The URL can be used to link to this page

CR 02/26/2019 R 73 tD m c G Z z -o s 53 5. 5, my cf) Z t+n ' OZu> O c� Z O mZo Go 2- -_ \.1r.N V) U, O a ,- _ CI Zv o Z g C O v o S as o G -kaon co o rrA T T O m ) .) cfl ,,,,A 4. 5. ��m . O �� G a �� 0 � o m = b `vV C) O CP m cr 1.. m r2 5, 7J , N m r"--ti, _o mooc O N50 Zma Zm y G � 0�` � n � �� '37 - -‘ 73 co t n "--\ , Q N com �� ov -O U 37 O m r C— CP Z vm 0 N �`cn v !�� a -A c� 0 r CI ?nm 2 m OZ _m` 7 as ZO G G S m 5. TTA Om .G �� n m Z v -,3O "Z. -p.13 V oz a O zz m z co toto co O sco L • - O co a O 03.o : 6 ' • cD G G Z to• 1' A o ) 0 O r u) -Z cop mZ z C� G � o rtA Zcn 4 nZ n 0 N 0 J1 G J • W9k 0 oo Z, VA 51 � Z �ovO m vt 4 0 VI .Zr)N CO o Oo .� o ,- m 73 C:-.-_,% ? Z T Q0 m .\ fl- mo cla G-�G VA ZO O N 'n 0 O O 73 co m cor � ? 2� amo T -0 ril 0 �0 -11 5. 0 N N G m i Ca --1 9 n `f-ii- ---k Q % 1 �L� 2 0� Z. --0 -e- ro `O N 7 Z T-m tik m 73 ro 011 f^o m0 fA 0� G o .e' T' Z N Z � n m0 2 r oZ � , 03 y7 oo Z0 y 730 � , V 7, m� 2 co to m 3 6co o Ca CD 0 73 m 4 Z rn� omo -o a O r-• 70 o - y , nfoo VA CD m --- \_. ,,--Q n mClq5/13 c. z z� .a .,� jo 73, z Z mz NiZ �Z yVI 70o Z to f S 3 � oO oO �o CD N T�m ? 4:205C.',' Z -11 Go 6' co0 izmv e. G rn T� -nN mem 1 � � 0N O• m 4Om � O N0 v .:2.c----0 C) gm 91 n 00z rill ' . �, -1 -A cn mfl I* -fl rt m z No ZO�, r.----- rr_ JP- O _ o T 5n N � � (.7'-4 Ono 7 0 z z�m z� O z O t11CA (I1 y 1 mrn ..1 Z737 17,-, pzaco C4 w cri ,c- , vo Z � rmri amsN ---k,.:)' m mo c--- gr"-m �r 0 - ZC) \tk4V Z. A trl Zco13 CD Z. CD \° 10 Q- 11 So. �� 0 G Zo `9-0 `1 0 73 ` . 2 7 co Z a n " zoo �Z `� -0 -v - a Z c7 cnZ 73 G5 vi < o � o .p o 0 c 3'. Sc'' , Ci- Z ZO � �� co o ZO 3 r• .Z. -T1 -IA aS o � pv -Z O '0 GO o ,_ O orn mo W5n 9n 9‘ ooz zBr 2ma •os� lit v , -23 c33 O c:- 7 . . n Nai O �m O 727:3 o--c---2.3A O c!) mm m ?, �v, u � O z )cii� m -TA 70 -23 o 3:3 ,‘ m oo 3 m� } �h 2. z ) 51 s n = m Z �� \� m . o Z _ `, 6� m ter' 9 '< u n m m 73 0 cD co 3 v O `-° a Gm G zZ '0 v y O CD o -ACI m -o = �J Z O .37 03.23 rn "" mom " z Z. 'N \ cOc► '' c� z m of c ZN O o2 6 O 10p GO � -k O y - 1- S P at cam` o o °I -I' '� `"v v o m Z CCI -n -� �, w o�. J` o 0D 0 o° -- orZ 677 Zo rno -� Zi 0 -� v w X11 O C. n 0 woo' yoi9 'V C. eV- al 96)3 0 33 T-7 Cr T = n 7doUn O m � ' s zN 0 ��.. O Til r' O zVo o G O o �O O (P Oo 0�m� C -4ary O Q o a 4 rnoo i�G h- O o� ao --N 0 = -4-- 91 0,-, Q '•)• 3 i cm Zz p 3.;3' o5o' m Ti t+ 73 m5 Nco g mZ65 1111:117:1:17 ".433. C;;Ar yon O cno - m Z m 1--.4 , •r ' /�'_�oGZ smT c>0 \ ; a O mZ X'� cn 73 G� V O �. 02 1- .� m 121 Z 0 LOLO CD -a co, ca /�� co iA.�, T. 0 f• O i0 rri- oaom - 2 -a m � O mvci -f- Sze O \-- - C) mz 4 zZ � • j O cno myo 4 r� m r1-0 LO -n oo .7oN CD 73 � _,m w °I".-- 0 Z z� my N N �• / 4 G rn f � y N nelt co _crt �T CA m G 5, o r m m .1 ------- ‘- O a �■ O CP g 70 - 7370 Z o ca- C) D o G) Z m ni � , ---A --4 m? moo > � ► rO 0Ob v 9 0 o Z iCIz�m zo O 4 Z y o o -0 cvn7 O U, Q 6. y ou) d o0m m 0. 73 os � -o lc;0 m 0 CATil 37 Z m0 N m° � T -4v O mor" 7 o � �1 Z1 0� 7a c� N1 n 0 7 z 1. 7 OO ZO 0 co co 0 .00 G G ZZ - rt: 2 GO ? Ca w %' in 4 nZ 2i �oGNOO 0 Cf) -02 GeoU' r S " 0 7 NS 13 O- � to Z mo Z N %:-% 6) O -A �. 6,0-A� -o ..,.1O -0 0 � O r m o v C71•• 15 0 •p --67. o 1• -.7c110 oa'� CDI,N 33 2 �,�'� � rn s � o �o cc% 70 o -� 00Z .- r 03 '-1o� O2�No _ ' � -- 0 O 1.11 s o Z o O oOZ VA mZ \moo O �o% N oN G 73 ' -n tl OZQ CIA el 0 5. "P' 53 %-- ‘ N ‘ O -SON to W (Po11‘ N"li 13 vl a-.\ 1 ` CI) y ' - T O Zrt Pm O Z N N rm0'7 ill � mo2 r � w -02 4. T � Wilk 2OG y ?�m o 002 v m co v O t9 O 0 rm cru �_ 03 0 Iii G z 2 -o \ 0 73 no a � ` 7 �mm u)z4 n \ cn Z N Q C) -Z. A',. CI n ill Zr c� w� O Z o c� w a NZ " GW O �O � O � \ o '^ 0 moo37 , � i � �3P m C ) ma O o G��a a'� to 3 eire Z. 0 G crt m° O (.11. 3 S• o5. N oa '-� --4 9-R3 0mm2 11 • y w73 a cn n fi O o mm •-•41Wt ill T - omOo� O •n N N �m , IP 7 O ZzR` 4 %�770m' \ i cp co cf.,i, Cil .. -.3, (I),TA .'( m 36 13 m\%% my em 2 m � a as o 13 , G 3V Ilk 7- 11 Z y 730 o o�z - o Z Z m C Z CD tfa 73 ca co CD `P Q- COco SIA) D Cr-0 73 yo =� � __10 rrt 1--- I- Cr- 0 r in r Oma cv \ 0 -th 0 6 /2 --I ( -"---- :*VI 5 N9+ O � �� I . 1" ' \ -0 -o Z Z o c� , rrn 7001 ' . 70G' y o ► T33 % W o T m Z Zo G = � `3: Q Q) CD 15- r=r, u' N co o-) O 72-4 Z. mm o "' R r � r -Go m O m � 0 � -4ooG -4 - w73 -O o 70 0 4 „ 0 si .--1 U' y a _ 73 Z O • u• -) -6 yn ril Z. r•-,r" o .1 911 0 y o =+ y mZ 4 Z _1 r) o CI �� moo' p c1 mom, z7070 \.1,-A - yy p oz ' nzozG _,m o . mo (r) m m CP o � Kg?,m� N � 3 N.. 1 - O j"01 )8 mm Z - o o rTI oD - o� ...4 _.•4 70 0� "(D- r- -4 O r 73 73 5 IP Z CD LO IS m o Ci9 c- CD 0 G `a �_ CD o Cn f r ". m-0 mroa � 5. o r m � 0 ) 03 ' oo � %--N s:\*. ss - O cmno mG' o ( '' 51,, Ci m �?� z ` _ CO p go ill oo CD 70 �,m =+0 w 7' o O G 'X0 ` cr Z Zso .-4 mv77 (14 @N n = O5- � m o co R � 0 O► O ,v0m � N � � G oh o o 7o o . . " ynyZo C oo oPv m '3', c3 cll ? ?1 -tGn t\f m m2 0 '[1 O 0 0f O �o Ci VAZ5. vz�om o `'� . v z 3:. i 51 yr, -.4 z m m la O 0nQ rrt .r.., z,Ow 4 • \oc %l) Y,o- CI) -o3yv Z1 av O �a� n mm Z 0 0 m 0 Z rc Z n en to tit o ,...% `i► 7 f� 0 m p OCD 0 -a co, (9 7'. Ci)..., cn n ow f � r O \. Z < vi In O 'O m �T CD r m O �: t- zN 4 p2� . ‘ -,%.... 1.._ cn -4 O Who y --A Z. �► N Z G1) 2 C> \ oa m U, vm tQ 4 7a m moo W O oo o ` o v3 r VA 2 2. G o uj N �, No n a0 - a <3 C. Z mill ill � n 0 2 5.aa O VA 4 �9 y Go- CD ,, � N m r ommma O m(en \m 4Q 0 so up0 A, a �2 ).m� N fo` t � av ` - y fl%; � 31-4,0 G Z Z = 7 Zm Lo 73 0 4 CD Z 0 CD CI CU -o 0 oa CD co c. G Z c.Z -0 r �OcD 0 73 v -. -1 o rn C-)40 Ti y 5- G-o m • o �rWim ? my - 0 ? man c , ill m z czN 4 - z ‘ t 0 O N - - CD a p o "1 m zm R' G`� 7. v7, otn z � Tt� -n � a wmoE. ► o CD 700 0- -' o �Z o � �,m 0 m Q s Q► 7, Z �, m a s�- ) D9 t 0 = 05. P oS 0r0'040" cN 'P' 2N 70 m 73 Z0N n rtg Zm � zN • c. O o C. O 5� 7 m �Z CP ill ` 9n 9-k - rn r cn o -n " - rn Op -73 N ' ..--V-- -rt o� W__, 73,, C3 Ill z5. 4 �0 ' o\ N a, ciz rn ?tcnv 1 111 m c" �Ill rn 7:3 m o O s 70 .< ^ mmNN, v v' r -ANn omz •rns�mm,m C-1 z 70 o � mz 2 m tg2 CD sll SO -a O �o r G al 0 2 O -73 ia0 O \ \ ,Z, o r o .-_._ , rct N � Vin � n O o2ihrip � � O 20 � O oo .-, o ,Z 13 Z GIC. VI WA° 0 .. 3 (D y 95. N WA ?... S VA /\;_,- -IA oaz -A � O �m mm 73 y CO �nm oO 73oot O �o mi C �nmcP oo p2o2 iil 1 p0 5.�aom m iiihiki - -3n O`o o G 2 V3-1' N like O 5. Nao m y 9-‘ 0 2- tFck 2 Q • ` _ 7. -‘ V3 co 5,t a2:: i - rrr:4 o CP m %am r 01 c".1.1' o rn 0 N ��PC);:::::;2-Zr: a� 1;790 ¶ 1.11 m G) 0 � // 7C) ozyZ o % co co 11) o -fl O � � D c G Z ZD r- GQ Q r -,35 �� • n rri N ; Zm m2 -0 CP G - ?y g3 --k O Zo 2a m �� 4 A fi Z � � AZ ck' e:/-1-s.1,- S 7 ovZ� mm ( 51, 0 20 ,fa�� N 3 0/1 G) R► s o o N 3 (Cs eV- = o5. (1) m=y7' n -23 � -noa2 S �� O7,3,CP m2 r 15 2N5. 0 N0 (I)m cis+ --� y 99 p 202 Ill m2 2 ��0 r r .� �mao ril 0 -3 i.1 OG yo -nN �� 0 05 :74, CI 0� • T 5- n N N C.m cb til 2 5. z,2 c'i tom O N � � m -* N� I m O Z � mm CI (13 oi N CP 73 m m0 i y 2 �mm - -0 2 ill o -x T 17 4?:3$ m4 = r � � rmm 37 o 73 0 kcc)-- i) WI m Z CD CO tt 3 ri. CD N o r- y -' 0 civ l � CAI -4n m r0 c. Zom-v m . h r73 � ? ' '''tO V co , o toll CPVIm Wm Z C C) "Z• C1) O o T. V\. t -D \."04'. O cmi�Z moo • m► �Z 73 m G'-- z v7,om m z CO o -° o o o �- _�W ¢ �.11 � o -n G =mow e 0 = oN r- � N S v on VI � -n T � G ` S ▪ o• .73 amaO 03 m7oh ...4? o • m �rM0 , O - Ti;.- O 5.N 70 Cv z o ) 2 C') Z o oO ) G rn - ry , W Z r -4rn .+ ril � -0 m moo -Ac3 -' \. O oOr �� N � V � , R m . oamo5) z� z� 0 O n y moo mou) � � yp- • 1O rn" 77 ..4 0o6 cn c my oCP o o0m R► o= 73 oi`n+ cn m =. .o mm N awl, 73 yy NR'oov C� =im Z � o .6 m oz -4 zosP4 70 G�5. ni •=rr, Z� n 0 70 ___,........,...._ cc Q s - Y `c \ �oZ 'r Zoo- �j r o 0 �y r 4.�o- N 2?. ot1' N "' vorz - io 111ro a4. o- 1 o �. • o o r 0 o ' - V q � o r mrt o am 2 o l Nzs ., Z>y `j oak- oN y \ \ 0OG o� O C)0 •moo ! 7- vs O J� v1 0 � yo7 yip owY p oo r �, a % y;� v, 01.,.. cc. y o v d -(9 ', u-�j O CtS co °" ' o O'� Qoco� ` O "' oy � o 4p CD 2Zy yZ y 0u, y o r2� C no y a2Za. yLo Z Z N1-- - A 2 od O 2� o O (t � o. ozr 2- y L) 1--- A1--- ACDo u= ' ya( 1 cc' yY vw -. dtt- • a) rLv-1o 2 e CO N Rcc r5), Z 17 Z m 3 CD ocpm tri et -0 O w ° 'Z c c 9a c m (240 r a -o m% 1 Go .43 , , Z r' =i Z g 0 In UPz w , f re, • O mp �1 r o 2 VrTh o -uZO d - vzo mZ = lw � w 0 zrc, m , y I, qfl m zcn '11 •-v a 6.. 0 !TAO 0 o r m 09, CD Zo �'O -n ymS C" „ oG � o-4m m0N 1 0 sal rn 73 -n -r, oa Ill o =70 o O coo �. 0 -40 NI 7 CmA = O P. -;10• m �� ozoz �- n r mz � cvo (Q� T-- 7070 ,C m, T13-a moQ 03 c CO)� o-i, � 6O or 1c -n 0 (.1) w o a 940 o c m m zi v 11,10 � o 0 IP z, w 1 1D v y '-i cn�:::• �'. 2 O _ E: j cn" • 70 v m t!� �—' u'► - Z mo N _ O �o v —4c 11 1 1.7:4-::::": m ", m �V 4 ,.-% � m gOl t) Z. 70 oG mz to Z c co oOcto Ca N y � n 7 � o o c 2 o i ' a2� ", w ---�7 cmn Z •; ZN 0 c� Z n m Z G O t- O No O oN c Z o cf Z 0 w r`' zm 0 2N -tC1 (D O O o ..' O I m ` ,. -a 73 O9: -11 GT aom s ¢ �, � Z 2� �1 ;► a -G D 3 C 7' -r' -npati la = O73� mz 7 Nz '' Cf 1 N 73G o "- o 5, o a .., roc' O 5.0 Na�Ym ry a o0 mZQ cve -o G - Z �-A 73 Trk cD c • 1 mm �� N� • ov � W M � w0 ill SO � N a7 c O 4. s .TmO�mp � sO� r k' rn S G) -Th'73 oz m Z CDCO73 3 5 CD ctt /" co 4. Cr.. N w C u, �-0 `, C 1010.. SD _ o D 0m � la �, ! of • Zm5- oRi-t r. m m � ', 0 mo � \ \< • Z mo C. �� 0zW4O . - O Z-) a z � Z mNZ73m2Z my 0m �, z IP LCI o o0o� CD -0 Z0 c. N � --1 ' S 37 • c' C Til --n .11 Gin DS o� O mco-+ Z 0 m o v O Tri 0 Ell "v.) Zi" O O 0 70 0 CI 73 7„ o 6 O _ �� Q0Z J -0G m mO �o `�.., 1 Pi 7 c. ��'► 0 � � \ e 0 �n to 5,C oo y C) 7----1 m 2 5. 4 z�o O 4 Z y e;_9 0 k U) t33 CEO Cll 37 o '' rcn mo�CD � �z �1 CP 0= 73 o = -+ -o III cn m = , 7� G z. to m 0 -A N ' yv r m,v O ?273. -8 r �m r mO rED 'S z TC3 rrt o 7 -4 _4_ 70 2� = 2 Li 0 Z CDCO cD ZVa CD 3 CD -0 G moo � l �' CO zz CD C-- v -v73 et rn � o rGV mp � 77 0 _ z m- 2, ,� C5 mz o i- S% W O o t., c. 0 -1 cn Z 70 p w rrtri O p C- vo m zcn 7. -n -4 W 0O'77 TCO O O o O 9, CD C � 37 Zp -+ m fl. cr 0 51 p Z Z O GI -1 -I - CSD 0 .n p p CD _1 Cr( -11,,,11_,� OzzN �. 0 moo � floz .\ C'� vp %..._ ,.I 73 � al Z � N . . o -n Cl)N w0- Z � o �' mz i r 70 mom -+ 1 51 m cn -4 S ;111 rnw U � 0 zymbn 0 U, 1-11 o= 73 � 2 ^ mo rn m - •li � N nnZ Z . .1c----- %) m c,,,„73::...:80:-%Cr)-i '3=fmtm m OG m z i1 73 0 2 o tD N ea►° 0' CD co SP kyot ,► a to a o c_ Z. 7 OD�, 0 0 z , C) 0: m 2m fn 4 nZ -� n mZ Go O osn 0 O ON •"0 mti . w i `�` z a m 7 4 Zva m ZN �► O o o _..do1,73 153 m -0 S. all 2 Z p ...1 a -< CI) o Zp N 3 et- 2 o5 C.l) ova N .1 Q m z ZN � 4tri CCI CO .4 cAn fi OZ 1:3 �O � '. m C7 � nm ooO 0oym ? a r n 2 m O o f1 -0 G ci1 p -0 , -1 ( ; N -n 5- n " c_m 2-2 40- . m Z � vo mV $Z iO "O O Z� cil VA p . . 7p -7 - , m - v � 32.�' N N� 7,0 Z N A0 2 a ov O T '-'17- � OZ 1' mn 7 a O 2 o o rn co itv 14 ' . -73 0 73 � o s Z m CD z cC � c O CCO -G Cl) p::,.. co CD O rt v ral co ° C.C l `D COcCl)= @nn o o ' ,� .-v = m D D K ,—r . 00 orn O CD C7 cum � � � 3 M cn -I =1 m OC) gig C7 2- c7 177 CT) � Z � O O oz -t -p --i p m G�z -� 17 73 � -.1 c��n �_ � s '_1 Wm = zo M Oo Xi moa 0 ym RI G) zz TI r ° m cnDo / 0 -0 -I _ mzm. i[1 0 r- p 5 = m m * 0ry a — z -n Z = -< w CO w Q CD m0_ T i orn= o 7 nD vr- CD C .� =1 m ocp r .� m oipnoz m 1- .< OmnO xx C 03 mo r- -G -1 n 0 = 'I= op 0 Dcl � � Ooz „r- wo O cz m � z �� z 3 -rt m � � n � c m = zrn ... O 0W -1 Cpo 2 0 � wo Drxi o p 0 hFil oz D Cn � -z-� X00 O 1 m -0 177 a --,-4C TI Dm Dpi mCl) � O ci x D m � � � 0 m � cn D - - c xi m o m v m IT 177 cnm = 6- -I-Im GG) CO om w D O -I 0 0 a C0 _ � rl:t r mm Z mop � , xi oo zoW ill -< m = o -G J �r M z cn r W C) - 0 > N X Z ccDtp o 73 GI rm CD 0 0 7 0 cp `' • S o 73o rn �• 1:-.;= • • rm = Z 'Z 5 III (p_ it Zm ‘ l 0 Z U' C/ n Z ‘ rn 2 O CP O o-A la N Illb 73 (31 • TO moa -rn Iv IP --k w o 0 0at a (D 73 -, Z 7 m o �. CI- cr Om Z Z.531 G1 �� 3-G No0 n Cl3 oh Nm • (1)m 73 -n -noa o 00 o � mlb. S 77 =N CO M 51 aZ ._.d' : N mv OZ -a. 0o73m D -2'1°0 5o =o ` CP 5 0 CO m at 0 9/1 9k OZo2 m ��f Z � rn T moo =o m ooQc O 0N o0Zrn ill �o� �v� WiO P OZm .1) . � —' 70 mom —+ cmc (l) ; No rn ZA u)y ' o U,f o 72:-...4 ' r , o s 70 v u, � C7�r °tz rCm =�mTm1 zmT• o 73 Oz WI Z CCD COD D n CQ Z o - 2 °C' . ` -< r- cD co r-ea it oro DC zc co N, 2 n -I c-) ou > -zi '0 \ . 1 .. -o = 0 Mn -< air r4- D r— < = CD O CO m M =i g =. 3 m m .1 _-� m > `D Z C) zcn m z O mz p zn M cn O z co . M, �cry m = 2 N o �' o z o m C_W -n r0 rn -ID c O v --I z cn O 0 C 0 O D �C =gym m > rm CD 0 D m m Z 0 � O „� CO CL --1 070 c � o � v Si cD D 0 O -noo o X CD n ma _ O" 000 cn o CO xim . "I zrn > 3 M rm CDz O ,„ ,:iO zzN 7' ..t-4. 3 M MI mo n 11> mo o O �-- cn o O z cc' y �'1 0 m rm. z M o � z -0 .Ti -nom m u 0 � Ilmill MI CI 13 p � zoo 4y� Amo2202 M o9 Zmzm • Ni!. � . m O � m p D c k — r z Z7 c7 7 c� r cn 1- -I � � � m O mm m z � --I � r wD —I � mD -i m mm O OD Q D o 70 n z '- �. • m -I 5 cn p � � "' O rn W � t • --I -mi D CI) c) -IS r mm O m = Z x D n 0z 1"' * r- N r- cc -.I = m -< � m mxi cn C) n 0 D � z D -I z Z m 2 Z � 5 CD yo c•c to O oy �, -v O CO) S l` \‘ CD G Z c '' z m : z CD 1 O W Z NZ • G c.rn c.t.) — ill =:--; rn \--4 ‘. 0 ZN 0 0 mZ GO 5. cu'n --k Q 9:1,-1 1 C ZOO r 'O R►?1 = c) G r III O 0 73 - cn —+ v :TAO O ya Ill ZU' 0\, t, 6 Z n C Amo o- 5 Ca m n m '70 -11 Tooa t3- ? � 0 = cn Z o " rr rcn 0 1 . m 2. -4 m � .G5U' m-r1 -1O ZZ P -o. O o -o co O 0 0Nmc�r C) •,1.19,194 OZOZ 0O 5, - 37 .ril 5;1 oo-, Y "4 opo m1�o 3- mZ5. 4075 O k Zia' � O Z uyim r- 4 n tri of 'm m — ' 7C3 '2. Oicm) rr -o Z -4 = m7 --I �o �o r m rr, � '� jZ?,c'C. ca Z 30 �c� S 73 o �G m2 cc CDCU CD D n -0 a CD = CO r- O CO CD um CD m CD 13 O W — Q. C C -< 0 �' c� > z z c� Sy = O m -0 r 0 . CD r- m � 1- -nI O \, c 0oom E -_-i — = CD n zu5 m OOZ � z � zm r-- Cn0 —1 P c a . -1 0 c0 > c�nlT = � o �' " -Cr m Oo ,-i m - W 0 D m rn C w o. TIr 0 rn .-i D -}-'` O -0 -1 ZCn 01 cp -n zoo o� = G7c "1 � OW I� 0_ c _ Q .a m � -mri CO mho 24 0 D o0 m °' o0 7 cn o Nio 03 mm Xx 3 m -nm GO r m CD O xix O zZN r = - K Cc0o r cn --I cn PJ m 2 — Ei a 71 = OO C7 Amo 1 - I- � o O zaoD m mz E0Dzo �' �. -I -a2 m oo 3: C'7 O o0 ZOoQ a —I o ° cn 2npa' 3, = =1 O Docs '' . 171 0 — -z-I Dm0m73 cn 0 Cr) m -o m z —t ceo 4 > r Z ,_r- ..... o — v CI) 0 13 I— =o W ;,- z trni) G) c 1 1�1 0 = o O m = of r. mm Z XD W m oz r * rr- G m < � m = = 0 '- 2- x rn m70 CO 0 rn- m 2 _ � Z c D C.- P3 -10 . o -h m z (.Q Cc: Add-On Item 10B February 26,2019 BCC Agenda EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation to waive any failure to meet any contract deliverable,and to authorize payment of outstanding pay requests for Economic Incubators,Inc.totaling$87,897.65,and to provide direction on future contract deliverables. OBJECTIVE: To authorize payment of outstanding pay requests for Economic Incubators,Inc and provide direction on future contract deliverables. CONSIDERATIONS: On September 25, 2018, the Board of County Commissioners approved an agreement with Economic Incubators, Inc. (EII) in continued support of the public-private partnership to operate the County's Accelerator Project. This agreement continues operational funding support at a reduced level of$600,000 for the Naples Accelerator and the Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee,as outlined in Article III of the agreement and in the updated Collier County Accelerator Business Plan submitted by EII. Under Article IV of the agreement, the County is obligated for direct payment of$203, 829 in rent for the Naples Accelerator, and for$396,171 in reimbursable personnel and operating expenses outlined in Exhibit B1 for EII. Per the contract,EII shall submit payment requests for eligible expenses on a reimbursable basis to the Board.The FY 18 agreement between EII and the BCC followed the same process. EII has submitted the following invoices to the BCC for reimbursement which Finance and Internal Audit staff have yet to release payment for,totaling$87, 897.65.One payment,#FY 18-24 is outstanding under the previous contract for Fiscal Year 2018. Pay Request Amount FY 18-24 $16,963.76 FY 19-06 $15,234.71 FY 19-07 $20,656.31 FY 19-08 $15,559.82 FY 19-09 $19,483.05 Total Outstanding $87,897.65 Clerk staff have cited failure to meet contract deliverables as the reason for withholding pay requests from EII. A summary of outstanding pay requests and the current agreement are attached to this item for the Board to review and provide direction on future contract deliverables. FISCAL IMPACT: Outstanding payment requests back to FY 2018 for EII total$87, 897.65.These pay requests are consistent with the FY 19 EII budget.Funding is available in Fund 007. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There are no growth management impacts associated with this executive summary. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney, is approved as to form and legality, and requires majority vote for approval.-JAK RECOMMENDATION: Recommendation to waive any failure to meet any contract deliverable, and to authorize payment of outstanding pay requests for Economic Incubators,Inc.totaling$87, 897.65,and to provide direction on future contract deliverables. Prepared By: Commissioner Burt Saunders,District 3 Outstanding Pay Request Summary—Economic Incubators, Inc. 1. Invoice: FY-18-24 Amount: $16,963.76 This is the last pay request from EII for Fiscal Year 2018. The Clerk's office has withheld payment claiming per Florida Statute 287.017(1), all deliverables under the annual contract were not met. It is the opinion of EII management and the Board of Directors that all services required by the contract were provided and met. Deliverables linked to budget estimates were not fully achieved due to unforeseen circumstances and events, including a hurricane and the delayed opening of the Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee. Although some budgeted revenue estimates were not met, this did not increase contract costs to the County. EII performed services at a reduced cost throughout FY 2018. Though$800,000 was budgeted for the year, EII billed the County for only $503,359.21 in reimbursable service costs, which the final payment of$16,963.76 is outstanding. The County direct paid another $197,892.50 in rent for the Naples Accelerator lease,putting the total FY 18 costs at$701,251.71, or $98,748.29 less than the budgeted amount for the Fiscal Year. 2. Invoice: FY-19-06 Amount: $15,234.71 This payment was for payroll ending 12/31/18, and had quarterly reporting and deliverables tied to payment. The Clerk has withheld payment citing unspecified errors and inefficiencies, while also claiming that EII is behind on revenue goals. EII has requested further information regarding the errors and missing information be provided. The EII contract with the County has annual revenue deliverables as outlined in Exhibit B of the contract. If the annual revenue deliverables are evenly divided across four quarters, EII is substantially exceeding business income while behind in private investment. Business income through December 2018 was $63,105 vs. a budget of$59,319 which is a 6% improvement. Through January 2019, Business Income totaled$85,506 compared with a budget of$77,156, or 11%better. Private investment was $10,663.79 through December 2018. Though this accounts for only about 10% of EII's annual goal, our fundraising committee is working diligently to raise private investment. EII fully anticipates meeting private investment deliverables in the current fiscal year. 3. Invoice: FY- 19-07 Amount: $20,656.31 This is for payroll ending 1/15/19 and per communication from the Clerk's office, has no specific deliverables tied to it. 4. Invoice: FY- 19-08 Amount: $15,559.82 This payment is for payroll ending 1/31/19. All deliverables, including the January month-end financials are uploaded in SAP and awaiting review by Internal Audit. 5. Invoice: FY- 19-09 Amount: $19,483.05 This payment is for payroll ending 2/15/19. Though it was only recently submitted, like FY 19-07 as a mid-month payroll, there are no specific deliverables tied to it. Total outstanding pay requests: $87, 897.65 AGREEMENT BETWEEN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AND ECONOMIC INCUBATORS, INC. This AGREEMENT is made and entered into as of this 25th of September,2018,by and between Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida (the "COUNTY" or "Fiscal Agent")and Economic Incubators,Inc.("Ell"or"Administrative Entity"),a Florida not- for-profit corporation. WITNESSETH WHEREAS, on September 10, 2013, Agenda Item 11.C, the Board of County Commissioners ("BCC") approved the Office of Business & Economic Development's FY 14 Business Plan, which included a goal of developing a Business Accelerator program. Policy direction from the November 26,2013, and December 10, 2013,BCC meetings culminated in the May 13, 2014, approval of the Collier County Innovation Accelerator Business Plan, including authorizing its implementation; WHEREAS, on November 18, 2014, Agenda Item 11.C, the BCC approved an agreement between COUNTY and Ell, designating Ell as the Administrative Entity for the Collier County soft landing and Immokalee culinary accelerator development strategy identified in the Collier County Innovation Accelerator Business Plan ("Accelerator Project"), and maintained the successful public private partnership for fiscal years 2015,2016,and 2017, and 2018;(the "Agreement"); WHEREAS, the COUNTY recognizes the advantages of having a not-for-profit entity to administer the Accelerator Project, including, but not limited to,the Naples Accelerator and Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee (hereinafter referred to as the "Project"), and the COUNTY finds it is in its best interests to engage Ell as the Administrative Entity pursuant to the terms and conditions set forth below, as Ell is an independent not-for-profit corporation; WHEREAS, Ell will strive to achieve the core objectives and to support the goals and objectives identified in the updated Collier County Innovation Accelerator Business Plan; WHEREAS, the COUNTY has determined that it is in the best interests of Collier County to continue to support the Accelerator Project efforts that support and further the goals and objectives identified in the County's Business and Economic Development Business Plan; WHEREAS, the parties wish to enter into this Agreement to continue the COUNTY's continued support and funding of the Accelerator Project beginning October 1, 2018, through September 30,2019,for fiscal year 2019; WHEREAS, the COUNTY enjoys broad Home Rule Powers, which include the authority to enter into agreements to enhance economic development within Collier County; WHEREAS, Section 125.045,Florida Statutes(County economic development powers) provides,in part,as follows: "(1) The Legislature finds and declares that this state faces increasing competition from other states and other countries for the location and retention of private enterprises within its borders. Furthermore, the Legislature fords that there is a need to enhance and expand economic activity in the counties of this state by attracting and retaining manufacturing development,business enterprise management, and other activities conducive to economic promotion,in order to provide a stronger, more balanced, and stable economy in the state; to enhance and preserve purchasing power and employment opportunities for the residents of this state; and to improve the welfare and competitive position of the state. The Legislature declares that it is necessary and in the public interest to facilitate the growth and creation of business enterprises in the counties of the state. (2) The governing body of a county may expend public funds to attract and retain business enterprises,and the use of public funds toward the achievement of such economic development goals constitutes a public purpose. The provisions of this chapter which confer powers and duties on the governing body of a county, including any powers not specifically prohibited by law which can be exercised by the governing body of a county, must be liberally construed in order to effectively carry out the purposes of this section. (3) For the purposes of this section, it constitutes a public purpose to expend public funds for economic development activities,including,but not limited to, developing or improving local infrastructure, issuing bonds to finance or refinance the cost of capital projects for industrial or manufacturing plants, leasing or conveying real property, and making grants to private enterprises for the expansion of businesses existing in the community or the attraction of new businesses to the community"; and WHEREAS,the COUNTY has adopted an Accelerator Project with the specific purpose of diversifying the economy and enhancing the employment opportunities and careers of Collier County citizens. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants, promises and representations contained herein,and other good and valuable consideration,the COUNTY and Ell agree as follows. ARTICLE I SCOPE OF SERVICES AND ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES Ell shall administer the Accelerator Project by performing the roles and responsibilities described in Exhibit "G" and providing the services and activities described in Exhibit "A," 4 Scope of Services. Both Exhibits A and G are attached hereto and by reference made a part hereof. The matrix in Exhibit A guides COUNTY staffs ability to authorize payment for measurable services performed by Ell. Exhibit "0," which is incorporated herein by this reference, defines the broader COUNTY economic development relationship with Ell,which will be reviewed and monitored by COUNTY staff. Exhibit H,which is incorporated herein by this reference,defines the roles and responsibilities of the Fiscal Agent. ARTICLE II TERM OF AGREEMENT This Agreement shall be effective upon execution by both parties and shall cover services provided from October 1,2018,until September 30,2019,unless otherwise terminated in accordance with this Agreement or extended by mutual Agreement of the parties. ARTICLE III CONSIDERATION AND LIMITATION For its performance of the Deliverables in Exhibit A of this Agreement,Ell will receive funds from the COUNTY in the amount of Six Hundred Thousand Dollars($600,000). ARTICLE IV PAYMENT AND REPORTING REQUIREMENTS It is intended that the"Personnel Costs,"as delineated on Exhibit Bl,are to be construed to ensure maintenance of staffing requirements to include,payment for leased employees and independent contractors. Funding shall also include salaries, hourly wages, holiday pay, vacation and paid time off,dental,vision and health benefits,payroll taxes,cell-phone service allowance up to fifty dollars per month, Worker's Compensation coverage, matching 401K contributions up to 5%, service fees associated with third-party payroll service providers and employment agencies shall be on a cost-reimbursement methodology for actual eligible expenditures. Upon Ell's written request, the County Manager may change job titles and compensation,not to exceed 10 percent per position and report said action to the Board. Rent, as delineated on Exhibit Bl , for 3510 Kraft Road, Suite 200,Naples,FL 34105, shall be paid directly by the County. Equipment and facility, as delineated on Exhibit B 1, may include, but are not limited to, culinary utensils, equipment, pots, pans, kitchen items, materials, office furniture, technology,labels and printers,lab equipment and items used in the laboratory,automated entry system, software, signage and facility improvements at the Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee. I 0 Actual expenditures eligible as a basis for reimbursement can and shall include Personnel Costs for Ell personnel performing services described in Exhibit "A", rent for 3510 Kraft Road, Suite 200, Naples, FL 34105, and equipment and facility expenses. Ell shall be entitled to compensation upon BCC approval of the Agreement, distributed as requests for reimbursement are submitted for reimbursement of eligible expenses approved by the County, beginning October 1,2018. All payment requests shall be submitted in accordance with COUNTY procedures and in a form acceptable to the COUNTY and Ell,as generally outlined in Exhibit "B," Method of Payment and Budget Detail for Services, and Exhibit "C," Program Performance Report, attached hereto and by reference made apart hereof. All payment requests by Ell to the COUNTY shall be submitted with a completed Program Performance Report,Exhibit"C"and Exhibit"D"Payment Record Chart in a form acceptable to the COUNTY and Ell,as generally outlined and set forth in Exhibit"C," attached hereto and by reference made a part hereof. Payments to Ell will be made as soon as possible,but in all circumstances within forty- five(45)days of the date of the requests,in compliance with the Florida Prompt Payment Act. If the COUNTY determines through its inspection or review that Ell has performed, or is performing less than the total agreed upon services,then the COUNTY shall notify Ell in writing specifying those services that it alleges have not been performed or fully performed and Ell shall have thirty(30)days from receipt thereof to submit a then-current Program Performance Report, which shall address such allegations in detail and/or shall meet with the appropriate representatives of the COUNTY to discuss resolution thereof and cure or remedy any services not fully performed. Upon failure thereof, the COUNTY shall be entitled to reduce payment otherwise due for such services not fully performed on a pro-rata basis. Ell shall submit its Program Performance Reports (Exhibit"C") at least monthly and a year-end analysis, and any other required reports shall be submitted before October 15, 2019, or earlier termination of this Agreement,or as provided otherwise elsewhere in this Agreement or Exhibits.If Ell fails to comply with the requirements of this Article,the COUNTY may refuse to honor or be liable for payment of any late request for payment,however the County Manager or his designee may enlarge said reporting periods or deadlines as necessary. ARTICLE V MAINTENANCE OF RECORDS Ell shall maintain such financial records and accounts, including invoices, purchase orders and backup materials or documents that are reasonably deemed necessary by the Parties to assure a proper accounting for all COUNTY funds for which the COUNTY is obligated to reimburse Ell under the terms of this Agreement. The aforesaid records and accounts shall be made available for inspection purposes at reasonable times and upon reasonable notice during normal business hours and as often as the COUNTY may deem necessary to verify reimbursements and any other financial records or matters covered by this Agreement.At the COUNTY's request,a COUNTY representative may review the Business Income and Private Contributions records.Ell also shall provide timely and reasonable access to Ell's Chairman of the Board, or his designee, at times convenient for the COUNTY for the purpose of questions or explanations related to such records and accounts.Ell shall retain for such inspection all of its records and supporting documentation applicable to this Agreement for a period of five(5) State of Florida fiscal years from the date of the COUNTY's Grant Agreement, SL007, with the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity ("DEO"), when an audit report is issued, or five (5) State of Florida fiscal years after all reporting requirements are satisfied between the COUNTY and the DEO and final payments have been received, whichever is longer. In addition, if any litigation, claim, negotiation, audit, or other action involving the records has been started prior to the expiration of the controlling records retention period,as identified above,and the COUNTY has provided notice to Ell of such action, the records shall be retained until completion of the action and resolution of all issues that arise from it,or until the end of the controlling period, as identified above,whichever is longer. Ell shall also: I. Keep and maintain public records required by the public agency to perform the service, 2. Upon request from the public agency's custodian of public records, provide the public agency with a copy of the requested records or allow the records to be inspected or copied within a reasonable time at a cost that does not exceed the cost provided in this chapter or as otherwise provided by law. 3. Ensure that public records that are exempt or confidential and exempt from public records disclosure requirements are not disclosed, except as authorized by law for the duration of the contract term and following completion of the contract if the contractor does not transfer the records to the public agency. Any exempt or confidential records withheld by Ell in a reasonable attempt to comply with this provision, or excluded from any other section in this Agreement purporting to require disclosure of such records, is not a breach of this agreement, unless such actions are in direct contradiction to a written request from the COUNTY. 