BCC Minutes 05/08/1990 R Naples, Florida, May 8, 1990
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Board of County Commissioners in
and for the County of Collier, and also acting as the Board of Zoning
Appeals and as the governing board(s) of such special districts as
have been created according to /aw and having conducted business
herein, met on this date at 9:00 A.M. in REGULAR SESSION in Building
."F" of the Government Complex, East Naples, Florida, with the
following members present:
CHAIRMAN: Max A. Hasse, Jr.
VICE-CHAIRMAN: Michael J. Volpe
Burr L. Saunders
Anne Goodnight
ABSENT: Richard S, Shanahan
ALSO PRESENT: James C. Giles, Clerk; John ¥onkosky, Finance
Director; Harriet Beech and Ellie Hoffman, Deputy Clerks; Neil
Dorrtll, County Manager; Tom Olliff, Assistant to County Manager; Ken
Cuyler, County Attorney; George Archibald, Transportation Services
Administrator; James Reardon, Emergency Services Administrator;
Kimberly Polen, Project Review Services; Frank Brutt, Community
Development Services Administrator; William Lorenz, Environmental
Services Administrator; Robert Mu/here, Raymond Bellows and Philip
"Scheff, Planners; Sal Gardino, Director of Mediation/Arbitration; Sue
Fllson, Administrative Assistant to the Board; and Byron TomlJnson,
Sheriff's Office.
Page
Nay 8, 1990
eeeee Comtieelonar Shinihen absent mm ra£1ected in 4/0 votaa
T~pe #!
~em #3
~GIJFDA AND CONSENT AGENDA - APPROVED NITH CHANGES
Commissioner aoodnlght Roved, meconded by Comulootoner Volpe and
carried 4/0, that tho agenda end consent agenda be approved M/th tho
following changes:
2e
Item 5C - Recommendation to proc/aim May 9 as Miami
City Ballet Nutcracker Day - Added
Item 12B - Permission to issue Special Events Permit for the
Christ le the Answer Revival to be conducted in Naples -
Added
Item /OF - moved to Item 6C7 re Ordinance amending Ordinance
No. 87-9! as relates to Court Mediation and Arbitration
Services.
7e
Item 6B! - Petition R-89-28 requesting a rezone from A-2 to
PUD to be known as Brentwood PUD - Continued until May 15.
Item 6B5 - Petition PDA-89-13 requesting amendment to Point
Marco - Continued until May 22.
Item 7Al - Petition A-90-2 R & L Developments of Marco re
administrative appeal of decision regarding site preparation
prior to four-laning of S.R. 951 - Continued until May
Item 6B2 - Petition R-90-§, requesting a rezone from A-2 to
PUD for affordable housing to be known as Arbor Lake Club
PUD - Continued to May
Item 6B3 - Petition R-90-15, requesting a rezone from A-1MH
to "I" Industrial for property north of Immokalee Airport -
Continued to May 15.
Item 6B4 - Petition R-90-3, Immokalee Habitat for Humanity,
Inc. requesting a rezone from RMF-6 to RSF-§ for property
on the east side of 9th Street, Immokalee - Continued to May
22.
10.
12.
13.
Item 6C3 - Petition AV 89-029, requesting vacation of al/
public interests in certain rights-of-way in the Vineyards
development - Continued to May 15.
Item 6C4 - Petition SMP-90-1, requesting Subdivision Master
Plan approval for Woodlake South Mobile Home Subdivision -
Continued to May 15.
Item 6C6 - Petition SMP-90-4, requesting Subdivision Master
Plan approval for "Mission Village" in Immokalee - Continued
to May 22.
Item 14A8, final plat of "Park Place West Subdivision,,, moved
to 9Al at request of Commissioner Volpe.
MINUTES OF SPECIAL MEETING OF MARCH 21, 1090, RKGULARMEKTXNG OF MARCH
2....~..g._~990, AND SPKCIAL MF_~TING OF APRIL 2f 1990 - APPROVED
Page 2
May 8, 1990
Comlssloner Goodnlght ~oved, seconded by Comtssloner S&unders,
and carried 4/0, that the minutes of the Special Nesting of ~ch
the ~1~ ~tlng of ~rch iT ~d the S~ctal ~ettng of April
1990 ~ a~r~d ~ presented.
Xtem
· NPLOY~ 8~VXCE WARDS - PI~S~NTED TO WXLLX~ A. EDGAR AND J0~ B.
RALL
Commissioner Hasse presented Employee Service Awards to William
A. Edgar and John B. Hall of Facilities Management for 10 years of
service with Collier County.
Item #51
PROCLANATION D~SXGNATXNG NAY 8 1990, AS BILL PRICB DAY IN COLLIER
Commissioner Goodnlght read a Proclamation designating May 8,
1990, as "Bill Price Day" tn Collier County and presented same to Mr.
Bill Price, retired Chairman of the First Bank of Immokalee tn
recognition of Mr. Price's contributions to the community of Immokalee
and for his assistance to the county's farmers In times of need.
Co~lsslonsr Ooodnlght ~ovsd, seconded by Co~isetonsr Volpe and
carried 4/0, that the proclamation designating Nay 8, 1990, as Bill
Price Day in Collier County be adopted.
Mr. David Borden read and presented a Proclamation on behalf of
the Collier County Housing Authority, lauding Mr. Bill Price for his
work on behalf of the Farm Workers Village In Immokalee.
Page 3
May 8, ]990
,~m,.PR~TION DISXGRATING MAY 9, 1990, AS THE NZAMX CXTY BALLET
Commissioner Volpe read a Proclamation designating May 9, 1990, as
"The Miami City Ballet Nutcracker Day" and presented It to Mrs. Myra
Daniels recognizing the establ/shment of the M/ami City Ba/let and the
Introduction of neoclassical dance to Florida, and Its achievement of
national and /nternattonal acclaim in four short years; and tn
recognition of Its premier performance of the "Nutcracker Suite" to be
held in Naples this coming autumn.
CO"~tllJOnlr VoIpt Ged, elconded by COU~leionlr Ooodntght and
carried 4/0, that the proclmtlon deeLgnating May 9, 1990, as "The
Mi&mi City Ballet Nutcracker Day", be adopted.
Page 4
May 8, 1990
R~OLUTIOI 90-245 RE PETITION $MP-90-5, ROBERT CA~TER REPRESERTIRG
C&VALZ~ D~VHLOFI~RT COR~TZOR, FOR S~DZVZSZOR ~9TKR P~ APPROVAF.
~R ~~ KSTA~S - ~KD Ml~ STX~TZORS
Legal notice having been published tn the Naples Daily News on
April 22, ~990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication fi/ed with
the Clerk, public hearing was opened to consider Petition SMP 90-5,
fi/ed by Robert Carter, representing Cavalier Development Corporation,
requeskln~ an resolution approving a Subdivision Master Plan approval
for Baycourt Estates, a subdivision contain~n~ 5.8~ acres more or less
in Section ~5, To.ship 52 South, Range 26 EasT, Collier County,
Florida.
Planner Ray Bellows discussed the background for this Petition,
saying that staff has reviewed this petition and found the SMP to be
in compliance with the Subdivision Regulations and Zoning Ordinance as
amended. The design is comparable to other single family developments
in the area, he said. Access to the proposed subdivision is from San
Marco Road, a two-lane collector facility which is operating at an
acceptable level of service, he continued, and the CCPC reviewed this
request on April 19, 1990 and forwarded it with a unanimous recommen-
dation for approval, subject to staff stipulations.
Commissioner Hasse asked if the road impact has been properly
addressed and Mr. Bellows answered affirmatively. Commissioner Hasse
asked how far in it is located and Mr. Bellows said it is 255 feet
east of Good/and Drive.
Commissioner Hasse then asked if there is adequate water in that
area and Mr. Bellows said Portland Lake is behind this property which
is near the Marco Shores PUD. Commissioner Hasse asked where they
will get their potable water. Planner Bellows said it will come from
the Marco Island Utilities.
There were no public speakers.
C~mmlonm~ Smundere moved, seconded b~ Commissione~ Goodnight
and r~x~Zed 4/0, to close the Public Rs&ring.
Commiselonmr Saunders movmd, seconded blf Comm/sstoner Volpm mhd
carried 4/0, that Resolution 90-245 re Petition SNP-90-5 be adopted.
Page 5
May 8, 1990
RESOLUTXON 00-246 RE PETXTXON CCCL-S9-8, GEORGE V
~ INC. ~UESTZNO A CO~T~ C IN9
V~Z~CK TO CONS~U ONS~ZON CO~OL
CT A CO~M~NZ~ P~ZNO ~ ~~K ON THE
SIDE OF ~HO~ DR~
- ADOPTED WITH STIPULATIONS 0.5 MILE NOR~! OF VANDKRBILT BEACH ROAD,
Legal notice having been published In thu Naples Dally News on
March 25, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication flied with
the Clerk, public hearing was opened to con~tder Petition CCCL-89-8,
filed by George Varnadoe of Young, Van Assenderp, Varnadoe and Benton,
representing Developments Duken, Inc., requesting a coastal construc-
tion control line variance to construct a condominium, parking and
boardwalk on the west olde of Oulfshore Drive.
Ktmberly Polen, Project Review Services, addressed the matter
saying that the petitioner proposes to construct a condominium that
will extend approximately thirty-five (35) feet seaward of the adopted
Coastal Construction Control Line (CCCL), which was established by the
Florida DNR on October 31, 1974.
