CCPC Agenda 10/06/2011 RCCPC
REGULAR
MEETING
AGENDA
OCTOBER 6.2011
Court Reporter
AGENDA
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION WILL MEET AT 9:00 A.M., THURSDAY, OCTOBER 6,
2011, IN THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING ROOM, ADMINISTRATION BUILDING,
COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER, THIRD FLOOR, 3299 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, NAPLES, FLORIDA:
NOTE: INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO 5 MINUTES ON ANY ITEM.
INDIVIDUALS SELECTED TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF AN ORGANIZATION OR
GROUP ARE ENCOURAGED AND MAY BE ALLOTTED 10 MINUTES TO SPEAK ON
AN ITEM IF SO RECOGNIZED BY THE CHAIRMAN. PERSONS WISHING TO HAVE
WRITTEN OR GRAPHIC MATERIALS INCLUDED IN THE CCPC AGENDA PACKETS
MUST SUBMIT SAID MATERIAL A MINIMUM OF 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE
RESPECTIVE PUBLIC HEARING. IN ANY CASE, WRITTEN MATERIALS INTENDED
TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE CCPC SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE
APPROPRIATE COUNTY STAFF A MINIMUM OF SEVEN DAYS PRIOR TO THE
PUBLIC HEARING. ALL MATERIAL USED IN PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE CCPC
WILL BECOME A PERMANENT PART OF THE RECORD AND WILL BE
AVAILABLE FOR PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
IF APPLICABLE.
ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE CCPC WILL NEED
A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE
MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS
MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON
WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED.
1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
2. ROLL CALL BY SECRETARY
3. ADDENDA TO THE AGENDA
4. PLANNING COMMISSION ABSENCES
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES August 18, 2011, September 1, 2011, September 15, 2011
6. BCC REPORT - RECAPS
7. CHAIRMAN'S REPORT
8. CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS
1
9. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
A. Note: This item has been continued from the September 15, 2011 CCPC meeting:
PUDZ- 2003 -AR -3608: Orangetree PUD -- An Ordinance amending Ordinance Numbers 2005 -42 and
2004 -73, the Orangetree PUD, to add 1,250 residential units for a total of 3,350 residential units of which
100 units may be resort lodging; to add 100,000 square feet of office use and add 172,000 square feet of
retail use to the existing 60,000 square feet of retail for a total of 332,000 square feet of commercial
development; to revise the development standards including building height and setbacks and to add
allowable residential, commercial uses and mixed uses, and to delete environmental commitments for
property located in parts of Sections 11, 12, 13, 14, 22 through 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East,
Collier County, Florida consisting of 2138.76 acres; and by providing an effective date. [Coordinator: Kay
Deselem, AICP, Principal Planner]
B. Note: This item has been continued from the September 15, 2011 CCPC meeting:
BD- PL2010 -1473: 266 3rd Street West, Lot 8. A Resolution of the Collier County Planning Commission
relating to Petition Number BD- PL2010 -1473 for a 25.5 foot boat dock extension over the maximum 20
foot limit in Section 5.03.06 of the Collier County Land Development Code for a total protrusion of 45.5
feet for the benefit of Naples Barge Rental, LLC in Collier County, Florida. [Coordinator: Michael
Sawyer, Project Manager]
10. OLD BUSINESS
A. Note this item has been continued from the June 2, 2011 CCPC meeting, again from the September 15,
2011 CCPC meeting:
Presentation of final draft Collier County Watershed Management Plan and implementation plan
[Coordinator: Mac Hatcher].
B. Master Mobility Plan Update — [Coordinator: Nick Casalanguida, Deputy Administrator]
11. NEW BUSINESS
12. PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM
13. DISCUSSION OF ADDENDA
14. ADJOURN
CCPC Agenda/Ray Bellows /jmp
AGENDA ITEM 9A
NOTE: THIS ITEM HAS BEEN CONTINUED FROM THE SEPTEMBER
159 2011 CCPC MEETING
YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS MATERIAL AT THE SEPTEMBER 15r"
MEETING
PUDZ- 2003 -AR -3608: ORANGETREE PUD
AGENDA ITEM 9 -13
THIS ITEM HAS BEEN CONTINUED FROM THE SEPTEMBER 15`h
MEETING.
VOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS MATERIAL AT THE SEPTEMBER 15th
MEETING.
