Recap 01/22/1991 RNOTICE:
COLLIER COUNTY
DQARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
AGENDA
Tuesday, January ZZ, 1991
9:00 a.m.
ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON ANY AGENDA ITEM MUST
REGISTER PRIOR TO SPEAKING.
REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON SUBJECTS WHICH ARE NOT
ON THIS AGENDA MUST BE SUBMITTED IN WRITING WITH
EXPLANATION TO THE COUNTY MANAGER AT LEAST 13 DAYS PRIOR
TO THE DATE OF THE MEETING AND WILL BE HEARD UNDER
"PUBLIC PETITIONS" IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING THE ADVERTISED
PUBLIC HEARINGS.
ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS
BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING
THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A
VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD
INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE
APPEAL IS TO BE BASED.
1. INVOCATION
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
APPRQVAL OF AGENDA AND CONSENT AGENDA
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
November 20, 1990 regular meeting.
Approved. w/changes
5/O
Approved as presented
5/0
PROCLAMATIONS AND SERVICE AWARDS
Recommendation to recognize Richard D'Orazio, Emergency
Services Division, as Employee of the Month for January,
1991.
B. Proclamation - recognizing Joan Jenks
Recognized
Adopted. 5/0
ADD:
C. Service award to Francis B. Black - 10 years
Library/Naples Branch.
Presented
ADD:
Proclamation designating the week of January 19th - 26th,
1991 as. "Purple Martin Time".
1
Adopted 5/0
January 22, 1991
6. ~QVERT!SED pUBLIC HEARINGS - BCC
A. COF~PREMENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENTS
B. ~NING AMENDMENTS
/ (1) R-90-18, Robert L. Duane of Hole, Montes &
/ Associates, Inc., representing Francis D. Hussey,
~ requesting a rezone from C-4 to PUD for property
~/ located east of U.S. 41 and west of Old U.S. 41 in
~ Sec: 10, T48S, R25E, consisting of 34.2 acres.
(2) R-~0-33, S~e~ O~Steen o~ D~e~s~on O~e
~c., representing Su~er Glen of I~okalee, Ltd.,
requesting a rezone from A-2MH to PUD to be known as
Summer Glen Apartments for 46 affordable housing
units for property located on the south side of Lake
Trafford .Road (C.R. 850), approximately 1 mile west
of S.R. 29 and approximately 500 feet west of Palm
Drive in Sec. 32, T46S, R29E, consisting of 7.43
acres.
Ord. 91-5 Adopted
as amended 5/0
Ord. 91-7 Adopted subj
to changes in stips. a
Affordable Housing
Agreement approved by
Board. 5/0 ,: ~..
~,- i~?. ?~.3.)i R-90-25, .... Michael~:',
Marcus of Morris-Depew
Associates, Inc., representing Desha N. Sanders, Jr.,
:.-- .Trustee,., requesting a'rezone from RSFv4:to C-4 for
~e;-~'retail:;;shopp~ngcenter/business offices for property
· located on the south side of Pine Ridge Road,
approximately 740 feet east of U.S. 41 in Sec. 15,
T49S, R25E, consisting of 4.2± acres. (Continued
indefinitely)
C. OTHER
CONTINUED TO
2/5/91 MEETING
(1) Petition AV-90-014, Anchor Engineering as agent for
owner, Amilcar, Inc., requesting vacation of all
public interest in.a portion of an eighty foot (80')
road right-of-way platted as Goodland Drive on the
plat of Marco Beach Unit 13, as recorded in Plat Book
6, Pages 105-106, as recorded in the public records
of Collier County, Florida.
Continued indefinitely
Continued to 2/5/91
Pet~ition PDA-89-1 and DOA-89-1, George Vega of Vega,
2
January 22, 1991
DO 91~,; RES 91-37;
ORD 91-6 - Adopted. 5/0
Brown, Stanley & Martin, P.A., representing Donald K.
