Loading...
Backup Docs 11/09/2010 (CR)MCI Complaint letter Page 1 of 1 From: rescue024 @aol.com 9 A To: Rickey_Stone @doh.state.tl.us Subject: MCI Complaint letter Date: Fri, Oct 29, 2010 3:29 pm Attachments: state_letter.docx (69K), New_Drug_Calculation_Exam 4.doc (49K), revised_rug_calculation exam # 6.doc (49K) — — — — Ricky, As per our conversation on Monday in regards to an alleged complaint between Collier County EMS and a North Naples firefighter, I have written an explanation about the entire event and attached the two exams as proof. I apologize for not sending this Monday but I had a family member ill and could not respond sooner. Thank You, Richard Gonzalez, President/CEO Medical Career Institute # 145 ENTER ►4T httn: / /mail.aol.com/32843- 111/ aol- 1 /en- us /mail/PrintMessaee.asnx 7 t /R /I)n1 n Medical A&MAEU& Career Ilistltute, LLE Training Tomorrow's Professional (239)992 -1624 To: Ricky Stone October 26th, 2010 This is per our conversation on Tuesday October 26,2010. • 1 On October 18, 2010 I reviewed a drug calculation guide containing 40 questions that I had created for the class to review 3 days before the actual exam. I also produced a drug calculation exam that contained 40 questions from which I picked from the Mosby test bank and a few of my own. The guide was labeled guide 1 and the actual module exam was labeled exam 6. In the mayhem of my day I grabbed the actual drug calculation study guide on the 21" instead of the Module 6 exam and gave it to them as the calculation exam. The problem is that a student took photos of the study guide since our copier was jammed and not working to send to all the students in class as a study guide. Of which two students left class early unbenounced to me. These two particular students were unable to give their email addresses to be sent a copy of the said study guide like the rest of the class. Chief Page clearly stated to me that one of the two individuals that were not on the initial bulk email that left early initiated this complaint to his chief stating " why do the other firemen get better grades than me, when I study so hard "? Since this packet was for a guide purpose only, there was no malicious intent behind this action. However, on the date of the exam I grabbed the wrong 40 question exam and gave it to them. Someone in the class forwarded an email to Collier County EMS Chief Page whom in turn called me immediately to express his personal views /concerns about what had transpired. I drove to the Collier County Government Center and met with the chief. He showed me an email sent from a student which had pictures of a drug calculation study guide. Again, the packet that he showed me was in fact the review guide that I had prepared for the students to go over with in class. When I returned to the school around 5:00 P.M. I went to their student file's to see what exam I had given them. October 27th, 2010 around 8:40 am, I returned Chief Page's phone call of which he had left a message for me the night before., As per our conversation he stated to me that he had additional information regarding the individual whom initially took the pictures of the study guide. Chief 9A Page stated that Eloy's brother Omar works with me at Miami Dade Fire Rescue and insinuated since Omar and I have a working relationship, that Omar might of received this study guide from me. He also stated the study guide that was emailed to the class was the actual exam, he assured and reiterated the student indeed confirmed that the study guide emailed was the actual exam given. I appreciate the quick response from Collier County and praise them for bringing this to my attention but unfortunately, no one is to blame but myself for giving the wrong exam. I know this is going to turn into a huge complaint between Collier County and some of the firefighters.I assure you that this problem has been corrected. Chief Page was concerned about the thought of having paramedics cheating on exams and then performing life safety procedures on citizens. I can assure you that every student in my class has been taught with the highest standards and are highly proficient in their skills. On October 27`h, 2010 the paramedic class received the new Drug calculation exam 6 accordingly. All the scores from the last drug calculation study guide were removed from the system and replaced with their new scores. Be advised, the same individuals whom failed the previous study guide, again failed this exam as well. Undeniably I am very taken back and its discerning the manner in which Chief Page alleges his assumption that Omar could have possibly have been involved in this ordeal. Let alone, disparage my integrity not only as an Educator but as a human being. Due to the animosity that has been brewing between North Naples Fire District and Collier County EMS, It's no surprise my class consists of 70% of North Naples Firefighters. Chief Page insisted he had an obligation to inform Dr. Tober, Collier County's Medical Director and the state about this incident. I am perplexed as to what's the correlation between the medical director of Collier County EMS and this alleged isolated incident. I would hate to think that this is merely an avenue for Collier County EMS to further continue to harm North Naples reputation in order to hinder their endeavors to approve COPCN for ALS non - transport and by the same manner demean my business. In conclusion, I hope that I have not caused so many headaches due to my hastiness. Needless to say, my inclination to contact the Bureau of EMS was of the essence. I have attached the study guide and the drug calculation exam that was given. Should you have any further questions or concerns, feel free to contact me. Respectfully, Richard Gonzalez, President/CEO Medical Career Institute License #145 9200 Bonita Beach Rd Suite #c 203 Bonita Springs, F134135 Fwd: Ride Time From: rescue024 @aol.com To: jeffpage @colliergov.net; DL- EMS @colliergov.net; RodRodriguez @colliergov.net; AlanMcLaughlin @colliergov.net; SMclnerny @comeast.net; OStolts @northnaplesfre.com; OStolts @northnaplesfire.com, jaguilera @northnaplesfire.com Subject: Fwd: Ride Time Date: Mon, Nov 1, 2010 4:09 pm Attachments: Dear—Chief Page.doc(82K) November 1St, 2010 RE: Student riders Dear Chief Page, Page 1 of 3 9 A I opened up the email you sent to me on Saturday October 30th, 2010 11:32 A.M. and several others this morning. As per your email stating that effectively no more Medical Career Institute students will be able to ride on Collier County EMS units, I find it imperative that I remind you only two students were ever allowed to ride on your EMS vehicles of which one of them works under Collier County. Unfortunately, I have made several attempts over the past 2 'h years to come to a mutual agreement with Collier County EMS and MCI in order to allow students whom are Collier County residents the ability to ride on the EMS trucks that service their community proudly. This would enhance the skills and knowledge of the students that choose to ride on your units. When we spoke last month I requested permission from you to allow my paramedic students the ability to ride on your EMS units and you stated "that at this time no and that NO North Naples Firefighter will ever set foot on your EMS trucks ". Our conversation ended by you saying you would allow students to ride on a one by one occasion. Needless to say, I agreed on your decision! Two weeks later you allowed two of my students to ride on your units. One was a firefighter for Ochopee Fire, who drives your ALS rescue unit on shift and works under Collier County. The second student was a Naples Firefighter, who received permission from your agency to ride as a paramedic student. I hope that the email you sent me on Saturday morning concerning the two student riders is not a reflection of our conversation Tuesday afternoon at the Collier County Government Center pertaining to your false allegations towards my paramedic students. I honestly hope that personal issues between the two agencies (Collier County EMS and North Naples Fire) are not getting in the way of the only reason we are here, which is education! Education is the main concern and it should be our only concern regardless of where students are employed. Your remark to me in regards of hiring a student that is cheating is quite disquieting. That to me was you insinuating they cheated and that I had a part in it. Another remark you made pertained to your trepidation of the community. It's not only with admiration but with great gratefulness I can say that my paramedic students are learning more then what they should be taught at a basic level. These students are given over 100 medications to master throughout the course and are taught above and beyond the National Curriculum. So YES, I can pompously assure you that all current students in Medical Career Institute are able to demonstrate not only basic but advanced EMT and paramedic skills. The only question that should be of any concern to you, is how advantageous these students will evolve and httn: / /maii.aol.com/ 32843 - 111/ aol- 1 /en- us /maii/PrintMessaee.asnx 1 1 /R /7n 1 n Fwd: Ride Time perform patient care in the real world of Fire /EMS. Page 2 of 3 I'm openly extending an invitation to you, your medical director, and all Fire/EMS chiefs to come in and visit our institute and look at the quality of training we offer if that is your true main concern. Once again I have an open door policy and eagerly await your arrival. Now I see why we cannot and will not see eye to eye on this issue. It's evident our focus and concerns are different. My focus and main concern is the education of the students. However, it saddens me to think you will not accept my invitation. Be doing so, my school and my students will speak for themselves. It's initial impression will nullify every negative thought pertaining to my establishment and those who partake in it. Hopefully that will not refrain you from coming. Respectfully, Richard Gonzalez, EMT -P President/CEO Medical Career Institute 9200 Bonita Beach Rd, Suite 203 Bonita Springs, F] 34135 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: page) <JeffPaae(a)collieroov. net> To: rescue024aaol.com <rescue024652aol.com> Cc: DL -EMS <DL- EMS(a)colliergov net >; rodriguez_r <RodRodryuez(a-colliergov net >; McLaughlinAlan <AlanMcLaughlinCakolliergov net> SMclnemv(acomcast net < >; Orly Stolts (OStolts( northnaolesfire com) <OStoltsanorthnaolesfire.com> Sent: Sat, Oct 30, 2010 11:42 am Subject: RE: Ride Time Mr. Gonzalez, Effective immediately, all Medical Career Institute students will no longer be allowed ride time on Collier County EMS units. Jeff Page, Chief Collier County EMS From: rescue024 @aol.com (re3cue024 @aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 23, 2010 3:29 PM To: page_j; surfin2311 @hotmail. con Subject: Re: Ride Time Chief Page, Thank you for the letter and if you could please mail the original to: 9200 Bonita Beach Road, Suite 203 Bonita Springs, F1 34135 Thank You, RIchard Gonzalez President /CEO Medical Career Institute httn: / /mail.aol.com/32843- 111/ aol- 1 /en- us /mail/PrintMe.ssane_agnx i i iaicnin Fwd: Ride Time Page 3 of 3 9A - - - -- Original Message---- - From: page_j <JeffPace@collieraou.ret> To: 'rescue024 @aol.com' <reacue024 @aol.com> Sent: Wed, Sep 22, 2010 10:40 am Subject: Ride Time _ Richard, Let me know where you would like the original mailed! Be safe! Jeff Under. Florida Law, e -mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e -mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. htti): / /mail.aol.com/ 32843 - 1 1 1/ aol- 1 /en- us /mail/PrintMessaee.asnx 11 /9/2(11 n 9A , County Bureau of Emergency September 23, 2010 Richard Gonzalez President/CEO Medical Career Institute Dear Mr. Gonzalez, Please let this letter serve as my agreeing to allow Firefighter Austin Bleweiss and Firefighter Justin Raymond obtain their skill training and field experience as a Paramedic student while on a Collier County EMS transport unit. Both students will be required to sign an EMS Department Passenger /Observer Request and Release form and a Hold Harmless an6 Indemnification form, to-be notarized in my office, prior to their initial ride time taking place. Please have both individuals contact my office to set up a time where we can take care of their paperwork and arrange for their ride schedules. Respectfully, Jeff Page, Chief Collier County EMS �Ci q yMCJiraiS v 8075 Lely Cultural Parkway, Suite 267 • Naples, Florida 34113.239- 252 -3740 • Fax 239 - 252 -3298 • www.colliergov.net/ems ( } \ ƒ 4 � \ i \ � / o 3m = \\ # k Q(� o � 22 t \�[ 2 , \ \ \G ®ORE/ ƒ)�_ ` /\ \\ \ / }/# : W0 Ul / \ \ RESORTED rc@ # :.. c. . Hasler Cl) o ){�� e\ \ I e ! r H Q J Q J V Z li IL LU V/ W IL u L co CL Q 0 Y M L A CL L �1 a �L 7 O1 � v CL C Ch w O N O M v W w O D a uj H D zz W W f W �J f W 0 z W a W S a z d r O d a m C L CL 9 � Z �O m U- v 00 J C)� ¢Ow in ~Q W — Q Ln W UJ z 0 DV)N aLU° Q O LU N Q � O O Q N LU w n Lw Q�� N J Z o g oz° w 0 U m m z-w z Q O U in rZa� 00 V O 0 w m O w Q>O Q Q MZ-j Ln U M m W oOO Z Q uzLU Q O LD H H < 0 �W(n Z W W :D0z OWO UmLo �. LU O Ln v a a 2 U W 2 F J z O W W D a O LU a D z a H z cW L f O U m O ce O LL W W z M M_ W LU w 2 H O 0 W H J W a 7 0 0 ce W 2 z m W 00 W rn m y W x H 0 d O ce CL E O a O m W H z w a w D W 2 U- 0 ui J W J !L F. W z O FE oi U. G ui ui W J a E v W 5 CL MW 1� H W Q a J V Z uj ..aww V/ W a `/ 00 a O FA t Y L O 0 a a 3 N a 01 e Cl d f d U W a C7 z LU W W �a u r x uj D z W a V) N W D D a W f a z i 9A a� Lol d C Y d a m c c H L CL 9 a U-)z �O U M LL 00 J QOw w f F' Q W CL z W 0 D�� O' L ° LUQO LU N Q Z O Q N w ! n w a� Ln J H C 0 °Z� WHO U m m (� z H �D¢ OUP >Z� Co .O V)m www o = w >� EEOO Q Q � m H J In � U M m W ON 0f- 2 Z Q UZW QOVOi LU � H H O } W (( j z�w �Oz OUWO . �mLo LU H O=U U Ln a a 2 U W 2 H J z O ui ui ce a 0 ce a In z a H z W i O U m O O L6 U) W H z N W W 2 F O G W LLJM f N w a 0 H m w a ce W `V r H a uj Vl W a %m/ ca l 00 /J- CL �n O t (A O 3 (i is a �J CL m C v N L v v uj 0 Z H W W W H F- f W M D z W a W S a z 4- u m h W O D Q C O tl d a m C C C y v M O s o a O ww LL O d LU ° 0 QED a Z:) a Lr) J H O ~ Ln vow a _ !J 't oo a ¢ D Q Q% o z S (n O y ? °F-¢ Fes- m N� 0 Z m f w 0 Z W Z &W w �P- a N z'L= Z H 1— ` LJ V% H H r O �0Q U `-' W ��Q V w O J o O Q C O p =O w >-� O 0 C mH¢ > D o(nm 2 �, Q 0Lnm 0 2 www O F. oww LL O F- LU >� O J�/ w >F- W O W �.. w Q O0 j t LU w W W Z J J LO >- ,. m J Ln U M CO omw V om= LU 2 W N p� LW LL oOF W w z � 2 Z ZQ� F- Z z a ~ Z w z z w ~ u' w O E a (i F- o cC o— a) azN o Z z �� W c z H H W O 0 (Hj (D F- LL ` W O p U` (D N LL LLJ 0 0� E D " F.. •y 0 (J w E O �"'(n J W W ~ /�^� a pII--w�' _j w Lu LL] cl� j O z Q d Q W y C � 0 Z Q CL ►r a U O O w p O O O LU >. U) L. LY O< � w u Q y J¢ 0 QU 0cnU 2 � Q z a pi2p g 09A y o o w p U-) p m m m H W 2 U m O m w Z Z m O w w H H J O J 2 W w J U U O O Q Qmw W W W W �' _ amp F F m � Qr m __� m m NI=¢ > >. O Q m F F F-na, J J c cn C2 Z Z W y C � � 'z" � O O = = ��� o of ~ o y.� C of D Dip ( O CY W ( (n O L L d d w p w (WJf O F- NvQW a a 0 o oL 1 10 a C C a a a a' o o��z 0 0 a a odo a ° H H i i C C)0Q F F- E E H 'a a Ch J LU a V Z. H a LU Y/ W m Nft/ d 0+ 'o 3 00 C. 0 t Y O R a cn a ap1i CL. p cm C d f d i v V W Q 0 U) Z 0 W i Z W d 4J d c O d a a c Y C H V CL 9 i �z H0 U m(i m0 O ¢0w CO Qw� a W Z W D Lf) au° 0 U LU N ¢ ° z °o ff ¢ N w N Q� w � C) C) Z w�0 U m m C7 LU z�l- ° °a OUO°C mho ° N m www in _ H Q ¢¢� ( j H J } (n U Mmw C, 0 2 Z Q v.� a (D F- LU Z t5 l7 H ,^ 0 (D w (i Z w W D O Z °w° � m w H J � 020 U(nU 2 U W m F J Z O LU LU D D a O LU a D Z a z W O v 0 C: LL O N LU F z w E M W W S O 0 LU LU N w C a 7 0 tt W H w a J ce Q J V Z H m LU W J a 1 a V 3 ao CL O m Y 3 10 � C 3 a rrg CL H 0 � t O 0+ d f d i LU U W .i LU O 0 Q c-D LU 3 a" fi c 0 6 a Im GW c F C U' Fr C Z W Z W N W C f a z 9A ai z a � 2 W (n 0 m m O C w w OJcrF� = m Q rj 0W U m W W < LU H m H H ¢ Y ul wZw W Z U) a � ~ LU 0 0 O N ¢ m O CD0° o a ON ° ¢ O °� F C: O Q2:° Q C: o JH Z ce moo a a C) Z O u� U 0 Z W m m W = Q(D= f Z O p ° H U 0 U ° w }ZQ 0 G CO .i O W °ww LL. LL z >� of O Z60 t (A Z J M Z w J U M m M m w .. °001- W W N J = C : _ zap H Z LLJ z�w i ¢Z o Z N H W oOw N O 0 LD i c O Z i s J H w LU w W J 2 oO Z Q CL U C0 O U H UJ LLJ a 0=0 a CT J_ o. N E W O~ l Q Q W V Id. a LU W a. d m 9 3 m CL O s Y 0 O W a c� Z W W f W J 0 Z W C7 a a C e d W i z w Z �0 U m U- m 0 J p J ¢ ~ ¢Ow m Qw WSW Z p cr Dcnp aU� uj 00 N ¢ O O ¢ N LU Ln LU Q Z) U-) z O � � O O CD w�0 u m m C7 ZZf OUp m �0 p v)m LU w w p = Q 0 ¢ ¢ cr ui U j Z J 1n�U �j m w No O I=- 2 Z v�� ¢Ou~i Z Z H p U w ¢ K l7 0 Z -: i w (n Z � W 00z oWo mLn w J ¢ O = O 0 o.' O LL W W Z M W W C: 2 F- O 0 W H J W a Q O Y 0 W 2 V Z M W m U W m W W H O 0 C: a i O O a C: Q m W H Z H a 0 W 2 F LL O t ui J W J m H W 2 F 2 O E a O LL 0 W W a f O U W 5 CL a� 01 3 O1 s 7 m CL O v L Y d z \� 3 C R + C a z a W 7 IM U ` � W m LU i Q r o � Q Q � d L i -J W a c� Z W W f W J 0 Z W C7 a a C e d W i z w Z �0 U m U- m 0 J p J ¢ ~ ¢Ow m Qw WSW Z p cr Dcnp aU� uj 00 N ¢ O O ¢ N LU Ln LU Q Z) U-) z O � � O O CD w�0 u m m C7 ZZf OUp m �0 p v)m LU w w p = Q 0 ¢ ¢ cr ui U j Z J 1n�U �j m w No O I=- 2 Z v�� ¢Ou~i Z Z H p U w ¢ K l7 0 Z -: i w (n Z � W 00z oWo mLn w J ¢ O = O 0 o.' O LL W W Z M W W C: 2 F- O 0 W H J W a Q O Y 0 W 2 V Z M W m U W m W W H O 0 C: a i O O a C: Q m W H Z H a 0 W 2 F LL O t ui J W J m H W 2 F 2 O E a O LL 0 W W a f O U W 5 CL Q J V Z H a LU V/ W 0. `OO .J J l � � O J v W W k% D D Q a� 01 s 7 m CL O L Y J P 3 W Q R + C a z a W 7 IM � W m a i Q r 01 C d Q � d L Q J V Z H a LU V/ W 0. `OO .J J l � � O J v W W k% D D Q a nZ H 0 rU in LL m00 J � ¢Ow m Qw Wz W p D N p aU� Lu Q� LU N ¢ K z C)o ¢ N LU U') LU QED Ln J H v00 C:) Z p WHO U m m Z -w Z z °¢ O U p 001 0 pcnm LU w w 2 LU 7 Q ¢ M Z J in } U Mmw O 0 f 2 O Q U Z d a�� Z Z H < l7 LU o K LU zCZw DoZ ow0 LU CO V) LLJ H J J 0Ln0 M W W C: 2 H O 0 W M f H W a a 0 i 0 a W Z H W m V W m W W H 0 C: O a E O C: O m W 2 F Z H a w D W 2 H LL O W J W J m H W 2 H Z O f 0 a W W a f O U W CL W C O J P W Q W + C a \ Im z a c � W W dLU a i Q z a nZ H 0 rU in LL m00 J � ¢Ow m Qw Wz W p D N p aU� Lu Q� LU N ¢ K z C)o ¢ N LU U') LU QED Ln J H v00 C:) Z p WHO U m m Z -w Z z °¢ O U p 001 0 pcnm LU w w 2 LU 7 Q ¢ M Z J in } U Mmw O 0 f 2 O Q U Z d a�� Z Z H < l7 LU o K LU zCZw DoZ ow0 LU CO V) LLJ H J J 0Ln0 M W W C: 2 H O 0 W M f H W a a 0 i 0 a W Z H W m V W m W W H 0 C: O a E O C: O m W 2 F Z H a w D W 2 H LL O W J W J m H W 2 H Z O f 0 a W W a f O U W CL Cr 4W H cn Q J a J i uZ m CL 0 s Y Q Q R Q) a m m 3 d a Q IraH C d U INZ j G ,,Www V/ LU Q o A �a v J Z Ol W 3 " x a z m v CL 0 s Y Q Q R Q) a m m 3 d a Q IraH C d U INZ 13 i d 41 O L y d a m e c a d � G N G W t�o ca 17)o = U O N Op "" W 0 J a H Jin = m aow 00 � W ao o `C w , i 00 = W Q W H Q W H H m W z W Z U W Z W Z V1 W p S 7cno V)" V1 �U) C) ( ~ ce uj C2 U) p W p Vf O ly X00 w Lm X00 oWe ~ v _ c� 0 LLJ v Q p Q W D w y f o¢ O t = oQ O C) o¢ N LU W W w W O W i Q a T O ¢ a o f Z Cl Ln Z ce o~p0 a w =w'' yyy r0 a a °F._.Q f�" W 41 °�Q H m U m m W U m m W = Z' W d„ Z Ur z�H 0 i `t zHF= Z f Q U .Vi W pDQ U Vf OUp w 0Up 0 o '—` 0 W0 a 0 N 0 IX _ 0�rWC+W 0 / �rrW W 0 W W j� LU y w j l- W O F Q�O- m ii% Q �- W aQ� Z Q < Z py M Mz_� �_ W Mz_� S LU r U M J r V M a Vi m= v , p m 2 V H O0E- W w 001- W W � _ zz� F uZ _4 zzr z LU u H w O ^ i , , U H W O 2-1 Q N � Q% Q a o W o C, << �Ey J C2 < C C LLI w LO J W ' O a }0 W V) j I- W V� W z W W 7 Z Q Q W ` c 7 0 Z Q a 0 Q 0 l- o f gWo W m gW° D O W m ° Ii mi r Z W W m ° U �¢� W W i a �¢� °(=il° `� i Q z °v=i° d I G ,,Www V/ LU Q o A W H a J Z IL W " x a z 13 i d 41 O L y d a m e c a d � G N G W t�o ca 17)o = U O N Op "" W 0 J a H Jin = m aow 00 � W ao o `C w , i 00 = W Q W H Q W H H m W z W Z U W Z W Z V1 W p S 7cno V)" V1 �U) C) ( ~ ce uj C2 U) p W p Vf O ly X00 w Lm X00 oWe ~ v _ c� 0 LLJ v Q p Q W D w y f o¢ O t = oQ O C) o¢ N LU W W w W O W i Q a T O ¢ a o f Z Cl Ln Z ce o~p0 a w =w'' yyy r0 a a °F._.Q f�" W 41 °�Q H m U m m W U m m W = Z' W d„ Z Ur z�H 0 i `t zHF= Z f Q U .Vi W pDQ U Vf OUp w 0Up 0 o '—` 0 W0 a 0 N 0 IX _ 0�rWC+W 0 / �rrW W 0 W W j� LU y w j l- W O F Q�O- m ii% Q �- W aQ� Z Q < Z py M Mz_� �_ W Mz_� S LU r U M J r V M a Vi m= v , p m 2 V H O0E- W w 001- W W � _ zz� F uZ _4 zzr z LU u H w O ^ i , , U H W O 2-1 Q N � Q% Q a o W o C, << �Ey J C2 < C C LLI w LO J W ' O a }0 W V) j I- W V� W z W W 7 Z Q Q W ` c 7 0 Z Q a 0 Q 0 l- o f gWo W m gW° D O W m ° Ii mi r Z W W m ° U �¢� W W i a �¢� °(=il° `� i Q z °v=i° d I V 3 1 m m 19 m a N V6 W H W a J a W V H a W V) J a `/ m 7 O1 O. 01 C G1 d d i U w a D c� Z W W oa W J F f W D z W a w LU O f a W f a z L d 0 d 0 v a m c r c H `1 CL w LO z Ln O U m W mO 0 J Q Z Q m W QW ~a Wzw .LnU) :D V p CY you ui N Q ui C) O Q p Uj W ZQ :D Ln J ry oz� W O u m m C7 Z z F- Z Q O U n m Q W m w 0 W x W >F- Q�o (n Q Y Q 0 w j Z J nru M m W 00H x zz� Q W u LU LU Q U m zz ;3 (D dQ d' wLn Z � W ooz owo �mLn LU H J 0=00 uV) u z H f M W w 2 H O D w .. J W ce a n O Y 0 1 i 3 a" CL m 19 m a N V6 W H W a J a W V H a W V) J a `/ m 7 O1 O. 01 C G1 d d i U w a D c� Z W W oa W J F f W D z W a w LU O f a W f a z L d 0 d 0 v a m c r c H `1 CL w LO z Ln O U m W mO 0 J Q Z Q m W QW ~a Wzw .LnU) :D V p CY you ui N Q ui C) O Q p Uj W ZQ :D Ln J ry oz� W O u m m C7 Z z F- Z Q O U n m Q W m w 0 W x W >F- Q�o (n Q Y Q 0 w j Z J nru M m W 00H x zz� Q W u LU LU Q U m zz ;3 (D dQ d' wLn Z � W ooz owo �mLn LU H J 0=00 uV) u z H f M W w 2 H O D w .. J W ce a n O _. lbrred inV-the- (i.,0o(frePor-te-{ HENDRY COUNTY H s , — -- ' COLLIERVOHNV 1/ L..