4. Upon completion of the contract,transfer,at no cost,to the public agency all public records in possession of the contractor or keep and maintain public records required by the public agency to perform the service. If the contractor transfers all public records to the public agency upon completion of the contract, the contractor shall destroy any duplicate public records that are exempt or confidential and exempt from public records disclosure requirements. If the contractor keeps and maintains public records upon completion of the contract,the contractor shall meet all applicable requirements for retaining public records. All records stored electronically, except those exempt from disclosure under the terms of the Section 3 of this Article V, must be provided to the public agency upon request from the public agency's custodian of public records in a format compatible with the information technology systems of the public agency. IF THE CONTRACTOR HAS QUESTIONS REGARDING THE APPLICATION OF CHAPTER 119, FLORIDA STATUTES, TO THE CONTRACTORS DUTY TO PROVIDE PUBLIC RECORDS RELATING TO THIS CONTRACT,CONTACT THE CUSTODIAN OF PUBLIC RECORDS AT: Communication and Customer Relations Division 3299 Tamiami Trail East,Suite 102 Naples, FL 34112-5746 Telephone: (239)252-8383 ARTICLE VI INDEMNIFICATION To the extent allowed by Florida law, Ell shall indemnify, defend, and hold COUNTY harmless from all claims, suits,judgments, or damages to the extent the same arise from the negligence or intentional misconduct of Ell in its activity as the Administrative Entity of the Project pursuant to this Agreement.Ell's undertaking pursuant to this Article does not constitute the COUNTY's consent or waiver of sovereign immunity or consent to be sued by third parties. To the extent allowed by Florida law, COUNTY shall indemnify, defend, and hold Ell harmless from all claims, suits,judgments or damages to the extent the same arise from the negligence or intentional misconduct of COUNTY. COUNTY's undertaking pursuant to this Article does not constitute waiver of sovereign immunity or consent to be sued by third parties. The Accelerator Project is an important catalyst for economic diversification, job creation and capital investment in COUNTY's economic development ecosystem. However, obtaining and providing resources to entrepreneurs creates risks for the Accelerator Project.The management of the Accelerator Project has been placed upon Ell under this Agreement. Ell's management of the Accelerator Project's risks is an integral part of this Agreement. Ell agrees to manage risks resulting from the Accelerator Project operations through oversight, by obtaining a liability insurance policy approved by COUNTY, and utilizing participant forms approved by the COUNTY,which requires participants to assume the liability and risk related to their participation in the Accelerator Project's facilities, equipment,resources and materials. Ell shall require all participants of the Florida Culinary Accelerator@ Immokalee to operate in accordance with all state, local and federal statutes, regulations and food safety requirements and to indemnify the COUNTY in the same manner provided herein above, ARTICLE VII TERMINATION Termination at Will:This Agreement may be terminated at will by either party by giving a minimum of thirty(30) days'prior written notice of such intent, specifying the effective date thereof to the other party. Termination for Default: Each of the parties hereto shall give the other party written notice of default hereunder and shall allow the defaulting party no fewer than five(5)days from the date of receipt of such default notice to cure said default,or the minimum amount of time as provided elsewhere in this Agreement, whichever is longer. In the event the defaulting party fails to timely cure the default, the non-defaulting party may terminate this Agreement by written notice to the defaulting party. Upon termination all nonexpendable property, purchased under this Agreement using Project Funds, shall be returned to COUNTY. The aforesaid termination notices, as well as all other.notices required herein, shall be considered received by Ell and the COUNTY if sent by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by overnight personal delivery service requiring a signature for delivery, and addressed as provided for in Article XXVIII of this Agreement. ARTICLE VIII EQUAL OPPORTUNITY CLAUSE Ell agrees to abide by the provisions contained in Collier County CMA #5383, as amended. ARTICLE IX STATEMENT OF ASSURANCE During the performance of this Agreement, Ell assures the COUNTY that Ell is in compliance with Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, as amended, the Florida Civil Rights Act of 1992, as amended,and the Collier County Human Rights Ordinance(Ordinance No. 00- 37), in that Ell does not, on the grounds of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, age, handicap or marital status, discriminate in any form or manner against Ell' s employees or applicants for employment. Further, Ell assures the COUNTY of Ell's compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990,as amended,as applicable.Ell understands and agrees that this Agreement is conditioned upon the veracity of such statements of assurance. Furthermore,Ell assures the COUNTY that it will comply with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 when federal grant(s) is/are involved. Other applicable Federal and State laws, Executive Orders, and regulations prohibiting discrimination as hereinabove referenced are included by this reference thereto. This statement of assurance shall be interpreted to include Vietnam-Era Veterans and Disabled Veterans within its protective range of applicability. ARTICLE X INSURANCE Ell shall, procure and maintain throughout the period of this Agreement on behalf of itself and COUNTY, a policy of insurance that shall be approved by the COUNTY and that is consistent with Exhibit "E." County Manager or designee is authorized to update the insurance 1 Ir requirements, as needed, and must subsequently provide a report to the BCC of the updates granted. All insurance shall be obtained from responsible companies duly authorized to do business in the State of Florida. All liability policies shall provide that the COUNTY is an additional-insured party as to the action of Ell, its employees, agents, assigns, and subcontractors,performing or providing materials and/or services to Ell during the term of this Agreement, and also shall contain a severability of interest provision. Every insurance policy must provide for up to thirty(30)days'prior written notice to the COUNTY of any cancellation, intent not to renew, or reduction in the policy coverage. Ell shall provide the COUNTY with a Certificate of Insurance that documents such coverage within thirty (30) days of execution of the Agreement by the COUNTY. ARTICLE XI CONFLICT OF INTEREST Ell represents that it presently has no interest,and shall acquire no such interest,financial or otherwise, direct or indirect, or engage in any business transaction or professional activity, or incur any obligation of any nature that would conflict in any manner with the performance of service required hereunder. ARTICLE XII DRUG FREE WORKPLACE Ell shall administer, in good faith, a policy designed to ensure that Ell's employees, agents and subcontractors are free from the illegal use,possession, or distribution of drugs or alcohol. • ARTICLE XIII GOVERNING LAW:VENUE This Agreement shall be governed by the laws, rules, and regulations of the State of Florida,or the laws,rules,and regulations of the United States if Ell is providing services funded by the U.S. government.Venue shall be in Collier County,Florida,or in the event such claim is a federal cause of action, in the Federal District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Fort Myers Division ARTICLE XIV COMPLIANCE Ell shall comply with the requirements of all federal,state, and local laws,rules,codes, ordinances and regulations pertaining to this Agreement. ARTICLE XV ASSIGNMENT Neither party may assign or transfer its rights or obligations under this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other party. ARTICLE XVI HEADINGS Article headings have been included in this Agreement solely for the purpose of convenience and shall not affect the interpretation of any of the terms of this Agreement. ARTICLE XVII WAIVER A waiver of any performance or default by either party shall not be construed to be a continuing waiver of other defaults or non-performance of the same provision or operate as a waiver of any subsequent default or non-performance of any of the same terms, covenants, and conditions of this Agreement.The payment or acceptance of funds for any period after a default shall not be deemed a waiver of any right or acceptance of defective performance, ARTICLE XVIII ADDITIONAL RIGHTS AND REMEDIES Nothing contained herein shall be construed as a limitation on such other rights and remedies available to the parties at law, or in equity, that may now or in the future be applicable. ARTICLE XIX ORDER OF PRECEDENCE In the event of any conflict between the provisions of the Articles of this Agreement and the exhibits hereto,the contents of the Articles of this Agreement shall control over the contents of the exhibits. ARTICLE XX SEVERABILITY In the event any section, sentence,clause, or provision of this Agreement is held to be invalid or illegal,the remainder of the Agreement shall not be affected by such invalidity or illegality and shall remain in full force and effect. (Ti S) ARTICLE XXI PROJECT PUBLICITY Any news release pertaining to the services performed by Ell pursuant to this Agreement must recognize the contribution of the BCC as a funding source.As a not-for-profit corporation that receives public funding or non-monetary contributions through the COUNTY, Ell shall recognize the COUNTY for its contribution in all promotional materials and at any event or workshop for which COUNTY funds are allocated. In written materials,the reference to the COUNTY must appear in the same size letters and font type as the name of any other funding sources. In addition, any development project announcement, ceremonial business opening, or publicity event resulting from Ell ' s efforts, and particularly those projects induced with { COUNTY funded financial incentives or other contributions, will be planned in cooperation with the COUNTY's Office of Business & Economic Development and Communications Departments for purposes of coordinating the COUNTY's official COUNTY protocol and public recognition.Prior notification to the two departments for such events will be no less than 15 working days whenever possible or practicable,and potential prospects will be made aware of the COUNTY's publicity protocol before final inducement with any incentive packages or contributions. { ARTICLE XXII SURVIVABILITY Any term,condition,covenant or obligation which requires performance by either party subsequent to termination of this Agreement shall remain enforceable against such party subsequent to such termination. ARTICLE XXIII THIRD PARTY BENEFICIARIES This Agreement is for the benefit of the COUNTY and Ell.No third party is an intended beneficiary so as to entitle that person to sue for an alleged breach of this Agreement. ARTICLE XXIV POLITICAL ACTION Ell shall not engage,participate or intervene in any form of political campaign on behalf of,or in opposition to, any candidate for political office. ARTICLE XXV MERGER-MODIFICATIONS This writing embodies the entire agreement and understanding between the parties hereto and there are no other agreements and/or understandings,oral or written, with respect to the subject matter hereof, that are not merged herein and superseded hereby. This Agreement may not be modified,amended,extended,or canceled,verbally or by conduct of the parties,but only by a written instrument executed by the COUNTY and Ell. Similarly, no contract that purports to affect the terms of this Agreement shall be valid,unless in writing and executed by the COUNTY and Eli. ARTICLE XXVI NOTICES All notices required or permitted to be given by a party under this Agreement shall be in writing and sent to the other party by certified mail,return receipt requested,or by overnight personal delivery service requiring a signature for delivery,and shall be addressed as follows: If to the COUNTY: Collier County If to Ell: Leo Ochs, County Manager,Collier County Jennifer Pellechio 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Ste.201 3510 Kraft Road, Suite 200 Naples,FL 34104 Naples,FL 34105 I With a courtesy copy,not itself notice, to:P. Christopher Wegner Wegner Law PLLC 3510 Kraft Road, Suite 200 Naples,FL 34105 ARTICLE XXVII • BUSINESS INCOME The Accelerator Project is expected to generate Business Income, which includes, income from service fees,rental fees,usage fees and other miscellaneous revenue generated by the Accelerator Project's operations. Private contributions (in-kind,cash, services, etc.)will be excluded from Business Income. Private contributions revenue may be expended by Ell for purposes determined by Ell without Board of County Commissioner approval. Private contributions and matching expenses must be maintained separately from Business Income records and may be reviewed by the County Manager or his designee upon request. This information is considered confidential and will not become a part of the public records documentation or County funded records. Business income will be managed, collected, recorded, reported, and retained by Ell within the Accelerator Project. Business income is considered unrestricted funds and will be used for program cash flow or allowable program costs as detailed in the budget and Article IV.The use of business income will require a budget, which shall be reviewed quarterly and approved by the Executive Committee of Ell's Board of Directors, and will be approved by the County Manager or his designee. Travel allowance or reimbursements shall be paid by Ell. Rent for 170 Airpark Blvd., #103, Immokalee, Florida 34142,shall be paid by Ell.At the termination of this Agreement,any unspent Business Income and private contributions will be returned to the County or Ell's successor. The establishment of an organization that maximizes business income to leverage the County's fmancial commitment is paramount to the relationship created by this Agreement. During the term of this Agreement,it is the intent of the parties that COUNTY funding be used primarily for all expenditures reimbursable under the COUNTY's reimbursement policies, whereas Business Income may be used or held in reserve until such time as it is required or carried forward to the Project's next fiscal year. Ell's establishment of a Reserve Fund to meet its future cash flow and capital requirements is authorized. Ell's Board of Directors' Executive Committee shall approve quarterly reports that account for Business Income and private contributions or in-kind private contribution, and the minutes of this approval will be provided to the County Manager or his designee. The monthly report on Business Income and private contributions or in-kind private contribution shall detail Ell's progress toward the budgeted amount identified on Exhibit B 1. The Fiscal Agent is authorized to seek BCC approval of an adjusted budget, revenue and expense, in response to revenue shortfalls that are 70 percent of the quarterly targeted revenue budget calculated by dividing the Business Income and the private contributions budget delineated in Exhibit Bl by 4(fiscal-year quarters). The USDA Rural Business Development Grant("RBDG")used to purchase equipment at the Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee requires that a percentage of business income generated from grant-funded equipment be used to create an equipment maintenance fund.Ell agrees to account for and segregate the percentage allocated from business income for the equipment maintenance fund and to submit these funds to the COUNTY monthly. ARTICLE XXVIII SUBCONTRACTS Ell shall be responsible for all work performed and all expenses incurred for the Project subject to reimbursement. G�� (a) Ell may,as appropriate and in compliance with applicable laws, subcontract the delivery of the services for the Project,provided,however,that Ell will be solely liable to the subcontractor for all expenses and liabilities incurred during the contract subject to appropriate reimbursement pursuant to this Agreement. (b) Any and all subcontracts Ell executes for the Project shall include provisions whereby Ell and the subcontractor agree to abide by all local,state and federal laws and indemnify and hold harmless the COUNTY. ARTICLE XXIX BUDGET MODIFICATION Modifications of the Ell Budget(Exhibit B) may only be made if approved in advance by the County Manager or his designee and if such modification to the Ell Budget(Exhibit B) exceeds Fifty Thousand Dollars then it will require an Agreement amendment approved by the Board of County Commissioners. ARTICLE XXX PROCUREMENT POLICY Ell shall provide the COUNTY with its approved procurement policy, which Ell will maintain in compliance with its grantor agencies. • SIGNATURE PAGE TO FOLLOW REMAINDER OF PAGE INTENTIONAL LEFT BLANK. • 0 IN WITNESS WHEREOF,this Agreement was dated on the day and year first written above. ATTEST: " ••••• BOARD OF C► i T COMMIS E S CRYSTAL K.KINZEL CLERK COLLIER . ,FLORID 71- By: t 'l Aire By: Attest as t*Chairman's DEPUTY c d►3� NDY SOLIS, CHAIRMAN signature only`: - Approval for form and legality: Jennifer A. (3� Assistant CountyBelpedio Atto c> O ECONOMIC INCUBATORS,INC. By: Signature Print Name and Title EXHIBIT A SCOPE OF SERVICE ORGANIZATION: Economic Incubators,Inc. PROJECT:Naples Accelerator&Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee OBJECTIVE: Project Administration Performance Criteria Ell shall only provide the supporting documentation identified herein below to substantiate the following activities/accomplishments for reimbursement: Deliverable 1: Maintain staff which shall be comprised of a Chief Operating Officer, Business Specialist, Culinary Program Manager, Culinary Business Development Manager, and Facility Maintenance Specialist, based on the FY19 Compensation detail model included with this Agreement. Progress and completion of this deliverable will be evidenced by providing the COUNTY with a Request for Payment Form, and Payment Record, Exhibit C, Exhibit D which includes payroll reports and bank transaction report. Deliverable 2: Administer the Project as evidenced by generating and providing the COUNTY with a cover letter prepared monthly by Ell's bookkeeper that identifies overall positive and negative financial conditions. Ell's bookkeeper also will provide accurate monthly financial statements, including a monthly and year-to-date Statement of Activity, monthly Statement of Financial Position, General Ledger (GL), Statement of Cash Flows, aging reports for Accounts Receivable (AR), Accounts Payable (AP), and bank statements. Monthly & Quarterly financials are to be submitted by the 30th of the following month. Deliverable 3: Demonstrate utilization of accelerator program assets as evidenced by providing executed Participant User Agreements (PUAs) quarterly. The Naples Accelerator shall meet the budgeted revenue targets as identified in Exhibit B. In addition to the monthly report required by Deliverable 4, a quarterly report of progress toward meeting the annual revenue target shall be submitted to the COUNTY. Deliverable 4: Monitor and report progress towards meeting revenue goals as evidenced by providing a report that compares estimated revenues with actuals and an updated annual projection by the 30th of the following month. Deliverable 5: Prepare and submit an updated draft business plan for the Accelerator Project. A draft for review and comment will be provided to Fiscal Agent by December 31 , 2018, with the final updated business plan to be submitted no later than one week before the Board's second meeting of January,2019. Deliverable 6: Timely submit IRS Form 990 Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax to the IRS with a copy to the COUNTY within one week of filing with the IRS. CO.Y. Deliverable 7: Provide a quarterly report of accomplishments to the COUNTY with an biannual report prepared for the BCC and an annual accomplishment report in compliance with Section 123.045(4),F.S.to COUNTY on an annual basis within forty-five(45)days of the end of the term of this agreement. Deliverable 8: Ell shall provide the COUNTY with its FY 2019 fundraising plan, by March 1, 2019,which contemplates achievement of the budgeted annual private contributions. Deliverable 9: Maintain a search-engine optimized website which identifies the relationship with the COUNTY created by this agreement,and monitor analytic reports on its usage, as evidenced by the submission of quarterly analytic reports. 1 • Economk Incubators Mc. MS Budget&Revenue Reuss Plan Nl W4FK Ihm O1Mate Contrhutiom Mitt • Pi 1014 Budget M1010116dte xsi �. �ftwit.tMtle4prtb eFraB : Calmat iorot/hi.MNOsreOudortiOCrrStvue Ntwirtiiplleintas Mahe 4VIVOTN S 141.105 S 447M S $7444 S - 5 5.17,740 Moms MMwr+n Spw.rdipt 41143/0111 KM 1$.000 170.000 Mera,y4cu. W7MOTTR - e W grimes ierats/hlvaa 4.a iolw/OAarsrs..s ($`^•`22L404( 1 s:.,.:=6705( I's::;::sa4$1 ($«:- ::>::r1 11:.:;4,,117.7$0( Allo nno he Doubtful Aoonnts 'MOM (.17M1 1444 • 110570) eon Invm.i.ts 45740Th - Tani TeOINDeO¢Crr +. (S'.".:;(e/+( (s .: . , ;i( (S�i14(.....::a (t_>'... �wwl t`.,fit,. .:�.vhw' ...'5! :.•7;1', 1"'».a• ' ti':`'.:,•:''I•,:C^‘ NnCrfnasInnotott(MrneCoo0110WerarSono I1v:4y44I r$''',019:2K ($:;•sus' f:zi'..VI.i �i'..A.....'.i67.iio b ny( m ltetw County Gnn=Raw,Yar7.wam a • 2!0•= 171,531 41005 Covlenww 4001 Kane(534YowpMleeMvM( 00 000 • 401 4.240 Coot yOkoct PAT Kim) at SOUK 2011077 OM,2 norating//ad4ryGrs(GiRr Cowell CO - - - ' 6awyTNsotAwwt riari9 KEPT9 Ilii• 1 CawAT$writ,14sbstkm ryC4MN .5111.15 tr41 Mewl Cr.4TFrraq NSA_ 4."1,;iiga` .4'.."V:,,'•.=;i, i#":.,.1472*$: $ '`15USDI Trsr o F_a.T F `x' OZat1102. • OpntrLO borer Cempens4ra sod Moab OSMIVOTN - 250.241 • 7711534 404SAI hnoenaMwGn Tarr Ccl4VPV0TN 401 - 140 1.700 Item event*(13WhIt Rr4) CC/CV,VOTM Menai •C 7 MpAIC - -- � SOUKftnMenioewM4 Gterot CC!/1Nt/0T11 Mae * Ill S I 4' St;Mr1 ote►G14.1144.14$044405 InMot MtKKIM*Ie F4.4.4 boron h.Mt Ono of CONY UN /47407 - LM • SAM Ion Gptee 0501107)1 • 47./74 4,047 • 77.413 M tts:end Senior(See Can[Tri) $574077 MON 74,000 Oilitka(Taephom lrree4O4b/611 ) 01101)0144 4-400 72.4 0 • 31.101 C.Mee.r:tl Trlrw(fr,&twill,rnrtrlslr) 0101/0TN 5.00/ 000 7240/ Fwalor4Stfrnr$aaM 111NJOM 1,000 1.000 - - 72.100 [wog Spnersihn 447VOM 33.000 LOCO SO.MO. MSW SM•e i htiCry/r.IM4) 0575077 0.41 - A541 004oet 111711027 700 1.000 - • 2.700 Immo**bpre. 147110TH 1.300 7.441 - • 10.110 Cryie trtlnting botror *MOTH 7.400 7.200 - - 4005 TrtAtt 440510111 - - 7.400 1.100 htWtMMlmeaOar 0411)021 1(000 4100 • 70.200 MaA.Wag1M.Abng 41/10/0TM (7.000 41.100 74.000 ' FaolOcti[r gement Lwow 04011021 000 7.1105 44014.0 0424 41174021 2.405 4.200 • • 4.400 Moon W/WNe 4105017 7.700 205 • 1.740 Onn•SAtw!pdtw 141110TH • 340 • 7410 100 hat MeV* 4VUU7TM • - 720 104 420 . Ods Guy 7wreri.g per *5p1/01N 7.440 3.405 IManst/Iise 4571/0744 • 1.100 I.204 A/Oiwi CoroeMwMnx(Nat,rmy 01,74V0TH • - Swtta•lr uitoSa ►otO4M0Rn0•IbpOse IS`?3`774SMI 11'^5 7tus:l I`S 044 3O1l72'( Ted Orme"tower R -_r7 LCV:.A1!$ &EE= E ?' g$._--,ua:.r::s Ormailp srpkohOtOdt) I'$+ agwmel -s lhb4 1,41f46nn041J $ '1}5.10 Is -5sbs!( 0 111 NtM1YAtn leototLc Fontat 41541 25051 2.171 CAN Amro 454,700) 13 4.10K 12.171) 14471 - OtpritWn taprar 44011077 (7A•W3) 47/3.414) (1%) - (174115) 44.10401e161+•444.44Air..e l Vatn1I2t1liz4017•00( 110j1 1.41-s -7',-',71 43 11 aM 7777 ......... ... ........... ..__7777.__., ! 01)[VO17I•Mr iresinee4:intneenehme rwarMa e/ drone ..... ..... eC-RevrepreentelnrCemt ente1 hinted v2Mu7.A IPM ras.Ill1 EXHIBIT B1 Project Budget of County Funding FY 2019 ORGANIZATION: Economic Incubators,Inc. PROJECT:Naples Accelerator&Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee Budget Category Uses Notes Project Budget County Funding FY 2019 Compensation $394,971 Cell Phones for Business $1,200 Rent(3510 Kraft Road,Suite $203,829 200,Naples,FL 34105) Equipment&Facility(Florida Culinary Accelerator @ $0 Immokalee) = Total County Funding $600,000 Exhibit 02 Economic Incubators Inc. FY 2019 Compensation Budget Foca)Year Ending September 30,2019 :Xs Z; �Innu al:Amounits'and.l'neraas a .. r� tiry CUrrarrt .Salary ..:.':'..',...,...];:,':...•:;,... Annual pp,e"� s spy�• 3-� ::.-....;-....:-!'-.c Primary Hire Salary increase Salary . ' "-t ?z,, Location Data FY2018 FY2019 FY2019 President/CEO(Vacant) Naples TBD - 2.0% - Chief Operating Officer Naples 6/1/16 92,610 2.0% 94,462 Business Specialist Naples 10/1/15 41,160 2.0% 41,983 Total Naples $ 133,770 $ 136,445 Winery Business Development Manager lmmokalee 2/1/18 63,889 1.3% 64,733 CtilnaryPragram Manager Immolates 2/1/13 78,000 L3% 79,030 Facilities Maintenance Specialist Immokalee 3/1/18 40,000 1.2% 40.467 Total Immokelee 181,889 $ 184,230 Grand Total $ 315,659 $ 320,675 . .-, -----q..A.,--ft . ---,a s:, ' aM=>vripeasas -- zu t ..„ „7.,,,. Naples 33,443 34,111 Immokalee 45,472 46,058 Total $ 78,915 .$ 80,169 :e TotiiltaripetnWda Naples 167,213 170,556 Immokalee 227,361 230,288 Total Compensation $ 394,574 $ 400,844 ats 4.18iiiiiier_ AWASIO Naples 167,21.3 164,683 . Immokalee 227,361 230,288 Total CotapensaUon $ 394,574. $ 394,971 L(1)Fronted based on Nredate to 9/30/18. ' • { • Exhibit B3.1 Naples Accelerator Revenue Assumptions FY 2019 Budget I Naples Accelerator Co-Working Space Rentable Units 25 Potential Revenue Year/Month $ 37,500 Occupancy Rate 50.0% Total Gross Revenue $ 18,756 Rent Promotion Discount 0.0% Total Co-Working Space,Net �. Dedicated Desk Rentable Units 6 Potential Revenue Year/Month $ 18,000 Occupancy Rate 40.0% Total Gross Revenue $ 7,200 Rent Promotion Discount 0.0% Total Co-Working Space,Net Et-- .d� Half Office Rentable Units 20 Potential Revenue Year/Month $ 144,000 Occupancy Rate 40.0% Total Gross Revenue $ 57,600 Rent Promotion Discount 0.0% Total Half Office,Net Full Office Rentable Units 6 Potential Revenue Year/Month $ 66,600 Occupancy Rate 40.0% Total Gross Revenue $ 26,640 Rent Promotion Discount 0.0% Total Full Office, Neter ' ' Double Office Rentable Units 2 Potential Revenue Year $ 42,000 Occupancy Rate 50.0% Total Gross Revenue $ 21,000 Rent Promotion Discount 0.0% Total Double Office,Net >$ - 40 Net Revenue Co-Working Space $ 18,756 Virtual&Reserved 7,200 Half Office 57,600 Full Office 26,640 • • Double Office 21,000 -:err Total Net Revenue =_ 49SA Exhibit B3.2 Immokalee Accelerator Revenue Assumptions FY 2019 Budget .tet::,rs:. `<.- 'otal.ita='_ Immokalee Stations: 4 Hours Per Day 8 Work Days Per Month/Year 255 Total Potential Billable Hours 3,392 Starting Hourly Rate $ 25.00 Price Increase 0.0% • Hourly Rate $ 25.00 Potential Revenue Month/Year $ 204,000 Occupancy Rate 24.896 Total Stations 0 • . Storage Rental Income: Storage Units 5 ' Starting Monthly Rental $ 40.00 Price Increase 0.0% . Monthly Rate $ 40.00 Potential Revenue Month/Year $ 2,400 Occupancy Rate 31.7% Total Cold Storage y-"`°ate' Cold Storage Rental Income: Z� Storage Units 8 Starling Monthly Rental $ 220.00 Price Increase 0.0% Monthly Rate $ 220.00 Potential Revenue Month/Year $ 20,960 Occupancy Rate 30.0% Total Cold Storage ..tat University of Florida Food Lab: Number Studies 24 Price Per Study $ 150 Total Revenue IS u_x ';_.3$0pr Amor Total Immokalee Revenue .. .,-,-- _Amor Printed 8/24/18 7:47 AM Page 1/1 C. EXHIBIT C PERFORMANCE REPORT ORGANIZATION: Economic Incubators,Inc. PROJECT: Naples Accelerator&Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee REPORT PERIOD THROUGH • 1. ACCOMPLISHMENTS: • Deliverables and Supporting Documentation Deliverable 1:Maintain staff which shall be comprised of a Chief Operating Officer,Business Specialist, Culinary Program Manager, Culinary Business Development Manager, and Facility Maintenance Specialist,based on the FYI9 Compensation detail model included with this Agreement. Progress and completion of this deliverable will be evidenced by providing the COUNTY with a Request for Payment Form, and Payment Record,Exhibit C,Exhibit D which includes payroll reports and bank transaction report. Deliverable 2: Administer the Project as evidenced by generating and providing the COUNTY with a cover letter prepared monthly by Ell's bookkeeper that identifies overall positive and negative financial conditions. Ell's bookkeeper also will provide accurate • monthly financial statements, including a monthly and year-to-date Statement of Activity, monthly Statement of Financial Position, General Ledger (GL), Statement of Cash Flows, aging reports for Accounts Receivable (AR), Accounts Payable (AP), and bank statements. Monthly & Quarterly financials are to be submitted by the 30th of the following month. Deliverable 3: Demonstrate utilization of accelerator program assets as evidenced by providing executed Participant User Agreements (PUAs) quarterly. The Naples Accelerator shall meet the budgeted revenue targets as identified in Exhibit B. In addition to the monthly report required by Deliverable 4, a quarterly report of progress toward meeting the annual 3 j revenue target shall be submitted to the COUNTY. Deliverable 4: Monitor and report progress towards meeting revenue goals as evidenced by providing a report that compares estimated revenues with actuals and an updated annual projection by the 30th of the following month. Deliverable 5:Prepare and submit an updated draft business plan for the Accelerator Project. A draft for review and comment will be provided to Fiscal Agent by December 31 , 2018, with the final updated business plan to be submitted no later than one week before the Board's second meeting of January,2019. Deliverable 6: Timely submit IRS Form 990 Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax to the IRS with a copy to the COUNTY within one week of filing with the IRS. Deliverable 7: Provide a quarterly report of accomplishments to the COUNTY with an biannual report prepared for the BCC and an annual accomplishment report in compliance with Section 123.045(4),F.S. to COUNTY on an annual basis within forty-five(45) days of the end of the term of this agreement. Deliverable 8: Ell shall provide the COUNTY with its FY 2019 fundraising plan, by March 1,2019,which contemplates achievement of the budgeted annual private contributions. Deliverable 9: Maintain a search-engine optimized website which identifies the relationship with the COUNTY created by this agreement, and monitor analytic reports on its usage, as evidenced by the submission of quarterly analytic reports. 11. PROBLEMS ENCOUNTERED: a co EXHIBIT D (Sample) PAYMENT RECORD CHART FOR Ell AGREEMENT Budget Approved Current Amounts Reimbursement YTD Remaining Categories Budget Request Requested Submission Request Balance but not Date reimbursed EXHIBIT E INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS Ell's Liability Insurance: Ell shall procure and maintain in force such insurance as will protect it from claims under Workers' Compensation laws,disability benefit laws,or other similar employee benefit laws from claims for damages because of bodily injury,occupational sickness or disease,or death of its employees,including claims insured by usual personal injury liability coverage;claims for damages because of bodily injury,sickness or disease, or death of any person other than its employees including claims insured by usual personal injury liability coverage; and claims for injury to or destruction of tangible property, including loss of use resulting therefrom,any or all of which may arise out of or result from Ell's operations under the Agreement,whether such operations be by Ell or by any subcontractor or anyone directly or indirectly employed by any of them or for whose acts any of them may be legally liable.This insurance shall be written for not less than any limits of liability specified in the Agreement or required by law,whichever is greater,and shall include contractual liability insurance. Ell will file with COUNTY a certificate of such insurance,acceptable to the COUNTY. These certificates shall contain a provision for cancellation as found in Paragraph 5 of Section B immediately below. Insurance Required: A. General Ell shall procure and maintain insurance of the types and to the limits specified in paragraphs B(I) through (4) below. All insurance policies under this Agreement shall include the COUNTY, its officers and employees as an additional insured. Ell's coverage shall be primary to the County's policy.All policies shall provide for separation of insured's interests,such that the insurance afforded applies separately to each insured against whom a claim is made or a suit is brought. B. Coverage Ell shall procure and maintain in force during the life of this Agreement the following types of insurance coverages written on standard forms and placed with insurance carriers approved by the Insurance Department of the State of Florida.The amounts and type of insurance shall conform to the following requirements: 1. Workers'Compensation-Ell shall procure and shall maintain during the life of this Agreement the appropriate types of Workers'Compensation Insurance for all its employees engaged in work under this Agreement,in accordance with Section 440,Florida Statutes.If any class of employee engaged in hazardous work under this Agreement is not protected under the Workers'Compensation statute, Ell shall provide employer's liability insurance for all said employees. EXHIBIT E(CONTINUED) Employer's Liability Limit each accident Not Applicable(N/A) Limit disease aggregate N/A Limit disease each employee N/A 2. Commercial General Liability-Coverage must be afforded on a form no more restrictive than the latest edition of the Commercial General Liability Policy filed by the Insurance Service office,with limits of not less than those listed below,and must include: General Aggregate/Bodily Injury/Property Damage $1, Products and completed operations N/A Personal and advertising injury N/A Each occurrence 1,000,000 Fire damage(any one fire) N/A 3. Business Automobile Liabili ty- If Ell owns an automobile, coverage must be afforded on a form no more restrictive than the latest edition of the Business Automobile Liability Policy filed by the Insurance Service office,with limits not less than those listed below,and must include: Business Auto,hired and non-owned vehicles$500,000. 4. Professional Liability: $N/A per claim 5. Certificate of Insurance and Copies of Policies-Certificates of Insurance will be furnished by Ell that evidence the insurance coverage specified in the previous paragraphs B(1)through(4)inclusive, and upon request of the COUNTY, certified copies of the policies required shall be filed with the Insurance Claims and Management Department of the COUNTY. The required Certificates of Insurance not only shall list additional insured described above,for the operations of Ell under this Agreement (excluding the Workers' Compensation and professional liability policies), but shall name the types of policies provided and shall refer specifically to this Agreement. If the initial insurance expires prior to the expiration of this Agreement,renewal Certificates of Insurance shall be furnished thirty(30)days prior to the date of their expiration. Cancellation - Should any of the above-described policies be canceled or not renewed before the stated expiration date thereof,insurer will not cancel same until up to thirty(30)days after prior written notice has been given to the below-named certificate holder.This prior notice provision is a part of each of the above described policies. I I EXHIBIT F COLLIER COUNTY CMA#5383 EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY(EEO) [Effective Date: March 17, 1999(Revised: October 1, 2001; Revised: October 1,2003;Revised; May 1,2009)1 §5383-1.Purpose. The purpose of this Instruction is to provide for the implementation of an equal employment opportunity (EEO ) procedure authorized by the County Manager, §5383-2.Concept. It is the practice of the County to ensure that all Human Resources procedures are in compliance with state and federal law.The County prohibits discrimination as defined by state and federal law. A. All Human Resources practices, including compensation, benefits, discipline, safety, as well as social and recreational activities will be administered and conducted in compliance with state and federal law. B. Recruitment, selection,placement,promotion,transfer,training,reduction in force and layoff decisions will be based on factors including the candidate's/employee's job-related qualifications and abilities. Seniority may be considered as a factor given other factors are equal. C. An outreach program may be utilized to recruit, hire and ensure advancement of qualified minority group members,women, disabled individuals and veterans. D. Collier County government will take necessary steps to ensure that the work environment is free of unlawful discrimination or harassment. E. The County will continue to review its Human Resources procedures to ensure that its supervisors and managers adhere to its commitment to equal employment opportunity(EEO)principles. F. Employees who have EEO-related questions, comments or complaints are encouraged to discuss them with their Supervisor.If they are unable to resolve the situation through their Supervisor,they may discuss it with their Department Director, Division Administrator or a representative from the Human Resources Department.The employee may also utilize the Commitment to Fair Treatment Procedure. §5383-3.Currency. The Human Resources Department is responsible for maintaining the currency of this Instruction. 