Loading...
Backup Documents 01/06/1998 R{{J~GlJl~J'~I{ BCC M]~E'I~ING OF JAIN'U/',RY 6, 1998 NapLes Daily News Naples, FL 33940 Affidavit of Publication Naples Daily News BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ATTN: NANCY SALOGUB PO BOX 413016 PUBLIC MEETING NAPL£.~ FL 34101-3016 EOARDOFCOUNTY COAA/~iSSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLOR~)A Tue~k~v, Jc~'~x~y 6, 9:00 A.AA. Notice I$ hes'eby given tttot the Collier' Courd¥ REFERENCE: 001230 800440 aoo-d of CO.,~.qty Co~nml~ slo~er s will 57617728 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEE 8~s C~s Third FI~ of ~e Admln- State of Florida ~s~l~ 8ul~dl~ F) ~ ~ C~ller County of Collier government Complex, N~les, F~I~, ~o c~- Before the under3~gn~ author{ty, personally ~ct ~e business ~ C~- appeared B. Lamb, vho on oath says that she serves tier C~, m ~he ~ve slued time O~ ~e. as the Assistant Cor~r8te STcretary of the N~te~ C~e~ of me o Daily Uevs, a da~ly newspaper published at N~pLes, f~ ~ld meeting mo~ ov~ll~le to ~e in Collier County, Floridn: that the attoched pr tess ond m~ be copy of ~dvertis~ng ~as published in 3a~d laird ~ fha office ot County Admlnlstroior newspaper on dates Listed. ~me ~1~, ~me per- Affinnt further says tha~ the ~a~d tlaples Daily ~ttme. ~ny perso~ News is a ne~paper publ~sh~ at Naples, ~n ~aid es to ~e~l o ~clsl~ Collier County, Florida, and that the ~8~d ml~ B~d ~11 need o ra- ced ~ t~ pr~eedl~ new~paper has heretofore been continuously pedolnlng ~er~o, published in sa~d Collier Eounty, Florida, each ~ef~e moy need s~e ~ o ve~m day and has been enter~ as sec~d class ~il c~d~~n~ ~tter at the ~st office ~n Naples, in said m~, which raced I~- clu~s ~e te~v Collier County, Florida, for a peri~ of I year evlde~e ~ ~lch next precedi~ the first publication of the BOARD OF COUNTY attached copy of a~vertisement; end affiant COmMiSSiONERS COLLIER COUNTY, further ~ay~ that she has neither paid nor FLORIDA promised any person, firm or co~ration any TI~OTHYL. H~NC~K, CHAIRMAN discount, rebate, comm~ss~ or refund for the DWIGHT E. BROCK, pur~se of securing this advertisement for CLERK publication ~n the said newspaper. Oepu~Cl~ Jon. 4 No. PUBLISHED ON: 01/04 AD SPACE: 52.000 INCH FILED ON: 01/05/98 ............................. ==-7' ..... } ..................................... Signature of Affiant COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA January 6, 1999 9:00 A.M. NOTICE: ALL PERSONS WISHING ~D SPEAK ON ANY AGENDA ITEM MUST RFX~ISTER PRIOR TO SPEAKING. REQUESTS q~D ADDRESS T]FE BOARD ON SUBJECTS WHIC}! ARE NOT ON THIS AGENDA MUST BE SUBMI'I'FED IN WRITING WITH EXPLANATION TO TPIE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR AT LEAST 3.3 DAYS PRIOR TO THE DATE, OF T}IE MEETING AND WILL BE HEARD UNDER 'PUBLIC PETITIONS". ANY PERSON W]IO DECIDES ~D APPEAL A DECISION OF ~"HIS BOARD WILL ~ZED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING ~qIERETO, AND T~[EREFORE MAY N~.q~D TO F~NSURE~ T~DRT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES 'Iq{E TESTIMONY AN]) EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. ALL REGISTF~RED PIIBLIC SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO F/VE (5) M-INIYl~ES UNLESS PERMISSION FOR ADDITIONAL TIME IS GRANTED BY THE CHAIRMAN. ASSISTED LISTENING DEVICES FOR TIIE HEARING IMPAIRRD ARE AVAILABLE IN T}IE CO~ COMMISSIONERS' OFFICE. LUNCH RECESS SC}tEDUI,ED FOR 12:00 NOON TO 1:00 P.M. i. INVOCATION - Rev. Fred Thorn - Golden Gate United Methodist Church 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA AND CONSENT AGENDA Approved and/or Adopted w/changes - 5/0 4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approved as Presented- 5/0 A December 2, 1997 - Regular meeting. B Dece~ber 2, 1997 - Land Development Code meeting. C December 9, 1997 - Regular meeting. D December 16, 1997 - Regular meeting. E December 17, 1997 - LDC meeting. F December 22, 1997 - Emergency meeting. 5. PROCLAMATIONS AND SERVICE AWARDS A. PROCLAMATIONS 1) Proclamation acknowledging the "Do the Right Thing" Program of the Collier County Sheriff's Office. To be accepted by Sheriff Don Hunter. Adopted 5/0 2) Proclamation proclaiming the week of January i1 - 17, 1998 as County Fair Week. To be accepted by Terry Wolfson, President of Collier County Fair Board. Adopted 5/0 B0 SERVICE AWARDS Presented 1 Larry Henry - Road and Bridge Department - 20 years 2 S~]san Rossi - Utility Regulation Department - 10 years 3 William Craig - Water Department - 10 years 4 Judith Puig - Code Enforcement - 10 years 5) I~arilyn Vanatta - Library - 10 years 6) George Richmond - OCPM - 5 years 7) Brent Smith - Water Department - 5 years C. PRESE/F£ATIONS 1) Recommendation to recognize Bryan Thurston, Craftsman with Facilities ~4anagement, as Employee of the Month for January, 1998. Presented D. SELECTION OF NS~ CHAIRMAN AND VICE CHAIRMAN. Commissioner Berry elected as Chairman and Commissioner Norris elected as Vice Chairman 5/0 6. APPROVAL OF CLERK'S REPORT A. ANALYSIS OF CHANGES TO RESF~VES FOR CONTINGENCIES. 7. PUBLIC PETITIONS 8. COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT A. COMMUNITY DEVELO~ & ENVIRONM]KNTAL SERVICES 1) Community Development and Environmental Services Division staff requesting approval to serve as agent in applying for an amen~nent to the Ford Motor Company vehicle evaluation center planned unit development. Approved - 5/0 Added 2) Interlocal agreement between Collier County and the City of Marco Island foz the County Planning Services Department staff to present ten land use petitions to the Marco Island Planning Board and Marco City Council (Staff's Request). Approved - 5/0 B. PUBLIC WORKS 1) Adopt two Resolutions related to applying for a Highway Beautification Grant from the Florida Department of Transportation for a portion of Davis Boulevard, Project No. 60013. Res. 98-3 & Res. 98-4 - Adopted 5/0 2) Ranking of alternative landfill sit,is pursuant to the final report from the Landfill Citizens Advisory Committee. Site 'L" designated as ~1 site; Site "U" desiganted as backup and Dufresne Henry to return to the BCC with costs - 3/2 (Commissioners Mac'Kie and Berry opposed) Moved from Item ~16B1 3) Approve Budget Amendment for purchase of vehicle from Public Works Utility Reserve Fund (408). Approved 5/0 C. PUBLIC SERVICES D. SUPPORT SERVICES E. CO~ ADMINISTRATOR F. AIRPORT AUTHORI~ 9. CO~ ATTO~'S REPORT A. Update on weed abatement liens on property owned by James Lorenzo Walker and analysis of options regarding this property and other properties similarly situated. Staff (Messrs. Mihalic, Cautero and Weigel) and F~r. Walker to pursue legal assistance at reduced rate. 4/0 (Commissioner Constantine out) B. Proposed settlement in the Federal Court case of Wadsworth v o Collier County and the City of Naples, et al., Case No. 95- 88-CIV-FTM-23D. Approved 3/1 (Commissioner Norris opposed and Commissioner Constantine out)) Added C. Results of Canvassing Board for Lely CDD Approved 4/0 (Commissioner Constantine out) 10. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS A. Appointment of members to the Ochopee Fire Control District Advisory Committee. Res. 98-5 ap[>ointing/reappointing Michael Hart, T. Anthony Brock and Charles R. Reynolds - Adopted 4/0 (Commissioner Constantine out) 1 1. OqqIER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS PU]~LIC CO~ ON GF2qERAL TOPICS PUBLIC HfD1RINGS WI[,[, BE }{F3%RD IMME. DIATEL¥ FOL[X)WiNG STAFF ITEMS 12. ADVERTISED PUBLIC }{F2%RINGS - BCC A. COMI'REq{ENSIVE P[2%N AMY'S B. ZONING AMENDM~iNTS OTHER I) Recommendation to consider the adoption of an Ordinance prohibiting the conversion of roadway swales to culverts in the public rights-of-way within the area of Naples Park unless a permit is obtained and providing for the type of materials acceptable for use. Ord. 98-1 Adopted 4/0 (Commissioner Constantine out) 13. BOARD OF ZONING APPF31I,S A. ADVq{RTISED PUBLIC I~.LARINGS B. OTHER 14. STAFF' S COMM~3NICATIONS 1 5. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' COMMUNICATIONS :.6. CONSENT AGFa.IDA - All matters listed under this item are considered to be routine and action will be taken by one motion without separate discussion of each item. If discussion is desired by a member of the Board, that item(s) will be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered separately. Approved and/or Adopted w/changes - 5/0 A. CO~4MUNITY DEVELO~ & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES 1) Approval of the final plat of "Pelican Strand Rep]at-4" Constr~ction and Maintenance Agreement and Stipulations 2) Approval for recording the final plat of "Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C, Second Addition" and approval of the vacation of the previous plat, Quail West Unit One, Repiat C, First Addition, Petition AV-97-025. Res. 98-1 3) Approval of the final plat of "Bougain Village" Construction and Maintenance Agreement and Stipulations 4) Request to return Bond #400FL2056 to The Deltona Corporation for work associated with "Marco Beach Unit 24" 5) Assignment Agreements for easements for Fiddler's Creek, Phase l-B, Units One and Two. 6) Approval for recording the final plat of "Creekside Commerce Park West - Unit One". Subject to Performance Bond, Construction and Maintenance Agreement and Stipulations 7) Approve an amended Resolution regarding the Saddlebrook Village PUD to account for conditions pertinent to an approved affordable ho~sing agreement and new sunset date. Res. 98-2 8) Approval of Excavation Permit No. 59.451 (modification) Sapphire Lakes stockpile removal located in Sec. 33, T49S, R26E, bounded on the north by Interstate 75, on the east by Sherwood Park PUD, on the south by Twelve Lake PUD and on the west by Berkshire Lakes PUD. w/Stipulations B. PUBLIC WORKS '~oved to Item t8B3 1) Approve Budget Amendment for purchase of vehicle from Public Works Utility Reserve Fund (408). 2) Approve an Agreement between the Board of County Commissioners and a Landowner's Group for improvements to the Pine Ridge Road/I-75 area. 3i This item has been deleted. 4) Approve staff selection and award Agreements for Professional Structural Engineering Services - RFP 97-2728. w/Kris Jain & Associates, Inc.; Anchor Engineering Consultants, Inc.; and Jenkins & Charland, Inc. 5) Approve Budget Amendment for Right-of-Way Acquisition Activities for County Barn Road Four Laning Iraprovements, CIE No. 033 . In the a3nount of $200,000.00 6) Award Contract to Highpoint General Contracting to construct picnic pavilions and pumphouse building for Sugden Park, (Bid 9'7-2757) (Project #80081). In the amount of $133,111.00 7) Approve the Lease Agreement with Big Cypress Elementary School for the use of their cafeteria. Ca,~ita] Projects Management to conduct a Public Meeting on January 8, 1998 C. PUBLIC SERVICES D. SUPPORT SERVICES 1) To obtain Board examination and approval of the sufficiency of bond:.~ of County Officers. 2) Approval to award Bid ~97-2761 for moving services. Awarded to Adkins Transfer, Inc., Suncoast Moving, Inc. and Schaap Moving, Inc. E. COUN"i"f ADMI![ISTRATOR 1) Appropriate funding for the State Attorney's Telephone for Fiscal 'fear 1997. In the amount of $13,206.00 2) Budget Amenclu~ent Report. Budget Amendments 98-098, 98-104, 98-105 and 98-106 F. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS G. MI SCELIJkNEOUS CORRES PONDF/qCE 1) Satisfaction of I,ien: NEED MOTION authorizing the Chairman to sig~n Satisfaction of Lien for Services of the Public Defender for Case Nos.: 97-2604-MMA, 97-3428-MMA, 97-7052-MMA, 97-7775-M~431, 97-0529-~LA, 97-4759-MMA, 97-3142-PR4A, 97-1537- I~4A, 97-4714~I.~MA, 97-6358-M}4A, 97-1065-MMA, 97-3887-I~J~, 95- 10192.-MMA, 96-8614-MMA, 96-5336-MF~A, 96-7973-M~4A, 97-0695-~4A, 97-7239-14~4A, 96-1664-MMA, 96-9563-MMA, 97-7243-MMA, 97-00092- CFA, 97-0454-M~4A, 96-5092-~, 97-3370-MMA, 95-tO725-MMA, 95- 1 8 5 6 - 2) MISCEL[.RNEOUS Iq'F~4S ~) FILE FOR RECORD WITH ACTION AS DIRECTED: H. OTHER CONSTITUTIONAl, OFFICERS I. COUNq"f Aq'IY)RNEY 1) Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approve the Stipulated Final Judgment as to parcel nos. 141 and 141A in the law~;uit entitled Collier County v. David N. Sexton, Trustee, et al., Case No. 94-2826-CA-01-DRM (Bonita Beach Road Right-of-Way) and authorize the County Attorney's Office to forward the Joint Motion for Stipulated Final Judgment to the court for action J. AIRPORT ALVIn{OR ITY 1) Reconnmendation to approve the attached budget amendment which will increase the Marco Island Executive Airport terminal building exr.ense budget, grant proceed budget, loan proceed budget and reserve for debt service budget by $45,000. 2) Recommendation to approve the attached budget amendment which will increase the Marco Island Executive Airport budget by $2,310. 17. ADJOURN INQUIRIES CONCERNING CHANGES TO THE BOARD'S AGENDA SHOULD BE MADE TO THE COUNTY ADMINIS~RRATOR'S OFFICE AT 774-8383. ............ ~ .................................................. ill .............. Il ' I I .... II ...................................... I A(;ENi)A CilAN(;ES IIOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' IMEETING .IANilARY 6~ 1998 ADD: ITEM 8(A)(2) - IN'I'F,I~.I.OCAI~ AGREEMENT BETWEEN COLLIEI~. COUNTY AND THE CITY OF MARCO ISI,AND FOB. TIlE COUNTY PLANNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT STAFF TO PRESENT TF, N I,ANI) USE I~ETITIONS TO TI tF, MARCO ISLAND PLANNING BOARD AND MARCO CITY COUNCIL (STAFF'S REQUEST). PROCLAMA TION WIIEREAS, it is the duty, honor ami tratfition of the Collier County Sher![£s Office to preserve and protect the lives, properO, and constitutional guarantees of all persons through an tmrelenting commitment to prqfessional excellence; and IVItEREAS, .Vher([f Don thmter trod the Collier Count~ Shcr(ff's Qffice have joined the "Do the Right Thing" program, which the Miami Police Department began in 1990: and tVtlEREA& the "Do the Right Thing"program see~; to build se~-esteem in )'oungsters by reil~Jrcing socittl¢-dcsirahle behavior; anti ttqfEREAS, the "Do the Right Thing" program 3timulates ident~c~tion in the community n'ith positive role models (peers and law et~orcemenO. NO W TttEREFORE. be it proclaimed &v the Board of Co~tnO, Commissioners of Collier Cou,ty, Florida. that ' TIlE "DO TtlE RIGHT THING" PROG~M of the Collier Cotmty Sheri~'s Office is a tru& unique and innovative endeavor, valuable to the communi~ of Collier County. DONE AND ORDERED TttlS 6th Day of Janua~, 1998. BOARD OF CO~ COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUN~ FLORIDA TIMOTH~ ~ANCOCK, CHAIRMAN  ' :. )CK. CLERK PROCLAMATION WHEREAS, the County Fair is the link between our urban areas and our agricultural heritage; and WItEREAS, the CounO, Fair provides a unique forum for the display, exhibit and recognition of the productive activities of our young Collier Countians; and WItEREAS, the County Fair provides a unique educational opportunity for youth involved in 4H, [~.4, and other organizations to exhibit their livestock, handicrafts, horticulture and other projects; and WHEREAS, the Co~mty Fair, and its partners throughout the Caunty, sponsors the development of practical skills and leadership in our youth; and WtfEREAS, the (.'firmly Fair partner,vhip includes the vohmteer ,vervices of the Board qf County ('r~mmis,¥ioners, the Fair Board ~f Directors, the Cooperative Extension Service, the CounO, £'ouncil of Family and Community Educators, a~'~d the County Public Schools. NOW TttEREFORE, be it proclaimed hy the Board o. f County £'ommissionerx of Collier County, Florida, that the week of January I I - 17, 1998 be designated as COUNTY FAIR WEEK .nd the Board o.f ('ounty Commissioners urges all citizens of the CounO, to attend the Cottnty Fair and show their support of and recognition to yottng Collier Cotmtians who proudly participate. DONE AND ORDERED TItlS 6th Day of &muar): 1998. BOA R D OF CO UNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTE FLORID~ ~q/y/L. COCK, CHAIRMAN A?7'EST: DWIG[~T E, BROCK, CLERK · Retn: 2269480 OR: 2380 PG: 1973 CLERK ?0 TH){ BOARD RECORDED ~n the OFFICIAL RECORDS of COLLIRR COUNTY, FL RNC F~I{ 19.50 INTEROFFICE 4TH FLOOR 01/16/98 aC 09:07AM DWIGHT l). BROCK, CLERK BIT 7240 COPIES 4.00 INTERI~OCAL AGREEMENT TillS INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT is entered into this 6th day of January, 1998. by and between 'File CITY OF MARCO ISLAND, FLORIDA, hereinafter called the "City", and thc BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, hereinafter called the "County". The City and the County are referred to collectively herein as the "parties". WITNESSETIt: WHEREAS, the City was recently incorporated pursuant to charter established by special act of thc Florida Ix:gislature on August 28, 1997; and WHEREAS, the City is located within Collier County, Florida; and WHEREAS, the County desires to assist thc City and serve all of the citizens of Collier County by assisting the City in the transition to self government through shared services of administration; and WHEREAS, Section 163.01(2), Florida Statutes, per]nits local governmental units to make thc most efficient use of their powers by enabling them to cooperate with each other to provide services in a manner that will accord best with geographic, economic, population and other factors influencing the needs and development of local communities, and WHEREAS, Section 112.24. Florida Statutes, authorizes intergovernmental transfer and interchange of public employees; and WIIEREAS, at the time the City of Marco Island was incorporated there were ten existing land use petitions scheduled for consideration by the Collier County Planning Commission and/or the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida; and OR: 2380 PG: 1974 WIIEREAS, pursuant to the City Charter. these land use petitions shall now be considered by the Marco Island Planning Board and/or the City Council of the City of Marco Island; and WI-~EREAS, the City Charter provides that the Collier County Land Development Code in effect on August 28. 1997, shall be the land development regulations within the City boundaries: and WIIEREAS, the City has requested that the County provide assistance to the City by furnishing County stuff members for purposes of reviewing, analyzing, advertising for Marco Island Planning Board meetings and presenting the ten existing land use petitions to the Marco Island Phmning Board and/or thc City Council fi~r the City of Marco Island. NOW, TtlEREFORE, ~n consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein, the parties hereby agree as follows: 1. Thc County ,.viii provide the services of County Planning Services staff ("County Staff") to the City to review, analyze, advertise and present the ten existing land usc petitions to, d~e Marco Ishmd Planning Board and/or the City Council of the City ~t' Marco Island. as appropriate. The County shall perform all staff functions customarily performed by County Starf in the review, analysis. prcsematiop, and public notificatitm for Marco Island Planning Board meetings of thc ten land usc pcthions. County Staff shall remain employees of i~e County at all times during thc effective term of this Agreement. 2. TF. RM OF AGRi';EMENT. "l'his Agreement shall be effective as of December 16, 1997, and end upon thc final disposition of the ten existing land use petitions by the City, including any appeals. 3. COMPENSATION. County shall be paid thirty dollars ($30.00) per hour for the actual staff time involved in presenting the existing ten land use petitions to the Marco Island Planning Board and/or the City Council for the City of Marco Island, as appropriate. County Staff travel time shall not be compensated. ltowcvcr, the City shall pay for mileage for County Staff's travel tYom the Collier County Government Complex to the City of Marco Island at the rate of 29 cents per mile in accordance with Chapter 112. Florida Statutes. Said OR: 2380 PG: 1975 payments from thc City to the County shall be made to the Board of County Commissioners. Thc payments by the City shall be governed by Chapter 218. l:lorida Statutes (Thc Florida l'rompt Payment Act). The County shall invoice the City for all of the payments referenced above. 4. INS[JRANCI",. Thc County's liability coverages will extend to both the County and County Staff for this agreement subject to normal exclusions. Thc City must procure its own insurance coverage for any risks related to County Staff's service on behalf of thc City of Marco Island. 5. INDEMNIFICATION. To the extent permitted by Florida law. the City shall, in consideration of the benefits received from the County by the provision of C{mnty Staff services (which are acknowledged to have a monetary value substantially in excess of $I00.00), hold harmless, indemnity and defend the C<mnty. its agents and employees from all suits and actions, including attorney fees and all costs of litigation and judgments of any name and description, arising out of or incidental to thc peril)finance of this Agreement which results from any negligence, intentional conduct and/or willful and wanton behavior of the City and/or its agents and employees. This provision shall also pt:main to any claims brought against the County by any employee of the City, any subcontractor or anyone directly or indirectly employed by any of them, other than by Count>' Staff. The City's obligations under this provision shall only be limited to the extent provided by Florida law and not by the City's limit of. or lack of. sufficient insurance protection. This section shall not apply to any claims arising I'r{m'~ thc sole negligence or intentional or willful and wanton conduct of the County. County Staff. or any other employee or agent of the County. 6. TERMINATION. This Agreement may be tem'finated by either party by providing forty eight (48) hours advance written notice to the other party. Notice to thc City shall bt: provided to: l larry J. Cowin, Chairman City of Marco Island. Florida 1280 San Marco Road Marco Island, Florida 34145 Notice to thc County shall bc provided to: l/orbara I3. Berry Chairman Board of County Commissioners 3301 East Tamiami Trail Naples. Florida 34112 · *** OR: 2380 PG: 1976 *** This Agreement shall also terminate in accordance with the provisions set tbrth in paragraph 2 regarding the term of this Agreement. 7. RECORDING. This Agreement shall be recorded in thc Official Records of Collier County. Florida. THE CITY OF MARCO ISLAND, BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS FI.ORIDA OF COLLIER COUNTY llarry J, Co,din, Council Chairman l~ar~ra B. L~rry ,~YL'~tr~ah'\ Attest' Attest: i~atricia'L. Berry, 43"~ 'wighi E. Bro~.k,' Interim Assistant City Clerk Clerk of Courts Approved as to form and legal sufficiency Approved as to form and legal sufficiency for thc City of Marco Island, Florida: for Collier County: Kenneth B. Cuylcr, Esq.~ '"'lkrfimiro MafialicVhl Esq. Interim City Attorney Chief Assistant County Attorney 116784 I.WP5 4 III 88 ! M~R~ORANDUM Date: January 8, 1998 To: Susan Usher, Senior Accountant Public Works Department From: Ellie Hoffman, Deputy Clerk Minutes & Records Department Re: Resolutions 9R-3 and 98-4 Enclosed please find twenty-two originals of both documents as referenced above, Agenda Item ~SB1, approved by the Board of County Commissioners on January 6, 1998. As per our conversation this date, I understand that you will be forwarding the originals, in lieu of certified copies to the Florida Department of Transportation, as part of the Highway Beautification Grant Application Package. If you should have any questions, please contact me at: (840~). Thank you. Enclosure RF, S()I,UTION NO. 98- ~ A RI.:SOI.UTION OF TIlE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COI,LIER COUN'FY. FI.ORIDA. AUTIIORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO APPI.Y FOR A I II(;I{WAY B[';AIJTIFICATION GRANT I:I~,OM TIII.; FI,ORIDA DEPARTMI-;NT ()F TRANSPORTATION FOR MEDIAN I,ANDSCAPING f)F [)AVIS BOUI.EVARD FROM AIRPORT ROAD EASTWARD TO COUNTY BARN ROAD; PROVIDING AN I'~FFECTIVE DATE. WI II':RI-;AS, many median strips within the Dcpamncnt of Transpo~ation, State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard) right-of-way arc capable of receiving and sustaining landscape beautification f~atures: and WI IEREAS. thc Counly Administrator and thc Board of County Commissioners desire Ihat Collier County participate in the beautification of this highway's median strips from Airport Road to County Barn Road through landscape development: and WIIILREAS. the Board of County Commissioners intends, by thc adoption of tiffs Resolution. to authorize Ibc County Administrator. to apply fi~r a llighway Beaulificatkm Grant I?om lhe Florida Dcpa rrm cat o f Tea nsportat ion. NOW, Tt{EREFOR[L BE l'F RESOI,VED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF C{)LI,IER COUNTY. FLORIDA. TtIAT: Scctionl. Thc Board of County Commissioners of Collier Count,,,', Florida. hereby authorize the County Administrator to apply for a tlighway Beautification Grant from the Florida Depamnent of Transportation. pertaining to thc median strips along a 2.3 mile section of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard) bctxvccn Airport Road and County Barn Road whhin the unincorporated area of Collier County. Section 2. Thc Clerk to the Board of County Com~nissioner. is hereby directed to Ibrward a certified copy o{' I}lis Resolution to the Florida Dcpamnent of Transpo~ation ~s pa~ of the llighway BcaulilScat ion (;rant A ppi ication Package. Section3. This Resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption. A I)()P'I'I.: D hy thc B .mrd or County Corem issioncrs of Collier County at regular meeting assem bled this ~__ day of January, 1998. AT'FI':ST BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGI FF E. BR()CK. CI.['~RK COI.LIER COUNTY. FI,ORIDA ny tX. ~. '' -~hai~an ~~ Approved as to form and legal su ff~cicncy: RI:SOI.tYI'I()N NO. g~- 4 A RI.:SOI.UTION OF TI II-: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION:RS OF COI.I.IER COI~NI'Y. FI.ORII)A. AlYFtIORIZIN(; TIlE CO{~N'I'Y AI)MINISTRATOR TO ENTER IN'F() A I.ANI)SCAPI': MAINTENANCE MF. MORANI)UM OF AGREEMENT AN[) ItI(;IIWAY BI':AlYI'IFICATION (;RANT MI':M()RANI)UM OF A(;RF. EMI-:NT WI'I'tl 'I'lll: FI.ORll)A DEPARTMENT OF TRAN~P(1RTATION FOR TiII': INSTAI.I.A'i'ION AND MAINTENANCE ()F I.ANI)SCAPING AND IRRIGATION I.OCATED (')N A PORTI()N OF STATI': IH(;IIWAY 84 (DAVIS P, OUI.EVARD) BETWEEN AIRPORT ROAI) AND COUNTY BARN ROAI) WITI3IN TltE UNINCOPORA'FED AREA OF COI.LIt-:R COliN'FY. FI.ORIDA: PROVIDING AN EFF:C'FIVE DATE. WtI[:RI~AS, many median strips within the Dcpartmclit of Transportation, Stale Road 84 (Davis Boulevard) righl-of-way are capable oF receiving and sustaining landscape beautification features: and WI II!RF~AS. thc Cot, nty Administrator and thc Board of County Commissioners desire that Collier County parlicipatc in the bcautillcalkm of this highway's median strips From Airport Road to County Barn Road lhn~ugh laudscape developmcnl: and Wt II';RI(AS. thc Board of ('Otlllt)' Commissioners inlcnds, b)' thc adoption off this Resolution. lo aud~orizc ~he ('mmty Admh~istralor. Io enlcr into a I tighwny I,andscapc Maintenance Memorandum of Agreement and a I lighway Beautification Grant Memorandum of Agreement between the Board o[County (.'ommissioncrs ol'Collicr County. l:lor~da, and the Florida l)epa~mcnt of Transportation. NOW. TIIt(REFOR[L BE I'F RESOLVED BY TIlE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COI,I,II(R COI~NTY, FLOI~II)A. TttAT: Scction l. Thc Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby authorize the Cotmtv Administrator to cn~cr imo a t lighway I,andscapc Mah~Icnancc Memorandum of Agreement and a I lighx~ay l~caulification Grant Memorandum of Agreement from the Florida Depamncnt of 'l'ranspt,rlatitm. pcrtai,ing to thc median strips along a 2.3 mile section of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard) bctxvcc, Aiq~,rt Road ami Courtly Barn Road widlin thc unincorporalcd area of Collier Counl)'. Section 2. l'he Clerk lo thc Board oF County Commissioner. is hereby directed to Ibrxvard a certified cop5 of this Rcsolutitm lo thc Florida Depamncnt of Transpo~alion. Banow. as a rcsull of having been ax~ ardcd ami accepted a I lighxvay 13cautification (~ranl. Scclqon3. This Rcsoh~lion shall take cFl~ct hnmedialclv tlpon adoption. AI)()P'I'I~I) by Ibc Board of ('otllllv Commissioners of Collier County at regular meeting assembled th i~ _..z ..... day of January. l t208. A'I'TI.;ST I~()ARI) ()F COUNTY COMMISSIONERS I)WIGI IT 1(. 13R()CK, ('IA~RK COLI,IER COUNTY, FLORIDA Byc' ~-' . ~:- ..,.:~ .... By Approved as to fom~ and legal suFlScicncv: 882' SPOONER INSURANCE ~ A~ENCY INC 806N 15THST IMMOKALEE FL 33934 1813) 657.2569 Herman Spooner 'I'o: '1 he l~oard'ui'the (Joilier Cot,,ly Co,,,.,issioners From: 'lhe htm~okalee C,,mmunity nnd Concerned CiUzcn:; Reference: New l.andfOi Sites Issue. We. fl~e citizens ~d commmfily of Immo~ee. would ~ke to let you. tim Co~er County Commissioners. ~ow ~mt we opt>~e ~e opmfing ora new lm~d f~. We do not agr~ wiflt you proposed com~ly l~df~ sites ~ause ~ fl~e n~ ~i~s flint you have ch~e~ citijet site A, L, or U, me a~cffitutal p~ope~ly around hmuok~ee. We do not wm~t Io cai vcgehables fltdB flint mc grown next to a ~dli~. O~ ~mfing commmfity is s~ling enough wiflmut rite ~. ~o, ~e new 1~ w~ ~h hmnoimlee'a image, hint ikq economy, and hinder devdopment and We would hke fi~l you h~ lake in t'mmidetation these ]. hlcntil~ nmi solve tim odor pml,lcm. 2. l)cvclop a plan thnt will enable { 'oilier County Io dcm wifl~ ils lmtdfill needs without ..... dmna~ng rely of om lined. 3. T[uck fl~e w~ to a ~cp~onM c;,licc6on hcility out of~e co~ty. 4. Use a ~ccychng ~oflicr au~csfion fi'om o~ commtmity membe~ is flint you ne~ ~ have fl~ese hnpm~t mce~gs lnuno~cc ~d at our ~nve~fiencc so the worhng people c~ arid. It N not ~ ofyou to have meetings at your mmvmfien~ which ks not bcnefici~ for 0~e people who voted for you. Sh;ccrel7, 'Ibc ~mtnmfity of hnmokMc< . To: 'Ibc l~oa~d ol Ibc Collier Com~ly 8 B 2' We, tim c[~z~n:; ;md commmfiiy ol'hm~lol~cc, would like lo Ici you, ~m Collier Courtly }mow flint we vf~i~l~sc Utc Olm~dnl; ora new hmdlill. We do not ,gtco wifl~ you pmlmSCd county lmidlill sitcs bc<ause ~ flit ncw $i~s flint you have chosen, ciflmr sltc A, L, o[ U, mc ulgic~tmal piVl>ctly ~oond hmno}mlcc. We do not wmll to cat vegc~blcs ami Om ~lnh}g community is sau~ling cnoul~ wiflmut rite ~d~. ~o, tim new Imt~ w~ t~l~h hmnok~cc': image, hint iks cconomy, trod hinder devdoprt:znt and We wo~d ~e for you to ~e ht coimidemfion fltcsc 1. Idcnfi¢ and solve rite odor problem. 2. l)cvclol~ a plan th;t~ will enable Collier Cotmty to de:~ with iB lm~d~ needs wifl~out 3. Truck tim w~lc lu a ~cgiolt~ c~,licction fiicility out of the comtty. 4. Usc a rccycling AnoUm[ nurl;csfitm fium our conmmnily tncmbc~s is flint you need ~ Imvc fllcsc impofl:tnt meetings lmmo}mlcc m~d at vm convcnicncc so fl~c woff&~g people can attcml. It ~ not f~ oryou to havc these Inccfings at your cvm, c~ficn~ which [s m~t bcaeliciul for fl~c pcople who volcd for you. 'Iht CmmL)mdly ol'lnun~cc" / ~ , , t' >.'~ .,.. .... . .... ~,, · To: 'Ibc l;oa~d otthe Collicr County CommisaioncJs c. From: 'l~e hnmo~cc Community and Concerned Ci~ns ' Refexcnce: Ncw Lmul~ 5i~ Ise;ue. We, tim ci6z~m and commulfily of lmmol~ee, would hkc to let you, fl~e Collier Comfly Commisnicmers, know that we oppose fl~c opening (ifa new lm~dfill. We do nut ngtcc with you plUl~O:;cd cm,nty l;uLdlill sites ~ausc ~t fiLe new sites flint you have chosen, ei~cr site & L, oi U, me nl~icuRtn;fl lnope~ty motntd [111111o~¢0. W0 do llot wmtt to cut O~ ~uing conunulfity is s~iing cnou~t wiflmut ate ~. ~o, ate new l~t~ w~ m~fish Immo~ee'= image, h~t i~ economy, m~d IMtder devdopment ~d We wo~d ~e for you ~ ~e h~ emmidcxafion atese 1. Identify ~id solve tim odor problem. 2. D~elop a plm~ flint will ermblc Collier Courtly to de~ wi~t i~ lmt~ nec~ will,out dmn~ m~y of o~ 3. Truck fl~e w~ to a 1c~on~ coliec6on ~cHity out office ~unty. 4. Usc a rc~cling ~tofltcr su~esSon fi'om o~ ~mmunily members b ~mt you riced ~ Imvo fl~ese bnpot~tt mecSngs bt Inuno~ec mid at o~ ~nvcnicncc :;o ~= woff&~g pcoplc ~t armed. It b not f~ of you mcc~gs at yo~ ~nvenien~ which is ~ot benefici~ for arc people who voted For you. 5b;cc~cly, 'l]le Commmlily of ht~llo~cc ' '" ' ' :" " ' Ik /;'7' 1'?~:5- ::.,,.~./.v> /'5'":' >: " :- ' ..0 ,".,",,: ' ' ~q::- l~t ,.~,,,,:,~, -.. .i , ,/ ~_ From: 'Hm Immokalce Communily and Concerned Citi~ns ' Rcfetcnce: Ncw I.m~d~ Sit~ Isstlc. " We, ~m cifi~ and commmdly of hnmok~ce, would ~c to Ict you, ~c ~cr Comity Comn~sionc/s, Pa~o~v flint wc oppose ~c upc~g ora haw Imtdfill. We do nut ag~ wiat you Hoposcd cmmty hmdliil sitcs ~a~c ~ fire n~ si~s flint you lavc ciQmr site A, L, o~ U, me a~ic~lural property ~ound ~uno~ee. Wc do not wmtt to eat vege~bles ~ flint me ~own next to a ~ulli~. Om ~mh~g co~mnmtity ~ s~lh~g enou~t wiQtout fire ~1~. ~o, flzc new ~ ~ ~t~h hnmoY~ee'3 hnage, h~ iB economy, md l~dcr dcvdopment mtd We wo~d ~e fo~ you ~ ~c h~ ~uidemfion flmse 1. Identify ~d ~olve flze odor problem. "· 2. D~clop a plm~ flint w~ c~mble Colher County to de~ wiflt i~ lmzd~ ncc~E wifl~out dmna~ m~y of om ~td. 3. 'I'~uck Qm w~ to a ~cl;ionM coliccfion hc~ity out of Q~c comity. 4. Usc a tccycling lnunok~cc mid ut our convcnic~;cc so tim wol~&~g people cmt attend. It h not fi~ of you to have lllCCfi/igs at your ~nvcsfie,cc which is m~t bcneficiM for flse people who voted for you. Sbtcctcly, 'llte Commmfity of hmno~cc .. / '~ ' , ~, . To: Thc Board °l/he Collier County Commissioncis From: 'lllc Im,lokalcc Community and Concerned Cintra ' Rcfc~cncc: New l,m~dfill Sitas Issue. " V/c, tim cifiz~m and commmfily of Immo~cc, would ~kc to Ict you, fl~c Co~icr County Conm~sionms, Brow flint we oppose tim ot)m~g o[~ new lm~dfill. We do m~t agtcm wifll you I)mPoscd county lmtdfill sites ~a~e ~ file new si~s flint you have chosen, ciflmr site A, L, ot U, mc ~gficdtural l>rVpc~ty mound hmno~ee. We do not wmtt to eat vcge~blcs mid f~ flint mc ~own next to a ~dlill. O~ ~mh~g commmfity is s~h~g cnou~ wiflmut rite ~. ~o, tim new ~ w~ ~h hnmok~ce'~ hnage, hint iB economy, ~d l&Mcr devdopment m~d We wo~d ~e lot you m ~e h~ cm~iderafion fltese 1. ldcafify ~d solve ~e odor problem. " 2. ~clop a l>lm~ flint will c~mble Collier County to ~ wifl~ i~ Im~ nee& wiflmut 3. 'l'~k ~m w~ lo a rc~o~ ~liccfion hc~ty out office 4. Usc a tcc-/c[hx2 mcd~. ~oalcr ~ui~csfion fi'om our ~nunmfit7 members is flint you nccd to lmmok~cc mM at om c~nvcnicncc so dtc wod:b)ll people mz at,nd, it ~ not ~ of you to lmvc Q~csc mccfiJ~s at your mnvc~dcn~ which is not bcncficial for ale people who voted for you, Sincerely. 'Ibc Commmfity ofhmno~cc · To: Thc Board el'thc Collier Courtly Comlnissionc~s Fwm: 'lhe hm,oI'.alee Conununil7 nl~d Concculed Citizens ' Rcfctcncc: New Ixmdlil'l Sites Issue. We, the dfiz~:ns trod community of lmmokalce, would [ike 1o lei you, tile Collier County Comnti.ssioncrs, }mow that we oppose 'dm opening ofn new hmdfill. Wc do not nglcc wilh you proposed termly lm~dlill sites lxx:nuse 'all the new sites tirol you lhave cl,oscn, either site ^, L, et' U, me ~gficultural pmpclty around hmnokalce. We do not waJlt to eat vegetables fiuits that rue tTov;n next to a landlill. Our fmmh~g coimntufity is strugglh~g enough without rite l~lltdlTl]l. ~o, file new landfill will tanfish hnmokalee'3 image, bm! ils economy, and hinder development and growfl~. We would l.ikc for you to take in cmtsidciafiun lllcs¢ sugg~fions: 1. Idcnti£y and solve tim odor problcnl. " 2. Develop a plan that wilt enable Collier County to deal with its lan. drill nccds without ...-, dmnagi~ rmy ofou. t lmtd. 3. Track the w~te. to a ~egimlal ct.licction 15tcility out of file cotmly. 4. Use a recycl/J~g method. Another ,mggcsfion fi'om om' cra,, ~mfit7 members B tlmt you need to have these i,npor 'trait meetings Immok~tlee mid at our convenience sc tim wotl'-h~l; people coa~ attend. It is not fair of you to have these mecth~s at your cxmvcNcnce which is mit beneficial for lhe people who voted for you. 'llte Colmtltu~ily ol'hmnokal¢c .. . . l:mm: 'Ibc hLlmo}:alC¢ Commtmily :iud Co[~ccmcd Citizens Rcfc]cncc: New I,andffll Silcs Issue. We, e~c cifi~ m~d c~nmmfily of Immo~cc, wo~d ~e lo let you, ~c Co,er County Comm~sioners, ~o~ flint we op~c fl~e opc~g old ncw lmLd~. We do not a~ wi~ you proposed comity Imd~ sites ~a~e ~ ~e n~ si~s flint you have chose~ ci~cr site ~ L, or U, ac ~tic~tui~ propcxty aound ~mo~cc. We do not w~t to ~t vcgc~blcs ~d ~ ~at ~c ~o~,'n ncxt to a ~df~. ~ ~ming comm~fity ~ s~ing enou~ ~fltout ~c ~. ~o, ~c new hnmo$~ce': ~nage, huff its economy, ~d lfinder devdopment ~d ~o~. We wo~d ~e fo~ you to ~:c ~ co:=idcrafion fltcsc s~fions: 1. Identify m~d solve O~e odor problem. 2. Develop a lfla~t fl~at wilt c~able Collier C:ounty to dcm wiUt i~ I~d~ ncctLs wiflmut 3. Truck thc w~ste to a regic~M c~.licction ~xcility out office county. 4. Usc a ~ccycliug Anofl~cr ~u~esfion fi'om o~ commmfity mcmbe~ L~ flint you need ~ have fl~cse impor~tt meetings Inuuo~qlee m~d at our convenience so fl~c working l~oplc ~t at,nd. It ~ not f~ ofyou to have mccOng~ at yo~ ~nv~ficnce which Ls not bcncfici~fl for ~e people who voted for you. Sb:cc~cly, g',,, [ ~/.. , . z// ~:.' ./)~ , , ., '. ' ~:~ ~',~ b, ~ .~,,.,, /~. ,'.,%-. ~...-.~,,,q~.. ,- ~,.~ xx, '. ~ ' :., .._ , " ' .... ' ' ' , From: 'll~e Immokalce Community and (]oltc~r~lcd Rare[anco: New l,aJMfill Silos Issue. We, thc citi/ens ami COmlll~Zttily of hnmoknlca, wuuld like Io Icl you, thc Collier Courtly k~ow fl~at we opp~c ~te opc~g ora new We do not ag[~ wia~ you propos~ comtty l~dfiH sites ~a~e ~I flze n~ si~ ~t you have chosen, eiflt~ site A, L, or U, ~e a~culturM property ~o~d hxuno~ce. We do not w~tt to eat vege~bles and ~ ~mt ~e ~o~'n next to a ~ ~ming comn~ity b s~g cno~t ~tout fl~e ~. ~o, ~e ne~ ~d~ ~ ~h ImmoY~lce'3 im~e, hm~ i~ economy, ~d hinder devdopment ~d ~o~. We would ~e for you ~ ~e ~ ~idc~fion fltese 1. Identify ~d solve ~e odor problem. 2. Develop a pl~ ~at ~ enable Collier County to de~ ~t i~ l~dfilt nec~5 ~out d~na~ [my ofo~ ~d. 3. Thick ~c wm~te to a tcgion~ coliccfion ficility out of fire county. 4. Use a rccyc~: A~ofl~cr ~u~,,csfiun ~'om our community mclnbe~s is fl~at you need to have fl~e impotlant meetings lnuno~ee m~d at our ~nve~fience so fl~e wo~n;~ ~ople cm: attend. It b not f~ of you to have meefit~s at your co;wenien~ which is not bencficM for ~te people who volcd for you. 'II~e ~mmu~tity oflmmukM~. Rcf~'rcm'e: New l,mullill ~iles kmnv Itm[ ~',c upi,usc tim vpcuh~g u~n ucw Wc do nul nluc~ t~Jlh ym~ i,mlmsol couuly hmdl}ll silos b:~ause all Iht ncr/silos Ihal yim have chosen, I. hlcntiFy ami s{,lvc the odor plul,h:lU. 2. l)cvclop a i,hm thai will e;ml,lc t ',llicr (:mmty fo deal wilh ils landfill n,:cds 4. T/sc a rCCS't'l~: mclh<xl. Auo~cr suj~gcsfioH frvua our commtLnily mc;ubcts is th~tt yotJ need lo ]mvc these iml~Odasd JucclJugs hnmok~cc and at our convenience so IJ~c working pCt)l~le can attend. It is not hh' oFyou it) have lhcsc ~qnce~cls', '1 hc C~,uummily ~d' hm re,kalco /.../.~ ~r~ ,//t./. ,,'..~;,,,~./~.~/r/ .,-~'7--'..' -- ................ '::~ '" ~'--~'" ' ' ---a~ ......... ~:-.~,~z~~_~ t21¢;' 1/, ~ -.. ..... (~.' ,-/~"~',.'.-- ~,,,~,, -.-, :... /:./ , /~,~1 ~ . v ~ . y - ~, * ......... : i.j. / .-- ............................... . ---:~.:-~( ........ ~' ~'~,~, ,.',.~ 1/~,.< ~,' ~-~/~ / , ¥ '1'o: 'l]m l;o,.d u£flm CoUic~ Courtly ¢.'ommissioncrs Rcfmcncc: New Lmldffll Slims Issu,:. We, tim cifi7~us and c,mmmfily of Immolaqce, wotfld like to Icl you, tim Collier County Commissioners, ~low flint we opp~c Ole opmfing ~,fn new lmldfill. We do not ng~ wifll you proposed comity lmdf~ sites ~a~e ~ ~e n~ siUs tint you have chosm~ eiflmr sile A, I,, or U, n~e ngficulltmd p~ope~ty mound humo~ee. We do not w~t to eat vegeCables and fl~m flint ese g~own ncxt to a l;u~dlil{. ' ~lr farming commuuity is s~ul~gling enough without fl~c lnndfill. ~so, ~e new hmdfill will {amish ]mmol~lce'3 image, hint its ecomm,y, mid hinder development mid growO~. We wo~d ~kc for you to ~kc in cousidcmgon these 1. Identify m~d solve Hie odor Inob~cm. 2. Dcvelop a plnn O~at wi~ cn:~ble ('oilier County to dc~ wiOi iU I~ld~l needs wiOlout 3. 'l'xuck Om wm~ to a re~ou~ co]~ccOon ~sc~ity out of tim eo~ty. 4. Use u recycUng ~o0~cr ~u~e~on fi'om o~ comm~fi{y mcmbe~ g Inuno~ee ~d nt our ~nveniencc so tim workin~ people m~O1~s at yo~ ~nvc~cn~ width is not beneficial for Om people who voted for you. Sb:cerely, ?lle Co[mnuzdty ofhnmokdca - /' '~ / ~ ~ ~' ,, // ~ ..... , ~ ., , ~. ~ - /' ,/ ~ ,~ , ... / ,'W..*/,~I~I.' ic- ~: L; ~,.. ~' ~ ,~. .: / ~ , - " ~' .... ... ~ . ~.,-.,.~ .,. ~ ~L ,', -(... ',. "' _) ?',: ...... -..,,, 1/( .... : .............. . ~. /~/.~,~ .... ~ ~,'~ (~'~' (, L~(~ ~-t' To: Thc Board o£thc Colhcr Comity Commhsioncrs From: ~c hnmok~cc Community ~tl Conccrncd Clans Kefc~cncc: Ncw I.md~ Sil~ Issue. Wc, fl~e c~us ~d commu~fity of Immok~cc, wo~d ~kc to Ici you, ~e Co~c~ Counly Com~sioncts, ~ow fl~at we opp~c U~c opct~g ora new lm~dfi~. We do not agr~ wifl~ you proposed comity l~dffll sites ~ame ~ fl~e n~ si~s flint you have ehose~ eifl~er site A, L, or U, a~e agricultural properly ~ound Immok~ee. We do not wmt to eat vege~bles ~ ~m~,g comm~dty ~ s~ling cnou~ ~fl~out ~c ~. ~o, ~c new 1~ w~ ~h lmmo~lcc'~ image, huff it~ ccon(,my, ~d Ifindcr devdopm~t and ~o~. We would ~c for you Io ~c ~ co~midcm~on fl~cse su~o)m: 1. Idcn~fy ~d solve fl~e odor problem. 2. D~clop a plan ~t ~1 enable Co,er Courtly Io deg ~ i~ ]md~ needs d~nn~ my ofom ~d. 3. Track O~e w~te to a rc~on~ colJcc~on ~c~ty out office co~ty. d. Usc a 1c~clb~8 ~o~cr su~cs~on ~'om o~ ~mm~dty mcmbc~ ks ~mt you need ~ lmvc O~csc hmno~cc m~d st o~ ~nvcnJcncc so fl~c wor~n8 I~oplc cm attend. It ~ not ~ of you m~s at yota ~nwficn~ which ~ not beneficial for ~c people who voted for you. ~inccrcly, / - 8 B 2 TAXPAYER ACTION GROUP RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED TAG opposes the closing of the present landfill and the planning to acquire a new landfill site. Whereas the reason given for closing the present slte (i.e. the'foul smell) has become moot because of the almost complete elimina- tion of the smell originating from tile landfill, Whereas tile remaining smell which cannot be eliminated will conti.,e to exist for 30-40 years even after the landfill is closed, Whereas the smell which currently pervades the area actually originates from the water treatment plant and which smell should be shortly eliminated with the installation of a long-overdue scrubber. ,i . Whereas the present landfill is expandable on adjacent property owned by the County and can serve effectively and at minimum cost for many years to come, Therefore: Let it be resolved that the Taxpayers Action Group opposes the closing of the present landfill and the planning to acquire a new landfill site, in the interest of the taxpayers, voters and residents of Collier County. DECEMBER8 1997 Mary Dunavan, Secretary Taxpayers Action Group of Collier County hie ILO. Box 10246 Nnples, Florida 34101 8 B 2 January 4, 1997 O "~ a~~.~~ O r~ Collier County Board el' Commissioners Timothy I lancock, Chairman 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FI, 34112 RE: Results of the I.andfill/MRF Siting Committee Project [)ear Chairman I tancock and Commissioners: I am writing both at thc request of thc Board of Directors of Collier County Audubon Society, and as a member of the Citizens' Advisory Committee (, AC ) which helped produce Ibc list' of recommended landfill sites you are discussing on January 6, 1998. I have two points I wish to communicate to you concerning these recom- mendations. Thc first is to clarif.v ,,,,'hat thc recommendations are, as opposed to how thc), ma5, be perceived. Thc charge of thc CAC ,,','as to select a via)lc site(s) for a new Coil/er landfill/MRF, ii'Ibc dcc'isi~m [,'; re[t*ct~lc./)'t~m l]w ?rc.¥cnl xitc. That decision has not been made, therefore, no one should construe site reconnmenckttions by thc CAC as recommendations to move the landfill, or endorsement of that idea. Second, Collier County Audubon Society is supportive of keeping the landfilling operation where it presently is and maximizing that capacity. Thc process of participating in thc site selection process and listening to the concerns oF neighbors, farmers, Immokalee residents, in addition to the expertise of local and hired engineering and enviromncntal help, has brought us to this posit/on for these reasons: I.) We live in an area possessing t~rcat natural and human which are not compatible with a ~ resources landfill anywhere. Since it already exists, that damage is done and will continue to be done for man)' years to come. Let's not expand a necessary, evil Further than necessary. There is adequate capacity for 20 or more )'cars, depending on maximization techniques and waste stream d/version rates. 2.)There is considerable unlhirness in moving the landfill to an area where people were not aware of its imminence in order Io appease another group of people ',,,'ho knew it was there when the),' bought their homes. 3. ) The Count,,, owns 360 acres adjacent to the present site which was intended to be used for expansion, and still could serve a var/ely ot's~did waste managcmcnt purposes. 4.) While thc County did previously request proposals on alternative waste management technologies, which could reduce landfilling needs substantially, it did not fbllow through on these proposals as the issue of the landfill itself seemed to dilute thc Board of Commmsioners' interest. During the next ten years there is great potent/al for a number of these technologies, including covered composting of mixed soiid waste, to become viable alternatives to landfilling here and should be pursued as they become available. Some are viable right now, such as increased curbs/de recyclable collection xv/th a large Clean MRF, backvard composting and better source reduction programs. · ' I served on the CAC ',,,'/th genuine interest and in the hope ofdoing good. i thank you for that opportunity, and for your consideration oFmv input now as you make a very difficult decision. President ~ _ P.O. Box 11387 · Naples, Florida 34101-1387 · {941) 64~-9754 ~ rec¥c/edpaper To: The B~ard of ("oilier Counly ("ommissioncrs Frmn: The lmmokalce Chmnl~cr oFCommcrce and Conccrncd Cillzens Reference: New l,andfill Sites Issue We, Ibc citizens and communily oF lmmokalee, would like Ihe Board of Collier County Commissioners to know that we oppose II~e opening o~a new landfill sile in our area. We do nt~t agree with your proposed county landfill sites because they are all agricultural related areas. We do not want lo grow or eat vegelables near a landtill site. Our farming commtmily is slruggling enough tvilhoul the landlill. Also, Ihe new landfill, ir chanson in our area, would tarnish Imm(~kalee's image, hurl its economy, and hinder developmenl a~d growlh. We would like you Io lake into consideration these suggestions: I identify and solve thc oiMr problem; 2 develop a plan thai will enable Collier County to deal with its landfill needs without damaging any agricullural lands; 3. Iruck thc waste to a regional colleclion lhcilily out oFIhc county: and 4 use a recycli,g method Sincerely. The ('ommunily oF Imm(~kalcc NAME ADDI~IiSS PHONE tt ~ '~ ...... ~ ............ ~ .,?~/ · ' / //-' '.~ .... 'F ~ " 8 B To The Board el Collier Cou~ily ComJl}lssIor~oers From The Jmrnokalee Chamber of CommercoondConcornedCdzens Reference New Landfill,Sr~es Issue 'vVeAhe ohzens and commundy, of Immokalee, would fine Jhe Board of Collier Counly Commissioners, know lhal we oppose Ihe opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree wllh your proposed counly landfdl sdes because~lhey are all .~grlcuRural rela~ed areas We do not Wahl Io grow or o,~I vegelables near a landfOI sJ~e. Our farming commun~ly ~s slrugghng enough wOhoul lhe landfill Also, lhe new landfill if choosen Jn our area, would larnlsh Immok,'~lo.n'5 ~mage hi Jrt ds economy and hinder deveJopmo, n! and growlh ' ' ' We would like for you Io ~ake in conslderabon these suggestions; 1. Identify and solve Ihe odor problem 2. Develope a plan thai will enable CoJher Couoly lo deal ',,',qlh ils landfill needs wilhout damaging any 8gncullure lands 3, Truck the wasle to a regional collecl~on faohty ot~t of lhe county 4 Use a recycling mefhod Sincere y, TO: Tho ~oard of Colhr;r lC; ..... lly f;() Reference: New LandMi Silos We,tho citizens and commlJn~ly of trflmoka g~. v,'oul¢¢ hk(! Ibc Board of Collier Counly Commissioners, know. that we oppose Ihe Open,hq of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree wilh your proposed counl¥ landMI sites becatJse lhey are all agricullural related areas, We do not want Io grow or cai vegelables near a landfill site. Our farming Community ~s struggling enough wilhoul Ihe landfill, Aisc, [he new landfill if choosen in our area. would larnish Immokalen's image hurl ~IS enonomy, and hinder developmenl and growlh · We would like for you lo I;lke itl corls~derahnn 1. Idenlify and solve lbo odor problem 2. Develope a plan Ihal will enable Collier C, olfnty fo dnaf w,' f~- landfill needs wilhoul damaging any agr~cullure lands 3. Truck the wasle lo a regional colleclioi*i 4. Use a recycling Sincere y. The Community of Im To. The Board of Colher Counl,r' Comm~ss~oneers From The Imrnokafee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned Citizens Reference New Landfill S~tes Issue WeJhe cd~zens and community of Immokalee, would hke the Board of Collier County Commissioners know that we oppose the opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree wdh your proposed courtly landfill sdes because lhey are afl agricultural related areas. We do not want Io grow or cai vegetables near a landfill site. Our farming community is struggling enough without the landfill. Aisc, the new landfill if choosen in our area, would tarnish Immokafee's image, hurt ~ts economy, and hinder development and growth, We would like for you to take ~n considerabon these suggestions: 1. Identify and solve lhe odor problem 2. Develop a plan lhat will enable Colher County Jo deal wdh ~Is landfill needs wdhout damaging any agrfcullure lands 3. Truck the waste lo a regional collochon faohly ot~l of lhe county 4, Uso a recycling melhod Sincere y, The Community of Immokalee To: ] he Board of Cotl~er From: Tho Immokaloo Chamber of Commerce nnd Concerned Citizens Re~erence New Landfill S~tes Issue We,lhe cilizens and commumty of hnnmka ee, wnuM hke lbo Board of Collier County Commissioners, know Ihgt we oppose (he opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree wilh your proposed counly landfill sites bemuse ,they are afl agricullural relaled areas. We do not wahl to grow or eal vegetables near a landfill site, Our farming commundy is slruggfing enough wilhout Ihe landfill. Also, lhe new ~andfiil if choosen in our area, would larnish Immokalee's image hurl i s economy and hinder development and graph ' ' We would hke for you Io (gke u] corts~deral~on lhese suggeshons 1, Identify and solve the odor problem 2. Develope a plan ~hal will enable Collier Counly to deal wilh ils landfill needs without damaging any agricuI tJre lands 3. Truck the wasle ~oa re~ional calleo ion faohty out of lbo county 4. Use a recychng Sincerely, 8 B 2 To: The Board of Colher Counly Comrmss~oneers From: The Irnmok~leo Chamber or Commerce. ,"jrlrJ Cr~ncerned Citizens Referorloe Now [.