The URL can be used to link to this page

HAAB Backup 10/25/2001 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Backup Documents October 25,2001 - ..~~--~ NOTICE OF MEETING & AGENDA COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD THURSDAY, O<;TOBER 25, 2001 7:00 P.M. County Commission Meeting Room Turner Building (Building F), Third Floor Collier County Government Center, Naples, Florida * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * NOTICES * * Public comments will be limited to 5 minutes unless permission for additional time is granted by the Chairman. Collier County Ordinance No. 99-22 requires that all lobbyists shall, before engaging in any lobbying activities (including, but not limited to, addressing the Board of County Commissioners) before the Board of County Commissioners and its advisory boards, register with the Clerk to the Board at the Board Minutes and Records Department. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * AGENDA I. 7:00 P.M: Meeting called to order and determination of quorum. II. Approval of minutes of the September 27,2001 meeting. III. Determination of excusal of absences. IV. Discussions: Presentation by David Weeks and Tim Durham of Collier County, and Michael Kirk of the Collier County School Board on redistricting of County Commission and School Board Districts. VI. Old Business: Proposed Executive Summary for larmworker issue and presentation to County Commission. VII. New Business 2002 Report to the Board of County Commissioners on the Status of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board. Results of the Hispanic Board and the Elections Departments coordinated efforts to register voters at the Latin Festival. VIII. Public Comments.' ** IX Meeting adjourns. ~. -..--",,-.--." ""---",-'~'-- ..,.-------. .._--~_. HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES OF MEETING of September 27, 2001 PRESENT: ABSENT: Carlos A viles, HAAB Member Eugene Greener, HAAB Member (Excused) Sofia Pagan, HAAB Member David Correa, HAAB Member Susan Calkins, HAAB Member ALSO PRESENT: Frank Loney, HAAB Member John Norman, citizen Robert Pin a, HAAB Member Pete Cade, Jr., HAAB Member Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison The September 27, 2001 meeting of the Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) began at approximately 7:07 p.m. in the Board of County Commissioners meeting room. A quorum of 7 members was present. APPROVAL OF JULY AND AUGUST, 2001 MINUTES The Board reviewed the minutes of the July 26, 2001 meeting. Frank Loney made a motion to approve the minutes and it was seconded by Susan Calkins. The Board voted 7-0 in favor of approving the motion. The Board also considered the minutes of August 23, 2001 and a motion was made by Robert Pina to approve said minutes. Frank Loney provided a second. A correction was included in the motion to reference that Mr. Norman is ~ not the, director of Cinco de Mayo Festival in Immokalee. As amended, the Board voted 7-0 to approve the motion. HAAB REVIEW OF MEMBER ABSENCES A discussion was held regarding attendance standards in the HAAB ordinance and excusal of absences. With respect to Mr. Greener, Liaison Ramiro Mafialich reported that Mr. Greener had been in contact with the County Attorney Olfice prior to tonight's meeting and that Mr. Greener's office indicated they had not received timely notice of the September meeting. With regard to Mr. Greener's absence in August, Ramiro Mafialich reminded the members that Mr. Greener had previously stated at the July meeting that he had been prescheduled to be away at the time of the August meeting and that those plans had been in existence prior to his appointment to the HAAB. Susan Calkins made a - .-.-.-....-....- ~._.__._, -,""'..-- _..<--~.,"_..~, -"-~---~._.,-~ ------ motion to excuse both of Mr. Greener's absences. Robert Pina provided a second. The Board voted 7-0 in favor of the motion. Frank Loney commented about his absence in May by stating that there had been illnesses in the family at that time. A motion to excuse the absence was made by Robert Pina and seconded by Carlos Aviles. The Board voted 7-0 in favor of the motion. Sofia Pagan explained that in May and June of 2001 she had had problems in attendance because of illness and Red Cross commitments. Frank Loney made a motion to excuse both absences which was seconded by Pete Cade. The Board voted 7- o in favor of the motion. Robert Pina explained that in May he missed the HAAB meeting due to an operation. A motion was made to excuse the absence by Frank Loney and seconded by Susan Calkins. The Board voted 7-0 in favor of the motion. FARMWORKER ISSUES David Correa informed the HAAB that he had made contacts with members of the County Commission about farmworkcr issues. He stated that it was his impression that Commissioner Colletta would support the HAAB's request for the County Commission and/or the Governor to make a plea for dialog about farmworkcr issues between thc growers and the farmworkers. He said that he had explained to the Commissioners with whom he met that this is not a labor~management issue, but rather an economic-social issue in Immokalee affecting the Hispanic community. David also explained that he had met with Commissioner Henning and it was his impression that Commissioner Henning would not support said request of the HAAB because Commissioner Henning appears to bclieve that it is a labor-management matter. David stated that in his meeting with Commissioner Carter, the Commissioncr appeared inclined to support the plea for dialog between the farmworkers and the growers. He also mentioned that Mr. Carter had suggested having a forum on the matter including Florida Gulf Coast University's capabilities for dispute resolution. David thought that was a good idea but he was not sure if FGCU would require paymcnt to provide these services. He wondered if the County Commission would pay for such scrvices? David said that he thought that Mr. Carter would prefer that the matter came to the County Commission after the November elections. Mr. Carter seemed to think that the matter would receive a more favorable reception at that time. Frank Loney commented that he has long been involvcd in the farmworker issue. He did not prefer to wait to present this item to the County Commission. He emphasized that the HAAB is not asking for specific negotiations, just for dialog. He stated that the HAAB proposal is not asking for dollars to compete with other ballot items in November. He thought the issue needed attention now because there are too many impacts in the community. Mr. Norman commented that the average farmworker in Immokalee makes only around $8000 per year. He said it was hard to get accurate data because many of the farmworkers do not have social security numbers. He says that many times taxes are taken out of their wages but nothing comes back to them from the federal government because they are constantly on the move to other migrant jobs. . He also reminded everyone that the farmworkcr's occupation is subject to weather conditions. David Correa commented that the growers have refused to sit down at the table to discuss wages with the farm workers. He mentioned that the Governor has previously sent a representative to Immokalee but there has been no significant progress. Sofia Pagan added that the growers deal with contractors. - 2 - ---_.~~~--"._----"_. - -- -----..-------.--..---.----.---.-...--------..-- ---------------- ---.--------- She thought there were' two ways to look at the situation: the first was to get the farmers to improve Jiving conditions; and the second was to improve the educational opportunities for the young people so that they can hold better paying jobs. She said it was necessary to break the chain of repeated generations doing the same low paying jobs. Frank Loney mentioned that it is difficult for illegal workers to cooperate with law enforcement. The growers continue to make profits; the workers do not even have social security numbers and still have taxes taken out of their wages. He mentioned that in Costa Rica the law requires that education be provided to citizens through the first two years of college. Mr. Norman observed that Immigration is never around when the growers need the workers in the field. He says that the pattern has been that after the crops are picked, Immigration shows up and rounds up illegals. He said this is kind of a standing joke in Immokalee. He mentioned that it costs the worker money to return to the United States. He commented that despite deplorable conditions in Immokalee, the workers return because the conditions in Immokalee are still better than those that they face in Mexico or other countries. He mentioned that there is a big push for reform and that President Bush has advanced a proposal to recognize the legal status of workers. Carlos A viles added that even if the workers are granted legal status, the issue will not disappear. He said that children in Immokalee need mentors. He cited Manny Touron, who is a principal in Immokalee and is a very good role model. He said that there is a need for Immokalee children to aspire to goals beyond high school and farm work. Susan Calkins asked if businesses in Immokalee were giving children openings for educational opportunities. Pete Cade added that Redlands Christian Migrant Association and the high school are involved in job training and mentoring. He said that recently there was program that featured an author about migrant life but there was small attendance. Frank Loney commented that he has been a member of Alcoholics Anonymous for 20+ years and has been sober for that time. He mentioned that he use to be a soccer player and has coached the Optimists' Club youth soccer league. He said that he requires good grades for the children on their soccer team to be eligible to play. He thinks that it is necessary to have the Immokalee community educated and involved in requiring all high school children to be exposed to career alternatives. More importantly, the growers need to sit down and talk with the workers showing respect for human dignity. He is not asking that the County Commission get involved in any terms of employment, merely in the plea for dialog between the parties. Sofia Pagan agreed that the problems will continue to exist if the causes of the problems are not addressed. Mr. Norman stated that he had never been a field worker but he has observed for several years the people in Immokalee and they are hard workers. He said many of them are uneducated and young and come from Mexico. From the census, it was determined that many of the workers have no schooling and cannot even count the money they are paid. He mentioned that in Naples, many of the construction, hotel and other service workers are coming from Immokalee. The main problem is for the field workers. There is no doubt they are taken advantage of by employers but they continue to do the work because they are still better off than in Mexico. Mr. Pina recalled his Chicago high school experience where students were strongly encouraged to either pursue a university education or vocational/trade preparation. He thought that that type of emphasis was needed in this community where a large percentage of the students do not go to college. Mr. Norman agreed saying that many technicians are making more money than college graduates. There was a brief discussion about the timing of the presentation to be made at the Board of County Commissioners. Susan Calkins questioned whether there was a need to present powerful personal - 3 - - ~'-"-""'-'--~--~"._-~'--' ~--,'~~~-~---'...-._.. -.-....---.-..---- testimony. Mr. Norman stated that on a positive note, there were lots of housing projects underway in Immokalee and that short term rents are available to workers so that they can avoid a double rent as they move between jobs. A motion was made by Susan Calkins to bring this matter to the Board of County Commissioners, if possible, at the October 23'd County Commission meeting. Specifically, a request of the Hispanic Board for the County Commission to request dialog between the growers and the workers and for the County Commission to request that the Governor also make the same plea for dialog. This is based on dialog being good for the Immokalee community and the County. The motion was seconded by Frank Loney. There was a 7-0 vote in favor of the motion. Susan Calkins asked whether Immokalee Civic Association Representative, Terry Aviles, could participate in the presentation. IMMOKALEE BANK PRACTICES David Correa mentioned a concern that he had regarding an Immokalee bank which is charging laborers to cash checks when the worker's employer does its banking at the same bank. David said this is a hardship on workers. He asked whether the HAAB should take a position on this. David said he felt this practice is wrong where the laborer is paid by check from the same bank where he is trying to cash the check. He thought that Commissioner Colletta might be willing to write a letter taking an interest in this matter. Frank Loney commented that he thought there were legal requirements that affected these types of practices. Mr. Norman stated that it is not just the Bank of America that has this practice. He said that banks argue that there is no guarantee the employer will have funds in the bank merely because the employer has an account with the bank. The bank maintains that it has to pay a percentage of money to insure that funds will be available for cashing the checks. He suggested that a HAAB representative should confer with Steve Price of Florida Community Bank in lmmokalee. Robert Pina made a motion for Chairman Correa to investigate this matter with the banks and report back at the October, 200 I meeting. There was a second by Frank Loney. The Board voted 7-0 in favor of the motion. The meeting of the HAAB was adjourned at approximately 8:54 p.m. Prepared by: Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison Approved by the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board on this _ day of , 2001. David Correa, Chairman HJRMlHAAB/Minutes - 4 "_.."~"-.--_._-_._,..,.,,--- ._.__d._ _-.._,...-..~. -- "--'-"'.' .---...-.-..'< -- 10/18/01 13:30 FAX 9416436968 COLLIER CO COMMUNITY DEV 1i!l002 ~!~ gt: · I ! ~ I~g ~i; , g ~ ~ g to<<' I~U .' U.S.4' ~5 tll ~~~ ~. ~! a~ ~!i ~ ~ ~ ; E UI ~ ~ WILSON IllUILVMD ~ ~ l """" .--. 'w.',,'" l\UClUDiS eouL!V~ - 0 , ~ ~ ~ ! E ~ 5 i " ~ ~ . " ...... SJl. all ~ . ..- HDlllR'I'COUNlY I ell n ~ %n ~ ~ 00 ~ l 0... I ~ ....- ~ ~ i a- lii _m . en:lll en ! - ~ -In . . !o I'" ~i I !:~ I'" Z Z m m en ......"'" ............" - ~,---_.~ ---.-.--. -- _"n'_ --= ~~ ,--. ,..~>>,-_._. ..-..--,,-. 10/18/01 13:35 FAX 9416436968 COLLIER CO COMMUNITY DEV Iill 003/007 ~n E[: I I ~.i i~m -ll!l ~U ~ 8 ..... I~a li .S.4\' ;il il! ,- " . I! U ! 19 ~ . I Ii ~ III ~ ;;l M.SllN 8QLJlLYNIb ~ I = ..."""y ......... .....,... ........... ........ - 0 , ~ n . ~ m Ii ~ ~ I .. il" . . . ..." SoH, a ~ " . m ........ -"""'" I I . 8 ~ n :I: ! = I 0"111= i ; ~ ~ O!iii . ~ I r"'''I:a - .. ion n , ::I: .. . ..0 ~ 8 ... ... ~mc c !az ~ a ~ I: ili ....""'" ...-""'" ~. --."'.- - .-."-.-.. -- - ._,----~ 10/18/01 13:36 FAX 9416436968 COLLIER CO COMMUNITY DEV !at 004/007 ol~ ~~: '- I ~.~ S. id -~: ~ii 8 c M ,.. ti~ h~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~ a~ ~9 i ; ~ .~ I z III ~ ~ 'Ml.SllN 8llI.lLEVARb ~ . """"NlY .--- ..........- - , " ~ Ii I ~ ..... ...... ~ ~ f ....... -"""" I fII n I n ~ :z: 0 ~ . ~ 0..1= I !I ~Bm ~ ! ~ . ~ I a"- - i _On , " ~fIIO " N me I !1a~ .... fII ifi ...."""'" ...... """" - -"..--..------,.--- ,.. ,., _...~ - ..~---'._~..~._>_._- u_"__~__ 10/18/01 13: 36 FAX 9416436968 COLLIER CO COMMUNITY DEV Ii!l 005/007 ~I~ r ~i! ~t.. I ,- I~g ~d I ~ . ., ~h , ~ m- ;Ii ~~ i~1 ,-,. ; i~ ~ a! ~~ ii ~ =wu I ~ ~ i:; I I UI ~ MLStM 8GlUWRO ~ ~ : D ~~ ~ IIOUI.n'ARII EWRl2.ADO 8CIlIIZVAIlO , . ~ Ii SJl.2e UD p " ~ . Ii ....... HENIlR1'CGdllV I en n I ~ n 0 . :z: I'" ! . I ~ !I 8:11: ~ e ~ Iii ~ I"'O!! . · l!l 51 "II a"ll'" ~ ~ i!i =II: ISg ~ w ..me ! !"z !l !l ~ i en CWECDUNTf ~COUN1T _40__ __.._, ._^_ _ __ _______ 10/18/01 13: 36 FAX 9416436968 COLLIER CO COMMUNITY DEV Jal 006/007 ~S~ " j;l1~ t .~m ~i~ ~ I I lEI ~ ~ i ~ Q " ~ lIU ;n PU":''' ,I~ U~ ~ ,-" ~ ~~ . i ! I I a~ III 8. ~i ~ . ~ ~ I · I' UI pt ... BCIl.UYNIIl ~ ~ . ~N C\IIlUIIAOlS8llIUVAAD l'WJfGUoUES IIllULP'NID ~ ~ ~ 0 I . ~ I.. . I , < e- I ill. a 11.11.21 ~ I ....... ~EHIlRY COWNTf I ,I III II . :z: r- ~ I ~ I: gil!: ~ ~ i Iii .. r-Om · ~ l!l iii "a,,:lID '" z -On ~ 2 CI WI .UlO ~ .. ...me ~ 2lP' z ~ !:I :I !if UI m DAIlECOUNIY 8llQlURlICCUNTY - ,~,,__._ M__ ""..__ _...-._... ~'_<'_,~.'~_"""'- __.~"~~~,_,._ ..._.,~.~,__. '10/18/01 13: 37 FAX 9416436968 COLLIER CO COMMUNITY DEV IaI 007/007 ~U~ ~" J~ ~ ~~; E'" I ~.a s~y ~ Ii ~i 8 ~~g ~U ,,~ '. N tii ..... """"'"' , ~ i~~ -" ~ ~~ . i ~ I ~ aM Wg ~i ~ ~ ;; i ~ UI ill __ BtlUI.NIRD ~ ~ , ........ DalI.AClt'IIGlUVMll a'IJIlI.MlES 8lXUVNlD , f: ~" E ; I I 1.1I,21 s.R,21 ~ ~ i E ...- .-.....IV I · n I ~ n 0 ~ ' ::z: ... ~ I I !I SiI!: ~ ! 5 tii ~ ~~I ; 1Il ~ .. .an · ~ eft "'tmg ~ i!!az ~ a ~ ~ DADlClJlIIA'l' IIRDWAADClIlUN1Y ~ ,"-_._,.,--,-,~-_. .~-"'''--'_. -- ----..."---..--'""'. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDA TION REGARDING THE NEED FOR DIALOGUE BETWEEN IMMOKALEE GROWERS AND F ARMWORKERS. OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners to call for dialogue between the growers and farmworkers for the good of the lmmokalee economy and community. CONSIDERA TIONS: For a number of years, the Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) has received information regarding very low wages and deplorable living conditions for farmworkers in the Immokalee area. The Board has also received infOlmation that the problems faced by the falmworkers negatively impact the rest of the lmmokalee corpmunity and area with particular emphasis on the Hispanic population. The HAAB has previously brought this matter to the attention of the Board of County Commissioners and the prior Board declined to involve itself in this controversy primarily because it viewed the matter as a labor-management pli vate sector dispute. Since that time. the dispute has continued and the problem appears to be getting worse. During the course of the last year, the HAAB has had public meetings in Immokalee and heard from farmworker representatives as well as other interested citizens and community leaders who have appeared at public meetings in lmmokalee. The HAAB has again voted to request that the County Commission formally, by resolution, call upon the growers and the farmworkers to engage in dialogue to try to solve the problems faced by fatmworkers. The HAAB is not requesting that the Board involve itself in telms and conditions of employment. Rather, the HAAB believes that the Board should merely make the call to the parties to have dialogue. It is believed that such an action would benefit the citizens and economy of Immokalee and especially the Hispanic community. The Board is convinced, based on information received, that the lack of dialogue and solutions to the farmworker issues are impacting the Immokalee community and Collier County as a whole. The Board also believes that the County Commission should formally, by resolution, request that Florida Governor, Jeb Bush, also make a plea for dialogue to the growers and the workers for the benefit of the Immokalee community and Collier County. FISCAL IMPACT: None. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None. RECOMMENDATION: That the Board pass a resolution (attached) calling for dialogue between growers and farmworkers in the Immokalee area. Also, that the resolution include a request to Florida Governor. Jcb Bush, to join in the call for dialogue between Immokalee growers and fatmworkers. Finally, that the Board authorize the Chairman to execute said resolution. - --------~~._-- ~--- ___._____n__.__.__ .._._._._____.~_____ SUBMITTED BY: Date: Ramiro Mafialich, as Liaison to the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board REVIEWED BY: Date: David Correa, Chairman Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board APPROVED BY: Date: David C. Weigel, County Attorney h:RM\HAAO\Ex Sum-Dialogue - --,---~---,---,~_._-._-,--.._- -.--- GOODMAN, GLAZER, GREENER & KREMER, P. C., OF MEMPHtS, TN., ArrORNEYS HERBERT GLAZER EUGENE GREENER, JR. 600 FIFTH "VENUE SOUTH EUGENE GREENER. JR. '''OM F~" TN> RESIDENT PRINCIPAL SUITE 203 RICHARD H. KREMER NAPLES, FLORIDA 34102 fl. PERCY MAGNESS TELEPHONE (941) 435.9800 IElRUCE M. KAHN FAX (94') 435-9802 HA.Rf"ETTE R. COLEMA,.. greener@naples.infi,net EDWARD E. WOLLMAN, .N....~"" <u Of" COUNSEL ..."...Il....BLE BY APPOiNTMENT WILLIAM W. GOODMAN 5UNTRU5T BUILDING (HiOO.11l81) MORRIS L. STRAUC" MARCO ISI.AND, FLORIDA ,1909.20001 IALL CORRI;:SPONDENCE TO NAPLES) October 17, 2001 James D. Carter, Ph.D. , Chairman Board of Collier County Commissioners 3301 East Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112-3602 Dear Dr. Carter: I hereby resign as a member of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board. ~~egard" .....-- - <'-'~~ E gene Greene~ EG/ds cc: "Mr. Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney '-I:::'," ._-~------_._" '.'._..,.. ~'--- - 'H_.~_ --'--'-_. - U r-l - 0 ;;.- o 2: ~ ' U i o ( , \ ~ o Q... ,,, '" \ ~ r-l ''::::J~ ~ \" .~ (- , '.J 'IN - if]" I r\. \ " ( d \ \ . , \__X ) Q:l 0f') ;- \l:.- ~ ~~ 1 (\ \ ~" ~ w o ~.. 1\' \r\ if] ~ >- \\ ... \~ .. 'i~ ;;..J ,'i <. . , \ ' . ". . ' <)..~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ 1 Ii \~, "t'\:' ..'::Y___ ~ ,( \ r-l~ \ --;::0 '- I ./ ..,""' ''--' ''\l :;: ~ 2:1~ M' \\, (r--"" ~ i [;j = ~ ) . \ "" ~ """ '''. ' , ," i r-l ;:. ..., l..J--..) t~., l U...., l. "'" ~ Q 2: =2 >- ' .,....'" ~ ! -~ U -<tj) ~ ~ ~ \ ~ vJ \ ~l I "'""'l -...01 ~"" \,) ,,\ \j _ <-l. _'-..:> I 2:2: ~, - ~~ ~ [:~ ,vtJ ,. ~- I ,- .... ~if] Q... , , ~:a -< \.\ ('\ . . /1 0' , ". o , ~ ~ I~ ~ I N~ - '~\ 2: -< -..j '.." L ~I 5 ~ ~ ~ "-~ 0- ~ ~i'~' ~ u ,- ~ Q:l~~ \b ',~- -"" ' ,-, fEl, 0. - . ":-.) ,"'" i:it'." . I "-0 i - -' \. '- ""'. c-. : I - -, ~. ' -----I ..J -c.; " 8 ~ & ~ ,C" '~~ . ~ J >c\ ~ ~ ~ 0 ,0,-:<'1\ r-l ~ (CJ >-' ~ ""g" Q:l,,; '" ,,;- -1. \:.., .".. [ii ><,,; Z ,,; H ',0 ~ " ,.e, ~ " [ii Z ,,; z"' _" ::. r-l ~ [ii Z 0 (CJ H Z""-> ~ I..[, ~ .... 0 Q 0 Q ,,; p,,,; "1 " ~ U ,,; H ~ P, tfl rJ; '" U ,,; ",,_ -..... '::(: o Q ~ U ,,; ~ Z .~ <: WV\ ,v H [ii Z H [ii H _ <r' ....:> "' ,,; 0 ~ 01:> G:. 'v)" <.cS ~ ~,,; [ii 0:: [ii 0 0 H r :::>J O Q P, ~ H tfl ~ [ii _, \~ r CQ I ,7~ \j ~ '-l./ 'J _'~_"_"__,._.._.h__~_.._ "__.m" ~_'_",'~" "P_'__""'~_ __.m..~. R2SE RZ5E R27' H28& o MAP #1 J' -: . .T~ ~FT .--,- -:r:-~ ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES' -'. - -! .... ' --, "BOARD Of' CDUNTY COMMISSIDNERS '.. " ",'-r-'. :._~'_" :~ ~..~ -"~I !_~_.~- COWER COUNTY, FlORIDA , . I:.> '. ,~,.. ......., ----" . " \ ___~.I _'n '__. .'. __ __._ '_j' .\ ./ -' - , I ..,' ,. \" ','" II ' " 1 ..'" ",. \~i ! ;, lEE COUNTY _n f---__-~_-----~ \~\l' f. . .,. .1' 1-', e_";:' ,.."..'. _.1"......,.. .' . ~" ;;.. -.. .. - -. . -- ., . IO~ ~~I::'-. -~T-: ..','" = '. .. .. .. ~ li.!-J. ~ ;:>> -1 --.-.1- -.-1. -1- ,- -- " ~rq",.~, f""" .., '" " \ ' ""'I .,,, .:..!-.:.. ,.,. ..,. .,,, ",. :! _. _d~ ~._ ......,i --- I i_ i " .. '" . 'I . '~jl!II' ~,,, .. I, k I,. ".. '. I.. -., -'-J. _....'.."" -- J__ .~--: I . ......... --r- ""l--'I' - -,---- -- " ~. ! " .__~. ",' \ '" I.,.. .' " ...."._.., '''''''''''' ....._." , ,=' 1:1 ., 1---"=-'':;-':'-' --::T::I ~:T::: -=~= :::.. --:~::"I~:-=-- . -t- --1'1 ! --- )' -- C::i' 1-$''''- 1 .. .""'''in --..-- . . . .. I ....,." ." -" -","" .'" ...., ..,~. ,,", " .." ".. r. . ---" 3 r:t .. i " : l' 1 " ..,,, '." -.-:~ ",,,.1..,,,, -:- --- --:, -..---.. --- : -~ -- ~ - . -''':- ,..'~> -1---1- - ~- ~ ~ ~ "f ~"'::~ -_..~-,-~- ~-- 'j" , 'j ""'1'""" '1 1.._-' I -'.,,, "'11"'" .." '1" --: ~,-'.--..-~I-~".L/;c~ ,..." I r---- - ----- -~--__1..---~-.--- -- __~ <;) .I , . w . . , "t.;,. t. "'I ... ,... >:: ~. 1 -' ;-,. u, __"" ..'- 1-- '. ,'__~_ _~ ."_::.c r-- __. _" . " "" I' '* L' Ii'" ~' , I'. I " '" ". .,. .'. ..,,, -"- -- ~. i ,------ I __.. ~ 1 ......_'~.M !. ,I-----.-. "".. '1'J - I ~ r ' .' '---'" -! -I ,," .- ". t~/.; PJ . .,' I ,. I . \ 1 " "'" '<;'. ...... I - Ii" I....,... "". '.""E.....".' . ><""E~ 'X I 1--,- --------1. _ ---_.~ . /. ~ II. . . j'''' i . '. . . . ;--- - - -- o ~ - I .-- - -- --L. _. _ ..,,"~; ~". . ."" ,,".. o 0 ,j I . I. ," '.. i "" :::.--- ---- - o ',L- /.Ii _ I' _ _ _ -'- I . '" . ~"" ....1 '".''' ~"". " ---., 1 I I'.... -- "-_'n_. " I -..,.. ".. i .. I -- -. -- -- --- .~. ..' It.-h '1 -I---~ --- -~~- 'u'_~~ ..,. " ::J--l-' ,,,,,,.. '- ~, .. I/'!-~ ~-'-- . "- -:..1 "_~" ".~ ~ :::.1-=:: ,.:: ~ \~, . I . i . ~.~ ~ I' . . " .., :1:'--" j '" \'B '-"I" ,- _'S, . - - _. _ u_ _ ....... ~:! ~". _" "...... ~"" R \~ .>' \\l , .J.~'I "'''' - ---1---- ""'. - ,tJ -It - - 1"--.... u_ - --. -. ' .."" ~: """ ~"" "". ..". .., ", () ,,\{~/;~ . f' , ". ...- ---- -.. --.- ~_.".~~ o 0 1. -~" v I---c--f~ ._____ ..".. '" ."" .'", ~". ~".. -'. ~.~, l I . +-.--.. - ..- . //-~~:~\~ ~0.i I~ ~\ ""-. ' i' I I jl'~' . . ,,,..' ~i ...... ...,t....". """ I- / \11 f- - - - ---- /. -- ,..~ ..' ;; ~ .- --- I I ' I \ .. - 't- --- --I I' ""-' ~,.., ~, ~"" ~.,,' ...... ....." - y I i \\\ ". ~'-J" ~='~ ...-.-" ,..~_. .._~--"- ~ 1 -, \, ,.", r '-:.- .",,, -'" ...." . " ----c ~~,_ .... I '~)'" / - \--. ""~t":--- -- -- - ... .- \-.--:: J. I\t)d:.lf~ i!JI:i~'\ {"'''-''''''0, , , " . . " \ '.....!: /".. :'-;c' 5;",,:, ,1\ '1"1 ... .--1--".--- --.--.---- .. vI( 1"'1 '. - \ 1 . . '.' . . '-,.......: . . . y (..~, 1/';;),1 J\' ~ --. ..u......_ "~~:' . L.", ~~."';\:-..~0~ \~1\' .1' ff" .."