Backup Docs 05/22/2012 (CR)Ga1qDe
IRON & METAL INC
C
3350 Metro Pkwy., Fort Myers, FL
6101 Shirley St., Naples, FL 921 S.E. 13th PI., Cape Coral, FL
Paper Products 2998 South St Ft M
k— www.
yers, FL
ROBERT WEBER, PRES.
(239) 337 -5865
ing.com J
s�
_.e
WASH NuWAOENImfri
May 16, 2012
Daniel Rodriguez, Director
Solid Waste Management Department
Collier County Public Utilities Division
3339 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 302
Naples, FL 34112
VJ E aE ►2 t i e m GO
6A `4
NAPLES LANDFILL
P.O. Box 990400
Naples, Florida 34116
(239) 455 -8062
(239) 455 -0853 Fax
Subject: Challenges Associated with Use of ASR as Cover at Naples (Collier County) Landfill
Dear Mr. Rodriguez,
Waste Management Inc. of Florida (WMIF) is providing this correspondence to present
operational challenges associated with the proposed use of Auto Shredder Residuals (ASR) as
cover.
(1) The current mulch: dirt cover preparation area is unlined, which precludes use of this
area for receipt, processing, or storage of ASR or ASR:dirt mix;
(2) A new lined area with similar protected and limited exposure would have to be built
to accommodate this material;
(3) There is no dirt savings, as ASR must also be mixed 50:50 with dirt;
(4) The ASR will displace mulch in the cover mixture with the following consequences:
(a) reduction in tipping fees received ($3 for ASR vs $33.70 for yard waste);
(b) reduction in landfill gas production (yard waste produces gas, ASR does not);
(5) The analyticals are highly variable, making this an undependable cover source;
(6) Adding any kind of fines to a landfill will represent a higher maintenance cost to the
leachate and gas collection systems. Generally, gas wells will silt -in earlier than
expected, leachate force mains and sumps will have to be jetted/vacuum more often,
and leachate /condensate pumps will see a shorter life. These potential early failures
could cause system shut downs that could trigger potential offshe landfill odors.
H
Mr. Dan Rodriguez
May 16, 2012
Page 2
X��
For the reasons stated above, WMIF proposes that ASR not be considered a viable alternate daily
cover material at the Naples Landfill.
Please contact me at (239) 776 -5565 if you have any questions or require additional
information.
Sincere
Waste
Fernan
Distric
Copies: Bryan Tindell, Director of Landfill Operations
Michele Lersch, Environmental Manager
00"''Poll
WWW. GSIMRECYCLING. COM -r
GARDEN STREET IRON &METAL, INC.
Opening in 1958, Garden Street has a long and established history of providing dependable and
environmentally friendly recycling services. As a long standing member of the community, Garden
Street has served Southwest Florida for over twenty years. Providing essential recycling services in a
manner benefiting our customers, community, and environment.
Since 1989, when Garden Street opened in Southwest Florida, it has paid a competitive price for
ferrous (iron and steel) and non - ferrous (copper and aluminum) metals.
Our 20+ acre state -of- the -art facility on Metro Parkway in Fort Myers is the largest, most
comprehensive recycling center in Southwest Florida.:
Beginning in the early 90's, Garden Street embarked upon a mission to concrete the entire site.
Working closely with Florida D.E.P. to achieve the best management of storm water while providing a
safe, clean environmentally, and customer friendly facility. X
t f1N iLPTAL INC.
'.
I
FEATURE 0
C.
e
In 2008, Garden Street completed its single largest expansion to date with the installation of
Southwest Florida's only automobile shredder. This 4600hp machine grinds complete scrap autos,
appliances, and steel into fist sized pieces at a rate of over 100 tons per hour. The shredded material
is then conveyed through an advanced technological separation system. Where magnets, screens,
eddy currents, and an ISS sorting system removes, sizes and separates the scrap to be recycled.
Today, Garden Street has three locations. Although we are the largest in Southwest Florida, we still
maintain our "family business" values and small business roots. While offering advanced services,
capacity and highly competitive prices of a 21 st century scrap metal recycling business.
* Y\ X X sue . C ,
r=,000-
r .;
", r
. X' .+
� � 1
y r '
SMMR
11M'�w°
OU
„7
W
v
■ ■ ■ t
e
WWW. GSIMRECYCLING. COM
t7p �L 7 7
MOH c o
1�i�J j J�1� JJ '1JG3
3350 Metro Parkway
-t Myers, Florida 33916
bA y
921 S.E. 13th Place
pe Coral, Florida 33990
�4 -
a
NON FERR�OIiS ]IMM T ERIALS
s. -,
I
,
m99@Z9UN 9
Following the 2005 Hurricane Season
�.�-: V.�, ..:iii► .
A.
14,
k", 10 W
�S a
lr
rn
o-
v
a,
('
m
s:a
- t�-oZcnX
Z
m
D
oZrn0D
Z
m,
m
o
1* i-A
�
=
3
cn
-rni
oam
o
-+
=0
lr
w
r
c
m
a)
r
m
Z
D
Z
0
m
T
U)
v
F
v
a,
('
m
s:a
Z
m
Z
m,
\
4
1
1* i-A
w
r
c
m
a)
r
m
Z
D
Z
0
m
T
U)
v
F
Good Morning. My name is Dick Lydon. I am the Vice Chair of the Vanderbilt Beach
MSTU. I am here to talk about Beach Access Signs.
In the past 25 years I have come before you on behalf of the many advisory committees
on which I have served as well as the community organizations I have had the honor to
chair. In almost all of those appearances I have been supportive of your affirmative
actions.
Today is a true 180 from the past!
In June of 2001 our MSTU was formed for "beautification and maintance of public areas
within our borders ". I have been a member of that committee since its inception.
After hiring Wilson - Miller to give us their ideas (we did not want to look like Ft. Myers
beach) and several resident meetings we set our present course to bury utility lines. That
project is underway, following which we have other ideas to further beautify our area.
On December 3, 2009 county staff appeared at our regular meeting and asked for
approval of signs to be placed at the entrance to our beach accesses. While agreeing that
marking was necessary, we felt that the signs looked more like the post for a street light
and were not compatible with any other signage on Gulfshore Drive. We asked them to
come back with a better designed and more modest sign for our approval.
Nothing further was presented to the committee by county staff until May 4, 2012 —30
months later! ! Staff appeared, not for us to approve anything but as a courtesy to tell us
that the same signs with numbers were going to be installed in accord with a "Settlement
Agreement" the BCC made with residents (none of whom have ever been a member of
the MSTU committee) relating to 3 not 8 beach accesses. We were not privy to the
details of this settlement until this meeting.
Efforts to negotiate have been fiuitless except for a 2 foot reduction in height! We have . r
found no signs as obtrusive and ugly on any street or beach in Collier County$ /64J
Our residents pay voluntary taxes of nearly a million dollars a year to beautify our
neighborhood. We strongly believe serious input on this and other beautification projects
by our committee is in order.
As I speak plans go forward to install these signs!
Please help usM
7;4
Id
2
C) 3DO 3 zm-i
3 r (p m
n v,� y Z r
O c r)Tn m
3 a �0 v
r m 70 S al
rn r- '� z O �; m iii
v 3 MDR
T 1 �� 0 C m
O m
X v
30 0 � n
z H
rn
z ADZ Z
m m =Ojo n
aW
� � W � N r
m M D ` i m
r z T.yLn
<
rn �m �,
Om cn = �( 1 r
In M
_ co � p
a
v � > z00 °v
n
70 m
A A
-zi 3 rn , z __0 n
m m 0c:M C 3
a
z OD No
0° > o z o rr m
3�0 .f
z 5r� CL
v v �D
(�
Om Ln M m �%
pN n
O v
.o z ° PI"
a 00
i un
D �p Z
M v M � _
m O . rn of
O
= O p
m z rnC)�
C
-< D -i
W M D o� _n 19th watrl
n z > I
-{ r
m p O O
z n W G
n-
_ 0 U) a
m
v r
r
a
n
m
n
3
r
m
--i
m
v
In
X
O
z
m
a
r
m
r
m
n
O
m
v
a
N
z
m
W
a
X
v
O
3
•v
O
2
m
C
V
m
m
z
G)
2
m
a
v
O
c
a
m
r
m
v
O
X
m
w
3
z
c
m
m
X
0
c
C)
3
m
z
--I
a
z
v
a
X
a
v
v
X
z
rG
2
m
n
a
0 =0 m a 0 m
3Dr ' 3 m m ^ ncnn
Z r m fD m N O� D Or
W 70 (D a r 3rrn
0 no =*. v m cr) mx
a c
~rn
3 -� p
700 -1 rn MAO
N rn
c� � ° 0 "' .v 3 70
Ln zD M�°
Ln
�zM C 1 H v __ c6)
�zz �� Z� 8o �z,r',,
2
-IOo
w m
m
n�W r �. rnW °w
fM z ' j rn w �n IZD 4c -Iq>
_C~-Iz r -4 o.3
In M
OH W O O m rn
ono ��
Dio° � n c °n°
Dc
2 G-) D n 0
rn_ n ��, > D =zD
p c 3 un c rn,z
70 Z o a (D m z Q C rn
n z
� cn
z�
p o V D °
ADS �� �, = 7 ) 2OVo
rn p, ro �' ' N
n p z rn D A
ono �, � op
�U`OC 0pm
rn eo
p z rn n m c
MAN ai "1 ��
-0 �zrn
= G� Un
C -I rn D
zpDD rnm-i
-�o0 0 O MoD
n� c� o0
W -n m
o� a. n-.<
� z
(D
12 1
(D
rt
V
fD
X
0
0
n
3 m
m z
v
a
m
�3
r
m
74
0
a
m
F
t.4
m
m
H
z
v
m
1 N
�• N
r
m
m
m
X
Z
I
2' n
R�
(D
rt
m
cD
(�D
Q
a�
Ln
13
(D
C
RL
C.
0)
(D
Vv
0
V
s
0
w �
a
CD
m
�
a
m
^i
r
1
u
2' n
R�
(D
rt
m
cD
(�D
Q
a�
Ln
13
(D
C
RL
C.
0)
(D
Vv
0
V
s
0
w �
a
CD
m
fD
U)
fD
rt
U2
fD
0
(D
O
S
(D
n
a 0
3 m
m z
v
n
-�i
3
r
m
74
F
m
m
z
G)
v
m
�J
IG
v
� J
n
cli { m
3
fD
rD = (D
cD,
t ua
-C
'm
U
o
0
.0
w
m
a
m
Ma
X
H
Z
r
m
a
X
u
a
m
� V
CD �
d
Z
1$
i
V
0 =0
:Dr
fDD
-a
a
m
/'�
;
0 =0
[1
n
3��
�
3
m
rn
rr
n
O
.n co
cD
D
Z
r
)
U'aom
3
C
000
='�
1.4
m
C
C4 rT,
OT'O
�°
m
rn
rn ;z
U)rn�
�
'1�3
m
D
m
a
a
z�c
�m
M
•�
m
D
3
70
rte-
m
j 3
�D0
.n
O
G)p
0m
H
rn0°
m
v
Ln
z
n
O
-�-lG) D
O
O
m ~n
�zrn
r,,Hz
n
n �zr
Z
-�
�zz
►
Z
-�
�zz
m
m
- loo
ED CD
r
%3
m
m
-loo
=mCD
a
w
rn W w
A
[ 1
I �-.
w
rn vo w
n-<<„
m
3
7m�D
�
m
-
3
MC),
z
Dm �
/`J
a
Z
D
77Dc
1
<
0n
0�
O
O
rn�o
_
j
=�z
mjp
Qom' °
^
O.�
I 0
Co Ln 0
,.0
c
°��
X
°moo
Z
n
3
-Dio°
n
-I
3
=ZD
m, z
n
3
MP
m
m
v000�
O
r,1
co
3
m
mmC)
w
O
...I
NO
;o C)
°o-�
w
S
/+
fD
Lo
mq
cn
> -{ N
oz °o
a
o
a
z
3�o
At
°o
v
a
��z
O
O
m
-cl�z
rn -I °
cn MN
cD
S
;�
a
7o
m
-�
rn°
O
z-lCD
3
~
n,
p
M
x
a
pON
rt
a
z-°lo°
°oV
O
X
0
rnD�rP
n
v
v
rnDNP
°,
-I
m
070 rn
X
0°7u
O
(A
p M '0
L
d
m
m PO
m
z
Z
�_
°zrn
w
V
O
to Ln
°Zrn
rn
n
m cn
m
m
3rn�
n
rn >
3 co
n
n
=
z p D
�>�
0
m
m
rn 0 D
ado
�
z
n-
o�
<
m
��
9
W
0U)
a
z cn
a
fD.
z
v
m
fD
U)
fD
rt
U2
fD
0
(D
O
S
(D
n
a 0
3 m
m z
v
n
-�i
3
r
m
74
F
m
m
z
G)
v
m
�J
IG
v
� J
n
cli { m
3
fD
rD = (D
cD,
t ua
-C
'm
U
o
0
.0
w
m
a
m
Ma
X
H
Z
r
m
a
X
u
a
m
� V
CD �
d
Z
1$
0 U) m z a 3
n D I 3 m m
3 r n
n O0 �c0X m m A z O
o c 0 T n ! v lit a
m Mrnz0 `� rt 3 -�i m
m (n M :� -o m V) r
m XQO (° ( rn 3
'n ~I G) G) o m m
O m zz 3 v
v M"z 7 o
3 �zrn H
z = z p _
N
m = r N m
-< .
...� m = 0 o .-.
�. rnWw 1 A W
r rnzW r r3i
r' N VDU z
c
m c�
0 m O < M
Om =�z r
n ° _< X ,� m 0
° o ono c
O
z
m�z o \.: m
m m 0C:M N 3 � -z-I
W -i N Ln (D /* (A
CD fD O 70 z CD G� l V a
z3 °0 z
Ln rn °
o n � 3 z ` �i X
O m rn rn rQ M 0 m
3 -I `n o � n ~ '� O
w O z-I° .� fD
N > 0 p O v p
N
v >
x a c v
rn c� �, ' X
0 � � rt
;0
m Z 0zM Cy z n r
pro = 3 rn � ((D (A -� 2
m
n m M O D N O n
.� f7 z0r H. 2
_ -I x r A+ w X
m om-+ 00 1 70
z X OT m rt o 'a
N Oo
-<
m
U) N a.
X
p ry
O D O a m T ^m /1
3
M � m� 0 Z r
M n 5 fD ITI
T rt
O�O � rn D
70 M z �° 3 m
�0 rn
O _r
�
Co c rn
( J) Z 4
-�Iz
Z
rn �r
�zz
= r N
=W °o
M CO W r
C-) �CI y
M C) R1
�
O < rn
i-
M
co o a u
Ol v
�z� v
-I z z
M
au n �
3
ONO c(D
�zo _r
3 ° o c
'- r LrI
/\
z -' D .-
Mrn� ?
z -j � P'f
M D A
0 M
m ,O
o Ln �
z M
M �.
3rn�
M O D
-� � r
r0 ..
0
O W -�
O - fl.
to
m
rt
n
0 =0
n 3D�
m 3 !- rn
n` 0 LO Wn
M
�,
X O0O
r �rn
m
m �rn:�
m z
v 3 rn D
m �Go
O m v,zz
3 rnHz
O O z rn
Z -I �zz
<
m m -I O o
00 O
a
0 1-.
w rn co W
m 3 rnzw
c�
r Z nD D
-4 m 0<rn
0
m M
_ Lo
m Q
p 0 �z-<
D C r
r)
O
-I 3 rn�z
= m 0 n
pp "� OD
O °o
x z z 6
v z Ln
X a C A D
00 m Arno
M N
O > --1 C)
a off'
1-1 N
X x r)
rn
O
m ;a MCD
= O
m Z o z rn
r -v
-< D -I
-�{m>
n m rn0>
m m 0
H
Z X -n m
C) (>
m O
y z
X
v
�a
fD
o'
(DD
G
�1
z a
3 m
m z
v
a
�
3
r
m
J a
v
rn
V)
F
rt
a
z
P
�
I
ZO
w
S
m Ow1
m MO
r
v m
m (�
rn
H
N Z
c
X
r
M
3
m
v
O
X
m
m
.-.
w
3
z
C
m
V)
m
c
n
3
m
z
a
z
v
a
X
m
O
a
v
v
m
z
2
m
n
2
H
C) cn n
O =D O
3rF�
Lf)� rn
0Wo
z O C
rn�az
rn
rn
z 0
70 G)0
rn D
z z
� G) D
_z
�zrn
z
D
0
rj
=moo
m LW
�Ln
M
U)
D
O0 �rn
z
rn
W U rn
0
�
z�
0�0
moo
rn z
m W n
Oho
o O -A CD
3 j o
r
D
(n m
z -I o N
� 0 V
70 D A
rn
O . rn
mCD
z rn
M C)
3rn�
rn D
O
p r
O
O m
OU)
zLr)
G
X
cD
-a
0
cD
rt
0
z a
3 m
m z
a
3
rn
�
ra
G
C'
1
a
v
v
m
Ni
1
O
rt
S
fD
I
C
m
r
v R'1
-a-I
rn
rn
Z
n
r
rn
a
n
cD
3
fD
rt
tC
.a
fD
tQ
n
0
-t
S
O
v
W
a
cQ
r+
a
LO
m
CL
m
3
J
m
0
0
r
r
�
rn
a
z
X
Z
`�
l
�n
�n
(
"I ID
cQ
rt
m
U2
.�
'a fD
fD
�
v
Z
o
W
S
O
m
Q
La
fmp
c
X
r
M
3
m
v
O
X
m
m
.-.
w
3
z
C
m
V)
m
c
n
3
m
z
a
z
v
a
X
m
O
a
v
v
m
z
2
m
n
2
H
C) cn n
O =D O
3rF�
Lf)� rn
0Wo
z O C
rn�az
rn
rn
z 0
70 G)0
rn D
z z
� G) D
_z
�zrn
z
D
0
rj
=moo
m LW
�Ln
M
U)
D
O0 �rn
z
rn
W U rn
0
�
z�
0�0
moo
rn z
m W n
Oho
o O -A CD
3 j o
r
D
(n m
z -I o N
� 0 V
70 D A
rn
O . rn
mCD
z rn
M C)
3rn�
rn D
O
p r
O
O m
OU)
zLr)
G
X
cD
-a
0
cD
rt
0
z a
3 m
m z
a
3
rn
�
ra
G
C'
1
a
v
v
m
Ni
1
O
rt
S
fD
I
C
m
r
v R'1
-a-I
rn
rn
Z
n
r
rn
a
n
cD
3
fD
rt
tC
.a
fD
tQ
n
0
-t
S
O
v
W
a
cQ
r+
a
LO
m
CL
m
3
J
m
0
0
C Pt
Good Morning Commissioners,
red = overhead document
For the record, my name is John Barlow, former vice president of the non - profit
HOME.
On May 9, I finally received the Clerk of Courts audit of HOME....
Why am I here and what do I expect to achieve ?`
I am here because I have no other recourse.
I think it is important for you to be aware of the administrative nightmare this
has become. I have in excess of 100 hours of my time for this audit.
A lot of hours were spent to produce an audit that makes unsubstantiated
allegations.
Although I am the founder of H.O.M.E, I did not have any input into the draft
audit. I find that difficult to accept since I have access to all H.O.M.E.'s records.
The audit fails to clearly identify who is responsible for the stated deficiencies. Is it
H.O.M.E or Housing, both and /or some of each?
(Hold up the audit) This audit by the Clerk of Courts is unacceptable and
disappointing.
Let me tell you why.
On December 7, 2011- I received an e -mail from the clerk's auditor indicating
"everything appears in order. You will be hearing from me soon" L•
— 154 days later is SOON?
41. This audit alleges: Unable to fully reconcile program generated income.
The facts are:
7
The grant was closed out June 5`h, 2010. Housing declared there was "no Program 13
Income generated."
On July 22, 2011 Grant Compliance Office verified there was no program income.
1
Pres, nted by
The Clerk requested ALL invoices for H.O.M.E. rehab and other operating items.
Not just invoices that pertained to grant funds, they wanted access to ALL invoices.
H.O.M.E. questioned the clerk's authority to review private, internal documents for
the non - profit. We waited but never received a response. Nevertheless, H.O.M.E.
provided all requested documents. It totaled over 700 pages.
#2 This audit alleges: Ineligible program expenditures noted.
The facts are:
All eligible /ineligible expenses were provided during the June, 2010 Grant close-
out procedure.
#3 This audit alleges: Unable to validate the distribution of final assets which was �
accepted by Housing and subsequently deposited. jk'j
The facts are:
HOME provided a Balance sheet along with a check (dated 6/9/2010) for all
remaining assets. The amount of the check was $644.37!
#4 This audit alleges: Grant close -out procedures did not include coordination of
deed restriction transfers to the county; liens recorded for properties by H.O.M.E.
to Collier County without the prior knowledge of Housing staff. * 6
The facts are:
This statement in the audit is false. HOME was an active company when the Grant
close out procedures took place.
In April/May 2010, HOME discussed with Housing proper procedure if a home
purchaser defaulted on the subsidy "deed restriction ".
In October 2010, H.O.M.E. notified its lawyer to file for dissolution
In October 20101 HOME notified Housing. County Attorney's office started
drafting mortgage transfer documents.
