BCC Minutes 03/06/1984 R
it
,~
~
."
~
~~
ï:
l'
Ìi-
j;
6""
Iiiiiii1
&11
.
IiiIiI
--
--~
.
Haples, Florida, March 6, 1984
LIT IT 8E REMEMBERED, that the Board of County Commis.ioners In
and for the County of Collier, and allo acting a. the Board of zoning
t App..l. end .s the 90v.rning board(.) of such .pecial district. a. have
b..n cr.atod according to law and having conducted bu.ines. herein,
on this date at 9100 A.M. in Regular S..sion in Building -P- of the
Courthou»o Complex, Ea.t Naples, Florida, with the 'ollowing members
present I
\
CHAIHMAHI David C. Drown
VICE CHAIRMAN I C. C. -Red- Holland
John A. Pfstor
Frederick J. VOIS
Mary-Franc.s Krule
ALSO PRESENT I William J. neagan, Clerk, Jama. C. Cilel, Filcal
Officer, Elinor M. Skinner, Deputy Clerk, Burt L. Saunders, County'
Attorney, Torry Virta, ^cting County MDnager, Donald Norton, Acting
Allistant County Manager, Irving Berzon, Utilitiel M~na9or, Heil
Dorrill, Public Safety Administrator, Loe Layne, Zoning Director, Ann
Ober, Planner, Knuto tlartman, Public Work. ~dmin1atratoq Chri. lIolluy,
Acting Admini.trative Servicel Administrator, Crace Undorwood, Admini-
.trative Afde to the Board, and Deputy Chiaf Raymond Barnett, Sherfff'.
Deparbrrent.
me 080 P.~t 405
t.....""..._._
,.""'""""'_."'n..'_"'_·,·...._"~,;...,...«,..,..."';___"..,'f_".."."...""""",_...._,~.'_",....___~_........"""'''""_,__,,,.,,.,,,,,,,,,_<
" """_'"''''''''''·''',.-ft~h''''_''''' ",.'''-'''.. ,.., ''''''_'"~_'"'~~''''''''''''H''',_';:<'''"''''<___''"'"''''''''' ''''!_
_..-.,. ~, nl' ...,.....""__...""'".,".~"_~."..."'~."'."...~.,'"'..,,,.,,...",.,,
<"'·'"'~'''''''_'''''''''"N''''''''__'_·'''''''''_''''_'''''_~'~.""""",~~"".";¡O;.._I.,...."_";I..~__"'."'...UI".._~_,_"",;,...____....".._""'d'''...."'""'.,....._,"',..;",_".'^.-...."-.."",.'"~..,_,"".,,
"'""'""-"'"'-"~~'-""'~",--"---,--"",---,--~""",-",-,,,""'"'~-,."._...",.....-.,_..,.,.--,...,,---_....._""""~~
'..---'-..........----"',--...
-·····"....·""·,-,·-·......,,,....._·...,·_____'0i..~..."'_1..__..._'
.'.'-'"~------.~~--"--"".""",";..-"",-,,,,,~- """""""-''''';~'''''''''''.'__''''' "_""'m"
......_.,,"',.""...._,..,-_."""..._'"'~,..,",.."'~.,,'"'_..._..,,";-_..._.._.~""'-_._-""".-....-.._--...."--~~..--..,--~~."''',.."'~-,..~..._'''"_.'.,",'~~'""'"
---------------------------------------~~~
080 mt 418
March 6, 1984
In the area and that the varianco will not Bot a precedent becau.. the
other properti.s are developed. He _aid that tho average denslty in
the area is approximately 29.4 unitl per acre and that the requested
density i. below the existlng den.ity.
Commllaioner tlollancl laid it wa. hll underltanding that the reason
for the requolted increa.e in the numbor of units is to allow the ownor
to build a more palatable appearing building in the area, to which Hr.
Pickworth agreod.
Responding to Commissioner PlItor, Mr. Pickworth uid that th1l 11
an area where all tho other propcrty ownors hav~ double the density
that his client hes ftnd he added that it is difficult to compo to
oconomically when everyone el~e can build twice as many units on tho
.ame amount of land.
