Resolution 2022-172RESOLUTION NO.2022- 17 2
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A
CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW A
COMMUNICATIONS TOWER WITHIN THE
ESTATES (E) ZONING DISTRICT WITH A
WELLFIELD RISK MANAGEMENT SPECIAL
TREATMENT OVERLAY ZONE W-4 (ST/W-4)
PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 2.03.0l.B.l.c.12 AND
5.05.09 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND
DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR A 2.7f ACRE
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1680 GOLDEN GATE
BLVD EAST, ALSO DESCRIBED AS THE EAST 180
FEET OF TRACT 20, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES,
UNIT NO. 51 SUBDIVISION, IN SECTION 2,
TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, COLLIER
COUNTY, FLORIDA. [PL20200002584]
WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 67-1246, Laws of
Florida, and Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on Collier County the power to
establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary
for the protection of the public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code
(Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which includes a Comprehensive Zoning
Ordinance establishing regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of
the County, among which is the granting of Conditional Uses; and
WHEREAS, the Golden Gate Area Master Plan, Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -
Element, Policy 1.1.6 requires Conditional Use approvals to receive a super majority vote
(minimum of 4 votes) by the Board of Zoning Appeals; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals ("Board"), being the duly appointed
and constituted planning board for the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing
after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability
of a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower within the Estates (E) Zoning
District pursuant to sections 2.03.0l.B.l.c.12 and 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land
Development Code on the property hereinafter described, and the Collier County
Planning Commission has made findings that the granting of the Conditional Use will not
adversely affect the public interest and the specific requirements governing the
Conditional Use have been met and that satisfactory provision and arrangement have
been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in
accordance with Subsection 10.08.00.D of the Land Development Code; and
[21-CPS-02091/1739550/1] 8/29/2022
1680 Golden Gate Blvd E. Cell Tower (CU) Page 1 of 2
CU-PL20200002584
CAO
WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this
Board in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters
presented.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
Petition Number PL20200002584 filed by James F. Johnston, Esq. of Shutts
& Bowen LLP, on behalf of Cellco Partnership, a Delaware general partnership, d/b/a
Verizon Wireless, with respect to the property hereinafter described in Exhibit "B", be
and the same is hereby approved for a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower
within the Estates (E) Zoning District with Wellfield Risk Management Special
Treatment Overlay Zone ST/W-4 pursuant to sections 2.03.0I.B.l.c.12 and 5.05.09 of the
Collier County Land Development Code, in accordance with the Conceptual Site Plan
described in Exhibit "A", and subject to the conditions in Exhibit "C". Exhibits "A",
"B", and "C" are attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes
of this Board.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second, and super majority vote of the
Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida thisZ'=gday of Q (-T66ER , 2022•
ATTEST:
CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK
By.
Attest aS to Claj) Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legality:
Dy-tkD-
Derek D. Perry ,Lv
Assistant County Attorne
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLLIER CO DA
Cam? c
By: '
Wil am L. McDaniel, Jr., Chairman
Attachments: Exhibit "A" — Conceptual Site Plan
Exhibit "B" — Legal Description
Exhibit "C" — Conditions of Approval
[21-CPS-02091/1739550/1] 8/29/2022
1680 Golden Gate Blvd E. Cell Tower (CU) Page 2 of 2
CU-PL20200002584 CA
Exhibit "A"
Conceptual Site Plan
O<WWr
N
O
<
Q W
W
h
a
Z
���,
•� M
Waax�
NzoW�
a OZOjW
\11/11111/I No
\\ II N
�� '�I�
�� ���`?T
Z z
O
p
Z
Q
m
N
W
7�
o
��m¢
opMo�
.,,�j��i
p F
�o-,z
y
m ad
O NMM
uiawJN�
a�
TI-
� O=M-)
�ozUzO
3�az�Z
,,,,Q��•��,.