2
7
In December 2010, H.O.M.E. was dissolved.
I received a copy of January 6, 2011 e -mail indicating the mortgages were being
pulled from the BCC Agenda, for what reason(s) I do not know.
CDBG grant procedures and H.O.M.E. legal documents require H.O.M.E to
transfer the mortgages to the County.
HOME waited 3 months from December 2010 to March 17, 2011 for the BCC to
approve the mortgage transfer.
After consulting with Counsel; I recorded the mortgages to ensure the County
received any recaptured Grant funds.
indicate a lack of proper
#S This audit alleges: The audit observations p p
documentation, process coordination and compliance with the requirements of
the grants. The facts are:
HOME received tremendous oversight and guidance from Housing staff during the
life of this project. With their help, we documented, coordinated and complied with
ALL requirements of the grant. At no time did HOME take any action without
Housing's knowledge.
On May 16, 2012, I made a Public Records Request for the audit work papers. I'm
keenly interested in reviewing them.
#6, This audit alleges: From the records maintained, it is difficult to determine the
use of funds, consequently, grant funds could have been used and then replaced
with donations, which would constitute a violation of the grant award and
contract.
Come on now:
"Could have" ?? Either they WERE or they WERE NOT "Could have" is not a
valid audit concept!
K
And finally, #7 This audit states: It is relevant for the reader to note this program
was a one -time endeavor and an unusual one. It is highly unlikely we would
undertake such a program in the future, especially one that involves private
contributions to the project.
The facts are:
Whoever made this audit comment apparently wants to abandon private leadership
and funding for the public good of Collier County just because the County cannot
establish proper accounting protocols and adapt to an innovative program. DO WE
BELIEVE IN CONTINOUS IMPROVEMENT OR NOT? The BCC is responsible
for approval or denial of grant programs. I hope Collier County welcomes private/
public partnerships in the future.
The Clerk of Courts writes in the 2011 CAFR Report:
"The concept of reasonable assurance recognizes that the cost of a control shouldr
not exceed the benefits to be derived, and the evaluation of costs and benefits
requires estimates and judgments of management."
I do not think the H.O.M.E. audit by the Clerk of Courts resulted in a proper
relationship between audit cost and benefits derived?
Having been a CEO of several major corporations, I have participated in many
annual audits. In fact, I always looked forward to a review of internal controls,
process execution and suggested recommendations.
Audits should provide actionable items to r I
1- Improve processes
2- Identify costs associated with poor internal controls and execution.
3. Recover misused public funds.
I find this HOME audit by the Clerk of Courts Finance and Internal Audit team
disappointing and unacceptable. This audit contains highly subjective andC�
irrelevant statements, lacks precision, accuracy and relevance.
I expected better.
Ell
Why am I here.? 7
1- No other recourse
2 Administration nightmare ....
(death by paperwork)
3- Why? How many hours spent
to produce an audit that makes
unsubstantiated allegations?
Founder of H.O.M.E. had no
input into the draft audit.
5 -Audit fails to identify who is at
fault for alleged deficiencies.
1
»M
Dec. 7, 2011
E -mail from clerk's auditors,
154 Days Later
7
Audit alleges:
The facts:
6 -5 -10: Grant closed out with
NO PROGRAM INCOME
7- 22 -11: Grant Compliaince
spreadsheet verifies NO
PROGRAM INCOME
700 pages provided of non - public,
internal- funded paid invoices
C
r,
Audit alleges:
The facts:
All eligible expenses
were recognized
during Grant close out
4
r.
7
Audit alleges.,
The facts:
HHVS DID have Balance Sheet
and Income Statement AND
accepted check for final asset
distribution.
The check was for
$644.37
wait allege
Grant close -out procedures did
not include coordination of deed
restriction transfers to the
county; liens recorded for
properties by H.O.M.E. to Collie
County without the prior
knowledge of HHVS staff.
e T
It's 004MIM WI&
Audit alleges:
The facts:
Housing provided TREMENDOUS
oversight and guidance.
ALL requirements of the
rant were fulfilled.
7
Audit alleges:
G
The facts:
"Could Have" is NOT a valid
audit concept and has no
place in a professional report.
M
Audit alleges:
7
The facts:
Why shy away from private leadership and
private funding because Collier County
cannot adapt or accommodate innovative
concepts and unique new programs.
Embrace Continuous
Improvement or Not.?
9
7
"The concept of reasonable
assurance recognizes that the
cost of a control should not
exceed the benefits to be
derived, and the evaluation
of costs and benefits requires
estimates and judgments of
management."
10
Audits should provide
actionable items to
1- improve processes
2- identify costs
associated with poor
internal controls and
execution.
11
6
7
This
Audit
is
Unacceptable
)A-eg- We-a-j- i -r rn
5 l -L-L ( l -I-
Tourist Development Council
�>6 9B
As of May 22, 2012 Term Expiry Date Category Dist.
Commissioner Tom Henning
1/8/2013
Board of County Commissioners
3
Mayor John F. Sorey
4/21/2016
City of Naples
4
Councilman McBeth Collins
4/21/2016
Everglades City
5
Mr. Clark Wakefield Hill
4/21/2015
Owner /Operator
2
Mr. Edward R. Olesky
4/21/2014
Owner /Operator
5
Mr. Rick Medwedeff
5/22/2012
Owner /Operator
1
Mr. Robert A. Miller
4/21/2015
Non - owner /Operator
2
Ms. Susan Becker
4/21/2014
Non - owner /Operator
4
Mr. Murray H. Hendel
4/21/2016
Non - owner /Operator
4
New Ordinance I Term Expiry Date I Category I Dist.
Commissioner Tom Henning
1/8/2013
Board of County Commissioners
3
Mayor John F. Sorey
4/21/2016
City of Naples
4
Councilor
City of Marco Island
Everglades City Nominee
Owner /Operator
Mr. Clark Wakefield Hill
4/21/2015
Owner /Operator
2
Mr. Edward R. Olesky
4/21/2014
Owner /Operator /otherwise qualified
5
Mr. Robert A. Miller
4/21/2015
Owner /Operator /otherwise qualified
2
Ms. Susan Becker
4/21/2014
Non - owner /Operator
4
Mr. Murray H. Hendel
4/21/2016
Non - owner /Operator
4
9B ii 'I
Section 125.0104 (4)(e), Fla. Stat.
The governing board of each county which levies and imposes a tourist development tax
under this section shall appoint an advisory council to be known as the " (name of county)
Tourist Development Council." The council shall be established by ordinance and composed of
nine members who shall be appointed by the governing board. The chair of the governing board
of the county or any other member of the governing board as designated by the chair shall serve
on the council. Two members of the council shall be elected municipal officials, at least one of
whom shall be from the most populous municipality in the county or subcounty special taxing
district in which the tax is levied. Six members of the council shall be persons who are involved
in the tourist industry and who have demonstrated an interest in tourist development, of which
members, not less than three nor more than four shall be owners or operators of motels, hotels,
recreational vehicle parks, or other tourist accommodations in the county and subject to the tax.
All members of the council shall be electors of the county. The governing board of the county
shall have the option of designating the chair of the council or allowing the council to elect a
chair. The chair shall be appointed or elected annually and may be reelected or reappointed. The
members of the council shall serve for staggered terms of 4 years. The terms of office of the
original members shall be prescribed in the resolution required under paragraph (b). The council
shall meet at least once each quarter and, from time to time, shall make recommendations to the
county governing board for the effective operation of the special projects or for uses of the
tourist development tax revenue and perform such other duties as may be prescribed by county
ordinance or resolution. The council shall continuously review expenditures of revenues from the
tourist development trust fund and shall receive, at least quarterly, expenditure reports from the
county governing board or its designee. Expenditures which the council believes to be
unauthorized shall be reported to the county governing board and the Department of Revenue.
The governing board and the department shall review the findings of the council and take
appropriate administrative or judicial action to ensure compliance with this section. The changes
in the composition of the membership of the tourist development council mandated by chapter
86 -4, Laws of Florida, and this act shall not cause the interruption of the current term of any
person who is a member of a council on October 1, 1996.
0=r) Z a 3 U) C')
=O ( a c�
n 3D� 3 m m
m 3 �, (D m Z N j r
can p v I
0 O mn a Z r W
m m � M z 3 ' M z
M> rt r I rn °
O -4
3 p - -j ((D I �C,)D
O O m �zm
Z -i �zz �~ zz
o
-q � _�� � Z Le
m m f N _ 0 O
m O o
a •. rn 'D° ( Ti
Ov w n cn N Ln
m 3 m Z w z w
m z �D� iiiD�
-ml �<rn
O -I<z ��z
Om rn m° r rn m
..< °
_ X 0 Lo ° a
p < >z� v ` z�
Fri (7 —Dips O (m
Z 3 =ZD
G) ems, n M, z
_ (3t7 Oo 00 (� P% > 0 W m
w -Z1 DO-CIo (3D > o
a0 cn ;a CD rD ✓' zo
a °0� v �3�0
X Z 3 -I o Lam. to ,� cn Lrl a c3D O C 'G �z
3 ..' (1] O N (fD u N
m O z-lo pl• z�°
a °o" (� °0
v �D� 'o O� �D�
n070 n°p;o
Q (A x M ?O � m �
2 O °
Lr) 70 'n �► ° cn .�
zm
�crnn n
m Z M MG�cn
03 2 = rn > I � W �
M z 0 D 0 0 D
D ° ,
Z 0W m
-n
�
G1 n L 00 U)
m O
a zU) a z`J'
v
e-r
0
.3 m
m
Z
� a
rr �
� m
� � 3
(D
0 r
o r^
fD
a
v
v
X
m
O �
rt �
M
3gm
m
-i m
rm
v rn
a
m
rn
N
N
^
n
(D
(3D
(D
rt
7'
m
'G
fD
u
cD
=i
u
(D
a'
O
s
0
10
a
cD
rt
m
X
H
Z
n
r
rn
X
m
CL
0)
r+
m
M�
MI
( r
J
a
W
J
U
H
z
w
a
W
a
W
J
a
g
C1
-a
m
Uz
U) O
U
CL
O
m p
�
O
Q m w
°
R
_R
7
Q)
a
H
G7
dl
O
U
1
1�
W
a
0
(D
Z
I--
W
W
►
2
U
W
H
J
z
0
V)
W
W
0
0
a
O
W
a
0
Z
a
Z
W
i
U
0
0
W
H
z
M
W
W
�c
H
0
W
H
H
J
W
Q
O
C1
V
m
CL
O
s
(. Y
O
I �
�U
a
4J
/H
■V
Q
�1
J
J
V
Z
a
W
V)
44
LU
J
CL
`OO
L C
d7
� N
d7
CL
P -2
Im
� d
L
N
W
Q
D
c�
z
H
I-'
W
W
►E3
1
M
,S
s
V
O
W
O
a
s
O
� Gl
C
W O
J +Lj
J
�~- a
01
F/ C
H �+
CA
z W i
U CL
Q z W
9 B
0
OC
Z a
W
Ln O =
} U ('
m 0 N H
O = m
ry
t-
Q m w W W
LU l- �_. CO
~ ~ L J
w z
w Z W
C) =
� L) 0 (n ~
Ce LLJ C2 V) p
0 0 LU ~O
UJ
NQ LLJ O O
O
C)oQ f
LU w W O
c? Z o�c
� O p Q Q
C:) cn O
m
U m m W W
Q (D Z
Z I- O
p ° U
0O U p
O
� O
m �0 W ce
LU H m LU 0 F
°~= o
�-
H
H u.
Q O Z W
(n Q `-� z J
azw i LU
L } U M Q
M m w u
C) O I- W W
�- = F-
zOQ� F- Z
O
QUA D Ce
z z H W
0 (D W O LL
��� i O uj
?
LU cn J W
cl� I � W
w oz Q J
O ,L O M O
Q) m� O U
LLJ
LLJ
H
J J U
0 d Lo u
Qwf-
� Q
�
z W
W
°
U)
:D cn p
U-J 0 0
O
U
N Q ct�
0
L
C) Q Q
W
N w W
s
° F--
D
O
Q
Lr) J
,t0C)
oz°
m m
U
W
Q U =
J
Z z F--
H
°
Q
H
� 9
�.
OU°
W
>- Z 0-'
°° "
O
a „a
�wm
LU
Z
ti
z H
w >
W
H
U ro'p
U) Q Y
Q Z W
�w
L }U
M
m w
O m =
C:) 0
aQ6 z
p z
LU
U W
Cl
QUA
o
(DU
o U
-r,
w
U
O
a
we
�
w
z w
I
o z
ULUO
a
Ln
Z
W
LU J
W
a
J Q
OU
Q
Z ce
0 U)
2
U
W
H
J
z
0
V)
W
W
0
0
a
O
W
a
0
Z
a
Z
W
i
U
0
0
W
H
z
M
W
W
�c
H
0
W
H
H
J
W
Q
O
C1
V
m
CL
O
s
(. Y
O
I �
�U
a
4J
/H
■V
Q
�1
J
J
V
Z
a
W
V)
44
LU
J
CL
`OO
L C
d7
� N
d7
CL
P -2
Im
� d
L
N
W
Q
D
c�
z
H
I-'
W
W
►E3
1
M
,S
s
V
O
W
O
a
s
O
� Gl
C
W O
J +Lj
J
�~- a
01
F/ C
H �+
CA
z W i
U CL
Q z W
9 B
0
OC
Z a
W
Ln O =
} U ('
m 0 N H
O = m
ry
t-
Q m w W W
LU l- �_. CO
~ ~ L J
w z
w Z W
C) =
� L) 0 (n ~
Ce LLJ C2 V) p
0 0 LU ~O
UJ
NQ LLJ O O
O
C)oQ f
LU w W O
c? Z o�c
� O p Q Q
C:) cn O
m
U m m W W
Q (D Z
Z I- O
p ° U
0O U p
O
� O
m �0 W ce
LU H m LU 0 F
°~= o
�-
H
H u.
Q O Z W
(n Q `-� z J
azw i LU
L } U M Q
M m w u
C) O I- W W
�- = F-
zOQ� F- Z
O
QUA D Ce
z z H W
0 (D W O LL
��� i O uj
?
LU cn J W
cl� I � W
w oz Q J
O ,L O M O
Q) m� O U
LLJ
LLJ
H
J J U
0 d Lo u
I
M
.a
cD
rt
U3
O
0
(
FE
S
z
a
m
m
z
v
-i
m
r"
m
m
m
z
G)
v
i
m
N
0
r
r
m
a
m
Ma
X
H
Z
m
X
a
CL
a)
CD
rt
M
3 D 0
;a
z
a
a
3
^
O nc O n
_n
A
m
r r
3rrn
M
3
m
m
C
m
3 D r
A
p
C
U) m
fD
a
z
'"•
�
! 70
3
a
OOp
z c
='
-4
m
v
m
c
OmO
O
r-
m
�rn
3
-q
m
��w
X
rnrnz
m
v
3
p
rt
z
r�
�
mDp
rt
C
m
m
3
GAO
m
X
v
� Gz� D
m
V)
3
m�z
..
v
--q G)
O
O
�Dm
�"�
p
�zrn
'�
2
jZO
2z�O
m
m
==W r°ry
m
Oo
a ..�
011%
o
rnoow
-_ I
=°o °w
.Wi
� z W
1\�
Z,
n< n
r w
m
Z
�D�
(��
H
Z
�DcDn
-cl
0�3
l
c
�qD
O 3
O
-n
m z
m
rn�u
/�
r
m<
cn
m
=-IZ
=
O
aocmnmp
\j
p
mmmm
m
OD^oo
�.
\./
X
pz�
v
o
v
-c
50
a
�y
n
Dc�
m
c
Dc�
Z
3
'-
1
3
=� D
rn- z
n
fD
3
3
= z D
rn G) z
z
0�m
3
0Cm
w
O
�zC)
rt
z
DAN
o
X
z
:K
v
v
C)
z�D
tC
-I
Z
v
3�0
Zr-�
X
a
-Ci�z
°
-tea
I��
iY
a
D
C�z
O
ran
�rn�
:�
HI
m
m
cn
3
-I
o
D o
o
(
O
D No
o
X
a
o) V
C) N
)
a
O
O
v
MUD
rnp'A
-i
m
0 m
fli
v
0O�rn
O
m
70
o L `_C
1�
V�
V)
rn �O
2
O
�' �
ozrn
-a
n
°
cn
O
o � '_'
�,
�zrn
,
�
DG)�
m
=
m
3 WD
_
-4 mDI
m -
A
A
_
m p D
zD�
O
m
A
rn
zO r-
D
m
op
c
D
r
oO
Z
OTm
'O
003
-n v�
=
O cn
z�
3
�.
O c~n
cLO
n
X
m
M
.a
cD
rt
U3
O
0
(
FE
S
z
a
m
m
z
v
-i
m
r"
m
m
m
z
G)
v
i
m
N
0
r
r
m
a
m
Ma
X
H
Z
m
X
a
CL
a)
CD
rt
M
e .
i�
f
J
N
Q
W\
a
a
W
V
Z
H
a
W
a
W
J
a
`�
3
m
N
R
U
d
a
L
G1
a
C1
C
U
M']
W
a
D
c�
Z
i—i
W
W
9
W
J
H
H
W
a
D
Z
W
a
I
LA
Ln
W
D
D
a
d
s
L1-•i
c
�a
} a
c
W �
L
a
Z Q�
Lr)z
�O
M LL
m p
0 C)
Q m W
awe
WW
z
� Lr) Lf)
Duo
O' wU a'
� Q O
N Q �
O O Q
N 0 U')
LLJ
H
Q��
4 O
O z
LLJ O
U m m
z � I=-
a
O U D
CO �O
Lr) on
LU
� I 2
w
Q
Q ¢ Q
�
LLJ
u� y U
M CO w
°0 0
rq O Q
uz�
Q��
4
o <
� Q w
�
w
zLuw
�pz
0W0
�CO
U)
LLI
H
J Q
O O
H
Q
_
U
W
Z
W
OC
0
Q
O
W
a
Z
Z
W
U
n
O
0
LA
W
H
Z
N
M
W
W
_
H
O
H
D
W
N
H
J
W
a
0
0
a
W
_
Z
M
W
m
H
U
W
rn
m
W
H
O
O
a
O
w
Q
m
W
_
Z
M
a
D
W
_
N
LL
O
H
LL
W
J
W
J
00
9
W
_
H
Z
O
0
0
W
H
W
J
a
O
U
W
U
Q
J
CL
t0A
I �1 a(y� 10 E':' S/ Z -Z-1 I -Z_ ..rwwl 0
l N M t 1 c E-! e �- �-
v^ yY
Collier Countv Government •f` °F'
Communication & Customer Relations
3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 102 collieraov.net
Naples, FL 34112 -5746 twitter.com /CollierPIO
facebook.com /CollierGov
youtube.com /CollierGov
May 17, 2012
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
The Collier County Board of Commissioners is seeking applications for positions on several advisory
committees.
The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee currently has 2 vacancies for full members and 1
vacancy for an alternate. It is required that one of the applicants should reside in Immokalee. This is
an 11 member committee created by Ordinance No.91 -65, as amended, to monitor the implementation
of the Affordable Housing Task Force's recommendations, and the goals, objectives, and policies of
the Housing Elements of the County's Growth Management Plan and the City's Comprehensive Plan.
The committee also determines the effect of proposed ordinances of affordable housing, and makes
recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners and the Naples City Council; and
investigates any other relevant areas so directed by the Board of County Commissioners. The Board of
County Commissioners will appoint 9 members, including the alternate member. The City of Naples
will appoint 2 members. Terms are 3 years.
The Animal Services Advisory Board has 1 vacancy for a term that will expire April 13, 2016, in the
category Veterinarian or Vet Tech. This is a seven - member board that was created on January 27,
2004, by Ordinance No. 2004 -06, to make recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners
on programs, services, classes and special events that will further assist Collier County Domestic
Animal Services in providing the best possible service to the community. The board will also analyze
and review construction and improvements to Domestic Animal Services' facilities, and make
recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners regarding such.
The Bayshore /Gateway Triangle Local Redevelopment Advisory Board has 1 vacancy for a new
term that will expire on May 22, 2015, in the category Davis Boulevard Business Owner. The
Advisory Board was created by Resolution 2001 -98 on March 27, 2001 to review the Redevelopment
Plan, to make recommendations to the Community Redevelopment Agency, to receive input from
members of the public interested in their respective component areas and to report such information to
the Community Redevelopment Agency. Resumes will be accepted from all interested parties,
including Bayshore residents, Gateway Triangle residents, Bayshore business owners, Tamiami Trail
(US41) business owners, Davis Boulevard (SR84) business owners, Bayshore MSTU representatives,
and at large representatives who reside or engage in business or both in the Bayshore /Gateway
Triangle Component Redevelopment Area. A person who "engages in business" means an individual
owning real property or a business, practicing a profession or performing a service for compensation or
serving as an officer or director of a corporation or other business entity so engaged. Consideration
will be given to appointing members that have experience in the following professions: finance,
banking, architecture, engineering, education, law enforcement, social work, real estate sales and
development, planning or design and building construction. Terms are 3 years.
