Agenda 12/11/2012 Item #11I12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to consider the current status of the County's initiative seeking direct
vehicular permanent access from Golden Gate Estates to I -75 and staffs request for
direction regarding future initiatives.
OBJECTIVE: To provide the Board of County Commissioners (Board) with an update of staff s
efforts seeking direct access to I -75 from Golden Gate Estates, status of the I -75 Interchange
Justification Report (IJR) and to seek guidance on the future direction regarding this initiative.
CONSIDERATIONS: In February 2001 the Board directed a restudy of the Growth
Management Plan (GMP) including the Golden Gate Area Master Plan ( GGAMP) to place a
strong emphasis on mobility improvements for the residents of Golden Gate Estates. On October
26, 2004, the GGAMP section of the GMP was updated through Ordinance 04 -71 with the
inclusion of Policy 6.1.2 which states:
"Collier County shall coordinate with the Florida Department of Transportation to initiate a
study of a potential interchange in the vicinity of I -75 and Everglades Boulevard. "
In July of 2005 the Collier County Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) voted to include
the interchange in the 2030 Financially Feasible Long Range Transportation Plan (LRTP), and in
October of that same year the Board budgeted $750,000 for the IJR. Following these actions, staff
began coordinating with FDOT, procured a consultant and on May 7, 2008 the first Methodology
Letter of Understanding (MLOU) was signed by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA).
The Board has maintained this project as one of its highest legislative priorities and on January
12, 2009 this project received $245,000 in federal funding.
Early in 2009 the project was entered into the Efficient Transportation Decision Making (ETDM)
programming screen and due to environmental impact concerns raised by several agencies, an IJR
dispute resolution meeting was scheduled and held on August 5, 2009. During discussions held at
this meeting, FDOT and FHWA directed that the 2019 opening year for traffic modeling purposes
was no longer appropriate. A new opening design year was stipulated, which required an
amended MLOU and additional funding in the amount of $125,000 to update the traffic model.
This funding request was approved by the Board on May 10, 2011.
The IJR dispute resolution discussion also led to an agreement to initiate one of the largest
environmental Cumulative Effects Evaluations (CEE) in the state of Florida. FDOT funded and
initiated the CEE in the summer of 2010 and this year released a draft report which stated that
there was no significant difference to environmental impacts within the study area when
comparing the impacts with and without an interchange.
In April of 2012 the preliminary IJR was submitted by the consultant to the county for review.
After review, updates and modifications, it was subsequently submitted to FDOT for review and
comment. On June 21, 2012 staff met with FDOT to discuss the draft IJR and it was agreed that a
presentation by County staff and consultants to the FHWA, FDOT and the Interchange Review
Staff (IRS) would be appropriate. The IJR application has been submitted and a meeting was held
in Bartow Florida with the IRS on October 29, 2012. As of the writing of this executive summary,
staff has not received comments on the UR. The summary above and attached power point
presentation provides a detailed review of the history and concerns regarding this project.
FISCAL IMPACT: The UR has committed funding totaling $799,104.50 with $78,920.04
remaining in the budget as of November 16, 2012. The current environmental support contract
Packet Page -1860-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
with Stantec is funded at $60,000.00 and has a current balance of $47,40040 as of November 16,
2012. The balances do not reflect work in. progress or needed to either oornplete the project or
close it out. The construction of the interchange is currently projected to; be fully funded in the
current 2035 LRTP through 2025. If the interchange application is postponed, funding currently
projected for the interchange could be reprioritized for other County .transportation projects.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: The completion of the IM the future Project
Development and Environmental (PD &E) study, design, right- ofaway acquisition and
construction of the interchange would be in accordance with the GGAMP and the current 2035
LRTP. Postponing the IJR and the construction of the interchange would not be in conflict with
the GGAMP, however the 2035 LRTP would need to be amended.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This is a policy issue for the Board, raises no legal issues, and
requires majority vote for direction. - JAK.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board considers all factors regarding the progress of seeking
direct vehicular permanent access from Golden Gate Estates to I -75 and provides direction to staff
with respect to future efforts on this initiative.
Prepared by: Nick Casalanguida, Administrator, Growth Management Division
Attachments: I- 75/Everglades PPT
W
Packet Page -1861-
12/11 /2012 Item 11.1.
r .
