Agenda 12/13/2016 Item #16A25 16.A.25
12/13/2016
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing
be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve
Commercial Excavation Permit PL20160001369, to excavate 355,000 cubic yards of material and
remove the material off-site from the Panther Island Mitigation Bank(PIMB)Expansion.
OBJECTIVE: To approve a Commercial Excavation Permit for the excavation of 355,000 cubic yards
of material and to remove the excess material from the Panther Island Mitigation Bank (PIMB)
expansion.
CONSIDERATIONS: The applicant wishes to commence operation of a commercial excavation which
would involve `scraping down' existing farm fields 1' - 3' (355,000 cy), to create wetlands and haul the
excavated materials off-site. The excavation activities will be phased over what is anticipated to be a two
year period of time. The removal of overburden material is a bi-product of the Natural Resource
Protection Area (NRPA). Pursuant to Section 22-110 (b) (2), applications for commercial excavation
permits shall be reviewed by the Environmental Advisory Council for recommendation and approved by
the Board.
The initial PIMB was approved in 1999 to establish an accredited mitigation bank. The property is
owned by the National Audubon Society and multiple agencies participate in this program. It is
anticipated that 355,000 cubic yards of material will be excavated and removed from the site. The off-site
removal of material will not last for more than two years.
PIMB was originally designed to result in 934.67 mitigation credits for the restoration, enhancement,
preservation and perpetual management of the 2,778 acre bank site and was issued a Wetland Mitigation
Bank permit(11-0002-M) in March 1999,from the south Florida Water Management District(SFWMD).
PIMB was approved with seven (7) phases and included: the establishment of freshwater marshes and
pine flatwoods; filling of drainage ditches; removal of cattle and grazing impacts; vegetative restoration
of vehicle trails; re-routing of diverted historic flow-ways; enhancement of wetland hydro-periods,
eradication of exotic clearing of vegetation, management to prevent exotic vegetation invasion and re-
infestation; mechanized and manual heavy brush to allow prescribed burning; and reintroduction of
appropriate fire regimes.
The PIMB Expansion mitigation will likewise be conducted in phases, specifically five (5) phases; 8, 9,
10, 11, and 12 and has been designed to result in 382.39 mitigation credits for the establishment,
restoration, enhancement, preservation, and perpetual management of the approximate 1,692 acre bank
expansion. Exhibit 4 identifies the completed PIMB Phases 1-7 and the proposed PIMB Expansion
phases 8-12.
PIMB is considered to be a viable alternative for compensatory mitigation for impacts to freshwater
herbaceous, shrub,and forested wetlands within the Mitigation Bank Service Area(MSA). No changes to
the previously permitted MSA are proposed under this application for Phases 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12. The
new phases represent the addition of land located contiguous to the existing bank and will increase the
existing bank acreage and expand the bank benefits.
The exact haul route and destination have not yet been determined. The egress from the site is via Carter
Road in Lee County. The applicant has met with the adjacent property owners (Carter Road Residents
Committee) and has coordinated potential impacts with the Lee County Transportation Department. Several
stipulations relating to traffic and hours of operation will be added to the permit.
Packet Pg. 689
16.A.25
12/13/2016
FISCAL IMPACT: The applicant has paid permit review fees totaling $5,673.60. Road Impact Fees
totaling $1,127.55 have been paid based on a traffic trip analysis. Annual monitoring will occur and
additional road impact fees may be required.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) IMPACT: There is no growth management impact
associated with this Executive Summary.
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES: Off-site hauling of excess fill, if done properly, will have no
Environmental impact.The excavation is intended to create enhanced wetland habitat within the property.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The Petitioner is requesting a Commercial Excavation Permit under
Section 22-110 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. The attached staff report and
recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) acting as the Environmental
Advisory Council (EAC) are advisory only and are not binding on you. All testimony given must be under
oath. The Petitioner has the burden to prove that the proposed Commercial Excavation is consistent with all
the criteria set forth below, and you may question the Petitioner, or staff, to satisfy yourself that the
necessary criteria have been satisfied under Section 22-110(d) of the Collier County Code of Laws and
Ordinances. Should you consider denying the Commercial Excavation Permit, to assure that your decision
is not later found to be arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable: the denial must be based upon competent,
substantial evidence that the proposal does not meet one or more of the listed criteria below.
Criteria for Commercial Excavations
(1) The excavation will not interfere with the natural function of any sanitary, storm or drainage system, or
natural flow way, whether public or private, so as to create flooding or public health hazards or jeopardize
the functions of the natural resources and environment of Collier County.
(2) Dust or noise generated by the excavation will not cause a violation of any applicable provisions of this
article. Rock crushing operations or material stockpiles that will be adjacent to any existing residential
area may require separate county approval. It is anticipated that these activities will not occur during this
operation.
(3) The excavation will not adversely affect groundwater levels, water quality, hydro-period, or surface
water flow ways. The County Manager or his designee may require the applicant to monitor the quality of
the water in the excavation and adjacent ground and surface waters. Under no circumstances shall the
excavation be conducted in such a manner as to violate Collier County or applicable State of Florida water
quality standards.
(4) The excavation will be constructed so as to not cause an apparent safety hazard to persons or property.
(5) The excavation does not conflict with the growth management plan or land development regulations
adopted pursuant thereto, nor does it conflict with existing zoning regulations. Special criteria and
approval procedures may be necessary for projects within the Big Cypress Area of critical state concern.
(6) In cases where a wetland is no longer capable of performing environmental functions or providing
environmental values or in cases where it is determined that no reasonable alternative exists other than
disrupting a wetland, certain alterations may be allowed, except as otherwise authorized through
previous county review processes.
(7)Flow of water within and through preserved wetlands shall not be impeded.
Packet Pg. 690
16.A.25
12/13/2016
�"\ (8) Appropriate sediment control devices (hay bales, silt screens, etc.) shall be employed to prevent
sedimentation within the wetland pursuant to the design requirements of Section 10.02.02 of the Land
Development Code. Any building site adjacent to a wetland and elevated by filling, must employ the same
erosion control devices. Fill must be stabilized using sod, seed, or mulch.
This item is approved as to form and legality,and it requires a majority vote for Board approval. -SAS
EAC RECOMMENDATIONS: On November 17, 2016, the CCPC, acting in their role of the EAC,
voted 5-0 to send a recommendation for approval to the Board of County Commissioners (Board), with
stipulations recommended by staff as listed below.
RECOMMENDATIONS: To approve Commercial Excavation Permit PL20160001369, to excavate
355,000 cubic yards of material and remove material off-site from the PIMB Expansion, subject to the
following stipulations:
1. The required Conservation Easement must be recorded prior to issuance of the permit letter.
2. The excavation shall be limited to a bottom elevation of 3.0 feet below grade.
3. Access to the site is through Lee County. There shall be no access to the site through Collier
County without approval of the Board.
4. Dewatering is not allowed.
5. No blasting will be permitted.
6. Vegetation removal permits in accordance with the Land Development Code (LDC) shall be
obtained from the Development Review Division for those phases of the project which require the
removal of vegetation.
7. The petitioner will obtain all necessary Local, State, and Federal permits prior to starting any
excavation.
Additional stipulations related to Lee County:
1. All dump-truck traffic exiting the site will operate between 7:00 AM and 5:00 PM, Monday
through Friday only. There will be no truck traffic on weekends.
2. There will be no truck traffic on Carter Road while school buses are loading children in the
morning or unloading children in the afternoon.
3. Speed limit signs and monitoring devices will be set up along Carter Road to monitor the fifteen
(15) mile per hour speed limit. Any truck found to be violating the movement or speed conditions
will be permanently removed from the project.
4. Certified flagmen will be positioned at the north and south ends of Carter Road to control truck
movement.
5. Trucks entering and exiting signs will be posted on Corkscrew Road, east and west of Carter
Road.
6. Trucks traveling west on Corkscrew Road will exit at Alico Road to access Interstate 75. Any
truck found to be violating this route will be permanently removed from the project.
Prepared by: Matt McLean,P.E.,Director,Development Review Division,Growth Management
Department
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Location Map (PDF)
r'"\ 2.Plans (PDF)
Packet Pg.691
16.A.25
12/13/2016
3. Traffic Impact Statement Potential haul Routes (PDF)
4.Letter to Lee County Transportation (PDF)
5. PANTHER ISLAND EAC Report (PDF)
Packet Pg. 692
16.A.25
12/13/2016
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 16.A.25
Item Summary: This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members.
Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to
approve Commercial Excavation Permit PL20160001369 to excavate 355,000 cubic yards of material and
remove the material off-site from the Panther Island Mitigation Bank(PIMB) Expansion.