-) --- 1 , 'I .- —I I a \ E... ....,_j,:„ rol. n P., _ — — 1— i..D. ,..„. ,I. , .. -,,..— -- ' *014614,! \-----,.1 dr/ „:-.---..,;74,ito-A, ---_____A ..... . .-= 4.4-- ff.; 5A . -.,,,..',...--, bziA i c.. Field i,,,I,1' .' -'. . i I. H!,„,..!,,,,, ,, tr, / ORALEE . . wish-,I USA) . SSA 14■,.. ;40 .490,.' moimouv „ i..,t4, 4,*7 ot SP' , 1\ , 40 to.” 1111,0* 1, ' is•V ,--;_ \, [Op .,,, ..- .? 4- SSA' /J, , I 'dr'. *". 4. , .a.■ AEA, ,4.W . Z".- -...-"- I ., .'‘• -( - -- ,,,-„,-, . lit$011).e'• X,11 ,. '''' I ld IMMOKALEE 77 E---, 1 _.,-.-'i ■ ',.,-, ----i., - e N,e . 's 444111,004.WI ''''t40•40,i• 4' .4' S A ',..-‘ '4 A Ae ,, c111001002 ;') 2 i--- g ' "j ji*Aci•1r*..'i -1 m //e. 1 a ,,itory ■,..A".* .. I ii@&..ilg — At ). W•4,I: 9', i'm--r'1-- sspl-,' p P:, ",, **4 '.• OIL WELL RD '1111.1.---- —..1 „,,,-."--.." / ., lj--I 1 M-A% - '"s' .L17' —__ La GOLDE V G ITE BLVD - , 61 LEGEND ESRA 44.4 4,40*kW .400 griVW "*--rii4'47.4,-*0. i SSA -, 0 D,.., 7,,, _ ) Rural Land Stewardship Area Boundary a -- 1 a 1: 1 u Area of Critical State Concern 0,0 'aa I ' a I 1 . . a] 1 Il a —.c---,--, 0 _ ia, '' 0 ' Existing Public Lands 0 'ari a a WilsOnMiller i it, , - _..E _ 500-Foot Restoration Zone New Drect VIIS in Pranring Design$Ervneenng 0- . U Er . ' 1 Flowway Stewardship Area Planners Engineers Ecologists Surveyors GIS Consultants F-7 =, a a — 0 Landscape Architects Transpodabon Consultants II RI fs il 0 11 410 Habitat Stewardship Area 3200 Barley Lane Sude 200 I Co I Naples Ronda 34105 ll r TEL(239)649-4040 i a i , woo.vollsonmr1Wr coon GIS@W!son..cam Permitted Water Retention Area Once,snategicany louden to serve our dents I I ' I I o ■6 I fThi----1 ',.''es 0 0 RLSA Overview Project Status , CI\ FR \ I 7.—117::1-17..Ztrm---71,7,", . . . . Mtmicode Page 1 of 5 9B -GR Collier County Florida, Code of Ordinances >> PART II - SPECIAL ACTS >> Chapter 250 - PLANNING >> ARTICLE H. - PLANNING. ZONING AND SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS >> DIVISION 2. - ZONING >> DIVISION 2. - ZONING r22n Sec 250 -51 - General provisions. Sec. 250 -52. - Establishing district boundaries, adoption of regulations. Sec. 250 -53. - Amendment. Sec. 250 -54. -Continuity. Sec. 250 -55. - Board of zoning appeals — Generally_ Sec. 250 -56. - Same Powem and duties. Sec 250 -57 - Exercise of Powers. Sec. 250 -58. - Appeal from decision of administrative official. Sec. 250 -59. - Staying of work on premises. Sec. 250 -60. - Revie_w of decisions' precedence- vests of action. Secs. 250 -61- 250 -70. - Reserved Sec. 250 -51. - General provisions. (a) Purposes and districts. For the purpose of guiding and accomplishing coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development in accordance with existing and future needs, and in order to protect, promote and improve public health, safety, order, comfort, convenience, appearance and general welfare, the governing body or bodies of an area or areas described under section 250 -29, in accordance with the conditions and procedures specified in this act, may enact or amend a zoning ordinance or ordinances. In such ordinance or ordinances the governing body shall create zoning districts in such number, shape and size as may be deemed best suited to carry out the purposes of this act. Ordinances need not be uniform in all geographic areas of the county served by different planning commissions, but the provisions of zoning ordinances may vary from geographic area to geographic area established under subsection 250- 33(a). (1) Special districts or zones may be established in those areas deemed subject to seasonal or periodic flooding or where necessary for flowage of water during the time of floods, and such regulations may be applied therein as will minimize danger to life and property. (b) What may be regulated. Within the establishing zoning districts the governing body or bodies may regulate and determine: (1) Height, number of stories, size, location, relocation, erection, construction, reconstruction, alteration, removal and use of buildings, structures, and signs. (2) Use of land and water for commerce, industry, residence, agriculture, recreation, forestry, resource, conservation, and other lawful purposes. (3) Size of yards, courts and other open spaces. (4) Percentage of lot that may be occupied. (5) Density and distribution of population. (6) Expansion, change or elimination of nonconformities. Notice of elimination of nonconformities shall be recorded in the official records of the county. (7) Damage or nuisance producing characteristics such as, but not limited to noise, vibration, glare, and the handling of gaseous, liquid and solid wastes, including junk and wrecked automobiles and appliances, and trash. (c) District regulations, boundaries. Regulations and district boundaries shall be designed to help accomplish the objectives and purposes set forth in paragraph (a) of this section, and the comprehensive plan. The regulations shall apply uniformly to each class or kind of use throughout the zoning districts in which that use is permitted, under the particular ordinance involved. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67.1246, § 9; Laws of Fla, ch. 69 -964, §§ 1, 2) http: // library. municode .comlprint.aspx ?clientlD = 10578& HTMRequest= http %3a %2f%2fli... 11/9/2010 Municode Page 2 of 5 090 Ck Editors note— Laws of Fla. ch. 69 -964, § 1 amended Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 9(a). As the 1969 act made no reference to § 9(a)(1), the same has been retained. The title of the 1969 act does not indicate that there was an intent to delete § 9(a)(1). Sec. 250 -52. - Establishing district boundaries; adoption of regulations. (a) Tentative report by planning commission. Tentative recommendations as to the boundaries of districts and the regulations to be enforced therein may be prepared-by a planning commission for its planning area on its own initiative, or at the request of the governing body. The commission may hold preliminary hearings and conferences at such times and places and upon such notice as it may determine to be necessary to inform itself in the preparation of the tentative report. The tentative report, which shall include the proposed zoning ordinance with maps and other explanatory material, shall be made to the governing body by the planning commission. A recommendation shall only be made when approved by a vote equal in number to a majority of the full membership of the commission. (b) Action on tentative report. The governing body or bodies of the area shall consider the tentative report of the planning commission and shall return it, with any suggestions and recommendations, to the planning commission so that the planning commission may prepare a final report. (c) Final report and action. A final report on the zoning regulations shall be made to the governing body after the planning commission has considered the suggestions and recommendations of that body, and after a public hearing with due public notice. After the final report has been submitted by the planning commission, the governing body shall afford all interested persons an opportunity to be heard with reference to it at a public hearing or hearings, with due public notice, and shall act upon the proposed zoning regulations. No ordinance under the authority of this division shall be passed until after the final report of the planning commission has been received by the governing body or bodies. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 10) Sec. 250 -53. - Amendment. (a) The governing body may from time to time amend or supplement the regulations and districts fixed by any zoning ordinance adopted pursuant to this Act. Proposed changes may be suggested by the governing body, by the planning commission, by the hearing examiner, or by petition of the owners of 50 percent or more of the area involved in the proposed change. In the latter case, the petitioner or petitioners may be required to assume the cost of public notice and other costs incidental to the hearings. (b) The planning commission, regardless of the source of the proposal for change, shall hold a public hearing or hearings thereon, with due public notice, and submit its recommendation on the proposed change to the governing body, except that the county planning commission may only render recommendations for those proposed changes which pertain to the county and which would change the actual list of permitted, conditional, or prohibited uses within a zoning category, or otherwise would alter or amend provisions of the county's codified land development regulations. The governing body shall hold a public hearing or hearings thereon, and shall act on the recommendation. No change in the zoning ordinance shall become effective except by an affirmative vote of four -fifths of the full membership of the governing body. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67.1246, § 11; Laws of Fla. ch. 2001 -344, § 1) Sec. 250 -54. - Continuity. In the event any unincorporated territory within Collier County shall hereafter become incorporated, to insure that there shall be no lapse of zoning, any and all zoning regulations which may be in effect in such territory and administered by the county shall remain in full force and effect and shall continue to be administered and enforced by the county under this zoning law until such time as municipal zoning within such territory shall be adopted and take effect. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 12) Sec. 250 -55. - Board of zoning appeals — Generally. (a) Establishment and composition. The governing body may appoint a board or boards of zoning appeals for its planning area or areas, or may act as such board or boards of zoning appeals itself. Boards of zoning appeals shall have not less than five nor more than ten members. Not more than two members of a board of zoning appeals may be members of a planning commission. http: // library. municode .com / print. aspx? clientlD = 10578 &HTMRequest= http %3a %2flo2fli... 11/9/2010 Municode Page 3 of 5 t 9B -Ci�t (b) Tenure, organization. Unless the governing body acts as a board of zoning appeals, then terms of office, removal from office; vacancies, shall be treated as follows: (1) Terms of office of members of the board of zoning appeals shall be for not less than two nor more than four years, and not more than a minority of such members' terms shall expire in any one year. (2) Any member of a board of zoning appeals may be removed from office for just cause by four -fifths vote of the full membership of the appointing governing body, but such member shall be entitled to a public hearing if he so requests in writing within 30 days of the date upon which the vote is taken. (3) Wherever a vacancy occurs on a board of zoning appeals which reduces the membership of the board of zoning appeals below five, the governing body shall fill such vacancy for the remainder of the term, within 30 days after the vacancy occurs. No meetings of a board of zoning appeals shall be held when the membership is less than five. (c) Officers, rules of procedure, employees and expenses. Boards of zoning appeals shall elect a chairman and vice - chairman from among the members, and may create and fill such other officers as are determined to be necessary. Terms of all offices shall be for one year, with eligibility for reelection. (1) Boards of zoning appeals shall adopt rules for the transaction of business, and shall keep a record of resolutions, transactions, findings, and determinations. Boards of zoning appeals may provide for transcription of such hearings and proceedings, or portion of hearings and proceedings, as may be deemed necessary. All such records shall be public records. (2) Boards of zoning appeals may, subject to the approval of the governing body concerned and within the financial limitations set by appropriations made or other funds available, employ such experts, technicians and staff as may be deemed proper, pay their salaries and make such other expenditures as are necessary to conduct the work of the board of zoning appeals and effectuate its purposes. (3) Members of boards of zoning appeals may receive such travel and other expenses while on official business for the board as are made available by the governing body for these purposes. (d) Appropriations, fees and other income. The governing body for the area under the jurisdiction of a board of zoning appeals is hereby authorized and empowered to make such appropriations as it may see fit for the conduct of the work of the board of zoning appeals. The governing body is authorized and empowered to establish a schedule of fees, charges and expenses, and a collection procedure therefor. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 13) Code reference — Boards, commissions, committees and councils, § 2 -816 at seq. Land development code reference —Board of zoning appeals, § 250-55. Sec. 250 -56. - Same — Powers and duties. (a) Boards of zoning appeals or the governing body acting as a board of zoning appeals in the event it so elects, shall have the following powers and duties: (1) To hear and decide administrative appeals where it is alleged there is error in any order, requirement, decision, interpretation or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of any zoning ordinance or regulation adopted pursuant to this Act. (b) No administrative appeal shall be considered by a board of zoning appeals or the governing body acting as a board of zoning appeals except after public hearing with due public notice. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67.1246, § 14; Laws of Fla. ch. 2001 -344, § 1) Sec. 250 -57. - Exercise of powers. In exercising its powers, boards of zoning appeals or the governing body may, in conformity with the provisions of this Act and the zoning ordinance, reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify the administrative order, requirement, decision or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of any zoning ordinance or regulation adopted pursuant to this Act, and appealed from, and may make such administrative order, requirement, decision or determination as ought to be made, and to that end shall have all the powers of the officer from whom the administrative appeal is taken. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 15; Laws of Fla. ch. 2001.344, § 1) http: / /Iibrary.municode.com/ print. aspx? clientlD�10578& HTMRequest= httpa /o3aa /o2f/u2fli... 11/9/2010 Municode Page 4 of 5 r,9B -Coon' Sec. 250 -58. -Appeal from decision of administrative official. (a) Appeals to a board of zoning appeals or the governing body, as the case may be, may be taken by any person aggrieved or by any officer, department, board, or bureau of the governing body or bodies in the area affected by the administrative decision, determination or requirement made by the administrative official. Such appeals shall be taken within 30 days by filing with the administrative official a written notice specifying the grounds thereof. The administrative official shall forthwith transmit to the board all papers, documents, and maps constituting the record of the administrative action from which an appeal is taken. (b) Due public notice of the hearing on the administrative appeal shall be given. (c) Upon the hearing, any party may appear in person or by attorney. A decision shall be reached by the appellate body within 30 days of the hearing; otherwise, the action appealed from shall be deemed affirmed. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 16; Laws of Fla. ch. 2001.344, § 1) Sec. 250 -59. - Staying of work on premises. When an appeal from the decision of any administrative official has been filed with the administrative official, all proceedings and work on the premises concerning which the decision was made shall be stayed unless the official from whom the appeal was taken shall certify to the board of zoning appeals that by reason of facts stated in the certificate a stay would cause imminent peril to life or property. In such case, proceedings, or work shall not be stayed except by a restraining order which may be granted by the board of zoning appeals, or by a court of record. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 17) Sec. 250 -60. - Review of decisions; precedence; costs of action. (a) Review of decisions of boards of zoning appeals is exclusively by the circuit court of Collier County. Any person or persons, jointly or severally, aggrieved by any decision of a board of zoning appeals, or any taxpayer, or any officer; department, board or bureau of the governing body, may present to the Circuit Court of Collier County a petition, duly verified, setting forth that such decision is illegal, in whole or in part, and specifying the grounds of the illegality. Such petition shall be presented to the court within 30 days after the decision of the board of zoning appeals. (b) Upon the presentation of such petition the court may allow a writ of certiorari directed to the board of zoning appeals to review such decision of the board of zoning appeals and shall prescribe therein the time within which a return thereto must be made and served upon relator's attorney, which shall not be less than ten days and may be extended by the court. The allowance of the writ shall not stay proceedings upon the decision appealed from, but the court may, on application, on notice to the board, and on due cause shown, grant a restraining order. (c) The board of zoning appeals shall not be required to return the original papers acted upon by it, but it shall be sufficient to return certified or sworn copies thereof or of such portions thereof as may be called for by such writ. The return shall concisely set forth such other facts as may be pertinent and material to show the grounds of the decision appealed from and shall be verified. (d) If, upon the hearing, it shall appear to the court that testimony is necessary for the proper disposition of the matter, it may take evidence or appoint a referee to take such evidence as it may direct and report the same to the court with his findings of fact and conclusions of law, which shall constitute a part of the proceedings upon which the determination of the court shall be made. The court may reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify the decision brought up for review. (e) All issues in any proceedings under this section shall have preference over all other civil actions and proceedings. (f) Costs shall be allowed to the petitioner only if it shall appear to the court that the board acted with gross negligence, or in bad faith, or with malice in making the decision appealed from. (Laws of Fla. ch. 67 -1246, § 18) Secs. 250 -61- 250 -70. - Reserved. http: // library. municode .com / print. aspx? clientlD =1 0578& HTMRequest= httpa /u3aa /o2f%2fli... 11/9/2010 Municode FOOTNOTE(S): (222) Land development code reference — Zoning, art. 2. Back Page 5 of 5 9 B -OC http:// library. municode .comlprint.aspx ?clientlD = 10578& HTMRequest= http %3a %2f%2fli... 11/9/2010 1 9 0 "3p� Jump To: Bill Tex Amendments (0) Staff Analysis ( VoteLHilstory Citations .Previous House Bill Next House Bill ► House 1859: Relating to Collier Co. /Governmental Powers H1859 LOCAL BILL by Goodlette (Similar 52376) Collier Co. /Governmental Powers; amends scope of act to authorize county hearing examiner program; amends definitions; amends functions, powers, & duties of planning commissions; amends provisions re supplementing & amending zoning ordinance; amends powers & duties of board of zoning appeals; amends provisions re appeal from decision of administrative official; provides procedure for establishing county hearing examiner program; provides for severabil.i.ty. EFFECTIVE DATE: 05/25/2001. 