Loading...
CLB Agenda 09/19/2012 Co er County COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD AGENDA SEPTEMBER 19, 2012 9:00 A.M. COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS CHAMBERS ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THAT TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. I. ROLL CALL II. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS: III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA: IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: DATE: August 15, 2012 V. DISCUSSION: (A) Repealing County Ord. No. 82-20 As Amended. VI. NEW BUSINESS: (A) David Goff—Waiver of Examination(s) VII. OLD BUSINESS: (A) Orders of the Board (B) C.L.B Case 2012-03— Linda Curiale— D/B/A Global Maintenance & Restoration, Inc. VIII. PUBLIC HEARINGS: (A) C.L.B. Case 2012-10— Linda Curiale— D/B/A Global Maintenance & Restoration, Inc. IX. REPORTS: X. NEXT MEETING DATE: WEDNESDAY OCTOBER 17, 2012 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING THIRD FLOOR IN COMMISSIONERS CHAMBERS 3299 E. TAMIAMI TRAIL NAPLES, FL 34112 August 15, 2012 MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD MEETING August 15, 2012 Naples, Florida LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, Collier County Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present: CHAIRMAN: Lee Horn Vice Chair: Richard Joslin Michael Boyd Terry Jerulle Thomas Lykos Robert Meister Jon Walker Excused: Kyle Lantz Patrick White ALSO PRESENT: Michael Ossorio — Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office James F. Morey, Esq. —Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board Jeff Wright, Esq. —Assistant County Attorney Rob Ganguli —Licensing Compliance Officer Karen Clements —Licensing Compliance Officer 1 August 15,2012 NOTE: Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the Appeal is to be based. I. ROLL CALL: Chairman Lee Horn called the meeting to order at 9:02 AM and read the procedures to be followed to appeal a decision. Roll call was taken and a quorum was established. Seven members were present. II. AGENDA—ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS: (None) III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA: Thomas Lykos moved to approve the Agenda as presented. Second by Vice Chairman Joslin. Carried unanimously, 7—0. IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES—June 20,2012: Changes: • Page 13, under question by Vice Chairman Joslin, the amount of the payment made was corrected to $4,919.70. Thomas Lykos moved to approve the Minutes as amended. Second by Jon Walker. Carried unanimously, 6—0. (Note: Robert Meister could not vote to approve the Minutes because he did not attend the June 20m meeting.) V. DISCUSSION: (None) VI. NEW BUSINESS: (Note: In cases heard under Sections VI and VII, the individuals who testified were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.) A. Doreen J. Visser—Contesting Citation Business: "Willowood Home Design,LLC, d/b/a Willowood Kitchen & Bath" Citation(s): #7165 ("Unlicensed Advertising") Date Issued: June 15, 2012 Fine Amount: $300.00 2 August 15,2012 Description of Violation: Engage in the business or act in the capacity of a Contractor, or advertise self or business organization as available to engage in the business of or act in the capacity of a Contractor, without being duly registered or certified. Raymond Visser: • He was contacted by Rob Ganguli concerning a problem with the company website; • The problem was the word"installers;" • When they purchased the business,the website was already running; • The website is hosted by"Kitchens.com;" • They had no idea they were in any violation due to the language on the website; • They added, "Legal Notice: Local permitting, licensing, and Codes apply"to all pages of the website; • It is an"international" website—they do business internationally; • Does not understand how Collier County can claim to have jurisdiction over a world-wide website; • Does not think they should have been cited without first receiving a warning and an explanation of why there was a violation—he thought they had corrected the problem. Chairman Horn asked how long ago they purchased the business and the response was"six years ago." He noted the language that caught his attention on the website was: "In addition to providing the professional installation of cabinets and countertops, we are able to arrange for plumbing, electrical work, or major structural jobs—whatever you need " Chairman Horn continued, stating his problem was that the Vissers were not licensed—they merely had a Business Tax Receipt and only made cabinets. Mr. Visser responded if a customer needed a General Contractor,they would make a referral ("introduction)—the website stated "to arrange for." Chairman Horn explained that was one of the functions of a General Contractor and may have been why they were cited. Mr. Visser stated he was informed by Michael Ossorio of another problem --the only category of subcontractor he could hire was a cabinet installer. He thought he had been cited only for the language issue. Chairman Horn asked Rob Ganguli to explain why the Citation was issued. Rob Ganguli, Collier County Licensing Compliance Officer, stated: • A complaint was received by the Contractors' Licensing Office on May 22nd regarding internet advertising of Willowood Home Designs, LLC, stating they could provide cabinet installation services; 3 August 15,2012 • There was no information concerning licensing—the owners had only a Business Tax Receipt for retail sales; • Mr. Ganguli contacted the owners and advised them of the complaint and the violation. Abatement measures were discussed. • On June 15th, he met with Doreen and Raymond Visser: o The disclaimer has been placed on the website in an effort to come into compliance; o He noted that the Visser had taken remedial action; o A Citation was issued for"advertising self or business organization as available to act as a Contractor"without being duly registered or certified; • The phrase, "cabinet installation,"was the trigger. Thomas Lykos noted he knew"Ray and Dorrie"as members of the CBIA("Collier Building Industry Association"), but has never conducted business with them. He stated his existing relationship would not impact his ability to be objective regarding the matter before the Board. Jon Walker asked about the website designer. Raymond Visser explained the website was hosted by "Kitchens.com" and the arrangement was "inherited"when they purchased the business. He stated have worked for clients in England,New York City, the Cayman Islands. Jon Walker stated the information on the website and the testimonials provided gave the impression that they were operating a business in Collier County. Mr. Visser acknowledged the majority of their business was from Collier County and that is why the legal notice was placed on each page—to protect the business— but their clients were not limited only to the Collier County area. Thomas Lykos noted even though the Vissers were from outside the U.S., since they chose to buy and operate a business within the U.S.,they must learn the laws and follow them. Even if they have clients from outside the U.S. they cannot ignore the laws of Collier County when operating a business in Collier County. Mr. Visser reiterated he did not understand how Collier County could claim jurisdiction over a website that was not strictly limited to only Collier County—it is a world-wide website. He stated they were not trying to avoid anything—they did "cue diligence"—and always try to comply with the law. He understood why there are rules and regulations. He further stated they did everything that they thought they needed to do to come into compliance. Mr. Lykos countered the Vissers were using the international aspect of their business to "water down" or not communicate their limitations with their Collier County clients. He suggested the website should state: "In Collier County, we are not licensed to install cabinets. In Collier County, we are not licensed to hire plumbers, electricians—it is strictly the responsibility of a homeowner." If the website listed the restrictions within Collier County, while offering to provide the names of three licensed General Contractors that a homeowner could interview, 4 August 15,2012 there would not have been a violation. The disclaimer they placed on the website was not specific enough to Collier County. He further explained since the Business Tax "license"was in Collier County and their business was in Collier County,they must observe the laws of Collier County. Chairman Horn referenced Page 3 of the website, "Working with Willowood," and stated the very top of the page notes "Willowood Kitchen and Bath, Kitchen Design, Bathroom Remodeling,Naples, Florida." The business address is North Tamiami Trail in Naples. The business telephone number is a local number. Based on that information,the Board considers it to be a local issue. The information tells a consumer the business is based in Naples, Florida. He suggested the matter could be settled by removing the sentence, "In addition to providing the professional installation ... etc."from the website. Vice Chairman Joslin concurred, noting the website gives the impression that "Willowood"can handle a project from start to finish but the current license for the business allows them to build and sell cabinets and nothing more. Mr. Visser again stated the actual language was that they could"arrange for"—not that they were doing the actual work. Vice Chairman Joslin countered that a General Contractor"arranges"things—he does not do everything himself but hires subcontractors to complete a job. Mr. Visser stated his attorney informed him there should have been a meeting to explain the violation which did not happen—they were simply fined. He stated he will continue to make changes to the website as necessary—they have already made changes they thought were sufficient. Chairman Horn asked if the Respondents would be willing to allow Michael Ossorio and the County to examine the website and explain exactly what changes are necessary to come into compliance. His question to the Respondents was, "Would you be willing to remove language from the website?" The response was, "yes." Vice Chairman Joslin asked if the owner from whom they purchased the business was, in fact, licensed to perform the work as advertised on the website. The response was, "no." Mr. Visser indicated he should consider obtaining a General Contractor's license. He stated he understands what is required and why it is required. Chairman Horn asked Mr. Ossorio if there have been any other complaints lodged against this company since 2006. Michael Ossorio stated he was not aware of any other problems. He explained the Mr. Visser could obtain a cabinetry license by taking and passing the Business Procedures test. Until he does so, he should remain within the realm authorized by the Business Tax Receipts, i.e., retail sales. 5 August 15,2012 Rob Ganguli asked the Respondent if he received information concerning licensing. Ray Visser confirmed that he had been provided information on how to obtain a cabinet installation license. Thomas Lykos asked the Board's Attorney to read the Ordinance concerning contested Citations. Attorney Morey referred to Florida Statutes, Chapter 489, "Contracting," and Section 2-203 of the Municipal Code. He stated if a Citation is contested, the Board has the ability to uphold the Citation as issued, as well as to overturn the Citation in a situation where remedial measures have been taken and there has been no harm to the public. Vice Chairman Joslin stated after being in business in Collier County for six years, the Respondent should have realized the website was advertising services that could not be provided under his license. He stated he supported upholding the Citation as issued. He asked if the change to the website had been made. Doreen Visser had spoken to Mr. Ganguli on the phone and stated the disclaimer was added to the website prior to their meeting in June. She further stated it was initially only on Page 3 of the website but was added to each page on the website. She asked that the fine be waived since they had complied. Michael Ossorio stated merely adding the disclaimer was not sufficient to correct the violation prior to the Hearing. Vice Chairman Joslin concurred. Ray Visser countered he had discussed adding the disclaimer with Rob Ganguli who thought it was sufficient. He stated they did what Mr. Ganguli asked them to do. If the mediation wasn't enough, they should have been contacted and told what else was necessary. Chairman Horn asked Mr. Ganguli what he told the Vissers were the changes necessary to correct the website. Rob Ganguli stated he did not advise the Vissers to do anything—they decided themselves to add the disclaimer which he admitted he viewed as an effort to take some type of remedial action. He stated he was not in a position to determine if the remedial action was or was not sufficient. Chairman Horn asked Mr. Ossorio what was required to bring the web pages into compliance. Michael Ossorio agreed with the suggestions made by Thomas Lykos. He concurred that the following statement should be removed "In addition to providing the professional installation of cabinets and countertops, we are able to arrange for plumbing, electrical work, or major structural jobs—whatever you need. " Suggestion: Mr. Visser could insert a disclaimer on the website to clarify that the above statement does not apply to the City of Naples,the City of Marco Island, 6 August 15,2012 Everglades City, or unincorporated Collier County. Mr. Ossorio stated he would be willing to explain to Mr. Visser in detail exactly what was necessary to come into compliance. He suggested calling the Contractors' Licensing Office to make an appointment. Mr. Ganguli noted during his meeting with Mr. and Mrs. Visser, he acknowledged their remedial action of inserting statement of"Legal Notice"on the website, but did not confirm that the action would be sufficient to bring them into compliance. Vice Chairman Joslin moved to uphold Citation #7165 together with the fine of $300.00. Second by Jon Walker. Discussion: Thomas Lykos stated he was conflicted and that the goal of the Board is to achieve compliance, not inflict punishment. He further stated there were no clear-cut actions that the Respondent could take in the situation before the Board. There was intent on the part of the Respondent to take remedial action although it was not sufficient in his opinion. Chairman Horn asked the Board's attorney if the motion to uphold the Citation failed, what options were available to the Board. Attorney Morey responded if the motion failed, a new motion could be made as long as the Hearing was open. County Attorney Jeff Wright agreed with Mr. Morey's assessment. Terry Jerulle stated he was also conflicted. The impression from other pages on the website was that the Vissers would oversee a project—which is what a General Contractor would do. There was further discussion concerning the options available to the Board. Mr. Ossorio noted the Board had, in the past, withdrawn a Citation when a violation had been abated prior to the Hearing. It was rare, but had been done previously. The Respondents were given information concerning how to obtain a license. He stated that, in the County's opinion,the Vissers had not met the burden of meeting the requirements to waive the Citation. Mr. Visser stated he was very willing to make whatever changes are necessary to the website. He further stated if he had been given clear direction,the changes would have been made prior to the Hearing. He stated it would be easier to delete the page rather than to revise the website due to the difficulty of dealing with the webmaster. Mr. Lykos explained a number of risks relating to the advertising claims versus the type of insurance coverage—it is more serious than just misunderstanding the rules 7 August 15, 2012 and laws of Collier County. He stated the Respondent could have put a client and the client's property at risk because there may not be adequate insurance protection in the case of a problem. Mr. Visser stated he was "quite willing to put it right and not buck the system." Chairman Horn called for a vote and restated the Motion to uphold the Citation. Motion carried unanimously, 7—0. Mr. Visser indicated he would file an appeal. Attorney Morey advised Mr. Visser to consult with his counsel and asked the County Attorney to provide information concerning the appeals process to the Respondent. B. Darlene Rowe—Credit Report(s) Ms. Rowe explained she was appearing before the Board to qualify her company, Dazzling Floors, Inc. (Trade: floor covering installation) The company has been in business since 1999 in Florida but is new to Collier County. Michael Ossorio stated: • The application is for approval of a floor covering license. • The Applicant took and passed the Business Procedures Test. • Ms. Rowe is licensed in other jurisdictions that do not require taking and passing the Business Procedures Test. • There was a question concerning her business credit report which is why the application was presented to the Board. Chairman Horn stated he had read Mr. Rowe's letter of explanation concerning the 2006 judgment against her company in the sum of$11,269.00. Ms. Rowe explained she has not yet paid anything on the judgment. At the request of Vice Chairman Joslin, she reiterated the background concerning the judgment. She stated her company was subcontracted to install tile and was supplied the tile by Destin Floors. There were no complaints about the workmanship. Approximately four months later, she was requested to replace the tile for free because the client's wife changed her mind about the color and she refused. When questioned about a collection on her personal credit report, she stated she had undergone three surgeries and lost two houses to foreclosure. Mr. Ossorio stated if a business has been open for 12 months or longer, more emphasis is placed on the business credit report. He noted medical issues or a foreclosure was not an indication that a contractor could pay his/her business expenses. 8 August 15,2012 Vice Chairman Joslin stated, in the past, the Board had approved granting a probationary license when there were credit issues. He noted she had achieved an 86% score on the Business Procedures Test as evidence of her knowledge of her trade. Ms. Rowe stated she had worked for Carpet One for 13 years in Okaloosa County, Florida, without any problems. Michael Ossorio stated the County recommended granting a probationary license for six months. If there are no problems at the end of the six month period,her Certificate should be changed to "active status." Thomas Lykos suggested a one year probationary period with review of her credit reports at six and twelve months to give her time to demonstrate some improvement. Thomas Lykos moved to approve issuing a probationary license for a period of twelve months. The Respondent will return to present her current business and personal credit reports to the Board at six and twelve months. The Board will make a final determination concerning her license at the end of the probationary period. Second by Terry Jerulle. Carried unanimously, 7—0. C. Jeff Yingling—Review Credit Report Chairman Horn welcomed Mr. Yingling who was appearing to qualify the company, "Paints & Coatings, Inc." He asked the Applicant if he knew a Frank Jackson of North Port, Florida. Mr. Yingling responded, "Yes." Chairman Horn explained there were some minor discrepancies ("housekeeping issues") concerning the Verification of Construction Experience that Mr. Jackson submitted. He noted Mr. Jackson's Affidavit of Integrity and Good Character was also incorrectly completed. He requested that Staff review the documents. Chairman Horn asked the Respondent to explain the Company's "major"credit issues. Jeff Yingling stated: • He and his partner began the company in 1994 and have devoted their time to compliance and safety issues for jobs with confined spaces. They were field-oriented and worked each job site. • In 2008,the Office Manager and another employee were found to have embezzled several hundred thousand dollars from the company, including the theft of payroll tax deposits. • The employees were fired, prosecuted by the State's Attorney, and convicted of First Degree Grand Theft--they are serving sentences in jail. 9 August 15, 2012 • The company has entered into a repayment plan, approved by the IRS, and has enacted new office procedures and internal controls to prevent a similar situation from happening in the future. • Neither Jeff nor his partner took a paycheck for 2010 and most of 2011 to keep the company going. • The payroll taxes are current and the company is on the road to recovery. A CPA who reviews the payroll on a monthly basis. • He has become computer literate which he was not in 2007 and he is more office oriented now. Mr. Yingling explained the company usually works for utilities and, in 2008, worked primarily in Lee County, with only a few jobs in Collier County. The company provides special paints and coatings for drinking water and for wastewater pipes and lift stations. They clean out sewer systems and drinking water tanks. Michael Ossorio stated Paints& Coatings, Inc. was hired by Collier County Public Utilities. He received a Citation because he was not licensed to work in Collier County. He has been licensed to work in Lee County for years but forgot about obtaining licensing in Collier County. The Applicant has taken and passed the Business Procedures Test and the Painting Exam. There have not been any complaints made against the company in Collier County. The immediate concern was the business credit. Vice Chairman Joslin asked if the monthly payments pursuant to the IRS repayment plan were being made on time. Jeff Yingling replied affirmatively. Michael Ossorio confirmed the County recommended approving a Certificate for Painting. Thomas Lykos moved to recommend approving a Certificate for Painting. Second by Vice Chairman Richard Joslin. Carried unanimously, 7—0. Jeff Yingling noted the Citation fine had already been paid. VII. OLD BUSINESS: A. Nelly Nava—Review Credit Report Chairman Horn noted Nelly Nava was appearing for Board review of her recent credit report. He stated Ms.Nava had been on probation and has been required to present her credit reports to the Board every six months. He stated he did not see very much improvement in her personal credit report. Ms. Nava stated: • The year started off slowly with only a few job—she did not make enough money to make regular payments, although she is making payments. 