Loading...
Agenda 06/24/2008 Item #17B Agenda Item No. 178 June 24, 2008 Page 1 of 19 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Petition SNR-2008-AR-12854, Christian Spilker of the Hamilton Harbor Marina, Inc., requesting a street name change. The applicant proposes to change Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. The street length is +/- 2,300 feet with 11 parcels abutting the street. The site is located in Section 23, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. OBJECTIVE: Recommendation to have the Collier County Board of County Commissioners approve the Resolution renaming Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. CONSIDERATIONS: The Petitioner has met the requirements for requesting a street name change and the proposed name does not duplicate an existing street name in Collier County. Of the 10 owners of property abutting the street in question, 8 (or 80 percent) have granted their approval of the change. Collier County Ordinance No. 2007-62 states that anyone wishing to rename a County street must submit a petition establishing that at least 66 percent of the property owners abutting the street are in favor of the change. FISCAL IMPACT: Fiscal impact will be incurred in the form of staff time spent noting changes on plats by the Engineering and Environmental Services Department and address records by Addressing staff. Fiscal impact to fire, police (Sheriffs Office), Post Office, EMS, and 911 Emergency Services will be incurred in the form of costs to update rccords and maps. The Petitioner will bear the cost of replacing the sign(s). GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: The renaming of the street will have no impact on the Grow1h Management Plan. ZONING DEPARTMENT STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve Petition SNR-2008-AR- 12854, changing the name of Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The Collier County Planning Commission does not review street name change petitions. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The County Attorney's Office has reviewed this matter and prepared the proposed Resolution. .TW. PREPARED BY: Ashley Caserta, Senior Planner Department of Zoning and Land Development Review .- 1 Item Number: Item Summary: Meeting Date: Page I of2 Agenda Item No. 17B June 24. 2008 Page 2 of 19 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 17B This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approve Petition SNR~2008-AR~12854, by Christian Spilker of Hamilton Harbor Marina, Inc, requesting a street name change from Fern Street to Hamllton Avenue, located within Section 23, Township 50 South. Range 25 East. 6/24/200890000 AM Prepared By Ashley Caserta Community Development & Environmental Services Planner Date Zoning & Land Development Review 5/22/200811:49:10 AM Approved By Ray Bellows Community Development & Environmental Services Chief Planner Date Zoning & land Development Review 5/28/20088:51 AM Approved By Susan Murray, AIC? Community Development & Environmental Services Zoning & Land Development Director Date Zoning & Land Development Review 5128/20088:53 AM Approved By Judy Puig Community Development & Environmental Services Operations Analyst Community Development & Environmental Services Admin. Date 5/28/200811 :59 AM Approved By Heidi F. Ashton County Attorney Assistant County Attorney Date County Attorney Office 6/5/2008 11 :15 AM Approved By Joseph K, Schmitt Community Development & Environmental Services Community Development & Environmental Services Adminstrator Date Community Development & Environmental Services Admin, 6/10/20088:05 PM Approved By Norm E. Feder, AICP Transportation Services Transportation Division Administrator Date Transportation Services Admin. 