Loading...
Agenda 05/22/2018 Item #16E 505/22/2018 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation that the Board direct staff to work with Ave Maria Development, LLLP and the Immokalee Fire District with respect to the transfer of four acres of land as now required by Resolution 14-220, for public safety and general government use, including directing staff to negotiate a long term lease with the Immokalee Fire District for use of the property as a Public Safety Center. OBJECTIVE: To provide the Town of Ave Maria and the surrounding areas with adequate EMS and Fire services. CONSIDERATIONS: In 2005, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida approved Resolution No. 05-235 (Development Order No. 05-01) which approved a Development of Regional Impact (DRI) known as the Town of Ave Maria DRI. This Development Order contained a Developer commitment with respect to fire and police protection, which commitment is now set forth in Resolution No. 14-220. The commitment reads as follows: POLICE AND FIRE PROTECTION A. Developer shall assist in the development, building, and funding of a Multi-purpose Public Safety Center to house emergency response personnel and equipment to ensure that the development does not dilute the existing emergency services in Immokalee and surrounding communities. B. Developer has committed to provide a temporary public safety facility and a minimum of three acres of property for a permanent joint facility which will meet the needs of the Immokalee Fire District, Collier Emergency Medical Services, and the Collier Sheriff’s Department as the Town grows. In addition to the commitment to dedicate a minimum of three acres for a joint facility to house EMS/Fire Station/Sheriff sub - station, Developer agrees to reserve an additional one acre site within the Town for “Government Building(s)” adjacent to the joint facility. This site shall be reserved by Developer until development of whichever is the latter in time: 75% of the total number of residential dwelling units or 75% of total area of non-residential uses; as measured at time of building permit approvals. If such a commitment is not exercised by timely notice from the County to the Developer as stated immediately above, then this one acre site reservation shall terminate. The one acre site shall be dedicated to the County in exchange for impact fee credits upon the County committing to construct a “Government Building(s)” facility by identifying same within the County’s CIP. At this point in time the Immokalee Fire District would like to proceed with developing a fire statio n on the three-acre parcel. The County and the Developer are in disagreement with whether the Developer is entitled to compensation for this transfer. The Immokalee Fire District is willing to provide Developer with the requested funds for the transfer of the three-acre parcel to the County, on the condition that the County extend the Fire District a long-term lease. Staff is seeking direction from the Board of County Commissioners to work with both Ave Maria Development, LLLP and the Immokalee Fire District to bring back to the Board the necessary 16.E.5 Packet Pg. 1206 05/22/2018 conveyance and leasing documents to consummate this transaction. In addition to the three-acre parcel, Staff believes that it is appropriate at this time negotiate and bring back to the Board a transfer of the one- acre site for impact fee credits. Staff is seeking Board approval to do so. FISCAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact associated with this action. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There are no Growth Management Impacts associated with this action. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney, is approved as to form and legality, and requires majority vote for approval. -JAK RECOMMENDATION: That the Board direct staff to work with Ave Maria Development, LLLP and the Immokalee Fire District with respect to the transfer of four acres of land as now required by Resolution 14-220, for public safety and general government use, including directing staff to negotiate a long-term lease with the Immokalee Fire District for use of the property as a Public Safety Center. Prepared by: Len Golden Price, Administrative Services Department Head ATTACHMENT(S) 1. Ave Maria Res. 14-220 (PDF) 2. Immokalee Fire District, Joint Public Safety