Resolution 1998-395
r
....;
.
:"-~-- ";,J
~-~"
,'.
"
13A4
.
.
;~-; .;/
+" ;~~
RESOLUTION 98- ~S
"
:it
!;
:r:
~'
,
A RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT
OF EARTH MINING CONDITIONAL USE ~ln IN THE
"An ZONING DISTRICT PURSUANT TO SECTION
2.2.2.3 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND
DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATED IN
SECTION 16, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE28 EAST,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
'f. ..', ',!
. WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter
"
67-1246, Laws of Florida, and Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has
conferred on Collier County the power Lo establish, coordinate and
enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the
.-
protection of the public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land
,-.f~':' -t
Development Code (Ordinance No...91tl02) which includes a
Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regulations for the
zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which
is the granting of Conditional Uses; and
WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission, being the duly
\--,
appointed and constituted planning board for the
affected, has held a public hearing after notice
area hereby
,'~
as in said
regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of
Conditional Use "I" of Section 2.2.2.3 in an "An Zone for earth
mining on the property hereinafter described, and has found as a
matter of fact (Exhibit '"A") that satisfactory provision and
arrange:r.ent h"ve been made concerning all applicable matters required
by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 2.7.4.4 of the
Land Development Code tor the Collier County Planning Commission; and
WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to
be hearD by this Board in a public meeting assembled "nd the Board
having considered all matters presented.
liOn, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS of
Collier County, Florida that: . "
.
13A4 .
The petition filed by Jeff L, Davidson of Davidian Engineering,
Inc., representing Joseph D. Bonnes. for Southern Sand and Stone,
Inc., with respect to the property hereinafter described as:
Exhibit "B" which is attached hereto and incorporated by
reference herein
be and the same is hereby approved for Conditional U.. "I" of Section
2.2.2.3 of the "A" Zoning Di.trict for earth mining in accordance
with the Conceptual Ma.ter Plan (Exhibit "CO) and subject to the
follOWing conditions:
Exhibit "0" which i. attached hereto and incorporated,by
reference hereln. .".
minutes of this Board.
BE IT FURTHER P.ESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the
Done this
.1..1
This Re.olution adopted afte motion, .econd and majority Yote.
, 1998.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROC~, Clerk
Atttl~ ,~ to Ch,tro,.
UQIlltlH't 0.1/.
:Z; ;f
A proved a8 to Form and
Legal Sufficiency:
~~t~.~. ;~.~o<(
Assistant County Attorney
flCU.'U-12 U.SOLUT~<*
dly of ~
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLL I ER COUIITY, FLORI DA
,;i .3.
,it ~....-
Ii'
"'----------------
13A4
PINDING OP PACT
BY',.
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNlNG COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-98-l2
The following facts are found:
1. Section 2.2,2.3.1 of the Land Development Code authorized
the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth
Management Plan:
Yes No
B. Ingress and '9res. to property and proposed structures
thereon with particular reference to automotive and
pedestrian safety and convenie~ce, traffic flow and
control, and access in ca.e of fire or catastrophe:
Adequate ingre.s ~ egress
Yes No
C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise,
glare, economic or odor effects:
No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the di.trict:
Compatible use within district
Yes No
Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with
stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for
approval
DATE:
CHAI RMAN:
,'.
f/CV"S'12 FlMO:sa or FACT CMaI~1
.;~_.,,,,
EXHIBIT "A"
'1
, .
"
."Iff. .
:: 'k,
}~,-NA - '-.
"-'.' --;-,
'-:;c,'.'- -.,.-'
~~
UgaI DescrIption
"
:11
-PI'!_
.'
,
13A4
Section 16. Township 48 South. Range 28 East. less the south 50 feet Road
ROW., CollIer County. F\orida, .'
. .
,;, '\lI..
EXHIBIT -D"
f; I
. i! ... "'" L
I · I '
II ·
I ~ .
.
ft III
I r I
"Ii I
II I
.J,
III ·
Ii! I
J J
~
· il'llIlll
I ..1....
N'NI" .11 iiill
'.. -.
~
~
'I
_d~~'''''''' a,1W.
h ~
- !
r:
I. I
:ji
Iii N '-
bl
U..
r: .....
d 13 4
I
~
w
.'
it
I
,
*,
-~,~.. '....., ....~~
", ,~,:",",-'
)j......-,' - '" ......... .....
