BCC Minutes 01/11/1983 R
~. ..,. '~'''''''''"'''''''-'';'~'--~--'''-'''''-'",'''', ...... ~._",.........,
~a?l.., rlorl~a, ~'nu~ry 11, l~P'
LET IT BE RE~'E"'Br.REÐ, that the Board of County Com",18IIon.rs in
~n~ ~or th! County of Colll~r, and also actinq as the ßop.rd of ?oninq
App~als an~ as tho ~overnin~ hoar~(a) of suc~ special districts DS have
b.en creat.~ ~ccorrlin~ to Jaw an~ h~vinq con1uct~~ husinoft. h~raln, Met
on this dato nt ~:~~ ~.~. 1n R~1ular St.810n In r,uil~lnq RP" of the
Courthous~ C~mnl~x, Pnst ~aples, ~lor1da, with the (ollowIng Menhers
present:
("I" TR"'^" I "',II ry-rr~nce!4 Kruse
VICF' cl!"rn....^~': !').:wlc' c. "!rown
.1o~n ^. Phtor
rr~~~r1ck J. Voss
~. C. "Pad" Moll~n~
,,!. ~ 0 r· P r. S !" ~ ~ T : ','1111 II m .1. "n II '1 'In, C 1 e r k 1 .1" m e!J C. C 11 ell , F is c a 1
Officor; !':Iurt'en .....nyon ".,ri nlnor <"kinnpr (11~('\ P....1, ~"uty Clerks,
Purt ~~"unrlcrs, r"':>IIr1ty ~ttorney, ':. \o'jll1.~.., "or~"n, County V3nal'Jer; ~ð
~mlth, ~SS!Bt~nt roun~y ~~n~"~rl ~nute u,I rtmDn, ruhllc ~~rk~ ^~~lnl.-
tr~torl Tt'rry Vjrt~, rO~Munlty n@velorm@nt ^dmlnl~tr...tor; Loe L~yn.,
PInns !mpll"m,.nt.,tlon !"jrC'ct()r; ~r. "1&rl< Benor!ict, r.ollnty r:nvirnn'l1en-
tallstl ~ðncy Tsrðelson, ~rlmjnistrative ~.crøtary to the Board; an~
Chief re~ut'l ;'~y '-\I\rn@tt, 5h@riffts ~ej:)"rtmon':..
aoo~ 073 rACE Z79
,
'-I' II~'" ,
,'.
,
'''...nulIry 11, 1M'
Tape 11 07'12 ðOA
Item tl ~~~( .¡ rASt Wt
AGENDA - APPROVED
COlMlh.Jcn.r~ ~i..ocrl -mOHQ, ,ecorfd*d '-by "'Comm1a.ioner Brown and
carrieð unanImou.ly, that the agenda be approved a. pre.ented.
Item . 2
MINUTES OF DECEMBER 20, 1982, SPECIAL MEETING AND DECEMBER 28, 1982,
REGULAR MEETING - APPROVED AS PRESENTED
Commissioner Piator moved, seconded by commi,sloner Voss and
carried unanimously, that the minutea of December 20, 1982, Special
Meeting and December 28, 1982, Regular Meeting, be approved aa
presented.
Item . 3
ANDREW J. MARTIN, SUPERVISOR, IMMOKALEE LANDFILL, SOLID WASTE DEPART-
MENT, HONORED AS COllIER COUNTY EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH FOR JANUARY, 1983
~: ,) ~ i r"',~ ~ 'r 1)';., r I'.~ "J " t t ... r .1 ~ -I :") r ,. ~ ~ f' t (' (1 " p} II C" lH' t ('> ... r. "",II r t ( n
C0'11;.1Jr'~r:t!n~ ì:1"' I)n n¡, fIn,.. ;0" h... It' "'oln., ~5 " rOllnty a"'r.1oY~f!.
<; h ~ .,,, I r " t :' - t h ~ t, ~ ~ ~., ~ 1 ::) y,. n I) f t ~.,. ,. t"1 n t r, t ~ n r ~ \</1"1 LJ J'" ...., ,. I'! , (',. . n (I
'.> 0 r.LJ s j.., i; Inn ~ x t ~) ," Y c h (' c I: .
Item .4
RESOLUTION 83-1 RE PETITION CccL-82-15c, SCOFIELD MARINE CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY REOUESTING A VARIANCE FROM THE COASTAL CONSTRUCTION CONTROL
LINE FOR LA PLAYA BEACH AND RACQUET INN LOCATED ON VANDERBILT BEACH _
ADOPTED, SUBJECT TO STIPULATIONS
L"Gë!l nC'1t"ICt, hH' r ~ '1~(',. ftr"" l~h~:-I In tht! ~1 lr"J:t "'')ily f,'ews on
Dccenbcr 'C, lO~", ~n ~vl"'~n~r" hy ^ffi~~Y1t o. f\uG1icotlon fl1.A with
th't C]t'rJ.., ru'" Ir. hCl'r¡n~ \.,,~, Otlt<,,~~1 to C'o:-,¡I"nr r'''~1t:lon l"'r.cL-"I:'-JSc,
Sco!J~l~ ~pr1n~ ronstrur~lon ~omp~ny r'~u~~tln" p v~rJ~nc~ from the
CODf!t"'~ :-on~~ru=t:C'Jr. ;(";¡tr(')' !.In!: (or r'rnr(lorty ]oC"Itccl on Lots '1: ðn~
f'ðqe 2
~."....'
~
lIB
-
~ .
~: ;.
~"¡'
~ I+~,",'",):~
~. ~'..;."
!:s .'.::,
'iI·.','
!' .
. -....
I f
I ~..
,5a
¡ 8~ ,:~;i
I !Ii 'v
I~' ~:"'" tt
,..t.;~:'E,,'
,r:!.,..."'" -1,
~""". :."
: !t..:.. 0 ¥i~', ~ £,i
.....'_ø' .~}"
It""'-'" };
.Ja:1uary U, J "~~
2(" Block A, Unit .1, V'Jndorbilt f!each (La Phy.. Reach IIn~ nacquet Inn
^rt~itlon, ~~~l ~ulfshore Orlv8'.
Cr. Benedict, County rnviro~~pnt!lIAt, st~ted that ~cof1.l~ ~arin.
Constructio~ Is r~questin~ rock rovetm~nt P feet s~awðrð of the Coastal
Construction Control Iln~ ðn1 ~ feet 8e~w'r~ of t~a ,xlstlnq seawall.
Ho stat.d that he !ß conductlnr¡ " be~c!'1 procos8 stu1y of the entire
County which ln1ic~te5 th~t ~~n~er~11t Pe~~h Is ~n 2roslonal hnt spot,
which 11 1uc to ~~e hir¡h rlocu~antc~ rðt~ of erosion which avera~es to
ðbout n Inches ~er ye~r, ~11In~ thðt ~noth~r factor contrlbutlnq to th.
~ot Spot 1~ th~ r~ct t~~t th~ ~n1orlty of the ~ulldln~s located at
V~nrl~rl>11t p~~c~ ^rQ lnc~tn~ ~xtremoly ~,os~ to thQ current storm
;:Htnctr!ltion 1 fn~.
!In not...d th.'It 'T10!1t "'ul1111n19 lire hl'twcen 10 anrl .,,,
feat hf"h!nJ thn ntor~ rQn~trrt!on l!n~ which 1~ whQr~ tho highest waves
1urln~ II stor~ woul~ r~~ch.
'If' noto:!r1 thð" thl' ~lIl1cHnlS ðre ~ullt
ax!;r"'",p.ly c'ö!:., to t~ro ·.nt~r 'n,1 ]rf' fH "("f'ntl~1(! to !It:orm 'ia.,.,,,..,e durln:r
:':1~ior 5tor:':1 tl;j~f!, I', d!r.l U;.H r>rot('ctlv'!' 'Itructur'3 built se",w~r~ of
t h I) oS 0 L lJ ! 1 '!i n ('I !'; H n ! nt' , '! 1 C t ! V" ',,, M:' I' 7. 0 n "!' 1':''' U ~ ! n, ,. r., r' Ion 0 f. the
b,...ch !H~IH',H(' of '~l",S(" :.;~rl ctlJr~g. '~ r~;"\ortc" ''It t~1! ~ubllc "ftDch
is :')~inl "r'J\Jt'ez'1è :)1Jt," 'lct\'~'!n ) rntre~tln'" ~~(" r"11n" ...n'" per",anontly
fl (o!!-i :HrlJctlJr~s,
!:e St't('rI thðt .,c:tion:J ""Hlt: hI} t,'Ik'3n to protect t~1I
~tructure8 rro.., th~ O,e~l':'t:s or "'~1or ßtorm W~Vftl, ~"'~in.., thftt on1y hare
~Inl~~l ðct1vlt!l)q 5houl~ h~ ~llowert to protect the structures anð
thðt, ~hlr~v~r ~o~.!bl~, ~('nwl'l] Rtru~tur('~ Lh!t ðre I~pro~.rly P4ftced
or "'1fHlll"1n(',,~, s~olJl~ ')(' rcloc.:ltor',
lie r~t>ort.<" that '¡herevor poa_lhl.
t~e ,ubllc ...cces,/$ to tl-¡I) t-~"ch s~oul(~ t:>~ 'nlllntð1"!lrl. "0 rrðsentet1 ~
short slide pred~ntðt1on ~n ~9~ch eros1~n on van~erbilt neach an~ the
t»a-;re 3
&OOK 073 fA~ 285
. ...;J~j~J(~î1t;¡~i} 1.:;¡::
"::""':~.:-: ·\~~~$..",(~:r.:W£'
~~HI..:¡
~'s l~~..··
~b ~ )...~;,'. '.
~U~:: .~.
, II ~,~'.
IL~a :s ~ ,~"
,,!.~ ;;
Jj! ..~
:, ~
,~;~
~.,¡
"',a.
, .9 hb~+¡.
'~.=,t;:..'~
L'Tanuary 11, 'O~."
ßO~,( 073 FA~t' 286
lack of public beach. He stato~ th.t h. Is trying to reali9n
structures that arA f~r Into the Ðctlv~ heach zono In or~er to have one
unified front ð9~inst erosion. He .tðte~ that In some area. there 1.
only '1 feet of bcnch ~~tween the corner and the me~n ~iqhwater, adðin~
that recently It has b~~n n~ted that th~r@ is only 5 'eot. H. stated
that he woul~ ð~vise th~ rl~ce~ent of riprD~ with the condition that
the wall ~~ rCðli~n@~ first and th~t a pedestrian hy-p~ss be assured
Ðn~ that ~t 'uch tfm~ thnt the s~awall become A ~etrlmental to the beach
that It woul~ hf' relocllte~. tie reported .!tt this tiMe, it is
econo~lcn]ly unf~~~lh]~ to rrnulrf' thr r.loc~tlon of the w~l] ~nð, as
It Is In pf'rfcctly 'Joo~~ Sl-¡ðr>C!, "e would reCO""OT1cnr! th<'lt the Wð}) he loft
until SllC~ tlm~ ,II!': thl' \"'1]] (':'oul, !1e rfltlll1oner' IOn" then the rlpr~p
could t-e ;'1]t1cerl. lie concluded hy statlnl'1 that his over..11
recommon~~tlon Is to ~cny thr perMit.
"'r. frllncoeur, J7") ~. Culf S~or@ f'1vc'., repros.ntinq the
petltlonrr, prr~~ntp.~ j)lcturc!\ trJ tht> RCC of tit rlaYI'I'ø sf!'awnll as weU
<'Iß ðt'r{ð] r.hoto"rM)hs. Ill' lIlao presentet1 F:xl'liblt .". frol"l the Dr.n
reQ~r~lnn ð 1t'n~r<'l] rpr~lt, ~xhlblt .p. fro~ thp City of Narl.1
regðr~in~ ~ðpl~s ke...ch ~tu~y Report, Exhibit ·c· fro~ Tackney ,
^saocl~tp.s, Inc. r~qðrdino the u~. of rock rev.t~ent, Exhibit .0. from
DNR regarding erosion and rock revetment, ðn~ F.xhJhit .r,. from Bruce
Cre~n r. ^Sf1oclðtp.r., InC'. show[nl1 the rock rev Hm@nt for the act"JtJon to
La PI a ya .
