Agenda 02/12/2019 Item #16A1002/12/2019
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve the release of a code enforcement lien with an accrued value of
$8,205.37 for payment of $1,105.37 in the code enforcement action entitled Board of County
Commissioners v. Pentecostal Church of God, Code Enforcement Board Case No. 1999071503
relating to property located at 630 W. Main Street, Collier County, Florida.
OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners (Board) to accept an offer to release a code
enforcement lien with an accrued value of $8,205.37 for payment of $1,105.37 in relation to Code
Enforcement Board Case No. 1999071503.
CONSIDERATIONS: As a result of code violations, consisting of interior alterations to include framing,
insulation, plumbing, electric, drywall and mechanical without first obtaining a Collier County building
permit, a lien was imposed on the property.
The lien was recorded in the Official Records on November 6, 2000, at O.R. Book 2740, Page 0550. The
lien amount of $8,205.37 is based on 151 days of accrued fines ($50 per day from August 28, 2000,
through January 25, 2001), totaling $7,550 plus $655.37 in operational costs. The property was acquired
by St. Matthew’s House, Inc., via Warranty Deed, recorded on August 30, 2016. The property was
brought into compliance on January 25, 2001, before the property was purchased by the new owners, as
they were unaware of the violations.
Pursuant to Resolution No. 2012-46, a request for waiver of fines may be considered when a code
enforcement lien encumbers property that is under new ownership and compliance has been achieved.
The property is being actively maintained, and $1,105.37 has been paid in settlement of fines. The new
owner is requesting a waiver of $7,100 in accrued fines. There are currently no known violations.
FISCAL IMPACT: Payment of $1,105.37 has been made, representing $450 in fines, plus $655.37 in
operational costs. If approved by the Board, accrued fines in the amount of $7,100 would be waived.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated with this
action.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The County Attorney’s Office has reviewed this item and approved it
as to form and legality. Majority support is required for approval. This item conforms to the Board’s
policy contained in Resolution 2012-46. - KN
RECOMMENDATION: To waive the fines in the amount of $7,100, accept payment amount of
$1,105.37, release the lien, and authorize the Chairman to sign the attached release and satisfaction of lien
for recording in the Official Public Records.
Prepared by: Michael Ossorio, Director, Code Enforcement Division
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Release and Satisfaction of Lien (PDF)
2. Lien Orders (PDF)
16.A.10
Packet Pg. 573
02/12/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 16.A.10
Doc ID: 7745
Item Summary: Recommendation to approve the release of a code enforcement lien with an
accrued value of $8,205.37 for payment of $1,105.37 in the code enforcement action entitled Board of
County Commissioners v. Pentecostal Church of God, Code Enforcement Board Case No. 1999071503
relating to property located at 630 W. Main Street, Collier County, Florida.
Meeting Date: 02/12/2019
Prepared by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Code Enforcement
Name: Iliana Burgos
01/10/2019 10:35 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Division Director - Code Enforcement – Code Enforcement
Name: Michael Ossorio
01/10/2019 10:35 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Code Enforcement Michael Ossorio Additional Reviewer Completed 01/10/2019 11:14 AM
Code Enforcement Marlene Serrano Additional Reviewer Completed 01/10/2019 3:12 PM
Growth Management Department Judy Puig Level 1 Reviewer Completed 01/10/2019 4:04 PM
Growth Management Department James C French Deputy Department Head Review Completed 01/14/2019 5:40 PM
Growth Management Department Thaddeus Cohen Department Head Review Completed 01/15/2019 1:52 PM
County Attorney's Office Kevin Noell Level 2 Attorney Review Completed 01/29/2019 9:50 AM
Office of Management and Budget Valerie Fleming Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 01/29/2019 11:57 AM
County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 01/30/2019 9:56 AM
Budget and Management Office Mark Isackson Additional Reviewer Completed 01/31/2019 9:33 AM
County Manager's Office Geoffrey Willig Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 01/31/2019 1:54 PM
Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending 02/12/2019 9:00 AM
16.A.10
Packet Pg. 574
16.A.10.a
Packet Pg. 575 Attachment: Release and Satisfaction of Lien (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
ic luering before
at
of Facl and
AuSusl I,
BOAR.D OF COTJNry COMMISSIONER,S
EOLUER. EOIJNTY. FLORIDA.
vs,
PENTECOSTAL CTIURCH OT OOD'
Rcrpon&nu
fHlS CAUSE came
duc noticc o Rcspondcnt.
