CESM Backup Docs 03/02/2007 2007 - Special
Magistrate
Backup
Documents
March 2, 2007
HEARING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY SPECIAL MASTER
AGENDA
Date: March 2,2007 at 8:30 A.M.
Location: 3301 E.Tamiami Trail,Naples,Florida,Collier County Government Center
Administrative Building"F",3rd Floor
NOTE: ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE SPECIAL MASTER WILL NEED A
RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO,AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A
VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND
EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. NEITHER COLLIER COUNTY NOR THE SPECIAL
MASTER SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR PROVIDING THIS RECORD.
I. CALL TO ORDER—Special Master Brenda Garretson presiding
A. Hearing rules and regulations
II. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES—February 16,2007
IV. MOTIONS FOR CONTINUANCE
CASE NO: 2006011073 (ARTICLE VI,A,4)
V. PUBLIC HEARINGS
A. Stipulations
B. Hearings
1. CASE NO: DAS 11270
OWNER: MATTHEW CLINTON HUBBARD
OFFICER: DAVID G.LEVITT#112
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING DOG TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 2396 SPRUCE STREET
2. CASE NO: DAS 11195
OWNER: JAMES ALLEN GIDDENS
OFFICER: KURT ZETTLER#114
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING DOG TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: HIGHLAND DRIVE
3. CASE NO: DAS 11155
OWNER: MELISSA COMPOS
OFFICER: WILLIAM GEORGE#113
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING ANIMAL TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 561 11TH STREET SW
4. CASE NO: DAS 11158
OWNER: MONICA ZAMARANO
OFFICER: WILLIAM GEORGE#113
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-41, SEC. (A)5
LEAVING AN ANIMAL IN A VEHICLE WITHOUT WATER AND PROPER
VENTILATION UNATTENDED.
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 5054 AIRPORT ROAD
5. CASE NO: DAS 11121
OWNER: LEANN NORRIS
OFFICER: ANITA MARTINDALE
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING A DOG OR CAT TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: BIRDSONG LANE
6. CASE NO: DAS 11122
OWNER: LEANN NORRIS
OFFICER: ANITA MARTINDALE
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING A DOG OR CAT TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: BIRDSONG LANE
7. CASE NO: DAS 11067
OWNER: ENRIQUE ACEVEDO
OFFICER: JORGE ARAUJO
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING DOG TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS:
8. CASE NO: DAS 11069
OWNER: BERNARDO CRUZ
OFFICER: JORGE ARAUJO
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(7)
SHEPARD SNAPPED&GROWLED,OTHERWISE THREATENED PERSON
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3590 RANDALL BLVD.
9. CASE NO: DAS 11070
OWNER: BERNARDO CRUZ
OFFICER: JORGE ARAUJO
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-34,PARA.(A)
FAILURE TO LICENSE ANIMAL
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3581 RANDALL BLVD.
10. CASE NO: DAS 11071
OWNER: BERNARDO CRUZ
OFFICER: JORGE ARAUJO
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(7)
SHEPARD SNAPPED&GROWLED,OTHERWISE THREATENED PERSON
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3590 RANDALL BLVD.
11. CASE NO: DAS 11072
OWNER: BERNARDO CRUZ
OFFICER: JORGE ARAUJO
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-34,PARA.(A)
FAILURE TO LICENSE ANIMAL
VIOLATION
ADDRESS:
12. CASE NO: DAS 11215
OWNER: WILLIAM BREEN
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING DOG TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
13. CASE NO: DAS 11218
OWNER: WILLIAM BREEN
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: 01W. 14-34,PARA.(B)
FAILURE TO VACCINATE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
14. CASE NO: DAS 11219
OWNER: WILLIAM BREEN
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: 01W. 14-36,PARA.A(5)
1ST AGGRAVATED: TO TRESPASS AND DESTROY PUBLIC PROPERTY
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
15. CASE NO: DAS 11220
OWNER: PAULA SOARES
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(2)
ALLOWING DOG TO RUN AT LARGE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
16. CASE NO: DAS 11221
OWNER: PAULA SOARES
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-34,PARA.A(4)
FAILURE TO AFFIX LICENSE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
17. CASE NO: DAS 11222
OWNER: PAULA SOARES
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-34,PARA.(B)
FAILURE TO VACCINATE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
18. CASE NO: DAS 11223
OWNER: PAULA SOARES
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-36,PARA.A(5)
1ST AGGRAVATED:TO TRESPASS AND DESTROY PUBLIC PROPERTY
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
19. CASE NO: DAS 11224
OWNER: WILLIAM BREEN
OFFICER: PAUL MORRIS
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 14-34,PARA.A(4)
FAILURE TO AFFIX LICENSE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 230 16TH STREET NE
20. CASE NO: CE 002634
OWNER: WALTER J.KANE JR.