Ross and Robert B. Leeber (Defined Benefit Pension
Trust) requesting an amendment to the Marco Shores
(Isle of Capri Commercial Tract) Planned Unit
Development Document and Development of Regional
Impact Development Order. (Continued from the
meeting of January 8, 1991)
CONTINUED TO
1/29/91 MEETING
(3) Petition SMP-90-35, Robert A. McGinnis requesting
Subdivision Master Plan approval for Bass Point, a
portion of Tract 48, less the north 150 feet and
portions described, Golden Gate Estates, Unit 30,
Sec. 29, T49S, R26E, consisting of 5± acres.
Continued to 1/29/91
/~'Petition CCSL-90-12, Westinghouse Communities of
Naples, Inc., representing Westinghouse Communities
of Naples, Inc., and Collier County Board of
Commissioners requesting a coastal construction
setback line variance for the construction of utility
services to the Pelican Bay North Beach facility from
the strand in Pelican Bay Unit "8", Sec. 5, T49S,
R25E. (Continued from the meeting of January 8 1991)
Res. 91-38 Adopted
subject to stipulation
as amended. 4/1 (Comm
Hasse opposed).
(5) Petition DOA-90-6, George L Varnadoe of Young, van
Assenderp, Varnadoe & Benton, P.A., representing Elba
Development Corporation, requesting amendments to the
Brettone Park Development Order 87-2 as previously
amended by Development Order 88-1, for property
located on the south side of Radio Road, on the north
side of Davis Boulevard, and approximately 1/2 mile
west of Santa Barbara Boulevard ~in Sec. 5, T50S,
R26E. (Continued indefinitely)
Continued indefinitely
/6) Ordinance creating
(C.A.T.) Program.
the Combat
Automobile Theft
Ord. 9]~8 Adopted
4/1 (Cbm~. V6I~e oDpos~
7. BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
A. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
CONTINUED TO ~
3
January 22, 1991
2/26/91 MEETING
(1) Petition FDPO-90-4, Marty V. Ellington, requesting a Continued to 2/26/91
variance from the minimum base flood elevation as
required by Flood Damage Prevention Ordinance (FDPO)
Number 87-80 on property described as 629 Palm
Avenue, Lot 18, Block C, Goodland Isles. (Continued
from the meeting of December 18, 1990)
CONTINUED TO
2/26/91 MEETING
(2) Petition FDPO-90-3, Gary Weeks requesting a variance Continued to 2/26/91
from the minimum base flood elevation as~requi~ed by ~ _
Flood Damage.Prevention Ordinance (FDPO) Number 87-80
on. propertydescribed as 239 Harbor,Place (Lot 10,
~9c~.6,~ ~uod%an~ .Hei~h~st~bdi~si0~)~ (Continued
from the meeting of December 18, 199~)
END OF ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
(1) ?e2ition PU~90-28, Mrs. Crews of Crews Salvage Res. #91-39 Adopted
requesting !provisional use "B" of Section 8.10 subject to Agreement
(Rssentiat. Services) within the C,5 Zpning District Sheet 5/0
for a Transfer Station for property located at 105 '
East New Market Road, further described as Lots 9,
10, 11 and 12, Block 44, New Market Subdivision, Sec.
34, T46S, R29E, consisting of 0.21 acres.
B. PROVISIONAL USE~
Petition PU-90-25, David S. Wilkison, P.E.,
representing? Immokalee Auto .Sales, .Inc., requesting
provisional use "g" of the C-4 District to establish
a used car-lot.
Res. 991-40 Adopted
subject to Agreement
Sheet. 5/0
(3) Pgtition PU-90-21, Ervin Ross, representing East
~aples Baptist Church, Inc., requesting provisional
/use "a" of the RMF-6 zoning district for parking lots
/ and for two educational buildings to be accessory to
/ a_ church for property located on the east side of
Shadowlawn Drive and south of Connecticut Avenue,
further described as Lots 22, 23, 24, 25, and 26,
Block 3, Naples Better Homes Subdivision, and Lot 27,
Block 3, First Addition to Naples Better Homes
Subdivision in Sec. 11, T50S, R25E, East Naples,
consisting of 0.95 acres.