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 11.1
Item Summary: Recommendation to consider the current status of the County's initiative
seeking direct vehicular permanent access from Golden Gate Estates to 1 -75 and staff's request
for direction regarding future initiatives. (Nick Casalanguida, Growth Management Division
Administrator)
Meeting Date: 12/11/2012
Prepared By
Approved By
Name: LynchDiane
Title: Administrative Assistant
Date: 11/19/2012 3:08:45 PM
Name: LynchDiane
Title: Administrative Assistant
Date: 11/19/2012 3:20:10 PM
Name: LynchDiane
Title: Administrative Assistant
Date: 11/26/2012 11:07:32 AM
Name: KlatzkowJeff
Title: County Attorney
Date: 11/26/2012 4:08:53 PM
Name: Finn-Ed
Title: Senior Budget Analyst, OMB
Date: 11/27/2012 6:11:13 PM
Name: OchsLeo
Title: County Manager
Date: 12/1/2012 1:49:33 PM
Packet Page -1862-
N
°o
J
N
O
= O
N
T
v
5 ON
� � O
7 W
3
S
� N
T O
-IP
N
O
O
N
O
O
Ol
N
O
O
V
N
O
O
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1863-
3 o n
� Qn
O (D
_Q
��r
�
n
N
rD
v� D
O
rD
O M
Lo
v+
(D
>y
rD O
rD
rt
o'
ono
-1 n
(�D
O
Q
O_v
(D
O
'
(D
�
� Q
r e
O
0
rt n (D
rD
3
gu
fD
Q
rD
0
N
�� a
°�
�n
�o
N
I
(D
_
S
r
N :3
'
LO
_ n
mom.
C)
0
0 C
O
�.
(D
>v
3 LO
O -+
�.
N
<
(D
W
Orlt
(D
`G
O
O_
-n
r'*
O
:
�
n
n
u
—_
—
C:
CL
(D
r-r
(D
Packet Page -1863-
N
0
N
O
O
-n LA -n
DrD�
r
�O
C
�u
m -0
--1
Z
CL
fD
fD
n.
o
�
-0
0
ID
000M.�o
<
z
-''
Q
n
0
Co
-►,
M
cn
V)
Ln
M
'<
Lo
n
r
_
_
ML
�u
m -0
--1
fD
fD
C<D
o.
<
O
Q
Eu
.
rD
Ln
7
'<
v
n
O
Q'
(D
N
V)
<
Packet Page -1864-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
;E
�r
E
W
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1865-
r�
+�r
is
s,
'r
f
r�:
N
N
C
C
N
O
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
"I C)- rD r-t Pi T
rD pi .Q f-+ <�
CC N �
C rD �' —t =�'+ rD G
N O n• �'
rD r-t rD
0
rD rD
� O n•
rD Q
O
� = C: O rD
< rD Q O 8 � r-r O.
rrDD • • �' O
rD 3 3 '+
CL M O rD rD
0 S rD rD
C rD �• cam, c� 7v
f
Packet Page -1866-
sF
t
o
�Lo
O
rD
O•
7
Lo
mrD
(D
1
'7
Ln
r-t
(DcO
I
i
n
rD
�
j
O
•n
r)
I
OMM
rO
n•
�
O
N•
3
rD
rD
rD
o
cQ
o'
"I C)- rD r-t Pi T
rD pi .Q f-+ <�
CC N �
C rD �' —t =�'+ rD G
N O n• �'
rD r-t rD
0
rD rD
� O n•
rD Q
O
� = C: O rD
< rD Q O 8 � r-r O.
rrDD • • �' O
rD 3 3 '+
CL M O rD rD
0 S rD rD
C rD �• cam, c� 7v
f
Packet Page -1866-
sF
t
N
O
O
N
O_
n�E;
-o0D
rD
rD
rn
rn
3
o
n
=
iv
C:
CL
rrD
O
Q
�u
r-t,
O
C
•
rD
rD
r-r
.�
V)
rD
rD
m
m
(
oo
p
n
-�
Qo m
n
�70
0
Z
V)
rri
O
rD
r+
Q
<
�-r
D
O
'<
�
pu
-1
O
u
Q
3rn
-o0D
rD
rD
(D
•
rD
0
;0
rD
O
CD
I
O
rD
0
0
Packet Page -1867-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
tom►.
t
Packet Page -1868-
LA
rnrn
—h
rD p
LA
rnr)
< 0
w -�
E E
o
N
n
rnCL
`.. r.t.
V, o
CL (D
LA
n
ro
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
..
ot, 0�
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1869-
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
'� r r
Packet Page -1870-
ED
'� r r
Packet Page -1870-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1871-
j
r+
0
-C
ro
-, L .
'D
I
Q
0
r)
0
ID
rD C- Or
M
CD
ID
IOD
-
- = =
w w
0
M
X
CD Lu
-V
0
r,
r+
M
rD
(D
rD
4�
C-1
lu
o
0
a c
—h
M
Cu
(D =
W
(D
—j
(D
(D 0
(D
M
0 ,
V f.
=
eb
V)
(D
V
X
X
CD
w
nD
to
rb
.0 eb
<
=*
(i)
R.
(D
Qj
(D
aj
CL
0
M
0
2j
;
r 0
r—
0
4
FD-
0
x r-)
M
ti )
r+
CD 0
eb
Ln
Ln
r)
(D
Qj
Ln
r
<
CD
(D
(D
TS
r)
(D
t)
CL
eb
CD
w
(D
L)
(D
Cu
Co
ID
if.