BD- PL2010 -1473,
2663 RD Street West, Lot 8
Additional material provided as requested at the September 15'h
meeting:
• Affidavit from Gregory Orick regarding Non Commercial use of the
proposed Boat Dock Facility.
• Enlarged survey of proposed dock facility with additional topographic
information.
• Complete survey of proposed dock facility with additional topographic
information.
• Complete survey without proposed dock facility.
September 16, 22011
To- Collier County, Plam3ing Commissio.-a
C/o Mchael Sawyer j
Pro ect Manager
Re: Petition BD 2010-1473
.u-�,, 0 %L
Affidavit
L GLegoa, Orick U . am the o-m-ter of Naples Barge Rental LLC.. -the owner of
record Of1he PmPtTly d cribe-dasap-,"vatesinglefai-nitvboa-tliDt zones -RSF-4,loca.�ed
Ges
qrd Street We_-�t, -ribed as Lot 8, Block"Ir in, the replat ofthe'Unit
at 266 , _ flinher desc
Littl=e Hickory Shores Subdivision, Section 5 TownsMo 48 Soudi, Range 25 East of
Collier Coun-q; Florida. I h Tzby state tliat I have read and f WRy understand the
Resolution 99-236- n RSr -4 Zoned Di s ict tr
I , the conditio-LA Use I of section 2.2.4.3 in a
for Nort Commercial boat lwanching facilities, that all boat docks =cted on subject lom
shall comply with thereqdumments; of Section 16.21 of tdie Land Development Code and
that the rental of boat slips are strictly prohibited.
7E7
Pri&-d'd name
Nola P sizie :,f Flortaz
Patridia 1-awlGin
My corrut,46-on Df)e7 7013
Exp�lres O4!O?j2Ol3
arc
NA-
signature 4waer
�-
' DRAINAGE EASEMENT
-2.86 \•
MEAN LOW WATER LINE 24 MAR 2410
ELEVATION 0.40' NGVD 1929
-3.9
-5.22
-5.89
EXISTING DOCK
PROPOSED 20' BOAT MAX.
,_MEAN HIGH WATER LII
ELEVATION = 1.2' NG
t_
SAFE UPLAND LINE 29
ELEVATION = 1.6' NG\
PROPOSED 25'
67
4.16
-5.17
R,�6.81
s.5$
-6.98 x
—s.so
\ x -6.43
1
X-6.09
x -6.17
'-- RIPARIAN RIGHTS LINE
N:\Land Projects \09 -0086 ORICK MARINE CONSTRUCTIOW
- d-c-�- Pq -73
E UPLAND LINE 29 OCL2009
1ATION = 1.5' NGVD 1829
EXtBTLYG CDC,{
17
:22
t -5,81
-5.58
\lt
r -&43
s
tY _5.89
SYMBOLS LEUND
0 = FOU:'vD 11r ERON ROD
(F) = FiELD MEASURUENT
+! = SET 5 %8" .RON RM /CAP AM L9 3664
= WOOD POWER POLE
°u = WATER METER BOX
�} = BACKFLOW PREVENTOR
y o TDr, t;nrL:unr )- VIN11- r jrd.;gr ::
F 1 NAPLES BARGE RENTAL, INC. i
D e f {stle; NEAT' OF BOUNDARY SURVEY . Crown.
c a LOT 8, BLOCK A, UNIT 3, UTTLE HICKORY SHORES A
PLATBOOK 5, PAGE 2 VDA
F < ' SECTION 5, TOWPTSE311? 48 SDUtTH L'09 2S EAST
aCDLIii.'ft COUNTY IT.OfitDA ocad
a ny ■aaaa view:
o a 111 `GNO11 LOSS ex 7a 8 APRIL 2010 1 P a ct
alt., _
w ri ■avM■ f'- 16' IU
uau ARSET2
■maa cogo 9;
a .uuaa 09 -0085 `shett
rs w aaaau13RUNDAGE,-
Prof —I ..I engu,ecr=, PTaanccrs, k kn6 sa Y-= r- {ss}ue e2a0 i of
�uul C.-Ir. S.1" M. 1400 T-J-i T,vt, V o,'.pk, r U.00 tz0a}Er -s�sl pE g:
Lu c> v: ucra c--A r-,L S.tu I= a..,u sPri=ct FL 34M {zss�sr atil � 1 i}�s8.�
u uek. .r u,.si: n >u Ls xu .ae 13 sAU rs t2aska0 -=24
d 1. 16
N :\Land "ds\09-0096 CRICK MRINE C0N5TRUGTT0Njdw91L T T Lt HiCKUKY SiVKtS Urv1 i 3 W I a CLK miuz a-wmv,
C
rs?- N ..
