The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 09/29/2009 Item # 7A Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 1 of 96 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CUR-PL2009-44, SR 846 Land Trust represented by R. Bruce Anderson of Roetzel and Andress LPA and Margaret Perry, AICP, of Wilson Miller, Inc., requesting a Conditional Use Re-review (CUR) of the property commonly referred to as Jones Mine. The Conditional Use (CU-2004-AR-6904) was approved on September 25, 2007 and in accordance with condition No.3, the Conditional Use approval shall be reviewed by staff and brought back to the Board of Zoning Appeals on the first anniversary of approval and again one year after the first anniversary review. The subject property is located at 16000 Immokalee Road, Sections 35 & 36, Township 47 South, Range 27 East; and Sections 1 & 2, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. - OBJECTIVE: For the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) to re-review the approved Conditional Use that was approved and make a determination in the community's interest to either keep the current conditions and operations of approval, modify the conditions of approval, or to reconsider the conditions of approval. CONSIDERATIONS: On September 23, 2008, the Board of Zoning Appeals approved Resolution Number 08-290 for the earth mining operation on the subject site that is zoned Rural Agricultural with a Mobile Home Overlay (A-MHO). The BZA directed staff to review the Conditional Use after 1 year from the date of that hearing. The conditions associated with the approval of CU-2004-AR-6904 are attached to this executive summary as attachment "A" (Res. No. 08-290). Within the Conditions of Approval for Jones Mine, Condition No.3 requires that the earth mining operation shall be reviewed for compliance with the Conditions of Approval and applicable provisions of the Collier County Land Development Code every 2-years for the life of the operation. This is the third Conditional Use Re-review petition presented to the BZA in order to satisfy that original condition of approval. In accordance with BZA direction, the petitioner submitted an application for their annual Conditional Use Re-review. Staff has met with the petitioner to review the performance of the earth mining activities at Jones Mine. In addition to this initial meeting, County Inspectors were present during all of the blasts. The purpose of the on-site inspection of the excavation facility by the reviewing County Staff was to evaluate the site's compliance with the original Conditions of Approval. During the on-site inspection, staff found that the facility was in compliance with all of the original conditions of approval. FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Conditional Use Re-review will have no fiscal impact on Collier County. CUR-PL2009-44 1 8/25/09 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 2 of 96 GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Conditional Use Re-review will have no effect on the Growth Management Plan. ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES: The environmental issues were addressed in the original Conditional Use application review and approval. The approval of this Conditional Use Re-review will not create additional environmental Issues. ENVIRONMENT AL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION: The EAC previously reviewed this petition for the original Conditional Use application. Their recommendations were added to the original conditions. The approval of this Conditional Use Re- review will not adversely impact the previously approved conditions. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC heard the original petition CU-2004-AR-6904, Land Trust Earth Mine on August 2, 2007 and recommended its approval. The Collier County Planning Commission is not required to review a Conditional Use Re-review. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: Before you is the second annual review of a Conditional Use authorizing an earth mining operation for Jones Mine. A Conditional Use is a use that is permitted in a particular zoning district subject to certain restrictions. Decisions regarding Conditional Uses are quasi-judicial. As such, this item requires ex parte disclosure, and all testimony given must be under oath. The attached report and recommendations of the Planning Commission required are advisory only and are not binding on you. Petitioner has the burden of demonstrating that the necessary requirements have been met, and you may question Petitioner, or staff, to satisfy yourself that the necessary criteria has been satisfied. In addition to meeting the necessary criteria, you may place such conditions and safeguards as you deem appropriate to allow the use, provided that there is competent, substantial evidence that these additional conditions and safeguards are necessary to promote the public health, safety, welfare, morals, order, comfort, convenience, appearance, or the general welfare of the neighborhood. As a further condition of approval of the Conditional Use, you may require that suitable areas for streets, public rights-of-way, schools, parks, and other public facilities be set aside, improved, and/or dedicated for public use, subject to appropriate impact fee credits. Approval or denial of the Petition is by Resolution, with approval of the Conditional Use requiring four affirmative votes of the Board (supermajority vote). The proposed Resolution was prepared by the County Attorney's Office and is legally sufficient for Board action. (STW) CUR-PL2009-44 2 8/25/09 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 3 of 96 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) approve the attached Resolution for CUR-PL2009-44, the Conditional Use Re-review for SR 846 Land Trust Earth Mine (commonly referred to as Jones Mine) to allow the continued use. PREPARED BY: Melissa Zone, Principal Planner Department of Zoning and Land Development Review - CUR - PL2009-44 3 8/25/09 Page 1 of2 Agenda Item No. 7A September 29,2009 Page 4 of 96 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Item Number: 7A Item Summary: This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. CUR-PL2009-44 SR 846 Land Trust, represented by R. Bruce Anderson of Roetzel and Andress LPA; and Margaret Perry, AICP, of Wilson Miller, Inc., requesting a Conditional Use Re-review (CUR) of the property commonly referred to as Jones Mine. The conditional use (CU-2004-AR-6904) was approved on September 25,2007 and in accordance with condition #3, the Conditional Use approval shall be reviewed by staff and brought back to the BZA on the first anniversary of approval and again one year after the first anniversary review. The subject property is located at 16000 Immokalee Road, Sections 35 & 36, Township 47 South, Range 27 East; and Sections 1 & 2, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Meeting Date: 9/29/2009 9:00:00 AM -. Prepared By Melissa Zone Principal Planner Date Community Development & Zoning & Land Development Review 9/8/2009 3:50:51 PM Environmental Services Approved By Ray Bellows Chief Planner Date Community Development & Environmental Services Zoning & Land Development Review 9/10/200910:17 AM Approved By Norm E. Feder, AICP Transportation Division Administrator Date Transportation Services Transportation Services Admin. 9/11/20093:01 PM Approved By Judy Puig Operations Analyst Date Community Development & Community Development & Environmental Services Environmental Services Admin. 9/15/2009 4:48 PM Approved By Steven Williams Assistant County Attorney Date Attorney's Office Attorney's Office 9/16/200912:34 PM Approved By Susan Istenes, AICP Zoning & Land Development Director Date Community Development & Environmental Services Zoning & Land Development Review 9/16/2009 2:45 PM Approved By Nick Casalanguida MPO Director Date Transportation Services Transportation Planning 9/17/20097:49 AM file://C:\Agendatest\export\135-September 29,2009\07. BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS\7... 9/23/2009 Page 2 of2 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 5 of 96 Approved By Jeff Klatzkow County Attorney Date County Attorney County Attorney Office 9/17/20091:13 PM Approved By Joseph K. Schmitt Community Development & Environmental Services Adminstrator Date Community Development & Community Development & Environmental Services Environmental Services Admin. 9/17/20094:17 PM Approved By OMB Coordinator OMS Coordinator Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 9/17/2009 4:45 PM Approved By - Mark Isackson Budget Analyst Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 9/21/20099:02 AM Approved By Leo E. Ochs, Jr. Deputy County Manager Date Board of County Commissioners County Manager's Office 9/21/20093:28 PM file://C:\Agendatest\export\135-September 29,2009\07. BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS\7... 9/23/2009 .- , . .. .. '. ... "' . I . I . . . . . . " ., .. ,. ~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . ., z. <( 0'> co . ' . ,~ . . ,.~', . ., I","; .' . , . . .... . . ";' I",," ,.......00) ,I "'. W"' " '" ..w 'IIIIIt.....1 " < ..w 1IIIICt.. II -< It ~UJt. CD.. C. ~~o I ..- II .- I" 1-'1' :' t" :: .J:~ ::~:: .1-:: o ~.""". ~.... ". "" ";;; CI) r W..., </ ..... ,I, . . .. 2 Qi ~ ~ ~ ~ .....< / ..< ....< Wi ,b.. " ., <<< ... < . , :; .ClE u.... OYO~ .oWl! QfN"lS1 ~Ill ~ B q co:- <:' :::'/: > ..v <.,..... :::: <<::~ ::: . . . . . . I .. "'0 CI) - - ~ .--- .. .", . , , " 0.. C~ :::: . OJ 0. '< 'Nn 'KlO <( OJ OJ" ..... <( (/) , '. . . . W .~, , . " ~ )NVl dlHSON: .. \W' . . '. 1-'....' 9~' i \ ~,~ .L " ~ r---lOi--g~ .... ..... fn ~ I---l :r: -<> , . , , , , , .. '-' ~ . , - ' '.... .,,,. ,u," Z Iill~ ~+ ....< < ... .... . " "" - ~1""1n ... "m ..... .... ........ . . . . . .. Z < ..... /<< ......< .'. < / . '" ,u,. !.< .') .......... I ."< / < .. 0 Q < < < ....< < I>.. .... / ) < . . . . i < ... .... ...... << > ... / ....<< ..' ,,'. . . N It1 i('/< ..... ... ..... ...... \ .....< ...... '.,~ Kl' Q "< '.. .... ~ .... ....<< <<0<< ..... 1-=< .... :' u<< 1/ ..:!: ;11: .... .... ..,. w i in . ""'l"""" .....(\ ...)>. .."1' .'. < < .... ,.... J' <>< .....< .....< ..... .....< ...... . u,' ~ ! .','< ..<< . ...) ... < . .'. .... >. > I ~ .>..< ...... .....<< ..> . ~ . < .....)/< ...... ..... <.. .... . , A<<< .... ....< .>< ........< ...<"" i.<< < ...... ...... ...... ....~ fi! ~ "'!I'~ '.." < . < ......< ..... .....<,:. .. '. 0) , :::~ .;1"' NI;<; I ~ ~ ~ Sl' ~ I U ! I ! . I '101 t I . . . . I . I ::!: oJ / ~ fi 0 0 ~ 0 I' I 'M Z I I ~ of. i ; i i i ~ i ; W..C") ., ~ ~ --'.ct <et <1: ~ ~ "-"" I II , . " ." 0: . a:: :::> 31WOS ell lON / "'E- () I _ 'It ~I f-' n ~I is is I U u a~~ 0.. <( ~ Z "' 0 " -'- - r- <( o o .....J ~~6 .~.:::> o;;L-1 i'~C y,<'; (,.,)-jcf. ----- COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESlrmlacDRlwE No.7 A DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW NAPLES, FLORIDA 3~ember 29, 2009 WWW;COLLlERGOV.NET (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643'-8 of 96 ~ - . 'C,gND1TfONALUStR~A~e\tf~Wl~UR} ".' ,,' . (R~v-h~wolC(i)Odjtional'~a'PPl'GV$u..w..'Stl:ptilations'." Should the Board of County Commissioners approve a Conditional Use with stipulations, the Conditional Use shall be reviewed to determine whether the applicant has met the conditions of approval or whether additional stipulations are necessary. Applicant must submit required documents addressing the stipulations no later than six (6) months prior to the date mandated by the Board of County Commissioners. PETITION NO (AR) PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER To be completed by staff DATE PROCESSED ASSIGNED PLANNER r, i' . , .. 'AP:P~JE'AN~f'1~#~1tJ0~1tItf.N<,; . r NAME OF OWNER SR 846 land Trust ADDRESS 3606 Enterprise Avenue CITY Naples STATE FL ZIP 34104 TELEPHONE # 239-643-3343 CELL # FAX # 239-643-4726 E.MAIL ADDRESS: NAME OF AGENT/APPLICANT R. Bruce Anderson FIRM Roetzel and Andress, LPA ADDRESS 850 Park Shore Drive CITY Naples STATE FL ZIP 34103 TELe'PHOt.ie # 239-649-6200 CELL # FAX # 239-261-3659 E-MAIL ADDRESS: I,'i<~'"..;,.., .,Rt=~-Wies~,'~IS11~ll,;;" .', ......... I Property Address 16000 Immokalee Road CU Resolution 08-290 SectionlTownship/Range 35,36, 1, 2 /47,48 /27 Folio # 00113480009,00209240001,00209200009,00113520008 Submittal Requirements: ~ Application Review fee in the amount of $750.00 ~ Legal Advertising Fee $500.00 (estimated, will be reconciled when invoiced by newspaper) ~ Addressing Checklist ~ Eight (8) copies of Letter describing request ~ Eight (8) copies of all documents necessary to address stipulations ~ Eight (8) copies of application form Make check payable to Board of County Commissioners G:\Current\AppJication Forms\A.dmin Fence Waiver.doc rev. Jan 09 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 8 of 96 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC Response to the Conditions of Approval for September 29, 2009 Review Mining Ventures, LLC CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Following is the response to the Conditions of Approval that were part of the Conditional Use re- review approval issued for the SR 846 Land Trust parcel on September 23, 2008. The responses are in bold and have been prepared by members of SR-846 Land Trust Earth Mine consultant team consisting of: WilsonMiller (planning and civil engineering), GeoSonics (seismology); Roetzel & Andress, LPA (land use attorney); Passarella & Associates (ecology), and Missimer Groundwater Science (groundwater hydrology). Collier County Conditions of Approval CU-04-AR-6904 Land Trust Earth Mine This approval is conditioned upon the following stipulations because of the close proximity to Golden Gate Estates in Collier County. 1. The BZA may revoke the approval of this Conditional Use if the approved use or the manner in which the approved use is conducted, managed or operated impairs the character and integrity of the zoning district and surrounding area, or the applicant does not fully comply with or complete all conditions of approval or improvements indicated on the development plan and modification of the conditions or plan are found no to be in the public interest or are detrimental to the public health, safety, or general welfare. All conditions continue to be complied with and monitored, and are addressed in this response. 2. Jones Mine shall assist in the formation of a committee comprised of surrounding neighbors that will work together to hire a qualified engineer(s) who will investigate blasting complaints. The firm and/or candidate should be unbiased toward all parties and hired prior to the BZA six month review of the conditional use. The neighborhood engineering committee was formed and two engineering firms were chosen (Forge Engineering, Inc. and Bob Rude Structures, Inc.) to investigate blasting complaints if the complaints cannot be resolved by SR-846 Land Trust Earth Mine. Since the task assigned to this committee is complete, there is no longer a need for the neighborhood engineering committee. 3. The conditional use approval shall be reviewed by staff and brought back to the BZA after six months from the date of this conditional use approval, on the first anniversary of this conditional use approval, again one year after the first anniversary review, and every subsequent two years thereafter to determine whether additional stipulations or mitigation are necessary to ensure compatibility with other properties in the area and to assure public health, safety and welfare is adequately addressed. Development Services staff will use the foregoing standards in their review and in the event of the inability of Development Services and applicant to agree upon additional stipulations or mitigation, the matter will be referred 518l2009. 211992. Ver: 1 - MPERRY 1. 04208-00.s..0G4 - PVl/RK - 32605 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 9 of 96 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC to the Board of Zoning Appeals using the land Development Code procedural requirement for appeals. The applicant has initiated an application for Conditional Use Re-Review and attended a pre-application conference on May 27, 2009 for said application. The applicant will be available for the September 29, 2009 aZA meeting. 4. This Conditional Use for blasting shall be reviewed by staff and brought back to the CCPC and BZA after one year from the time the excavation permit is issued. Acknowledged. The excavation permit has not been issued as of May 15, 2009. 5. JOnes Mine shall set-up a bi-annual $40,000 fund that shall be designated for neighborhood improvements. The escrow account that was established with the Roetzel and Andress law firm was closed on November 21, 2008. An account was then established at Bank of Florida on November 28, 2008, in the name of Mining Venture, LLC - Community Funct to receive and hold monies associated with the Community Fund. Disbursements from the account require two signatures. This was done to ensure proper disbursements and compliance with the Conditional Use Permit. The monies are in an interest bearing account in order to provide additional funds for the community. Members of the Community Fund Committee include Charles Icenogle, Margaret Kemp, Joyce lancosta, and Damon Jones. The committee made three disbursements in 2008. The committee was approached by the local area schools with numerous requests and the committee agreed that an effective way to help the community was through the schools. With the economy struggling, many families are under a great deal of stress and by assisting the schools in providing quality education and activities for their children would take a little stress off them directly. The following disbursements were made in 2008: $10,000 to Palmetto Ridae Hiah School (12/18/08) - The committee approved donating $10,000 to PRHS for to be used to supplement their after school transportation program. With many of the students at PRHS living quite a distance from the school, participating in after school programs such as tutoring, sports, band and clubs can be difficult if not impossible. PRHS has provided a bus to transport these students home so that they have the opportunity to participate. The cost of this transportation has come out of their general transportation fund which fell short by $17,000 in 2007. The school has had to try and raise these additional funds or suspend the programs. The committee felt that keeping these students involved in these programs was extremely important and that the community would benefit as a whole by students b~ing involved. A contribution in some amount to this fund will probably be an annual occurrence. 