Agenda 11/12/2019 Item #16A19 (Release of Code Enforcemeent Lien - Rives)11/12/2019
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve the release of a code enforcement lien with an accrued value of
$220,980.21 for payment of $730.21 in the code enforcement action entitled Board of County
Commissioners v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives, Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Case No.
CEPM20160008025, relating to property located at 5378 Broward St, Collier County, Florida.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners accepts an offer to release a code enforcement
lien with an accrued value of $220,980.21 for payment of $730.21 in relation to Code Enforcement Board
Case No. CEPM20160008025.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Code Enforcement Special Magistrate ordered the imposition of a lien
against Janice Rives and Arturo Rives, in Case No. CEPM20160008025, for a code violation at the
property located at 5378 Broward St. The violation consisted of the boarding of an unoccupied home
without first obtaining a Collier County Boarding Certificate. The lien was recorded in the Official
Records on October 31, 2016, at O.R. Book 5328, Page 1642. The lien amount of $220,980.21 is based
on 883 days of accrued fines ($250 per day from September 7, 2016 through February 6, 2019) $220,750
plus $230.21 in operational costs.
The property was acquired by 5378 Broward St., LLC, via Certificate of Sale recorded on December 27,
2018. The property was brought into compliance on February 6, 2019. Pursuant to Resolution No. 2012 -
46, a request for a reduction of fines may be considered, in part, when a lien encumbers propert y under
new ownership, and the new owner has diligently pursued abatement and achieved compliance and/or
when payment of the lien would impose a severe financial hardship on the owner. The new owner took
title to this property, with an uncorrected code violation, with the intent of remodeling the property and
providing a home for their parents. It took a substantial amount of time with extensive follow up and
inspections and approximately $219,944 in funds, including taxes due, holding costs, and permit f ees, to
come into compliance. The property is actively maintained, and the owner has paid $730.21 in settlement
of fines. The owner is requesting a waiver of $220,250 in accrued fines. There are no known code
violations remaining on the property.
FISCAL IMPACT: Payment of $730.21 in settlement of fines has been made, representing $500 in
fines and $230.21 in operational costs. If approved by the Board, accrued fines in the amount of
$220,250 would be waived.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated with this
action.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The County Attorney’s Office has reviewed this item and approved it
as to form and legality. Majority support is required for approval. This item conforms to the Board’s
policy contained in Resolution 2012-46. KN
RECOMMENDATION: To waive the fines in the amount of $220,250, accept payment amount of
$730.21, release the lien and authorize the Chairman to sign the attached release and satisfaction of lien
for recording in the Official Public Records.
Prepared by: Michael Ossorio, Director
16.A.19
Packet Pg. 750
11/12/2019
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Initialed Release and Satisfaction of Lien (PDF)
2. Lien Orders (PDF)
3. New Owner Letter- Rives (PDF)
4. Backup Rives (PDF)
16.A.19
Packet Pg. 751
11/12/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 16.A.19
Doc ID: 10335
Item Summary: Recommendation to approve the release of a code enforcement lien with a value
of $220,980.21 for payment of $730.21 in the code enforcement actions entitled Board of County
Commissioners v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives, Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Case No.
CEPM20160008025 relating to property located at 5378 Broward St, Collier County, Florida.
Meeting Date: 11/12/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Code Enforcement
Name: Dana Rarey
10/04/2019 3:41 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Division Director - Code Enforcement – Code Enforcement
Name: Michael Ossorio
10/04/2019 3:41 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Code Enforcement Michael Ossorio Additional Reviewer Completed 10/08/2019 11:00 AM
Code Enforcement Colleen Davidson Additional Reviewer Completed 10/08/2019 11:11 AM
Growth Management Department Judy Puig Level 1 Reviewer Completed 10/11/2019 8:36 AM
Growth Management Department James C French Deputy Department Head Review Completed 10/11/2019 5:06 PM
County Attorney's Office Kevin Noell Level 2 Attorney Review Completed 10/14/2019 2:03 PM
Growth Management Department Thaddeus Cohen Department Head Review Completed 10/15/2019 4:30 PM
Office of Management and Budget Laura Wells Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 10/15/2019 4:41 PM
County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 10/16/2019 7:55 AM
Budget and Management Office Mark Isackson Additional Reviewer Completed 10/17/2019 10:34 AM
County Manager's Office Nick Casalanguida Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 11/03/2019 11:27 AM
Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending 11/12/2019 9:00 AM
16.A.19
Packet Pg. 752
16.A.19.a
Packet Pg. 753 Attachment: Initialed Release and Satisfaction of Lien (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
INSTR 5328561 oR 5328 PG 1542 RECoRDED LO/3L/2O16 11122 A PAGES 2
DHIGHT E. AROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIOA
REc 318.50
COLLIER COTINTT CODE ENT'ORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
Case No. -{EPM20160008025
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER CO['NTY, FLORIDA,
Petltloner,
vs.
JANICE RTVES AI\D ARTURO RIVES,
Respondents.
THIS CAUSE came
for Impositior of FineVLiens
respective to all appropriate
Magistrate, as follows:
l. On August 5, 2016,
and Ordinances, Chapter 22,
first obtaining an approved Coll
property located at 5378 Broward
upon the Petitioner's Motion
having heard argument
and Order of the Special
Collier County Code ofLaws
boarding ofa dwelling without
which violation occurred on the
Folio #62259720001 (Legal Description:
NAPLES MANOR LAKES BLK I() LOT 36).
An Order was entered by the Special Magistrate ordering Respondent to abate the violation on or
beforc September 6, 2016, or a fine of$250.00 per day would be assessed for each day the
violations continue thereafter until abatement is confirmed. (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at
oR 5304, Pc 3793).
Operational costs of $ I t 5.33 incurred by the County in the prosecution ofthis case were ordered
to be paid.
Respondent, having been duly noticed for the public hefiing regarding the County's Motion, did
not appear at the public hearing and no legal defense to the Motion was presented.
No Request for Re-hearing or Appeal pursuant to Ordinance 2OO7-44, as amended, has been
timely filed.
3
4
5
found guilty of
6. The violation has not been abated as ofthe date ofthe hearing.
2.
16.A.19.b
Packet Pg. 754 Attachment: Lien Orders (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
rrr oR 5328 PG 1643 *+r
ORDER
Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162,
Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No. 200744, as amended, it is hereby ORDERED:
Petitioner's Motion for Imposition ofFines/Liens is granted.
Daily fines of$250.00 per day arc ass€ssed against Respondent for 3l days for the period from
September 7, 2016 to October 7,2016, for a total amount offines of$7,750.00.
Respondent shall pay the previously assessed operational costs in the amount of$l15.33.
Respondent shall pay operational costs for the Imposition ofFines hearing in the amount of
$l14.88.
