Backup Documents 05/26/2009 Item #10B
1'0, 8- r,f
The Mangrove Action Group Inc.
'\'lay 26, 2009
Greetings Board of the Collier County Commissioners,
The Mangrove Action Group io.; a,' Jl1l1'lLll1 1\ ". l"sroots orgal1iz;1 'I: dedicated to the protection of
a significant Mangrove ecosystl'lll 11 ( ,1Ill I~ay. I n the last sever:L y l':lrs there has developed a
concern that elements in the government ot'Collier County are seeking to significantly alter the
Clam Bay wetlands. .fr2.jects tmve bCt'n Il!!!.posed that may, rcsult in significant alteration.
The Mangrove Action Group launched a Petition drive to SlllH\ :ll.!:QD.g community~uo.w:1..12.
mp the Clam Bay, Wetlands in it's Natural -.;tate. This petitio' rl':Ids as follows:
SAVE CLA:vI BAY WFTLANDS - KEEP IT "lATURAL
We, the undersigned, support the County's !:loal to provide l1lure heach access at Clam Pass
Park. WE OPPOSE THE CL'lUU:'\T 1>1.A'\S THAT WOl'1.D DEGRADE THIS
SERENE NATURAL RESOCRCE PROTECTION AREA \\/I1'H SIGNIFICANT
CONSTRUCTION IN UNDISITRBED 'VtANGROVE IL'dHTAT, DREDGING OUT
THE EBB SHOAL, INSTALLI'\C CHA \'1EL MARKE:~"'l, OR OTHERWISE
ALTERING ITS SHA1.LO\\ rILU.: BA\ SYSTEM.
In the last several weeks \uIUlll,,'\.." . ,'.', ,.1..'1.. 1..\.' U\er 2,OUu" :i.c'" 'WI..' urge you to consider
the strong community SLlPPUrll..il'Il,I:I< :':Ik" ! 'c' o.;lgl1ero.; or t: ',)I..'i tillt! Vve urge you to take
steps to..u.phold the prineiplt's u r Cur:.>:ena t lU'1. that the h ighl..'<.Jl, bc'''l Lise or this area is to
maintain it in its n"tund l.om.I..lL..c,...2_.....:..:il' _ tb its m,lll\ c_: ;d1kliolh.
Thank you for YOLl considerat".;'
Cordially yours,
1f~~
Marcia Cravens, Presidelll \iall""[I\ \l "I}
lOB -'1 eR
Save Clam Bay Wetlands - Keep It Natural
We, the undersigned, support the County's goal to provide more
beach access at Clam Pass Park. WE OPPOSE THE CURRENT
PLANS THAT WOULD DEGRADE THIS SERENE NATURAL
RESOURCE PROTECTION AREA WITH SIGNIFICANT
CONSTRUCTION IN UNDISTURBED MANGROVE HABITAT,
DREDGING OUT THE EBB SHOAL, INSTAlliNG CHANNEL
MARKERS, OR OTHERWISE ALTERING ITS SHAllOW THREE
BAY SYSTEM.
PRINTED NAME
ADDRESS with zip code
SIGNATURE
Please Return--Mangrove Action Group c/o Marcia Cravens 6075 Pelican Bay Blvd, # 703, Naples, FL 34108
~
~
-+-
l
't
f;>
~
-
0:
UJ
CD
::::
:::l
z
::::
UJ
I-
<l:
Cl
Z
UJ
"
<(
1
UJ
....J
l-
t=:
::::
UJ
I-
<l:
Cl
Z
UJ
"
<(
>-
....J
0:
<l:
UJ
....J
()
I-
Z
a:
c..
UJ
(J)
<l:
UJ
....J
a.
Cl
0:
<l:
UJ
J:
"
Z
UJ
CD
I-
U
UJ
....,
CD
:::l
(J)
UJ
J:
I-
o
I-
0:
o
0:
0-
::::
o
o
0:
Cl
0:
<l:
o
CD
UJ
J:
I-
Z
(J)
<l:
Cl
UJ
J:
I-
u.
o
I-
u.
UJ
....J
UJ
....J
CD
<l:
I-
UJ
J:
I-
Z
o
::::
0:
o
u.
Cl
UJ
I-
UJ
....J
0-
::::
o
u
UJ
U
<l:
....J
a.
~
.>
~
t
<3'
Q
.........