OFFICER: CHRIS AMBACH
VIOLATIONS: ORD. SEC. 130-66,PARA.2(F)
PARKING WITHIN 100 FEET OF INTERSECTING RIGHT-OF-WAY
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: SUNSET DRIVE&GOODLAND DRIVE
21. CASE NO: 2006070516
OWNER: JUAN LUIS&ANA OCANAS
OFFICER: CRISTINE PEREZ
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41, SEC.2.01.00(A)
INOPERABLE/UNTAGGED VEHICLES
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 4801 MIRAHAM DRIVE IMMOKALEE,FL
22. CASE NO: 2006070623
OWNER: JOSE FINA MUNOZ
OFFICER: CRISTINE PEREZ
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 05-44, SEC. 6,7,&8
UNLAWFUL LITTER
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3026 IMMOKALEE DRIVE IMMOKALEE,FL
23. CASE NO: 2006120183
OWNER: JOSE FINA MUNOZ
OFFICER: CRISTINE PEREZ
VIOLATIONS: ORD.04-41, SEC. 2.01.00(A)
INOPERABLE/UNTAGGED VEHICLES
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3026 IMMOKALEE DRIVE IMMOKALEE,FL
24. CASE NO: 2006080378
OWNER: CAROL L.CANOVA
OFFICER: CRISTINE PEREZ
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41, SEC.2.01.00(A)
INOPERABLE/UNTAGGED VEHICLES
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 1605 CARSON ROAD IMMOKALEE,FL
25. CASE NO: 2006100235
OWNER: KELLY E.CAPOLINO
OFFICER: JOE MUCHA
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-58, SEC. 6, SUBSEC.
1,8,9,10,11,12A,12B,12C,12I,12J,12K,12L,12M,120,12P,12Q,12R,19A,9B,19C,19D AND 20
MULTIPLE MINIMUM HOUSING CODE VIOLATIONS
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 2721 VAN BUREN AVENUE
26. CASE NO: 2006070273
OWNER: PATRICE MOBLEY
OFFICER: JOE MUCHA
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-58, SEC. 6, SUBSEC. 11,12C,12I,AND 12P
MULTIPLE MINIMUM HOUSING CODE VIOLATIONS
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 5260 DIXIE DRIVE
27. CASE NO: 2006100656
OWNER: NORBERTO AND JOSE F.A.DE LA ROSA
OFFICER: THOMAS KEEGAN
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41, SEC.2.01.00(C
COMMERCIAL VEHICLE/EQUIPMENT IN A RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 616 POINSETTA STREET
28. CASE NO: 2006090205
OWNER: WENDY L.KLODT
OFFICER: STEVE ATHEY
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-58,SEC. 7(5)
RENTAL REGISTRATION
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 325 DUNES BLVD. #402,NAPLES
29. CASE NO: CE 002331
OWNER: JAMES S.CARRUTHERS
OFFICER: HEINZ BOX
VIOLATIONS: ORD. SEC. 130-66,PARA.2(F)
UNLAWFUL PARKING-ALONG SIDE RAOD IN RIGHT OF WAY.
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 1725 CAMELIA LANE
VI.NEW BUSINESS
A. Motion for Imposition of Fines:
1. CASE NO: 2005030060
OWNER: JOAN HANDSHAW
OFFICER: CHRIS AMBACH
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41, SEC. 10.02.06&ORD. 04-58, SEC. 6
UNSAFE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE-NO PERMIT
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 875 109TH AVENUE N.