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
COLLTER COUNTY. FLOzuDA
cAsE No. CEB 2000-010
!t!t
E1
-E
E
At thc Public
evidacc, ard isstcd its F
on &tobcr 26 2000, lncr
under oath. received
thcreupon issucd its onl
to Rcspon&nt. (attxhcd
-t3<8
=-H169:r tB:?3 6:! crrEEar--iE:
-E-J
=sBEg-
i:E F
EqoI...E!l rrr:.O
gE
I rtl-E
orrdcr which rmr rcduc.d lo
DE,oibit-A)
said ordcr rcquircd R6pondcnr to tale cqtsin corrcctive action to corrcct tb€ violetions
by E timc carlin as more spccifically set forth in this Ordg'
AnAffi&vitofNon{omplisncc,baringlhcd8lcofAugusl]0'2fi)0'h!'b.cnfl]Cd
wirh rll. Bo.!d by rlrc Codc Enforumcnl Officiel, wltiCh Affrdavil Certincd undor odh lhll thc
rcquircd concctivc *tion had not bccn tatcn by the Respondents' ss ofdcld'
Accordingly, it having bccn broqhr lo the Board's atrcntion that Respondcnb havc nol
cocrpliod with thc Ner cntcrcd on Augusl I ' 2m0' it is hcrcby
nEt
Paitiorcrs,
I
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 576 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
I
STATEOFTLoNDA )
SS;
COTJNTY OF COLLIER)
Ilrc foregoing insttunent
Corraty, Florid&
Flod& Ddvcr' Liccarc rs idcotification.
#Hffi
i
I
oRDERED, ttl8t thc Rcspondent pey to Colli* County a line in thc emounl ofotE
thousrnd orcc hrurdrcd doll8rs (tl,30o) foI thc Friod of Autust 2t, 2000 through Scpcmber
22,2000 ar e nrc of$50 per day plus $555.37 for thc operEtionsl costs incund in thc
prbsccution of this crse.
This ordcr may bc rccorded and shall, pursuant to section 162.09. Flori& Suutcs,
Cgnflitutc 0 lign !6dns any real or pcrsonal propcrty owrrcd by Rcspondent'
D,NE AND 9RDERED THrs \(J ouy or_CB)_:_-,2ooo, in colli*
County, Florida.
EMENT BOARD
, FLOzuDA
Drirrc
-Soayorcode Enforcement Board of Collicr
posorully knoun to nrc or
--
r+'ho tus Ptodwtd a
F
oa
l\,.-J5e
.c,
G:
o
ta
,€)
NOTARY PUBLIC
My comrnission cxpires:-
)
tot
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 577 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
4 >a-
M ean ' Esq
Flori& Bar No. 75031I
400 Finh Avcnue S., Stc. 300
Nrplesr Florids 14lo2
(941 ) 263-8206
e)
*
3\'
-I.-o
.!E'6
o(Jr1r!h,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
t HEREBY CERTTFY thst a lru€ and corcct copy of this Order lmposing FincJlien has
bccn fumilhcd by U.S. Mrrl to Rcspondcnts rt t0320 Moin Streel, Thonotlsassa, Flori& 33952
Flori& 34103 rhis \v dry of 6Y\) , . 2000.
I
(.
C
I
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 578 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
vcd .vidcncc,
of 6od is thc
aDt to ilt utt
rlndfict
trr rtlt
ln rd
EODE ENTOR.EEMENT BOARD
COLLTER COIJNTY, FLORIDA
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS'
COLLTER COUNTY. FLORIDA'
Pclrtioncr,cEB NO. 2000-Ot O
PENTECOSTAL CHTJRC}| OF GOD,
Respondart
FINDINGS OF FACT. CONCLUSIONS
Tt{lS CAUSE camc on for on March 23,20(n and lhe
Boerd hrving hcard tcstitnony 8tgummts ?rsp€clive to
.ll rpptoPrialc matrcts, I
lhg Dorrd' .' follows;
of Law. and Na of
l, Th.t thc ofthc cubjcct prupcrty.