04/03/01 HOUSE Filed; Introduced, referred to Local Government & Veterans Affairs (SGC) -HJ 00451 04/17/01 HOUSE On Committee agenda -- Local Government & Veterans Affairs (SGC), 04/19/01, 1:00 pm, Reed Hall 04/19/01 HOUSE Favorable by- Local Government & Veterans Affairs (SGC); YEAS 8 NAYS 0 -HJ 00,551 04/20/01 HOUSE Placed on Calendar, on second reading -HJ 00551 04/24/01 HOUSE Placed on Local Calendar; Read second and third times -HJ 00629; Passed; YEAS 116 NAYS 0 -HJ 00629 04/24/01 SENATE In Messages 04/30/01 SENATE Received, referred to Rules and Calendar -SJ 00658 05/02/01 SENATE Withdrawn from Rules and Calendar; Placed on Local Calendar -SJ 00952; Read second and third times -SJ 00928; Passed; YEAS 40 NAYS 0 -Si 00928 05/02/01. HOUSE Ordered enrolled -H,i 01829 05/1.4/01 Signed by Officers and presented to Governor 05/25/01 Approved by Governor; Chapter No. 2001 -344 Bills Version: Posted: Format: H 1859 04/04/2001 Web Page PDF H 1859ER 05/10/2001 Web Page PDF Amendments NO AMENDMENTS AVAILABLE Bill Analyses Analysis: Sponsor Format: h 1859 Local Government & Veterans Affairs PDF h 1859a Local Government & Veterans Affairs PDF h 1859z Local Government & Veterans Affairs PDF '� Vote History Chamber: Roll Call: Date: Format: SENATE, 0112 05/02/01 Web Page Citations - Statute NO STATUTE CITATIONS FOUND FOR HOUSE HILL 1859. Citations - Constitution NO CONSTITUTION CITATIONS FOUND FOR HOUSE BILL 1859. CHAPTER 2001 -344 House Bill No. 1859 An act relating to Collier County; amending ch. 67 -1246, Laws of Florida; amending the scope of the act to authorize a county hearing examiner program; amending definitions; amending the functions, powers, and duties of the planning commissions; amending provi- sions relating to supplementing and amending the zoning ordinance; amending the powers and duties of the board of zoning appeals; amending provisions relating to appeal from a decision of an admin- istrative official; providing the procedure for establishing a county hearing examiner program; providing for severability; providing an effective date. Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida Section 1. Sections 1, 3, 6, 11, 14, 15, and 16 of chapter 67 -1246, Laws of Florida, are amended, and section 31 is added to said chapter, to read: Section 1. Scope of act. All municipalities lying within the county of Collier, state of Florida, and the county of Collier, of the state of Florida, may plan, may zone, may regulate subdivisions and may establish and maintain the boards, hearing examiners, and commissions described herein for carry- ing out the purposes of this act. The powers delegated by this act may be employed by municipalities or the county individually, or, by mutual agree- ment, in such combinations as common interest dictate. Section 3. Definitions. As used in this act, the following words or phrases have the meaning indicated below: Area: The complete area qualifying under the provisions of this act, whether this be all of the lands lying within the limits of a municipality, lands in and adjacent to municipalities, all unincorporated lands within Collier county, the portions of such unincorporated areas as may qualify under the provisions of this act, or areas comprising combinations of the lands in municipalities and Collier county. Due public notice: As used in the phrase "public hearing or hearings with due public notice" involves the following requirements: Unless otherwise public notice requires that at least fifteen (15) days notice of the time and place of such hearings shall be published one (1) time in a newspaper of general circulation in the area. The notice shall state the time and place of the hearing, the nature of the matter to be discussed and that written comments filed with an appropriate designated official will be heard. Governing body: The municipal commission or council, county commis- sion, or any other chief local governing unit, however designated, for the political jurisdiction affected. CODING: Words striekew are deletions; words underlined are additions. x`96 -GR Ch. 2001 -344 LAWS OF FLORIDA Ch. 2001 -344 Nonconformity: A lot, structure, or use of land, or any combination thereof, which is not in compliance with a zoning ordinance, but which was lawfully created or begun prior to adoption of the zoning ordinance provi- sions with which it does not comply. '7 Ordinance: When used in relation to Collier county or the board of county commissioners shall mean a resolution of the board of county commission- ers, or shall mean such other appropriate official action as is customarily taken by the governing body involved, regardless of how such official action is regularly called. Plat: Includes map, plan or replat, and is a pictorial representation of a subdivision. Subdivision: The division of a parcel of land into two (2) or more lots or parcels of land, for the purpose, whether immediate or future, of transfer of ownership, a map or plat of which is recorded in the public records of the county, and intended for use as residential, multi- family, commercial or industrial properties. The term includes a resubdivision and, when appro- priate to the context, shall relate to the process of subdividing or to the land subdivided. Street: The primary means of access, whether public or private, to a lot or parcel of land. Special exception: As used in connection with the provisions of this act dealing with zoning, a special exception is a use that would not be appropri- ate generally or without restriction throughout the particular zoning district or classification but which, if controlled as to number, area, location or relation to the neighborhood, would promote the public safety, health, com- fort, good order, appearance, convenience, prosperity, morals and the gen- eral welfare. Such uses may be permitted in such zoning district or classifi- cation as special exceptions, if specific provision for such special exceptions is made in the zoning ordinance. The singular usage includes the plural and the plural the singular. Section 6. Functions, powers and duties of the planning commissions. The functions, powers and duties of planning commission shall be, in gen- eral: (a) To acquire and maintain in current form such basic information and materials as are necessary to an understanding of past trends, present conditions, and forces at work to cause changes in these conditions. Such basic information and materials may include maps and photographs of man made or natural physical features of the area concerned, statistics on past trends and present conditions with respect to population, property values, economic base, land use and such other information as is important or likely to be important in determining the amount, direction and kind of develop- ment to be expected in the area and its various parts. (b) To prepare, and from time to time recommend amendment and revi- sions to, a comprehensive and coordinated general plan for meeting present requirements and such future requirements as may be foreseen. CODING: Words AtFie#en are deletions; words underlined are additions. Ch. 2001 -344 LAWS OF FLORIDA Ch. 2001 -344 (c) To prepare and recommend principles and policies for guiding the development of the area. (d) To prepare and recommend ordinances designed to promote orderly development along the lines indicated by official principles and policies and the comprehensive plan. Lejtl} To keep the governing body and the general public informed and advised on matters relating to planning. Jf {g; To conduct such public hearings as maybe required to gather infor- mation necessary for the drafting, establishment and maintenance of the various components of the comprehensive plan, and such additional public hearings as are specified under the provisions of this act or may be required by ordinance. jg)04 In addition, a planning commission may make, cause to be made, or obtain special studies on the location, condition and adequacy of specific facilities of the area. These may include, but are not limited to, studies on housing, commercial and industrial facilities, parks, playgrounds, beaches and other recreational facilities, schools, public buildings, public and private utilities, traffic, transportation and parking. lhhjl# To perform any other duties which may be lawfully assigned to it. Section 11. Supplementing and amending the zoning ordinance. The gov- erning body may from time to time amend or supplement the regulations and districts fixed by any zoning ordinance adopted pursuant to this act. Proposed changes may be suggested by the governing body, by the planning commissioner the hearing examiner, or by petition of the owners of fifty per cent (50 %) or more of the area involved in the proposed change. In the latter case, the petitioner or petitioners may be required to assume the cost of public notice and other costs incidental to the hearings. The planning commission, regardless of the source of the proposal for change, shall hold a public hearing or hearings thereon, with due public notice, and submit its recommendation on the proposed change to the gov- erning body, except that the county planning commission may only render body shall may hold a public hearing or hearings thereon, and shall act on the recommendation. No change in the zoning ordinance shall become effec- tive except by an affirmative vote of four fifths (4 4s's) of the full membership of the governing body. Section 14. Board of zoning appeals; powers and duties; boards of zoning appeals or eu the governing body acting as a board of zoning appeals in the event it so elects, shall have the following powers and duties. CODING: Words str-ieken are deletions; words underlined are