�C •ji. LL A.�Y I
V
�y�j�
N
W
Y M
O
VI
N
N
Dw '
Z �M 7
w a m� O
2 0yU � �'¢
Z _� o
w=w O
<W�
0
W
ao
UV
N
_
W
O
U
5
r
U OZrn
N
W .- W�2m
O� w
1=W�VQUIW
¢
CO
YZ�SW 2SzU
m47�W115�
c'�
m7o<Z�
VI ¢ti<W
< a
•Z CC0 * pia
•W ~ D�Z
' (i O Q Q
�/
WH
U
Q/
K Q�
a c=ic¢J"
w xo
�� N Z J
ON�Wpzo
w
? ❑
W � c)
awi
wo
=Olw Wz
az.a z
sozo
I� �� \
i'y', Z ��� �,�
I f1 '•,, ���
/
J ly
OQ
y w
w
`�
V
w
a wm
o
��N Jo
a~
���� iW
���0^ ••. •'l����
o
<o
m � Ud
LU
zz
° N
a •�����/
w '�IIIfI
_ CIO=
N
w
ii�W
z
IIIP�,
cn
O In
o
FL -FAST GRID
(Nn0 83/2011)
i I
�I I
-----------y--------=-------
I � I
'I I
1
I I
ram' I I 4 I
I 1
-__.Wq�.•'O__1_______________________________________iz
____'JO
egji i +S. w u��'oiiz Cm ori� I _ I
ew��c o�s2�1 � �ZH
_-
Oa^F I U 41 OG 41 ¢Q I I
2a2ca;
Qf
' -. 31'W' p Om Op i
w^ x rp p Fp_____________ ____..
r________.� - - Ill X Z _ N
w� ^w za r '
I_ OQ wa ww Wm�� OZ - Ow Off¢ OW a0$ O�U ON _ 1 aN I r
L �11 Ozz O¢ OZ O=� O� s „� Ow
'I �¢ O lY W LYO xO¢ w¢ ¢ W I
•----------y 1 o- a.., a 2 EL Il w a In I
9 �)
._..:. _-_-------L--
FOB
m
,
r„�v, lil
---------- \ �.
.._.._..
s
I
I
I
1
'
ON
I
I W W r
I ! n
w
W U
! n Q
w �
W U Z
V t Q F w
I T o�
oo<
0WON
Of
U
t
as S K
a $i Q W
I
.:'•
�O F41
I ZM
I
O,,y Z
VN047� rrx�1 CNq�gFq!2
gI.i2
s�lQ
ix
u u
Yam[. .•
Nam` '
Ap
Mz
UR
W Q VI w `•
U +'...
C)
------------------
W N d Q O
00 d U
U p Y F Z U
OComo a a
Z aav�
1
y� 1
yT '
I
I
� I
I
� I
Uli----------____----�___-_-
f 9
1 F°� _ f. ",
J
a�
Fa— O
as
Z
°❑w
fA
o0
F-
� �
Aga
o
0
0
0
�n
�°J
ww
a0.