The Coun ty Government Productivity Committee has 2 vacancies with the terms expiring on 1 O E
February 4, 2013 and February 4, 2014. This committee is composed of 11 members, with the vice
chair of the Board of County Commissioners serving in a liaison capacity. The members are appointed
by resolution of the Board of County Commissioners for a two -year term and must be permanent
residents and electors of Collier County. Committee members are required to possess special expertise
and experience related to managing large organizations, and must be balanced in representing the
views of the community. The committee reviews the efficiency of departments of County Government
under the jurisdiction of the Board of County Commissioners. The committee may analyze and review
existing structure, organization, staffing, management, functions, business practices, and procedures of
any or all parts of county government and make recommendations for increased efficiency and cost -
effectiveness. The committee may also assist in the implementation of those recommendations.
The Development Services Advisory Committee has 1 vacancy for a term expiring on December 14,
2013, representing trade contractors. This committee is composed of 15 members and represents the
various aspects of the development industry such as architect, general contractor, residential or builder
contractor, environmentalist, land planner, land developer, landscape architect, professional engineer,
utility contractor, plumbing contractor, electrical contractor, structural engineer, and attorney. The
purpose of this committee is to provide reports and recommendations to the Board of County
Commissioners to assist in the enhancement of operational efficiency and budgetary accountability
within the Growth Management Division and to serve as a primary communication link between the
Growth Management Division, the development industry and the citizens of Collier County.
The Board of Building Adjustments and Appeals has 2 terms expiring on August 9, 2012, in the
categories licensed engineer and licensed plumber. This five member board was established by Ord.
83 -16 (amended by Ord. No. 91 -57); Repealed and amended by LDC, Div. 1.22.1 (Ord. 91 -102, as
amended) to hear appeals on rejections or refusals by the Building Code Compliance Director to
approve mode of construction or materials to be used in construction or alteration of a structure.
Membership consists of five members representing the following professions: One state licensed
architect or structural engineer; one Class "A" general contractor, one state certified fire protective
equipment contractor or State Certified Fire Fighter with the rank of Lieutenant or higher or State
Certified Fire Safety Inspector with the rank of Lieutenant or higher; one licensed electrical contractor;
and one licensed plumbing or mechanical contractor. Members must be knowledgeable in the
following Collier County Codes: Florida Building Codes, Electrical Code, Fire Prevention Code, Gas
Code, Mechanical Code and Swimming Pool Code. The membership term is four years. The meetings
are held quarterly, or on an as needed basis. This is a Quasi Judicial Board.
The Environmental Advisory Council has 1 vacancy for a technical member with a term to expire
July 28, 2016. This 5 member (plus 1 alternate member) council acts in an advisory capacity to the
Board in matters dealing with the regulation, control, management, use or exploitation of any or all
natural resources within the County, and the review of all land development petitions which require an
environmental impact statement (EIS) per section 10.02.02 A of the Code, all developments of
regional impact (DRI), lands with special treatment (ST) or Area of Critical State Concern/ Special
Treatment zoning overlays, areas of the county covered by inter local agreements, any petitions which
cannot be resolved between the applicant and staff. The membership will include technical and non-
technical members. Technical members shall demonstrate evidence of expertise in one or more of the
following areas related to environmental protection and natural resources management: Air Quality,
Biology (including any of the sub disciplines such as botany, ecology, zoology, etc.), Coastal
Processes, and Estuarine Processes, Hazardous Waste, Hydrogeology, Hydrology, Hydraulics, Land
Use Law, Land Use Planning, Pollution Control, Solid Waste, Storm water Management, Water
Resources, Wildlife Management, or other representative areas deemed appropriate by the Board such
as, but not limited to, a representative of the development community. Terms are 4 years.
The Golden Gate Estates Land Trust Committee has 1 vacancy for a candidate to "ui
October 13, 2014. This five- member committee serves in an advisory capacity to the Board of County
Commissioners for the purpose of carrying out the requirements, conditions, and various provisions of
an Agreement relating to the use of land, or funds derived from the sale of land, conveyed to the
County by Avatar Properties Inc. (f/k/a GAC Properties Inc.). Applicants must reside within the
subdivision known as "Golden Gate Estates." Member selection may depend upon location of
residence within specific areas (phases) of the Estates.
The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Committee has 3 vacancies for terms to expire June 25, 2015. This 9
member committee identifies and evaluates problems unique to the Hispanic Community, reviews and
recommends ways to ensure open communication between the minorities and Collier County
Government, and provides periodic reports to the Board of County Commissioners. Terms are four
years.
The Ochopee Fire Control District Advisory Committee has one vacancy to fill a term that will
expire on December 31, 2013, representing the Port of the Islands area. This five- member committee
advises the Board of County Commissioners on the budget and operation of the Ochopee Fire Control
District. Members must reside within the taxing district. Terms are two years.
The Radio Road Beautification Advisory Committee has 1 vacancy for a term expiring on March 3,
2016. This 5- member committee was established on October 21, 1997 to aid and assist the Board of
County Commissioners in carrying out the purposes of providing curbing, watering facilities, plantings
and maintenance of the median areas as set forth in Ordinance No. 96 -84. This 5 member committee
shall recommend work programs and priorities to the County Administrator or his designee. Members
shall be permanent residents within the MSTU. After initial staggered terms, terms will be 4 years.
How to apply for an advisory committee on -line:
Go to www.collier og v.net
Click on "I want To"
Click on "Apply For"
Click on "Advisory Boards & Committees"
After you complete the application, at the bottom,
click on "E -mail Ian Mitchell"
You will receive a confirmation that your application was sent. Note: You must put your e-mail
address in the application to receive a copy of your application.
Residents interested in applying for advisory committee positions may also obtain an application by
calling 239 - 252 -8097, or from www.collierizov.ne. Please forward to the attention of Ian Mitchell,
Executive Manager, Board of County Commissioners, 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303, Naples,
Florida 34112 -5746, or fax to 239 - 252 -6406. The deadline for acceptance of applications is June 5,
2012
-End-
ROM: Mayor JohT Jolky
-
3artyi�
THE CHALLENGES OF BEACH REN' RNISHMENTAND �.
f ENTRANCE TO THE GREENWAY AND ZOO PARKING LOT
�Opy
I have heard comments and seen in the newspaper various
statements about the upcoming beach renourishment project and the
construction of a new entrance for the Greenwa.y and the Zoo parking lot. As is
usually the case, there are some facts in dispute and a considerable amount of
incorrect information floating around. I have been very-involved in both projects
and will attempt to provide some information for your consideration.
2013 Beach Renourishment
During a joint Board of County Commission (BCC) /Naples City Council meeting on
February 9, 2011, the decision was made to develop plans to maximize the time
between renourishment cycles. This was conveyed to the Coastal Advisory
Committee (CAC) which is a Collier County committee charged with advising the
BCC on beach and- inlet matters and consists of representatives of Collier County,
the City of Naples and the City of Marco Island. I have the honor to currently
serve as its chairman. After working diligently with staff, several steps were
developed: (1) create a model to determine past beach performance, identify hot
spots and incrementally increase the scope and cost to maximize beach life; (2)
determine alternatives to reduce costs and maximize the life of the beach; and (3)
obtain grants to reduce the cost to the County. All of these objectives have now
been accomplished.
The precise scope of the next project is currently unknown and will depend on the
funds available at the time of renournishment. On April 4, 2012, the BCC agreed
to and approved proceeding with a ten year permit. This is expected to provide
the most flexibility and is consistent with our charge from the BCC and Naples City
Council. We can always reduce the scope of the project downward, but it-is quite
difficult to increase the scope of such a project once underway.
The 2005/06 renourishment project was limited in the placement of sand
quantities due to Florida Department of Environmental Protection's (FDEP)
concerns that sand would migrate to the near shore hard bottom marine habitat
and adversely impact it. This resulted in a six year beach design life, that is
currently being stretched to eight years, with numerous beaches becoming very
11A
height to five feet, as well as increases the width as required to increase the
critical mass to resist erosion; improves the jetty at Doctor's Pass, renourishes
Clam Pass Park beach, rebuilds /repairs Barefoot beach, removes various groins,
and addresses hot spots.
Approximately $16,500,000 will be available from tourist taxes allocated to these
projects. The problem we face is that funding is accrued at a rate of $2,000,000
per year based on a ten year plan, but the current renournishment model lasts
only six years. Various alternatives are being explored to generate additional
funds: $5- 7,000,000 could be received if FEMA Tropical Storm Fay work
authorization and appropriation is accomplished; $1,000,000 could be saved by
combining with another entity and sharing mobilization costs and economies of
scale; $1- 2,000,000 can be anticipated with our schedule flexibility; and we will
work hard to maximize FDEP's cost share contribution to this project.
Even with all of these potential sources, funding could still be short of our needs.
Every survey that is conducted indicates beaches are the number one reason that
tourists come to Naples. In addition, it is a key issue affecting the quality of life
for our residents. Some additional potential funding sources from the tourist tax
collections are Fund 183 -Beach Park Facilities, of $10,000,000 and the
Catastrophe Reserve of $5,000,000. The CAC is committed to explore every
alternative to insure that we implement the plan which is optimal for the beaches
utilizing the resources available.
4
a)
C3
C3
iJl
C.`
U)
S
n
T3
c
N
rn
c
w
u)
N
CL
o-
ral
N
00
t
(� Ce)
(Y] N
`— O
N
C �
. .
��-_-
,~
-�__-
/
m ]
,
�} \\
, ■.
J 2� °
�� �
^�^
�
r
�'
� N
T
�� Q
4 � �'� "° ° g@
A � L
)� d
y
9 �ry
Y '��'�
n
,�;�: _
J
��� µµ
+������roM�a „�
�;a
p"i"'4n
'. � r'sk*"Y� {a"
�
M" �
'.
���
A f
✓
S�YF� P�
"�E }�I., �S�R �Y�
ID �..
� �
�^?i„
�,
�", ,�A ,
�"
t.s, ;
�,
I �,
w 3
t� `��
F.µ @ 5 �
^�^
p �` 4 �,q r
ar
r
�'
� N
T
�� Q
L
O �
,�;�: _
J
i d x
f
r
AV
N
co
F.
.Em
U) P,:
w�
/ \^
��.
� \ �
\:)
Or
�?¥
� \
( �
■
»
L
m
m
6
G
«
m
m/
/ ®
Cf) » cz
.
� AV
3
N
�n
N co
N LO
d
N
O 1�
a
m co
s
k
y
N
�n
N co
N LO
d
N
O 1�
a
m co
n
N
r
ILA
v
4%
m
W
D
J
0
>
Z
(D
N
w
0
H
w
J �
Z
T
X
W
m
d
Q
PV\
W �'i.
O
O O
N N
�{ (D
Q( O
Cl) m
00 h
tO mil'
m n
T to
Q� to
O
n (O
M t0
tO r
a v
M V
N 00
O O
to V
r h
0
M
0
m N
m
O M
O
N N
00 N
N M
O n
M m
M 0
O
00 tO
0 0
O
0 0
0
0 m
M M
O co
n
(n
et
O O
O n
r
tp
O O
O
O
ZJ}
'Q N
N
M r
M r
N r
r V
M N
N M
N
O m
m (O
a
N
N 00
M
r
(")
V)
m C0
O
V
N
`
IL 0U
00000OD
o00
r-
00 m
(DoO
V O
MCO 00C)M
LO
V 0
0 m
m0m000OO
OOOOO
(O n
J
M
0' 'f)
m
LO
CO
W OD
m
M
N
n (0
M
O
M
1
M CN
e a}
to w V
r
O
J
000
N N
V (O
O m
(n
N t`
M tD
O
m V
(n M
m M
N
0 0
N V
v O
O
O O
M 7
LD I-
V w
0
0 0
0
O_ U�
0 0
0
to
Q W
m m
00 V
m (O
(D (D
N I�
N V'
L M
N
N
^
M N
O N
I�
M Lo
N m
O (D
(n
co
O�
Lf)
O
Q1
O j}
V M
N N
M r
N O
N r
r V
N o
N N
0
N
t� (0
00 0
N
N r
Cl)
O r
Cl)
M
0) nCi
N
h
m Jp U
v
Z
o
0 O
N
M
m
O
co r-
V
0 (
m M
m O
O
O
-
N
Cl)
m 0
Cl)
0
(N
h
(D V
1n (n
O m
O
o
m
t.-
N
O O
O
O O
O
cO o
M
O
V M
h N
17
17.
M
N Oct
M
M N
N
co M
-
V
(C]
N
'-
N }
N
r N
r
C
r
U
r
N W
00000oOM00
MpOOnD
O
co 00
MO�OOr
M000O000oro00o
V
000
N
W
O
N
r M
N (D
CD
n V
N
M
ON
00
o
V N
W
O
V
CD
N
N N
O sf
(n
m
(O
r I�
O
� O V
M
m
Z
W >
2
z
N
0000
0
0 0
(D o
0
p O
M n
O O
O O
O O
O
0 0
m 0
0 0
0 0
M O
0 0
0
0 m
O
0 0
0 M
0 0
0
O
00000(DOr00
moomoomwmo0
(OMMC)OOt00000000-
000ONCOO
Ooh
Z W }
°z
w
v
000mNOM
Vro
oo
MOOCOOOO
oOrMOOOr
�0000v
.
raioo'oi�000
" "'oo ""
0Z
(D
(O (O
O(DOm
V'NfD
O(DNNCDO(V
OO(O
fD
OOO�CC14
OO(D(D
m moo
V
fN
O(D(D
M(0
CDO
n
Q Z a
}
�Q
uj
w
......................
_._
O
_._. ....
o 0
_... _._.
0 0
..... ._....._..._..
0 0
0 0
.... _._
0
.._. ..__
0 0
_... ..._.
0 0
._.. ._._
0 0
_._ ._..
0 0
._._ .....
0 0
.._......
0
...... .....
0 0
..__ .....
0 0
._. ......
0 0
_... ...........
0 0
._ ...
0 0
..... .._..
0 0
....
0
_._. .._...._
0 0
0
_._.._.
0 0
._._ _.
0 0
0 0
0
O'
Z
M
m M
M (D
(O (O
M m
m
M (0
O m
(O m
O 0
w (D
M
m (D
(0 (D
(O 0
CO (D
M (O
(D (D
(O
(D (D
M
(D o
(D O
(D (D
(D
(O
N LL
W J }
0
O
O O
_
.0 _ .....
.IV
0
m
0 0
0 (n
C O
.....
....
1
Z
N
M
N
()
O
to r
Dr 7
d
-
N
C� M
(n
N
N M
O' p
Cf7 `
�
0
W0 v
U
W0000000000
"T
0 0
0 0
0
0
0
N
0 0
0 0
m 0
0 0
0 0
0
0 0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
N
(V
M
�... W
Qg
0?
(o (D
MO
M
NM
o
O N
(DM
M
MO
tNp
Nr
M
(4 JU
O
F
w W
N M
V V
(0 I�
n
O (D
O
0 o
M O
to
m
0 0
N�
N o
t- O
N O
N 00
0
co
V
N
00
to O
O
O O
to
O
V co
(D CC)
0,0
N
N
M M
N P,
00
>
R
c:z
Ism
VO
r W
N(DN
NN
.'-
�r�-
N
�(p
N O
(D
O W
(D (O
O
aD
N �-
dorm
N
V �mr
to t•
.-
0)
W J
r(pN
N
V O
�- N
f�(+)NO
N
N�--�
-mtD
r N
N00
hN
N
v
Or(.'>M(M(2
r
N N
r
N
�-
M
N
Mmr
N +-
C?
17
CD
N'
N
U
W 0
2' >
.......................
LL O a
o>
.................
M
M M
..... ......
M M
...........
M M
__. ......
M M
..... _..............
M
M M
..... ......
M M
..... ......
M M
................
M M
..........._..
M M
M
...... .....
M M
...... _...............
M M
M M
..... ......
M M
..... ......
M M
_... .._..
M M
.....
M
...... ..........
M M
M
..............._
M M
M M
_._.._..
c) M
_........................
M
M
7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7
7 7
7
7 7
7 7
7 7
7
.
f--NZ
OF
w
O U LL
Q
........................,,
0000000000
.........,
................................................................................
00000000000
...............................
00000000000000000000000..."
................................................
............._.............._._
_..
" "'o
>
V
vV
vvvvvvv
v�
Vav'IT
V-'ry
vv't
,I—
vvcvvvvaavvvef.fa
m0 Q
w —z
m =F:.
LL
S Z
O
m N
M m
r M
N V
m
m O
m N
V N
r 0
�- I�
�
f` (D
� (D
M O
m (n
....... ...............................
tf) N
(O (D
M
to N
V
O) m
N 0
_�- 'O
n ••
....N ...
+- 0
V m
M M
n V
N
W
m N
06 M
M O
6 C.O
V
N (D
O '-
(N (A
.- C>
V N
O
O M
m
u
N
r M
N M
r
M
N
N
M
r
r N
N N
M
M M
n
UO )
M
w LL
O
O 0
N F
O000000000
O
O O
O o
0 0
0 0
0
(n (n
M M
u7 in
M M
(n u)(n
W a0
N(n
W CO
«')(n
W O
O
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0 0
0
N
Z
N W
0
0
0 0
0 0
0
0 0
0
0 0
C1
O O
O
C7)
c�
6 LL
W
O
w w
O O
r V
(0
n 0
N co
N O
c0 O
'o O
r N
M r
O m
n
n .-
m (n
V
V M
n O
n
O M
1-
M M
W m
N M
M O
to
F- V
O O
M �-
n
O O
m M
O m
m N
O O
V M
Cl) C
m M
0 M
n V
O O
to O
m O
t` o
C N
0 (0
.- m
(0 (n
o O
co M
m V
1- M
OD P--
M M
C 0
V
o O
M (n
m Co
O
M M
p
a0 m
O
w
O O
N W
O
00
O
[b o0
m m
h lh
w M
C- m
N (n
r (n
w
O
W F-
LL Cn
LL
W
W W
m
N
m
V)
CK
=1 w
LL m
n' N
N
Cl) V
N N
(n to
N N
r O
N N
m O
N M
r m
M LL
(n Co
V
I.-
V
m 0
N
N
1n 1n
M V
(A U)
m a
N`
Q co
(n
m o
(D
r N
(D (fl
M
(0
(n 0
(D ((�
i.- M
(O (O
m
m
0 �-
h
N
M V
(�
(!7 O
C� h
I� �
fz
0) C
Q
C
w wx
0:C
Qx
Q:K
�LL'Q:K
d'Rf-
q'
�KK0:0
OAK
Q'D'_R'0:
0: 2�
w
w K
O.'
K w
LL'��a'tY
�.'d'�'D0
U
U
w
-'
a z
_
U
0
0
0
a
Q,
11A 1
1
P�
0
3
U
N
m
0
w
J
0
a
3
z
Z
U
W
O
0
N
U
0
U
N
o
i
a
Cv
U
D
c
0
U
�f
0
U
m
a
N
W
J
m
H
m
co
N
a
11A
0
N
W
Q
a
O
0
Z
z
0
W
O
0
N
Uq
U
v
c r
La o
C N
rno
� o
LL
rn
C
0
O
c
m
Q
t0
J
d
V
0
�p
U
N
U
w
Q
t
d
I
(0
LO
LO
to
0)
n
0
0
0
M
N
LD
n
O
V
O
LO
N
n
w
0
ci'i
00
m
O
LO
O
LD
O
O
m
m
V
Op
0
0
m
n
M
w
O
O
O
O
T
m
N
m
N
M
V
N
LO
LO
O
m
O
N
V
N
n
0
0
0
0
M
LO
O
O
O
O
0
0
0
Co
W
n
tD
N
co
m
O)
O
co
O
r
co
m
m
r
n
n
V
M
V
V
V
N
N
M
V
r
00
OO
n
LO
V
Cl!
J
N
N
tD
et
O
M
ced
M
et'
M
M
n
r
co
r
r
r
r
V
N
r
N
lh
h
M
Oi
c0
0)
N
LO
M
to
N
N
M
N
a0
Oi
a
Ln
00
r
Z}
O
m
M
W)
V•
r
M
w
LL O
O
O
O
O
O
co
O
O
O
O
O
O
LO
N
O
O
O
n
m
(D
O
O
O
N
n
0
0
0
m
V
co
0
0
0
0
n
0
0
0
0
0
m
0
0
0
NT
O
N
V
co
co
0o
n
m
M
N
co
M
M
V
(D
m
0
n
r
O
J
J
LL
C?
N
r
LO
N
Cl!
r
n
N
r
r
LO
V
(D
CO
M
r
O
N
(D
r
N
Ut
�-_
N
M
N
e }
W U
O
J
O
LO
to
Co
m
n
O
O
O
V
N
O
M
m
O
co
m
c0
n
(o
0
W
Lp
0)
O
(n
LO
m
V
M
m
M
0
0
N
M
V
N
m
O
0
0
m
(D
M
(D
LO
m
V
N
((�
Ln
O
0o
O
n
V
CD
O
O
O
O
n
tO
W
O
n
0
0
O
O
V
O
O
O
cD
¢ W
n
(D
LO
n
m
tO
O
M
cc
r
oc
m
n
co
n
LO
r
(D
co
m
o0
cc
N
M
V'
V
n
LO
r
V
V
m
Ln
n
H
Q }
N
N
to
V
O
M
W
CO
CO
M
co
n
co
r
r
O
O
N
r
(d
M
to
(D
co
N
O
O
0)
00
V
M
N
o
LO
N
co
m
M
(n
n
N
H J U
r
M
M
n
00 O
> >
(n
O
O
O
O
O
O
N
N
M
O
m
o
n
O
o
o
O
N
0
W
0
0
0
LO
m
O
O
N
V
m
V
LO
O
N
O
LO
O
O
o
0
000n000(DOOO
o
Cl) Z
m
V
tmO
c00
_O
r
0
N
Cl)
CO
M
M
n
co
N
V
.--
N
N
LO
M
m
w
O
r
m
CO
0
to
(D
m
r
m
V
O
LO
m
Cl!