EXHIBIT .C"
. .'
1 3A 4
MiREEMEriI
I. Jeer L. Davidson. IS authorized aaent for Petition CtJ-9I-12, agree to the following
stipulations mauc:stro by the ('oilier COIDlty Planning ('ommi55ion in their public hearing on
September 3,19911.
PlannilK! Services:
.. The ClIImlt Pl8nnina M.llp:r may ;.p.,.,,~e mind!' changes in the loation. siting.
or heiaht ofbulldinp.ltllKllio~ IIld improvernents authori7.cd by the: conditional
_. Expansion of the ... identified IIld lppI'OVed within this conditional use
appIic:aIion. or major chanan 10 the site plan submitted as part of this application.
sball require the: submittal 0( a new conditional u..e application. and shall comply
with all applicable County onfillll1Ces in eerect at the time of submittal. including
Di,ision 3.3. Site Development Plan Review and approval. of the Collier ('ounty
I.and Development Code. Ordilllll1Cc 191-IO:!).
b. The conditional use Ippl()~" sball he reviewed allhe end of five years 10 determine
wbethcr additional stipullllions or mitigation an: necessary to insure compatibilily
"ith other pI~o1ies in the IR'lIIIld \0 assun: public health. safely and welfare is
adequately addressed. DcvekIJlIl"".t Services stafT will ~ the following standards
in their review and. in the event of the: inability of Development Services and
applicant \0 agree upon additional stipulations or mitilllllion. the matter will be
referml to the: BnenI of l.onilll Appeals usinS the I.and l)evelopmer1t Code
pmcedural requi.~".tlll for ippals. The standard. for review are:
I. Atl~ six months prior to ,I)c fifth annivC'l'Slr)' of-the Boord of Zoning
Appall _v.... applicant 'sball submit . noise study acceptable to
Dcvclop.IIomf Sm1ca stier \0 determine whether additional henning.
IlIldscare or huerm an: neces58r)' 10 insure eompalibility with adjacent
residential 'ltnlCturcs.
2. At least six monlhl prior \0 the fifth annh'ersary of this appronl, applicant
will submit \0 Deve!opnlCnt Services a Trame Study conduc:ted in a manncr
approved by County Transportation Department that assesses the Icvel of
service on County RoId ISI. the project's impect on COIDlty Roed 8S8. and
any mitigation needed 10 address this project's impacts on automotive and
pedestrian safety along the section of County Road 858 from the projecl
entrance on CR 851 \0 the intersc:c:tion of CR 158 and CR 846, Additional
mitiplive meamres that may be required include:
EXlIIBIT "0"
J
.
,',
..
13A4
(I) PMjed CIOIIIribulion (on I propOltional share basis) 10 add
sipliDlJon or tam lanes for other public roeds or for institutional
UICIIC( :",..,on County RMIIISI west of the pcoj.;ct.
(b) Limitation of the number ofhaul trips from the project to a maximum
of 175 per 24-hour period.
(C) Chqa in dIys or houn of operation but no less than 60 hours or
opmdJon per week CStipulldlon I) to Ieaen project traffic interface
with KhooI or other tratTle on CR ISI or other impec:1ed Counly
roads.
Cd) Contn'bution of it, JIIopot1ionate shire c0st5 for any addilional
sidewwlb rwedcd in the vicinity of any institutional U5c:S localed on
('oilnly RMII 151.
"
(e) Mitiption of Ibnonnal wear or tear caused by Ihis project's use or
County Ro.d 11511 wnt of it, entrance that are not addressed by thc
(IlIyment of impa1 fees.
3. Dcvdopmcna Scnic:a Department may rtqui~ additional studies or reporl~
to demonstnde thIl there are no ad\'erw environmenlal imJlllCt~ resuhinll
from orcrntions of Winchester I.ak,'"
c. The petilioner shall mnovcllll exotic "CJletalionon situs listed in the LOC 3.9.6.4.1
prior to any ellCaVIIion Kthitles on site. Subsequent annual exotic removal (in
perpetuity) lhall he the ...~lSlbilil~' of the prorerty owner.
d. Tum Iancs shall be required, both eeslbound and westbound. on CR 1151111I the
project entrance.
e. The petitioner .hall be lRf'uldible (or the maintenance oflhc lurn lanes for the lire
of the project. Failure to pcopaly mainlain the J1IIvement shoulders. signa!!e. and
J1IIvement markingS shall be ClIUllC for revocation of the CU r.mnil.