6/12/20086:34 AM Approved By OMS Coordinator OMS Coordinator Date file://r'\Aopnrh:aTpd\Pvnrwt\ 11 n_ TllnPO/h')fI')A O/",)(\'1(\nQ\ 1 '7 O/'flCIIJI. H A An VO/"'l^ .I. ".......,... .I.' Page 2 01'2 Aoenda Item No. 178 " June 24. 2008 Page 3 of 19 County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 6/12/20082:17 PM Approved By Mark Isackson Budget Analyst Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 6/12/20086:29 PM Approved By James v. Mudd County Manager Date Board of County Commissioners County Manager's Office 6115/20089:07 PM file://C:\AuendaTest\Fxnort\ II O-.IlJne%)())4%~mOOR\ 17%)OSIIMM A R Y%?OAGFNnA \ Ii/I R!?OOR co OJ en f'-O~ ",,;:-0....... NO "':" NO) E Q) Ol Q) C '" .:!::::::io.... ",' '0 ~ (jj OJ <l: N , o ::;) '" J:, z wQ !::!< ",0 o ~ < o ~\ =>~ a. ;; " I- I I , I I " ~ !! " O~ ::lil Cl." > ~ , I I "I ~If.- ~1V1 I I I I I I I , , I I I I ~ ~ ~ " i'\ @ , 3 ~ , 0 " " > ~ -;- S3ld'lN ~6 A11:1 Jl~:>S OJ ,DN / - I- . Oi~- * w.n~ : h ? ~~ " \ ~ \ ,-I ~J 'Of '0 . J"f ".! i! (/ , ~, .. \ f! \ ~ ~~ " ~~ ~~!l-, ~ad~ o o h." i'e ". H- ".~~'ii~i... ~._)W'" , ! ;:; ~ ~"",.., ""'""'" ""'" OOOM""I ~~ .. _ ______".l"'~: $( ~ , c::q I "'---J ! ~ I " . ~ ~ , Vr.n D~ ~N~~"-3H"O(}"': ,,'" .~DI ,.., ._.~ \1 ~-~ IUZ a.. <t: ~ C) Z Z o N " ~ '" N "' <l:, cb: g: ~I ZI ,,"'I Z o l- I- W n. a.. <t: ~ z o I- <t: U o ....J ~,Qenda item No. 178 " June 24, 2008 Page 5 of ',9 RESOLUTION NO 08 - RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, RENAMING FERN STREET TO HAMILTON AVENUE, WHICH STREET IS LOCATED IN SECTION 23, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH. RANGE 25 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE, WHEREAS, the legislature of the Stale of Florida by enacling Scclion 336.05, Florida Statutes, has conferred on all counties in Florida the power to name or rename streets and roads, except for certain state roads; and 'WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted Collier County Ordinance No. 07-62, codifted as Chaptcr 22, Article X, of the Code of Laws and Ordinanct:s of Collier County, Florida, and establishes criteria and procedures to rename streets or roads; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners (Board), has held a public hearing after providing notice as required by said ordinance and has considered the advisability to grant the request by lIemilton lIarbor Marina, Inc., to rename Fcm Street to Humilton Avcnue, which is located in Section 23, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier Cmmty, Florida; and \VHEREAS, the Board has detennined that all criteria .set forth in Ordinance No, 07-62) have been met and specifically finds that there is no other street in incorporated or unincorporated Collier County with the same name or any similar sounding name as is being requested; and WHEREAS, the Board hus determined that it is necessary for identification purposes to confirm the name of the street. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, lhat; Effective the date ofhearillg, the name oftrus street described in the above recitals is changed from FERN STREET to HAMIL TON A VENUE, and is confinned as such. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED thai this Resolution be recorded in the Public Records of Collier COlmty, Florida, and referenced upon the maps of the street, any applicable plat(s), and in the zoning atlases of Collier COWlty. Page 1 of2 Agenda-hem No. 176 June 24, 2008 Page 6 of 19 This Resolution adopted after motion, second and super majority vote. Done this day of ,2008 AD'EST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIOl\'ERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA DWtGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA By: , Deputy Clerk BY: . TOM HENNING, CHAlRMAN ed as to Form and Legal Sufficiency: I ACA>, Page 20[2 Aaenda item f-.Jo. 17B ~ June 24. 