Respondent is ordered to pay fines and costs in the total amount of $A&Al or be subject to
Notice of
Florida.
Assessment of Lien against all ies owned by Respondent in Collier County,
F. The daily fine of$250.00 has been confirmed by a Collier
County Code Enforcem
DOIIE AND ORDERf,D this County, Florida.
E ENFORCEMENT
c.ON
cc:Respondent -Janice Rives and Arturo Rives
Collier Co. Code Enforcement Division
Staeot
co6ty of
lolrua .
COLLIER
PAYMENT OF FINESI Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this order may be paid at the Collier
County Code Enforcement Division,2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104,phone# (?39) 252-
2440, or www.colliergov.net. Any release of lien or confirmation of compliance or confirmation of the
satisfaction ofthe obligations ofthis order may also be obtained at this location.
APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a final order ofthe Special Magistrate to the circuit court
within thirty (30) days of thc execution ofthe order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearingde novo,
but shall .b€ limited to appellate review of the record created within the original hearing. It is the
resPonsibility ofthe appealing party to obtai[ a transcribed record ofthe hearing Itom the Cleik ofCourts.
Filing an Appeal will not automatically stay the Special Magistrate's Order.
A
B
C.
D.
E.
ue to accrue
I HEREBY a lrue and
16.A.19.b
Packet Pg. 755 Attachment: Lien Orders (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
INSTR 5302427 oR 5304 PG 3793 RECoRDED 8/a7 /2016 11:48 AM PAGES 2
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIOA
REc r18.50
COLLIER COI,'NTY CODE ENFORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
vs.
Case No. {EPM20160008025
BOARD OF COT,INTY COMMISSIOIIERS
COLLIER COI'NTY, FLORIDA,
Petitioncr,
JANICE RIVES AI\[D ARTI'RO RIVES,
Respondenls.
THIS CAUSE came on strate on August 5, 2016, andthe Special Magistate, hav and heard argument
respeclive to all appropriate
Magistrate, as follorvs:
and Older of the Special
L Respondents, Janice Rives the subject property.
2. Respondents tvere nolified ofthe mail and posting and thc Special
Magistrate has jurisdiction of this mstter.
3. Respondents, having been duly notified, did not appear at the public hearing.
4. The resl propcrty located at 5378 Broward s&eer, Napres, Florida, Fotio #6225972000r (r*gar
Description: NAPLES MANOR LAKES BLK r0 Lor 36), is in vioration of collier counti
Code ofl:rvs and Ordinances, Chapler 22, Article VI, Section ZZ-Z4l(l) in the follorving
particulars:
Boarding ofdrvelling witbout first obtainirg an approved collicr coutrty boarding certificrte.
5. The violation has not been abated as ofthe date ofthe public hearing.
ORDER
- -Bas€d uPon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority
granted in chapter 162, Florida statutes, and collier county ordinance No. 02-44, as amended, it is hiie(ORDERED:
Rives, are
16.A.19.b
Packet Pg. 756 Attachment: Lien Orders (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
*r* oR 5304 PG 3794 '*.
E. Respondent is ordered to pay
$11533 on or beforr S
F. Respondcnt shall notiry
abatement or compl
DONE AND ORDERED lhis
A. Respondent is found guilty ofviolation ofcollier county code oflarvs and ordinances, chaprer
22, Aflicle VI, Section 22-24t(t).
B. Respondent must abate the violation by obtaining all requirsd collier county building permits, or
demolition pe'mit, inspections, and certificate ofcompletion/occupancy on or beforJ september
6, 2016 or a line of5250.00 per day rvill be imposed for each day the violation remains-
thereaft€r.
c. Altematively, ifa boarding certificate is obtained and the structure is properly boarded on or
before August 12,2016, then the time required to complete the repairs, inspections, and
certificate ofcompletion/occupancy will be extended to and musi be compteted by February 6,
2017 or a line ofs250.00 pcr day will be imposed for each day the violation remains thereafier.
D. IfRespondent fails to comply rvith this order, the collier county code Enforcement Department
may abate lhe violation using any method to bring the violation into compliance. If necessary, the
County may request the services ofthe Collier County Sherifls Oflice for the purpose of
accessing the property for abatement. All costs ofabatement shall be assessed against the
property.
of this case in the amount of
Athey, within 24 houn of
to confirm compliance.
County, Florftla.
C. GARRETSON
PAYMEM O_F IINES: Any fines orrdercd to be paid pursuant ro this order may be paid at rhe Colliercounty code Enforcement Division,2800 North Horseshoi Drive, Naplcs, FL 34154, pfrone # (239) 252-2440, or www.coltiergov.net. Any release of lien or confirmation oflompliance ordonfirmation 6itl,e
satisfaction ofthc obligations of this order may also be obtained at this locaiion.
AIIFAI: Aryaggrieved party may appeal a final order ofthe spccial MagisEate to the circuit coortwirhin thirty (30) days ofrhe execution ofrh€ order appealed. An ippeat shail not te ahaniagie iii,
but shall .b€ limited to appellare review of the record created wiihin rhe original hearing. - L is-fi;
rc.sPonsibility ofthe-appealing party to obtain a transcribed rccord ofthe hearing iom the Cleik ofCourts.Filing an Appeal rvill not automatically stay the Special Magistrate's Order.
Sta:g ci Fl5 J3" ....- .1..
Couniy qtdrilu;R; '.',. - .
rnenfi.v.siiilfFrr idsrs a true and
;.,::',.:1'...,1'* * ;; c.lL, .**,
.-,,.l'. & - - -!. :.-,.. -.:1 .-l l--r.! r3:l lnls
'' i[ilfi;) i;' :i{i*,*l\iir6 " -
- "'i.t.Y "
enl Invesli
be
c
SPE
CL:RK OF R,TS
Respondent(s) - Janice Rives and Arturo Rives
Collier Co. Code Enforcement Division
16.A.19.b
Packet Pg. 757 Attachment: Lien Orders (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
9119119
Board of County Commissioners and / or
Michael Osorio
Growth Management Department Code Enforcement Division
2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples FL 34104
239-252-6865
Atention: Board of Collier County Commissioners
From: Diana Marin
ln reference to Property: 5378 Broward St
Naples FL 34113
REQUEST FOR REDUCTION OF FINES
CODE VIOLATION CASE CEPM 20160008025
I am the new owner of the property 5378 Broward St Naples. I purchase the property at Collier
County Auction on December 13, 201 8. The purpose of the purchase was ,or my parents to own
their own home-
As soon as the purchase was finalized, I went to the county to request a floor plan o{ the
property. When we started to research for the floor plans the county informed me that the
property had an outstanding Violation since 2016.
The violation CEPM 20160008025 was due to Window and doors boarded without first obtaining
an approved Collier County Certiticate.