10 August 15,2012 • She has not applied for business credit because she is afraid of rejection due to her personal credit problems. • She stated her credit is a"bit better." Chairman Horn noted the American Express balance was reduced by $800. He stated the other balances remained about the same. Ms. Nava continued that her son required surgery in 2011 and she is paying the medical bills incurred for his treatment. Michael Ossorio stated his only complaint was that Ms.Nava would call him frequently and requested that the Board"move forward with this if possible." It was noted this was her 3rd six-month appearance before the Board. Vice Chairman Joslin moved to end the probation and allow Ms. Nava to "start fresh." Second by Chairman Lee Horn. Carried unanimously, 7—0. B. Orders of the Board Vice Chairman Joslin moved to approve authorizing the Chairman to sign the Orders of the Board. Second by Robert Meister. Carried unanimously, 7—0. VIII. PUBLIC HEARINGS: (Note: In the following case, the individuals who testified were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.) A. Case#2012-09: Lucius Blackwell, d/b/a "AAA Air-Conditioning& Refrigeration,Inc." Chairman Horn noted Mr. Blackwell was not present at the Hearing. Chairman Horn outlined the general process of the Public Hearing: • The County will present an Opening Statement to set forth the charges and, in general terms,how it intends to prove the charges, • The Respondent will present his/her Opening Statement setting forth, in general terms, defenses to the charges. • The County will present its Case in Chief by calling witnesses and presenting evidence. • The Respondent may cross-examine the witnesses. • After the County has closed its Case in Chief the Respondent may present his/her defense, i.e., to call and examine witnesses, introduce Exhibits, cross-examine witnesses to impeach any witness regardless of which party called the witness to testify, and rebut any evidence presented against the party. 11 August 15, 2012 • After the Respondent has presented his/her case, the County will present a Rebuttal to the Respondent's presentation. • When the Rebuttal is concluded, each party is permitted to present a Closing Statement. • The County is allowed a second opportunity to rebut the Respondent's Closing Statement. • The Board will close the Public Hearing and begin deliberations. • Prior to beginning deliberations, the Board's Attorney will give a"charge" to the Board, similar to the charge given to a jury, setting out the parameters on which the decision will be based. • During deliberations,the Board can request additional information and clarification from the parties. • The Board will decide two different issues: o Whether the Respondent was guilty of the offense(s) charged in the Administrative Complaint, and a vote will be taken on the matter. o If the Respondent was found guilty,the Board must decide the sanctions to be imposed. • The Board's Attorney will advise the Board concerning the sanctions and the factors to be considered. • The Board will discuss the sanctions and vote. Vice Chairman Joslin moved to approve entering the packet for Case No. 2012-09, Board of County Commissioners vs. Lucius B. Blackwell, d/b/a "AAA Air Conditioning&Refrigeration, Inc., "License #CAC-1816210, into evidence. Second by Terry Jerulle. Carried unanimously, 7—0. • Chairman Horn entered the information packet into evidence, marked as County's Exhibit "A." Michael Ossorio referred the Board to Exhibit E-8 and stated a letter of notification of the Hearing(Exhibit E-7)was sent, via Certified Mail, to the Respondent's last known address in West Palm Beach, Florida. He confirmed the County was ready to proceed. Chairman Horn concurred that the Respondent had been properly noticed and determined the Hearing could proceed. Karen Clements, Licensing Compliance Officer,presented the County's "Case in Chief' and stated: • She received a complaint on May 31, 2012 from Greg Governale,the son of Marilyn Governale, regarding 2018 Duke Drive,Naples, Florida. • AAA Air-Conditioning&Refrigeration, Inc. is a State-certified Contractor, License#CAC-1816210, from West Palm Beach, Florida. • The Company was contracted on April 27th to install a condensing unit, an air handler, and a dehumidifier at a cost of$8,050.00 • A deposit of$3,750.00 was paid and the Company proceeded with the work. • A Permit was not obtained. 12 August 15, 2012 • Marilyn Governale is experiencing problems with the air-conditioning unit. • AAA Air-Conditioning is not registered with Collier County. • Mr. Blackwell was contacted and came to the Contractors' Licensing Office the on June 1St to register the company. • He was unable to register the company because he did not have proof of insurance. • Michael Ossorio gave him a Notice of Non-compliance which he signed. • Mr. Blackwell spoke with Jim Turner from the Plumbing Department and received the necessary paperwork. • Instead of returning with the documentation completed, he went to his car and left. • Numerous phone calls were placed to Mr. Blackwell ---his response was stall tactics ... he was always waiting for"something" (paperwork, information, etc.) • The Notice of Hearing was sent to Mr. Blackwell via Certified Mail and it was received. • On July 16th, an email was sent to AAA Air-Conditioning but there was no response. (See Exhibit E-12) • Tom DeGram, Interim Chief Building Official,was contacted concerning the case (Exhibit E-13). He determined there was a willful Code violation of Section 105.1 of the 2010 Florida Building Code(Exhibit E-14). • The violation has not been abated. Chairman Horn asked if the job required a permit and inspections and Ms. Clements replied affirmatively. He asked if a State-certified contractor was required to register with Collier County before beginning a job. Karen Clements concurred. Michael Ossorio met with Lucius Blackwell on June 1st and he was issued a Non- compliance Order to inform him(and all State-certified Contractors)that they must pull a building permit to be in compliance. Mr. Blackwell assured Mr. Ossorio that it was an oversight and apologized. He stated he would obtain the required building permits. He continued the Governales were waiting for the Board's decision to avoid being in breach of contract. They have another contractor who will pull the required permits to install a new air conditioning unit. He stated the Governales have filed a complaint for misconduct with the State Board. Chairman Horn reiterated the system has not been permitted and not C/O'd. Jon Walker asked if restitution was ordered by the Board and verified the customers paid over$3,000 as a deposit. Karen Clements stated they had paid the entire amount of$8,050 to the Contractor. Chairman Horn noted that since the Contractor was State-certified, different rules applied. Attorney Morey stated he would explain the regulations to the Board during the penalty phase of their deliberation. 13 August 15,2012 Thomas Lykos stated the Board was required the protect the consumer and the case before the Board proved why the rules were necessary. Robert Meister noted the Contract stated the owner was responsible for obtaining a permit (see Exhibit E-11) and confirmed the statement did not absolve the Contractor of his responsibility to register in Collier County. Michael Ossorio stated the County recommended the Board determine that the Contractor was guilty of a willful violation of the Florida Building Code, and concluded the County's presentation. Vice Chairman Joslin moved to close the Public Hearing. Second by Thomas Jerulle. Carried unanimously, 7—0. Attorney Morey read the Charge to the Board and outlined the Charge as follows: • The Board shall ascertain in its deliberations that fundamental fairness and due process were accorded to the Respondent • Pursuant to Section 22-203(g) (5) of the Codified Ordinance,the formal Rules of Evidence set out in Florida Statutes do not apply. • The Board shall consider solely the evidence presented at the Hearing in its deliberation of this matter. • The Board shall exclude from its deliberations irrelevant, immaterial or • cumulative testimony. • The Board shall admit and consider all other evidence of a type commonly relied upon by reasonably prudent persons in the conduct of their affairs, whether or not the evidence so admitted would be admissible in a Court of Law. • Hearsay evidence may be used to explain or supplement any other evidence but hearsay, in and of itself, is not be sufficient to support a Finding, unless such hearsay would be admissible over objection in a civil action in Court. • The Standard of Proof in actions where a Respondent may lose his privileges to practice his profession is that the evidence presented by the Complainant must prove the Complainant's case in a clear and convincing manner. • The Burden of Proof on the Complainant is a larger burden than the "Preponderance of Evidence" Standard set in ordinary Civil cases. • The Standard of Evidence is to be weighed solely as to the charges set out in the Complaint. • The only charges the Board may decide upon are the ones to which the Respondent has had an opportunity to prepare a defense. • The damages awarded by the Board must be directly related to the charges. • The decision made by the Board shall be stated orally at the Hearing and is effective upon being read, unless the Board orders otherwise. • The Respondent, if found guilty,has certain appeal rights to the Contractors' Licensing Board, the Courts, and the State Construction Industry Licensing Board,pursuant to Florida Statutes and the Florida Administrative Code. • The Board shall vote upon the evidence presented in all areas and if the Respondent is found in violation, shall adopt the Administrative Complaint. 14 August 15, 2012 • The Board shall also make Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in support of the charges set out in the Complaint. Chairman Horn noted the Respondent had been properly served notification of the Hearing. Michael Ossorio referred the Board to the second page of the Administrative Complaint which detailed Count I. Chairman Horn read the County into the record as follows: "Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended, Section 22-201.1(2) states, `Willfully violating the applicable Building Codes or Laws of the State, City or Collier County. " Vice Chairman Joslin moved to approve that in Case #2012-09,Petitioner versus Lucius B. Blackwell, d/b/a "AAA Air-Conditioning& Refrigeration,Inc."the Respondent was found guilty of violating Count I of the Administrative Complaint as stated Second by Thomas Lykos. Carried unanimously, 7—0. PENALTY PHASE: Attorney Morey stated if, after a Hearing has been conducted, the Contractors' Licensing Board found there was misconduct by a State-certified Contractor within the meaning of Section 22-201,the Board may, but shall not be required to, impose any of the following Disciplinary Sanctions individually, or in combination: (1) The Board may deny the issuance of Collier County Building Permits or require the issuance of Permits with specific conditions; (2) Notification and information concerning such permit denial(s) shall be submitted to the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulations within fifteen days after the Contractors' Licensing Board decision. Attorney Morey further advised the Board that, when imposing any of the possible Disciplinary Sanctions on a Contractor holding a Certificate of Competency or a State-certified Contractor who has been found to have violated the Ordinance,the Contractors' Licensing Board shall consider the following: (1) All of the evidence presented at the Hearing; (2) The gravity of the violation; (3) The impact of the violation on public Health/Safety or Welfare; (4) Any actions taken by the violator to correct the violation(s); (5) Any previous violations committed by the violator, and (6) Any other evidence presented at the Hearing by the parties relevant as to the Sanction which is appropriate for the case given the nature of the violation(s) or the violator. 15 August 15, 2012 He concluded in addition to any other action that may be taken, the Contractors' Licensing Board may also issue a recommended penalty to the State's Contractors' Licensing Industry Board. Chairman Horn asked the County for recommendations. Michael Ossorio stated: • To pull the Respondent's Building Permit privileges for the City of Naples, the City of Marco Island, and all of unincorporated Collier County, and • To authorize the Contractors' Licensing Office to send a Certified letter to the State with the Findings of Fact and a recommendation for revocation of the Respondent's Certificate in the State of Florida, as well as imposing full restitution with penalties and an investigation to be conducted by the Department of Business and Professional Regulations. Michael Boyd asked if the Respondent could be fined for the County's costs. Mr. Ossorio confirmed the Board could recommend that the State order the Respondent of pay all costs incurred by Collier County related to its investigation. When asked about a public reprimand, Mr. Ossorio stated the Board had not previously requested that the State issue a public reprimand against a State-certified Contractor. Chairman Horn noted the Board could ask. Chairman Horn moved to recommend approving the following actions: • pulling the Respondent's Building Permit Privileges for Collier County and its municipalities; • granting permission to the Contractors'Licensing Office to send a Certified letter to the State requesting revocation of the Respondent's license, restitution for the homeowner, an investigation to be conducted by the State, reimbursement to Collier County for its investigative costs, and that a public reprimand be issued. Second by Vice Chairman Joslin. Carried unanimously, 7—0. Chairman Horn outlined the Board's Order: • This cause came on for public hearing before the Contractors' Licensing Board on August 15, 2012 for consideration of the Administrative Complaint in Case #2012-09 filed against Lucius B. Blackwell, d/b/a"AAA Air-Conditioning& Refrigeration, Inc.,"the holder of record of State Certificate#CAC-1816210. • Service of the Complaint was made in accordance with Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended. • The Board, at this Hearing, having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard arguments respective to all appropriate matters, and issued its Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law as follows. 16 August 15, 2012 Findings of Fact: • Lucius B. Blackwell, d/b/a"AAA Air-Conditioning & Refrigeration, Inc.," is the holder of record of State Certificate#CAC-1816210. • The Board of County Commissioners, Collier County, Florida, Contractors' Licensing Board is the Petitioner(Complainant) in this matter. • The Board has jurisdiction of the person of the Respondent. • Respondent, Lucius B. Blackwell, was not present at the Public Hearing held on August 15, 2012, and was not represented by Counsel at the Hearing. • The Respondent had been properly noticed concerning the Hearing. • All notices required by Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended, had been properly issued and were personally delivered. • The Respondent acted in a manner that is in violation of Collier County Ordinances and is the one who committed the act. • The allegations of fact as set forth in Administrative Complaint as to: o Count I, under Section 22-201.1(2): "Willfully violating the applicable Building Codes or Laws of the State, City or Collier County" have been found to be supported by the evidence presented at the Hearing. Conclusions of Law: • The Conclusions of Law alleged and set forth in the Administrative Complaint as to Count 1 has been approved, adopted and incorporated herein,to wit: "The Respondent violated Section 22-201.1(2) of Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended, in the performance of his contracting business in Collier County by acting in violation of the Sections set out in the Administrative Complaint with particularity." Order of the Board: • Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law,and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 489, Florida Statutes, and in Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended, by a vote of seven(7) in favor and none (0) in opposition, a majority vote of the Board members present,the Respondent has been found in violation as set out above. • Further, it is hereby ordered by a vote of 7 in favor, and none in opposition, a majority vote of the Board members present,that the following disciplinary sanctions and related Order are hereby imposed upon the holder of State Certificate of Competency#CAC-1816210, to wit: o Pull all Building Permit privileges in Collier County; o The Contractors' Licensing Office is to send a Certified letter to the State recommending revocation of the Respondent's license, restitution to the homeowner, an investigation to be conducted by the State, reimbursement to Collier County for its investigative costs, and that a public reprimand be issued. 17 August 15, 2012 Chairman Horn noted the case was closed. IX. REPORTS: • Mr. Ossorio noted the Office has been working with the Department of Financial Services regarding shell companies (a corporation that opens without obtaining a license and only minimal insurance coverage) . He stated approximately 25 "Stop Work" Orders have been issued during the past three months throughout Collier County. He will provide the Board with information concerning the issue. X. MEMBER COMMENTS: • Vice Chairman Joslin requested that the County Attorney investigate what would happen to a Citation if a Motion on the floor failed. County Attorney Jeff Wright stated he would research the issue for future discussion. He stated if a motion failed,the Board could not take any action. A follow-up motion could be made which the Board could vote upon. • Vice Chairman Joslin asked if a Board's decision regarding whether or not to uphold a Citation could also be appealed. County Attorney Jeff Wright noted an appeal could be made. The Respondent has the right to a re-hearing within 20 days following the Board's decision. He referenced Section 22-204 of the Ordinance. • Attorney Morey stated the Board's earlier motion to uphold a Citation was appropriate as stated. He suggested an alternative motion have been phrased to deny the Respondent's request to waive the Citation. He further stated the Respondent had contested the issuance of the Citation. There was further discussion. It was noted there have been questions in the past concerning the Board's action if a Motion fails, is the Respondent not liable for payment of a fine. Attorney Morey stated he would report to the Board concerning options to "fine tune"the process. • Michael Ossorio outlined the Standard Operating Procedures regarding issuance of Citations and stated it was explained to a Respondent that the back of the Citation contained instructions concerning how to contest a Citation. A Respondent is also provided with a copy of the Ordinance. • Mr. Ossorio stated that for future Hearings,the Board would be provided with a full copy of any Citation(both front and back) issued. He noted a Respondent may change his/her mind concerning whether to pursue contesting a Citation or decide to pay the fine even after the back of the Citation was signed. XI. NEXT MEETING DATE: Wednesday, September 19, 2012 Board of County Commissioners' Chambers, 3`d Floor—Administrative Building"F," Government Complex, 3301 E. Tamiami Trail,Naples, FL 34112 18 August 15,2012 There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by the order of the Chairman at 11:15 AM. COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD Lee Horn, Chairman The Minutes were approved by the Board/Chairman on , 2012, "as submitted" [ } OR "as amended" [ 1. 19 F"r`d *ow., - l ORDINANCE 82 - 20 AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS TO DESIGNATE AGENTS OF THE COLLIER COUNTY BUILDING CODE COMPLIANCE DEPARTMENT AS CONTRACTORS' LICENSING INVESTIGATORS AND TO DESIGNATE GENTS OF THE COLLIER COUNTY ZONING . r' ARTMENT AS ZONING INVESTIGATORS; MJ :f, THORIZING SAID INVESTIGATORS TO ISSUE CXTATIONS FOR VIOLATIONS OF COLLIER ca -- - vs . COUNTW CONTRACTORS' LICENSING ORDINANCE AND AMENDMENTS THERETO, AND ZONING ORDINANCE AND ANY AMENDMENTS THERETO; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT, SEVERANCE AND .**.0 •.. .. PENALTIES; AND BY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. . WHEREAS, the Laws of Florida, Chapter B1-364, author- ized the Board of County Commissioners of Cdllier County, Florida to designate agents or employees of the Collier , County Building Code Compliance Department and Collier County Zoning Department as Contractors' Licensing Investi- gators and Zcaing Investigators, respectively; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: . r• SECTION ONE: DESIGNATIONS '"4 ,. A. Those agents or employees of the Collier county ild-...4 ing Code Compliance Department who are to Se a eAI' Contractors' Licensing Investigators shall be des gnat-" ' ed by the Board of County Commissioners' adoptidt of . the appropriate resolution. m B. Those agents or employeesof the Collier County Zoning Department who are to serve as Zoning Investigators shall be designated try the Board of County Commis- sioners' adoption of the appropriate resolution. SECTION TWO: DUTIES .. A. It shall be the duty of any person designated as a . Contractors' Licensing Investigator or Zoning Investi- gator to enforce the provisions of the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Ordinance end Zoning Ordinance, respectively, and subsequent amendments thereto velat- ing to licensing and zoning regulations. ` B. Nothing herein contained shall be construed to autho- a rize or permit any person designated as 'a Contractors' Licensing Investigator or Zoning Investigator pursuant to this Ordinance to perform any function or duties of a Law Enforcement Officer other than specified herein. Said investigators designated, pursuant to this Ordi- nance, shall not make physical arrests or take any r person into custody and shall be exempt from the re- It i, quirements relating to the state high-hazard retirement program and Police Standards: and Training Commission as ° defined and provided by general law. SECTION THREE: TRAINING AND QUALIFICATIONS A. A training program for the certification of Contractors' Licensing Investigators and Zoning Investigators for the purpose of authorization to issue citations for . to& 0! 