Loading...
Agenda 12/02/2008 Item #10F Agenda Item No.1 OF December 2, 2008 Page 1 of 17 ~ EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation that the Board of COWlty Commissioners provide direction to staff for the disposal ofDelasol Neighborhood Park Obiective: That the Board of COWlty Commissioners provides direction to the COWlty Attorney and the COWlty Manager, or his designee, related to disposition and or disposal of properties identified to be a neighborhood park within the DelasoI PUD. Considerations: On January 15,2008, the Board ofCoWlty Commissioners voted 4-1 to (a) not proceed with Delasol Neighborhood Park, (b) revise the PUD if necessary and (c) for staff to return with recommendations regarding disposing of the property. (a) All plans to proceed with developing the park were ceased and Q, Grady Minor, the consultant working with staff on the project was directed to provide both invoices paid to date and any outstanding invoices to determine current costs associated with the project. The total cost to date for services rendered is $36,342.50. (b) Furthennore, discussions with CDES staffreflect fees associated with amending the PUD to be approximately $15,250. A breakdown of the fees associated with these costs is as follows: -- ITEM COSTS PUD Application Fee (Base Fee) $6,000 PUD Application Fee (Acreage Fee) $3,650 Fire Review Fee $150 Comprehensive Plan Consistency Review $2,250 Fee Easement Vacation Fee $2,000 Collier County Planning Commission $760 Advertising cost Board of County Commissioners $440 Advertising cost Total *$15,250 * Additional fees may apply and would be detennined at the time of the pre application process with CDES to pursue amending the PUD. lbey include Environmental Impact Study (EI5) fee of $2,500; a Listed Species Survey Review Fee of $1,000, which would apply if an EIS is not required; and a Transportation Methodology Fee (from $500 to $1,500) ,- Agenda Item No.1 OF December 2, 2008 Page 2 of 17 In addition, CDES staff has indicated that by working with Parks and Recreation staff, CDES staff time would amount to 30 hours @ $100 per hour for an expense of approximately $3,000 to complete the PUD amendment process. Costs associated with public noticing for the amendment of the PUD would amount to approximately $1,200 and the Delasol Homeowners Association has indicated that they would be willing to pay these costs. The text of the PUD states: "Within the project, the developer shall dedicate a minimum of one (1) acre of property to Collier County for the development of a neighborhood park which is accessible by the general public." In addition the PUD Master Plan contains text that refers to the same dedication requirement language and also provides for and indicates the location of a 20- foot wide public pedestrian access point to the neighborhood park inside the development from Lakeland Avenue, outside the development, abutting the Willoughby Acres subdivision. (c) Subsequent to the Board's decision, an unrecorded agreement between the Board and the developer, Centex, was discovered which limits the County's options in disposing of the Park Property. According to an Agreement for Dedication dated July 29, 2003: "2. Upon Acceptance of Centex's dedication, Centex shall be entitled to an impact fee credit against the County's Park Impact Fee requirements in the amount of $39,761. 7. If the County, by action of the Board of County Commissioners, determines not to construct a park on the Park Property, it will execute an appropriate instrument releasing the Park Property from the dedication obligation. 8. This Agreement shall be binding upon the successors and assigns of the parties, and is for the benefit of, and may be enforced by, the parties hereto or their assigns, including the Delasol Homeowners Association, Inc. The parties agree that specific peiformance and/or mandatmy injunction as appropriate shall be available remedies for the enforcement of this Agreement." This Agreement provided that Centex would be entitled to an impact fee credit for the dedication of the one acre park by dedication on the plat. Records revealed that this impact fee credit was not received by Centex. Officials with Centex have agreed to waive this entitlement and formally release the County from any future claim arising out of this obligation, Although the PUD contemplates the entry of a developer's contribution agreement pursuant to s. 2,2,20,3.7, of the LDC, it is silent as to the release of the Park Property in the event the County decides not to construct a park. Nonetheless the Agreement seems to reflect the Board's decision to permit the return of the Park Property in this instance, Consequently, if the Board intended to be bound by this Agreement, its subsequent decision (0 halt construction on the Park Property will require that the County execute a Agenda Item No.1 OF December 2, 2008 Page 3 of 17 recordable instrument releasing the Park Property from the dedication. Because the Park Property was also conveyed by Warranty Deed to the County, staff proposes that the County re-convey the Park Property to the Delasol Homeowners Association. The Delasol HOA has agreed to the County retaining the 20 foot platted access easement provided it is shortened to extend from Euclid Ave. to approximately 10 feet from the south boundary of Tract U. This easement will expire in 5 years if not used by the County. To modify the access casement, the County will be required to proceed with a partial vacation of platted easement in accordance with Resolution No. 2006-160. The Delasol HOA will cooperate in the vacation of the platted easement to ensure the above terms are met. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The developer has conveyed the one acre site to the County for development ofa park site pursuant to Section 6.14 of Ordinance No. 00-80, by dedication in the Delasol Phase Two subdivision plat recorded in Plat Book 41 Page 51 et seq of the Public Records of Collier County and by warranty deed in OR Book 4165 page 122 of the Public Records of Collier County. Although a PUD amendment is technically required to remove the PUD commitment, this should not be necessary since the property was conveyed and the BCC no longer desires a neighborhood park for the public in this location. The Dedication Agreement provides that the Park Property, if not used for the intended public purposes, should be returned to the developer, or its assigns, which is presently the Delasol HOA. In keeping with this Agreement, together with Board direction, staff has prepared a Quitclaim Deed that complies with Section ]25.411, FS, which conveys this Park Parcel to the HOA. The Park Parcel is zoned CR, Common Area/Recreation by PUD Ordinance No. 00-80, which allows lakes, open space/preserve areas, pedestrian and bike paths, docks, outdoor recreation and a clubhouse. To reduce the County's exposure against any claim that might arise out of this conveyance, staff has obtained an Indenmity Agreement with the HOA, in which the HOA agrees to defend and hold the County harmless against all claims which might arise involving this matter. To further reduce the County's exposure, the County and the fornler Developer (Centex) have agreed upon a Mutual General Release. A copy of these documents is included in this agenda package, This matter is legally sufficient for Board action. This item is not-quasi-judicial and as such, there is no requirement for disclosure of ex parte communications. A majority vote of the Board is necessary for Board action. -HF AC Fiscallmllact: There has been a total of $36,342.50 spent to date on the development of Delasol Neighborhood Park. There has been no payment of impact fee credits to Centex for the acceptance of the parceL It is anticipated if the PUD were amended by Parks and Recreation Department an additional $12,050 would be spent on fees associated with CDES to accomplish this task along with costs associated with CDES staff of approximately $3,000. There is a $2,000 easement vacation application fee that would be applied should it be required. There are sufficient funds in Project #806051 to meet these Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 4 of 17 expenditures. The Delasol HOA has indicated that they will pay for advertisement costs up to $1,200 associated with amending the PUD should the Board of County Commissioners require this action, There will be costs associated with recording, which costs should be paid by the Delasol HOA, in an amount not to exceed $60. Growth Manal!ement Impact: Neighborhood parks are not inventoried in the Growth Management Plan. Recommendation: That the Board of County Commissioners authorizes the Chairman to direct staff as to one of the following options: Option 1: 1. Amend the PUD solely for the pwposes related to the matter of a public park, direct CDES staff to assist the Parks and Recreation Department in the processing of the PUD amendment petition; and authorize the payment of associated costs associated from Project #806051. 2. Authorize the Chairman to execute a Quit Claim in the form attached hereto and condition closing on this conveyance upon receipt of a release from Centex in favor of the County as to all claims arising out of the Dedication Agreement and an Indemnity Agreement with the HOA, in which the HOA agrees to defend and hold the County harmless against all claims which might arise involving this matter. Option 2: 1, Find that construction of the Park Property will not serve the public interest and direct staff to forego a PUD amendment. 