PREPARED FdC NAPLES BARGE RENTAL. INC.
GATE OF F:-= SURVEY TUNE 10.
AGNOLL BARBER &
P.�i'- SStC^IAL ENGItNEDRS. & SURVEYORS AND 14APPM
WA J. R..lt. Mo, 5335 DATE +, " -
/'
Tt^- stvDARY SDRtf_'t WEE FLEE MItXu -tN .:E S7ArtDARSS ;` ET FLO�6 B`4 i
WAND SURVEYORS N CHAPTER bld7 -B. i3ORID {NESTRATI?E COu�.- Pl1RNAN'TO SEC7C�V ' ADFA
72.u"t7, FLIMMA STATSI ES.
TIT - SOLMOARY SURVEY IS NOT V.+u6 YWTNOUT 3s SIGNATURE AND irK ff :CxNA.. RA �O Scca�t it A..
dR f*7.e'itsk+�TO- SIiRyEY MAPS OP, S
FLORIDA LICENSED SURVEYOR AND MAPPpi, AdHATiONS -PIA
BY 0-ER THAN THE SCNING PARTIES FATHCUT ThE W. T04 CONSENT "If :5E 5Cw9N6�PA_:
PARTIES IS PROWBITED BY CHAPTER 5„17 FLORIDA ADMINtSTRAFVE CODE :.; ..'. .:..
TIES BOUNDARY SURVEY IS C . ERIFIRED AS TO THE DATE OF FIELD SURVEY NOT r�&-:.Sj ATURE DATE.
ABS -ACT NOT REV£WEQ
f49RAL qQT 1-
L DW- NSIONS ARE N FEET AND DECIMALS THEREOF.
2 P.O.B. = POINT OF BEGN."G.
3. P.O.C. - PONT OF COMMENCEMENT.
4 R.41k = RIC-HT -OF -'NAY.
S CURVE OWIERS"S A.iE AS FOLLOWS
C - DELTA . R = RADAK, A = ARCH. Ci = CHORD. ANO
CHE - CHORD BEAMW-
a. BEARINGS ARE BASED ON THE FLCRIDA STATE PLANE COORDINATE SYSTEM EAST ZONE. NAD 93/90
DATUM AND REFERENCED TO THE EERIER LINE OF 'THIRD ST_ W..UTT" HICKORY SHORES LYNG N SECTK}N 5.
tANGROVE
TOMSHIP 48 SCUTH, RANGE 25 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY,.:LORIOk AS BEING NORTH 58'4T�lI'EAST,
7 EYISTING MANOROVTS AS SHOW VALL RE"N.
NCAM HIGH WATER LINE 24 MAR: 20.0
rr rvATrnN = t 7 #UrAm T�?A,
E UPLAND LINE 29 OCL2009
1ATION = 1.5' NGVD 1829
EXtBTLYG CDC,{
17
:22
t -5,81
-5.58
\lt
r -&43
s
tY _5.89
SYMBOLS LEUND
0 = FOU:'vD 11r ERON ROD
(F) = FiELD MEASURUENT
+! = SET 5 %8" .RON RM /CAP AM L9 3664
= WOOD POWER POLE
°u = WATER METER BOX
�} = BACKFLOW PREVENTOR
y o TDr, t;nrL:unr )- VIN11- r jrd.;gr ::
F 1 NAPLES BARGE RENTAL, INC. i
D e f {stle; NEAT' OF BOUNDARY SURVEY . Crown.
