Loading...
CESM Backup Docs 03/16/2007 2007 - Special Magistrate Backup Documents March 16 , 2007 HEARING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY SPECIAL MASTER AGENDA Date: March 16,2007 at 8:30 A.M. Location: 3301 E.Tamiami Trail,Naples, Florida,Collier County Government Center Administrative Building"F",3rd Floor NOTE: ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE SPECIAL MASTER WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO,AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. NEITHER COLLIER COUNTY NOR THE SPECIAL MASTER SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR PROVIDING THIS RECORD. I. CALL TO ORDER—Special Master Brenda Garretson presiding A. Hearing rules and regulations II. APPROVAL OF AGENDA Ill. APPROVAL OF MINUTES—March 2,2007 IV. MOTIONS FOR CONTINUANCE V. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Stipulations B. Hearings 1. CASE NO: DAS 11234 THRU 11238 OWNER: GREGORY COCHRAN OFFICER: DAS OFC. PETER HINKLEY VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-36,SEC.(A)(2) INJURED DOG RUNNING AT LARGE AND MULTIPLE DOGS RUNNING AT LARGE VIOLATION ADDRESS: PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY IN FRONT OF 624 10TH ST.&NORTH 10TH ST, IMMOKALEE 2. CASE NO: DAS 11239 THRU 11243 OWNER: GREGORY COCHRAN OFFICER: DAS OFC. PETER HINKLEY VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-34,SEC.(A)(I) FAILURE TO VACCINATE MULTIPLE DOGS VIOLATION ADDRESS: PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY ON NORTH 10TH ST, IMMOKALEE 3. CASE NO: DAS 11244 THRU 11246 OWNER: GREGORY COCHRAN OFFICER: DAS OFC. PETER HINKLEY VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-41, SEC.(A)(5) TORMENT ANY ANIMAL VIOLATION ADDRESS: PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY IN FRONT OF 624 NORTH LOTH ST,IMMOKALEE 4. CASE NO; DAS 11278 THRU 11281 OWNER: RAUL DIAZ OFFICER: DAS OFC. PETER HINKLEY VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-36 SEC.(A)(2)&CODE NO. 14-36, SEC.(AX7) DOGS RUNNING AT LARGE; SNAP,GROWL AND SNARL TO THREATEN PERSON VIOLATION ADDRESS: 505 HOPE CIRCLE, IMMOKALEE 5. CASE NO: DAS 11285& DAS 11286 OWNER: MATTHEW HUBBARD OFFICER: DAS OFC. PETER HINKLEY VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-36 SEC.(A)(2)&CODE NO. 14-34,SEC.(A)(4) DOG RUNNING AT LARGE; FAILURE TO AFFIX LICENSE VIOLATION ADDRESS: BAYSIDE STREET 6. CASE NO: DAS 11287 THRU 11290 OWNER: NATALIE MYERS OFFICER: DAS OFC.PETER HINKLEY VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-36 SEC.(A)(2)&CODE NO. 14-36,SEC.(A)(5) DOGS RUNNING AT LARGE; DEFECATION CREATING PUBLIC NUISANCE VIOLATION ADDRESS: COMMON GROUND ON BLAUVELT COURT 7. CASE NO: DAS 11298& DAS 11299 OWNER: CHRISTINE JODOIN OFFICER: DAS OFC. PETER HINKLEY VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-41, SEC.