Agenda 12/14/2010 Item #16K 5
Agenda Item No 16K5
December 14. 2010
Page 1 of 16
EXECUTIVE SUMMAHV
Recommendation to approve a Stipulated Final .Judgment in the alllount of $29,250 for Parcels
15911EE and 159TCE in the lawsnit styled Collier COUllly 1'. Till/othy Malolley., et aI., Case No. 10-2690-
CA (Collier Blvd. Project No. 68(56) (Fiscal Impact $18,750.50)
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners approve the attached Stipulated Pinal Judgment
for payment of full compensation, I()r the taking of Parcels I 59FEE and 159TCE in the lawsuit styled Collier
County v. Till/othy Malolley. ct. al.. Case No. 10-2690-CA (Collier Blvd. Project No. 68056)
CONSIDERATIONS: Collier County has condemned a .121 acre parcel (1591'1'1') and .17acre for a
temporary contruction easement, Parcel l5'iT(,E, Irom property owners, Peter Zivich and Joyce M. Zivich,
for the expansion of Collicr Boulevard 1;'OIn Green Boulevard to Golden Gatc Boulevard. The County's
initial appraisal valued compcnsation al $13,900 and in June 2008 the County made its statutory offcr of
$24,400 which included a $10,500 mitigation expensc.
The County's updated 2010 appraisal valned compensation at $12.100. The owner's updated appraisal
valued compensation at $78,400. On October 13, 2010, mediation was held prior to the Order of Taking
hearing and a settlement was reached ill the amount of $29,250 ]()1' compensation and a stipulation to the
Ordcr of Taking. The ('ounty dcposited $12.] 00 into .the Coulis Regisliy on November 4, 20! O. Expert's
fees and costs will be brought bell)re the Board at a future date.
If the attached Stipulated Final Judgment is approved, the County will be responsible for the hlllowing costs:
Additional Amount Owed:
*Statutory Attorney's lees:
TOTAL
$17.150.00
$1,600.50
$ 1 R,750.50
** Attorney's Fees are mandated by ~73.092, F.S., and arc based on 33% of the total benefit achieved, i.e.,
0.33 x ($29,250 - $24,4(0)
FISCAL IMPACT:
impact fees.
Funds in the an1llunt of SIR, 750.50 arc available in impact fees. Source of funds are
GROWTII MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
Nunc.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item is legally surlieient I(]r Board action. RNZ
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners authorize the Stipulated Final
Judgment as 10 Parcels 159FEE and 159'1'('10 'lIld authuri/.e payment ol'the funds as stated.
PREPARED BY: Robert N. Zachary, ;\SSiSt;:llll County Atll1rllCY
I ()-26()OCAi2430
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
Agenda Item No. 16K5
December 14, 2010
Page 2 of 16
COLLIER COUNTY
ElOARO OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
161(5
Recol11mendation to approve a Stipulated Final Judgment in the amount of $29,250 for
Parcelsl59FEE and 'lS9TCE in tile lawsuit styled Collier County v. Timothy Maloney., et aI.,
Case NO.1 0 .2690-CA (Collier Blvd Project No 68056) (Fiscallmpacl $18,750.50)
t2/ 14/l0 10 90000 AM
Prepareu By
Robert N. Zachary
County AttOtfley
/.l,:O.sistan! County A!.torney
Date
Count\' l\ltOH1C>'{
11/73/20109:26:41 AM
Approveu By
Norm E. Feder, tdCP
Tmnspe>rlilUol1 Diviskm
hdministriltor - Transportation
Date
lri1!1SportilliOll f:\chninistl<11ion
1'l/23/2010 9:57 AM
Approveu By
Usa Taylor
Transportation [Ii 'i~.;fc,n
N!;J11,)getll0!1U8lHlgc! r,tldlyst
Date
Tr<1nSL~0ft(1jiDj\ i'\dn;ir !i,,~', ;l(ion
11/23/201010:55 AM
Approved II)'
iJaJ(~lll',t\lnad
TiGiw:po;taUon U;. '_"Un
Oiwctor 'fr;msportdiinn EI1fi1lleering
Date
11';;;\C:'i;;_-<';i,,~i:),; b.(liIVCi ii Iq ('.
11i:4/2Ul0 6:53 PPJi
~::nn:;tl '10;',1i] ,'r;,,! i;\:lCn1('nt
Approved Ily
i:;',dicrl: 1.J. .,.:'1Ci'~,:1}'
COlltllV M[Olllf~Y
r-,~"i:,;t i:il i>~tlntv /.\1 (::i'l": 'I
D8te
C~lI.lll! I\tl '111'Y~'
1'1/3().",'010 8:29 AM
Approwd By
::,('Vill H:'Il(~! ;(:!~"',
hclll,;pc-:L:'llnn Ui--Lf(','
r':an:YY,'1 \'!';1It '-'f 'hi;,)'
[jill'=.'