Ms. Polen continued saying that the petitioner ts also proposing
to construct a'boardwalk with a viewing deck extending one hundred two
(102) feet seaward of the adopted CCCL. The subject property, she
explained, is located on the west side of Gulfshore Drive Just north
of the Intersection with Vanderbtlt Beach Road and ts bordered on the
north by La Playa Tower and on the south by The Villas. The proposed
Le Dauphin Bay building will be across Gulfshore on the east side, she
said.
There ts a high storm hazard potential for Vanderbtlt Beach and
the barrier beach is classified as a "Coastal High Hazard Area" for
storm surge, Ms. Polen continued. There ts a high erosion rate tn
this area, she stated, and she discussed the shoreline recession rate.
She noted that the Growth Management Plan Policy addressing this
situation is Collier County Comprehensive Plan 11.4.7 and other poli-
cies. She summarized her background explanation by saying that staff
recommends approval of Petition CCCL-89-8 subject to a stipulation
concerning vegetation and dune management.
Page 6
Hay 8, 1990
Commissioner Hasse asked how high the buildings will be and Ms.
Polen said 90 feet is the planned height. Commissioner Hasse asked
what the DNR policy permits and she noted it allows construction up to
100 feet, or 10 stories. Ms. Polen said that the Florida DNR has had
communications with the Petitioners regarding a beach management
design as well as variables concerning the height of the project and
Involving pervious area. The planning is for pervious areas in the
parking areas throughout the development as well as a latticework on
the back of the development parking zones to permit water to flow
through the paver blocks, she said, adding that these are recommen-
dations from the DNR.
Ms. Polen said the plans include a boardwalk with a viewing deck
and chlckee, but the DNR will only permit a 12~ X 12~ foot area on the
dune system and the p/an has been reduced to minimize the impact.
Commissioner Has~e asked if the height is similar to the buildings
nearby and Ms. Polen said yes, in fact, the height is less than
buildings constructed tn the past because of less strict limits.
Commissioner Volpe said he understands that in the past six years
there has only been one principal structure permitted seaward of the
Coastal Construction Control Line and questioned if that is because
there have been no applications for a variance? Polen said that was
correct, adding that there has been no construction along that corri-
dor for some time.
Commissioner Saunders confirmed that staff ts recommending this
variance and Ms. Polen said that is correct, primarily due to the
fact that a precedent has been set for building principal structures
very near the shoreline in Vanderbtlt Beach. She added that the two
structures on e~ther side of the parcel ~n question are well seaward
of the CCCL, and the Petition's seaward limit is consistent with the
seaward extent of other buildings in the immediate area. Ms. Polen
then referred to Exhibit "A" which ts a stipulation recommended by
staff concerning the revegetation and enhancement of the dune system
that now exists.
Page ?
May 8, 1990
Mr. Varnadoe commented that staff has discussed with the peti-
tioner the new CCCL requirements, and asked if the County will in fact
adopt the new CCCL line? Ms. Polen said she is not cognizant of
whether the Board wishes to do that, but she has reviewed the Petition
based on the 1974 CCCL in the Comprehensive Plan because that is what
Ordinance 75-19 states.
Commissioner Hasse said that the State adopted a new CCCL in 1989
and the Board of County Commissioners should do the same.
Commissioner Volpe questioned if the State has a newly-adopted
coastal construction control line that has presumably been adopted in
other counties along the coast, will this petition be reviewed by the
Florida DNR based upon the 1974 or the 1989 CCCL? Ms. Polen said the
State would review it based upon the 1989 line. Commissioner Volpe
said the State is using the 1989 line for review and the Board is
looking at the 1974 line, but the 1989 line was moved significantly
landward from the 1974 line limit. He then asked how much further
seaward is the 1989 line in re/at/on to the 1974 line? Ma. Polen
responded that the difference is 35 feet seaward. Commissioner Volps
asked County Attorney Cuyler if the Board should be considering a
relocation of the coastal construction control line under the Growth
Management Plan? Not necessarily under the Growth Management Plan,
Mr. Cuyler answered, but the Board does have the alternative of taking
that line into effect a/though at this point the 1989 line is being
used by the State somewhat differently. The county's line, he con-
tinued, is basically a line of prohibition, although variances are
permitted thereto, and the newer line ia more regl/latory in nature and
Collier County has not specifically adopted that ss yet. He added
that the Environmental Board will confer at some future point with the
County Attorney's office and a presentation will be made to the Board
to determine the Board's pleasure in this matter. Commissioner Hasse
asked if there is a specific reason why it has not yet been adopted?
County Attorney Cuyler said the County may not ever adopt that line
in the same nature as the 1974 line, a line of prohibition, because of
Pags 8
May 8, lggo
where the line is located. For example, he continued, in the northern
part of the county, it is well landward of the majority of the
construction already there. It would entail variances for all of that
existing construction, he noted, and our 1974 line prohibits construc-
tion beyond its llm~ts, unless there is a variance granted. However,
he said, he expects that the Environmental staff will soon make a pre-
sentation to the Board regarding the aspects of both control lines.
Commissioner Basse said he feels the Board should look at this matter
very seriously in the future.
Commissioner Volpe commented that the City of Naples has adopted
the 1989 line and he wonders how this relates to continuity along the
coastline and asked County Manager Dorrtll if the city has, in fact,
adopted the 1989 COOL. Mr. Dorrtll pointed out that the State did not
adopt the new line until 1989; therefore the county has not been
delinquent since 1974; he then added that Mr. Cuyler is correct, the
state is applying the change in distance to building resistance to 140
MPH winds and other factors and are now putting these requirements
into effect for new construction. If the County adopts the 1989 line,
he said, it will change the whole Ordinance and the approach to the
issue and that should be considered in deliberations on this issue.
Commissioner Volpe asked if the Growth Management Plan references the
1989 line and County Manager Dorrill said it does not, adding that it
specifically references the 1974 line for construction control along
beaches.
Attorney George Varnadoe, representing Developments Duken, stated
that Jeff Scott, the architect and John Barber, the engineer for the
project are also present to answer questions. He reviewed the reasons
for requesting the variance, stating that the development will be com-
patible with surrounding properties. This ts the next-to-last lot
zoned RT on the Gulf and Vanderbllt Beach, he said, and after this
property has been built upon, there is only one more lot to the south
that is vacant. The RT zoning would allow 26 un/ts/acre for
hotel/motel use and up to 16 unite/acre for multi-family/condominium
O00(710O23
May 8, 1990
use such as proposed here, he noted. There will be l? units placed
across the street as a part of this development, and som~ off the
parking for the gulfstde units will be placed Jn that area to reduce
the Impact on the gulf side, he said. He pointed out that the 1989
line, from the state's perspective, Is not a prohibition line, but ts
used to find the area where special design criteria ts necessary to
protect the beach dune system, the proposed structure and adjacent
properties.
Hr. Varnadoe said that the general standard under which the
variance was applied for ts In Chapter 161, the applicable state law
since 1965 which was not changed when the Coastal Zone Protection Act
of 1985 was adopted nor when the "Glitch Bill" of 1986 was adopted.
The same standard ts reflected tn Collier County Codes, Section 7-14,
he added, and then read the standard for the Board's information.
Mr. Varnadoe pointed out that their planned development meets all
criteria, as staff has recognized tn their recommendation, In that
tn the Immediate area all the property 1o developed with existing
structures In reasonably uniform setbacks. He also pointed out that
the development tn question has a setback greater than that of adja-
cent existing structures. He demonstrated this by referring to the
model present In the Boardroom.
Mr. Varnsdoe addressed Objective 11.4 and 11.4.? where it states
that building can be allowed on the coast where It meets the criteria
of Chapter 161, under which the petition requests the variance. He
then briefly reviewed the existing structures in that area. If the
CCCL variance is not allowed, he noted, there can be little use made
of this property which would be compatible with the surrounding area.
Mr. Varnsdoe reviewed the dimensions of the lot tn question, stattng
that the butldtn~ ts ss far landward as possible, considering the turn
radiuses for fire protection equipment to enter the area. He
explained that the Board~s approval of the variance request will allow
the developer to petition the DNR for a variance from the state's CCCL
line. They have filed their application with DNR staff and have hsd
Page 10
Nay 8, 1990
three meetings with their staff on various elements of the develop-
ment, he added, and notable among adjustments being made is replanting
native vegetation seaward of the building tn an attempt to stabilize
what remains of the coastal dune system at this property line and
removing exotics. It appears that from 1960 to 1966 photographs show
there was a construction road and an east-west road on this property,
Mr. Varnadoe continued, and native vegetation was removed at that
time. Replanting was done with Australian Pines and there ts very
little native vegetation where the building will be, he said, but
seaward there are vacant areas where replanting will be done. He
noted that the staff report is favorable, the petitioner has agreed to
stipulations and a mitigation plan, adding that the plan includes a
dune walkover with a 10' X 10' sitting area attached.
Commissioner Hasse noted that most of the building will be west of
the coastal control lines. Commissioner Volpe asked if there is a
provision for public beach access. Mr. Varnadoe pointed out a number
of beach aocesses In the area, and said there will be none on this
property. Commissioner Volpe asked if there Is any provision for
dedicating a right-of-way because there are some plans for widening
Gulfshore Drive tn order to put in a bicycle path. Mr. Jeff Scott
from Forsythe Architects replied to the question, saying there ts an
existing bicycle path, but it ts simply striped on Gulfshore Drive on
the east side of the roadway at present. Mr. George Archibald,
Administrator for Transportation Services, said they will widen the
roadway by expanding the existing pavement and by encroaching Into the
grassy swale area both on the east and west side of Gulfshore Drive;
however, al/ the work done will be within the present rights-of-way.