As soon as lfound out, I immediately applied and obtained the boarding certificate I also got in
touch with Steve Athey (Code enforcement) case representative.
Mr. Athey informed me of what I needed 10 do to correct the violation. I was able to work with
Steve and corrected all the violation as soon as possible and re-secured the property. Mr Athey
was able to close the case, and thank me for taking care of the violation in such a short period.
It seemed that the home was abandoned / vacant since 2014 and the property was a hazard to
the community, a big headache to the police department, County and code enforcement
department, specially due to the ract that the property is located at the entrance of Lely High
School.
The property needed lots ol work that was not anticipated at the time of the purchase but
our main concern was to get the home up to code as soon as possible, unJortunately I did not
anticipated the complications and damages the property had and how costly and difficult it was
to bring everything up to code.
With the guidance of code enforcement department we were able to obtained all permits
needed to complete the work. We worked on repairing the property: New Roof, NewA/C
system, New Water Heather, New Kitchen, New Appliances, New Windows, Shutters, clean-up,
repair in the outside of the building, painting, all debris and hazard items removal that were left
16.A.19.c
Packet Pg. 758 Attachment: New Owner Letter- Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
9/19/19
behind, fixing the land scape, etc. Between all fines, Liens, Past due taxes, county permits,
professional assistance remodel / repair work and holding cost, my expenses to date are over
$219,944. a value much higher than what the house is worth.
The jobs are compleled and passed inspections. Please see attached before and after pictures.
We exhausted all our reserves to do all the repairs, witch were way way more than anticipated.
For the above stated reasons, we respectfully ask Code Enforcement and Board of County
Commissioners to considered a reduction of the fines ol this code violation that are the fault of
the previous owner since 2014 and before.
We would like to offer a settlement of $500.00 towards the fines, plus agree to cover any cost
that the county had incurred.
Si
n
dianamarin20l 5@vahoo.com
Cell: 239.560.2634
16.A.19.c
Packet Pg. 759 Attachment: New Owner Letter- Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
cEPM20r60008025
5378 Brolvard St
Folio # 62259720001
Boarding of dwclling rYithout first obtairing an approved Collier County boarding ccrtilicat€
Order Irems B - F: $2it)/day fine x 3| da1's (September 7,2016-october 7,2016) = $7750.00, plus FoF
operational costs of $ I I .1.88 plLrs IOF operat ional costs of $ I | 5.33
Total Fines owed: $7,980.21
FOF Order OR 530411'(; 3793 recorded on Ausust I 7, 201 6
IOF Order OR 53281|(; 1642 recorded on October 3 I . 20 | 6
Violation abated: 2/6, 1')
Fines accrued after IO I r
S250/day fine x 852 drl s (October 8. 2016 - February 6, 2019) = $2 I 3.000.00
'fotal Fines: $220.980.1 I
Deed recorded on l2rlll18 and case is in cornpliance as of2/6/lr9.
OfTer ofsettlemerrt: '.-30.21 (5500.00 fines + 5230.21 costs)
NEW OWNf,R
ACCRUED VALUI.]:
PAYMENTOF:
TOTAL FINES TO II I] WAIVED:
s220.980.21
s730.21
s220,250.00
Janice Rives and Arturo Rives
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 760 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
Collier County
Growth Management Division
28OA Harseshoe Drive N.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
RECEIPT OF PAYMENT
Receipt Number:
Tra nsaction Number:
Date Paid:
Amount Due:
Payment Details:
Amount Paid:
Change / Overage:
Contact:
FEE DETAILS:
Fee Oescription
Specral Maqistrate
Cashier Name:
Batch Number:
Entered By:
20 19 60168 7
2019-024961
03/21/2019
$7 ,7 50.A0
Pavment Method
ACH
Reference Number
cEPNr 2 0160008025
Karina Noble
81 17
KerryAdams
Amount Paid
$500.00
Check Number
14027451-729A5
209
$500.00
$0.00
DLG GENERAL CONSTRUCTION L.L.C. 7566 GARiBALD] CT
Nap es, FL 34114
Orioinal
Fee
$ 7,7 5 0.00
Amount
Pa id
$500.00
GL Accou nt
111- 1389 r 1-3439 22
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 761 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
Collier County
Growth Management Division
23OO Harseshoe Drive N.
Naples, FL 34104
RECEIPT OF PAYMENT
Receipt Number:
Transaction Number:
Date Paid:
Amount Due:
Payment Details:
Amount Paid:
Change / Overage:
Conta ct:
FEE DETAILS:
Fee Description
Operational Costs (SM)
Operational Costs (Sl,l)
Cashier Name:
Batch Number:
Entered By:
2019 6016I6
2019-024960
03/21/20L9
$230.21
Pavment Method
ACH
Amount Paid
$230.21
Check Number
74027451-72985
209
$230.21
$0.00
DLG GENERAL CONSTRUCTION L.L.C. 7566 GARIBALDI CT
Naples, FL 34114
Refe rence Number Amount
Pa id
$115,33
$ 114.88
GL Accou nt
KarinaNoble
81 17
KerryAdams
cEPM20160008025
c E Pr,4 2 0160 0080 2 5
111- 138911-343922
111- 13891 l-343922
oriqinal
Fee
$115.33
$ 11.4.88
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 762 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
rNsrR 5653810 oR 5585 PG 761 REcoRDEo L2/27/2018 4:43 PM PAGES 2
CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIOA
Doc@.70 t1.085,70
coNS s155,100.00
IN TTIE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUI'|
IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLOzuDA
GENERAL JURISDICTION D IVISIONU.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION' AS
TRUSTEE FOR TtsW MORTGAGE-BACKED
TRUST SERIES 2006.4, TBW MORTGAGE PASS-
THROUGH CERTIFICATES, SEzuES 20064
PLAINTIFF,
vs.
JANICE RIVES, ET AL.,
DEFENDANTS.
I
E
The undersigned CIerk o
CASE NO. I 1-2017-CA-001522-0001-
xx
ate of Sale has been filed in this
described hercin and that noaction on
objections to the sale have
The followinir prop
LOT 36, BLOCK I O
for the
for filing objections.
THEREOI.- RECO
PUBLIC RECOIIDS T,IER COUNT
.. <a.1was sold to J -, /
ING TO THE PLAT
87, INCLI.ISIVE,
x)aples f I
t-
.5q tl s+^. (,
PI,AT BOOK
r.'i
v"r.
FtO
(
Crystal Kinzel
As Clerk of the Court
Clerk
.^:-"
.'l
_)
^..ut' c,v'
Casc No. I l-2017-CA'00 I 522'0001 -XX File No. 1i r0l26l-Fc0l
Witness my lrand and seal ottn court on D.rc,nhre r 27, 2O13,-.