2008 Page 7 of 19 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET <i> 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 STREET NAME CHANGE APPLlCA nON J SNR AR # PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER DATE PROCESSED ASSIGNED PLANNER [ SNR-2008-AR_ J 2854 HAMILTON HARBOR PUD PROJECT: 199903 J 6 DATE: 2/6/08 DUE: 2/21/08 I APPLICANT INFORMATION NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) Christian Spilker ADDRESS 3003 Tamiami Trail N., Suite 400 TELEPHONE 239.26 I .4455 CELL # E-MAIL CSpilkerlalColliel.Enterprises.com CITY Na~_.__ STATE f1-__~ ZIP ;;3103 FAX # 239.263.3849 NAME OF OWNER lIamilton Harbor Marina, Inc. ADDRESS 3003 Tamiami Trail N., Sll)!.e 40(j __._. CITY Naples TELEPHONE 239.26 1.4455 CELL # E-MAIL STATE 1'1-_ ZIP 34103 FAX # 239.263.3849 ASSOCIATIONS Complete the Following for 011 Association(s) afFiliated with this petition, Provide additional sheets if necessary. NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION MAILING ADDRESS CITY.. STATE ZIP NAME OF MASTER ASSOCIATION MAILING ADDRESS __.__ CITY_ STATE. ZIP NAME OF CIVIC ASSOCIA nON MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP *Be aware that Collier County hns lobbyist regulations. Guide yourself accordingly and ensure that )'OU are in compliance with these regulntions. ApplicBllon fOIO Slreel Name Chnnge - Rc\'lsed MilY 2007 Pllgr2(Jf6 Agenda Item No. 17B June 24, 2008 Page 8 of 19 I PETITION TO: THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COlliER COUNTY, FLORIDA THE UNDERSIGNED PETITIONERS HEREBY REQUEST THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS TO CHANGE THE NAME OF THE FOLLOWING STREET NAME FROM: TO: .ffi2 N ~T- NAME OF OWNER (PRINTED) () fr!ICHI'lr;1.. ;Ml'1t>'1Y ;r) c. E,\JT)1l..~ ~\ll'ripOI"''''; Prr Wj;JOS'T'A~ P1~I,."q \ .>. "o;n<l ~ f1ltIr;. n,..1t... " I ,;S':>CCIA'i1 0-0 , II WlNOSt'l:l>t.Cu.4Q lnlc OWNER SIGNATURE II 1\ If. j.C 1I11<.:ro"J J.lAfl)OO'L '. mlH2IN(.I 1\ T ....! iLL ( 8l.... .J<.A. "i-r H.4/'YJ/L.70<l IIvCNlAe ADDRESS AND TAX 10 MAILING ADDRESS # OF PROPERTY (IF DIFFERENT THAN . ABUTTING STREET ADDRESS ABUTTING STREET) CS'2.. VAIIlFOQ,ll r G02.5" WfiR..f:r-r r. 'Afi.€> ytJl /V'.q.oce;; ':f(:?''fll?. $1 Lor:. r I II ~ Of 10 No 17'G Ao1>~.s I. O. 'Box ~o('Z... ~~~.o~"'1fu 12/o~A 1 ;1/""<'0 k Fi.. '5'11'11. J 0 T~c.r/l gyp /f}OOWIt-lllS'1'A....13w &,(JTj.jpoINfl 17../fJ'!./e7 N4>r9<.E> fL. '3<f/lZ- y_'I'CIo.....~.~K Q.fuo WI"'l)Sm>t."lS<.vD 10: LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF ADDRESS DATE <211c c;:...~ If I?.JOg bl) J12.0 W,"'\?S'mt1. L.Vp II ;;t:\J~V;;,J 12/0 101 10\ i) 'l/fJJ21 N!J. rorJ "nD L.lr '2 I tj.i5fi /..1I~i1rH"I>t~r; L/"J N~ un f FZ. "3'1 WZ_ No 'cn. AoD~e'S) 70fi> H:-"l2.tJ ID54 T. l () ,,)' K,....-w ~r. It ~N 5:Tt!2-lEG'r AppJiCRtioll for Street Nlllllt Chflllgc- Revised May 2007 Page S of (} .~.genda Item No. 17B June 24. 2008 Page 9 of 19 'is OK NAME OF OWNER OWNER ADDRESS AND TAX ID MAILING ADDRESS LEGAL (PRINTEpJ SIGNATURE # OF PROPERTY (IF DIFFERENT THAN DESCRIPTION DAn . ABUTTING STREET ADDRESS ABUTTING OF ADDRESS STREET) .. . (.20tlRIC.tz:; f bL8:!NO, l)ANR>(2.,\::>~. r:>3<t:f1)1~'" Ac.l.G 0< NI/fl.6S g~Ylllt I e'lloJl>,A<R..i) tJAfu.~I'f;:.. 3'1~:J. /"trr kfs -- I AppllC'atioll fcw Street Nall1~ Ch:ltlgc- Rc\'iscd i\ln)' 20G7 Page G of6 Agenda Item No. 178 June 24. 2008 Page 10 of 19 PROPOSED CHANGE CURRENT NAME OF STREET Fern Street PROPOSED STREET NAME Hamilton Avenue STREET IN QUESTION IS: I{] public, or 0 private REASON FOR PROPOSED CHANGE 7;:; 7J.COCrN I 'iC;: 7HG' 14",,/l..roN fAmILY I EIJr:z.L7 .r €77lGiC2S OF [Ou...1 f'R. r"CtlNTj ;:JiJn --r;:,~Mf'77)/~."..1.. 0ITNI-I.cAtL("ILJ2f 7Hr;. 