Facility, Ave Maria (PDF) 16.E.5 Packet Pg. 1207 05/22/2018 COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 16.E.5 Doc ID: 5705 Item Summary: Recommendation that the Board direct staff to work with Ave Maria Development, LLLP and the Immokalee Fire District with respect to the transfer of four acres of land as now required by Resolution 14-220, for public safety and general government use, including directing staff to negotiate a long term lease with the Immokalee Fire District for use of the property as a Public Safety Center. Meeting Date: 05/22/2018 Prepared by: Title: Department Head - Administrative Svc – Administrative Services Department Name: Len Price 05/15/2018 2:43 PM Submitted by: Title: Department Head - Administrative Svc – Administrative Services Department Name: Len Price 05/15/2018 2:43 PM Approved By: Review: Administrative Services Department Paula Brethauer Level 1 Division Reviewer Completed 05/15/2018 3:21 PM Administrative Services Department Len Price Level 2 Division Administrator Review Completed 05/16/2018 9:12 AM Office of Management and Budget Valerie Fleming Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 05/16/2018 9:54 AM Budget and Management Office Mark Isackson Additional Reviewer Completed 05/16/2018 11:40 AM County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 05/16/2018 2:07 PM County Manager's Office Leo E. Ochs Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 05/16/2018 2:12 PM Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending 05/22/2018 9:00 AM 16.E.5 Packet Pg. 1208 RESOLUTION NO. 14 -220 RESCISSION OF THE TOWN OF AVE MARIA DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL IMPACT DEVELOPMENT ORDER A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PURSUANT TO SECTION 380.115(1)(b), FLORIDA STATUTES, APPROVING THE APPLICATION FOR RESCISSION OF THE TOWN OF AVE MARIA DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL IMPACT; PROVIDING FOR FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW; PROVIDING FOR APPROVAL OF THE RESCISSION OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF REGIONAL IMPACT DEVELOPMENT ORDER, AND COMPLIANCE WITH POST- RESCISSION DEVELOPMENT WITH COUNTY REGULATONS; PROVIDING FOR CONDITIONS; PROVIDING FOR RECORDATION; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED NORTH OF OIL WELL ROAD AND WEST OF CAMP KEAIS ROAD IN SECTIONS 31 THROUGH 33, TOWNSHIP 46 SOUTH, RANGE 29 EAST AND SECTIONS 4 THROUGH 9 AND 16 THROUGH 18, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 29 EAST IN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. PETITION DRIABN-PL20130002016] WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida approved Resolution No. 05-235 (Development Order No. 05-01) which approved a Development of Regional Impact (DRI) known as the Town of Ave Maria DRI on June 14, 2005; and WHEREAS, the real property which is the subject of the Development Order is legally described and set forth as Exhibit A to Resolution No. 05-235 (Development Order No. 05-01), as amended, to correct a scrivener's error by Resolution No. 05-377 adopted on November 1, 2005 (the "Property"); and WHEREAS, the Town of Ave Maria DRI was amended by Resolution No. 08-153 Development Order 08-01) which revised the Development Order relative to the Affordable Housing Section and by Resolution No. 11-132 (Development Order 11-03) which revised Development Order Exhibit "C" and Map "H" by dividing Town Center 2 into Town Center 2a and Town Center 2b, relocating Town Center 2b to Oil Well Road, and relocating an access point on Oil well Road; and 14-CPS-01325/1115227/1] 76 Ave Maria1DRIABN-PL20130002016 1 of 6 Rev. 9108/14 Cq 16.E.5.a Packet Pg. 1209 Attachment: Ave Maria Res. 14-220 (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) WHEREAS, Section 380.115(1)(b), Florida Statutes, provides the procedure for rescission of a development of regional impact; and WHEREAS, Ave Maria Development, LLLP, as Developer and original Developer for the DRI, has applied to the Board of County Commissioners to rescind the Town of Ave Maria Development of Regional Impact pursuant to the above-referenced Statute; and WHEREAS, all owners of property within the Town of Ave Maria DRI have not consented to said rescission; and WHEREAS, the Southwest Florida Regional Planning Council considered the application; and WHEREAS, the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity has reviewed the application; and WHEREAS, all required public notices for hearings on the application have been published; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission has conducted a public hearing on September 4, 2014 and recommended the approval of the application to rescind the Town of Ave Maria DRI and the Development Order and recommended the adoption of this Resolution rescinding the DRI and the Development Order. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: SECTION ONE: RECITALS. The Recitals in the preceding "Whereas" clauses are true and correct and are incorporated herein by reference as if repeated verbatim herein. SECTION TWO: RECESSION APPROVED. The application for the rescission of the Town of Ave Maria Development of Regional Impact and the Development Order is hereby approved in accordance with this Resolution. SECTION THREE: CONDITIONS. The following conditions will apply to any future development of the Property and will run with the Property unless and until they are modified or repealed by subsequent resolutions of the County: 14-CPS-01325/1115227/1] 76 Ave Maria/DRIABN-PL20130002016 2 of 6 Rev.9/08/14 C;4 16.E.5.a Packet Pg. 1210 Attachment: Ave Maria Res. 14-220 (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) HISTORICAL AND ARCHEOLOGICAL SITES The research used for the ADA will be utilized to develop text for a historical marker commemorating the Second Seminole War activities, which will be placed at an appropriate location within Ave Maria. The historical marker, size, content, and location will be subject to approval by Zoning Services Historical Review staff. This marker will be installed by no later than December 31, 2014. EDUCATION Notwithstanding the abandonment of the DRI, upon request by the School District, (but in no event later than June 1st, 2020, unless such date is extended by the School District in writing, at its discretion) the Developer shall dedicate approximately 60 developable acres for a high school and ancillary facilities, outside the Town of Ave Maria and in a location requested by the School District staff that is approximately two (2) miles west of Camp Keais Road, north of Immokalee Road and generally situated in Sections 20, 21, or 22 in Township 47, Range 28 of Collier County, Florida or in another location that is agreeable to both Developer and the School District. The School District's acceptance of the dedicated site shall be contingent upon a satisfactory feasibility study demonstrating that the land is suitable for the School District's intended use as a high school site with appropriate environmental conditions, useable acreage and direct legal access to a public right-of-way. The Developer shall receive educational impact fee credits in exchange for the dedicated site as set forth in a Tri-party Developer Contribution Agreement including the Developer, the School District and Collier County) with the amount determined in accordance with a mutually agreed land appraisal valuation for the dedicated site. POLICE AND FIRE PROTECTION A. Developer shall assist in the development, building, and funding of a Multi- purpose Public Safety Center to house emergency response personnel and equipment to ensure that the development does not dilute the existing emergency services in Immokalee and surrounding communities. B. Developer has committed to provide a temporary public safety facility and a minimum of three acres of property for a permanent joint facility which will meet the needs of the Immokalee Fire District, Collier Emergency Medical Services, and the Collier Sheriff's Department as the Town grows. In addition to the commitment to dedicate a minimum of three acres for a joint facility to 14-CPS-01325 1 I 15227/I] 76 Ave Maria/DRIABN-PL20130002016 3 of 6 Rev. 9/08/14 16.E.5.a Packet Pg. 1211 Attachment: Ave Maria Res. 14-220 (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) house EMS/Fire Station/Sheriff sub-station, Developer agrees to reserve an additional one acre site within the Town for "Government Building(s)" adjacent to the joint facility. This site shall be reserved by Developer until development of whichever is the latter in time: 75% of the total number of residential dwelling units or 75% of total area of non-residential uses; as measured at time of building permit approvals. If such a commitment