a2F-
LLI
z
o
F
w
fA O W
a
w
o
Z
o
w
❑2O
o
0
o
O W a
LL
d v
2
z-
O
U
in
w
to
I
Y
U-
cN3
W w
-I N
Ww
v
*
<
n
*
H
J ~
z
z
a
7 a
o
o
Z CO) Z
Oar
as
�
*
+
+
*
*
+I
*
-H
H }
z
Wo
g
=�
0
0
0
0
0
0
m
� LL-
O
a W
awa
O
WW
W
z
0
_
w
U
w
U
N�
0
W d
W 2 O
O �"
W
w
o
0' Z
0'
Z
0
0
ON
(AW
w
3
O
to
-
O
V1
LL
o
Q
M
m
U
0
Y
0
0
f
C)
p< O r
ry
ry
O
m
O
O
CD
QW
y
zf
W
pa J
pp�aWa��••�........��•II
�IIIIIIIIIIII�
�--
Qz-��
r
N
of
F
W O
�G
M M
W�V6Z0
���
�?�
• A
�F
OOZ
Du�
O
m
r/
r
N@
MM
W �0�..�
J�^F-
60cOp� QO
O`M
tfU
Z17iV
: � tt
LL Y-•�Y..\-LOE���J
`/Q
p
O
Z
O
O
N
O
ICIQW
yyZ F. 00M�
U' Z��
o=cOZ�a¢
pUa
w=61J�F
.•�
V:•GJLn O O•/
OOU
N_
W
rZ
$
(Z
K O
0 ozorn
zu WQmI�O
o ff^^F r
YE++�=Lj Z.5
mznc7C�LJi
m<pQpW
'i <w
.I W
=.W aD *
'IIll
J
�
Q
W,'
p 0¢^
K z (x
QWL V¢NJ
r (,W
� � V / z a
UMWLi 33
CJZ Jl1
K � �
U t
<o z�>
��a
> � 1. Z
Q O:Z
�•v O �•O
' Z ~
i�:�
If
/Q�
li
N
w Q� Xov
z p
zN�o0Z�
OWc
w
..
wo=o^o
� N��:��
'--tis''•'. .��.�'
W
cn
m
M
a Wm
��NJ�
a~
_` ����qw
N�6�Naw
'-i��r •''• ... •�( ���
''''•III
0
O
o
m
F
z 1
v
o">' N
z
u 'o o s -z W
w 111 P �O''`,
o
N N
>
Rz (,A
FL -EAST GRID
(NAD 63/2011)
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
-------------------------------------------------------------------�
I
I
ow
o
W
omw
0¢
N
¢
J
ON
CL 0 ¢
ozz
00
a N
0¢
CL �
0- �
A
L..-
I
I
1
I
I
I
__________________________________________________l
I
F�
owe
2yFF
`�ot's
---------------------
---------------�
V CO p4i�
t�Olii�
>03 olu)?e
u
Zati�e
q tk,, O,u�
eZ"
aeZn
I
p7
U G 114
J
u
o¢
¢ I
F
F
1
Ox0
N
N�
H�
>O I
Ot0 m O•-.01- �___________
___
___
w
WN .______�
0
}_
I
Oa
vw0
O
L,wNovi
(plw
n�I
00
0MUO
O, II
Z
o
a-x
Ma,
OO
M
OW
a1n I
NNW
oN¢w
I
W
�Z
r
o
2
zL
KMOW
P
a- Z
�mi¢
f/1:0-
x=1
o
X�0
ao
aim
a�¢w
wCO
wD-m
F
ou'
F
N U
(%1
w
w
0
V �
1-
�N
o'
a�
U w
Z U
a a
W
J
Z
-1O
a
m
Q
�a
Q
H
*
+1
41
Z O '•'
ya
W O
F
o Q CO)
Z
25 a
N
O
O
M
J
W
N
IL >
LU
U)
_
_
W
>
W
N U W
a
Q
LLI�
o
Z
o
0
w
0 O
o
a
0 � d
o
d v LL
Z
w
U
uj
°
I
1
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
-----------------J
I
}
a
U.
w U)
n
N
m
Q
M
W W
J Vl
W
<
ii
v
ii
n
fi
N
fi
N
fi
I
I
J
z
Z
O
¢�
m Q
QJN
maw
Da
o
o
o
CN
z N Z
a
-H
+�
+1
+�
+�
OQJ
a.*
y
}
z
LU
p m
Q U.