County Attorney ~aunoorl Boid that in 0 varlance .ituation the
economic hardship argument il not sufficient justification for granting
the varianco, if the ~CC finds that tho variance is not in the public
interelt. Acting County Mðnager Virta »a1d, although tho area is
developed, ~t some point in time the Planning Departm~nt will be
looking at redevelopment of that area and, at that point, the people
could argue that they ore in need of additional density becauao of the
way the property i. dovelopod. lie said that the sole criteria lor
9r.ntin9 the variance ia hardship and that tho burden of proof of
hardship is on tho pefitioner. He lald it il the position of the Staff
that hardship han not been proven.
Co..issioner Kru.e moved, seconded by Comm'..ioner Voss and
carried unanimously, that the public hearing be clo.ed.
Co..is.ioner Holland moved, seconded by co..issloner Kruse and
carried 3/2, Co.-i.sioner. Voss and PI.tor oppo.ed, that Re.olutlon
'4-42 re Petition V-84-2C, be adopted.
Page 8
--------------------
-
-
-
,-,~_._---~, - .--.---,....
.... ·"".·,....,...·.__·.-."·.,u..".'_"'''',,o·,,_''',...·.-~...",'__,__''*......,:___..? If~
~",..'....-..-----,-..""'...."'..,---..-- ,.,._,"'."'~~..;."""'".................._.......,.'"'...._----_.._".-
"".._......"..;,..'"..~""-"";".',.......-"...,.,..~.,",,.. '....._-'''"..,~.,
~""'''''_._..."""","......~.,_.._-_.",~,_.,..",-,_.,.,.-
""".*~."-",,,",....._.,..._..,,,,,,"_.,",,,,,,;-.,."",".....,;,,,,,,,,,,,,.,..___________"'·___...,......''''0''.'"", '-,;-'...-,..... ,'.....","...,'~..,...._,"'."".....'..._"'.~>,~.,,_
-, ~> ,. ",._.....><.._~_'r._,..'..."...,....,;'"'_,...;_, .'_doc. _,......,.-"__.-.-...~_...'_,,. _, ....,
b ""~'-'_'''__'''''''.__,fI''_'''''~IU_,''''''''~
..... .._--,--_.._--,----,',.,..,.,,'_..,..~,.."
8]
I&J
~ -- -- -'" - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -. - - - - - - - - - - -----
March G, 19B4
mended that a ba.e rate ot t~o for tMS lervice. would be a rcasonablo
rate that would enable tho County to maint3in the billing dopartment
and to encourago II higher collection rat..
Commissioner Pistor maid that his discussions with hospital
personnel have resulted in their exprcssion of th~ fOAr that people
will use tho ombulðnc~ as ~ tÞxi, if the chdrgc is for ~~o ~nd th~
in.urance companies pay it, ond that the hospital ~mergency Dopartment
will be unable to tako care of 1111 tho people. 110 said th.\t the
parsons with whom ho has discUSBOd the situ~tion would like the County
bale rate to be $60 or $70 so th~t Qvoryboøy will havo to pay a tee for
ambulance use, oven though the insurance pays most of the ulll. ~r.
Dorrill said that the ßee ~ill have to adopt an ordinance if the
referendum is approved and tho district i» created. He said that Gtaff
is currently working with Dr. Tober on a new systom using thQ existing
radios ln tho hospital Emergoncy Room, so a paramedic ~ay consult with
an Emergency Room physicion ofter an onalysis has been made ot a
particular case in the tiel~. 110 soid that ~he physician will be able
to authorize the paramedic to rofuso a transport that does not appoar
to be fully warranted to tha dxtent that a County ambulance il noces-
s/lry. lie .aid that this system would romove a majority of borderline
CDse. where the par~mudic may choose to send somoono to the hospital in
his or her privato vehicle. Ue lIIaid th4lt the t.MSAC has u'ceoivod t-..o
petitions during tho pa.t year from privato, non-emergency transport
companie. desIring to come to this area to do bu.In.... tie laid tho.e
companies could piCk up the non-em,rgency call and would b. able to
oft.r a more reasonable l~vel of service to people who need non-emer-
gency transvort b.tween a nursing home And the hospital or between
'their home And a privAte doctor's office. He said these two .y.toms
would drastic~lly r.duce thu total numbor of runu that the County EMS
lODe 080 "~r 435
pag. 14
-----------------------.--------------
080 PA~t 436
Ma rch G, 1984
-----.------------------------------....