Meeting Date: 12/13/2016
Prepared by:
Title: Site Plans Reviewer, Senior—Growth Management Development Review
Name: John Houldsworth
10/27/2016 6:40 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Project Manager, Principal—Growth Management Department
Name: Matthew McLean
10/27/2016 6:40 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Growth Management Department Judy Puig Level 1 Division Reviewer Completed 11/18/2016 11:25 AM
Growth Management Department Matthew McLean Additional Reviewer Completed 11/18/2016 2:26 PM
Growth Management Department Jeanne Marcella Level 2 Division Administrator Completed 11/18/2016 2:50 PM
Growth Management Department James French Additional Reviewer Completed 11/18/2016 6:27 PM
County Attorneys Office Scott Stone Level 2 Attorney Review Completed 11/21/2016 8:20 AM
County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A.Klatzkow Level 3 County Attomey's Office Review Completed 11/21/2016 8:39 AM
Office of Management and Budget Valerie Fleming Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 11/21/2016 9:03 AM
Budget and Management Office Mark Isackson Additional Reviewer Completed 11/21/2016 11:22 AM
County Manager's Office Leo E.Ochs Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 11/28/2016 12:20 PM
Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending 12/13/2016 9:00 AM
Packet Pg.693
16.A.25.a
'SITE MAP
(LIMITS)
Vri3O 1111
o+-a7-v -v
Yoit
a-n-n .n
r O
$-47-rr i7-7-37 111-f7•T c.+-.>-» 1
APR 0.01
tutrJ 09IMAOREM N
a.+w
t�cww!
J( t ACC) ! 47
t6
MITA earn w AeD
POWWP
K.A[rJ
LEE pOUNTY `�
ICOLILIER COUNTY g
its� � W
E
N
N
N
tti
2
C
O
of
U
O
—J
E
U
Packet Pg. 694
S69 '6d laVed e
. `XL; '0' 4 § g n'-',, E ii 1
2 2' s$ w„ 0
9 N c�= c f� a 20; o E Ig 5 i
3 " °w "5 �,� c
uq 2= p t W Nwo. t ' q a g e C zC7
'o II yo 0 o coir w i p 1 1 r 1£ - y6, ''R_op 'GE —
c ow w� s� i,,!oo �t 'V- Z d d� i I a C a
c d! X$ E uui 6� g b'75 EN o
EV E.o ��,6W o '2.o7` 3 eco V E 4 c$ lK gp W7§x a jE
:X W= ° az u W Tel :Y= °D W - - 11 t
�{ Z=sSSiQ a a18
O Q Sr; i Q �ol m No guo Q i g i $ itQ :It;
u�$ a
W� wc°Ansis m z$4LLW z 2 Q�w a w n 1 8 < o
Z
K a�u xa m amnTsa MI§dp°'d m�u�iim �O
Q 1
m3
` -----•,- z-
-. 1
>1<
11 ; . I
N cc ..LN ° i 1
N S� 4 ° i
N z 0 CC c > 1
z
n Z < Z o 1
H- I— Zw ' } a
mf— �_ O e J `n n
0 a`
W O d'O Z.Z co Cl C.J ' m
111O
I- jZ ) o W J4 ¢V
mYOq o
�+ CI P. —
X J "� E g J N ��Z L---.' o o m
2 W C Z J ct— Z Go Wo \\ €hilt_ 1 Vi) 0,a o
': J G co OU a" O o o eye I-_
Q — e
�
Qo Z5 ii
s W z g3i r wei.)
m 0 Q LL
to mom= CL
z. CC Yi
CD W
I--
< pgmmowimEgmmmwimH
ksw =��= ss"zad �.Wpo= p<„� � „,, .a=.`` po> .L.
C1 Q = Th
omwe� E,WW=,,fin ; '1 6 � "w W
2 'aie;;
�'Ul `rgill a; P 'ww' ' v,4 a; omn.ge
W Q - €a g = 8u PAM
d Wa”
0 W m W a �m g
J m co m
e 1 LF
mo o _ d= ������
W �w = gm.—Aoa=5w,aO% } {fi11T+1} }Irl@C..44,1ta _
11•9Z.V.91:' .. ..v. ....., v__–. , .. .. ....- ... ..m_.,, .,_..... __rv,__..e._a,._
969 'fid 1e)ped
i
in r
�" ., ., .. ---,,:,F,•,',--'i4 ",
c ,' .;�us '�� ,r'''ate O_ w F .ate
® 5 z z� N a z¢O z i
� �� 3 es wtxitO -'N v¢ < z zz m5 i
a ' Z z ]Z� \mow w�In E2
W .r ^ �.1',„,,,, F s 1 sp, # 0 .� W Z¢ w w an O Z 2¢Z
� , ` r. 55' Z y, / d�.m . w �� ozm �1.0 zea ¢
dx z z • a w3 vv Nww a�w w
4 I FHH
„, 0‘..1
fiN_: t -, �,^ik? - „PA x ' .p4, r 6
. . . , id
d ?.sre.,� s'[.�-s :.3ea i- 'ilr- . r... .'',- tde,.`. w.'e'.`.- F
n
Z
W.gg
CD
U iC
'fl = #,�ta”" ns '� rt«r' �# a'L, '* ,z :- x r .Wa_'.5�`F #, ' ' ' x h"-°�%r:' N
3 # a"r,"-:-i ° x ,- ,,"7�` +ttir i s-4.'#a `i.,vt fit, " 'ap xf Ni'y 4.,yfivt . •A-Hr: Oz .<
N � �„,4-%.,,,,,k,y. b i-77"''''','4":"C'1.)."';‘','"-'t:of, PJ>` � �Y. g.. �, � .g, r) 4s 1' ' ;� _ � - J <
N �„ gy ,@ ��°' �':,t . t' xr•.,4 aa,- - 'g,4i ¢
j `.. ” i�+ �cr" rr1-�. V. . i t ;erf 'Q`::xW a 4"`0421 n ':I. s"e.`:,- .' . { ..4r,;' ,: ",:+ .;', ;i@ ',`- ZO g
n + 'i.-----.2,4 a ra .. .:'y1� i''''''.:'',!...40.4.,
M 'sL ''. 'tib itIM OO'g P*Cs PP�"P I,YF Pr '&; F
!r f ag 3 r .ef Q; FB POfR Flr7t� f10 P0,94,0 :41:0 514Ks> �� a a
n r �� ,r. ;,. I,B Pe BB BB< ,11'4 �iie fig ,amf (1 1 t,, 11 Btu i,
r., 't' �. "' b � ,. 3e ".,gi Boot r,q,!%PBB ,,plop, �e3P' qr^9'*Pi t,i v{ ''
<: ggy� €
t, e,41
wi e` x e fi . .i {q . 't:e ,0,00 ,0460,0,0 0gr BBi 1pei,eeSt¢ fi. f.-; ' ',,,?,�*a ' P
rG: �, '�' ':«..,�,° ..w �� 9 .sy... �� i�PP F rP�': APS �B s � B4.Ei 4' '°jr i�G tl 'vF�-
cD ':� a fes,; T; ltig Of it OF4 f 11/rt ggP0 E ,i+B Lr'F0%t4ri4 ' - :fgl.
a P,G 41,04f,!,00%4
!P BPB Nrf, �r .: �<:� I
y' �' �_ �-au�t 6. 2/p EP� `��P�� � E � 6d° F�° 8 P �t ��1 ;tIu'
— , o.--,41,4,,.;....",a *: '� �^ # r:..: N- t - ,iB 41, 0�iP•� lo�l' Bir i,�R•eBi "i`r4lop i,._... :' 0;e.
!Tl t ' "+ a�,_, / .. tyw .7 ,r,6 %fr ifiPB B tg 0„, P , d ii r#i f ',..
, " � .rPr pBP ,r �� � � �36I
X n f ` saes a ' r� fy i p. �A 0BB 40e.;.t 4: v '"IL-
�'."'.: .�t: p ".' *� �aua^� - ,i� B. pp � �Pagr:siPE. i,B� �,f; �PP A � F
i6i �FifP4 6BPP� B/r e 56
¢ : ' s'" v .v� 4 ¢.. 7. ar-, , `' ,«r,',ra Y vx,:; 64 BBB 1� fdBi aPF ' Bd,> irr�, 1 i B000100 �+
a+ t �4 ""' '�'2 s FB�����i �NfiI�i,10 �EPid9i ''� g,` �%PP�`��f �o r¢.j : 1
044'114* >r $.: xa k� �z.r� O. vPB `�sBBG�pJ �dy{ bFF�rr+� r6a ��R �C#8 �'AB *. � ;
LlagV
0 L �tY+ :, :';. ::-•-•'. .,''' ' i s- �t _ itt* atet—,,*, . ' .ft4 ii�tIfi.1��,`�pbio0 f6g$,000 B4,0,1cB ,'�+ �, fa
s; t€ pail
Z ,r+ .v-'i ytiRF r�' ,'�. '� 2. - xP�P. Fr fR�6.G4�,r � �i ��J�Brr? �`fa•B .`+,Pe°fi a.. s'.