CL
Z
M.
0
SLJ
rD
C)
CD
(D
rn
q <
V) 0
C)
(D
(D
6;
(D <
0
Lo
,a
(D
(D
E7
=
C)
(D
rD
tit
C
CIS
*<
V)
M
0
CAD
r.L
M
E7
0)
0
0
0
LA
OU
M
(A
M
eb
—
=
Cu
M
(D
M
0
Cu a
CO
—,,
DO
0
<
w
CL
CM
0
0
(D
Cu
a:
00
LIN
(D
NJ
n
<
=r
V�
L-W
tn
CD
th
CD <
M
0 cu
w
eb
1+
M
w Cu
w
=
(D
3-
rD OQ
— —
LC
.
(D
0
eb
= =
r— oL
Cu
M
V)
w
su <
0
CD
r+
511 r
0
—Z
CU
(D
aj
%
M
0
C)
CU
r)
eb
(D
(D
CL)
r"+
o
=;
M
=-
rD
0
,
.4, —a is —h
u)
rah
W) 0
Packet Page -1872-
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
ti
Mll I
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1873-
9
f;
P
M
IM
1
r�
M
0
■
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1874-
r
r
G
r� r
w ■
lu
s,
t�
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1875-
i
`i.
'i.
1
wwij� a
I
r ■
Pi j
(+
1 ■
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1876-
1
0
I
■
04
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1877-
km
I
r.
i
i d
0►
O
w
Ln
O
3
Q
o'
Ln
O
0
rD
:'
C
I"h
Ln
r'h
Q
I
O
r-r
+
vi O
w v,
C,
s
N
�. 0 rrm
'EWV
O '*
(D
2
5 £I
v
N (.0 W
0 ? lQ
rte* `r
O rp
U-) (A
�oLn
O
0
0
O
Lo
C)
rD
I
Packet Page -1878-
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
k
tJ ,�
S
Q. `Q
0
1
I
(D
Lq
`)
1
O
r-+
rD
G
rM+
n
0
—F,
(D
PD
r*.
tQ
r-r
Co
r'If'
_ fir/
N
O
J
J
N
O
J
N
N
O
J
W
N
C
J
-P
N
O
J
u�
N
C
J
Ol
N
O
V
N
O
J
00
N
O
J
N
O
N
O
N
C
N
J
CD
CLI t/1
X�.
0I�
�rt
Ln
o
Ln
rt
n
rh
iiia:;*-
Packet Page -1879-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
I !
!
•
a
i�
G y
1
r
Ak
■.
Mir
•
a:
t;
•
!
i,
r;
•
EN%
/I--
Ln
rD
O
Ln
0
CD
r•-r
0
rD'
In
Ln
rlt.
_3
N�
rD
rrDD
LA
0
Ln
n
I
rD
0
0
rD
In
3
(D
Un
rD
Q
3
0
rD
Ln
LA
r+
rD
3
CL
rD
O
r1
OUJ -• ��
pu. V)
0 n (D rD
rD
LO
LA ,� n � 0
w O N
rD rD M M 3 Fu
rD rD rD rD 0
O
Ln rD Ul tri 0 O
LA
n' p, 0 rD 0
C rD= o- Q 0
cn rD Q
'a3 C) =O
0 � �
= O.
rD �
rD n rl
rD • rD O � —'=
'D LA 3 �D
Lo -0 _. W W =
rD = --h 0 3
1 0 n' � 9.
rt 0 —'c0
rD L4 rD
CO C 0
<
0-
:3
CD
N
C
rD
O
Ln
C
rD
o-
�00���
C
C:
s�
..p
OWN
C
rD
=
C)
�u
un
o'
Packet Page -1880-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Ln
3
(A
0
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1881-
T
rrt
rrt
r*
n
D
_.
Nam
<�
�
w
r°N�
p
rD
O
un
.,•�
Ln
W
-
*
r-t
CD,
-
n
(D
rD
2
S3
(D
CL
N
V
O
r
D
O
Q
D
r
o
(D
7C3
rD
e
N
�
rD
(D
Un
r-
—'
cn
_
(D
��.
._.
C.
-
�
n
¢,
-
�
-t
n
rD
r*
�
=
3
-r
<_,
-%
n
0
�
_
rD
w
-�,
W
Lo
(D
—
r+
rD
LA
=3
Lo
_.
_
S
—'
r +
rD
r*
�
O
vi
v'.
Lo
:3
V)
'<
w
_
:3
Lo
cQ
--%
�
c
r•*
�'
N
(D
_
rD
(D
C:
-1
(D
(D
O
Q
r*
LD
Ln
Ln
Un
r+
Q
rD
X.