2. Authorize the Chairman to execute a Quit Claim in the form attached hereto and that any future plat amendments are responsibility of grantee; and condition closing on this conveyance upon receipt of a release from Centex in favor of the County as to all claims arising out of the Dedication Agreement and an Indemnity Agreement with the HOA, in which the HOA agrees to defend and hold the County harmless against all claims which might arise involving this matter. Prepared by: Barry Williams, Director, Parks and Recreation Department Page 1 of 1 Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 5 of 17 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Meeting Date: 10F Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners provide direction to staff for the disposal of oela501 Neighborhood Park. 12/2/2008900:00 AM Item Number: Item Summary: Prepared By Barry Williams Director Date Public Services Parks and Recreation 10/9/2D081 ;12:48 PM Approved By Barry Williams Director Date Public Services Parks and Recreation 11/24/20081:38 PM Approved By Sue Zimmerman Property Acquisition Specialist Date Administrative Services Facilities Management 11/24/20082:54 PM Approved By Marla Ramsey Public Services Administrator Date Public Services Public Services Admin. 11/24/20D8 2:59 PM Approved By Heidi F. Ashton Assistant County Attorney Date County Attorney County Attorney Office 11/24/20084:30 PM Approved By John A. Yonkosky Director of the Office of Management Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 11/25/20081:48 PM Approved By Leo E. Ochs, Jr. Deputy County Manager Date Board of County Commissioners County Manager's Office 11/25/20082:35 PM file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\117-December%202,%202008\1 0.%20COUNTY%20MANA... 11/25/2008 Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 6 of 17 MUTUAL GENERAL RELEASE 1. In exchange for good and valuable consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, CENTEX HOMES, a Nevada general partnership (hereafter "Centex") and the BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA (hereafter the "County") hereby release and forever discharge each other from any and all claims, entitlements, causes of action, debts, or any other legal action in law or equity, which were or could have been raised, and any other cause of action in law or equity that the parties may have against each other, their agents, employees and principals regarding that certain Agreement for Dedication dated July 29, 2003 between Centex and the County (the "Agreement"), a true copy of which being attached hereto and incorporated by reference. This release specifically includes, but is not limited to, any claim by Centex of entitlement to impact fee credits referenced in the Agreement. The purpose of this release is for each party to release all of the other parties from any and all claims or causes of action of any nature from the beginning of the world to the day of these presents, 2. The acceptance of this General Release and anything contained herein shall not be construed as an admission or acknowledgment of any liability or wrongdoing by any of the parties. The parties also agree that this document may be executed in counterparts and transmitted to one another by facsimile transmission and taken together the faxed counterparts shall constitute a binding agreement. The parties hereby declare that they have read this Mutual General Release in its entirety and know the contents thereof, that they have had the benefit of the advice of independent counsel of our own choosing and that they have signed it as their own free act and deed, This Release is understood and agreed to on this _ day of ,2008. Witnesses: CENTEX: Centex Homes, a Nevada general partnership By: Centex Real Estate Corporation, a Nevada corporation, its managing general partner Print Name By: Name: Its: Print Name STATE OF COUNTY OF Before me, the undersigned notary public, appeared of Centex Real Estate Corporation, managing general partner of Centex Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 7 of 17 Homes, who is personally known to me or was identified by driver's license, and who acknowledged freely executing this Release and who took an oath on this _ day of ,2008, Notary Public Printed Name of Notary My Commission Expires: Witnesses: COUNTY: Collier County, Florida By its Board of County Commissioners By: Name: Its: Print Name Print Name STATE OF COUNTY OF Before me, the undersigned notary public, appeared of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, who is personally known to me or was identified by driver's license, and who acknowledged freely executing this Release and who took an oath on this _ day of , 2008. Notary Public Printed Name of Notary My Commission Expires: Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: Jeffrey A. Klatzkow, County Attorney Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 8 of 17 INDEMNITY AGREEMENT In consideration of TEN DOLLARS and 0/100 ($10.00) and other good and valuable consideration, receipt of which is acknowledged, DELASOL HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC., a Florida not for profit corporation (hereafter "DelasoI"), agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA (hereafter the "County"), from and against any liability, damages, reasonably attorney's fees or costs the County may suffer as a result of claims, demands, judgments against it arising out of: a) the County's election to not construct and maintain a public park on Tract "u" in Phase Two of the Delasol subdivision, as such tract is further identified on the Plat of Delasol Phase Two, recorded in Plat Book 41, Pages 51 through 55, Collier County, Florida Public Records (hereafter referred to as the "Park Parcel"); and b) the County's election to release the dedication of the Park Parcel and convey the Park Parcel to Delasol pursuant to the Agreement for Dedication dated July 29, 2003 between the County and Centex Homes. The County agrees to give Delasol fifteen (15) days' written notice of any claim made against the County on the obligations indemnified against. The obligations of Delasol hereunder to indemnify the County do not include any claims against the County associated with the County's retention of all or a portion of the twenty (20) foot access easement shown on the Plat of Delasol Phase Two initially dedicated for access to the Park Parcel. 2008. This Indemnity Agreement is understood and agreed to this _ day of October, Witnesses: Delasol Homeowners Association, Inc., a Florida non-profit corporation Print Name By: Name: James R. Culkar Its: President Print Name STATE OF COUNTY OF Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 9 of 17 Before me, the undersigned notary public, appeared James R. Culkar, president of Delasol Homeowners Association, Inc., who is personally known to me or was identified by driver's license, and who acknowledged freely executing this Release and who took an oath on this _ day of , 2008. Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: Jeffrey A. Klatzkow, County Attorney Notary Public Printed Name of Notary My Commission Expires: Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 10 of 17 DELASOL HOMEOWNER'S ASSOCIATION, INC. c/o Inte~rated Property Management 3435 10 Street N, Suite 201 Naples, Florida To: Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida Re: Disposal of Tract U ("Delasol Park Property") Please accept this letter as confirmation that the Board of Directors for the Delasol Homeowners Association, Inc, ("Association") has voted to contribute up to $1,200,00 for advertising public notice of any PUD amendment required in connection with the County's release of the park dedication and conveyance of the Delasol Park Property to the Association, Sincerely, James R. Culkar Association President Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 11 of 17 MEMORANDUM Date: July 30, 2003 To: John Houldsworth, Senior Engineer Planning Services From: Trish Morgan, Deputy Clerk Minutes & Records Department Re: Agreement for Dedication - Park in Delasol Enclosed please find one copy of the document as referenced above (Agenda Item #16A9), approved by the Board of County Commissioners on July 29, 2003. The original agreement is being retained for the record. If you should have any questions, please contact me at: 774-8406. . Thank you. Enclosure Agenda Item No.1 OF December 2, 2008 Page 12 of 17 AGREEMENT FOR DEDICA nON This Agreement is made this ~day of~, 2003 by and between Centex Homes, a Nevada general partnership ("Centex") and the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida ("County"), and together, "the Parties". RECITALS Centex is the owner of certain real property in Collier County zoned "PUD by Ordinance No, 2000-80, and known as the Madeira Planned Unit Development Ordinance (the PUD") to be developed by Centex as a residential community called Delaso!. The real property covered by the PUD and this Agreement is described in the PUD, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A. Pursuant to Section 6.14 of the PUD, Centex has agreed to dedicate to the County one (1) acre of property within the PUD for development by the County of a neighborhood park. This Agreement shall. set forth the terms and conditions of such dedication and shall constitute the impact fee credit agreement provided for in the PUD. WITNESSETH For and in consideration of the mutual promises contained herein, the Parties agree as follows: I. As provided in the PUD, Centex shall dedicate to the County the one (1) acre parcel (the "Park Property") identified as "Public Park" by dedication on the plat of Delasol Phase Two (the "Plat'') attached hereto as Exhibit B and made a part hereof. The dedication will be deemed to have been made upon the approval of the Plat by the Board of County Commissioners; however, Centex shall be responsible for maintaining the Park Property in accordance with applicable County regulations until the earlier of (I) 50 % build out of the project, which, for purposes of this agreement shall mean the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for the residence which, - together with all previously issued certificates of occupancy, represents one-half of the number residential lots approved by the plats of Delasol Phase One and Delasol Phase Two, or (2) the County shall commence construction of a neighborhood park. Centex shall have the right to go upon the Park Property to maintain the property and to enable Centex to install subdivision improvements on the PUD property. Following the dedication, the County shall be responsible for all then due real estate taxes and/or assessments, if any, that previously have been, or in the future may be, imposed by any govemmental authority on the Park Property, 2. Upon acceptance of Centex' s dedication, Centex shall be entitled to an impact fee credit Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 13 of 17 against the County's Park hnpact Fee requirements in the amount of$ 39,761. 