6/8/2009.211992.. Ver: 1 ~ MPERRY 2 04208-005-004 - PWRK - 32605 Agenda Item No.7 A September 29,2009 Page 10 of 96 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC '2.000 for sponsorship of Estate Area Schools' Fundraiser Annual Carnival - (12/19/08) - Every year PRHS, Corkscrew Middle School and Corkscrew Elementary School jointly host a carnival for the entire community with the proceeds being split between the three schools. With the budget constraints being faced by the school system, these types of fundraisers are vital for our local schools being able to continue to provide quality educational experiences. This carnival is not only a great way to raise money, it provides a quality family activity to bring the residents of this area together. The $2,000 sponsorships helps offset the direct costs of holding the event and allows a greater percentage of the funds raised to be kept by the schools. $5.000 to Estates Elementary (3/04/09) - The committee approved donating $5,000 to Estates Elementary for the purchase of a multt-function copier, printer and fax machine. Estates Elementary students come from quite a distance as well backgrounds. A great deal of communication is required with the families of these students. Previously the County provided printing services for this communication but again budget cuts have restricted this service. The school has had to look for volunteers to call the homes of students to relay information. This. had proven difficult not only from the time required to call 800 homes but also the language challenges from their students' diverse backgrounds. The purchased equipment will allow them to keep the families of their students involved and informed. The school has assured the committee that ongoing costs associated with the machine can be handled within their budget and that just the mitial acquisition funding was needed. 6. The County shall monitor the conditional use for blasting, and an inspection charge shall be applied to cover fees associated with the inspection. County engineering personnel have been present for each blast. The inspectors share information with the operation's technical recording team to review and compare the statistical data from each blast event. A $200 fee is paid to the County for each blast that covers the inspector's costs. 7. A $500,000 bond shall be set aside for settlement of any claims for structural damages directly resulting from blasting. Applicant has a $500,000 surety bond to assure compliance with LDC requirements. Current term of this bond is from March 31, 2009 through March 3:1, 2012. 8. The local damage contact will be Mr. Damon Jones at 239-304-1506 or www.jonesmining.com. Damon Jones remains the local concerns contact and his telephone number remains the same. The Jones Mine website is updated periodically with new information about the various mining activities. .'.,2OD9. 211992 . Ver 1 . MPERRY 3 00200.DO&-01>4 . PWRK. 32805 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Page 11 of 96 Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC 9. To reduce the impacts to the neighborhood, and to account for changes in weather conditions, air blasts shall not exceed a maximum limit of 120 db!. Sixteen (16) blasts have occurred between the September 23, 2008 re-review hearing of the conditional use approval and the preparation of this response (early June, 2009). Engineering Services Department Staff has monitored every blast and the applicant has not exceeded the maximum limit of 120 dbl. A log of blasting events since August 25, 2006 is included as Attachment 1. 10. Ground vibration shall be allowed up to and not to exceed a calendar monthly average of 0.20 inch per second. Sixteen (16) blasts have occurred between the September 23,2008 re-review hearing of the conditional use approval and the preparation of this response (early June, 2009). Engineering Services Department Staff has monitored every blast and the applicant has not exceeded 0.20 inch per second ground vibration. A log of blasting events since August 25, 2006 is included as Attachment 1. 11. The maxim um load per hold shall be limited to less than 100 pounds of explosives per blast. Sixteen (16) blasts have occurred between the September 23, 2008 re-review hearing of the conditional use approval and the preparation of this response (early June, 2009). Engineering Services Department Staff has monitored every blast and the applicant has not exceeded the maximum limit of 100 pounds of . explosives per blast. A log of blasting events since August 25, 2006 is included as Attachment 1. 12. The maximum number of blasting activities shall be limited to eight (8) days per month and the maximum number of holes per month shall not exceed 1,680. Sixteen (16) blasts have occurred between the September 23, 2008 re-review hearing of the conditional use approval and the preparation of this response (early June, 2009). Engineering Services Department Staff has monitored every blast and the applicant has not exceeded the maximum limit of 8 days per month of blasting activities. A log of blasting events since August 25, 2006 is included as Attachment 1. 13. A one dollar ($1.00) per heavy loaded truck exiting Jones Pit shall be paid semi-annually fqr ongoing maintenance of county roads impacted by the heavy vehicles. This surcharge will expire when the property is rezoned or the conditional use has been terminated. A one dollar ($1.00) fee per loaded truck has been collected and paid to the County. The fees for the second quarter of 2009 will be paid shortly, and documentation. will be forwarded to the County. 14. The applicant shall hire a consultant to establish an archaeological monitoring plan and make sure the employees of Jones Mine are aware of the monitoring plan. -- 6/812009 ~ 211992 - Ver: 1 . MPERRY 4 04208-OQ5-0Q.4 - PWRK - 32605 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29.2009 Page 12 of 96 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC A proposal has been received from Dr. Robert Carr, the archaeologist who performed the initial study of the property. He will meet with employees once the Excavation Permit for the expansion area is issued and inform the employees of what to expect and the procedures to 'be followed should any historical or archaeological artifact be uncovered as the result of mining operations. 15. Beginning on the first anniversary date of BZA approval and continuing each year thereafter, the owner shall provide a report to the Collier County Transportation Services Division which will include the condition of the roadway adjacent to the property entrance, accident reports, and average daily and peak hour vehicle trips entering and exiting the earth mine. Each quarter, the applicant provides the Transportation Services Division with a traffic count report. The 2009 second quarter traffic report is included as Attachment 2. The report for the third quarter is currently being prepared and will be forwarded to the Transportation Services Division upon completion. Included as Attachments 3 are photographs indicating the conditions of the roadway adjacent to the property entrance on Immokalee Road. The report submitted last year, for the re-review of the conditional use approval reported on accidents at Immokalee Road and Jones Mining Road from 2005 through September of 2008. The Collier County Sheriff's Office has informed the applicant that traffic crash information from the last reporting period until present are not available due to a backlog in data entry on traffic crashes (see e-mail from Marianna Herrera dated June 4, 2009, Attachment 4). To the knowledge of the mine operator, no traffic accidents have occurred at the Immokalee Road/Jones Mining Road intersection since September 16,2008 until submittal of this report, 16. The storm water run off quality should not be affected with the proposed excavation area expansion. The storm water run off quality has not been affected by the existing mining operations and will not be affected by any expansion that occurs in the future. 17. A twenty (20) foot wide Type B buffer and fifteen (15) foot high berm shall be installed along the perimeter of the operation adjacent to the residential structures immediately upon approval of this conditional use to insure the noise reduction is addressed. Mulch berms shall not be permitted as part of the buffers. A Site Improvement Plan (SIP) was issued by the County in September 2006 for the Type B buffer. The buffer has been constructed and maintenance performed as necessary. 18. To lessen the potential for noise, dampening of the rock crushing equipment shall have attenuation properties/enclosures around the motors of the equipment. If attenuation enclosures are not able to be achieved for other large equipment then an earthen berm shall be installed around the pumps and equipment; up to the height of the equipment being 6/8/2009 . 211992 - Ver: , w MPERRY 5 04208-005-004 . PWRK ~ :!260S Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Page 13 of 96 Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC shielded, (Le. if the equipment is 10 feet high then a 10 foot high berm is required). The berm shall be installed within six (6) months of approval of this conditional use. Only portable rock crushing equipment is being used. Surrounding each power- generating unit attached to the equipment is a noise suppression device. Pumps used in the dewatering process either have rock stacked adjacent to them or have sound deflectors next to their motors to deflect the noise away from the adjoining properties. 19. Blasting is allowed only within the "Permitted Lake Boundary" as shown on the Conditional Use Master Site Plan - Phase I and II. Blasting has only occurred within the permitted area shown on- the Conditional Use Master Plan - Phase I. Blasting will not occur in the Phase II area until an Excavation Permit for Phase II has been issued. 20. Adequate utility, access roads, drainage, and other necessary facilities already provided shall continue to be maintained. Existing utility, access roads, and drainage are functioning and are being maintained. 21. The mining operations shall be conducted in compliance with the laws of the State of Florida, Collier County Government and the Federal Government, especially as related to safety standards set forth in the Blasting Regulation of Collier County Ordinance No. 04-55, as amended. Blasting operations have been conducted at the Jones Mining site in specific compliance of the Collier County LDC, these Conditions of Approval, State of Florida Regulations, and applicable federal regulations. 22. The hours of pit operation shall be limited to 7:00 AM. to 6:00 P.M. Monday through Saturday to prevent disturbance noise to the surrounding residential property owners. If the County receives any complaint regarding the noise from the rock crushing equipment then the hours of operation shall be limited to 7:00 AM. to 6:00 P.M. Monday through Friday. The hours of blasting shall be regulated by stipulation number 23. The hours of pit operation have been from 7:00 A.M. to 6:00 P.M. Monday through Saturday. 23. The hours of blasting shall be limited to 9:00 AM. to 4:00 P.M. Monday through Friday. Blasting activities shall not exceed eight (8) days per month with a three (3) second maximum initiation duration with a low volume and close pattern to minimize noise and vibration. All blasting has occurred between 9:00 AM and 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday. Engineering Services Department Staff has monitored every blast and the 6/812009 - 211992 - Ver: 1 . MPERRY 6 D4?D8-DD&-OD4 . PWRK - 32605 -""-''; Agenda Item No. 7A . September 29, 2009 Page 14 of 96 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC applicant has not exceeded the maximum limit of 8 days per month of blasting activities. A log of blasting events since the public hearing for the conditional use review on September 23, 2009 is included as Attachment 1. 24. The maximum allowable depth of the excavation shall be 45 feet or to the confining layer, whichever is shallower. The depth of the blasting and excavation has not exceeded the maximum allowable depth of 45 feet. A confining layer has not been encountered in the excavation operations to-date and therefore, excavations are reaching the 45 feet maximum depth. 25. Excavation shall occur from the eastern boundary and work towards the western boundary of the property. Excavation is proceeding from the eastern edge of the excavation and working toward the western edge of the excavation area. 26. A southbound lane shall be installed to include a passing lane and the length shall be determined on an acceleration rate to 45 miles per hour (mph) or posted speed limit of a loaded dump truck exiting from the property on to Immokalee Road. The southbound lane shall be built to the standards of the Transportation Services Division and all costs of the construction of the southbound lane as well as the land for right-of-way shall be the applicant's responsibility. The southbound truck acceleration lane has been designed and informal discussions have occurred with Collier County. The southbound lane has not been installed because the maximum limit of 800 loaded trips has not been exceeded. 27. The conditional use shall be limited to 800 maximum loaded trips per day until the southbound passing lane is constructed. Once the southbound lane has been installed, the limitation on 800 maximum loaded trips shall be lifted. The maximum limit of 800 loaded trips per day has not been exceeded. 28. Upon completion of excavation activities, all buildings, equipment, buffers and berms shall be removed within six (6) months, unless such buildings and equipment will be used in tbe reclamation process. These procedures will be followed at the end of mining activities. 29. During each blast a seismograph machine shall be placed in three locations; at the northern property border closest to Fawn Avenue and adjacent to the closest residential structure; at the southern property border adjacent to the closest residential structure between 16th Street N.E. and 20th Street N.E.; at the eastern property border between 52"d Avenue N.E. and 58lh Avenue N.E. 6/812009 - 211992 . VQr: 1 . MPERRY 7 04208.005.004 PWRK. 32605 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Page 15 of 96 Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC Seismographs were installed at the site per the above condition. The instruments were installed permanently on September 4-5, 2006. Each instrument meets the criteria of the State of Florida and is oper~ted by GeoSonics, Inc. a qualified and independent vibration consultant. The instruments operate from 6:00 a.m. through 8:00 p.m. daily to cover all blasting and operational hours. Following each blast, all results are downloaded from the seismographs. The records are printed and the results provided to SR-846 land Trust Earth Mine, Collier County CDES, and Florida Drilling & Blasting (a licensed blasting contractor conducting the blasting at the mine site). 30. A pre-blasting survey shall be taken for all affected property owners who expressed a concern at the Neighborhood Information Meeting, Collier County Planning Commission and the Board of County Commissioners as well as those who transmitted letters of dissent and existing structures along with the future structures that meet the pre-blasting inspection criteria of Ordinance 04-55. One copy of the pre-existing survey will be given to the homeowner and another copy shall be filed with the Collier County Engineering Services Departm,ent Director. Engineering Services Department has the records of the pre-blasting survey, and the inspection reports are kept on file with the County. 31. An approved indigo snake plan is required to be implemented prior to beginning any construction including site clearing. The name and contact information of a qualified biologist who will monitor work shall be supplied to Environmental Services Department staff at the pre-construction meeting or prior to excavation permit approval. The indigo snake plan and name of the monitoring biologist have been provided to CDES as part of the Excavation Permit application. The eastern indigo snake plan follows the guidelines established by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 32. Evidence of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) accepted mitigation for impacts to panthers, woodstorks, Florida black bear and other listed species will be required prior to excavation permit approval. The applicant shall comply with all protocols and procedures for listed species as required by federal and state law. An application to FWS has been made and the County was notified by FWS of the application. 33. An updated listed species survey less than 6 months old is required for areas of expanded excavation prior to issuance of an excavation permit. As required by FWC Technical Assistance, follow up pedestrian surveys of each new mining block will be conducted between 60 and 180 days prior to commencement of any mining related activity through the life of the project. The applicant shall submit a copy of these surveys to Environmental Services Department staff. 611l12009. 211992. V.r 1.MPERRY 8 04208..o0S-004 . PWRK. 32805 Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 16 of 96 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC This initial survey was provided in the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the Phase I excavation permit. Follow-up surveys will be conducted as required by FWC Technical Assistance and submitted to Environmental Services Department staff. 34. Vegetated buffers shall be maintained around all wetlands. If any of these buffer areas do not include the minimum required vegetated width, a replanting plan will be required as part of the excavation permit. Vegetated buffers exist between wetlands and the mining operation. 35. Any other additional or updated environmental permits or information as required in the LDC will be required prior to excavation permit approval. The applicable permits and other information will be provided by the Applicant prior to excavation permit approval. 36. Provide a 5.3 acre littoral area, suitable for wading bird habitat within the created lake. Construc;:tion of the littoral area will commence no later than 2 years from the approval of the Conditional Use and be finished within 5 years of said approval. The location of the 5.3 acre littoral area is shown on the Excavation Permit application drawings for Phase II. The conceptual plans for the littoral area have been provided to the Environmental Services Department. Construction will commence no later than September 25, 2009 and will be finished on or before September 25, 2012. 37. All conditions of the original Conditional Use shall remain in effect, but only to the extent they are not in conflict or inconsistent with these stipulations. The applicant has complied with all applicable conditions of the original Conditional Use. 38. The water table in adjacent on-site wetlands shall be monitored. Levels shall be recorded and reported to the Community Development and Environmental Services Division every March and September for 5 years. The results shall also be provided to the Environmental Advisory Committee. The mining operators have monitored, recorded and reported the water table in the adjacent on-site wetlands as required. The most recent data collected is included as Attachment 5. These results have been provided to CDES staff for forwarding to the EAC members. 