Loading...
Agenda 04/22/2014 Item #16K2 4/22/2014 16.K.2. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation to ratify and approve a stipulated Final Judgment as to Publix's interest in Parcels 113FEE and 113TCE as part of the US-41 / Collier Boulevard Intersection Improvement project(Project No.60116) Fiscal Impact: $4,768. OBJECTIVE: To settle the lawsuit styled Collier County v. New Plan Florida Holdings, et al, as to Publix's interest in Parcels 113FEE and 113TCE and eliminate exposure to further costs arising out of extended Iitigation. CONSIDERATIONS: Parcels 113FEE and 113TCE were taken by Collier County for the purpose of constructing at-grade improvements to the intersection of US-41 and Collier Boulevard. The parent tract property is a shopping center known as Freedom Square which is home to many businesses, one of which is a Publix supermarket. Publix is the holder of a reciprocal access easement over New Plan Florida Holdings shopping center property from which Parcels 113FEE and 113TCE were taken. As such Publix had to be served as a party defendant in the eminent domain lawsuit styled Collier County v. New Plan Florida Holdings, et al, and was therefore entitled to hire counsel and expert witnesses for the purpose of exercising their right to make an apportionment claim on the proceeds from the County's deposit. Publix has agreed to resolve their entitlement to apportionment for the total sum of $4,768 inclusive of attorney fees and expert witness costs FISCAL IMPACT: Funds in the amount of$4,768 are available in the US-41/Collier Blvd Intersection Improvement Project (#60116). Source of funds are impact fees. There are no on- going maintenance or repair costs associated with the acquisition of right-of-way for the project. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated with the approval of this agenda item. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been approved as to form and legality and requires a majority vote for Board approval. -ERP RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County,Florida: Approves entry of the attached Stipulated Final Judgment with the Circuit Court. Prepared by: Kevin Hendricks,Right-of-Way Acquisition Manager Attachments: (1) Stipulated Final Judgment with legal description; (2) Location Map. Packet Page-1423- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 16.16.K.16.K.2. Item Summary: Recommendation to ratify and approve a stipulated Final Judgment as to Publix's interest in Parcels 113FEE and 113TCE as part of the US-41/Collier Boulevard Intersection Improvement project (Project No. 60116) Fiscal Impact: $4,768. Meeting Date: 4/22/2014 Prepared By Name: CrotteauKathynell Title: Legal Secretary,CAO Office Administration 4/11/2014 8:38:55 AM Approved By Name:HendricksKevin Title: Manager-Right of Way, Transportation Engineering&Construction Management Date: 4/11/2014 1:22:48 PM Name: TaylorLisa Title: Management/Budget Analyst,Transportation Administration Date: 4/11/2014 2:02:42 PM Name: ShueGene Title: Director-Operations Support,Transportation Administration Date: 4/11/2014 4:16:24 PM Name: AhmadJay Title: Director-Transportation Engineering,Transportat Date: 4/15/2014 7:20:34 AM Name: KearnsAllison Title: Manager Financial&Operational Support,Transportation Administration Date: 4/15/2014 9:03:55 AM Name: MarcellaJeanne Title: Executive Secretary, Transportation Planning ^ Date: 4/15/2014 9:11:53 AM Packet Page-1424- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. Name: PepinEmily Title: Assistant County Attorney, CAO Litigation Date: 4/15/2014 9:39:29 AM Name: KlatzkowJeff Title: County Attorney, Date: 4/15/2014 10:26:57 AM Name: UsherSusan Title: Management/Budget Analyst, Senior, Office of Management&Budget Date: 4/15/2014 5:59:02 PM Name: OchsLeo Title: County Manager, County Managers Office Date: 4/16/2014 9:11:32 AM n Packet Page-1425- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA CIVIL ACTION COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, Case No.: 13-CA-238 Petitioner, Parcels: 113FEE, 113TCE, v. NEW PLAN FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company; et al. Respondents. STIPULATED FINAL JUDGMENT THIS CAUSE having come before the Court upon Joint Motion made by Petitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, by and through its undersigned counsel, and Respondent, PUBLIX SUPER MARKETS, INC., through its undersigned counsel, for entry of a Stipulated Final Judgment as to Parcels 113FEE and 113TCE, for Project 68056, and it appearing to the Court that the parties are authorized to make such Motion, and the Court being fully advised in the premises thereof, it is thereupon ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that: 1. Respondent, PUBLIX SUPER MARKETS, INC. does have and recovers from Petitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, the total sum of Four Thousand, Seven Hundred Sixty-eight and No/100 Dollars ($4,768.00)in settlement of all claims,including attorney's fees and expert fees and costs incurred in defense of this case. 2. That within thirty (30) days hereof, Petitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, shall pay Four Thousand, Seven Hundred Sixty-eight and No/100 Dollars ($4,768.00)to Packet Page-1426- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. counsel for Respondent, GAYLORD MERLIN LUDOVICI & DIAZ, and forward same by U.S. Mail to Gaylord Merlin Ludovici & Diaz, Attn.: Lorena Hart Ludovici, Esq., 5001 West Cypress St., Tampa,Florida 33607 for further disbursement as deemed appropriate. 3. That upon payment of the aforesaid sum this suit shall stand dismissed with regard to PUBLIX SUPER MARKETS, INC., as to Parcels 113FEE and 113TCE and the same shall be removed from the service list for this case. 4. Title to Parcel 113FEE and 113TCE, being fully described in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein, which vested in Petitioner pursuant to the Order of Taking dated March 13, 2013, and the deposit of money heretofore made is approved, ratified, and confirmed. IT IS THEREFORE, DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Naples, Collier County, Florida, this day of , 2014. HONORABLE CYNTHIA A. PIVACEK CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE Conformed copies to: Emily R.Pepin,Esquire Lorena Hart Ludovici,Esquire Kevin Hendricks,Acquisition Mgr./Transportation Bookkeeping And all parties shown on the attached service list. Packet.Page-1427- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE TWENTIETH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA CIVIL ACTION COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, Case No.: 13-CA-238 Petitioner, Parcels: 113FEE, 113TCE, v. NEW PLAN FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company; et al. Respondents. JOINT MOTION FOR FINAL JUDGMENT Petitioner, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, together with Respondent, PUBLIX SUPER MARKETS, INC.,by and through their undersigned counsel,hereby respectfully move for entry of the foregoing Final Judgment as to Parcels 113FEE AND 113TCE as described in Exhibit"A"attached hereto. Dated: 1 i Dated: COLLIER COUNTY & !? LORENA H. LUDOVICI, ESQUIRE By: JEFFREY L.HINDS,ESQUIRE Florida Bar No. 847062 Florida Bar No. 0008710 Gaylord Merlin Ludovici &Diaz JAY J.BARTLETT, ESQUIRE 5001 West Cypress Street Florida Bar No. 875163 Tampa, FL 33607 Smolker Bartlett Schlosser Loeb &Hinds PA (via electronic mail) 500 E.Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 200 lludovici@a,gaylordmerlin.com Tampa, Florida 33602-4825 dwilliams(u�gavlordmerlin.com (813)223-3888 ATTORNEY FOR RESPONDENT Special Counsel to the County PUBLIX SUPER MARKETS,INC. Packet Page-1428- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. i K . �I�p=1 ti � SCHEOU IV : : " 4,. -74))to A Pag of! oo �.,4, mom 1012 1'• 4B' `i " gp'Lb� 4 \\*NNN N35'39'32'1 0.00' 4b.fit ` $Q M SS4 20'28'E LE 3' �J f N35'39'D4'E Ate��J' o ' `. C, A 15.00' �� POC DOB `, �' P06,04? ie ey`3f 113TCE '� *� 'Ib r A 650 SF / 535'39'32'W �"p yes N54'20'261N 10.00' ■ 65.00' t Ca57MO RW (/S �. h- RmOR6 10CK\Al I 0! . C PPOOND OF amNMNG PVC -Roam or CONMOICENplt \. NO.. MAWR 5R- VIM ROAD AKA -ALSO KNOWN AS NN LEGAL DESCRIPTION — PARCEL 113TCE • A PARCEL OF LAND LYING IN SECTION 3, TOWNSHIP 51 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EA51, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: COMMENCING AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF TRACT 3E, FREEDOM SQUARE, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 22, PACE 56, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS or COWER COUNTY, FLORIDA: THENGE N35'39'D4"E FOR 15.00 FEET ALONG THE WESTERLY BOUNDARY OF SAID TRACT 3E: THENCE LEAVING SAID WESTERLY BOUNDARY 554'20'26'E FOR 7.63 FEET, TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF THE PARCEL DESCRIBED HERON: THENCE N3S'39'32'E FOR 10.00 FEET: THENCE 554'2D'28'E FOR 65.00 FEET; THENCE S3516'321,1 FOR 10.00 FEET: THENCE N54•2D'28`W FOR 65.00 FEET. TO 'THE POINT OF BEGRIMING OF THE PARCEL HEREIN DESCRIBED. COMMITTING 650 SQUARE FEET MORE OR LESS. SUBJECT TO EASEMENTS AND RESTRICTIONS OF RECORD. TEMPORARY ' ROW j CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT 1UN i 5 2012 ' DURATION 3 YEARS. Ati , MICHAEL A. WARD PROFESSIONAL LANO SURVEYOR LS# 5301 DATE SIGNED NOT VAUJD WITHOUT THE ORIGINAL SIGNATURE k RAISED EMBOSSED SEAL OF A FLORIDA REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR MC MAPPER. THIS IS NOT A swim. _w aie,-wtUr w..116 Hw1-...r 1t+Rr MOW ryAS... PROJECT: U.6.41/C.R.NI/E.R.961 at RAC SATETCIL AND ALGAL DESGREPTION PARCCL 2 1'CE: TEMPORARY CONETRUCT1ON lASKl[EK! ottroh MM.Waal) 5~l~ �� Man 1010 C9I1AR COUNTY COO�tRQIfT/bo& 01 COOR}T VD!MJ 4fWIW N'"R'r+l'�Awe;,, uN.:+r1 JOB NUMBER 1 REM5ION SECTION TOMNSHP RANCE SCALE DATE DRAWN BY FIE NAME SMELT 000081.00.00 2 1 3 I_ 515 26E' 1' ., 40' I 5/6/12 1 RAK, , SK0,013TCE I 1 Dr 1 ` - Packet Page-1429- -� ` — _ 4/22/2014 16.K 2. IN / / , ' ;+ SC EDULE 11 UNPLJRIED ge 1 of 1 ° 30 SO SOUTHERN MANAGEMENT CORPORATION R OLRI FOLIO NO.T 300 , N.NiNNN yb 1 • LELY RESORT PHASE I, �N35'39'04'E PO 16, PC 87 i 15.00' i 4 S5410'26'E TRACT 16 41I 79.115' SUNTRUST BANK OR 4364, PC 446 FOLI N54'20'281Y O NO. 55425004005 79.85' Ir S35'39•04'W 113FEE *5.00' 1,198 SF PO8 / S.W. CORNER C!3. OF TRACT 16 NNNeN �9r mimic Pr 0411 NNNN / LEGEND /'\ RW . -WAY OR .• OTP ORPICML ML REDOROS WOO PO •MAT ROOK NO.O . MA POB • POINT or T[G1NMNC N. C OR . SURE ROAD FEE SIMPLE MN` MO KNORR AS LEGAL DESCRIPTION - PARCEL 113F£E 'MEREST ■ A PARCEL of LAND LYING IN SECTION 3. TOWNSHIP 51 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST. COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: BEGINNING AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER or TRACT 16, LELY RESORT PHASE 1,AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK IS, PAGE 57, OF THE PUBUC RECORDS Cr COWER COUNTY, FLORIDA. ALSO BEING A POINT ON TOE NORTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OFUS.41; THENCE N5410.2619 FOR 79,55 FEET ALONG SAID NORTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF U.S. 4 t: IN PLAT 143519'04T BOOO22,, PACE 56 F THEPlUBLICG RECORDS Of'COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA; FREEDOM SQUARE,AS RECORDED 'THENCE LEAVING SAID WESTERLY BOUNDARY 554'20'28'E FOR 79.55 FEET; THENCE 535'39'041V FOR 15.00 FEET ALONG THE EASTERLY BOUNDARY OF SAID TRACT 3E, TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF THE PARCEL HEREIN DESCRIBED: CONTAINING 1,198 SQUARE FEET MORE OR LESS. SUBJECT TO EASEMENTS AND RESTRICTIONS OF RECORD. TECM-ROW JUN 152012 MICHAEL k WARD PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYORI LSD 5301 04 SIGHED NOT VALID WITHOUT THE ORIGINAL SIGNATURE & RAISED EMBOSSED SEAL DF A FLORIDA REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL SURVEYOR AND MAPPER. THIS IS NOT A SURVEY, r&am IL,".OUlw.4.r♦,Oyi,liver,6 ar,w..........w.,or g,.,rls rr.Ir■1.6../1INi/a,r OorrirrAIWrior ar. /IC. PBOJBCT: U.9.41/C.R.061/6.B.961 1 .,c 'BSTCS AND ISGAL 1686CRIPIION . I, '; • .arialmnis �. PARCEL 1 L11t�6lS: RIGBT-Op'-WAY • man TSR CONJaR DOOIIIR wn+r.Pwl°Irarr an Mw+a 9oaso 0N7jBOAtD or CO91ITT L'OYRiSBOR rh.rsm4nenowa!lomon JOB NUMBER REVISION SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE SCALE 1 U ogoo111.00.00 i 2 1 3 1 51S 1. 