� N. w ',- •^1...J e P`t "1-1P040'.:0-
Y9! s,4 r �t�[i p irr `6B G��B '
""' Sart.. <r`N '.;.c ?`s`- # "y'..'r l.^ - '�rgA ar#,e''¢�� '' � �r, £as �ERB0,40,4 , T 6NP. 6 ,Prop i1 .r'i
'0
5-'5-. 4148.,- a� a.: O 6 *as� 6i � BFi°��rs �6ffrB � siiPB��
a4.01.0,-....40,
r�O v R fs' /BB R *B� bB rf i!6� ter is FPGr $
r-,:-
k*t.� r "" ' a ar t` B 4 4:1 BG BB rr 0 BSB pPB i „:s p
�_ -.- �;y;p I, 4:: v°"t s. Or t g�,' � 4 rfa$$ flji0 ' rB.OP.41- Pt iaegop a 6
YCD '" E s ,',F;;,440.0,6,910.*.:
at 40. ,9 w`';I atm'c - 7ar r Y, , te:r/0 BEi E BPJ $BBB �1
— x, pp 4rP'pp, t i# Q 4.<iB��BB" Pig' FrPi 4i esF
&.rx' Min*" ;;4445/" �i/lP6BB� 0,4 8 004 P15B B r; ii:V,'4';': �61 ii
ii
t '. ',4 B%� ':-Ar iPP Bira #,0 Bfd R
- +�,.. m W '� .�.� �^`d Part` BPJ' PBB PiB i 'z4' w
CI ;.;:: :-,4,34,14....'C' , a .: ypa B/i Bei 1ifB
:�� ^� <� � 3; 1.tv x is � mac; "i�� 3� �:gg����►TSI' �P BBB �BB /`�BB/ r�/i ,��; v
" ov -. f / / ,t I BPP 4�/%B /BBB'�iBi 'f
.+ xW *" 't:':::::-a,�` ta. a F` 'C.)D tl / t i Bre XPi 6i 3
Apr s ,,, .P,-‹g /i! BB BQ 1 ,/ 0PB� F
t� qtr #a ce yrs y ' a t 3 �� '� � 6 i y/r Be�P
y q�¢ fat. t.nn w� % B �siE "? 4030 P< 1 L,I P .
'�: t�.`K� " '.,� �,� wry ,' � �' Kal(710 / BPB �,�` s,B �P`t°`�4if�i'�: '.
`S . ;',,,,4A.c ! - - �.. / BBB` - t Ja,40 rf�PBi rtk"
s .-;ate • i / iiBptkB * sii6i * ia1ii e.
CO =� ' s1,'s`''�. " t4,3 A.r�4`' .y^`'+«.`" fx / / e' red t1%A B di ¢,�°• .,.SPS
,,,or,,,i,/ .-,1,44, ,oly,*4.4;-:,7:::$04At
yx�/4.: Via, �r R s,.B5 i x el d,1i¢$ 0 4 �:
'15V,itl,,,:,,,',.„1- !t,-::-.Mi.-'1'':1:-:e47,;,t5,7iT, — --. '..1:' / ,
-. r ` s
P � f$ 0_ , ' i / A ,F ` /%jBd49.. t-,- ,. , qmak !� / I�if ;. P
g, ' `.� x '*- " „s i1; rBBiBt firce ^ .
�Y. 4
4, ' / / _ r 044 B aBr ," ° a � - s ` #:+ G:� ,.
k,: 0
.c" #; '' �:� ,� n ate' r a2R'-°.". ti g re
b 3o- :.;
yi- 1.1 -. �' 1*;,,,, "`t-,?f` �� iM �q, 4"--- ,1, y( FF 1 tt.'.F 6
...a. g �4t'a T _f..$%'moi` iii��� i M t ,
•
q'SZ'V'9� ... �v<. _ �.: f,,:,?-."_,-,,,,,,:.. ai
i. w.e:w 5..,..,...w,..eouo.:,.,uu.,: ....w,..o...m,o,m,d..:.-....,„--„,...,---.,.,M,i....,A.:..�..:�..an w.,�o.n.....,Ra.evah..�
L69 '5d 3aMfaad
- " z 4
# ¢ ,, 'Y * z U 1 8 g
/1 -,J ,a 'i.is �: O w r= L..;L LCi F p m H
i ! , -� .44,...4X.,14.:, '�,r ' F Ul Q wK S,inj m z
aY^ www' r :. U Q > O p O O 5
'eat . v a a }WLu Ld mW�.,N oz m F O
Lu Ld cc
} .,`0 '".".',14,', 0 . ash : N ZZ N Wm W< QO< > > O at �,�
a,>sx, ///j g tai).---,, .tt,a9 �P-T a0-.,4 'i tri 0 O E Q 0 0 0 0¢Q -Zap Z > rn p, G L
_ , +,.,W _ uj 0o U>-H QUZ WOQ0c9 Lx Ww W a 0 Et 4!p
Z 467;d44446� a .. 2@@ ,a W a
w ��' 4 � d, 6 J ZQ L=..'b.; A ozg U�d� =w o� d cac r
Y 3 K, � " S a�� 3" , :: Z Z u i v'W t W d o ~ c F-H z—�� I
""'*::*;*;,°
."A2, CS+3 :94 �t, N 1— J Z!D >i N _F—�.O Z Z Q ~
, �. alp "{• xw OOaO W XQ -JQ QQ Z Z =Q
c'.F° S ?+ W� UUv (nWW JM.¢i�dm J� WOV Z�
art � Q gym" x Pf��it, 1;-771 ___ JJ 03z� •t ni�a a
3
•
# Y ' . o ro
IT;...-1
n r s,, .,s.........,— a� `' °. - l s�u.ssv r. € w
0 U-0 ot>
cc Q w n Z
o z
0-
CD
LT
F ,• o r �i
z =s
Lu
ao,-�awx Z
,, aY b\0 0 N
w F �a �a Q > w U o �
J oQ z0 ZZ C.�� W m F>
6 41 < z JFza�W dd21N OHM :DNINOZ o0 Zz F a� 22�222
Q <>,0Z
N= O O Q Z Q
N p F N m W m J 2 N= Z W O U
VLri w U ' wa>a a z
o__J Lri
" m w z+ i Po 0// / ///' /// 4%41$i40 /0/ //
o n z N z 14 0,040/0001001$011/00,00 / '�0' �
0 < Z `,, O/,/ %II,,.� o .L iff
o< ; ,/ /�S �,IlO,,.,�i ,� �/I //�� cr
U {
O w �� I/ ea6��l/0��I//�;�•3W II///I 1 Al N O O Z ,r ;Hindi
Si)• z a o l�� iI/,/ �/// I� r� 4 41 �,, / ¢ s
/I/ ///
W z W ti I /`,I/JI o Z// p /� /Z Z a o a 0 ii.€:
X !// , c / , /' A, _
n w w Z E 1100400010,46t
��/ 00:11,0041�� y/II/L/(( / �� r�l <v z rn z w w CO 5
m__ z mw a o // I/� /%/ � h R / /�i/ �I/ I 3 o Z LL") w 3�to
�' I // J/� N/. // I x cn <—w Z. z
a W QIJ��II /��III ,t ��/I J W L,<_,„, =U— >
o w Z 0111/00100001$74V400041
J// //4 I//JC " I /41- / 6
U m O%% IP /�/.I//�/ y%q y /�i-, a II/ r a o U 0 z w a
( I �Jr� ,� a 0- w -
V!n /// w'// �!�: //a r W U z
0 o? g a fg Ie0%i''/I�`�',,, i0/I:')'/ /. •• 'ION Ai z ce o<a z r-d-3 m a
p J U „es r/L��///II / °�I//%�� I I� i 0 w z Q K- p OJ O a.2_
13 o z f/ �//,�11 /,/ // J do - /
04 A
n r-avo/pooripe
/// /o/ r'// '!///o ! I: ,e N n¢owo a =w� / I / h// // ..'� // w w wolpOr tiwzo0 0. v)
3 sg7 410,0010,114,00144,4 .'