_ .. . "1'.: .. o ...." - ....;l~'( l"'-;-+--'t N : .. "", L j i../ .. ,. .. o W+'. \ \ W"J...."<< 1 ,:2. :~'.jl..._. ~M../" -.t'----J-.--. .--- ' .J-..l " .--\' "'V" ,. ::-, '"....\~...., CIl' ~ \ - ,(, "0(\'''. 'iN"~ ,~'--, . ~. " .. .. ___ s ~~~~ ~" - ~~ lP~ '-tL.. --~ ",~ - - - -- _ "^,, . _, l,c=~f~~~~J' :i~.J /~U) '\.-t Ie !_,~J . _ '''' 2"" ,.., ..., VE AS __lE6eND _ PROPOSED DISTRICT llNE ..Sf"''' "".....u..~,. _ I DONNA FIALA OI.STRICT. PO. p. ULATION' I ii! JAMES D. CARTER Ph,D - 1n-----~--~~--- :I - TOM HENNING --2------- 50,759 I 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KIE ~_____~___~~-=-=-~--:,~,!1!~ 5 - JAMES N. COLeTTA. Jr. ___~______ _ _ -~~L--1 _ I~O'tATU to......!,.. ""to", Wff ____~? ___ _ _ _ _. _ -~.----...~~.~~-~..1 .~r..~EO ay, G"~P"'[;S ".0 TE"''''''Al ~l!P."'" SEemm sum ",51.377 I '"....lI~'TY DEVE:L"""['" >NO rNVlRO""r><TAI ~[~"'CfS ml<S<ON ,AT,. '0/100' riLL CO"-0'~l-.....-1 0.... / !'l01: .'l!TOCAD_.",,- _.,..___..._ _~...___m~ ~o_."_. ~_~~_.__~, .~_, '_".., _.-".._~.__,,~.__ III 25 E " 26 E III 27 Ii III ZB E . MAP #2 '::-[.'. ... .. .. . ._~.~ = COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES "~"I". -. . ' . _" _". \ -..,- .. ":- BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ____ __ _ _----. __ ____ _ ___ ...'" _ _ __ __~ COl.lIER COUNTY, FLORIDA " . ., ~ I: ~. - . J -, . \ \ ,i -'!i--~;.~~ -~-I , i- - - --f-~- ----- -~,..I~~ :~ --- ~ \~~_ ~~, ~ !~! ~ lEE COUNTY J._.+- ,-- __ _ _ .. i __ ___ _ i(j. . //+ 1 ~ 1. ,. -, -,. -" I ~(I . Y' "'1 . . . .. .. I-r- - -'. -" ., ; 'r ~t .'~-.. J,il ,= = ..... ~...' .... ~~~ :.:~::~~::. ~:~ -~ .. '~'I")" . ~ 1- "1 1 -",I -", .." -"", I- '~' n, i':' 'JC~ ~ n ':" ..:_. "I ...._ ,M'" ,...", I _~_ -I i_ I I I'- -...- --" " " '1l )-'1'1 'jlill'hl~!III'~ ."" .. .. I.' . .,. ....", -'" ...'" '-", ".." -,,, _,,:1_____...... ~-I--\I- ,'" __ .... .. j" ---,-----.------,-+----" . -. .Ii'" .\ '" i. ,,' ""'1-'" """,-"'-'" -"'-'''\' . r:r~' ,:c:::..... ".__;__._ -- ---l- ----i- n_,__ t '/'1 ' 1-' -" -" -" "'''!'''''' ...,,, ...", -" ,., ...,. -'" .",.1 \ ,___ _1'1__1 __ _._00_ ____:~, _.~': ,",' .~. .-- ~_ ~___ ___ . . . .. I , _,,, . "~,, _" ... '_,., _.. _", _", .'" _.., .. .,. ,.", , : l". "~-~'" ..~~ -.:;;-, ....1."" 'E--T- .' -'-'--'- ~'- : ,-1"1-": ,,-. """, .'''1 -"-c---.. ' .. ." ...... ..~:' ....:,'_.. I ,.. . ... ! .", I' .. -- L"'" ."1- -- ~li" ~ '..- _J~~ _",'-" --I.. - '-- . - ~- "-- ~i -=---.::......._..> . (J .I..." ,.. .".1.7" , , I. -'I j .f- ~ - ~ ~- - ;~'~" ",:::~;~i~~:' -~--!---i- " !---.--: ~_~_~ ~ -.. ".,..~ _: ~ ~ t' I" ~ ,.. !, _:~..' "'-',; ~,. " "..: ' " .! -'. .,,, .. . " '-;., I ;:;<i: . I. ~-' -." , "". ",~I ,. .". I'." :~"'\- .' .. - "...., I.! .1_ " - - . ,..' .".~' "''''.= ..."" ~ __I . I"" I ' .. .,.. I' I..... ---, . .I~.+ , ,\11' (". .'. '-_I .,-- .,....1 ." ...-...--1-.''''"'' _". -.:.... ."" -"......: i o 0 .. ~'I . 1 . ,I", , 1 " 1 .. I' . .". .,,-- f---m - - l . '-.. ~'lr'" "... - I. '._, -.-- I' '" ."" .. ."" ."" I """' ., i.'.. .. .!" ..:.' " I. . "I -"-..-. . ...----- -j- . ~I"~.II*" '... '. -I --.-l. I -,. ' . ". -"" ., -,.... .....- '. ."" .. \. ",I. I'" 1 " ...---. '-- f'. ~~i-'I"'I '-~~" I - ....... .' 1- .1- i - _j...... .'" "'I .",," "-,,, _". :;-. I " '! f------. --- .., .....,_. ~, ~,~~ "" ' I .. I~ I - -- '_[' 'I . ."" .,,,.j -".. "-",,.... '" N~~r[t'\ 1 . I" 1 ~ . . " ....- --... . --- "... -..- c'. If(~"..r,1' ~ "'-..:1 i- I ---..! - ,.,,,, '" ...,,,, ."" ."" .". ."" C') " ,,~c. . {' " ' '" r--e--f- ..- o ":""c' , '~ J -"" '" .".. -'" ."" ....." -"" . I' '-;1""1-;:;:[ /;-'1 -, ,- - "-- ---- '-'..--- Ui \ I "'''--. ,,,'? I , , '. ~ " " \:!\: " - -I"~ 1" -, " ."" '" .... .". -'" -'" -.... "~~ -.---..In-- ~ ")0 , " '. .. .u I..... ",. 'M' -... -... -.'" . '.j .. - - t -"" .. -". \ '--. "\" r?- ~ - -- - -- - - - .:v.r j ~ ~, -, -, ,.--- - ----;0 ~,\~~ "-:' :" ~I- -f' '- """,lIi-.__...:. . ....-.." .'.: --"- . ~;,~ ~!7-0' v~o' r." ." :::..'::", "." , , '" \. . :;WSc"d ",',,, I _} __ I _ _1 "- -..- - -- ._f-. " -~-;C-:'~ r. J" - ~ /'~" ~I (ft .. j .', , I" ~. .L~~ V",,' ""C,c: ",Ii' --c) .n S-k- 1._ r l( It.. f<, &~''-f, . . .. . . " .., . ,( .. '.'1'. ,,!$ ~..~~\~ ~'\.J) [- / 0~ - ..-) - ___,__1..__ 1__ N + "' ~c\\'i '1., "" ..,,~ ,-., , "1'1 III \ \ <". M~ //\ ~r $ ~z L -~ - " w '~~, /\: ~ \ ;t.! (1(11.. WI.'.'- ,-~I\ . i fp'); ~ Oc JF -t ":-, , :;:,g I I1.:PII,J R'.. \i\G~ \1;k 7-"- ;('''1 I~" - - - ~_+-~~~~_ T-~-=1 - ,<~~lsJJ~1~~~;~~ _:. , Xwi?L;S' ~.--\ ,~;~ /_J~' - .~, '~I "" .~, .~~~~!!I~ _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE D'1T.'~! "0......"0111. , 00""" ,,~" [~ -""- i! - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D --1--------- --49,840 - 3 TOM HENNING -2 .-----56,759-- 4 PAMELA S. MAC'KIE ---- 3 . - --------- ~4l(3~ S JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. -~~.~~_-~~_=____=__=_~=----j~~~ _ 1~"'"A'" c,..""~~IO~ ~"'","T u~. __,_ __ ~ ____________~,<43L_ PR(P.RED BY' GRAP~FCS '~l> T€CHNlC.l SUPPl>IlT Sl:GlJO~ sum 251,3n CO....u~lrr On.UONU<T....O ENWroN"'EN1.l SEIl"'CES OI\iSION _ _______ 0"['0/'00' mr,CO"-O<SI-"AP-,_OW<;/I'tOI,.U1J<;All_PAl __~,",___ __,h_~ H_,~'" ____,_~~_________~'"-,- __."~____~__~,_._,. W__._M__.__. Ri!5E Ri!tiE A27E AZ8E MAP #3 --1_14-- -- -- -- ---- ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES ~L :1-:'-< : . . .\" : .:- BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS _ I - ~ ~~__, ...." ...'.. ...,., COlUER COUNTY, FlORIDA I . " II ~ ' ~ D ~ \ j I "... ".. , -. .--":- --'I - I -, -,-'- -.---, - i ~ I . , . , , . ....' " \~~': '- i \\ lEE COUNTY ' ,._,.,__ __ "_:_= ~_"_ ____ _n__ \ ~\. II' . /1.1 "_!_" . I, ' -, --'--",,' '..... ..,. -! ..... ...,," ,. IT -- l' - --- n -- I '1'0'" .,.~' f- -'--..:'...f- .-- -- - -,--- ,~ ,.... " " """""'" . , ,. . '.... ~.. """ '" "'" ".., '.-';:'~ I l I~. ~- ~ "-'Jli--2!'::; -; -.--. +--' J-' "I ~ "." .'~" . '" .... ....' "'" .." "". . .. . : _.'-_. "'-1 " - "-', '-it"'. -," - '~J'--::- . ,. . I . 1" ",,," I' " I' ",,, ",,, ".." ,,"" -'" -'" ..'" ~ --" ' -- --- --,--- ; - -~- "I . ..--- -~- '-~:- --~-- ." ." .. I . ,I.. "..""... "'"1''''''''' "'"-''' ~ "_ . , =:.." 1 ____ __-' - ---t- __ c'--- _n__ .I. " ,. "'"" 2" _" ..". ",,, -'" ,,'" ", -... -",I __ I' I ~ I I .. "'''' 1_: __1_ ' ,-1-1 . -.-'- - !:~.... I -'--, I... ." - - . " -'" . ,,:I'" "": ,," ".. 1 ,," "". "", ".., ,,'" " ",.-. . - .- -.:".:.. -- _.J_--..J - --- -- "i' .. '~"'.. . '.'" ", t'" """i-""" I.' -- ----- : _, --- _u_ _m_: = j ...", ---- ___ _~ 1_ _L _----=- __= ,",'" _~_-+~_ , "i' :.... ; ..,,, I '" .." --I """. I . .." ; "I ':,'1 ",. "". -- ,. ; ~ '-. ---' .-- --;i;;;- ".... n__ __~--,,_"_- -- --" '~" "I.~ " ,,","'" "~". l/'" . I "" ...,f - -- --- c;] .";"." -....-.. ". .... c.. , - i' "'," ... I" " ..! -'. "'. .. " .".1 r:: I-- I, I I <"" - "-C-. . : -- ----- '.- '- --" -- _1___ c-... "'~l' ,.,-~,"",~"",.. ,,' "'''",,, --1- '- ,..: V ,- ..'~ " " " " . ,,'.' ...,., ,- i .c. 'I ' " , 'I! ----." - .". I i:," -1--'\.... .~,'~ ~. ,,,.:. ~ I ,__..!. .......,,~' ",," .""" .'.'''' . ."'.. -: I~' I' " .: i- - -, i'- f-- -, -_1-- ~ 0 "((~.~I'\l.-t".- r 'I +~--' ~ ."-'-.::"",--",,"'--'--.::.::- . . 'f I' /.."" . '-., 1--,' -, I ----- . 1---"--'"' -"" "-- ''',,' ."" ' I'.~!;' ~, I:~I' , . " " I ,...-- --- 1 -.- \j ~I:i - 'I~.. - -- " I -11""- .. - ' - -1=" --"" -::'. . ".....c-- ".l ' ~ ' . '. ,. , .. ~ - - ,'\---. I - -I ---.1-. - .... "'I "'''''I".. "". ,.,,,, ? , . 1 ..' , I --- -- --" n ~ 'It ,I_c~' --, (-i'-1' '- '.".""...1-" ".'''.'''' He" D ~ , I .... . 1,---- -" - -. ;,.;. \'~~\r:<~)_' -~ ~,-I -1_ I' -.:--'" -" """ .: .'", "."" """ .". ."" (j 1\\: :?\i?; ,_. _ ____ __ __ _ ~. _~___ ,'.""'" ../ I...... '" lit 0 \.~ ",-=" '-'=' .-;.:~ q-- _-- --"'IIIlIII ~ ,_ --f--- _.._ "~_ ,~,... ~; ...' ,,. ...' '" i ...' ," ...' '"' - '''' , \\'",,--, ,0~ ,. * f-------- III \ <.::\ . \ /" . I ~ . '" . \..,~~,,'''-~~I-I --, -----..:.-1.':""., ."''''''''''''-''~-... '\'~".""'I" "'1,.,,, "~I ,\ iLi. I ....."., """ "". ,,"" " \''\' :::i-,\~r'-" ",' ~,-5 --- .1.- --- ..."" .., ...,... J I \~ \~1~r.- ~ c' \" "I. "0..,, ,,~" ~ ---~ " ',,\lr,-..il': ~.'" __l~ ,_."...,," I~ \,) J / ,. ---\- ".., - --- - -- -,- -- -. I\'~J~ ~~(:'\;:;("~1"-;-' f l' ',,-' 1"<" "'"'' '/ ti;,,~ O"(~lj I~;~ '\\)1." ----- --1--"o,f'.-- - -,,------ I' L\ ,v.T J - :::;;h~ I - - "- -- fU - - ~. -- ... r '( ~,",,,\ ""'\--- - ,,(.~ ' "" , . TT. " .. .. : .. \ ',"I \"tr=t:ifV( " J',-" \. ~ . - 1_ - ~L--' . + \ \ '''W\''''~'.0 - K f' /z -- . " '~:'"/\ - '\~J:)1:~ ,-;;; '~ ;iJr:; tc~J:~ -4: .:. in- - - n ~ , >C.,," I ~~ l[ "I "1,\0, ;l~'Yfn I -, ) I C, is - - seNf ~f:l\x-'\ p I' I 'l~' (. \"'-, I' .. _3 - 0;:-' ---- I T____.-f.-___:r:"_:--:-=1 -- '_-!, _ < . 11 i' L-L j~ I, k ---'\ '"' "_'- __I ''', '~I ,,,' '~I ---.!,E&END _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE ".""",, C......I"'..'" I DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATION i2! JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D T' ---------00.1.5 - :I - TOM HENNING -i -,----- 50,-473 4 - PAMELA 5. MAC'KIE 3 50,375- 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA. Jr. _ .4: _ _ _]9..Mi~_~_ _ '~OICArll Co........m. ","TR'"' 1101 5 __.__~,043 ~A[PAR[I' ay, G..<PHJCS '-ND 'rC'''',Ol SU""ORT S~CTIOO ____ _______._______ ~ 251,317 ~~~~'~~'/:og,[~L~t~:r'~~'<.~,~~:2~~~~ r~~~~s..z'~~~p"'_ _..."~--------------_."- .._,---_._._-,~.. .---. ----~.,'," R2SE RZSE R27E RZ81i MAP #4 ~-' -- 1'- -- --- --..- III _, ~, ",,, _, ~ ~ ~ " " . . I . COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES - ,-- - . ..- t- BOARD OF C~UNTY COMMISSIONERS __=-_.~_'j:." '_II~_~_-=,,_::-~: ~,~_" ~ ~ COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA _ ":" -I~ .. _,,, _j'~ , . ,..., 1 .. . -- .n.".:-' ---[---;-.- - - - I t-- .... 1- +--- ,'. l' ,I/! I. .1, .. i ' \', ~ ' ' " ".",. ..."., , ~ ! I.: \\ LEE COUNTY - [___1___.'-- --.. _ cr, ,r'l ~ I .....-...-......-~-'... . I . t' .... ...',' I ./- " -' ..., .,.. ',C.:: -- -. -.- -. ... .-. - i _ ~-:"~'~= ---I~"- -c-,- ~ r-:-, . J;",?.. I' " ' . I" . I ~_ ."_ .'."'" ..., I . F - ,._, +---. . ..-- I : iJ;li;;pj, ~. r"'", " , '.. --'1'- .. ..~r ..., ',I" ..." .". ..,". .. ,\1;' ..... .. "'- ,"I -- -- . I " " , \'''_''...1.':.... ... . \- -'" "--. I;' - .' ," r.=""!..'" -... .,,, -'" ...=' --I. .-- 1~1_ . _ , _ , _ ,,''!, . ~,' ~::..,~ J"" . -'''i ....,. ,~,., ...,,, _,,, ...,,. ...T" _~_ ., . ... .,._ 'j__ _.1-__.._ _1-'_ - , .I. I ,. ,... _.. ._.. .'.. .... ...., .", .'" ."'.' .,. .." .... I' I _ i-"- -....-- -.--- \ _ ...~ ._.u -. . I . .. _:.. ..", .". ' :.",' f" ..... ... ..... ... ~.~ ..,,, ,'.'" _,,'''.. .:" _.~. -: C.- '--j'\ . _._,- -1--1 : ..~"'" " .-,,, -'''.'' ,.,,, '.... -"" .,,, .~. . -.- ~' ,..., -'" -: -.---- " , 1 -, .1"': i ",.. r Em'-- :'.~i- - -.--. -.- ~1 :~- ~.:::-~~-: '. -e -- ---' .... .- "':c- " . -.-- .,. -- - -" I' I ' t/o..,~ ...,,, I --- -- i .~.._- c;) .."" ~'. ..,,, " ", ~'! ---I ~ ~~~. .;_ ~'Y"', ':~:~_ ~.:..~~\ _ ,__ "_I ~ .:. _P_ ~ ~. ...'.. "M'''~____:__~,._ ~ \"" - ...L I' I,,, '~",". , ... .'" .", I '- : V ' --.. ~ ',,-...... " " -, ..,., '1' ;6-=' - .., i "'" """,,-I ' " II ' 1 " ,~c--~ .J... , I '1" ' .'. ". ~". .....' .".. . .."",- II'l 1 ... -"1 I "!l " - ". . . --- ._U --, ...- -., . '.H~I ,,~' I!'.\~:::';;;: i'_ .--' ..... 1.'_ --'--1-"- - ,.", Col' "'''. ._'., ....., ."'''''_1 o 0 . ~ I ., ....,.":;-.". I . - - ,- ~ ] I -......- 1 i ......, . . JI ' -- ...., . '1- ".", ."" ."", " -;, ~\l\J'~~~~.1 --"-- '~"'F' ::. - -~-~ .:,. ,~ =~: ' = :::=_J \1 ' . i' ./ \ I' "I' r I f-. '-, -- , '~-+ -,,".~.-I- - -'- I . .." _ _ I- "_ ..". ~:l ...... - _ ' -'" ."" ;:;:: ,~,,,... .., ':: " I" I .. --'. - --- ''0 \l;J.!\' I.-/-r,1""'- , - -. - -__ _', ."" ~,! ...., -"" .". H \"d.,~1 l ' '. . "" ""j--- ----f-- o \'~""~~J' ,,r . '1' .. .' ---- ,-- --- --- . 0 \~'.-.:"''''. ';~.{ I\-I-."~', -.' .---.-- ."" ~'f"" ."'.'.."" ."" ."." ;; \,."'~. ,) .,' , (: I.. '1'"" --- - -- - . \' I\; ~~/_. . _' _ ."ll~.,,,, ,.,,,,"' .". .'" -'" ",... .". " \~!J;;:? ..... ".~." ....!-~ -.-- - -- --f--' "W . . "" "'. .""."".",," \~\\~I'~'\-")",:,~1f. 0.'.-.. .-. '-.'." I . -\ ~ ~ liro:., ~=:' ': .':" - , l ",,1 -I' ";("'~~'t"~ ~ f!I"'-, -"'." f . \:J:'.~~""".'.~J"'~;'.lC;~.'." "';..~~';;:---=-~- ~ "\-, ,,',-, I' .. ".> "-""'~?' * ...\ \ ... ~-.... - - ---+-- .. /~i'- ",0/,;V"'\,I. ['>..~' , (/.r/'i( '< 'c"'~.~tj'\= ." - \) 1- - I' ~ - . . ~ .fJ '~'" .,,1;, I' . " -..... I : ' .\: ~,"rfj;'\l' ./ f( -.- -~ 1-:-""" - . + ...... .. ....- ..,~ ..;.-0. ,1'I)';'z t r -" - - " W 'i:" /1.' . \ ;!\r ..~ ~T:'"" 'r~ F:: 1..:. '..'- "-"-. ~ - - -" :... " :::,g SJf. 'i~'" 'pC" .i-) - 1-'- ,r,' -- - - 'Y., \ ~. \'('l-~-' ~;' '.I ll{ r.:- --'\.-\ " T"/ ",J ~~ ~ S(;Al.['_~~_. '. 0',:00"', __if"' .' 'uL),t , " _'i... .,_, ,,...~ .~ i. -- --, r--r- r, .. ,.:;_1",. ~ -" (.,- ----. ~. . __ ___ o '"' 1" .lOlL .y, \,E6END _ PROPOSED DISTRICT UNE .tl1o,cI <o....'.."Hf~ I DONNA 'FIALA _~~~CT ~~POflULATlON j ii! JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D 1 50,229 :. - TOM HENNING 2 49;-492- 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KJE ----3--------- 50,8&4 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. 1_ ____-!. u. _~,~J:.~~_: _ '".'CA''' <....."".. .",",Cr II~I 1-!5 __ _._ ._,_50,.013'._ PRfPA"fD ~v: G/l.o.P><.cS AND '['CHNIC'L SU'"'Oftl ,(cnON -" ___.__. sum ~51.3n ~~~~~~l;.,g,f~,~~N~~N_OD'~~':':~~~~~_'t r~:i,~[S~~'~~p.... ,-,--.-..-- "~-"_..."-'.---.-'" -._".._._,._-_.,-~'._-_......'" ,-,.~.,-".'-,. --.-.--- Ri!SI RZ&E R~7E RZ8E o MAP #5--- .:' ',. '". I" ,,[':' : COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES: 1,'.- , " "".., .'" \ ,~. . ":- BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS -- -.. ----. -- --- --f------ "..", ____ __ '.__ COlUER COUNTY, FLORIDA " " " "I ~ ". ~-.. \ _" .,,_....,/ _.__'_ --, ..--e:~',""~.' "".."-1-.-- \:'li ~. d -.j . ,I, ' .. I . \,~ (.~.L_~ . /1 '.\ tH COUNTY ~____._ -f--\---- _'~ ~,:..:~ - -- -- ':-" ! I: i I. . ..., _.. ""',.. I ~" "\' I ,1/.'1... I' I,.. I, 1-- f-.'-" . "'" , ""," ""," '.' I 1 ".,,, ",," f- " 1l~. ' . I ",,' -1-,-, "", "'- -- -- . -I-- -, ,-, ---- -,- o fYi" ~ . e' 1 ,. " I .' I .., , . '.. ""," ""'. ""." ... '. ", = ;*~CUj - -j'::.;;,j 1-- --j- 1.1--'-:] -- ""1 I- \~i; --;.-~ ':.__..:.. r:-. } _ ,~--' ":.....L~J .:_ ,. "''''1 ...". ..::........::- ".". ""',.. "",,, --,~ ---- -~- 1 \, I F=" \ I I ' . ..."' , . I I,". ",," ~., '''''', ...., ..,,, ,,,.., ...". .'" .'" " , r!i':'" '""" j. ' . ~'i ;'- -. .-- ~ -"1' -, .- --t. -- - -- I -- . ',- I " " .. "'.,, .. '.' .', " I" I I" """'I""'" "'" .". '.'" .,,, .", I -."- '-r---'-~~;''' .f-.. ----."'----. -.--- -.--"\' \ J., j , . 1, -,!~" u"'" ""'_L..." .." "."" ...,,, ""'.. .~, """. "~'n ,.,". ,-- - ._1 ~ --! --- t:~ ~,,: _. ~', . ,~, ... -- __'_ __n__ _ . .. . .. I , ...", . ";II -" ." I ,." ,""" .".. """, ,,"'" """. " .... """'. -I ; 1- -~'~'~I '"",,, "",,,...,, ".,:::~. ."..1"",,, ~ I~--r~' O' """" ..",:~..t:,-1 .. II' "-;'1.:;1--"';-:--1' :::-:'-_--:..--1 -"'---J-' ". , i ; - ~:-~ I COlD N '___ _ _ "_"" I , ":: I ~.,,. "~'", "!,, " : --I --r _H_ ---1 ,- i;rr ...". I - -- __ ---;; -----.--._~_!_ () "~.! ',.. ..:.. ..'" ~',:, ,,/. ,;'" , ._ I' ",," i, 'j .,1 ..,. ...". " ,,' -.:- i::: I I '~'"_O",,,-,,' i I .-'" -- --.1-- .. --- - r""-.., "I I" ~ I . .-" = ~ . " "" "n' ",,,,, ...,.. ----- '- \ ", 'Q' -- ".- "'__ .~. j. I "'",,~ . "" . "', -\ .c:;, i I" r' I' ~! "r -I'"~': -, ,," - .......oiI I -. I I"""'!.' -'.. ."" ."" ' ,<>P[5 I -~ - ' _ .1'.. . I. j ..' I --r-- u_ .- _' n. o \. . hh I~ ,I. I" -!' ,," ." .J..""t " "".... --'. ""," .....'." .. o '1" I 1 1 i- ---,- .-- ---'- III 0 . '\ l' . I ' .'" . "~"o' , t Iii ".L.._ -". I I . j", -,,, . """"t""" .' .. -." IfTfJtF""~" - ! . -- 'I! .. , "- - u 'd'I , \. ".... ,--t-" - - \.. \~lll 1 -: II -- - .... ~': "':! 1"'" "" _ ',.",,, __.", \ 1,1 .. 1 .~. I' , " -.- ,- ;..!.;.1.. ' . .1- ~ I ~ .. .."..~ """" __..1.__. "",,, """" 2::. ""' . I ~. ". I --I . -- ..,- '" \~T.'~'~-"l" ..1 I 1.,,;1 . I . ~ __ . _' -....Id .....' "-,,, ,...... " c I . IJ, I.. I' -- _L_ - -",. - --- - :J \:" 'l.Ji d l '''~ " ,"," '.., .."" ...,,,. -"" -,,,. ..'" '.:2' \0"~' ';;.. -. ~ 1'-:-. :'-':' t -- --- U '.", .. _ j I. _ ~ _. ..". "" _". """. ..... -", _,.. III \ ---rllf"/~-S- li ..~ ------.:...- -- __ ______ _ iii \ .\) 'I ' 'a'" " .. " ~~r.. l' I -II _1 . - '... \ . -"" ,'" -,.. -". ...., "".." '."'" " j...". I \ I ...... .--- -.- .-----. ,. .....~." ,,;"Ill L ,1\ r'l (-', I I ..... " """ ,~, '" ... ". ...'" ' \:1 \b~,.. "(!r . . I . -. ..,.. " ..., ,0 . .- - . .-- 'I I'" JI." " ,~ . " ' ,\1, -c;i<,,"YI .'_ -"- ~~ """ "",,, "",,, " .. ril( ~~i~ I~~,;\ -:'" . 17 ".; ="=.~~___ -- \ ...._"__~ /~. I' 'ft~f4'(()\ J . If~. "-,..." ,II 1 I ,:'\", l,-o'-' '. _ t.- If _ --- }-n___ I 1:, ~c,_, ;,. -- - ! { . ~ v J..!: -' , ,. ~ o ,( -,"~ ~ 'l'~~\= l\ ~. 1\' _- __L -.K- N + ~\"." _),. . III ':I~ '\;:. J~) ---, - .. w , \ \I "Y?R'('~ -"'" . "', ,,"= _"('I . -" ...."" T ! "" -\ \ ..,1<< ' '. r"" " I ' " " " ;:""'0 l""; ~ rill '5 J A ,.l', _'- _'~: ~ ,,""" I :~~ II Ir, i/~ ,,~("I, 7t '\ -: I fl, \ .~~,,' -- "" :;~~~_~;:..::::,,, ; -~--- (",~I!'" _ __ u {_~-,-~J ~ '\ '( ,..!..~-_, __~:; .~'~_~ - _._ ll;filli~D _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE "IS"I" cc"'u''''o.,' I DONNA FIALA [DISTRICT POPU~nON Z - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D _=--~ - --....--"--- ~--~-:]!~11=: 3 - TOM HENNING 2 48,626 4 - PAMELA 5. MAC'KIE ---3---------------49,570- 5 - JAMeS N. COLETTA. Jr. 4 50209 --.'5---.------------------51'455-- _ . . _ 100Iel". c......'..IOH "".'cr lI~f r.---.-.--------~>i'i"f-. ~HlP'~(O "y- ~"""~tC' 'NQ 'l~"N'C'L ",PPORT ,EcnON ______ ___'_n__ _ L- sum ~ 251,3" ~;~[~~(~;'/og'[\'l"\<~:'L~~N~:.ODI~~_""~2:.'~~~ Ir~L'6t;[\~''i'o~~ PAl ",,-_. -.-.....--.- -.--..'------..--..- -- - .-...---. , . . , . . . . . . -.. - - . - . . - t , t. ;i~~ \~':,'l' (:~. \; ;,r.; ~ . "- .. DRAFT DRAFT Table of Contents Paae Introduction...... .., ... ,...... .",...... .,.....,.....,.,... ................ ... ,... ........... ..........,. 2 Redistricti ng Criteria.........""..............,.,.,..............",..,.....,..,................... 2 Methodology...,.. .,.,..,.... ...,... ... .......,..,..........,."... ,.,..... ..".. ... .....,...... ..... .... 3 Pre-clearance Data.. ....... .......... ........... ............... ,........ .......... ............ ......... 3 Features"......,.... ..,. .,.. ... ..".. ... ..,...... ....".."... ........ ......... ..... .." ...... ,............ 4 Strengths.,.. ........... ..... .... ..,........ ..,.... ..."....... ...... .....,.. ,..... ..... ".. ...,., ,........ 5 Critique..,.."..,......" ...,.,...,....,.. ..,.............. ........... ,.. ."... ........ .., ...... ."......... 6 Retrogression Analysis.. "...,.." ,........,...... .....,.., "...... ...... ..... ,....... ..... .". ,.,.. 7 . Exhibits 2000 Census Tract Map 2000 Census Tract Population Retrogression Analysis Map of Existing Districts Proposed Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 Gener~1 Descriptions of Districts for Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 1 <<~._,~- ..~~-- --,~~._~~. ....... ~,~...._-. _._~._._-_..- DRAFT DRAFT Introduction Collier County has experienced extraordinary growth since the establishment of the present Board of County Commissioner (BCe) Districts in 1995, when the permanent population was 182,823, The present population of Collier County is 251,377, according to the 2000 Census. As one might expect, this increase in population was not uniform throughout each district (see Table below). Bee District Population in 2000 Ideal Population Deviation District 1 49,840 50,275 - 0.8% District 2 47,164 50,275 - 6.1% District 3 57,712 50,275 + 14,7% District 4 40,662 50,275 - 19,1% District 5 55,999 50,275 + 11.3% Total 251,377 Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). As a result of the uneven growth in Collier County, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners directed staff on June 26, 2001 to redraw the commission districts in order to comply with the one-person one-vote constitutional mandate, The Board of County Commissioners specifically approved the following redistricting criteria: (1) The population of each district should be as similar as possible; (2) All districts should be as compact and regularly shaped as feasible; and (3) The incumbent Commissioner's residence must remain in his or her current district, Additionally, though not specifically directed by the BCC, there are additional considerations of a legal nature that must also be taken into account, This report contains a summation of the five (5) proposed plans. Redistricting Criteria Each of the five plans attempts to balance the following redistricting criteria: . Create districts that do not exceed a 5% deviation from the ideal district population. . Create compact and contiguous districts that observe well-defined and easily recognizable boundaries. . Protect incumbent commissioners by building each district around the residency of its commissioner. . Minimize disruption to former districts. . Avoid retrogression of minority voting strength. . Maintain communities of interest. . Devise plans Whereby uniformity can be achieved between the School Board and the Board of County Commissioners, 2 ..,.~~ " ..~"_.._.._,- --,.~....__. ~ -_.. - ,-...__.._~ --. DRAFT DRAFT Methodoloav The first step in creation of all five proposed maps was to plot the residency of each commissioner on the 2000 Census Tract Map for Collier County, The next step was to build each district by incorporating those Census Tracts adjacent to the place of residency, to the extent possible and practical. (See attached Exhibits, 2000 Census Tract Map and Tract Population,) Examole: Commissioner Carter, representing District 2, resides in Pelican Bay which lies within Census Tract 102,04. Given his place of residency, the place of residency of the other four Commissioners, and the existing boundaries of District 2, it was only natural that Census Tracts 101.01, 101.02, 101.03, 101.04 and 102,05 be incorporated into his district, Generally, this same process was repeated for all five districts on all five proposed maps, The next step, which was the most challenging, involved expanding or retracting each district as necessary to achieve relative equity in population, while at the same time creating compact and contiguous districts with well-defined boundaries. that did not split voting blocks or neighborhoods, Concurrency with the District School Board was another important element that was considered. This was achieved by plotting the residency of each School Board member to ensure that no two members resided in the same district. Collier County is a covered jurisdiction under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Asa covered jurisdiction, Collier County must obtain pre-clearance before enforcing any redistricting plan, In order to obtain pre-clearance from the U.S. Department of Justice, the County must demonstrate that the new plan does not result in the retrogression of minority voting strength. This is ascertained by comparing minority voting strength, as measured by voting age population, under the existing and newly adopted plan (before and after comparison for all five proposed maps). Pre-dearance District 5 has the greatest minority population in Collier County (See Table 1, below), Although it does not qualify as a minorit:y-majority district at this time, it is the district that warrants the closest scrutiny fer possible retrogression of minority voting strength. As District 5 is presently configured, it has a total voting age population of 39,440, based on the 2000 Census, Of this total voting age population, 2,875 are identified as Black and 14,242 are identified as Hispanic, This means that in District 5, as it is presently configured, Blacks make up 7.3% of the voting age population and Hispanics make up 36,1% of the voting age population (See Table 1), [It is important to note that "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity,] 3 ".n~..'_____~_'_"_"',"_"___"__ ,o_._.___~..______,_..,. ,.-.-.-.-- DRAFT DRAFT Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population by District Present Configuration District Total Black Hispanic (All) 1 43,038 1,036 (2.4%) 5,141 (11.9%) 2 40,401 257 (0.6%) 2,249 (5,5%) 3 44,153 1,811 (4,1%) 8,238 (18.6%) 4 34,404 1,333 (3.8%) 3,685 (10.7%) 5 39,440 2,875 (7,3%) 14,242 (36,1%) Total 201,436 7,312 (3.6%) 33,555 (16.6%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 9+171). ANALYSIS OF EACH OF THE PROPOSED MAPS Features MAP #1 District 1 remains the same, Collier Boulevard is the main feature as it fonns the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area. MAP #2 District 1 remains the same, Collier Boulevard is the main feature as it forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area, MAP #3 Most of the population in the coastal area south of US-41 is included in District 1. Portions of the Livingston Road corridor fonn a north-south line parallel to Collier Boulevard, MAP #4 The main feature of this plan is the elongated shape of District 3 - extending. from the Lee County line to below Davis Boulevard, and from 1-75 and the Livingston Road corridor to Collier Boulevard, Also, Collier Boulevard forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area, 4 -~.._._---- .--..--. _,_.c~,"o_._, ~__.,__.,...__ ---~-_._- _.'