is not exercised by timely notice from the County to the Developer as stated immediately above, then this one acre site reservation shall terminate. The one acre site shall be dedicated to the County in exchange for impact fee credits upon the County committing to construct a "Government Building(s)" facility by identifying same within the County's CIP. SECTION FOUR: FINDINGS OF FACT. The Board of County Commissioners hereby makes the following findings of fact: 1. Developer owner requested the rescission of the Development Order because circumstances and the DRI law have changed such that development within a rural land stewardship area created under Section 163.3248, F.S. is now exempt from the DRI review. 2. The Town of Ave Maria Stewardship Receiving Area (the "SRA") created by Resolution No. 2004-89 adopted on March 23, 2004 and Resolution No. 2005-234A on June 14, 2005, as amended are within the Rural Land Stewardship Area Overlay. 3. Under Section 163.3248(11), F.S., the rural land stewardship area located in Collier County is "to be recognized as a statutory rural land stewardship area". 4. Under Section 380.115, F.S., a development that has a DRI Development Order, but is no longer required to undergo DRI review because it is now exempt under 380.06(24) shall be rescinded by the local government upon a showing that required mitigation will be completed under an existing permit or equivalent authorization by the county provided such permit or authorization is subject to enforcement through administrative and judicial remedies. 5. The amount of development constructed to date is approximately 552 residential dwelling units, 145,843 square feet of retail/service, 333,442 square feet of office development, and university buildings and student housing have been completed to date. Additionally, lands have been developed for infrastructure, water management facilities, parks and open space uses in accordance with the approved DRI and SRA master plans. 6. The development proposed after rescission shall comply with (1) the provisions of Resolution No. 2004-89 adopted on March 23, 2004 and Resolution No. 2005-234A on June 14, 2005, as amended, (`the SRA Documents"), which are the Planned Development Document for the Town of Ave Maria Stewardship Receiving Area; 114-CPS-01325/1115227/11 76 Ave Maria/DRIABN-PL20130002016 4 of 6 Rev. 9'08/14 16.E.5.a Packet Pg. 1212 Attachment: Ave Maria Res. 14-220 (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) 2) the conditions set forth in Section Three of this Resolution; (3) the Collier County Land Development Code, as it may be amended; and (4) all Developer Contribution Agreements and other applicable agreements between Collier County and Ave Maria Development, LLLP. 7. Other impacts of the development proposed after rescission will be adequately mitigated by compliance with the provisions of the SRA Documents and the Collier County Land Development Code. This includes, but is not limited to, the payment of all required impact fees, and compliance with the County's Concurrency Management System. 8. The rescission will have no adverse impact upon, and is consistent with, the Collier County Growth Management Plan and land development regulations. SECTION FIVE: CONCLUSIONS OF LAW: The Board of County Commissioners hereby makes the following conclusions of law: 1. The Town of Ave Maria DRI is eligible for rescission because the development within a rural land stewardship area created or recognized under Section 163.3248, F.S. is now exempt from review under Section 380.06(24)(m), F.S. 2. The development proposed after rescission is consistent with the Collier County Growth Management Plan and Land Development Code, and does not need to be authorized as a development of regional impact to proceed. 3. The development proposed after rescission is consistent with the Collier County Growth Management Plan and land development regulations so long as the post- rescission development complies with the SRA Documents and the Collier County Land Development Code. 4. The proposed development after rescission will be consistent with the State Comprehensive Plan, the State Land Development Plan, and the Southwest Florida Regional Policy Plan. SECTION SIX: APPROVAL OF RESCISSION OF DRI, REPEAL OF DRI DEVELOPMENT ORDER, AS AMENDED, AND COMPLIANCE OF POST RESCISSION DEVELOPMENT WITH COUNTY REGULATIONS. 