c a LOT 8, BLOCK A, UNIT 3, UTTLE HICKORY SHORES A
PLATBOOK 5, PAGE 2 VDA
F < ' SECTION 5, TOWPTSE311? 48 SDUtTH L'09 2S EAST
aCDLIii.'ft COUNTY IT.OfitDA ocad
a ny ■aaaa view:
o a 111 `GNO11 LOSS ex 7a 8 APRIL 2010 1 P a ct
alt., _
w ri ■avM■ f'- 16' IU
uau ARSET2
■maa cogo 9;
a .uuaa 09 -0085 `shett
rs w aaaau13RUNDAGE,-
Prof —I ..I engu,ecr=, PTaanccrs, k kn6 sa Y-= r- {ss}ue e2a0 i of
�uul C.-Ir. S.1" M. 1400 T-J-i T,vt, V o,'.pk, r U.00 tz0a}Er -s�sl pE g:
Lu c> v: ucra c--A r-,L S.tu I= a..,u sPri=ct FL 34M {zss�sr atil � 1 i}�s8.�
u uek. .r u,.si: n >u Ls xu .ae 13 sAU rs t2aska0 -=24
d 1. 16
N :\Land "ds\09-0096 CRICK MRINE C0N5TRUGTT0Njdw91L T T Lt HiCKUKY SiVKtS Urv1 i 3 W I a CLK miuz a-wmv,
C
rs?- N ..
1 7,
x SECTION 5, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH. RANGE 25 EAST
,f• -5.89 �\ -6.98 -I O COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA aC°d _
\ p }�1 x -6:45 CL - m <`?
DUSTING DOCK -.- •' ` -5.fi0 v Y i 14 Y RUN 7 � d0:e• view:
x -6.42 \ U L] r O O iii�GNOLi �. T085 62 74. 8 APRIL 2010
x -6.43 0 0 0 0 0 ■��: scale: I Projec
1 l \ O O Z 00 no ::a ice. 18' -
-J( ■a��■ ARHER &
PROPOSED 20' BOAT MAX -&Og O o 0 p ■au:• 1 lC�'° sheet
0 vUt - ■nuffm US -UO86
•u�iRT3Ni}�GE —�
\I'. -5.17 » > � ? Profe¢sioaaT eagi>n c^s. gtenaers, k land sa y*= r- (M-Ala S-zxos of
RIPARIAN RIGHTS llNE x -5.89 r_ u L_! L4 wlu� ce®tr- Smtr zoo. ]436 r me 71al, xsAx N•vl=•. PL uxa¢. f 1 - r.file ^3^.
C` - .- x = { iN maser 9 C<ea 3wd. 5¢ax 13Y HeWL Spec n 31394 f439)I561-3111 Y
i
AESTRACT NOT 2MEWFD
W G
GENERAi NOTES;
1. O;MBiSONS ARE !N FEET AND DECIMALS FiFEREOF.
2 7.011. = PONT OF BEGINNING.
�- 3
3, 7.0,C. - 7OiNT OF COMMEkCEMV`'T.
4, ILO,W- v XCHT -OF-WAY.
5, fiUR�E DWIDNSONS ARE AS FULLOYl5:
A = DELTA, R = RADIUS, A - ARCH. CH = CHORD. AND
OHB =CHORD BEARING,
6. BEAMNDS ARE BASED ON 'FIE FLOiIDA S-ATr PLANE CJOP A-j. SSTEM ,EAST 2CNE, NAO 83J'a
QE D
TOWTi5r{ 48 SCUT.t, RAtit>= TS EAS<', GOLLtER CO'�,:tiT'; r_ORfDM AS BEtk6 NOR_ 8H'¢S'1S'JST-
SCALE 2` _ !6' �
�y_�Cc�.,N R
7. FR07OSF` DOCK AREA = 3O MO 5G. FL =
f O
O L
L NAPLES BARGE RENTAL, 'NC. FOLIO No. 5600S68DOC8
1L E=1114 MANGROVES AS SHOWN WILL RELtA -
..fir- • ;
l N. '� —J7 P
HRv?'r]A„^E. I!r-
S1if.ANCAi(:VES
` (
BY
10' DRAINAGE EASEMENT `
WAYNE D. AGNOLL R -SM. NO. 5335 DATE
MEAN 1
11 O
\ t SAFE UPLAND LINE 29 OCT.2009
EOur- OF MANGROVES \ �` �
1929
t k -0.54
PROPOSED 25' B
BOAT MAX SYMBOLS LEGEND
a\ \
\5,62
"s, G._ -- k- 67 u m
m PROPOSED CRUSHED SHE
10
2 -Q-40 A0 E -415 .
.- .-
ti S A� -SA2 '
'o N H
�\ -2.85 Se. ' `
D; �
- 6
p
N
; +
, P
,
i