2. Thfl lhr Codc En of lhc pcnon of the
Rcrpondent and rhar rhe Rcspondent, having bccn duly notilicd, appcarcd al lhe publiC haning
by Rw. Wcndell C. Rimea.
3. Thsl Respondcnt wss notitid ofthc violation by ccnilicd mail, rcccivcd on
Novccrbcr 26, 1999.
4. Thar thc rcel propary locttcd al IO2 N. 7d Su?el' Immokalcc, Floridq morc
paniculerly dc*ribcd as FOLIO NO.0000060182920006, Millcrs ParI Blk. 5. Lots l9'22' Lcss
S. 20 Fr, for 8l/w is in violation of Scction 2.?.6, prregraph I & 5 of frinrnce No. 9l-102, as
tot,TtN ul(: I00u ni: JUJ,[!m b tl.ott8 nf !0t rt llttm c;rt, ,l
al/atrlaaa rt ltlllrr |ftatl t. lE, ttttt
xr ll!iltu It.llt.ll
vs
I
oD
;
-a.-e
Eo
-(Jl
a,
naa6hl
*Iit
l-o,
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 579 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
utt; 400u ru; JUJ0
amcndcd, rhc Collier Counry Land Dcvclopmant Codc, in thc following particulsrs:
lnrcrior .hcrationj to includc traming, insulation, plumbint, glgctric, drlrwoll ond
mcchadcal without ,irsr oblaining a Collicr Counly building permit.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
l. Thal Oc Pcntecoslal Church ofcod is in violation ofsections 2.7.6., paragragh I
& 5 of Ordinancc No. 91.102. as amended, fi? Collicr Counly Land Dcvclopment Cod..
ORDER OF TIIE BOARD
Bascd upon lhc forcgoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuanr ro thc
authority granled in Chaptcr 162, Florida S Collier Co unty frinancc No. 92-80, il is
hcreby ORDERED:
l. Thar thc ons 2.7.6., paragraph I &
5 of Ordinancc No. 9l - 102, as cnt Code, by
obleining a SDP or SIP or by and twcnty ( 120) days
(July 21,2@0).
?. That iflhc vi thin 130 days (July 21,
2000), a linc oft50 pcr day will bc Yiolarior contilucs pa$ $id date.
DONE AND ORDERED rhis }Lgtrry of March, Z0q), al Colicr Counry, Florirta,
CODEEMORCEMENTBOARD
COLLIER, EOUNTY, FLORIDA
BY:
oifr
2800
FI
Drivc
Ntplcq ftodd. S.llO{
\
o
=a\,
o
a!,
G>
-arraJr.E
\
.c
thc vio o
cofiscld oraBtaltom
an(
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 580 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
STATEOFFLORIDA )
)SS:
COTINTY OF COLLIER)
The forcgoing
Cliff Flcgd, Chairmrn of the Code En
-
p€rsonrlly known to mc or
idcnti6cation.
ffiffi
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a
Msil
FL3
Chirrch of
N+16,
imtrum?nt w.s rcknowkdgcd ucforc me ttris!!$ry of Mmh, 2000 by
fortcmentl/ who has prcduced
Board ofCollicr Counly, Flodd& who ts
a Florida Drivcr's Licence as
NOTARY PIJB Ltc
Mv com,rnission cxpircs:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
ORDER hrs bccn s.nt by U. S.
Main Strcet, Thonotrsassa.
il
Enforccmant Board
s.. sre. 300
3rl I 02
\
o-,
FJr{
e
alE6r
:rrr
aJr
\
I
a2(x
\_----*J\-
ln
\-
C
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 581 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
by Cliffncer|. Chrinnrn ofth
-
pcrtondly knowa tog i&nti6crtion.
I HEREBY CERTIFY
Meil to Rcv. Wsr&ll C. Rimes.
Flori&33JD rhis O dry ofAugrt, 2000.
1)
M.J
r*r gx. 2706 tG; 20?? $r
County. Flodde. wto is
a Flod& Driran' Licens.
ORDER hrs becn scnt by U.S.
2'e-/
No.7t03ll
dDONE AI.ID ORDERED THIS dry of August, 2000, at Colliet County, Flori&.
