commission 1977-1979 Final
Report: Study 1-N. Tallahassee.
Guillory, V., and W. E. Johnson. 1986. Hahitat, conservation status, and zoogeography of the cyprinodont fish,
Cyprinodon variegatus hubbsi (Carr). The Southwestern Nat. 31(1):95-100.
Hall, E. R 1981. Mammals of North America. 2 nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Harvey, M. J. 1992. Bats of the eastern United States. Arkansas Game and Fish Comm., Little Rock.
Hersh, S.L. 1981. Ecology of the Key Largo woodrat (Neostoma floridana smalli). J. Mammal. 62:201-206.
Hipes, D., D. R. Jackson, K. NeSmith, D. Printiss and K Brandt. 2001. Field guide to the rare animals of Florida.
Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Hirth, H. F. 1971. Synopsis of the biological data on the green turtle Chelonia mydas (Linnaeus) 1758. FAO Fish.
Synopsis 85.
Hobbs, H. H., Jr. 1942. The crayfishes of Florida. Univ. Florida Publ., BioI. Sci. Ser. 3(2):1-179.
Hoehn, T. S. 1998. Rare and imperiled fish species of Florida: a watershed perspective. Office Envir. Serv., Florida
Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Hovis, J. A., and M. S. Robson. 1989. Breeding status and distribution of the least tem in the Florida Keys. Florida Field
Nat 17(3):61-66.
Humphrey, S. R. (ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. 1: Manuna1s. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville
Humphrey, S. R. 1988. Density estimates of the endangered Key Largo woodrat and cotton mouse (Neotoma floridana
smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola) using the nested-grid approach. J. Mammal. 69(3):524-531.
Humphrey, S. R, and H. W. Setzer. 1989. Geographic variation and taxonomic revision of mink (Mustela vison) in
Florida. J. Manuna1. 17:382-392.
Hurst, H. N., G. Bass, and C. Hubbs. 1975. The biology of the Guadalupe, Suwannee, and redeye basses. Pp. 47-53 in
R. H. Stroud and H. Clepper (cds.).
Black bass biology and management. Sport Fishing Institute,Washington, D.C. Jackson, D. R., and R. Franz. 1999.
Survey for the fire-back crayfish in the Apalachicola ravine system, northern Florida. FInal report to The Nature
Conservancy. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Jackson, D. R., and E. G. Milstrey. 1989. The fauna of gopher tortoise burrows. Pp. 86-98 in J. E. Diemer, D. R.
Jackson, J. L. Landers,J. N. Layne, and D. A. Wood, eds. Gopher Tortoise Relocation Symposium
Proceedings. Nongame WildL Program Tech. Rep. no. 5. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm.,
Tallahassee.
Jackson, D. R., and R. N. Walker. 1997. Reproduction in the Suwannee cooter, Pseudemys concinna suwanniensis.
Bull. Florida Mus. NaL Hist. 41 :69-167.
Jackson, 1. F. 1973. Distribution and population phenetics of the Florida scrub lizard, Sceloporus woodi. Copeia
1973:746-761.
Jackson, J. F., and S. R. Telford. 1974. Reproductive ecology of the Florida scrub lizard, Sceloporus woodi. Copeia
1974:689-694.
James, F. C. 1991. Signs of trouble in tlle largest remaining population of red-cockaded woodpeckers. Auk 108:419-
423.
Johnson, S. A. 2001. Autecology of the striped newt (Notophthalmus perstriatus): life-history, upland-habitat use,
pacdomorphosis, and conservation genetics. Ph.D. diss., Univ. Florida, Gainesville.
Kale, H. W., n. (cd.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. 2. Birds. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville.
Kale, H. W.,ll., B. Pranty, B. Stith, and W. Biggs. 1992. An atlas of Florida's breeding birds. Final Rep.
Nongame Wildlife Prog., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Keppner, E. J., and L. A. Keppner. 2000. A preliminary search for the Panama City crayfish, Procambarus
(Leconticambarus) econfinae, Hobbs, 1942, in Bay County, Florida. Report to U.S. Fish WildL Serv., Panama
City, Florida.
Knisley, C. B., and J. M. Hill. 1994. Studies ofthe Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: distribution,
abundance, habitat characteristics and biology. Report to U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Jacksonville, Florida.
_. 1996. The Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: habitat requirements. remaining range, life
history, and management. Final Rep. Florida Nongame Wildlife Prog. NG9l-Ol2, Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee.
Kulhavey, D. L., R. G. Hooper, and R. Costa (eds.). J 995. Red-cockaded woodpecker: recovery, ecology, and
management. Center for Applied Studies in Forests, College of Forestry, Stephen F. Austin State Univ.,
Nacogdoches, Texas.
Yahl Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 PrOICC\ed Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 12
APPENDIX 0
Kushlan, J. A. 1974. Observations on the role of the American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) in the southern
Florida wetlands. Copeia 1974:993-996.
_' and F. J. Mazzotti. 1989. Population biology of the American crocodile. J. HerpetoL 23:7-21.
Lazell, J. D., Jr. 1989. Wildlife of the Florida Keys: a natural history. Island Press, Washington, D.C.
Layne, J. N. 1990. The Florida mouse. Pp. 1-21 in C. K Dodd, Jr., R. E. Ashton, Jr., R. Franz, and E. Wester (eds.).
Burrow Associates of the Gopher Tortoise. Proc. 8 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council. Florida Mus. Nat.
Hist., Gainesville.
Loftin, R. W. 1992. Use of nest boxes by the Florida kestrel. Florida Field Nat. 20(3):57-64.
McMillian, M. 2001. Florida lmportam Bird Areas Program, site nomination form -Lake lstokpoga, Audubon of Florida,
Tampa Bay Sanctuaries.
McNair, D. B., and J. A Gore. 1999. Recent breeding status of royal and sandwich terns in northwest Florida. Florida
Field Nat. 27(3):1l7-]20.
Maehr, D. S. 1987. Florida panther movements, social organization, and habitat utilization. E-l-l] annual perfonnance
report. Florida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm., Tallabassee.
Martin, W. H., and D. B. Means. 1998. Distribution and habitat relationships of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake
(Crotalus adamanteus). Herpetological Nat. Hist. 7:9-34.
Means, D. B. 1975. Competitive exclusion along a habitat gradient between two species of salamanders (Desmognathus)
in western Florida. J. Biogeog. 2:253- 263.
Means, D. B., and A. A. Karlan. 1989. A new species of Desmognathus from the eastern Gulf Coastal Plain.
Herpetologica 45:37-46.
Means, D. B., and C. J. Longden. 1970. Observations on the occurrence of Desmognathus monticola in Florida.
Herpetologica 26:396-399.
_. ] 976. Aspects of the biology and zoogeography of the pine barrens treefrog, Hyla andersonii, in northern
Florida. Herpetologica 32:] 17-130.
Means, D. B., and P. E. Moler. 1979. The pine barrens treefrog: fire, seepage bogs, and management implications. Pp.
77-83 in R. R Odom and 1. Landers (eds.). Proc. rare and endangered wildlife symposium. Georgia Dept. Nat.
Res.. Game and Fish Div. Tech. Bull. WL-4.
Meylan, A. B. 1999. Status of the hawksbilJ turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region. Chelonian Cons.
BioI. 3:177-184.
_, and M. Donnelly. ]999. Status justification for listing the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) as Critically
Endangered on the ]9961UCN Red List of Threatened Animals. Chelonian Cons. BioI. 3:200-224.
Mettee, M. F., P. E. O'Neil, and J. M. Pierson. 1996. Fishes of Alabama and the Mobile Basin. Oxmoor House, ]nc.,
Birmingham, Alabama.
Minno, M. c., and D. Pierce. 1999. Florida butterfly gardening: A complete guide to attracting, identifying, and
enjoying butterflies of the lower south. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Mitchell, 1. C. 1977. Geographic variation of Elaphe guttata (Reptilia: Serpeutes) in the Atlantic coastal plain. Copeia
1977:33-41.
Moler, P. E. 1981. Notes on Hyla andersonii in Florida and Alabama. 1. Herpetol. 15:441-444.
_' 1985. A new species of frog (Ranidae: Rana) from northwestern Florida. Copeia 1985:379-383.
_(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. ill: Amphibians and reptiles. Univ. Press of Florida,
Gainesville.
_. 1996. Alligator snapping turtle: distribution and relative abundance. Final report 7544. Florida Game and Fresh
Water Fish Conun., Tallabassee.
Mount, R H. 1975. The reptiles and amphibians of Alabama. Auburn Univ. Agric. Exp. Station, Aubum, Alabama.
Myers, R 1., and 1. J. Ewel (eds.) 1990. Ecosystems of Florida. Univ. Central Florida Press, Orlando.
NatureServe. 2006. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 5.0. NatureServe,
Arlington, Virginia. http://www.natureserve.org/explorer.
Neill, W. T. 1971. The last of the ruling reptiles: alligators, crocodiles, and their kin. Columbia Univ. Press, New York.
Page, 1. M., and B. M. Burr. 1998. A field guide to freshwater fishes: North America north of Mexico, 2nd ed.
Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Paul, R. T. 1991. Status report- Egretta rufescens (Gmelin) reddish egret. u.s_ Fish Wildl. Serv., Houston, Texas.
_, and A. F. Schnapf. 2000. Florida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomina-tion form - Passage Key National
Wildlife Refuge, Audubon of Florida, Tampa Bay Sanctuaries.
Pennal<, R. W. 1978. Fresh-water invertebrates of the United States. 2nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York.
YahI Mulching
SDP" AA 7633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 13
APPENDIX 0
Peterson, R.T. 1998. Peterson field guide to eastern birds. 4th ed. Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
Petranka, J. W. 1998. Salamanders of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Inst. Press, Washington, D.C.
Pilsbry, H. A. 1946. Land Mollusca of North America, VoL 2, part 1. Monograph of the Academy of Natural Sciences,
Philadelphia.
Piuun, S. (ed.). 2000. The 2000 Cape Sable sparrow annual report. Accessed 2001 May 8.
Poole, A., and F. Gill (eds.). 1992-2000. The birds of North America. The Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia,
and The American Ornithologists' Union, Wasbington, D.C.
Post, W., and J. S. Greenlaw. 2000. The present and future of the Cape Sable seaside sparrow. Florida Field Nat.
28(3):93-11 O.
Pranty, B. 1996. A birder's guide to Florida. American Birding Association, Inc., Colorado Springs, Colorado.
Printiss, D. J., and D. 1. Hipes. 1999. Rare amphibian and reptile survey of Eglin Air Force Base, Florida. Final report
to U.S. Dept. of Defense. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee.
Pritchard, P. C. H. 1989. The alligator snapping turtle: biology and conservation. Mi]waukee PubL Mus., Milwaukee,
Wisconsin.
Quay, T. 1., J. B. Funderburg, Jr., D. S. Lee, E. F. Potter, and C. S. Robbins (cds.). 1983. The seaside sparrow, its
biology and management. Occ. Papers, North arolina BioL Surv. North Carolina State Mus. Nat. Hist., Raleigh.
Relyea, K., and B. Sutton. 1975. A new troglobitic crayfish of the genus Procambarus from Florida. (Decapoda:
Astacidae). Tnlane Stud. ZooL Bot. 19(1-2):8-16.
Rice, D. W. 1957. Life history and ecology of Myotis austroriparius in Florida. J. Mammal. 38:15,32.
Robbins, C. S., B. Bruun, and H. S. Zim. 2001. Birds of North America: a guide to field identification. St. Martin's
Press, New York.
Rodgers, J. A., and H. T. Smith. 1995. Set-back distances to protect nesting bird colnnies from human disturbance in
Florida. Conserv. BioL 9:89-99.
Rodgers, J, A., Jr., H. W. Kale II, and H. T. Smith (eds.). 1996. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, voL V: Birds.
Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville.
Robertson, W. B., Jr" and G. E. Woolfenden. 1992. Florida bird species: an annotated list. Florida OmithoL Soc. Spec.
Pub. no. 6: ix + 260.
Roosenburg, W. M. 2oo0.lmpact of a bycatch reduction device on diamondback terrapin and blue crab capture in crab
pols. EcoL Applic. 10:882-889.
Ross, J. P., S. Beavers, D. Mundell, and M. Airth-Kindree. 1989. The status of Kemp's ridley. Center Marine Conserv.,
Washington, D.C.
Runde, D., J. Gore, J. Hovis, M. Robson, and P. SouthalL 1991. Florida atlas of breeding sites for herons and their
allies: update 1986 - ]989. Nongame Wildlife Program Tech. Rep. no. 10. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comm., Tallahassee.
Semlitsch, R D. 1983. Structure and dynamics of two breeding populations of the eastem tiger salamander, Amhystoma
tigrinum. Copeia 1983:608-616.
Shealy, R. M. 1976. The natural history of the Alabama map turtle, Graptemys pulchra Baur, in Alabama. BulL Florida
State Mus., BioL Sci. 21:47-11.
Shriver, G. W., P. D. Vickery, and S. A. Hedges. 1996. Effects of summer burns on Florida grasshopper sparrows.
Florida Field Nat. 24(3):68-73.
Sibley, D. A. 2000. The Sibley guide to birds. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
Spotila, 1. R., A. E. Dunham, A. 1. Leslie, A. C. Steyermark, P. T. Plotkin, and F. V. Paladino. 1996. Worldwide
population decline of Dermochelys coriacca: are leatherback turtles going extinct? Chelonian Cons. BioL
2:209-222.
Sprandel, G. 1., J. A. Gore, and D. T. Cobb. 1997. Winter shorebird survey. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm.
Final Perf. Rep. Tallahassee.
Stevenson. H. M. 1970. Occurrence of the carpenter frog in Florida. Quart. J. Florida Acad. ScL 32:233,235.
_, and B. H. Anderson. 1994. The birdlife of Florida. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville. Stys, B. 1993. Ecology
and habitat protection needs of the southeastem American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) on large-scale
development sites in Florida. Nongame Wildt Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 13. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
Comrn., Tallahassee.
Telford, S. R. 1959. A study of the sand skink, Neoseps reynoldsL CopeiaI959:100- 119.
Tenant, A. 1997. A field guide to snakes of Florida. GulfPubL Co., Houston, Texas.
YaM Mulching
SDPA AR 7633
Spring 2008 Protected Species Report
15 June 2008
Page 14
APPENDIX 0
Timmerman, W. W. 1989. Home range, habitat use and behavior of the eastem diamondback rattlesnake. M. S. thesis,
Un;v. Florida, Gainesville.
Thaxton, J. E., and T. M. Hingtgen. 1996. Effects of suburbanization and babitat fragmentation on Florida scrub-jay
dispersal. Florida Field Nat. 24(2):25-37.
Toland, B. 1999a. Nesting success and productivity of Florida sandhill cranes on natural and developed sites in
southeastern Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(1):10- 13.
_' 1999b. Nest site characteristics, breeding phenology, and nesting success of American oystercatchers in Indian
River County, Florida. Florida Field Nal27(3):112-l16.
Tuberville, T D., J. R. Bodie, J. B. Jensen, L. LaClaire, and 1. W. Gibbons. 2000. Apparent decline of the southern hog-
nosed snake, Heterodon sirnus. J. Elisha Mitchell Soc. 116:19-40.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1982. Stock Island tree snail recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_.1984. American crocodile recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia.
_.1987. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; proposed threatened status for two Florida lizards. Fed.
Reg. 52(13):2242-2246.
_. 1998a. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; 90-day finding for a petition to delist the Squirrel
Chimney cave shrimp. Fed. Reg. 63:67618-67619.
_' 1998b. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; detennination of endangered status for five freshwater
mussels and threatened status for two freshwater mussels from the eastern Gulf Slope drainages of Alabama,
Florida, and Georgia. Fed. Reg. 63(50):12664-12687.
_' 1998c. Okaloosa darter (Etheostoma okaloosae) recovery plan (revised). U,S. Fish Wildl. Servo Atlanta, Georgia.
_' 1999. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; final rule to list the flatwoods salamander as a threatened
species. Fed. Reg. 64:15691-15704.
_. 1999. South Florida Multi-Species Recovery Plan U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. 2172 pp.
_' 2000. Candidate and listing priority assignment form: Cicindela highlandensis.
_.2006. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service The Endangered Species Program [web application]. US Fish & Wildlife
Service. Washington, D.C. http://www.fws.gov/endangered
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Gulf States Marine Fisheries Conunission. 1995.Gulf Sturgeon Recovery Plan.
Atlanta, Georgia.
Walls, J. G. 1976. Fishes of the northem Gulf of Mexico. T. F H. Publications, Inc., Ltd., Hong Kong.
Whitaker, J. 0.1996. National Audubon Society field guide to North American mammals. Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
Williams, J. D., and G. H. Burgess. 1999. A new species of bass, Micropterus cataraCIae (Teleostei: Centrarchidae),
from the Apalachicola River basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Bull. Florida Mus. Nat. Hist. 42(2):81-
114.
Witzell, W. N. 1983. Synopsis of the biological data on the hawksbill turtle Eretmochelys imbricata (LinnaellS, 1766).
FAO Fish. Synopsis 137.
Wood, P. B., M. L Hoffman, M. W. Collopy, and J. M. Schaefer. 1988. Southeastern American kestrel (Falco
sparverius paulus) natural history, life requirements, and habitat protection guidelines. Final report to Office of
Envir. Services, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comrn., Tallahassee.
Woods, C. A., W. Post, and C. W. Kilpatrick. 1982. Microtus pennsylvanicus (Rodentia; Muridae) in Florida: a
Pleistocene relict in a coastal saltmarsh. Bull. Florida State Mus. BioI. Sci. 28:25-52.
Wooley, C. M., and E. J. Crateau. 1985. Movemeut, microhabitat, exploitation, and management of Gulf of Mexico
sturgeon, Apalachicola River, Florida. North American J. Fisheries Manag. 5:590-605.
Wunderlin, R.P. 1998, Guide to the vascular plants of Florida. University Presses of
Florida, Gainesville, Florida
Zambrano, R., M. S. Robson, D. Y. Chametzky, and H. T. Smith. 1997. Distribution and status ofleasttern nesting
colonies in southeast Florida. Florida Field Nat. 25(3):85-91.
Zambrano, R., R, H. T. Smith, and M. Robson. 2000. Summary of breeding roseate toms in the Florida Keys: 1974-
1998. Florida Field Nat. 28(2):64-68.
PROJECT LOCATIOIAPPENDIX 0
YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE, NAPLES, FL
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St.
Naples.FL 34120
239.564.1660
.-
-I ,. ,-
5
,
o
10
15 Miles
,
5
PROJECT:
Figure 1. Project Location Map In Collier County; UPDATED 12.29.06
Yahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, Twn 49, Rge 27, totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
N
W+E
S
FLUCCSNEGETATION MAP; SUAPPENOIX 0 S
ltfi
0.7AC
t1
at' ltf
0.3 AC O. AC
lli4l8146
15.8AC
N
fE
S
,
, , SURVEY ROUTE
ID I N:. 'LUCfCI
ItJ~=
tuil!=
i i:1 ..
1 a~ m
U~ ==
TOTAl. aCREl2L8
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
100
,
o
100 200 Feet
Yahl Mul~hlng EXl!anslon Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31, TWn lI9, Kge 27, totaling approXimately 28.8 acres.
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Napl,,!~FL 34120
239.5_.1660
Figure 2. FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; Survey Routes.
PRESERVE AREA MjAPPENDIX 0
PRESERVE AREA I
PARCELID
#4 621
#5 624
#6 624/8146
#9 624
#11621
1.57 AC
2.82 AC
0.24 AC
4.70 AC
2.40 AC
TOTAL
11.73 AC
N
W+.
PROJECT: YAHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
Yahl Mpll<hlnlLExllansill.n PIP"c;el 2250 W;lShbllm Ave.
sec. 31, Twn'l9, Rge 27, totalln~ approximately 28.8 heres.
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 4th St. NW
Naples, FL 34120
239.564.1660
Figure 2. Preserve Area Map.
LIST OF USFWS AND FWC PROTECTEAPPENDIX 0
FOR COLLIER CO., FL. AS OF 01/30/08
caMMON NAME
.cl~NTI"IC NAMII!:
DESIGNATttD STATUS
2001 ZOOI
PWC .ws
AMPHIBIANS
1il:00hecfroll
BJllDS
C:;apcSablescasidclparro....
Florida pnhopper SpWTOW
FIQrid.a scrub jny
llmpkin
Florida bunowinll owl
jvory_bilk.Owoodpockcr
C\lbllll.finowyplo~
piplnJ:plover
K.inhlntl'SWarbICT
link blue heron
R,Jdub qreI
JnoW)'egrel
lricolorcdbnotl
whitclbls
p"l'8SfinefaJ,c{>1I
Soulb_tern Amcriclln kestrel
Florid" undhin cTWIC
Amcril::&lIoy,lcn:8tcber
l>>.ldea&1e
WOO<:\IIOrk
brownpe1ican
~-cocbd~ woodpeckec-
ro~ltclpoonbm
cn::~dctBCara
Eyu;ladnsuilkilc
black skimmer
~tlcm
toseatctem
~bmo.n',warbkr
FISH
smalhoothJGWflSh
riwlul(mangmvcrivulut)
MAMMALS
tci",hal.:
nn whalll (fiftbac!<" whak)
Nonh Allantic nanl whllk
FIoridamastlf(bll
humpbad;wbl1le
Caribbc:~monkteal
EVCfIladesmink
spumwhak
Aoridapan.tber
BiJCypreu(tI';'lqllluel
AoridafWc...'t Indian ml.natc:c:
Aaridl.blae\cbc:ar
REPTILES
Amni<:anamptor
jOtlubc:ad.ellll.lnlt
vn:c:nsealurth:
Amnicl.ncl"O<lodik
ica1.herb/lcksemrtk
Ea.llemind.liosnako:
hawksbiDsc:at\lnle
gopherlOrtoise
K.emp'srklleyseal\lrtJ/O
INVERTEBRA1ES
MOLLUSKS
Florid. IT" lnail
PLA""
(NONE)
R.rmacapilo
Ammodrall'u~ mo.,lr/m.utrliro.biJ;4
ArllmodramU8 sll\IQ"rwnrmflo,,"danllS
Aphc-loconuJ co.,ru.l.~c:cns
AromlU,lI"rolona
AthCII.c..nlclIl<r.ria (ArhclIl!'
cunlclI/Driafloridunll)
CampriphilJu principali4
Chamdrl"sQlriJUllldri"us
CharudrllU nldoDlIs
IN,ulro;CQ kirl,""dU
EKr.lto.Co.C""M
EKrcUa rvfn~.ns
E,r."a'huw
Egr."nlrlcDlor
Eudoci1lll'~ ..u...,
Falcopri""rlfl'u
Falco Sp<I,....,riut p,W11l8
C;"ucrulad.nslspra'Uls;8
Humo'oplls palfJo'"s
Hr,(Jl1cdus k'4Couphr.lus
M)'curioanrririctmtl
Pc&t:c"im,/.SoccldltnUJlis
Pit'Oldl!'sbDntllls
Pklt,,zcaGjajaCNa'atJjajn)
1'0l)lOO",s plancws ollnl/hlmli
(CaraCQ,.och.ri_y)
1(0",.1IIr"""$ wciabilis pll/mk~u
Rynchops "i,u
Slltmaantlllarum
SUmt!. 401/801/1 (SUl1la dOllga/UI
douroJfIi)
V~rmlvora bachmanii
Prlst/sp'c,'"o,O
RiP/l/llsma".lDro"LJ
Bou..",optera borltolis
/krklltnopurophyslllu~
WllIluna ,ladll{js (Saklcna
gllldoUs {JItt'~fll/llraZ;sj)
Ewnopl1 gla14c1nusjJorldaflUS
Mri,tlpttrfltullltU01llNce
MonccAAs/roplt:t1Us
MIIs'rlflll/sDnwerglDdrns;s
Ph)'Sff'u mfI"rrx~pMbts
Pruroa(F,Us)conctll4rcoryl
Scillfllsn1SCfa",lc'l>Inio
Trlchcchu4 manarus lAr'roslns
(Ts-icMchMsmollanrs)
Un'" amulcr",..sflon"d"n'"
AII/'f"Of mJS~JIS/pp/~nsjs
Car..."acoritl/n
Chdcm/lIm:JdrlS
CfOc04ylwflcuWlf
D~rmoch.lys cofiw:c"
Dry1nKlfl:llo"coralscol/prr;
Eutm,.ch~I}'slmbric"/a
atlphltTIIS polyphltmOlI1
Ltpldoch,I)I,umpil
U,w.sfiucl"'l/s
SSCO,2.)
E
E
T
SSC(l)
SSC(l)
E
T
T
E
SSC(1.4)
SSC(l,4)
sscm
SSC(1.4)
SSC(2)
E
T
T
SSC(l,2.)
T
E
SSC(I)
sse
SSC(l,4)
T
.
SSC(I)
T
T
E
SSC(l)
E
E
E
E
E
T
E
E
T
E
T,
SSC(I,3)
T
E
E
E
T
E
T
E
SSC(l)
Proiect: YAHL MULCHING SDPA AR 7633
Figure 4. List ofUSFWS and FWC protected species for Collier Co., FI.
Yahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31. Twn 49. Rge 27. totaling approximately 28.8 acres.
E
E
T
E
T
E
.
E
T
E
T
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
TSIA
T
E.&T~
E
E
T
E
E
Ramsey Inc.
En~ronmel1lal Col1Swling
2631 4'" St NW
Naples,fL )4120
239.564,1660
PROTECTED SPECIES/WILDLIFE FIELD sAPP END IX 0
CUMLA TIVE TOTALS
PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS
PROJECT:
COUNTY:
DATE:
OBSERVER:
TIME START:
TIIME END:
WIND:
TEMP:
RAIN:
CLOUD COV:
WATER:
COMMENTS:
YAHL MULCHING
COLLIER
04/02/08-05/25/08 ALL SURVEYS
AM & PM TOTAL COUNT
M. RAMSEY, M. HUSSION
0610 AM
2015 PM
0-15
61-88 F
NONE
0-20 %
DRY, DROUGHT CONDITIONS
BIRDS
RED SHOULDERED HAWK
BLUEJAY
CARDINAL
PILEATED WOODPECKER
CAT BIRD
GREAT EGRET
CATTLE EGRET
MOCKING BIRD
HAIRY WOODPECKER
RED BELLIED WOODPECKER
GRACKLE
MOURNING DOVE
VULTURE BLACK
GROUND DOVE
VULTURE TURKEY
MALLARD DUCK
MEADOW LARK
MAMMALS
COTTONTAIL RABBIT
(Sylvilagus ftoridanus)
RACCOON
GRAY SQUIRREL
REPTILE
BLACK RATE SNAKE
TOTAL
COUNT
7
10
8
1
13
3
54
22
2
3
16
67
11
22
12
6
1
8
3
15
Proiect: Y AHL MULCHING; Snrinl! 2008
Figure 5. Cumulative totals for Protected Species 1 Wildlife Survey.
Daily field sheets in Appendix C.
Yahl Mulching Expansion Parcel, 2250 Washburn Ave.,
Sec. 31. Two 49. Rj!e 27. totalinj! approximately 28.8 acres.
Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consulting
2631 411I St NW
Nllples, FL 34120
239.564.1660
lit- '~~D ~GE NES~ LOC4-'A~~ENDIIXID -
'* NEST LO A TlON
~
- -
~ ~ it 1
-------,= -
1-11
~
:;:; .;m_~ %//3/';%:;
? 7/ '/ '// <<~/~0 /~'i,//// '/, /I' /7?t0
77'/ (// / '// '/ r//V~
'/ '/, / // 'l~~L/ V~ // / /, i// ///;
7'////// //~'/ '/// / //
, ~,~V;"~,.~~ ff~:,:;;:;:;;-/;;~~r
) /. 7: '/// ~ ~ ."] ~~~
~~!/0 ~/ :~ 7~~~
- j/7it//1/ / jj:.;Jt::'/V ~ '// // /,'N/ /
~-;:~v/;:;;;::1/I// ~0~~ / Wffi -/,7?,;;;:~~
8~~f~(Z~//-/'/"/~ ~m '/',-7%%0%%0.;;:'
~ // ~ / // '// /////17/00 /, //,%
- 0/~~ffi~~00~ :L;~ ~~~~~~//
~~//:J/A/N~~ V~' '// 'i'l: /I'/~ '/
o 0j///,//// '0 0/ k ~~~<<~~0~
~~~ / ~~~;~~~~~~t~[t0V/'l.;~%%
0//0 j~~I/ ~~ ~ 'l/7/~~0~0~/~:;
40( ~<</ /:/>/1/: /;/~ 0~///; ~.;J~00/>~
~//Vff~/I/~j '7 '//////1 //,,1///////,'//1//////// '//~/
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION w-tE
WASHBURN AVE. NAPLES. FL
s
Figure 6. Bald Eagle Location Map; Ramsey Inc.
Environmental Consultln9
2631 4th St. NW
I:hl rf.l~n\&XRans~~n par~el 2250 Wr.shb~m:Av,. Nalles.l!FL 34120
e. , n , ge , tota ins approx mate Y . heres. 23 .56 .1660 I
"'
'0;
>.
ro
c:
<(
It)
_ <II
c: 0.
~ E
oS:: "'
U Q)
ctl+:i
::;:: :=
<( U
<II
u..
.2
:0
::I
0...
"1ft
:&
..
~
.~
...
Ij
'"
'C
u;
::>
"0
E
a-
D
i
'"
s:
,..
~
..
~
!is;
."
g
i
c:
;jii;i.
!,
.9'"-~
S1~ CD
1=:5-5
oS! .2;0-0 C
ClJ .- Co Q)
:J :0 (tJ E
C'coE4:
~~l3)"O
<( ~o '"
'0 Ql ~
"'",0.
g.::; e
U "-
% ~
c::~-gM
:5 Q t> 0.._ U')
<(::-~l3g Ol
g~~j6 ~
N'S () (I)
'" >0
'" "'
.. ,
Ol
~.
Ol
:is
.l!I
o
l1.
i2' _
.s 0
"5a.t'J
S1:!:E
"'c:>:;:"
'" '" C
~:E~
!E'g
" 0 '"
S'::e
a; <(
z
roB
a.~
;;:~Q
"",,,-
"0_"
4:.E:~
O'OC/)
ti g!.o
",,,,-,
c.>
E C
-8
~
~
~.
E
..
"
'D.
$,
-g ~ ~
(Q00-
E 1:) . to
Q) Ui ~ a
o ,WaI
~~l5~
'(ij <; cD
Ou... ,Q c..
. ..... '0 C)
O)Q)Q)-
~ 0.(1)
~
'i/j to_
CN '"
2 01 Q)
C C '"
iijE~
'C :J c.
-"'E
~<'l",
'C -
E
" ~
'" 0> '"
[.5: ~
ol(l-
0i.,l3
~ c...!!!
o !!:.
~
z
ill
>-
..
8
0:;
~
Ol
Ul.
~'
.l!I
'2
'"
UlI
~
'"
o
o
ui
~
'"
N
~
;;
N
'"
'C
u;
::>
"0
.=
.8........
'" '" C
.~ -g ~
>-:::>"0
.9:l Z'-o c
C'Cl=c:11l
::1'0 ro E
"''''E<(
-8!!::","O
<( ~o '"
.0..... ~
'" '" 0.
g:; e
U a.
'0 .~
a::~i~
5<( e. u2 g. 0-
-....(,)(,9
;g~~E~
oC:oQ,)-
C\l'$O~
&! UJ
0>
C -
'" 0
"5n.C)
ill;!;::;;
Cl:t?::
'" '" C
~ ~ ~
e!E"O
g e [;
--E
a; <(
z
~
u
..
c.
..
(,)
s
..
"
Z'
:Jl,
!\!'
'"
c
..
E
'.~
~
I
I--
I'
I,
I'
t'U :5
c~
.Q.~-
:'6c:o
'Q.'!Ja.
<t=~
o'OCI)
ti ~o
",,,,-,
c.>
E C
-8
.'
II,
;;
"
li
"
"0 "'
c ~o
rocno-
E:S...: S
Q) (J) "'( '5.
Cl .W ro
>. (,) 'V ()
=<.(CDO
~u.:5ll.
. ..... U C)
03QlQ)-
< a.cn
~
'(;)1,{)_
CN"
JY Ol CD
C C '"
i'E~
'I.: :J a.
1D~E
::><( '"
"0 -
E
.'
"
1:: "C'
'" 0> '"
5,.5 ~
.QKl-m
",., "
~ a...~
o !!:.
~
z
"
'"
>-
"'
N
0;
...
o
o
o
'"
...
'"
Ol'
D) ,.;~.
'""
.5 i',::"
ra ,.
01
I: ,
I
I
o
o
ui
~
'"
N
~
~
o
N
"
,
'"
'C
u;
::>
"0
E
"
,
,
I
I
l:'
'g
..
'g;,
:1'1
(,)
!
'"
-Q"
..
."
0(
~
'0:
C
i
Cl
.;t;i'.
~
B....~
'" '" '"
.~ -g E
>-::>"0
"'~ c
ro='2?'"
::> '0 '" E
O"mE<(
~~C1l'C
<( ~o '"
'g Qi ~
0.",0.
,,::; e
U a.
"
'"
~o~~
:5 ~'~.o
<(.s LL. ~
COCenm
OCUt:(.)
0>:':::;1-
N .5.!!? 0
)(
w
.,'
0>
C
=
~a......
"'::;; c
"'C:>~
"''''"0
:g= lii
e E E
~g<
OJ
z
_ C
'" 0
C~
~._-
'6l'!0
'C.so.
<(cel
---
oll"'
u ~g
'" >
o.c
E 0
-U
:e-
..
"
';;:
'"
"'
-
o
Q;
>
'"
-'
U.'
It
"..
;;
;;'.
..'
'"
."
?
~' .
~
'(i;If)_
CN"
S en C1l
c C '"
i'E~
:silo.
" "' E
::> 0( '"
"0 -
E
C -c
C1l Ol m
~,5>
.Q~ro
",., "
~ o..,~
o !!:.
~
z
"
'"
>-
~
z
'Oasll)
lI)11l;.;;-
eao~E
,-,,-u~o
:21h_ _
0" W 0 tI)
Q)o.~.=>.::::-
~ Q):S: g. n) C
(/).olJ..Q)"9~
O.9U)cr:~w
..J__z.>.
cc~$[:Lb
z 'e~ ;5 ~
CL.su
~
z
>oc
"'0>
'9 'Ci)
"''''
100
>--
J,~
N>
OW
::;; E
~ ~
u.B
UJ"'
~
z
~
o
N
2
~
I
,
11- ~--- -'~';;;'e;"
r- .- E.........Y
I
1
I
I
I
, ,
, 'J'''''<1:
,~.
10
.
o
~
~
g-'--
PINE, RIDGE RD EXT
.
YS X (0 )( y 14
X ~)<XXXx N X ~. V'~"'~"
'xX I')< X X )( )()( )('
~ .~ '* '\('){' X)'
~,- I I ~ (.1)('
;"'i,( ~I)( X,' }(' I
~"" Y
IX)<)(]l. ..,. '\<
r>,,; I, >;Y< ':./\2<> ,
{)< ~ '~~. XX"
~ ~ ",'>< ' , 'x''x
'lNi: IX X'''k ..X I
I~i'l< ~ .~, ,~.X '
X ~. XxX, . ~
'X il<;;' , ',')( , '"Y<)<)( i
,. ')( X ')<. iX '*'>< ,~ !
IW'XV ''),Y')<X'
~ \0
~'35
II ~~<<ir" < 'r.v.'f.R.....N
;~"'l. "DlO" _ - I
.---------;rl '"
I""" ~r
! ..i'.~';,:J;;; I~ 3 2
'lb~e:~
, "
1-' - ," I
23
26
,.~.~~-_._-
~elv~""~_.-
.
11
&00..", '.\I\1~
T"'~"'~
I..
I
Attachment I
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Public FacifWes Exhibit
o
,
2,500 5,000
G9tDe~ GAlE 8LVO '1/
13
24
25
12
N
A
pI JI
I~
10,000
19
30
SUaJECT I
PROPERTY I
~VS.l'
.bk>~
'011I'",
6'."t~
B'
~;
17
16
20
21
Legend
E:::] SuOj<"ClI>'O~'~l
Thl..<l
-Ul'.l""
SE(:l'O,"S
,- ,I_~.~
.....
CAa'or,l""'-.g~oo".'"
_~Io''''''SI'<>'l'P.'~
_ Go....,. ~I. l'-Q....., OM r~""..Lo~""'.
_Go"kwG".Cc"'""'.,'y~'''''''
. Goldo'G'l<Cto"'",""Oyl'an.
_",.4,t<...~.',c..".,"'u~~rl'.'"
_""''''Spr~tN.'9''l><>~dP.,"
_ "ltae._"'I9~~'MO<I"'"
c:JLlMr,.
""
DSOh\'TP
W."oOi.,
Duc_
t::] C<>lh'" C(>~'lly ......,.s."'" Ot$l'l<!
DfG<'AoSol,,-,,"".o.,.,
-
6
* ..~
7
~ ~_","",.rvSl.,",,,.7~
. ,""or)
+ E'~S~!.'",,,,
.: SCHOOlS
-C<lI,.'Co""'yf,.lol~'''l.,...,.
C"h' Coy",y RoO<l,
OISCl....l.lE!'1
18
Q....A'''''l''...OO''...._I?......J>O''''''''......O r...
"""'ft,...""'..""'i...",Irg.m~'P"-_'.....~mG\'..l*\"'"
boW"~ .n11lO_~C'O"'(l<>'~Wt. ,"- T'-_...
:l&poo:leCIb,(n..~.".__ .1'ICI".l101roo<:t1SU,I.
"'......,IO........r"ll"'."ll"'"'"'O..._"'tlw;."IO......,....
..,'-ll""o.,.,....~.~11"'W;lrI"'''''..,...~(I0'''''....1>
15,000
,Feet
D'XTA'"
CO'\i...1...I.TI....C,
..&.,,' u.. ...
.r:.oIll""B .\I"~""7.o14'11
('vill:n~,~ettlft~ .SorHyl"'.!II. MOl'f'\111
P,-1l11are<la~fmJ~
Pnl1l>ng Dale ADIII :l0, 200~
F,le T\P'OJeel~\PrOjecls1D8OO1:l0000\RevOO\F.lCll1tlll!lim.o
Omega
Consulting Group
TRAFFIC IMPACT STATEMENT
FILLMORE RECYCLING CPA
May 2009
White lake Boulevard
Collier County, Florida
Prepared For:
John & Teresa Fillmore
Fillmore LLC
Clo Yahl Mulching
2250 Washburn Avenue
Naples, FL 34117
Prepared By:
Omega Consulting Group, LLC
Attachment J
Traffic Impact Statement
Project # R900S.02
H6S Woods Edge tirde, Unit 101, Bonita Springs, Florid. l4ll4
INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY
Omega Consulting Group, LLC is providing this update to the Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Traffic Impact Statement (TIS) previously prepared by Vanasse & Daylor, LLP for tbe Fillmore
Recycling. Tbe purpose of this study is to provide Collier County with sufficient infonnation to
assure that traffic-related impacts are anticipated and that effective mitigation measures are
identified for the proposed development.
The Fillmore Recycling facility is located northeast ofI-75 & Collier Boulevard interchange to
the southeast of the Collier County Landfill on Washburn Avenue in Township 49, Range 27,
Section 31 in Collier County. The site area is approximately 0016 acres and is currently utilized as
recycling facility for yard waste.
The site will have one full-movement site access onto White Lake Boulevard. Only traffic
generation, distribution, AM and PM traffic assignments, significance test and roadway link
analyses have been prepared for this study.
For purposes of this evaluation, the Buildout Year was assumed to be consistent with the Collier
County 20]4 planning horizon.
CONCLUSIONS. RECOMMENDATIONS AND MITIGATION
The analysis indicated that the estimated Fillmore Recycling facility site-generated trips are
projected to be de minimus (less than 1%) on Collier Boulevard. All roadway segments are
projected to operate within their maximum service volume (SF",,,,) or Level of Service Standard
(LOS).
As shown in Table 5, the levels of service for all links in the area of the project are projected to
meet the level of service standards computed by the AUlR Tables for PM Peak Hour with
Buildout Year Total Traffic. Therefore, no off-site improvements are projected to be required for
this project.
The developer proposes to pay the appropriate Collier County Road Impact Fees.
R900S CPA nS-OOJ.doc
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
EXISTING LAND USE
The Fillmore Recycling facility is located northeast of 1-75 & Collier Boulevard interchange to
the southeast of the Collier County Landfill on Washburn Avenue in Township 49, Range 27,
Section 3 I in Collier County. The site area is approximately II 6 acres and currently utilized as
recycling facility for yard waste. One full-movement access onto White Lake Boulevard is
proposed.
AREA CONDITIONS
SITE ACCESSIBILITY
AREA ROAD SYSTEM
The existing roadway conditions for the area of the project were used to provide the base
Buildout roadway network. Exhibit 1 shows the existing roadways in the vicinity of the project.
The roadway system inside the study area consists of the following arterial and major collector
roads and streets:
Collier Boulevard (CR 951)
Collier Boulevard (CR 951) in the study area will be a north-south four and eight lane divided
arterial roadway under county jurisdiction. The roadway alignment is fairly level and tangent.
The speed limit is posted at 45 miles per hour (mph).
White Lake Boulevard
White Lake Boulevard in the study area is an east-west two-lane local roadway that tenninates at
Collier Boulevard. The roadway alignment is fairly level and tangent. The speed limit is 30 mph.
R9005 CPA TIS-OOl.doc
2
COMMITTED ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS
Roadway improvements are const11lcted to alleviate current area road deficiencies and to support
future area development. For purposes of this study, a "committed" roadway improvement
means that the characteristics of the higher-level facility may be used in the reserve capacity
estimates. Since this is a Comprehensive Plan Amendment TIS, roadway improvements that are
currently under construction or are scheduled to be constructed within the FY 2009 to FY 2011
time frame were considered to be committed improvements. These were identified in the Collier
County 2008 Annual Update and Inventorv Report (AUIR)
. 8.lane expansion of Collier Boulevard near 1-75 interchange and 8-1ane to 4-lane converge near the main
Golden Gate canal is anticipated to be under construction in 20 I 0
TRIP GENERATION
Site-generated trips were estimated using the anticipated operational characteristics of the site
and the expected daily hours of operation. Approximately 500 weekly and 100 daily truck trips
are estimated for the existing yard waste recycling facility entering and exiting the Fillmore
Recycling site. Approximately 10% of the trips are estimated to be from private individuals with
90% coming from commercial sources. It is estimated that about 50% of site truck trips are to
and from the nearby existing land fill site on White Lake Boulevard. The remaining 50% trips
are projected to use Collier Boulevard directly to/from the project site. The proposed
construction debris recycling facility is projected to generate an additional 150 daily truck trips.
It is anticipated that the distribution between private individuals and commercial sources would
be similar. The existing yard waste recycling facility operates with IS full-time employees. An
additional 10 full-time employees will be required to operate the proposed construction debris
recycling facility. Operating hours are anticipated to be 7AM to 5PM averaging 10 hours per
day. Based on the operational characteristics, 150 daily truck trips are expected to be evenly
distributed through 10 working hours.
The site-generated trip estimates that were derived as follows:
1 SO trucks/day = 300 directional truck trips per day := 300 trucks/ J 0 hours = 30 directional truck
trips/hour. Based on anticipated estimates of 50% in and 50% out, then 15 trucks are entering and 15
trucks are exiting the site during AM peak hour; and 15 trucks are entering and 15 trucks are exiting the
site during PM peak hour. 50% of the truck traffic is anticipated to be to/from the existing County landfill,
50% of the truck traffic will access Collier Boulevard. The recycling facility will have an additional 10
R9005 CPA TIS-QOl.doc
employees so at most, there would be I vehicle per employee for 10 vehicles entering in AM and exiting
the site in PM peak hour.
For analytical purposes, the truck component of the estimated site-generated trips was converted
to passenger car equivalents (PCE's) using a truck factor multiplier of 1.7. The multiplier is
based on Exhibit 20-9 from the Highway Capacity Manual 2000 (see Appendix of Original
Vanasse & Daylor, LLP TIS for copy of the exhihit). The site-generated trip estimate results are
shown in Table 1.
TABLE I
AM Peak PM Peak
LAND USE AQI I2!1!l Enter W; ~ fnlli gjt
Estimated Truck Traffic 300 30 15 IS 30 IS IS
Passenger Car Equivalent (peE) multiplier* = 1.7
Truck PCE', 510 52 26 26 52 26 26
Employees 20 10 10 10 10
Total 530 62 36 26 62 26 36
*Per Vanasse & Daylor, LLP TIS
DISTRIBUTION AND ASSIGNMENT
The pattern of site traffic distribution is based on locations of generators in the area surrounding
the project and engineering judgment. Table 2 presents the assumed trip distribution and
assignment. Exhibit 1 graphically presents the trip distribution.
Table 2
Site~generated Trip Distribution and Assignmentl
AM Peak PM Peak
!.ink From To DI5T I2lO! Enter ~ Io.IlJ fm<r <>ill
Collier Blvd Golden Gate Pkwy Utilities Drive 25% 16 9 7 16 7 9
Collier Blvd Utilities Drive 1-75 25% 16 9 7 16 7 9
White Lake Blvd Collier Blvd Land Fill Access 50% 31 18 13 31 13 18
White Lake Blvd land Fill Access Project Access 100% 62 36 26 62 26 36
I All site-generated trips are based on peE values.
ROOD5 CPA TIS-OOl.doc
4
The percentage distributions were applied to the site-generated traffic volumes to detennine the
site-generated vehicle trip assigmnents. Exhibit 2 shows the site-generated trip assignments for
the PM Peak Hour.
SIGNIFICANCE TEST
According to Collier County Land Development Code (LDC) Section 6.02.02 and Collier
County TIS Final Guide Dated 11-03-2006,
"Significantly impacted roadways and intersections are identified based on the following criteria:
a. The proposed project highest peak hour trip generation (net new total trips) based on the peak hour of
the adjacent street traffic will determine the limits of the trip distribution and analysis.
. Trips distributed on links directly accessed by the project where the project traffic by direction is
equal to or exceeds 2% of the peak hour service volume for the adopted LOS standard.
. Trips on one link adjacent to the link directly accessed by the project where the project traffic by
direction is equal to or greater than 2% the peak hour service volume for the adopted LOS standard.
. Trips on all subsequent links where the project traffic by direction is equal to or greater tnan 3% the
peak hour service volume for the adopted LOS standard.
In other words, a project will have a significant and adverse impact on a state or regionally
significant roadway only if both of the following criteria are met: (1) the project will utilize 2
percent or more of the maximum peak hour service volume at the adopted level of service
standard for tbe adjacent and next to adjacent link, 3 percent for the other links; and (2) the
roadway is projected to operate below the adopted level of service standard.
Significance was estimated according to Collier County's 2/2/3 rule, and the links were
evaluated to detennine whether projected operation would be within County standards. The data
resources used for this analysis are shown in the Appendix. Table 3 presents the siguificance test
results.
Table 3
Significance Test
PM Peak
Site PCT of
1ink From 12 Sfmox Trips ~......
Collier Blvd Golden Gate Pkwy Utilities Drive 3,515 9 0.3%
Collier Blvd Utilities Drive 1.75 3,515 7 0.2%
White Lake Blvd Collier Blvd Land Fill Access 760 13 1.7%
White Lake Blvd Land Fill Access Project Access 760 26 3.4%
Note; SF ,.",,, rer White Lake Boulevard were obtained from Thomasson Road and were provided by
T ril.nsportation Staff lor Collier Boulevard
R900S CPA TIS-OOt.doc
The only site-generated trips that were estimated to be significant (>2 percent of the SFmax) were
on White Lake Boulevard between the land fill access and the project. The site-generated trip
assignments were not projected to be significant on any links of the Collier County roadway
network.
PROJECTED BACKGROUND AND TOTAL TRAFFIC VOLUMES
Background traffic volumes were developed using multiple sources. Specific Link volume data
were provided by the Collier County Transportation Department. Data reviewed included the
Collier County Transoortation Goerations Deoartment 2008 Traffic Count Reoort , Collier
County Concurrencv SeRments Tables dated April 4,2009 and the 2008 Collier County AUIR .
The Appendix contains copies ofthe applicable data used.
Per methodology meeting dated April 22, 2008, proposed 4 to 8-lane improvement of Collier
Boulevard near 1-75 interchange was confirmed by Collier County Transportation Staff.
Maximum capacity SFmax 3515 vph for Collier Boulevard between 1-75 and Golden Gate
Boulevard was used in the subsequent analysis in this report, per Collier County Transportation
Staff's instruction.
Table 4 presents the link-specific background traffic data with the information contained in the
Collier County AUlR table for 2007.
Table 4
BACKGROUND TRAFFIC VOLUMES
Based on 2008 Collier County AUIR
.I.lnk
.Er:l>ID-
Max PK Hr
To .sE.AUX I Volume
Trip Total Remaining
Bank ~ ~
Collier Blvd Golden Gate Pkwy 1-75
3,515
1,384
617
2,001
1,514
1 SFmax provided by Colliet County Tran~portation Staff
R9005 CPA TIS-DOI.doc
6
Growth trends have been negative so the AUIR Trip Bank was used as the most conselVative
total volume of background traffic.
ANALYSES
CAPACITY AND LEVEL OF SERVICE
LINK ANALYSES
Link Levels of Service were evaluated for both Background and Total Traffic conditions for this
project. The SFma> for different roadway segments were provided by the Collier County
Transportation Planning Department or from a similar roadway within Collier County as denoted
on the 2008 AUIR Table. Copies of these data are contained in the Appendix. Table 5 presents
the link analysis results.
Table 5
LINK LEVEL OF SERVICE ANALYSIS RESULTS
PM PEAK HOUR W/15td
BKGD Project Total AUIR BKGD Total
Road Se9ments From To illf!i!; Traffic Traffic SFmox illf!i!; illf!i!;
Collier Blvd Golden Gate Pkwy Utilities Dr 2,001 9 2,010 3,515 Y Y
Collier Blvd Utilities Dr 1.75 2,001 7 2.008 3.515 Y Y
The studied links are projected to be within the level of seIVice standards for the PM peak hour
with buildout year Background and Total Traffic.
Based on this analytical result, no further analyses are required. Appropriate turn lanes should be
analyzed during the SDP process for this project.
The developer proposes to pay the appropriate Collier County Road Impact Fees.
R9005 CPA TIS.Q01.doc
7
<:=Jl
.
,
<
~
.,
E
,
~
"
~
( I
0
ct,!;!
0:'5
0:9
- I
"'-
~.!1
'... Q~
1> Q......
~....-
u~~
1 ~..~
Q:.!1
! e ~
o .
e"
~~
;;;
"
~
I
'"
.5
'5
! ~
! :;;
~
O!
(Ji
~ ~~ ...
~ ~ ~~
~.
~i~1
S:;d.:..
it I::~:I
;;
- ~-~
+- '" ~:h
~n-+ &U
JQmo:) ftt
111
~ ~
~ c.
~ Ql,!
0 Q)~
~
~ E~
0 cH
.
.
i'
I
.
~
in
1J
.
'0
-
0.
i1nUiI^Iq'UJnqllnM %001+
i
" ~
. .
". j~
< ."
5~ ~
u~
~~ ",,-1 11 i
.. ~
u ~ ~
~
~
~
'0
0
~ " .
" .~ L"n
.J U
'--"H
"StJ
"n--'
f
~
.
<3
<
.
~
..
~
(=J~
,
.
1
.
~
"
t3
<
.
"
o
~
-.
,--
~
.
>
.,
~
A
-S
~
<l;~
"0
L>~
g>.~
....IIlt'(
1311I1-
~~Qi
!! QI ~~
, Q::"",
~ ~ ~
oct
.5"
:'::::Cl..
"-
!l
in
jj
.
-e
..
.
,
"
~
~
~
t
1
Olnu",^'q'UJnq4sIM
"t
"
o
,=
O;r:
U~
.~ j
8
..
0
:;;
! ~
I :;;
~
.2~
'" "I
~ ~ ~ cj"l!;:.:
+-1 t ...lE:;
~ ,"
.
~ ei~t
c ~ II:;;
~ e Q.!!;:.
[OJ ;; t il~~:t
0
=
~
s
"
;:
.
.,
<5 ;;
. ~-~
. .~~
[..0 L, -,
.J '5 &U
,J ,l~1II0j f!l
dl
"
~ c.
~ Ol! ;'
"5
0 CIl!
=
.~ E~ I
0 C;~ j
ApPENDIX
. Initial Meeting Checklist - April 22, 2008
. Collier County Annual Update Inventory Report (AUIR). 2008
. Excerpt from Collier County Traffic Count Report
. Excerpt from Highway Capacity Manual 2000
Golden Gate Parkway Mixed Use Subdistrict TIS
Appendix
INITIAL MEETING CHECKLIST
APRI l 22, 2008
APPENDIX A
INITIAL MEETING CHECKLIST
Suggestion: Use this Appendix as a worksheet to ensure that uo important elements
are overlooked. Cross out the items tltat do not apply,
Date:04/22/2008
Time: 9:dO
Location: Collier County Planning Conference Room (Trans. Oos.\ SMD Suite 211
People Attendiu\!:
Name, Organization, and Telephone Numbers
I) Reed Jarvi. P.E.-Vanasse & Daylor. LLP 437-4601
2) John Podczerwinskv-CC Transoortation _
3) ~..r 4~"" -6:;. r-r..-~i7n.
4)_
5)_
Studv Preparer:
Preparer's Name and Title: Reed Jarvi. Vice President
Organization: Vanasse & Davlor. LLP
Address & Telephone Number: 12730 New Brittany Blvd. Suite 600
Fort Myers, FL 33907 (239\ 437-4601
Reviewer(s):
Reviewer's Name & Title: John Podczerwinsky. Proiect Manager
Collier County Transportation Planning Department
Reviewer's Name & Title:
Organization & Telephone Nwnber: _
Applicant:
Applicant's Name: John & Teresa Fillmore, Fillmore LLC. Clo Yahl Mulching
Address: 2250 Washburn A yenue, Naoles Florida 34117
Telephone Number: _
Proposed Development:
Name: Fillmore Recycling
Location: On east side of 1-75 & Collier Boulevard interchange. southeast of the
Washburn Avenue & Crawford Avenue intersection in Town5hio 49. Range 27. Section
31 in Collier County. Exhibit I shows the location and study area.
Land Use Type: :to IS Acres site to be used as construction debris reevcling faeility
ITE Code #: N/ A
Proposed number of development units: N/A
Other: N/ A
'.'.f~...,,,:;;';'~lf,;r J~_r'~~.l!J!~,r;: :,;.;','J<',,'
Description: NIA
Zoning: Rural Fringe Mixed Use District fRFMUD)
Existing: Urban
Comprehensive plan recommendation: Growth Management Plan Amendment
Requested: N/A
Findings of the Preliminary Study:
Trip Generation: This proiect is proiected to generate 62 PM Peak Hour net new
(primarv) trius (26 entering. 36 exiting), 62 AM Peak Hour net new trips (36 entering, 26
exiting) Exhibits 2.3 and 4 present trip distribution. AM and PM Peak Hour Site Trip
Assignments.
Studv TVlle:
~ (WIJ-f{..-
t1iiD Minor TIS l8! 4r 1~ r
o ~L~~),
Study Area: ClwK"v /'
Boundaries: Collier Boulevard & Utilities Drive/White Lake Bouleyard intersection (see ~.
Exhibit I) (
Small Scale TIS
Maior TIS
Additional intersections to be analyzed: N/A
Horizon Year(s): 2013
Analysis Time Period(s): Weekday AM and PM
Future Off-Site Developments: N/A
Source of Trip Generation Rates: Site generated trip generation estimates were based on
anticipated operational characterlstics of the site and the expected daily hours of
operation, Details of site-generated triP estimates are included in the Appendix.
c:r&
r
Reduetions in Trip Generation Rates:
None:N/A
Pass-by trips: N/ A
lntemal trips (PUD): N/A
Transmit use: N/A
Other: N/A
Horizon Year Roadwav Network Improvements:
N/A
Methodologv & Assumptions:
Non-site traffic estimates: N/A
Site-trip generation: manual method based on anticiDated operational characteristics and
hours of oDeration
Trip distribution method: Manual method Der attractors/generators in the area
Traffic assignment method: manual
Traffic growth rate: 2.88% 0",,~d UH rDOT Tluffie Treas. "2.Q soft'vare
.No I~ t'ta..- (,. r;t: ~ ~,
,."""""".""".1<'.,"',,,,,,,,""'" ~ /7J 1'2 y<- I ~~.
;r
Special Features: (from preliminary study or prior experience)
Accidents locations: N/A
Sight distance: Adequate
Queuing: N/A
Access location & configuration: One Full-movement site access on White Lake
Boulevard
Traffic control: Unsignalized
Signal system location & progression needs: NI A
On-site parking needs: Adeauate
Data Sources: Collier Countv Traffic Counts and AVIR for 2007
Base maps: Roadwav Network
Prior study reports: NI A
Access policy and jurisdiction: Collier County
Review process: Growth Management Plan Amendment aooroval TIS
Requirements: N/A
Miscellaneous: N/A
Small Scale Study l~u F't",. _ X _
Minor Study - $75(),00 X
Major Study - $1500,00
Includes 2 intersections
Additional Intersections - $500,00 each
AU fces will be agreed to duri1lg 'he Methodology meeting and mllst he paid to Trall.\'porfatil1tt, prifJr to
our sign.off Off tlte application.
Applicant
(~'ri:i,J>I"~ j".c-~'!~:":'I*,Mi'V.\.'~, i1 ~ i ~.:=
EXHIBIT A
Collier County
Trame Impact Study Review Fee Schedule
Fees will be paid inerementally as the development proceeds: Methodology Review, Analysis
Review. and Sufficiency Reviews. Fee::> for additional meetings or other optional ~ervices are
also provided below.
MethodoIo\!\' Review - $500 Fee
Methodology Review includes review of a submitted methodology statement, including review of
submitted trip generation estimate(s). distribution. assignment. and review of a "Small Scale
Study" detennlnation, written approval/comments on a proposed methodology statement, and
written confirmation of a re-submitted, amended methodology statement, and one meeting in
Collier County, if needed.
"Small Scale Stud,," Review - No Additional-Fee (lnchides one sufficiencv review)
Upon approval of the methodology review, .the. applicant may submit the study. The review
includes: a concurrency dctennination. site access inspection and conlinnation of the study
compliance with trip generation, distribution and maximl.l,m-threshold compliance.
"Minor Stud, Review" - $750 Fee (Includes one suffieienc, review)
Review of the submittedtral1ic analysis includes: optionalfield visit to site, confinnation of trip
generation., distribution, and aSSi,b.'llment, concurrency dctermjnation, contirmation of committed
improve~ents, review of traffic volume data conected/assembled, review of off-site
improvements within the right-of-way, review of site access and circulation, and preparation and
review of "sufti.cicncy" cornments/questio,ns.
"MaiorStndV Review" - $1,500 Fee (lnclndes two intersection analvsis and two sufljciencv
rcvie,vs)
Review of the submitted trame analysis includes: field visit to site. eontinnation of trip
generation. special trip generation andJor. trip 'length study, distribution- and assibl'Jlment,
concurrency detennination, confinnation of committed' .improvements, review of traffic volume
data. collec;te&assembled. review of traffic grO\vth analysis. review of ofl~site roadway operation.
and capacity analysis, review of site access and circulation, neighborhood traftic intrusion issues,
any necessary improvement proposals and associated cost estimates, and preparation nnd review
of up to two rounds of '~sumcienGY" comments/questions andJor recommended conditions of
approval.
'~Additionalintersection Review" 6 $500 Fee
The review of additional iniersections shall include the same parameters as outlined in the "Major
Study Review" and shall apply to each intersection above the first two intersections included in
the "Major Study Review"
"Additional Sufficiency Reviews" - $500 Fee)
Additional sufficiency reviews beyond those initially included in the appropriate study shall
require the additionat Fee prior to the completion of the review.
l'if,'<;~;';': ~f,'H~';:;': j,,/,!!,,,:,'.V:!,',',':;) 3' ~~"_<l'.,,;
<P'iUUMORE'REGycLi'NG"'"
': Date: .t)4.{)g-08
Filmore l.LC, Comer CoUllty,
: 2250 Washbum Al,Oenue
1,000
V'~~'~$;$e(.?~~l::" "
DayJor _;;~~~::oo
Sour~: ~ CounlyPAand A.~ls. E:.cp,MI;lne. tPrlol(? OJle JDn. 2001}
~ja~~~.~~~~ty.loy~ly.ihCl:~~ii:~~~
o 1,000
'Feet
NapklsFL34117
'PItI}ed:Nuinbef:811$2
V.IO_,.\lnf'lt"<:,..l:'<lI......,..c:J-..._.....,......
Fillmore Recycling
-i/2In008
The site-generated trip estimates that were derived as follows:
ISO truckslday '" I 50 trucks/l 0 hours'" 15 rmo-way truck tripslhour '" 15
truck trips/peak hour entering and exiting
Based on anticipated estimates of 50% in and 50% oUt, 8 trucks entering and 8
trucks exiting the site during AM peak hour; and 8 trucks entering and 8 trucks
exiting the site during PM peak hour will access Collier Boulevard.
The recycling facility will have an additional I 0 employees so at I vehicle per
employee there will be 10 vehicles entering in AM and exiting: the site in PM
peak hour.
For anaiytical. purposes, the truck component of the estimated site-generated
trips was converted to passenger car equivalents.(pCE's) using a truck factor
multiplier of 1.7. The multiplier is based on Exhibit 20-9 from the Highway
Capacity Manual 2000 (see Appendix for copy of the exhibit). The site-
generated trip estimate results are shown in Table 1.
TripGen
t:\Projecu\B ~ I\B II S2\Traffic\B 1152_ GMPATIS_O t.ldS"
.-
~ "
>: 0
S ~I
N j::
"' ~
:E
'"
I
~
!9
v
~
!O
N
'" '" 0 '" ~
~ N M
'"
~ Cj '" '" '" ~
" ~ N ... "
" .
D- C I
1: W
D- o N 0 ... ~
~ M '" '"
'" '" '"
.~I N ...
WI
-" '" '" 0 '"
A J
" '" M
D-
1:
<
! a N 0 '"
M '" '"
a
61 a
M
<I
w
~
1:
j:: ~ ~ "
C
Ul .2
w I .0 .0 C
If ~ If ."
IL "
'" ~ .~ 1i.
ii: A .0
.s E "
I- ~ .0 ~ E
~
0 v " u W
. ~ " u
W a: A a: S
~ ~ u ~ ~
.C ~ .C
.D C .D .
. " " ~
W 0 ~ 0 .8-
z e .5 e w
0 <T .2 v
W .<; ~ ~ ~ .
CI u " " u
41 " " " "
b ~ b >-
:is w 0 ] ~
~ ~ ~ 1'i.
<<l l- e " e ~
0 ~ 0 JJ 0
I- iii u U I- ~
.~
].
.
"
~
o
.5
a:
c
o
'"
~
.C
I-
ro
0
0
C' ?
N 0
'" ~'
.~ '" '" F
'" '" '"
Jl! M ~
-" E
0 J "
W I
0.. I'- I'- M '" N
:E '" ~
0.. "
! '" '" '" ,.
M '" ~
!::
]] N
I'- I'- M <> ~
'"
-" "
. J
. 0
0.. '" '" '" '" B
:r: M
-< .
! ."
'" <> '" $
M '"
~I ~ .. ~ ~
'" "' 0 0
'" '" '" 0
.
>
'C
a
~
.~
~
;2
~ "0
"
.
>
.
:; .
0 . ~
'" . .
J! u .
< ~
..'J -<
S u: ~
~
"0 .
:c '" c I
~ ~ .
-' ..
~ .~
- ~"
-.... \) a
c 'ilt
..
E
"
""
.;;;
~
< ... li 1:
.., :; .
c 0 ~ ~
0 r: w .
:; ~ .
c . '" :i .3
c l:) 0 0 ~
." c -' '" w
.E " . " u: :r
~ .~ ~ "0
0;:: - .c "0 c c
~ ~~ ..'J 0
~ u ~
is ~
<>- ~
"0 1: E
"j; "
l- . 0 .
t t .
.., "0 1: ~
" :; :; "S
fl ~ ~ ~ c 0 ~
0 . co '" ~
~ ~ :; . J!
M 0 '" .
c '" '" . ..'J t
.SO OJ . -'
:0 'l' " " s .~
-g. .. ~ ~
~ ~ 0 0 :c .c ~
. f- in ~ ~
'" u u
. <
B 0
'0
E .
~
'" .~
i5
~
8
<::
<::
~
"
0
~,
(; I ! ~ ~
'" I- ~ ~ ~
. u t;;I '" 0 I:
. l;J
D- o. M ",'
I: ~
D- 1) -~
Vi '" .... '" '" !l
N Ii!
~i g
i '"
0 0 ~
t;;I '" '" ~
co co
~ ~ ~
"" \'I
W\ tf\ 0
'0
~ 9;
""
0
~
~
~ ;2
"E
.
~
" ~
0
to ~ ~
.
~ u .
'" u u
" ..; :i.
-'
1) i.C ~
u
:2 '" "'0 .
~ .... c '0
-'- .:l ~
D-
~
x.~
. ..
>
Ow" ."
"3 ~
o ~ t::
~ Q] ll.l ll.l
ell IU :i v
l?~ 0<
.j to
c
.g .~ g
~ ~ ~
t
..
~ ~I
. "'0 "'0
I- ~ ~
. ~ .
>
u ~
; "3 "3
... 0 0
u to
~ .! '= to
.0 "2 ~ ~
u J:l .~ JI
1;- ~ "" 1i
~ u; "0
0 U U
a
J
"'
N N
"'0 "'0
~ ~
~ ~
'3 3
ell ell
ji ~
.cd
~ ~
.~ ~
~ ~
'"
~
r;
2
~
o
~
:g"
o
N
t
o
5-
'"
u
o
8
Oi
~
r-
t-
o
,
II
~
~
o
-s
.0
i.C
"'0
C
..'J
J2
,g
"
E
j;
~ .~
,
~ I;
w ...
:r "5
o 0
o 'i!
] .g
z 0
~ ~
,
~ J
'S In
1 ~
~ ~
" 0
.~ ~
~
<: 9
o
r-
~
~
..
~
u;
00
o
S
M
"
Ul
W....
1: g
:l N
~ r..
o .Q
>' :5
u ~
u:: a:
Ll. 5
;;l!~
~ t:
o 5
:z u
::) ~
0=
a:: 8
CI c
:0: 0
U i!
~ -
a:l Jl
~
"
~
.
"'
.
i
X
0,
~
~
l:
"',
M
~
" ~
c
'" '0 ;';
'. 8. M
E .
~ U
a:
~ '"
11 E N
,
~ ~ N
Sl
~
e
!;
M
~
~
00
..
v
.
'e
~
.9- -E '"
'"
- . '"
f- '"
" ~ 0
c c E
.9 J: ....
~ "1.
~ " ~
~ "-
is 'j'I
e 0
E -
v> ~ '~ ~
9 I: ~
v>
v> 0 0
9 t;
~ ~ ~
~
'It c
~ ~
'"
~ ~I ~
~
0:.
~
~
.
\.~
-0
<:l,
I
"C
~
~
'3
o
'"
-
,~
'15
u
~
9
l
m
0
S
N
"
,
.,
+ ~'
." ~ ~
~
VI a u "
~ ~
~ '" 0 >- >- L
'" 0': <:)
"" N I
." ~
~ 0 ~
VI l.j
~ " >- >- ~
aJ to
" "
a:: <l'i 0 0 ~
5 VI "'
VI T T !!!
<I: 9 '" '"
m
;0
] u "' M V
.
IE M M E
a:: 0 e '"
f- '" ~
:J f- -
0
I ~ u '" ....
u
'" ~ IE
<I: '0 .
w ~ .::
Cl. Cl.
:!: 0 u '" '"
t1. t:l IE '" '"
'" . '"
~ '"
"" f-
.>< ..:
. aJ ""
~ is
t1. Z Z
~
0
~
~
:~
'5
'" ~I :J
!:i 'i;
>
:::l a;
~
II) .><
W j
a: l'l
'" ~ VI
~ ~
~
<( 0
Z ~
~
<( ~~
w j ~ ~.
.><:>
U ~ :0
:> tf .::
l'l aJ
II:: . ~
W l:J .><
II) 0 j
u. ~ l'l
."
0 "0 ~
t:l
..J
W ." "
> I ~ ~
~ ~
w " ~
..J ;; ;;
r lll: 0 0
aJ aJ
~ Z ~ ~
J1 .~
.:! ::i "0 '"
e u (J e
0 8-
E
= .:!
u:
S
~
0
~
~
c
::l
<)?'".
7- '",
,
~
%!it-.-
.
,
o
~ \
II
I ~
I iii
II .i
1 ~ I ~
I a. I I
. \ L_ %001-.' ~
tl
i\
OInuOl""f P)o}Mu:)
(/
i
-IS';
~~
JI
.
..-%St
,
v;
'"
"
o
~
%OS~
-----'
"
.
~
~ <I
tI .~...
~ ~ ~ c: ~ %st
I" " tI U
U~
J
p.l-e"':ajnog.lal1lo::)
%!iz.~'
~
~
.
~
o
,
"
..
"
"
>
31
.3'
~I \
~)
/
.
I
,;
~
I
~
~
I
i
I
l~'i'~t
%5l--)o>
l'
~
.
..
o
m
.,
(!
-- --
(
\
~
I
~.g
:!E'
D~
Ol~
.s: C N
u..SoI-
" ~~i
€g~~
~lt~~
~ 11II
0:;;
Ell
"".
it~
:;-----
~
.~
"
0
! '5
"
I :c
, ,:!
~ ~.
! \
u~'<t""
:JA~
~ ~lt-
S 3::~
~~Il
-,
M~-
II !"
"',~ ~-j
- .-r =
:. '\j' ~
! '..=
j~'l'!'=:
i ~~"''''''''8
,~~ -l;l~-f
:i ~.,---~
":1'.\ "':!';.
If I
(J) :....
VlO
1/)-
eIl>-
C ell
CllO
>
.
,
..
,
~
~.
z{)~
::.
6-0
t
~
"
~
,
~
..
~
.
,
5
~
~
{
e
u
I ~ I
"
~
5
___J
+-
pJ1MOlnog JO!llO::>
:ll"1Ull""V pJo}'/'tJ:)
I i
g I
"I
~
lL
~~
..II
.
,.
Bl--':
~
..I
,.
6---'
~
~
"
.,
o "
~ 8L
.:l t: 6
..... "'lJ
I "'-
..~ ~ ~
~
iii
"
"
.
'e:
..
I ,
~
! \
I'" !
I
I
/'
,.
I
~
I
~~
:E .
----, (!)~
i "'~
* .S; <;{ to')
u~t:
> ~ ~\.::~
.' "
! . , ~ '?l
w I'd
~ Ll I' e ~
c o .
l' Eel:
; :::::~
'" u.:"
h
"
~
OJ
,
o
0>
"
~
-'l
"
"
~
~
:;
L-.
"I
~
~
.~
o
('-=<
'"
.
:0
"
. i
l
~ ~
nt'
.
u'''Ct::
:ij~
eiiitRo
g,~ ..;-~
~~!l
+-
!h(,
",
.>I"..:
il !~
..! 11 :;
'i .
iJiH~:1
l~:!-,lS~{
j]G1,~..!~;
II
<1J!-
VlO
VI~
((1>-
c r:l
roO
>
lr-~'
il \
\20~
~
i
i
i
I i <(-
\ \ i i 0...
:00
B I i]l , (!l"
~
in "'~
" I .::;'o;('"t
\ U , u.g-!:::
. I~ \
'0- ., ~ ~~ ~
. , ' $
0. i<\U5>c
I c JlQ:.ow
i ,,~ ~ U I ' "
~ e..
. ~ I c 0
I _ 0
~~ \ .so.
. . itt
, ,
. "
~ " ~
I ~ !
~ .
i 5 I "'I
~\ S.
u \ ~\
-- I
~nu~,,'V pJOJl"'~J::l ~ )
r~
(/
'"
.~
I <;
~'::. , 'S
'! ..
8 I I "' ! :;;
;;; '" .. :; , ;:
'" o .
~ \ l3 ~
. .
,; nJ ! ti'~t:
,.j. E"
I I._~ " " -1..6 ~
\ E: e ~"~
c~lf
"' ~~"a'r
S I it "'~~
I ~ ~L
L
+-- . ~ ~ ~
~ . "
.1 U~ .- L
;i~
h;:: :
I pJV""lnoQ ..I"!llOj ~ 11 . "!,!
'I ) ,
. 'i J ~
L-
L-....
I .-~ i!iiI~~[
.1 ,j i,j'l
a:!.-;5'-~
"7;1..
IfJ
il l
~ .
g ]
,; Q) !,..,
. , II) 0
" ii
~ "".......
'0
<.:> (1$>-
C (ll
~o .
COLLIER COUNTY ANNUAL UPDATE
AND INVENTORY REPORT (AUIR)
2008
j
.
,
,
.
,
,
1
i
I
~
1
j
;
,
,
i
,
j
~ ~
1 i ~ i
~ ~ ~
~ ~j
~ !i~ i~ !
'" M.::=1 ~
o .>
~ H~~ i
~ :-a;:~ ~
, -.
~ ~ l
~
l
!
~
8
.
8
." !
~. =
1H
!
~
!
;
;
.
;
~ ~
]
l
S
I
!
.
,
l
, <<<<
<<< , ~~~~
mBB ,
ill' ~ ~ un
~~ ,
. ~!!~
.::;<~~<..
59P~~~
'UUp
z z ~~';I: ~
<
,
,
,
~
l
!
iii
,!I ~ II
.
L
"
a
ii~
i
.
1;
,~.
<..
"' .
..
H
wuuu~=p c~uPPP~~OUU~UUQ~==C=
J~ i~:g~!a~ii~~sE~~~~~~~~~:~l~~:i
~~~~:~~~g~~!!!5~~3!::g~fi3i~~~5
..;::;:f:
~~g~~===Q ~~~~~~~;~~=;~;~S~&#~
~~i;;
!~~~iS~1S~Z~~==::~!~~~~:!~:~Si
~33S
!~~~5!~5S~!a~:~~!5~~5~5~~~~~~!
p~~~~~~ cppc~pcccccw~~w~pcp~~c
000"
5~ i~~~~~a~~;~E~~~~~3~~~~ili!~~~i
.n
..
.
?!i!U e
.
C~~~e$Coc??~~~oc?~~geccoc?3 "?
I 1 , .
Ii!! /. 1 1 i J i!; il~l
H,! ! I JI~ p- Hl : -ljll I.HI
.i 11] I jji]l~l;~lll. 1~2~~_il'i'~~1
. nHV H6<llmU. ~ {Jd: JJ !
1 ~ III 1 "j- -.11
~" " I,l . l' 1 ~j
l~jll ! tiI 1ljl 1 l,; "lijj;i!l!!~
~~=J~]!_~~!__~l~ }~_~~K ~1:~!'~j1~
1 Ii 1~iA~13!;;<j !i~;~.~. 1,1 lJ~l!.
I
.
nIlH
UpH
~ ~ _ .t .~ _~
~J~~~~
i ~;~~S~- i ~5~::~
;; uuwuQ ~ !:1... 1::1..
i i~~ill!EI if Ell
o
"'~'" ...,., - ,.,
... ~ '" ..,"'
~,
!
a
!
"
!
1
I
!
~
~~~ !
;>;:"'.. !
",
]
I
<lb...
~~!~gg>-
H .ll;lm i
J!
;ll~
~=~~ ==~=o~~~~==. u=c==~ u
S~h~~~ii;a! ~~ij~~~~~~~~ a~~= a
__ _ _ ___ ~n "'_
~ .~!!!~~;S~~~!~~;!i!5~E~;!~~Q5
~ ;~=!!...~~=~_€~~~~~~~;Q;~~E3Q~
~'5;~~~~~!~~~5~5!=t.i~~;~~~:~ ~
~ ~~~!~!~!~~~5~~~Si~ ~~!!!!!O~
Q ~~OOOQ==~~~~~Q~~OCCC Q~~~w c
i ~i~~ssaS~~~it~~5~i~;ia~a!& i
o
~55e~e~~e~QQe ~@~~~e~~~e5cQ~
I 1
,1 i. 1! 11~ 1 I, l'j~lj!~ ~
i". -. 1 ,. "HO 'i I
~ ;!il~l; ~~, ~1;1;~~.~lll~iJ~j
~. .~~l.s .35 ; .,10 ~!.,~,
l
1
ii, ,"; ,q L
. l~ !j !~ ~1; lj'11;1'
Q 11 i 6lj~ i~~ !_=;~~
.1"'11. <1' . - 'lo,t"!
, =s~~ d>S 3~ ~~~~>
EXCERPT FROM COLLIER COUNTY
TRAFFIC COUNT REPORT
.
~
.
i ~!
:~ 8
.
oo.....:!
~]li
8:<(1,1
..
.
1,i
:~~
.
:pi
"
l
,
i
0
~
i
;
~E
,.
;
0
a
!
a
~ ~
~ a
! ;~
! .
~ ;
a
f
I a
.
^
. "
^ a
~E
"
.
"
a
!
a
;
.
a
"""....
::'~';';
ggg
,:,.:,.:
!~ ~SS~ ~~~~~~~~~5~~ ~ a~~~~
i,"~,
a~~~~o~~:~o~~~~~~~~~~OO~~ ~ ~~;~~s~~;~~i~~~~ o~~a~~~a~~;~~
R~~". .~~~ .~a~~~~~~~ =~ ~ .~~"~.. N4~~~~~"~~ ~.~ ~~~NN_~~
~~~~a~~;~!!O~~~E~~Oi~~~~~~i~~~~ ~
,i...i..;~,...,i
~~~... ~~.-~~ ~~
D.......~,.,5:......."'..'"
!:l;:r;li!",-..:e:1l~li:;:;;;;
;!....,; ..,.:.,;,.,;..'O\!!;:.
.<."...;..,;;;."","'~~'i..;,. ~ ..~.",.~.;,,".!.
~ .~~~~ ~~..~~~~~.t"'~d~~~~~~~~.~~ -.,;~~,.: ri~":ri_t"~~
f.:~E~!!.~~~~~$.g
..-.... ..."....."'.....,
N_ __
'c' ~~~~ ~ ~ ~l~~ ~~~~ ~~~~ ~~
,-. ~N~~ije2~~I~R~~~ Q~Q~~~~8~~~~~
~ .;7"~~'~~~,~.~~,~;."";";~~~..
If .....,. .,..,.;1. """'''''''''"1.''' ~
~ ~:=~.~!~Q~~~8~=~ ~~~II~~III~li
~ "';q~..~ ~~~..18i~;: ~~~~~~~~~~~~~
.. "i' 'i~~ ";~.. i,.i~~iieiei,
;<>::; i~~ ~8E. i
.. ~ ~~,""'''' S!
,
;
<> ""'li:::;::;!;~
iii ~~a::!t,l:~
~.' 5~~:=:;~g
~ '~:::;~"lIl~ri
t-i ~
~L~ ~
~;!~ ,
.::~~ ~
m~
cici....
~
,
.
~
,
~
~
.
8 ~~!.~
lit Il:Rl:t
!
1
,
I
lU:JO<M.l.
Ug~'lt
i
J
"
.
~
I
il
..
II
II
II
II
II
"
EXCERPT FROM HIGHWAY
CAPACITY MANUAL 2000
Highway Capacity Manual 2000
wh~rc
vp = pa$~~nger~Ci\r equi.....alent flow rate for peak 15-min period (pclh),
V = demand volume for the fun peak hour (vch/h),
PHF = pc~k-hour faclor,
fa = grade adjustment betar, ilnd
'HV = hC::l\'y.vchiclc adjustment f;J,clor.
PHF
PHF represents the \'a.rialion in traffic flow within an hour. Two-kine highway
analysis is h~scd on demand volumes for a peak I5-mill period within the hour of
interest-usually the peak hour. For operational an:llysis, the full-hour demand volumes
mmil be converled LO now rates for Lhe peak 15 min, os shown in Equalion 20-3.
Grade Adjustment Faclor
The grad!.: adjustlncnl faclor, fe. accounts for the effect of the terrain on travel speed.l;
nnd paccl1t time-spcnt-following, even if no heavy ...ehicles arc prescnt. The values of
the grade adjustment factor arc: listed in Exhibit 20-7 for estim:Hing aver3gc travel speeds
and in Exhibil20-8 for estimating petcent time~spcnt-fQlIowing.
EXHIBIT 20-7. GRADE ADJUSTMENT FACTOR (fol TO DETERMINE SPEEDS ON TwO-WAY AND
DIRECTIONAL SEGMENTS
Type of Terrain
Range of T wo~Way Fla.... Range 01 Directional Flow Lev,1 Roiling
RBles IPCIh) RBles IpcJhJ
0-000 0-300 1.00 0.71
, 600-1200 ' 300-600 1.00 0.93
> 1200 > 600 1.00 0.99
EXHIBIT 20.8. GRADE ADJUSTMENT FACTOR 110) TO DETERMINE PERCENTTIME-SPENT-FOLLOWING ON
TWO-WAY AND DIRECTIONAL SEGMENTS
Type of Terrain
FiBng, of Two-W;;y FloN IQnge of Directional Fiero" Level Rolling
RBles Ipc/h) Rales IpcJh)
0-600 0-300 LOO 0.77
> 600-1200 > 300-600 1.00 0.94
:> 1200 > 600 1.00 1.00
Adjustment for Heavy Vehicles
The presence of heavy vehicles in the fraftie strcilm decreases the FFS, becDuse at
hase conditions the Iraffic stre~m is assumed to consist only ofpassc:nger cars-a iJrc
occurrence. Therefore, traffic volumes must be adjusted to an equivalclJt now r<lte
expressed in passenger cars per hour. This o.djuslfficnl is accomplished by using the
.fi'lctor fHV.
Adjustmc.nt for the presence of heavy vehicles in the traffic stream applies to two Heavy.vehicle adjustment
conSIders 'rucks and RVs.
types of ,'chicles: trucks and RVs. Buses should not be lrented as a separate type of Buses ara included with
hea....y vchicle but should be included with trucks. The hC3vy.vehicle adjustment factor trucks.
requires two steps. First, the passcnger~cnr equivalency factors for trucks (~) and RVs
(ER) for the prevailing operating conditions must be found. Then, using these values, an
adjustment factor must be compulcd to correcl for aU he<l.vy vehicles in the trnffic slrcom.
20.7
Chapter 20 . Two.Lana Highways
Methodology
Highway Capacity Manual 2000
P<lsscngcr-car equivalents for extended two.way segments ilrc determined from
Exhibil20-9 for estimating speeds and from Exhibit 20-10 for estimating percent time-
spent-following. The Icrr:J.in of extended two~wilY segments should be categorized as
level or rolling.
EXHIBiT 20.9, PASSENGER-CAR EOUIVALENTS FOR TRUCKS AND RVS TO DETERMINE SPEEDS ON
TWO-WAY AND DIRECTIONAL SEGMENTS
Type of Terrain
Vehicle Type Range of Two-Way Range cI Directional Level Rolling
Flow Rales (pclh) Flcw Rates (pclh)
Trucks,ET 1Hi00 0-300 1] 2.5
, 600-1,200 ' 30Q-.600 1.2 1.9
, 1,200 '600 1.1 1.5
RVs. EA: 1Hi00 0-300 1.0 I 1.1
, 600-1,200 ' 300-600 1.0 1.1
:> 1,200 ' 600 1,0 1.1
EXHIBiT 20-10, PASSHlGER-CAR EaUIVALENTS FOR TRUCKS AND RVS TO DETERMINE PERCENT
TIME-SPEN1-FDLLOWING ON TWO-WAY AND DIRECTIONAL SEGMENTS
Type ofTerrain
Vel1icleType Range orT.va-Way Range of Directional Level Rolling
Fla" Rates (pc/h) Flail Rales (pcIh)
Trucks, ET IHiOO 0-300 1.1 1.8
, 600-1,200 :. 3DO-QOO 1.1 1.5
:. 1,200 '600 1.0 1.0
RVs, E, 0-600 0-300 1,0 1.0
, 600-1,200 ' 300..{l00 1,0 1.0
>1,200 '600 1,0 1.0
Levet Terrain
Level terrain is any combination of horizontal and vertical alignment permitting
heavy vel1icle:s (0 maintain npproximntely the same speed as passenger cars; this
gcnerully includes short grades of no more than I or 2 percent.
Rolling Terrain
Roiling terrain is any combination of horizontal and vertical alignment causing heavy
vehicles to reduce their speeds subst:an_tiolly below those of passenger cars. but not to
operate al crawl speeds for any significant lel)gth of time or at frcquenl intervals;
generally, this includes shorl-_ and medium-length grades of no more than 4 percent.
Segments with substa~daJ lengths of morc than a 4 percent grade should be analyzed with
the speci,fie; grade ,proc<:dure, for directional segments.
Heavy- Vehicla Adjusiment Factor
Once values for ET and ER have been determined. the adjustment factor for heavy
vehicles is computed using Equation 20-4.
1
fHV = (20-4)
I+PdEr -I)+PR(ER -I)
where
Pr = proportion of trucks in lhe traffic stream, expressed os a decimal;
PR = proportion of RVs in the tr3ffic stream, expressed as a decimal;
Chapter 20 - Two-Lane Hlghwa s 20-8
Methodology
Highwav Capacity Manual 2000
Er passenger-car equivalent for trucks, obtained from Exhibit 20-9 or
hhioi120-10: and
ER pns!\cnger-cflT equivalent for RVs, obtained from Exhibit 20-9 or
hhihi120-10.
flerative Computations
Exhibits 20-7lhrough 20-IO-thc grudc ildjustmcnt factor fc and the passenger-caT
equivulents for trucks (ET) and RVs (ER)-arc stratitied by now rates expressed in
passenger cars p~r hour. Howe.....er. unlil Equ:\Uon 20.3 is applied, the now rate in
passenger CilTS per hour is not known, Therefore, an iterative appro3ch mU!il he applied to
determine the pa5scngcr~car equivalent now r31c vp' and from that. either average travel
speed or percent lime-spcnl-folIowing.
Fi~t, determine the flow rate, in vchicles per hour, as YIPHF. Seconu, select values
of fo, ET. and ER appropriate for th:\t now rate from the tables. Then. determine the "p
from those vah.lc.<; using Equ:uions 20.3 and 20~4. If the computed vi.llue. of \'p is less lhnn
the upper Iimitor thc sclected nOW~r3.lC r:mgc for which fe. ET. <lnd ER were dctcnnined,
then the computed value. of "f> should be used. If the vp is higher than the upper limit of
the selected now~ra(c rnngc, repent the process for successively higher ranges unlil an
acceptahle \'alue of v fI is found. Because the highest range includes all flow r:\tcs grea!er
lh::m 1,200 pc/h in both direclions of travcl combined. it can be used if a computed v:\luc
exceeds lhe upper limit of hath lower flow-rule ranges.
Determining Average Travel Speed
The 3\'cragc travel specd is estimated from the FFS, the demand flow rate, and an
adjustment factor for the percentage of no-passing zones. The demand now ram for
estimating o.v~ragc travel speed is dctennincd with Equation 20.3 using thc value of fHV
computcd with the passengcr~car equivalents in Exhibit 20~9. Average lra\'c\ speed is
then cSlimaLcd using Equation 20-5.
ATS = FFS- 0.00776vp - I,p (20-5)
where
ATS
'np
vp
= average travel speed for hoth directions of l'fl1,,'el combined (Olinl).
:::; adjustmcnt for percentage of no-p3ssing zones (see Exhibit 20- t 1), ilnd
= passenger-car c.qui....rilent flow rate for peak 15~min period (pclh).
The FFS used in Equ:nion 20-5 is the value estimated with Equation 20-1 or
EquaLion 20~2. The adjustment for the effect of thl: percentage of no-passing zones on
average travel speed (fnp) is listed in Exhibil20~ t I. The exhihit shows that Ihe effect of
no~p3ssing zones on average travel speed increases to a maximum at a lwo-way flow rMe
of 400 pclh and then decreases al hig.her volumes. The maximum value of fop is 4.5 mi/h.
Determining Percent Time.Spent-Following
The percent timc.spc.ol-following is estimated from the demand now r<lie, the
directional distribution of trame, nnd the percenlage of no-p3ssing zones. The demand
flow rate ('-'p> for estimaling percent timc-spent-following is determined with Equation
20-) u!;ing: \hc \'tlJuc of fHV compuled with prlssenger-car equi....alents from Exhibit 20-10.
Percent timc-spcnt-following is then estimated using Equation 20-6. Appropriate values
of base percent time-spent-fOllowing can be determined from Equation 20.7.
PTSF = BPTSF + 'dI,p (20.6)
where
PTSf
percent timc~spent-following.
20.9
Chapter 20 - Two-Lane Highways
Methodology
~~-::-~: :-:~_:_~:;~~~~-::~~:_.', ~~: _ '1-~:<,~:~-::~~D 'o'cl~:::~
~;-,--- -f?~ ~-~~-,"
':': ,; ;- ~ to - ~ ~ ~
'~t i;t 8:>- g;; ~ ; i
:, Ii ~ 8 ~ '-I'
I' ,'.' ~ ~ ~ ~
~; !~ 0 ~ ~ E
1f .:: ~ - ~ jJ
~
>
~~
!;~
@fii
~~
iiI"
<::
>
"
I
,
I
R(',~1~~"'f
"
.,.
"
'\
;<-:f~'"
::'j;~:;~~ .
i
.101.(
'1.
,'.J "
.,
,
>iY}t<:~~: ,
-j' -:\ .
!...
" ,','.:;, - :-.~.
i
.. ~
o.
'.' .,,'-
u:
,.
:~>..,.;, -;;:,,<:>
""R,,'oil-- "",~'-,- .
J ~ ~;j;;:ti~,C:;; . .
d}""" "...,'t'" ' ,
~ 1 ;<"-:"'--';: .....~"::~r-...:
~. ''Il
~ ' ,
_~ i
!,'
"~"/~~:~'~-'
I'
'I
,'>
-i.._
~-'--'
. u_. ",,:~' . iIi_ __ '
f~~ ::_~C:
'j
s-
",01 _~
;;~ II
lli~ l.tI!i
'....'I'.'t'..:
:;, l' ..
:j:t'lf
, ,.,~i,,-L~J,c -_"~F"~'
-';':f-~-- ; bl" ' h, ,
,~ t~ >;~
, ",''I q,,, : t' , ,:,.
1:: . "J-:;,o. ..4 . 41 ,_~
'.r ' .~. r" :""l,,~r<:!,->'~
,<'::'~" :Lf----~~~~'~:..':',,~:.;.. .
r:ll ,I . l._..___.n.. ~{---,--
89 1.1 I' i!
:J> mil' ,q'/ II ~
I, 20lrH I jl
-'-'-I -1"11-1"--- Ii
I. I '.
i :;
I~~~-~
i,
I
'J,
:to-
:0
r,n
v
U>
:I:
o
:;;
z
o
z
<::
:to-
'U
Z
:?,:
'"
m
:u
N
'"
'"
('J
o
..
'"
-.--_.-.- .
~
.'>r'~
,
J
"
1
"
o
.
~/
y'
)
~'
~ '
II t
u,
I~'
lW'f
Ii
,
I','
~
,.
J ~
f~
" i~ d ,-"It
~ "~' .~ t:~'
~. ~ ~:. l
,::. ~
lc
1.
} ~~,
!! ~?
.~ ~
. ~~
,
~!
-, ~.
1i;Ht;
~, ~a"
>'~~~~::
~;.,~~.~-~l
I,' ~ F~-,',
"', ~ ,~~
:,: ~:;~;;'
.'
::H.
~, ~
r.
,
,t
i"
,:,
~~ ~~ );
,
~
,
~
I
"'.,
f
,I
~ ~
~. 4,
"",,'
..,
"
~ ;
-"
,.
. ,
,.,'"
~~ d, -l
o
~~~,~:~r,
~~~~ ;~
;~~
1;'
'00
; ~ ~~ ~
- ~ ~'j ~
'I ,j ;~ ~
~ ~ .; ~ t
i:'
t~
~ :,
.iij
3."
"
:!,o,
-Ld;
.q~
~H~
"! ~ ~
"
,II<;
li
"
~;;-
~ ~, '.
, .
, ,
;~~
~; j' ~ s,
'~t~: 93
~
n
H
Ii."
:;
~':
: ~ ~
..;:
:,-;'
)"};'
~~ .' ", .
> ~., ~ r c
,,,,,,.,
- ". ~}~"
.. ~
. ~ ~- '
"
:,
( .~
'>-
:..
L
" ~
.'",'J' e"i' ,,~,
I ~'
-~-~-{i."~::' :~.i
~'I,..,_J. _.I
~,t, J
':"';"---~-.. ~.
.'" .... , -. '"" ~,
;;;~s~i~~r~t
~.. ~ ~ .'- '<~~
{::f'~'::'~:'!\'~:~
'-..Ij<--!'i',~
~!
-.' '...',
"../1
1.....~~\.:I;
l'
:jn,:~~i
;'",-,'''''~''''',~Js
1\ ',' ~--'J .', 'il'
\"'_,,,.t
:r:~'r'
.>'" ,~,
,
i
,
"
."""""
.
;".---:.:')
.
"~",,~-"
,
. .j
:\' ;~'t.,,,. ~;
~ '." ':~'~,:I,:.,j
",.' ~',
.,
"
,.r,
':~:
I
1---
,
I
_ r____'....
,
.
--i"
~ +---
'.,~ .,';O';:""....rl~
"~. . t
~,._~~...,...I
i;;:~':':t-:~f;;/A'y.;}:,,~)/ ..;::::~~<; 'i_ ~ ~ ~ .' ,\<'.~ > : '!~:2'~' > 'I
'$"'.~"~""":-~"A" ,;';':",";."7>'\'''' ,;. , .1_;. '~, ';.t. t'~' -:.-~
1.;.';:~~,'~...~~.'.',.~:.;*::F::',:~~~~:<7 ....'_~.:,;,.i../,~.~..:.'.j
"+~'':<f'~ ~
"':_~i- '~~,""l
t\
"
._n-t -
"
- ~-, CC'----. .r,-~-
..
__ _-}.i._ _,_ _ ';-;"_,. -;-
r
_,.__'U___ '~ _-'-I~< ---~N' ,,','
l ~3==-';~ .'~~,-:-:-_ _:'~~__
J -,r-:-;c"c.
.,nik
I~
__.Jj
"I
"
, -...!I~
,-,t
'Ii.
.~:il"
."
.It
I, --
.~+
t
---",
- ."~".
o
.
-'-----10
.J
I
<1_.
".
~ ~ ~ ~ ;
~.. ~
'~~~ ~ ,~"
~ /.-
n~}
~n;
~~~;
~ ~,~t
~ ~ ~ f
~' ~
~
~~
om
~
li)0!
,
,
I
[J
,1
_.~
.1
"
~ ~~
!
,.!@tf)
! I
'.
,
,
r
m
~; Cl
w~ ~
,-
..
UP.
l~~~
~'l ?t'
',}'
: ~~
"
?~:
, ~ 'l
f:-:;
> :;..
.
l'
.:
': ~
~ ~ i, t~
..-
os.,-
-,.
~~i
"
'j!
~ ~
",
.'
. ~'
T',"
~r
:J
'u; l~
f ,,~: ~
:r~~'~
1--,.;;'''
~ ~~ ~
'-,"..
r~
,~ f
I,,'
~'"1 "
.1
~:D
o
"
"
~ c:
,
.
i
-j
j ~
"
,
,
~hv;]
.....(J:2;j
f
,
H
.~
Attachment L
Letter of Authorization
'~~/~3/2~B8 05;14
2"9-597-B5'/6
RI.JA lflO
FAG~ 03/~3
LE.T:re~ OF AUTHORIZATION
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCIERN:
I hereby authorize Dwlqht NlldQau. RWA. Ino
(N~me of Agent - typed or printed)
Signed:
Agent l~qUe~i to "mend thl;l Collfer County Growth Man~gement
Ii property i a lifJ\Jj iy1lhe Application. I /
Ju.!JDL., .~ Data: "'f.L'-1Lo't'
Teresa Fillmore AI./", ( )5
Dale: . r _--rIG
Signed;
John Fillmore
lOTATE OF ~FI9rtd",)
COUNiY OF (Collier)
AI
dey of ffi A:~ 1_
,2008
By
MY COMMISSION EXPIRES:
. ~j
....,."~ ANGELA L KRUM
~IT MYC(IMMlli~ION * 00lll.9516
~1'NI\~ nxrl111:Jh ,hpI.1.:l.CI09
~J\u~~'~~51Qo"A(It~
C~:;;Ei ONE Of TliE FOLLOWING:
,.' who Is personally known to me,
_ who has proctuoad
and
did tall'" an Oalll
"f.- did not taka an Oaih
NOTICE - BE AWARE THAT:
Florldl'l5tatute l;laotlon S37,O~ - f~IS. OftlcJal :;;W.mlFl1\$ Law $t~t.s that:
"Who~v"r KnowIngly ",,,-Kes a f.J.... $t.tem.nt in wfitlng with th.lntent to ml.I."d
a public se.van! in the performanca of his official dulY' !3h'lll be guilty of 'I
misdeme'lMr ofthe s.ooml degres, punishable 'lI" pr<>vided by II fine to a
maxImum of $500,00 aodfor m~xlmum of a sixty day Jail! term,"
Rx time:04/0~/2008 05:88
R:, NQ.:078 P "008
~--..
SDO/lOO'd 990# LO:[O 8006/~O/~O
G~9~lSS68l
lHrO 3lXIO/8NIH8lm lH'<lA:ulO.lj
Z~ 3~~d
8NI \lM~
SL9G-L59-6~0
6P:GQ 80G~I.0/P~
"
00/18/08 Og:53 F~ Z3gZIZ1V04
a1D'll'EST TITLE
141001
~4J2Jl OR: 4041 PG: 3807
RlCORDID in OPPICIAL RlCOIDS of COLLIIR CODITI IL
OS/23/2006 at 01:4!Ak DIIGHT I. IIOCI, CLIRI '
DC DR 18.50
00c'.70 ,70
COlliS !. 00
IIlC 1.50
-------
--------.
TJlJS INS1llL1MENTPRllPAREP BY,
Jornes D. Vosel. Esq.
flL Bot No. 0051373
Vogel Low Ollice, P.A.
Suille 8, Mi_Tid. Bldg.
3936 TlIllIl1Ili Tnil Nonh
~opl...Florid.34J03
(139) 262.221\
PIU'PARA 110N ONI. Y Wl'THOTJr OPINION
Retn:
P1LLMORI LLC
mo IASHBDRJ AVI
IAILIS IL 31117 IOl2
QUITCLAIM DEED
TInSQUITCLAIMDEEDmadethe11-dayOf ftA ~ 2006,bym.LMORE,
LLC, hereinaftcrcalled the GRANTOR, to FILLMOIm~st office address is 2250
Washburn Ave., Naples, Florida 34117-4032, hereinafter called the GRANTEE.
(WhcteVllfUSed herein the term "grantoI" and "gIllll.lCC" include all the parties to this instrument and
the heirs, legal rqnesentatives and assigns of 'ndividuals, and the successors and assigu.s Qf
corporations). '( 1ER COtJ:
~y .tV
tor, for and in
. hmbyackno
. t,
~.
o
fa
o
Commencing at the N er of the Southwest quarter of
Section 31, Township 49 ~ ence along the North line of the
Southwest quarter of the So Section 31, North 8!j058'41" East, a
distanee of343 feet to the Point ofBegimung of the Pl\I'Ul ofland herein descnbed; Thcace,
continuing along the North line of the Southwest quarlcl' of the Southwest quarter of said
Section 31, South 89059'49" East, adistan<le ofl029.30 feet; thence So\llh 02004'30" East,
a distance of658.93 feet; thence North 89"58'14" West, a distance or 342.85 feet; thcmce
South 02005'32" East, a distance of 558.99 feet; thence North 89057'41" West, a distance of
1029.48 feet; thence North 02007'49" West, a distance of 558.60 feet; thence South
89058'27"East, a distance of343.20 feet; thence North 02003'36" West, a distance of658.67
feet ofthe Point of Beginning.
. on of the sam orSl 0.00, inband
ed does b=by remise. release
clal and dcIIIand which the said
f d situate,lying and being in
Wl'DWlSETH: That
paid by the said gxan1eC, the
and quitclaim unto said
gnmtor, haS in and to the fa 0
the Colmly of Collier and
A poroe1 of land 1 . (i
County, Florida,
ge 27 .East, Collier
PropertyI.D.: 00341040004; 00341360001; 00337520004; 00337040005; 00341920409;
00341920302;00338600004
,,~~~T'..~51I\..~.""'~
Attachment M
Quitclaim Deed
05/18/08 09:SJ F.U ZJ9Z8Z7904 lIIDWEST TITLE
--------.-----
~OOZ
xxx OR: 4041 PG: 3808 **t
~ convEYance is beIll!: dODe to co..olidate all narcels as outlined in the Prouertv In'. .hlJ1VD.
~ _ in ~d rettlrded iD OR Book 3270. pale 2754: OR Book 3270. Daile 2756 ad OR Book
3270. Daj1e 2759.
to HA VB AND TO HOLD the ssme together with all and singnJar the lltlPurteoan<<;eS themunlO
belonging or in anywise appertainlng. and all the estate, right, title, interest, lien, equity and claiJn
whatsoever of the said gnmtor, eithCl'in law or equity, to the only proper use, benefit and behalf of
the said grantee forever.
IS WITNESS WHEREOF, the sllid grantor has signed and sealed tbesepresents the day and
year first above written.
Signed, scaled and delivered in Olll" presence:
Wi1n_:
J
, its Manager
(Sign
(Print Name
~
STATE OF 1='~D~
COUNTY OF _ L...:=
The foregoing Quitclaim Deed was acknowledged before me this ~ day .of
TercsaFillmorc andJ"hn Fillmore, Managers ofFillmore.~, who an:
ersonaJl known to me or who bas produced " . . .... .' as '
) entilication. ~ ^ ')J"\ (lf~;{(S~ ,-'
~~~. fN~' - ,... .,
1 eo 0 ,.:: ~ I. .". :. ~
_ --e.n '. -., ',I. . ,t..
CTYFed or~N~edNamCOfN~~i;itll~/.:~::'
omm1SSlon o. . tl.AN
My Commission Fxpires:i"'li ..:.;;it...z.a~~.... ~i
;;f I...~t.~' .2, ..-t:~
- . ' . ...
S*:" ~s.
V~S~fiW~1l'PoR4e.1-..... =. ...~ . =
i ; # l*E
'a .....;1. . llD2su32a .. iii
~_f.:2'.~ _JIf\.":::
~ ~..4........,~,=":~ $
~ 1Jt~.._._;:.....~\..$'~
""I:~.sr.IJE~ \\\''''
1I1JI1'III !~I\\I'\
~K-"'-GUlI~ THU 1!:!~'..BI1 ~KlUW ::;ULUAV IN!, cPA, PA
rAX NU. <',~ b~l <881
p, U4
Attachment N
Disclqfure of Interest .Information
OPER..A.TING A.GREEMENT
FOR
FILLMORE, LLC
nITS AGREEMENT is m~de effective'~ of this day of March. 2003, by and
. -
among.TereBD Fillmore and Jobn A:FlIImore (heremafteJ' refmed to in the singular as a
"Member" and colle"lively aJl the "Mcmbor'" and tile "Membership").
DEFINITIONS
). "Act" I'Il0!lll.B Chapter 608 of the Florida Statutes, SllIlDended from time to lime during
the telm of Company.
2. "Alljustad C"pitnl Account Deficit" mel\nli, WiUl respeot to any Member, the deficit
bal.nce, ifallY, in snch Member's Capital Account as of the end of the TelovM.t
. fiscal year, aftor giving effect to the fcncwing adjustmonts:
e.
"Credit to ouch Capital Account any amount. which such Member is obligated
to re.tore (pur.uant to theteMS of this Agreement or otherwise) or
io daemed to be obligJIted to re.tore pursuant to Regulations
Section' L704-2(g)(1) and 1.704-2(i)(5), and, b. Pebit to such
Capital Aocount the items described in Sections 1.704.1
(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4),1.704-1 (b)(2)(ii)(d)(S); and 1.704-1 (b)(2)(ii)(d)(6)
of the Regulations,
The foregoing definition of Adjustad Capital Aooount Defioit is
intended to oomply with the proviaiolls of Section
1.704-I(b)(2)(ii)(d) oftbe ReglllaticlUl and shall bo interpl'tlt.d
oonsistently therBWitb.
"I,'
3. .' Affiliate" of any PeTBon means (1) any Person directly or indirectly cont,olling,
contIotted bY, or lmder common control, whether through ownership, agre.ment or
otherwisa, with such Person; (ii) anyporson owningbeneticillllyor orreoord 10% or
more of the outstanding voting,eecul'itie" Memhership intet'$ltB. or c.lher ownership
interests ofallcn l'erson; (ili) IU1Y of fleer, director, trnstee, seneral partner or Person in a
similar capacity in or with the mllIlugement of such Person, and (iv) nny Per.oll owning
bonefloi.ll)' or ofr.cord 10% or Illore ortha outstanding voting secun.I,..., Membership
interests or other oWllerl\hip intereats, or any officer, elirector, tnUlt.e, general Member or
Person h\ a similar capacity in or with the management of any person described h\ clause.
(i1) or (iii) .bove.
4. II Agreement" mOIlIl' thi.s Operating Agreement, as initially c".cated, or as amended
from time to tillle, IUI t11 e co\\text may r~qtliTC.
p.ge 1
FllLMORE, LLC . Operating Agreement
Rx Ii me: 04/221200'.3 23: 06
Rx No.:048 P.004
LlO/\700"d Z90# ZS:SZ GOOZ/Zl/\70
PO 38\1d
6\79\7Z9868Z
l~IO jIXIO/8NIH8lnrl lHV^:WOJ~
8NI "M~
8L,;O-L5,;-5EZ:
LO:OO 5oeZ:/EZ:/pO
RfK-,NUU8-.!HU lU:.~MJ!!<lIilV :;UWAVIHI,~~R, fR
fAX NU. ,,8 081 ,88]
f, Ub
5. "Capital Account" mellnS, willi respect to any M.mber, tbe Capital AccO\\nt!\5 defined
under ~elleral.ccounting principals and applicable tax laws. maintained in
accordonce with the following provisions:.
a. To each Members Capital Acoount shall be added the fbllowlllg:
i. The amount of any cRsh Or the fair market value (or agreed value, as lh. casemey
be) of any pl'Opelty made as capit.1 conlrlbutions;
ii. Such Melllber'~ dislTibutive share of profits and income Items: and,
iii. The amount of any liabilities of the Limited Liability CClnpany assumed by such
Momb.r,
b. From e.chMel11ber'a Copital Aoco\lllt shan be debited tile following:
i. Tho amount of any casll and the fair market valuo of any property cllatrib~lted to
,uch Member;
.:','.'!:::.';.,
ii. Such Member's diBtrlbutiv.. share of !lilY loa.as 0" items of deduction allocoted to
such Member; and
.-''1'.. .
Hi. Tha amOllnt of any liabilities of the Membl!:l .ssumed by the Limited Liability
Compeny,
c. In ilie event a\1 or a portion ohn Intereat in the CcmpmlY is ttlUlsferred in octoroenGe
willl the lerms oHms Agreemont, the tranereree shell Buoceed to the
Capital Accollnt ofilie tw~feror to the extel"! it relate, to the
transi'aued interest,
d_ In dotennining tlle amount oh"y liability for purposes oftlli. P<ll'agraph, there shall
be t.ken into account Code Section 752.(0) and any other appllcobi. .
provision. cfilie Code and Reg>llotionB.
'fhe foregoingprovisicns L\.'ld llle oth.r provisions ofthisl\.greonlcut
rebting to tlla mah~tcnallce of Capital Aocounts arB intended to oomply
with Regulations Section 1.704-1 (b), and shall be intarprel.d atld
applied in a meM.er cOllsislant with such Regulations. In the event the
Members altall deterl1'lhle th.t it is prudent to modify the mBmlet ill
whlc1l the Capital Ao.ollnts, or allY debits or credits thetoto (incJ\\diug,
withcut u!nitation. debits or credits reloting to liabilities tbat are
s.ctlled by eOlllTibuted or distributed property or Illal are assumed by
page 2
ml.,MORE. LLC, OperalingAgrcoment
Rx time:04/22/2008 23:07
Rx i'l0.:049 P.OO5
L00/900"d 090# GS:8G 600G/001vO
S0 38~d
6v9VGS868Z
l~la 3IXla/~NIHJln~ lHvA:wOJj
~NI ~M~
8LS0-L5S-5(1:
L0:00 6000/(0/P0
_ _APK-'o-cUUB~ lU:qj AM.HKIUW ~ULUAVJN1,t;PA,PA
rAX NU. coB bBl eBBl
p, Uti
tho Company or M=bers), l'r. computed in order to comply with such
Re~ulation6, the Members may mAk! such modification, provid.d that
it is not lilt.ly to have a mot.nal.rr""t oil \:he mnouuja diatdb\ltable \t>
!lIlY Member hereunder upon the tennination f.nd liquidation of the
Compeny.
6. "Capltnl CODtrlbutloDB" .\ueans, with respect to unyMemb.r, the amount oflI\on.ey or
initial value ofpltlpcrty (other th.nn money) contributed to the Comp.uywith reapect to tho
percentage interest in the ComplmY held by auoh per.on. Th~ principal amount oh
promislcry not. which iB not r.adily traded 011 an established securities markel aod which is
contribut.d to the Company by file maker of the note slle\1 not be included in the C.pital
Aocount of any person until the Company makes II taxabl~ dispo.ition ofthe note or until
(end to the extent) prinoipal payment I are mado on the note. Any I'ofercnce to the Capitol
Contlibullon of a Mambe, shall in.clude the Capital Contribution made by a predecessor
\lolder ofth.lnterest of .\jOh Mem1:>er.
7, "Code" meana the Int.mal Rev.nue Code ofl986, nS amended, and any oCll'esponding
provision ohucc..diltg law.
8, "Company" mellns Ill. limited liability compallyknown as FlLLMOlUt, LLC.
9. "company Property" means real propert)'!\l1d imprO""lllents thereon, tan{lible and intangible pmonall
uaed in conjuuction with its business.
10. "Consent" mean. the written consent ofep.erson to do the aet or thing for which the consou.t
ill solicited, or the !let of gtanting SUCll censent, as the OO!ltellt may require. Consent shall olso
include snch Person's failure to respond in writing to n solieitation fol' consent within fifteen
(15) days of the date the solioitation ie made,
11. "Debt" melUls (i) any indebtedness for borrowed money of def-arrod purchase price of
proportyor evidenc.d by allote, hondo, or otlter ;,uatruments, (il) obllgatione IlS 1es... under
capitellcas.a, (iii) obUgation. seeClrcd by my mortgage, ploclge, .eO\lrlty ilttl!Iest,
encumbrance, lieD, or cbllrge of any kind existing on any 1'161:1: ownocl or held by the
Company whether or not the Con1pany h., eseumi:d or beoolneliable for the obligation.
saclu'ed thereby, (iv) auy obligation under !ll.lY interest rat. BWllP sgl.'llement (tho pdncipal
amonDl of slloh obligation ahall be deemed to be the uoticual principal arnOUl1t on whioh such
awap i. ba.sed), !IIld (v) obligationu Ulmer direot or indiIect gUllrantees of (hlCludillg
obliglltiona (contingent or otherwile) 10 assure a creditor againJt loss in respcet of)
indebtedness or obliiatiOl1.5 ofth.leinds I'cferted to in cIUlla.. (i), (ii.), (iii), and (iv) il!love,
provided that pebt .hall not inoh\da obligation' ill respect of any Mcounb payable th.t are
incurred in the ordinary course of the Ccmp8l1.Y" business and are not delinquent or are being
contested in good f.ith by appropriatol'rooeodings.
pege 3
FIT..lMORE, LLC - Operating Agrcemel1j
Rx time:04/22/2008 23:07
Rx No.:049 P .006
LZ01900'd 690# 68:86 GOOU6UN
6v9176S888Z
l~IO jIXIO/~IIH81~~ lH~A:WO>~
90 39\1d
:JNl ~MOl
8LS0-LoS-oEl
L0:00 000l1Ell.0
RPK-2::H,UU8 THU ~j .!lD_HKIliW SULUAV INI, VPR, PA
,RX NU. cj8 b81 2881
p, UI
12. "FilleRl yenr" m.eM (i) tlleperiod commencing on the cff~ctive dete oflhia Agreement and
, ,,' ","'" ,,, . ending on December 31, (ii) any S\lbsequent twelve (12) month period con:unencing on
Jenuery I, Blld ending 011 Docember 31, or (iil) any portion of the period deaolibed in clau,e
(Ii) for which !he Company is required to ellocate Profits, Lo~a." llnd other items of income,
gRin, 10,s, or deduction.
13. "Gro.. As,et Value" means. with reepect to any asset, the: ",set's adjusted basis for
federel income tax purposes, except u follows:
a. Thelniti.1 Grose Asset Value of RI1Y Rsect contributed by a Member to the Company
shall be the gJ.ooss fair market value of such RSS.t, all determined by all
'Mombers, provided that, ifthc contributing Member is R MRnaging
Agellt. lile determination of \he fair morlcet vslue of a contributed lIBset
.shell be detennined by appraisal.
b.
The ilioose Assel Values of aU Compony A$scts shali be adjusted to equal tlleir
respective gross fair merket values, as dotermined by the Members. as of the
fcliowing time" (a) the w::qui!ltion of en additional interest in 1he Compmy by any
new or ex.isti.llg Membor in ex.chBIlgc for more than R de minimis Capital
.Cpntribution; (b) the distribution bytlie Comp.lll' to a Member of mere thma de
minimis 9luount of Property .. comid.ralicn for a;l interest in the Company; and (e)
the liquidation of the COlnpany withiu the meaning of R'lIUlatioDs Section
1.704-l(b)(2)(ii)(g); provided howovai:, that tho adju,tmentB pursuant to olaus.. (a)
alld (b) above shall be made only ifUle Mombeu nasonsbly determine lhat suoh
,sdjo'tments sr,e, noeessary or appropriate to refl.ct~the relative eeonomic interests cf
the Members in the CompB:nY; .
:' ~ . . . .
. .. . 1"
II'..>"
c, Tile Gross Asset Vellle of MY Compmy aSlets diStribllted to t1.llY Member shell be
adjusted 10 equal tM gross mark.et value of sllch aes.t on the date of
dietribntion as determined by the distributee and the M01I'lbou other
thllJl the distributoe, provided tbot, in tho ev,mt of,. disagreement, the
detennination ofth. fair market vahle ofthc distributed ..set shall bo
determined by appraisal; and The Grou Apet ValueIl ofCompa11Y
assets sh.ll be increaeed (or decreesed) to rell.ot imy aClJUlltments to
ihe adjusted bnsis ofeuoh essets pursl\an! to Code Section 734 (b) or
Code Section 743(b), but only to tb.e cxtonllhat such edjuSMelll:s .re
taksll into acoCllIlt ill detsnnining Capital Accounts pursuant to
Regltlatlons Sectionl.704(b)(2)(iv)(m); .pl'Clvi<led however, that ili:oss
Asset Valuss shllU \lot b. adjusted pursuent to this paragreph to the
oxten! t1le Memb.rs determine the. a" adjustment is nol neceSSEl1')' or
t1ppropriule ill .ollnectlon WiUl a lTanssclion \hit would o1herwise
result in all Rdjus1111.nt pursuant to ti,l. Seotion,
page 4
FILLMORE, LLC . Opel..ting Agreement
R.; time:04/22/2003 28:07
Rx No, :049 P ,007
L60ILOO'd 690# 6S:8Z 6006/66/VO
L0 39'7d
6v9v69868Z
ldlO 3IXIO,~NIH8ln~ lHVA:wOJj
:JNl "'M~
8L!;0-L5S-5Eo
L0:00 500o/EZ/P0
A~K-GJ-GUU~ THU lU:qq AM ~KlliW ~ULVAV1Nl ~~A ~A
__ ~ _" _ __ ._.__ ___" I I
~AX NU, GJ~ b~l G~~l
p, ue
.14.". . "Iotera't" or, "Memberoh\p Interest" meens the ownersbip \nt.reet of. Membor in the
, "',"" ". '" "OmpM)' et.any pBrtiC1.\lar .time, inchlding thnight ohuch Memberto any and all benefits to
which such Member may bc entitled $ Pl'Ovided ii' this Agr'eJI\ent and in the Act, together
with 1I1e .oblignlion:of Buch Member to comply with .11 provisions of this Agre<mtent .ud of
the Act, as the eame m.y fTom time to time change by virtue oftn1Ils'lers or ChiUl&OS in capital
contributions of the Members or otlJerwise, which interest, ellpreleed as . percentage, shall
absent proof to the contrtu)'he a) set forth on lh. Schedulel etls.ohed hereto or in an
ameudment thereto.
.. ,,,:',, 15:' "Member" me!li1s snYl'er.ol1 which becemes a member or a successor member as provided
Iter.i,n. and which is listed on the records ofthe Company as owner of a Membership
lnlorest in the Compony.
1G, "Net Cash from Operations" ,n.ams the gross cash p,ocee~ from Company operanons
(including seles and dispo,itiom in the ordinllt}' course ofblloiness),I.a; all expenses,
including toxes s\,d d.bt e.rvice of the Compeny, nnd 1es, the portion thereof l\Sed to payor
~t.b1ish re,.rves fer an Company expenses, debt pa)'lnents, capital improvements,
replacements, Sl,d contingencies, allllll delennlned by lh. Members. "Net Cash from
Ope"'tioo," .lta\! not ber.duced by depreciation, nmortization. com recovery deductions 01'
! ., sitnilar allow8li:os..
17. "Net Ca,h from Extraenllnal'Y Item'" meaps nay transaction not in the ordiDlll'Y cours. of
businesB which result! in the Company's receipt of caolt or other coosidera1i.ol\ other than
Capit.) Contributions, h,c)uctillg, without limitation, proceeds of sales OI exchanges or other
. dispositione.ofpropcrtynot in the otdit,etY course ofbusin.'s, financInfO, refirnmou'g,
condemnations, rccoveri e, of damage swarda, and w\lnInce proceade, less any portion
thereof used, to establish reserves, aU .s determined by the Members, "Net Cash from
ExtraordinlU)' Item," shall inelude all priuoipalll11d inlerest pnymelllll with resp.ot to any note
cr oth.r c'o1igation received by the Company in corolection with sales and other disposition.
(other thm in the ordinaxy cour,e ofbuaine5S) ofl'!operty,
18, "Notice" me.n, a w<iting contailling the lnfonuation requlrod by thi:s Agreement to be COmlllL\nlcated to
the last.known address oh"ch Person, the :rUth 'cu,iness day af\cr deposit in tho U.s. mail being
doemed the date of ."on Notica; provided, however, that any written communioation containing such
informnlion sent to ouch Poraon in any other manner .nd nchtally reeei.nd by such PersOll shall
cCl\lltiMe Notice for all purposea 1.U,der thia Al:l'eement on the date of actual receipt,
19, "Persou" mcnm any individual, limited liability company, Membership, corporation,
t\11Bt or oti,er entity.
ZO, "Profits" anrl "Lo,ses" menns, for ea.hFi.cal Yell!, en amount equalta the Company.
taxable income 01' los, for sllch yell! cr period, detennined in .ccordllilce with Cede Section
pege 5
FlLLMORB, LtC - Operating Agreement
Rx tirne:O~/22/2008 23:07
Rx No,:O~8 P.008
LZO/800'd Zgaif 88:8Z GOOZ/ZZ/rO
Gr9rZS8G8Z
l~IO 3IXIO/8NIH8lnW lH~A:wOJj
80 3~d
8NJ ~M<J
8L90-L59-5Ec
LO:OO 500c/Ec/~0
...!!~.K-,::i-,UU8..1HU lU:4Q AM ~HllilU ~ULUAVINI,~PA,PA
,AX NU. ,,8 b81 ,~81
p, U8
703(.) (for thi. l'UJ1'oae, aU item.; of income, gain, loss. or deduction required to be ,mIen
........" '" .epBIalOly,pursuant,\0.Code.s,cI10n 703(.)(1.) .holl be included ill te:J\able income or.lo..),...._.....,.
with the 1'CHowing BdJ1IBlInent.: .
....' ..'
.","
o.
Any income of the. Company that i. ~empt from federel htcom.tox and not
otherwise te-ken inlo account in oomputing Profit. end LOBse. pUT$UBJlI
to this Secti.on .haU be added to .uell llO(oble income or Iou;
b,
Anyexpflllditures ofth. Company descdbed in Code Sectioo 70S(a)(2)(B) or l:J:eoted
all Code Seol10n 705(a)(2)(B) expenditures pUrll\antlo Regt\1e.tiom
Section 1.704(b)(s)(iv)(I), and not otherwise takeo Into accoll.flt in
~omputblg Profits or Lo.se. pursuant to thiB Section 8hel\ be
sllbtracted from ouch tllXahl. income or lcssj
c,
ill the event tbe Gro~. A..etV.lue of any Company ..set is adjusted pursU;}1lt to tho
provision. herein, the amo\ml ohueh IlClJustment shall be tal,en into .
account as gain or loas from the disposition c!s\\ch OIlset for purposes
of computing Profits or Lesa.,; .
d.
Gain orloss !\l5ultil1g from any dlsposit\on of Company Properlywi1h respect to
which gain cr loss i. recognized fur federal inoome tB:>< purposes ahan be computed by
reforence to the Gross A.set Value ofthe proporty disposed of notwithstanding that
the adjuSted tax basi. oh\\ch prop.n~ differ. from its Gro.. Asset Value;
.. .e. '" .Te.the'extont,an .djustn\ent to the adjusted tal: bllSi. OfollY Company assetputsuaut
. to Code Section 734(b) or Code Scotion 743(b)laloquirad purBUllOt to
R.""lation. Section 1.704.1 (b)(2)(iv)(m)(4) t~ b. taken into account
iu determining Capiilll AccountB as a result of. distribution other than
in liquidation ofa Memb<>r's inte~st in the Colnpany, the amount of
sueh adj uslment shflll be treated 8S l\l1 item of gain (iftlle adjustment
increases.tlle bMi. of the aBset) or 10ls (if the adjuatmeltt decrellOe5lhe
basil oHhe saset) frOI11 the disposition ohlle asset Slld Bhall b.. taken
into account for Pllrpoa.s of computing Pl'ofi18 or Losus;
f, Nctwltllatattdin~ any ether provi>ion oHhiB Section, any items wllic\) are
specially allocated herein ahan not be taken h\to ~cccunt ht cotnp~ltlug
Profits or LOSBe,.
21. "Regulations" moans the reguiatiom promulgate4 by:the Depllltment cfT.ro..ury under the
provi$ion, of the Code.
22. "Substitut.e M.mb.r" m.ans any Perscn .dmitted to the Company pursuant te tlto
page 6
FILLMORE, LLC - Operating Agl'eement
R~ time:04/22/2008 23:07
Rx No.:048 P.009
L60/600'd 690# 88:86 G006/66/VO
5B 39';id
6v9v69868Z
l~IO jIXIO/9NlHOlnW lHVA:wOlj
:JNI ';ir;;j
BL.B-L55-6EI:
L0:B0 5001:/[l/.0
RPK-<NUU~ '12!~_1U: QUM ~K1UW oULURV INI, cPR, PR
---,-
rRX NU, ,j~ 081 ,881
p, IU
terms hereof. .
23
. _ . ,1'- .,'.'(,1\' ",...b.':"'l ...",.
':un;ta" meana all units of Mornbol'ship Interest in Company,
..i.:.
. . . , . . .
.. ,-...". "
page 7
FILLMORE. LLC . Operating Agre.ment
Rx time; 04/22/2008 23: 08
R:, No. :049 P ,010
L30/0l0'd 390# 88:838003/60/\70
8\79\7398883
l~IO jIXIO!nNIH811~ lHVA:WOJj
01 39\;id
:JNl \;iMOl
8L90-L69-6So
L0:00 600Z/SO/P0
~lH:'o-~UU8_JHU lU: 44 AM ~HJUW ~ULUAV1NJ, UPA, PA
PAX NU, ~o8 o~l ~881
P. ] 1
THE AGREEMENT
The members deBil'e to form a limited liability company pursuant to the laws of the Slat. of
Florida. Accordingly, in consideration of Ill' mutual covenants contained herein, they
agree end certify as followa:
THE LIMITED LIABn..ITY COMPANY
J, Fonniltion, The members hereby fonn a limi~ed liability company (tho "Company" or the
"Limited Liability Complll1.y") !llbjoct to the provisions of the Florida Limited
Liability Ccmpany Att as otmently in effect (the "Act"),
2. l!iIln2... Th. Limited Liability Ccmpany ha. baen organi..d as a Florida Limitod Liability
Company UIlder lb." Ploridll Litnited Liability Company Aat by the filing ot Articles of
Orgll\izaticn with 11\0 Orlic. of the Secrstory o[State ofthe State of Florid.. A copy ofthe
Articles ofOrl:anization, as filed, is attlWhed as Bxhibit A, The Members shall make ""y
other fllings l'squind by low to b. filed end recorded hereafter fur any re.san, in such of lice
or offices Il5 are required lmder the Jaw, ofth. State of Florida or elsewhere. The Mombe",
shan do all other !llllll and i{nngs that may now or herea.f\er be required for the perf.ction and
aantinuing maintenllnce of the Company... a limited liabiliiy company under the laws of tho
State ofPlorlda and maintain the Compauy B8 a foreign limited liability oompa\\)f under the
laws of any oUrer state. where Company prop~rty i, located.
3. Nama orUmited Uabillt'\! Cnmoanv, Tho nllIlle of the limited liabllity company sh..U be
FILLMOltE, LLC (herainafler referred to .. the "Company").
4, ROlliotared Office. Re!!istered Arrant. The location of the I.gistered omoo cfth. Company
shall be 2250 WlUlhb\UD Avenue, Nnpl.s, Florida 34117, SlId ther..t, or.t S\lab other
location Il5 me Members mllY designate. The ComplUly's regi~..ed agent at SllCh odd!." .mall
be Terun 1lIllmore.
5, prioeion! om.. ond Plllcs of Bu.ioes.. The principal office oflbe ComplU1Y Pha11 be at
:USO W..hburlI A'\I8I1UO, Nnpl.., FloridA 34117, or at such otherlocntion Ill! m.ybe
hereafter be determined by Ute Member.hip. The Company may o1so maintain a plMe of
business .t StIch otl,er locat10n I\S the Member.hip may datanuine. Tile Member,hip ,1\1\11
pron\ptly notify the 'Members of any change in 1:1\e principal office or othfll' placa ofbLlsin.ss,
or a!the ..tabUshment of ""lditional offices.
pagel
Fll..LMOR1l, LLC . Operating Agreement
Rx time:04/22/2008 23:08
Rx No, :049 P ,011
LlO/llO'd 190# 88:8l 600llll/vO
6179\7(;9868(;
l~IO 3IXIO/:Ji'IlHOlf1tlllH'I'A:wOJj
11 39~d
ONI ~M<I
BL>0-L5>-6Eo
L0:00 5000/Eol.0
',----_.., _._-----~,-. _._---~
~AX NU. coB b8] ,881
1
ARTICLE I \
PURPOSE AND BUSINESS OF jE COMPANY
'Pui-hoae'Of tb..Co"'tl~nV. The sole ;Jl\t;Jcse!ofthe COFpany!s to acquire, own, fillance or
refinance, oporato, develop, .lense, sell, dlspo.. of, sndjotllOlWlse mnnag. the
Compnny:Property for investment purposes snd to tmg~ge in allY md oU activities,
relatBd 01" incldamtal, to the foregoing pUlpose Met nnYtlother businen pennitteet by
Plorida law, parlioulI\l'ly the acquisition, mnnBi,omont d development oftent.1
.property (the !'project").. ,
Autborltv of Comnonv. In order to carry O\\t its pUl]ose, tho Compnny i. ompowered and
authorized in fmth.l'Ilnce ofth. Company business ani .ubject to the provlriona of this
Agr.ement to;
r. I,
_ R~~-,3-,UU8 THU lU:44 RM ~~l\ilU :;ULVRV1Nl, CPR. PR
..' '1,.. .,
z.
'.
Borrow money Ill\d issue evidences ofindebte nass ill furthersnce of any or aU of the
objectives of its blllllness;
b.
Lend money and g\\o1"onteo loans in f\llthC111l\ 0 of tho Company purpose
c.
Acquire, construct, hold, maintain, .ell, u.n! , convey, assign, mortgage, plodga,
exchange, or otherwise djspose of Compony sots;
d.
Acquire the assets, stook, limited liability co,PaIlY interests, Membership interest, or
other ownership .interests of, morge or consol date wiU\, any other
business org'll1\zntioni '.
Milke investments in interest bearing ond nOlinterest bo.ring obligations:
Enter into, exeont" ancl curry out contracl1; an~ agreements and any and all other
dOOumOI\tS arJ.d insl1'1llnents;
e.
f.
g.
Bring and defend ecliollS at law or at equity,
h.
Purch..e, caocel or othe1wise refiro or dlspo e of the lnterast of any Member,
pursuant to tI,e e"..pres. provisions of this A eement; and
i.
Ar,y and .n otber acts o.nd thlugs necessary r proper b, furU\erllflce ofthe COlnpany
b\1SilleSI.
page :I.
Ffi..LMORE, LLC - Opera ng Agrement
Rx time:04/22/2008 23:06
Rx Mo. :049 P .012
Gv9vZS888Z
l~IO 3IXIQ18NIH81nW lKVA:wOJj
ot 39~d
LZOIZIO"d ZSO# 28:8Z 60OZlZZIvO
8NI \1M<J
BLS0-L5S-5Eo
L0:00 5000/Eo/00
_ ~K-"'j-,,.uU~_~rHU lU:qq..Br!.~KlliW ,ULURVINJ,UYR,YR
rRX NU, ",8 081 ,,~~I
y, 10
ARTICL'.E II
, : ... :.' '.'. MEMBERS A1\'D MEMBERSHIl' INTERESTS
. ... '1;.. . .MambeTR"nlld Cnyltll'1 ContTibntlona, At such time as requested by tb. MllUngillg Agent,
but no Inter than the date of the purchas. money loan. for the Projeot, the Members
shall make CapitAl Contributions to the Limited Liability ComplmY (the "Company")
as .et forth on the attached Schedtlle,
a. Unite il1 the Compl\llY shall not he issued to a M.mber\lUtil reoeipt of such Member's
Initial Capital Contributioll hereunder.
Z. MembeTslIl1l [nterests. The names and ad.dresses oftlw initial Member., as well as their
initial Membership 111terests, shall be as set farlb on Schedule 1 attnehed hereto and
inoorporated hereiu by ref.renoB.
3, Additlon.l Contriblltlcns, Boeh Member sna\! be responsible for its pro rata share (baaed ou
its Mombership Interest) of additional capital oontribution. ("Required Capital
Conlribu\iono") required purronnt to a Dotlce li:om 1ha Membership, subjeot to thelimilJ1t\ons
her.in. In the event thut Required AddilionallContributioU! arc required by the Members,
ellCh Member flhall, wilhin thirty (30) dayl of:nolioeli'oln the Membership cf 8uch Required
Capital Cont'ributicna, cClnlribu\e cash to the CompanytowBrd. .atiefaouon ofauch ..
obligation, Notwithstanding tho fcregoing, tho Membership shall not r~quire tlme.sonably. "_""",.':~::c~..:',::..~'.
high reserve" ill order to caus.Required Capital Contrib\ltions to be made by the Members.-.......
FUI1her, tba Membersbip sh~lI1\ot give notices for Reqv.iIod Capiti1l Contributions exoept to
the exten.t that iuob Required Capital Contrihtltiol\:l or. neeeisary for the p\UOhnae,
development, operation or repnir of thIl Pl'Oject.
4. Ileturn of Capltnl Contribntions, Exoept all provided in thin "'gl-eom~t, no Member i8
enti\led to deUland or receive the return of Ius oapital contribution.
S, 1\mit.d Liabllltv Comoanv Votin2. In ell m.Uen submitted to the Members fot ·
voto, ench Member shall voto in propol'lion to such Member's 111terest in the
Company.