The work will increase the road run-off of stormwater and this will be
inoorporated into the storm drain systems of the projects situated
along the drive he said and asked if the applicant will accept some
run-off from the roadway Into its water management system and convey
it to the east lagoon. Mr. Varnadoe assured the Board there ts no
problem with that, and pointed out It applies to the property east of
000f 0025
Page 11
May 8, 1990
Gulfshore Drive.
Mr. George Keller, representing Collier County Civic Federation,
spoke to the matter, saying that he wished to commend the Board for
constderfng the application for the variance tn depth and regretted
that the same approach had not been used tn the past. He recommended
the Board approve the request for the variance because the area has
already been extenslvely developed close to the beach. Mr. Keller
then stated that If any undeveloped property still exists In the
county, he urges that no additional construction be permitted west of
the roadways fronting the beaches. There were no other speakers.
Commissioner Volpe moved, seconded by Contsstoner Saundsrs ~nd
carried 4/0, that the public hearing be closed.
Contsmloner Goodntght moved, seconded by Co~tsstoner Volpe and
carried 4/0, that Resolution 90-246 rs Petition CCCL-89-8 be adopted
· ubJect to stipulations as contained in the Resolution.
County Attorney Cuyler stated he will arrange for a future presen-
tation to the Board regarding coastline construction control require-
ments.
OOcf[O026...
Page
Zt~
M~y 8, ~ggo
sm~r~ ~x~w~ m~s~,t~zoNs 9o-ze/~9 APP~tOVZNO A~g~m~TS TO ~
Legal notice having been published tn the Naples Dally News on
May 2, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication filed with th~
Clerk, public hearing was opened to consider amendments to the Fiscal
Year 1989-1990 Adopted Budget for Collier County.
3chh Yonkosky, Finance Director, explained that this Item ts an
advertised public hearing as prescribed by Florida Statutes Chapter
129.06 which ps=mits the Board to amend its budget where the total
app=op=lattons are g~eate= than the original budget. This Is the
second quarterly advertised public hearing tn which the Board ts
requested to amend Its total budget upward, he said, and there are
four budget resolutions Involved. He brtefly reviewed the resolutions
and their contents for the Board's information. He asked that the
lout resolutions be approved after the advertised public hearing Is
closed.
Commissioner Volpe questioned the $11§,O00 increase over the
budgeted amount tn the fleet management Item7 Mr. Yonkosky explained
that last year, the Board approved a new vendor for Fleet Management
and at that time there was a catch-up of one month's payment to the
old vendor which had not been budgeted for In last year's budget, and
this amendment Is to use appropriated monies carried forward to make
that catch-up payment, he said. Commissioner Vo]pe asked If this
means that the budget will be over $115,000 and Mr. Yonkosky stated
that without the approval of this budget amendment, it will be.
Mr. Yonkosky explained that this item was budgeted for 12 months, but
mt the turn-over which was the thirteenth month, this money had not
been planned for in last year's budget. Commissioner Volpe asked
if the county ts paying $115,000 per month? Mr. Yonkosky said no,
adding that this amount Includes several adjustments to close out the
contract from the prior vendor which totals approximately $115,000.
There were no further questions and no speakers on the matter.
00OCI0030
Page 13
Hay 8, 1990
c~ied 4/0, that the public hearing he closed.
Co~missioner Ooodnlght moved, seconded by Com-isstoner Saunders
carried 4/0, that Budget Amendment Resolutions 90-26/19 he ~dopted.
OOCCIOO: I
~,"' * Ztmm ~6C7
Ha~ 8, 1990
ORDXII&)IC~ 90-34 &M~NDZNG COLLX~ COUNTY ORDZNANC~ NO. 87-91 ~DZNG
C0~T-O~D ~DZATZON ~ ~Z~TZON 8~ZC~ T0 ~SOL~ CZVZL
~lO~ ~ DZS~ ZR C0~ ~ CZR~ZT CO~YS - ~D
Legal not/ce having been published tn the Naples Datl~ News on
April 19, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publlcatton ffled with
the Clerk, publlc hea~ln~ was opened to conslde~ an amendment
O~dtnance No. 8~-91 to add ~ou~t-o~de~ed mediation and a~blt~atton
services to ~esolve civil actions and disputes tn county and
cou~ts.
Mr. Sal Gardtno, Director of Mediation/Arbitrations programs for
Collier County, explained the proposal to assess a $2.00 fee on
filings for mediation services required by recent state legislation.
He said that the fee would be used for mediation and arbitration ser-
vices that are now being provided by the county. Last year over 1,200
cases were mediated, he offered, and the number of case filings were
in the range of 10,000 to 12,000; thus the fee can generate substan-
tial revenue at no cost to the county and eventually it will become a
se/f-supporting program by fee generation.
The proposal also requires certain cases as set forth by the
Judues to keep paying a mediation fee to this budget that will be uti-
lized to support the program, he said. Commissioner Volpe asked
how much money this fee of $2.00 will generate? Mr. Gardino explained
that their budget is now under Genera/ Revenues in the Court
Administration, but they are expecting about $6,000 per year in Small
C/a/ms, not counting county filings which may be an additional 600 to
700 filings. Cases numbers fluctuate from year to year, and each year
the number seems to grow, he noted, adding that this fee will not be
child support cases, but it wtl! be applied to divorces.
Commissioner Saunders asked if this has been reviewed by the
Co,liar County Bar Association and Mr. Gardlno said he was not aware
of that, but it has been rev/awed by the Judges and by the Collier
County Attorney's office. Commissioner Saunders asked if the Bar
Association knew this item was being presented to the Board today?
o rcioo36
Page 15
May 8, 1990
Mr. Carding said he did not know if they had been notified specifi-
cally, but It has been advertised under legal notices in the local
newspaper.
the program
Commissioner Volpe said he supports the concept, however, the
county could end up with a lot of money from this which could be used
for training volunteers and other associated expenses. Mr. 0ardtno
agreed that the amount could be significant, but it would not be
extremely high. Commissioner Hasse commented that it will not require
more personnel, but it will provide additional instruction to the
volunteer mediators and the citizens of the county will benefit from
Commissioner Volpa asked how many paid staff are in this
program and Mr. Gardino said only himself and his secretary, the rest
are volunteers. The annual budget for his office, he added, is about
$50,000. Commissioner Hasse complimented Mr. Gardino on the fine Job
his volunteers are doing. County Attorney Cuyler said his staff has
worked ~tth Mr. Carding on preparing the Ordinance based on statutory
authority.
There were no speakers.
Commtaatonmr Saunders moved, seconded by Commissioner Ooodntght
mhd carried 4/0, to close the pub/lc hearing.
Co~u~tealonmr Saunders ~ved, seconded by Commissioner Goodnight
~tnd carried 4/0, that the ordinance aa ntuab~red ~nd titled below be
adopted ~%d entered Into Ordinance Book No. 38:
ORDINANCE 90-34
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 87-91 BY
REVISING SECTION ONE TO ADD COURT-ORDERED MEDIATION AS WELL
AS ARBITRATION SERVICES TO RESOLVE CIVIL ACTIONS AND DISPUTES
IN COUNTY AND CIRCUIT COURTS; AMENDING COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE
NO. 87-91 BY REVISING SECTION TWO AND PROVIDING FOR A COURT-
ORDERED MEDIATION SERVICE, PROVIDING FOR A COURT-ORDERED
NONBINDING ARBITRATION SERVICE, PROVIDING FOR VOLUNTARY
BINDING ARBITRATION, PROVIDING FOR AN ADDITIONAL $2.00 FILING
FEE ON ALL COUNTY COURT CIVIL PROCEEDINGS; PROVIDING FOR
CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE
DATE.
May 8, 1990
Planner Philip Scheff stated this item is Petition PU-90-3, filed
by A.A. Reeves of Florida Cities Water Company representing Robert A.
and Sally Billings requesting a provisional use "B", essential ser-
vices, for property located between Green Blvd. and 15th Avenue, S.W.
in Golden Oats Estates, consisting of 5 acres. He reviewed the land
uses, vegetat/on and zoning of the area, and sa/d that At has been
reviewed relative to the Collier County Growth Management Plan (GNP)
and no Inconsistency has been found. Hr. Scheff noted that staff and
all appropriate county agencies reviewed the petition and have no
objection to its approval. The Collier County Planning Commission
held a public hearing on April 19, 1990 and forwarded the Petition to
the Board of Zoning Appeals with a recommendation of approval by a
vote of ?/0, he advised, subject to staff stipulations and with the
addition of Stipulation "N" which requires a 6 foot high chain ]ink
fence instead of 8 foot high fencing as suggested by staff. Mr.
Scheff said that two other stipulations were added by the Planning
Commission, notably Stipulation "Q,,: street access to Green Boulevard
shall be limited to one Ingress/egress access; and Stipulation "R'.
The ingress/egress drive and parking area will be designed to be as
non-impact/ye as possible consistent with the use of the site.
Mr. Scheff concluded by stating that no correspondence has been
received for this petition and no speakers were present at the CCPC
public hearing, and that the Board approve Petition PU-90-3 subject to
the CCPC's recommendation.
Commissioner Volpe asked if this petition had been reviewed
against the Golden Gate Master Plan? Mr. Scheff mentioned conferring
with the long-range planning staff and said they are proposing that
essential services be permitted aea provisional use in the Golden
Gate Estates D/strict. He further commented that, while things can
a/ways change prior to adoption of the Golden Gate Master Plan, Staff
is considering that essential services including water storage
tanks, be permitted as provisional uses either anywhere in the
district, or in activity nodes, but this is still under consideration.