1. The application to rescind the Town of Ave Maria Development of Regional Impact is hereby approved, subject to the terms and conditions herein. 2. The Town of Ave Maria Development of Regional Impact and Development Order 05-01, as amended, is hereby rescinded in its entirety and shall be of no further force or effect. 14-CPS-01325/1115227/1] 76 Ave Maria/DRIABN-PL20130002016 5 of 6 Rev. 9/08/14 Cq 16.E.5.a Packet Pg. 1213 Attachment: Ave Maria Res. 14-220 (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) 3. The development proposed after rescission shall comply with (1) the provisions of Resolution No. 2004-89 adopted on March 23, 2004 and Resolution No. 2005-234A on June 14, 2005, as amended, (`the SRA Documents"), which are the Planned Development Document for the Town of Ave Maria Stewardship Receiving Area; 2) the conditions set forth in Section Three of this Resolution; (3) the Collier County Land Development Code, as it may be amended; and (4) all DCA and applicable agreements between Collier County and Ave Maria Development, LLLP. 4. The terms and conditions of this Resolution shall be binding upon the Owners and their assigns or successors in interest. SECTION SEVEN: SEVERABILITY. If any section, sentence, clause or phrase of this Resolution is held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, said holding shall in no way affect the validity of the remaining portions of this Resolution, and the remainder of this Resolution shall remain in full force and effect. SECTION EIGHT: RECORDATION. Ave Maria Development, LLLP shall pay for the recording of this Resolution in the Official Land Records of Collier County. SECTION NINE: EFFECTIVE DATE. This Resolution shall take effect as provided by law. This Resolution adopted this i LPL1•. day of 0(_'-? o hQ r"2014 after motion, second and majority vote. ATTEST: BOARD OF CO I TY COMMISSIONERS DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLL R CO/TY, FLORIDA D P. • h. D `ut Clerk TOM ENN ., Chairman Attes as to Chairman s i signature only. Appr ved as to form and legality: Heidi Ashton-Cicko v Managing Assistant County Attorney 14-CPS-01325/1115227/1] 76 Ave Maria/DRIABN-PL20130002016 6 of 6 Rev. 9'08/14 9 16.E.5.a Packet Pg. 1214 Attachment: Ave Maria Res. 14-220 (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) lmmokalee Fire Control District 502 New Market Road East, lmmokalee, FL.34142 Board of Fire Commissioners ApHl 19,2018 Leo E. Ochs, Jr. County Manager Honorable William L. McDaniel, Vice Chair Collier County Board of County Commissioners 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 202 Naples, FL 34112-5746 Re: Joint Public Safety Facility, Ave Maria, Florida Mr. Ochs: RFCIIVED O「ice′「Ⅲ。■■t,nむ Manager A`ヽ (242018 Actic ´ As a follow-up to our conversation, I am writing this letter to document what we discussed. Per your recorrmendation, Immokalee Fire Control District (IFCD) is providing a written request stating our intent and expectations concerning the property acquisition in Ave Maria Florida located within the protective boundaries of the IFCD. As you know, IFCD is ready to move forward with the constnrction ofajoint Public Safety Facility, (the facility) thereby solely funding the facility and housing IFCD, Collier County Emergency Medical Services (EMS) and the Collier County SherifPs Office (CCSO). Additionally, the verbiage in Section 3 of Collier County Resolution No. 14-220 (the Resolution) provides a condition in which the Ave Maria Development, LLLp (the Developer) will provide a minimum of three (3) acres for a permanent joint facility that meets the needs of IFCD, EMS andccso. Moreover, the developer agreed to reserve one additional acre for a "Govemment Building(s)." The site for the facility that was identified is located in the park of commerce (see attachment A) and has been deemed suitable by IFCD and Collier County in an effort to satisfu all terms and conditions set forth in the resolution by providing land. As you know, in 2007 and 2008, the Developer did in fact incur the cost of $243,5g0.79 in the development and improvement ofthe identified site (see attachment B). The developer is currently asking to recoup only fifty percent (50%) of their infiastructure improvement and development cost in the amount of$121,790.00. In an effort to move forward with the construction ofa new joint public safety