Loading...
HEX Final Decision 2020-14 HEX NO. 2020-14 HEARING EXAMINER DECISION DATE OF HEARING. September 24, 2020 PETITION. PETITION NO. VA-PL20190001921 - Titan Lane Communication Tower Maximillian Beyrent and Eco-Site LLC request three variances from LDC Section 4.02.01 to reduce the minimum rear yard setback for wireless communication tower equipment from 50 foot to 29 feet for the north setback,31.2 feet for the north setback,and 23.9 feet for the north setback for equipment cabinets, a variance from LDC Section 5.05.09 to reduce the minimum communication tower height setback from 70 foot to 15.7 feet for the north setback, a variance from LI)C Section 4.06.05 to reduce the minimum landscape buffer width from 20 feet to 10 feet for the north and south perimeter buffers. The property is located at Tract G of the Sherwood Park Natural Preserve Area, in Section 34, Township 49 South, Range 36 East, Collier County, Florida. STAFF RECOMMENDATION. Approval with conditions. FINDINGS. 1. The public hearing for this Petition was properly noticed and conducted in accordance with all County and state requirements. 2. The public hearing was conducted electronically and in-person in accordance with Emergency Executive Order 2020-04. 3. The Petitioner and or Petitioner's representative executed the Hybrid Virtual Quasi-Judicial Public Hearing Waiver related to conducting the public hearing electronically and in-person. 4. The Petitioner and or Petitioner's representative presented the Petition, followed by County staff and then public comment. ANALYSIS. Based on a review of the record including the Petition, application, exhibits, the County's staff report, and hearing comments and testimony from the Petitioner and or the Petitioner's representative(s), County staff and any given by the public, the Hearing Examiner finds that there Page 1 of 3 is sufficient competent, substantial evidence as applied to the criteria set forth in Section 9.04.03 (Criteria for Variances)of the Land Development Code to approve Petition. DECISION. The Hearing Examiner hereby APPROVES Petition Number VA-PL20190001921, filed by Deborah L. Martohue, AICP representing Maximilian Beyrent of Eco-Site II, LLC, with respect to the property described as Pine Vale Drive in the Palm Springs residential subdivision, metes and bounds and measures approximately 86 feet by 594 feet by 310 feet or 0.23 acres and is located north of the intersection of Davis Boulevard and Radio Road in Section 34, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, for the following: • A variance to reduce the minimum rear yard setback for wireless communication tower equipment from 50 foot to 29 feet for the north setback, 31.2 feet for the north setback, and 23.9 feet for the north