39. Additional information provided by FWC staff regarding impacts of blasting on burrowing owl embryo formation shall be forwarded to the County. The information from the FWC shall be provided to the applicant upon receipt. 61812009 . 211992 . VB" 1 . MPERRY 9 04208.00&.004 . PWRK . 32605 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 17 of 96 September 2009 Conditional Use Re-Review Response to Conditions of Approval CU-2004-AR-6904 - Resolution 08-290 Mining Ventures, LLC The FWC previously commented on the impacts of blasting and concurred with the USFWS that no additional coordination would be necessary for blasting in the project area. As required by FWC Technical Assistance, follow up pedestrian surveys of each new mining block will b~ conducted between 60 and 180 days prior to commencement of any mining related activity through the life of the project. No information regarding the burrowing owl embryo has been forwarded to the applicant from the County. 40. Expedited permitting shall be pursued to ensure that these conditions are met quickly and to shorten the length of time that mining will occur on this site. Community Development and Environmental Services Division has worked with the apPlicant to ensure the permitting process continues in a timely manner. 41. Blasting shall be terminated five (5) years after the expanded excavation permit has been issued. Blasting will terminate five (5) years after the issuance of the Excavation Permit for P,hase II of the mining operation. 42. Blasting shall be limited to the blast zone depicted on the attached map. Engineering Services Department Staff has monitored every blast, and ensures ~"-, that the blasts are limited to the blast zone, and those inspection reports are filed with the County. 6J81Z009. 211992 - Ver: 1 - MPERRY 10 0<1203-005-004 - PWRK . ~2605 Agenda 'tMab~t'1 September , Page 18 of 96 Blasting Log Info Peak Blast # of LBSI Hole Particle Date Holes Holes DiameterUn) Spacina (ft) Oeothlft) Vel. lin/sec\ PSPL ldb) 8/25/06 179 135 3.5 13 35 0.148 113 9/5/06 165 99 3.5 13 20 0.048 128 9/8/06 104 131 3.5 13 35 0.103 121 9/13/06 132 148 3.5 12 35 0.080 116 9/19/06 105 146 3.5 12 35 0,078 121 9/26/06 107 135 3.5 12 35 0,053 126 1 0/3/06 127 147 3,5 13 35 0,060 104 1 0/9/06 95 144 3.5 12 35 0,080 106 10/12/06 235 144 3,5 12 35 0.130 110 10/18/06 170 143 3.5 12 35 0.078 118 1 0/20/06 110 140 3.5 13 35 0.065 108 10/23/06 195 139 3.5 13 35 0.045 107 10/24/06 40 60 4.5 12 15 <.020 . 10/25/06 25 60 3.5 12 15 <.020 . 10/27/06 259 143 3.5 13 35 0.078 111 11/2/06 100 185 4 15 35 0,048 105 11/3/06 140 146 3.5 13 35 0.083 115 11/6/06 180 147 3.5 13 35 0.080 118 11/13/06 263 146 3.5 13 35 0.058 107 11/17/06 78 148 3.5 13 35 0.083 117 11/20106 103 199 4 15 35 0.075 116 11/29/06 100 194 4 15 35 0.048 100 12/6/06 100 192 4 15 35 0.123 110 12/20/06 94 155 4 15 35 0.100 112 1/16/07 131 161 4 17 30 0.098 108 3/6/07 132 132 3.5 14 35 0.185 117 "6/20/2007 78 78 4.5 15 19 0.088 113 6/22/07 78 71 4.5 15 19 0.065 110 6/29/07 76 155 4.5 17 30 0,165 116 7/3/07 69 155 4.5 17 30 0,148 118 7/9/07 101 70 4.5 17 20 0.083 104 7/17/07 96 70 4.5 17 20 0.060 106 7/19/07 99 70 4.5 18 20 0,055 106 7/24/07 99 70 4.5 18 20 0.073 107 8/9/07 69 139 4.5 18 30 0.133 110 8/15/07 69 129 4.5 18 30 0.178 115 8/21/07 94 135 4.5 18 30 0.153 112 8/27/07 89 99 4,5 20 25 0.100 111 9f7/07 78 75 4.5 18 . 20 0.090 107 9/13/07 43 60 4.5 18 20 0.070 108 9/19/07 70 51 4.5 18 20 0.055 105. 11/30/07 40 30 4,5 20 15 0.043 103 12f13/07 40 25 4,5 18 15 0.093 113 12f13/07 40 50 4.5 18 25 0.115 112 2/21/2008 20 30 4.5 20 15 0.038 104 2f21 f2008 20 30 4.5 20 15 0.043 100 2/21/2008 20 30 4.5 20 15 0.033 94 2/21/2008 20 30 4.5 20 .15 0.043 92 2/28/2008 10 48 4.5 20 20 0.043 105 2f28/2008 12 48 4.5 20 20 0,045 105 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 19 of 96 2/28/2008 12 48 4.5 20 20 0.038 104 2/28/2008 12 48 4.5 20 20 0.040 111 3/20/2008 28 48 4.5 20 20 0.078 110 3/20/2008 28 48 4.5 20 20 0.055 116 3/20/2008 28 48 4.5 20 20 0.060 111 3/24/2008 25 48 4.5 20 20 0.068 111 3/24/2008 25 48 4.5 20 20 0.055 109 3/24/2008 24 48 4.5 20 20 0.045 110 3/27/2008 21 48 4.5 15 20 0.048 107 3/27/2008 23 48 4.5 15 20 0.050 101 3/27/2008 23 48 4.5 15 20 0.058 101 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0.053 100 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0.063 92 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0,068 92 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0,048 90 4/10/2008 35 60 4.5 20 25 0,063 106 4/10/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 0.115 112 4/17/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 0.063 115 4/17/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 0.100 114 4/17/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 ' 0.100 112 4/28/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 0.080 110 7/10/2008 40 60 4.5 20 25 0.108 101 7/10/2008 40 60 4.5 20 25 0.068 106 101712008 40 50 4.5 15 25 0.078 107 10/9/2008 34 60 4.5 20 25 0,085 113 10/15/2008 36 60 4.5 20 25 0.073 111 10/23/2008 48 60 4.5 20 25 0,123 111 10/23/2008 39 60 4.5 20 25 0.078 101 12/8/2008 27 60 4.5 20 25 0,073 111 12/8/2008 35 60 4.5 20 25 0.115 114 .- 3/6/2008 20 60 3.5 18 25 0.050 106 3/18/2009 43 60 3.5 18 25 0.088 113 3/18/2009 47 60 3.5 18 25 0.100 119 3/23/2009 40 60 4.5 15 25 0.065 110 3/23/2009 48 50 3.5 18 25 0.090 112 3/26/2009 40 60 4.5 15 25 0.120 104 3/26/2009 48 50 3.5 18 25 0,133 111 4/1/2009 44 50 3.5 18 25 0.058 113 4/1/2009 44 60 4.5 15 25 0,135 111 .Florida Drilling & Blasting (Roger Nunez) took over blasting duties .. PPV cannot excees monthly avg of 0.20 (Collier County) or 0.50 at any blast per State ... PSPL cannot exceed 133db on any blast per State ~. Agenda IttM~J17~r2 September 29,2009 Page 20 of 96 - SR-846 Land Trust Quarterly Traffic Counts 2nd Quarter 2009 June 5, 2009 WWW.ftelnc.net 8250 Pascal Drive 7955 NW 12th St. Ste 418 501 E Tennessee St Ste A 11458 N 53rd Street Punta Garda, Florida 33950 Miami, FL 33126 Tallahassee, FL 32308 Tampa, FL 33617 (941) 639-2818 (305) 463-8411 (850) 222"()262 (813) 989-0729 Fax: (941) 639-4851 Fax (305) 463-8744 Fax (850) 222-0221 Fax (813) 989-0731 . - . .. ~' "'.... ; '" .., "'- _N -, 8~ ih NN .... i; . '" c ~O> 't - :I ..~ .. ..... ~ :r .. - ~ ... z :> .l!l 0 10'" ~. (,) c ,...,It). 111 ::J co~ i5 0 0 ... u 0 IE ~.~ ~ :r: .. I- '" l!_ ~ a: "l' t-Gl 0 '" >00 $ $ z u _0 ! II) "'N -0> ~ ~ ... C ~~ C :I :I i 1lI~ ~. '7 - ::J III N "l O::J ~~ ~ 'lilO !8 ! 2"C1 J g:... l!! t-I; ~...:. "CI- . )(~ u c .... .... ~ oi III 180> 11::1 ..I <'l~ '" ~ ~w i i; oC~ Cll) a'" IL;! II:: c ~ :I ~d! ::I !<2. II) '7' ~ g=: - ..., ON .., III a: "'''' ~ -0 "'''' ~~ , - - =11.I. i Ills: ~~ .. ~i c 0 ~~ '" >tII II "tSw -0'; ... ll!~= .!! i~ ~ w :Ii ~ a: a: .. ~ ~ ~e2 ~ ~. 0 ::loa: 0 ~~ - 0<0 (,) 0 III Oo:g "'0: o~ ,; owz a: z(,)::::) z.n .. g!~ "'~ " I !< '" ~'I' Offia: a: a: 9 ~ 0(,) "."'" . 0000 . N to 0'" N ~ GO 8 (l) a> <D <D co co co CIl co C') 0 C') (l) to 9.i! ~\~ 0 col 00 a>j C') N N N C') ~ co (l) ... ... ~ C') "" "" ... (l) a> ~ a> (l) (l) - C"I ~. 0 (l) ... - Or- G>!OI ....."N~~.,-..... ....,......N..-........ co cD N u; N 0...... CII(/) IN I 0 '... 0...... ,ll! ' ~N .~ ~ I 8l ~g '~ON......(l)(l)'<tN....COC"lll) OC"la>~O~....CO(l)~....~IC"l:8i 0 NI' 00 ~ 18 00 Gl N................C"ItO...'<tCC~tO (l)CC""....CO'<tCO....cotOtOC')C"l <;:! r: .. ~ ('t) ('l') 4) tX): -.r- N ,... ,- ..... ..- ,... ..... ,... N N N ,... ..- . CO ,.... "''''1 tC ..... ...... 0 ~Z' :N 0 i'" ~O ' I "0 - I o c: ., . .. .. . . . .. . .. ..... ..,..... II .. · .. . ., . .. 10 <'>0) g CD I ~~ '4 'I C I I ~ ,00 '00 ....... ,t11 " . .. .. . .... II......".".' fiI . '0 ' ~ \ I , I I I I . . .. ., .. .. .. . .. .. .... ....."......"...... \0 ' I I 1 ffi, I I I . 'I I ' ..... I ' : ~ ...... e.. . .. . tl. ...... ill .. .. .... .. Ii .. .. ; C 0, 0 I I CD ~ i . I I I . ,- . .. .. .. . .. . II . .... .........,........" ,0 i I CO! I f (/)1 ~ 0 0 u... . II .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. ... ..............,... 10 ; o , Q)~OO ~, >M~ 1 l ~MOO ' O~~ ' O-LL.cn ............. ...11111...........\0 c: ~ _ C") . I ~OOro~ ~ ' W ro "0 .-.. (fJ ti::o..5:;t ::J O~~ ~ 0 0 It)CO''''''''' 't- Ill............. ........"'41......0 N....::c OOC:o.. CD ~ z I I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;?t 13 S; t: ~ 0 it ..."............<< ; ~ g ~~ to' ,... N ,... ,... ,... ,... ~ i cti ~; ~ ... 0 "0 a>; ~ Gl I g 0 3: ,....OCO,.....MOI.ON.Olt).. <II................ '!U)-N 8 NL N Nr ~~~~~ooo .~ ~ a:1; ~ CliII,...,...,... 'co ~ N z! 0 ! I ; N""t")(l)CO(l)C')NN....NN C"l(l)~CbtO~CO....tOCO""~:... 0 C')j 0 a>1 II")NN~C"III")""OtO....II")"" ~coco...coO~O""ll)(l)C')!O 0 """i 0 ...\ co; ~ N N .... or- ..... ~ ,.... .,- ,... N ..- N ,..... '-iQ) cO N Ui N, WI IN I 0 .... \ 'Ill I : Mi II") ::J i ~ a; l- CO ~ "" to 0 .... II") N CO <0... "" C"I M N a> 1ft "" "" 0 M.... ... t01N:8l 0 Ni 0 to ll) I'. .... .... ... .... N"" "" ... "" to CO '<t to It') CO N co."" CO N a> to to C'),..... ' 0 ~'. 0 tOl' CO ,... N..-.,- ,.... ..... ,..... or-,... C'\I N 1:'.1 ,... ..... 'CD .~ t-:.. <"4] cD N zl i~ 10 '.,... I , I I W 1 ; I " Z . , . .. · · 9' " .. <<:n ~~~=~~C;;~~~~~:~ i g LOj 8 ~! .! ~ err ... ..........NN....... :;e . .;.; ..., ,ij ~: .!!! OIl/) I :....... 13 o 0:;> C') - z Ie: i ~ I to ~ ::l ,It') , ' to 0"'" ..........41:..... C"') ,....('t)COCJ)C01-00CC(J)CX).,-M~0('l2t 0 ('),0<0; ('t) '0 IV ".!.. cc ll"l""""a>IO""""....""lOtO('I');CO i 0 (l),0 !9' z u.. .OaJI -or- ,.....,....,.........iNN.....,... ,co ..;..; .....; cO \"IiIJ"iJ' UJ z; 1'- i"'" ,.... 1 W ' I I I ' ...J . ' " <( I ,O:::E000000088800:::E08' 00008000011ll >l~"",_.l""""",...i. .c:i1ii l- :X::. '0 0000000 00 0 0000 0000 a: lIJ' III Q'''''' as o' - ..... 0 .1::Gl"<"..,,......""........a............."........mo. Gl>'a.Ill>1 Eo 9 Q) I m EiN .... N M "" 10 (l) "" co a> 0... N ... Nil")"" to (l) "" co a> 0.... ,I l- ... Cl :::2: iti)f=:.... 000000000............ OOOOOOOOO...~I....I i a. : a. I. 8 8:. :::2:) i' , . 00 I ' , 00 ""'lDNIl'lCOOlOMOlIl'lIl'l"'" NCOlD"'MOl,...MM""Il'l.".;M '0 010 lO - A..... .. N..................co.CD.".OlNM ......"..".at.".NOlCD.".."..".N',... 10 COIO CD "'m ...~,.. 'r'*'>c- ...~;r-......-.....:<t- .. r'" ,. ...... .. g~ Olenl 'IN ~ ,~ .......... ~ I ~' gj ~ .~ : ,0 I : ~ .....0 '.l<i'j MCO,......M.".CDatOl."..".,... ......".MOONM,...,...lONMill'l 0 CDj 0 CD'I ~ 00 ~..... ....NM."..O'IMIl'l..... MMMIl'l....CD.....,...Il'lMMNM 0 CD 0 ,... MC') !CI)aJi .....~ ~'I"""'''' ~.....oe-,.....'l"'-.....!1I""" ,:..:.... cC ..... ....0 '~z: iN 0 ,..... ~g 'I ! ! 8 5 : ......"..... .."........ .10 I "' :;:; '00' I ... co ,I I ~ en enl 5 , I d 0 'rn . ill " " .. . . .. . .. .... ..".<<....""...: Q ; , '" I i I 1.01.,I i ' I Z I i ! I , i I ..." ill . .. .. << .. << .... "."............. 10 I ',l, ; I i , I , I , ' ' i<<j I i c;) 0 en ............ .................;01 I I' , ~ ! ZI I I , , . "..<<........"... If -II .. " .. " << ... , ;: .10 I co~ I 1 ~ I , I 'J:: I 0 ! 0 u.. ...II.......~.. ..............,.0' I o ' ' ~ ~ I ~~~ zi .t: C'? co .O....l c-;-& I o-~~ 00000000000. ~..... ...~..O c rs _(0) -:. UJ co (0 a:t W co "0 - en: G:a.o~ :3 000> J::. I 0' 0 It) (0"-" t- 0_0000000000" 11..."............<< '0 N_J: coca. 00 ::J Z a. , 1 ' , ' N N,... N CD 0 O.....CDOl.". 0 0 0 0 00000 0000.0'1 0 01 MN.....NN;!~~~~~ '~ c;:!~! ~, j.... I ~ 1 W; I I I '0 : ~ Ii! ~ I ~, lO 3: Ol 0 0'1.".0 N 0'1"" N 0'1.".0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O'It) t'lj 0""1 I' N I ......... ....M.".O'I..lO......... IIl'l 10.". CO, ....N.....NN I~ r..:. N: ~ 10 I , I I , N co co M 00 co CII 00 N ,... .... Il'l .... C') .... NON co .". ... .... N ,...' Ol I 0 0'11 0 N~ I' MN....NNNO."......NOlO'l CDMC')"'.....O.".O,...COCDMiCO 10 lD 0 Il) co ....NNN............. .....NNNNN........ IN I cD N aii N en, 1M 0:..... l I I al ! ' N,' N :;l i I M M ~ ,: OlLONOCO.....ON.".MCOCO ,...,...LO....M"""CONM...O'I,...;Ml2! 0 Nlo M ~ ...............NMCO."."'''''''CO.".LO .....,...O"""OIl'lCONOlLO""""'ICO 0 Il'l 0 CO:, NN.........N.... N....NNNN...... iN I' r..:. N cD Z' ,M 0 I..... I I 'I I , I, I' Wz :. . " . . . . , ., . . ClO CD N,... ! 0 """.". LO,... 0 M 1l'l!1t) : 0 co 0 """ -g , m ,... ..... 0 N co """ co Il'l ,... ,... "'10 I c;:! Oll c;:! ~ - """ co: ... ..... N N C\l ..... ..... ~ ' ..... ... Il'l ,~ .Jl! .:: menl 1'-:""'" G o 9 i ""1 I I ,... iij _ c' Ol 0'1 U (/)0 -7 11 ........... It .. . . II ... rD r-'oc:t""I:to)&n('l)(")cocnlOf"'oo..NN~ 0 co\ 0 Lt) ~ '0 .... CII ,...NOlOOM""O""Il)""""'Ol I q Ol q 58' z 0::: 0 CO' ... ..... N .... N N N ..... ... I ~ ~....., cO '''I lli zl 1 J.... I'" i ~ I j I C 'O~OOOOOOOOOOOO~OOOOOOOOOOO~_~~-Ol~~~ ~~ ~o ~ 10 000000000000 ooooOOOOOOODw" w~ ~ ..... 0 1:: all" <( " " " .. " .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 0.. .. .. .. .. .. " .. .. .. .. ..1 II: 0 <: ~ >\0.. al >'1 Eo.... ~, mEN ...NM"""Il)CO,...COOlO...N ...NC')""'Il'lCO""COOlO~-I I a. a. 01-.... en ::!E ci5F.... 000000000............. 000000000""''''-1 I i U CO ::!E I a. _, j I 88 . OOOOOOC'l~VCD~CD (I)-'IDC'loo<ooooooll""- 0 ~ 0 vi - 0..... \1)....i 10 ~II)..:: (I);:O>(I)C'I.... l~ i ~ ....1 ~ :: - ~..... i Cl::l! i I.... I.... , .....M mOl I ~ ' I ..- N..... > ; 1""-' I I""- 08 ~ oOOOOOflt(l)C'lI""-C'lID C)~vvC'lC'lOooooolv~ 0 c-l: 0 11)1 ~ 00 Q) , enCOI""-C'lC)1D II)ClII.I)c-l.... i~ '9. ml9. m ('1')('1') Q) 1 . CO c-l ..... 0 '3: ~I I 0 .... .. ., : I ~Cl I ~- ' o c: .. . . fl: ... .. .. .. . .. .... ........................ '0 00' ' :;:l .... I /l) CO =>, ~...... Oi ~~ , ' ;5 I I d 0 'en ."..." tr;. .. . , .' .. .. ell .. . .. . .. . It .. ..: 0 ! ~ I i I I I ' I! i i i............. ............)0 I I ....' i I I ~ I d 1 iij I 01 I 0 'CJ) Zi ,.",....... ",.., ~ , . , . '10 I I i _ ! -I l . . .. . .. '" . '" .. << .... ti....."..... II .. .. <<,0 I H ! ~ I d ... I 0: 0 LL .........., to ., ... .. 41' .." ......;.... 'It .. " .. .. . . 10 o i /l)~o:) ~ i >M~ 1 ~('I')~ I . Cl...J I ' o-L1..Cl .............. ..fII............~O c: ~ . ('I') .... I ~mCO~ :J i UJ CO 'E ;::- 0' j ti:a.O~ :3 OC!>cn .r:: 0 0 Lnm'--' J.- ....fI....,........ _.................110 N-J: o:)~a. ~ I I I ' I OOOOOT-O,.....,.....LO~. ...................<< .:,.- O-r-/ ,---1 II) CO CO I""- .... 1"- 0....' 5 .... IV 0....\ 01.... , i' I al i ;?;1 ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 ...... ('l') 0). C\I N ... .. fI ... .. .. ... .. ... ... .. .. .. I ct'),.....1 0 NI ,..... t-- t-- CO c-l en ~ ' 9. m, ~ : ~ I I I I OOOOOOv....N<01""-1""- vU)(I)a)C').....OOOOOO'M 0 C'l10 CDI'I 0 w .....OU)l")vO o........m.... ,v 0 CD 0 .... I""- L~l ~ ...... ~ ~ ...- .... ~ 0 I O::i ~ M "'-1 CD ::J 1'- lOT"" I .; I- 0 I I Ii.... ::> \1) 1 I ~ ' E' ~ 0 o ?-! 0 0 0 0 0 0 en V 1.1) C'I .... 01 CO C') c-lll) .... .... 0 0 0 0 0 0 01 ~I 0 ml 0 M ~ ~ Cl. CtCDI""-C'lc)v I.I)...VM.... CD 10 010 zi .... 't- to .. or- .. ,.... ~ -; i I~ ~ I z, ! I I Wi. ..."..,.., 1ft C'lfltc-lCOI""-MC'loooool.... 0 1.1)1101")1 0 , , ~! N I""- .... .... CO C'I .... .... I V 0 C'I 0 .... I""- '"'" ~, .... ... .... i 1ft ........ c.; ..-: CO. Z 01=>01 I .... I.... I .... <( '9 ' ' I 1 .... a= !e: : V I V ~ I-z ~ ,...."... ~ N C'I I""- V C'I C'I V 0 0 0 0 0 0: M ~I 0 C'l1 0 1""-1 IX; uJ ~ GO CO,...COM.... 'M 0 CO: 0 ..... W 0~1") I ~ i ~ I z · J ' ~ .00~000000000000~0000000000J~ ~~~~~~ ~m.... .... 000000000000 00000000000 m~~~O ~ (/') 1:: \1) .. 0:( .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. c.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..1501 CD >Ic.. Q) > E 0 Cl /l) UJ mSN ....C'lMvl()COI""-~mo....C'I ....C'lMVIl)COI""-COC)o~~ c.. c.. 0.... < Cl ZWi=I.... 000000000............ ooooooooo.....-j: I () t'G O. Ii! I a. ...., l' I , I . - . I- I. ... . - I - I' .. . .1- I :{SlI., ~J~~ :~. :"~ ~.; "-.. "~. -"" '- '---"......------- '-. "- Obf01/2[)09 I , ".,i ., ; ''-. I '" " "'''-....,..... /' I '.........., / ,/~ , "', " ,./" /' J :'(;.1,' :1 'i ':~,JJ.H' ;-1 . . - .- - . . -. - . . . ... . .. - . . '. n ---=-.-....,..-,.. /' " / . ~ "--. ~ " UU/\ 1/2GCn .. .~(.... t ~. ~ ,. t) , ~,. ~.fl..~ ~jr ,. .',' / "- .'-"...... e ", ''''-" .; , 06jO 1 f201i!l Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 27 of 96 0.1 Mile South of Jones Mining Road -'7t'::.~~;E~~ 0.2 Mile South of Jones Mining Road Agenda Item No. 7 A /~~" . '. 20 ~ears September 29, 2009 ~.L."..,.. . . .............,...i..~ Page 28 of 96 'i<" .' ... . ..-;;; - "~,..,,.n~"'" ,.'Hi '. ...."" " ,"'~'''H~ 0.3 Mile South of Jones Mining Road ~'- ....-.q 0.4 Mile Soutb of Jones Mining Road ( . . - ~ . .- . ... -. - . . .. . . '. '.. ~ {-:l_ " '. .'.. . " '::, Jl5'''. _. " . 'f;' ..,.. ,r.' , ~, , '~,' , I' I ,~ . '';--: :'\ .:. -.."' "7'..,. ~~',"" ~ - .' .' , ; \ . ~ '> " <I " ..:., -\1 ' , .,;~ / ". ':";;~'~I;";~'" '.' , . ' ".' ':"ct! 'If' ...:~ j~f~'~0 ,i' t "'~"'~~if:I\~~ ,.. - ,:'..'i1t:J\:"'~\""'l'" \'~ q, < lr' .....;;41-,~" ",' ;>,~~,",-., . """'lb"'.'ft ' t:'.:J".I~.~,:.~; ....::. " \ ( .1'"" _, " , ' ~." ;;;' . 't..- / . . "".,,~ :& ... ..... ~ -, '" ~ I :. ------- .;....-, if' i . c_,_. ,/ ~" ! i h~~li(. '/ L,..i 1#:~: ..;cJ \ ". .~- "'. .- I,. . PROJECT ENTRANCE AT IMMOKALEE ROAD I . ' . ~~""f,l ...' .- (~~ t'''l'', , ~... . ,'~_:, ~ -,'':;; k. ~ ~,,'~ ~-,..'>~. . ".~..~ <__'-~j.H.'", -"" . . ~ ~ ".-- ....... -~ ~ =,-' 'l~ .~ "- ~ -- :,,-:------.......~" Agenda Item NO.7 A . Sept~/'l~metl9 Page 33 of 96 Margaret Perry .- From: Damon Jones [djones@jonesmining.com] Sent: Thursday, June 04, 2009 11 :26 AM To: Margaret Perry Cc: 'Brian Bruce'; Don Barber Subject: FW: Traffic Crash Statistics From: traffic@colliersheriff.net [mailto :traffic@colliersheriff.net] Sent: Thursday, June 04,2009 11:24 AM To: Djones@jonesmining.com Subject: Traffic Crash Statistics - Good Afternoon, With regards to your request, we are unable to provide information about traffic crashes within the area of 16000 Immokalee Rd from September 2008 to date. This is due to a backlog in data entry of traffic crashes. At this time, we are unsure when this information will be available. If you have any other questions, or if I may be able to assist in some other way, please contact me. Thank you, Marianna Herrera Collier County Sheriff's Office -- Traffic Analyst 239-252-0367 - 6/4/2009 .....~.. -,..