311spotWl!t>n L;'':;il1'.:C'lir:~.! [!
'J'(::tt'lcjinn r;i;111?1~""";l"11:
12/'1,'20104:04 PM
Appl"ovcd By
].c..t-:l":{li:,<i'_IW
,,,un!\! l\ll"tlv\/
D"tp.
Approved By
12/2/2010 9:07 AM
orH1E:\ (,('fH'(!ii):'loJ
Ceuf11y Ma!FHy,'I"' ()jri':c
Dale
Uffi~0 of fJ'-:-1l1n98tnrml & i:;tur\qet
"12f2f201 (\ 2:09 PM
Approveu By
SU~;;'H) U;;ll':l
Uffice of r~'lil!l;lW'll","nl ':~
1'.!i;1Jl'1~,l""nj(:I;tiPlldqC't A1111yst. SCt\iOI
DRle
!f'i~0 'll f\:~,:;I1"tI;::fl1('nj ,~ q'lt"T:-1
12/31::0103:28 PM
Agenda Ilem No. 16K5
December 14,2010
Page 3 of 16
Rlldw:-t
Approved Ily
r,1;Jd< Isackso:\
Mal]iJ;)'~lnctlUfJud~ct I\IKdyst. Senior
Dale
Office of M;lnd~~elnellt &
[lur]get
Offic.e 0f Mana~J0'11elll 8-: f:3ucJ9ct
12/3/20104:51 PM
Agenda Item No. 16K5
December 14, 20'10
Page 4 0116
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH mmCIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
CIVIL ACTION
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, a
political subdivision of the State of Florida,
Petitioner,
Case No.: 1O-2690-CA
v.
TIMOTIIY MALONEY, et aI.,
Parcel Nos.: 159FEE, l59TCE
Respondents.
/
STIPULATED FINAL JUDGMENT
TIllS CAUSE having come before this Court upon Joint Motion made by Petitioner,
COLLIER COUNTY, and Respondents, PETER ZIVICH and JOYCE M. ZIVICH, by and
through their undersigned counsel, Jor entry of a Stipulated Final Judgment as to Parcels 159FEE
and 159TCE for Project No. 68056, and it appearing to the Court that the parties are authorized
to make such Motion, the Court fmding that the compensation to be paid by Petitioner is the full
compensation due the Respondents, PETER ZIVICII and JOYCE M. ZIVICH, and the Court
being fully advised in the premises, it is therefore
ORDERED AND ADmDGED that Respondents, PETER ZIVICH and JOYCE M.
ZIVICH, have and recover from Petitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, the total sum of Twenty Nine
Thousand Two Hundred Fifty and No/IOO Dollars ($29,250.00) for Parcels l59FEE and
I 59TCE, as full payment for the property interest taken and for damages resulting to the
remainder, if less than the entire property was taken, and for all other damages in connection
with said parcel; it is fwiher
Age!lda Ilern No. 16K5
December 14. 2010
Page 5 or 16
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Petitioner, COLLIER \=OUNTY, FLORIDA, is
entitlcd to a credit for the good faith estimate of value previously dcposited in the amount of
$12,100.00; it is further
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Petitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, shall
pay an additional Eighteen Thousand Sevcn Hundred Fifty and 50/1 00 Dollars ($18,750.50),
which includes $17,150.00 in additional compensation and $1,600.50 in statutory attorney's fees;
it is further
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Witllout further order of the Court, that within thirty
(30) days hereof, Pctitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, shall pay for the benefit of
Respondents, PETER ZIVICH and JOYCE M. ZIVICH, the sum of $18,750.50 to the Trust
Account of Dorman & Gutman, P.L., c/o Jack N. Gutman, Esquire, 305 South Brevard Avenue,
Suite 100, Tampa, Florida 33606-2360 for proper disbursement in accordance with this order; it
is furtber
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that fee simple title to Parcel 159FEE and temporary
construction eascment to Parcel 159TCE, being fully described in Exhibit "A" attached hereto
and incorporated herein, which vested in Pctitioner pursuant to the Stipulated Ordcr of Taking
dated October 19,2010, and the deposit of money herctofore made, is approved, ratified, and
confirmed; it is further
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Mediated Settlement Agreement of October 13
2010 attached hereto as Attachment "B", be incorporated into and made part of this Stipulated
Final Judgment; it is further
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED tllat the Notice of Lis Pendens filed in the above-styled
cause and recorded in Official Records Book 4559 Page 1177 of the Public Records of Collicr
2
Agenda Item No. 16K5
December 14, 2010
Page 6 of 16
County, Florida be dismissed as to Parcels l59FEE and l59TCE; it is further
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Stipulated Final Judgment is recorded in the
Official Records of Collier COWlty, Florida; it is further ordered
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that this Court reserves jurisdiction to enforce the terms
of this order and as to the matter of cxpcrt fees and costs and supplemental attorney's fees, if
any; it is further
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that this Order disposes of all claims arising out of the
taking of Parcels l59FEE and l59TCE and that have or could have been asserted in this cause,
except as provided for immediately above; it is further
DONE AND ORDERED at Naples, Florida on this _ day of
2010.