- DRAFT DRAFT MAP #5 Districts 1 and 5 are nearly identical in configuration to their existing boundaries, Districts 2, 3 and 4, while maintaining their core Census Tracts and most of their existing boundaries, are now neatly realigned along the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Uvingston Road, This north-south alignment, parallel to Collier Boulevard, is the distinguishing feature of this plan. Strenaths All five plans accomplish the Board's directives regarding population equity and respecting the residency of each commissioner. AIi five plans accomplish the Board's directive regarding the creation of compact districts with regularly shaped boundaries, though to varying degrees, MAP #1 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of lmmokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd. - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population, All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4, The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #2 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd, - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population, All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4, The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #3 Of the five proposed maps, the population is most evenly distributed on this map, This map shifts the communities of Everglades City, Plantation Island and Chokoloskee from District 5 into District 1 - these three communities have some characteristics similar to Goodland which also lies in District 1. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned, MAP #4 All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4, The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned, MAP #5 By using the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Uvingston Road as a major boundary, this plan creates highly compact and geometrically neat districts with well-defined and weli-recognized boundaries that follow major features, The Uvingston Road Plan avoids dividing neighborhoods, utilizing minor features and creating numerous irregular boundaries, At the same time, the boundaries of the current districts were respected where practicable: All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned, 5 ------~- -'-'-,-'-','""._'~" ...-.-- ~--- DRAFT DRAFT Critiaue MAP #1 There are several jogs and turns in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Districts 4-3, The common boundary between Districts 4-3 runs through Coconut Creek and Coconut Grove neighborhoods dividing each between two different Commission Districts. MAP #2 There are a few jogs and turns in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Districts 4-3. The deviation between highest and lowest District population is the greatest on this map out of all five maps. MAP #3 This map shifts the communities of Everglades City, Plantation Island and Chokoloskee from District 5 into District 1. Arguably, the character of these communities is dissimilar to many of the developments in District 1, e,g, Marco Island and Lely Resort, Also, at least in recent history, those three coastal communities have been located within Distrtct 5. MAP #4 The common boundary between Districts 3-1 contains several jogs; some of these do not follow recognizable features, e,g. the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, and the east side of Wing South Airstrip, MAP #5 Arguably, that portion of Census Tract 112,01 east of 1-75 has evolved into developments substantially different in character from the rest of the proposed district. This is a legitimate concern, and communities of interest were considered in devising this plan. However, it should be noted that no district is perfectly homogeneous, nor is it dear that strict class or ethniqradal segregation is wise or desirable in a community as diverse as ours, In addition, District 5, as it is presently configured, includes all of Census Tract 112.01. This plan shifts to District 2 that portion of Census Tract 112.01 west of 1-75 Retroaression Analvsis As noted earlier in this report, only District 5 warrants a retrogression analysis as it has, by far, the largest minority population, In the present District 5, the Black population comprises 7.3% of the voting age population, and the Hispanic population comprises 36.1% of the voting age population, As indicated in the attached Exhibit A-3, Retrogression Analysis, all five proposed maps result in an increase in these minority populations in District 5; conversely, none of the five proposed maps result in a retrogression of minority voting strength, Redistricting Report DRAFT1 F, Redistricting TD/dw Oct. 2001 6 -^~~"~._.- ---".--^--.--.... .~..."-~---'-~~ .. _.... ....._-,., - ~._-..'-~.,,-~~,- -~ I <0UlI~ c;l '" ----- ". a ~ ,. COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ., " 2000 CENSUS TRACTS 113 , , 114 " ~ i ~~ ~~ 0....... 112- ~ : -- I 'i r-1-U I . , m"~TY -"'""...... 101.02 <<- 112.01 - 0'_ 101.03 112.02 <<- , I :gIN "'''''''...,. I 101.'" . " 1 04.05 104.12 - ~.o ,....1 ,- , GIUlDI"""'''''''. , 102.lM , , , , -- ~.._....nf. 104.1<4 ,.3 , 3.01 , 4 I 2 10.....,3 3.02 "'......... =01'- - 1W'!.BS ...... l.lOOIT.T[_" ~~.. _."_1$ 1 108.01 ,...04 . . 107.01 m ~ I 'l. ~ ~ Q I 111.02 - , : cnYOI' AUllCOw-lND ".~ " ',.., .., ! ~----~ ~- '-"'0, j SCALE I , 0 lWI. 2'''- i I LEGEND I i 11- ~~, m,a 'OO",AA' l . ,A ! 'j---../-t ~, I .~ '- /i; Li;"-", .ao""'.... ""i V,OliO ;r:- J - -,. , rf-.-" ---c.:; ............" ~ , PREPARE)} ay: GRAPHICS AHO TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECTION I I CCMolUNtn' DE'<aOl'lolENT AIIO EH'IIROHtolENTAl SER\I1ctS Dl\llSiON ')I.)'--7_...l ~~ , > I O...Tt: ~/2001 fllE: ConR-"'-200Q.aWC - --~~._~-_._-~_._-'''-"''- .-- -.."-~'._-'-~ ...~-~""." '-""'-~-'" ._~- ~-_.~_._------- T_ April 1. 2000 Permanent Population Collier County, Florida 2000 Census Tract 2000 Total Population I 3,649 2 2,199 3.01 3,532 3.02 1,631 4 4,717 5 1,813 6 1,483 7 1,29Z 101.01 6,802 101.02 3,542 101.03 6,337 101.04 7,194 t02,02 8,106 102.03 5,283 t02,04 7,383 102.05 2,355 103 4,235 104.01 3,713 104.05 5,802 to4.06 7,007 104.07 6,926 104.08 3,147 104,09 8,380 104.10 6,469 104.11 6,102 t04.12 6,697 104.13 3,336 . t04.14 6,656 105.02 7,028 105.03 7,230 105.04 6,464 106.01 2,601 106.02 3,359 t06,03 5,699 106.04 3,757 107.0t 4,807 107.02 4,162 108.01 3,857 108.02 6,612 108.03 3,458 109.0t 4,048 109.02 3,377 109.03 4,090 110 3,698 111.01 5,887 111.02 4,213 t12.01 3,384 112.02 5,790 112.04 4,623 112.05 3,464 113 9,430 114 4,551 COUNTYWIDE 251,377 Noce!Tern Census Bweau: "Data not. adjustcrl b8sed on theACl:uracy and Coverage EvalUlllion." Source: U.S. Census Bureau. C"'l1ll1U 2000 Rcdiltricring Dala (Public Law 94-171) Summary File, Matrices PLJ, pu. Pl..3, lald PlA. Tractpopularion G. Cumprellcnsive, 2000 Census Jwl April 2001 -~-,._- "--~_._,... -~.- ",",--- -".~-'~'".~~ '_"'.~_e"'~._~', .._-~-.._~._-- Retrogression~Analvsis Maps #1. #2 & #4 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Maps #1, #2 & #4 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104,14 4,598 69 862 111.01 (portion) 1,594 2 106 111.02 3,437 105 7.29 112,02 3,877 126 1,012 112,04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112,05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 34,934 2,854 (8,2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Maps #1, #2 & #4) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36,1%) Proposed District 5 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40,2%) Change +0.9% +4,1% i Source: Figures extracted from U.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). ~- NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a raee; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. " . -~_.,-_._.,.."~_.._~-----_..__.~.".__.._-_..,_....._---------_._-~._,._._._..- , ._._-~--_._-""~._-_.,.....- ..._---.._.,._-'"._~." .----- Retrogression Analysis Map #3 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #3 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104,12 4,704 133 813 104,13 2,381 39 505 104,14 4,598 69 862 111. 0 2 (portion) 2,177 102 702 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112,05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 32,080 2,849 (8,9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Source: Rgures extracted from u.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #3) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Change + 1.6% +7.3% Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. ..".,~~,~,.,.~~~----" .. --- '''''~'-''._-~-- -.--,- .. ---"-'"-'-'._~---- Retrogression Analysis Map #5 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #5 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104,12 4,704 133 813 104,13 2,381 39 505 104,14 4,598 69 862 111.02 3,437 105 729 112.01 2,327 13 76 (east of 1-75) 112,02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112,05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 14,028 (39,3%) Source: Figures extracted from u.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs, Proposed District (Map #5) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 13,349 (39.3%) Change +0.7% + 3.2% Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. -"'^-_..*._--_.~.__.,..-- --- ~.. .-- "- ._~ -~---~ I In ~ _C zl ' _ w .... ' ~ ~; --. , ! ~ 0 -- I CJ - z _ ~ ' = a:: c I o .. z U In ~ a::c ffi ~. I I III ,,0 _ Z ~ u r.: ..Ie ~ ~ ..1- ;:: ~ o In r!1. U In 1;j ~ !l ' I ::E I ~ C l CJ u " . , I I I I I' ' .__ I I _" I . . , r . -- ~ , .. . " ! /0_." '. . d ~ . ' ~ " AJ../WIlD:)331 OI:IY....nlO8~ ~ QlffA:Inl8~ ; . a . OW^Tl~ll !<<IS1/IlA Ql ::i ci u III ; . , . ' ... g ~ :>:- . u i g8 ~~ " ' >. . z' , . " Q'l'O<l ~Hm 9 .ull . . -. . 1\1, ' " . ," ,lli" " , I' c' ., ,~ .Z ,... . .,. ""' .t.s ~~~ . 0' ... u .. Ii>\< \ 00" .151 . .aa " zZ< .," <<? So: g ~.~ 0., j'w 'c__'c" _c ' · 'I, II" ___ 1~ ~~_I ~ .. _'c" c, C' ," I .. C. g~. .. .1\ ~ ~. / '... &I:: 1l I I zc'" z I ;:)w! ... ~ I o /I) Cl =It: CI :i ~, U 0 Z ill ~ -, a::A.O A. <:l CJ I wO- CC ~ fil . -&1::/1) ~ ~ ~ I ...I /I) or:; 0.. ' ...I A. _ ~ <.1 I O:IE 0.. : u 8 I . I , I I i ~ i I A1H'lIXIl>lIOH3H 1-" I ~ \ - . o Q:"IlOS !ll""lI'S . . . . . . . ~ ~ ~ i I ;~J 0 " ! OlI'l'j\]1ro&~ QIn'/I3lrclS3Cl'tll:llG'U ~lm . i ; ~ 0lI'tM100ll NOSlW. ~ U1 " ~ ~ i ~ · < , s · ... ~ a ..: i iiI <J %~ 00 >- \:< ~'" ~ cIi'" ~~ x ~ ~ :~ g ~ g iStll \oJ 'it I :> <>- J " << iilg~ ~g~1 ~~S:I ., ",N ~571 a:::l. ;) 0"",0 . u "I '7 s'n # ;:;~~! <-> 0" '" t; I .ltll1~1~^ "Vov 0 1:1150: I~ 0 ~~.;jl . 8] "0'" I ~ N 5g.... I r-"'~ / -. r ~ _d,,) i "::0,", ' ~ >-c_ , u 1"; 1lI 0' _ U 0;.:.......' ~ ~ze I <" oj ~~I':' ",0-< :l..UO: - --~--- -~~-'"" -..- --'~ ._ <_.,,",.,.,. ~".........-.__ .. .._,..~",.,"~.L~"~. ^ "",_.__ .....__O~__.~.,,_,,~,._ I , I I I I I I I .uHl'IlXIawMOW AJ)lnoo~<l I fn w / z I- :J / U ti ~ i ~ zal- 0 z =w! (II 0 OJ Ofna . !II " c ::E UOz z ::E a. w 0 ar:a.o " <J C W c 11I0- ..J W . -ar:fn :E en ; 0 "'a.fn .. ... - li1 . ~ o :E .. ~ . U :E I ~ 0 > U .lJ,NnO:l..'IIOHlH -= ! . " " u " " " "n " ~ .;<D ~ . . " . u ! " 0 u " . u """""'. """""" Q"/\TI'Il8~ ~_m ~ . ~ ~ -""'" ~ g III ~ > ~ " ~ ~ . g . ~ z " 0 d . > 0" OlE c. ~ ::l~ ~ .. ., !~ ~. 0- I o. ;; SL-I &, i ~~~ I ." ;o!:::!o '=6';' , . ~~~ i . ", r ~OTI oo~ .t"$.rt ~~,!. , cd" 0 H:i 0 \~ :1 ~ "~ I I Ii". - ~~~! .t~~: 'a;!~... ' "",,oJ ..~~______.n_.'~"_ --.."-. --, - - "'-'~",""" --",~- ~"-_.,.., ,,~-- I I I I I I I M/f!1!n'll/YAlOllS I .u00Q:l~1I fft W Z t- :::J .... U ~ ~ i '" I t- en Zein is z 0 =w- ~ en OfftC en :a Q S! . UOz ill ::E a. 0 ar:::LO " " j ~ 0 wo- e w " -ar:::fft :& en . 0 j , -'Lfft 0.. -' - 0 . '" . ~ o :& 0.. . . U :& , . 0 , u ~....,""'"" ,....'" . . . " ""lI'S K"IlI'S ~ ," j '" . . . u . . 0 u ~ . , OlI'IA3'VlOlI SMn:IlB\J awwll:i1rlOlII~ "","",In . ; . . . -~. III ~ . J ~ " , . ~ . i ~ ~ . u .~~ ~= . . ~~ ~E .m"!' . ,~'" 00 . , Uw ~ . ~~ y ~~ ~s , ~~ , " , ~t il. .~ ....." t~ uZ , zg I "" ", i . "" It ~'r\ " .p" 00 I zZ I .' 'u" 0 ~~ 0 ", , ~ ~J ~ " '0 5~ I t.~ ~ 00. I '- ):""' I - ",06 e~d I ~z_ ~~~ 0 .0' .uo --'- ---....--- ... '. ~H" ~>.._~- w_,,,___., .._~~ r--- -----, I I I I I I I AlI'tflOO QIl\lMO!Ili Al.JiI1O::l:llJ'l'Q tn W z I- :J I- U <.1 ~ i ii: I- '" zal- c z =w~ 0 'III' ;;; Ofl)C '" ~ Q ~ . UOz z ::; w 0 a:A.o Do " <.1 . c:r: w 0 ~ . wO- ..J W " . -a:tn :E '" ~ , 0 ..IDofl) l1. . 0 ..I - a: . o :E l1. . U :E . 0 I U I Al.~1.1lQJGH _"11'::1 . . ~ .. u ~" ~ " . ~ " ~ " ~ :; .. . ('-) u .. u . '---...C """"'" """''''''' """"""""""""" AiHllO:IJ3'1 . j . I .. . . OWo\31noll ...... !: III I . ^ ,; g " . " .. i Ii oE ~ " ~ 0 ~ ~ ~i 'g~ 5 '~ , " ~L - I ~~ I .. '" "'""" ~~ 0" ~ ""' '-ll< 5~ ~Q I .. "". oo~ U \.,"!;'r\ " .. ~~..!. .{o~~NY^ ",J 0 ~~:31 0 "'I ~ ~j ~ ~~~ ~~" ,.....5 ~ 0'0:0: I Z ~~- I 8i'.:~1 ",,2'_, :.~ n I 0 ~~~ 1 'uo --_._------ ,....,---..--.-- .".--.-- ... ->>-_.._-~,,--_._"" -_.....-__.-..'~..~- ,.--,'~"-. .w_,__ I "--' I i i I I I I I Al.mo:I <lIl'l'MOiIlI JJ.Hl'1O:l3O'f'1l , tn w I I z / I I- ::l // U tJ ~ i Ii: Iii zal- l5 z ~w!! 0 In 0; Otna '" . =It Q 51 UOz z :Ii , a. w 0 Ill:a.o " (,) " wO- C( ~ c ~ , I w . -a=tn :IE '" 0 ;; ..Ia.tn "- . ..I - ii1 . I o :E "- . U :E . 0 I U I """""""'" _"11-:) :; . ~ " u Q: '~rs 1l1I"$ :; " .; . , OWA3lroi ~ awlll"Dlll~ U_'" ~ . i :i . awA31l'lDll NOS1III I!! III ~ ~ ~ z . il z " 0 " . , " " e ~ , . . "i ;l-I . .~~ 5~;; ~~d . ~ai~ .t'S' , oo~ ~~,!. 0' ",>-'!! -,,, 0 S!3O 0 ~%~ 11 21 ~gc..1 rt!!; I I ~ iii~-I I 0= ,. u o~~1 1 UJ ~~~I I 0" a,~~1 .0< a-uo, ,- n__"_,',_"'_" "- -_..~ .........<., _._- _..~_.~.."._u~,....~"..~,... _.. - -",,,- EXHIBIT '"Aw General DescriDtions. MAP #1 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco RJver; thence along the center of the Marco RJver, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest comer of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast corner of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine RJdge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of Lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of Lakewood Boulevard, northerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, westerly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, northerly to the center of Coconut Cirde South; thence along the center of Coconut Circle South, westerly to the center of Coconut Circle West; thence along the center of Coconut Circle West, northerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, easterly to the center of Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-7S, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road ______,'.,_...__0...' .. -"--'-'-._--~ __._....,.__._____"'.w._ ---.--------.-- 862 (Vanderbilt Beach R[)ad); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road)::.thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly to the south line of Section, 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly to the eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly to the southeast comer of the Regent Park PUD; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Park PUD, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Oam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Oam Pass and Oam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Oam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, southerly to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green Canal, westerly to the center of the Aorida Power and Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marals Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, southerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, westerly to the center of Coconut Circle west; thence along the center of Coconut Orde West, southerly to the center of Coconut Orde South; thence along the center of Coconut Orete South, easterly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, southerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, easterly to the center of Lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of lakewood Boulevard, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S. 41 (Tamlami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township SO South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence alntinue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence aiong the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County--Mlaml-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County- Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County- Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S, 41 (Tamlami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. DW /mklf:/comp.planning/davidweeks General Descriptions Map #1, A F, Redistricting --, .._---_.-- '--'-'~----~--"--,"""",""-""-- -- ,p--_.._---,-"- ._---,--- EXHIBIT ftA" General DescriDtions. MAP #2 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.s, 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence. along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning, District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and S of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections lq, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast corner of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Rorida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Bouievard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road - ...._~.._^.__.__.- ..- ."..~,.-......_-_.._-,_._.,--,~.,.,._---_.,._<>,-_._---.-.>"., _'~-"._~ ,...",~, 862, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundi;lry of Pelican MarSh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly to the eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly to the southeast corner of the Regent Park PUD; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Park PUD, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, southerly to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green Can(jJ, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center ofl-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the pOint where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence northerly to said pOint lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of u.s. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning, OW/mk\f:/comp.planning/davidweeks GenelllJ Descriptions Map #2, A F. Red~lIicllng _...~""...,._..,".'~'>'" __'_.___',.._..~_"_ H"__,__,,> .,...._~,..."'._" - -- ~._.. __ _.... - _w....,^" EXHIBITftA" General DescriDtions. MAP #3 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of County Road 864; thence along the center of County Road 864, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of said road, southerly to the north line of Section 11, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 11, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 12, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 7, Township S3 South, Range 30 East; thence along the north line of said Section 7, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 7; thence southerly along the east line of said Section 7 and continuing southerly along the east line of Sections 18, 19, 30, and 31, Township S3 South, Range 30 East, to the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, westerly and northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 2S East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and S of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 7S (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 29 and 32 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District. 3 - Begin at the intersection of the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26, and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Rorida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of County Road 864 (Rattlesnake Hammock Road); thence along the center of County Road 864, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence alon9 the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to east .~u -,--- -,-- '-.'''' .- line of Section 32, TO,^,l1ship 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 32 and 29 of said Township and Range, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U,S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Florida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier CountycMiami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point south of, and in alignment with, the east line of Section 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along said alignment and along the east line of Sections 31, 30, 19, 18, and 7, of said Township and Range, northerly to the northeast corner of Section 7, of said Township and Range; thence along the north line of Section 7, of said Township and Range, westerly to the northeast corner of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of Sections 12 and 11, of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of County . Road 29, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of Collier Boulevard, northerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Irnmokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. Genef31 Descriptions Map #3, A F, Redlstricllng -"'+~, -- '---'''-- -,."-"-.-...,.~,.." '."~'---'~.' -,~,,~" -, ......_....._.,~._- .".,. . EXHIBIT "'An General DescriDtions. MAP #4 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township SO South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U,S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, easterly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, southerly to the north line of Section 16, Township SO South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of said Section 16, easterly to the northeast corner of said Section 16; thence along the east line of said Section 16, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club; thence along said north boundary, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning, District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-COllier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U,S. 41; thence along the center of Sea gate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Oam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 3 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road) and County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club; thence along said north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club, westerly to the east line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Section 16 of said Township and Range, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, northerly to the north line of said Section 16; thence along the north line of said Section 16, westerly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, northerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the - --,--------..-.-.- -,. ."_.,.,,, -~'." .....~ ,-~-"~,~,--,..'." ,_.,~- center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos 'Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the intersection of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Sea gate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Aorlda Power & Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U,S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Imrnokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning, Gen""'l Oescriptions Map #4. A F, RedlstriclJng ._,--~-"----"-". .~,,,._,--_.~-~-,,,-,,,,.,,,,,_.,._--, --~_.."~.~;~--,'~._. ""'--,'~--_._~-' EXHIBIT "AN General DescriDtions. MAP #5 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U,S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning, District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the east boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Eboli PUD, southerly to the southern boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along the southern boundary of Eboli PUD, westerly to the southeast comer of April Circle PUD; thence along the southern boundary of April Circle PUD, westerly to the center of the Rorida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U,S, 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Cam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast comer of the Eboli PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the southwest comer of the April Circle PUD; thence along the south boundary of April Circle PUD, easterly to the southwest corner of the Eboli PUD; thence along the south boundary of the Eboli PUD, easterly to the east boundary of the Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road ,.-..----^-.--- ,." -,- .-_..- - - -~.<.,.._- .....~,.."~~ . - '--." '-~.~_._- -_.~ 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Florida Power & Ught (FPl) transmission line' . , thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U,S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (I-75) at the lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U,S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of u.s. 41, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of said road, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (I-75); thence along said I-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. General Desalpllons Map #Ii, A F, Redlslricllng 1 -.'--,- -,.~_...~ " ,.,-,~~-- .~.'~,,,... '-__"__H' ....__...._ 'M_._,_..'___"",_ ."".<~.'_ " ~ ~ ~ ~ "'"" ( r '3 '"., ~ .... ~ r- I) N ~ I' -' rfl. M. - - 0 ,., .-l 0 ....... ~ i;{ ~ f;'" .-> ~ ...) )n r- Q r'> ~ - ~ ,.... 1ft ~ "" 9 -:r- Q N ::r- C) - - -- ;: ~ :;j: '" ;< ~ Q) .. <:)0 .... ~ ... , .g ~ ..: ~ S <? :g ~ ~ U .... ~ ; ..- CD ~ . lI:I - .!! ~ c: ~::e 8 - .. ... Cl c: '" lI:I CI.i C ... c:i c: <: n u: ~ 'C lI:I C/) .!! C/) Q]i c: Q) Q) Q) {'il c: .. e e e ~ e ':lOa: -:r8 0 ~I\J ~ ~~ ...~ ..> ..~ Cl cr..., \-~ ""1f'r'\.. 0 rf... I . I ~l <$"\11.0 ~)n~ ..... ~:>QC'\l ,) -:: C") G> ,~ \n "'.... ~\t, - " .... ' .... ~-.... - .... .".... U U -.$' U ..,. .:> u .;:)~u ~ .~ ,.... E .,., ~_.- .,.~.- - "J: - 0 .- ::i N ~ - :..; .:: '" . - .... ~ .... " ." . .!!! C/) '^ C/) .!!! \\ C/) " " ;> '.. ... .- "" > p<, ,)':;, Cl Cl Cl \\ Cl > Cl ~ > ." }, '}.9 c: c: c: c: c: 00 " ~ 0 0 0 0 0 '" ~ ... .- ,- ,- ... .i .!J '" '" 0 C/) C/) C/) C/) C/) '" ~'> .!!! C/) .!!! C/) .!!! c.z: c ~ .- ... .9 e e e e e = C> <ii = ... "S e e e e e '" a. \\ 0 U a. 0 0 0 0 0 4i '> lJ lJ lJ lJ 0 0 c ._...",._, "-~-'.-....'-' .,.__..----,,-,.,,~ """"'-'" - _.