ARTICLE III
ALLOCATION OF PROFITS AND LOSSES AND DlSTRl.BUTIONS
1, Allocations.
a. Praflts. Profits shall be lllloealed to the M.mbors in aoocrdancc with their respective
M~bership hllerests il, the Compal1Y.
p.ge 3
FlLLMORE.l,LC" Operatil1g A.greemel1t
Rx time:04/22i2008 23:08
Rx 14o,:0Ii9 P .013
LZO/SIO'd Z90# V8:SZ 800ZIZZlvO
n 39~d
8v9vZ9888Z
l~IO 3IXIO/9NIH811~ lK9A:WOJj
ONI ~I>\OI
BLS0-L6S-6E2:
L0:00 60B2:/Eol.0
i .-
I
APK-{j-"U~rHU lU:4b AM ~KlUW oULVAVINI,~PA,PA
rAX NU, ,,~~ b~1 "~~1
p, 14
b.
Lo...s. Losso. shall be allocated to the Membafs in accordance with fueirrespective
. Mmbemhip Interssts ill the Compall)!. ... . ..... ..... .....
. ,
2, Distribution.. From time to time tho Limit.d Liability ComplUl)' may di.tribllte Ie the
. Momben;..nycasli or property which is doom'.d avllilllblo for distrib,\tion. In delermining Il,.
amonnt "available fer distl'ibution" the Member.hip sholl coru;ider the neede of the Limited
Liability Company fer operating Clll'iial, tho prcfits or loss.. and cash flow projected tc be
gener.tad from OpOIlllioIls ofth. Limited Liability Con1pany,the borrowing power of the
Limited Liability Company, as well as BllY debt reductions whioh may bo required to be
made, the Ilead to e.tablilh casll reserves fOT Bny oontlngencies Bnd such other criteria.. 'U10
Membership may deem appropriate under the circumsto:llce., No distribution shall b. lnade
if, aftor gIving effect to the dietn'bution, the liabilities oftbe Limited Liability Company,
other Ul8Jlliabilities to the MembMS for profitB, \OSO'. WlC! distributions and liabilities for
which the reoourse of er!ltlitors is limited to specified propslty ofthe Limited Liability
Company, exceed the foir market value offu. assets of the Lintited Liability Compony,
except that the fair vBlue of the prcl'erty tlult i. subject to a liability for which the r.ceUfee of
creditors is limited .hell be inotllded BS M Maet oftb Limited Liability CempllllY only to
SUoll."te:nt that the fair marlcol value of that prop arty exceed. tit. liability, Except a.
ctherwise provided for In the event ofliqllidation, all distributions, whether from Net
Operating Cash Flew or Nat Cssh from Extraordinill'Y Items, shell be distributed to the
,\.. I". 'Member. in accora.ow ";'ith their Membersl;ip lnter.sto in the Limited Liability Company.
. ~., :
",'
ARTICLE IV
lUGlITS, OBLIGATIONS AND ~OWERS OF THE MEMBERS
"
,
1, Mennaemellt. The Company shall b. mlUlaged by tho Members. Exoept.s otheT\vise
provided inlhio Agreement or the Act, each member h an agent of the Compony fer tbe
purpose oflhe Company's husiness aff'llirs and the act ofnny M.mber, in.cluding the
execution ill the nBme ofllle Company of an inst:rum.nt for opparontly canying 011 in the
ueunl way the busine.s or affairs ofthe Comp~ny, binds the Company, unless the Member
does not have authority to act fOT th. Company in the psrtieular m~tt.r end tho pOl'llOll with
wbom the Merl1ber is delliillS hBS ICllcwledge of the foc.t that the memb=r does llot have the
.utbcdty to act
:1. M.etinl!B of and Votin!! bv Members.
a. A n,eeling of the Members maybe called at IlllY timebytho.o Members holding at
least thirty percent (30%) oftlla Peroents.ges th.n held by Members. Meelil)gs of
Mombels .hall be hold at the C0ll111l\lI)"S prUwi,,"1 place ofbushJes. or at any other
place desifltlated by the por.on oalling tho meeting. Not leso tl,an five (5) not more
than ninety (90) days before e\!eh meeting, Ihe Person calling the nleating shall give
written notioe of the meeting to eeoh Member entitl.d to vote at the meeting, The
page 4
FIL1..MORE, LLC - Operating Alll'eemenl
Rx time;04/22/20U9 23:08
Rx No.:043 P .014
LZOlv [0' d ZgQ# v8: 8Z GODZlZZlvD
6v9vZg86SZ
1(110 3IXIO/OI'J1I{)U lHl"A:wOJ.::I
PI 39~d
:JNl ~M<J
8L90-L59-5El
L0'00 500l/El/P0
APR-23-2009 T.lliL1 0; 45 AM SRI G ID SOLDAV I NI, CPA, PA
FAX NO. 239 591 299l
p, 15
..I':
notlce sh.ll,st~~othe time, place Jlnd purpose ohhe meeting. Notwithstanding the
foregolng provillion., each Member who is entitled to notice walves llotioe if bafore
., or aiter th_ meeting the M.mbor sign,fa waiver ohhe aotio. which is filed with the
recorda ofMembsrB'Il\SetUlgS. or ill presel\t lit the n\eoting in per,oll or by proxy.
Unleas this' Agre'in1lent provid.s otherWise. at Jl meeting of Members, the presence io
person or by proxy of members holding not less tbM f1fty one percent (51 %) o[the
Percentages then held by Members con61:ituteR Jl qtlorom, A Member may vote either
in porscn or by written pro,;y signed by tho Member or by the M=bcr's duly
authorized attorney.in-fact.
b.
Except as otherwis. provided in the Act O' in tl\is Agreement, the affinnative vote of
Members holding fifty.one (5 l'Vel or more ofth.l'.rcentages thOlIl held by Members
shall he re'l.turod to approve any malter coming before the Members.
3. Per,oosl.Scrvtce. No M.mber ahall be requi11ld 10 perforlI\ Bervlees for tho Compeny solely
by virtu. orbei11ga Menlb.,.. 'Unl.ss i1flproved 1>y tbJl Memb.rs, no Memher sl1all be ""HUed
to compensation for ..rvioes performed for the Company. Upon Itlbstontiatlon ofth. amount
.nd purpo.' thereof, the M"moer atlal1 b. entitled to reimbursement for expenses ..ssonabl.
inculTed in furtherance oCthe bUlinoss end affaire of the CompllIlY.
4, Duties of Parttes.
a. A Merr.ber 8h.1I,10t belioble. r..po~ibl., or accountable in damages or otherwloe to
the CompMy or to any other Member fOI llnY aellon taken or any failure to act on
behalf ofthe Compnny within the scop. oftlte ."thorlty confen-ad 011 the Member by
this Agreement or by law, Il1ll.ss the action waB token or omission was mo.de
fraudulently or in bed faith or cnlBss the action or omission constiMed ~oss
negligence.
b. Except aa otheJ.wiss expresll1yprovid.d in Section 4.c., nothing in \hi. Agre.ment
shall be d..med to re.trict in any waytbe rights ofBnyMember, or oflll3Y Affiliate of
flllY Member, to conduct any o\h'I' busin.ss or activitywhatsoev.r, and no Mertlber
shall be flccollntable to \he COmpEWY or to at\y otb.er Member with respect to tlllit
husinflSS or aC\1vily even ifthe bllslness or oetivity compotos with tho Compa'\)"s
business. Tl,. OrllBltization ofth. company shall 'be without pr~iudic. 1;0 the
Members' respective rigbts (or the rigbts oftheirrespoctive Affilialc.) to maintBin,
oxpal1<l, or <liversify such other interests 'L\d ac\ivitias and to receive and enjoy profits
or compcn..tioll therefrom. Each Member wsives any rights the Member might
otherwise have to .hare oj' participate in s"ch oth.r iater.et or activitie. of any other
Member or the Mel\\ber's Affililrtas.
C. E.oll meln1>el' undcr.tmd~ and aclwow!e<:!IlCs tllat tbe oonduct of the COlnpany'a
pago S
FILLMORE, LLC - OpeJ:llting Agroement
Rx time:04/22/2D08 28:08
R~ No .:048 P .015
L60/910"d 690# VS:S6 G006/GllvO
51 38"d
GV9V698686
l~IO 3IXIO/9NIHOlru~ lH~^:WOJj
:JNI Wk>J
8L!:i0-L5S-5EG
L0:00 5000/Eo/;0
"
~K-L,-,.U~JI!I:l.D!:.4b AM ~KIUW ,ULUAV INI, G~A, ~A
FAX NU, 'J~ o~l L~~l
~. l~
b\l.iness m.y hwolvo b\\!iness dealing. ~nd undertakings wlth Members and their
Affiliates. In any arthoso csSOS,;Ul0S0 dealings and \lndertaklngs shsll be at ami'.
length ""d oil commercinlly leason,bi. torms, '
5. LllIblUtv.nnd Illdomnilleathm.
a A MEMBER. A1'I AGENT, OR ANY EMPLOYEB OF Tlffi COMP ANY SHALL
NOT BE pB,RSONALL Y LIABLE FOR THB DEBTS,
OEUGATIONS, 0):<. LIABILITIES OF THE LJMlTED LlABll.ITY
COMPANY WHETHER AlUSING IN CONTRACT. TORT. OR
OTHERWISE, OR FOR 'mE ACT OR OMISSIONS OF ANY
ME..IvlBBR. AGENT. OR EMl'LO'i'EE OF THE COMPANY.
b. The Company shall h\demuify CSllh Member for allY .c! performed by the Mamber
with respeot to Company matt..s. except for willful mlBconduct or
r.oldelsnes, or an intelltlol1lll breooh ofthill Agreement.
ARTICLE V
TRANSFERS OF, Al'\'D RESTRICTIONS ON TRANSFERS OF
INTERESTS OF MEMBERS
L Investment Repr.sentatlo.... Each Membar hereby r.pre.enta and warrants to the CompiUlY
Slld the Membership s.s follows:
a, Such Member ha. sdficient knowl.dge ll.nd experience in financial and business
matters that it is capable of evaluating 111e merits and risle! of it. invesllI1w in the
Company; ,
b. rhe Company has mild. avuilable to such Momber Illld his advisors the opportunil;i to
8lik'l\tcstions of, and rcc.ive allswer, from. the Company and any person .cting on
hIs behalf concerning the tel'ltll! Illld conditions of the otferillg ofthe ComplU1Y
Int.....sts. the Company. tts business, .nd ooy other matters which such Mmn.ber or his
sdYl sors deemed mulerial to its purohas. of tho Company Inter.ste and to obtain any
additional infommtlon. to the extent the Company poss.ss.s s\lch infonnation or C!lIl
acq,tlre it without \lJlrees01lllble effort 0' ol\[len.e. neoesssry to evaluate the m.rits Illlc\
l1sks of an investment in the Company.
0, S,lch Member i. scquiring the Company lntere.t for.hi. cwn acCOUtl!. for investment
only. aud not with a view to the re.il1e or distribution thereof. Such Member agrees
th.~t he will 110\ sell. assign., or trnnsfor such lnt.re.t or fraotion thereof!o llny PerSall
who does Dot similarly represenl, warre:nt and agree to these Illvestment
Representations. '
page 6
FIl.LMORE, LLC . Opere\mg Agreement
Rx iime;04/22/ZOCl'3 23:09
Rx No.:049 P.016
LlO/9l0'd lSO# V8:SZ 600lllZIvO
91 38'<1d
6v9vl9868l
l~JO 3lXIO/8NIH8lnW lH~A:WOJ~
ONI ..MOl
8L9S-L5i:;-5El
LS:88 588G/EG/~8
_ _~P\{-~HU~8 THU UJ!..4b AN eKl~1U ~ULVAVINI,l;I'R,PA
rAX NU, ~J8 b81 ~881
p, 11
. .. d.. . . ,,"::I;\1e,ov.ernll oommitment of sneh Member: to inv.~tm.nts which ere not readily
merl'etnble is not disproportionate to hi. net worth, and hi, inve.tment in th.
Company will not cause such overa]] commitlrlent tc become exoessive.
e. Such Menrllor hili adeCltlAte tneMS cfproviding for ita current neael. and p.rsoltlll
contingeo.cies end hM no need for eurr..lt income or liquidily in hie investrnent in tho
CompallY.
f, Suoh Member is awat'll that this lnvaslm.n! involvllll e high degree ofrisle and thnt it i.
pos.ible that it. entire invealment ",~1l be lost. Such ly1ember is able to beaT the
economic risk of this investment in 11\. Company end cen .fford " compl.te lOBS of
such investment.
,
g. Sltoh MembElI understands that (i) in r.liance \Ipon such Membol"a repre5entations,
the Company lnt.rests have not been registered \JI\der the S.ctultie. Act aT eny
epplicable etate sccuritleslaw, (ii) because the COlIlPaoy hrtercsts lll"llol 50
registered, IiUch Member lIlust bear the eoonomic risk cfllolding the Company
Interests indefinitely and the Company Interest. cannot be sold without regiBtraticIl
under !he Securities Act or applicable,etate seoltritie. laWS or exemption therefrom:
(iii) the Company will not. the restriction. on re.alo let forth abovo on its tran.fer
records and any certificates of OWller5hip: (tv) n.i.ther the ManagElI nor anyone cis.
hu undert.liei1. to register for resale MY ofthe Company InteJests undor the Securitios
Act, (v) Rule 144 proIllulgated under the Securities Act is not, and probably nev.r
. wi1~ 9,0, avllj!~h!e for resales of the Company l1rtel'osta; IIfld (vi) there is no trading 01'
resele market for the CcmpRllY Intereits. !L"d it is not likely allY IiUch market will ever
exist in the fu.ture.
Z, Limitation. on Transfer of Limited Liability Comnanv Intereslll,
a. Except as otherwise provided harein, no Memher ,lwl transfer the percentage intercst
in thc Limited Liability Compauy OWllfld by such Memher, by eale, gift, pledge, will
orby operation aflew, either voluntarily orinvQluntnrlly, DXcepl in compliance with
the temn ofthis Paragraph and MY tnlll,:rer in violation hereof shall be null end void
and ofne affoot. Until a Member's p.rcootago inter.!t in tlli' I~imit'd Liability
Company l~ properly tTlUlsImed in .o"ordance with the teIfllll hereof, tll. Limited
Liability ConrpllnY sluU\ not be hOllnd to recognize or deal with IlI1Y thire! party with
respect to such p.rc'.l1tage intere~t.
b. Subject to the provislone of aubpar.graph d, tl,e Memhers shall be permitted to
transfer their Intere.t, Illlder the following ciro\lIn,tnnce,:
page 7
PILLMORIl, U.C - Oper.ting Agre.m"nt
Rx time:04/Z2f2OG~ 23:09
Rx No. :049 P ,017
LZOILIO"d Z9O# V8:SZ 600Z/ZZ/vO
n 39\1d
6v9vZ986SZ
l~IO 3IXIO/8NIH8ln~ lHV^:W01~
ON I ~~IOI
BL90-L59-5Eo
L0:00 500o/Eo/PO
L
_ -.Bl'.K-c:h~UU~ H1U jU:qb AM ~KIUIU SULUAVINI,UPA,PA
rAX NU. c~~ b~l c~~l
P. l~
1. Upon the death of any individu~l Member. sttch Member's Interest shan 'os
trans felTed in ~ccordance with such Membor's Will. oubstitute testamenl2ry
documeut, or by operation of Inw, subject to the tems and condition, of any
'"pllIllte wl;tten agreerl.1ent between the Members:
,),!",:. \,'. ,,'
,
.. . Z. ,., ': An.indlvidual Member mny 8(1\ hi. Interest to an immediate family member. aT........
grantOT or non-grantor mIst for pereon~ estate planning purposes in oreler to
reduce or avoid potential fedefal gift or oslate tu..;
3. AMernber may transfer hi. Interest to auy Affiliate, lIS defined hereill;
c. lnli1e event a Member deaires to ..n ell of the Member's Int.",st in llw Compnny (the
"Selling Interest"), and suoh Member ba. received a bona fide Wlitten offer tc
purchase ITom n named third party, and the Member .desiTes Ie dispose ofhis Interest
pursttant to such offer, the followin& restrictioNl shall apply:
1.. StIch Membar shall immediately notify thc Compa"y and the other Members
thuthc hus.. bOl,a fide offer fer the purchase ofilia lntereat, stating the n.m.
and. address oi'the propos.d pureh...er, and enclosing with each !lotioe a copy
. of the written offer frt>m ill. third pmy sett~ r"rth ell of the tenns and
conditions ofthepropo..d s.Je;
2.. The other Members shall have the option, whicl1 they may exsrcise by giving
notiee to the sellinll Member within thirty (30) days ofraceiving written notice
from the sellillS Member, to purchase the of!'...ed InteTost at the same price lIIlCl
on tho SllI\'l' terms and conditions llll set forth ill the written offer from the
third party. In the event moro tilan one Member desires 10 exercise his option
under this paragraph, thell each Member shell have the right to purohsse the
selling Member's Interest in proportion to the Intereat then held by such
Member,
3. To the extent thot the Members de llot exorcise their option as sot forth above,
thonth. Company shall hove the option. which it may e"erci.. by giving
notice to the soIling Member wilhin fOl'ty (40) dltYs of wrlttell notice fi.om said
Member, to purcha.e the offered It1terest at tha e.me prioe and 011 the .a1\1.
terms and condilions as sot forth in the written offer from the third party,
4. In the ev.,nt th.1 nO Melnbel', nor the Complll1Y. desires to purch.se the S.lllng
ltuere.t, thollthe Membor dosiring to dispose Ofllis Intoreat may .ollllll (but
not 1e88 then ell) of such Int.t~st to Ihe named third plitt)' "pon the following
condiliono only:
pese 8
F1LLMORE, LLC . Operating Agreemen.t
RJ: t ime:04122/2Q03 28:03
Rx No,:049 P ,018
LZO/8IO'd ZSO# SS:SZ 600Z/ZZIvO
81 39\1d
6v9\7ZSS6SZ
l~Ia jIXlafJNIH81n~ lHVA:wOJ~
:IN I \IM~
8L"B-L6"-6€Z:
L0:0B 6BBZ:/€Z:/PB
APIH,H::UU8 THU ]U:4~ AM ij~lliW ~UWAVINJ,I;PA,PA
tAX NU, i::J8 o~l i::8~1
p, 18
n. That the tenn~ wd conclitiom of the sate IIle the same .5 set forth in
. .:". :".."".. ,;,'the written offor of the ,third party originallyprossl1ted to the ,alling
.' '..,;ld\:. ". :.I"Memb~r; F.Uld '
,..... t:;, i:
b. That tl\B third party, prier to cr contemporaneously with the sale to him
, . .ofthe Interest, agreea in writing,.l\Ild.in aoc.pt!l.ble fonn to leg.l
ooun,el for the Company, to b. bound by all ofthe terms nnd
provisions of this Agreement. Provide howllVer, if such sale is not
completed within l1inety (90) days after the eeml1!!. Membor'. notice to
the oth.rMembers ofbis doain ,to 9.11. or if the tenns of such ssle
sh.ll be materially changed, tho s.llingMember shall again givo notice
Ie tho other Membeu of his desire to sell Bl1d another opportl\uity to
exereise tbe .forasaid ~ight of fint refuslll.
,.""d,
,..1.... ,.\."
d. Notwithstllnding IllIY p,rovision. to lb. COl1crary, a Memb.r mny l\ot seU,
tl'nnil'fer, or assJllU in whcle or ilJ part its Membership Interest if snoh
sale, cransfel or assigument would cause n tenmnatioll of the company
for federal income tax purposes whioh would negntivcly i.1Upnct any
romnining Mmnber(s). Anypurported S~18, trimSfer or assignment that
would callS. slIch termin.tion shall b. void and oino effect Cot\nsel
fnr the Company ohsll eive it. opinion to the Membel:sl1ip as to
whether such .alo, trllll9fer or aesigmnent wO\lld oaUse the tarmillation
of Ute Company for f.llllral income tax purposes, as welles whether
mch termination nog.tively impaot6 any remaining Mellibcr(s}, and Ihe
. Membership shall be ~lltled to rely upon ouch opinion In det=iniltg
whether 6uch sale, 1r.mfer or assignment would cause sllch
tennination,
3. Admj,sion of SUbstitute Member,
a. Subjoct to the other provisions of \his Alticl., an assignee ofth. !'nterest of. Membllr
(which shllll be \mderstood to inolud. Il.llypurchiiller, transfer.a. dOl1ee, or other
r!cipiOllt of any disposition of such Interest) ohall be deemed admitted IlIl . Member of
the Compnny only upon the written ceusent ofan M=bon; ofthe Comp.ny, which
001\50nt ahall take effect upon the ocmplelloll of the following Ill! d'lennined in the
solo discretion otlll. Membership:
1. Th. llllsill',ec shall have accepted and .greed to be bo\md by tbe tenn~ and
provisions of this Agreement by exeouting . counterpllrt thereof andlor such
other doomnenta or instn,mlll\ts as tho M~bership may require in order \0
effset the 'Omission of ",eh Persen .s . Membor;
pnge 9
FTLLMORE, LLC . Operating Agreement
Rx time:04122/20m 23:08
Rx 140,:048 P ,0]8
L00/810'd 290# 9S:S2 8002/22/\'0
6v9v2SSG8Z
1<JlO ::JIXIO/8NIH81nl'l lHVA:wOJj
61 39~d
ON! ~MlJ
BLS0-L6S-6EZ
L0:00 600ZIEZI.0
" _.-..----,------'------,--.._-'-~-,_.,-~,----
-.B.~K-"O-FUU8 THU IU: q~ RM ~KILiJP ::;ULURV IN!, GPR, ~A
tRX NU, {,;8 081 ,881
p, ,U
2. If the assignee is a. cOlpofation, the assign.. Ghat! havellrovided tho
". ,.Membershlll with evidonc. $otis,actory to ooullsel for the Company of his
authority to become 0 Member'undor the terms on.d provi.ion. of\:hi.
Agreement;
;I.:'! ,..",
. 3, . Th....lgno. .hall have paid ali r.os.nablo legal f... en filing WId publication
ccst. inctured by tho Company endlor tho G'llel'1l1 Mana.or in connection
with the 5ub.titLltion of tho assignee ~ a Member:
b. For th. purpose of allocating profits N'td 10.s5s and dlstribLltions, a Sltbstitut. Memb.r
.holl b. tr..t.d aa having beoorna, sod sppell!ing in the records of the Company.., a
Member upon its Ol'ecutiug this Agreement .ndlor such other doouments refetted tc
ill thin Section,
c. . Th. Membership sru.J1 cooper~te with tll' Person soelting to become a Substitute
Member by prep~ng the documemal;o!> required above and ma1dllS all offieiQI
:filings !ll1d publioations, The Company !hel! tnlce all ~b action as promptly .s is
procticabl. after the ..tillfaction by tho ...ignce of the Intor..t of the conilltion. cf
this Article to the ,admission of such Person as a Member,
..'
4. Ri~lIt. of AR.i~ne.s of Memb.robin Interests, Subj.ct to the provisions above, and except
.s required by operation of law, the Company.,hall not be obligated for any purpose
;, "",",,' ;".. ". "whatspev,er, to; r.c.cog.llzll.thc.s,.igwnent.by ,eny. Momber of Its .rntC)"$I:5.:\lntil.th~ConlPIlllY''':'.:'- ,. .---.,.-.. ^ "...,
bas received Notice thereof, and eom.plillllee with all the conditions of this Agreement. The.
a"ignIllont of melt Interes!.s in tho Limited Liability Company does not it:lclfetttiUo U... .." ...........-..
..sign.. to participate in the munagemont and affair, of the Limited Liability Company or to
become s M.mber, Such asaigncc is only entitled to receive. to the extent assigned, the
lnterests to which tho IlSsigning Membe): would otherwis. be entiUed.
ARTICLE VI
TERMINATION AND LIQUIDATION
1. Dissolution oft,he Comnnnv, The Ccmpany shall be dissolved upon:
s, The 1111allimous consellt of all Memb.re in the Company;
b. The death, insanity, benlmtptcy, dissolulion. retirement, resignation, or el'pulsion of
any Membor; Except that if there is at lllcst Olle remaining Membor, tho remaining
Merober(s) have the right to oontinue the blUlinos. of the Con1pany, Such right o~n be
exercis.d only by the cffitmativo unanimous vote oftha rll111ainil1g Member(s), within
90 claye after the oceunence of such event. 10 contit1ue the business of ille Company.
lfuot ao exeroised, tne right o:ftlw MembOl'Il to continue the busine.s of the Company
page 1 0
Fn..LMORB, l..LC. Oporating Agroement
Rx time:04/2212009 23:09
Rx No.:049 P.020
LGO/OGO"d GSO# 9S:SG 600G/GG/VO
6v9VG9868l
l~IO 31XI0/8NIHOlnvi lHV^:WOJ~
01; 391:'d
8NI I:'M~
8L90-L69-6E1;
L0:00 6001;/E1;/P0
RYK-i::HUU~ lHU IU:4o AM ~lmW ::;ULUAVINI,WA, YR I-AK NU, ,jB oBI ,BBl
,Wl "".. ~ '''' ~'''''Y' _ ..Ub. ~ 'P'
TllO passage often (10) days after the ute or her dilpoBilion of substantially all of
the ComplUlY's nssets, \Ulloss, prior to Ill. end pi ,uch ten (J 0) day peJ.iod, the
Members conslln(to the acquisition ofothsr qOllpanYPlQPerty;
Any event which roa\s;.es it Qnlewful for the bU~ine~s oithe Company to b.
c""ied on by the members; I
Any ot~er evont oAusing a dissolution of a linJite. liabiUty company under the
Aot,1
W!l1d11l2 Up, l
. El' .. Upon the ,eli.solution of the Company, the Co ~~ y business shan be wouud up .nd
its aBB.ts liquidated IlJl provided h.rein, Md the 'f.t proeaedJl chuah liquidation (or
the procaed. to be distributed in ibe liquidati6n ,f any Member's Interest in the
Comp.ny) .hell be distributed in aocOlclMce \,vi the lerma below,
I
Th. Liquidlltor sh.1I file all certificates and oPti es ofthe dissolution of fl,e Company
required by law, The Liquidstor lOhan ploc..d w mout my W1nece~9f\lY delay. to sell
and oth.rwi;e liqtlidate the CompllnY'~ prop.lty I'ld assets; provided, however, that if
tbeLiquidator sl..all determine fi..at Wl'lmme~\at ~al. of pm cr all oHhe Cornp!\IlY
Pl'Opalt)' wotlld cause undue loss to the Memb'lJ8, in orde.: to avoid aucn 106s, the
LiquidalOrmay, except toth. axte;ntProhibi~1 d_fythelaw, ofth. State ofFlorlda,
defer the Iiquid.tion oftlle Compll!lY J?rop. f9r a raasonsbla tim., eKc.pt for ouch
liquidation as may be Itoe..eary to satisfy th debts and lilIbilities of the Compl\llY to
Persona other filB1l Members or Affiliat.s lhire~f. Upon the complel.liquidation end
distribution oflhe CompBtly a.acts, the Mertlbets shall ce..S 10 be Members ofth.
Compll!lY !\Ild the Liq"jdator ,hall el:ceute, .c~cwledge >nl;! cau.e 10 he filed all
certificates >lId notices r.quired by law to lebn*' "to th. Company,
Upcn dla,oh,tion ofthe Company, the Liqui~.t r ehall callSe lbe acccllut..nt. for the
Compony to pr.per., and tll. Liquidatol sh;;ji' mish tc each M.mber, a statement
s.lthtg forth tho assct~ aud liabilitje~ oflhc q;~l?IUIY tll'on it! dl.eoluticn, Promptly
following 1M ccmplete liq~Ud,lion aud diatri 'on ofthe CompllJlY Property and
as.ole, the LiqUidator ahallcauae ale CQmp~y accountanlS to prepare, lUId tho
Liquidator ~hall :furlliah to cach Memb.r, a stat Inent showing th. mannel in which
the COml'allY l\lleels wareliq\lidaled and di!~.utsd'
1lI.trl~uticn of As.ets \loon LiouidMton. The aSl t1r lhe Limited Liebility Compsny eh.U
b. applied or distrib\~ted in the following order of dO!ilY:
page 11
'lU-MORB, LLC. 0,0t'1 ".,-,
2.
3.
y, <'1
e.
d.
o.
b.
e,
Rx ~ i me: 04/22/2003 23: 08
Rx No .:049 P ,021
617917Z9ffiSZ
l~la jlXla/nNIHJln~ lHVA:wOJj
10 39~d
LZO/I60'd Z90# 9S:SZ 6006/ZZ/170
:JNl ~i'\,"
BLS~-L5S-5Eo
L~:~0 5~~0!Eo!v0
RP~-,',-,UU8 THU lU:4tl An tl~IUlU iiULURVINI,l:PA,PA
rRX NU, ,,8 b81 ,881
p, "
a. To payor provide for the payment of a.11liabllities of the Limited liability
, , . CompQl1Y, other than to tile Members; ~
,~"",""~~~'..., '::.! ~'..:t.,~;~:.ill.:~., :;,' ;:1; '..:
... "'." ':~ b.' '," ../:To'p.ay,ill'expensos ofliquldetion;
~ ,;.... ..: I : >! 1':', II : ~ lit ~. of. ... ... _'0 .
b. To payor provide for the pa)'l11Ont of ~lllinbi1\ties o[the Limited Li>l.bility
Comprmy to its MOl'llbcrs;
c, To the Member~, pro lata, in an amount equal 10 their positive Cnpital AccoUllt
.. !.Illi.,."....,.. ....balances;- and
d, The balanc., if any, 1<> the M~lnbm pro rata in aeeordanoe with their
Percentage I.nterests in the Limited t.inbillty Company,
ARTICLE VII
BOOKS, RECORDS AND FINANCIAL REPORTS
1. I1ooles, Record, BUd Fln.ncinl RlltllUiL
, .. 'e:. ""':"Tnc'LiInltecl'Liahllity Company ehall'maintain a. pm ofits bookund records
'at .!ltimea: ' :.
: .,',,' "';' ; ~' .':' ".; : ..',. " i
)"
i. a current list ofthe name and la,t known busine.s, re,idence, or mailing
adelreas of eacll Member;
..1.....'...."..... ..
Ii. a copy o[tho Certificate ofFotmatiol1 and all a1nOllldmenl:! thereto, lllld
a copy of this Agretltl'lent and all exhibits and amendulonts thereto;
]l1, oomplete inform.lion regarding the date on which .ach Member becsrne a
Member, the date and agr.ed value of ellCh capital con\:ri,butioll of each MemMr, the
peroelltalle illtere~t in the Limited Liability Company ef each Member, and tho Capital
AceoUllt of each Member; and
iv. . copy of aJl tax j.eturJls alld all !\IIIlu01 'CCCl1n!s.
b, The boo1" and records cBbo Limitod Liability Company shon ut all times '00
m.o'"lained at the principel office ofthe Limited Liability Company. Each M.mber, or
hi. duly authorized agrnt, shall have fuJI, complete, al1d unrestricted access to all of
tlle Limited Liabi1ity Compauy'. books and records at .11 timea.
Z, !;(uet9dv of CcmUllnV Funds: BAni, AccnunU,
page 12
Fl.L.LMORB, LLC - Operating Agreement
Rx 1:ime:04l22/200S 23: 10
Rx No. :043 P.022
LlO/ZZO'd Z90# SS:SZ 600Z/ZZ/vO
1;1; 39';'d
6v9vC:;9S6SZ
l~Ia 3IXla!8NIHOln~ lHvA:lliOJj
~NJ ';'M~
8L~0-L59-5E1;
L0:00 5001;/E1;/.0
. _~rK-,!-,U~\I...'IHU JU:q~ Rrl HKlliW oUWAVJNI,(;P~,PA
,AX NU, ,~~ 'o~1 ,8~1
p, ,~
a. The Mlllflbershil' ahaH have fi.ducill!)' responsibility fer the safekeeping and use of an
funds and assets of tho COI'l'_;lI!.UY, whether or 110t in the immediate possession or
eOlltrol of the Membe..hip. The t\\nd$ ofihe Company shallllot be commini1ed ,,1th
tlle l'Und!.of any other Par,cD, and th~ Mel1lb.'1!:~~jp,~ll~I)"!'~:.enlPloy, O! permi_t a~y
other Person to employ, such f1mds in. any manner except for the b"ll"fit of'tb.e
Compl1l\Y. .
b. All fllnd, of the Company not otherwi,a inv..ted shall be deposited in one or more
accounts maintained in luch bnnkinS instilu1iona as tho Membel1lhip shaH determine,
and withdrawals ,hall be lnsde onl~ in the rog\ll1ir cOl\rse of Company busillass en
such slS'lOtur. or signatuns as Ihe Memb.,.,hip may, from tima to time, determine.
3.
RenortJl to Members llDd Ta" l1'iIInl!l. The Co.mplU1Y shall file with tho appropriate internal
Revenue Service office all infOlmalion tax return and sh.11, at the time of iiling, mail 10 each
MemD.r . copy of it! Schedule K.1 to lhs Company's ulformation tax return within 90 days
chbe end of the Compeny's fiscal year,ln addition to all Company infonnm:ion ,equired by
tbe Members for lax reporting pl1l'poaes, the ComplU1Y also shall tnlIiJ to !he ;MembOla, within
the 90.day period after the end o!the Company'. fiscal year, a oopy of the Compl\llY'. audited
balaD.e. eheet, .aall. flow s.nd operating ~tement for the fiscal )'Oar juat etlded. At Ille close of
. .ach fiscal )'Oot, lUI aeoolmtlng lIhall be mado'ofthe operation. of tho yaar which shall jnc),lde
Ihe prepm'atioll ora balance sheet as at the close ofthe year and .t..t.ment ofth. operations of
the Limited Liability Compr.ny for the yeBI tl,e1l ended. Bll:Sed on Ule dctennlnatiotlll so made,
the Limited LiabilitY ComplU1Y sh.>ll, within th. time period roguired (including extensions)
fUe all necessary \ax rctunls and pay.ll taxes os may be due resulting from the Limilad
Liability Ccmpany'. operariona,
ARTICLE Vlll
AMENDMENTS
Nc amendment to this Agreement maybe made witholll Ihe unanimous cOIII.nt oftlle MllI1lbership,
elleept that thiB Agreement maybe alUsnded. by a majority illtue.1 of the ;Mem.bere (i) to admit
Additional or Substitute Members to the Compnny; (ii) to cure an ambiguity; (Ui) to correct or
supplement any provisicll her.ofwhich may be iUCOllllist01~t ,,1th IIny other provision hereof. (iv) or
to mate a.uy other provi,ioll witb ro.pect to matters or questions arising under thia Agreement not
inconsi.tOllt willl the intsnt of this Agreemellt.
Notwithstanding the fClogoing, Ihi. Agreement shall not be amln'lded without the consent of eae11
MonlDer adversely olfectod ifsu.h 'mendment wOt\ld(i) modifY the limited liability ofa Momber, or
(ii) alter the Inter..t ofa Member in the profit., losses, other item', or any CompilllY distribution..
ARTICLE IX
ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS
page 13
FILLMORE, LLC . Op.rating Agre'D18\lt
Rx ~ime:04/2212008 23:10
Rx No, :049 P .023
LZO/860'd ZSO# S8:8Z 600Z/ZZ/rO
Gr9rZS86SZ
l~IO 3IXIO/8NIH8ln~ lHVA:wOJj
EZ: 39t1d
8NI ~M<I
8LS0-Le.S-e.E~
LB:BB e.08~/E~/pB
_~PK-(~-(u~rHU lU:~~ RM ~KIUIU ,ULURV1NJ,oPR,PR
rRX NU, (~~ o~l (~~l
p, (4
.."..1. ,... M.r".r ofPrior,A!!l'eem."t.. Thi. Limited Li.blllty Comp.l!)' Agre.m.nt oontains tho .ole
, .', '" ",,,' cc' c. .Inl.(\ .cltiro .agTQoment:llIlQ'nndor.tending cfthe partie. with reapecllo the ertt!re subject matter
,., '."'" heroof. Any ond all plioI' dlsCl1S.iol1s, ltegotiatione, commitments, 8nd understllrlding.
rolating thereto "e.tleJ:l'by merged h.re!n. Thi. Limit.d Liability Company Agreemont cannot
be changed ortem1inated crally. .
2. Governln. Law. Thl. Limited Liabillty Company Agreement and the obligaticns ofthe
Membe.o hereunder ,h.ll be interpreted, con.trued, and enforced in eocordance with tbe laW!
oHM Stete of Florid.,
3. Wei"er. No CCll,enl or waiver, expre.. orimplied, b)' my Member to or of any breach or
default by another or the performanoe by llrlothor of his obligations hereunder 00.11 be
deemed or coltstrued to be a conaent or waiver to or of Ill1Y ether broaoh or default in
the perfulltlanco1>y such other party o!the Slll1t~ or any other obligation of ~ch
Member lwreunder.
4. Soverllbl1itv. If snyprovisiem ofthi. Limited LiebUity C01npllllY Agreement or the
lIppliclItion thereofto any psrson or circlun,tanea shall be invalid or unenforceable to any
.. . ...,'..".. ...., e.'Ctont,1hercmsindoT,oftlti, LitnitedLiabllity Compen)' Agreemcnt nnd theapplie.tion of
such provision' to other per.ons or circUlll611l!loes shall not be sff~cted thereby I\lId shall be
.:",~. J.;;..",. c;.. onfcirccd,t6;th.e,e1litent ,permitted by law.
., .....
""..~',,\"~""Il,"III"~1 ,."" '"''''',''''''' ..~" .,,~.'. ,
5, Blndin" A~reement, St\bjeot to the rostticti~ns on lran,f.ri and enoumbrances set forth
hereh\, this Limited Liability C9U1pmy Agreement .hall inure to the bl!lttefit of and be binding
upon tho Memben: and their re.pective heir,. executors, legel representative., succe.sers, and
assigns. Whenever, i.n this instrument, al'eferoneo to any porty or Member is made. Buoh
referenoe shall b. deemed te includ. a reference \0 the heirs, executors, legrJ representatives,
.uoeessors, and assigns ohuch Member.
G. No Riebls Creat.d in Third l'~n.n.. This Limited Liability Compsny Agreement is
intended solely fer tho Denefit of the pattLss nnd does ne1: ereolc any rights jn persells l1et
psrti.. heretc.
page 14
FILLMORE, LLC . Operating Agreement
R:( t. i me: 04/22/2008 23: 10
Rx No.:049 P.024
LlO/vlO"d 190# 9S:SZ 600l/ll/vO
6v9\7l986SZ
l~IO 3IXIO/~IIH811~ lHVA:wOJ3
~G 39\1d
ONI \l1~CI
8Lse-L6S-6E1:
Le:ee 6ee1:/E1:/~e
_HPI{-1'o-1'UUB THU lU: 4 ( AM ~I{IU IU :;ULUAV INI, UPA, PA
.rAX NU. 1'08 bBl c8Bl
p, 1'b
7. Counterpart, Execution, Thi~ l.imite Liability ComplID Agreement may be executed in
..one or. mer. couD~erp'lte, eaoh ofwhlc ,W~l executed a ui delivered, shall be an
.origin.l btlt.all o(wbich:together ~hall omutute one end 'Ie some agreement.
:IN W1TNESS WHEREOF, the Memb .s hay.e signed thie [,imitecl Lif'bility COmpany.
Agreement as of the dato first written above,
....--.-- ..-......-
Joh ; A, FilImol'e
WITNESS
WITNESS
Tor 9~ Fillmore
S;\CCL.IJ'~\I01 \He operalhllJ 'i1urflCI\\ 111'nlllroina m::mbcr,Wlld
peg. 15
"""l' u.c - "'_.......~
Rx time:04!22/2003 23:10
Rx No, :043 P .025
LlO/9l0'd 190# gs:Sl GOOl/ll/rO
SI: 39~d
Gr9rG98GSZ
IdlO 3IXIO/~~IHJln~ lH~A:wOJj
:JNJ ~M~
8Lse-L6S-6cl:
L0:ee 6001:/EI:/00
.1
RPK-cj-cUU~ THU 1 U: q I RM ~KIG W ~ULUAV INI, WR, PR
,AX NU, cj~ b~] cH~l
p, ctl
. .', ....I'....":....\.:....,!.I
''',,',,'' SCREDtlLE 1
In.itial Members lInd their inttial Membership Inter.osts " ,.. .
~ ._ ,. .'!; ,. . '.. l.,
Inltlol ContrllJution
Anticiunted Contribution
50 % InlatOSI
Jobn A. FilhllOre
~250 Wasl11:mrn Avenuo
Noples, Florid1\ 3411 ?
$
o
50 % !ntOl'"t
T.ros~ Fillmore
2250 Washburn Avenue
Nopl.., Florida 3411 7
$
o
page 16
FILlMORE, LLC . OperMing Agroemont
R~ time;04/22/2009 23:10
Rx No.:049 P.026
L00/9Z0"d ZSO# 9S:SZ 6000/001VO
6t79vZ9S6S0
l~IO 3IXI0I8NIH8ln~ lHVA:WOlj
so 39\1d
JNI \1MCI
8L!00-L6!O-6El
LB:00 600l/El/P0
RrK-~j-i'UUUHU.l~:.4( Alt ~KllilV oULUAVINI.~fA, ~A
__ -"0
rAX NU, i'3B ~~] ,~~l
r, i'1
SCHEDULE :z.
A~reed Upon Pre-V~nture Expen.e'
~ ~~.l' f'U~.L" ,.-.. 1,."" ",,' ",
page 17
FILLMORE. U.C - Operating Agreem.nt
Rx t ime:04/2212008 23: 10
Rx No. :049 P .027
LZOILZO"d Z90# 9S:SZ 600Z/ZZIvO
6v9vZ9SSSZ;
IdIO 3IX]O/~~IH8ln~ lH~A:WOJj
to 39~d
JNI ~M<I
8L90-L69-6Eo L0:00 6000/Eo/P0
APK-~6-~UU~ lHU 1U:4;1 AM ~KIUW oULUAVINI UPA,PA
,.__. ._"_. ._.. _.. ___ I
rAX NU, <;I~ b~l <~81
p, U,
...
ARTICLES OF ORGANIZATION
FOR
:FILLMORE, LLC
A LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
.o\RTICLE I
,
The Nama of Ul. Limited Liability Company i.:
FILLMORE, LLC
ARTICLE IT
The mailing addte'. and.treeteddr<;SB ofth. principal omce ofihe Limited Liability Company Is:
1250Walhburo Avenuo
Nuplea, FlorIda 3411 7
ARTICLE UI
;;!cn do
....~ ..,
r", ~.
~~ '"T1
~~ ". ~
i't\"" c:> \
me (11
. ." !$. 0
-n",
r-~ Q
"'.".
"'....
elm N
;p- c;::;>
Tho nnme ond the Florida street addre.. of Ill. registered agent are:
Teren FiIlmllre
2250 Wa~h1.lUrn Avenue
!'lapl.., Florida 34117
flavlng b.~n named Q$ rolJl.tered and 10 accept $.'1'Jco ofp..ocos.far the ().bove $Iated limited !labillt)' campa;
allha pIaa. designated in 1M. cartlficate. I hlJl-eoy accept rhe appointmellt as regi6t.,ed agent alld p.greo to a~
in IMs capacity. J furthlJr a_elo ccmpl~1 with Ih p cI'tsion.< of all statut"" relating 10 tile proper and ccmpj,
p.rformance oJmy dllll06, olldr amfamlliarwitl all accept rJr" Oblw:::-as regislerea age"
Dated: L\ \C\\t0.
.=~~.. .."
Slgnatur. of a member or nn lllltllorl?ed representative l
.. mambar: Tores. Fllhnore
(111 accordance with section 608.408(3), Florida Statutes, thl
el\.eoution oftllis document constillltos an affirm.tion under
tho penal nes of p'ljnry thet the faot. 5t.ted herein .re true.)
S:\C'CL\!5.:!OPI\!..J.C.U.'C.....'Pd
Rx tirne:04/22/Z008 23:05
R~ No. :048 P .002
LlO/ZOO'd Z90# Z8:8Z GOOZ/ZZ/rO
~B 38\1d
G1'9rZ98G8Z
IdlO 3IXIO/~NIH8lnN lHVA:wOJj
:lNI \11'1<1
8LgB-L6g-6E~
LB:BB 60B~/E~/.B
p, U:l
APK-"d-,UU~ THU 1U: qj AM ~Kltl W ~ULUAV IN I, cPA, PA
--- ---- -. -, _.
I,
(F.:lII~ucmi;2:lts Nlmtl)
(Addre")
(More.S)
(t;lty/StlitDl4lpJPt\Qne W)
o PICK.UP 0 WAIT
o MAIL
(Su5lnese en~ty Name)
(Do:lument Nurrll:j1i1f)
e.rtlfl.d CQple. _ .. Certill..te; of SIill\IHI--':'
Spool'lln'Wollen; 1>:> FllIn; Offl.."
!(!me
. .',II.bll'ty
" .-
.,,-- .
, DeC
~ -"':.'lTllnsr Ul:it'lOnly
, pr."-
fu-~ -
..
~ "iiiI'll , oeo
.....,.._. . -....
.. :,,~gl;:.'tlfJl"lt \jCC
,,-
\ 1,"', P. VerlfYar j.lt.,C
I- . .
\
Rx tlme;04/22120IJ3 23:06
LZO/SOO'd Z90# ZS:86 600Z/ZZ/VO
EG 39\1d
::JNI liMe!
rAX NU, C'j~ o~l C'~~l
;,.
13/~
~~\I\~\~\~l~~\~\~\~\\~ 1~11~\~~~~~ \ll
900015460859
04/10i03-n!Oi\'9~::-m4' 'H:!25.00
- <:>
",V> Co>
rm
r-f,':)
!.:iii: ~ :!J
r.~ "'"
..,)jl"
"" J ~"1 '" r-
111-": 111
r"""
. ''ll "". C1
;;:I,,, ""
i6~ ~
f5iTl N
". c::>
Rx No, :043 P .003
6\79\7Z98686
l~[a 3IX[OfJN[H8ln~ lHVA:wOj~
BL9G-L69-6Eo LG:GG 6GG"!Eo!~G
Attachment 0
Letter from Florida Division of
Historical Resources
!D ~ (q ~ JJ.W rn; ~
)(\ . U
u\ APR 2 1 2008
FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE
Kurt S. Browning
Secret.ry of State
DIVISION OF HISTORICAL RESOURCES
April 16, 2008
Mr. Dwight Nadeau
RW A Consulting
6610 Willow Park Drive, Suite 200
Naples, Florida 34109
Re: Proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Yahl Mulching Recycling Facility
Collier County / DHR Project File No. 2008-2169
Dear Mr. Nadeau:
According to this agency's responsibilities under Sections 163.3177 and 163.3178, Florida
Statutes, Chapter 9J-5, Florida Administrative Code, and any appropriate local ordinances, we
reviewed the proposed comprehensive plan amendment. Please note that this agency reviews
all large comprehensive plan amendments when they are submitted to us by the local
govenunent. At that point, our comments and concerns are submitted to the Department of
Conununity Affairs, and then transmitted to the local govenunent.
A review of the Florida Master Site File indicates that no significant archaeological or historical
sites are recorded for or considered likely to be present within the project area. Furthermore,
because of the project location and/ or nature, it is considered unlikely that historic properties
will be affected. Therefore, it is the opinion of this office that the proposed project wiII have no
effect on historic properties listed, or eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Plnces,
or otherwise of historical or archaeological value.
If you have any questions concerning our conunents, please do not hesitate to contact Susan
Harp ai (850) 245-6333. Thank you for your interest in protecting Florida's historic resources.
Sincerely,
~n' .Q ? G.JL
Frederick P. Gaske, Director
500 S. Bronough Street. Tallahassee, FL 32399-0250 . http://www.f1herilage.com
c:J Director's Office J:] Archaeological Research '" Historic Preservation 0 Historical Museums
(850) 245-6300' FAX: 245-6436 (850) 245-6444 . FAX: 245-6452 (850) 245-6333' FAX: 245-6437 (850) 245-6400' FAX: 245-6433
CJ South Regional Office 0 North Regional Office 0 Central Regional Office
(561) 416-2115' FAX: 416c2149 (850) 245-6445' FAX: 245-6435 (813) 272-3843' FAX: 272-2340
I
I
-~-\ 'IJ
i I \
L---i
I
---I
I I \
___L~_ I
J~
-----1-
SUBJECT
PROPERTY
I
\
'--.........-----.
"
\
~
L---'
o
13
~--
lJJ
D ..
J1IDl L --- ~~I
,- DEN GATE frf1 I
,GQL MERe, I CII~ I
\~~ UD !... A GATEfUD I
L "OLLl'R BLVD i. _I
MIXED USE eOMM I, ~,. ,I
~ ~ 1'- V-'<"ElAKE )",
~. . ....;;::sL, ---CciNDU:A':~~UD I
..1.S\17;.A~'J~~_(:
I L-J\_ . 1""'1 ~
;'16bsBLVI.' ~ g~.'lc~
., I ' ,( c~lw~
i., I , Q
iJ' ~I' " I
I <~s'lPORnl 'pUD 'I
COMMERCE \
i CEmNTER pue '.1 FO~EST I
!LJ ' I' GLENNQF I 1
i 1_ ^ "tiEs-pue, I
\ r/-Jj~ ',,- .
\ eE~~~ I 'I )~~)' I
T~~U~ .! ~~
.~ J
----'-J'ni
J__'I~---
,
I J
~~~
:rl~l~NAh
DRI(P) I
J
I
- iWtE~RITAG
~lF AND8ep~O T
CLU
Legend
C]SlJbjeel]rOl"'rty
- cllm~l_sln=~\_CIrt.inU
-M'.illr_Roa~!
CJ PUD_0607
',C';;';,':";;''',.,"
1,_A;......;. _.,~ ~
SAN
IMRINO
' PUD
I _
1r-r\J
NAPLES : I )
NATl GOLF 'r... f
CLUB pue 'l~_
I
R ".~ i1," TI\1'
DISCU.I~lE , f~r}'CllJf llerSGllll~~ m$)', m plrt, J'lQj
flC';. providu ~I~ d~~Ultillle Sllureu ~nc TIle .re.~
~::~,." :':',';:::~.. ~~~::.~'.~';;':;. "'i':':'~~::':~,"m..
becllrfcrIl. Ih" ma~arl'pprc nng.lll\d'~$. donlhilrmlp
dcpi=tellby ~POfellgIMtrmll;cneonlwlc
lc.curlllC IC III 'itilily lor tIlc tn II
nolegllrespcn
HOMES OF
ISLANOlA
PUD
:C-I
LA51P CONSV.
ARI"A PUD
9,000
, Feet
6.000
1,500
3,000
TK'
DlXT1NG
CONSUL,.L .L
.&.. ~J ~ \'i>U~1i~'iA M~n~
.I'IOIM'. -SIlM)'It{
.('i,a u.~.".trm~
o
,
N
A
I.ng Facility
. Recyc I t
Yahl MUlchmgplan Amendmen
ehenslve .
Compr lion ExhiM
General Loca
dBy:Vjpelle9l~
prep~reDale:ApriI7, 73.00.00
Printing . \200IMBOO d
File T:\PrcJ'c:ts GMPA Localionmx
Yahl Muldl1l'\s:l
Subject Property
- Collier County Major Roads
- Collier County Roads
RWA. Inc. provides thiS data for your personal use "asls" This
information is derived from multipe sources which may. in part, nof
be current, and be outside the amtol of RWA. Inc The areas
depicled by this map are approlomale, and are nolnecessarily
accurate to surveying or ef1gineering standards RWA, lnc, assumes
ooleg.al responsibility for lhe information contained on this map
o
,
200
400
800
1,200
,Feet
D'XTK'
CONSULTING
~....., ,........
.l'lanning.\lI._u.li'_'lit>n
.el\',1 f,,~,"ccrill~ .Su"'eyi"f & M"l'pi"~
Fillmore Recycling GMPA
Comprehensive Plan Amendment
Aerial Exhibit
N
A
Prepared By: vjpellegnno
Printing Dale April 16,2008
File T:\Projects\2008\0800730000,_Yahl_Mulch,ng
GMPAlAenal,mxd
- D"biREV1SEO'"SUBMnTAL \
l AUG ","00 l
lWC SE:RVICE CE:NTE.R
~~:c
N
W*E
s
~ ~i
i U
APPLICATION NUMBER
03 0 :1 0 7 w 5 "-
. "'.,
TOTA~ ACAll8 28.8
PROJECT: Y AHL MULCHING EXPANSION
WASHBURN AVE NAPLES FL
100 0
1"':"1..-
100 200 Feet
,
!'Iaura 4. FLUCfCSI Vegalallon Map, UPDATED 08.28.GB
Ramsey Inc.
!POnvlronment.. Consulting
BOl< 12M
Intmokal.....PL 34143
~39.564.16tiO
V.hl Mu1llhlnllll"oenelll.l1 Par98112~GO Washburn Av",
Sic~ 3-1 J TWn 1l$9, flge 27 J totaling approJUmately 28.1;5 LcreSll~
EXHIBIT 3.0
LLO/OSO'd vll# 89:00 LOOZ/tl/SO
8v9vZS8GSZ
l~la 3IXIOIDN1H811W l~V^:ruOJj
D'XZ^I.~C.
Planning
Visualization
{'()i'lSlJL"rli",jCl Civil Emrinccrine
...... '-., '..L ..a.. Surveying & :\Jh~pping
Education
Ul7in';!,~i!v Df
AriJ3i\a/ 5S./
i:;"9,Source M0r;d
'"./empfJasi.<; O{l
Urh/iI) Piry:.rin9
r'jiil:ur in
Anrnropn!Ggv:'
1984
Registration l
License
.::: Dj., -063982
Professional
Soc!fJties
/!O)t:"';Uf!! Fhnri.' lq
/\ss'_.:.r:;iaiiDf;
; !JH7 PJBS(,,',il
Fiorida Ci:'.S'lr{,:'<
Ar:!,!i";iiU-!lj Pia,'t{!i;19
As\se:u'SliO(!
7987 Pres'en:
D'.;"fi~~ht H. N?deau~ l'\.PJJ..,
?lElnnt'iG ,serv!c!-}s M,?nager
Experlenc!:j SurnH12ry
Mr. Dwight Nadeau is a professional Planner and Planning Services Manager. He is
responsible for coordination and management of resource allocations for planning tasks
associated with the firm's land planning and development projects Mr. Nadeau has over
20 years of planning and community service experience. He holds a Bachelor of Science
degree in Resource Management with emphasis on Urban Planning, and a minor in
Anthropology from the University of Alaska, Fairbanks.
Mr. Nadeau has significant experience in project planning and management: as well as,
comprehensive planning and land use regulation oversight. He has specific expertise in
the successful planning and zoning of monumental projects. Mr. Nadeau played a key role
in the planning and zoning, as well as professional support in the resulting legal battle over
the rural area residential development "clustering" of Twin Eagles Golf and Country Club.
After 12 years, the matter successfully culminated with the setting of a legal precedent for
'c1uslering' of residentiai developments in rural areas, and laid the foundation for the future
development of Eastern Collier County. In addition, Mr. Nadeau has vast experience with
beach front and waterfront redevelopment, which includes visioning, conceptual
development design, project team coordination, and public involvement through the
administrative review and political processes.
Represr::ntative Projec.ts
Olde Marco Inn; Marco Cat, LLC, Marco Island, FL - Project Planner responsible for site
analysis, master planning, and planned unit development rezoning. Established a local
historic designation, resulting in the refurbishment of this historic 1896 slructure, as well as
the addition of a 62-room boutique hotel. Facilitated an archeological survey that resulted
in an archeological dig that found significant tools and debris that further illustrated the day-
to-day life of the lost Caloosa Tribe.
Sancerre; EcoGroup, Naples, FL - Project Planner responsible for site analysis, master
planning, support and representation of a Coastal Construction Control Line Variance with
the Cily of Naples and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. Once home to
the historic Tides Inn, this 1.57 -acre beachfront property in Naples, Florida is now an eight-
slory, 23-unlt luxury condominium complex.
Vanderbilt Inn Re-Development; TimeMed, Inc., Naples, FL - Project Planner
responsible for redevelopment site analysis, master planning. approval of a zoning overlay
to provide for additional building height beyond exisiing zoning limits, support and
representation of a Coastal Construction Control Line Variance with Collier County and the
Florida Department of Protection. and played a significant support role in the resolution of a
building moratorium imposed as a result of the proposed redevelopment project for 4.83
acres of beachfront property. The site is now under construction with a 77-unit luxury
condominium project.
Attachment P
Resumes
D'XZAJNC.
Plunnin~
Visu<llii.~l1ion
(' () N S t.,.r L '1' IN (:; Civil Engineering
..a.. '-, '.L .JI... Surveying & VI:tpping
Dwiqhl H. Nadeau A.P.A
Pag€: 2
White Lake Corporate Park; 120-acre Industrial Park; Power Corporation; Naples, FL
- Project Planner responsible for research into additional commercial development
opportunities, with focus on the interface of land uses with the 1-75 right-of-way corridor.
Prepared and submitted the application to amend the existing planned unit development
document, prepared exhibits, attended board hearings, and provided expert testimony to
support the application.
Lake Marion Golf Resort, Phase I and 1/; 130-Acre 450-Unit Single and Multi-family
Residential Planned Development; Lake Marion Golf Resort, Ltd., Polk County, FL -
Project Planner responsible for due diligence, planning and development zoning. The
project lies within the 47,000 acre vested pre-DRI Poinciana Development, and required a
proposed land plan and PUD modification; construction and operation permit applications;
application for dredge and fill activities on federal wettands.
Sun City - Fort Myers; 1,200-Acre Mixed-Use Master Planned Community; WCI
Communities, Inc.; Fort Myers, FL - Project Planner responsible for land development
planning and zoning activities for the Trevisio and Rialto subdivisions of Sun City - Fort
Myers.
Hideout Golf Club; 220-Acre Master Planned Golf Community; WCI Communities,
Inc.; Fort Myers, FL - Project Planner responsible for the application, support and
acquisition of the Fishing Lake Conditional Use Permit.
White Lake Corporate Park, Phase 1/ (fka Phase IV); 2-Acre Commercial Out-Parcel
within 120-Acre Master Planned Industrial Park; Power Corporation; Naples, FL -
Project Planner responsible for land development planning, zoning and environmental
issues, including preliminary and final subdivision pletling, and permit application
preparation, support and acqUisition.
Summit Place (aka Hibiscus Village); 57-Acre, 230-Unit Residential Community;
Waterways Joint Venture IV; Naples, FL - Project Planner responsible for due diligence,
site planning, preliminary sub-division plat, zoning and permitting application, support and
acquisition; PUD zoning amendment application and support, miscellaneous rezoning
support, and environmental permitling.
Golden Gate Fire Station #73; 5-Acre Main Fire Station, Administrative Office and
Certified Fire Fighter Training Facility; Golden Gate Fire Control District; Naples, FL
- Project Planner responsible for planning and zoning review and site planning.
Tuscany Cove; 77-Acre, 316-Unit Residential Villa Community; A.R.M. Development
Corporation of S. W. Florida, Inc.; Naples, FL - Project Planner responsible for project
planning and zoning services, including due diligence; conceptual site plan, rezoning
application and support, public participation, PSP application and preparation of associated
exhibits for the acquisition of appropriate land planning, zoning and permitting application
approvals.
Palmero Cove; 131-Acre, 524-Unit Residential Villa Community; Elias Brothers
Corporation; Naples, FL - Project Planner responsible for project planning and zoning
services, including due diligence; conceptual site plan, rezoning application and support,
public participation, and preparation of associated exhibits for the acquisition of appropriate
land planning, zoning and permitting application approvals.
D'X~^'Nc.
Plallllinll
Visuali;';llion
C()NSl;I_'i'lf"~G Civil En~inccfing
..L. '" , .L .... Surveying & M:.ppil1g
Dwight 1..1. Nadeau, A.PA
Page :3
Golden Gate Fire Station #72; Existing 3-Acre Fire Station Site and Related
Infrastructure Improvements; Golden Gate Fire Control District; Naples, FL - Project
Planner responsible for the preliminary site plan, permitting application preparation and
support, and SFWMD ERP and ROW permit application and support.
White Lake Corporate Park Phase I; 120-Acre Industrial Park; Power Corporation;
Naples, FL - Project Planner responsible for due diligence, planning and zoning research,
PUD application preparation and support, including preparation of exhibiis, and board
hearing attendance.
Lake Marion Golf Resort - Phase 111; 130-Acre 450-Unit Planned Residential
Development; Lake Marion Golf Resort, Ltd.; Polk County, FL - Project Planner
responsible zoning application and support; PUD application and support; traffic impact
statement; Polk County protected species survey; environmental impact statement; site
planning; evaluation of existing wetland jurisdictional limits. and submittal to SFWMD and
COE for jurisdictional determinations.
Collier County Fleet Facility; Collier County Government, Naples, FL - Project Planner
responsible for project planning and zoning services, inCluding due diligence; conceptual
site plan, rezoning application and support, public participation, and preparation of
associated exhibits for the acquisition of appropriate land planning, zoning and permitting
application approvals.
Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations
ENVIRONMENT AL CONSULTING
Ramsey Inc.
.m.::.._____.._,.__~'~
....---
LEP, CWE, CFEA, REPA, CEHP
.
LEP - Licensed Environmental ProfessiOllaJ
CWB - Certified Wildlife Biologist
CFEA - Certified Florida Environmental Assessor
REPA . Registered Environmental ProperlY Assessor
CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional
OSHA 5 - Hazardo~l.s Materials Incident Commander
Cedficd F:orida Commercial Pesticide Applicator CMI9542 - Natural Areas
E-mail: Ramscy.lnc@embarqmajl.com
Office: 239.564.1660, Fax: 866.334.1496
2631 4lh SL. NW, Naples, FL 34120
www.ramscvinC.ncl
MICHAEL R. RAMSEY
President, Ramsey Inc. Environmental Consulting
Date: 10 March 2009
WORK EXPERIENCE
Ramsey Inc., Environmental Consulting Naples. Florida 1997 to Present
President
Provide ecological, environmental, permitting and land management consulting services for single family
home owners, subdivision!\, real estate, investors, agricultural, comme.rcial, industrial, engineeling firms,
financial and governmental institutIons. Landowner consulting for land feasibility evaluations, protected
species, state and federal jurisdictional wetlands, wetland mitigation specialist, wetland restoration,
permittmg. phase I audits, timber/wildlife land management, prescribed buming, statewide alligator
programs, site plan development, agricultural propel1Y tax management, hazardous materiaJs management,
exotics plant management, guided hunting operations.
Mitigation bank / ROM A creation and management planning for: wetland creation, panther habitat units,
native & exotic plants, listed species, monitoling, outside agency integration wilh watershed planning and
floodplain management
Collier Enterprises ImmokaJee, FJOJida 1987 to 1997
Environmental Mgr/Natural Resources Mgr/Land leasing/Property Taxes
Responsibilities include: environmental/safety policy development and implementation; environmental
audits; citrus, fanning, cattle grazing and recreation leasing; land use planning for agricultural operations;
permitting of projects; habitat and wildlife monitoring; wetland delineation: natural resources management,
prescribed burning; and agricultural property tax management
Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission Naples. Florida 1984-1987
Biologist
Responsibilities included: game, non-game and endangered species population assessments; habitat
monitoring/GIS mapping; check station management during hunt seasons, aerial/ground game & non-game
surveys, reviewed proposed development plans for environmental impact assessments; prescribed burning;
endangered species research, panther field trapping and data collection, deer herd health assessments data
collection, joint management projects with the National Park Service, exotic plant control, campground
development and reforestation. Primary responsibilities \~Iere on the Big Cypress National Preserve, but
worked all over FWC areas in south Florida.
Attachment P
Resumes
MICHAEL R RAMSEY
Page 2
Georgia Department of Natural Resources,
Game and Fish Division, Fisheries Section Social Circle, Georgia 1983-1984
Wi/dltfe Technician
Assisted with research of heavy metal contamination of trout in the trout-swcking program.
Georgia Department of Natural Resources,
Garne and Fish Division, Fisheries Section Social Circle, Georgia 1982
Wildlife Technician
Bald cagle and Red-Cockaded Woodpecker restoration projects on Sapelo and 51. Catherine's Islands
EDUCATION
Bachelors of Science, Forestry and Wildlife Biology - 1982
University of Georgia, School of Forest Resources - Athens, Georgia
CERTIFICATIONS
Certified Wildlife Biologist Registered Environmental Property Assessor #452
Certified Florida Environmental Assessor #237 Licensed Environmental Professional #127
Celtified Environmental Health Professional #06-1645 OSHA Level 5 Incident Commander
Certifted Florida Commercial Pesticide Applicator eM] 9542 - Natural Areas
Reed K. Jarvi
Principal
Mr. Jarvi has over 24 years of project management and infra-
structure design and pennitting for a broad range of complex
residential, commercial, and institutional projects in Southwest
Florida. He has special emphasis, training and experience in
transportation engineering, transportation planning and traffic
engineenng.
Representative Projects:
Mercato Mixed Use, Collier County, FL *
Traffic Impact Statement, Access Study, County and FDOT
permitting for 390,000 sf retail, 100,000 sf office and 175 resi-
dential du's.
The Great Loop, Charlotte County, FL *
DRI Traffic Impact Study for 1,200,000 sf retail, 100,000 ot'
flee, 200 room hotel and 500 residential du's.
Su",mit Lakes, Collier County, FL*
Zoning Traffic Impact Statement for 968 residential du's.
Naples Daily News, Collier County, FL*
Traffic Impact Statement for both zoning and site development
plan for 164,000 sf manufacturing/office/production facility.
Caloosa Lakes. Lee County, FL*
Traffic and Access studies for 17 acre shopping center and 600
residential du's.
Vanderbilt Drive, Collier County, FL *
Pennitting, design and construction observation for a four lane
collector road overpass.
Treefarm Road Area Wide, Collier County, FL *
Area-wide traffic study for eight separate development projects
showing the value of a proposed collector road system in com-
parison to the status quo arterial system.
Sanibel Beach Place, Lee County, FL *
Traffic and Access studies along with ERP permitting for
110,000 sf shopping center.
* indicates work al {l prel'iollsfirm
Omega
Consulting Group
EDUCATION:
Bachelor of Science in Engineering
United States Naval Academy
REGISTRATIONS:
Professional Engineer
Florida #40156
AFFiliATIONS:
Institute of Transportation Engineers
Florida ITE
Southwest Florida ITE
BOARDS AND COMMITTEES:
Collier County Development Services Advisory
Committee and Land Development Regulation Sub.
Committee
SPECIAL RECOGNITION:
US Naval Reserve, Retired 1998-Commander
Attachment P
Resumes
SUMMARY OF BENEFITS FROM
CONSTRUCTION DEMOLITION DEBRIS RECYCLING
RESPONDING TO HOUSE BILL 697
Construction and Demolition Debris Recycling (C & D) provides both environmental and
economical benefits.
The environmental benefits are measured by the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions
by recycling the C & D debris instead of dumping those same materials into a C & D
LandfilL C & D materials like wood and cardboard breakdown into methane, a
greenhouse gas that is 23 times more potent than carbon dioxide. This reduction of
methane gas in the landfills reduces the emission of these gasses into the atmosphere
which contribute to global warming. When C & D debris such as wood, cardboard, metal
and concrete are reused or recycled to make new products, less energy is required to
make these new products compared to making these products from raw materials which
would need to be extracted from the earth. This extraction process burns fossil fuels
which is one of the main causes of global warming. The reduction of C & D debris into
the landfills and diverting it to a recycling facility will also extend the life of the landfill
due to the reduction of the materials placed within it each year which means less land
area needed per year for landfills. With the environmental concerns and lack of large
parcels for landfills available in Collier County, this is a significant benefit.
An example of this greenhouse gas emission reduction is in the analysis of the
construction of a 2,000 square foot home. A typical 2,000 square foot home produces 8.5
pounds per square foot of waste or 17,000 pounds of waste. The breakdown of the
materials is as follows: Wood (42%), Gypsum (13%), Concrete (15%), Cardboard (6%),
Metals (3%) and Other materials (21 %). By recycling 95% of the wood, cardboard,
concrete and metal debris keeps 6.4 tons of waste out of the landfilL The avoided
methane emissions and reduced energy consumption from recycling C & D materials
from this single home is equivalent to taking 1 car off the road for a year or avoiding 5.7
metric tons of CO2 emissions. Since commercial buildings are typically larger than
residential buildings, recycling of the C & D debris from these types of buildings is even
a greater benefit to the environment.
The economic benefits come from several areas. One of the economic benefits is the
reduction of the disposal fees at C & D landfills compared to C & D recycling centers.
The tipping fees for disposal at a landfill nm up to 70% higher than the tipping fees at the
recycle centers. An example is a load of wood from a building demolition that is taken to
the C & D landfill would cost $34 per ton. The same load taken to the recycle facility
would cost $20 per ton. This is a significant savings in disposal fees. The recycled
material could then be hauled to end users who need the wood to fire boilers in their
facilities.
Another significant savings is the use for the recycled materials. Recycled Asphalt
shingles can be processed and used as a 5% by product in hot asphalt mix with a savings
of $1 to $2.80 per ton of mix. Recycled concrete can be utilized as structural fill and
Attachment P
Summary of Benefits from Construction
Demolition Debris Recycling Responding
to House Bill 697
aggregate in Portland cement, with a 100% recyclable rate. The cost to grind concrete
spans a range from $5 to $9 per ton. The cost to dispose of the material along with the
need to extract raw material from the earth to be used in place of the recycled material
could range from $10 to $20 per ton. The other factor in this case is the availability of
the raw materials and the distance traveled in order to obtain it. In Collier County, this
material is getting scarcer with each year. Local C & D recycling would fill a gap much
needed in this area for both disposal and recycling.
The benefits of C & D recycling had continued to grow over the past 20 years as the
technology develops for new uses of the recycled products and the availability of disposal
lands for landfills become scarcer. All indicators point towards recycling versus disposal
for both economic and more importantly environmental reasons.
The information summarized in this report was obtained from internet research from the following web addresses:
I1Jm2/_~~\Y_\~J:_i__\\_nJ.h,~_:,;,s\).YLcJ:l!ldGn1tL California Integrated Waste Management Board
bJln:i."w\Y\\~__\~!l(1.!.'IClltl~~.).rk.sOI1J;'_~QlU;_n~teid(;m)1 iliD.nirill~~:UJ1g C(1ilCr<,;t~,bt_n Concrete Network.com
iJ.!.m,:,:,'i,\~:,:,~:_\~:,.~:_~\Lt:_;';_Yi;.i.<;Lc(:_l\m Construction and Demolition Recycl iog
http://www.shinglerecyc1ing.orgl Shingle Recycling.org
-. -'.. '11'~,~
AM'-DD
m
ADACoorOtnJ1tCIll
;\gt:nt!"CoordinOlUnll
..v.lm.,I.o;"'Vl,'M
Ar1 in Public f'lar,-."
AulJU "",I Mafl>lC<'''''f'f,1 S",ylrH
.........11..'"
Bull(~nM
llull,Jln~ Code- CQmpll~fl(c
e,lOinO!S.(}e,."t')Olm-.enl
(""""'''''-''""'IlICIIQn C'x>rdfn~U"'n
~hld4-Pffid~1 Ir.an5pOl'10Illon Irllsl
'Ir""~on on nhlr~ ~nd f'ubtlr IfUll
Cor"nJ...rll~olU<ln5
Community "'''linn Agt'l'l\ y
m""rl~'''' ~f.(>"')''''cDe.....I<Jlln...nt
0J.mmunityMel:\lio...
r:on,urnerS..n,c:es
CU'ft'uiom&Rl'r...b,lil.ahnn
CULlnlt""d('Hf'lhh,-,'''''Pbnrnng
Cultur.tINfalB
flNno.,.
I mtrgmcy MalI3gt."',,"ml
fllllJ!~""llPb~onl
fn'p"""('fRll"nl ""~l
Inl(,O'r><lw Tpd",("og)' !'1!f\1c<"
olllrlenl~l J<<.,Ol)fU'. MoInall<,nlC'1l1
1~lrflflplo~mPl'lI PractIces
111'l"nc~
fl,,,, R.""I U/;'
(;....,""...S~Y1Cl..,l\dmlnlll'.allon
Hl.lork 1"""'......lHnn
H.:>mf'lcs~ ['u.'
~1'JlJAnI:^grn<y
II0u'l,,!: flnal><:41'\ulh'llil~
I IUfnJnSnYlCf'f
Indefl'!"dMlltr'~i"wf':llll'1
Inll"""tl"'ulh"diPCIII",,nl,unl
JU'e<ljleA$K'Ssmeflll:cnIM
Mrolr..olh~n1h'f.
elro:opr.lll;tnf'lanrwngO'g.H'i7alio"
f',.,Ia."dll<<r~llon
P1anning:tndlontng
I'Ollle....
f'roCU<<''lYlN"Matlilll(:Il'lt'nl
Pn}pP.ftr"PP'~'St.
rubl;~ IlbrOlf)' !lysl"n,
P"blkW,..k$
S..feN.,;ghbo,hr...d P~lk1.
!OKlp'_""
SoIfdW~~le Milnagcmt'nl
SI,~I(l'c8u..n,,'"M~na~n"'''1
T"arnMf:lro
IralUll
l)rhanRe\lbllll""" r...k For<:e
vllcaya Mu""um..nd G..rdcm
Park and Recreation
275 NW 2nd Street
MiOlmi, Flori(la 31120
r 305-755-7800
March 30, 2009
miamidade.gov
David Weeks, AICP, Planning Manager
Collier County Government
Community Development & Environmental Services Division (CDES)
Comprehensive Planning Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
RE: Dade-Collier Cypress Recreatiol1 Area
Dear Mr. Weeks;
Please find attached an application to amend Collier County Growth
Management Plan to permit the creation of the Dade-Collier Cypress
Recreation Area. Through a partnership involving State, County and Federal
il1terests, we submit this application for review and approval. It is our hope
that the product of this application is a recreational area capable of improvil1g
natural resource values, providing compatible outdoor recreationai use and
improving stewardship practices on lands now subject to uncertain
management.
Pursuant to the application, James McCall, Park Planl1er, is listed as our
agent. You are asked to communicate all correspondence through Mr.
McCall and he will facilitate its resolution with our consultants at Milian,
Swain Associates and Miller-Legg.
Should Collier County staff need additional information from this office,
please feel free to call me at 305-755-7903.
Attachments
Cc:
W. Howard Gregg, Deputy Director
Gregg Owens, Aviation
Kevin Asher, MDPRD
James "Andy' McCall, MDPRD
Julio Menache. Milian, Swain
Jill Cohen, Milll:r-L.egg
" "t';'.'
MILLER~EGG
July 10, 2009
Mr. Thomas Greenwood, AICP
Principal Planner
Collier County Comprehensive Planning Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
RE: Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Petition CP-2009-1
HB 697
Dear Tom:
In response to the recently enacted House Bill 697 regarding Energy Conservation and
Efficiency and specifically, Greenhouse Gas Emissions (GHG), we offer the following for
consideration with regards to Petition Number CP-2009-1, Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation
Area Comprehensive Plan Amendment:
Regarding GHG emissions, vehicles typically contribute less than buildings, however, vehicle
emissions will contribute some to the community's overall GHG emissions. Due to the site's
location and the small number of annual visitors, the application will have a small impact on the
creation of GHG's, due in large part to the number of vehicle miles that area visitors will have to
travel to the site.
Miami-Dade County, however, is satisfied that this impact will largely be offset by the number of
lives that are saved and the reduction of personal injuries that are averted because this
Recreation Area will be open to visitors of more dense areas who would otherwise use an
unsafe and illegal location. Additionally, the uses proposed in this park are for leisure and will
therefore not have a daily impact which will also offset the impacts of GHG's.
Sincerely,
JC/rd
Cc: Kevin Asher, MDPR
Al1dy McCall, MDPR
Julio Menache, Milian, Swain & Associates, Inc.
V:\Projects\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\July 2009 resubmittal\Final Submittal\H8697
letter.doc.docx
IMP R 0 V I N G COM M U NIT I E S. eRE A TIN G E N V I RON MEN T S,
South Florida Office: 1800 N Douglas Road' Suite 200 . Pembroke Pines. Florida' 33024-3200
(954) 436-7000. Fax: (954) 436-8664
www.millerlegg.com
GMP A APPLICATION FOR DADE-
COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION
AREA
APPLICATION FOR A REQUEST TO AMEND
THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN
FOR THE DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA DISTRICT
PETITION NUMBER DATE RECEIVED
PRE-APPLICATION CONFERENCE DATE
DATE SUFFICIENT
PLANNER ASSIGNED:
COMMISSION DISTRICT:
[ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF]
This application, with all required supplemental data and information, must be completed and
accompanied by the appropriate fee, and returned to the Comprehensive Planning Section, 2800
North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida 34104. Phone: (239) 252-2400; Fax: (239) 252-2946.
The application must be reviewed by staff for sufficiency within 30 calendar days following the filing
deadline before it will be processed and advertised for public hearing. The applicant will be notified,
in writing, of the sufficiency determination. If insufficient. the applicant will have 30 days to remedy the
deficiencies. For additional information on the processing of the application, see Resolution 97-431
(attached). If you have any questions, please contact the Comprehensive Planning Section at 239-
252-2400.
SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS
I. GENERAL INFORMATION
A. Name of Applicant Miami-Dade Countv
Company Park and Recreation Deoartment
Mailing Address 275 NW 2lli1 Street. 4!b Floor
City Miami
State Florida
Zip Code 33157
E-Mail iamccal@miamidade.aov
Phone Number 305-775-7993
B. Name of Agent James A. (Andvl McCall
. THIS WILL BE THE PERSON CONTACTED FOR ALL BUSINESS RELATED TO THE PETITION.
Company/Firm Miami-Dade Countv Park and Recreation
Mailing Address 275 NW 2nd Street. 4!b Floor
City Miami State FL Zip Code 33128
Phone Number 305-775-7993 E-Mail iamccal@miamidade.aov
C. Name of Owner (s) of Record Miami-Dade Countv
Address 111 NW 1;! Street. 29!b Floor
City Miami State Florida Zip Code 33128
Phone Number 305-755-7903 Fax Number
D. Name. Address and Qualifications of additional planners, architects. engineers,
environmental consultants and other professionals providing information contained
in this application. See Appendix I.D.1 Team Qualification Additional Information.
Jill Cohen, AICP, RLA, LEED AP, Miller Legg. 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200. Pembroke Pines. FL
33024.
Matt Boerger, Planner, Miller Legg. 1800 N Douglas Road. Suite 200. Pembroke Pines, FL 33024.
Mark Clark, CEP. Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke Pines, FL 33024.
Paul Mann, C.A. Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke Pines, FL 33024.
Eric Czerniejewski, P.E., Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road. Suite 200, Pembroke Pines, FL 33024.
Jimmy Wright, E.I., LEED AP, Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke Pines, FL
33024.
Julio Menache, Director of Operations. Million. Swain & Associates, Inc.. 2025 SW 32cd Avenue.
Miami. FL 33145
Arsenio Millan, P.E., President, Million, Swain & Associates. Inc., 2025 SW 32cd Avenue, Miami, FL
33145
II. Disclosure of Inferesf Informafion:
A. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety. tenancy in
common, or joint tenancy. list all parties with an ownership interest as well as the percentage
of such interest. (Use additional sheets if necessary).
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
B. If the property is owned by a LOCAL GOVERNMENT. list the officers and stockholders and the
percentage of stock owned by each. and provide one copy of the Articles of Incorporation,
or other documentation, to verify the signer of this petition has the authority to do so.
Name and Address
Percentage of Stock
Miami-Dade Countv
Mavor Carlos Alvarez
111 NW Il!Street 29!b Floor
Miami. Florida 33128
305-755-7903
100%
_(hiahest elected offlcialJ
C. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the
percentage of interest.
Name and Address
Percentage of Interest
2
D. If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the
general and/or limited partners.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
E. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a Corporation, Trustee,
or a Partnership, list the names of the contact purchasers below, including the officers,
stockholders. beneficiaries, or partners, and provide one copy of the executed contract.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
F. If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all individuals or
officers, if a corporation, partnership, or trust.
Name and Address
N/A
G. Date subject property acquired (X) 1968 leased (): Term of lease_yrs./mos.
If. Petitioner has option to buy, indicate date of option: and date
option terminates: , or anticipated closing:
H. NOTE: Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur
subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, it is the
responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf. to submit a supplemental disclosure of
interest form.
III. DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY:
A. LEGAL DESCRIPTION See Appendix IliA
B. Section{s): 13.14.15.16 Township: 53 South
C. Tax 10 Number (Folio #): 01233520000
D. General Location: Mile Marker 48. Tamiami Trail
E, Planning Community: Bia Cvpress F. TAZ: 347
3
Range; 34 East
G. Size in Acres: Approx. 1.608
H. Zoning CON-ACSClST. Conservation District within Area
of Critical State Concern/Special Treatment Overlay
I. Present Future land Use Map Designation(s) Conservation and Area of Critical State Concern
Overlay
IV. TYPE OF REQUEST:
A. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN ELEMENT (S) TO BE AMENDED:
X Future land Use
Immokalee Area Master Plan
Transportation
Coastal & Conservation
Intergovernmental Coord.
Sanitary Sewer
Drainage
Golden Gate Area Master Plan
Capital Improvement
Housing
Recreation & Open Space
Potable Water
Solid Waste
Natural Groundwater Aquifer
B. Amend PagerS) 12.87 and 124 of the Future land Use Element
As Follows: (Use Crms thro'~ghs to identify language to be deleted; Use Underline to
identify language to be added). Attach additional pages if necessary;
See Below
Page 12
Policy 1 .4:
A.
The CONSERVATION Future land Use Designation shall include a Future land Use District.
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA DISTRICT
Page 87
A. Dade-Collier Cvoress Recreation Area District
The Dade-Collier Cvpress Recreation Area District encompasses approximatelY 1.608 acres of
land located within Sections 13. 14. 15. and 16 of Township 53 South. Ranae 34 East. adioinina the
Miami-Dade/Collier County line north of U.S. Hiahway 41 and south of the runway of the Dade-
Collier Transition and Trainina Airport. and within the Bia Cvpress Area of Critical State Concern
(ACSCI. All lands within this District ore entirelv owned bv Miami-Dade County and includes
wetlands. cypress and hardwood forests. and five man-made lakes.
The primarv purpose of this District is to enhance the existina natural resources while providina for
an appropriate level of recreational uses beneficial to the county and the reaion.
The uses allowed within this District. with limitations specific to this District. are as follows;
a. Visitors' center buildina - for administrative offices. orientation area. meetina room. and
restrooms - not to exceed 2.400 sauare feet:
b. Parkina lot limited to a capacity of 80 passenaer vehicles and associated trailers;
c. Primitive Campina;
d. Recreational vehicle campina:
e. Fishina piers and docks:
f. Multi-use trails for pedestrians and bicycles:
g. Wildlife viewina platforms and overlooks:
h. Archerv ranae;
i. Off hiahwav vehicles IOHVI trails; and
j. Other uses as allowed in the Conservation Desianation.
Development within this District. except for trails. may be concentrated on already disturbed area
alona the western portions of the site. primarilY in Section 16.
4
The drainaae and storm water manaaement systems for this District may be desianed to be
comoatible with environmental site assessments. develooment and mitiaation strateaies.
environmental enhancements and reaulatorv reauirements. Site develooment may
restore/realian existina trails oreviouslv created bv swamo buaaies that traverse the site orimarilv
in an east/west direction. Lake edaes may be imoroved with a shallow littoral zone where
determined aoorooriate.
At the time of rezonina. an adaotive comorehensive manaaement olan shall be orovided that
includes:
1. OHV uses as defined in F.S. 261.03 and 261.20 for ooeration of OHVs on oublic land. These
soecifications may address vehicle and tire size. noise control. orohibition of certain OHV
tvoes le.a. tracked vehiclesJ. orohibition of devices affixed to tires le.a. tire chainsJ.
2. An OHV insoection oroaram and vehicle reaistration oroaram.
3. Provisions to demarcate site boundaries.
4. Definitive location of all orooosed uses - camosites. oarkina areas. archery ranae. OHV
trails and trail access ooints. oedestrian and bicvcle trails, etc.
5. Develooment intensity limitations - maximum number of RV and orimitive camoina sites.
coo on number of OHV users dailv. etc.
6. Monitorina orovisions to ensure OHV comoliance.
7. Enforcement oroaram for comoliance with all site/oark restrictions and limitations.
8. Soeciflcation of oeriods of ooeration. esoeciallv for OHVs - dailv hours of ooeration. oeriods
of closure le.a. hiah water. fire threat. hurricane threatJ. seasonal restrictions or closure.
9. Monitorina for detrimental imoacts uoon listed soecies.
10. Restoration alan for oresentlv disturbed oortions of the site not to be utilized le.a. most of
the existina OHV trailsJ. and creation of littoral zones for all lakes where determined
aoorooriate.
11. Demonstration of comoliance with the ACSC limitations le.a. maximum site alteration of
WQ1
12. Deviation to reauest disturbance to areas Imoacted bv develooment in the ACSC where
unavoidable uo to a maximum of 10% of the subiect site area.
Page 124 - Additional Map to be added:
Future Land Use Map
Mixed Use & Interchange Activity Center Maps
Properties Consistent by Policy (5.9, 5.10,5.11, 5.12.5.13.5.14,5.15) Maps
Collier County Wetlands Map
Collier County Wellhead Protection Areas and Proposed Welifields and ASRs Map
Rivers and Floodplains Map
Estuarine Bays Map
Soils Map
Existing Commercial Mineral Extraction Sites Map
Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Redevelopment Overlay Map
Stewardship Overlay Map
Rural Lands Study Area Natural Resource Index Maps
North Belle Meade Overlay Map
Existing Public Educationol Plants (Schools) and Ancillary Plants (Support Facilities) Map
Existing Sites for Future Public Educational Plants and Ancillary Plants
Plantation Island Urban Area Map
Copeland Urban Area Map
Railhead Scrub Preserve - Conservation Designation Map
Lely Mitigation Park - Conservation Designation Map
Urban - Rural Fringe Transition Zone Overlay Map
Orange Blossom Mixed Use Subdistrict Map
Vanderbilt Beach/Collier Boulevard Commercial Subdistrict Map
Davis Boulevard/County Barn Road Mixed Use Subdistrict Map
5
Goodlette/Pine Ridge Commerciollnfill Subdistrict Mop
Henderson Creek Mixed~Use Subdistrict Map
Buckley Mixed~Use Subdistrict Map
Livingston/Pine Ridge Commerciallnfill Subdistrict Map
Vanderbilt Beach Road Neighborhood Commercial Subdistrict Map
Livingston Road/Eatonwood Lane Commerciallnfill Subdistrict Map
Livingston Road Commerciallnfill Subdistrict Map
Dade~Collier Cvpress Recreation Area District Map
C. Amend Future Land Use Map(s) designation,
FROM Conservation Desianation
District
TO Conservation Desianation. Dade~Collier Cvpress Recreation Area District
District
[If new District and/or Sub~district proposed, include Future Land Use Map with legend
depicting it]
D. Amend other Map(s) and Exhibits as follows: (Name & Page #)
I. Future Land Use (Countv~widel Map: See Appendix IV.D.l
2. Inset Map (for the Districtl: See Appendix IV.D.2
E. Describe additional changes requested: N/A
V, REQUIRED INFORMATION:
Note: All Aerials must be at a scale of no smaller than 1" = 400'.
x 11 shall be provided of all aerials and/or maps.
A. LAND USE
l. See Appendix V.A.I
At least one copy reduced to 8 V.
Provide general location map showing surrounding
developments (PUD. DRI's, existing zoning) with subject property
outlined.
2. See Appendix V.A.2
Provide most recent aerial of site showing subject boundaries.
source, and date.
Provide a map and summary table of existing land use and
zoning within a radius of 500 feet from boundaries of subject
property.
3. See Appendix V.A.3
B. FUTURE LAND USE AND DESIGNATION
I. See Appendix V.B.] Provide map of existing Future Land Use Designation(s) of
subject property and adjacent lands, with acreage totals for
each land use designation on the subject property.
C. ENVIRONMENTAL
I. See Appendix V.C.I
Provide most recent aerial and summary table of acreage of native
habitats and soils occurring on site. HABITAT IDENTIFICATION MUST BE
CONSISTENT WITH THE FDOT~FLORIDA LAND USE, COVER AND FORMS
CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM (FLUCCS CODE). NOTE: THIS MAY BE INDICATED
ON SAME AERIAL AS THE LAND USE AERIAL IN "A" ABOVE.
6
2a. See Appendix V.C.2a Provide a summary table of Federal (US Fish & Wildlife Service) and
(Florida Game & Freshwater Fish Commission) listed plant and animal
species known to occur on the site and/or known to inhabit biological
2b.See Appendix V.C.2b communities similar to the site (e.g. panther or black bear range, avian
rookery, bird migratory route, etc.).
3a. See Appendix V.C.3a Identify historic and/or archaeological sites on the subject property.
Provide a copy of County's Historical/Archeological Probability Map
3b. See Appendix V.C.3b Correspondence from Florida Department of State.
D. GROWTH MANAGEMENT
Reference 9J-11.006, F.A.C. and Collier County's Capital Improvements Element
Policy 1.1.2 (Copies allached).
INSERT "Y" FOR YES OR "N" FOR NO IN RESPONSE TO THE FOLLOWING:
1 . Y Is the proposed amendment located in an Area of Critical State
Concern? (Reference 9J-l1.006(1) (a) (5), FAC.). IF so, identify area
located in ACSC. See ADDendix V.D.1
2. N Is the proposed amendment directly related to a proposed
Development of Regional Impact pursuant to Chapter 380 F.S. ?
(Reference 9J-l1.006(1)(a)7.a. FAC.)
3. N Is the proposed amendment directly related to a proposed Small Scale
Development Activity pursuant to Subsection 163.3187 (l)(c), F.S.?
(Reference 9J-l1.006(1 )(a)7.b, FAC.)
4. N Does the proposed amendment create a significant impact in population
which is defined as a potential increase in County-wide population by more than
5% of population projections? (Reference Capital Improvement Element Policy
1.1.2). If yes, indicate mitigation measures being proposed in conjunction with the
proposed amendment.
5a. ---1....- Does the proposed land use cause an increase in density and/or intensity
to the uses permitted in a specific land use designation and district
identified (commercial. industrial, etc.) or is the proposed land use a
new land use designation or district? (Reference Rule 9J-5.006(5) F.A.C.).
See ADDendix V.D.5b
5b. ---1....- If so, provide data and analysis to support the suitability of land for the
proposed use. and of environmentally sensitive land, ground water and
natural resources. (Reference Rule 9J-ll.007, FAC.) See ADDendix V.D,5b. and
V.D.5b.1throuah V.D.5b.15.
E, PUBLIC FACILITIES
1. See Appendices below Provide the existing Level of Service Standard (LOS) and document
the impact the proposed change will have on the following public
facilities;
la)See Appendix V.E.la Potable Water
1 b) See Appendix V.E.l b Sanitary Sewer
1 c) See Appendix V.E.l c Arterial & Collector Roads: Name specific road and LOS
1 d) See Appendix V.E.l d Drainage
1 e) See Appendix V.E.l e Solid Waste
1 f) Nt A Parks: Community and Regional*
* 2.9412 acres of regional park land/l,OOO population. Proposed amendment will increase the
capacity for the County, the Region and the State.
If the proposed amendment involves an increase in residential density, or an
7
increase in intensity for commercial and/or industrial development that would
cause the LOS for public facilities to fall below the adopted LOS. indicate mitigation
measures being proposed in conjunction with the proposed amendment.
[Reference Capitai Improvement Element Objective 1 and Policies)
2. See Appendix V.E.2 Provide a map showing the location of existing services and public
facilities that will serve the subject property (i.e. water, sewer, fire
protection. police protection, schools and emergency medical services.
3. See Appendix V.E.3 Document proposed services and public facilities, identify provider, and
describe the effect the proposed change will have on schools, fire
protection and emergency medical services.
F. OTHER
Identify the tollowing areas relating to the subject property:
1. See Appendix V,F.l Flood zone based on Flood Insurance Rate Map data [FIRM).
2. See Appendix V.F.2a and Appendix V.F.2b Location of wellfields and cones of influence,
if applicable. (Identified on Collier County Zoning Maps)
3. N/A Traffic Congestion Boundary, if applicable
4. N/A Coastal Management Boundary, if applicable
5. N/A High Noise Contours [65 LDN or higher) surrounding the Naples Airport. if
applicable (identified on Collier County Zoning Maps).
G. SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION
1. Attached $16,700.00 non-refundable filing fee made payable to the Board of County
Commissioners due at time of submittal.
2. N/A $9,000.00 non-refundable filing fee for a Small Scale Amendment made
payable to the Board of County Commissioners, due at time of submittal.
3. TBD Plus Legal Advertisement Costs [Your portion determined by number of petitions
and divided accordingly)
4. See Appendix V.G.4 Proof of ownership [copy of deed)
5. Attached Notarized Letter of Authorization if Agent is not the Owner (See attached form)
6. Attached 1 Original and 5 complete, signed applications with all attachments including
maps. at time of submittal. After sufficiency is completed, 15 copies of the
complete application will be required. Additional copies may be required.
* Maps. aerials, sketches shall include: North arrow, name and location of principal roadways: shall be
at a scale of 1 "=400' or at a scale as determined during the pre-application meeting; identification
of the subject site: legend or key, if applicable. All oversized documents and attachments must be
folded so as to fit into a legal-size folder. For all oversized exhibits, at least one copy must be
submitted at 8-1/2 x 11 inches. All exhibits and attachments to the petition must include a title and
exhibit # or letter, and must be referenced in the petition.
8
lmER OF AUTHORIZATION
TO WHOM JJ MAY CONCERN
I hereby authorize AndY McCall, Park Planner. MDPR
(Name of Agent)
to serve as my Agent in a request to amend the Collier County Growth Management Plan affecting
property identified in this Application.
Signed: Miami-Dade County
(Name of Owner(s) of Record)
. Date:
I hereby certify that I have the authority to make the foregoing application, and that the application is
true, correct and complete to the best of my knowledge. ~
~-<'
Signature of Applicant ' ,
Carlos Alvarez
Name - Typed or Prtnted County Mayor
STATE OF
COUNTY OF
It>-ion-\\ - '\)"Jt
Sworn to and subscribed before me this '2 ~ ~ day of
by ~c "'~ ~-\-JciQ\ck, MYCO
Not&v Public -
CHOOSE ONE OF THE FOllOWING:
/ Wh~ is personally known to me,
who has produced
,~cA
"'LM M8IIEI.-IIlMCK
....,.......... II fIIIINI
..--......... n. 211
C 11.._
as identification.
and
did take an Oath
did not take and Oath
NonCE. BE AWARE THAT:
Florida Statute Section 837.06 - Folse otIIclallaw states that:
"Whoever knowingly makes 0 false statement In writing with the Intent to mislead 0 public servant In
the performance of his official duty sholl be gulHy of a misdemeanor 01 the second degree. punishable
os provided by 0 fine to a maximum of 7.s00.00 and/or maximum of 0 sixty day Jail term."
Petlllon CP-2009-1 Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS
RECREATION AREA
APPENDICES
Appendix
1.0.1
III.A
IVD.l
IVD.2
VAl
VA2
VA3
V.B.l
V.C.l
V.C.2a
V.C.2b
V.C.3a
V.C.3b
VD.l
VD.5b
V.D.5b.l
VD.5b.2
VD.5b.3
VD.5bA
VD.5b.5
VD.5b.6
V.D.5b.7
VD.5b.8
V.D.5b.9
V.D.5b.1O
V.D.5b.l1
V.D.5b.12
VD.5b.13
VD.5b.14
V.d.5b.15
V.E.la
V.E.lb
V.E.lc
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA
APPENDICES
Team Qualifications Additional Information
Sketch & Description
Future Land Use Map
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area Map
General Location Map
Aerial Map
Zoning with 500' Boundary Map
Existing FLUM
FLUCCS Map
Summary Table of Federal and State Plant and Animal Species
Panther Bear Telemetry Map
County Historic and/or Archeological Sites
Florida Master Site File Response
Area of Critical State Concern (ACSC) Map
Data and Analysis for the Proposed Use
Off-Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study
Collier County Park and Recreation Department Letter
F.S. 260-03. Definition of OHV
Existing Trail Conditions
Conceptual Diagram
Excerpt from State Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan (SCORP)
Public Inquiries
Lee County Agenda Request Form
OHV Titled in Miami-Dade County
OHV Titled in Collier County
Florida OHV County Title Activity, 6/30/02 TO 12/31/08
OHV Organizations and Clubs
Miami-Dade Resolution
Collier County Resolution
Letters of Support
Potable Water
Sanitary Sewer
Traffic Methodology and Traffic Impact Study (TIS)
Page 1 of2
V.E.ld
V.E.le
V.E.2
V.E.3
V.F.l
V.F.2a
V.F.2b
V.GA
Drainage
Solid Waste
Existing Services and Public Facilities
Proposed Services and Public Facilities
FEMA Flood Zones
Proposed Wellfields and ASR
10- Year Water Supply Existing and Planned Wellfields
Ownership and Encumbrance Report
Page 2 of 2
APPENDIX I.D.I
TEAM QUALIFICATIONS
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
County Petition No. CP-2009-1
Aooendix 1.0.1 - Team Qualifications - Additional Information
Name, Address and Qualifications of addifional planners. archifecfs. engineers,
environmental consultanfs and other professionals providing information contained
in this application.
Jill Cohen, AICP, RLA. LEED AP. Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke
Pines. FL 33024.
. Ms. Cohen is a Certified Planner and Registered Landscape Architect with 25+ years
experience in landscape architecture, planning, platting, urban design and site
engineering.
. As Project Manager, LEED AP, Planner and Landscape Architect. Ms. Cohen is
responsible for planning and platting entitlements and permitting, master planning.
specific site design, land use plan amendments. rezoning, variances, and
documentation as it relates to the firm's landscape architecture, planning,
sustainable design and urban design services.
. Ms. Cohen is also CPTED [Crime Prevention through Environmental Design) certified
and has been a course instructor.
. Recentiy Ms. Cohen has received her LEED (Leadership in Energy & Environmental
Design) accreditation and has been very involved in sustainable design projects.
. As Chair of the Broward 2030 Committee for the South Florida Chapter- Broward
Branch, of the USGBC (US Green Building Council), she has been partnering with the
Broward League of Cities on implementation of sustainable communities.
. Ms. Cohen is an Associate of the firm in the Landscape Architecture & Planning
Department and is very involved in several professional and civic organizations.
Matt Boerger, Planner, Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke Pines, FL
33024.
. Mr. Boerger has 5+ years experience in planning activities including land use
planning, comprehensive planning, land use plan amendments, rezoning, rewriting
of codes, site plan review and community involvement.
. He has worked extensively in throughout Florida, preparing Evaluation and
Appraisal Report (EAR) information, and Objective Recommendations and
Comments (ORC) report responses.
. In addition to working on planning submittals, he has also conducted plan reviews
for site plans, Planned Developments (PDs), Comprehensive Plan Amendments
[CPAs). Zoning Map Amendments (ZMAs), Preliminary Subdivisions (PSs), Final
Subdivisions [FSs) and Conditional Uses [CUs).
Mark Clark, CEP, Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke Pines, FL 33024.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 10f4
Appendix I.D.l
. Mr. Clark is a Certified Environmental Professional with 21 + years experience and is
a Senior Biologist, responsible for performing studies and investigations on biological
and ecological impacts affecting the firm's projects.
. As Department Manager for the Environmental Section of the South Florida office
his responsibilities include field evaluations, assessments, recommendations and
report writing.
. Specific responsibilities include: wetland jurisdictional determination, environmental
resource permitting. wetland mitigation design, mitigation monitoring, protected
species coordination, sea grass mapping, endangered species biological
assessments, permit construction compliance, coordination of environmental
geographic information system (GIS) applications, National Environmental Policy
Act (NEPA) documentation and assistance with plan preparations.
. Mr. Clark is a Senior Associate of the firm in the Environmental Department and is
very involved in several professional and civic organizations.
Paul Mann, c.A. Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke Pines. FL 33024.
. Mr. Mann is a Certified Arborist with 13+ years experience and is an Environmental
Specialist in the Environmental Field Office in Sarasota.
. He has significant experience working on both public and private sector projects in
Florida that focus on environmental improvements, habitat restoration. and
mitigation issues.
. Specific services he has provided to clients include: the development and
preparation of approved Florida Communities Trust Grant applications.
management plans, and stewardship reports including coordination with staff to
resolve scoring and site development issues for local municipalities, developing and
delivering complex county. state, and federal environmental resource permit
applications, and practical field experience involving environmental and
conservation principles and water resource engineering as it relates to, water
quality improvements. flood control, natural ecosystems, and municipal water
supply.
Eric Czerniejewski, P.E., Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200. Pembroke Pines, FL
33024,
. Mr. Czerniejewski is a Professional Engineer with 13+ years experience and is a
Senior Project Manager who manages the Company's Traffic Engineering
Department.
. His design responsibilities include management and preparation of all traffic and
transportation design services for the Company. This includes preparation and
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 2of4
Appendix I.D.l
review of all traffic studies including traffic impact studies. corridor studies, parking
utilization studies, Comprehensive Plan Amendment traffic elements and traffic
operation and safety studies. The design responsibilities also includes design and
preparation of signal plans, access management analysis and design. design and
permitting of transportation and roadway design engineering projects. planning
and developing and coordinating engineering documents. Services provided
include paving, grading and drainage, roadway design. intersection geometric
design, water management and traffic engineering.
. He has served as CDD District Engineer for a 600 acre Community Development
District in Cooper City, Florida called Monterra. He has managed the construction
for over 140 million dollars in publicly bid infrastructure improvements for this special
taxing district.
. As chair of the Transportation Legislative Issues Team for Broward Days since 2004,
he has advocated for the diverse needs and concerns of Broward County related
to finding a viable funding source for smart regional transportation facilities.
. He is past president of the Broward Chapter of the American Society of Civil
Engineers.
. Mr. Czerniejewski is an Associate of the firm in the Engineering Department and is
very involved in several professional and civic organizations.
Jimmy Wright. E.I.. LEED AP, Miller Legg, 1800 N Douglas Road, Suite 200, Pembroke
Pines, FL 33024.
. Mr. Wright is an Engineering Intern with 4+ years experience in Civil and Traffic
Engineering and Construction Management.
. He is responsible for the production of traffic engineering studies and design
services for the Company. He has recently completed traffic impact studies,
signalization design, university master plan updates and roadway design for arterial
roadways in South Florida.
. His design responsibilities also include design and permitting for water distribution
and sanitary sewer systems including lift stations, stormwater design/modeling and
permitting. paving. drainage and site grading and construction observation and
management.
. Mr. Wright recently became a LEED Accredited Professional.
Arsenio Milian, P.E.. President, Milian, Swain & Associates, Inc., 2025 SW 32nd Avenue,
Miami, FL 33145
. Mr. Milian has over 35 years of experience in civil and environmental engineering
including design, permitting, construction, operations and management of
numerous private and governmental projects in South Florida.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 3 of 4
Appendix 1.0.1
. Over the years, he has participated and directed negotiations with key members
of various regulatory agencies in the procurement of permits required for the
construction and operation of environmentally sensitive projects.
. He has been accepted as an expert, and has provided testimony before several
agencies in the State of Florida.
. In recognition of his community minded track record, Mr. Milian has been
appointed by three different Florida Governors to assist in statewide areas of
concern. For instance, in 1987 he was appointed by Governor Martinez as a
member of the Governing Board of South Florida Water Management District, in
1991 Governor Chiles appointed him to the State of Florida Environmental Land
Management Study Committee (ELMS III), and in 1999 Governor Bush appointed
him to the Florida Forever Advisory Council. He currently serves at the National
Council of the Wilderness Society.
. Mr. Milian is President and founder of Citizens for a Better South Florida, an
organization that promotes the safeguarding of South Florida's natural resources.
He has also been honored by receiving several prestigious awards from the
environmental community as recognition of his exemplary commitment to
preserving Florida's unique and irreplaceable natural environment.
Julio Menache. Director of Operations, Milian, Swain & Associates, Inc.. 2025 SW 32nd
Avenue, Miami, FL 33145
. Mr. Menache has 20 years of experience in project management, civil
infrastructure master planning, design, permitting, and construction administration
of private and public sector projects in South Florida. Mr. Menache's pro-active
approach. attention to detail and responsiveness to Clients has ensured successful
project results; "on time & budget".
. During his 12 year tenure with MSA. he has effectively managed the completion of
complex civil infrastructure improvement projects in environmentally sensitive
areas of South Florida. Specific responsibilities include establishing design criteria
for the MSA technical staff to follow in the areas of water distribution, sanitary
sewer, pump stations and stormwater management systems; cost efficient,
environmentally conscious and in compliance with regulatory requirements.
. As Director of Operations, he oversees contract management, quality control
reviews, budget control and marketing efforts for the civil and environmental
engineering departments. Representative public clients include Miami-Dade
County Park and Recreation Department, South Florida Water Management
District, City of Coral Gables, Miami-Dade County Department of Environmental
Resources Management (DERM), Miami-Dade County Public Works Department
and Miami-Dade Water and Sewer Department.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 4 of 4
Appendix I.D.l
APPENDIX III.A
SKETCH & DESCRIPTION
APPENDIX !lI.A
SHEET 1 OF 2
DESCRIPTION: (GMP AMENDMENT AREA FOR DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA)
PORTIONS OF SECTIONS 13, 14, 15 AND 16. TOWNSHIP 53 SOUTH, RANGE 34 EAST, COLLIER
COUNTY, FLORIDA, DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
COMMENCE AT SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE SOUTHEAST QUARTER (SE 1/4) OF SAID
SECTION 16; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION 16, NORTH 89'54'58" EAST
(BEARING BASIS) 1123.29 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING; THENCE NORTH 00'10'12"
WEST 4212.71 FEET; THENCE NORTH 89'59'14" EAST 5540.13 FEET; THENCE NORTH
00'44'17" WEST 147,89 FEET; THENCE NORTH 89'59'02" EAST 10,715.82 FEET; THENCE
SOUTH 81'03'32" EAST 573.99 FEET TO THE EAST LINE OF SAID SECTION 13; THENCE
ALONG SAID EAST LINE, SOUTH 00'40'03" EAST 3942.30 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER
OF SAID SECTION 13; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION 13, SOUTH
88'45'25" WEST 5090.33 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID SECTION 14; THENCE
ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION 14, SOUTH 88'45'25" WEST 5090.33 FEET TO
THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID SECTION 15; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID
SECTION 15, SOUTH 88'45'25" WEST 5090.33 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SAID
SECTION 16; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID SECTION 16, SOUTH 89'54'58" WEST
1587.10 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
SAID LANDS SITUATE, LYING, AND BEING IN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AND CONTAINING
1608 ACRES MORE OR LESS.
-l
1-75 THIS BROWAAD
&I SITE COUNTY
COUJER
a: COUNTY
en t
MIAMI-DADE
COUNTY ~
us. HWY. 41 ~
LOCATION MAP
NOT TO SCALE
SEE SHEET 2 OF 2 FOR SKETCH
SKETCH AND DESCRIPTION
n"lIs SKETCH DOES NOT
REPRESENT A BOUNDARY SURVEY
CERTIFIED TO:
MIAM~DADE COUtITY PARK AND RECREATIDN DEPARTMENT
I HEREBY CERTlN 11-IAT THIS SKETCH MEETS THE
MINIMUM TECHNICAL STANDARDS AS SET FORni BY
lHE flORIDA aOARD OF PROFESSIONAL SURVEYORS
AND MAPPERS IN CHAP'TER 61G17-6, FLORIDA
ADMINISTRATIVE CODE PURSUANT TO SECTION
472.027, FlORIDA STATUTES.
DATED THIS 25th DAY OF MARCH .2009 A.D.
MR
South Florida OffIce: 1 BOO North Douglas Road' Suite 200
Pembroke Pines, Florida .. 33024-3200
954-436-7000" Fax: 954-438-8664
www.mllferlegg.com
~.--o.~'
IIM11N P. _
PROFESSIONAL SUR\'€YOR AND MAPPER
STATE OF FLORIDA REGlS1RATlON No.S6!57
NOT VAllO 'MTHOUT THE SIGNATURE AND THE afGlHAL
RAISED SEAl.. OF A FLORIDA UCENSED SUR'oatlA ~ t.lAPPER
CERllF1CA'IE OF AUTHORIlA llON: LBeelO
MILLER~EGG
OAT!: REV J S ION S
PROJEC' "0_ ru"o.
DRAWN BY: RZ CHECKED BY:
09-00063 III, A
Y:\Ptojlctll -000&3 - Dod...cdl... Pen Nn<<ldlll~t\OrawlI\Oll\Sul'wy\A1V PARK REZOHlNO...5D.dlrf !.lon OJ/30/20Dll I1l21o By bzlmmMl'l
APP,ENDIX III.A
SEC1l0N 9
TOWNSHIP 53 SOUTH
SEC1l0N 10 SEC1l0N 11
SEC1l0N 16
S. LINE
SEC. 16
SEC1l0N 15
N89'59'02"E
SEC1l0N 14
S. WE SEC. IS
SE CORNER
SEC. 16
S. LINE SEC. 14
SE CORNER
SEC. 15
P.O.C.
SW CORNER
SE 1/4,
SECTION
16-53-34
SEC1l0N 21
GRAPHIC SCALE
o 1500 3000
~ I
6000
I
( IN FEET )
1 INCH = 3000 FEET
~
I ~
i
! TAMI~~- T
i U.S. HWY 4
I . 1 l1. OF PAVE!.ENT PER
E.R. 8ROWNELL ANO
DETAIL ASSOCIATES SURVEY
I_.M." NOT TO SCALE DATEO 7-S-68___
P.O.B.
UJ
, .
r-..N
...,-
-.i~
"'0
<00
Ul
;"
..,
MILLE~EGG
5090.33'
SSS'45'25"W
SHEET 2 OF 2
,
>-I-'!-
t-{f)lUJ>-
S ~I~ ~
o V 1l1:;:)
() r<') f"") 0
SEC1l0N 12 ()
8:i UJ I UJ UJ SEC1l0N 7
:J~i~Q
--~,",.",g'I'~ ---
573.99'
10,715.82'
E. LINE SEC. 13
UJ
an
"'0
~ '0 SEC1l0N 18
0>"
"'8
Ul
SE CORNER
SEC. 13
SECTION 13
S. LINE SEC. 13
SE CORNER
SEC, 14
5090.33'
S88'45 25' W
LEGEND:
P.O.C. = POINT OF COMMENCEMENT
P.O.B. = POINT OF BEGINNING
SEC, ~ SEC1l0N
It = CENTER LINE
SURVEYOR'S NOTES:
SUBJECT PROPERTY WAS NOT
ABSTRACTED BY THIS FIRM FOR
EASEMENTS, RIGHTS-OF-WAY,
RESERVA1l0NS OR OTHER MATTERS
OF RECORD AND OWNERSHIP WAS
NOT DETERMINED.
BEARINGS ARE BASED ON THE
SOUTH LINE OF SEC. 16, TWP. 53 S.,
RGE 34 E. HAVING A BEARING OF
S89'54'5S"W.
THE SEC1l0N LINES AS SHOWN ARE
BASED ON SURVEY PREPARED BY
E.R. BROWNELL AND ASSOCIATES,
DATED 7-5-68 FOR DADE COUNTY
PORT AUTHORITY TITLED TRANSI1l0N
AND TRAINING AIRPORT DADE AND
COLLIER COUNTIES, PROPERTY MAP
- EXHIBIT "A", TO ACCOMPANY
PROJECT APPLICATION FOR FAA
PROJECT 9-08-083-01.
SEE SHEET 1 OF 2 FOR DESCRIP1l0N
South F1ork!llotllce: 1800 North Douglae Road'SiAle200
Pembr0k8Plnes,flolida'33024-3200
954-436-7000 " F!lll: 954-<136-B664
_.mlllllilegg.com
Certificate of AuthorIzation LB. 6680
SKETCH "va) DFSCIlIPTION
VI rojlc:tI
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA
nilS SKETCH DOES NOT REPRESENT A BOUNDARY SUR\'EY
II
....., ...
09 00063
"'...
III. A
0i-0008.1 - OadcI-Cout.. pn NnWldmWlt w1n~1 SIIrw TV PARK REZONlN<LSO.dw'll Won OJ 2000 lI:22a By b%lrnm.-m
APPENDIX IV.D.I
FUTURE LAND USE MAP
T 53 5 T 52 5 T 51 5 T 50 5 T 4S 5 T 48 5 T 47 5 T 48 5
c..
0:J'\,:f<J}\ JO J1n~ ~
~
~ ... ~
~ c: ~
. 0 -t
}c ~, ~ c:
,.8or.: :II
l:Ezo Cl m
ii"i!'
lI:8~:i! l?, N
~~i~ ~ r- eo
II eo
Cl :I> ... ~
~ ~i>~ 0 z
c ~
~ J;o.E'i!ll ~CI m
m ~~iS N
." eo
."'"':10 ~ -
"'!il~fil c: ...
~i'i"')o ;S; (II
"' .
~~~~ ~ m
+i
~r iii:
~ , ~
~ :I> ~
~ ~
"'lI
~
~
m
~
.
~
~
~
~
,
,
,
,
,
........-.......
"
-. -t---____
,: ~ ----~~--,;;~
" ,
, 0
"
"
"
....(.
" /
,
/~-"' -,,------- --"-
j
-+-~
1
,
i
\
I
o
"
.
z
o
~
~
~
I
I
I
I
II .
~ II .
~ i:: "
~ -----1' ,
I
/
I
I
~
~
~
I
Ii
I;
'I'
,
~
~
~
~ lit
>:;Jt
~ I s Ii
~ ~ I!~
ii"
!Ii
s &S 1 S ZS 1
APPENDIX IV.D.1 - FUTURE LAND USE MAP
S 6tr 1
S LS 1
S OS 1
!~
\
.....
I"
d~
n~
,
< ~
""III.I~
!m
:i~ ~c:
il ~;
! ~~
~;;
~
~ ~!~~~I
~ ~! ~~ :~ ~~ ~
:~ ~f 3~
, -".l
~:-
~ ~
S 8tr 1
~
~
=
=
~
~
=
~
Q
=
.
--!!ii' ~
q~
p
,g
i5
~~
~
~EJ
,'~
o~
t<t:
~t
~ ~
=
~
~
-~I ~I,.
~ 5~
~ ~~
ofiij
~ z~
.11I.
e. !.III.
U ~ ~'n ~~
<'< ~ ~~ ~ 0;:
~ >-~ ~ i"
ij ~; ~ ~;
~!
"
c
.
~
=
~
~
=
~
~
nll~
Qj!!
~~
;~
r
I::JUIIIIIIIII
" m
~ I~ ' ~
\
~ ~
to ~
r:: ~
~ ~
~
S Lto 1
S 9tr 1
APPENDIX IV.D.2
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS
RECREATION AREA MAP
(lQ-l)IXl5J - [J,Il(-ro.ID PNlK .. """
1- ------
~D~
U1
r i ~ U1 r'l
r'l 0 U1
0 =J r'l
=J 0 0
0 z =J
~; i z 0
'" z
'1 '"
II!
U1
r'l
0
=J
0
z
~
0
I:
:;00
fTI)>
no
:;OfTI
fTI I
)>n
-j0
-r
Or
z-
fTI
)>:;0
:;On
fTI-<
)>"lJ
0:;0
_fTI
(f)(f)
-j(f)
:;0
n
-j
OJ
if)
r'l
o
=J
o
z
~\,~
III
'.
Iii
I ~.vo~~
I
...,
0
"
z
if) if)
r'l I
0 -u
=J
0 '"
z '"
:::: if)
0
c
...,
I
if)
r'l
o
=J
o
z
~
N
COLLIER COUNTY
RANGE 34 EAST
RANGE 35 EAST
DADE COUNTY
if)
r'l
o
=J
o
Z
-.J
if)
if) r'l
r'l 0
0 ~ =J CD
oj 0
0 ~ z
z OJ
-.J
, APPENDIX IV.D.2 DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA
______n_._____,. __ .. __ ______ ____
,I!! I. ~I ~ZE~.~. ~EGG 1 C DADE.COLLlER CYPRESS RECREAfiONARErMAPl r:R..'--'. ..-
I~ II _,_...=~":~""=--":',;s,..",, : [' COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ,FE1-- _
'1' -.:':'".:':."::."'"' I FOR: MIAMI.DADECOUNTY Id...--..L..-=",,,
~
TTi
I~.J.~"
APPENDIX V.A.!
GENERAL LOCATION MAP
..
r
~ - OADE-ro.Wl PARI( AlIIO.IEN
V.A.I~ lb .0lIC
~
~ ~
~ ~ ~
!!I~ 9
~m
I~
m i~
i ;
~ I~
!i
o
ON
8 ~ 0
is )> Z
zo_
'::! C/) Z
0G')
- ..
C/)
-I
N
o
z
z
G')
z
c
)>
0 Ul
ON c
OJ
~O L
rTl
)>Z n
0- -1
C/)Z --0
0G') ::0
0
- . . --0
C/) rTl
-I ::0
-1
-<
II: ..>1, ~
~n: .
~
j;
~Nc~
~
.-
-----
0 N
Z (j)
0 "'
. () (j)
)> oj "'
Z 0 ()
0 z oj
- 0
C/) Z '" Z
<D
-
C/)
N
o
Z
-
Z
G')
. .
o
o
z ~~ ~
I m_ =::J
)>:i ~
Om
C/)
o
-
-I
(j)
"'
()
oj
o
z
(j)
~
.,.
(j)
"'
()
oj
o
z
~
'"
(j)
"'
()
oj
o
z
~ 0
en 0 N
~O
)>
C/)Z
0G')
(j) -
ri ~ en
~ '-J -I
'-J
(j)N
BO
~Z
C;z
G')
. .
o
Ob
'"
(j)Ziii
"' . I
~ )>=D
O_(j)
z" I'"
~ C/)(j)
~ 0
c
01
-
-I
(j)
"'
()
oj
o
z
~
N
COLLIER COUNTY
RANGE 34 EAST
RANGE 35 EAST
DADE COUNTY
(j)
"'
()
oj
o
Z
'-J
(j)
"'
()
is OJ
z
en
APPENDIX V.A.l - GENERAL LOCATION MAP
I-~~LLE~EGG ! D .A. D. E-COLLliFiCYPRESS RECREA TIONAREl: ~ -.-.....j].-'.
_'~="::...'"":.-":;SO,."" I COlliER COUNTY, FLORIDA I __ .':-
. -:-=.-:::- ___~ __ u FOR: MIAMI-DADE COUNTY _ _ "=,__" ,__
APPENDIX V.A.2
AERIAL MAP
n
,
.
V..I..2~
..
.~
,
r---
, APPENDIX V.A.2 - AERIAL MAP
I: !H MILLE~EGG 1IDADE.COLLlER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA IF-- --1:R
~ i I "",'Fbklollllloo<''''''"'''''''''''''''_ S,""'J COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ~
i '~'i "==1t!..:r~ I FOR: MIAMI-DADE COUNTY ~ _1_ I "' '0., I.IJ
APPENDIX V.A.3
ZONING WITH 500' BOUNDARY MAP
, -lWlE-couEJlPIIlKA/iElIllEN ........., ,~ -
, - ------------- ---- - --------
~ 0 ~N
~ ~DD~ ON (fJ
(fJ :1>0 01
01 ~O () (fJ
~i i ~ g () =! 01
=! O~ 0 ()
)>Z Z -1
i.. ! 0 0
z
O- m z
'" enZ '"
~ ~ I 0G')
m i~ I - ..
en
-I
i ; ~
~ I~ (fJ
01
N 0 ()
0 =!
!i ~N 0
z z
Z ~
en
C'l :I>~
z
c enZ
)>
0G')
- . . (fJ I
en ~ 01
"'''' ()
-I ~:; =!
500' :~ 0 en
z V<
I ~ :::: (fJ
.... 0
c
::i:menz en 0 -1
I
m>OO c
enenC;C ;:: ~N
...,;-:1...,..., ;::
.. :I::I: >
nn.... ;C
oOnn -< :1>0
ZZOO
j,.>ZZ ~ (fJ (fJ
0(')>> III O~ 01 01
enennn r () ()
nQenen [1! enZ =! =!
0 0
(j)cnQQ 0G') z z
...,""enen
N~"""" - . . V< N
OZNN en
Z_OO COLLIER COUNTY
-zzz -I
i5Glzz RANGE 34 EAST
GlGl
> RANGE 35 EAST
Z DADE COUNTY
0 a (fJ
z 01 (fJ
CD<.Ji () 01
C =! ()
> 00 0 =!
CO ~O 0
(f) z
I: z
0:;0 "'0 c "
....s ~ - )>)> ZN CD
" '--
:;00 :1>0 111
-<- n
c -j
-j(f)
0 - Cl
(f) enZ :;0
0G') 0
-j Cl (fJ
(fJ_ . . 01
~AfC)~1Iclo\I) 111 ~~ 111 ()
:;0 -1 co
0
-j z
-< '"
"
APPENDIX V.A.3 - ZONING WITH 500' BOUNDARY MAP
--~---_.- --
Ji;:I'~8~1: 1!lf MILLE~.~;GG 1rOADE.COLLlER CYPRESS RECREATION AREAl it.'... -I
It..' 0; ~ii _",==~':".:"...",,=+"':,,;&J'''''' I' COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA___ - -I
'.' E:' P,L.. "'-.;0,,:::..-:- I F,()R: MIAMI.DADECOUNTY .... ,I. _. ,,,,,.. I_I~
APPENDIX V.B.I
EXISTING FLUM
T 48 S
T 49
T 50 S
Wnl::1 !)NI1SIX3 - rs'^ XICN3dd'<f
T 51 I T 52 S T 53 S
T 46
T 47 S
/
/
!
o
~ ~
~ ~
~ 0
: I
I
!
!
,
: ~
:u
,
ii!;~ ,.;~
j ~ ~HHni
l~iiJli;1 ci I
0"
.~
:~
;~
U,r&:
;/'"
,<
1!Il..::.
~
: ~
~ ,
i" n:-
o " E.,' ~
, ,,~; .,
~~n~~
i~ ~' c.. '
...~
i
,
< ;
!
.
:i,;;:t.
o:~. f !1 ~~. ~
~",i 'i ;, ~~ I'
3~1 ~ ;:.~ ,
i~I' I ; " "
o~ ' ~~ Ii
<I ',.I..IS!
~l
~ i
il
II
"l
~-
lit
o
,
;::.;'
'i~ ~
~ ~
01.
::l ~ ",
::; ~iIC_)vH0
~~ n~
"~ . ~ '
~i j ~~
... ~. ....md~
"
'I
ii
j
. I
.::::J~...
~
.
I
"
I
I
/
J~~~/
..-
t'
---, ,/
---~~ i----.
(...'.'
r.....'
,---
-----;;;;-;;;-;..;;:;---'---
~
,,-- -t-------
~
~
...
~ 00: ~
::IE 1"<
:::~ c~~
l~<~
Ill::lii "1 !
.i'l
c ~ <.<
NCII~ ;!l~
~ 0: 0 ~ 0: ~
125: B.!
..00:" rp
g......j J ~ 0;::
N 0 j!; ~ 0: ~
..." ;'li
oc
::I ~ i
l- .
~ ::I . 0 . ~
... MeX~c
Gulf of
S 9v .1 S tv.l , 1 " 1 S OS.1 S LS.1 S ZS.l S ES.l ..,
~
~
~
~
~
~
N
~
APPENDIX V.C.I
FLUCCS MAP
APPENDIX V,C.l - FlUCCS MAP
MILLE~EGG
__"""""100""""""""_'1<0""'"
_Pl....FI>ido.,~
........."""....:-
-......<IoIIl.....
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
FOR: MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V.c.t - Florida Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System Vegetative
Classifications
Field observations, in conjunction with the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)
National Wetland Inventory (NWI) coverage's, and aerial photographs dated 2004, were used to
develop a map of the vegetative communities on site. The vegetative communities are based on
the Florida Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCCS), Third Edition 1999.
Nine (9) vegetative communities were identified on the proposed 0101,608 acre project site. The
following vegetative descriptions list the dominant species observed in the field for the purpose
of describing the individual habitats and is not a complete list of all species that occur within the
project limits.
FLUCCS 6170 - Mixed Wetlands Hardwood 010166 Acres
This forested wetland habitat is composed of a hardwood tree community tolerant of hydric
conditions in which no single species appears to achieve dominance within the canopy. The
canopy is comprised oflive oak (Quercus virginiana), cabbage palm (Sabal palmetto), laurel oak
(Quercus laurifolia), red maple (Acer rubrum), bald cypress (Taxodium distichum), red bay
(Persea borbonia), poisonwood (Metopium toxiferum), and strangler fig (Ficus aurea). Shrub
canopy contains cocoplum (Chrysobalanus icaco), myrsine (Rapanea guinensis), wax myrtle
(Myrica cerifera), saw palmetto (Serenoa repens), buttonbush (Cephalanthus occidentalis) and
Carolina willow (Salix caroliniana). Representative ground cover species include swamp fern
(Blechnum serrulatum), leather fern (Acrostichum danaeifolium), Virginia Chain Fern
(Woodwardia virginica), royal fern (Osmunda regalis), saw-grass (Cladium jamaicense), and
sand cordgrass (Spartina bakerii).
FLUCCS 6211 - DwarfCvpress 010675 Acres
This forested wetland habitat is primary habitat on the project site and is composed of a stunted
pond cypress (Taxodium ascendens) tree canopy in areas with exposed cap rock and minimal
marl soils. Representative ground cover species include sawgrass, muhly grass (Muhlenbergia
filipes), Tracy's beakrush (Rhynchospora tracyii), Everglades daisy (Helenium pinnatifidum),
star rush (Dichromena colorata), marsh fleabane (Pluchea odorata), love vine (Cassytha
filiformis), and bladderworts (Utricularia spp.).
FLUCCS 6215 Cvpress - Domes/Heads 01027 Acres
This forested wetland habitat is primarily comprised of bald cypress with scattered dahoon holly
(Ilex cassine), pond cypress and cocoplum. It appears to be associated with slight depressions in
the cap rock where organic soils have accumulated. Ground cover is primarily sawgrass.
FLUCCS 6216 Cvpress - Mixed Hardwoods 010166 Acres
This forested wetland habitat is composed of a bald cypress with scattered pond cypress, dahoon
holly, cocoplum, red bay, myrsine, and wax myrtle. Representative ground cover species include
sawgrass, muhly grass, Tracy's beakrush, Everglades daisy, star rush, marsh fleabane,
bladderworts, swamp lily (Crinum americana), and lemon bacopa (Bacopa caroliniana).
FLUCCS 6310 - Wetland Scrub 01057 Acres
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
1 of2
Appendix V.C.l
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V.c.! - Florida Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System Vegetative
Classifications
This forested wetland community is dominated by dense, low-growing, woody shrubs and small
trees. Tree species observed include sabal palm, willow, wax myrtle, dahoon holly, saltbush,
buttonbush, and saplings of red maple, sweetbay (Magnolia virginica), and other hydric tree
species indicative of wooded wetlands. Representative ground cover species include sawgrass,
sand cordgrass, marsh fleabane, duck potato (Sagitaria lancifolia), and pickerelweed (Pontederia
cordata).
FLUCCS 641 OD - Freshwater Marsh, Disturbed c1c5 Acres
These small pockets of herbaceous wetlands are dominated by herbacous emergent vegetation.
This depressional wetland habitat appears in conjunction with the cleared areas surrounding the
borrow areas FLUCCS 7420 and adjacent exposed rock with marsh grasses FLUCCS 7310 and
appear to have been created when these areas were originally cleared for excavation of the
borrow areas. Representative ground cover species include spikerush (Eleocharis interstincta),
maidencane (Panicum hemitomon), lemon bacopa (Bacopa caroliniana), and torpedo grass
(Panicum repens).
FLUCCS 73 I 0 - Exposed Rock with Marsh Grasses c1c46 Acres
These areas occur surrounding the borrow areas FLUCCS 7420 and are comprised of disturbed
rock soils. Representative ground cover species include knot grass (Paspalum distichum),
torpedo grass (Panicum repens), common reed (Phragmites australis), common frog-fruit (Phyla
nodijlora), yellow nut sedge (Cyperus esculentus), broomsedge (Andropogon virginicus), rust-
weed (Polypremum procumbens), marsh pink (Sabatia stellaris), muhly grass, sawgrass, star
rush, marsh fleabane, southern fleabane (Erigeron quercifolius), and widely scattered trees such
as Brazilian Pepper (Schinus terebinthifolius) and Australian Pine (Casuarina spp.).
FLUCCS 7420 - Borrow Areas c1c51 Acres
The deep cut borrow areas contain minimal littoral areas vegetated with herbaceous wetland
species such as cattail (Typha spp.), sawgrass, wax myrtle, and scattered Brazilian pepper.
FLUCCS 7440 - Fill Areas c1c13 Acres
These areas are the filled roads leading to the borrow areas FLUCCS 7420 and contain minimal
vegetation along the edges with the surrounding habitat. In areas where vegetation is present
representative ground cover species include torpedo grass, common frog-fruit, marsh pink, rust-
weed, yellow nut sedge, broomsedge, star rush, and various upland grasses.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
20f2
Appendix V.c.!
APPENDIX V.C.2a
SUMMARY TABLE OF FEDERAL
AND STATE PLANT AND ANIMAL
SPECIES
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V.Co2a - Summary Table of Listed Plant and Animal Species
The following summary table of Federal (US Fish & Wildlife Service) and State (Florida
Department of Agriculture and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission) listed plant
and animal species known to occur on the site and/or known to inhabit nearby biological
communities similar to the site was compiled utilizing Florida Natural Areas Inventory (FNAI)
data, US Fish & Wildlife Service list for Collier County, and the Florida Fish and Wildlife
Conservation Commission List of Imperiled Species in conjunction with observations of wildlife
and assessment of potential habitat on the project site. Some species listed by FNAI were not
included as FNAI results include rare species not included on Federal and State lists or species
endemic to habitats found in area, but not on site (e.g. pine flatwoods).
Common Name
Mollusks
Florida tree snail
Scientific Name
FFWCC
USFWS
Liguus Jasciatus
Reptiles
American alligator
Alligator snapping turtle
Alligalor mississippiensis
Chelydra serpentina osceola
Birds
Limpkin
Little blue heron
Snowy egret
Tricolor heron
White ibis
Wood stork
Evcrglade snail kite
A ramus guarauna
Egretta caerulea
Egretta thula
Egretta tricolor
Eudocimus albus
Mycteria americana
Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus
Mammals
Florida panther
Florida black bear
Big Cypress fox squirrel
Puma concolor cOlyi
Ursus americanusfloridanus
Sciurus niger avicennia
Plants
Common Name Scientific Name
Blodgctt's wild-mercury Argythamnia blodgettii
Cuban snake-bark Colubrina cubensis var. floridana
Few-flowered fingergrass Digitaria pauciflora
Clamshell orchid Encyclia cochleata var. triandra
Pinel and jacquemontia Jacquemontia curtissii
Small's flax Linum carteri var. smallii
Florida royal palm Roystonea elata
Florida filmy fern Trichomanes punctatum ssp. floridanum
The following symbols indicate status of protection:
E - Endangered
T - Threatened
sse - Species of special concern; FFWCe Only
ns/ A/)- Threatened/Similaritv of Aooearance
sse
sse
ssc
T(S/A)
SSC
SSC
ssc
sse
ssc
E
E
E
E
E
T
T
E
FDA
E
E
E
E
T
E
E
E
USFWS
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
lof6
Appendix V.C.2a
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V,C.2a - Summary Table of Listed Plant and Animal Species
",/, FLpRt PA t A......
11 A-'Pf rA- rTTe.A-S
INVENTORY
Florida Natural Areas Inventory
Biodiversity Matrix Query Results
UNOFFICIAL REPORT
Created 3/24/2009
(Contact FNAI Data Services Coordinator
for an official Standard Data Report)
(Contact the FNAl Data Services Coordinator at 850.224.8207 for Information on an official
Standard Data Report)
NOTE: The Biodiversity Matrix includes only rare species and natural communities tracked by FNAI.
Report for 10 Matrix Units: 57381, 57382, 57688, 57689 , 57993 , 57994, 58296, 58297,
58596 , 58597
Descriptions
DOCUMENTED - There is a documented occurrence in the FNAI database of the species or community within
this Matrix Unit.
DOCUMENTED-HISTORIC - There is a documented occurrence in the FNAI database of the species or
community within this Matrix Unit; however the occurrence has not been observed/reported within the last
twenty years.
LIKELY - The species or community is known to occur in this vicinity, and is considered likely within this
Matrix Unit because:
1. documented occurrence overlaps this and adjacent Matrix Units, but the documentation isn't precise
enough to indicate which of those Units the species or community is actually located in; or
2. there is a documented occurrence in the vicinity and there is suitable habitat for that species or
community within this Matrix Unit.