5383-4.Reference. Collier County Personnel Ordinance, Ordinance No. 2001-50: Equal Employment Opportunity: It is the policy of Collier County to ensure that all Human Resources policies and practices are administered without regard to race, color,religion,sex,age, national origin,physical or mental handicap,or marital status. • 0 EXHIBIT G ROLE AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF ADMINISTRATIVE ENTITY The following are delineated for purposes of aligning the respective roles and responsibilities of the parties. Under no circumstances will these items be considered part of the Scope of Services or Deliverables as prerequisites for reimbursement, however, the Fiscal Agent is authorized to seek BCC approval of an adjustment to Ell's budget or responsibilities should Ell fail to fulfill its role and complete the responsibilities delineated below: Ell staff shall perform quarterly reviews of Accelerator Project participant job creation or capital expenditure or venture investment plans. Ell shall require attestations and supporting documentation showing job creation and capital expenditure or venture investment by participants. The COUNTY will provide the form of attestation and list of acceptable supporting documentation.Providing attestations and supporting documentation will be required for participants in the Accelerator Project and advised of this requirement before approval to participate in the Accelerator Project. Ell shall have the following responsibilities related to attestations and supporting documentation: 1)insure that participant's agreements clearly articulate the participant's duties to provide job-creation and investment data, attestations and supporting documents; 2) in coordination with the COUNTY, meet quarterly with participants to gather job-creation or capital expenditure or venture investment plans,attestations and supporting documentation; 3)timely submit a quarterly report, attestations and supporting documentation on a form provided by the COUNTY(sample attached). Ell shall achieve and maintain tax-exempt status as a Florida not-for-profit and IRS 501(cX3). Ell will maintain good standing with the Florida Secretary of State and corporate formalities under Florida law. The Board of Directors of Ell(serving as the Administrative Entity)shall exercise executive oversight over the Project. Ell, as the Administrative Entity, would provide all required administrative support and management functions collaboratively with the staff,who would generally be responsible for: managing operations; implementation of the Business Plan;providing Project services; and maintaining compliance with grant requirements. Ell shall account for the business income from the Florida Culinary Accelerator@ Invnokalee. Equipment for the Florida Culinary Accelerator @ Immokalee was funded by a USDA grant. Ell will retain a percentage of business income,set aside for equipment maintenance,generated from the Florida Culinary Accelerator@ lmmokalee and the set aside for equipment maintenance,shall be remitted monthly to Fiscal Agent,consistent with the USDA grant requirements for equipment maintenance.The assets purchased by the USDA grant shall be used for the RBDG's stated purposes only. Upon request by the County Manager or his designee,Ell's accountant shall provide a quarterly report of actual-to-budget that identifies budget variances exceeding 10 percent,and their contributing factors. Ell will maintain an inventory of capital and non-capital equipment and will provide the inventory when requested by the County Manager or his designee. I y EXHIBIT H ROLE AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE FISCAL AGENT The COUNTY,as a public entity,has responsibilities for funds received by it from State or Federal sources and for funds dedicated by the COUNTY for economic development. The Fiscal Agent shall provide the oversight and policy direction for the Project. The Fiscal Agent shall have final oversight and approval of the Project budget, wherein budgetary advice was provided by the Administrative Entity based on EII's proposed budget. In the event that the Administrative Entity commits resources or enters into a contract and the Administrative Entity' s proposed budget or the approved budget has that line item removed or reduced,then the Fiscal Agent shall give at least thirty (30) days' written notice of said action to prevent a negative fiscal event for the Administrative Entity. Should a negative fiscal event be created by a line item removal or reduction in the budget,the Fiscal Agent agrees to be responsible for the negative fiscal impact or reimburse the Administrative Agent for the negative fiscal event. The Fiscal Agent shall propound the audit requirements for the Agreement. 0 SAMPLE Collier County Board of Commissioners Department of Economic Development COLLIER COUNTY SOFT LANDING ACCELERATOR Progress Report: Contract No.:SL007 Contract Term: July 1,2014—June 30, 2019 Reporting Requirements: This report is submitted in accordance with the terms and conditions of the SL007 State of Florida Department of Economic Opportunity Grant Agreement,as detailed in Attachment 1(2)(f)of the agreement. Project Description:(Full description found within Attachment 1.1 Scope of Work) This project is for the establishment of a soft-landing Accelerator Network,initially consisting of two Collier County Accelerators one located in Western Collier County,that will provide expertise to assist burgeoning International and domestic businesses with budgeting,business plan development,formulation of marketing plans and strategies,venture funding,and distribution logistics;and an agribusiness-focused,culinary food accelerator located in Eastern Collier County equipped with commercial kitchen equipment,food-product development and testing equipment,cold food storage,and loading docks, meeting all FDA,USDA and state applicable requirements). Positive Return of Benefits:(Full description found within Attachment 1.2.g) The return on benefits has been met and progress continues,with the contract term ending June 30,2019. Item Item Progress for the Period: I. The number and types of companies recruited to Florida that have created high-value employment opportunities II. The amount of foreign-direct Investment generated by the project; ill. The amount and types of export opportunities realized by Florida companies iv. The number of entrepreneurs who stay in the region and build their own businesses as a direct result of accelerator activities v. Progress made toward completion of the return of benefits described in The return on benefits has been met and progress continues,with the Exhibit A to this Scope of Work. contract term ending June 30,2019. i . STATE OF FLORIDA ) REPORTING PERIOD: COUNTY OF COLLIER ) ATTESTATION Accelerator participant name(full registered business name): I,the undersigned,being first duly sworn,do hereby state that the following facts are true: 1. I am over the age of 18. 2. I have personal knowledge of the facts herein. 3. Capital Expenditures. 0 There have been no changes since the last reporting period. To the best of my knowledge,information and belief,my business had$ in capital expenditures for this period. This amount is represented on the documents listed below,which I have attached.A purchase qualifies as a capital expenditure if it has all of the following: a)the participant/accelerator affiliate entity owns or controls the asset,which has a measurable future economic value;b)the asset has an estimated useful life of greater than 12 months;c)the asset is not used for resale directly to participant/accelerator affiliated entity's customers;and d)the asset is not purchased for inventory to be used in production of the participant/accelerator affiliated entity's products.This amount is represented on Form 4562 and the balance sheet. IRS Form 4562 and balance sheet attached. 4. Venture Investment. 0 There have been no changes since the last reporting period. To the best of my knowledge, information and belief,my business had$ in venture investment for this period. This amount is represented on the documents listed below,which I have attached: Subscription agreements that represent venture investment.Provide the cover page,showing amounts and parties of an agreement,with the signature page(other pages are not necessary);and Canceled checks or proof of wire transfer for funds received(account numbers redacted/blacked out);and Bank account statements(account numbers redacted/blacked out). 5. Jobs. ❑ There have been no changes since the last reporting period. To the best of my knowledge,information and belief,my business created or maintained Florida-based job(s),including my own,at ANY time for this period.I have attached a list of individuals and their dates of service/work. These jobs and job-year equivalents can be identified on the attached documents: FL UCT 6 Form(redact/black out Social Security numbers and amounts,but NOT the employer's EIN or employer's name);or Form 1099, Miscellaneous Income &Independent Contractors, if you use independent contractors(redact/black out Social Security numbers and amounts,but NOT the employer's EIN or employer's name);or Schedule K-1, Partner's Share of Income, Deductions, Credits, etc., (redact/black out Social Security numbers and amounts,but NOT the employer's EIN or employer's name). PtraC CAA OA Joint-Venture agreements that identify Florida-based jobs arising from joint-i : . the agreement needs to be provided to identify the parties involved and the number of jobs). 6.Foreisn-Direct Investment. ❑ There have been no changes since the last reporting period. To the best of my knowledge,information and belief,my business took advantage of instances of foreign-direct investment totaling$ for this period.Please provide documents to substantiate this. 7.Export Opportunities. ❑ There have been no changes since the last reporting period. To the best of my knowledge, information and belief, my business took advantage of export opportunities totaling$ for this period. Please provide documents to substantiate this. The undersigned certifies the information provided in this attestation are true to the best of my knowledge. { Dated: Company principal Sworn to or affirmed and signed before me on ,2018,by , who is known to me,or produced a Florida Driver's License as identification. Notary Public Printed Name: My Commission Expires: Commission# I,Jennifer Pellechio,COO of the Naples Accelerator,certify the information provided herein involving job creation to the best of my knowledge. Date: Sworn to or affirmed and signed before me on , 2018, by Jennifer Pellechio, who is known to me, or produced a Florida Driver's License as identification. Notary Public Printed Name: My Commission Expires: Commission# Q,) Z 0 0 a 0 (/) C W 7-1 z I o 0 (./) N (1) c ()) 1 G � U O N u co>- N I- O) N w O H D cp 0 D 8 z 0 (Ni 0 a , DLu O U 1O __I 7 Q 7-1 o U LL O NU O J CC i Cn J w0 c13 —JCL H o- J CC D --J 0 CD O O 2 O U m (./-) U Z 0 w _1 w0 Z w H cc 0 JCC UJ HQ � H- Q z W o o U Q o � W . 0 Q O Lf) Lu � v� vLo � a O N U U N O 0 U W F-- — t� <t D • r l0 co Q w � z upo) N Ln � NOC Z N � cv cn � � n O rn Z N p M m N N M Z m (i) k.O U • • • • 4 � t 1' - . O ° W: ,iet.ac- ,.•:, ''. ;:;,,,,.:,-;.. , t ^ ,I.r..., 4.- --, .,,,, .„,,,,,. • $ 7',,t . $ n -‘4;- P f' OtiVA31f108 8311-100 - . {5- .+ar. .y4 # tory ' }",' t. K s " its' , . -= 144 , £ , ' -04'. fey.Ir- * �'`p ' ( 16s. 94rk.: `+t 4. z 3 -- -_-_■ 0 c El Z m \ III OIII 8111 1 08VA3111O8 N311100 Uno• ____ I__ ._ < . , v) i , ,... , zzz h w0 H. . Q 0 W x O _J z 11— Q Q U Qw Z Q � 0— U O F— c� _1 Q V t! Oz "- ZL9 UJ W 0 5 I LLI O w D Oz w p wp LU U J U Q f— Q N Q w z z c U w = - Q J z z = U o w QQOHD z �, 1 2 —J H 0J Oz cn cL I F- U U I— I (Ni I Z 0 U) �-- z Q 0 nc z LU w � h < rz U w L-9 w Q z < QQ 2 2 Z z ° 0 Q a 0 C W � Q I ^C z L1.1o 0 ( � 0 / 2 CIA-1: a3moa Q -- ass '8'0 '!' � W o / Cr m Z , W i W 6 \\ Lll N 0A19 NVJO-1I anis Q (..9 (i_) Q c C C zEEc ° cu Q W — E v � � w v ( F— N U ro >- '46C U U U U O CIJ •a cn QJ C_j cu r n = 0 4 �n _co cif, Q v E N cu Z I cn N — i 0 < u ~ Lr) 00 Q a� C co < (Y) C (13 H Ci. Lo m a v ,-iCN C 4.-, Z v-i cu - a) w > X - ' ) H , , .7 G U C o +' -c v +�� `� CJS QJ i 4J L CU CI) LA O co 0 U > CI) Z v OQ 7:5 O CU 0- (y, O }' c U cpo L o E o v, E � zQCLcoza ° 111 I z 0 I z 0 U Z 0 N 0 V 1 J z 0 z o - z 0 0U N cn U � w z .z J -� m (/) _ a)) z 0 Lil z wv .a ° w O � v � � a = N U 2gEa) w WW D w< 0_ . . . I Q U . • t/•) 111 Z v 0 CU Ci Z `� Q v � C :f1—; ro L a) IO p no no CD a, LE �„ Q a� °° o E v v `� a, O CI— ^ QJ } Q CUD v N 0 W Ca... Q! Q- 0- O i C 1- M U v C7 N N v -0 -, CO v E o �.L1 - E W D z ~ v v 0 o 0 ° �, Q v U _ _ tib NN�s r.a(4w, aZITA a B IIMIIme,,llp �® eu.._. Newt .y, I NOtlM01S1141W NVNVWON 3OV10 W w > CB 41t3 W Wt >88NJW ' i If w SPNE t1111 .52 gj H Q y� `o m I H¢ W fit ",,-,,: it,-S 13601! NZ;i., NW r W VVVK.i Ax e� ai W W f! ��$ N I"I ICP e- •_ "_— _"_"_._ { _� 9... ktt AVNr40-1MJM , « a. _.".y__ { S x kkaari a, 9 OAV9 213513M (a i 331..wN 1 ,. T L WJYBL3S .,j` 1 q j ___ . w o cc NJ II g NJ r W Q J Y. T Q r'- N— y� x , .y NW :11- LI JI _ Z.- g _ ___ I Lug I ( E':W N } W L n r NOLLYtl311V 3115 1 'i a c p 3Ni353Hd Al > O OJ W o 1 r U * 12 L F4 ,.r„.li it US W G 5 }' Ww< nr. N Q i Nom:.' »a e y.. \`- N E L, 111 hg t iT y Z W C' '<I, . > V:1' Tam S;Qj g 0` I jyyy�� ... N O yOW E Y ; it I 6n I- ---t —, — W wZ s j Y o V -,P'.--1 z g e›.., (62 3OVd V No091V1d) uI1wSy j AVM 401440W WNV0 A4N110O Ni 0 1 AVM-301410114 OHVA3Yloe 83moO (1N3W30VNVW d31VM 034013A30I IlVLLN30IS3i1 AlWVd 3l°JNIS 03dO13N301 S31V1S3 931V1S3 7 J v / z 0 z0 O � U 0 O0 w < 0O 0 0 oc 0_ z 0 N O 5 Q 0 .1 c a L N co 0 o a, m a c o E 4aa 81 o +' '^ • .-i 0 -G I- • -a G .a +' C C 0 t0 4; a t r- a O E ( o 0 a 0 = ': G 2 G •. 0 a1 s a C +_. > w > t O a- �= CIO S' f0 a — M i E G m o �a'a > sa) '5 ^ Ca u ") ns O a G >. N1 a 7>- `� O r •"-.7.- O ., o E 4.' o c mE v, E `F' a`� w o h. G m ` E ( 3 H G p '" '" O •E +' 4- Q- 4 aIn C o > .0 a) • E E QI U O a Val L i ; 1 CL ++3 ma 'C"' Tc E o F_ a Q C w o E w- • toE 0 x •E -o � O c (5 ai ' E +• E X a1 G 'f Cs u >- '5 -O E CO :4-' W •'- a CO W 'O E E ,. O G +. +' �, �a a) O E a a� a a, -a z o c • N a -a 4- 0 m a w 3 a, c W c o '5 o — • E — w a S — Q .t a c v. +' U a Q '" Q o1I a) E a) G a' +' — (Din . 1 u a -0 X vl E E oin > ali.a aaa � N .? - 3 a s 3 O i E 1a 42 O N C .+ 0 U V1 S L U r Z L E C L- - a s a; .> E a -c O � u CA O w U L '" . '5 a1 L. .G t)I i ti t v V t e-1 e0 v e Z .0 0 Q 0 a) OD N 0 "V -0 C C 7 C C fa to (-) -a 0 > y L CO fD taa a) 00 N N '6 ., w C CD N ata a v aci a) tea) 3 0 0 > � N -046o C a) c CD t0 O 0 0 3 3 0 o o "0OD ° E � m � C v0u0 • •N N 7 C V H W O .6 c CN L "O U• oo •� 7 Q)— to i- `0 ..0+ 0 m �>- m fz c C -0 -0 C) � N '" � L s m C2- 0 N -0 as o L lJ O y 0. 4_' vi z += a) a � 0 C to co .Op 3 - - c OD a) — - = u ° 0 0 aa) = CO c E ea :0 3 `) re Ts a) O c _ .-, 0 u ' U a) ` 0 7 > fo aa)) 3 m = 7 t E T.) s a) O_ t -c a) ` C C to fj ` 0 E fu a 3 a) O 7 C a) _ O N ♦�, C u 17. `p' d cu N U U _ L > CD v ami .E o cu a) C Q 0 C u 0 0 J a� a ` `� To ? C 0 O jc- p C fCa u C 7 7 d 0 Q a) _C N_ N 4- Q Y j, ff0 0. U m co u -0 ;, p v t 0 fo 0 Cl.) '.i •... > E a) u �' -0 J O _j 5L.+ ' p S O 0 co fa 7 fes`) O v) 0 - co Q } a C O C C 7.:3 ,• V1 j Z a) }, 3 C v 7 t 0 _ E N o a) ea O i, 0 p x 0 to �.) .a Y to L .3 a) aa) .> u E E E N O� t .., 0 >- N 0cu o_ _ c 3 c a) ^") OD N a•, O u to 7 E p to E c a)m o .� Ti c O to a Q c G O __ uo E a) N OD •— 0 O C f6 +_' U _ (n a) J N J to Q •fa • -p O to t vi p E ++ > Q C N C a) E 11 0 ti.O a)c 0 0 Q - ..' y a) t9 V `1 �, V A to _ O to Y 'j to `) ra d .E_ a) a a) N . a) to L N 7 N is N > v—_ j 0 a) N L c to To N O C .V `) 0. C V u O a. � 7 O ON ` O c N > to �0 'p r- a) s N N -� .D N ti ro u u to to o u °' o_ .. .ti o0 0 '0 bo fl. 0a) VI a) a) ti V N > N O ra O L N '6 0 O 0 2 l7 U O ,o H13 O LL V 3 W CIO .. N G a) u 0 o > Q : 0 ._. to >- >+ oo a) E t o C E a) 474 4-,_ C OP s 3 c a) C a o h °�' c_v o E c) CD C Q a) OD C w CU U `� 0 C C M o > y co'a a) U co -p s °' LA0 3 C -0 2 a) o +�_ C U = > a) E > `O " C x -0 s O N 4.4 3 o . m a E a <o a a) os.- ro a, > _ O = s (r) CI 4- C aC) a) 7 CO O - 0'o -a s Q .0 a) a) c c a) co ro-J -3 , Eo. Hro a) 4-i a) O U Ca O C +-' -a 'C +, C C L - O n) C CU 4- CO +- 3 ° L -p O 4— O. H O U LA 0 N E• CD "- r0 H a) C) a) .� 4- cu> L C Q u 3 t o •a ec s > O NI .. _mco 4.4 O. a) a) m 40 C _ t O C a) >a) U L cCI U fl E a) s .1) N N fa a) m •a E a) = _� ` m COon CL 0 a! `" O O +- d Y 4', co '� O C - �O `i' a) 4-' �c 40 E vi t y vi y •- N - fC a) > a) += - Q m a a) C ° vi a) _C E 0 O Q 2 O o n > — s a) _ Cl. a) L al > 4- O s 4.4 A 2 cu v) O to O _o S t O O. d0 i a O U t _ N +4 _ 40 — n. a) }' a) `° , E - m C '3 �c '3 0 a) to U 0 UC O L 40 <o M Q- O a"' a a) t C m C N +J E �o s o = •i s N c i:, II v- w U th a • }' 3 4n 0 a L7 C ° +� ° C E o 4E' E U _ = = a) t U O a) • Oco • '47., 40 al m M ._ , L -a .s, 0 . c L C �, i a0, w O N O. , >. •N C N u °0 .3 in o in t a` = Q 2 o - -0 E v to _ ° a) -a 4- _, p N o co .a �i O O a) ;,_ 0 O r; ra o E .1 tn re a)• O O O a) -2 `a) 70 O L .. H 21. b In co Q G o C.) 0 Q c -0 c c 0 a)rO _ C > 73 N 3 0) a) O c L •=-, N 03C 0) C N 7 f0 l- a) O N t et) V fa = a) 6_ a) a. L a) a I Z O o V >• N a) co 4-, C a) O u O 0 O.- Q u E O to 0 v 7 a) -0 a) O OD C OCA OCA a) E a a) O d 7 ea O CO '0 0l0 4.6 C C s s c a) ` E o 3 E -o 4- .° .a) c 0 E a) a) a) °cA a) a, ,n E c t z N XE 4- fa 70 o ° oo (V XCIS ° 3 — h.... a) to E C E N O Q c c O m v N O"' a. a 0 . CI. 45 > 'O a L CV c -O n3 C 73 CO u a) " o a� E a E o oo u L -o C Q 'i+ O. - u au) c v 73 .0 Cr .D a) a) C • C — a) L a' ca -c = E o 4' c c c N -. s ( L — C O O OO N u 0 0 ri '7 u c c " = a.+ v O L C L L a) L '.'� O '-i O u e0 •a) E .51 m U a) O D4.O Cj N a) CM C O O _o0 m 03 To c tly a) C i V)V N '� O C"o a)O O L N aJ ", N 'a, o to o ,v O Q Q. �'' NL 4-• r5 C N O = cu 7 N N + a) f0 CO `}, 4-' E U oOCOQ h- y 7 a.+ u u to C C to • OA U o ` Q N Q +J N J 479� y. . N L!O N }+ O N E C CO 0.0a @ 3 a a .y A N 4- -O 0 -p T-, "CI co L a) O a) a) a) o a) u O_A ► C o — > To E f0 i6 -No ,.. a) 0 i� ✓' yY N co , f0 a. i N C C f6 C L C J 01 V1 O 00 h O � C O L) . • "a N "1L a) a) a) L C L C E p U C +., • • • y C C C N O < < � O,. N 'Y1 C Z 3 Q 0 t- . LB % N a) C 3_3 V 'O co C tiq 3 O > L C p d0 -p aJ , 0 -0 a CU M d N C L -0 a) 0. C a) . h ,C L ns E H O a) Q c a) s 0 C14 I - L '0 'o 3 to H a c N aa) a) L N 3 y C a) N L C L.LJ > Q.. p O C < * ate. C re >• C O '^ c C L i+ e C > O O io a `0 - , c u t 0 a) O V M O L. Q C > a U a) N a) o = c CI) � a wcrs U O t0 s aC ro L p a)C O ++ } a) N >. CO C U I- 0 >• a.+ 00 .- a) O a) (t1 Q E N O CO 0 fp ` N a) L a) - 0 0 O �> � +J w YC C C Q. V [a 0 bO Ea) '� w O ar `N CO = ry aa)) Q) t w _ .. X 0U 0.TU .4 biD 45 o a) zs = +� ` w C O a) Q C f O _ap_ ,_ O C co =p C w 47, C CO •, a) O C W >, v 0 a Na F- V') C p` .+- -F3a a) L E 48 ° 1-- o v aa) o < Lc: N. o0 •H ,--, o, v e Z L / z 0 F- w c Z 0 0 0 it Ex parte Item II- Commissioner William L. McDaniel, Jr. COLLIER COUNTY RD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA February 26, 2019 ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS 8A This item requires ex parte disclosur=, be provided by the Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item,all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida, providing for the establishment of a conditional use to allow a church within an Estates Zoning District pursuant to Section 2.03.01.B.1.c.1 of the Collier County Land Development Code for property located on the southeast corner of Golden Gate Boulevard and Collier Boulevard in Section 11,Township 49 South, Range 26 East,Collier County, Florida.(P120160002577) (This is a Companion to Agenda Item 9.A) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE <Meetings (Correspondence Ee-mails Calls Met with Rich Yovanovich,Josh Fruth,Adrian Romas,Anna Weaver &Jewssica Harrolson/Davidson Engineering CONSENT AGENDA 16A5 This item requires that ex parte disclosu:< be provided by Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item,all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Maple Ridge at Ave Maria,Phase 6B, (Application Number P120180001175)approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE Meetings Correspondence e-mails I (Calls Ex parte Items - Commissioner William L. McDaniel, Jr. COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA February 26, 2019 SUMMARY AGENDA 17A This item requires that ex parte disclose be provided by Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item,all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180001954,to disclaim, renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in a portion of the 40-foot drainage easement, as described in Book 1065, Page 582 of the Official Records of Collier County, Florida,located in the rear yard of Lot 35,Queens Park at Lago Verde Phase 2 subdivision,on the south side of Kent Drive,approximately one-half mile north of Rattlesnake Hammock Road, in Section 18,Township 50 South,Range 26 East,Collier County, Florida. xi NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ( 'Meetings Correspondence I le-mails Calls FilsonSue Subject: Rich Yovanovich 435-3535, Anna Weaver&Jessica Harrolson/Davidson Engineering re Grace Romanian Church Location: BCC Office Start: Thu 2/14/2019 10:00 AM End: Thu 2/14/2019 10:30 AM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: McDanielBill Confirmed for: Thursday, February 14th at 10:00 Thank you© Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant cy The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435,1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. 1 FilsonSue Subject: Rich Yovonavich 435-3535 re Grace Romanian Church Location: 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Start: Thu 10/25/2018 11:30 AM End: Thu 10/25/2018 12:30 PM Recurrence: (none) From: Dianna Quintanilla<DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 23,2018 11:10 AM To: FilsonSue<Sue.Fitson@cofiiercountyfi.gov> Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Hello, Rich would like to meet with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming November 13th agenda item: Grace Romanian Church. Also attending: Jessica Harrelson,Josh Fruth,Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver Availability: Wednesday November 7th: 9:00-1:00 Thursday November 8th: 1:00—5:00 Monday November 12th: 9:00—3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant yK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 ,t Naoles Florida 34103 P: 239 435.35351 F: 239 435 1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. Trusted & Verified Filsor_Sue Fi om: McDanielBill Sent: Tuesday, February 26, 2019 7:52 AM To: John Kelly Subject: RE: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A - Grace Romanian Baptist Church Mr. Kelly, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. it is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider ail comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. if I can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 Web Page 1111 WEB PAGE: - From:John Kelly<johnkellyfl@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 12:31 AM To: FialaDonna <Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>; SolisAndy<Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>; TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A- Grace Romanian Baptist Church Dear Commissioners, I have been a resident of Golden Gate Estates (GGE) - Unit 4 in excess of 25-years. During that time I have watched the gradual decay of the Rural Estates quality of life. The residents of GGE-Unit 4 have located for the same reasons as those of other GGE residents; affordability, tranquility, avoidance of urban traffic, and an appreciation for wildlife. Unfortunately, it seems the residents of GGE-Unit 4 are paying a much higher price than any other unit within GGE as it is bordered by major roadways to the north, south and west; not to mention that Weber Boulevard South has become a high-speed bypass for Collier Boulevard. To that end, Weber Boulevard South already served, via 1st Avenue SW, as access to two Jehovah's Witness Kingdom Halls operating on the same property, Max Hasse Community Park, and what was a failed Presbyterian Church located at 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West (approximately 3,200 feet east of the subject property) which was purchased in September, 2018, by the petitioner.The residents in this area are frustrated with the amount of traffic, the lack of traffic 1 control, and the loss of the rural estates character and quality of life. The residents I have spoken with all believe that a traffic generating use at the subject location is an accident waiting to happen. Interestingly, you have heard this petition before and a vote was taken which resulted in the project's defeat: unfortunately, as a result of comments made by the petitioner's counsel after the close of public comment, Commissioner McDaniel motioned for the vote to be withdrawn and the item be sent back to the Planning Commission (CCPC). The comment made by the petitioner's counsel was that you, the BCC, have rejected the last three churches that were proposed at major intersections and that he no longer knows where to tell clients they can have a church. Commissioner McDaniel also noted that he would have liked to have seen better notification to the residents of GGE and desired to see if anything could be done to ameliorate the impacts of a church on the community. To that end, the petition was re-heard by the CCPC however only minimal changes resulted. More concerning is the fact there was no greater effort to notify the estates residents of this project and based upon the location of this project it will impact upon many GGE residents. As such, please note that your staff just held extensive outreach efforts with respect to the new Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP) that was recently approved by you for transmittal to the State. The subject location is located within the Rural Estates. GGAMP outreach efforts performed by your staff examined uses and recommended areas for change as based upon their findings; no changes were proposed for the subject properties and the general consensus of the study was that Rural GGE residents ultimately desired no changes that would impact upon the rural estates quality of life. The Rural GGE residents have spoken and you are urged to respect their desires. As to the question posed by the petitioner's counsel, there should have never been an expectation that a church could be permitted at the subject location as it is not allowable by either the existing GGAMP nor that just transmitted to the State. The criteria for applying for a small scale amendment to the GGAMP are very few and nearly everyone eligible to apply will satisfy said criteria, as such your staff should be much more critical in evaluating and analyzing such petitions; your constituents are counting on you to make things right. There is no question that property located within the GGE is less expensive than that in the urban area. Does that mean every GGE intersection is destined to be approved for a conditional use? How much sense does that make? Please, the subject project is not necessarily a bad one; unfortunately, the location is horrible. Any applicant for a conditional use should expect push-back; alternatively, they'd likely be welcomed at an appropriately zoned commercial location. I'd further suggest that the County define the term "community church" as perhaps at a lesser scale the project wouldn't be quite as problematic at the subject location. GGE is home to much of the areas working class, weekends are when these residents are outside trying to enjoy their peace and tranquility, weekends are when they walk the narrow sidewalks that offer little protection from the speeding traffic; the residents of GGE-Unit 4 should expect no less quality of life than any other GGE residents. Please note that the Grace Romanian Baptist Church is not without a home. As per the petitioner's website, tl.y„V,e,Y.�. ,"w� zw the church presently has services at and is housed at the 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West. This location is far better suited for a traffic generating use of this type as there is a traffic light at this location; additionally, as per the site's most current Site Development Plan, only Phase 1 has been completed and there is plenty of space for expansion. To my knowledge, absolutely nobody has opposed or said anything negative about this location. Be it noted the petitioner also owns a third location at 6645 Willow Park Drive which is within a Commercial Planned Unit Development. 2 In closing, GGE-Unit 4 has already been disadvantaged and we seek to prevent even further decay to the rural quality of life enjoyed by other GGE residents. The traffic impact caused by the already approved non-estates uses are considerable and any increase to traffic will likely be detrimental. Lastly, please be reminded that the southern side of GGE-Unit 4 could be just as problematic and the actions taken on this petition could set precedent for that side. As the residents of GGE have spoken during the GGAMP re-study, you are asked to bide by their desires to maintain the Rural GGE as rural. The estates is more than a zoning classification, it's a quality way of life. Thank you, John Kelly 221 Weber Boulevard South Naples, Florida 34117-3033 3 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Tuesday, February 26, 2019 7:47 AM To: Robert Statile Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Baptist Church_Collier County project numbers_ PL20160002577 and PL20160002584 Mr.Statile, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. It is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider air comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. if!can be of assistance to you in the future please d0 not hesitate to contact my office. Vett W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 WEB PAGE: - From: Robert Statile<flplumbob6@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 9:03 PM To:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>;SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Baptist Church_Collier County project numbers_PL20160002577 and PL20160002584 Importance: High Dear Commissioners, The above referenced project numbers have been met with much resistance and protest by property owners such as myself. I attended the last meeting even though I only found out about it less than 24 hours prior. I witnessed the deceptive measures one lawyer would take to represent his client. What a turn off. He did not inform all property owners of their intentions,as he claimed. I was not informed. The fact remains the impact that Weber Blvd South will suffer due to heavy traffic in a residential street is monumental and is contrary to what he claimed. Obviously, no vehicles are going to exit on to Weber Blvd,turn right onto GG Blvd to make a U-turn and go back to Collier Boulevard. They will all drive south right down Weber and right past my home. I did not buy this home 19 years ago because I wanted to live near a freeway. I bought in a residential area. I have been a resident of Naples for 40 years and have watched the destruction done to many areas in the name of growth! To frame it bluntly, a church/drug rehab center has no place here. We have very high property values and want it kept that way! I do not appreciate the fact that they are so misrepresenting their intentions and once they sell,the restrictions will not have to be followed by the next buyer. The biggest complaint I have is,economically commercial properties should not be allowed in residential neighborhoods. I do not want to send a message that it is ok to spot zone commercial. This is clearly a black and white matter. I appreciate your time considering what I and so many other residents are saying and I trust that you will rule as if you were in our shoes and your money, and your privacy was in jeopardy. Let's put this to rest once and for all. Respectfully, Robert M. Statile 480 Weber Boulevard, South Naples, FL 34117 239-253-4722- Mobile 2 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Tuesday, February 26, 2019 7:46 AM To: Pat Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Church Mr. Miller, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. It is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider aii comments and information when this item is presented to the Boarci of County Commissioners. if!can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. all W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 1 WEB PAGE: From: Pat<millpat210@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 8:17 PM To: FialaDonna <Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>; andy.silis@colliercountyfl.gov; TaylorPenny <Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Grace Romanian Church Commissioners, My apologies but this information just came to my attention. I have to withdraw my support for this request. It is my understanding the petitioner already owns two additional properties one at 3380 Golden Gate Blvd and one at 6445 Willow Park Dr. Naples Both more suitable than the Non conforming use and GMP amendment required for the property located at 951 and Golden Gate Blvd. Please please vote no! Thank you Patrick K Miller 210 Weber Blvd S Naple Sent from XFINITY Connect App 1 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Tuesday, February 26, 2019 7:44 AM To: Carlene Thissen Subject: RE: NO, please to Grace Romanian Baptist Church Ms.Thissen, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. it is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider ail comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. If I can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. eat W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 WEB PAGE: rt From:Carlene Thissen<carlene_thissen@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 5:33 PM To: McDanielBill<Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>; FialaDonna<Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>;SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; SolisAndy <Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: NO, please to Grace Romanian Baptist Church I'm sorry this is getting to you late, but PLEASE do NOT let them build the church at the corner of 951 and GG Boulevard! We have two churches and a school on our street already. Literally HUNDREDS of parents line up on our street every weekday, so we can hardly get in and out of our homes on 1st Street. When the parents are not lined up, they are late, on their phones, and speeding up and down our street at 50 - 60 miles per hour and the Sheriffs office doesn't help. People constantly use Weber and 1st as a "cut-through" to get to GG Blvd from White. Our real estate values are going to drop really significantly --- and it's already really difficult to live on this street--- and no one helps us! Please don't add one more thing to mess with us. 1 Thank you for listening. I wish I could be there. Carlene A. Thissen 3670 1st Avenue SW Naples, FL 34117 239-290-5558 - cell carlene_thissen@yahoo.com www.reverbnation.com/carlenethissen www.carlenethissen.com Member: BMI Americana Community Music Association Global Songwriters Connection Nashville Songwriters Association Women of Substance Radio Female Musician Academy 2 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Tuesday, February 26, 2019 7:35 AM To: Barry Kotek Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Ms. Kotek, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. It is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider ail comments and information when this item is presented to the Hoard of County Commissioners. If t can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. W. L. McDaniel,Jr.,Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 WEB PAGE: — From: Barry Kotek<bkotekl@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 3:39 PM To: FialaDonna<Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>;SolisAndy<Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject:Grace Romanian Baptist Church Sent from Mail for Windows 10 Dear Commissioners, We have lived on 1st Ave SW for 14 years. We moved to Golden Gate Estates for the rural character of the area. Adding another church to an area that already has a park, an Elementary School and two other places of worship is just too much for the roadways. We walk our dog on 1st Ave and Weber and have almost been hit several times by speeding school parents or church members. We have complained about the speeders to the sheriff's department, but they have done nothing to alleviate the problem. We already have to deal with parent lining up on 1St between 2 and 3 pm to pick up their kids, making it a virtual parking lot. We also have to deal with cut through traffic on Weber, almost always above the 35 mph speed limit. We do not need another 300 parishioners traveling on Weber or 1St almost every day of the week. The property isn't currently zoned for a church and we strongly object to any changes to the zoning. We will not be able to make the meeting due to doctors appointments, but please take our strong feelings into consideration. 