~rldflll ~dc~s Issuf~ We.lhe cilizens Bnd community of ImrnokBleo. wotiJ(~ hke lhe Board of Collier Counly Commissioners. know Ihal we oppose the opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree wdh your proposed counly I~nd[ill sdes because,lhey are all agricultural rel~led areas. We do not want Io grow or eal vegelables near a landfill silo. Our farming community is slruggling enough withoul lhe I~ndfill. Also, Ihe new landfill if choosen in our area, would larnish Immokalee's image, hurt ils economy, and hinder developmenl and gro~h We would hke [or you Io lake Jr~ corlsider~Jlioll Ihesu suggeslions 1. Idenlify 8nd solve Ihe odor problem 2. Oevelope a plan that will enable Colher C(~uniy l~ riehl wilh ils I~nd[Jil needs wJJhoLlJ damaging Bny agr~culhJre Im~ds 3. Truck Ihe wasle Io a regional colleclion fr~crhly ~1 Of lh~ county 4. Use a recycling molhod Sincerely, To: The Board of Collier County Commiss~oneers From: The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned Citizens Reference: I'ievv Landfill Sites Issue. We,lhe cilizens and communily of Immokalee, would like the Board of Collier County Commissioners know that we oppose the opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landfill sites because they are all agricultural related areas. We do nol want to grow or eal vegetables near a landfill site. Our farming community is struggling enough without Ihe landfill. Also. the new landfill if choosen ~n our area, would tarnish Immokalee's image, hurt ils economy and hinder development and growth. · We would like for you Io lake in consideration lhese suggeslions: 1, Identify and solve the odor problem 2 Develop a plan that will enable Colher Counly Io deal wdb ils landfill needs without damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck Iho wasle Io a regional colleclion i'acildy oul of lho courtly 4, Uso a recycling melhod. Sincerely, rnLxs--r BE yrs. old Jo 8 B 2' TO: The Board ct' Collier County Commissioneers From: The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and C, oncerned Citizens Reference: New Landfill Sties Issue. We,the citizens and community of Immokalee, wo~ fid like Ihe Board of Collier Counly Commissioners know lhat we oppose the opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landfill sites because they are all agricullural related areas. We do not 'want Io grow or cai vegetables near a landfill site. .Our farming community is slruggling enough withoul the landfill. Aisc, the new landfill if choosen ~n our area, would tarnish Immokalee's image hurt its economy, and hinder development and growth. ' We would like for you to lake in consideration these suggestions: 1. Identify and solve Ihe odor problem 2. Develop a plan lha/will enable Collier Counly Io deal with its landfill needs wilhou/ damaging any agriculture lands. 3. Truck lhe wasle to a regional colleclion f~,cilily out of Ihe county. 4. Usa a recycling melhod. Sincere y, The Community of Immokalee 8 B 2 To: The Board of Collier Counfy Cornrmss~nrmers From' The Immokalee Chamber or Commerce and Concerned Citizens Reference: New Landfill Sites Issue We,lhe citizens and communily of Immoka ce, would hke Ihe Board of Collier Counly Commissioners know Ihal we oppose Ihe opening of a new landfill in our area. We do nol agree wilh your proposed counly landfffl sdes because Ihey are all agricuIlural related areas. We do nol wan/to grow or cai vegelables near a landfill sde Our farming community is sfruggling enough w Ihout the landhll. Also, Ihe new landfill if choosen in our area, would tarnish Immokalee's image hurl ils economy, and hinder development and growth. ' We would hke for you lo Fake ~n considerahon these sug(..]ns OhS 1. Identify and solve the odor problem 2. Develop a plan lhal will enable Collier C. Ollnly lo final wdh ils I~ndhll needs wilhout damaging any agncullure lands 3. Truck the wasle to n reginnnl colloclion ft~cilily oul of Ibc COunty 4. Use a recycling melhod Sincere y To The []oard of Colher County Comm~ss~oneers From The hnmokalee Chamber of Gomme/coor~rl Cn~cernod CdJzens Reference ' New [.ar}dhll Sdes ISSLm We,l~e cilizerls ~nd commurldy of hnnmknlee, wrJt~lrl hkn lbo ~o~rd of Collier County Commissioners. know Ihat we oppose Ihe Open~n~l o¢ n new landfill in our area We do not agree wilh your proposed counly landhll sdes because Ihey are all agricu rural related areas. We do not went Io grow or eal vegetables near a landfill site. Our ~arming communily is slruggling enough wilhoul Ihe landfill. Also. lhe new landfill if choosen in our area, would f~rnish hnmoknlee's imn~o huh ds economy and hinder development and gro,Mh ' ' ' We would hke for you Io lake ~n cOnS~derohOtl those sttggqsJ~ons 1. Identify and solve lhe odor 2. Develope a plan Ihat wdl enable (;olher CoHtiIy ~o riehl wilh ds landfill needs without damaging any agric Ilure lands 3 Truck lhe wasle Io n regional col ecl on f~cddy oul n[ lhn courtly 4 Use a recycling method Sincerely. 8 B 2 To: The Board of Colher Counly Commms~oneers Reference NewLandhllSdes Issue ~Ve.lhe c~lizens arid commufllJy of Immok,~n ~. w~illi(J Jlk~ Ihn ~oard o~ Colhor Counly Commiss oners, know Ihal we oppose the opentng el a new landfill in ou~ We do nol agree wi~h your proposed counly landhll sites because lhey are all agricuJlural related areas. We do nol wanJ Jo grow or eal vegeJables near a landfill sile. Our farming commundy is slruggling enough withoul Ihe landfall. Also. lhe new landfill il choosen in our area. would tarnish Immokalee's image, hLir[ its economy, and hinder developmenl and gro~h. We would Pike 1o~ you Io l;~ke ~r~ cons~deral~on Ihese suggesl~ons 1. Idenlify and solve lbo odor p~obJom 2, Develope a pl,~ll ¢~n3ble Colher Oounly Io riehl w~lh ils I~nd[Jll needs wilhoul damaging an~i~ullure 3 Truck I~s/e Io ~ regional collochon G~ncer~y, The Communi y of rr '~'~:~,,~~, ~-:~: :'~ ' ,:,r~,~ ,, '"'. ~AL ~ ....... ' ' '_ ' ~y,,/,: / /7/ _. ~ D~ ~) //' / 4,~....-? I.' ?:, .:~/ . ~-,~ .... .,... -,~ ~,, .~,.,,..~ ~':~ .~ F..:.'.: j'{( i,,,~,,c~L(:~~?_7n~'~ ~_:7.~>~, 1~.~/(,:,. :~' ,, ~,:,.../; ( ~ .~.;,::.~,,:z~ /.e- 8 B 2 Tel Tho [~onr~ el (;r~ll~r!I ¢;o~nlly f;~ I~ m~' ~ ,~ ,,,~,. We,the citizens m~d commt~nRy of hnmok; o~, 'z,'nukJ hkr~ lbo ~o~,J of Collier Courtly Commissioners. know Ihat we oppose tho oporur~¢~ (ff o now landrW in our area.  e do not agree with ~our proposed county landfiff s~los because Lhey are afl agriculluraf related oas. We do nol want lo grow or oat vegelab~e~ near a landfill si,~. '1 Our farming commundy is struggling enough wW~ou~ Iho landfill. Also, the now landfill if choosen in our area. would tarnish Immokaioe's imaOe hurt ds economy arid hinder development and gro'~h. ' ' ' We would like for you to t;]ke (r~ cons~dernhon lhfme suqqeshons 1. Identify and sol'va Iho odor proh Qrtl 2. Developo a plan fh~l will enaNo Collinr Colnlly h} d,h'll wtlh ds landfill needs wilhoul damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck Ihe wasle lo a regional collochon f~ohty md rff Ihe courtly 4. Uso a recycling method Sincerely, To: The Board of Colher County Commlssloneers From The Immokalee Chamber el Commerce and Concerned C~lizens Reference: New Landfill S~tes Issue We.the citizens and communrly of Immokalee. would hke the Board of Collier County Commissioners know that we oppose the open~ng of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree wilh your proposed county landfill sdes because they are all agricultural related areas. We do not want ~o grow or eat vegelables near a landfill site. Our farming commundy is slruggling enough w~Ihcut the landfill, Also. the new landfill if choosen in our area, would tarmsh Immokalee's rmage, hurt ~ts economy, and hinder development and grov.~h. We would like for you 1o take ~n cons~derahon these suogesl~ons 1. Identify and solve the odor problem 2. Develop a plan lhal will enable Colhor County Ic) rl,',nt ',v,',h ,tS landfill needs without damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck the wasle to a regional collocl~on facddy oul of the courtly 4. Use a recychng molhod Sincere y. 'l"o: The Bc~ard or('~lEer ("pumy ('cmm~issicmers From: The Immokalce Chamber ~ff('ommerce and Concerned Cidzcns Reference: New la,drill Site.,; Issue We. thc citizens mid c¢)mmtmlty oF lm]m)kalee, would like the Board oFCollier County Commissioners Io know tl~a~ we oppose the .pening .fa new Inndlill sile in our area. We do not agree with your proposed c~mnty landlill sites because ll~ey are all agricultural related areas. We do not want Io grow or cat vegetables near a landlill site. Our farming comm.nily is slruggling eh.ugh wid.mt the landfill. Also. the new landfill, if chosen in our area, would famish lmm.kalee's image, hurl its economy, and hinder development and growth, We would like you to take into consideration d~ese suggestions: I. identify and solve the odor problem: 2 develop a plan that will enable ('oilier Cotmtv Io deal wilh ils landfill needs wilhout damaging any agricultural lands: 3. Uuck Iht waslc t¢~ a ~egltmal ctdlecfiCm Ihcility out ol'lhe county; and 4. use a recycling method. S ~ccr ely, Thc C~mmmnily oF Immokalee ~AMI:~ ADI)RI~SS PHONE ~ q[-~ ,;, . . ~ , , '.-' , , .~-,/~',' ...... :/:-~ '--"-.'- - ..':-~%. ': :, :, Z (~._r,~b.~ ~_ ~ t ~ ~ - ,, .: . / .... P) .-,. .. u-' ' :.:. ........ , '. -',',' , ,:. , %) ,', q.- , Z j '_ ~ , .. ~, .:. ,/ ..' / .. - ,~ . / / , .- . , . .f % - . ~-~' ~-:'~' -~-:' ' ' ~>: '~ ? ', '~ ',' ~ / ."- /c~q ..... ~ -/ ..................................... ~_')' 5 . ~ ~ ., /) , ~ / '' /' I To: The Board of Collier County Comm~ss~oneers From: The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned Citizens, Reference: New Landfill Sdes Issue ,. We,the citizens and community of Immokalee. would like the Board of Collier County Commissioners knov,, that we oppose the open~ng of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landfdl s~tes because they are all agricultural related areas. We do not wahl Io grow or eat vegetables near a landfill site Our farming community is struggling enough wdhout the landfill. Also, the new landfill if choosen in our area, would tarnish Immokalee's ~mage, hurl its economy, and hinder development and growth ' We v,,ould hke for you lo take ~n consideration lhese suggeshons: 1. Identify and solve the odor problem , 2. Develop a plan lhat wdl enable Colher County Io deal wdh ds landfill needs without ', .¢ damag~r,g any agricullure lands ,.: 3. Truck the 'waste to a regional coltechon facility oul of the county. .,' 4 IJse a recychncj method Sincere y. 8 B 2 To: The Board of Collier County Comm~ssroneers From The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned Cmzens Reference: New Landfill S~tes Issue We,Ibc citizens and commumty of tmmokalee, would hke lhe Board of Collier County Commissioners, know Ihal we oppose the opemng of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landfdl s~tes because they are all agricultural related areas We do nol want to grow or eat vegetables near a landfill site Our farming community is struggling enough without the landfill. Also, the new landfill if choosen rn our area. would larnish Immokalee's ~mage. hurl its economy, and hinder development and growlh We would like for you IO take ,n consrderahon Ihese sugpest~ons 1. Identify and solve the odor problem 2 Develope a plan thai wdl enable Colher County to deal wdh ds landfill needs without damag:ng any agr~cu!turp, lands 3 Truck the wasle lo a regional collect:on lacd~ty out nf the county. 4 IJse a recychn0 mefi'~od Sincerety To: The Board of Colher Counly Comrmss~oneers From: The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned C~hzens Reference: New Landfill Sdes Issue We,the citizens and commumly of Immokalee, would hke Ihe Board of Collier County Commissioners know lhat we oppose the opemng of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree w~th your proposed county landfill s~tes because they are all agricultural related areas We do nol wahl 1o grow or eal vegetables near a landfill site. Our farming commundy ts slrugglmg enough without the !andfill. Aisc, lhe new landfill if choosen in o~r area, would tacn~$h Immokatee's ~'nage, /'~.~1 ~fs eco, f"~::~,'~. ~ hif'~e¢ de, Ye~ ~ 9rowlh We would hke for you to Iake m cons~derahon these suggestions: 1, Identify and solve the odor problem 2 Develop a plan Ihal v,'dl enable Cr)lhor Counly Ir., deal wflh ils landfill needs without damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck the waste to a rog onal toilet or facrhly out of Ihe courtly. 4. Use a recychng method Sincere y To Thc, Board of Coiner Counly Comm,ss~oneers 8 B 2 From: The Imrnokalee Chamber o[ Commero? arid Concert;ed C~bzens Reference New LandfilISdeslssue We.lhec~zensandcommundyoflmmokalee would hke ~he Board of Colher County Commissioners. know Ihal we oppose the openm~ of a new landfill m our area. We ~o not agree with your proposed county landfill sdes because ~hey are all agricultural relate~ areas We do nol wanl to grow or eal vegetables near alandfillsite Our farming communRy is s~ruggling enough withou~ the landfill. Also, the new landfill if choosen in our area. would tarnish Immokalee's image, hurl its economy, and hinder development and gro~h ' We wou~d hke for you Io take ~n constderahon lhese suggestions: 1. Identify and solve the odor problem 2 DeveJope a Dian Ihal will enable Colhor OounW to de,~l w~th ds landfill needs without damaging any agriculture lands 3 Truck Ihe waste to a regional col~eqh~n fncddV ~uf nf the, courtly 4 Use 8 rf:?~'chnfl rnolhorl Sincerely, To: The Board of Coll,;r CounIy Comm~ss~oneers C'" From: The Immokal(e Chamber of Commerce .and Concerned Cllizens Reference: New Lgrldfill Sites Issue We.the cilizen.,- ,and community of Immokalee. would like the Board o/' Collier Counly Commission~, s know Ihat we oppose Ihe openrng of a new landfill in our are,a We do no. agree with your proposed counly landfill $1les because they are all agricultural related areas. We do not Wahl Io grow or eal vegelables near a landfill s~te. growth u . 7hOmy, and hinder delelopment and We would like for you Jo lake ~n%ons deral~on Ihese suggeshons: 1. Identify and solve lhe odor probk, m ' 2. Develop a plan that w~ll enable Colher County Io deal wdh ~ts landfill needs w~thout damaging any agr~cullure !ands 3. Truck the wasle Io a regional collechon facd~ty oul of tho county 4. Use a recychng method r Sincerely, To: The Board of Collier Counly Commiss~oneers From The Immokalee Chamber o1' Commerce and Concerned Citizens Reference: New Landfill Siles Issue We,the cilizens and communily of Immoka ee, would like lhe Board of Collier County Commissioners know Ihal we oppose the opening of a new landfill in our area We do not agree wilh your proposed county landfill siles because they are all agricullural related areas. We do nol want to grow or eat vegelables near a landfill sile. Our I'arming communily is struggling enough wilhou! Ihe landfill. Also, [he new landfill if choosen in our area, would tarnish Immokalee's image hurt its econo 'ny and hinder development and growth. ' . We would like for you to take in consideration these suggestions: I. Identify and solve the odor problem 2 Develop a plan lhat will enable Colher (;oltnly Io ,q~al v,,'dh ils landfill needs withoul damaging any agriculture lands. 3. Truck Ihe v/asIe fo a regional collection facilily oul of fhe Counly 4. Use a recycling molhod. Sincere y, 8 B / Tel The 8oard of Colher Counly Comm]ss~oneers From The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned C,Iizeqs Reference: New LandfilISdeslssue We.lhe cdlzens and comITItJ~]dy Of rmrnokalee, would hke the Board of Colher County Commissioners. know that we oppose lhe opemng of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landfdl s~tes because they are all agricultural related areas. We do nol want lo grow or ea~vegetab!es near a landfill site Our farming commundy is slrugghng enough wrthout lhe landfill. Aisc, the new landfill if choosen in our area. would tarnish Immokalee's image, hurt ils economy, and hinder development and growlh We would like for you Jo take ~rl cons~derahon ff~ese suggeshor~s 1. Identify and solve the odor problem ,4~ 2. Deve',ope a plan lhal will enable Collier County Io dn,~f'w,lh its landfill needs without damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck the waste to a regional colieclion faohty old of ihe county 4 Use a recychng method Sincerely. rnu .sT BE yrs. o/o' -b 8 B 2 To: The Board of Collier County Commissioneers From The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned Cilizens Reference: New Landfill Sites Issue. We,lhe citizens and communily of lmmokalee, would like lhe Board of Collier County Commissioners know that we oppose the opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landfill sites because lhey are all agricultural related areas. We do not want to grow or eat vegetables near a landfill site, Our farming community is slruggting enough wilhout the landfill. Aisc, lhe new landfill if choosen in our area, would tarnish Immokalee's image hurt ils economy and hinder development and growth. ' We would like for you to take in consideralion lhese suggeslions: 1. Identify and solve the odor problem 2. Develop a plan that ,gill enable Collier COunly Io deal wdh ils landfill needs wilhout damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck Ihe wasle Io a region,al cofleclion facilily otJl of the county 4. Use a recycling melhod. Sincerely, To: The Board of Colher Counly Cornm~ss~oneers From: The Immokalee Chnmber of Commerce and C, oncerned Citizens Reference New Landfill S~tes Issue We,the citizens and community of Immnkalee. would hke Ihe Board of Collier Counly Commissioners, know thai we oppose Ihe opemng of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed courtly landfill siles because,lhey are all agricultural related areas. We do not want lo grow or eat vegetables near a landfill site. Our farming community is struggling enough wilhout the landi'ill. Aisc, Ihe new landfill if choosen in our area, would larnish Immokalee's image, hurl its economy, and hinder development and gro,,C.h We would I~ke for you Io take ,n cons~derahon these suggeslfons: 1. Identify and solve Ihe odor problem 2. Develope a plan thai wdl enable Colher Courtly Io deal wilh ils landfill needs wilhout damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck the wasle to a regional colleclion faolily out of lhe counly. 4. Use a recycling melhod Sincerely, To: The Board of Collier County Commissioneers From: The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned Cili~ens Reference: New La~dfill Sites Issue We,lhe cilizens and communily of Immokalee, would like the Board of Collier Commissioners know lhat we oppose lhe opening of a new landfill in our area W~ do ~ol ~gree wilh your ~ropo~d ~ounty I~dfill ~ile~ b~u~ lh~y ~r~ ~11 ~gri~ullur~l area~. We do not want to grow or eal vegetable~ near a landfill ~ile. Our farming community is struggling enough wilhoul lhe land~ill, AI~o, lhe ne~ l~ndfill if choosen in our area. would larnish Immokalee'~ image, hurt ils economy, and hinder developmenl gro~h. We would like Eel you Io lake in consideration Ih~se suggeslions 1. Idenlify and solve Ihe odor problem 2. Develop a plan that will enable Coil,er County t~ deal wdh ils landfill needs withoul damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck Ihe wasle Io a regional dolfeclion facilily out of lhe counly 4, Uso a recycling method Sincerely, 8 B 2' To: The Board of Colhor County Commlssronoo¢$ From. The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and Concerned C~t~zens ~,-.., Reference: New Land;,ll Sdes Issue ~,~: We,the Olizens and commun~ly, of Immokalee. would like lhe Board et' Collier Counly Commissioners know Ihat we oppose the opening of a new landf~J in our area. We do not agree wJlh your proposed county landfill sites because, they are all agricultural related areas VVe do nol want Jo grow or eat vegetables near a landfill sde. Our farming commun~ly ~s slrugghng enough w~lhoul the landfill. ,\lso, lhe new landfill il' choosen in our area. would tarnish JrflrnokaJee's ~mage hurl its economy ;~nd hinder development and gro,..~h ' We would hke for you Jo lake ~n COnsldorahon Iheso suggeshons 1. Identify and sol,.,'e Ihe odor probiem 2 Develop a plan thai wdf enable Colher Ooun!y tr~ al%al wdh Its I]ndfill needs without damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck the waste to a regional coflechon faoldy oul of the courtly. 4. Use a recychng method Sincerely, 8 B To: The Board of Colher Courtly Comm~ssloneers From: The Immokalee Chamber o! Comrnerce acd Concerned C¢llzens Reference: New Landfill Sdes Issue We,lhe citizens and commumty of Immokalee. would hke Ihe Board of Collier County Commiss~ners know lhal we oppose lhe opening of a new landfill in our area, We do not agree with your proposed county landfill s~tes because they are all agricultural related areas We do not want lo grow or ealvegetables near alandfillsite Our farming commundy ~s strugghng enough w~thout lhe landfill. Aisc, the new landfill if choosen in our area, would tarnish Immokalee's ~mage. hurl ds economy, and hinder development and growth We would like for you to take ~n consJderahon these suggestions: 1. Idenl~fy and solve the odor problem 2 Develop a plan that wdI enable Colher Counly Io de,'~l wdh its I,'~ndf~ll needs wdhout damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck the waste Io a regional collechon faohty oul of Ihe courtly 4 Use a recychng mnlhod Sincerely. ",?' 8 B 2 To: The Board o~-'~"~ or ...rs. From The Immokaleo Chamb(;r el Commerce and C;.]ncerned Cd~zens Reference NevlLandfllJSdeslssue We.the citizens and commundy o~ Immokalee. would hke the Board of Collier Courtly ~mmissioners know Ihat we oppose the opemng of a new landfill in our area ~We do nol agree w~th your proposed county landfifl sites because lhey are all agricultural re~ated areas We do not wahl to grow or ea~ vegetables near a landfill site . ~' Our farmmg commundy is struggling enough wllhout Ihe landfill. Atso. lhe new landfill if choosen ~n our area. would larmsh Immoka~ee's ~mage. hurt ~ls economy and hinder development and grey,th ' We would like for you to take m consideration lhese suggeshons 1. Identify and solve [he odor problem 2. Develop a plan that wfl~ enable Colher Cot¢nW Io deal w~th ilmlandfill needs wdhout damaging any agriculture lands 3 Truck the waste Io a regional collechon facihty oul of the county 4 Use a recychng me[hod Sincere y, Tho Communil7 of Immokalee '_ --'t'Ozr, t z'// .'/ ' : . :'.;4' ~. . - ,~_. ,~ ..... ,'. ,.. . , ,:, 9C~ / "' ' ' ~- ~/W~ 7 ~ - . . ~ -- 8 2 To: The Board of Colher County Comm~ss~oneers From The Imrnokalee Chamber of Comlnerce and Concerned Cilizens Reference New LandMI Sdes Issue We,the cilizens and commurldy of Immokalee, would hke Ibe Board of Collier County Commissioners. know Ihal we oppose the opemng of a new landfill in our area We do riel agree with your proposed courtly landfill siles because they are all agricultural related areas We do not wahl to grow or eat vegelables near a landfill sile Our farming commumty ~s slruggling enough wilhout lhe landfill. Also, lhe new landfill if choosen in our area. would tarnish Immokalee's imago, hurl ils economy, and hinder developmenl and gro'~h We would hke for you lo lake ~n cons~dorahor~ Ihese suggeslions 1 Identify and solve Ihe odor problem :2 Develope a plan Ihal will enable Collier Counly to deal wilh ils landfill needs wilhoul damag~r~g any agriculture lands 3 Truck Ihe wasle 1o a regional collochon faohly out of lhe counly 4 Use a recycling melhod Smcerely, To, The Board of CoIIrer County Comm~ss~oneers From The Irnmokalee Chamber oi' Commerce and Concerned C~hzens Reference: New t.andhll Sdes Issue We.the citizens and commundy of Immokalee. would INe the Board of Collier County Commissioners know lhal we oppose the opemng el a new landfill in our area We do not agree w~th your proposed county landfdl s~tes because they are all agricultural related areas V,,.,'e do riel want to grow or eat vegetables near a landfill site. Our farming community ~s slrugghng enough w~lhout the landfill. Also. lhe new landfill if choosen ~n our area. would tarmsh Immokaloe's *mage hurt ~ts economy and hinder development and growth , We would like for you to lake ~n cons~derahon these suggesbons: 1, Idenbfy and solve lhe odor problem 2. Develop a plan thai wdl enable Colher Courtly lo de.al wdh ds landfill needs withoul damaging any agriculture lands 3. Truck lhe wasle lo a regional colloclion faolJty out of Ihe counly 4. Use a recychng method Sincerely, To: The ~loard of Colher ,':ourlly Comr'msslorlor:rs ReCerence NewJ_~ncffrll Srloslssue We.the c~tizens and community o¢ Irmnoka ce. v,'ouId hke Ihe ~osrd o¢ Collier Counly Commissioners. know Ihal we oppose lhe opening of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree wJlh your proposed counly Jsndf~lJ sites becsuse Ihey are all agricultural related areas We do nol want lo grow or esl vegetables near a landfill sile Our farming commun~ly Is struggling enough wilhoul Ihe landfill. Also. lhe new landfill if choosen in our area. would tarnish Immokalee's image hurt ils economy and hinder developmenl and gro~h ' ' · We would like for ~'(]LJ I0 lake in consJder8hon Itmse Suggestions 1. Identify and solvrz the odor problem 2. Develope a plan Ihal w~ll enable Colher OOLlnly Jo deal with ils landfill needs wilhoul damaging 8ny agr~cuflure Im~ds 3 Truck Ihe waslo Io ~ regional collochon facddy oul of Ihe courtly 4 Use a recycling nmlhnd Sincere y. 8 B 2__ To The Board of Collier County Comm~ss~oneers From The Immokalee Chamber of Commerce ,'~nd Concerned C~hzens Reference: New Landfill Sties Issue We. ho c I zens and communily of Irnrnokalee. wotJId hke the Board of Collier Counly Commissioners know Ihal we oppose fha open,ag of a new landi'ill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landMI siles because lhey are all agricultural related areas We do not wahl to grow or eal vegelables near a landfill site Our farming communily is struggling enough without lhe landfill. Aisc, Ihe new landfill if choosen in our area. would famish Immokalee's image, h~JrJ ds economy and hinder developmen! and growth ' We would like for you to take in consideralion lhese suqgestions 1. Idenlify and solve the odor problem 2 Develop a plan that will enable Collinr Counly In deal with ils landfill needs wilhoul damaging any agnculture lands 3. Truck Ihe wasfe fo a re¢~onnl collochon fncddy o~d of' fi"m counly 4. Use a recyclinr mefhod Sincere y. 1~ i'he Board o~' CoIl~er Coum¥ Comm~ss~oneers From The lmmokaleo Chamber or Commorce and Cor]cerned Citizens Roferonce New l.and~i~l S*tes We.rhe citizens and corem,ratty o[ lmmokalee, would IrNe Ihe Board of Colher Counly Commissioners know lhal we oppose the openm9 of a new landfill in our area We do nol agree wilh your proposed county landfill s~les because Ihey are all agricullural relaled areas We do not wahl ~o grow or eat vegelables near a landfill sile. Our farming communily is slrugg~ing enough withoul ~he landfill. Also. the new landfill if Choosen in our area. would larnish Immokalee's image, hud its economy, and hinder developmenl and gro~h. We would like rot you ~o lake m consideralion these t. Idenlify and solve lhe odor problem 2, Develop a plan fhat will enable Collier Cotmly In deal wdh ils landfill needs wi[houI damaging any agr~cu lure lands 3. Truck Ihe wasle Io a regional coflecf~on fac~lrly otll of tho county 4. Use a recycling melhod Smcerely, From; The ImmokaeeChnmberorCo~ercenndConc~rnodCd~zens Reference NewLandMfSdeslssuo WeJhe citizens and communffy of fmmokalee, wouM hke Ihe Board of Collier Counly Commrssioners. know that we oppose the opemng of a new landfill in our area We do not agree wdh your proposed county landfill sdes because they are afl agricultural related areas We do not wan[ Io grow or oBI vegetables near a landfill srte Our farming commundy ~s sJrugghng enough wdhou[ the landfill Also, the new landfill if choosen in our area. would larnmh Immokalee's ,maqe hurt ds nconomy, and hinder development and gro~h ' We would hke for you to take ~n conshJorahon lhoso su0goshons 1 Identify and solve ~he odor problem 2 Deve~ope a plan that wdl enable Colher CounJy I~ deal with ~ls landfill needs without damaging any agncullure lands 3 Truck the waste lo a regional collechon famhfy out of lhe county 4 Use a recychng method Sincerely. 8 B z To: The Board of Collier Counly Commissioneers From: The Immokalee Chamber o[ Commerce and Concerned Citizens Rererence: New Landfill Sites Issue. We,lhe cilizens and communily o[ Immokalee. would like ,,he Board of Collier County Commissioners know Ihal we oppose Ihe opening o[ a new landfill in our area. We do nol agree wilh your proposed courtly landfill siles because lhey are all agricullural related areas. We do nol want 1o grow or cai vegelables near a landfill sile. Our farming community is struggling enough wilhout Ihe landfill. A'lso, the new landfill if choosen in our area, would larnish Immokalee's image, ht~rl ils economy, and hinder developmen[ and' grov4h We would like for you Io lake in consideralion lheso suggeslion$: 1. Idenlify and solve lhe odor problem. 2. Develop a plan lhal will enable Collier Courtly Io deal wilh ils landfill needs wilhoul damaging any agricullure lands. 3. Truck Ihe waste to a regional colleclion facility out of lhe courtly. 4. Use a recycling melhod Sincerely, 8 B 2 To: The Board o1' Colher County Comrr,ss~oneers From: The hnmokalee Cl'mmher of Cort~l]l,~.rc.e nf~J Cor'~c.mnod Cdizens Reference Now Landhll S~tes ssur; We,Ihe citizens and commundy of h"r,r~oka ee. wauld hke lhe Board of Collier Counly Commiss oners, know ~ha[ we oppose the opemng of a new landfill in our area. We do not agree with your proposed county landfill sties because.lhey are all agricullural related areas. We do not want to grow or eal vegetables r~ear a landrill sile. Our farming commundy is struggling enough without lhe landfill. Aisc, lhe new landfill if choosen in our area. would larnish Immokalee's imaqe hurt ils economy, and hinder developmenl and growlh - ' We would like [or you lo (ake ~r'~ considerahor~ Ihese. suggeslions. 1. Idenlify and solve the odor problem 2. Develope a plaq Ihal wdl enable Collier CounW lo deal wilh ils landfill needs without damaging any agncullure lands 3. Truck lhe waste Io a regional colleclion facilily oul of lbo counly 4. Use a recycling method Sincerely, To: The Board of Colhor County Comm~ss~oneers From Tho Immokalee Char'nber of Commerce amd (Joncorr~ed Cd~zens Reference: New Landfill S~tes Issue We.the citizens and commumty of Immokalee. would hke the Board of Collier County Commissioners know lhat we oppos,': Ihe opon,~g of a now landfill in our area We do not agree wdh your proposed county landfill s~les because they are all agricultural related areas. We do not want lo grow or eat vegetables near a landfill site. Our farming community is slruggling enough wdhout the landfill. Also. lhe new landfill if choosen in our area. would larmsh h'nmokaleo's ~magc, hurl ds economy and hinder development and grow'th. ' We would like for you to take ~n cons~derahoq these suggestrons 1. Identify and solve lhe odor probh';m 2. Develop a plan thai v.qll enable Colher Coijnty tr~ ,"lr¢,ql w~lh ils I,~ndflll needs wilhout damaging any agr~cullure lands 3. Truck the waste to a regional co[lechon facihly oul elr the COunty. 4. Use a recycling melhod Sincerely, GENERAL RELEASE ST.'\TI'.' ()F FI.ORIDA ('OUNTT ()F ('OI.I.IF~R Know all mtn by these presents, that thc BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COI.I.IF.R COUNTY. ibcrcinaflcr referred to as "Rclcasor(s)"). for anti in consideration of thc General Release of Brctt Wadsworth and Colleen O. Wadsworth, executed on tile eleventh da.,,, of l:cbrttary. 1998, and other good arid valuable consideration, to the Rclcasor(s), executed by Brett Wadsworth and Colleen O. Wads`.vorth, (hereinafter referred to as "Rclcasce(s)"), thc receipt a~nd adequacy of which arc hereby acknov,'ledgcd, has rcmiscd, released, and forever discharged, and by these presents {_It), Ibr themselves, and for their successors, assigns, heir, executors and administrators, rcmise, release, acquit, satisfy and forever discharge the said Releasce(s), and the Rclcasec's shareholders, officers, directors, employees, agents, predecessors in interest, subsidiaries, associalcs, successors, assigns, servants, and representatives, of and from all, and any manner o1' action and actions, cause and causes of action, suits, debts, dues, sums of money, accounts. reckonings, bonds, bills specialties, covenants, '.van'antics, guarantees, contracts, controversies, agreements, promises, variances, trespasses, damages, judgments, executions, liabilities, claims and demands whats~3cvcr, in law or in equity (hereinafter referred to as "claims") (included, but not limited to, any claims that now exist, or may hereafter come into existence, in relation to any indemnity, contribution, subrogation or other third-party claims that have been, or hereafter may be. ;.lsscrlcd againsl the Rcleasor(s) by ;lily person or entity), which against the Releasee the Releasor's ever h'ad. now have. or which tile Rclcasor(s) or tile Rclcasor's successors, assigns, heirs, executors -I- or administrators, now have, may have, or hcruaflcr can, shall or may have, and/or any oFlh¢ claims which ,,','crc or could have bccn asserted in that certain cMl action filed in the United States District Courl. Middle Distr/ct of Florida, Fort Myers Division, under Case Number 95-88-CIV-FTM-23D and titled Brctt Wadsworlh and Colleen O. Wadsworth vs. Board of County Commissioners of ~p!licr Coun_t!Ll.L~a polifica; subdivision of tile .5;late Of Florida, City of Naples, a political subdivisiou 91'thc St;Itc 9f Florida, Richard Clark. Stephen L.Jman, Thomas Bartoc, and Unnamed Dcfcndant~. IN WITNESS WflEREOF, the undersigned have set our hands and seals this ~.~' da.',' of ( -'2 ,,t,'.,~ t,./ _. 1998. / WITNESS: BARBARA B. BERRY Chairperson, Collier County Board of Commissioners WI'['Nt!SS -2- COUN'r¥ OF 'o/,Ze I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this dav, bctbrc me, a Nora .fy Public duly authorized in the sate and county aforcmentie, imd, personally appeared BARBARA B. BERRY, who identified herself to rile by /¥/_¥',0,"1a//tv, ~5'riOt.-.3 ,--'~ (h'rrnt~ftdentificttttonJ. the person described in and ,,,.'ho executed the Iorego~ng and acknowledged before me that he executed same freely and voluntarily. WITNL:SS MY }lAND AND OFFICIAL SEAL in the County and State last aforesaid this NOTARY PUBLIC ........ .. Lawrence S. Pivacek -3- 10, RESOI.UTION NO. 98-5 RESOI.UTION REAPPOINTING ME.h, IBERS TO TIlE OCIIOPEEFIRECONTROi. ADViSORY BOARD. Wilt'~RF, AS, Collicr ('ounty Ordinance No. 75-6 crcalcd thc Ochopee Fire Dist, j;'l and provides for the establishment of an advisory board; and \VttEP, EAS, Collier County Ordinnnce No. 89-98 confirmed tim creation ofthe Ochopee Fire District Advisory Board and provides that the advisory broad shall be composed of five (5) members and such membership shall consist of one (I) member from each of the designated areas; and ~VHEREAS, the terms o£two (2) members expired creating vacancies on this board; and WHEREAS, thc Board of County Commissioners previously provided public notice soliciling applicalions £rom interested parlies; NOW, TIIEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY TIlE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: 1. T. Anlhony Brock meets tile prereqt, isiles for appointment and is hereby reappoinlcd to tile Ochopee Fire Conlro[ Advisory Board for a two year term, said term to expire on December 31, 1999. 2. Michael t-lan meets lhe prerequisites for appointment and is hereby reappointed to the Ochopee Fire Control Advisory Board for a two year term, said term to expire on December 3 I, 1999. 3. Charles R. Reynolds is hereby confirmed for reappointment to the Ochopee Fire Control Advisory Board for a two year term, said lcrrn Io expire on December 31, 1999. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the provisions o£Seclion Seven (b)(I) of Ordinance No. 86-41, as amended, Terms of Office, are hereby waived to al/ow reappointments of T. Anthony Brock, Michael Hah, and Charles R. Reynolds lo tile Ochopee Fire Control Advisory Board. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and unanimous vote. DATED: .la:mary 6, 1998 ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGtIT E. BROCK. Clerk COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ,'" ' B A R'~ A R A- B'B E R ~WL-"-~ai'~ ark_)'~ Approved as to Ibnn and legal sufficiency: David C. Wcigcl County Attorncy DCW/kn e~L'L%: FOR L£CAL ADV~RI~I$[.~G 0£ PL~LXC '0, C,.r. to th, ,o,r,: ':,,,, ,1,c, the roll.tn. ,, ,, ~ No~[ L~lal A~ver:[senenc ~ Other: Leqal Ad, (Display Adv., ~ocaCton, icc.) Ortltnactnl Oepc/O[v:Public Works Divisi~tson~ Prohibiting Swales/Culverts in Naples Park ~,tttt~ ~o..(I~ non~, ~[v, brt,~ de,crt~tt~)~ providing for right-of-way permit. ~e:[:~o~r: (N~ & addresl): Stormwater Management Dept. Nm & Address of any persons(s) to be noctfted by C~erk'$ Offtce: Reartn$ before: ~ BCC ~ 5L~ ~Other R~que~ted heartn~ date: ]/6./9~ Based on advertisement appearing ]~ days before ~lpa~r(i) to be used: (Co~plete only tf t~porc:nc ~, ~ ~apte~ Oat~y N~I or ~ela~y requtred ~) ~ Oc~r ~ropoaed T~C: (~nc~ude Lcla~ description & co~n ~ocatton & ~tze)~ Pn] ] imf ~nun~y Prohibition Ordinance - Naples Park. (see attached text) Cc~.panto~ petition(s), t~ any, & proposed heartnI dace: - Does Petttton Tee Znc~ude Advert:sCaI Cost? Ye~ ~ ~o ~ Z~ yeJ~ ~t accent Ih~d be for adverctJtnl co.ca partment D:rector DiviSion Admlnlstr Lt3t Actac~nr j:(%) (2) (~) A. rot heartn~ before ~CC or ~: 1ntt[actaI person to complete one copy and obtatn Otvt~ton ~ead approva~ . . before su~a~tttnE to County ~u~aler. ~: If lees1 doc~e~t ts [nvolved~ be sure. thxt any nece~sa~ re~tev, or request for sa~e. Is submt:te,l':o C~uncv At:ornev before lubmttc~n~ to County ~bnater. Hanz~er'~ Office v:[X distribute copter: -- ~ County Hanag~r aienda gtie; ~ Request[nR Olvtston; ~ Ort~tna~ to C~erk', I. Other hearin~: Xntttattnl Oivtsion Head to approve ~nd subni: ortstna~ to'C~erk'l Office, tetatntnl a copt ~R CLUE'S OFFICE USE ~LY Date Recetved Date Adverttsed ~te of Ii1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111.111111 Z']L~ HO. ~ Z63.-~486~ 12C 1 December 12, 1997 Ms. Judith F]anagan Naples Daily t.;ews 1075 Central Avenue Naples, Florida 34102 Re: Ordinance regarding Swales/Culverts in Naples Park Dear Judi: Please advertise the above referenced notice one time on Friday, December 26, 1997 and send the Affidavit of Publication, in duplicate, together with charges involved to this office. Sincerely, Jody S. Ku_hne, Deputy Clerk Purchase Order #601195 12C 1 NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER ORDINANCE Notice is hereby given that on TUESDAY,JANUARY 6, 1998, in the Boardroom, 3rd Floor, Administration Building, Collier County Governmenl~ Center, 3301 East Tam[ami Trail, Naples, Florida, the Board of County Commissioners will consider the enactment of a County Ordinance. The meeting will commence at 9:00 A.M. The title of the proposed Ordinance is as follows: AN ORDIr,/ANCE PROHIBITING THE CON-VERSION OF SWALES TO CULVERTS IN THE PUB[ IC RIGHTS-OF-WAy WITHIN AN AREA OF NAPLES PARK, A PLATTED SUBDIVISION LOCATED iN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA UNLESS A COLLIER CO[PITY PERMIT IS OBTAINED; PROVIDING FINDINGS AND PURPOSE; PROVIDING TITLE AND CITATIONS; PROVIDING APPLICABILITY; PROVIDING FOR TYPE OF PERMIT AND PROCEDURE; PROVIDING FOR RESPONSIBILITIES ASSUMED BY THE PERMITTER; PROVIDING FOR THE TYPE OF MATERIALS ACCEPTABLE EOR [3SE; PROVIDING FOR SiZE OF PIPE REQUIRED; PROVIDING FOP, INSPECTI©N OF PERMITTED INSTALLATIONS; PROVIDING FOR TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR INSTALLATION; PROVIDING PENALTIES; PROVIDING CONFLICT AND SEVERABILtTY; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN CODE OF LAWS AND ORDIi;ANCES AND EFFECTIVE DATE, Copies of the proposed Ordinance are on file with the Clerk ~o the Board and are available for inspection. Ail interested parties are invited to attend and be heard. Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the Board will need a record of ~he proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is ~,,a,e, :..'hich record includes the testimony and evidence upon which ~he appeal is based. BOARD <:F COUNTY COHHISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA TIMOTHY L. i{ANCOCK, CHAIR~L\N DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK By: /s/JODY S. KUEHNE, Deputy Clerk (SEAL) 12C December 12, 1997 Collier County Government Center 3301 East Tamiami Trail Naples, FI, 34112 Attn: John fl. Boldt Stormwater Management Dept. Re: Proposed Ordinance prohibiting the conversion of swales to culverts in the public rights-of-way within an area of Naples Park Dear Petitioner: Please be advised that the above referenced petition will be considered by the Board of County Commissioners on Tuesday, January 6, 1998 as indicated on the enclosed notice. The legal notice pertaining to this petition will be published in the Naples Daily News on Friday, December 26,1997. You are invited to attend this public hearing. Sincerely, Jody S. Kuehne, Deputy Clerk Eric 1. ORI)IN,\NCE NO. 9% AN ORDIN:\NCE I'ROIIIIHTING Tile CONVERSION OF SWALES TO CUI.VERTS IN 'FILE PUBIAC RIGIITS-OF-WAY WITtlIN AN AREA OF N:\PI.ES PARK. A PI.ATTEI) SUBDIVISION LOCATED IN COLLIER COUNTY, FI.ORIDA UNIA'iSS A COIAJER COUNTY PERMIT IS OBTAINED; PROVIDING FINDINGS AND PURPOSE; PROVIDING TITI.E ,\ND CITATION; PROVIDING APPLICABILITY; PROVIDING FOR TYPE OF PER.MFI' AND PROCEDURE; PROVIDING FOR RESPONSIBII.ITIES ASSUMED BY TIIE PEP, MITTEE; PROVIDING FOR TIIE TYPE OF MATERIALS ACCEPTABLE FOR USE; PROVIDING FOR SIZE OF PIPE REQUIRED; PROVIDING FOR INSPECTION OF PERMFI'TED INSTAI.I,ATIONS; PROVIDING FOR TECtINICAI, SPECIFICATIONS FOP, INSTALLATION; PROVIDING I"F. NAI.TI I';S; I'I~,OVII)ING CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY; I'ROVIDING F'OP, INCI.US1ON IN CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES AND EFFECTIVF~ I),.VI'E. WtIEP, F~.,\S, it has bccn a common practice within the Naples Park Subdivision area, Collier County. Florida, for individual homeowners to enclose roadside swales in front of their homes v,'ith small diameter pipes and earthen cover material, and; WI IEREAS, this practice reduces thc area available for utilization of grass-lined swales for stomp, valor quality treatment and water table aquifer recharge, and; WHEREAS, replacing the relatively large grassy roadside swales with small diameter pipes greatly reduces Ibc volume of stormwater runoff retention/detention storage that was available in thc swales and thus increases thc peak rate of discharge into the drainage systems outlets which increases thc potential for flooding in the area, and; WI IEREAS, CoIIicr County has in the past issued pcrmits under the Public Rights-of- Way Ordinance, Collier County Ordinance No. 82-91, as amended, to individual homeowners to enclose roadside swales in front of their homes with small diameter pipes, and; \VIIERE,,\S, in rcsponsc to thc County's application to the Florida Department of Enviroumc:'md Protection (FDEI') for approval for construction of major capital improvements to thc Naples Park primary drainaL-'c out!hlls. FDEP has modified the Special Conditions on the proposed project to thc fi'~llo,.ving: "The Pcrmittee shall allow the construction of a shallow swalc underlain by a slotted or perforated pipe within a crashed stone envelope, by property ov.'ncrs requesting this swale enclosure modification of swales on or adjacent to their property."; and ]2C WtlERf'_'AS, thc Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida has determined that it is in the public interest and the health, safety and welfare of the citizens of Collier County to allow the conversion of swales lo culvcrls in tim public rights-of-way within the Naples Park Subdivision located in Collier County, Florida, upon certain conditions as set forth in this Ordinance. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY TI-tE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that SECTION ONE: FINDINGS AND PURPOSE Thc Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, (hereinafter the "Board") docs hereby find and determine that it is in the public interest and the health, safety and welfare of its cili×cns to allow the convcrsioa of swales to culverts in the public rights-of-way within an area of Naples Park. a platted subdivision located in Collier County, Florida, provided a permit is obtained pursuant to this Ordinance. SECTION TWO: TITLE AND CITATION This Ordinance shall be known and may be cited ,'is the "Collier County Swale/Culvert Ordinance - Naples Park." SECTION TItREE: APPhlCABILITY This Ordinance shall apply to and be enforced in that area of Collier County, Florida known generally as "Naples Park", the specific area thereof for the purposes of this Ordinance is bounded by thc ccntcrlincs of thc following public roadways: A. 111°' Avenue on the North; B. U.S. 41 on thc East; C. 91" Avenue on the South; D. Vanderbilt Drive on the West. SECTION FOUR: I'ERMIT REQUIRED AND PROCEDURE No ov.,ncl' of il parcel of property may install a drainage culvert including pipes or other appurtenances in thc swales irt the public rights-of-way within the Naples Park Subdivision unless a permit is obtained. Thc owner of a parcel of property, or duty authorized agent, (hereinafter referred to as "Owner" or "Pcnnittee") shall apply for a right-of-way permit pursuant to the procedures set for in Ordinance No. 93-64, as it may bc amended from time to time, or its successor ordinance. 12C 1 SECTIO~ FIVE: RECORD KEEPING OF COUNTY The County T~ansponation Department will keep a record of all right-of-way use pe~its in thc Naples Park subdivision for the enclosure of sv,'ales and will prepare an annual report which will be sent each JanuaO' to thc Florida Dcparlment of Environmental Protection (FDEP), or its successor, i f requested. SECTION SIX: RESPONSIBILITIES ASSUMED BY PERaMITTEE Pcn'nittce will utilize the services of a contractor properly licensed to perform this type of work in Collier County. The Permittee is responsible for payment of all construction for the swale enclosure. Pcn'nittee will also pa.',' for all costs required to replace missing, damaged or deteriorated piping and related materials in the future. If the County is required to replace missing, damage or deteriorated piping because of health, safety and welhre considerations, the Perminee or his/her successor will pay the County all costs incurred by the County after written notice of thc costs is provided by County to thc Pcrmittee. SECTION SEVEN: TYPE OF MATERIALS ACCEPTABLE FOR USE The Pcnnittee shall provide a copy of the drawing of the swale enclosure to the County, whir~h shall comply with the approved design of swale enclosures prepared by the consulting firm of Agnoli, Barber, and Brundage, Inc., a copy of which is attached as Exhibit "A" (dated Rcv. 4/11/97) and incorporated herein by reference. A. Thc Pcrmittee shall design the enclosure using this design unless other,vise approved by the Cotmty. B. The materials used by Permittee or its agent shall meet Florida Department of Transportation quality standards. C. Thc usc of galvanized corrugated metal pipe will not be permitted. Approved pipe materials shall include sloued reinforced concrete pipe (Class II1), perforated smooth interior-walled high density polyethylene pipe, or perCorated aiuminized steel Type 2 spiral rib pipe (14 gage minimum). SECTION EIGtlT: SIZE OF PIPE REQUIRED Thc size of pipe shall vary between locations, depending upon the street address. The following list provides pipe sizes for the various street and blocks: 91'~ Ave. N. 500, 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 9? Ave. N. 500.600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 93'5 Ave. N. 500.600 & 800 18" diameter 700 24" diameter 94'h Ave. N. 500, 600 & 800 18" diameter 700 24" diameter 95'~' Ave. N. 500 24" diameter 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 96~' Ave. N. 500 24" diameter 600, 700 & 800 18" diameter 97o' Ave. N. 500 24"diameter 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 98'~' Ave. N. 500 24" diameter 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 99'~ Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 100' Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 101" Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 102"J Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 103'd Ave. N. 500 & 600 24" diameter 700 & 800 18" diameter 104m Ave. N. 500 & 600 24" diameter 700 & 800 18" diameter 105"' Arc. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter I06~h Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 107~ Ave, N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter I08'" Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 109'~' Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter I I0'" Ave. N. 500 & 800 18" diameter 600 & 700 24" diameter I I 1a Ave. N. No new swale enclosures allowed. Vanderbilt Drive (East side) 91~' Ave. N. to 110'" Ave. N. 24" diameter 110'~' Ave. N. to I 11'~' Ave. N. 18" diameter ' 6'" Street N. All Blocks 18" diameter 7'" Street N. All Blocks 18" diameter 8'h Street N. No new swale enclosures allowed. * Note 19" x 30" slotted pipe can be used in place of 24" diameter pipe when needed. 12C 1 SECTION NINE: INSPECTION OF PERMITTED INSTALLATIONS County Community Development Services staff will provide periodic inspections of the swale cnclosurc installations to ensure compliance with thc right-of-way permit and this Ordinance. Within thirty days of completion of thc installation, a final inspection must be made and notice of compliance provided to tire County Transportation Department. SECTION 'FEN: TECttN1CAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR INSTALLATION Thc installations must be in compliance witl~ thc following specifications: Localion of Property Corners ancj W,ql¢r/Wastewatcr Service Lines: Prior to issuance ora Right-of-Way Usc Permit for swale enclosure, thc property owner's contractor will locate the front lot property corner markers and thc water and wastewater service lines. The County Water and Wastcwatcr I)epar~mcnts shall he requested to mark thc approximate line locations on the ground surface and thc owner's contractor shall carefully uncover thc lincs to check for elevation conflicts with thc proposed swalc modifications. Tire Right-of-Way Usc Permit application shall include this information. Ifa conflict occurs, the application shall contain adequate drawings and written statements to provide for a proper resolution of the conflict(s), including the possibilities of lowcrin?aising thc utility sca'ice line(s) by the County Water and Wastcwater Departments staff. All costs to raise or lower the County utility service lines will be borne by the Permittee. lrcnchir.~g: Excavation of the existing swale to accommodate the proposed underlain pipe and rock lrcnch shall extend to provide a minimum ofone foot (1') ofrock on both sities of the pipe, si;: inches (6") on the top and bottom ortho pipe, and six inches of soil backfill over top of thc rock trench. During the course of thc construction activities, excavated material shall be placed in such a manner as to not restrict traffic movements along the street or avenue. _GA.x~tcxtilc Installation: A nonwovcn gcotextil¢ fabric with a minimum ,,,,'eight of 4 ounces per square yard (e.g. Mirafi NL140, Typar 3401, Synthetic Industries P0451. etc.) shall be placcd in the excavated trcnci~ to separate thc rock trench from thc surrounding soil. Sufficient fabric shall bc provided to allow for a one foot (1 ') overlap at all seams. A second layer of fabric shall be wrapped directly around thc pipe with a minimum one foot (1 ') overlap at all seams. ILock Trcr~ch Installation: The rock trench shall be constructed using a washed. Florida Department of Transportation certified No. 57 stone. The stone shall be wrapped by the outer 12g 1 layer o£ gcotcxtilc fabric and shall extend a minimum of one foot (1') of rock on both sides of the pipe and six inches (6") on the top and bottom of the pipe. ?l~lcement of ?ipc: After the bottom six inch (6") thickness of rock trench is placed, the inner layer of fabric shall be placed in the trench and the pipe laid to proper grade. All pipe connections shall be secure and thc inner layer of fabric wrapped completely around thc pipe with a minimum one foot (1') o:'crlap at ali seams. Placement of the rock trench around the sides and over thc top of thc pipc shall be perforated with due care to prevent the movement of thc pipe. For pipe utilizing bell and spigot connections, the bell shall be laid in the upstream direction of llow. P[accment of Risers: Twelve inch (12") diameter minimum risers shall be installed to alIow the shallow swale to discharge into the underlying pipe. The recommended configuration utilizes a manuh~¢lurcd "T" section but the use of Florida Deparlment of Transportation Type owner prefers thc catch basin installation. The top of the riser shall extend six inches (6") above tile bottom of thc swale. A cast iron slotted grate shall be installed at the top of the riser. Where reinforced concrete pipe is used. tile grate shall be placed in the pipe 'nell. Where other pipe materials arc used, thc grate shall be placed in a reinforced precast concrete collar sized to fit the grate ami pipe material. Minimun~ dimensions for thc reinforced prccast collar are six inch (6") thickness and twenty-four inch (24") oulside diameter (or 24" square outside dimension). The prccast collar will be mudded to the riser pipe and placed on compacted backfill material. Where neighbors cnclosc the swale, only one riser needs to be installed for each segment of regraded shallow swale. Placcnw_u~?Ll~n.d Berm: When the neighboring property utilizes an open swale system instead of an enclosed swale system, an end bem~ shall be constructed to separate the new rcgradcd shallow swale from thc adjoining open swale. Thc purpose is to force all of the water £rom the rcgradcd shallow swale to drain into the riser inlet and into the underlying perforated pipe. Thc top clcvation ofthe end berm will be six inches (6") higher than the riser inlet. .~d Treatment of Pipe: Wbcn the neighboring property utilizes an open swale system instead of an enclosed swale system, a mitered end section with concrete collar shall be required at the end of the pipe (unless thc County's Right-of-Way permit review determines the location 6 is not appropriate anti deletes this mitered end section requirement) anti the neighbor's swale bottom shall be rcgradcd (maximum bottom slope of 4 horizontal to I vertical) to connect to the installed perforated pipe invert (bottom inside elevation). When the neighboring property utilizes an enclosed s~vale system, and either the pipes arc different materials or invert elevations do not match, a Florida Department of Transportation Type "C" catch basin shall be utilized to make tt~¢ connection. This Type "C" catch basin ',viii also fimction as the riser inlet. When the neighboring property utilizes an enclosed s;valc system, and the pipe materials and invert elevations match, the pipes shall be connected directly, Backfilling and Rcgradiag_9.~',qllow Swale: Upon proper placement of the pipe within the rock trench, the nonwoven geotextile fabric shall be overlapped a minimum of one foot (1 ') across the top of thc rock and backfill sandy soil material placed a minimum ofsix inches (6") beneath the botton-i of the shallow swale and rcgraded to the proper longitudinal and side slopes. Maximum side slopes for the shallow (14" deep) rcgradcd swale arc 3 horizontal to 1 vertical. Thc longitudinal slope of thc swale shall be dircctcd toward thc riscr inlet(s). When a reinforced concrete collar is used to secure thc grate to the riser, the backfill material shall be '&oroughly compacted to prevent scttlemem and ensure that thc collar can support any weight placed on the grate. ~.5_Q~14ing and J2 aLo_~21l.t:-:2LQf_~lZdlL_klcrs: Upon completion ofregrading, the disturbed areas shall be sodded with the same type sod as the remainder of the yard, with the exception that where Floratam sod is proposed, the owner must provide for adequate sprinklers to keep the sod alive. Finished elevations must not project above the edge of pavement and shall be in conformance with the detail drawing prepared by Agnoli, Barber and Brundage, Inc. attached as Exhibit "A". Sprinklers shall not be installed within the Right-of-Way. Any sprinkler installations shall be on the owners property and shall utilize spray heads that can cast water across thc width of thc swale. SECTION El,EVEN: PEN.-\IJI'I ES If any person fails or refuses to obey or comply with or violates any of the provision of this Ordinance, such person upon conviction of such offense, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and shall be punished by a fine not to exceed Five Hundred Dollars (5500.00) or by !2C 1 imprisonment not to exceed (60) days in the County jail, or both, in the discretion of the Court. Each violation or non-compliance shall be considered a separate offense. Nothing hcrcin contained shall prevent or restrict thc County from taking such other lawful :~ction in any court of competent jurisdiction as is necessary to prevent or remedy any violation or non-compliance. Such other lawful actions shall include, but shall not be limited to, an equitable action For injunctive relic[ or an action at law for damages. Further, nothing in this Section shall be construed to prohibit thc County from prosecuting any violation of this Ordinance by means of Code Enforcement Board established pursuant to thc authority of Chapter 162. Florida Statutes. All rcFncdics and penaitics provided for in this Section shall be cumulative and independently available to the County and the County shall be attthorized to pursue any and all remedies set ford~ in this Section to thc full extent allowed by law. SECTION TWELVE: CONFLICT ANDSEVERABILITY In the event this Ordinance conflicts with any other ordinance of Collier County or other applicable law, thc more rcstr/ctivc shall apply. If any phrase or portion of the Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by an.'.' court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion. SECTION TIlIRTEEN: INCLUSION IN TIlE CODE OF LAWS AND ORDIN..MNCES Thc provisions of t~',is Ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County. Florida. The sections of the Ordinance may be renumbered or rclettercd to accomplish such, and thc word "ordinance" may be changed to "section", "article", or any other appropriate word. SECTION FOURTEEtN: EFFECTIVE DATE This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the Department of State. P.,\SSED AND DULY ADOPTED by thc Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this day of 1997. ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA By: TIMOTHY L. HANCOCK, CHAIRaMAN Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: Heidi F. Ashton Assistam County Attorney cw\f:'.Ordinancc~Naples P~tk Rights-~f-W,~y 9 L T:~':£ .'-£TAIL TO =-E Uc-_.ED I,',I CC¢~JUNC?,CN ~fTH "J'HE FRC..~eS-~D C,CNDIT, CNS DRAINACE ,'~?._E$ PARK AS P.=.z?AR?D BY A~CL~, =..AR~--R & BRUNDAG~ INC. F'iL.~. NO, CF C?,_L, zl,~ C,9UNT'T P£P,M{?. T~i$ efTA,'[. IS NOT APPLICABLE TO Illth A%r-_ 2_ 7~£ C£N~-RACTCR/CQuNTy 5HALL NO~t-Y Alt A~PROPRIAT~ U~UTY C~miPANIES ~E:.'N.';,','Ag AT ~,~E H;G:-~ P~INT O~. THE 5~AINAGE DI%4DE. SUC~ AS ['R.D~J 6T~ TO '~f-f.'~ US;ND 24' OR lg'x20' SLO~D RC~, THE ROCK ~CH DIVISIONS SHALL CZ ~-5 P:PE. ~f ~E C IN~S 5HA~ ES ROTA~ AS NECES$~T TO ACCEPT ~. ~LL ~=f~S D,'S~J,~E~ BT CONS~UC~CH SHA~ BE SODDED ~7H ~-:E SA~E ~E 5f I,'/ CCNFC,~.'J~.','CE ~ff ~d:S DETA:L ~':D ~E CO~'~ COUN~ PZR~I~ ~LA. ~EG. ,'~0. 40254// NAPLES PARK ~GA?LI, 8A,g~'ER & ~PJJNDAGE, INC. =~ ,~ - 740u TA,¢f;AHI TRAIL ~ORTH SECONDARY D,,~I,N..Cc SYSTEM DATE: FEB. 10, 1997 NAPLES. FLORIDA 55~03 SHEET: 1 ~F J REV.~APRIL 11,1997 ACAD: ~i52DEP EXRIBIT "A" 50.00' 50.00' R.C.,~, '~E' a sLo~,:9 R.c.P. ~ ROCK ~[,VCH CUL~T AND INST~LL ~8' SLO~9 R.C.P. q~:~ &' ~' 'l,h'__, NAPLES .......... ~=~;_ ~n.: INC. SECONDARY D,EAtNAGE SYSTEM FRAIL ~O~F~ DATE: FE~. 10, NAPLES, .:LC,,~ID.~ Z410~ ~~ SHEET: 2 OF 3 REV. AP,RIL 11,1~97 AC.AD: EXB~B~ "A" ~~.)!,)~~,~ co~~ cou~'~, · ~ .. - ~ .::,,,,t~:,~v' ..... . ..... ~) $ECOND.A~Y DR.AINA~: DATE: /~.vf..~,~l T.CA/L NO.~ TH ~- ~, N,A~LE5. FLC,,~O.:, 2.~05 ~ SHEET: REV. APRIL 11, lo~7. ,~,~ - --_ Naples Daily News Naples, FL 33940 Affidavit of Publication Naples 0aily News e0ARO OF COUNTY CO.. SS O.ERS 0110 0RDINAI .S ATTN: NANCY SALOGUB P0 BOX ~0~6 ~OFINTENT NAPLES FL )~0~-]0~6 ToCONSI~R ORDINAN~ ~J~ is hereby giv~ that on JANUARY 6_1~, In ~ ml-r C~ ~ernm~ REFERENCE: ~1230 ~551 ~er 3~1 E~t Ta~? 57614054 NOTICE 0F IN~ENT T0 mi Tr~ll N~les, State of Florida ~e en~men~ ~ o County of Collier O~l~e. The ~.~ Before the undersigned authority, personally A.~. ~he ~,e ~ ~ ~e appeared Judith A. FLanigan, ~ho on oath says that ~ ~dl~nce J~ ~ she serves as an agent of the Naples Daily News, a AN ~DINANCE PRO- daily newspaper published at Naples, in Collier HIBITING THE CON- County, Florida: that the attached copy of ~RSIONTo CuL~RTsOF SWALESiN THE advertising was publish~ in said newspaper on PUBLICwAY WITHINRIGHTS'OF'AN dates listed. OF NA~E5 PARK, A o~ATTED S~IVI~N Affiant further says that the said Naples Daily ;~AT~n IN C~LIER Ne~s is a newspaper published at Naples, in said ~%?,;~ FLORIDA ~iNLESS A COLLIE Collier County, Florida, ,~ that the said ~0~TY PERMIT newspaper has heretofore been continuously OBTAINED; PROVID- published in said Collier County, Florida, each lNG FINDINGS ANO PURPO~; pR OVIDtNG day and has been entered as second class ~i l TITLE AND CITZTION5; matter at the ~st office in Naples, in said pROVIDiNG APPLICA- Collier County, Florida, for a peri~ of I year BILITY; PROVIDING' F~ TYPE OF PER~IT next preceding the first publication of the AND pROCEDURE; attached cc,-.y of advertisement; and affiant PRO~DING FOR RE. 5PONSIBILITIES AS- further says that she has neither paid ~r 5U~EO ~Y TH~ promised any person, firm or co~ration any pERMITTEE; PROVID- ING FOR THE TYPE OF discount, rebate, commission or refund for the MATERIALS ACCEPT- pur~se of securing this advertisement for ~LE F~ U~: ~O- VIDING FOR gZE ~ publication in the said newspaper. PIPE REQUIRED; ~O- VIDING F~ INaC- TION OF pERMI~ED PUBLISHED ON: 12/26 iNSTALLATIONS; PRO- VIDING F~ TECHNI- CAL SPECIFICATION5 FOR iNSTALLATION; PROVIDING PENAL- TIES' PROVIDING CON- F L'l C T AND sEVERABILITY' PRO- V$DING FOR 'INCLU- AD SPACE: 94.~ iNCH S~ON IN CODE OF FILED ON: 12/26/97 LAWS AND ORDI- NANCES AND EFFEC- ................................................................... TIVE DATE. 3 C~i~ of ~e priDed Signature of Affiant ,.. "~, ,, . Sworn to and Subscribed 'before me this ; c day of / [ · c 19'., ~. All I~t~ ~ Personally known by me r~Q ~ '/~~~ pertaining ~er~O COLLIER couNTY,J FLORIDA TIMOTHY L. HANC~K,J CHAIR~N DWIGHT E. BROCK,J CLERK By: Isl J~Y S. KUEHNE, ORI)INANCI,; NO. 98- I ,.\N ORDINANCE PROIIIB1TING 'FILE CONVERSION OF SWAI.ES TO CUI,VERTS IN TIlE PUBi.IC Ri(;IITS-OF-WAY WITIIIN AN AREA OF NAPLES PARK, A PI.AT'FED SUBDIVISION I.OCATED IN COI.I.IER COUNTY, FI,ORIDA UNI,ESS A COIAAER COUNTY PERMIT IS OWFAINED; PROVIDING FINDINGS AND PURPOSE; PROVIDING T1TI.E AND CITATION; PROVIDING APPI.ICABII,ITY; PROVIDING I:OR TYPE OF PERMIT AND PROCEDURE; PROVIDING FOR RESPONSIBII.ITIES ASSUMED BY TIIE PERMITTEE; PROVIDING FOR TIlE TYPE OF MATERIAI,S ACCEPTABI,E FOR USE; PROVIDING FOR SIZE OF PIPE REQUIRED; PROVIDING FOR INSPECTION OF PERMITTED INSTALLATIONS; PROVIDING FOR TECIlNICAI, SPECIFICATIONS FOR INSTAI,LATION; PROVIDING PENAl,TIES; PROVIDING CONFI.ICT AND SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR INCI,USION IN CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES ANI) EFFECTIVE I)ATE. WItEREAS, it has been a common practice within thc Naples Park Subdivision ama, Collier County. Florida. Ibc individual homeowners to enclose roadside swales in front of their hol'ileS with small diameter pipes and earlhen cover material, and; Vv'tIER[{AS, this practice reduces the area available for utilization of grass-lined swales [bt stormwatcr quality treatment and water table aqui£er recharge, and; WHERE,,\S, replacing the relatively large grassy roadside swales with small diameter pipes greatly reduces the votun~c of stonmvatcr runoff retention/detention storage that ,.,,'as available in thc swales and tlms increases the peak rate of discharge into thc drainage systems outlets which increases Ibc potential for flooding in the ama, and; WItEREAS, Collier County has in the past issued pemdts under the Public Rights-of- Way Ordinance, Collier County Ordinance No. 82-91, as amended, to individual homeowners to enclose roadside swales in front of their homes with small diameter pipes, and; WHEREAS, in response to thc County's application to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) for approval for construction of major capital improvements to the Naples Park primary drainage outfalls, FDEP bas modified the Special Conditions on the proposed project to the following: "The Pcm'fittce shall allow thc construction of a shallow swale underlain by a slotted or perforated pipe within a cmsbcd stone envelope, by property owners requesting this swale enclosure modification or swales on or adjacent to their property."; and WI IEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida has determined that it is in the public interest and Ibc bealth, safety and welfare of the citizens of Collier County to allow thc conversion of swales to culverts in tire public rights-of-way v,'ithin the Naples Park Subdivision located in Collier County, Florida, upon certain conditions as set [brth in this Ordinance. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that SECTION ONE: FINDINGS AND PURPOSE Thc Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, (hereinafter thc "Board") docs hcrcby find and dctcrminc that it is in tire public interest anti tire health, safety and welfare of its citizens to allow thc conversion of swales to culverts in the public rights-of-way within an arca of Naples Park, a platted subdivision located in Collier County, Florida, provided a pcrmit is obtaincd pursuant to this Ordinance. SECTION TWO: TITLE AND CITATION This Ordinance shall be known and may be cited as thc "Collier County Swale/Culvert Ordinancc- Naples Park." SECTION TItREE: APPLICABILITY 'I'his Ordinance shall apply to anti be enforced in that area of Collier County, Florida known generally as "Naplcs Park", tile specific area thereof for the purposes of this Ordinance is bounded by thc ccntcrlincs of Ibc following public roadways: A. I I 1'~' Avenue on the North; B. U.S. 41 oll Ibc East; C. 91" Avenue on the South; D. Vandcrbilt Drive on the West. SECTION FOUR: PERMIT REQUIRED AND PROCEDURE No owner of a parcel of property may install a drainage culvert including pipes or other appurtcnanccs in the swales in thc public rights-of-way within the Naples Park Subdivision unless a pcn'nit is obtained. Thc owner of a parcel of property, or duly authorized agent, (hcrcinaftcr rcfcrred to as "Owner" or "Pcmfittcc") shall apply for a right-of-way permit pnrsuant to thc proccdurcs sct for in Ordinance No. 93-64, as it may be amended from lime to time, or its successor ordinance. 1 2C1 SECTION FIVE: RECORD KEEPING OF COUNTY Thc Cotmty Transportation Dcparlmcnt will keep a record of all right-of-way usc permits in tile Naples Park subdivision For the enclosure of swales and will prepare an annual repot1 which will lac sent each January to tile Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), or its successor, if requested. SECTION SIX: RESPONSIBILITIES ASSUMED BY PERMITTEE Pcrmittcc will utilize thc services ora contractor properly licensed to perform this type of work ill Collier County. The Pcmfittcc is responsible for payment of all construction for tile swale enclosure, l~crmittee ,,viii also pay for all costs required to replace missing, damaged or deteriorated piping and related materials in thc ft,ture. If the County is required to replace missing, dalllagc or deteriorated piping because of health, safety and welfare considerations, the Pcrmittc¢ or his/her successor will pay the County all costs incurred by tile County after written notice of thc costs is provided by County to tile Pcrmittee. SECTION SEVEN: TYPE OF MATERIALS ACCEPTABLE FOR USE Thc Permittcc shall provide a copy of the drawing of the swale enclosure to the County, which shall comply wid~ the approved design of swale enclosures prepared by the consulting firm of Agnoli, Barber, and Brunda;;c, Inc., a copy of which is attached as Exhibit "A" (dated Rev. 4/11/97) and incorporated herein by reference. A. Thc Pcrmittce shall design the enclosure using this design unless otherwise approved by thc County. B. Thc materials used by Permittee or its agent shall meet Florida Department of Transportation quality standards. C. Thc usc of galvanized corrugated metal pipe will not be permitted. Approved pipe materials shall include slotted reinforced concrete pipe (Class llI), perforated smooth interior-walled high density polyethylene pipe, or perforated aluminized steel Type 2 spiral rib pipe (t4 gage nfinimum). !2C1 '' SECTION EIGIlT: SIZE OF PIPE REQUIRED Thc size of pipe shall vary between locations, depending upon Iht street address. Tile li)llowing list provides pipe si×es For the various street and blocks: Street N;llllc Block Numbcrfs/ Minimum Pipe Size* 91" Ave. N. 500, 600, 700, & 800 18" diamcler 92'''t Ave. N. 500, 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 93r'~ Ave. N. 500, 6(10 & 8010 18 "diameter 700 24" diameter 94" Ave. N. 500,600 & 800 18" diameter 700 24" diameter 95'h Ave. N. 5(/0 24" diameter 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 96'" Ave. N. 500 24" diameter 600, 700 & 800 18" diameter 97'~' Ave. N. 500 24" diameter 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 98'~' Ave. N. 500 24" diameter 600, 700, & 800 18" diameter 99'h Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 80(1 18" diameter 10ft" Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 101 *' Ave. N. 500 & 7(10 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 102'''~ Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter I 0Ya Ave. N. 500 & 600 24" diameter 700 & 800 18" diameter 104''Avc. N. 500 & 600 24" diameter 700 & 800 18" diameter 105'" Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 106" Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 107"' Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 108'~' Avc. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter 109' Ave. N. 500 & 700 24" diameter 600 & 800 18" diameter I 10® Ave. N. 500 & 800 18" diameter 600 & 700 24" diameter 1 I I" Ave. N. No new swale enclosures allowed. Vandcrbih Drive (East side) 91" Ave. N, to 110"' Ave. N. 24" diameter I I0'~ Ave. N. to 111'~ Ave. N. 18" diameter 6'~' Street N. All Blocks 18" diameter 7" Street N. All Blocks 18" diameter 8"' Street N. No new swale enclosures allowed. * Note 19" x 30" slotted pipe can be used in place of 24" diameter pipe when needed. 12C1 SECTION NINE: INSPECTION OF I'ERMITTED INSTALLATIONS County Community I)¢vclopment Scr'viccs staff will provide periodic inspections of the swale enclosure installations 1o ensure compliance with the right-of-way permit and this Ordinancc. Within thirty days of completion of thc installation, a final inspection must be made and notice of compliance provided to thc County Transportation Department. SECTION TEN: TECIINICAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR INSTALLATION The inslallations must be in compliance with the following specifications: Location of Property Corners and Water/Wastcwater Service Lines: Prior to issuance ora Right-ofIWay Usc Pcnnit Ibr sxvalc enclosure, thc properly owner's contractor ,.','ill locate the front lot property comer markers and thc water and wastewater sen, ice lines. The County Water and Waslewatcr Departments shall be requested lo mark lhe approximate line locations on the groumt surface and the owner's contractor shall carefully uncover the lines to check for elevation conflicts with thc proposed swale modifications. The Right-of-Way Use Pernfit application shall include this in formation, l fa conflict occurs, thc application shall contain adequate drawings and written statements to provide for a proper resolution of the conflict(s), including the possibilities of lowering/raising the utility service line(s) by the County Water and Wastewater Departments staff. All costs to raise or lower the County utility service lines will be borne by the Permittee. Trcnching: Excavation of the existing swale to accommodate the proposed underlain pipe and rock trench shall extend to provide a minimum alone foot (I ') arrack on both sides of the pipe, six inches (6") on thc top and bottom of the pipe, and six inches ofsoil backfill over lop of thc rock trench. During the course of the construction activities, excavated material shall be placed in such a manner as to not restrict traffic movements along the street or avenue. Gcotcxtile Installation: A nonwoven geotextile fabric wilh a minimum weight of 4 ounces per square yard (e.g. Mirafi N LI40, Typnr 3401, Synthetic Industries P0451, etc.) shall be placed in the excavated trench to separate thc rock trench from the surrounding soil. Sufficient fabric shall be provided to allow for a one foot (1 ') overlap at all seams. A second laycr of fabric shall be wrapped directly around the pipe with a minimum one foot (1') overlap at all seams. t~ock Trench Installation: The rock trench shall be constructed using a washed, Florida Department of Transportation cerlified No. 57 stone. The stone shall be wrapped by the outer 5 layer of gcotcxtile fabric and shall extend a minimum ofonc foot (I') ofrock on bolh sides ofthe pipe and six inches (6") on the top and bottom ortho pipe. Placement of Pipe: After the bottom six inch (6") thickness of rock trench is placed, thc inner layer of fabric shall be placed in tile trench and the pipe laid to proper grade. All pipe connections shall he secure and the inner layer of fabric wrapped completely around thc pipe with a minimum one I'oot (1') overlap at all seams. Placement of the rock trench around the sides and over thc top of the pipe shall be performed with due care to prevent thc movement of the pipe. For pipe utilizing bell and spigot connections, tile bell shall be laid in the upstream direction of flow. Ph~¢¢ment of Risers: Twelve inch (12") diameter minimum risers shall be installed to allow thc shallow swale to discharge into tile underlying pipe. The recommended configuration utilizes a manufactured "T" section but the use of Florida Department of Transportation Type "C" catch basins arc also acceptable when a manufactured "T" section is not available or thc owner prel'ers tile catch basin installation. Tile top of the riser shall extend six inches (6") above the bottom of the swale. A cast iron slotted grate shall be installed at the top ofthe riser. Where reinforced concrete pipe is used, the grate shall be placed in tile pipe bell. Where other pipe materials are used, the grate shall be placed in a reinforced precast concrete collar sized to fit the grate and pipe material. Minimum dimensions for the reinforced precast collar are six inch (6") thickness and twenty-four inch (24") outside diameter (or 24" square outside dimension). The precast collar will be mudded to the riser pipe and placed on compacted backfill material. Where neighbors enclose the swale, only one riser needs to be installed for each segment ofrcgraded shallow swale. Placement of End Berm: When tile neighboring property utilizes an open swale system instead of an enclosed swale system, an end berm shall be constructed to separate the new rcgraded shallow swale from the adjoining open swale. The pt, rpose is to force all of the water from thc regraded shallow swale to drain into thc riser inlet and into the underlying perforated pipe. The top elevation of the end bem~ will be six inches (6") higher than tile riser inlet. End Treatment of Pipe: When the neighboring property utilizes an open swale system instead of an enclosed swale system, a mitered end section with concrete collar shall be required 12C1 at tim cad of thc pipe (unless Ibc County's Right-of-Way permit review determines the location is not appropriate and deletes this mitered end section requirement) and the neighbor's swale bottom shall be rcgradcd (maxinmm bottom slope of 4 horizontal to I vertical) to connect to tile installed perforated pipe invert (bottom inside elevation). When the neighboring property utilizes an enclosed swale system, and either the pipes are different materials or im,'crt elevations do not match, a Florida Department of Transportation Type "C" catch basin shall be utilized to make ttm connection. This Type "C" catch basin will also function as the riser inlet. When tile neighboring propcrty utilizes an enclosed swale system, and tile pipe materials and invert clcvalions match, tile pipes shall be connected directly. Backfilling and Rcgrading of Shallow Swale: Upon proper placement of thc pipe within the rock trench, tile nonwoven gcotcxtilc fabric shall be overlapped a minimum ofonc foot (I ') across thc top of thc rock and backfill sandy soil material placed a minimum of six inches (6") beneath thc botlom of tile shallo~v swale and regraded to the proper longitudinal and side slopes. Maximum side slopes for tim shallow (14" (Iccp) rcgradcd swale are 3 horizontal to I vertical. Thc longitudinal slope of the swale shall be directed toward the riser inlet(s). When a reinforced concrete collar is used to secure the grate to tile riser, the backfill material shall be thoroughly compacted to prevent settlement and ensure that tile collar can support any weight placed on the grate. Sodding and Placement of Sprinklers: Upon completion ofrcgrading, the disturbed areas shall be sodded with thc same type sod as the remainder of tile yard, with tile exception that where Floratam sod is proposed, thc owner must provide for adequate sprinklers to keep the sod alive. Finished elevations must not project above tile edge of pavement and shall be in conformance with the detail draxving prepared by Agnoli, Barber and Brundage, Inc. attached as Exhibit ",,V'. Sprinklers shall not bc installed within the Right-of-Way. Any sprinkler installations shall he on thc owners property and shall utilize spray heads that can cast water across thc width of thc swale. SECTION ELEVEN: PENALTIES If any pc(son hils or refuses to obey or comply with or violates any of the provision of this Ordinance, such person upon conviction of such offense, shall be guilty ora misdemeanor 2C1 ' and shall be punished by a fine not Io exceed Five Hundred Dollars (S500.00) or by imprisonmcnt not to exceed (60) days in Ibc County jail, or bolh, in file discretion of thc Court Each violation or non-compliance shall be considered a separate offense. Nothing herein contained shall prevent or restrict tile County from taking such other lawful action in any court of competent jurisdiction as is necessary to prevent or remedy any violation or non-compliance. Such oiher lawful actions shall include, bu! shall not be limited to, an equitable action for injuncti;'c rclicfor an action at law for damages. Further, nothing in this Section shall be construed lo prohibit tile County from prosecuting any violation of this Ordinance by means of Code Enforcement Board established pursuant to tllc authority of Chapter 162, Florida Statutes. All remedies and penalties provided for in this Section shall be cumulative and independently available to thc County and tile County shall be authorized to pursue any and all remedies sc, fbrth in this Section to tile full extent allowed by law. SECTION TWEI,VE: CONFi,ICT AND SEVERABII, ITY In the event this Ordinance conflicts xvith any other ordinance of Collier County or other applicable law, thc more restrictive shall apply. If any phrase or portion of thc Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a scparmc, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect tile validity of the remaining portion. SECTION TiilRTEEN: INCI,USION IN TIlE CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES Thc provisions of fi'tis Ordinance shall become and be made a part of tile Code of Lav,'s and Ordinances of Collier County, Florida. The sections of the Ordinance may be renumbcrcd or rclcttcrcd to accomplish such, and thc word "ordinance" may be changed to "section", "arliclc". or any other appropriate word. SECTION FOURTEEN: EFFECTIVE DATE This Ordinance stroll become effective upon filing with thc Department of State. 12C1 '' PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by thc Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this ~5~,e tlay of/~,--~fi~_, 1998. ' BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ATTEST: :-,'; 'DWIGIIT E. BROCK; Clerk COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Approved as to t~rm and legal sufficiency: Heidi F. Ashlon Assistant County Attorney ~w',f'Ordm~ncc'N~pl¢* Park R~gh ,-~f-W~y I. THIS DETAIL TO BE USED IN CONJUNCTION '~TH THE PROPOSED CONDITIONS DRAINAGE MAPS FOR NAPLES PARK AS PREPARED BY AGNOLI, BARBER & BRUNDAGE, INC. F')LE NO. 173~ FOR ISSUANCE OF COLLIER COUNTY PERMIT. THIS DETAIL IS NOT APP{.ICABLE TO 2. TH£ CONTrACTOR/COUNTY SHALL NOT1FY ALL APPROPRIATE UTILJTY COIdPANIES BEFORE BEGINNING CONSTRUCTION AND SHALL HAVE ALL SERIgCE LINES LOCATED AND FLAGGED PRIOR TO EXCAVATION. 3. iS" SLOTTED RCP SHALL BE UTIUZED FOR UP TO I BLOCK FOR THE MOST UPS'I'~EAM BLOCK BEGINNING AT THE HIGH POINT OF THE DR/INAGE DIVIDE, SUCH AS FROM 6TH TO 7TH STREET AS THE AVENUE DRAINS TOWARD 8TH STRF..'ET. 24" OR 19"x30" SLOTTED RCP SHALL BE UTIUZED DOWNSTREAM OF THE IqRST CONTRIBUTING FULL BLOCK LENGTH ONCE T~E LENGTH OF T"HE DRAINAGE AREA EXCEEDS I FULL BLOCK. V44EN USING 24" OR 19"x30" SLOTTED RCP, THE ROCK TRENCH DIMENSIONS SHALL BE MODIFIEO TO PROVIDE I' OF' ROCK ON BOTH SIDES OF' THE PIPE AND ,~" OF ROCK ON THE TOP AND BO'FTOM OF THE PIPE. THE TYPE C INLET~ SHALL BE ROTATED AS NECESSARY TO ACCEPT THE LARGER PIPE SIZE. 4. ALL AREAS DISTURBED BY CONSTRUCTION SHALL BE SODDED 14,1TH THE SAME T~PE SOO AS THE REMAINDER OF THE YARD. FINISHED ELEVATIONS MUST NOT PRO,.~CT ABOV~ THE EDGE OF PAVEMENT AND SHALL BE IN CONFORMANCE V4TH THIS DETAIL AND THE COLLIER COUNTY PERMIT. 5, PERFORA TED SMO0 TH IN TERIOR- WALLED HIGH DENSI T'Y POL Y~Pt~ENE OR PERFORA T~D AL UMINIZ[D $ T~£L TYPE 2 SPIRAL RIB 14 GAUGE MINIAUM) PIPE MAY BE USED AS AN ALTERNATIVE TO REINFORCED CONCRETE PIPE, COLLIER COUNTY ,;. ~j~/ "i / ~. ~ : , ,' 3,301 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST · ' ' '~ ;-" E- NAPLES, FLORIDA 34112 FL.4. RE(.L ~',i~. 1~R.'--2~5 NAPLES PARK A~_;h~©Lt, E).A,?~ER ~' BNUNDACE, INC. SECONDARY DRAiN,aGE E ~ ~.TEI, f 7400 TAMI.4t,¥1 TF~,~I; ;.IC3RTi4 DATE: FEB. ~0, 1997 t.;.APLE$. FLORID.:~ .~4~08 SHEET: 1 OF 5 REV. APRIL ~,1997 ACAD: 6900DEP ~/~/T' "/~" REV, DECEMBER 22, 1997 REV. JANUARY 5, ~998 ! 2C1 '"'" R.C.P. "TEE" & GRA?'E TO BE SET.--x /---R.C.P. "TEE" & GRATE TO BE SET AT 0.5' ABOVE NEW SWALE BOTTOM ~ / AT 0.5' ABOVE NEW SWALE BOTTOM ELE VA 11 ON. ~ '"N , / ELEVATION. '' '~' I~1 ],/ ~'' I I ~o.oo' I I "N '~"l::r:q ~o.oo' J" 50.00' ~ I I Rzw ~ ~'- j: :L 5,._FH . __/:- - _L _L Eoa_~ _ _ _L_ L__ ~c~;'.~3_\~L ~__._= I_ _\ Av~_uE ] ~ _ . I x,, ~: RO0< TRENCH R/W I ~ CULVERT AND INSTALL NEW ~ c~ 18" SLOTTED R.C.P. AND ! _ ROCK TRENCH UNDER DRIVEWAY. PLAN VIEW SCALE 1' = 40' COLLIER COUNTY \ ), ' ,. , $$0! TAM/AMI TRAIL EAST B'~'. f~.,x, ' " ' ~" " "' I,~'~ P.E. NAPLES, FLORIDA 34112 FLA. REG. NO. 1~915 NAPLES PARK AGNOLI, 5'ARBEF' &. B~UNDA~E. INC. ~ECONDARY DRAINAGE $~9TEM 7400 TAMIAMI TRAIL NORTH DATE: FEg'. 10, 1997 NAPLES, FLORIDA 3410,~ SHEET: 2 OF 5 REV. APRIL 11,1997 ACAD: 5900DEP REV. DECEMBER 22. 1997 ~hl / ~ / T- "/~ ~x REV. JANUARY 5, 1998 , ...~, COLLIER COUNTY · /?~ .5301 TAMIAMI TRAIL. FAST ' .... '~ " P.E. NAPLES, FLORIDA 34112 FLA. REG. &!O. lcR'2~5 NAPLES PARK AGHOLI, BARBEF) &: ~3RUNDAGE, INC. SECONDARY DRAINAGE SYSTEM 7400 TAM~AMI TR,,',IL h/ORTH DATE: FEB. 10, 7997 NAPLES, FLORID,A Z4'108 SHEET: 5 OF 5 REV. APRIL 11, 1997 ACAD; 5900DEP ,, REV. DECEMBER 22, 1997 ~-2(. ~/~/F- //,,~ REV. JANUARY 5, 1998 1291 STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) I, DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk of Courts in and for the Twentieth Judicial Circuit, Collier County, Florida, do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true copy of: ORDINANCE NO. 98-1 Which was adopted by the Board of County Commissioners on the 6th day of January, 1998, during Regular Session. WITNESS my hand and the official seal of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this 7th day of January, 1998. DWIGHT E. BROCK Clerk of Courts and./21erk Ex-officio to Board.of County CommissionerS. - By: Ellie Hof fman ",' Deputy Clerk CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT OF SUBDIVISION IMrPROVEMENTS PRIOR TO RECORDING OF PLAT T[ilS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION EMPROVEMENTS PRIOR TO RECORDING OF PLAT AGREEMENT entered into this day of r. ~: .... .... .,. , 19..'7: between Pelican Strand Ltd., a Florida Limited Partnership, hereinatter referred to as "Developer", and the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereinafter referred to as "the Board". RECITALS 1. Developer has, simultaneously with the delivery of this Agreement, applied for the approval by the Board of a certain plat of a subdivision to be known as: PELICAN STRAND REPLAT - 4 2. Division 3.2 of the Collier County Unified Land Development Code allows the Developer to construct the improvements required by said subdivision regulations prior to recording the final plat. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants hereinafter set forth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows: 1. Developer will cause to be constructed the Required Improvements within 6 months from the date of approval of said subdivision plat, said infrastructure (water, sewer, drainage & roadway) improvements hereafter referred to as the required improvements. 2. Developer herewith agrees to construct said improvements prior to recording said subdivision plat and the Board of County Commissioners shall not approve the plat for recording until said improvements have been completed. 3. Upon completion of said improvements, the developer shall tender its subdivision performance security in the amomlt of $19,941.39 which represents 10% of the total contract cost to complete construction. Upon receipt of said subdivision performance security by the Development Services Director, the Developer may request the Board of County Commissioners to approve the subdivision plat for recording and grant preliminary approval of said plat. 4. The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a statement of substantial completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records have been fitrnished to be reviewed and approved by the Development Services Director for compliance with the Collier County Unified Land Development Code. 5. The Development Services Direclor shall, within sixty days of receipt of the statement of substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of its preliminary approval of the improvements; or b) notify the Developer in writing of its refusal to approve tile improvements, therewith specifying those conditions which tile Developer must fulfill in order to obtain tile Board's acceptance of the improvements. However, in no event shall tile Board refuse preliminary approval of the improvements if they are in fact constructed and submitted for approval itl accordance with thc requirements of this Agreement. 6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum period of one year after preliminary approval by the Development Services Director. After the one year maintenance period by thc Developer has terminated, the Developer shall petition the Development Services Director to inspect tile improvements. The Development Services Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found to be still in compliance with Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by final approval by the Board, the Board shall release the ten percent subdivision performance security. The Developer's responsibility for maintenance shall continue unless or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for the County. 7. In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to fulfill its obligations under this Agreement. upon certification of such failure, the County Administrator may call upon the subdivision performance security to secure completion, repair and maintenance of the required improvements. The Board shall have the right to construct and maintain, or cause to be constructed and maintained, pursuant to public advertisement and receipt of acceptance of bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision perfbrmance security shall be liable to pay and to indemnil~' the Board, upon completion of such construction, the final total cost to the Board thereof, including, but not limited to, engineering, legal and contingent costs, together with any damages, either direct or consequential, which the Board may sustain on account of the failure of the Developer to carry out all of the provisions of this Agreement. 8. All of thc terms, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon the respective successors and assigns of the Developer. 2 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement the daF' first abovc written. Pelican Strand, Ltd., a Florida Limited Partnership By: Pelican Strand Development Corporation, its General Partiger By: Ro ul Hardy, Vice President / t ':--' - 4' 2'-. " / ' Witness' ' :- -,":/--.. .; ,. / 1' '.: :.,', , "/z! .' \ .' ':(":' / .... (Print name) ../? · ::, :. ?¥.,,., ,._... Witness ' ' ,/,z.4/,.. : . (Print name) ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Dwight E. Brock, Clerk OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Approved as to f°r,n m,d legal sufficiency ~hnothy l, I4ancdck: Chairman- Assistant County Attorney 1SA 2 Collier Co~ty, Ftorlc~'m RE(bUEST FOR LEGal AD~RTISING OF PUBLIC HEARINGS CD[~pLIy A~., l~tl~, etc.) (Sl~ cleirty) (if ~re spice ne~, aJtBch se~ro~e shee~) Hearing before: ~ BCe /-----~ BZA /-"--'~ Other He..~peper(,) to ~ u~: (Co~tete ~ly If f~rtant ~--~, ~ Naples Dally News Companion petition(m), tf ~y, L prof~sed hearing date: O~m Petit(~ Fee [~t~ Adverttsi~ Cost? Yes ~ Ho / / If yes. what accost shard ~ charg~ for ~ertimi~ coat=: 113-13~323-~9110 ;2122' i .......... ................. ........ ' ............................ '"'"" ..... '"'" List Att&c~ts: (1) (2) .(3) pI~TRIBUTI~ INSTRUCT I~S A. F~r h~erl~m ~fore 8CC or B[A: ]nltlatl~ ~rmm to c~[ete ~ c~ ~ ~tain Olvisi~ He~ a~r~at ~fore l~(tt{~ to C~ty Na~ger. ~: If legal ~3t {~ involve, ~ sure that any ~essary [~at revl~, o~ ~t for ~. tm e~itt~ t~ ~ty Attor~y ~fore S~Jttlng to C~tY Manager. The Na~ger~m Office ~ltt dimtrl~te c~le=: ~ ~ C~ty N~ger ag~ file; ~ R~sti~ Olvlml~ ~ Origin[ to Cterk~m Office I. Othar hearl~: Initliti~ DIvill~ ~e~ to w~e ~ s~tt orlalM[ to C[erk~ Office. retalni~ a c~ for file.) !11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111.111111 263-4864 iii11111111111111111111111111111111111111111ii11111111111111111 5il I i,=--J21 i5:9_'Z,, 00'"02'16 941 995 OK 4 8688808000006611, , 512I 12-12] 15:11 60°81'57 92654864 01< 3 868C808880008A13] .... TOTAL I::IPGS 48 Bate aunt: ' Time aent: 16A December 12, 1997 Ms. Judith Flanagan Naples Daily News 1075 Central Avenue Naples, Florida 34102 Re: Notice of Public Hearing to consider Petition AV-97-025 Dear Judi: Please advertise the above referenced notice two times, one time on Sunday, December 21, 1997 and one time on Sunday, December 28, ].997, and send the Affidavit of Publication, in duplicate, together with charges involved to this office. Sincerely, ~Kuehne, Deputy Clerk Encl. Acct. No. 113-138323-649110 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given that the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, will hold a public hearing on TUESDAY,JANUARY 6, 1998, in the Boardroom, 3rd Floor, Administration Building, Collier County Government Center, 3301 East Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida. The meeting will begin at 9:00 A.M. The Board will consider a Resolution to vacate the recorded plat of "Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C First Addition", and approve for recording the final plat of "Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C Second Addition" The item is scheduled to appear on the Consent Agenda as "REQUEST TO APPROVE FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF QUAIL WEST UNIT ONE, REPLAT BLOCK C SECOND ADDITION, AND APPROVE THE VACATION OF THE PREVIOUS PLAT, QUAIL WEST UNIT ONE, REPLAT BLOCK C FIRST ADDITION, PETITION AV-97-025" Persons wishing further information, or to have the item removed from the Consent Agenda and placed on the Regular Agenda should contact the Planning Services Section of the Community Development and Environmental Services Division of Collier County Government at 403-2400, Collier County, Florida. Ail interested parties are invited to attend, to register to speak and to submit their objections, if any, in writing, to the Board prior to the public hearing. Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the Board will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto, and therefore, ma}' need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. BOARD OF COUNTY CO[~MISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA TIMOTHY L. HANCOCK, CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK By: /s/JODY S. KUEHNE, Deputy Clerk (SEAL) PUBLIC NOTICE On Ja~uary 6,1998 the Board of County Commissioners will consider a Resolution to vacate thc recorded plat of "Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C First Addition", and approve for recording the final plat of"Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C Second Addition". The item is scheduled to appear on the Consent Agenda as "REQUEST TO APPROVE FOR RECORDING THE FINAL PLAT OF QUAIL WEST UNIT ONE,, REPLAT BLOCK C SECOND ADDITION, AND APPROVE THE VACATION OF THE PREVIOUS PLAT, QUAIL WEST UN1T ONE, REPLAT BLOCK C FIRST ADDITION, PETITION AV-97-025". Persons wishing further information, or to have the item removed from the Consent Agenda and placed on the Regular Agenda should contact the Planning Services Section of the Community Development and Environmental Services Division of Collier County Government at 403-2400 ()cl~d~cr 20. ly!)V ()u:~il \Vc.~l I~il ()nc' P. uplal, l~k~ck (~ Second Adclil~on: :\l~u;lila~ :~d ~,ll~c.r l'~,'c~pcrly c,,vnc..rs wilhii~ 250 l'c'cl ot' thc proposed vacali(~n: 'l'rac~ 1~-.1. 1'-2. P-3, P-9, P-'lO (Il) 6~975()049~3) Quail West, l.td.. 6289 l~urnham lb,ad. N:,plcs. FI. 3q119 'l'rac~s (~:-R, (;(:0 & (R~-2() (I[) (~,~97~0,i209~ Quail West. l.ld.. 6289 Burnlmm I~mcl, Naples, t:I. 3&119 I.,,~ c:.q (11) C,8975~)02201~ - Terence & l.inda l~loocl. 6349 Burnham Roacl. Naples. FI. 3.i 1 l.~s c~q ~ll) 68977~)~)(~2(~1 ) & (~2c~ {I[) (~897~22~) - Quail Wcsl. l.ld.. 6289 ltu;'~lmu~ R~acl. N:tplc. s. Fl. 34119-I[) ...... 16A · I RESOLUTION NO. 97 · I RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ACCEPTANCE OF QUAIL WEST 5 ONE, REPLAT BLOCK C SECOND ADDITION, A REDLAT OF A .... , ......... ...... 4 PREVIOUSLY RECORDED P~T ~'O>~ AS QUAIL WEST b~iT O:.:E, 7 REPLAT BLOCK C FIRST A~DITION, A~ A:~HOR I ZiNG THE ~ VACATION OF THE PREVIOUSLY RECORDED P~T OF QUAIL WEST .... 9 ~,IIT ONE, REP~%T BLOCK C FIRST ADDITION ACCORDING TO THE I0 ATTACHED LEGAL DESCRIPTION, PETITION AV-97-025 12 '~;HEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, .................................. ~3 Florida, on July 23, 1996 approved the plat of Qu0il West Unit One, .... ~4 Repla% Block C First Addition ~or recording; and <~?T2'.NFk"i'2ii:.27f.31'-3217C2 '" w~z~As, Quail west Limited is replatting Quail West Uni% One, 17 Rcmlat Block C First Addition and has filed for a replat of said ..................... ' "' ' 18 la~ds, and is petitioning to vacate the original plat; and ~9 20 WHEREAS, Quail West Limited desires to vacate all o[ the .......... ." ',~.~. ....... -:.... ......... 2~ previously recorded plat as described in Exhibit A; and 22 .................. -... ~.. 23 WHEREAS, this parcel, the approved plat of Quail West Unit one, 24 Replat Block C Second Addition is a replat of a previously approved .......... 25 and recorded plat Quail west Unit One, Repla% Block C First Addition, 26 and the filing and recording of this approved plat shall not affect ........................................... 27 access to lots previously conveyed under the Quail West Unit One, ........ . ........ .~-~ 28 Replat Block C First Addition plat. 29 30 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED ~D OP~ERED BY THE BOARD 3~ COU~4TY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COMITY, FLORIDA, that the plat '- ....... ....... ~ , Rep!at . 32 Quail W_~,t Unit One Block C Second Addition, a reDla~ of a 33 previously approved and recorded plat, Quail West Unit O~e, Rep]at ...... 3"'~ ..... ~ .....t ........... ~.~ Block C '~irst Addition, is hereby approved for recordinc and the . .:.. ........ 3~ dodicatious contained on the plat of Quail west Unit One, Replat. gJc,ck 3o C .~_c.,,= Addition are hereby accepted, and those lands d__cr.b_d J . _c~ ire ................. ~ .............. 37 Exhsbi[ A are hereby vacated. Said vacation shall become ef~" ' '' ' ~. ' ; 3~ upon recordation of the subject plat. .............. ~_..~. ................... m, BE tT FURTHER RESOLVED A_ND ORDERED that the Clerk cf the a~ Circuit Court shall make proper notation of this action upon the . ].' -.-: .- ..... ' ..... -..---'-,"-~ 42 Fre'/~o,.:s plat and record a certified copy cf this rep!~t a:ld a 4% certified copy of the vacation resolution in the Official Becords of 4-: Col!let County. "-' " ...... 4,, This Reso!u~ion adopted after motion, second and majority vote ................. ......... ~ .... '---- 47 ~.,~ ~ ~r,(.~ same. D;,TRD: ..... 5~ BOARD OF COD%;TY COMMiSSiO}~ERS .................................... s.~ DWIGHT E. BRCCK, CLERK COLLIER COb~TY, FLCRiEA - - "' ' .' S6 ~7 By: 5~ TIMOTHY L. H3C4COCK ," _.. ................. 59 CHAI ............ ~ ................................. (~ I 62 App:-oved as to form and legal ............................................ ~,,,~,.~ i,, } ~ f',,- . ~ }{ei,i: F. Ash~on a7 Ass:stan: Collier County Attorney 16A 2 December 12, 1997 Quail West, Ltd. 6289 Burnham Road Naples, FL 34119 RE: Notice of Public Hearing to consider Petition AV-97-025 Dear Petitioner: Please be advised that the above referenced petition will be considered by the Board of County Commissioners on Tuesday, January 6, 1998, as indicated on the enclosed notice. The legal notice pertaining to this petition will be published in the Naples Daily News on Sunday, December 21, 1997 and Sunday, December 28, 1997. You are invited to attend this public hearing. Sincerely, ~uy 3. Kuehne, Deputy Clerk Encl. cc: JRB Development Group Terence & Linda Blood 16A 2_ December 12, 1997 Terence & Linda Blood 6349 Burnham Road Naples, FL 34119 RE: Notice of Public Hearing to consider Petition AV-97-025 Dear Petitioner: Please be advised that the above referenced petition will be considered by the Board of County Commissioners on Tuesday, January 6, 1998, as indicated on the enclosed notice. The legal notice pertaining to this petition will be published in the Naples Daily News on Sunday, December 21, 1997 and Sunday, December 28, 1997. You are invited to attend this public hearing. Sincerely, Jody S. Kuehne, Deputy Clerk Encl. cc: JRB Development Group Quail West, Ltd. 16A 2 December 12, 1997 JRB Development Group 4061 Bonita Beach Road Suite 203 Bonita Springs, FL, 34134 RE: Not[.ce of [~ublic Hearing to consider Petition AV-97-025 Dear Petitioner: Please be advised that the above referenced petition will be considered by the Board of County Commissioners on Tuesday, January 6, 1998, as indicated on the enclosed notice. The legal notice pertaining to this petition will be published in the Naples Daily News on Sunday, December 21, 1997 and Sunday, December 28, 1997. You are invited to attend this public hearing. Sincerely, Jody S. Kuehne, Deputy Clerk Encl. cc: Terrence & Linda Blood Quail West, Ltd. 16A 2_ Naples Daily News Naples, FL 33940 Affidavit of Publication Naples Daily t(ews BOARD OF COUNTY COHMISSIONERS ATTN: NANCY SALOGUB PO BOX 413016 NOTICEOF NAPLES FL 34101-3016 PUBLIC HEARING Notice Is hereby given thot i'ne Bo~d of Courtly C~m $sl~s of C~ ~lJ hold o ~ubllC hearing on TUESDAY, jANU~Y 6_1~, In ~ REFERENCE: 001230 1113138323649 ~r~, ~d Ft~,~- mlnls~i~ ~lldl~, 57614544 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEA I1~ ~ m Troll, Nople~, P~ ~. State of Florida The me~ will ~Jn County of Collier 9:~ A.M. The ~d ~mm c~sl~ o Re~ appeared Judith A. Flanigan, who on oath says ~hat " ' she serves as an agent of the Naples Daily News, a daily newspaper published at Naples, in Collier c~df~ me ft~l pl~ I ,'Q~II West Un~ ~, County, FLorida: that the attached copy of Jpl~ B~k C ~ A~- advertising ~as published in said newspaper on /Jlon". The Item J ~he~led ~ ~ dates listed. J me C~ A~ Affiant further says that the sa~d Naples Daily ["REQUEST TO ~RO~ FOR RECORDING T~ Ne~s is a newspaper published at Naples, in said FINAL P~T ~ QUAIL Collier County, Florida, and that the said ~ST UNIT ONE. PLAT BL~K C ~CONO newspaper has heretofore been continuously ADDITION. AND AP- published in said Collier County, Florida, each PRO~ THE VACATION OF THE PREVIOUS day and has been entered as second class mail PLAT, QUAIL WEST UNIT matter at the ~st office in Naples, in said ONE. REPLAT BL~K C F RST A~ITION PETI. Collier County, FLorida, for a period of I year TION AV-gT~25'. next preceding the first publication of the flon, ~ ~ ~e me ~em attached copy of advertisement; and affiant re~v~ ~ ~ ~ further says that she has neither paid nor ~ent A~a ond ~ ~e R~uJ~ promised any person, firm or co. ration any $h~ld C~ ~ P~- discount, rebate, commission or refund for the nlng ~lce$ ~l~ fha C~mun~ pur~se of securing this advertisement for me~ ~ EnviF~ publication in the said newspaper. ~rvlce$ Dlvtsl~ ~ C~- I1~ C~ ~ 403-24~, Colll~ PUBLISH[D ON: 12/21 12/28 ~,F~I~ All I~erest~ ~e Inv~ to ~end, ~eglst~ ~ ~ ~ subm) ~elr ~s, any, In ~lflng, ~ ~d ~l~ to ~e ~lk h~t~. Any ~r~ ~ ~ AD SPACE: 82.~ iNCH es~ o ~1~ the ~d ~ll n~ o re- FILED ON: 12J29/97 c~d ~ ~ + pe~olnlng ~o, .......................................................................... ~eref~e. ~ ~ en~e ~ o v~m .... " ..... ' Is ~e, ~lchr~d Signature of Affiant }'t/v'- ;" ~ ' ~ v/ clu~$ ~e te~v Sworn to and . '- " ~ - - COLLIER COUNTY, Personally known by me ~' ~/ FLORIDA TIMOTHY L. HANC~K, CHAIRMAN ....... DWIGHT E. BROCK~ CLERK By:/~/JODY S. KUEHNE, · '~}"Y~'" ~YCE E. B~EH D~u~ Cle~ /~'"?~ '.~ (~AL) ~'"~:~ Apdl 10. 1~ RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ACCEPTANCE OF QUAIL WEST UNIT ONE, REP~T BLOCK C SECOND ADDITION, A REPLAT OF A PREVIOUSLY RECORDED PLAT KNOWN AS QUAIL WEST UNIT ONE, REPLAT BLOCK C FIRST ADDITION, AND AUTHORIZIHG THE VACATION OF THE PREVIOUSLY RECORDED PLAT OF QUAIL WEST UNIT ONE, REPLAT BLOCK C FIRST ~JDDITION ACCORDING TO THE ATTACHED LEGAL DESCRIPTION, PETITION AV-97-025 WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, on July 23, 1996 approved the plat of Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C First Addition for recording; and WHEREAS, Quail West Limited is replatting Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C First Addition and has filed for a replat of said lands, and is petitioning to vacate the original plat; and WHEREAS, Quail West Limited desires to vacate all of the previously recorded plat as described in Exhibit A; and WHEREAS, this parcel, the approved plat of Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C Second Addition is a replat of a previously approved and recorded plat, Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C First Addition, and the filing and recording of this approved plat shall not affect access to lots previously conveyed under the Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C First Addition plat. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED AND ORDERED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the plat of Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C Second Addition, a replat of a previously approved and recorded plat, Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C First Addition, is hereby approved for recording and the dedications contained on the plat of Quail West Unit One, Replat Block C Second Addition are hereby accepted, and those lands described in Exhibit A are hereby vacated. Said vacation shall become effective upon recordation of the subject plat. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED AND ORDERED that the Clerk of the Circuit Court shall make proper notation of this action upon the previous plat and record a certified copy of this replat and a certified copy of the vacation resolution in the Official Records of Collier County. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote favoring same. DATED: ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA TIMOTHY ,5. H~LNCOCK C~ I R~N *** 2266514 0R: 2378 PG: 0832 *** Approved as to form and legal RECORDED sufficiency: 01/08/9S at 11:22AK DWIGHT ~. ~ROCK, CLERK Assistant Collier County Attorney EZT 7240 'l 8A 3 -' CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT OF SUBDIVISION IMPROVEMENTS PRIOR TO RECORDING OF PLAT THIS CONSTP,UCTION AN MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT for SUBDIVISION IMPROVEMENTS PP`IOP, TO RECOP,D1NG OF PLAT AGREEMENT, entered into this _ __ day of ' , 19',, between PORT BOUGAIN, LTD., hereinafter referred to as "DeveLoper" and the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereinafter referred to as "The Board". RECITALS I Developer has, simultaneously with the delivery of this Agreement, applied for the approval by the Board ora certain plat of subdivision to be known as: BOUGAIN VII. LAGE. 2 Division 3.2 Of the Collier County Land Development Code allows the Developer to construct the improvements required by said subdivision regulations prior to recording the final plat. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants hereinafter set forth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and agree as follows: 1 Developer will cause to be constructed: Water, sewer, drainage, access, buffer and lighting infrastructure serving BOUGAIN VILLAGE within 3..~6 months from the date of approval of said subdivision plat, said improvements herein after referred to as the required improvements. 2. Developer herewith agrees to construct said improvements prior to recording said subdivision plat and the Board of County Commissioners shall not approve the plat for recording until said improvements have been completed. 3 Upon completion of said improvements, the developer shall tender its performance security (Letter of Credit/Surety Bond), in the amount of S~:,,l~r:-'~, r / , which amount represents 10% of the total contract cost to complete construction. Upon receipt of said sub&vision performance security by the Development Services Director, the Developer may request the Board of County Commissioners to approve the subdivision plat for recording and grant preliminary approval of said plat. 4 The required improvements shall not be considered complete until a statement of substantial completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records have been furnished to be reviewed and approved by the Development Services Director for compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code. ..................................... i .......... - ....... lit .............................................. l .... Il 5 The Development Services Director shall, within sixty (60) days of receipt of the statement of substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer in writing of his preliminary approval of the improvements; or b) notify the Developer in writing of his refusal to approve improvements, therewith specifying those conditions which the Developer must Fulfill in order to obtain the Director's approval of the improvements. However, in no event shall the Development Services Director refuse preliminary approval of the improvements if they are in fact constructed and submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this Agreement. 6 The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum period of one year after preliminary approval by the Development Services Director. After the one year maintenance period by the Developer has terminated, the Developer shall petition the Development Services Director to inspect the required improvements. The Development Services Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found to be still in compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by final approval by the Board, the Board shall release the 10% subdivisions performance security. The Developer's responsibility for maintenance of the required improvements shall continue unless or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for the County. 7 In the event the Developer shall fail or neglect to Fulfill its obligations under this Agreement, upon certification of such failure, the County Administrator may call upon the subdivision performance security to secure satisfactory completion, repair and maintenance of the required improvements. The Board shall have the right to construct and maintain, or cause to be constructed or maintained, pursuant to public advertisement and receipt of acceptance of bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision performance security, shall be liable to pay and to indemnify the Board, upon completion of such construction, the final total cost to the Board thereof', including, but not limited to, engineering, legal and contingent costs, together with any damages, either direct or consequential, which the Board may sustain on account of the failure of the Developer to Fulfill all of the provisions of this Agreement. 8 All of the terms, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon the Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer. ,~, 2 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Board and the Developer have caused this Agreement to be executed by their duly authorized representatives this day of ' ........ ,19' Signed, Sealed and Delivered PORT BOUGAIN, LTD. in the presence of: By: ; John P. White, President ; '~ :~ ,~ ~ ~ "~ ~ ' :~ ~ / 1,' Port Bougain, Inc., as General Partner of ~ '.-.v~ ~ ,' ~.'~ t ,,. ,.,; ! ~ ' Port Bougain, LTD., a Florida I' .,,,.~ {../' · .--/' Limited Partnership / !,,..',--4,.~ ' d: . ,. · ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Dwight E. Brock, Clerk OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ~imothy L. Hanco~:k, Chairman Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: David C. '~- Weigel Collier County Attorney 6 BOND 133~711 CREEKSIDE COMMERCE PARK YVEST, UNIT ONE PERFORMANCE BOND KNOW ALL PERSONS BY THESE PRESENTS, that Creekside West, Inc.!, a Florida corporation, located at 2640 Golden Gate Parkway, Suite 115, Naples, FL 34105, (hereinafter referred to as "Owner") and Amwest Surety Insurance Company, a corporation certified to do business in the State of Florida as a surety insurer and duly organized under the laws of the State of Nebraska, with its home office located at 6320 Canoga Avenue, P.O. Box 4500, Woodland Hills, CA 91365- 4500 (hereinafter referred to as "Surety") are held and firmly bound unto Collier County, Florida, (hereinafter referred to as "County") in the total aggregate sum of One NIil[ion Four Hundred Fifty-Nine Thousand Five Hundred Ninety-Five and 00/100 Dollars ($1,486,435.00) in lawful money of the United States, for the payment of which sum well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, our heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, jointly and severally, firmly by these presents. Owner and Surety are used for singular or plural, as the context requires. THE CONDITION OF THIS OBLIGATION is such that whereas, the Owner has submitted for approval by the board a certain subd/vision plat named Creekside Commerce Park West, Unit One, and that certain subdivision shall include specific improvenmnts which are required by Collier County Ordinances and Resolutions (hereinafter "Land Development Regulations"). This obligation of the Surety shall commence on the date this Bond is executed and shah continue until the date of fin,d acceptance by the Board of County Commissioners of the specific improvements described in the Land Development Reg-ulations (hereinafter the "Guaranty Pe~dod"~ /',,rOB', THEREFORE, if the Ova~er shall well, truly and f;dthfully perform its obligations and duties in accordance with the Land Development Regulations during the Guaranty Period estabhshed by the County, and the Owner shall satisfy all claims and demand~s incurred and shall fully indemnify and save harmless the County from and against ,M1 costs and damages which it may suffer by reason of Owner's failure to do so, and shall reimburse m~d repay the County all outlay and expense which the County ma), incur in making good ~my default, then this obligation shall be void, otherwise to remain in full force and effect. PROVIDED, FURTHER, that the said Surety, for value received hereby, stipulates and agrees that no change, extension of time, alteration, addition or deletion to the proposed specific improvements sluall in any way affect its obhgation on this Bond, Page 1 of 3 mud it do~ hereby w~v~ uo~e ~ ~Y ~ PRO~ED, ~~E, ~a[ i~ ~ ~r~[ a a, ~e Bond ~ wha~oever. { . ~ ~SS ~OF, ~ p~ h~e~ ~e ~u~ed ~ PE~O~~ BO~ m be ~ecu~d ~ 3RD ~ ~ .NO~EMB ,. ,1997. Wimess ~ Printed Na~: MARCIA J. WILHE~ ;: ~W ST ~¢~TY I~SU~CE' ~nted Name~' ~ ~. ~fle STEPHEN A. MUR~ TTORNEY ~mess I LICENSED RESIDENT AGENT Print:~ Name: gl& [~ ~A~ } ~AL~_ Paqe 2 of 3 STATE OF FLORIDA COT3NTY OF COTZI~.R NOVEMBE~ , 1997 by STATE OF FLOR/DA COUNTY OF HTT,r,,~BnnnUGH The foregoing' in_~rmnent wa~ acknowlec~ed,bef~re ~ne ~_M,, 3aD clay of_ NOVEMBER , 1999by STEPHEN A. M.UR .R~. [ , ~ ~WEST, ,SURETY INSU~NCE COMPANY , a N~SKA ~Or~, on ~ co~oraUon. ~ ~ pe~~ ~ ~ ma ~ ~ ~ ~ oa~. ' ~'~e C~c~l L. Beaird [~. ~ No~ Public. Stale of Florida >' ~.~ Commission No. CC }~ ¢o~°¢- My Commi~ion Exp. Page 3 of 3 oooo? o, ^ ~ d~um~nt i~ prin~d on ~ ~r ~n~nin$ ~c ~i~c~l ~arked Io~o (~) o[Am~st Sur~ In~u~ce Comfy (~c "Comfy~) on ~ front ~d bro~ ~uri~ ~r on ~c ~ck. ~ly un~l~r~ od~in~l~ o~c ~A ~ v~Hd. ~i~ POA m~y not ~ u~ ~n conjunction wi~ any o~cr ~A No ~n~tions or ~nties rc~rdin~ ~is ~A may ~ m~c by ~y ~on. ~is POA is $ov~med by ~ la~ or ~¢ s~ orCali[omi~ ~d is only valid until · c expiration date. ~e Comfy shall not ~ liable on ~y limi~d ~A which is [~udulcntly produced. [or¢~ or o~c~sc distributed ~out ~e ~ission o[~¢ Core,ny. Any pa~y concerned a~ut ~c validi~ or,is ~A or nn accompanying Company ~nd should call your I~1 Amuse b~ch office at K~OW ALL BY THeE P~E~, ~at Am~st Sure~ I~su~ce Comply, a Ncbr~ka co~raUo~ {~e "Comply"), d~s hereby co~ti~ ~d ap~int: ~EPHEN ~ MURKY ~tERYL L B~IRD ANE~ ~ CARDINALE ~ EMP~YEF3 OF AN~.~ SURETY INSU~N~ ~ its mac and la~,l'ul AUomcT-in-facL with limiu:d power and authority for and on behalf of thc Company a seal of thc company thereto ifa seal is required on bonds, undertakings, rccognk,nnccs, reinsurance agreement for a Miller A~' ~,'riHen obligations in thc natorc thereof as follow: Bid Bonds up to Contract (Perfomumce & Payment), Court, Sul~dlvialon $*'5,000,000.00 I~cer~e ~ Permit Bonds up to $"5,000,000.00 Mlacell~eou~ Bonda up to $' Snmll Bu~lnet~ Admbxhtraflon Gtmranteed Bonda up to and to bind the company thereby. This appointrncnl is made under and by full force and cftect. [, thc undersigned secretary o£Amwcst Surety. Insurance Company, a N~ .'r of Anomey remains in full force and effect and has not bccn revoked and furthermore, that thc re: on this Power of Attomcy, and that thc relevant provisions of thc By-Laws of the Company, are now in full force Bond No. ].3397].]. Signed&sealed Karcn G. Cohen. Secrctar7 This POA is signed and aealed by facsimile under pted by the Board of Directors of Amw~st Sure~y Insurance Company at a m~ting duly held on December 1975: RESOLVED. that thc President any Assistant Secretary, may appoint attom~'s-in-fact or agents with authority as defined or limited in thc for and on behal£or thc Company, to execute and deliver and affix the seal of the Company to bonds, undertakin of all kinds; and said officers may remove any such attorney-in-fact or agent and rc~'okc any POA previously 1 RESOLVED FURTHER gation shall be valid and bind upon the Company: (i) when signed by thc President and sealed (ifa seal be required) by any Sccr,'tary or Assistant Secretary; or (ii) when signed by the Prcsident ' or Assistant Sccr,-tary. and countersigned and sealed (if a seal b~ required) by a duly authorized attom~.in-£act (iii) when duly executed and tone or more attorneys-in-fact or agents pursuant to and within the limits of thc authority evidenced by thc po~r of attorney .ompany person or Persons. RESOLVED FURTHER, ',.hat thc s of any authorized officer and thc seal of thc Company may be aflix~ by facsimile to any PO^ or certification thereof authorizing thc execution ~d del y of any bond, undcrta, k ing, r~cosni?ance, or other suretyship obligations ofthe Company; and such signature and seal when so used shall Mvc the sarnc force and effect as though manually alT~xed. IN WITNESS W;IEREOF. Amwcst Surety Insurance Company has caused these presents to be signed by its proper officers, and its corporate seal to be hereunto affixed this 14th day of December. 1995 John Sa ag,. =4en, Cohen. State of California Kzu'en G. Count'/of Los Angeles On DccFmbc'r 14, 19~5 before mc, Peggy B. Loft. on Noua~' ~blic, personally appeared John E. Savage and Karen G. Cohen, personally known to mc (or proved to mc on thc ha.sis of satisfactory evidence) to be thc person(s) whose name(s) is/arc subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to m'. all that hc./shchh~, executed the same in his,~cr/their authorizzd capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their of which the ~rson(s; acted, executed th-. instrument. -'~ 'r'~.:'0 ~'". 0% Signature '",,,,,,, b' ~r ~?,,,,,'"' !.6A 6 CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDMSION IMPROVEMENTS THIS CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT FOR SUBDIVISION IMPROVEMENTS entered into this ' ~'~ day of - , 1997, between CREEKSIDE WEST, INC., a Florida corporation, hereinafter referred to as "Developer", m~d the Board of County Comnfissioners of Collier County, Florida, herein,Mter refen'ed to as the "Board". RECITALS: A. Developer has, simultaneously with the delivm~ of this Agreement, applied for the approval by the Board of a certain plat of a subdivision to be lmown as: Creekside Commerce Park West, Unit One. B. Division 3.2 of the Collier County Land Development Code requh'es the Developer to post appropriate g-uarantees for the construction of the improvements required by said subdivision re[,mlations, said guarantees to be incorporated in a bonded agn'eement for the construction of the required inq)rovements. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and mutual covenants hereinMter set forth, Developer and the Board do hereby covenant and aga'ee as follows: 1. Developer will cause to be constructed: The paving, landscaping, (h'ainage, potable water, irrigation water, sanitm'y sewer, and street hghting improvements for Creekside Commerce Pm'k West, Unit One, w/thin twenty-four (24) months from the date of approval of said subdivision plat, said improvements hereMter refen'ed to as the "required improvements". 2. Developer herewith tenders its subdivision performance security (attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and by reference made a part hereof) in the amount of $1,486,435.00 which amount represents 10% of the total contract cost to complete consmmtion plus 100% of the estimate cost to complete the required improvements at the date of this Agn'eement. 3. In the event of default hy the Developer or f,-filure of the Developer to complete such improvements within the time required by the Lm~d Development Code, Collier County, may call upon the subdivision perfbrmance security to insure satisfactm~j completion of the required improvement. 4. The required inq~rovements shall not be considered complete until a statement of substantial completion by Developer's engineer along with the final project records have been furnished to be reviewed and approved by the Development Services Director for compliance with the Collier County Land Development Code. Page 1 of 3 5. The Development Se, vices Director shall, within sLxty (60) days of receipt of the statement of substantial completion, either: a) notify the Developer m va-iting of his prchminmsz approval of the improvements; or b) noti. fy the Developer in vn'iting of his refl~sal to approve improvements, therewith specifying those conditions which the Developer must fulfill in order to obtain the Director's approval of the improvements. However, in no event shall the Dcvelopment Services Director refuse preliminaw approval of the improvements ff they are in fact constructed and submitted for approval in accordance with the requirements of this Agreement. 6. The Developer shall maintain all required improvements for a minimum period of one year after prelhninaw approval by the Development Stow-ices Director. After the one-year maintenance period by the Developer has terminated, the Developer shall petition the Development Services Director to inspec~ the required improvements. The Development Se~Mces Director or his designee shall inspect the improvements and, if found to be still in comphance with the Collier County Land Development Code as reflected by final approv,od by the Board, the Board shall release the rem,-fining 10% of the subdivision perfm~nance security. The Developer's responsibility for maintenance of the required improvements shall continue unless or until the Board accepts maintenance responsibility for and by the County. 7. Six (6) months after the execution of this Agn'eement and once within evew six (6) months thereafter the Developer may request the Development Ser, Sces Director to reduce the dollar amount of the subdivision performance secmSty on the basis of work complete. Each request for a reduction in the dollar amount of the subdivision performance security shall be accompanied by a statement of substantial completion by the Developer's engineer together with the project records necessary for review by the Development Services Director. The Development Services Director may gq'ant the request for a reduction in the amount of the subdixSsion performance security for the improvements completed as of thc (late of thc request. 8. In the event the I)eveloper shall f,xil or neglect to fulfill its obligations under this Agreement, upoll certification of such failure the County Administrator may call upon the subdivision perfom~ance security to secure satisfactory completion, repair and maintenance of the requfl'ed improvement.s. The Bo~'d shall have the right to construct and m,%intain, or cause to be constnmted or maint~fined, pursuant to public advm~sement and receipt and acceptance of bids, the improvements required herein. The Developer, as principal under the subdivision performance security, shall be hable to pay and to fl~demnify the Board, upon completion of' such construction, the final total cost to the Board thereof, including but not bruited to engineering, legal and other contingent costs, together with any damages, either direct or Page 2 of 3 " consequent, ia], which the Board may sust,'fin on account of the failure of the Developer to fulfill all of the provisions of this Agreement. 9. All of the terms, covenants and conditions herein contained are and shall be binding upon the Developer and the respective successors and assigns of the Developer. IN 1,VITNESS WHEREOF, the Boaxd and the Developer have caused this Agreement to be~xecuted by their duly authorized representative this [(~q,( day of qO . , 99,. ' - SIGNED, SEALED AND DELIVERED DEVELOPER: IN THE PRESENCE OF: Creekside West, Inc., a Florida corporation Printed Name: '~. ,I.#it,8~ Print Na~e: Lam~u: Gable "/~( ~ t e ~... '", [L.'c ~'/c ( ,,~. Title: ChairmanfDixector Printed Name: MARCIA J. WILHELM ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ' ' By :'..,'.:~.,~,, " : ..'"_,.,/ , .,...> . ,..,. . : /'..'~': .,, . . .., .', Deputy Clerk Tim HancoCk, Chah-ma~ / Approved as to form and legal ,, '2;, "' sufficiency: David C. Weigel County Attorney Page 3 of 3 : W- ~'0 ~ ~ ~.~.~,. I I I .12 16A 6 RESOLUTION 98- 2 A RESOLUTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO SECTION 2.7.3.4 OF THE COLLIER County LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AFFECTING ORDINANCE 91-55 ALSO KNOWN AS SADDLEBROOK VILLAGE PUD, EXTENDING THE CURRENT PUD APPROVAL TO DECEMBER 9, 1999; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the Saddlebrook Village PUD, Ordinance 91-55 adopted on June 25, 1991, is subject to the provisions of Section 2.7.3.4., of ~he Land Development Code (LDC), Time Limits for A~proved PUD Zoning Districts together with their respective Master Plans; an{] WHEREAS, the PUD was adopted consistent with and under the provisions of the Collier County Growth Management Plan; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has reviewed the PUD and determined to extend the current PUD Zoning for two years, until December 9, 1999; and NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, by the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida that: i. The above recitals are adopted herein by reference as if fully set forth herein. 2. This Resolution shall constitute evidence of compliance with the review requirements of Section 2.7.3.4 of the LDC. 3. Pursuant to said section of the LDC, the current PUD approval is hereby extended to December 9, 1999; at the end of which time the owner shall submit to the procedures in LDC Section 2.7.3.4, subject further to the following conditions: a. Phases I and II of the PUD shall be constructed in compliance with all applicable, existing Land Development Code requirements. b. Phase I shall be developed for 100% affordable units as provided in the new Affordable Housing Density Bonus Agreement approved by the Board of County Commissioners on December 9, 1997. Phase II shall also be developed as provided in the new Agreement. c. Prior to expiration of the 2 year extension period, a PUD amendment shall be filed with the County to formally incorporate the applicable Land Development Code standards in the PUD document. 16A 7 d. Architectural elevations for Phase I shall be constructed in compliance with the architectural elevations attached hereto as Exhibit A consisting of two pages. This Resolution supersedes and replaces Resolution 97-55 as corrected by Scrivener's Error Resolution 97-453. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its approval. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this Board and in the records of the Petition for which the extension is granted. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote. Done th~s day of .... '" '" , 1998. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Cha i rman ATTEST: DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk Approved as to Form and Legal Sufficiency: Assist. ant County Attorney -2- 'h 16A 7 NAi'A I~OULEVARI), I'iNE RII)(;E RO^I) ^(;RgE~ENT TI lin .'\(il~l'~liMt.iN'l', made and entered into, lhis .... day of ( :.~= ,,~ , z / lineR, hv and he,ween Vineyards I)cvclopmcm ('orpora~ion, hcrdnaflcr called '~ "VINI~YARI)N". ('lcvcland Clinic Florida (a non-profit corporation, as uwncr ol'Parccl I~ shown tm t'~xhihit I~, hcrdm~l'ter called "C'I,I~VI~I,ANI)-N.IL". Crossroads ~arket. Inc.. hcrcinalicr called "(.'I~()~gR()AI)~", (:lcvuland ('linic I:lm'ida (a non-prol]t corporation) ~kvncr ~1' l'arccl I) strewn <m Ifxhihit IL hcrcinalicr called "(~I,I~VI':I,ANI)-~.IL". and ('~fllicr ('oun~v. a p~litical suhdivisi~m of iht State of l"lorida, hcrcinalicr called thc "C()UNTY". VINI'~YARI)~, ('[,I:,VIiI,ANI)-N.I~., CI{()gSRC)AI)g and CI,EVI':i,ANI)-~.E. may hcrcinal~cr bc collectively rclkrrcd to as thc "I,ANI)()WNI~Rg" Wi'i'Ni,;~ E'I'! ! WI l I iR li,,\g, thc C(){ iNTY has engaged an cr]ginccring consultant to peril)tm a comprchc;tsivc engineering evaluation and tral'lic assessment Sltldv ol'the Pine Ridge Ro~td. Napa l~{)ulcx'ai'd and 1-75 intersection areas, thc findings {}fwhich stuth' arc in l~xhibil A and call lbr m{~di l]cations to thc 1-75 northl~t}Lmd ol'l:ramp al Pine Ridge Road (the "PR().II~CT"). more l~.~tlv clcscrihcd in l';xhibit "C" attached hereto and made a part hcrcoE and which Jmpr()vCnlCntX will bcncll{ iht C()[JN'I'Y and thc I.ANI)()WNI{RS whose bcncllting pre)putties m'c as sh<)wi~ on Ifxhihit "B" attached hereto and made a parl hcreoll trod WI llflLl']Ag, thc CO[;N'I'Y and thc I.ANI)()WNI.;Rg hereby agree to a joint sptmst~rship of thc said I~RO.II,:CT to meet thc desired ol2jcctivcs ol'salb tral'fic IllOX'CillCtlt Page 1 ot'5 fi'om northbound 1-75 to castbotmd l;inu Ridge Road while allowing lbr northbound movements from {~inc Ridge Road onto Napa Boulevard: and WI ItLRILAS, thc C()L ]N'I'Y and thc I,ANI)OWNI{RS, in consideration of the mutual bcncl]ts to c;~cl~ entity and to thc public, cio hereby a~rcc Io shnrc in Ibc estimated $70,926.25 estimates arc mom l'ullv doctlmUllted }11 [{xhibit "C" attached hereto and made a part hereof. Thc C()[JN'I'Y will contribute an estimated sum of $23,642.08 (33 I/3%). Thc I,ANI)()WNI~RS will each contribute an estimated sum of$11,821.04 (16 2/3% each): and WI II~RIS&S. thc COt JN'['Y is responsible Ibr assuring that thc consultants and c(mtractors ncccssm-y fi~r thc completion ot'lhc I~RO,IECT will be selected in compliance with all applicable State. l,ocal and l:cdcnd laws and regulations. N ( ) \V, TI 11!R 1": I:()I{I!, based upon thc m ut ual covenants hcrcin and ot her valuablc I. Thc above recitals arc truc and correct and incorporated herein. 2. Thc ('()[IN'l'y agrees to pay an estimated sum oF$23,642.08 (33 I/3%). VINI~YARI)S aurces to pay an estimated sum ors11,821.0,1 (16 2/.~ 4. CI,I~VI{I,ANI)-N.IL aurccs lo pay an estimated sum of$11,821.04 (16 5. ('R()SNR()ADS agrees lo pay an estimated sum of $11.821.04 (16 2/3%). 6. ('I.I(V!(I,2XN1)-N.I.;. aerccs to pay an estimated sum o1'$11,821.04 (16 7. Thc estimated cost of thc design, permitting and construction lbr the -3 g, fi)r conlingcncy, is $70,926.25. Upon exectllioll of I'R().II!CT. including ~ this Agrccmcnt, th~z I,ANDOWNERS shall each pay to the COUNTY an }~agc 2 of S amount equal lo $.~.)40..~>. a sum equal to 33 1/3% ol'each share of thc estimate. All moneys shall be deposited with thc C()[JNTY prior to thc issuance ol'a Ilolice to proceed to the design consttltant. g. t lpon completion and acceptance by lhe COtJNTY ofthe design plans, thc I.ANI)()WNILRS shall each pay to the COtJNTY an amotmt equal to 57.880.69. a sum equal to 66 _/3 N, of each share of the estimated cost of the ctmstructi(m work necessary tbr the I'I~OJECT. All moneys shall be deposited with thc C()tJNTY prior lo lbo issuance ora notice Io proceed to thc ~). Thc ('()I.~NTY will contract wilh lhe consultant and with the construction c~mtractor in accordance with the C()UNTY's purchasing policy, standard county procedures and all applicable State and Federal laws and regulations. 'l'he ('()lINTY shall be solely responsible lbr monitoring the perlbrmance of any c~msullanls and construction contractors hired lbr the PROJECT and lbr making payments to sallie. The LANDOWNERS shnll not have any obligations to thc COllStlllalltS or construction contractors nor shall they be parties Io thc contract between the C()[ iN'FY and thc consultants or construction contractors. Thc I.ANI)OWN[{RS sole obligation will be to make payments t ~ thc C()t IN'I'Y as set Ibrth in this Agreement. I(). Any additional I'tmds required to complete the PR()JECT, should the need tBr such additional l~mds become evident based on Ibc results of the construction bids. shall be deposited by thc LANDOWNERS with the COUNTY prior to thc execution of th,: construction contract. Page _3 of 5 .... 168 2 I I. ,'qhtmkl thc nccd lbr additional l'unds bccm'nc evident during thc course construction dt~c to either changed conditions, changes in the scope ol'work or additional w{~rk made necessary to complete thc I~RO.IECT in accordance with thc design intent, such flmds shall bc deposited by thc I,ANI)()WNHRS with thc C()[JN'I'Y Mthin five working days of written notice by thc COUNTY to tim I,AND()WNERS. 12. [Jpon complctitm of thc }~R().IECT any excess t~mds remaining in thc PRO.II,CT accom~t shall bc rclurncd to thc I,ANDOWNERS in proporlion their respective shams. 13. All reports, plans and other work product prepared lbr thc PRO.II,CT shall thc property of thc COUNTY. 14. This Agrccmcnt can bc tcmfinated by mutual agreement ofall parties and shall bc recorded in thc ()fficial Public Records of Collier County. 15. Thc ('()[ tN'I'Y confim'~s tt)the LANI)()WNERS that joint sptmsorship of thc l)rqjcct civics not include the l)inc Ridge Road widening rctbrred to in thc study attached as t(xhibil "A" and that thc I,ANI)OWNIiRS will not be obligated 1o share in such road widening costs. I,ANDOWNERS acknowledge that the COtJNTY will request their cooperation in providing any rigl?t-ot2xvay necessa~' to accommodate the additional widening made necessary by the dual lelk turn configuration at Napz~ Boulevard. I'agc 4 of 5 IN \VITNES$ \VI tERI!()F, ll~c parlics hereto have caused lhis instrtn'ncnt lo be ex¢ctnect in duplicate by Ilacir proper cd'l~cial.s or officers, duly amhorizcd so lo dc,, and have altlxect their seals thc day and year first above xvritten. ATTF. ST: , ..~/) . VINEYARDS DI:VELOPM[:.N'F CORPORA'FION t..t)rporatc Secretary N A. Sa~dch. President ff'~ Michael Procacci '{'ypcd Name Al'TI(ST: CI.L:VELA, ND CI. INIC FI.ORIDA ~' (,~'ion-pro fi - ]'>'pccl Name ~nd;i k~ia~-- Signature and Title ol'Signing OFficer Har~ K. ~n, Chief ~eat-ing Officer A'I-IT]ST: CROSSROADS MARKET . INC. Typ?d ~qa,nc[~gall 5tCorkle g~,uflt.'e and 'l'~llc ~ ~chard J. ~er, V. ATTEST: I~()ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COI.LIIZR COUNTY. FI.ORIDA Dxvi~ht E. [3mck. CLtiI~K Chairman APPROVED AS TO FORM ANI) I.E(;A[. SIJFFICIENC Y: Co[lieF (~OtllitV AllorlicV ' ..... l'agc 5 of 5 2 TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM No.1 ~HIH Pine Ridge Road/I-75 Intercha'nge Traffic Study Pine Ridge Road Median Opening at Napa Boulevard PREPARED FOR: Collier Count,,' PREPARED BY: CH2N[ HILL DATE: Jul,',' 31, 1997 Background In September 1995, CH2M HILL completed a traffic stud,,, for the Pine Ridge Road/I-7:5 interchange. This original smd?', dated September 28, 199:5, recommended near term and long range improvements to Pine Ridge Road and the intersecting interchange ramps with 1-75. Following completion of that report, Collier Count,,' and FDOT received a request to maintain the existing median opening at Napa Boulevard and Pine P, Jdge Road located approximately 1300 feet east of the 1-75 northbound ramp intersection. The September 1995 study did not consider the traffic operational impacts of a median opening at Napa Boulevard. This memo~'andum supplements the September 1995 study to consider the effects of a median opening at Napa Boulevard. Three intersections are considered in al'ds supplemental study: Pine P, Jdge Road and the southbound I-7:5 ramps (Intersection !), Pine Ridge Road and the northbound I-7:5 ramps (Intersection 2), and Pine Ridge Road and Napa Boulevard IIntersection 3). Traffic Data Traffic data for this supplemental study are based on existing and forecast traffic volumes presented in I-7:5 Muldmodal Master Plan prepared by FDOT. The opening ,','ear for the proposed interchange improvements is 1998 and the nominal design year is 2020. FDOT provided e,',dsting (1994) AM and PM peak hour turning movements at the interchange without the proposed median opening. FDOT also furnished desio~n ,,,'ear 2020 Aa'vi and P.'vI peak hour turning movements at the interchange and at Pine Ridge Road and Napa Boulevard with a median opening on Pine Ridge Road. ~EDIxr~ h~EU V3 073197 10~50.T6.01 Opening year (1995) tra(fic forecasts were developed using the 1994 and the 2020 ~ -, oreca~,s providedbvFDOT. ExistinS tra//ic volumes were.assumed to grow bv 3 Percent Per year from 1994 to 199S. It was iurther assumed that approximately 30 percent of the year 2020 Xapa 8ouicvarci traffic would occur by the year 1998. Thir9. percent o~ the Napa Boulevard traffic was assigned to the neNvork based on existing traffic patterns. Amual ~affic growth from 1994 to 199S and 30 percent o~ the Napa Boulevard traffic was added to the base year 1994 volumes to arrive at an ope~ng year forecast with the median opening at Napa Boulevard. The 1998 AM and PM trafEc volumes are summarized in E~ibit 1. Design year (2020) ,-XM and PM peak hour volumes were taken directly' from ~OT's 1-75 Multimodal Nlaster Plan and are su~arized in E~ibit 2. Based on the ~rai(ic forecasts, volumes at the three intersections included in t~s study are - expected to increase be~veen 1998 and 2020. However, in some cases the peak period is less in 2020. The traffic model used to develop ~e long-range traffic ~orecasts includes several new, or up-graded east-west arterials nor~ and south of Pine ~dge Road. Vanderbilt Beach Road is proposed to be extended easterly to 1-75 2.0 miles north o~ Pine flddge Road. A ~ull ir~terchange is proposed at Vanderbilt Beach Road and 1-75. A new interchar~ge is a~so proposed at Gotden Gate Parkway which is 2.5 miles south of Pine Road. Each o~ th, ese new interchanges are expected to draw ~a~iic from Pine Ridge Road. Intersection Geometry for 998 and 2020 Intersection geometry' and lane arrangements ~or both the opening year and desi~ year are based on recommendatior, s in the 1-75 Nlultimodal Master Plan and are su~arized in Exhibits 1 and q Pine x~ooe Road is assumed to have three basic lanes in eac}~ direction with exclusive leh turn lanes at each intersection. Traffic Analyses These analyses focus on impacts to the 1-75 ramp intersections and traffic progression along Pine Ridge Road assuming that the median opening at Napa Boulevard is maintained. ~-- Dl~ ~j-~M v'3 073197 Methodology Several dit'ferent analysis packages were used to model traffic operations and determine optimal signal timing at the study intersections. PASSER II-90 was used to develop initial phasing and timing schemes to optimize progression along Pine Ridge Road. SOAPS4 was also utilized to analyze initial phasing and tinting plans. Results from the initial PASSER and SOAP analyses were input into TRA. NSYT-7F to develop the final phasing plans, signal timings and offsets. The TRANSYT-7F analyses were prepared to provide progression alon~ l?ine Ridge Road while still maintaining reasonable levels of service on side road approaches. Results of the TR.;-XNS'~T-,.-'F and the SOAP analyses are attached to this memorandum. Weaving on Pine Ridge Road ,4. primary operational and safe~' concern associated with providing a median opening at ' Napa Boulevard is weaving traffic on .Pine Ridge Road bem,'een the northbound exit ramp from 1-75 and the eastbound left turn at N'apa Boulevard. Under existing conditions the right turn from th,: 1-75 northbound exit ramp is free flow and yieIds to traffic on Pine Ridge Road. When Pine Ridge Road is widened, traffic turning right from the exit ramp and then wanting to turn left onto Napa Boulevard will be required to yield to Pine I~idge Road eastbound traffic and make at least t,hree lane changes within less than 1000 feet. At FDOT's request, a weaving analysis usin§ the HCS sob, rare was completed for eastbound Pine Ridge Road between the [-75 northbound ramps and Napa Boulevard. This two-sided weave, formed by the free flow right hand entrance to Pine Ridge Road followed bv a left turn to Napa Boulevard, was analvzed as a Type C weaving area. Under this configuration the through traffic on Pine Pddge Road is functionally a weaving volume. Traffic turning right from the 1-75 ramp and then left to Napa Boulevard must cross all lanes of Pine Ridge Road to execute their maneuver. Based on the HCS analysis the weaving section would operate at LOS E to F during each of the 1998 and 2020 peak periods (See Appendix for HCS output). The }'{CS model predicts weaving and non-weaving speeds between'35 mph and 27 mph. These operating speed are over 10 mph below the posted speed limit of 45 mph. ~'EOI~ ~EN( v3 073197 3 To eliminate the potential weavin$ problem it is proposed that the existing free flow right turn lane on the exit ramp be reconstructed parallel to the left turn lanes and placed unde: qi~n-~control. With this treatmenL weavin~ would be controlled bv the si~nal. Ki~ht turninq traffic would ~1 be required to chanse lanes to make a left turn at Napa Boulevard, but the movement could be made freely while eastbounci Pine Ridge Road traffic is stopped at the ramp intersection. All the traffic analyses assume that tNis right turn lane is reconstructed and controlled by the sisal. Traffic Operations Traffic operations were analvzed under four scenarios, 199S AM and PM and 2020 AM and P~I. The TK.-XNS~T-7F anal?'ses were run to determine the optimum cycle length and intercal timing to minimize intersection delay and maintain progression on Pine Ridge Road. Signal timings and time-space diagrams with prosression bands for each scenario are inc]uded in the attached materials. Intersection average delav and volume to capacity ratios as reported in the T~N'St~-TF ou~ut are summarized in Table 1. Ea~ intersection will operate well at Level of Sec'ice C or better in the openin~ year and LOS D or better in the design year. The timing and phasin~ plans provide progression at the 45 ~IPH in both the eastbound and westbound directions. See the attached time space diagrams for si~al offsets and progression bandwidths. The primary purpose of these analyses are to demonstrate that the proposed rr-nocments will sate!v and efficiently accommodate ~e forecast traffic volumes with a reasonable level o~ progression on Pine Ridge Road. The signal timings offsets, and phasing plans should be ~urther refined to even out delay and V/C ratios on ~e side s~eets and improve progression on the arterial based on actual ~affic conditions at the time o~ cons~ction. Storage Lane Requirements Queue length requirements are summarized in Table 2. These lane requirements were calculated usin§ the formula in FDOT's Plans Preparation Manual with a default cycle length of 120 seconds. These dimensions do not incIude deceleration/taper distances. The total turning lane requirements are presented in exhibit. The TP,~NSYT-/-"'F and SOAP output also provide an estimate of maximum queue length for comparison purposes. It is ~£OIAN ~--:.~ '/'J 0731.97 '" 4 :'!'l~ :iCG:.. ~O.~D ~,'IEDI~N Or~ENING .~T NASA important to note that the TRANSYT-TF queue includes vehicles that arrive during the green phase and join the back oF the queue, while the front of the clueue is discharging durin~ the initial seconds of the §reen phase. Using the FDOT formula, The 2020 storage len,,..~th requirement for tile Pine Ridge Road eastbound dual left t~.~rn movement at ,:x,'apa Boulevard is 815 feet. The 1998 storage len§th for the same movement is calculated to be 245 feet. Based on the uncertainty development in the northeast quadrant of the interchange, the projected traffic makin~ the eastbound to northbound left turn (974 in the 2020 AM peak), and engineering judgment, it is recommended that 510 feet of dual left turn storage be irdtially provided for the eastbound to northbound movement at Napa Boulevard. Pine Pddge Road should be designed and constructed to allow for the t'uture extension of these left turn lanes to S15 feet of storage ii: needed. FDOT stal"f bas concurred v,'ith this recom, mendation. Conclusions .'v[aintainin$ the existing median opening at Pine Ridge Road and Napa Boulevard requires reconstruction oF the free Flow right turn lane from the [-75 northbound exit ramp. This modit:ication is required to control weaving on Pine Ridge Road beO. veen the ramp terminal intersection and ,X'apa Boulevard. The turning lane should be reconstructed to be parallel to the left turn lanes approaching the intersection and should be controlled by the traffic at the ramp terminal. The right turn lane on.lv needs to provide 270 feet of storage on the ramp, but the storage for the lane should begin approximately 355 feet south of the stop line to ensure the lane is not blocked by queued left turn traffic. In addition, an eastbound dual left turn with a storage length of S10 feet should be provided at Napa Boulevard. YVith these modifications and the proposed lane arrangemeats presented herein, the intersections studied will operate at acceptable levels of service in tile opening year and the design )'ear. Furthermore, good progression can be maintained on Pine Ridge Road between the interchange and Napa Bo,~levard with proper signal phasing and coordination. I Table 1. Intersection Operations ~-~$ .'x.MI I~,"$ Pxl' 2o:o .-\Mi 2C,20 P,xl CvcI.e = 110 sec Cycle = 120 sec Cycle = 120 sec Cycle = 120 se: I Avg. Ars. Avg. Avg. Intersection v/C Dele;'~ V/'C Delay' V/C Delay' V/C Deiav' (veL/sec) (veL/sec) (veL/sec) {'.'eh/sec) 1-75 Southbound 0.81 16.0 0.SS 1 !.9 0.74 15.6 0.91 12.3 Ramps 1-75 Northbound 0.53 7.S 0._;:3 5.7 0,84 14.1 0.87 16.0 Ramps Nape Bouleva rd 0.69 19.0 0,68 15.4 0.95 38.5 0.$5 31.3 ~$e TILA. NSYT-7F ou ,tput. Table 2. Queue Length Requirements Critical Cycle Length Peak Hour I No. of Storage Length Intersection Peak (sec) Volume Lanes (it/lane) (vvh) 1-75 5outhbound Ramps _CB Left 2020 ..\M 120 623 2 520 'WB Left 2020 ,AN[ 120 163 1 275 1-73 Northbou;~d Ramps NB Left *'" -0~0 PM 120 424 ~ 355 EB Left 2020 PM 120 587 2 490 NB Right 2020 PM 1.to j 163 1 270 Na2a Boulevard , NB Left 2020 P.M I20 91 I 155 SB Left 2020 AM 120 286 I 480 EB Left 2020 AM 120 974 2 815 WB Left 2020 P,M 120 30 1 $0 Implementation of Improvements Conceptual plans have been developed for the improvements to the northbound [-75 off ramp and the left turn lanes at Nape Boulevard. The reali~m'u'nent of the northbound 1-75 ~.~.