~""= Agen~~b~ . . .r~~~~iA~~~ Septe er , 9 Page 34 of 96 February 17,2009 Ms. Susan Mason Collier County Environmental Services Division 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 34104 Re: S.R. 846 Land Trust Semi-Annual W.etland Monitoring Well Data Project No. 99WAI374 Dear Ms. Mason: Pursuant to Conditional Use 04-AR-6904 Condition of Approval No. 38, please find attached the third semi-annual wetland monitoring well data for S.R. 846 Land Trust earth mine (Project). The well data represents readings taken from September 26,2008 through February to, 2009. The location of the five monitoring wells is depicted on the attached aerial. The monitoring wells collect automated daily readings of wetland water levels. The monitoring wells are located in wetlands meeting state jurisdictional criteria (Chapter 62-340, Florida Administrative Code), Data repo~d for each monitoring well includes daily recordings of water level in inches above (+) or below (.) ground surface and a survey reference .to water level in feet National Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD). Ground elevations in feet NOVO are reported for each ~onitoring well. There exists several feet of natural variation in the ground and surface water elevations in wetlands across the Project. The monitoring well data will be reported to Environmental Services by March and September of each year until 2012. Should you have any questions regarding this report, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, PASSARELLA & ASSOCIATES, INC. jItft ~ Matthew Brosious . Ecologist MB/pz Enclosures cc: Melissa Zone, w/enclosures Damon Jones, w/enclosures Don Barberl w/enclosures Jared Brown, w/enclosures Brooke Gabrielson, w/enclosures Bruce And~rson, w/enc10sures , 13620 Metropelis Avenue. Suite 200 . Fort Myers, Florida 33912 . Phone: (239) 274-0067. Fax: (239) 274-0069 . www.passarella.net . ", 'It '''l' "-- . " . -:....... 01'1"-- '~ -rp 'I -l\~~~';;).~';-"'l, . . . ~ ~';" ht~~., .A.-.!;W ,....., \,4 ~ \ .\: ('..-,- ff'':;1''f~')~ ~, , ). h';'~"~'f""!'~ " ....~ I' ''';', . .:. '., :::c: " ,"i.;;, \",i",". ~ -- ;.~, . '/j'l<;r.'!IY' ,. .. " f. -,-,' i,.. i~~~r ~ c,,', I'" , ,,J., " 1 , _d ,,~itJ.';;"IL o~' " :J "u1, ! lit..... 'IJ" 1,' l' (. ~l\. <"('1' ..... J1;-,.n" ~~~~'("', · ... r '., ....> ',:"".. Ji';~ "~:'~, '. f ,~...: _o;:! .~. ", ,-;-...... l . ' .4.~,,~~,~..)~,'...,' '1'):;'- " · . ", .,. " ",,:r.~.<. ;::)' ..~,.;~~;...~t,~;;~ r. ,; '<~'~i"/Z"'~j'r. .1 .~"J.., '.' \'''~'~'';f H. "1 ",.,..,...~".>,,~""dy,. ~j i.;I~" ~~; " ..':' ,:. ;~:\/';(!i:i,I,~,.L]jJ;I/,\:;,:'\':~:'" r>:,.!t. ' l"'I""~~_\ .. ...," . .1...,. I " /: ;':' ,';~1! .' \, i,J . ..I., . '"' . ~;:\ ' ", ,)?:;:~.~,I~~ "'. ~ . ~ < (J~: c.)~ :",.1' '. ..... "... '--"::lfi . ~.J I, "1' -, '" \ . '. ,T tJ 'I' 'Jf'" ..:'-,.., _, I _'. ,'). ':..t ''!~... 1 \. 7lA' ~ 'r. '-.1 . , """.~,.- -', :..... - ~, '''--4~__~.. ' (' ,,'l~~,. ,; , ! ~l:;~~, '<!t' ';" "I ! \~~~'v.c:;'rr..rf ~II,... .. _' ," I ~. ---...--- ~.. '(~.'4'".. 'I r : .i;\i, -'l' _'. "'-'::'".--:. "~ . 'lF~';'Il'.',,1 1_,,,., .'.. ..' '\"-"-" "1 'i" . -.,-,;I.r"-, , _~ I>.. \ . . ,'; . "'- -'-"'"" o <::> ,., ' ., J;, ",'% I J.l ! \:'t,~'1;" "(!' '.. ~" ~ :4.~".~.;,')li" ,.I'\'~t 71:"''':'-I".'.'-i '':11,1 I ' 'I IQ... .- ". ':"<'.-:..1~.'.~~. ,. . .' ,'. . " \ ...,', ~" '" ~ .' '. _,... . J" ,.,. I " --1~ r;!'. "'. \ I' 'I ~ _f. :<l:"'~ ;." jl~ I;">... I 1 :' "..,.-..t:;f,)~\:.f. iJ ;1.'.' . \-,: ,,:~ t"~...J _cu. *'-~ , ttJ'" I . I I" I"~'"'' "~,'J ~ ~". _ ,\:\,.:...:J f-t/'/.' ',1 -}:~ " ,.~..,.. r,1~ :"'1 I' I :,"- .'. '.~~~-ir.\..,j ~'.~~"))fl I):::: 1i'8' ,/ , II 'I' .:i~, ~ ~''''k~1':''~ 1 ' .", H,~;;,>:~ . .~, , . I ,/!, ,. ' , , , " ", ...,. \',. . . , r ' '.1 I '1,.' ilr"" " ..' " ...; \ ,..' J~~ ..A.t1::"\. ,;'- { '" :~: I.., - . II t. ~ ".:...:"." ~'.~~ . ;:).r;~',:\-> ' t h.",,' . \. II I.' I I r ~~r .,t '"",,,,:""" .. (,,, c:' i,', ~, ",j;,/. I 0 ...1",/\ '1 ~ ,..,. '>".. I 1 . '. "F?:'I4"'\'-\.:r.~ I" It '.. ~ ~ ,;. ~l '- -~ . I.' I I .Ii',~,:,.,~;'... ~l :i .,:^w I,' ,.;. . .' ~ ~,.('~<'.' l' 'It ~J J,."...f!i.,'." I'. ..~ i '\" .. ," .-:-~ ,.' ',' ',.-i., ".;li},,1 f;qt., '......, ," " .I, ~iJ j 1 ~ .. ~"~ . '... , I ". jt~1' I" , " ". l" '",. ,,,j ..' ': _-.t- ,.- , /-~'i:J'~""" .'. .1'" ~'5':", ',.;t~~".. #-....-<t! I 0" ;:! ~ \", , lal: i '. " . ' .'.. ..-....... .J"",~...,. '. "';,,'" I '--" ~1 .' ~. jif,.. ...,- '11 t"'."~~' ~ .., . ,., 11 " "' ",_. ) "",'H" i, I ...', '. , ,- "l ",. :. I' ). ~," ,\ .. . ,j!, ,\ W '.0....:' \ ',1;' .Jc';.., '.~'--~,.. -- "-~-"J{;r -'1' .oJ ;::'1,) ~', i 1 "~~:I''\~ .,.." ,;~t(J'. , :.:.J '.:: Z l\ 'Il I !' ,W'1.,... . . . \fj')'Y," ' ~ '10 l\ ,1. f:1 /'-1 ~ :, ,,' -.,~ 'i~ /r .. -l '\.1' ';ft'" , " ( .. ."...._.'.i-:'~.'\.... l ./ ~ ~.\.~._ ~.1'"". .' ,..(-~~ ....'."1.." \ I!-.- . - l,W ':,' l , , ~] ""', ~",,~"'\" '. ..:;;g ... ~' .' .' , ,l!.,~.... ' 1.~,.. .~-' ,-~" f ',\," " " ',' :' '--. 'k" ,'".., =~h. ~~ "M\.. I . , ~''',;;" \ " " ~-~",' ~. I,., I ,.~. '......11 ' i!1" l', ) 'll '-~ - - ~,-.~~~ -"l~~ i. ',')}' '. .I, ' . ;','_,' ", ,,(~ 'f "i"t.i\t~ \ ,., ,.1 .' ~ . . "".- .. ) I ~,"'Jj~. <~', ,! ".- . ,: "', . ;"1::' :\!~~~. 3.'~ ! I . ,~,--~....,...........",.,i" . '.l~':'\.~: '.,,'f..-..:,' ,:. .' I ..n . "--. ' .. . , \, ~1,~ ,F t ", :~:'~:;I , ) _'.\ 'r....:::'.. I "'t\-. , ~~\ll., ~~t,.}~~ '..'; -, ~ . .....1 :--- :~J Z,-<<'; q; . Ul':'::R ~!~,.\oo...,',:. I ;;.. ......- i a ,_'.0 , 1"< , /.... ...1_1 /' ~ L, z."; . ' . . '~'cr';; , / .:.J.:l.' I: I . /. ';:- ./ -"I' '.: -. .. j .. Irl . --I'" . ~c, tJ o.....:'.Vt, : ,} . :;,~I.:i ~. -l ~o ' l:J !- ;;'. 1': ,,~' :5:3 .~,: ~ . \./ .. ~~ ",>' ,--..'...~ .. ~''''''''..~.,. . ,~^'.., ,_.~ ... ,,- ';,~~ ....... ...... "-.. .'.. . ". .....--.,. ..... .. . ',{:<CZ)., : :" '.' .. r'....;.. ~ , 'I. '" Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 36 of 96 Data Acquired: 2/10/2009 Serial Number: N46C546B Wen No.1 Water Elevation Wllter Elevation Ground Elevation (inches ab9ve/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 26-Sep-2008 14.62 19.62 18.4 27 -Sep-2008 14.06 19.57 18.4 28-Sep-2008 13.44 19.52 18.4 29-8ep-2008 13.90 19.56 18.4 30-Sep-2008 15.79 19.72 18.4 01-Oct-2008 16.32 19.76 18.4 02-0ct-2008 15.78 19.72 18.4 03-0ct-2008 15.13 19'.66 -18.4 04-0ct-2008 14.36 19.60 18.4 05-0ct-2008 16.50 19.78 18.4 06-0ct-2008 16.33 19.76 18.4 07 -Oct-2008 15.73 19.71 18.4 08-0ct-2008 15.05 19.65 18.4 09-0ct-2008 14.38 19.60 18.4 10-0ct-2008 14.54 19.61 18.4 11-0ct-2008 14.61 19.62 18.4 12-0ct-2008 13.79 19.55 18.4 13-0ct-2008 12.95 19.48 18.4 14-Oct-2008 12.44 19.44 18.4 15-00t-2008 11.71 19.38 18.4 16-0ct-2008 10.99 19.32 18.4 17 -Oct-2008 10.25 19.25 18.4 18-Oct-2008 9.64 19.20 18.4 19-Oct-2008 9.01 19.15 18.4 20-Oct-2008 8.19 19.08 18.4 21-Oct-2008 7.59 19.03 18.4 22-0ct-2008 6.92 18.98 18.4 23-0ct-2008 6.44 18.94 18.4 24-0ct-2008 6.44 18.94 18.4 25-0ct-2008 8.71 19.13 18.4 26-0ct-2008 7.99 19.07 18.4 27 -Oct-2008 6.74 18.96 18.4 28-00t-2008 5.69 18.87 18.4 29-0ct-2008 4.51 18.78 18.4 30-0et-2008 3.78 18.72 18.4 31-0ct-2008 2.98 18.65 18.4 01-Nov-2006 2.36 18.60 18.4 02-Nov-2008 1.67 18.54 18.4 03-Nav-2008 1.05 18.49 18.4 04-Nov-2008 0.44 18.44 18.4 05-Nov-2008 -0.24 18.38 18.4 06-Nov-2008 -0.90 18.33 18.4 07 -Nov-2008 -1.49 18.28 18.4 08-Nov-2008 -2.08 18.23 18.4 09-Nov-2008 -2.71 18.17 18.4 1 0-Nov-2008 -3.42 18.12 18.4 11-Nov-2008 -4.01 18.07 18.4 12-Nov-2008 -4.14 18.06 18.4 13-Nov-2008 -4.62 18.02 18.4 1 of:) . . Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 37 of 96 Well No.1 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 14-Nov-200B -5.15 17.97 18.4 15-Nov-200B -5.60 17.93 18.4 16-Nov-2008 . -6.15 17.89 18.4 17 -Nov-2008 -7.05 17.81 18.4 18-Nov-2008 -7.62 17.77 18.4 19-Nov-2008 -8.30 17.71 18.4 20-Nov-2008 -B.9B 17,65 18.4 21-Nov-2008 -10.38 17.54 18.4 22-Nov-2008 -11.53 17.44 18.4 23-Nov-2008 -12.29 17.38 18.4 24-Nov-2008 -12.91 17.32 18.4 25-Nov-2008 -13.42 17.28 1B.4 26-Nov-2008 -14.09 17.23 18.4 27-Nov-2008 -15.05 17.15 18.4 28-Nov-2008 -15.55 17.10 18.4 29-Nov-2008 -15.99 17.07 18.4 30-Nov-2008 -16.41 17.03 18.4 01-0ee-2008 -8.73 17.67 18.4 02-0eo-2008 -10.85 17.50 18.4 03-0ee-2008 -13.09 17.31 18.4 04-0ee-2008 -14.08 17.23 18.4 05-Dee-200B -15.00 17.15 1B.4 06-Dee-200B -15.88 17.08 18.4 07 -Dee-2008 -16.55 17.02 18.4 08-0ee-2008 -17.00 16.98 18.4 09-0ee-2008 -17.53 16.94 18.4 10-0ee-2008 -17.B2 1'6.92 18.4 11-0ee-2008 -18.11 16.89 18.4 12-0ee-2008 -7.87 17.74 18.4 13-0eo-200B -11.74 17.42 18.4 14-0ee-2008 -12.91 17.32 18.4 15-0ec-2008 -13.80 17.25 18.4 16-Dee-2008 -13.99 17.23 18.4 17 -Dee-2008 -15.06 17.15 18.4 18-0ee-2008 -15.95 17.07 18.4 19-0ee-2008 -16.77 17.00 18.4 20-0eo-2008 -17.33 16.96 18.4 21-0eo-2008 -18.00 16.90 18.4 22-0ec-2008 -18.59 16.85 18.4 23-0ee-2008 -19.39 16.78 18.4 24-0ec-2008 -19.58 16.77 18.4 25-0ee-2008 -19.66 16.76 18.4 26-0ec-2008 -19.95 16.74 18.4 27 -Oee-2008 -20.56 16.69 18.4 28-0ec-2008 -20.99 , 16.65 18.4 29-0ec-2008 -21.40 16.62 18.4 30-0ee-2008 -21.74 16.59 18.4 31-0ec-2008 -22.1 0 16.56 18.4 01-Jan-2009 -22.52 16.52 18.4 02-Jan-2009 -22.93 16.49 18.4 03-Jan-2009 -23.20 16.47 18.4 04-Jan-2009 -23.66 16.43 18.4 2of3 - . - Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 38 of 96 Well No.1 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD~ 05-Jan-2009 -24.02 16.40 18.4 06-Jan-2009 -24.36 16.37 18.4 07 -Jan-2009 . -24.76 16.34 18.4 08-Jan-2009 -24.97 16.32 18.4 09-Jan-2009 -25.55 16.27 18.4 1 D-Jan-2009 -25.98 16.24 18.4 11-Jan-2009 -26.32 16.21 18.4 12-Jan-2009 -26.65 16.18 18.4 13-Jan-2009 -26.96 16.15 18.4 14-Jan-2009 -27.19 16.13 18.4 15-Jan-2009 -27.72 16.09 .18.4 16-Jan-2009 -28.09 16.06 18.4 17 -Jan-2009 -28.49 16.03 18.4 18-Jan-2009 -28.78 16.00 18.4 19-Jan-2009 -29.07 15.98 18.4 20-Jan-2009 -29.23 15.96 18.4 21-Jan-2009 -29.62 15.93 18.4 22-Jan-2009 -30.07 15.89 18.4 23-Jan-2009 -30.38 15.87 18.4 24-Jan-2009 -30.62 15.85 18.4 25-Jan-2009 -30.83 15.83 18.4 26-Jan-2009 -31.15 15.80 18.4 27 -Jan-2009 -31.44 15.78 18.4 28-Jan-2009 -31.60 15.77 18.4 29-Jan-2009 -31.86 15.75 18.4 3D-Jan-2009 -32. 12 15.72 18.4 31-Jan-2009 -32.34 15.71 18.4 o 1-Feb-2009 -32.71 15.67 18.4 02-Feb-2009 -32.99 15.65 18.4 03-Feb-2009 -31.09 15.81 18.4 04-Feb-2009 -31.92 15.74 18.4 05-Feb-2009 -32.84 15.66 18.4 06-Feb-2009 -33.52 15.61 18.4 07 -Feb-2009 -33.86 15.58 18.4 08-Feb-2009 -34.10 15.56 18.4 09-Feb-2009 -34.33 15.54 18.4 10-Feb-2009 -34.59 15.52 18.4 3013 - . I Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 39 of 96 Data Acquired: 2/1012009 Serial Number: N47FC958 (installed 7/18/2008) Well No.2 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (inches ab~veJbelow ground) (feet NGVO) (feet NGVD) 26-Sep-2008 28.61 21.68 19.3 27 -Sep-200B 2B.28 21.66 19.3 2B-Sep-2008 27.95 21.63 19.3 29-Sep-2008 28.03 21.64 19.3 30-Sep-2008 29.52 21.76 19.3 0i-0ct-200B 30.11 21.81 19.3 . 02-0ct-2008 29.85 21.79 19.3 03-Oct-200B 29.40 21.75 1.9.3 04-0et-2008 28.96 21.71 19.3 05-0ct-2008 30.09 21.B1 19.3 06-0et-2008 29.96 21.60 19.3 07 -Oct-2008 29.67 21.77 19.3 - OB-Oct-2008 29.33 21.74 19.3 09-Oot-2008 28.90 21.71 19.3 10-0ct-2008 28.98 21.72 19.3 11-0ct-200a 29.43 21.75 19.3 12-Oct-2008 29.20 21.73 19.3 13-0ct-2008 28.73 21.69 19.3 14-0et-2008 28.28 21.66 19.3 1S-0ct-200a 27.82 21.62 19.3 16-Oct-2008 27.34 21.56 19.3 17 -Oct-2008 26.87 21.54 19.3 18-0et-2008 26.36 21.50 19.3 19-Oct-2008 25.77 21.45 19.3 20-0et-2008 25.15 21.40 19.3 21-Oct-2008 24.57 21.35 19.3 22-0ct-2008 24.10 21.31 19.3 23-0ct-2008 23.50 21.26 19.3 24-0et-2008 23.23 21.24 19.3 25-0ct-2008 23.28 21.24 19.3 26-0et-2008 23.20 21.23 19.3 27-0et-2008 22.58 21.1B 19.3 28-0et-200B 22.09 21.14 19.3 29-Oet-200B 21.21 21.07 19.3 30-0et-2008 20.11 21.03 19.3 31-0ct-2008 20.21 20.9B 19.3 01-Nov-200B 19.80 20.95 19.3 02-Nov-2008 19.24 20.90 19.3 03-Nov-2008 1B.60 20.65 19.3 04-Nov-2008 17.98 20.80 19.3 05-Nov-2008 17.41 20.75 19.3 06-Nav-200B 16.7B 20.70 19.3 07-Nov-200a 16.27 20.66 19.3 OB-Nov-200a 15.81 20.62 19.3 09-Nav-2008 15.19 20.57 19.3 10-Nov-2008 14.32 20.49 19.3 11-Nov-2008 13.63 20'.44 19.3 12-Nov-2008 13.33 20.41 19.3 13-Nav-2008 12.36 20.33 19.3 14-Nov-2008 11.86 20.29 19.3 1 of 3 - I I Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 40 of 96 Well No.2 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 15-Nov-2008 11.45 20.25 19.3 16-Nov-2008 10.49 20,17 19.3 17 -Nov-2008 8.85 20.04 19.3 1B-Nov-2008 8.51 20.01 19.3 19-Nov-200B 7.21 19.90 19.3 20-Nov-200B 6.66 19.B6 19.3 21-Nov-2008 5.96 19.80 19.3 22-Nov-2008 2.94 19.55 19.3 23-Nov-2008 3.02 19.55 19.3 24-Nov-2008 2.72 19.53 19.3 25-Nov-2008 2.42 19.50 19.3 26-Nov-2008 1.68 19.44 19.3 27-Nov-2008 0.59 19.35 19.3 28-Nov-200B B.07 19.97 19.3 29-Nov-200B B.93 20.04 19.3 3o-Nov-2008 8.69 - 20.02 19.3 01-0ec-2008 9.16 20.06 19.3 02-0ee-2008 8.67 20.02 19.3 03-0ee-2008 8.62 20.02 19.3 04-0ee-200B 8.41 20.00 19.3 05-Dee-2008 8.15 19.98 19.3 06-0ee-2008 7.86 19.96 19.3 07 -Oee-2008 7.51 19.93 19.3 08-0ee-2008 7.24 19.90 19.3 09-Dee-200e 6,94 19.68 19.3 10-0ee-2008 6.69 19.86 19.3 11-0ee-2008 6.48 19.84 19.3 12-Dee-2008 7.68 19.94 19.3 13-0ee-2008 7.46 19.92 19.3 14-0ee-2008 7.23 19.90 19.3 15-0eo-2008 6.91 19.88 19.3 16-0ee-2008 6.65 19.85 19.3 17 -Dee-2006 6.40 19.83 19.3 18-0eo-2008 6.17 19.81 19.3 19-0ee-2008 5.74 19.78 19.3 20-Dec-2008 5.13 19.73 19.3 21-0eo-2008 5.35 19.75 19.3 22-0ee-2008 5.02 19.72 19.3 23-0ec-2008 4.61 19.68 19.3 24-Dee-2008 4.25 19.65 19.3 25-0ec-2008 3.29 19.57 19.3 26-0ee-200B 3.87 19.62 19.3 27 -Dee-2008 3.57 19.60 19.3 28-0ee-2008 2.01 19.47 19.3 29-Dee-2008 2.90 19.54 19.3 30-Dee-2008 1.47 19.42 19.3 31-0ee-2008 2.33 19.49 19.3 01-Jan-2009 1.12 19.39 19.3 02-Jan-2009 1.S6 19.44 19.3 03-Jan-2009 0.10 19.31 19.3 04-Jan-2009 0.88 19.37 19.3 05-Jan-2009 -0.24 19.28 19.3 OS-Jan-2009 0.21 19.32 19.3 20r3 - . I 1 Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29, 2009 Page 41 of 96 Well No.2 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 07 -Jan-2009 -0.03 19.30 19.3 06-Jan-2009 -0.76 19.24 19.3 09-Jan-2009 -0.95 19.22 19.3 10-Jan-2009 -2.68 19.08 19,3 11-Jan-2009 -1.98 19.14 19.3 12-Jan-2009 -2,30 19.11 19.3 13-Jan-2009 -3.94 18.97 19.3 14-Jan-2009 -3.89 18.98 19.3 15-Jan-2009 -4.26 18.95 19.3 16-Jan-2009 .6.06 18.80 19.3 17-Jan-2009 -6.98 18.72 19.3 1 B-Jan-2009 -7.44 18.68 19.3 19-Jan-2009 -7.85 18.65 19.3 20.Jan-2009 -8.44 18.60 19.3 21-Jan-2009 -9.62 18.50 19.3 22-Jan-2009 -10.41 18.43 19.3 23-Jan-2009 -11.39 18.35 19.3 24-Jan-2009 -12.75 18.24 19.3 25-Jan-2009 -14.17 18.12 19.3 26-Jan-2009 -17.S8 17.84 19.3 27-Jan-2009 -19.50 17.6B 19.3 28-Jan-2009 -20.43 17.60 19.3 29-J~n-2009 -21.74 17.49 19.3 30-Jan-2009 -22.98 17.39 19.3 31-Jan-2009 -24.40 17.27 19.3 01-Feb-2009 -25.39 17.18 19.3 02-Feb-2009 -25.88 17.14 19.3 03-Feb-2009 -17.69 17.83 19.3 Q4-Feb-2009 -23.92 17.31 19.3 OS-Feb-2009 -26.38 17.10 19.3 06-Feb-2009 -27.13 17.04 19.3 07-Feb-2009 -28.32 16.94 19.3 08-Feb.2009 -28.30 16.94 19.3 09-Feb-2009 -28.58 16.92 19.3 1 Q.Feb-2009 -28.87 16.89 19.3 .-." 3of3 - . ! Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 42 of 96 Data Acquired: 2/10/2009 Serial Number: N46C542D Well No.3 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (inches ab~ve/b8low ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 26-Sep-2008 5.30 17.54 17.1 27 -Sep-2008 4.77 17.50 17.1 28-Sep-2008 4.33 17.46 17.1 29-Sep-200B 4.92 17.51 17.1 aD-Sep-200a 6.21 17.62 17.1 01-0ct-2008 6.53 17.64 17.1 . 02-Oct-200a 6.34 17.63 17.1 03-0ct-2008 5.82 17.59 1.7.1 04-0ct-2008 5.13 17.53 17.1 05-Oct-2008 7.49 17.72 17.1 OS-Oct-2008 6.96 17.68 17.1 07 -Oct-200B 6.31 17.63 17.1 08-0ct-2oo8 - 5.73 17.58 17.1 09-0ct-2008 5.23 17.54 17.1 10-Oct-2008 5.48 17.56 17.1 11-0ct-2008 4.95 17.51 17.1 12-0ct-2008 4.33 17.46 17.1 13-0ct-2008 3.73 17.41 17.1 14-Oot-2008 3.79 17.42 17.1 15-Oct-2008 3.07 17.36 17.1 16-0ct-2008 2.42 17.30 17.1 17-0et-2008 1.77 17.25 17.1 18-0ct-2008 1.40 17.22 17.1 19-0et-2008 0.80 17.17 17.1 20-0ct-2008 0.01 17.10 17.1 21-Oct-2008 -0.32 17.07 17.1 22-Oet-2008 -0.74 17.04 17.1 23-Oct-2008 -0.92 17.02 17.1 24-0et-2008 0.14 17.11 17.1 25-0ct-2008 3.05 17.35 I 17.1 26-Oct-2008 2.28 17.29 17.1 27-0ct-Z008 1.08 17.19 17.1 28-0ct-2008 -0.02 17,10 17.1 29-0ct-2008 -1.35 16.99 17.1 30-0ct-2008 -1.83 16.95 17.1 31-Oct-2008 -2.22 16.92 17.1 01-Nov-2008 -2.34 16.91 17.1 02-Nov-200B -2.52 16.89 17.1 03-Nov-ZOO8 -2.63 16.88 17.1 04-Nov-2008 -3.04 16.85 17.1 05-Nov-Z008 -3.26 16.83 17.1 06-Nov-ZOO8 -3.6S 16.79 17,1 07-Nav-200B -3.86 16.78 17.1 OB-Nav-200S -4.14 1S,76 17.1 09-Nov-2008 -4.43 16.73 17.1 1 O-Nov-200S -5.21 16.67 17.1 11-Nov-200B -5.59 16.-63 17.1 12-Nov-ZOOS -5.67 16.63 17.1 13-Nov-ZOO8 -5.97 16.60 17.1 14-Nov-2008 -6.34 16.57 17.1 1 of 3 - . i ( Agenda Item No.7 A . September 29,2009 Page 43 of 96 Well No.3 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVO) 15-Nov-2008 -6.65 16.55 17.1 1S-Nov-200S -7.47 16.48 17.1 17 -Nav-200B -8.76 16.37 17.1 18-Nov-2008 -9.49 16.31 17.1 19-Nov-2008 -10.00 16.27 17,1 20-Nov-200B -10.18 16.25 17.1 21-Nav-200B -10.56 16.22 17.1 22-Nov-2008 -11.20 16.17 17.1 23-Nav-2008 -11.19 16.17 17,1 , 24-Nov-2008 -11.83 16.11 17.1 25-Nav-2008 -12.24 16.08 .17.1 26-Nav-200S -12.68 16.04 17.1 27 -Nov-2008 -13.00 16.02 17.1 28-Nov-2008 -13.44 15.98 17.1 29-Nov-2008 -13.92 15.94 17.1 3o-Nov-2008 -14.35 15.90 17.1 - 01-0ee-200B -9.86 16.28 17.1 02-0ee-2008 -9.59 16.30 17.1 03-Deo-2008 -10.55 16.22 17.1 04-0ee-2008 -11.43 16.15 17.1 05-Dee-2008 -12.37 16.07 17.1 0S-Cee-2008 -12.93 16.02 17.1 07-0ee-2008 -13.74 15,96 17.1 08-0ee-2008 -14.35 15.90 17.1 09-Dee-2008 -14,70 15.88 17.1 10-0ee-200S -14.98 15.85 17.1 11-0eo-2008 -15.45 15.81 17.1 12-0ee-2008 -8.23 16.41 17.1 13-0ee-2008 -10.35 16.24 17.1 14-0eo-2008 -11.45 16.15 17.1 15-0ee-2008 -12.42 16.07 17.1 16-0eo-2008 -12.46 16.06 17.1 17 -Oee-2008 -13.31 15.99 17.1 1B-Oec-2008 -14.12 15.92 17.1 19-0ec-2008 -14.93 15.86 17.1 20-0ee-2008 -15.22 15.83 17.1 21-0ec-2008 -16.01 15.77 17.1 22-0ec-2008 -16.36 15.74 17.1 23-0ee-2008 -17.03 15.68 17.1 24-0ec-2008 -17.24 15.66 17.1 25-0ee-2008 -17.71 15.62 17.1 26-0ee-2008 -18.12 15.59 17.1 27 -Oee-2008 -18.64 15.55 17.1 28-0ee-2008 -19.11 15.51 17.1 29-0ee-2008 -19.61 15.47 17.1 30-Dee-2008 -19.74 15.46 17.1 31-0eo-2008 -20.16 15.42 17.1 01-Jan-2009 -20.41 15.40 17,1 02..Jan-2009 -20.87 15.36 17.1 03-Jan-2009 -21.45 15:31 17.1 04-Jan-2009 -22.12 15.26 17.1 05-Jan-2009 -22.53 15.22 17.1 06-Jan-2009 -22.49 15.23 17.1 20'3 - . ...--. _....'-~ , 1 Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 44 of 96 Well No.3 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 07-Jan-2009 -22.76 15.20 17.1 08-J8n-2009 -22.86 15.20 17.1 09-Jan-2009 . -23.31 15.16 17.1 10-Jan-2oo9 -23.85 15.11 17.1 11-J8n-2009 -24.13 15.09 17.1 12-Jan-2009 -24.47 15.06 17.1 13-Jan-2009 -24.82 15.03 17.1 14-Jan-2009 -25.35 14.99 17.1 15-Jan-2oo9 -25.81 14.95 17.1 . 16-Jan-2009 -26.28 14.91 17.1 17 -Jan-2009 -26.44 14.90 17.1 18-Jan-2009 -26.33 14.91 17.1 19-J8n-2009 -26.49 14.89 17.1 20..Jan-2009 -26.69 14.88 17.1 21-Jan-2009 -27.70 14.79 17,1 - 22-Jan-2009 -28.27 14.74 17.1 23-Jan-2009 -28.71 14.71 17.1 24-Jan-2009 -28.83 14.70 17.1 25-Jan-2009 -29.02 14.68 17.1 26-Jan-2009 -29.47 14.64 17.1 27 -Jan-2009 -29.75 14.62 17.1 28-Jan-2009 -29.75 14.62 17.1 29-Jan-2009 -29.99 14.60 17.1 30-Jan-2009 -30.42 14.57 17.1 . 31-Jan-2009 -31.12 14.51 17.1 01-Feb-2009 -31.57 14.47 17.1 02-Feb-2009 -32.07 14.43 17.1 03-Feb-2009 -31.24 14.50 17.1 04-Feb-2009 -32.50 14.39 17.1 05-Feb-2009 -33.38 14.32 17.1 06-Feb-2009 -33.95 14.27 17.1 07-Feb-2009 -34.28 14.24 17.1 08-Feb-2009 -34.33 14.24 17.1 09-Feb-2009 -34.49 14.23 17.1 10-Feb-2009 -34.72 14.21 17.1 . 30r3 . . I I . Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 45 of 96 Data Acquired: 2/1012009 Serial Number N46C5442 Well No.4 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (inches ab!,ve/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 26-Sep-2008 5,74 17.98 17.5 27 -Sep-2008 5.14 17.93 17.5 28-Sep-2008 4.56 17.88 17.5 29-Sep-200S 4.89 17.91 17.5 30-Sep-200S 6.12 18.01 17.5 01-0ct-2008 6.44 18.04 17.5 . 