Resolution 2004-379
178
RESOLUTION NO. 04- 379
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY RELATING TO
PETITION NUMBER VA-2004-AR-6140, PINE RIDGE
CENTER PUD, REQUESTING A VARIANCE TO
REDUCE THE IS-FOOT EXTERNAL PUD SETBACK
FOR THE WESTERN PUD BOUNDARY OF THE PINE
RIDGE CENTER PUD; AND THE EASTERN PUD
BOUNDARY OF THE PINE RIDGE CENTER WEST
PUD TO PERMIT A O-FOOT SETBACK FROM THE
COMMON PUD BOUNDARIES DUE TO THE NOW
COMMON OWNERSHIP OF BOTH PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENTS, LOCATED IN SECTION 18,
TOWNSHIP 49, RANGE 26 EAST ON PROPERTY
HEREINAFTER DESCRIBED IN COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA.
WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida
Statutes, has conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and
enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the
public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code
(LDC) (Ordinance No. 2004-41) which establishes regulations for the zoning of
particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of variances;
and
WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals, being the duly elected constituted
Board of the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said
regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of a variance to
reduce the IS-foot external PUD setback for the western PUD boundary of the Pine
Ridge Center PUD; and the eastern PUD boundary of the Pine Ridge Center West PUD
to permit a O-foot setback from the common PUD boundaries due to the now common
ownership of both Planned Unit Developments, as shown on the attached plot plan,
Exhibit "A", in two "PUD" Zones for the property hereinafter described, and has found as
a matter of fact that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning
all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Section 9.04.00
of the Zoning Regulations of said Land Df~velopment Code for the unincorporated area of
Collier County; and
WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this
Board in public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered all matters
presented.
178
.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that:
The Petition V A-2004-AR-6140 filed by D. Wayne Arnold, AICP of Q, Grady
Minor and Associates, representing Pine Ridge Investors of Naples, LLC with respect to
the property hereinafter described as:
Exhibit "B"
be and the same hereby is approved for variance to reduce the 15-foot external PUD
setback for the western PUD boundary of the Pine Ridge Center PUD; and the eastern
PUD boundary of the Pine Ridge Center West PUD to permit a O-foot setback from the
common PUD boundaries due to the now common ownership of both Planned Unit
Developments, subject to the following conditions:
Exhibit "c'
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to Petition Number
V A-2004-AR-6140 be recorded in the minutes of this Board.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote.
Done this
day of
,2004.
ATTEST:
~ . ,. '. '
DWIGHT J~:'PJR'(')G~,CLERK
,,~',,':\t:J~ 'ÎBD~,~n "" '
,~.. ~,~\ .i.........~.,......'" itV <z,F..,
.....:: ....~ ... r"f--". .".;41 ....,....
.::: ".- f....·~~·,"";""~... ",:t' " CO, ~
. ff - :~"'_:,..' "',}/ '/" -,,~. {\ ',. ~ ':'¿
-. ,- .,
At.tt.~r.· ca'i~ .., J
t .4.. ~}", ~1 ~.. , \\ " . coJ.:
S i."~~..~.~_qtt .,'l,iJrr ....(C?l·
Appt.O'V.' ~..'. ~ .tQ Otm. .,,~..;.< <'."
. ":." " -"..:... ~('\)\~ ........
and Legal. OOtå~~~""
;IJ ;'<¡~H.~.·\I~~
I DC.. '
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY: ~ ~ d4~
DONNA At!.., AIRMAN
t
'Æ (ttA_J 'g ,'õâJ . ,!Jt¿uftd
Marjorie . Student
Assistant County Attorney
V A-2004-AR-6140/RM/sp
ItemN J '7 ß
~~~;da I Z. . t Lt· O'f
~:~d 5· b -0'.5
2
.~ I ~~~~I)III:I
. .~
\llJæH 'J..J.H1OO II!!rnOO
~~JIJ':,;J.$1t\II :r0lJlll3NId f . ~i :(
~~^ I h
. . iiII
- ~'J'-
= . ~~.. .1It _ -. - _ ----- _ III ~
~-~;".~- - --
--.... ~ ----z.~ -,- - ---- a. ~
IIIIi "" 110 III'" :!! i
~
ITì'---'
I ' !