Page 17
May 8, 1990
Mr. Don Ptckworth, a local attorney for Florida Cities Water
Company, said that Mr. Scheff has succinctly stated what the
Petitioner is requesting and stated that the purpose of the storage
tank ts to improve distribution ability, prevent pressure problems and
improve fire flow capability tn the system. The site, he noted, ts
located at the Intersection of three major transmission mains and is
hydraulically ideal for such a facility. The county received a letter
supporting this petition from the fire department which recognizes the
need for the facility, he said.
Mr. Pickworth briefly referred to the stipulations which will make
the sl~e non-impactive; natural vegetation will be retained, the water
tank will be hidden behind existing trees and vegetation will buffer
the borders of the property. Commissioner Hesse asked if this site
will generate any noise, to which Mr. Plckworth replied negatively.
Commissioner Hesse asked what the height of the tank will be, and Mr.
Ptckworth said it has a rounded top and will be 25 feet high at the
highest point. He added that only one person/day will arrive onstte to
read gauges, Commissioner Hesse noted that on the sketches provided
there are two ingress/egress, and Mr. Plckworth explained that the
Planning Commission decided to eliminate one drive, the other will
open onto Green Boulevard. Commissioner Volpe asked what plans the
water company has for the rest of the five acre site? Mr. P~ckworth
referred to Stipulation "M", which indicates that the acreage will be
utilized for wat.r management purposes. Commissioner Volpe indicated
that if there are future expansion plans, he would like to see the
petition returned to the Board for review. County Attorney Cuyler
said that tn the past, provisional use approval Is tied to the site
plan and if there are site plan amendments in the future, it would
requLre an additional provisional use approval. Mr. Scheff said that
would only apply to a situation where additional land would be added
to a ~rovieion use, and then a new site development plan would be
required. However, he added, the Board could add a stipulation
requiring that if there is any change on this site, the petitioner
00C. C10039
Page 18
May 8, 1990
would have to come back to the Board for approval. Mr. Cuyler noted
that if the provisional use approval is tied to the structure and is
approved today, then any additlona! structure or addition to the site
plan would require the need for addItional review. Commissioner Hesse
agreed with that idea and asked about adequate screening along the
front of the property. Mr. Ptckworth said the property will be
screened on all sides, and the color of the tank will be aesthetically
pleasIng. There were no speakers.
¢o~m~aeloner Saunders ~ov~d, seconded bFco~Aaa~oner Goodn~ght
m~d c~rr~ed 4/0, that Resolution 90-24? re Petition PU-90-3 be adopted
cont~ug~nt upon ~n add~t~orm! stipulation requ~=lng that the
Petitioner return to the Board for approval of any expansion of fac~-
O00CROO.,IO
Pag~ 19
Km¥ 8~ xggo
Commissioner ~ssse welcomed a group of exchange students
Francs who are part of an on-going exchange program sponsored locally
by Seagate Elementary School In association with an organization known
as the Association for American-French Classes located in Westmont,
Illinois.
X~gAI
~Xl~ OF FINAL PLAT OF "PARK PLACE WEST SUBDZVXSZO~ (FOI~RLy
~ JW Xlm~m~ e'~cl) - AI~OV~n
Commissioner Volpe asked that this item be removed from the
Consent Agenda for separate consideration because It relates to the
Imperial Golf Estates Subdivision and there has been an exchange of
correspondence with property owners in Imperial Golf Kstates con-
cerning the final approval of the record plat, specifically as it
relates to the relocation of a gatehouse. Frank Brutt, Commun/t¥
Development Services Administrator, stated that the Homeowners
Association have been engaged in correspondence with the developer and
have reached a resolution of the matter concerning location of the
entrance gatehouse. Commissioner Volpe said he understands there has
been some discussion regarding placing a stipulation on this item.
Mr. Brutt said he is not knowledgeable of any stipulation relating to
this matter. He said the gatehouse has been moved back and there has
been some widening of the entrance so that construction traffic and
shopping center traffic will not interfere w/th the gatehouse opera-
rich. Commissioner Volpe said he is concerned that this is resolved
as a part of the approval and questioned if there was notification to
the Homeowners Association when this item was scheduled for the agen-
da? Mr. Brutt said that a letter from the two individuals repre-
senting the Homeowners Association stated they are satisfied with the
work completed tn connection with this matter. Commissioner ~asse
asked if this would impact on the entrance to U.S. 4! and Mr. Brutt
said ~t would not. There were no speakers.
Co~mieeloner Volpe moved, seconded by Coll~ll~Onlr 81tlndlrl, I~d
i~O~ ~0
~¥ 8o XggO
4/0, to approve the ffAnal Plat o~ "Park P~ace ~.~
~iviein', nb~t to ~he roll.Lng etL~lat/o~:
Accept the Irrevocable Letter of Credit as eecurlt¥ to
guarantee completion of the Subdivision Improvements.
AuthorLze the recordLng of the final plat of "Park Place West
Subdivision-.
45
Authorize the Chairman to execute the Construction and
Maintenance Agreement.
That no Certtftcatee of Occupancy be granted until the
required lmprovemente have received preliminary acceptance.
Page
May 8, 1990
Zt~
O0JlBUL?ZNG IRGZRIIRZNG 8ERVZCE8 AQRKKNK]IT NZTH 3KRKZHB ARD CKARLAIID,
INC. ~OR DKSZi:F~ O~ THE S.R. 29 PEDESTRIAN OVERPASS STRUCTURE IN
~MMOKAZ,~EI IN THE AMOUNT OF ~66f322, - APPROVED
George Archibald, TransportatLon ServLces AdmLnLstrator, revLewed
the background of the request to approve and execute a contract
agreement for design of the pedestrian overpass
the Zmmokalee area. He explained that the contract is a standard
agreement, documentLng the hours to be spent on each phase of the
design contract. The total amount of the contract ~8 $66,322.00 and
that ~s for design services to Lnclude not only work to be performed
by the prime consultant, he continued, but work performed by soma sub-
consultants for the pro~ect. A substantial part of the funding for
the pro3ect, he noted, ts to be provided by the
Transportation, which agency has reviewed ~e ncope of servLces and
wil! be a party to t~e design review at 30~ and ~00~ of work comple-
tLon. Mr. Archiba~d said that the scheduled start
Nay of th~s year, to complete the desLgn by the end of ~990, and
start constructAon Ln early 1991 and complete the work by December
~992. He said tf the contract L8 approved today, he wLll be on sche-
dule. CommLssLoner Hasse commented that this pro~ect has been a long
tLme ~n reaching this poLnt. ~r. Archibald po~nted out that
Transportation has a half-dozen ma3or consulting contracts ~n fLnal
process that will be presented to the Board th~a month. There were no
speakers.
Comm/mmloneF GoodnLgh~ moved, ascended by Comm~aoLoneF Vo~po and
c~t~tod 4/0 to approve 8nd mate
agreement with ~enkLn8 and Chi~snd, Inc. faf daoLgn of the S.R. 29
p~de~tFlmt ovez~moa Ln lmmohlaa Jn the ~mount of $66,322.
Page 22
Hay 8, ~990
lq.~,SO~lO~ 90-24~ CALLING FOR A ~ ~LECTZON IIZI'BZ~ ~ BIG
~ X~ ~ COBOL ~ ~8~ DZS~X~ ~ D~X~ IF
~~ ~~ ~ DZS~Z~ ~ ~S~SSZ~ ~ COLL~Z~ ~
~ ~ ~z~ z~~s o~ co~~zo~z~ ~ ~z~ co~~
~s~ ~ c~o~ ~ ~S~ ~s~z~ -
C~e~oner Sanders ~d, seconded ~ Co~lseloner Vol~, ~d
to a~ t~ ~~t ~d collection of ~ ~ct f~ fo~ capital
['4"
00 C1 112
page
Coe~taaloner Smundero ~nmd, aeconded by Co]mismionor Volpe end
~~ 4/0, t~t ~lo~utX~ 90-249 cm~ng fo~ m ~fe?en~ e~ect~on
with~ t~ Borth Baple. ~lre Control ~ Ree~e Dl-trlct to appr~
~te wl~n t~ North N~p~e~ F~re Control ~d Reeve D~etr~ct ~
~t~.
00 C10116
Page 24
~ 8, JggO
· Xtem#lOC
R~OLUTZON 90-250 C&.T.,LING FOR A R~'F~q.B~ID~ ELECTION
N&FT,~ ,XI~ CONTROL J~D I~SCU~ Dx~rRICT TO D~I'~II~ IF TH~ ~T~CTOR~
~~ ~ DX~I~ ~ ~S~SSINO ~ COLL~XN~ ~ X~A~ ~ ~R
C~XT~ ~~ OW ~ CO~~XOW ~XW ~ ~T
CO~L ~ ~S~ DXS~CT - ~D
CmAmmA~mr Sm~dmrm ~ved, mmconded ~ Co~tmmtonmr Vol~ ~d
c~l~ 4/0, t~t Rmmolutlon 90-250 cml1Ang for ~ rmfmrmn~ mlmct/on
etth~ ~ ~t Mmplmm FArm Control ~d Rmm~m Dtltrlct to
~t ~ collect/on of ~ l~mct f~ for cmp/tml
00 C10120
P~ge 25
May 8, 1990
':;: ...... I~OL~TXOI[ ~O-25! CALLING FOR A ~~~ ELECTION ~ZN ~ ~CO
~ ZS~ YZ~ COBOL DI~I~ T0 DE~I~ ~F ~ EL~OR8 ~0~ ~
DI~I~ ~ ~S~SSINQ ~ COLLE~IN~ ~ I~ACT ~E ~R C~IT~
~ oe ~ co~u~o~ ~r~ ~ ~co ~s~ ~ co~o~
Co~lealoner Saundere novsd, seconded by Coutaetoner Volpe, that
R~solution 90-251 calling for a referendu~ election within the Narco
Xelaml, Fire Control and District to appr~e asseas~nt ~d collection
~ l~ct fee for capital l~r~e~nte ~ adopted.
