Loading...
Agenda 12/08/2020 Item # 9A (GMP Ordinance - Naples Senior Center Community Facility)9.A 12/08/2020 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance No. 89-05, as amended, the Collier County Growth Management Plan for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, specifically amending the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -Element of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Element and Urban Golden Gate Estates Future Land Use Map and Map Series by amending the Estates Mixed -Use District to add the Naples Senior Center community facility subdistrict to allow construction of up to 30,000 square feet of community facility uses for family social service programs and activities for seniors aged 60 and over. The subject property is located on the southeast corner of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane, approximately 350 feet south of Immokalee Road, in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, consisting of 8.7f acres; and furthermore, recommending transmittal of the adopted amendment to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity; providing for severability and providing for an effective date. [PL20180002622] (This is a companion to Agenda Item 9.A) OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners (Board) to approve (adopt) the proposed small- scale Growth Management Plan (GMP) amendment for transmittal to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity. CONSIDERATIONS: The subject petition is submitted as a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment. As such, per Florida Statutes, the request is heard only once each by the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) and the Board. If approved by the Board, the petition is transmitted to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity (DEO). This petition seeks to amend the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -Element (UGGE) text and Future Land Use Map of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP), specifically to establish the new Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict, affecting fewer than ten (10) acres, by amending the UGGE Future Land Use Map to depict the new Subdistrict and adding a new Future Land Use Map Series inset map that depicts the new Subdistrict, amending the Estates Mixed -Use District to add the new Subdistrict provisions, and revising other text to identify the new Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict, for f8.7 acres, located at the southeast corner of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane, and the southwest corner of Valewood Drive and Autumn Oakes Lane, approximately 350 feet south of Immokalee Road (CR 846), in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East. The maps proposed for change by this amendment are depicted on Ordinance Exhibit A. More specifically, the petitioner proposes to amend Mixed -Use District provisions to allow development of the site with a maximum of 30,000 square feet of floor area of community facility uses (variety of family social service programs and activities) for seniors age 60 and over and their caregivers. As stated in the proposed Subdistrict, "Services may include but are not limited to classes and programs for learning, exercise, employment and financial assistance, grief counseling, emotional support, and respite support and other similar services related to providing assistance for seniors." Aside from the building square feet limitation, the Subdistrict provides that building height is limited to two habitable stories, neither residential uses nor overnight activities are permitted, and the site must be rezoned to a Planned Unit Development (PUD) to permit the uses in this Subdistrict. Per Chapter 163.3187, Part H, Florida Statutes, limitations are in place for this type of small-scale amendment, as identified below, followed by staff comments [italicized in brackets]. (1) A small scale development amendment may be adopted under the following conditions: (a) The proposed amendment involves a use of 10 acres or fewer. [The proposed amendment pertains to an 8.7-acre property.] (b) The proposed amendment does not involve a text change to the goals, policies, and objectives of the local government's comprehensive plan, but only proposes a land -use change to the future Packet Pg. 33 9.A 12/08/2020 land use map for a site -specific small scale development activity. However, text changes that relate directly to, and are adopted simultaneously with, the small scale future land use map amendment shall be permissible under this section. [This amendment involves text changes that relate directly to site -specific Future Land Use Map changes] (c) The property that is the subject of the proposed amendment is not located within an area of critical state concern unless the project subject to the proposed amendment involves the construction of affordable housing units meeting the criteria of s. 420.0004(3), and is located within an area of critical state concern designated by s. 380.0552 or by the Administration Commission pursuant to s. 380.05(1). [The subject property is not within an Area of Critical State Concern.] (4) Comprehensive plans may only be amended in such a way as to preserve the internal consistency of the plan pursuant to s. 163.3177. [The amendment preserves the internal consistency between and among GMP elements.] FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS: Based on the review of this petition, including the supporting data and analysis, staff makes the following findings and conclusions. More analysis is provided in the Staff Report to the CCPC. • There is a demonstrated need for the proposed uses. • The subject site is reasonably central to the geographical area of the population served and has ready access to I-75, which may be beneficial to members residing farther from the site. • The site is an appropriate location for the proposed uses. • The demographics of the population served are projected to increase in actual numbers and percent of the total population. • The two square mile area of Golden Gate Estates in which the subject site is located is limited to large -lot single-family dwelling units except for the previously approved fire station and six churches (all by conditional use), a County stormwater treatment pond, the undeveloped Southbrooke Commercial PUD, the nonconforming commercial use adjacent to the south of the subject site, and the nonconforming commercial use on a portion of the subject site. • The proposed uses are considered community facility uses and institutional uses, not commercial uses. • There are no infrastructure impacts related concerns. • The submitted traffic impact study shows that almost all site -related traffic occurs during non - peak hours. • There are no unacceptable adverse impacts to environmental resources and no evidence of cultural resources on the site. • The proposed use is generally compatible with the surrounding area based upon the macro level at which GMP amendments are reviewed. FISCAL IMPACT: Petition fees account for staff review time and materials, and for the cost of associated legal advertising/public notice for the public hearings. No fiscal impact is associated with the approval of this petition. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Adoption of the proposed amendment by the Board and its transmittal to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity will commence the Department's thirty- (30)-day challenge period for any affected person. Provided the small-scale development amendment is not challenged; it becomes effective thirty-one (31) days after Board adoption. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This Growth Management Plan (GMP) amendment is authorized by, and subject to the procedures established in, Chapter 163, Part II, Florida Statutes, the Community Planning Act, and by County Resolution No. 12-234, as amended. The Board should consider the following criteria in making its decision: "plan amendments shall be based on relevant and appropriate data and an analysis by the local government that may include but not be limited to, surveys, studies, Packet Pg. 34 12/08/2020 9.A community goals and vision, and other data available at the time of adoption of the plan amendment. To be based on data means to react to it in an appropriate way and to the extent necessary indicated by the data available on that particular subject at the time of adoption of the plan or plan amendment at issue." 163.3177(1)(f), FS In addition, s. 163.3177(6)(a)2, FS provides that FLUE plan amendments shall be based on surveys, studies and data regarding the area, as applicable including: a. The amount of land required to accommodate anticipated growth. b. The projected permanent and seasonal population of the area. c. The character of undeveloped land. d. The availability of water supplies, public facilities, and services. e. The need for redevelopment, including the renewal of blighted areas and the elimination of nonconforming uses which are inconsistent with the character of the community. f. The compatibility of uses on lands adjacent to or closely proximate to military installations. g. The compatibility of uses on lands adjacent to an airport as defined in s. 330.35 and consistent with s. 333.02. h. The need to modify land uses and development patterns with antiquated subdivisions. i. The discouragement of urban sprawl. j. The need for job creation, capital investment and economic development that will strengthen and diversify the community's economy. And FLUE map amendments shall also be based upon the following analysis per Section 163.3177(6)(a)8.: a. An analysis of the availability of facilities and services. b. An analysis of the suitability of the plan amendment for its proposed use considering the character of the undeveloped land, soils, topography, natural resources, and historic resources on site. c. An analysis of the minimum amount of land needed to achieve the goals and requirements of this section. This item is approved as to form and legality. An affirmative vote of four is required for approval because this is an Adoption hearing of the GMP amendment. [HFAC] STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION: That the CCPC forward petition PL20180002621/CPSS-2019-4 to the Board with a recommendation to approve for adoption and transmit to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC heard this petition at their March 5, 2020 meeting and voted [4/1 - Chairman Strain dissenting] to forward petition PL20180002621/CPSS-2019-4 to the Board with a recommendation to approve for adoption and transmit to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity. More than forty public speakers addressed the Commission, with presentations both for and against the proposal. Reasons offered by Planning Commissioners for not approving this petition ranged from establishing a Subdistrict that allows a project as a regional attraction in scale and not the size or in character with its surrounding neighborhood, establishing a Subdistrict at this location will be setting a precedent for other similar Subdistricts for projects to be constructed in other locations of the County within residential neighborhoods, to unresolved traffic issues. RECOMMENDATION: To adopt and transmit petition PL20180002621/CPSS-2019-4 to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity. Prepared by: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner, Comprehensive Planning Section, Zoning Division ATTACHMENT(S) 1. CCPC Staff Rpt CPSS-2019-4 (PDF) Packet Pg. 35 9.A 12/08/2020 2. Adoption Ordinance - 060320 (PDF) 3. [Linked] Application-Petition_PL20180002621 (PDF) 4. Ashton Ltr (PDF) 5. BCC Affidavit & Advertisementl (PDF) 6. legal ad - agenda IDs 13658 & 13740 (PDF) Packet Pg. 36 9.A 12/08/2020 COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 9.A Doc ID: 13740 Item Summary: ***This item has been continued from the June 23, 2020 and October 27, 2020 BCC Meetings. *** Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance No. 89-05, as amended, the Collier County Growth Management Plan for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, specifically amending the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -Element of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Element and Urban Golden Gate Estates Future Land Use Map and Map Series by amending the Estates Mixed -Use District to add the Naples Senior Center community facility subdistrict to allow construction of up to 30,000 square feet of community facility uses for family social service programs and activities for seniors aged 60 and over. The subject property is located on the southeast corner of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane, approximately 350 feet south of Immokalee Road, in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, consisting of 8.7f acres; and furthermore, recommending transmittal of the adopted amendment to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity; providing for severability and providing for an effective date. [PL20180002622] (This is a companion to Agenda Item 9.A) Meeting Date: 12/08/2020 Prepared by: Title: Operations Analyst — Planning Commission Name: Diane Lynch 09/30/2020 5:01 PM Submitted by: Title: Manager - Planning — Zoning Name: Ray Bellows 09/30/2020 5:01 PM Approved By: Review: Growth Management Department Diane Lynch Zoning Diane Lynch County Attorney's Office Diane Lynch Growth Management Department Diane Lynch Growth Management Department Diane Lynch Office of Management and Budget Diane Lynch County Attorney's Office Diane Lynch Office of Management and Budget Diane Lynch County Manager's Office Diane Lynch Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Level 1 Reviewer Additional Reviewer Level 2 Attorney of Record Review Deputy Department Head Review Department Head Review Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Additional Reviewer Level 4 County Manager Review Meeting Pending Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM Skipped 09/30/2020 4:59 PM 12/08/2020 9:00 AM Packet Pg. 37 Agenda item 9. 9.A.1 C:�o e-V 4z;o141P1ty STAFF REPORT COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT, COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING SECTION HEARING DATE: March 5, 2020 ZONING DIVISION, RE: PETITION PL20180002621/CPSS-2019-4, SMALL SCALE GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN AMENDMENT (Companion to petition PUDZ- PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center Community Facility PUD) [ADOPTION HEARING] AGENT/APPLICANT/OWNER Agents: D. Wayne Arnold, AICP Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A 3800 Via Del Rey Bonita Springs, FL 34134 Applicant: Dr. Jaclynn Faffer Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. 5025 Castello Drive, Suite 101 Naples, FL 34103 John M. Passidomo Cheffy Passidomo, P.A. 821 5th Avenue South Naples, FL 34102 Owners: Sharon A. Winkler, individually and as trustee of the John H. Winkler trust agreement dated 2/28/07 and individually and as trustee of the Sharon A. Winkler trust agreement dated 2/5/07; Peggy M. White and Lowell E. White, both individually and as trustees of the Ralph L. Griffin Family Trust dated 9/11/96. GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The subject property, comprising ±8.7 acres, is located at the southeast corner of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane, and the southwest corner of Valewood Drive and Autumn Oakes Lane, approximately ±350 feet south of Immokalee Road (CR 846), in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, within the Urban Estates Planning Community. (see subject site on following page, highlighted in yellow) [Remainder of page intentionally left blank] Packet Pg. 38 9.A.1 Agenda item 9. REQUESTED ACTION: The applicant proposes a small-scale Growth Management Plan amendment to the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -Element (UGGE) text and Future Land Use Map of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP), specifically to establish the new Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict, affecting fewer than ten (10) acres, by: 1) Amending Policy 1.1.4A. Estates Designation, Estates Mixed Use District, to add the Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict; 2) Amending the Estates Mixed Use District to add the new Subdistrict provisions; 3) Amending the UGGE Future Land Use Map Series listing to add the title of the new Subdistrict map; and 4) Amending the UGGE Future Land Use Map to depict the new Subdistrict and adding a new Future Land Use Map Series inset map that depicts the new Subdistrict. The proposed amended/added text and maps are depicted on Ordinance Exhibit A's. PURPOSE/DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: The petitioner is requesting this change to allow development of the site with a maximum of 30,000 square feet of floor area of community facility uses (variety of family social service programs and activities) for seniors age 60 and over and their caregivers. As stated in the proposed subdistrict, "Services may include but are not limited to classes and programs for learning, exercise, employment and financial assistance, grief counseling, emotional support, and respite support and other similar services related to providing assistance for seniors." Aside from the building square feet limitation, the subdistrict provides that building height is limited to two habitable stories, neither residential uses nor overnight activities are permitted, and the site must be rezoned to a Planned Unit Development (PUD) to permit the uses in this subdistrict (there is a companion PUD rezone petition PL20180002622). Packet Pg. 39 9.A.1 Agenda item 9. SURROUNDING LAND USE, ZONING AND FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION: Subject Property: The subject ±8.7-acre site is comprised of three tax parcels oriented north to south: a 5.15-acre parcel at the southeast corner of Oakes Blvd. and Autumn Oaks Lane; then a 2.34-acre parcel to the south; then a 1.17-acre parcel further south. The 5.15-acre parcel contains a one-story, 2,240 square feet storage/warehouse building permitted in 1973 with an addition permitted in 1978 (staff characterizes the +40-year-old building as an eyesore — dirty, worn roof tiles, broken windows); the area around the building is cleared and sodded but contains no definitive parking area or noticeable water management facility; the southerly ±2/3 of the parcel is wooded. The two smaller parcels are both undeveloped and wooded. The entire site is zoned E, Estates; and, it is designated Estates Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict. Surrounding Lands: North: Across Autumn Oaks Lane, a two-lane undivided local street, an undeveloped 2.58-acre parcel that previously contained a model home; a 0.26-acre parcel containing a telephone switching station; and a 2.25-acre parcel containing a church. All three parcels are zoned "E" and designated Estates Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict. Also, to the north is Valewood Drive connecting Autumn Oaks Lane to Immokalee Road at a signalized intersection. The church parcel is identified in the GGAMP as an exception to the conditional use locational criteria. All three parcels front on Immokalee Road. To the northwest, across Oakes Blvd. and Autumn Oaks Lane, is an undeveloped parcel owned by the church located on the next parcel to the west. To the northeast, across Autumn Oaks Lane, is a water retention pond associated with Immokalee Road, owned by Collier County; then, two undeveloped and wooded parcels zoned Southbrooke Commercial PUD and designated Southbrooke Office Subdistrict, permitting 40,000 square feet of uses in the C-1, Commercial Professional and General Office zoning district. East: An undeveloped and wooded 5-acre parcel. The site is zoned "E" and designated Estates Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict. This parcel is included in the companion PUD rezone petition but is excluded from the subject GMP amendment petition; no GMP amendment is needed as the proposed uses in the PUD (preserve and open space) are consistent with the Residential Estates Subdistrict. Further east are single family dwellings. South: A 2,400 square feet motorcycle and ATV repair facility with parts sales on 1.64 acres (permitted in 1974). The site is zoned "E" and designated Estates Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict. The use is a legal nonconforming use. To the southwest, across Oakes Blvd., are single family dwellings. To the southeast are single family dwellings. West: Across Oakes Blvd., a single family dwelling on 2.59 acres, a single family dwelling on 2.27 acres, and an undeveloped and wooded 2.27-acre parcel. All three parcels are zoned "E" and designated Estates Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict. Identification and Analysis of the Pertinent Small -Scale Comprehensive Plan (GMP) Amendment Criteria in Florida Statutes, Chapter 163.3187: Requirements to qualify as a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment, followed by staff analysis in bracketed bold text. (1) A small scale development amendment may be adopted under the following conditions: (a) The proposed amendment involves a use of 10 acres or fewer. [The proposed amendment pertains to a ±8.7-acre site.] Packet Pg. 40 9.A.1 Agenda item 9. (b) The proposed amendment does not involve a text change to the goals, policies, and objectives of the local government's comprehensive plan, but only proposes a land use change to the future land use map for a site -specific small scale development activity. However, text changes that relate directly to, and are adopted simultaneously with, the small scale future land use map amendment shall be permissible under this section. [This amendment is for a site -specific Future Land Use Map change and directly related text change.] (c) The property that is the subject of the proposed amendment is not located within an area of critical state concern, unless the project subject to the proposed amendment involves the construction of affordable housing units meeting the criteria of s. 420.0004(3), and is located within an area of critical state concern designated by s. 380.0552 or by the Administration Commission pursuant to s. 380.05(1). [The subject property is not within an Area of Critical State Concern.] (4) Comprehensive plans may only be amended in such a way as to preserve the internal consistency of the plan pursuant to s. 163.3177. [Internal consistency will be maintained if the GMP amendment is approved.] BACKGROUND AND ANALYSIS: Golden Gate Estates Units 96 and 97 (±2 square miles) encompass all of Golden Gate Estates between Immokalee Road and Vanderbilt Beach Road, and west of Logan Blvd. (see below left map with subject site in yellow highlight). A zoning map from the mid-1970s shows all parcels abutting Oakes Blvd. as zoned C-3, a commercial zoning district, as well as all parcels fronting Immokalee Road (not the same as the present C-3, Commercial Intermediate, zoning district). It was in the 1970s that building permits were issued for the storage/warehouse building in existence on the northerly portion of the subject site as well as the motorcycle and ATV repair shop adjacent to the south of the subject site. The entire Oakes Blvd. and Immokalee Road corridors were downzoned from C-3 to the E, Estates zoning district when Collier County adopted a countywide zoning ordinance in 1982. This resulted in both commercial developments becoming non -conforming uses. R MINE I ERNMR111e1 I milli-foliii® 11s®®N, V 4 r UK E _ - � ,L — Subsequent to 1982, conditional uses (CU) for a fire station and four churches have been approved along Immokalee Road; a CU for a church has been approved on Oakes Blvd.; and, a CU for a church has been approved just west of Oakes Blvd. - all of which have been constructed and are in use. In 2015, the County adopted a GMP amendment and PUD rezone to establish the Southbrooke Packet Pg. 41 9.A.1 Agenda item 9. Commercial Subdistrict and Southbrooke Commercial PUD which permits 40,000 square feet of uses in the C-1, Commercial Professional and General Office zoning district; this property remains undeveloped. (the right -side map on preceding page shows the church CUs in yellow highlight and the Southbrook PUD in blue scribble) Also, Immokalee Road has been widened in this area to a six - lane divided roadway; Oakes Blvd. has become right -in, right -out only at the Immokalee Road intersection; Valewood Drive has been extended south from Immokalee Road to Autumn Oaks Lane; and, Vanderbilt Beach Road has been constructed and eventually widened in this area to a six -lane divided roadway. It appears that the developed portion of the subject site is rarely used. It is a nonconforming use but may or may not retain its status as a legal nonconforming use. Golden Gate Area Master Plan Restudy This Restudy was conducted at a high level, viewing large areas and major issues, not a parcel by parcel review. The Restudy -based GMP amendments were adopted in 2019 and did not change the future land use designation of any properties in Golden Gate Estates Unit 96 and 97. Of the three parcels comprising the subject site, the middle parcel is eligible (meets the locational criteria) for an Estates zoning district conditional use based upon the transitional conditional use provision. The southerly parcel, 75 feet wide and abutting the motorcycle sales and repair shop, is not eligible. The northerly parcel, containing the nonconforming commercial use, may be eligible under the Land Development Code's non -forming use change petition to convert the existing building to another similar or less intense use. However, staff questions whether this would be financially feasible, both because of the needed building repairs and site improvements and the relatively small size of the building (2,240 s.f.) in context of the parcel size of 5.15 acres. The subject site is proposed to be developed with a 30,000 square feet facility providing social service programs and activities for seniors >60 years old and their caregivers. Some of these services and programs are commonly provided by churches, e.g. grief counseling, emotional support, indoor games and recreation. Similarly, social and fraternal organizations also provide some of these uses though not necessarily with a focus towards seniors and their caregivers. Both of these uses (church, social and fraternal organization) are permitted as conditional uses in the "E" zoning district, subject to compliance with locational criteria in the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub - Element of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan. These two uses are permitted by right in the CF, Community Facility, zoning district. Though these uses are also permitted in some commercial zoning districts, they are also permitted conditional uses in residential zoning districts; they are considered institutional uses and community facility uses, not commercial uses, though they may exhibit some commercial characteristics. The CF district states, in part, "These uses can be characterized as public facilities, institutional uses, open space uses, water -related or dependent uses, and other such uses generally serving the public at large." CF uses permitted by right include: child care centers; churches; civic and cultural facilities; assisted living facilities (ALF); parks and open space uses; educational facilities (private and parochial schools, colleges and universities); libraries. CF uses permitted by conditional use include: community centers; private clubs; public swimming pools; tennis facilities. The proposed uses have similar characteristics as some combination of these CF uses: child care center (which has been interpreted to include adult day care); civic and cultural facilities; ALF (the recreational and social aspects); educational facilities; community centers; and, private clubs. Site comparisons EXISTING PROPOSED Property Size 0.81 acres 8.7 acres PUD 13.7 acres Building Size 14,008 square feet 2 story) 30,000 s.f. 2-storymaximum FLUM Designation Urban Residential Subdistrict Residential Estates Subdistrict Packet Pg. 42 9.A.1 Agenda item 9. The submitted data and analysis includes the "Needs Assessment of Seniors: Trends from 2012 to Present." Staff notes the following from that Assessment: • The 2015 Collier County population for age >60 was 122,019 [35%]. • Population projections for age >60 in Collier County in year 2040 reflect a 49.4% or 74.7% increase from 2015, depending upon the source; for age >75, the projected increase is 116.9%. • The average age of active members at Naples Senior Center is 78.1. • Naples is the place of residence for 89.9% of active members. Based on the large geographical area served and various locational data within the Assessment (population age ±60, population below poverty level age ±60, households with at least one person age ±60 that is a SNAP (federal food assistance) recipient, population living alone age ±65), staff finds that the proposed Naples Senior Center location may be considered centrally located (as may the existing site). In staff's opinion, the statutory requirements for a GMP amendment, provided on the next three pages, can be summarized as: 1) whether there is a demonstrated need for the land use change/the use(s) proposed; and 2) whether this is the appropriate location to fulfill that need. Staff concurs with the petitioner that the submitted data and analysis does reasonably demonstrate that there is a need. As to the appropriateness of location, staff has identified no infrastructure impacts that result in a lowering of the adopted level of service standard for any affected public infrastructure and has identified no natural or cultural resource impact concerns. The subject site is located reasonably proximate to the persons it will serve and has ready access to an arterial road (Immokalee Road) and I-75 which is beneficial given the broad area being served. Based upon the off-peak time and low volume traffic impacts, the project location near (one street removed from) the edge of the 2-square mile neighborhood, development pattern of the surrounding area — including other institutional uses and large lot/low density residential development, subject property size, maximum building size and height proposed, operational restrictions proposed (no residential or overnight activities permitted), and the characteristics of the uses and activities proposed — including that activities will primarily be indoors, staff is of the opinion that the proposed uses will be generally compatible with the surrounding area (at the high level at which GMP amendments are reviewed for compatibility) and that this is an appropriate location to provide the needed uses. The specific compatibility review is deferred to Zoning Services Section staff as part of the detailed review of the companion PUD rezone petition where specific compatibility measures are appropriately considered. However, Comprehensive Planning staff notes that the PUD: development standards table meets the "E" front yard setback requirement (from Oakes Blvd. and Autumn Oaks Lane) and far exceeds the side yard setback requirement (from eastern and southern boundaries); master plan far exceeds open space requirements; master plan depicts the Senior Center building and parking lot centrally located on the development portion of the site (the three parcels abutting Oakes Blvd.); and, master plan depicts the entire eastern tract (5 acres) as open space and preserve. Site visit to existing Naples Senior Center On Friday, February 14, 2020, staff (author of this Report) made an unannounced visit to the existing Naples Senior Center located on Castello Drive for a period of 40 minutes (11:50 a.m. until 12:30 p.m.). Staff provided an impromptu tour that included: an explanation and demonstration of the electronic registration system (each active member has a name tag with a bar code, registers upon arrival, and pre -registers for future programs and activities); observation of various activities including "chair yoga," card games, tables and chairs set-up for the next activity, and a "word game" activity in a separate room for about ten or so persons with dementia; observation of artwork painted by members, and potted plants prepared by members. All members observed during the visit Packet Pg. 43 9.A.1 Agenda item 9. (estimated 50 or so) appeared to be well over the Center's minimum age of 60 years old. All activities occurred indoors; noise was minimal and the conversation between County and Center staff was at normal conversation level. Upon arrival and departure, the parking lot appeared to be at or over capacity (valet service was provided). [It is acknowledged that this visit was not during the weekly peak time which is, per the petition materials, including the traffic impact study, during the lunchtime on Wednesdays.] Criteria for GMP Amendments in Florida Statutes Data and analysis requirements for comprehensive plans and plan amendments are noted in Chapter 163, F.S., specifically as listed below. Section 163.3177(1)(f), Florida Statutes: (f) All mandatory and optional elements of the comprehensive plan and plan amendments shall be based upon relevant and appropriate data and an analysis by the local government that may include, but not be limited to, surveys, studies, community goals and vision, and other data available at the time of adoption of the comprehensive plan or plan amendment. To be based on data means to react to it in an appropriate way and to the extent necessary indicated by the data available on that particular subject at the time of adoption of the plan or plan amendment at issue. 1. Surveys, studies, and data utilized in the preparation of the comprehensive plan may not be deemed a part of the comprehensive plan unless adopted as a part of it. Copies of such studies, surveys, data, and supporting documents for proposed plans and plan amendments shall be made available for public inspection, and copies of such plans shall be made available to the public upon payment of reasonable charges for reproduction. Support data or summaries are not subject to the compliance review process, but the comprehensive plan must be clearly based on appropriate data. Support data or summaries may be used to aid in the determination of compliance and consistency. 2. Data must be taken from professionally accepted sources. The application of a methodology utilized in data collection or whether a particular methodology is professionally accepted may be evaluated. However, the evaluation may not include whether one accepted methodology is better than another. Original data collection by local governments is not required. However, local governments may use original data so long as methodologies are professionally accepted. 3. The comprehensive plan shall be based upon permanent and seasonal population estimates and projections, which shall either be those published by the Office of Economic and Demographic Research or generated by the local government based upon a professionally acceptable methodology. The plan must be based on at least the minimum amount of land required to accommodate the medium projections as published by the Office of Economic and Demographic Research for at least a 10-year planning period unless otherwise limited under s. 380.05, including related rules of the Administration Commission. Absent physical limitations on population growth, population projections for each municipality, and the unincorporated area within a county must, at a minimum, be reflective of each area's proportional share of the total county population and the total county population growth. Section 163.3177(6)(a)2.: 2. The future land use plan and plan amendments shall be based upon surveys, studies, and data regarding the area, as applicable, including: [emphasis added] a. The amount of land required to accommodate anticipated growth. b. The projected permanent and seasonal population of the area. c. The character of undeveloped land. d. The availability of water supplies, public facilities, and services. e. The need for redevelopment, including the renewal of blighted areas and the elimination of nonconforming uses which are inconsistent with the character of the community. f. The compatibility of uses on lands adjacent to or closely proximate to military installations. g. The compatibility of uses on lands adjacent to an airport as defined in s. 330.35 and consistent with s. 333.02. Packet Pg. 44 9.A.1 Agenda item 9. h. The discouragement of urban sprawl. i. The need for job creation, capital investment, and economic development that will strengthen and diversify the community's economy. j. The need to modify land uses and development patterns within antiquated subdivisions. Section 163.3177(6)(a)8., Florida Statutes: (a) A future land use plan element designating proposed future general distribution, location, and extent of the uses of land for residential uses, commercial uses, industry, agriculture, recreation, conservation, education, public facilities, and other categories of the public and private uses of land. The approximate acreage and the general range of density or intensity of use shall be provided for the gross land area included in each existing land use category. The element shall establish the long-term end toward which land use programs and activities are ultimately directed. 8. Future land use map amendments shall be based upon the following analyses: a. An analysis of the availability of facilities and services. b. An analysis of the suitability of the plan amendment for its proposed use considering the character of the undeveloped land, soils, topography, natural resources, and historic resources on site. c. An analysis of the minimum amount of land needed to achieve the goals and requirements of this section. Also, the state land planning agency has historically recognized the consideration of community desires (e.g. if the community has an articulated vision for an area as to the type of development desired, such as within a Community Redevelopment Area), and existing incompatibilities (e.g. presently allowed uses would be incompatible with surrounding uses and conditions). NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM) NOTES: A Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) required by LDC Section 10.03.05 F was held on September 25, 2019, 5:30 p.m. at Hodges University, located at 2647 Professional Circle, Naples, FL 34119. This NIM was advertised, noticed and held jointly for this small scale GMP amendment petition and companion PUD rezone petition. The applicant team gave a presentation and responded to questions and comments. Eighteen members of the public spoke; beyond asking questions/seeking more information, two spoke in favor and sixteen persons expressed concerns and/or opposition. See comments summary further below. A total of approximately 100 members of the public attended the NIM, in addition to the applicant's team and County staff. The NIM minutes or notes, prepared by the applicant team, are included with the companion PUD rezone petition. The meeting was ended at approximately 7:30 pm. A second NIM was held on January 27, 2020, 5:30 p.m. at same location as the first. This NIM was advertised, noticed and held jointly for this small scale GMP amendment petition and companion PUD rezone petition. The applicant team gave a presentation, noted this 2"d NIM was due to changes in the traffic impact study, and responded to questions and comments. Fifteen members of the public spoke; beyond asking questions/seeking more information, two spoke in favor and thirteen persons expressed concerns and/or opposition. The meeting was ended at approximately 7:15 p.m. Comments summary for both NIMs combined: Supportive/positive comments included: this is a good project; the petitioner does good work in the Naples community and provides needed services; the use will displace the run-down building and rusty chain link fence on the property. Packet Pg. 45 Agenda item 9. 9.A.1 Concerns and opposing comments included: increased traffic on Oakes Blvd., Autumn Oaks Lane and Valewood Drive; increased traffic will cause a back-up on Valewood Drive at the Valewood Drive/Immokalee Road traffic signal, which has a short cycle for Valewood Drive, increasing the difficulty of residents attempting to exit the neighborhood to drive west on Immokalee Road; this is a commercial use and belongs in a commercial or industrial area; this use is intrusive into, and is incompatible with, a residential neighborhood; negative impact upon the rural character of the neighborhood; the use is an improper entrance feature to the neighborhood; commercial creep — if this use is approved others will follow; negative impact on property values in the area; if the use is approved, there will be future amendments to expand the use and/or modify or remove limitations e.g. hours of operation, building square feet; visibility of the building and/or lights by nearby residents; there are discrepancies between some statements made at NIM versus information on the petitioner's website. [synopsis prepared by David Weeks, AICP, Growth Management Manager] FINDING AND CONCLUSIONS: • There is a demonstrated need for the proposed uses. • The subject site is reasonably central to the geographical area of the population served and has ready access to 1-75 which may be beneficial to members residing farther from the site. • The site is an appropriate location for the proposed uses. • The demographics of the population served are projected to increase in actual numbers and percent of total population. • The two square mile area of Golden Gate Estates in which the subject site is located is limited to large -lot single family dwelling units exceptfor the previously approved fire station and six churches (all by conditional use), a County storm water treatment pond, the undeveloped Southbrooke Commercial PUD, the nonconforming commercial use adjacent to the south of the subject site, and the nonconforming commercial use on a portion of the subject site. • The proposed uses are considered community facility uses and institutional uses, not commercial uses. • There are no infrastructure impacts related concerns. • The submitted traffic impact study shows almost all site -related traffic occurs during non -peak hours. • There are no unacceptable adverse impacts to environmental resources and no evidence of cultural resources on the site. • The proposed use is generally compatible with the surrounding area based upon the macro level at which GMP amendments are reviewed. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This Staff Report was reviewed by the County Attorney's Office. The criteria for GMP amendments to the Future Land Use Element and map series are in Sections 163.3177(1)(f) and 163.3177(6)(a)2 and 163.3177(6)(a)8, Florida Statutes. [HFAC] STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission forward Petition PL20180002621/CPSS-2019-4 to the Board of County Commissioners with a recommendation to approve for adoption and transmittal to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity. [Remainder of page intentionally left blank] Packet Pg. 46 Agenda item 9. 9.A.1 PREPARED BY - DATE: UAVCD WEEKS. All CP. GROWTH MANAGEMENT MAN AGE R DATE: ES FRENCH. DEPLiTY b EPARTMENT HEAP GROWTH MANAGEMENT' DEPARTMENT Petition Number: PL2018000262VCPSS-2419-4 Staff Report for March 5. 2020 CC PC meeting Agenda item 4.A, NOTE This petitron has been tentatively scheduled for the April 14. 2020 6GC meeting CCPC Staff Rpt CPSS-2019-4 G:\CDES Planning Services\Comprehensive\Comp Planning GMP DATA\Comp Plan Amendments\2019 Cycles and Smalls\2019 Small Scale petitions\CPSS-19-4 Naples Senior Center\CCPC dw/2-19-20 10 Packet Pg. 47 9.A.2 ORDINANCE NO. 2020- AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 89-05, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES SUB -ELEMENT OF THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN ELEMENT AND URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES BY AMENDING THE ESTATES MIXED -USE DISTRICT TO ADD THE NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF UP TO 30,000 SQUARE FEET OF COMMUNITY FACILITY USES FOR FAMILY SOCIAL SERVICE PROGRAMS AND ACTIVITIES FOR SENIORS AGED 60 AND OVER. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF OAKES BOULEVARD AND AUTUMN OAKS LANE, APPROXIMATELY 350 FEET SOUTH OF IMMOKALEE ROAD, IN SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, CONSISTING OF 8.7f ACRES; AND FURTHERMORE, RECOMMENDING TRANSMITTAL OF THE ADOPTED AMENDMENT TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. [PL20180002621] WHEREAS, Collier County, pursuant to Section 163.3161, et. seq., Florida Statutes, the Florida Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act, was required to prepare and adopt a comprehensive plan; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners adopted the Collier County Growth Management Plan on January 10, 1989; and WHEREAS, the Community Planning Act of 2011 provides authority for local governments to amend their respective comprehensive plans and outlines certain procedures to amend adopted comprehensive plans; and WHEREAS, Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. requested an amendment to the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -Element of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Element and Urban Golden Gate Estates Future Land Use Map and Map Series to create the Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Subsection 163.3187(1), Florida Statutes, this amendment is considered a Small Scale Amendment; and [19-CMP-01053/1545347/11105 PL20180002621— Naples Senior Center SSGMPA 6/3/20 1 of 3 Words underlined are added, words struck through have been deleted. Packet Pg. 48 9.A.2 WHEREAS, the Subdistrict property is not located in an area of critical state concern or a rural area of opportunity; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPQ on March 5, 2020 considered the proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan and recommended approval of said amendment to the Board of County Commissioners; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County did take action in the manner prescribed by law and held public hearings concerning the proposed adoption of the amendment to the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -Element of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Element and Urban Golden Gate Estates Future Land Use Map and Map Series of the Growth Management Plan on ; and WHEREAS, all applicable substantive and procedural requirements of law have been met. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: SECTION ONE: ADOPTION OF AMENDMENT TO THE GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN The Board of County Commissioners hereby adopts this small scale amendment to the Urban Golden Gate Estates Sub -Element of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Element and Urban Golden Gate Estates Future Land Use Map and Map Series in accordance with Section 163.3184, Florida Statutes. The text amendment is attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by reference. SECTION TWO: SEVERABILITY. If any phrase or portion of this Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion. SECTION THREE: EFFECTIVE DATE. The effective date of this plan amendment, if the amendment is not timely challenged, shall be 31 days after the state land planning agency notifies the local government that the plan amendment package is complete. If timely challenged, this amendment shall become effective on the date the state land planning agency or the Administration Commission enters a final order determining this adopted amendment to be in compliance. No development orders, development permits, or land uses dependent on this amendment may be issued or commence before it has become effective. If a final order of noncompliance is issued by the Administration Commission, this amendment may nevertheless be made effective by adoption of a resolution [19-CMP-01053/1545347/11105 2 of 3 PL20180002621— Naples Senior Center SSGMPA 6/3/20 Words underlined are added, words stme'� have been deleted. Packet Pg. 49 9.A.2 affirming its effective status, a copy of which resolution shall be sent to the state land planning agency. PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida this day of , 2020. ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BY: Deputy Clerk Burt L. Saunders, Chairman Approved as to form and legality: Heidi Ashton-Cicko, Managing Assistant County Attorney HFAC 6-3-20 Attachment: Exhibit A — Proposed Text Amendment & Map Amendment [19-CMP-01053/1545347/11105 PL20180002621— Naples Senior Center SSGMPA 6/3/20 3 of 3 Words underlined are added, words struck through have been deleted. Packet Pg. 50 9.A.2 EXHIBIT A GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES SUB -ELEMENT *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** TABLE OF CONTENTS *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** A. Goals, Objectives and Policies B. Land Use Designation Description Section *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** C. List of Maps Urban Golden Gate Estates Future Land Use Map *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** Special Exceptions to Conditional Use in Golden Gate Estates Naples Senior Center Communi . Facility Subdistrict *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** A. GOALS, OJECTIVES AND POLICIES *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** GOAL 1: *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** OBJECTIVE 1.1: *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** Policy 1.1.4: The ESTATES Future Land Use Designation shall include Future Land Use Districts and Subdistricts for: A. ESTATES - MIXED USE DISTRICT 1. Residential Estates Subdistrict 2. Neighborhood Center Subdistrict 3. Conditional Uses Subdistrict 4. Golden Gate Parkway Institutional Subdistrict 5. Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict Q Page 1 of 4 Packet Pg. 51 9.A.2 *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** B. LAND USE DESIGNATION DESCRIPTION SECTION *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** 1. ESTATES DESIGNATION *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** A. Estates — Mixed Use District *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** 5. Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict The subdistrict consists of 8. 7+/- acres and is located at the southeast corner of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane. The purpose of the sub -district is to provide for a variety of family social service programs and activities for seniors aged 60 and over and their caregivers. Services may include but are not limited to classes and programs for learning, exercise, employment and financial assistance, grief counseling, emotional support, and respite support and other similar services related to providing assistance for seniors. Development within the Subdistrict shall be subject to the following: a. The Subdistrict shall be rezoned to a Planned Unit Development (PUD). which shall specify permitted uses. b. The maximum square footage permitted within the subdistrict is 30,000 square feet of floor area. c. No building within this subdistrict may exceed two habitable stories in height. d. No residential uses or overnight activities shall be permitted within this subdistrict. e. The PUD ordinance shall include development standards, buffers, etc. to insure compatibility with surrounding properties. *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** C. LIST OF MAPS Urban Golden Gate Estates Future Land Use Map *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** Special Exceptions to Conditional Use Locational Criteria in Golden Gate Estates Naples Senior Center Communi . Facility Subdistrict a Exbibit A text GACDES Planning Services\Comprehensive\Comp Planning GMP DATA\Comp Plan Amendments\2019 Cycles and Smalls\2019 Small Scale petitions\CPSS-194 Naples Senior Center\Exhbt A text & maps dw/12-17-19 Page 2 of 4 Packet Pg. 52 EXHIBIT A PL20180002621/CPS NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ADOPTED - XXXX,XXXX (Ord. No. XXXX-X) 0 250 500 1,000 Feet PREPARED BY: BETH YANG, AICP GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPT. FILE: NAPLES SENIOR CENTER SITE LOCATION MAP DRAFTMXD DATE: FEB. 2020 LEGEND ®NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT Packet Pg. 53 1 U) ti U) 00 U) U) 0 L0 m LO EXHIBIT "All PETITION PL20180002621 / CPSS-2019-4 Page 4 of 4 9.A.2 Packet Pg. 54 9.A.4 EDWARD K. CHEFFY Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer Board Certified Business Litigation Lawyer JOHN M. PASSIDOMO Board Certified Real Estate Lawyer LOUIS D. D'AGOSTINO Board Certified Appellate Practice Lawyer DAVID A. ZULIAN Board Certified Construction Lawyer CLAY C. BROOKER Board Certified City, County and Local Government Lawyer Heidi Ashton-Cicko, Esquire CHEFFY PASSIDOMO ATTORNEYS AT LAW 821 Fifth Avenue South Naples, Florida 34102 Telephone: (239) 261-9300 www.napieslaw.com Managing Assistant County Attorney Office of the Collier County Attorney 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Suite 301 Naples, Florida 34104 WILLIAM J. DEMPSEY Board Certified Real Estate Lawyer DEBBIE SINES CROCKETT RACHAELS.LOUKONEN Board Certified Business Litigation Lawyer BRIAN J. THANASIU Board Certified Real Estate Lawyer KIMBERLY D. SWANSON Of Counsel: GEORGE L. VARNADOE DIRECT DIAL: (239) 436-1529 amnassidomo o napleslaw.corn May 27, 2020 VIA F..-MAIL: heidi.ashton a)colliercotmtyil.gov Re: Naples Senior Center (PUDZ) PL20180002622 and Naples Senior Center (GMPA) PL20180002621 Dear Ms. ton-C�-[t We represent Naples Senior Center in the captioned matter. The Naples Senior Center elects to proceed with a hybrid virtual public hearing of the Board of County Commissioners during the declared emergency and waives its right to contest any procedural irregularity due to the hybrid virtual nature of the public hearing. Very tru you Pars, John M ssidomo Chefs � Passidomo, P.A. JMP/tpp cc: Dr. Jaclynn Faffer Mr. Timothy Finn Richard D. Yovanovich, Esquire [11329-0003/3479002/1] Packet Pg. 55 9.A.5 Naptr.q 4#r ai - N-jalls. PART OF THE USA TODAY NETWORK Published Daily Naples, FL 34110 BCC ZONING DEPT 3299 TAMIAMI TRAIL E SUITE 401 NAPLES FL 34112 Affidavit of Publication STATE OF WISCONSIN COUNTY OF BROWN Before the undersigned they serve as the authority, personally appeared Joe Heynen who on oath says that he serves as legal clerk of the Naples Daily News, a daily newspaper published at Naples, in Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida; that the attached copy of the advertising was published in said newspaper on dates listed. Affiant further says that the said Naples Daily News is a newspaper published at Naples, in said Collier County, Florida, and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida, each day and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Naples, in said Collier County, Florida , for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement and aftiant further says that he has neither paid nor promised any person, or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. 6/3/2020 Subscribed and sworn to before on June 3, 2020: _. - . .f)u_.Yvt_ uv1 cl 1.r>-L, ) Notary, State of WI, County of Brown TARAAMMONDLOCH Notary Puhlir State of Wisconsin My commission expires: August 6, 2021 Publication Cost: $1.008.00 Ad No GC10427933 Customer No: 505868 PO4:PL20180002621 & PL20180002622 Packet Pg. 56 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER ORDINANCE(S) Notice is hereby given that the Collier County Board of County Commissioners will hold a public hearing on June 23, 2020, commencing at 9:00 a.m., in the Beard of County Commissioners Chamber, Third Floor, Collier County Government Center, 3299 Tamiami Trail E., Naples, FL. The purpose of the hearing is to consider: AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 89-05, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES SUB -ELEMENT OF THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN ELEMENT AND URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES BY AMENDING THE ESTATES MIXED -USE DISTRICT TO ADD THE NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF UP TO 30,000 SQUARE FEET OF COMMUNITY FACILITY USES FOR FAMILY SOCIAL SERVICE PROGRAMS AND ACTIVITIES FOR SENIORS AGED 60 AND OVER. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF OAKES BOULEVARD AND AUTUMN OAKS LANE, APPROXIMATELY 350 FEET SOUTH OF IMMOKALEE ROAD, IN SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, CONSISTING OF 8.7x ACRES; AND FURTHERMORE, RECOMMENDING TRANSMITTAL OF THE ADOPTED AMENDMENT TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. [PL20180002621] AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 2004-41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH ESTABLISHED THE COMPREHENSIVE ZONING REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, BY AMENDING THE APPROPRIATE ZONING ATLAS MAP OR MAPS BY CHANGING THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED REAL PROPERTY FROM AN ESTATES (E) ZONING DISTRICT TO A COMMUNITY FACILITY PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT (CFPUD) ZONING DISTRICT FOR THE PROJECT TO BE KNOWN AS NAPLES SENIOR CENTER CFPUD, TO ALLOW UP TO 30,000 SQUARE FEET OF INDIVIDUAL AND FAMILY SOCIAL SERVICES (SIC 8322) FOR SENIORS 60 AND OLDER, INCLUDING ACTIVITY CENTERS FOR THE ELDERLY, ADULT DAY CARE CENTERS, COMMUNITY CENTERS FOR SENIOR CITIZENS, SENIOR CITIZEN ASSOCIATIONS, FAMILY COUNSELING, OLD AGE ASSISTANCE, AND OUTREACH PROGRAMS AND FOR GROUP SUPPORT SERVICES FOR THE ELDERLY ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF OAKES BOULEVARD AND AUTUMN OAKS LANE, APPROXIMATELY 350 FEET SOUTH OF IMMOKALEE ROAD, IN SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, CONSISTING OF 13.6+ ACRES; AND BY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. [PL20180002622] GMPA Immokalee RD PL20182621 Eil j Autumn Oaks LN 0 0 CD J Sri m ro p PUDZ PL20182622 All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ORDINANCE(S) will be made available for inspection at the GMD Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section, 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, FL., between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 PM., Monday through Friday. Furthermore, the materials will be made available for inspection at the Collier County Clerk's Office, Fourth Floor, Suite 401, Collier County Government Center, East Naples, one week prior to the scheduled hearing, Any questions pertaining to the documents should be directed to the GMD Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section, Written comments filed with the Clerk to the Board's Office prior to June 23, 2020 will be read and considered at the public hearing, As part of an ongoing initiative to promote social distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic, the public will have the opportunity to provide public comments remotely, as well as in person, during this proceeding. Individuals who would like to participate remotely, should register any time after the agenda is posted on the County website which is 6 days before the meeting through the link provided on the front page of the County website at ywww,,F,011i§tfxW1tyt(,9gy. Individuals who register will receive an email in advance of the public hearing detailing how they can participate remotely in this meeting. For additional information about the meeting, please call Geoffrey Willig at 252-8369 or email to Ge41(tey l(4illl9'cotlltl courttyQ,gOX. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Board of County Commissioners will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore. may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based, It you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 101, Naples, FL 34112-5356, (239) 252-8380, at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BURT L. SAUNDERS. CHAIRMAN 9.A.5 CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK By: Martha Vergara, Deputy Clerk Packet Pg. 57 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER ORDINANCE(S) Notice is hereby given that the Collier County Board of County Commissioners will hold a public hearing on June 23, commencing at ll a.m., in the Board of County Commissioners Chamber. Third Floor, Collier County Government Center. Tamiami Trail E., Naples. FL The purpose of the hearing is to consider AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 89-05, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES SUB -ELEMENT OF THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN ELEMENT AND URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES BY AMENDING THE ESTATES MIXED -USE DISTRICT TO ADD THE NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF UP TO 30,000 SQUARE FEET OF COMMUNITY FACILITY USES FOR FAMILY SOCIAL SERVICE PROGRAMS ANO ACTIVITIES FOR SENIORS AGED 50 AND OVER. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF RAKES BOULEVARD AND AUTUMN OAKS LANE, APPROXIMATELY 35C FEET SOUTH OF IMMOKALEE ROAD, IN SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, CONSISTING OF 8.7r ACRES'. AND FURTHERMORE, RECOMMENDING TRANSMITTAL OF THE ADOPTED AMENDMENT TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING FOP AN EFFECTIVE DATE.[PL201800026211 AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 2004-41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICF ESTABLISHED THE COMPREHENSIVE ZONING REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, BY AMENDING THE APPROPRIATE ZONING ATLAS MAP OR MAPS BY CHANGFNC THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED REAL PROPERTY FROM AN ESTATES 4E1 ZONING DISTRICT TO A COMMUNITY FACILITY PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT (CFPUD} ZONING DISTRICT FOR THE PROJECT TO BE KNOWN AS NAPLES SENIOR CENTER CFPUD, TO ALLOW UP TO 30,000 SOUARE FEET OF INDIVIDUAL AND FAMILY SOCIAL SERVICES (SIC 83221 FOR SENIORS 60 AND OLDER, INCLUDING ACTFVIT7 CENTERS FOR THE ELDERLY, ADULT DAY CARE CENTERS, COMMUNITY CENTERS FOR SENIOR CITIZENS SENIOR CITIZEN ASSOCIATIONS, FAMILY COUNSELING, OLD AGE ASSISTANCE, AND OUTREACH PROGRAMS AND FOR GROUP SUPPORT SERVICES FOR THE ELDERLY ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEASI CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF OAKES BOULEVARD AND AUTUMN OAKS LANE, APPROXIMATELY 35( FEET SOUTH OF IMMOKALEE ROAD, 1N SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, CONSISTING OF 13,6+ACRES; AND BY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. [PL201B00026221 GMPAJjA mmokelee RD PL20182G utumn Oaks LN D co t6 0 PUDZ PL20182622 AP interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ORDINANCE(S) will be made availat inspection at the GMD Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section, 28GO N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, FL., between the of a;00 A.M. and 5:00 PM., Monday through Fnday. Furthermore, the materials will be made available for inspection at the 1 County Clerk's Office. Fourth Floor, Suite 4D1, Collier County Government Center, Fast Naples, one week prior to the scl hearing. Any questions pertaining to the documents should be directed to the GMD Zoning Division, Comprehensive Piz Section. Written comments filed with the Clerk to the Board's Office prior to June 23, 2020 will be read and considered public hearing, As part of an ongoing initiative to promote social distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic, the public will have the oppo to provide public comments remotely, as well as in person, during this proceeding. Individuals who would like to part! remotely, should register any time after the agenda is posted on the County website which is 6 days before the meeting It - the link provided on the front page of the County wel at . Individuals who register will receive air in advance of the public hearing detailing how they can participate remotely in this meeting. For additional information abc meeting, please call Geoffrey Willig at 252-8369 or email to Geoffrey Willig@collarcount4 aov. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Board of County Commissioners will need a record proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may reed to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which, includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommadaiion in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entit no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division, It at 3335 Tamiami Trail East. Suite 101, Naples, FL 34112-5356, (239) 252-a38O, at least two days prior to the meeting. AE listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. HOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PFJRT L. SAUNDERS, CHAIF�MAN CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK 12A # WEDNESDAY, JUNE 3, 2020 1 NAPLES Packet Pg. 58 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER ORDINANCE(S) Notice is hereby given that the Collier County Board of County Commissioners will hold a public hearing on December 8, 2020 commencing at 9:00 a.m., in the Board of County Commissioners Chamber, Third Floor, Collier County Government Center, 3299 Tamiami Trail E., Naples, FL. The purpose of the hearing is to consider. AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AMENDINGORDINANCE NO. 89-05,7AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES SUB -ELEMENT OF THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN, ELEMENT AND URBAN GOLDEN GATE ESTATES FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES BY AMENDING THE ESTATES MIXED -USE DISTRICT TO ADD THE NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF UP TO 30,000 SQUARE FEET OF COMMUNITY FACILITY USES FOR FAMILY SOCIAL SERVICE PROGRAMS AND ACTIVITIES FOR SENIORS AGED 60 AND> OVER. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION t OF OAKES BOULEVARD AND AUTUMN OAKS LANE, APPROXIMATELY 350 FEET SOUTH OF IMMOKALEE' ROAD, IN SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, CONSISTING OF 8.7: ACRES; AND'" FURTHERMORE, DIRECTING TRANSMITTAL OF THE ADOPTED AMENDMENT TO THE FLORIDA', DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. [PL20180002621] AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,' AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 2004-41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH ESTABLISHEDTHECOMPREHENSIVEZONING REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, BY AMENDING THE APPROPRIATE ZONING ATLAS MAP OR MAPS BY CHANGING THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED REAL PROPERTY FROM AN ESTATES (E) ZONING DISTRICT TO A COMMUNITY FACILITY PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT (CFPUD) ZONING DISTRICT FOR THE PROJECT TO BE KNOWN AS NAPLES SENIOR CENTER CFPUD,TO ALLOW;+ UP TO 30,000 SQUARE FEET OF INDIVIDUAL AND FAMILY SOCIAL SERVICES (SIC 8322) FOR SENIORS'^ 60 AND OLDER, INCLUDING ACTIVITY CENTERS FOR THE ELDERLY, ADULT DAY CARE CENTERS,' COMMUNITY CENTERS FOR SENIOR CITIZENS, SENIOR CITIZEN ASSOCIATIONS, FAMILY COUNSELING,'i,; OLD AGE ASSISTANCE, AND OUTREACH PROGRAMS AND FOR GROUP SUPPORT SERVICES FOR THE _ ELDERLY ON PROPERTY LOCATED. ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF THE INTERSECTION OF OAKES'' BOULEVARD AND AUTUMN OAKS LANE, APPROXIMATELY 350 FEET SOUTH OF IMMOKALEE ROAD, IN SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, CONSISTING OF 13.6+ ACRES; AND BY PROVIDING: AN EFFECTIVE DATE.[PL20180002622] 7 Immokalee RD GMPA PL20182621 Autumn Oaks LN -v o > W J N m N C Y p PUDZ PL20182622 1. All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ORDINANCES) will be made available . for inspection at the GMD Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section, 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, FL., between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M., Monday through Friday. Furthermore, the materials will be made available for inspection at the Collier County Clerk's Office, Fourth Floor, Suite 401, Collier County Government Center, East Naples, one week prior to the scheduled hearing. Any questions pertaining to the documents should be directed to the GMD Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section. Written comments filed with the Clerk to the Board's Office prior to December 8, 2020 will be read and considered at the public hearing. As part of an ongoing initiative to promote social distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic, the public will have the opportunity to provide public comments remotely, as well as in person, during this proceeding. Individuals who would like to participate remotely, should register any time after the agenda is posted on the County website which is 6 days before the meeting through the link provided on the front page of the County website at www.colliercountyfl.gov. Individuals who register will receive an email in advance of the public hearing detailing how they can participate remotely in this meeting. For additional information about the meeting, please call Geoffrey Willig at 252-8369 or email to Geoffrey. Willig@colliercountyfl.gov. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Board of County Commissioners will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled,at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 101, Naples, FL 3411275356, (239) 252-8380, at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. : BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BURT L. SAUNDERS, CHAIRMAN CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, ' CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTROLLER By: Ann Jennejohn Deputy Clerk (SEAL) NDIGC10534364-01 Z a 'a r m to Z m to f1 O 3 m v Z m to v D Z O G m m z OD N O N O V a K Packet Pg. 59 Naples Senior Center Community Center Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Application and Supporting Documents March 5,, 2020 CCPC Hearing ® GradyMinor Civf] Fngfneem • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • wxvw.gradyminor.com GradyMinor Civil Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects April 12, 2019 Mr. David Weeks Principal Planner Collier County Growth Management Division/ Planning and Regulation Land Development Services Department Comprehensive Planning Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 RE: Collier County Growth Management Plan Amendment Application Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002678), Submittal 1 Dear Mr. Weeks: A Collier County Growth Management Plan Amendment (GMPA) application for properties located at the southeast quadrant of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane is being filed electronically for review. This application proposes to create a new subdistrict in the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Element to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building for senior services uses in the subdistrict. The proposed amendment reflects the market demand for non-residential development in this location within Golden Gate Estates. The GMPA is supported with a companion PUD rezone, which establishes the specific development standards for the proposed uses, and a Master Plan for development of the 8.6± acre property. Please feel free to contact me should you have any questions. Sincerely, D. Lo-�- D. Wayne Arnold, AICP c: Dr. Jaclynn Faffer, President/CEO, Naples Senior Center at JFCS John M. Passidomo GradyMinor File Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. Ph. 239-947-1144 Fax. 239-947-0375 3800 Via Del Rey EB 0005151 LB 0005151 LC 26000266 Bonita Springs, FL 34134 www.gradyminor.com APPLICATION FOR A REQUEST TO AMEND THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN APPLICATOIN NUMBER: PL20180002621 DATE RECEIVED: PRE -APPLICATION CONFERENCE DATE: September 27, 2018 DATE SUFFICIENT: This application, with all required supplemental data and information, must be completed and accompanied by the appropriate fee, and returned to the Growth Management Department, Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida 34104. 239-252- 2400. The application must be reviewed by staff for sufficiency within 30 calendar days following the filing deadline before it will be processed and advertised for public hearing. The applicant will be notified in writing, of the sufficiency determination. If insufficient, the applicant will have 30 days to remedy the deficiencies. For additional information on the processing of the application, see Resolution 97-431 as amended by Resolution 98-18 (both attached). If you have any questions, please contact the Comprehensive Planning Section at 239-252-2400. SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS I. GENERAL INFOMRATION A. Name of Applicant Dr. Jaclynn Faffer Company Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. Address 5025 Castello Drive, Suite 101 City Naples State FL Zip Code 34103 Phone Number (239) 325-4444 Email Address ifaffer@naplesseniorcenter.orq B. Name of Agent * D. Wayne Arnold, AICP • THIS WILL BE THE PERSON CONTACTED FOR ALL BUSINESS RELATED TO THE PETITION. Company Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A. Address 3800 Via Del Rey City Bonita Springs State Florida Zip Code 34134 Phone Number 239-947-1 144 Fax Number 131. Name of Agent * John M. Passidomo • THIS WILL BE THE PERSON CONTACTED FOR ALL BUSINESS RELATED TO THE PETITION. Company Cheffy Passidomo, P.A. Address 821 5th Avenue South City Naples State Florida Zip Code 34102 C. Name of Owner (s) of Record John H Winkler, Sharon A. Winkler, Lowell E. White and Peggy M. White Address 18151 Cypress Creek Lane City Alva State FL Zip Code 33920-3385 Phone Number Fax Number D. Name, Address and Qualifications of additional planners, architects, engineers, environmental consultants and other professionals providing information contained in this application. See Exhibit I.D. II. Disclosure of Interest Information: A. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, Tenancy by the entirety, tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership interest as well as the percentage of such interest. (Use additional sheets if necessary). Name and Address Percentage of Ownership B. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and the percentage of stock owned by each. Name and Address Percentage of Stock C. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the percentage of interest. Name and Address Percentage of Interest Lowell E. White and Ralph L. Gritten Family Trust Undivided 100% Peggy M. White and Ralph L. Gritten Family Trust Undivided 100% Sharon A. Winkler and Sharon A. Winkler Trust Agreement Undivided 100% Sharon A. Winkler and John H. Winkler Trust Agreement Undivided 100% D. If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the general and/or limited partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership E. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. 100 A Florida Not For Profit Corporation 2 Date of Contract: July 25, 2018 If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all individuals or officers, if a corporation, partnership, or trust. Name and Address G. Date subject property acquired (04/03/2007) leased ( ): Term of lease yrs./mos. If, Petitioner has option to buy, indicate date of option: and date option terminates: , or anticipated closing: 04/06/2020. H. Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, it is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form. III. DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: A. LEGAL DESCRIPTION See Exhibit III.A - Sketch and Leaal B. GENERAL LOCATION Southeast quadrant of Autumn Oakes Lane and Oakes Boulevard C. PLANNING COMMUNITY Urban Estates D. TAZ 188 E. SIZE IN ACRES 8.7± F. ZONING E, Estates G. SURROUNDING LAND USE PATTERN Residential, church and county water management area H. FUTURE LAND USE MAP DESIGNATION (S) Estates Designation, Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict IV. TYPE OF REQUEST: A. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN ELEMENT (S) TO BE AMENDED: Housing Element Traffic Circulation Sub -Element Aviation Sub -Element Sanitary Sewer Sub -Element Solid Waste Sub -Element Capital Improvement Element Future Land Use Element Immokalee Master Plan Recreation/Open Space Mass Transit Sub -Element Potable Water Sub -Element NGWAR Sub -Element Drainage Sub -Element CCME Element X Golden Gate Master Plan B. AMEND PAGE (S) Beginning Page 30 OF THE Golden Gate Area Master Plan ELEMENT AS FOLLOWS: (Use Strike _+hre glh to identify language to be deleted; Use Underline to identify language to be added). Attach additional pages if necessary: See Exhibit IV.B C. AMEND FUTURE LAND USE MAP(S) DESIGNATION FROM Estates Designation, Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict TO Estates Designation, Mixed Use District, Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict D. AMEND OTHER MAP(S) AND EXHIBITS AS FOLLOWS: (Name & Page #) Golden Gate Area Future Land Use Map (no page # shown on map). See Exhibit IV.D DESCRIBE ADDITINAL CHANGES REQUESTED: Create Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict Inset Map (page #'s are not shown on existing maps in the Comprehensive Plan). See Exhibit IV.E. V. REQUIRED INFORMATION: NOTE: ALL AERIALS MUST BE AT A SCALE OF NO SMALLER THAN I"=400'. At least one copy reduced to 8- 1/2 x 1 1 shall be provided of all aerials and/or maps. A. LAND USE Exhibit V.A. Provide general location map showing surrounding developments (PUD, DRI's, existing zoning) with subject property outlined. Exhibit V.A. Provide most recent aerial of site showing subject boundaries, source, and date. Exhibit V.A. Provide a map and summary table of existing land use and zoning within a radius of 300 feet from boundaries of subject property. B. FUTURE LAND USE AND DESIGNATION Exhibit V.B. Provide map of existing Future Land Use Designation(s) of subject property and adjacent lands, with acreage totals for each land use designation on the subject property. C. ENVIRONMENTAL Exhibit V.C. Provide most recent aerial and summary table of acreage of native habitats and soils occurring on site. HABITAT IDENTIFICATION MUST BE CONSISTENT WITH THE FDOT- FLORIDA LAND USE, COVER AND FORMS CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM (FLUCCS CODE). NOTE: THIS MAY BE INDICATED ON SAME AERIAL AS THE LAND USE AERIAL IN "A" ABOVE. Exhibit V.C. Provide a summary table of Federal (US Fish & Wildlife Service) and State (Florida Game & Freshwater Fish Commission) listed plant and animal species known to occur on the site and/or known to inhabit biological communities similar to the site (e.g. panther or black bear range, avian rookery, bird migratory route, etc.),Identify historic and/or archaeological sites on the subject property. D. GROWTH MANAGEMENT Reference F.A.C. Chapter 163-3177 and Collier County's Capital Improvements Element Policy 1.1.2 (Copies attached). 