"
f. A condition aney ofCR IISI from ilS intcnection with CR 1146 sball be perfonned
by the Rood and BricIp Sccdon prior to the start of any lICtivity on this sileo The
mullS of that survey shall be used as a baselinc for future maintenance of the
roadway.
a. The petitioner shall post . maintenance bond in the amount of $ I 00.000.00 for the
life of the project. Thi. bond sball he u!led (or (he: maintenance ofCR 1158 damages
EXIIIBIT "I)"
2
,
I,
'.' .~
13A4
above: normal war and tar ....lIed by this project.
h. A tralTlC rouIilll pIm shIJ1 be suIlmltted to the Count)' ror review and approval prinr
10 the IlIrt of'ln)' anh miaina Klivity on the site:, A copy or this plan shall be
rOl ",VdN 10 the Collier County Boerd o( Public Schools. .
, .
i. Hours or opendion nil be 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Monday throllJh Friday; no e:xcavation
or haulilll opendil1ll shall be IlIowc:d "" Saturda~' or Sunday. cxcc:pl in in~tanccs
wfIc:rc c:ontl'lc:lS ror -public- jobs dictate: ot~i!K:.
j. Any bIaIaina shall '501"111 a pamit rrom Planni/l1l Scrvkc:5 and shall comply Wilh
Collier County n....1na OntiIWll:C,
k. The applicants shall m.r.Jla bcnn not less lhan sill reel in heighl Ilona the propeny
linn adjaecnt to the f,.-- mnc:d p1\'ll(l1ics IS each phase: is initiated.
I. The: excavation shall be limited to a Iowc:sl l"OMiblc: """0m devalion or 25 rect
below existilll plIdc ...Iall pennit modilication isapplic:d ror Ihrough the EAB and
the BCC and shall be no IIlIIJowc:r than 10 reet below existinll sradc:.
m. Prior to any sile imllt(,,(.I~lIl ~ in rdation to this excavation or clc:arins. the
owner shall con1Kllhe USAl"OE and Sf'WMD 10 dck,,"inc: ir wetland pc:nnilting
is II('l;dcd. Ir 10, al! II'IICJ pc:rmItJ shall ~ obtained. prior 10 the commc:nccmcnl of
any site impnn-c:mc:ntJ.
SIItc or Florida
CounlY or Collier
The: r~lIoinll AlIIC:COlo:f\t Sheet w. ac:knowlc:dllc:d ~rort me this .D day uf
" ,','ff'''' ,1991, by :,... I II """"",,,,,, who is pc:nonally known to me or who ha._
produc:c:d' ... I I I ~ as identincation and who did (did nol) lake an oath.
: ., I. _' ,y\',' l-.: (
-
(Sipature "rSolar)' Public)
NOTARY PUBLIC
Commission If C( ~. /1,"/, ]'..:
My Commission Expires: I ,) ,. I
EXHIBIT "n"
3
Q) -IOIL.t.Jo
11\'- 'C1C_
DPIlIIt....1. DI
---'__A.
"t,.",!," .
"., ~ ..;, . ',"
13A ~
'.
~~
ENTAnvE FOR CCPe
Slalc or F1orid1
County or Collier
The rorqoina AJfC(llk.4 Sheet WIp Itknow/edsed bef'on: me thi, 12tiJ day or
S~~r ,1991, by /J),'CNe f.J)a<J1J ,who is_~ly known to me or who ha~
pfoduced . idcnIirlCalion and who diet (did not) take an oath.
)
NOTARYPtJ8L1C
('ommiuion "
My Commission ElCpirn:
,'.
EXIIIBIT "0"
4
j
J.
,
.
13A If
AGRt:F.MENT
I. Jerr L. Davidson, as authorized aamt (ar Petilion <:U-98-12, agree 10 lhe following
stipulations requc:stcd by the Collier County Planning Commission in lheir public hearing on
Sr:pcr:mber 3. 1998.