County Attorney Cuyler stated that he understands from the
Supervisor of Elections that the Board may want to consider requiring
election costs to be paid prior to the election. He said the
rationale Is that there may be problems relating to the legislation
dealing with the Incorporation of Marco Island, adding that the pro-
cess may become Involved with the Incorporation Issue at a later time.
Normally, each district pays election costs of 04,000.00 after the
election, but In this case the circumstances may be different, he
noted.
Commissioner Hasse Inquired when the Incorporation will take
place, to which Mr. Dorrlll responded that the election con-
cerntng Incorporation will take place this fall. Mr. Dorrtll said
there Is a potential conflict between the Independent fire district
and the City of Marco Incorporation, because they are on the same
ballot and Ms. Morgan has brought that point to the attention of
staff. Commissioner Saunders said he does not feel a need to require
payment up front on the cost of the election and he will not Include
that tn the motion to approve the referendum election.
If the elec-
tion is successful and Marco Island Incorporates, he is certain there
will be a mechanism for reimbursement to the county, he stated.
Commissioner Hasse asked Mr. Cuyler If he Is In agreement and he
commented that there may be a delay tn reimbursement, but ultimately
the county will recover the monies. Co-missioner Volpe said the issue
is that of ensuring collection and he asked if this Is a matter which
should be addressed by Ms. Morgan, a Constitutional Officer, when the
Page 26
Nay 8, ~990
~": necessary arrangements are made for placing this on the ballot,
Coulasioner Volpe asked If the Narco Island Ptre Dlatrtct had
budgeted the funds for the election and Nr, Cuyler said they are
required to pay the costs and Staff assumes the montes will be there
when It comes time to pay, but Ns, Norgan simply ~ants to bring this
-attar to the Board's attention at this time, ~r, Cuyler added that
.~?~. the ~atter may be out of the Fire District's hands when Incorporation
['~'.~ becomes Involved, C.o~lssloner Volpe satd he feels that this should be
~'" required up front and Commissioner Saunders asked that a separate
..~ sotton be taken,
~ all ~or th~ ~tt~, t~ ~tt~ carrl~ 4/0,
-'~: c~fltct tn co~ectlon with this referen~ election c~ce~tng lncor-
~rati~ of ~co Isl~, t~ ~rco l~2~d Fire District ~y the costs
;~-
of t~ ~fer~ election In a~uce.
00(1Cl0125
Page 27
and th/s As not a referendum election for that, rather, At 1~ a
referendum pursuant to legislation, In this case Involving salary
requirements and attendance requirements of Fire Commissioners.
County Attorney Cuyler said there Is need to adjust the lan~age In
the Resolution on the first pass because the ~estton presumes that
the voters are voting on a $~5 a month salary ~hen tn fact the
Commissioners already receive a 9~5 a month salary. He continued,
noting that the purpose of the legislation la that a Fire
.Co~lssloner ~111 forfeit his salary if he falls to attend meetings.
He read Into the record proposed lan~age: "Do you approve Chapter
89-451, Laws o~ Florida, ~hlch amends Chapter 87-498 Laws of ~lortda,
to provide that each district co~tsstoner that falls to attend at
least one scheduled co,lesion meetln~ during any ~tven month shall
forfett the $75 co~lastoners, salary ~or that month...and providing
tha~ if any district co~tssloner Is absent for t~o consecutive months
o~ scheduled meetings ~lthout sufficient cause, such co~tssloner
sh~ll autouttcally be dismissed from the District Board."
Coalssloner aasse asked if the replacement statutes concerning the
commissioners, discharge require a ~overnor*8 appointment until the
next election? ~r. ~uyler indicated that ts correct. Commissioner
Volpe asked if this means a failure to attend one meeting a month?
Yes, Mr. Cuyler said, forfeiture of salary would occur If a com-
missioner misses one reeler meeting tn a month and that Is tn the
starts. The referendum election ~estlon simply tracks the statute,
he mmld, and this election ~111 take place in November rather th~n
9eptmmbmr. Commissioner Volpe Indicated he has a problem ~lth a
:*~'dlmclpl/nary type of action to be taken asainst thoae elected public
o~tc/ala ~ho have a co~ttment to public eervtce althouffh he
Page 28
May 8, 1990
understands the purpose and inability to function in the absence of
cosmtssIoners. Commissioner Haese said that when there are only three
commissioners there, It Is vitally important for all three com-
missioners to be In attendance. He noted that If a commissioner can
miss two regular meetings prior to removal, he believes that Is suf-
ficient ttme for a commissioner to arrange his schedule to fulfill his
duties as a fire commissioner. Commissioner Saunders asked Mr. Cu¥1er
If this board has any discretion In the matter, and he responded that
the board has no discretion to change the ballot question and Its only
responsibility was to call the election.
~ ~1~ 4/0, t~t le~lutl~ 90-252 c~lltng ~ ~fer~ electl~
wt~ ~ ~1~ Gate ~lre C~ol ~d Rel~e Dtltrlct for
o~ ~tl~ ol ~tt~cs ~d al~ r~tre~t fo~ c~tsst~rs of
~t Dls~tct ~
00 £10130
Ha~8, 1990
· Ztem ~11Al&2
'" 190 -
Zt~ ~12A
Frank Blanchard, Chairman o~ ~he Marco Island Beach Nourishment
Co~lttee, ~nformed the Board that the consulting engineer ~s ~n the
process o~ preparln~ ~or the beach nourishment. He s~ld that they
must ~o back to the ~overnor and Cabinet to settle the starting date.
The Issue of the lease term Issue has been re~olved b~ the consulting
engineer, he said, end at this point the Count~ DNR ~nformed the
F~or~da DNR ~ha~ ~he~ objected ~o an Au~s~ ~ s~ar~ da~e for ~hls pro-
Jec~. Mr. Blanchard Informed the Board that the co~ttee has met
with D~ representatives and B~ll Lorenz, Administrator of
~nvlro~enta~ Services, and are now ~n Possession o~ a letter ~rom Mr.
Lorenz dated Ma~ 7, 1~90, stipulating that the beach nourishment
program cannot support en~ date ~or project start any earlier than
Septem~r ~. However, he continued, the letter goes on to state that
the D~ wll~ not object to a September 1 start d~te with conditions
that the turtle nesting activity essentially be completed b~ September
1 and that the work beg~n at the north end off the temporar~
t~on easement alon~ Hldeawa~ a.d Tlgertall beaches, and tha~
pl~n~ and storage o~ construck~on materl~s may be be~ Au~st
staging areas approved by Collier County Natural Resources and
~d Recreation Departments. The ~et~er continues with conditions
be met for this activity, Mr. a sea turtle relocation plan which can
be ~lemented by May 5. Mr. Blanchard saUs since the letter ~ dated
May T, he would l~ke to clar~ffy that
Mr. B~chard said that a contractor baa been hired to get the cea
turtle monitoring tn place Immediately. He added that the Beach~ront
Advtso~ Co~tttee reluctantly agrees w~th this date change but
Page 30
'i '
Nay 8, 1990
suggest8 some clarification of wording, dates, etc. Nr. Blanchard
asked for the Board to do thio today and, apart from those concerns,
the Advisory Committee agrees to the conditions. Commissioner Hesse
asked about the sentence cont&intng a date of October 1, 1990 commen-
cement. Mr. Blanchard said back in January they were looking at a
July 15 start-up In discussions with the Governor and the Cabinet.
However, he continued, Mr. Charles Lee of the Florida Audubon Society
raised questions about the feeding habits of the least terns and the
Governor and Cabinet changed the date to October i. Mr. Blanchard
says they must go again before the Governor to get it changed to a
different date, and that is why they are before the Board today, in
order to determine what date is appropriate. Mr. Blanchard said he ts
:? requesting a date change from October to September 1. Commissioner
;i'i] Saundera asked what action Is needed by the BCC today, a resolution to
'i' begin the work on September 1, 19907 Mr. Lorenz Interposed that it ts
'~".' a public petition with a staff recommendation and it is not certain
~ :' that the Board needs to make a formal motion unless It wants to go on
· .'~, record to endorse a September ! start date. Mr. Blanchard said they
have to have something to show Tallahassee that the County ts working
ii'. on one firm set of plans. Mr. Lorenz said that the work should be
started at the northern end of the beach area and proceed toward the
south, commencing September 1. Commissioner Hesse asked Mr. Lorenz If
? that date would give ample time for the turtles to nest and for the
,;., 'Conservancy to relocate the nests If necessary? Mr. Lorenz said there
~ii.i are three concerns involved in protecting sea turtle activity, one ts
that you have Incoming turtles nesting May, June, July and part of
4%' August. The problem, he said, with the August 1 date is that it would
affect the turtles arriving in August. He added that the concern
']~;' staff has with an August start-up is that the turtles hatch from the
:?. nest in 60 to ?0 days Incubation time and the turtles will be going
out to sea tn July, August, September and October. In August, Mr.