January 22, 1991
Res. ,~91-36 Adopted
with Agreement Sheet
as amended. 5/0 -,,,
(4) PU-90-23,
Terranee L. Kepple of Bruce Green &
Associates, Inc., representing Deltona Utilities,
Inc., requesting provisional use "b" of Sec. 8.10
within the RSF-4 zoning district for reverse osmosis
water treatment, storage and pumping plant and
associated facilities for property described as Tract
G, Marco Beach Unit 25, Secs. 16 and 17, T52S, R26E,
consisting of 7.68 acres.
Continued until 2/5/9
directed'staff to wor
w/Petitioner to provi
a study of an alterna
site w/cost compariso
3/2 (Commissioners
Volpe & Shanahan oppo
8. pUBLIC PETITIONS
A. Charles Strader, representing Southwest Florida
Archaeological society regarding County property for
laboratory facilities.
B. This item has been deleted.
Staff to meet w/petitJ
er and evaluate costs
to County to provide
insurance coverage and
bring back recommenda-
tions within 2 weeks.
5/O
Deleted.
Hispanic Chamber of Commerce of Collier County requesting
reconsideration of decision regarding Tourist Development
Council Advisory Board member selection.
Jerry C. Bosworth representing Sanders Pines SDP #89-220.
Commissioners $aunder~
& Shanahan to work w/
Hispanic Society to
encourage particiDati¢
by Hispanics to apply
for advisory board
memberships (Consensus
No Action Taken.
CONTINUED TO
2/26/91 MEETING
E. Marsha A. Gibbs representing Michelbob's - signage.
Continued to 2/26/91
F. Paul Hoffman regarding sovereignty.
No Action Taken.
Go
James R. Farral-i representing Golden Gate Presbyterian
5
January 22, 1991
Church requesting relocation.
No Action taken.
Robert i A.
B~er regarding East Naples baseball field.
County Manager author
ized to allocate staf
to perform labor. 5/
9. COUNTY MANAGER'S REPORT
/~~A. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
· -:a~.:,~o[th~ status~f c~rren%'pr~posa!s :fo~ a:"Sunset
~visiOn~relative to PUD rezones.
ment.~to..Ord~ 82~2 re
Sunset provisions .7~ .
B. TRANSPORTATION
C. PUBLIC SERVICES
D. UTILITIES
E. ADMINISTRATIV~ SERV~$S
F. EMERGENCY~SERVIC~S
G. ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
H. COUNTY MANAGER
CONTINUED TO
1 MEETING
~ . ~(1) Appointment of members of the-Pelican Bay Municipal
Services Taxing and Benefit Unit Advisory Committee.
C0nti~ued to 1~/91
(2) Report to the Board of County Commissioners on the Report accepted and
financing of the R~ad Improvement Element of the interim financing plan
County's Comprehensive Plan. to be brought back. 5/~
10, COUNTY ATTORNEy'S REPORT
' 11. CLERK TO THE BOARD'S REPORT
'A. Budget Amendments
6
January 22, 1991
(1) Regarding matters not previously discu~ged: 3
(2) Regarding matters previously discussed: 2
(3) Budget Amendment Resolution No. NONE
BA's 91-77/79 Adoptel
5/0
BA's 91-76 and 91-80
Adopted. 5/0
B. Tabulation of Contracts and Documents (as of noon
previous Tuesday).
Analysis of Changes to Reserves for Contingencies
(1) General Fund (001)
(2) Facilities Construction Fund (301)
(3) Community Development Fund (113)
12. BO~D OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
~_~/. Recommendation to appoint three members
Gate Community Center Advisory Committee.
to the Golden
Res. #91-41 appointin~
Scott L. F~ench,
Sarah Sparks and
Joan Jenks Adopted. 5
13. OTHER CONSTITUTIQNAL OFFICERS
14.
CONSENT AGENDA
All matters listed under this item are considered to be
routine and action will be taken by one motion without
separate discussion of each item. If discussion is desired
by a member of the Board, that item(s) will be removed from
the Consent Agenda and considered separately.
A.~ COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
(1) Recommendation to grant preliminary acceptance of the
roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements for
the final plat of "Queens Park at Lago Verdi, Phase
Approved and/or Adopte~
5/0:
Res. ~91-42 w/stips
/~) Recommendation to grant preliminary acceptance of the
roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements for
the final plat of "Queens Park at Lago Verdi, Phase
II".