~,-- .... t-- l"l ..., .... l"l .... M .... \Q l"l ~ ..., 0\ t-- ..., l"l r-:' ~ In + + I + I .e. .e. .e. .e. .e. ,- .- .- ,- ,- = = = =, = C" .C" C" C" C" r;.1 r;.1 r;.1 r;.1 r;.1 .. ... .. .. .. ~ ~ ~ ~ .. .. ._-. .- ,- ,- ,- -= -= -= -= -= '" '" '" '" '" -< -< -< -< -< Q Q Q Q Q ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... CI CI CI CI CI .. ... .. .. .. 8 8 8 .e 8 ... ... ... ... .. .. .. .. .. = = = = = .~ ,~ ,~ ,~ .~ "" "" "" "" "" -< -< -< -< -< ~ Q .... CI CI CI CI CI ~ Q Q Q Q Q ... .- .- ,- .- ..: ,- '" ... .::: ... ... ... ... ;0 .. .. .. .. "") .. - ll. - - Cl.l "S - .. = = = = ...J ~ ~ ~ .- ~ , ~ .2 Q ~' Q Q ~ Q :tll Q :a ~ Cl.l ~ ~ ~ ~ => 0 !';. 1::: 0) ~ .!! l'l .!!! ~ c:: 8 .. '- a c:: Cl .1\:1 v.i c Lt Q c:: :c: ~ " Cl.l .!!! '<= ;; 1\:1 II) :x: II) '0 c:: Cl.l Cl.l Cl.l ~ c:: e e e e 0 () ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 Q N ., I ~ I I ~ => '" ~ C") ~ c " - - - - - () U 0 0 0 0 E .- .- .... .- .... ,g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -0 .!!! .11) .!!! II) .!!! " C5 .- > Q Q Q Q '<= " -0 c:: c:: c:: c:: c:: ., () .() 0 () 0 !!! => '- - '- '- '- Cl II) II) II) II) II) ~ II) .!!! II) II) .!!! c 0 .- '.. .- m e e e e e '5 0. e e e e e 0 Q. () () 0 () 0 g 0 0 CJ CJ CJ 0 c .- N___'_ '--'-"-..-' ~~~.-' ,-,~-<..- --,'. ;:: ~ ~ ...: '" " III ..., .. ...J '" , .2 ...' ~ ~ :i3 ~ " CJ .!!! ~ ... ~ jl! .!!! ~ 0 .. (,) 0 Cl 111 cS CI) ." '- :c: :g l( 111 II) .!!! :3 ;;; '5 t: III III " t: E E E ~ 0 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 0 Cl N .. I . . . I " " ,... c-.. C") ~ 10 ." " - - - - - U CJ CJ CJ CJ CJ E '" .- .- '''' .- ,g .::: .::: .::: .::: .:= .!!! II) .!!! .!!! II) "0 " ... .- > Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl .." '" "0 t: t: t: t: t: " 0 0 0 0 0 .. l!' "C;l " '.. ... '.. ... .- i~ C> II) II) II) II) II) '" .!!! II) II) . .!!! II) ." ... ... ... .2 E E E E E = Q .. = ... "5 E E E E E Q 0. 0 U <l. 0 0 0 0 0 ;; (,) (,) (,) (,) (,) 0 " "._~ - ',--._- -,.,._-~-- _.,-- '-'.'-~---.'-"."_. , --'""-.---.----..-.-,-----.-- .... t-- ~ ..., ..... ~ .... M ~ .... ..., \C t-- ..., i r: a\ lI'i' + I + I .e. .Eo c .Eo .Eo ,_. .- '3 .- .- ::I ::I ::I ::I <:r et' et' et' et' f;;;l f;;;l f;;;l f;;;l f;;;l .. .. .. .. .. ii ii '" ii ii ... .- .- :a .- ,- .= "Q' "Q .= ~ '" '" '" '" < < < < < c., ." ., ., ., - - - - - - - - - - = = = = g .. .. .. .. a a g a a - - - - '" '" '" '" .. ::I ::I ::I ::I ::I ...., ,..., ,..., ,..., ...., '0 '0 '0 ." '0 < < < -< < ;:: = c:i = = = = ~ ., ., ., ., ., .,;. .- ~ ,- ,- ...: .- '" _. a: - - - ~ co co co co ~ co _. - - Q) - - ::I ::I ::I ::I ::I -' !:l. !:l. !:l. .- C. , !:l. .Q ., ...:- ., ., ~ ., .a ., :E r:o.. Q) r:o.. r:o.. ~ .... r:o.. " t) !S t:: 01 ca .!!! ~ ca ca c:: ~ 0 ;; 0 0 0 - ,- 0> ca c:: CJ) c .- c:i c:: <: il u: Q) ca :s ca III :r: III .. - '6 c:: Q) Q) Q) " c:: E E E E 00: 0 0 ~ ca 0 ca ~ 0 Q ~ a. N .. I I I I I " .. ~ C'\l CW) ~ It) " " .... .... .... .... .... u t) .t) t) t) t) E .- ;:: '- .- .- .g ~ .... ~ ~ ~ '0 .~ .~ III III III " .- ,- .- > Q Q Q Q Q 'C " '0 c:: c:: c:: c:: c:: .. " 0 .S! 0 0 0 5 '- .- .- '- 0> III III III III III ~ III III III III .~ c 0 .- '- '- .- 'ii E E E E E '5 0. E E E E E 0 "- 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 C ......N .....~..~-~-~..,",. . >-.". ...".._~" ..w_ ~ - o ~ <! NQI)OC")(")~ NaolOaoM~ ........O)C"')....N:g NC'\lao........t")~ ......aor--NCO>Q UOcn,....,C\lON UOC>>QI)OO.... U.....lOO",...C"')N UOCCM.....O..... U""N(,,)NCC~ -"tt":l~~~~o; _tC_~..._..,.~<<t.,; _N.""':.",,:ct!."":a.- ._"'!.M_~tt!.~d>i -<<).C"ttt).O..... :;,....(")0<0........ i....C"')occ....... iQl)MOlO......... ;aotf)CIO............ 5......(")oai.....-~ a.......('II S _N Q.........('II E:....."" ~-('I . . . . . i: ,:c % :E % ~. -~~ l~ ";]'1" ;"-IC""j '"'oW ;"t~' 1"",' jr....... ",T;i1';"c:-'~ ;'tl . ,j;! '.* NO)lONCO.... N<DO,...CC"'" OJlO....NtO..,. Ocn"NCO:! o)NCCt")~~ :NOC,....CO:a .lDNOlOlI)tQg :LI)N"l:f'NlO:g ".lOOLONtO'O "'.C'?OCCM g U,........N_C"{~.,; U..........."'!.N.<>>.on. U,.....,.N..N_~"'. U,......,.N."".O)_,,; U..........N..N. ...... III .... .......... ftII ............... lIlI ............. l'II ............. .. .............- = = = = = N N N N N AI AI Al AI AI g~8u:;~~ m~~t;f6~ ~M~~~~ ~~:!~~~ i(;~a;~~:; .......(oo)(")<o:f'....; ""'.....roClQM"It.,; "-MCCOlN..,.,,, ~C"')(Qo)N"I:t...... ...NCCaJN...."'!. .sN "":""':ai- .!c-i ....-.,.:0)-.... 1("; ""':"':Of-,!N .,.:...:ai-.lt'i "':""':oi~ o 5 5 5 5 ...~~~~~5 ...~~~~fES ...~~~~~S ...~~~~~~ ...~~~~~:ri GI lD CD CD lD - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;; ; i ; i g = iii ii iii iii iii ~ - - - - - ~ " = ,- . - - .! M.....OMN$ M.....OJ..,.N~ o)C':IC'\IC")(O$ ....N....MN$ '"ItO,....OCD~ ~ :sll U1,..,anN,........ IO,...MCW)r--.", CW)(J)"t'MCO", ll)(J)It)M.....", an(J)CO')MCO ..c Co::! CNM"ltP)......: c:C'Iol(")'"ItM........: CNM..M....._ CNM'"ItM......; CNM..,.M...."\ :>. 0; .!! .!! .!! .! .!! - 5 Oot - IG . co . IG _ Iaor 0( 0( 0( 0( 0( .~ ~ :;- .. . 0 _ _ b' 's ": .... Q = .;; <"I -5 ~ ::I .....J .!! o C ..... CO') T"" 10 M ,... c:.... C"') to Cl CO') <"I C en to ..... .... (0.... c: co lO to ..... M <"I C '"It an N N 0 <"I ,u ,Q" "5 QU lI:I..-anMo)'"It~ 1lI....."'NO"lt~ 1I:I.....ll)MQ)CW)~ ClI...."'Ncn..~ ClI....It)Mcn..~ ~:f ~ Q; :;.... T"" M :a..... ........M :a.... .... ('1'):0..... M;;......... M Sl-"", 100 ~= .5 .E .s .5 .5 5:...: w Q . . . . . ~ ..J "U E E E E E ,..';j a C( 0( C( c( tI( ~.~ u . U ;1)~M~~~ ~~l8!;:;~~ ~!9~~N; ~~C'Iol~~; ffl~~m~~ ~ JI'-",~..atC'4..M~": ~"'.""cx).N.cwt..... .)llCO.vCO......(")...: .)llUJ...~~.....p)...: Jl'-1.O."lt<<!,N.M...: ~ :;;- NNv- IQ..... NN"'t- g..... NN"- g..... NN"<t- g..- NN"<t- iZ m m ~ m m ~ i ~ ~~S;~~~ ~~~I;;~~ ;:I)~!;tl;;~~ ::g~ro~~ ~~u;~~~ ;=: .ot~~"'<t~""":...o .O!~"":.U).-r:..o .q"'.r-..N..""_.o .T""_IllN.C'Iol~",:..o .",.,....CX).ot",:'<I. '7 _..,.aoM"III,....t;:;j _.=....to"<t;::: _lOCO MIOM;:;: _Itl,.....,.",..,.;:; _<O<ON""ll);:; :. :2....,...,......(") :c.................,.M :2.......,...,......(") ~..,.v..,...,.(O') :2..,...,.......,.(0) ~ ~ ~ s: ~ ~ o n o .. ~~~M~~ !~::!~;;;::: ~~~;~~ fJ~:::;:~::: ::::!:~~:g::: ~; _<<!."":.~~......:: _ ~r--:.cotg."'t:- _....."III';,cotC'1.0h:J. _~"":.OCtrt~:: _1l't1O_1lt~"III::h a-a .CI)OO~OIl) ftlCDOCONOII) ClOOOOC'" l'lIOCbOOO.... ......GOOIO.....'" !3 _"'1010.10"" .......IO~IOIt)N _1010.01010"" _1O....It'lIOION -10..........1010" o~ o 0 0 0 0 U'':: .... I- I- .... I- tiU ~ 'g o~ u . - '" _NrJ.....1O .....('IIM...,.., _NM""'IO ....NM...,tn ....NrJ~tn 02 tit;uti'U oouuu UUUUU 1)u111)11 uouuu ii~ :5"S:S~:E :S:S"S:S:S bbE'E:E EEbbE :SEEE"!: .~~ .!! .!! .!! .!! ~ ~ .!! .!! ..!!! ..!!! .!!! ~ .!!! .!! .!! .!! .!! ~ .!! ..!!! ..!!! .!! ..!!! ~ .!! ..!!! .!! .!! ..!!! ! .~ = cecca.. cccco.. ceccc... ccccc... ceccc.. ~u 000(,)0 CJ(J(JCJCJ CJuoou uouuu oooou o:i ooouo OCJuuu uuuuu uuuuu ouoou u~ .a:lmmmm cammcam tDallllimm almcaCDaJ mmma:&m ~::I . '" = ~ u . 'II " " "G "a ~~ &: It.... GtN Glcwt .... at.., :;Gri '3 :. ~.. ~. :- :_ ~::i.g CLD,. .Q,L a.L "'a.. D.L II ij "" ecc fee fee oee occ u~ Do CI.:E CL:E a.::E a. 2: is.:E ~ ~ ~ _.~~O ...._. _"'~<._ ~_.~__..~___^. .., ..,,___ ..._____._~.____ , "". ~vr _t>J .~" - ,- ~ MEMORANDUM TO: Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant Boar?~of, County C?:m~:~~. ' '-~~_ t;. .~. FROM: Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney DATE: December 18,2001 RE: Approved Minutes of the October 25, 2001 Meeting of the Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Please find attached the approved minutes of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board meeting of October 25,2001. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. IUvl/kn attachment cc: David C. Weigel, County Attorney ~-----------------~,-------- ,--~ ~,,,-,, - msp ANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES OF MEETING /' of October 25, 2001 " PRESENT: ABSENT: David Correa, HAAB Member Robert Pina Pete Cade, HAAB Member Frank Loney, HAAB Member Sofia Pagan, HAAB Member Susan Calkins, HAAB Member Carlos Aviles Ramiro Maiialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison Also Present: Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones News Timothy Durham, Office of the County Attorney David Weeks, Collier County Planning Services Liza McClenaghan Michael Kirk, Collier County Public Schools, Chuck Mohlke Frank Rodriguez, Que Pasa Southwest Florida TV John Norman, Representative Ralph Arza's office The October 25, 2001 meeting of the Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) took place at the Collier County Co=ission meeting room and began at approximately 7:03 P.M. A quorum of six (6)) members was present. APPROVAL OF SEPTEMBER 29,2001 MINUTES David Correa noted a correction that was needed on the draft minutes of September, 2001. Specifically, on page 4, he noted that a reference to the "Immokaiee Bank" should be changed to "Bank of America." There is also a correction to the spelling of the last name of Commissioner Coletta. A motion wa, made to approve the minutes, as corrected, by Frank Loney. Carlos Aviles seconded the motion. The vote was 6 to 0 in favor of the motion. ,.'-'''-....---.-----.-...- ...,,_..". '^"~' - ._, EXCUSED ABSENCE Ramiro Mafialich informed the Board that Mr. Pina had called several days before and advised that he would be unable to attend the HAAB Meeting as he ,...., eslHl. gaUss to ",,,,,<I- <l,.. ""'-+- ll1;hc/-o.r7~ ~~qQC: in ~arolina Carlos Aviles made a motion to excuse the absence and Frank Loney se.foatle the motion. A unanimous vote (6 to 0) occurred in favor of the motion. REDISTRICTING PRESENTATION David Weeks from the Collier County Planning staff explained the reasons for redistricting of the Commission boundaries. The basic reason was that there had been population changes throughout the County. He explained that five maps had been prepared (the maps are attached to these minutes) as well as a report (attached) and a spreadsheet regarding population figures (also attached). He said that the basic redistricting criteria approved by the County Commission were to maintain incumbency, compact and contiguous districts, equal population districts, and seeking to have the same boundaries as the school district. He also said that additional legal criteria included: avoiding retrogression of minority votes (especially in District 5); and avoiding division of neighborhoods. He mentioned that other criteria that were followed are included in the report. He also stated that retrogression analysis indicated that there was actually an increase in minority populations in the districts. Mr. Weeks explained the redistricting methodology based on census tracts and where Commissioners live. He mentioned that Collier County is a "covered jurisdiction" and that it must submit maps' for "pre- clearance" by the U.S. Justice Department. He explained that the report that has been prepared has standout features and critiques of each map. There is also a description of each district in the package. Mr. Weeks commented about the differences between thc maps. With regard to Maps #1 and #2, he said that the only significant difference was in the area of Davis Boulevard. District I has not changed in those maps. Map #3 has a significant feature in that District 1 goes farther east. Maps #4 and #5 have different boundaries in North Naples. There are very few "jogs" on Map #5. Mr. Weeks also mentioned some significant changes in the maps regarding the so-called Manatee Road Triangle. Mr. Weeks recapped prior public meeting presentations regarding redistricting. He mentioned that there had been meetings with the League of Women Voters, the Black Affairs Advisory Board, and the School Board. He said the School Board wanted to follow the County lead in this matter and also wanted to wait for public comment. The School Board expressed reservations about Map #3 regarding Everglades City not being in District 5. There were also three community meetings. Weeks said that the turnout varied, but generally the numbers were small. He mentioned that notices of these meetings were provided as described. The notices were in English, Spanish and Creole. The BCC meeting is November 13,2001 for consideration and approval of the maps by the County Commission. The staff group would also be back before the School Board and in Immokalee. He said that residents of Irnmokalee felt that there was a need for another meeting due to lack of sufficient prior notice for the previous meeting. 2 ..-.,~.._---" --,-.....,..,,--..,.. .~..,.""-, -~..~,- ....-~.^ ."._._,...~--~,_.- -- "^'" ,,- David Correa mentioned that he felt that there was a lack of ample notice for tonight's meeting. He said that it would have been better if there had been earlier notice. He would have preferred a summary of the large amount of information. Liaison Ramiro Ma.iialich expressed regrets about not getting information to the HAAB earlier, but he explained that all of the staff had been very busy and that the information had been coming together recently. He suggested that the Hispanic Board could consider having another meeting betore the November 13lh County Commission Meeting. David Weeks mentioned that more information about the redistricting process was available on the County Website. Frank Loney asked about the Hispanic population figures in the districts and David Weeks explained the numbers of the spreadsheet. Mr. Weeks emphasized that County Sraff was seeking comments, criticisms and suggestions regarding all of the redistricting process. David Correa asked if any comments would be conveyed to the County Commission. Mr. Weeks explained that the comments would be presented to the Board of County Commissioners; However, staff will not change the maps without County Commission direction. Tim Durham from the County Attorney's Office explained that there had been lots of information received. He emphasized that there had been significant concerns expressed regarding Map #3 as well as regarding the North Naples communities on Map #3 and Map #5 not being similar to the rest of District 5. David Correa agreed that there should be concern over these North Naples communities being in District 5 because they are not similar in terms of income and in other ways. Frank Loney echoed those same concerns and he thought that including the North Naples gated communities in District 5 would impede minorities running for office in that district. David Correa asked Chuck MoWke, Democratic Party Chairman, to comment about the redistricting information. Mr. Mohlke stated that he had been monitoring the redistricting process and that he had previously commented regarding congressional redistricting as Chair of the Collier County Democratic Party. He said that the County Staff had made a good presentation. He stated that he has concerns concerning the North Naples' gated communities being included in District 5. He provided demographics intormation and mentioned that Commissioners Matthews and Berry had been elected from those North Naples' communities. He compared information of other representative areas in the Immokalee region in District 5. He also spoke of "age demographics" in Immokalee. He said that the last Census it was indicated that the median age in Immokalee was far younger (22.5 years of age) than in the North Naples' gated communities. In those communities, the median age is 55. He also mentioned that those under 18 years of age cannot register to vote. He said that the registered voters are 39% of District 5'8 population whereas in District 2 it is 66% of the population that are registered to vote. He mentioned that obviously age was a major consideration. He stated that the North Naples' communities had a higher number of registered voters and that they do not have much in common with Immokalee or the rest of District 5. David Correa asked ML MoWke about having just lmmokalee as a Commission District. Mr. MoWke responded that the districts all have to have the same approximate population. A variance of up to five percent is allowed. The present maps have one to two percent variations and they are good maps, but there are the concerns that he expressed previously. 3 -'-".~~--~---""'-~"-'--'-- --------".~,"_.,-'>~ - ,.'... .,,_.'-'~"" ._---~-.-"-,,~--~""~-- .-.. David Correa asked Mr. Mohlke if there could be one "minority" district? Mr. Mohlke explained that it was very hard to do that in the large Collier County area and not violate the compact and contiguous redistricting standards. He said there was no legal basis for line drawing with an exclusive focus on race and ethnicity. David Correa clarified that he was not saying that he wanted to have only minority elected officials, but he did want the Commission Districts to be drawn in such a way as to allow for that potential. Mr. Mohlke emphasized that minorities have a smaller percentage of registered voting age population. He believes that they should not be disadvantaged by mixing the minority population with other populations that have an older age and more voters. He said that Frank Rodriguez would also address this topic. David Correa stated that he would like for Mike Carr, Chairman of the Collier County Republican Party, to share his comments with the HAAB on this topic. Mr. Mohlke presented a spreadsheet (attached) regarding the total registered voters per district and a breakdown by ethnicity and race. The figures presented related to population percentages and minority groups and numbers of registered voters and the percentages of total population made up of registered voters in the Commission Districts. He emphasized again that District 5 has a younger than average population and many of them under voting age. There are also"a number of voting age adults who are not naturalized U.S. citizens. He felt that there would be a disproportionate impact to include the North Naples' gated communities in District 5. He repeated that this had been exhibited by the results in the 1992 and 1996 commission elections. Tim Durham emphasized that staff is inviting comments and contact by the public before the November 13th County Commission redistricting decision. MiciUtel Kirk, representing the Collier County Public Schools, stated that he had been working with County staff on the redistricting effort and that the School Board Policy is to seek to have the same school distrid houndaries as the boundaries for the County Commission District. Frank Rodriguez introduced himself as President of Vision Inc. which features Hispanic TV programming. He said that he is familiar with the census information and seeks to have more Hispanic representation in government. He mentioned that there had been a dramatic increase in the Hispanic population in Collier County. Many are not U.S. citizens and cannot vote even though they contribute to the community. He mentioned that in reviewing the maps he had a "Catch 22" concern over the lack of concentration of Hispanic voters. He thought that overall there had heen a dilution of votes of Hispanics even though it was not the fault of anyone in particular. When there is such a dilution there is a loss of ability to influence candidates. He said that he had been involved in voter registration efforts for Hispanics and that the HAAB and the County Commission need to keep an eye on the concentration of Hispanics in the districts. He observed that the Hispanic population tends to be much younger and that he thought there was a need to get representatives of the Republican Party involved in this process. Sofia Pagan then had some discussion with Mr. Rodriguez about the Hispanic media in town and how the community can best be reachcd. Frank Loney said that he was happy to see the new redistricting information from staff, but that he wished he had more time to interpret the data. A discussion occurred about the logistics of having another meeting versus taking 4 ._._n_________.___. "W_..~...._ . '"...__.,~._,._...._._--~_.~ ._---~-- -- .~"" formal action on this matter !bis evening. There was also a discussion about potential motions that could be made on this subject. Frank: Rodriguez observed that there was a concentration of Hispanic voters in District 3. Chuck Mohlke suggested that three maps (1, 2 and 4) show District 5 to the East of County Road 951. Frank Loney repeated that he was concerned about the lack of early information. A discussion ensued about the different maps. Susan Calkins made a motion expressing a preference for Maps # I and #2 on the basis that the HAAB does not want the minority vote diluted. A motion also included a policy statement that District 5 should not go West of Collier Boulevard (County Road 951). The motion was seconded by Carlos Aviles. A 6 - 0 vote in tavor of the motion occurred. The HAAB members thanked County Staff and Mr. Kirk for the presentation. IMMOKALEE CHECK CASHING Mr. John Norman explained that he had to get off to another meeting, but that he wanted to bave the Hispanic Board consider a potential solution to the check caShing fees problems for Hispanics in Immokalee. He suggested that perhaps the HAAB could persuade a business to cash checks for no charge if minimmn purchase occurs. RESIGNATION OF MEMBER EUGENE GREENER Liaison Ramiro Matialich passed out three docmnents relating to Mr. Greener's resignation. First, Mr. Greener's October 17, 2001 resignation letter. Liaison also distributed Mr. Greener's September 28, 2001 letter complaining about lack of notice and information of the meetings and a copy of Legal Assistant Kay Nell's Memorandmn in response to Mr. Greener's complaints about lack of notice and information. Chairman Correa stated that it has been his experience that Kay Nell has always provided fine notice for the meetings. FARMWORKERS' EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Liaison Ramiro Matialich passed out a draft of the Executive Summary regarding the HAAB's decision to ask the County Commission to request dialogue between growers and farm workers in the Irnmokalee community. The Board members indicated that the Executive Summary should be presented to the County Commissioners as submitted by the Liaison. MR VALDES' REOUEST FOR AN AGENDA ITEM Mr. Victor Valdes, Editor of Las Naciones News, requested time on the Board's next agenda for a variety of information regarding the activities of the Police Review Board which has been recently tormed. The Chairman agreed to his request. 2002 ADVISORY BOARD REPORT The 2002 HAAB Report to the County Conunission was deferred to a later agenda 5 -- ~-". .>-.-,--..__.._, - ,,----- _.- -'-'. - LATIN FESTIVAL. VOTER REGISTRATION David Correa reported that there had been an effort to register Hispanic voters at the Latin Music FestivaL He said that approximately 60-70 voters registered and more than 100 applications were passed out. He said he was assisted in this matter by Mr. Pina and the Elections Office, HARVEST FOR HUMANITY {\oa<lj Carlos Aviles asked for Mr. ~ to be placed on the agenda for November to discuss the Harvest for Humanity in the lmmokalee Hispanic Community. Mr. Aviles said be would contact Mr. Nojay to attend. . no~ FRANK RODRIGUE SPANIC BUSINESS Frank Rodriguez asked the HAAS for its support regarding a factory in Collier County that has a Code Enforcement Board hearing pending. He said that this filctory has many Hispanic employees. He said that the factory obtained approvals from the County for a new building off Airport Road. Neighbors complained and these approvals Were withdrawn. He said he wants the Board of County Commissioners to support the original approval. He said that this business may have to move to Lee County and Hispanics cannot travel there and then will lose their jobs. He is asking the Hispanic Board to address a private business that has a major impact in the Hispanic Community (200 Hispanic families). Frank Loney asked what was the name of the company and when would it be before the Board of County Commissioners. Mr. Rodriguez stated that he did not know when the agenda items was coming before the County Commission and that the name of the business was called Gulf Coast American Blinds. He said that the business owners name is Carlos Diaz. Liaison Ramiro MafiaJich stated that he would make no comments because he was aware that this item was being reviewed by the County Attorney's office. However, he stated that he thought this item was going before the County Commission at the second meeting of November. A discussion was held regarding options for action. future meetings or individual comments before the County Commission. David Correa mentioned that he was inclined to try to help in this situation, but he was not sure if the business had broken any rules. However, he recognized that sometimes Code Enforcement can abuse their powers. David Correa suggested having a special meeting with all parties involved. Liaison Ramiro Maiialich reviewed the HAAB' s role under its ordinance. Mr. Valdes stated that this situation could be assisted by the HAAB. He said that he has had success before on these types of issues. Frank Rodriguez stated that he was merely asking the HAAS for support of the original approval and not for a judgment on the Code Enforcement Case. The HAAB decision was to set a special meeting prior to the County Commission meeting with regard to this Hispanic business. They would invite representatives of all parties concerned with the matter. 6 -_.~--~-~ - " -.- ~--.~- _.__.,-_._-~----,-~---,...,- .. --.. The meeting of the HAAS adjourned at approximately 9:25 p.m. Prepared by: Ramiro Maiialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison -J-i )Cl// ('\1 " Approved by the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board on this~_ day of I, . j "/LMoJ , 2001. .,. . ( G~ . ,^,~1.' ~j l: &. i)t.."