'rAc( $01.614 101WWWW) O. Statements. a. Sworn statements. • b. Admissions by defendant. c. Statements by defendant. d. Statements of witnesses. C. Obtaining and securing evidence. a. Identifying photographs. b. Marking. c. Maintaining custody. • R V. REPORT WRITING �r • A. Composition. • a. Who, What, Where, When, Why, How? B. Forms. a. Complaint Reports. • +�, b. Supplement Reports. c. Letters and Correspondence. " d. Warning Citations or notices. e. Notice of Violations (Tags) f. Citations. VI. PROCEDURE FOR ISSUING CITATIONS ,` A. Establish that a violation of the Ordinance occurred in the presence of the Officer. B. Identify the violation. C. Identify the offender. D. Obtain all necessary evidence to prove the viola- tion of the Ordinance. E. Contact the offender and explain the violation. F. Issue the completed citation form. 0. Have defendant sign the citation form. H. If the offender refuses the citation seek prosecu- tion through the State's Attorneys Office. I. Write a comprehensive report of the violation for office records. J. Distribution' of the issued citation form and back-up material, evidence, etc. ,; ,= X. What to do when.... (1) The offender refuses to give you his identi- fication or driver's license. (2) The offender refuses to sign the citation. y 'v 1oIt Ot4 ra t. i I 14..11.4 .. SECTION FOUR! ,ISSUANCE OF CITATIONS .s-Y i A. Any person designated as a Contractors' Licensing ` , Investigator or Zoning Investigator is hereby autho • rized to issue citations for violations of the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Ordinance and Collier / A. County Zoning Ordinance, respectively, and subsequent amendments thereto, where such violations are witnessed • by said investigators. B. A citation issued by said investigators under the provisions of this Ordinance shall be in the following forms 4,, '< Agency Case # ,..,,,...,.,.. IN THE COUNTY COURT, IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA NOTICE TO APPEAR STATE OF FLORIDA, COUNTY OF COLLIER f` In the name of Collier County, Florida. The undersigned ( certifies that he has just and reasonable grounds to believe, and does believe that: 4' (a.m. ) On the day of , . , 19 , at (p.m. ) Last Name Y°ixt M.I. Aliaaes Street-City and State Date and Place or Birth Phone Race/Sex:feig t Weight HAtir Eyes Scars/Marks 00copetion Flea of EoPlOYoent . EOPIOYoant.?Donee complexion Driver's License i! -- Y.-- r !;racial Secs At (location) in collier County, Florida,;. tted tie Lollowing often***' (1) (2) ..:_ in violation of section(s) ( ) County Ord. ...' DID (Narrative) * a Name of Officer IDF Ageflcy ( ) Mandatory appearance in County Court, { r Location tl 19 �., at ( ) a.m.( ) p.m. Month and Day (. ) You need not appear in court, but Faust comply with instructions on back. Fine and Cost i, 100«4 01,14 PACE 340 CO-DEFENDANTS: ! ° ( ) Cited 1. ( ) Name DOS Address °® R '. ( ) Cited 2. ( ) A R Name DOB Address I ' I AGREE TO APPEAR AT THE TIME AND PLACE DESIGNATED ABOVE TO ANSWER THE OFFENSE CHARGED OR TO PAY THE FINE SUBSCRIBED. I UNDERSTAND THAT SHOULD I WILLFULLY FAIL TO APPEAR BEFORE THE COURT AS REQUIRED BY THIS NOTICE TO APPEAR, THAT I MAY BE HELD IN CONTEMPT OF COURT AND A WARRANT FOR MY ARREST SHALL BE ISSUED. 1 1 Sworn to and suscribed before o me this Signature of Defendant day f , 19 t ) Notary Public-State of FLA. I swear the above and t *:' reverse and.attached statements are true and correct to the best of : say knowledge and belief. Complainant COLLIER COUNTY ZONING DEPARTMENT ( ) OR t, COLLIER COUNTY BUILDING CODE COMPLIANCE DEPARTMENT ( ) C. Additional information shall be supplied on the back of . the citation in the following forms WAIVER INFORMATION ..,. ,r '° � If you desire to plead guilty or nolo contenders (no contest) and you need not appoal in court as indicated on the face of this notice, you may present this notice at the County court named on the reverse of this page. From • to , .; Date Hour Data Hour and pay a fine of dollars in cash, money order, or certified check. The waiver below must be completed and attached. Read carefully. Your failure to answer this summons in the manner sub scribed will result in a warrant being issued on a separate and additional charge. ,, "In consideration of my not appearing in court, i the undersigned, do hereby enter my appearance on the affidavit , 1 for the offense charged on the other side of this notice and waive the reading of the affidavit in the above named cause v and the right to be present at the trial of said action. I *4 hereby enter my plea of GUILTY ( ) or NOLO CONTENDERS( ), and waive my right to prosecute appeal e4r error proceed• ings." i'' "I understand the nature of charge against mei I under- stand my right to have Counsel and waive this right and the . , right to a continuance. I waive my right to trial before a judge or jury. I PLEAD GUILTY ( ) or NOLO CONTENDERE ( ) to the charge being fully aware that sty signature to this will have the same effect as s judgement of this Court." Total Fine and Costs _ . eoox X014 M 341 a- _ `e ke ss- "h _ __mt.(_ ror re-t-e-ncy _c&v-zl be_ r `H,5"I4 . rY a,e4 . -i-e m Iti Se ,+' refIOawd to oA �~ tWei € h �GG-�to h & s - 5 \ €A Cov lr t t 4 7%// t �1 t e ._ .0 lt Se e4r . �''^ c T G7o r[<4 - v-4&o D T ko rs_ i r�_ rat nc� tv O W' ct�S,nre.s i f 7ui.W3 ,� :roe,e, h Mc-t- lI phG e ( _I,_I,1,"- M / -4/ed -Pov d tuorce pia 4c/804-D1;01 One- L,5 ,pct .pr).Se a Alin _trnk-b ohs W6r' b gf Ko , S t,vh 4 t&, w tz.-4L e js hq trrjooq totrrk_664 el a ritfEi r fi 1.61Z5 t P I Ef ai le +o p oa ..YYtti s e t I,S�' _ -Kr-0144h to pail r- t o ie. year oft oe-v epe e am el r.-1 ° ►� __ ress'ID V T !`v£ Ve4-Ce -4'a re h ew Y 1 h_o w _re.d z e _ h d_ bn t 44a,. e- - - L a.s ,.-d( 10.045 _Cu54 " teL� o -Jt I 44e7 G6D-Se . ~ ►Qtr-LO,r5 a ,,t+ ars ctjtv ,S tyke e l ve 1 Pt- St,v a i 1 ' v v\_S t__TC(fri17.-Vare . Ieceis tar . e-,I`e 5s 44)e_ i n a 1 . `v.e -ri ei 40 .6 wrt/l tf€-44 rel t,ced' ler s -t 4-o a.` ui p p Y a�L _ u S i`he s (it.h I'v _rear-Mei I t' !u-�h a akc _ GL._ .`1 fry 4-L1 s k.)01. M vt d®v-c� a eCh t qu,h 0 to a-� wdra fek tJ - fit 11 11ui1 rr `t + c) tc!r- 6,4- tA,,e3 s4 +-1-e--- c " ktMttes� 0h c►eCa ,- 06.1 CC ►-At1A- v nec6( 1)e. W ,C4 a, I%uin meertv Sd t 04 r) _8e) r■ r ,1" ` he e.C[_ __9 tkiK Lei? 45 _6(0 --1-1 a . , 0 ar t CDES Operations & Regulatory Management Licensing Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY/CITY OF NAPLES/CITY OF MARCO FIRM INSTRUCTIONS: This application must be typewritten or legibly printed. The application fee must accompany this application. The fee is not refundable after the application has been accepted and entered on the records. All checks should be made payable to the Board of Collier County Commissioners. For further information, consult Collier County Ordinance No. 90-105, as amended. NAME OF COMPANY: +_ r� f ■ i p Exact Corporate/Business Name: ,. \ 5' l_G l.l�, t t I Fiction Nanie/DBA: Qualifier Name: 1 Q,U 1 A -P-f' Physical Address: c (1 (0 1 (1214/ a V O Mc, E, li a Q I-eec Pi, 3'(/2 umber 8s Street) (City) (State) (Zip Code) Mailing Address: Re e s(G q f l ? 4,045 Ft - 3z/ /o / (Number 86 Street) ty) (State) (Zip Code) Telephone: S d ,l. i`' 73--3g E-Mail: TYPE OF LICENSE: ❑ General $230.00 ❑ Electrician $230.00 ❑ Building $230.00 ❑ Plumber $230.00 ❑ Residential $230.00 ❑ Air Cond. $230.00. ❑ Mechanical. $230.00 ❑ Swimming Pool $230.00 ❑ Roofing $230.0 t Specialty $205.00 P t3' S ecial trade: Cc., cote . C h 8 � Li r C GE OF STATUS: einstatement> ( ) From One Business to Another ( ) Dormant License to Active Page 1 of 4 1, The names,titles home add ess and phone numbers of all Officers/Managing Members of the Firm. v t qo X761 k63 aid-, U EI ittales a P7 1(0 2. List all businesses,firms, entities or contracting businesses you have been associated with during the last ten years(ex. Held a license for or been a partner). Attach extra pages if needed. IA DIN 3. List all debts you or any company(s)associated with you refused to pay and the reasons for the refusal to pay. Attach extra pages if needed. AFFIDAVIT I, a_tj/ 4 certify that the foregoing is true and corr o the t • my k edge. uthonzed 0 cer • .. Firm STATE OF FLORIN t 1(t" COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this £1242 U 12-- (Date) By LUVI(L r of L�Ct CJ (Name of officer, tit e/a ent (Name of Corporation) , a çD(L(iL.. C orporation on behalf of the corporation. (State or Place oof,Corporation) t He/She has-produced 1' t> 4.& t�L be 1 identification and did not take an oath. (Type of identification) NOTARY'S SEAL - - i I ! gi ';111 I -A, A1, ... . . ,.4 ••••► `"N IGNATURE OF N•TA` CLAUDIA cl.auola M PROFFITT �'' 1 S 11' Notary Public-State of Florida 1 ;. , o, My Comm.Expires Nov 17.2013 1 '%� 41 Commission#DO 940882 . Page 2 of 4 QUALIFIER INFORMATION: Name: et, i pG Address: % a ti°�- ` ►, /,it (K.S (Number&Street) (• ) (State) (Zip Code) Telephone: 13 f 0Z. C+ Date of Birth: 7—c,94 S.S.#: 000-00- E-Mail: ri' j 'is 4 d cCI ( , " Driver's License: - 1. Type of Certificate of Competency for which application is de.m d C a,6 ill 64 et s-F Q VI C`®nt,a 4-eV' 2. The names and telephone numbers of two persons who will know your whereabouts. rc. \ ,-a+cf-- ,.c` cauQ 3. Have you ever been convicted of a crime related to Contracting? Ni 0 (If yes attach extra sheet with explanation) 7. Have you or any firms you have been associated with ever filed bankruptcy? t`.b 8. List all debts you or any company(s)associated with you refused or failed to pay and reasons why. 9. List your busin ss or work experience during the past ten years. 4-1 ii, 1 fe: s(e; 'J A • r C-60 I`1A.1 (1(5 hi &6rnLç e +G.ev Se At akplotteL Skkt-ez . o03 10. Statement of any formal training yod have had in the area for which the ap lication is made. 0 1 0 (r 1. __ .4 , 1_ , • 6-! .4 Page 3 of 4 AFFIDAVIT The undersigned hereby makes application for Certificate of Competency under the provisions of Collier County Ordinance No. 2006-46, as amended, and vouches for the truth and accuracy o f all statements and answers herein contained. The undersigned hereby certifies that he is legally qualified to act on behalf of the business organization sought to be licensed in all matters connected with its contracting business and that he has full authority to supervise construction undertaken by himself or such business or organization and that he will continue during this registration to be able to so bind said business organization. The qualified license holder understands that in all contracting matters, he will be held strictly accountable for any and all activities involving his license. Any willful falsification of any information contained herein is grounds for disqualification. tiijC APPLICANT(PLEAS PRINT) CalbL�ekr -I, c AME N ,, SIGNATURE OP•LICANT STATE OF FLORI COUNTY OF �1 L 1:r The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this C )1 f By . ( © who has produced ©( t,��-I . brde_,a L C (Name of person acknowledging) (Type of identification) as identification and did not take an oath. NOTARY'S SEAL `���, ,,,,I ct auDU PA- PROffnT (SIGNATURE OF NOTA- S Notary Public State of Florida ( �� �'� My Comm.Expires Nov 17.2013 ��,,d+;,.�' Commission#DD 940882 Page 4 of 4 AFFInA ITT Rnrinrd rnynnif thnt if!fni! tn nnrluirr or ronint•---.in (--nr•-•• •• •-••••• -•••-• t.72:.""-.!;1:.!. ._!;1;.!=,7 7-7; Certificate of Competency. /Y7/7 SIGNATUREOF APPLIC NT cAte t e(14 :-141 BUSINESS NAME LJAIC 1\ ti= A (1-, P.FFOF-1F-- ME- thin norrIonnih; , : affirms and says that he has less than one employee and does not reouire wnrk_rnrn,-, Corrmr-mr frm gmr! mr!---.rsdnnd::::that nl- Inv lime he -nn!e-Ais :tt-t t .71i t: STATE OF FLORIKA, COUNTY OF Ubt ti " The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this b 1 ) (D te) by t)Ct‘i Lit tj, Dt1"- r. who has produced iontteL, 6/1\11.T.c. I(name of of person acknowledoino) (Type of Iderinfletgion) as identification and who did not take an oath_ If; f 1 / 1 - 1\ t i SIGNATURE OF No ARle NOTARY SEAL - 4.rrAtz,„ cLauDIA M PROFRIT NOTARY PUBLIC 4 ‘t'I's Notary Public-State ot Florida r • *;,:.;My Comm.Expires Nov 17,2013$ 4 Commission 1 DO 940882 RESOLUTION OF AUTHORIZATON lr WHEREAS A Y `1 (,a�(Ci CO1W\ L14'G. proposes to (Name of Busin ss Entity) engage in contracting as OK_ aiCj"it, �Gi 1'O(n in (Type of legal dantity:corp.,partnership,etc. Collier County,Florida,according to Collier County Ordinance 2006-46,as amended;and WHEREAS r`1I '1s4 (a �loll it oposes to (Name of Bus<-1) 4 1)14 ((( 4'��'t qualify for a Certificate of Competency with c.�lJ . (Name of Individ 1) NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED THAT: (fin r We the undersigned 6`�tzt I GL1r' ( &14ct ) of - ��1 ,, (Officers,Owners,Partnels) A_r'r-f-S4t 6i (__()2?1 1,4 C( hereby resolve and represent to the Collier County (Name of Business Entity) /1 Contractors'Licensing Board that the qualifying agent, O`ff4(A#-t",is active i of I s•iv.dual1 in all matters connected with the contracting business of a ^tt c. • . piety f`' ,and (Namepf'us' En We further resolve and represent that & 14 ,;,..w is, / (Names of Individual) legally empowered to act for ,/ 7'7. �7 G a lo/ /VC. in all matters connected with its If' (Name of Business Enntity con ting bgsin sands a autho ity to supervise construction undertaken by - 1`94 7rc (:0,6 fhe 9 j3 ame of Business Entity) DULY PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS 02311--day of 114-1-1 OM Z (Officers,Partners,Owners-with t-ignatio 1 s 1 F: 1) r % i. ���/ ness ` ' - W it , 1 Witness Witness Corporate Seal(if Applicable) Or No . Public _ Certificate S , i to and subscribed befor • day of - " l Zby I , i R4. w , Or liMME alokli ' Notary Public Name Pride . i _,.,,- Notary Public Signature Commission Number 1l Ql1-( 2S My Commission expires: 11-11.1?3 1 :►1`.it". CLAUDIA M PROFFTT .' . Notary Public-State of Florida ■ „, u;(+, My Comm.Expires Nov 17,2013 ' f,:o Commission#DD 940882 --*49-----IP,7 4i6V-01%/"--TOITIPar-li% - grii.vaerliii twev.91 or i + * ‘11°Pr Ilk -' % u4k:111r 14 .11Pr- 1 a 4,%ar, - 1,,,, , , , +joib alltirli- i-, w ,i,,,, iTir .4.-1 \)--1 ;:et. \ --_-_,i 1-;:f 1--4 iv. .1-_--4. Ilk I. rff LI A 1:2, A T , 4 g. o E. a: ♦ ►r, :141,4.1•0/4"44 ii g: 0 - " 1= n ; tilriv 0. . 0 co 0 4/01110* $17 °54 CD rditl 0 K 4'or ■[o •, ci N Mt Ole O Icg R/* II. 4 °� o it to N we o CD ham`1-4.) t:1 51.4 ri" Ail tal•fal 0. 0- 6 t%) 0 m 40 \N aa ° cp r-i- Cid °I14 ti V a s : ,-,- (A . r) Ea w .... ;.; 5" 0 t-t- 7:1 0 r , *.40,... r, 0 , , i trkois a. tgA 1:1' 0 ' N ?)' t=e cat Fie041W IL O. be 0 - i�e-..4,N, =. cr CA 4-1- 2 ,.,, .�• I �� ....gi, (-, a. firs-w. a. 0 cL ..' ul ,01r:i„„, i■ 8 0 cr cl, 0 it/N4 5-.' o c411 t ' A ta. cr P n 5 411ht Ii04,4 1 P r cc, = . oi YAW r 44/00. _ 0 ik/t&lifit 4P40/A3'... --, 0. {toil _ _ 0 0 Pk *ire tir4: Of � � r *Illa"- 1. • la a • a am i id vri k \ lik: 4*it' ' -1 1 t IA*t jgalthil 4011111. 08/21/2012 16:46 2392773258 MERIT CREDIT PAGE 01/04 ?),CAS Fen 6,5Cticit<4 6fi� EXPNRIAN SUSINSSS =FOR PACE RFT DATE '•:I FORT TYPE 1 08115/2012 08.1;9138 -ADZ =PORT 404 DIN: 861958970 F. 0. EOM 9823 9 ARTISTIC 823 DAMS INCORPORATED EAR. 2004 F. O. . NAPLES IL 34101-9823 COMPANY DESCRIPTION CO ANY RA FORMATION TOR YOLLOAING WAS PROF ,' NT TILE STASH OF FLORIDA. HISTORY HUSKS INCORPORATED ON MARCH 11, 2004 AS A FOR-PROFIT CORPORATION. =DUAL TAX ID TO 550866696. CHARTER mums= IS F040000478 CURRENT STATUS : WJIVZ BUSINESS. ASENT XS DOFF DAVID R LOCATED AT 2761 GTE AVE NM, RADIMS, TL TITLE: z?IRIR.-rOR �aCxPAL(S) DAVID 3OFr ROOFER WILLIAM TITLE OFFICER THE INFORMATION =RR * IS FURNISHD IN CONFIDRINCS FOR YOUR RECLUSIVE USE FOR LEGITIMATE ' :S PURPOSES AND SMALL NOT RR RWRODOCID. NEITHER RXPERim INFORMATION ''•? r.; , INC., NOR ITS SUS OR PIS WARRANT SUCH TNFoRmaxog NOR =;:r_ TN]C HE LIABLE FOR YOUR USE OR RSLIANCR UPON COPYRIGHT 2012 :•- a INFORMATIOM SOLUTIONS, INC. ALL RIGHTS MRSIMUND. HERIT CREDIT RAS TEE ABOVE BUSINESS =PORT FOR LICENSING PURPOSES AS RRQUROTED HY THAWS * 6 /PROPI . PUBLIC RECORDS FOR THIS REPORT RAVE MEM CUIECKIND AND -j' • „ AT THE COUNTY (INCLUDING PZlMILLAS), STATE AND TRDRRAL LEVELS. PURL= RECORDS LEASED: _0_ SOURCES OF TI. NRIARRIAN BUSINESS INFORMATION SI VICES IRS LIEN =GMION COUNTY COURTROOM RECORDS IF YOU ONO =CARDING THIS RSPORT, PLEASE CONTACT Nam= MIT AT; 1-800-371-3348 OR 33*-277-3302. 61"-Sen,a(6refritled t 643 Prepared Ey: Merit Credit (239) 277-3202 (800) 371-3348 TRANSUNION CREDIT REPORT [FOR] [SUB NAME] [MAT SUB] [INFI 86 0D 08 15/12 08IME) ( I) Z NP6284423 MERIT CREDIT ISSN] [BIRTH DATE] [SUBJECT] - 7/51 GOFF, DAVID R. E RPTD] [CUR[CURRENT ADDRESS] 3/96 2761 NE. 6TH AV•, NAPLES FL. 34120 [FORMER ADDRESS] 6/96 9823 PO BOX 9823, NAPLES FL. 34101 2327 HUNTER EL, GOLDEN GATE FL. 34116 [NEAP] R9TDj [CURRENT EMPLOYER AND ADDRESS] SELF EMPLOYED CABINETRY 3/07 3/07 [FORMER EMPLOYER AND ADDRESS) DAVID GOFF 1/98 MODEL PROFILE * * * ALERT * * * . ***RICO CLASSIC 04 ALERT: SCORE +641 : 039, 013, 018, 016 *** IN ADDITION ***TO THE FACTORS LISTED ABOVE, THE NUMBER OF INQUIRIES ON.THE CONSUMER'S ***CREDIT FILE HAS ADVERSELY AFFECTED THE CREDIT SCORE. * * * T O T A L F l E H I S T O R Y CREDIT SUMMARY PR=0 COL=0 NEG=9 HSTNEG=5-25 TRD=15 RVL=10 INST=3 r, 1 OPN=1 INQ=2 TRADES MAXDELQ pAYI'AT 1-12 MOP SURNAME SUHCODE OPENED HIGHCRED TERMS MAXDELQ PAYPAT 13-24 ACCOUNT# VERFIED CREDLIM PASTDUE AT 30/60/90 ECQA COLLATRL/LOANTYPE CLSD/PD BALANCE REMARKS R09 BE. OF AMER B 1597186 5/054 $1305 $0 4745 I BUSINESS CREDIT C 6/09F $0 SETTLED [ FULL n C LVNV FUNDING F 21P9002 7/09 $517 09P 63260110236 8/11A $0 I 12 HSBC RANK NEV 5/11F $0 SETTLED [ FULL B C CAP ONE B 1DTV001 12/00 $6834 R9P 7/10A $6500 $0 I CREDIT CARD 10/09F $0 SETTLED [ FULL EL HSBC BANK B 2DQ1161 11/04 $7148 R9P 4/10A $0 $0 I CREDIT CARD 1/09P $0 SETTLED [ FULL = I CAP ONE B 1DTV001 10/01 $5867 R9P 9/09A $5000 $0 I CREDIT CARD 6/09F $0 CLOSD BY CRDT G` ' all CAP ONE B 1DTV001 3/98 $1906 R9F 7/09A $1450 $0 R C CREDIT CARD 4/09F $0 CLOSD BY CRDT G- � haps://www.creditsystem.comhnerit 8/21/2012 V0/Z@ 39td r i Z ELLZ6EZ 917:9I ZTBZ/TZ/80 4 79..1.c B 2DQ1120 8/06 $1637 4/09 '55432111].11 R05 1'URCH BY OTHER LEND, ' 34 1/ 1/ 4 2 SLDTO SHERAN FIAT•A 7/OQC $0 2 202 11222 WORLD OMNI F F 2729006 2/04 $27.6K $2M471 22212 221 2112221 110000000603474 12/09A 2/09C $0 CLOSED 48 9/ p/CLOSED 2 AUTOMOBILE . ►11111112111 102 CAPITAL 1 FA F 1W2K001 10/02 $15.0K 60M313 0 11111111111 62062111625371001 12/07A $0 48 1/ 0/ 0 I AUTOMOBILE 12/07C $0 CLOSED r11111111111 R41 TARGET N.B. D 6476004 12/03 $530 111111111111 '7'/10X3 $800 $0 I CHARGE ACCOUNT 2/06C $0 ACCT CLSD BY CONS r' 48 0/ 0/ 0 5J07 X�:XXXXXXXXXI R01 BK OF AMER B 6331059 2/04 $7438 p3 111111211113 7/09A $500 $0 I CREDIT CARD 7/090 $0 CLOSD BY CRDT GRAN SR 48 3/ 3/ 0 BK 5/09 432111111111 ROZ OF AMER B 6331059 6/09A $4727 $0 04 111111111111 I 4/09C $0 SETTLED ( FULL BLN 38 1/ 1/ 1 I CREDIT CARD .111121111111 R01 HSBC BANK B 2D011004 2/04 $1662 111111111111 7/06A $2000 $0 1111111 0/ 0/ 0 I CREDIT CARD 7/06C $0 CLOSED g 1�,Y004 5/90 $30.0K 18014270 111111111111 1401 CHASE 6/05A $0 111113-111111 P CONVENTIONAL REAL 6/05C $0 CLOSED 48 0/ 0/ 0 1ST NATE 111111113.131 101 K FL B 1Y4F001 11/98 $15.3K 6014342 11111111X111 19210501 12/03A $0 44 0/ 0/ 0 I AUTOMOBILE 12/03C $0 CLOSED I N Q U I R I E S TYPE AMOUNT DATE SUBCODE SUBNAME 8/15/12 ZNP6284423(FLA) MERIT CREDIT 3/23/12 ZNP3343169(FLA) MERIT CREDIT • C R E D I T REPORT S E R V I C E D BY 800_888-4213 TRp,NS(7MIdN 2 BALDWIN PLACE P.O. BOX 1000,CHESTER, PA. 19022 Consumer disclosures can be obtained online through Trans ion at: httP://www.transunion.com CREDITOR CONTACT INFORMATION BC159?186 (8 00) 421-2110 $IC OF AMER PO BOX 982238 EL PASO TX. 79998 (866) 464-1183 LVN5T FUNDING P.O. BOX 10584 GREENVILLE SC. 29603 (800) 955-7070 CAP ONE BC1DTV001 POE 30281 SALT LAKE CITY UT. 84130 (800) 695-6950 HSBC BANK BC2DQ1161 PO BOX 5253 CAROL STREAM IL. 60197 HSBC/RS 8C2DQ1120 (800) 695-6950 PO BOX 5253 CAROL STREAM IL. 60197 (80fl) 686-3526 WORLD (MNI F x'22729006 1769 PARAGON DRIVE MEMPHIS TN. 38132 8/21/2012 https://www.creditsystem.com/merit V@/E2 lailrel IM MO 5 lINAW 89Z£LLZ6£Z 90:91 Z L0Z/IZ/80 .er5 C (riIi e'-)-( � CAPITAL 1 FA FA1W2K001 (800) 946-0332 ATTN- CREDIT BUREA ELAND TX_ 75093 TARGET N.B. DC6476004 PO BOX 673 MINNEAPOLIS MN. 5544{} (800) 421-2100 BK OF AMER BC6331059 PO BOX 982238 EL PASO TX. 79998 HSBC BANK BC2DQ1004 (800) 695-6950 PO BOX 5253 CAROL STREAM MIULIL. 60197 (800) 848-9136 CHASE PO BOX 24696 COLUMBUS OH. 43224 1ST NATBK FL 1150 CLEVELAND STR CLEARWATER FL. 33755 MERIT CREDIT Z 3343169 (800) 371-3348 12734 KENWOOD LANE FORT MYERS Fig. 33907 END OF TRANSUNION REPORT MERIT CREDIT HAS RETRIEVED THE ABOVE PERSONAL CREDIT REPORT FOR LICENSING PURPOSES AS REQUESTED BY THE BUSINESS OWNER/PROPRIETOR. PUBLIC RECORDS FOR THIS REPORT HAVE BEEN CHECKED AND VERIFIED AT THE COUNTY, STATE AND FEDERAL LEVEL. PUBLIC RECORDS HAVE ALSO BEEN VERIFIED FOR PINELLAS COUNTY. PUBLIC RECORDS LEARNED 0 , SOURCES OF INFORMATION: CREDIT DATA SERVICES, INC/EXPO • IRS LIEN SECTION COUNTY COURTHOUSE RECORDS IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THIS REPORT, PLEASE CONTACT MERIT CREDIT AT: 1-800-371-3348 OR (239) 277-3202 Mips://www.creditsystenicom/merit 8/21/2012 b0/v0 39Vd lIQ ND 1IN3W 8SZELLZ6EZ 9V:9I ZIBZIIZi80 ............................... www.sunbiz.org-Department of State Page 1 of 2 FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF STATE DIVISION OF CORPORATION TIO Home Contact Us E-Filing Services Document Searches Forms Help Previous on List Next on List Return To List Entity Name Search Events No Name History Submit Detail by Entity Name Florida Profit Corporation ARTISTIC CABINETRY,INC. Filing Information Document Number P04000047869 FEI/EIN Number 550866696 Date Filed 03/11/2004 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event AMENDMENT Event Date Filed 06/27/2007 Event Effective Date NONE Principal Address 2183 CORPORATION BLVD. NAPLES FL 34109 Changed 04/30/2010 Mailing Address P.O. BOX 9823 NAPLES FL 34101 Registered Agent Name&Address GOFF,DAVID R 2761 6TH AVE.NE NAPLES FL 34120 US Officer/Director Detail Name&Address Title D GOFF,DAVID R 2761 6TH AVE.NE NAPLES FL 34120 Title 0 HOOPER,WILLIAM 1200 RESERVE WAY#107 NAPLES FL 34105 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date 2010 04/30/2010 2011 04/30/2011 2012 04/30/2012 http://www.sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?action=DETFIL&inq_doc number=P040000478698cing_came_from=NAMFWD... 