Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Backup Docs 06/26/2012 (CR)
I+ern*-lo 0 Jvne Zre,2vi2 OS— My name is Richard Rogan, V.P. of the Naples Heritage Homeowners Association. I am here with Patrick Dorbad, G.M. of our Club. We are requesting approval for the installation of Advance Street signs at the entrance to our community off of Collier Blvd. There are two entrances into Naples Heritage; one off of Collier Blvd (CR951) and one off of Davis Blvd. Many of our residents experience difficulty negotiating the turn into our community off of Collier Blvd. (CR951) onto Naples Heritage Drive. While we have not yet had an incident, we feel strongly that we are dealing with an "accident waiting to happen." This is about to become more critical now that the widening of Davis Blvd. in front of our main gate is getting underway. We anticipate that many more residents will be using the entrance on Collier Blvd. to avoid the construction which is likely to take 18-24 months. In April, 2010 we made a request of the Department of Transportation and Engineering that Advance Street Signs be installed both northbound and southbound on Collier Boulevard (CR951) identifying Naples Heritage Drive. Our understanding of the guidelines contained in the Traffic Engineering Manual, paragraph 2.37.6 (copy attached to our request to speak) required that a dedicated left turn lane be present and that the speed limit on the major road not be less than 45 miles per hour. Both conditions are present. In addition, the number of Advance Street Signs in place at non- signalized intersections on Rattlesnake Hammock, Livingston and at other locations around Naples would indicate that our request was consistent with current practices. In fact, we also received some verbal encouragement that our request was appropriate. We were advised that a new Guideline was under development and that there would be some delay. The drafts that we have seen since incorporate the requirement for an average daily vehicle count of 2000 on the minor roadway or that it serve as the single access to a residential development with a minimum of 600 homes. Acknowledging that we do not meet either of these requirements, but also not having been officially turned down, we decided to come before the Commission to request an exemption from what we thought were the new guidelines. AS I said earlier, the upcoming construction on Davis Blvd. has added to our anxiety. Since having been placed on today's agenda, we have learned that the new guidelines had not been put in place yet and are indeed scheduled to be approved by this Commission today. In the past two weeks we have been contacted twice with the suggestion that we withdraw our request to speak today and file a request for consideration after the new guidelines are approved. Quite frankly, nothing seems to have happened in the last 26 months. Giving up an opportunity to document our case now doesn't feel very good. We think that our patience has earned us some sort of consideration. If establishing new guidelines can wait 26 months, it is apparent that there is little demand for what we are asking. Surely making an exception from whatever rules or guidelines now apply is not likely to create an avalanche of similar requests. Can we just get a couple of signs? X 4 d co r- U Y) O 'J0 Q m N O ...Y QOw V U MI U.I 3 v ' Qw � = m H (I) .a Si w z w Z W c. to L � � � O = cn F- wCe p W F- E ' 1 CC cl U r ce = N a ce C O a a .�j OIL t^ oI- z Q H 1 1 a N w W O CO �� 8 z5z a 12 O O a � � a oG _ V 1- 00 a Q 0 CZ W in' � , cp cn O 01 cu E `" m0 z m Q w U 00 00 W = V Z (� Ill E L h zzH E Z „ , mQ U Q OUP w 1 m ~ - O W �J a Qwm O F'. J C U. re zEF (A Q Q a6o z W (n Q J ZN J n-iJ U om = ��( J N O = Ce _ z f t- d+ z ,e F— z H .J ( I uzce 0 0 5 / L z0I- 0 E a a� a z Ln W re uj �W ce Qry E c A P d O Z ( J W W 4 Q W s/ c z uJ 1 W u_ Z Q E F p =a ce U J z � o o w . 0. E Z W L W QU `S 0 W 0 a d 02 0 Q E 0 E a z cc Ucn8 W •c ( Z a m � o =■i.. AIN U O CO CO Q LL Z 0 to � � a m O Q m W W W 3 aw1- = m^ � � CL J U) �� wzpw Z W 4 .5 v) Le U E .L6 4 ce I-1-1 Ce 0 OU re ce CD at NI a ctre S c0Z 0 H ° pQ I- 2 113 T w. +_+ pww W O _ _ ( ooz 0 4 a W rep z 0 g w � 0 Z W cn cu Q O Um00 W I z w 2 H U � F Z U D 118 I- 5 0 0U � G n a m "p et W 2 LV W W 1- = W Ce N I-- O < 6o 15 t Q \ \+ ` cn Q �G Z J A H W riZW J Ln 5'2 U M m V �`` 0 0 1- W W W Z' _ H Z zap 1- Z re t U ~ W O- 2 0 a) a0 O re �W *' Q f c V 1 LU °' UJ &) J W W Q a W 81 Z � W � a C w �+• 0 L.L. = f W Z c • � mv) 0 u C IN r Z W a � -IZ U W W wrO Q 2 4 4 re Uu U 0. Cu „,,,,,„.,,,_ S 4 frig /z2 Co 70 4/2),,T,1 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. y or • 4‘,1,6:61,A7Leiux,c. 7 A/, // - E' r r�l-// ;„?_i - I Ys o f /r) L .10. � e.Z`' 4- 91-11113 I. j (/- °I-4(iv--c47;/#- 3 4/ 6 �4&f��:+`T '”' Y =-41; 1°-"!---/-2—1-I/40,- .. /.._ _.. .„8 cf(62 L..aliff.1044,1_0_64.1,9-Y.,..A-Lt____ _._ .w . .-y --� 1 10 a Zoo riut 9. ill-/ v� 34100) zoo ms 3e. &Zga_130S+Rd( 4.1.9_,.5 rutssaf ete_covtsp ....._...cv±...vni_ - o . ► boa e. II, ail&4-6 __,..A, 1 . I f4, ..._...,, q.f16 ______ t.°LI # A 4 Or tearr061,A 3s _kik , ' _si,L,QA), __ _ 2-(k? (9\39 q6 /-OS-66--- 36. / ' ...._.fly e cien:2-04 37 i)c ,,vo. Sct pro 0 , . Z iof 1 0 , , '5'7 It A,_. , I ■ i I f ' bif 1 09.4. 100-c7?0 'LW 04 A A . 1 , s 6 , 'IV / i z L-1. i ac -) 6 s I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples II� be destroyed or icons of our community that should creative solution. compromised. Let us pursue eole--.2W b (f) ' frfiz"--- 32,/ alp , 4 ,. , 6 4 C."- L e / ''' '`• 1/---• I 1/ fLIZA 3 / 0 ? t iG' 44)(-Cet 47. 5,:4 ,,fyit,c) , '---- • - , i, 3L-tqc , ...-- ,.... ___ ,,, . ___.„ <.3 q i 0 Tr 44 4/ // 7 _ cirg rr 111- ,,.,,,,,,,, 34/or i► ' 3W CI 314 « V A ■ i t, 4, SL1 \0 g k il ilie Ar 7 /4i1Tov -"7-407 /Y i w s� Or,IPPPIPw 404.-Air / --- 51/( 03 r .er chi--. -5 (//o 6itez, , . q, 3 ILL.(2_q_ f c*Tirt * ' 1' \, I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are or • icons of our community that should creative solution. compromised. Let us pursue a �d� ,g72 a,, 3 4- Al'y 'AL: Fri, r d fyI 6 I" 171 it ai t i a `,,r4 c ,-- Nil& ■P/7 el i •ter t o r k-- n �, • 3 . 1b W?mot AP ,--k--D.)-cs c7z( c. c4. cd,,,„__ - 2//4 'e9.-.0-z --- 3 //, . ( ,-,,-, ,--- ,. / 3.it , 3 e P---( 5 6/? Dvd Nr ; q7oF id. -c/l/M. 3c// o e 11n ma..11 4 i ' .0 Aa6 ■IIMECIMINIIMII , If , it t /412 r w l 1 , 0 ., r AAA ,/2/I/t Y`'r' I strongly support the preservation of the These and d bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zo are icons of our community that should not be destroyed detroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. , " i ?Le-8,-- 31110 _. °Li /, I 1)ilL 5 lin '; V I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and These are bridge at the entrance to the Naples z� be destroyed or icons of our community that should not compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. ,NA M � Z.1 i CODE, r�iL1A-►z- (-_-Lj i A • 3 V// C ` a�1 /. �; c G -----) aU, t/-77 ' tS '1i0. -, -7 ,. r)/e1 °Z 1.44ea,..h_..),Itn, Ill 02_, Co;21---- =1*, __1_6 , 3'111 8 • apt,g_ . yyioS , &)e--ax-ditilit,t,to Je-Po,3 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds here are bridge at the entrance to the Naples nz� be destroyed or icons of our community that should stive solution compromised. Let us pursue ;1-, '1(iig i - i) V ( - r K:a2_,e,„ .‘‘‘..6._ ne(-12A-evi'' i 9Jg r Nck, leS ./, i 3 it...4 I- ' , ei , ! I 4�! '� 01 j dill ilk 1 •-. .- 1,1„._g tty‹,c v-ci 0.C. ► . N 0 S 34k3.5 qilli 'NM 'RIM I 3 '-kt 07-- lir lt►- i e I. _lg. 1 please return to Arsenault Gallery,764 12th Ave. S., 34102 Jr. I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 3+1 o 5 Q.) /22emtk 3W/ boo') in afio- ncy , 7 aro, 7 _ 7g44 dtel / / 3 3L/ ./Z//4/ 3(.9 3 /4 (.2 1,i • I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and re bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These a destroyed or icons of our community that should not be compomised. Let us pursue a creative Cam , JRJJAled (3Vio4 1 , / -2C1()6 t A A A 14 Ilibi ( b • lesSN -..4,„..17. iali Nth\ C', . Lvvl I 1 g a �; s 1 /,,,v oe--'' a, / 1 -....m111111 11, 'r - '''''''' ' Al/A ALE ,j A 11/ ‘' C 5 40 . 71 4 C C ' 3 ( ( ( 7 , ow ., , . P IP /v / fir 5q- tC-) 3_- s, I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and e are bridg e at the entrance to the Naples Zoo.be destroyed or icons of our community that should not compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 1 / . 7 t '-s. 3 \-( 2 `82 Cave- A-4 ) yi 0 2, \AK,' I d-3 ,4/1 V -- X ' 7 " ey5//to , cf=- clitfrrierk, ir -c-/ I oZ___ . w 411/,...._ e /er4.42,_, i. . i _./ 4' 64 .( -AK. d 34/0 44111 2j1 ItD ,gel I. i� r I strongly support the preservation of ponds and the These are bridge at the entrance to the ghvuld not be destroyed or icons of our community that compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. CA\c4 V\e 1--4'"\(\t tik )\\(3D . • el c e-Re__Iltco 3L1 ) 03 obi /r epic 35//60 -r ,, 3 / 05 0 / 7 ... (_ , .)-1 ci Ik1 3q 103 ' 0;--2 11,4„,z, ___,,r ,02-) - ___,7 . S (X0v‘ (°0t1460(t) 1 llod.' z. L a di 1 trip,e_ cJn 4 B - "'"? Aq1)- , BO MD Acme 5 V1/g0 , 17oef� , 4 -7oNips if reservation of the ponds and I strongly support the preservation Zoo. These are bridge at the entrance to the should not be destroyed or icons of our Comm unity th compromised. L t us pursue a creative solution. K, -1:-,--- ----y-e _ , r iii4, ,e(sm,2.._ 0' Ak-,46..e/ Ala Z.. in IQs 'K7 kin 1 { p �� !�Y ' / 11 i - i % -Q ,izt vi. . 0 A Cu' 4 i Iii■ I A.1. . 311 )1 11/ A ri. :-=) ,,.. _7 `- l ') ,_ -' _if). '1- -- , ‘\,,,, • • f thi 1:2)Goco 0 L.)), ,ei., H i• ,_ t...,,k • i 411110 . (j Zi IGf \ ` P i I r ,,c: ,fry �.�� (4b o LP 3 "f ' o SUioi li }Ityyfr SgO7 V k (---- --U--k-g--re---, 714, A ,,Nku 1 -2? ‘f 1 0 if ' '4/ vtl e viv P' )04,4,1 14 . kli,.‘ 3 (..1 ( 0 ?i- bat; 6) '4-4i s 3 � lf foEfLOeIiibl9ry 9JcZAW-U-Pieoeari C.L. 5+( p. 5 fi @.4a1-,0,4 94/ \J�� i il mo1N 3/4‘if 6 Qo R. Zek:Cagl. Kibs ponds and support the preservation o the These are Istrongly edor bridge at the entrance to the Naples not be destroy icons of our community that s compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 4 t t A'adtclikk i 41 3 4 t b r2,■■-• 4 a air, 6) arm tea OW_ >v"44-2,‘L---1 L4t.e..:' ...5 0-7. - , `°`""i . .„, 3 0 C fir, r^,.":- ,3G7/0 )-, /nwizsg9,- ie i ponds and 1 support the preservation of the These are I strongly ed or bridge at the entrance to the should not be destroy icons of our community that compromise . Let us pursue a creative solution. i' 14 //' )' la,k 31 1 A- i # ric- / i / / � ! L.r_ 1 , 1 1 (9(2,449,e-, g 4 1 6 3 `' �.��a wt I ..01^ / ( 47r, , 1.A.,- ii . , 0,p. VlAdiLeitAA,1 \\C‘-‘ '04 LR ( ,A- ct is v /L61,04 a A,:, (-E1-8/0-/- ■ l 't . .,. 1 , LA , to b f -J. ® ti r , J 4' /./A A n I w 1.1i/Lit-' �/��'1�av`„ •��C �id144 ponds and support the preservation o the These and I strongly the entrance ed or at the entrance to the Naples be destroy j bridge unity that icons of our community a creative solution. compromised. Let us pursue [ z h° ice l r Z J . tc ' i -� ciejad,ovt 6L,/ ljupimj .---1 . .--• I/ / . ,, k , ,, , _ Y ( i ' qc-S . 3V/OS $ ' ,--)-\ c f 3 LH 1 ° ■ , I' 0/60- 1 0 f 1 • 0111/41-; 314 11 1/ • 3gcd * X77 /4 /2717o , i) I I _ _ ,L 4 6 Is g trop ly support the preservation o the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the s These are should not be destroyed or icons of our community that mi d. Let us pursue a creative solution. 119-/))compro )/i° ar.L y u 9 e i i , •-\-t104---- 5q---1 , - a , / it q ( 3 ( - /.. 4 A,44,,E D-/-44 ., � ponds and support the preservation o the These are I strongly ed or bridge at the entrance to the Naples be destroy icons of our community that s compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. j ' °aft Seiz,e 3 )4 / 4-5' . i „ . i , , ) 1 113 Akit... ._ , ,i / b Li e / , , ' , 1 d-)-- ai ,t,_ „__. j / / , 4 il 0)-1 r .:53o6 d--- I 6' ' �`` J !/ri 3 z-Ntz / - //I'..4,401111.1111"-- ii yoi .07 /1 Ail' 411 -2 . I 41/. 