POTENTIAL - This Matrix Unit lies within the known or predicted range of the species or community based on
expert knowledge and environmental variables such as cfimate, soils, topography, and land cover.
Matrix Unit ID: 57381
o Documented Elements Found
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
2of6
Appendix V.C.2a
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V.Co2a - Summary Table of Listed Plant and Animal Species
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma conc%r corvi GST1 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4GST3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit ID: 57382
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
4 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma concolor corvi GST1 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rockland hammock G2 52 N N
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4GST3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit ID: 57688
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma concolor corvi GST1 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis olumbeus G4GST3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit ID: 57689
o Documented Elements Found
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
30f6
Appendix V.C.2a
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V,C.2a - Summary Table of Listed Plant and Animal Species
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma conc%r corvi GSTl 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4GST3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit ID: 57993
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria amer;cana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma concolor corv; GSTl 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4GST3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit ID: 57994
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria amer;cana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma concolor corvi GSTl 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4GST3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit ID: 58296
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area 40f6 Appendix V.C.2a
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V.C.2a - Summary Table of Listed Plant aud Animal Species
Wood Stork
Puma coneolor corvi G5T1 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis D/umbeus G4G5T3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit 10: 58297
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma cone%r corvi G5T1 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4G5T3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit 10: 58596
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma cone%r corvi G5T1 51 LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4G5T3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Matrix Unit 10: 58597
o Documented Elements Found
o Documented-Historic Elements Found
3 Likely Elements Found
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Mvcteria americana G4 52 LE LE
Wood Stork
Puma cone%r corv; G5T1 Sl LE LE
Florida Panther
Rostrhamus sociabilis Dlumbeus G4G5T3Q 52 LE LE
Snail Kite
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
5of6
Appendix V.C.2a
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Appendix V.C.2a - Summary Table of Listed Plant and Animal Species
Matrix Unit IDs: 57381 . 57382 . 57688 . 57689 . 57993 . 57994 . 58296 . 58297 . 58596 .
58597
16 Potential Elements Common to Any of the 10 Matrix Units
Scientific and Common Names Global State Federal State
Rank Rank Status Listing
Aravthamnia blodaettii G2 52 C LE
Blodgett's Wild-mercury
Co/ubrina cubensis var. floridana G2G3T1 51 N LE
Cuban Snake-bark
Corvnorhinus rafinesouii G3G4 52 N N
Rafinesque's Big-eared Bat
Digitaria pauciffora G1 51 C LE
Few-flowered Fingergrass
Drvmarchon couDer; G3 53 LT LT
Eastern Indigo Snake
Elytraria caroliniensis var. angustifoNa G4T2 52 N N
Narrow-leaved Carolina Scalystem
Encvclia cochleata var. triandra G4GST2 52 N LE
Clamshell Orchid
Forestiera segregata var. pinetorum G4T2 52 N N
Florida PinewQod Privet
Galactia Dinetorum G2Q 52 N N
Pineland Milk Pea
GODherus DolvDhemus G3 53 N LT
Gopher Tortoise
Jacauemontia curtissi; G2 52 N LT
Pineland Jacquemontia
Unum carteri var. smallii G2T2 52 N LE
Small's flax
Picoides borealis G3 52 LE L5
Red-cockaded Woodpecker
Roystonea elata G2G3 52 N LE
Florida Royal Palm
Trichomanes punctatum ssp. floridanum G4G ST1 51 N LE
Florida Filmy Fern
Ursus americanus f10ridanus GST2 52 N LT*
Florida Black Bear
Disclaimer
The data maintained by the Florida Natural Areas Inventory represent the single most comprehensive source of
information available on the locations of rare species and other significant ecological resources statewide.
However, the data are not always based on comprehensive or site-specific field surveys. Therefore, this
information should not be regarded as a final statement on the biological resources of the site being considered,
nor should it be substituted for on-site surveys. FNAI shall not be held liable for the accuracy and completeness
of these data, or opinions or conclusions drawn from these data. FNAI is not inviting reliance on these data.
Inventory data are designed for the purposes of conservation planning and scientific research and are not
intended for use as the primary criteria for regulatory decisions.
Unofficial Report
These results are considered unofficial. FNAI offers a Standard Data Reauest option for those needing certifiable
data.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
60f6
Appendix V.C.2a
~" u.g";..;ci:
a .- a '" 8
8 '" ~ Z '" ~
8.8 ~ oj ~ en
]~~oo"C~"'Cl
~(\)~]~~8
"d .5 15 ~.s.~, "'",
~ .E 8 .c:; Q .~ 0..
..c: oj 8 oj.C.=: 8
_~ojO:;::"dojoj
oj ..c: ~ ~ i:t ~
.~ .D ~ ..0 ~ ~ 00
0.. 2 -+->..0 ,,(\) d) (\)
~u~2~~~ :>
CIl0.8~g(\)"fr ..8
af.:J "' :::'C d) (\) ro
$:l u v"'d .......- en ;> I;/';
's.. 0 -- = ro ro 2. ctl
8.~~r:;:: a~"' Il)
~ 8 en"" '" ~.... <= 8
._ _ (\) U = ~. ctl ctl _
::c ..c ~ 8.S. 0 8 ~ Vi
p:.!
.~
'"
"
....
-Sl
'"
"
'"
'"
"
~
~
II
'-
'"
!;
ct:
....
"
-B
<=
oj
0.
oj
:g
....
a
~
~
"
Ii:
Ii:
~
en u.
" ...,.!:!
;> ~;...
o (\) ~'a
I-< cti::r: l-<
a tG 00".....
~ o."d "
~g~~
'" ~ ~ ,,' i3
~ .~ ~ 'I:: e
l5 ~ '+='~ I-<
oj """ .!:!
..Q ~ = ro
~ v)'a :::
1TJ d) u 0 "5J
$-; .- (J)
~ ::s Vl r.J; '""
.c;t;OJ"'Cl~
-;;; oj ~ a ,
~ ~ ~" ~ .~
= IJ.) U .c:;.-
ct! :> 0 ctl ~
..c: a 80:;:: 0.
en .... 8 " ~
~ e oj.8 ~
~ _"J:::l ;;>
en
en
~
Of)
oj
"
CIl
,,'
>
8
Of)
~
~
<:
CIl
[::;
::c
UE-<
I.lS
.-
.i;;
'"
o<:l
-€
::t
;:J '"
- ;:J
'" "
e '"
!;-Sl
""
'"
::t
....
'"
o<:l
..Q
~
~
<=
~
<=
.8
~
<=
;:l
a
8
II
~
oj
8
;:l
"'"
oj
i3
u
oj
i3
~ u
~"d
oj "
<= ~
oj en
8 ~
<= u
oj en
'6 '<=
<= a
-.n
~ ;:l
en"d
" ;:l
~-<
~
..
'-
CCl
p:.!
'"
::t
'"
o<:l
!;
.21
;:J ""
.S .:::J
- -
't ;Z
'" '"
!; .\3
'" '"
::t '"
!; ;:J
~~~
c;Z1:
!; '" -
E .:, ~
""" !; <=>;
~
a
~
0.
en
"
:g
en
oj
'"
en
"
:g
CIl
"
0.
oj
U
....
"
~
oj
]
en
"
....
~
"
00"' 't::
"d ._
o oj
o 8 i:t
Z oj ~
,g~~
","d ,
= I:: .~
.- 0 I-<
o..Q.. 'a
'~..c="' a
.a ~ ~
~ oj ....
::C8o
p:.!
"
~
:Q
-
.8
<=
en
"
"d
oj
on
....
"
>
p:.!
~
<=
"
u
oj
'6'
oj
"d
~
m
N
o
:>
"
i5
c
.
"-
"-
'"
en
~
.5 rJ:l"JB
~ <=
8 ,g .~
on "d~
<= ~
oj <=
~ I: rJ:l Ij)
"d oj <= '" g
g o:S.9 ~.~
:<:: Vl +-> c"'g
.s r.n e"'O rJ)
w ~ ;::::S
0:;:: <=.s 8 ~
1l).9 " ro
.5 ~ I:: ~ 00"
........_..c "'Cl
~"~5~aVl
u ll) ~ (J) _ QJ
o>,-,..ooo~
all)....... >-,': ro
~ 8 ~ "'Cl:-;::
IU ro (l)'Q) a ~-g
i3 ::c 0 ..c: CIl t;;< "
p:.!
!;
t
'"
'"
'"
~
'"
'"
;:J
!;
'" ;:J
i:; '"
"'{l
!; .::::
!; '"
"""
~
o
l::
oj
0.
en
....
"
0.
0.
o
..c:
en
en
oj
5h
.g
.C
o
~
en
"d
a
o
~
0:;::
~
.n
2
u
CIl
2'
u
CIl
E-<
p:.!p:.!
'"
'"
'"
"
~
t
'"
'"
"
'"
!;
'"
"
-Sl
'"
"'"
~
.:::J
-
'"
!;
c3
~
oj
..,.
.n
2
u
en
oj
"d
.C
o
~
....
'"
""
u
'"
"d ....
o "
0=2
~ oj
"d ~
~ 00
-:0
:0 <=
, oj
at
~~
::c
U
E-<'
M
'"
o
rl
'"
-€
-Sl
'"
!;
;:J
~
i2
'"
c5
OJ
m
nl
0,
....
"
>
o
-s.
Of)
<=
.S.
p:;
. . 0::
" 0- 5
4 :~ ~ ~ '"
o ~ ~ U':l tI:.l
o .e-VJ"'l;j e
:;: ."," a'n <= '"
~ ~~~O(l)
<;:: '" ;0> 0-1>. rfJ
~~t54~g:..d'
..... 0 - 0 r./'J !:< tI:.l
o.o.so~,,;a
.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~<;::f,2<;::5.':lJl
,.....:; (l) (l) Q) I-< ~
(1)".5 S.5 E ~
=: "'C 0.. I:\i bl)
'a,g u:s: =:
~ ..c:....-I..r::.-
~.Ja i;j.Ja "':;: <= <=
._ Q) ~ ~..9: ~ cd
:r::r:~:r:~~",,::E
~" ~"
"'8 g e" 0:
~ 5"'~0l)g.~
~ 8 "'C .- "E $::;
."",oo-o~~
"8 ~ 8..c: ~ .~.E ~""d
o ._ .- ~ .g ..a t:: (l) ~
:;: 0-:" '" <;:: >> ;:l Ol) 0
"E..c:~1-< ::r::ua~
'" ,~::E g,$ . ,,' " 0::
..c:..c: ,,:::; -.D ~ ';:: ~ E
cd ~"9 E 2 O'~ "cd
u..o.... u 0 '""'..c: :>
-5..D .b .~ tJ') :s: 0.. ~ ~
o2r.n~ "~Cro$-o
~~",::E"'2<;::o5~
" "t:; .... ro (l) "I-;:> Q)
(l)~ro~::s;;l=oo(l);;>
=: u 0 u .- "'0 ~ OJ) >
'a 0 U 0 is 0- 0 :;: <= i2
5 --- 5 .... ::l 0 -<= 'S:
-<= 5 " 5 " '", E '" ~ <=
2 '" s '" ,5 ~ '" ~ B .g
.....-<=.",-<=I>.""<;::~~""
00" <J5'
'" '"
'" '"
.... ....
Ol) Ol)
'" '"
" "
rfJ rfJ
-d' .","
~ ~
- -
'" '"
ca ca
- -
'" '"
'" '"
or....; 04-1
U"U"
--.(l)--.Q)
(l) I-< 11> I-<
=: Q) =: Q)
;:j I-< ;:J I-<
.",0.",0
..c:~..c:~
U $-; U I-<
cd co cd cd
(l) It) OJ Q)
~:z:~:z:
ro
N
U
:>
x
'6
c
.
0.
0.
"
..0:
~ U~ '"" rfJ '"" ~ '"" '""~ U
---
'""
f')
"-"
0
('oJ
';;:: .~ Q)
Cl tJ1
'" ro
,~ ~ '"
'" ~ P,
l:: Cl '-
<:l ,~ " ::l "
i: <:l '" ..;:: 2
e '-
.;:a 2 " -
~ " l:: ..
- '- Cl '" ~ '- <:l
<:l ~ " .g .. -<l
~ ;:, - ,~
l:: " l:: iE' ~
Cl <:l <:l Cl <:l "
-<l ..;:: <:l
" <:l "
'" <:l ~
~ ,~ ';;:: '- g l::
1l l:: Cl
'c ~ ~ ..2 '" !
'- " '- '" ..
-
" (3 ~ ::0: G (3
ii: "" Q
....
"
-'<
C>
"
0- " "
.", t: -'<
0 ..!l .... ~ -<= '"
0 'B 0 B '" "
<= 0;:: ....
:;: "' -
0 '" " '" :;: '"
.", C> 0 t: " 0: ....
i2 ,~ '" '" '8
" - Ol) B 0 '"
.", ~ C> '" 'B .", " -<= -<=
j <= a ,5 '" '" - '"
- B " " B 0 "5
C> 0 '" of
0 12 '" u C> E '" 0
C> .", 'C 'C 0: " '" .::: '"
, 0 " " " " Ol) "",- ....
.", .", - Ol) "'3 S 1::
0 5 5 '" "
" ~ ::: '" .... 0 '"
"' ..0:..0: ~ 0 ....l OrfJ ~
'"
~
~ ..;:: l: ~
~ "" :::
.f::l ~ ..!:!
& ~ ... ~
:c: '"
..
..:;
.
N
<.5
:>
x
'6
c
~
o.
o.
<(
M
4-1
o
M
QJ
tJ1
f1l
P<
Florida
Notes:
o This report shows the listed species associated in some way with this state.
o This list does not include experimental populations and simifarity of appearance listings.
o This list includes non-nesting sea turtles and whales in State/Territory coastal waters.
o This list includes species or populations under the sole jurisdiction of the National Marine Fisheries Service.
o Click on the highlighted scientific names below to view a Species Pro fife for each listing.
listings and occurrences for Florida --114 listings
o 109 occurring in Florida
o 5 not occurring in Florida
o 1 species listed in some other state occurring in Florida
Animals -- 59 listings
o 55 occurring in Florida
o 4 not occurring in Florida
o 1 species listed in some other state occurring in Florida
Status
Species listed in this state and that occur in this state
T
Bankclimber, purple (mussel) (EfliQIQirie.usslQiilial1!ds)
E
Bat, gray (M,yQlisgr!s.esCfills)
E
Butterfly, Schaus swallowtail (Heraclides aristodemus oonceanus)
T
Caracara, Audubon's crested FL pop. (Polvborus plancus audubonil)
T
Coral, elkhorn (Acrooora oalmata)
T
Coral, slag horn (Acrooora cervicornis)
T
Crocodile, American FL pop. (Crocori,ylYs acutus)
E
Darter, Okaloosa (Etheostoma okaloosae)
E
Deer, key (Qriocoife.Lisvirginianusclavium)
T
Jay, Florida scrub (Aoheffif.orna cQe.rule.sCells)
E
Kite, Everglade snail FL pop. (Rostrhamus sociabifis olumbeus)
E
Manatee, West Indian (Trichechus mall'1!J/s)
E
Moccasinshell, Gulf (Medionidus oenicillatus)
E
Moccasinshell, Ochlockonee (Medionidus simosonianus)
E
Mouse, Anastasia Island beach (Peromvscus oolionotus chasma)
E
Mouse, Choctawhatchee beach (Peromvscus oolionotuS_'1!lOJIhrys)
E
Mouse, Key Largo cotton (Eeromvscus gossvpinus allaoaticola)
E
Mouse, Perdido Key beach (Peromvscus oolionotus trissvlleosis)
Page 1 of 5
Appendix V.C.2a
T
E
F
T
E
E
E
T
E
E
T
E
E
E
T
E
T
T
T
T
T
T
E
E
E
T
E
T
E
E
E
E
Mouse, southeastern beach (Pe[o[[lJ'scus aolionotusJJiveiventris)
Mouse, St. Andrew beach (PeramJ'scus aolionotus aeninsuliiJI~)
Panther, Florida (PumitL=Felis) eoneolo[cOI)'l)
Pigtoe, oval (Pleurabema avri[or[[l~)
Plover, piping except Great Lakes watershed (Charadrius melodus)
Pocketbook, shinyrayed (Lamasilis subanauliiJtiiJ)
Rabbit, Lower Keys marsh ($y!yjlagus aalustris hefnen)
Rice rat lower FL Keys (QrXzomvs aalustris natll/or)
Salamander, frosted flatwoods (AmbvstomiiJ_cinguliiJtum)
Sawfish, smalltooth (pristis aeetinata)
Sea turtle, green FL, Mexico nesting pops. (9helonia mvdas)
Sea turtle, green except where endangered (Chelonia mvdas)
Sea turtle, hawksbill (Eretmo.chefXs imbrieata)
Sea turtle, Kemp's rid ley (LeaidoeheJys.l<empg)
Sea turtle, leatherback (IJermochelVs coriacea)
Sea turtle, loggerhead (Caretta caretta)
Seal, Caribbean monk (Monaehus trapicalis)
Shrimp, Squirrel Chimney Cave (Palaemonetes cummit]gi)
Skink, bluetail mole (Eumeces_IWLegiusJivjr;1us)
Skink, sand (NeoseRs revnoldsl)
Slabs hell , Chipola (f,/liPtiochiaalaensis)
Snail, Stock Island tree (QrthaliQJ..SJ~sllJ;.{notjncLnesQr;1rXiiJs))
Snake, Atlantic salt marsh (N.eror;1i?clllrJQU?eniata)
Snake, eastern indigo (f)rymarchon eorais couaen)
Sparrow, Cape Sable seaside (Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis)
Sparrow, Florida grasshopper (Ammodramus savannarum f1oridanus)
Slork, wood AL, FL, GA, SC (My,et"ria.JlmeJ~_?'f]a)
Sturgeon, gulf (Aeiaenser oxvrinehus desotOl)
Sturgeon, shortnose (Aeiaenser brevirostrum)
Tern, roseate Western Hemisphere except NE U.S. (Sterna dougall/ir;1QJ1g?1Ii1)
Three-ridge, fat (mussel) (Amblema neis/erh)
Vole, Florida salt marsh (Mieratus aennsv/vanieus dukeeam-fib'2lfl)
Whale, finback (Sa/aenoatera ahvsa/us)
Whale, humpback (MegiiJP.1eriiJ_JlSiVaeanaliae)
Whale, right (8aJa'2nawaci;;.Jis.(incLiIUstr?lis)) Page 2 of 5
Appendix V.C.2a
E
E
Stat!!!>
E
E
E
E
Statll!>
E
Woodpecker, red-cockaded (Picoides borealis)
Woodrat, Key Largo (Neotoma floridana SmiiilfJ)
Species listed in this state that do not occur in this state
Beetle, American burying (Nicroohorus americanus)
Curlew, Eskimo (N(!menl!!', borealis)
Pelican, brown except U.S. Atlantic coast, FL, AL (Pelecanus occidentalis)
Wolf, gray Lower 48 States, except where delisted and where EXPN. Mexico. (9.fiOis luous)
Listed species occurring in this state that are not listed in this state
Wolf, red except where EXPN (Canis rufus)
Plants -- 55 listings
. 54 occurring in Florida
. 1 not occurring in Florida
. 0 species listed in some other state occurring in Florida
Status
E
E
E
E
T
E
T
T
T
E
E
E
E
E
T
E
E
E
E
Species listed in this state and that occur in this state
Aster, Florida golden (9.hQl.SOR.sIsflofiriang)
Beargrass, Britton's (Nolina brittoniana)
Beauty, Harper's (!iEj{R@[Qgalli!i.fla~a)
Bellflower, Brooksville (9.a.IJ1.Ji.aQ!i!aJoQ/Q,J.a@)
Birds-in-a-nest, white (Macbridea alba)
Blazingstar, scrub (Liatris ohlinaerae)
Bonamia, Florida (Bonamia arandiflora)
Buckwheat, scrub (Erioaonum IQJJ.!J.ifo]i.!!fJLYaLg,QliiQh.aIiIQIi(!m)
Butterwort, Godfrey's (Pinauicula ion_aDlha)
Cactus, Key tree (EiloS2J;@[el.!S[QQ;nit)
Campion, fringed CSilenePoIYl2et.a/fJ)
Chaffseed, American (S.cbwalbea americana)
Cladonia, Florida perforate (Cladonia perfora.t.a)
Fringe-tree, pygmy (Chionanthus ovamaeus)
Gooseberry, Miccosukee (Ribes echinelwm)
Gourd, Okeechobee (CU9li.[QltaoKee.chQbeensis sso. okeechobeensis)
Harebells, Avon Park (9.[otfiLiiifla avonensis)
Hypericum, highlands scrub (H.yp.fHicum cumulicola)
Jacquemontia, beach (Jacquemontia reclinata)
Page 3 of 5
Appendix V.C.2a
E
E
f'
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
T
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
T
T
E
E
T
T
E
E
E
E
E
Lead-plant, Crenulate (dmoroha crenu/aliJ)
Lupine, scrub (Luoinu'LiJri,lQlum)
Meadowrue, Cooley's (Thafictrum coo/evl)
Milkpea, Small's (Ga/actia sma/iii)
Mint, Garrett's (Dicerandra chri$tmiMlJi)
Mint, Lakela's (Dicerandr<LtmmaCu/ata)
Mint, longspurred (Dic'll:t!1]<:flar:;Q[nutissima)
Mint, scrub (Dicerandra frutescens)
Mustard, Carter's (War/t<Lcilrterl)
Pawpaw, beautiful (12e_erioSJQlhilmnus ou/chef/us)
Pawpaw, four-petal (!1$imiOillfitmmera)
Pawpaw, Rugel's (DeeringQthilmDJ.ilUuge/iI)
Pigeon wings (QlitQriafrilSJLilJ1$)
Pinkroot, gentian (SoiaefiilSJ~DliilOQirlJ!1i)
Plum, scrub (PWnus geniculata)
Polygala, Lewton's (Polvga/a lewtonil)
Polygala, tiny (EQJY9m'''.miJj/il)
Prickly-apple, fragrant (Cereus erioohorus var. fra9tfjO~)
Rhododendron, Chapman (Rhododendron chapmanil)
Rosemary, Apalachicola (ConradinlUJlilRriJ)
Rosemary, Etonia (Conradina etonia)
Rosemary, short-leaved (QQn.[l'js:tjn.ilR[~yifQlia)
Sandi ace (PQ/ygQnfilfiJmyriQPhyJ/g)
Seagrass, Johnson's (H.iJ/QPhi/gjQhn$Qnil)
Skullcap, Florida (ScJilfiflWiiJJIQLi!:iiJniJ)
Snakeroot (fIyngj!Lm cuneifofium)
Spurge, deltoid (Chamaesvce deltoidea sso. de/toidea)
Spurge, Garber's (ChamiJJ!$vce aarben)
Spurge, telephus (EI.if2h.QrPjgte/fiPhiQi!:i~$)
Torreya, Florida (Torreva tilxifofiil)
Warea, wide-leaf (WiJ[fiiJ.iJmRlfiXtfofia)
Water-willow, Cooley's (Justicia COQ/eYI)
Whitlow-wort, papery (piJronvchia chartacea)
Wireweed (Po/vaonef/a basiramia)
Ziziphus, Florida (Zi?/Phv$cfililtiJ) Page 4 of 5
Appendix V.C.2a
Status
E
Appendix V.C.2a
Species listed in this state that do not occur in this state
Pondberry (Lindera melissifolia)
~\I\IS Endanaered Species Home I EGOS Home I~Qn!1'-Qt EGOS I Privacv I Disclaimer
Page 5 of 5
Appendix V.C.2a
FLORIDA'S ENDANGERED SPECIES,
THREATENED SPECIES, AND SPECIES
OF SPECIAL CONCERN
May 2008
FLORIDA FISH AND WILDLIFE CONSERVATION COMMISSION
Appendix V.C.2a
CONTENTS
PREF ACE.......................................................................................................................... ii
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA
AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN ....1
OFFICIAL LISTS ....................................................................................................... 1
FISH ........ ............ ......................... ........ .......... ......... .......... ............ ......... ......... ............ ... 2
AMPHIBIANS............................................................................................................... 2
REPTILES. ............ ......... ........... ........... ......... ......... ............. ......... ......... ......... ............ ... 2
BIRDS ................... .............. ...... ............ ......... ......... ............................... ......... ............... 3
MAMMALS...................................................................................................................4
INVERTEBRATES ...................................................................................................... 6
CORALS .................................................................................................................... 6
CRUST ACEANS....................................................................................................... 6
INSECTS........... .................................................... .......... .............................. ............ 6
MOLLUSKS .............................................................................................................. 6
KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATIONS........................................................ 7
Appendix V.C.2a
PREFACE
This document consolidates the official state of Florida list of endangered species, threatened
species, and species of special concern. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission (FWC) maintains the state list of animals designated as endangered, threatened, or
species of special concern, in accordance with Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and 68A-27.005,
respectively, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.), https://www.flrules.org/Default.asp. The
state lists of plants, which are designated endangered, threatened, and commercially exploited,
are administered and maintained by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer
Services (DOACS) via Chapter 5B-40, F.A.C. This list of plants can be obtained at
http://www.fl-dof.comlforest management/plant conserve list.html. The federal agencies that
share the authority to list species as Endangered and Threatened are the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration-National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA-NMFS) and U. S. Fish
and Wildlife Service (USFWS). The NOAA-NMFS is responsible for listing most marine
species. The federal list of animals and plants is administered by the USFWS, and this list is
published in 50 CFR 17 (animals) and 50 CFR 23 (plants). Additional information regarding
federal listings can be located at the following websites;
NOAA-NMFS - http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov and
USFWS - http://endangered.fws.gov/wildlife.html#Species.
Please note that while the FWC has published a consolidated list of state and federally listed
species in the past, we now only publish a list of species listed within the state of Florida. This
list will be maintained and available at our agency website: hllP://www.mvfwc.com. Lists of
federally listed species can still be viewed at the USFWS and NOAA-NMFS web sites mentioned
above. It is our intent by providing the list in this manner that we will be able to maintain a
current list that is more readily available to the public.
. Common and scientific names listed first are as they appear in the Florida Administrative Code, Title
68A. Common and/or scientific names following this and located within parentheses ( ) contain names as
used by USFWS, or otber commonly used names.
Bradley J. Gruver, Ph. D
Listed Species Coordina1or
Species Conservation Planning Section
Division of Habita1 and Species Conservation
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Cover Photos by FWC Staff: Key Largo Woodrat, Burrowing Owls, Okaloosa Darter, Schaus' swallowtail butterfly,
Short-tailed Snake.
11
Appendix V.C.2a
NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED,
THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN
STATUS
DESIGNATION FISH AMPHIBIANS REPTILES BIRDS MAMMALS INVERTEBRATES TOTAL
E
T
sse
3
2
10
o
o
5
6
11
7
8
9
18
20
4
6
4
o
4
41
26
50
TOTAL
15
5
24
35
30
8
117
1
Appendix V.C.2a
OFFICIAL LISTS
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
FISH
Atlantic sturgeon Acipenser oxyrinchus SSC (I)
(Gulf sturgeon) (Acipenser oxvrinchus desotoi)
shortnose sturgeon Acipenser brevirostrum E
shoal bass Micropterus cataractae SSC (1,2)
Suwannee bass Micropterus notius sse (1)
rivulus Rivulus marmoratus sse (I)
(mangrove rivulus)
Lake Eustis pupfish Cvvrinodon varie~atus hubbsi sse (])
blackmouth shiner Notrovis melanostomus E
bluenose shiner Pteronotrovis welaka sse (1,2)
saltmarsh topminnow Fundulus ;enkinsi sse (1)
key silverside Menidia concho rum T
crvstal darter Crvstallaria asvrella T
harlequin darter Etheostoma histrio sse (1)
okaloosa darter Etheostoma okalossae E
Southern tessellated darter Etheostoma olmstedi sse (I)
(tessellated iohnnv darter) maculaticevs
key blenny Starksia starck! sse (])
AMPHIBIANS
tlatwoods salamander Ambvstoma cin~ulatum sse
Georgia blind salamander Haideotriton wallacei sse (1,2)
pine barrens treefrog Hvla andersonii sse (])
Florida bog frog Rana okaloosae sse (2)
gopher frog Rana cavito sse (1,2)
REPTILES
American alligator Alligator mississippiensis sse (l,3)
American crocodile Crocodvlus acutus E
key ringneck snake Diadophis punctatus acricus T
Eastern indigo snake Drvmarchon corais couperi T
red rat snake Elaphe gut/ata SSe1(])
Atlantic salt marsh water snake Nerodia clarkii taeniata T
(Atlantic salt marsh snake)
2
Appendix V.C.2a
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
Florida pine snake Pituophis melanoleucus sse (2)
mUf!itus
short-tailed snake Stilosoma extenuatum T
Florida brown snake Storeria dekayi victa T1
rim rock crowned snake Tantilla oolitica T
Florida ribbon snake Thamnophis sauritus sackeni T1
bluetail mole skink Eumeces ewef!ius lividus T
Florida Key mole skink Eumeces ef!ref!ius ef!ref!ius sse (I)
sand skink Neoseps reynoldsi T
gopher tortoise Gooherus oolvohemus T
Barbour's map turtle Graotemvs barbouri sse (1,2)
alligator snapping turtle Macroclemys temminckii sse (I)
striped mud turtle Kinosternon baurii E1
Suwannee cooter Pseudemys concinna sse (1,2)
suwanniensis
loggerhead seaturtle Caretta caretta T
(loggerhead sea turtle)
green seaturtle Chelonia mydas E
(green sea turtle)
leatherback seaturtle Dermochelys coriacea E
(leatherback sea turtle)
hawksbill seaturtle Eretmochelys imbricata E
(hawksbill sea turtle)
Kemp's ridley seaturtle Lepidochelys kempii E
(Kemp's ridley sea turtle)
BIRDS
piping plover Charadrius melodus T
snowy plover Charadrius alexandrinus T
(Cuban snowy plover)
American oystercatcher Haematopus palliatus sse (1,2)
brown pelican Pelecanus occidentalis sse (I)
black skimmer Rynchops nif!er sse (I)
least tern Sterna antillarum T
roseate tern Sterna dougalli T
(Sterna dougallii dougallii)
limpkin Aramus f!.Uarauna sse (I)
reddish egret Ef!retta rufescens SSC (1,4)
snowy egret Ef!retta thula sse (I)
little blue heron Ei!retta caerulea sse (1,4)
tricolored heron Ef!retta tricolor sse (1,4)
3
Appendix V.C.2a
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
white ibis Eudocimus a/bus sse (2)
Florida sandhill crane Crus canadensis vratensis T
whooping crane Crus americana sse (5)
wood stork Mvcteria americana E
roseate spoonbill P/ata/ea aiaia sse (1,4)
burrowing owl Athene cunicu/aria sse (I)
(Florida burrowing own (Athene cunicu/aria tloridana)
crested caracara Caracara cheriway T
(Audubon's crested caracara) (Po/vborus v/ancus audubonii)
peregrine falcon Fa/co veref!rinus E
Southeastern American kestrel Fa/co sparverius oau/us T
osprey Pandion haliaetus sse2 (\,2)
snail kite Rostrhamus sociabilis E
p/umbeus
(Everglades snail kite)
Florida scrub jav Aphe/ocoma coeru/escens T
eape Sable seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus E
mirabilis
Florida grasshopper sparrow Ammodramus savannarum E
tloridanus
Scott's seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (I)
veninsu/ae
Wakulla seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (I)
iuncico/us
white-crowned pigeon Columba /eucocevha/a T
Kirtland's warbler Dendroica kirt/andii E
Bachman's warbler Vermivora bachmanii E
ivory-billed woodpecker Campephilus principalis E
red-cockaded woodpecker Pica ides borealis sse
Marian's marsh wren Cistothorus va/ustris marianae sse (1)
Worthington's marsh wren Cistothorus pa/ustris f!riseus sse (1)
MAMMALS
Florida panther Puma conca/or coryi E
(Puma r ~Felisl conca/or corvi)
Florida black bear Ursus americanus jloridanus T3
Everglades mink Muste/a vison everrdadensis T
key deer Odocoileus virginian us E
clavium
4
Appendix V.C.2a
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
Lower Kevs marsh rabbit Svlvi/azus valustris hiTneri E
Bi{! Cvnress fox souirrel Sciurus ni<Ier avicennia T
Sherman's fox souirrel Sciurus nif!er shermani SSC 0,2)
Eastern chinmunk Tamias striatus SSC (1)
Sanibel Island rice rat Orvzomvs valustris sanibeli SSC (1,2)
silver rice rat Oryzomys argentatus E
(rice rat, lower FL Kevs) (Orvzomvs valustris natator)
Kev Lar{!o woodrat Neotoma floridana smalli E
Key Largo Cotton Mouse Peromyscus gossypinus E
allaDaticola
Choctawhatchee beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
alloDhrvs
Southeastern beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus T
niveiventris
Anastasia Island beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
nhasma
S1. Andrews beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
neninsularis
Perdido Key beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E
trissvllensis
Florida mouse Podomvs floridanus SSC (J)
Florida mastiff bat Eumovs f!laucinus floridanus E
"rav bat Mvotis zrisescens E
Indiana bat Mvotis sodalis E
Florida saltmarsh vole Microtus pennsylvanicus E
(Florida salt marsh vole) dukecampbelli
Sherman's short-tailed shrew Blarina carolonensis SSC (2)
[=brevicauda] shermani
Homosassa shrew Sorex lonzirostris eionis SSC (2)
sei whale BalaenoDtera borealis E
fin whale Balaenoptera physalus E
(finback whale)
North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena glacialis E
(right whale) (Balaena glacialis line!.
australis n
humnback whale Mef!aDtera novaeanf!liae E
snerm whale Phvseter macrocenhalus E
Florida manatee Trichechus manatus latirostris E
(West Indian manatee) (Trichechus manatus)
5
Appendix V.C.2a
Common Name
Scientific Name
Status
INVERTEBRATES
CORALS
pillar coral Dendrof!.Yra cv/indrus E
CRUSTACEANS
Panama eity crayfish Procambarus econjinae sse (I)
(econfina crayfish)
sims sink crayfish Procambarus erythrops sse (I)
(Santa Fe cave crayfish)
black creek cravfish Procambarus victus sse (\)
INSECTS
Miami blue butterfly Cyclargus [=Hermiargus] E
thomasi bethunebakeri
Schaus' swallowtail butterfly Heraclides aristodemus E
vonceanus
MOLLUSKS
Florida tree snail Lizuus fasciatus sse (\)
Stock Island tree snail Ortha/icus reses E
Ortha/icus reses [not incl.
nesodrvas]
6
Appendix V.C.2a
KEY TO ABBREVIA nONS AND NOT A nONS
List Abbreviations
FWC
E=
T~
SSC=
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Endangered
Threatened
Species of Special Concern
Reasons for SSC listings prior to January 1, 2001 are indicated by the number in parenthesis under
the following criteria:
(I) has a significant vulnerability to habitat modification, environmental alteration, human
disturbance, or human exploitation which, in the foreseeable future, may result in its
becoming a threatened species unless appropriate protective or management techniques are
initiated or maintained;
(2) may already meet certain criteria for designation as a threatened species but for which
conclusive data are limited or lacking;
(3) may occupy such an unusually vital or essential ecological niche that should it decline
significantly in numbers or distribution other species would be adversely affected to a
significant degree;
(4) has not sufficiently recovered from past population depletion, and
(5) occurs as a population either intentionally introduced or being experimentally managed to
attain specific objectives, and the species of special concern prohibitions in Rule 68A-
27.002, F.A.C., shall not apply to species so designated, provided that the intentional killing,
attempting to kill, possession or sale of such species is prohibited.
List Notations
Lower keys population only.
2
Monroe County population only.
3
Other than those found in Baker and Columbia Counties or in Apalachicola National Forest.
7
APPENDIX V.C.2b
PANTHER BEAR TELEMETRY MAP
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Panther and Bear Telemetry Map
County Boundaries
o
Major Rivers
Black Bear Telemetry
.
Panther Mortality
.
Panther Telemetry
.
Digital Ortho Quarter Quads
.Red: Band_1
.Green: Band_2
.Blue: Band_3
Wildlife Crossings
Wildlife Observations
.
Black Bear Nuisance - 1980 to
2006
<)
Black Bear Roadkill - 1976 to
2006
.
Copyright FWRI 2008
TRGIS_Service
Daniel Kiermaier
.0
C\I
.
()
.
>
><
-
o
z
UJ
a.
a.
<(
APPENDIX V.C.3a
COUNTY HISTORIC AND/OR
ARCHEOLOGICAL SITES
FIFTY - MILE BEND QUADRANGLE
AREAS OF HISTORICAL! ARCHAEOLOGICAL PROBABILITY
@
RNG 33 I RNG 34
11 12 7
CR~Ol
~""
L CR496
~~
14 13 18
V.S.41 TAlaAMlTRAJL
CRficee
8
9
10
11
12
DADE-CO
1'RANSlTIONJ.NllTlWNINGAIIIPORT
17
16 I
-~ "
i
15
PRO
14
o SED S
13
E
23 CRee? 24 19 20 21 23 24
.
=.. CR1U.
CRIe7. . CRIB<.
CRI"" .CIl170
26 25 30 29 28 27 25
35
36
31
32
33
CRt"".
CRIB"_
34
35
='.
COlliER CO
-~~._------
TWP 53
TWP 54
MONROE CO
.0:
I'l
~
.0:
z
~
E-<
.0:
I'l
~
U
I'l
ro ~
C']
CJ. ~
~
> H
A H
SR84 0
0 y
1- z
I'l I'l
P, 0
p, .0:
.0: 0
~
I INDICATES AREAS OF HISTORICAL/ARCHAEOLOGICAL PR08ABILlTY
. INDICATES HISTORIC STRUCTURE (NOT TO SCALE)
. INDICATES ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE (NOT TO SCAlE)
~II\DICATESHISTORICDISTRICT
~PREVIOUSLvSURVEYEDAREA
C~r County
~
PREPARED BY: GIS!CAD t.lAPPING SECT10N
CO~MUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION
FILE: MAP 36 - fIFTYMIL_OWG 2/22/93
xxxx.xxxxxx PREVIOUSLY SURVEYED ROAD
NOTTOSCilLE
APPENDIX V.C.3b
FLORIDA MASTER SITE FILE
RESPONSE
~y.
MILLER ., LEGG
Facsimile
IDa~
Nl,lmber 01 plIgQ:
(including cover)
;l
I
3120/2009
TIme: 3:19 PM
Frqm: Mark Clark To: Florida Master Site File- TRS Search
r.c .'.
.F . (954) 436-8664 Company: Division of Historic Resources
'ax:
.
'PrQ~" TNT Park 'fax: ".
N!I.m~ (850) 245-6439
~~ 09-1JOO63 Phone:
!!!~m~: ..
~itu: .....
ce:
0 Urgent 0 For your review Fax'
181 Reply ASAP 0 Please comment !lC:
-
0 0 .' .
Will mail original As requested Fax'
cOnIn1eiiii.: .
, .
Please see the attached request for a Florida Master Site File - TRS Search.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call.
Thanks,
Mark
I~ All IJtI: This infotmatlon Is 1_ solely for the Pfitsonlentily 10 >'!/10m it Is addrs!ss.ed and may
coiJtaJn "'-'1gSS that am P!fvIIsgtMi and con1Id9nt/al. Any cl/sl;lmlinatlon or copying of lhli(lntwmatlon by
unau/hori7>>d pmsons Is sliicIIy prohlbitsd. "you _lhIsfllx In error, p.".".le#IJp/IoniJ. (!I54}_7lIOO.
IMP R 0 V I Nee 0 M M U NIT I E S. eRE A TIN C E N V I RON MEN T S.
South Rorida 0IIice: 1800 N DousIas Road . Suite 200 . Pembrolce Pines, Aorida . 33024-3200
(954)436-7000' Fax: (954)436-8664
www.millerleg.com
Page 1 of 6
Appendix V.C.3b
2
jg
en
'0
....
c:
Ql
E
1::
ra
a.
Ql
Cl
ra
""0
'C
o
u::
ul
~
::3
o
III
Ql
0:::
iii
(J
'C
o
]2
J:
-
o
c:
o
'ijj
'>
is
Ql
.c
....
'0
c~
0::3
._ III
1ilQl
~o:::
Ql""O
III c:
Ql ra
~....
Q.1Il
(J Ql
.- ::3
~O'
~Q)
.- 0:::
J:.c
o~
::3 ra
ra Ql
Qlen
:;~
lXliI
'Ql
lIJ:!:::=
Men
. ....
~2
>:3
.~~
""Ora
C""O
Ql.c:
0.0
0._
<(u.
~Florida
fSite.
File'
Florida Master Site File- TRS Search
Pleliminary Investigation of Previously Recorded Cultural Resources
To request a search for previously recorded cultural rcsourcc:s, fill in the TOWDJIaip
(circle North or South). Range (citde East or West), & Section number(s) of your
project area and fax 10 15O-14S-643'. Also include a photocopy of the appropriate USGS
qUlld DIlIp with your project area clemiy marked.
r....II.fII'" (North wS: 5" ~ ? II...,. Qor Weal): "> 0./ €.
SedIoII (include a1laffec:led): I (p) I S I I '-I I 1:3 I 'i' I I t) I
III 1"Z.-
T.._.", (North 01' SouIb): ----' II.",. (East 01' War): _,
SedloD (include aU affected):
To_.lp (North 01' SouIh): _'
SccCiolI (lad" all affetled):
IIGlfe (East or West): _,
T......."", (North or SouIh):---,
S<<tIoII (include all affec:led):
..,.(East", West):_.
r.._.ip (North or Soudt): ----'
"Ie (East or West): _'
SftIItHo (include all affectocl):
(Searches generating more than 10 pages of material will be returned by US mail)
Return To: NAME:. /11 a.,.A. ~ I... ./,;L
ORGANIZATION: .11e-< J...e"j'l
DATE: :1 I z,o I z-009
FAX.: ('1S'O'"/3/r'l(,~<I
PHONE#l: ('l!)'() '1"34>- "7000
ADDRESS:
7 fJ'oc> /tJ.. P"'Vj /" $ /lc>",~tJ, S""U Z.oo
.P~-"" Io/'D~<Z P.'.....P % ~<- 330z- 't
P:\FSFIDOCSIMOMIMOM_DOCSITRSREQUEST.DOC
Page 2 of 6
I
Appendix V.C.3b
Q)
...
.l!l
Il)
'0
...
<::
Q)
E
t::
III
a.
Q)
Cl
III
"0
.;::
o
u::
V>
~
:J
o
V>
Q)
c::
~
.;::
.s
V>
:c
'0
<::
o
'(ij
'S;
Ci
Q)
.r::
...
-
o V>
<:::1:
.Q 1il
"'Q)
~c::
Q)"O
V> <::
Q) III
~
a.1ii
u Q)
.- :J
~ 0-
o Q)
1ii
.- c::
J:.r::
15l:?
:J III
III Q)
Q)1l)
~ Q)
:J_
OOU:
'Q)
al.~
Mil)
. ~
~.l!l
>gj
.15 ~
"OlIl
<::"0
Q).-
o.~
0.0
<ell..
Send To Printer
Change to Landscape
......
.........-=--......
lfo- _ ___ _.alJ.
-~- ---.-
...%":~. . -- -
~~......_-.- -- --
r __ ._--
...... -# I-9&---
..'1 - ':;" -~-::.-~ ...
~.,." , -.....--
"s '......... ___
+-.,'-tli----4!-4!"-J -- ----. ----
~.-: -'---:;.....- :~, - -- .... ':f----- -..-
~' -..... __ - - ... . --- __ - I ... ~.......
... ..... -. ".,. __ - ..... -""1 ....... -- --
... --.~...,,_-- __--~ ~ - --- -1. -- -:;;.- --
~ - __ . .. - .",...- ... J.-.j""- - - _ -
..4--"";:111- ----=- . ---~ i--------- ..
- - - - ........... ..... ...... ! -- - .......- - - -
...........~ ~ -fill- -- -...g. - ~ ~ _, ~ ---...... -.......
~ - - -- .... /. _ -- ---41 - - - - - __
_' - ............ _ ......... - ~':4l!- __............... ..... - -. ....... - -*--
~ -.... .....- ~-----..... - - -.1.... -- _ -.....-:-_ ..
.. 'tJ.1oo- .,-"" -.:"" -4.----- -- -_ ... _"":...1 -- \ ~raJt- :.... --
r:/ '2Km 0' '1M
Image courtesy of the U.S. Geological Survey
@ 2004 Microsoft Corporation, Terms of Use Privacy Statement
Q_ f'~:tc-.t" L ..~+..o""
-
http://terraserver-usa.comIPrintImage.aspx7T=2&S=14&Z=17&X=159& Y =893&W=1&q... 3120/2009
Page 3 of 6
I
Appendix V.C.3b
.l!l
tu
-
C/)
'0
-
c
Q)
E
t
tu
a.
Q)
o
tu
"
';::
o
u..
ui
~
:l
o
Ul
Q)
a::
(ij
o
';::
o
~
J:
'0
c
o
'00
'S:
is
Q)
.c
-
'0
c::t::
o :l
,_ t/)
-Q)
~a::
Q)"
t/) C
Q) tu
~
ll.'li)
o Q)
,- :l
~ 0'
,gQ)
.!!.! a::
J:.c
15e
:l tu
tu Q)
Q)C/)
~ Q)
:l_
cali:
'Q)
ca:.:
c<iC/)
, ~
~.l!l
>gj
.1$ ::?:
"tu
c"
Q),-
a.~
a..2
~u..
'''''~ -... ............... ........-....
Florida Master Site File
Oivtsion of HistDricaI Resources / RA. Gray BUildlng
500 South Bronough St" T.lahasne, Florida 32399-02.50
Phone (850) 245-M40 / Fax (850)245-&139/ Email sitefilfllfIldos.state.n.U$
FAX Cover Page
To: (Fax Number)6.\.. ~.~.~
Date
.2...J1dJ 2.Cn')
Pages ~ (including this sheet)
Please deliver these pages to:
I
~8r~
Name:
Organization:
.M.,t"Utz.r ~
Sender Name:
'Enn.M %ai~
Message:
In case of a problem with any portion of this transmission, please call (850) 245-6440
500 S. BroDoDCIl Street . T.IIa~_ FL 3V!I!I-0256 . http://www.Oboritalle..oom
00_.0_ O_oJopcollluooafth ..1u.1Gd<.....cno...... c__
(lI5O)2_.PAJ<,=-- (8SO)2<S-<I#f'P~~ (lI5O)~'PAX,~7 (lI5O).?4s.6400'PAX__
Page 4 of 6
Appendix V.C.3b
<Ii
~
::J
o
'"
Q)
a:
rl
';::
.s
.!!l
J:
'15
I:
o
'w
'>
is
Q)
~
-
.....
0",
1:""
.2 ~
-Q)
~a:
Q)'O
'" I:
Q) ell
~-
0..",
o Q)
.;:: g
~Q)
.- a:
J:~
152
::J ell
ell Q)
Q)CJ)
5~
lDU::
o Q)
aJ:t:::
'CJ)
~~
~~
>gj
.~:::'i!
'0 ell
1:'0
Q).-
o.~
0..2
<{u..
r""""....._~.;J ~'.Ll
r ,0;.0'::;'
, ." . " , " . r"
:... ."".. re....nh....n.II... ~. ~nfo~t..........~~ ~l)'::.~ .1I~"_ Co...~~!iI,.:
:, proj.ot.reYI_.. ThIa ~ 'o!I1)' tcIMt.1f1iie),~o""--!",~,,,,:at,""iI'IorIIle.M :~llr:
8.18 'FI.. and....... !!!.Rr ~.. ....~:.lipii~..~ ~ tho ...1VIa..... of H1~ ~.:.~.. $
Re80U_ eo....ot ~ Compl.... ..... ReVIew '!IJeotIon of the ...._. of H....,... .l!!
......_ at al!''' 'Ut' 11333 for. ~J":oI _ ...r..nnatlon.. . . C/)
'0
Man:h 23, 2009
Mark Clark
Miller Legg
1800 N Douglas Rd., Ste. 200
Pcmbfoke Pines, FL 33024
Fax;9S4-436-8664
iFlOrida
Master
. Site.
File
In response to your inquiry of March 20. 2009, the Florida Master Site File Iis1s one previously recorded
archaeological site and no standing strucl.Urcs in the following parcels of Collier County:
T53S, R34E, SectiOD' 9. 10, 11, t:Z, 13, 14. 15, and 16
When interpreting the results of our search, please consider the folIowing information:
. Thls .earell lI1'etllDay contalD UlU'eCo.tU4 arcbaeoIogicallites, hlstorleal struc:tores
or other resources ""en if previously 8urveyed tor ClIIturaI reaourees.
. Because vandaIi8ID and looting are commOD at Florida 8ltes, we ask that you limit
the dIatribatfOD of location informatloD OD archaeological 8ites.
. WhDe mllDY of our records document historically sitlnificaDt resources, the
doCumentatioD of a resource at the Florida Master Site FDe does Dot D_ariIy
mean tile reaoun:e is hlstoricaDy slplftcaDt.
. Federal, state and local laws require formal environmental review for most
projeeta. ThIs search DOES NOT CODlldtDte ..dla nview. If your project ,.lls
ander these laws, you should CODtaCt the ClIJDpUaDI!t: a.d Review SectioD of the
DIvision of Historical Raolll'l!es at 850-245-6333.
Please do not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions regarding the results of this search.
Sincerely,
~~~8
EriD MidleDe BaUey
Archaeological Data Analyst
Florida Master Site File
500 South Bronough Street . Tallah....... FL 32399-0250 . www.f1horitlllle.comlpreservationlsitefile
850-245-6440 ph I 850-245-6439 fax I SlteFlIe@dos.state.fI.us
Page 5 of 6
Appendix V.C.3b
-
<:
CD
E
t:
ell
a.
CD
o
ell
"C
.t:
o
u:
rJi
CD
o
~
"
o
'"
CD
C!:
m
o
.t:
B
'"
J:
'0
<:
o
'w
'S:
is
CD
.<;;
-
'0
<:"""
.2 iil
-CD
~C!:
CD"C
'" <:
CD ell
~-
C-'"
o CD
.- "
~ 0
BCD
.!11C!:
:1:.<;;
o~
" ell
ell Q)
Q)C/)
5~
cou::
, Q)
aJ~
c>:iC/)
. ~
(,)$
'",
> ell
.i!S::;j;
"Cell
<:"C
Q).-
a.~
a...Q
<(lJ..
,,10.,)
'-Ir'I~~":'...J~":'ll:.IC.lj r;.>O'.i.f
.l!l
, .!!! .0
I , en
, I '"
, '0
, . II
, :
, - >
, i c
,
, Q) X
i ,
, E'6
,
, , 1:: c
, I
i ~ I al Cll
0."-
' 1 Q) "-
! , o<C
I I al
' 0 ~ "0
I : iC
, , ,. \D ';::
I IIIl'lI.1 0
' I .. """ u::
I 1..61
J I i ~ 0 <Ii
o I ~
o 0
o ~" \D 2l
I ! ao; ~
! QJ OJ
tJ1 0
, ro III
0 1 p, Q)
0 0::
0
,
Ii'll Iii
wi <)
';::
I g i ~
I i ~ :I:
: I "l '0
111 I" c
o . ..
~ I ,- 0
'.
I~'''' 'w
C.~l~ 'S;
VI~I'" is
I::;: Q)
I , .c
~!il -
'0
.l!l
~ i ! c-
o OJ
u, , ,_ III
o ,
: I mQ)
I ! ;::0::
Q)"O
i I! III c
Q) al
~-
' I [l.<Jl
1 I <) Q)
I ~ , ';:: OJ
i;;i~ i 01iJ
' ,~ :! ~o::
' '" :I:.c
o i ~ i o~
1 il!i ~
! , ~ OJ al
~ <ll Q)
, I B . Q)en
! I =l ~ Q)
1!11l! ..~ OJ=
_M COu.
I I~ 5::i , Q)
,~..... ~ '0 aJ~
M
l'fl~ ::s 'en
l'"'!~ '00 C':!~
I I.... Z!:: C,).l!l
3::1 '<Jl
III~ ~, > al
OM
, I ~ . ,~ :2
I I ~ . o.
. "Oal
lei: :;1 C"O
. TOTAL P.133 Q),-
1~la ~~ a....
II'"" 1 a ";: 0.0
1u'J1ff ~.. <(u.
I
APPENDIX V.D.I
AREA OF CRITICAL STATE
CONCERN (ACSC) MAP
=
N
~
=
N
=
=
N
=
~
=
~
!
1
!
!
I
!
II
'.
I,
!~
l
.._m._-t
1
=
~
N
=
~
~
=
i
,
1
i
i
,
!
,
,
!
/
/
/
~
~
"'."
5 E!i 1
APPENDIX V.D.1 ACSC
T 52 5
T 51 S
T 50 S
T 48 S
T 49 5
a:J'1X9)'l
fa
fln:J
,
i
r-----~
~~.........
"
~-,t-i------
.. ".,.
f .
,l' -
.'
..-
"...........
"
~ c.,
" ~
c
,-,
~
\
I
VI>
~~>
'-i>:<>
mom
1""\"">
OI""\::E
Z:<>=i
h13;!;
:<>I""\Z
Z>
r-
,
<
,
,
I.
I ~
I;
11
~~
!~
Ii
-'i
~
5 Z!i 1
! . !jl '1' ,
:-~ C'F ,
" , T' ,
! 'i'"
ig , ~ ~ ~
, ~.;: , r ~ ~
, " 1 , 1 , " 1
, l1II ~ CJ ::1_ _Ill
0 m
~ ,',.. 0 ~
> .' ~ ffi
z
0 .., ~ ~
, ~ .
0 ~
m ~
.
~ ~
~
~
, .. 1
T 47 S
~ ~
~ n ~
)00010
lllEz!il
p~"
",g2!~
~~h
~g~
~~~!ll
g:;;1iS
,."'".
~~!~
'"=::1;0.
~~~~
-<i!?"
~ c 1>
, ~
I~
iCE....,.
! S'lv<< ,.
'!.jliii".",; n
. ~ . ~ ~,:-,; ~
~ j - c.
...
~~
~.~
EliI--I.ill
~ ~!ih i ~~
- ~. ~': ~ 1" -:!!
ii~~~ i ~~
:ilm~~~~gC!
~ ~H ~ ;c~
~ ! ~
. ~
,
~
...
IE:] l_an;1
! ~~ ~n~ f,~ ~ ~
~'~:.' ~"~' Q- '
;,~~~~~~
~~ ~~ ~5
5 81>' 1
5 LV 1
T 46 S
=
...
c:
-l
c:
::u
om
t-r-8
o)l.GI:ICI
g Z ~
iClN
on 9
~c:cn
5:fn
om
N
=
iI:
~
."
=
N
~
=
N
=
=
N
=
=
~
Q
=
~~~ --;1 ~
>
~,z
!~
",5
~:~
:~
=
~
N
L.. i~ ...
B,~~~~~~
iWi:'
=
~
~
=
~
~
APPENDIX V.D.Sb
DATA AND ANALYSIS FOR THE
PROPOSED USES
County Petition No. CP-2009-1
Dade -Collier Cvoress Recreation Area District
Aooendix V.D.5b
V. REQUIRED INFORMATION
D. GROWTH MANAGEMENT
5.b. Yes. The proposed land use district known as the Dade-Collier Cypress
Recreation Area District will create an increase in intensity of the subject area
which is approximately 1,608 acres. This area is currently owned by Miami-Dade
County and is managed by the Aviation Department. The area proposed for
amendment is part of a larger parcel of land (Parcel #: 01233520000) that is
known as the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport or "TNT".
Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department ('the Department'). is
currently developing, with State Department of Agriculture, Division of Forestry
funding from the T. Mark Schmidt OHV Recreation Grant Program, a plan for off-
highway vehicles (OHV) to use trails on the property. This plan is part of a State
initiative to address a deficiency in outdoor recreational areas suitable for safe
OHV use. In particular, the State is seeking a location proximate to Miami/South
Florida where such use can take place without impacting dense urban areas. To
this end, the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department did a
comprehensive feasibility study in August of 2007 to determine the most
appropriate and beneficial location considering all feasible sites within Miami-
Dade County considering (14) fourteen criterion: see Appendix V.D.5b.l - Off-
Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study for a copy of this study. Of the (20+)
twenty plus sites considered in the study, this site was considered 'the most viable
long-term option'. Collier County has similarly investigated appropriate sites
located on Conservation Lands that can support the type of OHV use
considered in this Application; see Appendix V.D.5b.2 - Collier County Park and
Recreation Department Letter.
The type of Off-highway Vehicles (OHV) to be allowed in this Recreation Area will
be pursuant to the Florida State Statute, Section 261.03(6) and 261.20, Definition,
"Off-highway vehicle", and includes any ATV, two-rider All-terrain Vehicle (ATV) ,
or Off-highway motorcycle (OHM) that is used off the roads or highways of this
state and that is not registered and licensed for highway use under Chapter 320;
see Appendix V.D.5b.3 - F.S. 260.03, Detinition of OHV. Florida State Statute
261.20 states that: "Operations of off-highway vehicles on public lands;
restrictions; safety courses; required equipment; prohibited acts; penalties. (2)
Any person operating an off-highway vehicle as permitted in this section who
has not attained 16 years of age must be supervised by an adult while operating
the off-highway vehicle. (4) (a) The department shall approve all off-highway
vehicle public safety-education programs required by this chapter as a
condition for operating on public lands."
The Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department seeks to transition this
subject area closer to its natural state. This includes reducing the current impact
of unregulated off-highway vehicle use and eliminating sport hunting throughout
Appendix V.D.5b
1 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
the subject area: see Appendix V.D.5b.4 - Existing Trails. The Department has the
resources to regulate and improve the area by stabilizing certain existing trails
system so that off-highway vehicles do not further destroy this area. Once this
recreational area is fully managed, it can serve as a regional resource for the
residents of South Florida and its visitors.
The Benefits:
The proposed Recreation Area Project will provide conservation and recreation
area for residents of both Miami-Dade and Collier Counties, specifically, the
benefits and intentions of this proposed project include:
1. Transition a portion of the TNT Jetport property back to an
environmental state that enhances the existing and intact natural
resources while still retaining an appropriate level of recreational use.
2. Secondarily. the transition of this property would serve as a buffer
between existing uses of the runway to the north and the existing
Tamiami Trail to the south.
3. Create a partnership between Miami-Dade County and Collier County
Park and Recreation agencies to create additional park land for
respective growing urban populations and support recreational uses
not always permissible within urban environments.
4. Introduce into the area a diversity of recreational uses, all suited to the
type of natural environments found on the property without
compromising biological systems that are presently in place.
5. Preserve intact natural areas that support and enhance the Big Cypress
Area of Critical State Concern/Special Treatment area and its policies.
6. Identify opportunities for mitigation and restoration of select areas of
the site previously impacted by runway development.
7. Introduce adaptive resource management to promote better
consistency with natural cycles such that only certain areas of the
property were completely open to use and time and location closures
would insure the protection of sensitive areas.
The Intent and Use:
The planning approach involves creating an outdoor recreation area that
balances the preservation of natural resources, such as the intact cypress heads,
tree islands, and wet prairies. with recreational destinations and amenities and
connecting them through trails for hiking. mountain biking and riding OHVs (Off-
Highway Vehicles). Due to the swampy characteristics of the site, trails are
necessary to allow the public to pass near the natural attractions, such as, lakes,
cypress heads, and tree islands.
. Existing trails that adversely impact intact and sensitive natural areas will
be removed and the area restored back to original conditions.
. Existing trails located on previously disturbed filled pads, around lakes or
aligned on existing swamp buggy trails that do not adversely impact
natural areas, will in some cases be retained.
Appendix VD.5b
2 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
. Existing trails that now interrupt sheet flow will be modified and stabilized in
a manner more consistent with the topography and sheet flow of the
natural area.
Trails will be buffered from sensitive natural areas to allow walkers, bikers,
birdwatchers, mountain bikers, and OHV riders a view without degrading the
natural resources. This will also involve buffering trail use between OHV and non-
OHV users by limiting the intersection in which the two trail types intersect and
distancing OHV trails from non-OHV trails where possible.
The proposed archery range will not be a fully cleared range A release to target
type of archery combined with trailed will be employed which will have only
selective clearing and minimal impact on the natural environs. These will be
'trued' during the final design to minimize impacts. Further details in the types of
buffering will be determined in the parks management program established
during the site planning process.
The proposed area is 1,608 acres and will allow for designated trails throughout
the subject area. A Visitor's Center building, approximately 2,200-2,400 square
feet. is planned which will include an administrative area (small office
room), orientation/education area, restrooms, electrical and a small meeting
room [with media capability for training/orientation purposes). The parking for
the facility may include a hard surface or paved with enough space for 80 cars
and trucks with trailers; see Appendix V.D.5b.5- Conceptual Plan.
Table 1-A: The following table delineates the existing and proposed uses, and
f
reauencv:
Activity Existing Total Proposed Associated % of Site
Annual Total Annual Acreage
Visitation Visitation
Primitive Comping 30 900 3-10 0.1
Recreational Vehicle 0 1,000 5-10 0.1
Camping
Fishing 10 2,000 100-300 6.0-18.0
Hiking/Bicycli ng/Wildlife 300 6,000 30-45 2.0-3.0
Viewing
Off-Highway Vehicle 150 3,000 5-15 0.1
(OHV)
Archery 10 900 2-10 0.1
Other Conservation Uses 0 500 1218-1463 79.0-92.0
Total 500 14,300 1608 100.0
Appendix V.D.5b
3 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
Note:
1. At present, the site is generally not open to the public, except for
gladesmen who operate unpermitted legacy campsites within the
property, OHV riders who trespass on the property and permitted Eco-
Adventure tours operated by the Miami-Dade Park and Recreation
Department.
2. Seasonal and location closures will limit the time and type of public
visitations to the proposed Recreation Area.
3. The maximum annual uses for OHV visitation will be limited by the number
of users and the frequency of their use via a permit system, not unlike
what the National Park Service uses for the Big Cypress National Preserve.
T bl 1 B Th f II
t bl d I'
t th
'f
d
d t'l t
a e - e 0 OWlnq.a e e Inea es e eXls In :l an propose ral svs em:
Activity Approximate Approximate Description
Existing Trail Proposed
Length (miles) Trail Length
{miles}
Hiking/Bicycling/ 27 10 Reduction in si2e and length of
Wildlife Trials existing trails to establish lightly
stabilized connections to
destinations and key natural
areas
Off-Highway 22 15 Reduction in size and length of
Vehicle Trails existing trails to establish
sta bili2ed routs that avoid
sensitive areas
Surrounding land use is all designated as Conservation and is entirely consistent
with proposed use of the subject site. Except for Aviation and Native American
tribal uses, many of the proposed uses already take place on adjacent lands.
~ Campina. Legacy camping from hunters and "Gladesmen" occurs
throughout the area. It takes the form of primitive camp areas and
formal developed mobile homes campsites. All date back to the
1950's, prior to land use regulations and permitting. There are similar
camp areas throughout the area, on both the National Park Service
(NPS), and Tribal areas. No adverse impacts on surrounding lands are
expected by an increase of camping activities.
~ Fishina. There are five lakes on the subject site and even more in the
surrounding NPS, South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD),
Tribal and private areas. All were created as borrow pits during the
construction of the Jetport. At present, the lakes on the subject site
are minimally managed and used. No adverse impacts on
surrounding lands are expected by an increase of fishing activities.
~ Hikina, bicvclina and wildlife viewina. Hiking, bicycling and wildlife
viewing within the subject site and on adjacent land is very minimal. It
is largely confined to occasional Eco-Adventure tours sponsored by
the Miami-Dade Park and Recreation Department and involving local
Appendix V.D.5b
4 of 14
Revised 7.1 0.09
residents only. No adverse impacts on surrounding lands are expected
by an increase of hiking. bicycling or wildlife viewing activities.
>- OHV. OHV use is currently authorized on adjacent NPS and Miami-
Dade County lands. At present, Big Cypress National Preserve
authorizes approximately 2,000 OHV permits to access and use NPS
property. No counts of annual visitation are provided by staff, but prior
year projections indicate that total annual user occasions exceed
20,000 during times the Preserve is open, on the over 400 miles of
designated roads and trails plus accessible waterways (2009 Big
Cypress National Preserve, Off-Road Vehicle Management Plan,
Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement). Additionally, the
County permits an unregulated number of OHV to access the property
year round for hunting and legacy camp purposes, with the majority
occurring off the subject site. No quantitative number of vehicles is
known since there is no requirement for permitting or inspection.
Proposed use of the subject site will limit OHV use to ATV and
motocross vehicles, thereby reducing the length of trails, areas of
impact and types of vehicles that now access the property. Although
there is an expected increase in the numbers of vehicles to the subject
site, an adaptive Management Program and the stabilization of trails
will reduce overall adverse impacts and serve to improve the overall
resource values of the property. It is further expected that the
numbers of Miami-Dade and Collier County accidents, deaths,
wildfires and resource damage caused by unrestricted use in these
areas will also be reduced. Moreover, since the Management
Program will be developed in coordination with Big Cypress National
Preserve, it may serve to reduce some of the present use on their lands
since this property under consideration shares an entry access road
with the adjacent Park use. No adverse impacts on surrounding lands
are expected by an increase of OHV activities.
>- Archery. Archery in the form of permitted hunting already takes
place on this and surrounding lands. No adverse impacts on
surrounding lands are expected by an increase of archery range
activities.
>- Other Conservation Uses. Other conservation uses in the form of
photography, scientific studies and game population management by
the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC), already
take place on this site and surrounding areas. No adverse impacts on
surrounding lands are expected by an increase of other conservation
uses.
The subject site will operate on a seasonal basis, effectively closing or limiting
operation during peak wet season and during the peak dry season. This will take
place to eliminate access to sensitive areas, limit adverse impacts to fragile soils
or limit the advent of wildfires. The anticipated annual visitation for each activity
is note in Table 1 A above. The peak usage seasonally is noted in Table Ie
below:
Appendix V.D.5b
5 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
Table lC - Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Proiected Fre uencv of Use
IAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AVa SPT OCT NOV DEC
Projected Peak X X X X X X
Attendance
Season
Projected Low X X X X
Attendance
Season
Projected Lowest X X
Attendance
Season (Largely
Closed) .
Peak Season 25 25 25 25 25 25
Weekdays - % at
Monthlv Total
Peak Season 75 75 75 75 75 75
Weekends - % of
Monthly Total
Low Season 50 50 50 NA NA 50
Weekdays - % of
Monthlv Total
Low Season 50 50 50 NA NA 50
Weekends - % of
Monthlv Total
% of Total 75 75 75 50 50 50 NA NA 50 75 75 75
Monthly Trips by
Time of Dav - AM
% oITotal 25 25 25 50 50 50 NA NA 50 25 25 25
Monthly Trips by
Time of Dav - PM
The Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department is committed to
reducing any adverse impacts caused by trail riders who may stray from the
stabilized trail. This effort will be addressed in the management plan during the
site planning process.
Every effort will be made to appropriately locate trails such that resources are
protected and visitor's experiences are not diminished. Where trails are close or
intersect, OHV riders will be required to maintain slow speeds that will reduce
noise and collisions. For much of the site, however, an appropriate separation
will be used to establish the trail system using best management practices
available from publications. The Department will be guided by national best
management practices as established in "Management Guidelines for OHV
Recreation" and "Park Guidelines for OHVs" both from the National Off-Highway
Vehicle Conservation Council (NOHVCC)".
Appendix V.D.5b
6 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
Currently, the proposed improvements and associated impacts are illustrated on
a conceptual diagram that is intended for illustrative purposes only and does not
represent a final site plan. A comprehensive analysis during site plan
development will also consider criteria associated with the intended experience
of the visitor to provide recreational OHV users with access and to avoid or
minimize visual impacts, safety ha20rds, and conflicts with other types of visitors
to the recreation area. A site specific analysis utilizing geographic information
system technologies and ground-truthing will be used to refine the
environmentally suitable locations for on site improvements and appropriate
routing for trails based upon existing trails and direct development to areas of
suitable substrate and maximize use of existing disturbed areas.
Subsequent to the Growth Management Plan Amendment, [GMPAj, and prior to
any development of the site, the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation
Department will complete an environmental analysis as part of an area
management plan along with a detailed parks plan. These plans will offer the
opportunity for both Miami-Dade and Collier Counties to partner with State and
Federal agencies to create and implement a comprehensive management plan
that will be a benefit for the natural environs, users and the public.
The proposed Resource Management Plan will include:
1. Enhance and improve intact natural resources by providing site
planning and resource management that governs use in manner that
protects water, soil, vegetation and wildlife resources.
2. Manage and balance recreational uses to eliminate trespassing on
the property, unregulated access and camping, eliminate hunting
within the site and establish appropriate locations and carrying
capacities for all uses.
3. Create a visitor experience that allows exploration and understanding
of the scenic and recreational value of the site without compromising
resource or public safety.
4. The County will work to prepare a Management Plan that establishes
policies and practices that are complimentary and supportive of the
Big Cypress National Park [BCNP) Management Plan and the Off-Road
Vehicle [ORV) Management Plan.
5. Institute management practices that improve certain areas (lakes) to
improve their biological diversity and improve the trail system by
closing, relocating and stabilizing certain trails to reduce the number
of trails, avoid sensitive areas and reduce access points.
Supporting Documents, pursuant to 9J-l1.006 Submittal Requirements for
Proposed Local Government Comprehensive Plan Amendments, F.A.C.: See
Appendices V .8, 1 - Existing - Future Land Use Map (FLUM), IV,D, 1 Future Land Use
Map (FLUM), V,D,5b.4 - Existing Trails, V.A.l - Location Map.
Supportina Data and Analysis:
Pursuant to 9J-11.007 Data and Analysis Requirements for proposed Local
Government Comprehensive Plan Amendments: The proposed future land use
Appendix V.D.5b
7 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
designation is based on the increasing demand trom the citizens of Miami-Dade
and Collier Counties for additional recreational uses. The Miami-Dade County
Park and Recreation Department has received multiple requests from citi2ens
and local community organizations for outdoor recreational uses that includes
fishing. archery, bird watching, mountain biking, hiking, camping and off-
highway vehicle use. This is an excellent opportunity for Miami-Dade County to
provide its citizens with these types of uses that the State has already
demonstrated and reported to be deficient within the region; see Appendix
V.D.5b.6 - SCORP. The State Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan [SCORP).
as provided by the Department of Environmental Protection, Division of
Recreation and Parks, clearly shows a lack of motorized trails in the South Florida
region. The subject area for the proposed amendment is within Collier County;
however, it is adjacent to the Miami-Dade County boundaries and offers an
opportunity to serve the residents of both jurisdictions due to its strategic
location. There are approximately 54,000 OHV's registered within 100 miles of the
subject area. The following website, htto://www.floridaohv.ora/ohvlocations.html.
provides the location for OHV activity sites. According to this site, the Big Cypress
National Preserve is the only public site in the South Florida area that provides an
opportunity for OHV's. Due to the continuing demand from citizens in and
around the area, an additional area for OHV's other than the Big Cypress
Preserve is necessary. This demand is demonstrated as such through emails and
phone calls as provided in Appendix V.D.5b.7 - Public Inquiries. It should also be
noted that both Lee and Hendry Counties were awarded the T. Mark Schmidt
OHV Grant Program funding, yet were unable to complete the siting process.
This also indicates that adjacent counties have been looking to fulfill the
additional demand for this type of activity; Appendix V.D.5b.8 - Lee County
Agenda Request Form.
The Need:
Over the years, the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department has
received numerous inquiries (approximately three to five phone calls a month)
from citizens and organizations requesting a place for such uses described in the
proposed amendment. In addition, there have been frequent OHV rallies, e-
mails, and other forms of public demand for OHV areas which are received by
Miami-Dade County. Documentation supporting this need is included in
Appendix V.D.5b.7 - Public Inquiries. Several OHV groups exist in Miami, and
have large groups of riders to support this need. This has resulted in the Miami-
Dade County Park and Recreation Department pursuing suitable and cost
effective County owned sites for these uses.
In further support for the increasing demand; see Appendix V.D.5b.9 - OHV Titled
in Miami-Dade County for a map representing the location of OHV Titled for 2002
- 2006 and Appendix V.D.5b.l0 - OHV Titled in Collier County for those in Collier
County. Miami-Dade County has a total of 12,842 titled OHV's from 2002 to
2006 and has the second highest number of titles in Florida. Collier County has
5,560 titled OHV's. Of the surrounding counties, Broward County has 12,543 titled
OHV's from 2002-2008 which is the third highest in the State. Palm Beach has
11.464 titled OHV's which is the fourth highest in the State, and Lee County has
Appendix V.D.5b
8 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
9,100 titled OHV's; see Appendix V,D.5b,1l - Florida OHV County Title Activity,
6/30/02 to 12/31/08. The Appendix depicting OHV's titled for 2002 - 2006 Map,
provides a graphic representation of the numerous OHV owners and potential
park users in Miami-Dade County, as well as the number of title transactions in
the adjacent counties, further demonstrating the need for the proposed request.
To date, the subject area for the proposed amendment is the most cost feasible
location to provide its citizens a recreational area for this type of use. This project
will bring a level of resource management and enforce and protect visitor and
facility security.
Support from the public, including a list of active OHV organizations that create
a demand for the proposed comprehensive plan amendment is noted below
and documentation of these organizations and others can be found in
Appendix V.D.5b.12 - OHV Organizations and Clubs.
o AtvMiamiExtreme.com Enthusiast Group [Cary Hernandez, Javier Ortega,
Leo Lopez)
o ATVFlorida.com Enthusiast Group (Jose Camps - Miami, Dennis Bolanos -
Naples)
o ATV Safety Instructor [certified through the ATV Safety Institute) - Brooke
Lynch
o M.E. Thompson Park Motocross Area, Steve Griff - Vendor, Manager
o Family Riders Motorcycle Club of Perrine (Shakum)
o Florida Trail Riders (Gustavo Medina - Miami group)
o Thehumponline.com Enthusiast Group (Brooke Lynch, Marc Lane, Amy
Collins, Robert Cote)
o Southeast Trail Riders
Additionally, the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department 011-
Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study [Appendix V.D.5b.1) addresses a feasible
location as well as also establishing 'The Need'. While this study emphasizes the
need in Miami-Dade County, it is important to note that the subject site, while in
Collier County, borders Miami-Dade and 'The Need' for the residents of Collier
County is attested to by the number of reported titled vehicles, [Appendix
V.D.5b.10). Further, the proposed park and use for the residents of each
respective county has also been supported by the recently signed resolutions by
both the Miami-Dade and Collier County Commissions, Appendix V.D.5b.13 -
Miami-Dade Resolution and Appendix V.D.5b.14. Collier County Resolution.
SUDDort:
In addition to the Joint Resolutions (Appendix V.D.5b.13 and V.D.5b.14) in support
of the need and partnership between both Counties, there is widespread
support for the proposed amendment beyond the user interest groups, as
typified in the letters of support received from a variety of people and
organizations including: The Everglades Coordinating Council; Miami-Dade
County's Aviation Department (MDAD); Commissioner Jose Dia2, Vice Chairman
of the Miami-Dade Board of County Commissioners, the Collier County Manager;
and the National Off-Highway Vehicle Conservation Council; see Appendix
Appendix VD.5b
9 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
V.D.5b.15 - Letters of Support, as well as Appendix V.D.5b.2 - Collier County Park
and Recreation Department Letter.
In addition, Miami-Dade County is within the State Department of Highway
Safety and Motor Vehicles (DHSMV) Region 4 geographical area, which was
identified by the State OHV Advisory Committee as the highest need area for
OHV trails and safety training areas.
Consistency and Comoatibility with the Comorehensive Plan:
As part of the supporting data and analysis, the applicant is submitting the
below objectives and policies from the Collier County Comprehensive Plan.
These objectives and policies support the proposed DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS
RECREATION AREA DISTRICT and indicate a consistency with the proposed
amendment.
Future Land Use Element:
Conservation Designation - The overall purpose of fhe Conservation Designation
is to conserve and maintain the natural resources of Collier County and their
associated environmental, and recreation and economic benefits. All native
habitats possess ecological and physical characteristics that justify attempts to
maintain these important natural resources. Barrier islands, coastal bays,
we tfands, and habitat for listed species deserve particular attention because of
their ecological value and their sensitivity to perturbation. It is because of this
that all proposals for development in the Conservation Designation must be
subject to rigorous review to ensure that the impacts of the development do not
destroy or unacceptably degrade the inherent functional values.
The Conservation Designation is intended to protect certain vital natural
resource areas of the County, which are primarily owned by the public, although
private in-holdings and privately owned conservation areas do exist. This
Designation includes such areas as Everglades National Park, Big Cypress
National Preserve, Florida Panther National Wildlife Refuge, Fakahatchee Strand
State Preserve, Collier-Seminole State Park, Rookery Bay National Estuarine
Research Reserve, Delnor-Wiggins Pass State Recreation Area, and the National
Audubon Society's Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary (privately owned). The
boundaries of the Conservation Designation may periodically change as
properties are acquired by public entities or private land management or
conservation groups.
Anticipated impacts on surrounding land uses are anticipated to be minimal. This
project emphasizes protection of natural resources in a manner that would leave
the resources unimpaired for future users, while allowing public access for
resource-related recreational opportunities. Habitat will largely remain in its
current state with minimal impacts. Habitat degradation typically associated
with urbanization, residential development, road construction, and conversion to
agriculture are not proposed with this project. It is the intent of the applicant to
fully cooperate with the local. State, and Federal agencies with jurisdiction over
Appendix VD.5b
10 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
the proposed activities to improve the public facilities in a manner that
complements and further enhances the natural resources of the site.
Policy 3. J (b):
The [Land Development Code] (LOC) contains proVISIOns that protect
environmentally sensitive lands and provide for the retention of open space. This
has been accomplished; through the implementation of various zoning districts
and zoning overlays that restrict higher intensity land uses in the Rural Fringe
Mixed Use District and, which require specific land development standards for
the remaining allowable land uses; through the adoption of permanent Natural
Resource Protection Area (NRPA) Overlays; integration of State of Florida Big
Cypress Area of Critical State Concern regulations into the LOC and, in part,
through implementation of the Rural Lands Stewardship Overlay. This has also
been accomplished through the implementation of regulations such as minimum
open space requirements, native vegetation preservation requirements, and/or
through the creation of incentives that encourage the use of creative land use
planning techniques and innovative approaches to development in the
County's Agricultural/Rural Designated Area.
As stated in the above analysis of this Appendix, the proposed recreation area
will conform to Policy 3.1 [b) by maintaining and enhancing the conservation
lands within the Big Cypress Area of Critical State Concern. No more than 10% of
disturbance to the total site area is anticipated. In addition, capital funds that
are acquired through the recreational use of this property may be utilized to
further enhance other previously disturbed areas of the site which are planned to
be utilized as passive recreation areas. By appropriately managing this
recreational use and improving previously disturbed areas to a more natural
state will allow the property to maintain compatibility with the Conservation
Future Land Use designation. The final location of uses will be 'trued' in the field
and a management plan will be drafted during the rezoning and/or site plan
approval process to ensure this compatibility.
Recreation and Open Space Element:
Policy 1.4.2:
Collier County shall continue to coordinate the provision of recreational facilities
and activities with other governmental jurisdictions that own or operate such
facilities and activities within, or adjacent to, Collier County. Said governmental
entities shall include, but not necessarily be limited to:
U.S. Department of Commerce, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration U.S. Department of the Interior, the National Park Service
The Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Division of Recreation and
Parks
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Division of Forestry
Lee County, Florida
Hendry County, Florida
Broward County, Florida
Appendix VD.5b
11 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
Miami-Dade County, Florida
Monroe County, Florida
The South Florida Water Management District, Big Cypress Basin Board
The Collier County School Board
The City of Naples, Florida
The City of Marco Island, Florida
Everglades City, Florida
The City of Bonita Springs, Florida
Policy 1.4.2 supports the partnership between Collier and Miami-Dade Counties.
Due to the location of the subject site, the proposed recreational facility has the
opportunity to be utilized by residents of both jurisdictions, as well as those in
neighboring Broward County. Further reinforcement of this policy as it pertains to
the proposed amendment is indicated through the Resolution directing the
Miami-Dade County Mayor to negotiate an Interlocal Agreement with Collier
County for the joint development and operation of the subject site, Appendix
V.D.5b.13, and likewise, by the Resolution recently passed by Collier County,
Appendix V.D.5b.14.
Recreafion and Open Space Elemenf Level-aI-Service:
Policy 1.1.':
Collier County hereby adopts the following level of service standards for facilities
and land owned by the County or available to the general public:
Level of Service Standard:
A. 1.2882 acres of community park land/I ,000 population (unincorporated)
B. 2.9412 acres of regional park land/I ,000 population
Policy 1.1.1 establishes the level-of-service standard for Collier County's
Recreation and Open Space. The proposed amendment to the Future Land
Use Element will further enhance the recreational level-of-service standard to
provide an additional 1608 acres of recreational land for Collier County's
citizens.
Recreafion and Open Space Elemenf Level-ol-Service:
Policy 1.1.6:
The County shall continue to establish and implement a program with
appropriate criteria to designate or acquire open space areas and natural
reservations.
Policy 1.1.6 establishes a program to acquire open space and natural
reservations. The proposed amendment to the Future Land Use Element will
further increase the land area within Collier County designated as these types of
areas for Collier County's citizens.
Appendix V.D.5b
12 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
Economic Element:
OBJECTIVE I (The Conservation and Enhancement of Natural. Cultural and Social
Resources): Collier County will encourage the conservation and enhancement
of those
natural. cultural. and social resources that represent the foundation of the
County's existing retirement, recreation. and tourist-oriented economy, in order
to place the County in a competitive position to enable the retention and
expansion of these and other business opportunities.
Policy 1.1: Collier County will encourage the development of diverse cultural
facilities through public. private. or public/private partnerships that meet the
needs of the residents and visitors of the County.
Objective 1 and Policy 1.1 promote the proposed use of a recreational facility
and tourist-oriented economy (RV parking and natural recreation area) as well
as the development of diverse cultural facilities. The OHV activity is a cultural
activity that has wide popularity in South Florida as indicated by the number of
potential registered OHV titles. Additionally. the proposed development will
comply with the demands of the ridership in the areas as established in
Appendix V.D.5b.9 and Appendix V.D.5b.l0. A parks management system will
have the capability to secure passive recreational areas by utilizing fees
generated by OHV permits.
OBJECTIVE 4 (Nonprofit and Civic Organizations and Local Groups/Programs):
Collier County will support the economic development goals. efforts and
community involvement of nonprofit organizations. civic associations and local
groups and programs.
The proposed amendment promotes Objective 4 by providing a recreational use
facility for the OHV organizations; see Appendix V.D.5b.12 for a listing ot these
organizations and clubs.
Conservation and Coastal Management Element:
GOAL I: The County shall continue to plan for the protection, conservation.
management and appropriate use of its natural resources.
OBJECTIVE 1.1:
Collier County will continue to develop and implement a comprehensive
environmental management and conservation program. which will ensure that
the natural resources. including State and Federally listed animal species. of
Collier County are properly, appropriately. and effectively identified. managed,
and protected.
The proposed amendment will contorm to, and further enhance the
Conservation and Coastal Management Element's Goal and Objective by
maintaining the sites conservational use in an effort to promote an outdoor
recreation area tor Collier County and South Florida residents. The site is currently
disturbed by unmanaged and unrestricted use of the property due to OHV's.
Appendix VD.5b
13 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
This is evident from the Existing Trails Map of the site provided in Appendix
V.D.5b.4 - Existing Trails which indicates disturbed trail areas throughout the site.
Should the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department be permitted
to establish a parks and area management plan system for this site, it will be
possible to protect further resources from being disturbed after improvements to
the site have been made. A parks management system will have the capability
to secure passive recreational areas by utilizing fees generated by OHV permits.
Additionally, the disturbed trail area, already existing, is approximately 22 miles
while the proposed OHV trail area will be approximately 12 miles. This is a
reduction to the current disturbance and will bring those areas back into the fold
of conservation management. The proposed OHV trail area and uses will be
significantly reduced, including a sizable reduction in the number of existing
trails; see Table 1-A above for existing and proposed use data and Table 1-8 for
the trails data.
The primary goal of the Collier County Conservation and Coastal Management
Element (CCME) is to ensure that the natural resources, including State and
Federally listed animal species, are properly, appropriately, and effectively
identified, managed, and protected. In addition, the CCME protects native
vegetative communities and discourages the destruction of undisturbed, native
habitats that are preferred by the Florida panther or other listed species by
directing intensive land uses to currently disturbed areas and directing
incompatible land uses away from listed animal species and their habitats.
This project emphasi2es protection of natural resources in a manner that would
leave the resources unimpaired for future users, while allowing regulated public
access for resource-related recreational opportunities. Habitat will largely
remain in its current state with minimal impacts. The focus is to establish activities
in existing disturbed areas and utilize existing trails where appropriate. Habitat
degradation typically associated with urbanization, residential development,
road construction, conversion to agriculture, mining and mineral exploration is
not proposed with this project. It is the intent of the applicant to fully cooperate
with the local, State, and Federal agencies with jurisdiction over the proposed
activities to improve the public facilities in a manner that complements the
natural resources of the site.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Florida Panther Recovery Plan and the South
Florida Multi-Species Recovery Plan both recommend similar actions that must
take place for successful management and recovery of listed species. This
project furthers those actions by maintaining listed species habitat in south
Florida (development will be concentrated on existing impacted areas and trails
and uses with an overall footprint of new impacts which is anticipated to be a
small percentage, less then 10 percent of the site). In addition, public awareness
and education regarding onsite listed species conservation and recovery will be
furthered through site specific learning opportunities via educational signage
along the trails and a visitor's center.
Appendix VD.5b
14 of 14
Revised 7.10.09
,
APPENDIX V.D.Sb.t
OFF-HIGHWAY VEHICLE TRAILS
FEASIBILITY STUDY
(
\
(
"";",,,,"'.h.~~_~'IoI.....,,,,,,,,,,,,,__;,,,=..,c_,,,,,,.,,_"..__'-r.''''<4eN-
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Honorable Carlos Alvarez, Mayor
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Bruno A. Barriero, Chairman
Barbara J. Jordan, Vice-Chairwoman
Jose "Pepe" Diaz
Carlos A. Gimenez
Joe A. Martinez
Dorrin D. Rolle
Katy Sorenson
Sen. Javier D. Souto
District 5
District 1
District 12
District 7
District 11
District 2
District 8
District 10
Audrey M. Edmonson
Sally A. Heyman
Dennis C. Moss
Natacha Seijas
Rebecca Sosa
George M. Burgess, County Manager
Alex Munoz, Assistant County Manager
PARK AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT
Jack Kardys
W. Howard Gregg
George Parrado
Barbara Falsey, Ph.D.
Maria Nardi
Mark Heinicke, CPRP, CLARB
Eric Hansen
Kevin Asher
Anthony Fouche
Andy McCall
CONSULTANT TEAM
Interim Director
Assistant Director, Planning and Development
Assistant Director, Recreation
Chief of Planning and Research
Section Supervisor, Park Systems Planning
Park Planner III
Strategic Recreation Planner
Supervisor, Special Projects
Grants Administrator
Park Planner II/Project Manager
Wallace, Roberts, and Todd, Inc.
National Off-Highway Vehicle Conservation Council, Inc.
Scott Lamb and Associates, Inc.
Appendix VD.5b.1
District 3
District 4
District 9
District 13
District 6
/"
Appendix V.D.5b.1
R
JEer PA
fl\. It::.
,,' t". 1::,
FLORIDA DEPARTMEIlIT OFAGRICl1LTlI~EAND COIllSUMER.SERVICES, DIVISION OF FORESTRY
'()HVE~THUSIASTS
ATV Xtreme
"' ATV Florida
'~Iorida Tra.i1 Riders
j,t .
} he Hump Online
t~Florida OHV riders
"At. LEAQE~~HIPn{
R,Elprellll.P .Iio Robaina, SIple Repr~llentati"e
jReprese~t n C. Za .te Rep~se6tative
'if o.," . J\, . :,'o.'f'..'o."
arlo~~layo~i ;
punty ommissioner;' District a
iSSi~1i! District 9
.s,siorer, District 11
lWnissioher, District 12
G!~IES
South Florida Water Management District
Everglades National Park
Biscayne National Park
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Agricultural Practices Study Advisory Board
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY DEPARTMENTS
Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
Miami-Dade County Aviation Department
Miami-Dade County Department of Solid Waste Management
Miami-Dade County Department of Environmental Resources Management
Miami-Dade County Agricultural Extension
Miami-Dade County Police (Agriculturai Patrol) Department
Miami-Dade County Department of Planning & Zoning
CONSULTANT TEAM
Wallace Roberts & Todd, LLC
National Off Highway Vehicle Conservation Council, Inc.
Scott Lamb and Associates, Inc.
"..".,......"'.,.,." I......""'.."..",,
..;,-,_. ..,,-.,~. ..~~.~."., ,.,.... '."._<."'''',,,,,,,,--.,,,,~,,,,,,;-,,-,,,,-~-,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,"''''.' ...,,,._'''''......._''''~...~''',,.'''~.,.., ...-
Appendix V.D.5b.1
REPORT ApPROVAL
This Off-Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study report has been reviewed and accepted as presented.
Jack Kardys
Interim Director
Park and Recreation Department
Barbara Falsey Ph.D.
Chief
Planning and Research
W. Howard Gregg
Assistant Director
Planning and Development
Maria Nardi
Section Supervisor
Park Systems Planning
George Parrado
Assistant Director
Recreation
Andy McCall
Park Planner II
Project Manager
LIST OF FIGURES
Appendix V.D.5b.1
22 FIGURE 1: 57 FIGURE 13: 78 FIGURE 26:
TITLES ISSUED FOR OHVs IN FLORIDA, TNT AIRPORT 58TH STREET lANDFILL
By TYPE, 2003 THROUGH 2007 FIGURE 14:
59 EAST OF SPEEDWAY LANDS 81 FIGURE 27:
23 FIGURE 2: SOUTH DAD!; LANDFILL
OFF-HIGHWAY VEHICLES TITLED, BY
COUNTY, FROM JULY 2002 TO APRIL 61 FIGURE 15:
2005 FRS HOLDINGS 82
23 FIGURE 3: FIGURE 16:
FLORIDA COUNTIES WITH MOST OHV TITLES 61 DERM MITIGATION TAR-
As OF JUNE 30, 2007 GETS NEAR FRS HOLD- 83
25 FIGURE 4: INGS
OFF-HiGHWAY VEHICLES TITLED IN MIAMI- 63 FIGURE 17: 8
DADE COUNTY AS OF SPRING 2007 AND COUNTYLlNE MOTOCROSS
SITES RECOMMENDED FOR FURTHER ANALYSIS PARK
26 FIGURE 5: 65 FIGURE 18: 85
OHV TRAILS IN UNAUTHORIZED OPA-LOCKA WEST AIRPORT
AREAS IN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
69 FIGURE 19:
31 FIGURE 6: LESS FEASIBLE AND 87
EXISTING OHV FACILITIES IN FLORIDA UNFEASIBLE SITES
39 FIGURE 7: FIGURE 20:
SITES INVESTIGATED AS POTENTIAL 71
OHV FACILITIES AEROJET GENERAL
40 FIGURE 8: 72 FIGURE 21: 90
EXCERPT OF GIS ANALYSIS BEACON COUNTYLlNE, LLC
43 FIGURE 9: 73 FIGURE 22: 91
DATA TABLE TEMPLATE FROG POND
49 FIGURE 10: 74 FIGURE 23: 93
SELECT ACQUISITION PROJECTS FOR HOMESTEAD GENERAL
THE MDC ENVIRONMENTALLY AIRPORT
ENDANGERED LANDS PROGRAM
DECEMBER 4,2001 74 FIGURE 24:
INDUSTRIAL LANDS NEAR 95 RocKY
50 FIGURE 11: LAKE BELT
SIGNAGE AT OCALA NATIONAL FOREST
GUIDES OHV RIDERS TO ApPROPRIATE 77 FIGURE 25:
AREA INGRAHAM Hwv AND
SW 217TH AVE
55 FIGURE 12:
RECOMMENDED SITES
"f',,<C>_. "':./ <. .: ''''"
. '1xE}:~'F'.. ...;t*:."NT' E ..~V.D.Sb.1
-_-:J:__<_-t,-~<:;~~:--___;<",:_;~;:~<_ F"':>: ',',' - -I",';:I-:~
'. S'p'n~ enthusiasts
Q-5' -
15
19
21
29
29
32
34
:Yehi~lesites... 38
f:;_>'i~;;~:/>_::f:__;;_f:,_:-_-:_ ~;-,,: ,;;,,:,,;.:,
stems Methodology & Results
i;~/ff_J/t:C;<;--2-;-->f .<- - -!',,:; - , ", ',' ;,-
sts: . .
;,->1;)-'. f_''f'~: r - -;"
i",' ""--"'':'' '-
. . efs~nd enthusiasts'
~:--T>');0;~_):~(_~;_-,Yl{:::,-;t_:u, - :"?: _-~_ _,':-'; ~ ", ,- ,u', --
.intqrma!ion
"/,'<_ 'p Y,'- u."'.f
.;;-::p.:\-:,;:-:';::' ',':-
,- '. . .
!,jf',,:, ;
i~"d~i~e!i s.,!sec:l on Ranking Matrix
;;~;---->- ',"<," - ,',' -": > - ".
F-y;ft2 Results
42
48
51
5\
55
69
99
...........-,~-~'*'.._._""'"'......_,..... ." -, --..,.....,..
.-
io
:/
.
.-+... -.
.,~
Appendix V.D.5b.1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
)
The popularity of off-highway motorized recreation activities has surged in South Florida over the past decade. According to
the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (DHSMV), over 25,000 off-highway vehicles (OHV) have been regis-
tered in Miami-Dade, Broward, and Monroe Counties since October 2002. At the same time, locations for lawful OHV riding
have not been available to meet the increasing demand in the region. This has prompted the Florida Division of Forestry
(DO F) to target South Florida as a critical area for development of new OHV recreation facilities.
Miami-Dade County also recognized a need to provide safe, convenient facilities to address conflicts resulting from unregu-
lated OHV riding. In April 2006, the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department (MDCPRD) applied for and was
awarded a grant by the DOF to conduct this Off-Highway Vehicles Trail Feasibility Study.
The study is founded on four premises: #1) OHV riding is a legitimate, family-oriented recreational activity that enjoys
increasing popularity among South Florida residents; #2) facilities for legal OHV riding do not currently exist within Miami-
Dade County; #3) the mission of the MDCPRD is to provide for the recreational needs of County residents and visitors; and
#4) the needs of OHV enthusiasts for such facilities should be balanced with the need to protect natural resources and to
use County lands in a responsible manner.
The goal of the OHV Trail Feasibility Study is to identify one or more sites within Miami-Dade County that could be trans-
formed into an OHV recreational facility. The scope of the study encompasses a County-wide site search and site analysis
to identify sites that are both suitable for use as OHV recreation areas, and available for sale, lease, or use agreement. The
MDCPRD will use the conclusions and recommendations in this report to determine an appropriate course of action, leading
to the acquisition, design, and construction of one or more OHV trail facilities within the County.
~
This study consisted of a series of steps, including GIS-based analysis in the initial stages to identify a range of potential
sites, and extensive interaction with OHV enthusiasts and governmental agencies throughout the process. In all, eight meet-
ings were held with stakeholder groups, both separately and jointly, to solicit input and to review and corroborate informa-
tion. Further, the criteria for the determination of site feasibility were established based on input received from these groups,
as well as on the expertise of the County's consultant team for this project.
')
15
Appendix VD.5b.1
Based on the findings and outcomes of this process, this study recommends additional investigation of five sites.
Land surrounding the Dade-Collier County Training and Transition Airport (or TNT Airport) stands out as the most
viable long-term option. While it is not immediately available, this location has the best overall collection of desired
site characteristics: large acreage under single public ownership; ready road access; potentially available for lease
or agreement; already vegetated; and distant from residential neighborhoods. TNT Airport will require extensive
permitting and coordination with several agencies, including the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the Miami-Dade
County Aviation Department.
Two other sites offer potential opportunities for permanent OHV facilities. These sites are identified in this report as
the Lands East of the Homestead Speedway and the Florida Rock and Sand (FRS) Holdings, both located in south
Miami-Dade County. Because of these sites' recent inclusion in the study, their recommendations are contingent
upon additional due diligence, including contacting the owner and determining willingness to sell. They have many
of the same desirable characteristics as the preceding site-they are large relative to other sites available in Miami-
Dade County, appealing to users, distant from incompatible uses, etc.-and have fewer environmental constraints.
They are less appealing overall because of their ownership composition. Both are privately held and in the case
of the East of Speedway lands, ownership is highly fragmented. The anticipated cost and coordination required to
assemble a large enough site for an OHV facility may make these sites ultimately unfeasible. Because these sites
emerged as possible candidates later in the study process, some investigation remains to be done, including mak-
ing contact with the property owners to determine if they are willing sellers.
The last two sites being recommended for further action are Countyline Motocross Park and the former Opa-Iocka
West Airport. Both are considered "near term," although the connotation of that phrase differs for each site. Coun-
tyline Motocross Park is an existing site with immediate availability. A private vendor has operated a motocross
practice track on the site since negotiating a short-term lease with the County. While that agreement expired at
the end of May 2007, the vendor will continue on a month-to-month basis until the MDCPRD issues a Request for
Proposal and selects a vendor to commit to a five-year contract. This report recommends that MDCPRD continue
this process in order to facilitate a more permanent situation. The former Opa-Iocka West Airport site is a near term
solution in the sense that the need for action is immediate and the site's availability period brief. The County Avia-
tion Department recently announced plans to sell 90 percent of the property to a private mining company by the end
of 2008. Unless the deal unexpectedly falls through, this will leave a very short and near-term-only solution, the
immediacy of which could be additionally burdened by a nine-month to one-year wetlands fill permit process.
This study recommends simultaneously pursuing two or more of the above-referenced sites to adequately serve the
needs, preferences, and geographical dispersion of present and future OHV enthusiasts. Given the current dearth
of facilities in the County, it is advisable to carry forward to immediately secure at least one near-term opportunity,
while further investigating the prospects of leasing, acquiring, or entering into a interagency use agreement for at
least one of the long-term sites. To this end, we recommend that the MDCPRD apply, at the earliest opportunity,
for implementation funds (acquisition, design, and/or construction). Possible funding sources include the T Mark
,/ Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle grant program, the Department of Environmental Protection's Greenways and Trails
i,
, grant program, as well as Miami-Dade County funds.
16
~~"",v,,,~~,Y''-'~'''',__''''
- ,--_..,,~"..
. C'''''_'''''' .___...._ ~ ~.-~_.,,_
_._..~'......--'...-
Appendix V.D.Sb.l
I. INTRODUCTION
The goal of the OHV Trail Feasibility Study is to identify one or
more sites within Miami-Dade County that could be transformed
into an OHV recreational facility. The scope of the study encom-
passes a County-wide site search and site analysis to identify sites
that are both suitable for use as OHV recreation areas, and avail-
able for sale, lease, or use agreement. The MDCPRD will use the
conclusions and recommendations in this report to determine an
appropriate course of action, hopefully leading to the acquisition,
design, and construction of one or more OHV trail facilities within
the County.
The feasibility study is based on four central premises:
OHV riding is a legitimate, family-oriented recreational activity
that enjoys increasing popularity among South Florida resi-
dents
facilities for legal OHV riding do not currently exist within Mi-
ami-Dade County
the mission of the Park and Recreation Department is to pro-
vide for the recreational needs of County residents and visi-
tors
the needs of OHV enthusiasts for such facilities should to be
balanced with the need to protect natural resources and use
County lands in a responsible manner.
The popularity of off-highway motorized recreation in South Flor-
ida has surged significantly over the past decade. According to
the Division of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles, over 25,000
OHVs have been registered in Miami-Dade, Broward, and Mon-
roe Counties since October 2002. At the same time, locations for
lawful OHV riding have not been available during this period to
meet the increasing user demand in the region. This prompted
the Florida DOF to target South Florida as a critical area for de-
velopment of new OHV facilities.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Miami-Dade County also recognized a need to provide safe, convenient facilities to address conflicts resulting from un-
regulated OHV riding. In determining the immediate need for action, the MDCPRD took into account the consequences
of not providing a park for local OHV users. Over time, recurrent, unauthorized riding in ecologically sensitive areas-as
evidenced by aerial photography of wetland areas in west and south Miami-Dade County-can cause heavy damage that -;
is costly to mitigate. In addition, OHV trespass creates conflicts between riders and property owners, as well as conflicts
with adjacent uses. The County's Agricultural Patrol Unit reports an increase in complaints coming from residential ar-
eas, farmers, and agencies responsible for environmental mitigation and protection efforts.
.9
RECOMMENDED
SITES
Long Term
LAND SURROUNDING TNT AIRPORT
*EAST OF SPEEDWAY
*FLORIDA ROCK AND SAND (FRS)
HOLDINGS
Near Term
COUNTYLlNE MOTOCROSS PARK (AT
M.E. THOMPSON PARK)
FORMER OPA-LOCKA WEST AIRPORT
. ~ECOMMENDA TION CONTINGENT UPON
,ODITIONAL DUE DILIGENCE.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Since the first draft of this document was presented for public review in Decem-
ber 2006, the feasibility study has been substantially revised to address new
or revised information provided by stakeholders or collected by the Consultant
Team. Over 200 OHV enthusiasts and representatives from stakeholder agen-
cies participated in a January 24th, 2007 public workshop. Stakeholder groups
had an opportunity to comment on the user appeal of sites and to suggest new
locations for further exploration. Attendees were also invited to complete a
preference survey. A multi-agency round table was held on February 20, 2007
to review the environmental, regulatory, and availability status of the potential
sites. Subsequent meetings were held with agencies and enthusiasts to verify
the most current and available information.
Of the 23 candidate sites evaluated in this report, this study recommends fur-
ther investigation of five. Land surrounding the Dade-Collier County TNT Air-
port stands out as the most viable long-term option. While it is not immediately
available-as described later in more detail-this site has the best overall col-
lection of desired site characteristics. Namely, it is large; under single, public
ownership; appealing to users; potentially available for lease; already vegetat-
ed; and distant from incompatible land uses.
Two other sites offer potential opportunities for permanent OHV facilities. The
Lands East of the Homestead Speedway and the FRS Holdings sites, both
located in south Miami-Dade County, share many physical characteristics with
the preceding site, while having fewer environmental constraints, but are less suitable overall because of their ownership
composition. Both are privately held and in the case of the East of Speedway lands, highly fragmented. The anticipated
cost and coordination required to assemble a large enough site for an OHV facility may make these sites ultimately un-
feasible. Because of these sites' recent inclusion in the study, their recommendations are contingent upon additional due
diligence, including contacting the owner and determining willingness to sell.
The last two sites being recommended for further action are Countyline Motocross Park and the former Opa-Iocka West
Airport. Both are considered "near term" opportunities. Countyline Motocross Park is an existing site with immediate
availability. A private vendor will continue to operate the existing motocross practice track on a month-to-month basis until
the MDCPRD issues a Request for Proposals and selects a vendor to commit to a five-year contract This report recom-
mends that MDCPRD continue this process in order to facilitate a more permanent situation. The former Opa-Iocka West
Airport site is both a near term and short term solution, due to the County Aviation Department's stated plans to dispose of
90 percent of the property for mining operations by the end of 2008. Unless the deal unexpectedly falls through, this will
leave a very brief period for OHV use.
This study recommends simultaneously pursuing two or more of the above-referenced sites to adequately serve the
needs, preferences, and geographical dispersion of present and future users. It is advisable to work toward immediately
securing at least one near-term opportunity, while at the same time pursuing one or more of the long-term sites.
to
BACKGROUND
Off-highway vehicles are generally defined as motorized vehicles not
registered or licensed for highway use. The term, however, encom-
passes a wide variety of machines, including 4-wheel drive jeeps, auto-
mobiles, or sport utility vehicles; motorcycles designed for off-highway
use; all-terrain vehicles, more widely known as ATVs; and other spe-
cially-designed off-road motor vehicles used in a wide variety of ways.
Users often combine the riding experience with other outdoor activi-
ties. Such activities include hiking, camping, hunting, backpacking,
photography, sightseeing, mountain biking, picnicking, swimming, fish-
ing, boating, skiing, and bird watching. The ideal OHV facility accom-
modates not only riding, but also a combination of these activities.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Demand for OHV driving and riding has experienced a notable upsurge
in the past few years. In 1960, when the first U. S. National Recre-
ation Survey was done for the Outdoor Recreation Resources Review
Commission, off-highway motorized recreation was not even officially
recognized as a recreational activity. In contrast, from 1982 to 2001,
the number of participants over 12 years old grew by more than 100 0 1 N I' 1 F 10HVI'1
ca a a lona ores ral
percent (Cordell et al. 2004, p. 37). The next rounds of subsequent Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
National Survey on Recreation and the Environment (NSRE) revealed
that the number of users continued to balloon between 1995 and 2000 from 27.3 to 36.0 million. Based on NSRE
results from last season, nearly one in four Americans (23.8 percent) age 16 and older participated one or
more times in OHV recreation within the past year.
While the number of people participating has increased across all demographic groups, the majority of participants
continue to be under 50, male, and white, and residents of urban areas. Interest is increasing especially rapidly
among 30 to 50 years old female, Hispanic, and urban riders.
According to the Motorcycle Industry Council, nationwide OHV annual sales more than tripled between 1995 and
2003, to more than 1.1 million vehicles sold in 2003. ATVs, specifically addressed and defined by the 2002 Florida
Statutes, continue to be the most common vehicle type purchased, accounting for more than 70 percent of the OHV
market. The population of OHVs in the U.S. grew nearly as fast, increasing 174 percent between 1993 and 2003.
In just ten years, the number of OHVs has grown from fewer than 3 million vehicles in 1993 to more than 8 million
in 2003.
Across Florida, there are approximately 1,781,000 OHV users, meaning that 14.2 percent (or one in every seven)
of the State residents participates in the activity. Within over 5 percent of the state's title request since 2002 coming
from Miami-Dade County alone, the State Division of Forestry has targeted South Florida as a critical area for devel-
III
Appendix V.D.5b.1
opment of OHV recreation areas. According to the DHSMV, over 25,000 vehicles have been registered in Miami-Dade,
Broward, and Monroe Counties since October 2002. Each year, the number of new riders increases. In 2003, 2004,
and 2005, the number of newly registered vehicles was 5,350, 6,139, and 7,368, respectively. The data show that
many individuals own multiple vehicles, lending support to feedback from local stakeholders that many South Florida
OHV users ride as a family activity.
According to an OHV Enthusiast Survey conducted at the Department's January 2007 Community Workshop, most us-
ers live in the south and southwest areas of Miami-Dade County, although it may be noted that this is where the meeting
was held. Local users have been riding seventeen years on average; they ride frequently-on average, once a week;
and they go in large groups-on average, 13 people per outing.
In recognition of the growing popularity of OHVs-ATVs and Off-Highway Motorcycles (OHMs), in particular-the
Florida legislature signed The 1. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Safety and Recreation Act into law in 2002 to pro-
mote the development of a statewide OHV recreational system. The intent of the law was "to create new opportunities
for OHV users (specifically ATV and OHM users) while safeguarding the integrity of Florida's natural resources." The
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services' Division of Forestry is responsible for coordination between
the planning, development and management of lands including those used for OHV riding. Funding is available for
ATV trails through a DOF grant program. The funding, collected through the titling of ATVs, is used to fund feasibility
studies, land acquisition grants, construction grants, and monitoring grants, to help develop more ATV areas for Florida
residents. With money collected through the titling of OHVs, the State legislature allocated between $700,000 and $1
million in 2005 to the DOF for the 1. Mark Schmidt grant program.
40,000
35,000
5,000
New Off-Highway
Motorcycle
.New ATV
30,000
25,000
20,000
. Used Off-Highway
Motorcycle
. Used ATV
1 5,000
10,000
o
200312004 200412005 200512006 200612007
FIGURE 1:
TITLES ISSUED FOR OHVs IN FLORIDA, By TYPE, 2003 THROUGH 2007
Source: Division of Forestry
lit
Legend
49 to 559
. 560 to 1272
. 1273 to 2369
. 2370 to 4032
. 4033 to 5861
FIGURE 2:
OFF-HiGHWAY VEHICLES TITLED, BY COUNTY,
FROM JULY 2002 TO APRIL 2005
Source: Division of Forestry
Hillsborough
Broward
Miami-Dade
Palm Beach
Polk
8,500 9,000 9,500 10,000 10,500 11,000
FIGURE 3:
FLORIDA COUNTIES WITH MOST OHV TITLES
As OF JUNE 30, 2007
Source: Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles
Appendix V.D.5b.1
.,
~.~.
>:~-,.~
~/
.,...'
lIS
Appendix V.D.5b.1
The Grant program has 5 categories, with the following maximum funding amounts to help local agencies
to develop more OHV areas for Florida residents:
Planning, research, and design of new OHV recreation areas, trails, or facilities ($50,000)
Construction of new OHV recreation areas, trails, or facilities ($150,000)
Repair, maintenance, monitoring, rehabilitation, and protection of existing OHV areas, trails, or
facilities ($75,000)
Rider education, safety, and training programs ($10,000)
Acquisition of lands to be included in the system ($200,000)
The lack of facilities has led many South Florida OHV owners, sometimes unknowingly, to ride in unauthor-
ized areas such as conservation lands or private property. According to sources at Miami-Dade Department
of Environmental Resource Management (DERM), there has been ATV use in nearly all County owned
natural areas in which access is not controlled. The South Dade Wetlands Acquisition Project is one of the
most common areas of unauthorized use of ATVs-and consequently one of the most damaged-but there
are others that are being used without permission, in particular: the West Biscayne Pineland, the Quail
Roost Pineland, the Ludlam Pineland, and Tree Island Park.
This situation prompted the MDCPRD to apply for a grant from the DOF in the category of Planning, Re-
search, and Design of New OHV Recreation Areas, Trails, or Facilities, to identify and evaluate suitable
areas throughout Miami-Dade County for the possible location of OHV recreational trails and facilities.
Although the grant funding is geared toward ATVs and OHMs, Miami-Dade County is exploring providing
facilities for an even wider range of vehicles in this study in order to respond to the full spectrum of demand.
The grant agreement was executed in April 2006, with an expiration date of September 8,2008. The County
chose the consulting team of WRT to conduct the study.
'14
(l)
^
a
3
ro
~
ro
~
o
ro
.
SW 8th Street
:..
., ,
. '.
,
-
. .
....
. NEAR-TERM SITE
. LONG-TERM SITE
. LONG-TERM SITE DE-
PENDENT UPOr,l ADDI-
TIONAL DUE gjLlGENCE
"
VEHICLE
IAMI-
"
-~
.4-
,,,,,'"
.~.wURE 4:
A~F-HIGHWAY VEHICLES TITLED IN MIAMI
.':t' SPRING 2007 AND SITES RECOMMENDED
if Source: Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicle
'^
"
(
',-
Appendix VD.5b.1
FIGURE 5:
f EXAMPLES OF THE EFFECTS OF UNAUTHORIZED AND UNREGULATED OHV USAGE IN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
\..... Source: Google Earth
,I>
,;__"""""'-......~>-"..d__,.">,-.c
II. PROCESS
The approach to conducting this study consisted of a series of steps, and
included extensive GIS-based analyses in the initial stages of the pro-
cess to identify a range of potential site candidates. The criteria for deter-
mining the feasibility of sites were established based on input received
from stakeholder groups, including OHV enthusiasts and governmental
agencies, as well as the expertise of the Consultant Team. Field visits
were conducted of each site, in some cases more than once. Most im-
portantly, the process involved significant interaction with the stakeholder
groups, including the OHV community at large, through workshops, pre-
sentations, surveys, round tables, and various other types of meetings. In
all, eight meetings were held by the Feasibility Study team to solicit input
and to review and corroborate information with the stakeholder groups.
MCDPRD conducted additional one-on-one meetings and held briefings
with local leaders.
ASSEMBLE BACKGROUND INFORMATION
WRT and the sub-consultants reviewed data on facility sizes and ameni-
ties, development cost, and operations practices at comparable publicly
owned OHV areas; researched legal issues related to operating OHV rec-
reational facilities; gathered information about what kinds of activities are
considered appropriate uses in OHV recreational areas; and reviewed
planning and feasibility studies, plans, and other relevant documents
about OHV areas around the country.
Among other sources, the consultants reviewed reports and data from
the MDCPRD, Planning and Zoning and Environmental Resources Man-
agement Departments, the National Park Service, the Florida Division of
Forestry, 1he National Recreation and Parks Association, the Everglades
Coordinating Council, and several municipalities and counties around the
nation that conducted OHV studies. In addition, the team reviewed past
and current legislation including Chapter 317 Off-Highway Vehicle Titling,
Chapter 261 Public Lands and Property Off-Highway Safety and Recre-
ation, and Senate Bill 1672/House Bill 7079.
Appendix V.D.5b,1
)
\
,
-;
It
.1<. " ,
... .. .
.. 11I.'-" IIiIIII
., '. . ... ""', ......
'-, IIIIIIIIIIIIIII ... ".', . -."... .
. IIiIII ..' I....... .
., .. '.' ..". -- ."'" ''','''.
.,'.\. -- .. ., _,. .... r
III'.'.'.' ._. ," .,' II...
.. ...... ... -' . - .
... _- ..., IIiIII
11II ...,.. ... .. ... .'. 1IiIII' ... -... _, III ..... '.'
III. .....' r,_ -'.. · .. . _ .' ,., - -",," .' ,....',.' ,
, '... '.. . 11IIIII' . . ..., ..' ..'.' .....' ., . '.....11I.
,-'.."" ........... -' .. .-'.' ' .
. - ....../ "- .',...' , ' -,
.".:'" .', ".",- · ""......, W/.' '." II .".'." '"
.' ."...,IJI,:", 11I,.::....-, ,...", ''',._ '_'.' .-"..'.-.....-', .,"
__' "'.'11III' ., ..,
.' ' . -., . :-. -' ........, .' .' .',.".
.... .. '. . . -. ..
'l,."-"._,.,, _._.,':'" "--,'g,,., - -,... ... _..
.. .",-. -., - ,.,-,,-' .,.., , .
III.. 11IIIII" -' --..' ." - .' .. ... ' _I
I', 11I-. .'" ." -' II!:. I .....
.' . , .... - "',.' -..., -, . .. B-
", ,'. - '_.' ' .' ...' ... ..-
.. ---"... .,... "" ',.'" " . lIP., · _...' .,_..,.
--.. .'.'.' II' , '..' "" ' · ...' IIiIII III
.'.'. _, ' ..', -. .",' III...,", .",'." .' ....11II,.' ,
.. .. I II _' I.' III' III,..
............, '.',.<' .' ,'. '.., -,11I11I, ',a
",-'~' '... ,-'.' '., " ""..g ',.'.,11- .."111".'..'.
'.' I III, "....' 'II' ...'. _ · IIIIIIIII', -- ...." · -..' ..'
, ".".., ..'-, .,.,.... ."., 1, ,--, " . .--'1
.JIll,,'.'.' .' '...........,.11'.,. · · .' ., '"
. .,_...., .",., .. ....."..'.', . --....., ..'
.'", - ."-'..' ..... - . ...'.'......' ",
."':"'. .-:.,....' ..,_, ......" .., '. .'.11 '.. .",' ...." '..' ....".'.. :"'.",.,,_ .."....
..., II, .;.. ....' ." ...,",.,n" ., ... ..."...~, . "~a . .''',..' '-, - .. 11II
., _ -.'.... ill., ,..' ... ".,,-,-. -. - ,--. ..
..".., ,III,:',." "",,".'., ",IIIIr".'.,' ..., ." '-h:'I" . -= , _- " ,.'1IiIII "III'"
__,B". . ...'.", _" .... I ..
.. -' ' -' . ' ' ..
.1'" II,.' 11II . -;:-'-:..' "., .,,;':...:.' '-'.'.,."..,.'.' II.,..,.,
'. 1IiIII.,.'. _. ."",
,', .:i ',.,.' .,-,:."
...... ","
- . .. III.
.. ---..,.. _"~a .." .'
- .. . -.. ...
-.... . ......" III ...._" .' .
· · .,..,..,' ,.,.,_., ..." "" .',lJI8.-""
.. .'.' .'.,." _., II,
-. - '". -;, - '.
.
III.:!
.
. '."-'
50
Appendix VD.sb.1
MEET WITH STAKEHOLDER AGENCIES AND ENTHUSIASTS
A project kick-off meeting was held to introduce WRT
and the sub-consultants to the Steering Committee,
which was comprised of MDCPRD Staff. The Com-
mittee and consultants developed the planning pro-
cess, reviewed documents and resources, and iden-
tified additional internal project participants and an
initial list of external stakeholders. This Team worked
together to meet with and gather information from
stakeholder agencies and OHV enthusiasts.
The Consultants and MDCPRD began gathering
input at a quarterly meeting of the OHV Advisory
Committee, a group under the direction of the DOF.
Stakeholders from throughout the state attended, but
because of the meeting's location, there was signifi-
cant turnout from Miami-Dade, Broward, Collier and
Lee Counties. Attendees represented public agen-
cies such as DERM and SFWMD as well as private
interests, such asATV and motocross users and OHV
dealers.
The second gathering, hosted on July 12, 2006 by
the MDCPRD, was geared specifically toward gather-
ing information from local enthusiasts. Users shared
information about the areas in which they ride, where
concentrations of users reside, and the challenges
faced by OHV riders in Miami-Dade County. Users
corroborated what the data suggest-in alignment
with the national trend, there has been a substantial
increase in both the sales and the popularity of ATVs
in Florida in the last five years. Most active, local
OHV users fall into one or more of three general cat-
egories:
families seeking passive, group-oriented experi-
ences on long, meandering paths in 'natural' set-
tings,
"mud riders," who enjoy wet terrain, often in the
form of a mud pit
riders seeking more active, "challenge" rides, of-
ten provided by very steeply sloped, bumpy ter-
51
rain that is navigated in a technical manner at
much slower speeds.
OHV riders are seeking a facility in Miami-Dade
County that is legal, suitable, and safe.
Intergovernmental coordination was an integral part of
the development of the Feasibiiity Study. WRT identi-
fied all agencies that might have land available and
suitable for OHV areas, or had concerns that would
impact or influence sites proposed in the Feasibility
Study. These groups included the South Florida Wa-
ter Management District, Everglades National Park,
Board of County Commissioners, National Park Ser-
vice, Miami-Dade County Agricultural Extension, Mi-
ami-Dade County Aviation Department, Miami-Dade
County Police (Agricultural Patrol Unit), Miami-Dade
County Solid Waste, DERM and its Environmentally
Endangered Lands (EEL) Program, and the Agricul-
tural Practices Study Advisory Board.
At the July 12, 2006 Stakeholders meeting, repre-
sentatives from DERM and SFWMD discussed some
of the challenges facing OHV facility site selection
in terms of land management and protection of re-
sources. The agencies expressed concern over two
issues-the trampling of plants and the degradation
of wetlands. These two agencies provided additional
input about the potential of their landholdings as po-
tential OHV sites on September 18, 2006. The Coun-
ty Park and Recreation Department hosted an inter-
agency meeting to gather information about potential
sites for OHV trails within lands owned and main-
tained by the South Florida Water Management Dis-
trict. Other government agencies attended, including
The Miami-Dade County Department of Environmen-
tal Resource Management, the office of County Com-
missioner Jose "Pepe" Diaz, and the State Division
of Forestry.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
May 2006 NOHVCC Conference
OHV enthusiasts meeting, Summer 2006
2006 OHV enthusiast rally, Bird Road and SW 157th Avenue
Photo sources: MDC Park and Recreation Department and WRT
55
Appendix V.D.5b.1
IDENTIFY SITE SELECTION CRITERIA
The Consultants and MDCPRD staff established a list of criteria to be used to identify those sites most suitable
for the development of OHV recreation areas. "Most preferable" and "least preferable" categories were created to
frame the anticipated array of circumstances encountered during the site selection process.
..... .'.....'
.. .. ./....... .' ....... ~'... . .. - · . '.' L. ....... ._. 11II
IJII.'_'" ._......-1.......1.......,... ........1. ........ ~~..
. . _. ....
:. . I.. III 11II'
:......... .......... Ii'.' :.:;...:.. .... : ,..... _. . 11I.11III .. ..11 . . ~...II-.I; :..... . .
I. .... .'. .'_' __..............-... ,1... .11... ...., ........1.........
I :...,.'11....... .1__' ." '.. ..'. ." ... ... ..-.-. .'1':.. .:. II
'.- ;'" "11I'.'''' ... .....-......,. _............ ........... ..... ....._...:. ._........
I........... .... .. .. ~., 111III.... -- .. .... : I... 11I1.... r.. ..:
........ ..'. ...................-. :'.11I. ..........-:....11:. .....1......11I11I. .1'. ... -........ ....'
II. . .--.. '1..11II . ..... . . _.. _ ."
...... .... - -.-' --..'.~. ...... . -.' .' .".1...11..
-.r. .... ..... . U- ...... :__11' __.... III'
.... .......... - II. 'IIL'. .....-. .... ...... .
1.1........... ....--. ....-. ...---1-..... ......
.., . .' ......... ... .... .., H". 11III-. .... ..' ....._.. III..: . . ..._.............. III'
_...___..... ': ".1 .... ..... _''':..11._'' ."'..' '. . JfItt#IJ........
I..... ..... "..'.. ... -'11III ... . ..-:.....1 '. __... I ..'. ....-..... .... _."
-. ~.... . ... ..... ..-..... .' .......-..... .11....... .' II.. .. .' .11..
.'..'11I'.'11.... .... :... .............. ..11.:.... ... ...... ..11-' :. .... ....~. ........
;1.... -' ..' .. III:.:....... '.' ....11II. ." ..1, .11.. :.... : 1......._...... -::........ .... ..,.. ..1..1...........
..:... ..... ~'."'.'.: :. =-._.... ......._.. .:.......::.. -.._. . ';;'.1. ......:. . _. .:.:......:. ....._. . ............../
..... ........... ......-.. . . -. ...;... ......... '1.
...... .....,..... . . - . _.. _........ III'
..---. . .' . . - . . -..........
:1.1'11II. --- .' ........ ":' .,. .... .... ....1... ...... --. .,. ..... ....
1,.,--. ......... .. ....... ...' ..' .. 11._.. ..-;.." ".- -. .... ... .....
..... III _........ .. ." .' -. .'...1.""" _' ..... .... _. _.
... ...... .-- . III: _.1111' . II.. . -. . ."
_.. _...... ........11I _.... . .... _..' ...... .rIIl.
.-. -III - IIIIIIIIII. ... .... . . ...... -. ..
. ...... .' II...... ".
..... .- ..... ..11.... .'-.. I ..
... ... ...:........................ 11II. I. . 1
.. __. ..' · "'.- 11II.... .:.. - .2;.;-. .... _ .
...- -
cC. ~
54
Appendix V.D.5b.1
11II
- '.' .' ""'.', .'..
.--..,.. -.......... .- - ..-.......... ...'" '," ....
'. ,..r,.. .....,..,.g,-, ,':.....'.....1.1. ...,.... ..,..., all'II" ' ..' I -
- .......'.' .. . .
...,- -. . --" 11II .' '.' I
:...,....' .....11II,... ''''_'..''.'~'..,.. _..'."~ '''..' .,. .
'.......'.., ........ "..-. B'."-' .".'."'11II'-' ".. ..._' _...
'. ,., - '.....,...,.--, - II _
11'.".'_ ..'. _'. .'_. ..'-... '
I.' .' .-"-' ,- ' · .. .,. - ..... ."
" 11II._. _. _ ... ... .
".,.' ."".' .. II'" ....'.. ._,~., .,11II. ....'1...'.. . I" ..11II.. .,..... ...
1.11..,...'....'.'11. .. ........ .,.....,. .. I, ..,. i'., 11III_, ..,
........ .. 1I111111111. ... ·
" · illig, _,11II.. . r . ."_,.' .'..- ... .-'
......' .', . . -.. .'..'...
II... -' ...,11'--' .. -.... ., · · U" -.. _.. · IIIIIIIIIIII
" ' 11II. .. .-. ' . ' I'
'I"." .' .!!II,....,--- -.-.. · .'....-11. ",II' .-.~.
..............,._.. . --=-_ _, ..:1,1 ..,.., .1,""11II' .....'., ......, ,
..' --' .., '.' -.- ...' .". .'....'.' ..' ..... .... .'.... . "
'..' _, ...11II. . -.. ." _... ............' __ ... _, .. .. III .' ... I.
. ,-. ." ...... .' ..........' .'. . -..... . - ... .'11II'.
r, . .', -, '. ...... ... ' _. ..... ...,
- .. .. '. _11II .
..,..._, ". _", '.'., -,..... ...... 11II......,... .'...... ........... .,....
_..-' .... ....'. 11II.11I,:., .; -... .,. .. '. _ " -" '.." -. ... .. .
-.. . -... -'.
.' '. ,-.. . '."..,..' - -.. ... ...
I ~'.....' _....' ".;.'1." .-.. .,.'..'.. .-'.,...,. -.'.
II . __'.. , '__..._ .......'___...~-'.' 11II _. .... ___. _"
1"111II ' . ___-.." '_.11II'11II'.. .11.-'__'"
, ..... . ' __ III..... . '
I"".,p ,;...;r-IIII .' .....-- .-..... ..... .,.".. .'
g."", .' .. ... .. III.... ~.,. ., ... . · -.... .
. .......'. .,' . III'.""
'.'. - . ., ,-'. "..
...., '. .', '. III," '.. ..
'. ...." ., .... '., ,',
._"", . '" . _".
.' ;;....... ..,..,..-...... ... .,11II../.--",. "...__, if,.,....."..
. ..... ..:. -. II'. ' III I .. '
_ . ..... .. .. I. ..', . . IlII II
...,....=11,.. ".11II ......_..,'.., ...:.. ...'. .... ,.,:'; ,".' ," '."" !...
. ..". . -' -'
"
55
SELECTION CRITE
OFF-H1GHWA V VEHICLE
TVPES
QIf....ay MotoroyeJes (OHM~
MX
Enduro/WoodstTrail
Tnal$
Dual-Sport
";i
,
I,ll .""
t ~" h,.t 1"
'f.I t ,., fitt
:",1
-'".~,. ''''''''-"''''-''' -
Appendix V.D,5b.1
DESIRED EXPERIENCE
CONSIDERATIONS
Trails
Beginner
Intermediate
Advanced
Tracks (Practice and Events)
Motocross (MX)
Supercross (SX)
Trials Area
4WD Challenge C(lurse
Training Area
Safety
Basic Skills
Adult Beginners Practice Area
Yooth Practice andLE/amingArBa
Parking Area and.Pit Area
Picnic Area and PlayAl"Ela
$helter and Shade
Rest Rooms
ObS$IVation ArE/as
Camping Area
Concessions (Food, Parts, Service)
Maintenance, Administrative and Educational
Facilities
-.
Sf
IDENTIFY POTENTIAL OHV SITES
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Using GIS data (the process and results are detailed on the following page), analysis supplied by the MDCPRD, feed-
back from local OHV enthusiasts and other government agencies, and the site selection criteria, the Feasibility Study
Team identified a iist of prospective OHV areas (Figure 3). In totai, twenty three sites located in all areas of Miami-Dade
County were investigated. They are:
S8
Site
Surfside Landfill (former)
Vacant Lands near Dolphin Stadium
Opa-Iocka West Airport (former)
Countyline Motocross Park
Beacon Countyline, LLC
Industrial Lands in the Lake Belt Rock Min-
ing Area
NW 58th Street Landfill (former)
County-owned land surrounding Dade-Col-
lier Training and Transition (TNT) Airport
SW 8th St and Krome Avenue
Land Surrounding Everglades Correctional
Institution
SW 100th Street and Krome Avenue
SW 232nd Street and SW 217th Avenue
Rocky Glades (SFWMD - L-31-North Proj-
ect Area)
Homestead General Airport
Frog Pond (SFWMD - 15 acre fill pad)
SW 360th Street and 217th Avenue
Ingraham Highway and SW 217th Avenue
AeroJet General (former)
South Homestead Lands
Florida Rock and Sand (FRS) HDldings
East of the Speedway Lands
Priv. Land N.E. of Homestead Air Res. Base
South Dade Landfill (former) and CertDsa
Location
3900 NW 215th Street
NW 195-215th Streets, NW 17-27 Avenues
Countyline Road and U.S. Hwy 27
16665 NW 177th Avenue; within M. E. Thompson Park
NW 170th to 154th Streets, NW 107th to 97th Avenues
NW 154th to NW 58th Streets, NW 117-147 Avenues
NW 58th Street and NW 87th-97th Avenues
Collier County, off of Tamiami Trail, within Big Cypress Na-
tional Park
east of Krome Avenue (177th Avenue), west of 159th Avenue,
south of SW 8th Street, and north of SW 40th Street
west Df Krome Avenue, south of SW 8th Street
south of Rock mines, west of Krome Avenue, north of SW
100th Street, and east of SW 188th Avenue
SW 168th Street to SW 260th Street (west of L-31 canal),
borders ENP addition to the east
SW 28oth-296th Streets, SW 217th Avenue
SW 304th Street to SW 408th Street, bDrders ENP to the east
SW 456 Street and SW 232nd Avenue
two sites east Df US1 and Card Sound RDad and south of East
Palm Drive (Area #1 - northeast of where US1, Krome Avenue,
and Card Sound RDad converge; Area #2 - west Df SW 137th
Avenue and north of SW 376th Street)
East of Card SDuth RDad and south of SW 360th Street
east of the HDmestead Miami Speedway, south of North Canal
Drive (SW 328 Street), north Df Palm Drive
SW 256 Street and SW 97th Avenue
,4
t~~
/J}J
o'c.~
1; "<1'"
f:/1!X1!'
~'
]f
BROWARD COUNTY
~
i
I
I
Legend
.
.
.
Top candidates
(near and long term)
Less feasible under
existing conditions
Not feasible under
existing conditions
^
a
3
ro
~
ro
~
c
ro
Q
~
SW 8th Street
o
MIAMI-DADE
COUNTY
'\
o
Biscayne Bay
~~
-",,.,.
;
,
tl
o
~,
f
FIGURE 7:
SITES INVESTIGATED AS
POTENTIAL OHV FACILITIES
~
40
41
Appendix V.D.5b.1
GATHER ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON SITES
Site data was gathered from the County GIS, County Tax Assessors office, officials from DERM and SFWMD,
property owners and managers, and enthusiasts. A "data table" was completed for each site (see Figure
5 for sample template) with the best available information, thereby producing a snapshot of each potential
property and allowing the team to draw preliminary comparisons between sites. This step also included the
first of two surveys administered to local riders during the feasibility study. The "user appeal survey" was
distributed to the three general user groups in Miami-Dade County identified at earlier meetings: mud riders;
family-oriented ATV riders; and "challenge" riders. Riders were asked to rank potential sites on the list at the
time using criteria such as general appeal, size, and accessibility. The feedback from this survey was the
source for the "user appeal" criterion in the potential site ranking matrix.
After gathering data on each site, the team made site visits to get a more information on the properties that
appeared to meet a significant number of the criteria established in an earlier step. The team checked infor-
mation that could not be gathered from existing site data, aerial photos, and images alone.
Photos from October 10 2006 and November 14 2006 site visits
Photo sources: MDC Park and Recreation Department and WRT
4'
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Name
Folio Numberls1
Location
Owner
Site
Surrounding Properties
Size
Vacancv Status
Existina Land Use
Site
Existing Disturbance
(Y/N)
Surrounding Properties
Average Size of Adjacent
Parcels (# of parcels)
Zonina
Site
Surrounding Properties
Natural Features
Presence of Significant
Environmental
Considerations (e.g.
wetlands, EEL lands,
endangered species etc.1
Percent of Site Covered
bv Water
Accessibility
Proximity to Existing
Road Network
Distance to Closest
Highway
Currently Served by
Utilities (Y/N)
Assessment Information
Site East South West North
Land Value
Building
Value
Market Value
Assessed
Value
Total
Exemptions
Taxable
Value
Average cost per acre
(market value)
FIGURE 9:
DATA TABLE TEMPLATE
'15
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Next, a ranking matrix was created to quantify site attributes. The team generated eleven categories by which to evalu-
ate the sites. It is recognized that several of these variables overlap. For example, if a site contains wetlands, they will
impact not only the site's environmental consideration score, but also the cost to develop, and perhaps existing land use,
zoning, and ownership. The purpose of the ranking system is not to provide a definitive order from best to worst,
but rather to generate a relative, quantifiable basis for comparison. The categories are as follows:
/
. Size: based on acreage and/or adjacency to large, vacant parcels.