8/30/2012 www.sunbiz.org-Department of State 1 Home Contact Us Ealing Services Document Searches Forms Help Certificate of Status Verification Listed below is the current information for the entity for which you are requesting a certificate of status.If this information is what you require for certification,please press the"Continue"button.if you do not wish to continue with this certification,press your browser"Back"button or select to return to the Sunbiz home page. Document Number P04000047869 Corporate Name ARTISTIC CABINETRY,INC. State of Inc FL Filing Date 03/11/2004 Document Type Domestic Profit Document Status ACTIVE Effective Date N/A Last Trans Date 06/27/2007 Last Trans Effective Date N/A Last Annual Report Date 04/30/2012 Last Annual Report Year 2012 Cross Reference Name N/A If this is not the correct information,please hit your browsers''Back'button and enter another document number. Continue I Home Contact us I Document Searches I E-Filinq Services Forms i Help i Copyright©and Privacy Policies State of Florida,Department of State • https://efile.sunbiz.org/scripts/certauthver.exe 8/20/2012 www.sunbiz.org-Department of State Page 2 of 2 Document Images 04/30/2012—ANNUAL REPORT( View image in PDF format 04/30/2011 —ANNUAL REPORT( View image in PDF format 04/30/2010—ANNUAL REPORT[ View image in PDF format 04/30/2009—ANNUAL REPORT( View image in PDF format 04/29/2008—ANNUAL REPORT( View image in PDF format 06/27/2007--Amendment ( View image in PDF format 06/27/2007—Off/Dir Resignation [ View image in PDF format 04/30/2007—ANNUAL REPORT[ View image in PDF format • 04/25/2006—ANNUAL REPORT( View image in PDF format 07/02/2005—ANNUAL REPORT( View image in PDF format 08/06/2004—Amendment [ View image in PDF format 03/11/2004—Domestic Profit ( View image in PDF format ) INote:This is not official record.See documents if question or conflict. Previous on List Next on List Return To List Entity Name Search Events No Name History I Submit Home I Contact us I Document Searches I E.Filing Services ) Forms ( Help I Copyright Cs and Privacy Policies State of Florida,Department or State http://www sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?action=DETFIL&ing_doc_number=P04000047869&inq_came_from NAMFWD... 8/30/2012 2012 FOR PROFIT CORPORATION ANNUAL REPORT FILED DOCUMENT# P04000047869 Secretary of State Entity Name: ARTISTIC CABINETRY, INC. Current Principal Place of Business: New Principal Place of Business: 2183 CORPORATION BLVD. NAPLES, FL 34109 Current Mailing Address: New Mailing Address: P.O. BOX 9823 NAPLES, FL 34101 FEI Number:55-0866696 FEI Number Applied For( ) FEI Number Not Applicable( ) Certificate of Status Desired( ) Name and Address of Current Registered Agent: Name and Address of New Registered Agent: GOFF, DAVID R 2761 6TH AVE. NE NAPLES, FL 34120 US The above named entity submits this statement for the purpose of changing its registered office or registered agent, or both, in the State of Florida. SIGNATURE: Electronic Signature of Registered Agent Date OFFICERS AND DIRECTORS: Title: D Name: GOFF,DAVID R Address: 2761 6TH AVE.NE City-St-Zip: NAPLES,FL 34120 Title: O Name: HOOPER,WILLIAM Address: 1200 RESERVE WAY#107 City-St-Zip: NAPLES,FL 34105 • I hereby certify that the information indicated on this report or supplemental report is true and accurate and that my electronic signature shall have the same legal effect as if made under oath;that I am an officer or director of the corporation or the receiver or trustee empowered to execute this report as required by Chapter 607, Florida Statutes;and that my name appears above,or on an attachment with all other like empowered. SIGNATURE: DAVID GOFF PRES 04/30/2012 Electronic Signature of Signing Officer or Director Date • Policy Number: 8090017029 Date Entered: 3/23/2009 ACCORD CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE �;(MINDD' ) THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES BELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUING INSURER(S), AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER,AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. IMPORTANT: If the certificate holder is an ADDITIONAL INSURED,the policy(les) must be endorsed. If SUBROGATION IS WAIVED, subject to the terms and conditions of the policy,certain policies may require an endorsement. A statement on this certificate does not confer rights to the certificate holder in lieu of such endorsement(s). CONTACT PRODUCER Perlin Insurance Agency PHONE (239)263-3141 239)263-8696 PO Box 366697 Bonita Springs, FL 34136 / �°"E"t)' FAX F4X �) ADDRESS: 24520 Production Cr. , #4 INSURERS)AFFORDING COVERAGE NAIC# Bonita Springs, FL 34135 I A:NORTHPOINTE INS. CO. INSURED ARTISTIC CABINETRY INC INSURER B: DAVID GOFF INSURER C: PO BOX 9823 INSURER D: NAPLES, FL 34101 INSURER E: INSURER F: COVERAGES CERTIFICATE NUMBER: REVISION NUMBER: THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD INDICATED. NOTWITHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENT, TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER DOCUMENT WITH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBED HEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS, EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES.LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIMS. INSR TYPE OF INSURANCE ADDL VND POLICY NUMBER (NNAIDD/YYYY) (POLICY LIMTS LTR INSR WVD GENERAL LIABIUTY EACH OCCURRENCE $1,000,000 X DAMAGE TO RENTED 100 000 A /� COMMERCIAL GENERAL UP,BILITY 809001702 9 07/25/2012 37/25/2013 maims(Ea occurrence) $ CLAIMS-MADE IXlOCCUR MED EXP(Any one person) $5,000 X LIMITS ARE AS PERSONAL&ADV INJURY $1,000,000 OF INCEPTION GENERAL AGGREGATE $2,000,000 GENT.AGGREGATE LIMIT APPLIES PER: PRODUCTS-COMP/OP AGG $2,000,000 XPOLICY r7 F a 1 1 LOC $ AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY COMBINED accident)SINGLE LIMrr J_______ ANY AUTO BODILY INJURY(Per person) $ ALL OWNED SCHEDULED AUTOS AUTOS BODILY INJURY(Per accident) $ NON-OWNED PROPERTY DAMAGE $ HIRED AUTOS AUTOS (Per accident) - $ UMBRELLA LIAB _ OCCUR EACH OCCURRENCE $ EXCESS LIAB CLAIMS-MADE AGGREGATE $ DED I RETENTION$ $ WORKERS COMPENSATION I WC CY LIMITS I I T AND EMPLOYERS'LIABILITY Y/N ANY PROPRIETOR/PARTNER/EXECUTIVE N/A E.L EACH ACCIDENT $ OFFICER/MEMBER EXCLUDED? (Mandatory In NH) E.L.DISEASE-EA EMPLOYEE $ If yes,describe under E.L DISEASE-POLICY LIMIT $ DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS below DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS I LOCATIONS I VEHICLES(Attach ACORD 101,Additional Remarks Schedule,H more space is required) CABINETRY INSTALATION CERTIFICATE HOLDER CANCELLATION __. COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD SHOULD ANY OF TH ABOVE DESCRIBED POLIC .S BE CANCELLED BEFORE THE EXPIRATION TE THEREOF, NOTICE ' LL BE DELIVERED IN DEVELOPMENT SERVICES CENTER ACCORDANCE WITH POLICY PROVISIONS. 2800 N. HORSESHOE DRIVE , l NAPLES, FL 34104 FAX (239) 252-2469 A t .•RIZEDREPRESENTATIVE \ D .',■r-a qn_-_• \ � \ I ®1988-2010 ACORD CORPORATION. All rights reserved. ACORD 25(2010/05) The ACORD name and logo are registered marks of ACORD Produced using Forms Boss Plus software.www.FormsBoss.com;Impressive Publishing 800-208-1977 Jul. 17. 2012 2:53PM No. 319U_ P. 1/1 �,.�-.� Poesy Monism: 8090017029 vow cRlella,_ J/L,�/2009 AR°® CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE I RATS 1"42001 '' THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER.THIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMID, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES BELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUNIG BNIURER(S), AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER,AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. IMPORTANT: If the certificate holder Is an AUU ODIAL INSIMED,the pn&y(Ies)must be endorsed If SUBROGATION IS WAIVED,subject to the terms and conditions of the pommy,certain policies may require all endorsement A statement on this certificate does not canter lights to the ' certificate holder In lieu of such endorsement(s). PRODUCER . -MAME Parlin Tnsurance Agency - P0 Box 366697 Bonita Springs, 8L 34136 X(239)263-3141 I (239)263-8696 24520 Production Cr., t4 Bonita Springs, FL 34135 INSIel SIAFFORWtBCOV�IQE _ RAIG/- _ t A:NUAT MI= INIT. CO. olsOnsO ARTISTIC CAHStISTRY MC IRDIRER e_ DAVID G089T umaume Q: PO BOX 9923 ROW=D: NAPLES, FL 34101 REHMEREt' 8150155 F: COVERAGES _ CERTIFICATE NUMBER: _ REVISION NUMBER: THIS IS TO CERTIFY TWAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD INDICATED. NOTWITHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENT.TERM OR CONUmON Of ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER DOCUMENT WITH RESPECT TO WINCH THIS CERTIFICATE MAY RE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN.11€BISURANCE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBED HEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS, EXCLUSIONS AND colan0No OF SUCH POLICIES.LIMITS SHOWN/MAY NAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAD CIA/MS. ORYNR M aalmllYS� LTR TROFsunAlIN y LIMITS - oE►tERAL LUMIITY FACMOCCURRENcE $1,000,000 A 1 corm.seN AanJIY 8090017029 X712512012 37/25/2013 a nosl $100,000 f(2AfAI3lRIIDE OCdg1 MEDICO)Oft/anspima) #5,000 LIMITS ARE AS PETRSONALaAUNauilty J$1,000,000 OF INCEPTION eE/It RALA,t sseerat 0,000.000 _ Gera AGGAEGATELUTAPPI EBrot p TS_tQlxrA s $2,000,000 - _I d y►� $ ANT AUTO 8OOLY$JURY(Per POMO $ AUTOS 8OUL erIIRY(Peraodosall $AUTOS HIRED AUTOS MIies IPRISalearil $ Ial9RELLA Wle _ OCpIR EKE OCCURRENCE R ACCESS LIAR CLAM-UWE , A88AEOATE $ MO I 1 IR O:KROH$ ! — WQNREtScONI INRATI 3N AIR!F.MPLOWRS'LIANUTY TORY LAM ER ANY PROPRIETORAVIRINEREXECIRIVE NIA lone In EL_DISEASE-EAEMPUNE: $ ELEACHACCEErrr $ - y n s IIONoropBUU10NSsow EA.OtsrASE-POIICYI*NT $ DESCII•rIONOP OPERATIONS/LOOATIOIS/YBBCLFS IASadfACORn 101.AMMO Roman meldee..Aaron spws Is wows CABINBTR2 INSTALATIONN CERTIFICATE HOMER C = ,TION ARTISTIC caunis2RY, inc. / DAVID ROW .c.i.„: •, =F THE ABOVE DESCRIBED POLICIES BE CANCELLED BEFORE PO StilL 9823 ' .,y TE08 DATE TIT , NOTICE WILL at t7ELIVERED NI i'i i {n_ t THE POt ICY PROV lS NAPLES, IL 34101 - " FAX 596-7625 I---"±+! . 4 1980--1• , ACORD CORPORATION. AN rights reserved. ACORD 26(2010106) The ACORD name and lege are regt tared marks of ACORD Armco who fans floss PIt4=Rims.wagtFptasaascran Impriasive Pa +9 800-208-1917 08-21-2012 JEFF ATWATER STATE OF FLORIDA CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES DIVISION OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION * * CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT FROM FLORIDA WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW * * CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY EXEMPTION This certifies that the individual listed below has elected to be exempt from Florida Workers' Compensation law. EFFECTIVE DATE: 08/10/2012 EXPIRATION DATE: 08/10/2014 PERSON: GOFF DAVID FEIN: 550866696 BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS: ARTISTIC CABINETRY INC 2761 6TH. AVE. N.E. NAPLES FL 34120 SCOPES OF BUSINESS OR TRADE: 1- CARPENTRY - INSTALLATION OF CA 2- CARPENTRY - 5437 IMPORTANT: Pursuant to Chapter 440 . 05114), F.S., an officer of a corporation who elects exemption from this chapter by filing a certificate of election ender this section may not recover benefits or compensation Ender this chapter. Pnrsaast to Chapter 440.05112), F.S., Certificates of election to be exempt... apply only within the scope of the business or trade listed on the notice of election to be exempt. Permit to Chapter 440.05113), F.S., Notices ad election to be exert and certificates of election to be exempt shall be subject to revocation if, at any time after the filing of the notice or the issuance of the certificate, the poses named on the notice or certificate no longer meets the requirements of this section for issuance of a certificate. The department shall revoke a certificate at any time for failure of the person named on the certificate to meet the requirements of this section. QUESTIONS? (850) 413-1609 DWC-252 CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT REVISED 01-11 PLEASE CUT OUT THE CARD BELOW AND RETAIN FOR FUTURE REFERENCE STATE OF FLORIDA IMPORTANT DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES s T' D F IVISION OF WORKERS'COMPENSATION e42,1, 'tr ^Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(14), F.S, an officer of a corporation who CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY -' elects exemption from this chapter by filing a certificate of election CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT FROM FLORIDA R ;� e L under this section may not recover benefits or compensation under this WORKERS'COMPENSATION LAWS D chapter. EFFECTIVE 08/10/2012 EXPIRATION DATE: 08/10/2014 Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(12), F.S, Certificates of election to be PERSON: DAVID GOFF H exempt.. apply only within the scope of the business or trade listed on FEIN: 550866696 the notice of election to be exempt BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS: E Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(13), F.S., Notices of election to be exempt ARTISTIC CABINETRY INC and certificates. of election to be exempt shall be subject to revocation 2761 6TH. AVE. N.E. if, at any time after the filing of the notice or the issuance of the NAPLES. FL 34120 certificate, the person named on the notice or certificate no longer meets the requirements of this section for issuance of a certificate. The department shall revoke a certificate at any time for failure of the SCOPE OF BUSINESS OR TRADE person named on the certificate to meet the requirements of this 1- CARPENTRY - INSTALLATION OF CA 2- CARPENTRY - 5437 section. QUESTIONS? (850) 413-1609 CUT HERE * Carry bottom portion on the job, keep upper portion for your records. DWC-252 CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT REVISED 01-11 VERIFICATION OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE GMD Operations & Regulatory Management Department Licensing Section 2800 N.Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 Applicant's Name: 1 (LV 1 0 e Certificate Category Requested: catty, OA,S"Tl&( t COO✓ .41—a C`C CD V-"" The Applicant is seeking a Collier County Certificate of Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of the application for this certificate the Applicant must verify their experience within this trade. You are being requested to provide information that will aid the Applicant in meeting this requirement.You should verify time of active experience working as an apprentice or a skilled worker(e.g.as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better in the trade). Time served solely in a supervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be considered sufficient to demonstrate required trade experience. The person verifying trade experience must provide the following information: Name,Title and license number of the person signing below and verifying Applicants relevant experience: Name: �_7"t " 1' /1 �-L•- 1 Title: J 1' • Z9 11_1 ei/s!...._ . I:)ec 17 i%J License Number(if applicable): Name of Business: I—i 1 1``\--t1 S tL- 'L%"1-, 'C' - / Y t / Business Address: ) �� �'f / /<��_". &) t_ /� � �L��y � T // 2-- Business Phone: 2 3 c•'i-/L[j "3.�S~L/The Applicant's years of experience from CO 2— to 4)/2_ 11 , The applicant's scope of work(specific duties)included: O n/J , ,t.; e !1_ t / 6i/_)? &//,1 /i ,L ii Additional Comments:. Ob'-"t) — Ai s j/ c'P/I) t=om-- 1 t`'I) e':vriJ/9-1.�F' - /9--.71-.,) 717 e et:I,)7,f), 7- Falsifying any information provided herein may subject your license to revocati '' 'I-/1 4 . �� �AP—. t4 Si a.•tare Print Name: ,_�16 k 4PP2 State of Florida County of Collier The for going instrument was acknowbdged before me on this 1 14 day of 4/3 i 7 2_0 / 2, by foregoing ft) 1 t II/ who is personally known to me or produced J-'1'i/'4 Or`,ye- L;c r'- c- as identification and who did not take an oath. •'c1,' ERIK Signature of Notary ; !1 Notary Public•Maio of Florida ii..�_ My Comm EgWss Jana 2016 '�xz{ Commis*,•1E NM 6 VERIFICATION OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE! GMD Operations & Regulatory Management Department Licensing Section 2800 N.Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 Applicant's Name: �V (� go.a Certificate Category Requested: ( Cv L (t t t� "L��- 1, ) !i b The Applicant is seeking a Collier County Certificate of Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of the application for this certificate the Applicant must verify their experience within this trade. You are being requested to provide information that will aid the Applicant in meeting this requirement.You should verify time of active experience working as an apprentice or a skilled worker(e.g.as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better in the trade). Time served solely in a supervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be considered sufficient to demonstrate required trade experience. The person verifying trade experience must provide the following information: Name,Title and license number of the person signing below and verifying Applicants relevant experience: Name: C1�CLI Title: €5`a z�- License Number(if applicable): C '-'t SC f I Name of Business: -� \ Z') e i lt Z— Business Address: ae fi >� i--'T J j C t j F 1` 4- ! f Business Phone:13 1"%'cm- 3g4- The Applicant's years of experience from t.0 oO to 2012- The applicant's scope of work(specific duties)included: C..ct i 4) o$'1-- Additional Comments: & \\--CL.5 (:tr1 4,0.-4-1 3 L $tn. (!)&. v"'/ eisuetti Falsifying any information provided herein may subject your license to revocation. Signature,--->- Print Name: 'S. cikar•ik. .14.4-V State of Florida County of Collier The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this 474'- day of 4vwb{ by Q }, CrS fleAKEr who is personally known to me or produced FL. tn. .moo` as identification and who did not take an oath. Ilb... K:� 11.1-41 ._. .igna a of otary o••"Y ru.,,� JOSHUA SELPH ..►'` a,. :"`,• Notary Public-State&Florida ires Ma •: ''' •' All Gomm.Exp May ' , t`- y Commission#EE 95001 1 iii-4 c I i i ti ` i aka) ��W SISI Pi tb !! D. opi'[S GMD Operations &Regulatory Management Department Licensing Section 2800 N.Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 Applicant's Name: a v i Cif T"° Certificate Category Requested: ea c) ji 44 I P‘.64-Ct.i-l (.._ — -rQ &- i. The Applicant is seeking a Collier County Certificate of Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of the application for this certificate the Applicant must verify their experience within this trade.You are being requested to provide information that will aid the Applicant in meeting this requirement.You should verify time of active experience working as an apprentice or a skilled worker(e.g.as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better in the trade). Time served solely in a supervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be considered sufficient to demonstrate required trade experience.The person verifying trade experience must provide the following information: Name,Title and license number of the person signing below and verifying Applicants _relevant ecperience: Name: /& / "14.1) 4)k ■ ay' , .e-�/1) ;L'I ,, 3� LOS 93e Title•/ ���� License Number(if applicable): Name of Business: /��A J I L z' e G' 0' JI e`' / Business Address: 3 7 f'til.- -2: Ct4 cab ,�,4 /1-1 /A 2.. 3 W i Business Phone: 'SY'9 6L --L 0 04e Applicant's years of experience from -�' 2:�` to • 6')' The applicant's scope of work(specific duties)included: D 6 4)— l5/-) t1 e e71S t j f1-1,.57-JCS 5 e–z"7 ,4S 4,16- TD Additional Comments: 4 ' 4' //4Z) � / 3! (t.,.'7 ,2J .7.7 -;),q./-7, C of f Falsifying any information provided herein may subject your licens/or^'r.:tion. ( ,z2-1 „ V4,..iff. Signature ) & =� � / c Print Name-f 7 , State of Florida County of Collier th The fo going instrument was acknowledged before me on this o f day of j4-a5 U ` 20/2— by -or i CV1 (V1 . Et if 6-fl- who is ona y own tom or produced as identification and who did not take an oath / /4-Z ,,,,�, RORI MORRISON Signature of No My ON#EE217109 �' i-.ig: EXPIRES' 4,2016 Beaded' Notary C l !� I-Cott) r 5 AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER I, c`'�-tir-i A • 4/15 , am a resident of Co\ ' e r"` County, F1 d : Oc (State) and have resided here for more than five (5) years. During the last five years I have known Z (Applicant). I have had the opportunity to observe his or her business and personal ealings and find him or her to be a person of honesty, integrity and good character. (Signature) - _,__l. h (Name)' '-c, ks--4.. "- . � (Address) 0 4-2 lC- M Gw P L.. 3 +I)Z Telephone) 2:5t STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this Z7 OC i4-wzk k by` (Date) Qn��ald AYS E who has produced PL (name of person acknowledging) (Type of identification) as identification and who did not take an oath. 110 1 t A TUBE OF NOT NOTARY'S SEAL (P NAME OF NOT OTARY PUBLIC JOSHUA SELPH Notary Public-State of Florida o My Comm.Expires May 17,2015 of,, Commission#EE 95001 9 AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER ki /6 , g�''j°/0 am a resident of ---4 ' County, f e2- b,1 (State) and have resided here fo more than five (5) years. During the last five years I have known ti kit applicant). I have had the opportunity to observe his or her business and personal dealings an. .1 s him or her to be a person of honesty, integrity and good character. //0 (Sign: ..• '�,' (Name)/4 661°11 (Address)3 7?-7-66J6-(-06(N) Z'�Q 41'4&6- ',�ti , /) Telephone) 39-6i/1'i-066-6) STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this (0 a 1 2011. by _ 'n (Date) �1■Q.Y1 .U\00-4 who has produced 1 ) (name of person acknowledging) (Type of identification) as identification and who did not take an oath. _RD SIGN• It !F NOTARY QrIQ ahOral) NOTARY'S SEAL (PRINT I\TAME OF NOTARY) NOT• : • in �,o'11''''' PRYA BAHORAN A0'11 L Notary Public-State of Florida My Comm.Expires Oct 5,2012 Commission#i DD 828411 `�� Bonded Through National Notary Assn. 8 I_. .. - w. :4 �icorw xrsrr'e nF'RII IWFSS FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION I. COLLIER COUNTY BUSINESS TAX BUSINESS T (239, BER: 901648 COLLIER COUNTY TAX:COLLECTOR 2800 N.HORSESHOE DRIVE-NAPLES FLORIDA 34104-(239)252-2477 VISIT OUR WEBSITE AT:www.cotliert ax.com THIS RECEIPT EXPIRES SEPTEMBER 30, 2013 , + ' DISPLAY AT.�LACE OF BUSINESS FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION LOCATION:2761 6TH AVE.NE �k EGAL F0Rm '/M1 FAILURE-TO DO SOTS CONTRARY TO LOCAL LAWS. .� THIS TAXIS NON-REFUNDABLE - ZONED: �.{ _ CORPOF3ATION�.0 ` '' BUSINESS PHONE: 353-9318 s:. k, I� ARTISTIC CABINETRY INC. COUNTY LIC: 11036 ; GOFF,DAVID P.0.BOX 9823 t,+ r x t NAPLES FL 34101-0000 w ,_ 'fit t NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES: 1 10 EMPLOYEES �,- ' ' CLASSIFICATION:CABINET 8 MILLWORK CONTRACTOR } '. DATE 08/24/2012 CLASSIFICATION CODE:02107501:.: AMOUNT 18.00 This document is business tax only.This is not certification that licensee is qualified. RECEIPT 3414.40 It does.not permitthe.licensee to.violate any existing regulatory zoning laws of the state,county or cities i ` -' nor does it exempt the licensee from any other or permits that may be required by law. ` ? ' w ti` � 4 - 17 cusses .4:44,-,„.-4,* ..-,:t.,4 .F � , 5 -• ; „„, ,, � 7 .-.;.,,, ,,... .,„_* 4 „4.-.),,,,,, -_,... ,....., ...h., • BEFORE THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD Petitioner Case Number: 2012-03 v. License Number: LINDA CURIALE CGC1508927/27333 D/B/A Global Maintenance &Restoration, Inc. Respondent / STIPULATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND AGREED ORDER LINDA CURIALE and BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD (hereafter BOARD) hereby stipulate and agree: 1. Respondent admits the allegations in Administrative Complaint for the purposes of this stipulation and settlement of this matter. 