I
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 763 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
i** oR 5585 PG 762 **.
//
/
Copies fumished to following;-l
v;A U € r"'r--"' I d/'
GusepPe Cataudella E sq.
Brock & Scott, PLLC
Anomev for Plaintiff
l50l N.w.49th Stretr. Suite 200
FL Laud€rdale, FL 333 09
FlCourtDocs@Srockandscott com
SERVICELIST
e!n-.t1,qq rz-/ zz /r (
Collier CountY, Florid r
c/o Board of County Commissioners
3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303
Naples, FL 341l2
kevinnoell@colliergov.net; rosav
Janice Rives a/k/a Janice Maria da
520 22nd Ave NE
Naples, FL 34120
Unknown SPouse of J:urice Ri
520 22nd Ave NE
Naples, FL 34120
Arturo Rives
4512lOth Ave SW
Naples, FL 34116
4512 30th Ave SW
Naples, FL 341 l6
/-V 5sl6 !\'o*^'
Case No' l 1-201?-CA-OO1 522-
0001-XX
Alex Nassimento
.ne r.
& W}itaktr
1
ll tr Cl
Mortgage Electronic Iiegistration Systems Inc' as nominee for Taylor' Bean
. / Mortgage corp.v J" Ct totpoi"tion s vstem' Ilegistered Agent
1200 South Pine Isla:rd Road
Plantalion, FL 33324
Unknown Spouse o11ftre Rives
) 9t LLc
File ir l7-F02263
It\v
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 764 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
Lcliler Lounly rroPerty ApPralser
Property Summary
Parcel No 6225972ao01 Site Address 5]78 BROWARD
ST Site City NAP LES
Page I of I
Site Zone
"Note 341 13
Name / Address 5378 BRoWARD ST LLC
5911 STAR GRASS LN
City NAPLES State FL Zip 34116
Map No.
5829
Section
29
Township
50
Rang e
26
Strap No.
s08300 10 355829
Acres :Egt!!!a!ed
0.1
Legal NAPLES x'lANOR LAKES BLK tO LOT 36
Millaqe Area O 1O8
Sub./Condo 508300 - NAPLES MANOR LAKES
!&e-!ede O 1 - SINGLE TAMILY RESIDENTIAL
Latest Sales History
(Not all saleg are listed due lo i:onfidentiality)
Oate Eook-Page Amount
12t27/18 s585-761 $ 155,100
o7t2ol06 4074-!897 $ 300,000
o9t18/e8 2_40]2911 $ 60,000
o1lo1rc3 1002-17,12 $ 25,000
, .osto1t77 707-1223 $ o
o3lo1l74 53!-172 $ 3,000
Millage Rates C 'Calculalions
School Other Total
5.049 6.4771 11.5261
2018 Certified Tax Roll
{Subje.t to Change)
Land value $ 43,655
(+) lmproved Value 3 68,430
(=) Market Value $ 112,085
(-) 10% Cap $ 34,078
(=) Assessed Valu $ 78,007
(=) School Taxable Value $ 112,085
(=) Taxable Value $ 78,007
lf all Values rhown above equal 0 thi! par.el was (real€d after th€ Final Tax Roll
4)
I
http://www.collierappraiser.com main_search/RecordDetail.html?sid:67535481 1&ccpaver= l7l0l 81 149&F... 212612019
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 765 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
Par(cl No 62259720001 T
1591
ar-Historic Ownca
Higtori( Owntr
RMS, IANICE&ART'...liO, addr.tr r5378 B
Rt';ES, l{NICE$AR.Jal. ndc.esr:5373 EAddre55(et)5 378
5378 Brow.rd ST il.ol.r, FL
5378 Browird ST
vi.vy A!!r:i oo thrs Proo€rty Orren Alcrts: O
Fees
Show ltac all rd.ted fea6 (Prop.rt) .
Add 6 ne* QllIgf or b-!:IlE-If to Addrtts Book
Fq"'lyW A,rcirnt i'si:Dnte
Refresh
cEPM2i160008n:5
CEPl.l20 t 60008o25
EEryr.0.L60s0!925
CEPM2g l50B,l8i:5
CEPlvl20160E0E025
coP280 t 040790
cDP20010{0790
PREp20r 90 t032ES
PR6D2019!l102289
PRgD2n 1901022s9
PR6O2,l !9D 10.2299
PR8D20190102289
oper.tion-, coits (St'l)
:5pacr!l Ma lrst..ste
Operatroni,l Cort5 (5M)
Initral Eoar ling,:ertrficate
SpEaral Fln ltstrate
Rernrpectr,n Fee for Bur,ding
Reinspcqtr:,n Fec ior Building
Structu.ai - Application Fe€
Inspacbon Fee
Structural . Re(rev Fee
E'A I
OEPR Sur - arge
51ls.33
I 7,750,00 .
s 11.1.88
s 21-i,oo0-00
s 75.00
S 75.00 i
s 50.00,
s 90.00
s 5i,.00
5:-85
s 2.00
a !1.00
E 0.00
5 0,00
5 150.00
! t 00
5 75.00
5 75,00
. s 50.00
sqn00
:i!D0
5 2.,10
01,'n9.2019
0u09/20L9
ot./18/2019
01/ 18,/ 1019
0t,/18 20r 9
01,'18./2019
0t./18,/2019
Amount ot'rinq,/ Amount Paid sr91.35
D.r(r-rptron Frncr rn p-osed of t250.00 per dar from 9/7./r6 to !0,;7./!6 (ll days) for 57,7Si.D,1, plus
ope.rti..al ccsts of S115.33.nd IOF corts of 311.1.88, ior a total of 37,980.21 ri-.r5 contrnue to
accrue_; a
Fro-Entc..d By lLEcAcYi Ka;tad;;;Qu.ntity
Fe! Pay.blc?Faa PardT oat! Entered lrOrOzoro
Payments
lacorialt P.!v Ch€<k;&!qsE!--uatitr; i i,-., ,'.
l
I t
5TA
I
I
Oatc : u- |
I
I
Paid Bv,' ro I
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 766 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
9/t9/19
Board of County Commissioners and / or
Michael Osorio
Growth Management Department Code Enforc€ment Division
2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples FL341O4
239-252-6865
Attention: Board of Collier County Commissioners
From: Diana Marin
ln reference to Property: 5378 Broward St.
Naples FL 3411 3
REOUEST FOR REDUCTION OF FINES
CODE VIOLATION CASE CEPM 2O160008025
I am the new owner of the property 5378 Broward St Naples. I purchase the property at Collier
County Auction on December 13, 2018. The purpose of the purchase was for my parents to own
their own home.
The violation CEPM 20160008025 was due to Window and doors boarded without first obtaining
an approved Collier County Certilicate.