3. Centex, as part of the plat process, will grant the County a 20 foot non-exclusiye easement for public access as shown on the Plat. The County will be responsible for all costs associated with access, including permitting. The County acknowledges that this access easement, in whole or in part, will be upon lands that are the subject of a conservation easement required by the South Florida Water Management District, A copy of the proposed conservation easement is attached hereto as Exhibit C and the County acknowledges that the terms of the conservation easement do not prohibit the COWlty, upon the issuance of required permits, from constructing an access facility sufficient for the County's needs, Centex acknowledges that the County will need to obtain appropriate permits for the construction of the access facility from the South Florida Water Management District and/or the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. In the event that the required pennitting will necessitate a modification of the District and Corps permits for the Delasol project that have been issued to Centex or its successors, Centex agrees to the modification of such permits and will, upon request of the County, execute such authorizations and consents as may be needed for the County to apply for modification of the permits. In connection with the modification of tlie pencits, and the construction and operation of the access facility, the County agrees as follows: a. The County will be solely responsible for obtaining any necessary permits or modifications of existing permits and constructing and operating the access facility, which responsibility shall include, but not be limited to the payment of all costs in connection therewith, including any additional mitigation costs. b. The County shall ensure that its officers, agents, employees or contractors comply with all applicable permit conditions and that the work is perfonced and the access facility operated in such a manner as to avoid violatio!)S of the regulations of the pennitting agencies. c. In the event that Centex or its successors, as pennit holder, is charged with the violation of any permit condition or the violation of the regulations of any of the permitting agencies in connection with the pencitting, construction, or operation of the access facility, the County shall indemnify such permit holder for any and all costs of whatsoever kind or nature, . including attorney's fees incurred by such permit holder as a result of such enforcement action. 4. The County acknowledges that Delasol will be a gated residential community with private roads. Accordingly, except as provided below, there shall be no public access to the Park Property through the roads in Delasol except for access by residents ofDelasoL' 5. The County, at such time as it determines in its sole discretion, will construct a 2 Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 14 of 17 neighborhood park as defined in applicable County policies and regulations on the Park Property. Centex shall have no obligation to provide infrastructure, including, but not limited to, water' management facilities or utilities to the Park Property. However, the County agrees that Centex may install irrigation facilities and landscaping, and maintain the same, within the Park Property prior to construction of the park at its own expense, and such facilities will become the property oftbe County. Centex shall obtain approval from the Director of the Parks and Recreation Deplll1ment prior to installing such facilities. 6. The County will maintain the park in a sightly condition in accordance with the County's policies for trash pickup and mowing, and will regulate use of park facilities so that it does not become a nuisance or eyesore to residents ofDelasol. Centex will grant access privileges to the County for the use ofDelasol's roads for the purpose of construction and maintenance of the Park Property. 7, If the County, by action of the Board of County Commissioners, determines not to construct a park on the Park Property, it will execute an appropriate instrument releasing the Park Property from tbe dedication obligation. 