HUGH D. HAYES
CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE
Conformed Copies:
Robert N. Zachary, Esquire
Jack Gutman, Esquire
Je.mifer Dixon-Abbott, Esquire
Kevin Hendricks) Acquisition Mgr./Transp.
Bookkeeping
3
Agenda limn No. 16K5
December 14, 2010
Page 7 of 16
JOINT MOTION ON STIPULATED FINAL JUDGMENT
Petitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, together with Respondents, PETER ZIVICH and
JOYCE M. ZIVICH, hereby respectfully move for entry of the foregoing Stipulated Order of
Taking and Final Judgment as to Parcels 159FEE and 159TCE.
Dated:
JACK N. GUTMAN, Esquire
Florida Bar No.602434
DORMAN & GUTMAN, P.L.
305 South Brevard Avenue, Suite 100
Tampa, Florida 33606-2360
Telephone: (813) 254-8980
Facsimile: (813) 254-8983
ATTORNEY FOR RESPONDENTS
IO-269UCN2429
Dated:
~ROBERTN~ZACHARY
Florida Bar No. 816604
ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
Hannon Turner Building, 8th Floor
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400 - Telephone
(239) 252-6300 - Facsimile
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
COLLIER COUNTY,
4
IF.CAL PE:SCRIPTION [OR PARCEL i59FEE ,..' i "
,''''''.;
IN pLA..1 BOI)!<..{' QAGE. 73'.0"- THt: PUBUC
.9 SOUTH. Jt~C:EJ ~6 .E($f( "OOL.UER
i l., ':: :">'\
\\~:'\f':."'.''''i'
.... .:' <' /!.I1P/1"i(.1
",,',. ",~,~/j/'
=:-:~~~~~
1IV>ftI~~,
""PVD.,-r~'Il[IlRQW.~II~tI/St'lIS[DctI\l.fIf
~!'I.ll'In/.aom1f..W1~.o!<ll.~-~
i
~
!
~
,
,
t
;
i
I
~
.
.
!
,
.
I-
I
I
J
f
J
I
I
,
i
N
W+E
S
TRAcr 113
:.55'
PROf'OSED Rlt:HT OF WAY
pAnCU 11:llWEE
~,JS) so, FT.
NOKlH 1 50' OF "tRACT 114
ZNCH" 7JV~
OR '2510/1965 pfiOPOS(O -:n4POFlARY 5'-,
CONSl1nJCll0N EA-t;EMEWi~
TRACT 114
GOLDEN GAl E ESTATES
UNIT 1
PLAT BOOK 4, PAGE 73
&
l
!
I
I
II
Ii i
--~l' ____J~
n+oo 2.7+~U 2!HDO 2tlC01
---+-_ ~'I--+----" -.... .1- ---+- f--
5TH AVf~ S.W.
. - - -- - .- . iii - _.- I -\
lWl1AN D~;n-lc;oA .
IfN'TISr CHURCH
OR JIl-\5jHi17
OR "" OFFrc~ Rt:CORDS (SOOK/PAGE:)
~ mor'OSEO RICHT OF WAY
r771 e:X1STINO RIGKT OF. WAY [)[\Jl~Tr.o 10 THE PERP('fUAl USE
lL.L..1 OF THE PU6UCI'ER PLAT Dom( +, PAGt TJ
^ PORl1QN Of TRAe! 1 \4. GOlDEN GP.iE ESTf,T"'<.S, UNIT 1 /IS Rf.:CQ~!)ED
. Re:COROS or COU.lER CoUNTY, fLORIOA. L'llNC IN Sr.GllON 10, TOWNSHIP
COUNT'1. FlORIDA ~rlN(l MOI{l".: PARTICVV\R1..Y DESCR1Sto AS F'Ol.LoWS,
THi:: EAST 35 fE:U OF lHE NORTH 1M F'ttT OF' SAID TRACT 114.
CONTAlNINQ 15,250 SQ\JA.fCE netT, lAOf([ OR LESS,
"
"
. SKHCH &: DESCRIPT/ON ONLY
NtlT A BOUHOARY l1iURVtr 9C.'I~ ,'..1:1lJ'
rOil: COI.LrER COuNlY C4lVERNJ.lOO aO.l.RD Of COUNTY C:OW.HS5tOWffi$
'I
I,
\
I
I
I
I
I
December 14. 201'0
Page 8 of 16
..... 1/
fXHlBIT A
rage f?l?' OUII!
~
a
I
r
I
I
I
L
I
I
\
lOD'WIDE:_'
pffl PLAl I
I
I
1\
Ii
II
I
11
''''
,
I
~
~
a
~~1
I
I
L
I-
I
FEe SIMPLE
INTEREST
R:'l.",\~
liltIGW&o<lPd~,"'lIllO
~......_)4\.