--------------------------------------~~~I~·
<·J;~:;'rrt..· ,. t
. .' "'..... :c.
'.......,'.. ",
·r . ¡ ..~'..:I;i,.¡
. ·~:.:~,~r
will experience durinq a year ~nd the County unit. will bo availablo
for only thoae call. that warrant the £~6 attontJon.
Co.-l..ioner Voss moved, .econded by Commi.sioner Holland and
carried unanimously, that the ba.. rate of $50 b. ..tabU.hed for EMS
.ervice..
Hr. Carri!1 asked if it wal the d.sire of the ~CC to freeze the
beao rate for a period of time?
Comai.sion.r Holland ~ov.d that the ba.e rat. of $50 be froz.n for
a period of thr.e years. The ~otion died for lack of a .econd.
County ^ttorney Saunder» advhed that the BCC could adopt a policy
to freaze the baa. rðte for 0 period of tim~, but that policy could bo
chenqed by thla SCC or ony subuq,,','.t ace by the pas8ðqo of a re.olu-
tion.
Co.-J..lon.r Holland ~oved that the BCC ..tabli.h a policy that
the ba.. rat. of $50 not be incr.as.d for any r.ason unle.. there is a
4/5th. vote of approval by the SCC. Thi. motion dJ.d for lack of a
.econd.
A .hort diøcu.alon followvd durJng which Mr. Saunder. advised that
Staff be dlrected to prepare a reloJutlon to state the baao rat.
policy, which would not have to be brought back to the BCC.
Co.-i.sioner Holland moved, s.cond.d by Co~.ission.r Kru.. and
carried unanimously, that Resolution 84-45 eltablilhing the policy that
the base rate of $50 for EMS .ervice. not be incr....d for any rea.on,
unle.. th.re i. a .i.pie majority approval by the BCC, be adopt.d.
Commilaionor PiGtor said that the public should bo mado aware that
if the referer.dum ~aD... hotels and motel~ will bo contributing toward
the ambulance lervice coat throUClh ad vlIlorOft1 taxo., whicll would al-
levlllte the concern tI,~t telllporary residents of Collier County would
not b. paying for ambulance service.
NOTE I DOCUMENT NOT RECEIVED IN CLERK'S OFFICE AS or HARCH 12. 1984
pag_ 15
-
..
-
__<_________,_~·~·....'._~-e.~_."~"'"'"...,,..."...._·,......,..,
..'.,.'"".._---"';...,-,,."._'''''"~.-_-_...-.._...'_...._--
h__...'_.....___~..·'>""'.....X~;_·~"_..."'_.·,·,,~,~·__'·m._
~"',',......-"">,,"',."....,,'"''''.""..-,_~.....,''''........,',.....'''...,,"....~",;i; .."." ,~'""_'''_''W·. .~ ,..""_,~.-,.C'""'''_''''''·''''''''"""".,__I"O,'''';'¡'."..__....__",..."...,,,,,,,'__"'"~"""."""' "'''_"","".._..~""...'' ..;....
_;""'_''''_.0I"~;j_,,;,·.,*''·'''~'_·.,, "'___""._'~~"~_",,,"'O'êC"',,"""..''''"·' ,"<,"..,...,.,
"~._",.,_",,,,.,,..,, ,..",~.....<"·;;¡,,,,,,,_,,,,.·.._,,"_"'_"'U.,",_______';";"""_"'__"~__"'"_'''''''''"II'
.,.'_.,___.""_._._..-.-......<o~","""._,,,.,~."'<=>''''_,'''_.,...__"'~.",_~
,.,,,...."",.~"',._---;---
~ ,.,,,-.~,,,,,,,,",,,.,,,._--_.,---_..,,,
~.,"_.........__........~~.".-_...>.--
,..,.",.,."'...,^"""""""',_,..,.,.....__J..u._·.....__'I>1<__""'_,·j_"__..,,",..._,·_,_;,;."',·... j",.....~u""'.-,,,.,,"""' ",·1'"'....,·...·,·"......_·",'.·"
..,..;..,~,q"_""""._.,_,,,,,,___'k____~'_'_'''_'_''''·'_''_'''·__-""~,"""".""....',,,,,,,,_.,,--....,,
.~~_._."...____"",_,.._"".,....".".,......,~.,_,.,~...,___"".",',,,", '''''''''''-'''''';'''''',""~_",,,,,,'-,..>___,,,...,,,,_,_...._.,,,,,_# II' .11II'."_"_I_"·_,",';~_~"""_iil'''_''''''''''''''''o''~.''''''''''''''''''·''.";..."......., """."......""' '"";~.,.^.._,,,.",,.,,,..._,,..