1 . INSERT "Y" FOR YES OR "N" FOR NO IN RESPONSE TO THE FOLLOWING: N Is the proposed amendment located in an Area of Critical State Concern? (Reference 9J-1 1.006(1) (a) (5), F.A.C.). IF so, identify area located in ACSC. N Is the proposed amendment directly related to a proposed Development of Regional Impact pursuant to Chapter 380 F.S. ? (Reference 9J-11.006(1)(a)7.a, F.A.C.) Exhibit V.D.1(3)/N Is the proposed amendment directly related to a proposed Small Scale Development Activity pursuant to Subsection 163.3187 (1) (c), F.S. ? (Reference 9J-1 1.006(1)(a)7.b, F.A.C.) Does the proposed amendment 0 create a significant impact in population which is defined as a potential increase in County -wide population by more than 5% of population projections? (Reference Capital Improvement Element Policy 1.1.2). If yes, indicate mitigation measures being proposed in conjunction with the proposed amendment. Y, Exhibit V.D.1(4) Does the proposed land use cause an increase in density and/or intensity to the uses permitted in a specific land use designation and district identified (commercial, industrial, etc.) or is the proposed land use a new land use designation or district? (Reference Rule 9J-5.006(5) F.A.C.). If so, provide data and analysis to support the suitability of land for the proposed use, and of environmentally sensitive land, ground water and natural resources. (Reference Rule 9J-1 1.007, F.A.C.) E. PUBLIC FACILITIES Provide the existing Level of Service Standard (LOS) and document the impact the proposed change will have on the following public facilities: Exhibit V.E. Potable Water Exhibit V.E. Sanitary Sewer Exhibit V.E.1 Arterial & Collector Roads; Name specific road and LOS Immokalee Road Oakes Boulevard Exhibit V.E. Drainage Exhibit V.E. Solid Waste Exhibit V.E. Parks: Community and Regional If the proposed amendment involves an increase in residential density, or an increase in intensity for commercial and/or industrial development that would cause the LOS for public facilities to fall below the adopted LOS, indicate mitigation measures being proposed in conjunction with the proposed amendment. (Reference Capital Improvement Element Objective 1 and Policies) 2. Exhibit V.E. Provide a map showing the location of existing services and public facilities that will serve the subject property (i.e. water, sewer, fire protection, police protection, schools and emergency medical services. 3. Exhibit V.E Document proposed services and public facilities, identify provider, and describe the effect the proposed change will have on schools, fire protection and emergency medical services. F. OTHER Identify the following areas relating to the subject property: Exhibit V.F Flood zone based on Flood Insurance Rate Map data (FIRM). N.A. Location of wellfields and cones of influence, if applicable. (Identified on Collier County Zoning Maps) N.A. Traffic Congestion Boundary, if applicable N.A. Coastal Management Boundary, if applicable N.A. High Noise Contours (65 LDN or higher) surrounding the Naples Airport, if applicable (identified on Collier County Zoning Maps). G. SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION N.A. $16,700.00 non-refundable filing fee made payable to the Board of County Commissioners due at time of submittal. (Plus proportionate share of advertising costs) Provided $9,000.00 non-refundable filing fee for a Small Scale Amendment made payable to the Board of County Commissioners due at time of submittal. (Plus proportionate share of advertising costs) Exhibit V.G.3 Proof of ownership (copy of deed) Exhibit V.G.4 Notarized Letter of Authorization if Agent is not the Owner (See attached form) Submitted Electronically 1 Original and 5 complete, signed applications with all attachments including maps, at time of submittal. After sufficiency is completed, 25 copies of the complete application will be required. * If you have held a pre -application meeting and paid the pre -application fee of $250.00 at the meeting, deduct that amount from the above application fee amount when submitting your application. All pre -application fees are included in the total application submittal fee. Otherwise the overage will be applied to future proportionate share advertising costs. * Maps shall include: North arrow, name and location of principal roadways and shall be at a scale of 1 "=400' or at a scale as determined during the pre -application meeting. LETTER OF AUTHORIZATION TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN I hereby authorize Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. and Cheffy Passidomo, P.A. (Name of Agent) to serve as my Agent in a request to amend the Collier County Growth Management Plan affecting property identified in this Application. Signe4 I hereby certify that I have the authority to make the foregoing application, and that the application is true, correct and complete to the best of my knowledge. Si ature of )(pW1cVr Dr. Jaclynn Faffer as CEO/President of Naples Senior Center at JFCS. Inc. STATE OF (FLde,nf, COUNTY OF ( Go1, L.%I-X IR— Sworn to and subscribed before me this Q day of M,R, o IP" 2019 MY COMMISSION E PIRF 1' J o ary Public FREDERIC J SHORE •' MY COMMISSION # GG038202 CHOOSE ONE OF THE FOLLOWING: `:',+ EXPIRES November 19, 2020 who is personally known to me, who has produced ri n 104t 60" (9 as identification and did take an Oath did not take and Oath NOTICE - BE AWARE THAT: Florida Statute Section 837.06 - False Official law states that: "Whoever knowingly makes a false statement In writing with the intent to mislead a public servant in the performance of his official duty shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of the second degree, punishable as provided by a fine to a maximum of %500.00 and/or maximum of a sixty day jail term." Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit I.D. Professional Consultants Planning/Project Management: D. Wayne Arnold, AICP Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey Bonita Springs, FL 34134 239.947.1144 239.947.0375 fax warnold@gradyminor.com John M. Passidomo Cheffy Passidomo, P.A. 821 5th Avenue South Naples, FL 34102 239.261.9300 239. 261.9782 fax jmpassidomo@napleslaw.com Transportation: James M. Banks, P.E., President JMB Transportation Engineering, Inc. 4711 7th Avenue SW Naples, FL 34119 239.919.2767 jmbswte@msn.com Environmental: Tyler King President/Principal Biologist DexBender Environmental Consulting 4470 Camino Real Way, Suite 101 Fort Myers, FL 33966 239-334-3680 tking@dexbender.com June 12, 2019 Page 1 of 1 NSCOB Exhibit ID-revl.docx ® GradyNnor CNN Engfnccrs • Land Suracyors • 111anncrs • Landscapc Archttccts Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002678 Exhibit III.A. Legal Description PROPERTY DESCRIPTION A PARCEL OF LAND BEING A PORTION OF TRACT 24 AND ALL OF TRACT 23, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES UNIT NO. 97, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 7, PAGE 96, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: BEGINNING AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF TRACT 23 OF SAID PLAT; THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID TRACT 23 NORTH 89'31'36" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 680.00 FEET TO THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID TRACT 23; THENCE ALONG THE EAST LINE OF SAID TRACT 23 AND THE AFOREMENTIONED TRACT 24 SOUTH 00'28'24" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 555.00 FEET; THENCE SOUTH 89'31'36" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 680,00 FEET TO A POINT ON THE WEST LINE OF SAID TRACT 24; THENCE ALONG SAID WEST LINE AND THE WEST LINE OF THE AFOREMENTIONED TRACT 23 NORTH 00°28'24" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 555.00 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING. CONTAINING 8.66 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. April 12, 2019 Page 1 of 1 NSCOB Exhibit 111A.docx ® GradyMinor C101 Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com i TRACT 20 J DRAWN BY: AH CHECKED BY: DLS JOB CODE: NSCOB SCALE: 1" = 120' DATE: 14 FEBRUARY 2019 FILE: 18-127-SL SHEET: 1 Of 1 TRACT 21 TRACT 22 (OR 3175, PG 465) (OR 3921, PG 1) I N 89°31'36" E 680.00' AUTUMN OAKS LANE ------------------------------------ I I II I I TRACT 23 I I I I I II I I NORTH 150' OF TRACT 24 NORTH 75' OF THE SOUTH 180' OF TRACT 24 TRACT 50 (OR 4516, PG 2875) 0 0 o 0 0 M � _N_ a 0 60' 120' 240' SCALE: 1" = 120' � THIS PLAN MAY HAVE BEEN ENLARGED OR REDUCED FROM INTENDED DISPLAY SCALE FOR REPRODUCTION REASONS oo LEGEND: � POB POINT OF BEGINNING rn OR OFFICIAL RECORDS BOOK PB PLAT BOOK PG PAGE(S) S 89°31'36" W 00U•UU 50.0' I SOUTH 105' OF TRACT 24 (OR 5182, PG 2272) �100.0' ROAD GradyMinor Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P. y 3800 Via Del Re Bonita Springs, Florida 34134 Civil Engineers Land Surveyors . Planners Landscape Architects Cert. of Auth. EB 0005151 Cert. of Auth. LB 0005151 Business LC 26000266 PROPERTY DESCRIPTION A PARCEL OF LAND BEING A PORTION OF TRACT 24 AND ALL OF TRACT 23, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES UNIT NO. 97, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 7, PAGE 96, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: BEGINNING AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF TRACT 23 OF SAID PLAT; THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID TRACT 23 NORTH 89°31'36" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 680.00 FEET TO THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID TRACT 23; THENCE ALONG THE EAST LINE OF SAID TRACT 23 AND THE AFOREMENTIONED TRACT 24 SOUTH 00-28'24" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 555.00 FEET; THENCE SOUTH 89°31'36" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 680.00 FEET TO A POINT ON THE WEST LINE OF SAID TRACT 24; THENCE ALONG SAID WEST LINE AND THE WEST LINE OF THE AFOREMENTIONED TRACT 23 NORTH 00'28'24" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 555.00 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING. CONTAINING 8.66 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. NOTES: 1. BEARINGS SHOWN HEREON ARE BASED ON THE STATE PLANE COORDINATE SYSTEM ESTABLISHED BY THE NATIONAL GEODETIC SURVEY FOR FLORIDA EAST ZONE, 1983 DATUM WITH 1990 ADJUSTMENT OBTAINED UTILIZING RTK CPS OBSERVATIONS ON THE FDOT NETWORK AND REFER TO THE NORTH LINE OF TRACT 23, BEING N 89'31'36" E, AS STATED IN THE REFERENCED PLAT. 2. DIMENSIONS SHOWN HEREON ARE IN U.S. SURVEY FEET AND DECIMALS THEREOF. 3. THIS SKETCH AND DESCRIPTION IS NOT VALID WITHOUT THE DIGITAL SIGNATURE AND DIGITAL SEAL OF A LICENSED FLORIDA SURVEYOR AND MAPPER. NO ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS TO THIS SKETCH & DESCRIPTION MAP ARE PERMITTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESSED WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE SIGNING PARTY. *THIS IS NOT A SURVEY* bit III.A. SKETCH & DESCRIPTION PORTION OF TRACT 24 AND ALL OF TRACT 23 GOLDEN GATE ESTATES UNIT NO. 97 PLAT BOOK 7, PAGES 96 LYING IN SECTION 29, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA DATE SIGNED DONALO L. SAINTENOY lll, P.S.M FL LICENSE 16761 FOR THE FIRM Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002621 Exhibit W.B. Amendment Language Revise the GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** TABLE OF CONTENTS *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** * LIST OF MAPS 46 *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** A. Estates — Mixed Use District [beginning page 22] *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** 8. Naoles Senior Center Communitv Facilitv Subdistrict The subdistrict consists of 8.7+/- acres and is located at the southeast corner of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane. The purpose of the sub -district is to provide for a variety of family social service programs and activities for seniors aged 60 and over and their caregivers. Services may include but are not limited to classes and programs for learning, exercise, employment and financial assistance, grief counseling, emotional support, and respite support and other similar services related to providing assistance for seniors. Development within the Subdistrict shall be subiect to the following: June 12, 2019 W Gradyh4inor Page 1 of 3 NSCOB Exhibit IVB Proposed GMP Language-revl.docx cis ii NAgincers • Land Survc},ors • i'i inncrs • IAndscapc ArcMtccts Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002621 Exhibit W.B. Amendment Language a. The Subdistrict shall be rezoned to a Planned Unit Development (PUD), which shall specify permitted uses. b. The maximum square footage permitted within the subdistrict is 30,000 square feet of floor area. c. No building within this subdistrict may exceed two habitable stories in height. d. No residential uses or overnight activities shall be permitted within this subdistrict. e. The PUD ordinance shall include development standards, buffers, etc. to insure compatibility with surrounding properties. *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** Itill 01.11:1W OIDIUM4L MUM4.1IV *** *** *** *** *** Text break *** *** *** *** *** June 12, 2019 w GradyMiinor Page 2 of 3 NSCOB Exhibit IVB Proposed GMP Language-revl.docx GEvil E•ingfneers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminoi,.com • www.gratlyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002621 Amendment Language June 12, 2019 w GradyNnor Page 3 of 3 NSCOB Exhibit IVB Proposed GMP Language-revl.docx CWU Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com EXHIBIT IV.D. PROPOSED GOLDEN GATE AREA FUTURE LAND USE MAP URBAN DESIGNATION MINA USE DI TRICT OVmun ueemai uw uma ESTATES DESIGNAl10N AGRICULTURAL, RURAL DESIGNATIC MMED USE DISTRICTRoreismmnn�ao onus QRemavnsiEw�es Sumnim ORna niuim uIy e m NAL USES SUBDISTRICT OVERLAYS AND SPECIAL FEATURES ®ERCUILDISRItt nrwlsmaula =x c.nursnuersvxv ® mo-�me P�axemuea o.wy DER nL.ND. GOLDEN GATE AREA FUTURE LAND USE MAP SITE I ESTATES DESIGNATION, MIXED USE DISTRICT, NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY ELL RD SUBDISTRICT = 8.7± ACRES m RANDALL BLVD J � J W U GOLDEN GATE BLVD K U Ai INTERSTATE 75 BAD JI Z O LL � U ) L N L 0 0.5 1 2 3 Mile! R 9RF GOLDEN GATE FUTURE LAND USE MAP ADOPTED-FEBRARY, 1991 AMENDED - MAY 19.1992 AMENDED - DECEMBER 4. 2007 ORD, NO. 200]-]7 AMENDED-OCTOBER 14,2008 ORD. NO. 20N-59 AMENDED -MAY 25, 1993 AMENDED - JULY 27, 1993 AMENDED - JULY 28, 2010 ORD. NO. 2010-31 AMENDED -APRIL 12. 1— AMENDED - MARCH 14, 1995 AMENDED -JULY 28,2010 ORD NO 2010-32 MENDED- SEPTEMBER 14. 2011 ORD, NO. 2011.29 AMENDED - NOVEMBER 18.2014 NDORD. NO. 2014-41 AMENDED-OCTOBER 27,1997 AMENDED -APRIL 14, 1998 AMENDED-SEPTEMBER$. 1998 AMENDED - FESRUARY 23, 1999 AMENDED - MAY 9. 2000 AMENDED- NOVEMBER 10, 2015 ORD. NO. 20t562 AM ORD NOM2016_012018 , 2 AMENDED - MARCH 13, 2001 AMENDED - MAY 14, 2002 AMENDED DSE PTEMBER 10. 2003 O AMEN R 26, 2004 ORD, NOT 2004-]1 AMENDED - JANUARY 25, 2005 ORD. NO. 2005-3 AMENDORD. ED- NO. 2JANUARY00I'S 200] ]-9 R 97F INTERSTATE 75 R 90 L EXHIBIT IV.E NAPES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT Collier County, Florida U U T S LANE m V) w Y Q 0 VANDERBILT BEACH ROAD EXT. Lc) Q I J L N T 0 E w o Q U z m w z PINE RIDG 0 H B D I N p ci) F-- J m > Q J � Q m m O Q E AT A a � z Q V) ADOPTED — ??, (Ord. No. 20—= 20-- ??) 0 1/2 MI. 1 MI. LEGEND GOLDEN GATE NAPLES SENIOR ESTATES CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT PREPARED BY: GRAPHICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECTION COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION FILE: ???????? DATE: ??/?? EXHIBIT V.B. EXISTING GOLDEN GATE AREA FUTURE LAND USE MAP URBAN DESIGNATION MIXED USE 013TRKT OUwn w7 ESTATES DESIGNATION AGRICULTURALIRURAL DESIGNATIC MMED USE DISTRICTR"�aiseluemenlaaapsmn Eauwswaauu OQReaaenm flB p" 0 9 NAL USES SUBDISTRICT OVERLAYS AND SPECIAL FEATURES Omxon samww = xwmow cmie�waeium ® Rsm.eevrnemo-�nv owr CDMMERCIAL DISTRICT oRwcw�xoaisamxun ��x5 Nam a S"�.�x ZE� ;�xx c un s m�a� c ms = �x�aaxa� � L,nlaaswaam�.�+«samumu � s>.uNaoxeomae swew"c SITE ESTATES DESIGNATION, MIXED USE DISTRICT, RESIDENTIAL ESTATES ' SUBDISTRICT = 8.7± ACRES DAVIS BLVD m K (J BLVD _ J 0 m ) 0 N L 0 0.5 1 2 3 Mile: R 2RF INTERSTATE 75 GOLDEN GATE FUTURE LAND USE MAP ADOPTED-FEBRARY, 1991 AMENDED - MAY 19, 1992 AMENDED-DECEMBER 4, 2007 ORD. NO. 2007.77 AMENDED - OCTOBER 14. 2008 ORD. NO. 2000-N gMENDEO - MAY 25, 1993 AMENDED-JULY 27. 1993 AMENDED -APRIL 12, 1994 AMENDED -JULY 2B, 2010 ORD. NO. 2010-31 AMENDED - JULY 20, 2010 ORD. NO. 2010-32 AMENDED - MARCH 14. 1995 AMENDED -OCTOBER 27. 1997 MENDED - SEPTEMBER 14, 2011 ORD. NO. 2011-29 AMENDED. NOVEMBER 10, 2014 AMENDED -APRIL 14, 1990 AMENDED- SEPTEMBER 0. 1990 E NOSER110, 201S A ORD �No E2015-02 AMENDED -FEBRUARY 23, 1999 AMENDED - MAY 9, 2000 10, 301S ORO. ND. 2ot0-t2 AMENDED - MARCH 13, 2001 AMENDED - MAY 14, 2002 AMENDED- SEPTEMBER 10, 2003 ORD. NO. 2003-44 M e, 2004 ORD. NO. 2004->t AMENDED-JANUARY 25, 2005 ORD. NO. 2005-3 AMENDED-JANUARY 25. 200] ORD. N0. 2007.18 R 27E GOLDEN GATE AREA FUTURE LAND USE MAP IMMOKALEE RD Z m w 0 OIL WELL RD F RANDALL BLVD m INTERSTATE 75 R 2QF EXHIBIT V.C. NAPLES SENIOR CENTER CFPUD Rezoning Environmental Information The Naples Senior Center CFPUD is 13.66 acres in size. Portions of the site, primarily the northwest portion, have been cleared in the past. A structure is present within this disturbed area, which is maintained in a mowed state. An area near the southeast portion of the site is also disturbed. Additionally, there is an area of Brazilian pepper located near the southern portion of the site. The perimeter of the property to the west and north consist of roads (Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oakes Lane). The remainder of the site consists of historic hydric pine -cypress that has been permanently drained by off -site development and drainage facilities. This consists of Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System Code 624DE1 and 624DE3 as shown on the attached Vegetation Map. There is currently 8.13± acres of native vegetation (as defined by Collier County Land Development Code Section 3.05.07.A.1) on the property. The Master Concept Plan will meet or exceed the required 1.22 acres of preserved native vegetation. Please see the attached Protected Species Assessment for a discussion of the current site conditions. The proposed project is consistent with Objective 6.1 and Policy 6.1.1. The proposed project contains 8.13 acres of native vegetation. The preserve area provided is 2.68 acres. This is substantially more than the 1.22 acres required (8.13 ac. of native vegetation x 0.15 = 1.22 acres). A management plan will be submitted that identifies the actions to maintain diversity, treat invasive exotic species, and fire management (Policy 6.1.4). There were no listed species, except for, the Wild pine that was observed in the proposed preserve and development areas. There are no ecological communities shared or tangential to State or Federal lands or other local governments (Objective 6.4). Tyler King of DexBender prepared the Protected Species Assessment. Mr. King has been employed as a full-time environmental consultant in southwest Florida since 1988. A copy of his credentials is attached. SEC77O1V, 29 TOWNSHIP 46 S RANCH- 26 E Notes: 1. Property boundary and road right of ways provided by GrodyMinor. 2. Mapping based on photointerpretation of 2018 aerial photography and ground truthing in July 2018. J. Delineation of jurisdictional wetlands is preliminary and subject to field review/approval by applicable regulatory agencies. Y 0 50 100 SCALE FEET FLUCCS Description Acreage 422 Brazilian Pepper 0.27 ac. 624DE1 Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics (10-25%) 1.23 ac. 624DE3 Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics (51-75%) 6.90 ac. 740 Disturbed Land 3.96 ac. 814 Roads and Highways 1.30ac. Total 13.66 ac. FOR CONCEPTUAL PLANNING PURPOSES ONLY FebruaryDrawing:l NSCIPLAN.DWG Vegetation Ma Naples Senior Center CFPUD E'BEDER P 91 AeV1fK).V?,?T tw IAL C'O1VSl1LTING FORT MYERS 239-334-3680 Naples Senior Center CFPUD Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East Collier County, Florida Protected Species Assessment February 2019 (revised June 2019) Prepared for: Naples Senior Center at JFCS 5025 Castello Drive, Suite 101 Naples, FL 34103 Prepared by: DexBender 4470 Camino Real Way, Suite 101 Fort Myers, FL 33966 (239) 334-3680 Introduction The 13.66± acre parcel is located within a portion of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida (Figure 1). The parcel is bordered to the north by Autumn Oaks Lane, to the west by Oakes Boulevard, to the south and east by existing commercial and residential development as well as undeveloped land. Site Conditions The majority of this site consists of drained pine -cypress invaded by exotics. A disturbed area with a structure is located within the northwest portion of the site. Vegetation Classifications The predominant upland and wetland vegetation associations were mapped in the field on 2018 digital color 1" = 100' scale aerial photography. The property boundary was provided by GradyMinor and inserted into the digital aerial. The property boundary was not staked in the field at the time of our site inspection and was, therefore, estimated based on the overlay of the boundary on the aerial photography. Five vegetation associations were identified using the Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCCS). Figure 1 depicts the approximate location and configuration of these vegetation associations and Table 1 summarizes the acreages by FLUCCS Code. A brief description of each FLUCCS Code is also provided below. Table 1. Acreage Summary by FLUCCS Code FLUCCS CODE DESCRIPTION ACREAGE 422 Brazilian Pepper 0.27 *624DE1 Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics 10-25% 1.23 *624DE3 Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics (51-75%) 6.90 740 Disturbed Land 3.96 814 Roads and Highways 1.30 Upland Subtotal 13.66 Wetland Subtotal 0.00 Other Surface Waters Subtotal 0.00 Total 13.66 * FLUCCS codes 624DE1 and 624DE3 are native vegetation associations. Total native habitat on site is 8.13 ac. (8.13 ac. of native vegetation x 0.15 = 1.22 acres of required preserved native vegetation). FLUCCS Code 422, Brazilian Pepper Brazilian pepper (Schinus terebinthifolius) is the dominant vegetation in this upland area. Widely scattered pusley (Richardia grandiflora) and whitehead broom (Spermacoce verticillata) are also present. 1 SEC770N• 29 TOWNSHIP. 46 S RANG, 26 E Notes: 1. Property boundary and road right of ways provided by GrodyMinor. 2. Mapping based on photointerpretation of 2018 aerial photography and ground truthing in July 2018. J. Delineation of jurisdictional wetlands is preliminary and subject to field review/approval by applicable regulatory agencies. Y 0 50 100 SCALE FEET FLUCCS Description Acreage 422 Brazilian Pepper 0.27 ac. 624DE1 Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics (10-25%) 1.23 ac. 624DE3 Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics (51-75%) 6.90 ac. 740 Disturbed Land 3.96 ac. 814 Roads and Highways 1.30ac. Total 13.66 ac. S Airplant (21) February 28, FOR CONCEPTUAL PLANNING PURPOSES ONLY Drawing:l NSCIPLAN.DWG FLUCCS Code 624DE1, Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics (10-25%) This upland association vegetated by slash pine (Pinus elliottii) and cypress (Taxodium distichum) appears to have been historically wetlands but has been severely drained and is no longer functioning as a wetland. Additional vegetative species present in this association include cabbage palm (Sabal palmetto), cocoplum (Chrysobalanus icaco), swampfern (Blechnum serrulatum), greenbrier (Smilax sp.), grapevine (Vitis sp.), myrsine (Rapanea punctata), scattered laurel oak (Quercus laurifolia) and live oak (Quercus virginiana). Exotic vegetation including earleaf acacia (Acacia auriculiformis), melaleuca (Melaleuca quinquenervia), Brazilian pepper, and air potato (Dioscorea bulbifera) has invaded this area and constitutes between approximately 10 and 25 percent of the vegetative cover. FLUCCS Code 624DE3, Drained Pine -Cypress Invaded by Exotics (51-75%) This upland area is similar in composition to FLUCCS Code 624DE1 described above but includes greater coverage of exotic vegetation. FLUCCS Code 740, Disturbed Land Portions of the site have been cleared and are being maintained in a mowed state. These upland areas are vegetated by species such as smutgrass (Sporobolus indicus), pusley, whitehead broom (Spermacoce verticillata), scattered ragweed (Ambrosia artemisiifolia), widely scattered cabbage palm, earleaf acacia, slash pine, Brazilian pepper, and cypress. A structure is also present within this association. FLUCCS Code 814, Roads and Highways This FLUCCS Code was used to denote the portions of Oakes Boulevard, Autumn Oaks Lane, and associated roadside shoulders and swales located within the boundary of the subject parcel. The shoulders are dominated by Bahia grass (Paspalum notatum) and pusley. At the time of the site inspection, no water was present in the roadside swales. Survey Method Based on the general habitat types (FLUCCS Codes) identified on -site there is a potential for a limited number of species listed as endangered, threatened, or species of special concern by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) or the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) to potentially occur on the subject parcel. These species include Gopher Frog (Rana areolata), Arctic Peregrine Falcon (Falco peregrinus tundrius), a variety of wading birds, Big Cypress Fox Squirrel (Sciurus niger avicennia), Everglades Mink (Mustela vison evergladensis), Florida Black Bear (Ursus americanus floridanus), and Florida Panther (Felis concolor coryi). The bald eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus), which has been delisted by the FWC and FWS, is still protected by other regulations and was therefore included in the survey. The Florida black bear (Ursus americanus floridanus), delisted in 2012, is still protected by the Florida Black Bear Management Plan and was therefore included in the survey. Please see Table 2 for additional listed species included in the survey. In addition, per Collier County regulations three species of orchids (Cyrtopodium punctatum, Encyclia cochleata, and E. tampensis) 3 and four species of wild pine (Tillandsia fasciculata, T. utriculata, T. balbisiana, and T. flexuosa) which could potentially occur on -site were included in the survey. Table 2. Listed Species That Could Potentially Occur On -site FLUCCS Percent CODE Survey Species Name Present Absent Coverage 422 80 Florida bonneted bat (Eumpos floridanus) 624DE1 80 Gopher Frog (Rana areolata) 624DE3 Arctic Peregrine Falcon (Falco peregrinus tundrius) Little Blue Heron (Egretta caerulea) Snowy Egret (Egretta thula) Tricolored Heron (Egretta tricolor) Big Cypress Fox Squirrel (Sciurus niger avicennia) Everglades Mink (Mustela vison evergladensis) Florida Black Bear (Ursus americanus floridanus) Florida Panther (Felis concolor coryi) Florida bonneted bat (Eumpos floridanus) ti 740 80 Florida bonneted bat (Eumpos floridanus) 814 80 None In order to comply with FWC/FWS survey methodology guidelines, each habitat type was surveyed for the occurrence of the species listed above using meandering pedestrian belt transects. The meandering pedestrian belt transects were spaced approximately 75 feet apart. The approximate location of direct sighting or sign (such as tracks, nests, and droppings) of a listed species, when observed, was denoted on the aerial photography. The 1" = 100' scale aerial Protected Species Assessment map (Figure 1) depicts the approximate location of the survey transects and the results of the survey. Prior to inspecting the site, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) listed species occurrence database (updated June 2018) was reviewed to determine the known occurrence of species listed by the FWC and/or U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) as threatened, endangered, or species of special concern in the project area. The listed species database indicated that a nuisance Florida black bear was reported adjacent to the subject parcel (Figure 2). According to the database there are no other known listed species sightings on or immediately adjacent to the subject property. A9 pp AT 1.4 '/f -fit r =i: , INK 1 VL Immokalee qoad.: ;+ r Autumn Oaks Lqne'S O } -4r i x # I 5 CD 4 +;1 # i i - - h• � ; �� �y' .� � ,?f .f ��� � f F � } �+ Y art ' }� f � 1 •II �� f o(% g000'a.41Z8,U?8RD&i1t3: ._! �` ' { . r f _' i ' . i `. C &l 0 0 0 � � - 0 0 o U&N. ow� � 0 0 0 no] Ift ��� �ia�r � 1Pll�lil � SURVEY RESULTS Twenty-one wild -pines were observed in various locations across the site (Figure 1). None of the other listed plants in LDC 3. 04.03 were observed. No cavity trees suitable for use by the Florida bonneted bat have been observed on -site. The existing buildings were also closely inspected for any signs of bat utilization. No other species listed by either the FWS or the FWC were observed on the site during the protected species survey. This is not unexpected due to the poor habitat on -site (significant exotic infestation and hydrologic alteration) and surrounding off -site developments. In addition to the site inspection, a search of the FWC species database (updated June 2018) revealed no additional known protected species within or immediately adjacent to the project limits. Y:\NSC-1\PSA Report.docx re Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria The amendment proposes to create a new community facility sub -district under the Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP), in order to create a campus for the Naples Senior Center (NSC) on 8.7 ± acres of land located at the intersection of Autumn Oaks Lane and Oakes Boulevard (the "Property"). The Property is part of a 13.6± assemblage of four contiguous tax parcels (the "13.6± Acre Assemblage"). This application for a new community facility subdistrict applies only to the Property and not the balance of the 13.6± Acre Assemblage. THE APPLICANT NSC is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit human services organization incorporated in the state of Florida in November 2011. The mission of the organization is to provide seniors and their families tools to address life's challenges. Services provided include the senior center, to address isolation, loneliness and create a sense of purpose and community for adults 60 and over living in Collier County, dementia respite support services for those suffering from Alzheimer's disease and related demential, as well as support for their caregivers, geriatric case management services to address the needs of frail seniors, emotional support services for those experiencing loss and grief and a food pantry for those experiencing food insecurity. NSC has a committed board of trustees comprised of 23 community leaders, a full-time staff of 18 and a corps of over 200 trained and vetted volunteers. A 2012 study examining the needs of seniors in a targeted area of Naples revealed several issues that previously had not been given attention. The study, performed by FGCU Division of Social Work faculty, found many individuals age 60 and over experiencing poverty, food insecurity and social isolation. As a result of the study's findings, NSC opened its doors in January 2014. It was expected that approximately 200-250 seniors might enroll at the center. NSC saw more than double that number of seniors in just the first year, and now has a membership of over 1,400. Including NSC's dementia respite and geriatric case management clients, the number reaches well over 1,600. NSC requested FGCU Division of Social Work do an update to the 2012 study and this was completed in 2017. The study found that the issues facing seniors still exist, in a larger geographic area. While the programs and services of NSC have helped the senior population, they are still experiencing poverty, food insecurity and social isolation. Further, the study found that an expansion of capacity as well as the establishment of new programs and services need to be of utmost concern to the local community, particularly considering the steep population projections among the 60 and over age group. December 19, 2019 W GradyllinDr Page 1 of 8 NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx f;ivll Engiriurs • Lund Snn•cyoN . I'lanoCrs • Landscape •kroll1cciti Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Fl, 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria POPULATION ESTIMATES- AGE 60 AND OVER � POPULATION PROJEETIONS - AGE 60 AND OVER. Population projections report significant increases through year 2040 in population over 60 74.7°o increase in Collier County Higher increases predicted €or Vie age group 75 and over 1 16.99'S in Collier County POVERTY- AGE 60 AND OVER Large percentage change Again, increases due to increasing populations Likely coupled with increased costs of living = Flvnrerrc MW 2011 2015 Percent Change Change ►'li[:1#�[�l�i►'l�t�il� MI►�:�� #��Illil Mi�l'1 � ►� Large percentage changes December 19, 2019 ® GradyMinor Page 2 of 8 NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx Givll Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Ft, 34134 • 239-947-1t 44 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria LIVING ALONE - AGE 65 AND OVER Seemingly small percentage -changes *Excerpted from "Needs Assessment of Seniors: Trends from 2012 to Present. FGCU Division of Social work Senior Center Growth 2014 -2019 by Zip Code V-0 no ■ 2014 1W ■ 3715 as ■ 2016 GO 40 ■ 2017 c4 NZOIS Mrw M ■4011:11: : The study recommended, as a first priority, the "Expansion of capacity of existing senior centers, specifically the Naples Senior Center, due to both high enrollment and provided feedback". (Needs Assessment of Seniors: Trends from 2012 to Present) Naples Senior Center provides professionally delivered services through a variety of core programs: • The senior center offers a place where seniors can remain connected and engaged through activities including wellness, arts and culture, education and socialization. • Dementia respite support is designed for seniors who are experiencing memory loss. The 4-hour structured program offers the opportunity for older adults who suffer from memory loss to enjoy cognitive stimulation, social activities and physical exercise in a clinically sound, safe and relaxing environment. The program provides caregivers a much - needed break from the constant demand of taking care of a loved one with a cognitive disorder. • Geriatric Case Management and Senior Outreach is a multi -faceted program that addresses the needs of frail, primarily homebound seniors. Professional staff provide December 19, 2019 W GradyMinor Page 3 of 8 NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx Givll ERgfneeN • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria comprehensive assessments and develop plans of care, enabling the seniors to age in place in the community safely, and with dignity. Naples Senior Center Food Pantry is open to the entire community 5 days a week, offering non-perishable items to address food insecurity. To protect the confidentially and dignity of those using the pantry, appointments are required. It is a "choice" pantry where individuals can "shop" the shelves and select what they need, one of the few of this kind in Collier County. NSC is the only organization of its kind in Collier County, offering comprehensive services to seniors living in the community, and staffed by professionals with experience and credentials in working with the older adult population. Programs and services offered at NSC are developed based upon the needs of seniors in the community, and NSC works closely with FGCU Department of Social Work to continually evaluate the needs. NSC is open Monday through Friday from gam to 6pm. Program hours for NSC are from 10am to 4pm and approximately 100 seniors utilize the varied programs that are offered during those hours. The exception is on Wednesday when a hot lunch, followed by entertainment, is offered and approximately 200 seniors are in attendance. The lunch provides an integral focal point for socialization and a unique portal into the ongoing needs of the seniors NSC serves. The hours of utilization on Wednesday are the same as the other days of the week. THE APPLICATION The proposed amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP) will authorize up to 30,000 square feet of building area for senior services. The 8.7+/- acre Property is located at the southeast quadrant of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane. The Property also is located at the terminus of Valewood Drive, providing signalized access to Immokalee Road. The underlying zoning currently provides for E, Estates residential uses at 1 dwelling unit per 2.25 acres, or the availability to permit a number of non-residential uses through other forms of approval including the non -conforming use change and conditional use application processes. The Property is also near the First Congregational Church which is located north across Autumn Oaks Lane. The Property subject to the proposed small-scale plan amendment will not be immediately adjacent, separated by Oakes Blvd. a 100-foot wide right-of-way, to any land presently utilized for residential use. Authorizing limited senior community center uses on 8.7+/- acres is a logical land use change. The underlying property owner controls the 13.6± Acre Assemblage. The small-scale plan amendment will limit the senior center uses on 8.7± acres of the assemblage and the remaining 5 acres will be dedicated to open space through the companion PUD rezoning application. December 19, 2019 W Gradyllinor Page 4 of 8 NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx G10 Engiriurs • Lund Snn•cyoN . I'IanoCrs • Landscape •Xrd111C0ti Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Fl, 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria The proposed amendment provides for a variety of senior services that are also commonly associated with social and fraternal organizations and religious organizations and are conditional uses in the Estates Zoning District. Under the GGAMP, there are locational criteria, which must be met before a conditional use maybe approved. The single owner assemblage of land includes four separate tracts. NSC proposes to locate the physical building and most of the associated site improvements on the 5+/- acre tract located directly at the Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane intersection. This tract does not qualify under the GGAMP for a transitional conditional use, necessitating the proposed small-scale amendment. The amendment proposes to create a new sub -district in the GGAMP, which would permit the senior community center uses on approximately 8.7± acres of the 13.6± Acre Assemblage through the PUD rezoning process in lieu of the conditional use process. The PUD rezoning will permit the Naples Senior Center to tailor and better define the permitted uses authorized on the Property, and to establish development and operational standards specific to the proposed use than offered through the conventional conditional use process. The Golden Gate Master Plan Restudy effort did not look at site -specific land uses. The restudy was a very high-level policy analysis of the existing master plan. The proposed use is compatible with the surrounding area. The PUD, which will be submitted as a companion item, will include development standards and buffers insuring compatibility, and a conceptual master plan, identifying the location of the proposed building and site improvements on the Property. Creation of the new subdistrict will not result in a domino effect for other properties. In fact, approval of the single use on 8.7± acres proposed under this application will insure that no other non-residential uses will be developed on the adjoining properties. The Naples Senior Center is acquiring the 13.6± Acre Assemblage and is proposing the new subdistrict on only 8.7+/- acres. The remainder of the 13.6± Acre Assemblage will be set aside as preserve and open space use through a companion PUD document and Master Plan. Authorizing limited senior services uses on 8.7+/- acres is a logical land use change. Since adoption of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan in 1990, the County has made significant roadway improvements in the area including signalizing Valewood Drive, providing direct access to the site. The Property is also located in Commission District #3, which has the second largest population of the five County Commission Districts. Recognizing the location and pattern of development occurring in the immediate vicinity, the proposed land use change is logical, and it is compatible with the surrounding development. The proposed community facility use makes sense at this intersection. With direct access to Valewood Drive and its signalized access to Immokalee Road, the Property allows good site access for members and other visitors travelling to the site from throughout Collier County without having to use Oakes Boulevard. A professional traffic analysis of the anticipated senior center use concludes that due to the peculiarity of use of the facility being concentrated during the middle of the work day there are negligible traffic impacts during morning and afternoon peak hours, and all roadways will maintain levels of service well within acceptable levels. December 19, 2019 ® Ca'adyllinol' Page 5 of 8 NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx G10 Engiriurs • Lund Snn•cyoN . I'IanoCrs • Landscapc 'ki'0111f'0"; Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Fl, 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria As presently written, the GGAMP does not permit use of the Property for uses such as the proposed senior center. A portion of the Property was previously zoned for commercial uses and in the mid-1970's and a 7,200 square foot warehouse/storage facility was constructed on the 5+/- acre tract located at the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane. This now non -conforming warehouse/storage building remains today. The warehouse/storage building can be repurposed into another comparable commercial use through the non -conforming use change permit application process. The Naples Senior Center provides essential services to a significant otherwise unserved segment of the local population and thereby helps to meet the vital needs of the people of Collier County to have easy access to services essential to sustaining the quality of life in Collier County. Naples Senior Center does so through a local not for profit agency funded by local philanthropy, operated by local professionals and managed by a Board of local community leaders without any financial support from local government. Naples Senior Center's proposed consolidation of the 13.6± Acres Assemblage into a unified plan of development which minimizes and mitigates external impacts on the surrounding area will provide a significant degree of control, cohesion and compatibility that four potentially disparate individual applications for nonresidential uses on each of the four component tax parcels will not provide. STATUTORY CRITERIA FOR PLAN AMENDMENTS Under Chapter 163 F.S., local governments are authorized to adopt and amend their comprehensive plans. Staff has requested that the applicant address three sections from Chapter 163. Chapter 163.3167 Scope of act. — (9) Each local government shall address in its comprehensive plan, as enumerated in this chapter, the water supply sources necessary to meet and achieve the existing and projected water use demand for the established planning period, considering the applicable plan developed pursuant to s. 373.709. The applicant intends to work with Collier County Water -Sewer District to extend potable water and sewer services to the subject site. There is potable water and sewer available to the nearby existing First Congregational Church and within Autumn Oaks Lane. There are no existing or anticipated capacity issues for water and sewer services for the project. Water supply sources necessary to meet and achieve the existing and projected water use demand for the next 10 years are identified in the Ten -Year Water Supply Facilities Work Plan, December 19, 2019 ® gradyllinol, Page 6 of 8 NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx G10 Engiriurs • Lund Snn•cyoN . I'IanoCrs • Landscapc 'ki,0111('0"; Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Fl, 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria dated February 2019 and incorporated by reference into the Potable Water Sub -Element of the Public Facilities Element of the GMP via Ordinance No. 19-06. Chapter 163.3177 (6) (a) 2. The future land use plan and plan amendments shall be based upon surveys, studies, and data regarding the area, as applicable, including: a. The amount of land required to accommodate anticipated growth. b. The projected permanent and seasonal population of the area. c. The character of undeveloped land. d. The availability of water supplies, public facilities, and services. e. The need for redevelopment, including the renewal of blighted areas and the elimination of nonconforming uses which are inconsistent with the character of the community. f. The compatibility of uses on lands adjacent to or closely proximate to military installations. g. The compatibility of uses on lands adjacent to an airport as defined in s. 330.35 and consistent with s. 333.02. h. The discouragement of urban sprawl. i. The need for job creation, capital investment, and economic development that will strengthen and diversify the community's economy. j. The need to modify land uses and development patterns within antiquated subdivisions. The 8.7± acres is the amount of land required to permit development of the proposed senior center, and to provide ample setbacks and enhanced buffers. The market analysis and senior demand studies provided with the application documents the demand for the proposed senior centers services. Chapter 163.3177 8. Future land use map amendments shall be based upon the following analyses: a. An analysis of the availability of facilities and services. b. An analysis of the suitability of the plan amendment for its proposed use considering the character of the undeveloped land, soils, topography, natural resources, and historic resources on site. c. An analysis of the minimum amount of land needed to achieve the goals and requirements of this section. Public infrastructure is available to be extended to service the site. A portion of the property is currently developed with a warehouse/storage building. The property is comprised of 4 parcels of land of which 8.7± acres is included in the small-scale plan amendment. 163.3184 Process for adoption of comprehensive plan or plan amendment. December 19, 2019 W G rady1l1 nor Page 7 of 8 NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx f;ivll Engiriurs • Lund Snn•cyoN . I'lanoCrs • Landscapc 'ki'0111('0"; Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.D.1(3) Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Chapter 163 F.S. Criteria This Section of the statute outlines the process and authority for the agency review of plan amendments. The applicant understands that regional and state reviewing agencies will be responsible for review of any transmitted comprehensive plan amendment per the requirements of Chapter 163.3184 F.S. The applicant's experts are of the opinion that there are no regional or state impacts associated with the application. CONCLUSION The proposed senior center use will fill an unmet need in the Collier County area at a location that serves its seniors who reside from North Naples to Marco Island. The site has direct access to Valewood Drive, which is a signalized intersection offering full controlled traffic movements with easy access to 1-75 and other north/south arterial corridors such as Logan Boulevard, Livingston Road and Collier Boulevard. The proposed text amendment includes language that requires a PUD rezoning and unified master plan of development, which will allow for a uniform plan for development at this intersection and it will include provisions for enhanced buffering and site -specific development standards. Access points to the site can be accommodated to lessen vehicle trips on Oakes Boulevard. Water and sewer services are not currently available at the property but will be extended to the Property. The small-scale amendment is further supported and the need at this location is demonstrated by a market analysis and study prepared by Florida Gulf Coast University which address the significant need in the Collier County for senior services which are provided by NSC, a not for profit agency. The study also contains a demographic and zip code analysis of membership, which identifies that a great number of the members are located in the North Naples area and east of Airport Road. The Property provides convenient access for that demographic to Immokalee Road via Valewood Drive. December 19, 2019 W G radyll i nor Page s of s NSCOB Exhibit VD1(3) Comp Plan Consistency-rev4.docx G10 Engiriurs • Lund Svn-cyoN • I'IannCrs • Lf111d8Cajw 'XF0111f.0"; Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Fl, 34134 • 239-947-1 144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Exhibit V.D.1(4) Needs Assessment of Seniors: Trends from 2012 to Present PREPARED FOR: JFCS and the Naples Senior Center IT f PREPARED BY - Dr. Thomas R Felke, MSW Department of Social Work Florida Gulf Coast University Executive Sum mary Est i m at es p red i ct : M ore seniors are I ivi ng alone More seniors are living in poverty M ore senior households are receiving SNAP benefits Sen i ors say: They do not know how/whereto find information They feel like a forgotten group and are not recognized as a population in need of services/supports Study Purpose Conduct ad escriptivestudy using am ixed methods approach focused on the current needs of seniors Expand the findings of the2012 needs assessment Larger geographic area (94 census tracts vs. 53 origi nal Iy) Additional target variables Larger sample of focus group participants Methods- QuantitativeAnalysis Updated demographic profile from 2012 study Examined an expanded geographic area More of Collier County as wel I as Bonita Springs and Estero Vari ety of d ata sou rces Primarily American Community Survey 90 variables gathered at census tract level Utilized datafrom existing senior centers Methods - Qualitative Gathered new qualitative information from seniors More focus groups (8 vs. 2 originally) Larger participant response (108 vs. 20 on gi nal Iy) Resident and seasonal seniors included From Bonita Springs, Estero, Golden Gate, & Naples Population Estimates -Age 60 and Over Large projected increases in population age 60 and over 011-201 2011-2015 County 2011 2015 Numeric Percent Change Change Collier , �. � � •� 1'. Lee MA :. 1 •• ' . Population Estimates -Age 60 and Over Slightly higher population of femaleversus male Collier County - 47.1% male; 52.9% female Lee County - 49.0% male; 51.0% female Similar to figures from 2011 with more change in Lee County Col I i er County - 47.2% male; 52.8% f em al e Lee County - 47.0% male; 53.0% female Population Projections -Age 60 and Over Two sets of population projections report significant increases through year 2040 Sh i m berg Center - 74.7% i n crease FL Bu reau of Econom i c and Busi ness Research - 49.4% i ncrease Higher increases predicted forth e age group 75 and over 116.9% in Collier County 141.8% in Lee County Living Alone -Age65 and Over Seemingly small percentage changes But, i n cr eases i n both co u n t i es d u e to i n cr easi n g p o p u I at i o n s Population Estimates - Age 65 and Over Living Alone Majority of householdswith senior living alone are along the coastlines of Collier and Lee Counties Highest pockets are in Col I i er County Three of the census tracts are near the Naples Senior Center, which once again is the bullseye of the target of need Poverty -Age 60 and Over Large percentage changes Again, increases in both counties due to increasing populations Likely coupled with increased costs of living 2r"IN: 011 2015 FPercent FNumeric Chan e Change (Collier � 1 � . • 1: � • 1' . 1 Lee 'M� .. .'. Population Estimates-Age60 and Over in Poverty Highest tract located within Naples area between US41 and Collier Blvd. Exceptions: Immokaleeand Marco Island/Goodland Two census tracts with high concentrations located in Bonita Springs Remainder is outside of the study catchment area SANIVIAP Households -Age 60 and Over Large percentage changes Again, increases in both countiesdueto increasing populations Likely coupled with increased costsof living r"Vor 201 2015 PerceAeF Numeric ChanChan e (Collier re e �lOtal ��� •:.' . . 1 Food Insecurity Issues Direct data on food insecurity among seniors is not available from Feeding America or any other source. Col I aborative efforts have found: In 2013 nearly 1 in 12 seniors had limited accessto food. 13 m i I I ion older ad u Its age 50+received assistance from the Feeding America network in 2015. Food insecure seniors consume fewer key nutrients& are more likely to develop adverse health conditions, such as asthma, diabetes and heart problems Poverty &SNAP Household Correlation Some correlation between the census tracts with high concentrations of poverty and thosewith high concentrations of SNAP benefit receipt 19 census tracts fall into the two highest indicator categories of poverty concentration 14 census tracts fall into the two highest i n d i cat o r categories of SN A P b en of i t r ecei p t 7 census tracts fall into the two highest indicator categories for both variables Participant Data -Naples Senior Center Active Registrants: 1,186 Av er ag e A g.e: 78.1 75.7% Fern ale Gen d er : 24.3% Male Resi d en ce: LivesAlone: 89.9% Nap I es 2.4% Bonita 0.8% Fort Myers 0.4% Marco I sl and 170% Participant Data -Golden Gate Senior Center Active Registrants: 1796 Av er ag e A g.e: Gen d er: Resi d en ce: 72.1 64.7% Fern ale 34.8% Male 97.1% Naples 0.6% Bonita 0.6% Immokalee 0.6% M arco I sl and LivesAlone: I Not available Qualitative Data: Focus Groups Total of 8 Focus Groupswith 108 Participants Golden Gate (2 groups) Naples (3 groups) Vi I I age of Estero (3 grou ps) Sessions scheduled on Marco Island and Bonita Springswere cancelled dueto lack of registration Focus Group Participant Demographics A ge (al 1 60+)— 70-79 (59.7%) Pr i m ar i I y Fem al e (78.4%) Mostly full -time Florida residents (91.8%) Majority are retired (76.4%) Race/Ethnicity-White/Caucasian (59.4%) Marital Status —Married (42.9%); Widowed (32.1%); Divorced (19.6%) Identified Problems Ph y si cal H eal t h - 57.4% Feel i n g s of Isolation /Loneliness - 32.0% Having too few activities or feeling bored - 31.3% Performing everyday activities - 30.0% Having financial problems-22.4% Provid i ng care for another person - 21.7% Food insecurity - 12.5% Only 1.8% receive home delivered meals Focus Group Participant Reporting Programs most requested Recreational activities (41.7%) Wel I ness programs (35.7%) Adult Education programs (35.7%) Most participants utilize traditional media as sources of information N ew sp ap er ',• • Television Focus Group Discussion Themes General perceived strengths of life in SW Florida Easy local travel and proximity to Southwest FloridaAirport Good weather, allowing for outdoor activities Availability of restaurants, shopping and public libraries General perceived weaknesses of life in SN Florida Lack of communication regarding programsand services Seniors not being recognized as a population of need Concerns over affordable housing Focus Group Discussion Themes Inclusion of a "senior section" in local newspapers Availability of information in Spanish (Golden Gate specifically) Further development of classesfor seniorson Internet, email and computer/tablet use Development of adult/senior day care programs and support programs for caregivers Seniors should be a priority, particularly of government entities Development of affordable housing The establishment of a senior center in t h e V i l l ag e of Estero Center Specific Themes -Naples Senior Center Wonderful variety of programming Good information sessionsfrom community partners Opportunity to meet peoplefrom acrossthe United States Need bulletin boardswith information about community -based events Need morespacedueto crowding Develop a better system for parking Center Specific Themes -Golden Gate Senior Center Thankful for caring staff and companionship Availability of information about community events Lunch menu should be changed to incorporate H ispanic culture Need indoor on -site food pantry; too hot and have to com pete w ith others at mobile pantry in parking lot Have moreactivities like bingo, dancing and some held outsideof Center Improve transportation options to Center Add more volunteers and specific trainings on topicssuch ascomputers, English and legal rights Utilize the computers and TV for programming Location Specific Themes -Village of Estero Positive about the quality of life in the Village Good access to restaurants, stores, the public I i brary, Koreshan State Park and the Estero River Expressed need for more programming for seniors Concerns about a lack of communication regarding existing programs Recommended shared programming through partnerships with FGCU and its Renaissance Academy and Lee Health through its Share Club Suggestion that the development of asenior center could coincide with the development of either the planned Village Center or the Lee Health medical village Future Impact Possibilities Unknown if general i n cr ease i n 60+population will result in specific i n cr ease of individualswho will experience poverty, food insecurity and social isolation. Impact of the current state of the housing market and daily costs of living on population growth unclear. Variables need to be monitored while the proactive development of programs and services targeting 60+ population will also need to be considered. mammary of Findings There are more individuals living in poverty, living alone and more households receiving SNAP benefits. Individuals report having difficulty accessing information about programs and services that may be of assistance. Sample of individuals (age 60+) report that they do not feel) they are considered a population of need. There are concerns about affordable housing among the sample of groups participating in the focus grou ps. Recommendations First Priority Expansion of capacity of existing senior centers, specifically the Naples Senior Center due to both high enrollment and provided feedback. Expansion of capacity of senior centers to accommodate increase in 60+ population. Second Priority Establish better communication of programsand servicesfor senior population. Third Priority Golden Gateand Naples Senior Centersshould conduct aformal evaluation of their services and activities. Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002621 Exhibit V.E Public Facilities Level of Service Analysis Provide the existing Level of Service Standard (LOS) and document the impact the proposed change will have on the following public facilities: The proposed Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict is an undeveloped 8.7± acre parcel. The Subdistrict proposes up to 30,000 square feet of community facility uses on approximately 8.7± acres. The property is zoned Estates and currently permits single-family homes at 1 du/2.25 acres. The property would support up to 4_single family homes under the current plan designation. The property is currently developed with a 4,700± square foot industrial warehouse building. The public facilities analysis evaluates the project impacts on potable water, wastewater, drainage, parks, schools, roadways, fire/EMS, and solid waste. The source for the LOS information is the 2018 AUIR. Potable Water The property is located within the Collier County potable water service area. Potable water service will be extended to the site. The County has existing plant capacity of approximately 52 mgd. The proposed addition of 30,000 square feet of general commercial uses will not create any LOS issues in the 5-year planning horizon. The level of service standard for Policy 1.5 of the GMP is based on population; therefore, the project will have no impact on potable water facilities. The project will be serviced by water, but will not impact water treatment capacity. Sanitary Sewer The subject project is located within the service boundary of Collier County utilities with standards for Sanitary Sewer established in the Capital Improvement Element of the Collier County Growth Management Plan. Sanitary sewer service will be extended to the property. This Project will have no significant impact on potable water and wastewater treatment system levels of service. The LOS standards are based on residential usage; therefore, this project will have no impact on the County's sanitary sewer system. The project may be serviced by sewer, but will not impact wastewater treatment capacity. Arterial and Collector Roads Please refer to the Traffic Impact Statement for discussions of the project's impact on level of service for arterial and collector roadways within the project's radius of development influence. October 24, 2019 Page 1 of 3 NSCOB ExhibitVE-rev3.docx ® GradyMinor Civil f•;nginurs • band Svneyor; • k'Itmnens • I.anflti['apt- vc1im,cts Q. Grady minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002621 Exhibit V.E Public Facilities Level of Service Analysis Drainage The County has adopted a LOS standard for private developments which requires development to occur consistent with water quantity and quality standards established in Ordinances 74-50, 90-10, 2001-27, and LDC Ordinance 2004-41, as may be amended. An environmental Resource Permit (ERP) issued by the South Florida Water Management District will be required, which has established criteria for the volume of water stored on site as well as the quality of the water, which may be discharged from the site. The development within the subdistrict will be consistent with the County LOS standards. Solid Waste The adopted LOS for solid waste is two years of lined cell capacity at the previous 3 year average tons per year disposal rate and 10 years of permittable landfill capacity of the disposal rate. There are no current capacity issues and none are anticipated through the year 2067. Existing: .42 Ib/sf/day disposal rate 4,704 sf x .42 Ib/sf/day = 19.75 lb/day x 365 = 7,211 lb/year Proposed: Community Facility 30,000 x 5 Ibs/1,000 sq ft = 150 Ibs/day x 365 = 57,750 Ibs/year or 27 tons/year Current landfill capacity in 2018 is anticipated to be 17,001,964 tons. Total Permitted Landfill Capacity Remaining, 2017 17,244,316 Tons Required Permitted Landfill Capacity, 2017 2,625,495 Tons Total Lined Cell Capacity Remaining, 2017 2,372,915 Tons Required Lined Cell Capacity, 2017 490,736 Tons Source: Collier County 2018 AUIR Cal Recycle Parks: Community and Regional Parks impact fees are not assessed for commercial development or schools. No adverse impacts to Community or Regional Parks result from the amendment of the subdistrict. October 24, 2019 Page 2 of 3 NSCOB ExhibitVE-rev3.docx ® GradyMinor Civil f•;nginurs • band Svneyor; • I'Itmners • I.all(ticapt. Vchilcrls Q. Grady minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002621 Exhibit V.E Public Facilities Level of Service Analysis Crhnnlc School impact fees are not assessed for commercial development or schools. No adverse impacts to schools result from the creation of the subdistrict. Fire Control and EMS The proposed project lies within the North Collier Fire Rescue District. The North Collier Fire Rescue District - Station #42 is located at 7010 Immokalee Rd, which is approximately one mile from the northern property boundary. No significant impacts to Fire Control level of service are anticipated due to the proposed project. Estimated impact fees for EMS and fire would be determined at time of SDP based on each unit. Sheriff, Fire Protection and EMS Services location/address of facilities intended to serve the project are; North Collier Fire Rescue District - Station #42 7010 Immokalee Rd Collier County Sheriff's Office - District 2 (Golden Gate City Substation) 4707 Golden Gate Parkway October 24, 2019 Page 3 of 3 NSCOB ExhibitVE-rev3.docx ® GradyMinor Civil f•;nginurs • band Svneyor; • k'Itmnens • I.an&'capt- xrrli Itcct,� Q. Grady minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com m I cs CH Healthca a Northeast: H merge cy Dep t NCH North Na le Ho pi al IM K CAD ® ® .If Coast FNart N les to io 45 O Laurel Oak Veterans a k m U� Oakridge F— J orth Collier fRegional C D Park G SUBJECT —ice_ CD PROPERTY--, Pelican Marsh _ rehter Nopl s Fire Rescae— St ' J—�jt— VAN E ILT BEACH RCA � I ne r s --�— Vine a Commu LEGEND ® SCHOOLS eadquaders Way" ❑ PARKS O F FIRE STATIONS 0 D E EMERGENCY MEDICAL STATIONS GOVERNMENT BUILDINGS * SHERIFF'S STATIONS AND C SUBSTATIONS F— G LIBRARIES Q WATER TREATMENT PLANTS H PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEMS AND HOSPITALS p EXISTING OR MODIFIED ®Osceola WATER RETENTION STRUCTURES SOLID WASTE FACILITIES - j ®Barra Collier 0 2000' 4000' } WASTEWATER TREATMENT SCALE: " = 14000' PLANTS u Physia i I Pine 1"'1 Ridge NAPLES SENIOR CENTER S`'� <.e. P.A. 6rUtlyMinormids„ar1, COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT roB1CCoDE: R=eaB De. GradyMinor :IB96 ��� not Rey Fiorillo Springy. Fwrfda 31134 DATE: Civil Engineers Land Surveyors Planners Architects EXHIBIT V.E. FEBRU— 2019 — xeeo:: NSCOB a„,BR I Ce. of Auth. EB 0005151 Cert. of Auth. LB 0005151 Cert. Bonita Springs: 239.947.1144 o w w. Gra dy44in Business LC 26000266 o r. nn In Fort Myers: 239.690.4380 PUBLIC FACILITIES MAP SHEET 1 OF 1 u ocucogn tnveiope Iu. juzjtoyior-C bo i-4C5tu-Ct5r- i-Syutoot5000mt5 JMB TRANSPORTATION E I`iII EERING, INIC. TRAFFIC" 1'R A NSPORTATMIN FNr..I #EERING do PLArVNING SERVICES TRAFFIC IMPACT STATEMENT For Naples Senior Center (Autumn Oaks Lane, Culfier County, Florida) March 25, 2019 Revised January 29,2020 Prepared by- BTRANSPORTATION EN[B1NI=CRING, IND. 4711 7TH AVEMLIE SW NAPLEB, FLORIDA 3+41 1 9 CERTIFICATE of AurHMRkzA-rinri No_ 2783a � *�#;;;.� 111 rf rr rrrr,rr*fi PROJECT ND. 1 8091 1 �octi gnedby: ' 1 `• i } E5,9D679023E47F... i0 4386 ' yk k } -MU-0 D STATE OF JnraEs aesx PEE FLIdRI REG. [ r96'' -} DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB TABLE OF CONTENTS Conclusions 2 Table A - northbound Queue @ Valewuod & Itt mokalec 3 Scope of Project 3 Table B - Proposed Land Use 3 Figure I - Location Map 3.1 Site plan 3.2 Project Generated Traffic 4 Table (l) - Existing Site -Generated Trips (Wednesdays) 4 Table C(2) - Existing Site enerated Trips (Mon,, Tues, Thurs, Fri) 4 Table D(1) - Anticipated Site -Generated Trips (Wednesdays) 5 Fable D(2) - Anticipated Site- enerated Trips (Mon, Tuts, Thurs, F'ri) 5 Table I - Existing Site -Generated Trips (4'ednesdays) 5.1 Table 113 - Existing Site-Crenerated Trips (Mon, Tues, Thurs, Fri) 5.2 Figure T1A - Existing Site -{generated Trips (Wednesdays) 5. Figure TIB - Existing Site -Generated Trips (Moo, Tues, Thurs, Fri) 5.4 Figure 12A - Projected Site -Generated Trips (Wednesdays) 5.5 Figure T2 B — Projected Site -Generated Trips (Mon, Tues, Thurs, Fri) 5.6 Existing + Committed load Network Project Traffic Distribution 7 Area of Significant Impact 7 Figure ZA - Project Traffic Distribution 7.1 Table 2 - Area of IrnpactfRoad Classification 7.2 Figure 2B - AM Project Traffic Assignments 7.3 Figure 2 - Mid -Day Project 'Traffic Assignments 7.4 Figure 2€l - PA4 Project Traffic Assignments 7.5 2019 thru 2021 Project Build -out Traffic Conditions h Table 3 - 2019 & 2021 Link Volumes 8.1 Table 4 - 2021 LinkVolumes/Capacity Analysis 8. Appendix 9 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB conclusions Based upon the findings of this report, it was determined that the proposed Naples Senior Center will not have a negative impact upon the surrounding road network. It was v.unfled that all roadways and intersections, within the praject's area of influence, currently have a surplus of capacity and can acconvnodate the traffic associated with the senior community center. As determined, tho road network will continue to operate at acceptable levels of service for 2021 project build -out conditions and the project Aill not create any off -site transportation deficiencies that steed to be mitigated. In support of the report's findings. traflic demand observations were performed on several occasions and during AM, Mid -day and PM peak hours at the intersections of: 1. Oakes Boulevard & Autumn Oaks, 2. Valewood Drivc & Autumn Oaks Larne, 3. Valewood Drive & Immokalee Road, and 4. Oakes Boulevard & Irnmokalee Road. During the various observations, it was confirmed that the intersections of Oakes Boulevard & Autumn Oaks Lane and Valewood Drive & Autumn Dales Lane function at very high levels of service with mWrnal delay incurred by drivers. The westbound-to- southbound left turn movement at Oakes Boulevard & Imrnokalee Road was recently eliminated and those left turn movements are now accommodated at the signalized intersection of Valewood Drive & Immokalee Road and at the signalized intersection of Tarpon Bay & Immokalee road. The site's primary point of access to the adjacent road network will be aligned with the intersection of Valowood Drive & Autumn Oaks Late. A detailed analysis of the projeef s impacts on this intersection were performed based upon the guidelines established by the Highway Capacity Manual. -l-he results of the analysis are provided in the appendix (refer to pages Al thru A3). As determinad, the intersection will operate at LOS A daring AM, mid -day and PM peak hour peak season conditions. The intersection of Valewood Drive & lrnmokalee Road functions as expected. More specifically, the signalized traffic control operation is for a major arterial that is intersected by minor side streets. The major arterial carries a high volume of duu traffic and the minor side streets accommodate a much lower demand. The priority is the movement of thus traffic on the major road, and therefore, those approaches are assigned longer green times, but the traffic signal still reasonably accommodates the side street demand- As observed, the northbound approach/queue at the intersection of Valewood Drive & Immokalee Road cleared on every complete cycle, which are timed as three (3) minutes during AM and PM peak hours and two and onle-half (2.5) minutes during mid- day peak hours. It was observed that other than waiting for the northbound approach green phase to occur, motorists experienced no extended periods of delay. In response to concerns expressed by the Oakes residents, a queue recurrence analysis was performed for the northbound approach at Valewood Drive & Imirno Calee Road for DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB peak hour peak season and project build -out conditions. The queue analysis was based upon the Florida Department of Transportation's (FDOT) adopted methodology which is based upon the NationaI Cooperative Highway Research Program's Transportation Research Board (NC R 279 method) as follows: (2.0) (DHV)( 5')IN Q = turn lane storage DI -IV = turn lane volume N = number of traffic signal cycles per hour The intersection's northbound left turn lane and the thrulright turn lane each have a maximum queue capacity of300'. Based upon the maximum cycle length of three (3 minutes for the AM and PNI peak hours and two and one-half (2.5) minutes for the mid- day and the estimated project build -out peals hour traffic demands depicted on Figures 2B, 2C and 2D, and the conservative assumption that northbound right turns on red will not occur and applying the recommended adjustment factor of two (2), it can be concluded that both the left and thrulrigbt turn lanes provide adequate storage to acc011`nmodate the background plus project traffic demands. The results of the queue "ysis are sornrnarized in Table A. Table Northbound Queue a Valewood drive & lmmokalee Road NB i.e#t Turn NR Left Tum NB Thru/Right NB Thnil ight Peak Hour Demand Queue Tom Demand Tur11 Queue AM 35 vph 4 Vehicles - 100' 57 vph 6 Vehicles - 150' (33% queue capacity) (50% queue capac4) Mid -Day 109 vph 9 Vehicles - 2 5' 74 vph 6 Vehicles - 150' (75% queue capacity) fJO% queue capacity) PM 36 vph 4 Vehicles - 100' 72 vph 7 Vehicles - 175' (33% queue capacity) (58% queue capacity) Scope of Project !Naples Senior Center is an existing senior cormnunity facility that is seeking to relocate from its current location (i.e., 5029 Castello Drive) to a site that is located on the southeast corner of Autu= Oaks Lane Lac Oakes Boulevard. The proposed site and facility wi I better accommodate the senior center's existing needs and aliow for an increase to membership as the demand for these type of human need services in Collier County grows. Table B Proposed and Use (pro oscd Land Use Size Senior Care, Center 30,000 s.f. 3 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB M ■ N Imrrokalee Rd 4 r$ n � 0 `o v 11 0 } 3 O Si m O � O� a� � a c � O c } Vanderbilt Ecach Rd M1 I z Autumn Doke bane Hidden Oaks Lane Spanish Oaks Lone Immaswlee Rtl Cowen Disks Lune v Q 4} C a NORTI I N.F.S. Wolfe Road v m m EL Vanderbilt Beon Rd —qmm�a ImEmbommm � � ) � � � � � � � � � IOR TRAMBPORTATIum ENGINEERING, ENO, Naples Senior Center Ocotber 3. 2018 LEGEND INr Rs1ATE HIOwAT 5-LAME ARTERIAL #^LAME ARTERML/M-1-LUIOR ----- 2-LAME ARTERIAL 2-UWE COLLECTOR/LOCAL FML ROC Project Location & I Roadway Classification FIGURE � WiN I I I < I I VALEVIIQOD DR. 70 r � E. IMMOKALEE RD. r i E. I I ESTATES (SIGNALarD I# TERSECTICIN I O I ESTATES RESIDENTIAL I Q I CHURCH I I I g l GI -} 1------------- ---------------- AU7'UT7hN Of4i4S LANE lie MINIMUM 20` WOE TYPE 'D' MINIMUM 3(' VWIUE TYPE V PROPERTY- �r RIGHT-W LANDSCAPE BUrF5R LANDSCAPE BUFFER � x—PROPERTY BOUNDARY BOUNDARY RIGHT -CUT ONLY I I � r 1 � 1 t PARKING OPEN SPACE w E. PARKING AREA BUILDINGAR AREA � ESTATES RESIEF- 7MAL I w .w ESTATES Li MiNIWM "OOT-WIDE RESIDENTIAL MINIMUM 2q" WIDE TYF?E LANDSCAPE BUFFER � 'D LANDSCAPE BUFF � �, * � EASEMENT SEE HATE 02)1 � V EAQEEIIT * 'PRESERVE AREA ,v w %v 1p w 4 y *v RIG HT -OF -WAY � IV W EASEMENT I, 1. MINIMUM SS VNIDE TYPE lV � I LANDSCAPE BUFFER # + I I E,ESTATE$ I I M07ORCYCLE REPAIR AND SERVICE, RESJDEHTJAL 1 I I I E. ESTATES I I REMDENTIAi I I 25 t i I SCALE: V = 150' YAf N p�011'EO $ -0.i X 7 7 ].ESiF ID MAPLES SE W&R CE20'E 7 {'F'PUD - 2 GradyMinor Sean` u.e nt rx� il,x,llabyl�p. b4"� iN Baia ClwilBpltluesle WW,%nvyum namfL&N LamMfW.Ara-+lnrle %III�R I; WAWA r..,rw►oawaa 0r w�i3i br Le aoavrLL MASTER PLAN arus ww 2ND11.1141 F+ Lkn* *)o&M OFm SHIrr t 6f DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Project Generated Traffic Traffic that can be expected to be generated by the Naples Senior Center was estimated based upon the existing site -generated trips at the Maples Senior 'Center located at 5029 Castello Drive, Maples, Florida. Traffic data was collected for the senior cenwes busiest recuning day of the week (Wednesday), as well as a typical operations day, which is represented by data that was collected on Thursday. Data was collected on September 2, 018 and on March 20, 2019, and again on January 9, 2020. Of the three (3) days surveyed, the highest demand occurred on March 0', and on that day, there were a total of 242 people that visited the site (i.e., 196 members, 22 volunteers and 24 staffs. On Thursday, January 9, 2020. there were a total of 199 people that visited the site. The ingresslegress trips were observed at the site and at a nearby off -site parking lot. Table IA and Table 1 B (page 4.1 and page 4.2) summarize the data collected on Wednesday, March 20, 2019 and Thursday, January 9, 2020, respectively, which has been quantified in Table C(l) and Table 2) below. As observed, the peak demand site -generated two- way trips were 41 vph and 25 vph during the AM and PM peals hours, and the peak demand occurred mid -day, which was 157 vph. Table C (1) Existing Site -Generated Trips (Wed n esdays) Peak Day Peak Day Peak Day Peak Day Total People AM Peak ?-lour Mid -Day Pk 1 I PM ftak Dour On -Site (VA) (vph) v 11 `trips Generated 242 41 157 25 (5029 Castello Drive) 36 enter! 5 exit 36 enter1121 exit 1 enterl24 exit Table C () Existing Site- cnerated Trips (Mon, Tues, Thurs & Fri days) Peak Day €'cak Day Peak Day Leak Day Total People AM Peak 1 lour Mid -Day Pk iir phi Peak Dour on -Site (vp11) 20 (vph) (v 11) I Trips Generated 198 59 19 (5029 Castello Drive) 20 enter/ 0 exit 23 enter/36 exit 0 enter/19 exit As previously mentioned, the Senior Center's rec using busiest day of the week is Wednesday and the proposed site on Autumn Oaks is expected to accommodate up to 485 total people Ox., members ,+- volunteers + guests). Therefore, the anticipated site generated trips are expected to be double the volume currently generated on Wednesdays at the Castello Drive site. Table D(l) and Table D(2) summarize the anticipated site - generated trips that will occur on Wednesdays during peals season and peals attendance conditions and typical operation conditions, which occur on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays and Fridays. 