As soon as llound out, I immediately applied and obtained the boarding certificate I also got in
touch with Steve Athey (Code enforcement) case representative.
Mr. Alhey informed me of what I needed to do to correct the violation. I was able to work with
Steve and corrected all the violation as soon as possible and re-secured the property. MrAthey
was able to close the case, and thank me for taking care of the violation in such a short period.
It seemed that the home was abandoned / vacant since 2014 and the property was a hazard to
the community, a big headache to the police department, County and code enforcement
department, specially due to the fact that the property is located at the entrance of Lely High
School.
The property needed lots of work that was not anticipated at lhe time ol the purchase but
our main concern was to get the home up to code as soon as possible, unfortunately I did not
anticipated the complications and damages the property had and how costly and difficult it was
to bring eveMhing up to code.
with the guidance ol code enforcement department we were able to obtained all permits
needed to complete the work. we worked on repairing the property: New Roof, New A/c
system, New water Heather, New Kitchen, New Appllances, New windows, shutters, clean-up,repair in the outside of the building, painting, all debris and hazard items removal thai were tett
As soon as the purchase was finalized, I went to the county to request a floor plan of the
property. When we started to research for the floor plans the county informed me that the
property had an outstanding Violation since 2016.
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 767 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
9/19/19
behind, fixing the land scape, etc. Between all fines, Liens, Past due t:xes, @unty permits,
prolessional assistance remodel / repair work and holding cost, my expenses to date are over
$219,944. a value much higher than what the house is worth.
The jobs are completed and passed inspections. Please see attached before and after pactures.
We exhausted all our reserves to do all the repairs, witch were way way more than anticipated
For the above stated reasons, we respectfully ask Code Enforcement and Board of County
Commissioners to considered a reduction of the fines of this code violation that are the fault ot
the previous owner since 2014 and before.
We would like to offer a settlement of $500.00 towards the fines, plus agree to cover any cost
that the county had incurred.
n
dianamarin20l 5@yahoo.com
Cell: 239.560.2634
Sir/eretd
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 768 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
( ol,t,tER ( 0t \ | \. t,t,oRlt).\
oFFt( u ot I [: sPE( t,\t, ]tA(;ts t tt \ I t.l
Stcp
()s\t ( .\st \{). ( uP\t20t60t}r)8025( ()l_l Ilalt ( ()t \l\
lt()ARI) O,' ( ()(.'\ I \ ( ( ), l\llSSl( )\t- l{S. t'(rrirr('r1cr
Sl Al'1, ()1 l;t.ORIDn
( otiN t-\' ()F ( ol.Ltt-.ti
BEFORII Illl. the undcrsigncd lruth$rity. personall) appeared Stcphen Athc). Codc Lnlbrccmcnt Official forlhe
lJearing bclore the Speci..l i\'lagistratq of C-'ollier Counl), who after bging full) sr\,orn. deposcs and says:
2 l'Ill thL. rcspQlldrrt did ct)l)tuel thc in!csligitor
Ihitl a re-inspe(tr.,r! \\'irs ncrlr'rmc(i on lehruar] 61h. l0l9
I{lYl-lS.,r.\\laU & .{RIl;I.O. lfc,ir)dirntr s r
I trl{lllLli,\l.l.l.\\ l S \\ liIll \()I
\t t-lt) \\ I I ol'( 0 \t Pl,r.\ \ ( [
(1)l.l-ll,RLOt \ r\'. ll()ltlt)A
HLARIN(] OIr THll SPtr('\,IACIS ItA III
4. Thirl the re-inspii I i(,n( . ) re!taled that thc corrective action ordered bv thc Special Magistrate was in
.,,r, plirrttr hr rtl .tirr;' ll.L \ i,,'.rt;,,
DA ff:l ) this 6th da) ,,l fehr ulr) . l0 I q
hcrr
(:
iS ignrture r,thli.,
(Priflt lrn( Slamp Com i'.i()nc(l \irre of\ota^ Publi()
Pea$n.rll\ lnljrvn \
xl rit
S fAl lr (ll Il-OI{lDA
('ol rNt Y oF c()t_t_ :R
flrl{,i('rrllirnrud}flnd. hiirih.(l l)eli,rc nl( lhr' 6 a,,',t fib*1 .:i,ilfh) Sr(phcrr \rtr.J\\
.itl.:.'t'- i/'t)w.:
HELEI.I BUCH ILLON
Ccmm sshn * GG 1C.i629
:r2'rea May 15,2021
3.iiu 1r,! ltncd fi ol/ starrt
lhrl on AutltNt r)5.2016. thc Spcirial \larislrate hchi a hutring and issuctl an ()rdcr in lhe rbrr,,e-srr.lccl
n'ralter and stntc(l lhal l).li'rrJxnt(s)\\lrt 1(r ilhill( lll riolalrons ir.:l.rtjrl in tllc r )rJct ,,, tlr( \pr.(ial \l.rSrstr:rlL.
recordc:l in thc pLrblic rrcords ol'( rrllier ( rrtrntl. Fk,ridir rrr ()R Ilrx'k :]gl_ P(l j?91 .
I
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 769 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
INSTR 5328561 oR 532E PG .1642 RECoRDED 10/11/2076 11:22 Atit PAGES 2
DTIGHT E. BROCT(, CLERT( OF rHE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUMTY FLORIOA
REc t18- 50
COLLIER COUNTY CODE TNFORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGIST IATE
Case No. -CEPM20l r,t)008015
BOARD OF COIJNI'Y COI{MISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNT\', FLOIUDA,
Petitioner,
vs.
JAIIICE RMS Ar- l) ARTURO RTVES,
Respondelrb.
TTIIS CAUST came b
for Imposition of Fircs/Liens
respective to all appropriate
Magistrate, as fgllows :
l. Or August 5, 2016, Respo
and Ordinanc !s, Chapt.:r 22,
first obtaining an spproved Coll lc
property localed at 5378 Broward St
NAPLES MANOR LAKES BLK IOLOT36).
g upon thc Petitioner's Motion
stratc, having heard argumcnt
Collier County Code of l:ws
r boarding ofa dwelling without
which violation occurred on the
F olio #622597 20001 (Lcgal Description:
n
ctt
2 An order was cntered b)'the spccial N'fagistrEte ordcring Respondent to abate the violation on o!
before Septer:.ber 6, 2016, or a fine of5250.00 per day would bc assessed for cach day thc
violations co.iinue thcreafler until abatement is confirmed. (A copy ofthe order is rccorded atoR 5304 PG 1793).
operational cosrs of $ I 15.33 incuned by the county in the prosecurion ofthis case were ordered
to be paid.
Respondent, having bt'cn dury noticed for thc pubric hcaring rcgarding thc county's Motion, didnot appear at rhe public hcaring, and no legal defelse to the Moiion wis presentcd.