40 t,11/ du/4 J. . , .Fc,";27cf:361-12 .._ . ponds and support the Preservation o the These and I bridge at the entrance destroyed or at the entrance t° the not be destrOY bridge a unity that a creative solution. \tAme icons of owed°L t us pursue P cot) , IA / ,A,, , t,,,,,_ v. ..,,,, . ,9 ivy 3"-1 I L el & C3 1 , Ail Ad ...I .4 ., _ A Atigi 3q 12.0 -le f IA 1' °41°I.7.0 3t-- .,.._■ ) - iiiiii 0 ,e0 3q /I 7 k VII) .,71 4,-... i .v�1sA - .1 LOtte;(k ALI i / 31/ 101 • n of the ponds and reservaai Naples Zoo. Thes ate or support the preservation the N p destroyed I ::zt that shouXt be our community pursue a creative solution. icons of Let us pure C &M,e,ka e_coy., St-ML.0 compromise d J_ _ot �l ___,-5 -, ..5-e.)/cAe- 3413--c) _ a ; 1_6( (;0•11 34 105 y._.,:ey)t) em (1c: __\51■ s r A - a 31110 5 i 1 * vr 1606 ( JO 311 , . - \(),(\12., \ c-,-e______ 1 • 1 I. • ' A , A 4.! - A alf ' t\2,0 OV --1-3" IV& 0.-e,11.,cY\ 3Liin ofthep°ndsand support the preservation es Zoo on se and I strongly' s e e the Nap ed or bridge at the entrance to cation• •t that should not be destr© unI Y creative sol icons of our community a compromised. Let us p 'P C oD E, , Ai Iv cSmer) .-- 3 ' -PI / L iimi.„ I ♦�`' it timaL: II - (.5 401 1 I , 6/11 kIVW1 00/1 A 1 ►, 1' A 0 AI ,, ;<;-0&-ii ,_N..c_ljWi2._----_-_ 3 Cf.( 0 1* I. # 1 --,/ i ,......,,A,"0- ..---__ MI 0 1 - i I , , , . ti ( i , A4. , , ' i _..... ...... _ 7 r/ of the ponds and reserve ai pon Zoo• ponds are t support the to the N p not be destroyed or I strongly entrap should a creative no solution. bridge at a oommun�tY that sue s , loons o our Let us pursue C d compromised. � r ) 3 . alk-----, ,, ,, _ .. - A V_ii SA -1\1CgW SO- iseA\E IN kI6 ____..... c --i . kJ oj &,1(-6-/ 6..1 v 31-( 101 ' A 4 --1 I -- ' 4 c� q , Pti 1 , ..._ - _ A • : I, i IL - I-- 0',AL.,.t /Aa - *f4S° "A° - • L C� - I ponds and support the preservation of the These and I strongly the entrance ed or eat the entrance to the Naples be destroy bring unity that icons of our comet us pursue a creative solution. Ylea -e, --‘ck 4.'Lo cscs\c-,p compromised. Let a v(-2- 241 se C-08)-e-, ■ ,E . ._ .ar. 3 '-/ 7,0,, / , • .f Li \ , ,) 7 * las / - .., _4,, .4.-i_ a 7' 7 1 t'i \it" if ha 3 iq 2, r.,AA ) c--) - -, % , .., - , ,,,,),, ---.4v\vpir\-- '/ c--\.:----._---•- ..i _. .. ' -) ci i i _�' i \ , Ji4(rA ki .trckg),,LL\ U 'II ,t(i ■A (I At ISL...„ 3'1 11i7 / i -(..-k\\) 3 ' of the ponds and 1 support the preservation I strongly Naples Zoo. These are or bridge at the entrance to the s vuld not be destroy icons of our community that sed. Let us pursue a creative solution. comproml C 'BO . / 3'1 13 ,L.AtAlki.-4 . 4 34 1 0 ' D4, 'A g5clob - I • NI .._ 04 411 6''-7-' //r O. 3 ‘ i 2- SCI i® a 714 X G o',A 3 • i ponds and support the preservation of the These are I strongly ed or bridge the entrance to the Naples be destroyed that should of our community compromised Let us pursue a creative solution. em. A ■ tr� w 3`-W /A /frt .-9- 5 o ,/i 3410' Ilk T IN% i 1 - 3L- 119 0 • ( /• .. °ft*---11_,L_M-Nrnew (\,\, 0\ __y- S ` /' // , ' ---7 g i - C 21 \ 00( &tflsber H 1 9 11 at • t \ . \ < • I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples II t be destroyed or icons of our community that should compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. • X11 \ \ � Ve. r c, 3i1IO 0/%61 soy, rn-42( t?' 5 a C AirceAco 3 jjci At- a / C1 U571' yes • Jnji2icki o • • SM. V)1 3 q-(1• ponds and support the preservation o the These are I strongly e d or bridge at the entrance to the Naples not be destroy icons of our community that ed. Let us pursue a creative solution. compromis '41r A `"\\00', 39° 10 ',.4t Ll.u►, 34ros 8L.Ari GUAVA/ yino Leprue- 3 ` 01 () qa: NOM 5 Lim I �,L� WW1 � . . V I 0�.t Is strongly support the preservation o the ponds and These are bridge at the entrance to the Naples not be destroyed or icons of our community that s compromised. Let us purslle a creative solution. III Ir Allill 410041111b-1111 -4111. 3 4 11-- ) y 34-112 Lod (It il 3 be ff 3y► � R lir\ 0� tIrt•aA/L-eaa 40 G) 4 ,III i1 nail. � -Sii_A i -4,J 3W/ LO _.... i_ 3(11fI ponds and the preservation of the These and I bridge strongly support e e d or eat the entrance to the Naples be destroy icons unity that should icons of our community et us pursue a creative solution. compromised. L I ..,1 , / , _ _ Li' "de / c).P \$ . ,,,, iliA! ,,,,,,------- dx/Tv:ei-AJ \VG/P"EA--- • c 106 . 1 i ,'1 �..� I;11 Pi.. , ) 0()r 321 )0(ii 1 elL 1 3L/) O kiàIrA 411111r��� 51&10'Mtn ' R \,.., i , d = Lot-1c.e., /311) (:/g r _ 0 , ' 32i1 06 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples not Zoo. destroyed These are or icons of our community that should t creative solution. compromised. Let us pursue a OA I jee 047 , cc 29( 1 , Ap 10-44 •411 , . , 3(d w%, ith 1 (7 ponds and support the preservation o the These and I strongly PP ed or bridge brl g that should icons of our community tY Let pursue a creative solution. compromised. L eo j8 N, I ,'"'" idi ayioy comp zi,, lAnt an ( 4 t r`1 6fl 34)lb ° a ` 3/`.- \O''' / * 1 5c 4, SC:--CD-4- Al-liy ...44L___,, -717Pcila 7 lti e_yi-- -)-e--, co (--(--{---- 141 ' 0 P 1 1'c Aie--_ kJ—-1 �;, G - ip i , 2,),LiA: cf,,,fi_52e,e_ K) 6,4)--tz-A---- �h7 12j1-&41 49v -2A-g "'-'6"64i'-- -ati P ` ,...,4,4---e--.)---- .---d" I ow---- �Avf cig-Y1,77,97--<766,/, of the Ponds and support the preservation es Zoo. These are I strongly destroyed or eat the entrance to the should not be bridge unity that creative solution• icons of owed. L t us pursue a compromised. J lrktrticA, 3 Li ) 0 9 t,'/..o / PR, 34101-1- te4-(1-lite. MOA L3 41 104_ f,a'k--- ioktall'A ZI-H DIA- L � V w 1 6 a., sc;11.1.- 4,1 ' L or du , I/_,,, I tom.0-6. efta _ 0 tIui - alit 0, b. ( J91)/1/(/)/ 4/ dWi44, a"11/1/, - 47?( -. F1:5 u�r- I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 4 NAME Z-1 P CAE, q(07 c - C(L'.( --21;41(/ ,____ /4,:,,_,,, (- . , , / dy, &of-) / 03 ,/,‘,,---m67q-ea),,,, ,,. /7z/ D 4 i r 1 I ■ 1 2 1-06 r1 ...0 / •9" ' A 3471/v V I jl., , Pr `� G 2 / O3 kit\CA INC, Tito z ( ./2,, _ ii _ i /2 _/ r -2 4-9..4-7 ,-, ___r), r-,,--, I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Z.Zif ,L: r C A.J 3 ' I l 0 \SG' 34 ?_eleccq j Ls c'V t 0 qe-01-e7 , . - `fro o/ eaA_61 3 1b7/710"- (7)*(431,0A-2,. Sia\-( 3; s A-A'� ScwAzs o (;„ 1 - Lam# 07}' ctse-i622>,d ft ,111 /1r ni (Li/innI I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Went zi:i fie\ aife,--...,K iiie.„0,-,7.L.--) 7 Lito ,..../%.0 3 /d r31(/ 01 It w , 3 .(-/Oz P, kLro,./L7 3c.icif.- daa,i, 3ook, ,_5-Aateil a„-jAnlog,- 3-V/O 2.- 6----;‘,7 2- ----2,-...,-- 3 1/4 in. (114a /1/2 riinfilill/Licari( A '7" , 4G / ,r ponds and support the preservation of zone These and I strongly ed or at the entrance to the Naples not be destroy bridge that should icons of our community ursue a creative soluti•n• wit 4 compromised. Let p ,,,E :-.7,,_ ._,,,,L..24 }:3/,_ ,? 9//9 1 Al Ip ip-a_zekect---cd i7,i.p__3 Ce-Q - e_ aQ10.)-0A 9 1 07..._— Atarmo,,, Pe--z-Cg2'1 3qicf. 4. itm Or" a s,t102... c- l 0 2 Y 3 2-1/6 D. '' A t i ,_ 1110,9- Aw,a( , la Min n (1440 old c>2J- -,Y.1 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and are bridge at the entrance to the should not be destroyed or icons of our community that s compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution.7__ ao),, Aku-NL P.1)3,47,60), dii --1- --- . , .. z ,y /os- , 0, ,L , 3c-( / a 3,-- 3V/ )1\4 -tA/,t ,v., a, ZC-e-et-y - Gl7 °-go, n ), 6c-a its b--arn . 3 g-i/ I Q--. I AlLiaibLi 3-11-- 1 0 To,-,,,- —‘07--. 0- --J13`5L- '3 (-1 ) SS"-- r--xi, ( , ( lw ko,„;,,e_., / to" ' ` /"7- a a / 304?)-d M aoati am btu& re&rn --h) Progxutd- 5ilkyii ion of the ponds and l support the preservation Zoo. These and I strongly ed or eat the entrance to the Naples bridge unity that should not bedessttroY icons of our COL t us pursue a creative solution. compromised. eala. 19441.04- 2t11.:00(-} aitfi J � Sill D3 ... � , 3 II/ d 3 r 60tA,s 3 J---/ / /2- 40t .4/03 (t) 3 /Go *4.11) • , 00 3 AP0 k (AL 40 - aikikf 4tui I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo.e These or icons of our community that should creative solution. compromised. Let us pursue a Aktrafb 1/4-41aivt.-J ilik r; e9 Add Z6 17- ;”20 ■01111 /6 ( 3-3 9'z5 , . (k )-(0\ ' Q tk 3• 0 4- I 0, I I 0 VYVe, ‘U-V\- Q,(9\Y2/ 41 c21 62-- 3,card ,ortz) c 19)060. reiornio 9rqazjJz3 Istrongly support the preservation o the ponds and These are bridge at the entrance to the Naples not be destroyed or icons of our community that s compromised. Let us pursue a creative solutio doa rilL Q do AP; - A i-, .4.6.,4_,... r A /6"- LIA-1/4-'-- // s , 4Uk-dt-Li /\/# 1 3q i o Si et-r-Z-- IA- AL-1'1/■&7 3 ii/og f -C6- .- l' 06q07 tit I '' I-Pcfkiitt ' U id ac,f) 4 ate"-- 3 '1-10 ....ei ailaiti-Afre-- 3 4 1 0 Ld 1, ` A g L-' i - 15 aarel °IP CO 51110 let In tO rhWini°10 62 deV i @anti/ COM C)175g'4)5 . , - I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let u, purfue a creative solution. 64 • IV r al& I 14 i ,g in I 6(- 6* • i'- 1 i 0 • - \ N. -' r - .11%.■ ' I 0 • ____m.-.--- di ■I-at sal ./ - - v i t / . .„( ...,i /. 0 1 p Ai 333 0 Aol. cairn / 9 -- cA"—f _—_. ..__. •- - . .?/.,re.,4-:7■4_, 16. 3 3 e), 2 t 0 1 ot. i"..... 4 . AUL= .. VI Il■A ‘,34 1 03 i i -. -scittt. • ti. • tio , ,Le - : • 3 Wiz__ • / / a 7 ' N6 )Nr■\.-&. V , ‘ikieq 39'a 9 •• ci---5-1:b"---. _,_ , _ 310.? . rS I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Onn Ea„ Lk o r9-1ctutf\ 8,e/ritz_vo t6vtetAei ` 170/kh4- 1117 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 0 Hata. , , 11 ( -0r4/ L-4 -- '1/32._ VAL I S,4.4c- 040 TY° Ot enTs, e) 9 0 r 0 :re) s ' 7 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. &-" 't \\r (\-\:\\\C Cinvfl t-G Par a Lap-os-07) lom,56i/) ny (3).(-- 7‘,4( Divroon ok 0 e) i I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 1 ( _, , i Of6Z f-C)3Q o , 06Accri( iqpriceec.4 '.-- to n n 4() fl( °lc( ip Vj-------. \(' an 5- c6 -VVE_ (.\,6e 5 C_ob ✓ v 7,,/,z,t) (PaKet mzu 6tArdet4) Jt y L-c 13 ,, CS't-t_sz A L.3 ,(N\\ ' _X.__i /4\N \ A I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. //1? --.6e eA.g ITi - O---e-/k )<j2_yl,t,,c_ 1 A . 1/4/4;//f/1- Mi7I , /// c,1_,_ c.,,,____ I , , 2. (API 4),(4 ,..._ , 0 / C,; - I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. DOC y I R ectitiinfda' Gr o C 1 � v. vvvt_e/t *AAAJJ4) y 1 A \ r t GrcLcP f r v ' L cirles S I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. eet."/SIXV '71 r I /11 ,1 Lkyri2J-e7r7 �JI k aormi /%(),,,, 1,49 -! r j;f c9400/tc&( 6/roar I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. / P `V ( 6104--,A JdE41,7-i rim /�Ca 2v }1)6254A14--- --/ 1 <N97 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us,purstfe a creative solution. NOP/1g ,I- aldi I 4 ...._, / g„.> .......- ,... ___.,_, ,,, ._, , , 4,„.4„,) . , -,,,,,,,z5,,,),, c,,,c„44Ade , c.. 5,/-0:4 f_._._____ .45 etig -ems ` ./% �'•sU��' A � ? 35zio.z7_ 0/1/( 5 ( 0-a i s-r& rEkar, ,eC.4 5 I( 13/ze. y 0 c-77-6c-e-L-___ tcr-- /eee .or9 3zi/o3,,, 14 /,/ c01/6-Cal:A 6' 9/. — c.);259:1- 3 V/0 a etrtc________-141___(2. -0 ________Z ti // . _ F e f MAN /6A1 06 i - yte7g 31/o3 L)5- illi 'OP , . - - g v/0� . WWI t . e 7,0w gy ( r ( 1 L/ ItLil 1tei?Lac Y,h e1 t Oco:COI - (f( ( `z_ ' 6 . _ , ��7� - a SZ�"7 3 (U/ ?-- i//�_ rG // rte. - 1-.< 11--i 1 1 ■ , c4;a,c2Loz,42e.)2.;0 a tc4w, e07-1.1 9/.4-3 :4 'ra /)/'GCS .�:9 zf. 7 X"" (-7 -//P Y 'a, , .S 42.y.,,P) aiN: .\►I)S-e i r4..cti lo,,Wot).co A\ 41 b4 AllrAA-4 .,%:.- A A kifiLlate.4 r 41° k U.,Z , I I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Skgit5 1 la "'j Skell aeh5ia @ OQh14) . rn.rn h co( CIY►'� (S"-4141 Jblid-brain to . cm?) MzeJTixy448( C� kAI .c�r1 b7RACIFS _• & J-r)rzes)2 E( �iJ�/1t2J Lvfr 7/10 / OK ILL' )//14Z-41 * // r PS 8,4, .4, j ei,Y11 , � mct ft i , 1 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. i/LC&C6\1\-/\ Alife 1 CAGS-bCe c4 kco.Givi i s ,v (De ktono L„) ® - '59-e, &AC aevt, ■c_a, z_ i ■ L E .