02-0ct-2008 6.29 18.02 17.5 03-Oct-2008 6.01 18.00 17.5 04-0ct-200S 5.41 17.95 17.5 05-0ct-2008 7.75 18.15 17.5 06-Oct-2008 6.97 18.08 17.5 07 -Oct-200S 5.97 18.00 17.5 08-0ct-200S 6.04 -18.00 17.5 09-Oct-2008 5.65 17.97 17.5 10-0ct-2008 5.S8 17.99 17.5 11-0ct-2008 5.34 17.95 17.5 12-0ct-2008 4.65 17.89 17.5 13-Oct-2008 4.01 17.83 17.5 14-0ot-2008 3.81 17.82 17.5 15-0ct-2006 3.23 17.77 17.5 16-0ct-2008 2.76 17.73 17,5 17 -Oct-2006 2.27 17.69 17.5 1S-Oot-2008 1.91 17.66 17.5 19-0ct-2008 1.51 17.63 17.5 _0 20-Oct-2008 0.95 17.58 17.5 21-Oct-2008 0.55 17.55 17.5 22-0ct-2008 0.02 17.50 17.5 23-0ct-2008 -0.27 17.48 17.5 24-0ct-2008 -0.24 17.48 17.5 25-0ct-2008 0.77 17.56 17.5 26-0ct-2008 0.49 17.54 17.5 27-0ct-2008 0.01 17.50 17.5 28-0ct-2008 -0.57 17.45 17.5 29-0ct-2008 -1.26 17.40 17.5 30-0ct-2008 -1.75 17.35 17.5 31-0ct-200e -2.19 17.32 17.5 01-Nov-2008 -2.59 17.28 17.5 02-Nov-2008 -3.04 17.25 17.5 03-Nav-200S -3.37 17.22 17.5 04-Nov-2008 -3.81 17.18 17.5 05-Nav-2008 -4.20 17.15 17.5 06-Nov-2008 -4.67 17.11 17.5 07-Nav-200e -5.18 17.07 17.5 08-Nov-2008 -5.87 17.01 17.5 09-Nov-2008 -6.55 16.95 17.5 10-Nav-200S -7.33 16.89 17.5 11-Nov-2008 -7.90 16:84 17.5 12-Nov-2008 -8.11 16.82 17.5 13-Nov-2008 -8.58 16.79 17.5 14-Nov-2008 -8.90 16.76 17.5 1of3 - . I Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 46 of 96 Well No.4 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches abovelbelow ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 15-Nov-200B -9.33 16.72 11.5 16-Nov-200S -9.97 16,67 17.5 17 -Nov-2008 '-11.19 16.57 17.5 18-Nov-200B -11.77 16.52 17.5 19-Nov-2008 -12.65 16.45 17.5 20-Nov-2008 -13.06 16.41 17.5 21-Nov-2008 -13.67 16.36 17.5 22-Nov-2008 -14.47 16.29 17.5 23-Nov-200B -14.86 16.26 17.5 24-Nov-200B -15.39 16.22 17.5 25-Nov-2008 -15.86 16.16 17.5 26-Nov-2008 -16.41 16.13 17.5 27 -Nov-2008 -17.37 16.05 17.5 28-Nov-2008 -17.75 16.02 17.5 29-Nov-2008 -18.06 16.00 17.5 30-Nov-200S -18.43 15.96 17.5 01-0eo-2008 -13.81 16.35 17.5 02-0ee-2008 -15.60 16.20 17.5 03-0ee-2008 -17.10 16.08 17.5 04-0eo-2008 -17.91 16.01 17.5 o 5-0ee-200 8 -18.82 15.93 17.5 06-0ee-2008 -19.50 15.88 17.5 07 -Oee-2006 -19.92 15.84 17.5 08-0ee-2008 -20.31 15.81 17.5 09-0ee-2008 -20.72 15.77 17.5 1 0-Oee-2006 -21.02 15.75 17.5 11-Dee-2006 -21.33 15.72 17.5 12-0ee-2008 -10.90 16.59 17.5 13-0ee-2008 -16.05 16.16 17.5 14-0ee-2008 -17.16 16.07 17.5 15-0ee-2008 -18.09 15.99 17.5 16-0ee-2008 -18.30 15.98 17.5 17 -Oee-2008 -19.14 15.91 17.5 18-0ee-2oo8 -19.85 15.85 17.5 19-0eo-2008 -20.63 15.78 17.5 20-0ee-2008 -21.05 15.75 17.5 21-0ec-2008 -21 .66 15.70 17.5 22-0ec-2008 -22.19 15.65 17.5 23-0ec-2008 -22.81 15.60 17.5 24-0ee-2008 -23.12 15.57 17.5 25-0ee-2008 -23.40 15.55 17.5 26-0ec-2008 -23.70 15.53 17.5 27 -Oee-2008 -24.20 15.48 17.5 28-0ec-2008 -24.67 15.44 17.5 29-0ee-2008 -25.16 15.40 17.5 30-0ee-2008 -25.51 15.37 17.5 31-0ee-2006 -25.98 15.34 17.5 01-Jan-2009 -26.43 15.30 17.5 02-Jan-2009 -26.87 15.26 17.5 03-Jan-2009 -27.21 15.23 17.5 04-Jan-2009 -27.71 15.19 17.5 05-Jan-2009 -28.10 15.16 17.5 06-Jan-2009 -28.37 15.14 17.5 20f3 - . I I Agenda Item NO.7 A . September 29,2009 Page 47 of 96 . Water Elevation Wen No.4 Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 07 -Jan-2009 -28.52 15.12 17.5 08-Jan-2009 -28,71 15.11 17.5 09-Jan-2009 . -29.13 15.07 17.5 10-Jan-2009 -29.62 15.03 17.5 11-Jan-2009 -30.02 15.00 17.5 12-Jan-2009 -30.36 14.97 17.5 13-Jan-2009 -30.74 14.94 17.5 14-Jan-2009 -31.04 14.91 17.5 15-Jan-2009 -31.51 14.87 17.5 16-Jan-2009 -32.00 14.83 17.5 17 -Jan-2009 -32.36 14.80 17.5 18-Jan-2009 -32.58 14.79 17.5 19-Jan-2009 -32.81 14.77 17.5 20-Jan-2009 -32.99 14.75 17.5 21-Jan-2009 -33.48 14.71 17.5 22-Jan-2009 -34.03 _ 14.66 17.5 23-Jan-2009 -34.43 14.63 17.5 24-Jan-2009 -34.59 14.62 17.5 25-Jan-2009 -34.74 14.61 17.5 26-Jan-2009 -35.02 14.58 17.5 27 -Jan-2009 -35.28 14.56 17.5 28-Jan-2009 -35.44 14.55 17.5 29-Jan-2009 -35.67 14.53 17.5 30-Jan-2009 -35.98 14.50 17.5 31-Jan-2009 -36.23 14.48 17.5 o 1.F eb-2009 -36.73 14.44 17.5 02-Feb-2009 -37.11 14.41 17.5 03-Feb-2009 -35.96 14.50 17.5 04-Feb-2009 -36.65 14.45 17.5 05-Feb-2009 -37.58 14.37 17.5 06-Feb-2009 -38.02 14.33 17.5 07 -Feb-2009 -38.25 14.31 17.5 Oa-Feb-2009 -38.30 14.31 17.5 09-Feb-2009 -38.50 14.29 17.5 10-Feb-2009 -38.68 14.28 17.5 3of3 - . '.. Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Data Acquired: 2/10/2009 Page 48 of 96 , Serial Number: N46C5453 Well No.5 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches ab9ve/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 26-Sap-2008 3.B2 16.62 16.3 27 -Sap-200B 3.30 16.58 16.3 2a-Sep-200B 2.94 16.55 16.3 29-Sep-200B 3.75 16.61 16.3 30-Sap-200B 4.72 16.69 16.3 01-0cl-2008 5.05 16.72 16.3 02-0et-2008 4.60 16.68 16.3 03-Oct-2008 4.07 16.64 1lp 04-0ct-2008 3.49 16.59 16.3 05-Oct-2008 5.91 16.79 16.3 06-0et-2008 5.31 16.74 16.3 07-Oct-2008 5.00 16.72 16.3 08-0et-200B 4.51 16.68 16.3 09-0ct-200a 4.06 16.64 16.3 - 10-Oct-2008 4.08 16.64 16.3 11-Oct-200B 3.57 16.60 16.3 12-0ct-2008 3.14 16.56 16.3 13-0ct-2008 2.80 16.53 16.3 14-0ct-2008 2.57 16.51 16.3 15-0ct-2008 2.31 16.49 16.3 16-0et-2008 2.02 16.47 16.3 17-0et-2008 1.54 16.43 16.3 18-0ct-2008 1.53 16.43 16.3 19-0ct-2008 1.19 16.40 16.3 20-0ct-2008 0.75 16.36 16.3 21-0ct-2008 0.99 16.38 16.3 22-0ct-2008 0.61 16.35 16.3 23-0ct-2008 0.66 16.36 16.3 24-0ct-2008 0.87 16.37 16.3 25-0ct-2008 2.44 16.50 16.3 26-0ct-2008 2.34 16.50 16.3 27 -Oct-2008 1.91 16.46 16.3 2B-Oct-2008 1.14 16.40 16.3 29-0ct-200B 1.13 16.39 16.3 30-0et-2008 0.77 16.36 16.3 31-0ct-2008 0.25 16.32 16.3 01-Nov-2008 0.42 16.34 16.3 02-Nov-2008 0.28 16.32 16.3 03-Nov-200B 0.28 16.32 16.3 04-Nov-2008 -0.14 16.29 16.3 05-Nav-200B -0.28 16.28 16.3 OS-Nov-200B -0.14 16.29 16.3 07 -Nav-2008 -0.39 16.27 16.3 OB-Nav-200B -0.03 16.30 16.3 09-Nav-2008 -0.27 16.28 16.3 1 0-Nov-200B -1.06 16.21 16.3 11-Nov-2008 -0.82 16.23 16.3 12-Nov-2008 -1.14 16.21 16.3 13-Nov-2008 .0.89 16.23 16.3 14-Nov-2008 -1.11 16.21 16.3 15-Nov-2008 -1.43 16.18 16.3 10(3 - . i ; Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 49 of 96 Well No.5 Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 16-Nav-Z008 -1.46 16.18 16.3 17-Nov-2008 -1.86 16.15 16.3 18-Nov-Z008 . -1.96 16.14 16.3 19-Nov-ZOOS -Z.65 16.08 16.3 20-Nov-Z008 -2.45 16,10 16.3 21-Nov-2008 -2.68 16.08 16.3 22-Nov-2008 -3.41 16.02 16.3 23-Nov-Z008 -3.17 16.04 16.3 24-Nov-2008 -3.69 15.99 16.3 . 25-Nov-2008 -3.63 16.00 16.3 26-Nov-ZOO8 -3.85 15.98 16.3 27 -Nov-2008 -4.77 15.90 16.3 28-Nov-2008 -4.34 15.94 16.3 29-Nov-2008 -4.86 15.90 16.3 30-Nav-Z008 -4.95 15.89 16.3 01-0ee-2008 -2.40 16.10 16.3 02-0ec-200a -2.92 16.06 16.3 03-0ee-2008 -3.37 16.02 16.3 04-0ee-2oo8 -3.57 16.00 16,3 05-0ee-2oo8 -4.22 15.95 16,3 06-0ec-2oo8 -4.06 15.96 16.3 07 -Oee-2008 -4.87 15.89 16.3 08-0ee-2008 -4,73 15.91 16.3 09-0ec-2008 -4.92 15.89 16.3 1 0-Oee-2008 -5.37 15.85 16,3 11-0ee-2008 -5.53 15.84 16.3 12-0ee-2008 -1.11 16.21 16.3 13-0ee-2008 -2.16 16.12 16.3 14-0ee-2008 -2.71 16.07 16.3 15-0ee-2oo8 -3.64 16.00 16.3 16-0ee-2008 -3.76 15.99 16.3 17 -Oee-2oo8 -3.76 15.99 16.3 1 8-0ee-2008 -3.87 15.98 16.3 19-0ee-2008 -4.43 15.93 16.3 20-0ee-2008 -4.06 15.96 16.3 21-0ee-2008 -5.06 15.88 16.3 22-0ee-2008 -5.Z0 15.87 16.3 23-0ee-2008 -5.89 15.81 16,3 24-0ee-2008 -6.21 15.78 16.3 25-0ee-2008 -6.36 15.77 16,3 26-0ee-2008 -6.09 15.79 16.3 27 -Oee-2008 -6.36 15.77 16.3 28-0ee-2008 -6.24 15.78 16.3 29-0eo-2008 -6.63 15.75 16.3 30-Dee-200S -6.95 15.72 16.3 31-0ee-2008 -7.54 15.67 16,3 01-Jan-2009 -7.19 15.70 16,3 02-Jan-2009 -7.65 15.66 16,3 03-Jan-2009 -8.16 15.62 16,3 04-Jan-2009 -8.64 15.58 16.3 05-Jan-2009 -8.63 15,58 16.3 06-Jan-2009 -8.35 15.60 16.3 07 -Jan-2009 -9.31 15.52 16,3 08-Jan-2009 -9,10 15.54 16.3 20f3 . . 1 f Agenda Item No. 7 A . September 29,2009 Page 50 of 96 . Water Elevation Water Elevation Ground Elevation Well No.5 (Inches above/below ground) (feet NGVD) (feet NGVD) 09-Jan-2009 -9.30 15.53 16.3 10-Jan-2009 -9.90 15.48 16.3 11-Jan-2009 . -10.54 15.42 16.3 12-Jan-2009 -10.54 15.42 16.3 13-Jan-2009 -10.89 15.39 16.3 14-Jan-2009 -10.41 15.43 16.3 15-Jan-2009 -10.97 15.39 16.3 16-Jan-2009 -11.62 15.33 16.3 17-Jan-2009 -12.12 15.29 16.3 18-Jan-2009 -11.79 15.32 16.3 19-Jan-2009 -12.12 15.29 16.3 20-Jan-2009 -12.16 15.29 16.3 21-Jan-2009 -13.65 15.16 16.3 22-Jan-2009 -14.00 15.13 16.3 23-Jan-2009 -13.29 15.19 16.3 24-Jan-2009 -14.08 15.13 16.3 25-Jan-2009 -14.32 - 15.11 16.3 26-Jan-2009 -14.34 15.11 16.3 27 -Jan-2009 -15.12 15.04 16.3 28-Jan-2009 -14.99 15.05 16.3 29-Jan-2009 -15.64 15.00 16.3 30-Jan-2009 -15.53 15.01 16.3 31-Jan-2009 -16.11 14.96 16.3 01-Feb-2009 -15.63 15.00 16.3 02-Feb-2009 -16.50 14.93 16.3 03-Fab-2009 -14.04 15.13 16.3 04-Feb-2009 -16.22 14.95 16.3 05-Feb-2009 -17.70 14.83 16.3 06-Feb-2009 -18.07 14.79 16.3 07 -Feb-2009 -17.43 14.85 16.3 OB-Feb-2009 -18.50 14.76 16.3 09-Feb-2009 -18.82 14.73 16.3 10-Feb-2009 -19.23 14.70 16.3 3 of 3 - . RESOLUTION 09- - A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF , , COLLffiR COUNTY PROVIDING FOR A CONDITIONAL USE WIDeR ALLOWS FOR EARTH MINING WITH EXCAVATION OF FILL MATERIAL TO A MAXIMUM DEPTH OF 45 FEET, OR TO THE CONFINING LAYER, WHICHEVER IS LESS, AND BLASTING OF MATERIAL IN A RURAL AGRICULTURAL MOBILE HOME OVERLAY (A-MHO), IN COMPLIANCE WITH ALL BLASTING REQUIREMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE IV, SECTION 22 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES AND SECTION 10.02.03 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY I~AND DEVELOPMENT CODE AND FOR PROCESSING OF MATERIAL FOR PROPERTY LOCATED EAST OF IMMOKALEE. ROAD, APPROXIMATELY 2 MILES NORTH OF OIL WELL ROAD.. THE - SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED WITHIN SECTIONS 35 AND 36, TOWNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST; AND ALL OF SECTIONS 1 AND 2, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, LESS ROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY FOR COUNTY ROAD 846 (IMMOKALEE ROAD), COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA; AND REPEALING RESOLUTION NOS. 99-420, 06-157,07-274 AND 08-290. WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 67-1246, Laws of Florida, and Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on Collier County the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which includes a Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of Conditional Uses; and WHEREAS, on November 9, 1999, by Resolution 99-420, a copy of which is attached as Exhibit E, the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County approved a Conditional Use providing for earth mining with respect to the same property which is the subject of this conditional use petition, which property is described in Exhibit B; and WHEREAS, on June 20, 2006, by Resolution 06-157, a copy of which is attached as Exhibit F, the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County approved a second Conditional Use concerning CUR-PL2009-44 Rev. 7/06/09 i ,~.;"'.'.: ~"'. ~ September 29, 2009 Page 52 of 96 earth mining and blasting of material with respect to the same property which is the subject of this conditional use petition~ and WHEREAS, on September 25,2007, by Resolution 07-274, a copy of which is attached as Exhibit G, the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County approved a third Conditional Use concenring earth mining and blasting of material with respect to the same property which is the subject of this conditional use petition; and WHEREAS, the owner of the subject property, Mining Venture, LLC, has filed Petition No. CUR-PL2009-44, seeking are-review of the uses upon the parcel as originally set forth in CU-AR- 6904 and approved most recently in Resolution 08-290; and WHEREAS, the parties wish that this Resolution supersede and replace Resolution Nos. 99- 420,06.157,07-274 and 08-290 so that this Resolution sets forth all conditions for the granting of the Conditional Use for the subject property; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals (Board), being the duly appointed and constituted planning board for the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of allowing this requested expansion ofthc existing Conditional Use; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission has found as a matter of fact (Exhibit A) that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning aU applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 10.08.00.1. of the Land Development Code; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: (1) The petition filed by R. Bruce Anderson, Esq. of Roetzel & Andress and Margaret Perry of Wilson Miller, Inc., representing the owner of the property hereinafter described in Exhibit B attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein, be and the same is hereby approved, to the extent that the Board hereby grants a new Conditional Use for Rural Agricultural-Mobile Home CUR-PL2009-44 Rev. 7/06109 ._, Overlay (A-MHO) district for earth mining excavation of fill material to a maximwn depth of 45 feet, or to the conftning soil layer, whichever is less, and blasting of materials in compliance with all blasting requirements of Section 10.0:2.03 Collier County Land Development Code in accordance with the Conceptual Master Plan (Exhibit C) and subject to the conditions set forth in Exhibit D which is attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein. (2) That this Resolution hereby supersedes and replaces Resolution Nos. 99-420, 06- 157, 07-274 and 08-290 which are hereby repealed and rescinded in their entirety and are accordingly no longer of any legal force or effect. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of thiS- Board. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and super-majority vote, this _ day of ,2009. A TIEST: DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA .- By: By: , Deputy Clerk DONNA FIALA, Chainnan Approved as to fonn and legal sufficiency: Steven T. Williams ,'-(..J Assistant County Attorney ,.t~ CP\09-CPS-0097I \5 CUR-PL2009-44 Rev. 7/06/09 _.. - "" Agenda Item NO.7 A September 29, 2009 Page 54 of 96 . ;ti :1 . l~l -, FINDINGS OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2006-AR-9699 The following facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorizes the conditional use. 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes /' No - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow - and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes~ No_ C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: _ No affect or ~ Affect mitigated by <text> t3~I'fV\"S l' 5(..tV'"t.4I.! 5 _ Affect cannot be mitigated \ -\0'-1' \ cJb "fU-^-~~,+- C>~. s:-hv ~ D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes /NO . - Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for approval. -., DATE: v~(-o(, CHAffiMAN:iJ( ~ ~Ak- Exhibit A -..--. ... ...-'"--., - ,,<,.-.,-... -.... . Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29S.~OO9 Page 5 of7B - FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2006-AR-9699 The following facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use. ~.- Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes V No - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed stroctures thereon with particular - reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes~ No C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects : .,/ No affect or _ Affect mitigated by <text> _ Affect cannot be mitigated D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes v' No - Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for approval. t ..(- () (' .-:-- .- DATE: MEMBER: I Pv I~ ~""'''' ..-.. -..---.--'" - .-.... .-...-. _..- .- -,"'~~'l" ~ - _.~-....- Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 56 of 96':' 9' ...... FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMl\1lSSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR C1J-2006-AR-9699 The foHowing facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use. 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Lanrevelopment Code and Growth Management Plan: " Yes No - - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular - reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egrey Yes_ No_ C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor eits: \ _ Affect mitigated by <text> v No affect or _ Affect cannot be mitigated D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within di7 Yes_ No - Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with (should not) be recommended for approvaL DATE: ~ /2(to MEMBER: I I ~OO S)~~ffJ\- .. ." _._... ...__.________.,_._ n, ..... _.'. h..... ..___._.. .......-.__....._.J. ..... .._.. ......._~. . _.., .__ M..____.~-..w., .. Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 57 off B -. FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2006-AR-9699 The following facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use. 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affe,ct the public interest and will -. not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes ~No - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular - reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes ~ No - - C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects : - No affect or ~ Affect mitigated by <text> _ Affect cannot be mitigated D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district ~ Yes No - - Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for approval. .- DATE: t 1116 l.. MEMB~~ , It _~ ...,' ....._. ~... .. .....'R... . .-- -_.- h. _.~......, _.~.-<<c._... Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page ?8 Of? B -, FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2006-AR-9699 The following facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use. . ' 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes I No - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular - reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress ~ /,(JIm ftM/1741JA:L- "5tJu11+I!:>tJPfAib Yes V No fJ,te.tJ Ut1J & - - C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: - No affect or V' Affect mitigated by </@fJffYl$ 4- ~f N~ _ Affect Calmot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes / No - Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for approval. .- DATE: U) J / D& MEMBER: AJJ~r7L.., ~ C~ / I .--." ..---'-"-"~ .-... -,~ ---....-... '.~.._--_." ..... . . . Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 ','~ Page 59 of 96 . 8 - FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU~2006-AR~9699 The following facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use. 2. - Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes~ No - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular ~ reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes~ No_ C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects : - No affect or _Affect mitigated by <text>,3f.'~I1).j r..kf!&6Jj _ Mfect cannot be mitigated D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes-L. No - Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, wi~ stipulati~ns, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for approval. \ \ I i ,~! . I I I . I,' . . (' 0 .. [.... t )' f'" )'.' I' I I .. ." ,- DATE: (/ f I It) MEMBER: f .