No ReTlest fJr Re-hclring or Appeal pursuant to Ordinance 2007-44, as amended, has beentimely filed.
The violation has not been abated as ofthe date oflhc h€rring.
found guilty ofv
h and Order of the Special
3.
4.
5.
6.
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 770 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
B
Based upon the foregoing Finding of Fact, aod pursusnt to thc authority graoted in Chapter 162,
Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No. 200744, as amcnded, it is hereby ORDERED:
Petitioncr's lvlotion for Impositioo ofFincdl"iens is granted.
Daily fines of $250.00 1:cr day are assessed against Rcspondcnt for 3l days for thc period from
September 7, 2016 to October 7, 2016, for a total amount of fines of$?,750.00.
Respondent shall pay the previously assessed operational costs in the amount of $l 15.33.
Rcspndcnt shall pay operational cosls for thc lmposition ofFincs hearing in the amount of
$r l4.EE.
s ordered ro pay fines and costs in the total amount of $12!qa! or be subject to
sessment cf Licn against all ies owned by Respondent in Collier County,
c.
D.
E.Respondent i
Notice of As
Florida.
F. The daily finc of$250. r) s
County Code Enforccr r r c
DONE AND ORDEITUD thir;
has bccn confirmed by a Collicr
Iicr County, Floridr.
DI] ENT'ORCEJ\I ENT
I]
TSON
T
c.
EAYMENT QF n'IN tas: L\:rv fines ordered tote paid pursuant to this ordcr may be paid ar the collicr
counly code Enforcement Dir ision, 2800 North Honcshoc Drive, Naples, FL 34lria, pirone # 1z:12i2-2440, or vww.colliergov.net. , rry releasc of lien or confimation of compliance or confirr,,,:iun of the
satisfaction ofthc obligations r :rlis order may also be obtained at this locaticn.
AHE4L: Ary aggrieved plly may appeal a final order of the special Magistrate io thc Circuit courtwithin thirty (30) days of thc crccution ofrh-e order appealed. Anappeal shail not bcahearin;;;;;;;:
but shall .be limited ro apper 'c revic* of the recori created wiihin thc originar r,"rri"g "iiir-oJ
responsibility ofthe appeaiing . .rj1y to obtain a banscribed rccord ofthc hearin.: irom the Cleik ofCourts.Filing an Appeal will not autor :rirically stay the Special Magistrat€,s Oder.
cc: Respondent -Jrnice Rir'.,.. and Aduro Rives Stale or rlcfloa .
collier co cc,le Enfor r)cnl Division county 0f c0LLlER
tor
ue to accrue unt
MASPE
rrr oR 5328 PG 1643 .r*
ORDER
IHERED
corec1 c
.t.:
COIIRTTD!!rGr
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 771 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
INSTR 5302427 oR 5304 P6 3793 -oRoEo 8/L7/2OL6 11:48 Ar, pacEs 2DIIGIfI E. aRocx, CLER( OF THE CIR ;IT COURT, COLLIER COUNIY FLORIDA
REC J18.50
COLI,IER UNTY CODI NFOR( ]EMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
Casc No. -{EPM:!0r600080,5
YS.
BOARD OF COUNT]' COI TNIISSIONERS
COLLIER COI'NTY, FLOI IDA,
Petitlotrcr,
( ItI)
THIS CAUSE came c
lhc Special Magistrate, havir
resPective to all appropriate
Magistrate, as follorvs:
Based upon rlrc for r.
granted in Chapter 162, Florid
ORDERED:
or
r ait
istr.,te on August 5, 2016, and
d :nce and hcard argument
and Order of thc Spcci8l
F
..r
Respondcnts, Janice )tives fuves, are the subject property.
ail and posting and the Special
T2. Respondents tvere norified oftho ni fied m
Magistnte hirs jurisdi rtion of lhis maner.
3. Respondenls, havi,:c een duly ol ified, did not appesr at the public h: aring.
4. Thc real propcrq' roc:r :d at 5378 Irroward st€cr, Napres, Florida, Fofo #6225972000r (Leear
Descriprion: NApLE. MANOR r_AKES
-BLK
t0 LOT 39, is in viotaLion "aC"iti;;a;;;i;-'code of [-arvs and or'.inanc6, chaptcr 22, Arricre vI, s;rio n 2z-z4r(r) in rre ioiio*inl-'particulars:
Boarding ofdrvc[ing \]irr,ut firsl oi (ainiog aD approvcd co[icr countl. boarding ccrrificare.
5. The violation h:r: ncr ' ,ren abared as ofthe datc ofthe public hea.ring.
ORDER
Speci
rg Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, art I pursuant to thc ;rLrthorilra Statutes, and CollierCountyOrdinaoceN". 02".t,'"r"r"ij"A,'1, i;ffiii,
JANICE RTVES AND AIITI .O RIVIS,
Respotlderls.
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 772 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
*rr oR 5304 PG 37q4 *rr
E. Respondent is ordered ro pay opcia
SI1533 on or lrcforr Scpte mli/,-\
A. Rcspondent is for:nd I ! irr), of vi. ration of collicr couoty code of La\, s and ordinanccs, chapter22, Article VI, S.stic , 22-24t(t).
B Respondent mrsl abarr rhc viora i ion by obraining alr required co[ier ciounty buirding pcrmi6, ordemolition permit' inspccrions, e:Ld certificare oacompr;tior/occupan;y on Lr beforJScptcmlcr
6, 2016 or I fi nc of 5250.00 pcr day rvill be imposed for each day the violation remains
lhereaner.
c' Altematively, if a boarding cefl ificate is obtaincd and thc structurc is I.roperly boarded on orbefore Argust 12, 2016, then the time required to complctc the rcpair,,, inspcctions, and
c^ertificate of complerion.ioccuF incy will be extended to and musi be .omitctcd by Fetruary 6,2017 or a finc of s25'i .0rr pcr dr v rvilr be imposcd for each day lhe \': -.lation remains tl:ereader.'
D. If Respondenr fairs tc compry wirh this o_Jder, the cillier county cod c Enrorcement Dcpartment
may abaie thc \ ic latic I using an.,, method to bring the violation into cr rnpliance. If ncccssary, theCounty may rr,lLi,rst tl g scn.ices ,fthe Collicr County Sherill's Ofl.icr: lor the purposc r f "
accessing lhe Iropcrty for abater rcnt. AII costs ofabatemcnt shall bc .ssesscd against ti e
property.
DONE AND ORDEI.:I]I. Ihi
abalement or compliar c9s
ls
Codr
da,
d;i
ment Investigat cn ,/, they, within 2'l l:turs of
bc 1.) confim compliance.