T.pe .2
~r. Francoeur state~ that the A.aw~ll was huilt on ðn ~rc for the
purpose of l"Ie~tln~ with La Play~'. s.aw^ll which was voluntarily 91v1n9
Page ..
,
ø:"2J
~
..
.. :.~, ,
)',i,if,"^-','¡'
.:
<'{PI
Jllnuuy t1, t~,,~
11f\ th., option to 1n('] !Hie ':'\orl) ~"8ch ":-~hinA thlt 8uwn11.
~.. stilted th..t
'l:oIder storM concf it: 10ns, Deoplt' nor",l'Itly ~t'! not: choos, to """,lk th3
heach. lie stðt~r' th..,t th~ ONR Ðnd th" N:P havf' t"k.,n 1'1 ?osit10n th" t
vl'lnr'erbilt ~I!"'c; 1 S 't'3~ 11 i ~~rI. I'" :H!lt'~~ thl!'t the r~R iDSU.d l'
1·nor~1 p~rMit on 1uly 0, 11'''', which 9tat~! th~t ð q~nernl ".r~1t in
1r~ntcrl to 'Iny !ll'rnon !n't,,11i~., rh'rllp ..... "hit to. of an Gy.htin'1
V" r tic :11 S '" HI !I 1 1 ~ r (1 OJ i .., I n 1 ~ (' r t r. I n eon ('! i t: lon!l ,H I? met, I~h i c h t h ~
~~tltlon~r ~,~ ~~t.
~'" ~t~tC'<1 th"t Ii" 1!'1 r^1uestinq thllt the Br:C
cHr.,ct t"lIt ~¡.3 ':~t¡t,hr~~r I,':! 1!3<1;uf'-1 t'H! proper n!H",it to protoct ~n1
rrf.l.."rvl) th,,'\~'d,,~!:,,~ '~( ~1 :-)O')"\/,,)J ·,..-It" roc:< r^vt'tl"1P,nt'.
"r. "'Il,!!! '·-:::'I'· ·!, "coflclr1Y'Irlnl! C'"onøtructlo" C'"o",p.1ny, ntateri
thl'lt tht' r-rr- ¡'1~'1'" '~"n~r,\l ;,"r..,lt r ltco..,,....nr\ln~ t~" ;))ðCCm.,nt of rock
In frr1nt or '1: ·,,·rtl::,1 .'1c/I'.....ll!1 on t~('\ h'J"cl-¡, I'!:"!¡'in'" thllt the t'~p
conr:l!r~ .:i,:I-, ~..."""\.\
, - t " t ,,-I t ~~H .' r " C' k r '!.. ~ t", ! n t ~ ~ .1 ! '!I t r u c t u r 1'111 y
to :1 ~"~'.'.'! I; "r::>~:'ct '"1 1)'/ t,~" f/')f., of th(' ro~lts './hlch C!!USOS the
W II V e !'o t 0 I i.' ~ j '" , t ' , -', t - -; t: ~ '1'1 r", .\ .' 1 In., ~_ " I' t r 0 ,.. k r '" v 0 t '" n n t ~ I! 1 ~ os b u 11 rl
th~ 3~n~ In fr~nt ?~ .~~ J'~wal1.
"r. ""~r~~ "~'1~r ~~n~~ In or~nßltlo" to t~~ rt'!~k rev~tment
st'tlr1~ nr0tJ~t!~n Of ~·IIC'h~n ~nA ~ro~lon.
-h:, r ('\ 1 : ')',' t ..' ;- " ('\ "), 'J ~ n 0 ~ .. In' II \I 0 r f)' t h '! r _ c: u .. ~ t c 1 tin"
rrotaction o~ i r~~~rlv:
r.:lrl I"('::or.
Lloyd r.. '0'",. ir
~'1'<'! 'o~r!'
..,~c: '1oro~ """.
,~, rulfghor~ nr.
!í'~ '··1110.....1/"'1( ror.
rr. renp'AI~~ stðt,A th~t ho Is tryln~ to c~~~ uc wlt~ ~ unif1e~
phn (or t"'~ ".!"A¡>rhU" "e"ch I!r!!/\ ,n" h.,,, '-If'.,,, ';~r"1nl'J .dth the peoT"l.
in tnfl! .'Ir-'ð, ,~-;,-!In" t",~t h" has n"I;: 'I\~ '1ny r"non'St or application.
flltq.
ao~~ 073 PACt' 'l87
~"'~!~\·;~I/i,~~"""it.'i :'ìi ,!"'!~.
·..'^"''''''''''--
J!'nUDry lJ, ,t>r')
M~~ 073 PACE 2.B8
reo~rrlin~ s~~e to this ~~te. H@ .t~te~ thMt h~ i~ not M~Dln~t ripr~p,
ð~~in? th,t h! ~orks very closoly with ~~R ~n~ "rn, M~AJn, thDt rirr~p
is not ~lway~ ju~ti!ie~.
commlsaioner Brown moved, leconded by Commi.sioner Pi.tor and
carried unanimoualy, that the pUblic hearinq be closed.
COr.'·r1ss1on~r VruF.~ iit,1t'!c' thnt R~(' h~J 1~'/(,s in the oropt'rty OWTurs
.,,'
riqht to ~rotect t~elr rr~r('rty, eArltn~ th~t ~hp. ~oc~ not n~rep with
rock r"vot","nt 11,lch "'OlJ),' ~xt(.'n" 1"'0 fp"t Into the COl!flt~l Con!ltruc-
;!I
tlo"l Control Un".
Co~r:-l!j!"loncr l:01',,,~'' <;toted thrt thl~ I" t-h,. flr~t ti",,. he h,s
herr~ ~nyon(' re~o"'~~n~ln~ not ~uttlnn rlprrr In 'ront of t~,. se~~Ml1,
....\¡qn., th.!'It rrr ,,~' :"""~ rf.co-m'·n"·~ thl~ rlrr.'r,. I'" co~~Ju-1p.r''''V
stc'ltln<" th~t hr. j.. in [,'vcr of th" of'tltlon'!r'!" r'!"u"!!'t.
Co'" n i !j:- ¡ 0 n ,.. r \' '1 :.: .!" ;- t . t",1 t ~ ,1 t t h". :' r n P r r ~ v r) I '''I ,. r h..... t ~ ~ r i (1 h t to
rrotcct r.1~ ::rnn<.rtv, "ut th" ~eDch II!! for al1 tö us!'. "(' C'luestioner'
""h"thr.r th'~ ~ ro["\ r·y :>...·n"r \<"0111" bt" \11 1) In!'! to rrr,nv" th" rl;'1r.." line'
ret'1i~n th" ·...,,11 If i~ r~!'\lI1tf) In I! loss or t-ei'lC~i, to ,-'hleh "r.
Frc'\ncof'ur !'!t"t...~ t"'-t rot' t:!\" no intrntior tc "r"",,,," ~~,.. hCc'\ch, ðd"ing
he.'1ch ð:'C'H"!,.
th~t If t~cr~ W~~ ~ot roö~ (or ~~or1e tn wð]k, hI' woul~ tAke ~ction and
mov~ hc'\ck nn~ wouJ~ ~p ~I]1in~ to r~~QV~ thr r ~r"r ~n" re~lfnn the
"""11, acì~in'l th.H it Is v~ry I!rnort!nt, "Qwr.vcr, to ~-=clc!«: "'1'10 I. to
rl@tcrmlnc such r ~-tter. ~f' ~t~te~ th~t ~~ ~~S ~o 1e~!r@ to c:lo.~
~orn''¡!'~lo:1''r ¡:rll!H~ lnr1Ic=::'c~ th',t r:o:""-In~io:'~r "OS~I answnr to hi.
quCFttlon I!' ,:,:)nt;l!n,-'1 In p..,rc('r/lrh : .'n~1 , or t~l~ ¡'ropo l e~ rl"olutlon.
Tape '3
. - ,
~
~
..
..
':
t~
,\"
:~~Uðrv ]1, I'r) ~
lor. c'rl1ncc-ellr s~.,t!<~ tnllt I,.. woul1'1r<;p t, ',nt:e( Int."
r:or,vl'r!'l:o'Itlono '."lth tr.'J ~r')unty ,=ont:~rnin'1 r:'r""rr.," I. \I~,I~h in:Hcllt'!s
t.h.!1t th~ !ltructur~ vloul':: "" 'IA1u9t.c:'!, ,,1tor'J'I, or r:!!movoc4 if It should
~ ')C'o..,~ rl~t r I ~"n t.~ J ~f) r-h", ~'I..w;\ r-1 bf!l'Ic~ (' r "A ~ r.~cnt u;"ll1n(! "roportialS,
'-¡ilnq th.'!t '1(.' :':1')111' ~ot: '1'HI!''' to It ln~l.,rlnltr'!lv.
Commis.loner Brown moved, seconded by Commissioner Rolland, that
Petition CCCL-B2-lS-C be granted as reque.ted by the petitioner without
any conditions. Upon call for the qu..tion, the motion failed 2/3,
(Commlssion.rs Voss, Plstor and Krus. opposed).
Commissioner Plstor moved that P~tition CCCL-82-lS-C be adopted a.
pre.ented. Motion died for a lack of s.cond.
Commissioner Pistor moved, aeconded by Commissioner Voss and
carried 4/1, (Commissioner Brown opposed), that Re.olutlon 83-1 re
Petition CCCL-~2-15C, Scofl.ld Marine Con.tructlon Company reque.ting a
variance from the CoaBtal Construction Control Line for property
located on Lots 25 and 2~, Block ^, Unit 1, Vanderbilt Beach (La Playa
B.ach and Racquet Inn "ddition, 9891 Culf.hor. Drive), be adopted with
the following stipulations:
1. That the placement of rlprap and the 8' revetment be granted
without moving the ..awall.
2. That La Playa B.ach and Racquet Inn, It. .uècel.or., heir., or
assigns agree to provld. in perpetuity a pede.trian by-pa..
to insure contlnu.d public acce.. to the beach north and .outh
of the structure only If the shoreline decreased to the point
that ped.strians could not walk on the .and. Thl. .hall b.
accomplish.d by the con.truction ~nd maintenance of rlrrap
cross-over steps at the north and .outh end of the revetment
and by granting the general public the right to walk landward
of the seawall cap during period. when high water preventl
passage aeaward of aaid atructure.
3. La Playa Beach and Racquet Inn, It. .ucce.sor., heir. or
a.aIgns agree to adjust, alter, or remove the permitted
.tructure .hould It become detrimental to the .eaward beach or
adjacent upland propertie., and/or becom.. dangeroul,
unde.irable, or unn.c....ry, a. conclu.ively documented by ,
ColI hr County.
ßC~,( 073 fAct 2.B9
P"C1' .,
·'I.i..:·~f~"":" :'~ ,;.'"
....
January )" l()r~
073 PACt 290
Upon roll call the vote v.. .. follov.1
Commi..ioner Piltorl Ay.
Comml..ion.r VOIOI Aye
Commissioner Roll.ndl Aye
Commls.ioner Brown. Nay
Commis.loner Krusel Ay.
***** Recess. 10125 A.M. - R.convenedl 10135 A.M. .....
"
r,o' '.^
"
',-'
.}.
~
~
..
-
¡.~~. )~~ ,,~,' ,
:, .', iii,'., '~,..,
.~, '. ;" .
JanulIry 11, 1(\~~
Il~¡: ,Q73 PACE 294
PROPOSED EAST NAPLES rIRE HYDRANT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT - CONTINUED 60
DAYS AND NOTICES TO BE RESENT TO ALL PROPERTY OWNERS
Le9~1 notice h~vin1 heen pu~lisheð In the ~aples Dally ~ewl ðl
evld@nc@d by ^ffln~vlt of Puhllcatlon, previously file~ with the Clerk,
public hearln~ w~s ~ontlnue~ from Dece~ber '-P, InnÞ, to consider the
creation of the r.ðRt NðpIcs Fire Hyrlrllnt Assessment nistrlct. ~r.
IIart",lIn, r>uhlic \o'orlq¡ ~r1,..lni l tr...tor, stðte=" th"t. t~1;t lIssossnent roll
wa~ ~odlflp~, ~1~ln~ th~t th~r' ar~ cert,in pooplc thøt never r.~eive~
~ l~tter but It w,s o~v~rtls@~ in t~e np.w9p~r'r.