(A)(9) LEAVING DOG IN VEHICLE IN A CRUEL OR INHUMANE MANNER THAT THREATENS THE HEALTH OF ANIMAL, NO WATER VIOLATION ADDRESS: 3451 TAMIAMI TRAIL E. 8. CASE NO: 2007010511 OWNER: CRAIG&GLORIA PERLOWIN OFFICER: CEO INV. RENALD PAUL VIOLATIONS: ORD.04-41,SEC.4.05.03(A) RECURING VIOLATION-VEHICLE ON PARK ON THE GRASS VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1900 46TH TERRACE SW 9. CASE NO: 2006040727 OWNER: ROBERT A.MITCHELL OFFICER: CED INV. MARIO BONO VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41,SEC.4.05.03(A) PARKING ON UNPAVED/UNSTABLIZED SURFACE VIOLATION ADDRESS: 3465 DORADO WAY 10. CASE NO: 2006060712 TIME CERTAIN/12:00P.M. OWNER: JAMES&CATHY DONOVAN OFFICER: CED INV.JOE MUCHA VIOLATIONS: ORD.04-41,SEC. 10.02.06(B)(1)(A)& 10.02.06(B)(1)(D);CODE OF LAWS SEC. 22,ARTICLE II, PAR. 104.1.3.5 CONSTRUCTION WITHOUT PERMIT VIOLATION ADDRESS: 200 TAHITI CIR. • VI.NEW BUSINESS A. Motion for Imposition of Fines: 1. CASE NO: DAS 11130 THRU 11150,DAS 11251 THRU 11267 OWNER: KATHY LAVERY OFFICER: DAS OFC.DAVID LEVITT VIOLATIONS: CODE NO. 14-41,SEC.A(6)AND SEC. A(5) ANIMAL WITHOUT WHOLESOME CHANGE OF AIR&CAUSING TORMENT TO ANIMAL VIOLATION ADDRESS: 3481 11TH AVENUE SW B. Motion for Reduction of Fines: 1. CASE NO: 2006040788 OWNER: PEDRO M.HERRERA ESTATE C/O ADAM HERRERA OFFICER: THOMAS KEEGAN VIOLATIONS: ORD.05-44,SEC,6, 7,&8 ACCUMULATION OF LITTER VIOLATION ADDRESS: 1 122 IMMOKALEE DRIVE, IMMOKALEE 2. CASE NO: 2005120270 OWNER: JALP,LLC CIO LAIMIS PAISELIUNAN OFFICER: CED INV.JOE MUCHA VIOLATIONS: ORD. 05-44,SEC.6,7, 8 TRASH& LITTER REMOVAL-COUNTY ABATED VIOLATION ADDRESS: 5234 MARTIN STREET VII.OLD BUSINESS A. Request to forward case for Collections/Foreclosure: VIII.CONSENT AGENDA- A. Recommendation to approve the Imposition of Lien for owners of record who have failed to pay invoices resulting from nuisance abatement violation enforcement actions. IX.REPORTS X. NEXT MEETING DATE: April 6,2007 XI.ADJOURN BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Collier County, Florida Petitioner, vs. Case NO. 2007010511 Craig M Perlowin/Gloria Perlowin Respondent(s), STIPULATION/AGREEMENT COMES NOW, the undersigned, Craig M Perlowin, on behalf of himself or Gloria Perlowin as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of Notices of Violation in reference (case) number 2005040909 dated the 21st day of April, 2005. In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for which a hearing is currently scheduled for 3/16/07; to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the parties hereto agree as follows: 1) The violations noted in the referenced Notice of Violation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence. Parking vehicles in the grass. THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall; 1) Pay operational costs in the amount of $126.28 incurred in the prosecution of this case. Respondent is to move any and all vehicles from the front yard of 1900 46th Ter SW Naples, FL and park them on a stabilized pervious or imperviously treated surface within one day of this order or pay a fine of$50.00 a day that this violation remains unabated. 