~ ~l~N ~E~ ~ 073197 right turn off ramp is shown in E~ibit 3. A right turn lane o(355 feet plus a 50 ~oot taper Js provided with the right turn lane being brought trader signal control as discussed above. The widenin~ of Pine Ridge Road to accommodate the dual left turn lanes at Nape ~oulevard is st~own in Exhibit 3. Pine P~d~e Road will be widened to ~e north for the following reasons: · Widening to the south will cause impacts to wetland S-3 for a distance of 485 feet. These additional impacts will ~igger the need for ACOE mitigation which is currently not needed and would likely ffigger the need for S~'MD mitigation which is also not currently needed. The volume of water quality tream~ent being provided in ~e pond located on the south side of Pine Ridge Road benveen the D-2 canal and Napa Boulevard would be reduced. This would not be favorably viewed by SF~D. · Right-of-way would be required from more property owners on the south side than on the north side. The desi~ for" ~ ~n,: eastbound dual Ieft turn lane shown in E~ibit 3 provides a queue length of 815 feet pIus 240 feet for taper and decelera~on which is required for 2020 volumes. A 50:1 taper is provided to transition the median width to accon~odate the dual left mm lane. The median width taper will overlap the taper for the northbo~d free flowing righ~ mm on ramp. This will cause the reatig~ent of the on ramp. For westbound Napa Boulevard a single left turn lane wiI1 be provided. The total length of widening to Pine Pddge Road to accon~odate dual left turn lanes is about 2,000 feet (Sra. 1110+28 to Sra. 1130+2S). As indicated earlier, it is recommended the i~tial construction of the dual left mm lane be 510 ~ ~ ,e~t of storage length in lieu of 8!5 feet of storage required in 2020. Additional right-of-way will be needed to provide for ~e dual left turn Ianes at Napa Boulevard. From Sra. 1124+00 (east side of Napa Boulevard) to Sta. 1126+50 (east end of the right mm lane) an additional 10 feet of right-of-way is needed. From Sra. 1126+50 to Sra. 1129+00 an additional 5 feet of right-of-way is needed. No additional right-of-way is needed west of Napa Boulevard due to the wid~ of the existing limited access right-of- way. These right-of-way requirements are approximate and are based on ~e conceptual I design contained herein. The exact limits and width oF right-o{-way will be determined durin~ final desisn. Cost of Improvements Costs have been icientit:ied t:or desioo-n and construction o{ the proposed improvements and are summarized in Table 3. The costs do not include the acquisition of right-ot'-,,va,v along the north side of Pine Ridge Road east o£ Napa Boulevard as described above. In estimating the project costs it ~,,'as assumed additional storm water quality treatment would not be required by SF~,,'~%,iD. It ,,vas further assumed that these improvements would not trigger environmental mitigation since none is currently needed. The costs provided in Table 3 represent an order-of-magnitude estimate based on the conceptual desi~rt of the improvements shov~'n in Exhibit 3. Final desioo-n and construction costs will be developed ii: the improvements are implemented. TABL-'_ 3. COST OF IMPROVEMENTS NORTHBOUND OFF RAMP MODIFICATIONS FOR RIGHT TURN LANE Construction Costs Ne,.,., pavement S11.970 Pavement removal $12,500 Sodding S9,000 Signal modification 55,000 Miscel[aneous S 19.230 Subtotal $57,700 Design Costs S5.300 ROW Ccs',s SO Total ~amp Costs 563,000 PINE RIDGE ROAD WIDENING FOR DUAL LEFT TURNS AT NAPA BOULEVARD Construction Costs New pavement S19,800 Addilional 18" pipe S600 Additional 54' pipe S900 Landscaping & irrigation S19.800 New signal S85.000 Miscellaneous S63.050 Subt$:ml S189.150 Design Costs S34,000 ROW Costs Nol included in cos! estimate Total Pine Ri~,~e Road Costs ,$223,150 GRAND TOTAL COSTS $286,150 ~ WIDEN RAMP 12' TO ACCOMMODATE S I / DUAL LEFT TURN DANES, PROVIDE 500' - ,~1 / OF DUAL LANES VVITH 600' TAPER. IX/~ ?~ '"". "'. '"-, WIDEN PINE RIDGE ROAD 7' TO THE / ~ :~ ",' ". ".. NORTH TOACCOMODATE DUAL LE~ t x ?. ~ x,..'~ ........... ~.~AL~ONRAMPAND TAPER / SCAL= -1'=200' / ~ "'~' % %"~'. /TOACGOMODATE WIDENING OF / ] ~'~, L 'x,%'.~... 50:1 TAPER /PINERIDGEROADFORDUALLEr~ / ~ ~ ................... ~ .............................................................. - ........ IS~ND ~'~: ~, /// ,.,/"~ REMOVE EXISTING FREE FLOW '~~ WIDEN RAMP f2' TO PROVIDE FOR RtGHT TURN ~NE, 355' IN LENGTH PLUS A 50' TAPE; TOTAL LENGTH = 405'.  WIDEN RAMP 12' TO ACCOMMODATE DUAL LEFT TURN - LANES, 475' STORAGE WITH 100' DECELERATION LANE AND 50' TAPER; TOTAL LENGTH= 625' EXHIBIT 3 Elimination of 1-75 Free Flow Right Turn Ramp and Widening of Pine Ridge Road to Provide Dual Left Turn Lanes at Napa Boulevard Pine Ridge Road/Naps Boulevard Median Opening Ramp Modificatio:as Construction Costs Quantity Unit Price Cost New Pavement 370 $21 $7,770 1" FC, 3.5" Type S, 6"ABC. 12" Type B Stab pavement I(emoval (SY) 2500 $5 $12,500 Asphalt pavement Sodding (SY) 3000 $3 $9.000 Include water, fertilizer Signal Modifications (LS) I $5.000 S5,000 Misccllancous $17,135 50% Subtotal S$ !,405 FDOT Coordination (Hrs) 8 $115 $920 Design (Hfs) 40 $75 $3,000 SF'~'M~ Coordination (Hfs) $ $90 $720 E~penses $696 Assume 15% Total Design Costs S5.336 Total Ramp ModiEcatlons $56,74! Contingency $14,185 Project Total Note: The purpose of this spreadsheet is to estimate the design and construction costs for the realignment of the NB right mrn off ramp. Costs assume no modifications will be required to thc water quality treatment ponds. Costs do not include any R. OW acquisition. 16B 7' Date: January 7, 1998 To: A. Nyankadau Korti, Project Manager Office of Capital Projects Management From: Ellie Hoffman, Deputy Clerk Minutes & Records Department Re: School Facilities Agreement Between the Board of County Commissioners and the School Board of Collier County Enclosed please find the original document as referenced above, Agenda Item ~16B7, approved by the Board of County Commissioners on January 7, 1998. Please forward the agreement to the School Board for the designated signatures and kindly return the fully executed original to Minutes and Records. If you should have any questions, please contact me at: (8406). Thank you. Enclosure ( ~(~~~ COLLIER COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS SCHOOL FACILITIES LEASE AGREEMENT THiS LEASE. entered into this~~' day of . 19 y and between the School Board of Collier County, Florida, hereinafter referred to as th~Y'School Board, and Collier County Board, hereinafter referred to as the User, of County Com~issioners WITNESSETH: The parties to this lease have agreed that the following terms and conditions shall be applicable to the lease of any of the School Board facilities described herein. 1. School Board Policy No. KG, as adopted by the School Board, May 6. 1982. shall be incorporated by reference into this Lease and is included on the reverse as a part hereof, and the parties agree to be bound by the terms and conditions found herein, 2. The following information is presented by the User in order to obtain the required facilities and the User affirms that said facts are true and correct to the best of its knowledge and belief: a. NameofschoohBip_. Cypress Elementary School. b. Dates bulldlng to be ueed: ~i'anu~.r¥ 8, 1998 c. Number of meetings: One d. Hours building to be used: 7:00-9:00pm. Anticipated attendance: 150 f. Purpose of u,,: Public }{earin~ g. Is meeting free Io public: Yes h. What price Is charged to attend: na I. Name oforgenlzatlonualngfacllttles: Coil].er County 5aural at County L;ommiss:~oners J. Name of Uaar'a President and telephone number: Timothy L. Hancock, Chairman of Board of Commissioners k. Name of User's Treasurer end telephone number: I. Furnlshlngaorapeclalpreparatlonsneeded: Tables, Ch, airs, H~crophone, Podium m. Check (X) facilities needed:* ( ) Claasroom ( ) Auditorium ( ) Baseball Field { ) Football/Soccer Field (X[ Cafelerla, Science/ _Middle _Without lights _Without Lights Vocational Lab _High _With lights _With Llghts ( ) Kitchen _LELY HIGH ( ) Softball Field ( ) Track ( ) Gymnasium ( ) Outslde Play fields _Wlthoutllghts _WlthoutLlghls _Non HVAC _Non-watered _With lights _With Lights _Middlew/HVAC _Watered ( ) OTHER _High w/HVAC · Use of these facilities is allowed for up to slx (6) hours at the current rental rates, regardless of the number of events scheduled within this time limit. Use in excess of six (6) hours shall be charged a prorated amount tn minimum increments of two (2) hours each. I(We), Collier County (User'h a legal corporation and/or citizens of the State of FIorlda and of the United States of America, do solemnly ,.',wear or affirm that I will support the Constitution of the United States and of the State of Florida: that I am not a member of the Communist Party; that I have not and will not lend my aid, support, advice, counsel or influence to the Communist Party: that I do not believe in the overthrow of the C~Overnment of the United States or of the State of Florida by force or violence: that I am not a member of any'o'rganization or party which believes in or teaches, dlrectly or indirectly, the overthrow of the Government af t~e Unlfe~l States or of the State of Florida by farce or violence. Furthermore, the c~rg.~..n, lzatj~ tha~j~l'eJ~(esenf s..~r~scribes to the above statements of loyalty. SIGNATURE. , ,-... ......... ~ADDRESS CITY ZIP PHONE ·-F- -.-- ,.. . - ..... ; -/ZTL-J-Z. If applicable: Check payable to Collier Coun[7 Public Schools / ~.Appucams, Please a~-rlo writ. . . e belo.____.~ thl__.~s Ilr~e2 -~ Copy orproSmm,'pr~senadon '~ must bear the designated signatures. _ ..... ! RENTAL FEES~ = S per use X uses ~ /SALESTAX S or Tox Exempt I.D.# tl~'~rincip°I / DEPOSIT S~ (High School oudltorlums) x--~u' /ADDITIONAL S ~ /CHARGEs ~'~ ~.~:~ssistant Supt./Administration LTOTAL S~ Check No ~l ~ White: Assistant Supt./Administration Canary: Business Office Pint(: School Gold: User THE COLLiE~ COUNTY PUBt.:C SCHOOL SYSTEM lc, AN EQUAL ACCESS / EQUAL OPPORTUNITY INSTITUTION FOR EOUCA"flON AND EMPLOYMENT *** 2266030 OR: 2377 PG: 3109 *** HCORDBD in OHICIAL ~¢0~S of COLLIER COUNTY, ~L 01/07/98 at I1:23A~ D~IGFf ~. BROCK, CH£K ~C H! ~.00 SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COM~ISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: JAIME JAUREAUI AKA JAIME JAUREGUI (10/19/60) CASE NUMBER: 97 2604 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 29th day of April, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2312, page 3159. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed .this.. . ~ day of~/~..~O , 199~. .T EST : '"' ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA '.~le~/~. of Circuit' Co6rt" BY' Timothy L. Hancock ?/ Chairman Approved as to form legal./sufficiency ~ CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ . P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266031 OR: 2377 PG: 3110 *** R]CORD~O iR O~IClAt. UCORD$ of COLLII~ COUIITL ~L - 01/07/98 at Il:IDA D~IGH? 1, BROCI, CLllI ~C Ill 6. O0 RetS: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 01~321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: JENNIFER OMARA AKA JENNIFER M OMARA (07/30/71) CASE NUMBER: 97 3428 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 20th day of May, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2320, page 2559. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~-~ day of~ ~~~ , 199~. /BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ATTEST: '... .. CO~R COUNTY, FLORIDA BY: Timothy L. Hancock '-.,.aler~'of Circuit COur~ / Chairman Approved as to form legal sufficiency _ PREPARED BY: { C CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT [~ . P.O. BOX 413044 ~ssistant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266032 OR: 2377 PG: 3111 *** RXC0~D in OUI¢IAL RXCOD$ of COLLIER COU~?I, ~L ~ ?H 6.00 ~n: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 010-321110  FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: JUAN TObiAS MIGUEL AKA JUAN MIGUEL TOMAS (02/14/68) CASE NUMBER: 97 7052 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 23rd day of September, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2354, page 3393. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. ' ~--~-~-/' , 199~. Executed this ~v-/ day of__~ ATTEST: ~BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS '..... COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA .dle'r~ of Circui'%-~C°ur% - " BY: Ti~_t~' L'.~a~6'ck ~ : Chairman Approved as to form leg~ sufficiency PREPARED BY: ~ ~ CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ C , ~ ' ~ P.O. BOX 413044 Ass%stant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266033 OR: 2377 PG: 3112 *** RECORDED in OFFICIAL £ECORD$ of COLLIER COUNT~, FL ~ SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER (}10-321110 /~ FOR CLERK'S USE ONI.Y KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: SHAYNE TREVER BENTZONI AKA SHAYNE TREVER BENTZONI ( 10/01/76 ) CASE NUMBER: 97 7775 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 5th day of November, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2364, page 1959. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this day of ~ ...... ~,~/' , 199~. / : COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA .tLePk~:-Cerc.uit"Co~Frt- / ' BY: ~t~haYnL. Hancock App. roved as.. to form legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ . P.O. BOX 413044 Asglstant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266034 OR: 2377 PG: 3113 *** ~CORD~D i~ O~ICIAL R~CORDS of COLLIER COUR?T, ~L . O1/07/gB at 11:23~ DWIGH? ~. BROCK, CL)RK ~¢ ~! ~.00 Rets: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~)1C~321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: ATIBA BABATU WALDEN (12/21/77) CASE NUMBER: 97 0529 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 5th day of May, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2363, page 1804. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~/~ day of ~~~/ , 1999. ATTEST: D OF COU-TY~ COMMISSIONERS %/COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Cl'erk.~f'CircSie"~do.~ '.% - BY: Tim/othy L. Hancock ' " Chairman Approved as to' form legal sufficiency ~~ ~~ PREPARED BY: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ C' P.O. BOX 413044 As istant Coun5y Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266035 OR: 2377 PG: 3114 *** ~IC0~DID in OFFICIAL ~CORD$ of COLLIIR COUNTY, FL ~ 01/07/98 aL II:Z3AI( DWIGHT l. BROCK, CLIH SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~i0-321110 / FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESES'TS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: FRED WILLIAM HE:~SON AKA FRED WILLIAM HESSON (05/28/58) CASE NUMBER: 97 4759 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 24th day of October, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2364, page 1927. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~- -~ day of -')~3L. ~_~.~/~ , 199~. ATTEST: ~ - ouaRD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA CIerR ~' Circu~it~..~C.0~rt' BY T~m6thy L Hancock : / Chairman / / Apuroved as to form legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~> · P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant -Coun~.~ ~ NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266036 OR: 2377 PG: 3115 *** I~CORD~D in OFFICIAL RECORDS of COLLI~ COUN??, FL '.- 01/07/98 at 11:2311 D~IGH? g. BRO¢I, CLIRI HC ~! 6.00 1 6 G 1 SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESEN'rS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: TABATHA ATASSHA WILLIAMS AKA TAB TAB (06/17/76) CASE NUMBER: 97 3142 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 21st day of July, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****FORTY AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2340, page 1909. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ c-~ /~/~ ~ day of ez~ , 199~. ATTEST: ~/' ~B~O'ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA C.lerK o/f/Circuii C.o~Zrt BY: Timdthy L. Hancock Chairman Approved as to form legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ~ ~ P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266037 OR: 2377 PG: 3116 *** RECORDED in OPPICIAL RECORDS of COLLIER COUNTY, FL '_ 01/07/98 a~ 11:Z3~ DWIGHT ~. BROC[, CLERK ~¢ ~I ~.00 SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 01~321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESES'TS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: PEDRO DAVID GARCIA (05/03/58) CASE NUMBER: 97 1537 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 21st day of May, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****ONE HUNDRED AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2318, page 1618. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Ceurt cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this /~ day of O~~x~' , 199~. ATTEST: D OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA CierW'of Circuit..~6ur( BY Tlmdthy L. Hancock / , Chairman / Approved as to form legal suffic'iency PREPARED BY: ~ , -~ P.O. BOX 413044 k~is*tant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266038 OR: 2377 PG: 3117 *** HCORDXD In OFFICIAL L~CORDS of COLLZIR COUIi?T, 01/07/98 aL 1I:23~ DI/IGR! SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~1~321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: BILLY JOE MOYER AKA BILLY J MOYER (10/08/70) CASE NUMBER: 97 4714 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 13th day of August, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2340, page 1795. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ day of 199~. ATTEST: ~ ~BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA C~erk/of CircUit ~/o~5 B : Timothy L. Hancock / Chairman / Approved as to form legal sufficiency .~ P~I~ PREPARED BY: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ C, t P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266039 OR: 2377 PG: 3118 *** R]COD~D in 0HICIA~ HCORDS of COLLIH COU~?T, ~L 01/0?/H at 11:23~ DWIGHT ~. BROCK, ~C H~ ~.00 SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~i~321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: FRANCISCO BALTAZAR (10/21/72) CASE NUMBER: 97 6358 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the llth day of August, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2340, page 1820. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~g-/~ day of ~ ,,~_~.~ , 199~. COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ~le~/ of Circ~it..-cZu~r-~/~- BY: Tin, thy L. Hancock ? ? Chairman Approved as to form legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~A4~. P.O. BOX 413044 AsSistant CoUnty Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266040 OR: 2377 PG: 3119 *** ~CORD~D In OFFICIAL ~CORD$ of COLLI~ COU~?~, E~ % SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 010-321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: ' LUISA ADEYRA AMPARO (01/14/76) CASE NUMBER: 97 1065 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 25th day of March, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS' under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2302, page 0268. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ ''''~' day of ~~-~7' _, 199F. ATTEST.: ~ARD ' OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BY: ~ami~rmh~nL' HancoCk -- Approved as to form legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT Assistant Couhty ~ P.O. BOX 413044 NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266041 OR: 2377 PG: 3120 *** ~C0~ID in 0HICIAL ~CORDS of COLLHR COUNTY, 01/07/98 at II:23A~ Dill? I. HOCI, SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~10-321110 ~ FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: WILLIAM ROBERT DUVALL AKA WILLIAM BILLY DUVALL ( 12/23/77 ) CASE NUMBER: 97 3887 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 17th day of JUNE, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2326, page 2031. The Board of County Conunissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ day of ~~ , 1999. ATTEST: ~/ B~OARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS :.'. , ', .~ ~ COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA / ~_, BY: Tim6thy L. Hancock ., ',, .... Chairman Approved as, t~ form legal' sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ' P.O. BOX 413044 Asslsr~ant Count~ A--{t-~rne'---~ NAPLES, FLORIDA 34 101-3044 *** 2266042 OR: 2377 PG: 3121 *** 01/07/9B at ll:23AJ( O¥I~,l~T !. BROCK, UC H! Rets: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES~OF TIlE PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: ALTHEA CHRISTINA OLIVER (09/20/59) CASE NUMBER: 95 10192 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 25th day of July, 1996, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****FIFTY AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2213 page 1047. , The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this _. ~ ~- day of ~.-~.~_~. , 199~. AT EST: OF COUNTY CO~ISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ~er~f CircuTt ~rt~ ~ ~' BY: Tim~hy 'L[ ~cdck Ch~i~an Approved as to fo~ legal sufficiency ~ CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ~ P.O. BOX 413044 Ass~=tant uounty Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266043 OR: 2377 PG: 3122 *** 01/07/98 at II:23~ DWIGHT l. BROCK, CLIRI SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~HI£RING FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: CLABEL JULIEN AKA CLABEL JULIER (01/07/72) CASE NUMBER: 96 8614 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 19th day of December, 1996, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****ONE HUNDRED FIFTY AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2269, page 1575. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. ATTEST: ~;/ ARB OF COUNTY COMmISSIOnERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA -Cle~k;~f Circu~Wc.~a~'rt' BY: Timdthy L. Hancock Chairman Approved as to form leqal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT P.O. BOX 413044 NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044~ *** 2266044 OR: 2377 PG: 3123 *** ~CODE lo O~ICIAL ~CORDS of COL~I~ COUP?I, ~L 01/07/98 aL lI:23,U( OUGHT [. tRO¢~, CL~H UC H! 6.00 , SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER /)10-321110 ~HIERIN~ ~ FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: GARY ROLAND RAYMOND (03/25/60) CASE NUMBER: 96 5336 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 10th day of December, 1996, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****FOUR HUNDRED FIFTY AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2261, page 0619. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this day of ~~/ , 199~. ATTEST: /BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ~t~lerk ~ Circuit"So.urt B : ~in~thy L. Hancock / Chairman / Approved as to form legal sufficiency ~ l~ PREPARED BY: f ,~ CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ~ P.O. BOX 413044 ~-ss'~stant ~ounty Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266045 OR: 23?? PG: 3124 *** ]C ~11 ~. O0 Reta: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~ FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: ' RASJIA HEISTON (04/11/76} CASE NUMBER: 96 7973 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the llth day of December, 1996, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****ONE HUNDRED AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2260, page 1991. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~/~ 7-~ day of ~7~~A~ _, 199~' ATTEST: OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ' _~~~ COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ' ' ~k/Q~ Circuit Co~t · / BY TimOthy L. Hancock :.. Chairman .Approved as to form lega~ sufficiency I CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ~ P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266046 OR: 2377 PG: 3125 *** 01/07/9~ at I1:23~ D~IG]~? I. BROil, SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: MICHAEL HENRY CASTRO (11/12/58) CASE NUMBER: 97 0695 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 3rd day of June, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2330, page 2445. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name ~y its Chairman. Executed this J /~-~ day of .~. . ..... ~l,_~ , 199~. ATTEST: B~RD%OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA r~ BY: Ti~dthy L. Hancock Cie C i rcu'i-~-CoU/r% Y - Chairman .. Approved as to form .legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT P.O. BOX 413044 t ou , '' ' y Attorney NAPLES FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266047 OR: 2377 PG: 3126 *** ~CORD~D in O~ICIAL ~C0~$ of CO~I~I COIf]ITL ~C ~11 le~a: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~1~21110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: DAWAYNE EDWARD GARRETT (05/06/76) CASE NUMBER: 97 7239 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 8th day of September, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2349, page 2273. The-Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ ~-~ day of ~ ...... ~/ , 199~. ATTEST: ~// ..... v~OARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS B : Ti~thy L. Hancock " Chairman / Approved as.to form legal sufficiency ~ ~______ PREPAREDBY: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT , ~' ~' P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant CouHty Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266048 OR: 2377 PG: 3127 *** O1/O?/gB at lI:~ DWI~? ~. BROCK, ¢~RK ~¢ ri! ~.00 Retn: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~)10-321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: LEEANNE SIMMONS (01/01/74) CASE NUMBER: 96 1664 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 22nd day of May, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2332, page 1258. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ day of ~~ , lgg~. ATTEST: J/ .... OF CO JNTY COMmiSSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA C ~e~k/of Clrc~.it ~,~Ot]r-~~- - BY Tin~othy Lo Hancock Chairman Approved as. tO form legal sufficiency ~ ~_____ PREPARED BY-: ~ ~ CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT '" ' P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266049 OR: 2377 PG: 3128 *** HCO~I~ in 0~ICIAL RICO~D~ of ¢OL~III C0UM?I, ~ ~ RIC 71! ~.00 ReLn: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER ~10-321110 //~ FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: JACINTO MONTEZ (08/15/30) CASE NUMBER: 96 9563 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 9th day: of January, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****FIFTY AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2275 page 2265. , The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. · Executed this ~ day of ~.~*. _~.~_,~.~,_// 199~. , · ATTEST: D OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS · ' ~ . COLdEr. COUNTY, FLORIDA Clerk/of Circ~it-fi6u~- * ' BY: Timdthy L. Hancock Chairman ... Approved as to form 'legal sufficiency ssQ~ss ~ PREPARED BY: ~ CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ C, P.O. BOX 413044 A rant Count~ Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266050 OR: 2377 PG: 3129 *** RICORD~D ~ OI~CIA~ RICO~DS of COL~ZIR CO,NTT, ~, 01/07/98 at 11:23~ D~IGHT I. BROCK, CLIRI UC ?~! 6.00 Retn: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: JMES WILLIES JONES (08/05/62) CASE NUMBER: 97 7243 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 8th day of September, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2349, page 2272. The Board of County Co~issioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Co~issioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~/ day of ×~~_~_~ , 199~. ATTEST:. ~/~RD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS  t COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA e~' of CifcUL~ COurt BY: Tim~th~ L. r~6~k -- Chai~an Approved as to form legal' sufficiency~ ~ l~._~ PREPARED BY: i CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ~' P.O. BOX 413044 AsSistant County Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 ZZ U51 OR: 2377 ?G: 3130 R~CORD~D l~ O~I¢IA~ R]~ORg$ o[ ~OLLIBR ¢OgR?l, ~ · Ol/O?/gB at 11:23~ Oilg~t l, BROCK, CLgRI RJR ~[[ 6.00 Retn: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 010-321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: JESSICA HOPE WEBB (03/31/78) CASE NUMBER: 97 00092 CFA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 29th day of September, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2354, page 3370. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~-~ day of ~' .~.~,_~_._~ ~ , 199~. ATTEST: ~ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA .-(2~e'r~of Circdit~ou~'- ~ BY: ~rtmhYanL. Hancock Approved as to form legal sufficiency  PREPARED BY:  CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ~-, I P.O. BOX 413044 As§istant-Coun~ty Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266052 OR: 2377 PG: 3131 *** R~CORI~D hi OP[ICIA5 R~CO£DS Of ¢OLLI~I~ CO~;gTr, ?L ~ 01/07/~8 at 1I:23~ D~IG~T !. BROCK, CL[RI ~C [~! 6.00 Re:n: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 01~321110 /~ FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: LAURA BAKER AKA LAURA L BAKER (03/02/62) CASE NUMBER: 97 0454 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 1st day of July, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of e***FORTY AND 00/100***********DOLLARS' under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2332, page 0324. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ ~ day of ~-~.~..~.~ , 19'9~. · ATTEST: ~/- B~OARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA · ~ler of Cir~uit/dou~t'~' ~~Y~/~/  BY: Timothy L. Hancock Chairman Approved as to form legal sufficiency ~v~ PREPARED BY: ~% ~ CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT . P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant un y ey NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 n *** 2266053 OR: 2377 PG: 3132 *** HCORHD in 0HICIU. HC01~D~ of COLLH! COUNTZ, ~L 01/07/~8 at II:23AM O~IGHT B. HOC[, CLHK ~C H! 6.00 Retn: SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: CONSTANCE M DENNIS AKA CONSTANCE MARIE DENNIS (03/25/63) CASE NUMBER: 96 5092 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 9th day of September, 1996, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2234, page 2307. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Exe'cuted this ~7~ day of ~~~ 199~. ATTEST: /BBOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA '- of Cird~i~ 2~ouFt - B : Tlm/othy L. Hancock · "' Chairman Approved a§' to form legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT ~ ' P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant C~Sunty, Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266054 OR: 2377 PG: 3133 *** ~ICORDIO in 0?FICIA~. R~C0~.~ of COLL[IR COUITI, ~. ~ SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 01~321110 ~11~I1~ FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: ROXINE CAROLE COX AKA ROXINE C COX (10/03/43) CASE NUMBER: 97 3370 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 3rd day of October, 1997, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2354, page 3412. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ ~ day of ..'~;~ , 199~. ATTEST: ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BY: Timothy L. Hancock ~ ~r~evof Cxrc61t Chairman Approved as to form legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT [~ ' P.O. BOX 413044 Assi§tadf County torney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266055 OR: 2377 PG: 3134 *** R~CORD~D in OFFICIAL R~CORDS of COLLIER CO0~?T, FL 01/07/98 at 11:23A]( DilGHT I. BROCK, CLIRK R~¢ HI ~.00 SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 010-321110 FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: DOUGLAS LAVONNE RIMES (04/06/61) CASE NUMBER: 95 00725 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 24th day of July, 1995, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****FIFTY AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, i under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2084, page 0499. The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~ ~-- day of _~ , 1~9~. ~ ATTEST: ~/ .. QBOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Qte f CircU B : Tlm{Jthy L. Hancock : -- Chairman : Approved. as'"to form legal sufficiency ~ : ~JJ. PREPARED BY: [~,~ , CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT P.O. BOX 413044 Assistant ~ount~ Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 *** 2266056 OR: 2377 PG: 3135 *** RICORHD i~ 0HICIA~ H¢ORDS of COLSHR C001?Y, ~L '~ 01/07/H iL II:~3D( D~I~H ~. HOCK, CHit He HI SATISFACTION OF LIEN FOR SERVICES OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER 010-321110  FOR CLERK'S USE ONLY KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, through its BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, is the owner and holder of a certain lien against: BRIAN FACKLER RICK (05/28/68) CASE NUMBER: 95 1856 MMA for services of the Public Defender, bearing the date of the 24th day of July, 1995, recorded in office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County, Florida, securing the principal sum of ****TWENTY-FIVE AND 00/100***********DOLLARS, under Final Judgement and Order recorded in Official Record book 2084 page 0575. , The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County hereby acknowledges full payment and satisfaction of said lien, hereby surrenders the same as canceled, and hereby directs that the Clerk of said Circuit Court cancel this lien of record. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby directs that this Satisfaction of Lien be executed in its name by its Chairman. Executed this ~-/ day of ~~.j , 199~. ATTEST: ~// ~BO - .. .. AND OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Chairman . Approved as to form ..'legal sufficiency CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT P.O. BOX 413044 As C nty Attorney NAPLES, FLORIDA 34101-3044 16G Z BOAR[) OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE JANUARY 6, 1998 FOR BOARD ACTION: 1. Satisfaction ot' Lien: NEED MOTION authorizing the Chairman to sign Satisfaction of Lien for Services of the Public Defender for Case Nos.: 97-2604-MMA, 97-3428-MMA, 97-7052-MMA, 97-7775-MMA, 97-0529-MMA, 97-4759-MMA, 97-3142-MMA, 97- 1537-MMA, 97-4714-MMA, 97-6358-MMA, 97-1065-MMA, 97-3887-MMA, 95- 10192-M MA, 96-8614-MMA, 96-5336-MMA, 96-7973-MMA, 97-0695-MMA, 97- 7239-MMA, 96-1664-MMA, 96-9563-MMA, 97-7243-MMA, 97-00092-CFA, 97-0454- MMA, 96-5092-MMA, 97-3370-MMA, 95-00725-MMA, 95-1856-MMA. 2. MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS TO FILE FOR RECORD WITH ACTION AS DIRECTED: 3. Minutes: A. Naples Airport Authority - minutes of November 21, 1997 meeting and Naples Airport Noise Compatibility Committee minutes of November 20, 1997. Referred to BCC. B. Environmental Advisory Board Agenda - agenda for the December 3, 1997 meeting and minutes of November 5, 1997 meeting. Referred to BCC. C. Environmental Policy Technical Advisory Board agenda for December g, 1997 meeting. Referred to BCC. D. Collier County [lealth Department Advisory Board - minutes of November 3, 1997 meeting. Referred to BCC. E. Collier County Historical & Archaeological Preservation Board - minutes of November 14, 1997. Referred to BCC. , F. LibraD' Advisors' Board - minutes of October 22, 1997. Referred to BCC. G. Pelican Bay MSTBU Advisory Committee - agenda for December 3, 1997 meeting and tninutes of November 12, 1997 meeting. Referred to BCC. I t. Collier County Planning. Commission - agenda for November 25, 1997 meeting and December 4, 1997 meeting. Referred to BCC. 1. Public Vehicle Advisory Committee - minutes of September 3, October I and November 5, 1997. Referred to BCC. AGENDA ITEM No. JAN 0 6 1998 Pg. J. lmmokalee Beautification M.S.T.U. Advisory Committee - agenda for November 1% 1997, December 17, 1997, minutes of November 19, 1997 and October 15, 1997. Referred to BCC. K. t listorical/Archaeological Preservation Board - December I I, 1997 agenda. Referred to [3CC. L. Marco Island Beach Renourishment Advisory Committee - December 3, 1997 agenda and minutes of November 5, 1997. Referred to BCC. M. Lely Golf Estates Beautilication Advisory Committee - December 12, 1997 agenda and minutes of November 14, 1997. Referred to BCC. N. The Beach Renourishment/Maintenance Commitlee - December 4, 1997 agenda. Referred to BCC. O. Planning Commission - November 13, 1997 agenda. Referred to BCC. P. l'~mergency Medical Services Advisory Council - October 15, 1997 minutes. Referred to BCC. Q. Golden Gate Beat, tifieation Advisory Committee - November l l, 1997 agenda and minutes of October 14, 1997. Referred to BCC. 4. Other A. l,ctter from Michael Welsh, Controller, 'Fax Collector's OFfice to Timothy } hmcock, Clmirman of Board of County Commissioners referencing distribution of Current Ad Valorem ]'ax and Non-Ad Valorem Assessment to the Board of County Commissioners, after Tax Collector's commissions and distribution recap lbr year to date totals of taxes collected net of discount for 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996 and 1997. m AGENDA iTEM No. ;L,. JAN 0 6 1998 pg..2. NiJvcmhcr. ?1. I'1'1/ I1:?!1:74 ^M 1611 nuiati.n Dr H.rlll HliUl,~hl, c 21. N,ii) ll,., , ~ 1 I XI CIII IVI DIRI I:[I)~, AT (9hl) 6h3 11/33. 1111, H.tpll,., Air'p(~Yt AtitlloYiti) ri'till'Ill'il iii ilill ,,trpnilth at it,, m[)ntl~LU re,pt iflq Thllr'idd~ WI'~I:IIRilT() Ti'on,led lhornton, %('%% ~ ()fl . ~J~()r Bill B,Ir'lTPlt ,Ittl'n(lp(l to prp,,pnt ri'tired ~utlmritv CIl,lJr~an Ni, il Pill/pi] ,i "co~l,~d,tt ion ((1~ ~()tJ~ ,;e~ui(:p ti) th(, I:it~ ot Haplp',." F'utz(,t[, ~h(]%~ (,eat thornton a,,,,tlml,,, , had ',pr'u(,d t ~l) t erR', o111, ill t he ear l~ ' 80% and ()IlP CIIITC ] lid i flij t h i ', mont h. ,;e,,,,ion uith CjiU Hana(j[,r Richard ~o(]drutf, Planning Director Mi',',~ H[:Ki~ and Comprehpn%iu~ Planner Ron Lee to finalize the recent 19 adoptpd flirpo~'t Ha.,tpr Plan Update ~or presentation to Cit~ Count:i] nPxt month ,,o it can he incorporated in the Cit 9'" C~)mprPhpn,,iu~, t'l,lr~. ~t)l)(lt'ui F pxplJinpd that . while an aui.]t ion ma..ter plan prl...t, llt.. (;ol~{:(.pt .. .lllll I~l'll('r'.l] i/~'d Jand IJ'iP% lot the ..qll.l/'l. Airport. thp Citu'.. Coml)rphensiue PI.i~ net.(led a detailpfl ,,it,, pl,,n wit h ,,r) l,(:it ie(I l) uildinq u,,e,, under the City',. /uninq ~:ld',',itic.llion',. ~ cun¢lict aro,,(, between the (Iemand driupn dpupIopment tn ~hic:h the fluthoritg re,ipon(I5 arid inteq*'dtt", ~ith StJt,' and tp(lpr,iI trarl',portation qui(Irlinr5, and it', ,shi]itu to fur'ni,,h thp Cit9 detailed Dui]din~ t he Pi,ill. I) ,l r' (: (' l ', (If th(' ~ir'port (]nlU ,l', f(lr "filttJri' d(.uelopment" on ~hJch thl' RIJth()~'iti) ~oul(I tllpll f'l'(JtlPqt (,r)i'C:J~J(: ',itc approua] ,1', rtl'p(ll'[], lhe Rutrt[)r-it9 ri'J) lJl'[l th,it proce,,,,inq a %itP plan the*oil(ih Cit.) ,,t,ltl, P~,~nuinq Iloa~'d and gitg Council and publi(: liearin(i., pa(:h time a buildinq pprmit w,l,, needed ~ou~d hr ex(:(,.,,,iup and inet ticient, lhe Cit~ .,ta~f acknowledged thdt thpir ,,~,,le~ u,],, dp,,iqllPd to handip .,mall, ind[uidua] propert ip,, f)t onl~ an acre or two and not the demands of a milp square di, uplnpmpnt stJCh as the ~irport. ~ ~:o~p~omi~,p ,,u',tp~ euolupd undpr ~hich the ~irporl ~ill pr,,,,ent to lhp Planninq ~dui,,orU ltoard and Council nPxt ,, "Utilization Slip Plan" cunlaininq ,in anticipated three to t iup Up,ir,, ot deuelopm, nt projpct,, ~ith tNp expectation that it will t)p Ul)dalE, d euprg ~('~ UP,Ir% a% the ~irport'5 future l)reviuu', ,,(:ltpdtJl(, ()t quarterlU joint work,,hop,, uitlt the CotJn(:il to ,t',',LJre (:ummtJnication hi, t~eprt the bodiP5 at the hiqhe'it lpuel a', ~ell a,, Detup~'n Ibp Haplp', ~ir'port ~tJtho~'it~ i', an iridppendent agPnc~ crP.IlPd [)~ the f l(]rid.i ll.(]i,;I,iturp who',P unltJnteer mpmher5 .ire ,Ipp()int~'d bU Ibp Hapl(,,, Coun(:il to manaqe the I:itU ouned H.,pl,.'..irport. [he nuth,,ritV ,*,.ceiue.. r,r, pr,)p,.rtg taxer, and o[)eralp', ,,olplV Ii'lin reul. ntle,, (]ent, raled from it,, airport act iuit ii,'. and qralll',. luprelt lhaVpr, ,.pr-p';ident of the fluion Park Propertg Ow~ler,, a,,,,or, ia! io~, tolti the ~uthoritg "pea]pie haue tellinq me i~'5 a 1o~ quieter this ~ear." ihe member5 noted hi', Yeport c:oincided with (lata from it'; ~taff that onlg noise (:omplai~t,~ had been receiued from the public in October conc[,r~i[~g nighttime (1Opm-Inn) operations at the ~irport. euen thou(ih thor[' ~ere almost twice a'; mang nighttim~ operation5 this ~ear. The total of daytime and nighttime operation5 durtn9 October reached 9,293 on ~hich ~8 complaint5 ~ere receiued from 2a persons inuoluing al euenLs. Ibp at~thorit~ ~a5 questioned about a ne~5 report last ~eek that citizens would henceforkh need to make ang noise complaints to the Federal auiatio~ administration in atlanta. The authoritg stated that this report ~a5 inaccurate noise proqram is unchanged. The aat. horit~ continue5 Lo receiue anti act on incident report5 and {urnish informaLion about it; Hoise abatement program to an~ interested citizen. lhuls, dny. N~lv,:mh,:r. ?Il. lq!l/ I].9:II:.':411 I~M I~agc ! of 1 t (ltl I IIRlitl R IHf ORMfilIOH COHIfiCT L ]Sfi l till ~HC-HIJTCIIIHGS The Haple,, airport Noise Cnmpatibilitg Committee held its ~onlhlV meet iraI ihur~da9 ~ornioq at git9 Hail. Staff reported that 7 noise complaints ~t, re receiued fro~ the pLJbt~C in October concerniog nightti~e (lapin-lam) aperatinn,~ at Naples Rirport. tess than receiu~d ~ast October euen thooqh there nang niqhtti~e operations this year as last. The fetal o[ do,time and nighttime o~erations at the R~rport dur~n9 the mooth reached 9,293 o~ ~hich receiued ~8 co~ptaints tro~ 2~ different part/es inuoluing separate euents. There ~ere no uiolat~ons of the ~irport's ban on n~qhttine Stage i jet aircraft operations. The committee heard that the ~rport ~uthorit~ has prepared equipment specifications in the process of obtaining portable no,se ~onitor~ng equipment ~h~ch deueloping data for the noise pro~ra~. Cit~ Councilman Peter Uan nrsdale -- ~ho is a ne~ber of the committee -- asked it t~ look at a 2~-hour, fixed m~nitor~ng sp~ten. He added the Con, it. tee should "turn ouer euer~ stooe and consider euerp option" and not be constrained bg ~hat ~s couered ~n the Part 150 stud~ of the ~rport recentl~ approued bg the Federal Ru~ation Rd~n~stration. He urged that the Committee's concern fihou~d be ~ore ~th the s~ngte euents oF no~,;p aircraft than a generatized, tabulation o~ noise. [ric ~e,,t, a citizen speaking ~rom the Floor, asked that the committee studg permanent ~enitoring as an adjunct to the present ~q,;tem nF tabulating complaints, lie described the complaint spstem a% a "perception ha~ed sgstem" and said an "actualitV ba~efl s~stem" ~as needed in addition. Seueral committee members pointed out that the ~urther i,;%ue i,; ~hat can be done ~ith the information ~rthcoming ~rem ang tgpe u{ noi,;e monituring sgstem. "~e kno~ the~e i~, noise" declared go~mittee member Bill flrodt. "~e need ~a~)~ to mitigate its impact For the ~ajorit9 et the public." In respon,,e to a question bp citizen Richard Cobb about ne~s reports that ~uture nflise complaints ~i11 need to made to the F~ in ~tlanta, he ~as e~phaticallg told that the report ~a~ not true. [he Committee and the ~irport's Noise ~batement ,,ta~ remain in operation and ~il] ~ontinue to respond tn noise issues. Oan ~r~dale stated that the legal opinion un ~hich the sto~g ~a'; ba~ed dealt ~ith access is~ue~, not noi~e. [he flirpart ~uthoritg has sent a letter to the authur oF the fitor~ and ,agor Barnett correcting the in~ormat ~on. COLLIER COUNTY ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY BOARD AGENDA ,, DECEMBER 3~ 19971 9:00 a.m COMMISSION BOARDROOM~ TTIIRD FLOORmADMINISTRATION BUILDIN(7 I. ROLL CALL II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - October 1, 1997 and November 5, 1997 1II. ADDENDA IV. CONSENT/ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL AGENDA V. REGULAR AGENDA A. Final Site Development Plan No. SDP-97-123 Naples Memorial Gardens Section 21, Township 48 South, Range 25 East Collier County, Florida B. Planned Unit Development Petition No. PUD-97-16 Naples Forest Country Club Section 15, Township 50 South, Range 26 East Collier County, Florida C. Planned Unit Development Petition No. PUD-97-18 Wiggins Pass Landings PUD Section 20, Township 48 South, Range 25 East Collier County, Florida VI. OLD BUSINESS Misc. Corres: VII. NEW BUSINESS Date:_ . , _ X/IH. ADJOURNMENT Ito, , .6. IX. WORKSHOP op,,.s TO: t4orr~$ ...... Hancock v' // Constantine Mac 'Kte ,, Berry. . MINUTES OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY BOARD DATE: November 5, 1997 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: 3m Floor Boardroom, Administration Building, Collier County Government Center, Naples, Florida EAB STAFF PRESENT Dejong X Burgeson X Espinar _X Chrzanowski X Foley X Lenberger X Hermanson Absent Mulhere X Hill _X_ Reischl X Hinchcliff X Seal X Saadeh X MINUTES BY: Stephen Lenberger, Environmental Specialist II CALLED TO ORDER AT: 9:00 a.m. ADJOURNED AT: 10:15 a.m. PRESIDING: Paul Hinchcliff, Chairman ADDENDA TO THE AGENDA: Item SDP-97-123 (Naples Memorial Gardens) requested to be withdrawn by petitioner. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Motion made by Mr. Foley, seconded by Mr. Saadeh and carried 6/0, to approve minutes of October 1, 1997. ITEM: Regular Agenda - Item V.A PETITION NO: Final Site Development Plan Amendment No. SDP-90-69C "Vintage Bay" COLLIER COUNTY .... ,,' 2 ;: ;15:7 ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY BOARD AGEND'~ ' .DECEMBER 3~ 1997; 9:00 a.m. COMMISSION BOARDROOM, THIRD FLOOR--ADMINISTRATION BUILDINt' I. ROLL CALL II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES. October 1, 1997 and November 5, 1997 III. ADDENDA IV. CONSENT/ADMINISTRATiVE APPROVAL AGENDA V. REGULAR AGENDA A. Final Site Development Plan No. SDP-97-123 Naples Memorial Gardens Section 21, Township 48 South, Range 25 East Collier County, Florida B. Planned Unit Development Petition No. PUD-97-16 Naples Forest Country Club Section 15, Township 50 South, Range 26 East Collier County, Florida C. Planned Unit Development Petition No. PUD-97-18 Wiggins Pass Landings PUD Section 20, Township 48 South, Range 25 East Collier County, Florida VI. OLD BUSINESS iV, isc. Corr~s: VII. NEW BUSINESS //~/¢~ Date: VIII. ADJOURNMENT -- IX. WORKSHOP Copies To: Norris ~_(-/ H~ncock v Constantine Mac 'K le 8err~ ...... _~ Environmental Advisory Board Agenda .................. December $, 1997 Page 2 .................... NOTES: A. [Board Members]: Notify the PLANNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT (403- 2400) no later than 5 P.M. on December 1, 1997, if'you cannot attend this meeting or if'you have conflict and thus will abstain fi.om voting on a particular petition. B. [General Public]: Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this board will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto; and therefore may need to insure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. 16G 2 MINUTES OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY BOARD DATE: November 5, 1997 TIME: 9:00 a.m PLACE: 3m~ Floor Boardroom, Administration Building, Collier County Government Center, Naples, Florida ,,EAB STAFF PRESENT Dejong X Burgeson X Espinar _X Chrzanowski X Foley X Lenberger X Hermanson Absent Mulhere X Hilt X Reischl X Hinchcliff X Seal _X. Saadeh X MINUTES BY: Stephen Lenberger, Environmental Specialist II CALLED TO ORDER AT: 9:00 a.m. ADJOURNED AT: 10:15 a.m. PRESIDING: Paul Hinchcliff, Chairman ADDENDA TO TIlE AGENDA: Item SDP-97-123 (Naples Memorial Gardens) requested to be withdrawn by petitioner. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Motion made by Mr. Foley, seconded by Mr. Saadeh and carried 6/0, to approve minutes of October 1, 1997. ITEM: Regular Agenda - Item V.A PETITION NO: Final Site Development Plan Amendment No. SDP-90-69C "Vintage Bay" E~vi~me~a~ Advisory ~ard ~|~te~ .............................. N~mber $, ~? Page 2 ........ REQUESTING: Vintage Bay is an approved multi-family condominium complex located within the Marco Shores PUD. The proposed amendment is for the addition of three overlook boardwalks. REPRESENTED BY: Russ Danser, The Phoenix Environmental Group, Inc. MOTION: Made by _Mr. Foley, seconded by Mr. Saadeh and carried 6/0, to approve Final Site Development Plan Amendment No. SDP-90-69C with staffs stipulation. Environmental: I. The overlook boardwalks which extend into Barfield Bay shall never be used as boat docks. This would preclude the installation of cleats for the purpose of mooring boats. ITEM: Regular Agenda - Item V.B PETITION NO: Planned Unit Development Petition No. PUD-97-13 "Veterans Park Center PUD" REQUESTING: Veterans Park Center is a planned development of commercial acreage with a potential of a mixture of uses limited to medical support, medically related and other uses which are consistent with the provisions ofthe Collier County Comprehensive Plan. REPRESENTED BY: Michael Fernandez, Planning Development, Inc. Marco Espinar, Collier Environmental Consultants MOTION: Made by Mr. Foley, seconded by Mr. Saadeh and carried 5/0, to approve Planned Unit Development Petition No. PUD-97-13 with amended stipuIations. Mr. Espinar abstained from the vote. Water Management: The developer will remove all exotics, debris, trash, and snags for the total width and length of Horse Creek within the project boundary. Environmental Advisory Board Minutes .................................... November 5, 1997 Page 3 '" Environmental: Create an Environmental sub-section, in the PUD document under Development Commitments and add the following: 1. This PUD shall comply with the environmental sections of the Collier County Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan conservation and Coastal Management Element at the time of final development order approval. 2. An exotic vegetation removal and maintenance plan (CCLDC shall be submitted at the time of Site Development Plan review. 3. Petitioner shall amend the PUD Master Plan to add the following language to the land use chart: "A minimum of 1.3 acres of native vegetation shall be preserved for this PUD. Tract A and Tract B shall each retain a minimum of 15% of the existing native vegetation". The following language shall be added to the PUD document under the newly created Environmental Sub-section: "A minimum of 1.3 acres of native vegetation shall be preserved for this PUD. Tract A and Tract B shall each retain a minimum of 15% of' the existing native vegetation. These areas shall be identified at the time of final site development plan submittal". 4. Buffers shall be provided in accordance with CCLDC Section 3.2.8.4.6.3.. All Preserve areas shall be recorded, by separate instrument, as conservation/preservation tracts or easements dedicated to an approved entity and to Collier County with no responsibility for maintenance and subject to the uses and limitations similar to or as per Florida Statutes Section 704.06. Contact Collier County Real Property Division if the conservation areas are to be dedicated to Collier County. 5. A Gopher tortoise relocation/management plan shall be submitted to Current Planning Environmental Staff for review and approval. A copy of the approved plan language shall be included on the final Site Development Plan. 6. Prior to final development order approval (FSDP) the petitioner shall submit a copy of the Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission Gopher Tortoise Permit. 