2. Respondent and the BOARD hereby agree that she will be subject to probation for a period of twelve (12)months whereby the Respondent will perform her contracting activities under the supervision of the Board. 3. Respondent and the BOARD further agree that Respondent will personally apply for all permits and be present,either in person or telephonically for any reviews or questions as to the contracting operations of the company which she qualifies during the probationary period. This includes permits issued by the Cities of Marco Island or Naples and for fire code reviews. • 4. In the event the Respondent violates paragraph 3 of this stipulation agreement while on probation,her license/certificate will be immediately suspended for any new permits and a hearing on the suspension and violation shall be held at the next scheduled Board hearing. 5. This stipulation and order shall be forwarded to the State Construction Industry Licensing Board with a recommendation of no further action. Executed this day of March,2012. Tibia . . 4,-, „L Lin a unale . •ssorio Respondent Contractors' Licensing Supervisor ORDER ADOPTING STIPULATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT THE BOARD BEING FULLY ADVISED on the Stipulated Settlement Agreement,it is hereby: ADJUDGED that the foregoing Stipulated Settlement Agreement is adopted in its entirety, and the parties are ordered to comply therewith. DONE AND ORDERED at the regrlarly set Contr ntors' Licensing Board hearing at Naples, Collier County, Florida on this day of goe RI ,2012. Lee Horn Chairman Contractors' Licensing Board Page 1 of 1 Paul Bollenback From: bjvpglobal @aol.com Sent: Wednesday, July 18,2012 11:22 AM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: mcuriale2 @aol.com; Curiale47 @yahoo.com; gmriinc @embargmail.com; surfsedgemgr @comcast.net Subject: Re:4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 Attachments: 247080.pdf unit 707_glass_data_sheet_surfsedge.pdf Mr.Bollenback Here is the information that I found in regards to glass currently installed at the surfsedge unit 707. The glass is fire rated. It is rated for 45 min. Please let me know if this is sufficient. Please let me know if you have any concerns. Thank you again for your help with this matter. Have a good day! ----Original Message---- From: Paul Bollenback<pbollenback @naplesgov.com> To: 'bjvpglobal @aol.com' <bjvpglobal @aol.com> Cc: mcuriale2<mcuriale2 @aol.com>; Curiale47<Curiale47 @yahoo.com>;gmriinc <gmriinc @embargmail.com>; surfsedgemgr<surfsedgemgr @comcast.net>; David Matthews <dmatthews @naplesgov.com>; Robert Banker<rbanker @naplesgov.com> Sent:Wed,Jul 18, 2012 7:02 am Subject: RE:4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 I will have an inspector from this office contact the owner or building manager to gain access to the unit to confirm the glass etching and specifically what information the etching contains.We will need whatever paperwork you can get from the manufacturer for our records. At that time a determination as to code compliance can be made. The paperwork needs to be directed to me. Be advised that I will be off the week of July 23-27. Paul Bollenback . Building Official City of Naples g. 239-213-5037 pbol lenbacknnaplesgov.corn ( From: bjvpcilobakaaol.com Imailto:bivDolobak aol.coml Sent: Monday,July 16, 2012 9:58 AM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: mcuriale2 @aol.com; Curiale47 @yahoo.com; gmriinc @embargmail.com; surfsedgemgr@comcast.net Subject: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 Mr. Bollenback, G Goodmorning Paul. My name is William Rench and I work for Global Maintenance. I am emailing you because I need to get the issues at hand in regards to the fire rated glass at the Surfsedge unit 707 resolved and put behind us. I have found out with a little research that piece of glass installed currently Is fire rated. I took the information which is etched on the glass in the bottom right hand corner (Oldcastle 8 laminated 41 16 CFR 1201-11 DCA LSG BUTACITE)and found out it is fire rated glass. It is called Pyroguard. I am currently waiting on the manufacturer to get me the fire rating on it. It is either 20,45,60 or 90 minute fire rating. As soon as I find this information out I will contact you and the Surfsedge. Please if you have any questions call me or email me at your convenience. Thank you and have a great day. 07/30/2012 BEFORE THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD Petitioner, V. Case Number: 2012-10 License Number: CGC1508927/27333 Linda Curiale D/B/A—Global Maintenance &Restoration, Inc. Respondent. / ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT Collier County(County)files the Administrative Complaint against Linda Curiale ( Respondent), a State of Florida licensed General Contractor( license#CGC1508927/Collier County Certificate#27333), and states the following facts and allegations in support of the cited violations below: 1. The Respondent is currently licensed by The State of Florida as a Certified General Contractor with License number CGC1508927. 2. Under the provisions of Florida Statute 489.113(4)(b)the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board is authorized to impose penalties against State Certified Contractors for willfully violating Building Codes. 3. Under the provisions of Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended,Section 22-201.1,the following actions by a holder of a Certified General Contractor License shall constitute misconduct and grounds for discipline pursuant to Section 22-202. a. On August 8, 2012 a complaint was received from The City of Naples Building Official, Paul Bollenback,concerning construction at 4001 Gulfshore Blvd. North#707,with City of Naples Building Permit#09-1552,described "as install drywall and one electrical outlet to make the lanai look finished". Permit was then revised to include the removal of sliding glass door from kitchen to lanai. Said revision included the installation of a sliding glass door and fire rated glass at exterior of vertical opening at lanai area. Correspondence from representative of Global Maintenance& Restoration, Inc.,William Rench, and City of Naples Building • T Official, Paul Bollenback,show the specifications of the glass being "Oldcastle 8 laminated 41 16 CFR 1201—I.II DCA LSG Butacite".Said correspondence further indicating that product is fire rated, as required by 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9—"Vertical separation of openings". Communication between City of Naples Building Official, Paul Bollenback, and representative of manufacturer, Oldcastle Glass, resulted in a determination that product installed was not fire rated. Installation of non-fire rated glass in this application constitutes a violation of the 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9—"Vertical separation of openings".Above permit had a last passing inspection on 6/15/09 and had a scheduled expiration date of approximately 12/15/09. Between 12/15/09 and 9/1/12 several extension /reapplication requests were made to the City of Naples and granted.As of 9/1/12,the permit is in an expired status. b. Pursuant to the settlement of Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board Case#2012-03 on March 21, 2012,within the "Stipulated Settlement Agreement and Agreed Order",the respondent and the Board agreed that respondent will be subject to probation for a period of twelve(12) months whereby the Respondent will perform her contracting activities under the supervision of the Board. c. Thereafter, pursuant to Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended,Section 22-202(b) and Section 22-202(c),the case was investigated and found sufficient cause to file formal charges. 4. Collier County brings the following charge in this formal complaint against the Respondent. COUNT I 5. Collier County Ordinance 90-105,as amended,Section 22.201.1(2) state"Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state,city or Collier County". WHEREFORE, the Petitioner asserts the above facts and charges are grounds for disciplinary action under Section 22-201.1 of Collier County Ordinance 90-105,as amended,and WHEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing,the Petitioner respectfully requests the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board to find the Respondent guilty of the violations charged. Dated: 1i/L, KI ZOt Signed: Lb Collier County Contractors' Licensing Supervisor or Designee i I C.L.B.Case#2012-10 Linda Curiale—D/B/A Global Maintenance& Restoration, Inc. Summary On 12/22/08, Global Maintenance& Restoration, Inc., qualified by Linda Curiale,contracted for the installation of exterior slider on balcony at 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N.#707,owned by Farid Chehab. (E10& E11) City of Naples Building Permit 09-1552 (originally issued to install drywall and one electrical outlet to make the lanai look finished) was revised to include the installation of the exterior slider. (E12& E13/ E19&E20) On August 15, 2009 The City of Naples review of the plans submitted for the installation of the exterior slider revealed the elimination of the existing sliding glass door in the non-sprinkled building would likely require the exterior door to be compliant with Section 704.9 of the 2007 Florida Building Code. (E32& E33) July 16, 2012 correspondence between Global Maintenance& Restoration, Inc. representative, William Rench and City of Naples Building Official, Paul Bollenback, indicate the specifications of the glass installed being"Oldcastle 8 laminated 41 16 CFR 1201- 1.11 DCA LSG Butacite".Specifications were confirmed by inspection by City of Naples Building Inspector and by Collier County License Compliance Officer, Ian Jackson. In said correspondence, It is indicated by Global Maintenance & Restoration representative,William Rench,that the glass installed is fire rated, as required by 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9. In communication between City of Naples Building Official, Paul Bollenback and Oldcastle Glass/ Miami office, it was determined that, by utilizing the specifications from the glass installed,the product was not fire rated, as required by 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9.Said determination was confirmed, in telephone communication, between Collier County License Compliance Officer, Ian Jackson, and Oldcastle Glass representative at Miami office.The installation of non-fire rated glass in this application constitutes a violation of the 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9. (E33) The above noted Building Permit had its last passed inspection on 6/15/09.The scheduled expiration date for Permit was approximately 12/15/09. Between 12/15/09 and 9/1/12 several requests for extension were made to The City of Naples and granted. As of 9/1/12,The Permit is in an expired status. Pursuant to the Settlement of Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board Case#2012-03 on March 21, 2012,within the "Stipulated Settlement Agreement and Agreed Order",the respondent and the Board agreed that the respondent will be subject to probation for a period of twelve(12) months whereby the Respondent will perform her contracting activities under the supervision of the Board. (E48& E49) The installation of the non-fire rated glass in this application constitutes a violation of 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9.The respondent's refusal or inability to abate said violation constitutes a violation of Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended,Section 22-201.1(2), "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state,city or Collier County. (E50) Contractors' Licensing Board 2800 North Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Fl.34104 Complaint Number-2012-10 Complainant: Any person who believes that a Contractor holding a State Certification or Certificate of competency has violated Collier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended, may submit a sworn complaint to the Contractor Licensing supervisor, or his/her designee.The complaint shall be in substantially the form prescribed by the Contractor Licensing Supervisor.The complainant shall pay a fee of$50.00 to defray the costs of administering the complaint,at the time of filing the complaint.The complaining party shall state with particularity which section(s) of this Ordinance he or she believes has been violated by the contractor and the essential facts in support thereof. Complaint: Please print or type and return signed copies of the complaint. Date: September, 10,2012 Against: Contractor's Name: Linda Curiale Phone: 239-774-3990 Business Name:Global Maintenance& Restoration, Inc. License Number if known:CGC1508927 Collier County Competency number: 27333 Contractor's Business Address: P.O. Box 534 Marco Island, Fl. 34146 Filed By: Name: Collier County Contractors' Licensing/Ian Jackson Address: 2800 North Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Fl. 34104 Business Phone: 239-252-2451 Address where work done:4001 Gulfshore Blvd N.#707 City: Naples County: Collier Date of contract: 12/22/08 Date job started: Permit applied for 5/18/09 Date job completed or new home occupied: Not completed Were there plans and specifications?Yes Is there a written contract?Yes. If yes, amount of Contract:$4,375.00 Has Contractor been paid in full?Yes. If not,what amount? NA Was a Building Permit obtained?Yes Building Permit number if known:City of Naples 09-1552 Have you communicated by letter with the licensee?Yes Date: 8/21/12. Do you have a reply?Yes Please attach to this form all copies of the purchase agreement, building contract, home improvement contract,copies of receipts and/or cancelled checks available and any additional evidence to substantiate your allegations. List any subsections of Section 4 of Collier County Ordinance number 90- 105, as amended, which, in your opinion, have been violated by the contractor which is the subject of this complaint, (list subsection number): 22-201.1(2)-Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state,city or Collier County. E2 T Please state the facts which you believe substantiate your charge of misconduct against the subject contractor. List facts separately for each subsection number above: On 12/22/08 Global Maintenance&-Restoration;Inc.-, qualified by Linda Curiale,contracted for installation of exterior slider on balcony at 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N.#707,owned by Farid Chehab. City of Naples Building Permit 09-1552 (originally issued to install drywall and one electrical outlet to make the lanai look finished) was revised to include the installation of the exterior slider. On August 15, 2009 The City of Naples review of the plans submitted for the installation of the exterior slider revealed the elimination of the existing sliding glass door in the non-sprinkled building would likely require the exterior door to be compliant with Section 704.9 of the 2007 Florida Building Code. July 16, 2012 correspondence between Global Maintenance& Restoration, Inc. representative, William Rench and City of Naples Building Official, Paul Bollenback, indicate the specifications of the glass installed being"Oldcastle 8 laminated 41 16 CFR 1201- 1.11 DCA LSG Butacite".Specifications were confirmed by inspection by City of Naples Building Inspector and by Collier County License Compliance Officer, Ian Jackson. In said correspondence, It is indicated by Global Maintenance & Restoration representative,William Rench,that the glass installed is fire rated, as required by 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9. In communication between City of Naples Building Official, Paul Bollenback and Oldcastle Glass/ Miami office, it was determined that, by utilizing the specifications from the glass installed,the product was not fire rated, as required by 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9. Said determination was confirmed, in telephone communication, between Collier County License Compliance Officer, Ian Jackson,and Oldcastle Glass representative at Miami office.The installation of non-fire rated glass in this application constitutes a violation of the 2007 Florida Building Code Section 704.9. The above noted Building Permit had its last passed inspection on 6/15/09.The scheduled expiration date for Permit was approximately 12/15/09. Between 12/15/09 and 9/1/12 several requests for extension were made to The City of Naples and granted.As of 9/1/12,The Permit is in an expired status. Pursuant to the Settlement of Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board Case#2012-03 on March 21, 2012,within the "Stipulated Settlement Agreement and Agreed Order",the respondent and the Board agreed that the respondent will be subject to probation for a period of twelve(12) months whereby the Respondent will perform her contracting activities under the supervision of the Board. The installation of the non-fire rated glass in this application constitutes a violation of 2007 Florida Buil 1n: Cod Section 704.9.The respondent's refusal or inability to abate said violation constitutes a viol t)io of Qollier County Ordinance 90-105, as amended,Section 22-201.1(2), "Willfully violating the app4cable b ilding codes or laws of the state, city or Collier County. lia ( Complai"ant's signature) State of: �Ie+�� je\ County of: C(.9 Iqr e--,3 SENDER COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A. Signatu` item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. ■ Print your name and address on the reverse X 0 Adde ssee i so that we can return the card to you. v t 3•�w Addressee ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, B eceived by ' _ • , - C. Date of Delivery 1 or on the front if space permits. Q 1 • 1. Article Addressed to: D. Is delivery¢' drff i 1 0 Yes — - --- If YES,en lied ess be.w: ❑No Linda Curiale ' Global Maintenance & Restoration Inc US1) P.O. Box 534 Marco Island, FL 34146 I 3. sendcerype 0 Certified Mail ❑Express Mall j 0 Registered 0 Return Receipt for Merchandise"f ❑Insured Mail 0 C.O.D. 4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes 2. Article Number (Transterfrom service label) 0 7 2560 5 6 0 0001 0 01 1485 8 5 5124 4 I PS Form 3811,-February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt _ -- t 1o2595-02�n� ,' li� DBPR- CURIALE, LINDA MICHELE; Doing Business As: GLOBAL MAINTENANC... Page 1 of 1 1:31:08 PM 9/10/2012 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: CURIALE, LINDA MICHELE (Primary Name) GLOBAL MAINTENANCE & RESTORATION INC (DBA Name) Main Address: P.O. BOX 534 MARCO ISLAND Florida 34146-0534 County: COLLIER License Mailing: LicenseLocation: License Information License Type: Certified General Contractor Rank: Cert General License Number: CGC1508927 Status: Current,Active Licensure Date: 04/21/2005 Expires: 09/14/2012 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective Construction Business 04/21/2005 View Related License Information View License Complaint 1940 North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email:Customer Contact Center:: Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395 The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395."Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,20.12,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change. https://www.myfloridalicense.com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&id=B2FOBBFC5F4D 1074F 1... 9/10/2012 Certificate Detail Report 'CDPR2305 - Certificate Detail Report CERT NBR QUALIFIER NAME DBA STATUS 27333 LINDA CURIALE GLOBAL MAINTENANCE & RESTORATION, I SUSPD DETAIL CLASS CODE CLASS DESC STATE NBR 1010 GENERAL CONTR.--CERTIFIED CGC 1508927 ORIG ISSD DATE STATE EXP DATE 5/26/2005 8/31/2012 RENEWAL DATE COUNTY COMP CARD COUNTY EXP DATE EXPIRE DATE 8/31/2012 0TH OL NBR COUNTY OL EXEMPT N CNCL DATE COUNTY OL NBR COUNTY OL EXP DATE 0TH OL EXP DATE 043585 9/30/2012 REINSTATE DATE DBA PHONE FAX (239)774-3990 (239) 774-0109 MAILING ADDRESS PHYSICAL ADDRESS PO BOX 534 13255 TAMIAMI TRL. E. #3 MARCO ISLAND FL 34146-0534 NAPLES FL 34114- LIABILITY INSURANCE COMPANY EXP DATE JACKSON AGENCY INC 7/12/2013 PHONE EFFECTIVE DATE (305) 824-3464 7/12/2012 POLICY NUMBER CNCL DATE CGL-0000014125-01 INSURANCE LIMITS 2000000 WORKERS COMPENSATION INSURANCE WC EXEMPT N COMPANY EXP DATE BOUCHARD INS. FOR WBS 12/31/2012 PHONE EFFECTIVE DATE (866)293-3600 12/31/2011 Collier County Board of County Commissioners Printed on 9/10/201 2j 31:56PM CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT Page 1 E , Details Page 1 of 1 Previous Back to list Next Property Record Aerial I Sketches f Trim Notices Current Ownership Parcel No.I 20185001289 Property Address 4001 GULF SHORE BLVD N Owner Name I CHEHAB,FARID Addresses I DAISY LOPEZ-CHEHAB 7103 MIRA FLORES AVE City CORAL GABLES State FL Zip 33143-6517 Legal SURFSEDGE A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 707 Section Township Range Acres*Acreage Map No. Strap No. 21 49 25 0 4A21 143200 7074A21 ✓'t Millage Rates Sub No. 143200 SURFSEDGE A CONDOMINIUM '1 Millage Area School Other Total 'It Use Code 04 33 5.527 5.5016 11.0286 *See Instructions for Calculations 2012 Preliminary Tax Roll Latest Sales History (Subject to Change) If all Values shown below equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll Land Value $0.00 Date Book-Page Amount (+)Improved Value $493,010.00 03/2007 4190-2420 $830,000.00 (_)Market Value $493,010.00 (-)SOH Exempt Value&Other Exemptions $0.00 06 I 2003 3313-72 $625,000.00 (=)Assessed Value $493,010.00 06/1999 2564-1234 $0.00 (-)Homestead and other Exempt Value $0.00 03/1991 1599-1589 $0.00 (=)Taxable Value $493,010.00 02/1991 1590-459 $240,000.00 (_)School Taxable Value(Used for School Taxes) $493,010.00 SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment 01/1987 1245-1846 $177,000.00 increases. Previous Back to list Next The Information is Updated Weekly. ai http://www.collierappraiser.com/RecordDetail.asp?Map=&FolioID=20185001289 8/8/2012 • Global Maintenance&Restoration,Inc. P.O. Box 534 Marco Island, FL 34146 !Date invoice# 12/22/2008 04292130 Farid Chehab 7103 Mira Flores Ave Coral Gables,FL 33143 Due Date Project 12/22/2008 _ 07 Option Description Amount To supply and install exterior slider on your balcony. 