2. CASE NO: 2005050256
OWNER: STEPHEN W.SCHESSLER
OFFICER: HEATHER GRIMSHAW
VIOLATIONS: ORD.99-51,SEC. 6,7&8
LITTER/ABANDONED ITEMS ON PROPERTY
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 1216 ROSEMARY LANE
3. CASE NO: 2005110329
OWNER: TERESO BAUTISA&EMILIANA LPOEZ VAASQUEZ
OFFICER: STEVE ATHEY
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41, SEC. 10.02.06
ALTERATION OF RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURE WITHOUT PERMITS
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3545 23RD AVENUE SW
4. CASE NO: 2005120555
OWNER: JOAQUIN&MAGDALENA SANTIAGO
OFFICER: JEFF LETOURNEAU
VIOLATIONS: ORD.04-41, SEC. 10.02.06
NON-PERMITTED RENOVATIONS TO 1ST FLOOR
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 5349 TRAMMEL STREET
5. CASE NO: 2006011073
OWNER: MARIA MIRIA ZARAGOZA
OFFICER: CARMELO GOMEZ
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41,SEC. 10.02.06
ADDITION TO HOUSE WITHOUT PERMIT
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 1822 43RD STREET SW
6. CASE NO: CO-4229
OWNER: RONALD ZBIKOWSKI
OFFICER: CHRIS AMBACH
VIOLATIONS: ORD.05-44, SEC. 6,7,&8
LITTER
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 291 11TH STREET SW
7. CASE NO: 2006030180
OWNER: ARCADIO ZEPEDA JR.&ALICIA Z LOPEZ
OFFICER: THOMAS KEEGAN
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41, SEC.2.01.00
UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 233 ADAMS AVENUE E. IMMOKALEE,FL
8. CASE NO: 2006030179
OWNER: ALICIA LOPEZ&ARCADIA ZEPEDA
OFFICER: THOMAS KEEGAN
VIOLATIONS: ORD.05-44, SEC. 6,7,&8
ACCUMULATION OF LITTER
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 233 ADAMS AVENUE E. IMMOKALEE,FL
9. CASE NO: 2005020227
OWNER: FERNANDO GUTIERREZ
OFFICER: JOHN SANTAFEMIA
VIOLATIONS: ORD.04-41,SEC. 10.02.06 &ORD.02-01, SEC. 104.1.1
GARAGE CONVERTED TO LIVING SPACE WITHOUT PERMIT
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3101 41ST STREET SW
10. CASE NO: 2006040807
OWNER: PAUL ZAINO
OFFICER: EVERILO YBACETA
VIOLATIONS: FLORIDA BLDG CODE
CHAINLINK&WOODEN PRIVACY FENCE WITHOUT PERMIT
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3341 CORANA WAY
11. CASE NO: 2006020919
OWNER: PAUL ZAINO
OFFICER: EVERILO YBACETA
VIOLATIONS: ORD.04-41, SEC. 10.02.06(B)(1)(A), 10.02.06(B)(1)(D)(1)AND 2004 FLORIDA
BLDG CODE,SEC. 105.1
NO PERMITS FOR EXTERIOR WINDOW OR SCREEN LANAI
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3341 CORANA WAY
B. Motion for Reduction of Fines:
1. CASE NO: 2005020443
OWNER: RAFAEL MORALES&JUANA PEREZ
OFFICER: JOE MUCHA
VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41, SEC 10.02.06 AND ORD.2000-01, SEC. 104.1.1 & 105.5
GARAGE CONVERTED TO LIVING SPACE WITHOUT PERMIT
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 5204 FLORIDIAN AVENUE
VII.OLD BUSINESS
A. Request to forward case for Collections/Foreclosure:
VIII.CONSENT AGENDA-
A. Recommendation to approve the Imposition of Lien for owners of record who have failed to pay invoices
resulting from nuisance abatement violation enforcement actions.
IX.REPORTS
1. CASE NO: 2005020698
OWNER: NAPLES SOUTH REALTY
OFFICER: EVERILO YBACETA
VIOLATIONS: ORD.04-41,SEC. 5.03.04 E
TRASH DUMPSTER WITHOUT REQUIRED SCREENING
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 4905 RATTLESNAKE HAMMOCK
X. NEXT MEETING DATE: March 16,2007
XI.ADJOURN
' CDPR0002 - Image Print
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 comm veh
IMAGE DATE COUNTY EXHIBIT
11/22/2006 Cal►�aSiX£ COUNTY-
A c20 66!OO L,5
,7J:01001). *" *ifig , ';',"4, "V=.,;/
''''-'4;',11%.,,,:, . ,r...... !sr A.„,_ ,,,,..- . pr,,,,,,A,,P4;.<4,,.... .-*j'
- .. -I "4' - Lt°.i , :- - ,-,,,iv, --,.'. .,,,,','
14 i
! ,,yam ,Al
i
. , ,
4.
...., ....„.b
11'2n`'2006 1 i4 am
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:27:50 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
•
•
,
k
a
i
b
y
A
t
t
as 3 4�.3
` f 1
a_
fit !, 1 It, r,
e
P
' ' e C 4 ten ..
CDPR0002 - Image Print
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 comm vehicle on property zoned rsf 3
IMAGE DATE
11/22/2006
• & -Ii!
.t.
iv
�An
1 1122 2. 19 i wit
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:28:56 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
CDPR0002 - Image Print
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 bus on property zoned rsf 3
IMAGE DATE
11/22/2006
4111ft • ` a° gam " ,� :
' a
1112:21,%2006 11 ani
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:28:47 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
CDPR0002 - Image Print
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 comm vehicles on property zoned RSF 3
IMAGE DATE
11/22/2006
1111 111111■ ....II i r--) -1()
— y s> y K
.4 414
'41(41.1.114.1`,....;.: . .,,,,,,,,.4.,,,,, t,,,,.. ,
„, . . . . 4, , .
...........................i .;. . . .,...,
. ,.,
...... ............. .
.., ,i _ .. ,
...., .._ _...
. .
