Minutes 05/19/2010
---,--!'~-
e
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE
COLLIER COUNTY BY: .......................
HISTORIC/ARCHAEOLOGICAL PRESERV A TION BOARD
May 19,2010
~~L~~~~I;~
Naples, Florida, May 19,2010
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Historic/Archaeological
Preservation Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at
9: 15 AM in REGULAR SESSION in Conference Room #610, Collier County
Community Development and Environmental Services Center, 2800 N. Horseshoe
Drive, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
--
Fiala
Hiller
Henning i
Coyle
Coletta
CHAIRMAN:
Vice Chair:
William Dempsey (Excused)
Sharon Kenny
Pam Brown (Absent)
Patricia Huff
Elizabeth Perdichicci (Absent)
Richard Taylor
Craig Woodward
ALSO PRESENT: Ray Bellows, Planning Manager - Zoning Services
Glenda Smith, Operations Analyst
~ Ashley Caserta, Senior Planner - Staff Liaisun Coo
.. Steve Williams, Assistant County Attorney ISC. es:
Date: ~\ \~\ \ \
Item ,: \ I....a -r "":2.. '1=\ \-,
C:pies to:
e
e
e
May 19,2010
I.
Call t.o Order
Vice Chairman Shar.on Kenny called the meeting t.o .order at 9: 17 AM.
II. R.oll Call
The Roll was called and a quorum was established.
III. Appr.oval .of Agenda
Changes:
· Ray Bellows asked to remove Item B under "VI. Old Business."
Craig Woodward moved to approve the Agenda as amended. Second by Richard
Taylor. Carried unanimously, 4-0.
IV. Appr.oval.ofMinutes - April 21, 2010
Changes:
· The attendance status for Sharon Kenny was changed from "Absent" to "Excused."
Craig Woodward moved to approve the Minutes of the April 21, 2010 meeting as
amended. Second by Patricia Huff. Carried unanimously, 4-0.
V.
Gr.owth Management Divisi.on Rep.ort
A. Merger and New Divisi.on Name - Ray Bell.ows, Planning Manager, Z.oning Svcs.
· The former Community Development Environmental Services Division has
merged with the Transportation Division and is now known as the Growth
Management Division and consists of two components:
o Planning & Regulation
o Construction & Maintenance
· Norm Feder was appointed as the Administrator and Nick Casalanguida is the
Deputy Administrator
· Bill Lorenz is the Director of Land Development Services
· Jamie French is the Director of Operations & Regulatory Management
· Planning & Regulation encompasses Comprehensive Planning, Zoning,
Engineering/Water Management, and Environmental Services
· Certain repetitive functions were combined
· There may be further layoffs and an across-the-board pay reduction has been
mentioned
Mr. Bell.ows estimated the reduction in Staff at approximately 70%.
Assistant County Att.orney Steve Williams mentioned there have been severallay-offs
within the County Attorney's Office (approximately 15 attorneys).
VI. Old Business
A. Historic Brochure - Status Rep.ort: Patricia Huff
The Brochure was revised as follows:
2
May 19,2010
e
PaRe Number Revision(s)
Cover Change Brochure title to "Guide to J-listoric Sites of Collier
County"
Page 2 Under ~~Naples," change the order as follows:
. # I - Naples Pier
. #2 - Palm Cottage
. #3 - Mercantile Building
. #4 - Naples City Dock
. #5 - Keeywaydin Club
. #6 - Tin City
. #7 - Naples Depot
. #8 - Collier County Museum
. #9 - Nehrling Gardens (Caribbean Gardens)
. # I 0 - Rosemary Cemetery
Under "Marc.o Island/G.oodland,"(note title change), change
the order as follows:
. #11- Old Marco Inn
. #12 - Caption Collier House
. # 13 ...... Church of God & Pioneer Cemetery
. # 14 - Marco Island Historical Museum
. #15 - Otter Mound
. # 16 - Captain John Horr House
. # 17 - Marco Lodge
. # 18 - Mar-Good Park
Under "Everglades City," change the order as follows:
. #19 - Old Railroad Depot
. #20 - Old Collier County Courthouse
. #21- Everglades Community Church
. #22 - Old Laundry Building
. #23 - Bank of Everglades
. #24 - Rod & Gun Club
. #25- First Baptist Church
. #26 - Ivey House
. #27 - Sunset Lodge and Brown Cemetery
. #28 ...... Fakahatchee Island Cemeteries
Page 3 Under "Ch.ok.ol.oskee," change the order as follows:
. #29 - Chokoloskee Church of God
. #30 - JT's Island Store
. #31- Ted Smallwood's Store
. #32 - Chokoloskee Cemeteries
e
e
3
e
e
e
PalleNumber
Page 3
Page 4
Page 5
Page 6
May 19,2010
(Pamela Brown arrived at 9:55 AM)
Revision{s)
Under "C.opeland," change number to #33
Under "Imm.okalee/Sunniland" (n.ote title change), change
the order as follows:
. #34 - Episcopalian Cemetery
· #35 - Roberts RanchlImmokalee Pioneer Museum
· #36 - Immokalee First Baptist Church
. #37 - Brown Cemetery
· #38 -- Pepper Ranch
. #39 - Black Cemetery
. #40 - Sunniland Oil Field
. #41 - Deep Lake
· Remove Fort (blank)
Under (first) "Tamiami Trail Way Stati.ons," change the
order as follows (n.ote number change):
· #42 - Royal Palm Hammock Gas Station, Monroe
Station, and Weaver's Station
Under (second) "Tamiami Trail Way Stations," change title to
"Al.one: the Trail" and change numbers (#43 - #46)
Under "Keewaydin Club," change last sentence as follows:
"The former Keewaydin Club, located on Keewaydin Island, is
accessible only by boat!'