4,375.00 This was done at the Surfsedge Unit#707 l 't'({fl � It11 Balance Due $4,375.00 Please remit payment to: Global Maintenance&Restoration, Inc. P.O Box 534, Marco Island, FL 34146 Cut along dotted line Please remit payment to: Global Maintenance&Restoration,Inc.and mail to P.O Box 534,Marco Island,FL 34146.Thank you for your prompt payment, Thank you for your business!!! Project: 07 Option Prompt: payment is greatly appreciated. Please call 239°774-3990 with any billing concerns. Invoice#: 04292130 Net 15 Days: Accounts not paid within 15 clays are subject to the Due Date: 12/22/2008 maximum finance charge allowed by state law. Balance Due: $4,375.00 Global Maintenance&Restoration,Inc. P.O. Box 534 Marco Island, FL 34146 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • AINMPIORINNIUP0111111/1010111•10111001•11111WINNMI■mellIOMNINPIRall~PEOMMINOMMINIIIMMINOW •:. • OPOIP/Male.08.140/~a4fr/DONMIM. Nmessinlwimmempla 1274 • TM=GOMA, • ii.Aultirlta • Mtlow_Ckalkdit-lainataidthr—'e. $ 4,52f eg tioulLA titt4pt•-•:-_-71-.. 0 w- VIAMOIVIA. . MY ofi.1.7rV? eamPLA4 — • • • • REF# PAID 01/30- 4.375.00 . . .. • • • .. • . •- _ .. ..... . . • . . • RECEIVED ��t - • MULTI- FAMILY ADDITION/ALTERATIO = 18 2009 bower-4. fig. :SIG 'EPT PERMIT APPLICATION ql, 34 FLORIDA BUILDING CODE 2007 4-1 cP" PERMIT# 559--- Job 1 iforniatrc,n Sc.c , hr:cjulations a,rc. Info-rnat;c:t, oil ppalge 2'" for mole details): Tax/Folio#: // :s!0 . . Jr egal Description:u rlkf- ' a 0,0040 un i f 70 7 Job Address: ,i,i CCU • •' lip WO • 0 `I' L 'F1-- (U Property Owner: /..,.:,,, 1, �A ' I ,0 Mailing Address: 0 , r: g• '': Aft' I Contractor:(' 0 i� a L L� :• L1 Wr�ir Cont. Phone# -7-7L1 3C o `�-S Est. cost:$ I IV O,Total Sq. Ft. of Working Area: 5 Co ' Permit expiration date: /Q /1101-11)S SQ.FOOTAGE MUST REFLECT ENTIRE ROOM AREAS IN WHICH EACH TYPE OF WORK WILL BE PERFORMED. Work Area for each Trade: Addition Alteration Building;number of stories(Above G 'DE): Building square ft. ROW Permit yes _n• RO , .q. ft. Electrical square ft. Roof type # • ' ' arcs Plumbing square ft. Identify type of =rmit prat;' ion t• •: sed: Mechanical sq. ft. I Fire Sprinkler sq ft. Existing Fire •pn ler Syst= ? yes no Fire Alarm square ft. Existing Fire .larm System yes no Construction Type Per Table 601 FBC(circle one): IA IB IIA IIB II IIIB IV VA VB PLAN COVER S MUST INC UDE CONSTRUCTION TYPE. Descrip i•n of wo : an • .t 0..' . • / .•/ h A / '4 ' 6,a 0 I . . is IA.0 _ _ Ja*� ,t f i7 r1I ChecK all items inc_,t: it.1 .3Ii: pe..f.;rir ,J,;�.k.gg,. , la.: .J,t•o ,it it,s at e Iegeure(I .v:rlr al applications) Two completely sembled sets of plans consisting of the following: � ) /2 V Detailed letter of scope of work ," "Fire Alarm/Fire Sprinkler Architectural Floor Plans Electrical w/Load Calculations Construction Site Maintenance Plan lumbing Structural Plans Mechanical Life Safety Plan Water Meter Sizing Chart Two copies of the following must also be included for any additions: Survey—Elevation Certificate Truss Layouts&Design Loads Site Plan w/Setbacks Storm Water Drainage Plan Energy Calculations DRB, PAB, &Other Approvals Le. J,f;;U,,rg Data ,aticlitcono only): Lot width: ft Lot depth: ft Lot area: SF Actual setbacks(feet): Front: Rear: Right Side: Left Side: New bldg.footprint: SF New gross square ft: SF Bldg height: ft Max.buildable area allowed: Bldg. depth: ft Bldg width: ft SCANNED Number of new units: Total Number of units: . l 2 8 • 1 i___ ‘. 3� 311/09 Ell- ____ • 7-W AIL tis rtd4;lrr 4'sr .iart=.1ta/► aizef«f itetos ar :ire' uitg twith:;ALL,a:°'lica#4on 1. Required plan size is 24"x 36"maximum, on standard sized paper, and to scale(minimum 316"=1). 2. A total floor plan must be submitted for any Interior remodeling with work areas clouded. 3. All plans must include a "Square Footage Legend"on the title page. This information must be broken down by"AC"and"Non AC"square footage. 4. Exterior windows and doors shall comply with FBC 2007 Existing Building Sections 606.4-606.5, and FBC 2007 Section 1609.1.2 for 140 MPH wind loads and impact protection, and Section 704.9 for vertical fire separation. Opening pressures and Miami-Dade NOA or FL State Product Approvals are :.uired. Electrical and Fire 5. All plans must identify exit signs, emergency lighting, tire extinguishers, fire rated walls, floors, ceilings and means of egress. Alterations exceeding 50%of the building's value must update fire protection 6. If the unit is equipped with an Automatic Fire Sprinkler System provide drawings that show the location of new and existing sprinkler heads 7. Fire sprinkler shop drawings require the signature and raised seal of a FL registered engineer for systems of 50 heads or more.A Fire Contractor may sign the plans if the system has up to 49 heads. 8. Electrical load calculations must be submitted with plans when electrical work exceeds 30 amps. 9. If the electrical service is equal to or greater than 600 amps, a Florida Registered Engineer must sign the electrical plans with a raised seal. [FL Statutes 471.003(2)(h)1 &2.] 10.A temporary power inspection will allow the power to be turned on,with the understanding that the areas under construction will not be occupied without a Certificate of Occupancy or Certificate of Completion. Additions 11. Max building Area must be calculated for any additions that increase the building footprint. 12.NO construction activity is allowed after slab is poured until a Spot Survey has been submitted to and APPROVED by the City of Naples Building&Zoning Division. 13.All accessory structures must be permitted separately. Including but not limited to fences,walls, pools, screen enclosures and generators. 14. If this site is located in a Special Flood Hazard Area(AE&VE Zones), additional information pertaining to Substantial Improvement/Substantial Damage may be required. 15. If an addition is being done to an existing building, a final elevation certificate must be submitted. prior to CO. 16. 1f a major remodel is being done to an existing building, a final elevation certificate may be required prior to CO. 17. Projects west of the Coastal Construction Control Line require a permit from the FL Department of Environmental Protection. Coastal Construction Variance from the Natural Resource Director may also be required general 18.Engineering Division approval of civil drawings is required prior submittal to the Building Department. Driveway width, setbacks and parking must be shown on the site plans.Verify if a driveway permit is to be acquired from the City of Naples, Collier County, or the State of Florida. 19.Other supporting documents, such as variances,conditional use permits,SAC and/or ORB approvals and GDSPs must accompany your plans. anz 20. Fee for this permit is$0.50 per square foot of the gross square footage of the work area for the building permit. Electrical, plumbing,and mechanical permits are each $0.10 per square foot of the gross square footage of their respective work areas. The minimum fee shall be$150.00. 21.A plan review fee,equal to 15%of permit fee,will be due at time of application. If plan review fee is less than$30.00, it will be collected at time permit is issued, or upon withdrawal. The plan review fee is not refundable, nor is it credited to any other fee. 22.A fee of$100.00 will be charged for required fire inspections,and$70.00 for low voltage inspections. 23. it is the contractor's responsibility to contact the Building Division when all final inspections are complete and obtain a Certificate of Occupancy or a Certificate of Completion. SCANNED NW 8 10 2 3 2 iioiCaiittrioll I c rfi , i:t : Contractors • �2/Ma • IAA I State Cert/CC Comp Card#: CA C /5 ) q Z 7 Address: r-0' V j Phone#: 17 L/ ,3qqo City f.5 Ctn/L State: Ft Zip: '/l 5 Job Representative: t C6Ctre,(,� Fax#: ? 7 'j p( f}q Architect/Engineer: Phone#: Address: City: State: Zip: q ub-C• . • toturin Electrical: er Yir �C gl CC T G State Cert/CC Comp Card#: F C 13Oic 6 . Address: �0 J (m'-c, /l ti-e Mechanical: State Cert/CC Comp Card#: Address: Plumbing: State Cert/CC Comp Card#: Address: Roofing: State Cert/CC Comp Card#: Address: Fire Alarm: State Cert/CC Comp Card#: Address: Fire Sprinkler State Cert/CC Comp Card#: Address: iStegrieous InftiUtiatititir Mortgage Lender: Phone#: Address: City: State: Zip: Bonding Co: Phone#: Address: City: State: Zip: 3 SCANNED WI 2 8 7009 3/1/09 f • i RECORDED NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE POSTED IF THE PROJECT VALUATION EXCEEDS $2,500.00 WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. Cc;p...,. ._ rill ,.adlt I certify that all the foregoing information is accurate and that all work must be done in compliance with all applicable laws regulating construction and zoning. I understand THERE WILL BE A FINAL INSPECTION of the work permitted herein. Compliance will be strictly enforced. No work whatsoever will commence until the building permit has been Issued. • The permit fee will be quadrupled if work is started without an approved permit. • The permittee further understands that only licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure shall not be used or occupied until a Certificate of Occupancy or a Certificate of Completion is issued. • See Section 16-112:105 Permits, of the Code of Ordinances for information regarding the time limitations and conditions of a permit. • Additional information can be found on our website: w •w.naolesoov.com ,C. uu01) ( i r4 it 106 A e / `. .. i►_ Print Name of Qualifier Signature of ualifier State of Florid County of The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this / o ,/ O day of /`�1 ,2009 by_ 1./fl dig (2 I(2t ,who personally known me or has produced as identification. " / II, (Seal) Signature,Notary Public—State of Florid, 0`�T°°� Arowen S. Gomez Commission#DD506703 Printed,Typed,or Stamped Name of Notary w4� Expires January 12,2010 ( act"be"M1n Maws*ti.114401.70f9 SCANNED *28 7009 4 3!1109 i • . � J RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL LIc#CGC1508927 6-(/01.0"e D v3 C To- lAs-fa,u dAr poc&ot ra-mt /a,n Ge;c cif a /-che-to m adee fooked (1.I .nishece s A s � d one e l•ec --in L ca av "k/e P.O.BOX 534•MARCO ISLAND,FL 34146•TEL:239.774.3990•FAX:239.774.O3eANNED Gllc I I'01 ty flke44 I 04 ---317-----3 u FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH LIEN LAWS Ei CAN RESULT IN THE PROPERTY OWNER PAYING TWICE FOR BUILDING IMPROVEMENTS. C.:. i,) OVI te-+ k,25 /7e_i_L, . \) e ..).'. , - K TWEE WM MJST M.KEPT g JOB SIE ..,(\e `o [ \ui,p - ISSUANCE OF THIS PERMIT BY BLDG DEPT 9�O DOES NOT CONSTITUTE FINALACCE'TANCE OF PLANS OR SPECIFICATIONS.WORK MAY BE HALTED AT ANY lox FOR NONCOMPUN'E' C - VI! , .ii r1 C"1 .. \ , - / 04 itt (9` ... t-_,. i _...... ....... x ` 'Y ...„ . tft OAP I & 5-6 r13 CITY OF NAPLES ri i v. c\4j eAli ALL ELECTRICAL WORK SHALL BUILDING AND ZO ING COMPLY H T E 200.5 C. ,•.4 - FA ' ' l A 'A All .1i C} .ENSURE FULL COMPLIANCE E WITH FLORIDA f LORtDA � 1 ARTICLE J. 2..�-i •4.-� 2007 EXISTING BUILDING CODE Date -/7+ - - o APPR•V Dea s ANNED sEC ' t �� MI 2 a JON En MULTI FAMILY ADD/ALT PLAN REVIEW CHECKLIST PERMIT# Oq - 1552 TRACKING EXAMINER DATE AP/REJ FEMA CAL s •.+�. FIRE ALARM FIRE SPRINKLER /1/41__ ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL PLUMBING BUILDING V/L- 5/Z , SCANNED Ills►t a 7199 SCANNED *Z81014 G��e } ECEIVED RECEIVED W AUG 27 2009 18 2009 0 , G DEPT 'NE•05. * PERMIT # Oi - /5s oP . REGIJJ ' ILNdi .3.‘ t ; rt;,r,rc,ns): 1. Only one revision at a time per permit may be submitted. 2. Submit two (2) copies of revision form with two (2)sets of revised drawings. 3. Revisions to drawings originally signed and seated by a design professional must be signed and sealed by the original plan-signing design professional. 4. Approved, stamped revision must be on job site before:scheduling inspections for work included in revision. 5. Detailed description defining the entire scope of revision(s) must be provided, and revised Miorfc ar+rss clouded(or otherwise cl rhr shown) ore r wised Diana. 6. Supporting documents (Manufacturer info. Product approvals, NOAs, etc) must be included. Job Address: L7) / 6U cS hcR/ 1)/I/L 2 '7° 1 Contractor: - ) s „ I. , U .nuis ' /ti Changes clouded on plans (checic1es _No (See # 5 above) Additional work area square footage: /U Additional job cost incurred by revision: Additional Subcontractors: A.) z) Detailed description of revised work (Include additional page(s) if needed: ie`erna)(4 a s uta- j j o 10-1,e43 L -c SCANNED 43& Cc p L �SEP i t X09 A NEW FEMA FORM IS REQUIRED WHEN REVISING ADDITION/ ALTERATION PLANS FOR PROJECTS BELOW BASE FLOOD ELEVATION. REVISION FEE IS $35.00 FOR EACH TRADE INVOLVED IN REVISION. tq 3/1/09 0 p1Y�r - ` V cit SCANNED SEP 14 2009 'y R VED , tU6 2 7 2009 BLDG DEPT €.to I i AUG-18-2009 11:37 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.2'12 >Y1) 611-- 1559N - . . i . .... : SI711140 : .9..24,1 ?InMkal1111rr.. r+APTUh•Fra,nPlp store Cowes/0rot. We/Press Preionet Coolant About PYRAN. Platinum F AV* -18 teS Premium Safely SOwfior) CemmIC Waxing J CI) ..N. 4 t a quote s', ac nr42/.1 Grod PO Fcheet IJ a i s >' .� now.. ...sr•m 1.rmrs eo: '4` r-x a, I ••• .. • •:.:. ..t •• ritOUSGT 11114 V..!;%.M'. ,, s:;:• :‘,.;.;23� rEATURGS •Sae a Mea d Ceh0..__._Go > �__.. UMW Cerarolu sre cot Senors to radiant heat.They do not moot ter.4 II These*envIroussetally-trbeally etre rated dfau mange!IN et standards ism Bile erIA 241.1( teadne and hasea ktie heave ruNaln yat•rlurtadktlon realm a Darr( a Offal unbeatable aplkal clarity free of tints and seeleevbre to radiant heat,plats use SARI • distortion wkimme tills willed asae daarlaaa polishing. rutSr Supertito It-Xt.r'products. A aurasdt.V•tewal aw111wMpepRikd aecatlty film Mete CP$C Heat appltolia c aver 45 minutes I macr4112111 augury 1 and 11 avant sum raMairaalanta. ere raquked to Nowet spinet •ripe rood team s ea'almNtee rillh hese straw sad positive Indio*heat trrrstnr. presser*. a Readily awaitu threu.h eta fact•er direct Qalc*+et ist moan' 1 • and eta natteawillIt 161401>ltev estimate. it Etowah d,absepra and Mier emstnm maks-ups wettable. ww...+...—+.._r rin.rq.thg ApptteaHee ran Mt Aram Wit Sr Not n Sleys 20-90 min' eidoetesnob ewor 9.171 oq.in. 7e 41n. re t4 MI SID• Tlansorer• ao•oo min, Doors"- :OM"I.11% eo at.in. 7e salt or (N.ri-Tano.Nu) 150.1 DeYn. Doom'• trmtcq.in 1204.Im. 3.3ezh. Sib' (Tamp.We.) I 100 resin. Miters 100 sq.Am 12.q.in. b tq.ii. Vr . L.-:.i slim( ,ca1rM.p.Ariii•iinutiii t-4, - &woe maMMM iraaM4.il.IA%(WIWI. .N ts.riy laud oar kw1,1lMAlMMr/. • $PRQIF1CAT(O1 x►to f> Ttliotnase: s/le'(Shim) Watoht: 2.S Ibs/tq.ft. t EP.141009 Aapaarancea free of tints owl nou0eible dWtvrtion Maximal Sheet Sort 43"x 77' . I .alb http//aafti.com/prod PYRANF,htm) • ,+,.., t'fi Had ZAUG-18-8(2/29 11:15 Froms 415 t32z 6222 rD:Et1G!_E __ .r i • . • . 5 RLJG-1B-2009'11:37 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.3'12 , • . 1 sonnet slam y Ratinoin CP5C teCJ'Ri201 Catalpa/1 t and II 1 J r — . earn.Minn=F by SAFI'l FIRST is fisted mg tateeha cy fntarteWwarnecK- NlrS4Y OK.,A 11515la1y rrlcoaThzod testing INOratory. Fd►more Rum 100 yeas IAttrtelt hid!UUr/et as the testing,.e•tdt,Won.and ceftlIkellon lender •for tiuNdklo products end materials.The Imo)mark is one of ins most i ra&Otta:ted product ditty end liCtollnance Audio Vol IAAJIrrp proot•:ls!litho world. .■s. --_ TESTING AND CDfIMICATION iGo to.►1 • PYRAN10 Manion F by SAFT1 FIRST is tested and cta'tllied to rout 111. totowinp standards by UL and fnrertekIWortmedc-riersoy ow.: • i.n*I.rwrterl 1.4b6/dr<,Nes,lot,:UL St.UI 10A.In i fit • • National fire Pmtectlnn Astrcsailnn: Wf7A AD,NF►A 259,NHA).67. • merlon twerp tar Twill)and r to l*b: arm 51074, A5TI■162110.1. • Uniform tfu ldklp Code: Ut1C 7.2,(AC 7.4. Consulter Product Safety Commission: CPSC 16 CPR 1201 Car,f and It L • SYenrb.d t}rrrnrA of C•nxln: tACCAN4.$104,ULC CJiN4-5106. DELIVERY .,•.., Readily dvallfUte tltrtWOh our factory diMCt fired•stn praeram Cro our ' W4111'400 dlstribtltQr ntlwvrk• SCANNED SEP 14 2009 i rI•rkbner • T 6/11/ ; http;fieaRi.comlp od_PYRANF.himl r'' Al1C-18-$009 11:16 From 415 822 5222 TO:EAfaT.F_ • -. AUG-18-009 11:37 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.4'12 p Wep:Cme to the SAFTIFJRS7.'M Outdo Spaeth: ml Syclem prepared as an aid to apsoMere In preparing Wawa corWiUOtlon Inctartanta. For sped1eelbn seaklenoo%Nh epsale prodi►ct epplkettena,pleat.contact SAFTIFiror . SPECIFICATION SECTION 01 IMO:FIRE RATIO QLMS 8 FRA$NG PYRANED Platinum F by SAFTI FIRST 20-1M min.Fire Rrt sd GNOMIC Glass PART 1 GENERAL 1.01 SUMMARY A, SeCticn Includes:Fire rated glazing 1. PYRAMID Platinum F by SAFTI FIRSTclear era rated,safety rated ceramic glass for 20- 180 minute Interior and exterior applcalbns. 2; Appli ons of fire rated glahg Inoksda: a, Fire retort glazing as vision Mee In door aseernbllea, b. Fire rated glazing as*loIites,windows ortrwuome in flee rated frames. B. Related Sections; 1, Section 01 3323: Shop Drnwmga,Product Data and Samples, 2. Section 06 4000: Architectural Woodwork. 3. Section 08 1110; Steel Doors and Frames. 4. Sara. on 081400: Wood Doors and Frames. • 5. Section 08 5130: Stool Windows. 6. Section 00 7000; Finish Hardware, 1.02 REFERENCES A. American Society for Testing said Materials(ASTM): 1. ASTM E2074-00 Methods of Fire Tests of Door Assemblies,inducing Positive Presstxe Testing of Side-hinged and Pivoted Swinging Door Assembles. 2. ASTM F2010-01 Standard Test for Positive Pressure of Fire Teets of Window Assemblies. B. National Fire Protection Association(NFPA): 1. NFPA 80:Fire Doors and Windows. • 2. NFPA 252: Fire Teals of Door Assemblies. 3. NFPA 257:Fire Tests of Window Assemblies. • C. Undotwrttcrs Laboratorloe, Inc.(UL): 1. UL S:Standard for 8efety of Fire Teets of Window Assembles. 2. UL 10B: Standard of Safety of Fire Tests of Door Assembly. 3. UL 10C:Standard for Safety of Positive Pressure Tests of Door AseembH9s. D. Standard Council of Canada(ULC): 1. ULC standard CAN44104: Fie Tests of Door Assembles, SC• ;NED 2. ULC Standard CAN4-S108: Piro Tests of Window Assombliea. E. Uniform Buidinj Coosa(UDC): SEP $ 1009 1, UBC-7-2: Methods for Fire Teats of Door Aseemblies& VP, . III HUG-16-2609 11:16 From: 415 622 5222 ID:EAGLE eon ° UG-18-2009 11:3B From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.5'12 • 2, UBC-7.4: Methods for Fire Tests of window Aeeerrtbiles, F. Consumer Products Safety Commission(CPSC): 1. CPSC 16 CFR 1201: Safety Standard for Architectural Glazing Materials. G. Glass Association of North America(GANA) 1. GANA—dazing Manual. 2. FOMA—Seafront Manual, H. (Insert building code used by Aylhority Houma Jurbdicdonj •, 1.03 SYSTCM DESCRiPITON A. Performance Requirements: Provide a firs rating 9lezIng manufactured,fabricated end installed to maintain pa formence criteria stated by mandfacturrer without ileac*damage or ra kve. 1. Fire Rating:isYRANG Platinum F by 6AFTI FIRST is frc rated from 20-180 minutes and is impactsal'ety rated to meet CPSC 16 CPR 1201 Category I and IL 2, PYRE Platinum F by 9AFTr mark lasted in accordance with NFPA 80,NFPA 252, NFPA 257,Ul 9, UL 108,It 10C,UBC 7.2,MC 7a,ASTIN E2074-00,ASTM E2010- 01,ASV!20T4-00,ASTM E2010-u1,CAN4.8104 and CANd-S106. 3. Testing LaboraIory Are teat shall be conducted by rl nationally recognized Independent testing laboratory. 8. listings and Labels: 1, Fire rated glazing shall be under cwittnt follow-up setvioe bye nationally recogrbed indopendant testing laboratory and maintain a current listing or certification. Assemblies shell be labeled In accordance with lintka of listings, 1.04 SUBMITTALS • A. Submit listed submittals In accordance with Condition of the Controot and DMeion 1 Submittal Procedure Section. 1. Shop Drawings:Submit shop drawings showing layout,protifee and product components. 2. Samples:Submit 12x12 glass Samples. 1 Technical Information:Submit latest edition of manufacturer's product data, 1.06 DELIVERY,STORAGE AND HANDLING A, General: Comply with Division 1 Product Requirements Sections. 8. OnierinCr Comply with manufacturer's ordering Instructions and lead-time requirements to avoid construction delays. • C. Defvory: Deliver materials to specified destinations In menufucturer'e or distributor's • packaging undamaged, complete with Installation Instructions. SCA NED SEP 4 2009 2 .°10 RUG-18-2009 it Frnmt 41.S 1322 5222 ID'EAGLE E,*t1 • 'AUG-18-2009 11:38 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.6'12 D. Storage and Protection:Store off ground,under cover,protected from weather and construction activities and at temperature conditions,rec ominended by manufacturer. 1.08 PROJECT CONDITIONS A. Field Measurements:Verify actual measurements for openings by field megetuementa before fabrication. Show recorded measurements on shop drawings. Coordinate field meatexernwnts and fabrication schedule with construction propreaa to*veld rionstructico delays. 1.07 WARRANTY • A, Project Warranty:Refer to Conditions of the Contract for project warranty provisions, S. Manufacturer's Warranty;Submit,forOwner'e acceptant*,manufacturer's standard warranty document. MMnulacturees warranty is not intended to limit other rights that the Owner may have under iho Contract Doeurnenta. 1. Warranty Period: 10 years commencing on Data of Substantial Completion. PART 2 PRODUCTS • 2.01 FIRE RATED GLAZING A. Manufacturer: PYRANO Platinum F by SAFTI FIRST as manufactured by SCHOTT Technical Gleam Solutions GmbH,Jona/Germany and distributed by RAFT!FIRST Fire Rated Glazing Solutions,a division of O'Keefe's Inc. 1. Confect: 325 Newhall Street.Sari Francisco,CA 94124-2693; Telephone 888/653- 3333;Fax 4181824-6900;emelt Info eaffi,00mln;Web alto www.sottLcom B. Description; PYRANO Platinum F by SAFTI FIRST fire rated and safety raids,glass ceramic. 1. Thicicrwss:3/16'(5 mm). • 2. Weight:2.5 lbs./sq.f t. 3. Fire Rating:20.160 minutes with hose stream. 4. Impact Safely Rating:CPSC 16 CFR 1201 Celoyoiy I and II. 6. Maximum Sheet Size; Approodmataly 43'x 77'. 6. Appearance:Free from tints and noticeable dtetodlon, 7. Environmental Impact: Free from toms or hazardous heavy metala. C. Manulantrmmr'a Fire Rntpd Glazing Malarial: 1. Each place ally-rated glazing material chap be loboled with a permanent logo including name of product,manufacturer,teeing laboratory Rnr!fire rating. D. Substitutions: No substitutions allowed. 202 MATERIALS SCANNED A. Glazing Acceesortes:Manufacturer recommended fire rated glazing accessory as follows: SEP;.1410119 3 ..doete. • ,r rut %I AUG-la-2009 11:17 From: 415 822 5222 ID'EAGLE 6705 L11- i J ' 'AUG-18-2009 11:38 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.7'12 1. Glazing tape: Closed aa*polyvinyl chloride(PVC)foam,Pemko Manu1actUrlr1s Company,Ref.FO3000890 or Units(Corporation Fiberfrax Awminro-Si ivato fiber gMO t*pe, 2. Setting blocks: Calm silicate or hardwood. 3. Cleaners,primers,sealers; Type recommended by manufacturer of gime And gaskets. 2.03 RELATED PRODUCTS k4S►4fhlHkk•4441MrM1 he**I$•ai4*kkk41,1ftF* s•MI*M*k**a*a*•w eMtAlts►HIln0**IN4N***** ALkilM•*******me Note: Basis of design for fire rated framing system Is 3AFTitireT'4 Framing as manufactured by SAPTI FIRST 1kkMkMiN�1aY114►IaN/M!