setback for equipment cabinets; • A variance to reduce the minimum communication tower height setback from 70 feet to 15.7 feet for the north setback; and • A variance to reduce the minimum landscape buffer width from 20 feet to 10 feet for the north and south perimeter buffers. The requested variances are related to cell tower equipment, concrete pads, and a cell tower monopole located in an agricultural zone district near 1-75. Said changes are fully described in the proposed Tower Site Plan, Boundary Survey, Tower Elevation Sheet, and proposed Landscape Plan attached as Exhibit "A" and are subject to the condition(s) set forth below. ATTACHMENTS. Exhibit A Tower Site Plan, Boundary Survey, Tower Elevation Sheet, and proposed Landscape Plan LEGAL DESCRIPTION. Pine Vale Drive in the Palm Springs residential subdivision, metes and bounds and measures approximately 86 feet by 594 feet by 310 feet or 0.23 acres and is located north of the intersection of Davis Boulevard and Radio Road in Section 34, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. CONDITIONS. 1. All other applicable state or federal permits must be obtained before commencement of the development. Page 2 of 3 DISCLAIMER. Pursuant to Section 125.022(5)F.S., issuance of a development permit by a county does not in any way create any rights on the part of the applicant to obtain a permit from a state or federal agency and does not create any liability on the part of the county for issuance of the permit if the applicant fails to obtain requisite approvals or fulfill the obligations imposed by a state or federal agency or undertakes actions that result in a violation of state or federal law. APPEALS. This decision becomes effective on the date it is rendered. Pursuant to Ordinance 2013-25, as amended, a Hearing Examiner Decision may be appealed to the Board of County Commissioners or the Board of Zoning Appeals, as appropriate. Appeals must be filed within 30 days of the date the Hearing Examiner Decision is rendered. RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS AND EXHIBITS: SEE CLERK OF COURT, MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT. DECISIONS OF THE HEARING EXAMINER FOR VARIANCES, CONDITIONAL USES, AND BOAT DOCK EXTENSIONS SHALL BE NOTED ON THE ZONING MAP FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES. 9.)11----- October 7, 2020 Date Andrew Dickman, Esq., AICP Hearing Examiner Page 3 of 3 I . ,� cn _ f Q slg0 4'° .• 1� c,G ggg1 I 8 (� It1 ! a t!? ',II ga o Ara �9 �.