PARAB Minutes 12/15/2010
December 15, 2010
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
RECEIVED
Naples, Florida, December 15,2010 JUN 1 0 2011
Board of County Commissioners
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Collier County Parks and Recreation
Advisory Board, in and for the County of Collier, having conducted business
herein, met on this date at 2:00 P.M. at North Collier Regional Park Exhibit
Hall, 15000 Livingston Road, Naples Florida, with the following members
present:
Fiala
Hiller
Henning
Coyle
Coletta
CHAIRMAN:
VICE CHAIR:
John P. Ribes
Edward "Ski" Olesky
Barbara Buehler
Phil Brougham
Kerry Geroy
David Saletko
ALSO PRESENT:
Barry Williams, Parks & Recreation Director
Sidney Kittila, Operations Coordinato~isc. Corres:
Tona Nelson, Administrative Assistanoate: ~\l-bl\ \
Tony Ruberto, Sr. Project Manager
Annie Alvarez, Regional Manager II Item #: l ~ :t:. "2-ALlc
1
December 15,2010
I. Call to Order
Edward "Ski" Olesky called the meeting to order at 2:00 PM.
A quorum was established.
II. Pledge of Allegiance and Invocation
The Pledge of Allegiance was recited and Invocation was held.
III. Approval of Agenda
Phil Brougham moved to approve the Agenda as submitted. Second by Barbara
Buehler. Motion carried unanimously 5-0.
IV. Approval of November 15, 2010 Minutes
XII - 1st sentence should read "batting nets"
Edward "Ski" Olesky moved to approve the November 15,2010 Minutes as a
amended. Second by Phil Brougham. Motion carried unanimously 5-0.
V. New Business
a. Employee of the Month
Staff will make recommendations for the "Employee ofthe Month" for November
and December 2010 at the January 19,2011 meeting.
b. Interview Applicants - Board Members
The Advisory Board received applications and interviewed the following
candidates for seats currently held by Edward "Ski" Olesky, Phil Brougham and
seat recently vacated by William Shafer: (See attached)
· Phil Brougham
· Gary McNally - New Applicant
· Lenice DeLuca - New Applicant
John Ribes arrived at 2: 15 pm
.
Diane Worrall, PH. D. - New Applicant
Gary Davis - New Applicant
Edward "Ski" Olesky
.
.
Each Applicant gave a brief summary on their education, experience, community
activities and groups associated with. The Advisory Board Members asked the
new applicants questions.
Staff distributed paper ballots to Advisory Board Members. (See attached)
John Ribes informed the applicants of the voting and recommendation
procedures to the BCC. He directed the Board to vote.
Tona Nelson collected the ballots and left the meeting.
Ballots will be tallied and Advisory Board recommendations were announced
after VIII
2
December 15,2010
VI. Old Business
Barry Williams stated Jennifer Robertson, Florida Department of Health, Regional
Coordinator sponsored a successful "Tobacco Free" event with volunteer high school
students at the Golden Gate Community Center, where they picked up cigarette butts
off the grounds. Jennifer took pictures to document event. He said he would forward
the pictures to the Board.
. Advisory Board open to limited smoking in certain areas.
. Staff is reviewing Ordinances and will make recommendations for areas to be
designated as Tobacco Free.
. Staff recommended Jennifer Robertson work with the Advisory Board.
. FDOH plan to hold a future "Tobacco Free" event at Veterans Park.
Discussion was made on limiting smoking to designated areas, City of Naples
struggling with banding smoking on beaches, Florida State Laws and enforcement of
Ordinance.
VII. Marketing Highlights
Annie Alvarez distributed some Season Greetings bags to the Advisory Board and
informational flyers on upcoming events.
VIII. Recreation Highlights - Christmas Events
Annie Alvarez reported as follows:
. "Snowfest" had a good turnout with over 12,000 visitors.
. "Christmas around the W odd" was held in Immokalee and the parade had 126
entries and Santa came in on a helicopter. The event included a Carnival with
rides.
. "Breakfast with Santa" held at Golden Gate Community Center attracted 450
children.
. Christmas Events scheduled at Eagle Lakes and Max Hasse and both had
successful turnouts.
V. New Business - Continued
b. Interview Applicants
John Ribes announced the ballot results. The Advisory Board recommended the
following applicants be submitted to the BCC for approval:
Edward "Ski" Olesky
Phil Brougham
Lenice DeLuca
Barbara Buehler moved to recommend Edward "Ski" Olesky, Phil Brougham and
Lenice DeLuca applications be submitted to the Board of County Commissioners
for approval. Second by David Saletko. Motion carried unanimously 6-0.
He thanked the applicants for their time and interest. He urged them to reapply in the
future.