~r. Larry rn~rn,." ~ttorn~y-at-Law, statod that ~Ummit Properties
di=! not recl"lv~ notlr;r> .,n" ~.~ ~"s hf'en ell'lploYftd to rÞ1:)rf"sent them.
County ~ttorn~y r,ur~rrR st~t~~ th~t th~ rrocedure is set In
0r~ln"ncc "H_JI \:'d~~, rl:'t'IJir('R t\.'o ty!"e!! o! notie'l:', one he!n':,! the
newspaper notlc~ nn~ one notlct' helna sent to Pilch affected property
o...·nPr. re !':t,1t~:1 th.'It If cl?rt.-ln property owneorø C"1c! not receive
notices the henrln" can utilI he henrC", a~dlnq that, howevor, If thore
Is evi~ene'@ th~t c('rtaln notices wer@ not sent, thp notices should be
sent ^nd the h~ðrlnq contlnue~.
Commissioner Vo.. noved, seconded by Co~ilsloner PI.tor and
carried 5/0, that the proposed East Napl.. rire Hydrant A.,e.,~ent
Di.trict be continued for 60 days and notice. be lent a9aln to all
property owners.
Ta pe 14
Ite. .6
RESOLUTION 83-2 RE PETITION V-82-29C, DAVID CONNALLY, REQUESTING A
VARIANCE rROM THE LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS rOR rRONT AND SIDE YARDS _
ADOPTED, SUBJECT TO THE PETITIONER WORKING WITH STArr'S LANDSCAPI
INSPECTOR
Legal notic,. hllvlnl) ~fH.':"I publhh.d In th. Nar1e!l "'.ally ~'elits on
Pccemh.r "", 1~r2, n! evidenced by ^ffi~avlt of. PUb11catlon fl1.~
fill
, . '~
Þ.g..J~:)
; '. ~,:~--,,;';'{,"
!::::f
;' .,.. ~!;'~~~/.:
-":...~.~.!.;.
.'1-
:'ot!' " '
,f....,¡;".'
~¡.'.,' ~.~
..
,jlfo1 \~ ',':.rl
"',.~'.....,.~ ,..~ "". ,,,,,,-."" .,- ..-.,",."..""""""
"3nu~ry 11, 11:''''
the Cleric, public ;u!lrinn 1':1\1 oponed to r.:orHI!-!'Jr p.,tition ~'_f.'~_"~r:,
David ~nnnal1y, roqu~stln, Q vl\ri~nco fro. ~h. l~n~s~~~., r~qutr~~~nts
for front ðn~ side yar~8 for pro~ftrty locato~ on ~hlrl.y ~trtet.
Pl~ns T~ole~ent~tion rlr~ctor r~y~~ 3t~t.~ t~~t thl3 r~~u.8t is
for ð v^rl"nc3 ~ro~ tho l!n~scðp, r"1ulr~~!ntl !or 'rant ~n~ .I~.
y"'rc!s, ·.lhlch r~qulrC's (\ ~, ~Il~,> hn1!Jc~¡:::~ strip !lro'Jnr' v..hicular acce..
ðnd p~rkln1 ðre~s, with on~ troe for !v~ry 5~ lin.ar fe.t. ~he stat.1
that, In "'d·11t:\.on, II '1 h~04.,t' i!'l rf!('1ulr"-' 1'101'\-' th, front Yo'lrr1. ~~!
noted th~t y.~r5 J10, tha ~.tltlon~rlg ~roperty WðS used ~s a cl.~nln9
and ~u~~lno ~r~(\ !or ~~~pnt tru~k~, ~1~ln~ th!t ~c ~ rOßult, thp.
~ðjorlty of the pr:>rrrty is cov~r~~ In c~~~nt. ~h. stðte~ th~t ~"'..~
on th~ 5trn1'r~H In ~~. tonl", ~r~ln·n=~ 'or rl~t~r~lnln" ~h~ rpason .or
^ v~rl'nce, ;,t~f! I, re~OM~pn~lnq t~~t t~~ retltl~~~rls ra~UQst n@
.... per 0 V (: d ~ ,,'-- ~ ,.. ~ ~ tot ~ 1 ... 1" I' .. fi C /I P') In., :? (I ~ ~ ~ r r ~ \' 1 ':! .d n" ... " "'I'" " " ~ ;, ~ v in,'
tho P!tlt1..:>rl'r nrovl"" ~"njr,cl~pln~ 1'1 tht 'r..,.,t y,H-! "/h...re therft 1. "0
con C' r ~ t,~ .
Commissioner Plstor moved, seconded by Commissioner Brown and
carried unanimously, that the public hearing be closed.
Commissioner Voss moved, .econded by Comml.,loner Holland and
carried 5/0, that Resolution 93-2 re Petition V-82-29C, David Connally,
requesting a varlancQ from the landlcape requirementl for front and
.Ide yards be ad~pted, subject to the petitioner working with Staff'.
landscape inspector.
&O~< 073 FA~t 295
rðn,.
'¡....:t";:J,:~:j,~,..,~'N~H .
,'¡" ,
'....-..""....-.-.
~".,.~,.",_".""","--,-,..","....""",."---_.__._-~..",, ""'"
,'Y.!InUllry 11, 1 C'" ~
80~~ 073 PACt: 298
Item 17
PETITION A-82-10, ARTHUR V. WOODWARD APPEALING ADMINISTRATIVE INTER-
PRETATION or DEFINITION OF ANIMATED SIGN - (PIRST BANK OF MARCO ISLAND)
- APPROVED
r.C111) notlc'" h,'vln,' ~"f:n ;1u....ll!"!1e~ In th·~ "::11'1<:15 l"!'\llv ~~ H'S on
t'ece",be r ,.., , 0:>":", M1" t¡"... ....1' rco I!J1.'n" 1"llC" L~ or, "'c~""''''(' r "", ] CO",, a.
evid','l"ce(! by !\ffirillvltl> of rubl1C''Itior. fil~~ ':lth tlt(' :::'lcrk, :')uhllc
herrin" ""'5 o::>..nt'~ teo ":'onrd~ar p...tltio"l ',_1'''-'''' lrthur \'. '.,1t)0,",\-~l'Ir1
ðcr~£1In1 ~~~In ntrntlvr Intar"r~tDtlon of ~ef¡nl~ion of ~nl~cte1 .lan.
C':1)r'11"ur.lty "nV-:]:~,r""nt rlrl"ctor l'lrt" J';t,"'tl"-'I ~f¡l't t",,, ~('tltloncr
h",: ,'r~llt"" [or" "'III](' ;),., rcr"lt to Instl'11 .- ,",,"I: ~I-:n ~.,,,~, in
1\,.... I t Ion t ~) t I r,~' ~ n :' '. ,........ ~ r " t lJ r c, 1..'0 U 1 r' ,., 1 1 ("¡ '..' f" r \I.- r I ~ '" ,!, P ß ~ !II ~ (" S . He
not~~ that thr ~~[Inltlon In th~ zonln'" "r~ln"ncr nr ~n ðnl~.t.~ R1~n
1~ "I' r.1~n ....,It~, 11'C~¡n~ '"Ir ...,t')'~"'''nt w¡.,..t~.,r 1,'1 'l"""in- 1iCl'1tS, color
ch'ln"~~, wln~ rntntlnr, ~nvn~cnt of ~ny ~~rt c' t~c nlan or sign
1: t r Ul'" ~ U r'" 0 r r "1': '"I t. h" r ..,,' i co ~ " .
u~ ~t~t~~ ~h-', h,c"'-'I u~on cl~r1ty a~
ßeen ~i' :t.l:f~ In t~1" or(~fnl'nc~, the ;')'!rr-it lor; ,-1",1,.." l!r.(', ~t t~ls
timç, th~ ~~tltIDnrr Is ~r~c~1in~ th~ ~nC"iCI"n.
"'r. :-ttorh"'n l'lIr~ctt,.., ~"'''r¡c'll'1 'ï"n I'~'" rn~IC'..tor Company, s~ow.d
II n lH tis t fI' n ~1 '" r I r.'" (' f t h '? pro 1"0 S r.' ~ ~ 'II ~ r for t).¡ t' S ¡ "n .
Commlsslo"1cr Vrus~ qucstion"" if t'H' r'ln¡!.:lY I'ltero~ Its form, to
I-fhich "'r. rur":-tt" f,t,~t,,·1 tt'!1t It "'t"'rs It'1 'or". In t"t' ml'nn!r 1n
't:hlch t1mf' IIn'" te~r'-'r...tllre "'I~r.l,'v~ "ltl~r thclr for::", ch'lnclinlJ fro:'1 one
f-Ihce 0' lnform,-tlon ..., t~.!' ~ther.
"... str terl t"1<'1 t' t'lI II IIl('1n 18 II
InOSlIlIQI" unit for F'lr!\t ¡"'nk o~ 'l'rcro T!!lð!'l-1 ....~iC'~ Is ~illdll'r to th.
MP.SSð-,r. unit no\.' In O"1~Pt!~r" ....:1 ~'3r~"s r,.l'!er,." l't Co1~Qn r.8tp rarkw.y.
'i(' stat..., th...t this ,"I~rl."y Is "'one Idt~ solar rr.flectivt' pent-II .n~ 1.
ln~talled on c~ stln'" ~vlnrs.
lIt C'oncluc'p,", hy "ttltln~ that it il
r'eabne-1 to I"¡~ntify th" 1c(>"t'ior, of ttu" custoMt'r's htJsln~ss and to
P.~.
t?t;",'~n
IIi1
..
...':.~ " :¡,~;'.... :,~,: .' '. ".'.....A'\'o¡' '.."~\"~....~:;:.I, .
".¡' ..,i,.'~ J,. ~.,
Jl.nu~ry 1', J~~'
provido Inforn~tion to th~ r.orl~ ~~ssin~ hy '9 to the activity
on in th~ Cll~tomflrl~ I,lIslncss.
Co~mI8Iio~~r v~,,~ quo.t1o~@d I' t~o ~~In~qt mov.ø ~~rns., to
"'r. ?ur:1"tte !Jt~t~,,, it. <:10..,8 ~ot p:rl1v"l, 1 t ...~.,s not noat up nnd <:1own,
~nd I~ ~0~5 ~ðt rn!~~t~.
Yr, .1:>"'1 "O:1l.'v, rC!nr"~!"ti,,- 1'.'1" T~l"t{t1o:'1~r, st...t't<'1 t.l,lIt
.'Inl~'''t!.,n ¡!II -:)V~-"'1t t~1H.,.': uIA "'~·,,:.,c:t:'''1~ ':1y !lo:11lJboc1y ."ðtchinry th't
....
51'1'1. "" ~...,t~" .".~ ~,I"'I ~y , '~~'J!'" ~~.. '1!~r. r:",~n,"''''~ ~OOB not "''''en that
it Is ,'nl,"\l'Itc', .:~ ~,,:...(. t::1t th, r!"~'" ~H4 ",.,t{'r"'ln~~ t~ðt this sil.Jn
Is r,ot ,'n "'\~t"", ',, ·f...·, ':',~t. j:~ !!I r')""J",.!'.ln~ thl'~ t~'!' ~"t1tlon '.:-e
a P r r 0 v C" .
Commissioner Plator moved, seconded by Commissioner Voss and
- carried unanimously, that the pUblic hearing be closed.
Commissioner Plat.or moved, seconded by Commissioner Vas. and
carried 4/1, (Commissioner Kruse opposed), that Petition A-82-10,
Arthur V. Woodward appealing admini.trative Interpretation ot
definition of animated sign, be approved.
Item '8
PETITION PU-Q2-24C, KILIAN BAYER - WITHDRAWN
Commissioner Pistor moved, .econded by Commi..loner Holland and
carried unanimously, that Petition PU-82-24C, Kilian Bayer, be
withdrawn as requested by the petitioner.