1 Sincere{1, Barry J. Kotek 2 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 12:26 PM To: 'Lauren Fraclose Osborne' Subject: RE: Letter of petition against church for February 26th meeting Ms. Osborne, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. It is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider all comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. If I can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. Bill W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 Original Message From: Lauren Fraclose Osborne<mrslaurenosborne@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 12:01 PM To: McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Letter of petition against church for February 26th meeting I apologize if your are not the appropriate person to send this letter too, but I have attached a letter of petition in reference to the building of a church at the corner of Golden Gate Blvd and Collier Blvd for the Tuesday, February 26th meeting to be held at 9am. I cannot personally attend.Thank you. -Lauren Osborne 1 I was asked to contact you in reference to this possible amendment located at the property at the corner of Collier Blvd and Golden Gate Blvd. The public hearing request is in reference to the building of a church there, Grace Romanian. Project Number:PL20160002577 and PL20160002584 I'd like to submit this letter, as I cannot personally attend the hearing that is set for Tuesday, February 26th at 9am, as a petition against the building of a church. My family and I live on Weber Blvd South just about a block away from this property. Modifying the amendment to allow the building of a church at this property, which would cause a lot more vehicular traffic, is definitely not what Weber Blvd South needs. Weber Blvd S is already used as a thru street for rush hour traffic Monday through Friday from Collier Blvd morning and evening, as well as for Big Cypress Elementary School Monday through Friday when school is in session, morning and afternoon. During the peak of these times, I refuse to walk on the sidewalk with my children along Weber Blvd S because of the consistent traffic speeding highly above the posted 30mph speed limit. I'm even very nervous about checking my mailbox. The Collier County Sheriffs Office has been requested numerous times to conduct speed enforcement along the road. There is no raised curb along the road and the sidewalk is only just 1 foot away from the main road. In addition, recently new traffic patterns at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd and Weber Blvd S, as well as the intersection of Weber Blvd S and White Blvd, have denied traffic from making left turns. One entrance exit Their current church i., 9 � t!_e No U-turn* € r.f' �� 3t'4 Sts 91 '=,e_?l Fs t . Fr 1rr No left turn Max A Hasse Jr Community P.:'< • 1 : ' ,,_.:Ce, 7 ... '....4%.„, tittist‘ 4 ,,,L : - ' . . e1 'i e 0 ,_., _____ _ _ No left turn „ ► Itli Ho n• Gold 1 Ga n Get Blvd�n9 Blvd W 50 ' .,4 r 0 " %" Ito .4,,i,,... 3 I , , •1'' � 4 em k 1 , _ ve 6,5 a _ _ # The intersection of Golden Gate Blvd and Weber Blvd Sl has a raised median ina place, but the intersection of Weber Blvd S and White Blvd has a painted median which many people consistently violate to make a left turnfrom Weber Blvd S to travel east on White Blvd. If the building of a church is granted there at that property, there will be an increase of vehicular traffic during church functions everyday f the week as well as on Sunday. That will be an additional 2 days, making it 7 days a week of vehicular traffic that is not residental, that travel on Weber Blvd S. :x a rlY1 . „ ,_ , .. ..,2 .,,, 41,..t., .:: ',.;','" ',, - .--:_Or'' ''''''','''' ,,,. -•:ft:‘" ''..: 'f'''- y 114 ''##1,1 ' oridiTi ,.,4„ 'tkir".,-.:_, --,..- '..,,,,44,,A,.. .-- N-.. . ':"-- ' r, x--v, - ...-- „ 1-7-* - 4.. '..,;i-1. t., -.10, *--..-vt , --.* r;,.., -_,.-4, - 4,7,..; ,-,, , . e ' 1,' .ii, ' ' 4:4'0' ' '',) ,' . .-,_ --',::.-44,:;.......ro'r ''' -111N"!--,140.,,,,'.",,,'.:; . - -4r,--',.4._ , ';',i,...,\. 1.--..4...tti 'r-.-ttt. ,:': . , ' ' .,,,,.-: -• ,40- , .--it si4xi.,.",-:, ' -.1 -...f.- . j':!..401...;. ',".... ------, '` . . to „it__it No let't turn Ct> -. i v a�vd C Ott) ::::;'I OW -t 4t z- .,I --- ", . i ' t--,::' 'Il:-... It"It" --. - -r-t7' " , --#''1'1 ''' I I- ' ..t„; -.1.'''''' '41'1* f it=' lit -: In addition to traffic, there are a few churches within a 1 mile radius of the intersection that are an option for a place of worship. Not to mention the fact that Grace Romanian already owns a church property not even a mile down the road from their new proposed church. They already own the church that contain a parking lot, facilities and everything else that they need! New proposed Current church existing church 11' 0 ,, P i3t-vc�`: ,n ett;Gaze ii4ve V4' F thtr r;Napie-, ell ^t,rtac e Rr, ri r art .. jcorn Hall MO 1 C. .!r. rtit M{ax A Ncai.> 4 Jr f;Urroaurtrty ':ark It's our family's, and other neighbor's opinion, that the only reason they want to acquire this property is to purposely build a residental structure, as well as their church, in order to live on the property tax free. They already own an existing church right down the road, a few thousand feet away. My family and I politely request that this amendment is denied for the building of a place of worship, and to remain for residential structures only. -The Osbornes 161 Weber Blvd S FilsonSue From: Brad Cornell <millercornell@mindspring.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 11:55 AM To: FilsonSue; McDanielBill Subject: Conservation Collier Ordinance:2 concerns Hi Commissioner McDaniel and Ms. Filson: I hope you had a good weekend. I want to bring your attention to two concerns Audubon Western Everglades has with the Conservation Collier ordinance revisions on your Summary agenda tomorrow (both were raised in the first reading last month): 1. Section 14, Policy 7:Audubon Western Everglades recommends keeping the language that is stricken in order to allow for lot trading to help complete multi-parcel acquisition projects like Red Maple Swamp and Winchester Head (both in Golden Gate Estates). The idea is that if the Conservation Collier had bought an upland lot in the Estates or elsewhere and it no longer met the needs of the program, it could be traded with the owner of a lot within the multi-parcel project area being acquired. So far,that apparently hasn't occurred but it is just a strategy that seems possibly useful. 2. Most importantly,there is a Whereas clause portion in the existing ordinance that dedicates use of Conservation Collier funds to the purposes of the program which Audubon and our conservation colleagues want retained. Despite staff's assertion that it remains part of the legislative history, it's deletion appears to anyone not a lawyer to mean such a dedication or restriction on the use of Conservation Collier funds no longer exists. The Whereas Clause is the 5th one in the proposed revised ordinance. Here is the deletion of that dedication reference in strikethrough form (a deletion not shown in the proposed revised ordinance): WHEREAS,it is the intent of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County to establish Conservation Collier to implement this mandate and to support its purposes to the fullest, '•-' '• . - : , .- '• - ••-• -. . :-, - - - '- _ - - =- =_ - ;and I've asked another commissioner to pull this off the Summary agenda, but it would be great if you supported that and the brief discussion needed to sort these two issues out. Thanks, Brad Brad Cornell Southwest Florida Policy Associate Audubon of the Western Everglades/Audubon Florida 1048 Goodlette-Frank Road, North, Suite 201 Naples, FL 34102 239-280-6278 bcornell(a audubonwe.org 1 filsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 10:15 AM To: 'John Kelly' Subject: RE: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A - Grace Romanian Baptist Church Mr. Kelly, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. it is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider ail comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. If:can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. i W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 WEB PAGE: From:John Kelly<johnkellyfl@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 9:58 AM To:GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov>; FilsonSue<Sue.Filson@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Fwd: Feb 26,2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A-Grace Romanian Baptist Church Good morning, It would be appreciated if you would please forward this e-mail to your respective Commissioner as it was previously returned to me by the automated mailer-daemon. Thank you kindly Original Message From:John Kelly<iohnkellyfl@comcast.net> To: Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov,Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov, Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov, Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov, Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov Date: February 25,2019 at 12:30 AM Subject: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A-Grace Romanian Baptist Church Dear Commissioners, 1 • I have been a resident of Golden Gate Estates (GGE) -Unit 4 in excess of 25-years. During that time I have watched the gradual decay of the Rural Estates quality of life.The residents of GGE-Unit 4 have located for the same reasons as those of other GGE residents; affordability,tranquility, avoidance of urban traffic, and an appreciation for wildlife. Unfortunately, it seems the residents of GGE-Unit 4 are paying a much higher price than any other unit within GGE as it is bordered by major roadways to the north, south and west; not to mention that Weber Boulevard South has become a high-speed bypass for Collier Boulevard.To that end, Weber Boulevard South already served,via 1st Avenue SW, as access to two Jehovah's Witness Kingdom Halls operating on the same property, Max Hasse Community Park, and what was a failed Presbyterian Church located at 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West(approximately 3,200 feet east of the subject property)which was purchased in September, 2018, by the petitioner.The residents in this area are frustrated with the amount of traffic,the lack of traffic control, and the loss of the rural estates character and quality of life.The residents I have spoken with all believe that a traffic generating use at the subject location is an accident waiting to happen. Interestingly,you have heard this petition before and a vote was taken which resulted in the project's defeat; unfortunately, as a result of comments made by the petitioner's counsel after the close of public comment, Commissioner McDaniel motioned for the vote to be withdrawn and the item be sent back to the Planning Commission (CCPC).The comment made by the petitioner's counsel was that you,the BCC, have rejected the last three churches that were proposed at major intersections and that he no longer knows where to tell clients they can have a church. Commissioner McDaniel also noted that he would have liked to have seen better notification to the residents of GGE and desired to see if anything could be done to ameliorate the impacts of a church on the community.To that end,the petition was re-heard by the CCPC however only minimal changes resulted. More concerning is the fact there was no greater effort to notify the estates residents of this project and based upon the location of this project it will impact upon many GGE residents. As such, please note that your staff just held extensive outreach efforts with respect to the new Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP)that was recently approved by you for transmittal to the State.The subject location is located within the Rural Estates. GGAMP outreach efforts performed by your staff examined uses and recommended areas for change as based upon their findings; no changes were proposed for the subject properties and the general consensus of the study was that Rural GGE residents ultimately desired no changes that would impact upon the rural estates quality of life.The Rural GGE residents have spoken and you are urged to respect their desires. As to the question posed by the petitioner's counsel, there should have never been an expectation that a church could be permitted at the subject location as it is not allowable by either the existing GGAMP nor that just transmitted to the State.The criteria for applying for a small scale amendment to the GGAMP are very few and nearly everyone eligible to apply will satisfy said criteria, as such your staff should be much more critical in evaluating and analyzing such petitions;your constituents are counting on you to make things right.There is no question that property located within the GGE is less expensive than that in the urban area. Does that mean every GGE intersection is destined to be approved for a conditional use? How much sense does that make? Please,the subject project is not necessarily a bad one; unfortunately,the location is horrible.Any applicant for a conditional use should expect push-back; alternatively,they'd likely be welcomed at an appropriately zoned commercial location. I'd further suggest that the County define the term"community church"as perhaps at a lesser scale the project wouldn't be quite as problematic at the subject location. GGE is home to much of the areas working class, weekends are when these residents are outside trying to enjoy their peace and tranquility, weekends are when they walk the narrow sidewalks that offer little protection from the speeding traffic; the residents of GGE-Unit 4 should expect no less quality of life than any other GGE residents. Please note that the Grace Romanian Baptist Church is not without a home. As per the petitioner's website, [www.grbcn.org,](http://www.grbcn.org,)the church presently has services at and is housed at the 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West.This location is far better suited for a traffic generating use of this type as there is a traffic light at this location;additionally,as per the site's most current Site 2 Development Plan, only Phase 1 has been completed and there is plenty of space for expansion. To my knowledge,absolutely nobody has opposed or said anything negative about this location. Be it noted the petitioner also owns a third location at 6645 Willow Park Drive which is within a Commercial Planned Unit Development. In closing, GGE-Unit 4 has already been disadvantaged and we seek to prevent even further decay to the rural quality of life enjoyed by other GGE residents.The traffic impact caused by the already approved non-estates uses are considerable and any increase to traffic will likely be detrimental. Lastly, please be reminded that the southern side of GGE-Unit 4 could be just as problematic and the actions taken on this petition could set precedent for that side. As the residents of GGE have spoken during the GGAMP re-study,you are asked to bide by their desires to maintain the Rural GGE as rural.The estates is more than a zoning classification, it's a quality way of life. Thank you, John Kelly 221 Weber Boulevard South Naples, Florida 34117-3033 3 • Filsc raue From: James Schortemeyer <schortfire@aol.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 7:24 AM To: McDanielBill Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted February 2019 Bill, Thanks for the prompt reply and suggestion. Unfortunately, I will not be able to attend the Tuesday meeting. I will check and see if I can get someone to attend and submit or read my statement as part of the public record. Jim Schortemeyer Original Message From: McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> To: James Schortemeyer<schortfire@aol.com> Sent: Mon, Feb 25, 2019 7:12 am Subject: RE: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted February 2019 Mr. Schortemeyer, Thank you for sharing your additional comments and suggestions. This item is on the agenda for Tuesday, February 26, 2019, agenda item 8A. You may want to plan to be present to make your requests part of the public record. Bill William L. McDaniel, Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 Bill.mcdaniel@colliercountyfl.gov Web Page WEB PAGE: — From: James Schortemeyer<schortfire@aol.com> Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 9:23 AM To: McDanielBill <Bitt.McDaniel@cotliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted February 2019 Honorable Commissioner McDaniel, Thanks for sending this item back to our planning commission for further review in November of 2018. Unfortunately, they were unable to address most of my concerns and once again, I urge you to deny this petition. If approved this change will continue and exacerbate the degradation of our rural lifestyle in Golden Gate Estates, especially here in Unit 4. One cluster development is enough in each square mile of the estates (We already have 2 churches, one park, and one school located in the NE corner of Unit 4). Incidentally, one of these churches is apparently owned by the Petitioner. Lastly, in the event that you are in the minority and a favorable vote is imminent I would urge the following: 1 1. Require an easement be established on the western edge of the property to allow public recreational use and access to the South Florida Water Management District Water Way. The width and use of that easement should be similar to that availaale adjacent to St. Agnes Church to the north and many other locations throughout the county. As Always, Thanks for consideration and diligent work, Jim Schortemeyer Original Message From: James Schortemeyer<schortfire@aol.com> To: BillMcDaniel <BillMcDaniel©colliergov.net> Sent: Mon, Nov 5, 2018 10:28 am Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, Honorable Commissioner McDaniel, PLEASE DENY THIS PETITION. Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, a Growth Management Plan Small Scale Amendment specific to the Conditional Uses Subdistrict of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan, to allow church uses for the Grace Romanian Baptist Church. (Adoption Hearing) [This is a Companion to Agenda Item 6976] South Weber Blvd. has already been adversely impacted by zoning changes on first avenue SW and so called road 'improvements' on Golden Gate Blvd. and White Blvd. Left turns are not allowed onto either of these roads from South Weber BLVD. Traffic patterns are already intolerable and another zoning 'exception' along this corridor should not be approved. It will further exacerbate traffic issues with increased illegal turns, u turns, and wrong way traffic. The Weber Blvd. Estates Zoning has already been severely severely compromised by high volume traffic on CR 951, White Blvd. and golden Gate Blvd. Along with already approved variances including nearby commercial developments we are at the threshold of losing the wildlife and environmental benefits that we cherish. Right now, we are fortunate to have large mammals such as deer, panther and black bear frequent our neighborhood but there have already been too many vehicle collisions with these large mammals. Please protect our'estates zoning', environmental values, and wildlife by denying this petition to allow another zoning exception in Unit 4, GGE. Jim Schortemeyer 3481 5th ave sw Naples, Fl Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 7:22 AM To: 'Renate' Subject: RE: BCC 2/26/19 - Grace Romanian Baptist Church - PL20160002577 & PL20160002584 Ms. Kelly, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. It is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider all comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. If I can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. Bill W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 Original Message From: Renate<renjakl@comcast.net> Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 9:14 PM To: FialaDonna <Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>; SolisAndy<Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: BCC 2/26/19-Grace Romanian Baptist Church- PL20160002577& P120160002584 Dear Commissioners, Time is running out for all of us living on Weber Blvd.S. And 1st Avenue SW. We all moved to the quiet country setting to enjoy life to the fullest. We loved all the extras that came with it : little traffic, many different species of animals,we even had people riding their horses on our streets. Traffic on Weber is as fast if not faster than on 951. I am 88 years of age and have a hard time crossing the road to get my mail. Please help us to preserve the rural character of the Golden Gate Estates! We do not mind the church only the traffic it brings. They already have a church+/-3,000 feet down the street. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Renate S. Kelly 291 Weber Blvd S. Naples. Fl. 34117-3033. 1 FllsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 7:19 AM To: 'David Stonitsch' Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Mr.Stonitsch, Thank you for contacting me to express your opposition to the proposed Grace Romanian Baptist Church. it is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider aii comments and information when this item is presented to the i'soard of County Commissioners. f: can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. ate W. L. McDaniel,Jr.,Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 1111 WEB PAGE: From: David Stonitsch <dstonitsch@hotmail.com> Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 8:20 PM To:donna.fiala@collierrcountyfl.gov; andy.silis@colliercountyfl.gov; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill <BiII.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject:Grace Romanian Baptist Church Dear Mr. Chairman, I am writing to you about project PL20160002577, PL 2016002584, Grace Romanian Baptist Church. They are proposing a church at the corner of Collier Blvd, and Golden Gate Blvd. There is only one entrance/exit proposed off of Golden Gate Blvd. This is a terrible idea. My wife and I live on Weber Blvd and we already have too much traffic bypassing Collier going to Golden Gate Blvd. We purchased in the estates to have extra land for our three grandsons. By adding this commercial building it will make this street less safe for children and wildlife. The Golden Gate Master plan was just approved by the board last month, and it did not include changing the church property. The people of this area, like the rural lifestyle and do not want commercialization. We are asking that this change in the master plan is not approved. At a minimum, there should be an entrance and exit only accessible on Collier Blvd. Please keep any additional traffic off of Weber Blvd. It is barely wide enough for the traffic that is currently on it now. 1 Thanks, David and Vickie Stonitsch 840 Weber Blvd S Naples, FL 34117 2 Filso:1Sue From: McDanielBill Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 7:13 AM To: 'James Schortemeyer' Subject: RE: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted February 2019 Mr. Schortemeyer, Thank you for sharing your additional comments and suggestions. This item is on the agenda for Tuesday, February 26, 2019, agenda item 8A. You may want to plan to be present to make your requests part of the public record. William L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 Bill.mcdaniel@colliercountyfl.gov Web Page-, WEB PAGE: From:James Schortemeyer<schortfire@aol.com> Sent:Sunday, February 24, 2019 9:23 AM To: McDanielBill<Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted February 2019 Honorable Commissioner McDaniel, Thanks for sending this item back to our planning commission for further review in November of 2018. Unfortunately, they were unable to address most of my concerns and once again, I urge you to deny this petition. If approved this change will continue and exacerbate the degradation of our rural lifestyle in Golden Gate Estates, especially here in Unit 4. One cluster development is enough in each square mile of the estates (We already have 2 churches, one park, and one school located in the NE corner of Unit 4). Incidentally, one of these churches is apparently owned by the Petitioner. Lastly, in the event that you are in the minority and a favorable vote is imminent I would urge the following: 1. Require an easement be established on the western edge of the property to allow public recreational use and access to the South Florida Water Management District Water Way. The width and use of that easement should be similar to that available adjacent to St. Agnes Church to the north and many other locations throughout the county. As Always, Thanks for consideration and diligent work, Jim Schortemeyer 1 Original Message From James Schortemeyer<schortfireaaol.com> To: BillMcDaniel < ,,. ��n,, ri42.4•> Sent: Mon, Nov 5, 2018 10:28 am Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, Honorable Commissioner McDaniel, PLEASE DENY THIS PETITION. Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, a Growth Management Plan Small Scale Amendment specific to the Conditional Uses Subdistrict of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan, to allow church uses for the Grace Romanian Baptist Church. (Adoption Hearing) [This is a Companion to Agenda Item 6976] South Weber Blvd. has already been adversely impacted by zoning changes on first avenue SW and so called road 'improvements' on Golden Gate Blvd. and White Blvd. Left turns are not allowed onto either of these roads from South Weber BLVD. Traffic patterns are already intolerable and another zoning 'exception' along this corridor should not be approved. It will further exacerbate traffic issues with increased illegal turns, u turns, and wrong way traffic. The Weber Blvd. Estates Zoning has already been severely severely compromised by high volume traffic on CR 951, White Blvd. and golden Gate Blvd. Along with already approved variances including nearby commercial developments we are at the threshold of losing the wildlife and environmental benefits that we cherish. Right now, we are fortunate to have large mammals such as deer, panther and black bear frequent our neighborhood but there have already been too many vehicle collisions with these large mammals. Please protect our'estates zoning', environmental values, and wildlife by denying this petition to allow another zoning exception in Unit 4, GGE. Jim Schortemeyer 3481 5th ave sw Naples, Fl 2 Filson-Sue From: Patrick Miller <Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent: Thursday, February 21, 2019 11:19 AM To: McDanielBill Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Church Request Bill, Thanks for your response. Pat Patrick K. ! litter Senior Vice President Lake Michigan Credit Union i \h1 • (239) 919-1362 U( I 11C r \\ (239)216-2285 (mobile) 3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 1 Naples FL 34103-2714 Patrick.MillerCa�lmcu.org I LMCU.org 4]_S 111.Y-4 9 3 1 106 0 0 1:1 From: McDanielBill [mailto:Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyf.gov] Sent: Thursday, February 21, 2019 11:04 AM To: Patrick Miller Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Church Request WARNING: This email originated outside of INCU. Pat, You are right;this is item number 8A on the BCC agenda for February 26'. I nave asked for possible traffic calming measures if this should be approved. Also,for your information, Sue Filson, my Aide posts the agenda to my web page for your convenience. The entire agenda is posted along with the issues that affect District S. hope this helps. It is very helpful to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider all comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. If I can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 3299 Tamiami Trail, East 1 Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 IIIIIWeb"Pag. WEB PAGE: — From: Patrick Miller<Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent:Thursday, February 21, 2019 10:57 AM To: McDanielBill<Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Grace Romanian Church Request Importance: High Bill, I know this is coming to the Board on Tuesday. I know it will be approved I'm not against it but we need your help with traffic calming on Weber Blvd S. The traffic each day in the morning and in the afternoon has no concern for the residence on the street and 95% never obey the speed limit. We need to either have some speed humps installed or stop signs or anything to slow the traffic down. The amount of traffic is directly related to school drop off and pickups and people using Weber Blvd S to bypass 951 ! I ask you and each of the commissioners to help us with the County Traffic department in making our nice residential street safe again so people can walk and ride Bikes on the bike path safely with traffic not re than a couple of feet away traveling at high speed it is not safe. Thank you for your time and all you do for the people of Collier County. Pat Patrick K. Miller Senior Vice President Lake Michigan Credit Union I \KI (239) 919-1362 \,,it, i II( ,;\\ : (239)216-2285 (mobile) 3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 I Naples FL 34103-2714 Patrick.Miller lmcu.orq I LMCU.oro NMLS ID# 911706 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Thursday,January 17, 2019 8:54 AM To: 'bmisalz@aol.com' Subject: RE: Proposed church on GGB and 951 Mr. Baxter, • Thank you for contacting me on January 17, 2019 expressing your opposition to the proposed church on 951 and Golden Gate Boulevard. This item was heard by the Board on November 13, 2018 and,at that time,the Board voted to send this petition sack to the CCPC. it is very he pfui to receive your input on the issues that concern you. Your opinion is important to me and I will carefully consider all comments and information when this item is presented to the Board of County Commissioners. If i can be of assistance to you in the future please do not hesitate to contact my office. W. L. McDaniel,Jr., Chairman Commissioner, District 5 • 3299 Tamiami Trail, East Naples, FL 34112 239-252-8605 11111 Weii,Page WEB PAGE: — From: bmisalz@aol.com<bmisalz@aol.com> Sent:Thursday,January 17, 2019 7:51 AM To: FialaDonna <Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>; SolisAndy<Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: BMISalz@aol.com; FaulknerSue<Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Proposed church on GGB and 951 Good morning, A little late to the party, my apologies. The proposed church on the corner of GGB and 951 should not be approved. Strictly from a traffic aspect, the property will greatly affect the residential neighborhood around it with increased traffic. The application calls for a 24/7 operation, and the size of the property is a sure indication of future expansion plans. The application also acknowledges that if they are successful in rezoning this property, the one on the North side of the intersection will follow suit. Also, the vagueness of the answers provided to the residents of GGE at the neighborhood meeting are disconcerting to put it mildly: "Approximately 23 citizens, 4 members of the applicant's team, and the 2 planners from the County attended the NIM. Questions and concerns from the attendees included: • • Number of acres for project site? 6.25 acres • '• Number of square feet of storage shed? 1,800 sq. feet • • Types of special events? Not defined yet • •Where will special events be held on the site? in the pastor's residence? Outdoors? If outside, could be in parking area, or in open area, if pastor residence not built. • •Traffic is already a nightmare. Applicant will continue to work with County staff. • •Traffic access to site locations. Applicant will continue to work with County staff. • •Could a bridge entrance be constructed over the Collier Blvd. canal? Not possible, since land that would be needed does not belong to church and safe distance from Golden Gate Blvd could not be accommodated. • • If an event is held in parking area, where will people park?As part of a special event permit a parking plan is required. • • Do not want carnival or revival type events. Agent asked if citizen wanted any other types of events eliminated. • • Speeding on Weber Blvd. Citizens need to work with Sherriff's office. • • Have an off-duty officer for traffic control. • • Churches do not pay property taxes. • •What will be cleared in the preserve area? Only native vegetation would remain. • • Dates of Public Hearings. No dates were set yet. " • Before the permit should even be considered, the applicant at the least should come back to the residents and address the concerns listed above. Otherwise, the approval of this rezoning is essentially an open book to do what they want with no consideration of the impact to the neighbors in a residential neighborhoods peace, privacy and home values. Regards, -SSB- Scott S. Baxter "The true science piscatorial is occupation without ostentation, fun without fury, patience without glory; a desire for nothing better nor fear of anything worse-an existence in vacuum." A.V. Dockery(from the book Bass and other Fishing in the Carolinas, 1909.) Please do not print this e-ma!! eun!ess necessary 2 FilsonSue From: StrainMark Sent: Friday,January 18, 2019 1:16 PM To: FilsonSue Hi Sue. ,(t/q \7S' Grace stop signs t� 1.pdf.pdf PIT Grace stop signs 2.pdf During the efforts to process Grace Romanian Church, neighbors expressed concern over the traffic and speeds along Weber in their area. I had suggested stop signs to slow the traffic down, as just one idea to help. Attached is a layout for a single or even two, stop sign locations along Weber. At the time,transportation did not want to impede traffic along this route but the neighborhood would like something done on Weber to slow and discourage traffic. I discussed this today with Bill and he asked I send this a something to initiate a conversation with when the issue comes up. Thanks, Hank, 239.252.4446 oer wnca zap.e-mail addresses are public recordsif you do not want your e-mail address_released in response to a t...u,ic,ecwk as iequea�, v„ui sw electronic mail to this entity Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 '�k i £r t .: .>:;, a 4a sir + r. , } 4:.i is. "�, ' '11�-w-. � '�` `' boA , ..r .cr• d.EY'. A s �. Q i y �E- � R>r �' '"'t: F ; ,„:„ 9G• , . . �� t $fir • • may. ,-- '`+^ -,„„ 3 3 t 1 aa..' t#� f "fes '...14,11,-,fig ---,- " .--.*„...„...4 :s T. `""".vim" : .-► ir.: � � `� °'�' 44.r'-',".. --4 s� s� i I p r ° .tom'a, # j'r e t;;,..#' '7 >!1. waaa x CJ a Yom. xt IIi ? '!. .. as 1 TJ l >' �'} 4 'C 3fi tX f;K: .. ...„t. :42 -iii,i;o= '.. I i i!"-- . ! A 3 � �` . ,,at ,'3 r , ,�a r . mea k'a r ¢ y. *4.4. 'x s fir` -%, — #'y ry ' t4:,-;. a �'I" ° „,,1„,,V. ,s� sip Xtra >.A# .a,4 y` #w”` ! 4J, .,.m-? ' �. y; "'it 's! +.ems a A iE.fi x+-h-- i ,iyfn, ., z r * yam"' �. � `+y3 6 T 41. y7 r a t ,s" - - . �t Pte -+� •ap g: 3 •` $ ".T4t-it: ,-4:-, ......- .''''.).--kli .. _S_L $"" '- s msµ; -r , x .s SAM' y tt u �s Wt; #"P fit" ` � kL.' .£' - .. M . ,j .t' .. !...-;'1';',,gsli'''''''----'1` -et .1 1 CP:4p ,,:i,-„,',:' .,!-It.'''' rr r iI y 'OA ,,:: . . ,...-. ....#' -.....r k,.., f 4 . .. , , . , $ $ .„,. , _,‘ �� sem , ili; 41,11 t r .,._ ,., ' c4 c 'a it iu,I5. ,,,,, , .,4„... .. f.t.....8.0. -, _, ,,_„..,.,,,,.4„...: ,„.,:siti _ -' • �� •2. 1V,4`;`, { V l� �;� . �, . tp` ♦ „3„„,,,,,,„,,,I., , ,.. ., . ., , ..1....7„ ...,,,,,, ..t....4 . ff-4 �w r1 �( t '4,41, tx .' > iw' '4r'0cr,a 1.3.--4;::s .tea. , em ,'. -_-. :.. v ,- . A - itir .,. ,.. /11104,,,,.....