}
V
CO
n
N
(V
r
C
N
O
.-
Lf>
O�
co
N
m
W
r
M
n
r
LO
N
LO
O U
o
r
W
N
w
F
O
Z Z
W
a (n
(n
a.
co
0
0
0
O
O
O
M
m
O
M
V
n
D
LD
m
O
O
O
O
O
m
O
M
O
O
n
O
M
0
0
N
m
0
0
w
to
V
m
0
0
0
0
n
n
0000
to
000
M
W
h
co
w
n
M
M
O
O
V
M
m
LOO
V
t0
V
n
LO
co
M
V
n
co
.-
O
O
n
O
O
O
V
W
O
N
n
M
LD
oD
M}
N
o
r
w
N
m
co
M
N
r
O
c`m'M
m�
r
N
LO
H J U
M
O>
W
w
O
O
O
O
O
O
0
0
n
O
0
0
O
O
O
O
O
M
n
0
0
tD
O
O
O
O
O
O
m
0
0
0
O
0
M
�❑
000
0o
000roo
o
om
rM
v0
0000vtrio0
o0
o0
o(0000
o
w
002
z w }
❑ w
w z
U
Z.»..... ................._............_
».._.
»...._
...............
»..
...
_....».
...
».
....
......
...
».»
.. »....
¢ U
O
O
O
O
O
O
m
N
O
M
V
.-
O
O
O
O
O
O
n
M
0
0
V
0
0
0
0
0
0
.-
M
O
O
O
r
n
O
...
0
0
.....
o
V
m
0
0
0
n
0
0
0
» »O
> Z
❑ _
O
O
O
O
O
O
tb
LO
O
m
V
w
O
0
0
0
0
0
U)
N
O
O
N
O
o
0
'-
0
r
O
O
O
N
cq
0
0
o
to
O
r
r
�
.-
.--
r
�
r
M
0
�
0
�
0
�--
r
¢ Z K
w
W
Q'
.................
0
.....»
0
......
0
».........�
0
0
0
0
.. ..
0
»....»..»....................
0
0
0
0
0
......
0
_.
0
...._»
0
0
. »........_
0
0
0
._.
0
..»
0
...
0
_._
0
..._..
»..
_...
_._
_..
s
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
6;3;3
0
0
0
0
0
0
z
0
0
0
6666666666
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
r
U_' W
-----------------------
N LL_
w J }
❑
.......... _. .....
...
_..
«. ._.
.....
.._
V
N
_.
co
_. ».....__.._........_.
N(D
LO
_.
_..
_._
-C--
O
0
_
0
_._
w
...
1L7
.._
(D
__.._._
O
O
n
M
0
LO
Lf)
m
LO
OD
O
O
O
o
n
M
m
o
_
0
0
LO
0
0
0
_ __ _
�n
Z
O
M
V
W
W
Ln
M
O
n
M
Cl
n
V
V
m
V
m
LO
V
M
n
n
n
'�
W
N
O
n
(D
LO
O
r
M
LO
Cl)
n
co
LO
UO
N
V•
r2 fA
r
N
CO
CO
r
M
Ln
N
C
N
N
Cl)
r
O O }
U W U
W
❑
0 L
0)
000
0(0
0
(o
000000m
0000000000000000
r
H W
O
o
13i
w'0oo000on00
o
M
o
O
N
(O
M
n
Jj}
M
N
M
O
to
co
(07
LO
00
to
N
O J U
�
Q
F«
w
N
M
O
O
W
cA
U)
V
m
V
w
n
n
V
0
m
O
co
M
o
O
LO
07
o
0
0
0
o
LO
n
n
O
N
0
0
co
V
O
O
tO
O
O
O
O
V
M
O
W
m
0
M
N
M
M
N
n
V
W
O
>
WD}
Lb
M
r
cc
(D
o
(V
(D
O
O
n
tb
(`')
V
O
O
N
r
tp
to
N
N
O
O
N
M
N
N
N
O
V
r
LO
.-
M
tO
N
m
O
O
O
O
w
Co
O
W
N
m
.-
r
to
N
V
V
O
V)
m
n
r
V
m
V
OD
m
r
OD
to
JU U
N
N
n
W
N
N
r
r
r
CA
N
CD
In
co
n
LO
N
V
CO
r
M
M
C7
M
Lo
M
M
m
n
M
V
n
O
M'
CO)
r
N
N
r
r
N
N
r
NV
w >
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M»
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
r
_ Q
z
IL O
w❑ LL
U
................
...
0
V'
»._......_...
o
C
O
'7
V'
__.
V
...._
V
V'
._.._.
V'
V'
_._..._.._..._.._....._.....
V
V
V
V
__.._.._._
V
'7
. ».._..
__
._._
_._
_.
_._
__..�
..._..
»._
..._.
_._
».....__
_.»
_ >
V'
V'
V'
V'
V'
V'
V'
a
W S2
Z
m=FL
LL
Z
m
O
N
Ll')
m
N
O
m
M
N
V
LO
m
O
m
M
V
N
r
O
r
n
n
•• »••n
(o
n
o
M
o
O
O
O
N
M
o
M
N
O
r
m
n ._
•• »O ••
_ CD
C14
o
n
N
r
M
N
M
M
M
n
V
M
N
W
M
N
M
N
O
W
M
O
N
V
LO
O
C)
C i
O
m
n
m
L
CO
7'T
N
M
M
LO
w
V
M
w 7
O
O
N
Z
M
V
W
V
LO
V
0000000000
O
O
O
0
0
0
0
O
O
O
OOOLO
Lp
M
W
M
LO
W
w
W
LO.000
a0
Lb
W
LO
Lb
a0
w
W
W
LO
(b
00
m
000
Lb
aD
O
O
O
O
1120000000000000000
O
0
0
0
0
0
0
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
o
0
O
C7 F
M
M
N ❑ L~1.
�
❑
W W
(O
o
OO
eh
O O
00 O
O
O
n
V
cD
LO
cD
N
M
N
O
o
N
M
00
O
M
O
n
OO
OO
n
O
m
LO
n
n
LO
m
LO
n
V'
V
M
LO
O
LO
O
M
n
M
M
LO
m
N
M
U
LO
O
CD W
r
O
n
O
L!')
O
OD
m
m
O
N
O
V'
m
M
0
m
0
LO
M
0
N
0
n
0
V
0
LO
M
O
O
n
O
O
N
O
r
eD
m
(D
0
lO
0
OD
0)
M
V
n
Co
M
n
Lo
0
o0
0
V
0
o
eo
m
0
a0
O
c0
co
O
A
co
O
b
O
co
O
co
O
p
00
O
p
m
n
m
n
co
n
M
m
CO O
N LO
O
m
F-Z�
r Ll7
N
W F- LL
V
LL
_y
LL
W ❑
cn
N
¢
W
w
cn
N
N
W
'J W
V
LO
m a
N
N
M
N
V
N
M
(D
n
w
m
0
O
�'
N
M
V
LO
Co
n
w
m
0
N
M
V
m
a<
co
m
o
N
M
V
tO
O
n
W
m
0
N
M
,
n'
¢
N
N
N
N
N
co
M
V
V
V
V
V
V
V
V
U)
L17
LO
Lo
M
LO
LLD
LLJ
(D
(D
O
(o
w
w
w
w
O
(D
n
n
n
n
V
n
M
n
CO
n
n
n
W
n
m
n
az
U
O
p
0
❑
0
a
11A
0
N
W
Q
a
O
0
Z
z
0
W
O
0
N
Uq
U
v
c r
La o
C N
rno
� o
LL
rn
C
0
O
c
m
Q
t0
J
d
V
0
�p
U
N
U
w
Q
t
d
I
}
a
Z_
E
J
W
It
IL
d
N
a
W n
fD O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O M
M N
N N
V M
N n
t0 C
n 0
0 r
r c
co O
O t
to c
co M
M N
N O
O O
O L
Lf) t
tD t
t0 0
0 0
0 M
M L
LI'1 V
V N
N T
O T
T O
T M
M 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 t
t0 l
lb n
n 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 O
O
J N
N C
CO O
O L
LO' M
M L
LO N
N' f
f� r
r O
O O
O) O
O O
O t
t0 t
t0 0
n M
M N
N N
N M
M O
O N
N t
to M
M '
'W7 T
T V
V
a O} N
N V
V M
M M
M r
r t
t0 r
r r
r c
co r
r N
LZ t
to O
O O
Oi O
Of t
O) M
t0 N
N' M
M' M
M N
N 0
00 M
M M
M N
N P
P O
O
?
J
U n
O O
M L
LO V
V r
r M
M T
T
LL O
n
O O
O O
O N
N O
O M
N N
M n
n 0
00 O
O 0
00 W
W O
O M
M U
U7 0
0 0
0 p
p O
O n
n 0
0 0
0 M
M N
N (
(D O
O O
O 0
00 O
O 0
0) O
O O
O O
O O
O N
N O
O O
O O
O O
O M
M O
O O
O D
D M
M
J M
M N
N N
N W
W N
N N
n m
m M
M c
n (
co C
Cl) (
(o O
O c
co C
Cl) C
Cl) C
CD W
W C
Cl)
J N
N V
V C
CO r
r N
N .
.- V
N
L Lnw } N
O
J l
O L
LO O
O) 0
0 0
0 0
0 N
W O
N O
O C
Cl) V
V n
n 0
0 0
({� O
00 O
O c
co 0
0) 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 W
W o
o O
O) 0
0 0
0 o
o t
to V
V L
Lo M
M M
M 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 V
V n
n n
n O
O 0
0 0
0 C
Cl) 0
0 0
0 0
0 M
M
Q W n
n C
CD t
to n
n 0
0) n
n L
LO r
r O
O r
r O
O W
W (
(D M
M L
LUi V
V t
to t
N (
(D M
M c
co c
co N
N L
LO O
O_ O
O n
n M
M t
N -
-'T
ttff77
OVi
F N
N C
CD O
O t
tO M
M M
M N
N n
n �
�- (
(p n
r N
n N
r M
N n
n L
LO n
n 0
00 V
V O
O V
V N
N N
W V
V r
N M
M O
O N
N L
LO n
n a
an
J U N
r M
M M
M
M 0
D >
O C
Cl O
O O
O O
O O
O N
N c
co M
M m
m O
O n
n 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 N
N O
O O
O 0
0 0
0 0
0 t
to W
W M
M 0
0 0
0 N
N V
V (
(o V
V t
to C
CD N
N (
(o L
Lo O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O c
co n
n 0
0 0
0 0
0 C
CD O
O O
O O
O O
O
M O C
O 0
0) c
co V
V O
O [
[D
_r O
t c
co C
Cl) n
n V
N N
V N
N C
CD L
Ln O
O O
O O
O i
io c
co
r U) n
V M
M n
n N
N N
N .
.- C
C .
.- N
N O
O r
r t
to O
O n
n W
W N
N 0
0) 0
00 .
.- M
M .
n O
.-
O N
N U
U) Lr)
N W
C7 Z o
o
Z W
W
U7 LU
U) F
aU)
a �
Q
O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O Q
Q O
O M
M V
V
0 0
0 O
O O
O O
O
M C
O
M O
M O
O O
O O
O M
M O
O
N L
00 L
LO L
Lo V
V O
O
O O
O O
O V
V O
O
0 0
0 C
C N
N
W
M M
C
CO
M
O O
io (
(o O
L M
M N
N
O n
n N
N CD L
L W
N
N
W
N
W L
Ln o
o 0
0- M
M N
N N
M
M
N O
O W
W L
N
F J U C
O>
Cl)
W O
O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O U
Uo 0
0 0
0 .
.- M
M O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O) O
O O
O O
O V
V O
O 0
000
O
O O
O W
W 0
0 0
0 0
0 O
O V
V O
O 0
00 0
0 0
0 N
N n
n 0
0 c
cc 0
0 0
0 O
O O
O O
O M
M
C] O
0 0
0 0
m n
n 0
0 0
0 N
N 0
0 0
0 C
CD 0
0 0
0 0
0 D
Di 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 r
r 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 U
U) O
O O
O O
O O
O C
CD O
O O
O O
O
D W
O o
z W }
oW
W z
U
............. _
_.. _
_..........._..._.._. _
_ .
._.._. _
_._ .
...__.......... «
« .
.
Q .
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O C
C0 N
N O
O m
m n
n r
r 0
0 O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O r
r V
V O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O N
N U
UD r
r 0
0 0
0 0
0 O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O U
UX) M
M O
O 0
« O
> Z O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O (
(7i C
CD O
O (
(A (
(O O
O 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 O
O (
(D N
N O
O O
O N
N O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O O
O M
M O
O O
O 0
00 C
CD 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 U
U) V
V C
C2 O
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0O O
0 0
O «
O«
Q Z
Q }
w
W
w
.................. _
_._ .
0 0
.._ ......... _
0 0
_._.....__ .
0 0
0 0
...._. _
0 0
_ «.._. _
0 0
__.................. .
0 0
... .
.... .
.... .
...._. «
0 0
«...._
._ _
_._ .
... _
__ _
__...._ .
0 0
......_._ _
0 0
_......_ _
0 0
_._.... _
0 0
_._ _
_....._ _
0 0
_._...« _
0 0
_._.... _
0 0
_._......« _
0 0
0 0
_._.... _
0 0
_._.....«_. .
..... .
..... «..__........._...
z o
o 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 6
6 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 6
6 6
6 0
0 0
0 0
0 6
6 6
6 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
N LL Q
C
O O
O O
O n
n (
N c
co N
(p M
M t
to O
O O
O O
O O
O a
at O
O M
M 0
0 0
0 0
0 W
W W
W O
O O
OOn W
__ C
W (
(0 C
C!j t
t2)» W
W O
O O
O D
D O
O n
n M
M m
m O
O O
O O
O t
to O
O O
O O
O n
n
Z V
(o M
M V
V C
CO 0
00 t
to O
O M
M n
n V
V O
O O
O V
LO M
M n
n n
n C
C0 O
N n
O C
CO C
CD c
c) M
M
CD W
W �
� C
D' O
N c
co C
Cl) �
�- M
M W
W N
N M
M N
N N
N M
M r
r F
C
O O } -
-
U m U -
-
W C
C
L
C
W
O
n
O
O
O
O ^
^ n
0000
O
O O
O O
O n
n
0)
O O
O O
O O
O O
O M
n
0
n
n W
O
O O
O O
O N
N r
co
000
O
O 0
000000
O
O 0
000
O
O O
O r
w
F O
0
N M
0
O
M n
N O
0
O C
O
O
r
O N
JCl) c
co N
N V
V r
r C
CO M
M 6
6(d m
m c
c0
r w
cn U
U) '
' o
o F
a° N
N
W W c
co O
O O
O O
O) N
N n
n M
M L
Lo O
O O
O n
n r
rn N
N 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 7
7 O
Q) C
O W
W W
W O
O O
O W
W O
(D M
O O
O N
N N
N V
V O
O O
O O
O n
n n
n M
M C
CD M
M (
(o W
W M
M (
(O U
Uo v
v n
n M
M N
N
V (
(D M
M N
N O
O O
O) M
M N
N (
(D O
O) U
Uo n
n L
Lo n
n V
V L
L n
n O
O O
O M
M r
r N
N n
n n
N O
O V
V W
W t
tb N
N W
W (
(o M
M O
O n
n
N J U 7
7 n
n N
N �
� N
N a
N N
N r
r� M
M C
Cp L
LO W
W i
n t
to V
V I
I� N
N N
N N
N V
V V
V O
O N
N N
N N
fA M
M L
LO I
IX) t
tD N
N f
N
WO v
v
.......... <
Cl M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M c
c 1
M M
<
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M M
M
r
co
2 Q r
O z
0
W U
U L
a
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 O
O o
o 0
0 0
0 0
0
Y C
_ > L
to L
LO t
to L
LO L
LD L
Lo t
to U
U) t
to 0
0 m
m L
LO 0
0 W
W L
LO L
LO L
LO U
U1 0
0 U
U1 t
to L
LD L
LO L
LO U
Un t
to i
in L
LO L
LD U
U) L
LD U
U) L
LO L
LO t
t[j U
U1 L
LO L
LO L
LD U
U) L
LD U
U) L
Ln U
U) L
LD L
LD C
CD L
LD L
LD Y
C
w�? a
a
m W F =
=
= LL C
C'
..__............ _
W O
_._..........._. _
N
=
U')
_._. _
_. _
__ .
._.._. _
_...._..__..._............._.« «
«......_._ .
... .
.
� .
• !
.
O
O n
n W
W N
O
"
"'_.._ O
= U
N M
M V
V V
V .
N
N C
M r
M M
M I
I� V
N m
•
m M
M N
N M
M n
ni M
M w
w W
W c
c6 V
V N
N (
(D O
O r
r N
N 6
6 m
m V
V 0
N C
!o 1
O
M P
P) O
O
M
r V
V O
O
2 m
O C
O r
C
LL
A
y
0
N
ro
Q0
W
Q
Q
0
3
W
z
H
z
0
U)
W
0
0
U
o
U
c .-
m o
C N
rn�
� O
D
c
LL
rn
c
0
m
m
0
a
V
U
D
0
U
o
U
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
MEETING DATE
. 3 t
Agenda Item #
C n
(Circle Meeting Type) Regular Special Workshop Budget
AGENDA ITEM TITLE Gh
NAME 1)AA1 UV l ADDRESS 7S
Representing/ Petitioner: UVUr�iS��iq
Other:
Z 12V/
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2003 -53, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE 2004 -05 AND 2007 -24, REQUIRES THAT ALL LOBBYISTS
SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS), REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT.
V(i11 ARF 1 TMTTF:n Tf% TL.IDCC /21 MTIUIITFC Ft1D vrm PYIMMFNTC ANn AD F: Tn AnnRFSS ONl Y THE CHAIR
i
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Agenda Item #
MEETING DATE /-V4� 2-. (Circle Meeting Type) Regular Special Workshop Budget
AGENDA ITEM TITLE WA I I 1
NAME ' . '" '? ' DDRPSS / -ItRs
Dnmrncnntinn /DntitinnPr �JL/1 / /�W/ GI f1 r: _
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2003 -53, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE 2004 -05 AND 2007 -24, REQUIRES THAT ALL LOBBYISTS
SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS), REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT.
YOU ARE LIMITED TO THREE (3) MINUTES FOR YOU COMMENTS AND ARE TO ADDRESS ONLY THE CHAIR
PLACE COMPLETED FORM ON THE TABLE LEFT OF THE DIAS IN THE BOARD ROOM PRIOR TO THE SUBJECT BEING HEARD
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) Agenda Item #
_
MEETING DATE � (Circle Meeting Type),, Regular ' ",Special Workshop Budget
AGENDA ITEM TITLE U !�h M C) vv�-
NAME � `)U_A D_ �d V 1 ADDRESS
Representing/ Petitioner: Other: CDv\ v- Ci
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2003 -53, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE 2004 -05 AND 2007 -24, REQUIRES THAT AL LOBBYISTS
SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS), REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT.
YOU ARE LIMITED TO THREE (3) MINUTES FOR YOU COMMENTS AND ARE TO ADDRESS ONLY THE CHAIR
PLACE COMPLETED FORM ON THE TABLE LEFT OF THE DIAS IN THE BOARD ROOM PRIOR TO THE SUBJECT BEING HEARD
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
MEETING DATE J 7_ -2-2 - I -z—
AGENDA ITEM TITLE H A-
Agenda Item #
(Circle Meeting Type) Regular Special Workshop Budget
NAME f)"k' de_ MIDY6' U cE�, �r &zk 401- ADDRESS 2L2 3 X11)), i a
Representing/ Petitioner: Other:
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2003 -53, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE 2004 -05 AND 2007 -24, REQUIRES THAT ALL LOBBYISTS
SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS), REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT.
YOU ARE LIMITED TO THREE (3) MINUTES FOR YOU COMMENTS AND ARE TO ADDRESS ONLY THE CHAIR
PLACE COMPLETED FORM ON THE TABLE LEFT OF THE DIAS IN THE BOARD ROOM PRIOR TO THE SUBJECT BEING HEARD
d
cn
m
.r+
N
m
a
06
O
Ac
i
O
P.
a
R
a�
A
d
fl.
H
CD
d
i
u
OWN
J
ce
a
uj
mi
V
z
a
W
a
J
W
Q
W
W
2
J
W
H
D
W
Q
`
QY
a�w
Z
g
a
1
LLI
Ln O c�
U
u.
