Loading...
CEB Minutes 11/25/1991 1991 Code Enforcement Board Minutes November 25, 1991 ......'" ;"T'tT"";" ,)~ J.... or r~.c"S . :\1T::',rr.rTr.::s t""i"1 ;-: ';:-_I~LED TO ( PR,F:S:-D;;I~ A DDF?JD.A ............................ \ J \..' .', ~ . , ;" ,).., q ~ " \.)'..).~ j- ~ *('c~ 71 {)Ci-r' Gc; . . "-: " . (iii:-' ; 1 \. ......v'P. Ar~DR.RWS ~7':F"nRl~:v.?i.r"'" " :1 ... .--, ~-... ... ..; '~; -p,{ 1rl (; -j"t'jC;j'; r. ~ ,~li"; l~;' _""",",T_~" "'.....,....,.........~ .... ;_c \) ; \, ;~) l.. ;...;:., \j .l .i 1\0 '.. T T.,. 'r". "'r T""I '..' !~ r ; ;- ~......A".,n':' .......-.....................,."..... r .....' Ii.,' ,.,. :j"""''P ,4 "7" ~': 1'".......... T" ..... ..... ~"'.i""""< J... ;'; i-\ ',-, r'I~"r"\T-.r. tJ ~'": U 7""~ (i: .. . ;.,. ( ~ ' :~.~F?:nA : ,,~ H " ~~ n,-),} --- ;~S. :-J\' .., -,J"'1e ~, l.- ,..j Y->_..or-........... '-' ; ,'-'-, ~-: r;i fJ ; t--.:-; ~.... ,:.., ~~~ t. . ~ , . '"I :1 i (J 11G "F'" ?"'O , ., r ; j-) t (j,rl r1 ~-.. T""""""""',",_7 \Jl, ;IJ'" } "I i I _'r"'" T""IT""I .......T'"'1..,..,,,......,,,...rT1 ."" i t~!'" r' r~ --0;, t"". ,- j ,'" ':"4 j "';"" ~,- ivT A 'fl.'; A "':" T r: ....: ~J A :-,;-: ....\ 0~~7" r.,........... .-. _....... \I'IJ . .-" '~ ; ...................T'"'l...1" f'. j .'1: '-j-/ ;~ J."7"r....i":".....~....... I: . ,.. I; r:l'~:)r)t\j' .. v Pagp ~ CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Ag~tlQA Date: NOVEMBER 25, 1991, at 9:00 o'clock A.M. NOTE: ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. NEITHER COLLIER COUNTY NOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR PROVIDING THIS RECORD. 1. ROLL CALL 2. APPROVAL OF AGENDA 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES September 30, 1991 and October 24, 1991 (if available) 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Board of County Commissioners vs. Moses W. Howard CEB No. 91-019 5. NEW BUSINESS N/A 6. OLD BUSINESS 7. REPORTS Request for a corrected copy of Order Imposing Fine/Lien on Aspen Lake Development, Inc., be signed CEB"#91-006 N/A 8. NEXT MEETING DATE December 26, 1991 9. ADJOURN (Regular Meeting) 10. WORKSHOP A. Discussion of Form of Motions B. Identification of Respondent(s) (i.e., partnership, corporation, etc. ) C. Discussion of site visits by Code Enforcement Board Members D. Discussion of the POssible methods of computation for the number of days a violation exists between the compliance date and ordered by the Board and the Order Imposing fines. E. Modification of Code Enforcement Board Ordinance (88-89) to increase amount of maximum allowable fines to $500. -- CC:)F S7'J~nRr20l~~;J'":""' ITEM: MOTION: CASE NO.: RESPONDENT: LOCATION OF VIOLATION: __.__ ~_., '___','_,___""uv., ,-,. u '~'___ gO~NTS: '!:)"......~~ r,\; ~ J-: ;.: (-..-.. \jr r:n7",~,T~R r: n '~r;'J7Yv~ *** Agenda for November 25, 1991 Made by Mr. Pedone to approve the agenda as pre- sented. Seconded by ~.!.:..iUll_iam~. Carried 6/0. *** 91-019 ~'!()SP,S !.;,J. 1."1 ('}",,:<-; S';) rl ~,. <'~ , ',~ D rl ; f-.l~:"; ; ....... (1.l, - . ;:;. , , {j : -, P \M :~~ <::' 1.> (l ,i' ". F.) t 1 :-: e1] 1" () 1 ()g' ~. SIr i; t' rH(";,; ""l '':/ i '"-. ~,..:; '---:: -('Prl_ t f~<~ ! L,dr B (JWril--' [1 or, .'J ..:... , . \-\!H.S nlS , ,-, T 'l [-j \/.....r-i "-'S .. - (~ ' J e~, t ~: ,-'J! p d w) ~ I~ t- ~l. e r , , u. <-. \, f )'_0\. ;- t ~ . . .'-'. : ....... ., :,;1,; : --: I ~; I r' {o Y' J': l-' ~- p y' j R (' : ~ l j ,",' <"'i , ;'1 I ~; ~~ p d () l? ~~ 1 { J l .. r. "'\.-. ;'1. ; rl i ".it !., \;;,! !j ..--~ . i ~ lj(J~,~ j r ,', {.I r , l'--'; . , ()(: . . ~^ j '--. i. S_ :c':i '. M d_ ~rJ -i. ;._~ :::~:--: fUI t ~..{) TO '1; rl \ ~ r; ( H~ P r { .-. ,l'~ll 1 :., f~ r: ,-j (1 ~~~ d -r 1') a. t () -r'~ : r:d:-..)~ Nt.~. 'l~ --(;;"":j" d,r1,(l rn::-:(-)C:(-'\f~(l~!(l {J r'~.~":qi :~, d; '":1 (-!~l(1 -....P(lUp~1 f()~:-' IJ,j.:J'" ;:;~':I"'" C~~r)()r'-~ F~{J '-';.-:11 Re:,::;p()DeJent- ;~::; ;-.ld'(IC~ 7.~__~4 S,~t"";t~f)r'?; rf;:;nlCJ\la1 of r;T'~,1- ~ :"1-; fe-I :~ t d, I-p;.'!p! :-', . , \: 'I () j ~~ -'. , )n i :'I:~t~ '~. .... , I) . ~ r- '_.J I ,_ ;:-:.;.~~:. ,::" [W d No! i c:p O-r""(~ inAnce c; f C"(-jIl"l.I'lli=-.' i Ci ~ 0 t ~: CJ n ;-'i),f:;;" of qO-7~1 Spct ~.CJ'~-l .- .., ,.......... .f,.:" "i ~), -, . ',='mnva 1 f) [ t r~ps rJc'iCH' ;;:'i -!- - f:1 ~:l c~ '\; j () ] at j Cl n s ;,J f t(l ISS'I--,?i';( ~. "c. ii R:) ~ i () ~ ! J ':)(..::. () r~{3 -1. -Cc2l1C;P ........ ".." '1:--+1; S ~'1,~ ~- i {)n s G; 7 8, (":f. l{} g. felt' n(tc"-JL:~'q~." :"...{_.{~ .i p U ( ,1 cO: ~ ~; \ <~~ eJ f~ 1 J '<. "; S ; ') n ~ J r 0 I'i f",i. !". t- Y rJ( . lfll J ' C'. ~ :;) ; ,"i i of'; (;,.; ; ,(-~;,,', (<1 . \ i p, i" p() ()'; r "'e'1 . ]:p, f' a re two ~~~ ~ : eOt~{1 ,.1.:,: (~(; "{..f~"-;T: : r\g i) t-~1H( )' f d. ~ () -: t 1""eF~ s 11, \-} ,~. r "'.... ,J () J !''oI( 1 \ j i. t... Commen,cemPti t , ,"~ ", '1 t c) i) ~ ~.; ~~ -I j <0 . 1, 1-" ~ c~ ~ ra ?ermi t: s . - f'" C.fU PS ~ ",o-.J' ;---< \ ';~r :/:-' ,/: (; Tri'! -; ;Jns; l'~ ./:-~, ;,di)- ~.~ J ( 1 P F?l f () y c: t~ :T1 F:;. '-I i ,-' , . ~j f:.l ,... \j ~; c~ Ci:n C.~ ~i 'c' ;., -:~ t' ..:-, ~_ ~ (} ~..;; .... ; ( , {1 () f) \1 t-. , ( ('jl";!-.; ; rl,,) . .. ;';p eY~r)] ~; .~ , , , !' t ~ ;- f-' ;'"~cl tl1at ::-:;l- c~ f f o t ~ P;-'~I;t : ~'-"U i. (l :.., t- ';'i~().'!'-l ~:~; t ., ~ ~: ~ \iilj:,..-:i. j{)tl (Jf n:tlt1p l' h,...:j,.D. (),ne 0 f'<3i ~-tC:tf 'ct ; f"-J . f-"\/-\ (1~nCfl t-e: u'::';~:LgPR1 ("j "!:~e ~'~!n'~lc.luncPfj . i ; 'ri ~ ~ ."~ t \ -, .:-. :'.,; \1'1. "i ~.:..~ {j', ;.;' " , , ,'! ~ . , \ , {i i I' ~~. i"~'\Jl,.t-'" ~ :l.- __ .L '" nine '" {~ :.:.; (-,: C (j " , -, , pO ~ .;,~; 1 J ; ~ ci L _ . ; ~ ! I ': I ~ t-'Il(::_.o ,- ;-; ~ C)1--~ 0 FdU(~ "; -~~~ R7JFGPrFMFN7 ~nARn OF rn~~ ,.........'...T,r~... .~( N'OV"l'~:'F:?~R ?!=) .. qg'" A:~;~~".):";,l <"~~ l{~ f~( -C,;r 1_ 0 I r, t :."-. -; C: -1 -; ~ { . ~ '. v' ~', r) :)~~t-.' \/t-1 ~ C) _.. .J _ ~ , It} i, l. t=~ {J. on vJas -(. ~l-i -n sf' t- c '7 (:1 \l e ~~'i ()f~-1 i' ./ : (: 1 d, 't :~,;- i /: (.~ f) ~ r ~ ~....I { " ": ~-t1 ': (). j ~ c: 0; .. iii.hl r: ( ;~; I) :l( _ , . ; f~j f; C f,;,,); i.. ~ s i tF' (H-' ~\,-( i ( l ,'ell"' ~':~ . J i.., 1" '-' ~ 't 1 , ( ~ (~ (""1 ; . .c l: I ...... ,., "t.., , .. '.'! '-!.... ~'"'7>> t ) {r i 1-.... 1"''' ~ "I. "l '.AI: j i' )V.J s ': Lf., t... : ~ fi (' n'~ ~,~ f-~ ,JefLtit ion Compos:Itp .,. I {--~ v ~ ~t,;:::._ , r.. ,. ... ." ; )f-:-~ \/ ;,.., i ,'; ~ f-) ~.:.-< .'-' . j ; f I ~.~ , i ('J -:- : -,.".;-,'(J(") ;!; : t-\ "I c1 , ,vj: '-; I.: ; .J f-l \ q. .co f. ;~ '.! J ~ ~ ,..'." i t ~.j .,.... " t\, i :" n 'i .......-- -. - t'" [' .; l. J r' l'-'~ r) , ~ ]rll'.1 F-t ;:.=-;, 4 ...... ,~ .'":l ~. ~ i r. ! Ci'; ('.~ n~ i";; ~-~ - 1 C? t-~~ ( ~ M r~ :t' "'" L ~ -~,.- , .L ('"~ : t-' \. t..J ~ -: ~().(i "\/(1 ";_(;f-l(1 (i~j"-.~:i-~prqf-~~.)"t R.p~:--;r)l.')'l(11~")nt n.at l,-,e f(O)';- (1 ir-l PIH--J"t ;- f~l ~ ,j J J- l- -,-4 \..':"=,,, I i'hp \l'~O_l;il'.~C)~\ W~:-; .C .: ""'d t- t.~,-:~ (H.\i:--je1-' W'd,S 9 i \:'t,~, [) ~ ) ~" j {I(! fjY'l ,,,1 rl Y n.. 1 991 : ;:)1'" corcech"~d by ;':I)\il"nilJP' '1:':; (-j[ 1'< L) ;,ace c:y: OctCI~":;t--~ ;. j .. 1""',"," ""'-1, .-'" v ~ 1_1' ,::;... ;---;: I () '-.; .If.: (i ..... !l'V{~I'~ t r , r I,J;,.(li,i :11, ("-..; : r (;'~ j l:'F:".-.;.l.'.... -t (J \, r 1) tl{--) t ~~ y ~.~( ~ , - , 1 '"_! I (; 'c' -:-'iY'"\i' ,(-"- ,: J 11 {-. .. :t , , ~:('lP rF2~3\~~j. i- ()f \.-\if'! i {;: t-' "T~ j s t p cl ~ , :-... (-; -"-' ( 'f-) i J. ,__ _ , ...,.... \ -.' I.. (i , _' ~~- ~ - c, 'qq, - gq' -, JU \^L, s t 1; rt t- :=-~ -j C': .1" .co 1.1; c: 1---: ct 'it. (ll ~ (! .; ..~J ./ ~ ,.. 1. :..... C OJnr)(~ -:""1 ~- ~H ~ -, 21 -1,1": -1 "" " ;... llY bot}: par'tips '\/er' !- j jHt-=:' . ,j\ 1')":t1 j.Jjs ~ r.J(:j ~ C;-:j L~'. Fr'~T/i rCJ}:lrl~li~ d 1 : ~J'rl r{) r-' }Ii; k'-,p K 1. rl)y \/t::~r'; f -:' :~){.~ t.".,.~~ J ~ {.,:). <jP:-~: .. U~-;t ;l)~rl.: -it;ns rH ) ~:;l :.~ t d t':lP (""1 'J (J , ) -"I!.] , i. J~' ,... ., ._,,~ l_ \. ~ , rt (' ,.~ 1''/1-(' .! (. d: i)~"1()! Pt."":! ~{J t. ",;-'t--o .. t)~;;';;; S~" ;:;~:}~ ~ j 'nl~ Sc i l.i , , .....:,( ; , \ ;," t:'FlnH)<V~'(~ fr.OIl: ".. - ...; '--; . T..j rl ~ cat' C:..." l I ~~ i ; ~ ,.:.,~ ( ., !. r~ pes t\1y- ~~ j runnel " ~ If H i., A. '2 ri. 1.:'11.,~; v~. ~31Jr')ject _ L. _ ._. .-, :--; { (J i) .. "d'r' f'r)'i , -';-i')':"i h,. n..~. :., , i; V~i "t,' : fJ L~;, li'~ , . SL; r}J:::.JC-' P~-i (,i ..t.'_ .. i. ~ I ~ nn 80 . " ,j ,I pagp !-)>1 C 13.r1.< c(n'~ r- r'liip<l ...\! t~W r,~~ n {] 1,: I ' , , V}r~ ' 'I'jf-'c:;; . p;; ,-; (: , ~ t:) r3 ': 11 rl t . , ~ I:P ~ ,", ., "" -!-- 4 . .i '" I r--_' l ] ('; , ~ 'I t J iJ r' ( )~.; e c -;:J. t i ( ;; rr '1 PI I Pc. \ ~:. . , , I. t I ;.-:t l. ; r-.' ,~; ;.' iJ :'<-j , :-. ~, '-''-'t :(;C; ~. r~<, ""':'~':) ; (l':~!,!(,:F~. ) j- !.-'l, l<lS;P 1(.... d:~ f ci -r.: 1 "; ... r; ~ C:.