26E 11' . 60' I 6/6112 I R,A.K. I Si{pL T�� 1 s O 1 Packet Page -1430- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. SERVICE LIST ALL PARCELS: Jeffrey L. Hinds, Esquire Jay J. Bartlett, Esquire Bricklemyer Smolker 500 East Kennedy Boulevard Suite 200 Tampa, FL 33602-4825 Primary E-mail: jeffrevh(a smolkerbartlett.com Primary E-mail:!avb aesmolkerbartlett.com Secondary E-mail: kristenf a smolkerbartlett.com Secondary E-mail: betsvb(Q7smolkerbartlett.com Attorney for Collier County Larry H. Ray Collier County Tax Collector 3291 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FL 34112 Lely Community Development District do Gerry Campkin, Chairman 5672 Strand Court, Suite 1 Naples, FL 34110 PARCELS 113FEE and 113TCE Mark P. Buell, Esquire Buell & Elligett, P.A. 3003 West Azeele St., Suite 100 Tampa, Florida 33609 Primary: buell a belawtampa.com Secondary: Mallory(5 belawtampa.com Attorneys for Respondent New Plan Florida Holdings, LLC Fred S. Werdine, Esquire Fowler White Boggs, P.A. 501 East Kennedy Boulevard Suite 1700 Tampa, FL 33602 Email: fwerdine(o fowlerwhite.com Attorney for Bank of America, N.Q. Packet Page-1431- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. Andrew G. Diaz, Esquire Gaylord Merlin Ludovici & Diaz 5001 West Cypress St. Tampa, FL 33607 adiazca gaylordmerlin.com Attorney for Southern Management Corp. d/b/a Burger King Kent L. Hipp, Esquire Gray Robinson, P.A. 301 East Pine Street Suite 1400 Orlando, FL 32802 Primary: khiop(c grav-robinson.com Secondary: nick.dancaescuegray- robinson.corn Secondary: debbie.townsend(7gray- robinson.corn Attorney for Sun Trust Bank Gregory S. Rix, Esquire ,.� S.W. Moore, Esquire Moore Bowman& Rix, P.A. 300 West Platt Street, Suite 100 Tampa, FL 33606 grixembrfirm.com jslwia a mbrfirm.com bmooretcmbrfirm.com ksasset7a.mbrfirm.com Attorney for Commercial Properties Southwest, Inc. Thomas R. Boif. Esquire Greenspoon Marder 200 East Broward Boulevard 15th Floor Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 Primary E-Mail: Thomas.bolf(t cjmlaw.com Secondary E-Mail: chervl.cochran(c gmlaw.com Attorney for Esprop, LLC Marilyn A. Wahe, M.D. P.A., a Fla. professional association c/o Marilyn A. Wahe, as Registered Agent 700 Second Avenue N., Ste 203 Naples, FL 34102 Packet Page -1432- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. Foodpros International, Inc., a Florida corp. d/b/a Sapphire Dry Cleaners do Johnathan C. Fiori, Registered Agent 610 Seventh Street South West Naples, FL 37119 Patricia M. Dillon d/b/a Maneland Barber& Beauty Salon do Patricia M Dillon, Owner 3921 Forest Glen Blvd., #101 Naples, FL 34114 Isaura White 12691 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FL 34112 UT Thi Nguyen d/b/a Lovely Nails do UT Thi Nguyen, Owner 5148 32nd Avenue SW Naples, FL 34113 Celldistributions Corp., a Florida corporation do Diego Grisales, as Registered Agent 26455 Old 41 Road, Suite#12 Bonita Springs, FL 34135 R & J Holdings of Naples, Inc., a Florida corp. d/b/a Jack's Golf Shack do John P. Ftorkowski, as Registered Agent 8994 Mustang Circle Naples, FL 34113 McDonald's Corporation, do Stephen Tabano, Esquire trenam, Kemker Scharf Barkin, Frye O'Neill & Mullis P.A. 101 E. Kennedy Blvd, Ste 2700 Tampa, FL 33602 stabanotc�trenam.com Packet Page-1433- 4/22/2014 16.K.2. y �H r' `Le." 14.4r.4,.., �: '" v. �s; . ��a .44,1'."'t.,:,-:.,: s� ce ' _L a � a i .a k ti; . + '7',1t,"7`1'.1";,'� y f' :� A$ t 'r X F ',a ! ' .z:' ; aF..Jae%f x 4 _ i*' h 't,';'=„'4'''' 4 ,— .A' * �t" §z k r - NY;. s 4s � . . .CL r' x c rv. s'W } �� �C ^, �r y r c , '% y: &'n h '1�� 7 „ ",1 �f a. ;c ems a+..'• :. .. ..4,,,z, -;:--'----::.-s.,„ -,.'..,... .4p ' --1 ikitx..-It. , ..._ - , „.,.. .:. , ., ca rii/ � y Q �R t C" " ~ 4 '4).44-4 _ $r r M_ F Q Y .��A�� nv T'' ,, e'k 1 - ,te :'...-',.:(,:,.,44,,,,:-!t..,// --as'; 3, + €.,�' ti3s + t�, . .mr : d e a �$ rn ,a: I # x Q�'V 4� "# _ - ' , ..,-' "?'".!"„,.-:,,, . ,14.:' y . ,..,...,..„... .,„ - - iiii4:4,.. ., , rte. Packet Page -1434-