„t - i -. , .- a � w rti ' --,.*.i.,,,,,, 4..... .....„..... ...„._. a .�..i - d r-�r4 .-.t,. _ ':;.'„.7''''':";..:0'.f4.1%.-"4",'.: may x M,�. R'''"r' . ` ! ' s',,,Vt , il• pa` -a, - 3 -<:-...4 t.#.- :. - ` 30. `.! -pt V ' -p - ` ' . fit, s ak* ,� � ... `. it , _'-'-`,.• 4 0°44,„ * *-1-t!., ,., � `< s§r, ". . s °44 > sig„' , i s°!r, . "yam `'.. '» -1,,,...-,..4 • �, � �' '4 � a s ..' :. r # 7 F a .=.xkilt �,. .,fir a' Ar,.v ' , & ,. v .rte . ..:. _ . fir'. .:. . S:r" yat ;sr �► * "., 'ipt. sLs, `.V�. .. r ``.i "�5 :. p`'• «�'#ate d-,----, ..: , - --- 4-. t ass -4 ,' ; ,. .. . .,.., . 0. „ lc?, :,....,.....,,,......,,. ..,. _ .....1 . „ .. ... ,i.,:. ,.. . . . , _ s x* ,,, � +y' F' ,'Y^h'-i t -JFK x R � 4” ` tom, , 0, �. _04, ' + "` . i 4t.. ,' �at'.. ^1 ash t FilsonSue From: Gary VanDeWerken <garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, November 15, 2018 3:31 PM To: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaboJames; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna; FaulknerSue; StrainMark; HomiakKaren; stanchzanowski@colliergov.net; FryerEdwin; SchmittJoseph Cc: GARY VANDEWERKEN Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Attachments: W-2_2.pdf;ATT00001.txt;Willow_2.pdf; ATT00002.txt To Collier County Commissioners and Planning,Just a couple of concerns. Did this church shrink in size they bought and rezoned then sold land in 2011 on Learning Lane and Livingston Road because they were asking for 500 seats and 150 preschool students on 14.3 acres. They acquired property on Golden gate Blvd and 1st Ave SW looking to rezone as conditional use purchased on 11/28/16 Then purchased another property at 6645 Willow Park Drive less than a year ago purchased on 12/11/17 I believe there attorney said they have outgrown this property as well. But failed to mention the new church they recently purchased. Located at Max Hasse Park on 9/20/18 Thank you for your time, Gary VanDeWerken 1 • AGENDA COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION WILL MEET AT 9:00 A.M.,THURSDAY,APRIL 7,2011,IN THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING ROOM, ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER,THIRD FLOOR,3299 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST,NAPLES,FLORIDA: NOTE: INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO 5 MINUTES ON ANY ITEM. INDIVIDUALS SELECTED TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF AN ORGANIZATION OR GROUP ARE ENCOURAGED AND MAY BE ALLOTTED 10 MINUTES TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM IF SO RECOGNIZED BY THE CHAIRMAN. PERSONS WISHING TO HAVE WRITTEN OR GRAPHIC MATERIALS INCLUDED IN THE CCPC AGENDA PACKETS MUST SUBMIT SAID MATERIAL A MINIMUM OF 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE RESPECTIVE PUBLIC HEARING. IN ANY CASE, WRITTEN MATERIALS INTENDED TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE CCPC SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE APPROPRIATE COUNTY STAFF A MINIMUM OF SEVEN DAYS PRIOR TO THE PUBLIC HEARING.ALL MATERIAL USED IN PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE CCPC WILL BECOME A PERMANENT PART OF THE RECORD AND WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IF APPLICABLE. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE CCPC WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 2. ROLL CALL BY SECRETARY 3. ADDENDA TO THE AGENDA 4. PLANNING COMMISSION ABSENCES 5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 6. BCC REPORT-RECAPS 7. CHAIRMAN'S REPORT 8. CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS A. PUDZ-2005-AR-8674: Grace Romanian Baptist Church of Naples CFPUD.An Ordinance of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County,Florida,amending Ordinance Number 04-41,as amended,the Collier County Land Development Code, which includes the comprehensive zoning regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from an Agricultural (A) zoning district with a portion of the real property in a ST overlay (Special Treatment) to a Community Facility Planned Unit Development(CFPUD)zoning district with removal of the ST overlay 1 • for a project known as Grace Romanian Baptist Church of Naples CFPUD. The project will allow development of a 500 seat church,a single family residence and preschool of up to 150 students along with other permitted and accessory uses commonly associated with a church and preschool use. The property is located at the corner of Learning Lane and Livingston Road in Section 13, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida, consisting of 12 +/- acres and by providing an effective date. [Coordinator:Kay Deselem,AICP,Principal Planner] 9. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS A. PUDZ-2007-AR-12292: Cope Reserve RPUD--An ordinance amending Ordinance Number 2004-41,the Collier County Land Development Code, which includes the comprehensive zoning regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps; by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from the Estates(E)Zoning District to the Residential Planned Unit Development (RPUD) Zoning District for a project to be known as the Cope Reserve RPUD. The project proposes a total of 43 dwelling units comprised of single-family detached,single-family attached, multi-family and townhouse unit types, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, consisting of 14.3± acres; and by providing an effective date. [Coordinator:Kay Deselem,AICP,Principal Planner] 10. OLD BUSINESS 11. NEW BUSINESS A. Comprehensive Planning section staff requesting coordination for the availability of the Collier County Planning Commission for upcoming "Special" CCPC meetings for FY 2011/2012. [Coordinator: Mike Bosi,Comprehensive Planning Manager] 12. PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM 13. DISCUSSION OF ADDENDA 14. ADJOURN 3/28/2011 CCPC Agenda/Ray Bellows/jmp 2 Collier County Property Appraiser . Property Summary ,,, P:41: � 6645 '! �4 ; , �t ,,,„q y x�rz' � ;:�.e4,,a�.WILLOW v 1 82597000188 ;; NAPLES i 34109 j :� -� PARK : 0 ; I `SDR . 4 , N ! Name/ ddb°,GRACE ROMANIAN BAPTIST CHURCH OF NAPLES INC4_ _._ __. 6645 WILLOW PARK DRIVE .......wM . __... ._ . �fP. NAPLES �1 `�� FL -�4 34109 1 p h x xr z� �$ _��*-,T' 'yh.' der `.: a 3 .Acre +s mR� ' ' Md.PF.Ia. r� .«.... s' ... :,....."'µ..;.ew' "`......,....,�..•A. :ke. .:8,. .. . A, .z' •.aa.�.. . 5 CPPB 6" 4A01 720200 74A01 1 49 25 ! 8 1 _. _ ... WILLOW PARK LOT 7 Sub ICond 720200 -WILLOW PARK V , m ;, x '� x :� 1 C • STORY 18 - OFFICE BLDG, NON-PROF, MULT 5,049 1 5.8222 1 10.8712 .._ w__ _._._._. __... .._ Latest Sales History 2018 Certified Tax Roll (Not all Sates are listed due to Cor�f cier�t at�t (Subject to Cha e} Date Qok. Page;" , E ' ,' ,� , 3 � $ 354,677; fit 701 987 i. 12/11/17 5457-3083 . ____ $ 1,555,000.1 1 *,:` i ;. 11/28/06 4144 3738 $ 0 ` ,:;,..7..,., r% , $ 1 056,664 12128!05 = 3955-1884 $ 0 �F , ° ,. i , . _$ 1,056,664; 06/10/99 2557-1408 $ 325,000 1,0 6,6 _ _ 5 s4 x ` 11 ' _ ry .$ 1,056,6.64, If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created • after the Final Tax Roil Fit'onSue rrom: Gary VanDeWerken <garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, November 15, 2018 12:09 PM To: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaboJames; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna; FaulknerSue; StrainMark; HomiakKaren; stanchzanowski@colliergov.net; FryerEdwin; SchmittJoseph Cc: GARY VANDEWERKEN Subject: URGENT ATTENTION (CCPC) Grace Romanian Baptist Church Attachments: CCE 15112018_2.pdf;ATT00001.txt To the board of Collier County Commissioners, It has come to my attention that Grace Romanian Baptist Church has purchased an existing church located by Max Hasse Park on 9/20/18, when Grace Romanian Baptist Church presented this project to the board for rezoning this was not mentioned to the commissioners. Is this church involved in real estate business? Im a Weber Blvd Resident of 32 years and care for my neighborhood and would like to keep it quiet as possible with less traffic. Thanks For your time Gary VanDeWerken 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary 3380 Site Parcel No 36765600007 Address GATE GOLDEN Site City NAPLES Site Zone34117 BLVD W Name / Address GRACE ROMANIAN BAPTIST CHURCH OF NAPLES INC 6017 PINE RIDGE RD P0 BOX 84 City NAPLES State FL Zip 34119 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres 1Estimated 4B11 326500 97 04E311 11 49 26 4.77 Legal GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 4 TR 97 e Area 0 11 Millage Rates 0 'Calculations Sub./Condo 326500 - GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 4 School Other Total Use Code 0 71 - CHURCHES 5.049 6.3222 11.3712 Latest Sales History 2018 Certified Tax Roil - - Date Book-Page Amount Land Value S 242,793 09/20/18 555'87313 $ 1,000,000 (+) Improved Value $ 480,407 09/18/18 5554-2900 $ 0 (--) Market Value $ 723,200 06111196 2196-19.6G $ 185,000 Assessed Value $ 723,200 05/28/96 218i-753 $ 0 ol 01108/96 253-2schoTaxable Value 302 $ 0 01/08/96 2136-737 $ 0 Taxable Valre 12113/95 2128-85G 5 3 12/06/91 1569-23-20 $ 52,000 11/01/88 1395-1058 $ 0 04/01/87 1260-346 $ 0 FilsonSue From: McDanielBill Sent: Wednesday, November 14, 2018 2:58 PM To: Gary VanDeWerken Cc: McDanielBill Subject: RE: "Property Zoned Residential Estates Keep it Residential" Grace Romanian Baptist Church Gary, thank you; I'll share this with the commissioner. Have a great day. Sue From: Gary VanDeWerken<garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent:Wednesday, November 14, 2018 2:25 PM To: FaulknerSue<Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov>;Andy.Solis@colliercounty.gov; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaboJames<James.Sabo@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>; FialaDonna<Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny <Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Re: "Property Zoned Residential Estates Keep it Residential" Grace Romanian Baptist Church Hi Sue, Heres some more info,they have a new location down 1st ave SW across from Max Hasse Park this was not mentioned at the meeting its on there face book page,the only thing mentioned was Naples Baptist church off orange blossom that they had to leave and office space they have out grown. Why not tell us about this existing church? Thanks Gary New Location !!! Locatie Noua !!! Duminica 10 am-12:00 pm & 6:00-7:30 pm 3380 Golden Gate Blvd. W, Naples, FL 34120 N coo.ap"fwePw:ve» Phone: 239-961-0262 AveNW contact@grbcn.org www.grbcn.org On Nov 13,2018,at 4:34 PM, FaulknerSue<Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov>wrote: Dear Mr. VanDeWerken, Thank you for your communication; it will be provided to the Collier County Planning Commission and Board of County Commissioners. Kind Regards, Sue Faulkner, Principal Planner Collier County Growth Management Department Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104 phone: 239-252-5715; E-fax: 239-252-2838 Website: www.colliercountyfl.gov Email: Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov NOTE: Email Address Has Changed Collier County Motto: "To exceed expectations." Tell us how we are doing by taking our Zoning Division Survey at ,:tN:/;b „':2,:; .L:`2c . Original Message From: Gary VanDeWerken<garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, November 12,2018 12:36 PM To: FaulknerSue<Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov>;Andy.Solis@colliercounty.gov; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>;Saboiames<lames.Sabo@colliercountyfl,gov>; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>; FialaDonna<Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny <Pennv.Taylor@col liercountyfl.gov> Subject: "Property Zoned Residential Estates Keep it Residential" Grace Romanian Baptist Church To The Collier County commissioners, As a long term resident of Collier County of 50 years, Im living on the property adjacent to the subject property for 32 years with my family because it is zoned residential estates. I will ask all commissioners these questions,when you purchase property in a residential neighborhood did you plan on changing the zoning? Do you want a church and traffic associated with it next to your home? Would you want somebody to change zoning in your in your residential neighbor hood? Would you like drug rehabilitation center next to your home? Do you think its in your neighborhoods best interests to have drug rehabilitation and traffic associated with a church? We have seen no plans of the actual building,just plotted land and parking, septic drain field.There was an environmental study completed? How did they forget the land purchased for a supply well by Collier County off 1st Ave SW less than 100 feet away from proposed church drain field. 2 A seating capacity of 300 on septic system is not acceptable for anyone in the vacinity using well water for drinking supply that would be everyone. Is there room for a sewer water treatment plant on the subject property? No sewer available, should not be allowed. Grace Romanian Baptist Church had another piece of land rezoned conditional use,they sold it. I appose anything other than residential estates, keep it residential estates. This is the gateway to the Golden Gate Estates. Thanks For Your time Gary VanDeWerken Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 3 Ex parte Items - Commissioner Donna Fiala COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA February 26, 2019 ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS (none) ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 8.A. This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida, providing for the establishment of a conditional use to allow a church within an Estates Zoning District pursuant to Section 2.03.01.B.1.c.1 of the Collier County Land Development Code for property located on the southeast corner of Golden Gate Boulevard and Collier Boulevard in Section 11,Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. (PL20160002577) (This is a Companion to Agenda Item 9.A) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM XJ SEE FILE ®Meetings ❑Correspondence se-mails ❑Calls Met w/ Rich Yovanovich, Jessica Harrelson, Josh Fruth, Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver, Discussions with Planning Commissioners, and received a couple of emails CONSENT AGENDA 16.A.5. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Maple Ridge at Ave Maria, Phase 6B, (Application Number PL20180001175)approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. XQ NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ❑Meetings nCorrespondence ❑e-mails Calls SUMMARY AGENDA 17.A. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180001954,to disclaim, renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in a portion of the 40-foot drainage easement, as described in Book 1065, Page 582 of the Official Records of Collier County, Florida, located in the rear yard of Lot 35, Queens Park at Lago Verde Phase 2 subdivision,on the south side of Kent Drive,approximately one-half mile north of Rattlesnake Hammock Road, in Section 18,Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. DQ NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ❑Meetings ❑Correspondence ❑e-mails ❑Calls BrownleeMichael Subject: Meet w/ Rich Yovanovich, Jessica Harrelson, Josh Fruth, Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver re: Grace Romanian Church Location: BCC Conference Room Start: Tue 11/6/2018 2:00 PM End: Tue 11/6/2018 2:30 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: FialaDonna 1 BrownleeMichael From: bmisalz@aol.com Sent: Thursday,January 17, 2019 7:51 AM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Cc: BMISalz@aol.com; FaulknerSue Subject: Proposed church on GGB and 951 Categories: PRINTED Good morning, A little late to the party, my apologies. The proposed church on the corner of GGB and 951 should not be approved. Strictly from a traffic aspect, the property will greatly affect the residential neighborhood around it with increased traffic. The application calls for a 24/7 operation, and the size of the property is a sure indication of future expansion plans. The application also acknowledges that if they are successful in rezoning this property, the one on the North side of the intersection will follow suit. Also, the vagueness of the answers provided to the residents of GGE at the neighborhood meeting are disconcerting to put it mildly: "Approximately 23 citizens, 4 members of the applicant's team, and the 2 planners from the County attended the NIM. Questions and concerns from the attendees included: • • Number of acres for project site? 6.25 acres • • Number of square feet of storage shed? 1,800 sq. feet • • Types of special events? Not defined yet • •Where will special events be held on the site? in the pastor's residence? Outdoors? If outside, could be in parking area, or in open area, if pastor residence not built. • •Traffic is already a nightmare. Applicant will continue to work with County staff. • • Traffic access to site locations. Applicant will continue to work with County staff. • • Could a bridge entrance be constructed over the Collier Blvd. canal? Not possible, since land that would be needed does not belong to church and safe distance from Golden Gate Blvd could not be accommodated. • • If an event is held in parking area, where will people park?As part of a special event permit a parking plan is required. • • Do not want carnival or revival type events. Agent asked if citizen wanted any other types of events eliminated. • • Speeding on Weber Blvd. Citizens need to work with Sherriff's office. • • Have an off-duty officer for traffic control. • • Churches do not pay property taxes. • •What will be cleared in the preserve area? Only native vegetation would remain. • • Dates of Public Hearings. No dates were set yet. " • Before the permit should even be considered, the applicant at the least should come back to the residents and address the concerns listed above. Otherwise, the approval of this rezoning is essentially an open book to do what they want with no consideration of the impact to the neighbors in a residential neighborhoods peace, privacy and home values. Regards, -SSB— Scott S. Baxter "The true science piscatorial is occupation without ostentation, fun without fury, patience without glory; a desire for nothing 1 BrownleeMichael From: Patrick Miller <Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent: Thursday, February 21, 2019 10:58 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: Grace Romanian Church Request Importance: High Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED Donna, I know this is coming to the Board on Tuesday. I know it will be approved I'm not against it but we need your help with traffic calming on Weber Blvd S. The traffic each day in the morning and in the afternoon has no concern for the residence on the street and 95% never obey the speed limit. We need to either have some speed humps installed or stop signs or anything to slow the traffic down. The amount of traffic is directly related to school drop off and pickups and people using Weber Blvd S to bypass 951. ! I ask you and each of the commissioners to help us with the County Traffic department in making our nice residential street safe again so people can walk and ride Bikes on the bike path safely with traffic not re than a couple of feet away traveling at high speed it is not safe. Thank you for your time and all you do for the people of Collier County. Pat Patrick K. Miller Ni4\ Senior Vice President Lake Michigan Credit Union (239) 919-1362 A IICHICANc t.i (239) 216-2285 (mobile) of F3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 I Naples FL 34103-2714 Patrick.Miller@lmcu.orq I LMCU.orq NMLS ID# 911706 0 0 BrownleeMichael From: Glembin <jglembin@embarqmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 1:06 PM To: McDanielBill Cc: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; Burt.Suanders@colliercountyfl.gov; TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Roman Baptist Church Categories: PRINTED My husband and I have lived on Weber Blvd South for over 20 years and have seen lots of changes. However the addition of this church can only be considered a bad one for this neighborhood. Almost all of the traffic going to and from this church will go down residential streets. Any parishioner coming from the east will have to turn at the light by Max Hasse park and drive down 15t Ave SW, or come down White Blvd and turn on to Weber Blvd S to get to the church. When leaving traveling on Golden Gate Blvd will be an option, all others will head down Weber Blvd S again. I am also concerned about their ability to keep up a church. I haven't ever seen a church that could support itself with only 300 parishioners. I'd like to know if they plan on "renting" out their spaces and what that would be for before I would even consider this a viable possibility. This land is zoned residential for a reason. Please leave it that way. Sincerely, Donna Glembin BrownleeMichael From: Lauren Fraclose Osborne <mrslaurenosborne@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 11:58 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: Letter of petition against church for February 26th meeting Attachments: Petition.pdf Categories: PRINTED I apologize if your are not the appropriate person to send this letter too, but I have attached a letter of petition in reference to the building of a church at the corner of Golden Gate Blvd and Collier Blvd for the Tuesday, February 26th meeting to be held at 9am. I cannot personally attend.Thank you. -Lauren Osborne 1 I was asked to contact you in reference to this possible amendment located at the property at the corner of Collier Blvd and Golden Gate Blvd. The public hearing request is in reference to the building of a church there, Grace Romanian. Project Number:PL20160002577 and PL20160002584 I'd like to submit this letter, as I cannot personally attend the hearing that is set for Tuesday, February 26th at 9am, as a petition against the building of a church. My family and I live on Weber Blvd South just about a block away from this property. Modifying the amendment to allow the building of a church at this property, which would cause a lot more vehicular traffic, is definitely not what Weber Blvd South needs. Weber Blvd S is already used as a thru street for rush hour traffic Monday through Friday from Collier Blvd morning and evening, as well as for Big Cypress Elementary School Monday through Friday when school is in session, morning and afternoon. During the peak of these times, I refuse to walk on the sidewalk with my children along Weber Blvd S because of the consistent traffic speeding highly above the posted 30mph speed limit. I'm even very nervous about checking my mailbox. The Collier County Sheriffs Office has been requested numerous times to conduct speed enforcement along the road. There is no raised curb along the road and the sidewalk is only just 1 foot away from the main road. BrownleeMichael From: Pat <millpat210@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 8:17 PM To: FialaDonna; andy.silis@colliercountyfl.gov;TaylorPenny Cc: McDanielBill Subject: Grace Romanian Church Categories: PRINTED Commissioners, My apologies but this information just came to my attention. I have to withdraw my support for this request. It is my understanding the petitioner already owns two additional properties one at 3380 Golden Gate Blvd and one at 6445 Willow Park Dr. Naples Both more suitable than the Non conforming use and GMP amendment required for the property located at 951 and Golden Gate Blvd. Please please vote no! Thank you Patrick K Miller 210 Weber Blvd S Naple Sent from XFINITY Connect App 1 BrownleeMichael From: Carlene Thissen <carlene_thissen@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 5:33 PM To: McDanielBill; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; SolisAndy Subject: NO, please to Grace Romanian Baptist Church I'm sorry this is getting to you late, but PLEASE do NOT let them build the church at the corner of 951 and GG Boulevard! We have two churches and a school on our street already. Literally HUNDREDS of parents line up on our street every weekday, so we can hardly get in and out of our homes on 1st Street. When the parents are not lined up,they are late, on their phones, and speeding up and down our street at 50 - 60 miles per hour and the Sheriffs office doesn't help. People constantly use Weber and 1st as a "cut-through" to get to GG Blvd from White. Our real estate values are going to drop really significantly --- and it's already really difficult to live on this street--- and no one helps us! Please don't add one more thing to mess with us. Thank you for listening. I wish I could be there. Carlene A. Thissen 3670 1st Avenue SW Naples, FL 34117 239-290-5558 - cell carlenethissen@yahoo.corn www.reverbnation.com/carlenethissen www.earlenethissen.com Member: BMI Americana Community Music Association Global Songwriters Connection Nashville Songwriters Association Women of Substance Radio Female Musician Academy i BrownleeMichael From: Barry Kotek <bkotekl@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 3:39 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Sent from Mail for Windows 10 Dear Commissioners, We have lived on 1st Ave SW for 14 years. We moved to Golden Gate Estates for the rural character of the area. Adding another church to an area that already has a park, an Elementary School and two other places of worship is just too much for the roadways. We walk our dog on 1st Ave and Weber and have almost been hit several times by speeding school parents or church members. We have complained about the speeders to the sheriff's department, but they have done nothing to alleviate the problem. We already have to deal with parent lining up on 1st between 2 and 3 pm to pick up their kids, making it a virtual parking lot. We also have to deal with cut through traffic on Weber, almost always above the 35 mph speed limit. We do not need another 300 parishioners traveling on Weber or 1st almost every day of the week. The property isn't currently zoned for a church and we strongly object to any changes to the zoning. We will not be able to make the meeting due to doctors appointments, but please take our strong feelings into consideration. Sincerely, Barry J. Kotek 1 Ex parte Items - Commissioner Andy Solis COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA February 26, 2019 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS 8.A. This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item,all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida, providing for the establishment of a conditional use to allow a church within an Estates Zoning District pursuant to Section 2.03.01.B.1.c.1 of the Collier County Land Development Code for property located on the southeast corner of Golden Gate Boulevard and Collier Boulevard in Section 11,Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. (PL20160002577) (This is a Companion to Agenda Item 9.A) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ®Meetings (Correspondence ®e-mails ❑Calls Meetings: 11/6/18 Rich Yovanovich, Jessica Harrelson, Josh Fruth, Adrian Roman, Anna Weaver 11/30/18 Patrick Miller via phone Emails from neighbors ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS NONE REQUIRING DISCLOSURE CONSENT AGENDA 16.A.5. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Maple Ridge at Ave Maria, Phase 6B, (Application Number PL20180001175)approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE I (Meetings Correspondence ne-mails ❑Calls SUMMARY AGENDA 17.A. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180001954,to disclaim, renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in a portion of the 40-foot drainage easement, as described in Book 1065, Page 582 of the Official Records of Collier County, Florida, located in the rear yard of Lot 35, Queens Park at Lago Verde Phase 2 subdivision,on the south side of Kent Drive,approximately one-half mile north of Rattlesnake Hammock Road, in Section 18,Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. XQ NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE I 'Meetings I (Correspondence ne-mails ❑Calls SolisAndy Subject: Rich Yovanovich, Jessica Harrelson, Josh Fruth, Adrian Roman, Anna Weaver: Grace Romanian Church Location: Cohen &Grigsby Start: Tue 11/6/2018 10:00 AM End: Tue 11/6/2018 10:30 AM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: SolisAndy Required Attendees: Andrew I. Solis (ASolis@cohenlaw.com) From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 23, 2018 11:09 AM To: GoodnerAngela <Angela.Goodner(a@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Hello, Rich would like to meet with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming November 13th agenda item: Grace Romanian Church. Also attending: Jessica Harrelson,Josh Fruth,Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver Availability: Wednesday November 7th: 9:00-1:00 Thursday November 8th: 1:00—5:00 Monday November 12th: 9:00—3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O i E M A.N I Y O V A N O V I C H I K O S T F R SolisAndy Subject: Patrick Miller, resident on Weber Blvd; Grace Romanian Church - call him at 919-1362 Location: phone call Start: Fri 11/30/2018 3:15 PM End: Fri 11/30/2018 3:30 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: SolisAndy Required Attendees: Andrew I. Solis (ASolis@cohenlaw.com) Categories: Phone Call From: Patrick Miller<Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent:Tuesday, November 27, 2018 8:41 AM To:SolisAndy<Andv.Solis@colliercountvfl.gov> Subject: RE:Grace Romanian Church GG Blvd and 951 Importance: High Ms. Goodner, I would like an opportunity to speak with Mr. Solis regarding this issue before it comes back to the commission. Please let me know when that might be possible. Thank you. Patrick K. Miller v") Patrick K. Miller Senior Vice President Lake Michigan Credit Union LAKE (239) 919-1362 MICHIGAN t tt (239) 216-2285 (mobile) 1.E ill4,5:+. 3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 I Naples FL 34103-2714 Patrick.Miller(almcu.orq I LMCU.orq ,+►j From Mr. Miller's email: "Please review your own county attorneys guidance that the CPI ignored! I quote "their job is to how to make the conditional use compatible with the neighborhood "They failed in their duties and this conditional use is not compatible with the neighborhood when it is allowed to operate 24 hrs a day 7 days a week and have drug and alcohol rehab services. This request also requires an amendment to the Land Development Code which should also not be approved. SolisAndy From: James Schortemeyer <schortfire@aol.com> Sent: Monday, November 5, 2018 10:17 AM To: SolisAndy Subject: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed Honorable Commissioner Solis, PLEASE DENY THIS PETITION. Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, a Growth Management Plan Small Scale Amendment specific to the Conditional Uses Subdistrict of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan, to allow church uses for the Grace Romanian Baptist Church. (Adoption Hearing) [This is a Companion to Agenda Item 6976] South Weber Blvd. has already been adversely impacted by zoning changes on first avenue SW and so called road 'improvements' on Golden Gate Blvd. and White Blvd. Left turns are not allowed onto either of these roads from South Weber BLVD. Traffic patterns are already intolerable and another zoning 'exception' along this corridor should not be approved. It will further exacerbate traffic issues with increased illegal turns, u turns, and wrong way traffic. The Weber Blvd. Estates Zoning has already been severely severely compromised by high volume traffic on CR 951, White Blvd. and golden Gate Blvd. Along with already approved variances including nearby commercial developments we are at the threshold of losing the wildlife and environmental benefits that we cherish. Right now, we are fortunate to have large mammals such as deer, panther and black bear frequent our neighborhood but there have already been too many vehicle collisions with these large mammals. Please protect our'estates zoning', environmental values, and wildlife by denying this petition to allow another zoning exception in Unit 4, GGE. Jim Schortemeyer 3481 5th ave sw Naples, Fl SolisAndy From: Patrick Miller <Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent: Saturday, November 10, 2018 4:10 PM To: FaulknerSue; McDanielBill; donna.fiala@colliercountfl.gov; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; SolisAndy Cc: StrainMark Subject: Grace Romanian Church GG Blvd and 951 To all: This petition continues to change from a neighborhood church with limited hours and restrictions which are much more compatible with our Neighborhood and the life that we all have moved to the Estates to enjoy. My wife and I have lived on Weber Blvd S for over 25 years and in Collier County for over 50 years. Please review your own county attorneys guidance that the CPI ignored! I quote their job is to how to make the conditional use compatible with the neighborhood "They failed in their duties and this conditional use is not compatible with the neighborhood when it is allowed to operate 24 hrs a day 7 days a week and have drug and alcohol rehab services, This request also requires an amendment to the Land Development Code which should also not be approved. Please Please do not vote for this request and send it back for reconsideration to the CCPC and instruct them to do their duties as out Inked by the county attorney Thank you for your time and consideration Patrick K. Miller Terry B Miller 210 Weber Blvd S Naples, Fl. 34117 239-216-2285 SolisAndy From: MARK WOOD <mmw3530@comcast.net> Sent: Sunday, November 11, 2018 4:15 PM To: FaulknerSue; SaboJames; FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Growth Management Plan Amendment (PL20160002584) and Conditional use approval (PL20160002577) Dear Ms. Faulkner; Mr. Sabo; Ms. Fiala; Mr. Solis; Mr. Saunders; Ms. Taylor; Mr. McDaniel: I am writing this letter as I cannot attend the scheduled meeting on Tuesday, November 13th at 9:00am. My husband and I have owned our home on 1st Avenue SW since January of 2004. In that period of time we have seen the expansion of the Estates Naples Kingdom Hall Church at 3480 Golden Gate Blvd West, the closure of the access road from Golden Gate Blvd to Webber, and now the new Church that is slated to be constructed on the SE corner of Webber and Golden Gate Blvd. We already have the following on our street: Cypress Wood Presbyterian Church Estates Naples Kingdown Hall Church Max A. Hasse Jr. Community Park Big Cypress Elementary School All of these are within 1/2 a mile of the site where the new Church is being built. We are already subjected to morning and afternoon traffic, and cars parked on our street (to the point that our home cannot be accessed from 2:45pm until 3:15pm) due to the school. There is also traffic all day long due to the park and the 2 Churches. The Estates Naples Kingdom Hall Church has services during the week as well as the weekend. In addition, due to the closure of the left hand turn on to Webber from Golden Gate Estates when heading east, now our street has become a cut through to get to Webber. In the morning at 7:00am there are cars driving 50 miles an hour down our street. This happens from 7:00am to about 9:00am as people are heading to work and then later in the afternoon for either picking up children at Max Hasse or cutting through to Golden Gate Blvd. Once a month on Saturday the Park has a yard sale that last from about 8:00 until 2:00pm. I walk every morning from my home at 3530 1st Avenue SW to 5th Avenue SW, and it has become extremely frightening as the traffic on 1st Avenue SW and the traffic on Webber is excessive, and for the most part everyone is speeding and none of these individuals live on either Webber or any street off Webber. You are now letting another Church be built on an already congested 1/2 a mile radius and honestly do we need another Church so close to the other two? If people are coming from the East to attend the new Church on the corner of Webber and the Blvd, and if there is an entrance on 1st Avenue, then they will be coming down 1st Avenue SW to access the Church. More traffic on our street and more traffic on Webber. We did not move out to Golden Gate Estates to live next to a drug and rehab center, that I am assuming will have 24 hour access, or 3 Churches within a 1/2 mile radius. Please put yourselves in our shoes and think "would you like to have this much congestion in your neighborhood"? Sincerely, Marlene and Mark Wood GrecoSherry From: Gary VanDeWerken <garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, November 12, 2018 12:36 PM To: FaulknerSue;Andy.Solis@colliercounty.gov; McDanielBill; SaboJames; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna; TaylorPenny Subject: "Property Zoned Residential Estates Keep it Residential" Grace Romanian Baptist Church To The Collier County commissioners, As a long term resident of Collier County of 50 years, Im living on the property adjacent to the subject property for 32 years with my family because it is zoned residential estates. I will ask all commissioners these questions, when you purchase property in a residential neighborhood did you plan on changing the zoning? Do you want a church and traffic associated with it next to your home? Would you want somebody to change zoning in your in your residential neighbor hood? Would you like drug rehabilitation center next to your home? Do you think its in your neighborhoods best interests to have drug rehabilitation and traffic associated with a church? We have seen no plans of the actual building,just plotted land and parking, septic drain field. There was an environmental study completed? How did they forget the land purchased for a supply well by Collier County off 1st Ave SW less than 100 feet away from proposed church drain field. A seating capacity of 300 on septic system is not acceptable for anyone in the vacinity using well water for drinking supply that would be everyone. Is there room for a sewer water treatment plant on the subject property? No sewer available, should not be allowed. Grace Romanian Baptist Church had another piece of land rezoned conditional use, they sold it. I appose anything other than residential estates, keep it residential estates. This is the gateway to the Golden Gate Estates. Thanks For Your time Gary VanDeWerken 1 SolisAndy From: Patrick Miller <Patrick.Miller@Imcu.org> Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2018 4:18 PM To: SolisAndy Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Church GG Blvd and 951 Importance: High Ms. Goodner, Yes that would be fine. Should I place the call or will he call me? Pat Patrick K. Miller Senior Vice President Lake Michigan Credit Union LAKE (239)919-1362 y) MKC:HLGAN(1 1 (239) 216-2285 (mobile) 3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 I Naples FL 34103-2714 Patrick.Miller@Imcu.org I LMCU.org 0 From: SolisAndy [mailto:Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Tuesday, November 27, 2018 4:14 PM To: Patrick Miller Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Church GG Blvd and 951 WARNING: This email originated outside of LMCU. Hello, Mr. Miller—are you available for a phone call at 3:15pm this Friday afternoon? Angela Goodner, Executive Coordinator Commissioner Andy Solis, Esq., Chairman Collier County Board of County Commissioners Phone: 239.252.8602 Fax: 239.252.6947 Sign up for the District 2 newsletter HERE! Thank you for taking the time to be an engaged member of our community. Please feel free to call or email whenever we can be of assistance. Sent on behalf of Commissioner Andy Solis, by Angela Goodner, Executive Coordinator Commissioner Andy Solis, Esq., Chairman Collier County Board of County Commissioners Phone: 239.252.8602 Fax: 239.252.6947 Sign up for the District 2 newsletter HERE! Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone at 239-252-8602 or in writing at 3299 Tamiami Trail E,Suite 303, Naples, FL 34112. Original Message From: Patrick Miller<Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent: Saturday, November 10, 2018 4:10 PM To: FaulknerSue<Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov>; McDanielBill<Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>; donna.fiala@colliercountfl.gov;SaundersBurt<Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>;TaylorPenny <Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; SolisAndy<Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:StrainMark<Mark.Strain@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Grace Romanian Church GG Blvd and 951 To all: This petition continues to change from a neighborhood church with limited hours and restrictions which are much more compatible with our Neighborhood and the life that we all have moved to the Estates to enjoy. My wife and I have lived on Weber Blvd S for over 25 years and in Collier County for over 50 years. Please review your own county attorneys guidance that the CPI ignored! I quote their job is to how to make the conditional use compatible with the neighborhood "They failed in their duties and this conditional use is not compatible with the neighborhood when it is allowed to operate 24 hrs a day 7 days a week and have drug and alcohol rehab services, This request also requires an amendment to the Land Development Code which should also not be approved. Please Please do not vote for this request and send it back for reconsideration to the CCPC and instruct them to do their duties as out Inked by the county attorney Thank you for your time and consideration Patrick K. Miller Terry B Miller 210 Weber Blvd S Naples, Fl. 34117 239-216-2285 SolisAndy From: bmisalz@aol.com Sent: Thursday,January 17, 2019 7:51 AM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Cc: BMISalz@aol.com; FaulknerSue Subject: Proposed church on GGB and 951 Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed Good morning, A little late to the party, my apologies. The proposed church on the corner of GGB and 951 should not be approved. Strictly from a traffic aspect, the property will greatly affect the residential neighborhood around it with increased traffic. The application calls for a 24/7 operation, and the size of the property is a sure indication of future expansion plans. The application also acknowledges that if they are successful in rezoning this property, the one on the North side of the intersection will follow suit. Also, the vagueness of the answers provided to the residents of GGE at the neighborhood meeting are disconcerting to put it mildly: "Approximately 23 citizens, 4 members of the applicant's team, and the 2 planners from the County attended the NIM. Questions and concerns from the attendees included: • • Number of acres for project site? 6.25 acres • • Number of square feet of storage shed? 1,800 sq. feet • •Types of special events? Not defined yet • •Where will special events be held on the site? in the pastor's residence?Outdoors? If outside, could be in parking area, or in open area, if pastor residence not built. • • Traffic is already a nightmare. Applicant will continue to work with County staff • •Traffic access to site locations. Applicant will continue to work with County staff. • • Could a bridge entrance be constructed over the Collier Blvd. canal? Not possible, since land that would be needed does not belong to church and safe distance from Golden Gate Blvd could not be accommodated. • • If an event is held in parking area, where will people park?As part of a special event permit a parking plan is required. • • Do not want carnival or revival type events. Agent asked if citizen wanted any other types of events eliminated. • • Speeding on Weber Blvd. Citizens need to work with Sherriff's office. • • Have an off-duty officer for traffic control. • • Churches do not pay property taxes. • •What will be cleared in the preserve area? Only native vegetation would remain. • • Dates of Public Hearings. No dates were set yet. " • Before the permit should even be considered, the applicant at the least should come back to the residents and address the concerns listed above. Otherwise, the approval of this rezoning is essentially an open book to do what they want with no consideration of the impact to the neighbors in a residential neighborhoods peace, privacy and home values. Regards, —SSB— Scott S. Baxter "The true science piscatorial is occupation without ostentation, fun without fury, patience without glory; a desire for nothing SolisAndy From: Renate <renjakl @comcast.net> Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 9:14 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: BCC 2/26/19 - Grace Romanian Baptist Church - PL20160002577 & PL20160002584 Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed Dear Commissioners, Time is running out for all of us living on Weber Blvd.S. And 1st Avenue SW. We all moved to the quiet country setting to enjoy life to the fullest. We loved all the extras that came with it : little traffic, many different species of animals,we even had people riding their horses on our streets. Traffic on Weber is as fast if not faster than on 951. I am 88 years of age and have a hard time crossing the road to get my mail. Please help us to preserve the rural character of the Golden Gate Estates! We do not mind the church only the traffic it brings. They already have a church +1-3,000 feet down the street. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Renate S. Kelly 291 Weber Blvd S. Naples. Fl. 34117-3033. SolisAndy From: John Kelly <johnkellyfl@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 12:31 AM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A - Grace Romanian Baptist Church Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed Dear Commissioners, I have been a resident of Golden Gate Estates (GGE) - Unit 4 in excess of 25-years. During that time I have watched the gradual decay of the Rural Estates quality of life. The residents of GGE-Unit 4 have located for the same reasons as those of other GGE residents; affordability, tranquility, avoidance of urban traffic, and an appreciation for wildlife. Unfortunately, it seems the residents of GGE-Unit 4 are paying a much higher price than any other unit within GGE as it is bordered by major roadways to the north, south and west; not to mention that Weber Boulevard South has become a high-speed bypass for Collier Boulevard. To that end, Weber Boulevard South already served, via 1st Avenue SW, as access to two Jehovah's Witness Kingdom Halls operating on the same property, Max Hasse Community Park, and what was a failed Presbyterian Church located at 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West (approximately 3,200 feet east of the subject property)which was purchased in September, 2018, by the petitioner.The residents in this area are frustrated with the amount of traffic, the lack of traffic control, and the loss of the rural estates character and quality of life. The residents I have spoken with all believe that a traffic generating use at the subject location is an accident waiting to happen. Interestingly, you have heard this petition before and a vote was taken which resulted in the project's defeat; unfortunately, as a result of comments made by the petitioner's counsel after the close of public comment, Commissioner McDaniel motioned for the vote to be withdrawn and the item be sent back to the Planning Commission (CCPC). The comment made by the petitioner's counsel was that you, the BCC, have rejected the last three churches that were proposed at major intersections and that he no longer knows where to tell clients they can have a church. Commissioner McDaniel also noted that he would have liked to have seen better notification to the residents of GGE and desired to see if anything could be done to ameliorate the impacts of a church on the community. To that end, the petition was re-heard by the CCPC however only minimal changes resulted. More concerning is the fact there was no greater effort to notify the estates residents of this project and based upon the location of this project it will impact upon many GGE residents. As such, please note that your staff just held extensive outreach efforts with respect to the new Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP) that was recently approved by you for transmittal to the State. The subject location is located within the Rural Estates. GGAMP outreach efforts performed by your staff examined uses and recommended areas for change as based upon their findings; no changes were proposed for the subject properties and the general consensus of the study was that Rural GGE residents ultimately desired no changes that would impact upon the rural estates quality of life. The Rural GGE residents have spoken and you are urged to respect their desires. As to the question posed by the petitioner's counsel, there should have never been an expectation that a church could be permitted at the subject location as it is not allowable by either the existing GGAMP nor that just transmitted to the State. The criteria for applying for a small Sol isAndy From: Barry Kotek <bkotekl @comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 3:39 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed Sent from Mail for Windows 10 Dear Commissioners, We have lived on 1st Ave SW for 14 years. We moved to Golden Gate Estates for the rural character of the area. Adding another church to an area that already has a park, an Elementary School and two other places of worship is just too much for the roadways. We walk our dog on 1st Ave and Weber and have almost been hit several times by speeding school parents or church members. We have complained about the speeders to the sheriff's department, but they have done nothing to alleviate the problem. We already have to deal with parent lining up on 1st between 2 and 3 pm to pick up their kids, making it a virtual parking lot. We also have to deal with cut through traffic on Weber, almost always above the 35 mph speed limit. We do not need another 300 parishioners traveling on Weber or 1st almost every day of the week. The property isn't currently zoned for a church and we strongly object to any changes to the zoning. We will not be able to make the meeting due to doctors appointments, but please take our strong feelings into consideration. Sincerely, Barry J. Kotek SolisAndy From: Carlene Thissen <carlene_thissen@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 5:33 PM To: McDanielBill; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; SolisAndy Subject: NO, please to Grace Romanian Baptist Church I'm sorry this is getting to you late, but PLEASE do NOT let them build the church at the corner of 951 and GG Boulevard! We have two churches and a school on our street already. Literally HUNDREDS of parents line up on our street every weekday, so we can hardly get in and out of our homes on 1st Street. When the parents are not lined up, they are late, on their phones, and speeding up and down our street at 50- 60 miles per hour and the Sheriffs office doesn't help. People constantly use Weber and 1st as a "cut-through"to get to GG Blvd from White. Our real estate values are going to drop really significantly---and it's already really difficult to live on this street--- and no one helps us! Please don't add one more thing to mess with us. Thank you for listening. I wish I could be there. Carlene A. Thissen 3670 1st Avenue SW Naples,FL 34117 239-290-5558 -cell carlene_thissen@yahoo.com www.reverbnation.com/carlenethissen www.carlenethissen.com Member: BMI Americana Community Music Association Global Songwriters Connection Nashville Songwriters Association Women of Substance Radio Female Musician Academy Ex parte Items - Commissioner Burt L. Saunders COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA FEBRUARY 26, 2019 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS 8.A. This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida, providing for the establishment of a conditional use to allow a church within an Estates Zoning District pursuant to Section 2.03.01.B.1.c.1 of the Collier County Land Development Code for property located on the southeast corner of Golden Gate Boulevard and Collier Boulevard in Section 11,Township49 South, Range 26 East,Collier County, Florida. (PL20160002577) (This is a Companion to Agenda Item 9.A) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ®Meetings ❑Correspondence ®e-mails ®Calls Meeting with Petitioners Agent; numerous emails. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS - None CONSENT AGENDA 16.A.5 This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Maple Ridge at Ave Maria, Phase 6B, (Application Number PL20180001175) approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ['Meetings ['Correspondence ❑e-mails ['Calls SUMMARY AGENDA 17.A This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180001954,to disclaim,renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in a portion of the 40-foot drainage easement,as described in Book 1065, Page 582 of the Official Records of Collier County, Florida, located in the rear yard of Lot 35, Queens Park at Lago Verde Phase 2 subdivision, on the south side of Kent Drive, approximately one-half mile north of Rattlesnake Hammock Road, in Section 18, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. XI NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ['Meetings ['Correspondence ❑e-mails ❑Calls Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA February 26, 2019 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS 8.A. This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item,all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida, providing for the establishment of a conditional use to allow a church within an Estates Zoning District pursuant to Section 2.03.01.B.1.c.1 of the Collier County Land Development Code for property located on the southeast corner of Golden Gate Boulevard and Collier Boulevard in Section 11,Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. (PL20160002577) (This is a Companion to Agenda Item 9.A-Grace Romanian Baptist Church) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ®Meetings ®Correspondence ®e-mails ®Calls Our office has received emails and had a meeting with Rich Yovanovich on Tuesday, February 19, 2019. Phone conversation with Michael R. Ramsey, President, Golden Gate Estates Area Civic Association. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS NONE CONSENT AGENDA 16.A.5. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Maple Ridge at Ave Maria, Phase 6B, (Application Number PL20180001175)approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. 7 NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM 7 SEE FILE ['Meetings flCorrespondence De-mails ['Calls Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA February 26, 2019 SUMMARY AGENDA 17.A. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180001954,to disclaim, renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in a portion of the 40-foot drainage easement, as described in Book 1065, Page 582 of the Official Records of Collier County, Florida, located in the rear yard of Lot 35, Queens Park at Lago Verde Phase 2 subdivision,on the south side of Kent Drive, approximately one-half mile north of Rattlesnake Hammock Road, in Section 18,Township 50 South, Range 26 East,Collier County, Florida. F NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ❑Meetings I (Correspondence ❑e-mails ❑Calls GrecoSherry From: John Kelly <johnkellyfl@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 9:58 AM To: GrecoSherry; FilsonSue Cc: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Fwd: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A - Grace Romanian Baptist Church Good morning, It would be appreciated if you would please forward this e-mail to your respective Commissioner as it was previously returned to me by the automated mailer-daemon. Thank you kindly Original Message From:John Kelly<johnkellyfl comcast.net> To: Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov, Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov, Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov, Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov, Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov Date: February 25, 2019 at 12:30 AM Subject: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A- Grace Romanian Baptist Church Dear Commissioners, I have been a resident of Golden Gate Estates (GGE) - Unit 4 in excess of 25-years. During that time I have watched the gradual decay of the Rural Estates quality of life.The residents of GGE-Unit 4 have located for the same reasons as those of other GGE residents; affordability, tranquility, avoidance of urban traffic, and an appreciation for wildlife. Unfortunately, it seems the residents of GGE-Unit 4 are paying a much higher price than any other unit within GGE as it is bordered by major roadways to the north, south and west; not to mention that Weber Boulevard South has become a high-speed bypass for Collier Boulevard. To that end, Weber Boulevard South already served,via 1st Avenue SW, as access to two Jehovah's Witness Kingdom Halls operating on the same property, Max Hasse Community Park, and what was a failed Presbyterian Church located at 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West(approximately 3,200 feet east of the subject property) which was purchased in September, 2018, by the petitioner.The residents in this area are frustrated with the amount of traffic, the lack of traffic control, and the loss of the rural estates character and quality of life.The residents I have spoken with all believe that a traffic generating use at the subject location is an accident waiting to happen. Interestingly, you have heard this petition before and a vote was taken which resulted in the project's defeat; unfortunately, as a result of comments made by the petitioner's counsel after the close of public comment, Commissioner McDaniel motioned for the vote to be withdrawn and the item be sent back to the Planning Commission (CCPC).The comment made by the petitioner's counsel was that you, the BCC, have rejected the last three churches that were proposed at major intersections and that he no longer knows where to tell clients they can have a church. Commissioner McDaniel also noted that he would have liked to have seen better notification to the residents of GGE and desired to see if anything could be done to ameliorate the impacts of a church on the community.To that end,the petition was re-heard by the CCPC however only minimal changes resulted. More concerning is the fact there was no greater effort to notify the estates residents of this project and based upon the location of this project it will impact upon many GGE residents.As such, please note that your staff just held extensive outreach efforts with respect to the new Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP)that was recently approved by 1 you for transmittal to the State.The subject location is located within the Rural Estates. GGAMP outreach efforts performed by your staff examined uses and recommended areas for change as based upon their findings; no changes were proposed for the subject properties and the general consensus of the study was that Rural GGE residents ultimately desired no changes that would impact upon the rural estates quality of life.The Rural GGE residents have spoken and you are urged to respect their desires. As to the question posed by the petitioner's counsel, there should have never been an expectation that a church could be permitted at the subject location as it is not allowable by either the existing GGAMP nor that just transmitted to the State.The criteria for applying for a small scale amendment to the GGAMP are very few and nearly everyone eligible to apply will satisfy said criteria, as such your staff should be much more critical in evaluating and analyzing such petitions; your constituents are counting on you to make things right.There is no question that property located within the GGE is less expensive than that in the urban area. Does that mean every GGE intersection is destined to be approved for a conditional use? How much sense does that make? Please,the subject project is not necessarily a bad one; unfortunately,the location is horrible. Any applicant for a conditional use should expect push-back; alternatively, they'd likely be welcomed at an appropriately zoned commercial location. I'd further suggest that the County define the term "community church" as perhaps at a lesser scale the project wouldn't be quite as problematic at the subject location. GGE is home to much of the areas working class, weekends are when these residents are outside trying to enjoy their peace and tranquility, weekends are when they walk the narrow sidewalks that offer little protection from the speeding traffic; the residents of GGE-Unit 4 should expect no less quality of life than any other GGE residents. Please note that the Grace Romanian Baptist Church is not without a home. As per the petitioner's website, [www.grbcn.org,](http://www.grbcn.org,) the church presently has services at and is housed at the 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West.This location is far better suited for a traffic generating use of this type as there is a traffic light at this location; additionally, as per the site's most current Site Development Plan, only Phase 1 has been completed and there is plenty of space for expansion.To my knowledge, absolutely nobody has opposed or said anything negative about this location. Be it noted the petitioner also owns a third location at 6645 Willow Park Drive which is within a Commercial Planned Unit Development. In closing, GGE-Unit 4 has already been disadvantaged and we seek to prevent even further decay to the rural quality of life enjoyed by other GGE residents.The traffic impact caused by the already approved non-estates uses are considerable and any increase to traffic will likely be detrimental. Lastly, please be reminded that the southern side of GGE-Unit 4 could be just as problematic and the actions taken on this petition could set precedent for that side.As the residents of GGE have spoken during the GGAMP re-study,you are asked to bide by their desires to maintain the Rural GGE as rural.The estates is more than a zoning classification, it's a quality way of life. Thank you, John Kelly 221 Weber Boulevard South Naples, Florida 34117-3033 2 GrecoSherry From: Robert Statile <flplumbob6@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 9:03 PM To: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Baptist Church_Collier County project numbers_ PL20160002577 and PL20160002584 Importance: High Dear Commissioners, The above referenced project numbers have been met with much resistance and protest by property owners such as myself. I attended the last meeting even though I only found out about it less than 24 hours prior. I witnessed the deceptive measures one lawyer would take to represent his client. What a turn off. He did not inform all property owners of their intentions, as he claimed. I was not informed. The fact remains the impact that Weber Blvd South will suffer due to heavy traffic in a residential street is monumental and is contrary to what he claimed. Obviously, no vehicles are going to exit on to Weber Blvd,turn right onto GG Blvd to make a U-turn and go back to Collier Boulevard. They will all drive south right down Weber and right past my home. I did not buy this home 19 years ago because I wanted to live near a freeway. I bought in a residential area. I have been a resident of Naples for 40 years and have watched the destruction done to many areas in the name of growth! To frame it bluntly, a church/drug rehab center has no place here. We have very high property values and want it kept that way! I do not appreciate the fact that they are so misrepresenting their intentions and once they sell,the restrictions will not have to be followed by the next buyer. The biggest complaint I have is, economically commercial properties should not be allowed in residential neighborhoods. I do not want to send a message that it is ok to spot zone commercial. This is clearly a black and white matter. I appreciate your time considering what I and so many other residents are saying and I trust that you will rule as if you were in our shoes and your money, and your privacy was in jeopardy. Let's put this to rest once and for all. Respectfully, Robert M. Statile 480 Weber Boulevard, South Naples, FL 34117 239-253-4722- Mobile 1 GrecoSherry From: Pat <millpat210@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 8:17 PM To: Fiala Donna; andy.silis@colliercountyfl.gov;TaylorPenny Cc: McDanielBill Subject: Grace Romanian Church Commissioners, My apologies but this information just came to my attention. I have to withdraw my support for this request. It is my understanding the petitioner already owns two additional properties one at 3380 Golden Gate Blvd and one at 6445 Willow Park Dr. Naples Both more suitable than the Non conforming use and GMP amendment required for the property located at 951 and Golden Gate Blvd. Please please vote no! Thank you Patrick K Miller 210 Weber Blvd S Naple Sent from XFINITY Connect App 2 GrecoSherry From: Carlene Thissen <carlene_thissen@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 5:33 PM To: McDanielBill; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; SolisAndy Subject: NO, please to Grace Romanian Baptist Church I'm sorry this is getting to you late, but PLEASE do NOT let them build the church at the corner of 951 and GG Boulevard! We have two churches and a school on our street already. Literally HUNDREDS of parents line up on our street every weekday, so we can hardly get in and out of our homes on 1st Street. When the parents are not lined up, they are late, on their phones, and speeding up and down our street at 50 - 60 miles per hour and the Sheriffs office doesn't help. People constantly use Weber and 1st as a "cut-through" to get to GG Blvd from White. Our real estate values are going to drop really significantly --- and it's already really difficult to live on this street--- and no one helps us! Please don't add one more thing to mess with us. Thank you for listening. I wish I could be there. Carlene A. Thissen 3670 1st Avenue SW Naples, FL 34117 239-290-5558 - cell carlenethissen@yahoo.corn www.reverbnation.com/carlenethissen www.carlenethissen.com Member: BMI Americana Community Music Association Global Songwriters Connection Nashville Songwriters Association Women of Substance Radio Female Musician Academy 3 GrecoSherry From: Glembin <jglembin@embargmail.com> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 1:06 PM To: McDanielBill Cc: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; Burt.Suanders@colliercountyfl.gov;TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Roman Baptist Church My husband and I have lived on Weber Blvd South for over 20 years and have seen lots of changes. However the addition of this church can only be considered a bad one for this neighborhood. Almost all of the traffic going to and from this church will go down residential streets. Any parishioner coming from the east will have to turn at the light by Max Hasse park and drive down 1st Ave SW, or come down White Blvd and turn on to Weber Blvd S to get to the church. When leaving traveling on Golden Gate Blvd will be an option, all others will head down Weber Blvd S again. I am also concerned about their ability to keep up a church. I haven't ever seen a church that could support itself with only 300 parishioners. I'd like to know if they plan on "renting" out their spaces and what that would be for before I would even consider this a viable possibility. This land is zoned residential for a reason. Please leave it that way. Sincerely, Donna Glembin 1 GrecoSherry From: Barry Kotek <bkotekl @comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 3:39 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Sent from Mail for Windows 10 Dear Commissioners, We have lived on 15t Ave SW for 14 years. We moved to Golden Gate Estates for the rural character of the area. Adding another church to an area that already has a park, an Elementary School and two other places of worship is just too much for the roadways. We walk our dog on 15t Ave and Weber and have almost been hit several times by speeding school parents or church members. We have complained about the speeders to the sheriff's department, but they have done nothing to alleviate the problem. We already have to deal with parent lining up on 1st between 2 and 3 pm to pick up their kids, making it a virtual parking lot. We also have to deal with cut through traffic on Weber, almost always above the 35 mph speed limit. We do not need another 300 parishioners traveling on Weber or 15t almost every day of the week. The property isn't currently zoned for a church and we strongly object to any changes to the zoning. We will not be able to make the meeting due to doctors appointments, but please take our strong feelings into consideration. Sincerely, Barry J. Kotek 1 GrecoSherry From: John Kelly <johnkellyfl@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, February 25, 2019 9:58 AM To: GrecoSherry; FilsonSue Cc: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Fwd: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A - Grace Romanian Baptist Church Good morning, It would be appreciated if you would please forward this e-mail to your respective Commissioner as it was previously returned to me by the automated mailer-daemon. Thank you kindly Original Message From:John Kelly<iohnkellyfl@comcast.net> To: Donna.FialaPcolliercountyfl.gov,Andy.Solisc colliercountyfl.gov, Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov, Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov, Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov Date: February 25, 2019 at 12:30 AM Subject: Feb 26, 2019 BCC Meeting Items 8.A and 9.A- Grace Romanian Baptist Church Dear Commissioners, I have been a resident of Golden Gate Estates (GGE) - Unit 4 in excess of 25-years. During that time I have watched the gradual decay of the Rural Estates quality of life.The residents of GGE-Unit 4 have located for the same reasons as those of other GGE residents; affordability,tranquility, avoidance of urban traffic, and an appreciation for wildlife. Unfortunately, it seems the residents of GGE-Unit 4 are paying a much higher price than any other unit within GGE as it is bordered by major roadways to the north, south and west; not to mention that Weber Boulevard South has become a high-speed bypass for Collier Boulevard.To that end, Weber Boulevard South already served,via 1st Avenue SW, as access to two Jehovah's Witness Kingdom Halls operating on the same property, Max Hasse Community Park, and what was a failed Presbyterian Church located at 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West(approximately 3,200 feet east of the subject property) which was purchased in September, 2018, by the petitioner.The residents in this area are frustrated with the amount of traffic,the lack of traffic control, and the loss of the rural estates character and quality of life.The residents I have spoken with all believe that a traffic generating use at the subject location is an accident waiting to happen. Interestingly, you have heard this petition before and a vote was taken which resulted in the project's defeat; unfortunately, as a result of comments made by the petitioner's counsel after