Ite. 19
RECOMMENDATION THAT PERVIOUS PARKING REQUIREMENT BE DELETED ON ALL
PREVIOUSLY APPROVED PROVISIONAL USES - APPROVED, SUBJECT TO MEETING THI
COUNTY'S W~TER MANAGEMENT REQUIREMENTS
aoo~ 073 fACf299
n'lns '~¡','-':nt~t!:>n I"irl}ctor r.~Yr'., stat'!1 th!'lt this reQuest is to
:!~l,!to t!'." ").:!r','¡.,·,n ,-HI-In" st.1!,ul;.tJon fro., prt'vlo~Jaly ~ppro'I.1
provlslona! tI!lo1!'t, "'~ln1 t":'It It hlu hten rltC:OMM.n~Ðt1 In the P".t
tt,Q rnvlro~M~nt'l1 ··'vi~ory ,="oul'\cil !In"" !as cr~...tG" pro~l(ll"" for
M:~ 073 f.\~t 300
,1anllðry ", ](\/",
proje~tc èurin1 tM~ r~iny se~son an~ for ~U9 ~n~ h^n~icð~ p~rk1nq. r.h-
ctl'tel" tt:/lt t!'1er'" h'lv(, hp.cn se\'t"ro' rl'!que~t!' ror thl/11 IIME!n~'!1.nt an-J thll
r~c h~ß ~rO?~D~ t~~ ~~I~ul~tion, ~A~in~ th~t rrtM~r ~~t~ ~rln,ln~ eoch
~rovl~ior~J U3r ~~C~ tn th~ Ao~r~, r re~un~t Is ~1 ~7 ~~.~ to (tlÐt~
thlr ~t ;·)ul/ t!o~ !Jubi!'':t ::0 "1('~t. n,; t~/" ~ounty'~ I.'.~t'~r !'!'t'n~('!E'ment
r~~ulr('::1cnt~.
Commissioner Pistor moved, seconded by Commissioner Brown and
carried unanimously, that the recommendation to delete pervious parking
requirements on all previously approved provisional uses be approved.
Item '10
CARNIVAL PERMIT 83-1 RE PETITIO~ C-R2-6C, COLLIER COUNTY AGRICULTURAL
FAIR AND EXPOSITION, INC. REOUESTING A PERMIT TO CONDUCT THE ANNUAL
COLLIER COuNTY FAIR - APPROVED WITH THE WAIVERS BEING CRANTED
Commissioner Plator moved, seconded by Commissioner Brown and
carried unanimously, that Carnival Permit ~J-1 re Petition C-B2-6C,
Collier County ^qricultural Fair and Exposition, Inc. requesting a
permit to conduct th@ annual Collier County 'air on January 15 through
January 23, 1983, be approved and the followinq waivers be granted
excep~ for the waiver of the $50.00 feer
1. A Surety Bond In the penal SUm of $2,500.00, conditioned upon
the operator complying with each provl110n of Ordinance 75-11.
2. A non-refundable fee of $50.00.
3. A current occupational license iSlued by the Collier County
Tax Collector.
4. The name, identification and SOClll lecurlty number o! each
person accountable for the operation of each activity.
s. The duration of the permit shall not exceed five calendar
days.
PI'Ç.'.
r:=J
mIm
..
\ '.'/.';':'" ~,t.I'~
,Mnu:!ry 11, 11'1"3
It.. t 11
R!COMM~NDATION TO WAIV~ THE ON! (1) YEAR TIMI LIMIT rOR REAPPLICATION
OF A REZONE PETITION BY WOODFIELD LA~ES LOCATID ON CR-95l NORTH or
US-4l - APPROVED
Plans t~p1ementatlo~ nlrpctor L~yn. stðte~ that th~ ~etltlo~er
W1Dheø to rCMpply [ðr ~ razon~ r~tltion prior to thð on~ y.~r
requlr...,ent ^ftpr ~cnl"l of th~ or!~lnð1 requ@!t. ~hc not9d that
S~ctlon 1~. I'~ of t~ft 70nln~ 0r11n~nc~ q~ðte~ th1t wh9rQV~r thl eo~r~
of r.ounty ~oMml5cloncrs hDS d~nle~ ~n ^pp11c~tlon for the rezoning of ~
propprty, t~e rl~nnln1 ~ð~~i~nlon ~~~ll not th.r~'f~~r co~qt1~r 8ny
further app1lc"tlon for ~,~ S~~~ r01.onlng of ~ny p...rt or ~ll of the
SD~e oropnrty for ~ n~rlo~ or twolv~ ~onth3 frn~ the ~'te of su~h
.'Ictlon. ~he n'jt~,1 t>¡~t t',,, po"r~ m",y ,r,~nt '"I '.....lv~r t:) t'l1~ ti",.
parlo· ·...It') t"'r"" '~r r~,,)t I\'~ v(')t('~ or ':t'-.. no~r" ~Ih"n !'Inch '~tlon Is
c1" f} I"! c'1 n N~ " ~ 3 ,H Y t J r' r I'V l" n tin 1 us t 1 ~., CI r to f D C I 11 t ,1 t ~ t h () pro r "o! r
dAVp.1o!)"I"nt o~ rolll"r Count'!. "h, ~t."te-1 thl'lt the !'etltl~n W.... A~n1'?'"
In ~...y, I'r~, whl~~ woul1 not ~~~" the p~tlttonnr el1~1~1, to raapply
prior to Y~y, I~"'.
"II~ ":o~,r:ll1ll'~ '1Y 3tH!n", tl''It th~ ~"tit:ton.r 1s
r·J('lu~'tlno ''''.'Iv~r :)r!l)T to "i'lY 'nA ~t,,~, If¡ r3co"''''~n(!ln'1 a~prov"l.
"0:1,,1'1 FIn"., r"; r"!';/":1tln'l r..,n".J ( ~orr,.,r.'t1on, ntllt.1 t"'at th4t
ro.Hlon for rC·llJ'!5tlr., thl!' ',I,lvfH "r t~,'t ono y@"r tine l1:nlt 111 t""t "u.
to t~~ ~n~ n~Arf¡, t~~ ccn~~r~1 0' th~ ~oM~I~~ionQrø h^v. heen resoly~A.
Pl~ns J~ple~~nt~tl(')n rlroctor L~yn' statftd th8t tMe potltlon would
hl'lve to b., r(,'.Iu')."I~t~, ..]o~., llith '" n~I" rllt, an~ th- 8ntlr~ :"ro~.ss
woul~ h~v.. to h~ 10n~ ~hrou~"J~!n.
"'r. Goor.;:!' "111~r, H"I: ""th ·v~. '"....., stlltt'~ th'lt h" "''IS A?"lnst
th" wa1v.r of the one Yf'lIr tine petrlo!"!.
Co-.11.10ner Brown moved, .econded by CommS..Soner Holland and
carried 4/1, (Commi..Ioner ~ru'e oPPO'.d), that the r.co...ndatSon
&O~K 073 'ACE301
·"·""'·_'·_-___._,__'~,'___",..._,...K',.
"
,.fI,·J". . ,!'if, -" lit'
,Tanul'lry 11, 101:?~
MOK 073 PACt 30Z
waive the one year time limit for reapplication of a rezone
Woodfilld Lake. located on CR-951 north of US-41 be approved. ,
Uell 112
RESOLUTION 83-3 REOUESTING COUNTY REPRESENTATION ON THE PROPOSED 8rO
CYPRESS AREA MANAGEMENT TASK rORCE _ ADOPTED
Comml..loner Pi.tor ~oved, lecondld by Commi..ioner Vo.. and
carried unanl~ou.ly, that Relolution 83-3 reque.ting county
rlpreøentation on the propo.ed Big Cypre.. Area Management Ta.k rore.
be adopted.
'.
'.; ..
rag.
,.
fII9
..
,.,¡: ,~';:.. .
, '.
~,"'I j,
. ._'''''..,.,......~'''''.._~_.,,~.,-'''"~~".""-
't
14,
'I'
;£;'
1"
,Ii,
..~,'.
:Ifl
,1ÞnUðry ]], 1/)1'3
Ite. '13
REPORT ON ASPHALT VERSUS CONCRETE BIKrwAY8 - EXHIBIT -A- ACCEPTED AND
EXHIBIT -B- PAVEMENT APPROVED POR THE PISCAL YEAR 82/83 8IKrwAY PROGRAM
WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT THE BIDS BI BROUGHT B~CK TO THE BOARD POR
PINAL APPROVAL
~'r. lJ'Irt"ll"n, COU:'1ty F:nglnur, stlltt'd that this r"port wal 8lke(f
for when the blkew^y rro,r'm w~~ npproved for o~/~1, ~dding thðt Some
bikeways were nt!1}c>cto" in the repc't: which werft roquestft<! by thft
School ~01H". f':, stðt~d th....t such ~lk(!wIIYs ~r" th'J "nes for ~olden
G ð t C ... I ,J: 1 t' <:' ~ h 0 " 1 ',' hie h " r (' 0 n , n T err", c f:' S . ',.' ., :' -: t h r> 1 "c eo ~ . '''. ,
Troplcanð Plv1. ~n~ ~ol~cn G~t~ P~rkway. P9 st"'t~d th'lt Colden ~atø
Parkway Is In=lut~r In th~ report, ....~~lnl thAt ~n ~"ul~ reco~mend that
the h1k~WðY on V,'n.'~l'r~¡lt r:rlve fro"! '1'I:¡111ns 'laB!' POliti to Bonita Shores
be us,,'" 'IS thO! 30urC1 of r1Jn:l~ t" ?ro\lI(1~ thf' ~ll(~....",y~ For tho ("',olden
CHoP "'H11~ ~C't,,,o1. II" nott'1 th,H t'1.. ch~n'l!s lirA heln" recornrHtn1e1
bec...us~ 1)[ t'1'! "-,rl'ty or <:,"'n ~C'~~:)o) :!'111'~ren. :." noterl th,'t blc1s "'oul~
be t~~on for ~~ncr~tu 'n~ n~~h~lt.
CO~~IF~I"~ftr nj~tor ~t^tl!1 th~t h~ woul1 11~~ th~ ~lkow~v on I.l~
of C~rrl to he c~ngldcr~~ for =o~~rrt@ 'B the people there have
con-:rete Wð'~".
~r. 0tl~ P1~r1q~~, ~~nl ~ul'shorc Rtv~., st~tc~ th~t "'s,~~lt
sh"ul~ not "! \J5~:J for th,,"!! 1:>1KI!WðYS ",'lIt 1eter1orlltes very ra~ldly
1 fit 1!1 not ., u ') -\ " :: t (0 ,t ·,0 t h, k n e""l1 n'" , C t:1 0 n :> f. '1 '1 " W, Y t r ð f f1 c . ne
rioted thH. thl ~)!:\")w"Y!1 for chll~r.,n I!Ihoulrl be I'Iðfe and concr"te woulð
he l!1uC'h better.
Tape . 5
CommIaaioner Pistor moved, aecond.d by Comall.loner Brown and
carried un.nlmoualy, that Exhibit -AR b. accepted and the type of
pave..nt on Exhibit -81 be approv.d regarding the PY 82/83 8lkeway
Program, with the underatandlng that the bid. be brought back to the.
Board for final approval.
&o~x 073 tACf 1>5
Page l~/t~;
"~"F.~..~/t~
<::,.,;,~~¡~' ,
.1, ,'\
, I ;,~t1I~::":Vo¡~',~') ,!~~'i., ,¡:-~ I;~~'}:':;¡, '¡'c,',' '-;
"{¡' ~
"
" ':, ~..,~ '~..{ '(It ~\\;,l,.J :'..,.ÇI:\iÏ(I:·.~~,;tl ~IV ,;
,'anu.uy ] 1, l(l~"
nem 114
LEASE/OPTION AGREEMENT FOR THE EMS FACILITY ON TERRACE AVENUE
APPROVED AND CHAIRMAN AUTHORIZED TO EXECUTE SAME
}!eil Dorril1, puhl1c S"hty Mmintstutor, stat.." tho!lt on '1ovember
9, 19P./., the no~r1 unðnt~ously 4pprovo~ th~ c~ncept of providIng for ð
consolir1...ter1 ;''''f '¡,cility. lie ,t:l'lud th.1t th"r.. Is "10" ,;'I teal%ption
ðgreement th~t Is ?n3 of th~ Mo~t f~vornhle 1!nsð8 wlt~ an option to
purch~se '1r~e~ent t~~t h~~ ~cen n~10tiMt.~~ For offic~ ty~e s?ac~.
Co~m!s~lon~r VO~g 1uontion~~ If t~e 1~1se an~ purch~se option is
ð.~lqnnhle, to ~h!ch rounty "ttorn~y S~un1.r9 r~plie1 ~f.flrm~tlvely.
Commissioner Piator moved, seconded by Commissioner KruI. and
carried 3/2, (Commissioner Rolland and Brown opposed), that the
Lease/Option Agreement for the EMS facIlity on Terrace Avenu. be
approved and the Chairman b. authorized to execute .ame.
eo:.< 073 'ACED
\~- ~. :. ",'- .\1 . \~!. '.t\t.. ';", :".,,~J'¡' ,'! ""'-t" ..