-l ' :':,---, ,. . . -, , 'i)Y \" (-' rr;: ; , ,/(-", ; l;I'(}lH,;,;;.,t<.: ~ ;:~TI.(l aisc) . , \ '1r.... r.c;p; r t~ t-.. :"1_ L:: : ;l~ >, j 1- 1_ f.) i \,{-: Cn Ml) 1. d -'~g' ~" 'L,/ - ~ ,~ - <' (J j lIH~I~, ~ 1 p P-;,.Z> '", l r ~"(Jl-1 11-) 1.t.P~-~ 1. (1 t '--,t,~ :~i"'v CCJ(lt:, st'H-- .;nIt"ri.leo H i!.~ ~()1' "lC. " , ~ . . ~.. ( -{ '. '1:--" r { . i .. j~. ; t : (_(Ulst~. ~--ut{:::. r:: () "1 f~ q n - (' .~ ".. r, ;.r ., - ;-;.; - ~. F ',.i , t--.s " CJ; f-' F;< 1'1 -j!] . r T-; fJ I 1 _~ }'1 ~ ( t ~ (1 r-. -t p 1) t 1 CJ r't l,l ,..{)~ t .t.... r; { :; ; IH J ~<.~ -n I' A'~ rl. ;--lll ~~.Ut'>- .............~'"'~-....,..........".~ ~,I',,;i'1.)t\\,~,j\'~,:\ ; ~n.4?~ n? ~rr:-,:-.~~~ ^-"--"'-. ,."'.----'-------~.-M-.-..-_'~.~___..."_M"______.___------__._.'~_M. ;--' t-~ i :. f> l <"i i ,'; i:--' '_I ',} , I ~; '!+..l: i' I : ~ ~ I Ie) , . , L (-' :' './ l.... , ; ),1 ,'t' ....~. ~ ().rJ~-~~f ~i i i r:~ _, . Ii: ~~; , '-.; ; 'o! ~ , ,-"S; 'j l't-". ,r t.-..I";l(l, IiI (-11> J ':1 ()l)Sf~ r'\/pd c: ~r;i'-:~"'{ ....;c;\ r::,".,~~,' ~ ~ ... .j .. ."'"l.~" . , " : ~ t. I ;: , ~ _ ,:..~ (} .~ ""c.-:.:;,. .i.; ;"':"';':') . ~-. .c: ~~ pc1 -}\ ~ ; ,.', ); i>~ { ~. , (~t) t- ~ \ ~~ r' f..:&f-l "'; ;'"'; ';; () WI ~~:: -t- i,) , , f"~ m (J\7 dJ '[ : !'-'l: If-- , (,1U I , . (j (_-1 [ ., ;,-1(, , :t--~dl;n \ r-J ~ :---,i.J-~j~c:~ ii~ c ~ .~ () ,~ " ~ {J; ~ i I f-' '~f-;,... . , :~[; -:;.~y'k (l'lt:;ost -icjnj;'~g wl1et1'-)f"""' ~-~tp. }'!MO (}q :~ I Lt-_.l ln i l 'j U(:i i "'I (J"rl ~r1(1 rl-.~'::;l(1 tl 'U ",rl; :..:;i'd1'~. () i"'_ T' IJ r. f) 1 p, t " st;3nd U , ) '"I" ., j (-- (1, ., ~ J ".- ~ , '-.)\i\j'.!' . t; .,.. ~ J i , ., ~ an HF- ; d T..... . , . r [J'.,. f-Ij' .-. ., '- i t"e}(") -\7 rl. yo ; (; -; ; '~, fJ -j ,(') l' ~ f ~ i ~ {"; ,.'.. i ,-': 1_ u ~ i ,--' t ., ; ~...-:'; { . (' ; i; : :~ , t ; ::' y' t--./ ,.:... i-~ is, C" ( " , l-) ; ~ , , '- f}f-l c.;;,hjt-'(. i 1;-1 .it}Swer .,....; . q '\.1 (~ , ( (-J 1:_, . ~ j, ri ~ f',). ~; ( 1\-,,1 (-- R !'~^l rl -;p,-: hi :!, .;:";f-~ r}--"()(:t"t..{1f~(-1 t-cJ P-xf> 1 a i_rl n~Pt'-jS-\J r'~~~.:':; .--...: \in I ; ..'~ 1,-_1; (:' 1:0 r}.l~ Howr;rd 't' \; ~'/~--"' t ;-"H(-~:..'; h {~ :~'l) {) ~ J_' \ 1. } ;r' i ) 1) ~ r t :.;' t }Jf~ -: (' -'.-.f.::....nr-i;,.7,;:) ~ ~>Ii . '.,":, ! ',J' n : ~.". ~"-'., r~lrl1' : -.Ie : .~ r:~ '-Il; 'n ~;"J: 1 c;~ ,;~1jhj,->cL proppc'!~Y f~P ,.~ ,= ();Fld OD .i. hp ~H (~ ..." "'-- ~ ~"';.:):1 ..~ ",. , , I j rl .:.~ as we _ ....L ~..,. i t j . ,r- ~'I~ ,"le c' id 1. !'iMp '-', . l, Jl~ , , (-~ .;-; (~ ;; '\; "'7 :,-j. . t 'i i, I ~~ i ,~ '" rr J' t-; ;.. ,I r'O .'"; ; r r c \/1"0I-'t a I j on :n "1 ~: t~ :_:1 r :':" . ... ~-\ J ! tJ. . d C'C{~ \1r con f t'tnPc:l s ;. te on MdY i"~ c) ;-~'I iT';l !' t. p cJ . K :rby '~<lbj PC t \,' : () 1 .-): 1 (). ..::.... ;j "-' L , \ i1 t-> r f)j t~ , i (",& \/ r ; ,', ~ '_-..., I ;. ["pc;: ,If-' off- tu ~..c; '1 f' . Ht")wa r'c) ; '-:-: t "1 r:; ( 1 CJ f ; \; ~ ~U.(-J 1. n g- l.he sitl=' ,) r-o"'j ~ '\.jy. T:iY;t")y S-~-d,te(l thd; D(. [,-j( :.; admit b~; ng Uo.spon:::., j b".=, fo ,"' tTPPs cd 1Y'piY' initiaJ meetjnG_ eJ i (-) : t-1 f' t',~: ~'i ,; a l {')f ~~1 Jrn 5 :.~; :~ i . Dr. How<3J'I"l .intpr "c.(;[,-'(; '.'rl , , ,"; I l , ~_ -; r.~ 'r (j l'i7r ~ 1 rl (':.:" .. I)rl')r)~)' , " t-..I, a ; t....~ . (: i { .:.., cf I .. c.liiy [.1-'" (: \/ j, :-< i "h : '~'"'le(3 ';,( :-... ,..: f ,- V,,ji Howard f) Y' () j- f-':\ ( , ,- ~l (") or-. ~i p j--_H....; Vv'~ _:,,"'.;...::. ?p~:;rJ~-) (Jt-.. F) \71 (1 e j ! t, ~ .;.'\ i '. t (: . '-)i...l t'~ 1 C"i l , , l ( ;W t-' ~J rod /c~-j .l.. Ic:1'~I(-"{1 1) (, () {:~ Fl ed "I ,..~ g' rl ?')(J , ~'i;( n ;-I~ c~ (-) ';' m ~~. .;: p , (jt:"l \P 1 r' 1",.~;:, ~-: {) ~-, .c -. ;~.:P r1 t l~<~ t ,. , , \i i () ; c'-; :~f:)'('\ , r-:l. <' J '.(),1 w~--)s :.c--i: .1 y\ 1"\j.-~ y-t ~ , I .' ~')2 r t ~~~ ~\I: <,-j 1 Y1g () ...., d \ ~ji,~'rl~' (~.(1In. t t j n,9 (";.J PdJ' t}1P ] anc' I Hnc1 that :--) }--)e.'-j r-' (j -..i , :-\ jUt 1 \i ,;... {~ l~:t -i f, i:-':_J ;'"'j}; j (.;..;0 ( ~ 1 '~(ii 1 "! () r~' v~~),.:h j nlP r:hr~ hpct:Y'~::,a''l r l"rn~~l-' ! 11 ('11 '; ~.~ ~.; ~ n rH 1 ;'(i 1)"1 .~ s t- r <1 t j \7 P f-3'-,j I 1';'1-" i' 'p ,s p~r. } t'r-p(). ?;::.u~ 4 r:nj? ~!;JF()Rc;F~1RN'T RnA ~~ :jF :--:rJ7",-;-, T SR r-:nrI7'ITTy'" ---".----..--.---- _.~'--_._--'-'--,~,-..., NnVRV~~~ 7~~q~~ ?; 1 :-" ;~-~ij ("1 1 t- ,I) /'f'~(lUI-'~':, r (:"'I''',d ;:'lrl n .,.. -- .