the close of public comment, Commissioner McDaniel motioned for the vote to be withdrawn and the item be sent back to the Planning Commission (CCPC).The comment made by the petitioner's counsel was that you,the BCC, have rejected the last three churches that were proposed at major intersections and that he no longer knows where to tell clients they can have a church. Commissioner McDaniel also noted that he would have liked to have seen better notification to the residents of GGE and desired to see if anything could be done to ameliorate the impacts of a church on the community.To that end,the petition was re-heard by the CCPC however only minimal changes resulted. More concerning is the fact there was no greater effort to notify the estates residents of this project and based upon the location of this project it will impact upon many GGE residents.As such, please note that your staff just held extensive outreach efforts with respect to the new Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP) that was recently approved by 1 you for transmittal to the State.The subject location is located within the Rural Estates. GGAMP outreach efforts performed by your staff examined uses and recommended areas for change as based upon their findings; no changes were proposed for the subject properties and the general consensus of the study was that Rural GGE residents ultimately desired no changes that would impact upon the rural estates quality of life.The Rural GGE residents have spoken and you are urged to respect their desires. As to the question posed by the petitioner's counsel, there should have never been an expectation that a church could be permitted at the subject location as it is not allowable by either the existing GGAMP nor that just transmitted to the State.The criteria for applying for a small scale amendment to the GGAMP are very few and nearly everyone eligible to apply will satisfy said criteria, as such your staff should be much more critical in evaluating and analyzing such petitions;your constituents are counting on you to make things right.There is no question that property located within the GGE is less expensive • than that in the urban area. Does that mean every GGE intersection is destined to be approved for a conditional use? How much sense does that make? Please,the subject project is not necessarily a bad one; unfortunately,the location is horrible. Any applicant for a conditional use should expect push-back; alternatively, they'd likely be welcomed at an appropriately zoned commercial location. I'd further suggest that the County define the term "community church" as perhaps at a lesser scale the project wouldn't be quite as problematic at the subject location. GGE is home to much of the areas working class, weekends are when these residents are outside trying to enjoy their peace and tranquility, weekends are when they walk the narrow sidewalks that offer little protection from the speeding traffic; the residents of GGE-Unit 4 should expect no less quality of life than any other GGE residents. Please note that the Grace Romanian Baptist Church is not without a home.As per the petitioner's website, [www.grbcn.org,](http://www.grbcn.org,) the church presently has services at and is housed at the 3380 Golden Gate Boulevard West.This location is far better suited for a traffic generating use of this type as there is a traffic light at this location; additionally, as per the site's most current Site Development Plan, only Phase 1 has been completed and there is plenty of space for expansion.To my knowledge, absolutely nobody has opposed or said anything negative about this location. Be it noted the petitioner also owns a third location at 6645 Willow Park Drive which is within a Commercial Planned Unit Development. In closing, GGE-Unit 4 has already been disadvantaged and we seek to prevent even further decay to the rural quality of life enjoyed by other GGE residents.The traffic impact caused by the already approved non-estates uses are considerable and any increase to traffic will likely be detrimental. Lastly, please be reminded that the southern side of GGE-Unit 4 could be just as problematic and the actions taken on this petition could set precedent for that side.As the residents of GGE have spoken during the GGAMP re-study,you are asked to bide by their desires to maintain the Rural GGE as rural.The estates is more than a zoning classification, it's a quality way of life. Thank you, John Kelly 221 Weber Boulevard South Naples, Florida 34117-3033 2 GrecoSherry From: TaylorPenny Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 11:14 AM To: GrecoSherry Subject: Fwd: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted, February, 2019 Please print out Penny Taylor Collier County Board of County Commissioners District 4, Commissioner 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303 Naples, FL. 34112 Penny.Taylor@CollierCountyfl.gov Begin forwarded message: From:James Schortemeyer<schortfire@aol.com> Date: February 24, 2019 at 9:18:45 AM EST To: pennytaylor@colliergov.net Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted, February, 2019 Honorable Commissioner Taylor, Thanks for sending this item back to our planning commission for further review in November of 2018. Unfortunately, they were unable to address most of my concerns and once again, I urge you to deny this petition. If approved this change will continue and exacerbate the degradation of our rural lifestyle in Golden Gate Estates, especially here in Unit 4. One cluster development is enough in each square mile of the estates (We already have 2 churches, one park, and one school located in the NE corner of Unit 4). Incidentally, one of these churches is apparently owned by the Petitioner. Lastly, in the event that you are in the minority and a favorable vote is imminent I would urge the following: 1. Require an easement be established on the western edge of the property to allow public recreational use and access to the South Florida Water Management District Water Way. The width and use of that easement should be similar to that available adjacent to St. Agnes Church to the north and many other locations throughout the county. As Always, Thanks for consideration and diligent work, Jim Schortemeyer Original Message From: James Schortemeyer<schortfireaol.com> To: PennyTaylor<PennyTaylor(a colliergov.net> Sent: Mon, Nov 5, 2018 10:37 am Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, Honorable Commissioner Taylor, 1 PLEASE DENY THIS PETITION. Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, a Growth Management Plan Small Scale Amendment specific to the Conditional Uses Subdistrict of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan, to allow church uses for the Grace Romanian Baptist Church. (Adoption Hearing) [This is a Companion to Agenda Item 6976] South Weber Blvd. has already been adversely impacted by zoning changes on first avenue SW and so called road 'improvements' on Golden Gate Blvd. and White Blvd. Left turns are not allowed onto either of these roads from South Weber BLVD. Traffic patterns are already intolerable and another zoning 'exception' along this corridor should not be approved. It will further exacerbate traffic issues with increased illegal turns, u turns, and wrong way traffic. The Weber Blvd. Estates Zoning has already been severely severely compromised by high volume traffic on CR 951, White Blvd. and golden Gate Blvd. Along with already approved variances including nearby commercial developments we are at the threshold of losing the wildlife and environmental benefits that we cherish. Right now, we are fortunate to have large mammals such as deer, panther and black bear frequent our neighborhood but there have already been too many vehicle collisions with these large mammals. Please protect our'estates zoning', environmental values, and wildlife by denying this petition to allow another zoning exception in Unit 4, GGE. Jim Schortemeyer 3481 5th ave sw Naples, Fl Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Friday, February 22, 2019 10:02 AM To: 'Patrick Miller' Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Church Request Good morning, Thank you for writing our office with your concerns on the above mentioned issue. The Commissioner will take your comments into consideration at the Board meeting on Tuesday. sIierrj C7reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Patrick Miller<Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent:Thursday, February 21, 2019 11:01 AM To:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Grace Romanian Church Request Importance: High Ms. Taylor, I know this is coming to the Board on Tuesday. • I know it will be approved I'm not against it but we need your help with traffic calming on Weber Blvd S. The traffic each day in the morning and in the afternoon has no concern for the residence on the street and 95% never obey the speed limit. We need to either have some speed humps installed or stop signs or anything to slow the traffic down. The amount of traffic is directly related to school drop off and pickups and people using Weber Blvd S to bypass 951 I ask you and each of the commissioners to help us with the County Traffic department in making our nice residential street safe again so people can walk and ride Bikes on the bike path safely with traffic not re than a couple of feet away traveling at high speed it is not safe. Thank you for your time and all you do for the people of Collier County. Pat 1 Patrick K. Miller Senior Vice President Lake Michigan Credit Union LAKE (239) 919-1362 MICHIGAN c (239) 216-2285 (mobile) OFFu*ra% 3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 I Naples FL 34103-2714 Patrick.Miller(c�lmcu.orq I LMCU.orq NMLS ID#911706 0 0 ..; 2 GrecoSherry From: Patrick Miller <Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent: Thursday, February 21, 2019 11:01 AM To: TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Romanian Church Request Importance: High Ms.Taylor, I know this is coming to the Board on Tuesday. I know it will be approved I'm not against it but we need your help with traffic calming on Weber Blvd S. The traffic each day in the morning and in the afternoon has no concern for the residence on the street and 95% never obey the speed limit. We need to either have some speed humps installed or stop signs or anything to slow the traffic down. The amount of traffic is directly related to school drop off and pickups and people using Weber Blvd S to bypass 951 ! I ask you and each of the commissioners to help us with the County Traffic department in making our nice residential street safe again so people can walk and ride Bikes on the bike path safely with traffic not re than a couple of feet away traveling at high speed it is not safe. Thank you for your time and all you do for the people of Collier County. Pat Patrick K. Miller Senior Lake Michigan Vice CreditPresident Union LAKE v.) (239) 919-1362 MIGAGANcu (239) 216-2285 (mobile) Of Finkink 3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 I Naples FL 34103-2714 _ " Patrick.Millerlmcu.org I LMCU.orq NMLS ID# 911706 0 0 1 GrecoSherry From: Renate <renjakl @comcast.net> Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 9:14 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: BCC 2/26/19 - Grace Romanian Baptist Church - PL20160002577 & PL20160002584 Dear Commissioners, Time is running out for all of us living on Weber Blvd.S. And 1st Avenue SW. We all moved to the quiet country setting to enjoy life to the fullest. We loved all the extras that came with it : little traffic, many different species of animals, we even had people riding their horses on our streets. Traffic on Weber is as fast if not faster than on 951. I am 88 years of age and have a hard time crossing the road to get my mail. Please help us to preserve the rural character of the Golden Gate Estates! We do not mind the church only the traffic it brings. They already have a church +/-3,000 feet down the street. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Renate S. Kelly 291 Weber Blvd S. Naples. Fl. 34117-3033. 1 GrecoSherry From: David Stonitsch <dstonitsch@hotmail.com> Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 8:20 PM To: donna.fiala@collierrcountyfl.gov; andy.silis@colliercountyfl.gov; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Dear Mr. Chairman, I am writing to you about project PL20160002577, PL 2016002584, Grace Romanian Baptist Church. They are proposing a church at the corner of Collier Blvd, and Golden Gate Blvd. There is only one entrance/exit proposed off of Golden Gate Blvd. This is a terrible idea. My wife and I live on Weber Blvd and we already have too much traffic bypassing Collier going to Golden Gate Blvd. We purchased in the estates to have extra land for our three grandsons. By adding this commercial building it will make this street less safe for children and wildlife. The Golden Gate Master plan was just approved by the board last month, and it did not include changing the church property. The people of this area, like the rural lifestyle and do not want commercialization. We are asking that this change in the master plan is not approved. At a minimum, there should be an entrance and exit only accessible on Collier Blvd. Please keep any additional traffic off of Weber Blvd. It is barely wide enough for the traffic that is currently on it now. Thanks, David and Vickie Stonitsch 840 Weber Blvd S Naples, FL 34117 2 GrecoSherry From: James Schortemeyer <schortfire@aol.com> Sent: Sunday, February 24, 2019 9:19 AM To: TaylorPenny Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, as resubmitted, February, 2019 Honorable Commissioner Taylor, Thanks for sending this item back to our planning commission for further review in November of 2018. Unfortunately, they were unable to address most of my concerns and once again, I urge you to deny this petition. If approved this change will continue and exacerbate the degradation of our rural lifestyle in Golden Gate Estates, especially here in Unit 4. One cluster development is enough in each square mile of the estates (We already have 2 churches, one park, and one school located in the NE corner of Unit 4). Incidentally, one of these churches is apparently owned by the Petitioner. Lastly, in the event that you are in the minority and a favorable vote is imminent I would urge the following: 1. Require an easement be established on the western edge of the property to allow public recreational use and access to the South Florida Water Management District Water Way. The width and use of that easement should be similar to that available adjacent to St. Agnes Church to the north and many other locations throughout the county. As Always, Thanks for consideration and diligent work, Jim Schortemeyer Original Message From: James Schortemeyer<schortfire@aol.com> To: PennyTaylor<PennyTaylor@colliergov.net> Sent: Mon, Nov 5, 2018 10:37 am Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, Honorable Commissioner Taylor, PLEASE DENY THIS PETITION. Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, a Growth Management Plan Small Scale Amendment specific to the Conditional Uses Subdistrict of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan, to allow church uses for the Grace Romanian Baptist Church. (Adoption Hearing) [This is a Companion to Agenda Item 6976] South Weber Blvd. has already been adversely impacted by zoning changes on first avenue SW and so called road 'improvements' on Golden Gate Blvd. and White Blvd. Left turns are not allowed onto either of these roads from South Weber BLVD. Traffic patterns are already intolerable and another zoning 'exception' along this corridor should not be approved. It will further exacerbate traffic issues with increased illegal turns, u turns, and wrong way traffic. The Weber Blvd. Estates Zoning has already been severely severely compromised by high volume traffic on CR 951, White Blvd. and golden Gate Blvd. Along with already approved variances including nearby commercial developments we are at the threshold of losing the wildlife and environmental benefits that we cherish. Right now, we are fortunate to have large mammals such as deer, panther and black bear frequent our neighborhood but there have already been too many vehicle collisions with these large mammals. Please protect our'estates zoning', environmental values, and wildlife by denying this petition to allow another zoning exception in Unit 4, GGE. Jim Schortemeyer 3481 5th ave sw Naples, Fl 3 GrecoSherry From: Patrick Miller <Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent: Thursday, February 21, 2019 11:01 AM To: TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Romanian Church Request Importance: High Ms.Taylor, I know this is coming to the Board on Tuesday. I know it will be approved I'm not against it but we need your help with traffic calming on Weber Blvd S. The traffic each day in the morning and in the afternoon has no concern for the residence on the street and 95% never obey the speed limit. We need to either have some speed humps installed or stop signs or anything to slow the traffic down. The amount of traffic is directly related to school drop off and pickups and people using Weber Blvd S to bypass 951 ! I ask you and each of the commissioners to help us with the County Traffic department in making our nice residential street safe again so people can walk and ride Bikes on the bike path safely with traffic not re than a couple of feet away traveling at high speed it is not safe. Thank you for your time and all you do for the people of Collier County. Pat Patrick K. Miller Senior Vice President Lake Michigan Credit Union (239) 919-1362 mi HICAN u (239) 216-2285 (mobile) Of FlOittfU 3003 Tamiami Trail N. Ste. 100 I Naples FL 34103-2714 Patrick.Miller(c�lmcu.org I LMCU.orq NMLS ID# 911706 1 GrecoSherry From: Gary VanDeWerken <garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, November 15, 2018 3:31 PM To: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaboJames; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna; FaulknerSue; StrainMark; HomiakKaren; stanchzanowski@colliergov.net; FryerEdwin; SchmittJoseph Cc: GARY VANDEWERKEN Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church Attachments: W-2_2.pdf;ATT00001.txt;Willow_2.pdf;ATT00002.txt Follow Up Flag: Flag for follow up Flag Status: Flagged To Collier County Commissioners and Planning,Just a couple of concerns. Did this church shrink in size they bought and rezoned then sold land in 2011 on Learning Lane and Livingston Road because they were asking for 500 seats and 150 preschool students on 14.3 acres. They acquired property on Golden gate Blvd and 1st Ave SW looking to rezone as conditional use purchased on 11/28/16 Then purchased another property at 6645 Willow Park Drive less than a year ago purchased on 12/11/17 I believe there attorney said they have outgrown this property as well. But failed to mention the new church they recently purchased. Located at Max Hasse Park on 9/20/18 Thank you for your time, Gary VanDeWerken 1 GrecoSherry From: Gary VanDeWerken <garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, November 15, 2018 12:09 PM To: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaboJames; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna; FaulknerSue; StrainMark; HomiakKaren; stanchzanowski@colliergov.net; FryerEdwin; SchmittJoseph Cc: GARY VANDEWERKEN Subject: URGENT ATTENTION (CCPC) Grace Romanian Baptist Church Attachments: CCE 15112018_2.pdf;ATT00001.txt To the board of Collier County Commissioners, It has come to my attention that Grace Romanian Baptist Church has purchased an existing church located by Max Hasse Park on 9/20/18, when Grace Romanian Baptist Church presented this project to the board for rezoning this was not mentioned to the commissioners. Is this church involved in real estate business? Im a Weber Blvd Resident of 32 years and care for my neighborhood and would like to keep it quiet as possible with less traffic. Thanks For your time Gary VanDeWerken 2 GrecoSherry From: Gary VanDeWerken <garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, November 14, 2018 2:25 PM To: FaulknerSue;Andy.Solis@colliercounty.gov; McDanielBill; SaboJames; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna; TaylorPenny Subject: Re: "Property Zoned Residential Estates Keep it Residential" Grace Romanian Baptist Church Hi Sue, Heres some more info, they have a new location down 1st ave SW across from Max Hasse Park this was not mentioned at the meeting its on there face book page,the only thing mentioned was Naples Baptist church off orange blossom that they had to leave and office space they have out grown. Why not tell us about this existing church? Thanks Gary Grace Romanian Baptist Church New Location !!! Locatie Noua !!! Duminica 10 am-12:00 pm & 6.00-7:30 pm 3380 Golden Gate Blvd. W, Naples, FL 34120 Go &AtBird w Phone: 239-961-0262 3 V'Art SW contact@grbcn.org a www.grbcn.org On Nov 13, 2018, at 4:34 PM, FaulknerSue <Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.Rov>wrote: Dear Mr.VanDeWerken, Thank you for your communication; it will be provided to the Collier County Planning Commission and Board of County Commissioners. Kind Regards, Sue Faulkner, Principal Planner Collier County Growth Management Department 3 Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104 phone: 239-252-5715; E-fax: 239-252-2838 Website: www.colliercountyfl.Rov Email: Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.Rov NOTE: Email Address Has Changed Collier County Motto: "To exceed expectations." Tell us how we are doing by taking our Zoning Division Survey at http://bit.ly/CollierZoning. Original Message From: Gary VanDeWerken<garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, November 12, 2018 12:36 PM To: FaulknerSue<Sue.Faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov>;Andy.Solis@colliercounty.gov; McDanielBill <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaboJames<James.Sabo@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaundersBurt <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>; FialaDonna <Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>; TaylorPenny <Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: "Property Zoned Residential Estates Keep it Residential" Grace Romanian Baptist Church To The Collier County commissioners, As a long term resident of Collier County of 50 years, Im living on the property adjacent to the subject property for 32 years with my family because it is zoned residential estates. I will ask all commissioners these questions, when you purchase property in a residential neighborhood did you plan on changing the zoning? Do you want a church and traffic associated with it next to your home? Would you want somebody to change zoning in your in your residential neighbor hood? Would you like drug rehabilitation center next to your home? Do you think its in your neighborhoods best interests to have drug rehabilitation and traffic associated with a church? We have seen no plans of the actual building,just plotted land and parking, septic drain field.There was an environmental study completed? How did they forget the land purchased for a supply well by Collier County off 1st Ave SW less than 100 feet away from proposed church drain field. A seating capacity of 300 on septic system is not acceptable for anyone in the vacinity using well water for drinking supply that would be everyone. Is there room for a sewer water treatment plant on the subject property? No sewer available, should not be allowed. Grace Romanian Baptist Church had another piece of land rezoned conditional use, they sold it. I appose anything other than residential estates, keep it residential estates. This is the gateway to the Golden Gate Estates. Thanks For Your time Gary VanDeWerken 4 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 5 GrecoSherry From: Gary VanDeWerken <garyvandewerken@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, November 12, 2018 12:36 PM To: FaulknerSue; Andy.Solis@colliercounty.gov; McDanielBill; SaboJames; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna; TaylorPenny Subject: "Property Zoned Residential Estates Keep it Residential" Grace Romanian Baptist Church To The Collier County commissioners, As a long term resident of Collier County of 50 years, Im living on the property adjacent to the subject property for 32 years with my family because it is zoned residential estates. I will ask all commissioners these questions, when you purchase property in a residential neighborhood did you plan on changing the zoning? Do you want a church and traffic associated with it next to your home? Would you want somebody to change zoning in your in your residential neighbor hood? Would you like drug rehabilitation center next to your home? Do you think its in your neighborhoods best interests to have drug rehabilitation and traffic associated with a church? We have seen no plans of the actual building,just plotted land and parking, septic drain field. There was an environmental study completed? How did they forget the land purchased for a supply well by Collier County off 1st Ave SW less than 100 feet away from proposed church drain field. A seating capacity of 300 on septic system is not acceptable for anyone in the vacinity using well water for drinking supply that would be everyone. Is there room for a sewer water treatment plant on the subject property? No sewer available, should not be allowed. Grace Romanian Baptist Church had another piece of land rezoned conditional use, they sold it. I appose anything other than residential estates, keep it residential estates.This is the gateway to the Golden Gate Estates. Thanks For Your time Gary VanDeWerken 6 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Wednesday, November 7, 2018 11:44 AM To: TaylorPenny Subject: RE: Grace Romanian Baptist Church & New Hope Ministries Attachments: graceromanianchurch.doc Importance: High Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Updated executive summary for Grace Romanian attached. S/ierrj C7reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From:TaylorPenny Sent: Monday, November 5, 2018 9:19 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Re: Grace Romanian Baptist Church & New Hope Ministries Sherry, I didn't get the complete Executive Summary on the Romanian Baptist Church. Penny Penny Taylor Collier County Board of County Commissioners Commissioner, District 4 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303 Naples, FL 34112 Office (239) 252-8604 Fax (239) 252-6393 From: GrecoSherry Sent: Monday, November 5, 2018 2:50 PM To:TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church & New Hope Ministries See attached. I think it might be the New Hope Ministries. Sherry Clreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 8 GrecoSherry From: TaylorPenny Sent: Monday, November 5,2018 9:19 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: Re: Grace Romanian Baptist Church & New Hope Ministries Sherry, I didn't get the complete Executive Summary on the Romanian Baptist Church. Penny Penny Taylor Collier County Board of County Commissioners Commissioner, District 4 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303 Naples, FL 34112 Office (239) 252-8604 Fax (239) 252-6393 From: GrecoSherry Sent: Monday, November 5, 2018 2:50 PM To:TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church & New Hope Ministries See attached. I think it might be the New Hope Ministries. scierj Clreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 9 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Monday, November 5, 2018 2:51 PM To: TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Romanian Baptist Church & New Hope Ministries Attachments: graceromanianchurch.doc; NewHopeMinistriesl2-13-16.doc it might be the New Hope attached. I think g Ministries. scerr, 4reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 10 GrecoSherry From: James Schortemeyer <schortfire@aol.com> Sent: Monday, November 5, 2018 10:38 AM To: TaylorPenny Subject: Re: Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, Honorable Commissioner Taylor, PLEASE DENY THIS PETITION. Ordinance petition PL20160002584/CPSS-2017-1, a Growth Management Plan Small Scale Amendment specific to the Conditional Uses Subdistrict of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan, to allow church uses for the Grace Romanian Baptist Church. (Adoption Hearing) [This is a Companion to Agenda Item 6976] South Weber Blvd. has already been adversely impacted by zoning changes on first avenue SW and so called road 'improvements' on Golden Gate Blvd. and White Blvd. Left turns are not allowed onto either of these roads from South Weber BLVD. Traffic patterns are already intolerable and another zoning 'exception' along this corridor should not be approved. It will further exacerbate traffic issues with increased illegal turns, u turns, and wrong way traffic. The Weber Blvd. Estates Zoning has already been severely severely compromised by high volume traffic on CR 951, White Blvd. and golden Gate Blvd. Along with already approved variances including nearby commercial developments we are at the threshold of losing the wildlife and environmental benefits that we cherish. Right now, we are fortunate to have large mammals such as deer, panther and black bear frequent our neighborhood but there have already been too many vehicle collisions with these large mammals. Please protect our'estates zoning', environmental values, and wildlife by denying this petition to allow another zoning exception in Unit 4, GGE. Jim Schortemeyer 3481 5th ave sw Naples, Fl 11 09/13/2016 OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (Board) review staff's findings and recommendations along with the recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) regarding the above referenced petition and render a decision regarding this PUD rezone petition; and ensure the project is in harmony with all the applicable codes and regulations in order to ensure that the community's interests are maintained. CONSIDERATIONS: The petitioner, who owns the subject property, is requesting to rezone 12.17+ acres (from CFPUD) and incorporate the land area into the existing RPUD, in order to allow for an additional forty-eight(48)residential dwelling units. The developer would also have an alternative option to develop the site with group housing [i.e., up to one hundred and fifty (150) additional units] instead of residential dwellings. This petition also seeks to amend an existing deviation related to the allowable Floor Area Ratio(FAR). FISCAL IMPACT: The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of building permits to help offset the impacts of each new development on public facilities. These impact fees are used to fund projects identified in the Capital Improvement Element(CIE) of the Growth Management Plan (GMP) as needed to maintain adopted Level of Service (LOS) for public facilities. Additionally, in order to meet the requirements of concurrency management, the developer of every local development order approved by Collier County is required to pay a portion of the estimated Transportation Impact Fees associated with the project in accordance with Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Other fees collected prior to issuance of a building permit include building permit review fees. Finally, additional revenue is generated by application of ad valorem tax rates, and that revenue is directly related to the value of the improvements. Please note that impact fees and taxes collected were not included in the criteria used by staff and the CCPC to analyze this petition. GROWTH MANAGEMENT (GMP) IMPACT: Future Land Use Element (FLUE): Comprehensive Planning staff finds this petition consistent with the FLUE: however staff recommends a possible interconnection to the north be identified on the PUD master plan and in Exhibit F - Developer Commitments of the PUD Document. Transportation Element: Based on the 2015 Annual Update and Inventory Reports (AUIR), the adjacent roadway network has sufficient capacity to accommodate the project within the five (5) year planning period. Therefore, the subject rezoning can be found consistent with Policy 5.1 of the Transportation Element of the GMP. Transportation Planning staff is also recommending that a future interconnection be shown on the master plan to the undeveloped parcel to the north. The agent notes in the application that his property is currently owned by the Diocese of Venice; which may or may not eventually develop this parcel in the future. These types of interconnections can provide access between developments reducing access to Livingston Road. For this reason, staff is recommending the interconnections be added to the master plan. Conservation and Coastal Management Element (CCME): Environmental Review staff found this project to be consistent with the Conservation& Coastal Management Element(CCME). The project site consists of 40.25 acres of native vegetation; and minimum of 10.06 acres (25%) of the existing native vegetation shall be placed under preservation and dedicated to Collier County. GMP Conclusion: The GMP is the prevailing document to support land use decisions, such as this proposed rezoning. Staff is required to make a recommendation regarding a finding of consistency with the overall GMP as part of the recommendation for approval, approval with conditions, or denial of any rezoning petition. This petition is consistent with the GMP. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC 09/13/2016 reviewed this petition at their June 2, 2016 meeting. The applicant made a presentation and provided a slightly different version of the proposed master plan than the version contained in each Commissioner's packet. Both versions of the master plan illustrated the potential for interconnection from the subject property to Learning Lane, a roadway owned by The School Board of Collier County,Florida. However, the new version eliminated the vehicular component of the access point because the School Board would not allow it. Notwithstanding, the potential for pedestrian interconnection from the subject property to Learning Lane would remain as part of the design. When the public hearing portion of the meeting was opened, four(4) members of the public spoke. Greg Bosco, who represented the Camden Lakes Homeowners Association, spoke in opposition to the project. The other three (3) speakers, (Karen Paul, Barry Weissman, and Fred Smith) expressed their concerns as well. Commissioner Chrzanowski made a motion to approve, which was seconded by Commissioner Assad. The vote to approve was unanimous(7-0)with the understanding the following would be corrected: 1. No vehicular access shall be permitted from the subject property to Learning Lane. Pedestrian access shall be permitted; and 2. Show a continuous preserve area along Learning Lane with an arrow signifying optional pedestrian access. The pedestrian access through the preserve shall be a boardwalk, pervious pathway, or similar composition. Notwithstanding staff's recommendation and the CCPC's unanimous decision to recommend approval, there are still letters/emails of objection for this petition. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This is a rezone of 12.17 acres of land from the Grace Romanian Baptist Church of Naples CFPUD to the RMC-Enclave RPUD and an amendment to the existing RMC-Enclave RPUD(Ordinance No.2014-34, as amended). The burden falls upon the applicant for the amendment to prove that the proposal is consistent with all of the criteria set forth below. The burden then shifts to the Board of County Commissioners, should it consider denial, that such denial is not arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable. This would be accomplished by finding that the amendment does not meet one or more of the listed criteria. Criteria for PUD Amendments Ask yourself the following questions. The answers assist you in making a determination for approval or not. 1. Consider: The suitability of the area for the type and pattern of development proposed in relation to physical characteristics of the land, surrounding areas, traffic and access, drainage, sewer,water, and other utilities. 