CODE ENTORCEMENT BOARD
COLUER COI'NTY, TLORIDA
BY:fur,lz-^/
Clfrrllsd,,Chdtrtu
2300 No# Honishoc Drirrc
Naplcs, Floridr 3410{
STATEOTTLORJDA )
SS:
COI.JNTY OF COLLIER)
'ClIhc fongoing inrtrumcnt urrs aeknowlcdfd bcfon mc this , &y of Augn. 2ffi
of C6llicr
tl00 Fifth Awnuc S-, Stt. 300
Nrglc* Floridr 34102
(rl) 20r-0206
3t.u.,:tlorldl,Crrtr ot Cctltl
I frr
ecrntttrE dt Iuilss
0.tr
,GIY
IILT!'rm]
TINCATE
,
E
C
!traf
c)v
F'
-J.-o
.te
G)tt
CI
tr]*
\I
I
10320 Mein Strect. llromrrqssr,
E
I"'
I.
lil I ulr
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 582 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
267e066 0R: 2?06 PGI 2876
USIDI! ll OllCru UCiD! 0l Ollm iln, I
coDE E*o^cE*nroilEtllf tt r2:0lrt lnnt
'' ifl,i,*u ,,,
cotuER couNTY. FLORTDA lll:'o l:l!
D0A8D 0F couNTy coMMISs'^'--^ r.t!:
coL,ER co.JNTy, FI.RIDA.
llul\E'tl) cmr l0 rir !0110
mn0m0 tl! ll001
peritioncrs. m lilo
vs.cAsE NO. CEB:000-010
PENTECOSTAL CHI.JRCH OT GOD,
Rcspondcnts.
ORDER ENLARGING TItr,{E FOR IMPOSITION OF FINE,I IEN
Ii{lS CAUSE csm! on Boad on lftrch 13. 2000. aflo du
nolict to Rcspondcnt!, st under orth, rcccivcd cvidenct,
rnd iswd its Findinp issued its onl Order
which rras rcduccd to Rcspondcnts
Srid 0drr action lo corcct thc violadon
rs mor spccificrlly sct forrh ordocd thrt tlrc costs for
cOrtcting tlrc violrtrons on thc pmpcf cots incuned in thc prosecution of
this crs. h a licn on rlrc subjccr propcrry,
No A!fidrvir of Non4ompliencc has ycr bccn filed with rhc Board by rhc Codc
Enforccmem Otficid.
Accodingly, it having bcco brou8hr ro rhc Borrd's arlcnrion rhar Rcspoodcnrs hlve
rcqrrsrcd an exrcnsion ofrhc time for imposing tincvlicn, it ls her€by
ORDERED, that no imposition of lina wrll bc entercd aglin'l rhe Rcspon&nr prior ro
Augut 27.2000
thc Boud hcild
to tdrc
I
olxrt
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 583 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)
til 0R' 2706 PG: 2877 m
DONE AND ORDEITED THIS t:I
- day ol'August, l(,}t)(), at Collicr Counrr'. Hurrda
CODI: INFORCT MENT t]()ARI)
COII IHR COI]NI'Y. FI.ORIDA
BY tcz%zJ
Clrtl t'lctsalrchatFfon
lEoo Nonf llorsishu l)nrc
Naplu. lilorrda -i,l l0.l
STATEOTFLORIDA )
couNt'Y o[ c0t.l.rER)
SS
'l he lbregorng rnstrument was acknowledged belbre nre rhis /'Ly ot luer.r. l0ri0
by ClilT Flesal. Charrman of the (-'o<le E Board ol'Collier County. Florida. r,,h.r is
penonallv known to me a Flonda Drivers' I icensr.
as id€ntilication
I HEREBY CFjRTIFY rhai is ORDtiR hns bcen senr br U S
Mail to Rev. Wendell C. Rimes.10310 Main Strecr 'l'honotasassa.
Florida.13592 lhis _i,-_ 6y of August, 2000
)
, :-) -.*<,t .C-z -.LL<t *.?:J
M JcEnBowson, Esq.
Floridlfar No 7501I I
400 Fiflh Avenue S. Ste .100
Naples. Flori& 3.1102
(94 t ) 263-8206
ffi u{ 0l8Dt
ExPriali
)
TIFICATE Of
16.A.10.b
Packet Pg. 584 Attachment: Lien Orders (7745 : Pentecostal Church of God, Release of Lien)