-' ct ' L ~:~i '-\..t" David Correa. Chairman 7 "_._______,______.~.___M~____.____._._.___ ~""'., -- RilSE J RiUii& I 112710 112!8E . MAP #1 .. . r. i ,. .. i.. . I.... .. ~ COMMtSSIOI\I DISTRICT lINES- -- : -- .. .. . i'" . .. \ .. .. .. BOARD Of' CDUNTY CDMlIlSSIOJIeRS ..... ...._.. -.. _ _~__ \ COWER COUNTY. FLORIDA I I' I - . \.J . .. . " '" I . -.. , \\t}J' ,'_..../ -,+~- - ~--I-:I ~I ' ' 'I ',1/ I\, LEE C/l\IlllY ., ...... ...... " i . IJ. . lL_I. '~I"f: .:.. -'.. - --1-- .. -- ""J-' I . . . . ... I . L -t-I I . I '. . I. . ". ... ." -,. I" = ~ ~ ~ I;::>>~ - - l -.. -- i--~'---- -.. -.. , .. 1'<'.. c:.. ..... .','.. .. . . [. [ ..1_. .... ... i _ --.. ...._ . ~ ~_I -.. -.. '1'01\ 'li' . .. I' , ..~" . .. ..... 'l; "i' .. --, _.. -.. -', ..- ... -. . . .. ~- 1_. - -- -T -,-----,--- . ""'......, .: .' .. j. . . . _.. ... _.. .'" -. .... --' . i . ..::... . .':' -- . . I,... . I '~ ." ... ... -,1--1-" -.. -.... -. -:1.:-' \ __ __f ~__ i.. __ __ ~ - M" I - __t : '," .. -"-- -.-'" , .. - ~:':_-:'''. . ~ ~:.. ..,' -.. ,,"0'" -~ ,."-i' .. .. .. I . "I "- -- - C;C -, ji ,-r -- ..-1 - )/.. tAli; ...." I I -------J,-~ --5- _~__ ,I . ~ ~ .. ..~.. .. . _.. " i -- ../ " . -- w..... "'I' . r. ~ I ~ ~ " ~'I -. -.. ~ I -~ .. , - 1-- ----.1 . .. , - --.. ~ I I ~ . . lIs" " ~ ~ I - I. " . .... _'" -- '--.,. - --.. ' . .. -..... . -, ~ II~., r - -, eH" ...:-1 -..... , . , .' -j~l4f _. .- 1-- - 1'''1'' .,. .... - -- -'" -... . .' ! """"'~ v _______ . --- ,- ~_.- .-j- ---- .. , . /'-.... I" . '1'- '" . . i. .~~- ~ ~ co ~ -/( j 1" --,-1-:- -: -:-.- ,.1---:---.:- -:-1-.:. . - =. = '" ~-:"'I-'" ~'-:... '--., ,L'll I ,. I. ~ ."'1 . -.... ~... . .. :;;. fJ. j .. ~ .. ..~ - ,., ..:-rl-~--:-'-:- .. #" 1-1- / i 1_: 1/- .~ ''\;-:-1'. -:'-!-'" .--~ I.E'" . ...~- "', -.. .-----=c-:-- --e--\----r---- -- -~.-I_.~-----.-. '" -..... "-.. ....... :::::: .. . ' .. ".-.,. . ", . . --i'- (<:) ~:,.' --~. - -1:'S, .il-.~.1... - .~I... _' " _=... ":'; _.." .. ..... .,.. H),\' . *. " 'J' . +,-- -- c'. ,d .- ~. ---N-' '" J.' .,.. '" ...- ..- ....... -.. -... ('J ~ 'c.,,"", . '. . j I -~ - . 0 ., -- . i-- ~___ __ _" .. ..... '" -- -- -.. ." -.. in -. 3,,13, /6 - .;.. . ---- - .. // ..... ~ 01~- ---j _~l '.' 'f- i~~~- ------ . ..."" ..... .... -.. -- -.. --.- "L.....,~""!'l ._- I' ~ "'- .. llO.. ... .. -... -" ..... .. J I ' ,,' "\ - - ..... ... ....- , ,(~ .'( '((- .. '" I .1'll..~. -- ~- 1--' ~;:/ -- \.J - - '- :- + . fI~- ~~ . ~:'f--:"-'" .... . - .. I 1---1., 1\ .,.v_?',' ,4:,.-.1'<......,.. ,,' \ ....- I. /, - 'v \. -- -j-- -- - - - -- - --- . (.Vi~< :'~~I .,.,/\j !C.'.... . 'J . I. "'-",. .. 'j .. .. ~ ,.{ ..,,-' __ __,___ i-------"-~__- _.~ .m . ~ ~~~ ..~...~'~~I~-. ff' - ,. .. . . . . ',: .. . + "'.. -"\" ~ "" ~. ----- '. ,/.. ,. . III . \ . ,,- Jlri 1- /.L. F- t- w e ,~ '. ,~ '. _ 'Ii' - ~(I-., llr" J" f,x. :.,.( ~ .. .. , ~-;;{:~.'frYI~ ~~ \.--- I I ,.-' '0 SCALE -r--l - m_l~___ -'t:.:~:.L.7--- . . - . J.. ____. __~ \.--,,-~_-4 . a. 2t;O ..... .'" .....l:.!!!!'!~ _ PROPOSED OISTRICTUNE ....JlUe. ,..._..... I - DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPUlAnc:w .f ii! ..JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D --1'--~ ----~--- ~ - TOM HENNING -~----.-- 50.759- 4 . PAMELA 5. MAC'KIE :_=_.!.~=_~~_ 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. _.~'L-,___~731_ _ ....'..n.'..........H...11IOCTt'... ~____.._~~!._ ""..""flJ."'QI.,.,.,.,s'"""II'O*llC.\l..,...OIITSE'nON __ __ lWm ~1,377 i~~;..;.,Q"::"'-~t:EtO;,:.~tlIS~=~:: r:..~~~=-"... -------.------.-..- -~,--,----,,-,'-'_._-_._---'--'~----_." --.------- -- MOl'. J II a.. e I RUIi II 2. Ii . MAP #2 -;- 1 : COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES ~~I~ . ": :: "\ ::~ BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS -------+--- '.-nl - -" -.. -.. ~_ .__ _._ CDWM COUNTY. ,.LORlDA . i ". ,: w. - -. I. . \ ..1 . I ~.. -. "... \ - ~ -I' "T-"-'~- I --,- f- \'~ ~., d :I l .. I, " .. i \"~ 'l ~,7 ~ \EIiCIlUNt'f" .. -.. -'" ! t'!' ,i . '.-:- ,... _.. _.. . ',' ,III 'I' 11' l +. G - .. --".,. '. -- "''''' ---J " ... , "'"-~~I-"~'-I . --- 1.1 . ." . t +: . . '.. ., ". - ' . . . . . 1 . .- --; i" . ". s I ..' -.. ...,,, = -' - - - --- --- -, ~-r-- I I - I I . ,,>DO,' ::,_-:::: ! I. ", .I~-l' -- -~" I' .... _.'-"1 ", I" " j,(;.! 1 I \! I '" '" 1 ~-'- . _~.:w: . -., ..-" !_~.~ --=-'-~I-:~-:'~ ~." -"I...,.. ":'"" -~ -'''!-'-h "f1I" -j I .1" I" '," . " ," _." I. . - "I' -.. -" -"1-. -" -- ."'. _LI +-j ---' -. .--.. " ,J' - -' '---I 1 . . ,/,. . ,I, h 1_, _. ... r::T.,. -- -" -.. .. -- -- .:~, , f-- _1 "e-'j--'! 1'0 1-' -', ' . .. '_' . ..~ -.. . -:~..... I"" 1-' -, "." .." "..1 -. -: ... a.. --:----:-- ~ : t'" ~ . '..-., -1-_... -- -"." ':1 - ".. _"1" +" . " -..-- . I - - r -- -- ,," " " . 1'"'''''' ";--1"""'" ~I --I- . -" "b~'l---.I , - -'--f-' "- -,'- - --j - L " " " . <;j I> .I ~ J ,,". . ... t7"~, -. I .~. -'I j '- -- ! . \," -- ~ on _ ~ ~. R . r-:". -.. ...... _. I [:: 1 '''' ".. , , ~ . I" =' I . ., '''. I" " '" -: -.-. ....." '::8:: __" .." - ... .... 1'=1.. r: 1,.1 . "' ~ ,.- _ 1_ _J Ij '. .,. "::' ".." ..... -... . ~_!S . . I - --- - ~-- 1-- ---I ~_ I " . "I. . . .,. I '.". -- - ,---- -- . ~~'~H"~"~'"'' 11,,,-,, I-t .j-~ -. -1--""" '" -- ~ -- ".:,~ DO' '1' "I" . . " . . I", ' ..- f..- f---- . L ! J '. "--- -- "t:: . I'.'. '" -- . -. .... " .." --~ U ,,"'-- I- . !! ,," " " . " " _ ' . ,,' $'1j" ~It,. ~_L ~, -"--I" L~~" -,. '" __I, .. -'. " ~"'.. "/\" ", "I' "I' .:" .1---1------; \. . ",I . - . _... _.. - -~- ~ --- - __L_ "- ----1 -- -. ''', -'-- '>> ~ . I ~" ~ I ---- ~ '."....,. - . - , -. . '" \, . - "-- --, -1---1-- 1---- -..,1 -..' "~"- -,.1 p, :c'!" . . . ". '1" ", . - c-' ~ '. ,'" ,.. ~ I'---..: . /' 0'''' - -.. ..... -- -,. -... c;' - "~~ . ,- - -" '--:-..~-~---- I ,,, o " 't, 'e_" :t " ..... '" -- -.. _'a ... -,. . ~, 0" ---- -...1---__ ____ ii '" ~ ."r ...., '. ~~ ..., -" . ~~ _I mm~~ __ " ...:., -" '" -. ..- ..,,,. -" -- ~"~ Cl; I I r"~ ... . ." " "I...".... . .. =:::._ '.. .._.. '-- i. . _'U -= _,.. -- -.. -... ~ ~\}, ,');,- ,'[. .. '"' -~1 ~ 1--- ""'~:. ....... :-.. ",. " . .,~'~' aWi"'~?'; ~ \7 . "=..-:: " i:'\...: " .. .. " , /fi;,; .1{; _,CY 1.{ ,f. 'ib~ " [. "'>--, .. r!Z " .~~~;' '-:- -:-\" . . . . . "1'-." : + ~~\. .\......... .,':;. .,,~ - :-;:.'-:; :- .. ,. " .. -- . _. H I- W Ii: .\" ~~ " . 1~;: I ".M{ '~~", ' ~,/~:) 7. . ~ :,! - ~~l[ ~ ~-~..3>~_ ~;;::::..'-d' ~ :i ...=iJ_ r . <'I - . '.. l~' ..., ... a. $ _"!,~NJ;I_ _ PROPOSEDDlSmlCTllNE .'u.., "".......... ---..- f DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATION ii! JANeS D. CARTER Ph.D ---t ~840 :3 - TOM HENNING ~ 50,758 4 - PAMI'lLA S. MACKIE -3-----~~.313 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA. Jr'. .. ~- --034 _ ,.....".",....,....".""'..,,... .:.5--='- ,.._.1 .Rt....U1~"'all_C!""IIr(CHNICAl.SU'POIl''it<::OON IUm 251,3n C.-UNIT'< DfInOf'Ul"' ,,"0 OfWKJ.....",.... 'il./roIlcn PM_ __~_...____~__.__ .~ '.~"f:llKl1 ,'-LOOW-...,-"....-H>WCf"'-O',NJ1OCAOP.... ,.........,..._._"._._--~~ _.,-,-_.. -_._- ,>.'.... R;iS. I ,lIZlIilil I R27E Ri!8E . MAP #3 -:TTT~l~ .!. " . "I. "' ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES --+-E' +-+ , -- .... BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS .~"L~. ., . . M .. -.. -1."") " ~ .. CDLUER COUNTY. FLORIDA , 'I" " . 'I"' .. ~, ~ I. . I " .'. -.. I ---- -' -- -, -- '~"I--,-' -....j--.---!--I \\ ~., ,\ .:/ . , . I . I . I. ..' -- ." I '1 . , \' i l ^ ~7 lft eoU~TY ___~- .-- t---- M -. . --L-...-__ . i ~-1ll' . -- I .:. fJ ~ I.~ !. I~-'" ..:. :: -- -- .". -.. _.:l_=--I_~~~ . ~~.. .. i .; I. ",.11 ~--I' -" -.. .. . .... -"Il. . I .. I . ~~ = --2---:::J 1.L---- -'1 -- - .- I : . "~ " . ..... " I " ".." I " -"I --. ' ... -. -.. . "1- I ~ .. ...- .._I _:.l .... "~ .," -=--" 10' ...~.-1- -- -" -" -.- -. -. .,. . .L~J .'. "-. I ' I " "I" "_ ')' . -.. ... D " ~ - . I . i -"l""~_ ~" -'" -.. -=," =---- r-~--I .". . . . ':'_, .... ." ... _.. _. _.. _,,1- _" __ __ \ --1'.. I .1"' , , , .-:-:1-.-':: --:-'1';;;;0-: ."1,,,:1-, ...1-- n - '::-_1_._1-__+__ - :r" ..,,, ....'.. -.. I .. 'I -- .. -\ f'" : "~... -- .. - '::'1-'. .,. . ~ - - ~ e---1 : : _ __ _ _ ~: """. ~ ~= ___ . . ." ...... ",'M __" ~ ~ I .' ,.. -, I'" "- " I " I -I 1 f.--j f 1 !"""" I " I n ~ .. -.. -'" "~ I <;] ~I.;.-=-- -::- ....._.I/"~. -. -:-i- --t-5T I I I u.,,,,,:,, - - .~- ,," .. :. . ~ . ":,'! ........... r::: ".. I " . ::.;;0;- ~"- i'" . -. " . .. '-~ "I !".;Q' h. -" ., '. . . .. " "- ,.. -. -- I -,., on\-,i~I... ~- I. 'l-ti \" .- ".." :"" - -. .- I .1-.., - . 1-""-' .'- .."" -." . . , ' ,.. .:. I - .-1-: . - -. 1,__ -- -_. -- . . \ -.~.I -, - __ ' '+-i---L __ - - __ -..::: .,," . -." -- _____jl go' 'I,L~" I'" " ." . I I, . ...1-- --f- L. 'I .. "-- . ---- t - ."" " -." -.-, :-J . -" -1-- ~~ . "i-' I . J. .'. " .'" --. c..' .~ .. y ~ I - -r' _C__ ~ . : .:._ ..- ::: .'. ____1-=_.:1 . IU' . .1\,I~'" " , i -- - - I --1-- "~ ~ . ~ , . I ~ . ~ - - - - -'. - _.""_ -- "I -- .J..-.. _m -." ~ ~ ". . . . ".; .."." " .- -: . '" \~';~ " -I_~ J [______1: ... ~.l -.. . I . -" -.. R ,>. .c!i~" ..... I I f-t_ -- !-~ ~. -'( ~# -- . u ::....... ...:.. ~ _ _1_ . .... "" '.".. -- -." -- -... ~,v:.., ?'~... 1/1 0 ~~ - '1-1 - __ .__~-- ~~~ ":; ..."..-."-:-==-... . Q~ \'.cv;. . ... , . I . \ ~ .... ..~ rt---~___r___ ----1- -- - -lIIlIr.:- ~l-~ . ....... ':; -,.,. ........ ....'" ....... -- ~~~l~"" "1_ "f" ":'ll~. 1\ ,1 ,~. __ -... -,.. -... . ~ "t .." L. . .- .... f-- .n - .". ,I J1{'(- ".1..< "," '_ . .. ~..... -. _m _.. " "I . - " .. I --l-- - -.,,::t.:". -- ---,- . : 01\1~) ~"'1'l '1'1\':-";;-"'J)' f . p",: " ........ . .. " " .. " , . "LC;;l/l~ _ _ -- .. r--\---........j v/" ',J /' '{-i1 ,.." - - 4' ~~f~! -":"'--~1- - i-..,;" ~." '--:_~ [ ~ , 'f.-.W~ ~l' . - .. .J7/," '"1-.' . " ,',,~ Ii\..'..',,~'r' '-. -:c.\ ----- . - - . + \'" .....<"'" -\. ~- I. "... . . : w,; - \ ~__ .r J~" /L __ _~__ ~n /1' . w~.~~:" " i+"? ~J') ~ .' - .,~ .. : . ,;\1 ~ - e., _. ":,, _ .." _ ~: \lli,'I' , 'j :"1 , G:' _'='.. Hr' __, . ~ >----~'" ;:- ~___ ~~"~~ v -~ . j- '-'--. ----C; ~ ~ s 1.1l1iEN1l.... ---------i _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE .- Ulft1lo:T ....__,.... __._._~_ I DONNA f=IAI.A DISTRICT POPULATION 2 JA.MES D. CARTER Ph. D ,145 :3 - TOM HENNING 2 50,473 4 - PAMEI.A S. MAC'KIE ----3--- -56:315-- 5 - JAMES N. COl.ETTA. Jr. ___!_-=--__.~.M.!== _ ................."."""....:r".. ___~__.___~_~~_ .lIU'....IO."'''''...'''''''OH/1ltC>lNlC...''''f'POII,S!CflOf< ___~_...~ a~ ___ 251,~11 ~~~r.'':>Ur.':~~~J~"a: ~S~'~.~.. -- - -----_..._._--------_..-----~._---~..._~---_..._---~-,,--_._-----. ..-..--..---............---......-----.-------- ------- ,-- .- R as II I II 0!5 II! I II ~7 II! .... MAP #4 r.=rr- -- .-.- ~. -- - . . ~ I " - .. .. . COMMISSION DISTRICT UNES .- .._-- - . " . . . \ . . BOARD Of' COUNTY COUMI5 SIGNeRS ___ COWER COUNTY. FLDJllDA it I" ~ - -- - \./ '. - ,. I - .". -" -0 ... .. .. -_.. -- - -;-I----c.. -_ - -I---- '\<j .' , j . .1. i ..1 I, ~'I ~ lSii r:cuJm' .. _.._~ ~ T. ' i - . . _ _.._.. ., - III. . . I . I, . .. I ., , ". -, -.. . . I ~ ' ff" " ..O~. -. .,------ -.. - 1--- . J -- .,' -f-.".-F" .. I .. I . I .. :.J -. - . ,. . '. .' -. _M _... ~ ',-. -: - .-,1- -i-[T - , " '.;' ,..,... I. .. .. ':-L . .. -. ."'.. - .'0 ... -." .. I' .. - - .. -- -:-t- - i - .. t- .... '1' I; l" .. Ei.'" _n. _: ... -. ''- .. -+-:- -:-; -. : 1----- -- jr- --- . ..+-.- \ . , .., .. ' .. . I' .. ."11." -" -.. -. _0 ..., I '. I . -:.... -' r---i"; , ... ,I:" .. I~' -. ..., -:.1:'" ,-.. .'''1-'' .... -,." -. -.. - ,_ -I ___ - __ +. j.- ~._- _._-- 1_, , I, "." .. ,I. -' . .-' -' ... ... -'j.'" ..01-.0' ...-. : .."~ -.. '-. -.' -'::~:r..+".. 1- j- -- ~---~ - . t; ~ J ,..., _.. . . .. . ..,,-- " ; -. ~~-:-I . i -. i "" ., c- ---: FT-'-;'. L ..-- --=-,.:. .:- , ~ I . ~ - ,,~... -.. , E-.!....,"---'c--- ---,--' '-'-. 4' . -I,; . . _...,l/.~~, -. . .. . _" -----1 c;j - -... .. "....r. I. .. .1 ... .... ~ I I < ~ _.,-- .... ---j--- --1- .. .-:1.. .. ~ "I'~I' I~ :~.. '~ . . .. '.L... "'''_'' -r-- <...." ---1'::8: I... _.... '_. ..... co" I ~I ,. , ' I . i"'~ I. I 1 . -'.. -- -'" .... . i ~_[S _ -~ I - I - - ~ , ., I..:... "J-'u';~'" '. I ~ . - - !-. .1 a 0 . l ./ L' . I. -.i:' . ,,' ... I - - ~-- III '\ -'. ~ . . ~ _,_ ~ '---., "-'ii' - I' .... - '. -- - .. - . -- "L-"...----=". -.. . ~( t ~ "--J-" .. '. 1--' -~ I- . 1 c_ . - -- -t- ....: . ~.:- -" '" -." -' ..:_ -". .. , . If I . ~ .. I.. . I 0 I -1.- r- -I , i_ _, ___ - ._:+. .._______ :_."."1 -"," . -,. -,.1 i:::: ~i" I. . . ~ I . .. . .. " Y--f-+- .~ ro J ,~- .- -_. - ... .'r' 1-'." . -"-" N " 9 d' . ' r>--. .- m_, -: ~' , '-,' -- .' ~' ~ ~'-:--: 1_ .' ,.-.-- .'''i ,,-,... -'" -+... -.: o ~_i:':-:. Ll I --".--1 . -,.1" -.. -i:.. -.. -~ ~ \ 3;: !,,!~ "I '- ---.. --t- -. , : ~I .~' o_ll~+ __I__~_ . . _,..1.. -" -+.. _..-- II\G ,~ . 1---- ]. . 1--. ~ . . 1-':,1_'" -.. -- -.. .... . ':,Ill!:" r-lOll C ~ ~T' . ~: -- . . -~.. ~~ --- --.- t~r"" . ~"j :- ,'-:: . . .. . . . . . . ,,;': ~,. \- _1--__ _1__ --- --I-- 'f G- '.~ Y, "" ) h I"js / _ ._. -[ . +- - 1.0-- ,-f--- - . ''<<'<'' 41 " . "K "' " . \" ~'- ~' _ _ -..., -'<- : + \ - ~ ~- ,-:.;oJ: " ~ VI E \ ,.. _. _ l ~ '\" -.. - g'" / /]"7 ..~ ~ }) ~ ~ ~ >-- ":,, , = ~1),~fI8<~ ~"t~ J ~ ~- __ o ~ _ _ .~ ~~ ------ ....l-~I!!!!!l!"~_ - PROPOSED DJSJRlCT UNE ...11"" .........."'" , DONNA 'FlAtA _DISTRIcT ---P<iPuuTlO~ 2 JAMES D. CARTeR Ph.D ~~~_50,22liI___,1 ] - TOM HENNING -=--_~ --=--=--i:S.----l 4 - PAM6LA S. MAC'KIE 5 - JAMES N. COl.ETTA, Jr. -- ~--- 50,431"" '~[."'fO P" ""......cs ...c> ltt''''-'l;Al SU"'OOl Sl:CllON - ,..,..... -'-~~":'_.~~~~__-1 ---un' __ 251.:ur-=:j """"lIHIlYO(>U1lJ'WIlO'_["""_.T"'-"'."l;[5D"<I$O/O O,",I[,'O/lOC' '~E, COY-<llSr_~__',OMl/I'UlT, ...,01::""-.... ..._---- '._-" - .,---- - ,,,~'" _. Ri!!lE I Ri!Iii& I Rue I II it.. . MAP #5 '-'---U'-~ " . . .1. . . I, ~ ,.. , I ~ I : COMMISSION OISTRICT UNES- :-', -~-. . .' .. _.. -::.:i BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ~- -. . --....:-. - 1----.. CDLU.R COUNTY, Fl.ONlDA 1-- , ,,\ _ "I . ,. . . I. . -.. -" __ .. \'I":.i ill J ,,-,., ,I. -' -+1' \ ~.~ ili.,7 ,,\ lU ~QUNn . t' _~_ r- ~.. r---1---=-- ~_=+-='.: _ I V'I I, "I I' . '1- -. -.. . . , ".. ',' J'.' .. - _.. --' , I -.. -.. " .:.\ -:,:: .- -:- -. . i J~ . i . FCI~. . I . _", -.. ' . . . . ~i-- - ~ --- - 1 I., -- : " 'V:-~ " :!-? .'~,.,.. I" I. ,,~i:""i -. .:.,' .... -.. -..' , .. ,. .. i .. . - ~~ .-: ,. I .. !' "ft':"" il"o., ,,'" -. ... -.. .,,, ..~ -- _:-1--;- -1-- - ~ ~~-t-- 'l"----- --- ' . .... '" I '. 1 'i=" ,. " " . ,.. " " . . " _ --...... _lot "''''1_''' ...". ...". ,-. },.: "-'-"~'." '.., .m~:::',:: ~-::"-=::'I-=:'-"'::::::::~.'-' ',-~~ \ '. . I~- _--- ' ,---0-----,-[' .[- --, , - .... ,,1.._... -' '."."1_,,'_,_,, -..._.- - .. .n, -. .,,, . I :1%'" ,,-:- ~ "-," ".:. -. -.:;;;. ..no ""'1-' j':' --+1+' '-"-- . Jt-'- l+--'.---, r- .". - -- -," '. . .". -"]. . .. 1 . ,>,.., '1,.' -" I" --,- .0'1" "r--t--- -- -, -- !;! ~ . ~___ "'"- h _ ~~ I" ~ "'I ...t.. ......1" 9 M c;J ,.l.! :-' --; -= .,. i/<m,' "'J.' ~-~ .:- i-I :-1--:. "'1', ,----- ~./ to- I !_.~. MO "" ~.~~' f- ~J . )_^__ _~ _~ ~~ ~ _--:: -"i" ~ 3 ~ \'11'" ...' ,"' I' . , ----r-, ' _ !.=-:t--L '- 'V ~ .. "f-c;;t"....J -" ,j 7'- I I - , , J ... -"" - " . .. C;' -"~," ..:,,1' Ii" '. "1...-)'- ..". -'" -'" . , ,,-,. 1"-. ., I .--: '-~'I -~.-~.- ___.1.". .--1 ~_I ~ . '-J}.:"':' I ~"!':'-:1'-- Ct' '1-,. I..:..c-'-_' -"--i=s."r;:. ::-:f',:~ ."..=. o 0 . \J} .1 ...., ." . ' .. " .] , '--- --::1 \/I ~\ , .~ " '...,.. L , - " ". "". . -." ..." 'J . ~ -- r l~ h ,- , -- -- -. --- 1 11;( "I. ' ,. . , " . ,.1.. '----~ GIib\"'+'j'--'I~-' ,I:. ' ,,! -t- II ~Ii: II~ '=~E:I I.:." ':'-j-' -.. .. i I ';J ~ II ~ . " ~ " . - . - - - --1--- /- "". "I -,,,' . -" -,. ::s:: IfY" - ",' ,,, . . - ---- - ",--1---- ('0 " 1-' 1-1------- ". :_1_. .. -""1.:1-,,," .. ..""..". H ,j" 1 ~ ..' --I - -" L_ --- o b.~''''~~ . " . 1 . 0 'Co:' __ __1__...... __ _ ". -~" _.. .". _,,, "." _'. \\ '\. 1"-'--" I ~r- --''"lII I --- -----~~ ~~ iii \"!::)~~ 0 ~"'. . =.1. 0 . \~j\ -k-- '-1--- -, ' --.-.::. -,. '" -.. -,,, -,,, -- -', \ --[' ~. "... ~ n ",' - - ___ -- I' I1i " ~.' .' -", .". ."" ' \ ,'--~" - '" - '":-- .". .. .". -------- \ \ /, ~ . F" ~ '~.' . , '" j~ -.- .. , i\l,:,..,;;o," -4-~ _ _ ,_....... l 5'l, --. , -- -- - - -- ~,!,' ~ ~ {' \1' ,-I. , { "'-!::r--'-':;- 'id\: .. ' .. , k:..~.~'(j. ,,- Y Iii j - -' -- -- -- (o/'JI, c:.r VC;-:3"-:~\" . ~_ ___' __ __I' -.:. . . ' r~ '~(1,,,- "...\~~""'- . .+t .. .'" to.,. . . " .', 'so':'" 'i _ -- -- ---'----- ,"" : + \ . Id." ,m-: - ',,' . .. '"' W ~ \ .;. -r J .:;t.e;: ~ "T":"'"',....';; .- _._-~ ~:/ ' ~':ij(\.1 ~- ',~, .. f:?~ .,,: i) ':. :.. __ s ."..1On ~,;~" ~ ". -. _ 'j --; ;u" t.:---~~~qJ% ''i' H:"\,<;';'i'- I. i, _:,' ".- r-~---'-~=+-=-:..::.+==l --------: _~ r_'_~k- _< ~ - ,\. l-L-- __ ,~ ,~ ~ - ~ " _~!~'~D _ _ PROPOSED DISTRICT UNE -. --I .....,.. .........-. l I - DONNA FIALA DI5TRlCT POpuun~ ii! JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D _~_~__1_=:--=~_-!jMt!-- 3 - TOM HtiNNIN6 _ 2 . <18,828 4 - PAMELA 5. MAC'K1E - -3------ 49.518j- 5 - JAMES N. COl.ETTA. Jr. -----"4--- ~-.~ 50,209 _ ...",.m '_"'10. ''''''OT ""' ~.~ 5----=-=-_~~~=-:.-~~!4! ~.~ I'fI[p..~(O "" "".....a; ."'D ,!w,.e... """""'" ~[,nOlO sum 25,_"", c,,","""',",ot\'fiOF'-'Mt MI<I"'""","""",,, $(11"'.."",,,,,,,, --- -------..-~~ --~.;---"---. nM(,"il00' nLL.:ou-o.n-lIN'~'_OfIC/I'lO,,""tOCIO_''''' -- ------ .._..~ -- ---.-- - ~...,,-------_.. ..__.._.~..._._._--.._.__.~~_._~._----"._---_.. , , . , , .. . . ... . . .. . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . ...,', .';i#f' ..::~c::-~:;;,,~:- ..~~~~;:;;:.:::;::,.- .~ ~~~:.".:~,..~". ' ~':::;~:-_:*:"::2~_'" ,~l':":~~ -J. ~,.,_., ,', ~:;i . . .- II -,,- DRAFT DRAFT Table of Contents Paae Introduction...... ....... ..... ....,. .... ......... .............. ..... ..... ,........ ... ..................... 2 Redistricting Criteria......... ..., ..,...,....... .,. ................. ...... ............... ...,. ....... 2 Metl1odology...............,.......,...............,..............................,..,.......,...,....... 3 Pre..dearance Data...................,..................,..,... .....,....-.................. .....,.,.., 3 Features......................... .,...............................,................,...,..................., 4 Strengths.......,... ,....,...........,.,.......................,................-....."""'" ...,....:... 5 Critique.....,...,...,....... .,..........,., ........ ......,.... ..........,... ..... .......... .......,.... ..." 6 Retrogression Analysis............ .....................,... ........ ..............,.................. 7 . Exhibits 2000 Census Tract Map 2000 Census Tract Population Retrogression Analysis Map of Existing Districts Proposed Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 Gene191 Descriptions of Districts for Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 1 __w." -_._^-_.--_._.._-". - ,.,.,,,,~"" ...,- DRAFT DRAFT Introduction Collier County has experienced extraordinary growth since the establishment of the present Board of County Commissioner (BCe) Districts In 1995, when the permanent population was 182,82.3, The present population of Collier County is 251,377, according to the 2000 Census, As one might expect, this increase in population was not unifonn throughout each district (see Table below), Bee District Population in 2000 Ideal Population Deviation - District 1 49,840 50,275 - 0.8% District 2 47,164 50,275 - 6.1% District 3 57,712 50,275 + 14.7% District 4 40,662 50,275 -19.1% District 5 55,999 50,275 + 11.3% Total 251,377 Source: Figures extracted from u.s. C-<>nsus Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public law 94-171). As a result of the uneven growth in Collier County, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners directed staff on June 26, 2001 to redraw the commission districts in order to comply with the one-person one-vote constitutional mandate. The Board of County Commissioners specifically approved the following redistricting criteria: (1) The population of each district should be as similar as possible; (2) All districts should be as compact and regularly shaped as feasible; and (3) The incumbent Commissioner's residence must remain in his or her current district, Additionally, though not specifically directed by the BCC, there are additional considerations of a legal nature that must also be taken into account. This report contains a summation of the five (5) proposed plans, Redistrictina Criteria Each of the five plans attempts to balance the following redistricting criteria: . Create districts that do not exceed a 5% deviation from the ideal district population. . Create compact and contiguous districts that observe well-defined and easily recognizable boundaries. . Protect incumbent commissioners by building each district around the residency of Its commissioner. . Minimize disruption to former districts, . Avoid retrogression of minority voting strength. . Maintain communities of interest, . Devise plans whereby unifonnity can be achieved between the School Board and the Board of County Commissioners. 2 --.-..-.-....-.-.-,., .____~______ _ _.._ ..._.. .._.___.___ ...._.._____~.M..____ .-'---' ..~-- DRAFT DRAFT Methodoloav The first step in creation of all five proposed maps was to plot the residency of each commissioner on the 2000 Census Tract Map for Collier County. The next step was to build each district by incorporating those Census Tracts adjacent to the place of residency, to the extent possible and practical. (See attached Exhibits, 2000 Census Tract Map and Tract Population,) Examole: Commissioner Carter, representing District 2, resides in Pelican Bay which iies within Census Tract 102,04. Given his place of residency, the place of residency of the other four Commissioners, and the existing boundaries of District 2, it was only natural that Census Tracts 101.01, 101.02, 101.03, 101.04 and 102.05 be incorporated into his district. Generally, this same process was repeated for all five districts on all five proposed maps. The next step, which was the most challenging, involved expanding or retracting each district as necessary to achieve relative equity in population, while at the same time creating compact and contiguous districts with well-defined boundaries that did not split voting blocks or neighborhoods. Concurrency with the District School Board was another important element that was considered. This was achieved by plotting the residency of each School Board member to ensure that no two members resided in the same district. Collier County is a covered jurisdiction under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. As a covered jurisdiction, Collier County must obtain pre-clearance before enforcing any redistricting plan. In order to obtain pre-clearance from the U.S. Department of Justice, the County must demonstrate that the new plan does not result In the retrogression of minority voting strength. This is ascertained by comparing minority voting strength, as measured by voting age population, under the existing and newly adopted plan (before and after comparison for all five proposed maps), pre-dearance District 5 has the greatest minority population in Collier County (See Table 1, below), Although it does not qualify as a minority-majority district at this time, It is the district that warrants the closest scrutiny fer possible retrogression of minority voting strength, As District 5 is presentiy configured, It has a total voting age population of 39,440, based on the 2000 Census. Of this total voting age population, 2,875 are identified as Black and 14,242 are identified as Hispanic, This means that in District 5, as it is presently configured, Blacks make up 7.3% of the voting age population and Hispanics make up 36,1% of the voting age population (See Table 1). [It is important to note that "Hispanic" is an ethnidty, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity.] 3 _.._".~_._.~--~~._---_._---~-"---_.- ,....~,._-" .~,--" ._.~'-~-.'<. ..<"'...., - DRAFT DRAFT Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population by District Present Configuration District Total Black Hispanic (All) 1 43,038 1,036 (2.4%) 5,141 (11,9%) 2 40,401 2'57 (0,6%) 2,249 (5.5%) 3 44,153 1,811 (4,1%) 8,238 (18.6%) 4 34,404 1,333 (3.8%) 3,685 (10,7%) 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Total 201,436 7,312 (3.6%) 33,555 (16.6%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 9+171). ANALYSIS OF EACH OF THE PROPOSED MAPS Features MAP #1 District 1 remains the same. Collier Boulevard is the main featJJre as it forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area. MAP #2 District 1 remains the same. Collier Boulevard is the main featJJre as it forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area. MAP #3 Most of the population in the coastal area south of US-41 Is induded in District 1. Portions of the Uvingston Road corridor form a north-south line parallel to Collier Boulevard. MAP #4 The main feature of this plan is the elongated shape of District 3 - extending from the lee County line to below Davis Boulevard, and from 1-75 and the Uvingston Road corridor to Collier Boulevard. Also, Collier Boulevard forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area. 4 -- --- ---"......