„hk • MICL D-C -E)0i) • Lcarne V" " -CL.) \J3fQjS �.. I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. i ic11-1-1) j l&y r1\4 4112, ccal\(>c7._ 4 ( lcV c & IR. yew a ( 7.Z3? /d )/7Y f 1NY 1/4109 .9J2-19-0nkL dLee, 4 (2t9�O I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. --r (A)/s-C._; rs& cictuA_&. Cf f)-,7ti 1 k\eNkq\, . • \/))-) \ '2(644N,, c.. I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursua creative solution. kildffg 1I pul____.- "loot& xmo,,,e, Ail e g ,9°1-// .0 3 1. ..„ A/ . / , 4 1 N - 251/6/ ..1_,.. , -5 V/0 a 4Eirk _� / AWIT g: -.4c--%- le = - 0. " .rk ,.cs P.e. 4 ":' 6"e--\-'r` -.-. \i„,. c,,,,, (-1--tc'2 ') Mi r / ,, r / Writ" ' --.Y. ili)) A -0/(4-ckea0i 6/6t0/S - tt 5 -71 5e,4 —>/eJA J,.A41. j. DoetA„0,_ fiRio u! 1(:), • - 4 i 1 •I'16 l(,.t - ,c4,/ ,' Z", ,.e7 .L/4/I. .- LV \l i) "% ilf--c-,4--- 'k k 2 S G 11 --1-4. . c:,1 ,v---- _ ` l j '2_ e ,12 f . 90 D2. I/ I 'Mk 14 Al , NWifikaraft, ! . e " c, A 4 t rte / - lia/47 )4 e- 't IQfirYikMia -c&ICI-0(-. - 3WO (.( (129 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Wig 4 o_" Laurc*,_ cutionc, 2 ‘1163 —20( 1 <s 34/0 co/4- Pi:el I L3V/___,L0 ke-Le It/ ?ec(-/ d-y\e /ic, - t/p-c y/4„,„_, 4ga-Lai r k/L96 ho, '2' /Lr� ,• s 672 4614.K C!--- 1/i dyeka e - r 2 cam 3'110.3 1\rmstjtil COZ 4,4 , NAD I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or co promised. Let us pursue a creative solution. &\\, ° 3C)t)141-e z � C � cti 1 o 0‘07r Pulh 3L//os' 39105 441,4,6_ i!k4,7,11 3 /6 g t, -sr- l ® % � I D en $ �Ce Szi .3I I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. „ ic,...., ,_ _ CX-Ait,.., *IPA ,� An echo%c � fcw /4w' Mi_ • C3o ‘E )-1 i 7-v--sa.-- 3108 d 9,6_,L4,4-ut,44_,/ 3 Lt-i a a' Iir / __ Ii- )) 1-/ 1 / - f) lip , Cc7r -e.)-e---- JL(- ( tif. C--- dr .?V6,_c ,; r 6/06 � _ &' (Os.&(/\.)04-4--&(gt_ . --"1-11 ,2._ /t” a/Ix& --L-yi.e._, LJ II I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. • ry r ( t 'z- /\:Onann adti, (541k.3 Lip\ if, ,f � /- /? 4„,„4 .3 .//--? cuti&AA 6A1/012- 3 VL13. Vtror- & &i1C X1.3 *Pipa.A,0 iris 1-1)irr 471 Aga-, j 911)- rAI L 33 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Ne-a,[ e -V,047-(4, 3) ( J •' 676 0- 35z/a3 c I 3 e //o 3 1, v Ar. - 10D, 3L/ I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. d Cc,re v,\,ov,e`r-- t 6)44A-/At >h. 34/ 0 t4 ‘34 , 05 4,g)uieeiy ) • / /i A/1 t ;iZ7 tudait.a.- 6. aca00-7 Jef 0 ,or, 3 V? o z Aidir /4440(e/z, 3e-// O75 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the'Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let,us pursue a creative solution t 11)th I Me 1—Avo,.a.vfo G ‹p .0 o,� ct.t© 1 110 'rl_g_Am2,-.-1 :_z_,..ay;t:PIAL Co", 3<-1)4 _ , ?Air.jimagirmow,_,•• • to 'tc 6.sgptS L Oil II a Or— to � Tot). afrow4. &Lai 111144 d, (0 ( -- a1 c k e r 3q1 (-1, t . ` ' C tool Am- r 111 rh 3 11/40 - ZtOZ 9 113aeW lon)I>piled 4, I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solutiop. LdinO e,1 ')(pe------ --7 L'Aiit 1euac_.r1 1, c A-10 2A--- 3 4k 4 7 5 3 eL f�e,m p.II ,34-1/b- ---d aal 0)/4 4-a-vt) 3 ci>/. te-i , ,. M ( o2 411!_.L..10 . c-ilecti '/V'Cl- � 6a e 102 3/7 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. , y8 2' (1A0 341// ea roAA,C,&:-rov 6 1 (4 ( 02- '1P/IVICP/kggei 344/0 2- 441t 64-/t J- 12 3 0 coo 'Y,ejetALC J> � I I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compro iced. Let us pursue a creative solution. art. 2?:0p Ock 31°9 I � 39, 07 3 /O • (t- t -46 , , ILL ,/ i�is� . X?e,c ,A7/Z SUSNA b K.) e \AS 0 A (34 ( q. gq/03 39 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compro iced. Let us pursue a creative solution. , OM ft 49 id Nek.341408 J ccy) i _CPck y 3y / on /4 0(1V ;r- 111 Iffeft,/ile7 eTil ' 3 Y/Ya SAeg 4-1/144-4 - 3 'Hi 2, 4..,,d_et...y..) 41-10-c-----z_ 3 4 I c? a . , 3 r -2 ' -idea ,___..•10\ .. 0, -N "P , f 3 /a 0)--- /9p,- _....... 2/(17 -(c) L0 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compro . ised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 10/92e/ dale yad,,,,,Ltath 6 5,4co5 to,, 3 f a 4 -2/774/7/4/(_ 3 a 3 * / avvv‘—‘ 3 +- ie73 3 �%� z_ Li( I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. NOW-e, ko Ca it_ maw le /4,7,0 /04/4 3 Wo z_ 11itryk P,tfte 1— 3 (/ 3 /7) /W!ETTE a+; t 3y>o.3 Mar\l Com me r.s 3 5strv3 C 3 Li/ o8 L_` b(-4- kY2/- #010D141 -(\''\ 17=-----03141 o --- 34/ 0 2---- I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. tk\urt zap cek_ ' 6 &a 1'9\414-x4 6 1/ //0 g /11( 391 o 3 6,61 3 ` Io ‘-741A/Aggio 4ev-i) 34 02 t(3 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compro ised. Let us pursue a creative solution. I u)i/vet 341.10 • A a Zar/ i } JY/ 3 4/G a._ 34 „,. 12,,) -3v/a Cf-risfit. 40shA LL._ ) •5`2- # 11VR CIL() 63. (6 gieiv k35(fig 1.4 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Z:UP (bC. dr /, ....14. ..se.. ___...A...:..icAbillw 3 d, A 13(ketAf\'' 0(10.4., 00.-- 34 10 itILLF4 3 rte g' CT _ iii /i''' 0 ii, 3Y4(d 4 ' \ ; I, , liors i 340 2___. haithat iiii-otait: , 3 '/11 ‘7 ,10,pf 1-cigc-A&,/ 34/06 pel.a/Sd pi sb-lio , 4/2//2/"I 1 z 0723;2 -6P....5?? I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative soluti /din t t; tA 4,‘4‘ 3-f( oS f#110ii cfSvy tc-tx Amami. 3Y/D z. `//P 4-1c)S� ‘itiVh IAN' 31) 1 , (5 ��� Lis I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compro ised. Let us pursue a creative solution. I flit aLck 377..zo 1-cg /47 4/4/4t- ‘,53 Dal c. 3 C�� a RJ1 3`f/oc -70 J "l 0 4,01111;" /y✓,u #' 3 09/1/92 97 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 2 Wi r ,/'- `0e 3c-t ( 0 - 0a.-er- .1-1-L.CrehAiriNee 3 ur o 2 Wau//kizz r (9Q444-4 Alk . f.4-‘,94#, am/22.- 4Eg I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 54//oz..._ aciutA4 341i d e C j Vuezi7(*14-- 3 37 kj:Z.Y.L. -- -. s �..% ..._...�_........,s. �.mac __ ",►� _ ,1_t ,41 1I� 44414_ Te, c ,_sLtrtis/go, 0/ -40 angivi2 9.2 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. i € \'.- cc )t 3L1 / o,..3 Cls) — ) \---V-INN;1 • • ,% / atlei 3 V/03 / ,___A/ — .-)/b( c,kc.6---(__-, cgl-M3 j--).--\_ // 3q)0,3 3 hi '14, )29, ei,), -- c31-1-)O3 igcol 0)a,A_____ ____ 5 ,,O,s-- /Afyitii/d/--__ .5N J ......_ 4.-__./ d g(- ,,v 01_ ,,,2o--,-z -,P?Or-9 563 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. . 14- 3 Y 3 et CaL9-1 _Skek\lit jx- ZL-111(0 gezze-e7- XitOti ` 341 ( 9 diass �i� X4/1 7 e /0 '0(42qpi-fa 1?asiR 63 &/;41,,_ 4 -6-z, 3411 o1_4/ cget r I I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or._ compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. q; veoi 39 / 300X 3 WI 9 -_ _ _ ob- Q o2 f S //-o $ '41 3 4//o3 -1 "---" X77/ 3 WoIF Ant4ij .341IO fC��a2 L. 81 3047=5 3I-4C claa, 3 io Z. C-e0"&ar-11_, 6LAA_Qa.giz_ 3t-kto a-- i d r--'LkTs) 0 !� , FOB .31-104Z 3 Ail62- `1i , ' `3,'•/O$r Vo I Pow 3Lt ( v ? c,,roxii Pare- 3 L/l0 APA AO. rohern -1-, Ya/e.onr /51"AO 11,4917 I I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. ni_e zip ci d 6-e t�//,i3 yji\itt �, 3g(0 off° Scxa LA Nuirtuv 31f 36--- 00- . 44„ ? 4% 3 LP 0/nM, Is di .. V. I //1 ,1 , , /Y141/�I' , 19 'e -KA" ` I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or A compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. . ] J Tel: (239)434-8518 ..1,.1..(..... h�a (y 7 Y' S ` j rJ Fax: (239)434-8518 t() a�� �r! 2-Z Josephine A. 1\Z o�"� C� =-' e 7 QQ9g 5 it/(q 735 Southern Pines Drive •Napier, ,FL )j-Ut-- - ei 1 ‘ Ilf---- 3 j--1:}4- ;e//ge:j,lg � T Stepha nie Vii-„—j morseshj @aol.com 39- LvR 17-61&la__ z ill 2-c) ` Lott t Ftv (ci‘a ' i cr S, ______ P /7 jrelit LIAAldit 4- i o I ______ __________ kit(.1' kaAV-edidll 4. l61 Pi 'eft di/WA- c 3 4 CO 3 -------- A4.11 y C e- L t•Y. I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. • / alth A I 10-5 \c- -V ■.'S \'‘ 9//p, pa4L-Led■ 117/f/ r L. HOC ga4,10A1-0 ° I i I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. J1)( ‘ Na-7-0(;f S'M ail 5Wd Jess c G 1(hue\ler 34,\1 1 a-H- P vo71s-} 3 U 4 .1 tt$ ash Y1 1Pc ^3L-114 7 S- osh Mue \ ei- 3L-41 ( 1 gur1- ; ,1 Aue \ ter 3 117 c1 t. Ai 3c1og j c2F- Pe() Gok) , Dg RT. 6r-R-07,c.)--/- -3q/ epg EttiG .: A_ R_o-vo- il '3 Lt 1 De I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. f Co ( 1-on � foL, c-c-i 0 3 11 ,_5 /1/63 Q � i / / scito 6f, k_ei ‘ W3 g4-RY 3 96/d 4b4H ( " I 37O(3 1Bee H cArk 33 'q © ,7 o‘n skork 339 ) Nairn --cre_v ■ynv 33 9 oe I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. co,a , ODA 1,44-1.A/ 'P'(-)C Aug)ke,,_ mr„, ii, ,,,„ , D0, 6d 70,,,,,/,, ,,_ 3(0 q Do o,,,,1 Muf'l' 3Lii( 1 NAT AA/ % 3`I l -5 eSYve. \A;\k ova 341114 4 / -4 Rey,Rois -39lo3 nuki4Oi Vu cis,o to ?,/I ic), -- -, d i 3 /o3 i... • • 3L\ \03 ,1-010.mil, q_ I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 6LJtL !Jh (Se 3416 3 \f' -til ituiL, asst 3 X163 C1J LaLck No 04, 5 ) 4-0 $ rrtit, vi use C' ._.-vv_ci_( a.te./ .1 t). : ._- tr,„42 te i 3 4- = - .4.-cataa,Irsirlagbill AIS_r/ .4.-.-/Alili 11,41.1./t■ \,__, 177/°3 j eiL-V-144 11144--A DIA 3 4/ 0.1r- I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Arne__ Pi-(a 1G Z (P ec) V-70 ff7 ai'f6 0()' 11---1-11-"9P CP/0) fu3 y ys--- 411A4 17(-euftlAA10 c‘.--zfu) E' 3 4 4. 5 3 4 -tjj (psi L.“- S uts ` e /vlo"re �� �' � C I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 1\bsiML if1C r Z ( tom cobsU ;W P„e) thilet, q- 4S ' el/4 403 my- -77.5'- 7 .,zi (),(4y/Atia_i 35 6/ Ago? ,2174:/05" Fit< SY e / �Z G /- 1 .�-.... c//v 7--- ,3L ) _ f i / 11 41/1/�, ���- -23 . .3 q, /27a/-7 - / C2OO 8 3 We)3 -- 3y /0Z • I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. �3 L 171 066 --q5� -2)6 7 3401 3 &cvx, 630 72 7 - S-7_-? � `f 4,1 Atvi7) a-)6164 .a(-7 _ Q ven adryif 5410 .3_ / 9Y5 jet77-/ .`„,2-) ,14 Qs to,, 3t//v 8 , / S7.(5.V- e 331 C65 0 -3501 4/kotitO - c 9 -4 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. \ �� , 341°z 7 77 - d(-0 7 6s-lea `3 yi© �� 7O 7/ 3_3 ig - 3 Y- ` _ 7 A _ 71;6 46k Ad 3 0.7(3 /s 6o/d /Ire., 2t)' J/V�y.� /'/55 OPP I I / k �� ' - 5 r 333 e I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. n1AvrkL Ztp Co 01` I--A-ct-s- S y oa.0 FictALS 215- 9'4<‘-- 55Q Z (//A : .4 Iv 4' PV/'Y-9r/P7 _ 3.3 �U " dieL0e, < D17/1/A41 39 -a 3 ) -R3).44 3410 3 Li( 0`� '61 Gjy„ , 3LtI03 . 0.41 ‘vytAdtem,-.. 10 kw/6e I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. GC ���ao y� .1Z1 3,'3-z 3 -/ar37 ii-.s-15---- fl c-3?— 36a — liG zP ci<f_�1> /g-, ,4 .23 -•75=27 i/-2 7 3 •, .9 7/7euett_i. 0.2.."..4.7.,2„ ?z-tis-- ,01,- ,/,.,,, Ki_e4•3/ • 3 y1/ piAl)f), S.c(za,6 33 d4 $ e, L( 4 ( 4 , e ,,12- 9. Lc ► 6,..___„_,Ii_ko , .S` 31- ( 05 , ,,,r__,_,.; (24,,,./d"-e___, ‘ 3,Vi c I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a. creative solution. . K dit />- , I il � - 1 a+4airi 34-L---- -Pcuert ('1, ,�� Tom- 0 4/o ,a bir .k 1k e-C LIA-e d e b c— -j .n .nd 3i)«z Va K fIpc,u e, ( I 0 1 c_ i ro L rye ue I (@ emio r -vrY;i Latil E`i I d 9 ..,4„, / if Iii.....4,. 34-/G ( C '4w I V:2(V 1' -=__,,y 4-‘c . , -- , 6- . hio2 . i _1 i?ussi ry 6- - N Ucs j ili CO alp 1x.4',14 3'H i 2_ Ferh ---blef f _t _- r3"P') agiAl-LALL rte4- ;-lig 5' $4/og. . Y bitat 0. , / 3 /0,2_, Lt4Y) .4/ 1 / i , a Al it / / . 4 - I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge'at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or tat; 4 compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. . ,Odit J 6111 EML£ ec. G ES A-L 5z/c /16 r D f Il n (@ n o a(6 -6 ) co/ti ( 3 I36c excAL, Lbutz l( g C�19C1� /4,3, /TTY SrQJp r2 nra7 i /G�/r/,q �/f�Pti$ 7`c 3 // 7(Gco n/.e- Src 0., ,41 S 741 A 3 / 1 '7 JACO,: 0-, 42J\,)11' 11 zi\pr-tx c_A% • 3 4t-( 8 s an YVl LF'8' r4tA 00 r co /qa- ' y ytilloo•com g41.105" :A , !� / - - / j / Ti- 3 /o 137 'h FL 3/11 491. Aitra_t/ii (Aries- 2i? 9/6" , aa,.c-#04,-e 4%a j% 3 p 2 4 ife,„ Ade ( L( 3 ce..62.ez„ / / I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pur ue a creative solution. .0117) Z4ç "Ii, 6e5p_.794E P�= L2 /C cc, avt „ c94--1.1 l oz-- _ ' ' 3411©.3 __._ . . �., CY, 10.4 tE1QAOLz e `3 / 0z i ! / ._ -2 l of U v 2 4 ,hl f 3`F?--3-z_. e_o, Li2 ,,,e' , -.,./ 2----ite 0- '"--' 3 V l 0 .2— '11b. / e+-----. iserzeldi ad'.c evrk Aar# ,_ -r-Al OD- I( I f q it w<<` I w(fpf 4 - 3 414 * -- - -- 7',;(...;,_. - r/9#,7 --/e)"c-itie-- ' f-e$St/di lifi ler'th r At ,,lirMr■----L' L "I '41J Irmo"' Nip, _ / eibk. 71-Ike . S. W LAS I Air. . >> -Ave ir/ 1-‘3 a"j¢r . /V 44;b0,6-5, FL ..