~r="4lI7,IlUtF~1a::lII)Ul-41'1
UlrlllJ_
f1lftWolt
UNl SXtSlh"E.E
EXHIBIT
I
A
'"'0vl,,:a It,.,,, r;,. 101(~
December 14. 2010
Page 9 0116
f
~
I
TRACT l1J
II
I,
II
I
II
g
.
~
:f<HIBIT /1'
'99 &"'1~J'
I I
r
I
I
I
L
I
I
I
lOa' WIDE .
PER f'lAT------j
~
'I
f
"
.
.
!
j
I
e
~
(
,
.
,
r
'N
W+E
5
s
i
,
.
t
1__--_-
!
I
f
11
i
) TRACT 114
, GOt-DeN GATE f.5TATfS___
,--- . UNIT 1
I PlAT 8001< 4. rNJE 73 I
11
~ HAITIAN Or1flEstJA 'II
~ BAPTIST CHURCH
~ QR JG4~/llill '.. ,
Ii II I
I! j' __ _ ~J
ij' ~- ~ F'l'OO 211.00 2t+Ol
:--+-- - J 1 ......... -----I -- 1- -+--- -f. -
_ -- ~l A~',W~ -J- ____I -
40'.
PRoroSED lElo1PORl\RY
CONSTRUCTION fASEMENr-......
PARCO. 1.:59TCE:
NORl1-l'150' orTRAG"T 114 '50 SQ. F1.
ZJVCH II; ZNCH
OF!: 129"0/1965
"
~
1
I
I
L
I-
I
I
'g 1
."
---,-~
OR '" D::-F1CIAL RH,,'tlRDS (flOOK/PAGE>
&ssI PROPOSaI:5' 1'EMPOAAR'T' CONsmlJCTION !::A.C;rME:NT
tS2QJ
fZZ.J
PROPOSf;;D RlC:HT oF' WAr
fXlSTINC nlGHf OF WAY D!;:DICATED TO niE PERP~TUAL USE
OF THE: PUBUC Pm. PL'\r BOOK 4, ~~AOE 73
I
TEMPORARY
CONSTftUCTlUN EASEMENT
DURATION :;; YEARS.
LEGAl CCSC~fON fOR PARCO. lseTCE: . ,', ) .,.,,,,,
A pormON or TRACT 11+; GOLDtN GilT! E:STAr~, UNrT 1 AS- RE:CORDEU IN PlAT BOOK- 4:' tAut..73 OF THE PUBWc
RECORDS OF COLUER COUNTY, fl..llRlOA, LYING IN SEcnON 10, TOWNSHIP 49 50llTH. ~Gtr2a/WT,'COWliR
~'OUNTY. rLORlDA DONG MaRiO f'AmlCULARl.l' Or.SCRlBE:O AS FOu.owS ; : r I ' .
. I' 1r,' i
me Wt::!."T $ fOCT O~ tHE lAST 40 Fro or IH~ NORn-l 1fJO tEET Of SAID TRACT \)4,~~,I' . I ,;
CONTAINING '150 SOU~RE n:a, MORt: OR lESS. '.. ~' .? ./~ .r~1
. " }"I'
Il' '0 811 IIlO 1m ' ,
5KnCH ~ DESCklFnON ONLY) ! = :-r~~'= ~
NOT A BOUNOARY SURVE:Y llI:d.t: L'cflg' to*lRl lI4nr
FOR: COI.1J(~ CQumy c:ovt1MlQrr ElOARD or COlMY COw.u&SlONE:RS :nn.: ~f-=--I&IIW.~~~ SUI. tf'
COl1..n:R ButJLSVA..M
Sn7c:lJ &: DESCRIPTION' OF:
PROPOSED TFJ!.PORARY CONSTRUCTION EASSMiNT
PARCEL H\9'tCE
COLIJER COUNTY, rr.oRID!
..loa NUl,IB'ER Rt,.'VISJOl'f Si:C.l}/)1ol
)50105.02.00 0005 R~;} 10
DUll''"
ft~~~
5Illlwu.......l:a/ft,""":lOO
~Acr'Wa.11tJ1
fhlrlr.lIUI~fAX:f&U)'I7.Q57t
1.81M,:_
l':\U: HMtE
UNI' I(\Sllf
S!ittT
lor 1
!t~';j-,.. .,
~.: ;;
P'lj8l1da Item No. 16K5
December 14. 2010
Page10 or 16
. .
IN TIlE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR COLLmR COUN1Y, FLORIDA CIVIL DIVISION
COLLIER coUN1Y. FLORIDA, a
political subdivision of the State ofl<1orida,
(
Petitioner,
TIMOTHY MALONEY, et at.
Case ~o: lO-2690-CA
Parcel Nos: 1S9FEB. 1S9TCE
v.
Defendants.