7 iJj$
ciZQty 4/ � ,/Spole/ ir/el % Q Q W w 0'-0`-'j o ai 3$
i4!i, I chj
00 G1E wz w0
=Q QOP41 .0 0Or - � m aA U t- UOgQ FdZ in w
S Ncwno ,iii, _ z, / z zw�~_� woQzw d
�/j'.: 0 o,wU UUUaw
__,
�,� .:JF ar O�U U�Z W JNZ W IW—
Oce w00 wQ OU <
CD
w
? I1 • N oad UwDa
v /� Z inv,mMo 3incnMw
/7 / / /r /
l9 C 40•11
/i // 1 or
a00 l '()<t:t 'id, ,srpipi ,4, off ti 0 z
PrrPOS
A.
r -; 10/ I/y I//, m Q Q Zm-<1., fi
®zaz�n� NzHo�z QW
} CC
owc��w < zm a c�oWwo 0
FZ F��n 1.......
a ¢ a N�nz?min • Z $
�� j jV UwF-ZZZ z wo Z QZ
U O >�,Zj�$N Ja 0 ZF 0 .L
2 WWW WwJ= z�'m = �CQ7 I "� ''''''''.1.•
W�
IX -wF fj w� N
id U Roam WRQ z z a Wct
gp
G'9Z'V'9� N a ��,, ,dddlll �o-�,.<........ �.m a � . «, � ,..n ,...,e�.... _®,,..�a,«.a. � 4,..,,�dG
869 '6d W)Ped
e
ir
"E
P
El
;.-
z 2
=1 _
O
U
a
i t
__ 1
R¢
i
B
I
N
X11
n 1 �y
c3 5
Z Vi 1.
co
rt r$s
13
11 g 11
E 29
N iO
El
1 6
M1 0
1
co C� 0
n 9' 0
ET a e
0 0
0
m 90 y
K
n
K es
cr) \ \
''
�.
M
or,
rt
m I �i 33
F, ;s _ y
1 P.: ear�r ��' . . - 9 kCE
FP- 6i
ryi 2 )'74. ,1 S
i
DI i iia) 1 4,r i-.010111111
.
O i : )
CO
IS';' \
°-' "2 II T . . lel,„„„. .N7444%.4: 74111
''''' '''11 - • •=6 %-.co -,-,,, ''',,; ',,,, ". ) '\44.-410 - ';°'-. ' ' .
(Plii—:- 2 4
.,)Ni 1
1 i g
q'SZ'`d'9 6'
0 I • ^ Z Y 'J
669 '6d19)10ed 1.
zIx z 0 w vi.c.'-' o io;XW1_W��mN m
II I I a WW 0 U= J r U Z NpzP Nr Jr ZO REM' ! b
W om .3 5,.u-H-. cri J� ow 3¢ z • �' O oQ2 r3 w aQ�o¢oo= '^
:��QJ W N W O ow Z F 24p.E mFw-2y p
<t) �_ a� •vrz oZ,zcrcwiw(4e� W aW c awNY_<aozw„'¢ozm7m III
0 o'—ot 3i6-,..vr'vri y ,`: aL.aiiOwZn= 0_,0.. zO w -o WN58+Zw�Y=�rawaZ5d 5^i
N ... wrr 'k-'c6 Et—z a o �ommrarm mo¢ JmNW .
ish I/Ir - wr o W �Z roar w'' c wU
za z w-L..w,nw
0 0 w� /;' ww}E,w0R'0¢ ¢ UI mF" zcg= waYF ,zomm PI J N ... '. JKJW SZ¢r�r p U xOm mW aWm4a�Vl-
' 0 —0 m3 e.: IZWaN-.'iU}ZW 1- z• F.c/ 2 2zzNUmO>-wI71 ,„Sw JwmN •P,
Oa ¢ ,” ¢ L,.?.iHW WN d JWW WZ JW U ON SFwO F ¢CZzmmZr�=LPIW p a
u —o 3w - I- :. 'l z3 aom J (7:-
z ,+'a° m--m YaW W,nz o& 1-
n� aYNwN owngwo�az�l QW 2. ?— a ao°o o o2,,ii-ow'a oo-cram IW
a,-.J mOro a p-iL,' FFJwaO � � w � ¢ 'n N s zoa
0,:3 �r N¢z rZZ a 8003w� UZ m— f O m m Ww mvi-, U frit,,. wmm
I NN....m W� L.1 r ¢ Q r 0!` ,'w OmO (/lozf/IroJw-Zrrw a
nU >d z =U¢Z aOC.� pJ OQ c� mai`=zw'�'" ioa�cwp.N�mw m� w E
oaowm° 'ow f wJNwz¢wzZ<ZNo~m°,rllm v a1',Tni l:IgiW=6;g11im!wog ¢a €
� 1 I I I� ; N r.x- �a wJwJ> ¢ awm�w a sew VI Y�omz. aWp
o a �a�� v_,aa��w U.,LoiEox i,ia -,o ta-4g-§m=2.z.<R�mro.<a gR 6,
0 M C'h a = m''w>'°=wow U 0 Ua R¢So amcowFWwwzma Nz
rinm�aOf7NKNf~ m'.-2W'F-- mOrUmY 2 zmr m0� W Sa
r vi r � o�- Qa— aJza �Uz mwo waY„ wmdW rscwi�
f-- o- Jf- !wok o �w:orm zaoJiazo yz
\ a r a z J N� am mmOYmwao�aaw"mswaaaNuFiawag
SL-c.-
\ . Et
w¢ m ��-"ammw za wommm�s wwm w za
\ -v-----..
O- amr Q Oa w¢ mmO Owaz ¢z0 U
Y ar= o� ,04;•:.-`1',a Q z Nmo m m zo>�uo�omwo��m�^°��'�a^� 6 i
¢ , Ea !> t!
\ � � a==aQ�z �urzIX
\� < ¢i e .,„ u..1. f W�vj -Akigoo 1=W J !Iv(
n aJ\ _ , Lia ,� •• I H wz mz=fn aim
'c'31m r UX ).:\i':.5 w 1:; NU o 1 JQi- mo aao,r„ a -1 h
^ \ w \ m= �'/.e W I Z �at,,J wd2 2 -W •a < Z 4' Q K 2 �a y \ mw :: \ Q aN �c.�yLL_Z m �o z ?.. \o? o� ,
I z m Q z Q --- - r-Zi O_1z WL a clm w clic m ao g ii ,
U x `� \ Q wU > W m Z F'¢m u}zo� F�wo Wm
Sv z \ Iy •r •.., J m '..:4i0,,,,
}°". O �Q ��ozW o'"m m�fn <�
Dw W=Q • :Z �a '' W W Zm _ � Z= J ZQD FO Naa Po
WO m U'i
N r \ .,Jrm a f ��S U�.�r Q Q p N �warwo� �$ z z o f
amr •01 F- �$ Q NN MO-IJ J .}a m Z 4Izz mza �- m 2n
_ -W '-op u4) Z: W WJ-w Z mg a
x \ e� O a J �� n W wQ4QmmaF^ oYm¢ yo ¢
N r \ v,v.; \ N �.' ''•, mc;4 tfi w W oEWmJ u Waw3o E
N w ` 0W \ \ r \ b ••z k,--,4 --- - W U aJgowa mxc! 0.
�I < \ \ oQ . VU o ���• (x<,,,,.. QZ 0-nNc�w 3 ¢ �oamw �om z �j
IV < \ wm \ �^' RozN W 03E1) i;Iff cc a J�m=w a2zwa w'Lr'''Q�' wiz F Z
z\ ow \ H�WW z W m Q a„N� -<!-5.1 ]...,..5 mw0;/
0 W \ 3 _ \ Z�.m mi x� o c '000Q=z= c°� W aWo€
I- \ aom < r W W m� o N m F i
not r� aom I Np�m �0' Z c<�rYWz °zz� wo
I row, OQa dm=-clw u wc� mzr .'1:'t„v
' � ?o=z m Ja W z:;awJ�o ,aro czg =te c�tt
Z >� Ox�O L U oowoa¢a mxdw w3 ;`5
a N2a m ZFU as a�az a''''‹ -; [inti
n Y U T c=,
a ; {iEIfEtE
VI ,..>..