C
O
Iri
Q ce PA
m
ILA
00
H
Ii
QOw W
CO _
,
_
d
N
L
Lu O =
J
H
oa J °
~
O
o oC
=
0U m 0
O
N Q Ice- Q O:
`
r O i
V
W O
Im
is N LLI U) O
O
Q
Ln Z O:
O a Q
CD C2 H m
Z
N�0 2
W
U CO w f-
t'�
s '
U Q
0 u 0 O a
>- ,� Q W 0 ce
m .�
n Q
pcnm O 1=-
Lu
LL, 0E=
m O
w >� us
qS
S'
Q �j F- O W
W
Q
W
W
2
J
W
H
D
W
Q
`
QY
a�w
Z
g
J
J
1
z�
0
C
O
Iri
ZH�
p Q W
ILA
LL
p
Ii
o ~
,
_
d
N
L
~
J
r
Z Q
~
O
O
W
Q
W
W
2
J
W
H
D
W
Q
`
w Z cG
H w
E'
7-
1
Ln
0
C
O
Iri
ZH�
p Q W
ILA
LL
p
Ii
0 Z
,
W
d
w cn
w
uj
LU
Q
W
U
Z
a
a
�L
=
0U m 0
O
U
IV
a
V
W O
Im
~ J
Q
ONO
d
Z
m
CL
O
N
i
O
F
I �
F#
41
H
Q
ce
Q
W
V
a�
LJ
v
11
0
LLI
U')o
m 0 H W
Op a m
Q O W W W
m� = n
cm
UJ
W Z 0 ZO _
H
�w O LU 0 ce
d' Q � Q
N op a a
a� NwN W O
w
�
Ln J fZ-+ -+
m~� Q O
1- 0 CD H m
Q
umm0 Z UA
i H
Qoi i z
Z F- F-
H U u
pia
Oup O C
CO 5.
O ce
owm ui O 1
D
1 w > ~ H
O O
L N H
LU i
Z J
U M
M m W �
r� 5 0 Lu
U °G O
w
Z o W
�) O
OZ J
CL w n= W
Lu
gv = p Z a
= OU w 0 O`
m H
W y w J5,
L
z A oNo
H
Ii
A
U
r� D
H
H
LU
Q
W
Q
LAO
Z
'�
D
�-
W
Z
f
a
�L
t'�
s '
11
0
LLI
U')o
m 0 H W
Op a m
Q O W W W
m� = n
cm
UJ
W Z 0 ZO _
H
�w O LU 0 ce
d' Q � Q
N op a a
a� NwN W O
w
�
Ln J fZ-+ -+
m~� Q O
1- 0 CD H m
Q
umm0 Z UA
i H
Qoi i z
Z F- F-
H U u
pia
Oup O C
CO 5.
O ce
owm ui O 1
D
1 w > ~ H
O O
L N H
LU i
Z J
U M
M m W �
r� 5 0 Lu
U °G O
w
Z o W
�) O
OZ J
CL w n= W
Lu
gv = p Z a
= OU w 0 O`
m H
W y w J5,
L
z A oNo
z
Ii
A
W
H
H
LU
Q
W
H
LAO
Z
'�
D
�-
W
Z
f
a
11
0
LLI
U')o
m 0 H W
Op a m
Q O W W W
m� = n
cm
UJ
W Z 0 ZO _
H
�w O LU 0 ce
d' Q � Q
N op a a
a� NwN W O
w
�
Ln J fZ-+ -+
m~� Q O
1- 0 CD H m
Q
umm0 Z UA
i H
Qoi i z
Z F- F-
H U u
pia
Oup O C
CO 5.
O ce
owm ui O 1
D
1 w > ~ H
O O
L N H
LU i
Z J
U M
M m W �
r� 5 0 Lu
U °G O
w
Z o W
�) O
OZ J
CL w n= W
Lu
gv = p Z a
= OU w 0 O`
m H
W y w J5,
L
z A oNo
ncn � a m A 3DOr 'aa 3 m rn /1
O = O a
D -a 3 rn m m r-arm a mN. z
A 3W � i m 0 z 0 0 � rnn 7 \a O r c O C Orn0 tr. w 0 3 > z00 a - 0 r ITI
3 a z0c 3 rn a r 70 70rnz t\ 3 -al
m re � mz -I -I m � z -< m (I)
rn C) O rr 0 3 mDx =,; ■ r
nil
3 � � o o -'7 O m ~ z = , rn
�° D HG)) D a 3 0 -1 G-) m
3 m ,-1 n " 0 0 z rn ( Im1
� z - z 0 � zz
z o * zz 24 = O
I 70 = � 0 ' = m -1 Oo
r ry
m rn O o ►-- !I . _ co °w 1\ CI■
00
r. n ~ w ` gba4 rrn 3 rn � w r
m 3 rn G� • ∎__°, r z
1-1 70 D >Dn rn
r 1.4 XD > NO4 m z
m
D \ ›
z W• > m o2rn
m < rn =.gym .. O � z < z
0 en z .• () D m TI mm � r
1 O W m m 9, to „ a m /� o n ° a
m D^ CO ' ?, o m re 0 0 ; n0 D r
0 O > 2—< y m -0 a c ° r0 70
a n Dc � n -I a0 cmn ..
A
Z O _, z ° -1 n -1 z 3 = z > n
3 rn� z m n = 3 m- 1:11
a
3 r m W W
m Z Ocm 1 3 a W D --Io �3p tia
W -� DH0 p �D r 0 Vf � zo r�i
0 a ozo4 . Tao > 3 ° 0 t
7o z 3 -I o to 0 0 z , u, -1 a.
0 7o rng0 z `\w4 -I 0 m v, rn � m ,,, ::
O m v, rn N m a .. 3 -1 D ° oo n -
o zoo .. m a pON (D
0 n °, Q oT _1 70 pox N
xl
70 ° x -' -4 rn ' �
m � rn t0 0 U ° y`. �� cn
0 u) ° V A = O cn 'o
-I O pzrn g rn z � Gz) �
m Z G) u' IV c 'F > _ _
CU
C � Z2 - W -I -Irn D I
m I ao
CD m mWD O n zD �� 0
A A z O r o I 71 x r H
_ 71 xr SU ET m m cp Z
,rn., ''' OoOo O Z OTc
70 GI n
Z Z1 0o
A n � = O � co
a z � as xi � � lb
a) 0 rPp
0 rt
V�
11A
G
�- OG
cn cn L W
m H OU C9
CD LL- Z
co 0 p 00 Q m
Q O W W W
ca r-I
co
iy-
~ u Z W
V ° Z =
O f.
N CY w ce N O
is � ° Ow O LLJ
O~ ce
7 N a
W o Q Q O
o w V) W O
W
Lr) Q J H
0 o a O
N ? 0 Z W
U m W 2 H
Q Q H 2 N
v � cNn o °a u a
.. 0 Ov° O D
G mH W
Q �"
^ a ° V) m G
° =
j z O
J/ A p = r
:i. N N J
Q W J
W MHO m
J M Co uJ
0 co W F-
_
i W
V N O
Z Q H O
Z
UHw Cy
Z N W Q
% HH� H LL
CL o
j '+� ��� H W
O w W d (1) J
W
a Cy-' W =
oz
Q
W ° "4 _ °m° o
C7 a ai LU H >- W
~ W i J J 5 Q
W W Q 020 Cam.
ia z & uNu
-v
a
A
m .�
3 c
r m
i
in 3
v N
0 v
3 �
z =
—I X
rn
m m
m
r° 3
rn Z
0 -n
m
v 0
c
�-+ O
� 3
m
W
a
v
O
3
O
O
m
Ul
c
m
Q
03
N
Gi
_'
m
v
z
3DO ? 3
arm N rn
rn n rt 7')
,o R' z ,
r) rn
� H 0
c~nzD M
z,
�zrn
p Vi Vi
=r NO
= prn o
w
rn yo
Ln
rn�v
>z.
��z
= v
rn ri rn
6'1
m
v
=1
T
m
m
N
a
m
,-41
1
m cn v
a
rn
" H
n Z
7o
D C
tmlf
I
C
= Z D
3 r= )
m 0crn
� N
N �zo
a
.�
30 o
v
z 0
O
C 3 z ,.,
4tjv S
m Ulm"
0
�oo
vv rn
n p 70 rn
p
O vzrn
Z �G)N
—I �jrrnn�
rn rn0D
v
r
003
O�
Z N
r
r
rn
n
n
cD
M
�a
:i
00
H
V
0
D
3 C
m
TI
� M
7 N
� v
0
z =
= rn
n rn
rot o
D
4*
a
I C
n
n
-r
n
t� I
n
I �
TI
9
3
z
3D0 � m
rN -irnT'I n �
rn z
z �D
G) 0 cz
D
3
�!'► z �D
�zrn
D z
= 0rn Cc) b
rn W Le �.
-G Ln b c
rn
Ln
O�D
3
—, z ���
k
o3 � o
D zpG t,
pn0
c�
= z D
3 rn G� n
rn a° c rn
Z.1 Duo
v0
3
-I o
v zHv c
a rn'
mLnrnN !
00N
v 70 I
v
v nv�
to a NA
O azrn
Z rn G)N
-�
_ = rn -I
rn rn p D
_ �7r
or
003
ON
C LI)
a
m
v
a
m
3
3
m
v
m
'D
m
m
V
H
4
A
m
rC
� W
rn
" H
n Z
^i
n
I
C
�
n X
a O
C
n A
.4 O
r!
C
ft
0
D
D
rot o
D
4*
a
I C
n
n
-r
n
t� I
n
I �
TI
9
3
z
3D0 � m
rN -irnT'I n �
rn z
z �D
G) 0 cz
D
3
�!'► z �D
�zrn
D z
= 0rn Cc) b
rn W Le �.
-G Ln b c
rn
Ln
O�D
3
—, z ���
k
o3 � o
D zpG t,
pn0
c�
= z D
3 rn G� n
rn a° c rn
Z.1 Duo
v0
3
-I o
v zHv c
a rn'
mLnrnN !
00N
v 70 I
v
v nv�
to a NA
O azrn
Z rn G)N
-�
_ = rn -I
rn rn p D
_ �7r
or
003
ON
C LI)
a
m
v
a
m
3
3
m
v
m
'D
m
m
V
H
4
A
m
rC
I
^i
N
r!
A
0
N
S
0
v
W
c
c�
rot o
D
4*
a
I C
n
n
-r
n
t� I
n
I �
TI
9
3
z
3D0 � m
rN -irnT'I n �
rn z
z �D
G) 0 cz
D
3
�!'► z �D
�zrn
D z
= 0rn Cc) b
rn W Le �.
-G Ln b c
rn
Ln
O�D
3
—, z ���
k
o3 � o
D zpG t,
pn0
c�
= z D
3 rn G� n
rn a° c rn
Z.1 Duo
v0
3
-I o
v zHv c
a rn'
mLnrnN !
00N
v 70 I
v
v nv�
to a NA
O azrn
Z rn G)N
-�
_ = rn -I
rn rn p D
_ �7r
or
003
ON
C LI)
a
m
v
a
m
3
3
m
v
m
'D
m
m
V
H
4
A
m
rC
J
E-
0
H
A=
W
a
J
J
V
z
H
a
W
14
uj
J
IL
`wo
V
m
0o
M
s �. v
CL
Y
3
a
v
R
7 v
a�
J L
Im
C y .
U �
W
C �
O
Q
a�
s
O
F
W
Q
D
(9
z
H
H
W
W
W
J
c>
H
W --T
a cJ
z W
C a
a z
a
a�
d
a
ce
a
Lo z
c! 0
U
m U-
co 0
0
Qmw
QLU
~ ~ d
W Z W
0
s��
oy L °
� Q O
N Q
� 0
z
CD <
N W Ln
LLI
a��
Ln Jzi
C)
O O
oW=)O
U m m
Z H �
O U �
m O
UJ
�-
H
< b
Qary
r�z�
Ln
U
j
M m W
0 �-
�z�
Q
U H Uj
Q F-
z�14
H ' n
VQ w
W U)
zEw
0 Z
0 W 0
�mU)
LLJ
H
J J
ON0
w
H
U
W
J
Z
W
0
0
O
W
a
z
H
Z
W
U
D
0
0
V)
W
I—
Z
M
W
W
2
I—
O
D
W
H
J
W
a
0
0
Q
W
2
(7
Z
W J
ca
W
� v
W 0 `
z
O
O
Ea
O
w
Q
CO
W
2
z Q
N
W
LL
0
�' J
LL
J Ii
a
a' W
J
uj
V
Z
O Z
O N
LL ce
W IL
~ W
W
J
a
0 a
o W
W mi
U
a
a u
�a
3
00
a
0
s
L
0
�U
CL
L
C
CL v
h
C1 -4%
cc�
y
U
�IN
i.p
W
a
0
z
H
W
W
►E3
CU
._
re,
--Ai�
LU
W
0 `6
�J
W
J
H
!- t
H W (�
a
Z
Z W
LLI a
a z
a
:N
_
0
a
I.
_
�z
�0
U
M 0
0
Qmw
QW
LULU
0
::D U)
aU°
0 u
Lu
N Q
o
o�Q
N 0
W W
Ln J H
O
O O
CD
U m m LLJ
z L7
Q
0 U
m �Q
oLn co
W �
I—
Qbo
aa�
C7
J
Ln j U
rq CG W
oN O H
O Q
LU
U
Q��
�
Lr)
C2 Q � W
U
W
z�w
�oz
UO w O
C� m �
LIJ
J Q
020
11D
Q
U
W
2
H
J
z
0
W
D
a
0
W
z
H
Z
W
0
0
0
Ln
W
F-
n
z
M
W
W
2
H
O
in
W
N
N
J
W
a
W
CG
W
2
F-
z
i
0
LL
a
W
H
W
J
a
O
V
W
U
J
a
e
V
W
Q
D
(9
z
H
H
W
W
W
J
c>
H
W --T
a cJ
z W
C a
a z
a
a�
d
a
ce
a
Lo z
c! 0
U
m U-
co 0
0
Qmw
QLU
~ ~ d
W Z W
0
s��
oy L °
� Q O
N Q
� 0
z
CD <
N W Ln
LLI
a��
Ln Jzi
C)
O O
oW=)O
U m m
Z H �
O U �
m O
UJ
�-
H
< b
Qary
r�z�
Ln
U
j
M m W
0 �-
�z�
Q
U H Uj
Q F-
z�14
H ' n
VQ w
W U)
zEw
0 Z
0 W 0
�mU)
LLJ
H
J J
ON0
w
H
U
W
J
Z
W
0
0
O
W
a
z
H
Z
W
U
D
0
0
V)
W
I—
Z
M
W
W
2
I—
O
D
W
H
J
W
a
0
0
Q
W
2
(7
Z
W J
ca
W
� v
W 0 `
z
O
O
Ea
O
w
Q
CO
W
2
z Q
N
W
LL
0
�' J
LL
J Ii
a
a' W
J
uj
V
Z
O Z
O N
LL ce
W IL
~ W
W
J
a
0 a
o W
W mi
U
a
a u
�a
3
00
a
0
s
L
0
�U
CL
L
C
CL v
h
C1 -4%
cc�
y
U
�IN
i.p
W
a
0
z
H
W
W
►E3
CU
._
re,
--Ai�
LU
W
0 `6
�J
W
J
H
!- t
H W (�
a
Z
Z W
LLI a
a z
a
:N
_
0
a
I.
_
�z
�0
U
M 0
0
Qmw
QW
LULU
0
::D U)
aU°
0 u
Lu
N Q
o
o�Q
N 0
W W
Ln J H
O
O O
CD
U m m LLJ
z L7
Q
0 U
m �Q
oLn co
W �
I—
Qbo
aa�
C7
J
Ln j U
rq CG W
oN O H
O Q
LU
U
Q��
�
Lr)
C2 Q � W
U
W
z�w
�oz
UO w O
C� m �
LIJ
J Q
020
11D
Q
U
W
2
H
J
z
0
W
D
a
0
W
z
H
Z
W
0
0
0
Ln
W
F-
n
z
M
W
W
2
H
O
in
W
N
N
J
W
a
W
CG
W
2
F-
z
i
0
LL
a
W
H
W
J
a
O
V
W
U
J
a
U)
ti
ro
n
ru
c.
CD
3
I�
�n
m
_i
U
:U
I�
b
11
I I E 44
"I 4T
Fire Service Steering Committee of Collier County, Inc.
P.O. Box 770134, Naples, Florida 34107
May 21, 2012
Board of County Commissioners
Collier County Administration Building
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
Dear Commissioners:
This evening, the Collier County Fire Service Steering Committee voted to oppose the suggested
straw vote to consolidate the independent fire districts under the Sheriffs Department..
During the 2011 legislative session, The County Commission supported legislation that would
make it easier for the independent fire districts to consolidate. That legislation passed and some
of the districts are currently exploring the ramifications and possibilities of consolidations(s).
Immokalee and Corkscrew Fire Districts have implemented functional consolidation. The Fire
Commission's of North Naples, East Naples and Golden Gate, a couple months ago, instructed
their staff s to review and update The Collier County Fire Chief s Association June 2008 "Study
of Consolidation and make recommendations on the feasibility of possible consolidation(s).
Now, out of the blue, comes another recommendation to conduct a "straw" vote regarding the
placement of the independent fire districts and EMS under the Sheriff. There doesn't appear to
be any analysis, study or plan for such a move. Yet the Commission has been requested to
conduct the vote. Those who are in favor of the vote advocate there would be a cost savings of
10 -15% to the citizens of Collier County. Where do those cost estimates come from? Have you
seen any such analysis? In some cases those advocates have not even addressed or talked to the
Fire Commissions of the fire districts or their staff s. Thus the calculations are suspect at least.
In the past couple years the fire districts have made drastic cuts in their budgets and operations.
They are no longer flush with money nor do they have an excessive number of "chiefs" hanging
out waiting for someone to make a claim that they could be let go at a great cost savings.
The Independent Fire Districts are independent units of governments just as the County
Commission is. We answer to the citizens of our districts. Please let us do our jobs without
having to answering to those who think they are better fire service experts. If they feel their
expertise is superior, let them run for a commissioner position in their respective districts.
11E i
ytEew�
Fire Service Steering Committee of Collier County, Inc.
P.O. Box 770134, Naples, Florida 34107
Therefore, we respectfully request that the County Commission refrain from putting on the ballot
any straw vote until such time as specifics are developed to inform the citizens as to what they
are actually voting for and how it will impact them.
Sincerely,
HMO"
Pamela J. B wn, Chairperson
Fire Service Steering Committee
n 3DO m rn 6 3D0
A 3�� (DD m Z v 3rrn
3 z0 -1 v m a ZOc
a z c m a rn�
M U2 m r, '�z0 � � � GO
v 3 rnD� rr r m rnD70
In 1-4
T�1
0 0 �z,� V`e H 0 �Dz
z D Z !_ Z � z
_ =gip V-1 =�0
M �`' t/3 m --I O o
M m =0rno �'� % =Wow
M 03 w ,
rn�
m 3 rnz'w rnzw
m Z n V) �` a C -{DD
o D C m OZ X m �cz
In
-� o Wm° -� o �o
_ ° a u M 0,
v -< �Z� °v o ��`
H 0 °r 0 M C °r-p
p ��z 0 �zZ
-I 3 mPz 3 rn,Z
2 D
m Z co 0Crn 3 Z 0cN
Oo -1 D No Q 'i D o
0 70 ZO r oZo
> Z 300 ° /�� Z 300
v Z�� � -1 CL ZED
N ., (� °
O tE 0 \ fMD rt 0 Z-j 0
a 0P , D (D a °oN
w p �DNp C D rnD.A
np� ` 7o Dorn
O p �A o ��
= 0Z
°►-� cD 0 °
m z m M � G� �
D -I -i fli
70 m
rn rn
LA 3 '�• = 3 co
A A Z> ZD�
_ -1x�
GD a °r
z M OrnC M OT a°
Gi n (7
O cn
m ZV) a z�
M `M
v
3L t
V m
3 Z
I m a
Z
rt
a
_ v
v
t X
\ m
ro
d
m
z
a
m
7"
m
a
m
ma
H
Z
n
r
m
a
X
rm
O
'a
00
CL
U2
rt
2
-n
(DD
M
to
�D
ar
cn
n
O
'a
00
CL
U2
rt
c�
4
2 E
4w
H
m
Q
ce
Q
W
J
V
1
Z
H
ce
a
W
V] W
Q a
W °
J z
Z
a LU
u i
a�
o�
V
O
m
a
O
s
Y
L
O
a
L
O
Im
a �
CD Q
3t Z
r
0
W
°
a°
U
s
Gl
_
W O
J �+
N�
O C
Im
W
C
a �
°
z W
LU CL
Q z w
a�
'C
7
co
a
O
s
L
O
CL
�a
c
0
I
e
a�
� L
L
U
W
°
a°
.id
O
O
a
N
�o
�
m
\
c
U-
m O
H
�°
a
p
a
c m
J Q z
H
~
a
F --pOpz
W
W
i
a
i
F-
z
1:2
CnUa
J_
LU z
Z
M w p
(�
W0
� O
OWL
moo°
N ° Q
O
N
LV W
W
a
m
QED
Lr)� ,
°
Nr 0
a
=
who
z
cn
z�W
Q
z
0
OI°
m �<
O
V) m
C
n
LU
°Nz
U
W> �-
V)
<
a (D
Q
M H J
W
M m W
°O F-
W
V
oz�,
Z
' -, LL1
0
H
z
Q cD F-
z
°
ce
Z
LU
a
;
oz
J
�W�
L1J W
DW
o z Q
�W
V J
Q
oWo
°
W
wC°�
JJ�
J
a
oho
i
u
a�
'C
7
co
a
O
s
L
O
CL
�a
c
0
I
e
a�
� L
L
U
W
°
a°
.id
O
a
N
Z
0
U
m0
° ° Q
F-
< m W
LU F-
F- F- Q !-
(n U' w
L.LJ J
Z
WLf)° O
Cy w coif
LU p0
LLJ
NQ� °
�O° a
° F- z O
CN
°Fw-w W
a
Q2: Z a
Lf) °
o a
°C
`" Z) o z
V m m W
z0w
z H O
0U°
O
p}p Q }
owm LU 00
°E_ .