F. Respondent slrall notil',,rlr6
rl
on ofll,is case in the amount of
licr County, Florida.
D.] ENFORCEMI]NT
Tf,
CO
SPE
E
A C. GARRETSO.
P NT OF T'ES:
County Code Enforcenrcnt Di
2440, or rnvw.colliergov.nct.
satisfaction of thc obl il:alions
./.irl:.ri-es(.iercdtobepaidpursuanttothisordr:maybcpaidarr,reCollicr
rr.i n,280., Noflh Horscshoe Drive, Naples, FI 41d4, phonc f )g\ 252-
An_r, rclease of licn or contirmation of complir:rcc or ionfirmation of thcof tlr is ordc. may also bq obtained at this locaiior
Ai,P,E4!, Anyaggrieved pr.nl mayr peal a final order ofthe Sp€cial Mat,istrate to the Circuit Courtwithin lhirty (30) da1.s of rheer.ei. rio" ;h-e Order appeated. A";pp";i sh,,r notbcahearin;i;;;;,but shall.be limired ro a.pe, r" rc : :f thc record created iriir,i"-trr. ,ginnr teailg "iiis-lhl
rcsponsibirity ofthe appea i ing ,a r ''1()ol .1in a transcribed record ofthe lcarir . from the crerk ofcourrs.Filing an Appeal rvill notirrror:,ll r.s: ,r,theSpecial Mugirt.ur";. ijrd.i.
-'= rt =t.t 12
,uril';rtC-'-iLti ",i,,,
,utirv.cc-;, 'rl i"'is is a true ard
-'rLl e:#:i ; ,::, 'r':ii: ca'ilc in
-,:.ri i ";'r'.:i:+i:.: : :a) :3 a-lCr".:r County, rir.s:i +i i,-. :.r,rj cii'j.::l s:al ihis
l@ir:i!i:):.t*t+Ab
cc Rcspondent(s) - J;rrrice :. i sand ,rluro Riyes
Collier Co- Co.Jc hnforc-'r :nl Dir ision
ofu&
Ct:RK OF RTS
-\]
\?\
.BPT'
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 773 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
tt2n0t9
Board Of Collier County Commissioners 8nd /or
lliana Burgos
Operations Supervisor-
Growth Managernenl DcFrtmer Code Enforcement Divisbn
2800 Norlh Horsesha Drive Naples, FL 14104
739-252-6865
Anention: Boad Of Collier Couty Comm issioners
The purpose of this letter is io r€qu€st a rcduction offines 537E Broward St Naples FL., since the fines
were accrued prior to transfer oftirle by pr:rlxrs owners Janice and Aurhor Rivers.
I Diana Marin rhe new ownerr purcluscd Foperty 537t Broward St Naples FL at the Collier County
Auction. When I prchased the property I was not aware ofany County vblsrions m the property, that
were accrued by previous owrrrs.
Typ(ex OSM, CEB) CASE# CEPM20|60fl)8025:
Open case for windows and doors boardcd witlnut fint obbining an approved Collier County Boarding
Cerrificate. order oR 5304 FG 3793. Lien OR 5328 PC 1642.
As soon as I found out I got in touch with Steve Athey css€ repr€sentative, (a member ofthe Collier
county Code Enforcernent Division).
Mr. Athey informed me ofthe County violation on the property and what I needed to do to co'I€ct the
violations; I was able to work with Steve and corecred all the violation. Mr Athcy was able to ckxe the
case # CEPM2Ol 60008025.
Unfortunately I did nor know how bod the property was and I did nor anticipate the large amount of
money rcquired to fix il.
I will greatly appreciale ifyou would consider waiving the fines or at least rcduce it substentially at rhis
momenl lhe max amounl I am able to pay for the fine is $500.
I really appreciate your help.
Diana Marin
591 I Star Grass Ln Naples Fl 341l6
PH: 239 200 38,18
dianamarin20 I 5@yahoo.com
7*,\
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 774 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
IxsTR 5328561 oR 5328 PG 1642 RECORDED \O/1L/2OL6 11:22 A}l PAGES 2
DI'IGHT E. AROCK, CLERT OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER, COUT{W FLORIDA
REC t18.50
vs.
COLLIER COTINTY CODE ENTORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
Calc No, -{EPM20160008025
BOARD OF COI'NTY COMMISSIONERS
coI r rDR couN'IY, FITRIDA,
Petltlo[€r,
JANICE RIVES A}ID ARTI'RO RTYEST
Re!ponden6.
THIS CAUSE camc
for Imposition of FineVLicns
respective to all appropriatc
Msgistrate, as follows:
L On August 5,2016,
and ffiinances, Chaptcr 22,
first obtaining ar approved Col
property located at 5378 Broward
NAPLES MANOR LAKES BLK I O LOT 35).
g upon the Petitioner's Motion
having heard argumcnt
and Order of the Special
Collier County Code ofLaws
boarding ofa dwelling without
which violstior occumd on the
Folio #62259720001 (t gal Description:
2 An order wrs enrered by the spccial MagisEEte ordcring Rcspondcnt to abste the violation on or
before Scptember 6, 2016, or a fine of$250.00 per day would bc assessed for each day thc
violations continue thereafrer until abatement igconfirmed. (A copy ofthe order is recorded atoR 5304, PG 3793).
operational costs of $ r 15.33 incuned by thc county in thc prosccution ofthis case lvere ord€rcdto be paid.
Respondcnt, hsving_bccn duly noticcd for thc public hcari[g reglrding the County,s Motion, didnot appear at the public hearing and no legEl defense to th;Mo-tion wis presentcd.
No Reqres for Re-hearing or Appear pursusnt to ordinanc€ 2007-44, as amended, has bccntimely filed.
T'he violation h8s not been abatcd as ofthc date ofthc hearing.
found guilty of
3.
4.
5.
6.
OBDE SP
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 775 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
a.r oR 5326 PG 1643 r*r
Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFac! and pusuart to thc adhority Branted in Chapter I62,
Florida Statutes, and Collia County Ordinance No. 2007-44, as amended, it is h€reby ORDERED:
ORDER
Rcspondent shall pay op3rstioml costs for thc Imposition ofFincs hearing in the amount of
sl14.88.
Respondent is ordered
Notic! of Assessmcnt
Florida.
to pay fines and cosls in the total amount of$Zpgqzf or be subject to
ofLien against all ies owned by Respondent in Collier County,
F. The daily fine of$250.00 has been confirmed by I Collicr
County Code
DOI{E AND ORDERED lhis CouDty, Florida.
ENFORCEMENT
A.
B.
c.
D.
E.
c.