(D
r�-r
p
(D
r-r
`<
w
rn
N
-0
{•�
�
D
f-
_
'<
(D
r�
rD
n
X
O
�
n
ry
t�
<
rD
v'
(D
<
rD
`_".
Q
r-
n
0'
n
inn
rD
3
<
—•
•
�'
N
O
rD
Lo
n
rD
to.
C4
o
p
n
t0'
n
r-t
p
r-r
.....
o�_3
n3
��'o"�o
C -W
rD
rD
�
p
—v
(D'
to
CL
—
r-t
ED
Lo
r-r
�<
v'
,-r
—
'<
O
I
O�
=
-+
rD
sla
O
rD
n
p
rt
n
O
to
=-
M
rD
3
(�D
p
<.
'�
S
(D
=
r-r
CAD
rD
w
Lo
O
rD
Pi
—
(
rD
x
e-+
'<
rD
�
CL
(D
t�
tD
w
Ln
0-
rD
lO
n
=
O
fD
Cl
CL
O
W
rD
rD
r,•
rD
r�
<
rD
n
n
rD
n
O
_.
-•
O
LO
to
Ln
(D
t'D
C7
0
-
rD
N
�
o-
rD
n
Q
rrt
¢1
C
N
72.
Lo
rD
N
N
(D
_
I
C
<
r-t
�.
o
PU
n
c.r i
rD
co
-7
co
=
rD
rD
_"hh
Cr
'1
r
o
Cr
CL
*<
Ln
Packet Page -1881-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
�o rD <rD ����0�rD m3 rD
CQ : rD < N Q r�'-r rD W D <
_ -% rD p
D gu A} Ai o PU : < — F
un -0 to
n r* W rD �_ `< gu rD rD O
n 0C
'rt r+ -1 = M 3 r* D n rD SL
0 Lo rD .< r•* I
M
rD Q r-r r-r '� O O M rD V) '� Q cn
S – r-+
O r1 rD rD
SM ��n� rD (D rD 3
A� rD rt — Q •� rD X cn
N Q � r-h � to � rD 0 un
CD Q O O cn rD O � < Sv
rD (n -< --h -� * <' CQ 0
n • O • Q' O `,I rD cn — • CQ
rD W to Q, Ln
rD rD
CD r'+ r n < -� rD rD
un rD CL s =nom
rD �� fD� *•�o_� rD I
sv
� � ° � < rD rD Ln
—�h rD � �• (z Q tin
3 r+ r* ov w Q rD
S O O �
n _.
— rD —
r� rD .n C rD (D Q, <
S
-*,On <w= rD
CD O0 3 rD v-+) CrD �
� = Cr —S -+ r+ � � C -0
r+ r+r rD rD S = * —%
pu rt' cn rD rD rD r* O
:3 rD W A�
:3 U < r--r rD
O N rD pi
Packet Page -1882-
s.
s
•
6
s
i
r
•
r
•
0� -7 �_ o -� � �� � (D r m0- rD rt �
X (D ' crn N , X rrt O O
a � np nX X � , (D 0 r •
�-o n � O 0 OrD 33
CD -ti, -+ M.
-.
O n r r LO r.* O p� p� A� rD
to -• — p.i Ln r-t f-+ rD
ID Q
O p pi rD n(D O n G G
"% r--r -% w O Q n rD - • p�
O p (DD � .Q n r-r -% rrDD NCO
< f-+
(0D -7 r-r -. O. rD •-•t - (D
Q CO M � 0 W r�-r rD � • r�-r
rD rD rD _ rD Q0 rD -. O p� rD N rD I" r1
r-� �O. rt, —n S< :3 <
(D :3 (D rD O n O r-r rD
-s rD O -�
— M rD p p= O CO n :3 rD S
O(D n -S n .+ P O O rD rD O_
Q�� un O r�D n - V) N rD
rD O C Q
Cr
n (D -. rD --+) p
(D o r M cn O N O S (D
n��� ��• rD� ���' QC CD SA'
O n r* -S O_ Q < r-r N < n
rD
e-+ -r, p.� -t p O O O
rD N LO n (D (D W U- 3 -o N O
- h -r O (D V) ) r-r f -t
3 O P :3 00 =- O -1
Sy O rD A
� Q
:3 } rD r�-r rte*
to O O rD rD rD
Sv -t -' s cn <
X M �' O �. N lO (Q
:3 . O rD 43 P G Lo �' CL A�
O W m n p N O_p cn m CL
C) (D S .0 p rt p LO cn
r-r Lo Q0 7 rD
r--r O -•t
(D V rD v
(D Op �n
u O
Packet Page -1883-
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
•
•
r
+s
t
r •
•
•
r
r •
•
r
•
Packet Page -1884-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
•
a
s;
s
•
F!12
r-r
W
O Z
—-
n v�
� O
O
0:3
(D
O
�
O
C_
DrD
� rnD �'
rD • <
LA
rD
-t,
rD
p
n
U- 0
O C-
�- X
Q- rD
fl)
:3 =3
rD
PU
lQ
'� Q <
� -0
Sy
p
=
O
<
0
O
LA rD
n
O
D
Q �
O
O
rD
CL
n O
rD
O
rD
r-t
�
O
n
LA
� N
��
<
O'
�
n
S
0'
CD
O
vi
Q- Q
((
rD
-%
A•'
(D
rD rD
Q
W W
�
a,
r+
(D
•
a-
rD
�
rD a'
�
O _
CD
LA r-+
rD
Z3
� rD
rD
< ¢r U
.� r�
r
O
rD
o o.