facility, IFCD is more than willing to pay this $121,790.00 asking price for the identified site to the developer. This will hereby give the residents ofAve Maria and all public safety personnel a permanent, safe and secure structure. Alule Goodnighl. Chair Joseph Brisrer. Vice Chair Edward ,.Ski,, Olesky, Secretary/Treasuer Bonnie Keen, Commissioner Robert Halman. Commissioner 16.E.5.b Packet Pg. 1215 Attachment: Immokalee Fire District, Joint Public Safety Facility, Ave Maria (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) Considering all facts above, please consider this letter a written formal request for IFCD to receive the deed from Collier County. It is our intent to purchase the identified site. Further, it is our expectation that this matter be taken before the Collier County Board of County Commissioners and further, the Board of County Commissioners to vote unanimously for IFCD to receive the deed to the purchased property. This will clearly satisfu the intent of your own county resolution and enable IFCD to expedite the construction of this facility that is so desperately needed for this community. We always strive to be good colleagues and business partners with the Collier County Board of County Commissioners. We are looking forward to having many years of Camaraderie with all of our public safety partners. Thank you in advance for your continued support of the Immokalee Fire Control District. Should you wish to reach me, please don't hesitate to call me directly at239-250-3914 or email me at aeoodniEfit@immfire.com. You can also reach our District Manager and Fire Chiet Michael Choate at 239 -657 -21 I I or at mchoate@immfire. com. Sincerely, Plru*ln t' Anne Goodnight, Chair Board of Fire Commissioners Immokalee Fire Control District CC: Thomas Peek, Chairman - Ave Maria Stewardship District Liesa Priddy, Vice Chair - Ave Maria Stewardship District Robb Klucik, Assistant Secretary - Ave Maria Stewardship District Jay Roth, Member - Ave Maria Stewardship District Tom DiFlorio, Member - Ave Maria Stewardship District David B. Genson, PE - Director of Development, Banon Collier Companies Kenneth K. Thompson, PA - IFCD Joseph Brister, Vice Chair - IFCD Edward "Ski" Olesky, Treasurer - IFCD Bonnie Keen, Commissioner - IFCD Robert Halman. Commissioner - IFCD Michael J. Choate, Dstrict Manager I Fire Chief - IFCD Page2 of2 16.E.5.b Packet Pg. 1216 Attachment: Immokalee Fire District, Joint Public Safety Facility, Ave Maria (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) Attachment "A" =PROPOSED PARCEL CONTAINS 4 0 ACRES+/‐ DESCR:PT10N OF PROPOSED PARCEL: ALL OF TRACT F‐7 AND THE SOUTH 10947 FEET OF TRACT F‐6,AS MEASURED PARALLEL WTH THE SOUTHERLY L:NE OF SAID TRACT F‐6,AVE MAR:A UN:T¬″0,PARK OF COMMERCE,RECORDED:N PLAT B00K48,PAGES 22 THROUGH 28,COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA SAID PARCEL CONTAINS 4 0 ACRES MORE OR LESS PROPOSED PARCEし BEING ALL OF TRACT F-7 AND THE SOUTH 109 47 FEET OF TRACT F‐6, AVE MAR!A UNIT TWO, PARK OF COMMERCE (IN「EET) 16.E.5.b Packet Pg. 1217 Attachment: Immokalee Fire District, Joint Public Safety Facility, Ave Maria (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer) Attachment B Ave Maria Public Safety Faciltty (AM pSF) Construction Costsl December 1, 2017 Prepared By: Ave Maria Development, LLLP Earthworkand crading Total Cost Incurred:2 $ 7,416,463.23 Total Acreage Benefited (outparcels only) i3 43,83 acres Cost Incurred per Acre: $ 32,317.21 per acre AM PSF Earthwork and Grading Cost: $ 32,317,2L per a$e x 4.00 acres = $ 129,268.83 Sanitarv Sewer and Potable Water Total Cost lncurred:2 $ 793,325.00 Total Acreage Benefited (ouparcels only):3 27.76 acre Cost Incurred per Acre: $ 2g,577.99 per acre AM PSF Sanitary Sewer and Potabble Water Cost: $ 2B,S7Z.99 per acre x 4.00 acres = $ 114,311.96 Notes: o""'oo'to"*l-Illi,, 1. Includes only costs incurred byAve Maria Deveropment, LLLP and does not includethe folowing costs: Pavingand Signing (Ave Mari: Stewardhsip Community Disrrict tunded) Drainage (Ave I\4aria Stewardhsip Community District funded) Conduits Landscaping SoftCosts 2 Based on Final Pay Application (No. 10) frorn Mitchell & Stark Construction Comf'any, tnc., dated 2/2912 00g. See Exhibit A. 3. See Exhibit B. 16.E.5.b Packet Pg. 1218 Attachment: Immokalee Fire District, Joint Public Safety Facility, Ave Maria (5705 : Ave Maria land transfer)