•..". * N ". a Y U O Z fili ir !i ;; ! \'4 auF _} -"�6"'•' o i : a A t..11,.,eS+,•..._.., o - e m < ! F n f U did0lfiYa+d N „ N N N 1 a. , a Z YJ,n 30/71 � .n yr e. _ ca ry n r SS Z v. rn u. » » t tl339,a X $ i R 4 g3. e * t oMn ,03__.. .Sn_ I U 5 a � 39 3 d 2 ' r o 1 4 (Q� �2! gw K iCO k o ; 1 6 H i a g M ' I w e 3. ,', " gI 'gLv t• 'i a Ii 1 a ,i = a e lea P 8 I / .7 :.. - _ I li 1 iii i . ' , a Li- 7---- -1 111 S0 O. . a .0-.9' .i X ;-'2 ;`,3 :•5:761-,Y* ,, „i X. , $e u g 1 li / �' I +1 0 1 r ( IN( Hsrai3s 6 V g 'i'. 11 is :1 1 --f--- i , i 1 , 1 I n R. , s 3 I ' §qa / /) - .c .a i_ oI 3 4q a SS ' b45 .__. ._........ 4�d �.� i �.u-.ar w lily ' /,- �W , ( i �' L / < `� s� L——•i I '"�rc"r3 t • -- _ �'�. �_`�� ) 1N31135Y3 MON L_ il! ., QM3500/ ... X / 7 o sa L....._________/ c. g tit.tir a►wtvrt. a.ar a i.�ar.'+1� ak F J .-..�...__-.i ) QN(10d11W , .t '' I1- .0-.0/ /.O±AI .B-,K 1 t Y30Y 35Y11 'W 1 it ii itgi i-.,' ux o „ og .sue - is -- nn CO. ifo an w w e.a ...env-,rt o .. o-,w a ..,..0 a:-. +oe-Arco-,wsse.wwet�+v+,•r»wwnw w { L Y I �} ° i I a ": X$ X F ' Rq hi e riR e p A R itayLgey1aaa {$sF; 404y� j $ q q g°iY 6Y 0 40 X T «X 1 tl F RIPF} 9Y4 Y y 1. 1 i B i1F 61 D Y �I al ;x " ae Ii laY3 yyFlyF2 § RyF Y 83 C?+t e I r ° 4 a„P6 q 2i F l' ii'5 4 a' ;gzli°Y � y7 g ; ta1,71i¢I a6 sg Y ge iY . 3" AI ai S 4!�`p y ,YR ::: g s i V YFba.P_ � aIY?r 3 • P� F� ! 1!� s� a � qi� 4���1 YT9� [�*F�3 P�Ty X ¢t§�� P t iii Y 4 g-in q 4 it aF f Yi ipgge YF -4M - qa{ Ogy g2Dpp y94F"cR 1;6�PFrig6Y = th t 1 t i: l j {:Y HE X ry 1I2 $e�T8 a .E -- `S I aq `� R i $ £€$. t:`T-1' I riiYf i{I XIi S a ?ia`�i, ii Ty ;l1 €d q ;111 YY. y s a; I yytii 's,4Yy 14J 2(i°i a F �,` �I"( q Y # 8P� y r $ i�ie a Fs• a ' d66 'O. i X„ p a s Will T1 F . i?f YYX i a.�L� Pg F- iARy<•Y 4`�� ��`��C �-Pa'. � Y�F ` i e�#a Y1 Yrdt Rp I 8 i,6 i 11 - > 99 gi ,I"yy c g � aY e} &b� r:i,91111 ,1.1g8 F2l II 1 >a. 11-!!3.4 4 11ri 8 G asp 1.XP p'(F XD �� � ; � �Y f a Y <D:a.d :lab!31 li11,Xr:SIR-Aiiii!PEA :Ft!9d�iaRY>4if!P4:rs1!PA M iIII Pr F. r 9 !hi I il III r -.tu hoTP.x}0•*0 fi 1,==§44 i t i= i ':, ,...::--i. r,:,--......,:-:-27:71—,, I— tt.r.,_-_----,-----7,-;,,,:il al I Bi/1lF P q'R el:b4 Fit 11'Y2I' I 1; ' .,.,... . ' -> ligill bls; 6051ag93YEl I 1 tgr It $ b 0 $ • tI ea-;- qR ;Y i i 1. illi! fC9Sa5" kYl}iel8isy ••�sT rt Ily R6Y� `Y • ! it ' I t i q I :a ,1 2 , -:. 1 : 1 , ee88i �Ia#; s of • Y:. , • lriy(p �� Y awe � ' '."'fyJ� ` �E � a` Y °ig ;�p; a 8 x ini ri rRi i, Kw ` 'dl�` - gj x (• ¢a Ra E�ui 6yga3 �; �l a - R $ 9�Yia d1Rrt 8i '11 I 8 S "a P D a t dD n t6 a 1 I Y F ° �33 i Y 1 si ! R j tyf shy lie 'zt Zatli VI Rb a 4 F r I 1 S 7 titt 1 i 3 qa g!! gel I';IFF h a 1 1510 �u¢ , , 4 41 "F I` F g1i ,X 1 U i� ;AlAT_4 �t 1i{{2 t tti fS a ash 10 t 1S R Ye Y Y w W - r.1 : bi nI 4k-; a 4165 a'Rb3 4 tt 8 v i 8�ay"4 +M aaay6 1 ` E icz e3`et ; ba6Fna` 6"112Z24I LiJ �[. 1l y pa ,INR 9 `I��8X II Y g � 1 a 1't :: ii ! : xgiP3i11 Ia �il r ii I t!!I 1d 4 Ii ; I;� g� ii g�g±� o :° r I 1g°e$ a I x 8 P g s 1 ! NSaza R h.11! I P4.5 co g €t �< 1 • , sills (0111/41' 7';_ i% : - ir. N Li 111 1 Oil Iii ., .. d t . 