2) Respondent is to pay a civil penalty of$200.00 for a recurring violation. 3) Respondent must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of abatement of the violation and request the Investigator perform a site inspection to confirm compliance (24 hours notice shall be by phone or fax on made during the workweek. If the violation is abated 24 hours prior to a Saturday,Sunday or legal holiday,then the notification must be made on the next day that is not a Saturday,Sunday or legal holiday.) Respo dent helle Arnold, Dire,tor a a1-�1 Co &Enforcement D.\partment Date v - 7- o 7 0774'(P7/0 4e/) Date REV 2/23/06 6111661 (e4 , tet g) Activity Report Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type: A06-005980-2 OWNED/OTHER 06/15/06 08:00 AM NORM 7 DOG Photos: IVy r. - _. - ' . ... , , ,,.......,,,,, 7-7, . ... . t ,t, ,,...., „,,,,,,,, .. ,, ..,.„,.. .. ,, ..... •_ :... ,,- - .- _ , 4. Y`0rr' 1` 4 $y A Y t Photos: • '.' 1 ,.. 4111;111.‘ 11 rte,. lit COVNTY EXHIBIT COUNTY EXHIBIT Page 3 of 5 �d si r� �ll��� - /12 3 Print Date: 6/14/2006 C�vh Activity Report Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type: A06-005980-2 OWNED/OTHER 06/15/06 08:00 AM NORM 7 DOG Photos: Page 5 of 5 Print Date: 6/14/2006 Activity Report Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type: A06-005980-2 OWNED/OTHER 06/15/06 08:00 AM NORM 7 DOG fi r :a.Photos: s c ' , r i *4"ex.; . i . - a . .. "mot.. • r F- sk Photos: t ° -;\'''' 4 ; Y r ,.wr�.�^^ 6. `, `'1 x'44 '" ,.: z x „.ate ,- , .--, ,,.. .;,..,,,„..,F,41 5 0,-04,1-0,,?'...-�*«`,''i. t ,fir a •0'k f,, °'y1 �```• '„ `y f f f : ?4 pw Page 4 of 5 Print Date: 6/14/2006 a•; '„ . ,- '''',;° lip i lI .y�`;;�"" • ,..»s«>^cam •o •. a •1> tml '#-p ` , ,, • , ,„„ CO 0. i. o xa w, ' N �'+ 4 * : J}X 4. r • I. r 141111. , u t «q x { } ` a t r.� � ask'" _. ..' °4 _ »» p - _, tee ..... , F r' FF •u _ •. ' lz F2 , S,„a vz4 { '. ,' s d� t a,” • • 1.t. 't. •V • r 4)It *�F , 1 i t ] OTTY EXHIBIT COUNTY EXHIBIT (•o )ps' - /!.23tf-16 St w. ;Y.'s 411.4-k li . • .. . . ,._...z4,1,_ .._„,....: _,..,-1,1_.:!_: .vii!,_. _ . v_. :,....:..... , ,,..... .....,,,..,,:....1 _ ::::: • . _0_ :c.....c....„.:. ,_-,.....s..::„.....11.. _ :., , . . :...,....- „._‘:„ •,.•!...... .,.,.1.,.: ::,. ... .,-.. " . . iC......^:;.....N..!.;:. , . ' v� .,t- ' #4414:.••� _ , tier, � ,.:• • b' � ... . rFir"-a :r ..yam �.�,', i '$.44 a I) 44 4�' qt i4 . a n t. £ •t 4 s : F r_ ;,4 ` r -,'i •s x p r , ... ' r,^.: .4, 1's�S-"1. r „ �� �' : 4 rte.g; 444;. , ate" S w f .x,, '. Pit°' . !�* , 44--gyr m. :.,.X k-Kt s ;`1 � "��, " , ^ i c { i 000 a'4 k .. OUNTY EXHIBIT COUNTY EXHIBIT ; • x r . �' ,, ,..