2. Is there an adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of agreements, contract, or other instruments or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as they may relate to arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing operation and maintenance of such areas and facilities that are not to be provided or maintained at public expense? Findings and recommendations of this type shall be made only after consultation with the County Attorney. 3. Consider: Conformity of the proposed PUD with the goals, objectives and policies of the 09/13/2016 Growth Management Plan. 4. Consider: The internal and external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions may include restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and buffering and screening requirements. 5. Is there an adequacy of usable open space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the development? 6. Consider: The timing or sequence of development(as proposed)for the purpose of assuring the adequacy of available improvements and facilities,both public and private. 7. Consider: The ability of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate expansion. 8. Consider: Conformity with PUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of such regulations in the particular case, based on determination that such modifications are justified as meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such regulations. 9. Will the proposed change be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies and future land use map and the elements of the Growth Management Plan? 10. Will the proposed PUD Rezone be appropriate considering the existing land use pattern? 11. Would the requested PUD Rezone result in the possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts? 12. Consider: Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to existing conditions on the property proposed for change. 13. Consider: Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed amendment necessary. 14. Will the proposed change adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood? 15. Will the proposed change create or excessively increase traffic congestion or create types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses, because of peak volumes or projected types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction phases of the development, or otherwise affect public safety? 16. Will the proposed change create a drainage problem? 17. Will the proposed change seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas? 18. Will the proposed change adversely affect property values in the adjacent area? 19. Will the proposed change be a deterrent to the improvement or development of adjacent property in accordance with existing regulations? 20. Consider: Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to an 09/13/2016 individual owner as contrasted with the public welfare. 21. Are there substantial reasons why the property cannot ("reasonably") be used in accordance with existing zoning? (a"core"question...) 22. Is the change suggested out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or the county? 23. Consider: Whether it is impossible to find other adequate sites in the county for the proposed use in districts already permitting such use. 24. Consider: The physical characteristics of the property and the degree of site alteration which would be required to make the property usable for any of the range of potential uses under the proposed zoning classification. 25. Consider: The impact of development resulting from the proposed PUD rezone on the • availability of adequate public facilities and services consistent with the levels of service adopted in the Collier County Growth Management Plan and as defined and implemented through the Collier County Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance [Code ch.106, art.II], as amended. 26. Are there other factors, standards, or criteria relating to the PUD rezone request that the Board of County Commissioners shall deem important in the protection of the public health, safety, and welfare? The Board must base its decision upon the competent, substantial evidence presented by the written materials supplied to it, including but not limited to the Staff Report, Executive Summary, maps, studies, letters from interested persons and the oral testimony presented at the Board hearing as these items relate to these criteria. This item has been approved as to form and legality, and requires an affirmative vote of four for Board approval. (HFAC) RECOMMENDATION: Staff concurs with the recommendations of the CCPC, which are reflected in the attached PUB Ordinance. Staff recommends the Board approves the applicant's request to rezone 12.171 acres (from CFPUD) and incorporate the land area into the existing RPUD, in order to allow for an additional forty-eight (48) residential dwelling units. The developer would also have an alternative option to develop the site with group housing [i.e., up to one hundred and fifty (150) additional units] instead of residential dwellings. Prepared by: Eric L. Johnson, AICP, CFM, Principal Planner, Zoning Division, Growth Management Depai lment ATTACHMENT(S) 1.Attachment 2-Items Collected by Court Reporter CCPC June 2 2016 (PDF) 2. [Linked] Attachment 3 -Transcipt of CCPC June 2 2016(PDF) 3. [Linked] Attachment 4- Staff Report and Backup Material (PDF) 4.Attachment 5 -Email Omitted from CCPC Packet (PDF) 5.Attachment 6-Public Notice Signs (PDF) 6.Attachment 1 -Ordinance- 081816 (PDF) 7.Legal Ad-Agenda ID 16940000 (PDF) 09/13/2016 COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 9.0 Doc ID: 1694 Item Summary: This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance No. 2014-34, the RMC-Enclave Residential Planned Unit Development, and amending Ordinance No. 2004-41, the Collier County Land Development Code, by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of an additional 12.17+ acres of land zoned Community Facility Planned Unit Development (CFPUD) known as the Grace Romanian Baptist Church of Naples CFPUD to the Residential Planned Unit Development (RPUD) zoning district known as the RMC-Enclave RPUD; by adding 48 residential dwelling units for a total of 162 residential dwelling units or by adding 150 group housing units for a total of 500 group housing units; by amending the master plan; by repealing Ordinance No. 11-18, the Grace Romanian Baptist Church of Naples CFPUD; and by providing an effective date. The subject property is located at the northwest quadrant of Learning Lane and Livingston Road, in Section 13, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County,Florida consisting of 40.55+acres. Meeting Date: 09/13/2016 Prepared by: Title: Planner, Principal—Zoning Name: Eric Johnson 08/04/2016 9:08 AM Submitted by: Title: Division Director-Planning and Zoning—Zoning Name: Michael Bosi 08/04/2016 9:08 AM Approved By: Review: Zoning Michael Bosi Level 1 Sim. Reviewer 1-8 Completed 08/04/2016 10:39 AM Zoning Ray Bellows Level 1 Sim. Reviewer 1-8 Completed 08/08/2016 10:28 AM Growth Management Department Judy Puig Level 1 Division Reviewer Completed 08/11/2016 11:59 AM Growth Management Department Jeanne Marcella Level 2 Division Administrator Completed 08/15/2016 9:55 AM County Attorney's Office Heidi Ashton-Cicko Level 2 Attorney of Record Review Completed 08/23/2016 9:08 AM County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 08/23/2016 9:24 AM Office of Management and Budget Valerie Fleming Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 08/23/2016 10:20 AM Budget and Management Office Mark Isackson Level 3 OMB 1st Reviewer 1-4 Completed 08/25/2016 8:42 AM County Manager's Office Nick Casalanguida Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 08/27/2016 10:31 AM Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending 09/13/2016 9:00 AM • 12/13/2016 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance Number 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code,which established the comprehensive zoning regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from a Community Facility Planned Unit Development known as New Hope Ministries CFPUD zoning district to a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD) zoning district for the project to be known as the New Hope MPUD, to allow an 800 seat church and construction of a maximum of 319 multi-family dwelling units on 39.89 +1- acres, by providing for repeal of Ordinance Number 08-07, the New Hope Ministries CFPUD; and by providing an effective date. The subject property is located on the north side of Davis Boulevard east of Santa Barbara Boulevard in Section 4, Township 50 South, Range 26 East,Collier County,Florida. [PUDR-PL20150002519] OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (Board) review staff's findings and recommendations along with the recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) regarding the above referenced petition and render a decision regarding this Planned Unit Development Rezone (PUDZ) petition; and ensure the project is in harmony with all the applicable codes and regulations in order to ensure that the community's interests are maintained. CONSIDERATIONS: The petitioner is requesting to rezone the±39.89 acre site from the New Hope Ministries Community Facility Planned Unit Development (CFPUD, Ordinance No. 08-07)to the New Hope Mixed Use PUD (MPUD). This rezone will allow Community Facility (CF) uses to continue on the eastern portion of the property (+19.96 acres), while providing multi-family residential uses on the remaining ±19.93 acres at a density of up to 16 dwelling units per acre (DU/A) on Tract R (Residential), permitting a maximum of 319 DUs to be developed. The maximum number of seats for a church will be reduced from 4,200 to 800, since CF uses will only be permitted on a portion of the entire property. FISCAL IMPACT: The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of building permits to help offset the impacts of each new development on public facilities. These impact fees are used to fund projects identified in the Capital Improvement Element(CIE) of the Growth Management Plan(GMP) as needed to maintain adopted Level of Service (LOS) for public facilities. Additionally, in order to meet the requirements of concurrency management, the developer of every local development order approved by Collier County is required to pay a portion of the estimated Transportation Impact Fees associated with the project in accordance with Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Other fees collected prior to issuance of a building permit include building permit review fees. Finally, additional revenue is generated by application of ad valorem tax rates, and that revenue is directly related to the value of the improvements. Please note that impact fees and taxes collected were not included in the criteria used by staff and the CCPC to analyze this petition. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: The GMP is the prevailing document to support land use decisions such as this proposed PUD Amendment application. Staff is required to make a recommendation regarding a finding of consistency or inconsistency with the overall GMP as part of the recommendation for approval, approval with conditions, or denial of any rezoning petition. A finding of consistency with the FLUE and the FLUM designation is a portion of the overall finding that is required, and staff believes the petition is consistent with the Collier County GMP as discussed in the attached CCPC Staff Report. Staff believes that the proposed Amendment may also be found consistent with the 12/13/2016 FLUE, GMP Transportation Element and the Conservation and Coastal Management Element. Therefore, staff recommends that the petition be found consistent with the goals, objective and policies of the overall GMP. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC heard this petition on November 3, 2016. The CCPC heard testimony from the Applicant's agent and County staff. A motion was made by Commissioner Homiak and seconded by Commissioner Schmitt to recommend approval, with the following conditions be added: 1.Remove internal buffer labels on the Master Plan. 2. Add a note referencing an Exhibit for Deviation #2 on the Master Plan. Provide an Exhibit to the proposed PUD showing the buffer location/extent and buffer types. 3. Revise the Development Table to reflect Building A, referenced on the Master Plans, as having a maximum of three(3) stories. 4. Revise Exhibit F - Planning C: by removing a gated access and instead add pedestrian interconnection. The motion passed by a vote of 5-0. No correspondence in opposition to this petition has been received. This item will be added to the Board Summary Agenda. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This is a site specific rezone from a Community Facility Planned Unit Development Zoning District to a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD) Zoning District for a project that will continue to be known as the New Hope MPUD. The burden falls upon the applicant to prove that the proposed rezone is consistent with all the criteria set forth below. The burden then shifts to the Board of County Commissioners (Board), should it consider denying the rezone, to determine that such denial would not be arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable. This would be accomplished by finding that the proposal does not meet one or more of the listed criteria below. Criteria for MPUD Rezones Ask yourself the following questions. The answers assist you in making a determination for approval or not. 1. Consider: The suitability of the area for the type and pattern of development proposed in relation to physical characteristics of the land, surrounding areas, traffic and access, drainage, sewer, water, and other utilities. 2. Is there an adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of agreements, contract, or other instruments or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as they may relate to arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing operation and maintenance of such areas and facilities that are not to be provided or maintained at public expense? Findings and recommendations of this type shall be made only after consultation with the County Attorney. 3. Consider: Conformity of the proposed MPUD with the goals, objectives and policies of the Growth Management Plan. 12/13/2016 4. Consider: The internal and external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions may include restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and buffering and screening requirements. 5. Is there an adequacy of usable open space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the development? 6. Consider: The timing or sequence of development (as proposed) for the purpose of assuring the adequacy of available improvements and facilities, both public and private. 7. Consider: The ability of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate expansion. 8. Consider: Conformity with MPUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of such regulations in the particular case, based on determination that such modifications are justified as meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such regulations. 9. Will the proposed change be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies and future land use map and the elements of the Growth Management Plan? 10. Will the proposed MPUD Rezone be appropriate considering the existing land use pattern? 11. Would the requested MPUD Rezone result in the possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts? 12. Consider: Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to existing conditions on the property proposed for change. 13. Consider: Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed amendment necessary. 14. Will the proposed change adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood? 15. Will the proposed change create or excessively increase traffic congestion or create types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses, because of peak volumes or projected types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction phases of the development, or otherwise affect public safety? 16. Will the proposed change create a drainage problem? 17. Will the proposed change seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas? 18. Will the proposed change adversely affect property values in the adjacent area? 19. Will the proposed change be a deterrent to the improvement or development of adjacent property in accordance with existing regulations? 20. Consider: Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to an individual owner as contrasted with the public welfare. 21. Are there substantial reasons why the property cannot ("reasonably") be used in accordance with existing zoning? (a"core"question...) GrecoSherry From: Patrick Miller <Patrick.Miller@lmcu.org> Sent: Saturday, November 10, 2018 4:10 PM To: FaulknerSue; McDanielBill; donna.fiala@colliercountfl.gov; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; SolisAndy Cc: StrainMark Subject: Grace Romanian Church GG Blvd and 951 To all: This petition continues to change from a neighborhood church with limited hours and restrictions which are much more compatible with our Neighborhood and the life that we all have moved to the Estates to enjoy. My wife and I have lived on Weber Blvd S for over 25 years and in Collier County for over 50 years. Please review your own county attorneys guidance that the CPI ignored! I quote their job is to how to make the conditional use compatible with the neighborhood "They failed in their duties and this conditional use is not compatible with the neighborhood when it is allowed to operate 24 hrs a day 7 days a week and have drug and alcohol rehab services, This request also requires an amendment to the Land Development Code which should also not be approved. Please Please do not vote for this request and send it back for reconsideration to the CCPC and instruct them to do their duties as out Inked by the county attorney Thank you for your time and consideration Patrick K. Miller Terry B Miller 210 Weber Blvd S Naples, Fl. 34117 239-216-2285 1 GrecoSherry From: Michael R. Ramsey <michael.r.ramsey@embargmail.com> Sent: Monday, June 5, 2017 2:03 PM To: 'Jessica Harrelson' Cc: BosiMichael; StrainMark;VanLengenKris; SolisAndy; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna;TaylorPenny Subject: Grace Romanian Church Meeting Request to meet with Golden Gate Estates Area Civic Assoc Attachments: 2017 0605 LETTER GRACE ROMANIAN CHURCH RESPONSE.pdf Ms.Jessica, Please see the attached letter. GGEACA has decided at this time it is inappropriate to have a community meeting concerning this project. Michael R. Ramsey President, Golden Gate Estates Area Civic Association Ramsey Inc Ecological Environmental Consulting 2631 4th St NW Naples FL 34120 239.564.1660 Michael.R.Ramsey@embargmail.com Ramsey.lnc@embargmail.com 1 vea The Golden Gate Estates Area Civic Association, Inc P.O.Box 990596,Naples,FL 34116-6002 A% www.estates-civic.org 61arq 05 June 2017 Davidson Engineering, Inc. 4365 Radio Rd, Suite 201 Naples, FL 34104 RE: GGEACA Declines Request for Community Meeting regarding proposed Project: PL20160002584, Grace Community Church at 3899 1st Ave. SW; PID 36760720005 & PID 36760800006; and companion PL20160002577. Dear Sir/Madam Golden Gate Estates Area Civic Association (GGEACA)has received your request to hold a community meeting with regarding the proposed project of Grace Romanian Church. GGEACA understands this project to be applying for a Zoning Change,Growth Management Plan Amendment and a Golden Gate Master Plan Amendment. We appreciate being included in the proposed changes that may affect the Estates community. We have taken the information you have provided and evaluated it with our group. Concerns for traffic and the need for comprehensive planning in the community are the purpose for the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Restudy. Amending the Growth Management Plan through amendments like this is counter to the comprehensive planning being undertaken. As well, there are serious concerns with this project's traffic circulation, traffic impacts to the area, and the impacts to the gateway to Golden gate Estates At this time we have come to the conclusion that it is inappropriate to meet with your group concerning this project. The reason we have come to this conclusion is that the Golden Gate Master Plan is currently undergoing a comprehensive update and we feel it is inappropriate for this project to be considered during the update process. Furthermore, it is GGEACA's position that no applications of this type shoul be considered until after completion of the Golden Gate Master Plan Update. Sincerely, Michael R. Ramsey PresidentGolden Gate Estates Area Civic Association http://www.estates-civic.org Michael.R.Ramsey@embarqmail.com c: Board of County Commissioners, Collier Co. GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2018 1:22 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Confirmed© Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.comCOLEMAN I V A °/ i Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. sit a ti r • y Trusted & Verified • ,,, 0. 0. ,,,,,00.,1 P'.41' Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2018 12:20 PM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Wednesday at 11 AM is open please confirm. S4erry Cjreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter . From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 23, 2018 11:13 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church 1 Sorry, Rich just told me he will not be available Thursday afternoon anymore Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant c y K The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 .y dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com Cr O l E,M A N I .f O V A N O V I C., H { K O E S T R Visi8t cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. s ,. tai_ • Trusted & Verifiedfe , •I Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.cam or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2018 11:10 AM To: GrecoSherry (Sherry.Greco@colliercountvfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Hello, Rich would like to meet with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming November 13th agenda item: Grace Romanian Church. Also attending: Jessica Harrelson,Josh Fruth,Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver Availability: Wednesday November 7th: 9:00-1:00 Thursday November 8th: 1:00—5:00 Monday November 12th: 9:00—3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C t E M A N I Y O V A N O V I C H K O S T R 2 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2018 1:22 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Confirmed° Dianna Quintanilla CYK 1 Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN {I v O V A N O V I H I K O E S T E R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. got,/* i • 4,1 Tested & Verified ' 't....� Ti e Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla(acyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2018 12:20 PM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Wednesday at 11 AM is open please confirm. Sherr 4reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 23, 2018 11:13 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church 1 Sorry, Rich just told me he will not be available Thursday afternoon anymore Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com CO I F lM A N I Y O V A N O V I H K E T R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. S.",ib ,. a • Trusted Verified •Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2018 11:10 AM To: GrecoSherry (Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Hello, Rich would like to meet with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming November 13th agenda item: Grace Romanian Church. Also attending: Jessica Harrelson,Josh Fruth, Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver Availability: Wednesday November 7th: 9:00-1:00 Thursday November 8th: 1:00—5:00 Monday November 12th: 9:00—3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F. 239.435.1218 y,, dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O t MAN f Y O V A N O V I C H I K O S T R 2 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21St: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant cyK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN I YOVANOV1CH f KOESTER Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. soh'to Trusted & Verified 146, Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla(a cyklawfirm.cam or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 1. GrecoSherry Subject: CANCELLED - Grace Romanian Church, Rich Yovanovich, Jessica Harrelson,Josh Fruth, Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver Location: Taylor office Start: Thu 11/8/2018 2:00 PM End: Thu 11/8/2018 2:30 PM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Dianna Quintanilla 2 GrecoSherry Subject: Grace Romanian Church, Rich Yovanovich, Jessica Harrelson, Josh Fruth, Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver Location: Taylor office Start: Thu 11/8/2018 2:00 PM End: Thu 11/8/2018 2:30 PM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Dianna Quintanilla 3 GrecoSherry Subject: Grace Romanian Church, Rich Yovanovich,Jessica Harrelson, Josh Fruth,Adrian Roman and Anna Weaver Location: Taylor office Start: Wed 11/7/2018 11:00 AM End: Wed 11/7/2018 11:30 AM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Dianna Quintanilla 4 GrecoSherry Subject: Grace Romanian Church - Rich Yovanovich, Anna Weaver &Josh Fruth (Davidson Engineering) Location: 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303, Naples, FL 34112 Start: Tue 2/19/2019 11:30 AM End: Tue 2/19/2019 12:00 PM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Dianna Quintanilla Dianna, Can we please change this meeting to 11:30 AM? The Commissioner has gotten invited to an outside meeting that she must attend. 5 • GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Wednesday, February 6, 2019 9:16 AM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Confirmed O Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 +/ dquintanilla(�cyklawfirm.com O MAN ! Y O V A N O V I C h K EST R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. +�wert ,i Trusted & Verified • Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Wednesday, February 6, 2019 9:08 AM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good morning, How about Thursday the 19th at 9:30 AM and please confirm. Thank you. scerrj 4reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter 6 From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 5, 2019 3:54 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Just following up on the meeting request below: Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00, 4:00 Thursday February 21St: 1:00- 4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COIEAAAN Y O V A N O V i C H K O E S T E R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. ,,rlrr* 476 :Trusted & Verified Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry (Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 7 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21st: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22nd: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O t E M A N I Y O V A N O V I C H K O S T R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. :Trusted & Verified 4r' {",.. t'* Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 8 GrecoSherry Subject: Grace Romanian Church - Rich Yovanovich,Anna Weaver &Josh Fruth (Davidson Engineering) Location: 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303, Naples, FL 34112 Start: Tue 2/19/2019 9:30 AM End: Tue 2/19/2019 10:00 AM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Dianna Quintanilla 9 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Wednesday, February 6, 2019 9:08 AM To: 'Dianna Quintanilla' Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good morning, How about Thursday the 19th at 9:30 AM and please confirm. Thank you. Sherr &eco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 5, 2019 3:54 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Just following up on the meeting request below: Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21St: 1:00- 4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant cyK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O I E M A N ( Y O V A N O V I C H I K O S T R 10 • , Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. ttr , "1 1, Trusted & Verified ISI,,, fi r 14'aped P` Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.cam or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry (Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21St: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C Q t E M A N 1 YOVANOV1CH I KOESTER Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. 5,44tt Trusted & Verified f 4 Oa a Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please 11 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Tuesday, February 5, 2019 4:06 PM To: 'Dianna Quintanilla' Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Sorry I will contact you in the am. Arty Greco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 5, 2019 3:54 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Just following up on the meeting request below: Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21St: 1:00- 4:00 Friday February 22nd: 9:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla(�cyklawfirm.com C O t E M A N I Y O V A N O V I C H I K O E S T E R Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. 13 SOitl. • it 8 :: Trusted & Veri f id 4 rife.«d ti Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry (Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 215t: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK • The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla(a�cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN I Y O V A N O V I FI K ESTE R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. or1ti. «a Trusted & Verified s Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 14 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 5, 2019 3:54 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Just following up on the meeting request below: Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21St: 1:00- 4:00 Friday February 22nd: 9:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant C Y K The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 , Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN I YOvANOVICH I KOESTER Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. ‘41444 A 8 Trusted & Verified . • . io , Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla(a cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry (Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. 15 That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21st: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COL MAN I Y O V A N O V I C H K O S 3 R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. • +,+rf r,i Trusted & Verified t tr ,. r Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanillaPcyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 16 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21St: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla C y Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O t. E M A N l YOVANOVICH KOESTER Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. sous. J f 'w Trusted & Verified Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 1 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Wednesday, February 6, 2019 9:16 AM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Confirmed © Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O t M A 1N I Y O y A N O V I H K ESTE R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. sow Trusted & Verified w Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla(Bcyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Wednesday, February 6, 2019 9:08 AM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good morning, How about Thursday the 19th at 9:30 AM and please confirm. Thank you. sherry ( reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter 1 From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, February 5, 2019 3:54 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Just following up on the meeting request below: Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00, 4:00 Thursday February 21St: 1:00- 4:00 Friday February 22nd: 9:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN I YOVANOV1CH KOESTR Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. • i. ... * 4st.i� %-t8 :Trusted & Verified „, ...„ ....4 .1...6 ,, Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry (Sherrv.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 2 . Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21St: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla y K Legal Assistant . The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COL MI AN Y O V A N O V I C.H KOESTER Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. • **el tit 8: vt '-Trusted & Verified w .,z:, 1,4 Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 3 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 5, 2019 3:54 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Just following up on the meeting request below: Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21st: 1:00- 4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O f M A N I vOvANOviCH K O E S T E R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. sotriw ab ''Trusted & Verified Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanillaPcyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent: Wednesday, January 30, 2019 3:49 PM To: GrecoSherry (Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov) Subject: Meeting Request: Grace Romanian Church Good afternoon, I know I'm requesting this a bit early but Rich's calendar is getting pretty full for February. 4 . That being said, he would like to schedule a meeting with the Commissioner regarding the upcoming Agenda Item— Grace Romanian on 2/26. Anna Weaver&Josh Fruth from Davidson Engineering will also attend. Availability: Monday February 18th: 2:00, 3:00 Tuesday February 19th: 9:00—12:00,4:00 Thursday February 21st: 10:30—4:00 Friday February 22"d: 9:00, 2:00 Monday February 25th: 1:00, 2:00, 3:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O t E M AN I Y O V A N O V 1 C H I K S T R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. re ,94 Trusted & Verifie+d h Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cvklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 5 ,Lit CGAOA A � • C, (' 62 \6-n ti - c) -`' .- Board of Collier County Commissioners Penny Taylor District 4 -f._f {J� ��' _1.1 may _ ter :t' Ult ``-- -y- R cl -- ( verb eer-4-ci \i'vv-Axc ) 7 v v....._ ,.,c)(..c)._ ‘"?.,(e------ ' ..,.c., \C)06 TO • Pre G� I TIM 4 , _ allO 1 4. 1 /i .- — PM FROM ( � i PHON H GE ( 6! ,�[• 1 OF C -FPJ ) y N, 3J E 6 rot CC / 1i cvI C.Vt (A- k, M s \ a ®I`;Ce E A!J vt A 1 , sa, 00 i E-MAIL ADORES E:1 o .tivfLeL E - eIva ILL ALL s) ; u GEN ^ , , ice/ zo,z ®arlueune•r�For:M. �. (`"J b : t-f' 3299 Tamiami Trail East,Suite 303•Naples,Florida 34112.239 252 8604