20~ Q Z Z r sr.-. J x F-o W
Wim w F w z o w o wr JZmw�m m Old
it— ¢ Oa Z d w 2Q O wJ ¢NLa wJ W JZaaZWW o /45 N1
M amylw0 O D 2U D J aAa.00L„ rra-UJWN o �
X ` ,O Oc 'dm U Fw zJ Om < .L.0 r0ZK¢WUa}am?z Cis!` ` Z UNOwW�� aW tl1 wmO WrO mOW frrla0,¢igdw<actaam W1-z> Cis!g
a1-�` �',o,odo�o^z p..wPzW a. Nzr o0 o NoarwwJ W= 4
U ,,rw op m o u) LLQ1,-,-w oaz m o 0o m a a, .1•i ll
• ,_J Sw W2Z=waOU W UY�,,2 Ufn w -mNNWN.-N WO co ��//���
/L' WVLLi,,pO,n m'n W aUOWaW >a IIJ= 1-ma Ox--'N N WZNS z0_z •'7'
I N. r°.Zoo `P z2 w z N 1 c� za car II m rrr o.zw.0 a.. :Fr w
0 1 !� '�y U w°� OF�Om S"m a F ZF Sa ono Ka_ p mtr,a 0 as Ja Wa'� N=o c ® ,
!t ' Om0 O a Q m¢ 'Y„wY 51-w,9, vW a o0ow W WZ Wa0 >cl U�,
�, ' ,l-f -
ww �m oao� ofri�. U .i� mrj...wUmmmmomNWOm }N
\�'li' ' 'Z OarrFzw mZnY�wW,r^wwao', y ^ OU ( p0
Tol t ' OwU OQa m3 ma Ui Z2r10m JF YV 181-11-(/
Wu. Z
CD
` ' '(� a za ¢ i �m -awz°wo', T3 ozmr� aY
I OK 7,,EgE l-W� r UW 0ZQg pp a
3i' W woo Faw�¢V�aao a�szam `. VY,LC �w !� IiI\z
\' ' '0f 4mU xF a ",,,foto zaoEsrr. • U'a... -,1 F. U'1}^ N m (/')
' \\'\ '=°Qgwgj=z 000000�EEa2,www'. Pi aa¢ I , _Wz !
41 ``\ oor Oao oz'`au da yo rc>a, XN ¢ d , , g�J
, 'Q\,.. ,<C4). -U0 Z W W OZ
.�+ _« aJwaowm W�¢mmmmmaomr-�� ' W p^� CI 'I �_ �' _
oJfnmo oos s�xz m
mma roam o= yU2"7 , O O z. m m --.....1.6.---=r•—•• Q' 4
Unayozm>mwUz w zzzsw 0 . 0 0. m K Q �; gg
co cc zzo =xwaamc�m
(L') •
./-aU1-om^m� •�,o_.,c.)ovv,,. ...1-
'n
N�r- j W m
` •nj • ri•` Naw = /- J z K x 66
V t 1• \•` Z Z J _ Y m Fa- FC3—
=
= D \\'\1 h °.n I. Lua0v) a p f
t'', \` 4 a- ••SL of -L cr
m
1 .2!, rNw aow ao 0Mv R
o 1.0 ao - NzmU�xoN I-- s`i
Xy� a N w mocem¢o�Qm
��t � 'W ' Z O w J
O ( - 0 i, w zw�V)i E
„,,„_,_,,,,..... :.:.,. ... ,
r m03 1f ;; oCi e Y Z0CG
amara \ \\ m
I ':."3.‘,,/r1
,11, a OJ NW\ m� \ Q r :`� O. 1-
''...,.
rao a \ m 0m
t >� o Eo
W \ J■ Vr , m0
J_W •` UU Z \\ \ - \ <N'K t Ill Www— \ V a \ W W
/� • Q.• F,.'II NI-r \ m0 \ J ZN•
� WUe ate : \� Q -z���, O ' - Qr N:
w
o
IIPPIL
UhLif'� r I. �� a �\ W U
n O Q O (I..r[ �i \�- W \s\ \\ \; wNw e. \ D° O
..
h
a \\ \ aax El
xaHFm \\ ri,? O < M. 4
'1°- 3 U a v•. E
00L 'Bd 49)PUd ,
Z W J O J 0
0 Z J O W W H• J I.
O Z Z LU o
OW 1-wZw
(12
WWm Mw
¢=x 1-aiii
ok w-iz Ow z=?o QaW m> a-w w y �d
O Q p m m Wal- 2 ini
mO� O 0 � zfr- �0 6,0<zwwwa1 azf w<< =W0 a
0 1-Z¢ wzo ¢m zw JO --= w- wa =¢m >a¢ 1-SW M
N map w�wl- aZJf/J Qm Om maJmYZz�V ~Y= OZZ W OJ z _ri �\
W O=Z U' �g zJ W}SWy2O= wm Imo m~Q a
m 0.m Z<< -0020-5- <J w21 -aa� p0! W-GH w�> a
w C 0 O Z O U' w w g H U OL-OW
Q'm=m O tm� wm W w a J Q m a w .00 w f
W map z¢waJZO �= tLLi� =1=-��~zddW ��5 amj ZUQ w
Zms W OKQ 21-X-=QmOZr-N W ww pmaLL7lH W mU J . WCL W z> <
w5; OZJ Qaw=zZZ1-ww< LLUZ 2Qpz2OOUW`LpWU p�& woo Qu. Otap >
O r r
Zwm ~mx Z�mZa<a Few oVoi a1r¢-a�o JE w Oma �psJ Ogmm
Oww m0 W zoa2OmF-wfdpm ZZ 4c .-00zz0<z -ow ti m W¢mam m xgww0 - pz5 JUU W
2ZW mZO}F ogww Fy,0zww 2m0 Wmil WwU~aQm2S QZW mo, map mtAWW . @
OU z >m WWmJmOWO>W}= amw La~-W¢paUWa �W= >.�� �yp�< a 1
0U' K F-=p W Wow s2l-Z1-wZF p¢m ¢Z W LLZ�'JpZaz_ Zm mmZ r_w2¢ 4 F
mZO UZmm =Q>>r-Q =<Z UJa 20JQQ2mZmH p .= Jm- �-SH aW
D Qz2 U' wpwZ LLZ H 0 mZ W jQ}ZZZQOw W QOZ Qw Q W 50 /till
* OOW 0WO= zWWWONW>WLLO>V FO~ WOwW-OOWW2O wO‹ wpm wwWw � : g�
D'7)
Ups ULL,O pmmw,L2,pm ww QQZ 2wmHA2m=w 7Z HCmw I=-OQ 1-ow
PI€`€
R w O w- U a Z m O m>W m J z O a a o¢J a w y m¢w W p 51- O 0.0
3 o 2 x Z w 0 W=O w W w m O m O S W O m z w>x W W 0$f 0I< _ma Z m Zz
al-1- -¢>E N-r-UmmaaOaO mr-0 Q¢xz rm2U a :-.-00> Nam mac.¢ Z '"
CD U 11 13 0
1
Zw-
OrZwUS�m= wY
03
�
q = F- m
- WJU wQ2 0
ZQ ¢• Zr.
Zw
ZOmOf- O
w
JQ LOW ZW
wgZw x
>ma0w >- UO ow- 0
N O wJmOZZOWizpw ~ w
p¢LLOOnOoWWm
=_1=z0
2rz mON I-Z= "Iig
zi-
ww Ci
/V aWQWaUwwaWaw ¢ p � OoLLzdwUY > OW
N O�w wJ• am- } JV
LL w ammWQmO Zw FOZ • o
Ii
V'J = OwwmJJp5 ~0 QF.pQm -ZpmQ m ? mJp
JSZ5
-Jw ZzO ~ P 1wmJO
2aW5L Z a()Zf- m ¢pm
QzLLa a0UpZm U5WSm mmmWSWel
-
mW0 zZm0 h NW
3 W ~ = WWmO¢ pS OLLzwmWm O a pmUU J2WW!-mJHWW=ZOW Z0wmZ1a -W O ¢VO xm�y mWWpm WmF
wQW ma OmS_zO5z H I- Qc= LLZ 4.114i1
USVWWw OZZZm ¢ ¢¢O zazm O O} E0 ZOWm ZmQI-p O m = Q LLwo -
n } WQ �¢ pOxp�OC2 >Q � w !€�Eii
ZOW� o �i6t!€cn OUzwa
wmQ > =F ...-LL*,
X=<
2� w, z1> � z $azwiow , iWzmr-0m ,„,„, WEOKLLgpNOJ} £
QJQ W ¢mww °UamuoOaW maW¢QmwpJam t- =O Uzam i:B
> Ww=mHwWJQUyymw1- HLL=> _ U Oa K Ummawr-1- . ¢WWpW
_ 70mmz ZLLZ w Z a~Oil
fn 2 wowQO2 m C .JCmZJHmUmFOg 7
W¢WJSSW Q-0z1gLLOQm = 4
t= LLZWOopWU FWa.-I-oz mUz aQ Mil;m=>VO mNpUWaOQa a6¢ wQ w5Uz Q,F a OG mWUwWn aUm0 >OEz m
� OwSpW WI- mWm
'^
ZwwU o ip www. mSVam TQom H>0. a m -UmmFW - JpZ Z �a2�wm ¢roaU==_lWOZFzC WZ'
O zw= pm oz � IipZw0WW w Z
wl_
ow =cc
3 wzQomwW=JQw>wppwO< Oar2--I-I-U Omamww ¢O=y1-w mzwo OMMI-
O ?5 V O Sw m W W a w<<-Q Z F 1-rri ma O Z w O p a�z m w w a z>o > z w r2--- Z m=~
U w a H S'¢03 00 a uW o-X 0 C)W>zO a z LL~"p W fj I-Z m 1-,00‹,
Z I w 2 Ip p�IJJ O OU >w o0 Z O¢
"'� 2QwW am=dUmOwwLLNW, CHS W¢OO O�W 2r=„Sm ZmOSmW m2OZa 1¢_C72U
Wmpmp�=QHr}a-QKwmQZZZ mFpZUmO H W=Y��p O�F� >01- U�I-WO Wm mZF-Z
wm
_ �z w~O W p twi p -Z m S 060=oww m Wm W�m O y o 3 m W W� Q w¢m¢W p w z w F-> w 2??