I
. MEDIATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMEN'r .
At a Mediation Conference held on October 13.2010, the parties reached the following
Settlement Agreemcnt.
1. Petitioner will pay to Respondents, Peter .Zivich and Joyce M. Zivich, the sum of
$_ ':J-" 1 .;t. sO ~"v in full settlement of all claims for compensation from Petitioner
whatsoever, including statutory interest, but excluding attorncy's and expert's fees and costs.
Said sum will be subject to claims ofapportionment, if any. .
. t)::i
2. pctitionm' is entitled to a credit in the amount of $):2 . r12() ..,;)
. \ fl. " .,
\ ~ . ."
which ~t pF~..i6ltlli1-dcposited in the registry of the Court in this casc by Petitioner.
3. Counsel for Petitioner and Respondents will jointlySllbmitto the Court for.
sigtlJlt~e a mutually approved Stipulated Final Judgment in this matter as soon as practical
. hereafter. #I ...., 1,-,.... .1 J
I I). 1>> v. fI
4. Petitioner will pay Respondents the balance due of $~ ~.,.
within thirty' ~ ryS of the actual date of receipt by Petitioner's counsel of a COnf'ormc~ copy of
the aforeSaia:pulated Final Judgment from the Court.
5. The Court will retain jurisdiction herein as to the matlel: ofattorney(s) fees and:
expe:tts'. costs.
I~
-"."","=-_...,~-..,
o:..~
6.
tlgrmcla Ilem No. 1UK5
[)ccember 14. 2010
Paye 11 of 16
Settlement of this case is conditioned upon final approval by Collier County
Board of County Commissioners.
7. Attached hereto is an addendum to this agreement: L Yes
No.
8. This agreement dated October 13, 2010, and attached addendum, if any,
~~
Robert N. Zach , Esquire
Florida Bar No: 816604
Office of the County Attorney
Harmon Tumer Bldg.
Naples, FL 34 ~
Attorneys fo eti1~<ller
Offt/;;3 - 2iOO
~'/
ew G. Diaz, Esquire (Mediator)
'lorida Bar No; 81660
5001 West Cypress eet
Tampa, FL 3360
Oi1ice: (813) 2 1-9000
~~
Peter Zivlth, Respondent
~ ~ ,~
.~
~h; ~ndent
~t;~
Florid No: .t
Dorman & Gutman
305 S. Brevard Ave., Suite 100
Tampa, FL 33606
Attorney for Respondents, Zivich
Office: (813) 254-8980
~.
. ,
.
Agenda Item No. 16K5
December 14, 2010
Page 12 of 16
ADDENDUM
This settlement is made subject to the following additional conditions:
(J)
" ' II
C'~, ",tlJO.A.. W 1\\
c.... m -r 'B \ v.l.
""" \.L. re.1A.I1~ ,JJ.,
C c:.. It. "\ S- ,) .
ea..u...G.SS
-rw...
to
@ \~ trl1~ct:...+ ~.\UQ. c:..,A~1',."t.rBb ,v,
,
6t A.J .c,...... I ~ WI ih...J)... 4. ft-t-...~......Q. P \ GI."I.~
CJ'"1' It.~ J 1.y c.. to\- '). ~ \~ \ \ .
SUh$~~
C~~~'d:A- }
.ft, '$" "'\Y~"'7 ~
:i' 51!
I, b 00 ~"~
"B.c:..AJ~ ~ \\
.(;J",
q., I'c-
(3) Tk.. C.O""T e-e..~~"'" Tu~~..L.~-nV...J -lo &-tulO4.~i
Q..lC.p-~ l.D...n ~O ~\i'tle.~ ~~
~ +"'" d) \, te-\.W4l'1.'1 vi- tJ "'.i;;.
/ I
Esquire I Mediator
~
-7 ~
i ~
~ I"'
~\~
~ ~ i
Q:, I~
1- ~
\~ -~ ~
VlJ ~I ~ ~
~ ~i ~~~~
~.... 'C~~d
~ ~ ~ .~ ~ z
1 ~ ~.~ ~ ~ ~. ~
~ ~t9~ ~~~g
~~ p.. ~ ~ t'\'>> p..
~;1~ ,--~~.",,~
'f:. ~ ~ 0 s ~ ~ ~-l
~ ~.~ ~ ~ ~ ~
--L ~,~~l ~~~8
~ ll'" ~'-JGP"
~ ="'" fi'l
;s~ ~~~~
~~ ~~~~
>S ~~I"'>U
q ~r.:r;;~ 13'
~ I c) ~ ~~
~ ~ ~!J.J
!G~ 8
f"> 0"''''
~ u~~
""" ;:;~.
~8~
. .
-h.
~
..I...
-.s:
)/..
}~
I
i
i:js1
1--;5
!5 '"
"'~ '"
\i;<!i ~
~"i: ~
Q~ ,..(
em t;;
M
III~g
I~ ~ 8 ; ~ i ~mBI
~ .1 ~ ; 1.1 R !I
I~B iU' ~ U'~ I~I.