--_....~
\
January 11, 19A3
aOOK 073 PACE 322
Ite. 115
~IRST rOUR TUESDAYS or EACH MONTH TO BE SCHEDULED rOR BCC MEETINGS
BEGINNING TUESDAY, JANUARY 18, 1983 - APPROVED
Commissioner rlstor stated he would lIke weekly board meetin~.
reconsidered as he feels that the public has to take time off from work
and when th. meotln~ lasts until the afternoon, some of the pUblic can-
not stay to att.nd. He noted that p~ople that have attorneys present
are paying a large Sum for these attorneys to sit all day waIting. He
noted that thcr~ is no additional cost to have the meetings on a weekly
basis as It takes the S~me amount of tIme to prop~re the backup
.'
material whethor It Is weekly or bi-weekly. He conclurled by stating
that It Is mor~ of ,II convpnlonce for the public and staff to have
weekly me@t!ngs.
CommIssioner Plstor moved that in thIrty day. weekly BCC meeting_
be .cheduled. Motion died for a lack of .econd.
Commissioner Voss questioned if the a~enda was prepar.d every week
would it be a considerable ~ddQd time requirement to Staff, to which
County Manager Norman replied afflrmativ.ly, adding that preparing the
agenda and following up ,lifter the meeting Is time consuming and by
.,\.~\~..
,' ~"'1i~t+
having meetings every week, it would be a duplicatIon.
... \eo,"~
'..'
. )~ ~ 'f .
Commissioner 8rown stated that by having me.tlngl ""ry two week."
one person has been eliminated in the Cl.rk's offic..
Mr. Henry ~axant, representing Pin. Rld~e Civic A.sociation,
st~t.d that it is opproprlate to consld~r Commissioner PI.tor'l
suggestion at this time, ~ddin9 that th.re has b.en Some slippage in
the .fficlency and conduct of the me.tings by having only two meeting_
a month. H. stated that too many me.tIng. have b..n too ru.hed and
other meetings have 90ne Into afternoon ..,.ion. unn.c.,.arily.
Coc.i..ioner Holland moved, seconded by Co.-l..loner PI.tor and
.' ~.
" '".
1: ' , ~
"
P.g.
~ .
"'.
,/",
~'"
I,.,,>', :,
~'.............~
~
~
EBI
,.'
,,',".
~~ '.- l'
T'. __~"
,....,..___...." ·,.~·~.,·",.."","""".."",,=u. __"'.""~"N_·'
. ., f
January 11, 19A3
Qarrled 3/2, (Commi..ioner. KruI. and Vo.. oPpo..d), that the flr.t
tour Tuelday. ot each month be Icheduled for BCC .eetlng. b.glnnlng
Tuelday, January 18, 1983.
%tea 116
ADCITIOHAL FULL-TIME POSITION FOR THE ELECTIONS OFFICI AND TRANSFER or
FUNDS TO THE APPROPRIATE ACCOUNTS FROM CONTINGENCIES _ APPROVED
Mary Morgan, Supervisor of Elections, stated that in order to
accompltsh a lot of the goals and put the office in better shape to
withstand the five elections which are scheduled for 1~P.4, ad~itlonal
help is needed. ~he noted that In 19~2 there were 4,744 new re9istr,-
"
'~., tlons processer! an1 9,fJOO new 'Ioters. She stated that for every 10,000
,4~~·:
1
" ;,
voters therit Is ð ncad for an additional full-time employee. She
r e po r t e d thð t In 19:1;1 she put in 1;85 hours of overtime and the
employ@es put ! n '34 hours of overtime an" there was ðn additional 800
hours of ~vert!~~ (rom volunteer workers. She stattd that paying
overtiMe durin? the year Is more than one additional employee would
coat.
Commissioner Brown moved, leconded by Com.I..ioner VO" and
carrIed 4/1, (Commissioner Kruse 0PPoled), that an additional full-tl..
position for the Elections Office and transter of fund. to the
appropriate accounts from Contlngenci.s be approved.
County ~anðger Nor~an indicated that h11 Statf Is heavily engaged
at this time In pr.p~rin9 b'report and recommendation which will re.ult
In the reduction of ftorvlces in order to balftnce the budget tor the
current year.
Item 117
MOTIOK NOT TO CONSTRUCT ROADWAY BETWEEN FRANK BOULEVARD AND 14T8
AV!NU!,-xT MIDBLOCK LOCATION NORTH 0' MICHIGAN AVINUI _ APPROVlD
Mr. Hartman, Public Works Admlnl.trator, stated that he turnlsh,d
the board a report on the history of thIs il.ue, adding that prevloualy
6Of.)r 01.3 ~323
Tape 16
Ite. 118
ALTERNATE 2 RE PROPOSED CONNECTION or GULrSRORE BOULEVARD TO
DRIVE - APPROVED
,
. .
., ",-,~---"~"""""..",,,, ",.,,;,. '~'~",".,--,~-_......
, . ... ..,.
,~
.\,~~
'"::1}:
" .,it
,.,6t~
'~~~:~::.
January 11, 1983
&oa~ 073 PACE m
the board had accepted the donation of a piece of land from Mr. Peter
Stone that would enable the County to conn6ct Frðn~ Blvd. with 14th
":"J~:~:
" :i,·-'t,.~':,\
^yenue.
The following people spoke In opposition to the above referenced
ccnnectlon b@tween Frank Boulevard and l4th Avenue citing Increased
traffic, noise, safety hazard~, and decreased property valuer
Mr. Rick W,.,gqonor 1336 ~Ichlgan ^venue
Ms. Jeanette Van Be zey 1313 Michigan ^venue
Mr. Tim Zel1p.rs 135j1\ Michigan ^venue
Tape '6
Mr. La r n O'Hara 17.25 Michigan Avenue
Mr. Mike Zewðlk 4P",0 ~ est Blvd.
~r. Waggoner presenterl a signed petition from people that are
opposed to sðid connection.
The (o11o~in1 people spoke In favor of the above reforenced
connection c!t¡n~ le~ß commercl~l traffic through ð resirlent1a1 area,
community improvement, ^nd shorter response time for emergency
vehicles:
~r. Peter Stone
Chief Jim Jones
ISO Turtle Lake Ct.
North Naples Fire District
Commi8ø1oner Holland ~oved, leconded by Co~ml..ioner VOII and
carried 4/1, (Co~~i..ioner Pi.tor oppo.ed), that the roadway betveen
~,\ -:~ ~':
runk Boulevard and 14th Averlue, at mldblock location north of IUehI9In"'/.'
. . ..I ,
'('I ~;,~
Avenue, not be constructed.
0,
': t';. ¡I'
o ' 'iS~~
u.. .~~/
o.f\~
~'ivll . "
~! .\/~:..
, .J J"" '.--".,:'":,,
"," \.,."
'. '.;t'i'·
~,".' -f"tJ/
" ,;:', ,'f~~> ¡,~,;,
SIACATI'~\.\:,\.,
····RECESS' 12'00 Noon RECONVENED. 1r30 P.M. It whIch
Deputy Clerk Skinner repl.ced DePutr Clerk Kenyon.
Commi.sioner Pi.tor va. .blent li9n fled by 4/0 vote....
Public Works "rtmlnistr~tor Hartman referred to an aerl.l ~.p on
~
page
.:,. ..
. .
.. "., '...
u':ÚEJ
~.'
~
..
. .," ,~, ,. -", '~""
.,' ,',', ¡ :Pr,,'r. i:
January 11, 19A3
overhead board ~nd explained Alternate 2 regardIng the proposed
connection of Culfshore Boulevard to aeagate Drive as ~elcrib.d in the
<'" ~.'y-""
',');,~~h'
" :",:~\~Jt¡.
',t,. ..~,
"::')~ ,.~~1"
. Tt1;~;~< .
. ~,:.:,<;:~~~:~:'::
'~.;'.'
,~:.~.¡~J,. '.
""'~~,;
:_,~(.~).¡):~
'(I:1ì",,~'i
C"'f"'i
,,)1,:\
'·""N."
:r-'!·:~r'·':
Executive Summary In today's Ag.nda.
CommillIoner Brown moved, aeconded by Commiaaioner Vo.., that
Alternate 2 re proposed connection of Culfahore Boulevard to Seagate
Drive be approved.
Chief JIm JonGs, North Napleø Firo District, Spoke In favor of
Alternðte 2 of the propos9d connection of Culfshore Boulevar1 to
Seð1ate Drive, an~ pxpl~inod that such ð connection would decrease the
response tIme or hi a fIre depart~ent thereby posslhly saving lives.
At Commissioner "olL~nt:l's requ",st, ~r. Hartm~n Inrt1cated the route
of,the Þfoponed conn~ct!on b~t~een CUlfshore Boulevard anrt the western
terminus of S~'1~t~ Drive ðnd between the eastern end of the east-west
portion or feðQ~lp ~rIve and Crðyton Road. He said this connection
would be l@ss costly than "lternnte 1 bp.tween the proposed western
terminus of the four-l~ned ~!ð~ate Orlve and the north terminus of
Culfshore Boul~v'r~.
Upon call for the que.tlon, the motion carried 4/0.
Item 119
STArr AUTHORIZED TO ACOUIR" BUILDER'S RISK INSURANCE, JUSTICE CENTER
EXPANSION, FROM THE APPARENT LOW BID IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED .9,300
ANNUALLY FOR THE LIFE OF THE PROJECT
Public $ð(ety AdmInlstrðtor Dorr1l1 explain.d th~t as a r.sult of
providing for in9urðnce requIrcments for contr~ctors working on the
Justicrt Center, staff dlsco'/crcd" roquirttment that those contractor.
have called -ßullt:1or'n Risk InRurðn~eR, which .ss~ntlally Insures the
building and building matorials that are Involved with construction of
the projoct, fron nðtural hazards ~n~/or construction accidtnts. H.
sðld that, based on recomm@ndatlons of the conatructIon manager and
E. W. ~iver~ and Associates, the Risk ~ana9.ment Conlultant, .taff
&001( 073 PACE 32S
,:,,':'
,"':: .
\:
'i',,~<;·..:,
~J~'5lt,;:;
:' ~
;".' .y.
;''''+..'''\
." j\~, '.';
"p,',
}'i~J
",;;,'~r
, ,~,-~"':';.~
·,~~ ,~~t~ '
~¥:\.
,~..." .'.::f f"
: 'I.:(I~
.:\:::~:.,/:
"'. ~
" f
. .
c" J
, !'
January II, 1983
&OCK G 73 PACt 32B
r~Commends that the County obtain this insurance as the owner so as not
to involve numerous and duplicate coverages which might be held by a
variety of contrðctors. lie referred to the Executive Summary, dated
l/~/P3, which outlined the insurancu coverage. Chairman Yruse noted
that the recommendation In the r.xecutlve Summary should read win an
th@ street 0: that would he put on the street and or~neð sometiMe
amount ~ to exceed $~,300 annually for the life of the projectR. Mr.
rorrlll salð that tho insurance should give the County full coverage of
l~-1/2 million rlollars with the County as the solp party insured for
Builders nis~ with a tl,OOO deductible, which w~s the lowest available.
Rt'spondin'J to Commlscioner IJolhnd, ro'r. Dorrill said that the Risk
Management Consultonts Indicate that ð. a rOBult of things currently on
within the next two months, the savings to th@ contractors could be
approxim.Hcly ~C.fI,(1(1r. lie Ðald that he hoped, IJlvon competitive
bidding and the desire o( the p~ople to ohtaln the work, that the
contractors would p~~s ~ost of that ðMount on to the County but that he
could not say the County will save ~~o,noo. He said th~t the majority
of the contracts ~re "out on the street- at the present time Involving
primarily the structure and shell, and the mechðnlcal and electrical
þ.
,J:
work for the new jail Is to b@ opened the third week of this month. He
said that an ðd~endum went out So that the Contrðctors are aware of the
situation.
Commi.sioner Holl.nd moved, .econded by Commi..ioner Vo.., and
carried 4/0, that staff be authorized to acquire Builder'. Ri.k
Insurance for the Justice Center Expan.ion from the apparent low bid
(contingent on the County's Conaultant certifying that the bid ..t the
apeciflcation) in an amount not to exceed $9,300 annually for the I1f.
o! the project.