additions. r 9B -Gfl� Ch. 2001 -344 LAWS OF FLORIDA Ch. 2001 -344 (a) To hear and decide administrative appeals where it is alleged there is error in any order, requirement, decision, interpretation or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of any zoning ordi- nance or regulation adopted pursuant to this act. IMP IMF MIMP.1,010 No administrative appeal aariawee shall be considered aathoriaed by a board of zoning appeals or the governing body acting as a board of zoning appeals except after public hearing with due public notice. Section 15. Exercise of powers. In exercising its powers, boards of zoning appeals or the governing body may, in conformity with the provisions of this act and the zoning ordinance, reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify the administrative order, requirement, decision or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of any zoning ordi- nance or regulation adopted pursuant to this act, and appealed from, and may make such administrative order, requirement, decision or determina- tion as ought to be made, and to that end shall have all the powers of the officer from whom the administrative appeal is taken. CODING: Words stficken are deletions; words underlined are additions. i 9 B r'C Ch. 2001 -344 LAWS OF FLORIDA Ch. 2001 -344 Section 16. Appeal from decision of administrative official. Appeals to a board of zoning appeals or the governing body, as the case may be, may be taken by any person aggrieved or by any officer, department, board, or bureau of the governing body or bodies in the area affected by the adminis- trative decision, determination or requirement made by the administrative official. Such appeals shall be taken within thirty (30) days by filing with the administrative official a written notice specifying the grounds thereof. The administrative official shall forthwith transmit to the board all papers, documents, and maps constituting the record of the administrative action from which an appeal is taken. Due public notice of the hearing on the administrative appeal shall be given. Upon the hearing, any party may appear in person or by attorney. A decision shall be reached by the appellate body within thirty (30) days of the hearing; otherwise, the action appealed from shall be deemed affirmed. Section 31 The method and procedures for implementing a county hear- ing examiner program shall be as set forth by county ordinance. Section 3. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law. Approved by the Governor May 25, 2001. Filed in Office Secretary of State May 25, 2001. CODING: Words sE004@n are deletions; words underlined are additions. g8 -c The Collier County Rural Lands Stewardship Overlay Presented to: Collier County Board of County Commissioners November 9, 2010 Presented by Alan Reynolds, AICP On behalf of Eastern Collier Property Owners Future Land Use 1999 t,' • Private land zoned Rural-Ag I I • No effective strategy to protect natural resources/agriculture or , prevent sprawl. � °° • No cooperative relationship between property owners, government agencies and �.� environmental organizations. i • Tools to protect important natural ,;=s resources are regulation, litigation and public funded acquisition. 1 FLORIDA 2060: A POPULATION DISTRIBUTION SCENARIO A Research Project Prepared for 1000Fnends of Florida by the GeoPlan Center Florida 2060— at the University of Florda Derr be,2006 GeoPlan Center- University of Florida e , 1 Publi Land 16,00 ) 4'" * Agricultural/ Natural Lands 4111.0 ' ,x• r 44,000 I Developed +� � Lands * I _DEVELOPED LANDS 135,000 PUBLIC LANDS TURF I NATURAL LANDS N41ni Wi1es<a ` RURAL LAND STENWRDSNIP AREA BOUNDARY ACSC BOUNDARY Twarx' '� GOLDEN GATE ESTATES Not a pretty picture! LANES N ROADS RLSA Ownership Map " .ilk' The distribution of owners(10 or more acres) 1,000 acres or more 15 owners _ 29A } 100-999 acres 38 owners 0 40-99 acres 29 owners = 10-39 acres 44 owners A. Subtotal 126 owners Total acres represented:170,034 acres of private ownership represented:99 Average ownership size: 1,349 acres .4 r• a —. RLSA 0.. ,`. ...... .. RLSA .� - i i— ' 2010 Ownership 2 98- cR THE RLSA PROGRAM The Overlay was created through a collaborative community based planning process involving county residents,area property owners,and representatives of community and governmental organizations under the direction of a citizen oversight committee."(GMP Policy 1.1) A collaborative multi-year planning process created an innovative and incentive-based program that became the first Rural Land Stewardship Program in Florida. Approval of the RLSA resolved many contentious issues and set the stage for a new era of cooperation. RLSA program has received numerous awards and exceeded expectations in terms of owner participation, natural resource protection and creation of sustainable .� development. RLSA GOAL "Collier County seeks to address the long-term needs of residents and property owners within the lmmokalee Area Study boundary of the Collier County Rural and Agricultural Area Assessment. Collier County's goal is to protect agricultural activities, to prevent the premature conversion of agricultural land to non-agricultural uses, to direct incompatible uses away from wetlands and upland habitat, to enable the conversion of rural land to other uses in appropriate locations, to discourage urban sprawl,and to encourage development that utilizes creative land use planning techniques."(GMP Goal) • Needs of residents/property owners are paramount. -- • The RLSA balances environmental protection, agriculture and development. • Conversion of land to other uses is"enabled"and development that uses creative planning techniques is "encouraged". 3 98-c RLSA OBJECTIVE "Collier County's objective is to create an incentive based land use overlay system,herein referred to as the Collier County Rural Lands Stewardship Area Overlay....."(Objective), "Stewardship Credits will be exchanged for additional residential or non-residential entitlements in a SRA on a per acre basis, ....Stewardship density and intensity will thereafter differ from the Baseline Standards. The assignment or use of Stewardship Credits shall not require a GMP Amendment." (GMP Policy 1.14) • Incentives are the foundation of the RLSA. • RLSA Overlay established the permitted land uses. • The implementation process does not require GMP amendments. RLSA OVERLAY "The Overlay protects natural resources and retains viable agriculture by promoting compact rural mixed-use development as an alternative to low-density single use development,and provides a system of compensation to private property owners for the elimination of certain land uses in order to protect natural resources and viable agriculture in exchange for transferable credits that can be used to entitle such compact development."...The Overlay includes innovative and incentive based tools, techniques and strategies that are not dependent on a regulatory approach(GMP Policy 1.2) • Mixed-use development is"promoted"as a better alternative than sprawl. Ate •A Credit is"compensation"to an owner for the voluntary elimination of development rights. tf • Credits"entitle"development. •"Innovative and incentive based"-not a regulatory program. 4 ) B RLSA - EQUITY there shall be no change to the underlying density and intensity of permitted uses of land within the RLSA, ... unless and until a property owner elects to utilize the provisions of the Stewardship Credit System. It is the intent of the Overlay that a property owner will be compensated for the voluntary stewardship and protection of important agricultural and natural resources......{GMP Policy 1 4) • Unlike other property owners in Collier County- RLSA property owners cannot use the county's rezoning process to change density or intensity. • Owners must instead utilize the Stewardship Credit system and Designation process. • Intent-"a property owner will be compensated for voluntary stewardship". STEWARDSHIP CREDITS •A Credit is granted by the County to a property owner as compensation for the voluntary elimination of development rights on land designated as a SSA. •The owner of a Credit can transfer it to property they own or sell it to a third party. • A Credit is applied to land designated as a SRA to entitle mixed-use development. • The market value of a Credit(the owner's compensation) is solely based on the ability to use Credits to entitle a SRA under an objective, reliable, and predictable process. • The rezoning process is not an objective, reliable or predictable process, and is not available to RLSA owners for changes in density or intensity. ismemmoriner 5 RLSA vs. Rural Fringe TDR The RLSA encompasses 195,000 acres in the northeastern corner of the County. Collier County also has a TDR program that applies to a different area of Collier County called the Rural Fringe. There is no overlap,the two programs are entirely different and mutually exclusive. Stewardship Credits and Rural Fringe TDRs are not equivalent and cannot be interchanged. TDR provisions shall not be applicable to the transfer of development rights within the RLSA District"(LDC 2.03.07D.4.a.) STEWARDSHIP—PROTECTION BEFORE DEVELOPMENT The incentive based Stewardship Credit system relies on the projected demand for Credits as the primary basis for permanent protection of flowways,habitats and water retention areas. The County recognizes that there may be a lack of significant demand for Credits in the early years of implementation,and also recognizes that a public benefit would be realized by the early designation of SSAs."(GMP Policy ?.2?) • 55,700 acres of SSAs have been designated. • 137,600 Credits have been earned. • More than 108,000 Credits are currently held by SSA property owners for future use. • RLSA property owners have acted in reliance on the program and protected an extraordinary amount of land before there was a market for the Credits. • All County Citizens have benefited. 6 93C SSA and SRA PROCEDURES The procedures for the establishment and transfer of Credits and SRA designation are set forth herein and will also be adopted as a part of a Stewardship District in the LDC."