: hd I ~dB iM
~
~g~
1.11~!O
~ ;;;
~.
!i1:1:~
;~~tI)
" -
'"
~ ~
!5 q I--
a:cl ~ ~. ~
~~ ., t;;~ '"
",lu 8J ~..!$l
....~. "'" ~
fll:t:~ ~\!! I--
co.. III lulls III
~ ~ '"
~g~~1ij~~~
I--~.I-- llil ~ N
[;:10..; ~!!i~ :p.:\\! ~
~!Ilm8r.::)"!(!~~
, is ~~ III =s~ ~ e~ .
~ -.J ~ Q~:cC (,!)~~ Q"'-l.q
. e -.- h"'''''I--I.U~I--'''~1--
~ ~ ~ S:? lulu'" a:ill.IIlI>Jll. '"
~ ~i'~ --)
"'. ,~ ~ ~ ~ ~~M t:: r::
~ ~ II~t ei~hl~1 ~~a~~i .~ ~ ~
"- ~ ~ ~ ie~~~~~~i8~:.!m~w~!i gs s 8
"'~ ~~~!i ~~dlnM~IMmu ~~ G:
': ~~;";!i ~ ~ fC
~ ~~!i~~~ ~ ;_.~"r~.mm~~Nm: ~ 8
&l~~~~s ~ <:
~
III
-z
~
...l.! I!l
[;:1~ >'>!
~fj ~.
:z::s .
.~~ ~
A[J':mla Item No. 16K5
December 14.2010
, ',16
'~~ -
is
~. .~~
-< .
~ m
t I'
,: ~
II
I
I
I
l
~I
~
Ill"
~ i
I
~ .
~ ~,,~::J.... ,t
:a C\I~Qa"" "
~~
~ m ~~~ .... Ii
~ !Ii" " ~
Cl. ~ . ~I
~ Ll- ~ ~ . ~~
--'I D I '" ijn
~t; "= . d ;..I~~
~ ~ ~~h~ ~ ~~
Cl. ~ ~Ij"~~ ~ ~~
ij~h~ ~ ~~
. I I I . ~~~ e
~~lcl<~;..~
UU~U
I]!
s
Uu
ih!~1
MI~I;
111;1- ~!
11m! h
.
,
.'
tl!' ..
1
,I
,~ 1
\" I: 1
1
I.
\ I 1
I
.,/""',
\. ~J" "". I
. ~'
~..
. ~"
'.J'.
.'
..
, .
I
I'
~ .... if.
:.J. l'. .
g . :\h1i.
'j VI iIIili
":1.'
1:-
Agenda Ilem No. 16K5
December 14, 21 10
'. r 'Pt' ~ 'v. 16
i~ il
I
~ 2 ~ !e ~ ~ ~ ~
'" ...
:f.
,"
,"
:~ &
:~
;: -
,I'
,I'
,t'
,I'
~'"
"
~..: III
0.' .
:!" !j?~ ~
+_ :l![..~~ ~I
f-'-:.: ~~
..+--~ ,
. ~ ~ ~
.L --'~1 ~~ { B
09l-S~g'.y.lS . 3N/7 HO.lYIf I'lli I I
I .1 ,"t h:tl. ,I I'} l I
. ~sl \1m I I
'l, ',' \ .::. ,. ~ \: n. i :
I'L~I~' \1 i:l ~ a 1\'.'1: :
'/'\'. .'. I. "'1 I ill' I 1iI,1'
t~~ '. :::l ~= t\" i ;
.~]J!; .'1. '1: \k :/ I I ,
:l'..I.~n .r I I : ! (, J' : ..:~
j~: :1 ~I'~ l' ~:I, :~.
J I ~ " I" . I
;1_'.L",- ':f _I',. I Ii I
~. ,':i ,,!1. I' !,,':, ~:, :
. . ...;1. li
~" i~ ;:i:r J. 1 ' I I \.<.l I I 1'tI
. Fi I ," ~, .-l ,-
IE II! I~' \ \ Ii ~ 1 I 'I"
:j 'I !i ~'~II: I~I!; I I ,,'
. ,.",.~ I !l'dll 1 I I~,~.,
". '') '.1 \ ", 1 if-'-
;, I' 1\ : I: i ;t;
I .\11 J I \".
~.~ I. I ~'~r1'1 I _,_~J, !:':.ig:
i'! 1.~1 r ~' - ,-
lti-i I I 'I r 'I
'. II :I~f \ I I...J~
.1 I . "If\ :t,,'. I J
0'''' ,. I -... t,\\ I ~ i '" :::
I I' I ~!,I'I I. " "
>~ II. . 1;'\'1 ,;;: "f. I
-,I II. = . ':~\' I~ I :~: I
,I L I ~ I 'Ii::: f I -- !