Ln
O
O
LA
(DD
r�D
rD
K
p D
r-r
rD
rD
(D
(D
((D
w
<
N
LA
rD
W
rD o
rD LO
sL
rD
0
rD
O
3
Packet Page -1884-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
•
a
s;
s
•
F!12
r-r
W
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
Packet Page -1885-
n
-n
0
O
rD Z3
CD
S
rD
<
rD
°
_�
m
00
.
O
<
N'
-0
n
n
�
n
0O .
cn
0
O
�-
O
w
O
p
r-r
rD
O
p
•C
O
S
t01
-%
LA
ID
<
rD
T
Ln
O�'
r)
o(oCL
CD3
rD
0
zr
p
�
_ .�
ri
CD
—.�
�
Uq
..
—
r-t
rD
r-*
C)7
rD
r--h
3.
n
:3
3
N
:7
�
r
S
CL
rD
G
D
On
vi
Ln
O
--�
nQ-3��
���
rD
co''''
CD
O
r-r
p
-a
_.
n
�v
cn
_.
— •
®
-z
33
`Dpi
��'
w—
Ln
:
rD
W
rya
N
�,
rD
n
C
Q
3�
z
��
LA
—.
O
LO
W
r•-r
Q
C'
o
n
rD
O
0
T
Lo
3
rD
t11
A�
rrt
rD
rD
N'
L
r
�
:3
rD
Q
o
O
n
0
rD
n
<
rD
-'
�^
O
o
rD
n
=
S
(D
Q
%
p
rD'
r•*
=
rD
:3
:-*
O
N
rD
rD
Lo
rD
rD
IV
rD
rN-r
rat
Packet Page -1885-
Packet Page -1886-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
• • rD
•+
•
rD LA
•
rD
9u rD
0 rD
•
r
rD
s
rD
rD rD
rD
rD M
wl
s Ln
•
*
Vi
O
D
u *
:1
rD
N
rD
!.
O
lQ
rD
rD
M
rDD
rDDD
=
O0
rD
<
W
rD
Lo
Q
L
Z3
rD
O
QrD
�r
rD
s
�=r'
-
O
Q
O
rD
n
cQ
=r
rD
r-+
O
(D
;a
`^N
O�
�W
�
`�
L7-
O
—
rD
f-+
rD
Ohs
O
`�'
��
r,+
m
cn
n
OLo
n
��Q
CD
rD
L
--a
n
rD
�
O
O
rt
rD
rD
n
O
cn
C=
O
Co
�.
r�D
rD
n
O
n
r t
M
rD
`G
rD
o
N Ln
rD
M.
rD
_ Lo
lQ
Q
O
SL
rD
`-'
=
Ln
I
rD
�
Q
Q
Packet Page -1886-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
• • rD
•+
•
rD LA
•
rD
9u rD
0 rD
•
r
rD
s
rD
rD rD
rD
rD M
wl
s Ln
•
0
PJ 0 O �
14 O
O n rD -0
Ln r Q
rt
O rr
O —' O
� n �
7'
V � �
to cn �-
0- rD rD
rDD3
n Lo -0
O
N �
rD 3
r* rD rD
N
_ . Ln r--r
In
O �.
D r-*
S CAD
rD Ln
gu rD
(D
o
cn rrt 0
NrD�
rt
cn n O
0
0 r-r
lQ C CD
rD
n
r-r N . O
rD
cn • �<
Lo cn
F
Packet Page -1887-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
s
• 0
o
► 00
CL pu ►
.
LA 0-0
a �
! ,
► :
rD M
• rD
• rD
!t
• .
s
• i
rD Ln rD
gu
rD
un rD rD
rD •
s s
rD
• .
rD .
rD CL
QO rD
�_
rD
r-r
rD
<
Au
rD
O
3
=-
r-
D
(D
r-+
0
O.
n
o
rD
O
rrDD
rD
rD
r-+
�<'
—
r--h
(/1
rD
rD
rrt
_
LA
O
rD
C:
Q
Q.
0
O
_.
0
rD
rt
ul'
rD
-+,
(D.
rD
Q
-'S
Ln
V1
o
`
rD
O
*
rD
rD
_.