„„,,,,,„ f t *-47is -:,..4 ;- ,..,,,,- 4 40f � t x ,, -s- ''-- t ti. ,, ..,... ,, , ,. - 4.- . .‘„,„:4„,„_,...,,... . . ,,,, a' 'ter .,...„, . . .,, , -.. . ;- ,- ..... ''''V'''',''''''': '' ' ''. ;''Z':" ':•,'‘, • ,,,.!.. .;: „.„. .,- „;004,1!„'-• ' ''''' ' ,...„. ...,,. ...,.:. ,,,,... .„„ ..„.,' . , . .„ ... .,., ....,,....- ,,.: '..;.,:.-. ..„ ,,4,;....,. . , ...., .. . . .„. -.-' . .„ :-.' . ..., . ,.... , :. ...,:. ,,- ....: ,,.. ii ,., ..., ,,,..., .... . , .... y . . . . . . # . . % . . w ,. . p.. m . - . . . . ��« . . . ��j . . < ���\� . . ����\ . . . .�� \�° , � . � ��«` . :�©: = a .» y. . � �%�« . . «w »« z > � . f � �&���. �>���. . �<# - ^ �.» . . ��© ^� 77 � . . �\may . . /�\ ... • ,‘ , . iik: ...Y$•••-..,41.0....:4•• 4. , ' -•.*:.1'4. . - ." • . **. '411 4.- -t.str••••• ..-7twatoko, . . • •• • - .,. , , .• • •....... . .. 1,..: ...1,,if.-.„-Ar.- qt..... -A•••••. e.:01_,,_•• pl• ' ...,.4.,;..........aiif,..4,06.:;.: .:••••iir•-•_:.:mAt'......,4',.....4&-#.1.':.&; ..., ,.... ,,,,„ . . ...-. •• ..... .., .' ' ' '1;'. 6...,...• .:.,-.•:,....•••- '' ..,, '.11?'4' `., .*. .-• ' 6 - 4. ''.1*•• • * . • . ' 4,.. c• “.''-/('..q.,"*,( •„. .,' ,,g, '-'.. -- . ,4,4„ '... ...., '..:h: -...,, , i'-•4161P.'' ' • .- . . ..d. .*: ..i::',',.'ii.lk:'.''?.. .1,.. ,..,......... _ ..,„• ._ ......-.._ :„..,,,••••..„:„:„,:.,.. ... ..... _H..-- , ..,:..,.. • . , . .., . , . ... ....,, , .... ,.,.;,....„ , . . .. ,,,,, , . , ... . • . . • ,, .,, , 4:•;•.:....,T; ,. . ,. • • ,' 'NI:,'14*....„„rxft,• -,,,,, .., .. : ....J.•...._, . ( „ . , . .) . ...-. i . ' ■' 'e •• - . -. .,.. .,•slit:::%, 'ffi-,t-,A., : • . ..„“, -..• . ,,.•••........... :..-4. -,,,,,,, 4. , ':,;„.';•••. /:';.'-' if.4.'.r''.. .i% ''4'''.: ' ..., ...: , ii. . . .. ,r .4.....• ,,.:..... . . •- ,, ..,,,..., -,. . . . . , ., -•-..... .--•:, --. :..... , •k # r • :r.!... ‘1'. ...,... 16blinommov, -• A... . #4.,v .. = •:,_ • -;,.. 4-i ...ri.,,iii...-_... . -",-.... .....,.. ...:...-.- :,.- 1-..y * ---....:.„&•.,i..=A; :.4 ... ...A..lii.:......:,.: , ....1.4...,:jti.. ..':-I•f 2.1:-... "-if:. -'-' -::-5.:.•. , ' ' .1•4•4:_..:••:...: ••••.: ,„ 0: • •. • -. A*, ' • '4". • ' . . r, . , -• . .. • .,„ . . .., 0-.;' ur,•-•.,5-...."•- -':-4::r'..:' - - -:: •:' •:i•....',.9 ::.. : :.:.:0;.: •• A . ,. -: .,' -• .:;,.. .....'''.. t...,9...i, :'. .,,v •• , . .4 '"TI.,,,- ;:3•' - _, .1-::,71/..::!...---,•fm,F*-.0,,,.......tpoe:...,,:.:.• •• ••• .) ...1-fg,,A4.,•••: • ... • .4:;*•..i..:‘7;•ii ,:',1.?.•::.4;;I:AliP:T.Atelk,;4#,. :::;' , ,. .6 -•4,,, .' . '' "•-•,<-..-*.• .dief•ii,,•::4i:i:*•:i•1,,ri:fr . ' ... .••• .4.i-'.; Le'4.:`*1 i•..4.::•••...1-4.•....,:...,:ik:e;.....A••••••..4 .'• - .‘ . .% , , : •• . _. •4;:...,;;P• *•••1110.; .• :1'..• •'` ' '••••, -,. .'s . '.••• '4, •00:•:-... ; AV •'• •..4 '' '1' ',.; •- - A ''''ft, ',*,, .... . iih• :•;I: ..-4,14 t, w.• ?:. N.a -0F.:.:.-1: '• '' .'''. ;.4 . " !!:':;;'1 :,y:..':A': •';- ...... f■ .....