!
"-"-"-"~'-"l-"'A
I
i
!
~ tM*~"'H ~
v- .....~.~~---ø
I I œ
~ I
I I
I "
I !
.
M4 ~11:1Q (U¡ !o9 'hIJ'~, ¡tt.oqP;D
Exhibit "A"
178
~
3RANT FRIDKI~., :- - ',RSON,
ATHAN & CRC-'·.·'! P.~.
·SS1 Ridgewood 011\' SI,nte 501
;J Naples. Aorida 341 08
3316421 OR: 3468 PG: ;J.9f' EJ
DeGRDID 11 ontCIAI. RlCORDS of COWl. tmTI, rL
12/19/2003 It aZ¡3'PK DIIGRf I. 'lOCI, CLlII
COIS 2'25000,1'
dC m 15.00
DOC-.70 11375.'D
;o'!/v
\ 5
<11}\ This Instrument Prepared By:
\ 0 John PauUch ill. Esq.
l./Ì) Paulich Slack & Wolff, P.A.
v 801 Anchor Rode Drive, Suite 203
Naples, FL. 34103
Iletu:
GUft !aIDIt. IT AI.
5551 IIDGliDOD DR ,5Dl
lULlS n 3mB
Parcel LD. Numbcr(s): 0023740000.9
THIS WARRANTY DEED made the ¡¡r1:; day of December, 2003, by
PINE RIDGE
company
orida Iimlted liability
whose postoffice address is
See PARCEL 1 of Exhibit "A" attached hereto
GRANTOR WARRANTS THIS IS NOT HOMESTEAD PROPERTY OR CONTIGUOUS
THERETO. TIllS IS VACANT LAND.
TOGETHER with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging
or in anywise appertaining.
To Have and To Bold, the same in fee simple forever.
And me Grantor hereby covenants with said Grantee that the Grantor is lawfully seized of
said land in fee simple; that the Grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said
land; that the Grantor hereby fully wamnts the title to said land and will defend the same against Ihe
V A-2004-AR-6J40
PROJECT #19990239
DATE: 7/2/04
ROBIN MEYER
. - I ( -
8Y\\b\"\ b
'" ~.. ,.. ,. -... Y Y I ". ~ ." ''''
.... '" "' " . ........,.... "J ...' ..-
t...... o.¡ , I ~
..
OR: 3468 PG: 19~ 7 B
"'
.
lawful claims of all persons whomsoever; and that said land is free of all encumbrances. except taxes
accrning subsequent to December 31, 2003; and subject to all easements, restrictions and
reservations common to the subdivision.
In Witness Whereof, the said Grantor has signed and sealed rhese presents the day and year
first abQ-vc written.
Signed, sealed & delivered
in our presence;
.
(~~ JiÆ",Jj;j
W: ess #1 Signature
NA~>f é'uç,;) 's/Lt"Cf?TI.t
Wìtn~ #1 Printed Name,
~JM~
Witn Si atu~
~ 1"1 ( L/-A,,(
Witness #2 Printed Name
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF COUlER
The fOTcgoing ins
by AnthoDY F. Jancigar, IndIVI
produced driver's license as identi 1
My Commission Expires:
HANCVK.UI() MIWN
Ilf 0Qf.WISSI0N 'CC G89111
ÐlPØleS: FebIuIIy &. 2005
1MMId1llov IIoWt Nk...........
-. .. .. -.....
þ
. .
I .. '.~
. - ~ -", -
~"
. .
tt* OR: 3468 PG: 1941 *r B
..
49 lamb. RIup 26 East, Cok Cødt.1'1œidf.
J1IIt N 19' 34' W B 1219.76 !oct;
G of 1IIc paaœI of Iað
"11 UDc otÞ1lø 1Uc1p RoId
~ GO·.JUØI:\ a QaW ro 1bc 1cft
,ID 1aJ¡1h ot:2d'-OS ..-..