4 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Table D(1) Anticipated Site -Generated Trips (Wednesdays) — Pcak Day Peak Day Peak Day Peak Day Total People ,AM Peak Hour Mid -Day Pk [fir Pert Peak Hour On -Site v Y h 1ti Trips Generated 435 82 314 50 (Proposed Site) 72 enter/ [0 exit 72 enter/242 exit 2 enter/48 exit Table ID(Z) AnticipatedSite-Generated Trips (Mon, Tres, Thurs & Fridays) Peak Day Peak 6a-yF Pcak Day Peak Day Total People AM Peak I [our slid -Day Pk Fir PM Peak I four On -Site v h v h v it Trips Generated 485 49 145 47 (Prapesed Site) 49 enter/ 0 exit 57 enter/88 exit 0 enterf47 exit The report cnrcludes that the project will geneTate more than 100 net new trip ends during the weekday highest peak hour. As sued, the report investigates the traffic impacts associated with the project based upon the criteria set forth by the Collier County Government's Traffic Impact Statement Guidelines for developments generating "more than 100 trips", which is defined as a major study. DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB I BDie 1A Naples Senior Center Date of Count: March 20, 2019 Site -Generated Trips Wenestlay (Total staff+ volunteers + guests = 242 people on -site) Pk Hour A Hour Start Time 7:00 AM 7, IS AIM 7:31) Ai l 7:45 AM 9, DO A 9, 15 AM 6:30 AM 9:45 AIM s:DD AM 9:15 AM 9:30 AIM 9:45 AM 10:00 AM 10:15 AM 10:30 AM 10:45 AIM 1x:00 AM 11:15 AM 11:30 AM 11:45 A 12.00 PM 1115 PM 12:30 PM 12,45 PM 1:00 PM 1,15 PM 1.30 PM 1:45 PM 2:00 PM L15 PM 2:30 PM 2:45 PM 3100 PM 3-15 P 3:30 P 3;45 PM 4:00 PM 4:15 PM 4:30 PM 4:45 PM 5:00 P 5'15 PM 5,30 PM 5:45 PM Eater Exit (Orr -Site Parking, 0 D D 0 0 1 1 0 0 3 2 3 0 4 0 9 3 3 2 15 4 1z 5 17 3 15 5 11 6 9 3 10 7 7 1 3 0 4 0 7 1 0 0 3 13 6 27 15 35 12 23 4 8 7 6 5 9 3 6 7 3 6 4 3 5 0 3 0 2 0 2 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 7 0 12 0 1 0 0 0 3 Enter Exit (Off --Site Parking) D o 0 � 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2 0 6 0 8 0 2 0 o a 0 0 o 0 o D 5 0 3 0 5 0 3 � 0 0 D 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 4 0 10 0 7 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q 0 0 0 D 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 1} 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Enter Exit Enter Exit (Total) (Total) (Total) (Total) 0 4 I� 1 0 4 5 10 17 5 15 12 17 15 16 12 15 10 3 4 7 0 3 5 35 12 4 7 5 3 7 6 3 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 D 0 0 a 0 0 1 0 2 0 D 3 2 3 5 3 5 6 3 6 1 0 0 1 0 i5 31 45 30 14 6 8 6 3 4 5 3 2 2 1 0 4 7 12 1 0 3 36 so 36 1 5 19 121 74 . A DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB I aQle 10 Naples Senior Center Date of Count: January 9, 2020 Site -Generated Trips Thursday (Toro; stq#+ volunteers + guests = 1.98 geoP?e on-.0tej Pk Hour PAC dour Start Time 7;00 A 7,15 A 7:30 AM 7:45 AM 8:00 AM 8:15 AM 49'30 AM .8.45 AM 9:00 AM 9'15 ANC 9:30 AAA 9:45 AM 10:00 AM 10-15 AM 10:34 AM 10:45 A 11:00 AM 11:1S AAA 11*30 AM 11*45 A 12:00 PM 12:15 PM 12:30 PM 12-45 PM 1:p0 PM 1:15 PM 1:30 PM 1:45 PM 2:00 PM 2:15 PM 2:30 PM 2:45 PM 3=0D PM 3:15 PM 3:30 P 3:45 P 4:00 PM 4:15 VNI 4*30 €' 4-45 PSI 5.00 PM 5:15 P 5-30 P 5:45 PM Enter Exit (Ors -Site Parking 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 0 4 0 7 0 4 0 3 0 7 3 7 1 6 3 b 4 5 5 2 0 4 6 7 10 7 2 13 4 4 3 2 2 3 2 5 5 3 5 4 5 fi 5 4 7 5 5 7 8 7 11 5 11 4 6 Q 5 0 5 1 5 0 S 0 6 0 4- 0 4 Q 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Eater Exit (Off --Site Parking) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 3 0 2 0 0 4 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 � 0 0 0 0 0 00 +y 0 S+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Eater Exit Enter Exit (Total) {Total} (Total) (Total) 0 0 5 4 7 4 3 7 7 6 5 2 4 7 7 13 6 S 5 5 3 4 6 4 5 7 7 5 4 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 1 3 4 5 0 6 10 2 4 3 2 2 9 5 S 7 5 11 11 6 5 5 5 5 6 0 Q C? 20 24 33 19 23 13 19 27 36 0 19 0 0 U� 60 5 Wednesdays Existing Peak Season 50 a 45 40 35 30 31 r 30 5 2 17 17 16 15 15 , v 'a r_ 12 10 i0 1e, s � s s � r 7 7 $ 7 k4f r ## 3 2 2 t i 1 1 1 LEGEND 7 AM 8 AM 9 AAA 10 AM 11 AM I�j Noon1 PM 2 PM 3 PM 4 PM 5 PM Enl edilg 1Cripe HOUR OF DAY Naples Senior Center Existing Site -Generated Traffic Figure TI-A Januory 2D. 2020 0 0 0 0 c 0 m 0 m 0 cu Mon, Tues, Thurs & Fridays Existing Peak Season 50 4 4 3 n 3 �- 2 15 10 5 — _-LEND Entering Trips Exiling TriPS 0 7 AM 8 AM 9 AM 10 AM 11 AM Noon 1 PM 2 PM 3 PM 4 PM 5 PM HOUR F DAY 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 m 0 cu VI . Wednesdays Future Peak Season 8 7FJ 70 6 a� BQ 5 50 V) 45 CL 40 35 34 N a 32 3 30 3a 20 27 25 2+ 24 A 24 20° �e 4 14 14 �4 t 10 a 1 0 a e s s a a s## a 5 � LEGENDi EMm6ng Trips 7 AM 8 AM 9 AM 10 AM 11 AM Noon 1 PM 2 PM 3 PM 4 PM 5 PM Exilffiq UPS Naples Senior Center Projected Site -Generated Traffic Figure T-A January 0, 2020 0 0 0 0 c m m 0 cu Yl Mon, Tues, Thurs & Fridays Future Peak Season LEGEND Entering Trips Exiting Tripe 50 45 40 35 n 30 25 20 15 1C 5 7 AM 8 AM 9 AM 10 AM 11 AM Noon 1 PEA 2 PM 3 PM 4 PM 5 PM HOUR OF DAY 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 m 0 cu DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB F%,sling - Committed Road Network Table 2 A provides a detail of the surrounding E + C road network and their respective minimum level of service performance standards and capacity. Immokatee Roadis classified as a six -lane divided arterial. The road functions as a primary cast/west interconnect between northwest Collier County and northern Golden Gate Estates Area, as well as continues northisouth to the Irm okalce Community and interconnects with S.R. 29. Vanderbilt Reach Road is classified as a six -lane divided arterial. The road functions as a primary eastl est interconnect between its western terrninus at its intersection with U.S. 41 and its eastern terminus to the east ofCol Iier Boulevard. Oakes Boulevard is a two-lane loeaUniinor collector that extends nort:Wsouth between two (2) major arterials which are Vanderbilt Beach Road and Irmmnkalee Road. Oakes Boulevard provides signalized access to VanderbiIt Beach road and to Immokalce Road via its interconnect with Valewood Drive. Autumn Oaks Larne is a two-lane locaVminor collector that extends cast/west between its eastern terminus and its intersection at Oakes boulevard. Valewood Drive is a two-lane iocaUminor collector that extends north/south between Autumn Oaks and Im mokalee Road. The intersection of Valewood Drive and h mokalee Road is signalized. lrrterseaion turning movement counts were obtaint�d during AM, Mid -Day and PM peak hours at the intersections of I. Oakes Boulevard & Autwain Oaks Lane, 2. Valewood Drive & Autumn Oaks Lane, 3. Valewood Drive & Immokalee Road. and Oakes Boulevard & Immokalee road. Traffic counts are summarized on pages BA I thru BA1 and al so BA) 5 thru BA 18 in the appendix. Note, when the traffic dare was c allec led, the intersection of Oakes Boulevard & frr mvkalee Road allowed we.yrhour to-southhound left turns_ The intersection has been mod ted in order to prohibit the left eurning movements_ Therefore, the westbound left turns Brat were observed have been reassigned is Valewood & Imynokulee a shown in Figures B(b) thru D(b) and the resulf s are summarized in Figures 2B thru 2D. tote, residents within the Oakes corn runny requested that the traffic evaluation also include the expected traffic as.vacialed %vilh lire proposed Standing Oaks PAID, Therefore, Fi ur eLy l (b) rhru 2D(b) detail the Slan&n Oaks PUD traffic, which was also reassigned to account for the receni mvdl ccrrions a1 Oakes & Immokatee. Figures 2B rhru 2D provide a .summary of the reswils. In addition to the traffic data collection, on several occasions, traffic demand observations were performed during AM, Mid -Day and PM peak hours at the four (4) subject intersections. It was confirmed that the intersections of Oakes Boulevard Autumn Oaks Lane and Valewood Drive & Autumn Oaks Lane function at very high levels of service with minimal May caused to drivers. Also, the intersection of Valewood Drive & Iminokalee road functions as expected. More specifically, the 2 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB intersection is a major arterial that is intersected by a mirror side street. The Major arterial carries a high volume of thm traffic and the minor side streets accommodate a much lOWCT demand. The priority is to assign a long green cycle to the major corridor and still rcasonably accommodate the side street demand. It was found that the side streets' green time is dictated by the heavier sorthbound volume vs. The lower northbound demand. As observed, the northbound approachlqucue at the intersection ofValewood Drive lmmakalee head clewed on every complete timing cycle and other than waiting for the northbound approach green phase to occur, motorists experienced no extended periods of delay. Project Traffic Distribution The project's net new traffic was distributed to the surrounding road network wed upon logical means of ingress/egress. current and future traffic patterns in the area., the senior center's existing membership and the anticipated future memberships. Table 2 and Figure A provide a detail of the traffic assignments to the adjacent road network. Figures 2B thru 2D reflect the 2021 baukground traffic + project traffic + Standing Oaks PUD traffic + the redirected traffic clue to the closure of the directional left median opening at the interseetion of OakeslImmokalee. Area of Significant Impact The area of significant impact was determined based upon Collier Caunty`s 2%, 2% and 3% criteria i.e,, if the projcctrs traffic is % or more of roadway°s adopted Ievel of service capacity, then the project has a significant impact upon that link). Table describes the project traffic distributions and the level of impact on the surrounding roadways. loads that were identified as being within the projects area impact are shown in Table 2, 7 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB p I � ■ � � � � � + � µpp i * 4} O 5 �fS p � 4 A � 4 4 c s — J Yaflderbilt Beach Rd Ln r� LEENJ d a m 4 15 7;+ NOWAutumn Doks Lam Hidden Oaks F,pne Spanish Daks Lane Golden ppks {Lane Standing Daks Lone a O m Shady Oaks Lane Q a But Doks Lane J English Oaks Lane 1�► � uft� � : I 6�► PROJECT TRAFFIC 01STRIBUTION BY PERCENT Naples Senior Center February 21, 2019 ImmDkalea Rd WENEW 4� i dp� MEMP Wolfe Rood d 43 E Vanderbilt Basch Rd %WTRANSY47RTA-nDN ENGINEEMNS, INC. Project Traffic Distribution I FIGURE 2A 1.1 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 m 0 TABLE PROJECT'S AREA OF IMPACT 0 PM Peak Hour (Wednesday) 001 Projact.Traffic Peek Direction (vphpd) = 48 Exiting T Project Traffic Non -Peak Direction Jvphl = 2 Entering W v, LOS Service Project Project PK Dir. PK Direction Project Pk Hr Project Pk Hr Project W Road Serv. Vol. Volume Traffic PK Dir Pk Hr Nan-PK Mr Non -Pk Impact Percent Sign ifican W Class LOS JvphpdJ 14-Dist, Jv?Kpk (VPN DiR Standard Imluact twipact W Immoka lea Roao 0. to 1-75 to Vatewood or MAD E 3500 36% 17 w i E 2% 0.48% NO & 43.ttr Valewoad Or to Logan Blvd 6018D E 3500 15% 7 E 0 w 2% 0. 1% NO o 00 M Oakes Blvd S. of Autumn Oaks 2U D 900 50% 24 s 1 N 2% 2,67% YES S. of Spanish Oaks Ln 2U D 900 50% 24 5 1 N 3% 2.67% NO W Vanderbilt Beath Rtt11, 8 Livingston'oOak56iyd 6D E 3000 65% 17 4V 1 E 2% 0.56% NO 111.2b Oaks Bswd to Log a., Blvd 6D E 3000 15% 7 E 0 w 2% 0.24% NO Mich -Darr Peak Hour (Wednesday) Project TraHtc Peak Direction (vphpQ) = 242 Exiong Project Traffic Non -Peak Direction Ivph) = 72 Entering Iromokalee Road 43.1 ;9 1-75 to Valewood Dr 43.1b V.Ilewood Dr to Login Blvd Oakes Btvd S. of Autumn Oaks S. of 9pernsh Oaks Ln Vanderbilt Beach R( 111.2a Livingston to Oaks Blvd 11 1.2b Oaks Blvd to Logan Blvd LOS Service Project Project PK Dir. PK Direction Project Pk Hr Project Pk Hr Project Road Serv. Vol_ Volume Traffic PK Dir Pk Hr Non-PK Dip- Non -Pk Impact Percent Significant Class LOS v d) % Dist (vPhpdl Pk Dir "1111 DiR Standard imp Impact 6018D E 3500 35% 85 25 E 2% 2.42% YES 6018D E 3500 15% 36 E 11 w 2% 1.04% NO 9�0y 50p% 121 5 3� B N 2� % 1 4{ % ry21UJJ 2 U �D} D /0 900 50% 121 5 36 N 3% +3.4{ 1 J _44 % AYES YES 60 E 3000 35% 65 V4, 25 E % 2_82% YES 6D E 3000 15% 35 E 11 Vw 2% 1_21% NO DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB ti � f rf Iru1 A G 0 157 Ch Tmrnokalee Rd NORTH m-T.S. Autumn Oaks Lane -*-- 159 129 Im w a 1 f} r3 1725 ■ � 114 �. r� 20e 1167 �s r AM Pro]act Traffic = 72 Enter! 10 Exit LEGEND 00 10 AM Pk Hr Background + Adjusted + Vested Traffic P AM Peak Flour Project Traffic 0o 10 AM Peak Hour Total ]] Build —Out Trafric %M-r RAi•FBP4RTATIDN ENGINEERING, CHO- Naples Senior Center AM Background Traffic "+" FIGURE 2B January 20, 2020 AM Project Traffic (Wednesday) '7- cuSbnEnvelope ID: mymapBBe 4BESBBe- o mqmAB N_ M � _ M mQ wga 24 J f- Immoka|ee Rd 75� � 268 � j � 1498 � ■�')� \ g f � F F- Q wT , I I « k 2 \ i / ~ - ° 2 112«x, 229 Autumn Oaks Lane of o 2 � 88 2 4- » Mm- ay ProjectTraffic =72 [ntow 223Exit ` q G q n m M LEGEND q � Mid -Day Pk Hr Background + Adjusted + a #cmc c gg % and -Day Eck Hour ProjertTemC 2 0 Mid -Day wok H»r Total am 1-om 7mmt do 0 LJfflTFLA14__E3R_F ApQN ENS NEC ■wG,,N Naples Senior Center Mid -Day Background Traffic FIGURE 2C Mid -Day Project Traffic (Weadm-sda inuory 20, 2020 9.4 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB C+ t+1 � e'> n 3n {y na � 1W5 J 94 t[�� Imrnokalee Rd W 248 Z209 I :v T- * ,JORi H ra-r-s- C A r�r 0 0 3 m * ♦ • 42$ � 152 AUtlifYifl Oaks Lane x 85 0 PM Project Traffic =2 Entwf 48 Exit C4 as c*a C4 LEGEND 3 0 04 1P PM Pit Fir Background + Adjusted + Vested Traffic 10 ; ';' * PM Peak Hour Project Trn{tic 0) W s 00 IPP PM Peak Hour Total Build -Out Traffic M 0 MTRANSPORTATION E�MGiwEERJNG. INC- Naples Senior Center PM Background Traffic FIGURE 2D PM Project Traffic (Wednesday) January 20, 2020 -7. DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB 2019 thru 2021 Project Build -out Traffic Conditions In order to establish 2019 biro 2021 project build -out traffic conditions, two forecasting methods were used. The first traffic forecasting method was the ounty's traffic count data was adjusted for peak season conditions, peak ]tour conditions, peak direction, and an annual growffi rate was then supplied, The peak season/peak hour�peak direction factor and annual gr wtb rate were derived from the 2019 Cellier County ALTIR Report- Using the annual growth rate, the 2021 backgmund trnaffic conditions vver- determined, which are depicted in Table 3. The second traffic forecasting method was to add the nested gips (trip bank) ideriti fled in the 2019 A IR report to the adjusted peals season, peak Dour and peak direction traffic counts. The 2021 vested trips 'Y' background traffic volumes are depicted in Table 3. ?dale, residents within the Oakes community requested that the lraf is evaluation also include the expected traffic associated wUh the proposed Standing Oaks P UD. Therefore, Figures 2B(b) thru 2D(b) detail the Standing Oaks PUD traffic, which was also reassigned to acccruni. fbr the reseal madrfkaliaru at Oakes & Irr moWee. Table 3 and Table -J include the Standing Oaks traffic as noted The greater of the two values produced by the two forecasting procedures was then considered to reflect the 2021 background b'af1~ic. The net new project generated traffic was then added to the background traffic. Table 4 provides a summary of the 2019 thru 2021 traffic conditions and the roadways' level of service and remaining available capacity. As shown, all project impacted roadways will continue to operate at the oun's adopted minimum level of service thresholds at project build -out. E] 0 TABLE 2019 & 2021 ROADWAY LINK VOLUMES PM Peak Hour 2D19 2018 Growth AUJR "Counted" Rate Traffir- Traffic Pk per t phadr IvylIPM DiR AUJR Immokalee Road 43.18 1-75 to Valawood Or 2360 E 2.8895 43.1b Valawood Dr to Logan OW 2360 E 2.68°A Oakes Blvd S. of Autumn Oaks 195 N S. of Spanish Oaks Ln I 5115 N Vanderbilt Bosch Rid 111.2a Livingmn to Oaks BIvel 2213 E 4.009A 111.2b Oaks Blvd to Logan Blvd 221 D E 4.00,% Mid -Day Peak Hour (Wednesday) Oakes Blvd S. of Autumn Oaks 152 S. of Spanish Oaks. Ln 469 5 Notes Nole No. 1 - Trip Bank for Oakes Blvd is traffic expected From the app roved Standing Oakes PU D, refer io pages Ala and Al4. Estlrnated Growth Rate D_5096 0-5D% 0.50% 0.M% 0 0 0 c 0 m 0 m 0 0 w 0 0 00 0 W Per Ve��ed Trio Meth. ?rxr Growth Palo Melhad 2021 21021 a Peak Hour W Peak Four m PK Dlrection o PK Direcll4n Trfp m Background W m Background Bank Per Vested Trips &n v It d ;hDd� Foom rE covt 24 M 597 2947 rn 2498 597 w 2947 W 197 32 (No.1) 227 572 32 (No.1) W 230 78 22&8 2390 711 2286 154 32 NO 1) 184 t4 32 (No.1) $01 0 0 0 0 0 m 0 m TABLE 4 0 2021 ROADWAY AY LINK V LUMEI APA ITY ANALYSIS 0 0 0 w M PM Peal( Hour (Wednesday) 2021 2021 2021 2021 21321 W 2019 Peak Hour Peak Hour Project Project Build -Out Serve- Vol- Build -Out a SuItd-Oki W Peak Hour FK Direction Bkgd PI{ 101rection Pk Hr Prjct Pk Hr Prjct Pk Hr Pk Hr Peak Hour Peak Ho,1? m PK DirectEon Background Pk Background PK pir Pk Nan-PK Vir Nara -Pk PK Div PK plr PK Direction PK Oirecti W V3 Ghpol LOS iVphpdr rOOtnOt$ DIr LO V� Dlr "tit dir (vphpol V( ahpdf VfG R8ti0 CAS Immukslee Road 43.1$ I-75 to Vajewood Dr 2360 D 2947 E D 17 W E 2948 3500 0.8A D p 43.1b Velewoo-j Dr to Logan Bkvd 2360 D 2947 E D E 0 w 2954 3500 0.84 [] 0) w w Oakes 8tvd S. of Auturnn Oaks 195 C 227 ND 1 N C 24 S N 229 900 0.25 w D W S. of Spanish Oaks Ln 566 C 598 Firs 1 N C 24 S N 50 90G 0.67 O VanderbiIt Beach A 111.2e Liviagston to Oaks Blvd 2210 0 239G E 0 17 W E 2391 3000 0.80 D no 111.2D Oaks Brvd 10 Logan Blvd 2210 D 2390 E D 0w 2398 U00 0.E30 D Mid -Darr Peak Dour (Wednesday) Oakes Blvd S. of Autumn Oaks 152 C 184 No. I S C ' :.1 5 35 N 3f15 900 0.34 C S. of Spanish Oaks Ln 469 C 501 No. 1 S C 121 83f N 622 940 0.69 C Notes Nose No. 1 - 2321 $a ftrourid Tr ffrc ir4olvaes future trafric frcrn the approved Standing Oakes PUD, rarer to pages A13 and A14. DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB APPENDIX Support Documents DocuSi n Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D78683367B General Information Analyst )MR Transportat on Eny Agency/Co. Date performed lIZ512N Analysis Year 7A2i Site Infomlation Intefsection jurisdiction fast/West Street NoohlSoulh Street italewood Dr & Autumn Oaks Autumn Oaks Valewwod Drive Analysis Time Period ohm) 0-25 Peak Hour Factor 0.95 Time Analyzed 1arojea cescription AM Peak Hour - Proj Build Lanes J4 IL4-4� In Vehicle Volume and Adjustments Apprwrh Eastbound Westbound Northbound Southbound movemerit L 7 R L T R 1_ T R l_ T R Volume 83 7- 36 b 4 3 5 3G 153 % Thnrs in Shared Lane Lane L1 L2 L3 L1 L2 L3 L1 L2 L3 L1 0 L3 CanNuration L TR Crt I,TR LTR Flaw Rate, v (well fh) 87 40 7 11 201 Pement Heavy Vehicles 0 0 0 0 0 Departure Headway and Service Time Initial Departure Headway, hd tsa 3-20 3.20 3.20 3.20 3.24 Initial Degree of lltiti;W' nr x 0.078 01036 aW7 O.W9 4.179 FiriM Depar#ure Headway, hd (s) 5.44 4-�7 433 4.53 377 Final "ree of UtilLatirark x 0.132 CLO47 0-009 0.013 0,211 nntwe•up Time, in (s) 2_3 2-3 7.0 2.0 7.0 SeMce Timer is (Q 3.14 1.97 2.33 2-53 1.77 CapatityF Delay and Level of Service Flow Rate, v (vehM 37 40 7 11 201 Capacity 662 842 831 795 955 95% Qutut tengIN C?ys {veh) 0.5 0.1 1).0 0.0 0,8 Convol Defsy (Vveh) 9.0 7.2, 7.4 7.6 7.8 level of Sery ow. L% A A A A A Approach Delay (slush) 8A 7A 7.6 7_8 Approach LOS A A A A InWr$ecdan delay, sfvee l LOS S.0 A Copyright it, 2020 tl niversiiy of Flarida. Alt Rigbts Rmerled 14CS? W AWSC V�r ion 7.3 Generated= 1 {27}2020 8.32:01 AM AM Peal-xaw X DocuSi n Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB General Information Site Information Anaayst 1MB TranspnrtatiDn. Eng Intersection Valewood Dr & Autumn Oaks AgenryXo. luni5 irllor1 Cate Perfarmed 1f25{202 EaSij re5t 8treer Autumn Oaks Analysis Year 2021 NoTWSoultr Street Yalewwod Drive Analysis Ti me Period Mrs) G25 Peak Hoof FactoF 0.89 lime AnalyM Mid, Day Prof build put Pruje€t Desuiplion Lanes `# Jd 1 4- L Ir Vehicle VaIume and Adjustments Appmach East#c„nd WMtbounrl NontibcAind Saulhb and Movement L T R L 7 R L r R L T R Volume 58 4 36 0 4 4 121 121 0 3L 36 11 G 9, Thrus in $hared Long Lane L7 L2 L3 L1 L2 L3 L1 L2 L3 1.1 L2 L3 Configuration L TR LtR LIM LTA. Flew Bate, V {veh{h) 65 45 9 272 167 F'eroem KieaVy VehlCles 0 Q Departure Headway and Service Time trLitlal Departure Headway, hd (s) 3.W 3.40 3.20 3.20 3.20 Initial Degree of 1.lrili7atiprk. x OAS$ 17,040 O.Ow 0.242 0.149 Final i]epanufe headway, hd (s) 6.00 4.8r 4.1�7 d.% 4.1F9 Final Degree of Utilization. x 10,101g 0.061 0.012 Q340 Qi90 Move -Up Time, m (s) 23 P. 3 2.4 2.4 2A Service Time, is W 3.70 2.56 7.87 7-50 Capacity, Delay and Level of Service HOW Fite' V (V@F{iFh) 65 45 9 272 1fU Capacity 6M 741 740 i d90 45%Queue Length, ors (veh) OA 0.2 0.0 1.5 D.7 Control Delay (51vehj 9.4 7.13 7.9 8.0 Level of Service 1.05 A A A A Approach Delay tslvehk 8.8 7.98 PA 8.0 Api](Oaeh LCS A A A Intenwtlon Delay. V%reh I LOS 9.0 A Copyright 1P 2G20 tlniwP.mily of Florida. Ali Rights Reserved. I1CS7%fi AWSC Version 73 GenrratLd: 1/27/2020 8-36:0S AWN Mid day,xaw J ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE 1-59D7868336AB General Information Site Information Analyst J418 Transportation Eng Intersection VailmoGd Dr & Autumn Nks Agency/Co- Jurisdaian Date Performed 117512020 Ear.VWest Street Autumn Oaks Analy�ig Year 2821 Norlhl5oulh Suet+[ %e!�I-ew.wgd prive AnalySiS rime Period lbrs} 0-25 Peak Hour Faclar 0.90 Time AnaV ed PM Peak - Proj bVild Mt Project desC pLian Lanes Vehicle Volume and Adjustments I Apprq�Kh Earstbourd Westbound Northbound SmM bound Movement L T R L T R L T R 4 T R Valuma 80 4 1 0 3 d 24 24 0 4 1 125 % Thrvs in Shared Lane Lane L1 L2 1.3 ti L2 L3 I_I L2 L3 11-1 L2 L3 CDnfiguration L TR LT9 LTR LTR Flow Rate, v (veh/h) 119 6 8 53 144 Percent Heavy Vehi€res 0 t} 0 p 0 I Departure Headway and Service'rime I Initial uep@niurc, Headway, hid (s) 3.20 3.20 3.20 3.20 3.20 Initial Degree of IltilizatiorM x 0.079 0.005 0.007 0.047 0.128 Final Deparluve Headway, hd (s) 5.41 4.77 A-19 AA1 3-fk Final "ree of iltilixaWri� x 0.134 0.007 0.W9 Q065 0-147 Moire -Lap time, M (S) 2.3 2.3 2.0 2.0 e.0 Service rrrrle. es W 3,11 147 2.19 2.41 1.G6 ICapacity, Delay and Level of Service Flow Rale, v (vehlh) — 89 6 $ 53 144 Capacity 665 754 859 817 983 95%Queue length. Q,f (veh) 015 0.0 0-0 01 0.5 COMM] Delay (SIveil) 9-S 7.5 T2 7.7 73 Lewel of Servi€e. LOS - A A A A A Approach Delay Mehl 8.9 7.2 7.7 73 Approach LOS A A A A Interseclion Delay, slveh j LOS 7.9 A Copyright 9 2020 University of Amrid& All Righ-S Reserwed, HCS7IYG AWSC Vmian 7.3 Generated; 1/?,7f2020 8-37-143 AM PM peak.xaw o mS9 Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB514BE*BBw ago %Sys Ln w � � ® ,o � �,7m mall, � . 000�� Immo| Rd 91 [Al 116? \�— @ ic NORTH �a e � m � A 2 0 � \ . > _ n +L-,;S0C5) D] Autumn Oaks Lane q 59 ■ F- pr,� e [ 2 — AMP�o tTramc=66 EMgZ¥Exit k � LEGEND t « P AM Peokmour BackgroundTmmc *00 1P Reossriped AM Peok Hour BackgroundTraffic j (m) 0 AM Peak Hour Project Traffic k ks/Vm ood) [00] Op AM Peak Hour Standing Ooks PUDTraffic \ 0 Im AM Peak Hour TISud—tTraffic 0 %MTRANSPORTATkON1 EN &NEB WO,INC. Naples Senior Center AM Background Traffic "+ • FIGURE 28( Novern�f 18, 2019 AM Project Traffic (Wednesday) A A i DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB L0 •E,2t iImmokalee Rd r+ 24 —996 263 EN 149$ iv f4 OF T N(jRTH C"7 � Q O n � ry � v o -0 (� ] Autumn Oaks Lane " 226 4 c o 95 sa (z• � rp .s 4 1,_v {33} Mid -Day Project Traffic = 66 E rated 223 Exit Ln crs iV CD LEGEND 00 ON Mid—Oay Peak Harr Background Traffic flu() 0 Reassigned Mid —flay Peak Hour Background Traffic .00j -- Mid —Day Pk Hr Project Troffic (50/50 split Oakes valewood) 0 [00] sm Mid —Day Peak Hour Standing Oaks PUD Traffic 00 10 Mid —flay Peak Hour Total Build —Out Traffic w 0 TRANSPORTA-no" ENGINEERING, INC. Naples Senior Center Mid -Darr Background Traffic „+„ November 18, 2019 Mid -Day Project Traffic (Wednesday} FIGURE (l�} A DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB crt u'r m Ln s+� n o ,o ev � t3a5 ' Immkalee Rd s2 5.71 * 24S V 2208� D CV C4 NQkH MTIF. Autumn Oaks Large 4 *150 85 78 [2F] - 4 - p) PM Proiact Traffic - 2 Enterrr 44 Exit LEGEND 3 Y rva 00 PM Peak Hour Background Traffic 000 W Reassigned PM Peck Hoar Background Truffic (oo) PM Peak Hour Project Traffic (50/50 split Oakes/Valewaod) (001 m- PM Peak Hour Storiding Oaks PUD Traffic as P- PM Peek Hour T``otol Guiid-Out Troffc +�.�tiIQppTFtANBPORTAIIflN ENBINEERIMM. IN12L Maples Senior Center P-M mackgrI and Iraffic „#„ FIGURE PM Project Traffic (Wednesday) � � November i8, 2i7�9 AAS 1345 Oaks Bivd, north of Vanderbilt Beach Rd (CR 862) 2fli 19 St. r 12 13 14 15 16 17 q 23 24 Hour fst Quarter NIB SIB TOTAL 2nd Quarter NIB SIB TOTAL 3rd Quarter NIB SIB TOTAL 4th Quarter NIB 515 TOTAL HOUR 0100 15 13 213 10 11 21 30 6 36 14 4 16 0500 0 4 10 7 3 10 $ 2 10 4 0 4 0300 1 9 1 Q 4 4 8 12 5 17 7 2 9 Q400 a 5 1 D 7 1 8 5 3 a 5 1 6 OS00 10 0 19 4 6 12 6 7 13 17 6 23 0500 31 41 72 17 371 54 9 17 26 5DI 42 100 0700 95 127 222 87 106 196 82 87 f6o 103 171) 363 0900 243 341 584 229 303 532 226 366 552 256 481 737 0900 406 423 829 379 384 743 293 440 733 364 508 872 1000 269 314 603 279 278 557 261 304 566 307 416 603 1100 284 327 611 220 232 452 255 280 535 282 345 537 1200 301 380 651 252 2781 530 282 270 552 318 311 630 1300 398 353 751 291 2021 583 322 28d We X6 334 640 1400 367 376 743 260 252 512 320 313 633 333 361 694 1500 706 323 262 605 32+ 291 68 372 357 729 M0 4 a31 900 418 292 711 326 361 686 449 365 814 1700 865 425 331 756 351 345 696 500 412 912 16M C 666 380 946 509 370 879 588 381 906 543 381 024 1wo 66 318 237 5551 373 247 520 363 284 647 2MO 244 199 443 249 145 394 218 1w 408 330 214 544 100 185 118 301 188 100 277 248 147 305 263 132 415 00 111 90 201 114 60 174 142 87 229 136 64 200 3M 71 44 115 55 54 109 72 54 126 70 37 107 2400 23 24 47 33 23 56 47 21 88 32 7 30 TOTAL 5.376 4.949 10,326 4.658 4,D76 8,734 4,799 4.499 9,297 5,543 5.274 i0.817 UM c: 1i P&.�UId LJA I ff 0114MV1V LJA I t; (rz5rzU19 E)ATL, lur21201$ EB Average WB Average 5,094 4,699 Collier County Count Slativn 645 Annual Daily Ave. Dally Volume 9,793 0 0 0 0 U) 0 m 0 m 0 cu DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection: Date of Count: Autumn Oaks Ln & Oakes Blva 121512018 Wednesday Eastbound westbound AM Period I L T R L T R 7:00-7:15 1 0 0 D I 4 0 0 7:15-730 1 0 0 0 I 9 0 0 j 730-7:45 1 0 1 0 j 14 0 D 1 7:45 - 8:01) 1 0 1 0 I 20 1 0 1 9:00 -9: 15 1 1 D 1 I 15 0 0 8:15 -8.30 0 1 0 G 21 0 0 1 8:30 - 8,45 1 0 1 0 1 14 t 0 1 8A5-9:00 0 0 0 1 10 0 0 AM Tolals 1 1 4 I 1 1 107 2 I 0 1 Approach °l0 1 16.7% 66.7% 15.7% 1 9$_2% 1.89A 0.0% 1 % f Lane 1 0.2% 0.7% 0.2% 1 17.4% 0.3% 0.0% 1 °ln I Inter. 1.0% 17.71A I EzkstbOund 1Nesthound I PM Period L T R L T R C 4-00-415 0 0 0 1 9 0 0 j 4:15 - 4:30 0 0 0 10 0 0 4.30 - 4:45 0 0 0 12 0 0 4:45 - 5:DD 0 0 0 1 9 0 0 5.01)-5:15 0 0 1 1 9 0 0 5;15 -5:30 1 0 0 9 0 0 5:30 - 5:45 0 0 0 1 7 0 0 5:45-6:00 0 0 0 1 7 0 0 PM Totals C 1 0 1 1 72 0 0 1 Approach % 1 50.0% 0.0% 50.0% 1 100.0*/6 0.0% 0.0% 1 % f Lane 0.2% 0.0% 0.2% 1 11.7% 0.0% 0.0% I 1% I Inner. 0.3% 11.rA AM Period 7:30- 810 Approach OA PM Period 4. - 5A5 Approach % PEAT{ HOUR TL Eastbound L T R 1 3 1 20.0% 60.M 20.0% 1 0 1 50.0% 0.0"la 50.0% AM Peek hour Factor = 0.90 PM Peak Hour Factor = 0.93 Northbound I Southbound L T R I T R 0 10 9 I 0 24 0 0 5 12 0 25 0 1 18 20 1 35 0 1 18 15 0 27 0 0 15 19 0 42 0 0 11 21 2 46 1 1 16 15 0 35 0 0 10 8 0 37 0 3 103 C 119 1 3 271 1 1.3% 45.8% 52,9% 1 1.1% 913_5% 0.4% 0.5% 16.7% 19.3-A 0.5% 44.1 % 0.2% 36.6% 44.7% Northbound Southbound L T R L T R 0 18 14 0 21 0 1 22 15 1 18 a 0 23 19 0 24 0 0 25 18 1 24 0 1 27 22 I 0 22 0 0 30 22 I 0 28 1 1 333 20 0 31 0 0 26 14 0 19 0 3 204 144 1 2 187 1 1 0.9% 58.1% 41,0 1 1-1% 98.4% 0.5% 1 0.5% 33,2% 23.4% I 0.3% 30.4% 0.2% 1 57,1 % 30.9% Westbound Northbound k Sauthbound L T R L T R L T F2 70 1 C 0 2 U2 70 1 3 150 1 98.6% 1.4% 0.0% C 1 A% 44_13% S4.0% 1.9% 97.4% 0_6% 34 0 C 0 C 2 115 I 82 I 1 105 1 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1.0% 57.B% 41.2% 98_1.1A 0.9% Total All hh 47 51 90 83 93 103 83 65 62 67 {8 77 82 91 92 66 615 615 369 34 Aut & Oakes 1 I DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Intersection; Autumn Oaks Ln & Oakes Blvd Date of Count: 12151 018 2018 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Eastbound Westbound 1 Northbound Southbound L T R L T R I L T R I L T R AM Period 1 1 3 1 70 1 0 1 2 62 75 I 3 150 1 PM Poriod I I l 1 1 0 1 34 0 0 I 2 115 82 I 1 105 1 2018 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT Seasonal Adj Seasonal Adjustment Factor = 1.1 Eastbound Westbound J Northbound 1 Southbound L T R I L T R L T R I L T R AM Perled 1 1 3 1 1 77 1 0 ! 2 68 B3 1 3 155 1 PM Period 9 I [ 1 1 0 1 1 37 0 0 1 I 2 127 90 ] 1 116 1 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Annual Growth Rate = 0.5% I Eastbound 1 Westbound I No thbound 1 Southbound L T R I L T R [ L T R I L T R AM Period I 1 3 1 ] 78 1 0 1 2 69 84 1 3 167 1 PM Period I 1 I I 1 0 1 ] 38 0 0 1 2 128 92 1 1 117 1 Aut & Oakes 6AZ DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection. Autumn Oaks Ln & Oakes Blvd Date of Count; 1215i2o1a Wednesday I Eastbound I Westbound Northbound I 6outhbound I Total All Noon Period I L T R I L T R L T R I L T R I Aapreh' 12'30 - 12:45 1 0 0 0 I 5 0 0 j 1 13 13 1 0 17 0 I 49 12-45 - 1.00 0 1 1 5 1 0 1 10 9 1 2 21 0 52 1100 -1.15 0 D D I 11 0 0 2 17 7 1 0 25 0 I 63 1,15 - 1.30 0 D D I E 0 0 0 10 10 G 1 20 1 1 48 1.30 - 1-45 0 D 2 I 5 1 0 1 1 13 9 1 0 25 1 1 57 1,45 - 2:00 0 0 0 1 6 1 0 j a 20 4 0 28 0 I 59 2:00 -2:15 1 0 1 0 1 7 0 0 I 1 8 10 I 1 20 0 I 49 2-15 -2.30 1 0 0 0 1 4 0 0 1 0 12 10 I 1 28 0 I 55 :30 - :45 I 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 14 7 1 1 28 0 1 57 AM Tolals I 0 2 3 I 5o 3 0 I 6 103 72 1 5 185 2 1 431 Approach % I D_0°Io 40_0% 60.0% 1 94.30l0 5.7% 0.0°lo I 3.3% 56.9% 39.8% I 2_6% 96.4% 1.0% � %J lane 1 0.0% D.6% 0.7% 1 11.6% 0.7% 0, VA 1 1A% 23.9% 16.7% I 1.2% 42.9% 0.5°l0 � I Inter, 1.2% 12.3% 42.0% 44.5% PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound I 5outhbound I I L T R I L T R 1 L T R I L T R I Noon Period I I I I 1.00- 2:00 I 0 0 2 1 28 2 0 1 3 60 30 I 1 99 2 I 227 Approach I% 1 4.0% 0.01% 100.d°ln 1 93.364 6_7°!o 0.0% 1 3.2% 64.5°lo 32.3% 1 1,0% 97A% 2.0% 1 1 1 1 1 1 Mid -Day Peak Hour Factor = 0.95 ut & Oakes 3 K DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Aut & Oakes Intersection: Autumn Oaks Ln & Oakes Blvd Date of Count: 121512018 2018 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES I Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound J 5outhbound I I L T 1R I L T R I L T R I L T R I Mid -Da v I 0 2 I 28 2 0 I 3 60 30 J 1 99 2 1 I I I 1 1 018 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT Seasonal Adj Seasonal Adjustment Factor = 1 A Eastbound I westbound I Northbound 1 $outhbound L T R I L T R J t T R I L T R � Mid -Ds I n n 2 I 31 2 0 I 3 66 33 I 1 109 2 I I I I I 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT Annual Growth Rate = 0,5% Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound 1 southbound I L T IR I L T R J L T R I L T R I Mid- Dav 1 0 0 2 1 31 2 0 J 3 67 33 I 1 111 2 I I I ] I I Aut & Oakes 4 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection: AWLImn Oaks Lr Date of c)unt: 1215/2018 AM Period 7:00 - 7:15 7:15 - 7:30 7;30 - 7;45 7-45 - 8:00 8:15 ..8:34 8-30 - 8:45 8:45 - 9:00 AM Totals Approach `Yo % I Lane % l Inter. Eastbound L T_ R 5 a a 6 0 0 17 0 0 20 1 0 21 0 0 19 1 0 10 1 0 a 0 0 106 3 0 972% 2,$°la 0.0% 45.5% 1 _TA 0.0% 48-8% i & Valewood Dr Tuesday Westbound L T R 0 0 1 0 0 0 D 1 1 0 t ❑ 0 D 2 0 2 0 0 1 3 0 1 ] 0 6 8 0.0% 42.9% 57.1 % 0.0% 2.45% 3.4% 6.0% Eastbound Westbound I PM Period I L T R L T FE I 4:00-4,15 1 14 0 0 0 1 0 4;15-4:30 15 2 0 0 0 4:30 - 4:45 17 4 0 0 1 0 4:45 - 5,00 76 2 0 0 0 1 5:00 - 5,15 18 1 0 J 0 2 0 5-15-5-30 24 1 0 0 a 2 5:30 - 5:4a 20 2 0 0 1 1 5:45 - 6,00 14 0 0 0 Q 0 PM Totals I 138 8 0 J 0 5 5 I Approach % 194.YID 5,Wn 0.0% I 0.0% 45.59/6 54,5% I % I Lane 154.59% 3.2°ln 0.0% 1 0.0% 2.0% 2.41rn k % J Inter_ 57.7% 4.3°% AM Period Approach °la PM Period 4,45 - 5:45 Approach % PEAK HOUR TL Eastbound L T R fY 2 0 97.5% 2,5% 0-0% 78 6 0 92.9°1`0 7.1% 0.0% AM Peak Hour Factor = 0.95 PM Peak Hour Factor = 0.90 INNING M VEIV Westbound L T R U 4 3 0.0% 57.1 % 42.9°l0 0 3 4 0.0% 42.9% 57.1% Northbound L T_ R 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 t} 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 outhbound L. T R 0 0 4 0 D 9 0 15 1 0 19 a 0 13 1 0 9 3 0 107 2.7% 0.0% 97.3% 1.3% 0.0'l0 45-9a10 47.2% Northbound Southbound L T R L T R I 0 0 0 1 0 9 0 0 0 1 0 10 0 0 0 0 0 12 0 0 0 2 0 14 0 0 0 0 0 13 a 0 0 1 0 13 0 0 0 1 0 12 0 0 0 D D 7 0 0 6 0 90� 6.3% 0.0% 93.8-A � 2.4% 0.0% 35-6% � 37.0% IE T VOLUMES Northbound L T R Sauthbxound L T R 2 0 72 2.7% 0.0%u 97.Ylo 4 0 52 7.1 % 0.0% 92.9% Total All Apqrch's 10 15 38 42 38 42 28 20 25 30 30 35 34 41 37 21 233 253 lea 147 Aut & Val 1 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Intersection: Autumn Oa> s Ln & Valewood Or Date of Count: 1215/2018 2018 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES I Eastbound C Westbound I Northbound I Southbound 1 I L T R I L Y F I L T R I L T R I AM Period 1 77 2 0 0 4 3 I 0 0 0 I 2 0 }2 I PM Period I ! I I 78 6 0 1 0 3 4 I I 0 0 0 I 4 0 1 5 I 018 PEAK SEASON PEAK FOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Seasonal Adj Seasonal Adjustment Factor = 1.06 I Eastbound 1 Westbound I Northbound I Southbound 1 I L T R I L T R 1 L T R I L T R 1 AM Period I 81 2 0 1 0 4 3 I 0 0 0 I 2 0 76 1 I PM Period 1 I I 32 6 0 1 a 3 4 1 I D D 0 1 4 0 I 55 1 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Annual Growth Rate = 2.0% j Eastbound 1 Westbound 1 Northbound C Southbound l I L T R I L T R 1 L T B I L T R I AM Period 1 86 2 0 1 0 4 3 j Cl. 0 0 I z b 80 C PM Period 1 I I 87 7 0 1 0 3 4 I I 0 0 0 1 4 C. I 58 1 Aut & Val 2 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection: Autumn Oaks Ln & Valemod Dr Date of Count- 121512018 Tuesday I Eastbound I Wasthound I Northbound I 3outh5ourid I Total All Noon Period i L T R I L 7 R i L T R 1 L T R C Apprch's 11:00-11:15 1 13 0 0 1 0 0 2 k 0 0 0 1 0 0 12 27 11:15-11:30 C 14 2 0 1 0 2 1 1 0 0 0 1 2 0 1z 33 11:30-11.45 N 13 1 0 1 0 2 t I 0 0 0 1 0 13 I 30 71:45 -12:00 14 1 D 1 0 4 0 I 0 0 0 1 1 0 12 28 12-00 -12:15 [ 9 0 0 0 1 1 I 0 0 0 0 0 9 20 12.15-12:30 I 4 1 0 0 0 0 I 0 D 0 0 0 6 11 12.30 -1:45 10 0 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 j 1 0 7 21 1 ,45 - 1,00 fi 10 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 4 16 I AM Totals I 87 5 I 0 i 0 7 f 7 i 0 0 I a i 5 0 i 75 i 196 Approach % 194.6% 5.4% 0.0% i 0.0% 50,0% 50-0% j i 6-3% 0-0% 33-8% i % I Lane 146.8% 2.7% 0.0% i 0.0% 3_81% 3.8% [ i 2.7% 0.0% 40.3% � % f Inter. 48.5% 7,5% 43,07P PEAK HOUR TUBBING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Easthound I Westbound i Northbound I Southbound I L T R I L T g 1 T L I L T R I Noon Period I I I i 11-00- 12-00 1 54 4 0 1 0 4 4 1 1 3 D 49 1 118 Approach % 93.1 % 6.T/a 0.0% 0.0% 50.07. 50.01% 5.8% 0.0% 94.2% I I I i 1 I Noon Peak Hour Factor = 0.80 Aut & Val 3 o DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Intersection: Autumn Oaks Ln & Vaiewood Dr }ate of Count: 1 151 018 2018 PEAS{ HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Eastbound I Westbound I northbound I Southbound L T R ] L T R L T g ] L T R Noon Period I 54 4 0 { 0 4 4 I 0 0 0 I 3 0 49 I I I I I 2018 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT Seasonal Adj Seasonal Adjustment Factor = 1.05 I Eastbound Westbound I Northbound Southhound L T R I L T R J L T 3 I L T R I Noon Peiriod { 57 4 0 C 0 4 4 0 0 0 I 3 0 51 I 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Annual Growth Rate = 2.0% Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound I 8outhbound L T a I L T R I L 1 R I L T R Noon Period I 60 4 0 I 0 4 4 I 0 0 0 I 3 0 55 I I I I Auk & Val 4 us DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection: Valewood & fmmokalee Road Date of Count: 121512018 Wednesday I Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound 1 Southbound Total All AM Period I L T R I L T R J L T R I L T R Apprch's TOO - 7:15 1 25 0 0 9 0 3 I 7 2 1 1 15 8 44 114 7:15 - T 30 24 0 1 8 0 4 I 6 6 0 13 12 fit I 136 7:30 - 7:45 39 0 1 1 9 0 4 I 8 10 2 f 13 13 86 1 185 7-45 - 8:00 64 0 1 1 3 0 2 I 7 7 2 C 16 9 77 1 188 B-00-8-15 1 48 0 1 1 14 0 1 1 5 12 4 2& 5 97 I 207 8:15 -8, 30 53 0 4 1 7 0 3 I 5 15 3 14 7 88 G t 99 8:30 - 8:45 I 39 0 2 4 D 4 I 3 5 2 15 6 74 154 8:45 - 9:00 I 42 0 1 1 7 0 2 I 5 7 2 1 18 5 63 152 AM Totals 1 334 0 11 61 0 23 1 46 64 16 1 124 65 591 1335 Approach % 1 96.8% 0.0°la 3.2% 72.8% O.D% 27.401b I 36.5% 50.8% 12.7% I 15.9% 8.3% MAN. � % I Lane I 25.0% Q-0% 0.0% 4.6% 0.09Jo- 1.7% I 3.4% 4.8% 1.2% 1 9.3% 4.9% 44.371a ] o- J Inter. 25.8% 6.3°Io 9.4% 58. 4% Eastbound WestWund I Northbound Southbound I PM Period I T R I L T if I L T R J L T R 1 4:00 - 4' 15 I 37 0 3 I 3 0 2 3 9 2 j 14 5 38 110 4:15 - 4:30 [ 33 0 5 1 5 0 4 4 7 1 1 18 9 47 1 133 4.30 - 4-45 40 0 7 I 7 0 6 1 5 9 4 I 26 a 43 1 164 4:45 - 5:00 1 55 0 5 1 8 0 8 J 4 13 2 I 24 8 42 169 5.00 - 5:15 1 56 0 2 I 5 0 5 J 3 14 1 I 43 7 65 1 202 515 -5.30 1 62 0 0 I 9 0 9 5 18 3 I 45 5 55 211 5; 30 - 5:45 J 75 0 0 I 11 0 7 5 13 1 I 33 7 43 I 195 5;45 - 6:00 68 0 0 1 7 0 11 3 9 2 1 19 4 44 I 167 PM Totals I 435 0 22 56 0 52 I 32 92 16 222 53 377 C 1357 AWoach % I 95.2% 0.0% 4.81A 51.9% 0.01% 48.1 % I 22.9% 65.7% 11.4% 34.0% 8.1 % 57.8% � % I Larte 1 32.1 % 0.0"la 1.60% 4.1 % 0.0% 3.8% 1 2.4-A 6.8-A 1.2% f 16.4% 3.9% 77.8"la � % f Inter- 33.7a% a -VA, 10_3% 48.D% PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUME I Eastbound Westbound I Northbound I L T R 1 T R L 1 AM Period I I 7.30- 8:90 1 204 1167 7 1 33 1725 10 1 25 44 11 Approach % 1 14.8% 84-7% 0.5% I 1.9% 97.61% 0.6°la I 31.3% 55,0% 13.8% PM Period 4:45 - 5:45 Approach % 248 2208 7 10.1 % 89.6% 0.3% I\PwT Pcok Hour Factor 0.94 PM Peak Hatir Factor = 0_92 34 1045 N 3.1% 94.3% 2.6% 17 58 7 20.7% 70.7% 8.54/41 Southbound C L T R I 63 34 I 348 1 3671 14.2% 7.6% 79.2% {I 1 145 27 I 205 1 4030 38.5% 7.2% 54.4% 1 Val & arum rt DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Intersection: Valewood & Immokalee Read Date of Count: 121512018 2018 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Eastbound j Westbound Northhound I Southbound k L T R [ L T R L T E L T R AM Period J 204 1167 7 I 33 1725 10 25 44 11 I 63 34 345 PM Period ! k I 248 2208 7 C 34 1045 29 k 17 58 7 I I 145 27 k 205 C 2018 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Seasonal Adj Seasonal Adjustment Factor = 1 Eastbound Westbound Northbound I Southbound L T R L T R I L T R I L T R J AM Period I 204 1167 7 k 33 1725 10 I 25 44 11 k 63 34 348 I PM Period I k 1 248 2208 7 k 34 1045 17 5$ 7 k k 14 27 i 20 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Annual Growth Rate = (L5% Eastbound Westbound k Northbound k Southbound � L T R L T R j L T ft k L T R k ABM Period 207 1185 7 33 1751 10 1 26 45 11 l 64 35 353 k PM Period 252 2241 7 k 35 1061 29 k 17 59 7 k 147 27 208 � Val & Imm 2 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection: Date of Cou AM Period 12'30 - 12:45 12:45 - 1:40 1:00 - 1;15 1;15-1:30 1' 30 - 1:45 1,45 - 2:00 2;OD -2;15 2:15 -2:30 2;30 -2:45 AM Tolals Approach Yr, L'/c � Lane "/� 1 Inter. Valewood Dr & I it, 121512018 ' Eastbourtd L T R 55 0 0 67 0 1 51 0 2 33 0 4 57 0 1 57 0 2 51 6 52 0 4 57 0 3 503 0 16 96-! "% D_Oaln 3.1 % 35.4% 0.0°/o 1.1 % 36.5% mmokalee Road Nednesday Westbound T R U 7 6 a 6 6 0 9 4 0 6 2 4 3 5 0 5 8 0 5 8 0 8 39 D 46 45.9% 0.0% 54.1% 2.7% 0.0% 3.2% 6.0% Northbound L 7 R 4 a 2 6 7 3 8 5 4 6 9 2 4 6 4 4 2 6 4 6 4 5 12 3 5 7 2 42 55 28 33.6% 44.0% 22.49/6 3.0% 3.9% 2.0% 8.8% Southbound L T R 9 14 62 14 9 48 13 12 54 16 6 75 18 4 69 14 5 71 19 9 72 7 6 66 7 8 m 110 65 517 15.9% 9.44% 74.7% 7.7%a 4.6"/a 3fi_4°la 48_r Total Al Apprch's 162 1137 191 195 173 176 187 169 159 1421 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES I Easthound 1 westbound I Northbound I Southbound J L T R I L T R I L T R I L T R AM Period 1 l I I I 1:00- 2:00 26B 1498 J C 18 996 24 1 22 22 16 1 61 27 269 3230 Appfo�ch % 15.1 °fe. 84.4% 0.5°/a 1.7% %-OVa 2.3% 1 36.7 % 36.7% 26.7% 1 17.1 % 7.6% 75.4°fa � Mid -Day Peale Hour Factor - 0.94 Val & Imgn 3 DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Intersection: Valewood Dr & Irnmok�lee Road Date of Count; 1215Q018 018 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES 1 Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound 1 Southbound I L T R I L T_ R I L T R I L T R I Mid -Day 1 268 1498 9 I f8 956 24 1 22 22 16 1 61 27 269 1 I 1 I I 010 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Seasonal Ate_ Seasonal Adjustment Factor = 1.1 I Eastbound I Westbound 1 Northbound I Southt3ound I I L T R I L T R 1 L T R 1 L T_ R I MI-d-Qa_y( 1 295 1648 10 I 20 1096 26 I 24 24 18 I 67 30 2% I I I I 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Annual Growth Rate = 0.5% Eastbound I Westbound N Northbound I Southbound 1 L T R 1 L T R 1 L T R I L T R I Mid -pay 1 299 1673 1(} I 20 1112 27 I 25 25 18 1 68 30 300 I I I I I Val & Imm 4 t DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB 41 (3oWlolkwMark ILoad XWri-FkDrq Ruad UAgr-I n RW4 1 iL 1� R-76 %}lr n assiwmx]dan rcouuin 4 a ass SSandOr OaksttC Day j ac _ vP -WUwf sum 1 Ipi4jh'IFPFs#n'Sir!Ip `:' �L�RzcYgp 111 Gf I(fes,N 31�L' ' . ZIi�iRAlrl r:lUfliJFiE ..Apt71YM Agenda (kern No. 17C ,dune 24, 2008 N f i l+�ct tc Scak Irmm koft Raid RH 11 S�o��r`!r�' Dafrs AM Poak Flo ur Tra ffic A ssfgrrm Grp r i DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Uld 41 R Qf C F N QuwIwrc+ra* Read A�jwrt-nllnuflaad LivingswilPL*Od 1-75 AgArldaIlemNo. j7 .Iur1e 24, 2008 Pa aus ua 44' N L4' � 5 1i49 14 Std� IMRGh. w Road VwWeMIL Mach ,'toad :JT41 LAL a1JrY rlmnfq � IlG51Cb hY � NJ'.rs lildl�'i iM1iY� immral ,F.l�l �„„;r �uu &VI %way sv&r dOPF IL rL sr exPM Pear Hour Traf& Assi nmeal 1 va k MI bn�{ H� +rt Hroh4 �t x�uv wl.KKxIM1 " 1=XNr$JTd 31Aoo-,ula rEnUiu!L ApMMM h1�AY iY�le�lfL'_.LS.: i4 w ' AM DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection: lmrnokalee Road & Oakes Blvd Date of Count: 1215/2018 Wednesday Eastbound I Westbound k Northbound k Southbound ] AM Period L T R I L T R k L T R is T R 7=00 - 7-15 0 0 1a 1 6 0 0 k 0 0 10 k 0 0 0 1 7-15 - 7;30 0 0 16 I 9 0 0 I 0 0 5 0 0 0 1 7.30-7:45 [ 0 0 19 1 17 0 0 1 0 0 18 0 0 0 1 7:45-8:00 1 0 0 17 1 10 0 0 1 0 0 18 0 0 ❑ 1 8:00 -8.15 1 0 0 21 1 21 0 0 1 D 0 15 0 0 0 1 8:15 -8:30 1 0 0 24 J 24 0 0 1 0 0 11 I 0 0 0 1 8:30 - 8:45 1 0 0 23 k 7 0 0 1 0 0 10 1 b ❑ 0 6A5-9:DD 0 0 19 k 1$ 0 0 1 0 0 10 k 0 0 0 k AM Totals 1 0 0 162 k 112 0 0 1 0 0 103 1 0 0 0 Approach % 1 0,0% 0.0% 100.0"lo k 100-0% 0-0% 0-0% 1 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% 1 k % f Lane 1 0-0% 0.0% 43.0% k 29,7% 0-0% 0-0"A 1 0-0% 0.0% 27-3% 1 0-0°la 0,0% 0.0% k °to- 1 Inler. 43.0% 29-7°la 27.3% 0.09/9 Easthound Westbound I Northbound I Southbound I PM Period T_ R k L T R [ L T R I L T R 1 4,00 - 4:15 1 0 0 12 k 9 0 0 1 0 0 18 1 0 0 0 1 4:15 - 4' 30 0 0 7 k 12 0 0 1 0 0 22 1 0 0 0 1 4.30 - 4-45 k 0 0 11 1 13 0 0 k 0 0 23 1 0 0 0 1 4:45 - 5:00 0 0 12 13 0 0 k 0 0 25 1 0 0 0 1 5:00 - 5:15 [ 0 0 11 1 11 0 0 k 0 0 27 1 0 0 0 1 5:15 -5:30 0 0 13 [ 14 0 0 1 0 0 30 [ 0 0 0 1 5:30 - 5:45 { 0 0 19 [ 11 0 0 1 0 0 33 1 0 0 0 1 5:46 - 6:00 0 0 10 k 9 a a 1 0 0 26 1 0 0 0 1 PM Tolals 0 0 95 1 92 0 0 k 0 0 204 1 0 0 0 k Approach I/. 1 0.0% 0.0°l0 1 00.0"/o 1 100 0% 0.0% 0.0°la 1 0-0°la 0-0 o 100-00A � [ flu 1 Lane 0.0V. 0.Wlo 24-3°la 1 23-5% 0.0%. 0.0% 1 0-0% 0-0% 52-2% � k a/D I Inter 24.3% 23.51/o 52-2% PEAK HOUR TL 1 Eastbound { L T R AM Period 1 7:30- 8:30 1 0 D 81 Approach °to- 1 0-0% 0.0% 100.6% 1 PM Period 1 4-45-5-45 1 0 0 55 Approach `Y6 [ 0.0r1 0 0% 100.0% AM Peak dour Factor = 0-91 PM Peak Hour Factor = 0-87 IRNING MOVEM westhound L T R I ty 72 ��ff ❑ o 100-0% 0-0% 0-00A 49 0 0 100.m 0.0% 0.0% ENT VOLUMES Total All Appreh's 34 30 54 45 57 59 51 47 39 41 47 50 49 57 63 45 377 391 Northbound 1 Southbound 1 L T R L T R k k 0 0 02 [ 0 0 0 I 215 0-WA 0.0% 100-0°lo I 1 I 1 I 0 0 115 Q 6 0 219 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% � 1 I mmak & Oakes Aj li DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Intersection: immaWee Road & Oakes Blvd Date of Count: 1f51018 018 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES I Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound I Southbound N L T R L T R I L T R 1 L T R I AM Period I 0 0 81 1 72 0 0 1 0 Q 82 1 0 0 0 1 PM Period I I I 0 0 55 49 0 0 1 I 0 0 115 I 0 0 0 1 2018 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT Seasonal AdJ Seasonal Adjustment Factor = 1.1 1 Eastbound Westbound I Northbound I Southbound I I L T _R I L T R I L 1 R I L T R a AM Period [ 0 0 89 1 79 0 4 I 0 0 68 1 0 0 0 ] PM Period f I I C 0 0 61 1 54 0 0 1 I 0 0 127 1 0 fl I 0 1 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Annual Growth Rate = 0.5% 1 Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound J Southbound I 1 L T R I L T R I L T R J L T R I AM Perii d 1 b 0 90 1 80 0 0 1 ! 0 0 6 I I D 0 0 I PM Period I I 1 0 0 61 I 55 0 0 1 0 0 128 I 0 0 0 1 Immck & Oakes DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS Intersection: Immokafee Road & Oakes Blvd Date of Count, 12151 018 Wednesday a Eastbound Westbound I Northbound Southbound Noon. Period ] L T_ R L T 9 1 L T R L T R 12:30 - 12:45 J 0 D 7 10 0 0 0 0 13 0 0 0 � 12:45 - 1:00 0 0 11 12 0 0 0 0 10 1 0 0 0 1:00-1:15 0 0 9 C 14 0 0 0 0 17 0 a 0 f 1:15-1.30 0 0 10 j 10 0 0 j 0 0 10 0 D 0 1:30 - 1:45 0 0 12 N 11 0 0 0 0 13 0 0 0 1,45 - 2:00 0 0 13 13 0 0 0 0 14 J 0 0 0 2:00 -2:16 1 0 0 8 12 0 0 1 0 0 8 [} 0 0 :1 5 -2:30 1 0 a 13 16 0 0 [ 0 0 12 0 0 2:30 -2:45 1 0 0 15 14 0 0 0 0 14 1 0 0 ❑ AM Taaais 1 0 0 83 1 98 0[ 0 0 97 1 0 0 0 1 Approach % 1 0.0% 0.O'lo 100.0% 100.0% 0.( 0.0°lo C 0.0% 0.0% 100.0%a I � °fo f Lane 1 0.0% D.0% 29.9% 35.3% 0.0% 0.0% C 0.0% 0.0% 34.99/6 1 0.09/6 0.0% 0,0% � % !inter. 29.9"Yo 35.3% 34.9% 0.0% PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES I Eastbound Westbound Northbound Southbound � I L T R l T R L T R L T R I Noon Period [ I I G 1:00-2'00 G 0 0 44 40 (1 0 0 0 54 0 0 0 1 Approach " 0.01la D_0% 100.0% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% l � Mid-D7 iy Peak Hour Factor = 0-Q1 Immok & Oahe; r-) DocuSign Envelope ID: 3097893F-BB51-4BED-BBE1-59D7868336AB Intersection: lmmokelee Road & Oakes Blvd Date of Count: 12J512018 2018 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Eastbound I Westbound j Northbound I Scuthbound L T R I i= T R I L T R I L T R Mid -Da v N 0 0 44 I 48 0 0 I 0 0 54 I 0 0 0 E I I I I 2018 PEAT{ SEASON DEAF{ HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Seasonal Adisea sonai Adjustment Factor 11 I Eastbound C Westbound I Northbound I Suuthbound L T R I L T R I L 1: R I L T R Mid -Da Y I 0 0 48 53 0 0 I 0 0 59 I 0 0 0 I I I I I k 2021 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Annual Growth Rate = 0.504 Eastbound I Westbound Northbound I Southbound L T R I L T R L T R J L T R Mid -ley I 0 a 49 I 54 0 0 0 4 60 I 0 0 0 I ! ! I Immok & Oakes 4 Al Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict PL20180002678 Exhibit V.F Flood Zone Fenufflood2ones Final FEN1A DFIR_li Base Flood Elevation Contours Flood Zones X500 A AE AH YE X Au I Subject Property — Flood Zones X500, AH (12.5) and X February 13, 2019 Page 1 of 1 NSCOB Exhibit VF.docx ® GradyNnor Civil Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners •Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.G.3 Warranty Deeds June 13, 2019 NSCOB Exhibit VG3 Cover Page. docx ® GradyNnor Civf] Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com 3997055 OR: 4207 PG: 1133 RECORDED tk OFFICIAL RECORDS Of COLLIER COOETI. FL 04/03/2007 at 02:16PK DVIGET I. HOC1, CLERK RIC FEE 27.00 I11111HIG 3.00 DOC-.70 ,10 Reta: 1,ki. pmp" by: GEORGE P LANFORD GEORGE P. LANGF'ORD 1TAKIAKE A Attorney at Law EAFLPLBS FL 3i103 3357 Tamiami Trail North Naples, Florida 34103 (239)262-2011 WARRANTY DEED THIS INDENTURE, made this 28th day of February, 2007, between SHARON A. WINKLER, a married person, GRANTOR, and JOHN H. WINKLER, as Trustee of the JOHN H. WINKLER TRUST AGREEMENT DATED THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2007, whose post office address is: 7374 Bulb Farm Road, Wellborn, FL 32094, GRANTEE, WITNESSETH. That said GRANTOR for and in consideration of the sum of Ten and No1100 Dollars ($10.00), and other good and valuable consideration to said Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledge, has gmrited,bargained and sold to the said Grantee, and Grantee's heirs and assigns.f6rever, an undivided 116 interest in the following described property, situate, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to -wit: Tract 23, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit$7, as per plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96, Public RkcAs of Collier Coitilty, Flor-64 and f� Tract 49, GOLDEN GATEESTATES, Unit 97, as.per oiat f recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96, Public Recooi ,qf Collier County, FI(q ida;'. The North 75' of the South l Y'ofTractNo..24; WEN GATE ESTATES, UNIT NO.97, according to the map orpla{_(lierddr- 6d in Plat Book 7, Page 96, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida; and The North 150 feet of Tract No.24, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit No. 97, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96. of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida. This deed conveys an undivided fifty (50%) percent of the Grantor's total interest in the above described property. The property described herein is not the homestead of the Grantor, and neither the Grantor nor the Grantor's spouse, nor any one for whose support the Grantor is responsible, resides on or adjacent to said land. Subject to easements and restrictions common to the subdivision; oil, gas and mineral interests of record if any; zoning and use restrictions imposed by governmental authority; taxes for the current year. Property I.D. Numbers: 41931080006; 41933240006; 41931120005; and 41931200006 and said Grantordoes hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. OR: 4207 PG: 1134 TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the above described real estate in fee simple with the appurtenances upon the trust and forthe purposes set forth in this Deed and in the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust. If Grantor, JOHN H. WINKLER, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall be the Grantor's wife, SHARON A. WINKLER. If SHARON A. WINKLER cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall be the Grantor's wife's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON. IfCHRISTINE E. THOMPSON, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Co -Trustees shall be the Grantor's wife's son-in-law, ROY THOMAS THOMPSON, Grantor's wife's granddaughter, TRACY N. THOMPSON and Grantor's wife's grandson, ROY TRAVIS THOMPSON or if one or more of them fail to qualify or cease to act then the other of them as Co -Trustees or Trustee, as the case may be. Ali successor Trustees are hereby granted the power to protect, conserve, sell, lease, encumber, or otherwise manage and dispose of the real property described in this deed. The powers ofthe Trustee and all Successor Trustees shall extend to any and all rights the Grantor possesses in the above -described real property; any deed, mortgage, or other instrument executed by the Trustee shall convey all rights or interests ofthe Grantor including homestead; and the Trustee is appointed as the attorney -in -fact for the Grantor to cant' out this intent; which appointment shall be durable and shall not be affected by the incapacity of the Grantor. Any person dealing with the T Mail de However, no person shall deal w► �s"sor Trw received by that person or plac�r cord in the a A. The written resignation of the p ' r r before a no ';dc' fi . V 0 B. A certified cite e p C. The order of a clq 'a f competent j Trustee in the order as set forth above. 4alor more ofthe following have been r T ee. J dicating the prior Trustee incompet oving that T d& fo'r any reason. �f Zt `- certificates of tt so -r�[ee and aphysiciancurrently D. The written practicing medicine stating that the Trustee is unable to manage his or her own affairs or is physically or mentally incapable of discharging the duties of Trustee. E. The written removal o£a Successor Trustee and/or the appointment of an additional Successor Trustee by the Grantor's wife, SHARON A. WINKLER, or the Grantor's wife's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON sworn to and acknowledged before a notary public, this right being reserved to the Grantor's wife, SHARON A. WINKLER, or the Grantor's wife's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON. In no case shall any party dealing with the Trustee in relation to the real estate or to whom the real estate or any part of it shall he conveyed, contracteO to he sold, ]eased or mortgaged by Trustee, be obliged to see to the application of any purchase money, rent or money borrowed or advanced on the premises, or be obliged to see that the terms of this trust have been complied with, or be obliged to inquire into the necessity or expediency of any act of the Trustee, or be obliged or privileged to inquire into any of the terms of the Trust or Declaration of Trust; and every deed, trust deed, mortgage, lease or other instrument executed by Trustee in relation to the real estate shall be conclusive evidence in favor of every person relying upon or claiming under any such conveyance, lease or other instrument (a) that at the time of its delivery the trust created by this Indenture and by the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust was in fuII force and effect, (b) that such conveyance or other instrument was executed in accordance with the *** OR: 4207 PG; 1135 *** trusts, conditions and ]imitations contained in this Indenture and in the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust and is binding upon all beneficiaries undersuch instruments, (c) that Trustee was duly authorized and empowered to execute and deliver every such deed, trust deed, lease, mortgage or other instrument and (d) if the conveyance is made to a successor or successors in trust, that such successor or successors in trust have been appointed properly and vested ful ly with all the title, estate, rights, powers, duties and obligations of the predecessor in trust. Any contract obligation or indebtedness incurred orentered into by the Trustee in connection with the real estate may be entered into by him in the name of the then beneficiaries under the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust, as their attorney in fact, by this Deed irrevocably appointed for such purpose, or, at the election of the Trustee, in his own name as Trustee of an express trust and not individually, and the Trustee shall have no obligation whatsoever with respect to any such contract, obligation or indebtedness except only so far as the trust property and funds in the actual possession of the Trustee shall be applicable for its payment and discharge, and all persons and corporations whomsoever and whatsoever shall be charged with notice of this condition from the date of the filing for record of this Deed. tN WTI'NESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence. Witness: 1,, \Nancy P. C�llano: 'j STATE OF FLORIDA r COUNTY OF COLLIEM .e� GRANTOR R C6 A. WINKLER The foregoing instrun eM,4as acknowledged fie' ( rejQiri6 281h day of February,2407 by SNARON A. WINKLER and w!me,' personally known to produced as identification. >fI Ct�taut fret: orge P. Langford (SEAL) _r�gw'a, George P. Langfor commission # 00508 7 ?F Expires February 10. 2010 +� ii•BoM.a imy Pw ..n...•.nr. '+e K9•SSS•70'4 3997056 OR: 4247 PG: 1136 RICORDBD in OFFICIAL RICORDS of COLLAR COUNTY. FL 01/03/2007 at 02:16PH DWIGHT B, MCI, CLIRIt lie FIB 27.00 IIDIXING 3.00 DOC-.70 M TLir indsumeaf prep—d 6y: Beta: GIORGI P LANGFORD 3357 TANIiINI TR I GEORG£ P.I..AIVGFoIZD NAPLIS FL 3}103 Attomey at Law 3357 Tamiami Trail North Naples, Florida 34103 (239) 262-201 l WARRANTY DEED THIS INDENTLTRE, made this 28th day of February, 2007, between SHARON A. WINKLER, a married person, GRANTOR, and SHARON A. WINKLER, as Trustee of the SHARON A. WINKLER TRUST AGREEMENT DATED THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2007, whose post office address is: 7374 Bulb Farm Road, Wellbom, FL 32094, GRANTEE, WITNESSETH. That said GRANTOR for and in consideration of the sum of Ten and No1100 Dollars ($10.00), and othergood and valuable consideration to said Grantor in hand paid bysaid Grantee, the receiptwhereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted; bargained and sold to thesaid Grantee, and Grantee's heirs and assigns forever, an undivided 116 interest in the following described property, situate, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to -wit: Tract 23, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES-, UnitT, asp r 4thereof recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96, Public R�cor�s of C�llner o ht Flo ; ari[I Tract 49, GOLDEN GAtE.ESTATES, Unit 97, riper plat th6i:of recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96, Public Recvrds`pf Collier County, llgrida; The North 75' ofthe South'l $td' of TractNo_.24; GQLEiEN GATE ESTATES, UNIT NO.97, according to the map or pia(;rtierdop,r -Co,d" d in Plat Book 7, Page 96, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida; and TheNorth 150 feet of Tract No.24, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit No. 97, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96, ofthe Public Records of Collier County, Florida. This deed conveys an undivided fifty (50%) percent of the Grantor's total interest in the above described property. The property described herein is not the homestead of the Grantor, and neither the Grantor nor the Grantor's spouse, nor any one for whose support the Grantor is responsible, resides on or adjacent to said land. Subject to easements and restrictions common to the subdivision; oil, gas and mineral interests of record if any; zoning and use restrictions unposed by governmental authority; taxes For tine current year. Property I.D. Numbers: 41931080006; 41933240006; 41931120005; and 4I931200006 and said Grantordoes hereby fully warrant the title to said land,and will defend thesame against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. OR; 4207 PG: 1137 7`0 HAVE AND TO HOLD the above described real estate in fee simple with the appurtenances upon the trust and forthe purposes set forth in this Reed and in the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust. If Grantor, SHARON A. WINKLER, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall be the Grantor's husband, JOHN H. WINKLER. If JOHN H. WINKLER cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall be the Grantor's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON. IfCHRISTINE E. THOMPSON, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Co -Trustees shall be the Grantor's son-in- law, ROY THOMAS THOMPSON, Grantor's granddaughter, TRACY N. THOMPSON and Grantor's grandson, ROY TRAVIS THOMPSON or if one or more of them fail to qualify or cease to act then the other of them as Co -Trustees or Trustee, as the case may be. All successor Trustees are hereby granted the power to protect, conserve, sell, lease, encumber, or otherwise manage and dispose of the real property described in this deed. The powers of the Trustee and all Successor Trustees shall extend to any and all rights the Grantor possesses in the above -described real property; any deed, mortgage, or other instrument executed by the Trustee shall convey all rights or interests of the Grantor including homestead; and the Trustee is appointed as the attomey-in-fact for the Grantor to carry out this intent, which appointment shall be durable and shall not be affected by the incapacity of the Grantor. Any person dealing with the Trustee shall .deal -with the Trustee in the order as set forth above. However, no person shall deal with a $.ucrGste rtu� one or more of the following have been received by that person or placed ui the af(ireiotined county: A. The written resij�naj p '-Mst;e�swom'tp aT acknowledged before a notary n lic. B. A certified d6'af ift I f the �rior Trat4�. C. The order of a L of competent jurisdiction icating the prior Trustee mcompe r removing that "ltrustce'�r any reason. D. The written certificates ivstee arid a physician currently practicing medicine stating that '#]vs{ee is unable to manage his or her own affairs or is physically or mentally incapable of discharging the duties of Trustee. E. The written removal of a SuccessorTnustee and/or the appointment of an additional Successor Trustee by the Grantor's husband, JOHN H. WINKLER, or the Grantor's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON sworn to and acknowledged before a notary public, this right being reserved to the Grantor's husband, JOHN H. WINKLER, or the Grantor's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON. In no case shall any party dealing with the Trustee in relation to the real estate or to whom the real estate or any part of it shall be conveyed, contracted to be sold, leased or mortgaged by Trustee, be obliged to see to the application of any purchase money, rent or money borrowed or advanced on the premises, or be obligee to wee that the terms of this trust have oeen complied ►v&4 or oe obliged toinquire into the necessity or expediency of any act of the Trustee, or be obliged or privileged to inquire into any of the terms of the Trust or Declaration of Trust; and every deed, trust deed, mortgage, lease or other instrument executed by Trustee in relation to the real estate shall be conclusive evidence in favor of every person relying upon orcIaiming under any such conveyance, Iease or other instrument (a) that at the time of its delivery the trust created by this indenture and by the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust was in full force and effect, (b) that such conveyance or other instrument was executed in accordance with the *** OR, 4207 PG; 1138 *** trusts, conditions and limitations contained in this Indenture and in the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust and is binding upon all beneficiaries under such instruments, (c) that Trustee wale duly authorized and empowered to execute and deliver every such deed, trust deed, lease, mortgage or other instrument and (d) if the conveyance is made to a successor or successors in trust, that such successor or successors in trust have been appointed properly and vested fully with al the title, estate, rights, powers, duties and obligations of the predecessor in trust. Any contract obligation or indebtedness incurred orentered into by the Trustee in connection with the real estate may be entered into by her in the name of the then beneficiaries under the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust, as their attorney in fact, by this Deed irrevocably appointed for such purpose, or, at the election of the Trustee, in her own name as Tmstee of an express trust and not individually, and the Trustee shall have no obligation whatsoever with respect to any such contract, obligation or indebtedness except only so far as the trust property and funds in the actual possession of the Trustee shall be applicable for its payment and discharge, and all persons and corporations whomsoever and whatsoever shall be charged with notice of this condition from the date of the filing for record of this Deed. IN WI'i'NESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: GRANTOR �R c Witness Nancy o ,1 S N.A. WINKLER $ s� ieorge'P. Langford STATE OF FLORII7A COUNTY OF COLLIE The foregoing rostrum nl was acknowledged before me this 28th day of February, 2007 by SHARON A. WINKLER and wh\, .U: personally known to me, T,IL L 11�� ❑ produced k EnnisN Ewrtu i SEAL) �• George P. Langford Commission # DD5M37 Expires February 10, 2010 as identification. P. Langford Naples Senior Center CFPUD PL20180002622 Summary of Chain of Title The status of ownership, along with the interpretation of the relevant deeds in the chain of title to the subject property, has the potential to be somewhat confusing. Below is a summary. - Prior to 1996, all four parcels of the subject land were vested in "Ralph L. Gritten." - In 1996, Ralph L. Gritten recorded four deeds from himself, individually, to "Ralph L. Gritten and Anna Marie White Gritten, as Trustees of the Ralph L. Gritten Family Trust dated September 11, 1996", and, upon the death of Ralph L. Gritten and Anna Marie White Gritten, while still Trustees, their Successor Co -Trustees were to be Peggy Allen and Lowell White. THIS MI ENTUM made this + day OF I _r& 1994. P"Ween RALPH L„ (MITTEN, whose addrm is 792 lltkh Ave. North, Naplr rids 339963, OnLntor, Lad RAI.) i L. GRrEIMf Nd ANK4 INLAI#LE WHITS GRTTTEN, as Trustees of the RAL PIT Lr GR0.TY EN FAMILY TRUST dated . ,5F r� r t . L!fi. wltb the paver sad autkwiV to arctm% oonmrxe and to m1l, ar to Imse, ar go cntvmber, or elhat*JW to manap and @space or the rW property, whose address is 792110th Ave. North, Naples, Florida 33963, Grantees; t3pau the dear of RfaLFH Ly Glkn-' N and Ai --NA ?4AR1E WHITE GRr7TEN, white still Teusteer, their Stuxesmw C-T�rustew shall be PEGGY ALLEN and L OWrzLL WHITE. AL Truft;,es shaL be anihari=d with Full powers as staled hcreys and =a Lhc Trust doarmeot itself. - Ralph L. Gritten died 12/24/1996. - Anna Marie White Gritten died 09/17/03. - Successorship is clear on the four deeds from 1996. The four properties were not brought into any probate case, nor did we find any civil cases that might involve the subject land. - In 2005 there are a sting of deeds from the apparent lineal descendants of the above decedents. Then in 2007 there are several deeds that once again changed the vesting of legal title to the properties. We are of the opinion that the 2005 and 2007 deeds only clouded title. Nevertheless, since the parties to those deeds are not strangers to title, we have called for quit -claim deeds from those who were identified as grantees, namely, the Sharon A. Winkler Trust and the John H. Winkler Trust, whose interests were created by virtue of the 2005 and 2007 clouded deed chain, and we have presumed them to be equal co -owners, for purposes of disclosure to the County. - For purposes of disclosure of any interest to the County, and to be certain all possible interests have been disclosed, the Seller disclosed all of the above trusts which hold title January 10, 2019 W GradyMhior Page 1 of 2 NSCOB Summary Chain of Title-revl.docx Civil Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com Naples Senior Center CFPUD PL20180002622 Summary of Chain of Title to one or more parcels of the subject property, together with the identity of the trust beneficiaries. The complete chain of title in support of the above analysis is attached. January 10, 2019 W GradyMinor Page 2 of 2 NSCOB Summary Chain of Title-revl.docx CIVH Fingfnccr5 • Lana SuR'eyors • 111anncr;, • Lan[I$CalxC ArvhIttvtt Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com �r r pL �] I fr �} �1L fL1f *.naf MVT gCLO �xf .j� f - �r i'���[ #4J wawEa roll F'I c i This loam mg 11ttd kt ni' ii. - t.15 . J e.e t} Yarlmnrla Sheck•t' 11,W1II.I1Ire lgpfl"i I+Ir 1Fr.I111Fw III Naiph L. Qxliten ��yy reyL �y �i .1 ■y iF rlI FLM oN-%f4Ff IMF.. FIr111hrk% LE 792 110th AiPanUg Worth, Naplub Florida 33940 1..'r.'Allryilrl 1 rl�'F� fI.L' !11#ll�i•n� lhtile.r. J Li.wr ,I• .e.� ., iha'" ..A e..al.. I.iFxl. ¢ IW �elx1 w iw. IR,iu�.Y .xL �1��} F1� iFl+S•el+�+1h +I•fil iF1'y'•+.1 i...i, Ii.+l y� .L.L��i1.1� ..11 Ike •!L#r1., .nl +•'+5, +I iyl..ai�•-•� + !<Y++�LI\� Lrr FF JIlui III' {N.II++llo. irit IIFNr hi FNuFlF Aall,'idu))F11L rilll Ihr slllll 411 � 10.100 J Hnlr WIAn IIFrri nhti• F+Frl.iilrrnl{FFFL4, NY {+•AI.I Y'1li'FL'I,I F5 hrrl'1 y IFr4FMFlr'1'1F+111'r1. !IL'FL'11Y IIr+1+ m+ . 1INPIl /ilif./y.N II■I• oIhYu, Ir a nli.i'\. IrrkINM1.. .LILII'OVT NONNI nFr'lfteli% IALFrI3 fh" prI1FIFr - .., f1I11r Lr'rl1IILl IIIFIL! F110IIIlf, IF1 CaIIJ.*Y {•+FFFFIrY 14..J4111 .'12 All of Trafi: 49, Coiden Gate 6atateff, Unit No. 91. according to plat In Pl*t book J, Pages 95 and 96, Pub11c Revords of CoLlior Covaty. Florida. This it vacs c Isnd uni proved SaiLL usiste oud hAll %Tana of the ch4ract.0 .atier of hv�eetaad p�opri[ty1 L ,-..J , li is wu I a .. f LO R i A` t'. - L krl. aCT,y"li:?k�' ��La IL 09A will, all 11., lenm rnke„hm*JPIMINII! and 430p+lFrrnanw r7,4 fL 6nongr tr to wo- wrir apprrl ufn lap. To Hut and to mid} me "Priv in jop PPww,. iormwe- 1 A" 16 QF=tzor 6rr,ldy rovenaoti. wiP& Fall LAW nlr. 161 rho grantor IN Ivl4(u{ly Atlanrl of jm'i land In lee einWlr; Thal 114a' jTranfar hom Boo Fap11i iawjrLd aulh0NTy Io ,dli And tohwy A.ui "114 r6i rhr p+a.FiPr 6rrrhY 11IMY worroF)rr t6r HILL' Iv EZM fund And Fe'III drJrnd ILLi, imma oYa[nal Ik■ lawful C6'Md of all peruw, wJ46mle.var; and Thal Fard land rm jiw a) a encum6ratim, rxmpr lam ixtufnq d4pr']I1rni ro i +r*+111,rr il, 14 77 ",1 t=1SjCio'o8 and raitsi,eGlans 4t record. ci VRInM ro , rk...id y,f lnr kWr LfQnrd ORA FL"aIrd IhnWd r,Fkd raa. fdF l 06ar wellrn. Fraud artd'4U1Wj1d In OLEP pine"" {' L' +}118ria"Tidl shocker aT&T& or ' . 1'V#REIV CM-fiFY Ih,IF as All dy, 6r[aq ar, an erfiFer JOY rt•amlhC;F]14d in a& jul, atah-I W iFld 10 lie Coanir skan.0 - 1.4r 'F+F�I,gdM1H'+rIlL4 Vrrpa'E► ■pp'rarr4 .. . bp�s3L7�r SlssoteLr 1 'gip' Inl a L be IAr prn►x' d}lruhni in ilyd F4* #usuied 16q rarraul W..menl i,hd *bR a krre.lydv d iafaRl jW IMI Jb* 4•. Itd IILC Li9.F- '.i']TNZE4 FrFr glad and olrkul is Iwr CI:WLtx •.d M-11 IW Ma.r Lm diiwYW ul. tl r i d<x OF LLaard CV.FI*Y . A. Q- 19 / F JI.aILi 7i1�f `. liii filtFr,u.Wr I.. SmdrIoU. Vlcqi Pra*. r�dd�laa � f�C�i E11C1r.11�C. 1111RM F L ; Fein =41 a FFC]!.i RQC�p 811piL L'U L.rfR Collkl V1 FLOitt A (kT 9 9 (*AN III �f �l i� .792741 { 4ANTWNY 63229lF # I�4faMrOrber�l 1 J- WALT$Pl5 and KA0141 R. WALTERS, Humband and Wif, I 1"r...... PI.-r ..Irr-.l rl. 111•iii{,ii I.. RALPH La CAMEN i.IJ,.,.. d,r.+1.r1Pl. r- P.r.l..... . 792 110th Avt., North N.1plem, it8t`f1 Jb 4Lr lu�Yrlr.a l,'I I,Itl.�l #lN �Il.Ini., '��'1/ �1� _ ■r-1 .. + -.♦.i/�, r. !I,.., •!w 11 i.l++i l.,l ..I.r .i r r. �.l. l.,i+.��lr r4 rlil++ ,Ilnl A 31V. 013 .4Ilei eidl..4 f'llilnllrr` ..r- iJ, 1.il-1, .. Je+ll �l .. A. .r.o .� Lr. I.% 11.•L w•.rr 1,4l,.-,i ±I.r*. 1i1' ri.�..�1. L�r.•!.ol.- •�rr, plil�.la /{ mdk—, Fay: �s ,��u,. L. .11I.1 A. .1l.rlr" xi rlruI+.'!j.li11 lulu-.11... P.-hl The North 150 feet of Tract No. 24. GOlden Cate Estates, Unit No. 97, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat DID-Dk 7. Page 96, of the Public Records of Collier County, f`lorjdA. n� {ylcl •F1 1 6 :0 0 '7 1 IDII�6cr I. mi oil eke h,IWMP!!!d. jrrv"tidYAnd/ 'kn4 ajIPPIq 1 h-1m..'• tr4orl.r rr-iqurying yr iia ypf• u•JAr ri+n.•ndniiig To *We md to ■ fd. a., •.+rlr dI i.... ,uryNil• hu.,.y ad ll-r -ime tdm lirm1rr .iirrriu+dli ndiir ,nrri Irrn01.N Illnl thr .1rILn14pt a. 1h1.',.ILrw siYr.� Of rgi{G {and d4 trr arrmlrrlrJa il 16- eiramiRre hGA ir"f Nr{1L1 lin+l++i6.-fdol 1llJl..4rat toI .rli �1.1.; lalk"i-V MiJ i11�= 161 16F r+Funt•Y fiff. kv l iplOw nYYMFII% Ph.- jide Id. 4u.4 bidet A.11l a -all .i{-I.'+n.i lllr' 1i the - .III, . ( 1lw lmi4w1 rfedmi of gll j+r,rnrlq I4•l;..IFL,.4-.w- mill fl,gr MPII I6A+l l+ lrr, i!r ILrl rn1.IRlflrinli aa- r;.. IrF IgS+ti LS.I FuiaIJ 4111Uer#lwml ail 1".miwr F1 1479 and conditions mid restriutions of record. i Itr `s5 ECDI: Ill,, .un� dimn(w hn+ mrnn,vl Midi ■rnlw! IA~ prr.r-nJN Ihr Itur and! 7r .q+l nlrer•N Iuriv aL N:giyrf. .rPirJ nlul F1rhgvrmi in wiv rFFra mte'; 01 Al ERS 4 r + 3r.{[ FF54+' 1 lLCrJrt1l} 41r 1111.S1V Ely 1 411.l1I.M, L'F ' 111'+r 11Fi1 nn ItNI .1.15- jrrr,yr nw. 41, 1411drt dWY. •wiY -I.d .r. 41h. 4r,lr Al.101m.1 Aq•1 in ih, retina A4-wad 1-. U6- �Irr.rkdlll�r.ill i"'+wr•N� .pW.rwlil� - 11:.'Lhony J. Walters and Naomi A. Walters I CGI:I •'SA yr 1'.. j•—e 1r' Iw r?- ' r-o. r .1—r-1—I IN ,Fil 4h-- F.••wlnl IJV Lys.n• n..0the I1r Ih,1 ff-Qy %%II 4.,Fe1 on.] rain +l —1 m i,., Ir+wm% Ah4 i .Ir d..L I. &—..1 1111% F1i5 rH � 4 r •• r Y wrf,y#fJ��k � rfl•�•�f .fo mission expireiit NC RY.T:15i.I [[�� j�,1f.A'1 i i f.r...-lrNldli��rra[* AL r; bona, itj+J. C[• •1'fti;;. Naplt:ft, Florida is'#•d3 • r # at;L,•tuea� cEf>r�'17 �it� rRALPM itsAd 834555���} fifl u05U ni rnlg. Made ibis 5 th diry of May A.D. 3960 16.40rim GAC Pro erties tic.p 0_R. P� i43S Rex4.00oration exi.stirrg onde, the taws of the State of Florida having; its principal place of business in the of Dade rind State of Florida, party of the first part, and - C141TTFIR a pc-t y of the second part, whose post offirr address is. 792 110th Avenue North, Naples, Florida 33940 Witntlsopth. Tliot the said party of the first part, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN DOLLARS AND OTI[ER VALUABLE CONSIDE fIAT1ONS to ii in hand paid by the mart y of the second liars, the receil,t whereof is hereby acknon:ltNiged, has granted, bargained acid sold to the acid part y of the srcond part, their heirs and assigns forever, the fallowing descried lmsd, rituate, lying and bring in the County of Collier and State of Florida, to -wit: The North 75' of 24 zue__Snuth TRACT(S) NO.----, COLEW1a CATE ESTATES, U\iT NO. 9 77 — _. according tc the trap or plat 1hereaf recorded in Flat Book 7 ___., pages 96 of the Public! Records of Collier County. Florida. WBjECT TO THE following restrictions and -esemations. 1. The grantee. his successors. heirs or assigns, shall nay for the paving ❑. plattarl streets for the propet(y herein described if and when said sirvets are Paled, rntsuant to a reS:,lutirn by the Board of Co:Inty Cotnmissioners as mar., fully shown in O.R. Book W, Page lts3, Pubic Rec-erds of Collier Comdv -1 Suhject to easements, Restrictions and Resen•stinns of Reonrd with the Cleri of the Circuit Court in and for Co'Ler Courty. Florida. 3. Suhject !n Real Properly Tax sohseq,tent to 1930 And the said nerty of the frst part tines hereby jully tearrunt title !a said land, and :till defend the saint against the dae: ful claims of all prisons u.homwever. N MWIS . grof. the, said party of the first part has caused these presen ��¢ its rife by its duly anthirzed ofc—, end its corporate kp� f�4rtfjlVl y anr, year aUer a u'rtten. ,,--WAC Proportyes 44 / Co rarai /A�_B- Seul) t vice President FL4'~t4P -_ I Ft7GM'�7G3F�iG Sr'Q.J�t11�:r � ---.-- t)O =UNtEhIiAP.Yf—' STAMP PAX Sitatr of Yloriba' UEr"r_QF R'--VLHUE _ 16.4 O l = KATZ; m 3 lirrebrrg Qlrrtifg that on this day personally appeared before me, an officer duly authorfzed to admirrfste* oaths and tak, acknawledgmen3r, SERNYCE KAS➢IN_ Vice President of GAC FROPERTIES INC., a Florida carporat?an, to me well known ❑nit knnWn to me to be the individual described in cnd who e=rcuted the faregofng Irufrumrnt, .7nd he acknotcirdgrd the execution thereof to be his free act and deed as rich offic.- for the pews and purpose! therein expressed, and that he affixed thereto iho official seal of aid corporation, and the said ntstrurnent is the ice and .'eeri of said eorgorctwn. Utfa]rss my ;lamp and official seal at Afia of _ -2---19 rt.;;*a.0 N orr�br satwm w,w►,M �. Rinr»Y1 Ertl .r c� CM 441111 CY I] 6T PRINTED IN U $F county and rtate, an fair the Notary Public State fly Commisrfon expirrr: Norry PuW, limo of FT6rkk n tzro (SEAL) my 1:,,p4as D*Lvrb r 8, hill day *dµ1 f!l:F,ti�4r3r ! at belly pu�LIC. 4 I I -A0# 4.19 TM poplim"m Mocila 0i's , ".1 d" of A t) 19 11111mitam 14.'�'Try 11. 1m­,,il:iAV,!, irol A:.!l*F W. Auld PrU-Pif I.. 11AITTM ,whose post offloa Oddr"$ 16 *711.1 1 . A-.*i,! a- . t " , '-.4; . !'. ­ Willfieneds. That the drantor, for and in cons,clEwat-om 04 the svm of TEN MtAiS ANo OTHER VALUADLE CyNSID( QAT IONS m hand "z:: by +4 GF61-we is hereby &ck-Am-.iedqg-d.- N"qvi zoniloys to the Gforitisis the reel propiartv in Collar County. Fltsri4o. dwrillsaid as 1 ,,t t I,.' r t., In I RecorJ!. ut Cll! I i -.-r 0­471 tv 4 T.)T I M ------ 5"IMUCT to ranvm n t s. rA•stric-t tonr; *in-ri-ro-Irvat *r.n% , , : 1. FTATE t F:_0Ps0A ":J(.UtAfN 7 A2 Y ?A M P z 1, 00 And the %4'd Gfant," tws town mi tt,92t the g*rA`1f1tF1V -- bee -6 Q11 rnCw�!­1n--Wk% What jwfu3 %vi-, r, or and qkvd ?-of ?- cm%r% that vr,%slesh. are esteil -n I-,r Cvont.,t um! P14at vhf. Gront,,r I-c-rcb% t.l,. warrants tne Idle •j SJA 1AMI eyMs ..it itv ic—ir i.j :.n%l ­Wr 44-1— io W,,, J .,It *K sovvw, Sarmad in dw pmvimmr SOL _ HEAL STATI OF Fl,f)RIDA COMY OF LEE I He"m MOM that an this day personatly appeared 606re rnf, On Of#Ktf duly av*41,ze., to S&ntnmw *Oift ww take LESTRalM. HATCHARr) and ALICE W. HAT.CHAIRD, hu-;ban.1 ir..i wt7a-, No r�rw be Ow Fie'sm dowd3ad as Grffftr grid who executed ft endf0raqwng e�vd �d Lena we �II *m said pwacpm exocvvd the wyo lively and voltjmdjjv for " purpose 7 aow, clay of A.D. 19 r w bo it '? M 6 Mwery "ic 'NbTARY SEALI This irtanwaint III mps e by I'homas R. Brown, Esq. LAW OFFOC13 OF CARROLL, VIE", RROWN and MICNOU, P.A. DALCm SUPLOING. MAWLE11, FL0010A 2f7M45 '1ri2 frit 440 THIS Irt011111"44 r,ri:0e ! t,-. rt•r ft 0190gur 1 To wwre, the f,ovrr,enf k•f fhe a9grtgalt sum of money no`nsed in the promiuory rtole of even date herew Ih a J nerm,rwlle, alf,tc+,e1 t "jelher w-rn .ntertsl I+rgx,r, at%i all oi^gr turns uf,rrwney, Wured herlbr as f,rrr,nartrr Ike µotfoWr f4febv mortgages to the Morlpcg" that tier. to n reel poOtoer11 Kerr MOW crsc••bal 2 The Mttatpagar hurebv tuvenonts and agrees with the Mortgagee I" Tr 1yv c'r air! s.ryu'a, we •,n ,t+al an,1 interest do : v,er %.ml, of msr:ty parable by vrtlur ,l sa•,1 rtrT! rxl fh.y l+.rrg rife ••re' .•• r.rr.rr prompt', w• P. a.rn TMorocI very the softie severally v: b,et,v*,r due chi Tr t,o, a:' ;Jn,: r+.r tu.r� 01Nt5TCnrl Ir•,n t,:b +es, rbl•gat.,,ns Will entum- brar. e, ,It e,er, nfltulr. ,— sa•tf br.I p' petty aryl I I,,e sane be nJt pr,.mptis pn.d. the Wort. gagre rf•c„ of o,%y liar t,r.7t the same wlrr•,%A wo,v ng M urge:.l•„y the .Ipt,ar to film:tole or or, r-ihl hereurxfer, aril every po,ment to tnakle 0-:II bear ,nreresl both Ire ,,fate thereCt at the rote of ten per centum per annun, fcl To pov ar: and singular the c.rr,, cho,ye, un,: e•prn•,r•,_ r.zJiod rig law,efs fees and ob- aliuct c. its eta,• t.l, ,r•rurred : - pn•d of any hrne bs the 4•.-•rq see t+ecau,t of er.r failure on the pc': of lhr MorrgugoT to per!arM, cvr+pty and orb de b, e,Tcf• oin0 ere" fr,e st•t•ufat.:ns rr}ree• r Meats. c.,d,t,ans and Lu.rnunts of said mate and th,s m xtq,:ye CtreJ. of e,ther, and every su_r: P.0)- mirtil shall bear Interest fromi dote of Ine, *ate -• pe: cv' fi:^, 1x1 nnnum Id To pe,rr,d, c;war„•T Jr wier no waste, rrr•{,aur rr r -ctc, :,r,Tf :n of sa�J pr.nrerty or an. part thereof it, Tr pe,ft,m, r: mpty with and abide bs each unJ r.rry t-r st ;•alCRkrrt, CBreemer,rS, Ccndf- t,ans oink! covenant: ,n :,aid note and in this r,o,'gt:t;e or•ed set t.