•4.1.0,',•1 :.:41.a.-40,... ?..1"•••i•••frail. re j... '.: {:, 41544.:1:1.5.1:.4.: •;4..ii.1:::;:. : ••-:,...14*•••..,..i,:.:.•.:4•:!....`i....:*.:: • . . :,...,..... ' i ;,...... 20.4•:..-,•• .k•••': -,.4•;..k•sii.....• .1...,‘* ...4...:...=•: : '4.4...t..:.' . • " . ...... . 4::. 441:4 •.. :;.: -;:..4.::,....4,:peAv.*::::. ,•• -7F..1'.F-:: .-.. . .• 4........ ' ' ,... i: -:.;,- . •irit:•.:--Y.k..,. ;•5: ,•:-.. I.•::?,46.,....... .4"2'.li''"i. ' ', =•, ..,". -: W... :;':•Y'14-7) '; ., a :11i .. ,• -' tt it::•:‘ .. i.,,tif. ..... .*„.4 ,r,, ... .. ..: •...-.'-,.-l-'". ' - ... ...:... t 4 :....'••''...t. 11 """ .. ,, , .. 1 _ • . .S..F.e;....*.:•,.., 1 .:,,,, !,-■','.?:•- ....• . ■ —.•4.A. .. ... •••••'1, - , • ..:!!;.44/. . if, ' .......I ..".- ::".....• il • . !..!'::..-''. .r.... ..'-',x, 71,i., f...' . . -•••••:.O.:.-'•-:%. r.9'.-4..,::.;."4,'-'-`"-',"'.';.; ''''.ii'4';''.., '.. .....4:11......:1:;','-ti • tie' . t:.***-..4 - . I . • • • • ec CO 1vTY EXHIBIT COUNTY EXHIBIT . .. ..�;,. (;gym 44-" -b45 i/i-34- 1°O a CDPR0002 - Image Print CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION 2006040727 van parekd on grass 5-8-06 IJ-27 IMAGE DATE 5/8/2006 • - . el! Collier County Printed on 9/9/2006 2:40: 19 PM CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1 COUNTY EXHIBIT COUNTY EXHIBIT de/leSti-Z "A-* -040)60 , 7 CDPR0002 - Image Print CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION 2006040727 van parked on grass MB55 8-28-06 IMAGE DATE 8/28/2006 e , i _ , _ .,, , - kil:'''.4:: , ilf ii 4 r ' r » '}8/2&2006 11 33 am Collier County Printed on 9/9/2006 2:40:53 PM CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1 COUNTY EXHIBIT COUNTY EXHIBIT (!pr sirE. "4-* — ,o,6.5601/07-17 • CDPR0002 - Image Print CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION 2006040727 van parked on grass MB55 8-28-06 IMAGE DATE 8/28/2006 1 9 = r • 28i20O6 11,33 INn v : . 4' Collier County Printed on 9/9/2006 2:38:05 PM CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1 COUNTY EXHIBIT COUNTY EXHIBIT Cievneg,Tb 1114" - gook Ot/U 1017 1. . 7'7. ca -,-4 .. • ' ,•• y Ui c , I a •:: ,} I I a. 11:(.,.. 4. gill 4• t 'i` •• $ 0 j_ '' - ,, �O •ae a .._ [ - . _ ski 40=if f Ali 5 iJI `4 . , ►►►CCC ..:. . , .1 tiz; F . e •e I•. ` 'r / yytil�t - i r :...: .....j. -,. ...-. c. g •. , b '7 ,. ' �Y`'• $ '-'� .� ��-t + t fir. _•a"ti•c r..L'•• �. .. • �a ..mot _.. _` •',.,. '"`' , • :�, .. - ,Vi'µ,,. ''''; ,, t.,, nY �- ::::..c.,,,, .x, .. S .'� �f... ... } � ... :.1 .`* . : - .-- f,.., \ .. 4 F :,'ter wJ : �V 3 4--:-'''' j`�. •tY4•7:4r..; .. # X1. ..2 go, >, w. . . J .. i ,�: ::,I...r.,....:-1' ''.fit..:. .f.a.:1.,.;,,,:,.i, .'.1..., .,,,,,,,,..,,.:......0:...,.. 1 vu-r ..e.._ . .f r is - �`i`I 1Y �''r C §� 1 - 'f ice#' 1 . • . 3 a. ..' ; 4 1 .. $ ,, i 4 57 m li • i �O _ I'x x ,. _ , c w A 11..: 0 I r ye ....., '_� ..,'411.--..R 4