- J..-1 r', ,-:] ~ \,j:-~ .. "Yr." :( i l1 (1 ~'i i)7~t-)rff-lt'~(J }-!.i~~ { t':'_'{~:_~j' , j n . :-:'~ t:.ll"}, ~t~~':;-:~-; )(3t:~ \.'i: '~,.; (',It' t-CJ-:";-n~-'y.. ~</-r-- ~ K 1 ;'-';'-]'j' \(e('~~,,'~~_::-.., ".~~. ..;, ~'~./:," 1;n) :'.~:':~ ". i.;;': t-lH~ !:?D;-Jj~(,~t l:.Jrf)l)f~!"Ly 1H'~ }'C::{f), rln.1y pxaJ1l-j-'lPt1 tl1f-:~ r:.itF' by dr.: \I i <:0 pdS l- ; ,.. P'i'li. :~OI1lPt ime in rv1ay he [(nUll" certaj:n l'('pes 1--~d.(J 1~)f~prl relnCl"VPf] aT)(;, j"tl(lg:lng })y t"'he 1";(11) i pm!:: III ..d. i hp :',d te, de tprm ;'l.pc1 thpy hd(] bepCl : i '=-, ~ :;::~ d c; -,/ t~ 'r i \. (1 ; 110" f-}) p..~ -(" y"' () [} t S 5 D 1), r '; ,-' 9 (l I) ~ ::...:-i ,( ./ i, ~ 1. r"j ~ lj Y R. e S I) c> 11 (J P!"l. t ! ~~ a t 1: f) r i'J P'i: JV11,. K; rh:i r;0{1f i ymprl that the top photograph 011 page 43 of Composite Rxl.,ibii "Af' depicts trees which wer'e T-)}"'CJ1J.VYj-j- (-)titC) il-lt.... ~-~;(ljJect. I)-;-.')rlP~-;;~, Mt rj ~,r-:it~f" ~.~<c)tp: t--h~t"" c)i---Lly i-he r~r\"-i'l]t'r:~;:::< ()f :)t--'rld l)inps-; rel)resf'~()1. t'he protectecl t :r;r'f~S wh i en \,";f-q'f-> a J Jeged 1 y rernovp\1: t hrl~. ,') P, \Ai,'1.:-'; the n:umbp r [) r i r'pl-'S funnel j n the .p i 1 es nr;(Jrl (ilS jnlljril ":J1Sl'll~~ct-i()ll; ~'nc1 t11at t'hp nl1rnl-)pl" .~; 11C;;--' rl(Jd(~drel)r1es~1 ~...; ~'t-"'_.':" v.J~),: (:h d_,ied la_tpt' as .;), ('f"~:;lJ.l (- o (~~-'i;t:"j0~ , . ,1 t- ;-, f~ -j_ (' .r.' 00 1 ~ \1,'--::; t" p ; ',-; ~ , - -- L) 'i t--~ CriV;:i t ; ()'(l b'C1"tl;};;t--1j1 : \.11, . KjY'l-'~1 t~)(rJ~rl: t.....:--7<.; fC);jt:f1 '.~ l-' ' , F; ( I \: f.' (-) t-':' i-'-'t,) j'i'lptnCHl T1P l1.sprl 1 c} (1e~ f.....~"i!)-:~,.i:. t(~ l}-H-l l',:lf-n'l 'J~ 'i./i'::'Q"~-t<'1:-:\/l-" {It-~l)r'i<.:..~ ,... ':i;;-; ;'jf..lo ~-;11JJ~c'i site a.s (11){lCISPI] \.' ~J~....;tl~ h ,!..lJ1.' , r ; l; C' l ~.. <..~"? .. : t-~j . r , ~- \. r I rl ~ (1. ~- ~ r-1 ~'" { . ( j (! ~ ;t.; r. t-l C : 1 ; 0 ~ 1- I :...;) , " w-~~.~ :) n'l~ i , -"~>l-~ ~-~ I.l '('flf:'-'-' t-y.. [J i ~ .irlg ;; ~J" :',..;/""" i .f-~ t-'hF~ 'P(')VJd; "I ('IP~~' 1;~f-~ ~;':~i"j;~i~f-'( h t'1l.sh rl ,1 s; bseqller ~. "Y 1:. ReSI)e) n (1 ; nut (l tv;- f" r: ~ (~ ~..~~-; r!~ _-j rl }"\ nr't" ('~d (1 P,xc:f.)'t"llt-:.:.;; f;o"()nl h1~'~ ~';;;';t-d,tplnp-nt c(-)rtt<=1.jnt~t-] :,Ji"l [)t:-.;g-P q ()f C();~')r):'~~::;i.t.f" ~)?'L.1~;.:.t HA" "!J-;;-i-l Oi(lf-l-r1t-:f_")p(~ t-~-le tYI)RS elf t r c~e~.., h,p 11 rJ.J ,... t~j If; ~ -l ,; r.:...{? (') n; i) t'. B (}wa r (1 'So; [) l::~ t) rlf? r. t' .'Y' . Hf-~ \7F'l";_ f ~ t.;] ~!~-'i\7 ~ 01'1:.) ('iI)l"J -: 'i Pll. f ;.--:1< ~,~:().(] r:H~~ ;lsona 11 Y' recej,!t-'.tl.co R,j,'(; oe~'rn.i[:. He r;unfjrmpcJ t.h,"lt [Jo'1Ue j() c)f CC'iql'()~.;_it.p. ;:~-..:~1-1i'nI1 "T\" vJ;-{:~::' (-=:~ (1ljI)1.ic;a,tr~ (Jf tJ1F BUrTl Pp t'mi i. he hrl.(J r'pc,~; \!f"(} , I'n Y' P r} l~;: 1- () nlF,~ 11 r p (j t (':8 -t ~:_;t~J. f 31')(} n (. (;1-1(\ . y'rn;i.r") T'<:~Zc-:4rl"~S I t...1r ~ l:~-le d.gcP~ln~ll. t- (~~-\ t.~ j-'ec1 EllWMr'd w<"!s vague ,Ane] sppcifically whAt trees t 0 1 P iY\/ P . I,a. -irlhart c(){n- jn t c) 1)1~ t\Nt~eTl }-I j Fj- never told what :-'pps that he was tor'emovp and R{~ -r ~ r-' I' j I I U Me _ C lri .k rlUt::: 1[') : ,'} [>dg-P g ()f ques1iUDPd whe~her ComposIte Exbib.it "A", the sta1pmpnt that Dr. Page !) c oJ2~__ EN F O.:~ C E~:'I.gJ~J:: _ .B-9J\ R.Q_(]E._0()C,X. T ~ R en IFJTV NOVFMH~R ?'fi,. i 99i Helwc) d }-:;"H-1 S}-'lcJwn }-\-irn w1'"j:c:-, -t-r;f-~p~,,::; to rpnl()\lf~ 'W;...jS .~n d('e,uate. CHle, h) whi{1, iv','. T,.~jn,1.'d"!. "epljed t'-,~,. n-; :;()w;1T(1 c]-Id nc,! fJ(j";ni f)"iJi tVJ)"jc:h 1--cpps tC) rerOC}\iP~ .. n response 1:0 Re~;;p( Jll() F' (I t ! sat i 0 rney, ;vir. La j Ilhd r' i staipd he S;lW 1( }c~d~~ dumflPcl on the sllbjec~: propcc'rty which appeared to be tot. scrapings, but. saw no dl-tlJE-t..l t;"'(~'1f:;as: -l,}-lat hp (3i(1 renlC)'7f~ Sla_sll .Pj,'r1.p from l-h(~ :3uL,jec~t r)rc)l)el'tt-~l; lll;t (li::.;;r)1J.1~pd the nun1ber Cl'](' tprl: :1,.;-Jt hp vJri~; .',ot awar~ that S J ash P j nes were d protec-:;f-pd. Sr)eci.c:~:~ ~t the t -Imp; {,}-lri'f llP c)1(1 r;pm'-)\l~ CVr>r'PSS 1 r'(->e.s r~.'Olrj (hie" s;lbject pr'('pert-y hut 'N,',", lJn.AWd.t'P ()f the exact n"U;;~l')F~:r; t->,tdt h~) (1c}f7~s rl()t 1'plnembf'Y' navi ng y.'emovPeJ riny Wi llow trees; th.:J.1 hR is llncer'ta i.n about whet:hpr' nr'not hp remuvpd ~I(aplf' treps f-,.,(,,-~ ., P '-, ite; that theyp was eas.j 1,:/ over one hundrp~ Melaleuca 1 r~es f'emoved from the s :1 f~; ,-j \(1 t .ha t the genera J flU rpo~,p l; f the job was [) l'PlTl(')\fp t'he .i~pldIf-~lJ(;d tCf~E~S a.n.d. tl,e scr'U() l)rush~ l~ F -1 - P -(' :-; F-- -~ ;"1 9 ~ :;1.,'J :1'(- TJ r T: ly,it M ~ A.clrn f t-te~(] 1:--ld'\/ i I'~g ~_'l_f";".1fj r'(1 1 (ld t t.l-j Yt2r\1C)\i'p Me lc;J 1 t?l~Ca ~. -("r'-P::-. . Vrilcarcpl, Dr. Howard l'hl-~ ;::.., t- (~ t' po }~<~H.3 0 flt"'CJg'r-'anl ,L1 ,',: "f-~ caIl_F!cl tl:f-j St(-1'~-F< 'Fin r'(;;;,~O, 1 "'X Dep2 t' ("rnf"q t- dJH) was J_ n fu "mer) thpyvoie ;', ro~. f1Fll:1ing the p.