O
lQ
M
-'
r+
O
rD
=
(n
0
rD
O
n
—
-1
n
�
r-t
rN-r
N
rD
Z3
�
�
r--r
�.
,.a-
rD
Lo
-•tiy
�
--h
rD
rD
0
r+
��
=
7
r-r
(rD
D
O
cn
O
O
O
L
-0
�
D
�-
0
0
-°�
rD
r�•
—
�
°o
cQ
o�•=
-h
.<
r+
r*
-�
D
O
rD
:3
-�
'
O
s
x .
<
ire
:3
o
_
M
rD
lQ
<
`<
`<0.
rD
3O
•
CD
-0
-0
W
O
N
0-
r-
3
O
(D
O
n
:3
n
r*
n
X
Packet Page -1887-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
s
• 0
o
► 00
CL pu ►
.
LA 0-0
a �
! ,
► :
rD M
• rD
• rD
!t
• .
s
• i
rD Ln rD
gu
rD
un rD rD
rD •
s s
rD
• .
rD .
rD CL
N
FD
N
la
rr w * -a =h
Ln
rr o — 20o
n Qm�
gu rD N
CL 0- 0
rD � N
N �
rD -o <
� rD 9u
•, (D Q
rD �
�_ <�
S -< OrD
CQ�S�
Sv O Q cQ
CL M
(D
(D -eDQ
—
0(Dr_ -r.�
O'er¢' _
CD rD
<�"D
O S �-
3 = —•rD
3 LA
rD -00
-+2�
=w m-1
CL
n rD
rr Q
N
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
gu Q
N - _ N
;< r• f rD C: Cl rD n ;; rD O w 00
rD m ONO` -
u, rr M m = -r, =5 rr N
> 0 rD
��� QE%< ����,�Q ®
(D CL S cn
—� (D I
Z-3 PJ rD rD —� N N
rD S O ;7 C: 0 rD A� p = = 0 ('® rD 00
� gu Q M -t a- 0 5 a.
=--M C Q N N C_ —• � N rt O
n r-+r
—' � ' (D N w rn-r r-t
n =h (D m CL N rD N 3 CD
EL Z3 L (D rD (D � N � � :3 n
Un rD n S Ai rr rD Orr O In CD P rD � V) CL = =3 -1 t!1
N • < te ��
rD < rD
�pN (D '+ •
0— O O rD
. —r�-h
rr M
�D o-0 = w o F.
tQ O
rD "3-0 ��� D o� O (D
� Q < � r=-r Ln m rD tin r-•r S� CD
O mD o rD
_ n ��
rD rD w O si ,rt rr Z3 n
� • O � � � � r)u r� O rD rD
n 0 n C) rD -. S m 7 cn
LA O cn
� = rD (D � —I O ,-r
.M te n- N � (D CA to n
Q rr r-r (D --,in A� O
A�
CL �-6 ((DD Q- Q W. M u -p 3 M
rr ( e-+ < o CL r-t
—. (D 3 n Q r rN D N D Tv =' =-
9u (D
rr r"f,
rD A j (D A� rD V1
�
IT O (D (D r-r 0 p
M r-r r-r N <
�
un ¢? N
Packet Page -1888-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
n w -n
CL 0
O � p
X r+ 0 p� o O ,rt S cn
rD —r, Zs rD O Q- rD rD F-t —i
` • �i V
rD O Z3 O0 rD rD :3 (D O
Nog x c•, rD v rrDD 9u f-t n
rD Ln .-1
rD Z3 ,.� S ¢� r-r e--r
lQ � 0' O O rD D rD (D I
M ,..t to gu
N M W . r'1 3 fl r:y r+ <
Q rD rD
rD 1:�. r* g rD E n rD
.per CL :370 S::Z p.� r_r� (D ¢�
rD �=*, rD 2u rD : to �-�.
-0 � O Zi X. D n p � 0 CL
rD rD rD rD Z3 Ln
g O rb � n 0 r+ O r+ gu
3 LO w -+, = r) O = 3 —h
A� �D 7 rrt rD W rD
r- g r = r rD lQ Q
yi
-% r . (^ rD v I gu <
r) j u, O vrD �v O
,�3 o r n
n Lo 3 N < r+ �'' rrt rD
rip r7 rD �. O vi
`< O Q
rD
M rD rD
r � �1 O � O A' u' O r+ r+ rD
p � p
fl � rD rD a► vVi
N •< rD L/) r1 cn r+ rD Sv
O rD rD r*
CD ^ rD rD
r+ N ^ _
t ' Ln
rD rD io M
Ln
M
Packet Page -1889-
Packet Page -1890-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
:3
rD
�1
X
-o
3
rD
*�,—
rD
.�
r-t
rD
M
r
G
rD
���
rD
YL
iii• /i/
/'��
``
Ln
\iii
rD `G
�-
V ,
O -1
O=
n
rD
'�'
r-+
:�
;u
Lo
-%
rD
rD
s
n
Q
°
I*
N
V
rD
rD
X
rD
r-r
Lo
r+
w
D
—•
gu
�
�-
n
-n
Q
—•
rD
�.