111iPc; thaaø S ocr Z4' 3r E
10 ~ d¡bt.......ndius
.16 fee\ .. .... which
. 21' 55" 11 3S.~ fMt W 1b:
1-.
..
,
11/12/~Z lz:aC PAX 941 434 0338 RI~'~ ;D~"~I·
_. tV EARSeN':" ............... IA"'.~' ..
o \Øt1A~T. FAIOKlI'4-, " ,
.. t, ATHAN & CROWN, P.A.
\ " 5551 Rldgewood Drive. Suite 501
\'" NapleS, Aorida34108
,
~J)Om_~IWII~'" RdII'rn WI
Þoa&14 K. WtA.. , .:n::
....~ ~¡p: :Þe:!.t:';Ue. ~= .. ao.., P.......
:s~. ~t;h .~..t 1!fOZ:'t:h
1!hõIóI-\\IIt 3100
~_., F.ü 34102
3316420 OR: 3468 PG:
UCORDID in DlUCIAL IICOIDS of COUnt coum, It
12119/2001 at 11:35PI DIIGHT I. BlOCl, CLlRI
co.a 2625000,00
DC n1 15.DD
uec·,70 1837S.DO
lrB
tþ
,,~m t'llImbtin OO~B7:520D02
Ret1l:
GWI !lIÐllllf IJI
5551 lIDGlWOOD DR '501
'Warranty Deed IlAPLlS n mOl
Db IndePtarc, ~odl;. 11,; ða¥of 1).~J: , 2003 A.a., BBtWHA
:E'e~;C LOÞg'O, . -..xz::Leå m.an, aAc1 ~2::J.% D. x.oDg0, a maz::.:-.:l.ci Woa&¥L,
eaoh as to an uad.:i.v.:ldec1 one-ha1:£ .i.nt:ezoe.t:.,
of'lM co...., or Cu)r~09'. ,!haW of OÀi..o ,EI'lIDtoI'W, MIl
1i':in- Jd,clqa %'A~.i:o'l:'l5 oe ._1>10., u.c, . :J!"1o~:Lc!& ~;i..zU.t:;ed. 1:Lab:i.:u.t::y'
coapa:p~
""**' IðdIwa Ir-
or IIw c-w of
.
IIwœ of' 1i'1oS':i.d&
, ....tce.
S~j.et:. bO ~..~.:le~b.
and. t:á:Ke. .ub..qGeD~
o;rb.e Jiin'=opu:ty Mza:i.D
P:a:!CII5"II;r:i:3r o€ 1::b.e G&'.n
o~ G~ t:QZ'. !Ir.ha G:.:&..
1)2;i.."., coaClC:O~d., OD ..
440..0(Ano).
':t"B1:S :r:s ~!n ~.
z:oec::oz:oc!, ;I.J! any,
tme øaa:ø'.I!JIAD
t!I BOMJC.~ pa::opel:'CY
:UU5 z.g1. 1U.dø'o
:Lazae , 1IIa1.. td.1~., 0&
..... "'" .-1oQ clo 1Mnb)f ~11)' W,IIId1d Q:la daa IØ said 1-. a.olt will ,,~ Ibe -. a¡pãut 'Worlb1 c1&\D1t ot .u ~ ",,,,,,,",""_.
~__..,........._..... _ CIIII5)"""- _n.....w
. -... .. -..
12/~2/2003 12:$~ FAX 9414~4 O~~.
atCRMAN ÐBIFIK LANIER...
OR: 3468 PG: 19i'7 B
.
-
..
. Warranty Deed -1'... 2-
hrèII UI "\)...... OQ2.8?5200 02
"....... "
~"-""''''~='''ij--~. .~..~-: .~.;
~~:e LCI1l:~'~ " ., :
1'.0. ~'øH Þf\8 ~ ~ c:oaøwd. 011: ......-n; ,';-' "
".- .
, .