~---- . ._----- <-~. - -~._._._._~,-, -- -"." -"> .DRAFT DRAFT MAP #5 Districts 1 and 5 are nearly identical in configuration to their existing boundaries. Districts 2, 3 and 4, while maintaining their core Census Tracts and most of their existing boundaries, are now neatly realigned along the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Uvingston Road, This north-south alignment, parallel to Collier Boulevard, is the distinguishing feature of this plan. StrenGths All five plans accomplish the Board's directives regarding population equity and respecting the residency of each commissioner. All five plans accomplish the Board's directive regarding the creation of compact districts with regUlarly shaped boundaries, though to varying degrees, MAP #1 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north ofImmokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd, - a significant portion of which is within country dub developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #2 District 1 remains completely the same, The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd, - a significant portion of which is within country dub developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #3 Of the five proposed maps, the population is most evenly distributed on this map. This map shifts the communities of Everglades City, Plantation Island and Chokoloskee from District 5 into District 1 - these three communities have some characteristics similar to Goodland which also lies in District 1. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned, MAP #4 All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #5 By using the. FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Uvingston Road as a major boundary, this plan creates highly compact and geometrically neat districts with well-defined and well-recognized boundaries that follow major features. The Uvingston Road Plan avoids dividing neighborhoods, utilizing minor features and creating numerous irregular boundaries. At the same time, the boundaries of the current districts were respected where practicable: All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned, 5 -,.,_.",-- ". .~._-_.~,-,~ ----- "- DRAFT DRAFT Critiaue MAP #1 There are several jogs and turns in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Districts 4-3. The common boundary between Districts 4-3 runs through Coconut Creek and Coconut Grove neighborhoods dividing each between two different Commission Districts, MAP #2 There are a few jogs and turns in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Districts 4-3, The deviation between highest and lowest District population is the greatest on this map out of all live maps. MAP #3 This map shifts the communities of Everglades Oty, Plantation Island and OlOkoloskee from District 5 into District 1. Arguably, the character of these communities is dissimilar to many of the developments in District 1, e.g, Marco Island and Lely Resort. Also, at least in recent history, those three coastal communities have been located within District 5, MAP #4 The common boundary between Districts 3-1 contains several jogs; some of these do not follow recognizable features, e.g. the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, and the east side of Wing South Airstrip. MAP #5 Arguably, that portion of Census Tract 112.01 east of I-75 has evolved into developments substantially different in character from the rest of the proposed district. This is a legitimate concern, and communities of interest were considered in devising this plan. However, it should be noted that no district is perfectly homogeneous, nor is it dear that strict class or ethnic/radal segregation is wise or desirable in a community as diverse as ours. In addition, District 5, as it is presently configured, indudes all of Census Tract 112,01. This plan shifts to District 2 that portion of Census Tract 112,01 west of I-75 Retroaression AnalYsis As noted earlier in this report, only District 5 warrants a retrogression analysis as it has, by far, the largest minority population, In the present District 5, the Black population comprises 7.3% of the voting age population, and the Hispanic population comprises 36.1% of the voting age population, As indicated in the attached Exhibit A-3, Retrogression Analysis, all five proposed maps result in an increase in these niinority populations in District 5; conversely, none of the live proposed maps result in a retrogression of minority voting strength, Redlsllictlng Report ORAFT1 F,Redistrictlng ID/dw oct. 2001 6 ----------- - ----...-- -_.._--_._.._._~-_.... .---...- --..- _.0"____-.--.-.------------- ~ __..__..._._.._.____.___________ .- .- -~ -~ -' ,," ,s ". COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA 'j 2000 CENSUS TRACTS 113 , :f::i , 114 ~ Ii ~ ~ -...... ~~ -- -- ::! i :q (~ -- ) i i I i ! i I I I I -- '112.111 ,.- / i t I 181.03 112.Q2 -- , ~ 1:: 11M.D5 " 1lU..12 ! .- - a . - -~~ :l 1lM.07 ! . --..... ! , i -- ---.... 104.'4 ,.. J.D1 4 I 2 11W.13 I 3.lI2 .- C17TOI' - 0' NDU<S ......--" ........-..-,. 7 ''''01 ''''04 . 107.111 0 ~ i .,., ( " I I 0 111.02 ) - C17TOI' JUOCOm..uw ______ 0,. ,,.,.,... i '~, , I """ , 0 IW. <W, I i i i , I - I F'lID'AAED II'!': :o/W'tIIl:S AHD l'ECHNIC.AL suP9QIl:T SECtiON -~ ~ '!'-.r----Z...\ <f!...d~--' i CCl"llJMnYQE\ti.QPlIIDlTAA'O!'}f~r.olSiR'<<tSOMSIQJI ~~ "7 )> ! I DA'lt:: ~/2001 mE: CENlR->\-::!OCl(l.D'IiC ---..------- ~-----------_.._--------- - _._._-----~- -- -------_.._--~._-- .._,- ^- ,...." ," Aprd 1 2.000 Permanent PopulaTion CallIer' County, Florida 2000 Census Tract 2000 Total PopulatIon 1 . 3~649 2 1,199 3.01 3,532 3.02 1~631 4 4,117 S 1,313 6 1,483 7 1,292 t01.01 11.802 101.02 3,542 101.D3 Cl,337 101.04 7~19" t02.02 8,106 102.03 S,283 102.04 7,383 10Z.05 l,3S5 103 4,235 104.01 3,713 104.05 5,302 104.06 7,007 104.07 1i,926 104.08 3,147 104.09 8,380 104.10 "'469 104.11 Cl,102 104.12 Cl,697 104.13 3,336. 104.14 Cl,CiS6 105.02 7,028 105.03 7,230 105.04 6,464 106.01 l,r;ol 106.02 3,359 106.03 5,699 106.04 3,757 107.01 4,807 107.02 4,162 108.01 3,857 108.02 Cl,612 108.03 3,458 109.01 4,048 109.02 3,371 109.03 4.090 110 3,698 tl1.01 5.387 tll.02 4,213 tl2.01 3,384 112.02 5,790 tl2.04 4,623 112.05 3.464 113 9,430 tl4 4,551 COUNTYWIDE 151,377 N<xe fmm Cenms a~ ''DlIlaMl: IIdjIWCd butd on lhe A=ao:y =d C<nIcnp EvulWion." $0= u.s. CO\SU$ Bu=iu, C::mus 2000 Redisuicli"1/. Dall.(PuQlicLlw 94-.171) s~ Filll. MOItIiccs I'LL i>L2. I'U.3lIdPU Tr.Q::[popllWiou G..~2000Cm$D$ riwl Aprll.2001 ..._---~~---,~~~~-_._~_._-,-,- ,-,"-_.",~.,."---,^~.-.. - ,,~.~'.~-_._~_..~.- ....- ~ Retrogression'Analysis Maps #1. #2 & #4 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Maps #1, #2 & #4 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104,12 4,704 133 I 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 I 69 I 862 111.01 (portlon) 1,594 I 2 106 111.02 I 3,137 105 729 112,02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 I 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 I 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 . Total I 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Souro.: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Maps #1, #2 & #4) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Change +0.9% +4.1% i Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: '~Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any rac~ and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. -- .____.,_"_..._._w_.~__ -.', ,---. Retroqression'Analysis Mao #3 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #3 Census Tract No. Total Population Black I Hispanic (All) 104,12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111.02 (portion) 2,177 102 702 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112,04 I 3,276 I 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 I 167 2,382 Total 32,080 i 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Ce!lsus 2000 Redistricting Data (Public law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration VS. Proposed District (Map #3) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Change + 1.6% + 7.3% Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Ce!lsus 2000 Redistricting Data (PUblic law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. . ---- --. ~ "._,"~._,-..*._-" ,- ",,-- Retroqression"Analvsis Map #5 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #5 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104,12 4,704 I 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111.02 I 3,437 105 729 112.01 2,327 13 76 (east ofI-75) 112,02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 - , 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 I 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 14,028 (39,3%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #5) Plan I Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 13,349 (39.3%) Change +0.7% + 3.2% I Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an etbnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person ~y be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. .~-~.._.._-" , "'" ^,-- en III Z i - w ~~ z I i :::i I .uNrlQ:)Q_lIIl I t; i , zc" ~ ~~ I I ::)i '" I // 5 Ot- z I I "en 0 I ii.i I - ~I '!! I , a::C ::; i !:!!z ill ~ . I -' <J i ""'0 '" ""'- z ;:: I octJ '" ~ ,,!: i.j . , I 1 == ~ .1 . I I ; , == : i 0 I , , U u I > I A.l.I'OIIO:l.l.llllN3H _..":: . . . u ~ ~ ~n ! un . u ,J,~ . . f,~~ " . ~ . , """""'" """"""........., I -- . _ilmll ~ . : ,; III I ~ ~~ I l!lilll":J < i 0 " ~ ~ " I 00 ""all '.llCTll"W ll1t\o1aR' g fi" . ;~ I ~ iN, mn 1._lU I 1; . ~ ~S ",n ~~~I :3 i #'" ~g~ ~~~ I ~ 0' c" ~~gl 0" ....w 11 " 000 ~':; g .~2i co' .~" 0_ ':!oa ~' ~~~! - f Z 'b ij~':;:! J~ ~~_ I ",:=.EZi ~;~ -- ~~~ ,00 - -v___ -" ~~ -" ~-~ -~---- - - .. .__c I [ I ! I i I ",..,,- 1 .uflna:I~ I fI) w I z I ... ::J C; to ~ ii2 ~ i I '" Ze'" a I , z J I :)w! 0 'I'" 0; Ofl)C '" t c :> ) CJOZ z ::; 'I w 0 -I a:: a. 0 a. '" 0 wO- e ~ 0 i w -a:fI) ::E '" 0 i ; ....a.fI) ... .... - ~ : o ::E ... : CJ :IE I I 0 c; I I I I I ~- ~ --"";) I I . i . ~ 0 ," ~ l~~ . . : . . r (__~I -- .uHAOOp..., ~ ~1tOS1..~ . ; I . " ~8 ~ ;j' ; ~ , ~g ~I > ; . :aN W1 '1'i 0' : <I .. ' , ~ " :;:;1 ~~ ::."IJ 0 "I 0 ~I ; g] I ;:!i'; II ," 1- 0 ' . ~i - 1 ~ i 0" ~! ---- - ,-" I - I . " ~ ~ . ' I U ' ' I .. - s -- I I ~ "'. ' __ I , z_~ · ' ~-. " ' oiU N ~ / I UOZ =I: C !!! ( I ~a.O a. ili ~ · ..0- C'" ' 3::=:S -' ~ j o - .. > H:S ~ ~ _ 2 .' ' o I' I u . ! o ! ~-- -= ! ~ "~ "n ; . . o · ~ , ~ - .......... -- ~ . II ~ II! __ \!i! .. Iil ~ 1ft ~ . 0 .' I . g . . . .! . " . ~ . . 0" ' , .> I ~~ I ~! I ~. il;t ~~~ < ~~1[ " ..... 0'* I 00" wul \; ::" -. II~ ao' 8j ~g:; 8i ~~~ : I Z ~ ,.., - ~ ~~"-II ~~~ .- . " -- ,,' -- -- ---- --"'--. "---'-- --- ,,~...- - , I I I i I .J.J.MllDO'_ I ~... I) W Z ... :l U 5 ~ i ii2 ... OJ z cd" 2i % 0 ::)w- ~ iii I al)a OJ :a: " ;;; . Uaz ill " 0 a=a.a a. .. " I . cC .. " IUO- .... w S . -a:: I) ::E OJ . 0 , > ..Ia.1) a. f ~ 0 ..I - '" : a == a. . U == I 0 u ~-- -~ : . , . . . ,,~ .~ . . ! , . . 0 . ~ . " -- ~.- ......,'" . g . . . --. III ~ . ~ . . g ~ I - ~ . ~ 0 . . .> 00 E ;11I" o. . "" g . ~g ., '> > . . ~~ , ~ -, ~~ I ~ ~~ -, 5~ ~Q , I 11"s"n " .,. 00 i " ,< I ." o'~ 0 ~~ 0 ;J 0" ~'3 I I ~; II gj ~ ~~ I - =~~ ~~~ I ~~~ 0 ,0< ,00 --...,.-. " --..-.- -- - ---..--.-----.,,----- ...-- "- -, I I I I -,- ~- rn w z I t- :J ... I u <.l ~ i i'i! ... "' zct- a z :::tw!! ~ 0 ii'i OrnCl "' :a: " ,. . Uoz z ::; j w 0 ar:a.o a. .. <.l . j w I wO- 4 ... " ~ ; w -ar:rn :E "' . 0 I , ....a.rn .. 0 I .... - 0: o :E .. . U == : I 0 I u I """""-- -~ : - ~ ~ u" u>> . . .; ~ . -- -- ~I'" > . , . . -~" III . . ~ i - ~ I : > ~" ~IE "- . "" .~ ~ j" "< , I >~ l5~ I ~" - , ~< - ~~o ...!:;t~ I ~ -. I ~ ru Q~ ~= ~~i . ~Ci~ ~ ~~Q . ,.'I'A <"""'!' 0' -"- ~~^ \. ""~ 0 !:!15Q ~i ;j ~~~ I ~s .. 00' - ! I ~ < ;~::; 10 0"' ~ ~ ~~~ oj ~o I , e.~.8 i :f<.>~1 ~. ..._-_.._._~._"._---~--,~._-~~_._.- "~_'_~._~h._.'___.__ ,',--".,.,,-~ M'~,'____' ._-~.- ""-'=- --~. I , , , i , I I ..-- ..-- I . W I z / I- :l to / U / I ~ i ii: Iii I zal- ;:; z ;:)w! 0 I In OJ I o.a ., . Q S! , UOz ::& , z - .. 0 .:a.o a. CO 0 ~ .c ~ c wO- W ; -.:. :E ., ! 0 - ..I a. CD ... ..I - ~ I o :E ... U :E : 0 I U ....",,- -~ - - : : I K'n ..... I ," " . . . . . 0 " ~ , , - -.-- - ~- ...... ! = . .-nnos __ ~ III . , . ~ . . a I a~ -. .0 " ..m "" ~ ., ! g fa .. ~; . ~-, ~~- i ,~~ '~ ""... 5~~ . - R1~ cf ~!ii I <>_::11 "', I .0' ....,;" ::i:i:'!'1 .'v 0 '!^~ I 0 :::::i,z ~ 0, ~l!;"" ~J ~--'''-, . , ti..~ IZ j~ ," I o. ~~~ J" ! ;j~:i 0" iiis~ I a.uo. ! ------ - - - -"'~-- . ----- .- ~" EXttIBrT-A- -' General DesaiDtions. MAP #1 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly ro the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly ro the center of the leiy Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly ro the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly ro the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly ro the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly ro the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly ro Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of State Road 9S1, southerly ro the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly ro the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,SOO feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning, District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 2S East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest comer of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County. Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast comer of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly ro the south line of Section 25, Township 4B South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh pue; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence. along the center of. County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florlda Power and Ught (FPl) transtnlssion line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine RIdge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of darn Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly ro the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of Lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of lakewood Boulevard, northerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, westerly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, northerly to the center of Coconut drde South; thence along the center of Coconut drde South, westerly to the center of Coconut drde West.; thence along the center of Coconut Orde West, northerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, easterly ro the center of Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, northerly to the center of County Road 8S6 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 8S6, easterly ro the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of 5an Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-7S, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Florlda Power and Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-7S; thence along the center of 1-7S, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road --~-,._--~, _"""__0 ------,._~_.,.~, ,,'-----~- ,",_. 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Rc.ad); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly III the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Roadr.:.thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly III the south line of SectIon' 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUO; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly III the eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly III the southeast comer of the Regent Park PUO; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Pari< PUO, northerly III the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersectio" of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Aorida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Oam Pass and aam Bay, easterly and southerly III a point on the west shoreline of aam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western tenninus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, southerly to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green Canal, westerly to the center of the Aorida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence aiong the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly lD the center Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, southerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, westerly to the center of Coconut Clrde West; thence along the center of Coconut Orde West, southerly to the center of Coconut Orde South; thence along the center of Coconut Orde South, easterly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, southerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, easterly lD the center of Lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of Lakewood Boulevard, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly lD Highway U.S, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly lD the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly lD the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning, Distnct 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also befng a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Rorlda; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly lD the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterJy lD the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly lD the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Mlami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County- Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County- Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that Is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road B46 (ImmokaJee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and la, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. OW /mklf:/comp.planning/davidweeks General Oescriptions Map fI1, A F, Redistricting _._---~--~-- ------- - ----- --....--" ".,~ .- EXHIBIT -A" General Descriotions. MAl' #2 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 2S East, Collier County, FloJida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the LeJy Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U,S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 9S1; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U,S, 41; thence along the center of State Road 9S1, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Guif of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning, District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest comer of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 1q, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (1mmokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast comer of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly- to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range. westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Oam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westeriy to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast comer of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of I-7S, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Rorida Power and light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easteriy to the northwest comer of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westeriy to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road ~._-,------~---_.__.~-,_._~_._----~-~-----~._-'.._.".-~-'.,-,' .---., _..._._.e'_ - 862, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East,. also being the north boundary of Pelican MarSh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly to the eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly to the southeast comer of the Regent Park PUD; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Park PUD, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Oam Pass and Oam Bay, easteriy and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western tenninus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (I-75); thence along the center of I-75, southerly to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green Canal, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of I-75; thence along the center of I-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township SO South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Rorida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line rums north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Mlami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in. the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U,S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. OWlmk\tJcomp.planningldavidweeks Gene"" DesaipIlons Map #2. A F,R_g - --- ,..---. ,"",..,,",,,"" "'''''--.' -- EXHIBIT-A" General Descriptions. MAP #3 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Ronda; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the dty of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U .S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of County Road 864; thence along the center of County Road 864, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of said road, southerly to the north line of Section 11, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 11, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 12, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 7, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along the north line of said Section 7, easterly to the northeast comer of Section 7; thence southerly along the east line of said Section 7 and continuing southerly along the east line of Sections 18, 19, 30, and 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East, to the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, westerly and northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Ronda; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary - line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Dnve); thence along the center of said road,_ southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 29 and 32 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Ronda Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Dnve, westerly to the west shoreline of Oam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26, and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Ronda; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of County Road 864 (Rattlesnake Hammock Road); thence along the center of County Road 864, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Rorida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to east -- ..__._.._._._------~---_._--'"._.,._----_._,-_. - ~~.. '"'' _.- line of Section 32, TOW!:l5hip 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 32 and 29 of said Township and Range, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Oam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Florida Power &. Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Rorida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly . until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier CountycMiami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point south of, and in alignment with, the east line of Section 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along said alignment and along the east line of Sections 31, 30, 19, 18, and 7, of said Township and Range, northerly to the northeast comer of Section 7, of said Township and Range; thence along the north line of 5ection 7, of said Township and Range, westerly to the northeast comer of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of Sections 12 and 11, of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of County . Road 29, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of Collier Boulevard, northerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning, Genetal Dasaiplions Map #3. A F.RedlstlidIng _ -..-.-.-..--.. ._- ..- _._._--".._.,,_.~._"._.._.. -_..~- .. ,...-. .... -~_. ,-.- ,,... """ --.-""""'- EXHIBIT -A- General DescriDtions. MAP #4 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U,S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of DaVis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of Cope lane; thence along the center of Cope lane, easterly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, southerly to the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of said Section 16, easterly to the northeast comer of said Section 16; thence along the east line of said Section 16, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples lakes CountIy Gub; thence along said north boundary, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway u.s, 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the lI1arco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-COllier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Gam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Coilier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road) and County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples lakes CountIy Club; thence along said north boundary of the Naples lakes CountIy Oub, westerly to the east line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Section 16 of said Township and Range, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, northerly to the north line of said Section 16; thence along the north line of said Section 16, westerly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, northerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope lane, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Rorida power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northeriy to the ._.~.o,___.__~_~~ ~-_.._._.._. ...-.,.....- -.,.- '_'-'''''' center of County RoaQ 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos 'Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the intersection of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Oam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and 'westerly shoreline of Oarn Pass and Oam 8ay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Oam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Florida Power & Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Rorida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Comer Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.s. 41; thence aiong the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (1mmokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. General Descriptions Map #4. A F.Redbl1idlng ----------_..."