~:: 'J.l ~ 'I)"~\ ; i:::~.) .'-'.
,;i '-..1' ..' \ \ ::/~
:. . 1 11\ . ; . '::' " ....- \
,..f, I \1J ' I ::~ .
"'1 II . ~ I' , "
'/"1 ~. '-' I :~11
,"'.'1 i. r !iI,;' ,
'.'1 II __ WI "r : ~
...."I..J. ,- 1 ...,
. I "I
'. :[ Ji: - ~ !~+-'- - -- I~ ~t
)\W'[:~ .._
I : ,_.._111" .._"."__
<: :i I'~ ~,;. ~J-I, :~ : :::'I~;~~
J:~ is 11. ,_ b. ~ ,..
....~ '~: I r:-"" m\): _ Im~ n \ ~ t I!
, .. H", I --fU ~, ,
:,1 ..1.. ~ f- '" " '.:"
::. lI. ~ )~ I !! ...
? .~. >~ Ii M . I ~ Wi ::~
.~~.~ d:J: ".:: t=f' I i:
&1 1",1,\ /: I, I.,
!'t. .' I \ r I I"
h.):;:I"' I ::mllh : ~
.'1 I' , )l \ I ~~. I .,
J "..1 ~ j'I::": ! H~ ~~ =-ir- :::', .,
<,.'[' .t. ~ . I I i -H i :::,
rl~I-' . f\ \1 ] I ... 1.-..1 '" _M_
O;;+I,r.9'V.1S 3N17 HD.lYIf ~ 2 ~ ~ .. '" ~ .. .. ...
F
.~~!,:,
..~ ~~
g · I 'I-
~'r:("'1.1'-'},""" ·
'UFI, :1
f t,,: ~
~ ".( ': ,
. . ;,,".1 l:,.~...
!' "..
'[ mi.'
I Inl)~ B
l . I;':il ~
, &~
~ t! l.
, i! t- t,
, ~U~ I-I
lit I!l II
p~
e ~ ~;I J
l ~ll 'i~
i' ~~I ~
~ ~~, I
~ 1-1'
~ t,-(, 1', I ' e
"o"'j-I' :',T: III :~4h.ij
. I" j I.. . ,: " d ,.. ~
- H. .. II j~l; i '.
JL, f", ."
- -~ ir~ ':1 ': :5 '.,
I ~ 'ill m r J, ';.~ :. .....
, a, II I~ ...1'....
\, ~..<Gt~l )1 ".::
"j II .
.' ,\11. . 'SI,i:U
"'1 ~ if . :1':
-" I \ II: !
ti. 'I,., .::1 I:
I' ^ .,.1 .
,;;":(~I, ..IiJ ". .'" I'
".411 rl
"
c: _. ...
'.
'I'
"
I
.
~,p ~
:;ht-,
" II ~.
!llti
.. ~ 5
'I'
~.
~ \
:II QIi
~ I ~JII~
;:; .p~
I J'~
I 11
.~.
..
..._~.
~
~
-,~
.
.
~
.
.
.
.
'"
-!
...1P.
_c' ,_..,
.
I
, .
.. <. '
I
------ !
+- -j
I'\y'",rla Ilern NO.1 GK5
December 14, 2010
pC[JP 15 of 16
id ~
-t-I-f--
I- --
'. : ! '
~ ~
i ~
~ ~ ~
'"
1.---- -,
- 1--
, ---
H--,
1-- ---
" t- ----.
--'
,
[--1----
+..-
+--
H--
t- __c.
-1-
,
--~-
i"~ ~--,- ~~ II
----- -i~-Tlj - _ _, :
--- I -- I+-~I-
1- --, -I I I . I--
I ' 1 __J' I
1'+1__ L -- !- I I 1-- -
-~~ =:=-. ++-+-- tL -----4- I+-t-
=t:-I'--+lr~+:i ~ -I=-I=r-
. 1'1 '.\ir-r-T':iJ-
j:It.'ITr--:,=!=r:\iC=:IJ 1..C -I-- -1-=1_ ..
--I:J'-I-'c-l-h- I-+-c-li-h- --!-I--H - I
-t*r--~~-- -r-I- -L -I---I-'-T' I
__! ,__.__J. "1t' I I I , . 1----:
--j i +l-+~-- :~t.!+I+1+t--+ 1-1-----
-=-=I-~rpjj--P=i=tc=1=rn -- -!-.. \- --
Ji=I-IJ++---rl 'tt;=~'Tj.' -
~--!-t.L,--B=ii=F\~tt1-- - 1----.-- :_1 r- ,---
-'-+-I++:-t-H-'j-"'[-l- -: -r -- ~- _
4-rmi'-"rl+~jjrf-rit-~- ---I / I .
=R -'--=1:1= ---1--1-1-+ ,-1 - 1
-. '-r--t'T-,I-.I-,-i--r-iT -1- : I-
_1-1..'_--;-1___1 I-",*';"~'- -'-1- -- -= __ -.