# 1/.0A..., • C...._.7f.,/,.! aew--x..."-4.....-4_. 6?".45- r-l-ere-e---ev:_44gt- D-)alt-geAt,-.)-(Xl eill-my 14/ I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. 5 3 `r -69 0714gG .-- 31/itoi 3 'Po s 7 r n 6 (acuLL. L 30' 10'1 f)611/Q, rem 6a)19, I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that ,hould not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue.:a creative solution. k -P6rr h 3'1 I Ici ICj?cry;,:,\Ae j ill(0 .e 11) (. t 0 t Q Li l6 P--,,)0.1 (A6czec 6 (0. i a), C« roc (i \ [3 r ok gji-o+t,<:\n CY Q )/(t 'i jam. \ tki (1°1 ck14 12"1Z--L IC ?7 ( 1(I 6.--)(..,J 3t// ) C7 alit I 2 / ilk , Leard\o ' -- N(In Q. ,c) ''''- at---c\vroa--- `c- c)i . Cex 34 )v` I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. /VA ME. 7.1 r LODE e it_ s • I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. NAM L-- -Zi CCU.D E L Writ_ te macc�� �11 33q 1 (u c c a1n wk y� 339 ?' Y { c AAA RP\Ji A 339 1 9 pct A:rp c3Itad..cc, --3`f 3L gET.t Y C`ufrl9 m� (:,) 0 n n Lkeze Li 9 ---7c.9 C4 C I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. NVML 7AP L-D - aMA1L )7)4 /►_Li C `, f)' ea.nikr1 ell-P-e 11 ler 3 (it),5- gnic.a. cal& 4, 0 ( LIA--C7u4_1- iza 7) 3/6.7 heseia(tco. c TIc \)e T\ 0.- e s 3 3 cici I c-141,ci �C :2_,, -;--43 ci`'� Ck r I , fl hc-� _ Sc�� ,7 � ►j� Icky --S • k 2- QJ r trt1 X4RY,,z4, Z6 -,z4:, vd9 V 'le S ,/,_539c/7 6:1- /fd(:- (-c-2--v, 6,a....-t,_42 "„("6. J--> /' ,..i' S---" z Ailli. ', 73/4)3- i...-7,,‘ ..,t/I C _/ 1 I LOCN t `\ ''' .1 1 i'''1 . „fit -NJ). , Isk- ,s, 1, .1k, ( > 1 I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. NAM L 74 0 COD t=A%1 I L 1( tt sse ( i HI, I ic,. 4 ,N'N't,•:\ ,e ‘ 1 )0, 3,. vks1 i -; 4 /C r if Ej i lafiCerraZet 1 33S IZ - VNCS S3C1 0 LA a2. F VoIlAi tr ) iie Kc,-v► e Parf ' Slil 33101 Vi . i‘ Li C. Y fi" 2 \\ I strongly support the preservation of the ponds and bridge at the entrance to the Naples Zoo. These are icons of our community that should not be destroyed or compromised. Let us pursue a creative solution. Iv,A-M E Z i r CcD E l_:!4 4 i L i -L s L(L 0 �v'�C2.(s`\.v�&c;: cc o C r i Le' . k- x r k \j I I L--)4 i \I I\I \CCA 1CQ ..-.) ' 1 , ,< / I ACt LL(� ( �: C' <8� e I k. :3)(// , Jc((� i 0A ,: `,4,; ,l U j. I Vk 1\ , . , ),(1f `i )< )'I( V' 1_ ►\') (fi Ad a\X k\ \a(4"11 LA Dom, IVeNr 33 r(1 (,.2 (I- --, >k, c, , ) • ktt,_ vt-Rgoiwr ScHlo vx,64 341il° r4,0/-71176) 4,1p ji kAtif000 cc)1 oloarmd (74+1 QII-Ag 41/ 11C1172 QkH OWT1--0‘ r$ 7740 TTEI 3z -0•74-tx rAl7c‘74. --( 0 r0 M z > 3 a GI m ^ m z F- m Z C p Lnon a r � rn > z ° z II a m m rnrn � v ~ 3 m o � 0 0 ° �\ • -I 1"17 0 D• D zD m XI 3 rn z r 1'' O 0 Xzrn i 4 " H -1 I � F< O t t- m m -I O o � c� -I m n = 000 > Vij rn w 1:13 .i n _,C° ( 1- rzw r Z x > f 7 rn m 4 9 a' p ,. 7:11 rn rn 0 rn D ozo° v a z 3 = zD cn =. -I 3 rn� z cD m Z CO 3 00 -I oD -I N , C 0 ° cD al: (D a CO) o o z 3HN a = G p c D p CI, .'i �. 0 3 m v' rn o CD � N D ° H Ti 0 z -Io 7v p'r' p 0 � , cD p G rnD _ C 3 _1 m � x1rn - �, 'o in r A C -< D H --I ��' ni Ca _ -IrnD-- �. 3 I * < A m rnpD O -i = 71xI-A" rn 0 p N 0 Z m W 'OG G) n � I o -I c M �O. G 73 MI rt 0 I 010 r -a a GI m m arm m Z m la n p � Wxm XI -, a z r GI 3 p zoo - J 1 v r1'1 r m cnrn � 'a ' 3 m m r 1-1 :-• z (D Go G N rn > ; 2 ��} F rn m n o p m 0 m -I m �\ 3 rn - z " �. O 0 70 zm H z -1 * > z Z -I 2 1F<< 2 `j mei 2 1ry n m m el2pO r Z rnWW M 3 rnzw \r 1•4 X > Ail >I mr" 2 7C D (J) C 0 � 3 0 IN -1 < rn _ p r m m rn r. I O co ruT11 0 2 m v a C Dcx m J u' n --goo cn n z 3 = D V n -I 3 rn� z m i rn co ca pi o -zi ° -1N m tin 0 ,q z °o . , ray. 0 o z 3 -Ic = � 3z O .5 0) 0 m Nm � M 3 -i Duo � ► rt O z -I 70 a off " fD (D 0 o rno� _ 3 _1 m � � rn �i O � o �A co y* -1 (n (n . 'a �F A. C _1 70 2 D \ _ La 2 = H56I- x cn m 00 = Z " Orn co 0 C) O ~ co = m N a. a(0 0 3D0 -0 > m m /'\ A W m O Z r 1- m ,rn z `� 3 -ai -ml r � rn � M 77. v m M rn _ _ � O O N rnDX =r r n5N 0 m —1 G� z =--�` m •� � z D ai xi z � I� 3 -1 rnzn 1 H 0 0 ADZ $.1.) 0 m m rN O a � rn W w 2 el ,71 03 r rnz:,' m c� i 1-1 x ,, c m o X 3 -n rn < z m _ M o� ° a u m v 0 � z0 v° A I- > o E z 0 = zD 4' -I 3 rn� z V m m W W m co —1 DAN 12 0 ° O m lY 7o > z Ol o cfl v ,_,I- U1 CL Xi > D O 73 /- _ .0°3 n N (D D m o ' V H 0 Z ,_,-.1 V 7 fD r"1' xi > °o 0 v °� a-i m n70- rn 0 A '° � a: m Z ° zm (\ n rnG7 � C -rG D -I- -I sir Li 2 � rn D _ �2 ----- -r AM m rn 6 > -J� ---� 0 -1 = 71 r / 7C m N ° 0 0 in Z 70 OT W I rn Oc -in _ a z n/► t2 v �, CD n 3D0 -°tD 3 a 3 > m m m ‹ �r � y m 0 , '� n p Hrn a r a rnz (_____m -m a v x 3m F z N P' 77 . 111 C 3 rnD ri w GI _ rn GI 0 C m v) z z 3 3 v - . z 1 o 0 � zrn N - -1 = � � P Z m m -IOo A aCc_00 ^ r" oo `J r- - Nrn z,W 2 rn � u>rn 70 (� rn = = p mcrnnp m< rn D� oo a `� D 0 X � a � n D0 (c � n -i 3 rn � z � �, CO -I > -Ior' c3D 0 � �vzo N rt CD oZ 3 -10 ,r m a 73 a c3z O 0 m ,,,---1 - O :p D N •1 0 z --I °° N rt po a ooV cl CD n °o � c, 0 3 rn �° m x CD= p oz ?nu rn z EG v m D n m zor O J m co 0O z vi Z 'mi, Om 41 n ; x O (TA C M 0. 72 C . a r* n 3DOr 12 3 m m M ma m 3� rn rD m Z -< in m D 3 C 0mo -~I D rn > z0 „ m m m � rn � 3 m (n lb m r � z m D 3 rny � (` --/ rn O G) ~ z 0 m , 13 3 D rn0z x 0 0 � zrn H Z -1 * zz Z m m H 0 1 a •W � N ° N 1 m 3 m0D c 1'17 m Z T. (> � O C O < m \J Pa 0 to = n m En" 0 R X X O� W a D C � n -< a 0 o a n n c o m -1 G -1vz u j Z --1 z n -I 3 rn� z n x m 03 03 hi 3 a) m W z > - m 0 > ,-,73 o ° = (D C z 3 --1 0 ICI = a xi c3 o 'C m u) 0 :0 mN m su D ' o Oo ° ! F as a o .4 D rn >0 -1 m O � rn ( oc(nc 7'F m Z � zrn n r -rnv6-.) in D -I - W I -IrnD .r-� A m m p D 0 I _ 73 r (o � 71 - &-) r- m z d O. a in A 3DG .a > GI m n n G W rn n al rn a Z r 0 a z0C = v rn m 70 rnrnz 3 m hi m N f z_ -1 � O G 3 r" no _r r- rn .0 O \- m �'�;- O rn ( z 1 3 . 1 rn � n r_ Xz H rrl z = � zP Z -I � . t I - = W W ' \ A a co � n � u, f M 3 rn z:-A' \,^; ITI � � rn r Z D --II p rn m rn ∎_ .> I 1111 73 O� ° a D ' ' v° v 0 � z0 v a u' n LI oo rii O _1 ~ rn -1 3 rn- z - �.z W -I > H NO �� rn ■/� O (A ° zo ,)� C > c 3 > O —, %4 �• o m u' o ° c� N .t H z °-10 D a °' ' ! f' (D p 73 a rno C ET 3 -4 m Oxrn -1 O ( � I L, t .a m Z ° zrn c� rn0N n. r co 2 rnD ~" rn m rnW > rF. a ° p m ,.. s a Z x 0003 ° RI -i c 73 4 Z n', cfl a v at O = O (D > GI m /"` n F. - 3 m m m mFrn cD m Z -I n 0 � W � m y° Z ° v o -' o e9, G' RI m m rn ,�,i z c\ 3 M Ti --I r -' m M Z at D rn v 3 rnO rt zo = — m .v O m Nz X v -i GI z LTI Pa O 0 X zrn H z * z C Z M r N -I m = coc, c!. n 0. a , 1 Ei w rn �„ m3 rnz;`' c, m Z 7�CD (D1) ` a m m Xi X �_ co a u m 73 � v v C pn0 a n moo v 3 rnG) n I m Donn ,N m W -I > - ID 10 (D > > Z -I 6 cfl .= v 0 z � to 7o a c3z p r; O m Imo m a (D D 0 0 :1 ` Fem1 > z �. elm V _ (D m O rn v) r rn n G) v) .. a. -< D -I -I rnD�� = 3 --1 '1 r) 71 X I- I 7C Z 'w OTC .5 I GI O -1 _ m cQ a vfD n 3 > r .0 3 rn m 3_ rrn 7p m Z m ma n 0 Cnoorn m O Z r o O . mn a a 'CI rnXz m a m m � rn � - 3 m m a 3 rn > o C m O m ~ '-' z 0 � MO rA O O � z rn - • rn -I O0NO �j rn rn N n y rnWW co ... new Ci r r �. , nil m Z 7�CDD ' f`-V C 89 O Xi IN H < 2 7-- rn = ° r -n rn A_ x O� ° Dh-1ao 0 D o xn -� a ° o n HO0 E A Z 3 = zD n - 3 rn� z M m co W (") O c! xz °o m xl > 3H0 7-, a a z1- "I h -� C. O 73 rn3z �O '7a IN O m gym ° : . D ° N -o 0 z -Ic X P1' ^1'4 C rn D a _°; O P ° m m O J o A ( �� 'a 2- o ° zm CD rn Z rn G) GI n c D -1 -I - -I-ImD 1. 2 3 -I n m rnooD O . 1 x 1-_ 7, I- .. ° � = Z 70 T o W 'aa = O c a a rr fD 3:0 GI A-a 3 D O 73 3 m rn iv 3;- r7; a m z a r Q C 0 rn 0 rt G) 3 11 55 m x a z - c 3' C rn m rn rn rnrn 4 `, -3j m u) m 0 3 rn > O t m R1 O ~ z E '12 3 0 IH n - . \ X xiz V , f m m H 6 `� rn rn -� Oo a . mWw �. A.''' , V A W ..Wi C7 � � r r z w N rn m z 7scc> (D/� 1 > -, Oa3 t m < rn rn = O Z O Wro mc A >CJ c 0 rn ^ w H 0 U ca A z 3 = z > n -I 3 rn� z I. = m 00 con rn zDu m LO to -i o D O � zo _r 7o z 3 -I o to V > c1z O • o rn -0 iii r cD 3 -i Doo H O z -I 9 �p rF > off " , m < (D N G xD � C O 0 m o. xi xi-4 (11 - rn A ni tt I 0 m z ° zrn c .< x _ _ CU I m IT' w > Cse g Co 1-1 0p s Z TO 0 ``� G) n m z � a a to C rt A 3 D O 3 m m m �!- '�' m m 2 O � rn � a 3 v zoo n v fl' -vi m m v�irrnrrn � �v • 3 m ��w —I N ;. z O rt v 3 rn D x 2; c M o m G � z m G' 'p 3 v rn �z -I z n rn = m = 0o 0 /• a al W w • n Go n I4 cn �` , rb r w M (� ^ l z 7T. Dcan C OC3 U IV X 0 cn 0 o WMo ° c m D oo< ...0...0 p -< z 0 C D c x m N 0 _1 0 z � n Z � zz -,' —I 3 rn� Z n m Z Oc, N r 3 0 p0 -I D - 0 O Cl) oz o° C> p 72 > 3HQ co 0 0 (11 7o > c3z O O 70 rn 0 s 1■ m 3 m (n o rn N t F�1• 15 0 z -I 9 m al x a ooV o CD s o rno- i ig 3 pa 73 80070 A Q o N� ,, (I) '0 n. 1- -0 a; H D -1 - I M m m p0 > c n oa o m CO ' o5 0 M 7o O CO V O n� 2 a zN � � C. v0 o. n 3DG -0 > m m /1 m 3rrn 3 m Z ( O V) rn a r 3 a zp0 L D GI M m m m m 73rn _, `\ 3 -al a 3 mDx rt ` r M -n m G7 ~ z = � m Ti 73 v --iG) D 7 3 m n xiz z _ p Z = m _ M = r N a � rnvp0ow ` W CI - w �► `' r ih4 x > c\,.., :_:‘,. M -1-1 Oa3> p ..'• m < M O = m Z O rnr �- m 7. D. co G -. `/ - •O0 Ono p a C D c X m (i) n -i c 1 0 ) (1) -'-';''ei; m rn ,11 to GO -1 D - IN fD O z °o ,�_r, al xi > 3 O-I o (,--, 'gyp �� --1 a. 3 z .0 hil O m Arno m :- I.1 15 > ° rim G -I9 w a o 4 (D O G rnD � % . 70 m Oprn 0 0 �A -I 'o 0 ii m Z° �m n, 6 -4 D -I no -I = D W -I -In " m m m p D O q _ 71 7o r (n ZOT CO 'O O - _CO r" a a � v Pp n 3 > r 3 m m •■\ m 3 r- Z n p v) r � m y Z r O C OToo 'F", GI �rn j v p3 > rn C z to S. m a 0o te. -1 rn G rn 00 a \ m O -1 G ~ z 1- rn mp -1 xi zn D a Z I � � o I m = r- N Cn\ ''- ll \\ r rn9W W r z, n1 rn N � G� D r m Z 7C D El m 0 93 VN ■ XI m rn _ 73 o ,°c a u m CI 0 7) z ° O ono 0 I on H 0 z -I 3 rrnn- z m m z 0cm a 3 00 -I D --Io ( 0 a o ° D> o = z 3 -I 0 o ' 1( O › C O Z f Q. O M � rrnn N� m �p z H .p O O-i0 ,; xi a o C al 700 ° m 0- -I m O m (� 1* O u, 0 ul c tiNts 2 0 Ozrn A� ' m Z Di rn cn � •_. ., m I 3 -1 rn W I 71xI- In• Cu ra., 0 p Z Fi Z 70 Orn coo o n -‹ I O H co D re n 3rDO •° 3 m 3 CD > m op m -< ;51 ( m 0 F 3 zoo 0 I'll m m � rn � 3 m -1 r a 3 rny ° E I rn -n• m 6-) G") = m ' 2 3 a rn . z - ,� � zm 1-1 ? _ � o i N Z m rn = r- N . - a rn5w N n W u I-- z,--, N yy `V Z D V) 4 9 093 1 oi m rn xi 0 m rn 0 -I 0 ooVrnim 2 m -< D 1-x-1 00 a `� c � z � 0 o opo • C Dcx m n -+ o0 in n z 3 = z > n -I 3 rn z J m to 00 -zI > -I NJ L. c3D O ozo 0 m 3. > O � = 72 z z -I o to a G z � "' ( ) -I �.ci.o > m3z = `), 'moo Cii 0 m mrn 0 CD 1•4 :: X O z -Io ' rt M > ooV _m (D O CI rn 0 70 70 p 0 rn O t o VA -I cncn1-e M• Z ozrn cn r -0 Z_ ai -< > H- �. CO -Irrnn > m m m -1 n on 0 ri m a 0 o R` vvi z z OT OWo (-a m zu) NI Q a C a CD O = O m > O rn n m �rrn c) m z v o c OTo r '�' O RI o r∎ v -I r- z O rt M 3 r- im RI r rn m~ =O a -I0z a z M O 0 Xzm S. c ~ 2 ..I * zz c Z z 72 _ ,_ ° —I m m OD -I m r rnO ‘i�a W Oo � lt Zw I rn m 3 G .' •� D I- 2 7C D cn 1 m X � u_ o ° a m Dz � a n O ono u) n � o0 u) Z 3 = zy -�' Z M Z M m Z Ocm GA Z co -1 DHrJ m (� o o CD 72 > 3 ° 0 IM = v rUl "Cl cu Z m cn ° ° r� J D o H c 0 0P FDP ° n °� 0 3 -I m O ,7° rn 0 'C y L° U rn Z ° z rn n rn G) � BT Ca ..I --IIr=nT 2 3 -1 CO a ° 3 _ y m 0 c Z -n W = O H co m a o. a r+ n O O -0 > m rn ma m F-: rn Z ( m v r n 0 u") RI' J a Z 3 v o00 = 1 v 177 mxz 3 -a -I m 73rn � v m m r � � 0 rt 177 m � v 3 m D x = r q 1 rn -1 G� 0 p m L-._, O m v, zz 73 v -1 G) z 1 0 0 73 z m '' ft H z —1 * zz G Z xi m ,_ p m rn H o^ o -I rnw ° - A a w co .Wi n -< cn ' i. -7 Q l r rnz'-A' ■ , ., z 70 > rn 49093F 1 O m � < m 73 'n -n El r v -< > Z � °v 0 n D 0 p Z 0 —low n 3 = yD n_ -I= m woos al to m hi • cD 0 > - 0 °p C' 73 Z 3 -i 0 .0 m 7o a Can O �� 0 m rnrnO czp Ci CD 3 -I > O ;z ~ O z -1 0 °P K al O p rn o ..0. _ -I m o , m O m o 0zrn n--I f G� v, W _, x 2 D ........_• L. m3W -1 rn rn ta M w 0 0 O Z 70 Om w ?gm 12 I GI O c~J co m z U `r a. t v 1 rt 6 3Dr- -a 3 m m /'■ n 3 rr- 3 2 72 rn �' m y rn 0 t•D O PA a r 3 a zoo m y rn 73 mrnz 3 M r � � O et H M v 3 m > 7a = F rn 111 -n z 3 O m � - N XI '0 xzn e Z O-1 * > z 1 rn rN `' rn �r rn 00 a .. m co W n �o nzw r r ; z, -1 O a 3 ,e O (71 z -n ri > z � .fig `. 