-_._,-_._,-,-~._,,_.__. ~-._--~.."~,,......- .-_.- ^",.-. ...~.....", EXHIBITwA" General Descriotions. MAP #5 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the LeJy Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92.; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key tight; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 2.5 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the east boundary of Eboll PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Eboll PUD, southerly to the southern boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along the southern boundary of Eboli PUD, westerly to the southeast corner of April Circle PUD; thence along the southern boundary of April Circle PUD, westeriy to the center of the Florlda Power and tight (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S, 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Ciam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Eboli PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power &. tight (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the . center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the southwest corner of the April Circle PUD; thence along the south boundary of April Cirde PUD, easterly to the southwest corner of the Eboli PUD; thence along the south boundary of the Eboli PUD, easterly to the east boundary of the Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary, northerly to the Point of Beginning, District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Ciam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Ciam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence aiong the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road - - -.-...-. ---. -~~---_..~_._- ..-.----> ,~.. ".~"""" 896 (Pine Ridge Road)! easterly to the center of the F10rlda Power & Light (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U,S, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely OutJall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely OutJall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (I -75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Mlami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier . County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.$, 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U,$. 41, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of said road, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (I-75); thE!nce along said I-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning, _llesaipticn.Mapil6.A F,~ 1 "_._-------,---,.~~,_._-~-~---~."...-"-"...._- ~.__._.~ -_...~.,......__.._--~-~~._-,---~--~..........----_._"_._~ ,-----.--. -"'.- .......,.... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ." , r ':3 ..- .... r-S r- Q N ~ i"'-= ...:; ~ ("\. - - 0 n ~ 0 "'- ~ ~ s;- -"' ),., .- ~ ... ~ - r: ~ "" g" "T" <) N :r- C'\ - - -- ;:: ~ .. '" c-f'>, 3 Ql ~ ~ -' ~ .- J! .!l < .: ~ :is ~ - ~ -- ~ (,) Ql e, ~ . III - ~ .!!! III s::: ~:s Q ;; (,) .- (,) a s::: '" .lll uj " u: ci s::: <:: 'il ~ .!!! :s III III III ...!! s::: Ql Ql Ql {'"ll s::: .. e e e ~ e ~'" -:18 Q C-lll ~ . III ?.lll .> .~ Q ~.., ~a. '\'- ~ .., -!r ....~ . \:)~' ff... ~. <S'''\" · -:r)n ~ .... 'In",N ,l -::: CO) Q ."t -:> '" ~ _ m - ..,.. - .- ,:1-.... - - -:r U (,) (,) ';lo .> (,) --=>~(,) ~ .~ ..... E :s ~_.- .......,:).- - 't: -- ,g ,. Ai ~ - ... ~ . - .... ~'ti ~ . ,Ill . .!!! '" .!!! \\ .!!! m ;> a .- .?; -""'" >;;, Q Cl Q .> Cl m ~ } ').0 s::: s::: s::: s::: s::: w .. ~ Q 0 0 0 Q 'C ~ .- - .- '- ,- i~ '" V> Q III III III III III ~ :P'> " ,!!! ..!!! III III .!!! c.s .2 pz .- .- E E E E E = 0 ;; =.... ." ~ E E E E E 0 Q \\ U 0- S Q 0 Q Q ~ '> (,) (,) (,) (,) "5 " ----....----------- -- -- --------.- ------- -- ".---.,..-...----.. -~-" ~,.-' ..... t- t") ..,. ... ... .,', .-~ ..., I,Q. N t"). ..,.' a\ r---~ ..,.. ..., r-:' tI'l + + t + t Eo Eo .~. ~ ~ .a.- '; '3 ";: .; .... . ... ... ... ... Ii<l Ii<l Ii<l ~ Ii<l " ." ~. " " ~ ~ .. t ~ " :;: .- :;- ,:a :a -= ... ..r .. " " -< -< '-< -< -< 'Q" '= o. 0 0 ... ... ... ... ... ......-' I.... ...., .... - Of = =. = = " ." " " " a a !l a e, - - ... - '" ... '" ... '" ::I ::I ::I ::I ::I ,~ ;co .~ .~ ~ "" "" "" "" -< -< -< -< -< ~ = Q = = = = ... 0 0 0 0 0 ~ .- .- .- .- ..: ,- '" - . ... ... ... ... .. .s:: .. .. .. ""'j .. '" - Q.'3 - CD '3 - .. ::I ::I ::I -' Co Co "" '- c:. . -" Cll "" 0 .... 0 0 ~~ .... 0 :0 'p., Q) .p., p., ....10-0 ~ 1:: l.) .!!! ~ Cl ~ .l9 .!!! ~ .S 8 .. Q '" .!!! Q c: iii c c: I <: = 11.: 0 CD .!!! E III III :x: III .. 'C c: CIl CIl CIl " c: IS IS IS IS 0:: '" C ~ ~ ~ ~ :5 Q '" .. . c.:. . . . " .. ~ C") 'lit I/) c " .... .... - - .... () l.) l.) l.) l.) l.) E 1:: 1:: 1:: .,.. 1:: ~ .... .... - ~ .... "0 .!!! III .!!l .!!! .!!l " .- > Q Q Q Q Q 'C " "0 c: s::: c: c: c: " " c 0 0 0 0 '; .- .- .- .- .- '" III III III III III = III III III III .!!! c -" .- '- .- .- ;; IS IS IS IS IS '5 IS IS IS IS IS c- o "- 0 0 0 0 0 ~ (,) (,) u (,) u 0 c - - ------------ ---------~-_.._.._-_.__..._._- ~,-----._-_._,--~ --~~_._~----------_._-- ..-"",,---.. E ... a: ...: '" ;< Ql ...., .. --' '- , .2 .: ~ ;l! :c .! " u oS! e, ... ~ .\\l .!! lJ 0 .. 0 c '" III ci u) C .- :c: n u: ~ l' III II) II) .. '5 t: Ql Gl .. t: e e e '" 0 Q ~ 0 III ~ 0 CI ...., '" .. I c.:. , , . " .. ..... C") "t ." C .. .... .... .... .... .... u U U U U C,) E .,., 1:: ',., .,., ,- ~ ..;: .... ..;: ..;: ~ " II) II) II) .!!! III .. .- ,- ,- .- > CI CI CI CI Cl 'C .. " t: t: t: t: t: .. '" ~ Q 0 0 .!2 0 '" " .- .- ,- .- ~i ~ '" II) fIl II) II) III ~ c .!!! II) II) II) III >. .. c .- .- ..- ,- - - 1i e e e e e = Q = I'-< ~ 0- e e e e e Q c U a. Q 0 Q 0 0 ~ t.) t.) t.) t.) 0 1'5 c -- '.--~' ,.., r-- fOl ...,. -1"""'1' ,.., In' ,...4' fOl \C M <'1. ...,.. r-- ....,. i ~ Cl- Iff + I + I 'E- E- E- Eo E- .-. ',- .; 'S 's .. .. C" Q" Q" Q" Q" J;l;1 I'il I'il .I'il J;l;1 ... .. .. .. .. ~ ~ s ~ ~ .-" :a: ;a. ;a .- .<: ..= ... .... ... ... ... <( ..< .< < < Q, Q. Q Q Q ..- ..- .- - - .... - ... - - <1 '" = = = ~.- .. .. .. .. s a Sf a a ..- - - - - .... ... ... ... ... .. " ",. " " .~ ;;;' ,~ ;;;' .~ "". ",. "" < < < < < E = c:i = = = = Q Q Q Q Q ... .- .<:: ,- .- ...: .- '" ... - - - ~ .. ..c:: .. .. .. .., .. - 0..= - CD = = '" " .... "" "" "" ,- "" - "" .2 C>' ..: Q Q ~ Q J!! Q :a .~. CD p.., p.., p.., ... p.., ~ t:: u ..!!! !!, 01 ~ ~ .!!! 1\1 c:: 8 .. (J ,- 0 c:: '" 1\1 CI) c it c:i c:: <: il CD .!!! :s 1\1 III :x: III w 'a c:: CD CD CD ~ c:: E E E E a: '" 0 ~ 1\1 '" 1\1 ~ '" Q .., 0.. '" w . , , , rl> , D ..... c-.. I") ~ c ~ ... ... ... ... ... " u u u u U E ,- "t: "t: ,- :s 0 ~ ~ .:: ... ... ." .le III .!! .!! III 0 ,- .- > Q Cl Cl Cl Cl ~ 0 '0 c:: c:: c:: c:: c:: D ~ 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ,- .- '- .- ,- '" III III III III III ~ III III III III III c " .- .- '- .- '- ;; E E E E E '3 0. E E E E E 0 c- o 0 0 0 0 ;; (J (J (J (J (J 15 c -- .-..- -,-.. ~.,-. --.---.----.-- ...'- .........- o ,. . o ~ " NCO 0 ""'l:")-rJ NcaU)CO~'O ....Cl'"'J.....N'G NNCO,....."",oa _COr--NllO'O OO<D.....NO~ OClCDCDClO~ U""II1Q1""C"')~ UOOO<").....O~ .~....Nf')Nca~ -~"".C"!~CO_~ _lO_~~~_<<t~ -C'I!.""_""":~f'-:.o." -~('?_C'I!.u:J+~a.' .::!:CC_~iC_O."'gO ..C.....C")otO,........ ~....C")OCO......... ..CcQt'?OlQ......... iCO(O')OID......... ~.....f')OCD_-.... Q,.....N ~ -N:!II..-('II ~.....('It -('II . . .. . . : ~ : ~ % J"_'":;, 'Pl:- ....;"".. >-' ......, Nm"'NlO'" NCDO.....ca- OJCO.....NCO.... Ocn......-NCC..... diNe....,..,..... ..NOOJ.......CS!: -.NOIl1U)lD:g ..lON....NIO:g :IOOIONfO~ .....,OtQMca:g u ..... ..., <'II. N~ ~ on C,)......... C'II. N. O!. ",. 0......,. C\!. N. O!. ",," u,........ C"of. 1;"01_ CD. ....- 8"""'" IN.. "'t QI ..," e ....-..... l'I ............... . ............... . .....-..... . ............. ~ << ~ << ~. N N N N N AI Al AI Al Al g~Q]iO~~ m~a1ro:6~ ~;;;~~~~ ~~::~fJ~ ;r;84i~~:; :D"":u:JaJ.l;").........- ~"....CDCICI_r)_..._.... ;~(QOJ.N_""':", iii~CCOJ."!.""':"'" ~C'I!.(QOJ.N_"'I:~ .eN .......-O-.eN ..........aa-.eN .........c:n-.eN -.....QlI-,.eN ...........0- o 000 0 ...~~~~~~ ..~~~~:E5 ..~re~re~s ..~~~re:5S ..~~~~~~ . . . . . - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; :i ; i 1i g ii ii -; "Ii iii e :: - - - - - >> o . .- . - ~ ~. ~;:::~~~~ fri~~~~1! ~m~~~~ iO~~~~~ ~f6~~~:S Z ;.:! CNC")..,.....,_....: cNM..,.C':I_....: c::NM.M......; CC'\lM....Pl....._~ l:INCO')..M......:: >. 0.2 .; -! -! -! -! s. ::~ 0( 0( oil( oil( '" .?;...... .~' 3~ -~ -= I: ~ ...; 1i e--.; c .... CO') ,.... In M ... C..... Pl <D 0 (").... C OJ (tJ .... ..... (tJ... C llQ ID CD ..... M'" C.... an ('II NO.... .:: ~ '3 QU ......to(")a:...,.~ .....anNo..,.j::! 1II_IOPlCJMj::! 1'I.....IONOlI....~ lII......an(")r:>>....~ fJ:..... llI:~ c:=:;;;; .... M ~..... ...........C') ;;..... ...... CO):s..... Pl ii...... ("] e-s: ... ~= .5 .5 .s .E .5 5:..: ~~ E E E fiE E ~~ a -< <l( ~ -< c ~ .~ o . C,) .....Ol'?('\jO~ ..,.OIlO....OQ\. ....CO('llM.....'" anCJNPlOOl OONlOdJlt:I'" :::E la_a...,.......,. lO.....lOllO....:;;: _..,.""CO('l:; (CM..l.O.....; lt10(CCON:;;: ~ .)l:~....~.......l:"'J~...: ~1O...,.~N.~_. ~~""G2~-r:~....: ,,)ll(C_..,.~~Il":!...: .liI.1O...<<!.C"It"'!....: ..! u...... ('IIN....- U".... NN........ U...... NN....- u..... NC'\I"lt- U NC\ol...,.- '.z: .!! !! }! .!! .!! e:- m m III III CD .. ~ ~ ~~S;~~~ ~~~&ilS';i ;t'j~f;lD~~ .....~fJrn~~ ~~cor:::::~ ..... .!~:.:::-:;~ S:--:~:.:;~- ~~:~:ri~-~ :!:ri~~~~:;;~ ~~~~~~:ri~ ... _..............(")N -...,..........""... -.........,...,.M... -.......,.........C"'lM -..............,.(W).... go, i i i i i 3 o ~ ~ Cllnca.......::: OCD'"'.........;: tOMG.....cot::: at""'..............r;: .....CDCOdllO~ r.;:-;: :~;;~~." :~:;;SC"J.... ~~::;~~~ ~'=~~'1. ~::t;~~"'!.. ~:: Ii oi o~ 0 di c~ 5 iii ca~ o~ ,.; N :- S .. o~ ci 0 o. c E 'ii <> oi t::i t::i cf S ii ~ .; ~ 0 ;.: E 11 ~ O...IOIIJ...,.a 1;...10....1010 '01010"'1010 ~1f1"'IOIiDWJ '0.,........1010 8..5 ,... .... I- I- I- l:; "5 ::: :a 8 . ~ '" =~~~~ ....~~~~ _N~..., ::~C"I"lt1O =~C"J:!~ ~8 uuuuu OUUUCl uuuuu uuuuu uu1Suu ~'" Eli.::.::.::. E:s......:s ......SEE E:5E:S'E SEEE.:: .2;1 ~..!!"!!.!!.:!!~ ..!!.!!..!!~.!!!~ .!!.!!.!!.!!.!!~ J!!~.!'!"!!.!!~ .!!"!!.!!.!!.!!!~ .;fi cecco. cecoo.. cocoo... COCQO.. coccc", ~u 00000 QO(.)uu "c.JtJ"u (JUc.JOc.J uuuuc.J O~- 00 (J (.;10 (,)oUc.JO OU(,Jf,JO uouoo oU(JC,JU u:: mmmmca a:lOllDl:CUI alaJtOmm lDlDalGaI lDlDlDmlD ::-'3 . " g . u _ ,. "G " " "Cf ~ ~ 8: iII_ ON GlI"'I" ..... at., :;<ri;J :,. ~1l :. ::1: :_ ~;j ~ a.lI. a. II. Q. Q. a..a.. Q. II. ,I ;.: ece :!ce ece ect eel: u~... a. ~ Go:S Q. :E Q. ~ a. :e iii ~ ~ .~-_,~,__,_,~_____~,__,_,__ ~'_.,_~,,~,~.,,"~,'_~' __...~~, ".._" _ _~_'~~_m___'_~ msp ANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD MlNUTESOFMEETING / of October 25,2001 " PRESENT: ABSENT: David Correa, HAAB Member Robert Pina Pete Cade, HAAB Member Frank Loney, HAAB Member Sofia Pagan, HAAB Member Susan Calkins, HAAB Member Carlos Aviles Ranuro Maiialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison Also Present: Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones News Timothy Durham, Office of the County Attorney David Weeks, Collier County Planning Services Liza McClenaghan Michael Kirk, Collier County Public Schools, Chuck Mohlke Frank Rodriguez, Que Pasa Southwest Florida TV John Norman, Representative Ralph Arza's office The October 25, 2001 meeting of the Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) took place at the Collier County Commission meeting room and began at approximately 7:03 P.M. A quorum of six (6)) members was present. APPROVAL OF SEPTEMBER 29. 2001 MINUTES David Correa noted a correction that was needed on the draft minutes of September, 2001. Specifically, on pagc 4, he noted that a reference to the "lmmokalee Bank" should be changed to "Bank of America." There is also a correction to the spelling of the last name of Commissioner Coletta. A motion wa, made to approve the minutes, as corrected, by Frank Loney. Carlos Aviles seconded the motion. The vote was 6 to 0 in favor of the motion. .-~..,."--~.----,--~- ...--- ~~,_._~,.- ~,..".~"..,,~ ~-....". ----~~. EXCUSED ABSENCE Ramiro MafiaIich informed the Board that Mr. Pina had called several days before and advised that he would be unable to attend the HAAB Meeting as he 1,""' 118Wl1 QalI88. tl> Wl~q- <!.. Ifl>,r ll'\;lifo.<7~ J~qQlI in ~tarolina. Carlos Aviles made a motion to excuse the absence and Frank Loney seto'llile the motion. A unanimous vote (6 to 0) occurred in favor of the motion. REDISTRICTING PRESENTATION David Weeks from the Collier County Planning staff explained the reasons for redistricting of the Commission boundaries. The basic reason was that there had been population changes throughout the County. He explained that five maps had been prepared (the maps are attached to these minutes) as well as a report (attached) and a spreadsheet regarding population figures (also attached). He said that the basic redistricting criteria approved by the County Commission were to maintain incwnbency, compact and contiguous districts, equal population districts, and seeking to have the same boundaries as the school district. He also said that additional legal criteria included: avoiding retrogression of minority votes (especially in District 5); and avoiding division of neighborhoods. He mentioned that other criteria that were followed are included in the report. He also stated that retrogression analysis indicated that there was actually an increase in minority populations in the districts. Mr. Weeks explained the redistricting methodology based on census tracts and where Commissioners live. He mentioned that Collier County is a "covered jurisdiction" and that it must submit maps. for "pre- clearance" by the U.S. Justice Department. He explained that the report that has been prepared has standout features and critiques of each map. There is also a description of each district in the package. Mr. Weeks commented about the differences between the maps. With regard to Maps #1 and #2, he said that the only significant difference was in the area of Davis Boulevard. District I has not changed in those maps. Map #3 has a significant feature in that District 1 goes farther east. Maps #4 and #5 have different boundaries in North Naples. There are very few "jogs" on Map #5. Mr. Weeks also mentioned some significant changes in the maps regarding the so-called Manatee Road Triangle. Mr. Weeks recapped prior public meeting presentations regarding redistricting. He mentioned that there had been meetings with the League of Women Voters, the Black Affairs Advisory Board, and the School Board. He said the School Board wanted to follow the County lead in this matter and also wanted to wait for public comment. The School Board expressed reservations about Map #3 regarding Everglades City not being in District 5. There were also three community meetings. Weeks said that the turnout varied, but generally the nwnbers were small. He mentioned that notices of these meetings were provided as described. The notices were in English, Spanish and Creole. The BCC meeting is November 13,2001 for consideration and approval of the maps by the County Commission. The staff group would also be back before the School Board and in Immokalee. He said that residents of Immokalee felt that there was a need for another meeting due to lack of sufficient prior notice for the previous meeting. 2 -"'-., -_.._.^.-.~._._._..-.,.".._,,, .._"'"_.._-"~,-~~ David Correa mentioned that he felt that there was a lack of ample notice for tonight's meeting. He said that it would have been better if there had been earlier notice. He would have preferred a summary of the large amount of information. Liaison Ramiro Maiialich expressed regrets about not getting information to the HAAB earlier, but he explained that all of the staff had been very busy and that the information had been coming together recently. He suggested that the Hispanic Board could consider having another meeting before the November 13" County Commission Meeting. David Weeks mentioned that more information about the redistricting process was available on the County Website. Frank Loney asked about the Hispanic population figures in the districts and David Weeks explained the numbers of the spreadsheet. Mr. Weeks emphasized that County Staff was seeking comments, criticisms and suggestions regarding all of the redistricting process. David Correa asked if any comments would be conveyed to the County Commission. Mr. Weeks explained that the comments would be presented to the Board of County Commissioners. However, staff will not change the maps without County Commission direction. Tim Durham from the County Attorney's Office explained that there had been lots of information received. He emphasized that there had been significant concerns expressed regarding Map #3 as well as regarding the North Naples communities on Map #3 and Map #5 not being similar to the rest of District 5. David Correa agreed that there should be concern over these North Naples communities being in District 5 because they are not similar in terms of income and in other ways. Frank Loney echoed those same concerns and he thought that including the North Naples gated communities in District 5 would impede minorities running for office in that district. David Correa asked Chuck Mohlke, Democratic party Chairman, to comment about the redistricting information. Mr. Mohlke stated that he had been monitoring the redistricting process and that he had previously commented regarding congressional redistricting as Chair of the Collier County Democratic Party. He said that the County Staff had made a good presentation. He stated that he has concerns concerning the North Naples' gated communities being included in District 5. He provided demographics information and mentioned that Commissioners Matthews and Berry had been elected from those North Naples' communities. He compared information of other representative areas in the Immokalee region in District 5. He also spoke of "age demographics" in Immokalee. H7 said that the last Census it was indicated that the median age in Immokalee was far younger (22.5 years of age) than in the North Naples' gated communities. In those communities, the median age is 55. He also mentioned that those under 18 years of age cannot register to vote. He said that the registered voters are 39% of District 5's population whereas in District 2 it is 66% of the population that are registered to vote. He mentioned that obviously age was a major consideration. He stated that the North Naples' communities had a higher number of registered voters and that they do not have much in coormon with Immokalee or the rest of District 5. David Correa asked Me. Mohlke about having just Immokalee as a Commission District. Mr. Mohlke responded that the districts all have to have the same approximate population. A variance of up to five percent is allowed. The present maps have one to two percent variations and they arc good maps, but there are the concerns that he expressed previously. 3 ,_~u_,_____,_~__,~._ . ~~._-,. David Correa asked Mr. Mohlke if there could be one "minority" district? Mr. Mohlke explained that it was very hard to do that in the large Collier County area and not violate the compact and contiguous redistricting standards. He said there was no legal basis for line drawing with an exclusive tocus. on race and ethnicity. David Correa clarified that he was not saying that he wanted to have only minority elected officials, but he did want the Commission Districts to be drawn in such a way as to allow for that potential. Mr. Mohlke emphasized that minorities have a smaller percentage of registered voting age population. He believes that they should not be disadvantaged by mixing the minority population with other populations that have an older age and more voters. He said that Frank Rodriguez would also address this topic. David Correa stated that he would like for Mike Carr, Chairman of the Collier County Republican Party, to share his comments with the HAAB on this topic. Mr. Mohlke presented a spreadsheet (attached) regarding the total registered voters per district and a breakdown by ethnicity and race. The figures presented related to population percentages and minority groups and numbers of registered voters and the percentages of total population made up of registered voters in the Commission Districts. He emphasized again that District 5 has a younger than average population and many of them under voting age. There are alsO"a number of voting age adults who are not naturalized U.S. citizens. He felt that there would be a disproportionate impact to include the North Naples' gated communities in District 5. He repeated that this had been exhibited by the results in the 1992 and 1996 commission elections. Tim Durham emphasized that statI is inviting comments and contact by the public before the November 13th County Commission redistricting decision. Michael lUrk, representing the Collier County Public Schools, stated that he had been working with County staff on the redistricting effort and that the School Board Policy is to seek to have the same school district boundaries as the boundaries for the County Commission District. Frank Rodriguez introduced himself as President of Vision Inc. which features Hispanic TV programming. He said that he is familiar with the census information and seeks to have more Hispanic representation in government. He mentioned that there had been a dramatic increase in the Hispanic population in Collier County. Many are not U.S. citizens and cannot vote even though they contribute to the community. He mentioned that in reviewing the maps he had a "Catch 22" concern over the lack of concentration of Hispanic voters. He thought that overall there had been a dilution of votes of Hispanics even though it was not the fault of anyone in particular. When there is such a dilution there is a Joss of ability to influence candidates. He said that he had been involved in voter registration etIorts for Hispanics and that the HAAB and the County Commission need to keep an eye on the concentration of Hispanics in the districts. He observed that the Hispanic population tends to be much younger and that he thought there was a need to get representatives of the Republican Party involved in this process. Sofia Pagan then had some discussion with Mr. Rodriguez about the Hispanic media in town and how the community can best be reached. Frank Loney said that he was happy to see the new redistricting information from staff, but that he wished he had more time to interpret the data. A discussion occurred about the logistics of having another meeting versus taking 4 - --_._--~----.- - ----~-- -- --,-~--~----"---- -."- formal action on this matter this evening. There was also a discussion about potential motions that could be made on this subject Frank Rodriguez observed that there was a concentration of Hispanic voters in District 3. Chuck MohJke suggested that three maps (1, 2 and 4) show District 5 to the East of County Road 951. Frank Loney repeated that he was concerned about the lack of early information. A discussion ensued about the different maps. Susan Calkins made a motion expressing a preference for Maps # I and #2 on the basis that the HAAB does not want the minority vote diluted. A motion also included a policy statement that District 5 should not go West of Collier Boulevard (County Road 951). The motion was seconded by Carlos Aviles. A 6 - 0 vote in favor of the motion occurred. The HAAB members thanked County Staff and Mr. Kirk for the presentation. IMMOKALEE CHECK CASHING Mr. John Norman explained that he had to get off to another meeting, but that he wanted to bave the Hispanic Board consider a potential solution to the cheek caShing tees problems for Hispanics in Immokalee. He suggested that perhaps the HAAB could persuade a business to cash checks for no charge if minimum purchase occurs. RESIGNATION OF MEMBER EUGENE GREENER Liaison Ramiro Maiialich passed out three documents relating to Mr. Greener's resignation. First, Mr. Greener's October 17, 2001 resignation letter. Liaison also distributed Mr. Greener's September 28, 2001 letter complaining about lack of notice and information of the meetings and a copy of Legal Assistant Kay Nell's Memorandum in response to Mr. Greener's complaints about lack of notice and information. Chairman Correa stated that it bas been his experience that Kay Nell has always provided fme notice for the meetings. FARMWORKERS' EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Liaison Ramiro MaiIa1ich passed out a draft of the Executive Sununary regarding the HAAB's decision to ask the County Commission to request dialogue between growers and farm workers in the Immokalee community. The Board members indicated that the Executive Summary should be presented to the County Commissioners as submitted by the Liaison. MR VALDES' REQUEST FOR AN AGENDA ITEM Mr. Vietor Valdes, Editor of Las Naciones News, requested time on the Board's next agenda for a variety of information regarding tbe activities of the Police Review Board which has been recently formed. The Chairman agreed to his request. 2002 ADVISORY BOARD REPORT The 2002 HAAB Report to the County Commission was deferred to a later agenda. 5 .~-,...__...- ...,,_._~._~-_..--^," --'.'~''''-'-'"- LATIN FESTIVAL. VOTER REGISTRATION David Correa reported that there had been an effort to register Hispanic voters at the Latin Music Festival. He said that approximately 60-70 voters registered and more than 100 applications were passed out. He said he was assisted in this matter by Mr. Pina and the Elections Office. HARVEST FOR HUMANITY AO(l<\j Carlos Aviles asked for Mr. NeJei to be placed on the agenda for November to discuss the Harvest for Humanity in the lmmokalee Hispanic Community. Mr. A viles said he would contact Mr. ~ to attend. . 