PlanninC! Servicn:
a. The Current Plannllll MIII8Il:f may 3pprO\'e minor ehanges in lhe local ion, siling.
or height of buildings. slnIclurn, and imp"we:mcnts aUlhorizcd by the: conditional
UK. ElCp;mslon or the usn identified and aJlPl'ovc:d \\;thin this e:onditional use
al'Plication. or major ehanges to the sile plan submined as rart of Ihis applicalion.
shall require lhe submittal of. new conditional use application. and shall comply
\\ith all applicable County ordinances in elTcct allhe time of submittal, including
Oi\ision 3.3, Site: Deve:lopnJoenl Plan Rn'iew and appro\'al. of the Collier County
I.and On'c:I0Jl111C1l1 Code:. Ordlnancc 191-102).
b. The condilional U'IC apprcwal shall ~ rc\';c\\cd allhe md o( Ii\'c ~'c:ars 10 dClc:nninc
\\hether addilional stlrcdalions or milij;OIlion arc n\'Ces~ry 10 insurc eompalibilily
\\ilh olher rrormjes In lhe lUClI and 10 anure: public hCOlllh. safe:ly and welfarc i~
adequale:ly' addressed. r>r:vclopnw.'I~Sr:n'ices stalT will U'IC thc following slandard~
In their m'iew and. In lhe event of'lhe inabiliiy or Dc\'c:Iopmenl Se:r\'ices and
applicant 10 ~ upon Ilddlllonal slipulations or milillalion. lhe mailer will ~
referred 10 lhe Ooard or l.onlng Arreals using lhe 1.Md Developmenl Code
procedural requiremml for appeals. The: standards (or fr:\'iew are:
J.
Al least Sill monlhs prior 10 Ihe fil'lh anniversary o( Ihe Board of Zoning
Arreals approvals. appllcanl shall submil II noise study acceptable to
Oe\'elopment Services stalT 10 detmninr: whether additional benning.
landlCllpe or bulTers 1ft netessary 10 insure compalibility \\ilh adjace:nl
residenlial structures.
,
Allcast six months prior 10 the fifth anni\ersary of Ihis appro\'al, applicanl
\\ill submillO Develop.llCI11 Senicl.'s a Traffic Sludy conducled in a manner
OIpprD\'c:d by Counly Transportalion Dcparrmentthat assesses the Icycl of
!oCr\icl.' on Counly Road 8S11.lhc: project's imPKI on Counly' Road liS II. and
any milii!'llion nc:r:dr:d to ad"r~'~" Ihi~ proj.:.I's impacls on automoth'e and
r.:dntrian safety aIona the ~..ion of County Road 8S8 from the projecl
cnlranc:e: on,CR llS110 lhe inl.:ncc:tion of CR 8S11 and CR 846. Addilio",,'
mili~li\'1.' measures ahat ma)',~ required illCludc:
EXIItBIT "I>"
I
1XhuIi1
7JCC"p'
~?UI~
I
.
1:.
13A4 ".~
(a) Project con1rIbution (on a pr()flOl1ionaJ shan: basis) 10 add
sipall-.Ioa or cum lanes for other public roads or for institutional
IIllCS IIC~. on County ROCId ISlI west of the: project.
(b) Limitation oflhc: nummofhaullrips from the: project to a maximum
of 175 pet 24-hour ,.mod.
(C) <'111I18'-- in d8ys or hours of operation but no less than 60 hours 0 f
opmItion per Wftk (Slipulation I) 10 lessen projectlraffie inlerface
"i!h IChool or olher traffie on CR 858 or other impacled Counly
nJads.
.
Id) Contribution of its prl1"""ion:lle share cost!! for any addilional
si~-aJks nc:eded in the: \'ieinit)' of any in!!tilulional WIC!!localed on
County ROCId 158.
Ie) Mitiplion of abnormal wear or lear eau.~ "y this project'!! U!IC of
County ROId IS. wnl of ils cnlr:mc:e Ihat arc not addre:s!ICd by the
r:a)1IIClIt ofimpac:t fCl:s.
J. Oe\'elopmc:nt Services Dc:p:anmc:nt may require additionalsludies or re:ports
to dc:mon!ltr.lle that lhere arc no ad\'c:rse environmenlal impacl!! resulting
from OJlc:r3tions of Wirll:hc:ster I.akes.
c.