Ite. . 20
. ~ '
.'
Pag.
, ... ' ,
d. '~' """
',1, ..~ ~ .
, ~,.'
, ; ~,
\¡~ ..".
;"':1'
~"""
".",., ,";.
~~~,
l1li
-
., '~" \:" ~," ~ '. .,
.....tIr""'-~ ,\
'.. ,~~,~..
January 11, 1903
;·"~iJr
"1;;~~1,.:tJ:)
" ',:,.~~t~'~\!f!.I~'
, <'~~~\j~:
".' ;..~,~..i~f.:
. "I',~' ~,-
"";,;.f',!'., ,,'
" . , 'l;IC"
, "'i.,y~iJ.~'
PERMISSION FOR COUNTY MANAGER AND PUBLIC SAFETY ADMINISTRATOR '1'0 "nEND ',',\tì
THE NATIONAL EMERGENCY TRAINING CENTER IN IMMITSBURO, MD, JAN. 23-28, ';;:Ú:r¡
1983 - DENIED ,',,'1'f.
\ ,~\t,~
1,1 !;~. ",
. ~ t"l
'¡·...I:\
f,_,;
Public Safety Administrator Dorr111 expla1ne1 that thG County
~ana90r and h~ have been selected by the Federal Emergency ~ana9.ment
Agency to ~tten~ an ~~ergency mðnðgement training session in
r.mmltaburg, ~n, January '-J-?~, 19Q3, arlðln9 that all expenses would be
pðid except the food COSt5 of $11 per person/~ay.
Commissionor Voss moved, leconded by Chairman ~rule, that the
County Manager and the Public Satety Admlnlatrator be authorized to
attend this program. The motion was denied by a vote ot 2/2, with
Commissioners Holland and Brovn opposed.
Itelll 121
CONCEALED WEAPONS PERMIT, HARVEY TUBBS _ DENIED
rubl1c Safety ^rlmln!str~tor Dorrlll explained that Ita!! recom-
mends denl~l ot 'ð conct'l'Ile'" weapons permit for II..rvey Tubbs based on I
' ,.
"
recummen1ation of th~ Shorirf's Department.
Commissioner Rolland moved, seconded by Comml.,loner Vo.. and
carried 4/0, that a conce.led we.pons per_it tor Harvey Tubba be
denied.
It.. 122
CONCEALED WEAPONS PERMIT 83-1, LARRY J. McALISTER _ APPROVED
Public Safety ~~minlstrator Dorr111 explatned that statt
reco~mend8 l'Ipprovl'll of ~ concel'lled w.apons permit for ~rry J.
McAlister, adding that Mr. ~1c",11stcr's background has been thoroughly
check~d an~ thðt he Is e~ployed by ~ bon~in9 3gency and has ~
1egitimat@ request for conce~led weapons protection.
Comml.sioner Holland moved, .econded by Co.-i..loner vo.. and
carried 4/0, that Concealed Weapon. per_it 83-1 be approved for Larry
&oo~ 073 tAc£3f:1
Pa9·
,..:.ç,
,...~.. "~".~.'
,:¡ 6', OJ,,
, ,\',' ,
. ,I
.'. "
,"(~~:":,\~ .
.c¡..".
i!&;.· .
, .'-:~',
...{~;:
~"" ~~,...,'"....."''',.,.. ",'_"'__;""""-' "'0 ........
January 11, 1~~3
J. McAlister.
Item . 23
~ 073 PAct 328
ACQUISITION or ADDITIONAL FIREFIGHTER, OCHOPEE FIRE DEPARTMENT _
APPROVED
Public ~~fcty "dMinistrator Dorrill explained staff recommendðtion
that an additional firefighter be hireð for the Ochopee Fire
Dep.Htment. He said that ..dth the start of this fiscal ye1tr, the
County entered into ð contr...ctual arrangement with the City of
rver~l~rlps to provldo flro s~rvlce for the incorporðte~ city at their
fire station wr.lch resulted in the County assuming responsibility for a
second stntlon. !I(' s;lld th<'lt II contractual commltm~nt on the part of
both parties w~s that ...n additional firefighter would be hired so that
both stations would b~ ~blc to be oporated. He not@~ that one station
would be m~nned only h~]f of e...ch week and that th~ rest ~f the time
staffing lo'oulc1 rrovlde th~t two st<'ltions WQulc1 he open, however, al a
result oC the vo]um~ or clllls, the rire Chief hils elected to perform,
in addition to his regulllr duties, a standard fire service shift of
twenty-fours on, forty-el~ht hours ofC which me1tns that he has to work
every day. ~r. ~rrll1 said that, with the coming tourist season
combined with th. perennial ~ry season, the recommendation is that the
County acquire ~nother firefighter.
Tape 17
Commissioner Brown moved, seconded by Commislioner Holland ~nd
carried 4/0, that the acquisition of an additional firefighter for the
Ochopee rire Department, be approved.
Ite. '24
WILDERNESS ALTERNATIVE DIRECTOR POSITION EXEMPTED rROM CURRENT HIRING
FREEZE, AUTHORIZATION TO FILL VACANT POSITION _ APPROVED
Judge Trettls ~xpl~lned th~t the Wilderness ^lternative Program 1.
still viable and b~dly needed since the practice has b.gun of .ending
,"
.
~'..
.' "
Page 2'
L.~:J
~.,.,.,
~
..
l, H" f. 1, ~"'W'..,. f4-J,¡";.]:..~,..r.~:iif.\,>,,~, ,.lí'\"",~,,"\~,~.~l";:'}"';:kl,f."~'':, '"., ",~..-.:
:ranunry II, 1"111
.....
'/f.
, ,~~
,:~~~~~
.'.;<
"'t?'
.+,~.
":'..'.~.
.~,> .
.'¡
:"~
.~~
"'~.'
,.i,
j
hard core delinquents to Felony Court, a1~Ing that the County Court is
incraðsln~ly h~co~in1 a plðc. to stnd younq people ~ccuse~ of "
misdeM'!.!Inor if therl.1 Is!J felony triol. lie 9-!11d that It person to
h!n~le thet type of CðS~ lond i8 n~edo~.
Commissioner Holland moved, leconded by Commislioner Brown and
carried 3/1, with CommillIoner Kru.e oppo.ed, that the po.ltion of
Wilderne.. Alternative Director be exempted from the current hiring
fr.eze and that the vacant position be filled.
Item '25
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION ON PROPOSED AGREEMENT FOR PROSECUTOR SERVICES
WITH STATE ATTORNEY - CONTINUED TO 1/25/83
Commissioner Holland moved, .econded by Chairman KrUS4 and carried
4/0, that a report and recommendation on a propoled agreement for
prosecutor .ervice. with the State Attorney be contInued to 1/25/83.
Item '26
$2,322.96 TO POST; qUCKLEY, SCHUH' JERNIGAN, CONSULTING ENGINEERS, 'OR
ADDITIONAL SERVICES TO COUNTY REGIONAL WATER SYSTEM AS DESCRIBED IN
THEIR INVOICES NUMBER 19 AND 20 - APPROVED
:.,~
Commissioner Brown moved, .econded by Comml..loner Holland and
carried 4/0, that $2,332.96 to Po.t, Buckley, Schuh, Jernigan,
Consulting Engineers, for additional service. to the County Regional
Water System as described in their Invoice. Numbers 19 and 20, be
approved.
Item '27
$20,118.80 TO CH2M HILL FOR TREIR INVOICES 9-818, 10-823 AND 11-806 'OR
ADDITIONAL SERVICES TO THE COUNTY REGIONAL WATER SYSTEM _ A~PROVED
. " .' ~r
~",\'
,.,
",I(.
. :r,\
.'
.,1',,";'
'.,~
:1,1 ~L
J ,,,-,
t!.
,~
Commissioner Brown moved, .econded by Commi"loner Rolland and
carried 4/0, that $20,118.80 to CH2M Hill for their Involcel 9-818,
10-823 and 11-806 for additional .ervices to the County Regional Water
System, be approved.
Ite.. .28
M~ ( 073 PACt' 32S
f)ilq& 25
, ~ì}:'"
.'
.:1
. ~!~"~~;~
1.'~tJ~I,;J~..~,¡)-;, 1',\ "" ;'~,o" j
..'*~" ;
, "
tIi___,.._",._~,__
-' --'~~'·''''__'_'___'__'__'<"''._'''~''^TI,,,~, '.
,
.,
Jl1nu.'ry 1], It't..~
"
>',
'J~
j
,'f~~
·41
, ,
CHANCE ORDERS NO.2' 3, IN THE AMOUNT OF $3,935.50, TO BOYCE COMPANY, <i
CONTRACTORS FOR POTABLE WATER TRANSMISSION MAIN CONSTRUCTION FOR COUNTY
RECIONAL WATER SYSTEM - APPROVED
BO~~ 073 PACt 330
Commissioner Brown moved, seconded by Commissioner Holland, and
carried 4/0, that Change Order No. 2 1n the amount of $3,935.50, to
Boyce Company, contractorl for potable water transmislion matn
construction for the County Regional Water System be approved, making
the adjusted contract amount $1,546,279.80, and that Change Order .3
extending the contract time from 120 days from completion date of
November 10, 1982 to March 10, 19P3, be approved.
..::
,^
, '~
.'
, ,
,~
/Ir,
'J'
"'~~
, .>'j
.,,'.;-~
I::
"
,~~~
I ~1 ,
~' ,y
¡
P llC;:O
Œ.!:J
III!J
..
: ~:~;
January 11, 19P.3
Ite.. 129 ao~K Q7j PACf336
PAYMENT FOR ADDITIONAL ENGINE~RINa S~RVIC~S TO CR2M RILL FOR COUNTY
REGIONAL WATER SYSTEM FOR A TOTAL or $15,400 - APPROVED
CommIssioner Brown moved, seconded by Commissioner Rolland and
carried 4/0, that payment for additional engineering service. to CR2M
Hill for the County Regional Water Sy.tem for a total of $15,400, be
approved. (Engineering Cees Cor additional 120 day. extension to
contractor's contract - see item above).
Ite. '30
SETTLEMENT RE DIANE THOMPSON VS. BOARD or COUNTY COMMISSIONERS _
APPROVED. CHECK ENDORSEMENT AUTHORIZED
.." . '....
Commissioner Brown moved, .econded by Commi.sloner Holland and
carrIed 4/0, that .ettlement to Diane Thompson as outlined in a letter
fro. Renderson, Franklin, Starnes , Holt be approved and that
endorsement be authorized for the check in the amount of $14,237.94.
Ite. .31
RESOLUTION 83-4 ESTABLISHING PUBLIC PURPOSE AND NECESSITY OF ACQUIRINQ
CERTAIN EASEMENTS FOR CONSTRUCTION or A WATER TRANSMISSION MAIN AND
AUTHORIZING ACQUISITION OF SAID EASEMENTS BY GIrT, PURCHASE OR
CONDEMNATION - ADOPTED
Co_luloner Brown .oved, seconded by Co_h.ioner Vo.. .nd 'f,r,· ,
/~, . ~
carried 4/0, that Ruolutlor. 83-4, IIt.bl hhing public purpo.. .nd }~. ~.<t.':;
,f';" ,
nece.slty of acquIring certain .a.e..nt. tor con.tructlon of .
trans.i..ion main and authorizing acqui8ition of .aid ...e.e"t.
gift, purcha.e or condemnation, be adopted.
.,
... "
",
,'.
P.ge
c=J
~..'.
~
..
., f/
9' ....._ ]7
.. ."
, t I. 1
,~"
, . I,' ~ '. ¡ .". -e.. ".,'...\..t"..::,1,,',.,.7:",'t~,"..i.",,':.',.',,'...,'.','.:.,',',,'.' ~.'"''
. :,·:(,':,';·,V~:?,':'·X:'c.,':/,;". f' c' ~ " .. '0, v..,
M~K 073 PACt 342
January 11, 1983
Ite. . 32
ROUTINE BILLS - APPROV!D FOR PAYMENT
Pursuant to Resolution ~1-150, the following ch~cks were issued
through January 7, 19q3 in payment of routine billsz
CHEC~ DESCRIPTION
CHECK NOS.