01- '-- '' 1 ' I Pi, fl dry` al, tl r 6f;it} /§ 6.gin p iS C'x a 1-„ it 4 x i tOtt i l tDialo .6 "\ baum T-t :i66 k- w�...A. m 2 {t � \ : �- {,-' : ' � 1ft� t Ta —.�� • 1 a ... " 9 y�yt .5 " 1 A s, g a 1 �: 63S a 1 t —T t , 4 q `19! `6I iy ;aiII 6 Rf 1.�P i .•it �r § ill I j 011 p; rr y C ly' SAY@; q� A, :_ @g lgsriP, r SS, ' v @ 3 t ? jr •©ra,xio•� 1'xii�j & T �', A:y s _ ii13 y If rt F� 9 �O xe r ij §i igt9F'3t Ryyy r�7tr �7Vr p� (sy}<� jils re r ] r_4- . .a e a a971ip h ,,11 � h 3Z! T�; T�; o ;g 3 b d $F i H;YSE I i � 4 ;j; a I d: tl�1 �yT T g �> �Pt@ Y L pp tl ,p JJ i y' ! 3 :it ttA .iA a gi i . ,, OLL 1 8 r rFd p1h r;fhi i i$ a sg i a 4 . ; �1z.a Of Lah Q tr Eel e z % uI 9Otdi 8 p V F tii !! iiiii! ( !1j1 NIA a `�.` 74'-°' _ in, 13 r TKO r ix aj Qk ass. .e,.. .. _ - ... - i! a 1e ,._ - 4. `e' dx°3 dry_13 i sX b 4 > z •r r 1 ; is $ g o f La,a Ors 22 IIi ; Y ' t 7` �a ,•. F-'y t w,py 91 i £ i : ' ` 4?k;";T' Wi 1 1g:: 9 •F' q � 1 i° a... S /• • i.i r ,1 / ; 3 rT T rzi b .' .A ° R• a1 r r !" € it! galll3A!93} i! iiaT; °r ii''3a§ah xi,t 1111!1(a: Ta t �'*5'3 k' Y ea a toy a41as Seafp?alpM: 1d3iiYIiPIs,V T`z1:g_[r h4\ 1l $i� :�'"c S r as ac:ai r 3 I'' A• h ; ,1; 6a stiff. r r 'a as .i9 i1 1 l' e' if e 4 I. � I ��y��i�a�81 ��;Y: �"eel�;g���>�;��! Rt 1 r 3�^a 3 ii¢� if 3I il44atell A.4,1 m; 1; dirNr hj ; :aa ; g 1 Lk II 1-11 a j t48 , ( ii i .e : $ 1111 d1 II! i a N 1 Al ii Di u .! <l i aaky !••a z,he ,:t t T 1 O q �,: li g /, ��, G; 1 aeaa a� 4P aed eV 1 d "€ i� q g C. 17 r' Sc 1 ,r` rd dt 01. ra tih'i � g �d s016 U J F 1 ♦ r ip; r go d0A h A 6�i _ I, ;”. vgTy'3Tad1iT1 95U : 1 + lig 4 ; 4% 8r "P ,i2 r.• a" iR,ii5 ' ,:1 k il.1 1 ee¢! rt: -IQ 1 3 t^i chio i as 11 trrT g i' , :h7 Td L as G jai `� &YB1— " -a1 �• yF �a di $ ttk tr a.- Rhadpa pd j'' reY a'15 a j S? i µ t @ $ ' I .1 , i , !It, gt i,10 �° ZiWil)16j/OIL f ` 1 44giee8i T93`, 0AA a 's g� tte1EAit } .. �� irill gg aaY qa 9 (! S�yk ''a! !;9 ,.te/ .' - 0b.ieh f1?'TYpdiErfiAi hd I „SS 1 1' ;gig yag@¢' .:, :q:: , 1 ' tg v5 6W6T -- ilk!hdi " dt13 �'`� '\�. bb i "...o.•-• '.. • 11 rt• , *, pi:I,. i i ; i IP' if 4.---1 1.1. - rx, b".• h .41 ,z t.i•- h .t t 0,.. ! it 10% ta ‘4,10 si , q4 kti, I i .11 11 piZIO Ab 4 41 iPF q° 4 hle,:: r if !MO !" P.::f y'f: ?' 0 " il kIllii 11 i Pli; i 5 1 g 1 ' , tsipTZ10oto N-, . 1 1 : tix 1 it 1 h at q 1141 -t lo ;;A 1 .a ,..;„ kr s .t i4 1 6 /1 ,1 i;latt ;t! ;;Ii 0 ;!i A !I 14JA 41 i 40r Nil ' '''' ' 4 :-..- t . :41 i-: RAN iii ' i''"' 'A :It .-. Awl -= '4; ; P , i, ,!2 i ,, ot. 1,4, i .1,, i Ara i V iiii 1 t; i nii.ro r1 11 hilo.',s4 I.t "ra'-t :i.'0.