(GMF Policy 1.13) To make the SSA and SRA designation process objective, reliable, and predictable, Collier County: • Used data and analysis to predetermine which lands are eligible to be designated as SSA and SRA. • Adopted a Zoning Overlay over the entire RLSA. • Established procedures in the LDC under a specific Chapter that only applies to the RLSA. •Established specific land use requirements and standards for SRAs. • County rezoning procedures do not apply to the designation of SSAs or SRAs. RLSA ZONING Rural Lands Stewardship Area(RLSA)Zoning Overlay District OVERLAY R 28 E R 29 F R 30 E ;> This Zoning Overlay was • % - adopted specifically so the - ® F c-a implementation of the RLSA , '/ii.-` program could be • accomplished without �, .,; requiring a subsequent � i %?% rezoning process to designate /:/// //' i � /- a SSA or SRA. � j Approval of the zoning overlay r„,/ by the BCC was a change toj� ; the"Zoning Ordinance". 44/ The Zoning in the RLSA is j / "A-RLSAO". i fl 28 E R 29 E R 70 F Imp:'hbma.murucode_cam,print acp,clIemlP-11.02,4nm91Requc=r-h0ys;ac4%5l1bmy.mmmiand... 1 1X52010 7 9 B -C121 SSA DESIGNATION "Land becomes designated as a SSA upon petition by the property owner seeking such designation and the adoption of a resolution by the Collier County Board of County Commissioners (BCC), which acknowledges the property owner's request for such designation and assigns Stewardship Credits or other compensation to the owner for such designation. "(Policy 1.6) • 16 SSAs have been designated by the voluntary actions of property owners and approval of the BCC. • 55,700 acres of private land have been protected, including the majority of the Camp Keais Strand and much of the Okaloacoochie Slough. I s • The approval of each SSA was by resolution of the BCC based on meeting specific and objective criteria . The Resolution approving and designating SSA RESOLUTION SSA 12 for Sunniland Family Limited Partnership was adopted on February 9, 2010. 4,793.5 acres were protected. RESOLUTION 2019 A.. •. •°. ,.•._<. •:e W a as ttsL we es Mena a en Esnnne.Ago A Rea9Wtben ot the Collier County good Snow a Chewy SSA td Staawdeyr Senors Orna y paw�rlr•41, $ot$o 1.100 SSA 13 et ern Sewx.; at County Gamaassinnees designating r 0 Mme3 Arenwnf b Srrenane hPy SSA I. -CMS Actor to the Neon Mania SNwatdatdp Area toeing One.,OMlrtrt his Stied tan,torabb*oo ani1 a.Nan✓wa s*oO0,me 04$ as a Stewafdentp Sanding An. rata a In,>440114i atf.efr ta/ged and Cagy on and se area tQ ry*. deeigaendo as"Sunnrlar4 Family SSA 13" Snwarebtep OWNS 10 De eeneMfW ao es peas ends s'It tw.4 po sw0t to Mt toomo en forth Lr the .d the(iadf A70 's/0114,74.11114411.as Eafeas EsCt(!w Agreet0000 Stewardship$elldenp tM Sew.4441I0 A14411 as 0040 aMMPMIAO*N}4.14444/, Aeaa Credit Agoetwrd for Shnwta4W PamWy SSA t2,end Stowardshtp Easement SreaedMiR'+Easamtae to the Ara" Agnrenent rya Sunrtthead Ferrety SSA 12', 11 r*''* ddpreiong a Siew.rdstap Send.p *4*8 eI 40 tt•Sea n f aa:LAW dAAVnm:' .. Credo Agreement for $nndana Family Swrsrhra Sesseg Area es Cwaer SSA 12 apparrng a Stewardship a4sne'wa a'tr e.o•a•n 4,dw:weeny w La®t+ent A9RrinwN tw lonmtarat rArne.wsw eoelaaCaN Lwn*usd rs aw 5.: amaty SSA 12: 4114tlr08474 40 CSC/aw C,. a S0*04 r0 Swvay Nw Chen — Agoroetent fur Stnnitand Family SSA ta: bAd esthhhhA ng the nuattwt of Ytewardshlp Credits geminated by the ittf31ESRUyDN ADOPTED tn ? dy y Y ?aq rtesignntin qt ard M Sandals awYYWC0I1.1101 tore MN wedeln&S77ror+fto d'wn+r reran.naneatfh a/ewer trees NGNNID 9F C<'JIMTY G�:aeASStGWtK:: C:Jt.Iti;R COtwrY fICMf W^0M0M.y Dee w 1as d0e taNeOn zsw3000 04syem off naew a.04P0.ass•n*eaed.raw.w 6sa4e04 04 Mme Rua tea. 'itu+w�o Aee T.an.yA r*00*a...I SA r4.48 i k0Mta n a 0%4 7 OAK.,t 0.4400 K • �ruy1 f r.aa tied te vy rtFACtmE rr *Now proa.ewfersad doaap wwwd.raSorel,A.. 41,414 r.r�aa*A 4.11 301,1 14.46.1r4 m 1 a an a a E a(A 4.4Pe aMr Leerstien .Cola 1€4:4,0'0 e'0 t�wae M1* e N At`ewwrt Lea d w,ar STA 17 1114.047-30141 Awe.. 11/ny+n Are ,aN+g N0 e40.11 ayar.eraunE**+ee aynr...ert 0'13 .xa.0t1,w¢.y TMth HW Awrn C.u+.Ash 17'13-aee, 1 yet the;4a✓.L*.e 40.11 8 B --(,,P . _.,.: _, .. .. SRA DESIGNATION • "Land becomes designated as an SRA upon the adoption of a resolution by the Collier County Board of County Commissioners (BCC)approving the petition by the property owner seeking such designation.Any change in the residential density or non- residential intensity of land use on a parcel of land located within a SRA shall be specified in the resolution reflecting the total number of transferable Credits assigned to the parcel of land.'" (Policy 1.15) • • One SRA is approved to date,the Town of Ave Maria. • 28,658.4 Credits generated from several different SSAs were assigned to obtain the entitlement. • 11,000 residential units and approximately 1.26 mm s.f. of non-residential use were approved. • • ,.• NOW,THEREFORE,bed resolved by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County,Florida(the'Board'),that SRARESOLUTION I. The Board hereby approves and designates as the Town of Ave Maria SRA the five thousand and twenty-seven(5,027)acres described in the legal description attached as Exhibit A. 2. The Board hereby approves the Stewardship Receiving Area Credit Agreement,a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit"B,"requiring Applicant to transfer and assign a total of twenty eight thousand six hundred and fifty-eight and four-tenths(28,658.4)Stewardship Credits to Collier County. The Resolution 3. The Stewardship Receiving Area Credit Agreement itself has attached approving and thereto as exhibits a Master Plan and Land Use Summary which identify the number of units,gross leaseable square footage of retail and office designating the SRA for uses,and the other land uses depicted on the Ave Maria Master Plan,all of which are likewise hereby approved along with the balance of the the Town of Ave Maria materials otherwise included as part of the Application which is attached as Exhibit"C,"and incorporated by reference and is now approved. was adopted on June 14, 4. The Board's requested amendments pertaining to a site for expanded 2005. primary care medical facilities and a minimum of 50,000 sq. ft. of Business Park uses are found on Pages 5A and 77,respectively,of the Town Plan,which is Tab 6 of Exhibit"C." THIS RESOLUTION ADOPTED this 14ei day of June,2005,after a Motion, seconded,and majority vote favoring same. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COWER COUNTY,FLORIDA ATTt83'y f3rTE?r'f;OCK J .� 7%uacfr- Py 'flail s a.' '" he By: W. u -"'` , puty Clerk FRED W.COYLE n ataaatee k:ki."'.;:07 dr%�i11 Approved ea am9Yt d BY P�sufficie y G.; .White 1 Assistant County Attorney G:leeUnooBR.5e55,SRA WAR,MerrNSRA Reeot4nn 4-19-0S.,foc 9 98 - RLSA 2025 Vision SSA acres 92,000 Estimated Credits 315,000 RLSA OVERLAY SRA acres 43,300 r 4 , -, Baseline/Agriculture 43,800 Public lands/misc 16,000 Total acreage 195,100 Baseline/Agriculture i I 43,800 ,, .. ry �Fz SSA ESfAiES 3 92,000 SRA 43,300 ...x.. 16,000 Public Land& Misc. IN CONCLUSION • The RLSA is an innovative/incentive based program. • Participation is at the option of a property owner. • Owner receives Credits for voluntarily giving up development rights and permanently protecting important natural resources in SSA. • Owner participation has exceeded expectations and resource protection has outpaced demand for Credits. • Value is tied to the right to use Stewardship Credits to entitle a SRA. • Process for designating both a SSA and SRA is objective and reliable-and unique to the RLSA. • RLSA Zoning is already in place—designating a SSA or SRA does not involve a change to the Zoning Ordinance • The traditional Collier County rezoning process to change density or intensity is not available to owners in the RLSA. 10 lilt W H m a1 a hZ J it W V t� N ce W J z �Z G W z � 3 � WQ D 4 d t� B H� W 7 H W S r p t7 ZV m r u C7 tuL O ~ W O m 0 w J W 0 = m N Q m aQ J p W ^, O _ i JQz cS� V b ' Qmw Lu __� m �� 3 aW� ^m ~ a r� - WZp WZw z W cn O H i� C Ln O H• a ow o wce8 9 n: '11 Lcut�pou a a. �¢w p O W E D N a °i O: N Q ^�z a ai ,moo W W W O H y N W (Ln W 0 �z) L J Z O C F r �. C p CoY- z a p� C) z a °oZQ Fes- m ` d _ oz� H m rA �m f F a (�. zmm w = d w i iE Z Z, i zz F f z Q U a W °° a U °zQ o o °z° o 0 O ce _ /\ C m a p W W w LL LL a LLJ LU o ~ W O J 5 z" ~ W O QCjOH I t �= Q6p CL l W QY N J a �. \ U)QY Z j �z W J W -, Q W W H U m �,.� wj Z J ^ J ' m3 a J `" r v M ma m= W V W MOm2 F' _ _ `1 - N-j W F Lu t _ N J z Z Z q OzQ� S Q O z H Z O LL, H �.. ..._-._.. U H W V x {W. Q 0J Q z N W 0 Cd ` -�. . O �Z" (D N LL O z W �W/w� r... O a' x W � Oa Q f a a W ��_. C �oZ Q Li- v �m n W e Um. v O L O w W z } LU �aE g LU w f a -j ¢� g ^� a i a z uLnnu a v m m a 0 L fh Y L 0 v 3 � m � •y � a 4w H a W V Z N a LU Y/ W a a 7 O1 d FT m c d 01 d 'v u I iz h i v 4, o m W 0 ' Q i 0 `1 V� V � ti j o W J C O i+ a+ W N cn D Z W c C W LU ui W W z OX 0 c z Q Z 9 v 0 9B o W Ln r° m Ln 0 = m� o° a mo z ¢Ow u Y �¢~ = H Q m LU = O a m W W F- HF--¢ I 3 awl W n m Ow ~F-LL W Z R J aw° vmi vai 5(o (h ado 0 �0 W O Fyr v G � U VDQ r\j O Bo a NLOO m Q p O O } p[ B C) O a w U7 z�� W 1 '1 _ ° 0 < LU H O ¢ 4) t p�W ¢2: z Q c v0 p Q = ° CD z � N F Q m H moo o z a a i„ O z v °F a m mm Z W w f Q d1 u m 000 W = Q Z 2 Z & W - u Vl Z ~ O u z OJO O O W aDQ O Vf fr m "�' Q O O uj a m LU 0 G= LL w O ~ W >~ y W J Q � (A Q ce _ ui aQ� O M `�� Qj� U7¢1 O Z J c+� m Lu v '� ) N e u o0F W V �}, Om= N v H J x o )- _ Y _. O pO 1- W W z¢� Wz� F Z OZ - z¢� = H I_ Z ui p LU u z 0 O ¢ c7 p W �1�/1 w QZ� O D! 1.� y W O 0�w w N -� iii J !~i y �a17 O z o-�i W cn W w W W F ,; �' a z N J LU W J 0 O Q O ti O\1W W Q -0 �m� W c� He ate, lL-+ pOz °mom 'w"' J A A M C YI L o' LU J Q� I�i� W W T i JJ� u xO u(nu u E z � oxo a g m § 3 -1 § 0 2 k X 2 m 0 m \/\ / x m m ^ m rn ) \\ a z § ° n > o x §)E E m \ z j \ ! ] m d \ \ 0 . ma k §e\ n X § �2m z . m =\ƒ ° C > t ƒ P ) \ f p C) . \g> [ / \ =Hz ` r mG � /55 k } ( ono } z M > K E m \j( �.