EAYMEITT O=r ITNES: Aryfincs odcrrd to b€ paid pursuanr to this order may be paid strheCollicr
County Code Enforcement Division, 2E00 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, pL 34104, pironc # (239) 252_
2440, or www.colliergov.net. Any rcle&se of lien or confirmation of compliance or c.nfirmstio[ ;f thc
satisfac{ion ofthc obligations of this order may also be obtained 8t Ihis loc{tion.
AILE4!r Any aggrieved party may appear a fioal order ofthc special Msgistrate to thc circuit courtwithin thirty (30) days of thc execution of th,e order appealed. An ippeal shaii not be a hearin g de noio,but shsll.b€ limiled to appellate rcview of the record crcated within the original hearing. - Ir is theresponsibility ofthe.appealing paay to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing irom the cleik ofcourts.Filing an Appeal will not automaticslly stay thc Special Magistrate,s Order.
cc Respondent -Janice Rives and Afuro Rives
Collier Co. Code Enforccment Division
slae 0t rldrua .
Conty d COttlER
ue to accrue
MA
Petitioncr's Motion for Imposition ofFineyliens is granted.
Daily fincs of$250.00 per day are asscsscd against Rcspondent for 3l days for th€ period from
Scptember 7, 2016 to October 7, 2016, for a total amount offines of$7,750.00.
R€spordent shall pay the previously assess€d operational costs in thc amount of$l15.33.
sPt
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 776 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
It{sTR 5302427 oR 5304 PG 3793 RECoRDED a/r7 /2OL6 U:4E x't PAGES 2
DEGHT E. BROCT, CLERK OF THE CIRCUTT COURT, COLLIER CdJ}ITY FLORIDA
REc t18.50
COLLIER COI'NTY CODE ENT'ORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
Carc No. {EPM20160008025
vs.
BOARD Otr' COUNTY COMMISSIOIYERS
COLLIER COI'NTY, FLORIDA,
P€lltlooGr,
JANICE RIVES AND ARTT'RO RIVES,
Respo[de[E,
THIS CAUSE came on strate o[ August 5,2016, ardthe Special Magistratc,ord hssrd argumcnt
respeclivc to all appropriate
Magistratg as follows:
and Order of the Special
Respondenls, Janice Rivcs the subjcct propcrty.
Respondents rvcre notified ofthe mail and posting and the SpccialMagistrate has jurisdiction of this m8ner.
3- Rcspondcnts, having been duly notified, did not appesr at the public hcaring.
4. Thc real propcrty locst.d at 5378 Brow8rd Srecl Naplcs, Florida, Folio #62259220001 (Irgal
Descriplion: NAPLES MANOR^LAKES
-BLK
ro Lor 36), is in viotarion orcorti., -ouifl'
Code of lanvs and tuin8nces, Chaprer 22, Arfcfe vt, Sc;iion 22-Z+f tf t in .hc ioiiowing '
particulsrs:
Bosrdirg of dwerrrng $'rthout Ii,'r obrrilirg aD apptlved coucr county bocrdrtrg c.rtifrcrre
5. Thc violation h8s rot been abatcd as ofthe date ofthc public hcadrg.
ORDER
I
2
Rives, are
...BllduponrhcforcgoingFindingsofFactandconcrusionsoflrw,sndpursuantrotheauthoritv
ggcd in€h8pcr 162, Florida sratutes, andCo,ierCountyOrdi;";N.0'a;;,.;;;;&;i; "j#:di
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 777 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)
rr* oR 5304 PG 3794 'rr
E. Respondent is ordered to pay
Sl1533 on or beforc
F- Res?ondcnt shall notiry
abatement or complian
DOnlE A"hlD ORDERED thlg
Respondent(s) - Jsnicc Rives 8nd Artuo Rivcs
Collier Co. Codc Enforcement Divisior
A. lgspondent is found guilty ofviolation ofcollicr coulty code oft-arvs and ordinanccs, chaptcr
22, Article VI, Secrion 22-241(l).
B. Rcspondent must abare rhe violation by obtaining all rcquir€d collier county building pcrmits, ordemolition permit, i*pections, 8n-d ccrtificatc ofcomptition/occupancy on or bcforiS"pt".6u.
6, 2016 or a llne of5250.00 pcr d8y wilt be imposed for each day the violation rcmains'
thercafler.
c. _Altcmatively, ifa boerdirg cenificatc is obtsined and ttc stsucturr is properly boarded on or
b€forr Augult 12,2016, then thc timc rEquirrd to complete the rcpairs, inspections, and
certificare
-of
comprction/occuparcy lvill be odendcd io and musi be complered by Fcbruary 6,
2017 or a ,lne ofs250.@ per day wil bc imposcd for cach day the vioratiln rcmar:ns thereaf[er.'
D. IfRespondent fails to comply rvith this o_rder, the collier county codc Enforccment Depa.tment
may abate lhc violarion using any mcthod to bring thc violation into compliance. If n"o"lory, rrri
County may rcquest thc scrvices oflhc Collier County Sheriffs Officc for thc purpose of ' '
acccssing thc property for abatement. All costs ofabatcmcnt shall be assesscd againsl thepropcrty.
PAYIIfENI qF,FINES! Any fin^es-ordered. ro be paid pusuant to this ordcr may bc paid at rhe CollicrCourty Codc Enforccment Division, 2E00 Nonh Horscshoe Drivc, Naplcs, FL 341 64, pi";.iiia;;;t;_2440, or \yww.collicrgov.net. Any rele&sc of lien or confirmation of compliancc oi,lonn.,n.t* 6iin1salisfsction ofthe obligations ofihis order may 8lso bc obtained at rhis location.
#+ -Any.aggricved pany may appcar a finar order of the special MagisEale ro the ci.uit courtwrurn wny (JU) dsys olthe cxecutiofl of th-e order appeared. An appcar shail not be a hcari, gde now,but shall .be timired ro appellare rcview of thc record crcared wiidin thc original r,-rrri. " ii ir-tr,Jrcsponsibility ofthe.appealing party to oblain a trsnscribed record ofthe hecing iro, tfr" criif oi'cou.t .Filing an Appcal rvill not 8utomatically stay rhc Sp€cial Magistratet Order.
TE
AC, GARRETSON
ofthis crse in the amount of
Athcy, within 24 hours of
to confirm compliance.
County, Florlde.
EMORCEMENT
Slr:s ci Fiorrl3. 1'... '
Coufiy at€-'i.LlJaR;: '.,.7-
.
r nediif$j-, L+ r"rJ iils is a true and
cclr:t:s:f,ri': ':l: '."
)i: clTls in
6:::ii. r'rls i'r.l i.:i:' :a aiC::'?r County
Ii&t*l';3$#un'-''
IrlYest
be
ii
cc:
E,CL:RK OF RTS
16.A.19.d
Packet Pg. 778 Attachment: Backup Rives (10335 : BCC v. Janice Rives and Arturo Rives)