F-
Qo z
aa�
cD ~
�rj H J
M m W
°O 00 F=- W
N J = LU
za
LU p
U 0
4 w
a (D F LU
°
z Z_ W
°Uw
O U
W (I J
Lu W e LU
0 LL 0
ce mV O
00
UtnU
f � t
ce
W
2
Z
~
W
m
V
W
m
W
2
H
O
O
a
rj
c
N
l V
h
\
c
H
W
D
H
a
c m
H
~
a
m
W
W
W
i
a
i
¢
z
1:2
a
N
Z
0
U
m0
° ° Q
F-
< m W
LU F-
F- F- Q !-
(n U' w
L.LJ J
Z
WLf)° O
Cy w coif
LU p0
LLJ
NQ� °
�O° a
° F- z O
CN
°Fw-w W
a
Q2: Z a
Lf) °
o a
°C
`" Z) o z
V m m W
z0w
z H O
0U°
O
p}p Q }
owm LU 00
°E_ .
F-
Qo z
aa�
cD ~
�rj H J
M m W
°O 00 F=- W
N J = LU
za
LU p
U 0
4 w
a (D F LU
°
z Z_ W
°Uw
O U
W (I J
Lu W e LU
0 LL 0
ce mV O
00
UtnU
f � t
ce
W
2
Z
~
W
m
V
W
m
W
2
H
O
O
a
'v
a
m
n"In
OD0
ma
m
Z
a
��rn
rm
A
O
W
m
3
C
0 -n
rt
a
m
z °c
"'
c\
m
r
m
;0
rn
�'z
v
3
N
rn MD
rte+
m
O
m
~z
0
3
v
z
M
-� �zn
z
O
D z
2
�
=-Z<0
M
m
'- N
a
^
rn � °w
00
n � Ln
r
r
Z
.Al
�D�
M
m
O <
0
m
In
im
=�Z
rn rn 0
m
O^ O
�n0
a
c
� O
�
A
-DI�;a
~
O
z
-4
3
rnpz
M
z Ocrn
w
-i
D-INo
Z
a
o
v
z
3�6
a
c3D
O
3
m
m n
ma
m
Z
a
-
rm
(/1
m
v
m
-3i
m
rm
m
r
m
Z
v - n
m
70 1
r ,
O m rnMo s CR
3 -� Doo
V O > ;;E C)
CA
v � N
O v M
-1
m 0 �M
-I m ��rn
O 0 �O
Ln
m? MZcrnn
m m 3 03 D
rn
_ >rr-
m 00
7D O
m oZ4
v �
t% n
m.
(�D
c
n
of
O
S
O
'a
�o
c
m
cD
rt
U2
tID
CL
fu
rt
m
tJ�
3D0
m
(D
�
3r�
� M
Oc o 03 To rt
a ZOc
,'a rn rn z to
r �z ((D
M
3 M > f+
G� O
m Ujzz
v �G)z
OXzm
-t �zz
_ ��o
m
m =000°0
^ rn00W
n�LrI
rnzw
3 G)
Z �Ln
D
m <rn
cn =�z
O WMM
X D "0
.< >z�
C0 C) O
3 Dp
rn� z
m 03 w (')
.q ono
oz C)
z 3 o
v z ,ry u'
�
rn3z O
m (n M (=D
..' D ON
O z -IC)
a 00,
0 x> -NP
Mo-
m O;0rn
O o (n �
0 z rn
r a G) cn
D -�
-I X >
m rn0
_ -O�
m 0 O
X 0 W
c
z
11E
a 00 m
M Z
a z
Gi
m
3 -ai
m
m
\ (V
\^ a N
JJ �
N
1
a �
°v
X
'D ^
n
'0 cD
1 �
�o
-1 cD
N
U2
w
In
W
A
E�
O
S
O
.a
0
a
(D
rt
r
m
cn
m
v
H
Z
—I
n
r
m
X
rm
a
m
C.
cu
1
m
a
X
rm
O m rnMo s CR
3 -� Doo
V O > ;;E C)
CA
v � N
O v M
-1
m 0 �M
-I m ��rn
O 0 �O
Ln
m? MZcrnn
m m 3 03 D
rn
_ >rr-
m 00
7D O
m oZ4
v �
t% n
m.
(�D
c
n
of
O
S
O
'a
�o
c
m
cD
rt
U2
tID
CL
fu
rt
m
tJ�
3D0
m
(D
�
3r�
� M
Oc o 03 To rt
a ZOc
,'a rn rn z to
r �z ((D
M
3 M > f+
G� O
m Ujzz
v �G)z
OXzm
-t �zz
_ ��o
m
m =000°0
^ rn00W
n�LrI
rnzw
3 G)
Z �Ln
D
m <rn
cn =�z
O WMM
X D "0
.< >z�
C0 C) O
3 Dp
rn� z
m 03 w (')
.q ono
oz C)
z 3 o
v z ,ry u'
�
rn3z O
m (n M (=D
..' D ON
O z -IC)
a 00,
0 x> -NP
Mo-
m O;0rn
O o (n �
0 z rn
r a G) cn
D -�
-I X >
m rn0
_ -O�
m 0 O
X 0 W
c
z
11E
a 00 m
M Z
a z
Gi
m
3 -ai
m
m
\ (V
\^ a N
JJ �
N
1
a �
°v
X
'D ^
n
'0 cD
1 �
�o
-1 cD
N
U2
w
In
W
A
E�
O
S
O
.a
0
a
(D
rt
r
m
cn
m
v
H
Z
—I
n
r
m
X
rm
a
m
C.
cu
1
t% n
m.
(�D
c
n
of
O
S
O
'a
�o
c
m
cD
rt
U2
tID
CL
fu
rt
m
tJ�
3D0
m
(D
�
3r�
� M
Oc o 03 To rt
a ZOc
,'a rn rn z to
r �z ((D
M
3 M > f+
G� O
m Ujzz
v �G)z
OXzm
-t �zz
_ ��o
m
m =000°0
^ rn00W
n�LrI
rnzw
3 G)
Z �Ln
D
m <rn
cn =�z
O WMM
X D "0
.< >z�
C0 C) O
3 Dp
rn� z
m 03 w (')
.q ono
oz C)
z 3 o
v z ,ry u'
�
rn3z O
m (n M (=D
..' D ON
O z -IC)
a 00,
0 x> -NP
Mo-
m O;0rn
O o (n �
0 z rn
r a G) cn
D -�
-I X >
m rn0
_ -O�
m 0 O
X 0 W
c
z
11E
a 00 m
M Z
a z
Gi
m
3 -ai
m
m
\ (V
\^ a N
JJ �
N
1
a �
°v
X
'D ^
n
'0 cD
1 �
�o
-1 cD
N
U2
w
In
W
A
E�
O
S
O
.a
0
a
(D
rt
r
m
cn
m
v
H
Z
—I
n
r
m
X
rm
a
m
C.
cu
1
r. $
V
A
m
n
3
r
m
v
O
3
Z
m
a
Do
r
m
r
m
ZI
O
mn
m
v
a
U)
m
Z
2
m
W
a
X
O
3
V
H
X
O
2
m
c
m
W
m
Z
G)
2
m
v
O
c
X
r
m
v
O
X
m
..
w
3
Z
c
M
W
X
0
c
n
3
m
Z
Z
v
X
m
O
v
v
X
IN
W
Z
-1
Z
m
n
2
Eli
70
omo
3rrE
cD
NWT m
0,0
rn ,�,, z U2
Nrn:� V
x C) o 10
m > ox =*.
�zz 0=
m z n
Z
�nz
=moo
r N
200000
m
m
Z
C)
D
0�3
-i 'J< z
= F�
M m m
0o V) p
z
0Q0
mCo
'~ z
M, z
w co n
D --I N
0
p0�
3-�6
z to
� 3 z O
U-)rnp
DpoN
z -lo
op v
N
o ;M0 rn
rn AO
V) 'uh) 5i
p Z rn
a LO
� m
co
p r
003
Oc~i�
C N
z
W
Z 311,
3 M
m C
l
`�J m
k 3
r P,
m
Z
v
rn
N
ti
v
m
(A
� n
M
�`
to
M
70
C
'm
n
a
O
s
O
�
W
a.
\'
m
rt
Ma
r
m
a
m
Ma
H
z
r
m
rm
a
u
a
m
CL
rF
m
3D0 9
r r -e
m N
00o rt
mmz um
cn rn :� 'O
70 D°
0 C
c1 z Z
-I G) z
z rn
�zz
�..<0
=Wo
m C3
w
r)
rnzw
D Cn
O <m
= p
MLo
z
p r 0
z
,=pz
�cm
N
0
oz C)
0
3 --{ o
Ul
z
c3
m m Zo
� p N
O
O
0 p V
7a D
MO-
Qo
0;0 m
0 NA
Ln (f)�
pzrn
m U)
D -I =
3m DI co
Z D r
�r-r
p O
OW
-<
O
Z
J
O
s
3 m
m z
a
mm
`-- 3
r
m
G1 �
v
X
W
�rlilE
m
m
BrIL
v�
r
m
a
m
00
H
z
n
�r
m
a
X
u
/ (D
rt
m
-a
c
-e
'a
n
O
S
O
`1
fl.
rt
m
fop
m
a
n
m
A
3
V
r
m
m
T
O
z
2
m
a
r
m
r
m
0
m
a
N
z
-I
2
rn
W
a
v
O
3
V
H
O
m
C
m
Oo
m
N
z
a
v
O
a
X
r
N
M
v
O
2
X
m
w
N
Z
C
M
X
O
C
n
3
m
Z
z
a
X
O
v
M
Z
2
m
n
2
:K
Mrrn
T W
o
�O
zc
rn m z
� zm -a
M D R x
C) C)� o
m z
xzm
�zz
�<
= W C) �.
mCOW
rn �
�zw
D n
VDU)
<z
03
p
> z�
pro
4 p
m z D
rnPz
00 .m
�zC)
300 v
z r- crn
�3z O
�
rn p
D p o
z-�o
NJ
p � v
MO ,
0 o
X rn o
0(J)C
~
p z m
m G) �n
3rn-DI
z >�
71 X r
p0
oW
C:
z�
Z
3
A
M
z
a
m
r
m
m
N
z
v
m
r
m
a
m
Ma
X
H
Z
n
r
m
n
m
C
rt
�D
3Do
3�E
� m
~ m
o 30
�rn
rn:�
z O
D >70
rn
~ z
G) D
z
z m
�Dz
-O
=rry
zWOo
mcoW
m
G)
�DcDn
O <z
rnrn0
Co cn p
x z -<
pro
~z
rn p z
W03 rn
D -j No
p0�
c3>
D
�rnp
p N 0
z 0 -I
UP N
Mo-
070rn
MO
pzm
M G) (n
El 3 -
rnDI
z >>
p0
o03
n 03
o
z
■
cD
M
T
'v
rt
IT
;a
z a
z m
m Z
a
v
v
M
ul
m
N
r
M
,I
Is
s
cD
IE
m
N
Z
G)
v
m
Ma
r
m
a
m
N
Z
N A
m
ro
a
m<
A
m,
3
m
CL
fD
m
(DD
a�
0
0
10
a
rip
SL
J
d
O
P
4w
H
m
wC
W
Q
mi
a
W
V
H
Z
H
a
W
a
W
API
'C
m �^
=MR]®R
o
L
O
•U
G7 ,
cn <J
C
O
a�
O
v J
W
D
a
J
a
W
Q
D
c�
z
I--
W
W
�a
W
.i
N
W
N
z
W
Q
M)
Q
W
a
z
i
C
Gl
a
C
ip
C
H
i
CL
9
� "11E
z
P� W
LO m c~n 0 =
CO 1 �-+ U
l n
° Q 1 o° ce W
c \ �� a Co
Q O w V i _ Q Z V ~
H00� `, 1 O Qco W W
__� °. "U 3 aW� _ ^m
Lf) (D LU Q \ ~~d J
LU Z 0 z Ll •� cn (D W Z W
O Wzo
pt w C c�i �A M) Ln p 0 ~
wo° � OO'0� W O
S=QL C o ce
N G E v= Q w O O
moo a Q a+ N a ce `` 1
C:) co[ (C=:)>
� a a `WJ
O
L
W N W C P-1 N � LU Q Q �s z W
z a H O �D 0 O
J _ z ct
9
J H
Ch 9
C) 2! C �0z a Q 1
0 � 0 z � � `, °N �-- Q H ca
Umm W = Umm W =
a
Z z L z� z Z
z O
O -j � ��a a
mom¢ W G C6zQ D LU
co 0
M �Wi = LOL LL WQ W W O Ul) ca
W>~ W 1 w >� W v LU
< ¢ w m -� Q �a cn ¢ Y Z
Opp= W Mm W � a
N 0 W W ` N O W W v
ce Z< ~ Z Z zz� H z
Wz� O
z O I v WZ� O O
(� W
IW— p i w� + z
z W a ` c zz� W o ce
I- W W W w W ~ C. Or W L J LU
W \�}
z W W O: a H z W W J I V
OULU O W ooz
Wmcn >- W Z Q 1 a'm� V
020 ,Qj W W L CL J J V
U cn U CL C7 a O z 0
i a z cc U(u a
V
m
C)
3
T
r
m
m
0
Z
2
m
a
Im
r
m
r
m
O
In
m
Z
m
Im
a°
X
O
3
�v
N
M
O
2
m
c
V
m
-ni
W
m
N
Z
O
2
a
X
O
c
m
r
w
m
v
O
2
m
m
W
H
Z
c
M
IN
In
X
0
c
n
3
m
z
Z
v
m
0
av
v
70
m
Z
-I
m
n
N
3D0
r rn r
��
000
rnXz
Nm
rn�
z0
M Drn
z
M r) z
�Zrn
�Dz
,.Z� O
= r' N
o mcoow
n�Ln
M z w
70 D
�DLn
o <z
_ p
coLo
ol
>z�
p r O
o
2 z D
m,z
ca Wrn
Do -ciN
0
p0°
3-�6
z "'
c3z
Lorne
p N
z-lo
00 v
MO-
N
0070
rn �o
LO
pzrn
MGM
m
.1 5
' r
p
003
O Lr
c�
Z
9
'a
V
rp
rp
O
M
Z
3
m
Imo-
y a
�v
v
X
Xj
rt
T
G)
Z
a
m
3
r
m
m
z
G7
a
m
n
c�
3
U2
C
a�
U)
V
n
a,'
O
O
CL
U2
rt
I"
m
m
H
Z
n
I"
m
X
m<
t�
CL
a)
rt
m
`,
t
i
r
DO
P)
m
n
3
r
Ti
Z
77
D
n
n
TI
Ti
D
n
Z
-I
L
n
v
a
v
v
0
0
v
L
n
n
p
r
n
TI
Z
7
L
n
D
v
O
c
m
r
N
m
v
O
2
X
m
.-.
W
Z
c
M
w
In
0
c
n
3
m
Z
Z
a
X
0
v
v
X
m
Z
m
n
N
0 D O
�� rn
c�
�
Mn
0
Z 0
rn z
v) m
z
�G) 0 �
rn D
�Co
z
D
Mzn
D Z
Z
2o000
rnDoW Ln
m Z w
MG)D
T D U-)
0�3
-I '��' z
2 a
mm
W
p
�z
�
pn0
D C
z
m, G) z
co Do
n
D --I ►v
0
p0C)
3 o
"' Z
'
C3z
vi rn p
p N
z -i o°
molp � v
N
0�rn
MO
V) �c
p z rn
M
3rn--q
rn 0 D
O
71X
p r
O
OW co
O
z
i
9
�a
ID
ul
UD
T
rt
O
0
S
Z
a
mm
z
m
nG -I
\l m
v
-1�
X1,
�J
LE
C
��11
�\
m
m
11
Z
G)
a
m
I1�-1 \,-�
n
rD
3
rt
O
m
�c
M
fD
�Q
i
n
ai
O
1
CL
U2
FIP
r"
m
m
v
X
H
Z
n
r
m
a
X
rm
u
CL
fu
rt
CD
#r
n
f�
4w
� H
w
�1
J
W
V
Z
ce
a
W
Q
W
J
0.
`/
'C
m
CL
O
s
Y
L
O
a
V
� r
a
a C
� e
i C
O
U
u ,
W
D
D
Q
i.:
a�
s
Ln Z
H O
M LL
m 0
O /\
Q 0 W
ca
Q W
W z W
�Ln Ln
a �
�0
N Q
z
C)
w�
W
a Z:)
In J H
C)
ozry
WHO
U m m
z z I-
0U�
O
w w 0°
0 W
I-
a��
Qa�
(D
rrj Z J
Ln U
Mmw
00�=-
2
OQ�
U Z ,._,
Q (D
o H
CD U
0-'
a
(7 UJ
0w
z LU W
M0z
0w0
WmV)
020
UcnU
a
Q
V
W
2
F-
J
z
W
ce
O
O
I—
W
a
O
z
F-
z
W
U
D
O
W
H
z
M
W
W
ce
H
O
W
J
W
ce
Q
0
ce
W
2
z
w
W
C13
U
W
rl
m
W
H
O
0
oC
a
LU
l
J
y i
m
+�
LU
Y
R ^n
cn
D
FW--
k ce
O
W
O
QO
W
a
WLU
z
i
a
Ln Z
H O
M LL
m 0
O /\
Q 0 W
ca
Q W
W z W
�Ln Ln
a �
�0
N Q
z
C)
w�
W
a Z:)
In J H
C)
ozry
WHO
U m m
z z I-
0U�
O
w w 0°
0 W
I-
a��
Qa�
(D
rrj Z J
Ln U
Mmw
00�=-
2
OQ�
U Z ,._,
Q (D
o H
CD U
0-'
a
(7 UJ
0w
z LU W
M0z
0w0
WmV)
020
UcnU
a
Q
V
W
2
F-
J
z
W
ce
O
O
I—
W
a
O
z
F-
z
W
U
D
O
W
H
z
M
W
W
ce
H
O
W
J
W
ce
Q
0
ce
W
2
z
w
W
C13
U
W
rl
m
W
H
O
0
oC
a
W
J
V
z
H
ce
CL
W
U)
Q
W
J
IL
`O
W
a
C7
z
H
W
W
x
r?
:J
W
J
H
a�
a�
s
0
W
D
D
a
� {J
0
W
(7
a z
G7
a
_
i
pp
1
-
0
M LL
m0
i
-j Q z
¢mw
QLu
F-
U) Q
Z W
�Uo
V) p
(� a �
o° LU
N Q C)�
� 0
Z
CD <
wLn
w
z F-
Q�z
L r) -J H
oHg
C)
z�
w�O
Umm
0 Z ,z_, H
Q
OUP
m a0
owm
a w
2
H
Q
Q Q fn
,. Z J
Ln j U
M m w
°oN 0 I=-
2
O Z �
Z Q
U �
Lij
Q (D 14
oaW
WU)
W Z LU
O LL O
�mU)
W
a Q
O -rO
IE
�.
m
a
Y
R ^n
a J�
k ce
O
QO
i
W
J
V
z
H
ce
CL
W
U)
Q
W
J
IL
`O
W
a
C7
z
H
W
W
x
r?