~'nv,'",:; 1(J "~~j:ifJ\lP \':f->laleuca trees (i1 the t imp but r'pli3h:~d cer.tain cnntr'rictors hdd 1>"., Pf11J i Il'fi'iP Y"l ~ " !, (; -'f" "q( I..' t' \' 't tr'I~{':~S;. tllrlt })~ WhS IJY'f'\7 j (Jf~(3 , , , {,v " ~ ,) {i} ., 1 it' r' f~P:1_( )\/ F} t 11 (:. -; i ~- 1- ~) r ,~1 I" i ;_. 'J,; :: ;~1 {)~~~" ~/p -; ;1, 1Pl1i..r~ "f~(~!., rl (,(1 7(JTiY La j nloart was on J.1_ ",! \ [Jd, ~ . '. ! JSI I.n. r'eSr){I,'-lSr.:' -[(-I 1 ~:.s: r:1,i-t'{)~lp"ey; was 1-) ~ f~ 1 J T1 rJ f':' Y' S 1 ~ 1"1 (1 .~ " ; ~.J t}1 M t l) p .;'("j..: : ~ ic> ,.. : r'{">in;-),;-~ . , .. -" ., - ., ; ;-;~ :",;~ ;.-i;.f::~lJCc~ D~. H{)war~ rip~~I~{J had Y'eq.upsjf'rl Mr'. . > I'. SlJhjp(:t [lr(l:jf-C; ! r'pes r Y"-)if '-- ~, - i._;'~ Tn anS"vll~.i. 1" "l~-' r;,-:.:;'~<" j i-'owarc1 st-a!.pd he g(-d Hid'} a.Yid dif~ J'"l(j-l r'etnPHll-)pr \N~---ldt (-i.P ;:";Ff,j(:1 at the meetjng wiih (.oi,nty stdff. He sti'd-ed t}~cd what- IS ).'dPPC>";"s 1:--, cOilfi";(;rl1inn without compensation. 0-~j-" C J d!'R I)(} ."j"fJ 1 prJ () tj "f- t'ha~-: ~}y;.. t. CJ [J 1'.'" t=a 1) t3 -r.t.... t; i t~ S 1 j)) j,~ c t 1) Y' () r)e r t y hi) t (It.'t'~c1slo apt .:1 permit to do 1-1 P (ji (1 n () t . H () vJH .:-. (1 ~: ;.:c ~.; .:~.,", -l g;l t- [01" commet'c lB.] use; so arId; 0 f course, III response to M7.. r:'-)'i~:.~lt-'i-' s PC)!=-) i t- i 1)/). ga t lCin J. , _ __ ..... _ _,.1 t tJ t,lJI\ l dl i. PPdo:ne, Mr. r:.1 a t'k :r'p Jayec1 the ! h.t:1 tit j s t }H~ R~s L)()(1<'11~"n t- 's () 1) 1 sompone regarding preparation of 1 ()(l Y'ai~ht--:t r' t:'h.AD t-1:'""lP r;()1);-~ t\/ d() j "no- . .- a pIan f;,-OJJ' rn~.l :g(~:.t c c>r.1 Sill ] t ;i"(\ i T..vO '(.k . ?agt~ Fi COD P,~;i~ QBc:.~13.~::Ji'i_ ..B'2.~.~~_0c._._C:.0':::.~I'::5 ~-::.Q:lwr '~.. NOVP,MBFR ,--- .- , .' -.:~..,.,-,_. .. qQ-: M-fl. Clrlrk-Y;f-~(.() r~it-'-'-:HJt~(1 f-;-H-:" RC)<J:r-'d fine) th;~t ~-i \7-:Cilc:;- t10n ,1;e; ,~;,.1"~: Ie) which RF'spunc3ent's a.t-1or'npy voiced "l-'jt",! ~()T' to snch a f.;r:;d;.nL) OT' tf\f. G/'c'F',d~.:; that if" ::iy'y:.h:nu ,11,1 (JC[~.j" 11 W,-lS d'~i(;in;"'c:; <lllC:; thei'eforp; ;..ny 1.".',',21 i.:l.' ~::;110Hl(1 hp '.'Pds[)rk;~11~' T,..1;,te:l ru a ~ 4 , . I . c'.') t-"J l~ I n T r:;: t ~':"'; \/ l Cl ;' <_:I: \ I (J.n . MP'IIQJl: Made by M.:r~..~~g_Qne that the Findings Of'l!'a.c:::t:.i gg-~.c::_.!~~.!9_1}_~..Q:f'_b~w and Order of the Board in Case No. CEB #91-019 are that this cause came on.Jor 2..l!..QJ.i.c::h~_~_r ip.g before the Board on November 2~ 199 L..,. and the Boar(:t_h~yt~!SL he~1"_g J;est imony'.1J,!!~_~ ()a.1:J.:lL!"~~~ive!L ~Y.t9..~nce, and heard arguments :r.E:!spec ti_Y~.J:.Q.,a.l!._a.p.2.!:opr !~ t ~ m~,t 1:~:r.~.1 ,. thE!.:re:UP9n -~.!?~~-~_s..._JJ;_~_~J.~gJ_~g,~_9_L._Fact, Conclus.tQ!!~_gf._~aw and Order of the Board as follows: that Moses W. -,._._...._-"'~_. .., ,_.~_.."..,..~., "". "'..- -., "'_.--."~-'^ --~~~'_._.~---_.__._--,-'^'",. ''',,,'.-'' """.,,... "". ~.._........ - "...,......... ._,",. ..."...,,_... .. _ __V" ......._......_..........,~_..,,__ .___...__".._ 1:i9~^a.!,.q._..1~L !J}.~._.Q~t~t~. ..9J.rf:!..c::() r.d .()f. ..1:_h~. .s_~.1? 1~c::t_];lro- perty(....tl1~j:._.tJ.:l~..Code Enf'()!"~E!.J.Jl.E!_!1.1:...BQ.~~g_l1~s jur is- d i c t ion _.Q.:L.!1!E!_.P.~...I:~g_!:L9_t__thE!__~eS.E.OD:.ClentaIl.(i that MosE!s. W. .. Howard_~~~_p!'.E!~~p..1:. .~!_-_!h~.J2ub_:U.~___I1~.~.!'.!~ th~:t:_. ~JJ_.._ I:1g_!J,~.E!~-_!'_~~t!'_E!.g.__.1?Y__9.QJl!..~~_Coun ty Q:rg !.I:1~!!_c::E!~Q.."-~_E!:J:3.~_,.ha..Y.~_ J:~E!.~m_ ..proper 1 y issued ; that the real "p'!:'QPer.tr-lE:!gal!y. d.E!sc::.!.i1?E!Cl as, Township 48, Range 25, Section 10, Parcel 10 is in violation of Section 2 of Ordinance 75-21, Al03.1.1.1 of 91"gJ1!.a..I}c::.e_. ~.Q::.I_Q I and Sec t ions 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 0 f 9r.dinaIl.c::_~__~1-47 in the following particulars: ~val .2J tree~_.prior to issuance_ of.