~~I'= i-L --LJ...,; c-1-L1 -- +1
,-:-+-+i i I I I I , I',
-j-l-I---I' -tt---'lI,-H it-i---"-ff~
I----i-- b---1.T[J+cPlf '11=t-Jj ___
IFP:--:-I+ H+"i-i -1-4J I
-T:--'I-:j=q-~It1=R-\t1- =m' ~+-
-, --I - --1+ TT'''i~-- q= 1-- -
~-m' cD!,. ~~Ii -, -;T -,- ,-
J. -lI-Lj__1 r - -I-h.t I-I-- 1- T ----
_L --L --'-'1 -'- - - -r- 1----
'-f-I'--- __L_I_ --! +i I I I --, 1---
-- -_I -I- --r ,-j-ll+ +t 1- -.1- - -1- .' - . _
-::...L..!---l+ - i: 1-1-1.. . .J=I= r+ -... - ~ t-...
-:=f::'=ij-t_::rlJ4;llt--~~I-'I-t-. ,
_u-'I--.J1l-I-+--1 1:_ -- 1 I I -
1------
i
--- . ~IIP
.. -,,1-- 115il
I~ II-
. i1
IS
-.I-H- .-
- --1'
,
"__ I-
I
I
.1--
-l-
.- ~-
51-
ti-
.. -- .-.
--- -...
.. 1--- -1-- -- dl
J_....
- f~lf
--
-I-- -- I'n- .
-I-f--..
,,-
~ - -- -',-':--
---- -J:- ~--- -- =':::~-
~; g 1
. -f--' . --H- - --j-
- -r=~f~,t--~- '-t:C
-i~I---F-:--I-" -- 1-. l--
I ~.
-, "J- -- -..
I-t -b
.
J.
=F
_.~::
-...1-
L.
. t- -- --.
-. -, - --. -I-.
_ --- I-t:
-l-'~~l -
~ i ~ ,
1-'- -LI--t- - ,-
, 1
I
.- t--
I- - rr-
-I--i--I..---++-I- ..1-
, ,
~
"..!_"r
.. ! It ~ ~!'
. <
.
--.
_.:-~--
- \- -- ....
.
'11
I
'\ ., ..- ._-
I'll
1--. n .......
,
.
"
1-
.-
..,..-- - .
_ ___ n'
1-
_+_ _.u. ..
"-.-11101
-In__ _.1.
-
III I
I
..- '-'T
I Int---li- -- --
~g i;h~~=f~~I-~- I_~- - - --
!li~1 ----~ - -- -+ ~
1:6. -- . -'.1 .-
1m "~::-~I--.-+ T 1111'..---::
- I '1 I'
~! I ~- ~"::::..__e- .._~.
~ 'I=}-+:-= ;=:~~~-~-..
- i III~I_~_ .00 .._ ...._ I
m ~ I n_ - . "- .,.- - i-
~ 1'-1::: --7'[--- - --"'_.. :
... · .13 .
! '--- \c:::~ -'
ti F; - ,- '~.:C
I
.
Q r:- '1- - ...
~ f ~ i~!: :.- .-- .-
~ ~.:. ... I~.. bn. ::_
~ ~
@a
B
e-
_n_
.~
1
~
~
"
.i:l! p~ ~
.-f- _. .--
--71-
i
--I
[;
~
_........ .__ ,..::lIlt. - ---
.--'j- 1-. j- ...
l...l
. _ .,.... ._n" .
-f-- .'0_'-
I
1\
-.........
Itf -+ --
1\1,1
-
~
I
_\~... .-:f- u
I
I
---...-..:-
-1-1/ -,
,
. I
-1- --'-1---
--"'- - t- -
,
-.
,
I
10 ,.......;,
.
~.
-..1-
t.
I!-.--.
i'>
Agenda ltem.No. 16K5
Dec8mbpI.14 2010
~)~ )) 16
- - \-
~I-
,
1---
n _ .. .1_ -- .- .\---. --1-
._._._~;t,~i"-' ~-
~8'+ _.--
,
--
1--
--1-..-.....- ...
,
-" --
-\lIiIfN.... ...
.illiT
.. - 1=1= - \-\-
--t-:+
. - - - ....... I-
I
I'
.. ..-
I
. I'!.
~:-~~ .:~-I~-'
- -..--
~-===.:..
_ cc'--
-.-..-1-... .. .'-'1..'.. ...-., .
. .. -1:-
,
-I--' -- - f-
- ..,..,~:.. .-' .~ --,~ - .,- ~- - ;
I
I
.1-..'"' ,-' -. 1- ._- 1- .--...
.- ..... -- .-~>.I, --1-.. -.. -.-
..- #.--..- -.-~ _." ..._. -
,
\
_..-\.,._.~.
1-.
-'..
b
B
1-
'"
"I
,
""~
is
IJ
III
:i
ili