~
o
-
J-
M
~
~
\.I)
~
S
~
J
~
~
~
>
~
...
-
(J)
(J)
UJ
0:
Cl
Cl
<(
-
1
s.
...
(j
..j
1
~
~
UJ
::::
<l:
z
0:
UJ
J:
I-
o
f- --.J
<( LL
o
CC UJ
<( W
U)0-1
~[J)~
I:::wZ
> I ~
f=f-=:!
uO<(
<( f- a:
0:::.::1-
Za::2
;;::W<(
(()......J_
co02
OW<(
-1 II-
>- f- f-
ZIU)
<( f- <(
Z~W
,-
0a:O
zWCf)
0t;;Cf)
<( - 0
o @ ~
Z a: 0
w ~......J
WU)-
a: a: =:l
OW[J)
u.. Z a:
WOw
COU5Z
.-SU)a:
-1-=:l
<(21-
I2Z
U)OO
UJ02
f- >- a:
~f-<(
>-zI
CO::::l .
COOS
go _
-1 u.. a:
-1 0 0
<(00
f-a:-1
<(<(u..
I O~
f-m..q
~Wf-~
a:IZ
- f- w
=:l02
OZI-
W-a:
a: UJ <(
..qUJo...
C\jWW
,a:O
t'--O
OOU)
. <( 0
o - a:
ZOO
I-U
WOW
~Wa:
<(1:::0
Z2Z
o ......J <(
CCf-u)
oO~
>- Z =:l
~~~
=:lCO:2
060
uza:
a:-<(
woo
=:i3a:l
-1uw
o Z I
U ..:::.- f-
0:
UJ
Z
o
I-
i=
UJ
a.
"
z
I-
Z
UJ
en
W
0:
0-
W
a:
a::
<i:
J:
()
W
J:
I-
>-
....J
Z
o
en
en
w
a::
o
o
<(
o
I-
w
a::
<(
o
z
<(
(J)
I-
Z
UJ
::::
::::
o
()
a::
::>
o
>
a::
o
U.
en
w
I-
:::>
z
:2
-.
('I')
-
w
W
0:
J:
I-
o
I-
o
w
!:::
::::
.:J
w
0:
<(
::>
o
>
I
d}i
(J
-
0:
UJ
CD
::::
:::l
Z
::::
UJ
I-
<l:
Cl
Z
UJ
"
<(
UJ
....J
l-
t=:
::::
UJ
1::
<l:
Cl
Z
UJ
"
<(
Cl
0:
<l:
UJ
J:
"
Z
UJ
CD
I-
U
UJ
....,
CD
:::l
(J)
UJ
J:
I-
o
I-
0:
o
0:
0-
::::
o
o
0:
Cl
0:
<l:
o
CD
UJ
J:
I-
Z
(J)
<l:
Cl
UJ
J:
I-
u.
o
I-
u.
UJ
....J
UJ
....J
CD
<l:
I-
UJ
J:
I-
Z
o
::::
0:
o
u.
Cl
UJ
~ ~
!~
<l:
....J
a.
j
(J)
(J)
UJ
0:
Cl
Cl
<(
~
UJ
::::
<l:
Z
0:
UJ
J:
I-
o
1--- --.J
<1: LL
o -
ccUJ
<( W
U)0-1
~m~
I:::wZ
>I
f=f-='
UO<(
<(I-a:
0:::.::1-
~ ffi :2
>- -1 <(
~O:2
o w <(
......JII-
>- I- I-
ZIU)
<(1-<(
Z~W
,-
0a:O
ZWCf)
o t;; Cf)_
<( - 0
o @ Z
Z a: 0
w --1
W (f.a:) :5
g5wm
u.. Z CC
wOw
COU5Z
-TU)a:
......J -::::l
<(21-
I2Z
UJOO
U)U2
I->-a:
~I-<(
>-zI
CO::::l
COO~
g U _
......J u.. a:
......JOO
<(00
1-a:-1
<(<(u..
I O~
I-m..q
U) W -
W I I-
Q;f-rE
=:l02
OZI-
W-a:
a:U)<(
-.qUJo...
C\jWW
I CC 0
t'--O
OOUJ
<(0
o -a:
ZOO
Wf-U
U 0 W
ZWa:
<( I::: 0
Z2Z
0-1<(
a:f-U)
oOW
>- Z ~
~~~
=:lCO:2
060
uza:
a:-<(
woo
......J3m
-1uw
OZI
U ..:::.- f-
0:
UJ
Z
o
E
I-
UJ
a.