pmLL Z
2 O w w W w w a >Q Q Z O m m p op >¢O a>Z m=w O= Z m ¢W w �e i
z MFW�wwWOw�O=z�Cw70m� w5i�cnFwa yZLLULLC�O a=W>5z U-0 LUw wOOm � 3�
N m O W Z w w Q J¢Q w z O>Q?Z a m m O z a c9 m i-0 a m>Z t LL m O W> m -1-0'r-z w z Q m SS$
61 mw-020-0-0 JFwwO~aI W rU---a' a2OU�CZ a W?wgwU m W r-.9dm LLI=-W U== a Zwm ...*
O W O1ww>aar-cCm_W0002 mwz ¢m Uz2¢wzw LZ0Oz �¢zwr-F ?caw =
�- - Q,-w01=-=2¢(02><<W>WW Nii<WOwm <X201--Na maE2wc0 (,557_55 mi->a 9•
* is
f0
W
rr
0 xap m mz
w ¢a z
H p
CD Q W zo > �~ mO QI-
W c"zPm cay
¢z W =U w W
= WOan af/)w U�O ~J w0
V >ZUm ¢Oa w¢a pQ am H
O>a m 0.17 2 p O = Yaw w
aWCLW0Z U) Owa c7�� ¢2CC2 Z
a,-.¢zz_cp, mJm ZZO mi-Wm 0
a0 -- Q_m r-a- =U1- zwwz H
iliH p w C--i w w w?Z p W I-W a z Q
z>c?OpaoW w zW a 4! 0Fw� J
wmw4m_Or=-� Om J cc EOW22 cca
`wWU•-am2NZ IZ W Li ZrnOU I--U 2a2rn ¢
a y Z O-m W U G Z$ O a w- m O 2 zzw ¢01~¢ U-'
zm UZHZa 2 m"' 0 UWmz OCH U' J J CO
w Zp j7_UW' W g U? z> azmm waQ llim2aI- O
wz¢ >Q WLi >m 0m_w yr- m m�
ww
>.<2=<=z_,2
d=I-aa w mm mp U (p0 02w2= W z W •F-wco ti W U' ooz r-0 m .
w O a w p z-zoz
z W a U Z>o O U U V m <0<0 =Q Z J y W @
m Z.rZ C7Q U' OOm J FEE01< = s 1
aW¢i_¢z ,2z m2 rztjm z^�z 2z mJWOJ 1-a0x¢ m
_x_ =LLQ a¢ j °"-§° m wp O¢gO mwmmw w
zowwoamOog aow Z°mom _ioU-Z oo�� ozom'm LLr=w�a z
OZ¢avz =w 0mcoo}O mwz2 2~mm ZF<U SOLWZ m
m0OQm,`?OQcla<w 2 WmW zm hamOm Omr-m ¢mUO m=mz W W &
W o m m m¢o w-O m
moRoNc9ryma¢ -a~mow OO>>> �amoi �w Ja cWnprwi�m< m
¢Owrn-¢IOG LIJIOI-w6 2CNwa z -.ww 0== LU LZQ
Q'SZ'd9G `U`LO2c 1-U2 O1-1-maz I-zNz2 a.- -a c-Ccnr- a.-awl ni ¢
16.A.25.c
Y '
co
C �
m
Panther Island Mitigation Bank (PIMB)
Expansion a
Excavation Permit Application:
20160001369 -0
ca
Truck Traffic Impact Assessment Ti)
as
m
05
Prepared for: o
National Audubon Society, Inc.
225 Varick St FL 7
New York, NY 10014-4396 w
0
a,
E
Prepared by: o
Stantec Consulting Services Incorporated
Wilson Professional Center ti
3200 Bailey Lane, Suite 200 N
Naples, Florida 34105
a>
0
June 1, 2016
August 8, 2016 (Updated Attachments) 6'
a.
.iI
r�r
co
cn
D.
Dusan wiM COI-Munity in mind
a>
0
CO
w
Packet Pg.701
16.A.25.c
Panther Island Mitigation Bank (PIMB) Expansion
Excavation Permit Application: 20160001369 0
Truck Traffic Distribution Methodology
Pursuant to the pre-application held on April 14, 2016 with Collier County staff, and on N
L
behalf of the applicant (The National Audubon Society, Inc.), we have generated an
traffic distribution analysis or a "cone of influence study" in support for the commercial
excavation permit application for the project.
The estimate of truck traffic related to the PIMB Expansion project has been estimated a
at 104 trip ends per day (52 entering and 52 exiting) based upon a the removal of 0
approximately 352,360 cubic yards of excess fill material, use of 18-cubic yard truck
capacity, to be removed 5 days a week over an 18-month period.
w
Since the destination of the fill is not immediately known, and in fact is likely to
vary/change over the 18-month period, the distribution was created based upon a set E
of assumptions in order to evaluate which Collier County roadways might be impacted
0
by the movement of fill in the even that it is delivered to sites within Collier County. �?
As referenced in Attachments A and B, the initial distribution assumes 60% of the trucks N
will move to/from the west along Corkscrew Road toward 1-75, and the remaining 40%
to/from the east along Corkscrew Road to SR-82. Upon reaching an intersecting
arterial/collector roadway, professional judgement was used to divert some reasonable
percentage of remaining traffic to the intersecting route(s). This process continued until
resulting volumes were assumed to fall below 10% of the daily total of trip ends as
directed by Collier County Transportation Reviewers. Since this traffic can enter Collier
County's road network from two different directions (1-75 and SR-29), the scenario 0
a.
depicted assumes 40% of the daily total of 2-way truck trips will reach Collier County.
a)
E
Truck Traffic Impact Assessment
Based upon the assumptions used in the analysis, the attached graphic identifies the
percentage of traffic assigned to each road segment, and depicts the roadways that
could be impacted by daily truck 2-way volumes at four thresholds:
• <10% of the daily 2-way truck trips
• 10-19% of the daily 2-way truck trips
• 20-39% of the daily 2-way truck trips iv
• 40-60% of the daily 2-way truck trips
cis
Packet Pg.702
16.A.25.c
Since the County's maintenance responsibility extends only to the condition of County
roads (and not the roads on the State Highway Systems), in this example the only Y
County Road segments impacted by more than 10% of the total 2-way daily number of m
truck trips are:
O
• Corkscrew Road from the Lee County Line to SR-82-42 2-way truck trips per day
• Immokalee Road between 1-75 and Collier Blvd- 10 2-way truck trips per day
• Immokalee Road from SR-29 to Camp Keais Road- 16 2-way truck trips per day
• Camp Keais road from Immokalee Road to Oil Well Road - 10 2-way truck trips
per day
co
a
Encls: Attachments A and B
a
O
(13
L!J
tv
G)
N
ti
N
N
N
d
Y
O
ca
a
''^
VJ
f4
U
111
L
QCT
f4
Packet Pg.703
16.A.25.c
ATTACHMENT A
25% 26 10% 10 r 10% 10
5% 5 --., V Lee County � . f
Corkscrew Rd 30% 31 � c
'. �'', „ „� �, 40% 42 20% 21 OD
�_,, `°` 60% 62 SR29 o
l .5% 5 R
- 55% 57
litet i,--.' 2/'05%%
Z�
15% 16 ).
Collier County ,5% 5 =
/ 25% 26 Immokalee Rd y
5% 5 -..,_ ,;/ r
t
c
Bonita Beach Rd • 1 10% 10 d
20%21
... 1O% 10 , 5% 5 ..