~ptic~_.of QQ~nceme!!.!..t.._...I:~.!!1oY.:~L_Qf trees prior to issuanc::.~,J?J': ~ui ldi.!!9.Ye.:r~i1:,..~!l:Q._.that pi les of. ve.gE!tat ive debr is were dU!R];lE!9.__Q!!. th.e ,property. Seconded by Mr. Constantine. COMMENTS: ~, . ~ J ; ~ , '.'; H '~-l ~,~:~ Z;'1 "'-'1]~..; -'J(); ( . t-" eJ ". ~ 'i -: ~~ ('"lr,-; ';'J '"1 c.n t ~.} ct 1- 't 1-: P T F: haG j,)t--:)~~ :.--)~~ff;{' ,;--O"ll r'\/ l{,f'~ ':Cf:' rpg'd.t"ci_ln_Q' t}i:..... ;:11.j:~.~~:(? \7 ~ r .l 1 ;:-; t i en ~ c; r s f'..1 f. t --; r i ': ' S :=;; r-; ~ 7; n; ~q 11 \-1 '] c. ~ o ~'1 d.: .-11.'\ ( 'P q 1. - 4 7 . ~; ::.~ ~1 ~ 1) 1 c~ ~ t.! ,"'? ~; ~ r ~ p 1 '-; t~ ~-'I fool ,., P j~, ..\o!- "",f'"~. l.roof (If p'1p~, ,;.t:: r]phris ~-:;pjnG t.3'I)n~r)eli (lr) th.e sl.l1.)j~'ct r)rcjr)~rti'; d,rld. t~.i(:':i,r- t'1:i=) ~ ;'-, ~-";r) ()\It-'r ""lei..... ~-,Pi "'/it'~~! :>lr.~ t-\....,j(~ d.llegecl 'JiC)].;)t je.;(l:-., or, rplTIovctl {Jf 1-reps. ~"i _r t 1 , . , t-...t,~s rJ I;: ,., ~ He ~;! d t e ()_ h (~ f t-=~ P 1 ~:~ .~ 1.1 ~ : ~ ',~; H-) \..-'--1 ~ f'" . , ~ , , ; <""~ (' -~"'!-'i;'3. t ~.i\P -(,t-; /_... (.. ~ r: ~ i {- i '-~ ! e \/ __i. (.1 e (1 ( ,t~~ (J ["; f; (' t ~ .; r ....... H()Wt;"'j .,(1 .;-,s1:: pc] fl-J-) c J P,';'l"f-: I--:P ().r d I_I ,-j ('f~~('~~ ~:~j;c-~ -;lc>l tr'~~s. }YU.l~ [~~e f'f-:';'~ l~-.: -~ -, .~. + J L..;-j ~ t'; f ~l(::.. 1 ,4 1 Pll C ,:-; rlu.(._~ J ",7 j c: ~ d ~ _:_ ..-) ! }-i F' -~~ f~ 2 ~ ~-~ ,~:.)'Y M :~; h () -i 1 ll-] t l ( 1. ) ~ .- (: 11 (3 ;'- CJ f-' () f .::";1'0 c~~'nm the s;:nne fact'1al { - l i ' ,~".; ; . :..;JS, A~~s-;st(ti: ':i ;.t--t-(;"('lH-~.Y VJ~i ]:";011 Cll1~Sl jell-lPe] v.;1-'.~trl~-( Ch,,, i ('i{...u, T,a'.~.,; t'UR ""IriS h,.>(;ommend tng an AmpndmpD tit) Drlgp 7 CODE ~~'JF(Jr;'C-;RMR;-JT -~ -,.~_.~-- ._- >-"---'-"-~~--'-'''---",'~-~ ~A'II.T-..T"'\ iH j J4. '\ ,,; \, :- r~ ,---....... ..... .................... tJ\ _i; ,j ; f'I\" ,-, ,.... ,..... -~ v,''. .. ? i. ~ \ " < \+ i v ~Jr; \I~,-:r<r~ ~'R ~.S ; . '~q ~ t ],p v,( ,:: on t 1.,.,.1 W01J 1 (1 amf'Tl(1 ~~<irrif- by (~y'oPp j ")9 two (l f the tht'e~ partic111dY. \fiO~dt:jnn:,-; dill'! fInc1"':J IJ H(}w;:~~('d ~3c,_lp.1';} jTl \7~i().lct!-1(lTI e)f s('c''t ]C}rl ? of C~'d.~ ",........ ~u3 (:i1cj r-tn.--3/"j ,.~/..-'-:",.'--~ : (if.lf" ~LF-'i~ t-r~d.l ,l~:; ; _:'!(1~f.l(~ ;;: ~ L't (Ir)()~<:i1. ~ ,V!, (, (; 1 a r:' k~ (1 d t-' ~~: I:: I!-' (; v.f 1t (-l L lH'~ 'r' ;! i:":;;; 1) Cl ~~.; ::~> : (-) ~ t-. ! () r r -; .~_ ( 1 ::'dt trIP '.;-;nuu1ar or thp co]lp.ctjvF~ \ljo]",djCJn djd UCCUt' dnd thdt l-l is a violatior of both 01'ri;"""",>.,,:::; .....".i .iT fr,':l J ~,o.l. c;~'lP TJi'_ B"oINar[~ ~:;Ppr.u',"dp1:ii ;:l()f3 e}ld '!:~,,'1 I.a:2:aTUS dr'.sw~ced in U,t-' riff i;T,..,;t 1.\1.... t1'.'Jt i; po~~<::; j b Ip i'F.](} thClT hp 1-jas no I"'-!'o:.;" em vd tr-, the Rc),..;;_ (; r1 (~();. t,) ~J S;). r.tOT1Q!l: ~!:LJ:)edOIlE!_C3,I1lE!nded.l:1is .~C?!_~gl!_._!.9 reflect the pro- 120sed changes _..!'E!~Q.J1!.J!l.E!J!9E!(L!:>"y_Gh~.t:r:m.~!!.__kaz~. Mr. Constant ine"",-! thd!:ew_J?Js Seconq_tQ.._the _~Q..t.!9I.:1. Motion seconded by Mr. Lazarus at this time. CO~~~ : ~...1"Y"~ C:;cynst<i>~--'~1tP \.:c)iCt~d (l!SrJar~'pp~n(~q'~1 vJ-~t}~ t~--iP drHE'IIded. ,}'il{}t- ic)r: ~ MOTIQ~: Upon call for the question, Amended Motion carried 3/2 (Messrs. Andrews .C3,R9_S_on~an!il.!E!__QP.P9s;_E!gJ . COMMENTS: ~h,; i "nd'l ;''''l"/;;"1T'"Us r'[~: t ~."dt f'tl ! 1,<<t the Pindings of Fact )-ldliP been narr'()WF'd !o nne findinn of "";.7 .: () 1 rl t ; ()-. ?-l;r'Si~ .."l t n ,c,~..:. ,~, f"" 1 "f ;\.~Y'. C1 rl ,'1< J "'1y'. ['., r '. 'i: eypJa Lnpd ilIa! in casps; ~'nJ(:}1 as; tI, is thPt,t-' dh:> nor- ma 1 m i t1 gat ion "at i os ut i 1 5 zed I uenpri':ll: '1 spt on t h F; (, a (, . t y. n.f t h p h d. bit a t I wit II ::; - i 0 - 1 b 1" i n 9" (::srJpr c'IJ"( '~ rl tp .. Ht~ ree i. t- pcl t~l f'i f'PC]l; j ::--'p'inen_ t S \.---Jl1 i ell ltJC,,;,cJ 1;,",,;:) r)'C>i-'il npcl~ssary had thi::; 90'.1<-' t-hY.01Jg-h the rJt~ i_""'YO,! i. '~. t ~ ~-, U l."Ji ,{ J (. t. <.~::.~ . Tn "r,pply io r,1~,o ;-"":)1an T.a;.o;..,;T'iJS, Respondpnt' s <"!.ttornpy verified they acp willing. h) agree w5th any pqnj tal> 1 P nl<innpr of set t 1 prnpTlt, 1;1)T at]:]:...,j t"l-j,-' ~ "1'-',0, (J[ ~"'pr}ldf_'~lt ;r:,9 t'}l~ l~rl!.. ;_re rl_Ct'ed.ge sl.tc)lJ.J.