<.:l
Z
i=
z
UJ
en
UJ
0:
0-
W
a:
0:
<i:
J:
()
UJ
J:
I-
>-
....J
Z
o
en
en
w
a::
Cl
Cl
<(
o
I-
w
0:
<(
o
z
<(
en
I-
z
UJ
::::
::::
o
()
0:
::>
o
>
a::
o
u.
U)
W
I-
::>
z
:2
-.
('I')
-
UJ
W
0:
J:
I-
o
I-
Cl
UJ
I-
~
...J
w
0:
<(
::>
o
>
<'AI
o
0:
W
aJ
::::
::>
Z
::::
W
1:
<l:
o
Z
W
(.'j
<(
W
....J
I-
~
::::
W
1::
<l:
o
Z
W
(.'j
<(
>-
....J
0:
<l:
W
....J
(J
I-
Z
0:
0-
W
(j)
<l:
W
....J
0-
o
0:
<l:
W
:I:
(.'j
~
W
aJ
I-
U
W
....,
aJ
::>
(j)
W
:I:
I-
o
I-
0:
o
0:
0-
::::
o
o
0:
o
0:
<l:
o
aJ
W
:I:
I-
Z
(j)
<l:
cs
W
:I:
I-
u..
o
I-
u..
W
....J
W
....J
aJ
<l:
I-
W
:I:
I-
Z
o
::::
0:
o
u..
o
W
I-
W
....J
0-
::::
o
u
W
U
<l:
....J
0-
~
U
/'
.......:::\Q))
~
(j)
(j)
W
0:
o
o
<(
W
::::
<l:
z
0:
W
:I:
I-
o
f- '
<(eL
o -
a:UJ
<(w
(/) 0 _I
~(1)~
~wZ
> I -
f=1-:=!
00<(
<( I- a:
C)~f--
Z a: -
-W2
>-.-J<(
gsO~
OW<(
.-JIf--
>- I- I-
ZI(/)
<( I- <(
~~w
C)a:O
ZWC0
-1-C0
~ f!J. "
C)C)C)
Z W ~
w a: 0
w (/)" :=!
a: a: :J
owCO
u.. z a:
WOW
(l)" U5 Z
.-J (/) a:
.-J-:J
<(2f--
I2Z
(/)00
(/)02
I- >- a:
f!J.1-<(
>-ZI
(l) :J
(l) 0 .
gos
.-J u.. a:-
.-JOO
<(00
~ ~ u:
~ O~
(/)CO-.::t
WWr:-
a: I Z
-I-W
:JC)2
OZI-
W-a:
a:UJ<(
-.::t(/)Q..
C\.JWW
I a:O
1'--0
OO(/)
. <( 0
o -a:
ZOO
W I- 0
OOW
ZWa:
<(~O
~2Z
O:J<(
a:I-UJ
OOW
>-ZI-
I-I-::::J
Z::::J~
:J(l)~
060
oza:
a:-<l:
WOO
:J3rn
.-Jow
OZI
0-::::-1-
0:
W
z
Q
I-
i=
W
0-
(.'j
z
i=
z
W
CJ)
W
0:
0-
W
a::
rP
o
a:
<i
:I:
(J
W
:c
I-
>-
....J
Z
o
CJ)
CJ)
w
a:
o
o
<(
o
I-
W
a:
<t
o
z
<(
CJ)
I-
Z
W
::::
::::
o
(J
a:
::>
o
>
a:
o
u..
CJ)
W
I-
::>
z
:2
-
M
--
w
w
a:
:I:
I-
o
I-
o
w
!::
::::
..:J
W
a:
<(
::>
o
>
0:
W
aJ
::::
::>
Z
::::
W
1::
<(
o
z
W
(.'j
<(
W
....J
I-
~
::::
W
1::
<l:
o
z
W
(.'j
<(
>-
....J
a:
<l:
w
....J
(J
I-
Z
ct
0-
W
(j)
<l:
w
....J
0-
o
0:
<l:
W
:I:
(.'j
Z
W
aJ
I-
U
W
....,
aJ
::>
(j)
W
:I:
I-
o
I-
0:
o
0:
0-
::::
o
o
0:
o
a:
<l:
o
aJ
W
:I:
I-
Z
(j)
<l:
CS
W
:I:
I-
u..
o
I-
u..