5 O ° n0 z 3 rnAz i n M m co co Pi O � � z0 ) Lt a 7v 3. Z 3 -10 to 0 � A- 72 › C3z O Fr; D m m N c H D ° v rt O z H D -A a xi > p s o rnoi _ 3 ,,.rn-I m p O p �� It 'a r -I m Z o z rn n -I rn > 'lib-I \ O nm m m co D m - ° O 0 152 61 n _ -1 cc Vv c m CI rt n 3yo -0 3 m m rn n m 3rrn co m Z 13 -.< rA rn (D p n O v) rnn 0 a z r C 0m8 = rn 3 > z0c 5 m p X p m rn z D IA m (I) m 1 � 3 m m w 'J p frt p 3 rnD70 r r rn O 'n '--' z m 12 Z D -Ic z 70 0 0 � z m H I 73 2rN L H o o - m = 000 a .a. rn 5/ w F— . �"� (-71 m 3 rn G -) rn r z X D > ni S CI 00 3 � X = o rnmm • o, ° a G u m D . co p CI 0 ono p ?d C Dc � m to n -1 ° o to n Z 0 = zD U' n -i• 3 rn � z O m n - rn m co -I o CI rt a a O a ° o Cz 3 -1c (4, .5ca = n. p z _ > c3 z O ; �� c C i m :O m Um : ry V ° ° 4 r•O z -Io • a pON m (1) A O A )D rn °70 73 Q ° rn O (n r A p q i M Z mzrn n iii G7 ni W -IrnD Z- m D A O W �= � � m O o w ° CO 1:1 z z m 61 z -1 c a v gm 0. t; n 3DG m tD 3 m m n 3r fD m z ri -< ( H O �� rn Q O � rnn a C prnR = rn II > m ° z m D a m 14 m tD m 1 Goo o m 0 0 m v, zz = (Z- 3 C rn .• z -0 ; z m 1■1 z i � zo k- L. \ Z mm HOo \ > T. 3. rn co °w V ' N l J a r oro , r- zW N z XD � G1 nii -I --i o M a m rn rim m rn r n m D � 0G . `� p -X a � n D C 0 Z H A 0 = zn 3 rn � z W -1 D -I N co at M > Z 3 0 O= H > C3z O 5 v CG tA ,, CD � 4 D Cli O m rnN -0 O z -1 J 70 rim m a pON in M O a rno� 1 _ 3 7I I p5rn _i m � x Cl) o c�0 CA -a r=i7 0 rnZrn n of r' �rn � �" C -< D -I --I 3 -I n "' zo > o -t- -1 _ 71 xr A rn N o0 Z Z 73 O7'1 W m C H c Z (n m m a a rt rn 3rrn m m C ovW � c� a z r rn n C zoc z � c m n m ^� � rnz m , 3 m -I r" � rn � m N O cr. a 3 rnDPo = F 117 o j' � ° ° ID m 73 m -`sic D ° ��. O 0 z rn H - z 2 70 2 m m 2ppc) r p A a w r" 11i 0 " 0 ' D r" 1- .. r- zw m z � D ( Or. r r'S > Z xi m < rn ri I- _ X O [TA ° a \ m -< D ' � 0 0 O 7 ( Na C DC � rn N C -1 o P, D LI A Z 3 m , > n 3 rn� z 0 cD X m co CO rn Z 0 C pi 00 can � �° A C 74 a 0 72 � 3z "0 D O m em ° cD :� 3 12 -I z --1 o n ~ 7o a °� 9 rt � C 0 rn ° � _ 3 c'a -1 m O7, rn � ° p V, o rn A m Z rnzrn I/ . a. rn G7 Cn ACO = 30D 13-7 m rn p D O -1 = 71xr m r 0 ia., ° p = 2 'w Orn W 0 I c c a (r) v rP n 3D � .� 3 m m /•\ m 3rrn a m Z r_ii mil 3 C Op0 C. A v rn > z c = m -mi � m � a C 3 m v 3 rnD ° 7 �► rn O di ~ z 0 m 0 G) z 0 G rn H -( _ 1 O = m = r- N C m m -1 O o CI a 4u rn 9,3 V1 - 1. I-1 x > ..\1.-- i, 3 1- z 1:. (r) ,), 10 C -1 D C m O < z I "1 I rn 0 -I 0 p,o G > u m a o o z 0 o 0 no u) n -Ioo x 72 m 3 rn0z n 3 cD I RI 03 co a --Ii > -10 cl'1 IC O � � zo 0 o Pa z 3 ° o m = a a o > -cizz r9. o %4 0. O m � rn � cD o Ti 3 C z -io G H 0 73 > o° �' = CD 73 P2 O rn O m p A CA i* -p (/f r -0 ��0 lei C D -IE .� -�IrnD n m rn p > O m 00 0 Z 70 0 C) n -< rn z � a a in X 3D � n 13 3 m rn n arm Z OO u-) 133 m a O 1- 3 a zoo s m 0° 171 m m 73 rn X) H 3 m m ° �3y rnyX rt. F rn O m G� ~ z = m 3 ° rn � -LI ? _ Oz `• -" �.1 Z Z m = 1-- N C m - V rn _9 ° (� n „ W N n r. r- z �a. pC, 1� r z D� Y� LTI m Crlow C Ozz 72 -f rn 0 Imil 2 O cocmno m< m Damao 0 `� a C 01- 79 x D c 0 m cn - 3 rnG, z n rn m z 0C - p c�3D to OD a-a D �D ,-,x 0 z 70 z 3 -I = 0 ° ° z ”' C 3 0 z -oioo :: C rt 0 xi xi a ooV vi M 73 72 � 0 rn " ? o o NA N (I) = O � � ?.110 �\ m Z z • F -v G� � CO -Ir=rnD '0 A m rn p D O .4 n zD � = H to ln m N 0 O 3' -I Z 70 OT CWO 'a 0 0 n (, zrn a M 11 t T D Pp M '< �. rn m m 0 O v) rn � a I- 3 > ° o ' s " v rn r- rnrnz �j 3 rn -DI r- Ora -I r � rn � -1 m a 3 rnyx Ft r rn O m ~ z =, m 12 3 ° rn � z � z � N � o z I 70 = r- tv (7) 1% mmi m m m a w Fri W °w �l 0 N n rro .. r z w (\ {� r �� I- z 7 n � �- m o o z N X m m rn c = o° v v m Dzco a `/ O O 0 O n a a n Dc0 rnn xi cn � o � z 3 rnez n m z pcm Il 3 o to 0o -1 a -1 o 0 � � zo a CD o = > z z -I0 S. P 0 0 z "' G › czz O -0 CU 0. 3 - Arno M ) ' v Imi 0 z c n-io Q f'F • > °� N CD O 0 m p- 3 73_1 m O70rn 73 0 m O Vrni`CO Vf M 0 � zrn n G7 V _ cn r- 'V C _1 70 2 = o� ■ m rI 3 00 - 0 rn '4 Z -z-1 x rr- 7C' m - 00 Z z ' o c '°v I GI O -I _ M a a M XI m 3O /'\Dr .a 3 m n n o � � ° rn m n Z 1� � mn = G7 c O O = rn 3 a z 0 c s• m CI O rt v 3 20 Dxi rt r rn T F, 11~ = ^n O m � z D1 � z " `.,. Pa G C 7:I2 rn ! > - H Z "i z z `,- = i Z -I _ � � o r- Z m i ,- N � ! t ' mumi m -I O o r', , r -• I m I W 0 v el n m C D�A ( D iVi _ 73 3� ° a ` M � °z• c - v a ° n ° Z I-I 0 = Z D l A Z -1 3 rn� z , ■ , D m m 3 c m _ �', 3 a a ° 0 -i 2 3 r o .. j a G cn ° �p c 3 ° `` c, 'C �. d ° m rnrn ° C, c∎ 3 -I y ° o � 2 H ▪ ° zoQ _ rr a °_ ° p rn °-- € r 3 r , (' 2 ) 0 m M ��, (t \\ ; O u) 0 (nC (' 't (C1 I Z ozrn � n r. m G) cn -c 2 _ _ —' 1 _ -I rn > A m m 3 D • 0 Z OT c 'moo v ai A 1:1 0100 c) a a) m 00•% m 1� rn m 3 z 2 To r� m n 0 � c , ( D 2 r O C OTO = N rn �/ m o -a v rte- rnrnz to a 3 rnD ° r F 171 v �� m - z 6'•O m ` 73 v -ii c n n h" • /i3 -I rn z N v ? = , o • o G\ Z m m= r- ,v-I 0 c) r 1‘1 el a ^ nl CO new r il 1111 m r' Z y cn -I 0 < 3 m rn m rn ^ o= 7o O a u, '.< > z � v o O p n p 0 o a u) n -Di0 � n n 0 _, z cn —Z1 3 rn � Z �. m 10 -I > - " a m cc C7 v z r "' O rn = �, Ho �- 0 m (f) r,iN CD `. 3 -1 y0p 11E4 'G 0 z -I VO rim 1121 73 xi v n 0, -I m 077rn 0 � o c ITS 4 'C ? T n v) �. X _ _ rn m >1-1 op S Z 70 OT CO GI n �'"� 0 � n a z VV a D rrt p I -rep, 11 A- . BILL Ali AJ O I ° N G 1+ I 1 tI Ti KI 1 I o 1 -1 4I 1 z Pi l i IA 1 kl 0 i .1). i ‘ ) 14-4 u 1 \ 1 . - o N 1 _ f- 4 - -- --- ii N� (T1 • 6 tJ r f II � J \ ci\ o III p • a z + - te X -1 I1 V' T ' -- r 1> 0 I � ► t+ �,1 , , r V ' i i ,,N z . ° % . 1 is ksol3 © o- Z N tf ill .1` x). fri . ' V ,J _Z fn l 4` N 111 Q J114 0 cL 'a z a m � O = >_ U O 0 0o O N N OJD a m MM 0 J Q z = t O a 2 W W W auJ = m TO I- I- < >-■ = CL ..1 U) ti LU C9 W Z W CI) ' N0 O = 0'w o 0C CA 0 = , N a ce 0 0 W °0 0oz 4 a NINAI U 0 N N ~ 1113 0. �'' z ~� O O azz a w Ln --I 0 0 c \ p� Q Q \NDO Z a m 4 U W m W = z W E I- V U) z � H O w `-� U) lir 0a I- U v) rt 001 0 i w ^ 0 mzQ 0 W Q QWm 10 1.. LL w. 0 > O Lu O 15�/ a tut W r,` a0W W Vimi ) J c, - w M N MmW a I . 7 O W W CO N J = IX I 1-¢ N tA z z O O IX ciii 1\. UW z W ri z O W O 0j 7 N LL W O ° w W W J y(Y) W ~ d r- v a W !J Lij lia C W C g D Z Q II u_ 0 0 el J Z 4 y m O rjj 0. I Z W cu Jam~ } U W W z L t■ 4.4 } 0 '0 z Q ur m (/ O 2 Q U O. o0 W W H -I 0 Q m i J Q z U H Q U-11- Hama.w U) U RI .w wzp Z 2 O. v) 0 H OYwc U) 0 Q CC •` ce o I- z 0 a 1■1 Ni w cn W O 0 < sD a 1°rL = an Z a CU 0 X \ p Z p al f al Np0 Z m Q d U m m W = Z W Z I". i Z Z Z W 1801- U V) OL oo _ I-I U �1 \, Q m 1-"I < W O wwC W 0 H Z G ~ LU 0 LLI Q6o a u) < Z W ILI} M U v om ■., I-= 11 (Ni O 0 H W W ■ J Z OZ I— 1— Q Z H ' W Z ce 0 O si)CL 2 Z '5 0 W O W O U W N W O W a zi J Q D FW- � _ = 0z a a W f J 0 a I a owo o 0 Z W ��-, W Lin' Q Z Q < CC oc u a. Di 4 CC 3 v) z W m � O = >- u 0 03 LL Z O m O N H 9 0 4 m 22 \ J a H = H \,, � mW 2 n ..1,,,1 )i W U) •V V) 0 W z W W z 0 O ~• � �4 a , � cyce LU O w W O LU F- a) fr4 1 1_ <cz 0 re a I■11 _ `, L' N < I- 2 - o fa a� s 2 W re 0 >. * O QED 4 12 F- � Iz p C C c� 0 H Z Z Q W N F Q Z m U m O W = a :ii: Qom= g z U) zzH 0 i-i r in Q p O H U ul G O , VA G 0 m -‹> - W a 1 oww 0 i- Q LI- IL > 12 Is L Cie Q Cn < W Q z � W pi k4 ILI T U M m V �� \ om = u- Fa•• N OO 1 cd W Z ZQ F- Z U z c 0 0 et a) ¢ Ov 0 re 6 W Ow \� W O � C3W „� LPL W H E , J W - ILI 114 i&. W W W al a Q 0 h ZOz a E. OO = U Z w m (n 0 J G O. W I_ J J W `� W W Q 0 020 5 5 4 z a c� cn c� a CI 3 > r '0 > roman m ND n p Hoorn A m 0 z r o > zoc = � m v GI ni m -m-I m z 7 '<.l -I m tn M NI a 3 XDX rt r m nn ° o ` m 0 m �jzz = / \ xj 3 v rn � z n /� - 0 0 , zrn H 2 _ � o �' z IA ■Il rn rn -1 m 2 W O n rn CO W 'm Z 73 > m `. 0 o m 70 = � o r = 0 a m "< rn D. ao 0 t `/ D X z -‹ 0 D C > c � m VI n -1 v ° cn n 2 3 = zy = 3 rn nz m rTI 01 CO Pi 00 -I > -I N cC (Q 0 ,xzO° rt CD X > 3 -I0 1p = 0 � 3z .0 ai CL 0 m v) rn " M :� 1 3 0 z -I °o H 0 a ° O N cn CD w x° Box -I m � xi rn 0 U) Q � U) m m 0 rnzrn n, 1- -0 -C > -I �_ co 00 -1rn > Li = 3 m rn el n m � p s \ Z 70 OT W = O -I a (I) m al a re o = o X Z a 3 n 3pF M° 3 m GI m /1 m � :_ 1 y m 0 4 'v n 0 cn p0 a Z r 3 a z o ° 3 �\ m y R1 O- m � z � 1 m m •N O rt ► -1 nil 3 m _r' m 0 -NIG) z \ TI 3 "I z ` , X cto m m= ,- ry -I n a w r=nmw° s� (`V Oro .. mz.w . � r m z � D � ►. -1 0 � 3 m � < m O X m rn ■ � ► '" m > z 00 • u ~ 0 D c o m no Hoo in ■ n z 3 rn 7 z n m z 0 c m 3 0 00 u) „ O \ �p a �D O• a oo � '*• 70 Z 3 —I o f s A z � "' to -4 0 0 CI. C- 7o y c3z O Om r"rnc EU 3-i Doo n Et r. ▪ O z --1 O !"f co 0 0 m X > 5, E. 3 70 70 0 p rn 44. h 'C3 m▪ 0 °rnGI vrni n O c -< D -1 A. 0' --IIrnD .--• N Li 2 A 3 H k m co N w O O s ' 7v o w 'a 71 CO I O -I C a ICI 0 0 i S ono m a GI m A 3Fm m Z InWi a Z r a° 71 g A z0c 3 " rn M gi 2 Ni � � a m rn �p � z C 1 tj z a O O 73Zrn cr s\-- z z_, 1 0 ( r Iv M m = W00 �� p n mwW W v CI � w I P z mxG Z N in �,M11 M am ° a v v vno 7°v Nv n -1io (n n�3z o A rt o 73z ° CI a fl Tao Z 306 I-, to On 7vo a Zan g 1 to z ' 3- I > D ° - II r Q al 0 °v mn . ° 3 v Pi 41,1 O m v r"'o r' cn 1* O N � 14 ft m mo -i CCD CO v A n m D F N, , DI C7 Z ,'0 0 0 rt 0 � N G n I p 0 co z o. v r `° re. n 3D � > m m rn ND /'1 m 3!— rn al 2 N O C pmp g N G) rn 3 a z0c m p ''" m � z � '� 3 m (1) m c rn v 3 r.,, D 7a r=r. rrn p ( ' ' z = XI D 3 -0 rntz - zm W N o 0 gzz c' , )t1 Z _ mX _ moo ! C b ' -u —I m = W ° '' ■�� ∎ n a (4 meow Z co ..Wi r) ‹ cn m 3 r0W 1 rn r ~ 770DCDn , , A Gm O _ rn v lb� -11 G rn . rn co [11 p i go z -� p O u) n - o0 ce -. _;:- n Z 0 Hzz �► sn 1. -1 3 rn- z n z a) = m co 0o rn G --I D -I NO UM to 0z o --4 = s .p 72 2 3 -I 0 ■ IC p . a c3z D O . O rnp ( al CU m � N z oo n C P X > p O rF' ' m N ! rn O U)-1 o (j1 12 = 0 0Zr�n . n m Z "0 'c u ai 6 -< D -I - I 1, co 4.-. m 3WH ni A zD � 0 CD N ° O F� p Z p OTC r m GI c -I co m z 0 tD A 3D0 3 GI m — 3 r 71 m Z N 1 2 0 �� rn A O 0rnn 3 a C r > O -n0 = ') ern! ni m r vz4 1 � ' 3 m r,t III I-+ O _r rn 0 X rn D X rt ■ r m � = m O '-' z 3 0 rn � z O 0 xzrn . H --I = o C Z �' _ = 73 = i- N m m = Oo t— ' el � = WO r a rnooW r W i- cn 6- m 3 rn z:"' r- Si; I- Z XCDiD m fj 9 0 9 3 V 7a O m < m -I 0 rn rill rn A Dc m --I o N 0 o 0 .. c, -1 3 r=n� z n m CO -I 0cm 3 iCi xi z 3 -1 b Ul to = o � 3z ° -0 0) O m o m :: 3 -I yoo n H _1 m O A rn �; -1 0cnc m Z 0zrrnn �' n G1 cn 70 _ _ co m m z W rn m > ° O c) � C_r O m .Z ' O O W m z � a P 0 to I k-G,'nll G J0ne 212_ .. 4 S ti i fig?{ y A Ste•k ` ! k. . . ., . f, ,.,.. . . .„ :,:: .. .. . • ......... . ... . .. .. :. ,.‘ _ „.. .. , „ .. _ _,_, ....,,.. „i , ..,,„,, , .. ...,. 4 V{ -NJ z->1LLfi � AGtr �E/+CHMaof� i-4KEA) / L// .0 2 - wf- i4e4/1 1 IC 2ie 20(2- Joric -/ "ijo... , ..-.'-;! , . ..•.... tt 41,06 411. ilt, At ', , - , i.,..?. ..,,,,,, ,.„ .,,,,. ,._,, it lit• voiNitirt ;' ■,A, 1.. ;14; .4 , . ' ' 44 , . c.--, IP . 40.= ' ,. p,'4.Alci.,4,„ . ' :1 c., , "..-• .:. .,. . , '-: - - .. ...* ' ..' .,-..... . lip""1:. • kr,,,,,:,. , -, -- • ---,....: ri -It, ",.■• ' . ..: A,...) .4 . . ..„- ••• 4,4 t - ... . . ._ .. . 1 ili,";:c..'-,•,''',-' 1-',=-II44r,WON'i."''','.4.,■--,, .' - -, ' -*: .' .!.. '—' "-• ""4- ' ' "•°' ' ' • VC) 7 - 4-,, • ,..:,..._ 4, ....• -... . ,-.,_.•.. .. _, . .... ...-. . 4 7 ;....,. 0:-.4.. .„ .., . Am. . , ..tf... -,.4.' .„ .. . . . . , . 4:(ci - •, , .4*' ° •-- - , . 46? -- ,,. . ...... 4 Afit ,10 ti: . . •0,,,,..-,,, .,,....i '' - 4 C2 -Pair. •_*. ...040,-..., .., r .. ,. ., . , . , .... . , . ..... . ...... ,.,. . , .. „ . I . 7K. ,...' . . ... ra ,,,, .... ..4. e, ,. . . ' 0 Y al 44 - , d' •..4 • . _•- ,,,, . - :-'• 7',''''''.• '-' '-'dft'4"4,14-41441" - °'''' , .-3 p , '. ' '° ,°.,:'!'-''''''',504'';••1'.°." tr' 44''''`O.,,Z:4"' -'4,- 1 4. , •I'- 4-*ti-ii4,4V 411%4, .' •-• -ii,. •; 0 li ,. - ,.... (Z4) • - . -:' -f ',*47 ,-- . ..,..,...i#, ,,.,A, ; „..- ., ,, , 4. ..- . , :.,. -f-- . . , ,4 rr1 .. , • . . ,„7 4, , 4 • ''','• ''' ',;tr..3tV 4„':.4,i4 J.,..:*$4,Wrt.4.1...x _.s...''' ; ,Ii0 .,',..' . ... .4 . T 4., -. • . P -i . - - " ,• ',...- 1 . ;.- ..., I 4 0 . -'-",,141' '',,,t,i,.'..,(,,,','''' - -- - —', • , I ' ."-IA.Ipook • ' ' — 4 • '9■ ";41.74:1°... ...to.*,* - ' k. , ..., . ,i. 4 . .. . . ,. ,.., . . N . ,.. ...„ .. , 2 , , , ..... . ' • . _. .. - - /0/2 June.