QO
N
N
I
O W
0,
awa
Lu O
MW
Z
w
U
V
N W 0.H
W O
O L
r
w
O
zo
Z
0
z
0
2
0
Q
w
w
3
o
2
�O LL
o
H
ZLU
Q
Q
Q
m
U
0
Y
N
0
0 =
O
z
J
a
z
O
H
Q
a
W
o
O a
{� Q
= o
uzoos
,,1111y11111//// '41 N
%%
�
i
O
H�
LQU0�
W a
p�2o
OoN�C�QO
-.,o
D�z�
.•
•,��
oONQv
U
m
�
H
ppaZU
9`p'oU
ou
�, �,Q� �����
LLA
O
O
< Z
D
O
NN(\
O
0 ,n
Z
z WQmJuo
uMa�Z��O
>_ =Ll"
o
w=o��
m3o`z�
)O O
�Z N ,
W
OOU
In
-
wY
=
dJ
5
a
a
o UZ�
ua..
o rn wW
FW~'^v�viw
mc�M�Li L�
ar�aFa�,
m �:Q
.W ~ O;Z
Wa
'1W
Tom
w LZ K
a `n
as xL)
�� v/ Z (J W
0_ V� zap
o(n WwaU
= pz"
p:= J O
Koe
aW;
wF
Z 01,1 Z 0 2
rci�a
ova
Q :V Q F O
♦� Z:\`
• Qlc
''.,�'lSi '•
N
J
U
Z�
O U)
w w0
a m
0
�� N J o
m
w soz000
n �Q�Nzw
�`�'`
�� ��••,•, •• ,, •��!/,♦
��i���
o
ap
m
F
ci
z 1
z
o O o
z_-y��d�j"�
w
.. �i pFi�����
0
3
W
�, U
a
a
a
Es X.XtTm
m
HE
ut
o
FL -FAST GRID � � - Y � '•� -
(NAP 03I2011)
Y.
O p0
O y imp
F3 Z '+ O Z
o W W a0 "1opZ� v
w _ O l W
I W wLnD N W a W aJ WW o o V
o m Q o W o 0 o m
oz a o� V^
J Si o
i I
4,4 ..
i I
4 j I
I I
+ 1. I
� I 1
I I
W i
J I I
CD
m n
I I
W I I
F
Z t
W I
O Oft-4-
II
for
v
I of r a o z z
I
> m 3 otip 0 49
..
a
I 00 d Opp wa w
� N a > a >
o par a� pwa00 0� oZ o0
N VI VI W Z a V1 Z � V) VI 0V1 a
O ONE p O_a OVI O OX
a aww �Z asz aw 0_a aw
I O OU(n (/10 O�� OU 00 Oz
I 0_Ua RO a 0
I a aaW wm ads da aw WO
I
t
1
I ,
I -
MVj VIwow ZWWOW - ✓t A -..
O�a�z O ;wJ �zo -�
K O rt
W
J r N (OK V l CC)xC) W W N + • s I
pf ZmQ (L z NNOJ + 1_ •�
�U000 U 0WOZU • • 7 '•
a. w f Z Z V p
> as
w S W.
K W N U' x a-' f K~ N p 7 • • •�' Z
QOFow wvz u. a�F�cUi
> pQ ax
O -60Ww caJ ZU J� -+ - •11% LU
O
m W4ZFF z0 Oaa n1 :� •'
o�a�=a zwoa�` ♦� �• fn
xa k' pa awamo� -' Q
D
azmaxa °oa�x
,h�000
— w ci m
Na<zo ��� . W <WWr }ozZ F V Z M U
�OZuj
oNpz vFi w(ai1
OOWW oxzO Ra
vl?U?waO
Z
e
a
JJ
9
o
I
,
•
^���
♦''0i,.,�`�`
I�
�•'�
-eWOp
Q
,ITyI*.II.
'\♦l,♦a�♦V,�
.
��ZI/�/I
l.:�h♦�J�•
•�IRI7wI~�:.i/��
♦�/�♦/�,♦�
�r.
�F
?Ow�ra�
�p
mYYrNm��O�
.�
v
s(�
:�•♦
�♦
�
NNOZNO
•,�♦���.�♦
7O[♦•:.s�♦W2
•
��%
,��I,��'
I
I.�II•I
I.aIPuI.I
0
a
w
w
o z
N -
w
Q
0
0
W�7�W(aUw.wiI-�Jann Oa
O=Oi"JM�m�yYar.