. Ownership: based on status as available for lease or purchase and status as publicly and
privately held
Existing land Use: based on current use of the site and those surrounding it
Zoning: based on current County zoning classification of the site and those surrounding it
. Environmental Consideration: based on the presence of wetlands (and basic understanding
that wetlands vary in functional value), officially protected land or species, existing contamina-
tion, reclamation needs, and existing disturbance.
. Accessibility: based on access to external, paved roadways and proximity to a major road-
way
Cost to Obtain: based on tax assessor's market value; if the land was not free to the County
through existing lease, management, or ownership or donation, the average cost per acre was
derived from market value. A "natural breaks" statistical method was used to assign sites as
"low", "moderate", "high", and "very high."
. Cost to Develop: based on existing vegetation and topography, generally and unofficially
estimated cost for reclamation, estimated cost for permitting and mitigation (e.g. wetlands),
estimated cost to control access, if necessary
. Recreation Features: based on the number of facilities that could be accommodated on the
site (including a safety instruction and training area; motocross track, kids trail, trail system for
off-highway motorcycles, trail system for ATVs, trail system for 4-wheel drive vehicles, 4-wheel
drive challenge course, motorcycle trials area, and field center including restrooms, food and
drink concessions, and shop parts, supplies, maintenance, and training video room) given the
size and shape of the site and the variety of levels of difficulty, based on size, configuration,
and existing topography.
. Appeal to Users: based on user appeal survey distributed to mud riders, challenge riders,
and family-oriented riders, sites were ranked as minimally appealing, moderately appealing,
and extremely appealing.
Site Availability: based on information from landowners and government agencies.
~
The first nine categories were subdivided into five point levels, with "1" being the least desirable and "5"
being the most desirable. The tenth category, Appeal to Users, was subdivided into three point values, 1
for minimally appealing, 3 for moderately appealing, and 5 for extremely appealing. The last category, Site
44
Availability, was designed as a "bonus point." If the availability of
a site was known to be a long term prospect it was assigned a
-1. Conversely, if a site's availability was known to be near-term
it was given a +1. If information about a site's availability was
unknown, it was given 0 points. The point distribution for all of
the categories was based on the criteria established during the
step "Identify Site Selection Criteria", feedback from users, land
managers and landowners, and information gathered while as-
sembling background information.
Certain categories-size, environmental consideration, cost to
acquire, and cost to develop-were deemed to have greater im-
pact on the feasibility of a site and therefore were given "double
weight." For instance, if a site was a level "5" for size because
it was 600 acres or larger, 10 points were contributed toward the
final score. Size was considered to be of elevated importance
because, while there is no one ideal acreage for an OHV park, it
was determined that, generally, the bigger the parcel, the greater
likelihood of being able to offer a large array of OHV recreation
features. Environmental consideration was double-weighted be-
cause one of the objectives of the study is to balance the needs of
OHV enthusiasts with the protection of natural resources. Cost to
acquire was deemed to have greater importance because funding
is limited and having to allocate fewer resources toward obtaining
a site leaves more money to spend developing it. Lastly, cost to
develop was double weighted because, again, funding is limited
and a site with existing features, such as vegetation and varied
topography, allows more money to be directed toward offering a
greater number of recreational features.
Sites were then ordered by total score, with the understanding
that sites ranking within a few points of one another merited
the same level of consideration. The matrix of criteria is on the
following page.
After each site was assigned a point value in each category, score
totals for each site were added up. The sites were first ranked by
each member of the team and then, after comparing notes from
the individual evaluations, by the group as a whole. The results of
the group evaluation are presented in Appendix II of this report.
RANKING MATRIX
Size
(Double Weight)
Ownership
Existing Land Use
Zoning
Environmental
Consideration
(Double Weight)
Accessibility
Cost to Acquire
Cost to Develop
(Double Weight)
Recreation Features
User Appeal
Bonus Point:
Site Availability
4
1
acres
Appendix V.D.5b.1
2
acres
OR
Mixed ownership and highly fragmented
AND
OR
site is zoned for agricultural and located
outside UDB
ANDIOR
[Rvir6Rfficntslly [ndsn9u-ed lBnd~ ([[l)
AND/OR OR
endangered species
AND/OR
major contamination with very high
reclamation costs
greater than five miles from a major
wetlands present, but of secondary quality
according to DERM
greater than five miles from a major
Appendix V.D.5b.1
3
4
5
acres
acres or more
OR
y
compatible uses
AND
surrounded by vacant land uses
OR
agricultural (and located inside UDB)
OR
AND
has minor existing contamination that would
generate low reclamation costs
OR
site sensitivity can be easily
accommodated/protected
OR
site is disturbed and has environmental
within a 5 mile radius of a major roadway
AND
within a 1 mile radius of a major roadway
adjacent to a major roadway
no cos
mo era e
no cos
OR
all essential costs covered by private
or more
recreational features
ex reme y appea Ing
NOTE: Strikeouts and blue text signify modifications to the original ranking matrix.
Changes were made when the original criteria did not fit the characteristics of a site
(blue text) or a criterion became a showstopper (strikeouts).
47
Appendix V.D.sb.l
SEEK FEEDBACK FROM STAKEHOLDERS AND ENTHUSIASTS
Following the distribution of a draft report in December 2006, the Consultants and MDCRPD met with
agencies and enthusiasts to receive feedback on preliminary findings, gather updated information on
sites on the list, and determine if there were any additional sites to review for consideration. Based on
these follow-up conversations, the MDCPRD identified three factors that are to be considered "show-
stoppers." in other words, certain individual site characteristics were deemed to contradict the mission
and values of the County and be so detrimental as to outweigh the sum of the other ranking criteria; if a
site possesses one or more of these characteristics, it could no longer be considered a feasible option.
Therefore, while a site may have been scored in the initial list, if it was previously obtained for conserva-
tion or mitigation purposes (e.g. EEL land and/or a site dedicated for mitigation), absolutely unappealing
to users, or a former County landfill site currently undergoing environmental remediation, that site was
ultimateiy removed from consideration.
.'$HOWSTOPPERS
~!i'?i,>:'.'."""";:_
"Sl~:'"
'"~E':'i,r;i-'- , , ""
, .,' ".J'ub!1c tcmd:obtalned for conservation or mitigation (EEL site and/or site
.0, .d'1atld for mItI.atlon)
"'i;',!:g"""""
:,;,~u,u..", unappealing to users
_.'...... currentfy undergoing environmental remediation
Photo source: http://artfiles.art.com/images/-/victor-aberdeen/Dirtywold-STOP-sign.Poster-C12220416.jpeg
A third meeting with enthusiasts, in a community workshop format, was held on January 24, 2007, at the
John D, Campbell Agricultural Center in Homestead, The user groups provided additional input on the
potential list of sites and reinforced their interest in particular locations. A second survey was distributed
at this workshop. Meeting attendees, around 200, were asked to complete a survey about the vehicle
types and desired experiences they would prefer to see accommodated at a Miami-Dade County OHV
facility and basic demographic information about area riders. Most of the riders that attended the meet-
ing and completed the survey are from the southwestern portion of the county. While the results indicate
there has been a surge in popularity over the last several years, OHV riding is not new to the area-the
average length of participation in the sport is seventeen years. Participation is frequent-about once per
week-and often occurs in larger groups-the average is thirteen. Riders are overwhelming interested
in ATVs, but also regularly ride trials and enduro/woods/trails bikes, They would like to see ATV trails at
all levels, trials areas, and 4WD challenge courses, but also basic skills, safety, and youth training areas
for less experienced riders, Overall, riders expressed a willingness to pay for entrance to an OHV facil-
ity, but they were split about their preference for an annual or daily pass system. See Appendix III for
complete results,
48
FIGURE 10:
SELECT ACQUISITION PROJECTS FOR T
MDC ENVIRONMENTALLY
ENDANGERED LANDS PROGRAM
DECEMBER 4,2001
BROWARD COUNTY
Source: Department of Environmental
Resource Management
^
a
3
~
~
~
"
c
~
SW 8th Street
4D
Legend
. 50% or more acquired
. On priority list
Biscayne Bay
,
,
ti
,
J
,4
'.tf"'"
[J,l'
~o~
f <I"
f~t
cr'
If
"
Appendix V.D.5b.1
...... <
;.i.~,
. .
- - .,.J'~' ~~...~ ...~~. . ,'. - , ~
, ,~. ,,".__... ,JIIItt._- "'.-. _iiq..... .
~-<,~- " '.~
:i ~-:\.: '::~"~ .. ~.-: ''''''lIII1I
.~.:,. > .
FIGURE 11:
SIGNAGE AT OCALA NATIONAL FOREST GUIDES OHV RIDERS TO ApPROPRIATE AREA
50
Appendix VD.5b.1
Following the release of the first draft of the feasibility study and the January 24 public workshop,
a stakeholder agency follow-up meeting was held on February 20, 2007 to verify the most current
and available information regarding the environmental, regulatory, and availability status of the
potential sites. At this meeting, in addition to the sites that were presented, representatives from
DERM recommended looking into lands east of the Homestead-Miami Speedway and lands at
SW 100th Street and Krome Avenue. And in the months following these two larger meetings, the
feasibility study team held several "one-an-one" meetings with agencies and enthusiasts to verify
the most current and available information.
INCORPORATE FEEDBACK AND UPDATE INFORMATION
Since the first draft of this document was presented for public review in December 2006, the
feasibility study has been substantially revised to reflect changed and additional information pro-
vided by stakeholders.
SUBMIT RECOMMENDATIONS
The final step in the process is condensed in this final report, and consists in submitting recom-
mendations to the MDCPRD.
\
)
51
~
Appendix V.D.5b.1
'~l...
',oy ~.
!II ~ rI
-"t.. i or." Ajt
~ 'N}.'
....
,,"..
..
.~ -t ~.
l ~l~
~. .
"'-~_.'
Appendix V.D.5b.1
III N EAR AND L ON GTE R M R E COM MEN D A T I ON S -)
H land surrounding TNT Airport
U East of Speedway lands
T FRS Holdings
D Countyline Motocross Park
C Opa-Iocka West Airport (former)
This Off-Highway Vehicle Trails
Feasibility Study is recommending
that the following sites be investi-
gated further:
These recommendations are
based on the results of the rank-
ing exercise as well as additional.
less quantifiable factors. This
two-pronged approach was used
in recognition that, while the rank-
ing matrix provides a useful, fact-
based comparison of the physical
suitability of the sites, it was not
designed to examine political as-
pects of public decision making,
shifts in the land market and other
less tangible considerations. Con-
sequently, some sites that initially
scored highly in the matrix are not
on the final list, while others which
scored in the "middle-of-the-pack"
are included. This compilation
tries to account for the best bal-
ance of factors that will expedite
implementation of a solution-with
the understanding that the plans,
costs, and circumstances of today
are subject to change.
,
!
I
SW8lhStreel
Biscayne Bay
'\
r-
---t= ,"
'--
'I,"
~ "
,
. . ~/~/
FIGURE 12:
RECOMMENDED SITES
--."
ss
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Lon Term
LAND
SURROUNDING
AIRPORT
Although owned by Miami-Dade County, this property is located in Collier
County, approximately 40 miles west of Miami on the north side of US 41 at
the Miami-Dade/Collier County line. The existing access road to the airport
is paved, meets current standards, supports traffic to the airport operations
complex, and does not impact any residential areas. The property is ap-
proximately 23,100 acres and contains wetlands. About 1,000 acres of the
site (completely fenced off) is a training & transition airport (paved runway
and taxiway with a temporary building as an operations & maintenance office)
used primarily for "touch and go" approaches by private and military aircraft.
The fenced-in airstrip. which is east and south of a paved access road from
US 41. would be off-limits to any recreational use. The remainder of the property was intended to be used for a new com-
mercial international airport that never was developed. There are a few (possibly several dozen) hunting "camp" sites
scattered throughout the remaining property. The County has a management plan for the remaining property; it must be
reviewed to identify any potential conflicts.
SITE CHARACTERISTICS
SIZE:
2,000 acres of a
23,100 acres site
EXISTING
LAND USE:
Big Cypress Na-
tional Preserve
SURROUNDING
LAND USES:
Big Cypress; TNT
Airport
TNT
The 20,000 acres (+/-) north of the fenced-in airstrip offer a much larger piece of property but pose the most challenges
to developing an OHV trail system. The 2,000 acres (+/-) south and east of the fenced-in airstrip would be the most at-
tractive area for an OHV trail system. It contains at least six man-made "Iakes" created when fill material was excavated.
Access to these mining sites was created by fill pad "roads" which remain to this day. This portion appears to be drier
than the area north of the airstrip.
Size Ownership Existing Zoning Environ. Accessi- Cast 10 Cost 10 Ree. Appeal to Bonus Tot. Score Tot Score
Land Use Consider. bilily Obtain Develop Features Users Point (unweighl) (weighted)
5 4 3 4 3 5 4 3 5 3 1 40 55
RANKING MATRIX SCORE
Pros
All of the property. which is sizable, is under single ownership. the County.
The remote location minimizes impact on other activities or developments, reducing the likelihood of problems with
adjoining property or land use issues. Noise, dust and light should not pose a significant issue for this site due to the
lack of any significant nearby residential or commercial areas.
Thousands of acres included in the north portion of the property can serve as a buffer to the Big Cypress National
Preserve. Canal 28 provides a buffer to the east. While there are a few individual home sites and camp sites located
to the south of the property, significant buffer area is available between the proposed trail system and the boundaries
of the property.
The "Iakes" and access "roads" could serve as the nucleus for an OHV trail system since they would provide elevated
areas. There also is a network of established "trails" (one-lane tracks) that could be used to created loops to connect
the pad areas of the "Iakes" and access "roads". These existing one-lane tracks must be used to create significant
distance and variety to create a loop trail system.
(
51>
Appendix V.D.5b.1
This access road could be used to provide ingress to trailheads for an OHV trail system.
Electrical and water and sewer services have been provided to the airport complex, but would need to be extended
to serve adjacent lands.
Cons
Due to the remote location of the site, the cross-jurisdictional complications, and the abundance of wildlife, the pro-
vision of emergency medical support is a big concern. It may require the presence of a full-time, on-site emergency
medical professional. However, the property contains an active airport with runways and radio communication
equipment that provides a ready-made site for helicopter transport to regional medical facilities.
The site is flat and much of the 23,100 acres may be subject to flooding during the wet season; Creating a trail
system will require track hardening and elevation in places to allow the connecting trails to be used in wet seasons.
This will require the inclusion of culverts and cross-drainage structures to allow water migration during the rainy
seasons. Water flow considerations would have to be incorporated in the design. Without investing significant
infrastructure costs, an OHV facility may only be able to operate for a portion of the year.
The majority of the property lies within Collier County. Under less-than-favorable traffic conditions it could be a 60
to 75 minute drive from some parts of Miami-Dade County.
While the property is outside of the Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow Protection and Restoration Area, there are other
species that will pose serious health and environmental issues, including poisonous snakes, bear, wild boar, ot-
ters, alligators, the horn billed wood stork, and panthers. Continued communication with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service will be necessary. The permitting process will be intensive because of these species, the presence of
wetlands, and the possibility of being partially within the Biscayne Aquifer.
There is a large population of deer, which attract hunters with firearms. Anecdotally, it has been reported that deer
can jump fences over 10 feet high and gamesmen will cut through the fences to get to them. Due to wetness,
aluminum fencing, which is expensive, would be necessary, but not guaranteed to be effective at separating OHV
riders from hunters.
--~ BROWARD\
~----+-~-----\,
I ! (
f~
Appendix V.D.5b.1
EAST
OF
SPEEDWAY
LANDS
During a review meeting of the first draft of this report, SFWMD
and DERM suggested looking east of the Homestead Speed-
way. Because of this site's recent inclusion in the study, its
recommendations is contingent upon additional due diligence,
including contacting the owner and determining willingness to
sell. The site is located south of North Canal Drive, north of
Palm Drive, east of the Speedway, and west of SW 117th Av-
enue. Comprising approximately 450 acres, these properties
are privately owned, subdivided into five to ten acres lots, lo-
cated outside the Urban Development Boundary, and contain
forested wetlands. Their adjacency to an existing, compatible, "noisy facility" makes the site an intrigu-
ing potential candidate. DERM indicated that immediate action is critical because EEL has identified this
spot as a medium-term "area of interest" for its South Dade Waterway Project.
SITE CHARACTERISTICS
SIZE:
450 acres :t
EXISTING
LAND USE:
vacant;
agricul-
ture
SURROUNDING
LAND USES:
Homestead-Miami
Speedway; va-
cant; agriculture
(
\.
Size Ownership Existing Zoning Environ. Accessi- Cost to Cost to Rec. Appeal to Bonus Tot. Score Tot. Score
Land Use Consider. bility Obtain Develop Features Users Point (unweight) (weighted)
4 1 4 4 2 3 2 4 5 5 0 34 46
RANKING MATRIX SCORE
Pros:
The site is adjacent to another noise gen-
erator, so there would be fewer compat-
ibility issues; there is no nearby residen-
tial development.
The size of the site creates opportunities
for a variety of recreational features.
General land values probably less than
Florida Rock and Sand land due to the
nearby "nuisance" factor.
Disturbed wetlands, lots of exotics - likely
to get permits with appropriate mitigation
proposal.
With appropriate boundary controls,
could be designed to be compatible with
EEL lands to be purchased nearby.
58
Cons:
Forested wetlands require permits.
This land was farmed until the 1950s, which
may necessitate remediation; it could have sig-
nificant implications on the cost to develop.
These sites are listed for EEL purchase. How-
ever, there are no current acquisition efforts.
The contiguous parcels are comprised of nearly
fifty private landowners. Most of the parcels
are approximately 10 acres. The overall cost
to obtain may be higher due to fragmentation in
ownership.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
.""
59
Lon Term
FLORIDA
ROCK
SITE CHARACTERISTICS
SIZE:
1,000 acres :I:
EXISTING
LAND USE:
vacant; agricul-
ture
SURROUNDING
LAND USES:
vacant; agrculture,
residential
Appendix VD.5b.1
&
SAND
HOLDINGS
Of the properties Florida Rock and Sand (FRS) owns in the area,
the specific sites under consideration comprise approximately
1,000 acres and are located south of SW 31st Court, north of SW
376th Street, east of SW 167th Avenue, and west of SW 152nd
Avenue. In light of the withdrawal of the Florida City Commons
Development of Regional Impact application, there might be an
opportunity to obtain a portion of the land for an OHV facility. Be-
cause of this site's recent inclusion in the study, its recommenda-
tions is contingent upon additional due diligence, including con-
tacting the owner and determining willingness to sell. The parcels
are outside the UDB (but within the municipal boundary for Florida
City), and are currently a mix of agriculture, vacant, and rock min-
ing.
Size Ownership Existing Zoning Environ. Accessi- Cost to Coslto Ree. Appeal to Bonus Tot. Score Tot. Score
land Use Consider. bilily Obtain Develop Features Users Point (unweight) (weighted)
5 1 3 1 1 5 2 5 5 5 0 33 46
RANKING MATRIX SCORE
Pros:
FRS holdings consist of a cluster of large,
blocks of land within close proximity. The size
of the site creates opportunities for a variety of
recreational features.
All of the property is owned be one entity,
FRS.
Cons:
The cost of obtaining this site is likely to be
very high.
The uncertain status of wetland permits (wet-
land jurisdiction is variable over these tracts)
could delay the process.
Potential obligations to complete mitigation
partly underway may create discontinuity be-
tween available parcels.
As former agricultural lands, the site may
necessitate remediation, which could have
significant implications on cost to obtain and
cost to develop.
There is already significant, existing distur-
bance. As is evident from a comparison of the
aerials in Figure 12, which was taken first, and
Figure 11, much of this land has been filled
in the recent past. If action is taken quickly,
the current dirt movement may be coordinated
with needs for an OHV park.
The property may be available.
"D
Appendix V.D.5b.1
~
-+0 """,,-,
:0
.0.
o
~~'
o
Photo sources: Google Earth, DERM
permitted for fill
Itlgation areas
ned properties
61
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Near Term
r
'-
COUNTYLINE
SITE CHARACTERISTICS
SIZE:
40 acres of a 620
acre site
EXISTING
LAND USE:
Motocross park
SURROUNDING
LAND USES:
vacant; agrculture,
residential
MOTOCROSS
PARK
The 40-acre Countyline Motocross is within the 620-acre Milton E. Thomp-
son Park, which is located in the northwest corner of County on the east side
of NW 177th Avenue (Krome) approximately two miles south of US Highway
27 (Okeechobee Road). Only 40 acres are suited to recreation activities
due to environmental constraints. It is owned by the State of Florida (Trust-
ees of the Internal Improvement Fund) and is managed by the MDCPRD.
It was formerly developed as a campground, then redeveloped into an RV
campground and subsequently closed over a decade ago. A campground of-
fice/rest room facility building remains on the site but was partially destroyed
by fire since the campground has been closed.
A private vendor negotiated a short-term lease with the County to operate the motocross practice track on the site. The
agreement expired at the end of May 2007; the vendor will continue on a month-to-month basis until the MDCPRD is-
sues a Request for Proposal and selects a vendor to commit to a five-year contract. The track, known as Countyline
Motocross Park, is designed for MX competition motorcycles. Primary use of the facility occurs on weekends.
Increased buffering, fencing, and signage needs to be considered to improve protection of the adjacent wetlands from
both iegal and illegal activities. The vendor who wins the five year contract will be required to install buffering to prevent
riders from entering the environmentally sensitive areas. As managers of the forty-acre property, the Park and Recre-
ation Department is responsible for "policing" the site and ensuring that users of the site are restricted to areas in which
they are permitted.
The current use of the site for a MX track may be the most effective use of a 40-acre site. However, it must be recog-
nized that while a MX motorcycle track provides a needed place for a small segment of the Miami-Dade County OHV
public to recreate, it does not offer a large enough area or a wide enough variety of OHV recreation experiences to
satisfy the demand in Miami-Dade County.
Size Ownership Existing Zoning Environ. Accessi- Cost to Cost to Rec. Appeal to Bonus Tal. Score Tal. Score
Land Use Consider. bility Obtain Develop Features Users Point (unweight) (weighted)
1 4 3 4 5 5 5 5 2 3 1 38 54
RANKING MATRIX SCORE
Pros
The vendor is in the process of installing utility poles and stadium lighting fixtures to allow nighttime operation of
the track.
There is a paved access road from Krome Avenue and a major highway (US 27) is located within two miles.
It may be possible to add a small off-highway motorcycle and ATV training area that could be used by Motorcycle
Safety Foundation and ATV Safety Institute instructors.
There are no adjacent residential or commerciai areas.
In order to provide restrooms, concessions, and storage (i.e. "field house") of the quality typically found in a Mi-
..
-+c..'""" ~
..
ami-Dade County park, the County may want to consider rebuilding and perhaps even relocating the structure within the
forty available acres. This could create more room and opportunities for an improved configuration for the permitted OHV
facilities.
A small portion of the 40 acre upland portion of the site may be used as a kiosk and trailhead for the Krome Trail, a proposed
greenway along the adjacent l-31 North leveee.
Cons
There are only 40 acres of usable uplands within the 640-acre site and those upland acres are clustered near the entrance
from Krome Avenue; only six percent of the total acreage can be utilized for OHV recreation. The 40 usable acres accom-
modate a small Motocross (MX) track and provide a limited number of parking slots, but will not provide space for any non-
competitive OHV activities such as recreational trail riding.
Regardless of whether there is an increase in Park attendance when the lights are installed, increased buffering and fenc-
ing from the adjacent wetlands may be necessary. According the Miami-Dade County Solid Waste Department, which is
responsible for a portion of the wetlands in M.E. Thompson Park as part of their mitigation commitments, it has had to re-
peatedly repair damage to the vegetation caused by illegal OHV use.
The existing building on the site has been damaged by fire and vandalism and may be beyond repair.
Users indicated that while Countyline Motocross Park is working well as a motocross facility, the site is too small and per-
haps too dry to accommodate additional OHV facilities.
65
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Near Term
QpA-LOCKA
SITE CHARACTERISTICS
SIZE:
416 acres
EXISTING
LAND USE:
vacant; decom-
missioned airport
SURROUNDING vacant, mining
LAND USES:
WEST
AIRPORT
(FORMER)
This 416-acre site is located in the northwest corner of Miami-Dade County
on the east side of US Highway 27 (Okeechobee Road) at the intersection
with Countyline Road. Access is from a major divided highway (US 27) and
the site is located close to Florida's Turnpike. It is a decommissioned airport
owned by Miami-Dade County.
Adjacent land to the west is owned by SFWMD. land to the east and south is
currently being mined. It is necessary to explore Broward County's develop-
ment plans for the property just north of the site; it may be part of the City of
Miramar.
There are two existing paved runways. The runway does not need to be maintained; it could be removed. The concrete
jersey barriers on the runways would need to be removed if OHVs were to use this site. The County has entered into a
short-term lease with a private vendor to operate a drag strip on one of the existing runways. The Aviation Department
plans to cease the lease within eight months to one year.
,
The County Aviation Department has announced plans to sell 90 percent of the property to a private mining company-the
east edge will probably be sold separately for development of a commercial use. According to the Miami-Dade County
Aviation Department, the time frame for rock mining is not absolutely certain, but they hope to complete the sale by the
end of 2008. Because it is unknown which company will win the Department's Request for Quote and ultimately purchase
the property, it is unknown whether the mining company will begin operations immediately or hold the site for a later time.
If the latter occurs, there may be a possibility to negotiate a lease with the new owner until it is ready to mine.
Size Ownership Existing Zoning Environ. Accessi- Cost to Cost to Rec. Appeal to Bonus Tot. Score Tal. Score
land Use Consider. bility Obtain Develop Features Users Point (unweight) (weighted)
4 4 4 4 4 5 4 4 3 5 -1 40 56
RANKING MATRIX SCORE
Pros
There are no adjacent residential or commercial areas.
This site is very appealing to users because it is large, far from neighborhoods, full of trees, muddy enough for mud
riders, and suitable for several types of riders.
Cons
According to DERM, this property is in the C-g wetland basin and any portion of the site not currently developed is ju-
risdictional wetlands. A Class IV wetlands environmental assessment would be necessary and all applicable wetland
10'1
Appendix V.D.5b.1
----
regulations would need to be followed. In addition, DERM would require a formal letter of support for use of
the property as an OHV facility from the Miami-Dade County Planning and Zoning Department. This process
is likely to take at least nine months, the majority of the anticipated window of time before the Aviation Depart-
ment sells the property.
Due to the uncertainty and the timeline for permitting, it is recommended that this site be viewed as no more
than a short-term, interim option that could be used while developing one or more of the long term recommen-
dations.
65
.. -- ~
--~ ,
Appendix V.D.5b.1
I V . ANALYSIS OF OTHER SITES
R AeroJet General (former)
E Beacon Countyline, llC
o Frog Pond (SFWMD - 15 acre fill pad)
N Homestead General Airport
F Industrial lands in the lake Belt Rock Mining Area
Q Ingraham Highway and SW 217th Avenue
G NW 58th Street landfill (former)
W South Dade Landfill (former) and Certosa
S South Homestead lands
A Surfside landfill (former)
K SW 100th Street and Krome Avenue
B Vacant lands near Dolphin Stadium
l SW 232nd Street and SW 217th Avenue
P SW 360th Street and 217th Avenue
I SW 8th St and Krome Avenue
V Priv. Land N. E. of Homestead Air Res. Base
M Rocky Glades (SFWMD - l-31-North Project Area)
^
a
I
>
I
-j
The following sites were investigated but,
based on upon existing conditions, have
been deemed to have either very low or no
potential of feasibility given current circum-
stances.
Q
SWSlhSlreet
.
--1
Q' - ~
_0
I
..',
p
.,(
,I
~
---f
Biscayne Bay
The sites' location, ownership, size, vacancy
status, site and surrounding land uses, zon-
ing status, natural features, environmental
considerations, accessibility, cost to obtain
and develop, and general political feasibility
were examined, but for one or more signifi-
cant reasons-explained in bold at the be-
ginning of each site's profile-they are not
currently viable candidates. If adverse circumstances change, the Team recognizes a site may merit reevaluation; how-
ever, in most cases, this is not likely in the foreseeable future.
,
"
~\
I{
.~
~
FIGURE 19:
LESS FEASIBLE AND UNFEASIBLE SITES
'1
69
Appendix V.D.5b.1
AEROJET GENERAL (FORMER)
The size and configuration of available area is not suited to developing a satisfactory OHV facility. Unless
these conditions change, the site should not be given further consideration.
The site known as AeroJet General (former), located one mile east of Everglades National Park and on SW 408th
Street, was operational as a rocket booster plant from the 1960s until the 1980s and is currently owned by the SFWMD.
Access to this site, which is approximately 10 miles west of US Highway 1, is from Ingraham Highway. The entire site
is in excess of 24,000 acres; the portion described as the old factory site is approximately 1,300 acres. The area of-
fered for potential OHV trail use (approximately 100 acres) includes the upland area of the old factory site only-the
fill pads and entrance road associated with the former booster rocket assembly facilities- and is available for lease
or purchase by Miami-Dade County. The remainder of the site is not available now or in the future because of its en-
vironmental sensitivity. The wetlands are designated as critical habitat for the Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow and are
legislatively protected from development.
This site would offer a trail riding experience far from the urban areas of Miami-Dade County and close to the Ever-
glades National Park. The existing remnant AeroJet buildings would provide a trail user with an opportunity to see a
part of Florida's space history. Remodeling of existing buildings may also provide a concession facility or other trail-
head feature. The remote location of this site would eliminate any potential OHV/residential compatibility issues.
('
Accommodating parking and traffic could pose a challenge; the two lane paved road connecting the entrance of the
AeroJet site to the fill pads offered for OHV use can not be widened, torn up, or partially blocked because it is cradled
by wetlands and it is used by nature enthusiasts for access to other portions of the site. Two facilities in particular at-
tract recreational fisherman and bird watchers: Lucky Hammock, one of the most popular birding sites in the County,
and an aquaculture center, which has several fishing piers.
The design would have to take into consideration the site's proximity to the main entrance to Everglades National Park,
which is within one mile. Everglades National Park officials are concerned about potential noise and light pollution,
both of which could undermine the intent Parks' legislative designation as a "wilderness area." Again, proper buffering
will be critical.
Trails within the fill pad areas would require consideration (i.e. trail layout, buffers, fencing, etc.) of the adjacent wetland
areas that are preserved as part of the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan. Trail mileage would be limited
by the shape of the parcel and the linear layout of the existing roads and other paved areas. The SFWMD plans for
the areas adjacent to this site would limit future expansion of OHV trails at this location.
Based on feedback from the surveys and during community meetings, the user appeal of this site is high. However, it
appears that a significant portion of those providing feedback based their rank of this site not on what SFWMD offered
for OHV trails-100 acres of upland, fill pad-but rather use of the entire site, wetlands included. Because the size,
configuration, vegetation, and ability to design for a range of experiences and vehicle types of the actual site is much
more limited than what voters appeared to vote on, the feedback may be misleading.
70
Appendix V.D.5b.1
71
Appendix V.D.5b.1
BEACON COUNTYLlNE, LLC
This site does not warrant further consideration due to constraints on the redevelopment of a
capped landfill, lack of appeal to users, and acquisition costs.
This privately owned site in northwest Miami-Dade County was formerly used as a construction and demolition recycling
and disposal landfill and has recently been considered for re-development as an industrial/office park and as a potential
location for a new Florida Marlins stadium.
The size and square layout of this site would allow a good trail design with multiple loops and long trail distances. The site
is bordered by the Florida Turnpike and Interstate 75, therefore perimeter buffers between OHV uses and the roadways
would not be required. Residential areas are located approximately 0.5 miles east of the site on the east side of Interstate
75. Access to this site is good since there is an interchange from Interstate 75 southeast of the site directly to NW 138th
Street. The location would maximize the use of the site by Miami-Dade and Broward County residents.
The potential development of this parcel as well as the unknown landfill capping (formal closing of the landfill) costs are
likely to result in this site being too expensive as an OHV recreation facility. It is also unknown if the property is for sale;
it may be unavailable. Coordination between Miami-Dade County and the City of Hialeah and the Florida Department of
Environmental Protection would be required during the acquisition and design of this site.
User feedback indicated hesitancy over this site because of its former use as a landfill and the resultant condition of the
soil.
Photo source: Google Earth
7'1
Appendix V.D.5b.1
FROG POND (SFWMD-15 ACRE FILL PAD)
Due to small size and access issues, this site
does not warrant further investigation at this time.
This 15 acre site is located in southwest Miami-Dade
County within a large (5000 acre:!:) SFWMD restoration
project. The property is long and narrow. This site is
difficult to access by vehicle because there is no paved
road. Access from the south and east is blocked by a
canal, from the west by the Everglades National Park,
and from the north via an unimproved north-south berm
that requires high-clearance vehicles. Potential tres-
pass issues exist with active agricultural uses immedi-
ately to the east of the access berm and with National
Park land along the western boundary of the property.
However, this site should be considered as a potential
site for OHV trails if adjacent lands are designated for
access, trailheads, or OHV trails.
Based on feedback from the surveys and during com-
munity meetings, the user appeal of this site is high; it
was noted appealing to a variety of types of riders and
it is far from residential development. However, it ap-
pears that a significant portion of those providing feed-
back based their rank of this site not on what SFWMD
offered for OHV trails-15 acres of fill pad-but rather
use of the entire site. Because the size, configuration,
vegetation, and ability to design for a range of expe-
riences and vehicle types of the actual site is much
more limited than what voters appeared to vote on, the
feedback may be misleading.
Photo source: Google Earth
n
Appendix V.D.5b,1
HOMESTEAD GENERAL AIRPORT
The portion of the site currently offered for OHV use is too small
to justify continued consideration of this site,
This 700-acre:t property is located in southwest Miami-Dade County at SW 280th Street and SW 217th Avenue. It is
owned by the County and operated by the Aviation Department. Since the majority of the property is utilized for airport
operations, only a 20 acre parcel outside of the fenced in airport has been offered for an OHV park. The size of the
site prevents it from further consideration as a stand-alone option. It may have use as a trailhead/access point to
adjacent SFWMD land known as Rocky Glades (see Section III); however its potential is remote because the cost to
restore or replace the bridge connecting the two sites is estimated to be prohibitive.
There are several small parcels on the northern and western borders of the site which the Aviation Department has
leased to agricultural operations, and these small parcels (as well as several small, adjacent privately-owned parcels)
might be considered for small trailheads to access Rocky Glades. There are no adjacent residential areas.
Access to these potential trailheads from SW 217th Avenue would be via an unimproved road (SW 280th Street)
that would require upgrading. There is a closed bridge across the l-31 North canal that connects the site to Rocky
Glades, but the cost to inspect and repair or replace the bridge to allow OHV-only or limited-load vehicular traffic is
not known.
Based on feedback from the surveys, the user appeal of this site is high. It was noted as great for all types of riders,
especially"mudders." However, it appears that a significant portion of those providing feedback based their rank of
this site not on what the Aviation Department offered for OHV trails-20 acres on the western portion of the site-but
rather use of a larger, different portion. Because the size, configuration, vegetation, and ability to design for a range
of experiences and vehicle types of the actual site is much more limited than what voters appeared to vote on, the
feedback may be misleading.
Photo source: Google Earth
7'1
Appendix V.D.5b.1
INDUSTRIAL LANDS IN THE LAKE BELT ROCK MINING AREA
Due to ongoing legal challenges and significant environmental constraints, this site is not currently a
viable candidate for an OHV facility.
This 22,000 acre:t collection of properties is owned by a few private corporations (including Rinker Materials, Titan
Corporation and Vecellio & Grogan). It is located in northwest Miami-Dade County north of NW 25th Street, west of
Florida's Turnpike and east of NW 157th Avenue. While the site is large, land is disturbed, and access is good, the
limitations are overwheiming.
DERM directed the Consultant team to the SFWMD website for information on the lake Belt Plan Phase II, which
influences the type and extent of activities that can occur in this unique area of Miami-Dade County. The website
indicates that approximately 50 percent of the land within the lake Belt Area is owned by the mining industry, 25 per-
cent is owned by government agencies, and the remaining 25 percent is owned by non-mining private landowners.
Although the Vision for the future of the lake Belt includes a recreation component, it specifically refers to "opportuni-
ties afforded by the wetlands and waterways," suggesting that passive recreational uses were those contemplated in
the plan.
The Northwest Wellfield is located at the eastern edge of the lake Belt, and is the largest drinking water wellfield
in the State, supplying some 40 percent of the potable water for Miami-Dade County. The lake Belt Plan and the
Northwest Wellfield Protection Plan preclude development activity and public access to the wellfield area, and impose
limitations on the types of uses and extent of development to minimize potential impacts on drinking water supplies.
Other potential limitations include the planned long-term use of the area as a water reservoir, as part of the Ever-
glades Restoration Plan.
A decision is pending on the Sierra Club v. Flowers lawsuit. The lawsuit jeopardizes the future of limestone mining in
the area. A judge issued an opinion in 2006 that the government agencies had not properly followed procedures in
evaluating and authorizing continued limestone mining operations in the lake Belt. The permits in question are for
the mines operating under the Lake Belt Plan. A decision against the mining operations mayor may not benefit a
potential OHV use in the area. land acquisition, development, and mitigation costs could be substantial.
The Pensucco Wetlands are iocated to the west, separated from the Lake Belt by an FPl easement. Accessibility and
light/noise pollution would have to be minimized to protect this sensitive area from disturbance. DERM may be able
to offer the MDCPRD slime sludge from the WASA well to use a source of base material for OHV trails.
Based on the user appeal survey, riders of all types of OHVs were attracted to the size of the site and the potential
range of activities that could be offered. The soil accommodates multiple types of riders, including mudders and
dirtbike racers.
75
Appendix V.D.5b.1
INGRAHAM HIGHWAY AND SW 217TH AVENUE
Due to the potential presence of contaminants and present agricultural use, this site is not being recom-
mended for further consideration.
This site, located north and south of Ingraham Highway in the southwest part of the County, consists of several
contiguous parcels of property (approximately 150 acres per parcel) that, combined, total approximately 625
acres. Although located in a remote part of the county, the site is easily accessed directly from Ingraham High-
way, approximately 6 miles west of US Highway 1.
Currently, the property is used for agricultural purposes and located outside of the Urban Development Boundary
(UDB). While this site would not be subject to Miami-Dade County's policy on "no net loss" of agricultural land,
the MDCPRD strongly supports the spirit of the policy and not developing on farmland outside the UDB. The
Agricultural Practices Study Advisory Board has stated that they would oppose an OHV facility on this site. The
site would need to be tested for arsenic and other carcinogens often present in the soil of formerly farmed land.
Contaminants would have significant implications on cost to obtain and cost to develop.
Since the site has been used for agricultural purposes, there is limited existing vegetation that could be used to
design interesting OHV trails. Site planning would need to consider the creation of features on the site to make
an enjoyable OHV experience (i.e. excavation of areas, creation of topography, planting, etc.). As a cost coun-
terbalance, with use of design features like trail switchbacks, it may be possible to compress the footprint of the
OHV facility and purchase only a portion of the 600 acre site, thereby reducing acquisition costs.
The site is contiguous to publicly owned lands (SFWMD) so the opportunity exists to extend trails offsite at a later
date. However, a crossing of the C-111 canal would be necessary to connect this site with the adjacent former
AeroJet site. The other adjacent land-uses include low-density residential areas and other agricultural uses and,
therefore, no incompatibility issues have been identified at this site.
The design would need to take into consideration the site's proximity to the main entrance to Everglades National
Park. Everglades National Park officials are concerned about potential noise and light pollution, both of which
could undermine the intent of the Park's legislative designation as a "wilderness area." Proper buffering would
be critical.
Round Hammock, a high quality water habitat in Miami-Dade County, is located on the southern portion of the
site. It and the immediate adjacent land have been granted Natural Forest Community Protection, thereby
restricting the maximum allowable development of this portion of the property to 20 percent. Mitigation require-
ments would apply to any impacted areas of this portion of the site.
76
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Similar to the other privately-owned property identified in this report, the willingness of the owner to sell or lease the property
is not known at this time; the property is not listed for sale and a search for the owner's contact information based on the
property appraiser's database did not yield results.
According to the User Appeal Survey, some riders were satisfied with the size of this site while others found it small. Gener-
ally, however, they thought the size could accommodate several types of riders and is in "good condition."
77
Appendix V.D.5b.1
NW 58TH STREET LANDFILL (FORMER)
This site does not warrant further consideration due to constraints on the redevelopment of a
capped landfill and strong lack of appeal to users.
The County's Solid Waste Management Department owns this site located in the north half of the county and consist-
ing of approximately 400 acres. The southern third of this site has been reserved for other recreation facilities (soccer
fields) and other County department facilities. The north part of the site contains an environmentally protected area.
The remaining area identified for potential OHV trail use is approximately 200 acres. There are paved roads leading
to the site, making it accessible from either the Turnpike or the Palmetto Expressway via NW 58th Street.
This former Superfund site underwent "enhanced closure" between 1 991 and 1995. These additional safety mea-
sures included drainage and stormwater controls. The entire site is covered with an interrelated stormwater system
of ditches, swales, culverts, energy dissipaters, and stilling basins. The eastern fifth of the site, a large hill totaling
approximately 80 acres, is covered by a PVC liner and has gas vents protruding at the surface level. Therefore, riding
would be prohibited on this portion of the site; proper fencing or buffering would be necessary. Any changes to the
stormwater management of the site would require approval from the State of Florida.
The northern third of the western four fifths of the site is covered by wetlands, which serve as a stormwater mitigation
basin and recharge area for the aquifer. The wetlands provide habitat for two protected species, wood storks and bald
eagles, as well as for flamingos, ospreys, and alligators.
78
Appendix V.D.5b.1
The site's groundwater is tested at several locations. If gasoline
were detected from OHV uses or otherwise, the County would be
liable to install a remediation system. Currently, the surface water
quality is good.
Because the landfill was operated between 1952 and 1982 when
there were fewer safety and environmental regulations, the Solid
Waste Management Department is concerned about the presence
of toxins in the soil. For example, the groundwater still contains
high levels of ammonia. In addition to any ensuing health hazards,
they are uneasy about having the potential of having two highly
flammable substances, methane hydrogen sulfate produced by the
landfill and gasoline used by OHVs, intermingle.
The Solid Waste Management Department used this site as a hur-
ricane debris station following Hurricane Wilma in 2005. Because
of the success of this staging area, Solid Waste Management is
reluctant to endorse other uses of this site.
The north, east, and west edges of the site are bordered by in-
dustrial uses, therefore OHV recreation would be compatible with
the neighbors. The area north of the County-owned landfill parcel
is currently being mined and there may be an opportunity in the
future to extend OHV trails farther north once the mining operation
is complete.
While the topography and location of this site adjacent to devel-
oped areas seemingly creates the potential for a unique urban
OHV riding experience, the regulations associated with the former
Superfund site all but prohibit the interesting integration of these
features. In addition, the lack of trees or other brush on site would
require designing artificial obstacles and/or substantial plantings to
create OHV trails.
In the User Appeal Survey, this site received a very negative re-
sponse from OHV enthusiasts who were concerned about health
and safety issues related to soil contamination and the dryness of
the site for mudding. This opinion was reiterated at the January
2007 community workshop.
79
Appendix V.D.5b.1
SOUTH DADE LANDFILL (FORMER) B CERTOSA HOLDINGS, LLC
This site does not warrant further consideration due to constraints on the redevelopment of a
capped landfill and strong lack of appeal to users.
This former landfill site (approximately 107 acres) is
currently owned by Miami-Dade County (Public Works
and Solid Waste Management Departments). The site
is currently restricted from public access (fenced) and
contains a stormwater management system, methane
and leachate monitoring systems, and a grass-cov-
ered cap over the former landfill area. The area used
previously as a landfill is approximately 15 to 20 feet
above the surrounding elevations.
This site provides very good vehicular access from
the existing road network. There is an existing turn-
pike exit approximately 1.5 miles west of the site that
connects to SW 248th Street (a paved roadway to the
site). The closest residential area is approximately
one mile from the site and the existing surrounding
land uses would be consistent with OHV recreation
use (i.e. agricultural and landfill uses are adjacent to
the site). The site is outside the UDB; therefore, future
compatibility issues would be minimal. There may be
an opportunity to purchase additional property to the
south and west in the future to expand the park or trail
system.
80
landfill closure requirements include a 30-year moni-
toring and maintenance procedure. Additional coordi-
nation with the Solid Waste Management Department
and the Florida Department of Environmental Protec-
tion would be required to identify all issues related to
using portions of a closed landfill for OHV trails. This
may include changes to the FDEP permit, design of
the trail to include an additional barrier between the
bottom of the trail and the top of the landfill, and fenc-
ing/barriers around existing monitoring or mainte-
nance features within the landfill. Although this site
would be closer than any other available legal OHV
trail area adjacent to the County, the southern location
of this site would require a drive across the County for
residents in the northern part of the County.
This site received a very negative response from OHV
enthusiasts who were concerned about health and
safety issues related to soil contamination and the dry-
ness of the site for mudding.
Appendix VD.5b.1
Photo source: Google Earth
81
SOUTH HOMESTEAD LANDS
Appendix V.D.5b.1
These two sites are not candidates for further consideration because of their status as mitigation land
or DERM-protected land.
This site includes areas east of US1 and Card Sound Road
and south of East Palm Drive in the southeast part of the
County. This location contains existing trails and disturbed
areas that have been used by enthusiasts and has been
described as "The Hump" riding area. Within this general
area, there appear to be two separate places that contain
trails. Trail Area One is generally located northeast of where
US1, Krome Avenue, and Card Sound Road converge. It
has been used as a staging point for enthusiasts and con-
tains privately owned lots ranging in size from 10 to 20
acres. Approximately 2.5 miles southeast of this location,
there is another spot with a high concentration of existing
trails. This second area contains several larger, contigu-
ous lots (ranging in size from 76 acres to 144 acres) total-
ing approximately 750 acres on which the existing trails are
located. The two major landowners are 640 Homestead
Co., lLC, and FRS Holdings, Inc. The land between these
two areas is used for agricultural operations. Nearby roads
are narrow, unpaved farm roads.
The wetlands in this section are dominated by high quality
sawgrass prairie that is dotted with native-dominated tree
islands and scattered buttonwood stands. Although there
is some melaleuca present, it is scattered and generally of
low density, therefore the wetland function is considered to
be very high. Obtaining wetland permits would likely be ac-
companied by a large mitigation requirement. Eight of the
parcels lie within the boundaries of the South Dade Wet-
lands EEL Project, which was designated for acquisition in
1994 because of its environmental sensitivity. Acquisition
of parcels by EEL is ongoing in this area and DERM has
indicated that ATV riding is not considered a compatible
recreational use for EEL sites.
User appeal of this site was extremely high. OHV enthu-
siasts, many of which are familiar with the location, terrain,
and muddiness of the site, have deemed the South Home-
stead lands "great for all riders and all types of OHVs."
811
SURFSIDE LANDFILL (FORMER)
Appendix V.D.5b.1
This site does not warrant further consideration due to the potential presence of hazardous substances
and strong lack of appeal to users.
This site is privately owned and contains approxi-
mately 161 acres. A portion of the site (approximately
98 acres) was formerly used as a landfill. Based on
DERM records, there may be ammonia and chlorinated
solvents located at this site that may increase start-up
costs (need to consider reclamation/clean-up costs and
risks to OHV users). It is anticipated that some of the
site may be developed as an auto auction facility in the
future. The status and exact location of the former land-
fill has not been determined.
The site is located within the City of Miami Gardens in
the northern part of the County and is easily accessible
from the surrounding road network. The existing canal
to the south and the Turnpike to the north provide good
buffers from neighboring uses. There are residential ar-
eas within approximately 200 feet of the south and east
property lines that would need to be considered during
site planning and design. An existing landfill located to
the west would be compatible with OHV use. The site
is currently restricted from public access by an 8' high
chain link fence in good condition that would also pro-
vide good containment of trails onsite. The topography
and vegetation on the site would provide an enjoyable
trail-riding experience for OHV enthusiasts and would
offer ample opportunity for creative trails and destina-
tion features.
This site received a very negative response from OHV
enthusiasts who were concerned about health and
safety issues related to soil contamination and the dry-
ness of the site for mudding.
85
Appendix V.D.5b.1
SW lOaTH STREET AND KROME AVENUE
This site does not warrant additional consideration due to its likely high cost, its proximity to residen-
tial development, adjacency to a Everglades Seepage Control structure, and current agricultural use.
SW 100th Street and Krome is located in the southwest portion of the County, approaching the Everglades. This 412 acre
property was recommended for analysis by representatives from DERM and the South Florida Water Management District.
It is under single, private ownership and zoned agricultural. Its size and single-owner status is appealing. However, there
are several factors that reduce its feasibility. Its market value (estimated by the property appraiser's office to be $26.7 million
in 2006) is very high. It is bordered on the south by residential development. As an agricultural property located outside the
UDB, it would probably generate opposition from the Agricultural Practices Study Advisory Board. And lastly, the Everglades
National Park Seepage Management Project, which is ongoing, is planning to locate a levee which would run along the
eastern border of the site-the most logical access point for an OHV facility.
84
Appendix VD.5b.1
VACANT LANDS NEAR DOLPHIN STADIUM
This site is not recommended for further consideration because of the disconnectedness
of the properties and the lack of appeal to users.
Although originally listed as a potential site for OHV recreation several issues were identified that resulted in
this site not being ranked in the final scoring matrix. OHV trails would not be compatible with the existing over-
flow parking use during sporting events on the site. In addition, maintenance and design requirements may
limit the ability to negotiate a suitable lease with the property owner.
The user appeal of this collection of sites was very low. It was perceived to be unsafe for unattended vehicles
and trailers, too small for multiple riders, and too dry for mud riders. However, the amount of trees makes the
site good for scrambling and passive riding.
a5
Appendix V.D.5b.1
SW 232ND STREET AND SW 217TH AVENUE
Due to the potential presence of contaminants and present agricultural use, this site is not being recom.
mended for further consideration.
This 640-acre parcel is privately owned land adjacent to the l-31 North canal and west of SW 217th Avenue (at the
north end). Access to the site for an OHV facility would probably be via SW 232nd Street from Krome Avenue.
Users found this site appealing because of its location, size, and ability to accommodate several types of riders,
particularly mud riders.
Currently, the property is used for agricultural purposes. The site will need to be tested for arsenic and other
carcinogens often present in the soil of formerly farmed land. This could have significant implications for cost.
Although an OHV facility would not be subject to Miami-Dade County's "no net loss" policy, the MDCPRD would
prefer to respect the spirit of the policy and not develop agricultural land outside the UDB. Also, the Agricultural
Practices Study Advisory Board has stated that they would oppose an OHV facility on this site.
This property is not listed for sale or lease. However, the owner was confirmed to be owned by a willing seller by a
MDCPRD staff who specializes in parkland acquisition. Independentiy of the OHV Trail Feasibility Study, the park-
land acquisition department has been researching the property for potential purchase. There may be substantial
competing interest in this property to either create additional residential homes or retain the existing agricultural
use.
While DERM would not support residential on this property because of the site's proximity to a flood protection le-
vee, the potential demand may still cause the market value (or estimated cost to obtain) of the property to become
prohibitively high. With use of design features such as trail switchbacks, it may be possible to compact the footprint
of the OHV facility and purchase only a portion of the 600 acre site, thereby reducing the cost to obtain. If buffered
properly, the agencies see public use of the property as a better transition to the Everglades National Park than
residential development.
DERM and SFWMD view the existing buffers created by the roads to the north (SW 232nd Street), south (SW 248th
Street) and west (SW 217th Avenue), and l-31 North Canal to the west as a plus, a way to contain riders and keep
them from trespassing on prohibited, environmentally sensitive areas. However, should the decision be made to
pursue a connection to the publicly owned lands to the west of the l-31 North Canal (referred to as Rocky Glades
and described in greater depth in section III.H of this report), several small, privately owned, parcels in agricultural
use would need to be purchased or a suitable access easement obtained. Coordination with SFWMD and a bridge
crossing of the l-31 North canal would also be required for future expansion.
The configuration and size of the property would allow for a variety of OHV recreation uses on the site. However,
the lack of existing vegetation and natural terrain at this site would require additional design considerations.
86
Appendix VD.5b.1
The traffic generated by an OHV park and its impact on the adjacent residential neighborhood to the east would require
a traffic impact study and thoughtful design. Residential areas along the east and south edges of this property would
need to be considered (noise buffers) during the site plan process for the OHV facility. According to the Miami-Dade
County Police Agricultural Patrol, in other parts of the County there have been repeated reports of conflict between OHV
riders and property owners in adjacent residential areas. Because this site is located directly west of residential develop-
ment, the Agricultural Patrol called attention to the possibility that OHV use on this site will raise strong opposition from
neighbors.
87
Appendix V.D.5b.1
SW 360TH STREET AND 217TH AVENUE
Due to the potential presence of contaminants and present agricultural use, this site is not being rec-
ommended for further consideration,
This site is comprised of several individual parcels of
privately owned land under the same ownership. The
total contiguous acreage with the same owner is ap-
proximately 621 acres and the property abuts another
privately owned property to the south that contains
approximately 1,170 acres.
There is a series of interconnected natural water fea-
tures meandering throughout the property. These in-
clude loveland Hammock, which is managed by EEL,
hook-shaped jurisdictional wetlands known as love-
land Slough, and a second smaller hammock on the
eastern edge of the property. The slough divides the
property into two pieces, raising design and engineer-
ing questions with potentially costly answers: Can the
slough be crossed by a bridge? If so, what is the cost
of a bridge structurally sound enough to carry OHV
traffic and long enough to clear sensitive lands? If
not, would additional parcels need to be purchased to
create a "connector trail" between the pieces? If both
sides of the property were developed, what types of
buffers would be necessary to keep people from taking
a shortcut through the slough to get between sides?
While the complete answers to these questions are
for a later stage in this process, they merit consider-
ation during the feasibility phase. Should the site be
chosen for further consideration, a full environmental
assessment would be necessary to ensure the design
of an OHV park on this site is environmentally sen-
sitive and fully compliant with all associated regula-
tions. In addition, the need for adequate fencing and
88
buffering should be taken into consideration as part of
cost to develop projections. According to DERM of-
ficials, portions of this property have been discussed
in association with the CERP C-111 Spreader Canal
flow-way reconstruction project; while there no imme-
diate plans for this site, cooperation and communica-
tion with related agencies is necessary.
Similar to the other privately owned property identified
in this study, this site is not listed for sale or lease and
a search for the owner's contact information based
on the property appraiser's database did not yield re-
sults. Therefore the ability and cost to purchase the
property is not known.
This site configuration and size would allow a myriad
of OHV recreational opportunities. Other than the
aforementioned sensitive water features, there do
not appear to be any significant on-site restraints that
would limit development of an OHV park that includes
a lengthy network of trails. With use of design fea-
tures like trail switchbacks, it may be possible to com-
pact the footprint of the OHV facility and purchase
only a portion of the 600 acre site, thereby reducing
the cost to obtain.
This property is currently used for agricultural purpos-
es. Therefore, it is subject to Miami-Dade County's
policy on "no net loss" of agricultural land. The Ag-
ricultural Practices Study Advisory Board has stated
that they would oppose an OHV facility on this site.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
This has significant implications on cost to obtain and cost to develop. The site will need to be tested for arsenic and
other carcinogens often present in the soil of formerly farmed land.
Surrounding uses are not ideal. Most of the property within 1,000 feet is agricultural and, according to the Miami-
Dade Police Agricultural Patrol, the relationship between farmers and OHV users in Miami-Dade County has grown
increasingly contentious as cases of crop vandalism have become more common. While this does not merit removal
of this site from further consideration, the increased need for fencing and buffering between neighbors must be fac-
tored into the cost to develop.
Access to this area could be provided by one mile of paved roadway (SW 217th Avenue) from Ingraham Highway, but
the design must take into consideration the site's proximity to the main entrance to Everglades National Park, which
is within one mile. Evergiades National Park officials are concerned about potential noise and light pollution, both of
which could undermine the intent Parks' legislative designation as a "wilderness area." Again, proper buffering will
be critical.
Some of the users indicated that they thought this site was small. However, because they have referred to other sites
of equal or less acreage as being big, there may have been confusion over the actual property in question.
89
Appendix V.D.5b.1
SW 8TH STREET AND KROME AVENUE
This site is not currently for lease or sale, and is therefore not available
for consideration for OHV use.
This site was suggested by several of the attendees
of the January 24th, 2007 Miami-Dade County OHV
Trails Feasibility Study Public Workshop, as well as
several prior stakeholder meetings. The agencies
were aware this site has been historically popular with
OHV users. Aerial photography showing OHV tracks
throughout the properties corroborates this.
(
DERM, SFWMD, and the Miami-Dade County Agricul-
tural Patrol agreed that the land acquisition challeng-
es of this site would be immense. The Miccosukee
Tribe of Indians owns a large number of parcels along
the northern and eastern edges fronting the road, the
southeast corner was recently platted with several
hundred 50' by 100' lots, and many of the interior par-
cels are used for mitigation purposes. Plus, this area
may become a target of CERP's Bird Drive Recharge
Project, which is seeking to establish an area adjacent
to Krome and 8th Street for reservoirs to stockpile wa-
ter and stop seepage out of the Everglades.
In a conversation with representatives from the Mic-
cosukee Tribe, the Miami-Dade County Park and Rec-
reation Department reported there seems to be little
receptiveness on the Tribe's part to the idea of sur-
rendering land on these properties to OHV use, on the
basis of environmental and liability issues.
In addition, according to the Miami-Dade County Ag-
ricultural Patrol, there have been repeated reports of
conflict between OHV riders and property owners in
the densely populated residential area to the east.
The site contains a lot of Melaleuca, which is prone to
catch fire and generate significant amounts of smoke.
There have been several fires over the years, which
the Agricultural Patrol suspects were the result of ar-
son or tailpipe emissions from unauthorized OHV use
mixing with the dry vegetation.
/
\
90
Appendix VD.5b.1
LANDS SURROUNDING HOMESTEAD AIR RESERVE BASE
Due to the site's present agricultural use, it is not being recommended for further consideration.
This "site" is loosely comprised of lands to the north and east of the Homestead Air Reserve Base (HARB), an area which
contains several sizable parcels (up to 160 acres) under single ownership. Most of the properties are used for row-crop
agriculture (e.g. Alger Farms-S of HARB; Barry M. Brandt Trust-SW and N of HARB), tree farming (e.g. Manuel Diaz farms
N of HARB, and several smaller tree farm companies E of HARB), or mining (e.g. Singletary Concrete Products, which
owns over 1,000 contiguous acres, mostly rock mining lakes). One to two miles west of HARB (S of SW 312th Street) is
the north end of the FPl mitigation lands and some SFWMD land; much of this is part of the Acceler8 Water Plan, which
would likely make it difficult or not possible to obtain fill permits.
The property is within an area targeted by the Agricultural Practices Study Advisory Board for continued farming, and the
Board has indicated that it would not be in favor of this site for OHV use.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
LAND SOUTH OF EVERGLADES CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION
Due to significant environmental, archaeological, and access factors, this site is not recom-
mended for additional investigation at this time.
The property, which is approximately 730 acres in total, is located west of Krome, east of the l-31 Canal, and
just less than a mile south of SW 8th Street. It is comprised of two parcels. The first is 209 acres and owned
by the Department of Justice (owned by the Army Corps of Engineers until June 2007); it has no direct access
to Krome, but rather has ingress/egress via a narrow strip of land connecting it to the Everglades Correction
Institution to the north. Throughout its history the property has been used for a variety of activities, including a
processing center for illegal immigrants and alleged CIA operations and Nike missile site. Today, it has fallen
into disrepair and appears to be used mostly for paintball and unauthorized graffiti-ing. The second parcel,
which surrounds the former, totals 524 acres and is privately owned by la Primera International Corporation.
Both properties are categorized as "unzoned."
According to the DERM, Wetlands section, all of the 524, privately owned acres are "high quality" wetlands
and, therefore, developing this site in any way would be extremely challenging. Not only is there a high like-
lihood the Park and Recreation Department would be denied the necessary permits, the process would be
subject to the approval of the Miami-Dade County Planning and Zoning Department, who would have to en-
dorse an OHV facility on land currently designated as "open land/vacant." In addition to these obstacles, the
site also contains archaeological "midden" or deposits such as shells, bones, and refuse that indicate human
settlement, and environmentaiiy valuable tree islands.
'III
Appendix V.D.5b.1
9S
/
,
,
'-
t'"
i"
/
{
\.
Appendix VD.5b.1
ROCKY GLADES (SFWMD- L-31 N, PROJECT AREA)
This 5000-acret site is located on the western edge of Miami-Dade County, south of SW 168th Street and north of
SW 288th Street. It is a long (7 to 7.5 miles) and narrow (between .25 miles wide in the south to 1 mile wide in the
north) property bounded on the west by the Everglades National Park and on the east by the l-31 North Canal. Ac-
cess on the north end is via SW 168th Street. Krome Avenue is approximately 4 miles away, and does not provide
direct access to the site.
"Rocky Glades" is a series of properties owned by SFWMD, purchased for an environmental engineering water
conduction project, the components of which include two levees, several pump stations, impoundments, reservoirs,
and the canal system. SFWMD rules do not permit the riding of OHVs on levees; as such, there is no access to the
levees nor along the canals, which are currently protected by a Yo mile wide buffer of eight to ten foot tall grasses.
SFWMD has indicated that, in consideration of its goals for water storage and the improvement of water quality at
Rocky Glades and the construction timeline for the project, utilization of the property for either short-term or long-
term off-highway vehicle use would not be appropriate. The District requested that the this site not be utilized for
OHV use.
The large size of the site and the existing vegetation offer the potential for an extensive, designated trail system in a
non-urban setting. However, the site would present challenges in design, construction, operation and maintenance
that would require unique solutions. In order to protect sensitive areas and water management structures, facilities
and agricultural operations, this site would require a substantial investment in trail marking, user education and on-
the-ground enforcement presence.
While there are very few residential parcels in the vicinity and a limited number of private in-holdings within the site,
there would likely be competing interest in the land from the farmers who owned the property prior to the project.
However, according to SFWMD, some of the land-particularly to the west near the reservoirs-is likely to be too
wet to farm or ride year round.
User appeal of this site was moderate to high. While it was only the 5th most popular site at the January 2007
public meeting, results from the surveys indicated that it was good for trails, wet enough for mudding, in a location
accessible to all County residents, and has an appealing mix of vegetation.
9'1
Appendix V.D.5b.1
. '~.' .~~",..
'" ".11."...,<;;,~ . -.'.'
':").,J,]\ .~""""'''''.
::' ~,~ <<
;"
---.-..,-"
\
~-
~'
Appendix V.D.5b.1
v.
CONCLUSIONS
The results of the Off Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study indicate that while there is no single, ideal site
for an OHV facility in Miami-Dade County, there are several that merit further investigation (See Appendix for
complete rankings results). It is highly recommended that the County pursue these options simultaneously,
rather than one at a time. Due to the changing nature of conditions, there is no definitive order of suitability.
However, land Surrounding TNT Airport appears to offer the greatest opportunity for long term development
of multi-purpose OHV facilities. FRS Holdings and land East of the Speedway also offer a possibility for a
long term solution, however the time and money associated with the assembly of private parcels may prove
to be prohibitive.
'"'"\
I
The Countyline Motocross Park in Milton E. Thompson Park is well suited for the conditions of the site and
provides a location where a small portion of the OHV public-motocross users- can recreate. Therefore,
it is recommended to continue the current operation, while recognizing that this motocross motorcycle track
alone does not offer a large enough area or a wide enough variety of OHV recreation experiences to satisfy
the demand in Miami-Dade County. Based on its current popularity as a practice motocross track, and future
potential as a MX competition track with lighting for evening events, the Park and Recreation Department
should continue to pursue approval from the State to issue a RFP for eligible vendors. The RFP process will
allow the Park and Recreation Department to enter into a long term, formal agreement with a private vendor
to operate the site, and increase the likelihood of making this facility a permanent fixture.
'\
)
Acknowledging the intent to conduct future mining operations, the Opa-Iocka West Airport site will likely
serve, at best, as an interim solution. However, if the plans for mining do not come to fruition or an agreement
can be reached that allows both uses on the site, this facility could have long term possibilities.
NEXT STEPS
After review by the MDCPRD and stakeholder agencies, the recommendations in this report were presented
to the public at large at a meeting on July 18, 2007. Subsequently, the MDCPRD will brief the Board of County
Commissioners on the results of the study, and request support to pursue grant funding through the State Di-
vision of Forestry and the State DEP Office of Greenways and Trails for acquisition, design, and construction
through upcoming grant cycles. The MDCPRD is in the process of establishing a strategy for pursuing two
or more OHV recreation sites simultaneously. In the interim, the MDCPRD will continue to carry forward its
intent to issue an RFP to select a private operator for the Countyline Motocross Park on a five-year lease.
\
,
99
t.
-.
ApPENDIX:
PROJECT TEAM
Funded by a grant from DOF, WRT and its sub-consultants, Jack Terrell of the
National Off-Highway Vehicle Conservation Commission, and Scott Lamb P.E. of
lamb and Associates, have been working on this feasibility study with the MD-
CPRD since April 2006.
WRT is a widely recognized planning and design firm with a long-time presence
in, and in-depth familiarity of, Miami-Dade County. WRT has built a nationwide
reputation for its planning and design of parks of all types and scales. Princi-
pal Gerald Marston, FASlA, and Associate Silvia E. Vargas, AICP, lEED@ AP,
served as the team leaders and project managers; Project Planner lindsey With-
row, lEED@AP, conducted the site suitability analysis. These professionals also
brought to the team their vast experience in conducting public participation and
consensus-building processes.
Jack Terrell served as the team's OHV expert. As Project Coordinator for the NO-
HVCC, Mr. Terrell has been responsible for planning, and conducting Off-High-
way Vehicle Recreation Management workshops for national, state and local land
managers and landowners, and Association Development workshops for OHV
enthusiasts and other recreation stakeholders. For the past six years, Mr. Ter-
rell has been the Chair of the Florida OHV Advisory Committee, and previously
served in a variety of committees and organizations dedicated to the advance-
ment of responsible OHV recreation. Mr. Terrell has been a trail rider and cross
country motorcycle competitor since 1960.
Scott lamb, P.E., of Lamb and Associates Inc., served as the study's civil and
environmental engineering consultant. In addition to his professional credentials,
Mr. lamb brings to the team the experience of his long-time involvement in OHV
activities, including but not limited to the NOHVCC (Florida State Representative);
Florida Trail Riders (12 year member/racer); and American Motorcyclist Associa-
tion (12 year member). Mr. Lamb also constructed and marked hare scramble
and enduro trails (e.g. annual Croom, Richloam, and Daytona enduros and FTR
Benefit Hare Scramble).
The Consultant Team worked closely with, and under the direct supervision of the
MDCPRD's Assistant Director for Planning and Development, Barbara Falsey,
Chief of the Planning and Research Division, Maria Nardi, Park System Plan-
ning Section Supervisor, Mark Heinicke, Park Planner 3, and James A. McCall,
Park Planner 2/Project Manager. Prior to hiring the consultants, the Department
conducted a preliminary background study on OHV parks throughout the Country,
with an emphasis on the riding situation in Florida.
Appendix V.D.5b.1
ApPENDIX II: SCORING OF POTENTIAL SITES BASrij)ndixvD5b1
ON RANKING MATRIX
Size Ownership Existing Land Zoning Environmental Accessibility
Use Considerations
Opa-Iocka West Airport 4 4 4 4 4 5
former)
Land surrounding 5 4 3 4 3 5
TNT Airoort
Countyline Motocross Park 1 4 3 4 5 5
Rocky Glades-SFWMD 5 3 3 4 4 3
Ingraham Hwy and SW 5 1 5 1 2 5
217th Avenue
SW 360th Street and 217th 5 1 5 1 2 4
Avenue
Florida Rock and Sand 5 1 3 1 1 5
Holdinas
East of Speedway Lands 4 1 4 4 2 3
SW 232nd Street and SW 5 1 5 1 2 4
217th Avenue
NW 58th Street Landfill 4 4 4 4 2 5
I'formerl
Private land N.E. of 4 1 5 1 2 5
Homestead ARB
Indust. Lands- Lake Belt 5 1 2 4 1 5
Rock Minina Area
SW lOath St and Krome 4 1 1 4 4 5
Ave,
SW 8th St and Krome Ave, 5 1 1 4 1 5
South Dade Landfill 2 4 3 4 4 5
'former) and Certosa
Aerojet General (former) 1 3 3 4 2 3
Beacon Countyline, LLC 5 1 4 4 2 5
South Homestead Lands 3 1 3 4 1 2
Surfs ide Landfill (former) 2 2 2 4 2 5
104
Appendix VD.5b.1
Cost to Acquire Cost to Develop Recreation Appeal to Users Bonus Point Total Score Total Score
Features (Availability) (unweighted) (weighted) *
4 4 3 5 -1 40 56
4 3 5 3 1 40 55
5 5 2 3 1 38 54
4 3 5 5 -1 38 54
3 3 4 5 0 34 47
3 3 4 5 0 33 46
2 5 5 5 0 33 46
2 4 5 5 0 34 46
2 3 4 5 0 32 44
4 2 3 1 .1 32 44
1 4 5 5 0 33 44
2 4 4 5 -1 32 44
2 3 4 3 0 31 44
2 3 5 5 -1 31 42
4 1 2 1 -1 29 40
4 2 2 5 1 30 39
1 1 4 3 0 30 39
1 3 5 5 0 28 36
1 2 4 1 -1 24 31
*Note: The weighted total was derived by multiplying the scores received for the double weight categories (size, environmen-
tal considerations, cost to acquire, and cost to develop) by two and adding the sum of those scores to the sum of the scores
in the remaining categories.
105
Appendix V.D.5b.1
ApPENDIX III: ENTHUSIAST SURVEY #2 RESULTS SUMMARY
January 24, 2007 Community Workshop Survey Feedback
Miami-Dade County Off-Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study
A survey was administered to attendees of the Wednesday, January 24th, 2007
Miami-Dade County Off-Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study Community
Workshop. From the 140 surveys that were returned, data was gathered about
Miami-Dade County OHV enthusiasts' basic demographic information, riding
habits, vehicles types, desired experiences at-and willingness to pay for the use
of-an OHV recreation area.
BASIC DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION
AGE (average): 34
GENDER (percent): 81% Men; 19% Women
LOCATION WITHIN COUNTY (percent):
N 5%
S 14%
E 6%
W 4%
NE 1%
NW 4%
...S.E................................,.................................1.%.....,
! SW 60% !
hUNRNOWiir........'..................,.................S%......
RIDING HABITS
LENGTH OF OHV PARTICIPATION (average):
FREQUENCY OF PARTICIPATION (average):
SIZE OF GROUP (average):
17 years
51 times per year (Le., weekly)
13 persons
PREFERRED VEHICLE TYPES
There are four vehicle type categories; Off-Highway Motorcycles (MX,
Enduro/WoodslTrail, Trials, Dual-Sport), All Terrain Vehicles (Sport, Utility), Four
Wheel Drive Vehicles (Jeep, SUV, Truck), and Other Motorized Vehicles (Dune
Buggy, Rail, Swamp Buggy), Survey participants were asked to mark which
vehicle or vehicles they would like to see accommodated at an OHV facility.
UTILITY
SPORT
TRAILS
ENDUROIWOODSITRAILS
TRUCK
DUAL-SPORT
106 votes
98
67
63
63
43
106
MX
SWAMP BUGGY
JEEP
SUV
DUNE BUGGY
RAIL
40
37
32
29
22
19
Appendix VD.5b.1
DESIRED EXPERIENCES
Enthusiasts were asked to check the facilities and amenities they would like to
have in an OHV recreation area in Miami-Dade County,
RECREATION FACILITIES:
TRAILS-ADVANCED
TRAILS-INTERMEDIATE
TRIALS AREA
BASIC SKILLS TRAINING AREA
YOUTH PRACTICE AND LEARNING AREA
TRAILS-BEGINNER
SAFETY TRAINING AREA
4WD CHALLENGE COURSE
PIT AREA
ADULT BEGINNERS PRACTICE AREA
MOTOCROSS (MX) TRACK
SUPERCROSS(SX)TRACK
SUPPORT FACILlTES
PARKING AREA
REST ROOMS
PICNIC AREA
CAMPING AREA
SHELTER/SHADE
SHOWERS
CONCESSIONS
MAINTENANCE, ADMINISTRATIVE
AND EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES
PLAY AREA
OBSERVATION AREAS
120 votes
108
100
98
97
94
92
92
84
75
66
42
123 votes
118
109
108
85
77
67
59
56
54
In addition to the facilities listed above, survey participants indicated interest in a
mudding area, a fire pit, a bike cleaning station, ATV rental, and youth trails.
WILLINGNESS TO PAY (percent)
YES 79%
YES, but prefer annual pass to daily pass 9%
NO 13%
107
ApPENDIX IV: PHOTO INVENTORY
Appendix V.D.5b.1
LAND AROUND
TNT AIRPORT
Photo source: WRT
108
Appendix V.D.5b.1
109
Appendix V.D.5b.1
QpA-LOCKA WEST
AIRPORT
Photo source: WRT
110
Appendix VD.5b,1
COUNTYLlNE
MOTOCROSS PARK
Photo source: WRT
~
III
EAST OF
SPEEDWAY LANDS
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
III
Appendix V.D.5b.1
-~\]
1--1
:.:;:;; I
"
1
Appendix VD.5b.1
FRS HOLDINGS
115
SW 100TH ST. AND
KROME AVE.
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
Appendix V.O.5b.1
11'1
LAND SOUTH OF EVER-
GLADES CORREC. INSTN
Appendix V.D.5b.1
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
lIS
SOUTH DADE
LANDFILL
Photo source: WRT
Appendix V.D.5b.1
II'
Appendix V.D.5b.1
117
AEROJET GENERAL
(FORMER)
Photo source: WRT
,rA
Appendix VD.5b.1
118
Appendix V.D.5b.1
58TH ST. LANDFILL
Photo source: WRT
FROG POND
Photo source: WRT
119
FORMER SURFSIDE
LANDFILL
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
ItO
Appendix V.D.5b.1
BEACON
COUNTYLlNE
Appendix VD.5b.1
MDC Park and Recreation Department
Photo source:
III
Appendix V.D.5b.1
1 lit
ROCKY GLADES
Photo source: WRT
Appendix VD.5b.1
115
HOMESTEAD
GENERAL AIRPORT
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
114
ACANT LANDS NEAR
DOLPHIN STAD.
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
Appendix V.D.5b.1
lIS
Appendix V.D.5b.1
INGRAHAM HWY &
SW 217TH AVE.
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
SW 360TH ST. &
SW 217TH AVE.
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
It6
Appendix V.D.5b.1
5W 232ND 51. &
5W 2171H AVE.
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
11I7
Appendix VD.5b.1
LAND NE OF
HOMESTEAD ARB
F;;it/..
,"cc,c .
,,'~~
fJ"
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
i-
,-
~
~'t4~~~
.:
118
5W 8TH 5T. AND
KROME AVE.
Photo source: MDC Park and Recreation Department
Appendix V.D.5b.1
~'-" . - ~.. .
-;:,
119
ApPENDIX V:
Appendix VD.5b.1
FLYER FROM ATV ENTHUSIAST RALLY
For "P'. dnaIt viii;
FloridCl R.TV RCllly lit Fl'l'lual Florida FlTV Qalllj
III \IOU OIU\ CIIl f\lY Of' DII Lbl... CII\,cI care aboub ~ Q place t;o ride. \IOU tpvc t;o at;tcflCl.
This rally has been organized to bring all off road enthusiasts together to take a stand. We as taxpaying, voting
and hard working citizens will be heard as one voice on this day. If you don't like driving for hours to get to legal
riding places, then come out and be heard.
Bring your atv's, dinbilres and UTV's to show the public how much we all love and jnvest in our sport or hobby. There
will be coverage by several media ourie.. and hopefully some of our elected officials &om the state and local levels
will be there as well
There will also be several dealers on site to show their support as well as their products. There is a motocross track
and trails for those who want to ride (for a separate fee - payable to Quicktrack MX). If you need to camp for the night
RV's, trailet'S and tents are welcome at no additional cost (primitive only).
This will be a history making event that will set a precedent for all rallies in the future. Bring your whole family
as wen as your food and drinks to make a day out of it. Several'peaker. for the cause will be on hand and making
presentations. If we all stand as one, we can make a difference.
potVOIl
FlollJ""".coIll
~.coIll
,"",ldelllo" /pedu.....
.........1pCltlU ee.., 0# 0tIcIIld0
JllilII'l'llolllQ"';I\f.DdDllIOI\,
I{lVA...I4Cl.C1CNtl
/....... n.. 9lICld /erIu . //ljlll\<Otl\.
Trecuwe Cocull ttoI\.da ~
1\ -1\1IloOot1pCltlU. CIlle) IV""lI'I
fI\IT COf\JT PClUl8l/PClQT/
TIte r.-d c........, ItrboClll, IltoIlIr..od\. ~ eo.v-., 'IIl01\, ClIti
1\1Ol........IlI.co1ll. ~ IIlle
~_2007 ~ ~Otf"i/zr'lll'1\,
~r~ ~lIleJ\l
CoI*at II-. 111._
150
Appendix V.D.5b.1
ApPENDIX VI:
SOURCES
Montgomery, J.M. & Reckord. langus riverfront park off road vehicle feasibility study. Report pre-
pared for Everett, City of Everett, Parks and Recreation
Lacey, R. M., Balbach, H. E., Baran, R. S., Graff, R. G., & Construction Engineering Research labo-
ratory. (1980). Evaluation of areas for off-road recreational motorcycle use. Champaign, IL. Spring-
field, Va., Construction Engineering Research laboratory:
National Technical Information Service distributor.
lacey, R. M., Severinghaus, W. D., & Construction Engineering Research laboratory. (1981). Evalu-
ation of lands for off-road recreational four-wheel drive vehicle use. Champaign, IL.Springfield, Va.,
Construction Engineering Research laboratory U.S. Army Corps of Engineers: National Technical
Information Center distributor.
Off-highway Safety and Recreation Off-Highway Vehicle Safety and Recreation Act Report (http://
www.fl-dof.com/forest_recreation/OHVSafetyand RecreationActReprt. pdf)
Big Cypress National Preserve ORV Use Guidelines (hltp:/Iwww.nps.gov/archive/bicy/newrules.
htm)
A TVSource .com (http://www.atvsource.com/articles/articles/2006/052406 _places_to _ride_croom_
ohv_area_fl.htm)
hltp://www.fidof.com/forest_recreation/ohv_private.html
The Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Division of Forestry. Off-Highway
Vehicie Guidebook.
Fogg, George E. Park Guidelines for Off-Highway Vehicles: A Resource Guide to Assist in the Plan-
ning, Development, Enhancement, and Operation of OHV Recreation Facilities, National Recreation
and Park Association and National Off-Highway Vehicle Conservation Council. 2002
III
APPENDIX V.D.5b.2
COLLIER COUNTY PARK AND
RECREATION DEPARTMENT
LETTER
COLLIER COUNTY DIVISON OF PUBLIC SERVICES
Parks and Recreation Department
15000 Livingslt>n Road - Naples, Florida 34109 - Phone (239) 252-4000 - Fax (239) 252-8657
Website: colliergov.nel
June 2, 2009
Mr. Kevin Asher
Park Plannerl Project Manager
275 NW 2nd Street
Miami, Florida 33128
Dear Kevin:
Please find enclosed a Resolution that will be presented to the Collier County Board of
County Commissioners on June 9, 2009 for approval. The Resolution supports the
development of the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department's effort to create
a recreation area, ~Iusive of Off-Highway Vehicle use, at the Transition and Training
Jetport (1NT A.irpQrt) site located in Dade and Collier Counties, The Resolution is
evidence of Collier~ounty Parks and Recreation desire to work closely with Miami-Dade
County Park and R!lcreation Department to achieve Collier County goals and objectives
related to increased locations to enjoy this recreational pursuit.
As you're aware, Qlllier County has actively been in search of suitable park land to offer
recreational and OHV activities. In 2003, South Florida Water Management District
(SFWMD) and Colijer County entered into an agreement to provide 640 acres for all terrain
vehicles (OHV) llCttvity and later amended the agreement in 2007 to provide a temporary
site for OHV's a10~ with a pennanent site at Lake Trafford. While we have carefully
investigated a number of other Conservation designated lands in Collier and Hendry
Counties, it appears that TNT has great potential to meet pennitting requirements and
establish itself as a premium off road destination for Dade and Collier citizens alike.
If you need further :information or have questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at
(239) 252-4035
Sincerely, I
~;:V~
. t!{lj./< Ditector
Collie;~ P8fk!I and Recreation
Naples, Florida 34109
Appendix V.D.5b,2
,,,..,.,.,,.'.".,H."""_"........'........,,
APPENDIX V.D.Sb.3
F.S. 260.03, DEFINITION OF OHV
Appendix V.D.5b.3
Definition of OHV
Section 261,03 Definitions (partial)
(1) "Advisory committee" means the Off-Highway Vehicle Recreation
Advisory Committee created by s. 261 ,04,
(6) "Off-highway vehicle" means any ATV, two-rider ATV, or OHM that is
used off the roads or highways of this state and that is not registered and
licensed for highway use under chapter 320,
(9) "System" means the off-highway vehicle recreation areas and trails on
public lands within the state,
Section 261 .20
Operations of off-highway vehicles on public lands; restrictions; safety
courses; required equipment; prohibited acts; penalties.
(1) This section applies only to the operation of off-highway vehicles on
public lands,
(2) Any person operating an off-highway vehicle as permitted in this
section who has not attained 16 years of age must be supervised by an
adult while operating the off-highway vehicle,
(3) Effective July 1,2008, while operating an off-highway vehicle, a person
who has not attained 16 years of age must have in his or her possession a
certificate evidencing the satisfactory completion of an approved off-
highway vehicle safety course in this state or another jurisdiction, A
nonresident who has not attained 16 years of age and who is in this state
temporarily for a period not to exceed 30 days is exempt from this
subsection. Nothing contained in this chapter shall prohibit an agency
from requiring additional safety-education courses for all operators.
(4) (a) The department shall approve all off-highway vehicle public safety-
education programs required by this chapter as a condition for operating
on public lands,
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 1 of 3
Appendix V.D.5b.3
(b) An off-highway vehicle must be equipped with a spark arrester that is
approved by the United States Department of Agriculture Forest Service, a
braking system, and a muffler, all in operating condition,
(cIOn and after July 1,2008, off-highway vehicles, when operating
pursuant to this chapter, shall be equipped with a silencer or other device
which limits sound emissions. Exhaust noise must not exceed 96 decibels in
the A-weighting scale for vehicles manufactured after January 1, 1986, or
99 decibels in the A-weighting scale for vehicles manufactured before
January 1, 1986, when measured from a distance of 20 inches using test
procedures established by the Society of Automotive Engineers under
Standard J-1287, Off-highway vehicle manufacturers or their agents prior
to the sale to the general public in this state of any new off-highway
vehicle model manufactured after January 1, 2008, shall provide to the
department revolutions-per-minute data needed to conduct the J-1287
test. where applicable,
(d) An off-highway vehicle that is operated between sunset and sunrise,
or when visibility is reduced because of rain, smoke, or smog, must display
a lighted headlamp and taillamp unless the use of such lights is prohibited
by other laws, such as a prohibition on the use of lights when hunting at
night.
(e) An off-highway vehicle that is used in certain organized and
sanctioned competitive events being held on a closed course may be
exempted by departmental rule from any equipment requirement in this
subsection,
(5) It is a violation of this section:
(a) To carry a passenger on an off-highway vehicle, unless the machine is
specifically designed by the manufacturer to carry an operator and a
single passenger.
(b) To operate an off-highway vehicle while under the influence of
alcohol, a controlled substance, or any prescription or over-the-counter
drug that impairs vision or motor condition.
(c) For a person who has not attained 16 years of age, to operate an off-
highway vehicle without wearing eye protection, over-the-ankle boots,
and a safety helmet that is approved by the United States Department of
Transportation or Snell Memorial Foundation,
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 2 of 3
Appendix V.D.5b.3
(d) To operate an off-highway vehicle in a careless or reckless manner
that endangers or causes injury or damage to another person or property,
(6) Any person who violates this section commits a noncriminal infraction
and is subject to a fine of not less than $100 and may have his or her
privilege to operate an ATV on public lands revoked. However, a person
who commits such acts with intent to defraud, or who commits a second
or subsequent violation, is subject to a fine of not less than $500 and may
have his or her privilege to operate an ATV on public lands revoked,
(7) Public land managing agencies, through the course of their
management activities, are exempt from the provisions of paragraph
(5)(a),
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 3 of 3
Appendix V.D.5b.3
APPENDIX V.D.SbA
EXISTING TRAIL CONDITIONS
OO~
g ~ W Q ~
Cl~g,= C-
CD 0 ~
.. - '" -<
Q;!.gc-lD
o III ",' 0
-< 0 (1) t:
'" CD &
o C. III
~ ~ -<
)> (j) ....
g:. ~ -.
!!!. 3 B
o "0 ::T
50 lD II :;:
o c: 0 +
"0 co '
::r ~ W (J) :z
~ -I 01
o @ 2. m
~ CD
'"
APPENDTh: V
D 5b.4 -EXJSTJN
G TRAJL CONDll'DNS
I~
I
m
)(0
-)>
~o
-m
ZI
G)n
nO
of
z-
om
_:::tJ
:::!n
0-<
z"tJ
cn:::tJ
1m
-Icn
:::tJcn
)>:::tJ
-m
~n
s::::tJ
"tJm
)>)>
n:::!
-10
cnz
-
z)>
N:::tJ
om
0)>
~
APPENDIX V.D.Sb.S
CONCEPTUAL DIAGRAM
-DMlE-t:WEJlPNIK
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA I~' .. .... . ~,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA .n ' ,
1---
FOR: MIAMI.DADECOUNTY .J<'." '"'''' " ._
APPENDIX V.D.5b.6
EXCERPT FROM STATE
COMPREHENSIVE OUTDOOR
RECREATION PLAN (SCORP)
OUTDOOR RECREATION IN FLORIDA 2000
Currently, saltwater beach activities, bicycle riding, and hiking are the most popular
resource-based activities, while pools and golf courses attract the most user-oriented activity.
South Florida (Region 11)
Coastal Counties: Broward, Dade, and Monroe
Non-Coastal Counties: none
Located on the southernmost tip of the Florida peninsula, South Florida encompasses more
than 4,200 square miles, The region borders the Florida Straits on the south, the Gulf of
Mexico, Glades and Hendry Counties on the west, Palm Beach County on the north, and the
Atlantic Ocean on the east. Primary urban centers are Fort Lauderdale, Hialeah, Key West,
and Miami. South Florida's warm climate is subtropical marine in Broward and Dade
Counties, and tropical marine in Monroe County, Most rainfall occurs from May through
early October,
Outdoor Recreation Resources
South Florida has an abundance of natural resources, The Everglades and the Florida Keys
provide South Florida with a rich diversity of plant and animal life within its low coastal
topography. In addition, the Atlantic Ocean and its sandy beaches, numerous bays, coastal
marshes, marine sanctuaries, Florida Bay and Florida Keys offer excellent opportunities for
camping, hiking, swimming, bicycling, fishing, boating and saltwater beach activities, Table
5.21 shows the South Florida region's outdoor recreation resources by provider.
South Florida's abundant marine resources, which include the Florida Bay, Biscayne Bay,
Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuaries, and the John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park,
provide world-famous opportunities for nature study, fishing, boating, and swimming, The
Great White Heron, Key West and Key Deer National Wildlife Refuges offer a combination
of land and water-based opportunities, especially for nature study, fishing and boating.
South Florida's diverse cultural and historical resources are unlike any other region in the
state. There are many recognizable structures and sites, which include Indian mounds,
Miami's Freedom Tower, Fort Zachary Taylor, the Barnacle, and Cape Florida Lighthouse.
Outdoor Recreation Particioation
Table 5,22 indicates a regional need for resources and facilities to meet demand for hiking,
swimming, bicycle riding, non-boat freshwater fishing, fresh and saltwater beach activities,
and camping now through 2010, No other activity is projected to exceed supply through
20 I 0, Currently, saltwater beach activities, bicycle riding, and picnicking are the most
popular resource-based activities, while pools and golf courses attract the most user-oriented
activity.
Chapter 5 - 34
Appendix V.D,5b,6
OUTDOOR RECREATION IN FLORIDA 2000
TABLE 5,21
1998 OUTDOOR RECREATION RESOURCES AND FACILITIES BY MAJOR SUPPLIER
SOUTH FLORIDA (REGION 11)
RESOURCE/FACILITY UNITS FEDERAL STATE COUNTY MUNICIPAL NON-GOVERNMENT TOTAL
Outdoor Recreation Areas Areas 42 82 418 1,014 524 2,080
LandArell Acres 1,100,940.85 678,573.99 18,]95.65 9,557.32 24,095.43 1,8)],363.24
WatcrArca Acres 1,135,700.15 68,376.91 1,024.96 436.06 1,574.]6 1,207,112.30
Total Area Acres 2,236,641,00 746,950.96 19,220.6] 9,993.38 25,669_59 3,0311,475.54
RESOURCE BASED
Cabins Cabins " 26 17 0 292 388
TcnlSites Siles 209 98 86 29 659 1,08]
RVSites Sites 567 175 SJ2 300 9,029 10,603
Commemorative Structures 0 5 2 28 1 36
Historic Sites Sites 2 24 25 22 20 93
Museums 10 1 18 6 23 64
Picnic Tables Tables 391 1,584 2,441 3,]84 6,847 14,447
Hunting land Acres 204,690.00 664,883.20 0.00 0.00 0.00 869,573.20
Hunting Water Acres 0.00 1,578.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,578.10
HunringArea Acres 204,690.00 666,461.30 0.00 0.00 0.00 87],]51.30
Bike Trails (Paved) Miles 52.00 3.30 83.90 ]85.90 2.80 327.90
Bike Trai]s (Unpaved) Miles 18.20 ]6.90 9.00 8.80 1.00 53.90
Canoe Trails Miles ]84.80 41.70 7.50 12.00 50.00 296.00
Hiking Trails Miles 119.10 53.80 6.90 93.90 3.90 277.60
Horseback Trails Miles 0.00 0.00 17.50 50.00 24.00 91.50
logging Trails Miles 1.50 3.80 49.40 78.50 9.10 142.30
MotorcycJeTrails Miles 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Nature Trails Miles 16.90 10.80 49.80 21.20 8.20 106.90
Freshwater8each Miles 0.07 0.00 0.64 0.54 l.OS 2.29
Freshwater Beach Area Square Feet 10,350.00 0.00 295,700,00 3,543,750.00 112,600.00 3,962,400.00
Freshwater Beaches Beaches 1 0 8 2 22 33
Freshwater Boat Ramp Lanes Lanes 4 10 20 129 12 235
Freshwater Boat Ramps R,,",p' 4 60 19 " 6 114
Freshwater Catwalk Feet 0.00 80.00 1,720.00 3,183.00 2]5.00 5,198.00
Freshwater Catwalks Catwalks 0 1 1 21 5 40
Freshwaterletties letties 0 42 1,560 3,125 0 4,727
Freshwater Marina Dry Storage Boats 0 0 0 0 1S5 1S5
FreshwalerMarinaSlips Slips 0 0 3 0 300 303
Freshwater Marinas Marinas 0 0 0 0 6 6
Freshwater Piers Piers 0 0 8 13 1 22
Saltwater Beach Miles 16,18 10.60 5.19 24.91 10040 57.28
Saltwater Beach Area Square Feet 1,7]7,500.00 2,893,400.00 4,090,250.00 20,275,890.00 3,050,955.00 32,027,995,00
Saltwater Beaehes Beaches 10 14 14 180 51 215
Saltwater 80at Ramp lanes Lanes 13 18 81 15 130 311
Saltwater 80at Ramps Ramps 8 12 44 45 115 284
Saltwater Catwalk Feet 700,00 0.00 5,578.00 82,022.00 19,730.00 108,030
Saltwater Catwalks Catwalks 3 0 9 16 42 10
Saltwaterletty p,,, 9,000 920 9,895 1,367 1,404 22,586
Saltwater Marina Dry Storage 80ats 0 0 503 0 9,8]] 10,314
Saltwater Marina Slips Slips 222 66 1,015 995 ]2,172 14,470
SalrwaterMarinas Marinas 6 4 8 13 335 366
SaJtwaterPicrs Piers 2 9 2 9 54 16
USER-ORIENTED
Baseball Fields Fields 4 11 113 496 23 101
BaskelballGoals Goals 11 8 432 902 111 1,476
Equipped P]IlY Areas Areas 6 5 181 498 45 135
Football Fields Fields 2 10 66 226 11 321
Go]fCourses (18 holc:) Courses 0 0 3 10 89 102
Golf Courses (9ho]e) Courses 0 0 3 2 11 16
Golf Courses (Executive) Courses 0 0 0 3 23 26
Golf Courses (Tota]) Courses 0 0 6 IS 123 144
Mulri-useCoUrTS Courts 1 0 25 64 19 109
Multi-use Fields Fields 3 11 89 140 20 263
Pools Pools 2 6 26 11 251 368
Racquetball Couns Courts 3 40 99 326 12 540
Recreation Centers Centers 4 5 110 216 118 453
Shuffleboard Courts Courts 0 0 85 265 191 541
TcnnisCourts Courts 14 51 214 814 958 2,]17
Vollevbul\CoUrts Courts 0 1 26 19 0 46
Chapler 5. 35
Appendix V.D.5b.6
'"
'"
'"
'"
;:j
O:i
<:;)
Ii
~
~
i::
~
ei
~
~
<:;)
~
;;;,
<:;)
....
....
vi
Iol
""
~
,..
00
Iol
-
,..
-
""
-
u
..:
...
Q
~
00
Iol
~
;:;l
o
00
~
;z:
0;:;-
--
E;;;z:
~9
~~
c:: ..:
OQg
xCil....
-0
,..""
;0...
0=
C::,..
~S
QOO
Iol
Iol
;z:
<=i
~
Q
~
Iol
<=i
Q
Iol
,..
..:
:;:
-
,..
00
Iol
v
o 00
31l
:t;Z
.,~
'"
....
~
d
o
1'~
vO
Q ~
00
2
v
o 00
g]
OOz
"'~
g
....
~
o
'0 .~
P
o~
v
2
v
~~
~ ~
~z
~
a
'0 .-
~ ~
o~
u
2
'"
'S
::>
v
o ~
3"
o v
~z
....'"
"'
~
.
d
o
"0 .~
~ tl
o~
u
~
2
-l
...:
z;..
ot:
>=>
...:-
~t;
u"':
~
'"
'S
::>
.~ .".: .M ~ ] ~ <>.Q 11 ~ 3 ~ ...
~, ~."tij'S ~ ~ "s "5 14 "s S ~
o~os:~o ~=8:a80~o 8
:; ""'_ ;;:;~d~d ~ d
-.q. O. '<l' '<t".
N :::
N
. .
" "
E j
~~~~fls"~.~~~~~
oa:o\>.(l~- '<l'Mo\NIYJ"r-.:
~~::::~'D.~ ~_~oo::::~":l
';~''''; _ N <ri
i ~ 13
xi '1:)" a:;
~ M
~ ~
:j:'''': ("..;
'"
'S
::>
.
~.~.~,~~
o r::: 0 0
o M_
~
::
"" "'.. <It '"
<> ti ..!:! J:! ~ u .2 ...
E J:! "s 's i4 's. j ~
:fil~8&:go...,og
~;;;ogd ;!j d
~ M ~
~" ri
5. ~ ~
ON" N
~ M ~
~ ~ ~
..; (,.I N
N
s:: :2 ~
o ~
,..) ::i g
;;. ......"-
'"
'Q
::>
. .
.~ "] '5
o ~
~
,;
N
"l
'" J:! ~
.~ 's E
o ~ ~ 0
~ 0
~ j
S~"~8~~~~:j:.
fi~.~'~';i~~~ ~
00 ;;. r-. I"-: ~ ~ ~ ;:}
M
u ~ .2 ..S:!
~ i4 "s ~
~ ;1; 8 ~ 8 0
ori 0> d d
~ ~
N N
'"
!i ..S:!
~ 's
~ j ]
8
Q
N
~.
co
:;; 0
:!
::!lI'\O","O>CO\~~ ON'-'l"""'"
r-~~=:g8 ;;t"'O'I~.V\~gg~ f;l
~~~c,;:~g d~-~a;g~..;l=i ~
;;;'d~O\~- ;O:J.::.>02..;0i.:J. r-f
N ~
.
. . .
.~ "s '5
.
tl 2 u
liE j
o ~ 0 ~
;ii,
q 0
'51! ] ~ .1! 13
J:! "s '8 <Ii '8 j
$ f.:; ~ g ~
:g ...... 0 ~ 0
,.., N ....
cO 0\
~
..S:! rs ti
's] ,g
0.8 0 ~
,;
...... -0 ...... - ;1; -0 '" - on - 0\ 0 on \() 00
::::~;.;e",,~ ~~~;;1;~5.~~ ~
'r'-", 8 O(.;~,..: ;t~"g,..;~::o '!S'i. ~
:!:2N:""t:!r-N_"r--;.~"1'.oo l'i"'_,
...., "," N ...... N
M
~ v
~ ~
~ ~ :-3;;!
l:;I;l Cij ~ Q,
~ ~ l.o ~ a
= 'C 0I0l -< ~
.s :; .cc:r:
tl:E c _;: 1;.
ga _ l),CI~ -= ~
;;!.~~~~l.o~
o = ~ _"-' Clo1 0I0l
rI:l - ~ CJl c..o- 1;
~ f: .u .8 .S ~ ;r;
c:r: .a c:l 0. Q,.c -a
1:.~!!~e
<OlUU",,,,
-..
.
:a
~
ii;
-
B
.
~
...
00
e
'"
..
.
:;;
Iii ~
'" .
~ l),CI 00
ctI.Q = Clo1
= Q,l'" l.o
:.!2 l: = S
._ = = <<I
::::::Z
~ ~ Q
.;:;;! 1;1;;I
;:J Q, Eo-
~ a z
0( <<I - !ii;:I
~~.SO=
i1 g ~:z
1;41= = -....
= l.o l.o l.o ~
:i! ~ -! ~ ~
~ III 0# ClI_
'S .no!
.~ "it -; -;
~ CI.HI) 00
~ ~ ~ n.;<l
8;g 8 8 8 ;:g
000000
<0
.r.
L()
o
>
.~
'0
C
Q)
a.
a.
<(
- ~
& 8
~ 0
~Qb:08:!:~~~
r- "1' 0'). <:l;. N 00 ..., "1'
00 0\ .s; 0\ door-" N"
N'C :z;: r- 00 0\ 0\ ~
~~~~'C"~;.,..;
..;<IEee~-".
~~388~8.~
000000"1'0
~
N
8~.:!~.*~~~
g:o ;:!";t_ 00 r::: r;; ..;
~oo"~"N'''''2~~
H
8 Jj
o 0
~ ~ H
8 8 8 J!
o 0 0 0
_ e
8. 8
1\ 0
N
'"
~
~.~S~~~5~
~ 'jjf" ;i ~;j~" r- ~
N:"~~""'''1'"~~
N
~
-
.!l
Ii'
...
u
.
~ '0 ~ ~ ~ -6
ouooou
<.J <:: <.J v <.J <::
000000
..\2 ~
& 8
N 0
'"
o
~~ 28~~~ ~2
;0 ;t ~ ~ ;j f ~. bi
;:"~",,,,~.....~...,.~~
N
~
~ ~
1 8
-; ~ i ~ ~
oS ~] ~ .~
l.o ~:; ~ ~ '5
~ 8" .Q g .. a'i5
~ ~'E='; gj~
-;~ ::::'~!=Q= ~d.~
oSs"'o&]'f='s "'~~ ~
~..o~"'E.aa=~~g
=g~;:l'::.i=g'Uoo
=~ o=ci.i~ rI:l~..I:Cl.,.:~..."'"
APPENDIX V.D.5b.7
PUBLIC INQUIRIES
.l"'l.l:-'J:.IC.l..l.\,..I.,J.,........ V...........JAJ. I
From: Burzycki, Gwen (DERM)
Sent: Tuesday, July 19, 2005 11:57 AM
To: McCall, James (MDPR)
Cc: Young, Emilie (DERM); Casado-Acorn, Christina (DERM); Davis, Matthew (DERM); Jason Smith
(E-mail)
Snbject: RE: Division of Forestry - Grant Proposal for A TV trails - Feasibility Study
I think that this is VERY good news. I will be happy to help to the degree that I am able.
--Original Message---
From: McCall, James (MDPR)
Sent: Tuesday, July 19, 2005 10:52 AM
To: Burzycki, Gwen (DERM)
CC: Heinicke, Mark (MDPR); Bentley, Sarah (MDPR)i Fouche, Anthony (MDPR)
SUbJect: Division of Forestry - Grant Proposal for ATV trails - Feasibility Study
Gwen,
I wanted to update you on the status of planning for ATV/OHV trails in Miami-Dade County. Thanks again
for participating in the meeting whh the Div. of Forestry in June. Your statistics and explanations of the
effects of ATV use on agrlcuhurallands were very convincing of our need for a legal ATV/OHV riding area,
The Park and Recreation Department has decided to apply for a plannlng/feasibility study grant. The
Department could potentially get granted up to $75,000 to conduct a county-wide site
selectionlleasibllitylland compatibility study for ATV and OHV use,
The grant Is due In mid-October, and we hear a decision on the grant in November or December of 2005,
Assuming we get the grant, a potential feasibility study would likely be finished by late 2006, or early-to-mid
2007.
I will stay in contact with you about this project. Please contact me with any questions.
Yours truly,
Andy McCall, Park Planner
Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2nd St., Suite 423, Miami, Fl33128
305-755-7993 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax
www.miamidade.gov/parks
"Delivering Excellence Every Day'
Miami-Dade County Is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning pUblic
records. E-mail messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure.
file:IN:\Proiects\2009\09-00063 - Dade-CoIlier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June n. 6f212009
--r-r-------- .------.
v.D.5b.7 Marc Lane - response ATV Riders NEED YOUR HELP.txt
From: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
Sent: wednesday, April 12, 2006 11:36 AM
TO: 'thehump@thehumponline.com'; Mccall, James A (MDPR)
subject: RE: ATV Riders NEED YOUR HELP
Hi Marc - the Miami Dade county park and Recreation Department really is aware of
this issue.
AS you know we have recently been awarded a grant to do a planning study for ATV
sites -- I am co~ying the project manager - James (Andy) Mccall so that you and he
can discuss the 1ssues and so that we can get you and your group to be part of the
planning process which we are about to beg1n.
Thanks
Barbara Falsey, ph.D., chief, planning and Research Division
Miami-Dade county park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2nd street, 4th Floor, Miami Florida, 33128
305-755-7860 phone 305-755-7864 Fax
. VNo/W. mi ami dade. gov jparks
"oelivering Excel1ence Every Day"
Miami-Dade count~ is a public entity subject to chapter 119 of the Florida
Statutes concerning publ1C records. E-mail messages are covered under such laws and
thus subject to disclosure.
-----original Message-----
From: thehump@thehumponline.com [mailto:thehump@thehumponline.com]
sent: wednesday, April 12, 2006 10:54 AM
TO: Falsey, Barbara CMDPR)
subject: ATV Riders NEED YOUR HELP
Hi my name is Marc, Thank you for taking the time to read my concerns about a large
PROBLEM in Miami-Dade County.
AS a Native Floridian and a 25 year resident of Miami-Dade County, my love for our
great state is DYING. one of the biggest problems is the amount of construction
that has been 90i~g on in Florida. The cost of living and the opportunity to OWN
your own home 1S Just gone thru the roof.
SOMETHING HAS TO BE DONE.
My main reason for writing All of you in this FIRST OF MANY letters to come, is I
and my fellow Off-Highway vehicle Cali-terrain vehicles) riders, NEED YOUR HELP
NOW!!I see in Miami-Dade we can legally buy ATV'S however there is not legal area
to ride. see my self and fellow riders enjoy spending time in the outdoors with our
families and friends. Many of our riders bring their kids to enjoy this SAFE
activity and give them the chance to enjoy what outdoors Miami-Dade has left.
we understand that there are groups of BAD people who mess everything up for
everyone, such people like the ones who steal machines, speed on the streets and run
from the police. However this is as always a select FEW_.. This is not ALL riders as
you and most people "stereotype."
we need to work together as citizens and government officials, after all you are
citizens as well. DOn't you enjoy the outdoors and our great
state? see recently in the past r.ear we have been taking more heat from
the r:1olice for riding and enjoying 'our" state. In Homestead for many years kids
and families of all ages have been riding in area known as the HUMP. Recently we
have been told that we will be arrested and charged with a Felony for riding in this
area. so what I see happening is one of three
things:
1.) You end up having hundreds of citizens from as young as 4 to as old as 65,
arrested and charged with a felony.
page 1
v.D.5b.7 Marc Lane - response ATV Riders NEED YOUR HELP.txt
2.) YOU have people breaking more laws and causin~ bi~ger problems.
3.) we work together and find a place for us to r,de ln Miami-Dade and enjoy the out
doors.
I was told that Miami-Dade parks was given a grant for 75,000 to find a place for
ORV use. where is this money and what point is the process at?
where are the public postings about this money and what's been done?
The BENEFITS of establishing a riding area for public use of ATV'S are endless. It
will provide the sport being legally practiced along with: . Conforming to State
vehicle and Traffic Law' Environmental conservation. Impacts on natural and
agricultural resources . Public safety as well as safety of riders . will deter
illegal off-road ATV use. police man hours and court funds will be reduced.
Revenue collected for use can be great for the state. Teenage crime static's will
be reduced . Homeowner complaints will decrease significantly . promotes outdoor
family activities
Florida's off-highway vehicle laws and rules Section 316.2074 are intended to
promote safety and protection for people, property and the environment but how can
we exercise this legal right if we have NO riding area designated without the risk
of receiving a citation, arrest and/or even impound of our All-Terrain vehicle.
This Friday April 14th 2006 at 3:00pm EST. Local Miami-Dade ATV riding citizens will
be joinin~ together on Bird Rd and sw 162ave to talk with the news about the loss of
all the rlding areas. I ask each and everyone of you to PLEASE attend this peaceful
rally to hear what we have to say. Governor Bush your presence in Miami-Dade county
is needed as well. After all Miami is home to you is it not? .
Sincerely,
Marc Lane
page 2
v.D.5b.7 Marc Lane - ATV Riders NEED YOUR HELP.txt
From: Marc T. Lane [mtlane@bellsouth.net]
Sent: wednesday, April 12~ 2006 11:54 AM
To: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
cc: Mccall, James A (MDPR)
Subject: Re: RE: ATV Riders NEED YOUR HELP
Thank you very much...
My self and my group will do all we can to help find a place we can ride safely and
legall~.
There 1S much at stake here. Both Federal state local and civil. please let me know
what we can do. You can also join thehumponline.com which is a site i made for local
riders. we have over 180 registered users and thats only since october 2005. Feel
free to post any thing about this project there and also its a way you can work with
the riders directly... which is a great help / aspect for this i think.
Marc Lane
Appendix V.D.5b.7
From: Amy Collins [acollins@jciintemational.com]
Sent: Wednesday, June 28, 2006 8:26 AM
To: McCall, James A (MDPR); miamigirlrider@yahoo.com; Brooke.Lynch@djj.state.fl.us; Falsey,
Barbara (MDPR);jasmith@sfwmd.gov; Young, Emilie (DERM); Burzycki, Gwen (DERM); Casado-
Acorn, Christina (DERM); GMarston@WRTdesign.com; Silvia Vargas; thehump@thehumponline.com
Cc: Heinicke, Mark (MDPR)
Subject: RE: ATV Field Meeting Invitation - Wednesday, July 12th, 10 AM - Location TBA
I'd like to take the opportunity to express our gratitude for the promptness you have shown for this
cause.
I will definitely be in attendance and look forward to meeting with all of you. Cary, Brooke, Marc and I
will brainstorm to see if we can come up with suggestions as to where to meet.
Thank you,
Amy Collins
Controller
JCllnternatlonal, Inc.
General ContraClOlS
12315 SW 132 Court
Miami. FL 33186
305-254-1844 OllIoe
305-255-3359 Fax
E-mail: sMlllnsGiCllnlemAtlnnal com
Visit our webaRe at: wwwlcllnlAmatlnnAl com
.--orlglnal Message-
From: McCall, James A (MDPR) [mailto:JAMCCAL@mlamidade.gov]
Sent: Tuesday, June 27, 20064:35 PM
To: mlamlglrlrlder@yllhoo.com; Amy Collins; Brooke.Lynch@djj.sta~.f1.us; Falsey, Barbara (MDPR);
jasmlth@sfwmd.gov; Young, Emilie (DERM); Burzyckl, Gwen (DERM)i Casado-Acorn, Christina (DERM);
GMarston@WRTdeslgn,com; Silvia vargas
Cc: Heinicke, Mark (MDPR)
SUbject: ATV Reid MeetIng Invitation - Wednesday, July 12th, 10 AM . Locatlon TBA
Hello Everyone:
I would like to Invlle everyone to a field meeting at 10:00 AM on Wednesday, July 12'h. Cary, Amy, and
Brooke, the County would like to invlle you to show us those places that Interest you most as Off-Highway
Vehicle riders, and we would like to discuss and bralnstonn about the best places for OHV treDs in the
County. The County Is starting a Feasiblllly Study wllh the purpose of selecting slles for OHV trails. We
are interested In knowing how to better meet the needs of the OHV recreation groups, and would also like
to brainstorm for ideas on how to keep out natural areas and environmentally endangered lands prlsteen.
The South Florida Water Management District is providing transportation In an ARGO maintanance
vehicle (wllh room for 6 people), and may be able to provide an additional ARGO.
Amy and Brooke, please invite Marc Lane to attend if he is available.
Cary, Amy, and Brooke: please provide suggestions of a place to meet that morning, and let me know the
areas of the County that you are interested In showing us as examples of fun riding places.
Everyone please lei me know If you have any questions or ooncems, and I will be In oontact with you to
confirm the location as we get closer to the meeting date.
Sincerely,
Andy McCall, Park Planner 2
Mleml-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2nd St, Suite 423, Miami, FL 33128
fi]p./N.\!>rn;prt.\?Jl(lQ\OQ.mnn"l - nncl".C'.lllli"r Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June... 61212009
Appendix V.D.5b.7
305-755-7993 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax
www.miamidade.gov/parks
.Delivering Excellence Every Day.
Miami-Dade County is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning public
records. E-mail messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure.
file:/N :\Proiects\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June ... 612/2009
Appena~x V.U.~O.I
From: Leo Lopez [atvmiaxtreme@gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, July 13,2006 10:54 AM
To: McCall, James A (MDPR)
Subject: Meeting Pies
Hello Andy,
This is Leo Lopez owner of www.atvmiaxtreme.com and you can contact me here at this email.
atvmiaxtreme@gmail.com
Can you please send me some pictures of the meeting we had yesterday, also can you send me a pic of
the huge map
we were working with.
Thank You Sooooo Much your time on this matter is greatly appreciated!!!
Thanks
Leo Lopez
f;1,,'/IV'\Prni,.rt.\?00Q\()Q..()()()6"l . n"de.C.o11ier Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June n. 6/'lJ2oo9
Appendix V.D.5b.7
From: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
Sent: Friday, July 21. 2006 12:51 PM
To: Torres. Edith (MDPR)
Cc:: Hansen, Erie (MDPR); McCall, James A (MDPR)
SnbJect: RE: FW: ATV's for South Florida AdventureS Magazine
See answers below
Barbara F....y. Ph.D., Chief. Planning and Research Division
Mieml-llade County Perk end Recl'8llion Depertment
275 NW 2nd Street, 4th Floor, MiIlmI Aorida, 33128
305-755-7860 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax
www miamidad& aovloarks
'Delfwting_Every DIy"
Mlami./Jade County Is a pubBc enllty subject to CIlaptor 119 of the Florida STatutes concaming pubBc reconls. E.mall messages are
covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure.
--Qrlglnal Message-
From: Torres, EdIth (MDPR)
sent: Friday, July 21, 2005 9:30 AM
To: Fe!oey, Barbara (MDPR)
cc: Hansen, Erit (MDPR); McCall, James A (MDPR)
_jed:: FW: FW: ATV's for South AorIda Adventures Magazine
Importance: High
Hi Barbara, we just spoke In the elevator. Below are her questions. She says she's available mid to earty afternoon today for a phone
Interviewer alter 5 p.m. today. Let me know tfyou can do this so I can set It up.
Thanks again. Happy Fridayl
Edilh
edith T......., Public Information OlfIeer
MIem~ Peril end _Ion
Z7B NW 2nd Street, ThIrd ~
MIomI, FL 38128
305-755.7882 Phone
305-755-7867 FIX
e\omlSOmlamldade.gov
www.miamldade.gov/parks
'DeI/l'ennfIExtJeIIence Eo;eJy Day"
_Dade County Is a publlcenllty aubject to CtJap/er 119 of the Rorlda Sta/ule$ conoemIntI public reconJs. E-maU _ are
covered under such laws and thus subjooI to~.
--<lr1gInoI __
From' RIsa Merl [malllll,rgmerI@yehoo.comJ
sent: Thursday, July 20,200510:10 PM
To: Torres, EdIth (MDPR)
Subject: Fwd: FW: ATV's for South florida _ Magazlne
EdlIb.
Please see below. This is some basic: information, sent by an ATV rider, about !be issue at hand. It mentions !be $75,000 grant,
lhe OHV Advismy CoDlllliUee meeting 011 August 4th, etc.
If you know 8IIYone 011 your end that.... speak to me aboUllhis, that would be great. I tbiok it's imperative I get a soun:e from
your office to covery !be story fully.
Some things I would want to know_.
What is the IIIl\lO< is.... Padts sees witb A TV riding in Miami-Dade?
o The n18.jor issue is finding a lucarion that is both safe and lepl for the ride.. and safe for lbe envirol1lnen~ A.
d<velopmellt bas spread, lhere are fewer areas tbat are available and propeny owne.. who may have allowed
A TV use no longer do so. Also,.... tlte County and tlte South Florida Water Manag.mem District or nth..-
government agencies acquire land for <:onservatioD and protection. areas that wC're usrd fur A TV rid1ng are off-
limbs.
file:/N:\Proiects\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June ... 6/2/2009
....1:'J::'........~--- . .-._-_.
What is happening wirh rhis grant?
o Th~ County has hired a consultant to do a ~tudy with the goal of locating preferred alternative sites for A TV
riding. There has already been one meeting bet\,,'een the consultant team. park staff and ATV riders to discuss
tbe kinds of experiences and settings the riders are looking for. The cOllsullant willuted to identify areas where
tbe ATV riding experience suits the liders. whtre riding does not degrade the environment. \V.here it "fits" with
the sUITmmding area and where it is availabli: or could be acquired. They then make recommendations (Q the
Departmem and rhe ATV commuuity on how to proceed.
Is rhere a place that it can be safe and legal for A TV riders to ride?
o Right now there is no public land that is set..asic}e for ATV riders. There may he private areas where lando\Voers
allow it
Is Parks working with ATV riders to find a legal place for them to ride?
o Yes
What is rhe biggest threat or danger of illegal ATV riding?
o It can be dangerous tor the riders - even if they mean well they can he breaking the law and trespClssiug. They
may also.. Yriihout meaning to - damage ao environment that has natural resources that should b~ protected.
What can you tell me about the legal place to ride in Broward, dubbed the Holy Lands?
o At this point we bave not visited it- bllt will in the course ofrhe stlldy.
And any other takes on the A TV issue and legality of it in the county.
o We are committed to working with the ATV ccmmunlty and to make every effort to try to identify a suitable location or
locations and an implementation strategy. We expect the study to be completed by the end of this year. How soon a
location could become available will depending on the findings of the study,
o We will be attending the Off-Highway Advisory Committee Meeting on August 4 and hope to be able to get more
information on how other' areas have successfully dealt with the Issue,
I think a phone inl<:rview might work _ in this instance beclWSC I want to be able to feed off what the OOID'Ce is telling me
in order to ask more queslioll$ (I'm not sure what exactly their otance wiD be yet).
I am available mid-day through early afternoon tomorrow and after 5 p,m. Thogh I can try to free up at other times if this isn\
feasible.
Thank you very much for YOID' assistanCe.
Sioca'ely,
Risa Merl
Dari4 RDtm1uIrl <4nJtemum@SoFlaAJhellJura.eom> wrote:
From: "David Rall:rman" <dnllerlJJan@SoFIaAdvenlllrCS.com>
To: <rgmerl@yaboo.com>
Subject: FW: ATV's
Date: Sun, 16 JuI 2006 10:19:47 -0400
Risa.
Be sure to c:bedc with Miami.Dade.Puks spokcspenon aboul the study that is mentioned :in this attachmenL
fi]p.IN.\P..,..,;p,.t.\?mll\(}Q-()(\()/\~ _ nRrI.....l".nIli"'r PRrlc Am"'nnmenl\nOCUment.~\Reoort\June ... 6/2/2009
........l:"l:"'-.................. ......,. -~. ,
From: "ea.y ortega" <miamlgirlrider@yoboo.colD>
To: <s<:cjas@wsVD.COlll>,
<;jryzenberg@wsvn.com>,
<ncwsdesk@wsvn.com>,
<helpmehowaRl@wsVD.COID>.
<tfieclJer@miIm1beoJd.com>,
<;jmilJer!Wmiamiberald.com>,
<lgro..@miamIbeJaId.com>,
<dwilson@miamiberald.oom>,
<dadeDews@miomiberald.com>,
..1,..IIV'\Prn;,.rt~\?00Q\OQ.oo0/l1 - Dac\e-C'.ollier Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June... 61212C1J9
.M.J:.ll-'t:::HU...1...A V. u. ~J..J. I
<msallah@miamiherald.com>,
<aacle@miamiheraJd.com>,
<HeraldEd@miamiherald.com>,
<features@miamiherald.com>,
<aa!varez@loca110.com>,
<Ijennings@loca110.com>,
<kkrueger@localIO.com>,
<d1auderda1e@loca1I0.com>,
<;jsummers@loca110.com>,
<llOngen@loca110.com>,
<mputney@localIO.com>,
<edilOria1s@1oca110.com>,
<wfomews@wfor.cbs.com>,
<scott.zamo,t@nbcuni.com>,
<J1oticias@telemundo51.com>,
<info@telemundoSl.com>,
<wlVjdesk@nbc.com>,
<dbanker@sun-sentinei.com>,
<cmetzger@sun-sentinel.com>,
<bgnomillion@sun-sentinei.com>,
<emaucker@,un-sentinei.com>,
<kguy@sun-sentinel.com>,
<nbrochu@sun-sentinel.com>,
<Ietters@sun-sentinel.com>,
<tdodson@s1Jl1oosentinel.com>.
<dlyons@sun-sentinei.com>,
<Ietters@miaminewtimes.com>,
<channeI2@cbanne12.org>,
<carlas@diariolasamericas.com>,
<;jorgemigueI983@univisiolLcom>,
<DjWa1ter983@univision.com>,
<gustavopena@diariolasamericas.com>,
<elvacilon@mega.tv>,
<;joe@mariconson.com>,
<enrique@mariconson.ooD1>,
<aiJyn@elzol.com>,
<macbete9S@yahoo.com>,
<tomas@alzol.com>,
<mallS@rivamolOlSporls.COm>,
<roba@rivamolOrsporls.COm>,
<;jatpolar@aol.com>,
<aaamoped@yahoo.com>,
<drobinson@ridenow.com>,
<info@pa1meuomotorspol1S.com>,
<bmschoppers@psnnewsletter.com>,
<office@yamahascadoo.com>,
<servicc@yamAM-adoo.ooDt>.
<sal es@yamahasoadoo.com>,
<saJes@browardmotorsports.com>,
<scrVice@browardmotorsports.com>,
<info@blaiscycle.com>,
<hdsouth@bellsouth.nel>,
<perfonnanceatV@aol.coDl>,
<Ilopez@lola1bank.OOm>
Subject: ATV's
Date: Mon, 10 lul2006 08:35:42-0400
WE OFFICIALLY HAVE NO LEGAL RIDING AREAS IN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY.
13 Tickets were issued 10 my crew as well as Iforriding alV's with our kids the weekend of July the 4th. Wa were
advised that Miami Dade AgricullWl: Police is being paid OVERTIME 10 aack down on A TV riden. PaOO and
Recreation was given a 75k grant in Janwuy 0610 conduct a study 10 find us suitable riding land but???'l
TheR:fote, the next OHV Advisory Committee Meeting is being held in Miami and we need to SPEAK UP AND
SHOW UP. Lets show the County Officials as well as the OHV CouusD, South Florida Water Managements, Parks
and Recreation how manyenthuastics live in Miami. How many professional paR:IIlS want a safe place 10 practice this
fi1P.'IIV'\Prni...r.t~\?JJ(JQ\()Q-()()()I\3 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Reuort\June... 61212009
sports in the outdoors with our children... But most of an lets plea for a safe legal riding area for our kids.
Please either spread the word arouud or sbow up to show support. Yes, we are the same people that beld tbe
raUy ill APRIL. WE WILL CONTINUE as long as A TV's are beiug sold, taxes and titling fees are being paid ou
them and our kids want to ride.
ITS LEGAL TO SELL IN MIAMI Bur NOT LEGAL TO RIDE...SHOW UP ON:
FRIDAY, AUGUST 4, 2006
@ 10:00AM
Palmetto Golf Course
9300 SW 152 Street
traDer yonr bikes to the meeting and wear yoar crew shirts.
'l1umks
www.atvmiRnreme.com
WWW.tbehulllDOnUnpt'n1tl
Cory Hernandez
786.222~
Want to be your own boss? Learn bow on Yahoo! Small Business.
Groups are talking. We're listening. Check out the handy ehanees to Vahool Groups.
fil".'IN'\Pr"i"M~\?I1OQ\(JQ-noon"l - n..rlp..f'.olJip.r Park Amendment\Docurnents\Reoort\June... 6/2/2009
V.D.5b.7 Drew peterson - off-Hi~hway Motorcycle inquiry.txt
From: DREW PETERSON [drewhdsouth@hotmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, January 02, 2007 5:46 PM
TO: Mccall, James A (MDPR)
subject: FW: FMDA Board: Important Article
HELLO ANDY, IT WAS NICE TALKING WITH YOU, BUT I FORGOT TO GIVE YOU MY
E-MAIL, SO THAT YOU COULD KEEP ME IN THE LOOP ON WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE OHV
SEEN HERE IN SOUTH FLORIDA. AND IT JUST SO HAPPENED THAT I GOT THIS E-MAIL
FOR THE FLORIDA MOTORCYCLE DEALERS ASSOCIATION OF WHICH I AN A BOARD MEMBER,
SO I THOUGHT I WOULD FORWARD IT TO YOU. DREW PETERSON, PARTNER, PETERSON'S
HARLEY-DAVIDSON OF MIAMI AND SOUTH..
>From: "Susannah wesley" <susannah@HelpMembers.org>
>TO: "susannah wesley" <susannah@HelpMembers.org>
>subject: FMDA Board: Important Article
>Date: Tue, 02 Jan 2007 10:28:02 -0500
>
page 1
~~1:..l:.--~~......--~ ..~. ~_. .
From: Cary ortega [miamigirJrider@yahoo.com]
Sent: Wednesday, January 10, 2007 9:00 PM
To: Cary ortega; LIMoller@aol.com; Iswjth2@yahoo.com; vaughanlO@verizon.net;
gbryant58@comcast.net; Looprd@aol.com; VCNP@aol.com; dr-birks@tampabay.rr.com;
metfreakk@earthlink.net; admin@atvflorida.com;jsparJcs@legstrat.com; swampbuggy2@earthlink.net;
gordalfY72@hotmail.com; atvmiaxtreme@gmail.com; jose@swmiami.com; mleonI212@yahoo.com;
joev@c3ts.com; abel@bellsouth.net; cmpatino@bellsouth.net; OffroadSS350@aol.com;
leoleonb8@yahoo.com; alber,-menendez@adelphia.net; xjlisa@grnail.com; terry@onfa.org;
GladesGuru@aol.com; ypineiro@miamiherald.com; electric@peganet.com; mark@wildload.com;
info@jmairconditioning.com; atvgirl@thedirtygirls.net; Banshee1987@eathlink.net;
Blue@bluescycle.com; BMac240@hotmail.com; chris@southemknightsatv.com;
damon_m_lee@yahoo.com; dixieboyI479@hotmail.com; dustmudder69@netzero.net;
four_ wheelin4fun@yahoo.com; gwest@onearrow.net; harufam@earthlink.com;
jmnasdaqqqq@hotrnail.com; Justin888@bellsouth.net; mdaybc@hotmail.com;
mejasnanny@comcast.net; mjavy7@gmail.com; Muddywatersatv@yahoo.com;
Nalienprincess@aol.com; ramatv@msn.com; REDGRIZZL Y660@aol.com; rypiii@netzero.com;
SllIIL witch@yahoo.com; sawesero039@msn.com; sellin&-this_stuff@yahoo.com; support@fl-atv.com;
toothfairyI214@netzero.net; wildboy_2002@yahoo.com; wswisel@cox.net;
acollins@jciintemational.com; ailyn@elzol.com; brooke.lynch@djj.state.fl.us;
djwalter983@univision.com; dlsmith@naplesnews.com; elvacilon@mega.tv;
enrique@mariconson.com; gustavopena@diariolasamericas.com; joe@mariconson.com;
jorgemigueI983@univision.com; machete95@yahoo.com; maria.carpio@nbcuni.com; mnaanes@sun-
sentinel.com; mtlane@bellsoutb.net; rgmerl@yahoo.com; tomas@elzol.com
Subject: Re: Thank you all for all your hard work. Collier county will fmally have a ...
Congratulations to our friends in Collier County: Dennis, NorthPort Crew, A TVFiorida, Rick, Frank and
the rest of you. See whst hsppens when you do not give up. Thank you for offering to come and help in
Miami Dade. Trust me I will be calling your for you assistance in the near future. Anything we can
continue to do for you just ask. .
Car] orrega <miamigirlrider@yahoo.eom> wrote:
Great Job everyone, you should be proud of yourself. You stood hard for whst you believed in
and your right as a citizen of this State. Its was a long battle and hard one but you didnot quit
even when hopes were dim. Pat yourself in the back; its parents, children and neighbors like you
that make it possible for our kids grow to know and enjoy what the great outdoors has to offer.
Don't settle for one location, we hsve a law that entitles us to SEVERAL riding areas. Keep up
the fight.
Now its MIAMI DADE's time to shine.
Your friend in the 305
Cary Hernandez
uMoUer@Q()l.eom wrote:
I In ~ message dated 1/10120075:16:04 PM Central Standard Time,lswjth2@yahoo.com
wnteS:
f;l"./IV.\Prn;PM.\?OOQ\()Q-()(}()t;'l - n..tle-C'oJlier Park Amendment\Documents\ReJlOrt\1une ... 61212009
Folks, this has been a hard fought fight, but without your e-mails, going to
meetings and writing letters, the families of Collier and surrounding
counties would still be without a place to legally ride.Collier county
commissioners agreed to accept SFWMD offer 01 having a 150 acre
temporary site open while THEY CLEAN UP THE 620 ACRE LAKE
TRAFFORD SITE. It might be years before we can use the 620 acre site,
but probably before the summer, the temporary site will open. I
especially want to thank Brian, without his help this would not have been
possible, Dennis, Cary, Scott and Kevin and the atvmiaxtreme and
northport team, without us pulling together, this might not have
happened. Thank you all. This is an example of working together, we can
make things happen. Congratulations to aiL. Rick
Rick
You are correct in all that you say above. Do not give up and let this small chunk of land
be the only place you can ride. By working together you can accomplish much more.
This is how those who want you out of FL and off public lands have done what they
ave to your interest; they work together. Become organized, stay involved and work for
what you like to do; or stay home and watch it on TV.
Right now Lisa is working hard on stopping SR 40 from becoming a National Park Road
via the scenic highway process.
ack
Check out the all-new Yahoo! Mail beta - Fire up a more powerful email and get things done
aster.
\ccess over 1 million songs - Yahoo! Music Unlimited.
fil.../N.\Prnj,,,,t.\?J)()Q\OQ-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June... 6/2/1JXJ9
From: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
Sent: Wednesday, January 31, 200710:55 AM
To: 'Lynch, Brooke'; McCall, James A (MDPR)
Ce: Nardi, Maria (MDPR)
Subject: RE: A favor Please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Brooke _ I am not sure we can do this so quickly! Andy - see if you can talk to George about this -It would
require a permit and some kind of indemnification.
Brooke _ have you aPproached the CIIy of Homestead? They might has a space as well and their processes
could be shorter than ours to get through!
Barbara Fal8ey, Ph.D., Chief, Planning and Research Division
MiamI-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2nd Street, 4th Floor, Miami Florida, 33128
305-755-7860 Phone 305-755-7B64 Fax
www.mlamidade.oov/Darks
"Delivering Excellence Every Day"
Miami-Dade County is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning public
records. E-mail messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure.
--Original Message-
From: Lynch, Brooke [mallto:Brooke.Lynch@djj.sta~.f1.us]
Sent: Wednesday, January 31,2007 10:34 AM
To: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
SUbject: A favor Pieasellll!l!!l!lll!!!!!!!!I!lllll
Good Morning,
Could you please write me 0 letter stating that I would have access to 0 large
enough area to train safety to atv riders a few times a month. The location does
not have to be the some or in stone in any way or a date given. I just need
something that says I will hove on area to train people so that I can toke this
corse. This letter is not binding or anything. I do not wont locations or dotes or any
thing just that land will be available. Does that make sense? If not call me. It is
one of those days.... LOL I am sure you can understand. I would like to send in this
form ASAP pleaselll!!!
Thank You!
Brooke
Secretary Specialist
Department of Juvenile Justice
81990 Overseas Highway
Suite 102
Islamorada, Rodda 33036
f;1,,../IV'\PTnj,,rl.\?JlIlQ\OQ-0006::l _ Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June... 6/2/2C1J9
.M.J:Jl:..JIl=J..1U...L...... v .J../. ~j.,J. I
(305) 664-0662
brooke.lynch@djj.state.fl.us
The mission of !be Florida Department of Juvenlle Justice: To protect the public by reducing
juvenlle crime and !be deUnquency in Florida.
Florida has a very broad public records law. Most written communications to or from state officials
regarding .
state business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail
communications may
therefore be subject to public disclosure.
hlp'IIV.\J>rn,ip,...tQ\?fVlO\()o_{}{)()"~ . n~lIIip..rnll1p.r P~T1r Amp.nt1mP.T1t\nnr.nmP.nt~\Rp.nnrt\Tnnp. .... h12l2009
r:l.J:-.J:-.<;;;;.L.L.-I...I..J.>. V ..J...J.-'A."f.,
From: Cary ortega [miamigirlrider@yahoo.com]
Sent: Thursday, February OS, 2007 10:16 AM
To: Cary ortega; matts@rivamotorsports.com;roba@rivamotorsports.com;jetpolar@aol.com;
aaarnoped@yahoo.com; drobinson@ridenow.com; info@palmettomotorsports.com;
bmschoppers@psnnewsletter.com; office@yamllhllseadoo.com; service@yamabaseadoo.com;
sales@y"mllh"seadoo.com; sales@browardmotorsports.com; service@browardmotorsports.com;
info@blaiscyc1e.com;hdsouth@bellsouth.net; performanceatv@aol.com; Falsey, Barbara (MDPR);
waldroj@doacs.state.fl.us; McCall, James A (MDPR); gbryant5S@comcast.net; Iswjth2@yahoo.com
Subject: Re: Funeral Services for Alan Smith
Sorry I forgot the date...Tommorow Friday, Feb. 9, 2007
Cary urtega <miamigirTrider@yahoo.com> wrote:
Funeral Service for Alan Smith will be held at:
Salgado-Van Orsdel Funeral
9300 SW 40th St
Miami, Florida
Commencing at 6 pm
We will be there at 7:30pm.
Donations are also being accepted until tomorrow morning
at www.atvmiaxtreme.com home page or you can drop of
your donations at:
Encuesta, Inc
4990 SW 72 Ave Suite 110
Phone 305-661-1492 EXT 116
Ask for Michael Cerda' Or Annelise
Hours are 9:00AM TO 8:00 pm
Donations will be turned over to the parents to help with
funeral cost of the unexpected tragic loss of their 16 year
old son, Alan.