W
....J
W
....J
aJ
<l:
I-
W
:I:
I-
Z
o
::::
0:
o
u..
o
W
I-
W
....J
0-
::::
o
u
W
U
<l:
....J
0-
r
~
d
J
~
~
1
\f
()
~
s
v
~
~
(j)
(j)
W
0:
o
o
<(
.>
t
u
..~.,
W
::::
<l:
z
a:
W
:I:
I-
o
f- -.J
.....:r: LL
o
a: (/)
<( W
(/)o.-J
~CO~
~wZ
> I .
f= I- :=!
00<(
<( I- a:
c.9~f--
za:-
-w2
>- .-J <(
gso~
OW<(
.-JIf-
>- I- I-
ZI(/)
<( I- <(
-w
Zs.,.-
C)a:G
ZWC0
C) t:i C0_
<((5C)
C) W Z
tEa:o
W (/)- :=!
a: a: :J
owCO
u.. Z a:
wOw
(l)_ U5 Z
.-JUJa:
.-J-::J
<(2f-
I 2 Z
(/)00
(/)02
I- >- a:
f!J. I- <(
>-zI
m ::J
mO'
OOS
.-J _
.-Ju..a:
.-JOO
<(00
I-a:.-J
<(<(u..
I 0 I
I-rn~
(/) W .
W I-
a:Iz
-I-w
::JC)2
OZI-
W - a:
a: (/) <(
-.::tUJQ..
C\.JWW
I a:O
1'--0
GOUJ
0<(0
- a:
ZOO
W I- U
UOW
zwa:
<(t:O
Z2Z
o :::J <(
a:1-(/)
OOW
>-zl-
I-I-::J
Z::J~
::::JCO~
060
Oza:
a:-<(
woo
:J3rn
.-Juw
OZI
0-::::-1-
0:
W
Z
o
i=
i=
w
0-
(.'j
z
i=
z
W
CJ)
W
0:
0-
W
a:
a:
<l:
:c
o
w
:c
I-
>-
....J
Z
o
CJ)
CJ)
w
a:
o
o
<(
o
I-
waa:
<t
o
z
<(
CJ)
I-
Z
W
::::
::E
o
o
a:
:::l
o
>
a:
o
u..
CJ)
UJ
I-
:::l
Z
:2
-
M
--
UJ
UJ
a:
:I:
I-
o
I-
o
UJ
!::
::E
..:J
UJ
a:
<(
:::>
o
>
~
<:>
~
~
~
W
...J
I-
.=
:E
w
.!::
<C
o
z
w
<-'
<(
0::
w
In
:E
::J
Z
:E
w
I-
>-
...J
0::
<C
w
...J
o
I-
Z
ii:
D..
w
(/)
<C
w
...J
D..
ci
0::
<C
w
:I:
<-'
Z
jjj
In
I-
o
W
..,
In
::J
(/)
W
:I:
I-
o
I-
0::
o
0::
a..
:E
o
o
0::
o
0::
<C
o
In
w
:I:
I-
Z
(/)
<C
C
W
:I:
I-
u.
o
I-
u.
W
...J
W
...J
In
<C
I-
W
:I:
I-
Z
o
:E
0::
o
u.
o
W
I-
W
...J
a..
:E
o
o
w
o
<C
...J
D..
-\-:,
~
~
t\
. .
(/)
(/)
w
0::
C
o
<(
w
:E
<C
Z
Ii
w
:I:
I-
o
I- .
<(~
o
O:::(f)
<(w
(f}0...J
w,....o-
-......<(
!::WZ
>I "
i=1-:::!
00<(
<(1-0:::
c.')~f-
ZO:::-
-w~
>--f<(
~0::E
o w f-<(
...JI
>-1-1-
ZI(f)
<(1-<(
~~w
'<"'"
c.')O:::c
zW('l)
-1-('1)
~ ~ "
c.')c.')c.')
zwz
wO:::O
w ui:::!
0:::0:::::)
owO)
LLZO::
wOw
CD-Z
-I~O::
...J-::)
<(2f-
I2Z
(f}00
(f}02
1->-0:::
~I-<(
>-ZJ:
CD::::>
CD 0 .