'Lorenz noted that 45 percent of the turtles will be going out to sea
and then starting at a September deadline the turtles will be re/o-
O0o, ClOl 5
.,~ .... Page
May 8, 1990
cared to the southern part of that central portion so they will move
out to sea at that particular locality. If construction can be staged
to proceed from north to south, by the time the activity reaches the
southern portion, most of the turtles will have gone out to sea, he
said.
Commissioner Hasse asked if the Conservancy will take an active
part in relocating these nests if necessary? Dr. Fran Stallings,
representing the Conservancy, said they are concerned with the August
start-up date because it is in the middle of nesting season. The
State has given a date of the first of October and the Conservancy
sees no Justification for starting earlier, he said. The Justifica-
tion put forth was bad weather, and he notes that Mr. J. Allen Hough
said that the time of year made no difference. Dr. Stallings said
that petitioning the Governor and Cabinet to advance the date one
month is a waste of money, and as far as protecting the turtles is
concerned, the October ! date is far better.
Commissioner Volpe asked if Dr. Stallings disagrees with county
staff and he said not necessarily, but the Conservancy would prefer an
October ! starting date because it protects the turtles better, and
would avoid additional expense. Commissioner Hasse asked if Mr.
Lorenz agreed with Dr. Stallings that September ! is not the comple-
tion of the nesting cycle? Mr. Lorenz said if one wishes to reduce
the risk of affecting hatchltngs down almost to zero, then the start
date should be November 1. He said he feels that the impact will be
reduced to a tolerable level by beginning the work at the northern end
of the work area, and moving the date to September ! As an accom-
modation dependent upon phasing the work stages. Mr. Blanchard spoke
to the issue of weather patterns later in the year and quoted from
records showing days that dredges could not operate in various months
in 1988-89 on the Captiva project. In August, he noted, zero days
down, in March 38.39 percent lost time or about fifteen days down, at
a cost of about $25,000 per day to keep a dredge in place, even if it
is not working.
00fl( 9136
Page 32
May 8, 1990
Dr. Stallings referred to a memorandum to John Paterson, Division
of State Lands, from J. Allen Hough, Florida Marine Research Institute
which addressed that very question and indicated that the Research
Institute found that inlet dredging, shoal dredging and renourish-
merit projects can be conducted year-round without unusual adverse
impacts from weather. Weather related delays, were unpredictable,
' year-round phenomena and not restricted to winter months,
Dr. Stallings quoted. Mr. Ken Hummlston, Coastal Engineering
Consultants, commented that the contents of that letter are based on
Information that refers to communications with dredging contractors
who wish to remain anonymous. He says he has done an analysis on
this subject because of involvement with estimates for construction in
former work with dredging companies. He added that he has information
from these contractors that the difference in cost between summer
construction and winter construction is based on weather data that the
weather is more severe in the winter than in the summer, dramatically
affecting floating equipment by wave artery. Damage can occur where
heav~ wave action is encountered, he said
Commissioner Saunders indicated he plans to move to approve the
September l, 1990 start date for the Marco Island beach nourishment
project ~lith conditions stipulated by staff, although this will be
contingent upon Mr. Lorenz' concurrence that the date is satisfac-
tory. Commissioner Hasse asked Mr. Lorenz if he is satisfied with
that date, and is this turtle an endangered species? Mr. Lorenz said
the loggerhead turtle is a "threatened" species and it will be mainly
loggerhead turtles nesting in this area. He further stated that all
the speculation connected with starting dates are all probabilities,
both the movement of sea turtles and weather which might occur Since
they will be releasing the turtles in the south while the work commen-
ces at the northern end of the area, and based upon the information
provided by the engineers, it is probable that the turtles will move
out to sea unaffected by the dredging, he concluded.
Commissioner Seunders asked if the construction a¢:tivAt¥ proceeds
Page 33
i~.?~ May 8~ ~990
'~'~'' rather more quickly than anticipated, will staff be ~n a position to
~c~ stop the activity in order to protect the turtles? That is no~
:~:' ~ncluded in the petition, Mr, Lorenz sa~d.
.. Co--~esioner S·unders noved to approve the petition to begin the
' Narco Ill·nd be·ch nour~shaent project on September l, 1990, but Af
f!~-:' ther~ Am an ~ndZc·tton from the County*s EnvAronnent·l ·genc'F that
there is · potential negative tnpact upon the released hatchllngs,
county stiff ha~ the &uthority to hilt the construction until the
hatc~l~ng~ hav~ be~n safely releued.
i Commission Hasse said he feels that the Conservancy should be con-
'': suited as well in the matter of turtle protection because of their
?~:~:' knowledge of the loggerhead turtle species. Dr. Stallings indicated
[:... he is more comfortable with the October ! date but that is the Board's
to make. Mr. Blanch·rd said the work will begin in the
northern section which Is rocky terrain and it will be a number of
weeks before the work reaches the south end. Commissioner Saunders
asked Mr. Lorenz if he is satisfied with the motion? Mr. Lorenz said
he is, add~ng that there will be about 100 nests to protect
¢o~/se~oner Goodn~ght seconded the ~otlon.
She then reminded the 8oard that this is not a Marco Island pro-
ject, it is a Collier County project She said regardless of the
Advisory Board's statements, the Board of County Commissioners will
make the decisions and bear the responsibility.
Commissioner Volpe raised the question of Wiggins Pass dredglng
start-up date and asked that the two projects be coordinated. The
consultant said they would confer with county staff on that matter.
Upon call for the question, the motlon carried 3/1 (Co~eelone=
Page 34
M&¥ 8~ 1990
Deputy Clerk Ro~mn replaced Deputy Clerk Beech
VARIANCE FOR OVERNIGHT LIVING QUARTKRS U-HTZL MAY 22, 1990 FOR mCHRIST
IS TB~ AN~M~I~' R~VIVAL MEHTING TO BE H~LD ON TH~ CHLUM~Ky PROPERTY ON
U.S. 41 - AFIq~OVID WITII COgDITIOW~
County Manager Dorrlll advised that this Item ts a request rela-
tive to the current revival crusade that is tn town. He explained
that he understands that the request Is for the Commission to waive
the overnight camping conditions. He related that the "Christ Is The
Answer Crusade" does have a special events permit, and all conditions
are being met.
Mr. Larry Hammond stated that he ts the Southwest Field Director
for the Full Gospel Bustnessmen,s Fellowship and the sponsor of the
subject group. He reported that the crusade has been active tn 10
different countries, and they have never experienced any accidents,
f/res, or anything of that nature. He indicated that the group
recently came to Naples from Ft. Lauderdale where they were motivating
the young people during spring break not to use drugs, alcohol, or
participate In crime, etc. He explained that the crusaders have, for
the past slx years met at the Washington Monument under the first
invitation of President Reagan. He advised that they did a remarkable
Job in fighting the crime and dope situation tn Atlanta, and Mayor
Andrew Young presented them with a proclamation for their fine work.
Mr. Hammond Informed the Commission that the people involved tn
the crusade are al/ volunteers, they live day-by-day as the Bible
says, and they work strictly for the moral uplift of the communities.
He indicated that the group will be going to Immokalee and they may
bus people to the revival in hopes of motivating them to a more moral
life. He advised that efforts will also be made In the river area of
Naples and McDonald's Quarters.
Mr. Hammond expressed his Gratitude for the special events permit
which was received by the crusade, and noted that they have met the
conditlons of same. He indicated that at the end of the crusade, the
000 C 0172
Page 35
Nay 8, 1990
property will be left tn better condition than it was when they
arrived, as part of an agreement with Mr. Chlumsky, and therefore, he
is requesting that a variance be granted to allow 15 or 20 persons
to stay on the grounds overnight. He related that he understands
these tyFes of variances have been granted In the past to groups such
aa circuses.
Co~tsstoner Hasse remarked that the circuses have always been a
problems to the residents in the area: the influx of people, traffic,
etc. He called attention to the fact that the particular site that is
being occupied by the crusade is one of the most heavily traveled
areas In Collier County, and he suspects that the revivals will be
attended by a large number of people.
Mr. Hammond replied that the meetings will be held after the rush
hour traffic.
Commissioner Hasse suggested that the persons Involved tn the
crusade take advantage of staying at one of the RV parks in Collier
County since many of them are not presently filled. He advised that
he feels that the group ts doing something very admirable and posi-
tive, but he does have concerns about this type of overnight living
taking place within close proximity to a residential area.
In answer to Commissioner Saunders, Mr. Hammond advised that the
vehicles involved are campers, mobile homes, and there ts one small
bus. He advised that some of the vehicles are equipped with bathroom
facilities, but a number of port-o-lets have also been rented.
Commissioner Saunders stated that he has received a note regarding
the noise from the revival, and a complaint relative to sewage, and he
asked Staff If the toilet facilities are adequate?
Con,unity Development Servtces Administrator Brutt replied that he
ts unaware of any such problems, and noted that the temporary use per-
mit was reviewed and the site plan illustrates four portable toilet
facilities.
:: as many as 50 persons being housed in buses.
Commissioner Volpe indicated that he was Informed that there were
Mr. Hammond replied that
Page 36
Hay 8, 1990
an accurate accounting would be more tn the neighborhood of no more
than 20 or 30 people, and there are 8-10 vehicles Involved.
Hr. Dale Toil, North Naples resident and Vice President of the
Full Gospel Businessmen Fellowship International, stated that 2 to 4
persons will stay In each vehicle. With regard to cooking facilities,
he advised that one vehicle serves as the kitchen where the meals are
prepared.