-t:JJ,vj I, I ,~., ...r" ....~ . .~.-...,'_. - __'-',..'-'0,....,.,,___, --~._,.. Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 60 Of? B .- FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING CO:M:MISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2006-AR-9699 The following facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use. 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Lan~IOpment Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes No - - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular ~ reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience. traffic flow and control. and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egres/ Yes_ No C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: ~ect or _ Affect mitigated by <text> _ Affect cannot be mitigated D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes ~o - Based on the above fmdings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (co (should not) be recommended for approval. // / ....... DATE: tf -? t'C MEMBER: 4.6' <::~T ,:';/ /' &. ...t' rQ.?77 ,- .......-- ....--.-- ,...~.--._-_.... Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 200,~ .' Page 61 oL96 4 , .1] .. f. - FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2006-AR-9699 The following facts are found: 1. Section 10.08 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will - not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes.& No - B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular -- reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience. traffic flow and control. and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes~ No C. Affi 'ghb' . . I' . 1 . d ects neI onng properties In re ation to nOIse, g are, economIC or 0 or effects: No affect or X Affect mitigated by <text> - _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes).{:.. No - Based on the above findings. this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for approval. .- DATE: t$' , j-oL MEMBE~ ~--t ", ..---..-~_.---~" -.. '.~ "...-.,-- Agenda Item No.7 A September 29,2009 . Page 62 of 96 . . . . , ,LEGAL DESCRiPTION ALL OF SECTIONS 35 AND 36 IN TOWNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST AND ALL OF SECTIONS 1 AND 2 IN TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH. RAN~E 27 E(\ST, LESS ROAD RIGHT ..QF.WA Y FOR COUNTY ROAD f}46 (lMMOKAlEE R9AD). COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA. . - . , . . 'EXHIBIT "B" -.. ." --- . .. -- . ~ Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 63 of 96 . I PHASE I ~ ~NO IILA8T ZONE DIlLA8T ZONe PROJ1lc:m S.R. 846 lAND TRUST EARm MINE ClISN'n S.R. 846 LAND TRUST Wi,..,II" -~::..- ~ 1'.'500' -'01212007 ,."..". &rFa-' ....... 1/lMJOIt. ~An:fal1CIr . r~~ "'. """8 WIJ:sonM11ltr.lM. "- ..... 0420..000.000 .IHII....,........",.... """'UfIUIf'.1NiIt m.ffI.4Hf. FU zn.IfU4H....... _.....".- -'" ... Mar t .. , EXHIBIT C I ." . .......-.. ---..- ..-.... -. - . ... _-_0. ~~' -' -, '..- I I l Iw i. 'w F tz ~u.i >.. ~, ,_. I;':;" l to "lJ~ f-i. tz "'" .~(~~,. (0 , J ;.s2,",,-:'~... .-,~"'-_._~ - ._--~---- --- "',._,-- " 1 ..-.. ,- -- CC . C":J Z 0 ,I- / (.) lU (f) ~ , .- .' ~ 'j I ~ ' W i lih :, ,.t1 r r~' I r . U" I X; l ,:1 i' ~, I -- .- -- -,.--' ,,/ // , :// " -~,---_.! '''-----1 I I J . I II) ,I ~ t I Ii II ~ I I 1III cr: 04 I ~ III! ~ 1111111 ~ w t~...~~. b co;:) ~ IIIII111111 'illilill 310 I . , ~ G)N ::: 11100.11 ! I t i ~ii2 It.. .. .~ ioe ' . "..... I I I !lliii~~1 ~ N..... . . :.:.: I I, i~ o UJ ~ o .. ~.."., tI 3;1~~~Qn'l ;:)e! (,)0- ~ ~~ ~-- ..",,~_..-- ...~".",,~ ..-, """'"u.",~',_ Agenda Item NO.7 A September 29,2009 Page 66 of 96 Collier County Conditions of ADDroval CU-04-AR-6904 Land Trust Earth Mine This approval is conditioned upon the following stipulations because of the close proximity to Golden Gate Estates in Collier County. 1. The BZA may revoke the approval of this Conditional Use if the approved use or the manner in which the approved use is conducted, managed or operated impairs the character and integrity of the zoning district and surrounding area, or the applicant does not fully comply with or complete all conditions of approval or improvements indicated on the development plan and modification of the conditions or plan are found not to be in the public interest or are detrimental to the public health, safety, or general welfare. 2. Jones Mine shall assist in the formation of a committee comprised of surrounding neighbors that will work together to hire a qualified engineer(s) who will investigate blasting complaints. The firm and/or candidate should be unbiased toward all parties and hired prior to the BZA six month review of the conditional use. 3. The conditional use approval shall be reviewed by staff and brought back to the BZA after six months from the date of this conditional use approval, on the first anniversary of this conditional use approval, again one year after the first anniversary review, and every subsequent two years thereafter to determine whether additional stipulations or mitigation are necessary to ensure compatibility with other properties in the area and to assure public health, safety and welfare is adequately addressed. Development Services staff will use the foregoing standards in their review and in the event of the inability of Development Services and applicant to agree upon additional stipulations or mitigation, the matter will be referred to the Board of Zoning Appeals using the Land Development Code procedural requirement for appeals. 4. This Conditional Use for blasting shall be reviewed by staff and brought back to the CCPC and BZA after one year from the time the excavation permit is issued. 5. Jones Mine shall set-up a $40,000 fund to be paid biannually in $20,000 increments that shall be designated for neighborhood improvements. 6. The County shall monitor the conditional use for blasting, and an inspection charge shall be applied to cover fees associated with the inspection. 7. A $500,000 bond shall be set aside for settlement of any claims for structural damages directly resulting from blasting. 8. The local damage contact will be Mr. Damon Jones at 239-304-1506 or www.jonesmining.com. 9. To reduce the impacts to the neighborhood, and to account for changes in weather conditions, air blasts shall not exceed a maximum limit of 120 db!. 10. Ground vibration shall be allowed up to and not to exceed a calendar monthly average of 0.20 inch per second. Exhibit D Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 67 of 96 11. The maximum load per hole shall be limited to less than 100 pounds of explosives per blast. 12. The maximum number of blasting activities shall be limited to eight (8) days per month and the maximum number of holes per month shall not exceed 1,680. 13. A one dollar ($1.00) per heavy loaded truck exiting Jones Pit shall be paid semi- annually for ongoing maintenance of county roads impacted by the heavy vehicles. This surcharge will expire when the property is rezoned or the conditional use has terminated. 14. The applicant shall hire a consultant to establish an archaeological monitoring plan and make sure the employees of Jones Mine are aware of the monitoring plan. 15. Beginning on the first anniversary date of BZA approval and continuing each year thereafter, the owner shall provide a report to the Collier County Transportation Services Division which wHl include the condition of the roadway adjacent to the -- property entrance, accident reports, and average daily and peak hour vehicle trips entering and exiting the earth mine. 16. The storm water run off quality should not be affected with the proposed excavation area expansion. 17. A twenty (20) foot wide Type B buffer and fifteen (15) foot high berm shall be installed along the perimeter of the operation adjacent to residential structures immediately upon approval' of this conditional use to insure the noise reduction is addressed. Mulch berms shall not be permitted as part of the buffers. 18. To lessen the potential for noise, dampening of the rock crushing equipment shall have attenuation properties/enclosures around the motors of the equipment. If attenuation enclosures are not able to be achieved for other large equipment then an earthen berm shall be installed around the pumps and equipment; up to the height of the equipment being shielded, (Le. if the equipment is 10 feet high then a 10 foot high berm is required). The berm shall be installed within six (6) months of approval of this conditional use. 19. Blasting is allowed only within the "Permitted Lake Boundaryu as shown on the Conditional Use Master Site Plan - Phase I and II. 20. Adequate utility, access roads, drainage, and other necessary facilities already provided shall continue to be maintained. 21. The mining operations shaq be conducted in compliance with the laws of the State of Florida, Collier County Government and the Federal Government, especially as related to safety standards set forth in the Blasting Regulation of Collier County Ordinance No. 04-55, as amended 22. The hours of pit operation shall be limited to 7:00 A.M. to 6:00 P.M, Monday through Saturday to prevent disturbance noise to the surrounding residential property owners. If the County receives any complaint regarding the noise from the rock crushing equipment then the hours of operation shall be limited to 7:00 A.M. to 6:00 P.M. Monday through Friday. The hours of blasting shall be regulated by stipulation number 23. Exhibit D <,,,.,.-.... ".<.<^"~.~_._~"-,.,." Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 68 of 96 23. The hours of blasting shall.be limited to 9:00 A.M. to 4:00 P.M. Monday through Friday. Blasting activities shall not exceed eight (8) days per month with a three (3) second maximum initiation duration with a low volume and close pattern to minimize noise and vibration. 24. The maximum allowable depth of the excavation shall be 45 feet or to the confining layer, whichever is shallower. 25. Excavation shall occur from the eastern boundary and work towards the western boundary of the property. 26. A southbound lane shall be installed to include a passing lane and the length shall be determined on an acceleration rate to 45 miles per hour (mph) or posted speed limit of a loaded dump truck exiting from the property on to Inunokalee Road. The southbound lane shall be built to the standards of the Transportation Services Division and all costs of the construction of the southbound lane as well as the land for right-of-way shall be the applicant's responsibility. 27. The conditional use shall be limited to 800 maximum loaded trips per day until the southbound passing lane is constructed. Once the southbound lane has been installed, the limitation on 800 maximum loaded trips shall be lifted. 28. Upon completion of excavation activities, all buildings, equipment, buffers and berms shall be removed within six (6) months, unless such buildings and equipment will be used in the reclamation process. 29. During each blast a seismograph machine shall be placed in three locations; at the northern property border closest to Fawn A venue and adjacent to the closes residential structure; at the southern property border adjacent to the closes residential structure between 16th Street N.E. and 20th Street N.R.; at the eastern property border between 52nd Avenue N.E, and 58th Avenue N.E. 30. A pre-blasting survey shall be taken for all affected property owners who expressed a concern at the Neighborhood Information Meeting, Collier County Planning Commission and the Board of County Commissioners as well as those who transmitted letters of dissent and existing structures along with future structures that meet the pre-blasting inspection criteria of Ordinance 04-55. One copy of the pre- existing survey will be given to the homeowner and another copy shall be filed with the Collier County Engineering Services Department Director. 31. An approved indigo snake plan is required to be implemented prior to beginning any construction including site clearing. The name and contact information of a qualified biologist who will monitor work shall be supplied to Environmental Services Department staff at the pre-construction meeting or prior to excavation permit approval. 32. Evidence of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) accepted mitigation for impacts to panthers, woodstorks, Florida black bear and other listed species will be required prior to excavation permit approvaL 33. An updated listed species survey less than 6 months old is required for areas of expanded excavation prior -to issuance of an excavation permit. As required by Exhibit D Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 69 of 96 FWC Technical Assistance, follow up pedestrian surveys of each new mining block will be conducted between ?O and 180 days prior to commencement of any mining related activity through the life of the project. The applicant shall submit a copy of these surveys to Environmental Services Departrrient staff. 34. Vegetated buffers shall be maintained around all wetlands. If any of these buffer areas do not include the minimum required vegetated width, a replanting plan will be required as part of the excavation permit. 35. Any other additional or updated environmental permits or information as required in the LDC will be required.prior to excavation permit approval. 36. Provide a 5.3 acre littoral area, suitable for wading bird habitat within the created lake. Construction of the littoral area will commence no later than 2 years from the approval of the Conditional Use and be finished within 5 years of said approval. - 37, All conditions of the original Conditional Use shall remain in effect, but only to the extent they are not in conflict or inconsistent with these stipulations. 38. The water table in adjacent on~site wetlands shall be monitored. Levels shall be recorded and reported to the Community Development and Environmental Services Division every March and September for 5 years. The results shall also be provided to the Environmental Advisory Committee. 39. Additional information provided by FWC staff regarding impacts of blasting on burrowing owl embryo formation shall be forwarded to the County. The information from the FWC shall be provided to the applicant upon receipt. 40. Expedited permitting shall, be pursued to ensure that these conditions are met quickly and to shorten the length of time that mining will occur on this site. 41. Blasting shall be terminated five (5) years after the expanded excavation permit has been issued. 42. Blasting shall be limited to the blast zone depicted on the attached map. Exhibit D ~"" Agenda Item No. 7 A Se tember 29,2009 Page 70 of 9 PHASE I ~ ~ NO BLAST ZONE DSLAST ZONE PROJECT: S.R. 846 lAND TRUST EARTH MINE CLIENT: S.R. 845 LAND TRUST Wi/S;nlliller ~-~~~'~H' llCAU!: DATE: 1"=1500' 10/2/2007 ftC: IVIl': Aae: '"'V NO: PI'llners . ElIgfnllfr$ . EcotqgJ,11l . SItMJYlHS . LlmdsC8pe.Archltllct, . Tl.nspDlt4llon COMal/ants 47148 27 WllsonMlf/er, lnc. PllOJOOT 110. llIDexHO: 04208-000.000 DaWN aYJEMP' ND. 8HQI!T >>0; 32l11IBaU,y18M, SulJ.~ . HllploS, F1~ldD34fD5-fJ5Dl. PMIIIl 23S.~49-4D4D . Ftx 2394.3-64S4 . Wrb.S/Ie lIlIW.~r._ 1 OF 1 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 71 of 96 I ... ". - . RBSOUl'ttON 9t. ..!!O , . A RESOLUnON PItOVlDJNa FOIl TBI SSTABlJSH:WENT Of AN BA1lTHMDuNG. EXCAVAnoN OF FILL MATERW. CONDmoNA.L US! .,.. IN THB "A~ 1UJRAL AGlUCULnJRAL ZONING DISTlUcr PURStJANT TO S!C'IiON 2.2.2.3. OF TIm COWER. COUNTY LAND DJ!VBI..01IM.BN' COD! Faa PROPBllTY LOCATBD IN SBCTIONS 35 AND 36, TOWNS8Jp 47 SOtJrH. RANoa 1:1 BAST AND SBC'llONS 1 AND 2. TOWNsmP 41 SOOTH, RANOa 'J.7 BAST. COl.LIBR. COUNlY, PLORJDA. - WHBRBAs, the tesWaturo ottho StUa orPJarkfa in t'I1ttpter 67-1246, L&waof'Plcdda, IDd Chapter 12!. PJorida S-., hu COIl&lmd ClIl CoWer Cwaty the power to ataIlIWI. -..;..,,~ IIld eatoree ZODhIa and auch huainea ~ It mt DCIllClIIGy tor the prolectioa DttbopubJic; IDd WHERBAs. tIIo Couatyl*l1UDt thc:zero baa adopted aLaa4~ Cede COtdinaco No. 91-102) whic:hincludca a ~~'YtZoaUlI Ordbamc. eltallJilhilll1llpf-cioal1Ortbo zoma, of PIl1icaJar I\!lOIIIpbic divUiou 01 dao County,lIlDOIII which fa the 81'Illdng otcODdldonal Oa; IDd WHEREAs. the CoUler CoDllty PJaauius ~Niaa. bcbas die da11ll{l1lct,Od au COD&W:ated pIamUn, board JOz tho - ...,. afIiIatar.1Luheld . puWic~ aftwDDlice.. ill IIicl n:plationa made 8Ild provicfed. aa4 bu CODIfcfered the ~ otConditUmal UIe"" or Sectfcm 2.2.2..1. ofth. "A" Rural ABrieu1tm1 Zoaius Dilfrlct lOr ~ OIl the PlOI*t)' IulreiDaaer described, and bu RmJ.uI.. 12D8Ullz'ofiiet CBx&ibit wA") lIIIt tadst'actocy P1'OViIkIa IDll ~Fmeat have been made CllIICealia8 all Ipplicable:DWfen Nq1Iired by uid Rlp1aticu IlI4 io accaaIIaaawkIa Sobaec:tiOl12.7.4A oftlaoLaad ~ Codo&rtho Co. Cotmty PllaJdD&c-n..;~ IIId WIIB.RBAs. aU ~ pard-. bceD PYal ~ to be bcItd by th1I BllIllId ica public meetiDI USliIID1t1ed aa4 the BoIIId Itaviag CODIidcnld aU lDICterI ~ NOW, 'IDBItBFORB DB IT RBSOtV!D, BY nm BOARD 01' ZONING APPBALS or ColUer County, P10rida that: J 11lapelilioa.&led. by R. Druce ADd..... EaqaiN ofYCIIlIIt V.. A.aeadeIp. VIICIIdoe ad ~ P.A.,~" the SR.446L111d Tmst. wltha!llpeCtta thepzoperty~cr.cabod I as: , ..r '-=:.. . ~it "B" which ia altIchecI hento IIIId ~-biftftnaco benia i i I I I Exhibit "E" I -1- .- _>M.'_ -~"''''''~''''''.",,>~_.. .....><"- ,..... Agenda Item NO.7 A September 29,2009 Page 72 of 96 I \ '"" ~ 11Io_.-, ........ "'OlaIIIioooIlloo"l" _2.202.3.or 11Io "A""" . Agricul1ma12'.oDiDs D1IIdct fbrewd~_C in IClClClUIuco .the~MUIIlr PIIIa(BUiflit we") and whject to tho litUowma COIIItiticmc !xbihit "D" which j. IIttIChed be:reto md ~ IIyretcrae hcnlD. , BB IT FtJR.T'HB1t lU!SOLVBD that tbia Rcso1uti~ be nconIe4 ill tile miDaIes oI'thII Bod. ! 11J.is R.elalutioD IIIkIptccl after modon. aecoad uu:l majority vote. I ~ DoM ddI at ".. cfayor-b\~_d...lm. . BCWm OFZONINQ AP.P1W.S -~ 'AMBLA S. MAC'XIB. ...... .. . .<a .......... .:. " .:.....,';rf' l /A1T8ST; "'::' '\ i: : : DWI~ ~','ll'tXX. CIedc g ; r ~ ::;i1:!:.', ~ ..~: i ; \ \ . ;. ',.: .....::..,: Do I . , '. Q;"'~"':'" ~'i. j,.;(~~~~~.... ,~~ . . AP;:i~ ' Attest u to CIa'..... Lcp1 Su,;;~cmn-$Ignatlll"t Oftl,. '~;L7>',fJt1.bd M. SIDdeai AsIiatmt cClllllt1 A1tomey I ~WUllaWl'lDH "' - : ';:-:;..';,. . -2- -.. . ... . I . . . --- . IOI'CII) I . I f I . , I ,~ I l<a I , . I I , 0 : I I . . -- . ~ - . -, '^"-^~._'"'~". Agenda Item No.7 A September 29,2009 Page 74 of 96 RESOWTlON NO. 05-!S7 A RESOLtmON Of nIB BOARD Of ZONJNO APPBALS PROVlDING POll nm BSTABUSHMBNT OF A CONDl110NAL USE POll BAllTB MJNJNG wrrH f!Jf.CA V ATlON Of fD,J.. MATBRJAL TO A MAXIMUM D'EP11I OF 60 FEET. 01t TO TIm CONPININO SOIL LA YElt. WHtCHBVBR IS LBSS, AND BLAS'11NO OP MATBIlIAL IN AN AGIUCULTUltB (A) ZONING DJS'l'1UC1" IN COMPUANCR wrrH AlL BLASTING REQ1.JJRE.M6NTS PURSUANT TO All.11CLB IV, SBCTlON 22 OF TBB COLL1BR COUNTY CODS OF LAWS AND OltDlNANCBS AND SECTION lO.