{I•MNfI H tMtINNl►YYIatYiYM/Ia W/tl�lkMliY1/till/N,Y•KI NIaNM1•M��„ A. Glazing shah be Inetalod In an equally rated framing system. 2.04 SOURCE QUALITY A. Obtain Me rated glazing products from a single manufacturer. • B. Fabrication Dimensions:Fabricate to approved dimensions. The general contractor shall guarantee dimensions where practicable within requked tolerances. PART 3 EXECUTION 3.01 MANUFACTURER'S INSTRUCTIONS A.Compliance:Comply with manufacturer's product data Inckuding product technical bulletins and insulation Instructions. 3.02 EXAMINATION A.Site Verircalion of Conditions:Verify substrate conditions,have been previously inhaled under other sections,and are acceptable for product inetilbtion in scaordence With manufacturers instructions. 3.03 INSTALLATiON(GLAZING) A.Comply with referenced GANA manuals and instructions of manufacturers of glass,glazing eeatenta and glazing compounds, 8. Protect glass from edge damage during handling and Installation. Inspect glace during installation and set aside pieces with edge damage that could drool performance. C. Set units of glass in each sedan with uniformity of pattern,draw.bow and similar charactadatlea. D. Cut glazing tape to length end set again:A permanent slope,flush with eight lutes to fit openings exactly,with stretch allowance during installation. SCA NED E. Arrange two setting blocks located at quarter points of glass with edge block no more than ern A 1009 8 inches from corners. 4 pj AIJt3-1B-2089 11:17 From 415 822 5222 ID:EAGLE €1412 _ i •RUG-113-2009 11:39 From:ERGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.8'12 F. Glaze vertically Into labeled fire rated frames or fire rated walls with the same tiro rating is the glass and push agelnet tape for fun contact at perimeter of paste or unit. G. Place glazing tope on free perirnsbor of&Ana In same manner described above, 14. Install removable stop and secure without deplecutg the taps:. I. !natal so that epproprioto markings remain permanently visible. J. Field cutting or tsmpedng Is strictly prohit k'.d. 3.04 CLEANING AND PROTECTION A. Protect glass from contact with=laminating substances resulting from construction operations. Remove suoh substances by method approved by manufacturer. 8. Wash glass on both faces not more than four days pilot to data schedule for inspections intended to establish data of 5ubslantiel Completion. Wash glass by method • rewrnmended by glass manufacturer, • C. Remove temporary coverings and protection of adjacent work areas. D. Remove construction debris from project site and legally dleyoso of debris. 3.05.°LAZING SCHEDULE Firo Rating Appia on Max.CV Max.CV Mex.CV 'stops Area Width Httiht 20.90 min.' Steatites mss/ 3,422 sq. 7C sq.In. 76 sq.in. 518" - Transmute in. 20-60 min. Doors'Non- 2,736 eq. 36 eq.in, 76 sq.In. 518" Temp. In. 00-120 min. Doors (Temp, 100 aq.In. 12 sq.In. ~33 eq.in. b/8" Rise) 160 min. Doors'(Temp. ' 100 sq.in, 12 sq.In. 33 sq.In, 112" Wee • 1. In . i• s not e mall t0 realer*hat en.deaf Rd meetA r - e. 2. Equally rated steel framing system naked. 3. Equally rated door and frame rrqulrod. END OF SECTION . In the Wore%or con*nuous improvement Of is product line,8N'rIFINSra reserves L :tight to modify Its products'oaraposltton,colors,textures, ness,end Ow phys4oal and pwirsmena eildb aloe and Chess guide cpecifloolione at any time.SAFT1 makes no roomed or implied warranties regarding*ontant,errors,or ontisslons In the Information proaom tad,Spectlictions mowed or rewritten not in oonfremencs with SCAN ED monutooturen'a elend arr ard processes,products,and procedures may void warranties and related remedies. 5 SEP 14 r iih .■■. AdOWIlik VIa--:.----N, AUG-18-220E 11:16 Fromt 41S 8 5222 ID:EAGLE ED , :i.r.. -1 ' iA ...i_.v ._.... • *RUG-18-2009 11:39 From:ERGLE 2393520995 To:77.10109 P.9,12 Repen prepared tr.:Weedy bah(Prei User)cm Q24/20092:511:22 PM ; ;;•;f;Dln a rtnwmn et III • LISTING INFORMATION OF SAFTI FIRST Ceramic Glazing Panel Up To 180 Minutes NEW SPEC ID: 10095 SAFTI FIRST 325 Newhall Street San Francisco,CA 94124-1432 • 'Ns report to for be exclusive use of Inienet a rxpnt and is provided pwwant to the asiseewnt belw in Mnbrtek end ds C1tenL . Intarteli•responsibility and Debility are limbed le the tuns and condiYpns of the a/eement interteh moss no rnbitty to any pent', Oar than to the Gent kt amdence with the agreement,for any loss,expense or Qernape occasioned by the use of this repon.Only the Client Is autltaizod to wad oopyinp.or dletrlbutbi of IMC report end ih n any b Ile enliraty.Any use of Ina Intone unarm are of Pa rooks fcs ills Ws aaownbemenl of fire t/etel tnitabt,product or wales wt fleet be oppv ved hi ►M by Imo►lok.Thq . obMtvMlons and flint results in IPa report ale relevant airy b the sample haled.This report by itself does not imply Vial Pie material. • p'odud,ereerviee id or has cvcrbeen under an Intaeek certification program. - i SCANNED SEP 14 7009 SAPTl FIRST l 19209 I Rev:Jun I6 2009 2:39PM i Une ntrrolled Copy p e R! �._ = _~h•� AUG-M-24209 11:18 Fr•nm: 415 8222 5222 ID:EAGLE I + { • 'RUG-10-2009 11:39 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.10/12 Report pvepnred for.Wendy Nth(Fite Um)on&24009 248;22 PM 4ti : ':DjiE;(� raetuu i1 Superltte C,CfP,Map*runr.tu&Pyrsn'" Platinum (5mm thick Glazing) • Rating: Appliurlinre: Max Max W: Mix N: ' Stop N: Areal 8idetfites, Fire 2080 Mina Windows 3323 77314 77-3/4 5/8 Treneom in to Stt eel Assemblies must be rated per application. Suparltto G/S,CISP,Superceram P R Pyranm Platinum F(5mni thick Giosingi Rating: .r. Applleetion: Max Max W: Miix M: Stop H: Ana: 8ldeltro, Me 20.80 Mule Windows,& 3323 77-314 77.3/4 5/8 Transom in Steel haloes - Woot!/Wood 20 96 Haute stow or Stow priors(non- 2799 38 77-3/4 5/8 temp rise) Wood/Wood up!else Compote or 100 10 33 5/8 • Minute Steel Doors(non- __.o S temp riee) , AsSembilec must be rated per application. (5)=Safoty Sim (F)•Safety Film Pyran na Platinum L(9mm thick) Ranting: Application: Max Area: Max W: Max H: Stop H: Sidellies.Fire - 20-90 Windows. & 3143 75 75 9/2 Minute Transom in Steel frames Wood/Wood __.. 20-9D composite or SCANNED 30 Minute Steel Doors(non- 7b 5/9 SAP 14 11(19 temp;tee) SA1 TI MR67 1 1920!I Rev:Jun 16 2009 2:99Pi I Uncoeuofled Copy Aege `�.� Porril t R*PP:114i AUG-18-2909 11:18 From: 415 822 5222 ID:EAGLE f ; _ T RUG-113-2009 11:39 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.11'12 Upon prop rod for.Woody Ord(Free Ufa)on 140211092:51:22P11 :;[N:'i.:bli T Puwr+.anr go Wood(Wood Up tot80 Compoaile or. 100 12 ;t9 5t8 Minute Steel hour*(non- temp&temp rise) • Asesr;rtbiee most be rated per eppilootIon. Listed products are intended to be tnatatkd,unie21 otherwise noted,In acoordartce with the folowing: NFPA-80,hue Doors&WPndows Manufec*rrees Instructions, Listed rnex mum sizes of glazing are based on suet:tested and may raleved those allowed by boss codes. Dependent on the ere)use inviaertwn,local codes may require that Odder&criteria be met to address conelderettom such as radiant_ et hazards end impact lust*.Under such droumelances.the prbr approval of the ALpiodly Having Jurisdiction must be ebtettled unless conformance to retevent dddfionel requirements Is uriicsled within the indtvitktel listing. i Clearance between the edges if the gluing and the inside edge of the frame shell not olceoed lie"unless otherwise noted in the Individual listing or the ment%act rer's installation instructions. Ail glaring Is Identified by an etched mark or label bearing the W141 Certification Mark or ETL Meru. Attribute ,Stair Architecture Code 08 80 00 Glazing Fire Resistance 45 Min Neutral Preesure Fire Resistance 90 Min Neutral Pressure Fire Resistance 3 Hour Neutral Pressure Fire Resistance 60 Min Neutral Pressure • Fire Resistance 45 Min Positive Pressure Fire Resistance 90 Min Positive Pressure Fire Resistance 60 Min Positive Pressure Fire Resistance 3 Hour Positive Pressure Fire Resistance 20 Min Neutral Pressure Fire Resistance 20 Min Positive Pressure Listed or inspected LISTED Report Number 3056952,3144118,31431 3aMID-002rev2,3180436M10- 002 Criteria CAN4 8106(1985) SCANNED SEP 14 M9 SAM 111311192091 Rev;Jun 16 2009 24RPM I Uncontrolled Copy Peg AUG-19-2009 11:19 From 415 022 5222 ID:;AGLE E,30 A '• • PUG=18-2009 11:40 From:EAGLE 2393520995 To:7740109 P.12•12 Report prepared for Wendy Oft(Pres User)m 634/1009 2:SE:21 PM Spoi:binom $4Wttai e r ell • Criteria CAN/ULC 8104 1980(R19B5) Criteria UL 10C(R2001) Criteria UL 10(b)(2008) Criteria NFPA 252(2008) Criteria UL 9(2005) Criteria NFPA 267(2007) intertek Services Certification Listing Section GLAZING/GLASS • I . • • • SCANNED' SEP 14 7009. SAF71 F71kST 1 192091 Rev Jun Id 2009 2:19TM i Uncontrolled copy Page 4 AUG-18-2009 iit19 From: 415 8222 5222 102 EAGLE El\ �4r • t),Api..e4 6,411M-\(0 BUILDING DEPARTMENT ..73* 295 FikiERS11.::€diROLg NAPLES,FL 34102 NONE 239-213-5042 FAx:239-213-5025 nIE. Permit Number: 09-1552 revision Review Date: August 25, 2009 Contractor: Global Maintenance Project Address: 4001 Gulf Shore Blvd N#707 A review of the plans submitted for the above permit has revealed the following deficiencies: • Eliminating this sliding door in this non sprinkled building would likely require the oderior door to_13 compliant with 744.9 of the 2007 Florida Building Code. Please verify ciiiniglince(see attached). These plans are being rejected for correction of the deficiencies.as outlined above.. When the above corrections have been made, indicate the Ceriketiona-Onthe.drawings, cloud all corrections/revisions, andeltaCh a copy of this Letter before resubmitting for • further review. Thank you kr your Cooperation. SCANNED OCT 01 2009 ‘,4,z 6310 - - . . • I FIRE-fESZSTANCE-RATED CONSTRU 3N c;17 ( 55: ( where: supporting elements for the fire-resistance-rated roof 1 A z Actual area of protected openings, or the equivalentsemblyhasafire-t esistanceratingofnotlessthan 1 hour area of protected openings,A,(see Section 704.7). 704.11 Parapets.Parapets shall be provided on exterior walls a = Allowable area of protected openings. of buildings. A„ = Actual area of unprotected openings. Exceptions:A parapet need not be provided on an exterior a„ = Allowable area of unprotected openings. wall where any of the following conditions exist: 704.8.1 Automatic sprinkler system. In buildings 1. The wall is not required to be fire-resistance rated in equipped throughout with an automatic sprinkler system in accordance with Table 602 because of fire separation accordance with Section 903.3.1.1,the maximum allowable distance• area of unprotected openings in occupancies other than 2. The building has an area of not more than 1,000 Groups H-i,H-2 and H-3 shall be the same as the tabulated square feet(93 m2)on any floor. limitations for protected openings. 3. Walls that terminate at roofs of not less than 2-hour 704.6.2 First story. In occupancies other than Group II, fire-resistance-rated eotistniction or where the roof, unlimited unprotected openings are permitted in the first including the deck or slab and supporting construe- story of exterior walls facing a street that have a fire separa- tion,is constructed entirely of noncombustible mate- tion distance of greater thin 15 feet(4572 nun)or facing an dab. unoccupied space.The unoccupied space shall be on the 4. Otte-hour fire-resistance-rated exterior walls that ter- same lot or dedicated for public use,shall not be less than 30 urinate at the underside of the roof sheathing,deck or feet(9144 mm)in width and shall have access from a street stab,provided: 11 by a posted fire lane in accordance with the Florida Fire Prevention Code. 4.1.Where the roof/ceiling framing elements are parallel to the walls,such framing and de- 704.9 Vertical separation of openings.Openings in exterior ments supporting such framing shall not be of walls in adjacent stories shall be separated vertically to protect less than 1-hour fire-resistance-rated con- against fire spread on the exterior of the buildings where the struction for a width of 4 feet(1220 mm)for openings are within 5 feet(1524 mm)of each other horizon- Groups R and U and 10 feet(3048 nun)for ( tally and the opening in the lower story is not a protected open- other occupancies,measured from the interior ing with a fire protection rating of not less than 3/4 hour.Such side of the wall. ... . openings shall be separated vertically at least 3 feet(914 mm) by spandrel girders,exterior walls or other similar assemblies 4.2.Where roof/ceiling framing elements are not that have a fire-resistance rating of at least 1 hour or by flame parallel to the wall, the entire span of such barriers that extend horizontally at least 30 inches(762 mm) framing and elements supporting such tram- beyond the exterior wall. Flame barriers shall also have a ing shall not be of less than 1-hour fire sesis- fence-sated construction. 4.3.Openings in the roof shall not be located within 5 feet(1524 mm)of the 1 hoar fre-re- fire-resistance rating of at least 1 hour.The ti nexpond surface temperature limitations specified in ASTM E 119 shall not apply to the flame barriers or vertical separation unless other- wise required by the provisions of this code. sistance-rated exterior wall for Groups R and Exceptions: U and 10 feet(3048 mm)for other occupan- cies,measured from the interior side of the 1. This section shall not apply to buildings that are three wall. stories or less in height. 4.4.The entire building shall be provided with not 2. This section shall not apply to buildings equipped less than a Class B roof covering. throughout with an automatic sprinkler system in accordance with Section 9033.1.1 or 903.3.1.2. 5, In Groups R-2 and R-3 where the entire building is provided with a Class C roof covering,the exterior 3. Open parking garages. wall shall be permitted to terminate at the underside of 704.20 Vertical exposure.For buildings on the same lot,open- the roof sheathing or deck in Type III,Wind V con- ing protectives having a fire-protection rating of not less than structson,provided: 3/4 hour shall be provided in every opening that is less than 15 5.1.The roof sheathing or deck is constructed of feet(4572 mm)vertically above the roof of an adjoining build- approved noncombustible materials or of ing or adjacent structure that is within a horizontal fire separa- fire-retardant-treated wood fora distance of 4 Lion distance of 15 feet(4572 mm)of the wall in which the feet(1220 mm);or {{ opening is located. . .The roof is protected with 0.625-inch(16 mm) L.. i Exception:Opening protectives are not required where the ` ,. ' Type X gypsum board directly beneath the roof construction has a fire-resistance rating of not less than I. underside of the roof sheathing or deck,sup- 1 hour for a minimum'distance of 10 feet(3048 nun)from '' - — ported by a minimum of nominal 2-inch(51 the adjoining building,and the entire length and span of the mm)ledgers attached to the sides of the roof 2007 FLORIDA BUILDING COOS--Bl13L DtNO 7.5 63'S ___ i I i • • 40 yl, •�� CITY OF NAPLES BUILDING PERMIT _.* Application Number . 09-00001552 Date 9/11/09 Property Address 4001 GULF SHORE BLVD N 707 FOLIO/PARCEL NUMBER: 20185001289 Section-Township-Range: 21-49-25 Tenant nbr, name CHEHAB Application type description 434*MULTI-FAMILY ADDITION/ALTERATION Subdivision Name SURFSEDGE (CONDO) 111 Property Use CONDOMINIUMS REVISION Property Zoning PLANNED DEVELOPMENT DIST Application valuation . . . 4000 Owner Contractor CHEHAB, FARID GLOBAL MAINTENANCE-CGC1508927 7103 MIRA FLORES AVE P.O. BOX 534 MIAMI FL 331436517 MARCO ISLAND FL 34146 (239) 774-3990 --- Structure Information 000 000 INSTALL DRYWALL W/EL ON LANAI Other struct info SEAWARD OF CCCL CCCL (YES)_ ELEVATION CERT REQ (Y/N) NO NOC REQUIRED (Y/N) YES SURVEY REQUIRED (Y/N) NO REVISION Permit BLDG PERMIT COMM/MF/SF ADD/ALT Additional desc . . Phone Access Code . 1245216 • Permit Fee . . . . 150.00 Plan Check Fee . . • 22.50 • Issue Date . . . . 5/27/09 Valuation . . . . 0 Expiration Date . . 11/27/09 • Qty Unit Charge Per Extension . BASE FEE 122.00 56.00 .5000 ADDITION/ALTERATION COMM/MF/SF 28.00 Other Fees FIRE INSPECTION 100.00 PLAN REVISION FEE 35.00 SS INSPECTOR CERT.PROGRAM .28 SS STATE OF FLORIDA BPFEE .28 Fee summary Charged Paid Credited Due • CONTRAC SIGNATURE REVISION APPROVED BY BUILDING OFFICIAL ,�^�„�ED ISSUED BYU�f SEP.14 n �3y a t i l A •�� ; CITY OF NAPLES • R BUILDING PERMIT i** Page 2 Application Number 09-00001552 Date 9/11/09 Permit Fee Total 150.00 150.00 .00 .00 Plan Check Total 22.50 22.50 .00 .00 Other Fee Total 135.56 135.56 .00 .00 Grand Total 308.06 308.06 .00 .00 CONTRACTO SIGNATURE APPROVED BY BUILDING OFFICIAL �� ISSUED BY ic J-7 E I L S Jul 9,2012 10:00:05 AM TOT File Commands Help iSUliCLANT PUBLIC.SECTOR - Save�i.A_. Cancel✓.._.. E Exit.°°.. j ;::Spellch;-4i4 :Tunesanw Application number,type: 09 00001552 434*MULTFFAMILYADDITIONAAL Property address 4001 GULF SHORE BLVD N 707 CITY REMOVED SLIDING GLASS DOOR FROM KITCHEN TO LANAI August 27,-2009 1:18':53 PM ivargas: sent to rib August 27,: 2009 2:56:01 PM skf. approved rlb August 27, 2009 processed out August 31, 2009 2:22:47 PM .mfreed Did�7I tlC &' NCB Acs T lLCF - I JO/ T- TT (A, euri-otcti-e PCB eiler Page 1 of 2 Paul Bollenback From: Katherine Szostak Sent: Friday, July 06, 2012 11:12 AM To: Paul Bollenback Subject: RE: open permit Paul: The permit number is 9-1552. I performed a structural fire wall inspection on 9/23/09, and failed the inspection because they installed a window with less than 3' vertical clearance without a fire rating label. The window was supposed to be Aluflam system, but was not labeled as such. The contractor, Global Maintenance, scheduled two more inspections over the next year(2/26/10 and 5/18/10) but nothing changed so they still failed. As to the rest of the windows in the building, I do not know what permits were issued and when the inspections were. This window was part of the above permit. David Mathews also failed these inspections. At this point I am deferring to Building since this is a FBC code. City of.Naples Fire-Rescue Department ay SZaretti Fire Inspector/Plans Examiner From: Paul Bollenback Sent: Friday,July 06, 2012 7:23 AM To: Katherine Szostak Subject: FW: open permit Can you fill me in on this? I'm not sure what permit this is in reference to. Paul Bollenback Building Official City of Naples 239-213-5037 pbollenback @naplesgov.com From: Julie Williams [mailto:surfsedgemgr @comcast.net] Sent:Thursday,July 05, 2012 4:21 PM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: Chehab 707 Subject: open permit Mr. Paul Bollenback Building Offical City of Naples Building Dept. Mr. Bollenback, 07/09/2012 631 Page 2 of 2 I have spent the last one and a half years trying to help a unit owner get Global Maintenance to follow through and get a permit closed out for the installation of a window in their unit. Global continues to say they cannot figure out how to satisfy the inspector. Unit 707 at 4001 Gulf Shore Blvd. N, Naples, FL 34103. Global has called for inspection on this, but the inspector(Kathy Szostak)would not sign off on this window. All of the windows in the stack are identical and all other permits did close. Global says they have tried to find a window that the inspector is requiring, but according to Global,that window does not exist from any manufacturer for the state of Florida. I spoke with Kathy Szostak and she referred me to you. I have been unable to go any further with Global and need the building departments help. Please Advise, Respectfully, Julie Williams Julie �VilCiams GeneraCJvtanager Surfsedge, lne. 4001 Gulf Shore Blvd. N. Naples, FL 34103 239-261-3146 07/09/2012 Page 1 of 1 Paul Bollenback From: bjvpglobal @aol.com Sent: Wednesday, July 18, 2012 11:22 AM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: mcuriale2 @aol.com; Curiale47 @yahoo.com; gmriinc @embarqmail.com; surfsedgemgr @comcast.net Subject: Re: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 Attachments: 247080.pdf unit_707_glass_data_sheet_surfsedge.pdf Mr.Bollenback Here is the information that I found in regards to glass currently installed at the surfsedge unit 707. The glass is fire rated. It is rated for 45 min. Please let me know if this is sufficient. Please let me know if you have any concerns. Thank you again for your help with this matter. Have a good day! Original Message From: Paul Bollenback<pbollenback @naplesgov.com> To: bjvpglobal @aol.com' <bjvpglobal @aol.com> Cc: mcuriale2 <mcuriale2 @aol.com>; Curiale47 <Curiale47 @yahoo.com>; gmriinc <gmriinc @embargmail.com>; surfsedgemgr<surfsedgemgr @comcast.net>; David Matthews <dmatthews @naplesgov.com>; Robert Banker<rbanker @naplesgov.com> Sent: Wed, Jul 18, 2012 7:02 am Subject: RE: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 I will have an inspector from this office contact the owner or building manager to gain access to the unit to confirm the glass etching and specifically what information the etching contains. We will need whatever paperwork you can get from the manufacturer for our records. At that time a determination as to code compliance can be made. The paperwork needs to be directed to me. Be advised that I will be off the week of July 23-27. Paul Bollenback Building Official City of Naples 239-213-5037 pbollenback @naplesgov.com From: bjvpglobal@aol.com [mailto:bivpglobal@aol.com] Sent: Monday,July 16, 2012 9:58 AM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: mcuriale2 @aol.com; Curiale47@yahoo.com; gmriinc @embargmail.com; surfsedgemgr @comcast.net Subject: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 Mr. Bollenback, Goodmorning Paul. My name is William Rench and I work for Global Maintenance. I am emailing you because I need to get the issues at hand in regards to the fire rated glass at the Surfsedge unit 707 resolved and put behind us. I have found out with a little research that piece of glass installed currently is fire rated. I took the information which is etched on the glass in the bottom right hand corner (Qldcast!e 8 laminated 41 16 CFR 1201-11 DCA LSG BUTACITE) and found out it is fire rated glass. It is called Pyroguard. I am currently waiting on the manufacturer to get me the fire rating on it. It is either 20,45,60 or 90 minute fire rating. As soon as I find this information out I will contact you and the Surfsedge. Please if you have any questions call me or email me at your convenience. Thank you and have a great day. 07/30/2012 €30' Jacksonian From: Paul Bollenback[pbollenback @naplesgov.com] Sent: Thursday, August 02, 2012 10:15 AM To: Jacksonian Cc: David Matthews Subject: RE: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 Ian, at your convenience I need to discus this permit with you. Paul Bollenback Building Official City of Naples 239-213-5037 pbollenback@naplesgov.com From: bjvpglobal @aol.com [mailto:bjvpglobal@aol.com] Sent: Wednesday,July 18, 2012 11:22 AM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: mcuriale2 @aol.com; Curiale47 @yahoo.com; gmriinc @embargmail.com; surfsedgemgr @comcast.net Subject: Re: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 Mr.Bollenback Here is the information that I found in regards to glass currently installed at the surfsedge unit 707. The glass is fire rated. It is rated for 45 min. Please let me know if this is sufficient. Please let me know if you have any concerns. Thank you again for your help with this matter. Have a good day! Original Message From: Paul Bollenback<pbollenback a(�naplesgov.com> To: 'bjvpglobal @aol.com' <bjvpqlobalaol.com> Cc: mcuriale2 <mcuriale2(c�aol.com>; Curiale47 <Curiale47 anyahoo.com>; gmriinc <gmriincembarcimail.com>; surfsedgemgr<surfsedgemgrAcomcast.net>; David Matthews <dmatthewsAnaplesgov.com>; Robert Banker <rbankerAnaplesgov.com> Sent: Wed, Jul 18, 2012 7:02 am Subject: RE: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 I will have an inspector from this office contact the owner or building manager to gain access to the unit to confirm the glass etching and specifically what information the etching contains. We will need whatever paperwork you can get from the manufacturer for our records. At that time a determination as to code compliance can be made. The paperwork needs to be directed to me. Be advised that I will be off the week of July 23-27. Paul Bollenback Building Official City of Naples 239-213-5037 pbollenback a,naplesgov.com From: bjvpglobal @aol.com [mailto:bjvpglobal @aol.com] Sent: Monday, July 16, 2012 9:58 AM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: mcuriale2 @aol.com; Curiale47 @yahoo.com; gmriinc @embarqmail.com; surfsedgemgr @comcast.net Subject: 4001 Gulfshore Blvd N. Surfsedge Condo Unit 707 Mr. Bollenback, 1 E40 Goodmorning Paul. My name is William Rench and I work for Global Maintenance. I am emailing you because I need to get the issues at hand in regards to the fire rated glass at the Surfsedge unit 707 resolved and put behind us. I have found out with a little research that piece of glass installed currently is fire rated. I took the information which is etched on the glass in the bottom right hand corner(Oldcastle 8 laminated 41 16 CFR 1201-11 DCA LSG BUTACITE)and found out it is fire rated glass. It is called Pyroguard. I am currently waiting on the manufacturer to get me the fire rating on it. It is either 20,45,60 or 90 minute fire rating. As soon as I find this information out I will contact you and the Surfsedge. Please if you have any questions call me or email me at your convenience. Thank you and have a great day. 2 • Fire-rated Glass Pyroguard Wired Glass 0 ldca ie !a ro Where glass becomes architecture'" . sectron.ls•o3 ea Fire-Rated Glass Introduction CD Oldcastle Glass®stocks nonwired Pyroguard ^'-` laminated safety glass and polished wired glass (ii) all glazing,regardless of size,whether for commercial,industrial and residential fire- fire-rated or not, used anywhere in rated applications. athletic facilities,must comply with the Federal Consumer Products Safety Most codes were originally written around wired Commission's safety standard, 16 CFR glass,because for many years,it was the only glass 1201, Category II. product that could pass the fire tests. Building code and fire department officials have been able Previously,fire-rated wired glass was exempt from to instantly recognize the wire mesh as a sign that having to meet the CPSC standard in hazardous the glass was fire-rated. locations,as long as it was a fire-rated location and it could pass the ANSI Z97.1 standard.The Nonwired Pyroguard laminated safety glass current 1984 ANSI Z97.1 standard includes a (which meets CPSC 16 CFR 1201,Category I) 12" drop height, 100 ft-lb impact energy level test and polished wired glass have both passed the UL that standard 1/4" polished wired glass could and the ITS Warnock Hersey fire-rated glazing meet.The minimum impact energy level in the tests,and are accepted as fire-rated glazing by fire CPSC standard is an 18" drop height, 150 ft-lb authorities and building code officials. impact test,which standard 1/4"wired glass does not meet. The International Building Code and the NFPA 5000 building code now require the following: Thus,any jurisdiction that adopts the 2003 edition of the IBC or NFPA 5000 can no longer use (i)fire-rated glass in hazardous locations standard 1/4"wired glass in hazardous locations in (doors,sidelites,etc.)in educational facilities elementary and high schools,or anywhere in athletic in grades K to 12,must comply with the facilities.Only fire-rated glasses that meet the CPSC Federal Consumer Products Safety 16 CFR 1201 (Category I or II,depending on size Commission's safety standard, 16 CFR limitations)may be used in hazardous locations in 1201,Category I and II,depending on size schools,and only Category II glass will be permitted limitations,and anywhere in athletic facilities. Description Pyroguard fire-rated safety glass is available as a continuous rolling process. In the event of fire, (nominal) 5/16"clear annealed laminated glass wired glass acts as an effective barrier to flame, product.It is made of two lites of 1/8" (3 mm) smoke and hot gases.The wire mesh also helps annealed clear float glass filled with a proprietary keep the glass from falling out of the frame if it fire-resisting resin that provides fire and safety becomes fractured. features without the use of wires. It is considered to have the same bending strength of annealed Polished wired glass is commercially available as monolithic glass of the same size and thickness. a(nominal) 1/4" clear glass product with two different mesh configurations: a diamond mesh Polished wired glass is manufactured by joining (also called"Misco") and a square mesh(also two layers of molten glass and"sandwiching" called"Georgian" or"Baroque"). electrically welded steel wire mesh in one (continued on back) 4. ® section 1.5.03 Oldcastle Glass® Where glass becomes architecture- eA3, P age 3 eD 1 77J Fire-Rated Glass P Capabilities Pyroguard fire-rated safety glass can be used safety glass can be used in sizes up to 9 square feet in 20-minute(no hose stream), fire-rated (16 CFR 1201,Category I). Polished wired glass applications,up to the maximum sizes indicated does not meet the safety glazing requirements of P in Table 1. 16 CFR 1201. Cn CA Polished wired glass can be used in 20-to 90-minute, Pyroguard and polished wired glass are stocked fire-rated applications,up to the maximum sizes at various Oldcastle Glass®facilities.They can be indicated in Table 1. supplied cut-to-size from stock sheets and are readily available on short notice. In safety glazing applications,Pyroguard fire-rated Table 1. Fire-Rated Glass: Maximum Exposed Dimensions Based on Test Results Important Notes:The design professional is responsible for specifying fire-rated and safety glazing products that meet the project's fire and building code requirements.The maximum size allowed per code may be less than the actual test sizes listed below. Stop Maximum Glazing Height Area Width Height Rating Product Application Framing System inches in inches inches minutes 5/16"Pyroguard Door(single or multiple lite) HM C 3/4 1288 28 46 20(NH) clear tire-rated Door(single or multiple lice) W C 3/4 1288 28 46 20(NH) safety glass Sidelite,transom lite, HM C 3/4 1288 28 46 20(NH) borrowed life 1/4"clear Door HM A 1/4 3289 35-3/4 92 20(NH) polished wired glass Door(single or multiple life) W B 9/16 2856 34 84 20 Door(sidelite,transom lite) HM A 3/8 1296 54 54 20,45 Door(single or multiple lite) HM B 9/16 2856 34 84 20,45 Sidelite,transom lite NM C 3/8 4704 106 106 20,45 . Door(single lite) W B 9/16 960 12 80 45,60. Door(multiple lite) W B 9/16 1920 12 80 45,60 Door(single lite) HM B 9/16 1008 12 84 45 Door(multiple lite) HM B 9/16 2016 12 84 45 Door(single lite) HM B 9/16 552 12 46 90 . Door(multiple lite) HM B 9/16 2208 12 46 90 A—Standard the glazing system;B—PEMKO FG3000 Fireglaze with PEMKO doorlite kit;C—PEMKO FG3000 Fireglaze;HM—hollow metal framing; W—wood framing;NH—no hose stream test. . 1 'kik .f ° e 4 Oldcastle Glass' Where glass becomes architecture 6 n:r _ • Fire Rated Glass Ph Applications eD Pyroguard glass is ideal for applications in 20-minute Polished wired glass applications include cm) (no hose stream)fire-rated openings that are subject door lites,sidelites and transom lites requiring to safety and impact resistance requirements. fire-rated glazing material. Pyroguard glass applications include door lites, The design professional is responsible for Ci sidelites and transom lites requiring fire-rated specifying fire-rated and safety glazing products safety glazing material. that meet the project's fire and building code requirements. Polished wired glass is ideal for applications in fire-rated openings that are exempt(by code)from certain safety and impact resistance requirements. Characteristics Glass products must undergo rigorous testing at Pyroguard fire-rated safety glass meets the require- an independent laboratory(such as Underwriters ments of ANSI Z97.1-1984 as well as the impact Laboratories) in order to be classified as fire-rated. requirements of CPSC 16 CFR 1201, Category I. The testing consists of two parts. Pyroguard glass cannot be heat-treated,curved or bent. It is considered to have the same bending In the first phase, large pieces of the glass are strength as annealed monolithic glass of the same installed in a test furnace.Heat in the furnace is size and thickness. steadily raised above 1,600°F,following a specific time/temperature curve.Flames are directed onto Polished wired glass meets the requirements of the glass surface to simulate actual fire conditions ANSI Z97.1-1984,but not the impact require- in a building.The furnace burns for a set ments of CPSC 16 CFR 1201.Polished wired duration of time,which is then used to determine glass cannot be heat-treated, but may be curved the rating the glass will achieve.Various glass or bent.It is considered to have half the bending products have achieved fire ratings ranging from strength of annealed monolithic glass of the same 20 minutes to 3 hours. size and thickness. To achieve a fire rating of 45 minutes or greater, Both Pyroguard and polished wired glass are the glass must pass the fire"hose stream test." classified as fire-resistant glazing materials by This test demonstrates how the glass withstands Underwriters Laboratories. the thermal shock associated with being hit with water during fire suppression efforts. See Table 2 for additional information. Compartmentation would be lost if water from a sprinkler or a fire hose were to cause the glass to vacate an opening during a fire. (continued on back) al Or Oidc #i t l Where glass becomes architectureelP0 Sccr o;i Is a3 g V Page 1 s I.r • CD I 7d Fire-Rated Glass P et Table 2. Fire-Rated Glass Product Information Product Characteristics Stock Mesh %Visible USA ASTM Canada Wei�gqht Size Size Licht C1036.01 CAN/CGSB (Ib/ftZ) (inches) {inches) Transmittance Classification 12.11-M.90 C/) CI) 5/16"Pyroguard clear 3.3 98 x 62 NA(1) 86 Type I,Class I,Quality q3 NA fire-rated safety glass 1/4"clear polished 3.4 130 x 78 3/4 80 Type II,Class I,Form I, Type I,Style I (diamond)wired glass Quality q3,Mesh M1 1/4"clear polished 3.4 130 x 78 1/2 80 Type II,Class I,Form I, Type I,Style 3 (square)wired glass Quality q3,Mesh M2 USA Impact Test Information Test Impact ANSI Safety CPSC Safety Test Report Size Height Glazing Glazing Lab Number (In) (in Standard Standard 5/16"Pyroguard clear ITS 3031239-02 34 x 76 18 ANSI Z97,1-1984 NA fire-rated safety glass ITS 3009496-231-02 34 x 76 18 N/A CPSC16 CFR 1201,Category I 1/4"clear polished ATI ATI-18183-1 34 x 76 12 ANSI Z97.1-1984 None (square)wired glass 1/4"clear polished ATI ATI-18183-1 34 x 76 . 12 ANSI Z97.1-1984 None (square)wired glass Canada Impact Test Information Test Impact Canada Safety Test Report Size Height Glazing Lab Number (mm) (mm) Standard 5/16"Pyroguard clear NA NA NA NA NA fire-rated safety glass 1/4"clear polished ATI ATI-19401-1 (865 x 1930) (300) CAN/CGSB-12.11-M90 (square)wired glass 1/4"clear polished ATI ATI-19401-1 (865 x 1930) (300) CAN/CGSB-12.11-M90 (square)wired glass (1)NA—Not Applicable (continued on next page) ,,' 'ecdq"'''03 O dcastUe Glass Where glass becomes architecture-" . • Fire-Rated Glass Table 2. Fire-Rated Glass Product Information (continued) Fire-Resistance Listings Underwritersn' Warnockn' � Laboratories Test Hersey Test f�• 5/16"Pyroguard clear USA R 2098 3010340 fire-rated safety glass Canada NA{z) NA(2) C/) 1/4"clear polished USA UL17Y9 NA (diamond)wired glass Canada 23018 NA 1/4"clear polished USA UL17Y9 NA (square)wired glass Canada 23018 NA (1)Listed for Positive Pressure (2)NA—Not Applicable Additional Important Information Design Criteria: Contact Us Details on the following important topics can be For any additional information,including details, found in the Black Design Criteria Tab: Glazing technical data,specifications,technical assistance Instructions, Thermal Stress, Deflection, Glass and samples,or to speak with an architectural Design Load, Glass Thickness Selection, specialist,call 1-866-OLDCASTLE(653-2278). Spontaneous Breakage of Tempered Glass, Roller Wave Distortion in Heat-treated Glass, Visit Us on the Web Mock-ups and Warranties. Log on to www.oldcastleglass.com for project Specifications: photos,product colors,general inquiries and project assistance. A sample Section 08800 Specification for North America can be found in the Black Specifications To view performance data on a wide range of Tab.Information specific to Fire-rated Glass glass makeups or to build your own product can be found in Part 2 Products,2.02 Materials. specification,log on to www.oldcastleglass.com and choose GlasSelect:"R Section 1.5.03 OIdCasUe Glass' Where glass becomes architecture Page BEFORE THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD Petitioner Case Number: 2012-03 v. License Number: LINDA CURIALE CGC1508927/27333 D/B/A Global Maintenance & Restoration, Inc. Respondent / STIPULATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND AGREED ORDER LINDA CURIALE and BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD (hereafter BOARD) hereby stipulate and agree: 1. Respondent admits the allegations in Administrative Complaint for the purposes of this stipulation and settlement of this matter. 2. Respondent and the BOARD hereby agree that she will be subject to probation for a period of twelve(12)months whereby the Respondent will perform her contracting activities under the supervision of the Board. 3. Respondent and the BOARD further agree that Respondent will personally apply for all permits and be present,either in person or telephonically for any reviews or questions as to the contracting operations of the company which she qualifies during the probationary period. This includes permits issued by the Cities of Marco Island or Naples and for fire code reviews. Elea i 4. In the event the Respondent violates paragraph 3 of this stipulation agreement while on probation, her license/certificate will be immediately suspended for any new permits and a • hearing on the suspension and violation shall be held at the next scheduled Board hearing. . 5. This stipulation and order shall be forwarded to the State Construction Industry Licensing Board with a recommendation of no further action. Executed this day of March,2012. 411timm Chia .) 41 . Le ,� If Lin i a uriale I ssorio Respondent Contractors' Licensing Supervisor ORDER ADOPTING STIPULATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT THE BOARD BEING FULLY ADVISED on the Stipulated Settlement Agreement, it is hereby: ADJUDGED that the foregoing Stipulated Settlement Agreement is adopted in its entirety,and the parties are ordered to comply therewith. DONE AND ORDERED at the regularly set Contractors'�ensing Board hearing at Naples,Collier County, Florida on this �. day of ea-e ,2012. Lee Horn Chairman Contractors' Licensing Board eiii ARTICLE V. BUILDING TRADES* Page 30 of 36 Sec. 22-201.1 Misconduct--State certified contractors. The following actions by state certified contractors shall constitute misconduct and grounds for discipline pursuant to section 22-202 of this article. (1) Failing or refusing to provide proof of public liability and property damage insurance coverage and workers compensation insurance coverage as required by Florida Statutes. (2) Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or Collier County. (3) If the CLB finds through its public hearing process that the contractor was found by another county or municipality within the past 12 months, to have committed fraud or a willful building code violation and the CLB finds that such fraud or other willful violation • would have been fraud or a willful violation if committed in Collier County or within the respective city. (4) Fraud. (Ord. No. 94-34, § 4; Ord. No. 99-45, §4.2--4.2.3, 6-8-99; Ord. No. 06-46, § 1(4.1.8.2)) Sec. 22-202. Disciplinary proceedings, including minor violations. (a) There are three categories of violations: (i) violations of subsection 489.127(1), F.S.; (ii) violations of subsection 489.132(1), F.S.; and (iii) other violations within the jurisdiction of the contractor's licensing board. (1) Subsection 489.127(1), F.S., is incorporated herein. (Lack of required license, certificate, or registration). The following are designated to enforce subsection 487.127 (1), F.S.: Collier County Building Official, all license compliance officers, the chief building inspector, chief electrical inspector, chief plumbing/mechanical inspector, and/or other inspectors authorized from time-to-time by the building official. Procedures specified in this section shall apply except to the extent, if any, that Section 489.127 or Section 489.132, may require different procedure(s). The penalties for each uncontested violation of subsection 489.127(1) and/or 489.132(1), F.S., are $300.00 for the first uncontested violation and $500.00 for each subsequent uncontested violation by the same individual or entity. Penalties for contested violations of subsection 489.127(1), F.S., are as now or hereafter specified in Section 489.127, F.S. Penalties for contested violations of subsection 489.132(1), F.S., are as now or hereafter specified in Section 489.132, F.S. The citation form attached hereto as Exhibit "A" is approved, which form may be amended from time-to-time by resolution of the board of county commissioners. (2) Minor violations: The contractor licensing supervisor or designee shall issue a "notice of noncompliance" as the county's first response to a minor violation of any provision of any regulatory law, including this section, when (i) it is reasonable for staff to assume that the violator, at the time of violation, was not aware of the provision that was violated or it can be assumed that it was not clear to the violator how to comply with the violated provision; and (ii) that violation has not then resulted in economic harm or physical harm to any person; and (iii) the violation has neither adversely affected the public health, safety, or welfare, nor created any significant threat of any such adverse affect. The notice of noncompliance should identify the specific provision that was violated, should provide information on how to comply with that provision and should specify a reasonably time for full compliance. The notice of noncompliance shall not be accompanied with any immediate threat of any monetary fine or any other disciplinary penalty, but may specify that failure of the violator to correct the violation within the time specified in the notice for compliance may result in disciplinary proceeding ' Each 50 1... .in:1. ..,.� .V,...: ,.a .,.ia„F„1+m,.,Ar,,..,/1nc'7on I IAl01,;14..--')A(14 AK. 1/1//')!V1(1 . . .- .--;,.-7::: :-.,:;--.:,-;'-''',;:.,::,'---.„., -..', '?;•'-;j';',f7,1- 42-,-,"7,-t--X,A,,v,,:t.p--;.,-,,,,,, -• '' '"•-•?",--,...`!.',' :, "-.= -- . .1....1...-,.-..--.7:*alt.-1411:-.40$74--40t."4-'1:".""".`, ' ' ' '' - '--, -;-',.-•:,?,-.::-A,Z.,-,taylf•;,e,*!.,a..,.-_,,,,,,... , -2--"-----`—*•---.•\-------=-.:.-..-----a•l•-•---74.1-a-a,-.54.,,p, ,... ,,, : ‘-,::: ;:„-,-;,.---•:) -,-..:'.,7.;...,--..'-'",-,..-''':-._ '''''..,174.4-4,',., =:??--5‘'''':Z• 7 ' -:, _. --:-.4-4..--,--;'','-• '.:- = --7.'' '''.; -71-.'-'-`f•",i,,,:fri'lfetgl.'iA ,2,,• 7 r',..7'..,'7'41."''',"':J,;,,,,':::'-.',;'''.-.-" '',...-,..si-..i.;,,,,ST:ri..-,,,,,,,,,.:;,...,,,,?-,30,aitt-f,t..• ..,;kA , : -::. 7.-,-c."-'''• '''''''N,--‘,00Y1'..ta.a-1,!.?.:r.--,..,-,.--, ::•k-.'i,.-714.,7:ei-r-i-ow--,,,,,,.--mfte,t;',.-..1 , , ,,,.,, Lt-„1,‘!..4:-• ;57.r.,,--4,:-..,,,,--.t.=--;4:--,...„,--:-..-_,--,-,...-A41.. .,,,,t-4.'-aat',.,*,,'-' ''...`•-•-..7 ''.7 r . ' '''''''' riz,;.7.":,,,;d:',;;:.,,,,,::..sc,i7,47.4-,'%:f;-:.■.'4.:,"i"Y.-:.f..7.,:"..,-",,..;.;.$Q."""1;1;a,I-..7,':a :-.;,,-,i._'‘. ', 1 . .; -. -.',- .,,,,"...43/4,, .7,,a,;',..°,;;`,,a—t`,,'"-`iesei,,,,,',',-1,7:,-,-!-,-..:'-.,:-74',aa,= -'-14:i4.-',i'l?r-,f, ';'' • ' - S:1 „ii,,,'..-1.,,,,,.'.4.,,,,;-„,',,_414-e,-.1 ' -.:',..-..-'4_._:-,,,--,..;,,,,---_--;';'..;:_,•'-'7,"-',-.- --' • , ---",: A ',.'-,i-'fA "...•_ ;;','''-';ri." '--r:IP ' ''. -'':,:.z, :,;;;!‘ . . _ . tP.46 e,',4 l'r.1/1":: '... '..''''1•1•0,-,,,* ;,;.',"----- „„'" ,k,-- , - -_-..4. ''.....:: e'-•'- 11"'''''• 4. 4':" :.- .. ).. . . 'p--7.b.x.. . .. , -,.....,...... . ,•-' 7-.4: ,-ti.,.',-,.-..4, -::-- „ ,:,.., , ,. - ',---,,.:,-;,-,g.-Ili— 4---, ,--,--„4-',, ,..,-.,--,-,41,:,;!,-,--.r.-,t c,,..-,- ?:-:,- - -,,i'le.c.1.',1-----,,--:,-•-: = 1:'-= -,-1.;,-:-F-:?---f-— ,,-' -- •A..,' . - 0 ,,,,, '''Trj,..;.„,- - I ..- ..- i-;„ .1.:::4-“,,,,-.- .1 .-.,-,-1,•;.— 'Ar ''1,..:;,;* ; 1,', ' , ' ' '.14.- :';:'=,:.,' ■ ,-,-,-,t,-‘1* c - . ;;;---.:;,,. 2Z-,,.. 1 i'' . 1 .4.-'2.-":',! •,,'''''!1:f.T.,, ' .., f-' .— ,.._ -''.. 4,..1.;-•-■-•.'. ,, ;',r_.1:.+j '•- • 1•.,. ''. -...-- • .,.- ' r , 1... ,.„. . , i -pa f+r k ; • r. .. . k& S .,' y,a-, '�- �3 2 r S' � k t , � �4 a mad '$ �, .�*a te -.g,, �,^r�"a -., ., , ',,, ,,,!'; ,.,* ,0 : 1.142), 40 x Jacksonian From: Paul Bollenback[pbollenback @naplesgov.com] Sent: Monday, September 10, 2012 4:26 PM To: Jacksonian Cc: OssorioMichael Subject: RE: Global Maintenance case I have read the summary and in my opinion I do consider the violation as being willful. Paul Bollenback Building Official City of Naples 239-213-5037 pbollenback@naplesgov.com From: Jacksonlan [mailto:IanJacksonCa�colliergov.net] Sent: Monday, September 10, 2012 3:26 PM To: Paul Bollenback Cc: OssorioMichael Subject: Global Maintenance case Paul, Would you review the case summary and reply as to whether you consider the violation as being willful? Thank you. Ian Jackson License Compliance Officer Contractors'Licensing/Growth Management Division 2800 North Horseshoe Dr Naples, Fl 34104 Phone:239-252-2451 Fax:239-252-2469 ianiackson@colliergov.net Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. e65