Res. #91-43 w/stips
Recommendation to grant preliminary acceptance of the
roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements for
the. final. plat of "Queens Park at Lago Verdi, Phase
January 22, 1991
Res. #91-44 w/stips
Recommendation to accept the security for Home Depot,
U.S.A. Irrevocable Standby Letter of Credit No.
29150.
Recommendation to approve for recording the final w/stips
plat of "Crystal Lake RV Resort, Phase Two".
(6) Recommendation to approve lien resolution for the
~'a) Compliance Services Case No. 90-08-07445. Owner
of record - Charles B. Bolton.
Compliance Services case No. 90-06-02859. Owners
of record - Louis Cambruzzi and Loretta
Cambruz z i.
Res. #91-45
Res. #9I-~6'~
Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-06437. Owners Res. #91-47
of record - Bernard M. Collins and Colleen P.
Collins.
· Compliance. Services Case :No. 90-,08-07651~ Owners Res. 991-48
Of . reoord.'".~-~. Marlene?-Eguizabal and Casimiro
Eguizabal.
Compliance Services Case No. 90-08-06662. Owner
of record - Richard W. Field.
Compliance Services Case No. 90-08-07346. Owner
of record - A. Paul Gregg, Trustee.
~Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-05295. Owners
of record - James P. McCarthy and Karen A.
McCarthy.
Res. #9]-49
Res. #9].-50
Res. 91-51
January 22, 1991
h) Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-06232. Owners
of record - Patricia R. Mikelson and Robert D.
. Richter, Trustee.
'~ ,~, ~(i) Compliance Services Case No. 90-08-07492.
of record - P.S. Hanu Group, Inc.
Owner
Res. #91-52
Res. 991-53
Compliance Services Case No. 90-08-07636.
of record - Sea Con Industries Corporation.
Owner
Res. #91-54
Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-04487. Owner
of record - Howard John Schulte.
Res. ~91-55
~ ~1) Complianc~ Services Case No. 90-08-07573.
< of record - Tract B, Inc.
Owner
~m) Compliance Services Case No. 90-05-01390. Owner
of record - David Ward, Jr.
(n) Compliance Services Case No. W89-6630. Owners of
record - Mateo Ayala, Jesus Ayala, and Salvador
Ayala.
· ~'~ ~ ~o) Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-04393.
~.~/~. of r~ord - Bonifacio H. Alonsoi
Owner
Res. #91-56
Res. ~91-57
Res. 991-58
Res. #91-59
Compliance Services Case No. 90-06-03843. Owners
of record - Robert Ralph Atkins and Carolyn A.
Atkins.
i ~//(q) Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-05228. Owners
~t of record - Leonard Bubri and Gary Weinberg.
/, mpliance Services Case No.
~- V of record - Theresa Corda.
9
90-07-04884. Owner
January 22, 1991
Res. 991-60
Res. #91-61
Res. #91-62
Compliance Services Case No.
of record - Mary Esposito.
90-06-03316. Owner
Res. #91-63
~'~./~~t) compliance Services case No. 90-06-03052. Owner Res. #91-64
of record - Joseph J. Lauren, Trustee under
Joseph J. Lauren Trust.
Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-05067. Owner
of record - Thomas J. Liska.
Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-05376. Owner
of record - Robert J. Levine and Maurine L.
Levine.
Compliance Services Case No. 90-06-03642. Owner
of record - Marco Media Enterprises.
Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-06203.
of record - Earl N. Miller.
Owner
compliance services case NO. 90-07'06179
of record - John D. Offutt, Trustee.
Owner
Compliance Services Case No. 90~07-05253. Owners
of record - Edward J. Pelc and Laverda L. Pelc.
Res. #91-65
Res. 991-66
Res. #91-67
P. es. %91-68
Res. #91-69
Res. #91-70
compliance services case No. 90-07-04419. Owners
of record - Vincent Solimine and Marilyn A.
Solimine.
Res. ~91-71
~/. (~)compliance services Case No. 90-04-00947. Owners
/~ ~/ of record - Howard C. Hool and Irene L. Hool.