Commissioner Hesse questioned whether any of the RV sites within
the County have been explored? Hr Toll replied affirmatively but
noted because those that are Involved In the crusade work without pay,
they are not financially able to occupy these sites. He explained
that many of the members Include families with children, and all the
money that ts collected through donations Is given to the church for
missionary work.
Commissioner Saunders stated that the situation is whether or not
the Commission Is going to permit the crusade of 25 or 30 people to
stay on the site In 10 vehicles, plus or minus He said that he would
like to make a motion to approve the variance, subject to conditions,
If those Involved would be In agreement.
Commissioner Smunders moved, seconded by Commissioner Shanahan, to
mpprov~ the variance nbJect to tho condition that County Manager
Dorrlll be the designated muthorit~Z to sliminess, remove, or rescind
the variance, within his discretion if he ftnd~ anything that
him concern,
Idditional vehicles than have been represented.
Iddittonal people than have been represented.
Proble~ associmted with noise, or with the number of people
re, aiming on the sits after the revival is closed for the
evening.
4. Rsmlth, noise or police type problems.
Mr. Toll affirmed that Commissioner Saunders" conditions are
acceptable.
In answer to Commissioner Volpe, Hr. Hammond Informed that many of
'-.;the vehicles do have shower facilities, and the cooking takes place tn
Page.37
May 8, 1990
one vehicle in a well equipped kitchen. He related that most the
people will not be on the site 24 hours a day since they will be
preaching throughout the community. He Indicated that many of the
area churches have supported this endeavor.
Commissioner Volpe stated that he would have preferred, rather
than being put Into the position that the Commission has been placed
In, that some of the area churches would have accommodated the finan-
cial needs of this ministry. Mr. Toll replied that the financial
needs of the ministry will be provided for.
Commissioner Volpe questioned whether granting this variance would
be a violation to any of the County's Zoning Ordinances? Mr. Brutt
advised that under the Temporary Use Permit for sports events, reit-
9tous events, and community events, the placement of temporary signs,
merchandise, temporary structures and equipment, and temporary mobile
homes as an office ts permitted, but not for residency.
County Manager Dorrtll advised that there Is a separate section In
the ordinance relating to fairs, expositions, and carnivals, and
these requests are granted routinely for those types of events. He
noted that there has never been a problem as it relates to fairs and
~.,j..carnlvals.
Assistant to the County Manager Olltff explained that events for
circuses and carnivals fall under a separate ordinance, but they are
allowed to have on site living facilities and inspections are con-
ducted by Staff to ensure that those conditions meet Code.
Commissioner Saunders advised that his motion is very implicit In
that regard since Mr. Dorrtll may stop the operation for any health or
safety reasons that he finds.
Commissioner Hasee requested that County Manager Dorrtll see to it
that everything Is tn place, and that the County Inspectors and the
Inspectors from the Health Department be Informed of the situation.
County Manager Dorrlll stated that dally inspections will take
place.
Ulmn call for the question, the motion carried 4/O.
. Page 38
May 8, 1990
e~, C~lssioner 0oodnlght m~ved, seconded by Coaatsstoner
· almd~r~ and carried 4/0, that the following ite~ under the
Con~ent &genda be &pprov~dand/or &dopted: eeee
Item~14A!
R~80LUTZON 90-253, AUTHORIZING PRELIMINARY ACCEPTANCE OF THE ROADWAY,
DIqAZNAG~, #AT~R & S~R Z~RO~S IN ~GLE C~KK KSTA~S AT ~GLK
~ CO~ CL~ ~ ACCK~ZNG LK~KR OF C~DZT ~OM D~LOPKR ~R
~l~E OF S~ ~R NlXl~ OF O~ ~ - ~ STI~TION$
1. Accept the Irrevocable Letter of Credit as security for main-
tenance of the infrastructure until the Board of County
Commissioners grants final acceptance of all improvements.
2. Authorize the Chairman to execute the Maintenance Agreement
for Preliminary Acceptance and Resolution authorizing preli-
minary acceptance.
3. Preliminary acceptance of improvements will not become effec-
tive until water and sewer facilities have been conveyed to
Collier County Nater-Sewer DistrAct.
Zte~ el4&2
CR&xII~MI ~O EI[~CUT~ SATXSFACTXOM OF
· Nllq[ &I3EIIT FOR 3ANXE ~ SNZTR
See Page
Item 4~14&3
~-t%'OltDllg OF TI~ FZ!A~ PLAT OF "NZLLOUGHBY PZ_N~_$" - #ZTH STZ~'uI-ATZO~.
1. Accept the Escrow Agreement as security to g~arantee comple-
tion of the Subdivision Improvements.
2. Authorize the recording of the final plat of "Mllloughby
Pines".
3e
Item el4&4
Authorize the Chairman to execute the Construction and
Maintenance Agreement.
That no Certificate8 of Occupancy be granted until the
required Improvements have received preliminary acceptance.
00'"254, /'ZILILLACCKPTANCE OF ROADWAY, DRAINAGE, M&TKRAID
~ Il "WKST CRONB' POINT~", (FOIq34KRLY 131OWl AS LOCH
-wr1~ ~rlP~,a?zo~
Authorize the Chairman to execute the resolution authorizing
final acceptance.
2. Authorize the release of the maintenance security.
See Page-:~ f -.,,.-
Item #14A~
00 CI9176
Plgl 39
May 8, 1990
!*RESOLUTION 90-255, FINAL ACCEPTANCE OF "MOON LAKR, UNIT
1. Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached resolution
authorizing final acceptance.
2, Authorize the release of the maintenance security.
See Pager .~-~ /
Item #14A6
RECORDIJ~J OF THE FINAL PLAT OF "LAKE AVALON PROFESSIONAL CEIFTER# .
WITH 8TXFULATION$
Accept the Irrevocable Letter of Credit as security to
guarantee completion of the subdivision improvements.
Authorize the recording of the Final Plat of Lake Avalon
Professional Center.
3o
Authorize the Chairman to execute the construction and main-
tenance agreement.
That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the
required improvements have received preliminary acceptance.
That no building permits be issued until the four lane
entrance road Is submitted to an approved by Project Review
Services.
6. Upon submittal of plans for approval for the remaining por-
tion of the PUD, an appropriate easement shall be provided to
accommodate drainage from this site.
Item #14A7
RESOLUTION 90-256, CREATING A CITIZEN TECHNICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE TO
gOJO~WIT7 DKVELOPME~ OF A ~STER P~ ~oa THE I~O~lE P~INa
See Pages
Item #14A8 Moved to 9A!
Zte~#14B1
ACCEPTANCE OF WARRANTY DEED TO BE UTILIZED FOR RIGHT-OF-MAY PURPOSES
lt~ ~14B2
',' IASEMENTAGRE~M~NT FOR ACQUISITION OF RIGHT-OF-WAY FOR THE NORTH
N~.,~ ltOAIN~Ay MUNICIPAL SERVICES TAXING AND BENEFIT UNIT (LIVINGSTON
ROAD,PARCK/~ 11-16) - WITH STIPULATIONS
Authorize the Chairman of the Board to execute the attached
Purchase Agreement;
Authorize staff to prepsre related vouchers and warrants for
payment; and
Authorize staff to proceed with the related real estate
closing transaction and to record with the Clerk of Courts
000Cl9177
Page 40
May 8, 1990
all appropriate documents in the Public Records of Collier
County.
See Pages ~
Xte~14B3
A~E~I' I~:TAXNXNG JOE N. FIXEL, P.A., IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED
040,000, FOR PURPOSES OF I~PR~SENTXNG COLLIER CO~
~~~ ~R ~ CO~ATXON~OT~AT~O~ ~ ~P~TXON FOR
~X~ ON ~XNXN~ P~CELS ~T ~ NOT SE~LHD IN T~ S.R. 951
Item
See Pages
THREE PARTY rUHDXNG AGREEMENT FORRECEXPT OF 0698,800 XN STATE GRAXTS
.FOR THI POLYg'Y~LE P~OJECT AT THE I.'T:-.0KALEE AIRPORT
See Pages~
Item t14C1
RESOLUTION 90-257, ESTABLISHING AN ANIMAL NEUTER/SPAY PROGRAM AND
.ANIMAL CA.q~ AND TREATMENT PROGPJ~M AND RESCINDING ~SOLUTION 87-239
See Pages
"~' ' Xte~#14D1
NATIRAND SEWER FACILITIES ACCEPTED FOR GATES MILLS IN WILLOU~HBY
ACRES -- ~ ~Z~TiONS
1. The Florida Department of Environmental Ee~lat~on furnishes
a letter authorizing to place the sewer system ~nto service
and approving the water distribution system for service.
2. Bacteriological testing has met the County,s requirements.
3. The Fire Flow requirements of the project have been satisfied
and the F~re DistrAct furnishes a letter accepting the fare
hydrants for o~ershAp and maintenance.
See OR Book /5.~40 Pages 1493-1504
~' ACC~PTABCE OF EAGLE CREEK COUNTRY CLUB, TRACT D WATER FACILITIES
WI~ ~Z~TIONS -
Bacteriological testing has met the County's requirements.