OOS
...J "
...JLLO:::
...JOO
<(00
1-0:::...J
<(<(LL
I or
I-ID~
(f}W "
WII-
O::I-Z
- w
::)c.')2
OZI-
W-o:::
O::(f)<(
.q-(f}0-
NWW
,0:::0
1"-0
CO(f}
. <( 0
o - 0:::
ZOO
WI-O
OOW
ZWO:::
<(!::O
Z2Z
o::i<(
O:::I-(f)
OOW
>-ZI-
r- I- ::)
Z::::>~
::::>CD:2:
060
Uzo:::
0:::-<(
wOO
::i31D
...JOw
OZI
U';::"I-
0::
w
z
o
i=
i=
w
D..
<-'
z
i=
z
w
UJ
w
0::
a..
w
0::
Ii
;(
:I:
o
W
:I:
I-
>-
...J
Z
o
(/)
(/)
w
0::
e
e
<(
o
I-
w
0::
<(
e
z
<(
(/)
I-
Z
w
:E
:::E
o
o
0::
::J
o
>-
0::
o
U.
(/)
W
I-
::J
Z
i
-
C"')
-
W
w
0::
:I:
I-
o
l-
e
w
l-
i
.::i
w
0:::
<(
::J
o
>-
I
\/.
a:
UJ
CD
::
::J
Z
::
UJ
I-
<(
o
Z
UJ
Cl
~
(\
V i
.:)
r
<
.1
.,...
?
"'''''.
UJ
..J
I-
.=
::
UJ
I-
<(
o
z
W
Cl
~
>-
..J
a:
<(
UJ
..J
o
I-
z
a:
a.
UJ
en
<(
w
..J
a.
o
a:
<(
UJ
:r:
Cl
z
UJ
CD
I-
U
UJ
..,
CD
::::>
en
UJ
:I:
I-
a
I-
a:
a
a:
c.
::
o
o
a:
o
a:
<(
a
CD
UJ
:I:
I-
Z
en
<(
C
UJ
:I:
I-
u.
o
I-
u.
UJ
..J
UJ
...J
CD
<(
I-
UJ
:I:
I-
Z
o
::
a:
a
u.
o
UJ
I-
UJ
...J
C.
::
o
u
UJ
u
<(
...J
a.
: f"".
i i
,. .,
W
::
<(
z:
-'- 'I
(>.
.,,'
.'
;
j
en
en
UJ
g~
~t
~
't
<;.
l.
't.)
,1 _
a:
UJ
:r:
I-
o
f _j
<r:Ll.
o
IT: (f)
<r: LU
UJ 0 ...J
~a:J~
!::wz
> I .
i=f-~
Oo<r:
<r:f-IT:
c.')~!-
~ffi~
>-...J<r:
~O~
o W <{
...JIf-
>- f- f-
Z I UJ
<{ f- <{
Z~:=:
c.')IIO
zWC')
c.')t:ic:
<( (3 c.')
c.') w Z
dJIT:O
. ...J
W UJ -
a::a:::J
Owa:J
LLZIT:
WOW
CO. (J.j Z
....J UJ a::
....J - :J
<(:2f-
I:2Z
UJOo
UJO:2
f- >- IT:
~f-<(
>-ZI
co :J
m 0 -
OOS
...J "
...JLLIT:
...J00
<(00
~~li
I OJ.:
f-a:J~
UJ w .
WIf-
g; f- dJ
:=lc.'):2
OZf-
W _ [[
[[ (f) <{
-q-UJo..
C\jWw
1[[0
1'--0
OOUJ
. <( 0
o .[[
ZOo
wf-o
o 0 w
zwa:
<{ !:: 0
~ ~ Z
o ::::i <{
[[f-UJ
Oow
>-zf-
~~~
:JC02
060
OZIT:
a::-<{
woo
::::::i3a:J
...Jow
o Z I
0.::::.. f-
a:
w
z
a
i=
i=
UJ
a.
c.')
z
i=
z
UJ
(f)
UJ
a:
0-
w
a:
a::
<i:
I
U
UJ
:r:
f-
>-
...J
Z
o
(f)
en
UJ
a::
a
a
<t
a
f-
UJ
a::
<(
a
z
<t
en
I-
Z
UJ
~
~
a
U
a::
::)
a
>
a::
a
u..
en
UJ
I-
::)
Z
~
-.
("')
-
UJ
UJ
a::
:r:
f-
a
f-
a
UJ
I-
~
.:J
UJ
a::
<t
::)
a
>