+rTh it) '*Not if ony of sa,d sums-sf m,,nev herein rerette t t, }e r,t : •srnpt:y a^d !;stay j':I,f w r±-'n • often .:_ rs nest at!er The some severcfl, 'v carre, : ut ant: . =i, r •f a •cr, :rod s:,,rr, tk•e slit kit l h-,nS og,remrr. •kndd-ons and cavensnrs of s: ,a , . It ro-4 I••.; ^ ;-T;age dre.:, Cr e,thrr, C-e r+.,t to:=s pert;rme-. ca'r•pl•ed w,fh an3 ab:,:e: bs. the sa d %C.j nk,Tr sh:IF become slue .ins 1,n,aL•ls farth,w.N, or !hrracctter at the :{,In,n, , t-e .S•,•rs:r-,yre cr, fu: , un•l c"—pielel? nt •T the »:.: 7g91ey.3tC yum of said note vias trig hilt:: sf;^_i•.h.: r he t" i.,J• :u► anrt• ,r,g on a d twit jr he•s•u, to the confrgry not r .rhsrcn Fog ;, TI , i ,rt ,,rdet I,. a:etlerlc the n';71ur t, d me .rx rtrnlnrks r,r,rt. u• ,.,r,l hr e...r .•r vt•e fa,'ure rt 1••e tC P,),, :r, ru♦, a„e,srtnT, :.JL•• ON }.a • s . r er, .. ',r astir yr.•..+, s3 d 7 - pr.-{,err, as rerc.• �•a, e.i. it as n:r b. :•ry thl' Mime Ohl Tr•r Len t.ere:•f shall rrtrral ra r;-kl ,nc:%,.ft 1- t k,u rent..:r._I ; . r t•. + : j•vrt,•:er but The A! trh;eg: • ;etc:t huve the r ,get I, rensa.n to thl,srs.r. «t va : l r- ,c. •s,..1 r,•, + r• mr : r rece.,e the rents cad prohri Thtreol, watt-:•ut otcuuntfng +. t• M. rL; ;,a f• ov—f r n j ,.. r•.r•r yhk::, be no defuwJt he•cunar+, ;tr,a•Jcj tt•al :n the event : E :r, %,r, t:.:ef -11 0 wr„ o x, f.,r .r ; e- -1 of f.fiern da,., the 1&o1fg.,,]1Ue shall t.,e cnT•tled to the ! rev.., n cn.' w.r ,-1 s. -t '• .0.1 • ;r,:. of,, -` Ise., ,tn,: to rrcewc and cpplN, tf,e net rents crNj pr,,f,ts t''rrr_•i, u;,kv, . .: t.•.k;,,; ff,,. . •.^a"' f r+r n+Jebredfyess hemb, secured 6! in the e.enr there Shp i tx, Wed a b•11 to t.re:lase th, —",I: ,(I-r ,'fis•.:. r r r ',I , f• r :.f. :1 ,mmeJwfrly orli wifl.aut n,tf„r be cnt.T!ed to the=.po6n1ment of a rr:r„er ter re n• .r�:{oil l' p- erry, and the ftf-f:, eJln,nyS_ "Sues. ,nc �me and prpf.ts there.kl. ,n,th ••.e u•quo• la,w.•, -.f re rwe,s on such costs, and such receiver mc, be confine. ,n pknWA-usn of sad propert, urk.t ,,l ,,, ,: tents. e..rn ,ngs, ,slues. ,ncor„e cod pr,»f.ts of sa,.: properly duf,ng The "rw!e- a v .4 such t•.rre' %..•e •... t .. . rnr M0ort1}0qcor hereby specifically wolooes the r.ghr to object to ,ich acrt,a,nrmMt ,7n.; . ,nsen% lh.v opaorr,tment shaft y,- made as an adm,'!^d equity and ass matter or absalufr right fe the Morty .qer, and w,lhout reference 10 the ade,tuoc, or ,nadCqugCy of the vnlue of the mortga¢r• Vp7prrt, .,r w the solvetiky or insolvency of the Mortgagor or uns other party defendant IV such suit tll In the event the ownership of the rrortrgaj;e,y yre!roK4, or any r+.srt thtrr,,f hrc. nne, .esftd ,n a perm other than Iry Mortgagor„the AWrtgogre sos v.jitho., ncf.,e to the M.-rrrr,rg or. deal w,th such successor or successors in interest with reference Io this mortgage deed unit Of- -lrbt hrrtbi, se- cured, in the some rnonryer os with the Mortgogor w-Ihout in ar, wci r,har,ng o• J-%iharq,ng the N•.ntgoyyur's liability hereunder o, uWn the debt hereby secured No sale Lit the I rer- ." hereb, noicit gaged and Ise torbeoromeo on the port of the Morlgager, and no er<tens,on of the tome fur the •a,- mtnt of the debt hereb, secured goven by the Mortgagee shall operate to release, da,*arge, mod+,, change or affect the orry,rral liability of the Mortgagor herein either in whole ar on part tkt The lien of this ttarlgoge dead secures and shall Continue to secure payment of said-Mltbt• edness .n to ebtednesses, hover, tf evidenced, wherher by %aid We or any renewal or trttenston there• of or substitute therefor, or otherwise. Vntrl all such indebtedness shall have keen fully skord. (I) This mortgage shall inure to the benefit of, and shall Lind. fl+e he,r;, legal repr" serltahvgs. ` successors ankl ossryns of the Mortgagor and the Martgogee respectively. , 't'l! 462 MA 44�-_ III, vahw *0 10140-1.j_M F'olfl, • Ow "tit r— Is P"— A- t1o, .01. t"'I.-I ntq- w I r in - , *--..%: tr an.. x,.,-. r AM w -j r , —s—., -- ..,p,. it. IF hL LAW 09C.C.LS Cr ^-OLI E=-'JV%N Z- P A ..A 9uiTL : VA.: 4 ff 1'4t L -­ F L f.—)A "'Amp 'Ap 1 A .►.. r...� ,•! : •ty^}t.: '. .Ce•r, s••: he 6e0 ^b•eaS tp Ire . fw- (sire :f r .• A, . • `� . .� a s�G he r'. �t ! r • r• a Y. 'y;.�: •• •.s,.rg�Yt ..-,e•r•.rt .. .: r , Y ••r: s s^-. �.. >• �, Wit... • .:•! :+ I...w _�.e !J tl'e M: •rgagee a The r•-ric uai rs pre mi- viaq! nine wtc-or,: bti th,s mortgage .s SIX T11iR'!;A4I1 AND M01100 ------ - »-.- COLUIRS .rj•.,nnr,pn 1 A copy of said rIC•te •s wto,hhi hertW as A onct -ocopporotta herein bl tef*rtMae 4 The Motvq.igo,he.e,„•s FAI.Pli I.. (PIT EN 5 t►w Mur,gagte t tre,n ,s ;J S T I:R 11. Ii 4 dMARD isle..' Al. - t-F W. h:tKha d anA w!r- b Th* real estolr rncurnb fod b* this mortgoW Is situate in ker Gotrrsty, Store of Florida, and s U•galiy descr-bed at -----?Tact 23, Gulden Cott Est itt•t, (`ntt No, 97, -%p ptar plat thvrt•nf rrc-ortlt-1 i r, P131 R00% 7, ; a.l—t 95 anti 96, Public Pvc-ords of ("ollicr C,)unt-r, Florida .----- THIS I9 A PURCHASE MM .i MOPTr,AIl'• Iet• R,�: F :4 RICI WED IV. 11 PITMEMI Of TAKES -,UE OR 6 9 29 AH • ll CttSS 117ANalILE PWO1t11 PROPERTY. WA;,,7,RET 1. SCOTT CLERK + t REM" CtIRM, i UFA car*N 11f J"US WNRREOF, the Meftgagor has Caused th r presents Ic tie e.r- sited on th,s A ilA)' of in thJe�presence ....'(SEAL) ISLAU (SEAL) - .,SEAL) STATII Ot• FLORIDA �""r r firer M►•..r s.. COOK" or COLLIERr+`.rtrwn +tmnr. .LJ l r CMr M C,•..4 C.wr 1 141BUY CERTIFY that or rhls doy before me, an offi,er dui( authanted rn the Stole and CUUnfv'nlare*rd to taluc acktlaw+edgments• perscnallt appeared ,, ` 1(►1M 1%penm descr,bed m and who txmuted the forega.ng Irxtrumertt wid he . AW that he executed the snrtse official seal m the County and State lost aforaso O rhls 3 s' Lt ne AD 19 72. 5slr d fto " r! l► 1r •y 1 MY �` tfarri^p PM" Ti r - 1 SEAL) Th,s InztrUmenl preporet! tn, Thomas R. Brown, Esq. LAW *"#CIS OF CARROLL, VEGA, /ROWN ead MiCPIOU. F.A. 96AIc.•1 DUMPING NAPLEe. ep.OMP• *** 2099093 OR: 2228 PG: 230 UMU it MICM RCO D1 Of CILLITI OMM, !L 11116!96 at 11112m StIm 1. Jim, = fJOC=,�0 .7G ExLFE 1 qtp;C� TH'S n*-MUMENF P Et•'AAEDE rrHOtJT EX'kM1NA-n0N Or TlI; �5 DL) 31 ED IM FARCML M 0 OXW4193m itL[ YlZZ=F# FL 3411S %if Tais WDUTiYJRJP, es*do Lhis „ _ day of �-�r ` L"t Lk- 1S'96, trtrwtseo RALPH L} r-AnFLK uh= add= is 792 I'm Aw- Nortb, Naplcs, P'onia mko, C,ran.lcn, and RALPH L CR rMN and OL NA AIAROr ►VIM GRnIZEN, as Trugm of the RALPH L CR r EN FAMILY TRUST date4 - - I f I 194f>+ WAh am pw.er a.LLd LrAk iq' Co psi, oaoLa" and to tx14, or to Wor, or Co cmmmber, or ad horwfsr w mamW wW dispm OFtk raj paw. whew AM it 792 1109hAvL ltiad�, Naples, Ftwda 33%% Grantees; i P00 Lbc dWb of RALPH L. GRZrrEN and ANNA MARIE WH1TE GlrrrM wbDz still Tr=otes, 0xv Swr-wor Cc-Traancz shall Im PECGY AL LEN and LDWELL Vrarm. All Truuems s1 all ba muihan=d wiLh full pow % ss tined And is LINE Tru;t aw Wa. %7TWSSXT1ffo that raid Gratator. for and is cawi&ralton of TEN AND N0110D DOLLARS ($MM) and othrl good and wakubla Baas to " Grautec in hand paid by said 0rL[atces, the m eipL wbcrea is h=by admcmArdgcr L has wailed. bart Lmcd and wW Co Lava said G rapu= Lead Granlrx'r heirs and =igas fore-ecr, ec foi goring dczen'bod LLz4 cim.uc, 1 wA being in C drer Comwy. F7orxtx to vvit: The IlO1rth 130 taet Of Tract No. 24, GbIden rate Estates, UnLt No. , R7, Recarding to tha plat thereof as recorded in Plat Sank.7, Page raj RG, Of Q16 Public Records OZ Collier County. Florida. }' FROPERTY ODES HDT C VSTXTUTE HONES"TLL'AD of cRAN'TOR Dmo R=IDW AT 792 IZOTH AVE. NORTH, RApL=, rLORIDA. SUBTECT to easaments, restriOtions and rese- vation� of racord, if arty, and taxes for the Calendar year 1996 and subsequent years_ and said Graazor does bezeby fully wanaat Lb a title to uud land sod vritt dcknd the same 3g4ov the tawful rt hn of aQ permow wham r. 0 WMESS WHEREOF. GrAmor has lkfe- L w set Isis hand tad iL . the dry and yww rhu about: wrimen- W'urstu� f -<c W-a.ncsr STATF- OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF LEE RALP L G H 71t: fatcgokS 1twrumcnl was aanorwWgcd barare mu this � �� day of _ :d Y.` ice_ Lyg6, by5Aii LPH L CR EN, who, [ 6 puwma11y korram to me4 cr I bas produc d l is as idaotiFcatiq>q, Tbxa 1wtru. = pfcpwod by RALP13' A. RfCHARnSON /1.Lra4oey at 1 #w 725 Old 41 R=4 Sdw 104 Sauna Springs, Florida U135 3175.615 411C Printed NrmG'_ R.T?f r'4. RSCliAIMSON Noury Pubtir my Coo Lr= aa�fI1L,L11D%7FI e�'�ow �crFl� }} CCBiGa9 �`L3KfLtF wzpa t # 2099096 OR: 2228 P ; 2305 #:t no= i. olal= 11cow of caulu 04.11, n 1111 1 &t 111um mcri x. 214m, RUB uc nj 631 Nc-.7o ,7a utu rRLS 1t+IS'I UME-NT PREPARED Wiz' CUT EXAMIftiATION OF ILM k lYG wsm PARL'F1. fH 0 OMM4wit2iM Tr 4r5 di,4 m im 11H NFM RUNS K141I55ifl w AIR 9966 bcxweco RutH e. GRRTEri, WkW &WX= iS M V tb Aw- North, Naplrk F ��a 33M33 GmAtor. Xnd w�E..P'!i L CRMT q .. d AN -NA WHM GRWrEN, is Truud a we MU11 L. GRnTEN FAMILY TRUST dptvd r l / , � , wlUr ehr pgwtr sad i4 k4 p Eect, ma+erre ud to Sol, or is , or fo aacambw' or 0pwr,+f+e ea eaa o.�t rnd dttpaft dt the rxa] properq, whmv addrmz h M I IDLb Am NamA. htapk4 nwid.r % Cuaa mr upon the (Stub of R ALPH I.. G Ri1TEN aad .62Z A WJUE WHITE GPJT#EN, while Vill'Frustex:L, thck 5u{ xuar C*-Tr=Lr'M"be PEr.GV . � � EW #*d WWMLL "MEL AL TMaX*. a dkon bye asuher3rxsd with rLO pawcrFin off ZIAMM r-d isa de Tract docuamF kpo . eb t said Qga w. 60 toad In =A*W&Liaa of TEN AND NO/Im D011,kPS {S M) wd av Vxj mild vatuabla iaaw to Hid Ora=w la hand paid by t:fd Graalecs, OLD ra*ciPE WfiLc L is [Pwcby z aer �eLa bugainc+d abd cold to tbo and Grau*M and Greal=16 hcirc Lod ajs� forever, tbp rot[ouing dw—;bc4 I" cauat" 4 9 end bc!cg io Cyr . county, FUw d% m wit Tha H*rth 75* or the south Lao, Of Tract No. 24# G.GIL.7 EN CrATZ ESTATZ$r UNIT NO. 97 ac=rdirlg tv the map Or plat thereof racorded its Flat Book 7 F Page 96 of "a PLblic Rozords of Collier County, Florida. suwECT tO easements, restrictions and reservations of reccrd, it a- Y, and taxes for the Calendar year 2996 and subsequent years. PROPERTY DOES HOT COHS'ITIME HOMESTEAD OF GRANTORS wHo RESIDE jLT 792 110TH AVE. NORTHr NAPLESr FLORIDA, and Laid Graatof dM Loraby N4 *want the tiiln to said 6uA. aad wM dtrcnd Lbe ramp LE� Lw4ul dahm t#aII pumm '?' 1i►ITti S WHEUWL, Granlor has haMLLWO act b41 aW Lod seal the 6V aad yM firg abp wrilica vtra� r� F':;u� Namci4� I�, 41 :. tom,✓ _ STATE OF PUDR]DA COUNTY OF LEE �� GRrrrvg ,-L�? Yhc f0rc9Q4 inurn—c-nt was ac3cn0wlcd9ed bcforr, me this day of aY RAUM L GMTEN. who: r is P=Uma y ioamm to Fat; or ] has PrCduczd his .,c idcatij�ca[doa. 771s p mp-e l br. 2-klAr" A. WORA eDSON A mm ey s3 L.sa 27W Oid 43 Road, Soil,- w4 Sfta. Spring~ Florida 341M Pebbled Namur PH A ,. FiECHARDSON -g ltieasry Public My COMM a irri �y,uW r os rri •; .wrwFs. a� ` t Ceases ''rd� wr a�l.,,xs �'tFk �uLY r�,�eofl 2099095 OR: 2228 PO: 2304 sk it "1111tt at It: mar 9, dear. am Or m Lill W-M .70 WE: MR .A aIClW30 THIS MSiRUMEN—r PR -PARW WrrHoLrr E>Lkh4jNA-n0N QF TMf713 = it U fill PARCEL M 0 WWNi1953Z+ M RSA =OU n ]illy U79 E[V'>; RE, mac tNS l _ THIS RD day zaf _ _ 1 In ]RALlH 4 CoRrr ] wh®c .rddmc is 792 1 IOLb Avr. t4orLb, Napks, Fiar. Grantor, and RALPM L Qlrrp srd + +an1A MAaIE ISCIE G1R[F N, as Irptsss of ftAL,Fii Lr e;s rl�rter� FAMILY 7'RLTS'i cased 1"L wlfJr qre �iMleC � 4 � J [ aid m �4 or fo kes� ar to e»�m1�, or oll�eewsxa eo �*� � �4+a+e of dw rMA . Yrbcw ad&= a ?92 I10M Aw- NWih. p14 i6, 339d3. C, ram=-, LJpwo LLa death 4f RA.LP14 !_ GRn-rEN sad AAA MARIE WHrrE GRtI'k'�7�. while ails Truap;a t]eef Sued Go-Trbrma chNR ba FEGGY All -EN Lud W WZLL tri+H nm AX TrUA— shall be %19134cvcd with Fa p am a 900d hems ind in ibc TLvx d waun l itself WMMSSM4 LLU said C➢rsrs[vr, far ADd to opOW&FI ke 61 TEN AND NOJIDO DDLLAP-S {S70A0; and otbv prod and ratuab#c vwsi � to "M GrW*w in head paid by grid Graoenra, the rat wbcrmr a hcrft ackm&wkjsgpd� km zrmtrA bargsmad " WW to LW said Gm=vcm, aa+3 irraalcc's h► m znd asiigas f0c r. tha following deed land, 5izvaz�, sad b=9 In COM= CaQoty, FiarLk Co ■ C All of Traot 4S, Goldan Gate Eatates, uni-t No. 97, accordinq to plat to Plat Book 7, Pages 95 and 96, olio Records of Collier County, r1cridc . PROPEGCk']C DOES IiOT CONSTITUTE HOMSTEAD OF GRANTOR WHO RZSIDES XT 792 1102U AVE. NORTH, mApLES, FLMIDA. SECT to easements, reatri ions ar�d renervatiDns of record, ii any, and taxes for the calendar year 1996 and subsequent yeaEro. rud Wd Grawiot dow hereby fay,wrr;ne the LWa to Lrid lard, Lad wi0 dricad the LL= ask= the lawfal Bairns o r WhDW )v=. M VMWESS VVHEPWGF, Grawnr hay 6�=rew4a rct hEs head sad co9 4hc daps sad year rum •b owe -Auc - wan= p U1W No A/ 1Yuueas Pruned 11am 7 dgr.v STATE OF I;WRiAA COUNTY OF LEE the CoxWW9 i =Umenl was uvkwi4ac d before rye this by RALPH I, GRnTFN. whm [ ] is porsaosl]y known Eo me-, or [ bras produwA his Thk Ingntmcat prcpvsd W RALF-4 A~ RlC 1kkDSOIti Amwm cy at l w 2772S Old 41 R 5tuote 104 000�3alSpri FkwwU 34M RALFWL CRT 11 J {-' diyof - t+..UC4 19%. ss identefuatian A�aa� Prinicd .Name RALPH A. RICHARDSON hlotuy Pubne My Commeradon CXpir= "Ikv QFFJpiy4 rwrr�+t � a Ccaea�a9 Girton omwmfm N J zu=m is cnzcua nwos vi COLLM 09111, n 14116194 It 11=01" DRm 1. [It=, CLM 33{ M i.0a G0C*.74 .7U le EWI A 1lCSIJDiL� Y'KIS EWM ULMENTPREPAP.eD vrrm0VT E AM jt AT70N OF T115 OW 41 10 KU PARCEL ID r �iO4$93Z09DD:C* �RlI ePMR 11 1ii35 5V9 1'� TgtS II+LDDMME, made this dal' ar J-4.-P6 19K bctwrcn uAlsu L G>l:MEK, wbw& -ddrm is Tit 110th Ave. N#orlla, Kaplr rids n%a, oraalor. Lod i AIJPH X. GRRTEN mad; A..NNw WU= WHrM GR3rTMM ar TtultOM ai Me K&LPH L. GR1'i N FAMtLy TRUST dared - SF Lw r r +Irh tLe pvwsr Lad authq" to pevter•R, ooaser<r and Ca sea, ar to 1cs cw 4s cacumb¢, w othwwi c to aq#�Ia �d dls�nse K the s,ar] prn , whOw ad&w is 792 11 ABC, North N* Rod& 3390, Gnajez 5; UPoa ttma daaeh of R fd PH 1` GRrr'r F-N and ANNA }.l BRIE Wfi r[r-- ClUrT-EN, while aM Tn=omr, i1e& SL&w=4 ,r Co-'FrEW*cs shs.11 W FECrGY A A-F- V oatd LOON LL WMIRM An Tres = ihall be aul bor¢cd with fa poi cz t a!; u ted b mm �d is de Tv= dmw2aa hicif WrrNESF.'rH, that Wd GMWOr, for lad in CmAdmwLiGn d M ,AND N01= DOLUM (SSA} and ahar pod auwd alticabk ooaridamWm to Wd Grouter i& hazed wid by Said Gro atcca, the t ipt trbereaf is berzby nckmwwkjg4 has W-ot L4 bx,fd d and SOW 10 Ow SKM 13raDWM aad Ormmo's WYN rod ndq= fcr+br, (ba rotlowAng dcacrt`bad hDd4 ili=,[ lye and bdq b CsnIDeT Oanuty, FkrW16 to witr. Tract 33. GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit: 97, as per plat th*roaf recorded, Ln Plea: Bc2ck 7, page 96, Fublic Records of Galls*r Co•11nty. 710kida . PROPFRTY DOES NOT CONSTITUTE JHOMWTEAD OF aWafMR5 WHO Rzs-TZ>E AT 792 110TH XVE. NORTH, NAPLES, FLORIDA. SUWECT to c='h * rutdWoas and seas rva►ioas of record i r a", and M= for Lbe C11=d1r yzar i996 Ind nbscqww Y=a and s2A Graator does hereby fWTy warrant the Wr, W said Isad, and wW W=W the s;amc agLEw the Lww dsja aFall l?er cm LN Wr NF$S VVBT1 ZOF, Gr*Mror has hereon * = 4ii hard and aul Lbo day and }mar Lrat *ben= fritit4 Printed KLo LINDA L . ccNwh► c *h�u.uras FAWW Names RALPH A. RICHARDSON STAYS OF FLORIDA COT -Wry OF LEX RAi 1st L GBMEN The forcgaeng F-91 Cnt wrs Adknowbrdged before me this day of h. by RAU"H L GRIT#EN. who: ( I is pcvwaldly kwwm to me; or f bits produced bis >s idenlifitaiiag This 1nVA%u z prr gamd by. RALPH A. R[CH.AROSON AttwAuy of Law 27725 Old 41 Rbadr S4CsIo 104P Soaha $Prinips, Florida 3035 Primed ?tam RALPH A,. R1CH+7RDSOI� '_ Noesry public MYComM114i" OW''W= x, g+ eo.aa -oats #"'�u�x ��,7Gd6 o� rti z T3ii 1011 rum rnt prepared Wilhoot the Revinr of Title by_ GEDRGE P. LANC,FOFLD AaDffK}r ai Law 3337 Tamiami Trail Noah Naples, r-Jmida 34103 3667707 OR: 3854 PG: 3475 11COED10 it MICA; WWI of COL1111 t7DMI, n 011111R43 it I1:lltd Jlflia4 =- Imo Cif, 13C "1 11.51 tlt.n; QOC-. fO .11 (302a C L7uclnu 3157 7LELE It 1thJ'LIS IL 14101 C+rnrtarSi j.r,trfwfiry'Mnievr ��_ -mad SPECIAL WARR. UVr Y DEWED Z THIS IiTDEI]']'[JRE, mndr t4it �, day of ,luly, 2005 between JANET K. GREENE, GRANTOR, arkd SHARON A. WINKLiP, LOWELL E. WHIM PEGGY NL WHITE, sm Truants in Comildon, whose past offtce address is: 13151 C}-prm Creek I,,aat, AIvm, Florida 33970, GRAN7rEES. VVFIW8 uETH: BY THIS SPECIAL WARRAN-TY DEED. C rau tar, in consideration orTen ■tad Noll00 Dora (S10.00) Paid by Graoteei, %eir 611comors and asalggs, conveys to cmatm, in equal 911111 s, the following described property jp Collier Concha, Florida - Lot 57. PALM RIVEK SHORES, as per plat thereof mcorded in Plat Hack 3, Page 27, PUUC Records of CQ11kT County, Florida; and Tract 23, GOLDFN CRATE ESTATES, Unit 97, as per plat thereof n orded in Plat Book 7, Page 95, Rtblio Records of Collier Caunry, Florida; and Trent 49, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES. Unit 97, as per plea thcreo€recorded in Plat Boole 7, Fagc 96, Public Records of Collier County. V [catch; The Nmh 75' of the South l 80' of Tract No- 24, CrD1 DFN GATES ESTATE, UNIT NO, 97, according to the map or plat therro(recorded in Plat Book 7. Page 96. of the Public Records of Col hicr Counry, Florida; and "lire North 150 feet Df Trac# Nu.24, GOLDEN! GATF. ESTATES, Unit No. 97. according to the plat thc=f as record in Plat Book 7, Pagc 96, of the Public Reenacts of Col li er County, Flori da. This cited cooreys and uadivldcd one bundrEd (100%) percent orihe GI-antor's total intrrest in thr abavr described land. 'rhr laud described herein h not the homestead of the Grantor, and neither the Grantor nor the Graptor', spolist, nor icy axle for who3e 'I u pport the Crnntor is rrsporiAhle., r=idm on or ad]aoent to maid land. Subject to eom tuL5and restrictionstom monto(he 3ubid ivision.oil, gas andmitrt'ralinterests ofrecord lrguy; zoo[pg and ate restrictions fin pmed by govern meatAl authority; taxes for the current year, ProptAy LD- Nmm6rrs; 6557132 005; 4193108006; 41933240006; 419311200Q5; and 41931200006 GPAN'TOR coven$nte wi1L Grnnlines that GMF1tdr 61awfully mrixrd of the property in fee simple; that Granter has good right and lawful authority to soil snd cffnvcy tht property; that Grantor warrants the tldr to the property for say acts of Grantor and will dcfeod it agaiunt the lawful claims of Al prmons claiming by, through ur under Crgbtor. IN RTT?4ESS WHEREOF. Grantor has hereunto set Grattlor's head apd seal the day and year last abavt written. 0� 61 Aq-� j Signed, sealed and delivered In our presence: a,,�L WITNESS: {Prtwed N4,"z of ft'ns) _WIT F.S�S-.�� (Pr&fed Nai?w of FI ftm) ' STATE OF COUNTY OF k11t� V GRANTOR, *** OR, 3854 PG: 3476 *** The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this � day of July, Z005 by JANET K. GREENE, who is: personally known to me, or who has produced] Z P,, ifL as identification. ires910�i�TRRE OF N AR P UQ STATE AJ�C1 t�� I OF Prlut Name of Notary Public EK0 AR PUBLIC 1 3668825 OR: 3856 PG: 1258 This lostrunkenc prepared Wilhout the Rcclrw ofTilk by: GEORGE P_ LAL CrORD Aal mcy at f Rw 3357 Tamiami Teal I Nat+h Nepks, Norida 34103 t$MIND 13 01MIRL MM U6 of COCLIIR C4C>itT, IL Ml9f M it Gt WK MM V RUCK, CAA UC RI 11,i0 11MIN 1.0 W-.TO .70 arks; GUM r uxGton 1357 t1J IMT 7R 1 9UJI$ fe A101 �r�rra'Suefalrb��� _ � - —•� SPECIAL WARR.4Nl'Y DEED THIS I DENTLTM made chic _ day or April, 200S between WILLIAM R. GRI'fTEN, GRANMP, and SHARON A. WCNKLER, LOWELL E. WFIFTF, PEGGY M. WHITE,andJANETK.GREENF?.as Tenants In Comm no, whaydrpos! afGceadd ress is: 18151 Cjprem Crack Lane, Alva, Florida 33920, f_ RA.r�] MErS, WrIWES SETH: BY TEES SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED, Grantor, in co nsideration of Ten a n d MAN DoUars($10.00) paid byGrnrote9,theirsureessorsand fis gns. con veysiaGrantee_t, the fallowing described property in Collier County, Florida: Am undividcd. four (4°fo) pereem WeresI io each of thr ub ve specified Grantees in and to the following dcsr ibtd land, to wit: Lot 57. PALM RIVER SHOR17S, ca per p]at 9aroofrecordtd in Plat Book 3. Page 27, Public Records of Collier Cmmly, Florida; and Tract 23, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit 97, as per plat thereof recorded iu Plot Book 7, Page 96, Public Records of Collier County, l=lorid3; and Tract 49. GOLDEN GATE ESTATI. S, Unit 97. as per plat thereof recordcd in Plat Book 7. Page 96, Public Records of Collier County, Florida. The North 75' of the South I of Trnct No. 24. GOLDEN GATES FSTATE, VNTl• NO. 97, according to the map or plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida; MW The North l 5D feel of Trace T1o.24, GOLDEN GATT ESTATES, Unit No_ 97, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Boob 7, Page 96, of the Public Retards of Collier County, Florida - This deed conveys and undivided one hundred (100%) percent of the 6rootor's tutail intrust in the above described In ad, Th r land described h it rein not the ho mesiead of the G rantor, and ntither the Granter nor the Grontayr'a spouse, nor any one ror whose support The Grantor is respousibic, resides on or ad)acent to said land. Subject in easements and restrictions common to the sub divlsl0a, oil, gasand min era) initmts of record irany, coningand use reslrielions impoiredbygovrromcnialauihority;tax[ fnrthe current year. Property T.D. uca6m; 65571320005; 81931080046; 41933240006; 41931120005; und41931200006 G RA, TDR eovcaan is with Grantees t h at Caranto r is lawful ly seized of the property in Fee si mplr: that G ra4thtor hop goad right and lawful autbority to so and convey the property: Thai Grantor %varrsnis the title to the property for any acts of Grantor and will defend it agAinsI the lawful Claim# of all perxotts elaimikLg by, through or undtrGrarilor. *** OR, 3856 PO; 1259 *** IN Wr[NFSS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: WANESS: ubr r�� J77• f (Prfnled Name ofWimiss) �6b1AM kl— wnnins: ,S.lsus (PrJnred Namof Whnas) STATE OF =,,-ols COUNTY OF 4J GRANTO% Ae /5 . WILLIAM R. GRMEN The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this Af day of April, 20D5 by WILLJAM R. GRMEN, who is: personally known to me,.es'a— who has produced 37'F . c- . as identification. My Conmmfs m ftpires, 61deTURE OF NOTA)Y PUBII �y PrWt rYpme of NotAry Poblic tAY M 94U1. 3 6 66B826 OR: 3856 PG: 1260 13COlMID la 017101.4 111111 C5 Of M111 rt a4tr nd R 67181200E it *Lzl t wGr 1. Ii4Cl, CUU VC "1 11.50 ThtslnsirwmebtprepFredWilhou, II 111H 1.40 the Revlex of Tille by! M--70 .70 Mh: OEORCEF.LANGFORD GlOW 1 LRVAP 1 hitomeyarLaw 3357 WWI fl 1 3357 Tsmiemi Trail N*Mh IAl411 R 311H Naples, Florida 34103 Grmka' Udw smr&7 Nkfflh r : _ _.aid SPLAL WARRUL= DEED TWS II DENT . made this _LL day of April, 2NS between JERKY LEE GRITTEN, GRANM& and SHARON A. WINKLER, LOWELL F. VVHTTE, PEGGY M. V4'HTTTE, Sind JANET K. GREENE, its Tcnamts in Com mom, whose post office address 1s:18151 Cypress Creek L.aoe, Alva, Florida 33920. URANTM. Vv T,ISSSETH; BY TMS SPECUL WA UNTY I)LIED, Grantor, in couaidcratiori ofTfR and NoA 00 Do Hars (S I OAG) paid by Gran ted, their xucee on and assigns, conveys le G r■mtees, the following described property in Collier County, Florida: An undivided four (4%) percent into sst to ea ch of the above specified G ranters in and to the followingdesWbcd Iand, Co wit* Lot 57, PALMRFVER SHORES. as perp]at [hereofrcpordcd in PIatHook 3, Page 27, Public Records of Collier County, Florida: and TW73,GOLDEN GATEM-NI-E5,Unit97. asperpl[}tIherravfrccordedinPlat Book 7. Pagc 96, Public Records of Collier County, Florida; and I =t 49- GOLUN GATE tSTATE:S, Unit 97,asper piald=mfrecardedinPlatBook 7. Pam. 96, Public Records of Collier County, F lorld3; The North 75' of the South I BY of Tract No. 24, GOLDEN GATES ESTATE, UNIT NO. 97, accord ing to the map or plat thmrwf recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96,ofthe Pub] is Records of Collier County, Flaridsr and TheNlwh150fieetofTractNo.24,GOL DIFN GATE ESTAT'ES.UrdtNo. 97.awwding to the plat thcroofas raeordtd in Flat Book 7. Page 96, of the Public Records of Golf ier County. Florida. This deed conveys and undivided one hundred (IOr/a) percent of the Graptpr'.s MIA] ititsrest in Me above deseribcd land. The Lund described herein no[ the homestead of the Grantor, and neitbcr the Grantor nor The Grantor's spouse, nor ally one for whose support the Grantor is responsible, resides on or adjacent to said land. 'dub jeca to easernenls and restrkdons common to the subdivision; n il, gsx a n d min a roil irpic sts of record if any, zioningand uat restrictions imposed by gaveramenial authority; taxes for the current yeer. P-�P---O-D I tLm"- 65571330005; 41931090006i 41933240006; 41911120t}U5; and 4193120ON6 GRANTOR cove nants with C r9htc� that Grs ator is lawful ly seized of the properly id fec simple; that Grantor has good right' and lawful authority to sell and coney the property; chat * t* OR: 3856 PG: 1261 *** G rantor wa rrants the title to the property for any acts of Grantor and will defend it against the lawful claims of all persons claiming by, through or under Grantor. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our present WfffiESS: (Printed Name of Wuness] WITNESS: (Primed Nanee a �essJ STATE OF C0UT+1'F'Y OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this L day of April, 2005 by JERRY LEE GRITTEN, who is: personally known to me, or who has produced W--iyQ as identification. aty�1��2� MUM C*-P(t-) 3668827 R: 3856 PG: 1262 T#ix lexaty meat preps d Wiahou i The Review of TWr by; GEORGEPRLANCFORD Atimmy art l.aw 3357 Tamiiwn; Trail North Nspks, Flotids 341M RC01D16 it 4rrrCil1 HUM If CQUM tier, It 01"12001 it 0t:Iln Ono 1. awl, CUP1 11C F13 11.5E liMM 1.0 E8C•.110 .10 taro; GHM r tJlmm 3357 fatur it # UPLIS 1X 31103 gmmw. JMW sem" ffim&ff _ .wed SPECIAL WAR AMITY DEED THIS INDENTURE. madr this day of April, 2005 betwo n DAVID LEE CRITI"EN, GPLANTO& and SRARON A. WINKLELR, LO ELL $.WELETF, PEGGY M. VnIrM itudJANETK.GIREENE.a5TouambiuCum mon,whuse post ofiieraddreeaWIS15L Cypreaaa Crerk Lane, Alva. Florida 33920, GRANUE$ , 13YTMSSPECIAL WARRANTYDEED,Grautnr,incon%idsrationafTen and N011GO Dalian (S16.01)) paid by Graaatecs, their successors and assigns, conveys to Grantws, the fallowing described property in Collier CGuuty, Florida: An uodMded lour (4%) percent iatcresl to each of the above specified Grantees in and to the fallowing described land, to wit: L4157. PALM RIVER SHOM, , asporplat the wfrecordedin Plat 15000, PageV. Publ is Records of Collier County, riorida; and Ttatel23. GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit 97, asper plaal lhoreofrewrtlod in Plat Book 7, Page 96. Public Records of Collier County. Florida; and ' ruca t 49, GOLUEN' GATE ESTIOBS,Unit97,aspasplatthcrLofmcordrdinPlatBook 7, Page 96. Puhlia records of Collier County, Florida; The forth 75`ofthe South 18V ofTrwANo, 74,GOLDEN GATES ESTATE, UNrr NO.97, according to the map or plat thereof recorded in Plut Book 7. Paga 96. ofthe Public Records of Collier County, Florida; and The North 150fam ofTrart No.24, GOLDI 4 GATE. ESTATES, Unit No. 97, a wwding to the plat the ofasrecordedinPlatBook7.Page96.ofthePublisRecordsofColllcr County, Florida. This deed conveys and undivided one hund red (100%) pc rcent Of tht Grantor's total utter"" in the ■hare described land. The land described herein not the homestead of the Grantor, And neither the Grantor nor the Grantor's spouse, nor any one for wloose support the Grantor is responsible, resides on or adjacent to said land. Subject io vmgmicrats and restrictions co m n ron to the su Mkvisioo; oil. gals And m inera I interests of record ifsmy;zaningand use restrictions imposed by governmental authority; taxes far thr rya rT t year; P. ►err I.L?. N..6..- 65571326005, 4193 108 0006; 41933240006. 41931120005; and 419312G00416 GRANL TORcovenantswiihGrantees9hatGrantorisluwfullyseizedofIhepropertyinfee simple; that Grantor his good right end lawful authority to 5ell Rind ccnveY rlrc property; Marl *** OR: 3856 PG: 1263 "1 G rantor warrants the title to the property for any acts of Grantor and will defend it against the lawful claims of all persons claiming by, through or under Grantor. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presenee. WITNESS: csyd arYi (Friend Name of WlMasj �Iajj,a� O.A,74-AA4, WI SS: {Prire(rd Name of Witness) STATE OF A COU= OF Cej;7 am ILI] �DAVID LEE GRITTEN The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this L �ayofApril, 2005 by DAVID LEE GRITTEN, who is: Tr'� Jpersonally known to me, or P— who has produced dr; uK rS j,; 0Pr} 5- - as identification. My Commission E"M, SICK OP OTAR Li CL1a Et �C b e at Neme a Nomry PNIblk 3668828 OR: 3856 PG: 1264 This Instrumeal prWred 1YJIbuot ,rt Revtsw of lith by; GEORGE F. LANGMRD A=mey at Law 3357 TLmLLmi Trail Nunh Naples, FlurWo 34103 If4b 15 it 0111CAL UMUS at CKLUI C=T, 11 4112912W It 01211PR DGM 3, 810Ct, Cult "C Fnl ISM IID1= Lot 00C-,70 44 letn; GEM P LUGiotc- 135T 7dIal 11 1 KAMS R h03 SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED TIES INDENTURE, mitdc this ` day of April, 2005 between DAWN KARIE GRITTENSCALOGNA, GRAIN -TOR, and SHAROr*i A. WIIti X.M LOWELLE. WHITE, PF.GGY M. WHITE, and JANF.T K. GREENF, ae Tenants In Common, whose post Office addrms ia: 19151 Cypress Creek Lane, Alva, Florida 33970, GRANTEES, VVITN7SS)*TH: HYTMS SPECIAL WARRANTY DEEI), Grantor, in con si d c rai ion of Ten mad Nol100Dollars (S10.00) paid byGrantees, eloeirsuccc9sorssndas9igns, canvevstuGrau[ees, the following described property in Collier County, Florida: An undivided four (41%) percent interest ttt each of the above speci$ed {-mutes in and to Iho Mowing deactbed lend} to vrit: Lot 57, PALM RIVER SHORES. as per plat tht teof recorded in Plat Soak 3, Page 27. Public records of Collier County, Florida, and Trw 23. GOLDEN GATE ESTATES. UnatV.imperplat thermf recorded in Plat Book 7,1'age 96, Public records of CoU ier County, Florida? and, TFW 49. GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit 97, as per plat thcmurn-caarde d in Plat 1300k 7. Pagc 96, Public Rmorft of Collier County, Florida; The Notch 75"ofthe South IR0' of TractNo. 24. GOLDEN GATES ESTATE. UNIT NO, 97, according to the nmp or plea thereof recotded in Plat Book 7. Pagr 96, of tic Public Records Df Collier County, Florida; and The North 150 feet ofl-rw No.24, GOLDEN GATE ESTATE , Unit No, 97, wcording to the plat thereof asrecorded in Plat Book 7,Puge 96,ofthe Public Records ofCol lier County, Florida, This deed conveys and undivided one hundred (100%) percent ofthe Grantor's tot3d intcre$I in the *boy* dTescribt4 laud. Th c land described herein nut [bc hoauatead of the Grantor, and neither thr G ranto r uor th e Grantor's Spouse, nor auy one for whose support the Grantor i& responslble, reside;, on or adjacent to %Pdd land. 4u1+)ed to ensemeptd Avd r"trirtinn%rmnmom to the snhdiviainn; oil, gay and mineral inttmlx of record if imy, son ing and use real ri c6oaz imposed 4y govern men tat authority; taus for th r current year. 111—p�t,1,D. N4-PL6:.: 6*5571320005; 41431080004; 41933240006; 419311.20005; and 41931200006 GRANTOR coven an is with Grantees That Grantor is lawfully seized afffic property in fee simyle;1hat Grantor bas good right xnd lawful sulhority tq stfl bed convey the property; that *** OR; 3856 PG: 1265 **x Grantor warrants the title to the property for any acts of Grantor and will defend it against the lawful claims of all persons claiming by, through or under Grantor. IN WYINESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the dsy and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence. (PH-W Name of #Vd- ss) SS: (Pdnk-d Name of Witness STATE OF IF41- COUNTY OF [o L liM GRANTOR Ar�I 1 a UMV The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before use this I day of April, 2005 by DAWN MARIE GRITI'EN SCALOGNA, who is: (3 personally known to me, or V who has produced __ i2L— ❑ (.- as identification. My Commission Expires: Gam) JCfiN A. TENIAikY COMIRMODD249296 n E!0MAUG 7720M ib ICUMM CO~ SIGNATURE OTARY UBT AQ d n$ Print Hams of Nahry Public 3668829 OR: 3856 PGF 1266 k100M so MIMI MORS of cuLeita eopm. rt vinam at 11,31im aria 3, 31on. ang WsImtrumemprcporcgiWilhout RN 113 A.50 the Revic* 61"Nle hy: iniiiFG Gk RGE P. LANGFORD Rota: Aieomsg at Law G1010 P [hFGI a 3357 7aminmi 7rai3 14anh 3317 tdV M U 1 Nooes,?IvHd., 34W.3 1"111 11 1110) SPECIAL WAJtFJ0rff DEED 'I'fiflS INDENTIME, trade this day or April, 2005 b-ctween DONALD LEE t1R1T"L` N,SPL. GRAINY' IL and SHARON A. WINKLER,LOWELL E. WHUE, PEGGY M. 1WRITE, stud JANET K. GREEIVE, its Tenants in Common, whose post offiec address in: 1815E Cypress Creek Dane, Alva, Florida 33920, GRANTEES, VnTNESSETH BY THIS SPECLe LWARRANTY DEED, Grantor, in consideration orTto mod iti of100 Daliars (5I0.00) paid by Grsntess, their successors and assigns, Conveys to Grantees, the following described property in Cullisr County, Florida: An undivided four(4%)percentinterest to each of11wabove specified Granlc"in and ioihe fo11Dwingdeseribod land, iowit: Lot 57. PAL6M RIVER SHORES, ac per plat thereof ruvurdcd in PIal Book 3, Page 27, Pubho Records of Collier County, Florida, W Tract 23, GOLDEN GKrE ESTATES, Unit 97, as per plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96, Public Records of Collier County, Florida; and Traci 49, GOLDEN DATE ESTATES, llitit 97, as per pint thereof recorded in Plat Boost 7, Page 96, Public Records of Cad tier County, Florida, The North 75'ofthe South I80' afTractNm 24. GOLDEN GATES ESTATE, UNIT NO- 97. accords ng to the map or plat thereof recorded in Plat Hook 7, Page 96, of the Public Rewrds of Collier County, F1Drida; and The forth 150 foal of Tm= W24, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit No. 97- accarding to the plea thereof as recorded in Mal Boole 7, Page 96, of the Public Records of Coll ier County, Florida. This deed conveys and undMd ed one hut[" (100%) percent of the Grantor's total inferrwl in the above described land. The land described herein [tilt the homcsicad of the Grantor, and nelther the Grantor nor the Grantor's spouse, nor any one for whose aupPart the Grantor is responsible, rehides on or adjacent to soil land. Subject10 L43cmcults and restrictions common to the subdivision. oil, gacand mineral interests of recurd if any; zoning and use restrictions imposed by gavtramcutal authority; taxes far the Current year. Prq-rly I.D. Num6r.: 65571320005i 41931080406; 41933240046; 41931120005; and 41931200006 Gs RANTOR cuvenania with Grafttevs That Grantor is lawfu lly seized of the p roperty in fee A mple; chat G rancor has good right and lawful ilutkiority to s ell and convey I h e properly; that Grantor w2rmols the thle to the property for aov aces of Grantor and will defend it a1alost the lawful claims of all persons chiiming by, throb gh or under Grantor. *t* OR: 3856 PG: 1267 "' Grantor warrants the title to the property for any acts of Grantor and will defend it against the lawful claims of all persons claiming by, through or under Grantor. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has bereunto set Grantor's band and seat the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence. GRANTO% WITNESS: D DONALD LEE GRnTEN, SR. Of svIM—) WAnW Nank of frsMen) STATE OF • _..� COUNTY OF 10A#11 The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this dsty of April, 2005 by DONALD LEE GRITTEN, SR., who is: ❑ personally known i g who has produced My Camminion Expires: L� 3997055 OR: 4207 PG: 1133 29CORDI' :n 0111CIAS UUID3 of COMIR C11297T. 11 0002001 at 4` :Wx 010Ct. CLIK a1e !it 27.a0 IID111IG 3.00 MCI -10 ,to- Itto= GEORGE F. LANGFORD 0 �1IL tB I1 Allornmy al Law kpLLi AM 3357 Tamirhli Trail North Naplrs, Florida 34143 (234) 262.3911 WARRAI rff DEBI) TINS MENTURE, made this 28th day of February, 2007, between SHARON A. WINKLER, a married person, GRANTOP, and JOHN H. WI[NKLER. as Trustee: of the JOHNNH. YMVKLF.R TRUST AGREEMENT DATEDTHE2MDAYOFFEBRUARY, 2007, whose pest office address is' 7374 Bulb Faun Road. Wellbom, FL 32094, GRANTEE, WI SSETH. That said GRAIMR for and In e*nsiderst}grt or the start of Tea and No1100 Dollars (S 10,00), and other goad and valunhlc consideration Ce stud G rancor In b ad paid by said Grantee, thetxceiptwhsreofisberebyarknowtedged,has granted,haggined and sold to Thesntd Grantee, and Granice's heirs aad assigns forever, an undivided 116 iotereat in the following described property, situate, lying and being in Ivuilier County, Florida, to -wit: Tract 23, 001-01'N GATE ESTATES, UAE 97. as per plat then -of mr-orded in Plat Boots 7, Page 96, Pub]ic ReeordsofCol facrCounty. Florida; and Tma 49, 001-DEN GATEESTATF. Unit 97.aspapleadier+otmordedinPlat Book 7, Page 96, Public Records of Collier Cflunty, Florida; The North 75' of the South 1 90'of Tract No. 24. GOLDLN GATE ESTATES. UNIT NO.97. According to the map or plat thereof r000rded in Plat Book 7, Page96, of the Public Records or Collier County. Florida: end ThcNonk 1 SO fact offset Nb.24. GOLDEN GATE FSTATEti, Unit No, 97, according to the plat thmofas r= dcd in Plat Book 7, Page 96, of the Pub] ia: Records of Coll let County, rlolida. This deed conveys an undivided fifty (500/.) potent or the Gran tar'sf13(aI interrtsl in the above described property. The property described herein is oat the homestead ufthrC:ranior, and atilher theGrantor nor The Grantors spouse, rtor any one fur whose -tuppart the GraniDr is responsible, resides on or Adjacent to said land. Subject toca_iemeotaand restrictions eomman to the subdivision; oit,gas and minera3lluerc$L% of record iforty; zoning and use tcsirietions imposed by governmental authority; taxes far the current veer. Pwpepfr LID. NuakheM: 5193108 006; 41933140N6. 41931120005; and 41931200006 and said Graotordoes herby fully warranI the titit: to-4tlid land, and wilt defend the same ngains I the lawfut claims of stil ncrsans whornsoever. OR: 4207 PG, 1134 TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the above described real estate in fee simple with the appurtenances upon the trustand for the purposes set forth in this Deed and in the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust. If Grantor, JOHN H. WINKLER, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall be the Grantor's wife, SHARON A. WINKLER. If SHARON A. WINKLER cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall be the Grantor's wife's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON. IfCHRISTINE E. THOMPSON, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Co -Trustees shall be the Grantor's wife's son-in-law, ROY THOMAS THOMPSON, Grantor's wife's granddaughter, TRACY N. THOMPSON and Grantor's wife's grandson, ROY TRAVIS THOMPSON or if one or more of them fail to qualify or cease to act then the other of them as Co -Trustees or Trustee, as the case may be. All successorTnrstees are hereby granted the power to protect, conserve, sell, lease, encumber, or otherwise manage and dispose of the real property described in this deed. The powers ofthe Trustee and all 5uccecsorTrustees shall extend toany and all rights the Grantor possesses in the above -described real property; any deed, mortgage, orother instrument executed by the Trusteeshall oonveyall rights or interests ofthe Grantorincluding homestead; and the Trustee is appointed as the attorney -in -fact for the Grantor to carryoutthis intent, which appointment shall be durable and shall not be affected by the incapacity of the Grantor. Any person dealing with the Trustee shall deal with the Trustee in the order as set forth above. However, no person shall deal with a Successor Trustee until one or more of the following have been received by that person or placed of record in the aforementioned county: A. The written resignation of the prior Trustee sworn to and acknowledged before a notary public. B. A certified death certificate of the prior Trustee. C. The order of a court of competent jurisdiction adjudicating the prior Trustee incompetent, or removing that Trustee for any reason. D. The written certificates ofthe Successor Trustee and aphysician currently practicing medicine statingthat the Trustee is unable to manage his or her own afiairsoris physically or mentally incapable of dischargingtheduties of Trustee. E. The written removal ofa 5uccessorTntstee andlorthe appointment ofan additional Successor Trustee by the Grantor's wife, SHARON A. WINKLER, or the Grantor's wife's daughter, CHIIISTINE E. THOMPSON sworn to and acknowledged before a notary public, this right being reservers to the Grantor's wife, SHARON A. WINKLER, or the Grantor's wife's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON. In no rase shall anyparty dealing with the Tmstee in relation to the real estate orto whom the real estate or arty par: of it sh&}I f e conveyed, c-nntracrer.' to he sold, leased or mortgaged by Trustee, be obliged to see to the application of any purchase money, rent or money borrowed or advanced on the premises, or be obliged to see that the terms ofthistrust have been complied with, or be obliged to inquire into the necessity or expediency of any act ofthe Trustee, or be obliged or privileged to inquire into any ofthe terms of the Trust or Declaration of Trust; and every deed, trust deed, mortgage, lease or other instrument executed by Trustee in relation to the real estate shall be conclusive evidence in favor ofevery person relying upon orclaiming under any such conveyance, cease or otherinstr=ent (a) that at the time of its del iverythe trust created by this Indenture and by the Trust Agreement and DeclarationofTnust was in full force and effect, (b) that such conveyance or other instrment was executed in accordance with the *** OR; 4207 PG: 1135 *** trusts, conditions and limitationsconutined in this Indenture and in the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust and is binding uponall beneficiaries undersuch instrurrte K (e) that Trustee was duly aual orired and empowered to execute and deliverevery such deed, tnut deed, lease, mortgage or other hutr=cnt and (d) ifthe conveyance is made to asuccessor or successors in trust, that such successor or successors in trust have been appointed properly and vested fully with all the title, estate, rights, powers, duties and obligations of the predecessor in trust. Any contractobligation or indebtedness incurred orentered into by the Trustee in connection with the real estate may be entered into by him in the nameofthe then beneficiaries underthe Trust. Agreement and Declaration ofTrust, as their attorney in fact, by this Deed irrevocably appointed for such purpose, or, at the election ofthe Trustee, in his own name as Trustee of an express trust and not individually, and the Trustee shall have no obligation whatsoever with respect to any such contract, obligation or indebtednessexcept onlyso faras the tnut property and funds in the actual possession of the Trustee shall be applicable for itspaymentand discharge, and all personsand corporations whomsoeverand whatsoever shall be charged with notice of this condition from the date of the filing for record of this Deed. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: GRANTOR SHARON A. WINKLER COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 28th day of February,2007 by SHARON A. WINKLER and who is. - personally known to me, or produced as identification. hCM"M*"j Anif orge P. Langford (SEAL) 4ak, George Q. L a n 9 f o r 7 Exftesssion � QQ a';iw• �SFebruary 1e0�'�2010 3997056 OR: 4207 PG: 1136 U001011 n 0"ICR1 HCOUS of b1LLM 0OW7, IL 01f0112007 it 02t11H BRUT 1. 110f3, eaki 8C ell 21.09 Ioam 1.00 ROUT: GEORGEP. LANGF RD 33if 70T81q *>t I Attorney atl-aw 1]lPE1S kR 3357 Tsmiuni Teti North Naplea, Mrlda 34103 t134j 262-2a1l I WARRALI"= DIED THIS III? E TTI]RH. made Lhis 281h day of Februaq, 2007, between SHARON A. WI NKLER, a marred person, GRAI%rrOlt, and SHARON A. WINIKLER, as Tnustec of the SHARON A. WINXLER TRUST AGREEMENT DATED THE STH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2007, whose post office address is: 7374 Bulb Farm Road. Wellborn, FI- 32094, GRANTEE, EE, VtTrTiM SETH. 'Chat said GR.. NL MR for and is -co usiderniion of the sum of Tea aim 1Vo11t14 Dollars (510.00),and othergood and Valuableconsidendon 109aid Grantor in hand pRid by said Grantee, The receipt whercufrs hembyacknowledged,hesgrgnked,harrained and sold to thtssiid Grantee, arid Grantee's heirs and jimigns forever, an undivided 116 interest in 1hv following described propcM, situate, IYin g and being in Collier County, f`lorida, to -wits Tmcl23,GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit97,asper plat thereofreoordedinFiatBook 7, Page 96, Publip. Records of Collier City, Florida; and Tract 49. GOLDEN OATS F.STAM. Unit 97, 05 per plat Ihcsoofrwm*d in plat Book 7, Page 96, public Records of Collier Cauaty, Florida; The March 75' of she Seuth 190' ofTr= No. 24, GOLDEN GATE ESTATCS. JNIT NO- 97, according to the map or plat thumf recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 96. ofthe Public Records of Coll icr County, Florida, ar llle hlorih 150 fact ofTrwt No,24, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit No_ 97, according 10the platthemof25moordcd in Plat Book 7. Page 96, of the Public Records of`Qlliar County, Flarida. Th is deed conveys an u n d iv ided fifty (5110%) percent of the G ra n t or's tots l interest i n the above described property. The propertydeacribrd bcretn is not the homestead of ilk GMritor, and neitherthe 0rantornor the Grantor's spouse, oar arty one for w hope a u pp or[ The Grantor is responsibi e, resides an or adjacent to 3ald Ind. Snb*ect to cmemen Lr pad restricts ins com man to tha subdiril ioa 1 all, gas and in ineratl iatcmts oftword ifany; zoning and use resIHccions irnp+umed by governmeinial ausborityl taxe3 for The current year- Psopmrtt I.D. Numlmr.. 419310$0006. 41933240006. 41931120005, mind 41931204U06 and aaidGritaordoes hcreby fully warrens the iitleiosaid larid, and wiltdefend the same against the lawful claims of all persons rvlkoinsocver. OR: 4207 PG; 1137 TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the above described real estate in fee simple with the appurtenances upon the trust and forthe purposes set forth in this Deed and in the Trust Agreement and Declaration of Trust. If Grantor, SHARON A- WINKLER, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall be the Grantor's husband, JOHN H. WINKLER. If JOHN H. WINKLER cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Trustee shall he the Grantor's daughter, CHRIST'INIE E- THOMPSON. If CHRISTTNE E. THOMYSON, cannot serve or continue to serve as Trustee, the successor Co -Trustees shall be the Grantor's son -in - taw, ROY T HOMAS THOMPSON, Grantor's granddaughter, TRACY N. THOMPSON and Grantor's grandson, ROY TRAVIS THOMPSON or if one or more of them fail to qualify or cease to act then the other of them as Co -Trustees or Trustee, as the case may be. All successor Trustees are hereby granted the powerto protect, conserve, sell, lease, encumber, or otherwise manage and dispose of the real property described in this deed. The powers ofthe Trustee and all Suc essorTrustees shall extend to artyand all rights the Grantor possesses in the above -described real properry; any deed, mortgage, orother instrument executed by the Trustee shall convey all rights or interests of the Grantor including homestead; and the Trustee isappointed as theanorney-in-fact forthe Grantor to carry out this intent, which appointment shall bedurable and shall not be affected by the incapacity of the Grantor. Any person dealing with the Trustee shall deal with the Trustee in the order as set forth above. However, no person shall deal with a Successor Trustee until one or mare of the following have been received by that person or placed of record in the aforementioned county: A- The written resignation o f the prior Trustee sworn to and aclmowledged before a notary public. B. A certified death certificate of the prior Trustee. C. The order of a court of competent jurisdiction adjudicating the prior Trustee incompetent, or removing that Trustee for any reason. D. The written aertificatesof the Successor Trustee and a physician currently practicing medicine stating that the Trustee is unable to manage his or her own affairs or is physically or mentally incapable ofdischarging the duties of Trustee. E. The written removal of a Successor Trustee andlorthe appointment of an additional Successor Trustee by the Grantor's husband, JOHN H. WWRLER, orthe Grantor, sdaught+er, SINE E. THOMPSON sworn to and acknowledged before a notary public, this right being reserved to the Grantor's husband, JOHN H. WINKLEK or the Grantor's daughter, CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON. In no case shall any party dealing with the Trustee in relation to the real estate or to whom the real estate or any part of it shall be conveyed, contracted to be sold, ]eased or mortgaged by Trustee, be obliged to see to the application of any purchase money, rent or money borrowed or advanced on the prem:,ses, or be obliged to see that the terms of this trust have been complied w'tth,or oe obliged to•inquire into the necessity or expediency of any act of the Trustee, or be obliged or privileged to inquire into any ofthe terms of the Trust or Declaration of Trust; and every deed, trust deed, mortgage, lease or other instrument executed by Trustee in relation to the real estate shall be conclusive evidence in favorofevery person relying upon orclaiming under any such conveyance, lease orother instrument (a) that at the time of its delivery the trust created by this Indenture and by the Trust Agreement and Declaration ofTrust was in full force and effect, (b) that such conveyance or other instrument was executed in accordance with the V *** OR: 4247 PG: 1138 *** mists, conditions and limitations contained in this Indenture and in the Trust Agreementand Declaration of Trust and is binding upon ail beneficiaries under such instrments, (c) that Trustee wale duly authorized aad empowered to execute and deliver every such deed, trust deed, lease, mortgage or other instrument and (d) if the conveyance is made to a successor or successors in trust, that such successor or successors in trust have been appointed properly and vested fully with all the title, estate, rights, powers, duties and obligations of the predecessor in trust. Any contract obligation or indebtedness incurred or entered into by the Trustee in connection with the real estate may be entered into by her in the name ofthe then beneficiaries under the Trost Agreement and Declaration ofTrust, as their attorney in fact, by this Deed irrevocably appointed for such purpose, or, at the election ofthe Trustee, in her own name as Trustee of an express trust and not individually, and the Trustee shall have no obligation whatsoever with respect to any such contract, obligation or indebtedness exceptonlyso far as the trust properly and funds in the actual possessionofthe Trustee shall be applicable for its payment and discharge, and all persons and corporations whomsoever and whatsoever shall be charged with notice of this condition from the date of the filing for record of this Deed. IN VIUNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in ourpmence., GRANTOR SHARON A. WBgMER STATE OF FLORIDA OOUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before methis 28th day of February,2007 by SHARON A. WINKLER and who is: personally known to me, or D produced tWMi*Mb*M (SEAL) George P. Langford i. Crnnmission # ODSM437 PW,-,ce, Expires F dreary 10, 2010 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict (PL20180002621) Exhibit V.G.4 Affidavit of Authorization June 13, 2019 NSCOB Exhibit VG4 Cover Page. docx ® GradyNnor C101 Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134 • 239-947-1144 • engineering@gradyminor.com • www.gradyminor.com AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR PETITION NUMBERS(S) PL20180002622 and PL20180002621 1, Dr. Jadynn Faffer (print name), as CEO/Presldent (title, if applicable) of Naples Senior Center atJFCs, Inc. (company, If a licable), swear or affirm under oath, that I am the (choose one) owner= applicant=contract purchaser=and that: 1. 1 have full authority to secure the approval(s) requested and to impose covenants and restrictions on the referenced property as a result of any action approved by the County in accordance with this application and the Land Development Code; 2. All answers to the questions in this application and any sketches, data or other supplementary matter attached hereto and made a part of this application are honest and true; 3. 1 have authorized the staff of Collier County to enter upon the property during normal working hours for the purpose of investigating and evaluating the request made through this application; and that 4. The property will be transferred, conveyed, sold or subdivided subject to the conditions and restrictions imposed by the approved action. 5. Wall authorize0. Grady Minor 8: Associates, P.A. and Chaffy Passidomo, PA to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this petition including 1 through 2 above. *Notes: • If the applicant is a corporation, then it is usually executed by the corp. pass. or v. pnes. • If the applicant is a Limited Liability Company (L.L.C.) or Limited Company (L.C.), then the documents should typically be signed by the Company's `Managing Member." • If the applicant is a partnership, then typically a partner can sign on behalf of the partnership. • If the applicant is a limited partnership, then the general partner must sign and be identified as the "general partner" of the named partnership. • If the applicant is a trust, then they must include the trustee's name and the words "as trustee" • In each instance, first determine the applicant's status, e.g., individual, corporate, trust, partnership, and then use the appropriate format for that ownership. Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Authorization and that the facts stated In it are true. S[Chdlure T— Date STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me on51101 Dr. Jadynn Faffer (na a of pars providing oath CEO/Presldenl who is p sonally k own me or o as pr ce _ (type of identification) as identification. STAMP/SEAL 14, ,��rrrrrr%, LOU-LOU NEACE :State of Florida -Notary Public • * Commission # GG 271101 My Commission Expires °rrrnr���`�� November 17, 2022 CP\08-COA-00115\155 REV 3/24/14 (date) by ation), as AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR PETITION NUMBERS(S) PL2018022622and PL20180002621 1, ShamA-(print name), as Indmdu ww as sucom" Trusms (title, if applicable) of ftJohn H. WMer TnW1 AWSMWarardoWSW (company, If applicable), swear or affirm under oath, that I am the (choose one) ownerQapplicant [ c ntract purchaseroand that: 1. I have full authority to secure the approval(s) requested and to impose covenants and restrictions on the referenced property as a result of any action approved by the County in accordance with this application and the Land Development Code; 2. All answers to the questions in this application and any sketches, data or other supplementary matter attached hereto and made a part of this application are honest and true; 3. 1 have authorized the staff of Collier County to enter upon the property during normal working hours for the purpose of investigating and evaluating the request made through this application; and that 4. The property will be transferred, conveyed, sold or subdivided subject to the conditions and restrictions imposed by the approved action. 5. Well authorize Ne0asar orCmWatJFCS,1W. to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this petition including 1 through 2 above. *Notes: • If the applicant /s a corporation, then it is usually executed by the Corp. pres. or V. pres. • If the applicant Is a Limited Liability Company (L.L.C.) or limited Company (L.C.), then the documents should typically be signed by the Company's °Managing Member." • If the applicant is a partnership, then typically a partner can sign on behalf of the partnership. • If the applicant is a limited partnership, then the general partner must sign and be identified as the "general partner' of the named partnership. • If the applicant is a trust, then they must include the trustee's name and the words "as trustee". • In each Instance, first determine the applicant's status, e.g., individual, corporate, trust, partnership, and then use the appropriate format for that ownership. Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Authorization and that the facts stated In it are true. Signature Date Sharon A. Winkler as Individual and as Successor Trustee of the John H. Winkler Trust Agreement u/ald 02/28/07 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF GGf: tM Ca,"t ^ 614- The foregoing instrument was swom to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me on (date) by Simon A.Winkier (name of person providing oath or affirmation), as Wividaal and a9 Suomaer Tnistw who is personally known to me or who has produced �..-Qy (type of identification) as identification. STAMP CHRISTOPHER D PA:gtER8011 :•: `: MY COMMISSION EXPIRES June 12, 2021 CM09-COA-00115%155 REV 3/24/14 Signature of Notary Public AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR PETITION NUMBERS(S) P120180002622and PL201800 ml 1, SMM A. WWddw (print name), as lr&MuW mW as Tnisim (title, if applicable) of the Sh—nA. Winkler Trust AprSOMMu1M02MM7 (company, If a Iicable), swear or affirm under oath, that I am the (choose one) owner© applicant contract purchasermand that: 1. I have full authority to secure the approval(s) requested and to impose covenants and restrictions on the referenced property as a result of any action approved by the County ih accordance with this application and the Land Development Code; 2. All answers to the questions in this application and any sketches, data or other supplementary matter attached hereto and made a part of this application are honest and true; 3. 1 have authorized the staff of Collier County to enter upon the property during normal working hours for the purpose of investigating and evaluating the request made through this application; and that 4. The property will be transferred, conveyed, sold or subdivided subject to the conditions and restrictions imposed by the approved action. 5. We/I authorize Napi-Sen�C-tefatJFC8•lnr- to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this petition including 1 through 2 above. *Notes. • If the applicant is a corporation, then it is usually executed by the corp. pros. or v. pros. • If the applicant is a Limited Liability Company (L.L.C.) or Limited Company (L.C.), then the documents should typically be signed by the Company's "Managing Member." • If the applicant Is a partnership, then typically a partner can sign on behalf of the partnership. • If the applicant is a limited partnership, then the general partner must sign and be identified as the "general partner" of the named partnership. • If the applicant is a trust, then they must include the trustee's name and the words "as trustee". • In each instance, first determine the applicant's status, e.g., individual, corporate, trust, partnership, and then use the appropriate format for that ownership. Under penalties of perjury, i declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Authorization and that the facts stated in it are true. Signature Sharon A. Winkler, as individual and as Trustee of the Sharon A. Winkler Trust Agreement u/a/d 02/05/07 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF GeL+M COLUMA f4 The foregoing instrument was sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me on (date) by Shemn A. VV[Wer (name of person providing oath or affirmation), as VuJvWuWwWTrWee who is personalty known to me or who has produc6d 9 BC. (type of identification) as identification. STAMP/3E '; CHRIVOPHER D PARKERSON •': MY COMMISSION 0 GG113842 EXPIRES June 12, 2021 CP\08-COA-00115\155 REV 3/W14 gnature of Notary Public AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR PETITION NUMBERS(S) waore000x=-wP o'ww2w' 1, Paw M. Wre" (print name), as h%r WuWe =aS Co-T (title, if 1ph applicable) of dw RaL GO ► Family TRW wan 09111 s (company, If applicable), swear or affirm Q under oath, that I am the (choose one) ownerQapplicentcontract purchaserand that: 1. 1 have full authority to secure the approval(s) requested and to impose covenants and restrictions on the referenced property as a result of any action approved by the County in accordance with this application and the Land Development Code; 2. All answers to the questions in this application and any sketches, data or other supplementary matter attached hereto and made a part of this application are honest and true; 3. I have authorized the staff of Collier County to enter upon the property during normal working hours for the purpose of investigating and evaluating the request made through this application; and that 4. The property will be transferred, conveyed, sold or subdivided subject to the conditions and restrictions imposed by the approved action. 5. Well authorize SadorCWeratJFCS,Ina to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this petition including 1 through 2 above. 'Notes: • If the applicant is a corporation, then it is usually executed by the corp. pros. or v. pres. • If the applicant is a Limited Liability Company (L.L.C.) or Limited Company (L.C.), then the documents should typically be signed by the Company's "Managing Member" • If the applicant Is a partnership, then typically a partner can sign on behalf of the partnership. • If the applicant is a limited partnership, then the general partner must sign and be identified as the "general partner" of the named partnership. • If the applicant is a trust, then they must include the trustee's name and the words pas trustee" • In each Instance, first determine the applicant's status, e.g., individual, corporate, trust, partnership, and then use the appropriate format for that ownership. Under penalties of perjury, i declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Authorization and that thqJAcp stated in it are true. ignature Date Peggy M. White as indiMualy and as a Suooessor Co -Trustee of the Ralph L. Gritten Family Trust ula/d 09/11/96 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me on a (date) by Pam' M. "ft (name of person providing 6WA or affirmation), as In6V4,0W as as a Suweuw Co-Tmdee who is personally known to me or who has produced F4 AL (type of identification) as identification. STAMPISEAL HaneyY. Roof gig otPublic/ NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF FLORIDA Comm* FF928776 titer Expires 10/19/2019 CP\08-COA-00115U55 REV 3/34/14 AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR PETITION NUMBERS(S) PL201e00026m and FL201e0002621 1, Lowell EWhite (print name), as IndWuallilwWasaSuccessorC-Trustee (title, if applicable) of the Ralph L Gdnen r-amiyTrW u/aM OVIiM (company, If applicable) swear or affirm under oath, that I am the (choose one) owne �/ applicant ntract purchaserF]and that: 1. 1 have full authority to secure the approval(s) requested and to impose covenants and restrictions on the referenced property as a result of any action approved by the County in accordance with this application and the Land Development Code; 2. All answers to the questions in this application and any sketches, data or other supplementary matter attached hereto and made a part of this application are honest and true; 3. 1 have authorized the staff of Collier County to enter upon the property during normal working hours for the purpose of investigating and evaluating the request made through this application; and that 4. The property will be transferred, conveyed, sold or subdivided subject to the conditions and restrictions imposed by the approved action. 5. We/I authorize"ap- Senior CeMar atJFCS•Inc. to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this petition including 1 through 2 above. "Notes. • If the applicant is a corporation, then it is usually executed by the corp. p►es. or v. pres. • If the applicant is a Limited Liability Company (L.L.C.) or Limited Company (L.C.), then the documents should typically be signed by the Company's "Managing Member." • If the applicant is a partnership, then typically a partner can sign on behalf of the partnership. • If the applicant is a limited partnership, then the general partner must sign and be identified as the "general partner" of the named partnership. • If the applicant is a trust, then they must include the trustee's name and the words "as trustee" • In each instance, first determine the applicant's status, e.g., individual, corporate, trust, partnership, and then use the appropriate format for that ownership. Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Authorization and that the facts stated in it are true. Signature Lowell E. White as individually and as a Successor Co -Trustee of the Ralph L. Gritten Family Trust u/a/d 09/11/96 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER L/i�/j s Date The foregoing instrument was swom to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me on (date) by ell E whne (name of person providing oath orb, anon), as lnannauel[r and as a Sumemr CD -Trustee who is person, (type of identification) as identification. STAMP/SEAL NNNM LULJETA SLOVA = Notary Public . Stale of Florida a, Commission 8 GG 028371 My Comm Expires Sep 8, 2020 �� �•• CP\08-COA-0011M155 REV 3/24/14 Cofter County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliergov.net (239) 252-2400 Pre -Application Meeting Notes Petition Type: GInPA Date and Time: '?, Z7-1,T Assigned Planner: J)Xvid We_z/=5 Engineering Manager (for PPL's and FP's): Project Information Project Name: IVApW, Pl. #: 2 0l YooJ 2,b2/ Property ID #:'11 `1310FD006 l�3(�D©f ur/erit wee ; Project Address: 7-W aLz�) N4. City: 't r 1 State:/ Zip: ti Applicant: Agent Name: _� r" V I Phone: 5 `t 7 - ll qy Agent/Firm Address: 3SwyilL .1 pe-4 City: Zip: 3 It 13G1 Property Owner:_ 5011m H• Wshrl - rr�tt ��,�..o►. ,4. I .,Id ryt� . /-owe!/ F• ",'.1e Please provide the following, if applicable: � J i. Total Acreage: 1 5• ( 9,66 ii. Proposed # of Residential Units: iii. Proposed Commercial Square Footage: iv. For Amendments, indicate the original petition number: V. If there is an Ordinance or Resolution associated with this project, please indicate the type and number: vi. If the project is within a Plat, provide the name and AR#/PL#: Updated 7/24/2018 Page I 1 of 5 CAr County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliergoy.net (239) 252-2400 Meeting Notes As of 10/16/2017 all Zoning applications have revised applications, and your associated Application is included in your notes; additionally a *new Property Ownership Disclosure Form is required for all applications. A copy of this new form is included in your pre-app Note — link is https://www.colliergov.net/HomelShowDocument?id=75093. - l,✓ P' i r staff A►-;�C- ty ko t okc`'&A/� , 2.ffI l�J �a � �e 54� �YvYoss� C-r Se e, use— L1cP/ jr} e--, t4vq'}''n rpm)., ?e+;'-fiah (-pvD v- Gc)). •r (a ce-,. j V P e �4r5s cA, 16 3,3 ��F� A..Q �� s.31 ]����.r�z. �, ih Q' F^eAI k, � UfuJ el.. 0 St¢ -P -t �'1I, 53 2-Z 5" i 1 ? e,--w dey s�:y, 1, Ca 5. C.� �s ,•: AL I+ d„ ew t 'y /- SG,�Or Gt fy Z G+f,` Cav,4Le Ay ULjj_f � �cr j a r SzpYI ce T Cl rfcs% ' Disclaimer., Information provided by staff to applicant during the Pre -Application Meeting is based on the best available data at the time of the meeting and may not fully inform the applicant of issues that could arise during the process. The Administrative Code and LDC dictates the regulations which all applications must satisfy. Any checklists provided of required data for an application may not fully outline what is needed. It is the applicant's responsibility to provide al required data, n Updated 7/24/2018 Page 1 2 of 5 co 1er County y COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT Ply GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.coliiergov.net oil - CA 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 Pre -Application Meeting Sign -In Sheet PL## 20180002622 Collier County Contact Information: Name Review Discipline Phone Email ❑ David Anthony Environmental Review 252-2497 david.anthony@colliercountyfl.gov Summer Araque Environmental Review 252-6290 1 summer.brownaraque@colliercountyfl.gov 171 Claudine Auclair GMD Operations and Regulatory Management 252-5887 claudine.auclair@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Steve Baluch Transportation Planning 252-2361 stephen.baluch@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Ray Bellows Zoning, Planning Manager 252-2463 raymond.bellows @colIiercountyfLgov Laurie Beard PUD Monitoring 252-5782 laurie.beard@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Craig Brown Environmental Specialist 252-2548 craig.brown@col liercount fLgov ❑ Heidi Ashton Cicko Managing Asst. County Attorney 252-8773 heidi.ashton@colliercountyfl.gov IYThomas Clarke Operations Coordinator 252-2584 thomas.clarke@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Kay Deselem Zoning Services 252-2586 kay.deselem@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Dale Fey North Collier Fire 597-9227 dfey@northcollierfire.com ❑ Eric Fey, P.E. Utility Planning 252-1037 eric.fey@colliercountyfl.gov Tim Finn, AICP Zoning Division 252-4312 timothy.finn@colliercountyfl.gov �ue Faulkner Comprehensive Planning 252-5715 sue.faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Paula Fleishman Impact Fee Administration 252-2924 paula.fleishman@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ James French Growth Management Deputy Department Head 252-5717 james.french@colliercountyfl._gov ❑ Mir.haPl Gihhnns Structural/Residential Plan Review 252-2426 michael.gibbons@colliPrrniintyfl.gov storm.gewirtz@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Storm Gewirtz, P.E. Engineering Stormwater 252-2434 ❑ Nancy Gundlach, AICP, PLA Zoning Division 252-2484 nancy.gundlach@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Shar Hingson Greater Naples Fire District 774-2800 shingson@gnfire.org ❑ John Houldsworth Engineering Subdivision 252-5757 john.houldsworth@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jodi Hughes Transportation Pathways 252-5744 jodi.hughes@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Alicia Humphries Right -Of -Way Permitting 252-2326 alicia.humphries@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Marcia Kendall Comprehensive Planning 252-2387 marcia.kendall@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ John Kelly Zoning Senior Planner 252-5719 john.kelly@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Gil Martinez Zoning Principal Planner 252-4211 gilbert.martinez@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Thomas Mastroberto Greater Naples Fire 252-7348 thomas.mastroberto@colliercountyfl.gov jack.mckenna@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jack McKenna, P.E. Engineering Services 252-2911 1 ❑ Matt McLean, P.E. Development Review Director 252-8279 1 matthew.mclean@colliercountyfl.gov Updated 7/24/2018 Page 1 4 of 5 C' er County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 ❑ Michele Mosca, AICP Capital Project Planning 252-2466 michele.mosca@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Annis Moxam Addressing 252-5519 annis.moxam@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Stefanie Nawrocki Development Review - Zoning 252-2313 stefanie.nawrocki@colliercountyfl.gov V Richard Orth Stormwater Planning 252-5092 richard.orth@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Brandy Otero Transit 252-5859 bra ndy.otero@colliercountyfLgov ❑ Brandi Pollard Utility Impact fees 252-6237 brandi.pollard@colliercountyfl.gov 011"Todd Riggall North Collier Fire 597-9227 triggall@northcollierfire.com ❑ Daniel Roman, P.E. Engineering Utilities 252-2538 daniel.roman@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Brett Rosenblum, P.E. Development Review Principal Project Manager 252-2905 brett.rosenblum@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ James Sabo, AICP Zoning Principal Planner james.sabo@colliergo.net Michael Sawyer Transportation Planning 252-2926 michael.sawyer@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Corby Schmidt, AICP Comprehensive Planning 252-2944 corby.schmidt@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Chris Scott, AICP Development Review - Zoning 252-2460 chris.scott@colliercountyfl.gov I-1 Peter Shawinsky Architectural Review 252-8523 peter.shawinsky@colliercountyfl.gov Camden Smith Zoning Division Operations 252-1042 camden.smith@colliercountyfl.gov Scott Stone Assistant County Attorney 252-5740 scott.stone@colliercountyfl.gov Mark Strain Hearing Examiner/CCPC 252-4446 mark.strain@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Mark Templeton Landscape Review 252-2475 mark.templeton@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jessica Velasco Zoning Division Operations 252-2584 jessica.velasco@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jon Walsh, P.E. Building Review 252-2962 jonathan.walsh@colliercountyfl.gov Jz David Weeks, AICP Comprehensive Planning Future Land Use Consistency 252-2306 david.weeks@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Kirsten Wilkie Environmental Review 252-5518 kirsten.wilkie@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Christine Willoughby Development Review - Zoning 252-5748 christine.willoughby@colliercountyfl.gov Additional Attendee Contact Information: Representing U =1 I SUP '*.2!f1/=j1,WA7X1 F.�i Updated 7/24/2018 Page 1 5 of 5 OVX"4. AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD I hereby certify that pursuant to Ordinance 2004-41, of the Collier County Land Development Code, I did cause the attached newspaper advertisement to appear and I did give notice by mail to the following property owners and/or condominium and civic associations whose members may be affected by the proposed land use changes of an application request for a rezoning, PUD amendment, or conditional use, at least 15 days prior to the scheduled Neighborhood Information Meeting, For the purposes of this requirement, the names and addresses of property owners shall be deemed those appearing on the latest tax rolls of Collier County and any other persons or entities who have made a formal request of the county to be notified. The said notice contained the laymen's description of the site property of proposed change and the date, time, and place of a Neighborhood Information Meeting. Per the attached letters, pr�ynei's list, and copy of newspaper advertisement which are hereby made a part of thisompliance. Associates, P.A. State of Florida County of Lee as Planning Technician for Q. Grady Minor & The foregoing Affidavit of compliance was acknowledged before me this 5th day of September, 2019 by Sharon Umpenhour, who is personally known to me r-e a .,s (Si nature of No y Public) Kimberly Scher Printed Name of Notary KWBMYA. SC HM ;* My CpNlkliB< M 1l GG 281617 804R & December 12, 2Q22 G:INIM Procedures/Affidavit Of Compliance - NM Sept 25 2019.Docx GradyMinor Civil Engineers a Land Surveyors • Planners o Landscape Architects September 4, 2019 RE: Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Dear Sir or Madam: A Neighborhood Information Meeting hosted by D. Wayne Arnold, AICP, of Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A. and John M. Passidomo of Cheffy Passidomo, P.A., representing Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. (Applicant) will be held on Wednesday, September 25, 2019, 5:30 pm at Hodges University, John White Community Room, 2647 Professional Circle, Naples, FL 34119. Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. has submitted formal applications to Collier County, seeking approval of a Small -Scale Growth Management Plan (GMP) Amendment and a Community Facility Planned Unit Development (CFPUD) Rezone. The GMP amendment proposes to create a new community facility sub -district under the Golden Gate Area Master Plan to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building for senior services uses in the subdistrict and to rezone the property from the E, Estates Zoning District to CFPUD Zoning District. The subject property (Naples Senior Center CFPUD) is comprised of approximately 13.6± acres, located on the southeast corner of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. Project information is posted online at www.gradyminor.com/planning. If you have questions or comments, they can be directed to Sharon Umpenhour at Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A., 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134, sumpenhour@gradyminor.com, phone 239-947-1144, fax 239-947-0375. Project information is posted online at www.gradyminor.com/planning. Sincerely, n2A---- Sharon Umpenhour Senior Planning Technician prDfegstonalGtR yG0 G�� Florence L G O m o 1o11 La eel m O m �2 Ncrthbrooke Plaza DRY Z a t t z Executive DR `Z Z �o �gshore WA�f 0 LL LIMM KALEE RD Immokalee RD m n Autumn Oaks LN v 7 tD M r O J '00 Malibu Lake C,,p " SUBJECT 9 PROPERTY Hidden Oaks LN N W E VI. Lake PL 5 Protect Location Map Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey Bonita Springs, FL 34134 Ph. 239-947-1144 Fax.239-947-0375 EB 0005151 LB 0005151 LC 26000266 www.gradyminor.com PL2018000262 PL20180002621 1000, 5/24/2019 Site: FLN 41931080006, 41931200006, 41931120005, and 41933240006 NAME1 NAME2 - 1ST CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH OF NAPLES INC 2180 OAKES LLC 2180 OAKES BLVD 6220 HIDDEN OAKS LLC 382 SADDLEBROOK LANE 7 ELEVEN INC 1722 ROUTH ST # 1000 ACEVEDO, MARIO & FATIMA 465 CASE RD ALEKSEYCHICK, SERGEY PAVLOVICH IRYNA MYKHAILVNA ALEKSEYCHYK AMBROSH, JAMES R 10040 HEATHER LN APT 1401 AMSOUTH BANK PROPERTIES DEPT BARRETT, SIMON DAVID LESLEY CHRISTINE BARRETT BELL JR, JOSEPH R & LINDA B 4016 PRESTON HWY BELL, KENNETH A EDWARD H ZAX BLONDIN & PIETRASZEK INC 985 PINECREAST DR BLONDIN & PIETRASZEK INC 985 PINECREST DR BLONDIN & PIETRASZEK INC 985 PINECREST DR BRACCI, STEVEN J MICHELLE LIL BRACCI BRENTWOOD LAND PARTNERS LLC % KITE REALTY GROUP BRENTWOOD LAND PARTNERS LLC % KITE REALTY GROUP CANNELLA, PETER R & LUCILLE M 2884 DUDLEY AVE CARTER, ANNADANIELLE 10024 HEATHER LANE #1003 COLANGELO, ANTHONY L GERALDINE COLANGELO COLLIER CNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COLLIER COUNTY 3301 TAMIAMI TRL E CYPRESS CYCLE SERVICES INC 2300 OAKES BLVD DAVEKOS FAMILY TRUST 2 FARVIEW HILL ROAD DERBY, ALEX R 5981 HIDDEN OAKS LN DESTINY CHURCH NAPLES 6455 HIDDEN OAKS LANE DESTINY CHURCH NAPLES INC 6455 HIDDEN OAKS LANE E & C L ALEXANDER R/L TRUST 10049 HEATHER LN #102 EL KOMATI LLC 4521 EXECUTIVE DR STE 201 ELLINGTON, PHILLIP & JEANNE K 6040 HIDDEN OAKS LANE ENCORE VENTURE LLC 8009 KILKENNY COURT FAITH BIBLE CHURCH/NAPLES INC 6464 IMMOKALEE RD FAITH BIBLE CHURCH/NAPLES INC 6464 IMMOKALEE RD FERNS, MONIQUE D 10025 HEATHER LANE #703 FIDIS, COVENTINE & DEANNA L 6040 AUTUMN OAKS LN FOURNIER, NICOLAS O & DIANA G 6130 HIDDEN OAKS LN FRY, HEIDI S & KARI Z 6090 HIDDEN OAKS LN GLASE, JAMES A & JEAN A 6355 HIDDEN OAKS LN GLOBAL DYNAMICS LLC 4529 EXECUTIVE DR #101 GPS INTRNTL OF NAPLES INC 470 YUCCA RD GRENDOWSKA, JADWIGA 28413 VERDE LN GUDENAU, GERALD L DAVID DAVIS GUDENAU GUERRETTE, STEVEN L CHERYL O GUERRETTE GUTIERREZ, ALMA R & FRANCISCO 6070 AUTUMN OAKS LN HAGEDORN, JONATHAN 6130 AUTUMN OAKS LN HALLBERG, DAVID E & LYNNETTE L 10024 HEATHER LN #1004 HAMMOND JR, ROBERT J KATHLEEN HAMMOND HARR, DANIEL L 10028 HEATHER LANE #1101 HUDSON CAPITAL FUND LLC 34-27 CRESCENT ST HUGHES, MARK M & KELLY R JAMES K=& MARI-LYNN MCGREGOR HUNTINGTON LAKES RES ASSN INC % AMERICAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT HUNTINGTON LAKES RES ASSOC INC % AMERICAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT IANNOTTA, ANTHONY J & TARA A EDWARD R=& STEPHANIE J EHLEN IGLESIAS, ISRAEL 6080 AUTUMN OAKS LN JOHN H W INKLER TR SHARON A W INKLER TRUST JOHN H W INKLER TRUST SHARON A W INKLER TRUST JOHN H W INKLER TRUST SHARON A W INKLER TRUST JOHN H W INKLER TRUST SHARON A W INKLER TRUST KALDANY DEVELOPMENT CO INC 172 TOPANGA DR KAREN L OLDHAM REV TRUST 10033 HEATHER LN #501 KENTON D SONDENO REV LIV TRUST 6120 HIDDEN OAKS LN KURTZ, BRIAN & CARLA 27040 DEL LANE LACASSE, RICHARD & LORRAINE 10020 HEATHER LN APT 902 LAND TRUST % ROY A SCHUCK TR LEITH, BRIAN & SHEILA A 9654 WHITEHALL STREET LEO, LORI JANE & KEVIN FRANCIS 2291 OAKES BLVD LEPPI, GREG & CHERYL 6110 AUTUMN OAKS LANE LIVINGSTON, JASON S 2130 OAKES BLVD LOUISE V TAYLOR REV LIV TRUST 627 GORDONIA RD LUCKY CHICK LLC 10044 HEATHER LN #1504 LUTZ, SHARON S KIRK ALLEN LUTZ MARY C HOLDER CONDO REV TRUST 317 W 21 ST STREET #1 D MAZZUCCA, MICHAEL & MAUREEN 10037 HEATHER LANE #4403 MCCONNELL, SHAWN C 10041 HEATHER LANE #301 MCGANN, FANCI 11768 QUAIL VILLAGE WAY MCGINTY, HARRIET R 10029 HEATHER LN #604 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CK VILAGE CONDOMINUIM ASSOCIATION MERCADO, MICHAEL A 6181 HIDDEN OAKS LN MEYER, JOSEPH L & KATHLEEN A 10041 HEATHER LANE #302 MICHAEL L HUGHES TRUST 11401 OAKMONT CT MILLET, KRISTIN NAUGHTON 2271 OAKES BLVD MITCHELL, STUART & KAREN 6221 HIDDEN OAKS LN MITCHELL, WILLIAM HARRY LINDA TULL MITCHELL NAREKIAN TR, THOMAS A THOMAS A NAREKIAN TRUST NAREKIAN TR, THOMAS S THOMAS S NAREKIAN TRUST NEFF, WILLIAM L KERI NEFF NEW LOCK INVESTMENTS LLC 118 PROVINCIAL PLACE NEW SOLUTIONS LTD 3255 TAMIAMI TRL N NEW SOLUTIONS LTD 3255 TAMIAMI TRL N NICHOLS, JASON M & MARSHA A 10020 HEATHER LANE UNIT 901 NNPS LLC 4510 EXECUTIVE DR NNPS LLC 4510 EXECUTIVE DR NORTH NAPLES PC REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LLC OAKES RESOURCES INC 470 YUCCA RD OTTOS INSPIRATION LAND TRUST 8950 FONTANA DEL SOL WAY #100 PALLADINO, ANTHONY & CYNTHIA 6460 HIDDEN OAKS LN PALMERI, GRACIELA S 6160 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAME4 NAME5 � NAME6 AL2 I LEGAL4 — 6225 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8634 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 22 LESS N 50FT, LESS EAST PORTION FOR R/W AS DESC IN OR 4432 PG 1280, LESS THOSE PORTIONS FOR NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W1/2 OF N 180FT OF TR 27 NAPLES, FL 34110 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E1/2 OF N 180FT OF TR 27 OR 1459 PG 1008-1009 DALLAS, TX 75201 --- 0 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 LOT 9 OR 1501 PG 236 LABELLE, FL 33935--- 9458 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 150FT OF TR 68 10063 PALAZZO DRIVE NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 PALAZZO AT NAPLES LOT 36 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 9027 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1401 250 RIVERCHASE PKWY E 6TH FL BIRMINGHAM, AL 35244--- 1832 BRENTWOOD TWO LOT 1 LESS THAT PORTION AS DESC IN OR 4461 PG 2843 6060 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 75FT OF TR 69 AND THE W 7.5 FT OF W 150FT OF TR 72 LOUISVILLE, KY 40213--- 1612 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 101 2221 E STARLITE LN LOUISVILLE, KY 40291--- 1761 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 203 SUGAR GROVE, IL 60554 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1304 SUGAR GROVE, IL 60554 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1203 SUGAR GROVE, IL 60554 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 601 6141 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--- 1131 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 150FT OF TR 53 30 S MERIDIAN ST STE 1100 INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204--- 3565 BRENTWOOD TWO TRACT B LESS THAT PORTION AS DESC IN OR 4456 PG 285-288, LESS THAT PORTION AS DESC IN OR 4644 30 S MERIDIAN ST STE 1100 INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204 --- 3565 BRENTWOOD TWO TRACT P-3 BRONX, NY 10461 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1301 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1003 25 YORKTON BLVD MARKHAM L6C OJ9 CANADA MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 602 3301 TAMIAMI TRL E BLDG F NAPLES, FL 34112--- 4902 HUNTINGTON TRACT A (ROAD R/W) OR 2268 PG 2068 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 50 LESS N 50FT 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112 --- 0 NORTHBROOK DRIVE TRACT R 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112---0 TARPON BAY TRACT A 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112 --- 0 BRENTWOOD TWO THAT PORTION OF TRACT B DESC AS: COMM AT NE CNR OF SEC 30, S 02DEG E 49.97 FT, S 89DEG W 268.36FT, S 02 NAPLES, FL 34112 --- 0 BRENTWOOD TWO TRACT A NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 S 105FT OF TR 24 OR 583 PG 351 ATKINSON, NH 03811 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 801 NAPLES, FL 34119---1135 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 180FT OF TR 88 OR 1632 PG 1464 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 5 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 15, LESS E 300FT & TR 16, LESS THE E 600FT NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 102 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 9035 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE II LOT 13 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 150FT OF TR 74 NAPLES, FL 34112 --- 0 QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 201 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8843 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 19, LESS N 50FT, LESS S 15FT OF N65FT OF E 35FT DESC IN OR 2587 PG 2737 STIPULATED ORDER NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8843 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 20, LESS N 65FT OF W 300.01 FT AS DESC IN OR 2157 PG 1154 AND OR 2587 PG 2737 STIPULATED NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 703 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 157.5FT OF THE W 165FT OF TR 72 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 75FT OF W 150FT OF TR 54 OR 1107 PG 276 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 1134 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 OF TR 67 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8607 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 300 FT OF TR 15 2.27 AC NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE II LOT 12 NAPLES, FL 34102--- 5323 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 3 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 701 590 FARRINGTON HWY #524-424 KAPOLEI, HI 96707 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 OF TR 73 25 LOGAN BLVD N NAPLES, FL 34119---0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 104 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8633 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 75FT OF E 150FT OF TR 69 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8633 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 OF TR 52 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1004 18356 WESTOVER DRIVE SOUTH BEND, IN 46637 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 404 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1101 ASTORIA, NY 11106 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 304 17514 HIDDEN GARDEN LN ASHTON, MD 20861--- 3651 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1502 10621 AIRPORT PULLING RD N # 8 NAPLES, FL 34109--- 7300 HUNTINGTON LAKES UNIT ONE TRACT 5 (BUFFER,COMMON AREA) 10621 AIRPORT PULLING RD N # 8 NAPLES, FL 34109--- 7300 HUNTINGTON TRACT B 650 CENTURY CT MARCO ISLAND, FL 34145--- 1906 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 402 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8633 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 180FT OF TR 69 OR 1519 PG 2175 LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--- 3385 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 23 LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--- 3385 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 49 LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--- 3385 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N 75FT OF S 180FT OF TR 24 LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--- 3385 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N 150FT OF TR 24 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34134--- 8544 QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 101 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 9024 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 501 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 180FT OF TR 54 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 180FT OF TR 68 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8852 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 902 1023 GROVE DR NAPLES, FL 34120--- 1426 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 90 LESS N 50FT NAPLES, FL 34109 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1503 NAPLES, FL 34119---8758 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 600 FT OF N1/2 OF TR 16, 2.27 AC NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E1/2 OF TR 52 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8755 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N165FT OF TR 28 NAPLES, FL 34108 --- 0 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 71 LESS N 50FT NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1504 10044 HEATHER LANE #1501 NAPLES, FL 34119---0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1501 NEW YORK, NY 10011--- 3054 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 204 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 403 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 301 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 802 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 604 11655 QUAIL VILLAGE WAY NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8806 20 48 26 COMM SW CNR SECT 20, ELY 1000.01 FT, N1 DEG W 100FT TO POB, CONT NLY 860.81 FT, S 70 DEG E 541.22FT, S 14 DEG W NAPLES, FL 34119---1131 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 180FT OF TR 48 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 302 FORT MYERS, FL 33908 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 201 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8758 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 600 FT OF S 1/2 OF TR 16, 2.27 AC OR 1734 PG 1015 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8618 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 1/2 OF TR 26 8230 DONAWAY RD WHALEYVILLE, MD 21872--- 2030 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1001 UTD 12/31/96 28413 VERDE LANE BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 401 UTD 12/31/96 28413 VERDE LANE BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 502 2170 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8755 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 S 150FT OF TR 27 BRAMPTON L6S 6C3 CANADA MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1201 NAPLES, FL 34103--- 4106 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 LOTS 1, 2 AND 3 NAPLES, FL 34103--- 4106 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE I WILY 40FT OF LOT 4 LESS E 5FT, LESS E 23FT OF W 35FT OF W 40FT OF LOT 4 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 901 NAPLES, FL 34115 --- 0 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE I LOT 4 LESS W LY 40FT AND TRACT A LESS ELY 58FT NAPLES, FL 34115 --- 0 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PH 1 ELY 5FT OF WILY 40FT OF LOT 4, AND E 23FT OF W 35FT OF W 40FT OF LOT 4 11216 TAMIAMI TRAIL NORTH SUITE 120 NAPLES, FL 34110 --- 0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1002 NAPLES, FL 34102--- 5323 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 2 NAPLES, FL 34109--- 4420 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 303 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8600 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 14, LESS E 350FT NAPLES, FL 34119--- 1132 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 75FT OF TR 47 POList 1000 PL20180002622-PL20180002621.xls PL2018000262 PL20180002621 1000, 5/24/2019 Site: FLN 41931080006, 41931200006, 41931120005, and 41933240006 2 PANDYA, SUNIL RAMESH PASCUZZI, VINCE S & DIANE S PATRICIA J PHALON TRUST PHILLOS BRIGHTON REALTY TRUST PINELLI, EDDY & NANCY POKHOY,NEHAUL QCV LLC QUAIL PLAZA LLC QUAIL PLAZA PROPERTY OWNERS RAY REAL ESTATE LLC REFERENCE ONLY REFERENCE ONLY REFERENCE ONLY RELF, SCOTT B & RENEE R RESOP, JACQUELINE M RIESTRA JR, FERNANDO M RINGHOFER, ROBERT & JAMIE ANNE RONCA HOLDINGS LLC ROOK JR, JOHN A & MANDY LYNN ROW E, TIMOTHY E & AMANDA L SAALOUKEH, MICHEL & ELIAS SAMUEL, DARREN SAURBIER, KAI W & CORDURA SINGH, TEJESHWAR SOLOMON, ERIC P & CAMMERON SOPKO, EDWARD T & ELLEN SOUTHBROOKE MEDICAL OFFICE LLC SOUTHBROOKE MEDICAL OFFICE LLC SOUTHERN III, JAMES L STONE, HARRY J STREETMAN,STEVEN S TACHER, BRIAN M & SHANNON M TANNASSEE SR, KENNETH R TAYLOR, MATTHEW R & TRACY L TGM MALIBU LAKES LLC TIITF /DOT /ST OF FL TOMPKINS, J FREDERICK BROCK TRACI BUILDING LLC TRACI BUILDING LLC TRACI BUILDING LLC TRACI BUILDING LLC TRACI BUILDING LLC TRACI BUILDING LLC TWETAN, CLIFFORD ANDREW UNITED AMERICAN TRUST LC UNITED AMERICAN TRUST LC UNITED TELEPHONE CO OF FLA VAN PIERCE, ROBERT VANDERPOST, ROBERT JOHN VBS-LLC VINCENT PALAGRUTO LIV TRUST WALKER, DAVID K & LINDA R WALKER, ROBERT C & JUDITH E WELLS, SCOTT W IGLEY, NATHAN S W ROBLESKI, JASON A 2391 OAKES BLVD 121 SCHOLFIELD AVE 325 E 31 AVE 107 HEMLOCK DRIVE 624 W ILSON STREET SHERRY POKHOY 1016 COLLIER CENTER WAY 4522 EXECUTIVE DR STE 102 ASSOCIATION INC 4624 OAK LEAF DRIVE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING 6020 AUTUMN OAKS LN 10028 HEATHER LN #1102 GABRIELA RIESTRA 2290 OAKES BLVD 3232 ATLANTIC CIRCLE 6060 HIDDEN OAKS LN 6161 HIDDEN OAKS LN 9159 THE LANE TAMARA STROHL-SAMUEL 6461 AUTUMN OAKS LN INDERPREET KAUR 4001 SANTA BARBARA BLVD #327 164 BOULEVARD 9015 STRADA STELL COURT #102 9015 STRADA STELL COURT #102 625 MAIN ST AMANDA C GRIMES 10616 BROOKES RESERVE RD 319 ROOKERY COURT PO BOX 11623 6111 HIDDEN OAKS LN 1 NORTH LA SALLE ST #2100 PO BOX 1249 PENELOPE MARLYN TOMPKINS 2171 OAKES BLVD 2171 OAKES BLVD 2171 OAKES BLVD 2171 OAKES BLVD 2171 OAKES BLVD 2171 OAKES BLVD TRACEY MARIE TWETAN 4513 EXECUTIVE DR PO BOX 110101 % EMBARQ CORP 100278 HEATHER LANE #1104 CARMELINDA ABBATICCHIO 2270 MAHOGANY TRL 10021 HEATHER LN #804 10040 HEATHER LANE #1404 2171 OAKES BLVD 551 N 1230 E 10025 HEATHER LANE #702 6170 HIDDEN OAKS LN 10036 HEATHER LANE #1302 SUITE 101 12823 VALEWOOD DR THE A CONDOMINIUM A CONDOMINIUM 9589 CRESENT GARDEN DR C-201 2220 OAKES BLVD 10033 HEATHER LANE #504 5814 HAMMOCK ISLES DR 22 DAYMOND DR 6140 HIDDEN OAKS LN ATTN: PROPERTY TAX 60 EDWARDS DRIVE PO BOX 7909 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8760 PT COLBORNE L3K OA2 CANADA EUGENE, OR 97405 --- 0 W ESTW OOD, MA 02090 --- 0 SAULT STE MARIE P6B 2L6 CANADA NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34110 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 9013 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8502 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8633 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 9021 NAPLES, FL 34109 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8757 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 1134 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 1131 NAPLES, FL 34109 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8757 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8605 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34104 --- 0 NEW MILFORD, NJ 07646 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34109 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34109 --- 0 MILLIS, MA 02054 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119---0 UPPER MARLBORO, MD 20772--- 6618 MARCO ISLAND, FL 34145 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34101 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 1131 CHICAGO, IL 60602 --- 3918 BARTOW, FL 33831 --- 1249 GUELPH N1H 6H9 CANADA NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8756 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8756 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8756 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8756 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8756 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8756 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 9033 NAPLES, FL 34108 --- 0 OVERLAND PARK, KS 66207 --- 909 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 BARRIE L4N 9K8 CANADA DE PERE, WI 54115 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8862 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 8756 OREM, UT 84097--- 5437 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34119--- 1132 Q AND W SUBDIVISION MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 S MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE 20 48 26 THAT PORTION OF SEC QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 1/2 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 4 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 51 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 70 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 30 48 26 A PORTION OF THE NE 30 48 26 1-75 R/W 59.74 AC GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 1/2 TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE II QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 11 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W LOT 1 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 903 150FT OF TR 25 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 503 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 603 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1302 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 202 UNIT 102 TRACT C THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 904 20 NKA THE MEADOWS AT QUAIL LOT 5 AND ELY 58FT OF TRACT A LOTS 6, 7 & 8 NKA TRACI E 165FT OF TR 72 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1102 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1303 180FT OF TR 25 UNIT 103 OF TR 67 150FT OF TR 48 OR 1360 PG 2389 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1403 OF TR 26 OR 2010 PG 1257 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 504 180FT OF TR 47 OR 1276 PG 1146 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 103 LESS N 50FT LESS N 50FT 21, LESS N 200FT OF E 75FT, THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 704 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1402 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1202 180FT OF TR 89 180FT OF TR 53 1/4 OF SEC 30 TWP 48 RNG 26 LESS BRENTWOOD TWO OF TR 73 UNIT 101 UNIT 102 UNIT 103 UNIT 104 UNIT 105 UNIT 106 75FT OF TR 54 LOT 14 AND LOT 15, LESS THE LOT 15 LESS E 42.04FT 75FT OF TR 21, LESS S 200.98FT THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1104 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 803 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1103 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 804 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1404 350FT OF TR 14 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1204 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 702 75FT OF E 150FT OF TR 47 CREEK VILLAGE CONDO AS DESC IN OR 4047 PG 773 NKA QUAIL PLAZA CONDO AS DESC IN OR 3239 PG 1806 BUILDING CONDO AS DESC IN OR 4117 PG 2224 -2391 LESS N 50FT OF W 275.01 FT MORE PARTICULARY DESCRIBED IN OR 4636 PG 1773. W LY 143.19 OF LOT 15 AND LESS DESC. IN OR 2583 PG 2214 POList 1000 PL20180002622-PL20180002621.xls NOTICE OF NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD A Neighborhood Information Meeting hosted by D. Wayne Arnold, AICP, of Q. Grady Minor and Associates. PA. and John M. Passidomo of Cheffy Passidomo: RA., representing Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. (Applicant) will : e held on: Wednesday, September 25, 2019, 5:30 pm at Hodges University, John White Community Room, 2647 Professional Circle, Naples, FL 34119 Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. has submitted formal applications to Collier County, seeking approval of a Small -Scale Growth Management Plan (GMP) Amendment and a Community Facility Planned Unit Development (CFPUD) Rezone. The GMP amendment proposes to create a new community facility sub -district under the Golden Gate Area Master Plan to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building for senior services uses in the subdistrict and to rezone the property from the E, Estates Zoning District to CFPUD Zoning District. The subject property (Naples Senior Center CFPUD) is comprised of approximately 13.6± acres, located on the southeast corner of the intersection of Cakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. The Neighborhood Information Meeting is for informational purposes only, it is not a public (hearing. Project information is posted online at www.gradyminor.ccm/planning. If you have questions or comments, they can be directed to Sharon Umpenhour, Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A., 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134, sumpenhour%gradyminor.eonn. phone 239-947-1144, fax 239-947-0375. NEIGHBORHOOD I FORMAT?DN MEETING Petitions PL20180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL2018000fi 2, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***PLtAse be 2avLSe01*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency, If you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public rer.ords request, you can refrain from including such InformaVon on this sheet. You have the option of checking wlth the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county web site for additionai information - (DAME: L- AA i or...)& EMAIL: C7 } .I '- ~rjL,.,je _Jf-r ADDRESS- '-1&c> l` 6UA-Q G7, r)A�* � 3-tka3 PHONE: NAME-, r- ���� EMAIL: i�� orr � G.1 AfDRE54:6 0 ! #'r;rYk, �+� ,r- PHONE, 2311 `1 4 Ci P -z5, 15 NAME: EMAIL: O � 1"'\ 1 4 �r� 4Ca5r--. 'A'+`-, ADDRESS: (�'� PHONE: 1 1 NAME: 4 1 ir1f�� EIVI41L�r �r �3r I • CVO ADDRESS: F I L e�� PHONE: w NAME: ADDRESS: NAME. l AbDlt 'z -, r)f lEMAIL: PHONE: EMAIL: PHONE: NAMEf EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: o o Ad .' NAME: Z' 4&40 Fd EMAIL: ADDRESS: SaoUL PHONE: NIM Sign -in Sheet 09- 5- 019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL 0180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility ubdi5trict and PL2D1S00020 2, Naples Senior Center UPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***-PLense be The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e-maiI addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency if you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a publl[ records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff an your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional Information, NAME: ENTAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NAf41E.e— ENTAIL: fiE x 11 ; t ADDRESS. I } t PHONE: NAME: � 1 � � ENTAIL: 1¢ C Cr�t�f I t 7wa' ADDRESS: I e• PHONE: ll,l NAME: ENTAIL: 1 G#C,Qy 6Lt'lU, ADDRESS: a 9 � r C k 3 PHONE: -T- rt - 33 NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: _ '1 & PHONE: NAME: EMAIL. � m ADDRESS: h PHN£: NAIVIE: EMAIL: ADDT;ESS., PHONE: NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE, NIM Sign -in Sheet 09-25-2019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL20180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL201 OOO G2 , Maples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***please be advcseoi*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency, if you do not want your a -marl address, phone number of home address released it the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional information. NAME: 752 EMAIL: Oj ( 0�vl ADDRESS: C: PHONE: NAME: EMAFLF►.:3.:,,,�.,,.- ADDRESS' IPHOfYE �, � .� - w NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS, PHONE' NAME- J 1 M "Ricer EMAIL: �� Lyq L T ADDRESS: t (2 CAK) PHONE: NAME: ' Eh+xATL: ADDRE$ NAME: 0 EMAIL. ADDRESS:OPiE: NAME, EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE, NIIVI Sign -in Sheet 09-25-2019 t ( - 0V'-,� NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL2018000 621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL2018000 6 2, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***MtAse b& a�V�Sed*** The information on this shut is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings, Under Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency, IF you do not want your e-mail address, (phone number or hem address released JF the county receives a public records request, you can refrain From including such Information on this sheet. You have the option of check!ng with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional information - NAME: lk.& ly EMAIL.' ' ADDRES& ��� PHONE: Z,4/` 7-c 3 1- NAME, hdAA� f EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: � L - `[ do NAME: EI11lAlL: t 'i ADDRESS: rvl -a .S + PHONE: NAME: ' EMAIL* ADDRESS: 1 � _ . � ' � PHONE: ,�9 q NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS* PHONE: NAMIE, EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NIMSign-in Sheet 09-25-2019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL 01 00026 1 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL 018000 622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY " Please be 2dVLSe0l*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding #his project and future public meetings. Under Pic rida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certairn home addresses ire public records once received by a government agency. If you do not want your a -mall address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from Including such Information on this sheet. You have the option of chKking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional information. NAME: Mr4 EMAIL: lg ,en 611 LU ADDRESS: PHONE: —70 . ^ c1 G -1u 4 -92-12 NAME: I EMAIL,k It VA*I S c r s ADDRESS: !SE! lzr _ L e"d� `r lie7 dq" EMAIL. ?- ADDRESS: 7 Zo# -, .+ ta-c C41c PHONE' i . 1 <4 It NAME:I , —fR f J ' EMAIL: ADDRESS- '`` PHONE: NAME- cromllldiyf J EMAIL: �� P S r �II(I ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME, 1 I<51+1A1l: ;z A,',L- 0 r- V-A 3T. .�. ADDRESS: 6 0<1 PHONE: j'�- 0 t_ 5 F t- 4 t� NAME: Jc++ EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE:.I - NAMVIE: EMAIL: - I ADDRESS: [� P 011E: A ,x- Ale i / c NIM Sign -in Sheet 09-25-2019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL20180002 21 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Maples Senior Center crPU D September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ** an Se be 2OVCS g*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings_ Undef Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records ante received by a government agency. If you do not wart your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the protect as well as checking the county Web site for additional information, NAME: C A Al EMAIL.( 2_U /4 ,f', ± AD DRESS: F] PHONE: V 0 1L � a ffie� 'n, NAME.( ��_C�-1 EMAIL: �, �r • �iS�J ADDRESS: VI jZ'jLL, h4LzPHONE- r� k -. NAME�� � � L,,Ar-O EMAIL: 6;U/ ADDRESS: 1IFo, PHONE: tJ Z" NAME: r . —1—, / rr EMAIL: ADDRE`anti F's PRONE:, % n �f - ` NAME: ��- EMA11;-� �(���� �!� •�fi ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME: & r-A r0 V i llir r Cf �,? EMAIL: ADDRESS: I j PHONE, NAME: EMAIL ADDRESS: J PHONE: NIM Sign -in Sheet 09-25-2019 "/C _ C c� NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEET;N Petitions PL 01 0OB fi21 Na pies Senior Center Corr munity Facility Subdistrict and PL 01 000 622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***-PLaRSe be 2dVESa0l*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings, Under Flodda law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency- if you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such in€ormat on on thiis sheet. You have the option of Checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site For add ltlonaI information. NAME: ADDRESS: ADDRESS 9,6 J4/} NAME: I ter. i . ' �_ _ ADDRESS:I EMAIL, i . PHONE; EMAIL:��. e .� PHONE � EMAIL: b( y a) PHONE: NAME �� ENTAIL: • f` C - 'Vq ADDRESS: -�� PHONE, - .-' aQ. NAME. EMAIL: ADDRESS, PHONE: NAME: EMAIL; ADDRESS. A N� - PHONE- - 3q- i ` 1' or�, NAME- --- LL- i ENTAIL: ADDRESS: PHD 1 ` - Cos) NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NIM Sign -in Sheet 09-25-2019 N E IG HGORHIDOD 1NFOR MATION MEETIf Petitions PL20180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL201800026 2, Na pies Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT T LEARLY ***r-Ldast b� A�AVLSO*** The inferMation an this sheeet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings- Under Florida law, e-rnail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency- If you do not want your a -mail address, phone number or hpme address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from Including such Information on this sheet- You have the option of checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county web site for additional information. NAME: .. f 1- EIVIAIL- ?V 7` ADDRESS, /_4a 1- J►� � PHONE' 2,3 l ��5 ENTAIL: ` CA/V'J f 09vr.(�1 l -, >-V ADDRESS:V PHONE: } NAif1+lE: ht{f-5 �tb/�Ly ADDRESS: rib f Ih.' tL'Ir K. N NAME; PHONE: EMAIL: 7Ecr#-) f Cr ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME: L_ EMAIL. '► ' ' f `�, ,;r C ADDRESS _ PHONE: NAME:1CTI1 "3 a _L vffv .�MAII•. �r{f1 �'k. } 11 t lw/ ADDRESS: l� 1Dw1 PHONE. 9 NANIE+ yr f+ '�-�_�C EMAIL. — ADDRESS. on�h I�1�� PHONE. 'J- NAME: r EMAIL: ADDRESS: F a PHONE: NIM Sign -In Sheet 09-25-2019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATI0N MFFTING Petitions PL 01 00026 1 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Maples Senior Center OFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY The information on this sheet is to contact yov regarding this project and Future public meetings. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency, If you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or dome address released if the county receives a public records request, you can reFrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff on your awn to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additie naI information. NAME: ,_ e')I uL' 11jr, EMAIL. ADDRESS- 4f PHONE: A f" � I 4� MdC . cc, +" — ADDRESS. t �CcV �n - PHONE: �l4 C� ih1gN1E: rll „ EMAIL: ADDRESS: . % rr C L b +, I l r- PHONE: NAME: x] � P w �3 ADDRESS: + NAME: ADDRESS* � h s ,'_ t3 1 6 k.1 EMAIL: PHONE. EMAIL: PHONE: 0"- NAME C,�50EMAIL: wADDRESS: W 'S ZAJ PHOf : C - C-LLZ Sign-iri Sleet 09-25-2019 N EiG H80RH00D INFOR CATION ME€TINC Petitions PL 0180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL 0180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY The Information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency. if you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of cheding with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for add.1tional information. NAM - ' EMAIL: ADD E /P - 75 kPHONE: .--� NAME- / _ . , Y / / MAIU ADDRESS: t,r t0 (_ P14ONE: NAME EMAIL, ADDRESS: PHONE: N10.1VtE:} EMAIL:Ft ADDR15SS: {/yo ! PHONE: NAME* U±P� V_ b- EMAIL: ADDRESS: f 6 q A-�E�tLQ PHONE: NAME: ADDRESS: EMAIL PHONE - NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: { , c � J<-/ ,_ PHONE: n f n NIM Sign -ire Sheet 09-25-2019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL 018000 621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***PLeasz roc wlvised*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain hkorne addresses are public records once received by a government agency_ If you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You #gave the option of che[kIng with the county staff on your own to obtain updates an the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional information, �A NAf1+1E:/� � EMAIL* ## !� ADDRESS: 1 -JcZ f�HpfvE: Nam. NAME:Bd2b� SUV" (4y) EMAIL: &_ 901 • c { it l ADDRESS: �b L4,� PHONI<: NAME: - EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME- ` [ r EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: ADDRESS: 1 j`� lJ PHONE: NAME, ENWL: ADDRESS. 1 PHONE - NAME: �� Z4-f � � EMAIL: � u r� 114 '4emfe '+I� ADDRESS: 6110 � A 1 J ZiV PHONE: 35, 9 _ ' IF NAME: I+N4AIl: ADDRESS r ro �� 1�1INE: N I M Sign -in Street 09-25-2019 NEIGHBORHOOD 1 FORMAT[ON MEETING Petitions PL20180002621 Naples Senior Center Coma unity Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Fiorida law, e -rnaII addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency- If you do not want your a -mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such Information on this sheet You have the option of chiEckIng with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Weh site for additional Information. NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: k PHONE: NAME- �1 �'C E[ti+1A11,: ' CCU •C# Arl ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME,.C. !-4 C4.0 EMAIL: r1 rC C Q ,I-1r�'C'.'iQ ADDRESS: [ �� f ��� �' s �� �} L01— �-i 1141 NAME:' f &,fi\ l ADDRESS: I IY7 /1r7 e I f PHONE: -39i ` 16 g f f PHONE( - r1 ''. r NAME: �s "C' rfr EMAIL. `"r Cr'J-k iN- i i f ADDRESS: �4 (c PHONE. x NAME: 'A Ef4�AlE: n .c a r: - * cam.• rk s I � ADDRESS: yo c. I l '! PHONE: L ' e iVA11+iE: j { �� LEMA3L. ADDRESS: -�8 �„1c4. , .1i�� �� PHONE, NAME. �i. EMAIL. R&7w F � �{ ADDRESS: c iCiC_0 I i PHONE: NIM Sign -in Sheet 09-25•2019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL 018000 621 (Naples Senior Center Corrmunit Facility Suhd[strict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***-Pi ase be A01VLS10*** The information on this sheet Is to contact you regarding this project and future pubNc meetings. Under Florida law, email addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency. if you do not want your L-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrai,i from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional iriformatlon. NAME: 1 [ EMAIL: r6 Lo � v F I wf . ADDRESS: PHOf�I: NAME:MC L�L� L;VOf EMAIL: ex- +} ADbItSS: �1°ft� PFiONE:,�J� NAME: d� �4 I Lr�# MAIL Irc &_"'/' � ADDRESS: � / c PHONE: NAME: 1..t J.9.FWFV%a.J. if - NAME, ,' ,. # u/ EMAIL: J2179/ ADDRE : _ , PHONE: NAME, �� EMAIL: tAbta t...+,, 1� fw_e Api?RE55:�f�j SPAWISa Jpj PHONE: 61' 6 , ` . NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: � � PRONE: NAME: t ��trx-�t EMAIL: �+40 ., OZA ADDRESS: �� PHONE: NIM Sign -in Sheet 09-25-2019 gples Senior Center: It's more than a destination. 's a lifeline, a connection, a place for friendships, learning, and caregiving. NAPLES SENIOR CENTER ;._W ERA FOR SENIORS About Naples Senior Center In 2014, Naples Senior Center became the first service organization for seniors in Collier County. Over the years, our leased space on Castello Drive has welcomed seniors from throughout the community -from every zip code, income level, neighborhood -for social activities, educational enrichment, arts and crafts, wellness and fitness classes, and fellowship with friends. Additionally, Naples Senior Center offers the county's only Dementia Respite Program, where caregivers can bring their loved ones for four hours of therapeutic activities and engagement, two times each week, while gaining valuable time to take care of themselves. Hours of Operation: Naples Senior Center operates only Monday through Friday, with no evening or weekend programming. Staff hours are 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m., and a rotating schedule of small group activities takes place between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m. A Wednesday luncheon draws 150-200 guests for camaraderie and education. Registration is required so Naples Senior Center can manage the number of people who participate at any given time. Funding: Our operations are supported by philanthropic donations and grants; we do not rely on taxpayer funding to meet our mission of serving Collier County's older adults. New Naples Senior Center Naples Senior Center has filed applications with Collier County for a new, permanent home on 13.6 acres along Autumn Oaks Lane, just south of the signalized intersection of immokalee Road and Valewood Drive. The proposed site is centrally located to the highest concentration of members and offers convenient access from 1-75 for members who live in other parts of Collier County. The site comfortably accommodates the center with ample parking, as well as deep setbacks with enhanced, mature landscapingto ensure compatibility within the neighborhood. A full five acres on the east side of the property will be preserved as passive green space. No direct access is planned for Oakes Boulevard. NAPLES SENIOR CENTER A NEW ERA FOR SENIORS Ne wNaplesSeniorCen ter. org 239.325.4444 NAPLES SENIOR CENTER A NEW ERA FOR SENIORS Frequently Asked Questions Naples Senior Center is proud to support and enrich the lives of seniors and their families in Collier County and southern Lee County by providing tools to address life's challenges. We support and strengthen families and individuals of all backgrounds and beliefs through small -group wellness and social activities, as well as a Dementia Respite program. Following are FAQs related to the center's proposed location for a permanent home. Why did you choose this location for the new Naples Senior Center? The location for the new Naples Senior Center is central to the highest concentration of members, and its proximity to I-75 allows convenient access from other parts of Collier County. The entrance is located just south of the signalized intersection of lmmokalee Road and Valewood Drive, providing safe, direct access to the Center. Additionally, the 13.6-acre site allows for 5 acres of preserve and open space in addition to enhanced setbacks and landscaping buffers. Did you search for other locations for the new Naples Senior Center? Yes, Naples Senior Center leadership and its real estate consultants sought potential locations for two years, and the proposed site was the only location that met all the necessary criteria: centrally located, convenient access, ample room for landscaping and preservation areas, and consistent with our status as a charity, our budget constraints, and our fiduciary obligations. What are the hours of operation at Naples Senior Center? Naples Senior Center staff hours are 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. The vast majority of member programming takes place between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m. No services or activities take place during the evenings or on the weekend. How many members visit Naples Senior Center each day? A rotati ng sched ule of small -group classes and activities attracts about 150 members spread out over the 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. timeframe. Registration is required so Naples Senior Center is able to manage the number of people who participate in programming at any given time. How will Naples Senior Center impact traffic at the new location? Expert studies demonstrate little traffic impact because the vast majority of programming occurs between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m. - off-peak hours. Also, Naples Senior Center has a rotating schedule of small group activities, so the maximum attendance at any one time is lunch on Wednesdays, which currently welcomes an average of 150 to 200 members who leave by 1:30 p.m. How many parking spaces are planned at the new location? The site plan For the new Naples Senior Center includes 200 parking spaces - more than four times the number of spaces at the current leased space on Castello Drive. Do you have programs or activities in the evenings or on the weekends? No, Naples Senior Center does not and will not offer programming in the evenings or on the weekends. This commitment is included in the project applications submitted to Collier County Do members ever use Naples Senior Center for overnight stays? No, never. Naples Senior Center serves older adults only Monday through Friday, with no evening orweekend programming. How do seniors qualify for Naples Senior Center services and programs? Naples Senior Center welcomes any and all older adults throughout Collier County. Our members come for socialization, health and wellness, group activities, and educational offerings. How will you handle future growth in membership? The new Naples Senior Center has been designed as our permanent home. As population growth expands in other parts of Collier County, the Center will develop satellite programs similar to our existing satellite program in Marco Island. What taxpayer funds are being used for the new Naples Senior Center? No taxpayer dollars are being used to purchase, build, or operate the new Naples Senior Center. We are fortunate to be generously supported through philanthropic gifts and grants. What taxpayer funds are used for operations at Naples Senior Center? Though Naples Senior Center serves older adults from throughout Collier County, our operations are not supported by taxpayer funds. Our operations are funded through generous philanthropic gifts and grants. What is the project timeline? Applications have been filed with Collier County for the new Naples Senior Center. The review process will include public hearings at the Collier County Planning Commission and the Board of County Commissioners, likely in late 2019 and early 2020. If the applications are approved, construction would begin in 2020 and completed by late 2020 or early 2021. The Oakes Estates Neighborhood Association recently characterized Naples Senior Center as an "impending threat" and a"high-intensity commercial institution:' Is this correct? Such assertions misrepresent and mischaracterize Naples Senior Center, a nonprofit social service organization that has limited, off-peak hours of operation and serves a limited number of members Monday through Friday. We are committed to being a low -impact neighbor in Oakes Estates by preserving five acres for passive open space, providing ample setbacks from all public roadways, and planning forenhanced, mature landscaping that will beautify the site and the neighborhood while effectively shielding the center from the view of passersby. NAPLES SENIOR CENTER A NEW ERA FOR SENIORS For more information, visit NewNaplesSeniorCen ter. org. Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and P11-20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Tina Matte: [inaudible][00:00:00] of numbers up there about the petition that's been filed with Collier County, but this is our neighborhood information meeting. We very much appreciate everyone being here this evening. I just want to go over a couple of housekeeping, uh, items. One is the, um, we are required to have everybody sign in, so if you haven't done that, uh, before you sat down, if you didn't have a chance to sign in at one of the tables in the back, please do that before you leave this evening. The county requires a record of everybody who's in attendance, so thank you. If you don't have a copy of the handouts that were at the registration table, please raise your hand and we'll bring some to you. Thank you. And if — please, if you'd like to take extras with you if you have neighbors and friends who weren't able to be here this evening, please feel free to take handouts for them, as well. Right over here, Rose, thank you. Um... The restrooms are through this door, down the hallway on your left. Um, I do want everybody to be aware that this meeting is being recorded. So, everything that is stated from one of the microphones in the room will be on the record, as we are again, required by the county to submit a transcript of the meeting, including your questions and answers. To that end, um, we'd really appreciate it if we had the opportunity to get through our presentation this evening, and then we will entertain your questions. So, just be assured that we will answer all of them. And if it's something that you want to talk with somebody about after the meeting with the — project team will be here to answer those questions as well. We'll have — we have microphones in each of the aisles, so there's one here and one in the middle aisle there. So, when the time comes, if you have questions that you'd like to have answered by the project team, those microphones will be where you'll head. Um, it is now my pleasure to introduce the President and CEO of Naples Senior Center, Dr. Jaclynn Faffer. Yeah. You're in control. Dr. Jaclynn Faffer: Thank you very much. Thank you, Tina. And thank you all for taking time to join us this evening to hear of our plans for the Naples Senior Center. Having a neighborhood information meeting is part of our county requirements, but the requirement is only for neighbors within 1,000 feet of the property. We mailed invitations to everyone in Oakes Estates, because we want to share our story, answer your questions, and be transparent in this process. We have seen a number of communications contain misinformation about what is actually being requested, and who we are as an Page 1 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD organization, not unusual in these situations. Things like we are a high - intensity commercial institution, or that we are planning 400 parking spaces. Or that we have 2,000 people at our weekly Wednesday luncheon. These misleading statements are not true, and they misrepresent us as Naples Senior Center. By the end of this evening, you will know the actual facts about our services, our programs, our hours of operation, traffic impacts, our site plan, and any other information you might like to know. Most importantly, what we want you to know is we want to be a good neighbor. When I think about the Naples Senior Center opening its doors on January 22, 2014, 1 think of Helen, who was standing in front of the closed doors looking very anxious. She was one of the first 80 people to join the Naples Senior Center. When I welcomed her, she told me that her husband passed away three years ago, and that this would be the first time she would be having lunch with other people. Helen, like everyone who belongs to the Naples Senior Center, comes to us to handle isolation and loneliness. What you are going to hear this evening is not only about the Naples Senior Center. It is about your neighbor who has become isolated and lonely since his wife passed away, and now rarely leaves the house. It is about your aunt or your uncle who is struggling with dementia, and the family caregiver providing the care. And at some point, if not now, it will be about each and every one of us as we age in place in this community we call paradise. Let me give you a little history of our project. When we opened our doors in January 2014, there was no other senior center in all of Collier County. We commissioned FGCU-Division of Social Work to do a needs assessment, because we felt if there was no senior center, maybe one wasn't needed. What the study found, and the dean of the school summed it up by saying, "Older adults are alone and lonely." What we offer are small group activities provided by clinical staff and trained volunteers. Programs such as wellness activities, arts and crafts, educational activities, and what would a senior center be without cards and mahjong? We have a weekly hot lunch once a week where maximum 200 seniors attend. We have the only dementia respite program in Collier County. We have six groups operating in Naples, and we have two in a satellite location on Marco Island. We have been looking for a new home for the Naples Senior Center for more than two years. We had to observe certain parameters. We had to be in a certain geographic area to make it easiest for the majority of our Page 2 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD members. Our largest membership lives in this area. We have over 500 members who live in this district, as do many of our over 200 volunteers. As a non-profit, we have finite resources and must use our resources to support our mission of serving the needs of local seniors. We receive only 3% of our budget from the state of Florida, and that is for scholarships for our dementia respite program. We are supported by generous donors and grants, and we have a responsibility to steward the philanthropic funds we receive. We do not receive any local tax dollars. Now, let me tell you a little bit about the operations of Naples Senior Center. We operate from Monday through Friday, no programs on the evenings or on weekends. Staff professionals are typically the only ones who are arriving and departing during commuting hours, and that represents approximately 25 people. The programs for seniors are primarily scheduled between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m., non -commuting times. Typically, 120 members visit throughout each day. On Wednesday, as I stated earlier, we have a hot lunch for approximately 200 people. Unique to our program is that we require reservations or appointments for all programs that we offer. This slide represents the usage of our programs on a typical week, so you can see the numbers there under each program are the people who attend. Wednesday, of course, has a larger number in the middle of the day. Currently, we all know that we have parking difficulties at our current location on Castello Road. And that's because we lease the space in our commercial building, and we have only 45 parking spaces. We will have ample parking spaces at the proposed center, but certainly not 400. While some members drive, others carpool, take paratransit, or are dropped off by family members. The proposed site is just south of a signalized intersection. Being a good neighbor is at the heart of our site plan. We currently have approximately 13.6 acres under contract. That's four separate parcels that we are proposing to combine through our application to the county. A full five acres will be preserved for open green space. The building can be set back a long way from the neighbors and the roads. The entire site will be surrounded by landscaping and enhanced setbacks, so it blends nicely into the neighborhood. This will be our permanent home. Additional growth will be accommodated in satellite programs similar to the ones we currently operate on Marco Island. I'm sure you have questions, which will be entertained later. That's the synopsis, a snapshot of what we plan to do and here we — and who we Page 3 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD are. And now, it's my pleasure to introduce Wayne Arnold, our principal planner from GradyMinor. Wayne Arnold: Thank you, Jackie. I'm Wayne Arnold. I've seen many of you at other meetings, and I want to welcome everybody. I do want to introduce a couple of people in the room. Ray Bellows, the Collier County Zoning Director, is in the back of the room. He's standing. We love him. And David Weeks, who's with Comprehensive Planning, he's in the front row over here. And they're [inaudible] [00:11:03] staff representatives typically come to these meetings. They take notes so they can firsthand, uh, relay back to other staff members and planning commission members and county commissioners, uh, what's going on in these meetings. Even though, as Jackie mentioned, we do keep a full transcript of the meeting. But, uh, I wanted to make sure we introduce those folks. So, I'm gonna talk a little bit about the land use and zoning applications that we have pending with Collier County. Um, I think we're all familiar with the site location. It's, uh, the area highlighted in yellow. It's about 13.6 acres in total, and all of that will be included in our zoning application, but only a portion of it — about 8.5 acres — is included in our comprehensive plan amendment application. I'll talk a little bit about those, uh, a little bit more. But, so, we have a plan amendment application pending, as well as the zoning application to rezone this to a planned development. The site comprises four parcels, and um, I think that's significant for a couple of reasons, because we have four different tax parcels that four different people could apply for different applications on this. The benefit of our application is it takes all four of those parcels, wraps them into one application with permitted uses, restrictions, etc. that all go along with planned development, including a master plan for the entire site. Uh, right now, the property is zoned Estates. It's governed by your Golden Gate Estates area master plan. We are proposing to change this to a community facility planned unit development, which means it's going to be for a community facility use like the senior center that Jackie described, and other related uses that are part of our zoning application. We're also amending the Golden Gate master plan to create our own sub- district to recognize the Naples Senior Center and talk about those uses, including the restriction to a maximum 30,000 square feet of — of, uh, space allowed for the property. This breaks down, and as we call it, it's our regulatory framework. Page 4 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Because I think there's been some misinformation that the only thing that can be built on these properties are single-family residences. And that's not exactly true. While yes, the Estates allows residential development, the corner parcel — which many of you are familiar with — was and still has an old storage and warehousing building that, um, under the county's regulations is, um, non -conforming use. It carries with that some legal allowances for it to convert to other non -conforming uses through a different process. The unique factor of all these four parcels are that there are permitted uses by right under the county's Land Development Code that allows you to put, for instance, a non-profit childcare center here by right today, on all four of those parcels. So, you could have four potentially non-profit childcare. Would that happen? I don't know. But the code does permit a use like that. Electric sub stations. We've all driven by, uh, you know sub stations. Those are uses permitted by right under the existing zone. A library, sewage lift stations, other uses that are clearly non-residential are permitted by right, and there are a whole host of other uses that are permitted through the conditional -use process which some of you are familiar with that would allow things like churches and other daycare centers, adult daycare centers, and things of that nature. And those require a hearing and examiner approvals. So, I just wanted to set the stage of that regulatory framework we're working under, because if today we could have not -for -profit childcare, I think as is what Jackie's describing to you is another form of adult day- care, not so dissimilar from what could be there today. So, our request specifically is, again, to amend the Golden Gate Area master plan to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building area for senior services on the 8.6 acres of land that's been assembled, and we're going to rezone the entire 13.6 acres to a community facility planning and development. We'll have a master plan with permitted and prohibited uses associated with it for the entire assemblage. Our uses that we're proposing through the — the PUD process allows things that are generally under the SIC Code 8322. Probably means nothing to most of you in the room, but there's a codebook that the county uses that identifies thousands and thousands of use activity codes. But essentially, they allow for activity centers for the elderly and adult daycare centers, centers for senior citizens, and counseling, old -age assistance, group support services for the elderly. So, it's a lot of elder- care related activities that are associated with that. Page 5 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD One of the unique things about rezoning to a planned development is that we can also prohibit certain uses. And part of our initial application was to make it very clear what we're not. We're not a soup kitchen, we're not a homeless shelter. We don't allow any of this residential dwelling. And so, there's no overnight stay associated with any of this. We're not an offender or rehab agency, we're not a social welfare office. We're not a refugee service, and we're not a religious facility or church. So, by going through this process, we can add the prohibitions on these uses. We also had some other prohibited things, like we set hours of operation, for instance. So, we also prohibited weekend use of the property. Jackie talked a lot about us being able to bring ourselves away from property lines and isolate ourselves on the site, and one of the things that Jackie talked about also is the fact that, you know, their target market is North Naples, and they have a lot of their folks that participate in North Naples. I look at it as an opportunity for them to have something more than an office building location. For the activities they had, there's no form of outdoor opportunity for these elderly people to garden or do things that they would like to do at their own home in conjunction with people who are the same age and share a lot of the same hobbies. So, this gives them space, and the open - space area is to utilize for those additional services for the elderly. But this is a table from our, uh, planned development, and we've established minimum setback from Autumn Oaks Lane, for instance, 75', from Oakes Boulevard, 75'. From our eastern boundary, 350', and that's because principally, the area that's, um, east of Valewood Drive Extension would be all —we would preserve for open space as part of this project. And then, we've established another 75' setback from our southern boundary. So, we think we've s- tried to bring the building into the center of the site and, uh, make it disappear from your view. This is a copy of our proposed master plan that goes along with the zoning application. And I'll just point out a few of the —the highlights of this. I've got a colored one, but I'll start with this one. The principle access we envision is Valewood Drive Extension, that terminates at our property. This is the area that I talked about, that I'm highlighting, that this is a 5- acre tract that will be all open space or preserve. We also have preserve that wraps around our southern boundary. We have water management features that we envision to be along Oakes Boulevard, and also along our southern property boundary, which puts the -the building in the middle of the site and well isolated from any of our neighbors or the roads. Page 6 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD This is on an aerial photograph. You start to see, you know, how we relate. And so, the neighbors to the east of us will have preserve and open space adjacent to them as well, with the house to the south. Again, principally we're talking about access through Valewood Drive, which is critical for us, because it is a signalized intersection now, with Immokalee Road. So, that gives us very good access to get to and from not only Immokalee Road, but 1-75, Collier Boulevard, and the other ways that people will be finding their way here from the North Naples area. We have two access points that we're proposing on Autumn Oaks Boulevard. One is at the terminus of Valewood, where the three-way stop is today. And then, another access point where it -it's likely to move a little bit east to west along that frontage, but also another access point on Autumn Oaks Drive that will aid in just internal circulation for the project. This is the rendered version of our conceptual plan that shows you how we envision to have a large open space and preserved area all along our eastern and southern boundaries. We also then — you star to see the elements of the additional onsite landscaping that we have between Autumn Oaks Lane, Oakes Boulevard, and then the various layers that are associated with landscape parking, building perimeter parking, that will have an additional landscaping. And then, areas where we can use some outdoor space to have some outdoor gardening activities for some of the seniors. This is that in the context of an aerial photograph, so you can see how the Valewood Drive access comes directly into our property. Which we think is critical, and you're going to hear a little bit more about that in our direct traffic presentation by Jim Banks. Jim Banks: Good afternoon. Uh, my name's Jim Banks. I'm a traffic engineer in, uh, living in the southwest border for the past 32 years and a resident from the Estates area for the past 14 years. I am very familiar with the Estates neighborhood, and frequently drive on, uh, Oakes Boulevard. And, um, my firm, J&B Transportation Engineering, was, uh, responsible to prepare the traffic impact statement for this project. The, uh, traffic impact statement which we did prepare was prepared for so much of the criteria that's set forth by Collier County government. It follows standard procedures and practices, uh, for the purpose of determining what impacts the project would cause to the adjacent road system. Um, as a part of the, uh, traffic impact study, the first thing we did is we established what kind of traffic the Naples Senior Center generates. And in order to do this, we actually, uh, collected traffic Page 7 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD accounts at the existing Naples Sen-Senior Center on two occasions. Once was in September, and once w- once was in March of this year. Uh, this exhibit here, what this reflects is the, uh, traffic that is generated by the existing Naples Senior Center. On this particular day, we counted on the busiest day of the week, which is Wednesday, since that's the day that the, uh, uh, Naples Senior Center, uh, hosts lunch. And this is the day when, uh, most of the, uh —they have the greatest number of, uh, guests at -at this — at the site. On this particular day when we did the count, throughout the entire day, including the number of people that showed up to the luncheon, there was 242 people that came to the site on this particular day. So, this is by far one of their busiest days of the week, uh, and it did occur during peak season. And what you can see by this, uh, exhibit, is the -the traffic patterns associated with the Naples Senior Center. We have a moderate number of vehicles that trickle in, in the morning. That's the staff and the volunteers that arrive before the guests do. They had some prep work, getting ready for their classes, and that type of thing. So, before 9:00 a.m., if you see this, uh, look at this exhibit, I'm gonna step over these real -real quick. I'll speak much louder, but you can see that just a few folks trickle in before 9:00 a.m. Um, and then, uh, uh, throughout the -the -the midmorning is when m-most of the guests a -and - and the other volunteers arrive, and then actually the peak period of when the -the -the site impacts the adjacent road system to the greatest extent is after 12:30. That's, uh, that's after the lunch ends, that's when most of the folks are — are leaving the site. And you can see, that's the site there in the middle of the day, when the guests are leaving after the luncheon. And then, throughout the rest of the evening, uh, more people trickle out. Again, it's some of the guests that have classes, as well as the, uh, staff and volunteers. Uh, again, 1-1-1 just need to really stress this fact, that this is on the Wednesday that we did the survey, which is the busiest day. Monday, Tuesday, Thursdays and Fridays, well they — they generate about half as much — it's less than this amount of traffic. So, we — when we did our analysis, we picked the most critical time period, which is a Wednesday, and we analyzed the midday position. Audience: Could I ask you a question? Could I ask you a quick question? Jim Banks: Let me finish my presentation, and then — and then, I'll be happy to answer any questions you got. Um, after establishing what the, uh, existing traffic is, or the, uh, site -generated trips associated with the Page 8 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Naples Senior Center, we then went ahead and projected what the traffic — the trips generated by this site would be in the new location, knowing that we would have a, um, uh, slight increase in the number of guests that would visit the site, simply because they had a little bit more capacity — ability to handle, uh, uh, more class activities. Still gonna have the — pretty much the same number of members. The luncheon's going to look the same, but we did go ahead and estimated that there would be a -a -a slight increase in the amount of trips generated by the new site. This exhibit reflects that increase. And again, this is for Wednesday's conditions, and this is what the traffic would look like if you were standing on the site after it's built. You would see this [inaudible] [00:24:27] trickling in the morning, and then you would see the -the bigger push in the midmorning as more people arrived. And then, after the luncheon concludes, then you'd see the -the -the folks actually on the site. And then, towards the end of the afternoon, you would see uh, uh, you know, sporadic people, uh, uh, more a sporadic existing of -of, uh, staff and some of the guests. Uh... We then, uh, moved forward with establishing the existing traffic conditions in the Oakes neighborhood, in and around the Oakes neighborhood. I'm not gonna sit up here and tell you all what the traffic looks like in your neighborhood, because you drive there every day. You know what the conditions look like. Uh, we then take that information and we, uh, and then we assess what the impacts of -of the additional traffic associated with Naples Senior Center would look, uh, or cause, uh, being on top of the, uh, existing pattern of traffic. And -and all this information, again, follows the standard — the guidelines and procedures of -of how we assess these impacts. This, uh, the reports prepared, similar to the criteria of Collier County, was submitted to staff. They reviewed it, and they agreed with the findings inclusions of the report, which are that all intersection and road links that will be impacted by this project currently operate at acceptable levels of service and will continue to operate, uh, at acceptable levels of s-service. And in fact, today, Oakes Boulevard during peak season conditions operates at about 24% of its available capacity. And with this project, there will be an increase of 2%. So, we're going to go from 2-24%, uh, utilization capacity to 26% utilization capacity. Again, during peak season, peak hour conditions. With that, I conclude my presentation, and I'm happy to answer any questions. Page 9 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Jaclynn: At the end. At the end. Jim Banks: At the end, yeah. Does he have a focus [inaudible] [00:26:27]? Wayne: I wanted to jump in and walk through a few more exhibits that, um, we have for the project. And I'll start back with our conceptual master plan, because I think it -it paints a really clear picture of what it is we're attempting to do on the property. But one of the other things that we submitted early on in the process, we had some early small -group meetings with, um, some of your neighbors. We also made a commitment to the county as part of our zoning application that we would provide enhanced buffers along our Oakes and Autumn Oaks Boulevard. So, this an image that we're showing to enhance the buffer along Autumn Oaks. One of the other questions we had asked of us, "What does my drive experience look like?" So, I'll get to that in a second. So, this is Oakes, and you can see in the background that there actually is a two- story building in there. But looking at enhanced landscape -buffering, the - the building essentially disappears. And this is not tomorrow's planting, but this is with maturity on the landscaping. But what we have committed is to have taller than code -required trees from the start, more hedge material, and wider buffers than the county requires. But talking to some of the neighbors, they said, "What does my drive experience look like?" So, this is as you travel east — or, I'm sorry, west on Autumn Oaks Lane. And you can see the church, obviously, in the -the foreground, the stop signs you're all accustomed to, and then the Naples Senior Center back here, tucked up behind, hopefully with a small, tasteful sign. And, um, we're gonna be virtually invisible on your street. . So, this is the southbound view of Valewood. So, Valewood now terminates at Autumn Oaks, but this would — would extend into our parking lot, and you get a sense that obviously you see some building area through the vegetation, just like the church. But also, seeing that a large part of our frontage will remain green after we construct the facility. So, some of my planning conclusions are that I think this is a very thoughtful opportunity to develop this whole 13.6 acres that presents you with a finite picture of what could be there in the future. Not fighting in the future of three or four different allocations that might come along, or other applications you might not have anything to say about, like the nonprofit childcare, or Florida power and light substation, etc. We'll be at large building setbacks, we have enhanced landscape buffers, Page 10 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD more than five acres is devoted to preserve an open space, we're limiting ourselves to a two-story height and a residential form of architecture. We also think that the access to Valewood Drive is critical for this, because it does give us a good, safe haven to go on from Immokalee Road to get people east and west on Immokalee Road via the interstate, Collier Boulevard, or any other communities along the corridor. And again, we've made a commitment that there would be no evening or weekend use of the property. And we have limited the scope of uses that are related to the senior center's mission, as Jackie described. So, those are my conclusions. And I think we're ready to — Tina: Jackie's gonna [inaudible] [00:29:35] Wayne: Jackie's gonna say a few more words, and then we're gonna open it up for questions. Jaclynn: Naples Senior Center quietly has been doing good work. And we will continue to do so, if we become your neighbor. If you just drive by, as Wayne pointed out, you will barely know that we are there. If you come to visit during our primary service hours of 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., we will introduce you to our members, between the ages of 60 and 104. You will see them doing yoga, tai chi, taking art classes, and of course playing cards and mahjong. Our mission is to serve all seniors in the greater Naples area. We would love to serve even more living at Oakes Estates and the surrounding areas. We would love to invite you to join us as volunteers in our work to improve the lives of our seniors. We will make — we will work as hard as we can to make you proud to have Naples Senior Center as your neighbor. Thank you. I know there are lots of questions. Now, I'm gonna turn it over to Tina to field the questions. Tina: So, these are — these are on. So, you guys can use these to answer. Jim, do you want to come sit up by —? Yeah. So, as I mentioned, I know we've had some folks join us, uh, since we got started. There are microphones in the aisles, um, and I believe our, um, the Wizard of Oz back there has turned them on, so they're now live. So, if you come forward, would you please, um, do us a favor? If -if you'd like to give your name, that's great, but even if you don't want to, just let us know where you live, or give us an idea of if -if -if you're in Oakes neighborhood. Because the transcript will re- will reflect who asked what question, and that's just helpful in context for the — our county friends. Page 11 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD So, sir? Would you like to start? Tom: Thank you. My name's Tom Ellis. I'm, uh, a resident of Oakes community. I live on Standing Oaks Lane, and I'm currently president of the Na-Na — uh, Oakes Neighborhood, Oakes Estates Neighborhood Association. So, I wanted to first open by saying 1, personally — and I think everybody on the board, unanimously, and really all the neighbors that I've spoken to are in love with your mission. We -we think that what you're doing is -is fabulous work, and we want to make sure that it continues, but we do question the choice of location in a residential neighborhood for this particular project. Um, there's, um, in my opinion, and I think, uh, my board would support me, and if I had an opportunity to hear the rest of the neighbors talk about this to, but we think it is not consistent with the character of our neighborhood and the direction that it's going. Um, you know, back in — back in the '70s, when this five acres that you're looking at as the corner piece of, you know, you're -you're move to rezone this to a commercial application, um, it was a very different community at that time. And, uh, at that time, there was even plans for Oakes to possibly be a four -lane road connecting Immokalee and -and Vanderbilt, and possibly even going south from there. But at any rate, the neighborhood took a very different direction. And we don't think that this particular project fits in with that direction. I have ae few questions that I would just like to ask about that. Um, first of all, you talked about your attendance and hours, and your current facility is how many square feet? Jaclynn: A little over 12,000. Tom: Yeah. So, you're more than doubling the -the space, and you're building a brand-new facility. And -and 500 more of your members come from closer by this area than where they're going now, but you don't seem to take into consideration that there's gonna be additional attendance, and I'm curious about that. Can you address it? Jaclynn: Yes. We do project there to be additional attendance at some of our programs, and I believe both Wayne and Jim alluded to that. However, the key to the programming at the Naples Senior Center — and this is true for all good senior centers — is that the programs are limited in size, so that an atmosphere of learning, of -of socialization, of wellness activities can be created for the seniors. We plan, like we have done on Marco Island, to address growth in other areas of the county with satellites. Now, we total about 500 members. These are 500 current members. To Page 12 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD give you an idea how the seniors self-select the programs they go to, we have 1,400 members of the center itself. Not everyone comes to programs. Some just like to get the newsletter. The fact that we have 200 maximum seniors come to the center for lunch tells you that, for many people, a crowd is just too big for them. So, our programming will address that question that you're raising, and we will keep the numbers smaller. We do expect there to be an increase. We project that maximum we'll have perhaps 280 people at lunch, but never do we think we'll have more than um, more than that. It's just the nature of the way we program for seniors and what they like. Audience: What if you do? What if -if there comes 500 of them? Tina: Okay, 1-1— I'm just gonna ask that every — keep in mind, you have to come to the microphone to ask any questions or make comments, because it's gotta be on the record. So, please keep that in mind. We won't be able to address questions that are shouted out. Tom: Urn... Tina: And -and I do just want to reiterate one thing that Jackie said earlier. All of the activities at the senior center are required for registration, so it's very easy to control the number of people who attend any one function, because they fill up, and once they fill up then people are no longer able to register for those meetings. So, um, just for the good of the overall, I'll say that. Tom: So, you're saying that you don't see any chance that more than your predicted number would show up? Am I right? Jaclynn: That's correct. And I — that's correct. Because we require reservations. And the seniors themselves want to make plans for them to have. So, that works well for us. Tom: So, I just want to make sure I understand, that you don't have cases where people show up that haven't registered? Jaclynn: We have situations like that, but far fewer than the people who register and don't show up. Tom: Okay. And so — so, you said 240 is kind of your max? Is that — am I right? Tina: 280. Tom: 280? Page 13 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Jaclynn: 280. 280. We project that to be our max. Tina: For one — for -for the Wednesday. Jaclynn: For the Wednesday lunch. Tom: Okay. So-so basically, anything is subject to change? Hmm? Jaclynn: Life is subject to change. Tom: Exactly. Exactly. 