Thank you and may God bless you all.
Please wear your helmets and encourage everyone to get
involved in the fight to obtain a "LEGAL AND SAFE RIDING
AREA" in Miami Dade before more children continue to die
&.:l......'ltT.\n-..:............\l')fVlO\t\O_I\t"V'Vt.'::t ~ T\!'at.Jp_rnll;PJ" PArk AmP.TlnmP.nt\nnC'!nmenLc;\Renort\Tune ... 61212009
H1:J1:'t:=J..lU.LA V ..LJ.:;JJ..J. I
on our streets.
Bored stiff? Loosen up...
Download and play hundreds of sames for free on YahOO! Games.
Be a PS3 game guru,
Get your game face on with the latest PS3 news and previews at Yahoo! Game-..
file:/N:\Proiectsl2009\09-OO063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\ReportVune... 6f2J2009
--z:-z:- --------
From: Cary ortega [miamigirlrider@yahoo.com]
Sent: Thursday, February OS, 2007 2:44 PM
To: McCall, James A (MDPR)
ee: Falsey, Barbars (MDPR); waldroj@doacs.state.fl.us;jasmith@sfwmd.gov
Subject: RE: ATVMIAXTREME.COM Holey Land Clean up 2/3/07
Andy:
Thank you for your response. We had a great time. I attached more pictures that I am sure you will
enjoy. I love the one of the kids that found the little frog in some pants and moved it out of danger.
Have a great day and enjoy.
Cary
"McCaa, James A (MDPR)" <JAMCCAL@miamidoJe.gov> wrote:
Cary,
That was a great e-mail, and I am sure that the FWC was glad for the volunteer labor. I recognized
several of our MiamI area enthusiasts, and some of the gentlemen from the Northport off-road group as
well, from statewide OHV meetings that I have attended.
Keep up the good work!
Andy McCall, Park Planner 2
Miami-Dade County Park and Recreatton Department
Z75 NW 2nd St., Sulle 423, Miami, FL 33128
305.755.7993 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax
www.mlamldade.gov/parks
"Delivering Exce'I<<Jce Every Day"
Miami-Dade County is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning public
records. E-mail messsges are covered under such laws and /hus subject to disclosure.
--()rlglnal Message--
From: Cary ortega [rnailto:mlamlglr1r1der@yahoo.com]
sent: Thursday, February 08, 2007 2:17 PM
To: chuck.coIlins@myfwc.com
Cc: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR); McCall, James A (MDPR); John Waldron; jasmlth@sfwmd.gov;
david.rlvera@myflorldahouse.gov; Diaz, Rene (DISTl1)
SUbject: ATVMIAXTREME.COM Holey Land Oeen up 2/3/07
Dear Mr. Collins:
I would like to thank you for having given the ORY Community an opportunity to have
conducted the Saturday, February 3, 2007 Holey Land Clean Up.
It was a complete success and the effort made a visual impact immediately. In addition,
it teaches by example to our younger riders and visitors that we out there on Saturday,
that we must take care of the environment and we must coexist in a positive way with
nature to be able to maintain legal riding areas open to the community.
Several top people of the leading atv riding groups combined efforts to keep the group
small but efficient. ATYMIAXTREME, NORTHPORTOFFROAD, ATVFLORIDA
f:'A.IIV.\I'~;.~t.\?I'lf)(l\na_non,;~ _ nAA..._r"n;,.". PArle AmP.nilmp.nt\nncnment~\Renort\June... 612/2009
~l:-'1:Jl;::1.1U.L""" V .U. JJ..J. /
and the FULL TRACK CONSERVATION CLUB made this all possible. We
had riders from Key West to Northport and Lehigh attend this event.
We also had a member donate a dump truck to hau1 off the trash, Which btw we met our
goal and filled the dump truck to legal capacity.
Attached you will fmd pictures of the event and look foward to many more opportunities
to work side by side with your department. I personally fmd the picture of the two
children who found a little frog living inside a pair of old muddy pants cute. Its shows
how they respectfully pick him up and transfer him to a safe grassy area to avoid being
run over by.
Again, thank you for have given me the chance. If I can ever be of any assistance to you
please do not hesitate to contact me.
Sincerely,
Cary Hernandez
MIAMIGIRLRIDER
We won't tell. Get more on shows you hate to love
(and love to hate): Yahoo! TV's Guilty Pleasures list.
Everyone is raving about the all-new Yahoo! Mail beta.
fil"'IN'\Prn;,,",,,.\?()()Q\()Q-ooon~ - Oarle-r.nllier Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June ... 6/2/2009
v.D.5b.7 ATV acciden~ casual~y in sou~h Miami-Dade coun~y.~x~
From: Burzycki, GWen (DERM)
Sen~: wednesday, March 14, 2007 10:31 AM
To: Jason smi~h (E-mail); Rick conover (E-mail); Mccall, James A (MDPR)
cc: Young, Emilie (DERM); Grossenbacher, craig (DERM); Falsey, Barbara
(MDPR)
subjec~: FW: ATV ac~ivi~y in Miami Dade
The address of ~his dea~h was ~o ~he sou~heas~ of ~he Hump, near ~he A~lan~ic civil
rockmine. If ~he address info is correc~, i~ was on proper~y where cemex has an
applica~ion pending for ano~her rockmine,
-----original Message-----
From: Sara Fain [ma'l~o:sfain@NPCA.ORG]
sent: wednesday, March 14, 2007 9:25 AM
TO: BUrzycki, GWen (DERM)
subjec~: ATV ac~ivi~y in Miami Dade
Hi GWen,
I~'s been a while since we spoke.
~hough~ of your effor~s:
Dus~ cloud becomes deadly for ATV rider
h~~p://www.miamiherald.com/460/s~ory/39805.h~ml
I saw ~his ~ragic ar~icle in ~he Herald and
HOW'S ~his going? Are you around some~ime for me ~o give you a call?
sara E. Fain
Biscayne Res~ora~ion program Analys~
sun coas~ Region
Na~ional parks conserva~ion Associa~ion
protecting our Na~ional parks for Fu~ure Generations
450 N. park Rd, sui~e 301
Hollfiod, FL 33021
(954 961-1280, ex~. 205
(954 985-8047 Fax
(305) 546-6689 cell
www.npca.org
page 1
AppenalX V.U.~D. I
From: Cary ortega [miamigirlrider@yahoo.com]
Sent: Saturday, March 17,2007 12:03 AM
To: Trelles, Maria I. (MDPD); Trelles, Maria I. (MDPD); Foxx, Elvira (MDPD); Garcia, Diana L.
(MDPD); Julio.Robaina@myfloridahouse.gov; Moss, Demris C. (DIST9); Vega, Olga R. (DISTl2);
Districtl2; rconover@swfwmd.gov; McCall, James A (MDPR); acollins@jciinternational.com;
Brooke.Lynch@djj.state.fl.us;jasmith@sfwmd.gov; GMarston@WRTdesign.com; Palsey, Barbara
(MDPR); mtiane@bellsouth.net;Roy, Michael (MDPD); Diaz, Jose J. (MDPD); Wood, Laura L.
(MDPD); Vigoa, Oscar F. (MDPD); Gonzalez, Arthur (MDPD); Diaz, Rene (DISTIl); Guerra, Lorena
(DISTll); Ferrer, Susel (DIST12); executive@swfwmd.state.fl.us; rand.baldwin@swfwmd.state.fl,us;
District9; Districtll; Commissioners@MyFWC.com; curt.kaloostin@myfwc,com;
mark.hodges@myfwc.com; christian.rodirguez@myfwc.com;james.marvin@fwc.com; Building Better
Communities (GOB); jeb.bush@myflorida.com; rconover@sfwmd.gov;jgalis-menendez@herald,com;
Heinicke, Mark (MDPR); FDA VIS@SFWMD.GOV; jackterrell@tarnpabay.rr.com;
tbyron@articcatinc.com; wbriske@ubankf1.com; libbyt@highlands.kI2.fl.us;
ericpalmaI129@hotmail.com; laptop@vol.com; bigscrub79@aol.com; swarnpbuggy2@earthlink.net;
MIAMIGIRLRIDER@YAROO.COM; denniscrf@yahoo.com; gatorjobn@bellsouth.net;
gbryant58@comcast.net; Iswjth2@yahoo.com;jkreiner@cfl.rr.com; indianjoe6@yahoo.com;
admin@atvflorida.com; fmallyy23l8@bellsouth.net; Honda_ 400@earthlink.net; Terry@onfa.org;
Looprd@aol.com; LinetteC@baptisthealth.net; ffiTPOLAR@aol.com; vana31117@yahoo.com;
Klawunn99@aol.com; Travis@napsatv.com; robert4570@aol.com; italo_maguina2005@hotmail.com;
mivis33@hotmail.com; mpardo@aeronet.com;rmesa@powinc.com;
raulpdruiz@mycingular.blackberry.net; candipalma@hotmail.com; JWCUSTOMS@aol.com;
approved@rnhrninvestors.com; JennI629@aol.com; wswisel@cox.net; danny4025@hotmail.com;
juanmoncada@comcast.net; andy6688@aol.com
Subject: STATEWIDE ATV RALLY
Please copy and paste link to see our rally video clip. .
htql:llfloriclaatvrally.comlindex,pbp?option=com content&task=view&id=30&Itemid=2
Good afternoon everyone:
Due to a tragic death of a child within our riding group, we as a group withdrew out of disgust,
mourning and respect.
But I am prond to announce that we regrouped, strengthened and organized and in memory of
Alan Smith, Kyle Flint, David Cain and Pedro Sr. we at A TVMIAXTREME and now
A TVMIAXTREME.ORG are BACK bigger and more dedicated than ever.
We have alot of new exciting things we are working on and soon enough we will be
ready and strong enough to take it straight to any Government agency and an the way to
Tallahassee.
Attached please fwd a flyer to the first State of Florida rally being held in Lakeland, Florida as we work
together hand by hand with SHAWN, FLORIDAATVRAll Y, ATVFLORIDA. NOR'IHPORT,
NQRA, THE BROWARD COUNTY AlRBOAT-HALFI'RACK & CONSERVATION
ASSOCIATION to raise our voices loud enough to be counted and heard as we have mrited as one for
a common goal of "OBTAINING LEGAL AND SAFE ORY PARKS FOR OUR CHILDREN and
RIDERS".
The ftrst rally will be held in the middle of the State of Florida to show solidarity as this is a growing
filQ./IV.\1>rn;QPtol?moIOQ_flIlIlIi"l _ n"n.._l'nJ1ip.r Parle Arnenclrnent\Documents\ReDort\June... 6/2/2009
.....t"'.t"'-..---- -.-. --- .
State Wide problem but the next rally shortly after will be held in the heart of MIAMI DADE as we
rank #3 in TOP SALES OF ATV'S IN THE UNITED STATES but have no legal and safe riding areas.
Please join us in the fight so future generations can enjoy the right to practice outdoor family ohv
activities.
Sincerly,
Your friend
Cary Hernandez (MIAMIGIRLRIDER)
www.atvmiaxtreme.com
www.floridaatvrally.com
www .atvmiaxtreme.or~
Bored stiff! Loosen up...
Download and play hundreds of games for free on Yahoo! Games.
f';\p./IV.\Prn;"",.\?(\(\Q\OQ_1l(}(lI;1 _ n"IIp._C'ollip.r P"rk Amendment\Docwnents\Reoort\June... 6/2/2009
..H.J:.Il:..H:.u.U.J..A v. J..J. :::HJ. J
From: Cary ortega [miamigirlrider@yahoo.com]
Sent: Monday, March 26, 2007 II :48 AM
To: Chuck.Collins@MyFWC.com; rconover@sfwmd.gov; YPineiro@miamiherald.com;
Julio.Robaina@myfloridahouse.gov; Moss, Dennis C. (DIST9); Vega, Olga R. (DISTI2); District12;
rconover@swfwmd.gov; McCall, James A (MDPR); GMarston@WRTdesign.com; Falsey, Barbara
(MDPR); Diaz, Jose J. (MDPD); Wood, Laura L. (MDPD); Vigoa, Oscar F. (MDPD); Gonzalez, Arthur
(MDPD); Diaz, Rene (DISTIl); Guerra, Lorena (DISTIl); Ferrer, Susel (DISTI2);
executive@swfwmd.state.fl.us; rand.baldwin@swfwmd.state,fl.us; District9; District I I ;
Commissioners@MyFWC.com; curt.kaloostin@myfwc.com; mark.hodges@myfwc.com;
christian.rodirguez@myfwc.com;james.marvin@fwc.com; FDA VIS@SFWMD,GOV;
jackterrell@tampabay.rr.com; waldroj@doacs.state.fl.us; District1; District2; District3; District4; District5;
District6; District7; District8; DistrictlO; Districtll; District13; Rice, Suzette (Mayor's Office)
ee: Christopher.Conkey@wsj.com; info@motorsportsmiami.com; sales@motorsportsmiami.com;
partsdept@motorsportsmiami.com; sales@aamoped-motorsports.com; sachatauber@rickcase.com;
sales@motoportusa.com; sales@motoportusasuzuki.com; sales@palmettomotorsportssuzuki.com;
sales@browardsuzuki.com; matts@rivamotorsports.com; roba@rivamotorsports.com; jetpolar@aol.com;
aaamoped@yahoo.com; drobinson@ridenow.com; info@palmettomotorsports.com;
bmschoppers@psnnewsletter.com; office@yamahaseadoo.com; service@yamahaseadoo.com;
sales@yamahaseadoo.com; sales@browardmotorsports.com; service@browardmotorsports.com;
info@blaiscycle.com; hdsouth@bellsouth.net; sales@rivasouth.net
Subject: Pro Bass Shop Airboat & Pulltrack Festival
Good morning Commissioners and fellow friends:
I would like to thank all of you that stopped by our booth at the Pro Bass Shop Air-boat and Full-track
Festival this weekend.
Furthermost, I would like to express our gratitude to our fellow hunter, full-track and air-boat friends that
extended the invitation to us and made our group and sport a part of this Community Event.
Its incredible how 30 minutes each day on a microphone, spreading awareness of our sport and the lack of
places our children have to practice it safely and legally while the state benefits in taxes and registrations
congregated so many new faces wanting more information about the groups and cause.
We raffled out shirts, handed out flyer's, stickers.
Over all this weekend event was very very successful and brought many groups and sportsman's together. At
the end we all concluded that regardless of the sport we practice we all want OUlDOOR FAMll..Y
RECREATIONAL ACTIVrnES to remain from becoming EXTINCT and that we NEED SAFE AND
LEGAL AREAS FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS to prevent senseless deaths.
I hope you enjoy the pictures and I hope to see you all again and the next event.
Sincerely,
Cary Hernandez
www.atvmiaxtreme.com
www.atvmiaxtrem.org
www.flo..;.j.~\vrally.com
www.t1oridaatvsssociation.com
It's here! Your new message!
Get new email alerts with the free Yahoo! Toolbar.
fildN :\Proiect~\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park AmendmentIDocuments\Rellort\June ... 6/2/2009
From: Cary ortega [miarnigirlrider@yahoo.com]
Sent: Monday, March 26, 2007 1:27 PM
To: Chuck.Collins@MyFWC.com;rconover@sfwmd.gov;YPineiro@miarniherald.com;
Julio.Robaina@myfloridahouse.gov; Moss, Dennis C. (DIST9); Vega, Olga R. (DISTI2); Districtl2;
rconover@swfwmd.gov; McCall, James A (MDPR); GMarston@WRTdesign.com; Falsey, Barbara
(MDPR); Diaz, Jose J. (MOPD); Wood, Laura L. (MDPD); Vigoa, Oscar F. (MDPD); Gonzalez, Arthur
(MDPD); Diaz, Rene (DISTIl); Guerra, Lorena (DISTIl); Ferrer, Susel (DISTI2);
executive@swfwmd.state.fl.us; rand.baldwin@swfwmd.state.fl.us; District9; Districtl1;
Commissioners@MyFWC.com; curt.kaloostin@myfwc.com; mark.hodges@myfwc.com;
christian.rodirguez@myfwc.com;james.marvin@fwc.com; FDA VIS@SFWMD.GOV;
jackterrell@tampabay.rr.com; waldroj@doacs.state.fl.us; Districtl; District2; District3; District4;
District5; District6; District7; District8; DistrictlO; Districtll; District13; Rice, Suzette (Mayor's Office)
Cc: Christopher.Conkey@wsj.com; info@motorsportsmiami,com; sales@motorsportsmiarni.com;
partsdept@motorsportsmiarni.com; sales@aamoped-motorsports.com; sachatauber@rickcase.com;
sales@motoportusa.com; sales@motoportusasuzuki.com; sales@pahnettomotorsportssuzuki.com;
sales@browardsuzuki.com; matts@rivamotorsports.com; roba@rivamotorsports.com;
jetpolar@aol.com; aaamoped@yahoo.com; drobinson@ridenow.com; info@palmettomotorsports.com;
bmschoppers@psnnewsletter.com; office@yamahaseadoo.com; service@yamahaseadoo.com;
sales@yarnahaseadoo.com; sales@browardmotorsports.com; service@browardmotorsports.com;
info@blaiscycle.com; hdsouth@bellsouth.net; sales@rivasouth.net
Subject: ATYMIAXTREME in the Miami Herald
htq>:/Iwww.miamiherald.coml460/story/47850.html
Attached please fmd the latest article in reference to atv's and our fight to obtain safe and legal riding
area.
A special thanks to Commissioner Jose "Pepe" Diaz who is working hard to find a solution to this
growing problem.
For the rest of you lets do all we can to help Mr. Pete Scalzo open up Opalocka West Airport to atv's. He
needs our help and support. DERM is NOW claiming the area is sensitive land.... WHY DO THEY
CARE IF IT IS SENSITIVE LAND IF IN ABOUT 2 YEARS IT WILL BE TURNED INTO A
ROCK MINE PIT TO PUMP MONEY INTO THE MIAMI INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT?????
THIS TEMPORARY PARK CAN SAVE LIFES!!I WHY IS DERM HOLDING US BACK!!!
WE MUST UNITE AND PUT A STOP TO THIS! Everything else is approved and the Insurance has
been obtained now we need for everyone to unite and push for this park to open up to our kids.
Read about it here...........
htq>:/Iwww.kec:pmedia.com/pubs/Mj..miHeraldl20061051l1l1548338?extlD=l0032&oliID=213
NOW WHY WOUW DERM even try to stop this when it can save a life to open this place up
temporarily for atvs!!!!.
Don't get soaked. Take a quick peek at the forecast
with theYahoo! Search weather .hnrtcut.
j'a~"IV.\'Prn;,,"'.I?MQ\OQ-OOOfi"l _ n"ilp.-C'nlli"" P"Tk Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June ... 6/212009
.....t...t-.....................~.. ~. - . ~--. .
From: Breto-Barros, Arlette (DISTll)
Sent: Wednesday, March 28, 2007 4:32 PM
To: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
Ce: McCall, James A (MDPR); Nardi, Maria (MDPR)
Subject: RE: atv park
Barbara, thanks for your prompt response regarding this matter; yes, please contact Mr. Webb and keep us in the
loop. Thank you, abb @
YIrfette 'Breto-'lJarros
Commissioner Joe A. Martinez, District 11
1401 SW 107thAvenue, Suite 301M
Miami, FL 33174
Office: 305-552-1155
Fax: 305-552-0577
&naiL' arlette@miamidade.gov
district11lqlmiamidade.gov
"Delivering Ex...1/ence Everyd'!)l"
"We are the .-bange we wish f{) see in the world, Chandi"
Miami-Dade County Is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning public records. E.
mail messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure. All E.mail sent and received is
captured by our servers and kept as a public record.
--Original Message----
From: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
Sent: Wednesday, March 28, 2007 1:54 PM
To: Breto-Barros, Ariette (DIST11)
Cc: McCall, James A (MDPR); Nardi, Marla (MDPR)
Subject: RE: atv park
Hi Arlette,
We are going to be meeting with aviation in the very near future to discuss the feasibility of
doing an A TV course there. The issue is that they are working with rock miners and the site may
not be available to us. The study we are fini.hing up looks at a range of options. If you like we
can contact Mr. Webb directly. We certainly understand his frustration and are hoping to be able
to help.
Barbara Falsey, Ph.D., Chief, Plann;ng and Research Division
Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2nd Stteet, 4th Floor, Miami Florida, 33128
305-755-7860 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax
www.miamidade.gov/parks
"Delivering ExceUence Every Day"
Miami-Dade County is a public entity subject to COOpter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning
public records. E-mail messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure.
--Original Message--
From: Breto-Barros, Arlette (DIST11)
Sent: Wednesday, March 28, 2007 12:14 PM
To: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
SUbJect: FW: atv park
f;J,,'/N'\Pm;pJ't.120ri9109-000ti::l _ Dade-ColHer Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June... 612/2009
.M..1J.1J~HUJ..^ v. J.,.1. ;J.1J. I
Good morning Barbara,
Mr. Shawn Webb, Treasurer for the Florida ATV Association contacted our office (see below)
requesting consideration for temporary use of the decommissioned Opa-Iocka airport for OHVE.
Please advise, thank you. Abb
Please do not hesitate to contact with any concerned regarding the above.
Thank you for your assistance,
.9Irktte 'lJreto-'lJaTros@
Commissioner Joe A. Martinez, District 11
1401 SW 107thAvenue, Suite 301M
Miami, FL 33174
O.fJia: 305-552-1155
Fax: 305-552-0577
Entoil: lIrlette@miamidade.gov
district11rabniamidade.gov
"Delivering ExceUem'C Everydqy"
'We are tbe dJdnge we wisb to see ;11 the world, Chandi'"
Miami-Dade County is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning
public records. E-mail messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure. All
E.mail sent and received is captured by our servers and kept as a public record.
--Original Message---
From: Shawn & Tori [rnailto:f1naltyy2318@beIlsouth.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 27, 20074:39 PM
To: OIstrictl1
SUbject: atv park
Dear Mr. Martinez
I am the current 1reasurer of the Florida Atv Association.
Our members In your area have contacted me regarding opening a piece of property located at
the decommissioned Opa-locka airport.
This could be a temporary solution to the crisis that Is facing participants of this very popular
sporl, in particular the ones who are located In your district.
Not having anywhere to ride Is very dangerous and encourages illegal activlly. Please help us
provide a safe, legal place for these otherwise responsible citizens.
Give us a place to go and you will see a difference. Imagine if someone took away your favorlle
thing to do and told you that you stili have to pay taxes on it, I believe you would also be a little
upset.
Please do not hesitate to contact me If I can be of any further assistance.
Shawn Webb 772-216-5952
..1~.'IV.\Prn;p,.,.\?()()Q\OQ_nonti~ _ n"t1,,-r.n11ier Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June .., 61212009
A.ppenalX V.1).:;,D. I
From: gerardo rodriguez [jerry@jerryrodriguez.com]
Sent: Sunday, May 13, 2007 12:20 PM
To: McCall, James A (MDPR)
Subject: Re: OHV Feasibility Study - Review Meeting with OHV Riders. Top Potential Sites, Project
Status
Thanks for the invitation. Expect me there.
Jerry Rodriguez
Miami Trailriders LLC
---- Original Message ----
From: "McCall, James A (MDPR)" <.TAMCCAL@miamidade.gov>
To: Lindsey Withrow <LWithrow@cg.WRTdesign.com>; Silvia Vargas
<SVargas@cg.WRTdesign.com>; GMarston@WRTdesign.com; "Heinicke, Mark (MDPR)"
<MHEINIC@miamidade.gov>; "Nardi, Maria (MDPR)" <MNARDI@miamidade.gov>; "Falsey,
Barbara (MDPR)" <Barbara@miamidade.gov>; "Diaz, Martha (MDPR)" <MarthaD@miamidade.gov>;
acollins@jciintemational.com; Brooke.Lynch@djj.state.fl.us; miamigirlrider@yahoo.com; Frank F.
Denninger (Business Fax) <lMCEAFAX-
Frank+20F+2E+20Deuninger+40+2B 1 +20+28305+29+20836-9281 @miamidade.gov>;
pml @bellsouth.net; thehump@thehumponline.com;jerry@jerryrodriguez.com
Sene Friday, May 11, 2007 3:58:37 PM
Subject: OHV Feasibility Study - Review Meeting with OHV Riders - Top Potential Sites, Project
Status
When: Thursday, May 17, 20075:00 PM-6:3O PM (GMT-05:OO) Eastem Time (US & Canada).
Where: 275 NW 2nd Street, 4th Floor Conference Room
._._..*-----*_._*--
Hello Everyone:
Thank you for your continued involvement In the OHV Feasibility Study. I would like to invUe you all to a meeting
to review the top potential sUes Identllied In the OHV Feaslbillly Study, and a project status repon. The
Department is planning to finish the repon soon, and would like to have your Input before wrlling the final draft.
Please let me know if you are available to meet aI this time.
Sincerely,
Andy McCalt, Park Planner 2
MiamI-Dade County Park end Recreation Department
275 NW 2nd St., Sulle 423, Miami, FL 33126
305-755-7993 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax
www.mlamidade.gov!parks
"Delivering Ext:ellenCfl Every Day"
Miami-Dade County is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning public records. E-
mall messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to dlscJosure.
BEGIN:VCALENDAR
METHOD:REQUEST
PRODID:Microsoft COO for Microsoft Exchange
filp./IV.IPrn;,..,..,.I?flflQIOQ.0Il1lti1 _ n~tle-r.nllier Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June ... 61212009
~i-.l-.C...................... ".J..J.-,~.'
VERSION:2.0
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:(GMT-05.00) Eastern Time (US & Canada)
X-MlCROSOFT-CDO- TZID:1O
BEGIN:STANDARD
DTST ART: 160101011'02??oo
TZOFFSETFROM:-0400
TZOFFSETI'O:-0500
RRULE:FREQ=YEARL Y;WKST=MO;INTERV AL=1;BYMONTH=II;BYDA Y=ISU
END:STANDARD
BEGIN:DA YLIGHT
DTST ART: 16010101 T020000
TZOFFSETFROM:-0500
TZOFFSETTO:-0400
RRULE:FREQ=YEARL Y;WKST=MO;INTERV AL=1 ;BYMONTH=3;BYDA Y=2SU
END:DA YLIGHT
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTST AMP:20070511 Tl95836Z
DTSTART;TZID="(GMT-05.00) Eastern Time (US & Canada)":20070517Tl70000
SUMMARY:OHV Feasibility Study - Review Meeting with OHV Riders - Top Potent
ial Sites\, Project Status
UID:040000008200EOOO74C5B7101A82EOO80000000090FFEC3BE593C701000000000000000
010000000B 140DCF03EOB544083022DFE48AC3A7E
ATIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-
ACI'ION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="'Lindsey
Withrow"':MAILTO:LWithrow@cg.WRTdesign.com
ATIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACI'ION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Silvia
Va
rgas":MAD..TO:SV argas@cg.WRTdesign.com
ATTENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTlCIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-
ACI'ION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="GMarston@
WRTdesign.com":MAILTO:GMarston@WRTdesign.com
ATIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTlCIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-
ACTION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Heinicke,
Mark (MDPR)":MAILTO:MHEINIC@miamidade.gov
ATIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTlCIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACI'ION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Nardi,
Ma
ria (MDPR)":MAILTO:MNARDI@miamidade.gov
ATIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTlCIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-
ACTION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Falsey, B
arbara (MDPR)":MAILTO:Barbara@miamidade.gov
ATIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACI'lON;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Diaz,
Mar
tha (MDPR)":MAD..,TO:MarthaD@miamidade.gov
A TIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTlCIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACI'ION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Amy
Colli
115 (acollins@jciinternational.com)":MAD..TO:acollins@jciintemational.com
ATIENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-
ACI'ION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Brooke Ly
nch (Brooke.Lynch@djj.state.t1.us)":MAILTO:Brooke.Lynch@djj.state.t1.us
file:/N:\Proiects\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June ... 61212009
..M..t;J.t;JC.LJ.U..l....... V. J.....I. ;..JJ..J. I
ATTENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Cary
Hem
andez (miamigirlrider@yahoo.com)":MAILTO:miamigirlrider@yahoo.com
ATTENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Jose
Camp
s (pml @bellsouth.net)":MAlLTO:pml@bellsouth.net
ATTENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-ACTION;RSVP=TRUE;CN="Marc
Lane
(thehump@thehumponline.com)":MAILTO:thehump@thehumponline.com
ATTENDEE;ROLE=REQ-PARTICIPANT;PARTSTAT=NEEDS-
ACTlON;RSVP=TRUE;CN="jerry@je
rryrodriguez.com"':MAll..TO:jerry@jerryrodriguez.com
ORGANIZER;CN="McCalI, James A (MDPR)":MAlLTO:JAMCCAL@miamidade.gov
LOCA TION:275 NW 2nd Street\, 4th Floor Conference Room
DTEND;lZID="(GMT-D5.00) Eastern Time (US & Canada)":20070517Tl83000
DESCRlPTION:Hello Everyone:\N\NThank you for your continued involvement in
the ORY Feasibility Study. I would like to invite you all to a meeting to
review the top potential sites identified in the ORY Feasibility Study\,
and a project status report. The Department is planning to finish the rep
ort soon\, and would like to have your input before writing the fmal draf
t. Please let me know if you are available to meet at this time.\N\NSince
rely\,\N\NAndy McCall\, Park Planner 2 \NMiami-Dade County Park and Recrea
tion Department \N275 NW 2nd St.\, Suite 423\, Miami\, FL 33128 \N305-755-
7993 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax \Nwww.miamidade.gov(parks \N"Delivering Excel
1ence Every Day" \NMiami-Dade County is a public entity subject to Chapter
119 of the Florida Statutes concerning public records. E- msil messages ar
e covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure.\N \N\N
SEQUENCE:O
PRlORITY:5
CLASS:
CREA TED:200705l1 T195836Z
LAST -MODIFIED:20070511 Tl95837Z
STATUS:CONFlRMED
TRANSP:OPAQUE
X-MICROSOFf-CDO-BUSYSTATUS:BUSY
X-MICROSOFT-CDO-INSITYPE:O
X-MICROSOFT-CDO-INTENDEDSTATUS:BUSY
X-MICROSOFT-CDO-AllDAYEVENT:FALSE
X-MICROSOFT-CDO-IMPORTANCE:1
X_MICROSOFT_CDO_OWNERAPPTID:_540321833
X-MICROSOFT-CDO-APPT-SEQUENCE:O
X-MICROSOFT -CDO-A TI'ENDEE-CRITICAL-CHANGE:20070511 T195836Z
X_MICROSOFT-CDO-OWNER-CRITICAL-CHANGE:2007051IT195836Z
BEGIN:V ALARM
ACTION:DISPLAY
DESCRIPTION:REMINDER
TRlGGER.;RELATED=START:-PTOOH15MOOS
END:V ALARM
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR
fil,...tN,\Prn;p.cts\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June ... 6/2/2009
--rr-----.. . .-.--..
From: Katie A. Edwards [dcfb2@bellsouth.net]
Sent: Tuesday, June 05, 20072:13 PM
To: McCall, James A (MDPR)
Subject: Thank You
Dear Andy,
Thank you for making a presentation to the board of directors today. You did a great job explaining the options
and implementation process.
Please keep us abreast of any developments in the OHV park project.
Sincerely,
Katie Edwards
Katie A. Edwards
Executive Director
Dade County Fami Bureau
1850 Old Dixie Hwy.
Homestead, FL 33033
Phone (305) 246-5514 ext. 226
Fax (306) 247.5670
Mobile (305) 281-7323
www.dade-agrlcutture.org
m,,'/N.IPrn;Pr..I?OOQIOQ.f'lIlNi'l- n~tl"_('n1lieT P~rk Amendment\Documents\Reoort\June ... 6/2/2009
AppenQ~X V.U.~D. I
From: Johnson, Will (DISTI)
Sent: Monday, Jnly 23, 2007 11 :45 AM
To: McCall, James A (MDPR)
Cc: 'Brian.haunigan@mch.com'; Bernstein, Ron (CAO); Jdiberdo@mdpd.com'; Rock, Darin (MDPD);
Arias, Ruben J. (DISTI); Caviglia, Silvia (DIST7); Kim, Inson (DIST7); 'JClauser@EFOF.org'
Subject: Kid's Safety Week
Mr. James McCall
Parks And Recreation Department
Your name was mentioned in a Miami Herald Neighbors Section article on
Sunday in reference to possible ATV riding sites (Parks).
I have been meeting over the past few months with people and organizations
who are concerned with the escalating number of accidents, traumas and
deaths revolving around what we call: "Kid Motorized Vehicles." This designation
includes: 1) Off-road Dirt Bikes 2) Motorizes (battery powered) Toddler Vehicles
(Barbie Convertibles etc...) and 3) ATV's of all types. We noticed that more of this
type "toy," is being purchased for Christmas and the number of accidents have
gone up exponentially.
Prompted by growing number of these vehicles on city streets and busy highways
__ are engaged in drawing a resolution that will call for one week in November to be
declared .Child Safety Awareness Week."
The Commissioners and other elected, expert and those charged with public
safety -- will use this week to publicize (bring to the attention of parents and
guardians) the responsibility that goes with the purchase of such vehicles. Also
stressed will be the importance of "Buckling-Up" and using the proper auto restraint
devices while transporting kids. The target age (Kids) 2 to 18 years of age. I have
attached a draft of the Resolution,
Our group convened by District 7, County Commissioner Carlos A. Gimenez,
consists of the Metro-Dade Police, Miami Children's Hospital, The Epilepsy
Foundation and the County Attorney's Office. Since you have been studying the
possibility of legalized space to operate ATV -- we feel that a representative from
Parks and Recreation Department should be on hand and a working member of the
Resolution Committee.
A large part of the awareness campaign -- logically - should come through our
parks system. The campaign will seek to make parents and guardians think twice
before purchasing a motorized -- non-street-Iegal vehicle for a child - unlicensed
and under 18 years of age. If we can not persuade most to make an alternative
purchase -- then we want them all to know that there are limited places to legally
operate such vehicles and whole lot of safety equipment in recommended and a
whole lot of personal supervision is required.
We hope to convince some major retailers (Toys are US. Wal-Mart etc...) to join
us in dissemination information to parents and guardians at the point of purchase.
filp.:/N:\Proiect.\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June .n 612J2009
Please email or fax any of your findings to date (possible ride sites) on this
issue. We would also like Parks and Recreation to opine on the Draft Resolution.
You or a designated Parks Representative will be invited to our next meeting.
Thanks
Will Johnson
Aide to
Miami-Dade County
Commissioner
Carlos A. Gimenez
District 7
(305) 446-3311
(305) 660-4003
Cell: (305) 310-2075
Fax: (305) 569-7672
fi1",IN:\Proiect.~\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June ... 61212009
~.."t-' 1:" ...........'-0............ W.......................
From: Cary ortega [miamigirlrider@yahoo.com]
Sent: Wednesday, August OS, 2007 10:45 PM
To: jackterrell@tarnpabay.rr.com; waldroj@doacs.state.fl.us; Districtl; District2; District3; District4;
DistrictS; District6; District7; District8; Districtl0; Districtll; District13; Rice, Suzette (EPS); Ferrer,
Susel (DISTI2); Diaz, Rene (DISTIl); Guerra, Lorena (DISTIl); GMarston@WRTdesign.com;Falsey,
Barbara (MDPR); McCall, James A (MDPR); Julio.Robaina@myfloridahouse.gov; Moss, Dennis C.
(DIST9); Vega, Olga R. (DISTl2); YPineiro@miamiherald.com; Chuck.Collins@MyFWC.com;
mark.hodges@myfwc.com
Subject: LEGAL AND SAFE RIDING AREAS IN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY
I would like to share the news that Mike has come out of his coma liD and is recovering from his atv
accident that he had a few months ago. It is truly a miracle that we did not lose this child to another
tragic senseless atv death.
Several OHV Groups and I will continue to do everything in our power to ensure that this Community
fmally provides our children with a safe and legal riding area for them to enjoy this family sport.
Mike was on of the lucky ones but not every case is such. Gus, Alan, Kyle and Walter are only a few of
the children we have lost in the past year but they can rest assure we will continue our fight on there
behalf.
To those Commissioners such as Jose "Pepe" Diaz, Katy Sorenson and Joe Martinez and Mayor
Alvarez that have handled this problem with such interest I thank you from the bottom of my heart and
for those of you who still have not even returned a phone call I suggest you start listening to the needs of
your REGISTERED VOTERS!
Sincerely and working together with you,
Cary Hernandez
www.atvmiaxtreme.com
www.atvmiaxtreme.org
Ready for the edge of your seat? Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV.
file:/N:\Pmiects\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June ... 612/2009
From: Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
Sent: Monday, August 28, 2006 8:58 AM
To: McCall, James A (MDPR)
Subject: FW: Question from Representative Zapata
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Due By: Monday, August 28, 2006 2:00 PM
Flag Status: Flagged
Andy _ please get me a quick status report on where the consultants are and what we have done to date. Include
the funding source. Thanks
Barbara Falaey, Ph.D., Chief, Planning and Research Division
MiamI-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2nd Street, 4th Floor, Miami Florida, 33128
305-755.7860 Phone 305-755-7864 Fax
www.mlamldade.aov/Darks
"DelIvering Excellence Every Day.
Miami-Dade County is a public entity subject to Chapter 119 of the Florida Statutes concerning public
records. E-mail messages are covered under such laws and thus subject to disclosure.
--Original Message---
From: Oonnell Rodriquez, Vivian (MDPR)
Sent: Sunday, August 27, 2006 10:20 AM
To: Gregg, W. Howard (MDPR)i Falsey, Barbara (MDPR)
Subject: FW: Question from Representative Zapata
Update me on the study so that I can respond to this. Thanks.
From: Sanchez, Oaudia [mallto:Oaudla.Sanchez@myfloridahouse.gov]
Sent: Thursday, August 24, 2006 12:54 PM
To: Oonnell Rodriquez, VIvian (MDPR)
SUbject: Question from Representative Zapata
Ms. Rodriguez:
Rep. Juan Zapata would like If there are any plans to build or acquire a facillly (that provides for oft-road biking,
skateboarding, paintball, etc) In Miami-Dade County. If there are, how far along are those plans in the process?
If there aren't any plans, whal can our office do to encourage such a facility (or In other words, what is the
process)?
We would really appreciate your help. Thanks for your timellll
Claudia Sanchez
Legislative Aide
Representative Juan C. Zapata
T 305- 273-3288
T 850-488-9550
F 305-273-3290
file:/N :\Proiects\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\1une... 6/2/2009
....,t-',t-'.......................... ~ -.....,.. -'~ - ,
Frem: Jim UiIILWildecl999@yahoo.comJ
Sea" Mooday, Seplember 18, 200610:28 AM
To: McCaJl, James A (MDPR)
Subject:: Re: FW: Updated: Off-Highway Vehicle Feasibility Study - South Florida W8Ier Management District and Miami~Dade County
fun,
I trust the meeting is stilI proceeding as planned. If DOl, let me know. I will be driving down from Palm Beach County around 12:30 PM today to attend
Let me know iflherc is anything you need from me, either in my role 15 the President oftbe Southeast Florida Trail Riders, Vice President of the Florida Tmil Riders (the
oonprofit organization that sanctiOJ1!lstatewide events) or IS the Chairman oftbe OHV Advisory Committee.
See you at 2:00 PM.
Jim Wilder
561.702.3010 (mobile)
"M<Ca/I, J"",esA (MDPR)" <JAMCCAL@~ wroIc:
When: Monday, SeptEmber 1e, 2006 2:00 PM.4:30 PM (GMT-<l5:OO) Eastern lime (US & Canada).
Where: SFWND MiamI Regional SerVICe Center, 2121 SW 3Id Avenue, Miami, FL -fRh f1lXr" amtarenoe room.
.-.....-.-.-.-.-.-.-.
--()rlglM1..........b._.
fnIno= McCd."""'A(fIlOPR)
SUIt:~.~Dli,lOllli3:05""
~ ttcQI,.)ImIls"(flDl'llJ.;~.""CiKlI~s.Illvwow.UIlIMrWltMwr,~OIl",,,,bB1,",..-.;~,Gwen(l)ERM);YOlO'lp,Emllle{OERM);CKIIlo~QlrtlIInI(tlElIMJ;Smlh.
'TIlMr(D8Ull);Gcm8IeI,YGIInrlIl(DBUl)
Cct ftIter,IllnlInI(fl~;HneI,En=(MDI'llJ;IWd.""(MDI'R):~MR(MOPR);DlII."""(MDFI\);SnIllh,Jnon;OrdInes,AudNr.Waldlotl.)ohn
~; UpdaDed:0INIgIlnyVeHc2~~-$GuthFkrlllIWJllr........,.....1IlItJI!!8lllIM\moOIldIl(.ounty
...... """'*1,~18,2llO&2;OOfIM-4:30PtIl(GMT"''flll)Ellt8niIrM(U5.c..dJ).
wr-., SfWMDMlIm1fleglOllll!iavlcl!CmIllr,2Ul:;N3JdAftlu,Jll6ld..fl-MhIloar(tl'tswanlOlll.
E_,
The Maml-Dade County Park and Recreatloo Department Is In the process 01 compIeling an on-Highway Vehicle (OHV) Feulbntty Study, asearch tor kind or COITidor$ for OHV
trails on my available ptOpeTty within the Cour4y boundaries. The Department (end c:onsuIIant team from Wallac:e, Flcbert&. and Todd. ltC) are In the process ofldllntltylng /ancls
that are most auitable for OHV traI\S. The South Roode. Water Management DfstricI: (SFWMD) has a wide variety of large acreages, nelura! oorrldors, and ClI'I81 rIghts-of way thai
cauld serve u ateaS for OHV recreation.
Please atlend this Important meetlng, as we disaas the posslblllties for OHV recreatim wItt'lln SFWMO lands. Please let me know If 1hls dale and time works for your schedUle.
....on,
Thanks a.gaIn for helplng to coordinate this meeting, Md lor profflfng the meeting room. Would you please forward 1h1S meeting request 10 Mr. CaYis. and to all clthe land
manager.t IIOCI plannefs at SFWMD thai are Jnterested?
-~.
Andy 1Icc.r1. Park Planner 2
M1aml-Dade COunty Porkamt _Depo_
Z7S/ffl 2nd St., Suite 0123, Miami. FL 33128
305.765-7893 Phone 305.755-7864 Fax
www.m1amldade,gov/parlls
'OoU"""" _&ery Dey"
Miaml-Dade Coumy Is It public sntit;y subjecl to Chapter 119 of the Rorida Slatules concemlng pubUc: reconJs. E-mail messages are cavered urJfNr
such law.:s and thus subject to dJsck>sute.
Jim Wilder
561.102.3010 (mobile)
filP',IIV,\Pro;ect~\2009\09-00063 - Dade-Collier Park Amendment\Documents\Report\June ... 6/212009
APPENDIX V.D.Sb.8
LEE COUNTY AGENDA REQUEST
FORM
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Item #4
Page 1 of 8
Management & Planning Committee
Agenda Request Form
COMMISSION DISTRICT #
PRESENTED BY: John Yarbrough, Dept Director REQUESTED BY:Administration
TITLE OF ITEM FOR THE AGENDA: Off Highway Recreational Vehicles (ATV's & Motorcycles)
I. Description and Obiective ofthe issue:
Lee County cunentlyhas no facility for citizens to ride All Terrain Vehicles (ATV's) or off road
motorcycles. As a result, there is widespread illegal use of both private property and public property by
these users.
Lee County has applied for and been awarded grants from the Division of Forestry ($70,000) and the I
Department of Environmental Protection, Office of Green ways and Trails ($437,420). These funds are
available to identifY a site, and develop an A TV and motorcycle facility for the express pwpose of
providing safe recreational opportunities in an area which will not be detrimental to the natural
environment. Amenities will include marked trails, restrooms, parking area, training area equipment
washing area, and a small administration building.
.
2. Proposed Policv. Procedure or Plan of Action
BoCC give direction to Lee County Parks and Recreation to accept the grants and to identify potential
OHV site or sites. This would be a Board policy decision as to whether or not this should be a duty of
Lee County Government.
3. Options lList advanta~esI disadvanta~es of each ootion listed)
OPTION #1: Allows Lee County to accept $507,420 to develop a plan to encourage OHV use in a
recognized facility which is properly planned and developed.
ADVANTAGE: Allows Lee County to offer approved site for OHV's and motorcycles.
DlSADV ANT AGE: Lee County incurs financial burden of developing facility and potential liability.
OPTION #2: Do not accept the grant and do not pursue an OHV Park.
ADV ANT AGE: No costs to Lee County
DISADV ANT AGE: Riders will continue to use public and private lands.
4. Financial Impacts I Funding Source
Lee County has been offered two grants totaling $507,420 for the design and development of this project.
Parks and Recreation has a total of $600,000 budgeted for the next 2 fiscal years in Regional Park Impact
Fees to match the grants,.
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Page 2 of 8
5. Staff Recommendations and Justifications for recommendations
Staff recommends Option #1. OHV use is an extremely popular recreation activity in Lee County and is
supported by the State and Federal Governments. Lee County ranks in the top five for numbers of
participants in the State of Florida. In the last few years, Lee County has experienced an increasing
number of riders trespassing in search of a suitable riding area. As such, public and private lands have
been damaged by unsupervised activities and on several occasions there have been very serious accidents.
6. Mandated? YesD No ~
Bv what authority?
ature /
Meeting Date
Time Required
JOJ\,~,LO01
/0 VIA tVU;(C( s
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Page 3 of 8
~toIc.a
L
MOfOfl.'Yl"'~/^TV PAFtf<.
tor-JGef"TI.I~L. PLAN
.
~. tDI.INN' PAIZICh t ~~ .,.,0t0J
t
o
O,1.IAI~
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Page 4 of 8
,
.
.
""
~ f.
..
.
-
;::
I-
0
<C
w
..J 00
l- e
Q
- "- .+:;
I- Q U
- re ?ft.
..J c 00 ?ft. ?ft. ?ft. ?ft.
Q) c L[) N U) g
<C !: re ....... ..- ~o N
....
Q) I- .-
Z CL (ij
0 -
Q
- l-
t!) "- 00 "'"
W 0 c f::.:i_
0 L[) @-
0::: .... .+:; ffl .-
Q) "'" P{ ~
..0 U o_
re ""'-
E en 0") l:8 f8 .-
::J C co .-
2 '"
....
I-
.0_.
....
c Q)
Q .c
.c, E .- N \'l "'"
Q) :::I
0.::2
lQ
Cl
Cl
~
~
>- >- '0
~ ro 0)
?: ::]
.c I/)
.c .gl I/)
C)
.- 0) :cO) I/)
-I :c- ~ ll= 13 ~ ~
8~
c( o ~<1: :1:
.... <1: I-
0 ?:..9 ?: '00'0 ~
0)- 0)
en 0)00) I/) 0 I/)
- z~ z ::::>~ ::::> f-
U- 1\1 . 0 0 .
>-
CO
W -
(.) LO(()
Z 00
00
c( NN
::J
tnr:r:
tnc( -
-W ",,"10
~>- 00
00
l- NN
-
I-
~ -
("/')"""
00
00
J: NN
C)
-
J: -
U- N("/')
U- 00
00
0 NN
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ -
10 0 10 0 10 0 10 0 10
""" """ ("/') ("/') N N 0
.,... .,... ~
...
~
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Page 5 of 8
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Page 6 of 8
1-'
o
8
<Xi
0
IX; 0
0
0
,..:
~ In
~
Z <Xi
:::)
0
(.) 0
0
W " 0
(.) <Xi
Z :g
W ~
0
iij
w
a: 0
0
>- 0
1XI ..0
I/)
W UI
...l w
(.) ..J
I-
J: 0 j::
W 0 w
> 0
..... ..J
~ u
l:i :c
~ w
ri , >
J: ""
!:2 , ~
J: ri 0
0
u. 0
u. ",'
0
a:
0
u. 0
I/) ~ 0
Z .... 0
0 lB. 0
..... II) N
1= .... ....
(.) .... 11)0
~ r! ....
"!. [(;
Z .... ....
g 8l ....
0
'" 8.
w ~ "" ....
..J 15
I-
1= ~
0
<( 0: ~ 0 0 0 z w CIl 5 0: <( w 5 w ..J <( 0: Z Z t; CIl
~ w 0: 0:: 0:: ~ 1= ~ w OJ 0 X ~ OJ w ::::; w w
:r: l<: 0 ~ ~ 0 0::: ::::; ::!! (!i is ~ ..J l<: 0 ii: 0
u <( u. :r: 9 I- U ..J ~ CIl ::::l ~ Z ~ :r: ~
~ CD ~ W ..J U 0 ..J W 0 U ~ U ~ <0
0:: <( ~ U 0 0 ..J 0
<( CD 0: U CIl U. u. a 0
CD CD :r: u w ~
U ~
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Page 7 of 8
o
o
1..........-..-..---..--.--..---.-.---.--...-.------.~-....._--..--._.-.--...- -...--.--. 0
~ ~
, 1lS.
I "'"
I
I
! 8
,..:
:---_...__..----~_._--------y-_._--_._._---~---~_..
i ,... <lS
: flj cD
I .
I <0
i
Appendix V.D.5b.8
Page 8 of 8
"'--.-..-..------- -.------..-
~
,...
..il
w 0:: Z .0;
wOO 1ii
z ~ Z :=J
~ ~ ::l ...J
;:. ~
::l
en
10.
.,.
l()
~
~
Lr "L..,.
~
Lia
:5 Z Z
...J 0 0
::l .... t5
>c: :;t Z
~ 3: :E
en
~
a
a
a
,..:
a
:3
cD
a
g
<6
a
a
a III
.... W
...l
I-
i=
w
...
u
8 ~
M
a
a
a
N
a
~
~
rg
a
C!
,...
C!
N
APPENDIX V.D.5b.9
OHV TITLED IN MIAMI-DADE
COUNTY
..
OFF-HIGHWAY VEHICLES TITLED FOR 2OO2.200s
PlANNING I\. RESEil.R<;H QlVISlON
PARI< AND RECREATION OEP/>$TMFNT
,ul'f1OO/ OHV MDCrn~o
SOURCE [l(>p.ytrnenl or Highway Salory to Motor V('l1j(lo~ (OHSMV)
XX><)(
;/
". .~' X "'
'X ")(y 'X "1<'
;~*~.~>~.
:. ~: ,ex
A' .
X
>
,
.,
8roward
.
~.
~". .
"'.
...
.0
~.
.t~
~
..
%
.'
ii'
Miamj.Dade, County
.
,
,!Ilff s~
~
:I4IlTI-l 151 ~
39:mO Sf
.
\
3.
"0
..
~
\
~
Co U
.
.
12BTH 5T
Legend
. DHSMV . Households VWh OHVs Titled in MDC: 2002.
BICY i1ddilion
Big Cypress NP
Biscayn.
:.;.~~ E~rglades
~'a;~ Everglades addition
Water Conservation Area
W+E
S
WCA-2
WCA-3A
WCA-3S
11II Stille Parb
County Par1<s
Environmenlaly Endangered land Sites
Major Roads
o
1.252.5
5 Miles
"/,>/
"
.->
~
i:iI
0::
~
Z
~
t-<
~
i:iI
0::
u
i:iI
0::
UJ
UJ
i:iI
0::
P<
><
U
0::
f:Q
H
H
o
y
i:iI
r::l
~
r::l
I
0)
.Q
l1)
q
:>
~
r::l
Z
i:iI
P<
P<
~
APPENDIX V.D.Sh.tO
OHV TITLED IN COLLIER COUNTY
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF HIGHWAY SAFETY AND MOTOR VEHICLES
LOCATION OF TITLED OHVS WITHIN COLLIER COUNTY
I ".,
I.~ "., .
"., ~
,
~ .
.
CR846
LEE
.~( ,.
~. .. . ,. LEERDE
'\
III CR858
'"
..
, ...
.
COLLIER
~
.
. .
.
; ...
..
Legend
o 1.25 2.5
5
..
...
u,,,
. ~., 0
~
"
~
q
. >
" ~
~.. 0
z
~
"
"
~
N
W+E
S
MAY 13, 2009
DHSMV OHVs Titled in Collier County 2002-2009
- Highways
Ma"Of Roads
Miles
1 inch = 1.8 miles
APPENDIX V.D.Sb.ll
FLORIDA OHV COUNTY TITLE
ACTIVITY, 6/30/02 to 12/31/08
"
o
.f-
IT..
I~
!f'
-i
-
-i
r-
m
-i
^'
)>
Z
U')
)>
n
-i
-
o
Z
sU')
m'"
ZO
n^'
~--~- n.__n_ m 0
n'"
0'"
c:::t
iZ Cl
r:< ::t
------ti ~
fr,; -<
:' <
!J> m
f ::t
~:' -
'0. n
r-
m
U')
...
..
"
\D
(Xl
.f-
"
"
'"
0:>
.!"
...
Ul
"
...
-
\D
.f-
....
"
"
"
w
.!"
Ul
.f-
"
.!"
~m
"'-(
Un ;0
m
U')
!t'
... ....
" W
o 0
<
m
J:
(5
r
m
-I
:::j
m
'"
o
'"
'j",
'"
Ul
(Xl
'"
'"
Ul
----~-_.
-------------i~j,i,
It..
"..;.
t-!.
~~;
~,
4'::
r~
IF
ii'
~,::
~I~:
~"
&";
~
y
----.._.._--_.~.._-..-
...
."
(Xl
.f-
"
...
"
-
Ul
.f-
w
n
o
C
:J
r+
'<
-i
-.
r+
ro
)>
n
r+
-.
<
-.
r+
'<
m
W--
o
0--
tv
I
J-l
tv
W--
1-'__
tv
o
o
00
s;:N
Itl i
N'"
0....
N Itl :t
...
N
,.., IV
t> '"
IV
...
Itl
....
."
::0
r
._~
\11
~
'"
IV
'"
.!"
\11
53
.!"
...
~
~
o
CO
...
.!"
....
...
....
~
:J:
o
r-
m
-i
=i
r-
m
en
""
W
""
N
,""
...
...
co
,0'1
co
\11
o
,co
N
~
.!D
...
o
o
,;.,_."..."",.~,,,,,~....,,,,...,.-...",,...~.>.",,,..
....
-
....
r-
m
....
~
:I>
2
VI
o:J:I>
<!:I
~-
mO
,VI 2
! - VI
i C ."
1m 0
i2 ~
l~ 0
In'"
10 ."
c:::t
,2 ^
i.... WI
!..... ::t
......~
~
<
m
::t
-
n
r-
m
VI
n
o
C
:::J
~
--t
;:+-
-
fD
)>
n
r-t-
<-
--
r-t-
'< -
S1'
w--
9
0--
~
I
~
~
-
w--
p
~-
o
o
00
n
o
'C
:J
....
... m ...
i .. ... ...
UI ... ...
'" '" UI
ao--- ... ..
UI ~ 1"
IN
..
C>
..
~
....
....
IN
en
..
'"
...
N
:5 ...
~
UI
....
'"
;..
...
IN
....
...
-.0
IN
...
en
UI
...
...
en
...
...
'"
...
m
...
... ...
~ 't
..
APPENDIX V.D.Sb.12
OHV ORGANIZATIONS AND CLUBS
"
~
!}.
~
"
"
~
~
~
"
"
:a
~
~
~
0-
o
"
6
0:
o
o
"
o
U
N
.0
"'
o
:>
x
'6
c
W
0.
0.
<:
.2
o
'"
00
<..:
:3,
1::
c
"
~
u
<<:
"
.:;:
;;;
~
U
"
~
""
"
"
:;0
~
~
~
~
is
~
(9.-
o
~
~
"
~I
~
C
1!
o
>
~
g
~
.~
~
,
,
,
"
9-
:a
u
~
en
>
::c
o
.
=
o
.~
~
~
]
~
~
~
o
"
E
.
>
~
]
'"
"
"'
(;
en
"
E
"
'"
~
~
"
"
",..)
3>
5~
G:O
"
"
5
IL
~
E
o
'-'
"
.s
"
"
~
u
"
~
~
-
~
"
C/l
"
U ~
:.Eu
IJ) :E
> "
" >
" "
...c:; 'a
I:
::E " ::E
tt:=::~
O~O
"
"
" .-
a a
cd 'C
~u
. . .
.
.
"
."
.OJ
'- ~
" '"
:.a
~ ~
~~
'0
2
."
~
. . .
~
~
"
"
"
;;
E
"
a
"
U
o
~
'0
"
o
"2
"
o
~
t/)
.c
::::J
-
o
"C
s:::
m
t/)
s:::
o
.-
-
m
N
.-
s:::
m
Cl
...
o
>
:I:
o
a
o
'<
'0
o
..c:
u
~
"
"'"
:B
~
'6
:i
.u ~ "
~ .~"O,,: ~ ~
;:::;> ] 'i
.2 u ~
~ ~ ~
> ~-
~~~~E
~ "E ~ t: ~
U E ;;; 0 2
-uQ)<t:fc~~
'0 '" .2 >.
~ Q) ~ (;j]
>2~-g~
:>..';:: ;> ::l
~cu&~
~~.~ c<
.- u 'Jj -2 Q
=; :.a ..5 ~ '8
tt: ~ >. 0,) ::l
o>>~uaa
"'a .... cd >.
::::: ";j (/) ~ 0
.2 'u > .9 u
~ (.) E-o 0 ::r:
z~~::E";'
~
q
u
u
>
..c:
o
"
:i
"
"
;,;
~
"
u
u
5 ~
~ c
_ .~ .2
..... E-o ~
.S !::: f:
~ i3 u
'13 'I: Q)
o " ~
~ E 0,)
:g~~:D
IJ) .'(;i
.::: .~ 3: c
:i u " &
3: ~ 3: ~
3: a ~ ~
~ '0 '@ ~
..c: ::E '" ~
co c c c:
:J ~ .~ 13
"0 'C ;..."C
cd 0 () Q)
2 a a a
"'~~~
. . . . . . . . .
11l
C
o
:;::
as
.!:!
c
as
Cl
...
o
iii
c
o
:;::
as
Z
a
o
'<
~
~
"
u
u
"
,
"
I:
"
:i
"
"
~
.c
'"
ci
:>
x
'0
c
~
0.
0.
<:
11l
C
o
:;::
as
,!:!
c
as
Cl
...
o
Q)
'0
'3:
Q)
-
as
-
Cf)
~
o
,:
..c:
o
"
'0
.;:
o
0::
:i
~ a S
o ~ u
E ~ =: ~
cd 11) 4: '8
ED ;> IlS l-
e "8 E ~
0... G.) Vl C
;::: a;>-<
.2 cd ~ rJJ
(;j 3:..c cd
~ cd ~ ~ 3:
U ] a " ~
~ 0 3: ~
o:::i l?
"'8 00 3: en cd
cd -t: 3: ~]
c:g :.a 0
~-o.~u~
~ ~ t?l ~ ~
.Q~ao3:
u 3: '5 3:
~3:~:S~
> " a ~ "
:>.. OJ ~ >. ~
ro u cd .......
3: ";:;: c ~ ol1 ~
..c I- ro cd 0
OJ) 0,) ~ r/.l ~ ~
~~;...~~~
~eB3:c c
O&~;8 N
-0 '";j I- ::r: 0
E .o_c ~ b b
"fi .... ..... E 0,)
en cd U d) U
zUa'-
~ -< ~ t:: C
"" ~ > " r:>.
~ CIl ;> fr ~
b;:or3l~~
~
~
c,
".
c-.
7.
]
~
=
:'
~
o
-"",
.
.
"
~
c
o
~
~
.
~
.
.
.
B-
E
E
o
u
U
~
:::E
:i
"
"
~
o
vi
~
" u
o '0
';;'; :.s
r:/J -8
'E ~
E '0
o .t:
U 0
" !:;::
o :i
'(;;j ~
1: "
"
" ~ "
~ 5.g
u '"
~ 'w
P<: ;g 0
'2 _ (/'J
; :g ~
] ~ ~
OJ -g ci5
.E ("j
-> ..J:: >
>. ~ ~
1 r..r:: 0
J'
C-
o
U
"
"
c
,
~
o
U
'"
'0
.t:
~ 0
~~
.
.
.0
::s
o
<C
c
'0
...,
~
~
~
~
~ Q
'"
Ci5 0
.~ ~ 8
~ ..c:: E
'" OIl"",
" '"
~8o
o
u a 0
5 'C ::g
<fl0l
~ ~
u 0
'0 vi
~ ~
'0
." :.s
I- "8
'" ~
'" "
'0'0
't:; 'I:
o 0
Ei:t+::::
"
" "
0:: "
..c:: vi
g~~
'" cr,
0::.....
'"
'"
E
o
u
..... 0
-;: 0
~N --a
N l"d M ('f)
.~ ~ ~!;;
~ &~ """
~:2a~
~u~oc",
cMb\2"O
I-M.........ocC
..... 0 0 C':3
o-::c:~..:::
;>
"
E
o
u
~
~
~
"
'0
i:'2
'"
o
'"
'"
'8 ~ M
~ ~ '"
'" " ~
IJ.)'S: u
" '" ;>
~ u 2
.,g ;>-,u
~'D~
'" 0 '"
",0::.".
.".
'"
'-Ooc
'" 0
",0
~
~oO
d 5: ...c
o.~
E M ~
'" - ~
E- e]
~I-
..... "
o "
......... ~ ........d
rA1-1-8M::3
t=: 8 ~r-~~
r-Nuroo;"oc'-
c '" cocO,)
;;l"dI.C\O,.c
f;;tio~~G@J
x ;>, t Vl 8 ~ "'0
O~("j~"1"__1-o
~ ~ C '00 -- " t':l
2cs8~o:&:g
E
o
~ V') ~
Qt,o
~ '"
v';@I
.". ~
'" "
,-., '>
o '"
'"
e:o
u
u
~
~
'"
..c::
-'"
-;:;
'"
..c
"
o
u
U
..,
u
~ 0
o "
" '"
:::E .~
~o
o "
0.'"
~Q
..c
"
o s
u'"
> ;> '"
"'~'"
~ u
..,'"
.E E
o 'E
o(l "
" :::E
" .....
0'-0
Cl~
.".
'"
0\ 0\ \0
","''''
'-0"'''''
oc oc
><rii:
o
~ d \C
o~
OgN
p.:uC
"
"
2
"
N
"
"
-l",@I
~.".~
- '-0
.". ~
oo..g
'" '0
'" "
~S
5: ~
~'O
~
.;;
"
o
~
"'"
iJ
....
~
~
"
'0
i:'2
."
~
'"
~
t; 0,)
l"dlJ.)o..u
8 2 z 'g
~ a ~ ...J
~~U')~
'"
1:
'"
"i:o't:::
uN&
oc
'-0
'"
'"
-l
'""
...
~u..c::
'"0 0,) g
'" " "
:::lS~O
~ l"d ~
E E "!
;>, >-'\0
-l E .".
-q-Cl'i~
o ~'-O <U
~~Z~B
'"
oc
~
,,;$;
-lri
oc@l
os::
'1 g
g: a
oc 0
~:::E
~"i:
C:-u
..c
"
o
"
u
..,
u
~
o
"
:::E
00
'0""
0::'"
,,'"
~ri
c....... c
o ~.;;;
'" ~ is
~ >. U
'" ~
-<l3~
E
o
u
o
o
..c::
'"
"
"
..c::
u
'"
-;:
"
E
-
"
"
o
oc ~
~..c
'-0
'"
.,,;.
oc
'-0
8~
;~
.".
oc
~
0,) ~ E
< ~ 8
0,) u.. >-
E ?f.si ~
8 t:: u 4:
>t:l:j@
Eo-- Q) r"';., t::
~ <fl v, 0
, '" t::
-l 0 0 "
u..l.Oo.."l
~
~
"
'0
i:'2
'0
'"
"
CI
"
'" <=
...0 .....;
'" ~
o '"
, u
o E
'" 0
.g ~~u
'C U N M r- @J
o=a\O..J~r--
r."-oV'lL.L.r-O
- ~ ("') 0
"a C2 x (/'J trI ~
I- ,Ql"d-."'C
1:]-SM"O
.- 0....... I.C'C
8:::E~:;;:eE
~
~
U
'0
i:'2
'"
'"
'"
.....
v';
ci'i
..c::~
\O('f'")('l
oo..J~
'""",
~ ~
'8 rJ:J
~ '0
'" :;
..c "
"'0
b~
<fl ".".
.~ ~
OlQ~
E
o
u
o
o
..c::
'"
~
'" 0
'" 0
Cii
E E
8 0\ 0
>~:8~
E-N~~
~ >< -l @I
'" 0 "
'O0l-
'80 6 s
u:~.3..::2
u
"
- ~
:r. ro Ili
tl E >
~]<
0:: '" "
>. >. ,S:!
~ 2 ;3
E..c::>
~~
'-0
o
.".
~'"
"''-0
U.".
<fl,
d'[;:
.2'"
";:;0
;j.".
~e
~
~
"
'0
~
."
~
'" ~
'" <=
'0 0
'8 E
~ E
i:ii
'"
~ "
c ';;
" "
u;<:
N
.0
"'
ci
:>
x
'0
c
.
a.
a.
0:
OIl
<=
'w
'" .....
0:: ~
> '"
~~ri
-5 or.
::l cr.; ~
O..c:: u
><r::.~
"",..c::
'0 OIl
'c r- :..a
~~j
'u
"
"
o
U
OIl
<=
"
<= "
]<0
8~:
'"
~
.g~~
-sn -6
~ ~ c:j
&fj~
"
~
N
~.
~.
'1:
~
~
o
C
'" ~
6CJ 0
c7J~
1Jri
o
z "
",'0
.". ;j
0-;:
00
E
.E
~
-;:,
~
~
,
~
g
~
"
"
~
'-0'-0
88
"'",
~J,
"'",
00'-0
t::::'t::::'
00
."..".
~~
;
.
.
:;:;
8-
.E
@J
tt:
v-, .2
~ Vl
0- ~
':.5
r-
v-,
;;:- .E
('fj =
N "
~ ~
"
.~
.
~
~
~ ~
~ "
31 "0
~ C2
"
"0 -0
:E ~ ""d
~ 0 ~
~ (<j -g Vl
1 "0 o"D
~ 'I: a'i::
. 0 E!-o
~ ~ ~ ~
:g ,,,........
o ~ ~ lrl
~ ti ro 9
" u:;;-
~
c
U
E!
o
u
o
o
""
"
u
"
-
u
o
~
.;;:
>
""
..:
~-
~...,.
"00
:;; ><
" 0
qco
-gci
:;;0.;
.so
"
u'E
> 0
:I: '<
o~
0-0
" "
" 0
0,.::
U<+-
" ~
.- "
1:: ~
~ .-;::
:;; U
>>
"
~r-
_00-.."'"
'-' cs. 0\ ,.,
8.- ...,. ;;j:
~iil::;;;
. ~ ~ '.0
< C/'J...;-N
.~ 0\ ~ N
ro '0::1" :J r-
u~r/jt:-
"
.so
"
00 E!
g:::lf1~
.Jf2@
~o-o
~ 00 C
-00-0
8 \0 E
~ {i'j E
..::.:: \0 ro
je:a
E
o
U
o
o
""
"
...,.
'.0
r-OO
N'"
",0-
'"
~..j.
o
doo
u~-o
U'.O-O
~ 00 ::3
o c:;;
~
U
U
"
U
.2 c
~ .S
Z :;;
ro 'u
-; 5;
U ~
0":
E!
o
U
~
~ r- E!
OIl 0: ~ c 0
.. ro N:3: ~
~.~ ('fj 0 "0
C2 g~~\O ro
-:;; ..so;;1; @
.!:: ro Q) 0 V") VJ
0: ....... OOCQ I
ro 1; 8 ;J
S C/'J 0 ~
- - -
>>........ t:: c:
I:l:I MOO
O'.Oo..U
.so
"
U
~
~
"
-0-0
C2 g
>~
"" "
..: ~
" :;:
;::u
0...,.
~~
""6
1::'.0
0",
Zo-
r-
v-,
N
N
'" E!
~ r- 8
r.r.. <0 d
~M 00
- , E!
'S: ~ @)
g"':t ;>
.a~~
"0- "
..., ~ ~
-
'.0
'.0
o
" M
~\O~I"O
0.. \0 'o::t" V)
SO('f)('f)
o~,......:tA
"" ~o-
E-- ~ ~ 00
cCQ..:s N
k5 0 ~ V)
""o..oc
o
'.0-0
r- "
~"
'.0 0
00 ~
",.0
~-'"
>>
u ("j
o "
~ ~oM
..: .- '"
rr.:I:<:""J
~J2:M
"'O:=..J
C2-6~
" ~ -_oS
-0<8
'J:: ~ 'S:
o ,,-0
- ~ ~
~ U.O
..c:o~
'Ei""'" (OJ
z~u
U
U
:E
"
>
-0
"
o
~
It:
o :5
1:: .-
o :;;
E'u
_ 0
~ ~
o ~
z..:
~
~ t-<
" >>
-0 .2
C2~,;
~"'>
i:S8~
'0.:::1 ~
0= >-.
-'3~:;;
'" v-,
"O~........
B~~
@J
00 "
~2
,
~ E
0- "
86
v-, "
e-o
r-
oo
N
...,.
'"
Ii:
1::
o
0..
..c:
1::
o
Z'"
0-
o
o
M
N
...,.
,,"5
~2
~ "
coz
o~
u_
"'...,.
E!
o
'<
...,. '0
N "
~~@)
~ 8 S
~ ('fj E
"N
-00\:-:::
~ ~"
" -'"
~~~
"'~~
E!
o
U
o
o
..c:
"
'"
E! 1J
o "
U.J
. 0
~ -
"'gt>
" E
0'';
~o..
g "
,; "
-0'"
a~
UN
'" N
E!
o
v-, U
~ 0
N N 0
('fjV)-a
.J6?
~....,. @J
00\'.0
-0'.0"
8 r::- ~
"Coo
o~b
.so
" -
[) g
" ,:,;.
s .S
VJ :s
"[ ~ ~
"'gi~o@J
O..c:::aJ"i"_M
c ("j ~ M 0
5~""d~~::l
~~c9cn~..c
] C N d) --- E
"0 .g ~ ~ ~ ro
uco",z~~
~
...,.
0-
~
"
"
Vl ~..d
M M"5
~ M 0
C2 ('f'J ~
'eu....;tirrl]
'0- '" U . o@J
!:i ;;.-..~ N 0
>>~t:::;,::J,-
.-;: ~ ro >- \0
U>>;:EB"1"Vl
~-g\O~;;;-]
;;:. :::I <0 U 0 ::l
C2:;;~..;;e:.E!
~
""
U
"
"
co
-0
o
"
E!~
"N
~><
~ 0
. co
co .
cio
~o.;
'.0
v-, "
0- "
~ 'i
..J be 0
~o-~
d~ Q)
~ r- g
8~~
8 N Vl
:.ar-~
..st::-
u
"
~ J:l
0Jl",
,,-
"-
0-
'E~
0Jl'"
0Jl
"
.J_
'" -
E!
'.0 0
00 U
;:;;~2
('f"l~~
..J It)
r..L. ~ c
.....~ crI .@
~ G::
._ 00
:ECI-.
~
t5 tZi
-0
C2 ,g
t:: .> ~ <-'
.... c ....... ~
o ~~~ 0'"
C"j 0 ('<j ,-
~"5~~:g~
~~~ ~~.g
-0 >-. Z .~ '7 @
~"'8 7 ~~.:a
I-. C"j trI U I.C C
~~N~~e
U
o
~
.;;:
~
.~
~
"
'"
~
-0
" .
"-0
O'~
" ~
';;i"g
"5 0
" "
" :;;
~ti:
"'"
"
"'r-
.so
"
U
>
""
..:
o
.8 ~ ti:
:;;0
..J u d.i
>-. c g
o e ;::::;
co U E!
.~
--g ;:: ~~
CO'.O""
t>
"
,:,;.
00 .8
7 :s
r- ~
;A~2
.J...,.@J
~"iv-,
oiJl.C ~
1-."" CIJ
"v-, "
.so~"
~ N OJ
(\) trI 7;';
jc.s
0-
v-, >
~ a ';;i
('<j'7I.CO
:g trI .8
9o:'E
r-.".
...,.
N...,.O
~~.so
r-r--o
00"
:::!-:::!-.o
~
~
"
-0
C2-'"
.:::1
-g "
" 0
O'-;'j
" "
~ 0
..:~
" "
-0"'8
~ "
:;: E
ci5..:
t>
-at"') .5
~~O"I~
E ~ ~ E
~ti~8
~ 0"1 @
CI':lB~~
c:; .2 '7 r-
oo ~ 0"1 .u
lrI>__C"j
E
o
U
o
o
""
"
@J
.so
"
U
N
D
'"
ci
;>
x
'6
c
~
0.
0.
<(
u
o
~
~
..:
>
""
..:
N
o
0-
N
'"
~
:c
.2~ ~
~ N ci
E >< E
" 0 "
.s~]
=O~
,;so.;:;;
"
U
"
ll:
..c:
0\
r-
"
:B~
,gz
c."'"
00
~N
~~
~
~
M
~.
-i-:
~.
~
~
"
-0
C2
~
~
o
:!.
E
.8 ~
~ ~
,
C"j ~I
~ ,.<::.
~ 0
o --~
['
:;
"
""
"
o
'"
o
~
c
c
~
,
,
,
"
&
"
E
0
u ~
;> u
;;; u
~ "'"
~ " 7
.t: '" -
>- 7
.E , '" E
'0 '0 '"
"'" '" '" 0
'" E 0 0 ~ "
~ N U 0: 0: "0
u 7 .t: , ci '"
" :; :::: .t:
>.tA 0 :; 0 @
"'N 0 0 Oh",
~
:c: t'-@ ~ VJ ~ -
~ ~~ 0.:
." N "I: 0 U ~
~
.t: ",.t: ~ 00 ~ U
U ~ u on ~
'i)
"
'" 0
7 ~
'" "
N'i)
'" "
~@
.7
~ -
OIlN
" -
."
0. ._
VJo::!
.t: .t:
0Jl~
._ 0
:c: 8
.n
"
o
>
E-
<C
'"
'0
."
o
1i:
E
8
o
00 0
t'-.t:
::t '"
'"
00
N
'"
'"
~ri:
e~
~o
e~
d
-;;
u
ot::
"
.s ~
'El 0..\0
.u 0 trl
COM
~...Jr<""l
<C ~ ~
VJ VJ
~ "
U.t:
> 0
3~
t::C~
ONi5:
"
~ ~
~ ~
~ U
g '0
~ r.;::
."
" ~ .;; t'-
~ U 00 '"
v E- N ~ '"
" 7 E E- '"
:E U",
0 ~'" 0 '" ~
> " '0
~ 0 ,..l", ." '"
" g ~
~e 0: to-t'- 0 " 00
~on
"C U .7 1i: " UO ~oo
.n "N @ 3
E o ' ;;; U 0,
~ 00 7 "3 '0 <C
~ .; b '" 00 '" U " '"
. to- o: 7 N " 0 N .t: '"
~ ::;;;
" 0 ~ " .t: 0Il~
0 " '" '" <E :; :; :E
~ "'" '" U '" " 7
~ - 0 0 0 N U ~
" - ~ ~ E VJ ~ on ,..l
~
0
"
"
o
~
~
"
"'0
0"
(j<C
..:
ci
;;;
~
0
;;; N
" ~
~ .c
"'
0 0
0 :>
u x
> '6
c
:c: 15.
0 c.
U '"
-5
~
;:
0
U
"
~
'"
"
-a
en
.::
;;;
'0
0.
"
~
'0
U
"
"
c
.2
;;;
E
~
~
c
.n
"
U
~
"
0
>>
~
0
"
~
U
.t:
'0
1l
~
~
0
E c
0 ~
~ .n
.;; " ~
0 U
E u
U .S;:
0 u ~
'" .t: :E U
'" @ VJ
7 '" " ~
00 0 > U
0, N >> E
on N '" "
t'- 7 " ~
~] "
.t: 0
OIl
_.n ::E U
00 " '0
~.n
.' "
- '" -
(5 ~ E
'" 0
'0 " u
." "3 '""
0
0 .~ "'9
1i: 51,1;::
~ <C ?i
"
0 ~ "
>> 0
~ ;: "
- ~
~ "
E '"
cO t::
'0 '" .t:
0. 0. >>
::> ~ U ;;,
C ~ Cl ~
~ U
.2 '" ~
;;; 0 '0 0
to- ." to-
E ~ 0 ~
~ 0 1i: 0
0 " "
~
.5 0 t'- 0
";;j 8 .;;;
.n
" .S;: N >
0 0 Q! 0
E
:E
.
~
-::'
~
o
"
6
>
~
o
"
:g
o
~
,
,
~
!
~
~
~
"
~
~
o
~
'"
c.
o
'"
'"
.>:
~
o
;::
"'111)1.
Q) 0:
~I' ~.
~ CIl:
"1 =>,
811):
en 2:
0' c;
- I 0'
(/l u;
o Ui
J: u'
'" >1
~ II
00'
;;: zl
.~ ~II
-.0
~ <(
.;;;
"
c
"
:;
o
0::
~ "
VJ~
=> ::l
~" ~
CO l-
e.. -
CO
:0 (tl
" ~
:!::e
..J
U
U
>
J:
o
Z
'0
"
"
d-
O
o
.0
"
~
~
III
~
Q)
Z
..:
2
-
.~
f-<
"
o
U
u
:>
:r:
o
ZE
~ ~
.2 .....
o"t1
"" "
~O
" oj
" u
" "
u 0-
"CIl
o >>
><::;;
'"
;:
Q)
Z
'"
.!! '"
Q.l 15 co
~ 0 -g
a E C li=
3:: ro"OO
C 0 U ell
Q) C co ctl
EIJ)..c13
~"'C_Q)
_0 ~ ~..Q
".8
lE gf Q) r.J)
"'"
CD <3 co c
.s [)~E
.S '- C (j
o 0 co
c"O Q) E
~~.sQ)
"a rn 15 :5
~ ~ .~ *
o.cu~
fO~~o
en >'0<(
~-g~~
..E E - ()
Q) ctl i Q)
o~~~
~ ~ ~ ~
ctl..cI.!S!
~ u '"
u:.c ~:.c
(I) s: co +-'
f3~ ~~
Q) u) N 0
~~.E15
o
;;
c
o
"
o
~
"
:;;
o
0::
o
()
'" '"
~:5
:c '"
.0l0::
.8
"0
'" '"
2 Q) C
:::2 C t
::l '"
=>~t5
t: O)-S
'" " 0
(j):.c-g
.o~~
::l '" 0
utfj~
'"
.~
"0
.CO
>
",I
",0
.S ::i
~U5
2 ID
"'0 8 .0
C :::::l .2
N
n
"'
o
>
x
."
c
<::
o
-
III
"
:>
"
w
..
~
~
Q)
10
:;
oil
..
'0
(l.
2
"
III
-
<::
o
U
Q)
10
-
III
-
III
Q)
-
III
...J
~.~ ~
~~5
t:: Q) ::>.
~ C ~
.s ni
Q)Q)U)
..c ro "5>
.8(;)~
'" '" ~
D-o.!S!
~ ~ Q)
:)IJ)':;
2.!a ~
.~ "g .8
~8~
'" ~"
~_"O
'" '" "
E -5 ~
..c .E c
~ Q) ~
~ ~ ctl
ro~.e
";:: 0
.$ 0 g.....;
ro::2::.;:: I:
E Q) lI) 0)
(/) ..c ro E
:::::I I- ..lo:: _
o . Q) ..s
"E C/) Q) rJl
'" => ~
N Q) .!Q 'a:;
~:5:5:S
n
~
-i.
'"
"
:5 ~
~ ~I
"S"E
o "
-g.s
1;1.8
'" "E
I- '"
to
iD 0
'" c.
2.s
" ~
,9 Q)
10 >
N .S:
'c "5
gJ,c.
o ':
~ ::l
"w 0
05>-
" :>.
"'" "
E ~
<( '"
~ ~
<(0:;
~o.
- E
c. 0
a; U
I.8
E
o
:I:
I
u
u
>
:I:
o
Z
-
-
<::
E
~
:>
U
iD
'" "
""'"
- '"
~ E
"."
zc't5
" '" "
() '" ::l
()~C"
> ~ ~
I.::.:: 5
0.2 Q
z u ......
. . :;; <D
. . .(ii .8 vi . 1;; "- 5
.~ i:L . "' c . <D 0::
<D . ,:: ~ "' 0 f- "' <D "
~ ro 0 . 05 w . <D <D ~ . " 05 " 05 <D
.8 0 . " ~
> " w "- . .8 <D " > <D . CI) <D " " 0 "
" cr . 2 .~ c :E "- I e .~ . c .(ii .~ .~ "' e
I "' E .~ "' '" I . 05 0 0. " ~ N
0 E <D " '0 -"''' 2 <D . <D " 1;; 0 .0 . (9 i:i 0:: a. . 0 a; <D > .Q a.
.", c c . 0 c > a. . CI) " " D
i= ro '" "' - .~ "' .in C - .!)l . ro .8 > c '" .E :E i'- "'
.8 <D '" <D C >--" . <D 0 0 0 . <( ." '"
~ 0> " <D "' .!!! . Qi i!! "' <D E c . c !!!. I ~ :;; . N 0
C c <D " '" E c . 0 '" 0> "' '
"' c :c ci <D .2 ~ 0 '"
<D 0 '" E .(ii . ." <( 0 U .c . c ro .8 o>!!!. >
1;; ~ '" ~ .8 0. " . .~ c
ii) .~ ~ c c c > . (9 in c 0 c ~ rn . 2 CI) 0> (5 . 0 " ~ c <D LU x
c ." <D '" . <D .c Qi <D o.L!.. .in . ~ c B"8 '6
Qi i!! <D C e .(ii .>< > c '" :;; t3 . " '" <( c
'" -" > ~ . " > .c 1;; '" '" CI) <D c . <D E
c " " > .(ii s 1;; I 0 . ro I ." '" <D c 0. i!! . c :;; E ::> 0 :;; .c ID
'" " <D e <D c " "- 0. C.
0:: .c E z c.
"
-0
.E
" "'
il .!!! 0 E
>. - +:l ca
;:; "iU CI) ca ...
~;U:2tsg'
o ~~ 5,E-c.
:; ... '5 CI) 0 I:
NlIltn.cO".!!
'Eiil~~'-'iQ)
ca CD ~ _ III (.)
~;r:::~ca:J"'C
occa=.c'O._
>..- G> U CLI ::J,
go! g-g.;::;C)
(.) U -:;;: ;:; III _~
o"'o>w>.
> ._ G) rtI "C.!!!
'C..o'C'~~c:._
~~S~o~E
~n:st:o"'-ol-
- ~o-...
G) > :t: CI) .! :e ...
-::z:: G) "C ; m ::::J
J!l: 0 CD '5> 11)0
If) ~ > C) ca c:
"C C .- ._
c.~~ct.=~
rn coJ:Jo "Ctns::
- 'ii 1Il.o.!!! C1l ca._
"m c CLl co'n; III E ...
10. o::::l=...:J ~ns
1-._0"0....(1)11)_
';G G) U .....0 ~_
:s cg'cooo::s(/)
O 'O:w"'2 -.c:
....c_tn,ogui
Q) -. G) Q) I: Q) ... Q)
l.. :J III 0.. 'i: "0..0 c..
ra 2EE~; ~
..c:: C)Q.or.n-'E
f/'Jc(f!u:.=_m
<u
..<::
-
Of)'"
c: <u
:.au
... >-,
oj U
Of) "'0
<u _
... 0
:5::2
'.;j ""C)
oj c:
a oj
... '"
<8>
c: E-<
.~ ~
"0..<::
~ -
"
'" 0
~ >-,
<u c:
c: 0
-
'"
<u
-
oj
-
<u
-5
"0
c:
tE
~
.n
U
VJ
0..
U
o
OJ
>
'Ol
C
III
'tl
c:
co
oJ
Ol
-
co
>
.;:
D..
c,;
c:
'E
o
~
o
z
<u
"0
oj
a
-
oj
..<:: <u
~:o
1-1 ';;)
o '"
'" 0
:5 0..
o.,<u
'" u
c:
1::
~
c:
o
U
.I:II:~
..IIII~
...III~
II ~
;~I:I~i
~
...
Co
"r-.
.a.z::
"lil
:l;l],=
"
=
o
"
I
u
u
>
"
o
z
<u
-5
-'<
c:
oj
..<::
-
-
o oj
- "
<u c:
3~
"O~
-0
"0
~N
...
U "
U 0
>
::c
o
z
8
"
"
~
G
~
o
'"
'"
o
u
~
~
g
.
.
~
~
"
~
_ t:: ~
552 ~g
EO .t:::;::
t t 90
8.0 :::E:':::
a._en
f!~ Q) en 0-
ot:: ...1::
-., 0e ~~
:::) 0 ~<I(
....
~;;: z
21! 2
!cCJw!c
w-d-
e5~i:~
~~~~
II
~
o
"
I
u
u
>
"
o
z
.
~
as
:I
Ii
SIll!:
-2:!
=:1
;I-I
--=-"1-
~
~
~""'A-
~~---
~~
II
,
,
,
-- ~
"
N
.0
'"
ci
>
,x
D
C
.
"
:t
.
C~ ~
~ ~~
~:
~.
:E
~
N
~
o
~,
N
B-
"
'tl
..
U
l:
:> l:
g 0
c: +:i
<( ~
E -6
E ..
Cl 'tl
o l:
D: ..
Q. l:
o
~ :u
~ E
'0 .!!
.s:: l:
u
en
.s::
-
:>
o
>-
(J
(J
>
J:
o
Z
...
o
l:
..
Q.
'tl
'0
";'
o
~
-
<(
"">
"I
!;'O
-E .~
.~ Q;
OJ"
C i;
:..;;2 <.>
" '"
$: .f:
E "0
'" "
o,U)
o "
c.m
:: .~
~ ~
'" '"
"C 0 5
~~~
'" C <..>
1ii Q) :J
>-E~
~ ~ .~
~-g:5
'" Q;
'13 c .c
C " "
::::IE..2
o OJ 0
o C ~
55~
~ >.: 5
C: 6 '5
~ ;0::; a.
g:gg-
o '" ~
Q) .f: ~
:'Q w ctI
.c 0.
Q.l 0 CLl
> (,) ~
",c.c
~.Q C
.c - "
,2> ~ E
I" "
"' '" OJ
o 6 ~
<..> '" ^
~"'C E C
o ~ 6 15
~ ~ ~ E
Q) .~ ~ "-g
~ ~ ~ ~
Ol
!?
~
.E
'"
-
l:
..
>
w
iii
l:
o
:;:::
..
z
C>
N
l:
..
0:
'tl
..
'tl
l:
:>
o
3:
..
.s::
-
~
.E
~
..
Qi
..
.s::
3:
l:
:>
...
..
.s::
-
.s::
-
'i
Q.
Qi
.s::
l:
..
U
:>
o
>>
~
o
.s::
-
:>
o
'tl
l:
Ii:
'"'
0"0
'02 Q)
'c E
-g ::l !lJ
" " -
~:5x
"
~ 05 1i5
ctI ~ 0
O)=E~
c '" "
:O~:ECD
";;: Q) Q) a;
o .0 ~
a. E ~
o"E~:2
i:! .c
5 ~..... Q)
"00 2 ~ >
U)=.c~
'E'E~i5
~"'O ctI a.
m ~ c rs
E c OJ "0
";:: :::l E ro
c... 0 2 0
Q) s: '0 ';
:5y) ~:a
:5 5""0 1ii
.~ 3 ~ ~
c 0 C Q)
QU..2:5
16:::J......_
N 0 Q.) 0
.~.92:>,
~cii~Q)
o C Q) .~
c :.c "0 >
co f/.l..c ro
.~ ~ g .~
~ ~ E ~
LL ~~~
~ E E '"
"0 ~~~
~.s ~ ~
:J-g~c
~ ro~ e 6
Q) C)a.U
-E .~ .- 05
..... 0.. 3: Q)
o E (/) 0,
~ ~ E :s
Q; 0; ~ 0
a; c "" c
Q) :0 2 '$0
..c ro ro -
S:EU5.s
N
.0
"'
o
->
x
'6
c
m
0.
0.
'"
"
c
"
I
u
u
>
"
'"
z
:>:
"-
N
~
"
~.
N
~
8
r::
'"
~.
:;;
c
:!.
'"
o
8
>
~
o
o
.
.
~
B-
E
ili
::>
l:
l:
<(
i'
0..
o
<(
2:-
~
Ol
'"
..
l:
..
::E
E
..
~
'"
e
0..
>
I
o
...
o
l:
o
:;::;
..
'u
o
rJ)
rJ)
<(
ili
l:
o
:;::;
..
Z
'0
l:
..
o
o
>
I
o
Z
'"
o
o
"I
rJ)
Ol
U
l:
e
.!
l:
o
o
e
I.f) Q)"CO
Q) ~ g>
E' 0> Q)
C .!: Ol
'" -0 '"
::< -0 "-
'" Q)
E e "
'" 0 e
.... Ol ~
~ .~ .@
~ -'" e
0.. ~ 0
> f2 u
I > Q)
o ~~
O~U
c ~ Q)
2GO
co (I) a:i
"g u :c
CIl () ~
~ > "m
I >
n; 0 ro
,2 Z ~
1O]go
Z f- '"
ro
Q) cr:i >.
:SNro
""O..j. E
eN
ro ..c ~
U " 0
u Co'ii)
>::<'"
I c ~
00-0
Z '" Q)
Q) ~ ~
:Sm+-'
~ f- 0
.E C ~
la.8":;;'t3
o !!2 Q) Q.l
c 0 .c 'e
~ I I-- a.
0) 2.51
C .!: "(fj :S
8 ~ ~ :5
ro..c~(/)
~~.82
c ~ c ro
ro oR
~~E:
o 0. c 0
NOQ>-
Q) <( (I) ID
..cz2?-
1-_a..!Q
^
^
Q)
'"
-"
Q)
;:
'"
Q)
"
e
~
.l!?
e
o
U
0>
P
Q)
E
~
.E
~
Q)
-"
-'"
.~
(3
ui
0::
<
;;:
<
-'
W
e
0::
o
...
e
W
e
W
W
z
'"
w>-
>~
-u
f-:J
;5f-
ZZ
wW
"'~
We
O::z
3:;<
0::'"
w<
f-'"
<z
li;~
uu;
u-
>0
Iii!:
0-'
z=
"
o
-0
e
~ u:::
ro Q)
~ OJ
"51ii
-" ~
oS 0
> ,.,
U .!:
~ g'
Q) i5
Q) "C
5 Q)
E:c
Q.) '00
E e
o 0
" "-
Q) '"
-" ~
2 Q.;
"'-"
:~ t::
t5.2
'"
>
I
o
-0
e
~ a:i
Q) .~
Qj ~ ro
..c =' C
'0 t Q)
'" 0 '"
a.a.~
- "-
jg 0 CD
,.,> 0::
- I Q)
:5 0 ro
a ~ U5
e '" U
e Q) U
.Q U >
en .!: I
.~ 0 0
e ~ Z
'" -
OJ '" e
~ ~ i
o :s .8
'0 ~ 00
t '" e
'" e '"
"- Q) Q)
'" -" E
0> 0, .-
.f: ~ ro
" ~ -"
co 1ii $:
~
:::l
o
>-
Z
->
UlI
0..0
O~
IO
~u..
~Z
OW
3:0..
",0
0>-
O.J
"II-
~Z
OW
u..~
3:~
00
Zw
Ul~
W<(
<Ul
O~
W<(
>0
~ -.
W<(
UlW
W~
~<(
W
I-
:::l
o
~
Ul
u..
Ul
:::l
o
Z
<(
t-='
Z
W
::E
W
(,')
<(
Z
<(
::E
>
I
o
Z
o
~
o
o
Ul
Ul
<(
N
.c
'"
ci
>
x
'6
c
.
a.
a.
"
00 g'
-ij) ~ 'E
o 0
:S 0 u
OJ '" Q)
.~ ro ~
~ ~.g
l5.. c (I)
.~ E ~
Q) 0
:s g-
13 0..
.s ,.,
e e
o '"
U '"
,,; '"
0::>
o "
N .~
~ -0
~ ~~o
~ q
e "
~ ~
"'-"
" 0
- e
ij@
> -0
Q) '"
-0 Q)
e-"
core
g..;.
~ 0
-",,,"
~~
U
U
>
I
o
Z
Q)
-"
f-
Ul
0..
o
I
Ul
~
~
o
3:
Z
o
i=
<(
Z
(,')
ii.i
W
o
~
o
:t
I
u
u
>
:t
o
Z
B-
-c
/
-<
'"
>-
-<
'"
>-
"'
0
.c
"' ,;
.l< .E
~
~ 'iif'
"au
- 8(lj.c~
"
..
C E 0 "l l
..
0 .c :8 J.o" -0;:
'" "'
.- " .l< ~:E.cS
tii - ~
III '" ~ $t .~
Q) .9- ::E
,., 8"" '
" " u.' ~
U 0 ,2 -'"
:;:; Q) ~:_'I;f ~
:e '" n;
fIl " " ~(l)q; *-.
~
III c.. " '(ii ~-,;g",
c.. 0 ~ " :l ~fl~
- <( ..c > c
C lD fIl " S >- .c';v~
Ql >- ~ 0 " " .~ > x -
> " ... " 0 :; J: <: u;.'-,tU
:; ~ 0:: . '_ '. in
W " " ~ i'-
" '" > "
~ " " .c . 'i;;~..
() 0 0 " 1ij"";'g ".
" "' c::>"o-..
() "' () :;:; ~..!~.
- '" Q) 0. .
> () 'u " 0 N" ,- -/;, ,
" .~ Z "!t', - "
1: > 0 .c
:I: "' "' f'.;. , -.tI)
w "' Q) .l< g ~-tf:(
0 :I: <( <II l;
z !!l 0 " - 3: ~ It
"'
- Q)
z '" l; '"
-
<II u- P
, ~
0'
\. ~
~
0 N
'"
I 8
u N
U "
> ~.
'" CD
Z 0
os
&
"'
Americans For Responsible Recreational Access
About ARRA
News
.. Regional Access
Issues
. PlJlllic: Meetings
Federal Legislative
Update
Federal Regulatory
Update
'LJSFSOHVRolJte
Designation Center
:<] 1.1] e A.RR.A,r
Tell-A.Friend
If you have already registered,
you can help be a stronger
voice by sending e-postcards to
others. Our grassroots
movement needs more voices!
Use our Tell-A-Friend page to
help someone else stay
informed by registering to
receive ARRA's legislative alerts
and newsletters.
Education
Opportunity
A TV Ridercourse
ARRA encourages all A TV
riders to take an approved A TV
training course. Registration is
now available online! Visit the
A TV Safety Institute
HomeDaae for more information.
Action Needed!
. ~ House Bill to Overturn Ban on
Youth ATVs and Dirt Bikes Introduced!
. ~ Senate Bill to Overturn Ban on
Youth ATVs and Dirt Bikes Introduced!
. LeQislation that Would Close Public Lands
to Manv Forms of Recreation
Reintroduced
.Sign up with Americans For
Responsible Recreational Access
.Tell-A-Friend"1iiiff
Let your friends know about Americans For
Responsible Recreational Access
ARRA's Voice on Capitol Hill
.Current Members:
Email
I
Password
I I
o Remember me? I Log in I
lneedfforaot oassword?)
PROTECT ACCESS TO YOUTH A TVS
& DIRTBIKES - SEND LETTER TO
CONGRESS NOW
WARNING: Youth ATVs and dirtbikes can no longer be sold! A Consumer Product
Safety Commission-related crisis regarding the huge consumer product law passed last
August has had the unintended consequence of banning the sale of A TVs and dirtbikes
for use by young people. You must send a letter to Congress immediately! TAKE
ACTION NOW!
Washington Newsletter - May 2009
A new guide Sharing Our Trails is now available; recommendations announced to
improve RTP; and more details about how you can help oppose HR. gaD, the ill-
concieved Northern Rockies Ecosystem Protection Act. All this and more in the May
newsletter.
Posted: May 1, 2009
Participate Today in the OHV Route Designation Process
The U.S. Forest Service is in the process of implementing its Travel Management Rule.
The rule requires all forests to designate and map OHV routes and when completed, no
OHV use will be allowed except on these designated routes. Now that individual
Forests are in the process of implementing the rule, it is extremely important that OHV
riders participate in this process. ARRA will continue to provide you with as much
advance information about the designation process as possible.
Appendix V.D.5b.12
http://www.arra-access_com/arra/home.html(1 of 3)5/8/2009 2:26:56 PM
Americans For Responsible Recreational Access
(
\
The
ARRA Toolbox
II>
II>
..
II>
Get RTP Grant Applications and Infonnation
Contact the U S Forest Service
Leam How to Contact Federal Agencies
Send U s Your Ideas and Suggestions
Current Advocacy Campaigns from Americans For Responsible
Recreational Access
r;:;l
~
House Bill to Overturn Ban on
Youth ATVs and Dirt Bikes
Introduced!
March 26, 2009
... nlOC11'"
r;:;l
~
Senate Bill to Overturn Ban on
Youth A TVs and Dirt Bikes
Introduced!
March 25, 2009
Previous Advocacy Campaigns from Americans For Responsible
Recreational Access
c
leQislation that Would Close Public
lands to Manv Forms of Recreation
Reintroduced
April 22, 2009
Omnibus Public land leQislation is
Back!
March 17, 2009
MIC and SVIA Requests for Exclusion
reo ATVs and Dirtbikes
February 12, 2009
UrQe Your Representative to Vote
AQainst S. 22 Omnibus leQislation!
February 09, 2009
UrQe Your Senator to Vote No on
Restrictive land Use Bill! AQain!
January 07, 2009
UrQe Your Members to Support RTP
FundinQ in Stimulus PackaQe
January 05, 2009
UrQe Your Senators to Vote No on
Restrictive land Use Bill
October 01, 2008
Support a "Rainv Dav" Fund for
Wildfire Suppression
September 03, 2008
I Recent Messages from Americans For Responsible Recreational Access I
leQislation that Would Close Millions
of Acres of Public lands to Manv
Forms of Recreation Reintroduced
April 22, 2009
Omnibus Public land leQislation is
Back in the House!
March 20, 2009
House Fails to Pass S. 22 Omnibus
Public land leQislation!
March 13, 2009
c
. [Ulliil)
Support OHV Recreation!
February 27, 2009
Protect Access to Youth ATVs and
Dirtbikes - Send leUer to ConQress
Now
February 17, 2009
Urae Your Reoresentative to Vote
AQainst S. 22 Omnibus leQislation!
February 09, 2009
Appendix V.D.5b.12
hllp:l/www,arra-acccss.comfarra/home.hlm\ (2 of 3)518/2009 2:26:56 PM
Americans For Responsible Recreational Access
Americans for Responsible Recreation Access
115215th Street, N.W., Suite 800, Washington, D. C. 20005
webmaster@mail.arra-access.com
Privacy I Contact Us I About ARRA
http://www.arra-access.com/arralhome.html (3 of 3)51812009 2:26:56 PM
~
.ci
"'
c:i
:>
x
is
z
LU
<L
<L
"
c
0
;:
l'lI
'u
0
III
III
<C
'j!
I-
l'lI
"C
l 'i:
0
" u::
,
" Gl
~ .c:
..
- 1::
! 0
z Do
~ Do >
"
c ::I =
, en -
" c'i
" >
~
,
Z
-
-
, ~
.:@ .~
0
~ "
, ~
,
, ,
,
,
~
"
1
E
=
=
!
4
'"
","0
>. "C
'" 0
;:-
.s:;"-
.Q'loo
.s:; 0
o E
"co "6
E .,
io >
W :g
e: "'
"0 .~
e: 0
"'l!
Ole:
[5 '"
"ffi .~
",f;
~"~ ui
., "' e:
::5; "- .Q
~ ~ ~
-:; co ~
~:g~
o
~u:
o .,
Of;
;:
., '"
-:;:g
"~ 0
-",iI
~
'"
.,
-'"
'"
0-
.8
co I C CD
....g>.2Q.l115
.E..Q1U..r::.~
"m ro 'u ..... m
I-'=.$~~o
'" "' 0
~ ~ <( ;: ro
:c (.) 0 Q.l
(.) 0 .~ _ c
~;""'?A-m
8:'iij:2""OO
<{ ~ ... ~ u..
W C'J.2 U) "ffi
-:;.~u..~g
"CE~:o~
~B-"CZ
"' Ol 0
'>CO"~U:~
-:;-g"C(.)
g"~ :J ~ 0
"CcoC2"~Q)
'~:g-ofi:5
.Q ro ~ .~
"E u.. >. ,_ "0
ro.si3a..$
~ ..::.::: Cl3 :J "~
co (.) ..c '0 co
co c: Q.l Q.
~~~~~
~~~~~t6
~~:~~~~
00..- - l!2"--
co C C'J co t.i= CD
en-coCl)..c
~Ole:;gC'J=-O
>-:S2..r::.ro.~t)
~(.)Q)of;.....O
Q) co f.) Q.l co "~
Q) Q. c: :J "'C
of; TI J!! l!2 .C ~
co"!:!2 :J..Q ro
.f: ..c -0 c.. u.. --'
1;5
'e:
o
.8
~
o
'm
E
"0
e:
"5 '"
~~
Ol.,
0"0
e 'iij
:5 ~
-
.-
ctI
l-
I-
eI>
s::.
I-
,
~
"
~
"
,
"
z
~
~
~
]
o
C
~
"
,
"
,
,
,
"
t3
.;::
1;5
is
<:
.,
E
.,
Ol
'"
e:
'"
::;
~ e:
(I] 0 c 0 "'C Q.l
.9 Q) 0 "'C Q.l (1)
Cti "iij "C 0 1:5 ..c
~U5c:o~.$-a5
o Q) ro u .... e >.
o,-:;~~~c.o
CI) CI) Q) ~ co c
~ ~ ai .... en .~ ~
"'"- t5 u (1) :5 co
_ CJ2S'::;..r::.
.~ ro ~ "~ :.c ;> OJ
-;~~CI)~~3:
~ 'E .m is"ffi OJ
:c 0 E 2 :; .CD ~
,,,0 -115>;:
u~_~.~c~en
" ~ _0 8 CI) I~ "'C
".. C "(I] ..... co
U5 co C'J ro "'C ..r::. 0
~:5"ffi~'~~~
~~~~~g~
E ro 1ii 0 LL C'J
J!2 "'C (1)"c CI) C
"~~~.9B~~
~ ,~ CD "; l!2 0 ~
COW~&~p:~
"6~=......r::.o:C
E"ffi co 0 en en ~
co c E .E!:! J!2 c: ~
~~.g 6~e:'oE ~o.g
-0 "~ CI)
,"z~:.gQ.lo>."E
c-oCLlE..r::.O.~8
"6l.$'E0115"--wQ)
"C Cl3 :J o...s- C 13 of;
o c: "'5"'C 0 co W _
CI) ,Q'l > c: .e -:; c u
.E~:5ro:;~5.$
,,~~.3:COOf.)e
.._= ci:fl13 E 0- Cl.
~~~.$:c~:g;
"'8 "'C 0 0 3: ~ 0 ::c
.....~u:c...~>.uro
~
rn
~ .~
:0
'" 0
'" c.
0-
Ol~
"' t
~ R
OlE
e: .-
:S2 en
ro ~
E .,
,~ W
",0.
o E
.~ 0
o "
.; .8
~ ~
.!Q",
c..,
6 :;
"0 0
Q) .~
;: "'
"' 0
'" e:
~ :9-.
0"0
"0 e:
"5 '"
o
"' Q;
'", .,
"0<:
"~ :J
u:g
~ '"
.Q .,
o E
o 0
>- :;l
""CO
as
"
5
o
"'
II!
l/)
...
CJ
ctI
LL
...
l/)
ctI
LL
-"---_................_-_.._~~-
Q;
.0
E
.,
::;
'"
.,
E
o
"
.,
fie.
z
o
;::
<I:
(3
o
rJl
rJl
<I:
..J
~~
o-~
<1:",
C "
51'"
o 5
..J 0
"- "-
'"
N
0'"
Om
lfiffi
Ui U5
~
Q,) Ui
.0 "
E 0
" '"
E c.
-:2
o "'
~ ~
" "
.0.0
E E
o "
z :::E ~~,
.,
5
.s:;
"
o
in
c.
:<=
"'
Q;
.0
E
"
::;
cri
N
~
.,
.0
o
t3
o
'j;
"0 ~
,,0-
...J :E u
<1 .. '"
~ c. "
0- " "
<I: N rJl
C ItI n;
[i::Dc
_ 0
O..J ~ ~
u..ii:z
~
.c
on
ci
:>
x
is
z
w
(L
(L
<:
1;5
.,
o
"-
rn
e:
,Q
m
z
'"
rn
"
o
as
-'"
'"
..J
'"
"0
'~
iI
,",
"'
1;5
Q; .,
- 0
'" "-
~ rn
:Jl e:
U 0
~~
rocoz
co en ai
<D "
'" c '2:
~ t1l
.. (fJ "'
g, 00 .E!:!
"jjj ~ 'E
" 0
"LLg
i3 't.
(fJ
:::J
.s:;
:E~
'" .,
.~ -
Q,) .;
> ~
o 0-
0- 0
rJl.E
zo-
t
=
,
>
~
>2
~.
~
,
"
,
,
,
<
'"
:E
C>
'Qi
'" I
'" "
" c:
" 0
~ 1;5
N >-
'" '"
~ .9:::r::::
"E ~ co
8 'E ~
co~8o :.c
..-~ o::t 0 :,
l ~.. o~ ~ ~
~. t:.c: II) (Ii 0
.!! CI,!! .!! -
E:ii 'E 'Ed
.!-;"O~+:
II) ~ CLl - Q) 'E
>.,.- - ~ C).-
rn .c: <J :> n:I 0
::::I CI) "0 ... c.-
'jij .... '0 tl:l CLl "'0 II)
... .s::. ... 0 > .- 0
f-f-Q.l!:ct::ii::ii
,
~
.;3
~
o
Z
~
c
,
~
.
"
.~
-3
~
~
C
:J
o
U
>-
'"
Q.
'"
N
~
"
c:
1:
'"
Q.
as 'E!l'
~ co ell -
ro ro E E
~ () CLl ()
ooOmo
U5 c ttI Co
~o;o.
U 'c, E '"
a. f!:! "C ~
E ~ c:
co cu.!!:! 'co
() "5 - ~
Q. 0 '"
&.8 ~
E u::
i ~J}
Co
ctl
::
!!!
'co
"
'0
(5
c:
~ -o(/)
"E c ~
ctI .!:2 ctl "C
U5 '- en "'C
8 ~ ~ @
.!:2 8 ~ %
-g '0 ~
co jg Z" Q)
c Q.) Q.) ~
o -S .~> g-
~g'roo.
.e~E~
.~ c .g ,Q
Q)Q.)"Oro
co E Q) ~
:i 0. t) ()
u 0 Q.l ~
~ ~ =g ....
e Q.) () .E
'Cij "'C C ctl
c-g~16
'co co..o"'O
E '" '"
.9~~;.s
(f) Q) ro 1G
aJ-firo"C
> "'0 'S:
'C Q.) Q) 0
~~~5.
~ I ,~~
:c 0 c
:s: ~~
'" u
:ri ~ >.
EO);::
"co .5 ffi
(3roUl
'" '0 c:
o g. 8
~
.E
.c:
u
'"
'"
c:
o
'"
,!,!
(3
'"
'0
'"
'"
.c:
'co
<-
-
o
'"
c:
o
~
u
.Q
'"
Cii
,!,!
'0
,E
'"
o
.0
E
>-
'"
'co
~
N
~
.ci
on
ci
:>
x
Ci
z
W
0.
0.
"
o
E
c:
,Q
Cii
'<3
o
'"
'"
ct
,;,
'"
~
:J
'"
'"
'"
ui '"
'" '"
'C ro
'" '0
> '"
[)'-fi
~'O
:J c:
U '"
g~
'co
~
'"
'0
'g
u::
r--
o
o
N
~
E
"
1;5
>-
(/)
'iij
~
'"
'0
'g
u::
'"
Cii
'0
"
,E
~
C
"
U
l'
o
~
z
"2
i
"
,
,
,
~
9-
z
N
.ci
"'
ci
:>
x
is
z
w
"-
"-
"
"
"
(f)
<Ii '"
'"
c "
" 5-
> ;>,
" II
~ 0>
:J
a i:ij
"C E
" (f)
'" E'
<Ii ~ :::J "C
" 1:
E 'ro " ~ "E'
.<:: .,Q 0>
'" ,:: .!!l f- a iii
0, "
'j; cO ;>, " ;>,
E' E '" ~ "C '"
C. "C f- a :J C
a .~ a t)M a
" ~ iO '" ;>,'" ~
a 0> u: " ,E _0> a
:J " 0 = ~ "
'ro E ,:; "" <=- :c ,E "
.. '" 'in 0 in
,:: 0> "6 E z '" '" "C
:J '" 2
E Ii; .2? " '"
'" " '" 2
'" (1) ,:; > "
"C (f) 2 .c '" '" (f)
.~ - E a
" E " ,E " ,E ~ "C
a '" Ul 2
u: " ~ '" 2
'" a >- 'ro '" "
lD " .<:: '"
" " a " <5 ~ ;>,0>
,:; ~ ". '" CJ) t f- (/J "00 :::J
~ 0 '" " '" J!1 "
"C "
a tii " " Ul c. ~ "C .~ ,:;
'" 0> ,:; '" "C .~ tii
" '" :J '" f- '1] ,E
0> ;>, " " .- E' " u:
" " CO ro tii "
'" '" ;: "- c. " c. .!!l
,~ E a ... 15 ,:; " '" 'j;
! "C B I- '" " ,Q '" ~
"C " " " ,!a OJ "C ro ;S f- 'j;
" a -" 2: " " Z .~ ~
.:i "C i: - .~ "C f-
, '" ,E " CO .<:: :J " 'ro "
" >- a tii '" f- " TI ,:; ,:: " "
a. '" ~ C i: ,E " ..
~ ... :J a 0 :J '" ;: ,E '" i:
"g (1) "'5 t "- 0 "C '"
;>, 'S; '" "C "
, - E .<:: (1) tii .- "is E '" " 'g iO ..
1 - c. '" " - " a " iO ~
CO " ~ "C " a CO u: " 0, 'in u: 0
- .2 c.
" a .- -" ~ " '" " "" C.
i ~ " > '" Z .<:: ;>, a " " .. ,
0:: E f- Z f- '" II ,E ,:; z <(
"
, ~
"
"
! ~
0
"
0 ~
; 0
:: ,
" ,
,
, 0
,
, ~
,."..._........_.,_,..""...........,~'....__~,'_._.o . ----...-,....,
~' ',--,~
. i __ ~=~
- '- -
. :-.:::::=
.:::""'.....
. : .....:~<
~
.ci
"'
ci
!!1 !!1 '"
I .ffi '" ~
ro .:- OJ ro
~ rn a.
OJ
" "' ii5 ro
"g ::J C
, "0 .Q
~ 2
1;) :; E rn
I E .E OJ z
::J 1ii
ro !!f OJ ,., OJ
C ~ :; CfJ :;
0 !!1 E
~ -
Q) 0 .ffi .g
z c 1:- ~
!!1" :;;: 0 E
E 1;) ro "
.~ '0 E c ~
.Q "'
I- ,.,
" x ro rn CfJ
.E E 5 z !!J.
OJ "0 rn OJ 'n;
" ro c :;
CfJ 0 ~
i; "0 ~ I-
ro c .2 "iii
c ro ro
.Q ro 0. c
rn Q) ~ E 0
c .3 "' "
z '5 :; iD III
"' .> " c Z
" 0 OJ t "
"0 5- ro J:
::J :; a. ~
13 !!f ~ OJ ....
.s .~ ~ :; 0
0. 0.
E I- iD .00 III
'n; OJ E
'n; ~ c :E .>
~ ~ .Q "
l- I- CfJ rn rn c" "iii
i " .~ " !!1 OJ :; 0 U
." 'n; Cl t; ~ "'
'S: I- ~ III .~ ~
is " 1:- I- ~ OJ E :2
~ u ~ ." I- er ::J
~ " ..9 .2
e 'n; III C on (ij (ij
"iii "E ~ " :t: .s III
, ~ ~ I- ::> ~ c c: Q) "0
~ c l- I- 0 U u 0 .Q c ~ >
" N U '" ~ '> ro
III " " u rn 0 OJ .
.5 Cl E ro :g 0
." J: J: '" Z z E 'E "
" 'E ." <( u t 'u 0 ~ .:;: ,
0 10 '0 OJ "0 "0 (;
" 0 " 0 III J: c: c: OJ >
z u ii: .!:l z Z 0.. 0.. I- ro ro LL 0 CfJ
~,
" ~
'2
~ .
~
~ -
-
. ~
, ,
~ ,
,
~
.~ f
0
,
,
,
~
7.
~
~
4
~
"
,
~
,
~
~
,
,
,
~
.ci
"'
ci
>'
x
15
z
~
a.
<(
~
"
~
"
~
"
'3
,
~
~
Q
~
o
~
~
>
:;::
trJ
~
'" g
cOro~ro~
.!; ro z-.c -LL "C ::l
CO .--
E":mt)>COL-
if! - rot- - 0
m=:::J_<C(/)t
E::2:g-IDQ)~O
r- a.J::- c..
ro~ 0)1- m~ CJ)
-olJ:lctrib~~
.~ ~"E Q5 0 ~ Q)
u::......o-o-co03
o~2'~ 5u~
Q)5,Q)-o~~:s:
15'00 -:5 ~ e.:: '<;f""
1i)~-:5u..t)~~
ctl tf.I> en Q) co OJ
Q.lC'Q;:.!::'t:o..05
c,:S:~"E ~ai~
:;.:::: ro ~ Q):Q 3:
o:E3ef;l-(")
c..cg'_(/).9Q;l
";;; OJ I... :g'~ en :g
>~Eo0:5:Q~::l
1-_ ........COo
<CCI)e.E.2o..>.
"""OOUQ)LL -.....
Oro_.J::CCJ)Q)
Q)"oo ('IJ...'- >-:5
(/) :::J CJ) C Q) I- CD
::I..cWO:Q<(..c
roC:gQ)~'5$:
C OJ '- U...... 0
g>~ij5:J1-g2
m~s:~uc~
................L-('IJo
o C Q) 0.0..:0:: Q)
Q) '" c> "'.<:;
......- 3: C E - ::I
Q)3:!o!:;S:lo...tI)o
...c:L... .....oot/)>.
-.2>-oc_o
o LL I- .- ~ c: U '-
;C)<(~c:'a;ctlS
CD.!:"'C CO ~ ro 2 ~
~.c'~_-~~rn
.- 0 0 ~ 'w 0..
-o-"'C..::.t::Q)c::lCll
~.!Qre~:grJ:5=
Q) - C
.!Q:::: c: co e ~ Q).!Q
~ .~ ~ -g ~ ~~ ~
q:5~5....~4:()
C1J_o-,J2>l...cti
-oouQ)Q).!Q~:Q
.~ (J) _ S: I.....c _ 0
u:: (/) Q.) - ctll- 0_
oEooQ) 'Q:)LL
i:: e- 2 i:: a; E Q) i::
<C 6...E <( :5 8 E <(
"
-Q)
:;,:
E
::l
~
.E
Q)
'"
<f>
<f>
Q)
E
5
o
.S
Q)
OJ
'"
<f>
<f>
Q)
E
'"
1ii
o
0.
i
"in
Q)
,:;
'5
o
.c
'"
<f>
C
.2
1ii
Q)
OJ
OJ
::l
~u;
o ~
<f> '"
c.c
Q) f0-
E :;j
E 0
o >-
" E
>- E'
C _
'" ~
Q) '"
> Q)
'" .c
.c 0
::l ~
o Q)
>->
:::..2
N
.c
"'
"
:>
x
'6
c
.
"-
"-
"
E
o
"
oi
"
.~
u::
a;
-'"
iii
~
"
o
Q;
.c
<f>
<f>
Q)
~
"
"
'"
Q)
,:;
Cil
<f>
::l
'm
E
Q)
:>;
U
~
'Ei
<f>
::l
tl
'"
C
o
"
.8
"
Q)
Q)
C
::l
o
>-
'"
'5
o
'"
"
Q)
.c
"
o
<f>
;;:
v;-
a;
E
E
'"
0.
<f>
"
'0
>
'"
.8
Q)
OJ
'"
.~
Q)
:0
'"
-'"
.>2
13
C
::l
C
'"
<f>
~
E co
o ....
~"o::t"LO
~co~
._ N
~x...J
gaLL
LLtn
i::o
<(<L
"
~
~
~
~
N
~
"
~.
N
t
o
~
'il
.
i
.g
"C
o
"
"
.
,
,
::=::
E
N
D
'"
ci
:>
x
'5
c
~
~
~
'"
~
~
~
::S
N
8
"
~
"
^'
0
"
.g:
"
=
~ ;;
~ .8
~ A
~
0
~
<
< "
0 '"
~
0 .
~ ;
~ ,
~ ~
~
< f
CIl
en:=
=CV
~.=
~
2c
1!~
"""I:
l/lcu
c5t.i
.. ..
II: .. f
w.-::
~p
lIl"j
Q~l
'"
<>
o
o
o
o
~
-~
D-'
<nO
0;;;
,
>0
.~
"C
C
.
~
~
"
. .e
< "C
. 'N c; < 3 . ~'
, . .'0 0 0 c ~ U
~ .. ~ 0 0
U . U " 0 c a:
~ :E > ~ 0 . 0 .
U ~ u t:
< :0 :0 ~
~ 0 ~ 0 0 C 0
U c; E c '" ~ ~
0 ~
1l . c . 0 l'i 0 '0
~ z " 0 .e
~ . < ,; . ~ 00
i5 ~ '" . 0 ~ 0
. ~ ~ 1; E 0
~ ;: 'E c ,; . N
0 U ~ ~ '0 :0 .'0
'E . 0 "C ,
. ~ E 2 ~
. < u . ,;
0 E '0 c; u . .
. t u
~ '0 c u .
.. f]' c " 0 .
~ . u .
< 0. < . > 0 c ~ ~ c
. 0 '. . ~ ~ 0 c c c
'" '. 'E Jj E 0 0 ., .
~ ~ E u f-
a. . . c ~ E 0
i , > '0 0 u 0 ~ 0'
il e " E ~ 0 u ~
0 .0 C
~ " 4 ~ 0 .'0 0
~ ~ i:' '0 0
~ c . " E c
a; 0 . . 0 . ~ t!
0: J .0 , " c; E .0 . .
0 . E < > ~ E 0
, . '0 '0 .'0 . . 0 ~
:E c 0 ~
0 ~ " E u u
" . . u 0
~ b '0 ~ ~ > '0
. .~ C "C ~
.0 E 15 0
c .
c 0 E . E " 0
0 0 ~ ~ N
~ ~ 4 . 2 '0
c . jj ,; ~ ~ .
:g . E ~ ~
2 > "C C
0 2 0 c c .
u . 0 0 0
. .~ .
c; ~ C "C ~ >
C "C .
C ~ C 0
0 c 0
~ " . 0 ~ 0 E " E
0 0 1> ,g
'. N ~ E "C . ~
C . 0 c c ~
0 0 . ~ 0 0 ~ c .
E 0 s 0 >
2' c u " E ~ E .
E 0 . E ~ E 't 0 E
0 '" 0 c 0
u C u .
2 ~ . > 0 .,
.!! 0 u ~ . " 0
.~ ~ . c c 0 ~
c J'l u c u E l'
0 . ~ . c 'c
~ C "C >
. 0; . u '" . 0 "' ~
. .0 '" > > E "
" 0 " E .0 '0 E "
'j; c c; . c .. I
.~ Q 0 .Q " > 0
< w " c E ~ '0 u ,=
0 0 :g "C "C
1\1 " :t c " c c c "
.. ~ > .. 0 . . 0 c
t- ~ ,= . 0
I- < < c u " '. .0 C "
. 0 0 c c .~ . " 0 0 0
C ~ :J: . .0 0 ~ > . " z ,
. 0 ~
1\1 ~ :t E ~ u '" E '. ~ ;; . ,
U ~ 0 . .
0 "0 " 0 . ~ 0: :0 . ~ E t
.;: '" " ~ E t: 00 ~ " 0 ~
GI . .. .!! c; 0: " 0 00 0 0 c
E 0 w .~ c u ~ :': u u u "
J 0: " C; .Q ~ E ,'0 ~ 0 ~
CC . < f- :0 S ;: .'0 c c
" ~ '0 'E
c w c OJ 0 c ls E ,
... . c . ~ E 0 . 0 0
:t .
::;, . u "2 ~ ~ " " c J 0 0 ,
'" .~ . 0 0 g ~ u
0 ~ 0 c . E ~ ,
0 0 ,
.Q < :J: E 0 0 . 0 . . . ,
'0 :t E .e ;< ~ .e ~ 0 ~
CC ~ 4 <
"
"
,
i
~
~"
"
,
~
.
,
g
~
i
~
~
c
<;
~
t
~
E
~
~
'.
.
~
.
<
<
~
..
'.
'"
..
<
'.
~
oS
c
~
.
oS
,
.E
E
,"
I
o
o
o
N
"
e
.
~
~
o
o
.
~
o
"'
.'
u
~
.
"'
~
"
~
o
~
"
'" e
o 0
IJ'l :;::;
" ~
Q)~ "c
u .
.~ ~
.
"' ro
t 5
. "
~ .
ro e
e "
o e
:.;:; ro
. "
Z .
Q) '0
-E lii
:5 g
3 ~
E E
~ 0
~ "
e ~
; ~J
!1J .~
" .
e "'
:8 ~
~ :s?
a; ~
'" '"
ro ~
e "
o i.:i:
~ vi
z
. "
E
~ e
e .
:f;i ~
2 g
";;: c
. .
'" >:
~
~
.
~
.
e
.
E
"
e
.
"
2i
.
u
o
>
"
.
~
-.
.E
e
o
"
.
,~
:0
o
o
"
.
.
e
,
.
E
~
o
.
E
.'
e
N
.
~
.
>:
$
.
"
e
.
u
'0
.
E
'"
~
e
o
o
"
2
~
~
"
>-
.
.
e
.
~
~
"
e
.
$
~
.E
"
.
~
o
~
~
u
e
.
.
u
e
J'l
"
"
"
.
ro
u
'0
~
u
2i
~
e
'6
.,
2
~
~
"
.
"
'c
o
o t
'.E. 0
~ 0
. 0
e 0
t ~
. e
0... .~
g' b
:~ '0
"
$
.
"
ro
e
o
"
.
Z
.
E
,
.
"
e
.
ro
u
.
,.
c
o
e
.
"
e
.
"
.
~
o
o
"
~
~
e
c
~
"
o
o
~
"
~
o
.
!;!
"
"
~
,
.
E
o
u
e
.
~
e
'c
~
"
"
.
u
2
~
e
.
E
"
"
w
"
;:>
'.
"
ro
~
w
>
C
"
~
e
'6
"
2
~
"
~
~
o
.~
is
'"
"
.
u
u
.
.
E
.
>
e
o
"
B
"
>-
.
.
"
e
.
".
.
o
"
"
ro
~
"
"'
.
.
"
"
3
~
>-
u
e
w
~
.
e
o
C
c
o
E
E
o
u
"
~
.
E
~
e
'~
.E
.5
~
~
~
e
C
~
"
.
.
e
o
o
>-
o
Q
B
~
u
'0
o
>-
.
'c
Z
"
~
~
o
..
N
.g
:c
o
~
"'
u
.
.
~
>-
u
e
w
~
.
>-
w
~
.-
"
o
o
J:
2i
i'
$:
.
E
"'
"
.
0,
e
o
U
B
.
o
~
.
0;
it
w
g
.
o
o
>-
.
<<
"
.
o
"
"
e
.
E
.
~
.
e
.
E
"
e
-"
~
w
"
.1'
e
o
"
.
~
.E
~
"
J'l
"
e
.
"'
~
e
'0
.
w
~
.
~
e
"
.
o
o
e
.
~
~
0;
L
'5
B
~
.
~
~
~
~
.
t
o
o
o
o
"
~
ro
u
.Q
.E
e
:8
.
-,;;
'0,
"
u
e
.
e
o
"
u
.
ro
e
o
"
"
~
~
e
o
U
~
e
"
~
[>
2i
.5
.
~
<
c
.
~
.
~
"
c
o
~
z
w
~
~
~
'ii
l:-
e
.
,~
~
E
'"
e
'0
~
~
"
.
B
C
.
~
-5:
0;
i
~
o
o
>-
o
w
w
~
B
o
"
w
.
~
o
.
.
E
,
o
o
o
o
"
B
>-
.
"
B
"
.~
f-
e
.
u
o
w
E
'"
e
g
.
"
.
.
"-
e
.
~
f-
"
w
:0
.
o
ro
>
.0;
"
D
.
.
o
o
e
o
"
.
~
o
~
~
w
E
"
e
~
o
o
>-
o
o
~
c
'c
~
.l!
E
B
o
~
.s
"
.
~
.
~
.
"
E
-:'~I','.III".",.'
.... .y
'J',' ,IS;
..... ...,.
.~. ~
-:;. ",C,''':
'4- -,
'liJ: ''\11,,-
'"
o
c
o
c
8
~
o
<
.
,.
'E
o
<
'0
~
"
.
"
"
.
<
"
o
D
,
.E
.
.
>-
-
o
o
n
.,
"
e
.
"'
o
o
e
~
il
.0;
e
o
'0
>
;:,
~
e
o
e
o
<
il
E
o
,
.E
.
.
>-
-
o
~
.,
"'
ro
o
u
"
'6
.
.E
,
.
.
>-
-
~
N
.,
.
e
0,
w
D
"
o
i'
~
.
D
E
.
>:
..
"
w
o
~
~
e
o
o
o
.
:0
-"
.
>
.
~
.
.
e
"
m
'"
>'
'"
.~
f'
e
B
o
w
E
'"
o
"
.
'"
o
u
~
J'l
e
.
E
"-
E
o
u
;;
<
'N
.
go
.
'"
.!!
'ii
l:-
e
.
,~
.
E
'"
e
:8
.
~
:0
o
o
ro
e
o
"
.
e
>-
C
o
.
{;
"'
t
2:
.~
f'
>-
'C
W
E
.E
.'
e
,
m
'"
m
~
'"
"@
...
e
B
'0
.
"
'"
B
e
o
"
o
5
"
D
o
"
.
.
>
'w
u
~
~
W
D
E
w
E
"
'.
"
e
.
~
w
E
'"
"'
.
o
"
,"
.
.
e
~
e
w
E
o
o
"
>
.
"
0;
e
c
e
m
"-
~
e
'6
o
u
.
"
u
'"
B
"
.0;
.
~
~
il
>
o
u
.
.
,
m
.
>-
~
u
.
.
"
w
13
w
~
{;
>-
B
m
E
'x
e
o
o
'"
~
.
"
o
"
.~
ro
.E
J'i
e
.
>
.
"
e
m
e'
o
"
.
-,;;
0,
"
;;
.
~
u
.
~
<
o
u
"
.
"
e
.
u
o
.
E
<<
~
go
~
n
go
~
o
~
go
'"
U
0;
e
'6
u
.
'"
~'
go
~
n
go
~
X
o
"'
o
~
o
~
o
N
'"
~
~
o
~
"'
.
e
o
~
o
.
~
N
.c
"'
ci
:>
x
'6
e
.
Q
Q
'"
~
~
o
N
'"
~
~
o
~
~
2'
o
.!i
~
e
.
u
o
.
E
.
@
"
.
.
"
~
,
~
I
,
,
~
0;
e
'6
u
w
'"
.
o
o
o
N
;,;
"
o
o
'"
o'
"
e
m
i5
.
N
o
o
N
"
.
X
w
f-
e'
"
"
o
'"
.
~
o
o
N
ro
.
oS
u
e
.
"
'0
~
~
"
.
"
o
"
.
o
CY
.
~
o
o
N
,.
in~ ra
rn E
~ g
~ ro
" u
N
o
o
N
~
o
o
N
~
o
o
N
'"
o
o
N
.E
~
.
e
e
"
~
.
.
.
w
{;
w
w
"
E
~
~
e
o
"
~
.
.
'"
"
.~
f-
ro
e
~
.
z
w
{;
~
~
o
J:
'.
o
o
"
>
w
"
B
"
e
o
"
.
N
o
~ ~
o ~
o
w
u "
e 0
. 0
" ~
w ~
'0 "E
e .
. .
g' u
E .
3: ~
01 "c
C ';0
~ c
o "iiJ
$: >:
~ ~
~
~
c
C
.~
.
~
~
o
o
~
o
o
"
E
~
~
e fl
Cl. "5
.!!! '';::;
'~ ~
f- "
~ .~
in
" .-
E u
~ .~
e E
o '"
2i
.
>
o
o
"
e
.
.
~
"
0/
~
e
B
o
u
.
E
e
o
,
.
I
,
,
~~,
X
.
~
'.
~
w
B
"
'.
u
'0
w
E E"'O
'" . e
B ...... "'0 It!
Q) ~ ~ ~
u ~ iii
~ co 2~ .=
~ -g 2 a
Vi It! Vl
~ Vl~ ..c ~
co ..c ~ .a
~ .';2, 2 ~
'6 Vl~ ..c
os: Q) ...... 1! It!
e :..::; ~ I-- :0
~ .~ ~ >. E
~ ~ ~ Vl
It! n ..e n :l:
~ n co Q)
E 0 r: ~ ~
It! 0 :0 0 Ii5
E ~ .2 ~ E
.E Q) co ~ It!
.!: r: E g' ~
co co '- :..::; Q)
.!: o!: 0 O-F;
Cl n E -
~ ~ e -g
..... Vl 0.. It!
.
~
"'
t,j t,j t,j t,j
.
I,
~
<
z
~
"
::
>
~
~
<
ATVSafetylnstitute
Rldcl rldlrllr1Cj BLfolc You Rldc Mcdla IllfOtllldtlOIl RccrH r:t the Outdomc;
Rldrng Gl'ClI AS] Pfodurtc; COlltart U, Librdry I Sdflly rip,> IllStruclol':>
ASIHomelHome
ATV Safety Institute E-Course
ENROll NOW
About ASI
.
. .
, "
-. ~"' '*41'
,'" "R
~,
Watch Video
Watch Ride Safe, Ride Smart
The All-Terrain Vehicle Safety Institute@(ASI),a not-far-profit division of the
Specialty Vehicle Institute of America@ (SVIA), was formed in 1988 to
implement an expanded national program of all-terrain vehicle (ATV) safety
education and awareness. ASI's primary goal is to promote the safe and
responsible use of ATV's, thereby reducing accidents and injuries that may
result from improper ATV operation by the rider.
Now
Media Information
ASI Press Releases I SVIA Press Releases I Info Sheets
Public Service Announcements I Images I ASI in the News
SVIA in the News
This eight-minute video
demonstrates the
importance of getting a
proper start in A TV
riding, whether you ride
A TVs for recreation or
for business. Two
families are profiled;
both sets of parents
lead by example,
emphasizing riding an
A TV that is right for your
age, weanng proper
proteclive gear,
supervising young
riders, and respecting
the environment. They
also recommend taking
an ATV RiderCourse to
get the most from your
ATV.
For a CODV of the video
click here.
For the ATV RiderCoursesm nearest you, call toll free (800) 887-2887
The Ail-Terrain Vehicle Safety Institute (ASI), a not-far-profit division of the Speeialty Vehlele Institute of Amerlea (SVIA), was formed In 1988 to Implement an expanded
national program of ail-terrain vehicle (ATV) safety education and awareness. The ASlls sponsored by Arctic Cat, BRP, Honda, KTM, Kawasaki, KYMCO USA, Polaris, Suzuki,
Tomberlin, Tomato, and Yamaha.
hup:/Iwww.atvsafety,org/5/S/2009 2:31 :55 PM
---~\
Appendix V.D.5b.12
,
$
~
"
~
~
>
~
<:
B-
E
FL-A TV .COM land aquisilions
Dedicated to all Florida Off-Road Enthusiasts by
making
Land Acquisitions an affordable reality
"Click Here"
to siGn up in your County-of-Choice
,~
I~nt Up;ta~........LllDd.~....etaUiJlg....:oow is tliet\..e to. up 'r.lt.,..., YOUR
f!.:tcIJt:NDSt We are accepting cOffi.roitnJ,ents of interest (no Obligation) for ownership interests in
several multi-hundred acre parcels of raw land throughout Flori4ii. Please sign up IlOwand reserve
. . .>............. ..................... ...... ........ .. .... ....... ..... ....._,.. . .....
your plaee *******
hup:llwww.tl-atv.coml(1 of 3)518/2009 1 :50: 15 PM
We are a membership driven group of Florida
ATV enthusiasts who are securing ATV land
tracts for A TV parks, A TV riding areas, A TV
riding trails, A TV camping, and A TV events
through out Florida. No more being run off of
others property. This is ATV land acquisition
via fractional ownership - a proven method that
works - our own legal A TV riding areas forever.