__
1 1 12.X6 1
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:28: 10 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
•
CDPR0002 - Image Print
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 comm veh on prop zoned RSF-3
IMAGE DATE
il
10/24/2006
) bj , . ...• .-
V''''''■' '-''''m '-''',',....'1'''k.z.,'"- ''''^''',,,,'' '. '. a it,. ,, . r , ,... ,
,, ,, ,...,:-,., ..,..,t,„1:1-4,:::-,-, ...-, ...k,
If g
10,24m ' J0 a
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:27:31 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
CDPR0002 - Image Print
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 buses on property zoned rsf 3
IMAGE DATE
11/22/2006
mss+! e [ } s ,—
.4 1° .
� � 4 t' is 't t. + rte.
r
'.
.:,.:.,
g
11t22<„ 11 .4 ay',
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:27:41 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
CDPR0002 - Image Print
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 NOH posted at property
'48 0 '.. ..- . - ' , . :111;
IMAGE DATE
2/13/2007
441,‘" " lie '
it ftk
ft
--ift'
s
'AI, �� . : t
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:28:21 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
'
e Print CDPR0002 - Imag
CD-Plus Report - Code Case Image
CODE CASE NUMBER IMAGE DESCRIPTION
2006100656 comm veh remains
IMAGE DATE
12/27/2006
, ,,..1010.:'..:.:
, 6Naki4 'EN1' .1() .. , ,,. , ,,
a
A PI
1212712 '0 46
Collier County Printed on 2/28/2007 3:28:01 PM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Page 1
p
Nj
Y
. 5: ......4111:114itiAt'T :1 -.%.'":-:s:::'::
tti
E b v t ate.
g f H
/\ 3 S^ y I gg A Y.
.,........ . ,,..„...._..„,, „...
i mac ``
0
4
" ,( >44
16..3
•
� x
r
z 1
a�
• K
^2� 1
g 3.
•
•
LYL
r ' C. �. .7
t
•! .a ., ^110
n 3� a
re',ro
µ c.
�,r+ Ik41_ -. a `°�
is
x
k Ip'
4.
y M
i
V
^°,Y. tlf-ky 4 Ppp Il
2 �. rrx, a - sr y� .
..... .: „ G.,'f : 4„ �:iRE', N,u .. ,RYF k I£§ '' 4 d hn
�J _ f4 .p` tom'
M
6
,
�4
£f _ _i,f� ..t.,---1
��s!4 !fi`E-r��fM':' � :�;-F Y-,�gn
II' 4per{ y- 7-4:-�:41 !S, 1 ...L.
1e1,11:'!,.',,,v,,;.: b! e ff
f c li
,...- ., .. ., ':, �+" �#ate; �. 'k,4 i _ ..� ejp 3. s
s t a � s 'u � �
! .i Y fi. ''''''l " }, et r u. v aA r."ar§?t e z '>4-- t:, t ( v
fL rflii F.f -i. �3P : 3z— YC �' 4f .n N
..ce.+ _,W v —,7.?'', ��, ie X45 hh P4--¢ ry `
i ' c F 'fir"
F
��$ �1-� �x4 B,-'5.-' b.)
a �1
J�T X--' �� ",:I _3J f y
z
i
3 i - 4-g.L"f"--', i
Page 1 of 1
Teresa L. Polaski
From: MitchellDennis [DennisMitchell @colliergov.net]
Sent: Monday, March 19, 2007 3:51 PM
To: Teresa L. Polaski
Subject: RE:
Hi Teresa. Yes that is the correct case number. The ase started out as a citation. That's why the descripancy.
Thanks for asking . . .
Dennis Mitchell
Investigative Supervisor
F.A.C.E.III Certified
2800 Horseshoe Drive North
Naples,FL.34104
239-403-2496-Office
239-403-2343-Fax
239-877-8142-Cell
ATTENTION:Be advised that under Florida's Government-in-the-Sunshine law,information contained within this email
becomes public record,unless protected by specific exemption.The law provides a right of access to governmental
proceedings and documents at both the state and local levels.There is also a constitutionally guaranteed right of access.For
more information on this law,visit:Florida's Sunshine Law
From: Teresa L. Polaski [mailto:Teresa.Polaski @clerk.collier.fl.us]
Sent: Monday, March 19, 2007 2:52 PM
To: MitchellDennis
Subject:
Good afternoon,
We received in some Special Master orders today and I am certifying them and checking them off of the agenda,
one case has a different case number on the order compared to what is on the agenda. Regarding Ronald
Zbikowski Case#2005-120473 (this is the number on the actual order) I just want to make sure we have the
correct number before it is recorded.
Teresa L. Polaski
Clerk to the Board of County Commissioners
Minutes and Records Department
239-774-8411
(Teresa.Polaski@clerk.collier.fl.us)
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a
public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing.
3/19/2007