91101i - 91368
AMOUNT
\'oucher Ch(!cks
~1,129,227.05
$ :'~",211.ï:2
Re']ul ar P"'yrol) Checks
SP3f13 - Sq90~
Itelll 133
~ ~_"",t;A
, "'~s~
"I' ...
..i" '
I. I :~.I t,~ .
"', ,t"f ~.(r:
-..-. .....,~.
.'t.,
. ~'r~,,~l·1
~P·~1;<:
. ' .. ~¥'I>;~\
i'ÞW
',! .1111,'·.
':r.:~". '
.&~\/
,'" ,'"
BUDGET AMENDMENT 83-200 TO PROVIDE rOR EQUIPMENT AND SUPPLIES AS
AUTHORIZtD BY THE BOARD (DISASTER PREPAREDNESS) - ADOPTED IN THE AMOUNT
or $l8,667
Comlllissloner Holland moved, .econded by Commi..ioner Brown and
carried 4/0, that Budget Amendment 83-200 to provide for equipment and
.upplie. a. authorized by the Board (Di.aater Preparedne..), be adopted
in the amount of $18,667.
pag.
CJ
œm
-
¡tIC:"
....._"..~-:,.....
0'. ~',' '~\i 'V,"'~"
'-",' <.~"
, ,
'.
"
J '~.~
.
~ :¡ ;''': :~~:~!
~t"",;t,\'~~
"" ,"
,
...
January 11, 19R3
'MOK 073 PACt 344-
%tea '34
BUDGET AMENDMENT 8)-201 RE TRANSFER TO PROVIDE FOR THE APPROPRIATION
AND EXPENSE or CLIENT CONTRIBUTIONS AS STIPULATED IN HOMEMAKERS GRANT
(HOM!MA~ERS) - ADOPTED IN THI AMOUNT OF $486
Co~i..loner Brown moved, .econded by Commll.loner Holland and
carried 4/0, that Budget Amendment 83-201 r. trln.fer to provide for
the appropriation and expense of client contribution. a. stipulated In
Homemeker. Grant (Homemaker.), be adopted In the amount of $486.
~; .;' i~:'·"i:~;.
,: "9.',':t
';<;¡...f::j;Y~
"C, "1':t¡ ;¡ .
. "~:;r}i
~
~.~
GIll
..:","
. ',.,..,"
\¡';)\'
- ¡1~'F'11
',I ""~~'-:"'"
f'í,'" .-... I "f-- ~ '.. t', .,;
_.'_........'_M~__~._.' ".,_, .,,'''~,''''.....
~ 073 fA~346
J.nuary 11, 19P3
, ",'/>-1':.
Ite. . 35 "'!.:.¡~>
;~, . . , ' ~ ,.., tf!,'
BUDGET AMENDMENT 83-202 RI TRANsrER TO PROVIDI rOR ENVIRONMENTAL ". '" :~),~,
REGULATION GRANT rOR COASTAL ZONE MANAOIMENT (COASTAL tONI MOMT. PROO.) ;.j, I
ADOPTED IN THI AMOUNT or S32,OOO:~i 1 '
COJllllh:.loner Vo.. moved, .econded by COltlth.ioner Brown, .nd·;~~~:l
carried 4/0, that Budget Amendment 83-202 re tran.fer to provide for
Environmental Regulation Crant for Coa.tll Zone Management (Co..tal
Zone Mgmt. prog.), be adopted in the amount of $32,000.
'. '.
,','.:::%:"
":,<";r.t}f
'.'.,.~.,.f:¡.',..,;.'.'
,;."i~.,r'i;'
',', -",.",'"
';'~Il . ,1.;;,
\ - :-; > .~ <~ ~;~r:,: ""';,
,.... , ~\~.' ~-"...:': '"'(:"
. '" l' .~\'
'-I::
, ."~:~;'<~';:
'i ·...I~
.~ 'II'~,
. . . .
1r~·~·;"J
-
U'I,·,.-I]) ~'.<, 1, '): ";,:, ,...:'1,'
",-".,'..., .
I 'e',
J. '___..;._,._
'"~'''''''''"'-'''''''''''M'' __._~,_."".,
January 11, 1993
'.I
BO~K 073 PACE348
%tell '36
GENERAL DISCUSSION RE COMPETENCY CARDS, STArr TO REVIEW SAME _ NO
ACTION TAUN
CommisslonlH I:olland IIlJid that he felt there Is " serious problem
In the way the County is handling the I.suance of competency cardl in
conjunction with occupational license., aððing th~t he was not in favor
of doing away with th@ Contractor Llcenllng Boar~, but he felt that,
without changes, the sltu~tion fs now a burden on the people tryIng to
do ~uslness In the County. Ho said th~t he would be In favor of
ðbolishlnq the co~prtency card ~lto~ethor and leaving it in the hands
of the F.ur.'¡nIn'J T10ðrrl to qualify p.of'1e. fie uld that the original
inte-nt and purpose of the ordln.'lnce was for policing of the area and,
to his knowle~rye, th^t h~s never heen done. ^lso, he has been told
that thcr@ 1s on~ rnrsö~ rh@cklnl hut he did not soe how one person
could check roll of CollI~r rounty. I!e s"ld If the competency cards are
only heln~ usc~ .'IS , ~ourcc of rev@nue and not for protection, that he
is oppose~ to It. pn $.'Ild Ie there is a possibility thlJt the list
nee-ds to he rcvlr~~d to cllmlnate so~. of the people that would be on.
thing to consl~er.
Chðlr~~n VrU5a 5nl~ that she ask~d to have this item on the 8g.nde
because, currently, If ð person wishes to go Int~ buslne.s maintaining
swimming pools, It Is nocesRðry for that person to b. licensed to build,
pools which she thInks Is going too far, adding that In the eal. of
putting ð surface on Chatahootch.e rock patios, a pftreon has to b.
licensed to instoll the Chðtahootchee rock. Commissioner Voss said
that he agreed thllt Malnt..'Iinln') IJ pool has nothing to do with a person
being able to hulle! one. /Ie uld he would not lik. to Ie. competency
cards eliminated entirely. Chairman Krus. stated, for the record,
she would not lJke to abolish competency cards.
P.g~
æ:':~\~
''J}'~, ...~',., .
..
'-:"',
.,~11~ ft,/:,..,~:
7.,'"""""..........
~,
January 11, 1geJ
nespondinq to Commissioner Holland, Community Cevelopment Admini-
strator Virta explained that there is the ability to have a State
Competency Card but that a General Contractor can take a County exam
and not take a St~te ex~m, ~nd that, at the present time, there are no
requirements for an exam for plumbing, heating or aIr conditioning
bUlin.sses. 110:: 8I'Ild, at one time, the State had requirements for those
businelses and th~t the Stat~ Is considering "getting back Into the
business·. H~ ....lñ If the Stat. does go back into the busines., he
thinks that it would be ,ood for the County to "get out of the
buslnefts·, hut until thp. f,tnte does that, an examination of the County
ordinance in In ~r1~r ~nrl th~t staff Is In the process of conducting
such ,o)n ·~)("''T'ln''tlon. II~ !laid thðt the County '10es not requlr" a
compet~ncy cor1 [or lawn malnlonance business.., adding that pool
Ilconaln1 ia one bU9ln~gs provlderl for un~er State l1censin1 and that
the County or1inance parrots the State l1c~nse. He said that a person
c~n got ,0) r.tAtØ air condlllonlnq license, hut thðt It per.on can, al.o,
get a County license ðnñ not <'I 5tðte license.
Com'T'l!!siont!r "oll~n'i slllc1 thðt h. Is not In fltvor of doing away
with rro~er eXð~lnntlon of contractors as far as anythinq that Is
necess~ry for the h~...lth and w@lfare of the p.ople, but he laid he
thinks It is tlmo [or II review of th. ordinance an~ look at the
possibility of the County hav1n1 one perlon de.lgnated to han~le
occupational llconses ðnd comp cards. He laid h. had talked w!th Tax
Collector Cðrlton who ~<'Ild he woul~ gla~ly relinquish occupational
licenses.
County ~anager Norman said thnt the contrftctor licenslnq or
competency car~ pro~rQm of the County 11 not a money maker, but father
· money loser. He sðld that the feel have twice be.n adju.ted, sine.
he has been with th~ County, to try to bring the program clo.er to
&OOK 073 PACi:US
.'
-"'-''''-''''~''>''''"",."~,_..-...~,..""...,......."
-'.",~~....,...",,,--,,-,.......,
January 11, 1983
~q91 y ~ ltfi:MItð y.
"~ laid that, tor the past three or lour year.,
there have betn two p~ople employed, a Clerk III and a supervisor, but
that two yeðrs ðgo thQ contractors asked for the County to Increase the
enforcement pnrt of the progra~ ~n1 a person W~8 employed to do enfor-
cement in addition to the person who was the head of the operation. He
explainert that as pnrt of th~ bud~et balancing problems of the past
year, ~nd becauso the costs of adminlsterln9 the program had grown so
far beyond th~ rev~nu~, rnlslnry t~e fees (urthor could not be
justlfie~. Cnc of th~ three positions was eliminaterl, he sold, so that
currently th~r" /lrf' only two (ull ti"'e positions. nesponding to
Commissioner Holland, fo'r. Vlrta sllld thllt ð"'out six weeks ago the
States ~ttorn~y'~ 0fflce lnRtructerl the County'S Investigators of the
.. 0(
Bulletlng Code In tho IS!luanco of Noticos to lppear, which are ticket.
indicðtlng a r~rfion hð~ to aprpðr at a court date. He øði~ that the
only woy the County c~n utilize that device 1s to first warn whoever 1.
engaged In IIn ðctlvlty, such as ^ non-license~ contractor engaged in
construction, and if he continues th. op.ration, then the County hal
the ability to Issue ð citation. He said that the County has the
ability to stop work and then has to catch /I person a901n.
J\sslstl!nt County l.ttorney Cuyler sairl that It is a policy deciaion
that the County w~nts to make the best cas. possible and try to
establish /I pðttern of ð c@rtðin indjYld'lal when he is brou9~': into
court. Commlsslon@r Holland sðid that Lee County standards are
different than Colllu County's, because if a person Is WOrking in Lee
County without ü license, he must stop when he il Rcaught- and he .aid
he could not understan~ the Inability to stop somebody from WOrking
without a license or a comp c~rd In Collier County. Mr. Virta .lld
that the County Cftn stop ~ person, but it II tftking the .itu~tion one
step further to have a criminal charge fil.ð. ~r. Cuyler laid that,
.....-.-'..--....
r-~'1
,', )"';". I
t;..~.._ ~ ,..'",- .,~
&!m
..
,_·~ ..~.............T
---
~'>ç'-----,-...~ "~"'<-'-'"''"'''
Janul!lry J1, 1993
usually, the person who Is stopped will go off the jOb and then has to
be traced, and he added that it Is usually a subcontractor and not tht
main contractor.
~f. Cuyler pointed out that the State hð8 doregulated the area, to
a large extent, "nd that the Stat~ still has ex!ms for IS state-wide
Certificate of Co~petancy, adding thðt a person can come Into Collier
County without ð local Certi flcate of COfTIpetency and contract a job.
He s...ld th~t If ~ person ~o@s not have a State Certificðte of
Competency th~n he has to regIst@r with th. Stl!lte and that, under thole
circum5t~nceR, r~1iRtrðtlo~ Is primarily a formality and a person Itil1
has to go to th~ 10c~J jurl9~Ictlon and ohtaln ~ CertIficate of
Competency fro~ thðt offIce.
Comml5slon~r ffoJ 1..,no1 rpcom:nen1~d th/lt a !!I~etin'1 be set up between
the staff and the Contrðctors Llc~n.ln1 Boar~ to try and Iron out lome
of the ~jffer~n~es. Ch~!rm~n ~rus~ saId that rather than loosen the
law or rQmovln~ It sh~ thoulht It would b~ wiRer to tighten down the
lllw.
~r. Nor'T1.:!n s"lrl ho! thoulht that credit shoulcl be given to the
Contractor~ Licensing nOðr~, which 1. a hard working group, who triel
hard to correct çro~Jcms when they learn of them.
r.halrm~n Yrus~ said s~o underst1nds that If a person II a Ifcenltd
Coneral Contractor ~n~ Is buildin~ a new home, h. does not have to hire
a licensed roofing contractor for that hous., ~ut if he Is goIng to
repair or re'T1odel ð hou~e, ~hlch lnclu~.s roof work, that he h., to
hire a 11~en~:~ roofer for tho r~palr job. Commissioner Holland .aid
th!t he thou1ht ~ review of th. whole ordinance I. In order. Chairman
Kruse .ai~ th~t staff Is In th~ proco.s of doin1 that and .hould 91vt
Iptclflc attention to th! three instanc" mentioned, pool maintenance,
Chat~hoochee rock and roofln~.
aoDX ú73 ~35f
.