(W)3 OF THB cou..IBR COUNTY LAND oBVBLOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATBD IN SECTIONS 35 AND 36, TOWNSHIP 47 SOtrI'H. RANGE 27 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY. FLORJDA. WHBRBAS. tho l~gisIature of the State of Florida ill ChapCer 67-1246. Lau of Florida. ant! Qapter 125, Florida StatUte" has confened on Collier CourIty the powct to establlah, cocmIinate and enfmee zcmillg and sueb business regulatioas IS are necessary for lbe protection of the public: lIJld WHEREAS. the CoulllY pun;lIlU3t theteto has adoplCd a LlIIld Developmellt Code (OrdinlllCle No. Z()04..4I. as lQ'IlCIlded) which includes a Comprebensm ZoniDg OrdinaJK:8 eslllblishing ._iOlll for the zoning of partic:ulllf FOgrapblc divisions of the County, among which is tho granting of Condidcmal Uses; aad. WHEltBAS. On Novmlbet 9, 1m, the Boud of Zoning Appeals Bpproved Resolution No. 99420 for a conditional use for earth mlnirlg activities over the. same property whidl is the mJbjeet of the instBllt conditional use petition: and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning AppeaJ~ bcillS the duly appointed and constituted planning board for the area hereby affected, bas held a public beItb18 after nOD 8$ III said regulations made alld provided, and bas considered the advisability of a co.ndltional use for earth mining, with excavation of fill material to a maximum depth of 60 feet, or to the confining soil layor. whichever i. less. and blastinl ofmatcrialln aD Agriculture (A) Zoning District pursuant to Section 10.02.03 of the Collier CoWlty Land Dev.lopment Code on th8 property bereafter described. and the Colllc:r County PlaMln1 Commbslon has found as a matter of fact (Exhibit 'W1 that satisfactory provision and arrangement hale been made concerning an app1icable matterS required by said regulations and in accorciarlcc with Subsection 10.08.00.0. ot the Land Development Code; and WHEREAS, all iaterest pa11ies have been given opportunity to bt hean1 by this Board In a public mcctina assembled and the Board having considered all mll1tms present. NOW, THEREFORE. BB rr RESOLVED BY nre BOARD OFZONJNG APPEALS OF COUlER COUNTY, FLORIDA. that; The petition filed by R. Bmea Andcnon, Esq., of Rocucl & Andress. r~tiol Mining Venture. UC. and with respect to the property ~ in Eltblbil '"B," attached hereto and lnccrporated by reference hemn. be and the sama is be;reby approved for a conditional use fot earth mining, with excavation of fill material to a maximum depth of 60 feet, or to the confining 1I0it layer. whlcbcver is less. and bluting of material in an AJricultwe (A) Zoning DiRtrict Paptof2 Exhibit F -- . .. - .-.- Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 75 of 96 pursoant to Section 10.02.03 or rbe CoUler County LamllmtcJClpmeDt Code in eccordanca with the CoaceptDaJ Master Plan (&hibit ..C"). and subject to the c:oadilions set fortb ia Exhibit "D." which ia attadIcd bemo 1811 incorporated by n=t'enlnr:o hcnin. DB rr PUR.THBR RBSOLVBD, Iblll this RctoIutJoa be reconfed In fbc IIIinutes of this Board. This Rcsolutlon lldopted after motion, second, ad super-majority VOle. Done tU~day of g.(!) T 2006. A TI'BST: BOARD OPZONJNG APPEALs OF DWJOHI' .E. 8.ROCK, Clerk COLUBR. COUNTY, PLORIDA . ~~ By: ~>.~--" ~ ....: .'~ . ~ At~ at to .Qaf~CIerI: FRANIC HALAS. Chairman sfqn.tur.' OItb : ....JlIIRIVell..lQ tanr'lIIId Iept~ ~~:lv\ ~~J~-+~(JtMD, tr JeffieJ K1.lr.bw ....uistalIt County A.Itomcy I Pap2ot2 , .".. Agenda Item NO.7 A September 29, 2009 Page 76 of 96 RESOLutION Cf1-.:LlL A RBSOUTl1ON OF TIm BOARD Of ZONING APPEALS PROVIDING FOR A CONDmoNAL USE WHICH AU.OWS FOR. EARTIl MJNlNO wrm EXCAVATION OF FILL MATERIAL TO A MAXlMUN DiPI'H OF 45 FEET. OR. TO THE OONFINlNO LAYER. WHICHEveR IS LBSS. AND BLASnNO OF MATERIAL IN A R.URAL AORlCUL1URAL- MOBD ROM! OVER.l.A Y (A-MHO). IN COMPUANCE WITH AU. Bt.ASTINO REQUlR.BMBNTS PURSUANT TO AR11CLB lV. SBCTION 22 OF nm COI.LmR. COUNTY CODE OF LAWS M'D ORDINANCE AND SECTION 10.02.03 OF THE COUJER. COUNTY LAND D.EVELOPMENT CODa AND roR PROCESSING OF MATEJUAL fOR. PROPBRTY LOCATED EAST OP IMMOKALEE ROAD. APPROXlMATEL Y 2 MlLES NORm OF OIL WEU. ROAD. THE SUBJECT PROPBRTY IS LOCATED WITHIN SBCT10NS 35 .t: 36. TOWNSHIP 47 SOtJI'H. RANGB 27 EAST; AND AU. - . - OF SECTlON I AND 2. TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH. RANOB 21 EAST, LESS ROAD lUOHT-OF.W A Y FOR COUNTY ROAD 846 (IMMOkALEE ROAD), COLLIER COtJNTY, PLORlDA; AND REPEALING RESOLunON NOS. 99-420 AND 06-157. WHERBAS. tho Le:gislatuJ: of !be Swa of Florida in Chapter 67-1246. Laws of 'FWrida, and Cbaptcr 12S. florida Statutes. ha$ confcm:d on Colliet' County the power to establish. cootdiDat~ and enfcm:e zoning and &uch business ~gulations as are ne:essary for the pI'O{eCtion of the public; and WHEREAS. the County pl1I'$uant IhcnlIO has adopted I Land Development Code (OrdinlDcc No. 2004-41) whielt includes a Comprehensive Zoning OrdinlllCe estllblisbing regulations foc the zoning of particular geographic divisions of !tie County. among which is the granting of Conditional Uses; and WHERBAS. on November 9, 1999, by Resolution 99-420, a copy of which is auadJcd as Exhibit Eo tho BolII'd or Zoning Appeals of Collier County IIpproved a Conditional Use providing for earth mining with AlSpcct 10 the same property which is the subject of this conditional use petition. wllich property is described in Exhibit Bi and WHEREAS. on June 20, 2006. by Resolution 06-157.4 copy of which is attached as Exhibit F. the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County approved II second Conditional Use Ccmccmillg earth mining and blasting of material with resped to the same property wblch is the subjcc:t'of this conditional use petition; and WHEREAS. the owner of the subjed property. Mining Venture, u..c. hu tiled Petition No, CU-2004-AR~. seeking lOextcnd the boundaries of the excavation; and WHEREAS, the panies wish that this Resolution supersede and replace Resolutions No. 99420 and 06-157. so that this Resolution setS forth all conditions for the granting of !he Conditional Use for the subject property. and WHEREAS. the BoaaJ of Zoning Appeals (Board), being the duly appointed and constituted planning board ror the area hereby affect.ccl. has beld a public hearing aftct notice 8$ in said regulations made and provided. and bas considered the advisability of allowing this requested exp01'lsion of the existing Conditional Use; ltIId Page 1 of2 Exhibit 0 - -. -- Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 77 of 96 WHEREAs, the Collier County PlamlinS Commission Iw fOWNi as a mancr of fact (&biblt "A") that sllisfactol'y provision and amngemOllt have been made conccming all applicable matters required by said reguladons and in accon:tance wlrh Subsec:tion 10.08.00.D. of tilt Land Development Code; and WHEREAS, all intemted parties haWl been given opportunity to be heard by dUs 8.oatd in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters pn:sentcd. NOW, 1'HBRE:FORE, BS rr RESOLVED BY The Board or Zoning Appellls or Collier COl.lllty, Florida, that: (1) The petition filed II)' R. BlUce Andcrson.'Esq. ofRoct%Cl & Andress, ~ng the owner of rha property Ileteinaftet dc:scribed in &hibit "8" attached hereto and il1CQrporatcd by refcmJCC herein. be and the same is hereby approved, to tho extent that lhe Board bereby grants a new Conditional Use for Rural Agricultural-Mobil$ ffome Overlay (A-MHO) district for eaJ'lh mining: CJtctvatiOll of fill marcrial ~ a maximum depth of 45 feet. or to the confining soli layer, whichever is Jess, and blasrmg of material in C011'lpllance wirh aU blasting requirementt of Section 1ll.02.03 Collier County Land Development Code in aceonianee with the Conceptual Master Plan (&hibir "CO') and subject to the conditions set forth in Exhibit "0' which i! attached hereto lll1d incorporated byrefemu:c herein. (2) That this .ResolutiOn hereby supersedes IIIld replaces Rcsofutions No. 99-420 and 06-157, which are hereby repealed and rescinded in their entirety and are accordingly no lonF of any legal force 01' effect. Ba rr FURnfER RBSOI.vm thai lit!, Resolutlon be recorded in Ihe milWleS of lhia Board. This Resolution adopted after morion, scamd and super-majority vore. this ~day of ~p~n .2007. A 1'tBST: DWIllHraBROCK..ClEaK ~ By: lhuh <X..... By. Attest II ~acrk: COI.EM'A. Chatnnan ...... . Page 2 of2 Agenda Item NO.7 A September 29, 2009 Page 78 of 96 AFFIDAVIT We, Michael Boran and Ronald L. Brown Co- Trustees of SR 846 Land Trust being first duly swam, depose and say that SR 846 Land Trust is the owner of the property described herein and whIch is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of my knowledge and belief. We understand that the Information requested on this appOcation must b8 complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required infonnation has been submitted. As property owner; we further authorize R. Broce Anderson of Roetzel and Andress. LPA to act as our representative in any matters regarr:fmg this Petition. /!?f~;f~ ~f-~ Signature of Property OWner . ignature of Prope Owner Michael Boran Ronald L Brown Co-Trustee. SR 846 Land Trust Co-Trustee, SR 846 land Trust ~ fo1egoing in~ was ~ before me this . ~ day of ~ VI1( . 20 i)f . by ~ on.... (. ~,....,pv"" who is personally known to me or has produced j9~"f'7/J...1(? ./-'1-''''- as id ntification. e-- . . ~ Notary PubIie . sa. 01 Rodela M,Comm. __ MIr_ CoIatIIIuIIIl # lID "- The foregoing ins/nmIent was eckno~ before me this f day of ~lAue . 20~ by ft/leAu{, who is personally known to me or has produced as identification. I Q) Al1NlULIE to: _ Cori1mlseIon DO 809638 j'''; ." ~~29,2012 . BoIIdld1bllTtarAiln__~1Q1t .\ . Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Pa~e79 of 96 MINING VENTURE, LLC 3606 Enterprise Avenue Naples, FL34104 (239) 643-3343 The following are all of the business and individual interests of the parties involved in the above petition, as of July 21,2008: PETITIONER: Mining Venture, LLC -- Manager: Donald R. Barber Owners: SR846 Land Trust 50% Michael Boran Trustee Ronald L. Brown Trustee Jones Mining Company, LLC 50% Damon E. Jones, Manager -. - . TOTAL: 100% LAND OWNER: SR846 Land Trust Co-Trustees: Michael Baran Ronald L. Brown Beneficial Owners: HHH Investments, L,P", A Florida Limited Partnership 20% Francis Desmond Hussey, ill 20% Mary Pat Hussey 20% Francis Desmond Hussey, N 20% Sean Neade Hussey 20% Anne Craven Hussey 20% - Total: 100% . Agenda Item No. 7 A Septembec 29, 2009 Page 80 of 96 H.A Street 20% Ronald L. and Michelle M. B,rown, Co-Trustees of The Ronald Brown Trust 12.5% Ronald L. and Michelle M. Brown, Co-Trustees of The Michelle Brown Trust 12.5% Ronald L. Brown as Trustee of SLS Trust 5% Pamela L. Detrick 20% Ronald 1. Brown - 20% Tamara Brown 20% Brenda Brown 20% Christina Brown 20% - Total: 100% BCB Land Company, Inc. 30% Michael J. Boran 33% i Richard D. Craig 33% Richard A. Dykman as Trustee of The Richard A. Dykman Trust of May 9, 2002 1% Michael J. Boran as Trustee of The Michael J. Boran Irrevocable Trust of 2003 5% Donald R Barber and Anne B. Barber as Trustees for The Donald R. Barber Revocable Trust of2001 11% Thomas R. Craig 0.5% Melvin L. Engel, Jr. 11% Verlyn W. Fischer. Jr. and Patricia D. Fischer, as Trustees of The Verlyn W. Fischer, Jr. Revocable Trust of 2002 Dated J 1llle 7, 2002 3.5% James F. Bunnell and Nancy C. Bunnell As Trustees of The James F. Bunnell Revocable Trust of 2002 Dated October 1, 2002 2% Total: 100% - 1 TOTAL: 100% . Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29, 2009 Page 81 of 96 OPERATOR: Jones Mining Company, LLC , Manager: Damon E. Jones Owners: Damon E. Jones 33.33% Ben F. Jones 33.33% Stanton W. Gedvillas 33.33% - TOTAL: 100% , tit 22894eLJ OR: 2396 PG: f1.~c!a*~em No. 7A DCOIDID ill .....LClAL moans of ceLLI" COBentEBnber 29, 2009 ll3!U/9S at OZ:QOPII: DVlCll! I. noct, CLlU Page 82 of 96 _+ DC III 6.00 letl: VlGI SfAlLIt rr AL ftCl 1If I'aR>alID NIIIlII>l:t: WARRANTY DEE!l~~I.{ . This Indenture, Made Ibis Jrd day of A;tH. 1998 A.D.. Between lohn O. Vega as Trustee of me State Road 846 Land Trost Agreement, formerly known as the Land Trust Agrcementdated May 17. 1990 of die County of Collier. SIaIe of Florida, &raDtor, lIIId ~ :;;: li: If i:-=-::S- ~w:-:r" Michael Doran and Ronald L. Brown as Successor Co-TrusteeS to me State Road 846 Land :: = : Trust Agreement. ::: ii :3 .... ... :g=;! - ... ... ..:: of du: Cuumy of Collier, SULlO of Florida, grantee. = .. ~ -- = "" ~ Wltoessedt dIat du: GrauIur. lOt and Qkoc&sidetadon of !be lIUtIlllf 1'1:11 Dollan IIIId Olrulr Guoc1l11l11 Valuable Colllilleralioo. o in hand paid by lhe Ofllll1CC, rcccipl wbereof is bereby ackllDwledgc:d, lias gru&tCd, bargainadldllllUld lD die Aid Gramee "'- -: lUId GI'lIlIIeC's heirs lIIld lIIlligas forever. l11e followillll described land, situate. lying and being in che County of COLLIER ~ ~ SWc of l1\orida 10 wil: ::=;;: ... ~ ae : AU or SectloDs 35111Ul 36. T_,.,aup <f1 Swtll. RluIge 27 East, IU1d ll1l or Sect.lous l1U1d. %, T_lIlIhlp 48 ~ == (...) ~ South, Range 27 Bast Idlln o.UIer Caunty, Florida, less the Wdt fifty feet (SO') or SectIOll5 3S 1U142. : l;" (...) '" ... ~ (...) M ~~~ III lIDlI die Gramor does bcrllby fully W'oItl'll1lt lhe lide 10 said laud, alld will defc:OO lhI: same kgllillSt lawful claims of all penoIIS :: ~ ~ t.::I ....- whomsoever. := ~ <:::It ~ =0 ~ 1'bis is a Deed fwtllll TCUSI'eC of a TlUSllO m.: Successor 'l'rusteeS and is lheret'Ofe: ellClllpl from Florida docum\:IItary SIlIIII{l : == g rl .....__..: ii = .- ~ ~.OO. ~S ~ -(...) ~ ~=~ <II In WllnesS Wbereor, lhe gnuuor has ben:wuu lIt:l his. band and seal the: day aud year fltSt above wrihell. :;; ::t ~ _ SIgued, snIed and ddivered III our presence: ~ S ~ ~~~ ~~ ~Se - . ~' "'S ~ '" -v.' - =~ 0\ ,..., , :""0> _______.--_;- ~~----"'h ---._- '";: - ~ ~. * ~ U 'IoI-.h.c1 fJL ArM..l () ." ,I "'- I.., . Nfl........ Printed ame:Dt t~tO"" LUl: tAl\(" . S WitnesS ~ ~ STATE OF FLORIDA :s Z COUNTY OF COLUER ~ ~ d .n.. /, ?' ," . 'J)e f9rcgolng instrW1lCJ1t was ackllowledgec1 bemre IlII::!his 7 day ofr/~ 1.99'6 by, 8 '2 ,\.> (:r. (/~~r; .wlloisecrsooallYkDuwnromc:orwbohasprOdut.'edhiJI U . -~- ~ ] This Doc:umeltt ~ By: :J;r. ~ ~ . lolu1 a. Vega, Esquire / nted Name: ' p; Vega, StaIl1ey. Zell11ll11 "Hunlun, P.A. NOTARY PUBLIC 2660 AUpon Road Souch My Commission Expires: Naples. florid:l34112 (941) 774-3333 / 'rillS PEED IS BE:t:1IG RE-:RECORDED '1'0 CORRECT TilE NOTAlt.Y B1.OC1C. / I I ~ o ~ . I <:(OHO I:!~; ~ ,....,ocn ;<:;~'" ~ .O~ CZ::s ..... . ONO ",,"'j !g zoiC') , i< eo ENCO ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' _~Ol W to ~ -..cC'O ~ t- "".~ C'OEe. ~Q < "'i~ -g 2 5" ~ @ ~ ~ l ~! ill 0.. I;;~ ~ !/ .~~ b2 ~ ~'f :J.' c:J5 ~~ n ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ 1;1 ~~ ~ ~ a ~ ~~~ ui ~ ! :d .. ~ ;p; H i Hin ~ h ~!il!1 ~! ~ ~ ~i~n ~ ~ ~ ~ ..:~ ~ d ~gi i ~ ~o ..01S1"'!SI~a~~ =>~! aa~~ ., ~ en . ~~ ~t; n hI! i ~~I >- ~ I~ w ~ W ~ ~ - > <D r-: f-- ~ ~ I~ IV t') (J) (J) ~ a Q LL. <(<(00 <( .,., ::) 0 W W W Q: Ii.. "a,,\l ~ 'I . I z al UJ Co",,1l - (() <( I'- N I'- <( 0:: '::l ~\.\. . ~ I N NO U ;;; a\\. is J · ~ -(J) 0 ! >- t')WOW~W::; =oJ ,I! Ct: (J) ~ ~ ~ 9 0 ~ O^ 18 S30\ll~<!3^3 0 i ~ <C z <( <( LL >- S2 Iii! O~..-~ _...J --' S lill o ui= .(J) .~~ ~. ill Z IZIZ..J f- ~ 'n -.. ~~Q~:::>:::> (~ Jll -10f-005:2' t5 I'll O LL(J)U(J)Uf- '2: a i, OW ~ 0 a --' '. CD I'-(J)OJ~<( ~ <( 8 I f- we. u 0 ~vov- 0 Q: I I, <(z::Jw --' UJ LL. CL 9:: <( 9:: 0 ~ ~ '::l ~~ o I IUO Vi ;;; 0(J) (J) 2 ~ ZZ Z ~ . u. [jJ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ala 0 Z .. ~ <C f-f-[jJ ~ ~ 2 m ~ . o ~ · Z i <( , uH R u t{ ~UU~ ~ ~ ~ " R,~ ~ ~~ a!/.~. ~ ~ ~.~ . g s'l u~. 3... I "'~ i5 >- i5 I!:! t:l ItlIX ~ s~ ~~ ~ u~ , ~ s ~" ~ ~.~ ~ ~~ 5~ . ~ ~~ ffi ., ~ tl p ~ ~!/~. .~ ~1J . Ii ~~~ ~ ~ ~; ~;s, ~ ~i~ ~ i~ ~~ i 5 ~~~ Q ~ ~ ~ .~@ g i ~ ". ~.I ~~ i' ~~. ;; S ffi I'.' @~~ ~! H~ ~ M ~~ ~~ ! . Qi'" Z . i' ~ ~f~ ~ wfo '" .~ f ~.~ ~ ~ ~ Q il t.~' ~ .~! ~ i:::~ ~~ ~ ~ :1; ~ p ~ ~ ~;p ~ ~gi ~ n~ :~ g d ! M ! ~ n ! ii I~d! !;n! n:~ it ~; ~ I:.:h ~ ~ ~ i i ~a ~~~ ~ ~ e ~~ . ~~~ ~~~ b2 ~ 2 ~ h ~ ~ ~ Q ~~. ~~~; ~ ~,,~ ~~ ~ ~~~ ~>'~ o fu ". ~ .~~ ~. ~. ~ ~~ !~~ ~ g ~~~.~. u~: ~~Q Q... '" ~~ tal ;:Saw O:t: F t-!liE to ....~... ~ 0 !fillS ......~ ~ ~ ~~ ; ~~9 ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~! ~ ~ ~~ il~ ~ ;: ~~ ~;~ ~ ~ 0 ~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ · ~ .~" ~ ~, 152 ~8 . .~~ ~~~ ~ g ~i i ;:~. ~~! ~ ~ ! i~ ~u~ ~ ~~ ~~. ~~ ~ !~3 5 ~;;~ 1_ ~ ~ ~~ ~ U~iIi ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ j ~~~ @ ~~ ~~! g~ ; ~~~ t ~~~ i ~ 11)"': i . lSg ~ 11:"; :Z% Q e ~~ <.....1-" :Ii =: I=~ - t=1Ol:l II ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~d g i' ~ ~~ i ~f M'"~ ~~~ h ~. ~~~ 5 ~i~ i a:: ~ ~~ g ~~~. . ,~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~~g ~ .. ~~~ .l ~ S,!ffi en ~i. I ~ " "'~ ~ ..iI~. " "If '" .~ "eg ,,~~,,:!~~.. ~1! , .~~ ~ .g~ ! I I , I I '" N ~ m ~W ~N U ~~ ~~ ,0 s, <C 0'> (0 W"" . .1 -I ... i ID ~ ~ i Jl 1'-00'> .!. E!;': - ..- , "., · ; ,- .0_ * '7 zo8 I ;; I obi I ......e ~!.d.i~ "' \ .. rf"JO wzoo I I ..~..."."iI~p.. " Vl ~""i __ __. ' f~~I. ~II > ~ " ~ "'~~ ~ RANGE 2' 'AS1 I ...N)~;Nih I!: ~ _ ~ /' _, . . W_ ~o"' ,_W .1"iII' l :::: Q) OJ ~.~ lSV3 a 'ON"" ii~S I~ . \ I ;~.. .0 CIl iF-;! ~d I.' (~" <0 .g; E 0. !i~ ~ ~li~ i~~ .~'..~ '.~ I .~, I '- ~~i ~ c: .$ I .I;" I .!. :g.~-'! .,.! ~.~.~ tt'~~ 'i ":~..* Q) a. .hi I .e!~.". .'.f ! ....! e..! ~ 9CJ)Q) \ I ~~~..,~:. ~s~~N :;.N '" * ...... I -. .... I I w e 1 ~> I ,~ ~ · j d~~ !Ii. ~ g ~ ''<.. ::~h - l<~ z. · ',,~.., ~~~.~~ ~~: ~ '''). ~~:~~ 5", . ~ " ._~~ ~w ~I;i <?". ~~.U!; ~::! ~~ , ~... ~;~~~~ ID~ ~~ ~ ~ i~m~ I Ei ~ n _~~"'5w I 300 ii< ~d 1~~$:~ I ~"i ~ ~~~ i ilii!!: I .. ~ m I ~ I ~g"~B I I ~ U~ l!.l z ~ 5~b~~ I I I I I g ~..,g _ I " I zu~~~ ~ I 'i . 'i .~ ,~, ~;~ tJ' I ;~ _ _"', _ _ _ __nn___n- -- -- ---in--- -- - - -- --" - --- - -;1 ! Ii , '" J. 'ii' - t .. ~ ~ I I .,0 :3 I N , ' '" . .. ' - I I 'i' I ;i.~ ~ 'i I w 0. I ~::~ N I I ~ "''')''0" I 0. O'~ w II! I ~..~ "'., ';; i.ll ~ t. I "" N - II! z ;~ <?". I '"'" '. ~ : I iiI tt" ~". z z Iii e~ "t. I q,,, '0 - ' 11 , . I..... 5 1 . 'le ! ,. I ~ ",w' it ~ ~..~ii!~ I ~ ~f fl :e I w..: I 1 l(l I gg ~ i I ~m I J ~ ~ - g~ I 1.,..- _' _. - ~ I :': ~ ~ i ~ i ~ ~ ~ · J, ~ ~ i.'" R ~ ~ g g g g R ; e"~.~t ~ ~;~~ I, I J I i I I .!. ~.~~ b! ~,,~ ~ "",mo) __~= ! JNn NOu.:>35 O~ ~ ~ "n><3lN" ".-,,-,,"" ~ ~ ~ · I I I , · i' t f lVNVO _ R ~ . .ocrl.<< ~{ -"" ---------1------' I ~IBB .. ......,.. b , iS~::: . ..... ~ . 'N_ r-: P . · " w . ' . ~~~ I ~-:: . ""~ iae: ~ . I ~ ~ " ~o ~~~ I l>i " ~~ ie I '''. ~ ~~~ : --' " " WO; , :! ._ '" - ~o I <J ,0' _ . o~ 1 : : ;. f ". ~ I , , ~'- " - I : : S ~ '" ~ : ~ \ c. ~ . g I , , 1',' , ~~\ I :: ~-:: ' .~ I I ~~ l__.___.__ g I I 0(,) I ---.---.---,---.--.., I ' : ~ i ~ rl r I (M'Ir:I)OWOU I Ii I . ~.. I ~ I g Ii <.: , ! ~ i i '!I i~' , I ' Iii ~ ~" I ~i I" I ~.~ ~ ;1:: mil .--.- i ) 1 ." ~~ ~ I ~ e:: . I -: H=/=- ~ - - I .~ ,.., _'_0' """ ___ I I =n...........' (9til'~"D)~~ ~ I , I ! . Agendal~t2 . September 29, 2009 Page 85 of 96 -_. SR-846 Land Trust Quarterly Traffic Counts 2nd Quarter 2009 -"'~, June 5, 2009 www.fteinc.l7et 8250 Pascal Drive 7955 NW 12th St, Ste 418 501 E Tennessee St, Ste A 11458 N 53rd StrfJfJt Punta Garda, Florida 33950 Miami, FL 33126 Tallahassee, FL 32308 Tampa, FL 33617 (941) 639.2818 (305) 463-8411 (850) 222-0262 (813) 989-0729 Fax: (941) 639-4851 Fax (305) 463-8744 Fax (850) 222.0221 Fax (813) 989-0731 --.