The Fire Flow requirements of the project have been satisfied
and the Fire District furnishes a letter accepting the fire
hydrants for ownership and maintenance.
xtemel4D3
See OR Book _1530., Pages 1004-1022
Page 41
Hay 8, 1990
' aeRImlrr BETWn~ COLLXn CO~fl'r &eD ~ ~ CO~~ ~S~ YZ~
9PERATXJffO & TRAXWXWO ra~Tr.v~ .uu°n.~'..A__~l,A~ilqOOM FOR TH~ PURPOSE OF
.... .,- - -.~ ,nn AJ~JUN~ OF $2.400 AbnuALLY
Xtu #14[3
RK$OLUTXON 90-258, KSTABLXSHXRG TI~ PAY TXTLK OF ASSISTAITT COUHTY
&TTOBIlIT IX AT P&Y (3RA_~[ P132
Xtem #14F1
IMERelBCYPORC~ASE OF A~ g~OXn ov~.e, tur, fOR THE comrr~ a~LXCOPT~R
WIT~ AVIJ~,L O, -~&~t~S XN J~ ~ WOT TO ~.,, $30,000
Xt~e14F~
BXD ess 9001523, BI~S MZNOR MKDXCAL SUPPLXKS AND 90-1529,
t' I~I~DXCATXOBI TO VA~!0UaVIWDOI~
Legal notice having been published Jn the Naples Dally News on
February 2, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication filed with
the Clerk, bide were received until 2:30 P.M. on February 28, 1990, to
consider Bid #1523, EMS Minor Medical Supplies and Bid #90-1§29, EMS
Medications.
BID~I~-1849 lfORRKFORBXSlFZI~CJATYPK IIX MOEX2LARRKSCUIAMBULAXCE TO
.AKRC) PROlX/CTS O, ~---~J~JMOOD, IK__~R_XDA XX ~ns J_~ Off ~48,012
~ Legal no~ce having ~een ~ub~L8hed In ~e Naples ~atl¥ New8
.,-. March 23, 1990, 88 evidenced by Affidavit of Publication flied wlth
· the Clerk b/ds were received until 2:30 P.M. on April 18, 1990, to
consider Bid #90-1§48, for refurbishing a Type III Hodular Rescue
Ambulance.
~ELT~O~OFMO~XL~ CO~ POST V~XCL~ PROPOSAL8 AIIDRJ'P d~90-1546 To
~&~I:FTMIC~ 0F DRAT-I-AC~ ~_~l~pet~?f FROM cor, x, XKlq C~.~z HO~FOXIE~ A~J:n0~l~:
Page 42
Hay 8, 1990
::' BID ~)-lBl~, COlq~fRUCTZOW OF BECURITYF~RCZRG FOR NAPT,~ &lid
* ~ OF $18T,1B9
Legal notice having been published tn the Naples Dally News on
N~rch 8, 1990, ~s evidenced by Affidavit of Publication flied ~lth the
Clerk, bids were received until April 11, 1990, to consider Bid
~90-1519~ Construction si Secu~tty Fenclng.
ra~ coLr. z~ comrr~ com~r~ous- - .... i~--?as--A~-zTz°~L
Ztem #14Z1
REAPP0~ 0F KRI~ST Iq. FREEMAN TO THE COLLIER COUNTY
:,, ;i zt..-
ii':: ]lllTlqA ~&Zll T]ll~ FOR I~T~ NO~S 16922, 38863r 33943r AlqD 58880
!.~.; :'-' :S&TZ~JJiTfZOlq OF LZ~N~ FOR S~RVZC~S OF ~ha PUBLIC D~adD~R
The following miscellaneous correspondence was filed and/or
referred to the various departments as Indicated below:
1.
Letter dated 3/16/90 to Property Owner, from Robert H. Lord,
Project Planner, Community Development Division, Planning
Services, Collter County, re a public hearing of the Planning
Commission to be held 4/5/90. xc: Flied.
Letter dated 4/24/90 to Chairman Hasse, from Ronald Davis,
Chief Bureau of Housing, DCA, re Community Development Block
Grant, Contract #9ODB-49-O9-21-O1-HO§. xc: Nell Dorrtll,
Frank Brutt, Russell Shreeve and flied.
Letter dated 4/26/90 to Chairman Hssse, from Robert O. Nave,
Chief Bureau of Local Planning, DCA, re adoptton of the
Comprehensive Plan Amendments on 5/1/90 instead of 4/24/90.
xc: Nell Dorrtll, Start Lttslnger and flied.
Cl0180
Page 43
May 8, 1990
Letter dated 4/26/90 to Chalrman Hasse, from Patrlck Kenne¥,
Environmental Specialist, Florida DER, re Collier County -
HRR, File #111791615, 111790715, enclosing short form
applications involving dredge and fill activities in Collier
County. xc: Nell Dorrlll, Bill Lorenz Frank Brutt and
filed. ,
Letter dated 4/26/90 to Chairman Hasse, from Bobby Adams,
Orants Specialist Supervisor, Florlda DER, re FY 89-90
Recycling and Education, Waste Tire, and Small County Grant
Funds. xc: Nell Dorrlll Bill Lorenz Frank Brutt and
flied. '
Notice of Public Workshops dated 4/20/90 from DER, re Rule
#'s 17-660.200, 17-660.801, 17-660.803, and 17-660.804. xc:
Nell DorrilI, Bill Lorenz, Frank Brutt and flied.
Letter dated 4/26/90 to BCC, from Tony D. McNeal, Engineer,
Bureau of Coastal Engineering and Regulation, DNR re Request
for Public Comment, File Number: CO-247, Applicant
Scottsdale Company. xc: Nell Dorrtll Bill Lorenz, Frank
Brutt and flied. '
8. Legislative Alert Dated 4/26/90 from James C. Shipman,
Executive Director, F/or/da Association of Counties, to the
County Commissioners re Service Charges on Local Government
Trust Funds. xc: Nell Dorrill and filed.
9. Fax dated 4/25/90, from Leone F. Strickland, Florida Land and
Water Adjudicatory Commission, Executive Office of the
Governor, to Chairman, re Development Order 90-1, Regency
Village of Naples Development Of Regional Impact. xc: Nell
Dorrlll, Frank Brutt and fl/ed.
10. Minutes Received and Filed:
A. 3/22/90 Library Advisory Board
B. 4/12/90 Marco Island Beautification Advisory Committee
and agenda for 5/1/90.
C. 3/15/90 and 3/26/90 Collier County Planning Commission
and agenda for 5/3/90.
11. Notice To Owner/Preliminary Notice to BCC from Farreys
Wholesale Hardware, advising that they have furnished fin-
ished hardware for the Collier County Health Services
Building, under an order given by Mid-West Glass. xc: Nell
Dorrtll, Steve Carnell, John Yonkosky and filed.
12. Notice To Owner/Preliminary Notice dated 4/27/90, to BCC from
Sar-T-Green of Miami, Inc., advising that have furnished ren-
tal equipment for the Collier County Courthouse, under an
order given by Service Painting of Florida. xc: Nell
Dorrlll, Steve Carnell, John Yonkosk¥ and filed.
13. Copy of Notice To Owner dated 4/25/90, to D. N. Hlggtns, Inc.
and Hartford Fire ~nsurance from Florida Cnntrsctor Rental &
8ales, Inc., advising that they have furnished rental equip-
ment and suppltes for the South Service Area Regional Sewer
Systems, East and South Naples Waatewater Collection
Facilities, Contract #4, undsr an order gtven by Willie
White. xc: Nail Dorrtll Steve Carnell, John Yonkosky and
flied. '
14.
Copy of Notice To Owner dated 4/25/90 to Gulf Constructors,
Inc. and Seaboard Surety Company from Florida Contractor
P,P.f, f 018i
Page 44
May 8, 1990
16.
17.
Rental & Sales, Inc., advising that they have rum{shed
equipment rental and supplies for the South County Regions!
Wastewater Treatment Facility, under an order given by
Thompson Trucking. xc: Nail Dorrill, Steve Carnell, John
Yonkoaky and filed.
Notice To Owner to Collier County dated 4/24/90, from
Explosives Tach International of Florida, Inc., advising that
they have furnished materials and services, under an order
given by Jim Owens Excavating Co. xc: Nell Dorrill, Steve
Carnell, John Yonkosky and filed.
Copy of Letter dated 4/19/90 to Seaboard Surety Co., from Key
Wallcovering, Inc., advising that they have furnished wallco-
raring materials for the Collier County Government Center.
xc: Neil DorrAll, Steve Carnell0 John Yonkosk~ and filed.
Notice To Owner/Contractor to Board of County Commissioners
from Highway Va/ets, Inc., informing that have furnished
pavement markings and reflective pavement markers for Collier
County Project C.R. 951, under an order given by Better
Roads. xc: Nell Dorrlll, Steve Carnell John Yonkosky and
filed. '
Public Not/ce dated 4/30/90 from U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency Region IV, Water Management Division -
Ground Water Protection Branch, Notice of Intent to grant
an exemption for the continued underground injection of
hazardous waste and Nottce of Public Hearing, re Kaiser
Aluminum & Chemical Corporation. xc: Nei/ Dorrtll Bll!
Lorenz, Frank Brutt and f~led. '
Letter dated 4/24/90 from Virginia Helm Caustic, Town Clerk,
Town of Penney Farms, enc2osing Resolution, expressing con-
cern for the ~nequitab2e distribution of Federal Grant Funds
aa compared to the amount of Federal tax dollars paid by
Florida taxpayers to the Federal Government. xc: Nell
Dorrtll, Ken Cuyler, and fi]ed.
Ther~ beAng no further busAness for the Good of
meeting ~as adjourned ~ Order o~ ~he ChaAr - TA=e~
BOARD OF COU~ C~ISSI~RS...
BOARD OF ZONING'A~ALS/~X ,~ '
SPECIAL DISTRICTS U~E~ ~TS
" CONTROL ~ ".. '
~,; ,, .
'/.~JAMEB C. GILES, CLERK
· as presented
by the Board on~
or as corrected
Page, 45