=
rD
n
�-
r°
rD-
n
n
-,,
n
n��
ro
CD
70
�-1
N
n
rD
�.
G
7®
rD
:
to
r-+
(D
Lq
O
Lo
rte*
Ln
r-h
N
LO
Ln
(
rD
�
r-+
�°
°
n
G
�
�
O
�
-°
rD
-�
f V
— •
�
r-r
O
t!1
�
®
�
rfC
(li
r +
(DD
LA
Ln
O
M
un
rD
G
(D'
°
[�
M'
!
®
¢,
°
°
o
(D
3
3
Q'
rD
rD
n
S
rD
o0
M'
o-
C')
r..r
n
sv
"I
.
ID
�-
ro
rrt
r�
O
�.
_
n
0
rD
ID
n
_
�,
to
G
O
�
rD
Q
_LO
—
r-r
3
n
LO
r*
(D
L,'
rD
�',
n
=-r�
=
v,
n
V)
rD
cn
rD
n
M
Packet Page -1890-
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
rD
0
e rD
0 LO rD
o
:3 rD X O r-
O r-r n
3 O O rD
r-r – • rD
C S A.i _ N
TI` w r+� ®�
070 r+
Q W rD
Q -� r-r `G r•r
O n = rD r + O rD
_ S -t r+
0 0 0 W I W v �� rD
� C u�, N `n r-r r'
_. �.-
rD
0 rD
cn • rti (D O ®' —
O r) O :3 '® n
O rD cn M p P�- - 70
rD rl+
�! –• Q = -S W <
Lrl ;q: rD V'I rD
�? n CD f-+
C: w O Q rD n
M
lQ O CL "< I
rD
Packet Page -1891-
M rD rp rD rD -0 rD rD
n '_''. rD
W O r--r Q X. '-. rD
r�-r N � • � � � N E
p rD Q
`n n O CD _ n -�
rD fD L _ � N r-11
rD I rD N — ¢, tQ p
�r--r cn rD O V
LO.p � rf. < ��.
rD Q � 0 �
nS -ten
rD rD s
V) lQ N
rD r„� rD cQ
pi rD M X rD
rt
fD W rD M 70 rD rD tQ W rD
rD Q O rD � = n
<
fD rD �, cn O Q r-r
rb R rD CL
�n �O p O
_ r-r
CL rD rD rD � rD
!b r-r r.h rrt
O rb X (DD M n
�rt. O
CQ
Packet Page -1892-
Ln
r•-r
rD
r-t
t
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
r
gu
a
•
•
s
rD
rD
s
CO
•.
gu s
•
h LA
0 •
•
W. •.
0
n
<
P
o
D
QrDrDQ
�3unPuo
*<
(n
�-+
rf
�f�
(n
1
n�
+
�
r�-r
O
r)
rD
r.)
�
r)
te
(D
Sv
:3
t-n0
rD
5,
n
p
co
p,
—
O
O
Q,
C:
rr
M
rD
►-*
r%
Ln n
O
Lo
�
rr
0
0
-h
`
�
r.)
M
rD
rD
<rrDD
0
Vic^
v,
-
S
Lo
cn
0
=
�_
-''
�
rD
ON
Ln
rD
r+
0--%
O
•'
A�
n
=
S
rD
I
f-+
rD
I
0
3
M
Ln
Q'r=D
-
rD
Z3
- •
cn
Co
0
rD
CD
rt
p
rN-r
`<
rD
W
rDD
rr
S
�
rD
CCD
rD
n
r-r
Ln
0CD����
r*
rD
0_
— •
rD
^�
3
sv
A'
-z
rD
rr
rD
-*,
0
Q
p
rD
r-r
rD
0_
n30
rD
--.1
r-+
N
Q
<
�3(D rD
r-r
MN
Lo
<Q
w
rD
lQ
Ln
Lo
O0_
A�
r-+
n
0
-1
rr
0_
rr
S
O
1
0
=�
rD
0
N
Ln
CD
rD
O
rD
O
�V
CD
rD
=" rD
¢'
cn
rD
70
.•.S
:3
=
rte-+
0_
0_
rD
N
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
za
Packet Page -1893-
•
r
s
f•
I`
r
As
I
I" IN
s
r
rD
rD
3
CD
0
O
i
LA
W,
•
s
Aq
r
s
r
0—
foli
O_ 7
D
QrDrDQ
M
*<
(n
(D
(n
�u
Q
rh
r)
rr
0
�
r)
Z3
(D
Sv
:3
—
rD
C:
rr
rr
p
Ln
r-r,
rD -0
r+ -1
3
r+
rD
<<D
O
rD
rD
v,
p,
rD
=3
o
ON
=-
—�,0
Ln
I
rD
to
I
--j
rr
U
p
Ln
rD
-
M
�.
rr
S
�
rD
CCD
rD
n
— •
^�
3
rr
-z
cn
D
-%
0_
-*,
rD
0
<
(D
n
�
rD
=(�
rD
�
r-+
N
Q
�'
Lo
w
rD
Ln
Lo
rD
r+
0_
O
=
�rD-�
CD
M<
O
�
O
O
0_
=" rD
cn
rD
rD
—.