The major issue that plagues most of us is
'where are legal A TV riding areas, A TV parks,
ATV riding trails, and even ATV A~p~~r~~~2 areas
FL-ATV.COM land aquisitions
http://www.fi-atv.coml(2 of 3)5/8/2009 ] :50: 15 PM
where we can't get run off'. Wouldn't you love a
place where you can relax, ride freely, picnic
with the family, camp, a place you can call your
own. Let me introduce you to FL-ATV.COM
because that's what we're all about.......
We are not a club. Instead, this is about
ownership. This is A TV land acquisition via
fractional ownership whereby everyone is an
equal owner of all the A TV riding areas
acquired. They are all designed for the
common enjoyment of all owners, families and
guests. No more being chased off. No more
wondering where to go. No more trespassing.
There are enough A TV enthusiasts to
support a facility in almost every
county in Florida.....
BUT, we need everyone to sign up in your
County-of-Choice and be among the first
selected to acquire Florida A TV riding land in
your county. You must be signed up to
participate and then you'll be notified when a
riding facility is ready for purchase. There's no
obligation to purchase by signing up.
Spread the word because land prices are going
up.
Visit our "What we're about" link for more on
our mission.....
Appendix VD.5b.12
FL-A TV .COM land aquisitions
********
"We're making off-road an awsome reality."
~
Copyright @ 2004 FL-A TV Home
----------------------------- Friends of fl-atv.com
-----------------------------
CUCK HERE
~
Appendix V.D.5b.12
http://www.tl-atv.coml(3 of 3)5/8/2009 1 :50: 15 PM
o
~
"
o
i
~
]
,
f;;
~
c
]
,
"
"
~
~
E
,
,
~
~
<
;r.
,
8
x
~
~
~
"
"
"
I
:s;
~
x
,
.~
,
,
t
':!i;
:s
~
'"
<:
III
01
<:
'"
'"
o
:I:
o
~
0..
o
-
Ql
'"
III
~
01
0.
=>
,;;;
"
~
"
q
~
,
<
f
,
o
,
~
';""""""''''"'~~~'''-"'-'''--
,
,
g
South Florida XC racing
http://www.seftr.org/(1 of 8)51812009 ]:55:4] PM
South Florida XC racing
http://www.scftr.org/(2ofR)5/R/2009 ] :55:41 PM
South florida XC rdcing
Appendix V.D.5b.12
http://www.sdtr.org/(3 of 8)5/812009 1 :55:41 PM
South Florida XC racing
I
http://www.scftLorg/(4of8)5/8/2009 ] :55:4] PM
South F]orida XC racing
htlp:llwww_seftLorgl (5 of 8)5/812009 1 :55:4] PM
South rlorida XC racing
Appendix VD.5b.12
hltp:l/www.seftr.org/(Rof8)5/8/2009 ]:55:4] PM
c
.g
~
"
~
iO
~
Ci
5-
"
"8
-ij
~
.1i
'"
t
is
,
~
"
,
::
~
"
.
z
o
~
t
5
~
"
,
.
o
.
o
"
~
"
. ~ ~ "
u " . ~
e 0 l
~ " ~ E E .
" ~ j ~ "
~ ~ . 0 " g " ~ .
" , 0
~ ~ ~ E ! . " l j "i
~ . ;;; t ., ~ ~ " .
i ~ l . ~ " . .~ e
0 0 " . .~ j . "-
" u: [ " ~ a . ;;; i . 0
~ , .Ii " . 0
Q ~ . 0 0
;; ~ . . . ~ , ~ 0
! t l ~ ~ ~ . ~
0 0 f 0 0 ~
~ l ~ Ii E- .
8 . . .. . . . ~ " c
~ . ~ 0 ~ "- 5 .
. . ~ ~ . , " l 0 0 , .
~ ~ n C E ~ ~ E 0 . ~
5 Q ! . t ~ 5
0 ~ ~ ~ 0 . E ~
~ . 0 0 ~ . .
~ " . E . ~ 1 ~
~ E j 0 2
0 " ~ ~ . i ~ " " " 0 ~
~ ~ . ~ .
~ . ~ 0 ~ . 5 , "
a , 0 ~ . " j i 0 .
g .~ ~ g 0 , ~ ~
'6 ~ c 0 ~ 5 . ~
~ ~ , . 0 ~ . ~ g
" 0 ~ " " ~
* ~ , " ~ . " 0 .. 0 .
0 , . 1 " . ~ .
0 . 0 ~ 1 ~ . u g <; c
~ ~ 1 . ~ w ;0;
~ a ! E ~ ~ , . " 0'
0 ~ , c ~ ~ . g " ~ .. -
~ c . ~
. . . ~ ~ . c "- . 5 . ~
c . ~ . ;;
0 . 5 1 g 1 ]' ,
, " ~ . ~ c ~ . -
" . 0 . ~ 0 .
~ ~ ;;; . ~ , ~ a
" " c 0 l
" . . . . . " 0 u g 0 . ~
E ~ " . 0 . ~ . "gj E ~ . E
.~ . . . . i
. ~ :2 . . i ~
~ " 0 ]( . ~ . " , . .
. "- . , . " . c 1 . ~ "
" . 0 . c . U ~ C 0 E
c .~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~ .
0 ~ 0 " " ~ .. "
~ e- i ~ . ~ 5 ~ . 0 ,
~ " ~
~ m . ~ " ~ . . ,
~ " , , " E E . ~
~
. .
. ~
0
c c c
. . ~ .,
.. .. .
~ ~ . .,
c 0-
. m . 0 c
~ " a . ~
E E . 0 ~
, E $ ~
0 r 0 !' !' . u
u u . " . .. c
E 0
~ ,. "
E 0 "
0 0 . ~
U ~ 0 .
0 . 0
~ "
Trail Ranger Program
Home
Events Trail Ranger Program Volunteer
Documents Contact Board Meetings
Sponsors
Links
Maps
Trail Ranger Program
Trail Rangers are a group of specially trained volunteers riding
motorcycles, all terrain vehicles or driving their 4x4 vehicle in the
National Forest. They are responsible for greeting fellow OHV
enthusiasts, handling emergencies and passing along information about
backcountry travel on public land managed by the Forest Service.
Operating under a volunteer agreement with the Ocala National Forest
Association (ONFA) the Trail Ranger represents the U.S. Forest Service.
They are official representatives of the Forest Service, but carry no law
enforcement authority to enforce regulations beyond that of any other
citizen. Their influence is felt through their knowledge, friendliness, and
willingness to help others. They are a vital part of the Forest Service
who have a high degree of commitment to responsible use of off-highway
travel on public lands.
Key Activities
· Coordinate Forest trail maintenance with local OHV clubs,
associations and community organizations. Operating under the
Adopt-A- Trail Program, the rougher routes of travel for A TV,
motorcycle, or 4WD are assigned to local organizations.
. A group of trained volunteers patrol routes on A TV's,
motorcycles, and 4WD vehicles. These volunteers make public
contact to provide information, watch for illegal use, missing signs
or hazardous trail conditions.
· Special projects involve organizations or individuals who have
only a limited amount of time to donate - only one or two days per
year.
Program Objectives
To help off highway vehicle enthusiasts understand land and resource
ethics, the Forest Service has developed a partnership with OHV user
groups and industry to develop an OHV program.
Appendix V.D.5b.12
http;/Iwww.onfa.orgrrrail%20Ranger%20Program.htm (1 of 3)5/8/2009 1 :58; 18 PM
Trail Ranger Program
· Unite all concerned in safe, sensible use of OHV recreational
vehicles and responsible land management.
· Provide information and conservation education to OHV
enthusiasts who visit the National Forest.
· Promote the continued enjoyment of our forest, year after year,
for generations to come.
How to Become an OHV Volunteer
The OHV Volunteer Program is a partnership effort between the Ocala
National Forests and the Ocala National Forest Association (ONFA). The
ONF A manages the program for the partnership. The Partners have
agreed upon the following requirements for Trail Rangers.
. Have a strong commitment to the vision, mission, purpose, and
objectives of the OHV Volunteer Program.
. Complete and return the OHV Membership Form.
. Demonstrate the ability to contact National Forest visitors in a
courteous, informed and positive manner.
. Complete required training provided for Trail Rangers.
. Maintain your uniform in good condition and wear it only while on
duty
. Agree to a minimum of 90 hours of service per year (Host) or
less than 90 hours for special projects.
Individuals interested in the Trail Ranger Program may submit their
names to the Webmaster at any time of the year. Orientation and
training are conducted at least four times during the year, check the
training calendar for Orientation/Host class dates and times. No one will
be permitted to become a host candidate between training cycles - each
volunteer must complete all of the required training.
Background and History
Visiting the Forest used to mean camping and hiking. But with the advent
of today's sophisticated multi-terrain technology, there is a new and
exciting world of adventure - the use of all terrain vehicles that can take
enthusiasts to parts of the Forests few people get a chance to see. But
with this new use of public lands, there was also a concern and need for
~
Appendix V.D.5b.12
http://www.onfa.orgffrailo/r)20Ranger%20Program.htm (2 of 3)5/8/2009 1:58:18 PM
Trail Ranger Program
public education of the principles of trail ethics. To help OHV
enthusiasts understand land and resource ethics, the Forest Service,
together with the Association developed a partnership with OHV user
groups and industry to develop an Trail Ranger Volunteer Program.
The objectives of the program are: to unite all concerned in safe,
sensible use of OHV recreational vehicles and responsible land
management; provide information and conservation education to OHV
enthusiasts who visit the Forest; and promote the continued enjoyment
of our Forests, for generations to come.
The overall goal of the program is a more informed public and a more
protected Forest.
Appendix V.D.5b.12
http://www.onfa.orgrrrail%20Ranger%20Program.htm (3 of 3)5/8/2009 1 :58:18 PM
Florida Motorcycle Dealers Association - 'Trespassing' ATY, din bike enthusiasts want room to ride
II. Search I
~-~
, ~
~
. \.
~
. Home
. mm'Trespassing' ATV, dirt bike enthusiasts want room to ride
. Membership Information
. Board of Directors
. Discount ProgramsBy JOE CRANKSHA W
. Business Information. .
. Improving your busines_Joe.crankshaw@scnpps.com
. Site MapJanuary 2, 2007
The dirt bikes and four-wheeled all-terrain vehicles that roar through the vacant
sand dunes behind Terry Tillman's home in Jensen Beach annoy her and her
neighbors.
In fact, she is so annoyed, she wants to help the riders find someplace nearby
where they can ride legally - without disturbing anyone. If no such place can be
found, she wants to help build one.
Tillman is trying to deal with a problem that is vexing government officials and
law enforcement agencies on the Treasure Coast and across the state.
"These people are trespassing," Tillman said about the people who ride ATVs
and dirt bikes through the sand dunes behind the Publix on Jensen Beach
Boulevard. "They are a plague on our neighborhood, and I wish they would
stop."
The problem has persisted for years, and it is not confined to Jensen Beach.
Residents in Martin, St. Lucie and Indian River counties have complained about
noisy dirt bikes and ATVs.
Tillman and others have complained to the Martin County Sheriffs Office only to
be told there are not enough funds to patrol the area on a regular basis. Also,
Tillman said, most of the riders are juveniles, and even if they get arrested, they
are released to their parents.
Environmentalists complain the vehicles damage the environment. They make
trails over sand dunes and through fields and woods, disturbing wildlife with
their noise and habitat destruction. State legislators took note of the damage and
specified that any lands purchased for a riding area for off-highway vehicles must
have been heavily disturbed by earlier uses.
Meanwhile, the St. Lucie County Commission voted in December to opt out of
another state law that allowed off-highway vehicles to be ridden on dirt roads in
unincorporated areas of the county. The action came at the request of St. Lucie
County Sheriff Ken Mascara, who said he was concerned about the safety of the
http://www.t1oridamotorcyc\e.org/indcx.cfmlrcferer!contcnt.contentltemlID/I 75/item/7637/ (I of 5)5/812009 2:20:] 5 PM
I-lorida Motorcycle Dcalers Association" Trespassing' ATY, dirt bike enthusiasts want room to ride
riders on the roads, particularly at night.
In Indian River County, Sheriff Roy Raymond is working with the County
Commission to opt out of the same state law.
"The off-highway vehicles are a major problem in our county," Indian River
County Sheriffs Office spokesman Deputy Jeff Luther said. "We are having a lot
of injuries and problems on private property."
Martin County Sheriffs Office spokeswoman Lt. Jennell Atlas said her
department is not considering recommending that the county opt out of the state
law allowing ATVs on dirt roads. She said the county receives sporadic
complaints, but there does not seem to be a major problem.
Most people involved with A TV and dirt bike riders agree that having a place
where the vehicles could be ridden legally would help.
But when St. Lucie County Commissioners tried to establish an off-highway park
at the St. Lucie County Airport in 2004, citizen protests and the potential costs
and liabilities forced them to abandon the plan.
Still, Tillman said she is enthusiastic about the possibility of helping find land
where the bikers can ride legally. She plans to speak to the local state legislative
delegation at a Friday meeting in the Martin County Commission chambers in
Stuart to ask for state assistance.
"I don't want to be someone who just complains," Tillman said. "I want the kids
to have their fun, but I just want them to do it where they won't bother people."
Tillman also has recruited Winn Peeples, lobbyist for the Florida Motorcycle
Dealers Association. The association represents merchants who sell motorcycles,
dirt bikes, all-terrain vehicles and other recreational motor vehicles.
Peeples said funds may already be allotted for building riding trails and tracks in
areas where there are not such facilities. The Office of Greenways and Trails in
the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, is involved in three projects
that total $1.9 million. But none serve the Treasure Coast.
"The Off-Highway Advisory Committee oversees the funds and selects areas for
motorsport parks, and it meets quarterly," Peeples said. "I will try and see if they
will hold a meeting in the Treasure Coast area to listen to people and assess the
need."
The idea of a special riding area for off-highway vehicles has real appeal to
people who sell the machines. William Talero, operator of Moto Mania on Dixie
Highway in Stuart, said he believes a park for off-highway vehicles would be a
success.
http://www.f1oridamOlorcycle.org/index.cfmlreferer/colltent_contentltemlID/175/itcmI7637/ (2 of 5)51812009 2:20:15 PM
Florida Motorcycle Oealers Association - Trespassing' A TV, dirt bike enthusiasts wan! room to ride
"I would be glad to join in any effort to turn that into a reality," he said.
WHA T IS AN OFF -HIGHWAY VEHICLE?
Florida laws defines an Off-Highway Vehicle (also called an ATV) or Off-
Highway Motorcycle (also called an OHM) as any vehicle used off the roads for
recreational purposes, which is not registered and licensed for highway use.
. An ATV is defined as any motorized off-highway or all-terrain vehicle 50
inches or less in width, having a dry weight of 900 pounds or less, designed to
travel on three or more low-pressure tires, having a seat designed to be straddled
by the operator and handlebars for steering control and intended for use by a
single operator and with no passenger.
. An OHM is defined as any motorized vehicle used off the roads or highways
that has a seat or saddle for the use of the rider and is designed to travel with not
more than two wheels in contact with the ground, but excludes a tractor or a
moped.
WHAT DO OFF-HIGHWAY VEHICLES COST?
. Dealers say the price is based on engine size, and can range from $700 to
$10,000.
. In 2004, the last year statistics are completely reported, more than 1.4 million
were sold annually across the United States.
. Because they are not all licensed, no one knows how many there are in each
state.
. The Florida Department of Highway Safety & Motor Vehicles says it had
245,964 registered in 2004, but added that many more are not registered. Anyone
wanting to ride on state or local public land must register the vehicle.
LAWS GOVERNING A TVS AND OHMS
. The T. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Safety and Recreation Act of 2002,
provides the guidelines for operating such off-highway vehicles, and mandates
the state to find at least three additional sites for such vehicle use in areas without
such sites.
. Such vehicles can't be ridden on any road in most of the state of Florida, and
can't be ridden on any public or private lands unless the rider is over 18 years of
age. Young riders must be accompanied by a licensed rider, and all riders must
show written permission to be on private property.
. To keep up with the laws governing off-highway vehicles, you can obtain a
http://www.f1oridamotorcyc1e.org/index,cfmlrefererlcontcnt.contentltemllD/1 7Sliteml76371 (3 of 5)5/8/2009 2:20: 15 PM
Honda Motorcycle Dcalers Association - Trespassing' ATV. dirt bike enthusiasts want room to ride
guidebook from the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Affairs,
Division of Forestry. It is available online at: www.fl-dof.com or by writing to
the division at 3125 Conner Blvd., Tallahassee, FL 32399.
WHERE TO RIDE YOUR OFF -HIGHWAY VEHICLE
Always inquire about local regulations. Some sites will charge a fee and all will
check to see if the vehicle is registered with the state for insurance and ownership
purposes.
Federal sites
. Big Cypress National Preserve, Collier County, Box 110, Ochopee, Fl 34141,
Telephone (941) 695-2000.
. Apalachicola National Forest, Apalachicola Ranger District, P.O. Box 579,
Highway 20, Bristol, Fl32312, Telephone (850) 643-2282.
. Ocala National Forest, Lake George Ranger District, 17147 East Highway 40,
Silver Springs, Fl 34488, Telephone (352) 625-2520.
. Wakulla Ranger District, 57 Taff Drive, Crawfordville Fl 32327, Telephone
(850) 926-3561.
. Seminole Ranger District, 40929 State Road 19, Umatilla, F132784, Telephone
(352) 669-3153.
. Osceola National Forest, Osceola Ranger District, P.O. Box 70, Olustee, F.
32072, Telephone (386) 752-2577.
State sites
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission allows off highway
vehicles to use some lands. Here is where to call:
. Northwest Region, 3911 Highway 2321, Panama City, Fl 32409, Telephone
(850) 732-1255.
. Northeast Region, 1239 S.W. 10th Street, Ocala, Fl 34474, Telephone (352)
732-1225.
. North Central Region, Route 7, Box 440, Lake City, Fl 32055, Telephone (386)
758-0525.
. South Region, 8535 Northlake Boulevard, West Palm Beach, Fl 33412,
Telephone (561) 625-5122.
. Tate's Hell State Forest, 290 Airport Rd., Carrabelle, Fl 32322, Telephone (850)
...... ..
http://www.floridamotorcycle.orgJindex.cfm/rcferer/contem.contentltem/ID/175/item/7637/ (4 of 5)5/8/2009 2:20: 15 PM
Florida Motorcycle Dealers Association - 'Trespassing' A TV, din bike enthusiasts want room to ride
697-3734.
. Southwest Region, 3900 Drane Field Road, Lakeland, Fl33811, Telephone
(863) 648-3203. Local Government-
. Dade City Raceway, Pasco County Fairgrounds, Highway 52 West, Dade City,
Fla. 33525, Telephone (352) 567-0792, Web site: www.dadecitymx.com,
Daytona Beach, Fla. The city allows slow cruise vehicles that have licenses to be
used on the beach and some streets. Contact: Dune Buggies of Daytona,
Telephone (904) 252-4385, Web site: Davtonabug@aol.com
Private sites
. Motocross of Marion County, 14525 N.W. 21st Court, Redick, Fl, Telephone
(352) 591-2377, Web site: mxmarioncounty@aol.com.
. North Florida Raceway, 28422 Liberty Trail, Hilliard, Fl 32406, Telephone
(904) 268-2289, Web site: www.northfloridamotocross.com.
. Sunshine Moto-X, 41011 8th Ave. N., St. Petersburg, Fl, Telephone (727) 481-
8162.
. West Florida Motocross Park, 8824 Ray Helms Rd., Pensacola, Fl , Telephone
(850) 623-6038, Web site: wfmp@bellsouth.net.
. Croom Motorcycle Area, Brooksville, Fl. The 2,600-acre site off State Road 50,
Exit 61, Telephone Withlacoochee Forestry Center, (352) 754-6777.
. Moroso Motorsports Park, 17046 Beeline Highway, Palm Beach Gardens, Fl
33478, Telephone (561) 622-1400. This Motorcross track will open regularly
starting in January.
Florida Motorcycle Dealers Association .PO Box 14629. Tallahassee, FL 32317. Phone: 850/222-6000. Fax 850/122-6002
Terms of Use EaminQs Disclaimer Priyacy Policy
@ 2009 - Horida Motorcycle Dealers Association Inc. All Rights Reserved
http://www.i1oridamotorcycle.orglindex.cfm/referer/content.contentltem/1D1175/item/7637/ (5 of 5)5/8/2009 2:20: 15 PM
APPENDIX V.D.5b.13
MIAMI-DADE RESOLUTION
OnlCJALfJU COlY
C'LJlJlJ:: OFTBE IOA.RD
OF COlT.NTY COIDIISSlOlItUS
KlANJ..JMDJt COOXl'Y, lLOJaDA
MEMORANDUM
Agenda Item No. 14(A)(2)
TO:
Honorable Chainnan Dennis C. Moss
and Members, Board of County Commissioners
DATE:
May 19,2009
FROM: R. A. Cuevas, Jr.
County Attorney
SUBJECf: Resolution directing the
County Mayor to negotiate an
Interlocal Agreement with
Collier County for the Joint
Development" Operation of
a 1,600 Recreation Area
Resolution No. R-622-09
The acc:ompanying resolution was prepared and placed on the agenda at the request of
Prime Sponsor Vic:e-Chainnan Jose "Pepe" Diaz.
~.~
County Attorney
RACljls
Page 1 of 6
Appendix V.D.5b.13
.
MEMORANDUM
(Revised)
TO:
Honorable Chainnan Dennis C. Moss DATE:
and Members, Board of County Commissioners
May 19, 2009
FROM:ms-?
County Att~
SUBJECT: Agenda Item No. 14(A) (2)
Please note any items checked.
L
-:-
"4-Day Rule" ("3-Day Rule" for committees) applicable if raised
6 weeks required between first reading and public hearing
4 weeks notification to municipal officials required.prior to public
hearing
Decreases revenues or increases expenditures without balancing budget
Budget required
Statement of fiscal impact required
Bid waiver requiring County Mayor's written recommendation
Ordinance creating a new board requires detailed County Manager's
report for public hearing
Housekeeping item (no policy decisi1n required)
No committee review
Page 2 of 6
Appendix V.D.5b.13
Approved
Veto
Override
Mayor
Agenda Item No. 14(A)(2)
5-19-09
RESOLUTION NO. R-622-09
RESOLUTION DIRECTING THE COUNTY MAYOR OR
MAYOR'S DESIGNEE TO NEGOTIATE ON BEHALF OF
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY AN INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT
WITH COLLIER COUNTY FOR THE JOINT DEVELOPMENT
AND OPERATION OF A 1,600-ACRE RECREATION AREA
WITIllN THE DADE-COLLIER TRAINING AND
TRANSITION AIRPORT TO SUPPORT A V ARlETY OF
RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES INCLUSIVE OF OFF-
HIGHWAY VEHICLE USE AND TRAILS, SUBJECT TO
BOARD APPROVAL; IDENTIFY THE REQUISITE FUNDING
FOR PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT AND APPLICABLE
APPROVALS; AND SUBMIT A WRIITEN REPORT TO THE
BOARD REGARDING THE STATIJS OF SUCH INTERLOCAL
AGREEMENT, FUNDING AND APPROVALS WITIllN ONE
HUNDRED AND TWENTY DAYS FROM THE EFFECTIVE
DATE OF THIS RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, Collier County and Miami-Dade County (the "Counties") each have
approximately 12,000 all-terrain vehicles and off-highway motorcycles ("OHVs'') registered
within their jurisdiction; and
WHEREAS, law enforcement agencies within each County have determined that the
lack oCa safe and legal location for members of the public to ride OHVs have caused a growing
number of severe accidents, losses of life, charges of trespassing, and wildfires that cause costly
damage to private lands and to federal, state and county natural and agricultural areas; and
WHEREAS, the Counties jointly seek to provide a convenient location where residents
can safely and legally ride OHVs; and
WHEREAS, the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department ("Parks
Department") utilized a State of Florida grant to evaluate safe and legal locations that could
properly support OHV use and the result of the evaluations was that the Dade-Collier Training
C:1WPlRESOIAJJJ.DOC
Page 3 of 6
Appendix V.D.5b.13
Agenda Item No. 14(A)(2)
Page No.2
and Transition Airport (the "Airport Site"), located at the 48-mile marker of U.S. Highway 41,
was the preferred site; and
WHEREAS, approximately twenty percent (20%) of the Airport Site is located within
the legal boundaries of Miami-Dade County and approximately eighty percent (80010) of the
Airport Site is located within the legal boundaries of Collier County and Miami-Dade County is
the sole owner of the entire Airport Site; and
WHEREAS, a Miami-Dade County Aviation Department ("Aviation Department")
study, dated April, 2009, recommended that a I ,600-acre portion of the 24,480-acres Airport Site
be transitioned to support a variety of outdoor recreation activities including, but not limited to,
camping, fishing, archery, wildlife viewing, and designated trails for hiking, biking, and OHVs;
and
WHEREAS, the Parks Department and the Aviation Department have executed a
Memorandum of Understanding, dated December, 2008, that establishes the basis for the use of
the 1 ,600-acre property and provides for the joint development of a portion of the Airport Site as
the Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area (the "Recreation Area''); and
WHEREAS, because this Recreation Area is equidistant between Miami-Dade County
and Collier County resident population areas, it could successfully provide a suitable place for
OHV riders and could provide a functional replacement for the 2005 closure of the 640-acre
Picayune Strand, which was previously used by Collier County OHV riders; and
WHEREAS, the transition of this Recreation Area from Aviation use to Recreation use
will insure the preservation and enhancement of the ecosystem, while simultaneously permitting
the authorized and safe use of certain non-sensitive areas in the Recreation Area by OHV riders;
and
C:\IfIP\RESO\A.j,j),DOC
Page 4 of 6
Appendix V.D.5b.13
Agenda Item No. 14(A)(2)
Page No.3
WHEREAS, Miami-Dade County has already initiated required land use amendments
from Collier County as a prerequisite to establishing the Recreation Area; and
WHEREAS, the Counties understand that additional funding is necessary to complete
development approval of the property, as well as the coordination of the extensive input of
national, state and county regulatory agencies with the variety of affected interest groups,
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA, that this Board:
Section 1.
Directs the County Mayor or Mayor's designee to negotiate an interlocal
agreement with Collier County for the development and operation of the Recreation Area to
support a variety of recreational activities, including OHV use and trails, within the Airport Site,
subject Board approval.
SeetiOD 2.
Directs the County Mayor or the Mayor's Designee to: (a) work with
officials from Collier County to jointly identify funding for the project and the applicable
planning and development approvals necessary for the development of the Recreation Area; and
(b) submit a written report to the Board within one hundred and twenty (120) days from the
effective date of this resolution regarding the status of the interlocal agreement between the
Counties and the identification of necessary funding and applicable approvals for the project
C;\WPI.RE$O\,UJ1.DOC
Page 5 of 6
Appendix V.D.5b.13
Resolution No. R-622-09
Agenda Item No. 14(A)(2)
Page No.4
The Prime Sponsor of the foregoing resolution is Vice-Chairman Jose "Pepe" Diaz. It
was offered by Commissioner Jose "Pepe" Diaz
, who moved its adoption. The motion
was seconded by Commissioner SeD. Javier D. Souto
and upon being put to a vote, the
vote was as follows:
Bruno A. Barreiro
Carlos A. Gimenez
BarbaraJ. Jordan
Dorrin D. Rolle
Katy Sorenson
Sen. Javier D. Souto
Dennis C. Moss, Chairman aye
Jose "Pepe" Diaz, Vice-Chairman aye
aye Audrey M. Edmonson
aye Sally A. Heyman
aye Joe A. Martinez
aye Natacha Seijas
aye Rebeca Sosa
aye
aye
aye
aye
absent
aye
The Chairperson thereupon declared the resolution duly passed and adopted this 19th day
of May, 2009. This resolution shall become effective ten (10) days after the date of its adoption
unless vetoed by the Mayor, and if vetoed, shall become effective only upon an override by this
Board.
MIAMI.DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY ITS BOARD OF
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
HARVEY RUVIN, CLERK
By: DIANE COLLINS
Deputy Clerk
Approved by County Attorney as /11 f tf
to form and legal sufficiency. /" /!!It- ~
Martin W. Sybblis
C;lWPlJlf.SOlAJJJ,DQC
Page 6 of 6
Appendix V.D.5b.13
APPENDIX V.D.5b.14
COLLIER COUNTY RESOLUTION
I '
Appendix V.D.5b.14
RESOLUTION NO. 09- 1 44
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUmR COUNTY BOARD OF
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DIRECTING THE COUNTY
MANAGER OR DESIGNEE TO SUPPORT ESTABLISHMENT
OF A 1,600-ACRE RECREATIONAL AREA Wl1lIIN THE
DADE-COLLIER TRAINING AND lRANSITION AIRPORT
TIfAT WOUlD SUPPORT A VARIE1Y OF RECREATIONAL
ACTIVITIES INCLUSIVE OF OFF-ffiGHWAY VEmCLE
(OllY) USE AND TRAILS.
WHEREAS, Collier County and Miami-Dade County (!be "Countiesj each have
approximately 12,000 all-terrain vehicles and off-highway motorcycles mgistmed within their
jurisdiction; and
WHEREAS, law enfon:ement agencies within each County have determined that a growing
number of severe acciden1s and Joss of 1ife, charges of trespassing, and wildfirea that cause
costly damage to private lands and federal, state and county naturaJ and agricultural areas, are
caused by !be lack of a sa1e and legal location fur members of the public to ride; and
WHEREAS, the Counties seek to provide a convenient location where residents can safely
and legally ride oO:highway vehicles ("OHVsj; BOd
WHEREAS, Miami-Dade County Puk and Recreation Dep6lbu.mt utilized a State of
Florida gnnt to evaIuatc safe and legal1ocations that could 1'1V~ support OHV use, with a
prefia........ fur the Dede-Collier Training and Transition AiJport, localed at the 48-mile marlcer of
U.S. Highway 41; and
WHEREAS, a Miami-Dede County Aviation Department study, dated April 2009, later
recommended that a 1,600-_ portion of the 24,48O-acres Airport be transitioned to support a
variety of outdoor recreatioD activities including, but not limited to, camping, fishing, archery,
wildlife viewing, and IlMir- tmiIs for biking, biking, and OHV s; and
WHEREAS, Miami-Dede County Puk and Recreation Department and Miami-Dade County
Aviation Departmeot have executed a Memorandum of Understanding, dated December 2008,
that eslablisbes the basis for the use of the 1,600_ p,~ and provides for the development
of the Dade-CoDier Cypress Recreation Area (the "Re=ation Area''); and
WHEREAS, since this Recreation Area is equidistant between Miami-Dade County and
Collier County RlSident population areas, it could successfully provicle a suitable place for OHV
Page 1 of 2
Appendix VD.5b.14
Poac ] of2
riders, and could provide a functional repJacement for the 2005 closure of the Picayune Strand,
which was previously used by Collier County OHV riders; and
WHEREAS, the 1ransition of this Recreation Area from Aviation to RccTeation use will
ensure the preservation and enhancement of the ecosystem, while simullaDeously pcnnit the
authorized and safe use of certain D01HCIIsitive areas by OHV riders; and
WHEREAS, Miami-Dade County, as OWDC!' of the Recreation Area wholly located within
Collier CoUDty, baa aJrcady initiated required land use amendments from Collier County. as a
prerequisite to cslabtiahiog the Rccn:atioo Area; and
WHEREAS, the Countica uodcrstand that it is necessary to complete development approval
of the property. and to coordiDatc the extensive input of national. state and county regulatory
agenciea with the variety ofalfected interest groups.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COUJER. COUNTY, FLORIDA, that this Board:
Section 1. Directa the County Manager or his Dcsigocc to support cstabliahment of a 1,600-
acre recreational _ lD support a variety of activities, including off-highway vehicle use and
trails. within the D8do-CoDier Training and Transition Airport.
Section 2. Directs the County Manager or Designee to jointly identify the applicable
plann;ng and development approvals _SRI)' fbr the devcloplDCllt of the R.ecleation Area.
Section 3. Directa the County Manager or Dcsigocc to assist with coordinating input from
the applicable regu1alDIy agencies.
This Resolution adopted this q~y orJ~ .2009, after motion, second and
maj~'~('t.?,
Afi'EST: ." -.: \
~~k By.
Sliftltiltt (>>,0";- ..'
ApprOVelII"lOfbrm and legal
~.~ ~rn~
Ilcco M. Gteene '
Assistant County AtlDmcy
Poac 2 on
Page 2 of 2
APPENDIX V.D.5b.t5
LETTERS OF SUPPORT
Appendix V.D.5b.15
M;:a.
""A"" INTERNAT,ONAL Ar~"O"T
Miami.Dade Aviation Department
P.O. Box 02.1.104
Miami, F1oridol13102.5504
T 30S-876-7000 I" 1D'l-87fJ-1)941l
wWIV.miJll1i-airport.com
rommercialAirporl:
miamidade.gov
M,llihk,n""on.,IA'I,,;r1
(;.n~'aIA,.i,'ionAi'p<>'t"
LJ.1oe_C"lli('rk,;ning,,'r,ln,,!,nn
11"'l'p""."i{"""',,,1
K<.'",k,'.I'~''''I..nlll",c,'''u
0)1)"-1",(,,-,
1.11).11,,,k,1\"<<.""
March 12. 2009
To Whom It May Concern
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
T. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Recreation Grant Program
407 South Calhoun Street - Mayo Building, Room SB-8
Tallahassee, FL 32399-0800
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Miami-Dade County's Aviation Department (MDAD) owns and operates the Dade.
Collier Training and Transition (TNT) Airport. TNT is comprised of over 24,000 acres
located north of U.S. Highway 41/Tamiami Trail. The operating airport consumes 8,000
acres and is surrounded by 16,000 acres of wetland marsh prairie, cypress tree islands,
and man-made lakes. MDAD was approached in 2007 by the Park and Recreation
Department (MDPR) to find a location for trails for off-highway vehicles (OHVs).
The Aviation Department is nearly finished with a study that is recommending the
highest and best uses for the 18,000 acres of property for revenue generation and
resource conservation. The Aviation Department is amenable to OHV recreation as a
potential activity in the approximate 1,450 acres of previously disturbed land south of
the airport. In 2009 MDAD and MDPR executed a Memorandum of Agreement, and
have since worked jointly on the planning and design of an OHV trail area south of the
airport.
Therefore, MDAD supports MDPR in their grant request for planning work that leads to
land use approvals and environmental permitting for OHV trails at TNT. This site
appears to have the potential to support a regional OHV recreation area that will attract
riders from allover South Florida.
~~iL---
Division Director, Real Estate Mgmt & Development
Everglades Coordinating Council
22951 SW 190 Ave.
Miami, FL 33170
October II, 2005
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
T. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Recreation Grant Program
407 South Calhoun Street - Mayo Building, Room SB-8
Tallahassee, 1"1 32399-0800
Re: Off-highway Recreation Site
To Whom It May Concern:
The Everglades Coordinating Council (ECC) delegates agree and support enthusiasti-
cally Miami Dade County Park and Recreation Department's request for funding from
1"1. Dept of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Div. of Forestry, for a study of potential
sites in Miami-Dade County for future location of an off-highway vehicle recreation site.
Yliami-Dade is in great need of a structured OHV area lor our citizens to enjoy as well
as others from outside our county. As vice president of the Everglades Coordinating
Council and speaking on behalf of our many organizational delegates, I am totally opti-
mistic and looking lorward to the positive effects a future OHV site will bring to Yli-
ami-Dade County and our fellow citizens. Organizing this "Active" style OHV use will
greatly assist in removing it from un-authorized areas that the activity sometimes oc-
curs Ill.
Being in an organization that advocates and supports everyone enjoying all of Florida's
rich outdoor recreational opportunities, we wholeheartedly endorse this pr~ject and
urge the powers that be to also lend their support.
If you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact me at 305-588-9910.
Sincerely,
Al bert Bryan
Vice President
Everglades Coordinating Council
Appendix VD.5b.15
Appendix V.D.5b.15
gJ1aztd' ~~ C?J'~
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY - FLORIDA
~ '1J1'"w" go"""
COMMISSIONER
DISTRICT 12
111 N. W. FIRST STREET
MIAMI, FLORIDA 33128-1963
(305) 375-4343
FAX (305) 372-6109
E-MAIL: JPdiClz@micmidode.gov
March 12, 2009
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
T. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Recreation Grant Program
407 South Calhoun Street - Mayo Building, Room SB-8
Tallahassee, FL 32399-0800
To Whom It May Concern:
I proudly support the Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department in their grant
request for funding for planning work that leads to land use approvals and environmental
permits for off-highway vehicle trails at the Dade-Collier Training and Transition (TNT)
Airport. Miami has a great need for off-highway vehicle recreational trails and riding areas.
I have been approached by mothers and fathers who want a safe place for their children to ride
ATVs and dirt bikes. There have simply been too many people injured in OHV accidents.
along roadways in the county, and we are working toward a solution to the problem.
I am working closely with my colleague, Honorable Jim Colletta, Collier County
Commissioner to coordinate of planning and design of OHV trails at TNT that will benefit
residents of both counties. Due to the importance of this project, I brought Collier and Miami-
Dade COImty administrators and environmental regulatory agencies together and discussed the
need to expedite this project. Our agency partners in this project include Big Cypress National
Preserve, South Florida Water Management District, US Army Corps of Engineers, US Fish
and Wildlife Service, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, just to name a
few.
Again, I extend my support to Park and Recreation in their grant request for planning work
that leads to land use approvals and environmental permitting for OHV trails at TNT. This
site can provide a safe place for children and adults to ride ATVs and dirt bikes, with
designated trails and a family-oriented atmosphere. I underscore the importance of a regional
OHV trail area for residents of South Florida, and urge the Committee to support this grant
request.
DISTRICT OFFICE. 8345 N.W. 12TH STREET. MIAMI, FLORIDA 33126 . (305) 599.1200 . FAX (3051470-1791
,
Appendix V.D.5b.15
COLLIER COUNTY
OFFICE OF THE COUNTY MANAGER
3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples. Florida 34112' (239) 252-8383' FAX: (239) 252-4010
March 12, 2009
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services
T. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Recreation Grant Program
407 South Calhoun Street - Mayo Building, Room S8-8
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0800
To Whom It May Concern:
Please consider this letter of support for Miami Dade County Park and Recreation on their grant
application for the T. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Recreation Grant Program. This
application will provide necessary funding for planning work that leads to land use approvals
and environmental permits for off-highway vehicle trails at the Dade-Collier Training and
Transition (TNT) Airport located in Dade and Coiller Counties. Currently, there Is no public land
available for OHV trails, or all-terrain vehicle use within Miami-Dade County and in Collier
County. Land available for such use is not readily accessible due to the cost of land; difficulty in
finding land that is not considered environmentally sensitive and some lands require special
permitting.
At the request of Collier County Commissioner Jim Coletta, Miami-Dade County Aviation and
Park and Recreation staff made a presentation to the Board on the proposed use of OHV trails at
TNT. Collier County Commission directed staff to continue to work with Miami-Dade in
planning, design, and permitting of OHV facilities. The next step is to apply for land use approval
for the site. Supporting the request of Miami Dade County Park and Recreation will allow them
to continue work toward developing OHV trails at the TNT site for use by both counties'
residents.
Again, I extend my support to Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation in their grant request for
planning work that leads to land use approvals and environmental permitting for OHV trails at
TNT. This site can provide a safe place for children and adults to ride ATVs and dirt-bikes, with
designated trails and a family-oriented atmosphere. I underscore the Importance of a regional
OHV trail area for residents of South Florida, and urge the Committee to support this grant
request.
Sin/. '
<~.~~r
Collier County Government
~CreAtlng a Positive Future for Off-Highway Vehicle Re"earlon"
October 17, 2005
fouche(cj)miamidade.qov
The National Off-Highway Vehicle Conservation Council (NOHVCC) is a publicly
supported, non-profit, education foundation organized for the purpose of promoting
safe, responsible, family-oriented off-highway recreational experiences. We are a forum
for organizations and supporters of OHV recreation, including enthusiasts, clubs,
associations, OHV manufacturers, aftermarket suppliers, OHV dealers, and affiliated
foundations, to become partners in creating a positive future for the sport.
NOHVCC supports the development of OHV recreation parks and riding areas that are
designed, constructed, operated and maintained in accordance with the guidelines
contained in the OHV Park manual written by George Fogg. Copies of this document
can be ordered from our Wisconsin office.
NOHVCC recognizes the need for public OHV recreation opportunities in southeast
Florida, and supports the development of a properly designed and managed OHV park
in Miami-Dade County.
If we can provide additional information or support, please contact us.
Sincerely,
Russ Ehnes
Executive Director
National Off-Highway Vehicle Conservation Council
4718 South Taylor Drive
Sheboygan. WI 53081
Phone: 800-348-6487/Fax: 920-458-3446/Email: Trailhead@nohvcc.orq
Appendix V.D.5b.15
FROM
(FRI)AUQ 28 2009 10:44/ST. 10:44/Ho.763~1845a1 P 2
Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Serviees
CHARLES H. BRONSON, Commissioner
The Capitol. Tallahassee, FL 32399-0800
www.doacs.state.f1.us
August 26,2009
Please Respond to:
Division offoreslty
Forest Management Bureau
3125 Conner Blvd. C25
TaUDhD'see, fL 3299-1650
Mr. Kevin Asher, AICP, Supervisor, Special Projects
Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2 Street, Ste. 542
Miami, FL 33128
Dear Mr. Asher,
I have read the Staff Report to the Collier County Environmental Advisory Council
dealing with Petition Number CP-2009-01
With reference to page 8 of the report, the section titled Consistency with the "T.
Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Safety and Recreation Act" I feel my long standing
involvement with Chapter 261, F.S. allows me credible input to this section of the report.
In Chapter 261.02, F.S. it states that "The Legislature finds that off-highway
vehicles are becoming increasingly popular in the state and that the use ofthese vehicles
should be controlled and managed to minimize negative effects on the environment,
wildlife habitats, native wildlife and native flora and fauna,"
The key words in this passage are controlled and managed. It goes without saying
that without some funnaJized control or management of OHV use on public lands that
there would be an inherent risk of negative impacts to the environment. It is for this
reason that the bill was drafted and supported by such non-profit organizations as The
Nature Conservancy to help safeguard environmentally sensitive areas through good
sound land management practices. It was the intent of this law to get a handle of
uncontrolled OHV use on public lands and provide outdoor recreation enthusiasts
opportunities to ride in areas properly planned and managed to minimize negative effects
on the environment.
I find Petition Number CP.2009-01 to be consistent with the intent of the T, Mark
Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle Safety and Recreation Act. The fact that Miami-Dade
County and Collier County l\l'e working together to resolve the problem of no legal riding
areas for the residents of south Florida fully compliments the intent of the law. This
petition helps to protect sensitive areas in south Florida by putting into effect 8 planned
OHV riding area that will have both control and management. Thus making sure that
-
~a.
Flol'ida Agricultul'c and Forcst Products
0,'1'" SI(KJ B ill ion for Flurid,,'. EI'OIlOI1l)'
FROM
(FRI)AUQ 28 2008 10:44/ST.10:44/No.7~3~1e4e81 P 3
Response to Staff Report
August 26, 2009
Page 2
both counties take into account all required permitting laws on local, state and federal
level. Again, the process follows the intent of the T. Mark Schmidt Off-Highway Vehicle
Safety and Recreation Act.
I wish the staff that developed this report would have contacted my office and
discussed this issue, as it pertains to Chapter 261, F.S.; I feel we could have come up with
a clearer interpretation of the law.
Please let me know if! can offer further assistance on this issue.
Sincerely,
CHARLES H. BRONSON
COMMISSIONER OF AGRICULTIJRE
~
John C. Waldron, CPRP
Forest Recreation Administrator
Florida Division of Forestry
Ijcw
08/31/09 MaN 16:04 FAX 305 4712638
POLl CE SERVI CES
~001
Miami-Dade Police
Department
Director's Office
An u..mmiuionall}'
Aa::l"edilcd
Policl!.SI:Mce
w ' August 31, 2009
e
C
a
r
e
Mr, Thomas Greenwood, AICP
Principal Planner
Collier County Comprehensive Planning Department
2800 North HorSeshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34101
Dear,Mr. Greenwood:
e
This lett~r is written in support of Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation
Department's land use application to allow use of off-highway vehicles (OHV) in a
designated 1,60O-acre area known as the Dad&-Collier Cypress Recreation Area,
In December 2008, Collier County Sheriff Kevin Rambosk, administrators from Collier
and Miami-Dade Counties, and myself met afthe site to discuss the transition of 1,600
acres at the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport'from aviation use to park ,and
recreation use. The discussion addressed the rising number of deaths and injuries
related to OHVaccidents, and the increasing damage done by'trespassing OHVs to
agricultural lands and environmentally sensitive lands. The potential of having a new,
large acreage property for the safe 'and legaJprovlsion of OHV trails for A 1Vs and
motorbikes, camping, fishing, hiking and archery Was presented. ,
w
P
r
o
I
e
c
t
e
, ,
Tllere was a consensus at this meeting that even thoUgll, the site .is iocated somewhat
distant from the urban' areas of Nap'les and Miami, law enforcement agencies from both
counties and the state would suppOrt opening a safe, cOunty-operatad 'recreation area
with OHV trails. Miilmi-Dade Police Department is very supportive of this application to
use the Dade-Collier Cypress' Recreation Area, and is interested in partriering with
other law enforcement agencies to deter OHVs from areas of current illegal activity,
educate the f?ublic, about the new riding area after it opens, and provide emergency
response to the site as needed. ' .
w
S
r
~e~iPL
e
v
e
,Robert Parker
Dire'etor
9105 NW 25 Street. Miami, Florida. 33172.1500
Telephone (305) 471-2100 . Fu (305) 471-2163 . -Website http://www,mdpd.com
S~ptc:mbcr 1. 1009
Thomas Greenwood. AleI'
Priuclpal Planner
('"Ih~r County ('omprehcllsi,'e Planning Oeparlllll'nl
:ROO ,",ol1h llor~$hoc Drive \laples. Florida ,4104
Oem \11 Greerlwooll
fhis leller is ",Tillen in >uppol1 of MiamI . Dade County Park and KCCtellll"n
J)cpaltlllenl's land use application '0 allow use of OIl'lhg.hway Vehie!.;, HHl\1 11\ ,I
designlltcd 1."00 acre arca known as rhe Dade, ('ollier Cypre,ss R~-.:;reati"n Area
In December 20llS, I met with Miami. Dade ('Qunry Police Oepanmem, Dlr~,\:[Qr Rob<;rt
Parkel, and olhel ollicials tlOlll Collier and MiamI' Dade C:oullli~'S at Ihe sil~ 10 dlscu,s
uansition of 1.600 acres at the Dade - ('oilier Training and Transition Airporl from
a,i3lion use 10 park and rcercarion use The discussion addre.~scd the rising number of
serious injunes and deaths related to OHV accidents. and the increa.~ing incidents of
ul.'Spa5sing. by a few OIlV opel/lIOr, on agticultural and cnvironmentally sensitive lands
lhe potential of llilVIng il new, large acreage property for the safe and legal provision of
OIlV trails for ATV~ and mOlorbikes. campin!?, tishinl!- hiking and archcrv wa.'
presented
lhcr~ was a COlI!>CnS\lS at this m~""ling that C\len though the ~ile is localed sumcwhat
distant from the urban are.1. of Naples and Miami. law enforcement agencies from both
counties and the sUlle would suppol1 opening a safe. county operated recreation area With
Oil\' nails. The CotlieI County ShesiO', Office is supponivc of this application 10 u,e
Ihc Dade, Collier Cypress Rl-'WClltinn Area. and rcmaiM interested in panncring with
other governmental agencies 10 ,,/fer a sale altemalive where OHV riders may pursue
their pastime The Collier County SheritT. Office likewise remains committed in c/fon.
to redirecl OILY riders from areas of currenllllegal actlvllY. educate the publi\: l100ut the
ncw riding area aO('"1 it opens. and provide eme,w"ncy response lO the site as needed
SinCe~rel.YI.'
/.
~:-~. ' ~
Kevi;,'\1 Ra osk. Shelll
('olli' Count"
.;t.
': j:',. ~ l' ;\'" I'! l' - ; J .; J '.1;" ,.
tI'
it
.);
".,
to.,' ':". -I..;;
. .T'''',>rc''[ r
A.
. .. .
.I(),"/
:: . .
DADE COUNTY FARM BUREAU
1850 Old Dixie Hwy., Homestead, FL 33033 . Tel. 305-246-5514 . Fax 305-245-9170
August 31, 2009
Mr. Kevin Asher
Supervisor, Special Projects
Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department
275 NW 2 Street, Suite 542
Miami, FL 33128
Dear Mr. Asher:
Thank you for meeting with representatives from the Dade County Farm Bureau to
discuss our organization's position on the proposed Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation
Area. The Dade County Farm Bureau endorses the concept of a shared recreational
resource between Miami-Dade and Collier counties that will provide residents with a safe
area to legally operate Off-Highway Vehicles (OHVs).
The environmental impacts posed by the unlawful use ofOHVs in Miami-Dade County
is particularly noticeable in the agricultura1 area outside the Urban Development
Boundary. Farm fields are routinely used by OHV riders who destroy valuable cash
crops. Environmentally sensitive areas are used for "mudding" especially during the
rainy season.
The fact of the matter is that there are approximately 24,000 OHVs registered in Miami-
Dade and Collier counties. The owners of these OHVs do not have a designated area to
safely and legally use their recreational vehicles. We believe that approval of Petition
Area CP-2009-0l should be granted so that the conceptual project can move closer to
realization.
s~~~
Larry Dunagan
President
t~~
Executive Director
Cc: Chairman Dennis Moss, Miami-Dade County
Vice Chairman Pepe Diaz, Miami-Dade County
,\1//
.:::.:::.
~.~
~
..
..
FLORIDA WilDLIFE FEDERATION
~N.""'--'<u~.""'--
'-I&nIeyK.F_.III._ F'flotIf. lMOl_1113
2~$IlIlI_",,*o.-.TaII_.Fl=1 F.. ~l942""3'
F'oIlOlbBao1l810.T.U._.fL3231(-c;e70 ...".,liI- _"'011I'I.",,",
_.!OWW,fWbIlltneorg
September I, 2009
James A. McCaD, CMS
Parle P1amet IT
Miami. Dade Cotm!y Pm: and RccrcaOOn
275 NW 2nd St, Suae 416
M;om( FL 33128
Re: Dade-Coh Cypress Recreation Area - Lett~ of SlIppOrtfor
Oltdoor Recreation Area
Dear James.
Per our discus5ions I lIlIl pl"0\iding youwilb thefolloM:ig comments wbichyou may iDcb:le in yoorreeocds or share wil:htbe Colier EACfoctbeir mediogofSeptc:mber 2nd.
The CoIIicr fAC w:iD. be rCYiewiDg the Dade Couoty jetport recreatiomll proposallmown as Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area. We have reviewed concerns elpfessed by Co1Iier Counly staff and have
discussed those with Dade Counly staff' aDd consultants. It seems 1hm there have been some mb-..L~~ 'Which we would lite to see clari6ed 1Jrougb the re\'iew process_ For example, Colier staff'idcated
opposition to bcnns aIoogsMie trais. Dade County staff indicated aD trais d be at grade and would not acrl'c:e with sheet flow. Dade Comly stmf micated the only bc:nm womd be associated with the parkiog and
"isilor center to address stormwalc- ruoof[ Colier County staff'iDdicated objections to the portjon of !be plan aDowmg off road vebides bm urged a set cI coodDoos be requRd if that aspect of the plan is uIImmdy
approved In diseussioos with the Dade CouotyproponeDls. there was a willingness to incorporalemmlY of Collier stsIfcoodilions. In fact. Dade CounIy iodicatedtbatmost cfthese points were BlreadyiDcorporatedimo
"".....
The Florida WidIife Federatioo would i1ce to see the rules govcmiog eft'road (A TV) vemdes be specified as rcqWremenl:s for tbs site. It is 0..- UDdcrstlmdiDg that tbcI-e wi! be limits O:D. the IlUIIlbers of vehicles,
restrictions to daytiDeU5e OD!y, JimitaIioos to DO more than 8 acresoftbe 1600 acre silefor ATVuse" dearmlldciDg ofbothYciag aodAT\! vebiaUr trais. tOD2lllle some of the proposed m1es. We beieveil: is cribcal tbzt
ATVs noIbe aBowed to leave the approved designated trails. Our noderstandingis that: as part ofthisplaa the cxistiog swamp buggytJais wiIDn the 1600 acre se wi! be eliminated or convef1edinlo hieing aDd A1V Ir.!ils
We mdeJstaDd!bat these est8b1isbed Irais wiD be maintained 'Rib Dative materials from historic distud>aces associated w.iIb the jetport constroction.
We Me pIeascd that 0VCf" 90 percent of the 1600 acre area wi! be maiotaiDed aDd managed as mWve babd:at. We must emphasize how cribcaI it is for the entire jetport site to be ac1ively lMIllIged using tools '5
prescribed fire and exotic p1aol md animal control The plan would elimiDate Imnliogfrom the 1600 acre sile. bciogcontinoed on the remlining 22.000 aae5 but we believe lhatooiozdverteol.restriclions sboWdbe
011 control of exotics 011 this site_ Both Couobes. the NPS. FWC, SF\VMD. etc. sbouId be activd:y involved in dforts to eradicllle or CODtrol nuisance exotic species across the IaDdscape FWF would like to see tba. _ "
lighting at the faciities for the jetport recreation area utilize dark sky dowzrward ~eded lighting.
We would like to follow this project as it moves through the Colier COWlty process and see thai: any future ATV ~ OIl the site are cardbly managed subject to estabJisbed rules. We wiD continue to mooiIor
this project tbrougbtbe process IIDdprovide commmts as needed. Thank youfortbe opportulIityto provide comments OIl bcb2dfofthe Florida Wildlife Federation.
Sincerely,
l'\~ F...u........
ManleyK. Fuller
"'-
Florida Wildlife Ferlermion
cc: NICk Wiley, Florida Fish & \ViJd1ife Conservation Commission
Nancy Payton. FWF Southwest Florida. Fidel Representative
FnmlcIin Adams, FWF District vn Board of Directors
.. Ihfl Florida "'i1d1ife FfUhratJon Isastatewide citiZflns cons.THiltion awltldur:ation orgtD'lizatul/'l ",'orlcingfor thM proNctloll, UVO>'11Hlm ami>'iis. IISI' ofF/QTida'sffS~".-I1d1if1l antiothl'l' I1Q/fJJ'afrIlSOUTCI'S. The Florida Wi/dJp
FetkTat/01I1'1ICouragl'S the pubJl&'s appNC/atlon ofF1oT/do's fmIo'ir01lJ1ll'1Jt througll nata//'IQok nlimD'CI'-1Hmfd OutdooT Trl&1'f#ltlon
APPENDIX V.E.la
POTABLE WATER
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
County Petition No. CP-2009-1
Appendix V.E.1a - Potable Water
Existing level ot Service Standard (lOSS):
The Collier County Growth Management Plan - Public Facilities Element [Potable
Water Sub-element) establishes the following Potable Water LOSS:
1. For the Collier County Water and Sewer District, the LOS is 185 GPCD [gallons
per capita per day)
2. For the Goodland Water District. the LOS is 163 GPCD.
3. For the City of Naples unincorporated service area, the LOS is 163 GPCD.
4. For the Everglades City unincorporated service area, the LOS is 163 GPCD.
5. For independent districts and private potable water systems, the LOS is the
sewage flow design standards as identified in Policy 1.3.1 of the Potable Water
Sub-Element of the GMP. except that approved private wells are exempt from
these LOS requirements.
Proposed Improvements:
The proposed Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area [The Project) contemplates
the following development characteristics:
a. New Visitor's Center Building [approximate 2200-2400 SF) to include,
Administrative area [small office room). Orientation area, Restrooms and
small meeting room [with media capability for training/orientation purposes)
b. New Parking Lot for 80 vehicles.
c. Camping: primitive and RV [but with minimal offerings - not for extended
stay/luxury RV camping)
d. Fishing: piers or docks.
e. Off-highway vehicle trails [at grade) for Off-Highway Vehicles [OHV) use.
f. Multi-use trails [for hikers and bikers)
g. Wildlife viewing opportunities (could be a platform or overlook, or simply a
cypress dome or tree island visible at a distance from trails)
h. Archery Range.
Review of the Collier County "10-Year Water Supply Facilities Work Plan". The
2008 Water Master Plan Update" and the "2008 Annual Update and Inventory
Report (AUIR) on Public Facilities" indicate that the proposed development is
well outside the existing and future Collier County Water Service Area as
depicted in Figure A-1 and will not impact the capacity of the existing public
water distribution/transmission and treatment system; thus exempt from the
above listed LOS requirements. Given the remoteness of the project site from
public water distribution/transmission facilities, potable water and site fire
protection for the new development may consist of onsite well[s) with approved
purification system(s) designed, permitted, constructed, monitored and
maintained in conformance with county/state health department standards, the
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 1 of 2
Appendix V.E.l a
National Fire Protection Association and South Florida Water Management
District [SFWMD) Water Use Permit[s) general and special conditions.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 2 of 2
Appendix V.E.l a
I"IL,> S,OS flGLPE 1- ~ 1:1 05iniOS 12:59 G--,
R 25 E
.
(')
~
t'"
'r<
.
c
Ccj
'~
trJ
'X,
-
r:
c
~
OOS 1
1"'\..""'_
SCALE IN MILES
LEGEND
'" EXISTING WATER
TREATMENT PLANT
~ PROPOSED WATER
t-- TREATMENT PLANT
AREA SERVED BY
COUNTY WATER
R 26 E
R 27 E
FIGURE 1-1
II
.
"
.
I
'!,l^' ",.",_P
-~:+.'~T_L
, +--I-j Ii" ."j. '
" I " . "i I" I "
OLlIE00Ury l_.___-1__. i __,_
.:.~ W~TRS~~ H"l,,_~ ,,1____J
" I , 1-::1" j, ,I. I
-+-=-+--.t--t- ~ --'
, "i' I " ! ' :' j
l~~~{A~
-J_J
, I
I
1
~L-__~
~
-
*
-
"
" i " I
:1:l
, I~>
--1-1
"I " I
l'--1
" ',\ I.
-e----
,
I
,
N
"
CITY OF NAPLES
AREA SERVED BY
CITY OF NAPLES
FGUA
SERVICE AREA
ORANGETREE
SERVICE AREA
GOLDEN GATE
ESTATES
~tSTTER~~STE:6~NDARY -
~
~
~ DISTRICT BOUNDARY - --
PRIOR TO 2003
MARCO ISLAND
WATER AND
SEWER DISTR CT
EXISTING AND FUTURE
WA TER SERVICE AREAS
. GREELEY AND HANSEN
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
PUBLIC UTILITIES DIVISION
2008 WATER MASTER PLAN UPDATE
24 JUNE 2008
APPENDIX V.E.lb
SANITARY SEWER
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
County Petition No. CP-2009-'
Appendix V.E.' b - Sanitarv Sewer
Existing level of Service Standard (lOSS):
The Collier County Growth Management Plan - Public Facilities Element (Sanitary
Sewer Sub-element) establishes the following LOSS:
a. The North Sewer Area is 145 GPCD.
b. The South Sewer Area is 100 GPCD.
c. The City of Naples unincorporated sewer service area is 121 GPCD.
d. Independent districts and private sanitary sewer systems is the sewage flow
design standards identified in Policy 1.2.1 of the Sanitary Sewer Sub-Element
of the GMP, as required by the State of Florida.
e. Approved private septic systems are exempt from these LOS requirements.
Proposed Improvements:
The new project contemplates the following development characteristics:
a. New Visitor's Center Building (approximate 2200-2400 SF) to include.
Administrative area (small office room), Orientation area, Restrooms and
small meeting room (with media capability for training/orientation purposes)
b. New Parking Lot for 80 vehicles.
c. Camping: primitive and RV (but with minimal offerings - not for extended
stay/luxury RV camping)
d. Fishing: piers or docks.
e. Off-highway vehicle trails (stabilized trails - at grade) for Off-Highway Vehicles
(OHV)
f. Multi-use trails (for hikers and bikers)
g. Wildlife viewing opportunities (could be a platform or overlook, or simply a
cypress dome or tree island visible at a distance from trails)
h. Archery Range
Review of the Collier County "2008 Annual Update and Inventory Report (AUIR)
on Public Facilities - County Sewer Treatment and Collection System" indicate
that the proposed Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area is located
approximately 43 miles from the existing and future Collier County Wastewater
Service Areas as depicted in Figure 8-' and will not impact the capacity of the
existing public wastewater collection/transmission/pumping and treatment
systems: thus exempt from the above listed LOS requirements. The sanitary sewer
system for the new development may consist of onsite septic tank/drainfield
system(s) strategically located within the proposed development and designed
per F.A.C. requirements. considering required setbacks from potable water
well(s) and environmentally sensitive (wetlands) areas.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page] of 1
Appendix V.E.] b
FIGuRE 1-1
'1
R ,5 E
R 2b E
--T
,
,'.;' J
,- "II'; l
C~ Of ;i
"'iAPL(S -:
...,_...
NORTrtEAST
SER-VlCE AREA
t
..,....J,
I'
..,..
.
"
-., ...
,..
.
-
"
I'
J~
,
:.....1'_
'.
.'
.
+
A~(A
NAPLES
WRF-----.
.
SOUTH j
-~ERVId:
i
~~EfI
"
('LI5 I J
~--
SCll,LE 11\1 M'L('S
LEGEND
OOSnNG WAtER
IIfECl......TION fACtllTI'_
~~~~:~..~~J:iRr"'ClllTY *
:;; Dl"ElI' *
tA[Ah,IENT PLANTS
CCWSD W...SnWATnl
S[R-Vlct UtA
"
ClTl' or N"PLES-
fGlJA
SERVICE AR[A
ORANGE1RH
SERVICE ARtA
GOl.OEN CATE
[5T...,.[S
WAl[A.S[WER
DISTA1CTBOVNO",RY-
~~"'ft::ll?[ETWrEN _ . _
AREAS
[:<;3
"
,
MARCo ISLAND
WATER AND
SEWER DISTRICT
EXISTING AND
WASTEWA TER
FUTURE
SERVICE
AREAS
WW-14
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
PUSUC UTILITIES DIViSION
2008 WASTEwATER AU1R
58
APPENDIX V.E.lc
TRAFFIC METHODOLOGY AND
TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY (TIS)
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................... 2
METHODOLOGY STATEMENT.. ....................................... ............... ........................................4
TRIP GEN ERA TION.......................................... ...................................................................... 5
TRIP GENERATION SITE USEAGE......................................................................................... 5
TRIP DISTRIBUTION AND ASSIGNMENT.............................................................................. 6
TRAFFIC COUNT DATA............................................. ............................................................. 8
BACKGROUND TRAFFIC GROWTH/FUTURE TRAFFIc................................................ ...........8
ANALYSIS SCENARIOS...................................................................................................... .....9
SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACTED ROAD SEGMENTS/INTERSECTIONS........................................ 9
SUMMARY OF RESULTS.......................................... ............................................................... 10
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE 1- TRIP GENERATION SUMMARY.............................................................................5
TABLE 2 - PROJECTED ATTENDANCE PATTERNS................................................................ 6
TABLE 3 - TRIP DISTRIBTUION BY COUNTY....................................................................... 7
TABLE 4 - GROWTH TREND FACTOR ................................................................................8
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE 1 - SITE LOCATION MAP......................................................................................... 2
FIGURE 2 - TRIP DISTRIBUTION REGIONAL PERCENTAGES.............................................. 7
FIGURE 3 - AM/PM PEAK HOUR TRAFFIC VOLUMES........................................................... 11
FIGURE 4 - FDOT 2008 MDT DATA..................................................................................... 12
FIGURE 5 _ FDOT HISTORICAL MDT DATA (DADE COUNTY SITES)................................. 13
FIGURE 6 - FDOT HISTORICAL MDT DATA (COLLIER COUNTY SITES)............................ 14
FIGURE 7 - GROWTH RATE CALCULATIONS (1)..................................................................15
FIGURE 8 - GROWTH RATE CALCULATIONS (2)..................................................................16
FIGURE 9 - COLLIER COUNTY 2008 AUIR TABLE 1.............................................................17
FIGURE 10 - COLLIER COUNTY 2008 AUIR TABLE 2...........................................................18
FIGURE 11 - COLLIER COUNTY 2008 AUIR TABLE 3/GROWTH RATE CALCULATIONS (3) 19
FIGURE 12 - TIS ADDENDA DATED MARCH 29, 2009........................................................ 20
'\
)
')
Appendix V.E.l c
1 of 24
~
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
INTRODUCTION
Milian, Swain & Associates, Inc. (MSA) retained Miller Legg to perform a Traffic Impact Study
(TIS), on behalf of Miami-Dade County Park and Recreation Department, for the Plan
Amendment (Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Map) Petition CP-2009-1 for the
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area in Collier County, Florida. The proposed Growth
Management Plan Amendment application provides for a new Future Land Use District. This
Traffic Impact Study (TIS) has been prepared in accordance with the current edition of the
Collier County Transportation Planning Department's TIS Guidelines and Procedures.
Existino Conditions
The Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area District encompasses approximately 1,608 acres of
land located within Sections 13, 14, 15, and 16 of Township 53 South, Range 34 East, adjoining
the Miami-Dade/Collier County line north of U.S. Highway 41 and south of the runway of the
Dade-Collier Transition and Training Airport, and within the Big Cypress Area of Critical State
Concern (ACSC). All lands within this District are entirely owned by Miami-Dade County and
includes wetlands, cypress and hardwood forests, and five man-made lakes. Please see the
project site in Figure 1.
Figure 1 - Site Location Map
Appendix V.E.1 c
2 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County. FL
Prooosed Conditions
The proposed site is located on the Dade-Collier County border. Access to the proposed site
will share the existing service driveway for the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport. The
project entrance, site area, and adjacent roadways are shown in Figure 1. Tamiami Trail is a
two lane undivided roadway connecting Miami to Naples, and continuing north to Tampa/St.
Petersburg. The closest intersection to the project site is State Road 29, approximately twenty-
eight miles to the west. State Road 29 continues north to 1-75.
The primary purpose of this District is to provide an appropriate level of recreational uses
beneficial to the County and the region while retaining the existing natural resources.
Dade Collier CVoress Recreation Area Comorehensive Plan Amendment (Petition CP-2009-1)
The uses allowed within this District, with limitations specific to this District, are as follows:
1. Visitors' center building - for administrative offices, orientation area, meeting room,
and restrooms - not to exceed 2,400 square feet;
2. Parking lot limited to a capacity of 80 passenger vehicles and associated trailers;
3. Primitive Camping;
4. Recreational vehicle camping;
5. Fishing piers and docks;
6. Multi-use trails for pedestrians and bicycles;
7. Wildlife viewing platforms and overlooks;
8. Archery range;
9. Off highway vehicles (OHV) trails; and
10. Other uses as allowed in the Conservation Designation.
The primary purpose of the TIS is to quantify the potential impacts, ensure compliance with the
transportation concurrency requirements consistent with the plan and identify site related
operational deficiencies that impact the health, safety and welfare of the traveling public.
Appendix V.E.l c
3 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
METHODOLOGY STATEMENT
The TIS has been prepared based on the methodology statement dated March 27, 2009 as
amended per comment by Collier County on April 14, 2009. As requested in the May 5, 2009
sufficiency review letter for Petition CP-2009-1, the TIS has been prepared and is based on the
following information, rules and criteria:
o The TIS has been prepared by a transportation professional with training and experience
in traffic analysis and transportation planning. Please reference detailed experience of
the transportation professionals in Appendix LD.1.
o The TIS will be prepared as a Minor Study which is defined as a site with "no significant
operational impacts with minimal roadway impacts and work within the County right-of-
way'~
o New traffic data collection was not collected. Traffic data was taken and used from the
2008 Annual Update and Inventory Report (AUIR).
o Trip Generation was calculated per ITE Trip Generation Handbook, 8th Edition, Land Use
Code 417, Regional Park. The trips were calculated based on the acres of park that plan
to be deveioped. The acreage was determined based on The Big Cypress Area of
Critical State Concern (ACSC) Overlay. The ACSC requires that a site alteration shall be
limited to 10% of the total site size.
o Trip Distribution and Assignment was calculated based on the OHV title data from the
Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles for Broward County, Miami-
Dade County, Collier County, Hendry County and Lee County.
o The Growth Rates were calculated using the actual linear historical growth rate for
impacted segments or minimum of 2% linear rate whichever was greater.
o Internal and pass by capture trips have not been incorporated into the analysis, the land
use being proposed is not conducive to internal or pass by capture and due to the site
location.
o Level of Service Standards for all major road segments shall be consistent with the letter
standards shall be consistent per the County's latest Adopted concurrency tables in the
Annual Update and Inventory
Appendix V.E.l c
4 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
TRIP GENERATION
The trips generated from/to the site have been estimated using the latest Institute of
Transportation Engineers (ITE) Trip Generation, the 8th Edition. The ITE land use code 417,
Regional Park was used as indicated in the methodology statement previously submitted.
Please see the trip generation calculations in Table 1. It should be noted that ITE land use
code 416, Campground/Recreational Vehicle Park, has elements of some of the land uses being
proposed on this site, but the trip generation data from the ITE Trip Generation, 8th Edition only
has one independent variable from one observation based on site acreage. Site acreage is the
predominant variable being used to calculate the Average Vehicle Trip Ends since Occupied
Camp Sites have not been defined on a conceptual site plan.
Regional Park
The total project site generated trips of 24 in the AM peak hour and 32 in the PM peak hour are
below the threshold of a minor study. The site has been operational in the last twelve (12)
months but the existing trips generated to and from the existing site are minimal. Therefore
vested trips and net trips from the existing use are considered negligible for this study.
TRIP GENERATION (SITE USAGE)
The site trips generated in Table 1 are a conservative representation of the traffic flow to and
from this site. The existing and proposed use and intensity have been analyzed and
summarized in Appendix V.D.5.B of the Growth Management Application for the Comprehensive
Plan Amendment. In addition to the proposed use and intensity analysis, a review of the
seasonality and anticipated attendance patterns are included as Table 2. This further supports
that the number of peak users will be small and variable due to the fact that not all uses will be
used year round.
Appendix V.E.l c
5 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SPT OCT NOV DEe
Pro.ected Peak Attend. Season X X X X X X
Pro.ected Low Attend. Season X X X X
Projected Lowest Attend. Season
Lar el Closed X X
Peak Season Weekda s -% of Mo. total 25
Peak Season Weekends -% of Mo. total 75
Low Season Weekda s -% of Mo. total SO SO
Low Season Weekends- % of Mo. total SO 50
75
25
TRIP DISTRIBUTION AND ASSIGNMENT
The site trips generated in Table 1 have been distributed and assigned to the roadway network
based on the OHV title data from the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles
for Broward County, Miami-Dade County and Collier County. Users may also come from Hendry
County, Lee County and potentially St. Lucie County, but for calculation purposes the three
Counties of Broward, Miami-Dade and Collier have been used in the trip distribution and
assignment of the site trips. The method for determining the trip distribution and assignment
was outlined in the approved methodology statement that was reviewed and approved by
Collier County. For this specific use and due to the site location, the most current version of the
Collier County Model was not used. The trip distribution percentages have been shown
graphically in Figure 2, and summarized in Table 3, per the Collier County TIS guidelines.
Appendix V.E.l c
6 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
Figure 2 - Trip Distribution Regional Percentages
Hend 50% 1625 813 20/0
Lee 25% 9100 2275 6%
Collier ## 100% 12 500 12 500 33%
Broward 75% 12 543 9407 25%
Miami-Dade 100% 12 842 12 842 34%
Total: 37 837 100%
** Title Transactions taken from the County Title Activity 06/30/02-12/31/08 document provided by the Florida
Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. The Title Transactions are for Off Highway Vehicles by Residence
County.
## Title Transactions for Collier County adjusted higher per discussions with the Collier County Comprehensive Planning
Department
TRAFFIC COUNT DATA
All traffic data used for the TIS was taken from the 2008 Collier County Annual Update and
Inventory Report (AUIR), as included in Figures 9 and 10. Due to the location of the site,
manual turning movement counts (MTMC's) and daily directional machine counts for
significantly impacted road segments were not requested to be collected for the signalized
intersections. The TIS used the following Collier County Count Station Data:
Appendix V.E.l c
7 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County. FL
)> Count Station 97- US 41 (East Tamiami Trail) from SR 29 to Dade County Line
)> Count Station 96- US 41 (East Tamiami Trail) from San Marco Drive to SR 29
)> Count Station 80- SR 29 from US 41 to CR 837
BACKGROUND TRAFFIC GROWTH/FUTURE TRAFFIC
The traffic data used from the 2008 Collier County Annual Update and Inventory Report (AUIR,
Figures 9 and 10) was increased by a growth trend factor (GTF). The 2008 FDOT MDT Traffic
Count Tables (Figure 4), the FDOT Historical MDT Reports (Figures 5 and 6) published by the
FDOT Transportation Statistics Office and the Collier County published AUIR Tables from prior
years 2002 through 2008 were referenced in determining the linear growth rate. The
committed trips were also included as part of the existing peak directional volumes as shown in
the AUIR as trip bank or vested development trips.
As mentioned, the FDOT Historical MDT Report data was used to determine the linear growth
rate (trend rate) so that the future build-out traffic could be established. Data from each of the
nearby monitoring sites located within the study area was fitted with a linear regression to
determine the annual trend growth rate from 2008 to the projects design build-out year of 2016
(estimated). As mentioned, the back-up documentation of the average annual growth rate are
included as Figures within this report. Due to the relatively flat linear growth rate using the
FDOT Historical Data and Collier County published AUIR Tables, a conservative estimate of
2.0% growth per year was assumed as requested by Collier County. The GTF for the project
trips at the site access driveway is calculated in Table 4 below, using the equation GTF = [1 +
(Annual Growth Trend Rate/100)] ^ N, where N = number of years from date of traffic count to
2016.
US 41 E. Tamiami Trail from SR 29 to Dade Cnt Line 2008
US 41 E. Tamiami Trail from San Marco Drive to SR 29 2008
SR 29 from US 41to CR 837 2008 8 2%
*Minimum, annual growth rates in all cases shall be two percent (2%) unless otherwise approved by Collier COunty.
Appendix V.E.1 c
8 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
ANALYSIS SCENARIOS
The traffic analysis for the TIS will be limited to the following analysis scenarios as outlined in
Table 9.1 of the Collier County Transportation Planning Department's TIS Guidelines and
Procedures: Scenario 1- Existing + project trips (2008); Scenario 2- Future-6 year build-out
horizon, linear per growth rate (2016). The analysis included committed/vested trips on the
roadway network based on the absence of approved but un-built surrounding developments.
SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACTED ROADWAY SEGMENTS/INTERSECTIONS
The proposed project highest peak hour trip generation based on the peak hour of the adjacent
street traffic determines the limits of the trip distribution ilnd analysis per the TIS Guidelines.
The trips distributed on links directly accessed by the project where the project traffic by
direction is equal to or exceeds 2% of the peak hour service volume for the adopted LOS
standard.
For this plan amendment application/petition, the proposed project highest peak hour trip
generation by direction (11 trips) based on the peak hour (PM) divided by the peak hour service
volume (875 vehicles) provides the level of significance. This significance test for scenario 1 is
for the project trips leaving the site, making a left and heading east on East Tamiami Trail/US
41 toward Miami-Dade County. The significance percentage for scenario 1 is 1.26%.
The significance test for scenario 2 is for the project trips with background traffic (at the build-
out year horizon) for the project trips leaving the site, making a left (11 trips) and heading east
on East Tamiami Trail/US 41 towards Dade County. The significance percentage for scenario 2
is 1.26%. Please reference Figure 3 which graphically displays this volume information.
The significance percentage for both scenarios per current traffic analysis is below the 2%
threshold that would have required analysis of the next directly accessed link/segment (SR 29).
There also are no signalized (major) intersections within 1,320 feet of the site access on the
directly accessed link segment, East Tamiami Trail/US 41.
Left and Right Turn Lane Warrants as outlined in the Collier County Transportation Plannin9
Department's TIS Guidelines and Procedures were reviewed as well. The results of these
warrants are shown below:
Appendix V.E.l c
9 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
~ Right Turn Lane Volume Threshold = 40 or more peak hour right turn trips into the
project site ingress/egress
~ Left Turn Lane Volume Threshold = 20 or more peak hour left turn trips into the project
site ingress/egress
As displayed graphically on the exhibit in Figure 3, the build-out peak hour right turns into the
site ingress/egress are 10 vehicles. Similarly the build-out peak hour left turns in to the site
ingress/egress is 7 vehicles. Peak event operational analysis (i.e. peak hour of generator,
weekend rates) is not required by the GMP Amendment review process at this time, but will be
applicable at the time of Deveiopment Order (i.e. SDP) application or deferred to other
appropriate application phase. Turn lane improvements may be required at that time.
SUMMARY OF RESULTS
The results of the TIS for this project site are that the review shows that the proposed site
should be classified as a Small Scale Study which is defined as "No significant operational or
roadway impacts': The criteria outlined in the TIS Guidelines for a Small Scaie Study is as
follows:
~ The project generates less than 50 net new total 2-way AM and less than 50 net
new total 2-way PM peak hour trips, and (CONFIRMED)
~ The access point to the adjacent roadway network does not require modification
inside the Right-Of-Way above a standard driveway connection. (No turn lanes
or median modifications), and (CONFIRMED)
~ The project is a stand alone project and not part of a larger development, and
(CONFIRMED)
~ If the project uses a shared access point, the addition of the project traffic does
not trigger any operational deficiencies or additional work within the right-of-
way. (CONFIRMED)
Therefore a letter from Miami Dade County has not been submitted as part of the TIS
acknowledging impacts on US-41 since the peak hour directional project trip volumes are not
over 2% (directionally) in Collier County.
Appendix V.E.l c
10 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County. FL
--'-
148.2IJD'
'1.530'
131.5911'
:bl..8t.lW ~
~
t:
t
~ I
G _
II! ~
~ i
___244 {2O'J)
2CID(.344l-
!l
~
.,
~
l!
~
~
~
.
iii t
.-
- !
!'
t !!!
___1204 {'UIO)
1N15(12CJ4}_
-
,
.
(t} ~
~
N.T.5.
~
.
~
.
II
2.7.7 WILES
3.1! WILES LLJ
5
~
G
~
~
;0
.
;0
~ ~
oc 0
)1.... LOIe)
---z<< tzJ};Il
J E, TA..I.....I TRAIL
o(Dl~
2D"J (244}____
.
,
filftUl:'lI"!aNtlr lPI';T
((f"RP"IEQ'T 1FI1P5)1tRQ.LDWAY !iER\II~ WWr.E))..OO
[l" TIIPl!i)/(l!I1D lRIP5JJ"DC1 - un
l.EllEIlll
.. PE:otK HOOlE llIRECllCNAl..
\U..UIIIIES TAa;n FR[JIII AUtR
n'lI;nlll!! ~1Im1 ....TH R;ln...m 'M5"r1t!
J::~ ():~
\:'.~
'lllU'RCI\'II..IMES
g,~
1Jb!iF'FlC:\IlUAIIE8 ill
~
~
~
~ t
~;1
t ~
___1411 ("!!04}
115+(1411)_
~
~
.
~
o
148"lI:Itf
27_" IIllLi9 ~
.
~
.
E; I
~
.
11l1,tL]L1
1J1,.5&D'
klilhlLD !!l!
.
llr..J!IlIILE!!l: LLJ
5
~
~
i!j
<
G
~
t:
I
i!
e
Iii
~ i
_:2I!o{2:!!1)
2J5(.211C1)---
~
'"
"
f:'~ ~
.. -
)1.... L'lll)
_n8tll1J)
I E. TAWIAWI TVJL
'(ll~
!a!I~2I!I&)_
,
,
~
,
~
.Il;U~f.lNt:r 1R;T
((I"RO.ECT 1RfP'SllllmADl/A'r' !iE1l1.ol[s: 'IItlWI€))'"11JiJ ~
([11 TIlIPS)/(ljErTRIPSJ]It1~-1._ :lI:
PlZ!P1"JI;I:l'I 'JIW'11I::; IUTH PAn I'l"!'T '1IlI5'I'lt!
ClIIl"llnlIiI -"1I1l:
=
....-
MILLE~EGG
-"=C.LIIIJI!..~-.
.....-........
-
DADs.cowER CVPIES RECREA1KII AREA~,.;..,-:::::....
DDUJ"CUIIITI;,~ 7.lWF1C '.G:.IH"!I
...=-...... ilia!!': 1ClaUfIY...................amrr.
--
ClI(11/01
Figure 3 - AM/PM Peak Hour Traffic Volumes
Appendix V.E.l c
11 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County. FL
COUJlT\', 03
COl.oLUR
P'LOIl.:roA DU'.u.num OF 'tRANSPOJ.TA1'tON
2008 AIlN01<L AvnNlR !lAILY 't'IlAFI'H~ UPOllT . IlBPOR'! TYPE, ALL
II.AIn "K" OEMAIlD'D" Di:MAIfD"I'"
DDlBCI'IOJI" 1 tlJUCTlai' 2 TWC-KA'Y FCTIt DOG PCTl!. DIDO 1Tn.
0001
,,~
!lITH TYPE DESCRIPTION
."",~"","........._.........._____...._.._______...___..__n.n
Sit 29, NORm 01' Cll l!lo/lA" TKAl'PORD ROAD CCli
0002
00(1)
000'>
0006
O~ll
(1012
0014
001S
0017
0018
0022
(lO:!3
0024
0029
(Ion
003S
one
O(lH T
0104
0111
(lIB
0124
DIn T
0157
QUO
0110
01B
0175
0.71i
0177
0178
SITE TYPIC
AADT FLAGS
"KID' P'u.<:os
"T"I'LiWS
Slt 29. SOI]'l1{BAST OP elt 'fi/UTH llTI!Bn' N
Sk 45/U5 U, SO'[lTIl 0' ell 8U/P1"NB RlDGlll IlD ~
se !lOltls U, blOllTllMB8T OF C'R 92 CCS
8lt2\l,~TOFSR'O/USt1
CCHS III
us U. 200 l"l', &!>.STOFCR_Il'
SIt 45/US U IIOItTR or 0/. "", PWJ!, ItlDGIC &0 = S
SJt !la/us 41. NORTHllBBT OP' SR 951 CO It
$Jt ,altls U Sit 01' CR 864/RA'lTLBStu>.KB HAl9lOCK CC5
BRUNS 11, SOVI'HOPCR8o>J.!VMBl/:Jl.OlltO CC:SU s
Slt4SrusU, N OF CR8'6/tMfl1OULEE RD{111T1l AV C'C56 5
MOll.TiI RD, FROM TERMINAL DRIVE TO CIl. H C~6!2 M
Clt H/AIRP<JR'I' ROAD, S OF CR SBS/OOAn PIOlY C1:53 M
CIl. H/AIlU'OR't RD, S OF CR U6/fINB RIDGiI lW 0::: M
SR 29, W&ST OP CR 8U/IST ilTRDT iX"U" If
Illl 29, SOlJ'IH OIl'SR nil'S COLLIB:R COlM N
pnm RIDGE RO/OU6, II OF GlXlDLJI:I"18 FRANlt RD/CR9 W
SR29/1STH ST N, S OF CRUO/t.M:E TIlAFFORO RD CC' l>1
SR-90/I1S-41" ~ J(I SIl OF elUl/AIRpOR'!' RD,CO!.t,IBR
sa to/U!; 41, !liS'!' OF sa.t
SII: 90/US .1, lollS'!' OF Sit 29
CCU6
CCU'
BR90/usn III OF CR851/aOOOLS'M'B (WOP 12T11 BTf NP
SR 90IUS "1, SOU'l'BltUT 011" CR a51/ooOO1.iTTl: RD Ill' If
sa a,o,. 1ol1l,l 01' llR-1.2.I*OUJ..E!.COLLIl!.Il CO.
SR nl, SOU'l'H OF SR 90/US 41
FlNE RIDG1!: RD, R OF CR 3l/AIIlPORT RD
eeas,
1iIH:!i CC Ii:
sa 81. SotrrHWU'J"OIl"Cll 856
SR91/I7S,ltUrOrSll.,U
C1:S60
COu..ll!.llcotlJl'tl' lor
CR ll/l>.lRPORT ROAD, )I OF sa 8t/DAV:Jll BLVD cess N
SR 81, EM'!' or ell. n/AIRPQRT ROAD eel 11
Cll. H/AUP<lll'l' !lOA!), 5 OP SR 04/DAVIS BLVD ce55 N
sa U. J/U'l' or CR ll/AlRPORT RQAD
~, ,
M 5200
3500 S
2'000 N
1900 If
900 oS
,
1100 W
HOD
10500C
10.28F 9.73
24000 N
13000 W
19000 If
23500 II
29500 N
900 W
22000
18000
UOO X
100 S
20500 If
7000
.089. "
,
1300 'II
60.UT 5212
10..5A
HOO 74110l' 1n 2811" 9_13 60,861"5.8. 11 ,......
.5500 5.500l' 10 B3F10.50 S6..U'5J 82 2.6SP
1900 noo C 11 1.1' 1lLUo SILUP 5282 1055....
,,,
UI>OC 11121' 10.65 5".UF52 12
,..
,
lUO W
1100
2200 C 12 2S11" 11.73 52.flF SJ B. U UA
.
18500 W
2'000 W
6tU
151100
23000
22500 '651>0l' 111831"10.50 56.26r5..92 ..9M
34000 .701>0 l' 10 83F 10.50 S6,26F 52,0. 4.aA
185(10 3751>0 C 10.831" 10_50 56.21P 52-U 3.HA
230(10 46SI>O e 10 BH' 10.50 55.2SP 52.82 42'
10500 60000 e 10 83P 10.50 56.161" 52,81 3.11,0,
'"
1000 C 11 1.1" 1(1.65 $6,681' 52,82 1.04,0,
,
5S00 If
20500 4251>0 e 11 12FU.65 56.61'52.82
...
B600
26000 5
1.500 M
18000
1)500 II
11000 3500ao:: 111.1"10_65 56_6U'52.82 3.51SA
6100 IHOO C 10.211" '.73 U.UFS2.82 111A
~so USO l' 11.12F 10.65 56.681' 52.82 .11SA
21000 SS500 C l1,1~P 10.65 56,UF 5..U ! lM
HOO H400C 10_28P '.13 60,Hr52,12 "811>.
20807 41US-l' 10.BUIO.50 56_261.58,59 J.15A
130(1
1500
~600 C 12 .5F II.n 52.!!F 5,,!2 1] 55,0,
3100 C 11 121' 10.65 56.61'52.12 '.5'"
190(10 315000:: 10.831' 10.50 56.2V 52.82 l.S9A
2B500 56S00 C 10,83110,50 5lL2fr 52,12 2.86A
69ea Ut52 C lO_2eA 9.11 60.10.61.20 n."'1I-
15000 3110000:: 11541'11.11 54 !>!FS. 8. 4.1SA
23000 46000 C 11 121' 10,65 56611" 5282 3.101'1
6100 13:1000:: 11.121" 10.65 56 ill' 52 I. 5.~21'1
8900 17500 C 12 IS!" 11.10 53 11' S2 I~ 16,731'1
24000 50000 C 11 121" 10.65 56.UF 52 &2 4.12A
12500 :!Soooe lll.FI0 65 56.UF5.12 S4A
lUOo U500e 11I.FI0 &-5 SlIO.UI' 52 12 3.491>.
13500 .70DO C 1112rl0 65 56,UF52.12 4.23A
~_ FOR'l'AllU, T~ 'I'ltLEMarEll.W
c_ COMWl1lll; Il. MI'\NU1l,l. Ii:5T, F. FIIlST YSAA ES'T, s~ SECOND Y!:All. EST, ToO TKIRD YV\R UT, x. UNXMOlfII'
A.. AC1'tlAL; p= VtlLtIME rCTll CAro; !).. DJST/nw:::, CLA88; P. ~loa ttAA, S. S'fATB-WIDIl DBPAOl.'l', 1'1_ ClIQI-IQ1{ RQAD
A.: ACTUAL; P= I'IXLIf FcrR CAro; D. tllST/PtJlfC. CLMlS, 1>~ 1>UOR 'lEAR, .9_ 8TArR-MIDH OBFAw.r, X. CROS$-Rt:Pll:llB:WCB
~~ -"'PR-~009 18: J9 :41
PJl.Glt-l3-0F-73$'-
'22\JPll[1,0,0,2] 1_01_~_'l'XT
Figure 4 - FOOT 2008 AADT Data
Appendix V.E.l c
12 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
rlQrida Department of T~an$portation
Transportation Statistic8 Office
2007 Historical AADT R~port
c.ount.y: 87 - MIAMI-D~DE
Sit.e: 0003 - S~ 90/US~41/TAHIAMI TRL, 200' W S~ 99'7/KROHE lW
Year MDT Direction 1 Direction 2 K Faotor o Factor T Factor
---------- ------------ ---.-------- -------- -------- --------
Z007 5800 C E 3000 W 2BOO 1.90 63.12 14. SO
2006 5700 C E 2900 w HOO 7.39 58.66 13.30
2005 !;700 c E 3000 W :2700 1./0 65.10 15.40
2004 6000 C E 3100 . 2900 a.20 67.10 15.40
2003 5200 c E 2600 . 2600 e.l0 12.30 15.00
2002 1400 C E 3900 . 3500 9.20 68.00 11.10
2001 5900 C E 2900 W 3000 a.20 53.50 8. '0
2000 6600 C E 3.00 . 3200 a.20 53.10 12.60
1999 5700 C E 2700 . 3000 90.10 52.10 13.10
199a 5200 C E 2700 . 2500 9.30 52.10 11.50
1991 HOD C E 2'00 . 2000 9.10 6'. >0 12.90
1996 5200 C E 2600 . 2600 8.50 53.10 9.70
1995 3000 C E 1500 . 1500 7.90 62.60 10.90
199. 2700 C E 1300 W HOO 8.90 60.00 12.20
1993 HOD C E 1800 . 2600 0.00 0.00 0.00
tlorida Dep8rtment of Transportation
Tr~naportation Statistic~ Office
2007 Historical AADT Report
County: 87 - MIAMI-DADE
Site: 000. - SR 991/KROME AV, 1050 ' S or sw 8 ST/TAMIAMI TRAIL
Year AADT Dir.ection 1 Direction 2 R Factor o Factor T Factor
---------- ------------ ------------ -------- -------- --------
2007 16100 C N 7BOO s B300 1. ~O 63.12 10.60
2006 19000 c N 9200 S 8800 1.39 58.66 30.90
2005 15100 C N 7500 s 7600 1.10 65.10 5.20
2004 20500 C N 10000 S 10500 a .20 67.10 5.20
2003 14100 C N 1300 S 6900 a.10 12.30 19.80
2002 12900 C N 6600 s 6300 9.20 69.00 29.00
2001 14aOO C N 7600 S 7200 8.20 53.50 16.70
2000 16400 C N 9.00 s aooo 9.20 53.10 14.60
1999 15000 C N 7800 S 7200 9.10 52.70 16.90
1999 13300 C N 6900 S 6400 9.30 52.70 18.00
1~97 11400 C N 5900 S 5500 ~.10 6'.50 1-4.10
1996 10700 C N 5700 S 5000 :iI.50 >3.10 14.40
1995 8.00 C N ..00 s 4000 1.90 62.60 13.00
1994 6500 C N 3500 S 3000 B.90 60.00 22.00
1993 6000 C N 3000 S 3000 9.40 60.30 21. 2 0
Figure 5 - FDOT Historical AADT Data (Dade County Sites)
Appendix V.E.l c
13 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
Florida Department of T~an~poItation
Tran$portation Statistics Office
2001 Historical AADT Report
County: 03 - COLLIER
Site: 0006 - SR 29, NORTHEAST Of SR 90/0s 41 ce615
Year AAOT Oirect:ion 1 Direction 2 . Factor o Fact.or T Factor
---------- ------------- ------------ -------- -~------ --------
2007 1700 C N .00 S 800 I!. G8 50.38 22.10
2:006 l'6~O C N .00 S 750 11.27 57.97 16.10
2005 11s0 C N 900 s 850 11.1I0 54.70 17 .80
200. 2000 C N 1000 S 1000 11.30 55.30 13.40
2003 2400 C N 1200 S 12{)O 11.30 ;it.OO 13.40
2002 1900 C N 950 S 950 10.50 55.20 13..0
2001 1100 C N 850 S 850 10.00 51.70 6.80
2000 1800 C N 900 S 900 11. 40 56.70 16.20
1999 18"50 C N 950 S 900 9.90 54.70 16.60
199B 1500 C N 700 S 800 14.20 53.90 11.20
1997 1200 C N 600 S 600 12.5D 56.20 9.70
1996 1450 C N 100 S 150 11.400 ~3.10 11.60
1995 1300 C N 650 S 650 11.S{I 54.70 14.00
1994 1200 C N 600 S 600 10.00 52.20 12.10
19~3 1250 C N GOO s 650 10.20 54.20 11.70
Site!: 010.4 - SR 90/US 41, !<AST or sa 29 CC616
Year /\AOT Dirlilc~ion 1 Direction 2 K Factor D Fac'tor T Factor
---------- ------------ ------------ -- ------ -------- --------
2001 2100 C E 1300 . 1400 ll.73 58.S3 15.70
2006 2600 C E 1300 . 1300 13.54 62.92 14.20
200S 3100 c E l~OO . 1600 14.60 $4.60 20.80
2004 2900 C E 1500 . 1400 14 .30 55.60 20..80
2003 3400 C E 170.0 . 1700 15.20 52.30. 16.00
2002 3100 C E 1500 . 1600 12.30 56.30 14.20
2001 3400 C E 1700 . 1100 10.00 51.70 12.30
2000 3200 C E 1600 . 1(,00 11.IJO 56.70 15.30
1999 <300 C E 2100 . 2200 9.90 54.iD 15.20
1998 2700 c E 1300 . HOD 14 .20 53.90 12.10
1997 3JOO C E 1600 . 1'100 12.50 56.20 10.00
1996 2800 C E 1400 . !40D 11.40 53.70 8.10
1995 3100 C E 1600 . 1500 11.50 54.70 10.10
199. 2400 c E 1200 . 1200 10.00 52.20 11.10
1993 3600 C E 1700 . 1900 10.20 54.20 9.20
Site: 0111 - .a 90/US 41. WtST OF .a 29 CC617
Year MOT Direction 1 Direction 2 r< Factor [) Factor T Factor
---------- ------------ ------------ -------- -------- --------
2001 3200 C E 1600 W 1600 11.68 56.38 13.70
2006 3400 c E 1800 W 1600 H.27 51.91 11.20
2005 3600 C E 1800 w 1600 11. 40 54. 70 17.30
2004 42"00 C E 2100 w 2100 11.30 55.30 11. 30
2003 4800 C E 2400 . 2400 11. 30 ;4.00 11.30
2002 3900 C E 2000 w 1900 12.30 56.30 11. 30
2001 4100 C E 2100 w 2000 10.00 51.10 9.80
2000 3900 C E 2000 w 1900 11.40 56.70 13.20
1999 4aOO c E 2300 W 2500 9.90 54.10 9.40
199B 3400 C & 1700 . 1700 14.20 53.90 11.10
1997 3200 C E 1600 . 1600 12.50 56.20 10.60
19~6 3500 C E 1700 . U100 11. 40 53.10 9.30
1995 3900 C & 2000 . 1900 11.50 54.70 B.60
1994 3000 C E 1500 . 1500 10.00 52.20 12.90
1993 3800 C & 2000 . 1800 10.20 54.20 9.10
Figure 6 - FOOT Historical AADT Data (Collier County Sites)
Appendix V.E.l c
14 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
TRAFFIC TRENDS
E TAl'IlAMl TRAIL - BETWEEN SR 29 AND DADE COUNTY LINE
5000
r-ObservedCount
4500 _FItt8dCurve
i 4000
~ 3500
..
I 3000
i 2500
~
f2 2000
II
. 1500
f 1000
~
500
1998
2008 Z013
Y..,
2003
2018
.. Annuli Trwnd InCf8lH:
TRf1dR-tqIIIJId:
Tl'IIldAnnualHlstoricGrowthRatI:
Trend GrowItl RIle (2008 to DMlgn V,.):
.......
-24
6.0%
-0.81%
-0.86%
...........
TRAFFIC TRENDS
E Tamlaml Trail ... Between San Marco Drive and SR 29
"AMIlIlTmJdlll\;_:
TrendR4qUlred'
rrendAnnUII HiItoricGfowth Rat:e:
Trend Growth RIllI (2008to O..lgn Yur):
......,
o
0.0%
0.00%
0.00%
~Jun-09
2023
2028
Collier
97
E TAM1AMl TRAIL
.. ,
You ...."
1993 3600 3300
1994 2400 3200
1995 3100 3200
1996 2800 3200
1997 3300 3200
1998 2700 3100
1999 4300 3100
2000 3200 3100
2001 3400 3100
2002 3100 3000
2003 3400 3000
2004 2900 3000
2005 3100 3000
2005 2600 2900
2007 2700 2900
2008 2800 2900
2010 NIA 2800 I
2013 N/A 2800
2016 NlA 2700
"ArIe-AdJutted
Collier
96
E Tami8lTli Trail
T_ T"~
V..r aunt'
1993 3800 3700
1994 3000 3700
1995 3900 3700
1996 3500 3700
1997 3200 3700
"98 3400 3700
1999 4800 3700
2000 3900 3700
2001 4100 3700
2002 3900 3700
2003 4800 3700
2004 4200 3700
200' 3600 3700
2008 3400 3700
2007 3200 3700
2006 3100 3700
2010 NlA 3700
2013 NlA 97'"
2016 NlA 97'"
Figure 7 - Growth Rate Calculation (1)
'AxIfoAdjutt.d
Appendix V.E.l c
15 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
TRAFFIC TRENDS
SR 29 - BETWEEN us 41 AND CR 837
County:
Statlen .:
Highway:
3000
_Obsflr'VlldCount
'500 -Fitted Curve -.-J
E
..
.. 2000
0
"
~
0
~ 1500
0-
b
;! 1000
S.
j 500
1996
2003
'006
V..,
2013
2018
2023
.. AMUII Tnnd IftcrllH:
TrtndR.aquIl'ld:
Tl'4lnd AnnulI HlltorlcGrowth RIte:
TnmdGrowth RIte(20D8to DMignV..):
Prlnted:
10
45,2%
0.89%
0.00%
5-JI.Il-09
TRAFFIC TRENDS
KROME AVENUE.. S OF US 41/E Tamlaml Trail
'5000
lliI!II0b8erved Count I
-FiUedCurve
E 20000
..
.
'II
"
l 15000
/!
.
0-
" 10000
..
c
.
~
~ 5000
"..
2003
'008
V..,
2013
2018
2023
.. Annuli Trend Increul:
TrMd RoIqUIrH:
Trend.tnnUIIHlIIortcGIW/lhRatt:
TrendGIVWth RN(2OO1to DeslinYNf):
Prlnted:
147
73.4%
1.38%
1.11%
....,'"'"
Figure 8 - Growth Rate Calculation (2)
Appendix V.E.l c
16 of 24
Collier
80
SR29
Vel' OlIn ..n
1993 1300 1500
1994 1200 1500
1995 1300 1500
1996 1500 1500
1997 1200 1500
1998 1500 1500
1999 1900 1500
2000 1800 1500
2001 1700 1600
2002 1900 1600
2003 '400 1600
2004 '000 1600
200S 1900 1600
2006 1700 1600
2007 1700 1900
2006 1900 1700
2010 NlA 1700 I
I 2013 NlA 1700 I
2016 NlA 1700 I
*AxItoAdJufted
Miami-Dade
4
KROME AVENUE
c
V- 0 ...
1993 6000 10900
1994 6500 11100
1995 9400 11200
,... 10700 11400
1997 11-400 11500
'''' 13300 11700
1999 15000 11800
2000 16400 12000
2001 14900 12100
200' 12900 12300
2003 14100 12400
'004 20500 12500
'005 15100 12700
'008 16000 12800
2007 16100 13000
2010 NlA 13400 I
2013 N1A 13900 I
2016 N1A 14300 I
"AxIe-AdJuIted
Revised 8.12.09
Appendix V.E.1 c
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
III
II
.1
.
.
.
5
,
f '
! E
i
.
, i
I
I !
i
!
II
I ~
PI
I
1
I
I
J
J
!
i
!
, X
H
0( ~ 1
. .,
I Ill;
~mL
~ I
,
.
i
!
I
I
.
I 'I !
" ,
a 5" .$ ~
~~ ; 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ l
..
17 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
Appendix V.E.l c
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
Iii
, !
.
11
.1
, .
I ,
A ,
. ,
i
, ,
i
! .
,
i I
I !
,
,
.
i
!
I
E U
m I
t t iil iil
..
~. :Ii il!tl
, .
, -
!! 3
18 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
. u
. n
I II I I
"
i $!
Dade Collier Cypress Recreation Area - Traffic Impact Study
Collier County, FL
TRAFFIC TRENDS
Tamiami Trail -- SR 2911:0 Dade Countl Line
Collier
237
T~mi..miTr::lil
25J
I_o"~,,,~, I
~tteClO;ie
""
~.
.
~
! '50
.
I'
~
,. 100
~
.
~
.
. 50
'.
=r
;oi;
;0-.
=
Voa'
~...,.
~
",.
r:affic ADTI........DT
Ye1lllr Co..t" Tre.d....
2002 200 200
2003 200 200
2004 200 200
2005 200 200
2006 200 200
2001 200 200
2008 200 200
2016 NIA 200
2026 NIA 200
2036 NIA 200
.. #1....::111 Tread la'l:re::ase:
Tread R-sq..:ared:
Tread A.....I His:toric Growt. Rate:
rud Growt. R'IIte r2008 to Desiqa Ye:arl:
Pri..ted:
o
#Ol...../O!
0.00),:
0.00%
11.A"",-(I'
Str..lq"t L..,.., Gro.t" OP~IO"
.. A:de-Adiasted
Figure 11 - Collier County 2008 AUIR Table (3)/Growth Rate Calculation (3)
Appendix V.E.l c
19 of 24
Revised 8.12.09
MILLER~EGG
Appendix V.E.Ic
Figure 12
Page 20 of 24
March 27, 2009
Mr. John Podczerwinsky
Project Manager
Collier County Transportation Planning
2885 South Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
Re: Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area - TraMe Methodology
ML Project No. 09-00063
Dcar Mr. Podczerwinsky:
j
Please accept this letter as our Traffic Methodology Statement for the above-referenced project,
as required by the Collier County Traffic Impact Study (TIS) Guidelines and Procedures. The
intent of this letter is to propose a methodology memo with assumptions for preparation of a
traffic impact study for this site. The paragraphs below outline the background infonnation,
assumptions, and proposed methodology for the Traffic Impact Study.
Introductioll
The Dade-Collier Park Amendment is a proposed amendment to the Collier County Growth
Management Plan for +/- 1608 acres located north of U.S. Highway 41 (Tamiami Trail) at the
Dade County Line. The existing site is part of the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport
j property owned by the Miami-Dade Aviation Department. The proposed site is south of the
existing runway, and contains mostly wetlands with some excavated lakes and dirt roads
constructed wi!h the airport. The proposed park will include primitive campgrounds, an archery
range, fishing (from lake banks only), and bird-watching. The trails connecting these areas will
be designated for Off Highway Vehicles (OHV). bicycles. and hiking.
Study Area
The proposed site is located on !he Dade-Collier County border. Access to !he proposed site will
share !he existing service driveway for the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport. The
project entrance, site area, and adjacent roadways are shown on the map on the next page.
L Tamiami Trail is a two lane undivided roadway connecting Miami to Naples. and continuing
north to Tampa/SI. Petersburg. The closest intersection to the project site is State Road 29.
approximately twenty-eight miles to the wesl. State Road 29 continues north to 1-75.
IMP R 0 V I N G COM M U NIT I E S. eRE A TIN G E N V I RON MEN T S.
South Florida 0Ifice: 1800 N Douglas Road . Suite 200 . Pembroke Pines. Florid. . 33024.3200
(954) 436.7000 . Fax: (954) 436-8664
www.millertegg.com
Mr. John Podczerwinsky
March 27. 2009
Appendix V. E. Ie
Figure 12
Page 21 of 24
Site Location Map
Data Col/ectioll alld Correctioll Factors
The study shalJ use the data from the 2008 Annual Update and Inventory Report (AUIR - refer to
attached table) to demonstrate that the project will not generate significant impacts, as defined by
'" Section 8 of the TIS guid<;lines. ~_ Sl-lowA "$lbN1F,c...Nc.E.-iE-""-- ,.-lr.......
(?T..'?Ro",e-C-'T" ~,~~ 1'-ti-l"~":' 5>>"...."AJ6 I'Y104vW4'flbU''''t. !FoVEIZ- 2%
Trip Gelleratioll 1/oJ AM,/- -0 r-eEc.--nofJ, -r~6IJ ^"'.4t.fZL Su6>Sf'61"e!^,7 ~t....<:ts). 4P
The trips to/from the site shalJ be estimated using the Institute of Transportation J;:ngineers (ITE) /'
Trip Generation Manual. 8'" Edition. 01/:.. c;.1-/""'-' 'T......v "WA~ TV."'F' ~ (N"T :::::NS.7 .
E:NTE.IZ..f~?<rr SlJouJ 'bO'm''1>I1:.E.c:.TI('.....~ 0" 'T'R.Jo.~'-
I 01--' l!f.A<:}1 -::. ~ OF' 'P12-t>~ 'J>"E:lve",,~y.)
Non-wetland areas of the park will be utilized for these activities. It is assumed that thts area f
will be 10% (maximum) of the site area. I ~c-L-U'JJE- 'TOTAl.- ACUAGE.. /,0/'T>> ,,,,-, -rH E-
I,p,..1<.X-" DootJPA'Z-'<;<;' ft,'L 'f'R.,'E 6t;JJE='ZA'T'oAJ, Al<C4"- <hYT'
IIVCLl1:D~'l> ,^" THe, l U!OS/"""~l>
Calculation will be based on Land Use Code 416 - County Park. ?~ AC~ U N 3E-
,Ja,..TI",,!
CJ M \-rr G 't>~M "TlC{ P CrC-'
Lllnd.Use Unit Size AM Peak Hour PM Peak Hour
CQde' Rate. Enter 71 % Exit 29% Rate Enter 35% Exit 65%
416 Acres 161 0.52 60 24 0.59 33 62
iV. Tf':. : CiS b-\-A L L ICO - "("\'I'OL STVj)~ ~
The final traffic impact study to be provided ill be classified a a minor study as outlinid in the i So
Collier County TIS Guidelines and Procedures. d A oJ~ '(.'r"'O'JI
~75o 1U
Trip Distributioll (~ E"'~ '1/1 r ~ "1' T '5
The distribution of trips to/from the park will be determined based on OHV title data frgr:: ;6i-t.,.v6 ~
Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. Because some of the trips will
begin/end in Dade County, approval from the Miami Dade Public y.'orks Department will also
be r uired. ~T .l\f-( ; <; A t;jEA ~LE:- -TO -,,-IE I A f'EgOAC-1- I 'B vT N€6!:>S He> eJ; ,.u,oO .
~$:3MltJb TLJE. '""TI"TL-E:-Ac..-rIVITY" c.}.lA~.d::f::. ~ A-e.~ LJ~"I:::l>,,,,,,,,ue..'7"c.'b'S.,"\l......1'LLy'no-.....
I.<.>'~'" "Go ::30 '1"" ",. i/i!--SV 01" 'T>'E..,.'DLIV~~ 70"/1:' r3ft:>'(T"el-> ~T'" ~l,'_r~
Pass By and IlItemal Carpture "'~>>""4u..~y). (~ 'l3 A= 6014 TO $E; ~TO=-j,V 4s. 7
.;/ w€.t.l-
This site will not utilize trip reduction based on ntema] and pass-by capture due to the usage and .
site location.
oL
Page 2 of3
Mr. John Podczerwinsky
March 27, 2009
Appendix V.E.lc
Figure 12
Page 22 of 24
General Operational Analysis Requirements alld Software
This operation analysis will be limited to the following analysis scenarios:
l. Scenario I - Existing
2. Scenario 2- Future-5 years or less build out horizon
The analysis will not include committed trips on the roadway network based on the absence of
approved but un-built surrounding developments and related vested trips. (I,i,/JI-E. SoS TIJE. c"t!tl I 7TGJ>
RIps t'1f.M.~f[P ,4.a;e
The capacity analysis software that will be used is Synchro 7. 1J1G4et-" 4A.... 13AC.~:;s.~:;c+
r /1.Jt;.AL. G~""~' 5..:=1::
-- G1Z-~T~ tc:..A'Tlii.)
If you have any questions or require additional information, please contact me at (954) 436-7000
or at eczemieiewski@millerlegg.com.
Sincerely,
~
~-
-"
Eric S. Czemiejewski, P.E.
Associate, Engineering
ESC/jw/bmg
Attachment - 2008 AUIR Table /1
cc: Julio Menache - Millian. Swain & Associates, Inc. C, ~ Gv:[
Kevin Asher - Miami-Dade County Parks & Recreation ~
James A. McCall- Miami-Dade County Parks & Recreation 6. V I':; . . >....-
M61 OLt':6-'( lY 'T rl <'-'V'cS,
V \Projects\2009\09-OO063 - Dade..colher Park Amendment\l)()cuments\Report\4109 SubmHtal\APPENDlCES\Appendix V E~.c /. Traffic I 'S a \L ~
Methodology.doc
x
Fn\JT) "'vG S Of- S vf:Jr O~A..:JC1
i2'''H''''' IV IS '. .
1) IVGE:"-VSo f'. 1/<;' Jt.lA-T '5 CC>NSoIS'T buT
...,.tI~ -n5o G V WE-'- I tVt::So $ -r "'" 5 ""
M ~ T>I.s;r>OL-06Y /JO,E-S . AJ T 14E..
INCL[)"D(;. /A- :D1'E>'T<=-lbuT10.J MAP 1 ..
2....}/5U~.5TAI'JT\\J,l:" f\t:.VIe.L0 '?A~~("E-(WW""-H IJILl--
A# ItXLlJfJ.6;P 1,.1 TH"" '7~H'TTAL)
U- .<.t!> ,,,"""'-'$. C>'"
t'\. 1'-1\ :t::>A'D ~ k;<t--bw ~G I . ...
3) A-l+A-c." t..E:'T'T"-"-~:; \A Ie> I) tJITU-l'" C./I,~x... GUAJf! -
-LIt I~ CV''''''-- zl'o (V\~ "-""I' .
tJS ...- ~"';';';;""OCIc....'--- GU'-<l.1t
~ ('i7 U &12:- "7"'/./ E. Ac..'TUAL LI -;",J
4 GRoc....)..,i-J r\...-;'TE=-S - M""I"-r:> Cf'l:= ,A MI,uI}1UI1 '--tD L--IAJi=A"-~T6)
AJ. ,-_ IMf,.4c-ro3' ~ _.". J ~, .:>""",1 i="IUl"'<lAJ F",~ 1ZA-<:E."" U'iot=.:D.
'Tl!''fe -r=€-- '" G'\Z-iC."'T=-"--. GI.I"-
WH1c..t-l-E-ofE-k':- T' C()'~l.-GTG 4- c..M~4.-'1G:AT1>)1E.-</T
_ HE /T "'A~'> 0 n -, U
h) '-'-\)6. to tHE I ( ~:> OiJC 0)::- T E- '1,-,",0 PtJl-l-o..o1,vb
o tV s.",,,,pr "l,e.GOMr1 ,,--...... c:....t=.v;$) l-1.v~A'Z- G':~r"'" IU~""",>+
jcw€c; ='" ~Me~G.p: j
E.~-=- - ="'1 4 6- UV>-"'- n:"-"'. .
~~(... WII'fiJ <Gel"'!!? -( <0......<0,):> I fJ)?U /VU,...(?~ A 3i\Ac.."'-6R.-oU^-'> ~<.
lrN.:!EO', l..u~ c."MHI$~lo"14 .;~A~t yt>V.4TE i- ~CA~Gv""'T"'" =- ;:~,..1TI"
-oy l"\AS~ W r"'17o..J MO~T ~ Pa 30f3 "\:A..."'-jGO-Y'TE""''?O..v = '0'/'"
\\t1I,v,t4 ~ G;-e.~"':'" A;J'"Y''~I'''
f.\ N""LY~1=- . -=-c
--=- ~ -----
~YIE:..L0: 11J:>UT-FIC.tE...f0f rva
- J.
-r'eAf7' (c. S TUJ:;> / IS
10 eLl) DE-"1:=> .
,1
Legend
. DHSMV 4 HOUHhofdG Wlh OHVs nhd in MDC:: 2002.2008
BICY addition
SlgCyprellsNP
Stlcayne
Evero/aclell
ev.rglado.additlon
Waler CooHlWlon Are.
&8
OFF-HIGHWAY VEHICLES TITLED FOR 2002.2006
p\.~N(;&Re5fI\RCHOlVlSjON
PARI( AND IlECflEATrONDEPAAT"'f'Nr
.A..'lY2007 OHV I<OCmxd
SOURCE OapmfllldHl!J'lNlI'/ S""'.~ & MoIOl" Vlth'CltS IOMSMVI
, -.'
8 r [) w "r.;j C
~
,to
..
.
o.
" .
c-;o" .
"
'0
.
>
.
~
i'J; ( ~.1 iil i . 0 () d a C (: \I rl I Y
81HS-1
.
"
;I
'1
'i
.
1
r"
. ... .
...
. .
-.
.
I:
....
~
U4HI.n ~
3~1T1-I $1
aZJllo ST
.
\
~o
o
""b
\,
'"
"""'.2
""",.3A
WCA-3.
.
Appendix V. E .le
Figure 12
Pa e 23 of 24
o.
#."S.
J':m
...,-~.
W+E
S
o
1.25 2.5
SMiles
. &a:e Parb
COlnt)' Parks
Environmentdy Endangered l.and Sitos
Mo.jOfRoads
co
o
o
("'\j
---
rl
('Vi
--
01
i-1
(""I
,-
t....)
----
o
0'i
--
\..0
~
--
>
.-
+-J
U
<(
ClJ
-
+-J
--
f--
~
C
:::J
:J
U
U
rl
r>1
:> '"
~ ~ 0
.rl
"1J Q) '"
>:: "N.
Q) ;::l Q)
~ tJ1 tJ1
~.rl <1l
,,; Ii< p,
en
L1J
...J
U
-
:r:
w
>
>-
~
:r:>-
\,.!)1-
_Z
:r:::>
LLO
LLU
OW
o:::U
OZ
LLW
c.n9
ZVl
OW
- ~--
.... ..
u >- "'
<(a:l~
en N
Z
<(
0:::
....
L1J
...J
!::
....
I
J i
I ...j
! r
,.,-...~
!>.'!;~J
~~lr:ut
'"
N
~.
A-
{;J\~
~~
.-,c\--
i
,
I
-----1
,
,
I
i
I
I
I
I
,
.H-i
."
"'
"'
co'
-.-.; j
,--,
I
~
S{
\'
i
I
i !
, t
i _ i,
!
I
~
~
"'"
~
o
"'
'"
vi
".,
....
,..
,..'
"'-
e
'" e
,.;; ,..
'"
'" M
... I I
U\ ,
",' I i I
I
, I
i I f , '" ,
i ...;
i I "'I
I 1 ",'
1 i I I
I
: i
I j
I '"
! i ...
I co
!
r
I
~~
oJcA~
1'/' - 4l:)
rl t"'-
:- tiC)
U\
'"
'"
",'
,
i
,
I
I
!
,
i
i
,
I
HI
_.1
,--'
"
!U
()
T
~~;
."
i
!
i
i
I
....
'"
'"
",'
APPENDIX V.E.ld
DRAINAGE
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
County Petition No. CP-2009-1
Appendix V.E.1d - Drainaae
Existing Conditions:
The proposed Collier Cypress Recreation Area (The Project) is located North of US
41 [Tamiami Trail) near 50-mile bend within the 24,480 acre property known as
The Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport (TNT) property. The Project site
specifically occupies approximately 1.608 acres of the TNT property within and is
bounded on the north by the existing airport [Approx. 1,000 acres) that includes
a maintenance trailer, a single runway. taxiways and apron and to the west by
an existing access road that links Tamiami Trail to the existing airport. The project
site is currently in a semi-natural state; that includes wetlands, cypress and
hardwood forests, except for the presence of five man-made quarry lakes,
excavated in 1968 to provide fill for construction of the airport and access road
to Tamiami Trail.
Level of Service Standard (LOSS) Requirements:
The Project is located in the Collier County - Gator Hook Strand Basin and within
the Big Cypress Watershed Basin as shown in Figure 0-1. The drainage LOSS for
this project must comply with the goals, objectives and policies stipulated in the
Collier County Land Development Code (Chapter 6) and the Growth
Management Plan (Future Land Use. Public Facilities Element-Drainage Sub-
element and the Conservation & Coastal Management Elements). Further. the
site is within the Big Cypress Area of Critical Concern, thus subject to review by
the State of Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA). In addition, given
that the project site is greater than 40 acres and impacts existing wetlands within
the Big Cypress Watershed Basin. the Big Cypress Basin Board and the South
Florida Water Management (SFWMD) will have jurisdiction over review and
approval of design. permitting and implementation of drainage/stormwater
management systems at this site. At a minimum. the required project Drainage
LOSS for the proposed development to attenuate water quality and water
quantity requirements shall be as follows:
Access paved drivewavs. parkina areas:
The minimum elevation shall be above the highest stage [elevation) derived
from stage-storage computations of the 10 year-24 hour storm event using
SFWMD accepted methodology.
Minimum Finish Floor Elevation:
The minimum lowest floor elevation for buildings/structures shall be above the
established FEMA Flood Zone for the project site or the highest stage (elevation)
derived from stage-storage computations of the 100 year-72 hour storm event
using SFWMD accepted methodology; whichever is higher.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 1 at 3
Appendix V.E.l d
Perimeter Gradina / Allowable Offsite Oischaraes:
Perimeter grading along the project boundary shall be established at the
maximum stage derived from stage-storage computations of the 25 year - 72
hour storm event using SFWMD accepted methodology.
Proposed Improvements:
The new project contemplates the following development characteristics:
a. New Visitor's Center Building [approximate 2200-2400 SF) to include,
Administrative area (small office room). Orientation area, Restrooms and
small meeting room [with media capability for training/orientation purposes)
b. New Parking Lot for 80 vehicles.
c. Camping: primitive and RV [but with minimal offerings - not for extended
stay/luxury RV camping)
d. Fishing: piers or docks.
e. Off-highway vehicle trails (stabilized trails - at grade) for Off-Highway Vehicles
[OHV)
f. Multi-use trails (for hikers and bikers)
g. Wildlife viewing opportunities (could be a platform or overlook, or simply a
cypress dome or tree island visible at a distance from trails)
h. Archery Range
The proposed development uplands may be concentrated along the western
portions of the site in close proximity to the existing access road. Storm runoff
from parking areas and other development uplands can be collected via
drainage structures fitted with pollution retardant baffles and conveyed to dry
retention areas for water quality attenuation per SFWMD criteria.
The existing five quarry lakes were excavated in the 1960's without consideration
of safety or littoral [shallow) shelf areas for fish and wildlife propagation and
currently lack a littoral zone transition from the uplands to the bottom of the
lakes. As part of the site improvements, the existing edge of the lakes might be
improved with a shallow littoral zone to enhance fish and wildlife. In addition, the
restored lakes will provide controlled surface storage capacity for stormwater
management. The drainage system from developed areas may be conveyed to
the existing lakes after water quality requirements are achieved in dry retention
areas and subsequently released through controlled means [control structures,
spreader swales) in a manner similar to the natural surface flow regime of the
area.
There are existing trails, previously created by swamp buggies that traverse the
project site primarily in an east/west direction. As part of the proposed site
development. restoration/realignment of these trails, enhancement of compliant
trails and modification of trails to passive uses are projected in order to increase
overall compatibility with historical sheet flow patterns from the Big National
Preserve to the Everglades National Park.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 2 of 3
Appendix V.E.1 d
The drainage and stormwater management systems for the project will be
designed considering site constraints and opportunities but in unison and
compatible with environmental site assessments. development and mitigation
strategies. environmental enhancements and regulatory requirements.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 3 of 3
Appendix V.E.l d
Legend
-==:I Collier County Boundary
c::::::::::I Miami-Dade County Boundary
-MainRoads
=:<l Everglades Nat'1 Park
_BigCypress
Drainage Basins
Barron River Canal Basin
:::= Cocohatchee River Canal Basin
Faka-Union Canal Basin
Fakahatchee Strand Basin
Gateway Triangle Basin
= Gator Hook Strand Basin
= Gordon River Extension Basin
Henderson Creek Basin
L-28 Tieback Basin
LelyCanal Basin
Lely Manor Canal Basin
,",_...=::J Main Golden Gate Canal Basin
Palm Street Basin
=':::::-.::::J Rock Creek Basin
Southern Coastal Basin
= Turner River Canal Basin
MSA
MII.$wIirl..""IKla....~
+
-
GULF OF MEXICO
::r'
'.t,-, ~,'
'"
"'::--~' ~--'
'E,vargl~d~..-N8tiQrfll p~tt' . .
~. .;/... co
8calolr,Mile.
COLLIER COUNTY DRAINAGE BASIN MAP
APPENDIX V.E.1.D
FIGURE D-1
MEMORANDUM
MS.~MlliII1I,SWIIiaIllUl~
. . ',. .. .,2025S.W,. 32Ild A...'" PIclridilDI4'
. ... ... . .. 1'Il(3O$)44-IOOI2Jfa'(3OS)....r.o6ll
CIVIL ENGINEERING. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING. UTILITY MANAGEMENT. FINANCIAL CONSULTING
File: Mll-24
Date: August 25, 2009
To: Kevin Asber, AlCP, Supervisor, Special Projects - MDPRD
From: Julio Menacbe (MSA)
Copy: Andy McCall, CMS (MDPRD)
Jill Coben, RLA, AICP, LEED AP (MiIler-Legg)
Arsenio Milian, P.E. (MSA)
Reference: "Dade--Collier Cypress Recreation Area District"
Subject: Collier County Staff Report - Review Comments
We have reviewed the subject staff report ("the report") for the referenced project; particularly related to
drainage comments contained on page 9 (attached for ease of reference) of the report and offer the
following clarification:
1) The penultimate paragraph on page 9 of the report states that "...the drainage plan Indicates
that the perimeter of the property would be bermed limiting sheet flow across the site
from the surrounding areas..."
The drainage section prepared by MSA and submitted as part of the GMP Amendment application
(Appendix V.E.l D - Drainage) does not propose "a berm" along the perimeter of the property. I
believe the reviewer's comment may be stemming from a rigid interpretation of the minimum level of
service requirements for perimeter grading stated in the last paragraph of page 1 in Appendix
V.E.1D as NORMALLY required by the SFWMD. In reality. the final proposed grades along the
perimeter of this project site will (at a minimum) need to consider: Analysis of pre vs. post-
development stormwater modeling per SFWMD criteria taking into account restoration of historical
sheet flow across the site in a manner similar to the natural surface flow regime of the area AND the
regulatory constraints imposed by the myriad of regulatory agencies that will have jurisdiction over
the stormwater system for this project.
2) The penultimate paragraph on page 9 also states that "... This plan also Indicates the
existing borrow pits would be used for stormwater management which will require
underground piping and dry retention for pretreatment resulting In further wetlands
impacts... "
The use of dry retention areas and the existing lakes is offered only as an option that MAY BE used
for this project for attenuation of stormwater quality and quantity requirements. It is really premature
at this time; without comprehensive boundary & topographic surveys, final site plans and
environmental site assessment(s) to determine final method(s) of stormweter management systems
(i.e. dry and/or wet detention/retention systems. etc.) that will satisfy development opportunities and
yet minimize wetlands impacts. I think; however, that all throughout Appendix V.E.1D and
particularly in the last paragraph on page 2, Miami-Dade County clearly offers a commitment to the
design of a stormwater management system in compliance with regulatory agencies yet sensnive to
the protection and enhancement of existing natural resources.
.,\{:praj)\mJHI4.to-park\m<mK>'",IIpOI1..to...,llioreountydraJnas;e_t.o8.Z!.OP,dOCl<
APPENDIX V.E.le
SOLID WASTE
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
County Petition No. CP-2009-1
Appendix V.E.le- Solid Waste
Existing Level of Service Standard (LOSS):
The Collier County Growth Management Plan - Public Facilities Element (Solid Waste
Sub-element) and section 6.02.08 of the Collier County Land development Code has
established the following Solid Waste Facility Level of Service requirements:
a. The LOSS for capital solid waste disposal facilities is 2 years of constructed lined cell
capacity at the average disposal rate for the previous five (5) years. and 10 years of
permittable landfill capacity at the average disposal rate for the previous five (5)
years.
b. The determination of public facility adequacy for solid waste disposal facilities shall
be based on the following:
1. The required public facilities are in place at the time a final site development
plan, final subdivision plat, or building permit is issued.
2. The required public facilities are under construction at the time a final site
development plan, final subdivision plat. or building permit is issued.
3. The required public facilities are guaranteed in an enforceable development
agreement that includes the provisions of subsections 1. and 2. above.
Existing Collier County facilities include two franchise collection areas and three
recycling centers. as follows:
a. Naples Recycling Center
b. Marco Recycling Center
c. Carnestown Recycling Center
d. Unincorporated County Service Area and Immokalee Transfer Station
e. Collier County Landfill
Proposed Improvements:
The proposed Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area (The Project) contemplates the
following development characteristics:
a. New Visitor's Center Building (approximate 2200-2400 SF) to include. Administrative
area (small office room), Orientation area. Restrooms and small meeting room (with
media capability for training/orientation purposes)
b. New Parking Lot for 80 vehicles.
c. Camping: primitive and RV (but with minimal offerings)
d. Fishing: piers or docks.
e. Off-highway vehicle trails (at grade) for Off-Highway Vehicles (OHV) use.
f. Multi-use trails (for hikers and bikers)
g. Wildlife viewing opportunities (could be a platform or overlook)
h. Archery Range.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 1 of 2
Appendix V.E.l e
Per Appendix V.D.5b, it is estimated that approximately 14,300 people will visit the site
on a yearly basis. Using the EPA's daily average solid waste production rate of 4.6 Ibs
per person. the waste production at the Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area is
calculated as follows:
14,300 people per year / 365 days per year = :1:40 people per day
40 people per day x 4.6 Ibs per person per day = 184 Ibs per day = 36 tons per
year
The closest waste recycling facility to the project site is the Carnestown Recycling
Center [facility) located on US-41 in Everglades City. However, after discussions with the
Collier County Solid Waste Management Department (CCSWMD), it was determined
that this facility does not have the capacity to service the project site. Therefore, two
other facilities were identified for waste disposal: the Collier County Landfill and the
Immokalee Transfer Station, shown on Figure E-1.
It is projected that approximately 184 Ibs of solid waste will be produced daily at the
project site. Given the remoteness of the proposed development, the CCSWMD
indicated it is outside of the collection routes performed by both the City and/or
County. Therefore, it is anticipated that collection and disposal of solid waste and
recyclables generated from proposed development activities will be conducted by an
approved private solid waste hauler under contract with the property owner.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 2 of 2
Appendix V.E.1 e
APPENDIX V.E.2
EXISTING SERVICES AND PUBLIC
FACILITIES
T 4B 8
.
~
...
c
::IE
....
lil ::l
'" ;::
::;
CO U
Z ~
C u
.... ::;
m
~
.... ~
a:
'"
...
'"
...
T488
~. 01(0, .@.;.@'''''i>..@@.'"' r
: II.. .....,.........i
~ , !
;~~" ~! ~
'Il!!! I I! :! "i
~~~~~~ ~~"~!
I~~~~~ih"&~ ~~~ ~t
i1iili I!l!iiliidliiim i
~
N
~
.
;;;
o
~
~
~. I ~~
( ;to
.
N
N
N
<:::
"'::
.....
lo..
~ 0
......
~
~
.....
;:::
;:::
~ 0
U
lo..
<l.l
.....
......
......
0
U
8 a" 1
T 49 S
T 52 8
T51 S
.uN'10:J G<JVMC<J8
-UNnOJ 30VO
#'"
"
I
I
I
,
~I
II
I
.il
r
I
,
!
~
I I
~ --l
I
.., I
,
l
II
II
II
/
;~--
I
nn~1
"-- '
'-;
lJU--
,
z
o
o
o
w
{t
..".
..:-_~V
S !II' 1
8 U 1
:--- ---------....--~
f--
,
: !
'.
: .
"I
1m
, ' f~!
iJ'n~
l: .&....
.
- --"-II!
f i
il :
, .
I <
r~
=_m_mnm
" .1
,l ;1
I i.1
~ inl
1 ,n_'
----,
L___I
_________________nn__.!
, ---, ~l.-.
.'
/::~~
"o~
MeX~co
Gulf
of
80!l1
S LHl
T 53 8
.
~
~
~
N
~
;;;
~
.
N
.
N
0,1 ~
~
~
"
"
"
U
~
8
~
~i~ ""
~;~
'i~.!,
~!~
~h
ll~
"'
::/=
~~
~~
..
III
C1l
s:::
o
N
f/)
::i
w
C')
c
.-
-
III
.-
><
W
CO
Q
Q
N
143
+
-
,
"
"
CR85S
COLLIER CO. EMS STATION
STATION NO. 61
201 Buckner Ave.
Everglades City, FL
TAMIAMrTRF.
Sca,,'nMI'..
GULF OF MEXICO
Legend
_ Collier County Boundary
c:::::::::::::I Miami-Dade County Boundary
-MainRoads
c==-"'-", Everglades Nat'1 Park
. EMS Stations
'.~-> ~-' :'.r-.:.
~ '
,:.
.....
.,~
COLLIER COUNTY
EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES STATIONS
Appendix V.E.2
FIGURE 3
"11M, $wtIn . "MOdI_in(..
a.
<C
2
>-
0::
<C
o
Z
~
o
m
I-
()
-
a::
....
'"
o
w
a::
LL.
>-
....
z
~
o
()
0::
W
-'
-'
o
()
"
.!!
:Eo
N
I
'.- il
0 h
~
. ~
~
'"
o
~
u:
J!
m
~
!
*,
b
c
o
II
S .
e-II
:::I'C
ll."
",'"
CC
._ :::I
U
..-
-"
ll.-
~ u
.sfJj
.!!~
...02
"0
Ez
.11I
.c
l-
S
o
Z
0
w
(/) 11
0 i
CL
0 ...I
a::
CL
0
Z
<(
<.9
z
l-
(/)
X
W
..
~
is II
8! ~
1~~~~
o::~l:J8-
i!l~8
I..D~
(/)
z
o
I-
<(
l-
(/)
W
a::
c
o
;:I
Ii
toc
[~
E5
~~
l~
i.
-
l!
lL
III
III
...
~
o
:&
:&
-
~
I
~
i
~
o
o
.
i
"
~
I
LL
w
w
CL
o
I
()
o
<X)
o
o
N
105
2008 OCHOPEE EXISTING FIRE STATION
(LOS:4 MINUTE RESPONSE TIME /1.5 MILE RADIUS)
ii,
CMeKe~~SKEE
~l"
. /~~k::J
" . , ....~.
"'';"i~
~ '. ,""1 -I .
t. "fIOi;.",!lWll.,,_
~. "~J'":'~, .. .~,
~..', "'_ ~l .
.. ':.~_ '~:~t..
",r
::;
,I
it
:/i
.v.'~'I' .'
'. r.i."Ii,1 f
\~ :/)J j 1'-'
"t.Pil1j,.,."
:' f)~lif
... .~f1Y i'I'
,..-:,::1":'1";
,..-.....~..li-:r,...."
~'I' j:1::"I..:.I..:,
.t......
~'li; ai: : :
1""'1 itil
,&\.J1._;-, '
I(.;:-!~I ,
, -}!J,:~;, :,.,>
: ,J".j'"'ii': J'-
,,/.,.plii' . , r ' ..
"]~:I~;j,"Iii:.:~.i ~!~~~
' t;;::""',J:
.;'1- jli:T;--i"';,..