%'4 bi I'M 11 111t4 "',' 41 ;pi ; 4t. 44 11 ! / ? i 0 i r lihils ii 1 !I § IL/I ; `111 F iNql LI Ix 1 ,E)IS! ‘01 1Z,''!e'l gi Ix I; P 1 M 1 it i i :;1011 1;41 44! iii1 :01h;iYi iiii; .:.10 4•1 Ai! I101. ;41 A 1 Hi 0;,!. ;111,I li ifil 17 — 4111111 TA !;:%M. lii!.':1-11;V';1 !Ill T !ilii' li 1. 3 41i; ,;')1 ! ,,:„,,.I. ,1 1$7,,S.•',,',',:I, s,h`i jitj. cA .b.,!.',1 t!§prt tt.„/i!IR , 4:,1,1. 1444 14 lit t! /IN 41 i ill /:1, ? 1 0' 1 Is'itt 6Ilill 1 !:40 IN ?igitz 4.11 !!alli111016,;.1.,".1 Ifsi Iiilii gele hi g h iiiki:ii:I hi g o rill: li-sc,,flip , : . 1 4;1110101k! ' i 1 1 Oi. i il 1 I 11111i! 1 i 11111, (;• 5t ' . . i • ' 1 . 1 , xt 1 1 .4 11 11, • • . i 4ii , 3 Of •< 0 .4 n$1 zi-zg ! A 1 CO W 11 .4 . '• I i I; 110 @ f 4 i ks 1 1 lilt , ii 04ss''. ,tga - - T,- • $ W w i i Mil i 0 i• — I 1 (-:: -';••;;-**—• I i 1Z ,,t tt g\ tl 4 I! i- rA g 5 : tro . 13 1111x xi / I' I 1' rt • I wz„ w T' ti • i( / ‘:‘ 1 a . V w • • . ___0 • • -• I,. , \ / , i •?,lit • , „:,...„. ,_ I i • sl P.--- ,k11111.0 , I ' 1 s' 11 Iii a N 3. i rq Aft 1 - g 1 if :hi g g , j:13Itt:!; 'Cr i =At iig r9jF� ..5 a toy •,� „�1 g a. dI ,,ViiiiIiii O q ii: tti 111 te" =..\ \ Od A cur ! ! ! S E;tE I- A iKS }—z -3z6 3 ;lc. y W 'Lill?op 1 F�» Caa �...! c f■r} ccGi{td 6 IL o o i i s S e if S $ _i.1 i 3 _„ 6£ if st `a 4 �86iSit3il l7 'N N V rl M O v < } li 6 d IIISINltd; 1. f SV' s 4 zo o gd Q E d t N., t4 iQ i 1 i s 55. t!' ,,,,,_ ' I : i"; ii-/-4)1 :1!N VN HI �M VYN t 111 r o '' (1 . .,IN , 1 , 1.,4 N 7o8 al 4 il W P4 py. d t x= a �..•uw.�n .sainr.r W..l rLL t.OFVO?n M1l.t.wov�M\M•w�MitsM•+Mn 1 —"rib • —i {f pia r QP,..... „, _ 1 1 8 yZ Ofilit:f.asd O. gp o •,4 �i56 gg WWI •__ " �a.--4 , 1 g a q J iia33r :of $ o {iiiii a 0 IIIi39 ry d (i� a a p g A iC f i Z ; N 11 `0. w i 0 E Z s t i ' t , > s s e r4 i� Iu ///ovv�ovo ; a � a i o>�� P: , 1 L F' R 4 , 1 R k n b i 111) tI. 1 r , Y to it S 6 0 6 d 1 ' /e ill lit' 1111 � °rLsc,eee.aea .41114 i Si t3 , 1 � ag f a / . .;:i 4 1 8 i i 4 F, '.. g , 4 .8 - w oz. a (� U 4 w FO m w a c - 4/ j Z 4 O Fro c r m a a0r Ve U O IS YY 1 *wa & wl" wK :Si a Wi_ O >'�a=an Ue ,x64,xN4Ve` 50,1 W, i `O ((" L W Z ei-ELT Vx >,, •VUe-W N Til, U a w 03oa0 K=Z,QQ y�j OwoN j 0 O � Q NUZ2<JOa m0703Q JJ V O U._ O Fvla 3' 90)?Z I`OZZ er N h - a F J Z- '4 t z a W V I a W N F 2 I I rig g Q C G yUy W eN NQ] UN aa<Z�a O-- OO^ �+u0 Na°' }aV OUyOjp mNQ OW�� �Zw¢O 0:= 0 C O Ft. Vf O H w20'n > 2axx . ... 0 E p O P. y O xo ' o'-wzo JZ 0OV 00 OWPUC] >i2 O C n ti" W U� ww, aCZL, v_O w0 p ,,-, .2 v, 0 O O y v j OFO - aJOJ 3- Nt-WWSUWS 7 ucN 3,..s.1., =�N o as woz< a xsrcwaKwa i 0 wc• U WI' Wz d Jf � � vw o:ia�t o� a �c >Y�'�xw �,u 8;8Z i n `,�aw 'p g. 8zwZa,�o> _ w vayy=" uz's yaa� �Lzx ��ly�/u�Ie�{ 3g ga�zvi % aE au¢OAa4a .�i-- V>7 ' OT=¢ K03Q7 83n.'s W :.: 2.-K3� N MD Oad2 �Zd I I1UrI I 1 HUNf SOU V( R U 9? m...,aev«Ie Moenr,r.ar.,.vu-,.w-vaa<wwn«w.►.....v.v...wnavnu..t,,