(D
Packet Page -1893-
•
r
s
f•
I`
r
As
I
I" IN
s
r
rD
rD
3
CD
0
O
i
LA
W,
•
s
Aq
r
s
r
0—
foli
'T-
r-+
O �-
—h --% Q, f-+
C: rD rD rD
h= S
r-+ Q rD
= rD
3 -+ <
O
O
3
O c
O rD
~' :
a'
O C:
_�
lQ � �
• � rD
rD
n
Ln
tQ rD
Q
= — Ln
-1
rD
rD
� rD
rD b M
n
si
-
O
rD'
� <
�< M-- r)
n Lo
rD
<
r* rD
Ln
�•+
¢? O
rD
cn
cn
Q O
,C Q,
rD
CD
r� n
e-+
=3
rD e-+rDC)rD
n
—ham
O n
Lo
0 C
rD��Q�n
cQ
Ln
Q rD
O rD
rD
rD
�2o
rD rD�
rt
70 Cr
O
n n
F, r-+
3 rt
n
p
_
rD
rD
�'
rD
O 5
X.
<
_+;
Q
—
— O
cn
;4
rD
rD
rD
r-+
(D
_.
O p.,
Cr rD
3
vii p�
r-r
pi
r-r
— •
Ln
—h
rD
rD O
Xt
3
—h
•n
p,rrD
(D
sv
rD
rD
A�
Lo
�•
n
O
r-r
0 Su —I
-0 -- —I
==
h= S
r-+ Q rD
O
rD rD
rD
O
O
=
Q
N �
�n rD
O rD
~' :
a'
O
.
I �<
O
v cn LQ
o
= — Ln
-1
rD
D rD
M rD
rD
n
O v
_. LA
O
C �
rD
cn r-r
n
O rD
'-+, Q
C: n
E:xP-
rD - -'
rtrD
kJo
rD N•
-�
rD
rD
rD O
�rD
n
—ham
O n
rD
cQ
Q rD
r--r
¢� Ln
O
O
n
rt
70 Cr
O
n n
rD
p
Packet Page -1894-
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
12/11/2012 Item 11.1.
Packet Page -1895-
—h
rD
-1
Ir
rW
X
0
O
°`°�rlt
tQ
*=
�rD
f1
Q.
rD
3•
3
rD
N
�
—
O
00
O3CDr0.1
rD
�
rD
<
�
=3
-7
=3
C:
=3
rD
m
—i
rD
rt
3
0
rD
n
Ln
Ln
r-r
_.
r-t
Ln
r*
rD
M
rD
N
rD
—•
Sy
X
—i
p*
3
w
=.
S
rD
N
p'
M
M
�U
Ul
N
n
O
r-f
rD
CAD
�•
n
r�-t•
rrt
Q
in
p
rrt
`-
r-t
3
'C
O
N
v
�
rD
n
O
rD
o
O-Q-1
C
rD
Q�
h
�
i
_
E
L.
rt
Q,
-t
-
®
LA
h
CD
�<
<.
3
_
-�
rD
n
n
�-
z
0
rD
_*,
cn
p
�•
rr'
O
rD
r*
rD
cn
¢,
—
O•
Lo
r*
CD
(D
0
r't
�
O
—h
r*
=
O
-h
<
r-
(D
rD
rD
rD
V)
Packet Page -1895-
-0
N
N
z
-h r-t
(/1 W
O
<
O
<
O
rD
`G
rD
p
CQ -P
=
rD
_W
rD
Q
1,0
rD
�
r'D
� 0
O
-
rD
C: —
lfl
-P
CL
CD
Q.
rD rD
N
(D
gu
r t
O
r-r N
O —•
rD
N
O
p
<
O
o
O�
<
V)
=
_,
rD
N D
=�
O
c„
n
n
p*
cO
tQ •
. .
CD
rD
�
O
3
r+
V a
:3
LC
L
cQ'
rD
r+
:
0
O
cn
rD
r*
O
rt
O
70
A.�
Q
rD rD
O
o
a�
D
rD
r-
r *
-•
rD
rD
W O
N
r+
r-r
s
rD
Packet Page -1896-
12/11/2012 Item 11. I.
s
•