. "
'.
. .. ,_... ~'- ,.~ ....
,,- .
~ Of' f- .'
.... 1 \"
"t'"
- ..., .."
'.
.' "''(Seal)
,- . I
~~~..~ ;.,,' ...,
."
C>
~
('.
.". .
STA.TE OF ()b.:!.o
coUNTY OF
-n- ..,..-.. ~ _ .daIøw~1IId II
~~ ~90r ..~:S--
'I¥bo b ~~1d_OI'...mo1lD k'
J:h.~;¡C
~ . p- ...
~ 20Ð~' . . tri..··'
STATE OF <j.hj,o LA
COUNTY OF C vvft1'Ö(A(
Th. IbnpIq ~- ~
~Z'1.y D. ~~, .
bY
WIaø 1-& p--..zl.y Þowa 10 _ ~wtao.... ~
ci .~:
PabJ,:l..ð
....... ibv;"'1 PÂTRlCIA... L..AWL!Y.AIIonwt
NOTAR't' PUBlIC. STATE: Œ 0HIó
My CommIsIIon Has Noedt. 0.
O.R.c. SedIon 141.oa
,,, ,:a 0'7
..-~""D~ -,-.,..... _ (IIft)'JDotiIS ~ft._
-.- . .-
I ___
-....
. I - :~r: ..::~~~~::_l:-.:~::~~
. .r:,
. ~
.
EXHIB!,T If A II
. ~tt OR: 3.46.8 PG: 191.*" e
, '.
..
, :
to
.
....ñ;&st on&:haIf(B K) ~ftbe West ODe-half(W K)oftb.eNortba.ñone.-qUBW£{tœ v.) &;f1hc:
Nortb'M:at ODC.quartc:r (NW ~) of StlGtion 1.~ Tovœship -49 s~ }œ¡p 2Ci P.Iut. Co1Hø
County, FIoddl, == puticuWY deøcn"bcd II foUOVt'B:
" ,... U,. Thøtp'ortlob.of'thcEasthaJtoftbeW.11à.1foi1heN~.tJflñcN~~oI
SKtiOl1 II, 'ToWQsbip 49 Souths R.an¡c: a E'ut, èoniC:l countY. f1oGd~ 1)io¡,Sout1a of Pine ..; '. "\ .
RJdp Road c.L No. 1!16; bd:n¡ matt pDl11C111trly destnDed is foUo'WS1
Çomm~ at the NOI'IhWlSt comer of Section II, Tovms!dp 49 South. 1WJ¡e ~ Bøt. Caw. .
Cumd7. fJœtda;.~I1JDNorth 89° 33t 3P-E..staloq tbeNorth line ofsåd &d1cm 11 for I
distance of 1,60',34 f= 10 .. Nortbwm ecmar of.. But 1IøJf Dt t1se Wc:II bill of 1bc
NOItbeut qUIrta' aftbe }«mhweø q1J1Irta' of laid SCGtion 18~ fbrJøçe; 1'\IÞ Soath 00' 21' 4811 Ear
ùoøg 1bo west'llao gf1he EuthaJt'of1Ja West·hølfuftbo Northeast q1W1cr oftbo NOtIhWest
quattr.r of said Scotioa 18 for . dJs1gcc of'139,47 feet to t'bII Søri1crly d¡ln..o$.'\fty ~ of Bt*
RoIIð No. 8-19ð' (PIne æ. Rœd), 1150.00 loot tigbt-ot'"W&y, q1h& IIIQJI4 úebovm an FIaride.