1-1-1 agree with you. And in the presentations that were made to our neighborhood, the opposite was said. You're saying — you - you told us that, you know, you're gonna put this facility in that's never gonna change. Jaclynn: No. Tom: And the PUD was supposedly going to fix it that way. And -and we know that that's not true. We know that it's gonna... Jaclynn: Well, with all due respect, I will let my colleagues who are experts in that area answer that question. About — Wayne? Wayne: So, just for the record, this is Wayne Arnold. And going through the question, one of the advantages of having the planned unit development is that we can put controls in it, and they can be enforceable by the county. So, just as we put an hours of operation restriction in here, we've put in the uses. We've allowed only certain uses. There are other operational conditions that we're certainly welcome to talk to you about. We can have a dialogue in the future. I'm not sure this is the right forum to do that, but I'm happy to have a dialogue with your association and any representatives of it. Tom: Well, in all due respect, we've got other PUDs in our neighborhood that are not, uh, complying, and we don't really have any way to -to force them into compliance. So, we've had some experience with this, and that's one of the reasons that we're somewhat skeptical. And I think, uh, I think it's a healthy skepticism. Thank you. Wayne: Anybody else? Dawn Slanec: Yeah, Mr. Arnold? Tina: Somebody over here. Page 14 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Dawn: Who do you represent? Wayne: This is Wayne Arnold, I rep - Dawn: What's your title? Wayne: I'm — I'm a urban planner, and I represent the Naples Senior Center. Dawn: Okay. Uh, first of all, a representative of our area's not here. My name is Dawn Slanec, I live on Golden Oaks Boulevard. I was told from the chief county building inspector that there was gonna be a buffer between us and Saturnia Lakes, that Logan Boulevard was gonna go straight through in the years 2020. Now it's at my backyard, and I can't sleep. So, what's said here and what happens afterwards, two different things. That's what he was saying. And over on the map, it says that the boundary is in the middle of Oakes Boulevard. Does that mean it's gonna four -lane? Because there halfway through the middle of Oakes Boulevard by that turn over there, and the 20' boundary? Type D? What's Type D boundary? Because what we got? We didn't get a wall. There wasn't enough people. We got four palm trees. Perfect. Wayne: Well, I can address one of your comments, and this is Wayne Arnold again. One of the comments you had was on the property line. All of the property lines on Oakes and all the sub -streets, typically along the center line of those, and our buffer and our parking and our setbacks are -are faced on what's the inside of edge of that. So, we own to the center line of Oakes, we own to the center line of Autumn Oaks, but our setbacks and things are applied from the inside edge of that. The landscape buffers we're proposing, we're not proposing a solid wall. I don't believe Autumn Oaks Lane is probably ever intended to be more than a two-lane local street. I'm sorry that you have Logan Boulevard as your backyard, but it is a Collier County large collector road. That was a county decision. We had nothing to do with that, and we'll have nothing to do with the county making [inaudible] [00:40:43]. Dawn: Except that if you make it commercial, then they can four -lane. Wayne: One -zero -nine -five. Dawn: They never even made it so that the buses can pull over for the children that are out there at 6:30 in the morning. When I go to work in the dark, the buses can't pull over, so we all have to drive slower for the buses, Page 15 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD because there's no turn-off. Where is the guarantees in your proposal that it's not a four -lane? And not become commercial? Wayne: Well, it -it is a county road, I'm not sure that I can — I can give you the assurance that the county's never going to four -lane it. I'm pretty sure it's not had any long-range plan to do so, because it's not a through street and it carries so little traffic. Jim Banks: There are — Jim Banks. There are warrant thresholds for when roads get widened and approved. The traffic demand that's on Oakes Boulevard today and projected for the next 30 years is nowhere near, uh, meeting those threshold warrants. Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane will not be four-laned by the county. They do not just go around, willy-nilly, widening roads where it's not needed. They have many more priorities than widening Oakes Boulevard to spend the money on. Dawn: And I'm not on Autumn Oaks, but I know when a development like that is established, there's really big, bright lights. And that's not neighborly. Wayne: Thank you. Tina: Anyone else? Joe Gauta: Hi. Um, my name's Joe Gauta. I live with my family on Spanish Oaks Lane. Um, two things I noticed from your presentation. Um, that area that you have east of the building is a very large, open area. It's concerning to me. And No. 2, as a business owner in this community, and really just as a human being, none of us have a crystal ball. So, prospectively, uh, with that —those two things in mind, could you please answer these following two questions? Can you tell me what you had in mind for that open area east of the building? Because it looks like a very, uh, possibly place to have bands or music or other loud, annoying things. And No. 2, what guarantees do you have on those self-imposed restrictions that you quoted here on the screen regarding your use of the development and the property? What guarantees are there to us as non -owners and non -users of the facility that what you tell us today will not change? Is that — is it going to be in writing? Is it going to be with the county? And what consequences will there be if we, as neighbors, find that you've now broken those promises to us? Wayne: You know, I can try to answer one of those questions to start. The area that's the open space and preserve east of the building area, it's part of the five -acre tract. We don't have definitive plans for that, but I can Page 16 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD assure you it's not meant to be a band shell or an outdoor entertainment area. We have limited the types of uses we can have there as passive recreational -type uses, some garden use of things, some trails and things of that nature. It's all in our PUD document. I should mention, too, that if anybody wants to find the latest application materials that have been submitted to the county, they're on our website at gradyminor.com. You can go to our planning link and -and find them there. Or if anybody would like, you could give an email address to Sharon Umpenhour, who's in our office, sitting right up in the front row to make sure we get the latest information to you. From an enforceability standpoint, the PUD is a — it's a local board, and so it's a local law that gets adopted by the county at full -enforcement authority if we violate provisions of that. So, if for some reason Jackie decided, "You know what? I'd love to have something happen at 6:00 tonight, or 6:15." Because we've limited our hours of operation to 6:00 p.m. on a weekly basis and prohibited uses on the weekend on the document. So, Jackie can't have an, uh, an event there. Somebody's going to call the county, and somebody's going to come and shut that activity down. Joe Gauta: Thank you. Tina: Okay. Yes, sir? Scott: Yes. Um, my — my name is Scott Relf. I live seven doors down on Autumn Oaks from where the facility's going to be. Um, my wife's lived there since '94, and I've lived there since 2003. 1 lost my mother-in-law in 2012 to, um, Alzheimer's, and my, um, father-in-law, lost him four years later at 89 years old. They both lived in -in Cyprus. And probably could've used some of the services you have if it was in the neighborhood. And so, I just wanted to talk about what good — being a good neighbor means to me. And for me, it's — it's more about love and patience, and so I'm gonna talk about my experience living on Autumn Oaks. So, I've got a neighbor a couple of doors down, they have big dogs that bark. And I love that neighbor. And I've got the person next door's got a couple of little dogs, and they sneak under the fence and come bark at my door. And you know, I pick them up and I take them back. And I'm patient. And, uh, we've got, uh, people that drive golf carts on my street, and their kids are riding, and sometimes the kids are driving them. But it's a — it's a nice neighborhood, and we kinda look out for each other. Page 17 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD A couple doors down, a guy's got five peacocks. They're beautiful, but if they're standing in the street anywhere near you, you've gotta wait until they walk out of the way. And then, nature. We've got woodpeckers that peck on our gutters, we've got bears that dig through our trash. And you know, I could have an attitude that I hate everything, or I could just enjoy the —the wildlife and the neighbors. And so, I really am looking forward to welcoming you guys, because I think you're going to be a great neighbor. And I run several times a week. I drive out from my house probably a couple times every day. And for the last several decades, I drive past an abandoned building that probably hasn't been painted in 30 years. It's got broken windows, it's got plywood over the windows, sections of the buildings have collapsed, the roof has fallen down. The fences around the — the property are all falling down. And I think your beautiful facility will be an improvement to my street. I like the church; it's got a beautiful steeple. I won't be able to see you guys but for all the hedges, but it'll still be better than the falling -down fences and the collapsing building. So, I'm looking forward to welcoming you guys. Tina: Thank you. Thank you very much. That's it. Doug Swagert: He was up here before me, so. Tina: You're first? Jonathan Hagedorn: Okay. Tina: Thank you. Thank you. Jonathan: Were those my dogs keeping you up? Tina: Okay. Jonathan: I'm your east neighbor. Tina: Okay. Jonathan: My name's John; I live at 6130 Autumn Oaks. I'm concerned about the five acres. I don't want a three-story facility unless you guys expand and need living quarters, all that stuff. I don't want to have dumpsters in my side yard. I moved to Oakes because I wanted to be in the woods. The churches came in, now they're planning on a medical complex in front of my house. I just don't want to look like I'm in the city. So, I'm kinda concerned about that. And then, as far as the population of your facility, Page 18 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD I'm a contractor. You guys can say 240, 280, 300. What does the fire marshal allow you? What is the maximum occupancy of a 30,000 square foot house? That — or 30 — sorry, I'm used to homes, not commercial. Tina: No, it's okay. Jonathan: But you could have a 600-occupancy limit. Tina: Okay. Jonathan: That gives you full right. Jaclynn: Do you know occupancy? Tina: What the load is? Jaclynn: Yeah. Tina: If you can give you a — or your information, we'll get an answer for you. Jonathan: Okay. Tina: And get that number to you. Jonathan: Okay. Tina: Um, but again, the intent — the — the intent of that -that — the — I — Jonathan: Well, I know the intent, but once the county says — Tina: Is — is registration. Right. Jonathan: This building has a 600-maximum capacity. Tina: Right. Jonathan: Now, that gives you another 400 people that you can squeeze into that building. Tina: Right. And that's — Jonathan: So, 280 sounds okay, but then if you have a capacity of having 1,000 people... Tina: Yeah. Page 19 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Wayne: If -if I could, this is Wayne Arnold. Just to weigh in, I don't know about the building occupancy for a 30,000 square foot building. I think it depends on the use. And I just wanted to remind everybody, I think it's been mischaracterized that this is for commercial use. It's really a community facility, and I call it an institutional use to me. It's, uh, it's certainly not of commercial nature. They have to be in a commercial area now, but it really doesn't suit for what they want to do. But with regard to your question about what happens on the five acres next to you, we have — it's called open -space tract on our master plan. So, it allows for gardens and water features, gazebos, nature trails, and passive recreation uses. We also want to limit it to Tina: That's in the guidance. Jonathan: Well, as long as you — Tina: Yeah. Jonathan: have some sort of hedge. If you give me 75', 100' of natural — I don't want 4' scrub trees that I'll be 72 — I'll be checking into your facility when the trees grow up to mature height. So... Wayne: So, if I could, this is Wayne again. That — Jonathan: Yes, sir. Wayne: So, the area east of Valewood Extension which is shown as either open space or preserve. Jonathan: Mm-hmm. Wayne: So, open space uses, you know, I can put some of our water management there if we need to, to deal with the county's permitting requirements, maybe. But I think you can see that immediately adjacent to you, we have a pretty wide preserve area. Jonathan: Mm-hmm. Wayne: And, um, you know, certainly want to be — Jonathan: Well, like I said, I'm a contractor. I know once you get that property, you're gonna have to take out every exotic tree on that. That's — Wayne: Yeah. Page 20 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and P11-20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Jonathan: Copper hedge. Tina: Yeah. Jonathan: You're gonna be — none of those are going to exist. You're gonna take everything out. I've tried to save those trees, I think there's like two oak trees and like three cypress trees. The rest is copper hedge. So, it's going to open my house wide open. Wayne: The good news is — and this is Wayne again — is that in our building setback from our eastern property line to the buildings, I said 350'; 1 don't have my dimension up there, but we made that commitment in the — Jonathan: Mm-hmm. Wayne: The PUD document. So, we know you're not going to have a principal structure. You might have a gazebo somewhere on that property, or a bench, or some other feature to act as a — a garden structure. But, uh, we obviously have a commitment to preserve the land adj- immediately adjacent to you. Tina: We'd love to sit down and talk with you one-on-one about your specific issues. Obviously, you have a — you know — Jonathan: Well, I mean, you can see my house right there. I mean, I fought — Tina: Right. Jonathan: Tooth and nail to save every tree on that from the county, because I didn't want to come out here and clear my property. I wanted to live in the woods. So, I'm just worried getting rid of all that — Tina: Understood. Jonathan: That it's just going to be wide open. Tina: We don't want that either. So — Jonathan: Okay. Tina: Could we — we'll get your information. Jonathan: Yep. Thank you. Tina: We'll get you information. Thank you very much. Yes, sir? Page 21 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Doug Swagert: I think I should have gone before him, because I basically have the same question, but — Tina: Okay, okay. Doug: Um, the five acres that concerns me, because it's open space — Wayne: Thank you, sir. I'm sorry. Doug: Oh, I'm sorry. Doug Swagert. I live on Oakes Boulevard. Tina: Thank you. Doug: With my family, of course. Uh, I received plenty of room for, uh, detention, water management features. And that looks like a big, empty canvas for future building. So, have you — unless there's something in your — in the documentation for your development where it says you can never develop a tract for building for that, or you can never get some kind of variance to build that. That's a concern. Uh, another thing, I'm not sure if it's still in place, but we already had another DO that's behind my house to the west of me, uh, between my property and 1-75. Is that still in place? Tom: Yeah. Doug: Allen family? Uh, that's something that may come in the future when they, uh, find the, uh, initiative to build that. I mean, it's multi -family residential? Tom: One hundred and sixty-four units. Doug: So, you know, cumulative effect of that going on these roads, and uh, a big concern of mind is I see these kids out there catching the bus, the high schoolers are there at dark, and you've got the middle schoolers and the other — elementary schools, and you have people hauling butt through here. They don't manage — they don't do the speed limit. They don't even do 45. And, uh, you know, brakes lock up as your kid's standing on the corner and they lose control and you end up hurting somebody. So, um, that's my biggest concern. Your facility's much nicer than what's there now, but uh, just, uh, the number of trips? That's -that's a big concern. And that open space, of uh, additional possible buildings wanting to add more people. Wayne: Well, this is the master plan we're proposing with the county, and that will be part of, hopefully, the adopted ordinance. So, in order to change Page 22 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL201800O2621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD that, we would be going back through the process again of where we are today. It's not envisioned, as you heard Jackie mention, they would offer satellite facilities. They think the 30,000 square feet is plenty for them into the future. And again, our document today would not allow us to have any of those senior -service activities on the open -space tract. Doug: That's the scary part. It's possible. Jaclynn: Yeah. Doug: Anything is possible. Wayne: Right. I have —thanks. Doug: Thank you. Peter: My name's Peter Goodin. I live on Spanish Oaks in the same, uh, unit of, uh, Golden Gate Estates. And I wanted to, uh, clarify why you've got a very, uh... Not a hostile crowd, but a — a different crowd for this, in spite of the fact that you're focusing on socialization and relieving isolation in seniors. Almost everybody that lives in my neighborhood who has lived there as long as I have, for 20 years, is anti -social and is looking for isolation. Now, as far as a couple of questions, uh, when I moved to Golden Gate Estates, I moved there for the trees. I'm a nurseryman by trade; I work at Driftwood Nursery. Um... If there were no other purpose, other than open space for the five acres to the east, simply clearing the exotics — and by the way, when you do that, you have to do it in such a way that the trees that are left are not damaged. We see it all the time, but by brining in heavy equipment to take out the exotics, you actually kill the pines, and you wind up with nothing. 1-1 would prefer to see that left as wooded, as it is now. It would certainly work better as a buffer for your neighbor to the east, which is the only residence that you abut. And then, I have a question about the, uh, water management areas. Are those swells for carrying the runoff from your, uh, parking lot? Wayne: The water management areas that are labelled are conceptual. We haven't advanced this permitting through the water management district or Collier County. But conceptually, those would probably be dry detention areas. I have one of our engineers who's doing the preliminary design for work on that. Here, to answer any questions I can, but I'm pretty sure we designed this to be dry detention areas. I know that in Page 23 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD some of the other small -group discussions we've had, it was asked, "Well, why aren't you using the open space tract for water management?" Now, that certainly could be something we could utilize some of that for as an open -space use. But to your point about the vegetation removal, yes, we understand we have to remove the exotics. But, you know, to Dr. Faffer's benefit, you know, to — clearing trees just because they want to clear the trees is a costly expense that they probably don't want to undertake. But with the county's regulations, if I call it a preserve, I have to put in a conservation use, and then that further limits certain uses. She couldn't utilize it for some of her gardening activities, perhaps, or a gazebo, or other things of that nature. So, that's why we made the distinction, really, between open space and preserve. Peter: You're not telling me that the county requires it to be open space? Wayne: No, that's of our doing. I mean, we could have proposed to put a building there as part of our application. We could have proposed to put a parking lot there. We could have proposed a lot of other things. We've chosen to limit ourselves to open space and preserve on that tract. Peter: But it could be that its highest and best use is the one that it's being put to right now, which is just supporting the trees that would insulate you from the one house that you abut. Wayne: That could very well be, but the county has certain requirements for actual preservation vegetation they could put in a conservation easement. So, therefore, we've shown the preserve that actually exceeds the code requirements, and then we've further identified open space. Peter: Uh, if I could just mention one other thing, uh, before I give you the impression that everybody in our group is anti -social. There are seven churches in one square mile of Golden Gate Estates unit 96. The most recent one is the one that would be directly across the street from you, and they were all required to bring their concerns to us. And in no case did the community stand in the way. They did ask for some concessions. Uh... This is one of the most beautiful parts of Naples, and one of the few places where you could live on a piece of acreage six miles from the beach, and that's what people are trying to preserve. Thank you. Wayne: Thank you. Jaclynn: This is Jackie Faffer speaking. To your point, sir, we would welcome the opportunity to talk with the leadership of Oakes Estates, as well as the Page 24 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD other members of the community. We are, um, we would eagerly await a dialogue. Tina: Yes, sir. Tony: Uh, Tony Palladino. I'm, uh, Hidden Oaks. Um... I've got some notes here that are all discombobulated, so hopefully I'll get through this. But most importantly, just as Jackie said, nothing is guaranteed. We don't know what will happen with this. And unfortunately, hindsight is 20/20. Our sight right now has to be based off of what you guys are telling us. Um, and when I say that, we've met before. I sit on the Oakes board. Um, and we've met and had these conversations. The very first time that we met, it was presented to us as an idea that would not pursue — that you would not pursue if you didn't have the support of the Oakes neighborhood. We came back and said, "We don't support it." And you guys said, "Well, we're going to go for it anyway, because we can't afford to go buy some other commercial property." So, you've taken a residential — there's four parcels there, correct? Okay. So, three of those parcels are residential. They're not list stations and electric powerhouses and -and daycares. They have to go through a process to -to become that. But they're residential property. The five -acre property is a non -conforming conditional use. That can't be — run today — as a commercial business, unless it stays unaltered as it is, or minimal changes. Which nobody's going to do. So, this is a process that has to go through, but you can't take one parcel that has a non -conforming conditional use and apply that to the three adjoining parcels, because those are residential. And those should be developed as residential. Um, we're not allowed to run businesses out of our homes that generate additional traffic on our roads. The neighbors will call zoning enforcement, they'll come and they'll, "What are you doing? You can't have deliveries coming, you know, four or five times a day." We can't do that. That's what you guys are doing. Um... You said you have 200 people, and I know this has been like the rest, but what is the cap that you would put into your, uh, your application as how many people you would serve on a Wednesday. I mean, if you're saying, "We don't expect to have more than 250 or whatever it is," cap it. And I liked John's comment about, you know, what's the building capacity? So, that's an excellent point. Because the capacity of that building is what dictates what that building can be used for today and 20 years from now, when you guys move on. I know, "it's my forever home," but nothing's guaranteed, remember? So, Page 25 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD you -you can't broadcast what happens in the future. We deal with this stuff, and we know things change. Somebody else comes in, well somebody else has a vision. Jackie, you're gone. Someone else comes in, they go, "Uh, we've got this other five acres. We should expand this." It's - it's — everything can change. So, it shouldn't change from residential, which is what it is right now. Um... I'd like to know... I'd also like to know, what are your growth numbers from 2014 yearly to today? When we met, you had taken over just the bottom floor of the Castello property. Not when we met, but when you first opened, you had just the bottom floor, a section of it. And the growth was so great that you had to take over the whole building. Now, you have 12,000 square feet. But what is your — what is your growth numbers? Because it seems like you grew very fast when you opened up, and when this place opens up, it's gonna open up to a whole new group of people that don't even know what the Naples Senior Center is. What's that gonna do to your membership? What's that gonna do to our neighborhood? How is the facility going to operate? It's going to grow, that's — I mean, that's the intention of building a 30,000 square foot facility. I think. That would be mine, anyway. Um... Let's see. Oh, that's the other thing. Jim, the traffic study that you did. Jim Banks: Yes, sir. Tony: Was done before the westbound turn lanes from Immokalee to Oakes were closed off, which creates a whole lot more traffic on that Valewood Extension. So, I don't know how —you know, you s-you keep putting your disclaimer on there, "It's to the county's specifications." And I understand that. But we want to deal with reality, not what the county asks us to present to them on a piece of paper. We live it every day. So, I think that's it. I may have more; I may come back. Tina: Thank you. Yes, sir. Mike: Let's start with Mike Vitte. Um, lived on 20 — on Oakes Boulevard for 28 years now. And kinda piggyback on what T-Tony just said. And I'm also a general contractor, building and things. But once 13 acres is zoned commercial, once you have a 30,000 square foot building on your — and I applaud your mission. Everybody does. But like Tony said, 28 years I've been on here, for the next let's say 20 — next 28 years. You're done with it, you've moved on, things happen. It's gonna be a lot easier for the next guy to add onto this property, because it's already zoned commercial. And it is — that's never going away. Page 26 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD That'll be a 30,000 square foot building in our neighborhood for the next 57 years. So, we'll have to live with this, and the consequences, and the whatever happens next on this. And you know, it's just— it— I understand that you -you want to do this, but there's other places that's zoned commercial now, that I think you need to go. Bobbie: Hi. My name is Bobbie Sutton. I live on Autumn Oaks Lane. I have two boys in, uh, Collier County public schools who catch a bus stop at that corner every day. Um, a couple of things I thought of as I watched this presentation. One is I felt like the neighbors were given scare tactics. "If we don't build the senior center here, what will be here?" And scaring everybody into thinking, "Well, a senior center is better than this or better than that." Secondly, you're pulling on everyone's heartstrings. "But we're doing something for the senior population." I have a mother, grandmother, I value seniors and elders, and I certainly applaud your mission. This is not the place to do that. Um, I heard comments like, "Oh, it will blend very nicely into the neighborhood." I don't know how a two-story, 30,000 square foot building can blend into our residential neighborhood. I also heard, "It will disappear from view." Um, disappearing from view, um, with these trees, you know, 30 years from now? Um, it's not gonna ever disappear from view. Um, a couple of other things. We've had properties, uh, Destiny Church is an example now, where when that was approved to be in our neighborhood, it was a church for Sunday and Wednesday night only. Now, that church is occupied 24/7, cars coming in and out, disturbing the neighborhood. Um, it's a real problem. We've learned our lesson. We don't want to deal with that anymore. Um, this will affect the character of our neighborhood, the quality of our life, and most importantly our property values. We've worked very hard to be in this neighborhood. I feel especially blessed to be there, and I'm upset that I just put a lot of money into my house for a remodeling and addition, and that's gonna be smack-dab on my street. You can't tell me that's not gonna affect my property values. Um, your mission is to help the elder population, but I feel like you think because you're doing something good, it supersedes my right as a resident to have to drive past this every day, and to deal with that affecting my quality of life, as well as my property value. Um, also, I live by Station 42. It's a firehouse. That — that needs to go, and that was negotiated with the neighborhood, the neighbors behind it. There was a buffer. Guess what? The buffer's completely gone now. I can see the Page 27 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD entire back of the firehouse. And that was cleared recently. While all those, um, what I think are provisions being made, "Oh, we're gonna do this, we're gonna do that." Well, everybody's forgotten about those, and they just came and cleared it all out, so now I'm looking at the back of a fire station. So, I think that we've learned our lesson with Destiny Church, the fire stations, that all these things can be negotiated, but then people forget. And things change, and properties get sold, or they change hands. And I think that we really need to step back and think about —this is not a done deal, you guys. This has to be approved, and so don't roll over and just say, "Oh, we're gonna let them have it." Tina: Thank you. John: John Nicola, I live on Hidden Oaks Lane, and I'm a member of the board. Um, I also just want to talk— I'm not the last considering, uh, let's just call this what it is, which it's a commercial use within our residential neighborhood, what -what this is. Um, the fact that there were certain commitments that were made, you're saying that you were committing to us, well we thought you were committed to, uh — we were committed to you, and took you at your word through that you said, "If you come — if you don't like this use" in our neighborhood, then you won't be there. Well, we said we —you came to us, and we appreciated that. We came to the meetings, we said no. We — if you — if you guys aren't committed, we won't move forwards. We'll continue looking elsewhere. And I was —that was at the first meeting you guys met with us. Um, in addition to that, uh, you know, I'm -I'm curious about the transportation. Were those measurements taken before the Valewood cut? There's a — there's a Valewood there, but they also cut the left -turn lane onto Oakes Boulevard from Immokalee Road, so I'm curious if those were taken —and you can check on this later, but were — were those taken before that cut the left-hand turn to go south? Wayne: They were before that. John: They were before? Jim Banks: We collected the data when the left -turn from Immokalee was still open. But then, what we did is we — we collected the data then, and then we reassigned to this intersection on our analysis. So, the data that was collected prior to closing that has now been reapplied to the intersection at Valewood and Immokalee, as well as Valewood and Autumn Oaks, as well as Autumn Oaks and Oakes Lane. Page 28 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD John: What -what — ? Jim Banks: So, we modeled that after the fact. John: What's the distance between of the stacking capabilities for cars between, um, the light at Immokalee and Autumn Oaks? Because I can tell you know, with traffic there — Jim Banks: This distance here? John: Yes, that is — how many cars in that stack? Jim Banks: Um, I think it's around 400', if I last recall. We spent many days out there, many hours observing the traffic. Never did we see a situation where vehicles queued up past that intersection, and the intersection queues — John: Well, it queues actually now, because I see that every morning. Jim Banks: Let me — let me — let me rephrase this. When — let me rephrase this, everyone. Please. When we were out there making our various observations, we never saw a situation where the queue stacked up from Immokalee Road back to Valewood. We never saw that. I'm not gonna say that that doesn't ever happen, but I'm telling you when we were out there making the observations, we never observed it, and the recent improvements that they made to the traffic signal, as you all probably are aware, they put in a, uh, directionalized left signal for you because of the conflict with the southbound traffic. And that has since improved that situation, as well. John: One other point, um, right on Immokalee Road, in a parcel that's a little further east of this, uh, called the Southbrooke PUD, I think it's called. It's a plaza, shopping center that would — came to us, and the developer of that shopping center, uh, office park team and said, you know, "We want to be a good neighbor, you know, uh, what would make you happy? What would work for the Oakes Estates? What would work for the folks in Autumn Oaks?" And the comment was, "No traffic in Autumn Oaks." And the only way that got approved with our, uh, you know, as a recommendation for us is if they had access only from Immokalee Road. And -and that — and that was their commitment to us, and they made it and kept it. The -the point we're trying to make is this is — this is encroaching — a commercial use encroaching on our neighborhood, on our residential neighborhood. That's what it should be. Page 29 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Joe Thompson: Hi, Joe Thompson. I'm on English Oaks. I'm a new resident to Oakes. Hold your applause. I love it here. So, I saw this going on. A couple questions. Um, first thing: Would you classify this as consistent with the Golden Gate area master plan? Planner? Because I know the county just went through a restudy, and from what I look — again, I'm not — I'm not an active planner, but I did look through it here that a lot of the conditional uses that were identified along the Oakes/Immokalee corridor were on the Immokalee side, that were ones that were identified as future conditional -uses that would be subject to potential change that would be consistent with what the process was with regard to Golden Gate Estates residents providing their input through that exhaustive process that occurred. Wayne: Thanks. This is Wayne Arnold, and to be clear, we have a pending amendment to the Golden Gate area master plan for this specific piece of property on the corner that would support the senior services use. Joe Thompson: My question was about consistency to the Golden Gate area master plan. Do you feel that this is consistent with the master plan in its current form? Wayne: It is not consistent with the master plan in effect today or the [inaudible] [01:13:10] amendments. But the restudy didn't look at individual properties. This is a site -specific opportunity for us to look at the site and offer up, through a combination of a comp- plan change and the zoning change, a project that we feel is very compatible with the community and keeping with Golden Gate Estates. Joe Thompson: Now with the traffic impacts, I mean, at the end of the day, when you look at it from just a character and suitability/compatibility type analysis and perspective, to me, Oakes is a residential road. At the end of the day. People use it as a pass -through, obviously, from Immokalee to Vanderbilt. But at the end of the day, this is a residential enclave that we live in. Wayne: Yes Joe Thompson: Um, so just to downplay the impact I think is a little disingenuous on your part. Especially considering 1-1 talked to Tom about this standing Oakes PUD that has yet to be developed, which is going to contribute to further traffic on this boulevard as well. And to sort of isolate it to say it's only the Valewood area on Immokalee road — people are going to be coming from the south end, as well, of Oakes. So, that's —that's a guarantee that that's gonna happen. How many parking spaces are in that development? Proposed? Page 30 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Wayne: Two hundred. Tina: Two hundred. Jaclynn: Two hundred. Joe Thompson: Two hundred. So, two hundred. That's — that's a significant amount of traffic. And of course, as people have pointed out, if this is approved and you get the PUD documents approved, there's an administrative process from what I recall in the county where you can do a planned unit development amendment. So, any of that can change. So, once it's here, it's here, and the amendments can happen thereafter. And things that you promise today may or may not get into the PUD documents when it's actually approved. And I know that happened many years ago in the Pebblebrooke shopping center with the Stevie Tomato's debacle which happened. There weren't supposed to be any, uh, restaurants that were serving alcohol. Somehow, they got put into —that wasn't in the PUD documents or transcribed appropriately, and that use was approved. So, there's nothing they can do to go back and change that. So, there's no reason this wouldn't be the same case here. So, I just find that really disingenuous that you downplay that. And on top of that as well, you look at this — is there even w-water and sewer to this property? County water and sewer? Or is it just well and septic, correct? Wayne: This is Wayne Arnold again. Uh, Michael Herrera, our staff engineer, is looking at that issue. He's, uh — Joe Thompson: So, is there water and sewage here? Wayne: Oh, okay, gotcha. Yeah. So, Michael's evaluating water and sewer availability. There is water and sewer that can be extended to the site. That would be our desire to have that. We always have the option, just as you do — Joe Thompson: Sure. Wayne: To have a well and septic system that would serve this — Joe Thompson: Right. Wayne: This project. But our — our priority would be to get water and sewer service to the site. Page 31 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Joe Thompson: Makes sense from a development standpoint. So, the only other question I had was that of all of the other kind of ready -to -go properties in North Naples or in Naples, where is the exhaustive list of other properties that the senior center evaluated that would effectively be turnkey ready from a land use perspective, from a traffic absorption perspective, and from a character and compatibility perspective? Just... why didn't you look at those other properties first? Why come to Oakes Estates and come a block in, where the only other amendment to the Golden Gate master plan as it occurs has been on Immokalee Road corridor? Wayne: Right. Joe Thompson: So, this is a big deal, folks. This is — this is a — Jaclynn: We had a representative — Joe Thompson: This is an amendment right here. Thank you. Thank you, because we have planners at the county that I know are very competent. All disclosure, I know a planner personally, David Weeks, who's a very good planner, um, and I know he looks at this in-depth, the comprehensive planning. He's the gu- the guru there at the county. And it goes through a public process, so everybody will be involved in that process. Planning commission, Collier County Commission, etc. So, thank you. Jaclynn: We would like — Tina: She says if you like, we can answer your question. Joe Thompson: Yeah, go ahead. Sure. Jaclynn: Well, we would like to answer your question. Joe Thompson: Yeah. Jaclynn: We have a member of our board of trustees here, and um, he will address the question about the turnkey properties from the fiduciary responsibility of a board member. John Passidomo: Afternoon. My name's John Passidomo. I'm a member of the board of directors of the, uh, Naples Senior Center. Have been for probably four or five years now. So, I've enjoyed, uh, participating and seeing, uh, these dedicated use, and being engaged in this process. Jaclynn: John, is this — Page 32 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Wayne: Is there a mic on you? Joe Thompson: Yeah, mic is off. John Passidomo: It is on. Can you hear me? Wayne: There you go. Jaclynn: Yeah. John Passidomo: I'll speak up a little closer. [inaudible] [01:17:28] We've actually been engaged in this process for two going onto three years, so we've looked at a broad range of possibility. But part of what we need to do as we work our way through the process is reconcile our, uh, limited resources as a non-profit, for our fiduciary obligation to expend those resources in a responsible way to achieve our mission. Our mission is to serve the needs of the area's seniors. And we cannot afford commercial properties in commercial shopping centers, because we cannot do that with the resources that we have and the mission that we need to achieve, and the future obligations that we have to get there. Uh, this is the only way we can do what we need to do. We've been looking, we've had uh-uh-uh preeminent, uh, commercial developers working with us in this effort. We've looked at a broad range of different possibilities, uh, some of which were, uh, for commercial use only. And the fact is, we couldn't afford to do that and continue to do what we do on behalf of our mission. Joe Thompson: Correct me if I'm wrong; I read something that the Naples Senior Center raised over $10 million in donations. Is that incorrect? John Passidomo: [Inaudible] [01:18:451 that is —that is absolutely correct. Joe Thompson: Okay. John Passidomo: We're very proud of that. Joe Thompson: So, I guess — John Passidomo: And the fact is — Joe Thompson: Okay. John Passidomo: We want to expend those monies — Page 33 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Joe Thompson: Right. John Passidomo: To achieve our vision. Joe Thompson: Sure. Jaclynn: At our expense. Joe Thompson: But okay, I'm — I mean — Jaclynn: At our — at our expense. Joe Thompson: Correct me if I'm wrong. So, can you or can you not find a comparable sized property within this general vicinity — I say 'general' within a few miles of where you guys are proposing — for $10 million or less? John Passidomo: If we could, to do what we want to do — Joe Thompson: Right. John Passidomo: We wouldn't be here. Tina: It's not a magnet. Jaclynn: But if we could've found something — Tina: I'm sorry. What's that? Jaclynn: We might be able to find somewhere else. Tina: Well, you'll need to —you'll need to come over here. Joe Thompson: Yeah. Thanks. Tina: And I — yeah. I just want to make one thing super clear. That the capital funds made are -are not just for the land, but is also to build the facility. So, we've got just a few more minutes. I want to make sure we have everybody — give everybody a chance. Fifteen more minutes of official time here, then we can answer questions one-on-one. So, yes, ma'am? Tammy: Hi. So — can you — ? Tina: Yeah. Tammy: Can everybody hear me? Page 34 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Tina: Your name please? Yes. Tammy: Okay. My name is Tammy Samuel. My husband and I, um, live approximately, uh, four parcels away from, um, the end of Oakes Boulevard. So, we will be very much affected by the senior center. I'm not taking away from your purpose, um, but I'm just going to outline some of the things that we haven't mentioned today, um, that, you know, is obviously of concern to all of us that are living in the area. Um, you mentioned that you have 500 members, but you only have room for 200. So, when you said you have 500 members but you only have 200 parking spaces, and you have a maximum... So, that's not very logical to me. So, it — it looks as if maybe at some point in the future your satellite offices can't accommodate some of these people, that the senior center around the corner from my house might be. Um, my — we -we have two children, uh. One guy's a senior, and the other one is attending Gulf Coast High School. And when you come off of Oakes Boulevard, you're going to be using Autumn Oaks Lane to get to Gulf Coast High School. I use that, um, two to three times a day, if not more, because my son's in band. Uh, we're looking at about approximately what your plan says about a year of construction. So, when I get to the end of my street, I'm going to be grossly affected, because there's going to be tons of traffic and obstruction to get to Gulf Coast High School. Um, there's 2,400 children that attend Gulf Coast High School, and families that are using Immokalee Road already from all the other developments. So, it's already a very, very busy area. So, then, to put a commercial center in a residential center is going to affect me — my driving time, it's going to affect my kids, it's going to affect a lot. My kids are new drivers. Now, I'm going to have a new driver with a permit and a driver's license driving, right? They're seniors. That's not good. Um, the — I guess the major thing for me is the traffic impact and our property values. My husband and I have a pretty sizeable house on that street, um, and we've worked our whole lives to afford it. And this is going to majorly affect us. So, not just us, I mean all of us. And from our point of view, you know, while we appreciate what you're doing, we don't want it around the corner from our house. Jaclynn: I think this other man was up. Tina: Right. Excuse me. Page 35 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Tivis: Hello. My -my name is Tivis Nelson, uh, I live at Longshore Lake. Uh, I have some experience with um, watching these things and close to places where I live. I've been here for a bunch of years. I've got kids that live in the Oakes. They moved from Indigo Lakes into the Oakes. And, uh, this intersection right here at the northwest corner of the property at, uh, Autumn Oaks and Oakes Boulevard? Uh, if I had a nickel for every time I have stopped at that intersection, well I could take us all to eat at a pretty nice place. And that piece of property has been a sale — for sale for years. And nobody has jumped in there and said, "Hey, let me spend my money and make that a little prettier." I — even as a minor developer way back in my life, thought — I was thinking about that property itself. But you know, when I saw this, I would describe that intersection that I just described. The views of life from there are ugly. That's all I can tell you, just that that's an ugly intersection, and the time I've spent there, I have bitched the entire time hoping something nice be doing. Now, if you could take the motorcycle shop with you, that'd be good. But you know, when I saw them, I saw the small number of people that you think go through there. Even if it's understated. I mean, from my point of view, paradise was close by. If y'all put that up and hold onto what you say you're gonna do, uh, my view of life will be improved, and my kids who live in the Oakes and they're —they traverse this intersection up here many times a week. I'm talking I'm a bet 30 times a week. And so, I appreciate the fact that at least it looks a lot better than what I might've expected to go there. Good luck with it. Jim Trullinger: Hi, my name is Dr. Jim Trullinger. I live on English Oaks, and I'm against this thing for a couple of reasons. They're kind of anecdotal impressions that I've had. One is the general area of Mission Creek. Now, many of you addressed this tonight in terms of the set forth objectives maybe being pushed later on after the thing's built. And it reminds me of when I was living up in New York City, about 25 years ago. In my neighborhood, there was a big community meeting, the last one like this I went to. A big developer was there, and he was pushing building some apartment buildings. I stood up at the time. I said, "Can you assure us that there will be no Section 8 housing built in this thing?" He said, "Oh, don't worry. No problem." Well, guess what? There was. And it just went through, and now the neighborhood is declining, and it's uh, it's unfortunate. The other concern I've had is one that's based on something that involved Page 36 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD my mother. She lived for years up at Shell Point Village in Fort Myers. And she told me that just about every week, there were instances of Alzheimer's patients walking around that property and getting into the neighborhood, and knocking on doors and causing disruption. I'm concerned about your losing control of what's going on in your facility, and these types of things happening. Jaclynn: I'd like to address that point. Jim Trullinger: Sure. Jaclynn: This is Jaclynn Faffer. This is not a residential facility, nor is it an all -day daycare facility. The respite programs that we have are four hours, from 10:30 to 2:30, with a maximum of 12 to 14 patients with dementia, and a staff ratio of five people, five staff people and volunteers. And the people with dementia have to qualify for this level of program. No. 1, they are not wanderers. No. 2, they are always within a secured room, and they are picked up at the door by their caregivers. The -their — the facility you're talking about at Shell Point has a significant special area for people with advanced dementia. The people we see in our program have early to mid -stage dementia, so there would not be any wanderers. Jim Trullinger: Well, I hope you're right. Jaclynn: Teach them. Jim Trullinger: I know Shell Point has a tremendous staff. Jaclynn: I wish we could be like Shell Point. Jim Trullinger: There's still, uh, issues. So, and then there's the issue of you've got groups of people coming in, and maybe they're with you for a year so. Then, they begin to slowly slip. Who determines whether they can continue? Jaclynn: Our professional staff. Our professional staff determines that. They are licensed, they are credentialed, and there are many times that we have, um, discharged people from our program. And at that point, they usually go into a facility. Jim Trullinger: Okay. And nothing that I've heard has changed my mind. Jaclynn: Okay. Jim Trullinger: Good luck. Page 37 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Tina: Thank you. Okay. Yeah, we're gonna just take two -two more questions, and then if you have other questions, we can take them at the end. Steve: I was here. I was here. Tina: Okay, okay. Steve: Okay. My name's Steve Bracci. I'm an Oakes Estates resident. My neighbor — my property touches the southeast corner of your property that you're proposing this project on, okay? For starters, I'd like to know how many Oakes Estates residents only are here. Raise your hands? Okay, there's, um, several dozen. Now, I'd like for those folks to raise your hand who are Oakes Estates residents that support this project to raise your hand. Oakes Estates? Male Speaker: I didn't raise my hand, so no. Steve: You just — okay. Male Speaker: No. Steve: So, let the record show there's maybe out of a couple — several dozen people that have raised their hand, there's maybe two or three people that raised their hand supporting this project. And let's let the record reflect that. Um... Ms. Faffer said that you're stewards of your philanthropists' money. Mr. John Passidomo said that there is a fiduciary duty to spend your p- your p- your donor's money correctly. I'm astonished and astounded by the admission by John Passidomo that this — he needs —you need to build it here, because it's the only property you can afford. The reason why this is the only property you can afford is that it's not appropriately land -used, and it's not compatible. It's in the middle of a neighborhood. I'm — no, I'm not done. Tina: That's fine. Steve: I didn't — Tina: I just wanna — I just wanna say that that's not what was said, that this is the only place that could — could go. It's the only place that met the parameters — Steve: He said — I think he said this is the only way. Tina: Right. Page 38 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Steve: 1-1 took those notes down. I could be wrong. We'll check the — your -your transcript against my video of this, and we'll see how it is. Tina: All right, Mr. Bracci. Steve: Okay. Tina: Will do. Steve: And then — so then — th-this gets to the whole point of this. This whole thing is political. You wouldn't have a chance — a snowball's chance in Hades getting this project through if not for the political wins and the political favoritism. That's why Ms. Faffer started her presentation talking about this greater good need, making us seem like heartless people. This is a land use issue about compatibility. The gentleman who stood up here earlier and stated that we're all antisocial in our neighborhood and we're all isolationists, and everyone laughed, everyone laughed because — but they knew it was true. You're destroying that character with your proposed project. Now, it -it — that — that's — so... Th-the reason you're supposedly being fiduciaries is you're going to take a property that should not be up -zoned and land use up -zoned, and you're going to get it up -zoned. And you're doing it with Mr. Passidomo, who's not just a trustee, but he's also an attorney in downtown. He's well-connected, his wife is a state senator. He's in favor with the county because he got this $0.01 sales tax approved or he worked on it. It — you — y-you're a political [inaudible] [01:32:06]. Tina: Sir, that's — it's really inappropriate to [inaudible]. Steve: Well, it -it -it's just — I'm making a point. Tina: It -it's [inaudible] [01:32:121. Steve: I understand that, but it — I — it — I — I'm building — I'm building — I'm building to a point. I'm building to a point. Tina: Really not appropriate. Steve: I'm building to a point. Tina: I'm sure you are. Steve: Because to get a land use changed requires four votes out of five. To get a PUD change later on once they get this land use, it requires three votes Page 39 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD out of five. Now, that PUD could be amended by three out of five people. So, when Mr. Arnold stands up there, when you folks stand up and say, "Oh, we — we're protected by a PUD," yeah, you are, but in this case, you guys are so political and so politically connected that when you want to go and change because you have some future need, we're un- we're exposed. If you folks were truly going to commit to what your future uses would be, and Ms. Faffer said this is a permanent use, if you would permanent restrict file — record a restrictive covenant in the public records that says any resident of Oakes Estates can enforce the restrictions that you agreed to. And if you don't want to do that, then everything you say here is disingenuous. I'm not suggesting that you get that project in — on that basis, because I'm opposed to it, like all my neighbors are. Or almost all my neighbors. But this is political. The other thing: Valewood? It's not some kinda collector road that's coming off of arterial — o-o-o-off of an arterial road, Immokalee. That - that road is a workaround. The only reason it exists is because Oakes Estate — Oakes Boulevard used to go north, and had a traffic light. We're too close to the interstate, so we had to close — first they — the -the traffic signal came out, and they had to put in Valewood because otherwise you couldn't get out there if you lived in Oakes. Then, they closed the one median. Then, they closed the other median. So, Valewood as it is, I mean, it's dysfunctional as it is on that north end coming out of Oakes. You guys are just adding gas to the fire. They're gonna — we're gonna come around that corner, you got — and soon as we turn to go this way, we're gonna run into an i-i-ingress/egress point for you guys. That traffic light's gonna stack. That — Jim, you can look at that — that left — that left turn — that left turn signal, the northbound left — west? Maybe three cars can get through there now? Audience: Maybe. Maybe. Steve: If -if the county — if this is a project for the greater good, I'd ask Mr. -Mr. Bellows and Mr. Weeks to go back to their transportation department and say, "Guys? Are we willing to commit to extending that greenlight during peak hours?" And make the whole county feel the impact of this project, and not just Oakes Estates. Because then you're saying, "Okay, so now you've got the major east -west Immokalee Road corridor that everyone knows is over capacity, everyone knows is overloaded. And you're putting this use in there. This belongs at a commercial activity center with — on two arterial roads Page 40 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD coming together, and access under both arterials. That's where this belongs, not in the middle of the neighborhood. Yeah, the reason why Oakes is still — Oakes Boulevard is 24% capacity in the middle of the day is because it's in a freaking neighborhood. It'd be like going to [inaudible] [01:35:26] Like going to Palm River Estates and looking at Myrtle -Myrtle Road and High Ridge and say, "Hey, look at all this capacity here. Let's take these couple residential properties and land -use change it to an institutional use with -with peak hours." It makes no sense. The county has made — back in '97, when Destiny Church — or what used to be — went in, if you could look at the notes, 1-1 think actually, uh, um, Tim Hancock was on the board at the time. And there was a discussion about Oakes. They talked about how that church can go in, because not only was Oakes B-Boulevard four-laned at the time, there was a plan for Oakes Boulevard to go all the way through to Bonita Beach Road. That didn't happen. Oakes Boulevard used to be 45 miles an hour. It's been reduced from 45 to 35. Why? Because it's a recognition of the change. This is now our neighborhood. They are not even at the perimeter of our neighborhood, they're coming into the heart of our neighborhood. Why did Oakes E-Estate spend so much time with Southbrooke Medical Office to buffer the south end, to make sure that all the access was on Immokalee Road, and everything south was buffered and gonna be buffered you know, t-to — so that we couldn't see them and didn't have to impact them at all? Why did we do all that on the south end of that project if only to have this project come in and spill now south of Autumn Oaks? B- and here's the thing. In your— in that comp plan report that Mr. Arnold drafted, it says, "Well, we're not gonna create a domino effect. Nobody else will be able to go — a — latch on to what we're doing." Well, I hate to tell you, this is the domino effect. It's the domino effect off of Immokalee Road. Yeah, you put non -conformity uses along in there because they have a hardship. This isn't a hardship. They're spilling south. And I'd ask that the county also look at the representations Mr. Weeks — or, Mr. Arnold has made, about whether this is a legal non -conforming use, or whether it's expired or not. And is there a factual basis for that? If there is a factual basis, I'd like for the county to get back to us to tell us what the factual basis — is it — is it just the case that they were once commercial? Or are there other factual presumptions? And if so, what did the county do to assure that those factual presumptions were met? Thank you. Tina: Sir? Okay, thank you very much. Thank you very much. Page 41 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and P11-20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Marylin: Good evening, uh, my name is Marylin Vonseggern, and I live in Longshore Lake. But I'm not here to really discuss the property. I'm here to discuss the senior center. Um, I drive twice a week to the current property. Um, my experience with this organization is so positive, um, that I think — and I'm not trying to tug at anybody's h- anybody's heartstrings. I'm talking about the integrity and the courtesy and the, uh, respect that this organization treats the, uh, the resident — or the members of the organization, the caregivers, the people that provide the transportation. Um, even in the busiest times, which are really only once a week for a couple of hours. Um, they have several young men who go out of there to make sure that everybody who has a vehicle and is staying with their vehicle is parked. They help people in and out of their cars. The volunteers, they're extraordinary. Um, and they protect the neighborhood. We get notices from them, because it is a residential neighborhood right across the street. And they let everybody know who attends this center or drives to the center for whatever reason, uh, what they can and cannot do in the neighborhood, and they protect the people who are residents nearby. Uh, my husband attends several of the events and, uh, I see lots of people there. And I cannot tell you, I have seen very few organizations like this that have — do such great services for their members, and have such sensitivity to everybody involved. Um, my feeling is for those residents who are concerned — and I know you are, and I appreciate that, because, um, they put Palazzo right behind my house. So, I've been through this, and — many times. And I know what it's like to have concerns about new things that come to your neighborhood. But I would tell you that if these ten — people tell you they're going to do what they're gonna do, I believe they will. I think they're an outstanding organization. Tina: Last question, then we'll need to wrap up. Michelle: Um, I'm an owner — Michelle Bracci — on Hidden Oaks Lane. And I came in late, so I didn't have the benefit of hearing what everyone else spoke about. But, um, I wanted to talk to one of the bullet points that was in your postcard that was mailed out. And that was that you guys, um, are advertising your services as being Monday through Friday, 8:00 — or, 9:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. Um, I took a few minutes to look on your current website, and I see daily services Monday through Friday that begin at 9:00 a.m., and are scheduled until after— a start time after 3:00 p.m., Monday through Friday. I also saw there was one occasion of a scheduled Saturday Page 42 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD event. I have a screenshot of it, if you'd like to see it afterwards. Tina: Yeah, let's see it. Michelle: Um, so it raises multiple concerns. 1) if you have a start time at 9:00 a.m., you don't just have a handful of employees who need to gain access to your facility before hours, but you also have a population of seniors and their caregivers who are going to be traversing Oakes and all of the streets around the facility to get there in time for the event that starts at 8:00 — at 9:00 a.m. And that's a huge traffic impact in our area. Um, anybody who works or takes the kids to school in our neighborhood, knows that our streets are already packed with traffic. So, that's one issue. The other issue is, um, there's a special screen on your website that talks about special events. So, you're currently, it looks like, using other facilities to host these special events, which are weekend and after -hour evening types of, um, get-togethers. And they seem fairly large in scale, and there are multiple ones that are listed and go back on the calendar. Um, those certainly aren't Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. They're after-hours, and it reminds me of many of the issues that we had dealt with in our neighborhood with Destiny Church, which started as a restricted -use, you know, small number of worship times, and has expanded to a Monday through Sunday, any hour of the day, um, facility. And it's very disruptive to our neighborhood. So, I would just like to say that I don't want you as our neighbor. I think the service is probably better located in a high -intensity commercial use somewhere else in our county. It's not that we're a neighborhood of residents and owners that don't have compassion for this type of social service, but it's not being presented in the right location. And I ask that you please take that into consideration and -and look at other locations which are much more appropriate. Jaclynn: Thank you. I would like — I would like to address your comments about, um, off -site programs on the weekends. Yes, we do have those, and those are major fundraising events. And those are held at country clubs or golf clubs, and they would — they would never be held on our site, because we'd need catering, we need upscale, uh, venues. So, that's what your — we need, that would hold 300 people. That's something that is not part of senior center programming. When you see something at 9:00 in the morning, we do have individual appointments with clinicians at 9:00 in the morning. Senior center programming never starts at 9:00, and the last program is at 3:00. That's because we can't accommodate them earlier, they don't want to come Page 43 of 44 Transcript (09-25-2019 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and P11-20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD here earlier, and they want to get on their way. If you come to our parking lot, you — or our current facility, which I invite you to do, you will see that it's empty at those hours. Yes, please do. Thank you. Tina? Tina: All right. I'm just gonna say this for — for the record, that this um, gonna be the official end of the neighborhood information meeting. We really appreciate everybody being here. If you'd like to talk further, please let us know. We have a website: newnaplesseniorcenter.org. There's a comment form on there if you have questions that you'd like to present, or comments that you'd like to make and send those to use via that form. Um, we look forward to being in touch with you. Oh, I'm sorry. We have a county representative here who'd like to speak for a moment. David: Hi, uh, I'm David Weeks with the county's, excuse me, county's comprehensive planning section. I just want to make one factual correction. Uh, Mr. Bracci had mentioned that for the PUD zoning, uh, it would only take a three to two vote. Uh, that's incorrect. It does require a four to one vote, the same as the comprehensive planning limits. Tina: Thank you very much. Good night, everybody. [End of Audio] Duration: 105 minutes Page 44 of 44 Petitions P1.20180002621.. Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD September 25, 2019 Neighborhood Information Meeting radyMinor Project Team • Dr. Jaclynn Faffer, President/CEO - Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. (Applicant) • D. Wayne Arnold, AICP, Professional Planner - Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. • James M. Banks, PE, Traffic Engineer - JMB Transportation Engineering, Inc. • Michael T. Herrera, P.E., Engineer - Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. • Tyler King, Biologist - DexBender Environmental Consulting • Renee Zepeda, AIA, NCARB, LEED AP, Senior Architect - Stofft Cooney Architects • Dwight Thomas, Board Member - R.E. Development Manager • Tina McCain Matte - Gravina Smith Matte & Arnold • John M. Passidomo, Board Member - Naples Senior Center 2 10 NA PLES E, x 10 CENTER A NF.W IERA FOR SENIORS Dr. Jaclynn Faffer President/CEO Naples Senior Center 3 a E 'Al c r L� io~ r 4k Ilh lw At� 10 y bp — rig Alr ILI Al fqr � ' * it #**#Noit I 11 ■ a 19 Activity Schedule (Feb. 2019) M on 1,110 --- W&F_ --T-Ku-rs Fri 4:5414.I.L IM.. e! 1. ['Ld 114) iF.iS.il: u riie: 5..e d�onirh:. 1WLtlIN: LIUWOft 1%4] W)MII: L:.pl.r,aur Jh .. ,Nd !I &ILI5_1r tiir.rri iIJL%hC 4Ya{ Vd1 1.JIU:54: %I h J. I-- I1� 4)L&MAn4km% 5}ihlFIk1kLWOh.x 41...' fa) hH.IftmrL4hure 7)MLrMFs4.7ik UW1611k LW. IFTdOiM4 MIUMC.i. L.n, N.dn 9AM 1.0. SFr. t'.1w II.I. L�.6 a R1..r �J S..iL,..J W. :10W:IMi:o Ti- IFIF.Ix.*,16%. Ad da ykl14 im,I"'..rh.ir511. rk1?-\rrrr11" vr.dim II:ILrrll-w.U.A.JII- i6LA I:YkraliMfk ri � J. M5 *. h.Uklb M.- ILM I I.M. �i.4a['w.n.riw .J Ii.1Mi{' J4okd�o. I I TLIM n,.1 rk.i..,.p6, IhA.lxi 6.rl.rr?..r 11.r�ilFa.l IiI Li %Mk p.lr 13Aii {L�gAM'64h,� , 12.L RIw B& n ili7i.ILYd!ir.Yr!hrceY Y7-' IIJ�F. Zip 4 k P.r : N I" I_Y�-MS 1Ydb .17 . r.4.11..r 1ik M 1-1:I5: 14_'R G. _d i .rd. 1114Ia5iffi eModm 3WAn" 121 legWm" kim Lpawft J 64 M*1 111h JIM 1424) YS42_rk5.i i.i T.. i=Y}-i:15: 8rr.. w.m 46rzde '-a: L_m Leo P.ri, iJY J�F wee IJr 15r.,. h* iJk u Aff'e u Nk" Mem*h 11)1Y12n.A t.w 12}4I4MA: Y\ rr4o r L&II k: F.nmar.h 1A)I&I k-M: far. i. l.her 1ij 4ii iwi4i. .,. T>f-W ICIII493itiphxilh6nvlx IILLI,'-&1LuV 1b1[L=e*mil m WCiwk 16M.11AFCgT1r 1iti1E�12i78rlrl4i 5n.r�}ie� IWIAS_CkirI . eRIkIYj ..Sp iJdiw•r L..Y 1,lj ..C�oxnbd- II:15ALTnr.YHr"r>pl.. :*LW:1:ei_raii&i0-ITal 11.12145396PAENgh�erdr. 1I.LiSeei Mm dMil6iNti � 12.1if�Ln OM. 21Eipkeyi.rLlw. j"1hd fa: Mi is Qse,i Yi_FIIjF. Lip a nk P.n,: JI I42i i_Y}t:15: rnr.Ylr.irh J6LSn i� i,t:iS: V' _: P-.Lk. 1%lr} IYj4ILYS_.r wrrirh -Ii-r 1L h,. rd.Jw.-if y1I42 7ks Hrfro I,Z:I5: {'.air�5'.krrir� ua,[d. 'a.R.. 1,131: Q__d C.d. .rJl.o.er&&.6g" M. YL,Y.I:iS: Wr L..kk.L , 1-2: Rro-L k1-Tb.6, ia4.5:.'i: 51.h J..ql I - I." 1:15 k1h AMI. ftim 1i< kk., 2,1: Ii- L6-i.E Y:jil.l-Yl-r.1M T- 2LFiji_ M. irrr', MwL. w+ir..iry 1j45-A e� L: M-6.0 141&M. Ww" 1NIJILH-.a.rCbw 19)%,j,�A:WCh. 2DJ*L)Mkmmr6irL'," 21111LiYiY:Far.r.r.bLr 721Tjmmm..Ir..4rirwI" IC111i53Cti.p6MMhCMndx ULkSmbW.rb 1ltlisi.l.i`.reWnY 161k16FFCAt�TIr IMIS-121WeYhWheliSMffy*ft INIJS:{1�}q. 14.lkI1jF. i.r i{'w,rw.riw r5 IFll: erai. [:a:.+S wLa1q II:IS-Ir7r�..1 Lt.rgr.pk. 14-j411:15_ial{11IdiI1 idiMein511d56.r} 1I.Li%ndkhin 1L.IL� wdMw RWnri. exrh.p 1I.LMwhrim 11hL12iEipkne,mrkdw.ei.i1hd IIWil-W.. ]Lip I r.k F.n,: 34 I U, I,Z34:("". i+i•i.nir I,Z:I5:{'. �.i.r: iwl, U.. k.1 I IL)LIMS_ 1r�. tiir.rrh Sillh# 3 41-65 1.I !�:55. lem. 6.I1,.k6 h.v.,.iir. I,Z: Rr'� Li. lb.. 1-J q: {:L- _d { vd, YI-.kl:ei- n..r fl kL- zJ: Irrr.rdi.er I-lraa f i,2:)k: C_o I-, 4e41 Y,LJI_i.hl l.h 2a41.3L%%. W.', uwkdw - J. I-- I" I:M42-LW it hi T.. J64: Mrwrt I1ir[..L 1_.433k yii..4 Lhw C6. ?ij Lilx-n. ne 26)*.041A&.%weCir 27) ipwim.ksrhrrhrrier 28) LIUkLM:F-r r.hk iQ S ['�si�plln Ilrit'p ,C11,453cmpkw5LhF..uefw LOLIE MM&W.rb 4hWjJJ1ki?1i MrdkM(Vohr41b 16wil"C,Tim Ni IFR,Y1. 341Q3 r 14f I A5.I h.i. Ste. 0lFser&w iILLEW E-W S-k. p> ypt} 11AFL Xe-A FIMM..pk, IIJ2iii_hw.,L LkMLid Spm6hhlC4.Vn=kM*4 1L-11A*BWFMM1i 5appr.1 12.11MwLoim 2Y)-32!L�44 1-3: M5 ir:{1w.d YiA:-*.dkPid ::6Wlld>w!}CtPwipA41W IL-1_La..6-dkL--371 r•i.., 1,1:15:{'. H..-11I..j� -Ib--MLr.rd. dw..xi..'f 1-JJW.C-.p uA.id- I,Z:Ika�U-Lk... ,,a��. 341IT. U11ii}JYli i-YLl:ii:r�.r., 2.5:lwrr..Vi U..lea.x ILIkl:IS_5-Ead- I:1":15:1 Y. Q; 4 wr.o._ Ilwiw, dr E. 2aF-0j!W.iv'. A'.si,1.p M........ Y:)ILI-.k!rr.1 i tl r.. .yra. Aa }J: RdMLw-e 2j45aF IA^. Ls D._ Pre -registration required for all programs • Shuttle service available 20 Daily Activities JFCS Senior Center Tox_ QQ Tuesday, February 5, 2419 + Tuesday, February 5, 2019 9:30am Life Story Class #7 9:45am Water Color 10:30am Needle Works 10:30am Spanish & Conversation 11:00am Learn to Needlepoint 11:30am Zip Code Party: 34109 12:30pm Bonebuilders 1:30pm Tai Chi Two 2:30pm Beginning Line Dancing Wednesday, February G, 2019 9:313am Choir Practice 11:30am Lunch and More - Richard Watts & His Accordion 1:01)pm Computer Assistance 1=01)pm Collier County Sheriff (by Appt.) 1:15pm Dream Team Meeting 1:15pm Maintain Control of Your Life - Part 3 Thursday, February 7, 2019 10:30am Farm to Table 10:00am Guy Time 11:15am Newbies Social Hour 11:15am Travel Photography Events shown in time zone: Eastern Time - New York Featured Programs Mondays Movie Madness — Movies of just about every genre are shown every Monday afternoon. Art Classes — Instruction In still life, abstract and ffber art is provided on Monday mornings by the Llnfted Arts Council of Collier County. Computer Classes — Learn important computer skills each Wednesday afternoon and Friday morning. Exercise — A variety of chair, movement and Taf Chi classes are offered each week. Wednesday Lunch and More* -Meet and greet new and aid friends over a delicious lunch and entertainment. *RSVP is required. Contact us at 239-325-4444 for more information. Card Games, Mah 3ongg, & More — Spend Frfday afternoon playing games you enjoy or learning a nevi on.e from instructors who help get you up to speed. *x see our-:alendar of Evenl r: for more information ** Do not miss another program! Click the sign-up button below to receive the Senior Center calendar of events via email every month. Sign Up Now QGoogle Calendar 1' Activities Attendance 16 10 9 14 Wednesday February 6, 2019 11 173 5 2 16 33 13 3 10 16 Tuesday February 5, 2019 22 3 *20% of the seniors attend more than one activity during the day. 221 Activity Schedule (Sept. 2019) Mon "hit- M41 'Murm 3)F,i¢I I;7k WC'— 4] 9_lwmm, 47.dr r—&r. jOAF-11lM;{:71L.. 6)%Lwlmh ,rr.r TJi7d 11.1 Holiday_ 1w1> wyrarAsk, W;LnO•4Ml rn.rOM-k, :MOZIF{'�rA�ee 1411;Mtr_r7i} Ll"I11151i11{7dONp!I lhlwll I.M MEML{'MIML fts-Ll 11HI 13i LTe 7Aykwi we llllgghil�1141 —1 Lhw f Center [ IuSed 11-1#R \AIr� IT{'LIu4r {'.r.IF irr�ir�T 3�Y IZ-It:*4 {'aYy. liawlt:lktiri 71�wIZ�7. W-bi �L—EI- 1_Il LI9: �J1e �hrFH�_ I.Z:M L'.� YL_ .3-W.. Q__d Vni 7Srrw12ia CMaM rindw ph.rrr i Cie I. I i W &aV� W 6�1y ldwirM[ YIIIeY hr TMrMC ll-Ul 7:M•ZiM: N—W . Ni " H — ]b14L7F Hom L1L1L}{;.." 1:7"LW 1.4u_M_ M 76wz 19i7Yiilirf JLJFJi YSI�rw:! trfa.tr}r� Yr{�ti. �Ve 3��u�JA M'.krJ. SY.�krr� • ___ 11) r,Jwllhlr. {Lk rndrr J: I -4:W Hi— 16.dM % wIbIL4 b r T.1 L-M43-0 ] H Ili Arti>_' IOj TLwY1r16i 5Yrr 1-.Iw 12) %WHALr" TI.— IwILi1-SFir.43tr.+.�t�. lilt i.t�r iY..ra IRiI:�F. F..r.�le [41I ik 1. """t tiiw11J1e L'_901IC d..rr o� I Ii�S 11:1t: tYlr#:wtrXr 16LWI1 L%.so—hi[{'e.lel .rlt IL.Ii IrlY S i MET JL/rn II IS�1ii4#e 141rYY�fr w��rnii it Llhl►Il115ON {10�e1141 1.1<\w.-LI A, 54 ll.l \..i. Y-1 1�.}.O.{' w�,A.it� L:-It:11r 1..� Y,�r�i.r miLI I:J1, k.ph r,—lft r�LlY ON-,k W. urrr�,.�r.I t..� 1 11�1t�1.�H>i�L.. IIS I.Itit:15:{....rL It: l,4 Y�era.r Y�.aa.r l,ln nawl3:,ktiri5� rrr.r.dr.rr 11iL11:�4 {'..y. kur�i.r 11�.}.li: Orr.i rra. iJ941.4:l.L{irl1.. 1�aL:YI� ■.Yw4r., IA:a}r4a—aLarD� 4r1LW JAW Will ■Ldm 11M I14UL MN ILMWrlle 1Le aKIK 1. L# "& I¢}I11-33:A. t11-- 18 L$}l,Jwmy' I%*ftaShrr 1L • l.�l ii�k vi. r I.w ♦, wlll,ti,rr.tlrpdvhi. +q 1 F.e�I1SF. L. l.lr }trrki aLErt 1F1�*+f4lii.t, ILrrF ll.ibii �. LFII:R I.r�1. rMN M#w11.71. V""iLn116 �trp� I I:I!-11.1S: kvirF:s,.aiv i 1WI la111id"M Dmhrl rner YII+: 11 FILM«Ir He�a��klj M1411d#I Ti{iI �IIFq 1.*3w.*.,z. r...e. i1.1�.L.r Y•.n1 iiLk.}LF, {'.�rA.i�rr YI:It.1S�lF. On�{1LMe Iw1.Llukk.l'4*TrF IrY�.r ..aiw IMF}ll1. Y..ra,ns.l 4—p-wL i_i}{.,If; I...rwprI.i. It -It 11 [.ri.Fvrnrr II�wIJ:1k{I..k Y�rL rr­.riw r 13iM-Ixitli i'ai#:v.,:r ]AG4.M iki3.� Ix.71•J.1{�i-s.�LLi I :L�tJ�: 4J [ 1•h 1 LWAS: rA (l.' 1.. Y I:lk Hrpw L w O.s-S lMMLJ1t 10 Fresch Ile rlwr�o-Illo t:AWL)M: hkI r•r or" jL ni Yi14S�ik I� HEM« ee ILe arWC nd 14,11!An4ww 24)*,e1L11,4kA),Ircw 25)*04&7F1&Obidirhrrre .2619:15lim!(4}The 27)ftwlholklnMYr1ll14#1 IwiLI1�l:l r.tr 3r4clrFtri. ILFII'_Lw�%�L, :&1*n »Ff I:�IG IMY\k LFIIYrF. Far e. Li4 1/11w11L1F r_VL CM fill RR1� 1 L.aL L1•O.AYW-k,.r.w. jLlr rcr.rrr 0 f>...�.�1WrY1 I Y:Lw1:Vk Ampllkd Fb-4hr MWL, 111#,S ie. lY .Lrr.�br Yw ...w [i iY LLr1a.11i14 YY{ll e]..I�R I.Ir ltV}: Qb. . II.L 3..dr rr.l IY.li LarL..+41w S.�e rrllwrtix IFIL11:14-r.rwrr ta.r llrr�lFY I1wX1w Ilk ,F iilh..p-wx I,:31LIZ:34: 1wr%-U-S.oC 1�.}. {.�rtrAW..rr I.t: i4[r.eL. 17 jF13:lk{lr5.p rrw Yr 2-Elt-ai: L ..W kyr�r 1-1L}:Ii:aa.vre 1-I:Lk Mi..kL[!.I<�1+ Ix LM.JLM1 Lime%Md L'LLIrF i:33-1:IS: xrnt F.Ir 4Y,.kr 13wZ:l5:ri{1rw 7MdJ} 1Iq. L L.Ak[.—p 11tw4k IM"Mrrlre lL4hiiww[ Fy1wk11e Y.s.i fw lr.,a41FIiY I:LIw.F:iL; Yr{�ti� 4 sVs SL WI Y4 "immar GLrdo A. I ia:._-� __ lrr6% 30? "'.a..e­1 fflL.ri.rr. 02i{'eitrllaDrive Holiday rrud'"d NApkm F[. 341W CRRIer CIMCd -32L""4 Pre -registration required for all programs • Shuttle service available 21J Land Use/Zoning D. Wayne Arnold, AICP Principal Planner Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. 24 Project Location Mar) • Located on the Southeast quadrant of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane • Valewood signal access G Subject N o Property0 Immokalee Road o Acres (D , - f s .. m 4 Y t =' . Autumn Oaks Lane • d 4 _ Project Information Current Zoning: E, Estates Proposed Zoning: Naples Senior Center Community Facility Planned Unit Development (CFPUD) Current Future Land Use Designation: Estates Designation, Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict Proposed Future Land Use Designation: Project Acreage: 13.6+/- acres Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict 27 Existing Regulatory Framework Land uses permitted by right or through the conditional use process • 4 tax parcels • Uses permitted by right o Non-profit care o Electric substations o Libraries o Sewage lift station Eghrting ■torapaiwarahoum u mmy ba convarkod [o a/mltmr coma miml o & through Huring Examinrr apprm al. Governmental a OM Pa hr rtghi - .notuda; alac[rle xublaal", amargancy Coll iowars. IIGrarlss, orks. museums, oai-ror-profit C11i, are. - CwWonml Use +Cr churcA. w6a&atamat _ brj)alwaclon. privat& 9Chool- day CaYB, asq's 4E ` l itt-_ Jiving taai[ity, or sr howl hoard wtimle mzln[enamce or admims[rarlion or Cf11SfFo statlan po.mlHnd thr qh liaaring EzamLnerapprarala- Uism garml13*0 by righd Inc' Ibdr slecift suhriahcn, 9"s De IIPt elaiinni. Ilhrarles, mdaailmk parks, nnr-tarlprubt chRdcars v1 A 281 Proposed Request • Create new subdistrict under the Golden Gate Area Master Plan to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building area for senior services uses for the Naples Senior Center for 8.6+/- acres of assemblage • Rezone 13.6+/- acres from the E, Estates Zoning District to CFPUD Zoning District to develop the site for Naples Senior Center services 29 CFPUD Proposed Uses A. Principal Uses: 1. Individual and Family Social Services (SIC 8322) for seniors 60 and older, limited to the following: a. Activity centers, elderly b. Adult day care centers c. Centers for senior citizens/community centers d. Family counseling services e. Old age assistance f. Outreach programs g. Senior citizens associations B. Group support services, elderly 30 Prohibited Uses 1. Soup kitchens 2. Homeless shelters 3. Residential dwelling units 4. Offender rehabilitation agencies 5. Public welfare offices 6. Self-help organizations for alcoholics 7. Refugee services 8. Religious facilities/churches 31 Proposed Development Standards PRINCIPAL USES ACCESSORY USES MINIMUM LOT AREA N/A N/A AVERAGE LOT WIDTH N/A N/A MINIMUM YARDS (External) From Autumn Oakes Lane ROW 75 ft. 15 ft. From Oakes Boulevard ROW 75 ft. 15 ft. From Eastern PU D Boundary 350 ft. 50 ft. From Southern PUD Boundary 75 ft. 15 ft. Lakes {measured from control elevation) 20 ft. 20 ft. From Preserves 25 ft. 10 ft. MIN. DISTANCE BETWEEN STRUCTURES N/A 10 Ft. MAXIMUM HEIGHT Zoned 30 ft. 30 ft. Actual 35 ft. (1) 35 ft. MINIMUM FLOOR AREA N/A N/A MAXIMUM GROSS BUILDING AREA 30,000 sq. ft. N/A NOTE: (1) Not to exceed a maximum of 2 stories. 