., l.l!:lli' 1 I.: I. ~
-"- ,-:;ff.:! -~: ":" i: /'$
. . ~(f~i.:i, :~_~_J~w_,_ ~LAJIl:r~l1~_~~,_, . ~
EYERGtAqe
m,;::;:_
ill
1
~.; .! i
'41. ~:~
" f!
';'
- '_CO't;
"..~-
'~
::<~,
"'I'"
.~ ". !('lf~",
~j(~:_:~<~t;~<\ /~~~~ :~l.~' <1~
. ,Ii' STRUCTURES WITHIN ISO RESPONSE TIME VS.
. .~?{ b OUTSIDE WITH EXISTING STAT]ION]
'11. 'H~"
1(/)12 936 ,=~
w'
. I tl: 1 <<-- --.
. I ::> . ,
'1.'-.\ ~ I
'~ ~
'\t.__. __
------- }
';'
- '_.',-
"""--:'-fm._-
286
.,rl_
ITV
..'
,
Legend
I8i Existing Fire Station
Roads
-
Structures Within Ochopee
Fire District
I
. Q.,
I
0.5
I Miles
1
I
0.25
,
I
f/)
<U
.-
I..
C'CS
"C
C
~
0
OJ
....
(,)
.-
I..
....
f/)
.-
C
<U
(,)
.-
It:
0
f/) coal
Ii:: it
.-
I.. l::Ie
<U
.c:
UJ
~
c
~
0
0
I..
<U
.-
-
-
0
0
"Sl
tl'lil
!~
u~
J
.;.,j,;!
.:-'1 ........
OJ' Ie',:...,
i <i";;1V ,-
, N~
tlli
~J
'.;, ,i!;,'~" . , ' ,
, " <') II
,.~ X:;;i {-
c,.t.P.,. """''''.<d'_':,'', _,~.'
,."~~'''/:.-if ',-';,
,~ "":';-;'-',~,;~,'" '<
,<,i\j,J/->~' W
,'.:<,,0......
.16
APPENDIX V.E.3
PROPOSED SERVICES AND PUBLIC
FACILITIES
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
County Petition No. CP-2009-1
Appendix V.E.3 - Proposed Services and Public Facilities
Collier County offers multiple public facilities and public buildings, mainly throughout
the more developed areas. Please refer to Appendix V.E.2 - Figure 1 for a location of all
these public facilities. This map was obtained from the Collier County GIS/CAD
Mapping Section. and represents all the public facilities in Collier County as of April
2009.
Proposed Improvements:
The proposed Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area (The Project) contemplates the
following development characteristics:
a. New Visitor's Center Building (approximate 2200-2400 SF) to include. Administrative
area (small office room). Orientation area. Restrooms and small meeting room (with
media capability for training/orientation purposes)
b. New Parking Lot for 80 vehicles.
c. Camping: primitive and RV (but with minimal offerings)
d. Fishing: piers or docks.
e. Off-highway vehicle trails (at grade) for Off-Highway Vehicles (OHV) use.
f. Multi-use trails (for hikers and bikers)
g. Wildlife viewing opportunities (could be a platform or overlook)
h. Archery Range.
The proposed improvements will require the services of local emergency medical
stations, fire protection and law enforcement. A description of each of these is
provided below. The project site will not have an impact on local schools, as is not
proposed for residential use.
Emeraencv Medical Services:
The proposed Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area is located under the EMS 60/61
Zone, which encompasses most of the eastern portion of Collier County, as shown on
Figure 2 of Appendix V.E.2. In addition, Figure 3 of Appendix V.E.2 shows the location of
all EMS Stations in Collier County. The closest station is located approximately 50 miles
from the project site, in Everglades City. Therefore, the proposed development will be
serviced by Collier County's EMS Station No. 61. located at 201 Buckner Avenue in
Everglades City. The current LOS for EMS services as specified under the 2008 AUIR is for
8 minutes travel time for urban areas and 12 minutes travel time for rural areas 90% of
the time, requiring 1 unit for 16.400 people. Since the proposed development expects
an average of 14.300 people per year. the impact on the overall EMS Plan would be
minimal, with a maximum of one additional unit for the EMS 60/61 zone.
Fire Profecfion
The proposed development is located within the Ochopee Fire District Boundary. as
shown on Figure 4 of Appendix V.E.2. Furthermore, Figure 5 of Appendix V.E.2 shows the
location of all existing and proposed fire stations within the district. Ochopee's Fire
Station No. 60, located at 201 Buckner Avenue in Everglades City, is the closest (50
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 1 of 2
Appendix V.E.3
miles) fire station to the project site. The current LOS for this facility is 4 minutes per 1.5
mile radius as depicted in Figure 6 of Appendix V.E.2.
Law Enforcement
The project site is located within the Collier County Sheriff's Office District 7 [Everglades).
as shown on Figure 7 of Appendix V.E.2. The closest Sheriff's Station is located at 32020
Tamiami Trail East in Ochopee. approximately 43 miles from the site. near the
intersection of Tamiami Trail and CR-29. Please see Appendix V.E.2 - Figure 7 for graphic
reference. As stated on the 2008 AUIR. the LOS for Law Enforcement is 1.96 officers per
1,000 people. There are no major impacts expected from the proposed development
to the current Law Enforcement LOS.
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
Page 2 at 2
Appendix V.E.3
Co~er County
t::.... ~_
- -
Bureau of Emergency Services
Memorandum
FROM:
Mr. Thomas Greenwood, Principal Planner
Community Development and Environmental Services Division
Dan E. Summers, Directopti5J.
TO:
DATE:
November 9, 2009
RE:
Petition CP-2009-1, Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area, District Growth Management Plan
Amendment - Bureau of Emergency Services response to questions raised during the Collier
County Planning Commission (CCPC) October 20, 2009 Transmittal Hearing
Collier County Bureau of Emergency Services received correspondence and phone communication from Mr.
Thomas Greenwood, Principal Planner for Collier County CDES regarding the Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation
Area GMP petition. Emergency Services staff has reviewed the petition in its entirety, which was heard by the
CCPC at its October 20, 2009 continued transmittal public hearing.
Collier County's Bureau of Emergency Services acknowledges that the site of the proposed "Dade-Collier Cypress
Recreation Area" is a remote wilderness recreation site and response times from both Collier County and/or
Miami-Dade County will not mirror typical urban or rural response times. Collier County has a standard
emergency response time for rural areas such that 90% of calls will be responded to in less than 12 minutes.
Estimated arrival times for fire and emergency medical services may range from 28 to 38 minutes, depending on
the respective availability of aircraft, ground ambulances and fire apparatus. It is not feasible or cost effective at
this time to mandate or provide on-site professional fire and EMS services or traditional level of service
standards for this location. Therefore, Miami-Dade County must provide adequate notice (e.g. on-site signage,
on-site orientation to visitors, brochures, website) so that occupants/visitors are aware of limited cell-phone
wireless communication networks at this site. Similarly, adequate notice must be provided to inform visitors as
to the location of a land-line phone to summons emergency assistance.
Collier County's Bureau of Emergency Services has no objection to the petition, but requests the following
stipulations be met:
1. That a primary helicopter landing site be provided on stable soils or suitable pavement materials, that Is
at least 125x125 ft. square for daylight operations only at or near a location that provides the primary
access to the ATV riding area. It should be noted that the Miami-Dade Jet Port or TNT (Training and
Transitional Airport) should be referenced as an alternative helicopter landing zone, not a primary, as
this is not a tower-controlled airport facility. Miami-Dade Parks and Recreation staff has indicated that
adequate soils or existing fill sites are sufficiently elevated for this effort. Collier County will make
available technical support for review and selection of these landing sites. However, if upon field
verification a suitable site cannot be found at the location identified as containing adequate soils at an
8075 Lely Cultural Parkway' Naples, Flonda 34113 . 239-252-3600 . FAX 239-252-3700 . www.collierem.org
Letter to Thomas Greenwood
November 9, 2009
Page 2
appropriate elevation, then a paved landing pad will be required at the discretion of Collier County with
all costs borne by the operator.
2. Miami-Dade County has stated that the park will be attended by Miami-Dade Parks and Recreation staff
when the site is open for wilderness ATV activity. Miami-Dade county reported that personnel would
be on-site and capable of first-aid and patient stabilization of an injured ATV rider. This first-aid effort
should include a suitable ATV or utility type vehicle that could be used to transport EMS personnel to
the accident/injury site, or transport a properly packaged and stabilized patient under the supervision of
EMS personnel to a suitable site for ground ambulance transport or helicopter. Miami-Dade Parks and
Recreation staff indicated it was likely that their park attendant would have off-road vehicle resources
for basic first-aid assistance.
3. Miami-Dade County's designated park attendant shall have radio communications, which shall include a
base station when a semi-permanent or permanent park office is established, mobile vehicle mounted
radio and hand-held portable radio all with both Miami-Dade County 911 and Collier County Sheriff's
911 frequencies. In addition, the site may want to have Federal and State Park and Forestry VHF
communications capability - funded by Miami-Dade County - as an alternative form of communication. It
was reported that cell phone coverage presently provided only by Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile may not
provide a completely reliable cell phone network for emergency communications. Miami-Dade County
Parks and Recreation staff indicated that additional two-way radio equipment could be acquired to
ensure communications with Collier County, Ochopee Fire, Federal Parks, or Miami-Dade County as
needed.
4. Should Miami-Dade County elect to conduct rallies, races, or other high capacity/high census events,
Collier County shall have the first right of refusal to provide on-site standby paramedic services in
accordance with Collier County ordinance.
After the first full year of operation, and annually thereafter, Collier County will evaluate the calls for service to
determine if the calls for service to the park warrant a change in response methodology. The re-evaluation
may, at the discretion of Collier County, generate a need for other supplies, equipment, communication
resources, or ATV type units or tools to ensure reasonable delivery of emergency medical care in this remote
setting. Such evaluation shall not affect the approval or long-term operation of the site by Miami-Dade County,
but shall mandate coordination and emergency response support from Miami-Dade County Parks Department
should It be needed for the continued consistent and safe delivery of emergency services by Collier County.
Miami-Dade County shall fund all reasonably necessary public safety needs Identified in the annual re-evaluation
as a means to facilitate the long-term operation of the site. Funding to address necessary public safety needs
identified in the annual re-evaluation shall be included and considered in the Interlocal Agreement being
proposed to be executed by Miami-Dade and Collier Counties, should the application be approved.
Letter to Thomas Greenwood
November 9, 2009
Page 3
In conclusion, Collier County's Bureau of Emergency Services, which includes in its Division, the Ochopee Fire
Department, Collier County EMS, Collier County MedFlight and the Department of Emergency Management, has
no objection to the petition but requests the above stipulations be considered.
Thank you.
cc: Mr. Leo Ochs, County Manager
Chief Jeff Page, Collier County EMS
Chief Alan McLaughlin, Ochopee Fire Department
Chief Pilot, Steve Adams, Collier County MedFlight Department
APPENDIX V.F.1
FEMA FLOOD ZONES
u
GULF OF MEXICO
i
c
"
o
,
~
CRS5
"
So.I.10 M".,
Legend
c===:I Collier County Boundary
c::::=:::lI Miami-Dade County Boundary
- Main Roads
,;C"~."\:;'_:J Everglades Nat'1 Park
FEMA Flood Zone
.............. AE ~ Base Flood Elevations Determined
. . 0 - Areas in which flood hazards are undetermined
- VE - Coastal Flood areas with velocity hazard
= X - Areas of 100-year & SOD-year floods
- X500 - Areas outside the 50Q-year floodplain
- ~ "-v>' _." ....:~.- .0,""","
>~v&rgl~<l~lQrj\l p~rt>
t C'~ ~. ::'> ~.,,:.
>
,',;'.-
MU
FEMA FLOOD ZONES
Appendix V.F.1
MIIIM$Wllln .AtJl)li'!a*-ln(_
APPENDIX V.F.2a
PROPOSED WELLFIELDS AND ASR
1
I
I
,
,
EVERGLADES CTY I
WELL_FIElD ~
~ ~-~7J
~ ~
~47 I
~~.-
ASP = I\QUIFER S.TORAGF AND RE~OVERY I
/
COLLIER COUNTY
WELLHEAD PROTECTION AREAS,
PROPOSED WELLFIELDS AND ASRs
I\?:
100
I ~ Jl
! '
i I
t(ff
"-c
CR 846
,
-----.J
u_-Tl
"k"~~;
I ""'\I/'CA
. ROAD
PROPOSED NOP-HEAS REGIONAL
ORANGETREE
Wt:LLfILLD
PHASE 1,\ W::LLo-IELD
AREAS 0'- IN1EREST
CR 858
"--
CTY OF N,:I,PLES
::AST GOLDEN GATE
WELL;:-IELD
('
,
CITY OF
NAPL=S
COASTAL
RIDGE
WE'_LFIEL:::
75
IN OPERAT'ON
SR 8L.-
!
'\ FLORIDA, GOVERNM[~TA_
UTILITY A~TciOR:TY GOLDE,
GATE ,^"A~[R 'REATMEN-
~\ PLANTWF_LcIELD
'" \
CO
u
'0
'>
~
T
JO
SCu TH ,..,AWTHOR'"
WELL,:ELD EXTENSiO\
(UNDER CO\STR'~CIION,
FALL 08 COMPLETION)
i<(
I"
CO
w
>
w
o
*
MANA-EE
ROAD
ASP
';
co
"'I
CO
~
_-L.
SCALE
'-_---'------I
,m
/;
~J
R-r A81LITY ,vE LS
(E_'VI,CKISH OR FRESCi WATER)
AMf_NIJED-JANlJARY25,
0'0. No. 2007-18
AME"DEJ - SEPTEIVBER 10. 200.3
Ord. No. 2lJCJ-44
~
~
*
AM::NDED-DECEMBER4,200!
Ord.No 2'JOI-b)
WFLL' ELD AREA
PREPARED 3Y, G'lAPhICS A'JD TECH'JICA, SUP?ORT S~CTION
COMMU~I~Y D[V[LOPIY,ENT AND E"VIRONME~ ~AL SERVICES DIVlSIG~
SOURCE, CO._L1[R COUNTY PO,XJTION CONTROL A'JD P'<~VENTION DEn
DATE: ',2/20~7 FILE. WFPZRI2-2007-1.DWG
V\10KALEE
WFUFIEW
CR 846
~--
1
I
+
I
I
~I
Bil
1
,
<1l
C;
'"
:>
~
Q
Z
[il
""
""
<I:
APPENDIX V.F.2b
to-YEAR WATER SUPPLY EXISTING
AND PLANNED WELLFIELDS
IZZl
LEE CO
COLUER CO
"
,
"
~
Z
!i
,
"
o
.
(CRSoW)
-' NI\PLESIt.lIdOKALEEROAD
.
> n
~ 1\
." <>Ro ~
~ z
1) I 3
,b <
"
~
~
.
1\
<
II
o 1.5 3
r"\- -
SCALE IN MILES
LEGEND
EXISTING RAW WATER
TRANSIdISSION LINES
PlANNED RAW WATER
TRANSIolISSION LINES
EXISTING WELLS
PLANNED WELLS
.
.
POTENTIAL FUTURE
WELLFIELD AREA
FIGURE 5-1
COLLIER COUNTY lO-YEAR WATER SUPPLY F ACIL TIES WORK PLAN
EXISTING AND PLANNED CCWSD WELLFIELDS AND RAW WATER TRANSMISSION MAINS
.Q
C'j
'"
:>
~
Q
Z
r>l
0,
0,
'"
APPENDIX V.GA
OWNERSHIP AND ENCUMBRANCE
REPORT
., lal1rlAmertca'
_ Ctlmmonwealth
Appendix V,GA
Hemisphere Title Company
6135 N.W. 167th St" Suite E-16
Miami, FL 33015
305-558-8628
305-558-2269
commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company
OWNERSHIP AND ENCUMBRANCE REPORT
Order No.: 1974B85
This will serve to certify that Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company has caused to
be made a search of the Public Records of County, Florida, ("public Records") as contained
in the office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of said County, from January 01, 1925, through
September 04, 2007, at B:OO a.m" as to the following described real property lying and
being In the aforesaid County, to-wit:
All of Sections 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 2B, South 1/2 of 29, North 1/2 of 32, all of
Sections 33, 34, 35, and 36, Township 52 South, Range 34 East, Collier County, Florida;
and, all of Sections 1, 2, 3, 4, South 1/2 of 5, North 1/2 of 8, all of Sections B, 9, 10, 11,
12, 13, 14, 15, 16, Township 53, Range 34 East, Collier County, Florida.
As of the effective date of this Report the apparent record Fee Simple title owner(s) to the
above described real property is/are:
Dade County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, by virtue of Eminent Domain
Proceedings filed in the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, In Case No. 315-196B, with
Final Judgments recorded In Official Records Book 296, page 1, Official Records Book 30B,
page 227, Official Records Book 308, page 247, Official Records Book 774, page 69, and
Official Records Book B03, page 1194, Public Records of Collier County, Florida, together
with additional Final Judgments filed within Case No. 315-1968 but not recorded in the
Official Records of Collier County, Florida.
The following liens against the said real property recorded In the aforesaid Public Records
have been found:
1. Ownership of oil, gas and minerai rights of Sections 21,22,23,24, 25, 25, 27, 28, Sl/2
29, N1/2 32, 33, 34, 35, and 36, Township 52 South, Range 34 East are as follows:
Marguerite R. Collier, Barron Collier, III, Lamar Gable, Frances G. Vlllere, Phyllis G.
Doane, Donna G. Keller, and Oleum Corporation, now known as Collier Land and Cattle
Corporation have an Interest in the following:
1/2 interest in oil, gas and mineral rights by virtue of reservation contained in Deed
recorded in O,R. Book 54, page 286 and Oil, Gas and Mineral Deeds recorded In O.R,
Book 160, page 11, O,R. Book 177, page 305, O.R. Book 884, page 1555, O.R. Book
949, page 367, O,R. Book 979, page 459, O,R, Book 12B2, page 70, O.R. Book 1413,
page 945, O,R. Book 1413, page 107B, O.R. Book 1482, page 79B, O.R. Book 1B38,
page BOO and O,R, Book 1900, page 172.
Ownership and Encumbrance Report
Page 1 of 3
Order No.: 1974885
Appendix V,GA
Steven P. Kushner, Successor Trustee has the following interest:
1/4 Interest In oil, gas and minerai rights by virtue of Quit Claim Deed recorded In
Q,R. Book 173, page 530, Assignment and Q\llt Claim of Powers recorded In O.R. Book
188, page 554, (Death Certificate recorded In O.R. Book 1169, page 1058 and O.R. Book
1334, page 895) Assignment and Quit Claim of powers recorded In O.R. Book 1169,
page 1059, O.R. 1172, page 2323, and O.R. Book 1186, page 1207, Assignment and
Quit Claim of Powers recorded In O.R. Book 1381, page 1724.
NOTE: Security Agreement recorded In O.R. Book 1381, page 1727 and UCC
recorded In O.R. Book 1381, page 1731.
Dade County has the remainder in these sections by Eminent Domain Proceedings.
2. Ownership of oil, gas and minerai rights of Sections 2, 4, N 1/2 8, 10, 12, 14, and 16,
Township 53 South, Range 34 East are as foilows:
Marguerite R. Coiller, Barron Coilier, 111, Lamar Gable, Frances G. Viilere, Phyills G.
Doane, Donna G. Keller, and Oleum Corporation, now known as Collier Land and Cattle
Corporation have an Interest In the following:
All oil, gas and mineral rights by virtue of reservations contained in Deed recorded In
Deed Book 30, page 106 as to Sections 2,4, 8, 10, 12, and 14, and Deed Book 30, page
113 as to Section 16, and 011, Gas and Minerai Deeds recorded in O.R. 51, page 77, O.R.
Book 160, page 11, O.R. 177, page 305, O.R. Book 160, page 43, O.R. 177, page 312,
O.R. Book 884, page 1555, O.R. Book 949, page 367, O.R. Book 979, page 459, O.R.
Book 1282, page 70, O.R. Book 1413, page 945, O.R. Book 1413, page 1078, O.R. Book
1482, page 798, O.R. Book 1838, page 800 and O.R. Book 1900, page 172.
3. Ownership of 011, gas and mineral rights of Sections 1, 3, S 1/25,9,11, 13, and 15,
Township 53 South, Range 34 East is as foilows:
Dade County has ownership of oil, gas and minerals by reason of Eminent Domain
PrOceedings and Final Judgments recorded In O.R. Book 731, page 1840, O.R. Book 744,
page 770 through 773, O.R. Book 755, page 222 through 225, O.R. Book 758, page 272
through 275, O.R. Book 761, page 441, O.R. Book 772, page 117 and O.R. Book 788,
page 1310 through 1312.
NOTE: There may be additional Final Judgments for possession as to oil, gas and
mineral rights that have been filed In the Eminent Domain Proceedings Circuit Court
Case No. 315-1968, Collier County, Florida, or in the Dade County proceedings that have
not been recorded in the Official Records of Collier County, Florida.
Public Records shall be defined herein as those records currently established under the
Florida Statutes for the purpose of imparting constructive notice of matters relating to real
property to purchasers for value and without knowledge.
Ownership and Encumbrance Report
Page 2 of 3
Order No.: 1974885
Appendix V.GA
This Report shows only matters disclosed In the aforesaid Public Records, and it does not
purport to insure or guarantee the validity or sufficiency of any documents noted herein;
nor have the contents of any such documents been examined for references to other liens
or encumbrances. This Report is not to be construed as an opinion, warranty, or guarantee
of title, or as a title Insurance policy; and its effective date shall be the date above specified
through which the Public Records were searched. This Report Is being provided for the use
and benefit of the Certified Party only, and It may not be used or relied upon by any other
party. This Report may not be used by a Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company
agent for the purpose of Issuing a Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company title
insurance commitment or polley.
In accordance with Florida Statutes Section 627.7843 the liability Commonwealth Land Title
Insurance Company may sustain for providing Incorrect Information In this Report shall be
the actual loss or damage of the Certified Party named above up to a maximum amount of
$1,000.00.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company has caused this
Report to be issued in accordance with Its By-Laws.
Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company
Ownership and Encumbrance Report
Page 30f3
....., lal1liAmerlca
_ Ctlmmonweflllh
Appendix V.GA
Hemisphere Title Company
6135 N.W. 167th St., Suite E-16
Miami, FL 33015
305-558-8628
305-558-2269
Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company
OWNERSHIP AND ENCUMBRANCE REPORT
Order No.: 1974885
This will serve to certify that Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company has caused to
be made a search of the Public Records of County, Florida, ("Public Records") as contained
in the office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of said County, from January 01, 1925, through
September 27,2007, at 8:00 a.m., as to the following described real property lying and
being In the aforesaid County, to-wit:
Parcell:
All of Sections 19, 29,30,31,32; the Southwest 1/4 and the South 1/2 of the Southeast
1/4 of Section 20, Township 52 South, Range 35 East, Miami-Dade County, Florida; and, all
of Sections 5, 6, 7, 8 Less and Except the West 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of said Section 8;
17, 18, Township 53 South, Range 3S East, Miami-Dade County, Florida.
Parcel 2:
The West 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 8, Township S3 South, Range 35 East, Miami-
Dade County, Florida.
As of the effective date of this Report the apparent record Fee Simple title owner(s) to the
above described real property is/are:
DADE COUNlY, A Political Subdivision of the State of Florida, by its BOARD OF COUNlY
COMMISSIONERS, acting as DADE COUNlY PORT AUTHORIlY, by Order of Taking recorded
In Official Records Book 6126, Page 248, Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida, as
to PARCEL 1.
The United State of America, by Quit Claim Deed recorded in OR Book 10666, Page 1786,
Public Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida, as to PARCEL 2.
The following liens against the said real property recorded in the aforesaid Public Records
have been found:
1. Reservation of a 1/2 interest in all 011, gas and other minerals as set out In Warranty
Deed recorded in Deed Book 4121, Page 35, Public Records of Miami-Dade County,
Florida.
2. Reservation of one-fourth interest in and to oil, gas and mineral rights as set out In
Warranty Deed recorded In OR Book 1048, Page 26, Public Records of Miami-Dade
County, Florida.
OwnershIp and Encumbrance Report
Page 1 of 2
Order No.: 197488S
Appendix V.G.4
3. Subject to that certain Quit Claim Deed for Mineral Rights and Royalty Transfer recorded
In OR Book 23016, Page 564 and OR Book 23016, Page 566, Public Records of Mlaml-
Dade County, Florida.
4. Subject to that certain conveyance 'of minerai interests by Personal Representative's
Deeds recorded In OR Book 14243, Page 176, and OR Book 14243, Page 179, Public
Records of Miami-Dade County, Florida.
5. Oil, Gas and Minerai Lease by Dade County, as "Lessor" and Hughes & Hughes, a
general partnership, as "lessee" recorded in OR Book 11668, Page 1358, Public Records
of Miami-Dade County, Florida.
Public Records shall be defined herein as those records currently established under the
Florida Statutes for the purpose of imparting constructive notice of matters relating to real
property to purchasers for value and without knowledge.
This Report shows only matters disclosed In the aforesaid Public Records, and it does not
purport to insure or guarantee the validity or sufficiency of any documents noted herein;
nor have the contents of any such documents been examined for references to other liens
or encumbrances. This Report is not to be construed as an opinion, warranty, or guarantee
of title, or as a title insurance polley; and its effective date shall be the date above specified
through which the Public Records were searched. This Report is being provided for the use
and benefit of the Certified Party only, and It may not be used or relied upon by any other
party. This Report may not be used by a Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company
agent for the purpose of Issuing a Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company title
insurance commitment or polley.
In accordance with Florida Statutes Section 627.7843 the liability Commonwealth Land Title
Insurance Company may sustain for providing incorrect Information in this Report shall be'
the actual loss or damage of the Certified Party named above up to a maximum amount of
$1,000.00.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company has caused this
Report to be Issued in accordance with Its By-Laws.
Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company
Ownership and Encumbrance Report
Page 2 of 2
Property Information Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.G.4
My Home
MIA~I'!)
; ill: 11 n't.!: l.la.JjJ!XI
Folio No.: m519.QOQ.OD10
Property:
Mailing Address: MIAMI DADE COUNTY
AVIATION OEPARTMENT
PO BOX 592075 MIAMI FL
33159-2075
Property Infonnation Report
Summary Details:
~
Primary Zone: 81300 UNZONEO
CLUe: 0080 VACANT LAND. GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Bathe: 0/0
Floors: 0 .
LIving UnIts: 0
Adj Sq Footage: 0
lot Sin: 640 ACRES
Year Bullt: 0
Legel Description: 195235640 AC ALL OF SEe tAKA PARCELS 1-19 THRU 57-19l.0T SIZE
IRREGULAR
Property Infonnation:
Sale Information:
~
Sale OfR:
Sale Date:
Sale Amount:
~~O
$0
Year: 2007 2006
land Value: $128,000 $128.000
Building V"lue: . $0 $0
Market Value: $128,000 $128,000
Assessed Value: $128.000 $128.000
Total Exemptions: $128,000 $128.000
Taxable Value: $0 $0
Ass.ssment Information:
I~se window.}
[Click here tQ..Er1n.t1
This report was created on 10/19120079:38:14 AM for reference purposes onl'(.
Web S~e @2002 Miami-Dade County. All rights reserved.
Property Infonnation Report
Page I of I
Appendix V.GA
My Home
MIAMI'!>>
.;ilI:7ilr'(th~.~
Folio No.:
PrOplillty:
Mailing Address:
Property Infonnalion Report
Summary Detells:
30-2520.000-0010
~
TIITF/FEDERAl GOVERNMENT
BIG CYPRESS NATL PRESERVE
3900 COMMONWEALTH at VD TALLAHASSEE Fl
32399.
Primary Zone: 8900 UNZON ED .
CLUe: 0080 VACANT lAND. GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Bath': 0/0
Aoora: 0
Living UnIts: 0
Adj Sq Footage: 0
Lot Size: 840 ACRES
Year Built: 0
legal Do.scription: 2052 35640AC ALL OF SEe tAKA PARCEl 1-20 THRU 16-20 LOT SIZE
IRREGULAR
Properly Information'
Sale 'n'onnatlon:
~
r'leO/RO
Sale Date:
Sill Amount:
I:
Year: 2007 2008
Land Value: $128,000 $128.000
Building Value; $0 $0
Market Value: $128,000 $128,000
As,essed Value: $128.000 $128.000
Total Exempl1oht; $128,000 $128.000
Taxable Value: $0 $0
Assessment (nformatlon"
~;U'tind~~'tll
[Q1ik!!J!!lLe 10 Printl
This report was created on 10/19120079:38:31 AM for reference purposes onl~f.
Web Sile @20D2 Miami-Dada County. All rig his reserved.
Property Information Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.G.4
My Home
MIAMI'!)
;jrh1iltl;l=lir~
Folio No.:
ProDerty:
Mailing AddTlI5S:
Property Infonnation Report
Summary Delalls:
30-2529-000-0010
Primary Zone: 8900 UNZON ED
CLUC, 0080 VACANT LAND- GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Baths: ClIO
Floors: 0
LMng Units: 0
AdjSq Footage: 0
Lot Size: 640 ACRES
Year Built: 0
legel Descrlptlon: 295235640 AC ALL OF SEe/AKA PARCELS '~29THRU 67-291 tOT
SIZE IRREGULAR
MIAMI DAOE COUNTY
AVIATION OEPARTMENT
PO BOX 592075 MIAMI FL
33159-2D75
Property Information:
~
Sale Information:
~
ISaIe OIR,
Sale Date:
Salt: Amount:
J~~
Assessment Information:
Year: 2007 2006
land Value: $128,000 $128.000
Building Value: $0 $.
Market Value: $128,000 $128.000
A8'GS$ed Value: $128.000 $128,000
Total Exemptions: "'28,000 $128.000
Taxable Value: $0 $0
~ktse window)
[Clk;k here loErintl
.-
This report was created Dn 10/19120079:44:19 AM for reference purposes onl~.
Web Sit. @2002 Miami-Dade County. All rights r.served.
Property Infonnatioll Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.GA
My Home
MIAMI'.
:iil1:1 ;ifli!=1"i!:J.1{J!XI
Folio No.:
Property:
Malting Addrua:
Property Infonnatlon Report
Summary Details:
ID530.00Q.Q010
Primary Zone: 8900 UNZONED
CLUC: ~OVACANTLAND.GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Baths: 0/0
Floors: 0
living Units; 0
A,dj Sq FootagCl: 0
LotSil'e: 640 ACRES
Year Built: 0
legal Descrlptlon: 3052,3,5640 AC ALL OF SEe JAKA PARCELS 1..30 THRU 45-30 lOT SIZE
IRREGULAR
MIAMI DADE COUNTY
AVIATION DEPARTMENT
PO BOX 592075 MIAMI FL
33159-2075
Property Information:
~
Sale Information:
~
IS8'8 O/R:
Sate Date:
Sale Amount
l~~O
Assessment Information:
Year: 2007 20Q6
land Value: $128.000 $128,000
Building Value: $0 $0
Markel Value; . $128,000 $128,000
N..ued Value: $128,000 . $128,000
Total Exemptions: $128,000 $128,000
Taxable Value: $0 $0
(fdQ:;e window]
[Click here to Print]
This report was cre8ted on 10/1912007 9:38:59 AM for reference purposes only.
Web Slt.@2002Miami-Dade County. All rights r8served.
Property Information Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.GA
My Home
MIAMI'ED
ill ~1iitt.kl.f::;tfJW
Folio No.:
Property:
Mallfng Addrus:
Property Infonnation Report
Summary Details:
30-2531.000-0010
~
Primary Zone: 8900 UNZONED
CLUe: 0081> VACANT LAND- GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Baths: 010
Floors: 0
lMng Units: 0
Ad) Sq Footage: 0
Lot Size: 640 ACRES
Year Built 0
legal Description; 31 5235640 AC All OF SEe IAKA PARCELS 1-31 THRU 23-3111.0T
SIZE IRREGULAR
MIAMI DADE COUNTY
AVIATION DEPARTMENT
PO BOX 59207~ MIAMI FL
3J15S-2075
Property Inform~tlon:
Sale Information:
~
Isa,. OIR:
Sale Date':
Sale Amount:
-1~~
Assessment Information:
Yea,: 2007 2006
land Value; $128.000 $126.000
Building Value: $0 $0
Market Value: $128.000 $128,000
Assessed Value: $128.000 $128,000
Total Exemptions: $128,000 $128,000
Taxable Value: $0 $0
{QlQ!le window]
[Click here to Print]
This report was created on 10/1912007 9:39:19 AM for reference purposes onl'(.
Web Site @ 2002 Miami-Dade County All rights reselVed.
Property Infonnation Report
Page 1 of J
Appendix V.G.4
My Home
MIAMI'!\)
. mJ:7i; l't'{:li t9.J;fJ:XI
Folio No.: ~
Property:
Mailing Address: DADE COUNTY. PORT AUTHORITY
PO BOX 59-2075 AMF MIAMI FLA
33159.
Property Information Report
Summary Details:
~
Primary Zone: 8900 UNZONED
CLUe: Q08() VACA!fr LAND. GOVERNMENTAL
BedslBaths: 010
Floors: 0
Living Units: 0
Ad) Sq Footage: 0
Lot Size: 1l40ACRES
Year Built: 0
Legal Description: 325235 640AC ALL OF SEG/AKA PARCELS 1-32 THRU 68.321 LOT
SIZE IRREGULAR
Property Information:
Sale Information:
~
!,"'eOlR
Sale Date;
Sale Amount:
I~~
Year: 2007 200S
land Value: $128.000 $128,000
Building Value: $0 $0
Market Value; $128,000 $128,000
Assessed Value: $128,000 $128.000
Total Exemptions: $128.000 $128,000
Taxable VlIl\Je: $0 $0
Assessment InformaUon:
l<;;JQoiUilP.Jk!Yd
~KlIer!lN.f.rJillI
. ~l
This report was created on 10/19120079:39:45 AM for reference purposes only.
Web Site @2002 Mlami.Dede County. All rights reserved.
Property Information Report
Page 1 of I
Appendix V.GA
My Home
MIAMI'.
jilklij1'tif:1.t~
Folio No.:
Property:
Mailing Address:
Property Information Report
Summary Details:
30.3505-000-0010
Primary Zone: 8800 UNZONED
ClUe: 0080 VACANT LAND. GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Baths: 010 .
Fk)ors: 0
Living Units: 0
Adj Sa Footage: 0
lolSize: 635 ACRES
Year Built: 0 .
legal Description: 55335 835A AC ALL OF SEe LESS ElY PORTION FOR LEVEE 28
RfW IAAA PARCELS 1-5 THRU 69-5/ LOT SIZE IRREGULAR
MIAMI DADE COUNTY
AVIATION OEPARTMENT
PO BOX 592078 MIAMI fL
33159.2075
Property In'annation:
J
Sale Infonnation:
~
S.IeO/R:
SaIeD.to:
Sale Amount:
~~:
Assessment Information:
Year: 2007 200.
land Value: $127.060 $127,080
Building-Value: $0 $0
Market Value: $127,060 $127,080
AJjsQssed Value: $127,060 $127,080
Total Exemptions: $127,080 $127,080
TII1UlIble Value: $0 $0
l.k12se windowl
[Click here to Print!
This report wa. created on 10/1912007 9:36:19 AM for reference purposes only.
We~ Site@2002 Miami-Dade County. All rights reserved.
Property Infoonation Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.GA
My Home
MIAMI,Et
; ilk I mf;f-, r.[:;;jftJ:J
Folio No.:
Property:
M21lling AddpiJ$$:
Property Infonnalion Report
Summary Details:
30-3506-000-0010 :
.'.
MIAMI DADE COUNTY
AVIATION DEPARTMENT
PO BOX 592075 MIAMI FL
33159-2075
Property Infonnatlon:
=J
PritnBry Zone: 8900 UNZONED
CLUe: D080 VACANT LAND-GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Baths: Of 0
Floors: 0
Living Units: 0
Ad! Sq Foolags: 0
Lot Size: 640 ACRES
Year Bui": 0 .
leg2l1 Description: 65335 640AC ALL OF SEe 'Al<A PARCELS 1.6THRU 55-61 LOT SIZE
IRREGULAR
Sale Infonnatlon:
~
1"'" OIR.
Sale Date:
Sala Amount:
I:
Year: 2007 2006
Land Value: $128,000 $126,000
Bu~dlna Value: $0 $0
Market Value: $126,000 $'2S,000
Asliessed Value: $128,000 $'26,000
Total Exemptions: $128,000 $128,000
Taxable Value: $0 $0
Assessment Information:
[QIQ.se window!
[ClIklLbpre to Print]
This report was created on 10/1912007 9:36:46 AM for reference purposes only.
Web Site@2002 Miami-Dade County. All rights reserVed.
Property Information Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.GA
My Home
MIAMI'!)
j nb1 i jiM, r.1 'hjJ:JY
Folio No.:
ProDarty:
Mailing Addran:
Property Information Report
Summary Delalls:
30_3507..000.0010
Primary Zone: 8900 UNZONEO
CLUC: 0080 VACANT LAND- GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Beths: 010
Aoors: 0
uvlng Unlb: 0
Mj Sq Footage: 0
Lot Size: 640 ACRES
Yelr6u1lt: 0
lflgal Description: 75335 640AC ALL OF SEe tAKA PARCELS 1-7 THRU eO-7 LOT SIZE
IRREGULAR
MIAMI DADE COUNTY
AVIATION DEPARTMENT
PO BOX 592075 MIAMI FL
33159.2075
Property Information:
~
Sale InformatIon:
3
IS.'. OIR:
Sale Date:
Saki Amount:
I~:
Veer: 2007 2008
land Value: $128,000 $128,000
Building Value: $0 $0
Market Value: $128,000 $128,000
Assessed Value: $128,000 $128,000
Total Exemptions: $128,000 $128,000
Taxable Value: $0 $0
AsselSmenllnformetlon:
~:;JLwindowJ
1QJk:.!IJ!e.r.g.llLEJ:inll
This report was created on 10/19f2007 9:37:01 AM for reference purposes only.
Web Site @ 2002 Miami-Dade County. All rights reserved.
Property Information Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.GA
My Home
MIAMI.a
i i 1 h 11 i IM:r;f9J:ij:JY
FolIo No.:
Property:
Mailing Address:
Property Information Report
Summary Details:
3o-3508.QOQ:QQ!Q
Primary Zonu: 8800 UNZONED
CLue: 0081 VACANT LAND
Beds/Baths: 010
Floors: 0 .
living Unlls: 0
Ad] sq Foo1age: 0
lot Size: 68 ACRES
Year BuIlt: 0
legal Description: B 5335 66 AC MIL RfWTHRU E1/4 OF SEC FOR LEVEE 28 tor BIZE
IRREGULAR
SOUTH FLA WATER MANAGEMENT 0lS1
3301 GUN CLUB RO
POBOX 24680 WEST PALM BEACH FL
3341S4680
Properly Information:
~
Sale Information:
~
lSale O/R:
Sale Dale:
Sale Amount:
I:
Assessment Information:
Year: 2007 2006
Land Value: $13,200 $13,200
Building Value: $0 $0
Market Value; $13,200 $13,200
Assessed Value: $13,200 $13,200
Total Exemptions: $13,200 $13,200
Taxable ValuQ: $0 $0
[Q12Le window!
[Click here t<lY-linll
This report was created on 10119/2007 9:37:16 AM for reference purposes only.
Web Site @2002 Miami.Oade County. All rights reserved.
Property Information Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.G.4
My Home
MIAMI'!)'
;(Jf.:1jjJM'l't~
Folio No.:
Property:
Mailing Address:
Property Infonnalion Report
Summary Details:
30-3517.000-0010
Primary Zone: 8900 UNZONED
ClUe: 0081 VACANT LAND
Beds/Blllhs: 010
Floora: 0
Living Units: 0
Ad} Sq Footage: 0
lot Size: 74 ACRES
Year Built: 0
Legllll Desorlptlon: 17533574.28 AC MIL RIWTHR\J E1/2 OF SEe FOR LEVEE 26 lOT SIZE
IRREGULAR
SOUTH Ft.A WATER MANAGEMENT DIST
3301 GUN CLUB RD
POBOX 24680 WEST PALM BEACH FL
33416-4680
Property (nfonn_tlon:
j
Sale In'onnatlon:
~
Sale OIR:
Sale Oate:
Sale Amount:
~I=
Year: 2007 200S
land Value; $14.858 $14.856
Buildin9 Value: $0 $0
Merket Value: $14,856 $14,856
Assessed Value: $14,856 $14,85a
Total Exemptions: $14.856 $14,856
TaKoble Value: $0 $0
Assessment Information:
lCJ.Qu-Y!.lnl!9wJ
[Click here 10 Print}
Oil
This report wa" created on 10/19120079:37:33 AM for reference purposes only.
Web Site @2002 Miami-Dade County. All rl9hts reserved.
Property Information Report
Page 1 of 1
Appendix V.GA
My Home
.;ilh7iirti!-:1..t~~
MIAMI'.
Folio No.:
Property:
Mailing Address:
Property Information Report
Summary Details:
30.3518.000-0010
~
PrImary Zone; 89QQ UNZONED
CLUe: 0080 VACANT LAND-GOVERNMENTAL
Beds/Baths: 0/0
Floors: 0
Living Units: 0
Adj Sq Footage: 0
Lot Size: 840 ACRES
Year Buill: 0 .
legal Description: 185335640 AC ALL OF SEe/AKA PARCELS 1-18 THRU 13-18/ LOT
SIZE IRREGULAR
MIAMI DADE COUNTY
AVIATION OEPARTMENT
PO BOX 592075 MIAMI FL
33159-2075
Property In'annallon:
Sale Infannatlon:
==l
Sa Ie OJR:
Sale Date:
Sale Amount
3:
Assessment Information:
Year: 2007 2_
Land Value: $128,000 $128,000
Building Value: $0 $0
Market Value: $12P,OOO $128,000
AsSO$sad Value: $128,000 $128,000
Total EKemptlons: $128,000 ~128,OOO
1811l1bls Value: $0 $0
Ucl2Jill wlndo'N}
LClidnere to Prjnll
J."
This report was created on 10/19/2007 9:37:47 AM for reference purposes only.
Web Site@ 2002 Miami-Dade County. All rights reserved.
&DIM'
m G126',.., ?Vl
-.
OHlW:H1~:l1lmd AD.lUnGI';)) n6 rollow~:
J. TIlIH Com'l hnH ,1urlmllcthm of theMe! lJ1'O~('odhlltH.
2. 'J'h~ p1rn.HlIRl\ ill thill CllUHfl Rn!' }illCfirjC'IlL
3. 'rhe l'(.11I1I1IH'I' IH IU'OI'CI'1)' c~IJI'cl/llllg \Ill tl(llt!l~nl('(1 nlllhlll'il~',
01. 'rh(' PI'lIliulwr I'i\l\ Illnlle' n t(tHld fullh ('f11i1'llltt' (d \'111111', hrl1lt'tl
\11)011 n \'nlhll\lll'l"l\I:/'11 of I'udl ll:ll'l'l'l In lh(' Ill,(U.('t'llint!.
G. Snhjl~c~t In tlu~ Ilmlhn'u IWI'.lin /:It.hlll, 11\1' l'l'llll(lIll'I' hl,('nIUh.1I
'0 l'ofill('flIdoll (If lIu' 1)I'lllll'1'Iy lU!I'('inaHf'I' dl!ur.rilwd 111'101' 10 final Jmlf('lwlll
UpOll IIn eh'\lul:U In t1w 1'~I-!I!lIl'.Y of lhilt ('0\11" or /l\u-h mllll of 11l1ll1l'Y /l~ will
full,>' ""('Iln' /tllel rull')'{'omp~llttltltJ till' lWl't:llllt: t'l\llllf'llll) ('tlllll'l'nlllll;llll nr:
\Ill1nluh'ly c1l'h'I'l1lhll'll h)' rh ,1 JIIIII!nwlIl, 11\1' Jl,nll\f' 11Io\IlH lH1I h,lt!1 IhuH 1111'
nmnlllllllf Ill\' I't'tlll(llll'I,It> I'Hlilllnh' Ilr \'nhll',
G. 'Ihl' ("'III't Ih""I'llIilll'li lhnl ti,l' ll\llll elf 11111111';'. WI l".,t"il.'l'll II:
Om' t.lIll1f1H "'01'1)' ()IU' Thl\\wr'l1l1 NiI\.. IIl1nlll'I'" F1hy f$l,IJ.ll, \\;',0\ 1),,'11"'11
'/, 1111111111:"'IIII'IU 11\' Ill\' 1','ll1i'lIl1'I' "f ~;ai"'h'llll:'I', IIH'd.,r"I\,I:'I\!':
Rhllll fnl'lhwllh 1:1I1'1"'Il.h'I'l'tl~;HI'I;:!11I1l 10 iiII' 1"'11111111"1', willi tI,., I'Vt"l'\1111ltlll
11I"",'(lIl\fll.'I'I1"'I"1.
0, Iln'nl'lli:th"~'ul'f\nlhl'lhllldlll:nrl;:lillllt'I''':~d. 1111 Iii\!' 111'111"'1"1::1
hl,,'~'ln;.rh'I' ':I,.,'c'ifil,t1I:11n11 "t'!:! in 1111' 1'l'lilh'lH"', 1)-\111-: ("Il'\ I Y, 11
11"11lkllllilll'lIl\'llilnll or Un' :-tUttI' tl( FlOI'I.J:l. nutlIHli.llnnd.. 1;l1nlll..' .1t"'I..I'"
t(1 hi' f.'OIuh'lIl1l1'fll.lullnIlC'lI r(ll' tlll' 11I11' fir IIIl' 1'1'IlIlnlll'l', nll,JIIII'l'il'I'; ,..
t:tHJ1'Il'Jllintlun fill' 1Il1' ~llIl\f' tlhllll VI'I:l In IIIl' I,,'nallll: "lIlllh,1! 1111'1'1'1,)
P. ^, nll,\' thill' 111'11'1' hI 1111' I-ntl')' or (illnl 111"1:11I"111, 1111' p:..'lll'll
(,11\ll1e'lI \h<"I'1'11I IllR;\' wllh.h'll\\' lht, nnll\l'll ,II Ih'I';1I,1'1'11 MIIIl"lWjol"11 I,,' 1;,\,.'
10, If t:nill dl'JlOllil Iii lint m:uI1' wilJ.inlw('IIIY d:\Y~1 fl'llIll lit.. ..11......
nf Ihls (Il'Ch'I', 1111", unlt'I' Hhnlll11' \'11111 nll.lllf Ilil hll'lht'l' hn'I'(' n,' II!"h "~
I J. The lith' 01' 11111'I"";! 1'1Ha,ill/\ h~' 'hll, nl'oI"I' i:; Ih" rull :",'
atmplC' lillf' In tI'I' InmIHIH'lloI'lnfll'l' 111'~~l'l'ihl'i1 ...dlh IIii' (''>;I'l'l'lillll ..r 11:1'
r(lllowlnw
-2-
.~
r.~~;~~t\t'il*
;\\.~'~'M!.~ ~ J~
WL~~nl; rf~u. -&,"
!r~i~J!ilrll.(o.l\:
T"" iI'~f~. ~t;.", ~.
t,w~l IIllnI "1;'lIblfl
r.f~L: II.
Th. N 'nllhr & ....
:IIW ~ ~~Ik>n I lIr>1W..
n "Il~ "aiL
'!l\l' 0 ~~ ",Ilt
t... I TC:tMI'
!!lr /Y,llolJ."
I,'~ I' tI'~;1~ II>
Jjl~,\ r~ ,:.:~I~~,\.':r.
. ,.';~':\'~[' I ,,..
rr.;t II~ Ill. tv I ..1 "'i'lloo
\I, f1"'1l11,11l111""lh,Il'".'
...1.
Th1' r.\'\.Io'~r';llt4~~,! ~ ,..
.h,,'.. Ih, Rwn (I l\t,IlM
"' 1W1""'tl."Ili"'I.. RI,II."
. u:1J.lIi'}:1 "~.
I"" 1'11;', "I ~r Il" "'I"
r\\"~CfM<'rll.II'~I""\'ill'
I \I'');lll\ln~'l~ I~ 111ll.
T'", K'\. co\ 1~" M\\"I ..r 11..
f'l":!!..'" ,"" In",,, """""l
~~. t?.::,'''lIlJ1 n "',"lh. Iln~.
'1011I'1-\1'1-.1'
~.. h. ""< '''''1'' I"
Wl:.i,if1h.IlJ:1i ,. ","'IIft
, 11'1<'\' ~11li"1l , Ill.....
,,'
lr1.~t1I1JiI\ll1rl'H\\,; I( '~fI
:.0 n:"tt::II"" ~\~,'It."'h1"
~1,.t1',r....~..'"
m:\~''''I''tY,II''IIl''
r ",.""", ~..,..,",
'1' r1V'~!I~~1t ,r~'1
1"- II', .,r~" J1'11 111M'
r~11. ,,11lo'1"'~ l~ ",.,,,1",,
."llh)tI\\!"-!il'~ 1'.1\0'
,."",,:~.f ,~,i ,\,'. ,'111_
I,.n I'! ,,,.,,,1'11' ~, II...""
"'1l'1.'},1;~i~I'~' .
"lf~I", 1."l"'I!l'Iln.,
rr......"f 'P'I.M 1~1 T'""""""
"'~'I~\'t.l~'" 1\ t:~'1
m" " \l,. ~l, I'll '"
J},fl, l!t~,~ Ifln 1 TI'II>I"CI'
1 lL'it;itf\\~r.'{,:; .~,,\ 1
I.... \\,1, ~I ,h, .r.l; 1'1 .he
t:\\'~!I~IIt'lh'"'' T...wnl~11'
, 'l'A.III~':r..~I.}~ r..,'
Il'~ !;Ir '.1 1"~ N\'I. '" ,..~
.1' ~.::h.Il'll~~:..' ~\~;~;""
n~ 1I\:rl,~r^k" ~~t:'I' .'1 1.'i1'
ii ~!..:lJ. Iln.~~ ~~ 1::','" II
:r~ lI~tll~:n't.!'" Jh: ,.r Ih"
~r~,,~~,~,i~::~~ ':\ ~~,:,.""II'
", II~A~~r~t:. \,.t:.. .., ~
lIr.ti.'I.I'..n'onr",:,i.....,l.'tP
r.Jl""'lh ",,,.,,il:l:..,
. :li'i':'''; .'r~'" ,:..I~.'.~.I;. . .
)....'...':\.1....'
T~' NO, "'>I'~ Ilc.\"'lItr,
\t.~.~ l'~~r .11' ~ I'M'"
ffi "~~~~;r.:,:~.."It~ .., III,
.~ 1'\' tllllll ,....1."10111
, 'UI'~. hfl," .:..1
~. .H~I~'f\J,!ll' .1 ",.
1l!.-t.I..,IM ..-".!.IP
-... tn... 0111.
ll' '[':I"~!: m.., ,
II:" ....I*' !M,~ 'T"..n'~~l'
...~I I\ltn,. . ,....'1
J"'...!W~/l,..K~'.~;
r,...;..~"a5'r.:",
t~.~~tR~'t:I~,1-:w,t .., I t
.,W.c..\t. "It~c;1 n 1~:i~'I~1'
J1:I.Ji~..rt'/ll.:ll)." ..,
trLi~;.:i; i J.W'i~~;
I
.",1.."'.61....."..
-. c~iro--
X!JI uo\,v~ or
Ilf, '\l u~.... ex
I' c....
Ii' L\I\, ;.\i"I"
v.nl "'111.11'
, "a!\ ".
'k" "'M 'N...'I"
r.''i4.'.W'i'~ 'l'::t""
~..~. i{,il>..~'%I' 1l
RM ,~\o.: bl.~... \...
5~' vi 'hi 1''''1; I<l ,lor NJ:
~1 IN&\lotllt\'ll..nl'~
p tllIoIiih. IWIII ...
vI.
\~M'ff.I..\lt
y\~lr~ l.clt. t.i.~ '-::1I1.'lP
r.lfl"\llh,lln,,,,,,'\:.'C'I.
~"I."~~I"'~ji:">~\'=lI_" I"
~:\ ~\It~.~~,o::..'\ 'g~ ~
'thl N~'~'lgY.&.l'J~\v.. of'M
r.l~*."ft'~~O\:". % l!l':~f"P
l'AIlCI:!,JII
T~~.,f\\'~"'IiWtl."'l:It
~ \I<i\lr~, 11'':,~~ 1I\' t:L' fl
l'AlL~lI;l, II-n:;
~\! r~~ ,'I,}l't 'VV'" r'f
~1 ~,\flh."~.1n1t T&::.'~
Th llK~ll~rlih~~~~DI 110- I
NW'i ..'""'11.." II. ","~,t I
n '1\11"". 1I11nllr n .,.'1,
1....Iil.r\\II.lt" !
~h1: tI :~ ,i " ii-~ " 11" I
~,W~1"~~.tcyj~\W,I-U V;:::.IIll'
"J:"'l"~'i\~f.t I'
,.,h' ~ fll..' i: ~1!ll~"
"~~.lIlt.II" till ,1'."".
"~.r 1l1;...~~\I'\:~!,. 11;\~"" ..t ", I
:i'W'i I'll " r:~ &1 klllM
~.T""','I'fI.:l;"'I...ll.""
. I:H::.\li'I:I.I!'" I
r.t NIt ,'I llo, I\~~ "I I'" I
1.;~'11'~'11~'~' ~ni..f".K,~~.,,; ~
.~ t.." .
1 1'''1\\'1'1 I;~'
IThfIlK""T\hr l:11Iofl'.
~I.~, "I 1\<"".' I, T'i....". 'If'
rl I".ll~ ~ ~ Kr~, I h,l.
TII, ttr., 'J~,~ ..I II."
~M;." ltl~ 'I,,,,"hl,,
AJI'- !)"'<lII,
'I'll.. K" .of U..
~1"'~ I ~ ~f::~'I'I"
t~.. "'\"1" I .. A\~" d ,,... !
f/:I~ "'I toll.." ,.. t.......I'IP I
I~'tk'!ll~~~i.l~\ ......1
~h" N\l" " Ih',\\''t ..t'h.. .
,,'.', 1 "." , T......". \
,1\0>,,'" ~~1'-( U I'..'
~" I~.'II~. ,~i~"''4 ..f II'
wl"'f,r"'I\t't.~,..,...ItI"ll'
I 1li''il,~,\'r'l''t)..' r...'
Th..N\V ",lito .'1; "111'''\
~\\"l "III<,'I.,n 1\ ;:......'11\11
.1 "'~!"'Il~ll!i"rl'i; I',H
~I,. NII'l... ,h~ I'W'I 1-1 1M
~i\\'I'''k"''1''''''I'- 1',~''''''fI
, "1\ 'n~,~r;"i~ I~ ,I t
~~ r" ~..\. lll~ WII III., I
~ ~,,:;t 1~~::,I,,~~i"fI
'....lIf'r.l,..11
"'t,p"" ~.r"'l..,'h. l
N~.i'o:n:l~~. ~~"""nl. ~n~~ :
1\.:..1
I. .\'^':,fli,.-1l-tt. I h.
J\\f!j "\Ihr-N\Vfl..tlr,"1..11
\t'r.,~~l\l)It'U 1'4>11111. 111"1/'
tti.fr:\,'~Kli.l~\\~ "I I"
u~tt.~~;:.~, ~<;:tl"1\
'I'1\t.J1tya!t\l\"~~\1f. (I' h
wvi2JL~~. '\'~ 'F),t~~~IP
Il' .'.'.!II~fM'~e' (.r ,,,.
~... :,l,\;hIM 1 ~.TL"""
N' IIoRl'1o. nl"'" ""'1.
fr.. 1~~Ft~lII:l:Jl I'll"
r... ..1'''0<111'0 1,..,ll~I\O~"
11IiN'.. RIII<<- 'ti...
t'n~'b, "'J~
~.}rlt';:l':j'i:~~
.!i'D./I!
,,'I ' I lit:
f}"IU""' l.i/, *-."
t~\, '!f'~~."il'l ~'"Il:
!D. ':t.."'....1t~ lr~t". ~.n.f
II Ji:UJIARC~~ I~
II 'i:1 r 1'& ,\".
H:~~T."l~r,l u Jl,i\~~
,"n..~~
Tho"~"\' "'~l"
":t;"1 It.. W .11 ""
. 01:111111: D IhI W
..f ~Ugn ~ l:""hlP ~
11<'1111>. n~~r SU.!F;'
It\' I,l 1\1 It~
'W ~ ~4>W'
'-I .ril1llp ~,
SDII\II. u.
~~t I I ':ul:
. M ",,'..
,I),
~ji;t.il~"i;-ii M,: 'ii;'):\1\:-"
....~~F.'1S'k.i. :;-:I'~:
Flr'rW'l"rtfl'lDI\ ~U"I"h11'
, ~~'};nJI":'~\' JI~I\.
In ,,\1\1 1 Ill'"
'Ill:ll;;j' ,.')".,,,, I\lIJ'I'~'
l,,"i '. I ~\l}l' ~;,.
'''I''\~; '."...
"" ""W"~'I""'''M'
"~"..\ I" .....
n, NI~~!' H' . "I"'"
NW'I "I " r. ' 'lIU"
~ ~""1~ I', "'lIh.. ~~.".,
""\',\IjCt:l.~" .
Ir. "." "~ "'I ,"~
, .illl~ r. 1 II 11I'1"'''''
" ~"W"'hlll 1\i'~11", II"".
.:..1.
.. N~~Il:,tll'lti1.:11i ,'1 ...
*'v~.t\o..,.t1"lI'.:""T~'"
"'11'~l11ttl'.r.nn . .
Ttt,NW1, "III" Nl-:'\ qllho
~~~II ll'~1 It. Nt:l, "I '''''
\~~.., ,h'I'I\\" 1'1 F:l:rU""
. 1".1'1.\.11' ",,,,\0111,. 11......
, bIOI
T.... wl?I\"'::,~ 'S~"" ..111.t'
~\\'" "f~",\,,,, n~ J".""""
lI'-"1"1I~t1ti~iri'~t;"1.
'I" 1I~~ "I I~' it\\"1 1,111"
~\'I, I" "...11,'""'. '1',,\....111\.
.1"'''I'''I,'lVWII~'''I:~''
,.... "it, "I'\',~ 'I~' II..
,NW', ,d i=,tIMI' I' ,.","11'
I )O",l~. lI",r' ~\ ~.ftl'
... ,,\;i\l\~nit:.rv.'ll~ h,
~WI. "lll...II.lIL:I'. T...",I.II'
~11I'''lllt. IIM'p' l\ I'll',
~.. J:"'I~~I'.iltl"t\t.. , 1M .
\~Il'~ ... t:li "t l!:.lIur
, ''''\h'''II.RII,nll'' 11.....'
.~ ,.....1
Nlh'f-llI:l!
Jh. \' 1'1 \,,~ r.W\ '" 'l'
~U:~~, IIr.. ~.:\'\ . uf ..~
lit:!!jl WIINll~,\.lI"I,,1..1l
~I"'I\I ft, IhhCf ~ ".".
1~ lI~~.~\IL':I:~~~"'~1:~ 111 ...
S'I..IJ ,,'~.. ,,,,,!.1i1l_"'~'
"I'"..lh. Ih"_~ tnl.
I. '1l1'.~I' I":")
tu " .I. "I n~ s:,.~ "I ~"
~i':~lU~L.~litllC~ VI"'::I~' 'I'
1'''lI\'I:'If~
T~, Nt."-~' Ihr . :~..!r ~1ofI-
~f-~'\I'i1. H~:n f i..;I~" II'
h,. "ff"ll1i.tti':'~S III .
Y't:II" ~\'I''''' I 'f".l"l~
~'J .....'1. 1."1It 'r.ul,
1"Ull'r:\LI~~
1'1" "":~"I l~' .WI, "'I'"
NI:I\" H. '1 '~.
,,111.11\'" "I ,. r.'"J
r~~ JP'f1 ";:/ I;: llVhl'~~
11"11 n. T"""I'Ji. a~fk;t11r.;
I.... HI.,..
E". ,J.;t:~~h'~dn'l ,I 'hI
W.."'....'11"" . "..".MfI
,NNI...II.".. ;.,,1
t&tllC~Ib."~
~,r.,,\':l.~. ~~,mr.
~'ilWbi. "tn.. ".11.
Xll.!'~\I'~\\:j't. ~ ~'
p .....ff..~~\.":,~:rc.~~ I,
1ll...~W\l'~r\1ol';I!, . ,,,
\\w,,'it~:J. *\ 1J:.rc~lP
Exhibit II A 11
~\I~'IIt~ffl~..m~
l:U 'l.f J3;
\\"1 . B&I'.
'~\I~i~~: \ 'Uk::::
1&-.. '1{i'i!!'~li~ " J"
n.1:.~" nw\'\p '~LT., ~I\i:
iAnl'!Il:~1I
Tho ..\~, 1 'It" I"
8W\I ul "" At,,,'1"
n. 'rllWU,'" , nuolt
1:..1,
R.\J;~~f~~I,."ll$' " \"
F. 07\H .t;' or on
IIwn_klp :l~'III,'ltrnu
Jl~\\'lll:F.I.JN'II
nt. ~l\ I~I 'hk,l'~l Al~:
1I.'""'''''hrp~liCl'''I''' ""n.'
tull
w.' ,Mnyri~ ~~l'~~ "I lbf.
I "'I Nt:1 n Mo'I'I~1
. tg....",&I'~, ,nil.. ,,~nll"
f~l'I~A1\1''''1 :ll-tl
1M Iollt n! \hr,.r., I,ll""
J: i -~~ 1I~~ll."hll'
" ""I'J"
1 \' ., ""
'I' 1'111",""
nw,' II \l~' llll'II"
.~'
'liI'.I,a:!
l!r.'N;J\j:JI1"'~WI,\,"ltlw
tf"'A. nll'rlll~':;Pf "l'l'Iwndll"
Itll'llll~~:~' ~'l':]' t:.~1
N~; \" I 1:'''' ltot
,I N III. . ulfiM)
t:tl\\l11l1>l11 I.lIltt.,~\O\n!l"
r.0\";II"\"I'3'c.:fl
T" II'", l'~ ~1:'l"1 ~I'
1:1..::',,~1.':;, ~,\I".."V",1l17..~.~
:\":11'1
'lit ~,~II.I';'~'t:~"N1h, lOr lilt
Iw', "~I ~,.,'Il,'n ".' ,."",,~I"I'
"l1l""ll~l\\~~f' ~~lM"
1l~:" ..I Ikr \'11 ,It '1>9
IN,. 101 ~'f'l"" ,''tl'''''''l'
tr"'Pllh. It'''l.~ 1:..\
11It N\~'MI~:r- ~:I' ~VI, I" to'
Il-W'!" h'.\l"n """.".1.1\'
t4 f\i"\t'. It.n.. .~ 1:""
)' '.,II,~tr:JI~:=tJ~'11 ..I th,
t'~~,,~"C"U""l.oj T""UOkUl
t . 'IU%~r."n~.t,'n
Tftl' If:>.., 11.,. ")~II ,,' I'"
~w,~ ,,1 I"" H\"l " t\"'1 "'~
'.r~''''hllll' ~, ~"I'h. Il.uo..
, I.,X
....,11.1.1. 'J('
,1I."III'nlt b\'
t""1 "I II" n\~1 "t It..,l,.,
5 TI,..".I.II,}I1t.\I,'h 11..1'''
oUr."I. IU'I: .I~'
Th" ..f ""I, .Il'i ~ I"
Hr.\ n I, \Y'i" ,I...
~ t",,",tll,.U\I'dllh. ,.."""
:t: ""'~'i"nr.I:I.IA-:tI
"" nl Ihf 111\" I ll~'
~I'" I~r M'l\'" 'l~"'I"'n
j". 'f.......1011. ~ ...~., l1~IlJ~
\J:MI.....1I.1:1 n."
Tn, tikI, to' 11" NI:.\..I II...
lIW'; "'ll"lI,'ll~.Ti<",,,'''II'
w lI'l'I\" l/:l'r'~ ~ ",,\
ftt\AII~", ~. 'iI"", .~ ".'
n:f~ "1 '1''''" flIi. Tr-:'"lhl~
n "~\~i'I\<<I'rJ.-~ ,"'1
1'lt"Ir.\o.."i,<i~'~", ",..
.~ ~ trlll", fl ;\~'''h.10111
"'II~'\lll'r/.I'J~':.'1
rh~ !I~I. "blk'.fl~ III 'k'
ir\~.~"..:i.i'i'~1"1\ ):~~i"hlr
1'"III~I'''.tt
H't "'I"''''. HW'; "'I"
Yo " III II" nl ~,,'l ,,"
. ~,'."'l'l;. lot ~.~,lt.. 'I~""
I:ut
I lIr"'~ni'~ "t1~'QI' ,,' I"
R-~~ "" ~I' ., ..rl '"
. ",ltl'" Ih.'l,",r
...t.
1.....In:\ ,'.111
Ih' Ha'. i>f L. :-VW11 1.1 tllr
u.,~~" "'J~::'..: ~l't.~~:. '"
11l~ "W\l'~~M"\\'~ " II'
ifjl.i::l.,"~,,~ n'r1.,i.M ,
f.~;Fr>~l!il :;\\~
','
~~1i~
L~lI.fJ.~k' :'~'.'
il.'~~:t!ii " \I'
I) I!,~ 1 I. ~
~. '" ....' ~Jl.~.~:
i'1.'"i .~~_~~~:
ft.,~l\ltJ..KaIll.
j,l<d&'~fll.~r::
.._~
lllJ" C~'~"t\.
u~M l~'~"
wJ~~' "..Ill
'"I' ~t,t~~ t, "',d::
~.~IU,\;'rl n'~'1I
r.u~~ .c..~ "."
"II S 11I\ llW I lit
ti~kt...\.'; }:i\..,l ~~~r.
l1IL,k".li''J:,;IIJl!!.~I~
ljlo~~U'ir."~'il;!.
I'" ~nh~l. ,I 01 hI
n'IO\.:f'hl1l 1l~''''IlII!l,.
p ""wIll. Iknlt ':"11,
""';;;,'i.;l~:~iH..jl.~ iC"
n -S"~'-C-~';~:;"-'-'
bt H re I' )"
I; r nun
~. ':.'t;!" 11"" wU. lI~nn
.. lll;":r:r~;~.n:~" I'"
I~; l.\ ", 'ft:. I' N.fIOll
ft~"~IlI5JAYI.lhl1l"
111~."li!\U'I\)',~f.' " '"
J!G\t :r ...Jht.re '9\ S'!.,{l~~
t ;c'.r"~'I' ~:. Funlh, h."~'
0&11.A1I1'f:I.!.:1ol
"l,~ N\\"I pI \t>>o ~w~ "I It...
IU;l....1 ".~II,'u,).1 tu,,,.I,1I1
~ Il""W"'llt~~r.r,~\ I....
T... ~',' \'1 t"" ~,;... I" tt,~'
lf~!t." HtS\\'li ,,11to,II'1I
n:f""''''~'''''! R.11'11\, 1I..~"
n..n\""ll1'l:'.:.S'I
'r..." I III ''''' SH'!.!,I th,'
1Cr:." u 110. N\\"I, " ",,'llIIn
:p, =I....n.'''p ~I ~~ul , 11l1',"
""1;.'\"111'1'1.,.,\
no. reI, "IIII\' N\'{ pI IItf
"'1:\ II \~., (\'W\. I' P"....\I~"
;,1. t!1,'''''''hlP H 1\11I1 '~~Il~
'.\ '.'I~.\I~L'r:', ~~
ntl'll>: 11.'.}5W\lI'II"f
Hr...."" Ihr Ih\', nf ",.U"'"
I",. ,,,,"'1'111' l~ :t....h. 1l.1'~"
. "'I',Ull'I:I,U.>>
TI.. \\', "I IIt~ NW~ 1'1':'>'"
W~~'I:i~ 'J!~~l'"~''' r. :<"II'h.
l'AllI"l', ".1II
T'." 1\1',.... I'.. r.\\:') nl I",
r;r~,,~~~p ~l\'.:..i1.,'i'i'~~;~
l\I"../'jl.n'I:I,I":_'
"th" li'l I~ I~" /1\\"',.1'1 110.
NI:;t;;....1 " :ll\'~ ~ JIo'l"lIl1l1
S'. "..Ihlp ~ !illllll,. 1'~l\t.,
n .'..01.
",..I'Al~H,t;.Wtl.. I-f!"
Nt:....:"'... In:'/ ,,} 1..:0,' .',
'~IM If,.,.: ~. r:\o. 0:1 hr
H:',.' :n\"j; '....~Wl;
,I.., .1..11\\'1( 'lo.
"'tri' ""I' ".. '~'
"I.. "II\(' -':,1
IIlr I Ii\\", .., I..
.,.... "'I"
il~~'" "fnt~t
11I11.. ..~
... "', NJ.'" ..
~::tlll~ 'li1lo'll. D.,ul,11l
.'" 1I:'~lI:..tr..Il~~II:'II.
,......'Il':lllllll... Nroll. "I I"
~"V I'll II"'''',,,:D. """1'.,11'
.' \'Il'lntK"I~'\~ ~~ ......1.
'I'....I\\'I~III...~{J:I.vl"..
~F.~.s'.li,tI."~;rJ.-III..'P
~ '?'iJI~.tl\'f."n.~:UL-
11...tn:~lb.."II:~."llhl'
~l~ir.. R.J:r. \\ i::;~ ,I"
fi'lI.~;i'tf.it: :."'1<<~~:;
IA\'j3ftil~'= ~~""&r. . .
~lJ:l '. .~ BlI.' .. 'm.J'It'
~\I<<~S:let.~ L~J. '~~~I~I:KH
..l:'\\. " , nt"J f.t~ ~., d"
'Th'" .Wi~Al ~.tf.:" 91 I'" ~~'hi"0I~1~ II g,ft\, f1nt,::
~ ~ff.1 "WI",-i,,,&,:blP ~..!.:._____..:. .~. .
lll"c I. 1....J:l Iitll'.II,T,..atll..R.U~.
thr I'H\.., U1, II :... fit ,,,.,.:'\ ---.----~-----
... 'hr Hl'ltt .1Id I'" N F." nl Il.~ '!b H~~n~~ 1;A~\l ~l lilt
\1'. ,r ~, If" " ....,,,, ... ..."" li~" ..,,'.
i5.~~fn.hll1 r;o..lto. Ilant. n ""It 1..~,,'!Il~ ~11,
"^-ar.tL lIlloM "It, a ,,'ri'l'-lIj v. I'll,,,,
nft .... '" 11,. ar.K nl 111. Ir..... 11~1\ 1111. t:,..::ilrn ~1 110"'111,
tit IIIP HII:I, 1I011I..'1.....1t'I. 'l'1"''' IIJIJl~I."H<il!i. ~.ll
.'I~ ~11ln1t111. II.~U >> .:"1 ~t.e Ii :i~.1' \\: lit. rHl\l; ilL'
1M~lf~ttg~J::'ift:~"'~ll~l; ..I 1I,~.1 ~t:., .~~..tlu~~~.t:~~~
"''R(;ur.:.lf;n,.ll"i"l. I"" S\\'\& .lI I"" Nt:" ntU."".
Hr,hr~(,' '~WII.. I 11. W::..:~I!u 'f'p~~~'IoIP . h.
fkOl R!. ~\y !If 1.c\1.'1I l'AlI :1;1, 4'~'1
, Wl\.!Il,., lIn.lltllll' ~'t r:r" ,,,,r 1'\ ..11In<
uL :l,l' "",I<tIJ:~,."wnlbIP
I~A"f~l. '~\Q 1 h. a;~'\rl.ltt'l!\~ t. nl.
~~"i1 ~. ~ly ~ ,&'".,.1..n ~I'" Nt:~ .. I.,. ~ \"4 1'1 lb.
. 'tnl1iI,. gyt~ lliiil~r t:~ "' \I,,, In:", hili..'"""
. M. I. ".t",,.,,,I~I.j; 110,"110. u......
I~X\;.."tft.1l .1 lit. J-'f."......,I11'l:'.r.~\
IM.N" ;!fJ: "t"1f,,.ll1l1 '1'1o&o NW1" 'Iff. \'11111 lllP
" ii\, I n ,~". NE'! "I h. N.' ,., 11..11...
.;11 'i, 1'1I1l1.lt' ~ ".IIt, II"""
~,N ~""1":!ltlil 311!.'I""\lU'.:I.t'~1
C:' jt.,~" ~. ~ Cal. I' T1~ \\ "~'I Iho II:~ ,'1 lb.
. SK'..I ,'Il,,~ M, -1"....lll.....
.. ',... II,. fo~ '>1,,1,. 1 'I\i' l\(;,~"1
:<<l nnm."I\' I'A If ..,
, n~,,' Th~Nl""i..1 ,",I( .'\' ,'III.r
1"'1'1 I..... ~. 1',""''''1' ~ tI,,,.III.
, ntt N'. ',t.R.:'I!" 11... 11.,,~.'~' t)..1
I itlJ.' pi &WI. I' t:.<o11M 1"~I'1\I' 11..11
1'"""," 1'" lI'm I,. II.'I'~~ T~. t:" III"'" IU:!-4 "I 11.1'
't:"\1 \1'_'11 !,."..I"I",-,'''''II.
I .\~\IIf"f,-"~r:, 011 Ih. Ift~IC"I~1 i~:\', l"ll
~~ Il'\it. rl. WI' "ll1o","nn Th~ .:" ,'I Ihv ~\" "I 110.
, t l~'Vlll'''lp : j;l, I.... II""~~ "Hilt I"~ "....11".. " .,~""",.11'
'1 r....I, 11'.1 ":Il ~l MII~IU'H;I~I'l"I
r: 6~~t1::r'brlh:~'tll'~ T""\~'I"I'lw1,bl"IIAt
WI. nl."n....:n "I" II' ,Rr.', ,II 1'1'01"11.'" T"""..loIl>
1 :\"111' ""r_Tf._'~' ',,1 .: /l...,II, 11""f'"~' foUl
11\ ~'.\'lt'i'\1i..~'1'~' 1.1 ,\too TI'" \~:tl'.\;t\i.,.1 ,,1;"1 nl I~.
!oI\t~ t:ll~~ "t:'i .1/1,"'11"" II:~ ..,'I::,u".. :11I. T""'''''''I'
~1. 1"..1" .11' )1 ~.'U,. II"".... ~J "'tl!~I:~q!i~'11\~rnll
1 .}...n:I\IlI'tl.~'II1 T~":;~"I,'I;<..I~...1I.T,,""'
".. .\\ III il~ PI:',' "I !loP ,1.'1' ~111""h Iln."I":t,\ t:..,
~)I" ,t ". "" ' ,,,,.... ~ 'I'l ,.. ,
. It II'l.tnllt'I'~' """"" lIn..... I~,~',.t~~ ~:d~.:~' r.1:~;,,:l\1~~
"I'ADI'I'," XI-\:,3-1 !\;jlk",".\lI~H':'t 1:,,'1.
:thtll~r.)",I!".l,~"~I~!,,~:.t~; T". 1!:I.l~,11 ",~I ~\\~ ..llh.
U'1\ItI111l. 1I"II~lj n .:,..1 "}"" " "...I~,. U T.......MI'
"i:t\II::r!!.,.:I:ft-:11 III Ih. ~ tI<'''W\l~~~~f'''il Ir,,'1
I :1M. Pi'\. ,.".." "... T"......."'I' II n... w'. ..I 1101' !l<II11. 1.1 II"
~. _h Unlit.. ~ 1:.,1 ~WI. .1 ''''''..1' II 1','\""'1"1'
, . .l'A~I:il~I~;I!,,1~I ..I I,' ~ (lll'l'!~.ll\~~~~ il ,r'"
I lb.\. ,,1'.. '/11"11:1' ~..,,,.I"I' 'rh' , I;... '('r L1r.~ ,., Ihr
ifl\nlt.\I,' ~l'~r~' ll~,' II\\~ ,,' j;.11'"", 1\' ,.,..n'~'I'
. N\All '1" ~~~'t ,,' '~t I ", ":~i.I~\';f.";:\"r;1I1
I n);;,I~. \~'i .. ,,,,,.,, T~ ,,,. ,,' "" "W', ,,' ",
:ttI 'Wlllhll' '.ii""'lh.lll'l""'\ll.w" "III,...I~... JI .~('o,."."".
)J iIll' ~: "'''lIto. 11.'..... ,. ....1
,. IIl:~~nl~: 1~~, .., ,1<.. . n.,. .:I,'\I,IP;i;".~::'I' ,.111lr
1!.t+.", Ib fl.... "ill.,,,,," I ~"", "I ~'I','" 11 '\'.',~1<!1'
st. .'in,Wl' I'fl.""~ \11"~" I !.,!Io"',!....,\\!m.:~j~t't.,,1
l:t II: II'Alll.t'I.1.Vll T.... h'. ,'I I"r N 'I,,", '"
U,\t>., .., i~.. N\\", ... I~' , llW~1 ,.1 ,~, I... U .",.. """1'
III 11,. AW't.P' ~"Ilflll ~~"""lh llll""r "..",
I ~ ~:,:,"'''II' U I ,III. t.,." 'r"r \\,;~I\~i':~iJ.'"tl"1 III I~~
l'\!" \'Altrf.l.~-"'" :-IW.I..IR,.'.U....:I11.,...."",II'
. r: f1} n'It r,WI} ..lit". ..,1'....." 1111'1101'1.1"1
, '\..:n:t;rl' .)\'~I".\'~. Pl\"'.~;~ . .
Au} ',r.:lI, T.','.t W..lI nt;
",.. N:IAI!S.i\~o~'N'r.'1 "I ,t.. T/I~ ~i:\\l~~i'ifi.~i'~Jt:... ,.;:
'W;t.,' ~' RW'. ,. /lo'.I..... "..~ \, ,\, "I
... .,t" ""'''Lllh !lA.,' ... '" .,.."", \ r"'/Ihl'
11) (0) . ...11.. 1:,,"~,':1 tolll
~ ,\?W''1~.'l.s:ilP.' "I I"" TII. H"I"\:r~t'.~Jl'l ..I lh.
1& O't II I',r<-I Hr.~ u \~. ~t:11 ... 1o,'U..n
. 1't1:,"\.I~ 11'1 ,J\.~;~ lh:::e'". JI I 1....1... lI~t\~.
~ r....l_ l'AIWI1~i,.:t1
I!W' ,,'1tt~I\l.~"t~"J.''' rr."~ .,,1 i~ 111~:'~ if.1\.':~
I:3Wl6..;t~ n.:;.>>~ J;\l1 II' U r.~,IUM' ". ."If
nt,~~!I:t:h,~\,., "III.. TII. N~flIlSr-:/,~"'i~. 1'1 Ih.
""/J,,I '1r.~n:~ ~ T:~~::.h'l' Ntll,l" ""III.' ~,. ~"~',"'ll'
loI' ",,,I.. IIn,.,' :I/l ':..1
~"nC'r:TI.I_'W) l'AIICY.l'~'.'3
J1J!' '''' '"'JW'" ". fl""" " 'Vf'~"~" ",
i:i'~, i.",;.~~~ n'l:I'"hlr II.. nr I~. " ~mldll
.'.TI!or1IlhIP "11.11_"",
,",0 1I~:.~tl~~lilL1!"rt" ~, I"~ ....,.
.
. !I. ~ r. "" ~':~:-,<
. f.b};26!1,i~i251:f
'. '.', . .. "
C'"PSI-WI
n' ',1'l 'II',"~l!.,i::
lt~.r.:ri!"iI..'"'"''
nrE.'
lilt n~ "~I~' A\>>..J.!IU:
iJ"loi lIn,."'" 'bit
,,~,J:t'\'i'I~,'i\$.~'""
II: i\"JJ\I;' ....1111'
~J ....1~1I.J!WI ;011.
. l'IICr:L.
1\ tI ,,1111. ,~'" ,,' IIIf
!E~f nilI'll '~l T..."oJ,lp
.1 I~"::~~f,~ i:1U'1.
~I~'f\ I: iklllP
~):r."~lIlt ~~t 1I.\.~~
IIARORI.ll'~
If.~''''''''!r "'I ,,' '"
"III' .. ",1>",
" ,"',111(" i.~11I, '1.11111,
~ 1...~~I:Ano,l"a. I~'
TII.. H ..I 'If \\'1.; '" Ih~
NI-: D Ih. WI-: "fI,,'\1un
~l. ~'''ll' M "",( n.l'~\'
~r...l.
1'''IlCl'':L IJ.M
1'lIp B'\ n\'11i'\'11 fl1 1l1~
~. tit I .t:'\.... R~I1"n
r~. ~.I'.~ l' ~ !lwP" Il.,,~r
T",~l """".
fn;\l.... u,....bil'
~J 1I..'lh, ~ t:MI.
I'"'' :11
~'IW ~,1n,. ~rT.....:'~I:)~::
!.d!'l'\,' Iln"~" ~}::..,.
. III t:1. I..:t~
'rll,' K\4\ "' lh~ :I1~ ../Ih..
jj:t:I~ "\11....'111",\,1, -.-....nlltll'
." lI'~II. C'\llll":t} Itlll
I' II t:t,I1'~
l.~:i ~:,\ "I Ih,rv,ij ~'i ~.,.1:;;;
~; ~....".,111 r, 1l,,,,'jl",""IL'
,\):.-.,\.
'I' "1I'''ltl'W,IMJ~ III I,t
:ib-h ,.' w.,. frl~ fI' ~'. 11~1'
~~ .:,:\1"''''1' ,.,111 IlL".'
1','I,/'r:I,III"
TI:\' ~\l~ "II".. lit,,'" ,,' \1..
lI~.'\ " "",1'"11 U. ....n'hlr
~~ !(,,'UI. """/":1.\ l<t",I.
l'A1\I'r.':!l"
1'~,. N'{I' n,,' \'i","..1 ","
"'t" I"" II:, .' 11>','"''''
',' ..",.",...". J 11,.,110. 1l~1I~'
~ ..~.,
I'''!:!'I:I. ~I"
,.t... 11,. I~., NW'\ ..I 11...
1'1.",.'1 a:.-.. 11,','11.."
J.' .\..'.......1' ~1 ~",,' '. II.lor..
~~, 1:',1.
1'1""1'1 ~, U
I"" /I of) . . i~;.' iLl-:'l ,,' I'".
1;,1:' "1 r''''''I,l).''t,,''n.J'I'
. .. jl,'''1,'~i.1'1\'1,''.Y: J~ ,'1""
l'.' ~ ',.. IIII' :0.'\,.,;... \h"
~I\", .., 11.'.'1.... :11 ,.""...1'1
~J ~"'lhlll"P~"':I.\ t:MI
'..111'1:1.."'.1.
'no,'l'l:', ,.,'...:1\\''1..11....
rl... "I II....'....~. 1"~.",1..1.
,J ~""I!..lll~tt ~\\t~,.,
",~ 0.;1:' "II.... :o.'W', "lib,'
::1"', "I !;..l.....,.!\.:,..","'l"r
~..!l.~L1!, lIi'~tJ~lt"l
TI...III:t, "I lit" II\\'I,; "'I""
I ~p, "1 ~"I="".1J 'l"i,,,,nl.'I'
I ':'l....l\ll~*',...l:..;ul
TI.. )~II . I ~1... F~.iJ th. SW'i
,,' Ih. 1'1:', ,,' ~"'I"'" :','
I ':........"'r ~.' f...,".. 11.~r' :1.\ I
I.~,I
n,. Irr::I'~:rI'.;.'I!, d Il,~
l'1W.!. ..1.~.. ~.~'l .) ~..t."",
~~. T.....,"".I' :.1 ",.,'10. lI~l\"r
.1:.1:...1
,'0\1"'1"1.""', I
JV ~;;'I j;~~ I~~:~ ~~j :l...'~,~~' I
"I "tll' 1Ir.', ..1 ~..-IH' .,~
T""'Hl~'" ,l.~ 11...,11, 11... H ,\)
1:".1
1'0\11\'1-'1.:\0"'_'
Tn~ N'~" t,,~ :\'\\"', ,,' ,~,.
~1I';.:,~..,l~~, W~~""I'l,.l'ft~~~~
lUJ",1I
T"~ 1I1;"!!{t;!. ~~it;, "I ,."
"WI\ ." II... ~I'" ..I........",
~~. )~~;1 ".1"1' ~I ,."",'.. 'b"r.,
'. nt':.!ll~rl'::;l't\'" '" I~r
'TJ':'I ..I ~",'...q ~;_ 'f"..,,'l~I'
>>lItllIU, 11\..1....:1.'. .~'"
".\lll I 1.,.1'.'
T~Ir-. N,'.! ii~..I';fI:~\\;"Ii t~ ,\~~
'. ~"""'hl\.'" ~",\1, U"..U
. 1:.,,1
I'A llf'I~I. '1 ."
~l\~"":~1 "l...ll'l,;t:~~\',:II'~:!"I~~
~,. "'''..nl~''I' ." ,....'I~. 1t~"ILI'
'10 t:4'1. J.ll1'i:l :I.'.'~
T"~ H\\,Ih."1 ,\". A\\'I. ..I ~II"
~/W."r~ l~'~~~ 1,J'r:~::"'nl I"
---,
~ l~n~~~OI t1i,
\''lflfll",d...i;' ",'!IIp
8oiI1I1iI. n.np ~ ~.I.
:I'll',rW"m.'l.1., "' I"
~ ~rh. ~': \ 't~",'.i "
'"'! al~~tt'Jif\~ th,
t'."tLih ~~:" " '~ui:1'Ilr
~i~~lt\~I:l.Ll:
~ ...l\!~ 1f1~'\' ...,.
1":CnK.,J.I
'flIP Ii .. . II';".,., t.t
IlW "Ih~ W\..r Stttlon
h i::~UIlP 1ki"'ll, II....'
TI!I' RliAnf":~;.'n'1 01 tIIf
MW'lvi It,.\!l""l, r (1'...11....
I. TiI.n.hll'U.......nb. l!&nIt
~D'"
"... ,J~n~!1(lt....'li ..r 1"
t!s"'~~~l:'nu:...u't':~~: p
I n(,~I'~
T""S~' '.1.... \"~ IIlt"t
~Wll ,.1 s.~J: Tt'.nlhl~
1'....:!klllt~t:i~~1 UH.
TII. '\V'i ill"",. 'Il uI\bt
j;"a.,..r "''''''''''. \..1j.I'....k1..
M :~AIlI~'ltl~..UJ ..11.
'~'\.~..llhrl.\\.'t"II'"
H '~,.r 11..,1....." n'"'MM.
!IJ 1~\II\~~f.".f'.I:All
Tilt W"']' Ifw ifW'L ollh~'
~"., loW.IOtIII'" Iln.llh.
'"C\'l~\ '~'I~l. N,
1."" N.,:l,,, n.,. '';':1, ..r I~..
~1V'\.4 ",,'Il._," T.."',,'''''
IW"'P';Il\\1.t.~'i.~ ':"01
n.. N.. "' I"" SW', .-1 II..
I ~y.'. r>f 'h" 11\\''' n ".,',,~'
!\ 1~,~'''1I' ~, ,c;, "1>, I'.,,~.
1l~'A!,lrtil;.M\~.. ,,"hr
~ .J till' ~\\'r. ,.1 Ko..'"",
F ~"'I\I'II' I,) ~""", lt~h~P
1" 1:...);.'111",... ~;"
T,( W'_ "I ,'''' :I~:lf .llh.
r~'" ,., r..-hll ~ 1"'<1"10\1'
. '~..II,~\lll".lti': ;;f'"
Th\.N:', "111.., SI:', "llh'
t>;\'. ,of fI,,'I:,,1\ ~ ,..,.".1<11'
" f';"',!'u;Il.I~\~~'l'~ 1'111
~". 1'1.'. I~ I~~ ~';'. III Ih..
iln;",nl''''';':\''~';''l ~J"l:i;;
t 1~'''1l'''\'' '" It,,,,, . IlM'~.'
. ....~l'IIl.I',I. ti_
T". tlf.'. "II". 111:'1 I't 1\.'
P'" ", n"""" II T."...~II.
J 1lo.11~~al.'~rl~ nf'"
1'1.. t;l\ ..1 U r :>1\,", ,I ,~,.
'.j\"'.., ,...}:..I...,,,.,,,,,,
~ """"'1"1'.\1 :(,,11" 11.\1'("
)\1.1"
.,.... f..I:^.~I":~~~ ,\J~.. I 1_,
Nil". ,of I'." ~I.', ...r ~..h"n
~\ 1;~~ ,,'1-11' H 1;...11. Il~"~"
\'.\11\"1.1. II ~
n..aw", fiflhft NW'.." Ih.
1.]\""1.f..1,.,,..' ,.,...."'1.
'I'o.."'\::t.... ~;"A"
TII. :o.:t",..f.,..t\\'~ ."111'
~I'" "r :;..-1..... T,,'PI" I'
,I< "V,\I:,t:.t I'~"~"" I
'f"," 1i'~..1 ".. :tl,'1 'h. "1""\ I
'il~,;-;;'~\"...~, ...."'hl.. J. t
T.... N':',~I~:ilil:..t~~\.. ,. .... '
RR't '" ~.tlo"l C T!'''n\~lr '
,.. ""~I~. Il~....... It I:..' I
l'Ull'I:I. ..~ 1
TI...llr... "'II!.. ~\"', "' I~r I
1Ir.'a!. ,of l<o '11"" '\ 11-1",hl~
'.' 4~AItN'~~~i,~ .'~,' I
TI.' ~I:I """" tll\"1 ..I'~r .
1'1;1~ .~'K,:fl"'ll to ,,,.,,",11' ,
_.l "j'A 111~'~'f.rtl~l :..1
T'~ Nt\'. " Ih "Yo'; ,,' I'>\' I
1l1"i "1 ~..II.... , "'''.':11011'
1.1 1Io"".AI'II.\;t,.,,: .:..1.
"... l.al"k"llt. Nt:., "I L".'
~r:.t.,.:,L l;,l~~~ ~ f.~':'i"1 II>
~. N';4!~:lll"~~:r... <', Ih
1':\1"'11"''''''. T".",1,1pM I
~.ij", It""r.. 1\1....1
l'AIII'I~'. '.' ~ I
TO.' N'r.I,--..I'~.. In:" nllh
1'1". <f ""1'''". 1io."IMI'
\'!l",II, lI~u..."I:,,1
n,. Ilt!:~l~~i!:I'~l\':'1 ... II.
..r.!,o .,1 ",rll".. r. T"."'~ll'
~1,....111, 1I11nll''' ~rl'.&",
I,,' s~f!lI~.rh:-\!l'\.:., ..c II..
:n:~ ",""l<..,.." II. T".p."p
rJlI<I..lh.Il.."C.>>,-....I.
1IIJf:~ 1. ,.,.1111.. .. ii r..
i\/..~inllii~.\~
h~ .
~Al'f':L t-J'
t'K~~7 HAa af~~
fl' .!~..~.1t19 "'I"
t~""'li\; II ~'n~
'Ut.'
~" 1-:1,1-1
TtIl-. f, III nfl....
~*-. ,I, n~."\"r "..
01 Ihll ill~ to. lilt-
..I 111., ~!.. lit ,..,..U....
., 1X".t.lD 8tv1ll.11..Ullt
...t:".'
. "","..,
",~ 1I~'i ..llht Nr... ~l "....
\\,:11. 1. T~~.hIP AI 80'011'
I R"I"f~~I~~lt'l...t
Uh. Nil,. ,,\ I~' 8K,li "I ""'"
Inn I. 1\l.nlh'" M &\1111.
I,,,u~fi'rl
~q,:'iI",!i;;'~.\."'l1:
" ,I, r "1 !"'"
R ~;~ : i "" It:
f, '1~~ 1 ~~:.~~1It1'
fJ!"il:, ~'~"'I"
~, .". ,11'
I<ll S .111
'A I"
Nn; ..~ . 1'l'.:.~ll1~~
',TP....." ,II.,..,.
, .:...
"'i"'fl.Rllol
XI.. 11\\'1 "Jh' ~tl', 1'1 I~.,
i:.:"... lIl'ijl':I, iofllnlllll\
,\ (::::\".101". ft.""'''' Ilft"~.
1',1111'1:1. ~1
J:h.. H~'I. <II th.. Hr.'1 '.1110.
~illt' it...II101\'. 1\,""",I~
" . '~"I'~illl~'\'t'~'I'~: I:~'I
,. N m, W "'Ih.
~\;:, .,/,.. ..f; ,~,..,,""
/;~'''"'IoI'' n "".11". II".,.
;\ '~"'A''''I:I, II'
'h.'!I:.J...,.,.I\";"llh.
~)'i~,.,."l:': ~1KJ:~.li..~..~l;~~~
n ".~..
T" Nr'!:rn~ Il.l.. ., Ih~
l'~\" ) '''' ~I;I; d ""I"'"
',", f':~t'~'P .~I So..lh. 11.11'
1'~I'I''';l. nl
~~:,.1I:11 if.. l\:rd:I:~1 ~!~Il~:;
: , .. ""'I' ~l :':o,,,,~ ,I'''r,'
1\)'".,
1".. ~.I:.'.III.~h '~i:., I~r
!C\\". ..1 It-> ~')" .1"1,..
~I'I\~.I ~tt, ~:o( 'jl ~l' s~1t:.1
'..1.... T.. -l.......h'l. ~J .~~.I'.
,....,...\t...,
1'\.. Hl;~,II:,nf..I';~".. ..1 Or
:"':',"'""""''''1.",_10'1'
'JIt,;"'\rl'l~""'t~...,
f'O,.. :..1" .~\l~ I~~. ..I III
~\';-':..:;!'~:I~ ~~l~"'I?. ~, S~:'
1\ 1:~'1
~,. ,,'~~!rl;l',,'~h ", II.
lw.. "I H" ~l.:" ..' !\.,'''~.
\, J~::I,,",II" 1'0_ ". .' ..".
/'\lh'I'I. I' ~
!I" N:'; ,.IIl...!':\\,'. ..'1'.
S :'1 ., :I._It,.,.: T......I ,.
..lta.~'r.,I:..:m.~r..1
't" 111:'. ..I 1('1'''\\''. ..II~'
~.~ ,., J..U,". J. T....'-.I,.,'
., """:A:l~rr.~' ,:/""'.,
TI." ~lt ..1 11,.. SW.,..I \I"
\:'1\\"1."1",, NI:'. ",)1..,1",.
T"....hll. ~'II-..II'I 110"".
,....,
'I;' 1':..~.1;~ :~.\\.. .., Ih,.
frI:'!'.I'I'h'N'ICII..(,...I",.
J. To'~"""I' '1 Jto~'th. """E"
,,~ t.....l
, Nl;A,~lfl;l, ~"~' ... I~.
~W'I .., .1.. 'ft...r. "y.....II~"
,1I1'...."'r>> .n~. ".111"
1'...1
"A'II'r."7'11
TI" II'~" ,110- lilY ..,...
f,w., I"~ h, If"'\'~ It.,'II",,
T.....,I,II'M &,,"10, II.,,,,.
',....n
\'AIlI"'il1' < ".1
""'~" ", ..~'" ",
H"''' Il'r p:'.' th" "
"'J~"\"'II'I.\t\\l nil\:.
t "II:" N"..~ III' "",'U"I)
III p'" _1010. nUlI'
. ;t.1
TloP A~A~r~~'/~w". III ,I\;
"'JL~t1I~ ll~l( ~~'r.
\\,tiil. .
~l!:~~iJJt"k-~.11~
"I\""'~~ 'J;,I.. '" ",
. ""5friF~J~~""
.H .lp"'\v't ~fh'
n" lllll~ \'1.111"1"
".~'~ 'l\!:."
Hi::i~"!l;""".l' ,'!.:~t1:
\~),T:FJ:'~ r../:tlll,
"""'''''':'(1I1Ih,NIt'loll''
H\V\t ... Bl'P'k1" ,TQyp&"p
'" !\"l,lI~),<<'i~ IU':"'-
n. H' iif Ini! III Ih
~r.'i "/111" ~.1{~ :1IllrrtlNI
1\'.."'1011' !liiul1o.n."..
t;.,.I.
l'Allr'U.3i1-1
~.. ", .' ,.. "'I '" 10"
r. " I'~W\l'" 11m,
~ Irwn~l~1' J::t 111'111I10, '\:,,1..
. "1/'10''''' noT
f," N,".."'ih", 'Pol,,,,,, Iht
II II \\, ,I"'n
\ '.L\,,,\(ll' ~ ~u..~. ..n~.,
R~i.1.
NI"i:r""'U .
n!~~"'I~" J~\'... MI:\ ~. Ill:
r~ I ';'\'~~. ~"I~::; 1~~T~ r>!
",fp ~ 1IO"'!!,..llft~I' $ r...1
l'AlI'r,l.tn.
'I'r ~'I"'~' f1F.'I...1 II,,.
~'t" t'," \\'1, n ""11.."
.. '.',,11I1' /Ii","..11'''lIf
.. ...,
"!\III'I'I.UJ
]'I,~ ~ :1. OIl 1'1' NIl!.. .o! lb. I
\"WIl flIltt"'''~1 I. n~.I"11'
., ~"'III!A/l:~~:\t IV~'''l.
,. R~" ..1 I~.' 1:1, '" ,,,. .
;r~., ,,1110-"1\.., T.....llll'l
..'Il.""I~.,lll',!it.nrA'1
llj. St'l. ~I If. ~I". III I}...
~II." ." "...,110'. 1 T"....l,ll.1
'.1",.'''' lh"vr,rf:,,.,
1'\lln".1I1
J~r.,li!:;;~,~~ r':.i,,~t.l~ir.
1 ~"";~~I:'~~'I~ :~r'"
~~';I~f:;i,:INt\. ~t"i'h.."~l:',:' I
...". ,>1\'.," I,.!C,W', 1""1
SW'. ..r 1"~ SI" ,., I~.
:~~~',' .r:h~I'''s.~~' ,~l' t:
liW" " ~I"'""" ~ T....,..I"I' '
, "<'i!~II1\t~"i.:\\ t..., i
n... w'\,,' Ii.. ""'. ,,' Ih~ ,
:cw.... I.. "'...1 t~\. "1","1 I'
il.. X\\", ../ I~.. II l"i 1\,
!I'. ., I' ~ ,ll'" ,."" >,II".
.-( 'l" SWI. I'.. ~I\". ..I"~
"'W'. '''-1'10 S',,,'",,u'''
"I l~~ ~W'. ..1 u... :fW'l ,.1 .
':i.:~.~;" ,ll~;,~'" ,'.. . . .' .,". I
1'.~Il,'n. I~' .
~:\:;i~:~'~,::r. ~.';r i"'~.~,'.. ,:.1';:; ;
\'~"'I~.\I;:li~I~~"ir...' .
T,,{ "W'. ,.r II... ~.". 'It...
~"'. ... !I.,..... : Tn" .1"1' I'
\Illo.,... 1'.~.,-1\[...1
"1"'1'1,1
TI,rxll.,III";~ 'I ,., Ih.,'
~I:;\..;'~.r;;, ~ll'~. ..it. lIi;.I,:~::
:1\ I: "\''''''1"1. \. ~ I
'r.'::~', ~:.. ,~~ ~~~"~'~;\ :;~..~' { .
"...10,,, ".'''111. lI~t'~~ .11 I
".1
h. ~\\~t."::n"t.'Jf:I...1 "...
IWI; ,".~"'I"'I' , T.....tt"l' I
'. I " '.,,, I....'" 1\ '~1<'
l'AI"'rl.\\' .
T". In:'_ ,'111... 'HI". '''1'..'
ml\'j;! h"~~~':'~~ ,:l:,.....I.'I' .
1'.1.11.'1:1. ~o; 1
l",r.t~:;.;:. :.~ ~\\~~:,~.:'ij.
..~ ""',1',. I,,,.,,.. l' 1""1
n, IIt\~:":'ill~~,t1 '111 ln,1
,,... ~\\,I~ .f l/l~ "'~~\I I,r "'"
W', "'"",'n..,,1i ,-;,....hl"
.'IIo",'1i Ihl>,t...1( I'.."
",,, lI,'I'A~I'T~; 'f,~.. '" ""
k'~"""rN\V.:"I/l""C:"
1-., ~:,.~r'''~ '" If "", Un....
1"rr~Ilr.r'r,"m.\,.."r,,,.
1\00 .,.,.......1.... r T'...-U.J,II'
Al "'''I~ ho""" '1-' .....,
. -':'~r..::;...., "~'II. i.,' I:: .
I:AUI'~l(i'I'~' .. -.
~~~.. ~:l ~~ \11',) ,&'nl~
I.....h'll llOOh.IlI,,1I'r
~'I.
.,
.l~}:i;;!fi:;~12t;~\:[]t5'""
~
1l'\,..o(',14f,~a-r., 'If <<';j
~Ni;11. "" J'I1.. ,!'j,~
...~lIIl1IP''\lllWll''.
'Ill" 11'11.
I".." ..
'I"H\\ ilJl5r ~lO:.llh'Nr.Y.
'-! lh.NII:I4 lor ,....11"" .:
f;"'U'Io11'M8d'Ih.Il""1I''''
.NI. ~'llr:IU''''
n.,H\ "!'b"II',"tl~'~
.i1 Ih, JI:'~ ..1 I'"' N
1""1<1,, . '!'o~III"'P&1 I
,","/. I"
',1,1'1 .,
~'"\ .. 'li!,\t'tnflbF.lll\
~...'% v.~:J.~ :-r'6CWi.
JtMl.f.'...t~~ toll"
Tto'N',,"1~..\lJ'''llblllli~
~...~II:'~};; a..:i\I>.Sij:~~n:. 11
......11. l'AnC\'.1 i.1
,..~ II~ 01 u.~ Nil <1'1'" Iii"
"'I'" I'~ ,,""''''' \ n I....
~.l.. Ih'JUi'4,.,"I'IlPlIl.
.Mhll' U 8MiI', II""... 01
:...1.
~~~". ..
~~',l'l\ l'lIorfN\\"'."'II>'
!,.11''i'" ~ IIlJ\ 'I'nwnrltlr
. "'"IAIl~~II".ii}l.'1
~'jj\II\\\1 n'II'NW'.I\fIl..
I':~ I>llIrflOlll' TI1..nIMI'
. J;'"Y:",IW~:M.~:u,.
Vl.ll..~ ..r'iC-NW" .'IU..
~rltl nljltl"l\oIh ~ "\lll".kllI
"~I~iII:I,.''''
h. HI" "rlllo- W', ..rl"..
~rfu" "1.(I....Jl'hWP'hlP
"'~I~, 1:'1IJi~i:.J:I\l'
TIl,1t ',hl"I'!;. It"'" "I hP
rJ~\..t1 1'I1~'IlI'" ll. ~A..",I.,l'
W),/I~~l~ :U:""
'1,. N', "t .~.. :oIW'. ,,' 'h.'
J,'W'\' ,~.. :--'!l. ..r ~,'1'11looo
1\ T:';~lnl"I" ,\1 ~~,\I', 11~,,1"I'
.,,\,.tll...,
'lIr 1111" 11..11\\,'/ ,,'Iht
:1\\ '. I' 1"" !l:':'\ 'I 1I~'l1..n
, T,""':"I' .{I $00"11.. 11."'.1'
~'. I:..,
11\. ~1!:~I.I,\.ti~,I~~. "I ",,'
~.t~'. ..\ 1""110>1' 0 ~"""''''l'
"llo"',~.\ :~':~~ :.~ ~ll'l.,
TI... 1", "I 11" 1(\\"1"1 :I.....
'"l~" ",,,, ".h'r \. ~,".1I,
1I"~"11'1;r'i!I' , '.\ '1
Th,' H', ..1 ~,.. ~\\", "/'1'
XI\"..~ I.,. I>\\'I ,. .1 . ,
!III". ...,t". . w'",1 110..'11,," I
'1\ T:'~11\""1'.\I 1'..",". Il~"~"
l'AI(I'I'I.'" I
'!'"~,. "':'. ..I ,'', "W'. ..r 11"'1
~"\\'" I $.. I ." " t"""'Ml'
I "''''I.I!A':'~':!;:' il~ roo,
H. N'..III..... 1\'....llh.,
11",.1 .,,, SW', '" 1....11"" I
'I ."""1' II ....,"~ II."..
11 "'1
".\110 '11. ~.. t
Jl:'il ~:i t':. .~\\.~\\:~; A"l:~~
~..1:.:~i'..h'1' '.J ......Il 1'''''1''
1'~' NI;~lI.~;'::I...I,II... .Ii II'~
:>I1l'......."'......l....,..'tl'
..'S.."I:\~~WI. ;::rA"
T'~ /'I~I", '1'... l'l.... ..' l~..
!',";;"".i;' 1:..',..g';'\"I:.:;:...."','
l.....lIJ;~",:;l.I'",.~h "I ,...
{'''''. ". f. t..~, ~ T"...".I.".
.' !L~.\.. l"".~ 1\ 1:..1
": ..~i.\I"TII..~I>:.I\'. ,".
1l'~'. ,.1 ~"'II,..' ,.....'..11I11
'.1" "':.:.\ll~W ~t~'1 .
I;{...~:.:.;1 1'1:;; !~\\;~:,,;~~.~i::
\, ~ .,11. "M"~' 11 1:"1
T.... ~li.!.":;n;~.~;I~I, "1 ~r
11l\"j",,,,,,",...l't....,,.I"I'
"ll,... Iu"..,. ~'.t..",
,.... I'::'\!W'''I!~:;;~''; ..r l10r
'\II, .., !It."",,, r T"."'h1I'
,\1110_... 1l'''~''.1\ rul
II.. ~\~:~ll::th.~\'r." ,,' I~.
1~'1. ,.1 """,,,. , T...".MII
.' "",Ilt. 11_"" ~\ 1....1
I'.U:'TI,~.,
~t\~lil:.? ;;~ ::.~n ~I\'~~ :"!.,~,~
.\1 "',,,'h Il....~, "I r.....
I' 'III'I~I. :II' 0
l\\!"lll ~~i' ,,.:~ I~~~ ~ \V~, ~!'II.llr.
~~ 1\.",\1, II...... ~~ r...1
T". Il\l:~!':.n:'.~~i~"1 .., II, ".
Itn.,. T".".I"I' M II<-Il~
I'...... J\ .~~..
TIo. Nt~~:n;,r'.~t.l;.:., ..I it...
, , , , \ '. , ., ..,' ",', ^," J" ;1I.\., .( ." ~ " '. "~1;-" '" ~
....\:.~.~.
. ':." I!::"~'';~:' ".:..... _ <;~ .
aDPl!.~QOli~f~88 .
., ~whi261'\\f256'
~~if.:~~;~,~};,~,-;,:~;,,;~_:~ :
, . .' -. . ~
. .
tiVllltl.l':.i.hI:i:"lJIIP U- J:','t1l'1I1P. U hl\h. 1\8."" Uol::(6.->>t, P ,,"01. 1\1""
If'.d~~~:'ll: ~lf~ii.~~ij,.~ ~"I'fl.lu,*!::
W.'l.':~~~~''''~'I.~I: ~~~~~~i{~~~v. lr.~: ~~1L-!Y~;!<Ji!
!1'~ 1l[4"Sr:r.~ 1& III Ih n1l.a)prllC~ ~l,," UW..... ~~A_4~. .
~\It\l\'lt!\ii!'e:' . TfrnJ'" ~ ~:th "CI" l"ll ~ Jl &~ 'iWI ~IJ l!cl~
.. ~); "~'I'\i:V..' lilt ll' ~l\J;jp lot :lh.. n.n,_
....-r., ' .., ~.!'l~_ N,t; II 'Ill HR' of SHII(lq h,l. .
v." iN" - -- ~..'" N ...'. ...... .~R"'!i'.~ -" I".
""'...., N loolll, "..,., 35 ~,t A' I ,.,. "" ..
U~ J!~":r:I~.~l .~~ UI\I\,';: '~.er.~or:
~~3,f~~J~St~t.!!.", ~~~,.lir,'ll"A.*" ~l* I.lo;
i::I':"':e...... '1W'i'. \I'. ~tJ '"'J'l.?:I~,.t\\~ of l'"
'1"htoftl.!'lt\;tL,\\\T.ll" n-~~~t~fi~;! 1l,:il:'''~~fl''A,~,''A:~::
~,~" I'i ..."...~,.. II It:.~ F,' .r.'~i.'!;\J. .. ",
1:1." tI:toRSE1.aa-ll ~'lI.. oll~r r.\\'V:rl. 'lr.11an
~ R,r~rti:~lt'of..,.n ~,~.y I!/, lM.~'~1 c..1~ '~.~,.."... ....
Ih...r.I~" i'I.TI\ii.'nln.. . '..n,,,,'U'lIillih.II..,,,,,
oltk, ~ t>11.,I"l'lol ,I. ~~"~n~."Ii..!n~'llor'hf
'~~O:~';U1IM",p"""'-'1n, 1tl\I~A~:lt\.IU~ I~~ U'I ~~. ~o: ,,,t.:.t~"lP
Tr' ~~';C&~hti;.!.'lr~ u-c!nl~'ifl U~~lllIlJln r" 'j' -tVI( I \lr
J::r'\" 1.''':''1.. ....T. /j lM,;' '\'''I'u.\.~''" of .., ~}.f...:,~ itl ;.d::
~" "li"ij,~I\II":tRh' .r.~ \.l'~ ~';I".;\r~\1~.", ..~li'~~!'~V
.... " !lo'" \Ian ' M~lr.... lIl. l&') ~ II' Ill" ~ =<I\!l:
""nlhll' &\Ill.. "'1' \ N "rh''''llfollht 11. 1I1\1llhpU ~ll,,"nR'
.111. \ 'At' 'lI~n ,,:~.'t\1.lIIh'I' n t:..l.
""rN~'A mcl'~"1"'''Ir::.' I ;nl. 1'^nt~r.l.'U"I~
_. L "'!._ nr I'" ~ Ib,'''' r>J \"
... In. "...... k'. n nt:JI ~ .Ilh, 1"1.:'11" II\\''I Rut M
w:;.1.~ U ,.;:r.1Il, N Ik>\llh. ~~ TII""-'lll' 1. WIN 'I' >>~ . 1l~"1t
"'I'E'. ... I."'" 'j""''', ..n"k
~tll~~JIi;~i :"'V1'!.\~.l~j "'~ ! .'hM bl' T~' .,... Ill. HE '" flU
11fl1l" T..WlloNCI f,] ""11'1'1 'fiT","''' I\\\'\I. lit I"~ 11\\'. \(,Ilnn
"1<"1.,,...1 1 1I."".","",U"""h. III"
"""fr.loU" n I ~lf...ll.
"" "} n '10' ftKI\ rot I\H'o ~t lrol "I . IfW', ", bll' 1.~ftC.1 ~l!
I"'~" ",,_.IIolp "" 11"...11 , U ~~l~" \tl"ll: U'l~Tra'll'lIl III ~""' 8\~ '~I hit \ '" tll Iht
_"._....._.._...._., ........._ I .;.~ \\'Il'" IImI "~T1l.l\'M\l
Th~ II. ,r" ~'" '" ,,,. 1kI~~' ~I'>> ..1.
."ft. II. ". II MOl II, '" r.. N\~ \l (If clIr41 'ft'......'I' In I"";
....!f.~H~ N "'I~' , ,., ll\!..'~' " I~::!.:l,~\;
~K"-u.1 Hall C1's'''' ~ 14\ ~ Dt ~~. \:il\lil'~ .\"lit
. .I''''tI. ,r.'I." ":.~~... \':f:_'i~~\.:il 1~"Dr\'I.~ 11" N " '''f th.
I.''', ~~kw~::li r 1311Ol.l1~ ~ ~l D ~ll' ~\~'!111' ~ JI. ,,_h11'
n.p N~ ::r 0.. 1\"'- .... I~' ,~~i'''' I l~\ "r:- ,1'1 I, ',i il" I".
jtl~~Gnll:r.. ~J:;t..~k~\.~: \ ~~r~tlflli I. Mh1r rr:'~,,"t~;, II ,,~k h'~I,,:~
l~ );811.",11 n'~ '8:t~. r.ul. M 11:.. .
r/''':': I '''lll'~~JI:~ 1l1V~.. ,'hi~r,\ ~~'lfll~~ ! IIt'o\~W'l-i~~~ttl, Ilh
l\,t:.tl" ~~'1a ~t Il~' U'I "~'11 'll'ituM. 'It.II., IPt :;f II", II\\"~ ~ll."'"':'h
~1~ ,,' ~1...tlIllft \. '1II'P.I."''' ,'I.~'~::T"lh'~ &/liIul. t\~l1lr
"K~~ n1 I n~ II m ,." llW~ r>J l~, a\""l\I"~ ro.11 "
1" " ~ ,,:. . "'1 "II" 5.4.... ~<<,l'~.!o\' '~. ~Ir.\"'i' ,~, J ',,".~~ 'I~ J.:
~l:t Cl "-"fln I . "",.nlhll' ~"..wll I ft..,.i'~ Vol!' .
"11l'A,[1I!\1'''l'i' 1:.11 I Gila,IIlP tJ "'-:"'Ih, '.11" \ rn I't ;.. ~,.rll~", ~ ...~
11;,,1.,"" I ".~fl~ .'.' ,I"! I . tAlI1'r.I. nl' ,tlI' ~r 11\1 h. 1111\1' 11 ~.1\
\i-l~"~lhll' ~Ml. nl;::;; I W'>.:i/N.7 ~11~t\'~ '! ~:"l~ 1I\'AlIH~~ '~1.~ ,",.
~~""', ,.,' . 11;1;, ..i ""1\1.. II...." f,!!1'. "r n." IIW'I .iI &!..11NI
l r:".'.II.IIII'''-'IIo'''lh,lt.'I'':'
Jtt.H" t[l~l:"I~\";!:~:.l'l; ~~"'~;,An~rlC~p:\'Jt'~'t ..11.r "","
M 'J."''.'"I'''!~"''' ',~ hol. 011 'lI. . "-",'llD" ~r J:~I~\'r\~tm, 0' I"
3I.1ttH\~~II:.r't~,~w~nt\,';. ').,,'t"t II ",1111, II",." ~l~~,:tl\"~~;:f~~"''W;'..rr
lY'"",,~~. 'Wi~r' ~ l::l'" I' f1~~;tn.sK~~";,\~..... Ill" ~'I,
l'.ln~.F /.1' ,,' I~t II ~'I~ .. Jl'"I1\i<1n Tt.II\~~IIfi,~r.1 tf"lt 1110< H!..
l~' "W'l.~,'" 'W, '<I" ,....",,} ...... ...... "... ...., ..;"~. ~l\':
u"l.~ r;~~"';,,1r,~ 'T;::,~I I' '~~Ill'r.t:)I," II, fll Il" ~ ." 1"1 ',tr; , '1.\
t'~ll\'fl. ","n r~" p,', d. ,~r.~ "I Ih, i\!...'r::tlr:~.~ l\ tl'r 1~
~.t: ~~" lll~' ft~~~J'r :~: U':1"~hIP ,.~~, "P~~~ ."., ".,~1:\yrt"'~.fl'~"'.NlI"
. ':\_.""':~" Nil'" ','..1',' _~iAltCII.l\;." "III 01- llil ~
. A-.Qi.. Il-:'r ,lui p ~"~,,,"l l-";,.Ct:~ .1 ,I'" ~'ml'hIP lbtlll. t.",,, il
1',I,nt"'tl' 1M! " '" II, II II lW 1I~ ~"'" ""
71,' Nil" ft" Wltl, 11'1" ' .....11' r-i "..I ,'n,.." .r.;.... I:
"'!L. ", ..... .".~ "~~9" ~" i4L~i "'0\., n.1!.,r,..,:
U' "'Mial"''' 1'OlUlh. I1UU 1ilf'I,,\i 'a. l~" .... fI' Iht U'~ ........ ~ "all.
~Ii\'; 'r'~ '~" 'j" ' i.n':i ,~""l~ ~.. ~~"l'rU" 'i:'l~~ '" J"
TII~.' .. I. IC~ (.llh. UIi p,t.~ klllf'l'l;J II. WJiit't... ftoK
n~l>'l.",~-r, '''''fIi>\l~' ~r.~: &;'r~l. 'N 1cIuI"- 1\.1;......... J !!.i"'~'io II . 1Ia";:
';;:~m.~ "M !.\'.''l\!~t~j.Y', 'I ~.. ~'~.~. 'l.!~ .,
~"~~?..~i~ ir:L~l ~~* It'~.,,,,'~.. U;.! , r~i~I-U; A.~lItl ~~\~~
U- 1'''11. ~l' ./'SW "- ........ 0/ 'A If "v.l!
11~'~I. 't!' " ... S'R'~'~ W -
W...:.. ,lift.,. ~I I!..~ Ilr' Dr ~If ~ ,...
ll' l:.r.nol. I' La' 1',,,1ft,, 'ii..." If~r:.'lrl' 1I'ih. 'lrJ!:: 'Di~ ~I"
I~' rLitns.~V--U~ C. Uot tlS~~,~\I" nI bt rr~ ~
llh.:I:r,~, L..'l.. :0:'.':'; lrki'u\'1, Il'U.'.r.~,* lr,t\~.ll: 4....11. ~
Ul, J.:t~~'~1.:/J~\ i'J"r.: IN..l(~tlr'U,'j:.or.: nriir'I!';Vi.?J~!:.:
.
U'll~h1P N 8ll<lUlo nanK'
W. ''fr:r. ~,u_~ "Jl:
.\'all",~J~Lli..'it:....
. ...,
W~:!I11tt\l Nk.lli!
'i~:lJ
l{lfll I ollh.
U. ~:1I1 II' ~ a,u~~
1t"'~~l}S~h.1~'
Jt'~.,N~ lhr III ~)Io b~ll"~
~2:.V."1"II'U n;. nanl'
11~ I~'~?lll';l~~ .. 1'1
U'~I:!."'~ A~3.. ~:J1~
~f\f'-nW.
ho/~:M~'~ rl Ln. ai:~*
Xl\! .1:'W'lil"I~~ ~ i"
\1' ~:~,~Ir. iJ.~I~~, ~\rn;;
~ Ill",nCl'lllI'\I
~i "Ol "ff' ..,..,
nllt .. onnll
. :r'~p L;,k. 't.nrt
1'~lIcKl'u~
14~ " .1"~ ..:,...... J\l
...1"1"1" ~ J tll. r.'" .
IlIta~~ 1oI11^'I'D"ri
trl. .... 1\111'"
~~'!i'l\~n:r..~~.1; fl..1~:
. Wl\'~' lfL~l '1t;'~1f
':\.
'r'~t.I'u.
a I flU I'{ ",
l~\:, I W1..'lt ...,1..
lh:"tno pl. llar'l~..
'.tir;:'i;:T;:"i.;M.:iI~
_.:""ii"r.i;-~;i-"._.
T/II' 1Il\. ~..!.." lrIi.. ul for'
\1"" l~l'N''''" M 110\;11\
IJ"J:II'AI~'~I."II
Tilt N\, 1:1'\if.' ilK'" nl IIl'fo
ll''' n~ 11"" III' N 1It1l1\!I.
....~l.i~.I,.,1
Th, &1'1"11'." t,; ,1',,,,,
1\>Ih I J:iMh" el I\I\\LUl.
1"".tl'~I~t!I'''1I
Thr~m '>ll"INlI:lolllRfr.
\ll"'-il '''.r.ol,Utlo<lllh,
111l.'fl'~I~~I'8-I'
TI)t flllll r: n
11<11I'. Olrl\l~11I ~ L"tt.
lU..1 .\ 't:"I'
!'! '~'~~";f II\;U,. .. ...,.
\i:U t ".uhl\" N "'"'Ill.
"""c~'!\!l,',,,
~ Me 11111, r.W;i .~ II..',
tRlI~ ~r "~"lIh P 'llIlh.
P I I,.J
'",,,11'" nflll'~lw""I/I'f'
I"'" 11" '1:11""1"1'" !Ii'll'h.
n.l\I. '~I\~:~i.~"
1\/l~ Nl:\ln' iii, .""\0, nlll,,"
ltln lr., T\ltl'" P ... Ilooi,'h,
..nlf Itlr~'tIO'
l~' ,Cq .r... .1I., ....,-
11%11 ~ '9,:-i'" 'I' N ""..III
"J'l"~lltft.'I'\'
Th' N\~"L,;jp,p Pi \'" "I ~r"
''''''-'\ 1.,_1I'1ol1' N Iloulh.
ll~"J'.'l..1. n,tA
T\>, .!:I.ll.., "n'., ~ ,,..
\11ll1 d~~ ~.:"'\I\j\ N 1<\\1111,
\.."....AI 'T.' n.1 .
~" ,J.. ,. &, ilN~ "tUff,
11~~,J~ J.:~t."hlp n..
.......n.s...tont;cH.
_r;;j"'_.....J..:..,.~~
I' ~."'."'''''lI.!..
.. . .....U.L.1l..;t301
.. ..._'.... .!IlOCLs. ...
,,'~~:~;:t.,.;:.,i~~i:.. I."" ...:.,.:.. .'>-.
. -
J,
nrr 10666 -,
nEe It 7ffi
1'180 FED 2S P 2' 33
SOIl. 52G48
Big cypress Hat'I.
Preserve, Dade Co.
n,
QUITCIJ\IH DEED
THIS ItlbE:~'1'U~,. Made this the 9th day of January , A.D.,
1980 I between SOUTH F'"RIOII "'l\-n ..NIIG....HT 0 1
~ n&p ~~. ~~ ISTRICT, a publ c corpor-
at1~~ Qf the State of Florida, with its principal office at 3JOl Gun club
~oa~, a~~.who8e mailing bddreB~ is PQ8t Office Box V, West Palm B~a~h, ot
the Ct\unt.y of r9llrn 'BeaCh,. in the ~_t8te of Fle;ida, GMNTOR I and TnE UNITED
STATES o~ AMERICA, of Woahington, D. C., GRANTEE,
WIT N E SSE T " t
That the GRANTOR, for and in condderation of the Bum of ONE DOLL1\R
($1.00), and other valuable considerntionA 1n hond paid by the Bald GRANTEE,
the rec@lpt whereof 18 hereby acknowledgcd,-hao remtaed, released and
quitclaimed, Rlld by t.heso preRentB dotls t:em!ao, relebse tlnd quitclaim
unto the GlU\NTEE, nnd ita 0901gn8, the following described lande, situnte,
lying and baing in the County or Otu:1fJ, Statl:' of Florida. to wit:
1\11 that port of the SouthwOJJt one-quortcr ISW~) of the
Southwest one-quarter (SWI:4) of Sectlon 37., Township ~3
South, Range 3S EaDt, lying WostQrly of the rlqht of way
f.or South Florilla WotQr Mnnaqement DiRtdet f.ovec 28.
Tho above described porcol or land contnina ]2 ncre~, morc
or lees.
ANDI
The Weet onc-haIr (w'11 of the SouthC;;Htt ono.qunrter. (SE")
of Section e, onel the ::;outh one.-half Is.,) of the southwcfJt
one-quarter (S~) of Section 20, nod the Northwcnt ono-
quarter (NH~) of the SouthwcRt ono-qunrter (SW~) of section
29, 011 in Township 53 South. Tlnng~ 35 BOAt.
The above described parcels of laml contoin 00 ncre.., morc
or lees, in soction 81 ao acres, more or lOUB, 1n Section 21}1
llml 40 Bcren, more or le~'IEI, 111 st'lctton 2~1 ['or n totol DC 200
tiereD, more or lOSIl.
The above described Innd In being nC'lulr.ed Eor. tho USe and benefit: or the
United States by the Notional Park Service of tho n~PQrtment of the
Interior.
If the hnd herein conveyed io loca-ted in on Rt"en that haB not been
officially surveyed by the united State., the location of boundary lines
and the acreage intended to be conveyed may be estimates only. Then, end
in BU~h event, the GRANTOR shall not be liable for any deficiency, nor the
rl~,,,',"1 r..' w.'.-,,' '-,,-" '. r"j""" I,'; ,..,." '~'~'II,,'
:;I.~,:II r'" ,i.' ' ,..'.\ :. '. ,\ .-; . " II
.t.lll1';:.JOIIl.;"'I.'..I;.... ..1"'_;"_""'1.".:..1"'0':".'1""
'J
. ~ .
\\) t!
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.0PI120861IlPIOR.10666.1786Ilj3-12086
Page J of3
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19120074:50:16 PM EST
-"
~:I I 0666 rc 1787.
GRANTEE liable for any exceeD ocreDge such as an officlnl survey might
diaDlose. The GRANTOR r~leaBeB and quitclaims unto the GRANTEE, and
it. .8819n8,; all the right, title and interest whIch .tha GRANTOR may
have. in ftny such" ftXcel8 ecreaqe.
SUBJECT, ROKEVER, to exiBting easements for pUblie roads Bnd highway.,
public utilities. railroade, pipelines and mineral, g88 and oil IntereBte
of record out_tanding in third parties.
Saving and reserving unto the GRANTOR, itu auccessoro or nsslgnB, all
ri9ht, tiUe and interest in and to the dqht of WilY for Centrnl Rnd
Bouthern Florida Flood Control Project I,evea 28.
Saving ond reserving unto the GR1\NTOR, ita successor-R or neiJigllB. nIl of
the oil, gas llod other mIneral" nnd minernl r.:lqhl:F.I, in, on or under tho
above deRcribcd l~ndB.
This grant is qJ.vcfI wIth tho mCprfl!;m under.Etand:l.ng th~t I.f tho nbovD
deecribecl land", nrn not uBed for purponrld or t.lll' Jl1g Cypr~9r: Niltlonal
Preserve an provlll(!d by Inw, or \, r thQ nbovo dCBcr.lbml li;mcJg i.'U:-e othcr.-
wloe abandoned by the GRl\NTEE, t.hen in either of l:hoso events title to
soid lando ~ill ilutomnticnlly r.evert t.o the caU\N'J'OR.
TO Il1\Vy. 1\ND '1'0 1101,0 tho some totjctlu'!T. w.t th "11 nnd ningul<lT. tlm
nppurtenonc@B thm:-~unl:o bclongJny or in nnywiRo ilPpcrtaining. and till
tho entntc, right, title, interost, licon, equity nml clnlm whatBoever
of the saId GR1\NTOR, either in low or equity, to the only pr.opc%" UDC,
benefit Dnd behoof o( the said GRl\N'rEE, it9 IlUCCeIJ80ra <Iud LtGslgnB, for-
ever, subject to t.h~ provisions hereof.
IN WITNESS WlIEneOF, the SOUTII FJ.ORIDI\ WI\Tr::n MAN1\GF.MRNT DJ!';TnICT h,]!l
cauged theBo presents to be executed in its nome and its offIcial SOD 1
affixed hereto by ita Governing Board, acting by the
Chairmon of
Boid Soard and attested by itg
Secretory, at West Palm ne8~h.
-2-
i
.,
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.I0666.17861113-12086
Page 2 of3
Created By: andya Prinled: 10/19/20074:50:16 PM EST
-'.,
11l.~ 10666 rd 788
Palm Desch' county I' Stat" of Florida, this thd 9th day of JonuaTY
A'~ D., ~9 80,
SOUTH FLORIDA Wi\TER . M1\NAGEHEN'1'
DISTRICT!- BY ITS GOVERNING 'BOAN>
'- 2-)' '
By{ /t;'b1;__7A /"/.. /../
.~ alnnan
\11
~l
~l
~
STATE OF FLO"IDA
COUNTY OF PRIm nendl
1 HEREBY CERTIFY. that on thJ.n th~ lJth dny of .Innunry , 1\.D.. 1980,
before me the underoi9n~d Qut.hority, p(!r~onnlly nppE!ared ROBERT L. CLARK,
JR. and JOliN R. MliLOY ,. Chnirmnn LInd Secretary,
respectively, of the Governing Donnl or SOOTII FI,OIUD1\ W1\'J't::R MJ\NJ\GEMENT
DISTRICT. a public corporation of th€! Stato of Florida. to me known to be
the persons who signed the foregoing instrument os such officers ond
ncknowledged the execution thereof to be their Eree oct. olld deed 09 8uch
officers Eor the purpoElEls and U9(!S therein mentioned and that they affixed
thereto the official seal of the GOYQYOing DQard of SOUTH FLORIDA W1\TER
M1\NAGEMENT DISTRICT and that the FJait1 lnntruntont 1.8 the oct oml deed of
said SOUTH FLORID1\. WI\Tlm Ml\NJ\GF.r-1ENT DISTRICT and the Governing BOD1:"d thera-
of.
and of.(J.cil:ll ~enl atW('lIt l'nlm "Meh
and yenr. last a(orcsald.
, sold
" .0:, ','i.:! L .,/(
Notary Public
~ ~';"1
"~'~
'. " ,-~ ' .
..:.; .,
" ".,
......,.IrfIIniI_..
:.."'. cou'rr. ,....... ...
,"",,,'"
!J""ARJJP.BIIJNKER,
Ifoo..AUlK elltCutT tDlIlII
J
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.\ 0666.1786/113-12086
Page 3 of3
Created By: andya Prinled: 10119/20074:50:16 PM ES'1
&1t.\(' 4.0
311
r"
i
,
,
,.
.1
WARllANTY DEED
i
I
:i
i
THIS' ,INDENTURE Made lhh ...J.7.YL day of '11l;. E,~,f), between
MIAMI SHIPnUILblNO COllf'ORATlON, Ii F~orlda corporation, party of' the
first. p.:irl, and RICHARDS LANIl DEVELOPMENT COHP., a FJorlu(l CClI'IH\rF1~
\.100, whnse oddreu is 740 - 7lsl Strcet, Mlaml ~el\r.ht F1orlci\,
party of lhe gecond pRrl,
WJ'fNESSETH: That l.he said party of the ftrst pElr\. rDt' l\IHi
In con~ldernt.10n Qf lhe sum of Ten l.lol.If'rlli (~lu.l'n) rind ot-he,' vn}u-
,
;
Rble conslderrd.lons to it. 1n hand paid by the snld parly of the
s~cond parl, tho receIpt whereof 115 Ilerftb~' ~clmQwIfH]!lcd, hn'l prRnl(>-~I,
bergalnf':d ami sold to the sahl party of the second pnrt, It:;. Sl(CCr!\~
SOl'S nnd ~9sl9no forever. the following c.escrlbp.d lnnd RJt,uDLe, ly-
Ing and holng In IJade and Collier' CourlLJes, t"Jol'ldn., Lo..wltl
Section 19) Section l~J Section ZGJ !ieclloll l"). ltta
the W 1/2 of t.he SVI 1/1 lh0l'eof'i Stc;l1on ZO; Secl.lC'1l ;:9)
Sp.ct.lon30, leu tl1l;1 'II III of the NW 1/4 lhr:rH'r; See..
l.lon 311 Suction 3l, leu the W 1/2 of l.hbSl! 1/-1
lhere~fl SecLlon 33) SecLlon J4J SecLlon 35~ all in
TOWnshIp 52 South, Range 3f> ElliS!", III !Jade Count}',
flol'!d.a, and cunlRlnln9 7,411.1 acres, morc or h~,r., less
An undivided I/~ Int-nest III all oil. !lftS Bnd other".
nllnerals Unrein Which Is hereby r8~l;rved lmlf.' lIlt~
Orlthtor, 1\.9 successors 81\1~ 88S10nl.l)
~ecllon 1 J Seellon 21 Section 3, leu !.tIP. W liO! of. 'f.ill~
.' SW J/'J .thereofi Section III Sect.lon 5; SectIon l~, I f'1i 11
, the W l/l of the SYI 1/., thereof I Smct.lon 1, See Lion I),
j{~$9. Lht' VI Ill. of th~ SE 1/4 lhBreofJ Si$ct1on ~q SCl'-
t.lon 10; Section J 1, less lhl.: I~ l/l of ll10NW 1/'1
lI'~reor; Secllon 12. less thD Nt:: 1;'4 of t.he ru: 1/4
thoreofJ Section 13. 19811 the Sf 1/4 of Lhe NI:: Il'l,
the E 112 of t.he liE 1/4, tho S l/~ of the SW 1/'1, Ilnd
thp.; NE 1/4 of t.he SW 1/41 Sect.1on I"J Sect.lon l~;
S€cllon 17J the SW II.; of the NYI 1/4 of SectIon tOj
the N 1/2 of SectIon 19; SeCll:>n 20, less the S II?
of the ,5'N 1/0) lheraor, Section 21, IC8~ the SW J/'l of
the SW '1/41 Secllon 22, less the W 1/2. 0(' the NW 1/4
~hnqDfJ Sec\.ton ~31 Sect.lon 24J Ion the W 1/2. of the
m/'J14 ,thereof, Section. Z:5J Section ~O) leu t.11p.: W 1/;:
_ (If the ,HE Jill thereof, Section .27) Seallon. ZOj ~ecL10n
J4; S8dt.lon J5; Section 36. lesB the SE i/4 ond the J::
1/2 of ,the SW llh 8lJ In lown$hlp 53 SouLh, UlIn{lp. 3~
fa9t, In Uade County, florida ond ~I>.,t.cdntng 17,G60
nCris, "more (If !en, lees IIn ufldlvlded 1/2 lnLf.{I'cst. In
81 t ,011" gA,,"and other mlnerfth t.herel" whlr.h Is hereby
reuerv\J:d unto the Qrant.or, Its GUCCBS50rs arD ass1gns;
SG~l1on~ "!il 'In.. the E: 1/2 Of. the .58 1/4 thenofJ Sec- ~
tlon '11' 5e.ctJ~uh91...,Se'ctlon 19, leu the W 1/2 of the
5W: 1/~::'~h.8re:ofY~oQUQn l1J Section, 23, leu the E III
ther.of:J: S~OUOl\,~~",:'Sootl.h'27j SectIon 291 SectIon
31 J S.8f~Jl;)~, a,3'1,~.~.~.,B'.l .th! .W:"1t'"2 o~ ~lhe NE 1/4 thereof J
.;>{::~:i;;o';]ij~,:;;~;;:.i\\~".,;sh\!/;~:;t;~~A';.fi,~;~~[;~~ilt";i:";'. '::";'1' ,~.
f~ "''''J.1~t~'!I~~_itDlP;~:\\lqi''JJ6:~ '!',-'(,1,~ ,!;~,~,~.:;.,._~:;0:-~t:,l~.~:. ,'r ,y..;:'~ '. . :'\.'~.