- 2&,,,, •40, I' ' " / . , 9 , ,; t //;0,..4',.; , ■ f';',7:,:e...:-"''.4-r;:,-;5 :, ' •.'. ..-",-..--„,,,,,...-„;:"-I',-,,:',-,:i. - ...-4:,::::-44:-"CY,Ie•,*,,--;''': . ,, :',,,, 't'.. V . , _ „ ,-....„-,-, =. 4Tell •kt...„7.--r---,.-:-:: /,',/ ,,,,,..•_ :. - vilk.• ,: -.,'Vz . -....,. - .-4 .T■...) . •.,,":"'" '-'-',..;..',7-'-,.--'.-L' .,.' ..., -2 IP „ .. , . N ..... k .;. -- . ...4 r— `,■4, .. ...:..' \:■.A\ , . '''' &.■ '.....-....... 1.1 ■■- ■>_ ■....'' '.. ...'. ....P. .. 1 , , - --•::; ' --' '''-----1-4,--- '' • i -1.-` 1' ,.••: , 11-`. . • . , , .. t -:A‘-;---... _,....0--•!,-._-- 4 — ' •--- -- - -' .C,---s..\''", Zj - ' _.: ; - .■''-4. .1•' *ilk S 11 , -,i,i.. ..: .......: ....-_-. .. . 4 r, • • 4. _ ,• --- - iiaPi0^4IF ....... w . ... .. , . --4.....-... .-.4 . . ._ . . -- -:-- _....--,-.17,11,1*,-,.--'-- - ' • ..ft.-*.t.,- ..;,- . -. .:ft V.-- 111 40,10 Jt‘;:ot ii ri Z-' ' - • '2. - ',•. . -.......- . 7 • - , . .....- - . . . . , - -------- •-' .-- ' ' •• .. -.:- _ , . Jv14644*/IC ne 201 2a/L C a v (J ,. T- t , ".p ' ,i, -T, if.;1 ,, „ a1 z- .......ilsraMiiiik,- . . r' 1 N rj • n m 3rrn ( m Z A 0 � � ° (DD a z r O C 6T' o '_*. ITI 3 > z0c = -� 0 I- rn rn Ximz � 3 -ai. m F m - 'v -a m U) rnD � 0 3 5 F O m � '-' Z = m O -I x z m I _ 1••1 -1 -I 1 -1 o �� z .,_ o TW W n l a w � � r f. I" F El mew r m N 7o > m Z 7C c> cn S 0 m O < rn 4 X -� rn � o D r c I 72 o, ° a F `/ p '< > Z � 0 a C ° r 0 p Cl, 0 -lo cn rn N. A Z r - -I 3 rn z c� = m co co n CD -I D -I N vi cD (Q o 0 � � Za A /w C z 30c5 .) in = -I z g .a 0 m um, mn m tu ▪ O z- I 99 ; N 7o 7v a ° O V 0 p 0 rn8 � P M ,2, O , (C -I m m 0 o () C A to U-I o . , -a 2 O 0Zrn 4 n m z N --1 cn •< 1> _ _ 4 ai W -1 —I mI A La I m W > -n I = �1 70 CCI ° O m o , -- z � 0 co 0 F� I ° � M Z N a a la 0 Pp CEPD,Naples join forces for beach reno • t-CaptivaSanibel.com I Island Reporter,Captiva Current,Sanibel-Ciptiv,.1 i Page 1 of 2 LAP1; Mobile:mobtle.captivasanibel.com Sign In I Create an Account I Subscribe I Submit News I Home 0 V? ti;ciatmido 14,3„.at/Nwm44: Southwest Florida Properties , 'i .' I -a� - .ei� Riverfront custom home package ,,,-i-...+- -`_ Your Community News Business Opinion Lifestyles Sports Ads Classifieds CU Services e-edition Community News /News/Community News/ Sanibel,FL .__•_.__-'__.__ __._ _ O-R 14 82°F Forecast .Mobile Mammo Coach at Sanibe... County staff to conduct work...» 82 F Find Another Location • Community News iMri• • News from around the ( Data provided by The Weather Channel S region CEPD, Naples join forces for • Business p News, Blogs & Events • Arts&Entertainment beach renourishment • Obituaries I am looking for: • SUBMIT News August 12,2011 SEARCH ..............._..__....._.............._.._..__...........__..._......_ By SHANNEN HAYES,shayes @breezenewspapers.com,Island Reporter,Captiva in: Current,Sanibel-Captiva Islander r News,Slogs&Events r Web C EZToUse.com 1313Z13 i Save I Post a comment I'0 SHARE ,r : _' Your f!1 EZTOU______ n� saurce!orInternet Virginia Beach,VA The City of Naples is looking to team up with Captiva Erosion C:3====-*,..- yellow pages Prevention District on the next beach renourishment project.The Check a mm/dd/yyyyW�"_I . partnership would have several advantages,including hefty cost ' savings on multi-million-dollar projects. Article Photos Check out mm/dd/yyyy V. "It makes sense,"said J.Gary McAlpin,director of Coastal Zone Go I Management in Naples. r i McAlpin,along with Naples Vice Mayor John Sorey,discussed the •' f Virginia Beach,VA + ; Idea of joining forces with Captiva during the CEPD's Wednesday Hotel Deals ,J,...t-r • Just found on KAYAK meetingn 2013-14,Collier County will be renourishing eight miles of its beaches Barefoot,Vanderbilt,Park Shore and Naples at a cost r hA rir> $78.39-La Quinta Inn ' of approximately$25 million. Norfolk Virginia Beach ***do.■ . Its sand source will be 14 miles southwest of Sanibel using hoper dredges.While Collier's beach renourishment project in 2005 was $84.00-Wingate by Representatives from the City of Naples visit Captive Eros... Wyndham Virginia Beach/ designed for a six-year life span,the next project will seek to Norfolk Airport achieve a true 10-year reno Trio_t hment with hinhar and wider beaches ****" Including erosion control structures to reduce the impact for hot $129.00-Founders Inn and spots. +li Spa ****-- The CEPD will be looking at a minimum of six miles of beaches, I' including the first mile of Sanibel,for its next project. "' ' .—- $140.22-The Westin I i Virginia Beach Town Center If the two were to team up there would be a shared fixed cost .'-I ****A i savings and potential leverage on a$40 to$50 million project.In .. $141.08-Wyndham addition,there would be cost share points with the Florida r 1.j Virginia BBeach Oceanfront Department of Environmental Protection and the possibility of saving ` between$2 and$4 million overall on the combined project. $159.00-La Quinta Inn& it Suites Virginia Beach "It behooves us to do this,"stated CEPD Chairman Mike Mullins."We Hilton ****t are happy to be talking with Naples(about this joint effort)." Hilton ',Prices found recently. _ 0010 Click for more info Savings can also be expected by splitting mobilization and I demobilization costs,and becoming equal partners with a structured bid and contract.McAlpin told CEPD the details could be worked out r t;-. if a partnership evolves. Sanibel.f',,Marina "We are very flexible,"said McAlpin."There could be millions in savings to both parties involved." Condos on Sanibel Island • Rent Exquisite Gulf Front Condos.Hurry, In other business: - Book Now&Save Up To 30%I CEPD unanimously voted to transfer$50,000 out of its legal and wwwsandalfootcondo.com Adcho cgs lD professional fees budget and into its general operating reserves Sanibel Island Hotel fund.At the end of the fiscal year in September,the money will then Fromers Favorite Island for Less Save I u • be moved to the capitol projects fund. /���Biiggwiith Summer S ecial��V 1r 00,1 !, The next regular meeting will be at 3 p.m.Sept.8 in the Wakefield t\ ) " � - ■ Room at'Tween Waters Inn.It will be Immediately followed by an ��� ` �+�� initial budget hearing at 5:01 p.m.The final budget hearing will be �S�j (� S� held Sept.22. W 1 r I t4 Save I Post a comment I I e%: 1 >I Recommend Send Sign Up to see what your friends recommend. C?V. lP I--v j t)S- 0.... 11,1 bum r✓`'I- 51441 D ki��-06� —> 1 - `k4 httn://Sanibel-cantiva-islandencom/Wage/content.detail/id/517340/CEPD--Naples-i oin-forces-for-beach-renourishment.html?... 6/26/2012 T3Och--N T7 UCA-A- 2,"7 N � f RaineyJennifer 5 V vv 1ft) L i' t From: HillerGeorgia Sent: Monday, May 07, 2012 4:08 PM To: jerryt @baycolonygolfclub.com Cc: RaineyJennifer Subject: RE: Proposed v. Needed Beach Renourishment- Material Discrepancies Noted Attachments: Beach Renourishment Concept Plan 42-48.pdf THIS MATTER WILL BE HEARD AT 9:30 TIME CERTAIN, please attend if you wish to speak. There is a material difference between what the county claims is needed to renourish the beaches and what is in fact needed based on the current state of the beaches. The intent should be to restore the beaches to their as built volumes in 2006, with a six (6) year design life. We know what the current sand volumes are based on the monitoring reports compiled by Humiston & Moore Engineers, which you all have. The county can't know what will be needed to avoid renourishing for a 10 year period. What is significant is that Alternative 2 of CPE's concept plan which proposes what is needed to implement the "traditional/existing" 2006 design, materially overstates the cubic yards needed to restore the beaches to 2006 volumes. If CPE's Alternative 2 is materially overstated, in other words you don't even need as much as what CPE is proposing for six years, you don't need what is being proposed for 10 years which follows. Please refer to Page 41 of the proposed Renourishment Concept Plan prepared by Coastal Planning & Engineering ("CPE"). (See attached.) CPE introduction states on Page 41 that 482,031 cubic yards of sand are needed to re- establish the Vanderbilt, Park Shore and Naples beaches back to the 2006 historic design standard with a six year design life. The Humiston & Moore monitoring report shows that since 2006 to the present, the erosion amounts to 180,000 cubic yards of sand. CPE overstates the loss of volume by 302,000 cubic yards. CPE's design requires over 2.5 times more than what is needed to achieve the 2006 as built volume. The 2006 as built volume upon completion of the renourishment was 667,000 cubic yards. There is more than 500,000 cubic yards of sand still remaining on these beaches, 6 years later. The actual 6 year loss of 180,000 cubic yards represents a loss of only 27%, and yet CPE is proposing a design as if 73% of the beaches have eroded. On Page 41 of CPE's concept plan, even the wording as to what is the proposed standard for each of the three beaches differs. Reiterating, CPE under alternative 2, entitled Traditional Existing Design, materially overstates what is needed to achieve the 2006 design causing alternative 3, the 10 year design for advanced renourishment, to be overstated since it builds on alternative 2. A summary and analysis of Page 41 of CPE's plan follows: 1. CPE's proposal for Vanderbilt Beach - "41,733 CY to refill to 2006 design" Analysis : The 2006 design was 178,000 CY meaning CPE is renourishing for a 24% loss which brings that beach back to the 2006 design. 2. CPE's proposal for Park Shore Beach - "138,132 CY to bring it back to the INTENDED STANDARD" Analysis: CPE's proposal presumes a 99% loss of the Park Shore beach. The 2006 as built volume was 140,000 CY. CPE's proposal states 138,132 CY are needed. This is not the case. See Humiston & Moore's monitoring report. Note that the wording "2006 design" applied to Vanderbilt has been replaced by "intended design standard" which is not defined and is not the 2006 design standard. 3. CPE's Proposal for Naples Beach - "302,166 CY to return to its FULL DESIGN INTENT" Analysis: Again, CPE's proposal grossly overstates what is needed. The as built volume of Naples Breach in 2006 was 345,000 CY. Requiring 302,166 CY suggests a 87% loss which is not the case. See Humiston & Moore's monitoring report. Importantly, note the standard is not the "2006 design" as for Vanderbilt. The wording for this beach's standard even differs from the Park Shore standard. Lastly, "full design intent" is not defined. In sum, under alternative 2, only Vanderbilt Beach is being renourished to the 2006 design standard based on actual losses, verified by Humiston & Moore's monitoring report. Park Shore and Naples are being renourished to completely different standards, far in excess of what is need to achieve the 2006 design. Again the average actual loss for these 3 beaches is about 25%. The design for Park Shore provides for 99% or 74% more than the 2006 design. The design for Naples provided for 87% or 62% more than the 2006 design. CPE grossly overstates what is needed to achieve the 2006 design standard, before even offering the 10 year design standard/needs which builds upon the 2006 design standard. Neither alternatives 2, nor 3 can be relied upon. Furthermore, the Barefoot Beach renourishment must remain outside of the scope of this renourishment plan. Barefoot is a separate and distinct project that is part of the Wiggins Inlet Management Plan and must be financed and monitored separately from the VB/PS/Naples plan, as has been the case in the past. Incidentally, the engineering design for Wiggins Pass was done by CPE, the same firm that is proposing the overstated renourishment concept plan. The Wiggins project is estimated at between $3.5 to $5 million dollars. It is an unproven approach, and as such the portion of this project related to renourishment should not be buried in the VB/PS/Naples project. The financial success or failure of the Wiggins Inlet project and the resulting erosion of Barefoot Beach needs to stand on its own. The