7. Environmental permitting shall be in accordance with the state of Florida Environmental Resource Permit rules and be subject to review and approval by Collier County Current Planning Environmental Staff. Removal of exotic vegetation shall not be the sole mitigation for impacts to Collier County wetlands. Environmental Advisory Board Minutes ...................................... November 5, 1997 Page 4 8. Buffers shall be provided around wetlands, extending at least fifteen(15) feet landward from the edge of wetland preserves in all places and averaging twenty-five(25) feet from the landward edge ofwedands. Where natural buffers are not possible, structural buffers shall be provided in accordance with the State of Florida Environmental Resources Permit rules and be subject to review and approval by Collier County Current Planning Environmental Staff 9. At the time of site development plan approval the petitioner shall field adjust the proposed lake and infrastructure to preserve the maximum amount ofxefic oak habitat and therefor minimize the impacts to the active Gopher tortoise burrows. ITEM: Regular Agenda - Item V.C PETITION NO: Final Site Development Plan Amendment No. SDP-97-123 "Naples Memorial Gardens" ITEM: Regular Agenda- Item V.D PETITION NO: Conditional Use Petition No. CU-97-17 "Wind Dancer Airboat Tours and Alligator Farm" REQUESTING: The petitioner is requesting a conditional use for alrboat tour operations on a parcel of land approximately 194 acres in size. Proposed site facilities include parking, boat docks, administration building and alligator exhibit. REPRESENTED BY: Beau Keene, Keene Engineering Marco Espinar, Collier Environmental Consultants PUBLIC SPEAKERS: Teresa House, Everglades Private Alrboat Tours Robert Henry, Collier Seminole State Park MOTION: Made by Mr. Foley, seconded by Mr. Saadeh and carried 4/1, to approve Conditional Use Petition No. CU-97-17 with added stipulations: Environmental Advisory Board Minutes ...................................... November 5, 1997 Page 5 Environmental: I. At the time of private airboat tour operation commencement, the petitioner shall install and maintain no trespassing signage along the entire property line every 300+ yards. The entire property shall be utilized specifically for commercial cOnservation/ecological tours and exhibits. There shall be no other permitted uses associated with this conditional use. 2. The applicant shall utilize existing airboat trails in a round trip method according to the proposed existing trails identified on the aerial submitted on September 12, 1997. 3. Permits or letters of exemption from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Florida Department of Environmental Protection and the South Florida Water Management District shall be presented for the boat docks prior to the issuance of a final site development plan approval. 4. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy all exotic vegetation as defined by the Collier County Land Development Code shall be removed at a minimum of fifty (50) foot buffer from the approved final development plan development footprint. The filly (50) foot buffer area and all developed areas shall be maintained free of exotic vegetation (Collier County Land Development Code Section 2.2.24.7.4.18). 5. Upon issuance, the building permit is subject to a forty-five (45) day appeal period by the Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA). 6. The petitioner shall assist and work with the applicable state and federal agencies (i.e., U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission, etc.) to prepare base line environmental studies. 7. The airboats shall only be equipped with non-aircraft engines including spark arrestors and properly muffled to reduce the noise as much as possible. 8. Airboats shall be limited to a maximum length of eighteen (18) feet and no more than ten (10) people aboard, including the driver. 9. bio more than three (3) airboats shall be allowed to operate at this site, at any one time. 10. The alligator farm shall be utiz/ed for exh/bit purposes only. No commercial farming of alligators or crocodiles shall be allowed. Only native florida species ofcrocodilians shall be allowed on the subject property. 16G 2 Environmental Advisory Board Minutes. Page 6 ..................................... November 5, 1997 l 1. Airboats shall only be allowed to operate during daylight hours, one hour after sunrise to one hour before sunset. -COMMENTS_: For a complete record of the proceedings reader is directed to the tape recording of this meeting, located in the Office of the Clerk to the Board, 5t~ Floor, Building "F", Collier County, Government Complex. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned by order ofthe Chair. Env/ronmental Advisory Board Paul Hinchcliff, Chairman 16G 2 ENVIROMENTAL POI, ICY TECIINICAL ADVISORY BOARD .... _.~ AGENDA DATE: December 8, 1997 PLACE: Collier County Government Complex Health and Community Services Building 2nd Floor, Room 216 TIME: 4.:00 p.m. I. CALL MEETING TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL Ill. APPROVAL OF NIINUTES - November 10, 1997 IV. ANNOUNCEMENTS V. OLD BUSINESS a. Byron Meade's Position b. BCC Criteria for Membership VI. STANDING COMSMITTEES A. COMMITTEE REPORTS (I) Steering Committee - Bill McKinney (2) Resource Committee - Mike Simonik (3) Growth Management- Mike Delate B. SPECIAL PROJECT COMMITTEE REPORTS (I) NRD Budget - Bill McKinney VII. NEW BUSINESS VIII. PUBLIC COMMENT IX. ADJOURNMENT Norris ~2 ..... ~'*"!i ... Hancock _. C~s%ant~ne COLLIER COUNTY tlEALTIi DEPARTMENT ADVISORY BOARD Meeling Minutes - November 3, 1997 MEMBERS PRESENT: l)r. l)eniselleincmann, Mary Lee Montgomery, Charles Rhoades, Pat Myers, Jim Penczykowski, STAI:F I'RI'SSENT: l)r. Charles Konigsl)crg, Roger Evans, Susan Craig Marry Knicbes COUNTY IAAISON: Tom Olliff ABSENT: Anne Can, pbcll (;UESTS: Don Ward and Sharon Arragona of Collier tlealth Services, Inc. The meeting was called to order at 4:04 PM by l)r. tleinemann, chair. Introductions of all present followed. The minutes from previous meetings will be reviewed at the next meeting in December. Dr. tleinemann suggested that Collier llealth Services, inc. (CIISI) make their presentation before continuing with thc remainder of the agenda. Dr. Konigsberg gave a brief overview of the status and progress of the private public partnership. Don Ward and SharonArragona made the presentation forCtlSI. Information was distributed to all present (attached). tlighliRhtsincluded: · The dental clinic has had a big demand and has added capacity. Dental Director Dr. Frank ,Mazzco now has hospital privileges. · Adult health in the Naples location (Bldg. 11) has considerable resource limitations to meet the demand (1 doctor for 16 hours a week). Sees as many patients as he can. The Health l)cpartment docs the follow-np. The source of payment has a lot to do with patient follow-up visits. For example, Medicare patients almost always come in for return appointments, while Ihosc adults with no source nf payment tend not to return on a regular ongoing basis. Appointment times have improved. Im~ncdiate problems come in the next day; established patients can prol)ably Met in to see the doctor in one week. There are about 150 adult patients v, ith chronic diseases who are unable to pay, due to low paying jobs, no insurance. None are on Medicaid. The problem is funding. · Given the funding, a first class women's health clinic can be developed. · l)r. Konil~sbcrg, Tom Olliff and Don Ward have discussed funding. Collier County (;overnmenl, with thc assistance of CHS1 is applying for the Primary Care Challenge Grant. · FoCuS and the Econnmic l)cvelopment Council arc taking a look at the health care problems in Collier County. ,lira i'enczykowski is interested in learning more abo~/et]iatric health problems and /he ability to pa)'. l~:)rr~$ t Hancock Constant ~ne ~ / Mac'Kt~ ,./ v / , Berry ~___ _~'_'_ ........... 2 · There may be a problem with continued operation in Bldg. H. The Joint Commission on Accreditation for tlealth Care Organizations (JCAIIO) site visit for CIISI is September, 1998. All CIISI sites will be reviewed. At this time, Bldg. I!. would not pass inspection. Corrective action plan is under way. Security is an issue also. Not sure if CIISI can meet JCAIIO accreditation in present environment. Card security program for Bldg. lt. is due in Oct. 1998 budget year. It's a short period of time to do any correction action for JCAIIO. To retrofit will be costly, impossible to do. · l)r. Konigsbcrg stated it is very important to have entire service gruup be located at one site to meet patients needs. · Another problem CIISI has had is high staff turnover rate. This is their number one operational problem. This is due to lack of focus, social proble~ns. Salary is not an issue, ttigh turnover rate affects other staff members as well. I)r. tlcinemann thanked Ms. Aragona and Mr. Ward for providing the information to the board. A publicity issue was mentioned. Need to publicize what CIISI does and the problems they face. Don Ward gave a brief overview of the Primary Care Challenge Grant. The application was submitted on October 31. OLI) BUSINESS: New member update The position h;~s been re-advertised. The closing date is November 21. Dr. lleinemann will talk with Mclinda Riddle and discuss the possibility of her being a board member. Next Meeting: Set for Monday, I)eccmbcr 1, 1997 at 4:00 PM. It will be held at Building tl, room 202 (Administration boardroom). The board will "clean up minutes and look at possible candidates for thc position on the board". The meeting adjourned at 5:25 PM. Respect fuIly Submitted By Marty Knicbes, Recording Secretary I&G 2 PRIVATE/PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP DENTAL HEALTH PROGRAM DESCRIPTION The public'private denial program at tim Gulfshore Medic. al Group d~'clo~d as an expansion of thc panncrship in November, 1996. a~rrcntly employs two Full time dentists in four renovated dental opcratories. To date thc focus of thc prognun has been thc treatment of children, but the potential exists to add adult patients in the near future. Along with v,'omen'$ health, the dental hcahh program mn be cmuidcrcd one of the tree success stories of the pannership, more than quadrupling the number of previous patient visits. The on-site practice is now limited to general dentistry., but hospital admissions and specialized scr,,ices are arranged bv referral. , The Health Department provided new equipment lo r, vo operatories. The Health Director has been actively invoh'ed in program development d~rough facilitations of ~termati've service prov/der arrangements such as volunteer initiatives and dental student provider program. TARGET POPULATION Dental health sen'ices arc open to all people of Collier Count.','. The program ;vas initially only able to accept children who were part of SlX'Cial programs such ,'u }tend Start or patients with emergency dental needs but presently more general patients are being acccNcd. Thc current focus is pediatric, obstetric, and HIV/AIDS patients with service opportunities for others in need. PLANS FOR THE FUTURE With thc addition of thc two dentists and thc refitting of fl~rce operatorics and the installation of a new one. the dental program is largely complclc. Thc program would greatly benefit from a Mcdipass verification ~'slem which would save clerical time and allow for additional apixqintmcms. Longer-range ph'ms include the potential for providing dental care to the handicapped. DdnlalVi~Ns nl ~ulfsh~re Medi¢~l~raup 500 400 ! 402. 2C0 / 0 Mny '97 June July Au[l Sept Oct PRIVATE/PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP WOMEN'S HEAL'FH PROGRAM PROGRAM DESCRIPTION Thc Gulfshorc Medical Group (GSMG). located in the Collier County Government Center offers complete primary heallh care for x~omcn including prenatal care. STD. gynecology and family planning. The prenatal program, responsible for aboot 700 women a year. features on-site high-risk patient management, ultrasound, non-stress testing and (Healthy Start) educational programs in brcast-£ccding, childbirth, parenting, and nutrition. In association with the health department. paticnts arc also provided HIV tcsting and counseling. Deliverics for these patients arc providcd through a contract with a Naples obslctrical group. , The Health DcpanmcnL in support of direct clinical ser-,,-ices of GSMG, provides comprehensive obstetrical care coordination through the Hcahhy Slart program; contact investigation and follow up treatment for chlnmydia; home visits for clinical support; and direct pharmaceutical services which assures that every patient has access Io required medications. TARGET POPULATION Tile panncrship agreement includes service delivery lo fl~ose requesting care. regardless of their ability lo pa.,,'. Currently. man.,,' of the patients are indigent. Medicaid eligible (about 60%), or among the "working poor." A significant number of patients have no income but for various reasons of ineligibility (such as immigration status) do not qnalify for Medicaid. A high priority of tile program is ~o provide accessibility of prenalal care during the first trimester. Special emphasis is provided to identified high-risk cases. PROJECTION FOR TIlE FUTURE Thc padcnl volume is cxpcclcd lo continuc at the same level or incrcase slightly. Changing Mcdicaid niles may impact on patient eligibility. ,",,lonitorir~g of prenatal management data accumulated in Ibc CHSI prenatal tracking s>.'stem will ensure priority focus on tile prevention o£ negative birth outcomes. 100 5 0 ............ ' o ( ............... ~7 ~6 -~ I I Jst Qtr 2nd Qtr 3rd Qtr 4th Qtr i&G 2 PRIVA'FE/PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP DENTAL HEALTtl PROGRAM DESCRIPTION Thc public;privalc dcmal program al the Gulfsbore Medic~ll Group d~'clopcd as an expansion of tile partnership in November, 1996. currcndy employs tx~o full Imm dcutists in four renovated dental operatorics. To date tile focus of the progr,'ml h~ been thc treatmcut of children, but thc potential cxisls to add adult patients in the near future. Along with ',,,'omen's health, the dental health program can bc considered one oFthc true success stories of the parlnership, more than quadrupling tile number of prcviotLs patient visits. The on-site practice is now limited to general dentistry, but hospital admissions and specialized scm, ices arc arranged bv referral. , Thc Health Dcpartmcnt provided ucw equipment to two opcratories. The Health Dircclor has been actively involved in progr:un dcwclopmcm Ihrough faciliUllions of alternative scm'ice provider arrangements such as volunteer initiatives ~d dent. d student provider program. TARGET POPULATION Dental hcahh scp,'~ccs arc open to all people of Collier County. The program was initially only able Io accept children ~ho were pan of s~'cial programs such as Head Start or patients with emergency dental needs but presenth,' more general patients arc being acccplcd. Thc current focus is pediatric, obstetric, and HIV/AIDS patients with sen'ice opporlunities for others in need. PLANS FOR TIlE FU'FURE With the addhion of Ihc lxvo dentists and the refitting of three opcmlorics and lite installation ora new one, the dental program is largely complete. Thc program would greatly benefit from a Mcdipass verification system which would save clerical time and allow For additional ap[x~inlments. Longer-hinge pl,'ms include tile potential ['or providing dental care to thc handicapped. Denial Visils ;~1 ,..~ulfshure Medical (~roup 400 40J 20C // / I" C*'T ' I I [ Ma'.,, '97 June .July Au.,u Sep~ Oct 166.2: PRIVATE/PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP PEDIATRIC PROGRAM PROGR.-\.\I DESCRIPTION Thc public/private partnership pediatric practice at thc Gulfshore Mcdical Group (GSMG) provides I$.0(}0 medical care visits to mom limn 3500 patients a year. Sen'ices include carc lo children who arc acutely ill as well as preventive care, immmfixafions and screening during "well child" appointments. Thc current staff includes a full time pediatrician, tx~o nurses, txvo aids and ancillao' support. Most of thc pnma~ care staffarc fluent in Spanish and Creole translation is rcadilv available, A wide varicly of multi-lingual educational materials supports the clinical effort. Thc Collier County ~tcahh Department (CCHD) opcralcs an immuniz~qtion program both in support of the GSMG m assure av:uh~blc sc~'iccs to ~l~c community, including cvcmng hours and actively refers clients in need ora medical home m GSMG and Medicaid, The Health Dcpamncnt provides comprehensive pcdialric case management ncx~borns through the Hcalthv Sum program and home visits as rcqucsled in support of direct clinical sc~'iccs. Prescription pharmacctmcals arc provided 1o assure crco' patient has access Io needed m¢dicatiOtlS. This year the public/private pcdiatfic program was greatly enhanced through thc addition of thc capability for direct hospital admission For i~s patients. TARGET POPULATION Thc targc~ population for thc pediatric practice includes any children in Collier County in need of pfimao' health care. Primarily, ~hc children cmuing to thc GSMG practice are From thc Golden Gate, East Naples and South Trml arc~. Thc majomy of those p:n~cnts do not have a ~hird parly payor and most are unable Io pay their bills. Like many of thc xvomcn's hcahh lxmcnts, the Ihmilics might be financially eligible for assistance but fail to qualify for other reasons. Thc~ patients are attended to x~ ~l~ ~hc same priority as paying patients. Thc racial/ethnic makeup of the pediatric population is approxm~atc!y as lt)llox~s; f lispanic - 65%; ttaitian - 15%: Black - 15%; and White PROJECTION FOR T[tE FUTURE GSMG is ~xorking ve~' hard 1o establish lhe proper balance among % Gulfshnr~ Infnnl~Who Hnv~ OHgl Medical Hom~ patients' needs. ;tvnihd)lc funding and appropriate smffmix. Thc mosl clearly ~ao - idemifiablc problem is ~l~e large number ofchildrcn ~vilhoul il third parly 7S method of payment and whose ~ 70 % t, ~:lr:l~llors arc unable or mlw~lling Io pay lbr medical ;tltClllioll, Those so , children make up at least (,{)"..:, of lbo practice with lllili1v O( Ihcnl aitcnding lhc practice as sick children Ibr a single , visit xv~lhout pilylllCtH. '['llcv do IlO[ ] ....... Cglect~vo = 75% x Percent Achieved addifiomfl problem oF "aa ~ha~ s" ~.~t Orr 2nd Qtr Rrd O~r 4Ih whereby a '.'ahmbic appoim mere ~s wasted. The management of Ibc GSMG practice is considering options Ibr resolution of this problem. A second high priority objcc~ixc Ibr the pcdimric practice is to ensure that children bom to GSMG prenalal patient's find a "medical homo" in thc Collier Hcaldl Sc~'iccs. Inc. (CHSI) system of care. PRIVATE/PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP WOMEN'S HEALTH PROGRAM PROGRAM DESCRIPTION The Gulfshore Nfcdical Group (GSMG). located irt the Collier Count,,, Government Center offers complete prSmars., health care for women including prenalal care. STD, gynecology and family planning. Tile prenatal program, responsible for about 700 women a year. features on-site high-risk patient management, ultrasound, non-stress testing and (He~thv Start) educational programs in breast-feeding, childbirth, parenting, and nutrition, In association with the health dep~rtment. patients are also provided HIV ~esting and counseling Deliveries for these patients are provided through a contract with a Naples obmetrical group. , Tile Health Department. in support of direct clinic.~ sen'ices of GSMG, provides comprehensive obsletrical care coordination through the Healthy Start program: contact investigation and £ollow up treatment for chlamydia: home visits for clinical support: and direct pl~armaceutical services which assures that every patient has access to required medications. TARGET POPULATION The partnership agreement includes service delivery to those requesting care, regardless of their ability, to pay.. Currcndv., many of thc patients are indigent. Medicaid eligible (about 60%,), or among the "working poor." A significant number of patients have no income but for various reasons of ineligibili~, (such as immigration status) do not qualify for Medicaid. A high priori~' of the program is to provide accessibility of prenatal care during tl~e first trimester. Special emphasis is provided to identified high-risk cases. PROJECTION FOR T}IE FUTURE Tile patient volume is expected to continue at thc s:une level or increase slightly. Changing Medicaid rules may impact on patient eligibility. Momtoring of prenatal management data accumulated in thc CHSI prenatal tracking sS,stem will ensure priority focus on the prevention of negative birth outcomes. g~o I~re~a*,al Dettentfi Entering Care During 1ct Trime.~ter 100 75 2..5 '" ............... 1997 ..... I 9 ~ 96 0 ~"~-- 1 St C~tr 2ncl Qtr 3rd Qtr 4th Qtr 168 '2 ' PRIVATE/PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP ADULT HEALTH PRACTICE PROGRAM DESCRIP'FION An expansion of tile pannership became effective in November. 1996. which included primaw health care to adult health patients through the GSMG The patient population consists mainly o£chronically ill men and ,*,*'omen suffering from diabetes. disorders of tile cardiova.scular U'stcnt lungs, li,,'er, digestive sTstem and kidneys. In addition, GSMG assumed responsibiliD' for the diagnosis and treatment of any patients with or suspected of having a sexually transmitted disease. Currently. the practice employs one half-time provider sen'lng appointed and walk-in patients five days a ,,reek. Tile common denominator among these patients (other than the chronic state of their illnesses) is their universal lack of' third parD' coverage. 'File CCHD provides thc following primary care supportive services: STD/chronic disease/general medical, prescription ptmrrrm~utimls, field and clinic based STD case manngement and contact investigation services; adult immunizations, and comprehensive TB. HI V. AIDS and targeted conununicnble disease sen'ices. TARGET POPULATION The tm'get population £oca~<,cs on thc adult medically indigent population of the greater Naples area. however. GSMG accepts any client from Collier County. Thc patient population is rcmricted only by the availability o£ appointments. The current level of prey/der rcsourccs limits appointments to the chronically ill. STD. and some v, alk-in patients. The Health Department is a Mcdipass provider for SSI/Medicaid recipients of tile county. PROJECTION FOR THE FUTURE Cam for thc indigent aduil population of Collier Count>' is an important public health issue. Currently. there ,are no targeted dolkus av,'filable to care for adults. Collier Health Sen'ices and the Collier County Health Depnrtmcnt are jointly pursuing a pd~rmry rare challenge grant which will help provide additional p,'imm"y care to tile adult population. Collier County submitted tile application on October .31. If funded, this grant will provide only minimal relief. % Patients with an STP Completing Treatment & Follow-Up 1 O0 ...... ........... 7'5--, , Ob. jeetive - 90% "/i ! x Percent Achieved I 0 - :' 1 St Qtr 2nd Orr 3rd Qtr 4Ih Cttr 16G 2 16G 2 16G 2 F' .......... .iLO COLLIER COLTN COMMUNITY I)EVEI,O~'ME,NT AND 2800 NORT}! HORSESIIOE DRIVE tCNVIR()NMI':NT:\I, .%ERVI(;I.:S I)IVISION NAPLES, FLORIDA :]4104 November 25. 1997 ,,'Xlr. Michael Zimnv Bureau ot' Historic Preservation R.A. Gray Building 500 South Bronough Street Tallahassee. Florida 32399-0250 RE: Collier Count,,' Preservation Board Meeting Dear Mr. Zimnv: This letter is to inlbrm you that the Collier Count,,, Historic and Archaeological Preservation Board held a public hearing on Friday. November 14. 1997. [ have enclosed a copy of the minutes tbr .','our review and records. IFyou have any questions or concerns regnrding this meeting, plense do not hesitate to contact me at: 941-403-2463. Very truly yours. Principal Planner (CL(} Coordinator) I listoric l'rcscr~ation/I,~VB/tb cc: ViHccnt A. Cautcro Sue Filson ['{ O11 Jamro Robert Mulhcre Nancy Sicmiun PreseFvation Board Iluildintz R.vi.w & l'ermittin,_, t!Ml~ .t{):t-24(H} N.'~tural Resources (941} 732-2505 ('role Enf. rcemt, nt :9411 40;I-2-I-H) Planning St'~'ices 1941 ~ 40;1-2:100 t[ousmg &[;rhan hnprove)nvnt ,9.11 ) -H):t-'2:I;IO l~fllution (Mntrol tg.l 1~ 7:P2.'25{12 ~':-1 :.',." 16G rvllNUTI~$ C©L LI[_--_'P. CC)UNTY I--IISTOI~ICAL $~ AI~CI-IAI~OLOGICAL 13P.-E-$~[~VATION POAi~D [~,, - , ~ -, ,. ' '-' ~:,'.,,.L D ...... ~ r'~ 16G t,',l~c, Ccrre,;: " ,/ ~ ~ Et" ........... ~ Norris _ - l:',':;,,// L~ ' / NOV 2 Hancock _ .,./ -. tu:.~{ Constant ~ ne_ ¢(',?C2 T,): MaC'Kll x ¢, _ _ ',",! "I~,,"1:; ......... : Bet r.'t _._ IF/ --,--.' Naples, Florida, October 22, 1997 LET IT BE KNOWN, that the LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD met on this date in regular session at 3:30 p.m. in the Main Library with the following members present: CHAIR: SydMellinger VICE-CHAIR: Jaculyn Dering Sabina Musci Doris Lewis Diane Williams ALSO PRESENT: John W. Jones, Library Director Marilyn Matthes, Assistant Library Director Luz Pictfi, Secretary APPROVAL OF MINUTES Mrs. Mellinger asked for comments or corrections to the minutes of September 24, 1997. There being none, Mrs. Lewis moved, seconded by Mrs. Williams and carried unanimously, that the minutes be approved as submitted. REPORTS OF OFFICERS Mrs. Mellinger thanked all Board members for accommodating her by meeting at a later time. COMMUNICATIONS - None UNFINISHED BUSINESS In reference to the Marco Island Branch construction, Mr. Jones reported that construction is two weeks behind but hopes they will get back on track in the near future. Otherwise, everything is coming fight along. Mr. Jones stated that an appraisal and ,'tn environmental study are being done on the site located 'A ora mile from thc intersection between lmmokalee Rd. and Livingston Road. This is the area being considered for the Regional Library. The Board reviewed the nominations that were submitted for the selection of the Library's Employee of the Month. Mrs. Dering moved, seconded by Mrs. Lewis and carried unanimously, to select Michael Widner as Employee of the Month for October, 1997. The Board members also felt that employees being nominated should be employed at least one year. They requested that nominations be submitted to them typed, and deleting the name ortho person who is nominating the employee. Mrs. Mellinger entertained a motion to present Mrs. Harlene Richardson ,who is retiring after 19 years of service to the Library, with a proclamation ofappreciation. Mrs. Dering moved, seconded by Ms. Musci and carried unanimously, to approve it. Marilyn Matthes gave a briefing on comments being submitted about Inter'net access without pictures at the Library. She mentioned that she had received both verbal and non-verbal comments. Most of the them in favor of adding graphics. Some patrons suggested installing filters. Some other people were pleased with text only access. Mrs. Mellinger asked Mrs. Matthes to submit a monthly report on this issue to the L.A.B. The next meeting of the Library Advisory Board has been set for November 24'~', 1997 at 2:00 p.m. Mrs. Matthcs announced that at the last BCC meeting, Mrs. Anne Rubin, Reference Librarian, had been chosen as the County's Employee of the Month for November, 1997. NEW BUSINESS - None GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS - None DIRECTOR'S REPORT Mr. Jones reported that thc last book sale netted $5,700. The lmmokalee Library ~vas closed for a week to replace shelves and carpeting. Circulation has increased considerably. 2 REPORT OF THE FRIENDS There were no representatives at this meeting, but Mr. Jones reported that at their last meeting, the Friends had pledged $80,000 for Library purchases and programs. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business to come before the Library Advisory Board, Mrs. Mellinger declared the meeting adjourned. Time: 4:40 p.m. COLI.IER COUNTY GOVERNMENT PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION 801 LAUREL OAK DRIVE SUITE 6O5 NAPLES, FL 34108 (94.1) 597-1749 FAX (941) 597-4502 ^ CERTIFIED BLUE CHIP COMMUNITY NOT[CE OF PUBLIC MEETING NOTICE IS HERBEY GIVEN OF A REGULAR MEETING OF TI-HE PELICAN..BAY MSTBU ADVISORY COMMITTEE AT THE FOUNDATION CENTER, $962 HAMMOCK OAK DRIVE, NAPLES, FLORIDA 34108 ON December 3, 1997 nt 3:00 AGENDA I. Roll Call 2. Approval of'Minutes of the November 12, 1997 Meeting 3. Pelican Bay Security 4. Audience Participation 5. Committee Requests 6. Adjourn ADDITIONALLY, THIS NOTICE ADVISES THAT, IF A PERSON DECIDES TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE BY' THE PELICAN BAY ADVISORY COMMITTEE, \VITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, HE WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS AND Tr-IAT FOR SUCH PURPOSE, HE ?,,'lAY NEED TO ENSURE Ttb\T A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES TIlE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON W1HCH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED , 16G 2 Naples, Florida November 12, 1997 LET IT BE KNOWN, that the Pelican Bay MSTBU Advisory Committee met in Regular Session on this date al 3:00 P.M. at the Foundation Center, 8962 }tammock Oak Drive, Naples with the following mcmbcrs present: Dr, Alan Varlcy, Chairmau Mr. Herbert Hasson Mr. George Werncr, Vice Chairman Mr. George Hermanson (Absent) Mr, Thomas Brov,'n Mr. John Hoyt Mr. Rodkcy Craighead Mr. Russell Mudge Mr. Frederick Flatto Mrs. Cora Oblcy Mr, Edward Griffith Mr. Antl',ony Pitts (Absent) Mr. Glen Ilarrcll (Abscnl) Mr. Charles Popper Mr. Bemon Young Al.SO PRES£NT: Various residents of Pelican Bay (approximately 10); Mr. James P. Ward. DivisioH AdministrHtor and Mrs. Barbara Smith, Recording Sccrcta~'. AG E N DA: I. Roll CHII 2. Approval of the October I and October 31, 1997 Meeting Minutes 3. Update on thc Clam Bay Restoration and Managemen! Plan - T. R. Brown 4. Update on Bike Path Rcstripping and Public Hearing 5. Discussioa of Commitlcc invoh,'cmcnt with PBSD projects - Carryover from October i, 1997 Mcctir~g 6. Pelican Bay Sccurilv 7. CoHsidcration of selected Annual Flower Bcd conversion to Xcriscapc landscape material 8 Audience Participalion 9. Commillcc Requests 10. Adjourn ROI.I. CAI.I.: Dr. Varlcy called the meeting Io order and asked that the Record shov,' Messrs. Glen Harrcll and George ttcrm:mson wilh cxcHscd :~bscnccs and Mr, Pircs with an uncxcuscd absence. AI~'PR()VAI. OF MINUTES OF TIlE OCTOBER 1,~ 1997 MEETING: L .I Ir..~ lm'(~,e mm'ed, secot~cled b v ~ Ir. C'raighead and approved ut~animouxlv, the limtte~'_, of the October 1. 199~ ,~[eetin~, , ' APPROVAl. OF MINUTES OF TIlE OCTOBER 31~ 1997 MEETING: l,~lr, fla.rxo~r moved, seconded bv Air, Ilovt and approved unanimously, the l .Ittmtcx 2f the October 31, I997 Afeeting. I 2724 UPDATE ON TIlE CI.A~,! BAY RESTORATION AND ~,IANAGEP, IENT PI. AN-T. R. BROWN Mr. Ted Brown stated Ihat he would bring thc group up to date and lalk about what he sees lhe rations opdons lo be. We met in TaIlahasscc on October 22. for about three and one-half hours. Mr. Clough had brought in some new people with Beaches and Shores. The di~cuhy in that. just as an editorial commcnl and nol intending Io suggest anything by il, is Ihose folks were Ihere Io catch up. Some portion of~vhal ~vc ~vcnl lhrough was really Io bring Ihem up lo speed on this projecl. As a result oflhnt rattling it was articulated by Mr. Bray Ihal lhcy are desirous of having n series of calculations from Mr. Tackncv ;vhich will attempt lo quantity the assumptions that xxc have made. I talked with Mr. Tackncy yesterday and hc is presently working on those calculations. Mr. Ted Brown continued lhat lhe second thing that emerged from the meeting was the categorical rcjcclion of the notion of the disposal of slurD' walcr by pulling it in Ibc mangroves nnd allowing norm:fi exchange mechanics lo flush thai into the Gulf. Their clear anti tmanin~ous preference ~as ~hat the Plan now require lhe disposal of slurO' water inlo Ihe Gulf of Mexico by direcl pipe discharge. ~Ve have altered Ihe Plan 1o make lhat adjuslmcnl. Thal neccssilales Ihal we also gel beyond lhe parameters of the lurbidilv requirements and file a supplcmenlal application for a variance with Ihe FDEP lo bolh define the scope of mixing and define and oblain a variance from lurbidily standards Io nccomplish ihat. I am sure thal I represenl lo you Ihat will be processed atld approved as it is a yeO' routine plan in tlte conlext of what we are doing. We are fomma~e lhal Turrell and Associalcs has prepared a Clam Bay Management Plan which conlains a variely of dala dml will ensure our abilily to move through INs pan wilhout ~he nccessily of generating additional expense or dam. They were kind enough ~o allow us lo use Ihis part of Ihe report and inco~orale it into ours. We have already gone ofl~hore anlicipaling ihe spoil area anct gel lhe unde~valcr grid markings and identified the wnter charactcrisiics in ~ha~ pan oflh.: Gulf where ~e propose lo put fifisspoil. Thalisasignificanlcosl and lime savings. The si~e will be some~vhcre in the neighborhood of 2,500 and 3.000 feel off shore. The mixing zone is approximately L0(IO feel long and 1,000 feet wide 272.5 16G 2 PELICAN BAY ADVISORY COMMITTEE NOVEMBER 12. 1997 Mr. Brown continued that both the Army Corps of Engineers and the FDEP ns agencies, remain firmly committed to this project. I feel Ihat we will have the permits in hnnd by the end of the year. As we lalked about planning for the fulure, one oflhe lhings on the agenda is whether or not lo turn loose Ibc engineers to begin 1o develop our plan. I know lhal Ihe last lime we met I encouraged you Io begin to make plans to move in lhal dircclion. I have wrcsllcd lo'lng to understand what message we wahl to send to thc Corps and FDEP by tim aclions wc lake. I lhink as we sland here today, I feel vcD' comfomnblc in saying ~hat I don't think it is possiblc from where we arc Ioday Ihal we will dcsign a scl of plans lo build Projcct "A" when then they ~nay require us to build Plan "B". It is also line that having to dispose of slur~' wa~cr imo Iht Gulf creates an additional dynamic that has not had a significant amount of commcma~' front thc variety of agencies Ihal govern that. Even if we had a 100% assurance of exactly what xxc x~crc going to come out with and n guaranteed lime table and let's just pick December 13 as a date for p, rposcs at this lime, and if you lurned loose your team tomorrow to develop phms wilh the expcctmion that you could have people on thc ground working by JanuaU, 5 or 6. eyeD'thing is going to have to go ahnosl perfect in that scenario, incl.ding lhe main excavation before Ihe InHle nesting season on May 1, 1998. I Ihink you will all agree from your experience on Ihis project, is that firings don't go IO()% right all of thc time. That causes me to stop and think if il is pmdcnl al this time lo lurn loose those dollars in advance of acltlallv having Ihat permit in hand. having had it rcvimved and acceplcd by you. and having had it reviewed and accepted by Collier County. If you decide nol to move fom'ard today, it changes no~hing in terms of thc ongoing process of thc permit applicalion itself. I encourage you and lhi~k it is appropriale t'or you to see lhal process lhrough to completion and I believe complelion is in sight. What it docs mean is that xvt will get back in hand. a document with which you have Ibc capacily Io finally accept or rQcct. I would assume ir it comes as it is presented ~o you. you will accept and proceed xvilh iht implementation stage al Ihal point. The practical implications of that arc that the only potion of thc pcrmi~ that cannot be undertaken as fi~st as you can move fonvard is thc excavation of the main channel. Tim constraint of lhat is that you arc disposing of beach qualily malerial on Ihe beach and that mc:ms lhal you are under the conslraint of the ttmle nesting season and that phase or the project cannot be 2726 undcrl;lkcn umil OcIobcr, 1998. Ail of tile other portions of the projccl can be underlaken during thc ordinaa' course and implcmcmcd in Ihnl conlcxl. Thc othcr op;ion if that docs not make scnsc to you. to move [oavard. In proceeding fom'ard I lhink thc Nsk el producing a scl of plans for bid pu~oscs and ask someone Io build Projccl "A" and mn thc risk or getting a pcm~it fha[ requires you lo build Project "B" is slim. We arc no; talking about substantial changes to lhc comcxt of thc plan. Nlr. Tom Brown asked iflhnt can bc accomplished xvilh no more money being spent by Nlr. Ted Brown asked if he mc:mt finishing thc pcrmh or Jmplcmcntalion'~ Mr. Tom Brown replied hnishcd getting approval from thc govcrlllll¢lll? Llr. Ted lBrown replied Ihat is corrccL Thc other oplion is [o aulhorJzc Ibc cxpcndilurc of money 1o npprovc ~h:n i cnll thc beginning implcmcntalion singe, that would rcsull in Wilson. Miller. myself. Nlr. Lukasz and others mccling next Wednesday morning lo begin Io put logo[her Ibc mechanics of thc implcmcnmlion of thc plan. I~ ~votlld bc proceeding fo~vard 1o develop Ihe working drawings and bid spccific;ttions ~o go out lo a variety of contractors Io bid. for your ullimatc acccptnncc and approval. [hat comcxt you have lwo Ihings running on parallel courses and Ihat cvcnlually will come lo a One is thc completion of thc permit itself and thc oihcr is ibc dcvclopmcnl of Ihc spccinl Jmplcmcnlalion spccific:~lions and drawings. Assuming again all of that gocs wcll. lhalcan bcdon~during lhcmonthof December. One oFlhc coI1ccri1s [ hllvc is Ih/Il ollcc yeti get lo about December 20. government and socJcly steals lo shul do~ ~ tH~lil ilboul Jallllil~' 3. You can slill gel sonic ;hings done. bul Ihc sense or urgency nboul doing things gels caughl up in lbo holiday season. Thai needs lo bc faclorcd inlo ~vhal ~'c arc [alkin~ 'Jboul. If lhin~s go cxlrcmelv well you can conceivably have solneonc on site and ready durinkl Ihc llrsi l~vo ~ccks of Janua~', 199~. Thc contraclors we have lalkcd Io have lalkcd in ~crms 120 da~s Io do lhcir work. We have fell like ;Ind conlinuc Io feel like we nrc going Io gel a good number of bids particul:~rly for Ibc main channel work. which is Iht onlw work which is $uDjccI 10 Ibc constraints of lhc lurllc season. [ feel ~,e will bo able Io push lhnt number down by a magnitude of lhi~y days or 25%, so that there is some play in Ihcrc lhal would enable you lo pcrhnps gel il done. bul yo~l clearly have 2727 NOVEMBER 12. 1997 to be irt the field sometime before thc end of JanuaD' 1998 to have any prayer in concluding that ,aork before May 1. 1998. Wilh that sort of ovc~'iew I will respond lo .','our questions and seek 5'our direction. Dr. Varlcv asked what the advantages of doing the interior work ',,,ould be i£thc pass v, as closed? Mr. Ted Bro'an replied that it will be a requirement of the permit that it be done. if I *,,crc having Ibis conversation in June. 1997 and did not have this issue of turtle nesting season so that v,e could targcl h:lx'ing someone in Ibc field thc first da',' after tunic nesting season and xxhat v,c had anticipated and :~lx~:~.xs thought u. as tit:il v,c x~ould not launch Ilm initiatixc across Ihc resource simultaneously. depending upon how many conlraclors xxere going to be involved If.xou had some only intcrcslcd in Cuts 1.2 :md 1 ;md somc only intcrcslcd in channel Cut 4 ;~s oppo.scd lo somconc ~anting lo do bid all of that work. then x~c c:~n envision thc sccn:~rio all ol. that work would be going on sonlcxvhal simultaneously. If ~,OU Oplcd lo go Ih:il \'<Iv xx h:ll ~.¥c would be saying is that we nrc constrained bb' turlle nesting season for pnrposcs of doing the main channel excavation. In some rcspecls this perhaps affords you more lilne Io ncgoti:nc better prtccs. Dr. Varlcx' asked thc advantage o£ our gambling our money now to open the back end of the syslem which xxill have no value il' tim pass is not open? If we can't open that now. v,'c can do Ihe back end Ol'lhc construct/on work next year at a leisurely pace. Why would we want to do it now? Mr. lcd Brown replied th:it you won't be able to do the work until you get a permit. Option I is continuing down thcp;llhthatw¢ ha¥c talked about ttp until today. Tha! was lhc option lo go ahead and take thc risk of developing bid spccificalions now. with tile expectation that we could gcl in tile field and do thc main channel excavation during the carl',' calendar .,,'car 1998, so thai it would be completed abeacl o[ lunlc nesting scnson in May of 1998. I have said today lhat the risks of Ih:lt. aside from IbC permitting risks, is Ihal wc slill could not get il done unlcss things all went vcO', vet3' well. Oplion 2 is to sa5' let's not spend those doll;irs loci:tv. M:Lvbe wc will spend a few dollars to organize and get sonic thoughts and have a prcliminar-,' meeting, but not to turn loose big nmncy and develop bid specifications for any pan o1' thc plan until xvt have a permit in hand. When we have the permit in hand v,'e ,,','ill present it lo this Board for review to bc accepted or rQected, and carD' it ~o the Cou~lly for a recommendalion of acceptance 2728 or rcjcclion and oncc accepted, physically signed and sent back to thc agencies. If thc pcrmitling stays on thc same calendar you will have a permit sometime before thc end of thc year. You would hold a special meeting and cithcr accept or reject il. It then goes to lhe County Commission, who in all probability will not bc able ~o x'o~c on it before thc beginning o¢ thc year. That is not a real constraint to you in terms of conlinuing your plan, because I drink they arc going Io acccpl whatever you bring to them. Presumably at thai point you can cncrgizc your team to begin to develop thc bid specifications. That essentially means you arc not going to be able to do Ibc main channel before Iht end of 1998. EvcDlhing else flint is pan of thc phm. you can and wonld be expected to initiate promptly. Mr. Wcrncr slalcd that if you have resistance Io the widening of Clam Pass and you cannot get I]1;1I lhrot~gh, Ihcn thc rest of thc plan does not make sense. Mr. Ted Brown rcplicd that he would then not recommend that you go ahead. Mr. Wcrncr asked if Mr. Brown authorized Mr. Tackney ~o go ahead with tim computations and asked if there w;~s a cost associated with Ih;W? Mr. Broxvn rcplicd only wiflfin his hourly budget. Mr. Ward reported that lhcrc arc su~cicnl flmds in his existing budgcl Io do those calculalions. In terms of doing thc bal;mcc o¢ thc work olhcr than lho main channel cut. I doa't think there would be a nccd Io proceed as quickly as xxc xxcrc talking aboul. We could do fha[ more in a logical sequence as xxc gct thc main ch:~nncl cut. so thai xxc could schedule it out and put il in a sequence of cvcms x~hcn xvt coulddolhc m:~inch;mnclcut in Novcmbcr 1998. Il would not haveto~doncinlhc Winlcr. butdtmng Ibc later F:~m of thc ~ummcr or during thc Fall. Mr. Wcrncr askcd how thc pumping of thc slur~' water into thc Gulf xx:~s going lo affect thc bndgct? Mr. Tcd Brown rcplicd thai oi1 thc short Icrm il may be more cxpcnsivc. Long term it should be considcrabh' lcss cxpcnsix'c, Whcn xxc ;tddcd thc cyclone scparator xvt added some costs. The bcncfit of Ihat scpar:~tor xx:~s lhnt il incrcascd thc amount of bcach qualily disposable sand for xxhich we get some kudos lbr bc;~ch rcnourishmcnt and continue lo minimize Ihc amount of other materials that hns lo be 2729 PELICAN BAY ADVISORY COMMIq'q'EE 1 6 G 2 NOVEMBER I2. 1997 disposed of. Thc pipe, because it has ~.o go so far out into the Gulf, is not inexpensive, bul what v,'c have elimiaatcd from the project are all of the spoil islands and all of the plantings. There were imgation lines to be nm to the spoil islands to make sure that we had freshwater 1o makc sure Ihcy grew. To Iht cxlcnt that fl~cv didn't grow you had lhe ongoing problem of moniloring those and keeping them planted and looking nice. You arc essentially eliminating, long form. any kind of maintenance responsibility for those components of thc system that could bo problematic. There is probably some incremental increase in cosls for this disposal method. Thc longer I work with you and tiffs project, thc more I am convinced thai is thc righl solution. There is no disservice lo Iht ecology. When you arc done and pull thc pipe out and rcnourish Iht beach, you have done nothing other than cut a clear channel in the syslcm and nolhing rcmains to show whcrc we wcrc or what wc did. Mr. ttasson asked if we would be able to excavate Clam Pass again if it should closc before got thc permit? Mr. Ted Broxvn replied that if wc wcrc silling wilh a permit in hand wc could clearly get permission to lake care of those lhings short term. If wc do not have a permit in hand we would have to file for a Mmic new permit. What thc agcncics Iold you was {hal they would no longer do any piecemeal approaches any longer, and I don't think lhcy will. I am telling you Ihat I think you arc going to get your pcrmit to implement this Plan. IamalsotellingyouthatiFbccauscofthctimingofthcdclivc~.ofit. or arc not able to implement thal portion of thc Plan that calls for opening of thc main ch:mncl, you could prevail upon both thc FDEP and thc Army Co~s of Engineers for Iht righl lo go in and do lhal Clam Pass cxcavalion in order {o get lhings open and flmctioning x~hilc you wait for tunic season {o go by one more year. Mr. Mudgc staled thal you have Io prcscm a plan. Mr. Ted Brown replied that thc way that it is presented, is that wc will have an cslablishcd scl of profiles fi3r Ihosc cuts. If those cuts bccomc shoaled over or incapacitated in some way. sha~ or fem,. you will have thc righl lo re-excavate after nolificalion lo thc agencies and allo~ving Ihcm Io obscm'c Ibc dala set lhat yeti ]lllX'C gcncrmcd. You do not have to go through a permit, bul just get lhcir approval. You will 2730 .................................... '~ · .................. III never §c! thc govcnm~cnt, under any set of circumslanccs. Io al)ow you lo nm your ship without their approv:fl. But. wlmt you don'/havc lo do is an allcrnalivc analysis or data study, bul jnsl simply show system is nol working properly. N1v sense is fl~at tl~cs' would look favorably on ll~:ll rcqucsl since you have thc permit in hand. Mr. Young asked how re:my feet wc arc coming iillo our s)'slclll with tl~c spoils? Nit. Ted Brown replied flint ~l~c only spoil Ih:l/ is going lo go imo Iht Gulf is lhc spoil which will origimuc in Iht mmn ch:mncl cuL which is approximalcly 7,()l)0 - 8,000 cubic yards, after il/goes Ihrough thc cyclone. Thru was thc spoil il~:li was going lo go imo Iht spoil islands. Culs l, 2 and 3 have disposal sites inside oF thc chine lines, which have been looked at. idcmificd and approved. T]I:iI rcprcscms aboul 3.5()~) to 5.1)tit) cubic yards in fierce discreet locations that bavc been idcmificd :md contained in Ihis plan. klr. Ward sla~ed Ih;il Ihis has not been changed at all from Ibc original application. Nit. Ted Brown staled lh;l{ lhcrc bas been a change Io Iht extent Ihal we had asked Ihc govcrmncm to look at thc ]]otion ofacrial disposition ofCtlls I. 2 and 3. Solnc weeks back I advised you {l~;~t there was a f;lir ;ltllOt]l~l o~ reluclancc 1o cngagc in Iha{ and Ibal lhc physical COIISIF;liuls Of Ibc site in {hat localion did not allow Ih;il lo work vc{¥ effectively. That has no{ bcc~ a change, bul an altcrnalivc lhai has bccn in Ibis ~or some period of months. Wilh rcspcc{ Io what wc rc~cr Io as {l~c interior lidal cuts in thc pi;in and lhosc arc x~h:{t I idcmirv as {]~c cuts you already had experiencc wilh tl~al Mr. Lewis did under an earlier permit where ii,crc was some blasting and some hand cxcavation. Those havc remained exactly Ihe same in Ih:il format for lhosc particular cuts and there is no change Iberc. Thc only change Ihat tins occurred ~rom Ibc time I was last here. is lbat xvc had identified an area imn]cdialcly lo Ibc Soulh o~ tl~c main emro' ch:mncl where ii,crc was hisloricallv anolhcr main flow channel from Ibc Gulf as an area o~ possible disposition of spoil m~d lo put it ~hcrc. Wc wcrc excitcd bccansc Ibc ~'cloI3c separator was sccimi{gl) going lo require us {o }mx'c less fines cap;icily th;l{ we wcrc originally going lo have ~silb Ibc spoil islands and wc h;}d an area which Ibc agencics ~erc generally cnlhnsiaslic abo~t as a place lo put it. I xxam lo make lids record vcr,' clcar, bccausc lhcrc is always a lot of coati}sion and I fccl like I have bcca cxlraordimmly consistent in ibc rcpotling of Ihis lo you. Whal happened in Ih;ll colllcxl is Ihai 2731 cominucd Io explore the fcasibilily of pr,ling it in that location. Wc had to find a ,,','ay lo dispose of thc slurr.,' v, alcr. Thai me:ms Ihal ~shcn you are dredgi.g Ibis material, you are gelling huge quantifies w;~Icr mixed ~vilh thc slu~ lh:~l comes ~vilh il. Il goes inlo Ibc ~'c[one scparalor and good ~lnd comes out and b;~d sand goes somcpl:~cc dsc. II mis nol as feasible lo pul Ibc bad sluff in Ibc mangroves as we had hoped II really is fed primarilybvonc main channel inlhcarealhaIlicsbclwcen Ihcdune lincon west and Ibc main ch;mncl going lo Outer Clam Bay on the cast. Il does not flow as evenly across there as wc had hoped, liar it done that. we felt x'c~' secure in saying that we could put the slu~' xvaler in there and allow outgoing tides to disperse it and th',, sclllemenl time in thc mangroves would actually be a pl,s. Thc maricnt q,ality of thc fines x~o,ld be like putting fcflilizcr on it. Thai did not work. Thc FDEP was ad;~m;mlly opposed, so x~c had to find anolhcr sol,lion which was to pnt it in Iht scparalor, put Iht beach fl,ality sand on thc beach, lake thc fines and p,mp lhcm into Ihe Gulf;md thai is how we have gOllCn lo where xvc ;Ire now. Mr. Yo,n[ asked if thc o,lv sand ~oing imo Iht scpar;,or was from lhe pass and Ihe main Nit. 'Fed f]rox~ n replied in Iht Mr. Young asked iF ~c x~crc going ~o have pmnps in Ibc Ihrcc areas Io primp Iht spoil behind dtmcs'? Nit. Ted [3ro~vn replied in Ibc ;~rmalivc. Nit. Young ;~skcd ir I]l;l{ WiIICF immediately works il way back inlo Iht syfilClll. Or iS it cnlrappcd up there? Mr. Ted Brown replied that Ibc way it is designed is lhal there will be a mixlurc of ~aler and fines and gix'cn ~vhcrc we have Ioc;ltcd [o do it, is an upland area which is a good sand base and Ihal water will pcrcol~,c and ~hc m;,crial will soa of d~' up on ~op of ii. II will be bracketed around thc edge with straw and barrier to restrain ,. Evenlually as il stabilizes you will remove Ihe barrier and it ~ill r~vC~Cl:Hc itt ;i n:llural c'ondilion. 