..,..,.."_...'""'.'"_...._..."',..,,_""_.,_,..._·U~,;'-'!.W__,___"""'_;.,,_,_',·v,,,···,,,,,·#,,,·,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,·,,·W,,,.,...
,_,"'",'_...·"I".~",__;Ot.__·<_,_..,...-......._,___,.-....~....,,_~"""""'.,·,~.-,.
¡¡¡;¡¡J
E1
---:~.~.~=.~=~=~.~:'.~~,~~~.:::c:":' .:::~~. -.:--;1
aforementioned method. aro the WilY. Dome of thoso streets hove beon .~.
pllVed in the older subd1vi.ions. He said that Staff üoos not consider','~;
an alldY the .ame as an arterial or colloctor ro~d, in thot an olley
tends to .urve the abutting property owners more than ~olden Cato
Parkway, for in.tance, which i. a through route for °mllny citizons who
do not live in Colden Cote. lie explalnod thot the oll.y i. approxi-
matoly l/~ mile long and that tho right-of-wllY is 30 feet.
Commilsioner Krule a.ked if the HCC WGru to IIlter its e.tabli.hed
engineering policy and wero to bogin paving ðllcys whero the money
would come from? Mr. Hartman said there lire several avenueS such as
the 9as tax, however, that tho current policy is to apply that rovenue
to capital improvemonta. He .aid that some ~d vlllor~m tax ia devoted,
generally, to maintenance and that d good ahar~ of r~venuo sharing is
obtained from the State, the sales tax mOTloy, for this purposo.
Commissioner Kruse '/lid that the County is aprllading liS much road money
a. posøible to as many roads liS possible, to which Mr. lIartman agreed.
Sho pointed out ie any money is spont on an alluy then the money is not
available for "road. HOlponding to Commllsioner Kruse, Mr. Hartman
said there are many alleys in Colden Cate City. Chairman Brown said
that the a....amont process would be the only manner that the County
could afford to use to pùvo IIll~ys, to which Mr. Hartman agreed. Hr.
Hartman said that one sid. of the alley in question is residential and
one sido il comlnercial.
Mr. Savolidi. said that the opposito .ldo of the alley i. zonod
re.identlal, however, thore IIrG no re.idences built in that area,
pre.ently. He pointlld out that he is 'trying to avert accidont. happen-
ing in the area by putting the parkin? in the back of tho propo.ed
lùundromat lInd that hu ùoell not c'!dvocllto a chanqlt for all tho ÐUey. in
080 A page 31;-0£;,
IOOC mr'i65 .i;;:'
._-------------------------------------~~
..,_____..._...,M..,_"....."~',~;"',."_.~_",...,.,,............_,'...',-'_.....,>_~_"'....~__..___~""'··_; <..._...IIJIi_""'..'"_II___......;..._~"'''_i,'_'''"·'......,.\...,...,""..._-""'......,"',....._-......._,-""""-_."""""..,,..,,.,.-,,,,'-','
""__""""'_~ôi/._~_,.,,,,",..;.,,.......,.,.,..,....,,,,,,,_.....,.,,,_,,-=,-" ,~...."_,,,,,,,,"..__·~,.~,,,.......,.,,,,,w,.,,,,.,,.,·.·..,,,,,
'_T~"c"",..,.,,,,~____....._,,,,,_..___.""rt'''''',-,,,,,,,,,,,_._,,",-,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,·,,,,"""""''"''1,.._....01''''-''_' ,~._...,..,........",-...,,,,,,.,,,,,..",",,,,,,,,,....,-"<>=..,..,.,.' "·_.".,~",,.",·,;,<-<'''..m''· "",'"