IX. Adopt A Park - None.
3
December 15,2010
x. Director's Highlights
Barry Williams reported speaking with Bill Shafer. Bill Shafer said he had been
hospitalized for a couple of months. Ian Mitchel recommended going forward with
accepting his resignation due to attendance.
Barry Williams noted P&R was going forward with the recommendation to sell beer
and wine at the International Festival to be held at Sugden Park. The Ordinance in
place authorizes the Director to make that type decisions.
The Nancy Olson is working with County Attorney's office on crafting policies and
resolutions to submit to the BCC in January. It will authorize the County Manager as
designee to make those decisions.
He suggested the Advisory Board help make decisions on future requests to sell
alcohol in County Parks to responsible petitioner(s), the event is appropriate, security
in place and liability.
John Ribes suggested Staff screen petitioners to make sure they meet the criteria in
the developed Resolution and Specific Guidelines.
Staff responded the petitioner would have to demonstrate they meet requirements
before being directed to the Advisory Board.
Barry Williams reported an Executive Summary came down from the BCC on
Preserve Ordinance and to incorporate Conservation Collier's use.
It was noted Conservation Collier is part of Facilities Management. Conservation
Collier has been purchasing land for several years and had acquired over 3500 acres.
Facilities Management lacks the ability to manage lands. P&R may become the
manager of the preserve lands in 2012. Many of the properties are near or adjoin with
P&R properties. Conservation Collier needs to make properties accessible by public.
P&R has marketing to let people know of the access, a class system, ranger programs
and maintenance.
It was noted there is Referendum funds for the maintenance of the conservation lands.
John Ribes suggested P&R be given Conservation Collier's staff, have control of the
properties and receive funds. He stated it was a good idea for P&R attain that
position; for recognition and leverage when addressing the BCC as long is not a total
drain on P&R.
Barry Williams stated the City of Naples was holding a Workshop between the City
and County to discuss funding for the City parks. According to the City, a large
percentage of City park usage is by non-city residence. The County currently pays
the City $lmil for receptacle parking per year. $500,000 is paid directly from P&R
and $500,000 from a general fund budget item.
City states $1 mil is not sufficient. County has an existing contract with the City that
includes an index clause. The potential meeting date is January 26.
It was noted there has been talk of making a Countywide Districts for Parks.
4
December 15, 2010
Edward "Ski" Olesky moved Collier County Parks and Recreation take over all the
City's parks plus keep the current parks. Second by Phil Brougham.
Discussion ensued on the unknown factors, i.e. staffing, number of parks,
practicability, possibility and costs. Barry Williams suggested he confirm with
senior management on the Advisory Boards desires and bring back recommendations
to the Advisory Board before the Workshop in January.
Kerry Geroy stated she could not support the motion due to unanswered concerns.
Motion carried 3-2. Barbara Buehler and Kerry Geroy opposed.
John Ribes encouraged the Staff to provide additional information to help change the
Advisory Boards stance.
XI. Informational Items - Read only
XII. Public Comments/Board Member Comments
Barry Williams read a letter out loud from Susan Cone, business owner who was
unable to attend this meeting. (See attached) He noted Nancy Olson has been in
conversations with Susan Cone and is in the process of working the issue out.
Edward "Ski" Olesky moved to direct Staff to bring a report on the issue to the
Advisory Board. Second by David Saletko. Motion carried unanimously 6-0.
Barbara Buehler visited the Tiger Tail Beach over the weekend. She noticed there
is nothing around the concession stand in either direction. She stated there is an area
to contain the alcohol from the beach and park. She suggested consideration be made
to allow the sale of wine and beer at that location.
Barry Williams noted the Resolution covers special permitting of alcohol and allows
sanctioning to concessionaires to sell alcohol.
Phil Brougham asked when the Advisory Board will receive a copy of the Draft
Master Plan.
Staff is scheduled to meet with Marla Ramsey on Friday. It will then go to the
County Manager for review and the Consultant will present the Draft Master Plan at
the January meeting.
Phil Brougham requested Staff provide a copy of the 136 page document after the
Public Services Administrator and County Manager review to allow the Advisory
Board some time to read.
Barry Williams noted this was Kerry Geroy' s last meeting serving on the Advisory
Board, expressed appreciation for her service and insights.
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was
adjourned by order of the Chair at 3:35 PM.
5
December 15,2010
.
COLLIER COUNTY PARKS & RECREATION
ADVISORY BOARD
~'7~"-"
/" "",/ \ \
! (i \
\.~, \ ) d'
""/M'~''-~ ke/---
Chairfu~n Jo~ ;: robes -
''"---------,//
These Minutes were approved by the Committee/Board on
presented ''^ or as amended
1- '1-- \1
, as
6