1~"I/(.Tt)-J (YJ/DfM1,), , '2,"uo Approximate length of street )g{).Qft. Number of parcels or lots abutting street ~ \\ , Total Number of property owners abutting street to be renamed ] 0 Total Number of property owners signing petition to change street name is Percentage of property owners signing petition ~()% Applicant I{] does, or 0 does nOI, agree to pay cost of street sign replacement for public street, (approx. $100.00 per sign) ApplicatiDn fl)1" Strccl NnUlc Change - Revised May :Z007 PlIge3Qf6 Agenda Item No. 17B June 24, 2008 Page 11 of 19 r l LOCATION List legal description(s) of properties abutting the street to be renamed. (Altach additional pages if necessary) Subdivision: Naples Bayview Addition # 1 Unit No. 1-1 Tracl No. Section/Township/ Range: 23 / 50 / 25 Subdivision: Naples Bayview Addition III Unit No. 4-6 Tract No. Section/Township/ Range: 23 / 50 / 25 Subdivision: Naples Bayview Addition # I Unit No. 7-10 Tract No. Section/Township/ Range: 23 / 50 / 25 Subdivision: Naples Bayview Loll Unit No. Tract No. Section/Township/ Range: 23 / 50 / 25 Subdivision: Southpointe Yacht Club Phase II Tract No. B (Butler) Unit No. Section/Township/ Range: 23 / 50 /--1:~ Subdivision: Southpointe Yacht Club Phasc II Unit No. Tract No. A (R/W) Section/Township/ Range: 23 / 50 / 25 Application for Strcet Name Chnngc- Revl~ctl May 2007 rage 4 of 6 Agenda Item No. 178 June 24, 2008 Page 12 of 19 LoeA nON List legal description(s) of properties abutting the street to be renamed. (Attach additional pages if necessary) Windstar Subdivision: UnltNo. Tract No. A Section/Township/ Range: il / 50 / 25 Windstar Subdivision: Unit No. T Prt ofB&H rad No. Section/Township/ Range: II / 50 / 25 Hanington Sound Subdivision: Unit No. 21 Tract No. Section/Township/ Range: l4 / 50 / 25 Subdivision: Unit No. Tract No. Section/Township/ Range: / / Subdivision: Unit No. 0" ,___ Tract No. Section/Township/ Range: / / Subdivision: Unit No. Tract No. Section/Township/ Range: / / Application for Street Nllme Clinnl1e - Ucvlscd May Z007 Pag~4{tr6 00 ..ro DO m 0 ~o- 0 "&= 0 _ .N 0 ..........0 -(f) ,;z ('!,;- ---. ~m~ - 0...2 c C'C -"'0.. ",' - '0 t") C <r> " 00 m N <l: "" 00 00 00 K a- t") ~ g II ti . ~ c . ~ c !. '" Jt '" a , . ~ i . Od ~ ~ . .. Q [;:j . . . ~ Ql . . ~ ::J 1i ~ ;; , f:: c:: . ~ u Ql [.l.1 > ....l <( I!. c::: <l) 0, 0 oj 1:: ~ E [.l.1 ~ "" :c -< 0 u - tI) - CI <Il Z <Il -< ~ - , en c:: ~ 'C Ql u.. " Od <Il II Ol ~ c::: .t:: CIS - .c C'-. K " 0, <Il ~ E 0: CIS 'C Z 0, 0, oj ~@ 0, oj ~ <:: {l .Q ~ ::J -~ 0 a u - ...: .c <l) " en CIS '@ >- ... 0, ~ 0, 0 '" ... .n <l) ~ - ~ - '" I u c::: cO "" 0, 0 '>! " - ~ E E ~ fj" 'J:: I -"i "" --. Agenda Item No. 17B June 24. 2008 Page 14 of 19 Southpointe at Windstar Marina Association May 4, 2008 Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club 7065 Fern Street Naples, Florida 34112 Dear Randy, I enjoyed our telephone conversation last Friday night. We at the Southpointe at Windstar Marina are excited about welcoming our new neighbors, the Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club. This letter serves as our support and endorsement to change the name of Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. Let me know if there is anything else I can do to facilitate the change. Best Regards, (' ) ~~t:t;;: W~ynd~ieldsa President of the Southpointe at Windstar Marina Association __ W!liE.~11R Aaenda Item No. 178 " June 24, 2008 Page 15 of 19 1700 Windslar Boulevard Naplcs,Flol'ida 34112 (239) 775-3400 Fax (239) 775-9771 April 30,2008 Mr. Randy Ward Memhership Director Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club 7065 Fern Street Naples, Florida 34 112 RE: Petition to change Fern Street Name to Hamilton Avenue Dcar Randy, As abutting propcrty owners, The Windstar Club, Incorporated Board of Dircctors voted unanimously by an electronic meeting today to SUppOIt the petition (0 change Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. Sincerely, William E. Tesh, CCM, CAM General Manager ~). . Windstar On Naples Bay MatHer Association .Ll,genda Item No. 178 June 24. 