DepIØtmr.D1 o1"Traupotta1iou Right4W1)' Map for S1da Road ND. B..895, ScedoI1œSQ4.260!~
eoma- Couu\y, Sheeb 5 and 6 of J3J ad The fOINT OP BBOINNINO of1be paœ1 oflml
. hemiD deøtti~d; d&eDcc: çantinuc S along thè West tiœ of the Eøt b.Ilf of
1M Wen.balfof1bcNonheast ofllÍd StWuo II for. distanœ
on.~.~o.7.7r~t~.t'þ.t:~~.u... er.uftbeBast _ ~~.~~t:~~~~...
oftheN~,qoartcr . ec:dOl118¡thtnœX\1D 34'37" atouatbeSoath
Une of t1Jc East bãU' of a . 1he North9IetC qUIIW of IIfð
. ScctiOA 18 for a . of 24.14 fee East balfot_ W..bIdf
ofdac NOJ1bcast of; Ii tbeoœ fIII1 Nai1h ooe 23'
. ~ '., 11" W= aJoq dD of the NOLtIaMt ~ of 1bo
N~ qUU'ta' of 0 a paint on. citeuJIr CUM!
\ '~'}.", Q)tICØ8 to 1be"Noztb;. West a ~sUDciI: vf 5.104.58'.
jeet tbðs-oñom.. said of 1hc ~cmm BWe
Road No. 5-896; thence the løÌoc bdu¡ the Saud1crly
riøbr,.of-\Vq üs of S1aIe St804.SS r~ 1braq11a ceD1Dl
.ugta of 038 11' ~.s" fur an c roD'tT OF BEG~: .. "
LESS AND EXCEPT:
, .
..
~., "-' ...
. A Parcel ofbDd. JyIDa ÚI. S_on ] 8, TO'I9IIShip4a" South, JW¡IC 1" Eø, CaUicr-Ccft.mIt, "FIoiiða . ,
and beinS more pRIticu1ørly c1c8cnDc4 II foJl~ . . ".
CommenciDs _ the NOIthWHt ~ of aaiel Section 18: tbeøe Nor4\ 8' dep11134 ÍDImP- 36
eeconds East atq 1htI øanh 1Iœ of Aid Section 18, a dIsta1Jao of 1612.20 .W; u.c. Scnnh 0
de.- 24 ØIiøutcs 34 NCO.DIb East. . dlltaJlCe of 139,551 r- tg the POINT œ BBGJNNINOI
said Polbt aIsu 11_ ara tbc South rlgbr-of·W8.7 tiœ ofl. RJdge Road (CJl. 896) ml bIùI the
bcgbdng of aÞOJHlDPl11 cum. ~ to the North, bavInø I ndius of5904.51 r.t¡.. caa1rI1
aglCl of' depæll1 m.hwte& 08 ICConda. aUt!.. d1cmS of322.61 t.et budag Swth 81 ~
3S minuta 03 seconds ENt; 1heacc: I.ut alaq said oum. a dIJtmcø 01322. n bt; 1hacc ScNtb.
o degrcC'.l26 'mi:rMeS 17 seconds But, . dlltanco of ,s.oo feel to.dIe ~ of ~ of. DO!1'-
taD.cnt cum. c:aDCaft to the Nri, bavJug. rdus of" 5839"8 feet.. & ceaUllID¡1e cd'! c1e1ßCS
10 min1BCl 00 scçouða. IJJd . dum! of 322.70 teet baz'b1¡ NQrtb 81 clepIM .35 ~ 43
seconds West; 1htuee West 1Ú00g .said C1Inf" a dÎllt8D.CC 01322,74 feat¡ thaxo N011b 0 del*'
24 JDinutes 31S ReCmdI Wilt, . dlatance on~,o6 feet 10 th. POINT.oF BBGlNNU(G.
. .'
-,
178
Conditions of Approval
1. The variance is limited to a 15-foot variance from the required 15-foot setback for
the western external boundary of the Pine Ridge Planned Unit Development (PUD)
and a 15-foot variance from the required 15-foot setback for the eastern external
boundary of the Pine Ridge Center West PUD to permit a O-foot setback from the
common boundary between the two PUDs, as depicted in the applicant's site plan
stamped "Received-January 30, 2003," except as further restricted below. The Site
Plan is Exhibit A (Attached)
2. The variances are limited to the southernmost 534-feet of Pine Ridge Center and
Pine Ridge Center West. The property fronting the east and west sides of the shared
access road shall meet setbacks.
Exhibit "C"