Lo
powUwWwK
I
NKNa�wZ0000 .z
am0 zMj
dF�Z1Y
QQ UU d. -j d
Z wZ.,C) W-' 4d Z
FrU
OaYamOpn`-OZIn
Ja=xREisZU O
rON -WQ r wN Or wmaorw, V1 QO w MrawoO O,MIEZAp. OOlNOm
am WV0 OwK wwK
wo OOro woIr OzZW Z
X ZQ
U
iir -HW * Ow QU
OVII
W z0
Ln Q w
�Or � VoI
z
z,� 00z
sa FFa
aLU =1 O
p4ZUI
Z> ma7 in
Dwz U-/
6 Ind N
-Z. Z
NrZ w O
soaZ x F-
mUmoa_ wN ON�i ,W3 K OU Uz
Z
Z wwri
W
n op JO~
Oa�jZW2 >O m
RJrZU a
/i ,omwasW
W aco
o�Vw o1) a
0�'waO r
Z wNa
~
N
W
O
�
Z
0
0
0
�
0
�
^
�
W
�
W
CAO
Li
H
p Q W
a a3Nviim\mN
O
z_
0
c
w
o z
N
Q
N
O
C7 DOQZ� U
z w Z Z w p
JAW^
a 0 U Y
d
O
.
'pzz"m
oaYa
W Q a Y
W J x
in >ap
N x
d W Z
O
wX
N
v
J
Z N W Z
0
a,
V)
O O .N..
a a m W s'
K moons z
O
a z a a
02 VFW_-
p W
KO
-�wQ
J. r�
z
z
o
x z
w
z
w
0 a
N
W
w
w
z Z
-H Z i{� H O
*U
Z
w
O O O O W
O<
p
O<
a F a H MCA
- M
O F
F-
00 1
w
. Z p
Oa
Z
U W-
p
O
Q
c
w
ZF
Z0 3
Opz
w
az
�a
_zN
<Z� o
Z,
o
.pp V
way a
xo
�a
Ln
m J
'n N
oQ
, W
Qz o x
N 2 \ 2
Z
Jj
6
UN
0
No U ZU
Q
Q
p z
am'N
Z" H- w
OJ
W
y N
ON x
4 a 4 Z
J
O
W
xa
n
ow
>»o o.
w-z0 a
a
n
wa <0
W
W a~
F- a�
>._ sm o
o�
Q a�
a0 o
o>Wa o
0 a
Z
N
\ 8
7 �n
O ~
W O
ro
m
m�
�
N
m
Q
�/'�
O� J�
Lii W� v z�O
O
O
N
��v/ZU�J
W W~ w
=co C.7U3
�i
N
O
O W
a � UU--
2aJ
oN LL pz�
z
a'
aW"wLL 333 LL'
SO
VL
N
U1
�W
J
m
� W m
CAO
EXHIBIT "B"
Legal Description
The East 180 Feet of Tract 20, Golden Gate
Estates, Unit No. 51, according to the plat thereof,
as recorded in Plat Book 5, Page 84, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida.
Also known as: 1680 Golden Gate Boulevard East,
Naples, Florida, 34117
Parcel Identification Number: 39382280001
[21-CPS-02091/1739550/1] 8/29/2022
1680 Golden Gate Blvd E. Cell Tower (CU) Page 1 of 1
CU-PL20200002584 tr�
EXHIBIT "C"
Conditions of Approval
1. The western edge of the access entry -drive shall be a minimum of 30 feet
from the western property line of the project parcel.
2. Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless, its successors, or assigns shall
maintain the tower as a monopine style tower, and shall maintain the
tower (including, but not limited to, the tree branch canopy) in good
condition and repair in accordance with the appearance and condition at
the time of installation.
[2 1-CPS-02091/1739550/11 8/29/2022
1680 Golden Gate Blvd E. Cell Tower (CU) Page 1 of 1
CU-PL20200002584
Q