:J
W
J
H
a�
a�
s
0
W
D
D
a
� {J
0
W
(7
a z
G7
a
_
i
pp
1
-
0
M LL
m0
i
-j Q z
¢mw
QLu
F-
U) Q
Z W
�Uo
V) p
(� a �
o° LU
N Q C)�
� 0
Z
CD <
wLn
w
z F-
Q�z
L r) -J H
oHg
C)
z�
w�O
Umm
0 Z ,z_, H
Q
OUP
m a0
owm
a w
2
H
Q
Q Q fn
,. Z J
Ln j U
M m w
°oN 0 I=-
2
O Z �
Z Q
U �
Lij
Q (D 14
oaW
WU)
W Z LU
O LL O
�mU)
W
a Q
O -rO
IE
V
a
n
M
n
3
r
q
m
In
X
O
z
2
m
a
W
r
m
r
m
2
m
v
z
m
W
a
X
O
3
V
M
M
O
m
U)
C
W
V
m
W
m
m
z
G1
m
X
V
O
C
X
r
m
v
O
X
m
..
w
3
z
c
rn
ul
In
X
0
c
A
3
m
z
z
v
m
O
v
v
m
W
JZ
1
m
A
2
N
o =o
3rrn
0
00
m�z
rn
V) m
z
�G)0
a
MGo
D
mzc)
�zz
�Zo
= r N
=M °O
rnWw
�C
rnzw
')
D
<m
=�z
WLrn
p
>z�
pn0
moo
Z
rn,z
co w C)
rn
>Zo
°o°
Z -j o
z � "'
c3z
m
cn p N
Z
O
° O V
rn
O °rn
V �O
°zrn
M G) cn
3m>
M 0 D
ZX�
p r
O
O00
n�
O�z
I
r�
U2
T
rt
n
p
V
rr
S
a GI
3 m
M Z
a
3
3 �
r
m
v
rn
3
M �\
Ma
z r.
c�
a m
m
rn
v
N
� Z
n
n
c�
'a
fD
u
f�D
G
r
m
U2
m
CL
a)
rrt
m
`�
won�
V
M
n
3
V
r
m
v
�O
3
IZ
m
a
W
r
m
r
m
ZI
m
v
M
z
2
m
W
a
X
O
3
V
X
X
O
2
m
C
V
m
n
W
m
N
z
2
m
X
v
0
C
X
m
r
m
v
O
X
m
w
z
c
M
m
M
0
c
n
3
m
z
z
a
X
O
v
v
M
Z
m
n
2
w
ncn�
W
m
V '
n
1
a
G
O
3 rn
O
Z w
v
�rnn
W
d
a �
V
M
n
3
V
r
m
v
�O
3
IZ
m
a
W
r
m
r
m
ZI
m
v
M
z
2
m
W
a
X
O
3
V
X
X
O
2
m
C
V
m
n
W
m
N
z
2
m
X
v
0
C
X
m
r
m
v
O
X
m
w
z
c
M
m
M
0
c
n
3
m
z
z
a
X
O
v
v
M
Z
m
n
2
w
ncn�
z
V '
O =O
D r
rD
a
A m
m
3 rn
m
Z w
v
�rnn
�
a �
000
3
v
� ; ° z
m
zO
;
M D
G)
X
r
�m
�o
e
q G) D
mzn
�zz
=<o
=S N
r
w C)
mooW
I
�1
n;� Ln
r- Z w
-►
DN
r�
N
<rn
oN°
a
>z�
°
v
0,o a
m oo
m
�
mpz
Wcm
D-lo
00°
_r
3 --� o
G
z "'
-cl 3 z
'tea
L/) M
> C)
c�D
° N
D
ja
c
O °rn
���
�✓
° z rn
��
O
�G�cn
�.
i m D
z co
z0>
o
X r
p r
O
o
�
O
W
n�
'v
o�
a
VIA A
ff+
ma
r
m
m
Ma
H
n
rn
a
U2
m
CL
2)
r+
m
LM,
n
1 IrA
LLJ
H
cn
a
O �
co
CL
O
CL
s
3 �
v
L
7
C1
O
CL
fzlo
:
U �
W
ce
°
a
1�
Q
s
J
a �
.c
a
W
V
L
°'
a
W
O
W
Lu,
a
LU
W
J
°
z
a
L"L
W
°
W
W
O
O.
x
Q
z
I
(n Z
Ln 0
�O
m
o�
Q 0 W
CO
< LU
wzw
D L
(Y L °
�
QO
N ¢
i
n 0 Z
o
C)Q
w tn
W
Q
Ln
CD
400
oZcr
�:DO
U m m
U
Z Z f-
C', Q
0U0
v O
Ln m
W W w
o =
�-
Q F-
QQ se
rZ-� J
Ln } U
M CO w
CD CO
ON 0 �-
_
Z Q
U
Q (D t1
Z z
('�
0 0 cl�
F- W LJ
Z � W
0 LL 0
wCO Ln
0 = 0
U Ln U
cc
a
_
U
W
_
H
J
z
W
°
a
O
W
a
°
z
H
z
W
U
n
0
ce
LL
W
W
H
z
w
M
W
W
_
H
0
W
N
N
J
W
a
O
°
W
_
C9
z
W
m
v
W
m
W
2
0
ce
ce
a
O
w
w
m
W
_
F-
z
m
Q
t-L
°
W
_
LL
t
W
J
W
J
m
Fa-
W
H
z
0
°
W
W
J
a
O
U
W
U
a
O
01
'C
O° v
Y
L
3
ch
w 'E
W
4w
H �
aO
i
.j
a�
W 9
V
Z�
a�
FLU
V1 W
W °
J L7
z
a W
`IOO W
x
s
0
L
J
a �
.c
W
J p
H �
W�
D
W
oc
a z
C
Ae
a:+
a
G1
c
LA
i
fl.
o�C
I=
Z
V)O
m0
o�
¢mw
QW
a
w
LU
0
W
p
�LU �
Q u
LLJ
N Q
C)Oo
¢
N C
Lu
Qz
Ln
C)oh
0
U m m
(�
C,�DQ
0UD
m �-qO
owm
w
W >
< 6
Lo Q¢Wa'
M z -Luj
L.n>U
M CO W
oN JO I-
_
ZQ�
U
z z
0 (D W
�QLU
(7
F- W ( j
Z W W
D 0 Z
0w0
wto V)
JJ
Q
0=0
_
U
W
J
z
0
ce
°
0
I-
W
a
°
z
I-
z
W
U
O
LL
LA
W
H
z
n
M
W
W
_
0
W
t~i
J
W
a
O
IF
ce
W
_
z
N
W
m
U
W
m
W
_
0
0
a
O
9
°ce
m
W
H
z
H
°
W
r
W
J
W
J
m
H
W
_
E-
z
i
ce
0
°
W
H
W
J
a
O
U
W
U
a
U
Gl
L
E 13
W �
Fm ., cn
C
a
'C
m
O
s
L
\I'
0
U
Gl
L
E 13
W �
Fm ., cn
J
c
Q
W
V
Z
H
ce
a
FLU
w W
Q a
W °
J z
a
W
W
:,u
t
L
s
O
v
W
D
Q
I'N�I 41
_ t L
W G
LU J
i � a
am
oQ
W L
a z c°7c
Z
t O
U
m0
O 0
cz
J Q ~
QOw
m
awe
t7--ra
W z W
D V
aL °
mC)
o
low
N Q
i
O z
O
N
W
Q
Lo -J
d- O C)
oz�
U m m
z (5 W
z � H
�DQ
Ova
00 O
owm
o E W
H
Q>O
cn Q
Q0w
Lrn j U
C� 0o LL
°0 0 1z-
zap
U ,.z.,
a c~n
Q W
ce ce
w
W
M�z
0LL0
Wm�
0 =0
U Ln U
°
W
2
z
w
W
m
U
W
m
W
H
0
ce
O
ce
CL
r 11F
C
a
J
c
Q
W
V
Z
H
ce
a
FLU
w W
Q a
W °
J z
a
W
W
:,u
t
L
s
O
v
W
D
Q
I'N�I 41
_ t L
W G
LU J
i � a
am
oQ
W L
a z c°7c
Z
t O
U
m0
O 0
cz
J Q ~
QOw
m
awe
t7--ra
W z W
D V
aL °
mC)
o
low
N Q
i
O z
O
N
W
Q
Lo -J
d- O C)
oz�
U m m
z (5 W
z � H
�DQ
Ova
00 O
owm
o E W
H
Q>O
cn Q
Q0w
Lrn j U
C� 0o LL
°0 0 1z-
zap
U ,.z.,
a c~n
Q W
ce ce
w
W
M�z
0LL0
Wm�
0 =0
U Ln U
°
W
2
z
w
W
m
U
W
m
W
H
0
ce
O
ce
CL
r 11F
Collier County : News Releases l • Page 1 of
A,2. . 1 B
Communication & Customer Relatio ,,,n ,. ,
News Releases
Encouraging Decisions and Positive Changes in the Works for Immokalee
Posted Date: 5/15/2012
Encouraging Decisions and Positive Changes in the Works for Immokalee
On Tuesday, May 8,the Board of County Commissioners(BCC)agreed to release a lien on a property in
Immokalee that had reached over$405,000 in accrued fines for non-comp iance of the county's Land
Development Code for more than five years. Property owner, Mrs. Rolando Salazar, had continued working
with the county to make the appropriate changes and bring the property into compliance with county
codes, after her husband passed away in March 2011.Thanks to the continued efforts of the property
owners to make the required changes the county's Code Enforcement Department recommended that the
liens be waived and the commissioners agreed.
Commissioner Jim Coletta, District 5, said that property owners such as Mrs. Salazar should be commended
for doing the right thing.
"In these difficult economic times,we want to be able to assist people in bringing their properties into
compliance and that is what the Code Enforcement Department has done so diligently in this case and in
many other such cases,"said Commissioner Coletta."Waiving the lien was a good faith effort by my fellow
commissioners to support the property owner who helped her neighbors and her entire community by
showing them how to follow the county codes and agreeing to continue to keep property up to county
codes,"added Commissioner Coletta.
County codes were developed to maintain the integrity of communities as well as to address health,safety
and welfare issues. By complying with the codes,the community will benefit by having better property
values which will in turn benefit the county with a good tax base. More than $10 million dollarsin_fines
have been wain iveedd by the BCC,Code Enforcement Board,and Special Magistrate in the past several years.
Another item to better assist residents in Immokalee is the Immokalee Mobile Home Park Land
Development Code(LDC) amendment that is currently under review.The county is working with the Mobile
Home Park owners in Immokalee to develop a LDC that addresses health, safety, and welfare issues and
also takes into consideration the economic impacts of items that do not have a direct impact on health,
safety and welfare issues.
Some of the items under consideration are:
• removing the time limit for when a nonconforming mobile home park must get a Site Improvement Plan
(SIP);
• making the SIP process voluntary;
• mobile home parks that get an approved SIP will then be legal mobile home parks and be allowed to
replace units;
• mobile home parks that do not go through the SIP process will remain nonconforming and be subject to
the nonconforming provisions(i.e. may not be allowed to replace units); and
• removing the procedural/application content requirements, which will be incorporated into the
Administration Code.
Meetings have been scheduled with the Collier County Planning Commission(CCPC) and the BCC to
approve the changes.The location for all the meetings listed below is in the BCC chambers,third floor,
Collier County Government Center, 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Naples.
CCPC LDC Meeting Thursday,July 19, 2012 9 a.m. - 5 p.m.
CCPC LDC Meeting Thursday,Aug. 2, 2012 9 a.m. - 5 p.m.
BCC LDC Meeting 2 Tuesday, Nov. 13, 2012 9 a.m. - 5 p.m.
The meetings will be broadcast live on Collier Television on Comcast channel 97, and via colliergov.net.
http://www.colliergov.net/index.aspx?recordid=19744&page=18 5/21/2012
E
1 Bi N
cc
an
cu
z Q
W
'C Z m O =
} Z m m o N 0. O m co u_ t
0 c
�� Z _
t _i Q ^^ ) i p U
V) 8 o ¢ ow U ¢ wI- CO
I- Ca _ I- 1- a I-
2 = < F. .0 wzw W
Z
To WCw Z y.� a. CL Ln 1-1 O H
`� n ty . o O 7'F p�w0 U) O
•�` ace W re" ', � 0 ° Q o CeCIU C4
Ot , ILI 0
,-, °¢ ce ° ^ oz Q a ri 0 Q L °CD H 0 ¢ O E
Ela (2 H °o ~ Q O s o "' `n O
L N ° +.1 Z I- O
a 4a z " H oWC a , 0 „Q � p p
ma H O ¢ 5z Q = °' o � g Z IX
Q Q
c ° ! ' z w is (-1
o z ce in O
CU 7, oOp Q al y cv1- ¢ I- co
Z tY E w m m W W
a Umm z i, Qz = Z
Z I-
0� W poa
0 ���ssss---- G Odo 0 G
Ov . R ° m .¢ } W
G � � ¢ �\ Q � cnm 0 =
Q co °L J 1 ZZ � � n o
J 1-4 zEz � � O
ri W * 1 � < L
. 612 '5 Q 0 Qa � J uj
¢ .J �' w a W I Zw m
c■1 ' 4 L � U ^ V om = W I-
A co Lii Ai M O 0 1- W
V r NOH W v NJ = GC =iij I"
__I 1 C� ' z < 1- z
Z n zap 1- 1..1 j UAW 0 0
y Q W CL UHF zI-
O
re i Z ° 4 ° pC7U ~ LL IU
CL W ° � UU I- U1 ce N W OU
LU r ¢ wW Ce E ~ , a n i- U w
W
17 ` a w (n J Q W C Z Ce
Q d
Q Cr W _ o a W C7 _ OU � � O
W ° ,�.� ° o ° J Z Q a � m � o U
C7 C Uwe w ° W ., L _i~ W
CL ' ' Z W w
ta w m ~ O `I W
LU �Wp Q O2O J
`S W W p, J --� � !D tt Z OC UcnU a
E Q Z rt OU1oU u. � �/_
14B1 i
0 = 0 co a C) ) m "'
SD I- V > m m 3I- cp m 2 '1 v
3
m �� rn m v N o 4rnn = G ro
co c� — z r 117
0 C ~ ,min N 117 > zOOc = rn D
a z � Oc �Jrn a > m mmrnz t\ � 3 m
rn m xi rnz 3 m � z � fD
m
m -ii z 0 ,O-r Imo- M 3 X D � 4 r r rn
D 3 rnDO ■P rn G) 1--1 f m WV
_ � m 73
o m � zz = D 1IG)) z
v -I 0 z n J 0 z ,� H
3 -i min \/ ,
D i
2 * zz Z x _ _ P � N .1
—1 2 � � O r
r tv
2 70 rN �� m iOo
m m HOo �' ■. r=nc0oo °w '
a w ncao v rz,w F.
CCI m 3 MGD U `v rn Z XD (I)
m Z TDB CA � -I 0 � 3 Xi
Cm O < z l -n rnHo
-I 0 mmm 73 pro a `./
D O � � � C C o � � m
a C o r-
> X 7 Y n -I 0 0
n o -0 n 3 izn n
2 3 = z � n 3 rn� z m
= 3 m� z CD > m acm 3
m m co corn 3 -1 DHN rn tin
00 -I DANO ozp Lp =t CD
0 °cz) O a O � m
> > 3 -I o j IC .= D z � D -I M.
D D r_ N > c3 o .<
7p a c > O r --a a m F l o _ , , CU
0 X i. m o CD P (D o o n 1■1
3 -1 > oo - H 0 zHC) �. m , Pt
o z -1p 77 rim
> ° N ( [D
w a o' N I CC (D 0 m 00 _
p D rn > -p = 70 nom \„3,-
_.
73-1 m O m rn -s Nf 0 t A Uf u) x o 1 (I)
0cnc s ,a 1* o 0Zrn �'� n ts
2- 0 ozrn cD � � � ( ci
m 2 m � cn -C D -I -I
x 2 = 2
C
CD � 3W �
2 3rn -I * I m OD O !!--C��
n m m0D O- 2 � 73 r vii lam'
- 2 4 � r 0 E±: N o3 (b s
m 00 3 7o O0 'Oa
i A OO W 'OC n
6) n 71 O cn Co
= Oc -I c zcn tO
> � 0
D rt ��
4 14B1 4
ck
d1 F- a z 4
C0 II � O
CO (nn0 >. 0 =
>. C9
>_ U 0 mp �Zi
0 m0 c OJ0 Q m
,C Owi. _ JOz u 0
O Q o W 0 O 1 m W W
W � W = �
W Q I- m
3 . = iI- H HHa >. u)
I- Q >- ( LT) (_ w Z W
cnC7w '� �� WzD
.v Wzp z d w
(~n (n I=-
O i5w0 0 c'aiO W 0 Ce It 0
�Ce O W mow D
E i W G i N Q ce in 0
A d° a &I re O I- z 0 o.
O H Q 0 H G 7 O �W W 0
i. N � O t DI- W Lu a� W w re `p 0. C Q �I-I 4 re 0
CC
0 QEn a 'a 1- ( ln -jz 0 0
�-' Z_ G1 O Z Cd
C at
o � g Z I% o00 a a
i i � zce U w IP
1'J � � Q 0
d n NIHQ f' W 0=000 W W
Q U m m Z a O Z W S =I-
Qom= L z � H. 0 N CD
L.
z � l- 0 _ U p � H U Z U)
Uf W Q
a0 _ o m C
ce
ozo D
0 0 .� z Q }
Q Z � __ m � W
�\ a cn o re a W W w O2 F-
�" LL
CC •�••/' Z t-� cry
Z H W re 5 0 I- 17
e Q �jI-
O I- Q r % cn Q Z J
Q
UJ aa � Z W Qzw X uj
Ln '-' U ^ M00 W .. a
Oom = W `� NO = W cL =LLI
Imm ` N O = _ \ i Z z ~ = Z
Z 1 z ¢ 1- I■4 w � � 0 0
Uzw li 0 QC7fW- 0 t2
\,., cu ¢ � � 0 a = zz . W 0
MI V C Z Z 4 W W + O i (9 W N LL
v a W �� 0 IM 0 (7W 1~i UJ F o � � w
W H a;, o0 w rii) Fes- d � wci J H
W F. d � W (j J /� H a ZWW J
Q a W c � ° z ° ' W c I- o ° o a
W a ~,
= o ° o J Z a � m � r1
'J Z a U) � 0° � O} a I"' Z W L in - -� U
a W W X O 1-1 J Z �/ W Ue a O 0 = 0 4
`� W L9 4 a� 0 = 0 5 4 Z OC UcnU a
5 4 Z ce U (n U —
14B1
4
CD
} 0 Z 4C
Ct
Of
01 = In z W
3 � z CO � O =
w
CO } p 0 mo �C w
fl. mu. s O0 a FFW ea
CO 0 ~ Y 5 H = U
Y O = ¢ m W I.V. W
` 0 ¢ OW tJ 3 ¢ wl- m
J < CO g = 2 2 H Q
¢ w 1- I- ¢ >-
c R a ..I
Ta `� H1- ¢ >- V %J- , zW Z W
O fl, ., CL � o 0 I— � awc, ton O
to n v) p to -py L W O W F-
E i o w 1-11 O W / E � � W Q CC et
= wa0 fx 7 Nam Q 0
CI) al
N ¢ � 0 off °z a0 a
°1 ^ O °z a Q H �. `' No ¢ I- 5
Imi s 0Iw- w cd H ¢ � z a it Q P -J1-1 c
� O °
a° cc n
o= moo z a ° 1- ¢ co
CA 0 z o Z l- 0 Z f M w Q `� z0° w E la
114
o
U m m W
z W i = f Z z
z � I- w
tJ z 1- U V W 0 0 ¢ Q a
W w n Q U 0 O V G N
GC -� 0 >- z ¢ ›. Q
0 � z ° G ^ a co re =
Q m �� ›. W W w O I-
a ww °° 0 J zEE w
1--1 LLI= LL. I W > � W
.■I w � W > a6o IS W
Ce Q6o '6 1 a Qa � z
CE , V) ¢ Y Z ! W zJ f
W oz z � I J . Lt) j_ ■V CO
'-' U ^ I V o m = I-m Mmw t 0001- W W
V 00 = uj I ~ C{�, zz � = I-
O z � = 1 Z W z � p Z 0 H � � � I ai azc~n Q cd I/i / ��' G7 ¢ z � W 1 W o pC7w N u.
Ii `6 W 0 pC7U N i W H a OUP w 0
W M y
IP oz2 W F- a � "' u"' W W
//\ H x 1,� a r w (n W j Q
I- W C � � Z Q a
CE c LLr� c roz CC a : W a omo o' c�°,
LLI J w } W W E L aa
C W W E E JJz `/ a Z 0 = 0 Cl.Ln`I/ 2 Q Z cd uv) uU h. I
14 81 "Pi
c 4
4
C N- Z
3 I _
_
CO (1) 0
U W
m (1) O
fl.
u-
m) Z
U O m i J\ C m 0 rt =
v Y OCL I— 2 O QmW W W
Q
° I QmW "' _ _ � ~
a W I- _ = 2 I- Q >- D
. (1) W p, n in l-
a)
� °� O y� w �O 0
et
th a W IY m °CI Cd w O W LU
, , ° W O AO ° 4 CC
(N ° 0 ~ L ° IW- w UWG 0
H L �, ° W a 4+-' z � l ,i4
0 u.i 10 Ili �' c Q � � a IV �, O of °Z IX
,r, � z 0 C C 4000 4 s
= a' J 9F. g Z W ++ z � 4 ci) O
` V� o °z ° 4
a
CD z u
o I U m m W =
W m m W Q U
Q = x z
IT) z W x L" Z Z I- O 14
Q
ce Z = f U ° V m i '-' 1-- O ' W n Q a V ' '° � V i OJ U O 0¢ G 0 -
Ov ° 3 , G �Q W
'--,,,k'12 m
� Q � i �. 4 —0 re
° _ O —• Loci;„. W W W ' W > W
1 Z w > O ~ uj
Q I- D
12 5 O I
Q0 = Q Q Z J Q
Q � \ Q � ce ` W � } U ^ m
W z � J N MmW a
W F'
N ` � m W V o 0 I- W W
V N0 � W L. I tY ` N, Oz � 2 I-
= pWG Z Q I.. Z
Z zap H Psi z � w O E L:
ci O Q U (n I—
D C CL W O ° 7w N LL
Z
W fa
C. 1 W O 0 , 0 N u I— P” + C� N W
J � Q E C W I— CL FW (� J W
W t O2 - .1 f � F X r a 1Ww w J
/� W I"• CL r W cn W U Q W C 2 c Z Q CL
Q o W = r0z a 2 W Z a a Umo o c°�
W (�z C UWU7 0 C J H Z W i JJ� } U
, 11 a °° >. D.