- , - ~; -,- - ! 1 ltl~ ~ ~~ ... ... II> f- r ~, ~~ l! $ ~. ...N Jl. 41: 41:. 0>.... ! 00<'> - 00'" ...N I- .' f- " ~ ~ ~ '... "', '" ~, ::'1* "l<l ... ~ C ... " ~ 'l' ~, ... ..... ~. . ::I f- ~ 0 a (.,) It)lt) , '" w c; ....1/) ;:I; i!: :J oo~ 0 lI. "'" CJ "'. 0 ~ 00 U :1 ~ pj '" :z: Vl Ii: ;:: ... .. 00 001/) a:: () 0: l!_ '.... U') (D ... 0 ~ .. z U 1-0> ~ >00 ~- - I- '" ~ d1 ;:li;l ...0> ". ~ 's c' 8~ c QI .. " " :& "" i~ "? "'''' ~;, It! M ::J IV N, f-f- - O:J ) ~&l ~ '" tijO $ 'V 00 0>'" lD <-'- o!: ::J" "'''' .. c - . ~~ U I-N ,,- ? ~ S; ;!: lea:: c ~ ~~~ ,,. 00 "':1 lD ~~ ~ ~~ ~ I~ lil::! co ~ 0: C' c :(2- " " II) ( -.... (. gill .... .,.. > -'~ II . ON , '" !!II) ;~ ;m '" ~~ ~.. '" =~ 13l ::, W:c ~g III C 0 <z ~ >w 'J;i "5~ .l! :~i ~i ~ fl!~ S W :E ~ ~g::l c N ! !l tl :J U :>QCI: .. ! ~i il 0<0 (.,) uJ I)Ofll .nw lI.l!l:O , - - ;l! ~w~ . I o 0 !2~~ ..~~~!t 20) II ~~ u :(~lI. C 'I';t ! o~~ ;_.~;.~ ~J:! 9WlL . g g Ii I N 10 0.... N "t 1D'0 CD CD CD CD CO CO CO dj'!CO ('I) 0 C') CD 10 CO "tIc:>> , 0 , 0 ~ - 0.... (D~ ('I)NNN('I)"tCD'OCD........"t ('I)I'-I'-."".....'C>>C>>"tCDlPCOlPC')1C) 0 0.... 0.... C)tf11 .... ~;.N........ ....... ............~........... ~ ci:i N u; N g,~ II~ a)~i 0 N...... CD lP '<t N....:...CO C') 10 0 C') (J) 2:o....'..':."t...CO CD "t... "t C') ~ : ~' :,' ~ o 0 Q) N ,.. .... .... ... C') CD ....: "t CO "t It) lP lP I'- ... ID!"t CO .... CO 10 It) C') C') 0 0 CO M M Q) ED .... N;.... ... ... ... .... ... .... N ~iN ... ... CO f.,:. N ci:i i ~ I;:' ':1<1 NO, ... 8 g I · . · · . . . . . . .. ...... ". · · · · · · 0 I ! ~ I a: I ~s I u: CI)(/) I I t: ~ 0 i 0 i en ............ ............. 0 I I I ~ i I ................ .....11...."'....<<0 i ~ I I ~ I ~ : (en ~l ............ ............ 0 I I I 0 I J I I , . I , ............ ............0 I I I.t: enl 0 ! I 0 ill.. I ......<<....<< ..<<......... 0 I I ~~~ i ~i Ii I j' -M~ ! O..JC}l ! I I; ! : ~-~~~ I~' ............ ............10 I j I UJ !e-O........J . en J I I- '" ........ I u.Q.O-.:- '~ I 'i o ~ CJ) ''c, I I, 0 to co.......... ,..... I 'It *- . tl .. .. k ... . .. ... ... tt .. . .. << '" ... .. .. <<: *' 0 ~ " N - J: I I I I ~r:Q. EDI ' I &. I ZJ, l j ! I ,(') (') I'- ('I) I'- N ..,........'.'..,......,......<< ........... '1'<1' 1 0 (')! I ('I) N .... N N 10 CD:'(J) ,... N 0 C') I' 0 COi co ,- ~:'- or- """'...... ~ cO Nj en .::~ or- I 0 1"0 1\; I ~! ~ I, ~ I ,.. 0 CO I'- C') 0 10 N:.:"'" 0 It) · ............ It) N 0 NI II ~ 'N'" .... (') It) ....1C') CO 0 I'- 0"', ED ... e'\I.:........ .... CO 'I' f.,:. N ; Z:: 10 I I 'N I'- C') d) CO CO ..,: N N ... N N ('I) (J) "t CIJ.' ,It) "t CO .... It) CO "t '<t.... I 0 C') 0 , I (') N N... ('I) C') 1'0,0 lP... ('I) '<t" "t co CO.... ".'CO 0 "t 0,... It) lPJO 0,... 0 I m, .... N:N ... ,.. ,.. .... .... ... ... N,'" N ... ... ~ j ~ Ni ~ !~ CO -=t "t 10 0... (f) N..~.CO CD...,... ('I) ('I) N C>>i.n"...!I'- "t 0 ('1).......10 N 1 0 ~ 0 ~ I ,.. ,.. ,.. ... N '<1' I'- ....,-=t It) 00 -=t lP 10 00 N Ul''<t co N (J) 10 It) (f) ... 0 9- 'I co ,...~:~,.-T"",... ,.....-~"'~~N.....,... Q)';": cd . zj ." :'.:i IN 0 ,.. , '. .:, I' I . .' .........,. I' , '. ......, ~ Wz I" · · · · << · · . · · ~! (f) lP (') i>>.......\~;N ... It) co N N (') 0 0 9 "0 11): ('I) co I'- ""I'" QO ('I) QO lC) I'- r-- (f) QO 0 10 0 ,.. .Sl ;;;;: EDI ...., .,.. ... ... l'I.,'N .... .... co.;..: u; ro .:::: O)C/) "":1"" ~,... B 9 I~ ,(') I ~ (') (ij z ':;l ~ ~ () ,..., 17 I *...,. 'If .. .. . . .. .. Mo ,....t")<OO'JCt)-r-COtOO)CX).....MOtn! 0 (")10 co M......O ..... ... J' CD 10 ,.. I'- (J) It) '''t ,... .... ,.. 10 It) co "1 0 co 0 10 Z a:: 0 en "t"": ~ ..- """" """" N:N ~ ~ co " .;.: ~ <0 , .... ,.. I.... w . w , "J I ..J I . i o~oooooooooooo~ooooooooooom_~~_o.~~~ ~m ~ , 0 000000000000 ooooooooooot:_ _ v ~ ... ~O 11:: ..<C........................Il.....................~.t1l01<CQI>Q.lll>1 Eo 0 Ql m N ,..N(')'<tlOcor--oomo,..N ....N('I)"tIt)IDI'-CO(J)O ~ Il. Q. o~ <C C> ~ c55R.... 000000000........... 000000000........ I U &. ~ I I I ~ . gg I~' N~~~~$=.".'1~~~~M ~~!im]~~s;~~;~~I~ \ g g\ g J . o or-- ! Q) ~I<t- ~ -c- or- "I"'" ~ 'or-' ~l'" ~ ~ I <0 "1""') .0 o ..... I 01>1 , IN '0' '.... 0.... II!! 'I ~~,_. ; -.- ~ \ .~' ~ '"~ '" I> " ...... . I 0' ~ g i ~ I M QO r-..... (') -.t' CO'II). !.CD -.t' -.t'r- ..... -.t' C') 0' II)IN C') r- r- It) N ~ It) J 0' J 0' ~ o 0 I' II> ... .... N C') -.t' 11); CD C') It) .... C') (') C') It) ""'lD ... r- It) C') C') ,... (') ~ ~ COl '? C'? C'? II> ; ... .,.:.:.: ~ T""' "I"'" "I"'" ~ ~ 'f"'" .,~r "I"'" or- . r-- ~ CO .... 0 IS: z; : N \ 0' ... I .. .. I ' i ~O i ' "0- I' Os:: ~ \..11..41......". "...".."."."0. o g i al I ~~ !c:enl \ I;:, O'. 0' I"' .. · · · · · · · · .. ............ 0 I . ! . . . . . . . . . . .. ............ \0' I \ ~ ffi \ I 1&1J, ............ ............0'4 1 0' ! ~ i I t I............ ............01 1\ I : ffil I I '1 i i I 'C ' : I I 0' !u.. J .. II tl << ., .. << .. .. ... .,.. ....<<..".. tI ... ... .. .. .. 10 ~ i I o I \ \ I ! 10 len I (1)O)CO ,z I I > ('t) or" 1: 1 r i 'C C'? CO I ' I o N I I Otijrrd, '.! 0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0" ........... '110' I j' r.':CJ.C'? I, ' . -.lJ)mc.o enl Ii! LUIll"O- I enl i I i ti:a. 5~ i;:, . 'I ! 'I 0C!)0) '.r:;, 0' 0' 10...- II- 10'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0" ............10'. I I N "':::C " l' I CO c: a. enl' i : ,r ! z, ;! I I , I I I . I '.. I ' I , \f NNr-NlDO'O...'....lDCD-.t'O' O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'IOl i 0' 01 I C') N ... N N -.t' ~. !'<t ('I) It) QO '<t i ~ 1 I ' al ....'!iNN....... ('I) '(l) N : enl': I.... I 0' 1.,-0 ' ~ I '<t '(I) 0' is: ! OlO'Ol'<tO'NOl...........'NOl'<tO' O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'It) O'~' I ~ , I..... ... ... ('I) '<t CD '<to It) ... ... It) 0' '<t j ~ ...N......NN I:: ~ N1 i I ' .' I ' I I I ~ I N (l) ex) C") ex) QO G.'QO N I'- ... It) ... C") ... N.. .'.'0' N ex) ..,. ... ... NI'-l Ol 0' ~ 0' N I MN_NNNCO..,....NOlCD (CC")C")It)~O''<tO'I'-(l)(l)~(C 0' 0' en ... N.N N'" ...... ... N N ~'N N...... jN ' cO N ol) N , en'" M ~ 0' - I ,! , ,(I) ,": "I ~ ,;:' I" .,., : I- : en It) N 0' co ... 0' N.. ..:..,. M co (C I'- I'- It) .... ('I)..........-'..,'<t (C N C') ... Ol 1'-\1 C") tlll 0' j 0' ~I 18 . __I ... ..... ... N M (C ..,. 10; "'" co '<t It) ..... I'- 0' ..,. lQ,1t) (l) N en 10 '<t M (C , 0' I.(') 0' :1' ~l NN"..........N- N...NNN.,.:.:....i.N........ ~ ! ~ ~ N .......' I ZUJ I ~' ....... .:.:. . . cO.1., (l) N I'- "':.'0";"", '<t It) ..... 0' C') lOll.(') I 0' c:o 0' ~ 'tl , CD: r- _ 0' '<t,N ex) '<t co L() I'- I'- 0' l 0' ~ 0' Q) _ I ..... "". ... N N N'N .... ..... en ' .. ... .. N - ::2: ! ..... . . .' . ... .... It) J!! !~ I..... ,..... B 9 .: '.....1 I'- iii 00 ;:" CD CD U '"' 7 I ........... lQ' I'- "'" ..,. CD LD:M C'? co Ollt) ..... N N g;: 0' (l) 0' 10 g;: ~ 0::..... ..... CD .....NOlO'lQMI'-O'r-It)'<tMCD 10 en 0' ZO 0'9 ~ ~N,...C\lNC'\I"-~ m.. <r- .. W -J:: ~ w <i. !o 80'00'0800'0000'""'0800'0'0'0'00'8 (Ill ""'..!<:-""'..!<: .- l- .... ::c: 10 0000 0000'00''''''0' 0'0'00'0'0'0' 0' c: (Q"" (Q 0'.-; (Q 0 .og O t:: (1)1" ~ .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ., a. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..~. (Q 0 <( Q) >1Q. (I) > E 0 0 Q) co N ...NC'?"",It)COr-(lI)CDO'-N ...NC')'<tIt)COI'-COenO'.......J I a. a. 01- <( Cl ::2: ooi='" 0'0'0'00'0'0'0'0'........- 0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'0'-, U &. :2 I I i . g g II' I 000000 N.. ..,...,.CO .OI.....'.....'CO CO .....,..'...'...'.....'..~';.'CO N 0 0 CO 0 0 0 611'- J 0 c>>l 8 ~ - o ..- Q) .... CO (I) N Il) N,.... CO ~iC>> CO N .... (I) 0 N ..... o ..- 2l~ ..... ~.i.... r,:'j (I) 0..... c.; N ..- ~ ~I ,.,j ";"'1 I ... .... ~ ~ I! i 0 00 0 0 0 ~."".;oo N I'- ~; CO c>> ..,...'...'.~.f"lt "It N N 0 0 000 0 "It 1 J H ~ o 0 I Q) , CD'.:co I'- N (I) CO ll) ~.....::ll) C").... I'- ~ V1 ~ C") C") Q) z '." '" CO . co I t'? ..- 0 s: - .<I:! ! 0 ,.... I ~ ~ i!. · · . . . .~1. . . .. . 0";. . . . . . . . . . 0 I 1 .~s I ~ I I (/)00 , l ' I ~ ............ · 0 · · · · · ." · · · · 0 I 0 I ~ i I ! i I i ....1 ............ ............ 0 I i 51 I !&i , ............ .. 0 . . . . 0 . . . . 0 I 0 I , l I i i I i ;:)i ............ ............ 0 I I 1.- ~ ' ! :'- ! I 01 , . 0 ILL ( It '" .. to .. << .. " tl .. .... .. . .. .. .. .. . .. . tI .. .. 0 I ! I o )' I I I lO I I ~~~ - . i 1 'i:C")C:O 1 i : I O..J~ ! i ,I i i O-mLL.Ol ~ f................."...... ..................*0,' ! I .E: 0 .C") ! ~ I Will as~ i I- as'E..- I 0 , i u..c.. O'<t ::;, _i : i o (!) 0) l.c' 01 j i 0 1.0 "'......... (I...... j ............... fI ... .. <<tl ..,...... tl .. ole .. .,. .. .. 10 : l N...J: I j_ C:OCc.. ,~ I :::l I -I c.. . : I ' : i 00000 or- 0..... 1'oo1.t) ~-~'. ...... tI .. .. . tl .. .. tl,... 0 ~ . I f-j Il)lOool'-~: :;tJ ~ ..... I' , ;:).... 0 01 ,c; ...., I "i) ~ I$: I 000000 I'- M C>> N ~'o ............ M I-J 0 ~ I I'- , I r--r--lOMQ).: ..,. I ~ c>> , I Zj Mol I -' .f ...... I I Ii,; ~I i I , 000000..,...... N'CO 1'-'1'- "It 0....'.'00 lO MI'- 0 0 00001(') 0 ~I 0 co 0 .... I'- 0 Cl>>,(') ..,. 0 0 ....:1'- O'l .... "It 0 0.... I'- ::) ,... ~; ~ ...... ~ ~':' ~ dO ~1 c'; ,... <<!. I 01 .": 0........ ~ li~ Ii 00000 0 ~.".':'."" Il)JN... c>> <<) ~..'.;:'(') ll)......... 00000 1m ~ 0 t ~ g ~ o ~.co I'- N (I) oo:t ll) ;!:'oo:t (') ... l8 9. ~I 9. ~ z I ~:; ~ I ~ I ~, I ..~': I I, w! I........... II) N 1');(') <<) I'- (') N 0 0 0 0 0 .... 0 lOC')I 0 t> I J' ~; I'- ~:;: <<) N ..... ... ~ ~ ~ ~ :: ~ Z (1)0 ' ; ..... I..... I ..... <C 9 I I .... a::c: '"It"" 0 ~ 1 ........... N, N ...."It N N"It 0 000001'" J 0 NI 0 1'-1 \Xi <( W ..... eel <<) 1'-,<<) C') .... C') ~ co ~ ~ w :0 ~ :; ~'" :: ~ I Z' I ~: l!o:2!ooooooooooog:::Eooooooogooo ."",Jo':2!~ ~iU.... o 00000000000 0000000 0 C:w _ w _ .... (/)w t:Gll..<(........................a...................~ .GlOI<(Q)..;;)Q.Gl1 Eo 9 Q) ~CN ....NC')..,.~<<)....oo(l)O.....N .....NC')"ltIl)<<)I'-ooc>>o.....~ Q.~I a. 0.... ~ 0> Z U5'~- 000000000............ 000000000.......... i () as 0 ~ i 0. """) , j . Agenda Item No.7 A September 29,2009 Page 90 of 96 - 0.1 Mile North of Jones Mining Road 0.2 Mile North of Jones Mining Road . Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 . Page 91 of 96 0.3 Mile North of Jones Mining Road - 0.4 Mile North of Jones Mining Road ---- . Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 92 of 96 0.1 Mile South of Jones Mining Road 0.2 Mile South of Jones Mining Road . Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 93 of 96 0.3 Mile South or Jones Mining Road 0.4 Mile Soutb of Jones Mining Road Agenda Item No. 7 A Septembe,o.~9pgUUfl1t 1 Page 94 of 96 Blasting Log Info Peak Blast #of LBS! Hole Particle Date Holes Holes Diameterilnf Soaclno IfU DeDth(ft) Vel. On!sec) PSPL (db) 8/25/06 179 135 3.5 13 35 0.148 113 9/5/06 165 99 3.5 13 20 0.048 128 9/8/06 104 131 3.5 13 35 0.103 121 9/13/06 132 148 3.5 12 35 0.080 116 9/19/06 105 146 3.5 12 35 0.078 121 9/26/06 107 135 3.5 12 35 0.053 126 10/3/06 127 147 3.5 13 35 0.060 104 10/9/06 95 144 3.5 12 35 0.080 106 10/12/06 235 144 3.5 12 35 0.130 110 10/18/06 170 143 3.5 12 35 0.078 118 1 0/20/06 110 140 3.5 13 35 0.065 108 1 0/23/06 195 139 3.5 13 35 0.045 107 1 0/24/06 40 6Q 4.5 12 15 <.020 . 10/25/06 25 60 3.5 12 15 <,020 . 10/27106 259 143 3.5 13 35 0.078 111 11/2/06 100 185 4 15 35 0.048 105 11/3/06 140 146 3.5 13 ' 35 0.083 115 11/6/06 180 147 3.5 13 ;35 0.080 118 11(13/06 263 146 3.5 13 35 0.058 107 11/17/06 78 148 3.5 13 35 0.083 117 11/20106 103 199 4 15 35 0.075 116 11/29/06 100 194 4 15 35 0.048 100 12/6/06 100 192 4 15 35 0.123 110 12/20106 94 155 4 15 35 0.100 112 1/16107 131 161 4 17 30 0.098 108 3/6/07 132 132 3.5 14 35 0.185 117 *6/20/2007 78 78 4.5 15 19 0.088 113 6/22/07 78 71 4.5 15 19 0.065 110 6/29/07 76 155 4.5 17 30 0.165 116 7/3/07 69 155 4.5 17 30 0.148 118 7/9/07 101 70 4.5 17 20 0.083 104 7/17/07 96 70 4.5 17 20 0.060 106 7/19/07 99 70 4.5 18 20 0.055 106 7/24/07 99 70 4,5 18 20 0.073 107 8/9/07 69 139 4.5 18 30 0.133 110 8/15/07 69 129 4,5 18 30 0.178 115 8/21/07 94 135 4,5 18 30 0.153 112 8/27/07 89 99 4.5 20 25 0.100 111 9nt07 78 75 4.5 18 20 0.090 107 9/13/07 43 60 4.5 18 20 0.070 108 9/19/07 70 51 4.5 18 20 0.055 105 11/30107 40 30 4.5 20 15 0.043 103 12/13/07 40 25 4.5 18 15 0.093 113 12/13107 40 50 4.5 18 25 0.115 112 2/21/2008 20 30 4.5 20 15 0.038 104 2/21/2008 20 30 4.5 20 15 0.043 100 2/21/2008 20 30 4.5 20 15 0.033 94 2/21/2008 20 30 4.5 20 15 0.043 92 2/28/2008 10 48 4.5 20 20 0.043 105 2/28/2008 12 48 4,5 20 20 0.045 105 Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 95 of 96 2/28/2008 12 48 4.5 20 20 0.038 104 2/28/2008 ' 12 48 4.5 20 20 0.040 111 3/20/2008 28 48 4.5 20 20 0.078 110 3/20/2008 28 48 4.5 20 20 0.055 116 .3/20/2008 28 48 4.5 20 20 0.060 111 3/24/2008 25 48 4.5 20 20 0.068 111 3/24/2008 25 48 4.5 20 20 0.055 109 3/24/2008 24 48 4.5 20 20 0.045 110 3/27/2008 21 48 4.5 15 20 0.048 107 _ 3/27/2008 23 48 4.5 15 20 0.050 101 3/27/2008 23 48 4.5 15 20 - 0.058 101 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0.053 100 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0.063 92 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0.068 92 4/4/2008 21 48 4.5 20 20 0.048 90 4/10/2008 35 60 4.5 20 25 0.063 106 4/10/2008 28 60 4,5 20 25 0.115 112 4/17/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 0.063 115 4/17/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 0.100 114 4/17/2008 28 60 4.5 20 25 0.100 112 4/28/2008 28 ' 60 4.5 20 25 0,080 110 7/10/2008 40 60 4.5 20 25 0,108 101 7/10/2008 40 60 4.5 20 25 0.068 106 10/7/2008 40 50 4.5 15 25 0.078 107 10/9/2008 34 60 4.5 20 25 0.085 113 10/15/2008 36 60 4.5 20 25 0.073 111 10/23/2008 48 60 4,5 20 25 0.123 111 10/23/2008 39 60 4.5 20 25 0.078 101 12/8/2008 27 60 4.5 20 25 0.073 111 - 12/8/2008 35 60 4.5 20 25 0.115 114 3/6/2008 20 60 3.5 18 25 0.050 106 3/18/2009 43 60 3.5 18 25 0.088 113 3/18/2009 47 60 3.5 18 25 0.100 119 3/23/2009 40 60 4.5 15 25 0.065 110 3/23/2009 48 50 3.5 18 25 0.090 112 3/26/2009 40 60 4.5 15 25 0.120 104 3/26/2009 48 50 3.5 18 25 0.133 111 4/1/2009 44 50 3.5 18 25 0.058 113 4/1/2009 44 60 4.5 15 25 0.135 111 "Florida Drilling & Blasting (Roger Nunez) took over blasting duties ** PPV cannot excees monthly avg of 0.20 (Collier County) or 0.50 at any blast per State *** PSPL cannot exceed 133db on any blast per State Agenda Item No. 7 A September 29,2009 Page 96 of 96 t8D · Sunday, September 13, 2009 · Naples DaBy News ~",,"'''',-, ~'"~"""-.-.'.~' "":-:~m'_"",<~_'''''_W'''_;'''_''''''_''''';''''~' . .., '. .........-.--........"...,."""...-..,.w,._"...w,,'........,'..,. ,...._'....._.,.........'~. ......'..........,."...m.."....__w._,.....,..... .'""...~<__"......_.'___.'M..,.__.""N"_'~'.......;.,..........:;y.... NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING i '. . Notice is herebt given that the Board QfCountyCommission~. ~ the Board of Zoning Appeals, of Col ier County will hold a . public hearinQ on Tuesday, eptember. 29. 2009.. in .theBoardroom, 3rct Floor; Administration Buildin!J, Collier County Government Center. 3301 East Tamiami Trail. NaJ>les. Florida. The meetmg will begin at 9:00 A.M. The title of the proposed resolution Is as follows: ' , A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD 'OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY PROVIDING FOR A CONDITIONAl USE WHICH ALLOWS FOR EARTH MINING WITH EXCAVATION OF FILL MATERIAL TO .A MAXIMUM DEPTH OF 45 FEET. OR IO_JHECONFJNING .LAYER, WI{JCHEVER IS LESS, AND BLASTING OF MATERIAL .IN A RURAL AGRICULTURAL MOBILE HOME OVERLAY (A-MHO), IN COMPLIANCE WITH ALL BLASTING REQUIREMENTS PURSU. ANT TO ARTICLE IV,' SECTION' 22' OF. THE COLUER COUNTY CODE. OF. I.:AWS AND OROI- 'NANCES"AND SECTION 10.02.03 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AND FOR PROCESSING OF MATERIAL FOR PROPERTY. LOCATED EAST OF IMMOKALEE ROAD,APPROXIMATELY 2 MILES NORTH OF OIL WELL ROAD. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY, IS 'lOCATED WITHIN SECTIONS 35 AND 36, TOWNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST; AND ALL OF SECTIONS 1 AND 2, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, lESS ROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY FOR COUNTY ROAD 846 (IMMOKAlEE ROAD), COllIER COUNTY. FLORIDA; AND REPEAL. INGRESOLUTIONS' NOS.. 99-420. 06-157, 07-274 AND 08-290,. ... , Petiti'on: CUR-P12oo9.044, SR 846 Land Trust,. represented by R. Bruce Anderson of Roetzel and Andress VA; and Margaret Perry, AICP, of Wilson Miller. Inc., requesting a 'Condition- .al Use Re-review (CUR) 01 the property 'commonly referred to as Jones Mine. The ,condi- tional use (CU-2004-AR-6904) was approved on September 25, 2007 and in. accordance with condition #3. the. Conditional Use approval shall be reviewed by staff and brought baclc to the BZA on the first anniversary of approval and again one reear after the first an. niversary review. The subject property is located at 16000 Immoka ee Rd., Sections 35 & 36, Township 47 South. Range 27 .fast, and Sections 1 & 2. Township 48 South, Range 27' East, Collier County, Florida. . , NOTE:. All Persons wishing 'to speak on any agenda item mUst register with the County Administrator ,prior to . presentation of the 'agenda item to be addressed. .Individual speakers will be limited to 5 minutes. on any item. The selection of an individual to speak on behalf of an ,organization or group is encouraged, If recognized by the Chair, a spokesperson fOr a group or organization may be alloned 10 minutes to speak'on an item. . Persons wishing to have written or !lraphic materials included in. the Board agenda~ack- ets must submit .said material a minimum of 3 weelcs prior to the respective ~ubliC ear- inni In an~ caSe. .written materials intended to be considered by the Board- all be sub- m ed to t e appropriate County staff a minimum of seven days prior. to the public hear- ing. All mater\al used in presentations before the Board will become a .permanent part of the record, . . ' Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the Board' will need a record of the pro- ceedings pertaining thereto and ,therefore, may heed to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made; which record includes the testimony and evidence. upon which the appeal is based. . " . " ,. '. If you are a person with a disability .who needs any accommodation in order to partici- pate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain as- sistance, ~Iea~e c~ntact .the .CC?lIier count~ Faciliti,es Mana~ement Pepartment,locat~d at 3301 Tamlaml Trail East.. Bulldmg W, Nap es, Flonda 3411 . (239)252-B380. Assisted listen- ing devices for the hearing impaired are available in the County Commissioners'Office, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLUER COUNTY, FLORIDA DONNA FIAlA, CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E.BROCK. CLERK B~ Martha Vergara; Deputy Clerk (5 l) , Spntpmhp:r 13 700Q NolB14Rll6 "'