2732 NOVEMBER 12. 1997 Mr. Young slated that his concern is that this Smnmcr wc v.'orkcd on a lake in Michigan to remove thc spoil in order to deepen it. Our biggest single problem was thc a~nount oF water that it takes ~vhcn you pipe thc spoil. There was a good chance that we could drain that lake in j,sl Ihe first phase of faking thc spoil. Somehow wc had to design to get that water back inlo Ibc ~'stcm or it would do' up thc lake. Mr. Ted Brown replied Ihat he docs not lhink lhat is a risk in Hfis pa~icular instance. In each of Iht tot;il of lhc three cuts is something less lhan 5.000 cubic yards of malcrial. Thc dislancc from where thc dredge m:~chinc would operate and whcrc Iht spoil would bc disposed of is not far. None of thc opcralors xvt h;~vc inlc~'tc~cd have idcmificd that ;is a concern. O,r concern x~;is thc inverse, not a lack o¢ ~x:tlCr. Wc h:~vc salisficd ourselves, as has lbo government, thai lhis is not a concern. Whal they want us Io do and xxc plan to do. is simply confine it until it settles and dries out and Ihcn to monilor ~¥hal grmvs back. They do not ~vanl Brazilian Pepper or Australian Pines growing back on il. which is caO' to do. Mr. Young smmd those will come with thc cnginecri,g drawings, spccificalions and solutions. b,t arc lira things ~vc have not seen yet. Wc arc buying a program thai engineering wise has nol been crc:~tcd. Mr. Ted Brmvn replied thai is not trim. ~Vc have talked to halfa dozen contractors about how lo do this and what lhcir conslrainls, needs and issltcs were alld none o[Ihcnl have idcnlificd your concern as a problem. Mr. Young slated Ihal in Ihc Wimcr we do not get re,ch rain and il gms yeD' dD' up there, trove have lo usc thc w;ttcr wc have ~o pipe our residue, how docs Iht water get back inlo Ibc syslcm? Mr. 'Y~:cl Breton rep!lcd Ihat Ihcrc is plenty of water in this ~'slcm. Thc problem is that there is too much watcr fi)r thc most pan I don) view that as a problcnl in terms of where we arc. We arc not going Io nm out of water. We get a fresh tide cvc~' day. twice a day. We won't bc taking enough water out of there to makc a dilWcrcncc. NOVEMBER 12. 1997 Dr. Varlcy asked if all of tile construction work can bc done during turllc scason with Ibc exception of tile inain channel? Mr. Ted Brown replied in tile affirmative. Mr. Ward explained lhat because of lhe disposal area being close to Iht dune swale we may have some issues with respect to the tuale nesting season on Ihose particular sites. Mr. Ted Brown replied, only if you blast. If it is done by hand excavation as we are hoping you can do a majority of it. you can do it any time you ,,,,'ant. If you have to blast an.',' of the interior tidal cuts, then you would be constrained by lurlle nesting season. Dr. Verier stated thai lhe question we have facing tls loday is that we have an option of two courses of action. One is to just sit back. put our feet up and let tile process go on :md M'r. Brown as cxpcdiliously as he can. get file pernlit. If we do that tile chances are prclly good Ihat we will be beyond Ihe time that we can get done with file pass and channel this 3'ear. This means that part of the program is goiug lo be poslponcd until next .','car. The other altcnmtive is to continue along Ihis emcrgeno,.' path that we have idenlificd before of In.'ing lo get construction drawings done wilh the idea that somehow or other we gel Ibc approval and sitting at Iht line ready lo go. that we might be able Io get this thing done before lilt IleX[ lurlle season. Mr. ttasson askcd, suppose we approve this and they change the specifications on txs? Mr. Ted Brown replied that Ihe point is well taken and is lhe reason the issue was raised. I will sa',' lhal I think iht plan lhal you have in fronl ofyou is in Ibc plan Ihat ',,.'ill be pcrmilled or not pcnniltcd. I do nol anticipale thal ~hcre is any serious risk [o designing a set of specifications to do Project "A" nnd have tile p,:rmil issued that would rcquirc you lo build Project "B". llaving said Ih;It. I have Io sa.',' with this cereal, we don't know what tile permit is fitlally going to look like and what additional conditions might be imposed that we would have to deal with. I would sa>, to you that we have bccn far enough down Iht path at this point, that what v,'c arc talking about is permitting this plan. The only ~v,'o things v,'e are dealing with at this juncture is Mr. Tackncy's data and the physical application for the variance for d¢finilion of the mixing zone for Ihe disposition of thc slurry water. 2734 Dr. Varlcv asked if the resolutions of the sea grass had to be workcd out? Mr. Ted Brown rcplicd yes and no. Tile National marine Fishcrics and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service ;Irc simply a commenting agcncy to thc Army Corps of Enginccrs. That Inonns thc,',' have no legal standing to affect thc Corps' decision making process. They do have a right to request an elevation of a decision that they would not othcm'ise agree with and ask it to be reviewed by the headquarters of thc Army Corps of Engineers in \Vashington. DC. In this case tim Secretary of the Ann.,,' would bc involved in taking a look at this permit. I ,.,,'ill tell you and it is my judgment, having participated in permit elevations on a numbcr of occasions and having done enough legal research around it. it is highly unlikely lhat National Marine Fisheries would seek an elevation from this type of a restoration effort based upon .(}3 of an acre of impact to sca grasses. I personally foci that they would not look xcrv "polished" in carr'>.'ing that kind of a message to Washington. I view the risk of elevation as ','er',' small, not non-existent, but very small. I wouldn't let thnt be the drix'ing force of)'our decision nmking. Dr. Varlev stated that lie thought Mr. Brown had said thnt it was unlikely the Corps and FDEP would override them without going on and asking for a higher level. Mr. Bro,,vn replied no. that is not true. It is :'er).' likely they ,,','ill override them. Mr, Hasson asked what financial risk arc we taking if u,'c accept this? Mr. Ted Brown replied that thc immcdialc financial cxposurc is thc cost of rctaining Wilson. Miller. Mr, \Vard stated that a kc.,,' issue is that in order to get this dorm from now until May 1, as have known for a couple of weeks, things have to go essentially perfectly in terms ofbidding it. getting lbo drawings done. getting you to review and approve it immediately, get it reviewed a,d approved by thc County Commission and getting this undc~vay and constructed. The risk is not so much the fronl end of it, but what happens if you get lo May I and you are in the middle ora $1.000,000 construction program. tnrtle nesting season hits tls and we are still constructing that facility? That is the risk. because the 2735 answer to that question is, that you end up shutting dov,'n and you have to start over. That is tile real fimmcial risk in this decision. Mr. Popper asked if' there wasn't an extension granted during turtle nesting season once before? Mrs. Oblcy replied that tile Cily of Naples had received an extension for the beach rcnot,rishmcnt. Mr. Popper stated that thc Cily did and il' tile Cily was able to get a extension of tile window of opportunity, if xxc get to that point of another Iwo weeks to work, ;vouldn't they grant the same extension7 Mr. Ward replied that he docs not know what tile.',' would do. The real financial risk is shutting down a $1,000,(100 project. Mr. Brown stated that Ihcrc is ahvays discussion after a motion but would like to move that we spend no more moneys until we get a permit. Mr. Hoy't seconded the motion. Dr. Verity stated lhal he would like the audience to have a chance to conunent before the motion. Mr. Craighead stated that as he understands it, the main risk to us if we proceed v,'ith engineering dra'aings and spend anv more money, is that we won't get tile permit. As long as we get tile pcrmil, that money will not wasted. Il rna.,,' be spent now instead of later, or am I wrong? Mr. Ted Brown replied that you arc not incorrect. One of thc cards that I have been attempting lo pill.',' and cannot tell you if I have bccn succcssfifl is particularly as tile new players come in to review what we arc doing, it has been extremely difficult lo get them to understand what tile nature of this project is, how it is fimdcd and what this means to those agencies in lenns of how they ought Io be viewing it. I have had to cxplain that this is a group of people, pooling their personal resources lo tO, to do the right thing for an ccological resource ~llat is stressed. You ought to think of us as on >'our team, because there is nobodv else stepping up to tim plale to cover this stress. My point is, it' tile consensus of the group is that tile risk profile is Ihnt cvcr3'thing goes very well. we get thc permils and I ,,,,'ill sa.',' again I am convinced we will. and you start down Ihc path to implement and for whalever series of reasons where you get Io thc place that your are 2/3 done and turtle nesting season comes, you have an issue. The issue is wilt the government allow you to finish since you are 2/3 done, or are they going to shut you down. I 2736 PELICAN BAY ADVISORY COM,MITI'EE 1 6 G 2 NOVEMgER 12. 1997 think it is highly improbable that Iht government will give you a favorable answer at the front door oflhc process. They might give you a favorabI¢ answer in thc process, but it is a risk. If you have to get shut down. xvhatcvcr you had before is a new budget going again. If you conclude that risk is too much. then Mu~t message do I send when I call Mr. Clough and Mr. Bray tomorrow and give them a report on thc outcome of lifts mccling? I have indicalcd lo them that them was some potential al Ihis meeting that thc Board would bc Crustralcd enough lo tell mc to stop. pull {he plug and we are not going lo do any more. Mr. Tom Brown replied that is not what thc motion is. Don't give them II~c wrong message. Mr. Ted Brown slated that hc understands, he is only aucmpting {o relay to you Ihat he i$ I~'ing to show {hose folks that this is a uniquc scl of circumstances. This is not a dcvclopcr with a bottomless well of money that has a fin:racial upside in thc process and can afford to stay in thc running until all hcll freezes over. I am tu'ing Io say to lhem that at some point Ihese folks are going Io tire of my repons. That will help lhcm understand what they wahl to do nexl. It seems lo me thai there is a risk pa~icularly in Irc li~l~c conslraints. Wc have to tn' Io make hasle which might Icad to waste and we can send a message to thc government that we want to pursue lhis and will pursue this until the end ora permit, but wc are not going to I~' Io rash fl~rough the implcmenlalion cf this in a way which might make us lurn Mmn we ought to lurn right. Therefore, we are Mmrc we are. We arc commilled 1o see through Io a permit, but arc not committed to go fom'ard until we have a permit in hand. at which point we are going with deliberate and due speed Io implement it as il emerges. I mn intcrcsled in yonr reaction to Ihal. Mr. Popper asked what message are you delivering to these people? Mr. Ted Brox~n replied ~hm he has bccn pushing a great sense of urgent'. One of thc risks in lhat approach is th:n we arc perhaps suggesling Ihnt the sense of the emcrgcn%' is gone. I had told them lhat thc emergency is still on board because the finds oCthe consultant team will mn out at lhe end of the year. If it doesn't happen by ~l~c cml of the year, folks are going 1o be working for free or you have anolhcr issllc 1o confronl. There is nobody on my Icatll, including myself. Ihat wanls lo come back to Iris Board to confront that issue. The bottom line is that I am not uncomfomable with where we are or the lex'el of sincerity of thc government to get us to an issued permit. I am simply tu'ing Io wreslle wilh you 2737 about whcthcr you should go fom'ard now and spend money to develop plans and specifications. To Ir).' to respond lo thc question, it is kind of a mixed bag. Part of thc spin you could put on it is if I called up there tomorrow and told them ;~c had a ','cD' nice meeting and thc Board is dclcrmincd that tbcy will proceed fonvard aggressively to get the permit, but they also determined and the way I think you should interpret this is that thc Board might be getting a little lukewarm about this unless this permit can get a liltlc head on it quick and get organized. They arc not going to go forward and spend money on plans and specifications umil they have a permit in hand. I think if wc can get this done in thc next two to four weeks this could rc-cncrgi/.c real quick, but we probably have ;Hrcad)' lost tile ability to do thc main ch;mncl in thc first halfof 1998. That is a potential spin. I don't know how that plays with you. Mr. Tom Brown asked why you would even bring it up to them? Mr. Ted Brown replied Ihat it is important. You don't have to. Mr. Toln Brown stated that we have a fiduciap,.' responsibility Io the taxpayers because we said Ihc Cotnmissioncrs should tax tile people of Pelican Bay. 1£ we are going to do that we have thc responsibility to sec that the money is well spent and not frivolously spent on somedfing we don't knox,,' lvill happen. If we delay ~l~c additional spending, it doesn't reduce the urgency one bit. Mr. Ted Broxvn replied that he docs not disagree. Mr. Griffilll asked if thc engineering work that was going 1o be done was going to be bid out? Mr. Ward replied no. \Vilson. Miller has already been chosen. Mr. Grif'fith asked ifa price has been determined as .','ct? Mr. Ward replied dmt the proposals were brought before the Board at the last meeting and approved and have also been prcscnlcd to the Board of County Commissioners. Dr. Yartcv stated that thc proposals were approved with the proviso that we not spend it until we heard Mr. Bro~vn's rcporl. Mr. Craighcad asked if we could proceed v,'id~ the plans and specifications, spending ~l:at money but not implementing anything until we got tile permit? Mr. Ted brown replied that is an option. 2738 16G 2 PELICAN BAY ADVISORY CO,MMITTEE NOVEMBER 12. 1997 Mr, Hoyt staled tim! you slill nm the risk of a change in Ihc plan when thc pcrmi~ comes out. Dr. Varlcv staled 11~;~I iht only pa~ of Iht plan Ihal has any urgcn%' ns far as Ihc lunlcs arc concerned in lilt pass and Ibc firsl channel. If we can'l gel thal done and I am hearing that thc chances of that are ye%' slim this year, wc have lois of time ~o do thai engineering, all Summer long. Mr. Ted Brown replied thai you ccflainly have all Winlcr long. There is no question thai you will Imx'c plenty of time. N~r. Fred F1;{{Io sl;{lcd Ih;Il he sccs people in Ibc audicncc gelling lircd and would like lo call for a x'ol~ on th< Dr. V;~rlcv si;ired {hal hc feels it is only Fair {hal {he people in Iht audience have a chance lo speak prior Io caroling for Ibc vole. Mr. D;~x'id Rocllig, Chine:mn]crc rcsidcn{ and retired Army Co~s of Engineers employee - made ibc rccommct~cl:nion Io go along with Mr. Ted Brown on lhis. Once thc pcrmil is in hand it has {o be signed hcrc :md {hca go b:}ck, Wig~ linc mails you will lucky lo get ii signcd by Ihc middle of Janua~'. Thc idea of gelling thc dredging done before {u~Ic season, I fcci is a waslc of money. You should consider doing some of Ibc back work during Iht Summer. get lhe plans ready and have it all bid wilh a Notice lo Proceed :is soon as {{{~lc sc;ison is over. Dr. V;~rlcv asked if our casing up on thc whip and saying we give up for Ihis year. bul will come back l]cx{ ye:lC will bc comnmnicz~lcd on {o thc Corps and lhcy xxi[I fcc[ {hey hnx'c anolh~r twelve monlhs now {o :]pprovc this iIcm'? Nit. Rocllig stated th;Il his opinion is Ihal il is jusl human nature in general thal when you sec somebody Ih;il i5 ~'i:]g {o n{sh you by committing money, doing sludics and gelling ~lans ready, you are more likely lo lhink of ways [o delay. Nit. Young sI3lcd lhal is thc way hc would re;Icl. Mr. Rocllig stated lh:~t if you {~' 1o push somebody, {hey have a Icnflcncy lo push back. Whether or not ~our get Ibc pi:ms is one lhing, but Ihe other thing is what physical conditions migh{ change duc 1o sex'crc storms or such which would cause you {o have to redo significant pa~s of {he plans if Ihey are done 2739 too soon. It ',vould bc belier Io get Iht plans done at almost the time you are ready to go lo construction. My rccommcnd;ltion would bo to gel lbo plans read)' to go when lu~l~ season is over. Th~ back work is import:mi to get done as soon as possible. You want Io have Iht back opened as soon as the main channd is finisl~cd. It seems lo mc you would want ~o have them done first and can be done iaes~ctive of the tu~Ic nesting scaSOll. Mr. Ted Brown suggested that w~ get th~ permit and once we have it and it is accepted, approved and sanclificd by lbo levels of govcrnmcnl lhnt aced lo do so. you then proceed Io devdop Ihc bid doc,moms ,cccss;to, Io implement what wc will call Iho noflh portion of II1~ plan, which is cveQ~hing wilh Iht cxccption of tl~c main channel ctll. Undcrsland dmt thosc final plans also have Io bo reviewed bcForc thc Noticc Io Proceed will be issucd From lhc gox'crnmcnl, so Ihcr~ will bc some necessity of leaving yoursclFsomc Icad lilnc. This whole 1]ling results in a slrclch out, bul I believe uliimalcly it will be more cost c~cctix'c and thc qualily oFiI~c product you will get will be improved. Mr. Rocllig siilicd thai once yotl gel l]lc pcrmit and tha pass c]oscs up. basically whal you arc doing is 11 lilllc aclx'ancc work on Ibc pcrmil and I Ikcl il iSfilSt a sura Ihing. Dr. Var]tv slzIIcd Ih;Il il scorns lo him lhal Ibc Co~s thai says you can'! haw a permit unlcss you havc ~ long rangc plan and we spend $400.000 to dcvclop long range plans and Ihcy won't approve il. is a lilllc prcstmtplllOtlS lo say you can'l open thc chalmcl. Mr. Wcrncr asked iF wc arc spcnding Inoncy wilh Mr. Tackncy Io secure thc information ~ing rcqucstcd? Nlr. Tom Broxvn rcplicd dial money is alrcady budgclcd. Nlr. Wcrncr statcd/[~crc is a big di~crcncc bclwccn budgcling moncy and spcnding satisa' cvc~body's whim. Jtlsl bcc:lllS¢ wc hllvc it in Iht budgcL docs not mcan wc have to s~nd NIt. Tom ~rown slatcd Ihal linc qucstion was do we spend additional money For studics? Thc molion is not Io spend thc moneys thai Mr. Ward went Io Ih~ Cotltlly Commission for at laSl Inccling For cngi,ccring sltidics, tlc. This docs ,oI say thc work for tl~c pcrmil docs not continue. 2740 Mr. Ted Brown staled Ihat you will alwnys have tim ability with the ~overmnent Io tell them this is as filr ;is ~vc ;Irc going, l lcrc is a permit we have ]lashed :,lrolll'ld wil]l )'Oil folks for thc better part of a )'car and a half. We have addressed every concern limt could conceivably bc addrcsscd, we will vole il tip and slalc thc condilions, l£ we like the conditions wc will accept it, ir we don't, we won'l. That is prcuy much xx hcrc we arc. My recommendation Io you and my approach would be, I points of inquig' Ihal came out of Ihc FDEP's, one of which is the Tackncy calculalions and the other is Ihc ;ipplication for Iht variance for the mixing zone. ! think thc mixing zone is likely lo create some addition:il nccd for backup which Dr. ttillcslad or Dr. Sncdckcr can respond Io in Icrms of biological implications for ~ h:ll wc arc doing. I didn'l want to guess what they might ask. but ralhcr have them ask. so that wc don'l raise issues that don't nccd Io be raised. Beyond Ihat. I can lcll you that Ihcre is no one on our lc:un that lhinks there is a whole lot more lo be digested here. Mr. D,, Ifr,m'n move'ti, xec'ottt[ed b)' Mr. l[o)'t ttttd approvedj tt/ttl/lilltOtt,~l' t/tat tin)' ~ltId[l[ontll IlloItt[~' Oil engi. ceri.g ti. Iii .'e have the permit in l ]ttlntI. ! Mr. Young StalCd that ha wants cvc~'onc Io rcmcmbcr thnt whcn go for :in cmcrgcncy opcning, lhat work hns always bccn paid for through Ihe Tonrisl Tax. I would hope that wc would continue to have thc Tourist Tax ~ake care of Ihat scgmcnt of it. Thai lax was for beach rcnourishnmnt and pass Mr. Ted Brown st:lied that would ccmfinly b¢ his recommendation on how Io proceed, i have had enough comact wilh Cotlllly slllff lis we have bccIi working through this process, Ihat I would be su~riscd ir there wcrc any opposition to that at lhc County office. Mr. Ward agreed saying Ih;it he did not think Ihcrc would bc any opposilion. Dr. Varlcv asked if it would be appropriate lo comment 1o them lhat we arc Icrribly disappoinlcd because ~vc arc vc~¥ much concerned about lbo condition of thc pass right now and lh:ll if it does close bce:rose they have dchiycd so long we will be back looking rot an cmcrgcn%' permit? Mr. Ted Brown s,ggcslcd that he and Mr. Ward would handle that strategy. II is nol inappropri:~tc m alcrt ~hcm Io the likelihood that rcq,csl mighl emerge after Iht first of the year. 2741 PEI.ICAN BAY SECURITY Sgt. Todd Taylor of the Collier Count)' Sheriffs Department introduced Sgt, Mike Dolan ~'llo is taking over his spot at tile Norlh Naples Substation. We were asked to come today to touch on a couple of arcas, one of which was the perception Ihat burglaries have skyrockcled in Pelican Bay and lhere is a real problem, Sgt. Ta) Ior reported that comparing thc last Ihrcc years for burglaries Ihcre bas been no increase and has been mainlaincd at about thc same level. There was some concern about rcccut burglaries. I do not think wc havc had a large increase or large percent increase than anytime during the last three )'cars. Sonic olhcr examples is auto thefts, which appear to bc tile same as previous years. All of thc major classes arc m:fintaining about tile same. Dr. Varlcv asked ~vha! >'car we slatted lhe program in Pelican Bay? Mr. Wcrncr replied Oclobcr 199.'5 which is Fiscal Year 1996. Mr. Ward asked Sgl. Taylor to explain tile report that was gix'cn lo him prior lo thc meeting and copies will be sent Io the Board. Sgt. Taylor explained that prior to our contacting the ShcriWs Office for sen'ices. Pelican Bay did not have a grid assignccl to it. We designated Pelican Bay as 1201 grid so we could track a little more easily what was occurring in Pelican Bay. Tile Pine Ridge area is 1202 and the Retreat is 1102 which nrc used as a comparison for the crime numbers in those other txvo communities. Mr. \Vard slaled thal lie would like to rcschcdulc this ilcm for thc next meeting after tile Board has had a chance lo review tile malerial. Sgt. Taylor explained Ih:it the crime rates n Pelican Bay have all maintaiucd over the last three >'ears. You can look at Ihat o~e of two ways. You cal~ look at il ;Is thc Sheriff's Office has come in here and provided you :~ service and we have bccn able to maintain the crime rate. You can look at it as a good thing th;it x~c have done ourjob compared to the rest of thc Coullly. v,'hcre lhis >'ear we had a considerable increase in property crimes. Our serious violent offenses such as murder, rape. etc. maintained about same comity-wide. You can also look at it in that you hired tls three years ago lo come in here with some 2742 PELICAN BAY ADVISORY NOVEMBER 12. 19')7 additional scm'ices and thc rates have not dropped, but maintained and that can be a bad Ihing. I guess it is in the eye of tl~e beholder as to how you want to look at it. Mr. Tom Brown stated Ih:it what prompmd this is that a friend got burglarized while she was in her bedroom. Thc thief went through thc bedroom to get lo Ire bathromn Io steal over $35,000 ~'o~h of jewel%'. Anmhcr lady came in while she was not home and she said they slole over $50.000 in jewels'. If ~c arc averaging $4o.000 a burgla%' and we have 28 lhat is $1,400,000 going out the window. ! told both ladies we have twenty-four hour protection. One of the ladies I lalkcd said Ihat after lalking lo the deputy ;llld providing thc inform:ilion she had lhc fccling nothing would come of it. The other lady said thc deputy mid her ins.raaco agent th;it she Icfl her door unlocked. I have knmvn Ihis lady for four >'cars and havc never knoxvn her door Io be ,Mocked. Why would a dcpuly make thai conmlCnl? In Ire firsl case thc deputy said these guys are from Miami and we won't catch Ihcm. How do you know they are from Miami7 Maybe thc deputy isjt~sl making a dumb stale~x~enL but lhal prompted my loller. When we t~k on a depuly lwcnl)'-four hours a d',~y, what was thc pu~ose? If it was for Irate co~tlrol or lo reduce lhe theft in thc shopping centers that is one thing. I thought rcduclion of burglaries in residences was the prima%' goal and thai hasn't happened. It i5 not a question Ihat you are not doing a good job or what you arc supposed Io do. bul wh:ll is your real mission7 Is it to answer alarms for houses where lhey go off u~cxpcclcflly, lr~c COnlrol, etc.? Sgl. T~ylor replied llmt il is all of those things. Mr. Tom Brown asked how ma,y burglars have been caughl here in lhe residences in Pelican Bay in Irc lasl I~o a~d one halFyears7 Sgt. T;~vlor replied thai he can not answer that right off hand. bul hc docs nol work in cfinfinal inx'cslig:tlion. Mr. Brown s~alcd th:ti obviously if none have bccn caught, none have been convicted. $g[. Taylor staled that the persons he knows personally that have been caught were multiple burglaries of vehicles that have occurred at the Waterside Shops. There were some kids caught lhal were involved in a gang nnd were breaking into cars. I do not work in criminal invcsligation so I cannot tell 2743 you about c:lch individual casc dclails, how many suspccis thcy have developed or if Ihcrc ,.vas an arrcsl made or not. According to the report, during thc last three years a Iotal of 185 burglaries occurred in Pelican Bay. of th:~t there ,,','crc five arrests made. You have lo understand Ihat you have 185 burglaries and five :~rrcsls, but one person that ,.,,'ns arrested could have bccn responsible for twenty lo thirty burglaries. [Xlr. Tom Brown asked if you collld loll us lhal? Sgt, Taylor replied that he could not. /'.Ir. Tom F3rown st;lled that our position is that we went to Ibc Board of Courtly Commissioners and told th¢I~ to bill the people of Pelican Bay $200.000 which ,,','as bumped lo over $300,000 and in three .','c;lrs these people arc getting taxed $1,000,000. Tile qucslion is. what are Ihey getting for $I,000,000. Sgt. T;Lvlor slated that a lot el' Ihings Ihat you arc gcltirlg have been mcnlioncd. That is a dccisio~l Ih;H ','ou h;B'c to make is whether you foci thai Illc money you are paying is worth the sen'ices thai you arc gctH~g. Wc patrol twenty-four hours a day. I ,.,,'ill be honest v,'ilh you. I did the scheduling for tv.'o years for Pclic;~n B;iv ar:d not only do you get a deputy Iwenty-four hours a day in the community, but you also get about 20% of tile Sergeant's time sitting in the office doing all o£ the scheduling and personnel mailers lh;~t come up with tile Pelican Bay deputies. Again hopcfifily tile response times have improved. I do not h;wc the numbers on that. If 1 recall correctly, those ,.,.'crc tile things that you as a grot~p x',';~ntcd when you started these sen'ices with the Sheriff. You wanted the personalized conlact, a deputy avail;iblc txvcnt)'-fot~r hours a d;ly. traffic slow dov, n and that presence in lite community and that is what you have been given. b,'Ir. To~ Brown st;ued th;~t he is not saying that is not good. but these two v,'onlen asked rne v, hat we were gettillg for this. Thcv came to Sgt. Taylor replied that ;~nother argument back then was that you ha;.'¢ private security 'Milch was ,.'cD,' visible, but tln;ibl¢ Io respond Io your burglaries or unable to respond to your calls for sen'icc. When something occurred in Pclic:m Bay. they got on the phone and called tls and we responded. The argument was brought lip Ih;It YOU did not see tile Sheriff's Office as much as you did Ihe private security and that is 2744 probably tn,c bccat,sc tile Sheriff's Office is responding to all the calls for sen'ice v,'here thc private sccuritv w:,sn't responding to an)' of tile calls for service. Mr. Tom Brown asked if this could looked into and brought back Io our next meeting? Sgt. Taylor stated if.volt tell ale exactly what you ,,:'ant. I am a little confused as lo ,,,.'hat you ',V[lllt. klr. Toni Brown replied. ',vhat can be done to find thc people that have committed these burgl:lries :l~d convict them. Sgt. Dokln replied that v,c have a sci leant that focus on the daytime ;,nd night time burglaries. Abot,t two months ago we had a problem ,.vith people coming over from Mia,hi and focusing on gated co,re,amities sl~ch as your neighbors. The scl team in addition to patrolling this neighborhood and also foct,sed on Ih¢ other communities ;lad cal~ght three or four people with tools in the ;Icl of doing it. Mr. To,n Brov,'n asked ifthcv were convicted? Sgt. Taylor stated that it ','.'as three burglars from Miami which ',,,'crc cat,ght at Audubon in thc process of jr, roping a fence to go in and commit thc burglaries with tools, black masks, clothing and flashlights. Their story was that they ca,ne over to go to the dog track and tile.,,' ended up at Audubon to usc thc facilities in thc woods behind them. Ifyot, think tile>' are going to come fonvard and sa.,,' they did the b~rgl;~rics i~ Pelican a;l>'. )'or, arc fooling yo,rsclf. Our St;lie Attorney's office locally decided that there ',v;{s not cx'id¢~lCe to proceed with the case and prosecute them and all charges :,,'ere dropped. Mr. Ml,dgc stated th;n when Ibis was stat'led, in ;,Il of North Naples there were five deputies on the road al~d the a,,,o~,nt of time they were spending in Pelican Bay as ,,'er>.' small. We opted to pa.',' for full coverage. ;md what we are getting is fi,lc and is a great improvement over ',.vh;ll it :,,';Is before. Wc could ask for Ixvo a,ld it would cost ils twice as much. but think there has been a gre;~t improvement in tile service here. I don't like lo hear of ;lll of these burglaries, bl,t I am pleased with the progress that has been ,nadc. Sgl. Taylor states that Pelican Bay is guaranteed a dcpt,ly on sile twenty-four hours a da.,.' and tile problem tl,;~t v,'c haxe n,n into is v, hen a deputy is supposed to be working ai'~d goes on vacation or calls in 2745 ........... ~ll ................ I ..................... Ill ..... I NOVEMBER 12. I')97 sick. then wc nm rote scheduling problems. We have taken deputies from Immokalee and Marco Island and brought tlmm in lo work in ?clican Bay to fulfill our contract. M r. ltasso n asked aboul tile nu tuber of ale rms i n Pelican Bay and i f tile.,,' a re false alarms? Sgt. T:lvlor replied that thcv arc false alarms. (Mr. CRAIGItEAD LEFT TltE MEETING AT 4:45 P.M.) Mr. ttasson asked what could be done to minimize that number? Sgt. Taylor replied lhat this issue has come up many times. A False Alarm Ordinance has been passed ;md ill a, Ordinance now. The final arrangements are being set up now with the Clerk's Office who will be coll¢cting lh¢ money and under what circumstances ,,,,'ill a licker be issued, such as il' a lightning strike will bc ticketed. Mr. \Vard Staled ih;l! he feels tile False Al;~rm Ordinance is tile biggest tr;,,'csty of justice in this County. Thc police and sheriff have tile rcsponsibilily to provide you with whatever Icvcl of sc~'icc that is rcquircd in thc community irrespective of whether the fiflse alarm docs or does not go off. Although I am awarc Ihat v.'c have a significant amount of false alarms in this community, we currently pa)' a significant amounl of money for them to provide you with the additional levels of sca'ice. If you had the ability to collcct thc false al;irnl moneys th:it will be eoIl¢cled under this ordinance and utilize it to offset )'our Operating Cosls. that would be one thing that would be imporlant for you. but I quite frankly irritated that thc Shcriffand whoever decided to pressure and push and put in place a hist alarm ordinance that in lny opinion ,.,.'ill substantially adversely affect you financially because v,'e are paying for an additional level of sca'icc to which those officers arc going Io respond to which you are now going to get fined. I have never bccn happy with it and I Imvc indic;ired to tile Sheriffs Officc since tile day I heard about this Ordinance thai I thought it w;~s Ihc biggest tr:n'csty of justice thai I have ever scen happen around here. but be that as it may. thcv have gone ell and implcmcnled this Ordinance itl this County. For you. I think it is ridiculous. Sgt. Taylor staled that it is cmmly-wide and cvcr)'one is entitled to their opinion. In my opinion we arc not dealing wilh cvcr)'on¢ iii this room oil it. If we were take a percentage of thc people we were 2746 NOVEMBER 12. 1997 having a problem with, it would probably be one or two people in this roo,n. We hax'e aboul 10% of our pcoplc thai absolutely rcfusc lo maintain Ihcir alann ~'slcms. We arc responding lo ihc ~me addrcs~s Iimc and dmc again. ~Vc arc responding Io lhc ~mc homes lhrcc and four limes an cvcning, Thosc arc lhc pcoplc wc will bc largcling. Il is lhc samc thing lhroughoul lhc cnlire Counly. We lilcrally gel primoms on repeal addresses. Those arc lhc ones wc arc targcling and the oncs thai will bc fincd and I think Ibc fines will substamiallv dccrcasc over Ihc years as wc largct thai small pcrccnlagc of pcoplc thai will nol lake care oflhcir syslcms. Mr. Yom~g asked where Ihc fincs go? SgL Taylor staled Iha~ as hc undcrslands il, lhc money goes inlo thc Gcncral Fund. Thc Clcrk's O~cc is thc collcclor of Iht money and all wc arc is Ihc cnforccr. Nlr. Young slalcd Ihal hc was at a couple of mcclings on lids and Ihal is Ihc problem. I[ thc Shcriffgol lhc money, then wc could sil dou'n and ncgoliatc on Iht basis on whal we arc conlribming here in Pclic:m Bay agains~ thc Fcc Ih;il wc erg paying. Itit goes imo Ibc General Fund wc cannot. (MR. FLA~O LE~ TIlE MEETING AT 4:55 P.M.) Sgl. Taylor staled Ihal Iht Foundation o~crs a sc~'ice where iFyou leave your honlc unattended you can register with Iht Fotmdalion and wc pick up thc list cyan' week and do residence checks on those Dr. Varlcv s~atcd that i~ seems Io him Ih;il thc sccurily issue is something lhal xvt do not have a vc~' good grip on and we have lalkcd a good bit over lhc pasl year of identifying some individuals Ilmt would gc~ inlo specific problems and advise thc rest of us as Io how we could bailer do il. Dr. Varlcy asked Nlr. Tom Brown Io take thc time to lalk ~o who aver you need Io and I~' Io understand ~hc syslcm baiter. You can lhcn explain 1o us on a month Io month basis, whal is going on and wc can then respond to people who ask tis qucslions. Nlr. Tom Brown Sl:lled Ih:il he is responding lo ll~e women who were robbed. Sgl. Taylor sla~cd Ihat in Ihis posilion you gel a lot o[ rocks Ihrown at you and a lot otindividual sihmlions which arc brol~ght tip like lifts and whal I find is Ih:il when I lake ~l individ,al situation like Ihis 2747 and go back and do a folios,., up on it and ask fllcm spccifics and rcally dclvc into cxactly what happcncd, a lot of times there arc a ]Ol of ,nisquotcs and ,nisinformatior~. A lot of it is second hand information and a lot of what [ have been Iold is not ln~c once I go back in and research il. lflhcrc arc individual complainls that you have. please don'! bcsila[c lo contact cilhcr Sgt. Dolan or myself. We will bolh follow up on Ihe rcscarch lo see if that is Ihe cnsc alld Ihos¢ commenls were made. If they ',,,'crc. then we will correct it. Mrs. Obey staled that xve should again review the false alarm issue in lite Communique. People forget and thev are careless and we mighl help the cnuse. I! doesn't hurt 1o keep lolling. We need 1o appeal lo the people because it is faking )'our time to answer lite nlarms and could be laking someone away from Ihe robbe~'. Sgt. Taylor rci~cralcd that Ihe Ordinance has been passed and signed offby Ibc Stale. however has not gone into clTccl ycl. It is slill o[~ hold. Thc final arra,gcmcms between Ibc Clerk's O~ce and Sheriff are still tmdcm,ay Io get all of lhe lillle bugs worked out before il ge~s initialed nnd gets it going, Any time a dcpt%' is dispalched in Pelican Bay. n district o~cer is nlso dispalched in. (MR. POPPER LEgF TIlE MEETING AT 5:05 P.M.) UPDATE ON BIKE PATII RESTRIPPINGAND PIJBI,IC IIEARINC Mr. Ward reported ih:il the Public tlcaring was scheduled for FcbnmD. 18. 1998 at 3:00 P.M. in lifts room. We are waiti,g to hear from the Counlv with respect lo Ibc rcslripping of a portion of Pelican Bay Boulcvarct. We anlicipate hearing shortly and having Ihal work done. Dr. Varlov stated that once again ~his is somclhing tho community needs lo undcrslnnd, I would guess that 75% of thc people here have no concept at all of lhe pros or cons of Ihis and nn infommtion piece should be senl out in Janua~' Io the residents. DISCUSSION OF COMMITTEE INVOLVEMENT WlTII PBSD PRO.IECTS Mr, Werncr stilled Ihal lifts issue hns been broughl up in Ihe past and a perfect exnmple is what you jusl asked Mr. Brown Io do wilh security. I lalked with Ibc Courtly Attorney's o~ce rifler Mr. Yotmg made Ibc suggestion Ihal iff we nrc going lo get involved with subcommillccs and members of corem,nib' p;micipafing, why nol do il in Ibc Sunshine, 1 gol a, informal response as Io whnt would be 2748 PELICAN BAY ADVISORY COMNII'FFEE 1 6 G 2 NOVEMBER 12. 1997 required and it is not all Iii;it much. Basically you have Io advertise lhe same as we do for our meetings and all that involves is notifying Ihe County, and posting information at thc Foundation. You don't have lo record thc Minutes. You don't have to do verbatim Minutes like wc do. If somebody can t~c good notes Ih:it is fine ;md I am sure Mrs. Smilh could type Ihem up. I still would like to push this. There arc several areas where wc could get involved and I don't think it is fight that Mr. Ward is making all of thc decisions for our community. We live here and I think we would like to be involved in Ihe decisions. Wc have the sccuriw issue and also the ilem coming up about landscaping. I think Ihe community should be involved in some ofthose decisions. Dr. V;~rlev asked what h;~ppened lo lhe "Fact Finding" aspect thai did not require advertised Mr. ~Vcrncr stated thal after Mr. Young's comment. I think we were really dancing around the issue. ~Vc were not really just "Fact Finding". we were going to recommend. 11 is ahnost impossible nol to recommend. Dr. Varlcv stated that his notion was to ask Mr, Brown Io talk Io the Shcriffor who ever and Ihcn act as a li,ison xx'ith the Board as :t Committee of one. I was assuming thai was outside of the umbrella of the Sunshine Law. Mr. Werncr replied thai it is ifil is "Fact Finding" he can even have some cilizens involved, but I]l¢v CaHllOI COHI~ back and Illak¢ re~OllllnOnd;lliOl~S. Mr. Ward st:lied th:it the Chairma1~ asked Nlr. Brown if wanted 1o look Jnlo something of nature and was not :t formal action of the Advison' Commillee lo appoint him as a Chairman. He is taking it on as ;m individual member of the Board to go out and do whatever it is he wants to do with respect to security. In my opinion it's not considered any t)~e of a Committee. Any member of this Commillce who has a desire lo look into an aspect of the community and repo~ back to us whatever it is he wants to. inch~ding a recommendation, I would go along with. Dr. Varlcv stated that if Mr. Brown wanted to do this in a more formal way in Ihe form of a Commitlcc he could do that if he would take Minutes and advertise it. 2749 bdr. \Vcrncr slated Ilmt hc docs nol know il' there is ;in.,,' inlcrcsl in this or nol nnd if not I v,'ill si'm! up and Icl il dic. Dr. Varlcy slalcd Ih;ti hc [cc]s there arc u number o[lhcsc things and [ would like 1o ~s lime gms on [o ask a mm]bcr oF you iF you would bc willing [o lake an ~c~ and kind or clmpcronc j[ and come up ~vid~ things wc ought ~o know more :~bou:. Thc flower, i:rigafion business ~nd s[rcct signs ~rc ~II things tlm[ would be vco, good iF wc had more a coat,el wid~ [itc communib. :md broughl il Ihrough one individual ~ho could focus on it lo a grcalcr cxlcnt Ihan each oFus could. hlr. Gril~[h s[mcd lha: he has bccn doing dial on ano[hcr issue which is fl~c U.S. 41 median irrigmion. Wc (WC[ Communities) had a meeting Ioday wi[h DOT and brough[ up Ibc question irrigmc [hc mcdi:ms. They said [hcv did not Imvc plans For doing lhal in d~cir conslmclion documents. When ~his was brough~ up, il was s;fid lhal Ii'is was something lhat upon request lhcy would be glad Io Jncorporalc inlo lhcir design. Thc Cotmly has lo ask specifically b)' JOliet lO IIlglll lo inco~oralc Mrs. W;ms and I will coordimuc ~his cEon wid~ [l~c Coumy Io make sure lifts gc~s done. Mr. Young asked if should make a molion Io have Mr. Ward wrilc Ih;il Dr. Varlev sm~cd ~hm his tmdors~anding was Ih;il [his was beyond our jurisdiclional limRs. Mr. Gri~d~ replied Ih;il hc ;md Mrs. Walls will lake care o[~vrilJn~ lh~ Imlcr Io rcqucsling tim[ Ihis Jlcm bc added lo Ibc conslmclJon documcnls. CONSIDERATION OF SELECTED ANNUAl, FI.OWER lIED CONVERSION TO XERI~CAPt: LAND.~CAPE MATERIAl, N~r. W;~rd reported ~l~at all we were doing is laking [he meal of Iht Clam B;~y Managcmcnl Plan and convcrljng some of Iht anntml beds IIJ~H arc nol 5ig~ti~ca~l J~t I~rms o[ Ihcir looks or IocalJon Io mmcrials Ih;il we could pul hi and nol Il;we Iht expense of doing I]lal all )'mir long. I doll'l lhink any of lhosc areas would be of;my gre~tl problem lo do. Thc only one I know lJml would gel any cornmeal Oakmonl Park~vav recall;ms. They currcn[ly have flowers. The rest lend lhoms~lves Io Xcrisc:~pc mmcri:,Is. Ifyou all agree, wc will proceed Io do Ihal. Mrs. Oblcv s~;llcd ~hm )'o,~ jusl ~o[ done t)la,ui,,g ~he ngw Rowers, so I would nol change unlil you have 1o slcriliz¢ ~l~c soil. 2750 Mr. Ward replied that these beds have been sterilized, but not planted at this point. Mrs. Oblcy stated Ihal her other suggestion is to stay av,'ay from the ornamental grasses. You put them in and they are title for two weeks and then the weeks start growing and they arc ugly for three or four years until somebody hand corrects Ihcm. When we do pick flowers instead ora throe time rotation. I would suggest a two time rotation. Mr. Ward replied that we have been down Ihat road and Ihat is not working primarily because we cannot make plants last six months. Mrs. Oblcy slated that I know you can't. Lcls just have an empty period a liltlc longer. Have Wimer flowers [asl as long as possible and then put in thc Summer and have lhem last until you working again. Mr. Ward replied we have done fha/ for a long time and changed that about one year ago and have gone to lhree plantings on at least Ibc cntranccways and two plantings cvcDavhcm else. You need to stay with three planlings at your cntranccways or olhcavise you cnd up with vacant beds. Mrs. Oblcv statcd that shc thought thc flowers ~vcrc just at Ihcir fullest and they have been pulled out to put in new flowers. It depends on what flo~vcrs you pat in. Thc Petunias will last. bu{ thc Gcr;mimns will 1101. Mr, Ward replied Ih;l[ they arc not intended lo and will be pulled in May. Mr. Wcrncr sta{cd that one consideration about doing this and it is kind ora selfish lhing is. if~c do it now bcforc we get thc permit, we will probably not gct much crcdit for rcducing thc irhgation water going into {l~c system. Mr. ~Vard replied that it does not have a huge impact and is more of a "show and go" versus a real impact. Mr. Young stated that as long as wc arc irrigating with muse water and we get the work done in thc s)'stcm, thc amount of watcr {hal gets into ii will be a non-issue. Mr. Wcrncr replied that hc docs not lhink so. Maybe as far as thc hcalth of {l~e ~'stcm. but not as f:~r ;Is lhc continuing conditions of thc pcrnfit wc arc going to gct. 27.51 ' PELICAN BAY ADVISORY COMMITTEE 1 6 G 2 NOVEMBER 12. 1997 Mr. Young stated that it will really bca non-issue because thc more water wc can get into lhal ~'stcm. thc easier it is to keep Ihe pass open. Dr. Varlcy slalcd thai ',ye arc going Io south of us and slealing wnler from Ih¢ir system. Mr. Young stated wc nrc not taking water out o£wclls. Mr. ltasson moved, seconded b), Mrs. Obley and approved unt~nimously (9/0) to ~o ahead with the replanting program. I AD,JOI, IRNM ENT There being no further business, thc meeting adjourned at 5:20 P.M. Dr. Alan Varlcy, Chairman THE NEXT REGULAR MEETING IN SCttEDULED FOR DECEMBER 3, 1997 AT 3:00 P.M. 2752 16G 2 PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION CLAM BAY RESTORATION FUND October 31, 1997 F.Y. 1997 F.Y. 1998 Total Exp. Oct. 1997 Budget Budget Budl~et To Dale Balance Expen,~es EXPENDITURES Environmental Consult. Akerman. Senterfitt. et. al. S 153.168 $ 54.532 $ 207,700 $ 171.224 $ 36.476 $ 18.056 Lewis Environmental Sen'. $ 71.460 $ 7.540 $ 79,000 $ 71.460 $ 7.540 $ Tackncv& A~socintcs $ 54.184 $ 32.316 $ 86,500 $ 59.661 $ 26.839 $ 5.477 Wilson. Miller. ct. al. $ 47.112 $ 42.888 $ 90,000 $ 52. I55 $ 37.845 $ 5.043 Dr. Samuel Sncdckcr $ 7.001 $ 20.599 $ 27,600 $ 9.1)75 $ I8.525 $ 2.074 HilburnHilstad $ 10.550 $ 38,550 $ 49,100 $ 10.550 $ 38.550 $ - Others $ 18.524 $ 121.294 $ 139,818 $ 21.118 $ 118.701} $ 2.594 Sub-Total $ 361.999 $ 317.719 $ 679,718 $ 395.243 $ 284.475 $ 33.244 Capital Outlay Improvements General $ 15.459 $ 1.361.400 $1,376,859 $ 15.459 $ 1.361.401) $ Other Machincn' & Equip. $ 2.827 S $ 2,827 $ 2.827 $ $ . Sub-Total $ 18.286 $ 1.361.41)1) $1,379,686 $ 18.286 $ 1.361.400 $ - Other Fees & Charges Tax Collector $ 10.214 $ 20.000 $ 30,214 $ 11).229 $ 19.985 $ 15 Property Appraiser $ $ 13.400 $ 13,400 $ $ 13.400 Revenue Reserve $ $ 23.600 $ 23.600 $ $ 23.600 Sub-Total $ 10.214 $ 57.{)1)1) $ 67,214 $ 11).229 $ 56.985 $ 15 TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS 15 391).499 $ 1.736.119 $2,126,618 $ 423.759 $ 1.702.859 $ 33.260] ACCOUNTS PAYABLE - OCTOBER DATE INV. NO. AMOUNT Akcrman. Scnterfit! 11/18/97 2055950 $17,676.99 Lewis Environmental 11/19/97 97192 $ 4,481.47 Tackncy & Associates 10/23/97 0567 $ 6,096.92 Tackncv & Associates 11/20/97 572 $ 9,567.87 Dr. Sncdckcr 11/03/97 114)3-97 $ 243.75 WMB&P 11/18/97 7673 $ 5,182.5 I TOTAL INVOICES $ 43.249.5 i AGENDA IqO~ ~, !-~-!7 COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION WILL MEET AT 5:05 P.M., THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 25, 1997 IN THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING ROOM, ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER, 3301 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, EAST NAPLES, FLORIDA: NOTE:ANY PERSON WHO DECIDED TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. ALL MATERIAL USED IN PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE CCPC WILL BECOME A PERMANENT PART OF THE RECORD. THESE MATERIALS WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. 1. ROLL CALL BY CLERK 2. ADDENDA TO THE AGENDA 3. APPROVAl. OF MINUTES: 4. PLANNING COMMISSION ABSENCES: 5. BCC REPORT 6. 'CHAIRMAN'S REPORT 7. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS: A. July 1997 Cycle LDC Amendments- 2"5 Meeting 8. OLD BUS[NESS 9. NEW BUSINESS I0. DISCUSSION OF ADDENDA 11. ADJOURN U,,'~,c. · Cortes: Norr t S .. f/ Hancock _ '" ' Mac 'K la ' I ,/ ..... 1 (.,,,. ~:.~ To: 8~rrz ...... ~ ......... / ~orr ~ s / C" Hancock ' 2 Constantine sac K~0 ~ ........ AGENDA ' , Berr~ COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION WILL MEET AT 8:30 A.M., THURSDAY, DECEMBER 4, 1997 IN TIlE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING ROOM, ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER, 3301 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, EAST NAPLES, FLORIDA: NOTE:ANY PERSON WHO DECIDED TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. ALL MATERIAL USED IN PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE CCPC WILL BECOME A PERMANENT PART OF THE RECORD. THESE MATERIALS WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. 