2008 Page 16 of 19 December 3, 2007 Mr. Randy Ward, Membership Director Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club 7065 Fern Street Naples, Fl 34112 RE: Petition to change Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue Dear Randy, As abutting property owners, the Windstar Master Association Board of Directors voted unanimously at their November 17,2007 Board of Directors meeting to support the petition to change Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. Sincerely, WINDST AR MASTER ASSOCIATION, INC. );/J\Y //(4 ../':!;/.ic;)<Cl "- Michael Sherrilan, President~r:(f MS/dts 1700 Wind..tar Boulevard .,*. Naplc" Florida 34112~~' 239-775-3400, ext. 202 " -'.--~-~ ------- ._-~-_.- -~--_._- - _0.___- ;'\genda Item No. 178 June 24. 2008 Page 17 of 19 (. '1"1\" r "-'11') ..'--- .,_,....._.~-'-,\t.,.. --.-- If'rV2STi'i\ cl'ICi3, ll''iC ,- ~OOJ Tf\!I;\IA(v\1 TR.~IL ;''1., /1'1\00, flAPLE,s, FL 34 :OJ/Pl lONE 2J9/261-44~5 December 5, 2007 Collier County Board of County Commissioners 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112 Re: Folio #00395440003 Dear Board Members: CDC Land Investments, Inc. hereby supports thc request that the Board of County Commissioners change the name ofFeffi Street to Hamilton Avenue. We feel it better reflects the historical nature of the area including the Hamilton homcstead and the Hamilton Midden. Sincerely, ~ Robert D. Corina Vice President SNR-2008-AR-12854 HAMILTON HARBOR PUD PROJECT: 19990316 DATE: 2/6/08 DUE: 2/21/08 HAMILTON I-I A RBOR,.. ~._._"...- , Agenda Item ~.. 178 . June 2 Lklb08p-h Page of19 3003 Tamiami Trail N., Suite 400, Naples, FL 34103 December 5, 2007 Collier County Board of County Commissioners 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112 Re: Folios #61380040004 and #00395560103 Dear Board Members: Hamilton Harbor Marina, Inc. hereby supports the request that the Board of County Commissioners change the name of Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. We feel it better reflects the historical nature of the area including the Hamilton homestead and the Hamilton Midden. Sfift Ut Patrick L. Utter Vice President SNR-2008-AR-12854 HAMILTON HARBOR PUD PROJECT: 19990316 DATE: 2/6/0R DUE: 2/21/08 " COLLIER r:::i ENTERPRISES L;;J . ;'1' NAPLES BOTANICAL GARDEN Boftl'd of Directol's Charles M. Berger Chairman Juliet C. Sproul Vice Chairman hlmcs A. LaGrippe Vice Chairman Richard H. Benson Treasurer Catherine K Ware Secre/aD' Directors C(lOstancc T. Alsbrook Patricia Buehler Blankenship Robert M. Cahners B ~rbara J. Finn Elynor M. Flegel Thomas 1. Flood Leslie K.S. fogg Judith A. Herb James P. Johannsen Scott B. Kapnick L. Bates Lea Thomas D. McCrmn Karen M. Scott David Byron Smith John E. Vandenberg Linda G. White Ernest J. Novak, Jr. Ex Officio Brian Holley Exccrftive DIrector Harvey E. Kapnick. Jr. Director in Memoriam 11Ii,I'pmjcclis.\pmJsfJred ill {Xlrl by tlie Slate of Florida throrlgllllw Norida Dr:p(lrll/lefl' (JjSlllle,/Jivi.\iu!loj Cu/wm! AjJilin, and the Fiorida Arl.1 Cmmcif, Collier COUIU)' {md tIll! CnllierCmmlyloll/'i.f1 DeI'elopmclll Corme;!, A " Agenda item No. 178 June 24, 2008 Page 19 of 19 December 13, 2007 "Connecting People Ilml Pllll/ts" Mr. Randy Ward Membership Director Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club 7065 Fcrn Avenue Naples, FL 34l 12 Dear Randy, Naples Botanical Garden, as your neighbor and thc sole property owner of the east side of Fern Street, SUPP011 the petition to change the name of Fern Street to Hamilton Avenue. Your investment in the neighborhood is greatly appreciated. Sincerely, g~ Brian Holley Executive Director 4820 Bnyshon' Drh'c :'I:aplcs, PL 34112-7337 p!WIlC 239,643.7275 {fIX 239.!i49.7306 iIlCo@naplesgardcn.org naplcsganlen.nl"g ell/ail Wll'1l'. iOD();,flcc.ycled f:j