(l :-'F:" {~j S Wi .: ::=-~ :'::; t-~ {1 Mr, ~1ark TequPs~f:'(l :'1,::,t a satisfactory pJiili he :-;lJbm; i !".c.,] by Respondt-'td [Jr his r'erH'(.:>spntdt ive to In5tjgatp; -; -eL C)cjt.~4n ~"lf~rj1~Cf~~lijpnt (-)-r' C;-)Y'r-'Pf t-i"lP rnt~<'j:.;n_Y"~S :L; n;~:lkt-:' 1.>[J felt :~()jne ()( ~.:"'~;;~ 'ie-Cp~t.-i.ti-";l~~ l()ss Pagf~ R r:r02 FNFnRCRMFr~7 BOARD OF COLLIER r:nr;1':Ty" NOVF.:MRF.R ?51 1 qg 1 (l :~H" "'l/.'j:,,[.j 4 ('i.'l""~i. ~1t. F,"r11u.:Y' ~';1;gg€"";tpd ~-hat S:lCh p Ian bf~ ;:;i)bm j t: h'd w 1. tb : n '''; l ~'. :'. Y (FiO) days rlfl(C ;:0,] 1 ))"11 i ig,;tinn ulinpl.->t('>.'j vJ:i~..."n n:inety (90) days, w j t h f F:t j 1 U t' P to (() :~: p I ~ ~'I~ s;; 1 i' i n g' i n a fi n P (j f $? fi pp'r' ddY a :-)eJ cnn!"" i r 11 i ng:;.,: .;, SI1C:; cornp.1; ,=:ncp ,. t-': ~;t <'3 i i.-' c-:. {._~~ . Respondent's ,'; t: CIi'iJPY pyoffered <1 plan of payment fn the amoun.t. of $1,000, but 1\h'. Clark pointed out that this is ned the propPT' VPTJUf' to wo-rk out an (., 'T'; ; t a.: .1 ,. :3 0 11,; tic: . Rt::>sponde'IL's ait()rnt'!~ ObjPctH] h) .:'~lP ,<If'2, (}f 2, $7!l f){c,; "at fin,.' pr'uposed should 0.11 acct:"pra.hle agreempnt not he reached. ivir'. Clrirk sta.l.pd t;',;:;l'lhe abso.l.ute t 'h~~ rnr:J 1" -t- t=-~. ~-. ;-.1 t -f-.1--, -j S L)C) 1 YJ t ~ ~.:; f Cl r D .~_. way to conc.ludp ;; t-'W{~ -,-; (1 t ) MOTION: etu.('r) t1lP ~'-,u(,j,',r l.l"upecry to its ()rig.in.c'~ s!>:lt-P, and DI'. ~':;';"i,:."(~ counter'f.r] l'}l;=d ~s 'lot a posslbi -: ity. Made by M.~.:.....~~.c;!Q.l!~ that the Conclusions of Law are t ha !.J~.2r;;~.r;;..~.~._~Q~~I'(:L_i s __! n_.YAQl~!,i.Q:r:l". Q f S ec t.!.Ql! ~ Qf...Q.~9J.lla.IlC:~7.~= 2..1.1. .... GO JIJ~I'.C;Q.1,1.;l!.!Y._1'I'~~.. R~JJlQya 1 91'9.!!1.a.l!c:~ L.._ a,!1.g.~~tQ.~~_~...) .'.! ---Q.f_.QI'.9 ~.!!~Il~~___~Q= !E..L B1,1.;.!l..d~!!!L_c;ode. Based upon the foregOing Finding~ of, Fact al1d CC>l1c:lllr;;,iC:>.ll.r;;.()f LCl~c:l!lej_p'.1,1rr;;lla,I}:tt().the authority granted in Cha.p.!er_..!~.?_L_Xl_()rida.S.1::Clt.u!es, and Co 11 ier Cou.n t.Y-..Ql:c;!!llaIlC:.E:!._~Q_._._~..~=8~,_.! t:_.J~ h~.!'_~!>Y-Q~9~!'_~9__tI1Clt the Respondellt correct the violations of Sectio.n 2 of Ordinanc:~:Z.~=_?L.a.!1Q Section A103.1.1.1 of Ordinance 90-75 in the "_'. ". u..._._. .....__.___..."......."_______.,,_..,_...__...~_.__......._. .._.~..., _ _"_'^ _..__ follo~J_~manner: that a sui table plan be__r;;.'1!.1:::>= mitted to mitigate the violations within sixty (60) days anq be completed within ninety (99JdClY.r;;_or~ t:!.1l~-9-L~Z~~.Q-P.~I'Q.Cly_.~!J) be imposed as outlined in the above Findings of Fact; th.Cl.tS..~Jci coI'I'~c:.= tions be C0I!1.P...J~_!~ci..._9.l!..Qr _.b~Jo~e the 25th day 9..f January, 1992 and, if Resl;)ondent does not comply ~t!I1..!h..i_r;;...QJ:'geJ:'on()rbefore ., tl1a! ..9a,te , ..' thell..ClIlcL if! th~_t event Responden:l::.!r;;_..hereby ordered to ~_~ f ine Of--~I~~.9_Q~__<!~_for_~l:!..~d eyery day any y!gla,tign .dE!sc:ribedl1eI'einc:ontilluesp'~.r;;.t the saJej cia.!~.!..._..ra!lure to comply with the OI'ci~_r:_.!!i.t.l:1Jn._!l:1.~ r;;P..~c:!.f ,i.~.fL.tJ.m~ w i lJ..I'..~r;;ll.l,J:._ i n....! 11e. '. r~c 9 !'.9.a,t:_!Q!1._c:>f '. ,<1 JJ~!L..P..~.!'~!!.,!: to Cha.,p.ter 162, Flori4~._St~t'g..tes.1. ~h,icl1may .beforeclosed, Cll!g.R~spondent' s prope_I't..Y sold t~.~:nf().!'.s:~ the_..1....iel'!. Seconded by Mr '_ Andrews. ?'-1Qf'" q c:cm:=: ?NFORCEMENT R()A PI; O'=' COTT, T SF< \;OUNTV ------- co~r!':rs . MOTION: ----- *** ITEM: COMMENT~: j~()V?iyTB~~:) /;1; 199j r: f": t~~ i r n-j (--i ;-,.-j")' ct r-';J_~~ rJr';r)lJ()s,:....(~ Sf) -~: hp jj;()t,'-;_ ( ) {--I -r- f-', -} I :.:-:; J "" , 'd 1 'i......., rl UTi(10~-J. (IC~ "~ ~:~'ij i t r;tl~ e ,c': i l : ~,-:::- ! {; amended IJ.1 an C4 (, c: t~r) i a tl J f~' i (; c: CJ J 1 -~ {:.~ r. ~ 1,1';',.. l j ;') f~ f:; 1:: lYl~-i j t t-f~ (J wi I}.; }.(..: 1 ,"......,- \ I~ r l \) j ('j (~ \/ ~~ 4 . M~-.P.edone.accepted the proposed. language and a~~~ded his Motion acco~~!ngly. Mr. Ang~~~s ~~~!:lS!ed_J:!J~_ second to the Motion~tQ_~~fJ.e~.t the E.!'.Ql2.9s~,~L]._~!1Jlg~g~_s:_h~J:!Sl.~ . Carr i ed 5/0. A~~~.;;>,lc,.-,l (;(l:l.;-ty' A: ~c"'nf>Y ::'"il,,,<o() "'P(l:'P";;lt'(l thAt ,.;;\_,p :)f:C 0.;' Il\;ll-'() doH'; ng the cl.t'd.[ L ;,!~ 'jC 11 p Or-(]er, 1.0 SI1t:'cjr-j :-"r;.: d ;:"n'y )!';~'- j<:, ~"P f1atp f"(.l' t',,,,, ';i;,<ry ( 6 0) c'J a. y () P d d 1 i [It=> r d n d <'J ( T 01 n: t for i b. E:' n j n e t- :r (9 0 ) 1 ~ -.; j : 1 e <j (] "" : f~ r-~: >:i v.: f.'