financial impact of adjusting the concept plan based on the overstatement of the actual need and the Barefoot addition - without even going to the merits of the additional 2 representations in alternative 3 - is approximately an $8,045,000 reduction in the project's cost. Alternative 2 would drop from $19 million to $14 million. Alternative 3 would drop at a minimum from $31 million to $23 million. Adjusting for the volume inflation in concept 2, and the scope adjustment in concept 3, the overall savings over what has been adopted by the BCC is $17 million, which is the difference between $31 million (BCC adopted) and $14 million (need based). As to the Marco beaches, the monitoring report shows that the Marco beaches have grown since the 2006 renourishment by 174,000 CY of sand. There has been accretion, not erosion, except with respect to the South Marco beach which has lost 14,000 CY, but is filling in naturally. So why is additional sand being proposed for those beaches, which are now larger then they were after being renourished in 2006? The proposed cost to add 104,000 CY of sand to the Marco beaches should be removed saving almost $2 million. Separately, any federal funds related to Tropical Storm Fay should only go to those beaches adversely affected by that storm and made a part of the grant request. I have asked for a copy of the grant proposal and a summary of the funding expended by the county and reimbursed by the Feds to determine where the county stands on this application. This storm occurred several years ago. Those beaches should already have been restored to their pre-storm volumes. A separate review of this matter will follow upon completion. It is clear from the few examples presented above that Commissioner Henning is justified in bringing this matter back for reconsideration. With thanks, Commissioner Georgia Hiller Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 3 Park Shore The north Park Shore FEMA limits ext about from R-45 to R-47. These profiles will receive 21,000 cubic yards of fill centered The south Park Shore FEMA limits extend R-52. -51 to R-53. The design volume for this area is 30,000 cubic yards centered about Nanle�s Beach The fill limits for the Naples Beach FM umreJof 84,000 cubic yards. The profiles the to R-72. In total,this area has a design north will receive 64,000 cubic yards of fill concentrated near R-62 to help mitigate losses to Doctors Pass. The area between R-70 and R-72 is also designed to receive 20,000 cubic yards,with fill centered about R-71. Alternative 2: Traditional/Existing Design n berm and The design volume is based on the quantity of project des gnliThe desig nberm is 100 provide 6 years of advanced nourishmen t using the 2006 proj feet in Vanderbilt and Naples Beachesas back feet in Park design standard e Beach. h a six Tyeardesugn life is needed to bring the historic project are 482,031 cubic yards (Table 8). The design method in spreadsheet form is provide in Table 11 at the end of this report. Vanderbilt Beach The fill limits of the previously permitted project in Vanderbilt are approximately R-22 to R-31. This area needs approximately 41,733 cubic yards to refill the 2006 design. Park Shore Beach The fill limits of the previously permitted project in Park Shore are approximately R-45 to R-55. Overall this area needs 138,132 cubic yards to bring it back to the intended design standard. Naples Beach The fill limits of the previously permitted project in Naples are approximately R-58A to R-79. Overall,this area needs 302,166 cubic yards to return to its full design intent. Alternative 3: Expanded Design The design volume for the expanded design of advanced tnour nourishment. The desi`�n beach width construction profile to provide 10 years 41 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING,INC remains the same as Alternative 2, except as stated below. The area south of Doctors Pass and Clam Pass will have a design width of 80 feet. This design volume includes raising the berm 1 foot for the expanded design option. The berm will be raised from 4 ft NAVD to 5 ft NAVD, but additional analysis will be needed to provide the proper transition between the natural beach and berm system, and the additional height may not be practical everywhere. From preliminary analysis, it appears that approximately 75% of the profiles can be heightened. A typical cross-section comparing the 2005/06 permitted template versus the expanded template is shown Figure 8. The design method in spreadsheet form is provided in Table 12 and 13 at the end of this report. Typical Naples Beach Profile 20(16 vs 2010 Template Comparison • '010 Pro filc 6 x-2006 Icmplam "1 "•fispandcd'rcmplets 10 \ 1 \ \107 1 1• L 1 \ -4- \ \ -6 -8 -10 ' 10 100 110 200 210 300 310 400 410 500 Distance It) FIGURE 8: Typical Naples Profile. Vanderbilt Beach The fill limits of the Vanderbilt project area are approximately R-22 to R-31. Approximately 58,056 cubic yards is proposed within this project area to expand its design life and raise the berm elevation. The design beach width and berm elevation is 100 feet and 4 ft NAVD respectively. An increased elevation of 5 feet NAVD will be used where the landward intercept is accommodating and/or where beach width is restricted by near shore hardbottom. 42 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING,INC Park Shore Beach The fill limits of the Park Shore project area are approximately R-45 to R-55. Overall, approximately 186,166 cubic yards of material is proposed for placement within this reach. This volume is restricted at a few areas due to the close proximity of hardbottom, which may limit project life. This may be moderated by analysis during modeling or the detailed design phase. The design beach width and berm elevation is 85 feet and 4 ft NAVD respectively. An increased elevation of 5 feet NAVD will be used where the landward intercept is accommodating and/or where beach width is restricted by near shore hardbottom. Naples Beach The fill limits of the Naples Beach project area are approximately R-58A to R-79. The expanded design within this area requires 413,008 cubic yards of material. The profiles immediately south of Doctors Pass near R-58 cannot fit an expanded template needed to support a 10 year renourishment interval due to potential hardbottom impacts. Modified inlet management practices should be able to address much of the hot spot problem, supplemented with a spur off the Doctors Pass jetty. The volume for this reach does not change with a change in inlet disposal locations, but the distribution of fill in Table 12 does. The design beach width and berm elevation is 100 feet and 4 ft NAVD respectively. An increased elevation of 5 feet NAVD will be used where the landward intercept is accommodating and/or where beach width is restricted by near shore hardbottom. The design width south of the inlet is 80 feet through R-59, due to the hardbottom restrictions. New Areas The two new areas that are proposed for the expanded project are located directly north of Wiggins Pass and directly south of Clam Pass. Barefoot Beach The Barefoot Beach area is located from R-14 to R-16 and has recently been designated as a critically eroded area by the FDEP. Approximately 100,000 cubic yards is proposed within this area to supplement fill placed from the maintenance dredging of Wiggins Pass and the proposed inlet realignment project. Initial estimated total cut volumes from Wiggins Pass are realignment approximately 80,000 cubic yards. This material will be used to fill the meander channel and create dikes along with restoring the shoreline to the north. The shoreline at Barefoot Beach requires more sediment than available from dredging the Pass, so supplementing it with fill from the renourishment project will aid in its restoration. It is estimated that 25,000 cubic yards can be provided on the initial inlet dredging, and at least 35,000 cubic yards every 4 years thereafter. In conjunction with nourishment, almost 200,000 cubic yards can be placed in 8 years. The design berm elevation is 4 ft NAVD or equal to the natural 43 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING,INC beach. The design goal in conjunction with inlet management is to restore the beach towards historic widths. Clam Pass Park The area south of Clam Pass from R-42 to R-45 is the second proposed expansion area to the Collier County Renourishment Project. Fill to the north of Park Shore will stabilize the area, acting as a feeder beach. Approximately 30,000 cubic yards is proposed within this area. The fill will supplement sand from bypassing at Clam Pass, which alone is insufficient. The disposal site for Clam Pass bypassing should be extended further south to address a hot spot located south of R-44. The design template will be the similar to that proposed for the Clam Pass dredging project. The design beach width and berm elevation is 80 feet and 4 ft NAVD, respectively. An increased elevation of 5 feet NAVD will be used where the landward intercept is accommodating and where beach width is restricted by near shore hardbottom. The width is restricted for this entire reach. Alternative 4: Erosion Control Structures Structures have been proposed as one means of alleviating erosion in hot spot areas. Some types of structures suitable for use in Collier County are illustrated at the end of this report in Photographs 10 through 15 and Figure 20. Structural changes being considered for modeling are described in section XIV. Alternative 5: Alternative Sand Sources/Construction Methods Alternative sand sources and construction methods will be considered during design and project life. Each of the borrow areas that are proposed for use during the upcoming project requires different equipment in order to bring sand to the project area. For Borrow Area T1, a medium sized hopper dredge will be needed along with approximately 3 miles of submerged pipeline to transport the material to the shore. Booster pumps will also be required to supply extra force to ensure the sediment can transverse the entire length of the pipeline. For the Cape Romano borrow area, a hydraulic dredge with a scow will be required to remove sediment from the source. A small hopper dredge would also be feasible. Due to each of the borrow area's unique traits, a joint borrow area bidding scenario is unlikely, but could be feasible if a bidder used a hydraulic dredge and scow. In addition to the initial fill placement, upland sand sources may be used to alleviate erosional hot spots. Truck haul projects are advantageous when a small area requires extra fill, but they cause an unwarranted nuisance and need to be avoided. Mobilization prices can be costly for dredges, so using an upland sand source helps reduce the cost for smaller projects. 