.� ,r li
c
Immokalee Rd Oil Well Rd O
,
Immokalee Rd
ea
IIIU
X
Golden Gate Blvd W
la
U
Pine Ridge Rd 10% 10 m
5% 5 11111P
E
5% 5 U^
N
All Trips are 2-Way Daily Totals In
m
r 40-60% o
20-39%
10-19% S
ca
<10% t
Ta
Y
a)
O
n
.I.
a)
.1�J
0)
co
.FJ
N
dd
r..)
ra
D.
E
C.)
:f3
L
r_
N
E
C.)
co
Q
Packet Pg. 704
16.A.25.c
ATTACHMENT B
LL n
5% 5 g Lee County r,
' ''. GorkscrewRd �: 30% 31 - c
:t ti Vti z fib+ i---;;-: • _
60% 62 5R29 � x c
.�,+ 1 ' star p
mw R. t,„,,,,-1 ,-;-.0-4.c- --_,--;�a
AK7. �. .. ..'' . .. �,., .bt _ , .......,--..,),-:--,1-„,i,.,
*tom" �.+
s1 i�
U ' 55% 57 ter , ' -
M i r ti 41 —•
Collier
County
,' 25% 26 t .LmriuokaleeRd' N
Bonita Beach - d
s �'��-�
' 7. 1fl55 S1- 5,1% Y
r,
a
lmmokalee Rd �-' „%-i'f•7'.: ;*;..Z.-*.:7...-r.'1.-... ..;L'^-.' .
xn — r ,,,,,,,__ .1 I Oil WellRd r 7 -e O
lramokalee Rd .1 ' 1 �, e _ ; c>
.,x
{ Golden Gate B{v • W
'Ns:-...,;-',---:.,'--..--',---...-:"- } z ,
Pine Ridge Rd M',; ■! ' 0°�°1Ck r `c d
5% 5 } E
....a... a•..z •
-oc 1 .x. -c-.
iil • "".ar^ �""`;
Al Trips are 2-Way Daily Tota " 1 " x k- N
r"�'F 40-60%0: I_' ,.i r.,-.;� =
II
1 _.�° -.0.:39%::_, o
i,.,k ;� , 10-1990 .-` ,*-7./..4.3...,.::„.'air 3 ` _� R
sus t :.. ' _ Y4-4-,-r-':-'-.#4-4,-, .-:-....-.. .....--..--.-4-:;E;-.;_.:omc
�t,`w tea"•.... Gq, �' 1.--44—'7-..----'74144—,,z--=,------ -,-9.-"-,
^^", Ems„s i..' ,.,,a..z :• N
� ro• w^
ter '` a QJ
'r s ..' ar •/ e ,... ate.:. � 't C.)
;,r
f/.4 �;`" '�,> � v I ' 4: .._7.--V " . rte c..a^a....
' �/t ,r �iCgv}} anti�' ef i^` ,GW'`"' • �. -..t, r
sir
k
34_,,§vitt.444:, „.,„....,,:_.,.._,,._,.,, ....7._ ..,,,_
�t w 7� 5 � i .a ��
4 `„` Ott V.
�/ y. w�- f 4.�= l t.,: ,. ,w ''. ` aa.«,' x �'_•� i
,'„ ,y ' e€`,. #'▪fit r z (Sj
.........
,;.•...;.4.:."0.•
,& <'k.+�i G a.,x�a. my ' r'&n as,:•�.`" • per "�* ++
67
,,,.._,,./."'"'"'�. O„4 x %�L � y +4' 'fiy: err s,- '+# "31,y"'",
'fie '''. • , I A.?` i
II''''''I.7
if.tr. _mss �i`P+: #,-4"--,-71-#„?.."
R ,} .......:-.,°,,,,,,,,,,,,,-'kv �' `?`;�<^
Packet Pg.705
16.A.25.d
10097 Cleary Blvd. Suite 300
61. Plantation, FL 33324
Panther " ). Island 'I'clephone954.642.2427
M I -�i G .1 V_N -BANK Fax 866.433.4057 •
m
0
is
a
July 12,2016
Mr.Randy Cerchie
cc
Lee County Department of Transportation
1500 Monroe Street
Fort Myers,FL 33901
ra
Re: Panther Island Mitigation Bank d
E
Dear Mr. Cerchie,
d
Pursuant to our meeting on May 25'2016,this letter is to confirm the steps we have agreed to undertake to minimize any
inconvenience to the residents that reside along Cater Road as a result of our proposed temporary fill removal operation. co
co
On April 27, 2016,our team met with the Carter Road Resident Committee to discuss our proposed temporary fill removal
operation and to listen to the resident concerns and work to mitigate those concerns.As a result of that meeting,the
Ta"
following mitigation efforts were agreed to with the Resident Committee: L
1. The fill removal operation will occur Monday through Friday from sunrise to 5pm,no weekend removal will be
E
permitted. C.
U
2. There will be no truck movement on Carter Road while school buses are loading in the morning and unloading in ti
the afternoon.
3. Speed limit signs and monitoring devices will be set up along Carter Road to monitor the fifteen(15)mile per
hour speed limit.Any truck found to be violating the movement or speed conditions will be permanently removed as
from the project.
4. Certified Flagmen will be positioned at the North and South ends of Carter Road to control truck movement.
5. Truck entering and leaving signs will be installed on Corkscrew Road,east and west of Carter Road.
6. Trucks traveling west on Corkscrew Road will exit at Alico Road to access Interstate 75.Any truck found to be (j
violating this route will be permanently removed from the project.
J
Lastly,enclosed herewith please find the Title Policies and the Title Company opinion regarding our legal right of access o
to Carter Road. m
al
Thank you for taking the time to meet with our team and should you have any questions or need additional information,
please let me know.
Sincerely, ca
Robert B.Miller
Packet Pg.706
16.A.25.e
CoLe
Growth Management Department
Development Review Division
STAFF REPORT
TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION(CCPC)ACTING AS ENVIRONMENTAL
ADVISORY COUNCIL(EAC)
FROM: DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DIVISION,GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT 7
HEARING DATE: NOVEMBER 17,2016
SUBJECT: PL20160001369: PANTHER ISLAND MITIGATION BANK EXPANSION/
COMMERCIAL EXCAVATION PERMIT
PROPERTY OWNER,APPLICANT&AGENT: n
Owner:
National Audubon Society, Inc.
225 Varick St.,FL 7
New York,NY. 10014
Agent:
Stantec Consulting Services
3200 Bailey Lane, Ste. 200 E
Naples,FL. 34105
N
REQUESTED ACTION:
The applicant requests approval of a Commercial Excavation Permit to excavate 350,000 cubic yards(cy)
of material and remove the material from the site.
GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION:
The subject site is located in Sections 3 & 4, Township 47 South, Range 27 East, and is locatedUJ
approximately 2 miles south of Corkscrew Road.The project site is approximately 400 acres in size.
PURPOSE AND DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:
The applicant wishes to expand operation of a commercial excavation which would involve `scraping
down' existing farm fields l' —3' (355,000 cy) to create wetlands and removal of the excavated materials
off site,which removal is the subject of this application.The excavation activities will be phased over what
is anticipated to be a two year period of time. The removal of overburden material is a bi-product of thectt
creation of the wetlands, which is an approved use of the Natural Resource Protection Area (NRPA).
Pursuant to Section 22-110 (b) (2), applications for commercial excavation permits shall be reviewed by
the environmental advisory council for recommendation and approved by the Board.
SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING:
The surrounding properties to the east,south,and west are zoned Agricultural with a Mobile Home Overlay
(A-MHO). The surrounding properties contain active crop farms and cattle grazing fields. The property to
/1 the north is a rural residential area and is located in -- County.
Or
Development Review Dw sion•2800 North Horseshoe Drive•Naples,Florida 34104.239-252-2 •,,nn.cotiergevnet
Packet Pg.707
16.A.25.e
Currently, it is not know where the material will be hauled to. A potential haul route map is attached
indicating the probable'cone of influence'. The closest structure to the site is a radio tower to the northwest.