8. This Agreement shall be binding upon the successors and assigns of the parties, and is for the benefit of, and may be enforced by, the parties hereto or their assigns, including the Delasol Homeowners Association, Inc. The parties agree that specific perfonnance and/or mandatory injunction as appropriate shall he available remedies for the enforcement of this Agreement. In Witness Whereof, the parties have executed this agreement as of the date first above written, , Signature Page Follows 3 Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 15 of 17 neighborhood park as defined in applicable County policies and regulations on the Park Property, Centex shall have no obligation to provide infrastructure, including, but not limited to, water. management facilities or utilities to the Park Property. However, the County agrees that Centex may install irrigation facilities and landscaping, and maintain the same, within the Park Property prior to construction of the park at its own expense, and such facilities will become the property ofthe County. Centex shall obtain approval from the Director of the Parks and Recreation Department prior to installing such facilities. 6. The County will maintain the park in a sightly condition in accordance with the County's policies for trash pickup and mowing, and will regulate use of park facilities so that it does not become a nuisance or eyesore to residents of Delaso!. Centex will grant access privileges to the County for the use ofDelasol's roads for the purpose of construction and maintenance of the Park Property, 7, If the County, by action of the Board of County Commissioners, determines not to construct a park on the Park Property, it will execute an appropriate instrument releasing the Park Property from the dedication obligation. i-- 8, This Agreement shall be binding upon the successors and assigns of the parties, and is for the benefit of, and may be enforced by, the parties hereto or their assigns, including the Delasol Homeowners Association, Inc. The parties agree that specific performance and/or mandatory injunction as appropriate shall be available remedies for the enforcement of this Agreement. In Witness Whereof, the parties have executed this agreement as of the date first above written. , Signature Page Follows 3 1 I Agenda Item No, 10F December 2, 2008 Page 16 of 17 Centex Homes, a Nevada general, partnership By: Centex Real Estate Corporation, a Nevada corporation, its managing general ~ \U By: Tim Rucmler Division President - ATTEST: Dwight E. Brad(. Clerk . ~ . - I >.. .:::'. .. COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BY ITS BOARD OF COUN1Y COMMISSIONERS .~ ." - By. ~;;I~ ,'<t., ~. ~ At&r~li:~il"Uft's s1gnature:.Only. Tom Approved as to form and V;(~\Jhe> ~OI' David C, Weigel ~",,~I()l, G.wl\ \\Ii: County Attorney , 4 PARCEl: Delaso1 Tract"lJ" Agenda Item NO. r10F December 2, 008 Page 17 f 17 i . QUITCLAIM DEED THIS QUITCLAIM DEED executed this _ day of , 2008, by COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, a political subdivision of the Slate of Florida, (hereinafter called the Grantor), to Delasol Homeowners Association, Inc" a not-for- profit Florida corporation, its successors and assigns, whose post-office address is_ (hereinafter called the Grantee). (Wherever used herein the terms "Grantor" and "Grantee- include all the parties to thi6 instrument and their respective heirs, successors and assigns,) WITNESSETH: That the Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of Ten Dollars ($10,00) in hand paid by the said Grantee, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, does hereby remise, release, and quitclaim unto the said Grantee forever, all the right, tille, interest, claim and demand which the said Grantor has in and to the following described lot, piece or parcel of land situate, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to wit: Tract "U", as depicted on Plat of Delasol Phase Two, Recorded in Plat Book 41, Pages 51 through 55, as recorded in the public records of Coiller County, Florida Subject to easements, restrictions, and reservations of record and the following restrictive covenant: Thi6 property may only be used for purposes as set forth in PUD Ordinance oo-aO. This covenant shall run with the land, The Grantor acknowledges by execution of this deed that the dedication of Tract U for a public pari< expressed on the Plat of Delasol Phase Two Is hereby repudiated. By acceplance and recording of this deed, Grantee assumes all responsibility for any future vacation of this plat dedication, if such vacation becomes necessary. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the same together with all appurtenances thereunto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the eslata, right, title, interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said Grantor, IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Grantor has caused these presents to be executed the day and year first above written. DATE: COlLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ATTEST: DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk , Deputy Cieri< BY: TOM HENNING, Chairman Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: Heidi Ashton, @ Assistant County Attorney i I I II