44 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING,INC Gaps in Fill Currently, gaps are proposed where a portion of shoreline does not need fill. If desired by the County, these gaps can be filled in at a minimum 10 c.y./1.f., which is the smallest practical amount a dredge contractor can place. This "gap fill", however, will substantially increase the cost of the project, but does help prevent lateral spreading of the design fill into surrounding areas. It is important to note that these gaps may be modified in the fmal design. Some gap areas may be partially filled in to alleviate losses from spreading and to account for detailed hardbottom avoidance. Below is a list of the areas where there are gaps in fill plan and no fill will be placed for Alternatives 2 and 3: R-22 to R-24 R-50 R-66 to R-69 R-31 R-54 R-73 to R-75 R-49 R-55 R-77 to R-79 XIII. SCHEDULE The project is tentatively scheduled for the November 2013 to April 2014 period, and will take approximately 4 months. If construction savings are desired, then summer construction in conjunction with another community offers the best prospect for savings. The May-July period has the calmest weather, which will lead to a shorter construction period and higher production rate when pumping. XIV. TASK LEADING TO CONSTRUCTION OF THE 2013-14 PROJECT The project cost includes dredging and the professional services and management necessary to bring the project to construction and complete the required pre-, during- and post construction monitoring and inspections. This list should be updated based on a pre-permit application meeting with FDEP. A list of the tasks needed to prepare the project for construction and conduct the inspections and investigations necessary are summarized below: Permit Design, Plans and Specification for 2013-14 Project Pre-Application Meeting FDEP Pipeline Corridor Mapping-3 New Ones with Operational Areas Special Design Survey for Structures, ECL& 3D Design Process ECL Survey Structural Areas Survey intermediate lines at hardbottom inflection points for 3D design 3-D Design Update(around hardbottom) with larger fill section and new reaches Add Clam Pass Park and Barefoot Beach Address Hot Spots and Hardbottom Avoidance with intermediate profile line Run model with refinements and to revalidate design and Spreading magnitude Design structure modifications and removals Prepare BOEMRE Environmental Assessment 45 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING,INC Prepare&submit permit modification to 2005 Permit with new Permit Sketches RAI Cycle with Meetings Update biological and physical monitoring plans Develop Hardbottom Impact Assessment Develop Plans and Specifications Bidding and Award Pre-, During- and Post-Construction Task Pre-Construction Survey Pre-Construction Biological Monitoring Hardbottom mapping using side scan Construction Assistance Services Pipeline Corridors Monitoring Shore Bird Sea Turtle Monitoring Post-Construction Survey, Report and Certification Post-Construction Biological Monitoring and Report XV. COST ANALYSIS The cost of the project is principally a function of distance to the borrow areas, cut depths, and shallowness of the nearshore bathymetry, which leads to long pumping distance after the sand has traveled to the submerged pipeline location. Grain size, water depth at the borrow area, and equipment play a secondary role. This cost estimate is based on experience derived from the 2005/2006 Collier County Renourishment Project, recent dredge industry practices, and a price adjustment of 2.2% per year until 2013-14. Dredge contractors are placing a larger percent of cost in mobilization, and less in the unit cost component. The cost in Table 9 is summarized based on the volumes in Table 8. Given the ever increasing cost of dredging, combined bidding of the Collier County project with a similar regional project from the west coast of Florida could provide a significant cost savings. We have an estimate for cost saving considering a joint biding with another county or city government. A limited amount of structural work is considered, which includes building the south jetty spur at Doctors Pass and the removal of a few groins. Some matereail form groin removal may be suitable for use in the Jetty spur. The cost estimate includes removal of some of the existing groins for Alternative 2 and 3, and the construction of a jetty spur for Alternative 3. There is no cost difference for the alternatives designed to support sand bypassing to the Lowdermilk Park or adjacent to the Doctors Pass south jetty disposal area. Doctors Pass dredging would be less expensive with the closer disposal area. Fill for a feeder beach or additional advanced nourishment to a hot spot has been included for use during the detailed design phase of this project. The cost for increasing the beach design elevation to 5 ft. NAVD is small and will decrease the potential for hot spots. The County currently has a FEMA approved project based on erosion experienced during Tropical Storm Fay. This funding can help support the mobilization and demobilization costs, 46 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING, INC which are a costly component of the project. The County may also obtained cost sharing money from the FDEP, which will be used for applicable areas of the project. Alternative 2A illustrates one way to reduce the price of the project. It keeps the renourishment interval at 6 years, while keeping the two new reaches and limited structure funding. There are many strategies and small changes to the project that can be implemented to reduce the price, which can be fleshed out during the planning and implementation process. For example the cost savings of reducing the renourishment interval from 10 to 8 years amounts to $2.8 million. A moderate savings is assumed in the cost estimate from use of joint bidding and construction with an adjacent project to including cost efficiency desired by the dredge contractors. The greatest dredging cost savings need the following characteristics: -Early availability of draft Plans and Specifications -Long and Flexible Construction Timetable -Combined bidding with similar public projects -Construction period includes calmer months—May to July The total project cost including engineering, permitting, surveys and monitoring for the three main alternatives are provided in Table 9. Potential savings are estimated, including reducing the project to an 8-year life. 47 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING,INC TABLE 9 COLLIER COUNTY PRELIMINARY COST ESTIMATE AIt.2 Alt.2A Alt.1 FEMA AIt.3 10-yr Design Existing Existing 1 Nouri shment Design Design I Interval Item Unit Unit Cost Construct Beach Fill Hydraulically Fill Volume C.Y. 175,000 482.031 612.03) 787,130 I.Mobilization/Demobilization L.S. 53.700,000 83.700.000 53.700.000 53.700000 Beach Fill 2.Vanderbilt Beach(R22.5-R3I) C.V. $28.00 $1.120,185 $1.168,7071 51.168.707 51625.832 3.Pelican Bay Beach(R31-R37) C.Y. $3155 SO SO i 00 4 North Park Shore Beach(R43.3-R48) C.Y. $31.88 I 5669.391 $1.303.126 61.303.126 51.585.146 5 Park Shore Beach(R48-R54.5) C.Y. 026.23 • 5786.780 $2550.508 $2550.508 $3.575,581 6.Naples Beach(R58A-R79) C.Y. 030.29 52544.759 59.154.037 59.154.037 512.511.965 7 Hot Spot I Feeder Volume C $29.59 1 5591.806 Environmental Monitoring 8.Set Buoys for Pipeline Corridor 528,747.46 I S28.747 528.747 528.747 528.747 9,Turbidity Monitoring $197,692.43 It S197,692 5197.692 5197.692 5197.692 Offshore Sea Turtle Monitoring(Hopper Dredge onit) 10.Mobiiization/Demob.of Relit Trawler Event $4,233.83 I 04.234 04.234 04.234 I 04.234 I 1 Relocation Trawling Day 04.068.75 i S64,730 S178.297 S 178.297 0243.063 12 Endangered Species Observer Day $673.18 i 010.710 829.499 529.499 540.215 13.Payment and Performance Bond L.S. 1 591.272 $183.118 $183.118 0241.043 SUB-TOTAL 09,218,501 518.497995 518.497,995; S24315,324 New Reaches 14. Barefoot Beach C.Y. $28.00 SO $0 52.800.000` S2.800.000 15.Clam Pass Park C.Y. $31.71 I SO SO 5951.300 5951.310) New reaches Sub-total 1 53,751,300 B S3.751,300 Alternative 4:Strnctures 1 SO SOB 5400,000 51,600,000 16.Phase I Removal of Groins SO 50' 5400.000 87(01,000 17 Jetty Spur SO SO SO T 5900.000 Professional Services S906,950 $906950 r'i' 01,265.301 il S1.490,987 18 Final Design and Pemuning I $266,460 6266.460 $487.562. $576,000 19 Pre-.During Lt Post Conswcuon Services ' 0646.491 0640.491 8777.'39 $914.987 Sub-total without Savings 510,125.451 $19,404945 523,914,5950 531,187.611 Project Saving Goal Sub-Total -57,233,490 -$1,818,586 -52,016,322 1 -S5,614,001 20 Combined Project/Mobilization $1001100) -$1,000,000 -51.1100,000 -51.500.000 21 Year Round and Flecible Construction Specs -5333,490 -5918.586 -51.166,322 -S1,500.006 22.Turtle Relocation $100,000 5100000 5154000 $150.019, 23.Reduce Protect Design Life to 8 years. SO SO SO' -02.764,001 ■ Sub-total with Savings 58,891,961 517,586,359 521,898,274 525,573,610 5%Contingents 1 $444,598 S879.318 $1.094.914 51,278.080 TOTAL 59,336.559 518,465477 II $22,993,187 I $26,852,290 48 COASTAL PLANNING&ENGINEERING.iNC m M 'la G) ' Ce 'a z 4 m � O = >. u L7 ._ m H O CG In 9 0 a m i J ¢ ~ = I- I m E W W QwF- = la I- = R �' �" a _I u) 'v , W 0 w Z W d7 I to �. (J) N) ~ 0 L 0 OU 'U cc E a -, 1-<ace 0 O A (5.0 4 a N C: • c I- z N 0 < O _ c � a CU � � o a al ° N < co Q I- I- Um00 W = i f i L-1.— ZzH f Z � O-9-- iu ‘--_. 2 m < (") cn = N V0 O C . .c1.-- 0 ma W 0.1% a O r/- - oww u0,. H J W Q (n Q 1 Z W J ^\ V ` ----Z! o CO I- ... H W z , wa O zce O ce �' G) < (9 0 re O. Z 41 W W --' 0 p (7 C7 U.4, ce J IT( w � I) W .> wLu W W Q c _ 0 oz it. Ow0 =W z ° cemJ 4 y Loj ° U O. W w z W f C . < u la `� Q 020E 4 ct 0 (1) 0 0<. L`J 2 m o a) -a %L v) z a re m a acn o 3 _ To sJ c.) 0. � Q m LL CO 0 =Z m __I ce I. i w ao 1— �m W W = F- m= ce I- I- Q >- in (� w J W Q'w ce ui 0 E woo d iii cG CI 1a c) 1- a a O a) N 0 < I_ 2 to a� .c p W W 0 a z I- 0 ;. O Q2D a a = c ' si 9 F- z z CO *i -a- o z 0 Q a < a) c r"' " ,(NI- o Z CO Q = U CO CO W = Z i w 2 F. - Z Zu z ,' 1— O i-1 u U u) 1.1.1 d O N >- Z °C G _ cc c-- G W AM 1 Wm O ow ° F- o _ U.c _ zip I- � �11 Qu I- 0 W CE �1 , cn Q Y - J '� vj Z J 2 � ui J V c� om = w CD p I- W W Il •4 NJ = I I- Z I rr •b zz I- Z H l 1 wZce O O I U ~ w ~ / C Z Z 1- W ce J ■∎ 0 (j (7r� I°L �W 73 }o � ° W a) VJ W a - J ~w � F- W = W Q G .0 0 Z Q z W z , puw ° —I < i 1-1 � °m U O. Z W LU II I W a Q U • / < z re uu re uu cc .c z 4 m 0O 1 1 } U (.7 o m 0 N H OJ0 a m ---1 1-1- °CI Z Z n w F- m Ta I- F- a m w z W Z W 47 LUZo Q 2 a.it u) s : \ _ 0 U I- CY w c U) 0 ate' � o ° ILI I- ,:r'°ate ° o 0 az N A H z 0 a ■ L N 0 Q H f � w W (j) W Q M CL � 0 QED a it ma ~ Ln iii z a c oz 01 E Z.- Ni- O Z m Q d , .J V co m W = Z w f 1 U 0 I-1 m 8 ° Q U u) J OC O J Q = 4 Om1 o W \� a w u � E ~ t W W Q Q u F- Z W m V V) < �C z uj "' z w J M m W u U \ S a ` N O 1- W W 2 = z , z < F- z .. . C z O W 0 18 (1-5 LLI J .`.+ O a Eli W Vl W I- l) a w cn J W Q a W Y zz L z a a W G w + OOw _O E J 2 a . Um � Q U a H Z W E w J� >- W W f �- � J � U u f 4 o0 5 a ea'' o 0 = y p GL -a z Q m ,~cn,, O = U Vr O 0° V- Z m O d w u) OJ a m \ I 'V tea ~ _ O ¢ O w V V \ Q m W H W W = n \. j F- Ha >- w.v cn z � Z W Q. � O = It u' .5. v) I- CY J Ac 0 Q CI c., oHz O ria H . y F' f NoW m W 0 � �i. O ¢ Zz a a EC � ., Ln ni Z 0 0 rQ T . N co H. O z > i Umm W = Z W i,, z H Z. z�I o I- u W ce M ¢ p Ov0 0 p * W n m O I ;, Q W W LL ,./� 1 li z E- al O c Q I- Z 5" Q `.. U) ¢ Y N W W `�( ¢ mow g W \ M U m C-v c. co W I_ cci�() o O H W W 4 '''..c.'') = cd X Z z < 1- z \ Wz O 0 -` -- .. z '-' W 0 1... E '' `21(7) p p� a ` W `~' ''` O .6 C7 2 N u_ W �j . Oz � 5 W a. I- < Q ~w C Z ce Z Q C W p ;+ Ou_ 0 = f 0 0 y cem O. p n 0 Z W L W _I-'- W u J U LU. a z oco ° v=)° 5 o g Y M Z I- Z W C13 : • c~n 0 = >_ L w d m CO LL 0 d N �. O o Q W co 3 <Q W O W W• � m .0 L-� v) Ur W Z W a. ,!. � U) Lr) I- (i\ ii N a m 0 Hcc o1- z 0 a cg �'. . . W Now IO 0 W 0 W 9-._I' ozo a 0 al CT/Z �' (NI F- Z W QG7 c U 00 CO W = a/ W 1 801- 0 N O u C m � O CI Q �. a ° w"jm 0 J Z i� _ 0 a ,.y / (n < Z J W < -J Ln U M m moll U gm • om = O O I- W W •�'��jj N _I = ce _ J Z � , Z a H Z wz � O O ce (...) -,.- i„...CI. o 8 ( 0 (9 Fw W H t QW D .0 V I- c Q. w cn W W y.. Q H 1- �� _ =0 • ° pz < f W z m ° ? U� w c a` W W 2 a.i J z V W J Q I z a z re ° c=n° CL C, r r ce -a u) z 4 m J o = y. U Ve.,. co t 0O w z in O0 a m la Y J < U b '�' ' < 2 w W W _ _ cc F=- m .0 _ wzO Z W O = 4 to o,w ce� IA 0 X00 re F- EU w w moo 4 a ly `) a� RI0 < 0 f \ W O V 0 Qzz Q rt ma I- c s o0 z 4 o CA 2 N m O Z o0 Q . - Vmm W = Z w 2 F- i .. iZZ Z I- 0 N W 'w4 0OQ U 1g A odo C � C ■1 - mQ W a W 0 e O W /�/ I��"-'� W U. It V W > L�LI O Q0o zQ i (n < �L Z J _I J nzu f m U -.) z .- o m = W 4 r,1 JO I- W W 'L = cC I Z *• �. z Q 1 Z INNI r) I wz Q O Cn W O 0 (.9 F- u. IL F- a:+ 0 L 5 Lu w W '1 a 0 W V) J W 14 Z ILI 0 �, c 0 O z Q z a o � m � o U W W rW..' _I 2 W f ( S W 0 = 0 5 4 U u) U w 0 at cL u.) z a '4,1 m u O 2 U O En O • � r o o -I ° 1" W a m Q m w W W C/ 7 W � � ° Z W O. o = `n o'u n o L � oQ U ~ E 1C U "et 1-Q ce 0 N A 4 ii ii Iz ~ a x s ° Iw W O � p QE = a ce C _ ,7i- 0 p 4 4 ANIo Z CO ' \ U 00 00:1 W = CC Z w E E- i