The: pctitionc:rshall removnlJ nolie \'c:ec:t:alion on siteaslislc:d in the: LDC 3.9.6.4, J
prior to any nea\'aaion IICth,itin on site. Subsequent annual notie removallin
rc:rpeluity) shall be Ihc: rapu.llibilily of lhe: property owner.
d.
Tum lanes shall be required. both c::a.~lbound and westbound. on CR 1158 al the
project c:nlr.lllCe. '
,'.
c.
The: pc:titionc:r shall be responsible for the maintenarll:e: of the: turn lanes for lhe: Ii fc
of lhe: project. Failure to properly maintain the: I'avc:mcnt !!houldc:rs. signage. and
J':!\'c:rnc:nt marldnp shall be cause for re\'ocation of the: CU permit.
r.
^ condition 1lIr\'Cy ofCR 85. from ils intersc:ction with CR 846 shall be performed
by the: Rood and Bridle Section prior 10 lhe: start ofany :aclivily on !his site. The
rnults of lhal survey shall be u!ICd as a t.a'Cline for future: maintenance of the
roadwa)' ,
The: pc:tilionc:r shall post a l1IIIinten:anec bond in Ihe amounl of S I 00,000.00 for the
life of the: project. This bond shall be U!l4-d for the: mainlenanc:e of CR .5. damages
r~HmlT "0"
2
"
Stale of'Florida
County of'Collier
13A4
above normal war IIId tar ....-4 by this project.
h.
A UlIfTlc ftIIIlina pIIn _n be submitted 10 the Counry f'or review and approval prior
10 the sun of' any earth mlnina ac:tivity on the site. A copy of'this plan shall be
rorwarded 10 the Collier County Board of' Public Schools.
i.
Hours of' opemion shall be 7 LID. 10 7 p.m. Monday through Friday; no Cllcavalion
or hlulinl operallon shall be 1I1cnwd on Satunbyor Sunday, ellcept in instanccs
wilcre c..atl_1s f'or -public" jobs diclale otherwise.
j.
Any bIastina shall require a permit from Plannina Services and shall comply ",ilh
Collier County R1astilll Ordinance.
k.
The applicants shall inslalla bmn not less than Sill reel in heighl along Ihe property
lines adjXmlto the EsIalc:s zoned pmpcnies as each pha.w is initiated.
I.
The Cllcav*ion 1ha11 be Ilmiled 10 a 1cM'CSI possible IKJlIom elCl'alion of 2S fecI
below nisUlII p*unlasa permit modification is applied ror through !he EAn and
Ihe oce and shall be 110 ....Ioweril,an 10 reel below nisiing gracle.
m.
Prior 10 any site: impro~elllomt ~ in ~lation to Ihis Cllconation or clearing. lhc
owner shall conlX1lhe USACOE and SFWMD to dctcnninc: if wetland permining
is needed. If'so. allascllCY pennils shall be obt<linc:d. prior 10 the commencement of
any site impro\'cmmtJ.
~,
PE R OR AGENT
Thc forcaoinll A~rtcment Sheet W'lIS xknow ledged bero~ me this ..J.:J. day of
50i€""'~n.... 1991. by )H..~f.'i'l. ~",i)~..... who is personally known to me or who has
produced &: l.. l>.~ 'V;;"~ -: ~ ,'.&Uc:'lIS iclcndfication and who did (did nol) take an Galh.
.Ju.~mc.p~
(Signature or Notary P.ublic)
SOTARY PUBLIC
Commission II Cc Ie 1'" '&1 ~
My Commission Expires: q. ~ - C I
EXHIBIT "I>"
3
Q) 1IIIIIlAlCPIlI~
.,- -,...,.
.........20 ..
.....--.~I.&. ~_
, . .
".0/"1
,,,;"., .:
,{ :1:
Slate or Florida
County or Collier
13A4 .'.
~ufJd~
REPRESENTATIVE FOR CCPe
,'.
The ......JOioI ApeclllCftl Sheet .... acknowledged berore me this i.2t!J day of
S~ (l!r . 1991. by 111 j ch4~ lJ)atJt J , who i=IY known IQ me or who has
pr'oduccd .Idenlirlc:ation lInd (did not) take an oat .
SOTARY PUBLIC
Commission ,
My Commission Expirn:
,'.
EXHIBIT "P"
4.
,'.