'% \~ompliance Services Case No. W89-6469. Owners of
.record. _--George L. McDonald, Joseph McDonald and
10
January 22, 1991
Res. #91-72
Res. #91-73
Robert M. McDonald.
'dd)
Compliance Services Case No. 90-06-04250. Owners
of record - George L. McDonald, Joseph McDonald
and Robert M. McDonald.
ee)
Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-05724. Owners
of record - George L. McDonald, Joseph McDonald
and Robert M. McDonald.
Compliance Services Case No. 90-07-05256. Owners
of record - Florence O'Connor and Gordon
Sherwood.
Compliance Services Case No. W90-8604. Owners of
record - The Henry Oliver Trust, Florida Sunbelt
Properties, Inc., as Trustee with William D.
Collins, Jr., President.
Res. #91-74
Res. #91-75
Res. #91-76
Reso #91-77
(~ Compliance Services Case No. 90-06-03267. Owners
of record - Raymond J. Prindiville and Johanna M.
~'~/ Prindiville.
/
.Compliance Services Case No. W89-7927. Owners of
record - Frank S. Szymanski and Carrie J.
Szymanski.
WITHDRAWN:
(7) Recommendation to approve the final plat of "Paradise
Pointe R.V. Resort, Phase One". (Continued from the
meeting of 1/15/91)
Res. #91-7~
Res. #91-79
Withdrawn
B. /TRANSPORTATION
/(1) Recommendation to accept a Drainage Easement located
along Gulf Shore Drive from Clyde C. Quinby, Trustee
for Watermark Condominium.
Recommendation to approve a resolution and joint
participation agreement with the Florida Department
of Transportation for the maintenance of Bridge
11
January 22, 1991
Res. #91-80
#030121 on C.R. 92.
(3) Recommendation to approve the short-list of
professional engineering firms to fulfill design,
right-of-way, and permitting requirements for planned
four-laning of 111th Avenue and Vanderbilt Drive, CIE
Project Nos. 001 and 025.
(4) Recommendation to procure professional engineering
services to fulfill design, right-of-way, and
permitting requirements for roadway improvements to
Santa Barbara Boulevard/Logan, Santa Barbara
Boulevard, and County Barn Road; CIE Project Nos.
C. PUBLIC SERVICES
D. UTILITIES
E. ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES
(1) Recommendation to Approve and Accept the
Subordination, Consent and Joinder of Easement from
Westinghouse Communities and the Twenty (20) Foot
Permanent Utility Easement from Oak Lake Sanctuary of
Pelican Bay.
(1) Recommendation to select newspaper for advertisement
of Delinquent Tax Roll.
Recommendation to establish three new pay titles and
delete two existing pay titles.
(3) Recommendation to accept selection Committee's
shortlist on RFP #90-1654 for architectural services
for the renovation of Collier County Government
Building "B" and authorize staff to negotiate an
architectural contract with the top ranked firm.
F. EMERGENCY SERVICES . -
~.~. /(1) Request Board to authorize the Chairperson to sign
the resolution, county grant application and the
grant distribution form.
Naples Daily News
Res. #91-81
Res. #91-82
12
January 22, 1991
(2) Recommendation to approve and accept a warranty deed
from the Golden Gate Fire and Rescue District to
Collier County for a portion of Block 115, Golden
Gate, Unit Number 4.
G. ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
(1) Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
award Bid #90-1617 for a track type dozer for
$128,676.00 to the low bidder, Adams Dewind Machinery
of Fort Myers.
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners
accept the Third Year Recycling & Education and Waste
Tire Grants and authorize the Chairperson to sign the
acceptance agreement.
H. COUNTY MANAGER
I. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
A. Approval of appointments to the Collier County
Housing Authority by Governor.
J. MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE
1. Certificate for Correction: NEED MOTION authorizing the
Chairman to sign Certificate for Correction to the tax
rolls as presented by the Property Appraiser's Office.
RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
Res. #91-83 appointin~
Dorcas F. Howard and
Jose H. Betancourt
K. OT~ER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
L. COUNTY ATTORNEY
15. ADJOURN
13
January 22, 1991