· Add: "National Register of Historic Places"
Under "Palm C.ottage,"
· In the last sentence, insert "Norris Gardens" between
the words "and" --- "is"
· Change designation to "Designated historic site"
Under "Naples Dep.ot,"
· Richard Taylor will revise narrative
· Change designation to "Designated historic site"
Under "C.ollier C.ounty Museum," Patricia Huff will revise
narrative.
Under "Nehrling Caribbean Gardens:"
· Add "(Caribbean Gardens)" to title
· Sharon Kenny will revise narrative
. Remove bullets
4
May 19,2010
e
Paf!e 6 Revision(s)
Under "Naples Pier:"
. Add "for the Naples Hotel'l to the end of the first
sentence
. Richard Tavlor will research a photograph
Page 7 . Move "R.osemary Cemetery" to far-left side of page
. Change title from GoodlandlMarco Island to "Marc.o
IslandlG.o.odland"
Under "Marg.o.od Park," add period to end of last sentence
Page 8 . Change title from GoodlandlMarco Island to "Marc.o
Island/Go.odland"
Under "Marc.o L.odge:"
. Change from "on January 4, 1965" to "in January,
1965'l
Under "The Old Marco Inn:"
. Insert "wooden" between the words "The" and
"structure" in the second sentence
. Remove "wood" between the words "century" and
"hotels" in the second sentence
. Remove the word "woodll in the third sentence, add the
phrase "and became a hotel.l'
. Add 4th sentence: "In 1927, it was remodeled to a style
that closely resembles the current structure."
. Remove "City designated historic site"
Page 9 Move "Marco Island Historical Museum" to far left side of
page
. Photograph will be supplied after landscaping is
completed
. Still under constrUction
Move "Captain J.ohn H.orr H.ouse" to far left side of page.
. First sentence: insert phrase "as a residence for his
family and himself when they visited their pineapple
plantation on the Island" after 1877.
. Remove capitalization from tabby and remove quotes
. In the third sentence, remove the word "being, 'l add a
comma after census taker, and add an "s" to the word
"customs. "
e
e
5
e
Pa1!e Number
Page 10
Page 11
e
Page 12
-
May 19,2010
Revision(s)
Move "Church .of G.od & Pi.oneerCemetery" to the far left
side of the page, and:
· Second sentence: Change the phrase "build this
building" to "construct the church."
· Third sentence: "This Cemetery is the burial place of
many pioneers significant to Marco Island history."
· Fourth sentence: Insert period after the word "stones"
and remove the words "and borders"
Move "Otter M.ound" to the far left side of the page.
· Craig Woodward will revise narrative and provide a
photograph
Move "Captain Collier House" to the far left side of the page
· Elizabeth Perdichicci will provide information and a
photograph
· Will reference Merritt's Restaurant in text
Change "Original" to "Old" and move "C.ollier C.ounty
C.ourthouse" to the far left side of the page
· Patricia Huff to revise narrative
Move "Everglades C.ommunity Church" to the far left side of
the page, and
· First sentence: remove specific dates -- use only 1940
· Second sentence: "The Presbyterian congregation was
officially established in 1926."
· Third sentence. "The first visiting pastor was Reverend
George W. Gatewood."
· Last sentence: "The Everglades Community Church
was initially a Presbyterian Church, but is currently a
non-denominational congregation. "
Under "Bank .of Everglades,"
· Second sentence: "It was the only bank in Collier
County for 36 years, and the Hubble Oil Company
offices were located on the second floor for over 20
years."
· Fourth sentence: Remove "Ironically"
· Fifth sentence: "After Hurricane Donna in 1960
changed the City's fate, the Bank closed and its assets
were moved to the Bank of Immokalee."
Move "Old Laundry Building" to the far left side of the page
· Fourth sentence: add commas around "The Usevva"
6
May 19,2010
e
Pa .e Number
Page 13
Revision s
Move "R.od & Gun Club" to the far left side of the page, and
. Second sentence: Insert "store and traded with the
Native Americans" after the word "a" - eliminate
remainder of sentence.
. Third sentence: "The Storters eventually owned all the
land now known as Everglades City and sold it to
Barron Collier in 1923."
. Fourth sentence: "He enlarged this property and
opened the Rod & Gun Club which became. .."
. Fifth sentence: remove apostrophe (1960s)
Move "Old Railr.oad Dep.ot" to the far left side of the page
. Fourth sentence: "... along the strip of land along the
current Collier Avenue."
Fifth sentence: remove a ostro he (1950s)
Under "Dee Lake," correct sellin of Lake DuPont
Back Cover Remove the word "and" - HistoriclArchaeol.ogical
Preservati.on B.oard
.
Additional Revisions:
. Change item numbering within Brochure to match Pages 2 and 3
· If a street address is available, place under title in parenthesis and eliminate
sentence from text, i.e., "It is located at ..."
Ms. Huff requested the members to review the remainder of the document and
forward their suggested correction to Ashley Casserta prior to the end of June. Ms.
Casserta will send a reminder email to the Members prior to the deadline.
Pamela Brown suggested adding Lake Trafford to the ImmokaleelSunniland
category.
C. Cultural Arts Village at Baysh.ore Update
(Postponed to next meeting)
VI. New Business
(None)
VII. Public C.omments
(None)
VIII. B.oard Member C.ommentsl Ann.ouncements:
e (None)
7
e
e
e
May 19,2010
Next Meetine: Date: July 21, 2010
There being n.o further business for the g.o.od of the C.ounty, the meeting was adj.ourned
by Order .of the Vice Chairman at 10:50 AM.
The Minutes were approved by the Board/Committee on
as presented , or as amended
8