Cm H Z W i0„ w J z L `� W (W� Q 0 OiO J
'W W p, -IQ2 a E 4 z Cr UcnU CL
`d f a z re OU c=n OU G.
X z a 3 0 = 0 .4 3
A 1- r- 3 z �, 3r0 m �\
m r rn m _ p .4 m c m C Z
f1 O cn °0 � zing p in p7 X fD a z 17
3 C O o 0 CI
C rn C DTo •,,•
G1
rn
a z c a z � c = r"> m
i_
m � rnz c\ al > xi mrnz m 3 _1
X.
m
1,
m � � o = -� rn X6-, 0 rt / rn
O m GI = .0 m ( zz = -- nu
74 0 3 m ,� z m z I . f X
O 0 � zrn 0 xzm _1�> `> I∎I
z -I z z i ADZ T z
-I = -i -< O < C 7p , _ .4 o 1' .
a rn w n ^ m c W / n
c:
Oro .. rnzW r v - W r
73 > !� III 3 73u,> rn
Z cc> h- > z > } a
-1 -ii Oaz • 1 0 3 Lf I T1
O cmn � cz ~
ll -I < z y , ~
-4 17 m 0 TI m � 0
= p D^ oo `� OO C `�
M
O � z -t C 0 � z � CI
C DcX m : ,� C DcX m
C -1 oo n C -1 o0 u) 4_./+ n
z 3 = z > '-, n 3 = D ` _�'
3 rn� z ♦ as > 3 m- z as
X z 0crn 3 z co %A') 3
co �! jOz °o •, r. � m � z55 al as CD
a > ° off _ -t > ooh E' = =
X z 3 -io / m z z —I0 - to
0 0 z � D ,,`` -1 O. 0 z � D j -I O.
O 7o rn I O S V'i ran 3
O m rnN co . - m v' mN cD ... H
15 0 zo ° Chi rt o z -�io rt
a o. CD a o o N m CD
G 0 rn 00 1-\ D rn 0 71-4 m � p rn r �O � rn
0 � 0 �`� Cl), O cm�n ,---- V)
.O
m Z 0zrn n O Ozrn I n
z rn N
tw
La _ = mom " * _ = mom
A A z p m rn p D 'a O
'I 2 -� xr 7� _ -zj � � t to D'i O s Om ,.., O N O . .
c 'a o c - 1i-
> a z
O -1 C co O _co
c -1'�' zv) a z � a
a m
v rt
141
111
ke
4.+
a) cn cr
'C U) G 17 NZ W
O (1" = m c~n Q =
CO U U
mw 0. mw OG N
O.
CO N ,� oQ `"' W
En
Y J a i_ _ L J Q ~ _
C Q Q w W O Q m W W W
QwF�- I=.. QWH I- m NM
ra
y �� � � p O .G7 Wzp Z 1
`�. cn 5 , o aw ° U) 0
�T c O'er, m' W G� W a' W I-
C Apo \ � pWO C 0
i� NQ �c a W °, o `" ¢ p Q 0
� r. CU O �� CDI- 0 a
L Np < I- H i 0Q
H X N W O O W W W w
� a 4 .0 p a O Qc. z
O Q � H o E � oc
wri )• Z O
un O O
C _ ci- o p a + 1- op a 4
CD
F- Q I-
CA W CD p NH ¢ H m
al CLI
wp0 Z W m0 W W
a Qom= aZ= Z
�. z Z 1- O v Z I- O 1-1
Vf ,_ cA p p H U
U L p p 1- U Vf
W c = Q W J Q
Ce
z>.
O= Q
0u0 O G zce > C
� � Q �a O W
/'N wm� ^ a 0w ° o H
zW
H j Z
CI i
LLI W U.
� -N c-%. Q u _ W W aw a � F.w aU -
j Z J W .. Z J _I � (L J
,J � >" U M V Q LL CU O W QI- W V om = W Q NJO = _= (i z• c = Z zz z Z w 2 O O c uz � C - j W 2 H i 4 iO s Q (.7 ) G L z (.9 l- C� � Qt O
• ' W ~a Ni W ¢ W ~ 1 D W Q 1-i W W o (�W V I- L9
W a a �j /\ W W U)
-a lim ce a z � W e W a _ = � z a a a c F - o . o W � =Z _ ,ft`� _ um � c ..I a a) ce mn U
a {A ...1--4
M W H
Om W
0. W W Z a. JQZ `_ W W f 0. JQ0 aU
`� w Q z 0 = 0 E a Z cc uV ccn QV n.n.
1
4B1 „, i
w n cn n 74 Z a 3
-a n cn n 73 Z a 3 a 0 D O 'a a m m /'\
a 3 D r- "C 3 m m m , m ( m Z
3 r �p m a Z
Z -< cn
A N ai XI r"- a Z r O C 6 W n 1.1
A
O O ~ rnn r ~ O rn 3 a OO ° = -i 0 a
'30 zOZ gyp( m m x --1 t\
r m � rn �= 3 m r � z � x �'., m VA
m rn .., �/ m ,.., G� O _r
O 3 rn 0 _. ^ r
m > O f ' r pt rn 1� D o l� \ m ■ '�
O 3 � D X = r p -n - rn o F-'
rn0o �, � m O m z
0 m ( � z o : 3 0 H � z g
3 _1 rn ~ n .. ■ . 1 0 � z ,n,, ►�, 1=1
O O Z
� zm ,i Z `� zz
Z 2 * z0 _' 1 Z1 2 = = -< O 41
= = 1- . 3 _I m m H O o N
m m = mo -� a 1-2 rnW ° n
ar-. rnoow N W ... n ~ w o
m 3 rn � w rn r Z � D � rn
m Z 7Dn , a 4 EI 023 a
m Oi3 O m = < z
O = � z IL m rnrnr
m
_ Opp r=rl --C Dz W 0 `�
a C > ro m t/f A DC0 �\ A
v' A -D-I o 0 Vf n Z O -I z z V' 1 =e'
p � z cn 3 = � D n_
..� 3 rn0z = m oovon a
rn
v' Xzo ii,G0 --I D H o
O En ,- zo _+; > a ° 13 =
° 0. X Z 3 H o to
M > Z -Io in = 0 0 zif. ' -I Q.
O 0 c3D O .� O. 0 -i3z
70 a ,_, z rt .a nh s e N
p m � rnN) cm `. 3 -I D0oo .. !"F
D o .. 0 z 0 H
3 -I o F.y 'v z O �6
-a 0 zoo •--- ig ry a N (D
73 a pO , 0 mD ' L- itil
c
ry �D O rn
O 0 rn0 -p 7o npm a �"`
70 , n0x a, 3 -� m Ohm y.�
_i m Ohm p m ocmn`c_ Stu'
= O v' 2r �T m Z mc, � a D R.
m Z � zvmi n ''�- 0 D -I -I c'� f
C - D -I -1 co co C ..{ x2 =
CD � rn � =
LI _ rn o m rn00D A o
m m ooD i A r-
z a A 7� -(v��pr _.I• A �
-ir 7C
rn > O O = I - 73 O CO 13
Z 7:1 003 -� GI T �
CI n � I Oct c
I 0 � a co m Tao s c°to
p Pp
p rrr
� i � Lease Agreement JUAOX
�/ g
SCHOOL FACILITIES LEASE AGREEMENT
THIS LEASE, entered into this 24 day of 201 Z by and between the School District of Collier County,
Florida, hereinafter referred to as the District, and 1�ipq (�D p F eoyw�T'i CDM wt LSS ► On)E(L herein after
referred to as the User.
WITNESSETH: The parties to this lease have agreed that the following terms and conditions shall be applicable to the lease of any
of the District facilities described herein.
1. School Board Policy No. 7510 as amended and the implementing procedure (see attached) shall lbbe incorpor�ateed by
�
reference into this lease, and the parties agree to be bound by the terms and conditions found herein. %g►1ft ryttA
2. The following information is presented by the User in order to obtain the requested facilities and the User affirms that
said facts are true and correct t the best of its knowledge and belief:
Name ofSchool: 1MMOKAL_l_E 91 C.41+ Is meeting free to public:
Dates Requested: j orIE ( i Zp Z What price is charged to attend:
Number of Meetings: ONE Name of User's President: C oM M t 5 S i or\I E 12 ay Le
Hours of Use: l 2, Ndotj — 1Z MID NIGHT Phone Number of User's President: 23y - 2 5 Z - 809 �-
(Please use hours: Example 4 p.m. to 6 p.m.) Name of User's Treasurer:
Anticipated Allen nce: 00 Phone Number of User's Treasurer:
Purpose of Use: t0Lt C M Ee -rkt4 (a Users Email Address: '�qiJ (11t'i CNEI I. Coy �-1 CrOQ . T16j'
Furnishings or Special Preparations Needed: 'TNy. ME e-rir1 V IS -T b 8 E. -Tf LEVISE D
Please Check (x) Facilities Needed:
_1
O Classroom Basic or Portable
Auditorium (All High Schools
( ) Football /Soccer /Track (no lights)
O Cafeteria/Multi- Purpose Room
Except Gulf Coast)
( ) Football /Soccer /Track (with lights)
O Small Multi- Purpose Room
( ) Auditorium (Gulf Coast High)
( ) Softball /Baseball Field (no lights)
O Media Center
( ) Ad Center Board Room
( ) Softball /Baseball Field (with lights)
O Gymnasium (Middle School)
( ) Ad Center Training Room
O Practice Field
O Gymnasium (High School)
( ) Resource Room
O Storage Closet
User is a corporation, association, or entity lawfully authorized to enter into this lease agreement. User further agrees that it will use
the premises in an appropriate manner consistent with applicable laws, State Board of Education Rules, the policies and procedures of
the District School Board of Collier County School Board and the directions of the facilities administrator in charge of the facilities
being leased. User is responsible for comppfiance by all persons covered this lease with Florida State Statutes #1012.465
CorotMiSSioNE(L F, Coy 3299TAMiA^Ai -TV-AIL -,�. y
(.E s%ii-rE 303 NAQt_ES 34112 239 2.52 09�-
P AM jj � tDRESS CITY /STATE ZIP PHONE NUMBER
`
User Signature Principal or Designee Signature Superintendent or Designee Signature
Before this lease becomes effective, it must bear all of the designated signatures of all parties, including the Superintendent or
Designee.
ALL leases expire June 30`h. Please Attach:
Continuous leases MUST be renewed prior to June 1.
Approved as to form & legal sufficiency
ATTEST.
DWIG
DWIGHT E.�BRt7CK,V10rk
Colleen Greene,
Assistant County Attorney By-
(APPLICANTS, please do not write bel e ''
ALL FATMhNj3 MU5
Certificate of Liability Insurance
Tax Exemption Certificate (if applicable)
Verification of Not-For-Profit Status (government
entity excluded)
Category "C1" Form (if applicable)
Crowd Manager Certification or Waiver Form
Payment to District School Board of Collier County
(if applicable) - After School District approval.
ADE IN ADVANCE
Rental Fee Number of Uses ' ,•X 5yT,per use= Total Rental Fee
Sales Tax of Tax Exempt I.D. # , = Total Sales Tar
Other Special Fees =Total Deposits
Additional Charges = Total Other Fees
('heck # = Total
Grand Total
Rev. 11/0 1 /2010 COPIES TO: Facilities Management Department; Accounting Department; School; User
1481
OFFICE OF THE COUNTY ATTORNEY
MEMORANDUM
DATE: May 25, 2012
TO: District School Board of Collier County
FROM: Colleen M. Greene, Assistant County Attomc( W
SUBJECT: Collier County School Board Facilities Lease Agreement Form 7510
Collier County has reviewed the attached School Facilities Lease Agreement; however pursuant
to Florida law, the County cannot agree to the indemnification language provided in Procedure
7510, Section G, regarding Proof of Liability Insurance. The County proposes to strike the
language in Section G and replace it with the following language in compliance with Section
768.28, Fla. Stat.:
"Each party shall be liable for its own actions and negligence and, to the extent
permitted by law, Collier County shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the
Collier County School Board ( "School Board ") against any actions, claims or
damages arising out of Collier County's negligence in connection with this
Agreement, and School Board shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless Collier
County against any actions, claims, or damages arising out of School Board's
negligence in connection with this Agreement. The foregoing indemnification shall
not constitute a waiver of sovereign immunity beyond the limits set forth in Florida
Statutes, Section 768.28, nor shall the same be construed to constitute agreement by
either party to indemnify the other party for such other party's negligent, willful or
intentional acts or omissions."
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
cc: Jeffrey A. Klatzkow, County Attorney
05 -COA- 01260/298
W AM h! 60 � A N 5 W e4_ R&^i .� EFV W A1,-►C,t3 .
Collier County Public School District
Excerpted from the Use of District Facilities Procedure 7510
Proof of liability Insurance:
14Bj
y gp�e( 5�3�/la
WON
f
11
Proof of insurance must
be provided at the time of application. the
f r 9
m anion -of the user-, Me employees, membew, invitaee-,-e id all od erl7emons
s
e
i
The user agrees that at all times material to this agreement, it shall provide liability
insurance amounts of $1,000,000 on any claim or judgments and $2,000,000 on all
claims and judgments arising from the same incident/occurrence. The user shall
present proof of such insurance.0 (.11Ie/C&".BotWol OF " cmimissickwis
•J sel-F- i n�Yect
General liability insurance covering bodily injury and property damage arising from l_c
use of District facilities is required. This coverage shall have limits of $1,000,000 ��"T�1 Cai-r—
per occurrence and $2,000,000 aggregate. The District School Board of Collier a{}�h�
County must be identified as a certificate holder and shall be named as an
additional insured.
For more information, read Use of District Facilities Procedure at http:/Iwww.neola.com/collier-
fl.search/AP/ap7510.htm
ACORO" OP ID: DO
��-- CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE DATE(MM/DD/YYYy)
THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOL /25R THIS
CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES
BELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUING INSURER(S), AUTHORIZED
REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER, AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER.
IMPORTANT: If the certificate holder is an ADDITIONAL INSURED, the pollcy(ies) must be endorsed. If SUBROGATION IS WAIVED, subject to
the terms and conditions of the policy, certain policies may require an endorsement. A statement on this certificate does not confer rights to the
certificate holder In lieu of such endorsement(s).
PRODUCER 239- 649 -1444 CONTAC
Insurance and Risk Management NAME:
5ervlces,Inc. 239 -649 -7933 PHONE Fax
1960 Fontana Del Sol Way 0200 .MAIL Arc No :
4a les, FL 341094374 ADDRESS:
William H. Kuhlman, CPCU, ARM PRODUCER ID a: COLLI -2
INSURED INSURERS AFFORDING COVERAGE NA
Collier County Board INSURER A: Princeton Excess a Surplus
of County Commissioners 10786
3311 Tamiami Trail East, #D INSURER B : Undsrwritere n Lioyda
Naples, FL 34112 INSURER C: "calm Excess a surplus 10786
INSURER 0:
INSURER E:
THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INUUR D NAM R ABOVEB OR THE POLICY PERIOD
INDICATED. NOTWITHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENT, TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER DOCUMENT WITH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS
CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBED HEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS,
EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES. LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIMS.
INSR S
LTR TYPE OF INSURANCE POLICY NUMBER PO IC EFF LILY EXP
GENERAL LIABILITY Dn'YYY 1. MWDD LIMITS
A X COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIABILITY EACH OCCURRENCE $ 1,000,00
Ex000001508 10/01/11 10/01/12
CLAIMS -MADE F_%'_1 OCCUR PREMISES Ea occurrence a Include
sIa s2oo 000 occ
MED EXP (Any one person) $ 1,0
A I X ! Professional Liab
GEN'L AGGREGATE LIMIT APPLIES PER
AUTOMOBILE UASIUTY
A X
ANY Auro
ALL OWNED AUTOS
SCHEDULED AUTOS
X
N
HIRED AUTOS
X
NON -OWNED AUTOS
UMBRELLA UAB X OCCUR
C X EXCESS LIAB CLAIMS
DEDUCTIBLE
URRENCE
PERSONAL d ADV INJURY S
(100,000 PER PERSON 10/01/11 10/01/12
GENERAL AGGREGATE $
PRODUCTS - COMP/OP AGG S
Prof. $
60a
$200,000 OCCURRENCE
$100,000 PER PERSON
106
COMBINED SINGLE LIMIT S
10/01/11 10/01/12 (Ea acc d.rlt)
BODILY INJURY (Per person) S
BODILY INJURY (Per accident) $
PROPERTY DAMAGE
(Per accident) S
S
S
EACH OCCURRFN(:F e
10/01/11 1 10/01/12
IWORKER$ COMPENSATION
AND EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY
A ANY PROPRIETOR/PARrNER/EXECUTIVEY /N, 64A3EX00000160a 10/01/11 10/01/12
OFFICER/MEMBER EXCLUDED? NIA
(Mandatory In NH) SIR $500,000
N yes, desaibe under
DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS below
13 Property N12NA01521
04/01H2 04!01/13
I6% Named Storm REPLACEM COST /SPECIAL
DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS / LOCATIONS 1 VEHICLES (Attach ACORD 101, Additional Remarks Sctwdule, If more space Is required)
$elf Insured Retention included within limmits of liability as allowed by
Timoka ee Higeh School. The The BCC D striect School B and of Collier 18th ounty Is
sted as additional insured as respects General Liability with Waiver of
lubronatinn_
District School Board of
Collier County, FL
5775 Osceola Trail
Naples, FL 34109
ACORD 26 (2009/09)
DISTSCI
AUUMt[iATE $
Excess $
()en. IS
$
X WC STATU- OTH-
IORY
E.L. EACH ACCIDENT S
E.L DISEASE -EAEMPLOYEO S
E. L. DISEASE - POLICY LIMIT $
"rimary
\OP Reten
1
1
1
1
1
1
SHOULD ANY OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED POLICIES BE CANCELLED BEFORE
THE EXPIRATION DATE THEREOF, NOTICE WILL BE DELIVERED IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE POLICY PROVISIONS.
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE
®1988 -2009 ACORD CORPORATION. All rights reserved.
The ACORD name and logo are registered marks of ACORD
McZ . Sy-tP CoYY%P
M2. 71 eNmis LNGutv
C oIr L, t E. jL Co v ry -� �-( �►c4 /�N
t �uLL.IEYL CoUrQT 6r^JT
Trained Crowd Manager
Any user of indoor District facilities (excluding churches) where fifty (50) people or more will be present
in any one room must have trained crowd managers present and comply with the crowd management
requirements of the Florida Fire Prevention Code ( "FFPC ") Section 101 - 12.7.6. Where the occupant
load exceeds 250, in any one room additional trained crowd managers shall be provided at a ratio of one
(1) crowd manager for every 250 occupants. A user may become a trained crowd manager by
contacting the fire department and making arrangements for training and certification. NOTE:
An opinion issued by the Florida State Fire Marshall's office eliminated the need for crowd managers at
outside events.
Requirements:
50 — 250 persons: 1 Crowd Manager
251 — 500 persons: 2 Crowd Managers
Every 250 additional persons: 1 more Crowd Manager
Those users required to have a trained crowd manager may obtain the training from any of the fire
departments listed below. A certification of completion must be submitted with the lease.
Fire Control Districts
Big Corkscrew Island Fire Department
Inspector Andy Marfongella
13240 Immokalee Road
Naples, FL. 34120
Phone: (239) 348 -8006
Fax: (239) 348 -8007
E -mail: amarfonRella@bcifr.com
East Naples Fire Department
Inspector Robert Griffin
5001 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL. 34113
Phone: (239) 774 -2800 x2820
Fax: (239) 774 -3116
E -mail: reriffin @enfd.ore
North Naples Fire Department
Deputy Fire Marshal Robert Berman
6495 Taylor Road
Naples, FL. 34109
Phone: (239) 597 -9227
Fax: (239) 597 -3522
E -mail: rberman@northnaPlesfire.com
Immokalee Fire Department
Fire Marshal Leo F. Rodgers
502 East New Market Rd.
Immokalee, FL. 34142
Phone: (239) 657 -2700
Fax: (239) 657 -9489
E -mail: Irodeers @immfire.com
City of Naples Fire Department
Inspector Pamela Demeo
355 Riverside Circle
Naples, FL. 34102
Phones: (239) 213 -4918
Fax: (239) 213 -4907
E -Mail: pdemeo @napieseov.com
Marco Island Fire Department
Chief Ray Munyon
1280 San Marco Rd.
Marco Island, FL. 34145
Phone: (239) 389 -5046
Fax: (239) 393 -0099
E -mail: rmunyon@CityofMarcoisland.com
Those users not required to have a trained crowd manager present must complete a Crowd Manager
Waiver Form (F2) attesting that the number of people present will be less than the requirements of FFPC.
Rev. 01.09.12