� > oa [ \ , v \ \/ $ # § ))3 m $ lu �0f 2 (D / Mo- c_ 2 0 70 MO M k r) uzm (D «\\ M03 \ § j0> / = § /( / § )§ > )° v ■ \\\ o° CO 70 2 \§\ f)M m \\\ o \oy o �2G $#z m 2// m /g) qC) co z §§\ ■ 2 > LA m <\ /)§In 3, \ < >>« 2 Ano n 3CG M, k )\§ ° (A z /%z \ v 2 => m \\§ o /\{ 10 k Mo- \\\ 2 R/§ \V2 m )/� k \f ■ %E cu S\ j° \ (D � fD \ / rn m k � § ■ m k m � ] m e | x § § § \ m � � � 3 � 7 \ ] r rA 0 � k OOM% ma rm m � m ma � Z � � � m � X � � � m � � � it � On=nO a a) m n A 3nrn o m Z AO m p O �mn m a r i 3 a °off ,�= v RI m m m m m Cv3 m C m iri ' J D O K �' T v 3 m o ; r iii O O m �2!z m .v 3 3 ° m�z �'I \ �'% z z -1 P a z �. x m x m =rN W m �Oo �\ a •• mWy , A r w m ., �zW � m m z 7�c nna U) > iii O m OCZ O In �y TO rn rn o r m x Woo "� v v.< zz03 ° u > o v C D C m z 0 l z ° -IZZ y x 1 3 MP z > m m Y m z O c m \ 3 0 O m p z o ail\ ( p a a o041 G z :K 6 O A ° z�a V �. � 0 a � 3 z a% 3 O O m mm° m v N 3 0 z�C) fop a a o o " (D °x X v M o- %` O -1 m O701rn 71: -i m z ozm m C C) Ln (A D -I -�`... m m m 3 m 1 m n z�> xl m W a �0r �^ z z O W '0 T o x n m x c: c X m ZV) a v cm X O c a m w 3 m m v O x m m m w w v 3 Z C m m T O X 0 C A O 3 3 m z m a z v a X M O a v v m m Ul O z 1 x m n 2 N V90 o=o 3 3 D m cn m a Am z on 7 6) r 000 m ° w m:� y r 3 m �" mn71 '^" rn C) � m z z M�z Xzrn H D z �-Z<o c� Z =0N �U =W° Amoow zw r D Ln 093 V� C �Y =�o r wmo yip ol >z� ° v >c: m^ �. z � M, 2! rn c 7�° m (p CD F-P O 3 .� z � �3z o C- N m 0 m a a 0 0 2 rn D a oom 70 � U) Mo y Dzm J m v�N d 3 rn z O r o W 0O s O w cu L 0O W C/) a fD rt r v y 3Dr- 9 3 m m ^ A 3D Or m m A m a z r A O m n rn 3 a zoo ; v 3 a zoc r+t A 710 3 m rnA rn 70 z M N z p m m N p z 0 rn >70 O 3 X> x e7 r w m ° �+ a O m O m Nz� z z O m T 7o DNI�z /� 3 min 00 0 �zm i Z Z O �Dz T m - i o o / m = W 0 2 VJ 0 m W W v n r In W aWi r Z-+ W r- w N rn r m z, M 1� r 3 AT.DN r m Z �D� O cmi� "z r OT cn =nz mn _�° T rn rn D '{ C W m p \ 2 O 07 (n rnp u � o m X p H LN W 0 m -< D z� ° c aA Ono X c(n 0 m A D0 n O izz Z 3 z =zn Z -I 3 rn�z A -j 3 "'03n x m mm 3 m Z o�m ocm W y pzo S 0 ozo a a °oo ,� � z 3�0 G 3r- a v p c3D c3D O a z O moo � m p m �m0 O m cn rn �, ° p �"� 3 -I D o 3p O z�° m O 0O� a s ° o, .o � (p a s N U zD� o °v mo- A rn O m xp = O °zm m °z Ozm m Z rn cn ei v� A = _ I- v C 7 _ = W i m D W S 3 W DA m m m W D A A z D Dr ° A° r- -i v, y W Sa pr .� t+ O 0 O .+ 0 ao z p T W 10 z T A n A n� W x m Oc� a m Oz u' c UD X v X 'a A rt io m rm_r, O z a 3 m -}J A m rt` o fD a G) m Z °a m 3 r m ED 3 m z a m 1J � � 1 A n m 3 A 'r o' v 'm c m n Y O N s r c J m rt Ma m m Ma X z r a X CL I N m M.. 1 �J o V n r a m Ma z r a m CL H rr �� r J) A m � 0 ° 3 c a r m 1 r v 3 0 „m 3 ° O O Z .r S m m m a ^ W m 3 r m z Z o m O m m O S y m � D c � n O Z 3 1 3 = m m O (/f o z v � n 130 -m.I O n O ° � v OVmf m z U) r, m S A m � n W = m „n z z c� S m a v 0=0 3 D r 3�m Lr)W;10 .Tn 000 M A z �rn m z0 A rn D H M Z Z m �nz � 27 0 = r N =m °o mrnw n -< v, zw m � D Ln 0 m < ��z Wpm ol p >z� p n 0 moo = z D m�z WWm - { N °o° _3 -I o Z H cn c 3 n m c 0 p N z O CD i p 0 11 rn pD Oprn o�� H M 'V A== 3 rn -D-i M O D r p r Om T W oLIO c� z 5 >9 'o (D 0 K 0 A M O 3 Z a 3 m G) m Z a m m 3 m r v, n Iv IC 7 I Imo: rt A J a v v X m cn W 1' Foul FA -11i 3 m z a m n r m z �n m X rm m< u n n m W �D o � �o A IM rt A s n M. O H 0 0 'O W � c a R S = O m m :OK 3D� 0 D m C) m A 0 H: rn mm;v (D Z -m1 Z 3 c p T 0 D O 9 a m 0 C 7 j l m ° r m � rn z 3 1 1 r z O fl rt m v 3 m D x 0�o �* m O m = 3 ° G) z T H ;ozm O z O 1 D Z o m m -IOo l} a ^ m W 1� W � m 3 mz�' J m Z �>(ni m 0 < O 0 m =<z m m mp m Ol p a v 0 pz� vv p n 0 OZ 3 W -� m,z S m come ry A 3 W -I >O I N °a oog K y X z 3�° v zH X D c z D m O � O 3 m -i v o o m p O X / ° re UD C 0 p_ -1 m (A or) A O 0Np m Z pzm to r moALn m C j D --I -I v _ m D m m m o, 1 n zoo o ma p r to z z p O m n m o p c� n m 0 c� W m c CL M to rt n r a m Ma z r a m CL H rr �� r J) A m � 0 ° 3 c a r m 1 r v 3 0 „m 3 ° O O Z .r S m m m a ^ W m 3 r m z Z o m O m m O S y m � D c � n O Z 3 1 3 = m m O (/f o z v � n 130 -m.I O n O ° � v OVmf m z U) r, m S A m � n W = m „n z z c� S m a v 0=0 3 D r 3�m Lr)W;10 .Tn 000 M A z �rn m z0 A rn D H M Z Z m �nz � 27 0 = r N =m °o mrnw n -< v, zw m � D Ln 0 m < ��z Wpm ol p >z� p n 0 moo = z D m�z WWm - { N °o° _3 -I o Z H cn c 3 n m c 0 p N z O CD i p 0 11 rn pD Oprn o�� H M 'V A== 3 rn -D-i M O D r p r Om T W oLIO c� z 5 >9 'o (D 0 K 0 A M O 3 Z a 3 m G) m Z a m m 3 m r v, n Iv IC 7 I Imo: rt A J a v v X m cn W 1' Foul FA -11i 3 m z a m n r m z �n m X rm m< u n n m W �D o � �o A IM rt A s n M. O H 0 0 'O W � c a V mm 0 3 V r m v O 3 O Z S m a W r m r m O T -I S m v N Z S m O a v 0 O 3 9 O X 0 2 m m C W m m N z Gf S m a v O C a X M 3 m m v 0 S M m m w w 3 N Z C m m In O X O c n O 3 3 m z a Z v a M O v v X m En O z S m n S N X HDO rr r m w 0Tn z 0 mz 0 70 Vm� Z m y A C) C) Z 'lC) z pzm D Z �ZO -1 O o 20o0 rnWW n�� m Z w G1 D Ln o z 03 x o N O O 56z-< °P° �o� z mC) z rn D o 00C:, 3 o Z r V1 c3z m Lf) 0 N O Z O p V Op pa a MO- O70rn PO rn ,0 nLn. O z m MGl� 3 rn W ZO p r �O O CD O cz z Ln s a m m � m Z m H 0 z w v m m K O 0 m m O v mm m n m 3 0 m e d tai ti 0 H 0 'v W c CL m m rt r a m Ma X z r a r CL lu lys C a m m w 3 m v O S X m w 3 N Z c m m T 0 0 c n O 3 3 m z a z v a X O a v v v 3DOr O F G NWx o n o rt mpz Am cn m 70 y x 'r G) C) , O zz m�z A z m �Dz �z 2 r N -1 O O 207 C) n�� mZw G7 pT D O z 2 � O U) 0 AzW ono >o� z rxn � z Wpm D o oz 83 390 r Ln c 3 z r-nrn0 Ln O N O z O O o, D rrl 01 OOm m 0 � A 0 ozr'rn Z rnG) cn D-1= _ m > m m r a °o nW 0 ul O U) 0 rt m �e 3 m m z � a m 3 H r� r m v v X m e 3 _ rn Z r m v m I- m =} n 3 r a fop E m � d � =. o H 0 w E H Ma C w a N� 1e Q J V Z 1� a LU U) W a d m 7 00 a 0 t Y 3 j CL �- 01 G H H U v 01 r u �z E 0 �v m U- m ° J � J Q H QOw m W W z W Ln 0 � LU � Q u N Q � CD O ~ Q N UJ W U) LU a 2: :D Ln -i J t v 0 O Z Umm C7 Z H � :3 Q 0vo m �0 ocnm W W W W > Q � � QQ d C7 r, rZ-i J in V <h m W C:) 0 o Z Q U Z W Z H o(w Q LU C7 } W (% W �0Z 0W0 �mU) ti J Q 0=0 M W W 2 H O H O W J LU w a 0 0 a W 2 C7 Z m W m U rml W co W W S H 0 d a O a O ca W H Z M a M W S F W O r6 LU J W J m H W S H Z O O LL in LU H W J a f O U W 5 a Mae V i � � d e W -i W ~ d a l� \ o � a _> d �zr F Z W it W W a LU i a Z �z E 0 �v m U- m ° J � J Q H QOw m W W z W Ln 0 � LU � Q u N Q � CD O ~ Q N UJ W U) LU a 2: :D Ln -i J t v 0 O Z Umm C7 Z H � :3 Q 0vo m �0 ocnm W W W W > Q � � QQ d C7 r, rZ-i J in V <h m W C:) 0 o Z Q U Z W Z H o(w Q LU C7 } W (% W �0Z 0W0 �mU) ti J Q 0=0 M W W 2 H O H O W J LU w a 0 0 a W 2 C7 Z m W m U rml W co W W S H 0 d a O a O ca W H Z M a M W S F W O r6 LU J W J m H W S H Z O O LL in LU H W J a f O U W 5 a Mae V nO=nO Z m m m 3 r~ D 3 m m n O �. rn e rn; a Z r 3 a 000 v v r m N m m M M,rn� -31 Vi v 3 mDO ? � \ 0 m �ZZ 3 G m�z z '� Azn \ Z 2 z z �. -%\ N S r -O x r N m aw m �Oo m W °w v W .W. n�� \. �p� r r W m Z. m m z DN 1 mrn � 0�3 < Y T1 X O m U) � �jj z �' S 'n O Tmm r.. '' m co D^ 0i 0 N m< v 0 Z0 Apro v s z X N _A 0 z 3 =zD G) 4 -1 3 M, z _ W W O DO �N X z °o .A_+ \ 11 fD ip a a p 0 � 6 ~ U2 a d � -�o s ^ o 3 noo 'o O a z -I o pON /r/te� �Y O p mo a' c 3 X O p rn O p vmi ch 2 O p z m m z m�� C 03 La m I m D co Ll S i3 r H m X 0 O Orn :r z G) m n L S a O zU _ O v rt O C a m rn w 3 m v O S X m w 3 w z C m m O 0 E n O 3 m m z a z v a X O a v v M m O z S m n S w X 3DO 3�M W zmn O mpz m �m� z O �np m G) G) D _z �zm D Z 0 x r ° N = 003 o mmW H W mL D o <z 2 0 03 Ln p Az� p r O io rn,z co m n m D N 0 O � p 3 o Z r Ln c�3�yD m 1 o N p N Z O pOv �D� m Opm Amy L0 p z m 3 m rn 0i zO� -I >r p r O OW ED nU) O z eD 'a A ID K ua ua 0 7 G V I O rt S Z M z a g 3 re m m � � w 'n m a° 3 -I cr m 'w m rn Ma X a ro R a u v v � � n a m un M m U3 a u f�D m �o e n 0 H S 0 s C c a A rt 000% /J� li Q J V Z a LU w W m `� INUE W Q D zz W Ul 7 J M I- LU LU r, 0 z W a V) M LU O Q W E Q z d s Y z �O coO J � Q Q Om W Q W f- �Ua U') U` W W Z CY H Ln D(n0 V W d Q U Ui N Q Z oDa WN W Q Z Ill J O CD ZZ D� Q Umm Z U cl, n Q O U 00 O 0 LU W m 0 w S z Q Q ce M Z J vi } U p m = CD 0 S Oaf U . d W a� a(D� L ZrZU Y cy, y wn C LLJ S o Z OOLO fym�W N O S O a vcnU Q 2 U W x J z O LLI Q O W w a 0 z Q F z W x FE O U 0 ce LL m W z uj M f M_ W x F- O H 0 W LU M J Q 7 O 0 ce W x C7 z N W m v W m W S F- Q ce a i O Q O CG W x H z M Q w D W x O t: J J co F W S F z O O: 0 0 W W J IL i v QW J CL 11 a V ao O. O Ly i O 3 R �U CL E 1 H � r c1 ^ C Aim W cn � � Q d t2 �u 000% /J� li Q J V Z a LU w W m `� INUE W Q D zz W Ul 7 J M I- LU LU r, 0 z W a V) M LU O Q W E Q z d s Y z �O coO J � Q Q Om W Q W f- �Ua U') U` W W Z CY H Ln D(n0 V W d Q U Ui N Q Z oDa WN W Q Z Ill J O CD ZZ D� Q Umm Z U cl, n Q O U 00 O 0 LU W m 0 w S z Q Q ce M Z J vi } U p m = CD 0 S Oaf U . d W a� a(D� L ZrZU Y cy, y wn C LLJ S o Z OOLO fym�W N O S O a vcnU Q 2 U W x J z O LLI Q O W w a 0 z Q F z W x FE O U 0 ce LL m W z uj M f M_ W x F- O H 0 W LU M J Q 7 O 0 ce W x C7 z N W m v W m W S F- Q ce a i O Q O CG W x H z M Q w D W x O t: J J co F W S F z O O: 0 0 W W J IL i v QW J CL 11 0 a X m M 3 m v O X m W 3 N Z mm m O X O c A O 3 3 m z a Z v a m O D v v X O z 2 M n 2 M X 3D0 0mno 0 m m z m� Z mDp H C) Z 0 z rnn �zz _< O x r N =Wo Y n ul m zw 10 L7 Ln D <z x o mmm 03Ln0 pzj ono 70 >�� z M 03 03 m DNo c0� 3 o z � N c 3 Z mrno to p 0 N 0 OP N Mo- n D ? xm XMO n(n vi c H 0 z m m G) L/) 3m-Di Z OO Dr -�5r U r O W OU) z C A A 0 to C 3 fD r O s N Z a 3 m a v v X m m 12A a m m Z °D m m 3 m 3 m z O °D M M n m 3 rt 7 10 m N U3 C d tib n of 0 0 H S O 9 W a Q rt OWN r a m ma X H r a r CL a) H N a fC� V rV 0=0 A D Gaf m 5 m D FS 3 D E 3FM 0 t'o 3 m m z n "' W a z r O 30 a 0T0 zOC ' � m v a M r m Arnz En 3 -I T � ''ww m m -mi m r 3 z r r V/ rn v ,n pDp 0 =+ O' m O A O 7o m v �ZZ Z 3 .P T1 3 O Azrn S r H O z D z Z S ? 2 �3< p x m m so, w W .. W .. rxn {v r m m z w r � D� am C m OZ C O In T + r m O m.4 v 2 m m X WNp 0, a °v u v < °c zz� ono ` a n -DI�� A rn z z 0 3 "z n = z m�Z W ? D N a m o z o� = A a a 3Oo ' a X 3 Z n v 0 O O A m mac Z .�. 3 3 O C Do r„ X z m O ;0 y X m pX o m o O O 0 z m n m < a w S � m A A m m 03 m O 1 n 2 z�r � 70 70 u�i 03 m mD+ 1.4 ,y O O m '0O ~ z -n { r C = m a � a �J X v X m 0 a X m M 3 m v O X m W 3 N Z mm m O X O c A O 3 3 m z a Z v a m O D v v X O z 2 M n 2 M X 3D0 0mno 0 m m z m� Z mDp H C) Z 0 z rnn �zz _< O x r N =Wo Y n ul m zw 10 L7 Ln D <z x o mmm 03Ln0 pzj ono 70 >�� z M 03 03 m DNo c0� 3 o z � N c 3 Z mrno to p 0 N 0 OP N Mo- n D ? xm XMO n(n vi c H 0 z m m G) L/) 3m-Di Z OO Dr -�5r U r O W OU) z C A A 0 to C 3 fD r O s N Z a 3 m a v v X m m 12A a m m Z °D m m 3 m 3 m z O °D M M n m 3 rt 7 10 m N U3 C d tib n of 0 0 H S O 9 W a Q rt OWN r a m ma X H r a r CL a) H N a fC