~ ; r;~irl, 1 f'i!j,'1)') -' , '-.; t .-:i \ /.'(; ",< ..; rl ;..," '. j ~ '_'l.~, i ;)n'::;::\~\{ :~""'\JS cli : ;1.lS ;::;';di'<l I-hat j-1,p i'.-J(l ,',,~,~~c.; ;"<" cn.)fCI :HCC'c] not only If I :~:... t-':. LL-; ~" ;~1-' p t j (I] i g;.:..; (Y.;~ t d;:"':';(J ; '..'I t~'l~} dr-1,1:-l . , , G ,~,(; t=&:- i :"".; '- , (;:1 :~-;p Ch.=:\i rmAf.: r Q, r- evJ (~r""'!~' ~~~ . (~(J 1.11c1"{ t]-t~ di:~tf'~; Y;'ld-j Ur3_:" 'i ~ (-) \/ ... .4 Recessed: 10:30 A.M. - Reconvened: 10:45 A.M. *** *** Old Business Request for a corrected copy of Order Imposing Fine/Lien on Aspen Lake Development, Inc., CEB #91-006 C~~ir"k~ :('"f-.l:er'('~''''(1 t(l '{,'hplet1 ~r' jnc.llJdpcJ !,1 ~ h'::lrdn,,; .i:.I'uvid.J-.,tl by Ms. V<'Jlcarc~l Fp srdtp,] thrlt ?eSfH"IJP':L >01"3 ;;gT'ped:'j fl..,jy :'IP $n/,'ion :-'nl-' 1':'1-"- v: on:;; 1. y .imp'l81.:.d by U; i:::; Ro,::; Y'd dnd I add i. t iI), d 11 y, "':';U-""(~P(j t-f.-~ C!j"-'l~'.l ; '''It) .r;"'(ll/~f";1; 1i; ." {]~grpP ~~"'t'"c:l-r-..1 111dl-~ Wh'A L (h i 'C; h')2'::"; POSH j b 1";/ co:,11; dPt:ld':{1 () r thf:"'p,. f-!e !'--IPI)()f;~~~(-; t})...'i-i 'RpSr)f)l.l(lt~J'l; j~..; ()ffpy'i-r"jg to ~('P"({l()\l~ tl!e i..,~tll,..,i),',:... ~'fr-luent and sluc3Uf:!r f5:;; .it! t;!(.;, po.,,;; and Y(:';d:Hlf.,cape the arec;.. ~fe i"fj1,)Or'tpc} "'d; r~vo ;;;'-';;1:1'~""o ,',f 2:.)11.;1 iot, Cr, 01 pr....'':;pnt l(Jc)ciY I.() CU .'"]~iO;e~.lf',-; tprily .nld~ snr:;1--<c~ ion VJ'~i l'p;n,)\/{'" L' p poss5b 11 ity of [1i1". ('et: cL,.mdue. ,"'1" "F:'fl/' ..to", ",_' Pespondpnt c:tlso '.:;1 ipnL-ih'" t ,., r.pmCJ\llDg t11e ";0 1;;-,pl;~;d1 pl<7 t. He ".;.,;,-,,,(1 s."p1.)Orf for l.b.... "Pc.., 1'_ (.'f'~;r;" j ~ () .'in..'l <'\skp6 t 1,<,\( :";12 KCe')1"l'any: nu n ."'f' i' (I f i~hf" S';dr'.' he" pc:.iric""(~; adri:"9 11,,.,! s:","'f \'v11~ ..'cd .~;':'ri:.; ~ d nF"vi /'PCC1;;-'.";'-7",;<;i ~,), :.0 thp Board fcy impo- ?due j.O -.1........."':" ".I. ?;;:-CJRCF!v7Fi'JT ..., '. ~ MOTION: -- ITEM: COMMENTS: 11-" t't:"" 1'"):/ n i~_F--' 'RC1A R~ ....... ~".... -.... .,.. ..-,,---. i~nvF\.r~~R ,,<:; /- './ ~"-,_,,,__,_ w_____~._.~__,~___."_._,, ___.._. __,._.__.___~__. "~'''''_'~'_', ""'_.._,~,.__ "lOt: _ .i~ f j l \1 , , - d;jf,' - . , ci I C j :: e s (-.:1 [) { J '..1 f-' (.-, ~) . f':, -, (') 'i,:---. , i l ;[){J::";~~J :S6 F)OO : ~..., " {jf'l(-..Jo( ~ "N~'-'f-'; E-! _/_ ..., ~- ......" {J. 1 . f- '~~ i (" -,-, t ~tf:"~'.~P l S sl~f- " . . (.. 1 p;: ~ .. '--p j-1-r t)fJ<<.::,'-'( ; :; -:'1 (l I j, ,~(~ ~,"I f~ 1. (; f.... 1_1 ,'j l-.!i~ , , (; . ~-, i IJ .....l; '(.: '--'S()\)( L L. . l ~ i. f.l~t .1 ~ J n (_; ~' . fltl ") . ' Cf t:..,~ ,~ (, :'t_ _ l:!-'''-' A ti ,_\ , i1' '.. ;: 1 ~,; ~ '\ : '; n '::"(Jf:.A-:'"'I P,-\ ( ;, T ~ ,('....--.; \ ~', f1 .. Finn ~,,1 S,j ~ i ; i- ~' , , c: {.~ 1" (. E-~-;' 'r~r;,cj:~ 'I~l f-'" (~ } 1) c:~\/ , "~po .::.:. .. f-~ ( ) ,.. ].'} d f d i Ji f} i_ {; L~i ).~; p (' : { I ;',' fJ ~ j <::; \ ({-~ l. J <1 j i. ,.> ~ -_ 1-' ~..'---, ;- nr'f1~'r .('} oJ . f-~ :'j l;t :-~~:...;~n ,)(: ..=$ ~;' --.,1; .; p; ;"1, ~,......l.; -; r1 ~ , -: ;--. ~.~ i ~;~" ) ",-, (-j ;;-'" 'r , , '1/-: ".,.n(1;j ("1 .. [] r, ,/ <3_ -; , , . : ;-; (; if:... It-. ''':';~,i,... ._, ~~'~GI"~ ; {;;tS :":c) ~ '1 '~l.J:'; w; : ~ 1 1.t...}; 1(,,[ '(;1.i(}Sr:->>(l i. ~F '"::) ..' r (-, r:' " ~:-J :.:.; ~.., I.' ~ -! rl,~-l.{, ~ .4 t:Ci )~'I ~ ff j l t-- ~, . !:-, ( J : r, ~J i ;t'-~ t-:U--'-~t'!(~ t(~r;in:::.;.- ~ i, ;J! l't\~ S;.f}!j '''; . . 'J ; ;.! ',j R~....;,~;. ){-} i1 (1pn +-- .. (' ;,lll"I"i , ' -.1 ~ l.;{ ; ! t'", ,JLj .Pt~l"i~~ni . f:'~ "r" vJ "';-'ll,j "~ .'-iJt:..:-:,~'~:; J )." 'pc ,p'. t.l r' '71.:_ ~'~-, !-' ::'::"~j l)~'..,a;..\n i j f-')~: t- , .,. .. ,,' '.- . 1 itPS, .' ro< ; I) <::. I; ~- i_Pr' t- (;(]t':, '-; "t~ t-"'" (~~'l.~ rt'J .......J(..:, .- [ Y'~'.,;pY'\je':.; : (_:;- ~., t oJ rlf..i ; J {-'(ii-' v ~-':;ll ~ ;.\,' ( 1 1 ' ; (1 '( il. ,-:- ,< ( . l;t .... , , t ~.l. _" Made by Mr. Constantine to clea~_~~his vexatious ~robJem ~ad()PtTng-the Amended Order. Seconded by Mr. Andrews. Carried 5/0. *** Next Meeting Date . r . h I {.. '; Cl-'- :--:"; .t.' :.... '(J-~>\-~ , ! :-. , i L>Jd ~.., 't:--' i:(';;; j .! .~--' IN . :r::.:..... t)tJ *** () t-:~ f;j ;. l~j ! ~., , ~ '() (') i..l:-"": JI. ...'...:...... f-'f-! : It--. : 'ijl, oJ Wc-7'--) ,-,{ 't' ..-........--r-'\~ J II ~::JM~p ~m r.. r'1 T~"'.T,"!,~7 " .'...Ji, ,-,; , v vV t2-\< ~. ~\lZ..ih ~ 0'\'~ G~a.N\At,aJ I ~, ~ -, ~