;;....'.... . .
.'1.,.<"_,,,
"'"'.'"....""......."'."", .,~.._~...'"........""
.,."
,~'(
January 11, 1983
....~,...:'.,~..
, ·..~i"..1
':I:~~
.~¡J
.~
;tJ~
>.t,~
:..~
.~
::."
'}
'aoOK
013 PACt 352..
*****The fOllowIng item. were approved and/or adopted under
the Consent Agenda by a motion made by Commissioner Voss,
seconded by Chairman Kru.e and carried 4/0.**.*
Item . 37
R.solutlon 83-5 re Petition SNR-S2-S-C, Stanley D. Cochran,
requesting street name of Maria De La LUI Boulevard for .treet In
Section 31, one mile south of David C. Brown Highway
".ppendcd. See Pðqe 357
Item .38
Temporary Residence Permit re Petition TR-82-28C, Bernard R.
MCK.nna, during constructIon of a home on the E 150' of Tract 107, ,
Unit 97, Colden Cate Estate.
Item .39
Temporary R.sldence Permit re Petition TR-82-29C, Terrenle A.
Mills, during construction of a principal residence located 6
mile. east of SR-95l, fronting on Colden Cate Boulevard, I 150' of
Tract 56, Unit 48, Colden Gate Estates
';I:
Item .40
Reimburaable Aqreement with Florida Power and Light Company for
utility relocation on Pine Ridge Road
"ppended. See P..I(J~I HR-362
Item '41
Relocation of office trailer, for Sheriff'. Department, fro. lake
area to aite next to Courtroom -D-
It.. '42
-Minor- modification to CETA Title. 11-8, VII and adminl.tratlve
contract.
.',
"ppended. See P.:'Igu 363-369
.,
Pftge
~
~. ~'';'''I.:.....:J
IIiJ
-
_l
,II. ~.
Ite. 143
Item '44
Item 145
~~
'
J::
'1:1
~r
~.
~;'
~~
\~
.)f,
it.,
Item '46
'\,1,
"
t
Item 147
,'.
~,
:'~.."
Ite.. 148
Item '49
"\,, .'.;" ~~,'
,. .....Wn»~...~ ..,..,
~"""""-"""--
January 11, 1983
Social Service. C..e. W-9382, W-8813, W-8796
Bill ot Sale transterring ownerlhip of 8ailey Lane water.aln
extension to the City of Naple.
Appen1l!d. Soe Page 370··']73
Lea~e Agreement on temporary ICCI.. to excavate Airport Road
Canal, Chairman authorized to execute same in dup1icatl
Appended. See r.3qes 374-376
Aquatic Plant Control Agreement for allocation of Itlte .Itchlng
funds
\ ,
Ap,pondchJ.· $o@ Pages 377-193
NU~ßER
Chairman authorized to .ign Certiticate. for Correction to the ~ax
Rolls as presented by the Property Apprai.er'. office
19P?
TANGIBLE Pr.~AL PROPF.RTY
DATE
-
19P'·213 - 229
12/2P./A2 - 1/7/~3
~
,,~('..
1::!/1'i/R2
.!.2!U.
~C)r,
12/1S/"2
.illl
3"5 - 373
J'?c:., 177 - 30';
12/1S/~2
12/15/R2 - 12/22/82
Lako Trafford Cemetery Deed No. 327
Appendor1. See rðge 394
1001( 071 PAdS
,'þ .1
January II, 19P3
~O~K 01J PACt 3!.
MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE - FILED AND/OR REFERRED
There being no objection, the Chair dIrected that the following
correspondence be filed anð/or ret.rred to the various d.prtmentl II
.' ;~!.'·1'·
:-~~~I'~
, ~,,':ttI'
.",:J Z,ifj
,,;:(~:
'.,) ·;,t~\;
"'.:."(~~'~':'.'..'.'.
'(C" ":;~~:
l ~lf:~,
:.... ~~'\¡'
¡-.It, .,
. "'," ,~,.;\ ....,:
.\~"J,
it!;il' ,
·~H~¡~,.., . .
'¡;.t;....!
,':,'~~:r/
indicated below:
1. Dcpz:rtmentlll ne¡::orts. Filed.
,.. Pl"n Implcmentðtion I'epðrtm@nt, Novemher, 19"2
r. Collier County ~ufleum, I"ecember 31, 190'
'. ,
"~
2. Colllrr County Public F~hools Annuðl Report of the
~upcrlntrn~ent, IOQI-P2. Filed.
3. Lettt'r ~"tcrJ f'~ccnh~r l~, 19P2 from Fitcph.n 0. foIoon, C.P.A.,
Comptrol1cr, Florl~~ COT, transmitting the report advising of
the [!n,llndlll po!;!tlon of Collier County'. Po\ portion of
;'econr ðry ';ru~t fund (!iccond CIIS TlIx - ~th I'Ind "'th cent) at
NovcmtHH )(', Inp/. xc ~1r. Norml'ln, "'r. Hartmlln and Mr. GUes.
FIlc'!.
". LI~ttcr -j,'tc" rnccm'1"r 1(, I~P' from Stophen 1:1. />1oon, C.r.A.,
Conptroller, florlda f'0T, transMitting the report advising of
the [lnlln=lðl position of Collier County's Trust and ^gency
Funds (Pond run"!S) "t ~ove"l:>er 30, IC?P.?. xc "'r. Norman, Mr.
H!Htmlln Dnr' "'r. r.!les. Filed.
5. Co¡:,y of I! letter d...ted .1Dnullry ~, 1ge3 from Bruce Chapman,
u.s. rcpt. of ro~nerce, furf'au of the Consus. Copy of
County's tr~n$~lttðl of tho Eoun1~ry and ^nnexðtlon Survey.
~c ~r. Norn...n ~n~ ~r. VIrtð. Filed.
(i.
~Iemorðndum d"ted necember 17, 19R:' from V. Carl fluff, Jr.,
Stð{( rlrector CoordinAting Council on the TranRportation
DIsðdvðntðged, re a notice nnd agenrla of monthly meeting for.
.1ðnu...ry 1:', 19f13 ",nd trnnsmlt.tlng a copy of the [\@cember A,
1~P2 minutes. xc ~r. ~orman, ~r. Kloehn and ~r. Perry.
n led .
. '
,,.- ,
7.
ropy of... l!'tter from E. cn.nn Tucker, nttorner' dated
December 14, It'1P/, to ~r. Wayne Scamehorn, Bui o:Hn9 Director,
contlllnlng slgn~tures of Potltloners agreeing to stipulation.
as set by the Boðrd of County Commissioners on December 14,
19P? (R~ Petition ^-f.l2-S) Filed.
R.
Letter dated December 17, 19R2 trom Fredorlck H. Fllher,
District Fiscal Officer, Dept. ot Health, Rehabilitative
Services, District F.lght, transmitting a revised financial
report of the Collier County Health Department received fro.
tho Departm.nt of Health and Rehabl1itative Servicel. xc Mr.
Norman. filed.
9.
Copy of letter dated December " 199' from Wallace E. err,
Secrct"ry, ~tðto t'opartment of t.abor and F.mployment Security,
f£;~,.J
~
-
.,:"y.~" '
-
, " ~ I: "', ""r'
. ~ ,, ¡"
January 11, 1983
( ~'"
'.
'~~~'
'.~~.' 'I
.\ '
.~
: ~
I
...:.~.
..~
'-I
~;~
notifying of changes in CETA and elIgibility criteria. xc
Mr. Norman and Mr. Norton. Filed.
10.
Copy of Memorandum No. 82-82 dated December 13, 1982 from Tom
F. Wooten, Chle!, Bureau of Enrollment and Contribution.,
Dept. of Administration, Divilion of Retlrtmont, r, chang,.
in Social Security Contributions for 1993. xc Payroll
Department. Filed.
11. Copy of l"tter rlated December '-0, )CIS, from Robert J.
Krzemin3kl, Administrator, MPO Liaison, to Mr. Jeffory Perry
givln~ estimate of funds avnilable for FY 83-84 Unl!ied
Planning Work Program. Filed.
12. Copy oC Mamorðndum dated December Hi, 19q2 from Howard C.
Forman, Chairman, Broward County Metropolitan Planning
Organization, transmitting a copy of the Unfunded Short-Rang,
Transportation Needs for Broward County, Broward MPO and
Rosolution No. 82-7. xc Mr. Norman and Mr. Virta. Filed.
13. Memo received Dece~ber 28, 19R' from James R. Vereen, Chief,
to all Fire F.C' ulpment Dealers re DOT Bulletin DOT-EA8e.;,
Rcgul.alon 49CRF' 173.34(e) (<). xc Mr. Norman. Fl1td.
It.. Copy of December 15, 1~82 letter from Mr. Chris Anderson,
· Collier County Forester, to Mr. Virta reporting on activities
during ~ovember, 1ge2. Fl1erl.
15. Lettor dated Dec~mber 20, 19P,2 from Mr. Al Bl3hop, Chief,
ßurc...u of Water ~anagement, DER, regarding Fiscal Year 1985
ruhl1c Works Program and Annual Water Resources Development
Conference and transmitting Public Works Program Flow Chart,
^ppllcatlon and Puhl1c Works Rule. xc Mr. Norman and Mr.
Hartman. Filed.
16. Copy of ONR Permit Number CO-56, Permittee, Charter Club of
Marco Beach, Assoc. - copy of Final Orrler received for
construction of walkway structure .eaward of Coastal
Con5trucl10n Control tine. xc Mr. Vlrta and Dr. Benedict.
Filed.
17. Cop~' of memorandum dateð Dectr.'lber 20, 19Q, from Edwin J.
Conklin, Environmental Administrator, Bureau of Land
^cqulsiton, DNR, re notlco of C.^.R.t. Selection Committee
Metltlngs on January 12 and 13, 1ge3. JCC Mr. Norman and Mr.
Vlrta. filed.
IR.
Copy of "Iemorandum c1ated December 27, lqA2 from Elton J.
Gissendanner, Executive Director, DNR, re Aquatic Preserve..
xc ~r. Norman, ~r. Vlrta and Dr. Benedict. File1.
, ' " j '~',
'~"
, '.,1)0.11
~~:>~
, ;1~
' '~~',;f.
r;......\1~
, :~':;:~~~
t:~~,M'¡,
~·r~
",:\'
19.
Copy of Memorftndu~ dated Decomber 1~, 1982 from Con I.
Dunden, Assistant Executive ~ir.~tor, DNR, transmitting a
copy of the Final Peport of the dIue Ribbon Marina Committee.
KC ~r. Norman and Mr. Vlrta. Filed.
II
20. The following minutes were receIved and filed,
BOOK em PACt_
Page 38
~.-r ~, I"", ".4. 1, _I.
J.nuary 11, 1983
&O~K
013 PACt 356
A. CAPC December 2, 1982 and Aqenda for January ~, 1983.
B. EMSAC, December 14, 19B2.
C. Naples City Council, Oecember 15, 1992.
" t;;
,1j¡'S
, .J
':~f
,':,. ¡
., ~).
, ;
II
.
.
There being no furthor businesl to come before the Poard of County
Commissioners, the meeting was ~djourned at 2%10 P.M. by order of the
Chair.
BOAnD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS/
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS/EX
OFFICIO GOVERNING BOARD(S) or
SPECIAL DISTRICTS UNDER ITS
CONTROL
~~~L'~A"
ed by the BCC on ~~~71.(; /'/'J ..
corrected J'.
.,..
\}-i~
;J;", '
'1·,j ,:'
,,"";." :
, .' ¡, ....;, ,
,/ ...:, .,'
, '
.' '.
...
.. " .
. ~ ..' ...' -
----.
1.......__..1
,
£m'.m ..'
,.: , ~ .'. --:'" ~~.
~, "'.....,. ~, ~~;~·(1.;x~~1P~J.JIj~..~~:'\~t'l~-!.à;;~':"'ir",../.~,...~,~tl~~tf, ~.~~ .