1. ROLL CALL BY CLERK 2. ADDENDA TO THE AGENDA 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES' 4. PLANNING COMMISSION ABSENCES: 1,',.s?, Cotres: 5. BCC REPORT Date: 6. CHAIRMAN'S REPORT 7. ADVERTISED PUBLIC IIEARINGS: Copies Io: A. Petition No. BD-97-25, Ben Nelson of Nelson Marine Construction, Inc., representing Gordon Goodier, requesting an 11 foot boat dock extension to allow for a 31 foot boat dock and boat lift facility for property localed at 219 Bayfront Drive, further descried as Lot 21, Bayfront Gardens. (Coordinator: Ross Gocbenaur) B. Petition No. R-97-7, Community Development & Environmental Sen'ices Division, representing the Collier County Board of County Commissioners, requesting a rezone from "PUD" Planned Unit Development to "A" Rural Agricultural for the Naples R & D Park at Lely PUD, located immediately south of U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail East), m Sections 29 and 30, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, consisting of 64.8 acres, more or less. (Coordinator: Fred Reischl) C. Petition No. PUD-84-23(1). Thomas W. Olliff, Administrator of Collier County Public Services, is requesting an amendment to the East Naples Community Park Planned Unit Development, Section 3.2 - Uses Permitted to add "monopole communication towers" as a permitted use for property located south of Thomasson Drive and to the south and east of Avalon Elementary School in Section 24, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. (Coordinator: Bryan Milk) 1 D. Petition Nt~. I'{1D-97-14, Blair A. Foley, P.E., of Coastal Engineering Consultants, Inc., representing \Vhittenberg Development Corporation, requesting a rezone from RMF-6 to PUD to be known as Creston Woods. for a maximum of 25 dwelling units for property between 12m Street and Goodlette. Frank Road (C.R. 851) further described as the remainder of Lot 72, Naples Improvement Co.'s I,ittle Farms. in Section 22, Township .49 Soulh, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida, consisting of 9.63 acres. (Coordinator: Susan Murray) E. Petition No. PUD-83-1(§), Michael R. Fernandez, AICP, of Planning Development Incorpo'rated, representing Coast Communities Corporation, requesting an amendment to the Berkshire Lakes PUD for the purpose oF amending the Berkshire Lakes PUD regulations having the effect of adding the use of a self- storage center on the commercial tract located on the northwest corner of Davis Boulevard and '~Santa Barbara Boulevard together with additional development standards to enhance the appearance and compatibility of this type of commercial structures for property located on the northwest corner of the intersection of Davis Boulevard (C.R. 84) and Santa Barbara Boulevard in Section 32 and 33, Torres ~hip 49 South. P, ange 26 East and Section 5, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier Count),, Florida. consisting of 1093.9 acres, more or less. (Coordinator: Ron Nino) F. Petinon No. PUD-76-31(14), George L. Varnadoe of Young, vanAssenderp & Vamadoe, P.A.. representing WCI Communities Limited Partnership: Gulf Bay Land Investments, Inc., and Gulf Bay Land Holdings, Inc..: Parcel J-I Development, Inc.. and Quality Development, Inc.. requesting an amendment to the Pelican Bay PUD for the purpose of increasing the height of buildings on site specific portions of areas within the Pelican Bay PUD designated Group 4 from 200 feet to 250 feet above minimum floor areas established by law. (Coordinator: Ron Nino) (Continued Indefinite) G. Petition No. PUD-97-15, Blair A. Foley, P.E., of Coastal Engineering Consultants, Inc., representing George Vukobratovich, Trustee, requesting a rezone from "CF" Community Facility to "PUD" Planned Unit Development for a mixed commercial land use development strategy in a project titled Willow Park for property, located on the east side of Airport-Pulling Road south of Lone Oak Boulevard and immediately contiguous properly known as Princess Park in Section 1, Township 49 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida, containing 11.35 acres, more or less. (Coordinator: Ron Nino) (Continued to the meeting of December 18. 1997) lt. Report to the Collier County Planning Commission on a new Agreement for Affordable Housing Density Bonus and Imposing Covenants and Restrictions on Real Property for Saddlebrook Village PUD Ordinance 01-55. (Coordinator: GrcgMihalic) 8. OLD BUSINESS 9. NEW BUSINESS I0. DISCUSSION OF ADDENDA II. ADJOURN 12/4/97 CCPC AG ENDA/md 16G MINUTES OF TIIE PUBI. 1C VEIIICLE ADVISORY COMMITTEE DATI].: September 3, 1997 TIME: lO:00 PLACE: 2800N. IIORSESIIOE DR., NAPLES, FL CONFERENCE [/OOM"G" PVAC MEMBERS STAFF MEMBERS BAISLEY X PALMER .. X I.UGRIN X CRUZ X PEASE X BOLGAR X MINUTES BY: Maria Cruz, Code Enforcement Specialist C,.\t.t. ED TO ORDER AT: I0:10 A.M, ADJOURNED: 11:30 A,M. I'RESIDING: Patricia Bais]ey. Chairman 1. AI)DITIONS OR DELETIONS: Baislcv - questioned the appointment orthe new members and their affiliation with or without a vehicle for hire company. Ms. Cruz will contact Sue Filson for clarification. Mr. Pease requested nomination of Chairman and Vice Chairman be added under new business Ms. Cruz. requested two items under new business be removed at applicant's request and postponed until the December 3. 1997, meeting. Il, ,,\PPROVAL OF AGENI),,\: Motion made by Mr, Pease, seconded by Mr. Lugrin. carried unanimously. [1[...\PPROVA[. OF ,MINUTES: Motion made by Mr. Pease. seconded by Mr. Lugrin. carried unanimously. 'ry. NEW BUSINESS: Nomination of Chairman and Vice Chairman Motion was made by Mr. Pease to nominate Patricia Baisley as Chairman. seconded by Mr. Lugrin. carried unanimously Motion was made by Ms. Baisley to nominate Brian Pease as Vice-Chairman, seconded by Mr. Lugrin. carried unanimously. Medical Shultle. Inc.. d'b'a Sunshine Transportation Request [or approval to operate a charter service Application was reviewed and approved pending the following items be submitled and reviewed b,, the Board during their workshop scheduled for October I, 1997: a. Criminal Ilis~oo' background on S.[t. Friedman b. Credit Report on Business c. Vehicle's registration (',,'in ,",. _~7..,58) be classified "09". Motion made by Mr. Pease. seconded by Mr, Lugrin and carried unanimously. a~isc, torres: H,ncock /× Oate: I [0 Cons~;ant the ~/ .... ~Ol 16G 2 Minutes of I'.V.A.C. Bc, ard Meeting, September 3. 1997 Page 2 Sandra It. Fordley - d%/a AA 'rransponation P, cqucsl for approval to opcrale a charter service POSTPONED UNTIL 'FILE DECEMBER 3, 1997, MEETING. JoEllen Bates db'a Tropic Tours of Naples Request for approval Io operate a charier service I'OSTPONED UN'I'lL 'FILE DECEMBER 3. 1997, MEETING. Peggy A. Ncv, bcrry d'b'a Island. Airport Express Request for approval to operale a charier sec'ice Applicatic, n ',,.':ts reviev,'ed and approved, motion made by Mr. Lugrin. seconded by Mr. Pease. carried unanimously. Gabriel 'l'cjerina and Betty Lrejerinn d'b'a Caring for Kids Requcsl for approval to operate a char~er service. Application ,.,.'as rcviev,'cd and approved pending the following items be submiued to statTprior to issuance of certificate to operale: a. Criminal hislor5' background b. Insurance cenificale rcflecling both ,,'chicles listed on the ,.'chicle: list form. Motion made by ,",'lr. Pease. seconded by Mr. Lugrin. carried unanimously. .",Ir. Will:am P, olgar - re-opened nc,.,,' business after old business At Ihis t~me he read a letter dated August 15, 1997. addressed to Commissioners from Russ Baisley. Mr. Bolgar advised this board that Cod,: Enforcement Director. Linda Sullivan '.,,'as in the process of preparing a response to this letter. I. OLD BUSINESS: ?'.Ir. William Bolgar. Code Enforcement Supervisor. advised this Board of the results regarding Ihe complainl addressed by tile Board regarding a company by lhe name of Black Diamond providing transportation in Collier County ,,vithoul first oNaining the required certificate Io operate. Also. ,"dr. David S. Maglich, represemative for P, lack Diamond ',,,'as present. Mr. Maglich advised lhat Black Diamond is not a common carrier (transportation sen'ices) the.,,' stricdy provide transportation service for v.'orksman compensation. After an extensive discussion. Mr. Maglich advised thai hc would consult with his client (Black Diamond) in respect Io obtaining a certificate to operate from Collier Count.,,'. II. REPORTS: N,"A III. DISCUSSION: (Public Input) N/A The next meeting is tentatively scheduled for 10:00 a.m. on December 3. 1997. al 2800 N, Horseshoe Dr.. Naples. FL Conference Room "G". A work(sho~ is scheduled for Oclober I. 1997. Patricia Baisley, Chairman ~ · 166 2 MINUTES OF TIlE PUBI.IC VEtlICLE ADVISORY COMMI'I-I'EE "WORKS}lOP" I.)ATE: October I, 1997 TIME: 10:00 PLACE.: 2800 N. IIORSESIIOE DR., NAI'LES, FL CONFERENCE ROOM "G" I'VAC MEMBERS STAFF MEMBERS BAISLEY X PALMER X I..UGRIN X BOLGAR ,X PEASE X [:LEGAL X DOUGIIERTY X MINUTES BY: William Bolgar, Code Enforcement Supervisor CALI..ED TO ORDER AT: I0:00 A.M. ADJOURNED: ! i:30 A.M. I'RESIDING: Parr}cia [",aisle)', Chairman I. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS: Baisley - Presented ~wo new members, Mr. John Dougherty and Mr'. Clifford Flegal. Baislcy - Added to discuss phone book yellow pages advertisement. II. APPRO\'AL OF AGENDA:. III. APPRO\'AL OF MINUTES:. :v. NEW BUSINESS: V. OLD BUSINESS: Medical Shuttle. Inc., d'b'a Sunshine Transportation Board to review the followings: a. Criminal hisloo' background on S.tt. Friedman b. Credit Rcporl on Business c. Vehicle's registration (',,'in t: 537358) be classified "09". Informalion not provided to the Board for review - Motion made by Mr. Pease, seconded by Mr. Lugrin. m table issued to next regular meeting, carried unanimously. VI. REPORTS: NA VII. DISCUSSION: (Public Input) Enforcement assistance from the SheritTs Office to enforce ordinance No. 95-66 Baisley - Stated her husband contacted Sheriff }lunter and the CiD' of Naples Police Department concerning getting enforcing for Ordinance 95-66. He received a response from the S.O. which stated, the S.O. does not involve in the process of enforcing this ordinance, nor his staffis funded to assume the enforcement, inspection or recording keeping responsibilities in regard to Vehicle for }lire. }le further sta~ed that the Board has declared its all duties of all county and municipal code enforcing of'lScers to enforce the provisions of Chapter 142 of the Codes of Conduct and Laws and Ordinances pertaining to Vehicles for It}re. Further discussion ',,,'as held determining enforcement of subject ordinance more effectively, i.e.: · Add Vehicle R~r Fire ~o the Citation Ordinance · Ms. Baisley will supply with the High Schools homecoming dates and places for possible surveillance ·Compare the phone book yellow pages advertisements against licensee list. Contact non- licensees and obtain prices · Ms. Cruz to provide Mr. Palmer copy of last years notice of violation regarding advertisement VIII.The next meeting is tentatively scheduled for lO:00 a.m. on November 5, 1997, at 2800 N. ltorseshoe Dr.. Naples. FL. Conference Roo, l:n2C4~'. A workshop is scheduled for Oclober 1, 1907. Parr}cia Baisle¥, Chain'nan ,MINUTES OF TI IE PUBLIC VEl IICLE ADVISORY COMMI'FFEE DATE: November .~, 1997 TIME: I0:00 I'LACE: 2800N. tlORSESIIOE DR,, NAPLES, FL CONFERENCE ROOM"G" F'VAC MF. MRERS STAFF MEMBER?, BAISLEY × CRUZ X LUGRIN X BOLGAR X FLEGAL X MINUTES BY: Maria Cruz, Code Enforcement Specialis~ CAt. LED TO ORDER AT: 10:00 A.M, ADJOURNED: I I:00 A.M. PRESIDING: Patricia gaislcy, Chairman I. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS: II. APPROVAt. OF AGENDA: Motion made by Mr. Lugrin, seconded by Mr. Flcgal. carried unanimously. III. APPROVAI. OFMINUTES: NZA IV. NE\\' BUSINESS: Medical Shuttle. Inc.. d'b'a Sunshine Transportation Board to review and approve criminal histo~' backgrou~',d, business crcdit report. ,and rcgistralion classification. Board reviewed and approved thc above. Motion by Mr. Lugrin. seconded by Mr. Flcgal, carried unanimously. B. Beach and Island Cab - Change in Panncrship duc to panner deceased. It ,,',as requested for stag'to obtain the following: · Copy of death certificate or other document confirming same · Document describing set up and dissolution of pa~ncrship C. .,\A 'transportation - Request for reinstatement of Certificate to Operate Motion made by Mr. Lugrin, seconded by Mr. Flegal Io obtain opinion from Mr. Palmer, as to reissuing of certificate and associated fees. In addition, staff is to collec~., a new credit report, insurance certificate, and criminal history rcpom V. OLD BUSINESS: Mr. William gol~ar. Cod,: Enforcement Supervisor. informed the Board of sling operation results during cour; for not having proper Collier Count)' cenificams Io operate. VI. REPORTS: N/A VII. DISCUSSION: (Public Input) N/A The next meeting is tenlativeb' scheduled for I 0:00~a...~. on December 3, 1997, at 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, Ft.. Conference P, oom "G". Patricia Baisley, Chairman ' IMMOKALEE BEAUTIFICATION M.S.T.U. ADVISORY COMMITTEE 1 (3 ~ 2 Meeting of November 1997 , SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS AND MOTIONS: 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF OCTOBER 15th MEETING: Cherryle Thomas moved to accept the minutes as submitted; seconded by Rita Avalos and carried unanimously. 4. BUDGET UPDATE A. Copies of the budget status report for the period ending October 31, 1997 report were distributed and discussed. Rita Avalos moved to accept the budget as presented; seconded by Denise Smith and carried unanimously. 5. MAINTENANCE REPO2T 13. Chuck advised that the graveyard and additional 210' beyond 9th Street measures 5865 square feet; he noted the cemetery has a large flitch anti a tree needs robe removed. Clean up costs were estimated at $234 in addition to the cost for removing the tree. After a brief discussion Cherryle mad a motion authorizing the cleanup of the area and removal of the tree not to exceed $500; seconded by Rita Avalos and carried unanimously. 7. OFFICE OF CAPITAL PROJECTS MANAGEMENT REPORT B. There was some discussion regarding the $190,000 ISTEA grant. Mike McGee suggested utilizing the a,.varct for signalization at First St. and 29th, and First and Ninth Streets intersections. The funds will be awarded in 2003. The application will be revvorked to reflect this. Joe Delate noted that it may be possible to apply the fLinds to Phase III. Both he and Mike McGee recommended acceptance of the grant and to proceed with the project in the interim. Denise Smith matte a motion authorizing the acceptance of the ISTEA grant and to modify the original grant application as discussed; secondect by Rita Avalos and carried unanimously. t,:isc. Corres: Hancoc~ ',/ Date: Const~.t~ne ~/' Berry Copies To: Collier County Government Center · 3301 Tamiami Trail. East · Naples. Flodda 33962 IMMOKALEE BEAUTIFICATION M.S.T.U. ADVISORY COMMITTEE A ¢mta - Decelilber 17, 1997 1. Call to orcler 2. Attendance: Denise Smith, Committee Chair Rita Avalos, Committee Member/Past Chair Dorcas Howard, Committee Member Cherryle Thomas, Committee Member Steve Fabiano, Transportation Admin. Services Joe Delate, Office of Capital Projects Management Mike McGee, Landscape Architect Chuck Buckley, Landscape Maintenance Contractor 3. Welcome/Introduction of Guests 4. Approval of ,'Y/inures from November 19, 1997 5. Budget Update 6. Maintenance Report-CR 846 & SR 29: Chuck Buckley 7. Office of Capital Projects Management Report - Joe Delate 8. Old Busi~'~ess: A. B. C. 9. Tr,.lnsportation ,.~clministration Report/Update 10. Ne,.,., Business I 1. ©pen discussior~ oi'~ ,:'tl'~,',',v business not needing Committee approval 12. Next Meeting: January 21, 1998 - 5:00 p.m. ~ Immokalee Community Center Collier County G,)vcrnmentCenter · 33{)1 Tamit~miTrail. East · Naples. Florida339t~2 ' IMMOKALEE BEAUTIFICATION M.S.T.U. 1 0 G 2 ~ ADVISORY COMMITTEE Meettn, of November 19, 1997 I. The Inlmokalee Lighting and Beautification District Advisory Committee Meeting of Wednesday, November 19, 1997 ~vas called to order at 5:05 p.m. 2. ROLL CALL: Members present were Denise Smith, CherryteThomas, RitaAvalos, members. Also Present: Chuck Buckley, Commercial Land Maintenance; Steve Fabiano, Transportation Administrative Services; Joe Delate, Office of Capital Projects Management; Mike McGee, McGee & Associates; Jacqueline Silano, recording secretary. Excused Absence: Dorcas Howard, member. Guests: Cheryl Lewandowski, Main Street coorclinator; Mike Facundo, architect student, Florida Allantic University; Ann Olesky, Lake Trafford Task Force. 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF OCTOBER 15th MEETING: Cherryle Thomas moved to accept the minutes as submitted; seconded by Rita Avalos and carried ur~aninlously. 4. BUDGET UPDATE A. Copies of the budget status report for the period ending October 31, 1997 report ;vere distributed and discussed. Rita Avalos moved to accept the l)udgel as presented; seconded by Denise Smith and carried unanimously. B. Steve Fabiano provided copies of the Executive Summary requesting Board approval of tile contract for meclian and selected public area grounds mainter~ance for the Imnlokalee Beautification MSTU. 5. ,",,lAIN TENANCE REPORT A. Mr. Buckley reported that granulated l'ertilizer has been applied to the plants and furl'; the 200 replacement plants have been installed. B. Chuck advised that the graveyard and additional 210' beyoncl 9th Street measures 5865 square ieet; he notect the cemetery has a large ctitch and a tree needs to be removed. Clean up costs ,.',,'ere estimated at $234 in addition to the cost for removing the tree. After a brief discussion Cherryle mad a motion authorizing the c[eal'~Up of the area and removal of the tree r':ot to exceed $500; seconded by Rita Avalos and carried unanimously. 6. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT'S REPORT A. Mike McGee adviseci that some brickwork still needs to be clone. He cautioned Chuck to sta,.., on top of the dry conditions and to apply additional vvaterings as needed. Collier Cm.:nv,' G,'~vc,"r,,mcnt ('¢,',tcr · 3.t0l T:,mu:mi Tr;ul. East · N;~plcs. Fl~,rida 33962 7. OFFICE OF CAPITAL PROJECTS MANAGEMENT REPORT A. Joe Delale was pleased lo advise lhat as a result of lhe committee members efforts and several letters he had written to FDOT, he finally received the Joint Participation Agreement (]PAUS29 Light) from the FDOT so the MSTU's porlion of the project can go forward. The accompanying letter was received from W.H. Clark, Jr., District Contracts Attorney. The $100,000 from FDOT will be for streetlighting, which will be done at a later date. He advised that Mid-Continent Electric will extend their proposal for an additional 90 days (from November 3). B. There ,.',,'as some discussion regarding the $190,000 ISTEA grant. Mike McGee suggested utilizing the award for signalization at First St. and 29th, and First and Ninth Streets intersections. The funds will be awarded in 2003. The application ,,viii be reworked to reflect this. Joe Delate noted that it may be possible to apply the funds to Phase Iii. He also agreed with Mike McGee and recommended acceptance of the grant and to proceed with the project in the interim. Denise Smith made a motion authorizing the acceptance of the ISTEA grant and to modify the original grant application as discussed; seconded by Rita Avalos anti carriect unanimously. (Due re) an(}ti~er comrnitn'mr~t, Mike McGee left at 6:00 p.m.) Joe said it v,.,ould be the end of January when the project gets underway. After some discussion, Denise Smith stated that she would send a letter to the MPO, with copies to tl~e Commissioners, expressing the Committee's concerns regarding the application process which was not explainecl fully and had no set criteria evaluation procedure. C. Joe also advised that the permit to proceed with the landscaping for the Highway Beautification Grant ($78,000). 8. OLD BUSINESS A. Steve advised that ti~e new trash cans will be installed tt~is week. B. The Christmas banners ,,','ill he put Lip shortly. C. Steve said he is still waiting for the light parts from Lumac. 2, ..-., 16G 2 9. ADJOURNMENT ,'\s there was no further business to discuss, the meeting ,,,vas adjourned at 6:20 p.m. The next meeting ,,,,,,ill be held on December 17, 1997 at 5:00 p.m. at the Community Center. IMMOKALEE BEAUTIFICATION M.S.T.U. ADVISORY COMMITTEE ~" Meeting of october 997 SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS AND MOTIONS 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 17th MEETING: Cherryle Thomas moved to accept the minutes as submitted; seconded by Dorcas Howard and carried unanimously. 6. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT'S REPORT A. Mike McGee distributed copies of the Quarterly Maintenance Report which was reviewed. He recommended increasing the fertilization to four times a year using 20-20-20 with iron supplement and extending the maintenance beyond 9th Street to the north end of the existing sidewalk and perhaps also the cemetery. Chuck will work up the cost figures for next month's meeting. 8. OFFICE OF CAPITAL PROJECTS MANAGEMENT REPORT B. Copies of Mr. Delate's October 15 letter to Mr. Lovell, District Traffic Operations Engineer, FDOT, requesting reassurance of the lighting funding were distributed and discussed at length. Apparently the FDOT is now looking at the funding as a grant rather than a work project as originally designated. Mike McGee urged the members to appeal to any and all parties that would be able to help with this process and so that there would be no further delays. Steve noted that since the FDOI' was not able or willing to draft an agreement, he ,.,,,ill hold an inter-departmental meeting and develop an agreement. Joe noted that if permission is received soon, construction could get started by mid-December. Collier County Government Center · 3301 Tamiami Trail. East · Naples. Florida 33962 IMMOKALEE BEAUTIFICATION M.S.T.U. 1 (3 G 2 ADVISORY COMMITTEE ^d etlda - Novett ber 19, 1997 1. Call to order 2. Attendance: Denise Smith, Committee Chair Rita Avalos, Committee Member/Past Chair Dorcas Howard, Committee Member Cherryle Thomas, Committee Member Steve Fabiano, Transportation Admin. Services Joe Delate, Office of Capital Projects Management Mike McGee, Landscape Architect Chuck Buckley, Landscape Maintenance Contractor 3. Welcome/Introduction of Guests 4. Approval of Minutes from October 15, 1997 5. Budget Update 6. Maintenance Report-CR 846 &SR29: Chuck Buckley 7. Office of Capital Projects Management Report - Joe Delate 8. Old Business: A. B. C. 9. Transportation Administration Report/Update 10. New Business 11. Open discussion on a~y business not needing Committee approval 1 2. Adjournment Next Meeting: December 17, 1997-5:00p.m. @lmmokaleeCommunityCenter Collier County Government Center · a.01 Tamiami Trail. East · Naples. Florida 33962 IMMOKALEE BEAUTIFICATION M.S.T.U. 1 6 G 2 ADVISORY COMMITTEE Meeting of October 15, 1997 1. The Immokalee Lighting and Beautification District Advisory Committee Meeting of Wednesday, October 15, 1997 was called to order at 5:05 p.m. 2. ROLL CALL: Members present were Denise Smith, Cherryle Thomas, Dorcas Howard, members. Also Present: Chuck Buckley, Commercial Land Maintenance; Steve Fabiano, Transportation Administrative Services; Joe Delate, Office of Capital Projects Management; Mike McGee, McGee & Associates; Jacqueline Silano, recording secretary. Excused Absence: Rita Avalos, member. 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 17th MEETING: Cherryle Thomas moved to accept the minutes as submitted; seconded by Dorcas Howard and carried unanimously. 4. BUDGET UPDATE A. The budget stat'us report for the period ending September 30, 1997 and the status report for the new fiscal year, starting October 1, were distributed and discussed. B. Joe Delate will prepare a budget amendment to rollover the carry forward in Improvements General, project #68063 in the amount of $421,835.00 as reflected in the September budget statement. These are funds that were obligated to the project that were not activated. 5. MAINTENANCE REPORT A. Mr. Buckley reported that the turf and ornamentals have been sprayed and treated with 20-20-20 fertilizer with an iron supplement on specific plants; the plant replacement list has been complied; he has received a 90 day contract extension from the Purchasing Department. 6. LANDSCAPEARCHITECT'S REPORT A. Mike McGee distributed copies of the Quarterly Maintenance Report which ,.','as reviewed. He recommended increasing the fertilization to four times a year using 20-20-20 with iron supplement and extending the maintenance beyond 9th Street to the north end of the existing sidewalk and perhaps also the cemetery. Chuck will work up the cost figures for next month's meeting. Collier County Government (:enter · 3301 Tamiami Trail. East · Naples. Florida 33962 · 16G 7. OLD BUSINESS A. Steve advised that the new trash cans have finally been delivered to the County Barn. B. Steve is waiting for quotes regarding the street sweeping which are due by Friday, October 17. 8. OFFICE OF CAPITAL PROJECTS MANAGEMENT REPORT A. Joe Delate distributed copies of his memorandum to Mitch Momtaz, Interim Senior Project Manager regarding Phase II, subphase A, and copies of Mid- Continent Electric's proposal. B. Copies of Mr. Delate's October 15 letter to Mr. Lovell, District Traffic Operations Engineer, FDOT, requesting reassurance of the lighting funding were distributed and discussed at length. Apparently the FDOT is now looking at the funding as a grant rather than a work project as originally designated. Mike McGee urged the members to appeal to any and all parties that would be able to help with this process and so that there would be no further delays. Steve noted that since the FDOT was not able or willing to draft an agreement, he will hold an inter-departmental meeting and develop an agreement. Joe noted that if permission is received soon, construction could get started by mid-December. 9. ADJOURNMENT As there ,.',,'as no further business to discuss, the meeting was adjourned at 6:30 p.m. The next meeting will be held on November 19, 1997 at 5:00 p.m. at the Community Center. 2 AGENDA I ' '~ ~,!' ' COLLIER COUNTY HISTORICAL/ARCHAEOLOGICAL PRESERVATION BOA3~D WILL MEET AT 5:30 P.M., THURSDAY, DECEMBER 11, 1997, AT 2355 TAMIAMI TRAIL NAPLES, FLORIDA: NOTE: ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. ALL MATERIAL USED IN PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE HAPB WILL BECOME A PERMA~NENT PART OF THE RECORD. THESE MATERIALS WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. 1. ADDENDA TO THE AGENDA 2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: November 14, 1997 3. PLA/TNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT REPORT: A. Archaeological Training For County Staff 4. OLD BUSINESS: A. Historic Designation of the Morris Property Archaeological Site B. H. Nehrling's Tropical Gardens and Arboretum C. Captain Horr's House National Register Ceremony D. Historic/Archaeological Guide Map 5. NEW BUSINESS: A. Building Department Procedures B. Role and Responsibilities of The Collier County Preservation Board. 6. DISCUSSION OF ADDENDA 7 ADJOURN i~..~/~/~~ H I STOR I CAL AG E~A/md ~ ~ ~:~ _ tL:, i /~, ~, Hanc~ ----~-':"~--- .... C~stanttne ~--" 16G 2 MARCO ISLAND BEACH RENOURISHMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE AGENDA WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 3, 1997 - l:30P.M. FRANK E. HACKLE PARK 1. Call to Order 2. Approval of Minutes - November 5th meeting 3. Beach Cleaning Schedules - purchase of second machine - beach tilling - instructions re: shell removal Collier County Ordinance 189-11 - schedule for buoy installation 5 Hideavay Beach T-Groin installation additional T-Groins 6 Videotape presentation of beach - Harris 7 Caxambas Boat Docks project's 8 Capri Pass Inlet Management Plan - BCC hearing 11/25 9 Old business 10. New business 11. Public Comment 12. Adjourn till January 7, 1997 16G 2 MARCO ISLAND BEACH RENOURISHMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE MINUTES - NOVEMBER 5, 1997 The Meeting vas called to order at 9:00 a.m. by Frank Blanchard, Chairperson. Members present were Giles Goral, Barbara ~Schfering, Joe Christy, John Dougherty, Buddy Harris, Gil Scholes and Mike Gl[me. Also present were Harry Huber, Collier County Capital Projects; Pat Berry, The Bottom Line. Blanchard announced that Charles }[uttinger was forced to vacate his seat on the advisory committee due to a law which prohibits his serving on Collier County Advisory Committee's while running for office. }{uttinger can re-apply for the position if he chooses. A HOTION was made by Glime, seconded by Christy to approve the minutes of the October 1st meeting as presented. Motion carried. Huber reported that authorization has been given to purchase the new beach cleaning machine and tractor. [{uber will begin the bid process. The removal of shell is a continuing problem. The shell is currently being dumped at the landfill. Huber will continue to look at other options for use of the shells, such as Better Roads. Huber will contact Mac Hatcher, National Resources Dept., on the progress of the installation of the off-shore buoys per Ordinance 189-1]. Huber reported that the T-Groin installation at Hideaway Beach is completed. "Keep Off" signs are scheduled for installation on the existing pilings the following week. A MOTION was made by Gl[me, seconded by Goral to pursue the required engineering and permitting to Install additional T-Groins at the east end of Hideaway when and if they are required. Motion carried. Huber will discuss with Ken Humiston. Harris presented an aerial videotape of the beach taken by the Civil Air Patrol on October 28, 1997, 5:56p.m., at high tide. The video shoved the success of the T-Groin installation at Hideaway Beach. Blanchard discussed several applications for boat slips. Dele Park Place Condominium has applied for four docks while the Mirage has applied for 16 boat slips. A Planning Commission will be established by the new City of Marco Island to address all these issues. The City Council will have final approval on all zoning matters. [t vas suggested that the Beach Renourishment Advisory Committee make a recommendation to the City regarding this Issue. This will be further discussed at the December meeting. Huber reported that November 25th is the scheduled date for the Capri Pass Inlet Hanagement Plan to appear on the Collier County Board of Commissioners agenda. Any additional recommendations will be at that time. Blanchard reported on the October 30th workshop. There were several objections to filling in t:he Sand Dollar Island/Tigertai] area. A MOTION was made by Gllme, seconded by Christy to approve the Inlet Management Plan in total. Motion carried. I III IIII ...... ]1111 ii ii !11 168 2 Marco Island Beach Renourishment Advisory Committee Minutes - November 5, 1997 Page Two Due to the increase in drownings in Marco Island tn 1997, It was recommended that the Beach Renourishment Advisory Committee urge the County Commissioners to address this issue. A meeting will be scheduled with Ann Lazar, DEP; f{ark Robson, Florida Game Commission; Ken I{um[ston and Brett Moore, Humiston and Moore; Frank Blanchard, Beach Advisory Committee; and }larry }{uber, Collier County. All agreed on the urgency of this matter. A MOTION was made by Harris, seconded by Goral to endorse a task force for the purpose of addressing the Immediate life saving issue at the Sand Dollar/Tigertail area. Motion carried. Blanchard announced a meeting of the Florida Shore and Beach Preservation, on February 4-6, at St. Petersburg, Florida. A question was raised by Harris regarding the study of the T-Groins at }lldeaway Beach. Huber stated that there would be studies completed every six months for three to four years. The studies will also address alternates for future installations. The future of the Advisory Committee was discussed. The new City Council may abolish the existing MSTU and re-establish under the City Council. As there vas no further business to discuss the meeting adjourned at 10:15. Respectfully submitted by The Bottom Line. / qe;ttt, l - ,vteeti of December 12, 1997 ........... ...";. 1. Meeting called to order 2. AHendance 3. Approval of minutes of November 14, 1997 4. Reports A. Aclvanced Lawn & Landscape B. Transportation Administrative Services C. New Construction i. .Mike McGee, McGee & Associates D. Committee Members i. George Pearson ii. Al LePain iii. Robert Cole iv. Robert Weyers 5. Old Business 6. New Business 7. Adjournment A/art ~ ,./f t.'; ..... //' "~.'.:'~ck '~~- ,. :~t;. t, or/~.s: , ,~nr,~ ie - ~ NEXT MEETING: January9, 1998 C0O;~ssl0: 2 Lely Go ' £stntes Bea ltificatio Advisory co, , ittee - Meeth qf Nove lber lat, 1997 1. Meeting called to order at 4:00 p.m. 2. Location -Facilities Management, Conference Room 111. 3. Attendance Taken - Present: George Pearson, Al LePain, Robert Cole, Robert Weyers, members; Steve Fabiano, Transportation Administrative Services; Mike McGee, McGee & Associates; Jeff Koetting, Advanced Lawn and Landscaping; Jacqueline Silano, secretary. 4. Minutes of October 10, 1997: Bob Cole moved to accept the minutes as presented; seconded by Al LePain and carried unanimously. 5. LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE REPORT A. Jeff advised that he has contacted Tim Confoy about a coupie of irrigation breaks and a valve cover; the crab grass has been sprayed with Round-up and will be re-sodded by next week. B. Jeff supplied a copy of Top Notch's schedule to Mike McGee and Steve Fabiano. Mike McGee has met with Jeff and Ed Cassidy of Top Notch and he advised that their contract is for the minimum standards. He has advised Advanced Lawn and Landscaping that when additional spraying is needed, it should be done as a preventative measure. C. Mike McGee advised Jeff to prune the shrubs at Doral Circle; Steve indicated that the swale area by the bridge and the bus stop area need to be cleaned up. D. Steve Fabiano will coordinate the mulching with Jeff. 6. TRANSPORTATION SERVICES REPORT A. Copies of the Budget Status for the period ending October 31 were distributed and reviewed. Steve Fabiano will go to the Board to recognize the S31,700 in reserves for capital outlay which will be used for the effluent line, replacement plantings and removal of the monument at Baltusrol. B. Steve will obtain an estimate from E.B. Simmonds to replace the vandalized lights. 16G 2 7. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT'S REPORT A. Mike McGee reported that on November 4 he re-faxed the information regarding the pump and requirements for the effluent line prepared by Hole Montez to Tim Clemmons. George Pearson has met with Mr. Clemmons and he agreed to do the work. George has since followed up with a couple of phone calls and is still awaiting a reply. Steve will check to see if the Utilities Department can do the jack and bore work. B. Mike will see what will be required to add the Pebble Beach section to the effluent line. 8. COMMITTEE REPORTS A. George Pearson will send a letter to the Lely Civic Association requesting that their group repair the entrance signs at U.S. 41. B. Al LePain suggested including the pothole problems in the letter to the Civic Association, As there was no further business to discuss, the meeting was adjourned at 5:05 p.m. The next meeting has been scheduled for December 12, 1997, at 4:00 p.m., Facilities Management, Conference Room 111. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS AND MOTIONS: 4. Minutes of October 10, 1997: Bob Cole moved to accept the minutes as presented; seconded by Al LePain and carried unanimously. 16G 2 NATURAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34102 941-434-4655 FAX 941-434-3059 SUNCOM 974-4655 NOTIOE OF PUBLIC MEETING The Beach Renourishment/Maintenance Committee announces a public meeting to which all interested persons are invited. Tnursday 04 December 1997 DATE: TIME: 9:00 A.M. PLACE: City Council Chambers, 735 Eighth Street South, Naples, Florida 34102 AGENDA 1. Roll Call. 2. Consideration of a approval of the minutes of the 06 November meeting. 3. Consideration of an application for tourist tax funds for post-construction monitoring of the Collier County Beach Restoration Project. 4. TDC beach/inlet management bUdget spreadsheet, if modified. 5. TDC funding application guidelines, if finalized. 6. Coastal Resource Restoration program. 7. Project updates: A) South Channel/Water Turkey Bay; B) Wiggins Pass dredging; C) dune revegetation; D) upland sand stockpiling; E) rock removal. 8. Discussion of potential for revising committee membership structure. 9. Presentation by Mr. Bill Boggess regarding rock removal and funding for inlet and interior wate.r~.ay work. 10. Agenda for next meeting, 08 January 1998. 11. Open public input. 12. Adjourn. royAL ACTION ~ BE T^~EN ON WY ITE. DISCUSSED OR ^DDED TO T.ZS ~E.DX. WY ~ERSO. WY ~ECISIO. ~DS ~ ~.IS CO~I~T£E .IT~ ~ESPECT TO A~Y ~TTS~ CONSIDERED ^T T. IS .£DTZ.~ .IL~ N££n ^ ~ECO~D OF THE PR~EEDINGS ~D ~Y NEED TO ENSURE T~T A VERBATIM RECORD IS ~DE, ~XCH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY ~D EVIDENCE UPON ~ICN THE ^PPF. kL IS TO BE HE~D. WY PERSON WITH A DISABILITY AU×ILI~Y AIDS ~D SERVICES FOR THIS MEETING ~Y C~L THE CITY CL£RK*$ O£FXC: AT 434-470! ~XTH REQUESTS AT LEAST TWO BUSINESS DAYS BEFORE THE MEETING DATE. For additional ±n~o~uat±on, please contact Jori Staiger at 434- ~~. . ~isc. Cortes: ~ ' 'L Norr,,'' Natural Resources~ Manager Hancock ' /-':"-'" Item,, Constantine_~v/ / _ Mac'KlO /' '~-' AGENDA NO'~ 6 ~']~? COLLIER COUNTY PI.ANNING COMMISSION WILL MEET AT 5:05 P.M., THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 13. 19')7 IN TItE BOAP, D OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING ROOM, ADMINISTRATION BtJILDING. COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER, 3301 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, EAST NAI'LES. Ft. ORIDA: NOTE:.,NNY PERSON WHO DECIDED TO APPEAL A DECISION OF TttIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE TI-tA'F A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE. WI-IICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDEN('E UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. ALI. MATE. RIAL USED IN PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE CCPC ',\:ILL BECOME A PERMANENT PART OF THE RECORD. THESE MATERIAI.S \VII_L BE AVAILABLE FOR PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD ()F COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. 1. ROLL CALL B'f ('LERK 2. ADDENDA TO file AGENDA 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: 4. PLANNING CO..",.IMISSION ABSENCES: 5. BCC REPORT 6. CHAIRMAN'S R t-:PORT 7. ADVERTISED Pt :BLIC }'tEARINGS: A. .lulv 19<)7 ('>'cle LDC Amendments 8. OLD BUSINESS 9. NEW BUSINESS 10. DISCUSSION OI': ADDENDA ~- 1 1. ,ADJOURN I 1/13/97 ccpc AGENDA/md Hancoc~ C~stant ~ne ~' Ct,;,;~: lc'. 1 N0¥ 1§97 AGENDA !~oard of Cr',.r.~, ~ ,,'~,.; EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES ADVISORY COUNCIL (EMSAC) INFORMAL MINUTES October 15, 1997 2:00 p.m. EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES HEADQUARTERS 3301 EAST TAMIAMI TRAIL Council Members' Bob Laird EXCUSED MEMBERS: Palma Fuson Gary Young Mike Davis Bob Schank Gary Young Fay Biles Bob Schank Roger Evans Paul Gunther-Mohr Sheldon Reed Palma Fuson Others: Leo Ochs Jeff Page Joan Young (.,u;;~;:~ i,~: The regular monthly meeting of the Collier County, EMSAC committee was called to order at 2:00 P.M. on Wednesday, October 15, 1997 by Bob Laird, Chairman. In the absence of vacationing Barbara Brown, Joan Young took minutes for the meeting. OLD BUSINESS: Bob Laird wanted a :.orrection made to last months minutes. Under "New Business", paragraph 6 on page 3 of the minutes, with reference to the Productivity Committec, and 80% of complaints ....... it should have read "95%". Also, Leo Ochs clarified for Roger Evans, the verbiage between paragra2h 3 and paragraph 7 of~,p,,age 3. Leo said that his statement was based on getting l~orrts Hancock Constant the l~ac 'K t e Berry the information from Medicare as early as November, but that he had no problem with Fay Biles motion to table the fee schedule discussion until the December meeting. Fay Biles brought up the subject of ambulance fees in relation to the City of Marco Island and their emergency services. Two of the candidates for Marco Island City Council said, at an open meeting with about 900 Marco Island residents present, that ambulance bills were exorbitant and that the fire department could do it much cheaper than EMS. She commented that she wondered where they got their information. A short discussion followed. There were no other corrections to the minutes or discussions with reference to last months minutes. The minutes were approved. NEW BUSINESS: Jeff Page gave the following repod: The new EMS station #16 is in place and functioning and going very well. Only one minor problem arose. A new refrigerator was placed in the EMS quarters but the firefighters on duty thought it was theirs and proceeded to move all food out and their food in and told EMS colleagues not to use it. Their fire chief explained the situation to them, problem solved. There were no other incidents. MOU discussed. North Naples fire commission has approved signing the MOU with some stipulations, one being that the price not go over $25,000 and that EMS provide an accounting as to where the monies are going. AT East Naples commission meeting there was not much progress. Jeff has been dealing with Rob Pottiger. They are have some problems with the cost and some of the firefighters are Opposed as well. Jeff's impression is that it will not be an easy transition but it will happen. Jeff feels that ultimately Golden Gate Fire District will go along with the MOU but now there are some challenges with their fire commissioners. There were some difficulties with the district 1 contract but these problems were worked out. Each of the districts feel they could get it done for less money. They feel they can get people to instruct their firefighters in emergency medicine as far as responding to calls. Data Collection. Jeff said that the processing is going very well. This involves the crews electronically sending run report information and it being downloaded at building t4, then further downloaded to the DOR. This process should be started the week of October 20th, 1997 and will involve only a few satellite stations to begin with to work out any "bugs" that the system may have. It is 16G 2 possible to be on line as soon as November if the system continues to progress as it is now doing. Consumer Issues. There were only two consumer issues this past month. One being a trauma patient, motor vehicle accident, found unconscious, severely injured. Paramedics had to cut away her pants. Pants were inadvertently left at the scene and apparently there was money in one of the pockets. This particular piece of clothing was contaminated and should have been bagged and transported with the patient to the hospital. No one knows where this piece of clothing went. The Paramedics involved were spoken to and were reminded that the clothing should be transported with the patient in these situations. The other issue involved a stroke victim. She was transported to North Collier Hospital, which was the appropriate destination as it was the closest facility. A few days later she was transported to Naples Community Hospital and was upset that she wasn't taken there first. The problem came when a doctor at North Collier Hospital agreed that she should have gone directly to Naples Community Hospital as the rehab is there. A copy of the transport protocol was faxed to the patient and Jorge Aguilera, Training Commander, contacted Dr. Taylor at North Collier with a reminder of what our transport protocol is. Leo Ochs referenced Isles of Capri and their desire to have East Naples Fire manage their fire calls. This issue will go before the County Commissioners at the October 28, 1997 meeting. More details at the next EMSAC meeting. Jeff Page passed out copies of a Naples Daily News articles about the defibrillators being placed in public locations around the county and the move into North Naples Fire Station 43, near Bonita. Everyone agreed that this is a very good idea. Roger Evans suggested that perhaps is would be possible to get a joint grant with his department and EMS on the automatic defibrillators. Bob Laird brought up the point that there should have been an election of officers at this EMSAC meeting. After a few minutes discussion, it was decided that this election would be postponed until next month's meeting in hopes that more members would be present. November's meeting was discussed. Bob Laird suggested that November's meeting date be changed to Thursday, November 20th as Diane Flagg will be out of town for the next 5 or 6 Wednesday's. Everyone agreed that this would be a good date. The November meeting will be: 'thursday, November 20, 1997. The subject of December's me:~ting came up, as it will fall around the holiday, it was decided that this issue will be dealt with at the November meeting. 16G 2 Motion made and seconded that meeting be adjourned, Meeting was adjourned. Respectfully Submitted By Joan Young ...., ,.._,.. 2 ~inut~s - ~ee~ing o~ Ootober ]4, ~ 997 SUMMARY OF MOTIONS AND ~ECOMMENDATIONS 3. ~inutes to the meeting of September 9, 1997: Bonner Bacon moved to accept the minutes as submitted; seconded by Chuck McMahon and carried unanimouslv. 5. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT'S ~EPO~T B. Mike McGee recommended that an additional fertilization be added to the program (four applications), using 20-20-20 with an iron supplement. Fertilization will ~ake place in November, March, June, and August. C. Mike recommended plantin9 annuals at the west end siDn. Chuck made a motion authorizing the expenditure of up to ~250 for annuals; seconded by Bonnet Bacon and carried unanimously. 6. TRANSPORTATION ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES C. There was a discussion reBardin9 future 50/50 maintenance; a presentation will be made to the Board of County Commissioners. Mark Houghton made a motion authorizinD Steve Fabiano to prepare a draft of the Executive Summary regarding Phase I (C.R. 951), 50/50 lundin9, and the assumption of maintenance by the County upon completion; seconded by Bonner Bacon and carried unanimously. Misc. Cortes: ,/!/" Date: Morrts ~_ Hancock ./' [(._~ ~ Constantine Jt~al/~ . M~C 'K t e ~err~ ...... /¥~ Copies To; 16~ 2 Golden Gate Beautification vtsory Committee A,~e~da - November 11, 1997 1. Meeting called to order 2. Roll Call 3. Approval of Minutes - Meeting of October 14, 1997 4: Landscape Maintenance Report - Chuck Buckley 5. Landscape Architect's Report - Mike McGee 6. Transportation Administration Services Report A. Steve Fabiano B. Val Prince 7. Committee Members' Reports 8. Old Business 9. New Business 1 0. Public Comments 11. Adjournment Next Meeting: December 10, 1997, 4:00 p.m. @ Golden Gate Community Center · 16G 2 Golden Gate Beautification AdvisOry cotnmtttee Minutes - Meeting of October 14, 1997 ~ 1. Meeting called to order at 4:05 p.m. at the Golden Gate Community Center. 2. Roll Call-Present: CheryleNewman, BonnerBacon, CharlesMcMahon, Mark Houghton (4:30), members; Val Prince and Steve Fabiano, Transportation Administrative Services; Mike McGee, McGee & Associates; Jacqueline Silano, secretary; Chuck Buckley, Commercial Land Maintenance. Excused Absence: Sabina Musci. 3. Minutes to the meeting of September 9, 1997: Bonner Bacon moved to accept the minutes as submitted; seconded by Chuck McMahon and carried unanimously. 4. LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE REPORT A. Chuck Buckley reported that the installation of the replacement plants has been completed; fertilization of the plants and turf will take place this month; pump 3 tripped out again; he repaired some damaged sprinkler heads. B. Steve Fabiano will have E.B. Simmonds check the amperage in pump 3 since that pump was recently replaced. 5. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT'S REPORT A. Mike McGee requested that the 14 new trees be braced; Steve will provide the stakes. Mike noted that the oaks came in 50% defoliated and will need additional watering. B. Mike recommended that an additional fertilization be added to the program (four applications), using 20-20-20 with an iron supplement. Fertilization will take place in November, March, June, and August. C. Mike recommended planting annuals at the west end sign. Chuck made a motion authorizing the expenditure of up to $250 for annuals; seconded by Bonner Bacon and carried unanimously. 6. TRANSPORTATION ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES A. Copies of the Budget Status through September, 1997 were distributed and reviewed. The newly adopted budget statement for 1997-98 was also distributed and reviewed. Revisions will be mado as needed. ...... "' ............ -I ...................... Il II'l .......... ~ "l · - 2 B. Steve noted that Val Prince will be attendincj future meetings since the maintenance of ~he medians hms been picked up by ~he County {~und 104). C. There was a discussion regarding future 50/50 maintenance; a presentation will be made to the Board of County Commissioners. Mark Houghton made a motion authorizing Steve Fabiano to prepare a draft of the Executive Summary regarding Phase I (C.R. 951), 50/50 funding, and the assumption of maintenance by the County upon completion; seconded by Bonner Bacon and carried unanimously. 7. OLD BUSINESS A. Since the Master Plans have not yet been returned, Mark will send letters to the Commissioners requesting them. 8. NEW BUSINESS A. Bonner requested that the lighting on the sign at C.R. 951 be moved in closerto increase the illumination. Steve will take care of it. B. There is an opening on the Pathway Advisory Committee; Mark Houghton will apply. C. There was a lengthy discussion regarding the Christmas lights; Cheryle will be in contact with the Chamber of Commerce and Civic Association to try to coordinate the decorating. D. At next month's meeting, Chuck Buckley will provide a quotation for basic maintenance (mowing, edging, trash pickup) of the remaining medians in Golden Gate. 9. OTHER BUSINESS A. Cheryle advised that Russ Mueller of Transportation Services claims that Mr. McGee is not qualified to review the designs for the proposed bus stop shelters since he is a "landscape" architect. Mike requested that this be put into writing; Cheryle will contact Mr. Bobanick. As there was no further business to discuss, the meeting was adjourned at 6:12 p.m. The next meeting will be held at 4:00 p.m. on Tuesday, November 11, 1997 at the Golden Gate Community Center. RECEIVED ~/ / C ~ DEC 12 1997 ~x~/ f-....,, ac_ (~o/~ c.[:,.,c..~ ,.,; ~;ou~,r.~ COLLIER COUN'I'YTAX COLLECTOR ~ comm. rec'd cop/ COU~OU~E · BLDG. C-1 NAPLES, ¢LOR~DA 34112-4997 December 10, 1997 Honorable Timothy Hancock, Chairman Board of County Commissioners Collier County Courthouse - Admin. Bldg/3 Naples, Florida 34112 Dear Mr. Hancock: For your information, this date we have made a distribution of Current Ad Valorem Tax and Non-Ad Valorem Assessment to the Board of County Commissioners, alter Tax Collector's commissions, as follows: County Wide $32,388,319.67 Dependent District 9,730,193.86 Solid Waste .2~847~981.43 Grand Total $44.966,494.96 Attached you will find a distribution recap showing year to date totals of taxes collected net of discount for 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996 and 1997. Yours respectfially submittefl. TJ Mic_)(ael A. Welsh, Controlle_r, 1ier County Tax Collector s Office / b,L,kW/pld encl. cc: Hon. Timothy J. Constantine Hon. Barbara Berry Hon. John Norris Hon. Pamela Mac'Kie Mr. Robert F. Fernandez, County Administrator Hon. Guy L. Carlton, Tax Collector Mr. Claude A. Haynes, Deputy Tax Collector Mrs. Marilyn Lewis, Property Tax Dept. Director 16G 2