1 3;j Proposed Conceptual Master Plan G � i VJALEWUOU UFS. PO I I I I IMMOKALt - RD. i B. ESTAYE$ E. r r E. WATTS (SkCNAL1ZED 1HTERSECnara) i VACANTRESII]ENrulL ESTATES r , +k,#TFR UWrr r I CHURCH I AREA � I F � � 5 I �/J UMN L ..��---------a----- PROPERTY r ! MINIMUM 27 AIDE TfPE'D` �},11k11MUM 0' WIQ15 T' 'F � f PRpP€RZY r�0uN�5RY 9fSl1HbARY I RJCaI�T•pU LAf4QSC4PE BUFFER L NO4 PE.SUPFEi3 R*NT.OVT PRINCIA P Ll BUILOM F } PARNiNQ AREA ES BUILOING AREA PARKING Af { SPACE'` E. t I E$TA Oe RES DE�NTOL i IwINIAAu I iOMMUNITY F!A ILIIY r • &FOOT VNDE L MQG CAPE PRINCIPAL s WATE$ 6LIFFtR 9UILDINCs $EIEAe*J€ /m -$1�L RMWATION �UlmuuM) MINIMUM LIT WIDE 1Y#�IE (SE � E NOTE 92j DSCAf'E f • i - a LANDSCAPE BUFF f2 $EFtVAT*K eNdirE jarm pp I YIEk i�IT . . . . . . PRESERVE . . . . . FNGWT-OOFhWAY I . . . . . . . . EQE WNT k ; iAFNrAk11A i5` 111FIOE TYPE . E$TA7 E$ • _ _ _ _ _ . _ . ' _ T . IPd t. PG In AND%) I I kAWb+CAK nLPFFIER WTORCYCLE REPAik AND si Fk CE. { REST DENTAL 1 � � I I I I � � 1 ESTATES ' FiE$IpE�T'IAC r a Proposed Conceptual Master Plan Overlay IMMOKALEE ROAD ` f + i 3 + . 4 1 I I I I I I hp I I I I I P. 5 -I` I I r � k AIES WAlF3�mwaE.LE�IIE . iJ�I.KlCkl AWA -- .-___________- �nM1.�.5A� RAIa�Fl6 MGKInG Ii1FA � ffLfLfLL ft•f Yi ly f• •ir } •�: - r� € OMMUN,TY FA .IUTY k Y y F - - - - - - PMTA-LVE '�H E. L.lAfF3 rauch�nf4FrA1Fe- • � - . r�v,cxrvi . ra{g .[':UEr4TL+a A • Date aerial flown: January 2019, Collier County Property Appraiser 34 Primary Access to Valewood Dr.-,-, IMMOKALEE ROAD J * y µ� + f 10 k ! * } k i 1 t rM CC E, E ` o VATER ER V. IC H _Y; v :,rLAN E Date aerial flown: January 2019, Collier County Property Appraiser f. l' f 1 � f r � 35 Proposed Conceptual Site Rendering A N AuT_=mn OakLane s 9- �4 'AF .1_41 P f �­w �op OF op or m rm 0 op, OPK P op, tV 0 Ap'. $P jv op CU 36 it Proposed Conceptual Site Rendering Overlay A N I i 37 Traffic Analysis James M. Banks,, P.E. JMB Transportation Engineering, Inc. sfl 55 50 45 415 40 35 n 31 CL 30 as ry ~ 25 2q 17 17 16 15 15 15 15 15 14 12 12 12 1010 1p 9 7 7 7B 6 6 7 7 5 5 5 4 5 5 4 4 5 5 3 3 3 3 1 LEGEND 7 AM 8 AM 9 AM 10 AM 11 AM Noon 1 PM 2 PM 3 PM 4 PM 5 PM Entering Trips HOUR OF DAY Exiting Trips 0 Naples Senior Center Existing Site -Generated Traffic Figure T1 Morch 22, 2019 39 B4 55 50 45 40 3J �} 2 21 21 20 sa I� I a 15 ly 15 13 73 2 77 10 a v rt 6 iS S a a 3 a a x5 A 5 � LEGEND 7 AAA 8 AM 9 AM 10 AM 11 AM Noon 1 PM 7 PIA 3 PIA 4 PU v EnWeig Trips HOUR OF DAY F�Rinq Trip. Naples Senior Center Projected Site-Generatod Traffic Figure T2 March 22, 2019 Traffic Impact Evaluation • Established Site -Generated Trips by Collecting Data at Existing NSC • Data Collected for the NSC during the Most Active Day of Week (Wednesday) & During Peak Season • Monday, Tuesday, Thursday & Friday Generate Less Trips (> 50%) • Proposed NSC will Generate: Trips Generated 300 ' 51 195 31 (Proposed45 enter/ 6 exit 45 enter/150 exit 1 enter/30 exit • Established Traffic Conditions within the Oakes Neighborhood. Traffic Data Collected During Peak Season (December) • Signalized Access to Immokalee Road & Vanderbilt Beach Road • Prepared a Traffic Impact Statement Pursuant to Collier County Criteria • Determined that All Intersections and Road Links Impacted Will Continue to Operate at Acceptable LOS at Project Build -Out • Oakes Boulevard will Operate at 26% of its Capacity During Peak Season Peak Hour Conditions • Collier County Staff Reviewed the Traffic Study and Agreed with Findings 41 Proposed Conceptual Master Plan Overlay i A C I _ININ1 l[iAl-EE Rif:IU.�;..� it A • Date aerial flown: January 2019, Collier County Property Appraiser 42 Perspective View From Autumn Oaks Lane Autumn Oaks Ln. 0 Enhanced Buffer along Autumn Oaks Lane 43A Perspective View From Oakes Boulevard Autumn Oaks Ln. a t 4P n- • A•• • Enhanced Buffer along Oakes Boulevard 41 elelliffile 46 S' V T 5 IL 5 Planning Conclusions • Project thoughtfully designed to be compatible with the Oakes Neighborhood • Large building setbacks • Enhanced landscape buffers • More than 5 acres devoted to preserve and open space • 2 story maximum height • Residential style architecture • Project will have direct access to signalized access at Valewood Drive and Immokalee Road • No evening or weekend use of the property • Limited scope of uses related to senior center mission 47 Conclusion ki� .. rM.,iftm: - i • Thank you k 48 AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD I hereby certify that pursuant to Ordinance 2004-41, of the Collier County Land Development Code, I did cause the attached newspaper advertisement to appear and I did give notice by mail to the following property owners and/or condominium and civic associations whose members may be affected by the proposed land use changes of an application request for a rezoning, PUD amendment, or conditional use, at least 15 days prior to the scheduled Neighborhood Information Meeting. For the purposes of this requirement, the names and addresses of property owners shall be deemed those appearing on the latest tax rolls of Collier County and any other persons or entities who have made a formal request of the county to be notified. The said notice contained the laymen's description of the site property of proposed change and the date, time, and place of a Neighborhood Information Meeting, Per the attached letters, property owner's list, and copy of newspaper advertisement which are hereby made a part of this Affidavit of Sharon Umpenhour as Senior Planning Technician for Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. State of Florida County of Lee The foregoing Affidavit of compliance was acknowledged before me this loth day of 7anuary 2020 by Sharon Umpenhour as Senior Planning Technician for Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A., who is personally known to me. (Signature of Notary Public) Carin J. Dwyer Printed Name of Notary W COMMf.53lON tF FF 5700 =N ,a ������yy��D},(PiIiliM::�W1ry�1ry��..2M �~ Bwded TINY muo PIl UOUwUm GradyMinor Civil Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners a Landscape Architects January 10, 2020 RE: Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Dear Sir or Madam: A Neighborhood Information Meeting hosted by D. Wayne Arnold, AICP, of Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A. and John M. Passidomo of Cheffy Passidomo, P.A., representing Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. (Applicant) will be held on Monday, January 27, 2020, 5:30 pm at Hodges University, John White Community Room, 2647 Professional Circle, Naples, FL 34119. Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. has submitted formal applications to Collier County, seeking approval of a Small -Scale Growth Management Plan (GMP) Amendment and a Community Facility Planned Unit Development (CFPUD) Rezone. The GMP amendment proposes to create a new community facility sub -district under the Golden Gate Area Master Plan to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building for senior services uses in the subdistrict and to rezone the property from the E, Estates Zoning District to CFPUD Zoning District, which specifies permitted uses and development standards for the property. The subject property (Naples Senior Center CFPUD) is comprised of approximately 13.6± acres, located on the southeast corner of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. Project information is posted online at www.gradyminor.com/planning. If you have questions or comments, they can be directed to Sharon Umpenhour at Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A., 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134, sumpenhour@gradyminor.com, phone 239-947-1144, fax 239-947-0375. Project information is posted online at www.gradyminor.com/planning. Project Location Map prOFAsslo a1 ClR n �49 Florence CIR �y GGG p a GAP 9ton L96 o �z o �arthbrooke Plaza DRY m a m LL<, x Executive DR o Z �"",J— o IMM KALEE RD a Immoka lee RD m m Autumn peke LN 4 r] � cc Malibu Lake C�� " SUBJECT � ° PROPERTY Hidden Oaks LN Y W li @bu Lake PL 5 Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. Ph. 239-947-1144 Fax. 239-947-0375 3800 Via Del Rey EB 0005151 LB 0005151 LC 26000266 Bonita Springs, FL 34134 www.gradyminor.com Notice: This data belongs to the Collier County Property Appraiser's Office (CCPA). Therefore, the recipient agrees not to represent this data to anyone as other than CCPA provided data. The recipient may not transfer this data to others without consent from the CCPA. Petition: PL20180002622 & PL20180002621 I Buffer: 1000' 1 Date: 12/13/2019 1 Site Location: Parcels 41931080006, 41931120005, 41931200006, and 41933240006 NIL NAME4 N 18T CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH OF NAPLES INC 6225 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8634 2180 OAKES LLC 2180 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--0 7 ELEVEN INC 1722 ROUTH ST # 1000 DALLAS, TX 75201-- 0 ACEVEDO, MARIO & FATIMA 465 CASE RD LABELLE, FL 33935--9458 ALEKSEYCHICK, SERGEY PAVLOVICH IRYNA MYKHAILVNA ALEKSEYCHYK 10063 PALAZZO DRIVE NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 AMBROSH, JAMES R 10040 HEATHER LN APT 1401 NAPLES, FL 34119--9027 AMSOUTH BANK PROPERTIES DEPT 250 RIVERCHASE PKWY E 6TH FL BIRMINGHAM, AL 35244--1832 BARRETT, SIMON DAVID LESLEY CHRISTINE BARRETT 6060 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--0 BELL JR, JOSEPH R & LINDA B 4016 PRESTON HWY LOUISVILLE, KY 40213--1612 BELL, KENNETH A EDWARD H ZAX 2221 E STARLITE LN LOUISVILLE, KY 40291---1761 BLONDIN & PIETRASZEK INC 985 PINECREAST DR SUGAR GROVE, IL 60554--0 BLONDIN & PIETRASZEK INC 985 PINECREST DR SUGAR GROVE, IL 60554--0 BLONDIN & PIETRASZEK INC 985 PINECREST DR SUGAR GROVE, IL 60554--0 BRACCI, STEVEN J MICHELLE LIL BRACCI 6141 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1131 BRENTWOOD LAND PARTNERS LLC % KITE REALTY GROUP 30 S MERIDIAN ST STE 1100 INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204--3565 BRENTWOOD LAND PARTNERS LLC % KITE REALTY GROUP 30 S MERIDIAN ST STE 1100 INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204--3565 CANNELLA, PETER R & LUCILLE M 2884 DUDLEY AVE BRONX, NY 10461--0 CARTER, ANNADANIELLE 10024 HEATHER LANE #1003 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 COLANGELO, ANTHONY L GERALDINE COLANGELO 25 YORKTON BLVD MARKHAM L6C 0J9 CANADA COLLIER CNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 3301 TAMIAMI TRL E BLDG F NAPLES, FL 34112--4902 COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112-- 0 COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112-- 0 COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112--0 COLLIER CNTY C/O REAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 3335 TAMIAMI TR E, STE 101 NAPLES, FL 34112--0 COLLIER COUNTY 3301 TAMIAMI TRL E NAPLES, FL 34112-- 0 CYPRESS CYCLE SERVICES INC 2300 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--0 DAVEKOS FAMILY TRUST 2 FAIRVIEW HILL ROAD ATKINSON, NH 03811--0 DERBY, ALEX R 5981 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1135 DESTINY CHURCH NAPLES 6455 HIDDEN OAKS LANE NAPLES, FL 34119--0 DESTINY CHURCH NAPLES INC 6455 HIDDEN OAKS LANE NAPLES, FL 34119--0 E & C L ALEXANDER R/L TRUST 10049 HEATHER LN #102 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 EL KOMATI LLC 4521 EXECUTIVE DR STE 201 NAPLES, FL 34119--9035 ELLINGTON, PHILLIP & JEANNE K 6040 HIDDEN OAKS LANE NAPLES, FL 34119--0 EMIDY JR, PAUL 6220 HIDDEN OAKS LANE NAPLES, FL 34119--0 ENCORE VENTURE LLC 8009 KILKENNY COURT NAPLES, FL 34112--0 ENN CO LLC 16677 BOBCAT DRIVE FORT MYERS, FL 33908--0 FAITH BIBLE CHURCH/NAPLES INC 64641MMOKALEE RD NAPLES, FL 34119--8843 FAITH BIBLE CHURCH/NAPLES INC 64641MMOKALEE RD NAPLES, FL 34119--8843 FERNS, MONIQUE D 10025 HEATHER LANE #703 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 FIDIS, COVENTINE & DEANNA L 6040 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--0 FOURNIER, NICOLAS O & DIANA G 6130 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--0 FRY, HEIDI S & KARI Z 6090 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1134 GLASE, JAMES A & JEAN A 6355 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8607 GLOBAL DYNAMICS LLC 4529 EXECUTIVE DR #101 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 GPS INTRNTL OF NAPLES INC 470 YUCCA RD NAPLES, FL 34102--5323 GRENDOWSKA, JADWIGA 28413 VERDE LN BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135--0 GUDENAU, GERALD L DANA DAVIS GUDENAU 590 FARRINGTON HWY#524-424 KAPOLEI, HI 96707-- 0 GUERRETTE, STEVEN L CHERYL O GUERRETTE 25 LOGAN BLVD N NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 GUTIERREZ, ALMA R & FRANCISCO 6070 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8633 HAGEDORN, JONATHAN 6130 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8633 HALLBERG, DAVID E & LYNNETTE L 10024 HEATHER LN #1004 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 HAMMOND JR, ROBERT J KATHLEEN HAMMOND 18356 WESTOVER DRIVE SOUTH BEND, IN 46637-- 0 HARDY, R PAUL & MARTA 4581 BRYNWOOD DR NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 HARR, DANIEL L 10028 HEATHER LANE #1101 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 HUDSON CAPITAL FUND LLC 26-26 14TH ST 1ST FLOOR ASTORIA, NY 11102-- 0 HUGHES, MARK M & KELLY R JAMES K=& MARI-LYNN MCGREGOR 17514 HIDDEN GARDEN LN ASHTON, MD 20861-- 3651 HUNTINGTON LAKES RES ASSN INC % AMERICAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 10621 AIRPORT PULLING RD N # 8 NAPLES, FL 34109---7300 HUNTINGTON LAKES RES ASSOC INC % AMERICAN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 10621 AIRPORT PULLING RD N # 8 NAPLES, FL 34109---7300 IGLESIAS, ISRAEL 6080 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8633 JOHN H WINKLER TR SHARON A WINKLER TRUST LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--3385 JOHN H WINKLER TRUST SHARON A WINKLER TRUST LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--3385 JOHN H WINKLER TRUST SHARON A WINKLER TRUST LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--3385 JOHN H WINKLER TRUST SHARON A WINKLER TRUST LOWELL E WHITE ET ALS 18151 CYPRESS CREEK LN ALVA, FL 33920--3385 KALDANY DEVELOPMENT CO INC 172 TOPANGA DR BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34134--8544 KAREN L OLDHAM REV TRUST 10033 HEATHER LN #501 NAPLES, FL 34119--9024 KENTON D SONDENO REV LIV TRUST 6120 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--0 KURTZ, BRIAN & CARLA 27040 DEL LANE BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135--0 LAND TRUST % ROY A SCHUCK TR 1023 GROVE DR NAPLES, FL 34120---1426 LEITH, BRIAN & SHEILA A 9654 WHITEHALL STREET NAPLES, FL 34109-- 0 LEO, LORI JANE & KEVIN FRANCIS 2291 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8758 LIVINGSTON, JASON S 2130 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8755 LOUISE V TAYLOR REV LIV TRUST 627 GORDONIA RD NAPLES, FL 34108--0 LUCKY CHICK LLC 10044 HEATHER LN #1504 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 LUTZ, SHARON S KIRK ALLEN LUTZ 10044 HEATHER LANE #1501 NAPLES, FL 34119---0 MARJORIE ELLEN EBERT DEC OF REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST 10021 HEATHER LANE #802 NAPLES, FL 34119---0 MARY C HOLDER CONDO REV TRUST 317 W 21ST STREET #1D NEW YORK, NY 10011--3054 MAZZUCCA, MICHAEL & MAUREEN 10037 HEATHER LANE #4-403 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 MCCONNELL, SHAWN C 10041 HEATHER LANE #301 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 MCGINTY, HARRIET R 10029 HEATHER LN #604 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CK VILAGE CONDOMINUIM ASSOCIATION 11655 QUAIL VILLAGE WAY NAPLES, FL 34119--8806 MERCADO, MICHAEL A 6181 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1131 MEYER, JOSEPH L & KATHLEEN A 10041 HEATHER LANE #302 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 MILLET, KRISTIN NAUGHTON 2271 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119-8758 MITCHELL, STUART & KAREN 6221 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8618 MITCHELL, WILLIAM HARRY LINDA TULL MITCHELL 8230 DONAWAY RD WHALEYVILLE, MD 21872---2030 NAREKIAN TR, THOMAS A THOMAS A NAREKIAN TRUST UTD 12/31/96 28413 VERDE LANE BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135-- 0 NAREKIAN TR, THOMAS S THOMAS S NAREKIAN TRUST UTD 12/31/96 28413 VERDE LANE BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135-- 0 NEFF, WILLIAM L KERI NEFF 2170 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8755 NEW LOCK INVESTMENTS LLC 12 BATEMAN LN BOLTON L7E 2Z9 CANADA NEW SOLUTIONS LTD 3255 TAMIAMI TRL N NAPLES, FL 34103--4106 NEW SOLUTIONS LTD 3255 TAMIAMI TRL N NAPLES, FL 34103--4106 NICHLLS, JASON M & MARSHA A 10020 HEATHER LANE UNIT 901 NAPLES, FL 34119--0 NNPS LLC 4510 EXECUTIVE DR NAPLES, FL 34115--0 NNPS LLC 4510 EXECUTIVE DR NAPLES, FL 34115--0 OAKES RESOURCES INC 470 YUCCA RD NAPLES, FL 34102--5323 OTTOS INSPIRATION LAND TRUST % JOHN C GOEDE ESQ 6609 WILLOW PARK DR 2ND FL NAPLES, FL 34109-- 0 PALLADINO, ANTHONY & CYNTHIA 6460 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8600 PALMERI, GRACIELA S 6160 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1132 PANDYA, SUNIL RAMESH 2391 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8760 PASCUZZI, VINCE S & DIANE S 121 SCHOLFIELD AVE PT COLBORNE L3K OA2 CANADA PATRICIA J PHALON TRUST 325 E 31 AVE EUGENE, OR 97405--0 FOLK) IR L LEGAL2 LEGAL4 BLOCKBLDG LOTUNIT SECTIO 41931040004 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 22 LESS N 50FT, LESS EAST PORTION FOR RM/ AS DESC IN OR 4432 PG 1280, LESS THOSE PORTIONS FOR 22 0 29 48 26 41931440002 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 OF N 18OFT OF TR 27 27 2 29 48 26 68815031808 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 LOT 9 OR 1501 PG 236 9 20 48 26 41934760006 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 150FT OF TR 68 68 1 29 48 26 64917000809 PALAZZO AT NAPLES LOT 36 36 20 48 26 59952001069 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1401 14 1401 20 48 26 24745001683 BRENTWOOD TWO LOT 1 LESS THAT PORTION AS DESC IN OR 4461 PG 2843 1 30 48 26 41934880009 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 75FT OF TR 69 AND THE W 7.5 FT OF W 150FT OF TR 72 69 2 29 48 26 59952000028 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 101 1 101 20 48 26 59952000141 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 203 2 203 20 48 26 59952001043 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1304 13 1304 20 48 26 59952000426 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 601 6 601 20 48 26 59952000947 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1203 12 1203 20 48 26 41933400008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 150FT OF TR 53 53 0 29 48 26 24745000545 BRENTWOOD TWO TRACT B LESS THAT PORTION AS DESC IN OR 4456 PG 285-288, LESS THAT PORTION AS DESC IN OR 4644 B 1 30 48 26 24745001641 BRENTWOOD TWO TRACT P-3 P-3 1 30 48 26 59952000989 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1301 13 1301 20 48 26 59952000785 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1003 10 1003 20 48 26 59952000442 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 602 6 602 20 48 26 51070000021 HUNTINGTON TRACT A (ROAD RIW) OR 2268 PG 2068 A 1 20 48 26 41933280008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 50 LESS N 50FT 50 0 29 48 26 63940000107 NORTHBROOK DRIVE TRACT R R 1 18 48 26 76446000025 TARPON BAY TRACT A A 1 30 48 26 24745000561 BRENTWOOD TWO THAT PORTION OF TRACT B DESC AS: COMM AT NE CNR OF SEC 30, S 02DEG E 49.97 FT, S 89DEG W 268.36FT, S 02 B 2 30 48 26 24745000529 BRENTWOOD TWO TRACT A A 1 30 48 26 41931160007 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 S 105FT OF TR 24 OR 583 PG 351 24 1 29 48 26 59952000581 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 801 8 801 20 48 26 41936280005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 18OFT OF TR 88 OR 1632 PG 1464 88 1 29 48 26 68570000255 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 5 5 29 48 26 41930721007 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 15, LESS E 30OFT & TR 16, LESS THE E 60OFT 15 1 29 48 26 59952000044 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 102 1 102 20 48 26 68815032205 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE II LOT 13 13 20 48 26 41935120001 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 150FT OF TR 74 74 0 29 48 26 41931360001 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E1/2 OF N 18OFT OF TR 27 OR 1459 PG 1008-1009 27 0 29 48 26 68880000084 QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 201 201 20 48 26 59952000688 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 902 9 902 20 48 26 41930880003 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 19, LESS N 50FT, LESS S 15FT OF N65FT OF E 35FT DESC IN OR 2587 PG 2737 STIPULATED ORDER 19 0 29 48 26 41930920002 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 20, LESS N 65FT OF W 300.01 FT AS DESC IN OR 2157 PG 1154 AND OR 2587 PG 2737 STIPULATED 20 0 29 48 26 59952000549 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 703 7 703 20 48 26 41935040000 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 157.5FT OF THE W 165FT OF TR 72 72 1 29 48 26 41933520001 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 75FT OF W 150FT OF TR 54 OR 1107 PG 276 54 1 29 48 26 41934681004 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 OF TR 67 67 1 29 48 26 41930722006 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 300 FT OF TR 15 2.27 AC 15 2 29 48 26 68815032153 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE II LOT 12 12 20 48 26 68570000158 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 3 3 29 48 26 59952000507 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 701 7 701 20 48 26 41935080002 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 OF TR 73 73 0 29 48 26 59952000086 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 104 1 104 20 48 26 41934840007 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 75FT OF E 150FT OF TR 69 69 1 29 48 26 41933361008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 WI/2 OF TR 52 52 1 29 48 26 59952000808 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1004 10 1004 20 48 26 59952000329 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 404 4 404 20 48 26 41933360009 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E112 OF TR 52 52 0 29 48 26 59952000824 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1101 11 1101 20 48 26 59952000248 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 304 3 304 20 48 26 59952001166 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1502 15 1502 20 48 26 51075000974 HUNTINGTON LAKES UNIT ONE TRACT 5 (BUFFER,COMMON AREA) 5 1 20 48 26 51070000128 HUNTINGTON TRACT B B 1 20 48 26 41934800005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 180FT OF TR 69 OR 1519 PG 2175 69 0 29 48 26 41931080006 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 23 23 0 29 48 26 41931120005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N 75FT OF S 180FT OF TR 24 24 0 29 48 26 41931200006 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N 150FT OF TR 24 24 2 29 48 26 41933240006 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 49 49 0 29 48 26 68880000026 QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 101 101 20 48 26 59952000345 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 501 5 501 20 48 26 41933480002 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 18OFT OF TR 54 54 0 29 48 26 41934720004 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 18OFT OF TR 68 68 0 29 48 26 41936440007 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 90 LESS N 50FT 90 0 29 48 26 59952001182 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1503 15 1503 20 48 26 41930761009 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 600 FT OF N1/2 OF TR 16, 2.27 AC 16 1 29 48 26 41931480004 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N165FT OF TR 28 28 0 29 48 26 41934960000 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 71 LESS N 50FT 71 0 29 48 26 59952001205 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1504 15 1504 20 48 26 59952001140 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1501 15 1501 20 48 26 59952000604 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 802 8 802 20 48 26 59952000167 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 204 2 204 20 48 26 59952000303 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 403 4 403 20 48 26 59952000183 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 301 3 301 20 48 26 59952000484 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 604 6 604 20 48 26 00184520008 20 48 26 COMM SW CNR SECT 20, ELY 1000.01 FT, N1 DEG W 10OFT TO POB, CONT NLY 860.81 FT, S 70 DEG E 541.22FT, S 14 DEG W 090 20 48 26 41933200004 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 18OFT OF TR 48 48 1 29 48 26 59952000206 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 302 3 302 20 48 26 41930762008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 600 FT OF S 112 OF TR 16, 2.27 AC OR 1734 PG 1015 16 2 29 48 26 41931320009 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 1/2 OF TR 26 26 0 29 48 26 59952000743 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1001 10 1001 20 48 26 59952000264 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 401 4 401 20 48 26 59952000361 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 502 5 502 20 48 26 41931400000 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 S 150FT OF TR 27 27 1 29 48 26 59952000905 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1201 12 1201 20 48 26 68815031002 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 LOTS 1, 2 AND 3 1 20 48 26 68815031206 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE I WILY 40FT OF LOT 4 LESS E 5FT, LESS E 23FT OF W 35FT OF W 40FT OF LOT 4 4.1 20 48 26 59952000662 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 901 9 901 20 48 26 68815031154 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE I LOT 4 LESS WLY 40FT AND TRACT A LESS ELY 58FT 4 20 48 26 68815031303 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PH 1 ELY 5FT OF WILY 40FT OF LOT 4, AND E 23FT OF W 35FT OF W 40FT OF LOT 4 4.2 20 48 26 68570000103 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 2 2 29 48 26 59952000222 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 303 3 303 20 48 26 41930681008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 14, LESS E 350FT 14 1 29 48 26 41933080004 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 75FT OF TR 47 47 1 29 48 26 68570000051 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 1 1 29 48 26 59952000701 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 903 9 903 20 48 26 41931240008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 S 150FT OF TR 25 25 0 29 48 26 POList 1000 PL20180002622-PL20180002621.xls PECK, DONNA M 10045 HEATHER LANE #201 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 59952000109 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE PHILLOS BRIGHTON REALTY TRUST 107 HEMLOCK DRIVE WESTWOOD, MA 02090--0 59952000387 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE PINELLI, EDDY & NANCY 624 WILSON STREET SAULT STE MARIE P613 21-6 CANADA 59952000468 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE POKHOY, NEHAUL SHERRY POKHOY 10036 HEATHER LANE #1302 NAPLES, FL 34119---0 59952001001 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE QCV LLC 1016 COLLIER CENTER WAY SUITE 101 NAPLES, FL 34110---0 59952000125 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE QUAIL PLAZA LLC 4522 EXECUTIVE DR STE 102 NAPLES, FL 34119--9013 68880000042 QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM QUAIL PLAZA PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION INC 12823 VALEWOOD DR NAPLES, FL 34119---8502 68815016001 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 RAY REAL ESTATE LLC 4624 OAK LEAF DRIVE NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 59952000727 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE REFERENCE ONLY MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE THE A CONDOMINIUM 00185417000 2048 26 THAT PORTION OF SEC REFERENCE ONLY QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM 68815031400 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 REFERENCE ONLY TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM 68815031507 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE 1 RELF, SCOTT B & RENEE R 6020 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8633 41935000008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 RESOP, JACQUELINE M 10028 HEATHER LN #1102 NAPLES, FL 34119--9021 59952000840 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE RIESTRA JR, FERNANDO M GABRIELA RIESTRA 9589 CRESENT GARDEN DR C-201 NAPLES, FL 34109-- 0 59952001027 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE RINGHOFER, ROBERT & JAMIE ANNE 2290 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8757 41931280000 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 N RONCA HOLDINGS LLC 3232 ATLANTIC CIRCLE NAPLES, FL 34119--0 68880000068 QUAIL PLAZA A CONDOMINIUM ROOK JR, JOHN A & MANDY LYNN 6060 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1134 41934680005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 1/2 ROWE, TIMOTHY E & AMANDA L 6161 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1131 41933160005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E SAALOUKEH, MICHEL & ELIAS 9159 THE LANE NAPLES, FL 34109-- 0 59952001108 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE SAMUEL, DARREN TAMARA STROHL-SAMUEL 2220 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8757 41931340005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W 1/2 SAURBIER, KAI W & CORDURA 6461 AUTUMN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--8605 68570000200 Q AND W SUBDIVISION LOT 4 SINGH, TEJESHWAR INDERPREET KAUR 10033 HEATHER LANE #504 NAPLES, FL 34119---0 59952000400 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE SOLOMON, ERIC P & CAMMERON 4001 SANTA BARBARA BLVD #327 NAPLES, FL 34104--0 41933120003 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W SOPKO, EDWARD T & ELLEN 164 BOULEVARD NEW MILFORD, NJ 07646-- 0 59952000060 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE SOUTHBROOKE MEDICAL OFFICE LLC 9015 STRADA STELL COURT #102 NAPLES, FL 34109--0 41933320007 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 51 SOUTHBROOKE MEDICAL OFFICE LLC 9015 STRADA STELL COURT #102 NAPLES, FL 34109--0 41934920008 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR 70 SOUTHERN III, JAMES L 625 MAIN ST MILLIS, MA 02054--0 41930960004 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 TR STONE, HARRY J AMANDA C GRIMES 5814 HAMMOCK ISLES DR NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 59952000565 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE STREETMAN, STEVEN S 10616 BROOKES RESERVE RD UPPER MARLBORO, MD 20772--6618 59952001085 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE TACHER, BRIAN M & SHANNON M 319 ROOKERY COURT MARCO ISLAND, FL 34145-- 0 59952000921 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE TANNASSEE SR, KENNETH R PO BOX 11623 NAPLES, FL 34101--0 41936400005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W TAYLOR, KYLE JORDAN 8683 AMOUR COURT NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 59952000769 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE TAYLOR, MATTHEW R & TRACY L 6111 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1131 41933440000 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E TGM MALIBU LAKES LLC 1 NORTH LA SALLE ST #2100 CHICAGO, IL 60602--3918 00198560009 30 48 26 A PORTION OF THE NE TIITF /DOT /ST OF FL PO BOX 1249 BARTOW, FL 33831--1249 00198600008 30 48 26 I-75 RIW 59.74 AC TOMPKINS, J FREDERICK BROCK PENELOPE MARLYN TOMPKINS 22 DAYMOND DR GUELPH NiH 6H9 CANADA 41935090005 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E 1/2 TRACI BUILDING LLC 2171 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8756 76999500043 TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING LLC 2171 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8756 76999500069 TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING LLC 2171 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8756 76999500085 TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING LLC 2171 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8756 76999500108 TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING LLC 2171 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8756 76999500124 TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRACI BUILDING LLC 2171 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8756 76999500027 TRACI BUILDING A CONDOMINIUM TRUCHAN, MELISSA BOYER 1425 LUCENA LANE S NAPLES, FL 34113--0 59952000280 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE TWETAN, CLIFFORD ANDREW TRACEY MARIE TWETAN 6140 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--0 41933560003 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W UNITED AMERICAN TRUST LC 4513 EXECUTIVE DR NAPLES, FL 34119--9033 68815032250 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE II UNITED AMERICAN TRUST LC PO BOX 110101 NAPLES, FL 34108--0 68815032409 QUAIL CREEK PLAZA PHASE II UNITED TELEPHONE CO OF FLA % EMBARQ CORP ATTN: PROPERTY TAX PO BOX 7909 OVERLAND PARK, KS 66207--909 41931000002 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E VAN PIERCE, ROBERT 100278 HEATHER LANE #1104 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 59952000882 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE VANDERPOST, ROBERT JOHN CARMELINDA ABBATICCHIO 60 EDWARDS DRIVE BARRIE 1-4N 9K8 CANADA 59952000620 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE VBS-LLC 2270 MAHOGANY TRL DE PERE, WI 54115-- 0 59952000866 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE VINCENT PALAGRUTO LIV TRUST 10021 HEATHER LN #804 NAPLES, FL 34119--8862 59952000646 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE WALKER, DAVID K & LINDA R 10040 HEATHER LANE #1404 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 59952001124 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE WALKER, ROBERT C & JUDITH E 2171 OAKES BLVD NAPLES, FL 34119--8756 41930680009 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 E WELLS, SCOTT 551 N 1230 E OREM, UT 84097--5437 59952000963 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE WIGLEY, NATHAN S 10025 HEATHER LANE #702 NAPLES, FL 34119-- 0 59952000523 MEADOWS AT QUAIL CREEK VILLAGE WROBLESKI, JASON A 6170 HIDDEN OAKS LN NAPLES, FL 34119--1132 41933040002 GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 97 W OAKES ESTATES NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION PO BOX 111046 NAPLES, FL 34108-1146 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 201 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 503 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 603 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1302 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 202 UNIT 102 TRACT C THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 904 20 NKA THE MEADOWS AT QUAIL LOT 5 AND ELY 58FT OF TRACT A LOTS 6,7 & 8 NKA TRACI E 165FT OF TR 72 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1102 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1303 180FT OF TR 25 UNIT 103 OF TR 67 150FT OF TR 48 OR 1360 PG 2389 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1403 OF TR 26 OR 2010 PG 1257 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 504 180FT OF TR 47 OR 1276 PG 1146 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 103 LESS N 50FT LESS N 50FT 21, LESS N 200FT OF E 75FT, THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 704 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1402 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1202 180FT OF TR 89 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1002 180FT OF TR 53 1/4 OF SEC 30 TWP 48 RNG 26 LESS BRENTWOOD TWO OF TR 73 UNIT 102 UNIT 103 UNIT 104 UNIT 105 UNIT 106 UNIT 101 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 402 75FT OF TR 54 LOT 14 AND LOT 15, LESS THE LOT 15 LESS E 42.04FT 75FT OF TR 21, LESS S 200.98FT THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1104 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 803 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1103 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 804 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1404 350FT OF TR 14 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 1204 THE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 702 75FT OF E 150FT OF TR 47 C 9 CREEK VILLAGE CONDO AS DESC IN OR 4047 PG 773 244 NKA QUAIL PLAZA CONDO AS DESC IN OR 3239 PG 1806 BUILDING CONDO AS DESC IN OR 4117 PG 2224 -2391 5 47 1 51 70 LESS N 50FT OF W 275.01 FT 21 7 14 12 89 10 53 MORE PARTICULARY DESCRIBED IN OR 4636 PG 1773. 044 045 73 WLY 143.19 OF LOT 15 AND LESS DESC. IN OR 2583 PG 2214 201 503 603 1302 202 102 1 904 5 6 0 1102 1303 1 103 0 0 1403 1 4 504 2 103 0 0 0 704 1402 1202 2 1002 1 1 102 103 104 105 106 101 402 2 14 15.1 1 1104 803 1103 804 1404 0 1204 702 0 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 POList 1000 PL20180002622-PL20180002621.xls 1 /10/2020 NOTICE OF NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Fa- cility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD A Neighborhood Information Meeting hosted by D.'l+lfayne Arnold, AICP of Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A. and John M. Passidomo of Gheffy Passido- mo. P.A.. representing Naples Senior Center at JFCS, Inc. (Applicant) will be held on: Monday, January 27, 2020, 5:30 pm at Hodges University, John White Community Roo rn, 2647 Professional Circle, Naples, FL 341119 Naples Senior Canter at JFCS, Inc. has submitted formal applications to Collier County, seeking approval of a Small -Scale Growth, Management Plan (GMP) Amendment and a Community Facility Planned Unit IDevelapment {.CFPUD) Re- zone. The GM amendment proposes to create a new community facility sub- district under the Golder Gate Area Master Plan to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building for senior services uses in the subdistrict and to rezone the property from the E. Estates Zoning District to GFPUD Zoning District, which specifies permitted uses and development standards for the property. The subject property (Naples Senior Center CFPUID) is comprised of approxi- mately 13.8± acres, located on the southeast corner of the intersection of Cakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 28 East, Collier County, Florida. The Neighborhood Information Meeting is for informational purposes only, it is not a public hearing. Project information is pasted online at www.gradyminor. comJplanning. If you have questions or comments, they can be directed to Sharon Umpenhour, Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A., 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134, sumpenhour(4gradyminorcom, phone 239- 947-1144, fax 239-947 -037 6. N0.[1012- 201 HE NEIGHBORHOOD HBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL2018000 6 1 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD January 27, 2020 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***1>LmASe be- advsed*** The information on this Sheet is to Cogtact you regarding this project and future public meetings_ Under Florida law, e-mail addre$SM phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency_ if you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county recelves a public records request, you can refrain From including such Information on this sheet_ You have the option of checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates an the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional information- NAME. - ADDRESS: 'i6l;L2 PHONE' . 7 75 -,^ ezJ 4 NAME: �. � EMAIL - ADDRESS: PHONE* — — NAME:fC.r firs EMAIL:,T,•,o�,r►r'c���#-f ADDRESS: i 7f 1 •, r� d &7) l .f PHONE: -9 9 V14 01 NAME. - r EMAIL: C 0 )�1 ADDRESS: f PHONE: NAME: A i f �J #� � r' r �✓ EMAIL: o � p � �'4 o # DDRlE53 f') l- PHONE: NAME: " EMAIL: ` ADDRESS: � PHONE: NAME. EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NIM Sign -in Sheet 01-27-2020 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL20180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD January 27, 2020 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***-PteaSe ae.;IO[V%sea*** lrhe information on this sheet is to contact you rega rding th is project and future publicmeetings. Under Fin rlda law, e-mail addresses, phone nurnbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency. If you do not want your e-mail addfess, Phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet, You have the option OF checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as &ecking the county web site for additional Information. NAME: EMAIL. a K t 5 "04/. A�lf ADDRESS: � 6'P1,19 ,, v PHONE: ,1 NAME, S EMAIL - ADDRESS: Z t PHONE: NAME. - o �� , EMAIL: ADDRESS. � 1 '7-mA 5- x PHONE: EMAIL: k/ ADDES U� PFINE:' " NAME: EMAIL. -2-5--cc�0 ADDRESS: PHONE, N I M Sign -in Sheet 01-27-2020 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petlt[ons PL 0180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD January 27, 2020 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY be adVb"z *** The in formal! an on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Flo r da law, e-rnail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency. if you do not want your e-mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site far additlonal fnformation. NAME: %_ .4 tje_� EMAIL. yr e S ,,`' `'`"` •7� ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME: �" _P� y P1 C;kt"J�w EMAIL: V1 Ck/fn.%A r IN i d ' ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME; + EMAIL: ADDRESS. a PHONE: IlAI1JllE: �'V EMAIL:�`` ADDRESS: O J_ J/f,6Jr PHONE: �> 00 NAME: y] } ENTAIL: ADDRESS: �PHONE: s]1 Or ' NAME: � k('1+, 1 EMAIL: .fir. { in e I(.-c'rr'l ADDRESS, r-, i � I �- PHONE: ?I - NAME. �+��� EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME: 44) I EMAIL: ADDRESS: nY,J PHONE: L� NIM Sign -in Sheet01-27-2D20 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL20180002 21 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL0180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD January 7, 2020 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY **•#lease be adv�srd*** The inforrriation on this sheet is tD contact you regarding this project and future public meetings- Under Fiarida law, e-email addresses, Phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency. If you do not want your a -mail address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff on your awn tD obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional information. NAME: /i/ -A/ /:�JJ ADDRESS: �C ,r PHONE: ' 70 NAME: ENTAIL. ADDRESS: L." l 1 r PiONE:fj - r NAME: ADDiRE NAND: ADDRESS: EMAIL: z i� ENTAIL: 4f< PHON : --') l EMAIL: 3 PHONE: NAME: EMAIL: AaDRES r- j PHONE: r?`J` 4. �� , L4 knA NAME: �c � i EMAIL: -r--S f V1 �,"_I_�C Yi ADDRESS: t JL. — - PHONE: - NAME- ?C EMAIL: LA ADDRESS:f PHONE: I ' (_7 NAME: '&4 I � � �1 ENTAIL. '--> PcQJ- CC x l to-+'cw ADDRESS: 62 oAl �) , aicr \ rx Ltd PHONE; - - NIM Sign -in Sheet 01-27-2020 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL 0180002621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center OFPUD January 27, 2020 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY *»* Las be A9VLSed*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings, Under Florida Caw, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain horde addresses are public records once received by a government agency. if you do not meant your e-mail address, Rhone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can reffain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff are your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county Web site for additional information. NAME: l} li [ EMAIL: f 2 .o l2p_ ((Ch Idq , Cd ADDRESS: rJ I] PHONE: NAME: L-. EMAIL: I fJ �+ , _ 11 I.. ��- i ADDRESS: PHONE: ` ottz __ NAME: `rtic.`'1/ � EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME: �� Go ADDRESS: v� 5 EMAIL; L �c •rz, r ff Yt7 S` dl - PHONE: f . NAME,. � � EMAIL: r,AADDRESS; r4 I� PHONE: NAME: EMAIL ADDRESS; PHONE: NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS: NAME: P}IONE: EMAILt ADDRESS: PHONE, N I M Sign -in Sheet 01-27-2020 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING Petitions PL201 000 621 Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL O1 00O 6 2, Naples Senior Center CFPUD January 27, 2020 PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY ***PL4ase be advised*** The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e-mail addresses, phone numbers and certain home addresses are public records once received by a gavemment agency. If you do not want your email address, phone number or home address released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on thE! project as well as checking tine county Web site for additional information, NAME-. i *� �'� / � EMAIL, 6 -- ADDRESS:PHONE- Cp r NAME: ' C EMAlL. >�x+t { r%- 7IPS E) V. to -x ADDRESS: +� PHONE, NAME: E1+1AI1: ADORES 1 39 (2 QUeS f e PHONE NAME. EMAIL: ADDRESS: PHONE: NAME: EMAIL: ADDRESS; PHONE: NAME; EMAIL, ADDRES5: NAME: � ADDRESS: PHONE: EMAIL, -- PHONE: NAME: EMAM, ADDRESS. PHONE: NIM Sign -in Sheet 01-27-2020 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Wayne Arnold: All right. Well, I think we should go ahead and get started. I appreciate everybody who's taken their time out of their day to come and join us. I'm Wayne Arnold. I'm the professional planner with GradyMinor Associates representing the Naples Senior Center. And we had a meeting back in September, and we have some new information we wanted to share with you. So, those of you who were with us a few months ago, welcome back. And I'm gonna do a short presentation to give you the highlights of both the Comprehensive Plan Amendment, and the rezoning application, that are pending before the county. And, uh, then we'll have Jim Banks come and talk a little bit about the traffic analysis that he's prepared. And then we'll take some questions and answers period at the end of the — of the presentation. So, with that, let me get started. And Naples Senior Center — um, many of you probably are aware of what it is — but it's a not -for - profit senior center — social services — for, uh, elderly people in our community. And it's, uh, — a lot of misinformation, I guess, is out - and -about, about what they are and what they're not. But it is a place for seniors to have daily socialization skills. They can take exercise classes, arts and crafts, gardening, financial counseling. Uh, they also operate a small food pantry for the seniors. But there's a lot of things that, uh, they don't do. This is not a residential facility. This is for daily activities for seniors. Um, it — it's — it's a community — as we all know — we're getting older. We have an older population in our community, and the seniors desperately need a place for socialization skills. And also, we have a lot of folks with dementia. And there's a dementia respite care program that's part of the senior center as well. It's not for people who have dementia to live in this facility. It's for people to come and get skills related to coping with, uh, their loved ones who have dementia, etc. The funding for the senior center comes largely through donations and memberships. This is not a county -sponsored, taxpayer facility. This is a not -for -profit agency. So, we wanted to make sure we tell you what we are and what we're not. Uh, the daily programs that they have at the senior center operate between 9:30 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. Monday through Friday. You have to have a reservation in advance to attend the classes and programs that they Page 1 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD offer. So, this is not just a show -up. You have to call in advance and get on their schedule. We'll talk a little bit more about that in a moment. Uh, there's no evening activities here, and there's no weekend activities here. We've got those commitments that are a part of our PUD document. Uh, again, no overnight stays. This is not a residential facility. So, most of you, I think, are familiar with the location. It's about 13.5 acres, located at the northeast corner of Oakes Blvd. and Autumn Oaks Dr. Uh, a portion of the site's been developed with an older warehouse and storage building on the site. And we're immediately south of Church, and we're in direct alignment with Valewood Dr. And I think you're obviously all familiar, if you live in the neighborhood, but Valewood Dr. is a signalized intersection. And the 13.5-acre property is located in this location — will have a direct alignment with Valewood Dr. to that signalized intersection. The senior center is here for several reasons. One, the population shift in our community is shifting to the north and to the east, as we've probably all realized. This offers a location for the senior center — which is a non-profit — they don't want to be in a commercial location. They don't want to be an activity center. They don't want to be in a commercial shopping center. What they do want is enough space so that they can have a nice setting for the seniors to come and enjoy themselves while they're having their activities. It also gives the senior center an opportunity here to create some walking trails, gardening opportunities, and things that they wouldn't have in a commercial shopping center. So again, we're zoned estates, and the two applications we have pending are for creating a new subdistrict under the Golden Gate Area Master Plan that would allow us to have the senior services and social services for seniors. We're also, um, having a concurrent community facility and planning and development rezoning. So, rezoning the property from estates to a planned development. And that zoning change has the benefit of allowing us to create a list of uses that are specifically permitted — hours of operation. It also — in our case, we've listed specific uses that are prohibited on the site. Again, daily senior activities, not a residential facility, and no evening or weekend activities associated with the property. So, this Page 2 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD list of proposed uses we have in the PUD today, we're asking for activity centers for elderly, adult daycare centers, centers for senior citizens, family counseling outreach programs, senior citizen associations, and improved support services for our elderly. These are uses that are largely found under the SIC coding for family social services and our land development code. I think, almost importantly, things that we've added to the PUD is the prohibition on certain uses. So, we're not a soup kitchen. We're not a homeless shelter. There are no residential dwelling units associated with this. We are not an offender rehabilitation agency. We're not a public welfare office. We're not a self-help organization for alcoholics. We don't offer refugee services. And we're not a religious facility or church. So, those are listed in our document of what we're not, and what we're not able to do on the property. We have to create a conceptual master plan. And this represents what's in our plan development document today. So, the — the site — again, access directly from the Valewood Dr. extension into the property. The building area is centered on about 8.5 acres of the property. We'd have, obviously, extensive buffers, water management areas, and then one of the most, uh, critical aspects of what we're doing — there's a 5-acre track located east of the alignment of Valewood Dr. And in our document, that land would be restricted to open space uses or preservation of native vegetation only. So, that would allow the senior center to have possibly some gardens and some walking trails. That also satisfies our preservation requirement with the county as for retaining native vegetation. So, that entire 5-acre track gets nothing but passive recreation or preservation uses on it. We have two access points. One again, I mentioned, at Valewood. We have a second access point on Autumn Oaks Ln. to help disperse the traffic back to Autumn Oaks. We have no, uh, no direct access to Oakes Blvd. This puts it in perspective of an aerial photograph. Again, you can see the alignment directly with Valewood Dr., accessing the Immokalee Rd. intersection. Highlighting lots of green space, soaring around the property, with the central portion of the site for our building on [inaudible] [00:07:201. The property is, again, about 13.5 acres. We're asking for a maximum of 30,000 sq. ft. of building area on the site. Page 3 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD This is a representation of the daily activities schedule. And you can see programming starts at 9:30. It's got a variety of classes that you can sign up for: choir practice, yoga, theater group, card lessons, open gardening, etc. But those are all on a daily activity. And the reason I'm pointing this out, is because I'm gonna have Jim Banks, who's gone back through this as — as we came out of the first meeting that we had with — with the neighbors. We heard a lot of things, and we took a lot of those to heart. We went back, and we looked at the long-term use of this site, and the building, and how we could program it to allow for the senior activities. So, we had Jim Banks go back and analyze the traffic again, which is where I'm gonna turn the floor over to Jim Banks, and let him tell you a little bit about if there's any traffic analysis type scrap. Jim Banks: Thank you and good evening. Um, my name is Jim Banks. I'm a traffic engineer here in Collier County. I've been a resident in Lee and Collier County for the past 32 years. I moved down here in 1986, so I've seen the traffic patterns change over the years. And, um — but I was retained by Naples Senior Center to evaluate the project's impacts on the adjacent road network. Um, when we started the project, um, the, uh — there was an analysis done by the, uh, curators of the Naples Senior Center. And it determined what they projected would be the amount of, uh, of people on -site during the day. And after our NIM in, uh, September, there was a lot of questions regarding, you know, the size of the building. And could you actually have more people in the building that — than that. And then — so, the Naples Senior Center went back and reevaluated, and — and they came back with this, uh, more, uh, comprehensive schedule of potential, uh, classes that they could, uh, accommodate, uh, folks more in the area. And they came up with what they believe to be the absolute maximum — would be 485 people — would be in and out of the site a day. Now, that's not what the Naples Senior Center currently does. It's not what their demand is today, but there is a potential that the Naples Senior Center could — at this new location — grow into a level where they could accommodate up to a maximum of 485 people throughout a day, in and out of the site. And so, the traffic study that we had initially done was based on a lower, uh, usage — Page 4 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD a lower usage rate than what is estimated now. And for those of you that are active and look on the county's website on the documents that are — have been provided for staff to review, you're gonna find a traffic impact study that was done, but it was based on those lower expectations. We are currently have just finished up a new traffic analysis based on the higher expectation of — of the maximum cap of 485 people in and out of the site over a — in a single day. And so, we're getting ready to resubmit that to the county. So, again, for those of you that like to access the county's website and review documents, I submit to you that, uh, in the near — very near future, there's gonna be an updated traffic study that looks at a higher impact than what we did before. Um, again, this is pretty much the forecasted flow in and out of the building. This is — although it's headed up as traffic flow, it's not — it's persons flow. Um, this is the number of folks that are projected to, um, participate in various classes. Some of the members actually attend more than one class. They may come to the site at say, 10:00 a.m. They may do a yoga class, and then they may wait around for 30 minutes or so for another class to begin. So, they may — may participate for more than one — one class. But, um, we projected again that this bottom row should be the number of maximum participants a day that would most likely be accommodated. But then we also said that the maximum cap — even though we suspect on — for example, on a Thursday we would only have 335 people, we still submit to you that we may possibly actually have 485. So, the traffic analysis is based on this higher number. So, what we did is, we obtained traffic counts at the existing location twice on Wednesdays — which, as it turns out, Wednesdays is the — is the day of the week when we have the highest concentration of people in a three-hour period. Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday, the — the — you'll see from another exhibit, the traffic is more spread out throughout the day. But on Wednesday, that's when we have our — our — a period of — of the greatest number of people on -site in one given time, and that's because they have a luncheon on that — that day. And so, what this shows you is — you can see that the traffic enters — starts entering the site around 8:15-8:30 in the morning. That's staff. So, staff is arriving in the morning, and then they start getting ready Page 5 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD for the day. And then you'll start seeing, about 9:15-9:30 — that's when people start coming to the site. And they — they're coming for either class, or they're coming for lunch. And then at about 1:15-1:30, they begin leaving the site. And that's what those higher numbers represent. But if you'll notice, in the mornings, we have nobody leaving the site, because nobody's there overnight. This is a, uh, an operation where people come at 9:00 — there's classes begin at 9:30 a.m. and they conclude by 4:00 p.m. So, we do not impact your adjacent road network, um, on an outbound movement. So, your day — your morning commute to work or taking your children to school — you're not gonna be impacted by this project, because you are leaving the neighborhood. Nobody is leaving this site in the morning. We have staff that are arriving in the morning, and then we start having members and guests start showing up at 9:15-9:30. So, your morning commute is not gonna be impacted by this project. Uh, and in the evenings — what — what occurs after 3:30, uh, 4:00, are people are just exiting the site. So, when you're coming home from either your — your work or wherever — you're coming home in the evening — you're not being impacted, because the traffic leaving is leaving the site, not coming into, uh, the Oakes neighborhood. And this is the Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday counts. You can see it's more evened out throughout the day, and that's because people are just coming for classes. They're coming for scheduled classes. So, again, this is Wednesday. This is the day they have the luncheon. So, we have a more, uh, more people in the condensed amount of time. It's in the middle of the day when the traffic on Oaks and Immokalee and Vanderbilt Beach Rd. are actually at their lowest levels during the day — is — there — in — is in the middle of the day. So, I'll go back again: Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday. So, this is what it's gonna look like for four of the five days of the week it's in operation. And then what we did is we took this data we collected — is, uh, on these days — and then we forecasted it to the future conditions based on that maximum cap of 485. And that gives you something that looks like this. Again, in the morning, you have people arriving to the site, not im — impacting those residents that are trying to leave the community in the morning. And — and then in the middle of the day you have this — at the conclusion of the Page 6 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD luncheon you have people leaving the site. And then in the evening we have staff that are basically leaving from the — for the day. So, again, in the a.m. hours before 9:00 a.m., and in the p.m. hours after 4:00, the amount of traffic generated by the site — literally they're — they're — the impact to your level of convenience isn't even measurable. Now, I will submit to you that on Wednesdays, if you're — if you are leaving the community in the middle of the day on a Wednesday, that's when you are gonna notice a higher traffic demand. But Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to — uh, er 7:00 a.m. to 9:00 a.m. and 4:00 to 6:00 p.m., you are not going to notice any change in your, uh, morning or evening commutes. And this is the Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday's projected to that, uh, higher demand of 485, uh, people in and out of the site a day. So, that concludes my test — uh, my presentation. I'm happy to answer any questions you may have. Wayne Arnold: Let me just wrap up, Jim. Jim Banks: Yep. Oh, that's right. Sorry. Wayne Arnold: Thanks, again, this is Wayne Arnold, and I just wanted to say a few concluding remarks before we open it up for comment. And we are gonna have a — we have a live microphone in the middle, and we'd like to get all this — uh, it's being recorded, as we're required to do for the county. But I'd like to make sure everybody can hear, and make sure that, uh, if you have a question, and we'll do our best to get it answered. We have members of our team here, besides Jim and myself, that will be happy to try to answer the questions you have. But again, reaffirming why we like this site: we think it makes a lot of sense, because it allows us to have a very rural environment. It allows us to have lots of space for elderly people. We can have large building setbacks. We're committed to enhance buffers. We're gonna have 5 acres that are only open space and preserved entirely. Um, we're gonna have residential -style architecture, which we talked about before. And we're going to have direct access to Valewood Dr., as Jim Banks just told you. That's pretty significant, because your community's one of the fortunate ones. You have, I think, three signalized ways in and out of your neighborhood, if you look at Tarpon Bay, Vanderbilt, and Page 7 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Valewood — Immokalee. Most communities are lucky if they have one access point, and most don't have a signalized intersection. So, you have three of those. Uh, again, we've committed that we won't have any weekend or evening use of the property. And then you've seen our limited scope of senior activities that we're committing to. This, again, is our Community Facility Master Plan. And just to conclude — it's in our documents, but we wanted to reaffirm that — no weekend use of the property, no evening use of the property. We're committed to providing you with the enhanced buffers that we've shown you in prior meetings. Uh, we have a list of prohibited uses for the site. Our programming activities would occur between 9:30 and 4:00 Monday through Friday only. Uh, again, our 5-acre track to the east of Valewood alignment's going to be either preserve or open space only. And, uh, we're gonna limit ourselves to the maximum usage of 485 people, as Jim Banks just mentioned to you how we arrived at that number. So, with that, I'm gonna turn it over to anybody from the public who'd like to come forward. And you can — if you don't feel comfortable stating your name, um, you don't have to. It's nice. We really want to know, and so, when the Planning Commission or the County Commissioners read the transcript, they understand that it wasn't one of us who was talking. They'd want to know if it was a member of the public or part of the applicant team. But, uh, with that, if — I'd be happy to have — anybody want to ask us a question, if they could come forward and use the microphone there. Michelle Bracci: I have a question before you start the public. Wayne Arnold: Ma'am, we're gonna have to get you on a microphone, so if you wanna ask a question first — Michelle Bracci: Can I ask a question before we start, like of general feedback? Wayne Arnold: If you'd like to come forward and do that, sure. Michelle Bracci: I was just wondering if you could address a couple things about your presentation before you give the rest of us a chance to, uh, make our comments and ask — and ask questions. You said at the beginning that there were some changes, and I just wondered if you could point out what some of the changes were that gave rise to the second meeting. And then second of all, I wondered if you Page 8 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD would be hosting your presentation, either on Naples Senior Center's website, or if you would have availability for us to get copies of the drafts in part, so we can look at the data. Wayne Arnold: Sure. Tina Matte: We can put it on the website. Speaker 3: Mm-hmm, yeah. Tina Matte: It's newnaplesseniorcenter.org. Michelle Bracci: And then — Wayne Arnold: There's a website, it's called newnaplesseniorcenter.org. Tina Matte: Wayne. Wayne Arnold: I'm sorry, newnaplesseniorcenter.com. Tina Matte: Dot org. Wayne Arnold: Dot org, sorry. Newnaplesseniorcenter.org. Tina Matte: I'll put it up there. Uh-hmm. I can put it up there. Michelle Bracci: And so, the graphs and the presentation will be posted? Wayne Arnold: Yes, and to answer your first question — the reason we're back here was because we had Jim Banks reanalyze the traffic. And even though we're showing higher usage for the daily activities than we had in our prior meeting, I think the conclusions from Jim were the same. We don't have a negative impact on the surrounding roadways as the county looks at that. Michelle Bracci: And so, just in regard to those data graphs — which are hard to read from where we're sitting — when you say people are only arriving in the early morning hours — so, every person who comes to the center is arriving. They're driving himself or herself to the site, and that car or vehicle will remain in that parking lot, and is not leaving, until the time that you say that they're leaving in the afternoon? Tina Matte: No. Page 9 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Wayne Arnold: No. Tina Matte: I think you could get — couldn't you walk through a day in the chart, Jim? Michelle Bracci: [Inaudible —crosstalk] [00:20:31 ] Jim Banks: I'm sorry? Tina Matte: Walk through a day in the chart, so that it's clear what — what those num — the — the activity chart. Jim Banks: You can see on — on, uh, Wednesday morning, you can see we have — uh, let's see if this is the — that's non -existing. Well, what — we'll talk when we project. On Wednesday morning, uh, when we surveyed the site, there was one person that arrived, dropped off a person, and then left. That was one person. And then 30 minutes later, two cars arrived, dropped off two people, and then left the site. So, there were a total of three drop-offs, uh — uh, in the morning. The rest of the people arrived in their own cars, parked in their cars, walked in the buildings, took a class, or it was staff. And that's where I'm saying — so, we're talking one and two vehicles over a 45-minute period. That's not gonna have a measurable impact on your morning commute when you're trying to leave the neighborhood. Michelle Bracci: Okay, so, it's a little bit easier to read standing up here closer. Jim Banks: Yes. Michelle Bracci: That's why I'd like to know if we can have an opportunity to look at it on our own, typically [inaudible — crosstalk] [00:21:421. Jim Banks: And then when we did the — then when we did the Thursday count, nobody did that. There was no drop-offs in the morning. And I will tell you, the reason that there are drop-offs now at the existing site, is because of the — of the lack of parking that they have on -site, and so, it's easier to be dropped off and picked up later. And so, we have a little bit more of that goin' on than what we're gonna have at this new site. But we still analyzed it as if we would have drop-offs in the morning. Page 10 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Michelle Bracci: All right, [man coughs] to make that available, thank you. William: Hello. Jim Banks: Hi. William: Yeah, my name is, uh, William James. And, uh I live at, uh, 5810 Golden Oaks Ln. And I just want to say that my family has been paying taxes in Collier County since 1972, and we've always lived in residential communities. We joined the residential community for what it was worth, and what it gave us in privacy, for our children, you know, security, etc. And, uh, I bought here for that reason. It's a residential community. And granted, you've got a wonderful presentation here, but it's not a residential community. It's a brand of rezoning and commercial. Additionally, with respect to your analysis, Jim, um, I am a business broker, and I — I have an office in my home. And I am in and out all day long, so, your analysis will affect me pulling out on Oakes Blvd., and coming back on Oakes Blvd. And I don't know how many other people that live here have that same issue, but it's an issue for me and my family. But over and above that, it's not residential. And so, I'm against it. I'm gonna vote against it. And I will vote against any, uh, a — a member of Collier County that votes for it. Thank you. Jim Banks: Thank you. [Applause] Stephanie: Stephanie Swang, Oakes Blvd. `Kay, first of all, I don't even know why we're having this meeting. Okay, `cause it's not really any different than the last meeting we had. The only thing that you said was that you had changes in the traffic, which it was worse for you guys, `cause it increased. Right? So, you invite us here because you're trying to convince us how wonderful this property will be for us. Your presentation is fine and dandy for you guys, and yes, it's a wonderful property — of course it is. And it's ideal for you, and the price is right. But the purpose of this meeting is for us to tell you that we don't want you to be putting this building up here. Go get a piece of property somewhere else in commercial. Pay the money — you've got the money. Go get another one. I'm sure there are lots of real estate agents out there who would love to find you a commercial Page 11 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD piece of property that would suit your needs. We don't want it on this corner here. Another thing, um, this here — you can make predictions all day long, but you can't guarantee or promise that that's exactly what it's gonna be. Furthermore, the numbers you have here going on is for that building that you have. Once you come here, you're gonna have a grand opening, and it's gonna be wonderful, and your prog — your programs gonna change. More people are gonna come. That's the whole reason why you're building this, right? So, your numbers are not going to be accurate as to what they're gonna reflect here in our neighborhood, right? Okay, so, another thing. I'm gonna address a couple of issues. Can we go into that picture please? Jim Banks: The aerial, or —? Stephanie: Yeah, yeah, the — with the land around it. No, not that one. Jim Banks: Let me just — let me address one comment that you made, so we don't have to come back, `cause it sounds like you have several things you want to talk about. Stephanie: [Coughs] yeah. Jim Banks: These projections here are based on the 485 people, so we did project what the future site would look like. This — the — the — the blue and the white on these — on these two graphs represent the future, uh, at the — at post site. And the green and the white on these two graphs show what actually occurs today at the existing site. So, go ahead. Stephanie: Okay, but again, you can't predict the future. You can put grass up there and predict it your way. But not in all reality. Okay, so, see this. Now, if you want to convince us to have your — to build this here, you're gonna have to get a lot more creative than that. So, for example, I would say, why don't you, um, make a road that comes only in and out? So, like, here — God, where are we — by this stretch, and then, you know, by this piece of land. And then just have it come in and out. That way you don't come down Oakes Blvd. Or get creative and maybe block it off here. Or give us a guard gate here at the end. We could be a gated community. That would be nice. Page 12 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD And nobody else comes in. Or we want to let these people get out, but maybe that could be your entrance and exit only. And you don't even get on Oakes Blvd. You're gonna have to be a — a little more creative than that, if you, just, kinda want to cut through our neighborhood. Buy another piece of land and put your — your in and out road there. And then that will be it. You know, come — you don't drive down our street. Right? Can you do that? Who owns this property here? Wayne Arnold: I don't know exactly who owns that parcel, ma'am. That's at the corner of Oakes and Immokalee Rd. Stephanie: Yeah, so — Wayne Arnold: I — I would just — you know, I don't wanna argue with you — Stephanie: Just an entrance and exit — Wayne Arnold: —but these are public streets, and, you know, because of the Oakes Association, you've had a lot of traffic alteration of the road network — because of the Oakes Association. But some of those create issues for others, and, you know, you're not going to prohibit somebody from using Oakes as much as we say we want to do that. I don't think that's a practical solution for any of us. Stephanie: There's no entrance from Oakes, so, I mean, but you could make — Speaker 2: Could you verify that — that there's no access off of Oakes? Wayne Arnold: Yeah, we have no access on Oakes. Our access points are on the Autumn Oaks only. Stephanie: Right, but you'll still be able to come out and use Oakes Blvd., okay, right? So, that's that. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. Yes, sir. John: Hi, my name is John. I'm probably the one that's gonna be affected by this the most, because that's my house. That back, so —yeah, that's my house. I like what you're doing, but when I moved here, that property across from me was residential. I know how the county works — I've been in construction a long time — it's all politics, who greases whose hand. Now that's all commercial. Now you're making that commercial. Well, I talked to my attorney. If Page 13 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD this goes through, I'm gonna put a nice gun ranch on my personal property, with a proper barrack. [Audience laughs] I've got three attorneys working on it right now. Plus, I have pet wolves. I don't want elderly people walking on my fence line. So, you say that 5 acres, you know what, give me 50 feet of it, and I'll make sure it's a buffer. Wayne Arnold: Well, I think, obviously, our plan to fix, uh, native vegetation — we're gonna be restarting along your property line — our common property line. John: I don't think the parking lot's that big. Wayne Arnold: No, I understand that. The county has minimum standards that we will certainly, you know, meet, and exceed, those standards. And we'd be happy to talk to you about appropriate buffering next to your house, because we obviously want to be good neighbors, as well. John: No, I mean, I don't — as long as I don't see your property, I don't care. Wayne Arnold: And — and I think, too, we made a commit that on the — the 5-acre track that's immediately adjacent to you, that — that can only be open space or preserve uses. We can't put our parking there. We can't put our buildings there. John: So, clear out all the vegetation, I'll be able to see right into your center. Wayne Arnold: We obviously do have to remove the exotic vegetation, if there's any there. And I'm obviously not the biologist, so I can't tell you how much it is. You probably know certainly more than I do, as being the immediate neighbor. But again, we'd be happy to sit down with you and work out a specific plan for — John: Is your parking lot going to be litted — lighted? Wayne Arnold: It will. It will be required to have security lighting. We — we're not that far along, but certainly — John: Is it going to be on all night long? Page 14 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Wayne Arnold: Um, I don't think it has to be. There's a certain amount of security lighting that will have to be provided. But, uh, I know that in other projects we've worked on, we've had lighting standards. So, we'd be happy to work with you to create standards that benefit the neighborhood and, certainly, respect your properties. John: In the last meeting we had — I forgot the lady's name — but the occupancy load — that rule. Wayne Arnold: That's part of the reason Jim Banks did his reanalysis. I don't know the occupancy load for that building, but we know it's going to be more than the 485 daily patrons that Jim Banks did his analysis on. And we're willing to cap our facility at that as the maximum daily use. John: But it's the fire department who gives you occupancy. They could come in here and say it's 700 people occupancy. Wayne Arnold: They — they very well could. But we're putting a self-imposed restriction on it. John: But that gives you guys the right to go up to 700 people. Wayne Arnold: Not if it's in our documentation. We would put that in our PUD document — that we would be restricted to a maximum daily use of 485 people. John: Okay. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. John: Thanks. Wayne Arnold: Yes, ma'am? Tammy: Hi, my name is Tammy Samuel. We live off of Oakes Blvd. We're approximately, I would say, about five parcels away from where the senior center is supposed to go. Um, I don't want to completely repeat what has already been said, but obviously we moved here — uh, we have two children, and we moved here for our privacy. Um, we also moved because it was close to a high school, and a middle school, and an elementary school. And we take the route that would enter and exit closest to the senior center — so off of Dublin Dr., um, to take our son to Gulf Coast High School if he doesn't Page 15 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD take the bus. And also, when he gets home, those are your peak hours, because the school ends around 2:00, which is at the peak of when most of your members are going to be coming. So, it's going to affect the kids' bus system. They — I don't know if the route goes through Valewood, or if it goes straight along Oakes Blvd. — but you are dropping children off who live and go to school at Gulf Coast High School on Valewood near the church, and then you're coming around. So, it's going to affect the bus route, for sure. Um, and it's also going to affect what time the kids get home, and, you know, if they have an activity after school. It's going to affect us and the children quite a bit. Um, there's a lot of children that live in our neighborhood that go to Vineyards, which is at the end of Oakes. Um, and they have a bus system. So, I mean, you have to take into consideration that it's not gonna just be affecting the residents, but it's also gonna be affecting the children. Um, one thing I just — I guess I have a question about. There's a difference between your commitment and you actually putting it on your does and filing it with the county. So, my question to you is — you're committing to us, and you're saying these are the operating times. And you're saying that it's a commitment. But is that also in your county does? Wayne Arnold: Yes, ma'am. Tammy: Okay, so, you're saying that you're only going to do business until 4:00? Wayne Arnold: The daily programming activities are between 9:30 and 4:00. Tammy: So, if you have a demand from your residents and they want to have a class at 5:00, does that mean that you're not allowed to do that because you have it in your county does? Wayne Arnold: That's correct. We would be prohibited from doing that. Tammy: And if you want to change the times, you would actually have to go to the county and ask for a change in those documents? Wayne Arnold: I would be gunning back through the same process I'm in today. Tammy: Okay, um, so — so, can you show us the page that you're actually Page 16 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD committing to, that you're — that you're putting restrictions on? Wayne Arnold: I don't have the full PUD document here, but we do have hours of restriction that are in there. We also have all the prohibited uses that are there. And then we're making the further commitment — that you heard Jim tonight say — that we're restricting the daily use to the 485 people. Tammy: So, if somebody wants to rent your facility on the weekends or in the evenings, is that prohibited? Wayne Arnold: It is prohibited. Monday through Friday use only. No evenings, no weekends. Tammy: Okay, let me just look at my notes. Um, how do you suggest the conflict with the bus system and the kids — `cause that — that could be — that could have a — a really big effect. Jim Banks: Okay, right now, the bus route stops — they come up Oakes Blvd. and then they stop at Valewood, which is a three-way stop. The kids unload at the bus there. Tammy: No, no, no, they go to the ends of every street along Oakes Blvd. Jim Banks: Oh — oh, oh, oh, oh, okay. Sorry, I thought you were talking about right here at this intersection where we have our access. But you're talking about where the buses — Tammy: Well, yeah, what's gonna happen is they're gonna go down Valewood. They're gonna drop children off to the left of the senior center, and then they're gonna come back around and start dropping kids off along Oakes Blvd. So, all those cars — Jim Banks: At — at — at this location — at this location they unload on the right side of the bus, on this side. And then — and then — I've always seen, uh — uh, parents park here to pick up their children and then leave. I'm not saying, uh, some kids don't walk, I just haven't seen it. I've been there many, many hours. Tammy: Oh, well, yeah, there's kids that walk. I'm mainly concerned about the traffic, obviously. Jim Banks: Okay, so now we're talking about Oakes Blvd., so you're talking about Oakes — Page 17 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Tammy: Well, there's traffic for Oakes, and also the traffic for the residences that are right to the left of the senior center, because there's kids that live there. Jim Banks: Okay, well, we have the bus routes. We have bus routes, not only on Oakes. We have it on Mulligan Blvd. We have it on Wilson Blvd. We have it on Golden Gate Blvd. Tammy: Well, I'm concerned about Oakes [laughs]. Jim Banks: We have bus routes — my point is, is that those roads carry a substantial, uh, greater volume of traffic than what Oakes Blvd. does, and there're yet to be any disruption to the bus routes. The buses will stop at their normal locations, put out the stop sign — by law everyone has to stop when the children are either loading or unloading off the bus. So, the bus routes will not change as a result of — Tammy: Oh, I'm not concerned about the bus routes. I'm concerned about the traffic affecting the kids getting home from school, `cause, I mean, they're already in school by 9:00. So, I'm talking about on the way home. Jim Banks: I guess — I guess my only response is, it's not going to affect the — the children's schedule. I don't know why it would disrupt the — Tammy: Well, if there's a lot of traffic at that time, `cause you're saying your peak hours are 2:00. Jim Banks: Okay, the, um, the traffic on Oakes Blvd., south of Spanish Oaks, is operating with this project at its maximum occupancy of 485 people. It's still at 70 percent of its capacity — operating at 70 percent of its capacity. North of Spanish, it's at 30 percent of its capacity. So, this road is not operating at maximum capacity, and it will not operate at maximum capacity in the future. So, again, I — I — I — I refer to other roads where we have bus routes along Logan and Golden Gate. And there's other roads that carry much more traffic than Oakes Blvd. does. And you're suggesting that the amount of trips generated by this site — Tammy: Well, you — you're talking about having 500 people there. How do you — Page 18 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Jim Banks: Over the course of a day, that's correct. Tammy: Right, but look at your height of your day. It's 1:00 p.m., 2:00 p.m. Jim Banks: It's 1:00 — 1:00 — 1:00 to 2:00. Tammy: Yeah. Jim Banks: Yes, 12:30 to 2:00. Tammy: So, you don't think, logically, that isn't going to affect traffic? Of course, it does. Jim Banks: The bus has the ultimate right of way. They will flow through traffic just like they normally do, and they will make their stops just like they normally do. Tammy: But the traffic is gonna have to — it's gonna — everybody's gonna have to stop. Jim Banks: Okay, well, that's just — that's the way that the system works. Tammy: All right. Well, obviously, you know, I'm explaining to you how it's going to affect our life — Jim Banks: Okay. Tammy: —and it's pretty significant when you have children. Jim Banks: We certainly considered that, and we don't — do not find how this was going to impact the bus routes. Tammy: Well, obviously we disagree. Jim Banks: Okay. Tammy: Thank you. Jim Banks: Thank you. Pam: Hi, I'm Pam Storen, I've lived in the Oakes Estates for 24 years. And one of the things I love about living in Naples is the generosity of its residents and visitors. We only have to look at organizations that have thrived in this county: Neighborhood Page 19 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Health Clinic, Boys and Girls Club, Children's Museum of Naples, St. Matthew's House, the Naples Humane Society, David Lawrence Center, the, uh, Nichol's Community Health Center — which is currently being built on — on 951 — just to name a few. Well, what do all these organizations have in common? They are located on major arterial roadways, not in residential neighborhoods. Each of these boards raised funds — found appropriate non-residential locations to house their organization. And according to the September Neighborhood Information Meeting transcript on page 833, one of your board members said, "We cannot afford a commercial locations." On that loss, why the Naples Senior Center board is unable, or unwilling, to do the necessary work to raise the funds for a commercial location that is not infringing on the residents living in a low -density, semi -rural, residential neighborhood? To ask the residents of Oakes Estates to support spot zoning residential acreage to accommodate an organization that should be located on a commercial activity center on major arterial roads, is something I cannot support. Please, please go back to your board. Do the necessary work. Raise the funds to find an appropriate location for the senior center. Your mission is important. I have no problem with your mission. But your current proposed location is not compatible with the community, nor is it consistent with the Golden Gate Master Plan. Thank you. [Applause] Steve: Good evening, this is Steve Rochee, uh, 6141 Hidden Oaks Ln. Um, following up on the same point as the last speaker, um, this is — the statements — the — the opening by Mr. Arnold in this thing talked about why the senior center wants to come here. They said that they don't want to be at a commercial activity center. They don't want to be at a commercial zoning area. But — and they want to be in a rural environment. Well, we're — we want to be in a rural environment. Why aren't we entitled to have a rural environment and to maintain and preserve our rural environment. This is not a reciprocal situation. We — as we sit here in our community — are a rural, low -density community. This is not rural, low -density. This destroys the character of our community. So, you may like that, and you may want that, but that doesn't mean it's an appropriate use in our neighborhood. No different than, if Publix decided that they wanted to become a green, organic grocer and they wanted a Page 20 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD setting that was a little bit greener — you're not going to put them in our community. They're still gonna have to go in a commercial activity center. They don't have the luxury of having 20 different criteria, and probably making the criteria after they have located the spot. So, they're kinda, like — maybe they could make them meet the narrative that, suddenly, this is the only place in Collier County that fits the bill. Now, another reason why this is incompatible: you're saying that you guys started just a couple years ago. To your credit, you're filling a niche that's necessary in our marketplace. But a couple years ago, Miss Faffer, at the first NIM, talked about the one individual who showed up at the door the first day. And that's how they started this. And then it grew to 200 people. Now they're at 1400. You've outgrown Castello Dr. — congratulations. That's great, because you're providing a need. But you're talking about here — in your FAQ — the frequently asked questions — paperwork that you passed out today. You're saying, "We wanted to be here because of its proximity to I-75." Why? Because it's a regional destination for all of Collier County from Exit 116 all the way down to Exit 101. Your narrowed it — your — your literature says, "Even south Lee County will be served by this." This — our neighborhood is not an appropriate place to put a regional destination. Furthermore, any — you know, Oakes Estates has changed over time. Back in '97 when Destiny Church was first approved, the — the, uh, minutes from the County Commission Meeting talked about how Oakes Blvd. was going to be a two-lane divided highway that would go all the way to Bonita Beach Rd. That — that's never happened. Now we have — it's impossible to Eighth, Quail Creek, and everything else. And on top of there, Hunter's Ridge — it will never get there. Oakes Blvd. is what it always will be, and that's a two-lane road, and, in fact, just in the last couple years, Oakes Blvd. at the top, used to have a traffic light. Well, that traffic light first went away as Oakes — Immokalee Rd. got busier. Then, the left turn movement, that got taken out. They put in the left turn median. They took that out. Now, last year they've taken — they closed the median entirely. That's why you have Valewood Dr. there, which is really just a work -a -round. Page 21 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD It's an imperfection as it is, because of the change in the market, the proximity to I-75, which causes problem with westward traffic, because they need to preserve that. It's important — this is such an important arterial for the county. So — and then the other thing that the county did, is the county reduced the speed limit on Oakes from 45 down to 35, recognizing that this isn't becoming a more appropriate place for a use such as this, but a less appropriate, because they've recognized the neighborhood co — configuration of Oakes. We have eight east -west streets, each of them about a mile long. So, we have 8 miles of residential's homes that rely upon Oakes Blvd. as the only way in and out. Now, with our north entrance on Valewood — how is — how is this — I mean, when you come into a Master Plan Community, you have a feature, right? You have a fountain. You have something like that. What is our feature now going to be as you come south of — of, uh, Immokalee on Valewood Dr.? We're going to have a 30,000 sq. ft., institutionalized, high use building. That's not character of our — you — of our community. Um, up there in the upper right corner above the words "Autumn Oaks Ln." that was the southward PUD office complex that had a COMPLAN Amendment and a rezone from the county three or four years ago — maybe four or five years ago. When that went in, the county staff, the County Commission, the — the Oakes Estates neighborhood made sure that the tradeoff with those folks is that all that stuff south along Autumn Oaks Ln. was preserved. All the way across to kinda the midpoint of that piece. And they agreed that there would be no access whatsoever in order to preserve the interior of our community. Everything had to come and go from Immokalee Rd. And if you go around Oakes Estates and look at all of the non-residential — you know, churches and things of that nature — the one thing they have in common — in common is that all of them are along the perimeter of our community. Which is kinda condi — consistent with conditional use requirements and things of that nature, where there's a hardship. But this is now creeping into the heart of our community, to the southside of Autumn — Autumn Oaks. Why did the County Commission, and county staff, and the Oakes Estates neighborhood put so much effort into preserving that southern half of Southward PUD over by Autumn Oaks Ln., just to Page 22 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD have, a couple years later, this even more intense use — jumps south of Autumn Oaks and come into the heart of our community? I would submit that you guys have a great mission. I think that you're — as much as you've grown — this quickly — I think in a couple years your 200 space parking lot — and by the way your literature says — you — this is — this is, uh, 400 percent larger than the Castello parking lot, which has 50 spaces. But if you go down there, on your — on your, uh, Wednesday meal, uh, weekend, there's probably 85 cars parked there. You have double and triple car — parked cars. There's two gentlemen doing valet parking, so they can keep the keys and shuffle people around. So, this — so, even as you stand in that small square footage building at Castello, you're about half of your parking lot capacity which you have here. So, really, I think you guys need to plan bigger, `cause you're gonna need it in the future, and we are gonna suffer. But we shouldn't have to pay — we shouldn't have to lose our rural community and character, because that's something that is on your guys' wish list. Thank you. [Applause] John B.: My name is John Betcher. I live on Hidden Oaks, also at 5875. And, uh, I almost feel afraid to ask — or note — that I approve of this development. I've been here since 1985, 35 years. When I moved out to Hidden Oaks it was a gravel road with only three 1,000 sq. ft. ranch homes on it. Now we have McMansions of 6,000 sq. ft. selling at God knows what price. Uh, I have seen this area grow and I have enjoyed it — it's growth. Beautiful homes. Beautiful streets. Good neighbors. My own lot is 2 1/4 large acres, so it is rural. I wish I had less land, actually. But I am on just a little bit about where that, uh, electrical outlet is — is where my house is. It backs up to the church. There's a church on Autumn Oaks. There's four churches. No one seems to have complained about those being in the area, drawing crowds. I think this is such a good mission, and the beauty of it — they have these buffers all the way around, protecting, uh, the building, and, uh, the view of the building — all the way around. My only question is for the traffic control: when they leave their luncheon at 1:00 or so, and they go up, I can see that huge — that two hundred and something cars going out Valewood Dr. — will the stoplight there be timed to give a longer length to the number of cars crossing on — into Immokalee? My only negative point — otherwise I think the — there's — ev — everything about this Page 23 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD community — this project — is good. And I'm 83 years old. A lot of people here are maybe edging toward retirement. And I — I love the idea of service to the seniors. So, the traffic light — Jim Banks: Right, uh, this — this traffic signal goes on an actuated system, so as a vehicle pulls up, it sends a signal. And there's a 2 1/2 minute cycle — a maximum cycle length — on Immokalee Rd. And then there's 30 — the maximum allocated is 30 seconds — to Valewood. It doesn't always cycle at 30 seconds, because there's not always somebody there putting a demand on it. So, to answer your questions, yes, there is adequate time. There's 30 seconds allocated towards the Valewood movement. John B.: Now? Jim Banks: Now, today. John B.: But what about — what about when there is — Jim Banks: Yes, that is correct. You can sit out there with a stopwatch and you can time it yourself. By the time it turns green, to the time it turns red, will — is — John B.: Yeah, but the point is — will it — Jim Banks: If there's cars there making a demand on it, it will run at 30 seconds. John B.: It will be more. If a line of cars is there, there will be a longer period than 30 seconds? So, that's what I'm trying to get at — Jim Banks: They cannot — no, there won't be a longer period than 30 seconds as it sits today. The stat — uh, county could actually increase the timing during the middle of the day when there's less traffic on Immokalee, when this cycle would generate more trips. Um, there is a — if you're — next time you're driving up to this intersection, when you pull up here, look on this mast arm and you're gonna see a little ball — it sits here on there like that — they're watching. John B.: Okay. Jim Banks: I literally can talk to the guys, and they can tell me how many people are queued, waiting to get out on Immokalee Rd. So, they can adjust the timing when the demand is needed. And they have Page 24 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD more flexibility during the — the middle of the day. But I'm gonna repeat what I said earlier: during the a.m. peak hours we have no vehicles exiting the site. That's when you have the greatest demand of people left — turning left out on Valewood onto Immokalee Rd. And then the p.m. — we have less than something like 10 vehicles leaving the site a — a — after, uh, 4:30. John B.: That's just fine. I'm thinking of the lunch — lunch. Jim Banks: Right, and — and during the lunch — John B.: If they can — if — if someone's going to adjust that light to allow a line of cars to exit, that — that — that would be fine. Jim Banks: They can adjust the light, but they don't need to right now, because it — John B.: Of course, they do. Jim Banks: —it will go up to 30 seconds of green time for that cycle. John B.: Now, but — Jim Banks: Yes. John B.: —I'm talking about the future. Jim Banks: Yes. In the future. Thank you very much. Yes, uh, yeah, and the — and the county can get more green time in that move way. Bobbi: My name is Bobbi Sutton, and I live on Autumn Oaks Ln. So, this is the intersection that I go through daily to get to my home. My kids catch the bus and get off the bus at this particular point. Um, early dismissal days, my son will be getting off the bus between 1:00 and 1:30. Um, I'd like to know if you've done a traffic study — how many cars can stack up between Autumn Oaks Ln. into Immokalee Rd.? Because as it is now — summertime, I can see as many as six cars sitting there, um, no right turn. So, if somebody's going straight, you're stuck. And I'm looking at 100, possibly 183 cars exiting on a Wednesday? I'm not sure — I mean, the light cycle — Immokalee Rd.'s gotta keep moving. So, to — to think they're gonna adjust that too much to get these cars out, I think is unrealistic. Page 25 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Jim Banks: It — it has a maximum green time for, uh, on Immokalee Rd. of 2 1/2 minutes. It can't run longer than 2 %2. During the middle of the day it does not use up the full 2 %2 minutes, because the demand is much lower on Immokalee Rd. in the middle of the day. Um, but, uh, I — I forgot what your other point was. I'm sorry. Go — go — Bobbi: Well, my question was, how many cars can stack up between Autumn Oaks and Immokalee? Jim Banks: Oh — right — that's — that's — okay. Right, and so, just so you know, that 183 exiting, that's over an hour period. So, that's somewhere around three cars a minute. Over — averaged out over an hour period. Now, they — they leave at — more of a [inaudible] [00:53:241 than that, but I'm just saying, it's over 100 — 183 vehicles per hour will be exiting the site. Um, it's, uh, 12 for the northbound — the left turn lane will hold — accommodate up to 12 vehicles, and the — and the crew and right turn lane will hold up to 12 vehicles. It's 300 ft. of stacking. Bobbi: So, I just want to point out that Autumn Oaks Ln. has a speed limit of 30 miles an hour. It is a residential road. You may as well consider that intersection there a two-way stop, because that's — two sides stop. The others don't. It's pretty common for people to run that as it is. Uh, I just want to, uh, make a few notes that this is my residential community. This commercial building will affect the character of my neighborhood, the quality of my life, the quality of my neighbor's lives. And it will also, um, affect my property value, should I choose to sell. There's no doubt about it. Um, your mission is to help the elderly population, but the way I see it, is that supersedes all the rights of the property owners in Oakes Estates. Because you're doing something that's good, we should just go along with it. Um, and I don't agree with that. You think that doing good for a particular group suddenly makes it okay to infringe on our residential community. And I don't think that's right. Um, I've heard your professions of, "We're not gonna do this. We're not gonna do that." This neighborhood has been burned by that before. Destiny Church is just one example of that. Um, certain conditions were made when that was allowed to be a church many, many years ago. It was a Sunday and Wednesday church service. Now that is an everyday of the week, 24/7 pretty much, in and out. It has Page 26 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD definitely affected the quality of life of those neighbors and diminished their property value. There's no doubt about that. Um, I also, uh, noticed on your flier — you said there was convenient access. This is not convenient access. This is going to be a nightmare. Case in point: on Oakes — Oakes, uh, Seed to Table right now. That is a traffic nightmare there. Um, they have not planned for how that would be. Same thing here. You say you've made all these predictions. You cannot predict what this is gonna be like. If I wanna come home for lunch at 1:00, 1 guess I'm stuck. I mean, that is going to be, uh, it needs to be an — an Immokalee Rd. corridor, that cars can get in and out. Just like the lady before me mentioned about all these, um — um — sorry, what word do I wanna use — all these companies that are doing something beneficial. They are not -for -profit, uh, for people. Um, they're on corridors where they can get in and out. Immokalee Rd., maybe Golden Gate Pkwy., some of those roads — that are not 30 miles an hour residential roads. Um, and I would just — proposed to you that, you know, I know that you think this is a great spot for you. And it is a great spot for you. It's a great deal. But you, again, are infringing on my rights as — as a neighbor, as, you know, having my home here. Um, and I'm completely against this, and I wanna go on record in saying so. Thank you. [Applause] Peter: Hi, I'm Peter Goodan, and I've lived in, uh, Oakes Estates, Unit 97, for 20 years. I live on Spanish Oaks Ln. I just wanted to fill in a few gaps. Uh, first for Mr. Betcher. Unit 97 has seven churches in it. A lot of people in Unit 97 figure they've paid their social tax. Um, the other two comments, uh, that I want to enlarge on, are for Mr. Arnold. Um, you've heard by now that the — the issue for the neighborhood boils down to traffic and trees, essentially. Um, on the topic of trees, you said you're not a biologist, but you know that they'll make you clear out all the exotics. I am a biologist. I work at Driftwood Nursery. Um, I moved here long enough ago that most of the people moving in wanted the trees on their property. And the county rules that are requiring us to take out, uh, exotics are actually hammering the native trees, because you drive heavy equipment over a slash pine's roots in the process of getting out the Page 27 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD melaleuca that's in between every single slash pine and the next one. Those trees are gonna live one more year, and then they'll die. And everybody in this neighborhood has seen this happen over and over and over again on houses that are built to the left and right of them. Just to let you know, that year it'll look pretty good. But the — the gentleman that lives next door — he can't count on that being a green belt. There's no way to get rid of those things — those melaleucas and [inaudible] [00:58:401 without putting the — the — the native vegetation at risk. My other comment was about traffic. Uh, you made an assertation that the local community group has gotten the county to do a lot of things for it, in the way of traffic. I just want to correct the misimpression they can have. The founder of this group is Nancy Barrens, um, one-time wife to Jungle Larry. She lived on my street. And one day she got up, and the dump trucks that were going to build the development to our east — so turning to Lakes — were using Spanish Oaks for the construction entrance at that time. Uh, Logan had yet to be built. Um, that was the genesis of our group. Before that had happened, the county moved the roadbed of Logan and put it right next to, uh, houses in our neighborhood without any information to us. It was a concession the county made to allow Island Walk and other large developments to not have a street penetrating their property. They said, "Can we move this street? Trade you this amount of right-of-way for that amount of right-of-way?" And the county said, "Okay." When Tarpon Bay was built, the county put a light in. It coexisted with our light at Oakes, uh, um, for a few years. And then we were told that you couldn't have two lights that close together along Immokalee, and our light was gonna have to go. So, another delayed reaction kinda problem. The reason that Valewood has a light, and that you've got access for what would turn into your front drive, is that we asked for, and got, the Valewood extension built. That doesn't mean that — that we're getting concessions from county traffic. We're — we're negotiating from behind the eight ball on most of this stuff. When Tarpon Bay was built, the access road off Oakes Blvd. was supposed to have been Standing Oaks Ln. At the county level, they Page 28 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD got changed it to Spanish Oaks Ln., which is my street. And the reason is that Tim Constantine lived on Standing Oaks Ln. So, I just want you to know, if and when the county ever does anything for us in the way of traffic and roads, it's generally after a lot of pushing and shoving, and too little too late. Thank you. [Applause] Sinao: Hi, I'm Dr. Sinao Pundy. I live at, uh, 2391 Oakes. So, just to quickly go up there. I'll just point to my house. Oops, this is my house right here. So, there's, uh, my entire front yard, and our view is of the, uh, proposed senior center. The only way out for me, and my — my family, my wife, my children, is this intersection which is on the corner. And, um, we've lived there — we bought it in 2015 from Mr. Ken Carter, if you guys know him, um, [cough] uh, because of the garage. And I was good friends with him, and he since passed along. Um, I'm in favor of the Naples Senior Center. And I don't wanna — like he says, please don't lynch me. Um, [cough] I w — I've been — I wanna talk to my neighbors. I think that it's okay to have differences of opinion. Um, I think it's okay to vote opposite and still be neighbors and friends and I hope that we can do that. Um, my reasoning is, uh, to get up today, was only to comment on a few points. I just think, you know, I'm just — I'm a little forlorn, um, because there's so much misinformation. And if people would get into one room, and have a common conversation on both sides, and try to understand — `cause I love my neighbors on Oakes, and I love, uh, the people behind me. And even those who vote no, um, they will continue to be my friends. I wish some of what they want to see happening here, um — someone said, "Get creative." Whatever has to happen, let's try to get to a position where we can all, uh, live together. Um, and, that can only happen if people are actually talking. I've sent a number of emails, conversations, texts, phone calls trying to get, um, the association to talk to me. The association to talk to you guys. You guys talk to them. I just wish there was a lot more communication, `cause there's so much misinformation. And even afterwards, if you vote no, that's great. That's your — that's your right, and a lot of people — what you guys have said, have spoken to — it's really — really touched me — some of the things that you guys have said, on both sides. Page 29 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Um, so, let's talk about when someone says — says, "Well, what's our feature going to be?" Right now, our feature for the last 30 years, has been a rundown warehouse — where my wife is scared to walk our three dogs — rusted fence, that the current owner refuses to, uh, fix. It says, "Keep out," even though children — and I can prove it to you — use their — their — and, you know, whatever the children do on the property. There's wild animals. Um, there's bobcats that we've seen there. Um, you know, we've hit possums that come out in the middle of the night. It's dark. Um, it's not as if this gentleman is going to sell this to five millionaires to build five properties. He's not going to. I've spoken to him. I've tried to buy this property from him for the last decade. He's not going to do it, and his sons don't want to do it. So, at this point, my entire front yard just looks at this warehouse. And Mr. Carter, who I bought it from, said — he moved it in 1990 — says, "Man, they've got to do something with this property." This is something. It might not be perfect to everyone's specifications, but I believe it is far and beyond a great, uh, entrance way and location between — and — and we should be talking about what landscaping we want, and what matches we want, and what the fence should look like. And should there be a water fountain? And can there be a park for Oakes here? And can there be walking trails for our children? And, you know, can we have permissive use for our — our families here on — on — on nice weekends, if we want that? And, what else can we negotiate? This isn't, you know — this life's about compromise and negotiation. Uh, not about saying, "Not in my backyard." And I know a lot of people have said that they've had a, um — we don't want to debate, uh, Naples Senior Center. And I know that those who oppose it are not saying that seniors are bad, or anything like that, but — um, at all — and I understand that. But you sometimes have to accept things in your backyard. Anyone from Naples who is a consultant, like me, who is a physician, who does work in construction, who is in real estate, owes everything they have to the seniors in Naples, because they're the ones who created this place. It's not the 40-year-olds like me, or the 13-year-olds like my daughter. I want her to vo — volunteer there. I want to volunteer there. I want to give back to the people who have — who have created, uh, Naples to be what it is. And that's — that's the seniors. Page 30 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD And finally, um, Mr. Jay Baker, who's one of the proponents of this site, and who has — wants to put his name on it and — and donate. I don't want to — anyone to think that this man is just some rich billionaire that comes out of New York. He's a humble guy. I've been on the subway with him in New York. Um, and he's a loving man, and those of you who have agreed, uh, with me to meet him, have been in tears meeting this guy in how much he wants to help the community, and palliative care, and all that he does for us. And I don't think that you — to put a Baker Center anywhere in your community decreases, uh, equity or property value in Naples in any way. I think it'll have a big investment. I think it's gonna increase my property value. I don't see, uh, the traffic patterns. I think there's wonderful questions about, you know, what are we gonna do here? And traffic and let's negotiate. Let's talk. Let's sit down, instead of having two sides to this and being so against it and for it. And, uh, I just wish the ego would — would go down a little bit and we could all have conversation. So, thank you. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. [Applause] Michelle: Uh, so my name is Michelle Bradley, and I'm, um, an owner of 6141 Primrose Site. And so, our property abuts the, uh, southeast corner of the senior center. And a lot of the things I had wanted to mention have been talked about tonight, so I'll just — Wayne Arnold: Where is the microphone? Can you put it a little closer to her — Michelle: I'll just touch on a few of them. Um —um, the — the last gentleman who spoke, and a lot of the information we've received tonight — including the way the most recent mailings — were addressed to friends and neighbors. I think they go to the emotional arguments that are being made here tonight. To me, it almost seems like the whole purpose of this second meeting is to address and sort of justify many of the emotional arguments that the senior center is making for them to make their new home within our residential neighborhood, when they're definitely a commercial, high - intensity, industrial -use that is more appropriately located in, um, a comparable commercial and industrial setting. Um, a couple things that I touched on last time that were, uh, Page 31 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD discredited by Miss Faffer and the senior center — I went back and looked at. And I wanted to address them tonight. Um, some of the things that I had looked on the Naples Senior Center website, uh, pertain to their current schedule. Um, it was set forth in a number of public, uh, fliers, including the ones given us today — although these are slightly tweaked from the ones in the time frames given previously. Um, you guys used the word, "primary service hours". They began at 10:00 a.m. and end at 3:00 p.m. And it was stated that staff arrivals and a limited number of individual appointments with counselors or clinicians would occur before 10:00 a.m. The website showed back in September, and still shows, a number of things starting with actual start times before 10:00 a.m. For example, 9:30 Shine, 9:30 Choir Practice, 9:45 Watercolor, 9:30 Intro to Thai Chi, 9:45 Guide Time. 3:00 p.m. begins the Happy Ukulele Group. 3:30 begins the Sing -Along. 3:30 begins the Coping with Transitions. And 3:15 begins Ballroom Dancing. It was also previously — so, if those — those programs are starting at those times, I can only anticipate that they're hour-long or 45- minute-long sessions. That puts the end time as late as 4:00 or 4:15 p.m. Wayne Arnold: That's correct. Michelle: And then, also, uh, it was previously stated that there weren't double -booked timeframes. I saw examples of Crafts and Beginner Line Dance Steps both at 1:00 p.m. Writer's Workshop Memoirs and Square Dancing both booked at 2:30 p.m. Also, when you page back through the calendar on the website, there are two things listed on Saturday. One was Saturday, April 16, 2016, and it was a Saturday veteran's service. Another one was Saturday, December 8, 2018, for a brass quintet. Finally, there's a number of special events that appear to be largescale, public events that are advertised to the evening and/or Saturday events. And while it has been stated at the last meeting that those types of preeminent gatherings would never occur at the center itself, because they would need a much more formal setting, I find it hard to believe, given some of the other misrepresentations, that the Naples Senior Center would not want to showcase its new location to its shareholders and donors and hold these types of events at the actual center. Page 32 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Which again, would bring in the same types of misrepresentations that our neighborhood has had to deal with, for example, with Destiny Church. Where the scope, and hours, and the creed of the mission are just extended into every day of our lives. Um, another owner mentioned the issue of not just traffic, but as it pertains to the school system and busing. And I wanted to point out, I have two children, um, both which ride the bus and have ridden the bus, um, elementary, middle, and high school, for regular bus hours and the activities buses. It is mandated by the Collier County School System that the children only exit or enter the bus on the side of the street on which they live. So, for us, my children have to only get on the bus or get off the bus on the eastbound north or south trip. That means that they have to walk along the eastbound north -south border on a two-lane road that is heavily trafficked. Whatever the rate is that you want to say — with no sidewalk, no path — they're walking up in the grass, before dawn, and in the dusk hours. And now we're adding all of this traffic, with also, what you said earlier, was a lot of people driving themselves to the center. And the cars remain there. That raises even more questions for me about who exactly is driving there, and are those people, you know — at what stage of dementia, or other sort of, um, you know, mitigating factors that may add to traffic incidents along the border — raise public safety issues with our children, you know, before and after school hours. And I think it's something that you guys need to take a stronger look at. Um, finally at the last meeting, um, at the end of the meeting, Miss Faffer extended an invitation for people to come and observe the senior center, um, to look at the parking lot. I had an opportunity to do that a couple weeks ago. It happened to be a Wednesday that also led into the lunch hours, um, and it was utter chaos. Double, triple parked cars, not only in your parking lot, but also along the residential and other commercial, uh, roadways of that neighborhood. Um, there were valet people parking cars. There were numerous large transport vans, uh, vehicles such as, like, the Collier Paratransit size vans, uh, vans and buses dropping on multiple trips throughout there. It was absolute mayhem. And our neighborhood will be the next recipient of that mess. Um, our streets are not set Page 33 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD up for that kind of parking. It will increase the danger for people biking, walking, running, and getting off — on and off the bus, along the Oakes and the side streets. Um, I want to end by just saying, again, our neighborhood is just that. It is a neighborhood. We are not a high -intensity industrial or commercial hub. And we are not a regional destination. And we'd ask that you please take another look at your other opportunities for purchase. It may not be economically as, um, attractive as buying and going through this process, but it would definitely be more appropriate. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. [Applause] Brudy: Yes, hi. Brudy Bershowski. I live off, uh, English Oaks. I just have a question for [inaudible] [01:15:03]. Um, I see a lot of experts and, uh, different professionals working on the project. Has anybody looked at whether or not a project like this works on a similar property somewhere in Naples? Historically, Logan Woods, Livingstone Woods, Pine Ridge Estates — has anybody done something like this? Wayne Arnold: Um, well, this is one of the two senior centers in Collier County, and the only one that has activities that we've described. So, no, there's not another senior center — Brudy: I just think it's not fair to put the experiment on residents like myself, my family, and the neighbors. [Applause] Wayne Arnold: Could I — I would say, as the gentleman mentioned — you already have seven churches and the Oakes Association. They're not all on the perimeter, and what we're proposing is not dissimilar to what would be a church function. Brudy: Well, I think it's unique to what its function is. It's a little bit different than what we have — Destiny has. I just think adding something else would be a burden to the community, and to conform to what it is right now. I just want to share that, because, um, I think that if you've done something that's not out there, we're betting on, um, predictions. It's great if you predict correctly, but it's not good if you missed a prediction. And in hindsight, making certain decisions — it's gonna be very tough to go back. In most cases you can't reverse what you've done. Page 34 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD I've been in Naples for almost 20 years. Um, I think most residents would not believe what it is now compared to what it was before. Even to this day there's more things that are being built off Immokalee, including a new high school that we built. Um, we cannot bet on people's predictions in driving patterns. Um, so, I — I think that, just in terms of traffic itself, I find it very difficult to believe — I'm not a traffic expert. But I looked at some of the data. It's very hard for me to interpret. And there's gonna be another part of this question, as far as, like, how are these traffic studies done? Just because I don't understand how, if you don't have the facility there now with no traffic, and how you put a facility on there with cars going in and out with a capacity of 485 people, and it doesn't attract — it doesn't attract — it doesn't affect the traffic pattern now. I just don't understand that. How there's nothing there now. There's no traffic going in and out. It's secluded. It's fenced in. And by putting a facility such as you're explaining, does not affect the traffic pattern in going forward. I just don't understand that. Um, so, maybe you can help me understand that. The other thing is that I've lived in the Oakes Estates area for, um, 11 years. Over the course of 11 years, I've seen traffic patterns change, even without the facility you're talking about — or, proposing. Um, I have three children. They go up and down my street — the Oak — Oak — down Oakes, visiting neighbors and friends, including going to the park that's very close to the proposed location. I think that's, um, uh — safety becomes a concern, because what happens is the traffic flows the path of least resistance. Who would have thought that the Immokalee train going left into Oakes is gonna be closed down? I never thought that. Going and moving it. It was open. I was able to do that. Who would have thought that there's gonna be a huge shopping center in that area that's gonna attract too many people cutting from Tarpon Bay area, and including — there's a stop sign that many people blow it off going into the park, which, kids are walking. And — and — and people are walking their dogs. And traffic is just zooming in and out past these stop signs, making left turns in a no -left -turn. And we're focusing on a lot of, like, the entryways where the facility's is being proposed location. But I think that over the years, what I've noticed, it's not only the access points. There's no way to predict which end of Oakes they're gonna be going Page 35 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD through. So, if you're going to come through the Vanderbilt side, guess what? I'm guessing more traffic to that point, and things are just gonna get backed up. And that means the side streets are having to wait until all the cars pass by. The community's already struggling with speeders. Very often they get pulled over. Very often they don't get pulled over. Um, I don't know if anybody's done studies on accidents in that area — it's one way each way. Also, it's been brought up, the busing for the children. You know, I think that it's not the best set up as it is now. I have three children going to three different schools, three different bus schedules. The way that they're set up as far as waiting on the corner — and I'm not sure — did anybody do the studies on that — when that happens — when the kids — safe, and stuff like that, in regards to safety? Jim Banks: Um, uh, what? Could you please repeat that? Brudy: Did anybody who studies — in terms of when the school starts — how the kids wait for the bus from where they are, and the timing of the day? Jim Banks: Yeah. Brudy: You have it? Jim Banks: You said something about three to four at a corner? I'm sorry, you said something about three corners, that's what got me. Brudy: No — Jim Banks: Yes, we looked at that. Yes, we looked at that. Brudy: Okay, so, so, do you see how sometimes you can't even see where the kids are waiting? Specifically, when you come in one direction or another? Or if you have a utility vehicle, or if you have a trucking — the garbage trucks come — you can't even see sometimes. So, that's — it's a regular struggle in terms of safety. So, adding more traffic to that, I think, it's just — it's just more conflict. Jim Banks: There's nothing unique about Oakes Blvd. or Autumn Oaks, or any of the other roads in Collier County where we run school buses. Page 36 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Brudy: So, can you tell me — so, these reports that you've generated here, I — I saw them. Can you tell me, when you say, "Traffic re — traffic studies are done," I should say, how do you do that? What does that mean, exactly? Jim Banks: There's a specific guideline that Collier County requires we follow, and as I said earlier in my presentation, we're gonna be submitting an updated traffic impact study based on these new projections — which is on file, so you'll be able to have access. And it should be there within the next couple weeks. Something that you can review. Um, so, there is a specific criteria. There's specific level of services that we analyze, based on standards that are adopted by Collier County. And we're all subjected to those standards. And, uh, as you — as you look through the report, you're gonna find where it's spelled out. And we tried to do it in layman's terms, so people that are not traffic engineers can read these things and are understandable. Brudy: So, tell me — are you an independent contractor that was hired to do this evaluation? Jim Banks: I was, uh — I work on behalf of Naples Senior Center, that's correct. Brudy: Okay, so, can you tell me — at least give me a couple of things — do you — do you just stand there and just watch how many cars go one way vs. the other way? Jim Banks: We go — Brudy: Just — just to understand it — put it in — in layman's terms, because I'm not an expert. Jim Banks: We collected traffic data in the Oakes neighborhood, on three separate occasions. I've been out there numerous times taking photographs of the traffic flow, monitoring the traffic flow, and we count — we collected traffic data at the existing Naples Senior Center on three separate occasions. And all this information is compiled — compiled in order to look at what's on a — what's in and around the Oakes neighborhood today and what it's gonna look like when we add the traffic generated by the site. Page 37 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD And I would like to point out, just because this is all recorded for the record, I never said that the proposed site would not have an impact on your road network. What I said is, is during the a.m. peak hours when we don't generate traffic, and the p.m. peak hours when — that's when the traffic is at its highest volumes. The — the traffic generated by Naples Senior Center will not have a measurable affect on your traffic flow during those periods — during the, uh, middle of the day when they generate traffic, you will see — Brudy: But this is going based on predictions. If you take one location, you can have one traffic flow in one pattern, you take that exact thing, put it in a different location, you can have a different volume. You can have a different flow. You're talking about 75. You're talking about a bigger volume. And perhaps now that it's more accessible — this is why you like that location — what if people say, "You know what, I'm gonna have this activity at 8:00, I'm gonna go have lunch. I'm gonna come back"? Or if, with more people getting dropped off, guess what? That's two trips. One in and one out. Jim Banks: We — we — we account for that — Brudy: I mean, that's — all that — and now again, these are all predictions. You can't — Jim Banks: I'm gonna summarize it for you very quick. I've been doing this for 32 years. I have done thousands and thousands of studies. And we've gone back and validated the results of those — of those studies. And, the — our predictions are pretty much dead on. I'm not saying there isn't some slight deviation from what we've done in the past. But I have thousands of reports on record that you can review at any time or go compare these — these sites anytime. Brudy: So, along that same line, were there studies done based on increased traffic in the past, let's say, ten years, or five years? Jim Banks: Yes, we took that into account. Brudy: What about that? So, what is — is there a 20 percent increase every year, 30, 50? I mean, just, give me something, since you've been working on a project in other states. Jim Banks: Well actually — actually the traffic on Oakes Blvd. going to Page 38 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Spanish Oaks has actually decreased, uh, since they removed the traffic light. More people now use Spanish Oaks to get on Tarpon. That's just a — it's a — it's a fact. [Background chatter] The county has the record — you can — you can search the record yourselves. Wayne Arnold: If I might, we only have the room for a short period of time. There's another gentleman behind you, and not that we don't want to answer your questions, but if he'd like to have a discussion with Mr. Banks regarding traffic, I'm sure he's be happy to do that. Brudy: Okay, thank you. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. [Applause] Ross: Hi, Wayne, my name is Ross MacIntosh. I live very far away, but I'm here with my cousin, Gordon MacIntosh, who lives at Tarpon Bay. Wayne Arnold: Great. Ross: Uh, as you know, there are actually two petitions in process here. I don't think your exhibits exactly make a distinction between the Land Use Planned Amendment, which you're asking for, and the rezoning, the companion petition for rezoning. I notice that the rezoning is a 13.5-acre site, but the Comprehensive Plan Amendment only addresses 8.7 acres of the 13.7 acres — Wayne Arnold: That's correct, yes — yes. Ross: —which means that the 5-acre tract is not bound by the same land use regulations that the 8.7. Why is that? Wayne Arnold: Because it's less than 10 acres, it's considered a small-scale amendment. Ross: What was that? Wayne Arnold: It's considered a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment if it's less than 10 acres. So, the area where we want to put the — the facility, the senior center, and its parking and all of its services — are on less than 10 acres. It's on the 8.7-acre parcel. That's why there's a distinction in the acres. Page 39 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Ross: But the — but the site is 13.7 acres, so — Wayne Arnold: Our zoning application includes it, and as I've described previously, 5 acres of that is open space and preservation. Ross: But not by land use designation. Wayne Arnold: That's correct. Ross: Only — only by zoning. Wayne Arnold: That's correct. But I don't have a land use approval to put a senior center on that 5-acre track. Ross: No, not at this time. Wayne Arnold: Yes. Ross: But certainly, it seems to us, that the neighborhood might take some comfort in seeing if the zoning is going to be changed, seeing that the land use encompasses the entire property. Here's an idea: I think it would be a very good idea to have a seniors housing facility, an ACLF, on the 5 acres which is not encumbered by an obligation — a land use obligation — to limit development of the entire site to 30,000 ft. So, let's come in later and ask for a rezoning of the existing zoning, and a conditional use because seniors' group housing is a permitted conditional use — is permitted under conditional use. It — it just seems to me that there's a latitude under the current circumstance — there's a latitude for the future development of the 5 acres. It might be less accessible if the entirety were encumbered by the land use change. [Applause] Wayne Arnold: Well, to speak to that point, Ross, I don't — I don't agree with you entirely, because the 5-acre parcel that we're showing meets our open space and preservation requirements for the project, that the county requires. So, I don't think I could just come back at some future date and eliminate those features. Ross: So, your required open space — the — the 5 acres provides your re — required open space, and could not be developed for any other purpose, unless you provided open space elsewhere on the site? Page 40 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Wayne Arnold: That's exactly — Ross: Is that correct? Wayne Arnold: That is correct. Ross: Okay, thank you. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. Stephanie: I have to disagree with that, Wayne. Wayne Arnold: Yeah, ma'am, do you mind if he goes? He hasn't spoken yet, tonight? Stephanie: Well, it's real quick. I've got a bottom line here. But just to respond to what you said — have you seen how, uh, Orange Blossom and Airport, that big, uh, senior living facility is put — how awful it looks? Speaker 4: Yeah. Stephanie: Do you know what I'm talking about, next to the Greek Orthodox church? It's hideous. It's, like, it can only go three floors high, because that's the zoning requirement — three floors. Um, again, I've been here — we built our home in '90 — '93 — CO January of '94 — I've been here a long time, 26 years. Oakes Blvd. was a nice country little road. We loved it. We have three children that we raised, we have dogs, cats, all that stuff. So, we enjoy the use of it. What everybody here needs to know is that, they don't have a right to this. This is a residential neighborhood. You — you know, if they want to bully us into changing it, we have the upper hand right now. They would like to rezone it. We don't want to rezone it. It's residential and we want it to stay that way. I personally would love to see an equestrian center on that property. Stables, horses, a ring — we — we had one before. If anyone else is a horse lovers here. That would be beautiful there. And we could make it up like Pine Ridge. We could make it an equestrian facility. So, the bottom line here is that, you're not giving us any reason to tell us why we'd want to have this. We're a residential neighborhood. We want to stay a residential neighborhood. And Page 41 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD that's it. That's the end of that. And we need to get everybody out. This is not a good turnout. We need to get more people in our neighborhood to come here and gather together and say, "Hey, this is our neighborhood. It's residential and it's gotta stay that way." Wayne Arnold: Thank you, ma'am. Stephanie: Okay. [Applause] L.J.: My name is L.J. Noel, and I live on Standing Oaks. We've actually owned, uh, two homes in the Oakes Estates. One of the reasons we moved here is because of the way it exists. We have space. We have acreage. Not a lot of traffic when we first moved here, but it's been getting dramatically worse over the years. But you talk about traffic flow. We had one gentleman that was talking about the impact of turning onto Oakes. I know every morning, depending on what day it changes a little bit — but I usually am there 8:45, 9:00, when I'm turning on Oakes. I wait a lot of times — sometimes I wait for 10 or 12 vehicles in a row to pass me, which is in line with when your first morning shift is coming in. Maybe that's not a substantial impact to traffic — I don't know. But it is a safety hazard. Uh, also, if we look at the intersection coming off of Immokalee onto, uh, Valewood — I consider myself a good driver. I've never been a cause of an accident. But I know twice, I've actually messed up on that turn, turning off of Immokalee, because of that, uh, divider there in the road. I turned down the wrong side of Valewood. So, the way that's set up is a little awkward. Also, as you go out onto Autumn, on the corner of your property where you're turning onto Oakes, uh, there's been a few occasions where I've watched cars in front of me almost get hit at that intersection. And now we have a group of seniors, that are coming to this facility. I'm a financial advisor. I deal with a lot of seniors. I know the accidents they get in. I know the senior center — centers they attend and the groups they go to. And it scares me a little bit for our community being a neighborhood. Not a place where people should be going for a YMCA or a, uh, place to congregate. That's not what the road structure is set up for. But putting the roads aside, it's a neighborhood. We purchased here for that purpose. Where we used to live, we ended up with a commercialized multi -story building that got built — built right Page 42 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD behind our house in our neighborhood. We moved from that location because of that. Our property values — we happened to get out when it was happening — I'm friends with the people who bought our house. Uh, their value over the last, uh, four years — when real estate's been doing well — is up about $3,000. They just sold their house from when we originally owned it. So, when you look at property values, you look at traffic flows, you look at people, you look at safety. It's all a concern. But, uh, you can make numbers say whatever you want to with traffic, or with the number of people coming into events. I understand, but I see a lot of discrepancies. One of the — the ladies was mentioning this in her comments. But for example, on the brochure you handed out today, it says the vast majority of programs take place between, uh, 10:00 a.m. and — and 3:00 p.m. Well, on your schedule you have events starting at 9:30, so — discrepancy —numbers. You can change those schedules. You can have more things start at 9:00 if you want to. There's nothing that restricts when those events can change, or what it does for traffic flow. And as it was mentioned, you know, if the events were ending at 3:00-3:30, they last for an hour, that's already getting into traffic. Traffic in Naples, I think, uh, has, uh — Jim would know — starts getting a lot heavier at 4:00. That's exactly the time that something that starts later, and it affects the Oakes. When I come home during the day, sometimes it takes a long time. I know this year which [inaudible] [01:33:121 season, turning off of Oakes onto Vanderbilt, or onto Immokalee, is very difficult somedays. And you say with people coming in. Well, those people coming in are the same people that are coming off of Vanderbilt to turn onto Oakes to come through. Some of my clients live in the Vineyards, and they attend the Naples Senior Center events. They love it. It's a great organization. But now they'll be coming this way from the Vineyards down to Oakes, down Valewood, and so forth. So, it — it definitely is a — going to be a change from what it is. But I think the bottom line is, yes, there's some churches. Their small churches. They don't have the traffic flow. They're on the outskirts of the property of the Oakes Association. They're not in the middle. Basically, your plan puts you on three sides surrounded by residential. It's basically encroachment in the neighborhood I Page 43 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD purchased in — that I moved into — because I wanted my family to have a place to live that had space around it — that had the peacefulness and the quietness. And I think, the other thing that's really interesting to note — and I'm on a couple of charities and so forth too. I understand numbers. But it says here that it's of the best interest and under our fiduciary obligation and our budget constraints for this property. Yes, I've bought real estate too. I would love to buy a residential property and turn it into a commercial property. I could make a lot of money doing that. So, the question becomes, when we're having these meetings — I think it was alluded to. What's really changed? Where's the negotiation? Are you making this about the fiduciary responsibility to the board of directors, or are you making it about the fiduciary responsibility of the Oakes Association and the people that live here that have spent their hard earned money, to set up roots here? I don't think you are, because you said it clearly. It's to your financial best interest and your budget constraints to build this in the Oakes. Not on a commercial property somewhere else where it has better traffic flow, is safer for the residents, for their kids, and for the adults. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. [Applause] This is going to be our last speaker. John N.: Well, uh, John Nicole. I live on Hidden Oaks Ln., 5690. Uh, that's, uh, kind of a perfect segue, what we talked about being stewards of our environment, of our residential neighborhood. This is a commercial use in our residential neighborhood. And the last time I came up here and talked about it and said — we had last March, we did our — our annual meeting, and there was over 100 attendees and not a single one was in favor of its use. It was 100 attendees in March. Now since that time, we have gotten over 240 letters in opposition to this. Now, I'm not saying there's not people that are — that approve it or want this use, but we've got that many people in a — in a community like this where we'd live in the estates for a reason and we — we — by design, not social, as we've heard before from Peter. Um, that's a hell of a lot of people who come out and — and support our position of opposition to this. We don't want this. This is a residential use — residential community. The use is not compatible with this. Page 44 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Um, you know, one thing that has also come into play, Oakes Blvd. as we said went from 45 to 35. There's also gonna be — there's a Standing Oaks PUD that's gonna be built between Standing Oaks and Shady Oaks. Once that's done, in order to get their building permit, there's gonna be a traffic coming on four of the streets. This is all leaning to what we want this to be — is a beautiful, residential neighborhood. Now you're coming in with a commercial use. These are things that I don't know — what's considered the Standing Oaks PUD in your, uh, traffic numbers? Jim Banks: Yes. John N.: But that again, is a hazard. We're trying to make this a residential community. A residential strip. And we're talking about putting all this traffic down there. It's unacceptable. That's all I got. Wayne Arnold: Thank you. [Applause] Speaker 5: I just have one more comment. It's — it's gonna be short. So, I just, I'm just requesting that if this is going to be a platform for expressing ourselves, to have time constraints — very difficult, `cause, if I think — if this is what this platform is like, I think every single one person should be able to come up here and spend as much time as they need to, to express their concern. If it's all just everybody has 10 minutes or two minutes or whatever else, I just don't think it's fair. So, if we're gonna have this platform for the community to talk and — and relay their information or concerns, I think it's only fair we have enough time. Wayne Arnold: Okay, thank you. Speaker 5: Thank you. [Applause] Wayne Arnold: I would like to mention just two things. We have a tentative public hearing scheduled, so our next step is to go before the Collier County Planning Commission. We've been given a March 5t' hearing date as a tentative for that. And we have a county commission hearing date of April 14th. And I — I — I stress that those are tentative dates. Those are subject to change for a number of reasons. Speaker 6: What time on the 14th? Wayne Arnold: Uh, BCC meetings begin at 9:00 a.m. County Commission Page 45 of 46 Transcript (01-27-2020 NIM) Petitions PL20180002621 (GMPA), Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and PL20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD Meeting — 9:00 a.m., and so does the Planning Commission. They both begin at 9:00. Speaker 7: Can you repeat those dates again? Speaker 6: March 5t" and April 14th Wayne Arnold: March 5th and April 14th. And of course, if you received notice for this because you're an affected property owner, you will get another notice by staff and there will be zoning signs posted on the property prior to the — the public dates. Speaker 8: March 5th time, please? Speaker 6: 9:00. Speaker 8: And on the 14th? Wayne Arnold: Folks, I just want to thank everybody for coming out. We really appreciate it. And again, as we said, we're happy to listen and dialogue with you and hope we can continue to work with you. Thank you. [End of Audio] Duration: 99 minutes Page 46 of 46 Petitions PL20180002621., Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict and P1.20180002622, Naples Senior Center CFPUD January 27, 2020 Neighborhood Information Meeting radyl inor Project Lo • Located on the Southeast quadrant of the intersection of Oakes Boulevard and Autumn Oaks Lane • Valewood signal access Project Information Current Zoning: E, Estates Proposed Zoning: Naples Senior Center Community Facility Planned Unit Development (CFPUD) Current Future Land Use Designation: Estates Designation, Mixed Use District, Residential Estates Subdistrict Proposed Future Land Use Designation: Project Acreage: 13.6+/- acres Naples Senior Center Community Facility Subdistrict 3 Proposed Request • Create new subdistrict under the Golden Gate Area Master Plan to allow up to 30,000 square feet of building area for senior services uses for the Naples Senior Center for 8.6+/- acres of assemblage • Rezone 13.6+/- acres from the E, Estates Zoning District to CFPUD Zoning District to develop the site for Naples Senior Center services • Daily senior activities • Non-residential facility • No evening or weekend use E CFPUD Proposed Uses A. Principal Uses: 1. Individual and Family Social Services (SIC 8322) for seniors 60 and older, limited to the following: a. Activity centers, elderly b. Adult day care centers c. Centers for senior citizens/community centers d. Family counseling services e. Old age assistance f. Outreach programs g. Senior citizens associations B. Group support services, elderly 5 Prohibited Uses 1. Soup kitchens 2. Homeless shelters 3. Residential dwelling units 4. Offender rehabilitation agencies 5. Public welfare offices 6. Self-help organizations for alcoholics 7. Refugee services 8. Religious facilities/churches 0 Proposed Conceptual Master Plan PTinPIERTY -4 BoLmmy E- MATES RESMENTIAL NIMMUM 27 WIDE TVRI V APE SWPE� 1 1 I Rkkff-0E-W*Y (P6 7, PO 96 APM 9� 4 i r __ Y 1 �— - YALEwrd4U OR TO Y M j E. EySYATE$ E, E- SATES {Rkh�lLl VAC�W RESCENTRL ESTATES Y r wATER MANAmmENT CHURCH ; AREA AUTUMN OAKS LAbg— MwRAu►f AV W" TYPE V wr�Isw — , L13MMWb7F!M— 1. f .. r ' 4 - FYtOPERTY 00UNDARY RIGHT-00 r r f rf r {}} r - PRINCIPA BUILDING } , r } # }9KH9PJkCE- r FARNWLT.kR¢�A BrAL6IN6 AREA f r ' MUN17Y FACILITY f- y$ LMDSQMW- f PgoA1C1P4� I x f } { } r m , t8TA9Es 5WFrmR 13UdINNG SETBACK I f - * .r�p7 _ a RESIDEN-f AL RESERVATION y {MINNUM) — I r {SEE NOTE42) l = If }LMI AN Qk1PF f + * . PWSE WE M1mwIJ i 1T WWDE TYPE f E ESTATES a r + } lA1K*CAlpE 15UPFEl7 MOTpI Cr;LE WAS;t AND SOMCE- s RESIOENIm E. ESTATn RESLUENTLAL AN 7 Proposed Conceptual Site Rendering Overlay AN 3n . • s �. t x < s. .� Example: Activity Schedule • Pre -registration required for all programs in,F, Mon.j.py Atlf oct., l ir-, Projected Weekly Schedule TI]MJY Attrvnd.mce No pies Senior tenter In New Fatuity Wi dnehirlly Mlteadarxr Tb, 11-A 7y eme.odanfr- fi 1.1.1y ArbendmK! WAl.3bt35 Gde Cali! Alin Cafe L U Cade to. IJ:M YcVa TA7ChiInIro CiF 0 ftsimm 25YogA TAIChlWro Z} f r4parh Lc sdh TO SV■hryl, L.,saK JA GUY Tirn4 Y] Thr Aw Gtntrp 13 CamDvtErAss'iyUnee E9ralnExaters 1.9 [amperterAssntante 1.5 PI)MW, aphy+ELMS M 2Lr 11;40 Carqpvj�rSUpporLGroup 16 Mi: W4jj4t-rWj9r IS Commsmriy PaFtner 1 20 Am. muRi.medli 0 Air, multi MC4W 25 Art: rnutb-rnedL) 25 COre+rwp' V PAMV 2 2LD C (t WSOnS S 100.1&2=3M eGyjyta,GFUUM 71 AetPlleGrWpt 77 k"0W8r*UP.JL 74 RKPIUGFOUP3 72 ReiPF&rPWpS 10;401;30 openGardenirg :t;T31 Chi (ln4 1-6 Farm to7abk 20hketl6eCfalt l: 11-11:44 r um(.lr;le ;5 Cg<jf port !9 nGiprderiin g 19 r,pmp+rtlrrAsusLar,ue A Sinew Svekh EL 35 Carils and GarrC: 70 CA rd5 & Garrr5 70 Tal Chi Qbe 29 11-17W Apmde party 22 aprvdrpartV 21 LuFK:7 A more MOMIk pEty 22*ask p # 77 1I4M GardsanJGamma 7C GetOIL Evulse 35 5en6nr5trvi[hfx 35brdff,9kCiantes M0963AD 16 )2-;2'45 SenLarStrenjrth Ex ss A: mult1-mgd1z x5 SeniorStreVh jaerrd-e it Writes workV*p - 12:W2[34 A[ryUcsWarkihap 259aakouh is Arts and Cnft 20dnumCircle 1} 14011 t1ne Danpint tntr4 29 Ttawlaeus 100 ACPU1t CO0*&N a G" Rr Di"C sa ' N Wne Panclne .7s I-3:00 Sweavenani Group i". CSi4Yr=On ci5s�25 Mwir _- }lCompoterCLnq Veter n%,n war 3j!se .' A-.90- M ►,ne4,rm tnk;f, 25 COhniYS 25 To ChiTWp 15 Att;mUhI-tr'4dia :5 ttl UkWele Group 113 Lallroom Dandrla N 0 Traffic Analysis James M. Banks,. P.E. JMB Transportation Engineering, Inc. 10 Maples Senior Center Forecasted Traffic Flow in and Out of the Building Staff and Members ' A 81-30;00 A+1 .00.00 AM 0.00,00 A! 0:30:00 AM 0.45:00 A 1�1:00:00 Af1+'k 2--00:00 P 2:00:00 PM :30:00 PM .45:00 PAS ra3 00.00 PM 4*00,00 PM 4,30:00 PM 5:00:00 PM Aver # in bidg 15 35 26 36 485 335 15 15 15 35 50 45 44 88 36 36 80 31 62 29 125 27 40 32 5 46 35 25 81 20 20 30 20 36 40 44 44 41 62 15 1s 15 15 485 485 28 443 15 10 15 15 9 48 53 15 23 183 42 130 25 36 35 15 15 485 335 15 15 97 38 36 29 28 46 49 22 50 86 36 44 4 15 15 485 328 56 30 24 41 62 47 38 15 15 11 tL. — cr Wednesdays Existing Peak Season 5 45 40 35 r /1 37 4JrY 30 � 25 20 n 14 19 19 10 14 4 *7 7 5 . x s # f } 4 iflA2 x G D AM 8 AV 9 AM 10 AM 11 AM Noon 1 PM 2 Pit 3 PM a ISM 5 PM �MWFrq lre�m HOUR OF DAY Emwrq Tops Naples Senior Center Existing Site -Generated Traffic Figure T1-A 12 Mon, Tues, Thurs & Fridays Existing Peak Season N 4 40 V) CL30 2 2 ,15 +3 h� 7r LEGEND 1� 14 q � a t it 7 AM 6 AAA 9 AM 10 AM 1x AA41-yN{yV oon{� 1 PM 2 PM 3 PM 4 N 5 PPA EnF..rinq Trips �w IOU R F DAY . , q Tr4m [Naples SenIor C enter Existing Site- enera#cd Traffic Figure T7-B Januci 20, 202C 131 Wednesdays Future Peak Season 84 75 74 65 e# 60 55 S4 LO 45 CIL d0 35 3+ 3+ 30 so as �4 1 14 2+ 20 �d 1� 15 10 7 I LEGEW I T%tWr'q 'Mw 7 Aha R AM 9 AA! :0 AM S 1 AM Noon I PM 2 PM 3 Fm 4 NM 5 PFA Ei i nq 1'wj Naples Senior Center Projected 6 i -Generated Traffic Figure TF-A ^riL nry 20, ; 14, n, T es, 5Q 45 40 .35 CL 3Q 25 20 .5 .0 T urs & Fridays Future Peak Season LNEND AM B AM 9 AAA III PM AM Haan 1 PM 2 PM 3 PM 4 pm 5 FM 151 Planning Conclusions • Project thoughtfully designed to be compatible with the Oakes Neighborhood • Large building setbacks • Enhanced landscape buffers • More than 5 acres devoted to preserve and open space • 2 story maximum height Residential style architecture • Project will have direct access to signalized access at Valewood Drive and Immokalee Road • No evening or weekend use of the property • Limited scope of uses related to senior center mission 16 Proposed Conceptual Master Plan Overlay IMMOKALEE ROAD F'i�y��` a I f qrTt .Ar- - I I i I I I I I I II 1 11 I f_1�7hZ7 L 1 F-C. FEES �JJ.= -:0M.K E:,7AYM _ Y ViATER 4b*0-3ENENT QMX I 1 Y VF J SL fLIfLI'lYJ �Ak} / � ' it � I•� ' r f iaCrwj,Wrw I I ` Y. ['�1Mi I 1 MIIN111IYI;-A-.:.I ITY I ,y ,r4rr,h .eti,r•,T� _ _ WESe�.F L LIM= IESCIEMM 1 - A • Date aerial flown: January 2019, Collier County Property Appraiser 17 Project Commitments • No evening or weekend use of property • Hours for senior activities limited to 9:30 a.m. to 4 p.m., Monday through Friday • Enhanced landscape buffers along Autumn Oaks Lane and Oakes Boulevard • List of prohibited uses of the site • Preserve/open space uses only on easternmost 5-acre parcel • Site will be limited to a maximum Monday through Friday daily usage by 485 people. IF SIGN POSTING INSTRUCTIONS (CHAPTER 8, COLLIER COUNTY ADMINISTRATIVE CODE FOR LAND DEVELOPMENT) A zoning sign(s) must be posted by the petitioner or the petitioner's agent on the parcel for a minimum of fifteen (15) calendar days in advance of the first public hearing and said sign(s) must be maintained by the petitioner or the petitioner's agent through the Board of County Commissioners Hearing. Below are general guidelines for signs, however these guidelines should not be construed to supersede any requirement of the LDC. For specific sign requirements, please refer to the Administrative Code, Chapter 8 E. 1. The sign(s) must be erected in full view of the public, not more than five (5) feet from the nearest street right-of-way or easement. 2. The sign(s) must be securely affixed by nails, staples, or other means to a wood frame or to a wood panel and then fastened securely to a post, or other structure. The sign may not be affixed to a tree or other foliage. 3. The petitioner or the petitioner's agent must maintain the sign(s) in place, and readable condition until the requested action has been heard and a final decision rendered. If the sign(s) is destroyed, lost, or rendered unreadable, the petitioner or the petitioner's agent must replace the sign(s NOTE: AFTER THE SIGN HAS BEEN POSTED, THIS AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING NOTICE SHOULD BE RETURNED NO LATER THAN TEN (10) WORKING DAYS BEFORE THE FIRST HEARING DATE TO THE ASSIGNED PLANNER. -- - - - . . . AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING NOTICE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY, PERSONALLY APPEARED SHARON UMPENHOUR WHO ON OATH SAYS THAT HE/SHE HAS POSTED PROPER NOTICE AS REQUIRED BY SECTION 10,03.00 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE ON THE PARCEL COVERED IN PETITION NUMBERS: Sharon Umpenhour, Senior Planning Technician for Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. NAME (TYPED OR PRINTED) STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Rey P.O. BOX Bonita Springs, Florida 34110 CITY, STATE ZIP The foregoing instrument was sworn to and subscribed before me this 27 day of May , 2020, by Sharon Umpenhour, personally known to me or whe pi:,dueed as identifiea6an and who did/did not take an oath. CARIN J. DWYER my COMMISSIQN # GG 982367 EXPIRES: May 14, 2024 Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters My Commission Expires: (Stamp with serial number) Signature of Notary ublic Carin J. Dwyer Printed Name of Notary Public Rev. 314/20 1 5 PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN AMENDMENT & NAPLES PLANNEDIOR UNITENTER DEVELOPMENT NITY IL1TY REZONE PETITION NO. PL20180002621/CPSS-2019-4 & PL20180002622 CCPC: MARCH 5, 2020 - 9:00 a.m. BCC: JUNE 23, 2020 - 9:00 a.m. COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER 3299 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, NAPLES, FL 34112 DAVID WEEKS, AICP: 239-252-2 4 k IMOTHY FINN, AICP: 239-252.4312 $. -V ­- PUBLIC HEAR0ING NOTICE- NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY SUBDISTRICT GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN AMENDMENT & NAPLES SENIOR CENTER COMMUNITY FACILITY PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT REZONE PETITION NO. PL20180002621/CPSS-2019-4 & PL20180002622 CCPC: MARCH 5, 2020 - 9:00 a.m. BCC: JUNE 23, 2020 - 9.00 a.m. COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER 3299 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, NAPLES, FL 34112 UVln WEEKS- AICP: 239-252-23OL& TIMOTHY FINN, AICP: 239-252-4312.