HISTORY AND PERMITS:
This removal of overburden material is a bi-product of the creation of the wetlands, which is an approved 2
use of the Natural Resource Protection Area. Staff has determined that since a Conservation Use is a co
co
permitted use in an Agricultural Zoned District,a Conditional Use permit for excavation is not required. m
0
The Panther Island Mitigation Bank(PIMB) was originally designed to produce 934.67 mitigation credits "
for the restoration, enhancement,preservation and perpetual management of the 2,778 acre bank site and
was issued a Wetland Mitigation Bank permit (11-0002-M) in March 1999 from the South Florida Water -a
Management District (SFWMD). PIMB was approved with seven (7) phases and included: the a
establishment of freshwater marshes and pine flatwoods; filling of drainage ditches;removal of cattle and
grazing impacts; vegetative restoration of vehicle trails; re-routing of diverted historic flow-ways;
enhancement of wetland hydro-periods,eradication of exotic clearing of vegetation,management to prevent c
exotic vegetation invasion and re-infestation; mechanized and manual heavy brush clearing to allow a
prescribed burning; and reintroduction of appropriate fire regimes.
P
On February 22, 2000, the BCC approved Commercial Excavation Permit No. 59.720 which was the a.
original permit that allowed a similar shallow excavation of 770,000 cy of fill material which was removed o
from the site.This permit has since expired and the petitioner wishes to expand the limits of the project.
>
rtsu
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN(GMP)CONSISTENCY: w
This project has been found to be consistent with the goals,objectives,and policies of the GMP.
-12-
FUTURE
FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT(FLUE):
The subject property is consistent with the FLUE. o
U
TRANSPORTATION ELEMENT: N
Transportation Planning staff has reviewed the proposed Commercial Excavation and has approved the N
project. Traffic will be directed north on Carter Road in Lee County.
T.:
0
On May 26, 2016, the owner and representatives from the consultant team met with Lee County m
transportation staff. Based on the goals of the project and removal of overburden material, Lee County ce
Transportation staff indicated that they have no authority or mechanism to require a Development Order Q
for the removal of fill utilizing Lee County roads. However, during the meeting,there were several items W
that were brought up by Lee County transportation staff which the owner has agreed to implement. These z
items address life safety and cleanup issues along Carter Road, Corkscrew Road and at the intersection of
these roads. Certain stipulations were agreed to and are included as "additional stipulations related to Lee N
County"at the end of this report. CL
W
CONSERVATION AND COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT(CCME): Z
Environmental Planning staff has reviewed this petition and has approved the petition. An updated Listed a<_
SpeciesSurvey has been provided. m
P
ANALYSIS: 0
Staff has completed a comprehensive evaluation of this petition including the criteria upon which a cu
recommendation must be based. Section 22-110 b.2 of the Collier County Ordinance of Codes and Laws a
specifies the requirements for a Commercial Excavation permit. The specific criteria is as follows:
Packet Pg. 708`
16.A.25.e
/*"'"N (1) The excavation will not interfere with the natural function of any sanitary, storm or drainage system,
or naturalow way,y, whether public or private, so as to create flooding or public health hazards or
jeopardize the functions of the natural resources and environment of Collier County.
Staff has reviewed the Excavation Permit and has verified that this excavation will not interfere with the Y
natural function of any sanitary, storm or drainage system,or natural flow way,whether public or private,
so as to create flooding or public health hazards or jeopardize the functions of the natural resources and m
environment of Collier County. o
a)
(2)Dust or noise generated by the excavation will not cause a violation of any applicable provisions of this
article. Rock crushing operations or material stockpiles that will be adjacent to any existing residential
area may require separate county approval. It is anticipated that these activities will not occur during this a
operation.
Currently, there are three residential units within 1 mile of the site, along with a radio tower and a fanning
operation without a residence.An attached aerial depicts the location.Pursuant to Section 22-111 (d)of the
a.
Code of Laws and Ordinances, letters have been sent to all property owners within 300 feet of the site
advising them of this petition and the EAC and BCC meeting dates. Additionally, signs will be posted in
the area providing Notice of the meeting before the Board of County Commissioners. d
(3) The excavation will not adversely affect groundwater levels, water quality, hydro-period, or surface
water flow ways. The county manager or his designee may require the applicant to monitor the quality of
the water in the excavation and adjacent ground and surface waters. Under no circumstances shall the w
excavation be conducted in such a manner as to violate Collier County or applicable State of Florida water
quality standards.
as
Staff has determined that the excavation will not adversely affect groundwater levels,water quality,hydro- E
period or surface water flow ways. This creation of additional wetlands will enhance all of the fore-
mentioned.
ti
(4) The excavation will be constructed so as to not cause an apparent safety hazard to persons or property. `=
Staff has determined that the contractor will be required to follow OSHA guidelines with respect to the
excavation operation.
U
(5) The excavation does not conflict with the growth management plan or land development regulations
adopted pursuant thereto, nor does it conflict with existing zoning regulations. Special criteria and z
approval procedures may be necessary for projects within the Big Cypress Area of critical state concern.
Cl)
Staff has determined that the excavation does not conflict with the growth management plan or land w
development code regulations. This project is not located in the Big Cypress Area of critical state concern.
F--
z
(6) In cases where a wetland is no longer capable of performing environmental functions or providing
environmental values or in cases where it is determined that no reasonable alternative exists other than
disrupting a wetland, certain alterations may be allowed, except as otherwise authorized through previous
county review processes. -
f6
The developer has prepared a Conservation Easement over a portion of the site. Upon recordation of the
Conservation Easement, 90%of the site will be recorded as Conservation as required by the Development
tTh Review Division Environmental staff. The former farmland area does not count towards the requirement
of 90%of the native vegetation to be placed in Conservation Easements.
Packet Pg.709
16.A.25.e
(7)Flow of water within and through preserved wetlands shall not be impeded.
Existing and proposed Conservation Easements cover most of the site to ensure the integrity of the wetlands.
(8) Appropriate sediment control devices (hay bales, silt screens, etc.) shall be employed to prevent
ca
sedimentation within the wetland pursuant to the design requirements of Section 10.02.02 of the Land m
Development Code. Any building site adjacent to a wetland and elevated by,filling, must employ the same o
erosion control devices. Fill must be stabilized using sod, seed, or mulch.
Staff has reviewed the Site Development Plan which accompanies this Commercial Excavation Permit and
the plans indicate appropriate measures to prevent sedimentation and erosion control.
This project has been found to be consistent with the requirements of Section 22-110. d
COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW:
The County Attorney's office reviewed the Staff Report on October 28, 2016.
E
RECOMMENDATIONS: a_
Staff recommends that the CCPC, acting as the EAC, forward Petition PL20160001369 to the Board of
County Commissioners with a recommendation for approval with the following stipulations:
1. The required Conservation Easement must be recorded prior to issuance of the permit letter. x
2. The excavation shall be limited to a bottom elevation of 3.0 feet below grade. w
3. Access to the site is through Lee County. No material will be removed directly from the site
through Collier County without prior approval of the Collier County BCC.
4. Dewatering is not allowed.
5. No blasting will be permitted.
6. Vegetation removal permits in accordance with the Land Development Code shall be obtained from ••
Development Review Division for those phases of the project which require the removal of N
vegetation.
7. The petitioner will obtain all necessary Local, State, and Federal permits prior to starting any
excavation. Q-
8. A Performance Security must be provided and accepted prior to the commencement of excavation
activities. 0
w
Additional stipulations related to Lee County:
1. All dump-truck traffic exiting the project will operate between 7:00 AM and 5:00 PM, Monday sr)
through Friday only. There will be no truck traffic on the weekend. Ct
2. There will be no truck traffic on Carter Road while school busses are loading in the morning or
unloading in the afternoon.
3. Speed limit signs and monitoring devices will be set up along Carter Road to monitor the fifteen
(15) mile per hour speed limit. Any truck found to be violating the movement or speed conditions
will be permanently removed from the project.
4. Certified flagmen will be positioned at the North and South ends of Carter Road to control truck
movement.
5. Trucks entering and exiting signs will be posted on Corkscrew Road,east and west of Carter Road.
6. Trucks traveling west on Corkscrew Road will exit at Alico Road to access Interstate 75. Any truck
found to be violating this route will be permanently removed from the project,
Packet Pg.710
16.A.25.e
PREPARED BY: m
0
JOHN R. HOULDSWORTH DATE
SENIOR SITE PLANS REVIEWER
REVIEWED BY:
0
.c
MATTHEW MCLEAN, DIRECTOR DATE co
a.
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DIVISION
E
0
a
APPROVED BY:
JAMES FRENCH, DEPUTY DEPARTMENT HEAD DATE w
GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT
7a
U
E
E
DAVID S. WILKISON, DEPARTMENT HEAD DATE v
GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT N
ti
N
Tentatively scheduled for December 13, 2016 BCC Meeting m
U
Attachments: w
Traffic Impact Statement including potential haul routes
Aerial Location Map
Commercial Excavation Permit Plans
Letter to Lee County Transportation Department
Z
w
0
E
U
co
Packet Pg.711