.,'," . 1':)1' ~.." '.J<' j'~l ". <.
. ~.jl'(.~: r;!H';, .;.--~ ~ t.; .. ;J>'~;' Ap~ndi)C
.....;?~:~.;_,'.;,.:.'.'~;J.~lr..,:', \'~'::.,i'..~ ~~~. l' . _
.. '"j '.' ~:~r ~,~:';<J)'~;.:"~/;:~\,~, ...~,t ,.>:,_,~'",~ ::f(~'<~;r
BMl 40. 1,'3~r' "~'\ ,"!<'.>i:.',('::,' j-',/ :.(lg.;,... .
i ~~ ,,~...1.:.i'r,...r:I' ~.,.....~..~.' ~~'i, ',' .
" . .}I ,,~, -'..; J' '~::fH:{;r~1t~. -'\ "'::
.\ ',,:,"~.,'. '.';,' .'
..,-il;'_.,' "..\ '",,'. '....:.-:- .:'. ".oj,_;
cnd.S"e_9,t!o.fl. 3~,. .,~n.'ln-.:r~Wn.,~lp-.'5~/~c)"'~h, Ronge .33
E&&t.',...t;n j::ol1Ur.Co'unty, 'F"orlda~'.lInd oont.Rlnlnu
. .7.,UO a;cru, -mot." or 1.'11:1';: ..,. on und!vlded 1/l
In:te:rle\: fn all olr, 9&1 aJ\d;olher:- .h\lherah lhere;ln
which t_!. .hereby resc,;,ved unt.o t.h" :Grant-or, its s,,-c"
ce.StiO'",; 8nd .luui[gn?)' .
Sectl~~i!, I.... th.. 'II..1/l of the S8 1/4.thereOf) Sec-
tion J'l SecL10n tn Slotton 7 J SecUon 9, !en the <<
1/~ of ~he NW 1/4 thereon Seotlon 111'Sectlon 19,
Ie.. thF W 1I~ of the /IW 1/4 thereOf! Section ~II
. I Seellon; 23_Jleu .thl!' W Ilk. of tho SW 1/'1 t.horeor;
Secllon;~~J Scotlon ~1; Se~tlon 29; and Section ~5,
all In Township 53 South, Range aa ~ast. in Collier
Counly"PlorldB and contalnlno 6,000 Beres, more or
'!en I 1~s9 on undivided 1/2 Intel'BlIt tn a J 1 0 II, gu
Bnd olhllr minerals therelr. whloh is h-:reby resflrvcd
unto l'tu! Orantor.. J ts luecenors ond us31gnlJ
.1
.,
!
Section ,3; Sectlon 7) Section 9, less the E 1/2 or
the Sf: 1/4 thoreof, Section 19J SectIon ~gt less lhe
E I/~ oj' the SF. 1/4 end E III of the NE 1/41 Section
31, le.,~ the 'II I/~ of the NW 1/4, the E I/~ of the
NE 1/4 nnd the E I/~ of t1,e SE 1/4 thereof, .t I In
Township 53 South, Ranoe 31 Eaet 1n Collier COllnt.y,
florJu!\, Dud cuntnlnlng 3,JciO R(;rCB, mora or leu,
less an undivided 1/2 Interfilsl fn all 01.1, gos anti
other nllnarnls therp.ln which lEi hereb)' reeervcd unto
the Grant.or, Us SlIcceUf>Ors and asslgn!l.
This convoyauce I~ macle !lu"Jec~ t.o~
Oil, gnsBndmlnl.!fal1e.ase LoTrlnJtyOll COI'porntlon
dat.ed lJeccmbel' 1.7, I~!)O, ElS modJflcd by agreelllent
datod APril 17, 1951.
OutSlondlng grazing leau In .favor of I). 1.. Crum and
R. 1::. Futch elated lAay I, 195~, and expIring June 30,
1~155.
eaSClIlrlnt, to Central and StJulherft Florldi\ Flood ClJn"
LI'o! lHst.rlct dnlell January 12, 19!JO, Bnd recorded In
thll orf1(~e of the Cieri( of tho Clrcult Court. In Bnd
. for Dudff :Counly, Florida, on February 6, 1950, In Deed
Doolt Jl3~ at Pago 562.
ApplJcable counly toning regul~llon&,
Reurvatl.ontl, If Rn)', In favor or the Trustees or the
Internal :Imlll'OVemonl fund Qf the Slate of Flol'lda to
ent.er upon _Lha lands and conat.rl1oL such canals, t:uls,
slllhl(!'A'aY~r dike, and oth8r worln os may In theIr
J'Jdgmc!Ot. _bf! necessary anti needrul for the dralnl1{Je or
reClRmalJl,n of' the "1"n05 And to take from the lands
!Such gravel, elone or eatth ItO may In t.helr Judgment
be neceuary.t.o use 10 ccnslrucllng e~ch ~fln8.h, C\l~8,
9JulcBW8Y~, dlltes Rnd other work"
And thE"- !told part.y:o! the fir_!\. part does hereby fully WRrranl the
t.ltle tQ said lan~ ;lubJecl. t.o thft for~golno txce-ptlon8 and will
defend the :..11). ag~ln8t. t.he l~wrul clalm& of III pvnons whom6oevur.
, .
IN. WiTN.ES~::':WJiEREdF_~' I..':t~-Dald pnty of the flf'S\. po,'t hat
. .._., ,_ 1....._ .
C.elll.l"~;,~~e,I" Rrll!unh:,~o bir:-.d:grl'~_ 1.n...st_~ name ~y It., proper
'.. '. ..' /;,>.;,i :';:!l';,;...:'\:f~if;;:;t;z:.i,';,:",
,.:.~~;:_J.~!:
j,t,,'. '7~~,~.:::g.'I~~.~t"V~<J:o~~I~""':1:' '~7,,~ ":-'1. '. . <,
:' ~ . , ,rd.! J~ (0, ,,~, ,:", . 'l ,.....~. ';')!" ' . . .
':.:' ' """ '. '-"'~4i21IrAa '37
:,:".! .,..
~}:,' j: ~ ,I
.'.1
.j
, !
i
i
'1'
'0rflC'~u. and lts;~orpore.t~ nal ,"0 tJe affixed, altesteri hy q$
. ,j
Iml
40,
:)13
5e~rt.tQrYf th<< day.and yenr above wrItten,
i '"'''''''' I
; ~<~Il~~...~,:~t':~i~:''''' .
.~.:t-{ '-!/" ''r!\ "I",
r'; ''';;~\A~:;'~l '
'li.l'I.,I~.';,.., G'tj E ~
~\'~tl:\ ."w i'':' .: ~!/
":VKl..'~' ,,:,;~ . tJ ~
'.,~.f~; ';'J'i'i':;'~~"" Secr el~ry
~1 .i.,.]"IlIlIlIlllll"" ,. . ,
'l'p:.....:!:,t! .
I ;,.....
'-'- Slgrletl, teehd nn6 l1ellvererl In
the pr8&ence ofl
MIAMI SHIPBUILUINO CORPOR^TION
ny. ..'/~ ft. ~...f.~
. ~r~Sld'nt
~....I..~J. -<13..( ('.".,.
/4-;t:~~~
'STATE OF' PlOUWA
COUNTY OF' lJAllP.'
'5
JUlIO
I Jlf;ft~BY I:E!;t'flfYj to.hat Qn thl, _..J.1!!!... URl' or M&v, /'., II,
It'5fi, before IIlC pe~'90nn_lly Bppffored Theurlore G. Auhlel' 111)11 .1';00
E., BUlIier, PI'osldcn'l and Secretary, respectlvel)'. or Uleml 5hl"M
buIlding CorporE\~hm, n corporllllon Ilnder t.he Iftw5 of the Slale
of flor'da, t.o me ~nown to be t.he per~bnfo who &19I1e<1 the fClregc,JIl!1
Inst.rument. as 9ueh officer, and severelly IlcknoYJtedged t.he C>:Cf:ll"
lion thereof lo be -their truo ocl Bnd deod tiS' such offlcors fOT' lh(~
U8es and purpo8u t.hereln mcnllorll!d and thnl they arl'l:<cd 1l1l:reLo
the official u'Ell o'r saJd corporation, cHid lhnl the saJd Inllll'ument
II. t.hll 8cl and deed of saJd ct?rporllllon.
VnTNE:~S my: signature and offJclll! senl at /.I1oml In 1I11!
County,or Dftde and S.lo.t!! of ~'lorlda t.hc day and Y~flr lusl nforesntd,
. , . "({:~~\',.,(\",- ~ -~ .
i~'~\\\\lIillll'lf" ..
:j;' \"~\\)!'''';"$'''il::'''-, '.
".lI>~"'.""'\"'''O><i'~'''" '.',
i{,~;M!":~'r~,'..<l!.ij-Iod\'. :
~. ,- J rt... '1'1-'\ '
. ,,{;; ". '.'i1<'/''''''W,.r,''f''l .
. '1\11,,-.\,/)' ",'~I':'; "'j' .
. ;"',\,,'O',&~,1f. :!:,]"'...,.
;I~~~~.;;~;~,;~~:;~.~~~~\.. . 6~ :{;~_:.:_-' ." -....~:: >,
. ::.,-).. 'Cf.r(~,\,,' ,',:'1 .' "'<'.: ',' ". , ')l 'l I ~~
:,>r}i~:,i'."'~k~'~~~:::l:\~:/>~~~~l.~ :r;.~;.:~~, ,-,\ dt t '.~9 .'
. ~ -;.' Q, lS:I....."~~~
.:~otary PUbTlc Slate of FlorldlJ. nt. L.a.ryt'
. . Hf"'" 1I..t"\_ ',Ill" (If n,.~",,,~: ;.~~,~
lAy C~lNnl,S'lcn oxplrt'r "'ytom.""~OI' oXl'lU' r.Io~. '.:,.,.
IlonIId l>., ^n'I"~"" ),. ~1. 1
,.
v
.\
<>< 1I11!11l1nl1~
lr"..:l: 0
"-It- r:(1
'liI~ ("")
0"" 1f)
.,.J~
u.~
~" I
Ulffih
\til'~ Ii
I- Ii -
iU) Ihlll1l111 II!
HN110~
~ 30VO a
WARRAN'N DEBD
TillS INDRN'l'URE, Made thio /0'[1.. day of ooto~.r, 1958,
~.twaen RICHARDS LAIrD DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, a oorporetion
existing undor ~he laws of the State of Florida, and having
ita prinolpal plaoe of busines8 1n t:hO County of Dade and State
~f Florld&, party of the first part, and
BERNARD R. 1~IlYERS, TRUSTEE
927 LinDoIn Road
Miami Beach, Florld~
of the Oounty of Dade and State of plorldn, party of the eeoond
partl
WITNUSSETH, That th-d snld party of tho firet port, fol'
end 1n consideration of the own or Ten Dollars (.$10) and oth<ll'
valuable conBlderntlono ~1) It '.n hand paid, the reoQ!pt Whcl'eoC
18 hereby aotcnowledgEld, hos granted, bargained, Dold} aliened,
rem1ged, released, ~onv~yed and oonfirmed, and by theBe preoentG
does grant, barge!n, sell, a11en, rem18~, roles&e, convey nor.!
oonl'lrm, unto the oa1d pDrt~ 01' the Bccond part.. Rnd hio hclro
and 88Bigna fOrOV8I', all thDt oertain pBrcol 01' land lyi.ng
and being 1n the Count:y of Pl\du and State of ro'lorlriA, more parR
t1oula~ly doucribed po followDt
Seotion 30, 1... tho w..t lion (\~t) of tho
~"orter (NWt) thereof, ond
Sootion 3~. leo. tho Wobt 1I.1f (Wt) of tho
QU. rter (SEt) theroofl
in Townat1p 5~ ~uuthJ nnnge 35 Boot, oade County,
Florida, l,)ontll1nlntX 1120 ncrea luore or 1e88,
l'Iorthwo13t
southeoot
Tho Or8~tor horeby rauervOD to It801~, ita DuoceS60ru
and nUBigus, an undivided ono-fourth 1nterest in oml to.
the i'ull 01:\, Bae lInd mlnel~ol rightB pert1nent to the
abo.,e deaol'lbed lands"
1. Taxee for the ourront yvQr and I3U~8equont yeal'O.
2. Faoto thah would be d18010sed by an ooo~rote ourvey.
3. Any unreoorded labororn', moohunlu8 I OJ' mo terlulmen III
Ilona.
4. Zoning and/or othor reotr1ct1onu lmpoeed by govern-
montal authority.
1.
1.."'," o;or-..-IOCIJ SOHWAItZ 0. ZINN, Il!OO-llIO" ^INOl.:~Y UUII.DIN13. M!^M'.'LO"lIP^
1.1" , '. :,".~ " ." {d l; i ','
, 'I," ". I I ~f. ; I' I I , ' . "J I I ~ tv' .
,.,' ','. ,., .1. .'. 41'"
id 10~8 ;.",~ 27
7. An oil, goe and mlnernl lease rrbm ~aml
Shipbuilding Oorporation to Trinity 011 Corpore..
t1on, dated Doo. 27. 1950,. 1'11ed Feb., 22, 1951,
1n Deed Book )~02, peg. 5~7, Publio ReOordo of
Dade COuntYI Florida, nnd reool~p.d in Collier
County, Florida, under d~te or Maroh 15, 1951,
in Deed Book 2O,pageo 5 and 11. The aforementioned
le8a8 was mod1r1ed by an agreument ct<<tud Apr11 17,
1951, filed Cot. 9, 1951, in need Book 3500,
page 226 or the rub.de Roool'deof' Dade County, l"lnr1da.
B. Rightv of perBone other than tho owner 1n P08808B1on,
9. R6vorV'aHono,' if any, ~n favor of the Trufttee9
or the Intomal Improvvn1m t Fund or the State of
Florida, to entor upon tho lands and con8tl~et such
cannlo, cuto, aluioe,.,oye, dilcee and other works
as lIlay in their Judgmont be neoeoORry and neecU'ul
for the drainage or roclnmation or the land", and
to take from the 18nd Buch grave!, atone or eal'th
U3 moy in their Judgment'be nOCeSQal~ to UDe in eon-
Btl"Ucting sald oanals, cuts, alu1oewft)'e, d1keB and
othQk' worka.
10, U:osell\cnt to CentT'Il! ~ Southern Ji'lol~ida Flood
Oontrol Diatl'1ct dat\": Jan, 12, 1950, rocorded
Feb. 6. 1950. in Deed Book )236, pngo 582, of the
Public lIooorl\8 of Dade Oounty, Florida.
11, I\n undivided 3/LJtha intoreot in nnd to t.he 011,
gOB and mineral l'ighto, ono..half ot' which \'108
J'ellcrvad by HiI'm! Shipbulldlng Corporation, tmd
ono~fOUI.th of 'fhich 1n reBOl'ved by the grantor
herein.
'I'OOETIIEll with nl1 tho tcntllllcnt:s, hereditamont8 end
apptlJ'tonul1ceo, \dth OYOJ'Y pr.'v11ege, l'lght, tJl:1o, l.ntoreBt nnd
estate, }'p.vcrei1on, remnlndel' I nct easement thereto belonging or
in any wine DI>pcl'tatnlng.
'PO JlAVE AND '1'0 nOLO the SOnlO 1n fee allllple forevel'.
And the Baid partlr' ot' the ftrot pG!'t dOCD covcnlmt
w1th the Bold pOl'ty or the llcoond PI\l't that it 10 1Dwi'ully
3uizoct of the noil! prcm1e8j that l'wy are free of nIl cnvtUnbl'OU(lI;!BJ
and that it hoe. good right and lawtul authority to aell t.he Dnmei
amI the 8111d party of ths Urnt port doee hereby full)' warrant
the tl tIc to aaid land, and \'111). defend the uame aga1not the
lU'r/ru.\ \..lalmo of all pel'8on~ \olhomooever.
IN \llTNESS HHEREOF, the naid pnl'ty of tho fl1'!3t part
h8a cftuaed these p.rcfJonto to be s1gner! in its n81\1e by its
"l'eu!dent, and ita oorporp.to seal to be ai'tlxed, ott:cotod by 1tu
2.
L"W 0'"'"'00<0 Goo'ow""",'" 4:,..". "~O",-1l:071'''"!;lII.C:Y ~UILOINO. M'....~lI.rLOhll)^
f":.
." '. ., ,,()
f'~ - .. .:l . .'V.'"
:;"'~~~' .
\v .'
j-.
.,:"
11668 ~135a
',,"
nrr
Kt(
.. - ..'
(~~ !.:J~~,~_';,~'~.j.:.}iIl;~:~~ .E",:~.
"
,'llfl].') !IIDE.~r~.UI~f. or I.E/Is'::1 ,made ,L1nll only'reel lnto 11:". ',.,~ ':\..' pith _,V'!;.:
o!' _:?.!2.tember. ._' 1962, ty 3rliJ ,betwcan Dildc COI..lr'It.y, ::l pol ~ t '/::1 i ,
sUb,d1 vh ion~ or. \~H~ St'~1.e ',0!' 'foh;rl dll" tH."J'clnnfter no' f(: l'I'(,d '.t.r/ ';};'; ":. ;:' :'111'"
. arid.lJJtftES ~.IIUGHESI J\ 6eneral pactJrership, carposoo of Dudley J. 'f1ughe~ .md OM ^. .
. . Huohe!L:' HQl) CAPITAL ~RS. J~'s!fi.~i1~zaG"}.~~" _~~='.~-==_ :...~
.' ~n:;!'l.er ref'"Cll'rlJd to aG "'Co:;zl?e",: --r. ,... - .
.' .~ tJP .
.' . b '~.......,y,,,,,,,,~.'.:
." . .
"''''''I'.I,IMt~
~CI,.vll'C:"~IYC..It\_'
~nl'1/laJ1l\~
(-/3 -/{'~
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 125.351 Florida Statutes, and 111
response to pUblished invitation for competitive bids~ sealed bids
were ree~1ved for the award of .sn 011, gaa and mineral leaol!' on
certaln -lands owned by Lessor in Dade and Collier- Counties J and Leo:;ec
hav1ng subrn1tte~ the highest and but bid Cor the lease on the sa1d
premises, and the Lessor having accepted the same,
'rI) Tl;ESSETH :
um:, ':HEREFORE, the Les8or, by authority. of ::said 1 a..., and 1n
cons1deration or the payment by Lessee of the sum of $230,000.00
cons1derat lon~ receipt ~Iher('of in her~by acknowlerJr;ed and of ';he
royalties, renta.ls, cc'.'(.nan::: anri cond~tjon5 contHinf'rl he:"e.!n,
and hereb~' agr'.!f'd to be paid, obse~ved and perror~~d by L~SSCH~, do'.!.:>
hereby qem!se, ~ran~, leas~ a~d let er.clus1vel~ unto ~ne said Le~~ee
the said land described ~n Exhibit A, wh1ch 15 mad(> a part h"!reof, ~or
the purpose of ~n'Jes':lr;atlng, €!XplQr1nr, ~ro5peet~~c, t'.r~)l!nc:: of
bore-holes for the discover;,' and productio:1 or oJl, [~~. Jlllr-!~ur, "o31t
and/or oth~r brines f':"Or.J the leased prer.Ji:;es an'\ for the l~,:.'!n~~. ?f
J'1pcl~nes. building or rt;'')dc. t3nk~, pOHer lin~5 :!:1J ~o.,;e:' !>~Qtjr.'~:::,
CC~:7:w~~catl.OI~n equlI='HlE:n~ and uther structurC!l and equ.!.t=~e(l~. ",..'otied to
?:-'(1~lU~e, s~'J"". take ca:'"~ or, t:.!.'~~. t:"".l:-::,.r~:"t C!.!"'.d -:..;1: rn~! ;<.-~:;::t~
snd to hOOlse its e~plo~'ees enGs(;E:d 1n op~ra~ion:j ~0I. .j1'il:l:~I'; and/-.:r
pro::!.'.:ct!on o3:-:d handUnc, all s';~j,.!o::t :"0 th~ t!:-:"I:l::: [j::J '.::cn-::.t::J~::I
r;'?~e~!'",!!:.~~, :::et ~~~th.
;.';;!' ::':e ;.....:.:.:.:....' .;.:' ;:~:.:..::<:..j:-:f, :'";'"n1.:ll ;':i;;;-" ...._ l.'J:'o;;o',,::1o;;';':., "':'l~
!.:nd c-:".'''.:'O::-:: ":;.; :~,i;; }.:.;:::.:, ~~: .~:.;t.~r;...,t,,"j -:.::. ,~,:::-.;:.!. - :: r;'..':.
:..,l:1~:'::.i "'~:""~:::,'..,;;,,",':.i.:-:.':";,- 'lc':..::j~l'j t?;.,,':':::'J$ :.,"-:.;<., . ,:, :,..'! ~.",c:~
:ra:t; d.~=-CI'::bt::I in :::(~j!J~t ;, >: ...':;;'~I;:.:,:..~.'l :.., co:::;-::<:' .. ::;:"_:;(::' C,;
,)c:-'~~ stlpw::1,_.~1 '-'=-~:"~ :"..._ :" ........_...:,..:- ~T. ..... ".~".,
Of' le~s.
;.1-.:
The ':er::J "~:-'aduct~" ,~:;:.~,.! b'J:,!.'in ::,!..Jll !.n .;.,. '1:1:;'~~1:~ ::::. -):~..:!:"
:!leaning b~' l~:::ed!.at":! context, ~'l'~lude ;:l~!. J2;il5, :;:.:rh~:', :;'.''11:'' ::.:-:dt.,:"
othe~ brln.;.s.
1. sut-';'.:!ct tr. ':h~ :J,:i;~.:" ~r?v~:;ir..:\:". h"r":'!n ~.... '.'.!i.~:!:~i~r:!>;j~..:o
11;f f;;;;;:~;l;:j~:~:;Jj[:j}\~~\\;!g:%:}';'P:;:;:;;~';i;:.'"
.r pr'-"'c.'''.' ":-\'." :;:-. ~...~.:",: ~,b"':::':'
r:'1'=.::-'/\:~~~, :;;:; ~~~.~:::.:: ~<.: "",~',' :~::-_':: :.:;
!'~~::~1.lIr :l".~ ~:;/:~.~;",':. ....~. :'.';'... ..' ...;:','
~. :-r.,.:::: 6: ':'r.,-::: . " '- : .~:",~" ... -,
;:.:'.: :..~~~r. :,,,,:= ~r. :. "...... ';:...':.
: : I ':! ~ '.'
:1 ~ : :-'; .-. ");.
'iel.:"::
'.':.!....
::< :: ~I.
.' , , ~.
'~.' ,,,,
, ...
..: '. ~ . . .
... ::'
.. ..:.:.
:.."';'.....
...-.,'
.. . ~
.,:
',:.:::-
., ' ::. :! ~ ;'; .-.
..........
. r. \" ~ . ..
<\..,
.,
'..'..
"
"~f.
.,
Appendix V.GA
Order: [QuickView] Doc;
2.0jl I 120861BPIOR. 1 1668.1358j1 jl5-12086
Page 1 of 15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19120074:59:23 PM EST
.1'
,,~:
;;;
!II
<n.
..
CSGh
...
...
:xl
c:>
c:>
<0
<0
.....
'"
",
\n\\~~
'J' .
;,,:......,.
..
,y.,'/ ~
;. .,'
~
'. . ".
:'.*;';/668' ic'i359,
" ,
..'....,
. ~ ."
"
"
i-
.'
, '
..n "force ~nd er~e<:t by cotMfenelng' and"e6nt~nulns ~~erBi'to'n5 for drilling
~l%l' J"ework1ng the land:; of thi5 lease .or acrll!'age' pooled the_rew1th for
:." ~~e deve).opment- and pT'oduc;;t~on of 011,. gas;. 8ulJ>h.u.,.~, sait. and/or othe'r
brines covered. hereby'.on or bero..e sbty day!> after such 'cess'ation of
.. :,rodu~t"1ol1:" an~'p'fo~ecutl~g s-ame'wlth d.qig~nce'i,md 1n tl.workR;laral1ke
::tann,e:r w1th nq' ce~sat1oh fon '9ore'than th1nty ,~ons:e't'!ut1'Ve days, .an13 if
. . ,tUdh 'lSp..roatie:Jis with1n r?8sor:table-..time.. the,rearter..resu).t fn the"pro-
(luct 10n of. 011, gas., 'sulph~r, . s'alt and/or 'othe'rbr1nes covered het:'eby
from the lands of this lease or acreage pooled therewith in paving
~uent1tles this lease shall remain 1n force and effect thereafter as
long as oil, gas. sulphur, salt and/or other brines covered b~ this
1.ease are produced therefrom 1n paY1nSQuant1tles, subject to the pro-
,1s10ns of-the next suceedlng un-numbered paragraph, but in no event
beyond thirty (30) years from the date first set forth above. This
lease shall also te.rrninate 1n the absence of 'dril11ng or :reworking op':"
eratlons or production in paying quantities of 011. ga!!, sulphur, salt
~nd/o~ o~her ~r1nes from the lands covered hereby or lands pooled
;:herewith, within the time and 1n the manner as herein 5et forth.
If this lease is being maintained by production after the explra-
~lon of five (5) years beyond the prl.ary term, Lessor reserves the right
~o demand the re11nquishment fromth18 lease an13 the return to the Les-
:;or of all lands not drilled, worked, reworked or not in production of
011, gas, _sulphur, Be.lt and/or other brines in paying quant1tle6, or
:~ands not unitized or pooled with other lands belng drilled, worked, re-
;.:orked or producing in paying quantities. ,Lessee shall, thereafter,
...,1th1n six (6) months from the date of rece1pt of such demand, make e
:elec'tion of such lands 85 it may desire. to retain for a 5econd primary
t,erm in pareel{s) of not leas than 160 BCreS each of the lands leased
'-lere1n and so advise Lessor of its select.1on(s) 1n wr1ting within the
.;a1d six (6) months. As to such lends 50 selected, Lessee shall pay to
~essor, as addit10nal cash consideration for a second primary tel"1:l of
'~ive (5) years com:r.encing ten (10) years ~ror:1 the date first set forth
'n this lease, an ar.~unt to be computed and to be 1n the sape ~roportion
s the init1al cash consideration bears ~o the entire net miner~l 10-
:-ere=sts initially leased herein, As to suet: ~econe primar-y ter:r" lr.::;sell"
~ovenents to be bound by the same terms and condlt~an9 af contained ~n
aragraph 2 hereof as to' the lands.selected :"n acc=r1anc~ w1;;h ~~.is
':'I-numbered paragrat>h.
If this Lease is being miiinta1ned br p:'oductiQn after the np1re-
. ion of five (5) years be:yond ..he secontl p!'~l:lary term, LeS50~ :-e:erves
. he fUr~he!" r.lght to demand the rel1nqu1sr.ment frorr. tt,1s leF!se :!or,d the
'eturn to the Lesso:, of all lands not th'?:1 13:--!lled, ""corked. re~crked or
',ot in produCt1on of 011, gas) sulphur. salt! and/o:-' o~!-,<;,:" hrines ~n
. a~'~nb quantities, or lands not un1tized 0:- poole'cl_wlth other llInds
elr,g drilled, loforked. ~elolorked O!" produc~n& in peyln(;' G.ua:1t1tle!J.
..easee shal:!., therea:"'ter, .....ithin :;11. (6) months fr,?1:l the date :" !!:.:ch
"er.:.and. makl? a fU:-tl'H!:" selection of such lands ar it dC5~i'eS to rete:"n
or a third p!'ir:lary '::!!rm in f:.e same manner' 2$ s('t forth :!.n the p:--oceding
'n-numbered pal'agra~l-.. As to such lands SC' [,'?:':'ct~d, Lessee she!! pay
',0 Lessor as adcl~tic:~al o:ash considerat1or; !'c'ro ~ thir~ j"Jt'1rr.e:-y :t'r:: of
'1ve (5) years cor::--:er:cing t"lent~' (20) years !':--o:r. tt,e ::!a';e firs'; 5et !'orth
n this lea::;:~ J a:1 :s:-::-:..;"t ';0 be o:onputec ir, ~l,(: :;:lr.1l' :Oul:mer as- ::>e~ ~'::'r~h
n the preced1ng \;,r.-r~'..:r.-.bered pal'a~rl;lph,
2, ':'t,o:! L(..::~~.<o.: ~l.al1 ~r-,wj 1:': ~f1.-j l"_\!:,I',":'rl"': thO? ac';.u~l dl'!~~ill;'; o~
t least one 'I' ..... .,.(:11on ::~r(' l:.n\J" l'co"":".'l ).,...,.t.,. "d~r,~~', tho: ~~l"::t
ear" or the P~l~&;.:::e~I:;-he.reo.!': aDd ~~::::'j'~ :';il:!:l'~rud 1n &lId l.'~:;.!:,o:nCC'
,he acttJal dr111in~ o~ at le:,st 1'0\:1' (l;~ :IJ~!~~'~..I\:ll t.:l!l:s :l~:---~r'E :he
alu:1ce of tt.e pr~;-:a:"" '.:.er-r.: ~f :!".~:; 1(:;):;:0;:', :,w.! .::';:t::. cf.o~:n~nclnc =-'-lc!:
pe~at~om; shall P!',::-:..o;:'..:te sa",!! ~!: !;(j0c.i ;:-.~:t, :i!1'1 ~:l..,h :'~a~cnub!e ~l.H-
.ence' en.d .:!'.n.o. '..:I)I'~:-:-:~:r,l~l-':f:": ::..:mno:-:- t6 :j~:;9~"""':-' 'I:".:! ._ .d;;"Jc.~:-:= !laid lane
.'
.,
. i:: ~
."
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.01i112086IBPIOR.11668.13581i1IS-12086
Page 2 of 15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:23 PM EST
'.'
"
Appendix V.G.4
,:.'" ".
.
,\..~'.~' ! -' . .
"'..
r"",.
, "
. , ~ ,,;" '
',"'r,."
."
"
',".
,"' I
'.'.-
~[~11968 .;.'1360
.'
:'
'.
~ot" p,rcc1u.ct'iqn until ~uch ~ed' be completed or 8b8;1donel:J,', If no well'
shall be co~me~ced and'con~lnue~ to, completion) wlth reasona~le d111-
, fflenc~ an~ 1n ,8 workr.1?nl1ke manner- td d1scQver..and,'dev.el~p sail) land" ..
.for product1on"untll Buchwe.ll" 1s .complete_~ or abdndoned..wlthln the' .
....'flt!lt::i~ar lJe'rlo,d,rtl,f toe tet:nt '01' the ~e8se"'t~e,'el'lt1re' Ie/ase..shall be
" " Void. ", If ,,tour ,(~) additional weils shall not be',commencr:d an6 eon- .
_ . .t1nuftd .~Q .:comp.ht1on :'w~th' reasOnlil,bJ,o dt.l1gflOce' 'an'd' 1n a- w'orkmanl)ke I
. '~:}ai}ner-_~o dheo~.ez:. and' ~eve.lop said land 'for ;produetlon' untl1 such
:.~ ,-we.11s are. c:omphte~ -Ok'- abandoned within ttJe balance ,or .the Ilriinary
term of the lease, then th1s lease shall become forfeited and vo1o as
to all of tho land covered hereby. except that upon which wells have
been drilled. It 1s further un~er8tood and agreed that the only penalty
for failure to drill such well 1s the oancellation of th1s 1~a8e or 8
portion th~r~or, 83 hereinabove provided. In the event or such
forfeiture the Les$or shall be ent1tled to retain all payments thereto-
fore made or accrued,
All wells required to be drilled under the provisions of this
Seotion 2 shall be drilled in an efficient, diligent and workmanlike
manner and in.accordance with the b~st.praot1ce to a depth not less
than 6,000 teet before .abandonment'thereot, unless production in paying
quantities has been accomplished at a lesser depth.
3, This lease shall terminate as to both parties on any an-
niversary date hereof 8S to all land covered hereby on which rentals are
payable hereunder on such ann1versary date as hereinafter provided.
unless Lessee shall on or before such anniversary date pay 1n advance
to Leu,Bor an annual rental of $3.50 per net mineral acre, for the
number of acres' included in such land on which rentals are so payable.
,
Rental shall be payable Onder this lea~e on or before the anni-
versary date on all lands then covered by th-h lease, except land in
a section applicable to B drilled well or upon which sectlon production
1n paying quantities has been obtained' or upon which section drilling
or reworking operatlofi3 have been conducted in good taith and in a
workmanlike'manner within thirty days next preceding the annive!'a:'y
date.
The rentals herelnabQve provided for and all royalties p~?vided
for 1n paragraph Ll he:-eln below shall be paid by. ch~ck or draft of
Lessee. payable ~o Le!lsor and ma1led or delivered .to the orrtee of ':he
Comptroller, &ade County Avlation Department, Miami International
A1rport, P.O. Box 192075 AMP, Miami, Florida 33159, on or befo~~ the
the anniversary date for which such rental 1s payable. If any
1nterest In. the ~,-",n':al payable hereunder ~ay bec:or.\e owned by ano";he:'
or others than the Se3'OT', the entirE!' rental ma~' be paid T;c :'e3::'O~ e.:3
herein prov11ed. arlc !,t shall ::1ake approp!'!.~te dht:--ibutlon the~~c:'.
The cash consIderation is the consideration for th1s leasel
according to its ,;erm5, and shall not be allocated as rental. for aojl
per10d.
Leue!! ma" :'el~nqu1Sh the r1ghts g:oanted hereunder, e1ther as
';0 the enti!'e ar~a c~yered hereby or any portion thereot, at 3n:,' ';1me
by f1llng a release for recoro:! 1n the county where the land rel1c:r;!.shed
is a1tlJated and r!.l~ng a duplicate oristn,al, certified copy, or '.. ...
photostatic copy ~:- the release with Le350r within thirty d~j's . ro",
the date it 1s fil~d for rec~~d, and thereafter no rental $hall be
~8yable hereunder as ~o the acreage so releas~d and Lessee shall be
~eleased from further obligatlon5 as to such rellnqulsh~d :~~pa~e,
~. When production from the land covered by this lease 1s
4:t:t!lnI!1, :.:.~ i..e.;i1t'3e agrees ':.? pay or _caus~ :'0 ~e p.nld to Le;isor.
the' term hl!r~~r.. ::t)'! ~ollowlng rOY<llt 1e~:
'l'::'~ng
.'.
.......,
.,':, ':'
'. "
.,
'.,'
,'.
. .
. '.
(3)
,.
'1
< '.
"
"', i.
."
.'
Appendix V.G.4
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:23 PM EST
Order: [QuickView) Doc:
2.01 IjI 20861BPIOR. 1 1668.1 3581Iil 5-12086
Page 3 of 15
: :.... ~ ',~
'4'1 '
.1~:"';!'
,. .,
".
,.
: t.
'. s.:rl !668 ~ i'36J
'.,
,n "
. (a) On, o~ll -l.fi..6 ~ dr the &rO~5'prQd'uc~~on' ~.r9:r. t~l~:';
.1eaEe, 1;he same to be, del1vered.tQ,Le,srlo:, at',tlw ~l.'ll:; 0:' tc.
the c::-ed1t. of Lessors into.'the plp~11ne to ....hiet, the\iells ~a:.'
b~ <<fonne'cted or'1n lieu' of, del1ve.ring 6uch royalt~. oil ,1.n ,~1.r'!~,
Lttssee _ may ;:: a~' Les spr the valde. thereof at the. we,lis on the e(lte
of prQ(~,u"ct'!.~,n., ,. . . .,
t '," _'" -'."
:tb) Cn &85. 'inl;:ludii\g .ces!Pttlis~ . gas, o!' c:'hqr' sa~.E"''Ju::- .
:S\lbstehce., produ-ced'_.froin. th1s.leuse"ami, sold o~ 'used of!' ttJe ;.' I.'
pr.e_r.li'~e.s _.for the 'e~tra.ct1on of'Gasoli'ne or other pr,oducts '
therefrom. the value' at the well of '16.6 1. of the" 6BS so
sold or used. ~n gas sold at the well. the v~lue thereOf
shall' be 16" r. of the amount realized fror.l such sale;
wh1le there is B gas well on th1s leaae or on acreage pooled
therewith. but gas is not belng sold or used, Le~8ee may pay
as royalty on or before ninety days after the date on which
(l) said well is shut In, or (2) the land covered hereby or
any portion thereof ls tncluded in a pooled unit on wh1ch a
shut-in well 1s located, or (3) th1s lease ceases to be other-
wise maintained, as provided herein. wh1chever 1s the later
date. and thereafter at monthly intervals. a sum equal to
one-twelfth of the amount at. the annual rental that would
then be required to be paid 'to maintain said lease by rental
payments, and if such ~ayment is made or tendered, this lease
shall not terminate and it wl11 be considered that gas !s
being produced from this lease 1n paying quantlt1esi provIded,
however. thIs lease may not be ma1ntained 1n force by such
shut-in well payments for a longer period than forty-eight months.
(c) On sulphur. sBlt and/or other brines produced from saId
lands, 5% of value at wellhead.
The ~oyalties hereinabove provided for shall be computed aft~r
. deducting any 011 0:- gas reasonably used for the production thereof.
Lessee shall have the right to use any water that may be on the
premises for opera~10n hereunder and the right tQ use SQ mUl:n c~ the
su"face of t.he la:-:c cOYf!red hereby as may be rusonable necessar;,. ~or
developing and operating on this lease for produ~t1on and for 3~o~~n6.
_';Iarket1ng and :;re..,s?or't~ng the products therefrom, 5uch use to be ':::)nduct~d
under cond1t10ns of :e-ast InJ ury to the 5urhce of the land.
It is agreed that if !...essor owns the title to or an i~t~:-es~ ~n
~he 011 and gas 'u."\cler the lend covered b:r this lease less tha:l ~he
.,.ntire mineral' inte:'est. then the royalties and rental~ here.!.:1 ::,!'o':i1e~
for shall be :'educ~c! proportionately.
5. 1..11 roya::~~s due Lessor shall be pal:1 !:":""o;npUy am! ~:-:';::':",~
in accordance ~ith acceptable practice ~f the 011 and gas ~n~us:r~,
"'ubject. however, ~(I accountinB and audit as the Lessor may reason3bl:1
!"equlre.
6. L.essor o!" ~';s authorized representatives or ae;ents s!":a!l .a":
'111 reasonable tir.es have access to the '"ells, gauge books, oil and t;~!
meters, tank5, :-es'!:-'/olrs, sump holes, bu~ld1ngs and other structures
and epplian~es plac~1 upon the land herein leased by ~essee.
., ':'he :..es:o:..' s:~o:!.~ have a f1rst Hen ~pon all p:'od''':Ct;~0:1 t:-or.:
:hE- lu:1':is :!"'s-:r1b~~ ~:": :::x~~b1':; A to sec',,::-,:, the pa:::r.:ent of a:~. '~~1~'~~1
:'c.::1.1!.:. :l,r,j ?:n~!" ::t.:""_~ ':l:~ r.:':Jnej' that may becomE:' d1)e u:1de:- ~h:': ~~.:l!;~,
'd''",'; ":':1 3<;'Ct::'~ L"'~::e"::':: ..pe:-!"a!":::;ance Qf its obligat~on:; under. ";Il~!: ~':-'35':'.
',.,'
',.
, ',"
'r '..
'. ,
"
..
" '
( ~)
.",
','
; I
'. "
.,.
.;
Appendix V,G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.0111I2086IBPIOR.11668.13581I115-12086
Page 4 of 15
Created By: andye. Printed: 10/19120074:59:23 PM EST
,-
"
" ,
~;f', 1668',;c l3si
'f ". I
..
" ,
... '!.
" .
,....
.,'
."
.'
"
"
'. 8. Lessee shail hav~ the r.1ght 8t'l\ny .t1me w1111e> thl~:ll"ase' t~~
4. .forc& and ef(ect. or wlthlrl' a reason'able time a.rter tlw expiration
", r th1e lease,' t9 rembve..al1'.property and fhtures placed b;y L~~5oe on"
'the hnd covered her~hl}', 1n.t::.ludlng thE!' -right to .r;j.raw' and'l:emove't111'
caSln~J,' 'provided Lessee'has- .comn~ledwlth'all' 'obl1sat~'on'5'\.1ndei. tq:;;-
'lease',at,the- tlme'of.sach remova.L 'Le:slJec'sh'lI11 re~to~e.th~ ph'ot.~r::,'
.to".its forme'r: :c_ond1tl.on 1ni>Oni'1'.as th1s .1s..'dee.rned prac't1cbble upon the
cohcl\ls1on of .d~d,'lltn'g or .an~' oth~r 'o'perations auth'l).rlzC'd b~' "t't..f.s '/
1.e"s15e'-sgreement.. .' . - . .. . ,"
9. The lease contemplates the reB60nat-le devt>lopment of the
prOduct1on from the described land 1n Exhib1t A, including t.he
drilling of 813 many wells as a reasonably prudent operator ."ould drill
under the same or similar circumstances, In the event production in .
paying quantities ehoold be brought 1n on adjacent land dra1n1ns the.
leased premise>s, Lessee agrees to dr111 such offs.et wells as a rea3on-
ably prudent operator would 111"111 1n the same or Slr.;.:,.I[.1r ClrC'...l1lJ5tance::'
at 5uch locations required by spacing regulations adopted by the ~tete
of Florida Department of tJatural Resources.
10. A ltlg of each well dr111ed on this lease shall Oc !"11ed ~11th
the Lessor at The Office of the Aviation Director, 1.:1am1 International
Airport, wIthin th1rty days after such well shall have been completed
or abandoned and the correctness of such 10[; muat be sworn to by Lessee)
its agent or driller, and it must be accompanied by a plat showing the
exact location of said well.
',,'
11. Lessee il.s hereby given the r1Eht to pool or' combine the
acreage covered by this lease or any parts lh~!"C~o!' witl. other l&l'Id,
lease or lease, in the In-.mediate vIc1n1ty th(,I'C'C!', and wM'::her' :tote
land, Federal land 0:' prlvutely owned la:ld, ~1l,en l'ea.~"n&l'l:: r,('('(';;c~r;.'
to conform with (h'!1::'~n6 un1ts establ!r.bed b;/ t.he f'tate ::'~ ?:tI:':.i',
Department of !latur-r.l Resources or to CO:I~O:;'I~ .,:! ~h an:,. t,(";.:!.l:W '.:'
integration order' !~::>'Jed by su-.::h departm('n'.:. Cj'ero.t10m; ~O~. dl'~~I~nL'
reworking or prcduct.io:l 0:1 i,n:.. port of 3 rllQl~':J unit CO:1POCl"C ~T1 ',:l~r;l(:
or in part .o!' the- ~~I:ld CO;:C'l'e!.l h(;,l~b:: r.!-..=~~ H- ~':'n:.:~'Jt':'~d :n ti(;':.I:".~C:1::
for dl'ill!.Il(;) !'e~.:o:'t:~nr. 01' l=:.("juct~on ('I: ~'I:J'J t"':..\'~I',!r! t.~ .\'.:..~:. ~!!:::"."~ a:,j
the entire aC!'~3.t~ .:,;,r.s'.~:-lJt~nc such L:ll~~ '.;:' U]}~:.:, :~I::~l,~'~ '::'~:~':::
for all purpouc:; ~:: ::' ':bC' sa.me ~:C!'r:- ~r.cll;~l:J ~r! th~t' 1'.).1. _, I.:.'.~t;.',: .
that 1n lieu of to':" :"o.:21til?G o;>15e....il~rll IH:':.C'~:1 ~:('~! !'~l"j. ~::".:' ::.I,a~;
receive on produ~~~:n ';:"C:T1 (.'Cjd. of ~:.lc!. '.::i~'~: '...!-,(~ i-':'.~Ir.C:.t~01: ":!..~
royalties here!.n :;":.1j':'~13ted th~t. Uit' arnou~'.: C::'.~':S50~~; ,~\~I.I.:.l'::,!:;r.
the r:1ineral inte:'e~': In the <tc:.""f'=" pl;:r':,~(l ~n .ne i '.:! "_'.,",_.1, \..:l..t
involved be3r~ ~t' ':.:-..;: ent!. :,!":"ty 0:' the. l~.'.:}l.::.:i:. ~r,"'l',l.~" ~Il ;-..;"':1 -.:.
12.(:!.} ':1.':0 :'~.::::e~. :;)I:ll~ I.i~' ~m ~:.;::-\::";.~. ;:,'..~r.:;: '.111':1 .::. I.~';.".:.
~~~~~t~~~ r~~:~;,'.: ~~~~'.! .:;~~~) ~~~:-~ ~;~~ 1:;~ ~.~ ~:~..; ~'.:. ;.~~...~. '~:: :~!~.~.:. :,~::~:.?~,~ ~ :':!.,:::~,'~ ..~ :'::
liable for dar.-.:'H'"'. ~.; <J'il.1tltlc ".):. :-larine ......, .,.,..-" 1_.t.J l:_.;J,., ".,~ .....
;m~~.~~ Em~F :;~~;~L~~~:~r n~~~~:L', 'J:~\:U '::i':':.::~:},:~:;, ~:::~.:'::::';..{
if the Lc~sr:t.! r:3:';!,~~:~~;('.' t!',nt ':h(. ..l'oL:I.~~'.: ". .,.,:.;.... ,,:' ,.'!,..
pollutln(: r:ondl~l(J:, ;.:Ci:' t.ll,: l'l.':;ult 0; :~~',:.. ":.' :''''~:'.':~l~i'":
(.,) I,ct. I.,:: u~:"'j
{1.) :c.:: ~,," t):. (':f}':e ~.;l::a.ll t, ',' ~ . !.'.
~':) ..":.n .,:.' :.:' 'io.!, -;!'l\I:h ::-,!:.,~: :.
r')/",:.:..':,...~bl'.. ~ "'xc!:::..:."..'}:: oc..~:,:-! :..
n:I".::. ;"; ) ~ ~,;): '.,: -;' :~ It~C' ,,\':l~:~. :..~;~:n ~._ ~tJ~: : .;.
1-.
,.,
.'.,'.
! '., ~.,..!:; .
.J I';
.:' 1'.:......
"'..:1.':,': .
.,' :..
, ., :.~:' ;:!',.,
(.r.I.:.........
. t-" :, .-:: ~ : ,,-
':.1:.;.t1.
..'d
Co'
. ~ .
"
"
....'
,
." .
'.'
, ,..
,,'.
"
",
"
,....
;::~
.";..
,"
','
.'
Appendix V.GA
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.0111120B6IBPjOR.1166B.1358i'1/5-120B6
Page S of 15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:24 PM EST
"":.
I,: "".
"
l~ ' .
.,.
.;
. : ~
"
, r 11'668: n 1"363
, . ',.'
.'
'.
'12.,( 2) The Lessee shall: report. to ~h~ Lk'sll',:l' ~r.d to ~.!.l' ~"~"J~r.1;J:i'
or Inb~r1or Resources, all spills dr le'at-age of oq, [:!.i:;i. or att.l':'
.petrol,eum proo:ucts", 01' other waste mDtEr,rlal; nod a,!~'.'.:;uch :;ril~ 01'.,
:,leakt;lge nh~~h oannot be Imme01.at!'1y contl'oUell ahllll bt: repcl'tl:?'~! 1.0 the
,s'ppropriate .t;'ederal :agen~y and' the. 01 yislon' Qf Inter!or- Reriourcr.::'~,'
. Oepar'tme;nt. of Uat,ul'a~'. Re:solJr.,~'s. '.",' " . ' ,
. .' . ~ ,',' .
. '.'t=3, The Lessee shall not asslgn',thls le~st' in \'lhole. Or in 'j:)"&rt'
tlntl~'. and..ex'oept t'he Lc's5or'shall approve and consent, in "-'rHinE to
such asslsnment. SUbJeot to the preceding sentence, the covenants,
conditions, and aGreements contained herein shall extend to and be
binding upon the 5UCCt'ssors or assigns of the pa!'t~es t,ereto,
In the event of assignment hereor in whole or in P&l't, 1n
accordance wIth the prov15ions hereof,.l1abll1ty fol' breach of an~
obligation hereunder shall rest exclusively 'JJ;on the o~mer-or-'tht!!"'"}eafre-
'='1' a portion therec!', I-Ihocom~1t& such breDch. ~:" th~r, lease it'
assigned in accordance with 1 t~ terms as to 3 se1;r'llgate:i port1c:~ of
"he land covered hereby, rentals payable hereWlder :;hu.ll be apportionable
os between the several leasehold owners ratably on an ..creoge biJs13
and default in rental payment by one shall not affect the rlght3 0;
other lea&ehold mmers hereunder.
111, If Lessee 1s unable ~o secure a v&l1d dr~ll1nc peJ'm!t to
drill a well, or I!' t:y reason o!' war. labo!" trouble5, ('Or lack 0:" materials
caused either b)' the exercise or governmental Dutho!'it~. or b>' str1kt',
lack of labor, 0;' t:'ansportat1on, or as a r~sult of Dooo, stol'n:, f'ire
or blowout, the L~s:'e~ Is prevented frorr, l'ol:lt.If:ncing or COmr,ll-"t~nr-
operations ~or the ~l':llinG o~ any well or w~lls r' ~ul:'ed unde)' th~s
leose, then the t1:1~ durinG 'rihich Lessee ~:. 50 pl'e\:cnted from ca:--rY!!1&
out the terms of s:::.;': lease shall not be counted aca1nut L~ss(,o'... and
!.essee shall autor:ta-:':'cally have the addtt':Dnnl rel'ied \dthin 'r:il:'':I--, ::0
ccmply with the te-l"':!!S of this lease. In th~s connecti,)!'}, :"C':;~O;-'" 3hall
at all times be re1~;:I'Qd to usc' rea:;(lnuble 'l!l!.(ence to cv'~:'t.'o:r:~'
such difficulties as T-'!"ornpll>' as th~ u!rcumstanco:>r; w~ll p~!"'m!"',
15. If tho;.> ~'''[':Jee ~hould f3i2 OP r'C'~us,:, t.(. :-:,(:~:.: ;:::"IW:Il~ L: &:1::
st:.r. due eithe!' a:; :"::-;:.al O~. zhut-on ga::-, :'(;:;:.=~~:: "n t:.~:; !(:o;;e c::. ~.;):-'
royalty on the prc..;l'Jction ~'::'~hln thlrtj' J~::~' ':-I~'t'_.:, ~L ::);1,11 t,~:.,:.::;~ ~!;.;'..:,
0" 1f". the Lessee 0" ~ ~s outho:-'1:.cd. ugenl t,1;,'Jld ;o;~,:~n).l': ::;:!i:!:' ;,:1:: !':.r~:-(l
:'~turn or fa!se r'~;'~::-':; o:onc'.;':'n~:lG proc~l~l:.~:'j, :")l~::~:: .:":: d:'~l::~i;:-. C'I'
1f the L~s:;;e-e shO~I~.:! fall or T'C:'fU:H.' ';(' rJ~'::: 'Ill:; ~~:'~'e': \.;(:1: :i:' :~.:.::.~.
in good foHh 8:l :"J!';:.;~:'c'J t':: 1311 IlwJ the :';;~'"'' ::~'.-! :":'~~.l:l"~:>:-:~' :,io::r:~"l
by the !:"'u~e of fl~!'~'Ju, 0~' l!' t!H~ :.(,~:;('(. .:. :':' :,.....:;7 :;:,(1.0:''; :"~'.;.:"
~~~ ~~;:~~r! ti~.~t: i:,:~~~; ]:;~}i;~~i1:~~~~.~!: ..',';f~'::;;l ~:i,:;\'.:;'~~ ~.,';:;',': :.:.:.: '
after wl'it.ten no';lc'" ~c ~t;.':';:>.H: toy Le:;:'H..I' :." __'~;;:; _"~ .!;(-.' 1~.L.t'!. '.':-
\'Ihich Leaso:' conni.J'.'rr, ~e~'~(:-, 1n rJl-":-~\ll..., .:~ ::,~;~. t'''''~::'':,';lJlt' ~l':'.' ....
remedy any ::;UC~l tk~":'~!:', tlil:.'. 1~3~<" nll:I:;"? ;." :.-.;;t: ".;" ;....:.!'....:.'.OI L'::
';h'O' Lessor; and wt,-:.'n ~'O!':'Q1t.l>d t.lw :11'(<r .1:,:=:: ',f.;1::. !.. ::'JbL":l:~ '
l(o:J,se to the h1eh~!;~ b1.,j.J(:!", 1I:",'J':I' lhl' :;:I!::'.' l't.,.'.:::,~~,.:',:. "':':~J".'.~':
~~~ 1 ~~~ ~~~~:~ l~:' ;~rj~:':"~ '~:~;~~~~~'~1" ::~~~ ...~.L~.h~;;.'.'~:: :.\~.:~,:.;; :~:. :'u;'; \.'7. : ~.I~ ~ .~:: :"'"
::1<'1'.' be r(f~nr.t;~t<;,t1 i'~"":~lj'!'l ':!1'.' !'ll.ht;. 0:' :!,:!"J j 'd'! :0':' . ...... :,,~'
:n~~rven('~, ..
1&. :~tJ';.~I~~t.:-'...::-Jtrll" :1:1:.' ~f :!;(' I.!"---''''::'~ Ii;', ,.'.;,. ..'
::,:.io!1$ c;')nl:Jinr.:'.J .!, ~!':!:: ;...:t;; " , ;',!"':;;o.l I~,'"'' :.'" .,:..: '.j,:'::,;' :, I:
.~~. ".he- r:'':'',':~::~''n;- ':' :hl:; ~'.'~1:\~' .....lLh '.!1" ;',:; .",:>''''':';.:'11" '~." i:...l'.::....
.n'; ')pe t',,'. : ('II ~.:" .... ..;' ,)1, . i.'.' 'l :..,':, :;'.' :'" .. " !': 1 .' :, ..' !,:t'
;.:--',':I:;\Qn:- r<:;u,-,: ,','; :;":111 lJ':',;:'!~~(:lI ::.' 'j,~:' I,,', :1.1.1.....
'i,"
.-' ".
..
,
"
.,
.,:
; ,
.,'
"
,,'
,
"
"
,':
( ~
"
, ,
,.
Order: [QuickView) Doc:
2.0\111 2086IBPIOR.11668.135811j15-12086
Page 6 of IS
Created By: andys Printed: 10/1912007 4:59:24 PM EST
Appendix V.G.4
,'.
,f"
O'rl' 'r.' '."'')''.
'k<" 1,06B 1&1.;64'
"l'
.',
.'
11. Thel ~S5ee J 0'1 ns
lts"e.sse'rit to 81'1 the t-eJ'II1&
bound t:he reby. .
in ~hls le'Gee for ~he Jlurpose of Jndicating
a':1d ,pro,viaon:> ~he."cor. und ar;n:'(,13 to"be
. t8. All te.rms, and l:Xpres5,'oJ' Implled 'covenilhts of 'thJs ]cose
~hBll \)e subJec.t', fe.oIl '~eder81 and.S.tate 1I:IW!i, c'JS'ecut1 ~re ordeJ'!J.. J'ulE'os
'.or ll'egul.atlo05. .and this lcs:;a" shs'll not. be te)'mlnHte{l. 1"0 't/.holco .01' jn~
. P~!'t',. !'lor..Le"ssce hel~.1'1obJe .In .~a.mages, 'ror 1"911u1'1O' 'to,comply ber'c!~l:th)
1f. cOJ:llplhnc& Is prevent~d by, or,!f lfuoh'fnl1urc 10 tlic"T'Cpult of any'.
.~ such 'law, ,o.rder, 'rule or. ree~latlo_n. '. ."', .'
19. Le5see shall, on or before ninety days sfLer each anniversary
date while this lease continues in force and effect. fl1@ wIth Lessor
e notarized report. 8S to the otatu8 of operatloml the-reon.
20. Prio~ to the time that the LeS5ee mincs, drills or extracts
1.n any manner, petroleum, petroleum pJ'oducts, gss, sulphur or any
mineral from the land covered hereby. Lessee shall deposit wIth the
Lessor a surety bond In the amount of t 100.000.00 from 8
surety company authorhed to do buslne3s In the State of Florida.
The bond shall &erve as securIty and is to be forfeited to the Lessor
to pay for any damages caused by mining or drilling operatIons of the
Lessee, Dallsges 8S used in thIs {lection shall Include. but not be
limited to,. air and water pollut1on. destructIon or wIldlife or marIne
productl vlty and an, other damage which impairs the heal th and general
welfare of the citizens of the State of Florldn. Lessee shall pay
the premIwns for said bond as t.hey become severally due and payabJe
and furnIsh a re-ceipted bj 11 therefor to the Lessor.
21. That Lessee hereby coveritmts and IlgrE'E':; to !.nvestlgllte all
claims of every nature at ita own e1.pen5C find to lndcmnlfY, protect,
defend, ho]d and save harmless tile L(.>sDor f.rom an)' and all claims,
aotions, law suits and dcmand~ of :In~' kind or n~tul'C" AJ.tslng out of
th1s leasE'. .
22. Le!lsee may conduct. r.(-('rh;Y~;\~:ll l'y.1'1Cl,'nt!oll on the land~
covered by this lease,
23, Prior.to procedlnf~ w:!.th tll',. r;l'(.oT'h~'<,Jc.d !-xf'loJ'nt1on, t~'l('
Lessee shall serve J'Cflsonobl". not!c{' on \.h~. L~':,:;~':., ::'h" ,'out.f.- !.o t.(-
taken by the geophysical crev r:llmt ~IJ'l',', U{o ;1f'1~.t'..'''d t~.. th..... !.r:;;:'or.
If areas of vB]unble or ('ncj;j~lt:t'!"'ed ~\f,~,(:~r'~ 0~' v'..f''! .,' :-J~I ('J' ".;, ~1~ 1 ~('
would be di~turhed b\' t.he f'r'or;o:~cd 1'<"U:'~. ('~' r(.('r~..'::-~l"';l 0;....'.;,. ~NH..
the Lessor DIlly '{'1U",,(. r.t'r"_,ut~llf: ('I!" nl(. r"",l~: "!' I"-,.l.;".:!~ !on c:'~. '.,~H'
dama.g~d area aceo/'dinr:. 1.0 .it.. :~j''''l< r~(":ll i"n:~,
2"1. Al] r;elsrnlc r.hot holez. wll"l!I',." !'('i' !'~.~.!'~l:" l':m (lr r(~f'l('c-
tIon technique sh<lll lot! r)i'I]~...d f.u!'!'!df't1tly 'l""r' 'c. 1I',,\,('nl un()u" .
surface craterInr; nnd cnm;equcnt d:l:nal"(' Ic' l.!I<.' r.u!':"'~;:I:~lnr. Vl'f,c.UJt l-;n
and wlldl1 fe' n1:' :Jurfacc dlaJT.'~'l\ !\hn 11 b<.' rC"',d '. t ',d flnr: no C'xp] o~d on:;.
unless set off in geoph:;':dcnl t.ubing, nhall ht. ;,l't otr on tll~ bQttor:1~
or any water bodle~ on the ]OlH.cd premIseto,.
25. The Les!iee shall take all rell~orIO[ll(' pn:c1Jutlons der.lr;ncd to
prevent the 5tartin& of r!J'e!l tn area:! of r,corh;:r.lt'ul or ot.her opern-
t1ons.
26. Lessee nhall comply wHh aU l'ulf!~ IUd l.t'r.u]llt1om, o!. l:ht"
Florida Division of Forestry, the Florid.l Gnt:u' [m'.! !":'C'utl Wat.er f1.,h
C mmlsslon and the Unitt.?d -Stat('!' Bun'flu n!" :".p(>l.~ F~:'h(,t'ic:', and ...:!ldllrc
f~l'" the p~tectjon of v....r'(.l:lJ1.!mr and wlltlll!"l., '.!I~' .-::~lrul vlohtlon
of any of whict. sh..1::' C'''rl;".l!"..U!''. r'llu:-,'~.or '!.rm~llt,' ~~'!I 0f ':.hit1 It:O-f"l'.
Lesse~ Doe-reer. to Ahtdto t.:.' all e>r.113\.lnr Feder:.l r~ntut(':;, ru)e:;',ref,u;
1 t10ns and guldel1ne~ rfo'rR!"d1nr fhl' (.'xrllJrtlt.!Ofl nt. and rrodu(!t~on 0,
~l ga!t and mineral!;, 5pec1~1cnll:1 1nc)\ld1nc; t.hf" i'ult:r. ann T'C'r,ula-
. ~.10~8 or the !latlonal' r8~k ~erv~ ceo r.Clv~rn!nr r~~l)n:-~f'd(,:I.ll 0ll" Dn~ (i;!;.
.8ct1v1t:i~~, ':!1l\e,.:{(' .cFfI., Pn.!'t. ~', !"'.':JIo,rrol"l ~, Hi- ..t1P,'r?"'. exj.._..tfJ.J orr
, ,.' ' .
. ,
".
. ;
.'
"
" "
"
'.
. (7)'
".
'.
"
"
,.
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:24 PM ES.
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011 II 20861BPIOR. 1 1668.135811115-12086
Page 7 of 15
Appendix V.G.4
..,
~,' "
:,;;. ." . . '.' ,.J!f,JI668 ;c1'365o:, , ,". , ",
l~"Oct.ot:er5.1..e2.'I"1' .', '.
. ~,' n I.ole.e'JE!',nt ,an;}' such sh"t'utes, -ru) (:,5 J' 1.~'rIJ1f:t1'o~15. .
. Of' gu.drLnes ..re ~ulir.'('q\.ldnt]~. _C'llimf;e~.;ln ~u('h a !'~!.'~.l(m ~s 1:0 l.r'cV~de.'
. a. ]<:[;"st:r degr,ee of pr,otect) on to the t:'nv1 rorhn(;'nt J 1.l'&~I(.'e !:.),a,l],
"} , notwithstanding such changes,' 'contlnue" to. camp1\' w1th the'renuln::rnen'ts'
of th~5e .:stat.ute:s,- rules. rl?(;:ulatlons and 'c:U-lrlO~l'.lnf!S 1n ('xl~t:l:'nce on
Oct9"b.er S"; ~982., Lessee'sha]). pbtAln pll pl:')'mils 'l'l-Qu!,pl'd for Hs'
."operat1ons,"ln Da~e Count~. ," .
. 21,', DrllHnt J'l('J'm1t,~ .i\nt;J flrtlv~.nPf ~h'aJl be ~ubJl:'ct tb the
,I!iUPl'l'v.1s1CJI1 oJ" \.he'Oq &n.d.G(I~.. IodI1l1r\lstr:at.or' of',the.F1.o'rlQ.;i [.f'~:-~r't.ment>.
.' o~ J:etural' Reso-UJ'~E..'and' shall be ~ubJ_t!ct" tq' \.t,lt st.atew:l'de ,1;Gcot,r:ral :.
.Rules,,~n.4 J\e'g~]at1ons GOVE'lm'ng .the Con_5~l~vation or 01 i and. Gas 'in
, FloJ"lds:" . . '. .
28. The location, preparat1on, eonstT'Uct1on maintenance and
restoration of the access roed and drill sih shali be accompl1~~Jed to
the 98t! s fa ct1 on of t.he Lessor in accordance with the following:
(a) The locat1on and construction plans of the access I'oad
shall be approved by the Lessor pr10r to the cOlllmencement of
construction.
(b) No con::;tructlon work shall be undertaken without
approval of the Lessor.
(0) The drill sHe must be apPT'ovE.>d by thE' Ler.sor before
clearing of .any accel5s road or drl1l1ns sHe 1s donE', Lessee
must notify the Lezsor of th~ tentative s1te ~ocallon so that a
repre&entative can inspect the drill ~1l~. Drl111ng 1n or
within 200 yards of a rlv~r, strc-am. ].::Iy.1:' , }.Iond (or the nood
plain thereof), swamp. sJn~, or drain, ,hall rt'qu1r'e specl.al
approv.al by toile Lessor. if such driJl1ng 1l:' not prohibited by
]a"'.
(d) Lessee shall re~tore the drjJl site and 8~cess road in
conformance with plan eubmitted to and approved by the Lessor
at the time or &pJ:.,r{)\'oJ at ..tit. site t1)(.-l'('O[. f'.l'5~oreUon'
.shall mcet with the approval of the 01] and Gas t.dmlnistrat(l:",
find :hl? LeSfior shall be notl:-i~d W"11l;'r. '!"'f.~tC-:-"tjC'lr1 it {'omr]f>te.
:e.' :-ho:> ~::~~ of thf;' <!:'~lJ !'::{' :-!'11:~ ~l<-: f:.};:"~'U :",0:1:. 1; (','ef-
~r. i;,'(!c. un]e~~ e JalTt:'l' ..r~& J~' ;'-.:r.~~~:f:~; il!ld <:j.,:','\'cd 1n
~::":: ~~,i; by the L",~~o!',
(f) ':'he i..-p.sst'e ~.h~ll no~-l!'y Iht. ;('~:,.t'r' "'~t~!!n ::f IIOUf'!!
c!'t!:':- tr,€' ':.('l'r'.~r;(J~~NI ("~ 1T'~~l:rJr fi"":': ... '... :~;(. ~::'\1J ~~:('..
(E' _.~!;.~'..~ r:.h_ ~..._: .-.. ...... I..
t~on! c.!' :il(~ :":i.:'_ ::. ~.'~' _"- I.. ".
and wl1~lif!'".
....:. ;,~~~ ~."".;-::.-
" ' :.. . ~~
29. LecceE" acknow1edp:~- thOl U.! [ ;.' I::~'~. ~ r r::,ldf;' r.ul'.ll:lct
'to the terms. condltions and Obli[flt10n!'o of the ~:'''(':''C:]''cl!:~ J(rtf'ort Pa.ct,
dated January 16, 1970, as heretofore amended and as may b(J ht'rca!"ter
amended. It shall b~ the obl188t~on of lh~ Le~~ee to secure from the
Untied Stetes Secretary of Transportation 'and the Uniled Stales
Secretary of the. Interior. acting on behalf of the Unit.ed states 'of
America, written 8uthor!tation and ratifIcation b~ lett~r app~oval,
wIthin n1n-ety (90) daY3 from the (late first set for::h in th1s Lease,
permitting Dade County, Florida. as Lessor herein, to e~ter 1nto. perform
and fulfill Its obllEa~lons and receIve the benefits uno~r th~ terms and
conditions of this Lease, nolwithstandlnt any terms, cond1tIons, re-
straints or obligations co~tained in the seld Jetport Pact to the con-
trary. In the event the ~ald United 5tatef. ~t"c!'t'Le.iIer. of TranfJpor':.a-
tlan and InterIor, re&pectIve.Jy, db not r.rant ~"Jd. ~,::'~':.ten authori~ation
and ratification within th~ saId n3ncty (90) d~Ys. th~n thJs Lease shall
be deemed to be of no further forc~ and e~rect and the cash consideration
pa1rJ by, Le&see to LeSl'-or. f;h_al~ be repaid t>;.' Lessor to Le~,:;ee, ~d th~.s
Lease shal'] 'b'e cancelled without rurther' li.at-II.ily to e1ther .p8.r~y hereto.
",
"
','
.'
"
i'
"
'"
.\
, '.
,
.,'
.. (8)'
~" ~
,
"
..
",
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:24 PM EST
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086iBPIOR.11668.13581I\15-12086
Page g ofI5
Appendix V.G.4
1.: . . t ~:'
~~<: '
'~I::n~6B ~'lj66
:', ....
'.'1.
....
". .30. It 1s und.erBt'oo~:bY' ~he' lessee that the lands de5c~1bed
in Exhibit I\A1l, a'ttache,d he'reto and .made' a: part tier'eor, were acquired
,by, .lessor. for airport purposes and ~hat pur.s~ant t9 tho Everglades ,'\
. ~e.tport papt th~ US,e thereof .has \;leen restricted tb. the con5truc~ion.
.an~ 1n,l!ta~la~1on of.a slf1g1e.r,unway f\nd teXl)i'ay, contr-ol t:owo.r an,d :'
'ce~tal'n aerlal lJavlsat10n 5Nsterns' all ,to be operated and. u~ed"fio1e1y
'. .for aftera'rt 'training, and ,transition purposes, .It' 10 :rurtbel' under.. .
'; stood' by' 'tne lessee t.hat~"the .costs 'Of acctu,1"sHl'on 'aT sa;\~ lands 8fld'
~he' e'xht.ln.& eonstructlon,QO the 'portlon tpe're'of of. the faalpties' .
'mentioned above were funded by the proceeds of Dade County Port Author-
ity Rev~nue Bonds, presently outstanding, wh1ch-wc~e issued and are
secured by a Trust Agreement, dated October 1, 1954, as supplemented,
by and between Dade County Port Authority and the Cheee Manhattan Bank,
as Trustee, and the First Natlonai Bank of Miami, as Co-Trustee. The
leesee agrees that 1 t will not exercise any of Us rights and prl vi-
leges granted hereunder in any manner which will constitute a hazard to
or 'adve~sel>' affect the reasonable development an~ use or the lands
lee.se'd hereWlder for the airport purposes for which such lands were
acqu1red or aircraft or ,a'11at1on operations now conducted aT' to be con-
ducted 1n the future on or over said 18nd5.
31. Not...:ithstanding any terms, provlsions, conditions or
covenants contained hereinabove to the contrary, this lease shall
terminate not later than th'1rty (30) years from the' date f1r~t Get
forth 1n this leese.
DADS COUNTY. FLORIDA,
th:-ough its Board of
County Co~missione~5
:'
3ct1n&
[\y
/;::-~
county I"anq~:er
WI'lNESS;
'-L'
7 i.1 ('I)
a. .__
,",,:,':ES':': :'.!c:!,'\P.~' f. BR1::r:EP. f!..EP.t:
( )/l /~ ..-d-<c.a".J'
........ ." ..,....,~~put~. ClCl'k
'. '.
f :: (r;o~::: ~~a 1)
.....1
", ...........
~t::;,:-::::
~y
HUl1IES & IlWII:5, a ~ral l'arulL'u,hip
COf'\;oscU of OWlcy J. llUlJh!~s. t111d Pall
A. ""","
1"
1Iy, .'. )
OOOlL"Y J.
YYjc c,rd.:.
~~'"-J Q.....".L--
,
(J..
HtD,..
.;
'..r
(I))',
, '
.'
"
<,
.',"'"
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.~11112086IBPIOR.11668.135811"5-12086
Page 9 of 15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19120074:59:24 PM EST
. o:ut1Y OF HINOO ) .
, . :'. 'I, R~ '!.arter'Miller - '.. J\'~tary Public in and for silid tbunty I,
M.:! -St:atlil,. do,hereby,certi!=Y tl'\at' WOLEY J. H\.JGms. ~raonaf1y known to re to be!
a Gster.u ParlnQr in 'HUghes , IflJ9hea; a General P;u:tnershlp oonpo6ed of.,Dudley J~.
HUp8 and' Dan A, HUgtte:s an~:wtP a!J, 81.Xtl' Genep,.l' Partner eX9Clleeq the fljnepinq
_inatriirent On ,this ,day and 'a~ledged,befdx:.e.~ that he ~ted-'said, in:st.nllWm~,'
as _ 8Ucli General Partner in the rwre of and for an.don behalf of. soid partnership,
freely and.'volm\t:arUly for-the uses and purpolSeS therein elq>rea:sed aricJ with full
aut:b::)r1ty so to OJ. .
'.
,.
Appendix V,G.4
.~
~::j 1668 PGl35T
, . - ,. " .' ,.
.'
.. "
c'"
", '"
."r
"
'.
S'J'A'JE OF KISSISSIPP;I
I,
..
,r;~ J!8: ~' \b9reof, I have hereunto set my hand and official seal this
.<UL.::..,'day of. _ /- ,1982. ~~ .
/. . _-'4.
. C' ,
"
,.
..
..
Order: [QuickView) Doc:
2.0/1/1 20861BPiOR. I 1668.1358/1115-12086
Page 10 of 15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:24 PM EST
'.
EXHIBIT "A"
, ,,', "p<::~ D~stlRrPTIOt!. BY SEC~;OI,;" . . . ~;:;JI,~~8.~C:I36B
,.'. ,,'. . ..... '. " ...'
aro:J.~' SUl'racr;- Acres. Bfld '-Correl'Jp~nd~ng tlel' "'.1..net;'& 1 ACr&z,::
.' ,
T6imSHIP 5'2 SOUTH - H'nlIGE 34 EAST, 'COLL1ER cour~TY'
Section ... Orbs's Acres '", ~Ie~
',' 2~'
22
23
. .24
"25' ,
'26
27
26
29
32
33
34
35
36
~51. 19
6~~.00
646,81
6~3. 66
6J.iL861
'6~4,,5i
6~ 7.62
6~8.25
325.57
32~. 51
6~5.90
643.79
6~1. 68
639. 57
~393. 9B
TO\'mSHIP ~3 SOU'I'H - ?A!JGE 3Q EAST. COLLIER COUJ!TY
'.:.
(5/2)
(NI2)
1'~1heral Acr~:;
1G2. %.
It?:'2~
1(1.. 70
.,lfC,';12'
160." .
10..1f .
161.90
162,0(.
61. 39'
81.n
161. ~f,
16:). 9~ '
160.<1
11'9.9(1
20~',5)
Sect10n
Dross Acres
Jlet W.neral J.cre:;
2
<
B (N/2)
10
12
I'
16
639.26
6~2. 9B
325.17
627.70
626.06
635. QQ
710.27
Q20t.. !;ltl
-;?'..:!~t~:1' .,
:-.;.,::GE
:l. E;":':':" I
C[;':":"!!~I~ C0'J:1TY
~:(.: !';~nc:'~':,: ,,:::"'~~;
~,~. M,
~" ':'~ . .: ~
$E- c tion
G:-OC$ i,cres
~ (S/2)
~~~: g
32;. ;::-
-: ~:l. ';5
';;,(. =~
G 19.71
O:;:;!.l(.
Ll r,/;. 'J~:
H
)]
1~
1::'MllSHIP ~.~ 3Q!..::-:: - ?i\::GS 35 E~.3T. [,';!"l!:: cOLl!r:'Y
159. E2 .
160..7:. '
eL 29.
15-f.93.
15(,.~&
15S.85
155.1; .
1229. 2~
.'': :' j~
: ~ ;'. l;~
JiUi
~M~
OrO:lS Acre&
':~I:'t il~nr.':,,~~ tcr('~
13
20
2?
]'.1
:'1
"
.s 37. BIJ
€~2.51
':;'3~. ~7
:0 3:- . :.~.
..:, 30. l~
~:~~:: ;~
~~',':~:~i!:L_'_~,_~-_ ;.:.':":F, '.r, E;-':'. :;,:~i':..:':::'~'.;-:";'
~-';.~
';~',...~~
6jj. :,.
j ~:;:- ~~
. ....:..
.' ... -' .
,_. --.- ~. ---..
'.
'.
.....
;;,-'
., ,
.... r ~
.- .-
." -. ----.-
,'...'
'.'
. "
'.
"
, .
:.
. .... . - .,
"...:._'__:.._',--.--.-- -
---:.,..--..--.---.
Order: (QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.11668.1358PI15-12086
Page II of 15
"
'- ..
",
"
,'"
"
Appendix V.G.4
Created By: andya Printed: 10/1912007 4:59:24 PM EST
"
'1
..
"
'.
.'
'.'
.,
"
'~;:"116?8 ~1369 .
MD~NDUM .NO. tTO OIL," G1\5 M~b MIHEML LE1\SI:
'between
DADE COUtjTY,' FLORID1\.'. 016 Lessor,
'. .' ,ahel
HUGHES & HUGHES, oS' Les~ce,
, .
. ..".'."", I.. , .'
'rhiB Addendum: No.' I to au, Gas, and:Mine['al LeaSe,. entered
into as' of thi~' ~ day" Of' cect:lritbe'r', 198~, between ~a~~' 'count~,
Florida, a politiQal subdivision of the St~te of FloridB, as
Lessor, and Hughes' Huqhs8., a General Partnership, composod of
Dudley J. Hughes and Dab A. Hughes, 1100 Capital Towers. Jllckson,
Mississippi J9201-3385, as Lessee, dated as of September 15, 1982,
WITNESSET.H:
WHtREhS, the partioB have heretofore entered lnto 8n oil.
Gas and Mineral Lease (the "LeaBe"). as of the 15th day of
September, 1982, for drilling rights on certain lands owned by
Lessor in Dade and Collier Counties in the Stato of Florida~ and
\iHEREAS, Paragraph 29 of said Lease is as follows:
"Lessee aCknowledges that this Lease is m<lde
subject to the terms, conditions and obligations
of the Everglades Jetport Pact, datod January 16,
1970, as here~ofore amended and as may be hereafter
amended. It shall bo the! obliqation of the La:ssec
to secure from the United States Secretary of
Transportation and tho United States Secretary of
the Interior, acting on behalf at thl! United States
of Amer1ca, written authori=~ti6n and r3tification
by letter approval, within ninety (90) ~aYD from
the date first set forth in thi~ Lc~se, pcrmittinq
Dado County, Florida, as LeSSor h.:>retn, to t!nter
into, perforr:l and fulfill its obUIJ.Jtions and receive
the benefit~ under the terms and conditions Qt this
Le~5e, nothwithst3nclinq any terms; conditions, re-
straints or obli9ations cont.Jincd in the s~id Jetport
Pact to the contrary. In the event the said United
States Secretaries of ~rnn5portation and Interior,
respectively, do not grant such written authorizJtion
and ratification within the 8~id ninety (90) d~ys,
then this Lease shall be deemed to be of no further
force and effect and the cash consideration paid
by Lessee to Lessor sh~11 be repaid by Lessor to
Lossee, and this Lease shall bo cancelled without
furl:her liability to either party hereto."; and
WmmEI\S, Lessee has secured from the United States Secrot<Jry
of Transportation and the United States Secret.Jry of the Interior,
acting on behalf of the United St~tes of ~cric~, a letter dated
December 2, 1982, constituting their approval of the Lease in
accordance' w~.t:;h"the "Ter'.'l and condit~on of 29"; a~~.
"
',"
."."
.....
,,'
.'
,
" ,
~. ,
"
, \
, .
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.0pp2086IBPIOR.11668.135811115-12086
Page 120f15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:25 PM EST
. ~I'.
, '.,'
....
'.
'.
.,
Appendix V,G.4
~~} i1658:' Itl370
~EltSI\S, the .~ad:i,eB d~sire Eo . incorporate "t'he a.fotesD. i.d
. .
let't~r i~to .the ,Lease aei' it part therttor:
',,' " ',', " '"
',NOW, THE,REPORE, ,for 'and i? :conSid~rdt'imn of ,tho pramisos
and mutual cov~nan~s ryerein doQtained. the. patties aqrec.to ~nd
" '., " .'. " ,,",
" "h"re&y. augment tl1e. Lease' be~we~n. th'em dat.ad as df ,i:hq 'f5th' day.'..
'. ' . :'." . " .' ."
: ~(Sep.temberf ',1982, 'by ih*'attacl,m~nt' to the ~ell.se as 'E~hibit "B."
.' '. -, ,
th~reto of a true copy of the 'l~tte~ dated'D~c~~or 2, 19~2,
',".
",
:'
,.
addressed to the Lessee unQer the Lease, on the letterhead of
the United States Department of the Interior, Office of the
Secretary, W8shin9ton, DC 20240, and bearing the si9naturcs
of the Secretary of Transportation and the Secretary of the
Interior, and its incorporation into said Lease.
IN WITNESS 'iHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this
Addendum No. I to be executed by their respective officials 8S
of the date first above wrttten,
D~DE COUNTY, FLORIDA
<c:o,':'}i'~';;i' Q.. . ~~
.. . _: \ . .-;- qp jcounty Mana r.
.:.:./;;'; Y
..., ._,..~:-..~ST: ,RICHARD P. BRINKER. CLERK
.' .
'. ,~,. (0 .' 'r
...........l3.y ;, \ il I ....." { \,. r
, Qeputy Clotl:
(COUNTY SF-AL)
Lesseo
HUGHES, a
of Dudl[!v
I.
1 parntcrship,
hC!s ~nd Dan A.
fl).'~':JI~"A ;;.:.,. ,.,
..
/~' ,
'.,,("7 ,~"'-
_WI~t~ (. .
~_~,,;I", By
,
.,1'
. ""
.'.'
'"
".
.',
.'
'..
,.
Order: [QuickVicw] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.11668.135811115-12086
Page 13 of 15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:59:25 PM EST
"
,.-....
Appendix V.G.4
.. .
,"
i.I
.,
. ~;~
,-" f/66B pe;r371'
",
STA~E OF HISSISSIPPI
COUNTY Q~ HINQS
'. _1;' J,1e.t\& {\-\\. . ,'.a Notq.ry Pubiic ill And for
. saip County and'.St_te~ do he;reby eeq:if~. tl\at DUDLEY J. HUyHES;
. pe,rsona.lly kp!'W1'I to me tq be ,4 GJmaral Partner in' lIughes- & 'Huqhe:s,
A.General Partnership cipmpo~ed of-Dudley J. Hughe9. and D~n A. .
Hugh"B .nd who '.as such :Genetal Partner executed the foregoing .
ihstrument on this day and aCknowledged befo~e me that he executed
the inetrwment as such General Partner in the name of and for and on
b~half.pf said partnarship, freely and voluntarily for the uaBS and
purposes therein expressed and with full authority to do so.
IN WITN~a$, WHEREOF, I hava hereunto set my hond and official
seal this llyt~ day of December, 1982.
~.d~~ ~~
'.'
..
~r.,..c!6fiW'i1atJ.ton expires:
""'~~m
'~r""< '.~<;..,
: G ;!-It 'a \ V.;,
~ ~~.\ 't 5i J ~ i
"?' . c,lt'-< '.10. ~
\~: ~;-"'''.''''''''(~:t~
""".-. '''- . \\"
fffhll"mll!l\\\~
-)-
....
...."
,'.
\ .
".'
. ~
"
"
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011 II 20861BPIOR. 1 1 668.1358j1j15-12086
Page 14 of 15
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074;59:25 PM EST
..
" . . ~;r 11660 1cT372" ,
'lln'i.t~ Sta:t~ D~pa.rf~ent 'oi'thd~tetlor.:'
OFflCF: OJ THE SECRtT'AR y'
WASHINGTON, }:l,c. 202to
Appendix V.G.4
..
,
,
"
OB:29l2
.:'
'.:
Hr. Oudle~ J" Hughes
HUGHES & HUGHES.
1100 C~pl tal ,T..w.rs
.Ja~h~~1 Hi~si.ss1pp.1
. ..'Dear:Mr.. Hughes:'.
We are pleased to respond to your request of O~tober 11, 1982, for approyel
by the Secretary of Transportation and Secretory of the Interior, acting on
behalf of the United States, of the 01" gas and mineral lease you executed
with Dade County, Florida, on September 15, 1982.
39201
. '.
'"
.... '.
".
. ,
In accordance w1t~ Term and Condition 29 of th~t lease, this letter
constitutes gUT approval of that lease.
We are gratified with your consent to Term and Condition 126 of the lease
WhiCh requires your compliance with the rules and regulations of the National
Park Service governing non-Federal oil and gas Ict1v1ties, Title 36 of the
Code of Federal Regulations, Part 9, Sub-Part B. including th~ requirement
for an approved plan of operations in accordance with the standards set
forth thereini and with the rules and regulations of the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service (formerly Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife).
Please initiate contact with the Park Superintendent, Everglades Hational
Park, National Park Servfcc, P.O. DOI(219, Homestead. FL 33030; phone:
305-247-6211 j to begin the .36 CFR 93 process, as you have prev10usly done
for your-other operations within the D1g Cypress National Preserve. As
a part of this process. please conduct early and full consultation wIth
the Field Supervisor. U.S. Fisn and Wildlife Service. P.O. Box 2676.
Vera Beach, FL 32960; phone: 305-562~3909.
Sincerely,
s.
till"Y 0
c nterlcr
cc: County Manager, Dade (OVIlty, FL
"r.oI'IO"Il'I~"'""""-
GO 0.01 """~", II........
1I.......,.."'t
R1CflARI)r.lIltlNKER.
~tl~tun~1I\#fl
l.-
Exhibit "B"
.!
,.
'.
.:..'
.'
'"
L_
.'
".
--~-.'
.1'
t...
.'
,"
..1
Order: (QuickView] Doc:
2.0PP2086IBPIOR.11668.1358f1P5-12086
Page 15 ofl5
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19120074:59:25 PM E&.
'<:..
. ..'
. lis sa. ~5~'2! i.S'., . 89R3! 79~9
. :. ... . . WrU4Z43,b 176
PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE'S D1mI8\mVE DEED .
.(T~sllle)
'" .
;
THIS INDEN11JRE it. made lhts1L dB)' of
. D~roth~ De:rl'soy iJrQwn
. 19 8.i...--. byanclbciw<<n
Tn'y
. .
Ibe duly quaiified Ind IIcllng penon.t rep"sen'.livc of the esllle of
Itp1 Po" W na,......y
._ dee:eos~d.
. pm of I~ Rnl part., and.
Dorothy De<(k-B8Y Brown
whose pml office ,lddl'C55 Is:
,1560 N.E. l05th'street
.'Miami Shores, Florida 33138
plU1 of.I~~d part,
WITNESSETH: Th.t WHEREAS,
.
HA~~n W nAn~AAY
died le....le .resldenl of 8rAn , f"n'r'''',I'''....
QaItni1.Rorid1t;--oft
n",,~pmhp.~ 4~ ' 19 1.3..-..
sc!zcd'lltld po5Sc~I~d nflhe I'Cflll'rope(1)' hertinancr dcscrihcd: and
WHEREAS. Ilde 10 Slid proPeI1Y plloltsed 10 !he pUl1y of ltie second plU1 II of !he. dllc of said
d~edent's du.th punuBnl to .the provisions 'of Ihe decedent', lAst ~III on,d Tesllllmnl, which WIS admitted 10 " .
probate B.nd record by the 'Qreuit Cour1 for
Prob~le 'D'ivhion1In <A10 No, RQ_ ~1 ,;,n
D=-d_
Count)', AoridD.
. subject only 10 Ihe.ri8ht of the paft.y of-lIlC1 riDI part
10 lel.l. or encumber thc property for the: fl~rpo5e. of defrBY,ing claim1'l. C0515. Bnd expense~ (1~'lIdn.llnlslrullull of
decedent's CSID1e; and
..]
WHE~EAS,thcpart~ ~r l~ firsl pm wishes 10 di51ributc'sald property 1.0 Ihe pliny,. Qf'''e second
p~ tnd evidence tbe n:lessc of the property from said righl 10 51:11 or 'encumber,
NOW THEReFO~e. In cOl1siderulion of the foregoing and In cnnnnecllC1n whh lhe dhlribulion'of '(he
estale ofsak! decedent. lhe party of the nrsl par1 hl!ll,fe relllDscd'lo the pm y or the secondplrt the II,hIIO ,sell
Dr encumbcr18id propcny and Bnmted, con~l!ycd and confirmed unla Ihcpan y . oflhc scc,and put. Her heirs
"and ISSlans forever. an or lhe lnterc" of sold dcccdenl in lInd to Ihe real property !hUDled In' 'n.........
Counly, Florida, ~_FtWd:ul;faSlma:: set forth in J
Schedul,e A.' A~tached
This inlilf\lm.cnl prcpllrcd by:
Paul D. Barns, Esq.
1570 Madruga Avenue
Suite 211
Coral Gebles,- P'l 33146'
1'305) 661-0628
Form No, P.I5.0610
GUui Florida Bar 1987 -
~,,:,...
'"
4'-)
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView) Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.14243.1761112-12086
Page I of2
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:55:54 PM EST
If
'?
. :I!: 1424310 "7T
TOOIITHER wilh i1l1l1nd ilngulDf lhe 'Icnemcn'~, hcrcdhun;cnIS. ond Ilppu'1cnunl:c~ belong!ns ~(t or in nn)' way
~ppcrtDlnlnJ 10 Ihlll real property, ~ubjecl to DII. f'Cl4lricll\ln!l: rcM:tvullnn!l\, nod cuscrm:nt~ or I"Ctord, it liB)'. llod
lid valarern laJtc~ fnr the currerll ycur.
8Cl::IU~c this deed is ~iYcn 10 evidence the distribuliun llr !Isseis {If II (Jc~cdcnl's cstulc uoll Inv~lvcs
'.
Ihe 3.~sumpliun or nn mOnl.!llg~. minimum slille ducumcnlury slamps urc ufOll.cd.
I~ WITNES~ WHEREOF, ttll: undcr~i~ncd. llll po.:rM!,,"1 rC(lrc~l1n';lIi~.: I1r II... cSlatcllrl'I1iJ tJcccJcnl.
hu" cKcculclJ Ihlt; instrument under selll nn thl: dulo aforesuid.
Signed. SCllltd amI dcllvcrtd In the pn!scncc nr
/a./~
...,
~~~jJ~
-STATEOF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF
nllnR
hereby ccniCy Ibul the
Ihis ..lL- daY.Qr ",,11'
OJ pc~onal.rcprcst:nIDtivc
Ilrlhc c!\tall:.of
HA1An W np
"0
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.14243.1761112-12086
,&/....
Dorothy
Ai pct!iunu
llcccll~cd.
Helsn W~ DeoraBv
or lhe utalc ur
.'
tlc~nowlcdg~ berate .~
Deareey BrowI):. ':< .'r;:/.
. .>,1..
. ../l'!-1
.. 'f..'} .
I, l~"'.t
,,'~'~r~
rorcsoing instrumcnl W;:lS
. 19 ...8.!..., by Dorothy
~OIury Public.. Stulc or
My Commll:~h-'n Bllplrcs:
Appendix V.G.4
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:55:54 PM EST
Page 2 of2
~rF 14
REC: Z43f~ 178
. :' .
SCHEDULE itA"
ONE HALF OF THE DADB COUNTY AB8~B OF THE DECEASED, I. E. :
. PARCEL
. 1. One Thirty-.econd (1/32) Hine~al Inter.st 1n. the
f~11ov1ng.~and8 in To~ship 52 80ut~. Range 35 Eft.~:.
Section 19; 25: .26: 27 lesEI WI/2 of. 8W1/4, 28; 29; 30
lees."lU/2 or N'W1/41 311 32 1888 Wl/2 of SEl/4; 331.34:
351 36 leS8 El/2 of,NE1/4, co~tainin9 O,ODO ~ores, more
or less, .'
2. One Thirty-second (1/32) mineral tntereat in the
following lands 1n Township 53 South, Range 35 East:
5.otlon 112131... "1/2 Of 5"1/414'6' 6 lese 111/2 of
.8\91/4' ,,8 lesa W1/2 of SE1/4, 91..101.11 1es8 El/2 of
WI/4, ;L2 less N~1/4 of NB1/4,. 13, 14, .IS, 17;.'18.189.
111/2 of 5111/4.1 l~ 1... 51/21 20 l.s. 51/2 of 5111/41 211
22 le8S Wl/2 of NWl/4 r 23; 24 les. W1/2 of NWl/4; 25; 26
less WI/2 9t NEl{4i 27,"281 33 18.8 tl/2 of NWl/4; 341
35 and 36, conta ning 18,6eO acres, more or less.
;t, One seven-five hUhcirec1 and twelfths (7/512) Mineral
Inter.st in the foliowlnq lands in TownBhip 55 South,
Range 37 Easts .
section 20 less 91/21 :n: 22; 23; 24 188.S SE1/4 of SEl/4 f
26 lesB NEl/40f SEl/41 28~ 29 1eBs SH1/4, less Wl/2 pf
HWl/4 of SEl/4, less.NW1/4 of NWl/4 of N81/4, containing
4,530 acres, more or. less.
ALL IN DADE COUNTY .FLORIDA.
1fD:IIIlID. ."...,.-"'"
0I1IllH0ClIfIIY.1\llllMlIo .
lL\:niD.,uiftll .;.
. BJ(2IAID r.......
. tlUPJ,tlntMl."IllIUKT
u.w o,,'c.:. or PAUL D. ....~N., ..."'". U".,O "'~Il"'UGA AyeNUE" 5UI1"1: III, CO"AL IU..US.,.. 3::11"'1. . TEL:I:>>OS' Ge"o.~.
\~u'if;";.;"'''..''' '-.':"".'~'''~:lil
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.14243.178lljl-12086
Page 1 of I
Created By~ andya Printed: 10/19/2007 4:57:0 I PM EST
0'.
l!89slP -s 1112' 49 89~3179~O'
. :If: 14Z43'~ I r9'
PERSONAL REPRESENTATlVE'S DISTRIBUTIVE DEED'
. ~TesIBle)
,
'Of;
..... ,.
THIS INDENTURE is made lhjs~ day (If .Tn 1 y
OOROT>>r DEO~S~Y BROWN
the duly qUllincd and Reling personal rtrrl:5Cntaljvc of the c!ilnte of
. 19 /!2......;. ,b)'andbclwecn
U~lAn W npn~~RY
. dccco5ed.,
piU1 ofthc nflil plIrt. and
..Robert P. DeOrsey
whOle paS( orficc address i~:
12813" Hunstman Way
Potomac~ Maryland 2D854
pm of the sec~nd part.
WITNESSI?TH: Thul WHEREAS, UA 1 Aft W hnnrllPY
died testate. ~5Id~nl of Brshdford. eN
. , 19 13-,
)()wm,~RIlaltda, nn n'H,,!pmhAr 4
seiu:d Dnd possessed or .he TClIt property hcrclnofler dc5cribetJ; arid
. WHEREAS. Illl~ 10 !llilJ. p.ropcll~ palled 10 the pall
'.,
I)f lhe second plitt 15 of the dOle of sold
decedcnt'$ dctth pURu8nt to the pNVi5!l,lnS of the dcctdcllt's La!!, Will inti TC6~omcnl. which W85 lldmincd 10.
probale IInd record by Ihe Clreuil Courl for
Probale Division. in Cast No. 89-3160
Dede
. C01,l01)', . f1ori~lI,
, !lubjcct only t? Ihe right of tilt pal1 or the' OrM part
10 sell or encumbc! lh~ [lropcny for Ihe pUf1X1se or defraying. c1Dim~, cosb, and cxpell!lCJ or udmlni!llt'llll.on or
dcccdcn\'scslalc; and
WHEREAS.lhc part t1f the firM pun wi~h I~ distribute SI!d propert)' 10 thepal1 oHIle steamJ
. .
p~ and c"idcn~ lhe rclea~ o~ the prol'C")' from soid righllO !lcll ~'.encumber, .
NOW THEREFORE. In c0!'1ldcr31ion or the foregoing and In connnct:tion. wit.h Ibe dlsltibulion or Ihe
estate or SDld decedent, lhe plrt of tlle fi~1 part f111 rcl~ascd 10 ~hc'pal1' Dr the second part the right 10 sell
or encumber said propcn)' and granltd, conveyed a~ c~ll1firmcd unlo .he pal1 oft~ Jecond part; . heirs
and assigns forevcr, all ~f the lnlere:sl- of .said dccedc~t In i:and to the r~GI p1(1f)Crty silulted in Dade
Counly. Florida. dlut1Il~bos: set forth in
Scfiedule A attached
.niJli instrument prcpaltd by:
Paul D. Barne, Jr'., Esq
1570 Aadru9a AVenge
suite 211 .
Coral Gables, Florlda
33146
13051661-0628
\~
Form No. P.5.0610
OThe Florida Bar 1987
Appendix V.GA
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.0\1 112086IBPIOR.14243.] 791113-12086
Page 1 of3
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:58:16 PM ESl
. 'ilt'.\ 4'243,n ., 80
. .
~.OO6THBR wllh 011 (1m! :dnsuhlr the le~~mli:nls. 'hcn:ll1taml?AI5, and llrpurtcnlln"~'bet(ln8inlll(t or ,i!, pny wuy
.appertaining .10 thai real property, ~lIbjcclln all rc:lol,icliom, re~nulion~. pnd cu~cmcn1S C!r rcc.onl. If ony, pnd
od valorem IllllCS r~)f lhe currenl year.
8ccau!ft Ihill deed ill given to cvlcJcncc the distribution (1r assets, of.a decedent's CSI~~C lIod l~vnlyC5
the DS~umpll(ln of 11t!.mtl"~ugc. minimum illutc dCK:umcnl;lry 51l1rnfl!l llr~ ufrilled.
~'.
IN WITN~S WHEREOF.I~c umJcr!llJ;ncd, 1I~ p'nmnol u:prcl'lcnllllivc tlflhl.! cslllh:llf:lokJ dccccJl!nl.
hn cxcculel.llhill inslrumcpl vniler sculllll Ihe dale Urllrc511i,d.
"
Signed. !lcalc~ ond ~cllv.cn:d in" the prc5cncc of
./~~
;- .
?#' If} .
~ ~ -(f~
eRllIle of
Heien W. Deoraey
d~<:mll:d.
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUN7Y OF
Dade
bcn:lty ccnify IhDt the fnrC@:llinLZ .imlrumenl W3!\ Dcknowlcdgro before me
_. this "J.L. day of ,,, 1 Y
. 19 l!L.: by
Dorothy DeOr8ey.8~own
os peDonal repn:scnID!ivc of the CS!DIC' of
Helen w. Deorsey
',~:.,.,~.
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QulckView] Doc;
2.011112086IBPIOR.14243.1791113-12086
Page 20f3
Created By; andya Printed: 10/19/2007 4:58:16PM EST
~U: 142431~.1 61.. I
"
SCHErfi.n,E "A"
ONI!: ~ALF OF THE DADE COUNT.\( ASSETS OF THE DEC~SEO, t.E.:
PARCEL
1.
One Thi~ty-second ".(1/32) Mineral Interest in the
fol~(J\liI1:9 lands in To~nship' 52 South, Range 35 Eastl
sectioo 19; 25~ 26; 27, l"eSB Wl/2" of.SWl/4; 2Br 29; 30
less Wl/2 of NWl/41 31; 32 le8s Wl/2 of 8&1/4: 33; 34;
35.; 36 less El/2- ot NE1/4J contllining 8,000 .ilcres, more
or.less: .
2. One .Thir~y-.eeond (1/32) mineral Inte~QBt in the
following lands 'in T~""!1Shlp 53 Bout~, Range, 35 EllIllIt:
section 1. t 2 ~ 3 le8s 14'1/2 of. SWl/4: .4" 5:.6 199& Wl/2 of
. 9141/4: '". Bless Wl/2 ot 811/4: 9; 10; -II less El/2 of
NWl/4, '12 18s8 HEl/4 ot. NE1/4; 13; 141 15; .17; 18 l.ss
Wl/2 ot 9"'1/4119 less 81/2' '20-188111.S1/2 of SWl/4; 21:
22 less W1j20f NWl/4; 23: 24 1.eBB 14'1/2 ot NWl/4: 25; 26
less W1/2 of NE1/4: 27, 2&1.33 less Bl/2 of NWl/~1 34~
35 and. 36, containin9" 18, 680' acr.s, more or lass. .
3. One Seven-five hundred and twelfths (7/512) Mineral'
Int~rest In the following lands in', TOWl)ship 55' south,'
Rang_ 37 Bast: .
seation 20 less Sl/2; 21, 22: .231 24 leBS SE1/~ of 821/41
2:61e8S NEl/4' of SEl/4' 28r .29 less 514'1/4, 1088 W1/2 of
NW1/4 of 681/4,' ~e88'NWl/4 of NWl/4 of.NEl/4, oontaining
4,530 acr~B, more or less.
ALt.. IN DADE COUNTY FLORIDA. .
..........--
...:.-..",~... .
-- ""'llt . JIIRIII
.uc::::~ ....
L"'W ornCl:'. or ,....u... o. .""H.'. "".. '170 ",:ADflUG'" ...VI:NlIl:. IIU'T~.llI. co"'!'- 4"'81.11:.. ,.1. ~31_. . '1U..ln'lI~ eel-OD.'
Appendix V.G.4
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.0111 12086IBPIOR.14243. 179!113-12086
Page 3of3
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19120074:58:16 PM EST
Thia instrument prepared by:
Nonnan Roberts, P,A.
50 West Mashta Drive
Suite 4
Key Bisc.yne, FL 33149
Appendix V.G.4
111111I1111I11111111I111111111111111111111111
CFN 2005R0066611
OR Bk 23016 P.. 0~64 - ~6~; (2...1
RECOROEO 01/21/2005 08'3~108
DEED DOC TAX 0.60
SURTAX O.4~
HARVEY RUVIN, CLERK OF COURT
n1Anl-OAOE COUNTY, FLORIOA
.~
,
QUIT CLAIM DEED
FOR
MINERAL RIGHT AND ROYALTY TRANSFER
(To Undivided Interest)
STATE of Florida
COUNTY of Miami-Dade
KNOW ALL MBN BY THESE PRESENTS:
That JEANNETTB B. PARISH of Miami-Dade County, State of Florida,
hereinafter called grantor (whether one or more and referred to in the singular number
and masculine gender), for and in consideration of the 8U/I1 of Ten Dollars $ 10,00 and
other good and valuable considerations, paid by JEANNETTB BUHLER PARISH as
Trustee of the Jeanette Buhler Parish Revocable Trust dated June 30, 1999, hereinafter
called grantee the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, has granted, sold and
conveyed and by these presents does grant, sell and convey unto said grantee an
undivided One/Sixty-Fourth (1164) interes1 in all and to 1111 of the oil, gas and other
minerals of every kind and character in, on or under that certain tract or parcel of land
siluated in the County of Miami-Dade, State of Florida, and described as follows:
Township 52 South, Range '35 East,'Section 19; 25, 26, 27 less W V, ofSW \1,;
28; 29; 30 less W \4 of NW Yo; 31; 32 less W \4 of SB \1,; 33; 34; 35 and 36
less E \4 of NE Yo, con1aining 8,000 acres, more or less;
Township 53 South, Range 35 East, Section 1; 2; 3, less W V, of SW \1,; 4; 5; 6
less W \4 of SW \1,; 7; 8 less W \4 of SB \1,; 9; 10; \I less B \4 of NW \1,; 12
less NE V. ofNE Yo; 13; 14, 15; 17; 181es. W V, ofSW V.; 191e.s S V,; 20 less
S II, of SW \1.,; 21; 22 less W V, ofNW \1,; 23, 24 less W y, ofNW \1,; 25: 26
less W Yo of NE \1,; 27; 28; 33 less B V. of NW V,; 34; 35 and 36, containing
\8,680 acres, more or less.
TO HA VB AND TO HOLD the said undivided interest in all of 1l1e said oil, gas
and other minerals in, on and under said land, together with all and singular the rights and
appurtenances thereto in any wise belonging, with the right of ingress and egress, and
possession at all times for the purpose of mining, drilling and operating for said minerals
and the maintenance of facilities and meanS necessary or convenient for producing,
treating and transporting such minerals and for housing and boarding employees, unto
said grantee, his heirs, successors and assigns, forever; and grantor herein for himself and
Book23016/Page564
CFN#20050066611
Page 1 of 2
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.01 11120861BPIOR.230 165641112-12086
Page 1 of2
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19120074:52:40 PM EST
. , .. .
.
Appendix V.G.4
OR BK 23016 PG 0565
LAST PAGE
his heirs, executors and administrators hereby agrees to warrant and forever defend all
and singular the said interest in said minerals, unto the said grantee, his heirs, successors
and assigus against every person whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same or
any part thereof.
Gnmtee shan have the right at any lime (but is not required) to redeem for Grantor
by payment, any mortgages, taxes or other liens on the above described lands, in the vent
of default of payment by Gnm10r, and be subrogated to the rights of the bolder thereof.
This conveyance is made subject to any valid and subsisting oil, gas or other
mineral lease or leases on said land, including also any mineral lease, if any, heretofore
made or being contemporaneously made from grantor to grantee; but, for the same
consideration hereinabove mentioned, grantor has sold, transferred. 88sigued and
conveyed and by these presents does sell, transfer, assigu and convey unto grantee, his
heirs, successom and assigns, the ssme undivided interest (as 1he undivided interest
hereinabove conveyed in the oil, gas and other minerals in said land) in all the rights,
rentals, royalties and other beneflts accruing or to accrue under said lease or leases from
the above described land; to have and to hold unto grantee, his hein,successors and
assigns,
This instrument confers on the Trustee(s) the power and authority either 10
protect, conserve and to sell, or to lease, or 10 encumber, or otherwise to manage and
dispose of the real property desco'bed herein.
WITNESS the signature of the gr8lltor_this~ay 0~04'
Witnesses:
SC~ a-4A~-~4g .
9'~~\.1 f\-JlClCCj iF~NBTIB.B.PA1USH -ui-
V'19.{J;~
Ikm\~
STATE OFFLORtOA
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ~ay of~004, by
Jeannette B. Parish. t:7.~
Ignature ofNol8Iy Public)
'f,. ~...c. L. C...,.--
(Print N811le of7bliC)
Personally Known OR Produced Identiflcation
Type of Identification Produoed
Je''.:'!., BONNIB L. OOOPER
'!!W..IMYCOMfoATSSION. DD~
......,,, BK..It~:Ft"'-J l2,lOOlS
l<<ll).NQTNW R."",""'IIb'dr'Q,Int.
Book23016/Page565
CFN#20050066611
Page 2 of 2
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.230 16.5641112-12086
Page 20f2
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19120074:52:40 PM EST
.. ...
Appendix V.G.4
111111I1111I11111111I1111I1111111111111111111
,.
CFN 2005ROQ66612
OR Bk 23016 P.. 0~66 - 5671 (2...>
RECORDED 01/21/2005 08135108
DEED DOC TAX 0.60
SURTAX 0.~5
HARVEY RUVIN, CLERK OF COURT
nIAnI-OADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
This instrument prepared by:
Norman Roberts, P.A.
50 West Mashta Drive
Suite 4
Key Bi.cayne, FL 33149
QUIT CLAIM DEED
FOR
MINERAL RlGHT AND ROYALTY TRANSFER
(To Undivided Interesl)
STATE of Florida
COUNTY of Miami-Dade
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS:
That JEANNETTE B. PARISH as Attorney in fact for Theodora Buhler of
Miami-Dade County, State of Florida, hereinafter called grantor (whether one or more
and refClTCd to in the singular nwnber and masculine gender), for and in consideralion of
the smu of Ten Dollan $ 10.00 and other good and valuable considerations, paid by
Theodora B. Buhler, Jeanette B. Parish and Barbara B. Meloy as Co-Trustees of the
Theodora B. Buhler Revocable Trust, da1ed November 7, 1985 and amended November
7,1985 And October 20,1988, hereinafter called grantee the receipt of which is hereby
acknowledged, bas granted; sold and conveyed and by these presents does grant, soli and
convey unto said grantee an undivided Oneffhirty Second (1/32) interest in all and to all
of the oil, gas and other minerals of every kind and character in, on or under that certain
tract or parcel of land. situated in the County of Miami-Dade, State of Florida, and
described as follows:
Township 52 South, Range 35 East, Section 19; 25; 26; 27 less W V. of SW v.;
28; 29; 30 less W V. ofNW v.; 31; 32 less W Yo ofSE v.; 33; 34; 35 and 36 less
E y, ofNE \I., containing 8,000 acres, more or less;
Township 53 South, Range 35 East, Section I; 2; 3 less W Y, of SW Y.; 4; 5; 6
less W Y, of SW Y.; 7; 8 less W Y, of SE v.; 9; 10; 11 less E Y, of NW v.; 12
less NE Y. ofNE Y.; 13; 14; IS; 17; 18les. W Y, ofSW \1,; 19 less S Yo; 20 less
S y, ofSW lI.; 21; 22 les. W y, ofNW Y.; 23; 24 les. W Yz ofNW Yo; 25; 26
less W V. of NE Y.; 27; 28; 33 less E Yo of NW 110; 34; 35 and 36, containing
18,680 acres, more or less.
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the .aid undivided interest in all of 1he said oil, gas
and other mineral. in, on and under said land, together with all and aingular the rights and
appurtenances thereto in any wise belonging, with the right of ingress and egress, and
possession at all times for the purpose of mining, drilling and operating for .aid minerals
and the maintenance of facilities and means necessary or convenient for producing,
Book23016/Page566
CF N#20050066612
Page 1 of 2
Order: (QuickView] Doc:
2011112086IBPIOR.23016.5661112-12086
Page lof2
Created By: andya Printed: 10/19/20074:54:06 PM EST
..... ../1..
Appendix V.G.4
OR BK 23016 PG 0567
LAST PAGE
,.
treating and transporting such minerals and for housing and boarding employees, unto
said grantee, his heirs, successors and assigns, forever; and grantor herein for himself and
his heirs, llXecutolll and administrators hereby agrees to warrant and forever defend all
and singnlar the said lntereat in said minerals, unto the said grantee, his heirs, SUCCesSOlll
and assigns against every person whomsoever lawfully claiming or to claim the same or
any part thereof.
Grantee shall have the right at any time (but is not required) to redeem for Grantor
by payment, any mortgages, taxes or other liens on the above deScribed lands, in the vent
of default of payment by Grantor, and be subrogated to the rights of the holder thereof.
This conveyance is made subject to any valid and subsisting oil, gas or other
mineral lease or leases on said land, inoluding also any mineral lease, if any, heretofore
made or being oontemporaneously made from grantor to grantee; but, for the same
consideration hereinabove mentioned, grantor has sold, transferred, assigned and
conveyed and by these presents does sell, transfer, assign and convey unto grantee, his
heirs, suocessors and assigns, the same undivided interest (as the undivided interest
hereinabove conveyed in the 011, gas and other minerals in said land) in all the rights,
rentals, royalties and other benefits accruing or to accrue under said lease or leases from
the above described land; to have and to hold unto grantee, his heirs, successors and
assigns.
This inslrument confers on the Trustee(s) the power and authority either to
protect, conserve and to sell, or to lease, or to encumber, or otherwise to manage and
dispose of the real property described herein.
WITNESS the signature of the grantor_this~ay O~004.
Witnesses:
~~
b'''~'t trllc-<:"""'I
l~ ~k5
As
STATE Of fLORIDA
COUNTY Of MIAMI.DADE
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ~~ of~2004, by
leannette B. Parish as Attorney in Fact for Theodom B. Buhler. c:J
~:fnf::Q
~..~<- L.~
(Print Name of Notary Publie)
V'" OR Produced Identification
:i~ BONNI!! L. COOPER
MVCOMMISlIIDN.OOO'llBOS
\;,,~ EXPIRBJ:fIbrIlU)'l1.2OOI
1~ FL"*"'......~\rc.
Personally Known
Type ofldentl6cation Produced
Book23016/Page567
CFN#20050066612
Page 2 of 2
-.
Order: [QuickView] Doc:
2.011112086IBPIOR.230 16.5661112-12086
Page 2, of 2
Created By: andya Printed: 10/1912007 4:54:06 PM ES,
)
Appendix
1.D.1
III.A
IV.D.1
IV.D.2
VAl
V.A.2
V.A.3
V.B.1
V.C.1
V.C.2a
V.C.2b
V.C.3a
V.C.3b
V.D.l
V.D.5b
V.D.5b.l
V.D.5b.2
V.D.5b.2a
V.D.5b.3
V.D.5b.4
V.D.5b.4a
V.D.5b.5
V.D.5b.6
V.D.5b.7
V.D.5b.8
V.D.5b.9
V.D.5b.10
V.D.5b.11
V.D.5b.12
V.D.5b.13
V.D.5b.14
V.d.5b.15
V.E.1a
DADE-COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA
APPENDICES
Team Qualifications Additional Information
Sketch & Description
Future Land Use Mop
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area Mop
General Location Mop
Aerial Map
Zoning with 500' Boundary Mop
Existing FLUM
FLUCCS Map
Summary Table of Federal and State Plant and Animal Species
Panther Bear Telemetry Mop
County Historic and/or Archeological Sites
Florida Moster Site File Response
Area of Critical State Concern (ACSC) Mop
Data and Analysis for the Proposed Use
Off-Highway Vehicle Trails Feasibility Study
Coilier County Park and Recreation Deportment Letter
Collier County Off-Highway Vehicle Feasibility Study
F.S. 260-03, Definition of OHV
Prior Site Conditions
Existing Trail Conditions
Conceptual Diagram
Excerpt from State Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan (SCORP)
Public Inquiries
Lee County Agenda Request Form
OHV Titled in Miami-Dade County
OHV Titled in Collier County
Florida OHV County Title Activity, 6/30/02 TO 12/31/08
OHV Organizations and Clubs
Miami-Dade Resolution
Collier County Resolution
Letters of Support
Potable Water
Page 1 of 2
V.E.lb
V.E.lc
V.E.ld
V.E.le
V.E.2
V.E.3
V.F.l
V.F.2a
V.F.2b
V.GA
Sanitary Sewer
Traffic Methadology and Traffic Impact Study (TiS)
Drainage
Solid Waste
Existing Services and Public Facilities
Proposed Services and Public Facilities
FEMA Flood Zones
Proposed Wellfields and ASR
lO-Year Water Supply Existing and Planned Wellflelds
Ownership and Encumbrance Report
Page 2 of 2
APPENDIX V.D.5b.2A
COLLIER COUNTY OFF -HIGHWAY
VEHICLE FEASIBILITY STUDY
1''''1. O"'Httl & ()jJtY>,,<,,
~~~
Off-Highway Vehicle Feasibility Study
11""
For
Inclusion within
Collier County Growth Management Plan
Petition CP-2009-01
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 1 of 14
December 29, 2009
Collier County
Off-Highway Vehicle Feasibility Study
Introduction
Collier County has a permanent population of 292,932 as of 2008 (University of Florida, BEBR
Estimate). Its residents are spread across approximately 2,305 square miles, of which 2,025 square
miles are upland areas that include substantial County, State and Federal lands within protected
parks.
Like other Florida Counties, its residents engage in a variety of recreational opportunities in those
same protected parks. Included among these activities is Off-Highway Vehicle (OHV) trail riding.
The Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (DHSMV) tracks the number of
newly titled OHVs in the state, Between 2002 and 2008, they have registered an increase of 5,560
new vehicles registered within Collier County alone (Exhibit I). Although Collier County has one
tenth the population of larger and denser counties like Miami-Dade and Broward, it has registered
almost 50% as many new riders in the last few years as its larger neighbors.
Exhibit 1
Florida Registered New OHV Vehicles 2002-2008
County Title Activity 6/30/02 - 12/31/2008
TI!":"TR4N~~CTJq~~,.~q!! C2F~.tt'(i 1j~~Y veHI(:.LES
" "., "',' "._~N~C.U~\.<.\
".,. I I
. I
I I
3.,1:13
1}66S
12,S"3
'.'"
,.3QJ
3,uo I
1s..I4)
5'160
fii,::r6S
a.SS7
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 2 of 14
December 29, 2009
The DHSMV also tracks the location of
resident riders. Exhibit 2 shows that the
over 12,000 registered OHVs within the
County are uniformly spread throughout
the developed area.
While the demand for OHV trail riding
is growing, the locations where riders
can freely access these open spaces and
trails remains low. Exhibit 3 shows that
there are only a limited number of
places within the State of Florida for
OHV trail use.
The State lists only nine (9) publicly
owned OHV facilities and only one, Big
Cypress National Preserve, is within
Collier County. Big Cypress National
Preserve allows a maximum of only
2,000 annual permits to access the
Preserve at anyone time. As evidence
of the increasing demand for trail
access, the National Preserve is
presently undergoing public review to
add over 75,000 acres of newly acquired
land for OHV trail use. Two other sites,
the Holey Land and John Corbett
WMAs, are near Collier County but
allow OHVs for hunting use only. The
remaining public facilities are located in
more distant northern areas of the State.
The State lists an additional twenty-two
(22) private facilities, with the majority
located over 150 miles north of Collier
County. Two (2) facilities are located in
adjacent Miami-Dade County, but these
facilities cater more to specialized
motocross and drag racing vehicles than
traditional three- and four-wheeled
OHVs. Many private facilities do not
offer recreational trails that are easily
enjoyed by traditional OHV trail riders.
The result is a current Stale
Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation
Plan that recognizes that Collier County
is among the more deficient areas in
South Florida for motorized trail riding.
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Exhibit 2
Location of Titled Vehicles in Collier County
lUAU: UI- "LUKtUA
DIVISION OF HIGHWAY ."FEN ANI) MOTOR VEHICLES
LUr.:A11UtI U" IIIUr.UUHVMWllHlN CUUJIl.H:t:OUNIT
"
"
~-~-,-
",1,.
..t
- .......<\\'t.-
!I ..
,..
.'~ t
A~_~~
- -'
~
J
.
...~
-...
.+
......01.-
-..
,,-.........
1 r.o;h;1 Hml..
.........--
Exhibit 3
OHV Trail Facilities within Florida
t ,
tl\ "
.~II
Page 3 of 14
December 29, 2009
Background
Given the high demand for OHV trails, and the low supply of proximate facilities, the Collier
County Parks and Recreation Department has been tasked to identifY a location for OHV trail use,
This is in part due to the elimination of the Picayune Strand area of Collier County in 2002 as a
location able to support OHV use. Once it was acquired by the South Florida Water Management
District (SFWMD) in order to facilitate the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Project (CERP),
it was not available for public OHV use. As part of its acquisition and closure, a 2003 agreement
between Collier County and SFWMD provided that the District would endeavor to find replacement
lands in and around Collier County.
According to a Supplemental Agreement signed by the respective boards of Collier County and
SFWMD, the District was tasked with identifYing a temporary site for OHV enthusiasts prior to a
permanent site being developed at Lake Trafford. The Supplemental Agreement was crafted to
further define responsibilities of SFWMD to the Collier County Board of County Commissioners
from a 2003 agreement between the two governmental entities.
Along with certain input from Collier County staff, several sites in and around Collier County were
identified for consideration in meeting the original obligation of 640 acres of land for OHV use.
The following sites have been presented by SFWMD, but no other site than the Lake Trafford site
has been identified to fulfill this commitment.
The following pages describe six sites identified and evaluated by Collier County staff in order to
fulfill the commitment from the Collier Board of County Commissioners (Map I). A seventh site is
mentioned as well, but is located in Charlotte County, well north of the Naples area. Each site's
location, acreage, characteristics, opportunities and constraints, and potential for development as an
OHV recreational trail area are described.
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 4 ofl4
December 29, 2009
Map 1
Proposed ORV Park Sites
Collier County
N
W+E
S
PlAy. Cotf1m:t 0- Disr:ov,r
~CmtI1r,y
- Collier County Boundary
Collier County Roads
City Boundaries
Area
.'. Hendry County site SR82 and Church Rd
.2. Temporary A1V site
~ Lake Trafford site
o
10
,Miles
20
1(41 Oil Well Road site
M 1-75 exit 80
Source: 2009 Aarials - Collier County Property Appraiser
Created by: ColI~r County Parks and Recreation
GiS.a Turtle/GISI Proposed ORV Park locations
m Collier/Dade County Airport
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 5 of 14
December 29, 2009
Area I: Hendry County Site
This parcel is located near the southwest corner of Hendry County, a half-mile north ofImmokalee
Road, and five miles west of Highway 29. A non-profit, religious organization owns the site, and at
one time identified it for sale. SFWMD expressed interest in the property and the non-profit took it
offthe market. The non-profit organization plans to continue to utilize the site for rock mining, as a
means of revenue.
Aerial 1
Hendry County Site
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 6 of 14
December 29, 2009
Area 2: Temporary A TV Site on Northern County Boundarv
The 1,291 acre site was initially identified as a temporary site in the attempted 2007 Supplemental
Agreement. It is located on the north end of Collier County, 3 miles southwest of Okaloacoochee
Slough State Forest; and is composed of a 885-acre parcel privately owned by Alico Land
Development Corporation and a 406-acre parcel publicly owned by the State of Florida. The private
parcel was proposed as a lease site to SFWMD for operation of an OHV park.
Aerial 2
Temporary A TV Site
As part of due diligence, there were certain environmental concerns regarding the presence of the
Crested Cara Cara (Polyborus plancus audubonii), an endangered native bird species found to be
located on the property. During later discussions, the time involved in mitigating the environmental
concerns, along with meeting zoning requirements to operate this location as an OHV. site exceeded
the timeframe allotted by the lease. The site was ultimately determined not to be a viable candidate
for an OHV park.
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 7 of 14
December 29, 2009
Area 3: Lake Trafford Site
This approximate 625-acre site is located northeast of Lake Trafford, in the northwest comer of the
lmmokalee Urban Designated Area (Aerial 3). It is an approximate 30-45 minute drive for most Lee
and Collier County residents. The site is designated Low Residential Subdistrict in the Immokalee
Area Master Plan. The proposed use of this site for OHV s was publicly discussed in a number of
venues.
Aerial 3
Lake Trafford Site
The site was filled in 2005 and 2006 with dredge spoils removed from the bottom of Lake Trafford.
South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) is the current owner. The 2007 amended
agreement providing that Collier County could become the owner of the site for future use as an
OHV park. On September 27, 2005, however, the County rejected this site after soil tests showed
that the Lake Trafford dredge material placed on the site is contaminated and the site may not be
economically feasible for the intended OHV use. The temporary Lake Trafford site identified in the
attempted 2007 agreement was abandoned after environmental concerns were raised with the Collier
County Environmental Advisory Council.
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 8 of 14
December 29, 2009
Area 4: Oil Well Road Site
A 654-acre site located a half-mile west of Oil Well Road, on the north side of County Road 858, is
privately owned by Winchester Lakes Corporation. The site lies adjacent to neighboring
developments, and although the size, configuration and condition of the property would support
OHV use, the site was not pursued since the cost associated with purchasing the property greatly
exceeded expectations.
Aerial 4
Oil Well Road Site
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 9 of 14
December 29, 2009
Area 5: 1-75lHighwav 29 Site
A 3,066-acre site located near the southwest comer of the junction ofInterstate 75 and Highway 29
is fully owned by the State of Florida and assigned for Park and Recreation and Transportation
purposes. Its location, configuration and proximity to the existing State and National Park properties
makes it a viable candidate. However, State agencies have not been open to allocating this high
value property for the purposes of OHV trail use, particularly since it is very close to the Big
Cypress National Preserve expansion area.
Aerial 5
1-75 Site
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 10 of 14
December 29, 2009
Area 6: Dade/Collier County Airoort
In the late 1960's, Miami-Dade County, along with other South Florida counties, sought to build a
jetport capable of serving the area. Through federal assistance, approximately 24,000 acres was
acquired for the construction ofa supersonic runway and related infrastructure. By the mid-1970's,
a two-mile lone runway had been constructed, but the project faltered and was abandoned as a major
airport. Through 2009, the property was managed as an ancillary takeoff and landing airport, and
will continue to operate, with no plans for expansion of facilities.
Aerial 6
Dade/Collier County Airport
Over the years, the majority of undeveloped land surrounding the runway has been used by area
sportsmen riding in off-road vehicles to access hunting and fishing locations. In 2009, Miami-Dade
County proposed using the southernmost 1,600 acres to support a wilderness park that would include
formally developed OHV trails. In furtherance of this proposal, Miami-Dade County filed a Growth
Management Plan Amendment (CP-2009-01) to seek authorization to convert the site's use from
aviation to park and recreation.
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page II of 14
December 29, 2009
Area 7: Redneck Yacht Club
This 800-acre privately-owned site is located at 44570 Bennont Road, three miles east of County
Road 31 and east of Punta Gorda, Florida. A fonner agricultural plot, it was opened for public use
on weekends since January 2009 as an ATV park. In addition to ATVs, OHVs, swamp buggies, and
4-wheel drive vehicles, this site also accommodates hundreds of tents, campers, and recreational
vehicles. Newspaper reports indicate that trails, mudding, camping, riding areas and events at the
site draw as much as 15,000 guests during holiday weekends. The absence of many sensitive natural
areas permits the site to be fully used by visiting vehicles. The relatively high admission cost of
$30/day and up, and the 60- to 90-minute driving time to the site for Naples area residents make this
site an impractical solution.
Aerial 7
Redneck Yacht Club
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 12 of 14
December 29,2009
Exhibit 4
South Florida Water Management District
Alternative Sites
Soulhwe.llllorlda JU_-
Orf Road Vehicle Pareel Sean:h u
:..,Jrr-'2' l
'-". \ -.-
'u'<:__ "~'
--., :.-
Gladu
l'U~T----~~I---
Charlotte
1_
-. -+
~ .1... ~ ~ ;- 7 -
lee '-5 _I' 1,_. (~en:~,
... -.10#.Jl -~.
.,. ': 9 L -., '-l"cc~ .-116
-, (~:'? 15, :'-.17
\ I '. Collier I. ' ,
I
~
I
~
"
\.
w+,
,
02.55 '0
..'-
[liPfid------
15 20
_MIIElS
_~"""_~
-*"'~"'"--''''.
-18
f<<'Of--'~'J~"'''''
<:.-.....,..-..."'........,.....
.."
~:~t.;;;'.;.';.'~;~.'::,:..::~'t~::;~~;r.~;~~:"..:. ~~~;~J;:~~~"
1..>~".C"........."""...".....,"',_c..""...
.....,u~:"""''''-.,,,...,''.,,..,n''....u.;.''.~"'_...IOO~__
......"'......."........__~.,..'.......A.'" '_P","," ........,,".
"Qof~..""''''' ...
Map Index
1 Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area
2 Fisheating Creek Wildlife Management Area
3 CAlOOSAHATCHEE REGIONAL PARK
4 Gerry Holland Property
5 Alico
6 Conservation 2020 lands
7 C-43 - A Dudda - lee County Solid Waste
8 Ivan Howard Property
9 CREW
10 SFWMD lands
11 Lake Trafford Site
12 Collier Development Corp
13 Alico
14 Barron Collier Stewardship Easement
15 Collier Enterprises
16 Collier Enterprises
17 Hendry County Prison
18 Hussy Property
19 Southern Sand and Stone
20 Picayune Strand
21 Collier land Holdings
Sites not
shown on
map
Alico - Caracara Site Just south of the Hendry County Line
lake Trafford Independent Corp site - SR82 & Old Church Rd
Glades Tree and Sod Farm - CR720 and Silver lake Rd.
US Home Corp - Between CR 78 & Caloosahatchee river
Cypress #1 Inc - East of CR 835 Approximately 20 Miles South
of Clewiston
FDOT - S.w. Corner of 1-75 and SR29
Gnagey Family - North of CR 846 & 5 miles East of Immokalee
64630
one section 33 45 28
12 42 28 Glades County
508 acres
906 acres
3/4 Section
33 46 30
Appendix V.D-5b.2a
Page 13 of 14
December 29, 2009
Conclusion
Although SFWMD identified potential sites well outside of Collier County (Exhibit 4), the staff
evaluation focused principally on properties within the county. After eliminating sites whose size,
location, ownership, cost to acquire and ability to develop were not favorable to Collier County, only
the site south of the Dade-Collier County Airport evidenced any advantages. Until the County and
District are able to identifY and allocate a suitably sized and located property, this is the preferred
off-highway vehicle site for Naples area residents.
Appendix V.D.5b.2a
Page 14 of 14
December 29, 2009
APPENDIX V.D.Sb.4
PRIOR SITE CONDITIONS
Dade-Collier Cypress Recreation Area
County Petition No. CP-2009-01
Appendix V.D.5b.4 - Prior Site Conditions
Prior to the late 1920s, there was little to no disturbance in the area of the site,
due to its swampy characteristics and isolation from developed areas at the time.
The dredging of Tamiami Canal and construction of U.S. Highway 41 (Tamiami
Trail) from 1926-29 were the first impacts to the area. A series of aerial photos
on the following pages shows how human impacts have caused disturbance to
the site, making it an anomaly when compared with properties in the surrounding
area. Since 1940 or before, this property has been traversed by off-road
motorized vehicles for purposes of hunting, fishing, and camping. The 1940
USGS aerial map shows the early swamp buggy trails heading north from U.S.
41 through the site and continuing several miles in a northeasterly direction.
Major impacts were made to the 1 ,600-acre subject site between 1968 and 1971,
with the construction of the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport runway
to the north. The 1969 aerial orthophoto shows the series of large north-south
lakes created for purposes of making the runway. The limestone substrate was
blasted with dynamite and removed for fill, creating deep lakes with surrounding
fill pads and lime-hardened maintenance roadways. The 1969-1971 aerials
show not only the developing airport runway infrastructure, but also an
increasingly larger footprint of recreational trail structure created by swamp
buggies as the site became more easily accessible by the public. From the
1970s through the 2000s, the aerial images show that the network of recreational
trails remains, as the site is regularly traversed by motorized vehicles for
recreation. The 1 ,600-acre site differs greatly from surrounding properties due to
its past disturbance. The property has historically, and continues to support off-
highway vehicle use, fishing, hunting, wildlife viewing, and camping.
Appendix V.D.5b.4
1
12/30/2009
USGS Aerial
Orthophotos
1 : 40,000
Photoset
I mages from
April/May 1940
-CP2009-01
site located
NE of bend in
US 41 -
bottom photo
~
-Note: entire
area appears
largely
undisturbed
-Note: buggy
trail running
from SW to
NE - top photo
Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 1
1969 Aerial Orthophoto
".-w.. '. '" ,~ "'"" .'.~'- .-'. ...~~."f""'
'~.'."" .to>
~. ," ,'fi'
. I
';;.'~'
i;r~\l;(': \;
, -.- . - 'ii
Ff"
.
.
· Runway and roadways nearly finished
· Control building not yet built
· Buggy trails appear between lakes
Source: Miami-Dade Aviation Department
August 27,1969 Scale: 1 inch = 500 feet
. Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 2
1970 Aerial Orthophoto
· Vegetation clearing adjacent to runway
· Control building nearly finished
· Runway painted and striped
· Installing the perimeter fence
Source: Miami-Dade Aviation Department
March 28,1970 Scale: 1 inch = 600 feet
Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 3
1971 Aerial Orthophoto
Same image
Trails outlined
.
In orange
Trail spreading
effect
Source: Lampl-Herbert Consultants, Tallahassee
Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 4
1977 Infrared Ima
Source: Big Cypress National Preserve
Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 5
1980 Aerial Orthophoto
Source: Big Cypress National Preserve/USDA
Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 6
1992 Aerial Orthophoto
ACA-...._._,
Source: Miami-Dade Aviation Department
March, 1992 by Aerial Cartographers of America
Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 7
1995 Infrared Image
Collier County Property Appraiser
I ?
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Aerlel V..r:
11995.:::]
Sale. Yeer:
I OFF .:::]
DlSClAIIiR; '.......MN1 ~Aitrbl ,iMlglryupUWw-ntNtind. an )nOaiiIlphWdatlittb....., noUiM .....lYoIfle.ri~counIr, It llio d0t9
not HIDOOrl: owltfl'lbloadttIWh N"ch..wtM"lfl..~. Ilnaotn 'rlllJt f," ami '"' II WmR ontr.
Source: Collier County Property Appraiser
Appendix V.D.5b.4
CP-2009-01
8
2001 Aerial Orthophoto
Collier County Property Appraiser
1 '/
OlSCUlIlER -1UO.t.".'~rr..1 'Ilqtpg~phy 4trlalllNlJII'J upturwd bHwHn tUO ~nd. ..~ lMOl1lpt. dab. Ulland NY rKlt haw Im:lgary oftt.. .ntl~ Hunty; It alU) dOH
not SUDlM)ri DWIIeullll:llldoelllit\r HItCh" WMrw di5D~~fd., Ilrlol'QtlV IronI 1m.!ld t9t!llllnfnll"ftf onh.
Source: Collier County Property Appraiser
Appendix V.D.5b.4
CP-2009-01
9
2007 Aerial Orthophoto
,..
Source: Big Cypress National Preserve
Appendix V.D.5b.4 CP-2009-01 10