110 0.' FRANK RODRIGUE~;iIISP ANlC BUSINESS Frank Rodriguez asked the HAAB for its support regarding a factory in Collier County that has a Code Enforcement Board hearing pending. He said that this rectory has many Hispanic employees. He said that the factory obtained approvals from the County for a new building off Airport Road. Neighbors complained and these approvals were withdrawn. He said he wants the Board of County Commissioners to support the original approval. He said that this business may have to move to Lee County and Hispanics cannot travel there and then will lose their jobs. He is asking the Hispanic Board to address a private business that has a major impact in the Hispanic Community (200 Hispanic families). Frank Loney asked what was the name of the company and when would it be before the Board of County Commissioners. Mr. Rodriguez stated that he did not know when the agenda items was corning before the County Commission and that the name of the business was called Gulf Coast American Blinds. He said that the business owners name is Carlos Diaz. Liaison Rarniro Maiialich stated that he would make no comments because he was aware that this item was being reviewed by the County Attorney's office. However, he stated that he thought this item was going before the County Commission at the second meeting of November. A discussion was held regarding options for action, future meetings or individual comments before the County Commission. David Correa mentioned that he was inclined to try to help in this situation, but he was not sure if the business had broken any rules. However, he recognized that sometimes Code Enforcement can abuse their powers. David Correa suggested having a special meeting with all parties involved. Liaison Ramiro Maiialich reviewed the HAAB's role under its ordinance. Mr. Valdes stated that this situation could be assisted by the HAAB. He said that he has had success before on these types of issues. Frank Rodriguez stated that he was merely asking the HAAB for support of the original approval and not for a judgment on the Code Enforcement Case. The HAAB decision was to set a special meeting prior to the County Commission meeting with regard to this Hispanic business. They would invite representatives of all parties concerned with the matter. 6 .------------- The meeting of the HAAB adjourned at approximately 9:25 p.m. Prepared by: Ranuro Maiialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison ?' ,il; n1 . Approved by the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board on this~. day of k.MJ , 200!. r. e ~. I t_ I' '/ ~ ,,\,,~./ 6.- ')'l.X-ct - David Correa, Chairman 7 _ _ _ ___._M._______.___u.__._._,~_,.~_,_ - ~-'.,'~- Rn6 RU~ RUE RUE . MAP #1 ~.~ ~~ ~-~ ~ , " ,I, . " . ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES - '( ... BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS _ _~" ~ ~ -" ::. ....S 1--_ COWER COUNTY. FLORIDA I!'" _.. - --,.- . -1----- -'- \'. ~.' :I ; . ,I, , _ I ." __ 'i ,~ ",'I' I ,( co,""," 1--: ' .' .'._,. "'Ij~_"_ "_~_~__'~~" ,:t:::--;;__'"__ ':....".-,.._~~~ . ,,- .1 ,. . "I, r .'" ... '. "', ~ .q.,,~, ;.,. :; .,'- . i-,-:::' .~: , . -,. -". _.. " ... i _."'-~ ~... ' ".._1 ' ...." -.. !____ , ,ilL! \ ~ I I' ", ,{ . 'J' " ::C(4 ' -'" . . .. .. '!' .''', .". -" -" .,. .." -- _ __ ~- a'. .-- ;1- ----t --J - I ~ ~- ~ , , ' ". . ,. . ..". ... -.. -"'1.'" .", .". .. -... I ,- ' -. - -----T ----f----J-- _-' 1:,' iL,-'r ., ':+,1., ." .L.- +- .}." , .. L.:.."~ I..". . "_" -' ...,1,.",." ."J ..", L. -", " -. -,. --:- ~--.-- : ~ '1' '. . ..U-' -. -:;:-:, .,..!.... ~I.-P.- .' ~ ,--~.-~ -".---' -'''1 ...'''.------+----.-+-~l.~ -~-- -:-~-=-~=- " . .. . .,.'.. . i.." 'i" ~.- .. .""j'.'. ,I I -, r ~- --- I . ,'Il""":". 1'- 5'" '" ,." -". . , ..~ --J' -~- .Ii~" ." ,-----. -- - -- I ----1--- <;] "",.;:- ~:: V. "" i" - .. - . "~I -. -.. " . _ ~ '\["" I II, .. --:' -~ ~'. r, 1---'--'1-'- ------- --.,... .- ~-J-- . : ~~Ii' 1---. .... ...,,, '-;, "" ,--~~-I' ~ 1'1 i. -' ~ ' . i . I' I -. . I' " ~."' J ..- l---I~ 1--1-- __ -I 'I -"... -.. ."". -". ' : 0 ~-II>:, ~' .1:'+,-: ~: t i' ,-~----~..~.Jr-~--~-:..;;T=-:..-..........--- . ~t 1 "-'" '-.., ..... "'-- - '- - '" -,,, ' ",,,.. ."" " ... <') T........~- -r-- - --I -1- __ _ v.. ." . ,1. I,', / M~ -lrJt- f-+- --t - _L .1---/-.. ., "'". __." --, . "I , J 'l~' I' , ., r ,I r ~ ~ . . " . . I I . -- ----- -. --- - -i- .... "I --,' .. -." "'''. """ ~ I . - .-- ~ . " " ., ! '" ~ H -V _L :s I L "" -"" <,', -." '..", .". H \ >'" J .'. "', - - -- ~ --= -~ ,..., \ ~'H'Y - - --::-J - -------1-1....., ."...,.-....".'.".. o II--,' '& ' - . "', . 0 'if,,~ ..".;., ,f' I. -f~ -- -- - ~-- I.'" '" -" -." .". ."" -'. . ~~ "" 'v- , I:: . --- " //__.>..\:\;"'~- -' !- s.~.---_____J":,:,'= .,.._,--,,,.,..,,. , . \\~:; Jtt. . j . llo;;. , . I .' -" -,. -", ' I I ::::,-~\l>1. -.-- - '-- - 1-...... ....... I -- i. '" .,. "" .- " . . . ~ . , .. , ..., ---'-" ,',ll.. . __ _-___ ."",."" .. "'= -- 'll',," 7 ....:-1 -- ," - '-------- -j, vrl.~~'VI;'.c ./'=1::'-:= . :'<. .. 't' , ,.1,,1 , -... I: /".'" 5,' .~I .~ -- -j" -- ----------\ (" '"T!,P i'" I)' ' -.,.,~, , . . V /( _,' \, r . _ _. _ ~,_._______~__,__, ,.__ .__ "-..... ~_ , i :::,.\' F - .\ ___.___ ~ -- -------::"l, ~ 11.,,,.. "'~\-I' , . p, ., . . . .)>.,' .. . '''I . \'.:; .. " --- --~'~-~-- : + '~\ ...... "< "':~. ;Z ". ... W g ,~ ,\. . ~ ' --~--- --- '''. ~~-., 'M\',:..g;, '1"1'" .. . ~~co ~_. ') _ 'IlL 1"r e....,. (".<:, _,~ . 6 '......0 I '. o. ~. I l'~~ ,.. . - - SC,oL( \. _ A.._ ',,/ ,-~~ . _ ~ I'~ . ------'=> r:::..-,-----r---,--.., ---:__'t:___"~;;__",-7__-'~ __.p5 ~I",,_--. ...._\..Lc. ~ . ,.. 1" JI'O, ..., 5 , n_1 ~1IIi!ji!~~ _ PRQPOSEDDISTRICTlINE .,.n,o' ,.........~.. ____ I DONNA FIAl.A DISTRICT- POPULATl4 " i! JAME5 D. CARTER Ph,D ----,,------ 49,840 3 - TOM HENNING ----'2 --"---- 50,758 4 - PAMElA 5. MAC"KIE __~_=-=___~~_._ 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. _..J:__._.____..i~~:L _ ""',...... <.......,..~ 0,"'""" "M' ._...__~,__. ...," 50,431 _ --- ""'"_P ",,_ ""...""'~ A'" n;o-w.;:... ...._. sgnOll sum 251.3n ccw_,,~ nf;vnOP.....' ANn f;N""OH~'....l S(H"tl:S al"SI<II< -- ~_,___. ~ O"'-'Ol.om ~", COM--O<S.-WAP-',O..../"I.O" w'pCAO,p",- -- -----------.------,-.----------- -,--~-, RUE AH~ Ri7& RUE . MAP #2 ~~T: -:---:-~I',. . . _ . : ~ ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES - -.--. , ~. ... BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS -~ - -'--f~ ~ -~~~, :"'_: _\__" _ . ~ CDLUER COUNTY, Pl..DRIDA . " " ~ i: . . ,..,.. _.. - ". ...- ., - . ---..--.1--, ""'.. -'- ~ if" :I . . ,I, .' 'i " ~.J s i1 \\ lEECIIIlNfY '.. _ ~_ .. ...... ...... ,',' , ,1'1. " 'II' I't' "_~' . ~ -'-"" -- -- .", --f:::. . - -' ,.t.. -, -I. -- . ,. - -- -- ~,,,.....-- "" -=-- -. --- - -- ",e=.- .. " "1"1"':1' . ,,0"'_'''' . '. , = "" ::)_____ -i --_."--- _..- -'-'~_."_.- --- '--I -... ....'n ,'~'~ . =.. ,...... , I, 'I'" ~ 0'" .,. . , ' .,," . t- ----,,: - Ilu_ . ,. ,. I " I .~... _'M '. ,j -: ." "l~il' .",' I . I,' 1 f~"";' ... ." ."1....,, ."....:... -- . -- --:, ;- ,'1--- ,-- --I -- -- -- ---.---- . -:-:- '_"", " . I I. . . ....0....".'-0...".'.. '"--1 . ="".. -f'~- -+-- -I ~ ""~' ',' ,7,' -' ... . '1"" "". "'" ." ." .,. "'. .. .. -- --,: I ---- --" -j~-- ~ --- ~'I I - . ' ' ,! ,. ... . ~,"",."..I." 1-' ""', .' .,"... - i--+- . --- . .~" -l"~E r,.=.,::'':-:' ," . ""', .. , ....""' .". ."- .,... t. \' . . ,! + : . - R. "", f . .'''['n -- -- +- -"F" ..... ~" " J.' "I"!-., ',...,," '-1""" . I.'! '. %.-J . _ --I" ---' --."": :." : - --1--' I' . . "'" ... " . . \J t.1 ~ . -'" .,.I<:,'"J" 0"'1 I" . "t~~~~.i -. ""'. ,-- 'I ;:::: iY' 1 I . ~~I-, 7--+'--'--- - .-- - . !' . '- - I' ~!' p" ':0 " "'" ~; , i. . .. '. ~'-- -. '-... I = ' --.. " . , .., '75 II ~~. ".. "" -'.1'1'1" "" . " ---- ,.,.. 1'.J . , .,,,.' "'''. _m ."" "~"~R)'> I' . -'-L--'--:'- --.------- . ': ~_ ,,~- 1'+' r: "+_.~ ~_.:...! -..,"'" .,", ' -'''. ",,,,.' o 0 ,n " . I -. . . I ,--.- . I r 'I"". 1St . '-., - t- . . ~- - - '.--- - f--i-- ~ '" .".. . .... "'".' ~~{I ~I'" 'i '. ,', ' --1--- -- \ r- - - -. - - ." " -," . " -... ' ~ . . \.'" ,,! --, -- - --_.,-- > JJ IT-I~' - - - ' "':""""j . - . ",,- ~'l -,,, _"-, "-_-"'1." "" '~: ' , . ", ", 1 -- -, - _..1.._ '" \~,,~ ~d-I-~ "'" 1+- - +--.--- -,-~J... ."'" d .'". . -'e:: H '~:Jl t "',,-' " fll' cO, \ \ ~\ - I --- ,--.: '---, -- __~ ,__ ,."" '" .".. -'" ",,,. .". "'". (') S.\ . I ""'" . 0 't::";?::- .1. -__. ",,,..,,, .""'''''.'''.'''",,,. iii \S:\ }"S;--- .: .. ......-.. .. -..- -- ---" --"-~ . \ ,,-: __ I ---~llo.'- "\. .,,, '" ""-",,... .""'.'" "'". ,~I"~I' , , ,I, ~., " , - l 1 ..... ",,- "" .'".... -- "''''' ' ~ "0 ;.~ - -., .., -- ,-." ..~.....,.. c,?, _",'" __ .."..lllo.. . . ,_ .~'" .,,, . . , 4.'~ v:: " , I " "co . '-< . , .'" . , " h-'c ""llJIZi!, I":> l,-rl-, +F' I-- ,-.-- 0~l f"PY!' Ii/ref /, I,' . . ,,' , . 1"">-, f V \"'I.\f"o."--i.;;j rei ---.--~~ I - --. . . . . , ,(. ", ' ,lJ, ' " . , , , '. . : +' "V~~,';\ ~ ,,; ''''It'J-,/ _.____g.___L_,. ...l."'-_1.-' . -,' . ~~' / "A' " . \\ _ - /" \1"-" //.. .. I- W E ,,\'i[. '. 1 \ .:-:; , ..-- ::' / ~ ->D,",:' ~90 "'- Il ~ ..' ..~. 'r-\" ~ ":,,,.,1J~J.~J.~0< , ~~~L:::tL /. .:]1:<1'-L - r- ,.. '~I ~... ---~ E.-;O"~'" - '~f.L_ ~ ~--_.- __,"If~-1!D_ _ PROPOSED DISTRICT liNE .....lIlC. ""............. I DONNA FIAI.A DISTRICT -POPUlATION " i! JAMES D. CARTER Ph. D '--"--"-48.840 3 - TOM HENNING ----~-------5ii;759 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KIE ---:---3-__ --- ~8.313 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. ---"4------520S4- 5---~ ~------so431 . _ ,..ICA'" O,......".~ ""..OT w.. --iu~---.--~i.3fj--- ~=~\'.,'~~~~:'i<",~ ~~-',.\r."i'.:',~l~rD~"'slON _~___.___ _ __ O."','O/lOO' ,.u'O""-OIS'-~...-l.D""/I'lCT,""'OCl<l.P.... --..--.--.--..----.---- ~,--- ..,-_.~-----._--- AilSE Ri!filii RZ7E RaS. . MAP #3 --:I~ . r:-' . .... l . . I ' : COMMISSION DISTRICT lINES- '-~'. .. r. . _.. _.. \ ,. " .~ BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIDNERS 1-" __ __ ...... COlUER COUNTY. f'I.ORIDA , 11" ~ - ~ , 1 0-... _., - --~ --,.. -- --- -'- -- 1\ i ., ,f . I . ..! . \' ~~ ; / \\ tEE COUNTY -" L-__ ,', 1,7. I. I 1 I {;'" -- ...--< I . I/'. .. ~ . . I' ." .... .... - .. . -.. .... III ~~-':':'----'-:I" --:: ,,-~- "-,- --- :.- ~--- ,,_ ---- ,. i .- ~ '---"'-2-1--it---.. ---I -. , ...... . i ..... +" ~ . . ~. . " "," " . I ...,.. .. ",......- -- , I I I I .. .. . 'I"' ,. ". ,.,," ," " .' ....'" '"",,, ...... ...." -.. -" -... I '"~=, ,': ~ :'~.;;.:.' l~~i' -'1 .,,, -, :~-~C:" ...' .-.T'- I /11' 1. _ ~':-" '-" "~I~j .." -" -" -.. .., -" -: -- , ,\. f-- ---. ----- "" ... ..1.. .,oj' ~':J" .,. .,,! -. ... -"I.". .._ __~. ... "'~1 . -- .. -- ...... ~. 'n._"._ . ,... II .."." ,,,,,,,..., 0"" ...... _... . ....' -------r--- \--- : _~ ~ - _: -",. . :-.... .. ,__":"':"~' -.. .,. '1_. ", .' .... ,. I ' . ,.".... I --I ""1 :1 i" ", '- :. ~~~ .... -.1-------5~ -"-~.. .. -..... .. .. 'j c;] I ... .. . -'"'' - 1./, '. ..I --I--- :: . -.... ..., . l--':'" ,'-" I' , . '. ... -. ... r:: r 1 1--- 1 ..' '" . . 1-- '-. '-'" - _ _ _ __ ~ .. "'-~I'1 h. ,. ,,' .i". ..,. .' '''-- I '- . =. ~ -,' . .. ... ." on . 12:> i.. -~.. . i . \. ".,,' . ~. .. I'm. . F _n.,! --.-1.-, .L.' '. .... ~.'."~ "'.'''' ..'" ....1 -", '\0, 1 ' . '!. ., .1--'1 ..1 -. 1---- ---- -- -.... . I' Ie-x. ...'--, r-i_L":"'~"-i" " .".. ". '''- ' .,,,. -". . . 0 ..,,~ .i, . i. . . . .. .1.. I. '-:-1--- --- --1------ . '-.. ' . - ....f---:. , : 1-.... "...,,' -... -,.. " . '" '-:mJ "" ' ., ,,-. ". .." "ff'I'-:-' -.j-------- .--- f;;]i 1- r". -- ' ..- - "J...:L ...... " .... --:"':.'"'''' -'__ \,.. .... ,,' . .. 1 .- ~ \U-YI-'~- .1.'-'1". -#.....::11...=.,,1.,," " ----=.. .... ;:S:: "'" .,. . r '<i.;, J I, . . I' --- '" 'v;;, 1-'; ,- '_I." --___ "--,,-+-"-. .,,,. ,.' -,.' "-...-.. H " "', ..... -. --. . - ~. \ 1--41(1' -- - ... I I -- :I:--'-+-':'" .n" " .".. -.. ..'" -.. -. ... (') I~'''~ J -- . 0 ' ~" ~-.j'/1-- _ I~_ 1._ --' .:..' , ..-... .". -," -- -- .... _ \'" 1~/. I,' '- --1-- -... .. ---- .n._ III ~\", . ; . . - ~ . ,~ _+_ I _ _ . --ll.. _ _ --'- ... " -.. -.. ...., .,,':,.= \\\~~ ':s: p;" 1-" ~..... '" "'. ..... -." ..,.1 ' '\:\\- - -- .......... .~.... ... ...,- ....---- Iii ..'V)"r. """;1" " , .,...., . " ." . . \,\ ,~- ~\- ~4 ,,- ...~ i....,m -"~ _. " , I ~7-' \..., L \ 1 - -j--+-.---.- r ~f'l '. VI ~~a';~ ! _... ':_--f;:-d _ . -....J ~ '. ~ ---- . ,\[~. :~'\::..~:i~~' .~ 1-:. [L" . '---'1 _oIlT.', ~J .. : + \ \ ' = ." 1,./, "j" .. . --. . w , \: ,- ..' 0::: i:". ,412..---1--. ~. "( I' (I"'?- ""'~" ",., I. , , ~ffl ~ " ~ :;::;g H . -- '" J(" r~_ ~......... , . J- '.'N' . -.: .J;..,l. ;I;..!..i';~ '} "'}'\,'" ~\.--, Ilr!1 _) k .. -. r.=...-=r:::--+ ~r:=::-~ --___L _ ,~~ v'--'-~- ,'___.-,,_~.'--'-'> _., ".:.J_ p..,. .' ._ o lU1 "0' ,." ... - ~. 5 UlilENg _ _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE I>I",.:T co............ _____ I DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATlON 2 JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D :i - TOM HENNING --Y'-- - 50.473- 4 - PAMELA 5. MAC'KIE -3- ~-- - 50.375- !i - JAMES N. COlETTA. Jr.,4-----~-~-----50,34-1"--- _ ,."'..... coo........... ,"TO>I:t u.o --==-__~--::-' =~...:_ __' __..~,043 .O(p"ro a,. ""....C$ _ !(CffiiC..... SUf'!'OIIT S~C'IlOI< sum .0(1;11.3 <;('><IOU"'" DtV!;LCf''''E~T "'0 t~"'IIO""t:~T". Sf."'''S 0."""'" ____. ___= o"r, >00<>0' F1t[,C""'_O'!;l_~""-J,O""("'-OT,,"Hrx...,."'- . .~ .~--~-,.._-_. -.....- A~5~ Aa55 R~7Q AU_ ~ COMMISSI=A:S~ICT LINES qi~.T;:r-r~~~.I"\: I:. :- BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS __ __I ...'., ___' ___. _~ COWER CQUNTY. FUtRtDA , i "- ~ n . . ...,..:~ --- "f" . - --.----. - -- --- --;::: . -- --- \'..' ~ i d .; , ' ,I, . ..( ". \' ~~ 'I /1 ~ _ L~ClJllNn '_~_ ,". """:':_. - ~__ ,J-' Ii, ", -1:-1:..\.-- _[ _ _b~ I-:'-~'.:i= ~:' -:e=--'-,-:_-:" . ,; ~ ,'. [, .: L '," +' .,,, ... . I ' .'".-- '" i ". : \tr'~~. ~,- ....--:-1. --1 :i -:', ,,=1 ,:;,;:: ,.... .,,,, I, . ~ -." i"::". . - . ~ ~"-" -~ ""- ...... """.. ~" ~ . . I" ""1' .t" I' " . I., -". ...." -" -" .'" .", .", - --- - -, ,.,:,::,1-- -H. -!- ---" \". ,.'.. ." I. ,." I, ."'1 ::T=I-" -'" .". .". ' . . " ..' ,-""--, -f--- -- ------'- --,,-- --- I'{',,' '. ,\"1.,, '""""i..",..r"",-...."-,...."..... . I 'I '~dcc.' " -- - -- . :u ---- --.- =". -; I~'a' -. ." .... ." ..". ..,,, ... -. .:. .,. -.i-H-L - . -- - . . --- .- -1." " .. I -, "" ""M ...', ...,,, ,~".. .....n. . .... " - !;t- -.-] -~ .". - .". - - +-- -- --- -:.. ---- -,,-:'- ....~ ':'". . , . ,.'.1 .. ',' ... I' ..c-" f"""" ';. I ..( ." .,,---, -- I ~ i:<>.D ~ _ " ~ " I ~__ ___ _, .~~~ ...... ______ ____ ,_ +-~_ _ "_j ~ M, r-.. ,...1".. ..,. ..,,, i:, 'I,,' . .... . ;T I . ",,'1 ".. .... 1--- ;:/ L -.. .."~ ,"-_ -_ _ _: . .. _ .... ~ \Y 1 I I -~.' - - ---.--.-- t-.. ~ .. : I' ~,. I' I ,,-.. ~"'''.' -. ."... -- -- '-- ,'= '.., .' . . . ..,., -'1-6 r ..... "'. ~I ~l ,.,' . [" ~~P'($ ....- ~~, 1- ~ - -- "- - - ...'.. ':' ....... ,..,." ...',,, _' ~ ~I . 1'~" T':. .:. r. t I I --+- - I lit I _.. \f--li-";\.: :~~ I - - ~ -~-r~- _. _.OJ:' ,~,... ' ...,n. ...,... " . ~ .0 ,\01! .. .' I 1"4: -'- om' j . i' '1."" '" ."..' .-- .".. "~ .... --.".., ,.,... - - --- - -,,--- --.------- . . - I. " '. I ~{ -Ir\ - ~- - -- - -.-'- . -'--+. -.. C':l.~"."'" . .".. '. ~"\). . 1\;' .. I --- -- ,1---1 '= :.J. - 1- - '~t;;J'2 - . _L' ----:- 1 '- ."- "I ,.'" ---- - ..:_ -,. .". """ ,.' _.' "" I . - -: ,.. ----- "" '7r!,. .:LI... -- _ 1._ . .~_ """ ~'1 .". _'__ . .'" ... N 't~I'Pj)., "-. .-- --'-1---- ----~ - \'IC,~.,;11 - - 11 ."" - ."" ..-. ...1.,.. .'''' :=; \~~" ,-- - 1- --'" +--- o ~~" "'~H~' -.:.. ./[ -r......... "". '" .. .".. .". -~ ... III 'i1~'::'-' )/ ~ -"'IlIII, - --------- --__ _ : r" "./ '-1"-' - ....'.. .... '" t'" .". -... .'- .". \~~J~'lJo: " ,~ ---+ ~l--:\l&-' --- I . ~.--:-.____ ."j'" ..- "". -- ."" . \~\~~'11: o:-;fi -,,-. : -~ .~. ~ L-.- ."" .""t. . 7' 1 - -~~::==: -- ______ __ '~tJ~.'~. ""'....\} ~"C-.'.' ." ;'-:: . " .. . . " , . "'~[' "'\'r .1;',-"'1,1, )- '-- -".:..-- --. . ( .Iif .,), !.v'. . ' ' ' . . , --,.., -..: ' . . /" v": __ ____). ...------~~. [.' . 't-, :>!;.. . . . . .".. . .. .. .". . ' ,,'<<:t/ &.\''.. -~, /fi -I. - -- ... ,~.. ~ + \\ .~..., ". "K. . ~t. , . . ,.. W t ,,' . \ ,:.7,) '-::;, . .-1---., .-- ;~. / .. .01" .:~ -,'" . "'.}) .~ 'r" 1- """ \- )\;;-i.' . -- h ,..,-":"~ . ~AA' '~~'Tc~)::,,::\_::'"G;~::HIr' "5 f ' ." '_ a '.. ,.. .)Ot ..... VE s I _!-Iil'!!i~~_ --.--- _ PROPOSED DI9TRICTUNE ~tOl."" ........."'Nf. =0.- I DONNA -FIALA DISTRICT POPULAno~ ii! JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D 1-- 50,229 =:I 1 - TOM HENNING 2 "9."82 4 - PAMELA 5. MAC'KIE -"3-------------50,8&4.- S - JAMES N. COLETTA. Jr. --------.--------50~:_ --S---------------eo431 - _ 1M.'''''''' ,..........M ",,,..,. ".., ----....-- -----.--~D.. .,......~_<'AA'"'~...'"..,"''',O~ sum ~1.377 ",".",...... Or"':l~"' .u<. [N""'~,,'''' Sf"...CU 0......01< __-~_ ---- '~";"~/_' r.~, ''"'_015'_''''''_'0''''/'''-0'.. .".0<'"",.... --..-- .---- - -_.. R~& A~~& RUE RU' . MAP#5.--I. .. " '" '-'" " ' : COMMISSION DISTRICT L1NES':- -: -:-" " "_" ..,. \" " ~. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS . .._ __ __ __ __ _ ....., _ COW"R COUNTY. Fl.ORIDA . . , ~ i:' . _........ ....... . . . _...1 1----.-- ,~ -.-. ,iO..' II ;I "'-1' . .1. _'..,._~.. ~_: 'I 117 '., lEECQUNfY -~t-- ,,) ---- .j ';;(['1 .I'_L,.I.I [.. 'i-'--'~j'" ----..,'.....-.' , ,\ lr~- - '-1" -~-+ i ,.=...., "." ." ! . J .:- "..: ". """. I" ...., -. ..,,, .,. ! ~ . -:f. - - 1 n_____ -- __'.__~_- ---, ~"l ' _ . '?~. ......' .'-i' .. ,. I. .. "..,,,I ,-- ", . .'. _. ..,,' . '" . ,,'. "I.. - 'j . . . .,,' ,,".. ~----I I ___I _, ,., ~ . . I "..... . .,! I. , ' ." -- .." .'" ..'" ..,,, ..". ..", .'~ :~~, --, ~ R-~ --- I~_'---.-;-~ --~---::;~~~::~,~t-=" ":J~I= -=- --:---1 .. I " ',=~;"I" L--. -.----- '-'~I_ --'- ---~ .I. .' . 'IE7.:'..." ,," .... I." ."" -.. ..." .'" -:l.... -"'..'" , . ;-- 1'_.1 ' -- __I ,.- ---', .. .". \. . . .. .. I, _" . 7. :J"." .." ,"" ".. .'" "",..,.." " .... -"'I -- .- - , - 'I" ", . -1 r-+- \--- --~-- . . ~.'''; , , "u... -" -" ... .."... It... ""'-'1"-- :,- ..'" - : ''''If .. ..." -- - --f-:'+':' _e:::." ~_' .. . (' ,rl-i.1 "."'1"" -c' "'''I. ,'., .'1..," .", , :-i. ~ - -, - -'7""' -""---'--1- --5-' ~ --- "" "j" r-.. .I '" . ,..,,,,,,,, , . I I" , ..., - - "f.J - . ...._ ,. m ~ ell '".. """ -'" !':: ... , I ~ -.. ! -- -, i . - ~ - .:. "- -- --->-"- ~ ~,:~ I' ~ ,. .. , , . I";: "I" "' .. "" .'''.. '--,. 'I' 'Q .. .,,' ~. .. '" .-~ "'" , 7'--1 r!!' ,-'.'--" ,;' --",,~' "" t......' '.- - - I d' I ..,.~' ..... ..".. ..".. . .-,,, ',., . I --.-- - - +-- -----1-.- - - " '-h.~ "!_l:_--.: _.t: ..-___~_~__-_~_....~.-::: -...~-"....'''._ Q 0 "I ~,0 -! \.. I ' I ". I ' I - - - ~+- . c . IT' ,.:..-,. .. .. --" I: ." .,. '" "". . ,.". -.. "' . ~ I PO'r'\," ,--- --.- - - 1-- . "...!;i.. .. Vi '",.. "", I" ,- . ","" --" ~r -.1f"" "-,: . . ,-: ~-"--: r:.:" '" "..,. .. ---- ~:: '--'-- ! I -'\ ." .. -I - .."/-"_ :.~'"'- "'I.'"'" . I .. .'".'" ::::: k~ ." I ' , ,,, I- "I" , -: T' - - - -- '" \:8' -;c,-"c1 -"- ----- - -- _':-+___" """ "., ..." ".". ..". H ,,'J-P.J'"' r-.. .' .. , - --' -.e-- -- 1--- - ,.,. ~. -,~,d!.1 ---. - --~... .. ---'--_'n ."" '" ."" .". -." -- ..,", ~ \"..\ ,7f. --__ . . " ~': i.,,~.;. ',/,,' . . . . . 0 .,,:' ",'c~' i'- '-' -- - ---" ,- ~ ~- "1-'" '" .." ... ..." .... -'" iii \~,:-h.1\.. ~~.:- . ;;" I. j " -.- ~- . \';:.';;" '~-~~" -- '. -t' - ~ . . -. S .." ..' ----- ."" '" I"" -'" .."" -'" ."" "':\c"r"~'\')- , , . \ "'. ~~, - - -- - - ~ miL ,tA- ,_ __ _ ....." .."'" ,.n ."., ..". ..,", " \'\,'Xr'- ....\r _~:J -~ ,.--- \~(I~\!:..<'(,. !' cc-i.... '" ' , . . '" . ~ ~ u=:.= _.. .'" . . 1 ,r 1---' ""'--:--" -1--- - - - i~f:: -fi ~rjti, /,\" '. -" .... .. ::,":,.:'<. "" "" '_J-~~:;:( _ b"i./' IS \ - --- -- ,,!". ," '..') , '. ( ~'" " . ."~.f'''-. c" -,.. '- . ['1-( "':2-~.'~ ~".-" -it- ---I~ ." ..-l-,-~ . "",~ ~J-~*~ .r~ ' ,,' ~ -. .--1 "'--- : \ \ ~- \.._~,,\ rt~l f. .' ". "--- ,- ..... w F. \, \ ',)! ~q:,.... ~A --.---- + ;~..\ 1 ~i 1,,0i ,.- ~ ~i; ;;;;;-,(J4 ".. -' ""0 I . f"\ 'j -' W'- -! -- - ~ '....'" I . ~ \ --, c n -::.Yfi -f:S\ I. _ ,,) . J ~~'=;;=,. \ ~~1 ~ I~~L- ~7 I \-i.. sjl~_-~ ~ ""~ - ------ ------ _~_!~.ND _ PROPOSED DISlRICT UNE -- - ...'",e! ,............. ______ ___"_ I DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATlJ ii! JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D ----1--- ---------51:511---- :I - TOM HENNING 2. -- --..,m-- 4 - PAMELA 5. MAC'KIE ---3-------- 49,518 5 - .JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. ____~~-----m-- ._50.2i:i9 _ 'H"".flS co......".. OIor..., "Hf t~::"-== 5--- - ---=--=--=-~~_ - - "",p,,~,C "'" <;''''''..,," A~O ,,0"'"0<1. SlJPPOll' ~[cnOl< ._______~_ .!~-s~n ____ _ 251,,,,, ~~:':;O;::;'og,t\1\';;'ltN~:..~~:~':,'.:;_l~".,~~...e;',,~;:;.p"'_ ,,"-" ----.,,-------_.~.-~ I . , I . .. . . - - . . . :.. . . - . . . . " . :.."", .:;:"'11,: "",~k:;;:..:.:Il;:::,' <GE_~-':~.;'~"~ --~ ." .' - "'_ ~:-:'-":::-=:.~ . .A' ,..,.,:--,:--.:.., . -'., . - -"'~.::;~;~.-...-' -^- . . .- II DRAFT DRAFT Table of Contents Paae Introduction............. ........ ....... ..... ....... ......... ... ...................._..............:..... 2 Redistricting Criteria..... -.......................... ..................... ............ ... ...... ...... 2 Methodology................. ........-..................................... ......... ..................... 3 Pre-clearance Data.............................................................. ................... .... 3 Features... .........--................... ..................... ................................. ............. 4 Strengths... ............................................ ........................... --.... .................. 5 Critique.. ................... ................ ........ ..................... ... .............. ........... ....... 6 Retrogression Analysis............ .................... ..--. ............ ....... ........ .............. 7 . Exhibits 2000 Census Tract Map 2000 Census Tract Population Retrogression Analysis Map of Existing Districts Proposed Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 Genel\ll Descriptions of Districts for Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 1 -- --......-------.--. -----,. DRAFT DRAFT Introduction Collier County has experienced extraordinary growth since the establishment of the present Board of County Commissioner (BCe) Districts In 1995, when the permanent population was 182,823. The present population of Collier County is 251,377, according to the 2000 Census. As one might expect, this increase in population was not uniform throughout each district (see Table below). BCC District Population in 2000 Ideal Population Deviation District 1 49,840 50,275 - 0.8% District 2 47,164 50,275 - 6.1% District 3 57,712 50,275 + 14.7% District 4 40,662 50,275 - 19.1% District 5 55,999 50,275 + 11.3% Total 251,377 Source: Figures extracted fium U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (PubHc law 9+171). As a result of the uneven growth in Collier County, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners directed staff on June 26, 2001 to redraw the commission districts in order to comply with the one-person one-vote constitutional mandate. The Board of County Commissioners specifically approved the following redistricting criteria: (1) The population of each district should be as similar as possible; (2) All districts should be as compact and regularly shaped as feasible; and (3) The incumbent Commissioner's residence must remain in his or her current district. Additionally, though not speCifically directed by the BCC, there are additional considerations of a legal nature that must also be taken into account. This report contains a summation of the five (5) proposed plans. Redistrictina Criteria Each of the five plans attempts to balance the follOWing redistricting criteria: . Create districts that do not exceed a 5% deviation from the ideal district population. . Create compact and contiguous districts that observe well-defined and easily recognizable boundaries. . Protect incumbent commissioners by building each district around the residency of its commissioner. . Minimize disruption to former districts. . Avoid retrogression of minority voting strength. . Maintain communities of interest. . Devise plans whereby uniformity can be achieved between the School Board and the Board of County Commissioners. 2 -- - ~-~-_._._,.~-- --,_." DRAFT DRAFT Methodoloav The first step in creation of all five proposed maps was to plot the residency of each commissioner on the 2000 Census Tract Map for Collier County. The next step was to build each district by incorporating those Census Tracts adjacent to the place of residency, to the extent possible and practical. (See attached Exhibits, 2000 Census Tract Map and Tract Population.) Examole: Commissioner Carter, representing District 2, resides in Pelican Bay which lies within Census Tract 102.04. Given his place of residency, the place of residency of the other four Commissioners, and the existing boundaries of District 2, it was only natural that Census Tracts 101.01, 101.02, 101.03, 101.04 and 102.05 be incorporated into his district. Generally, this same process was repeated for all five districts on all five proposed maps. The next step, which was the most challenging, involved expanding or retracting each district as necessary to achieve relative equity in population, while at the same time creating compact and contiguous districts with well-defined boundaries that did not split voting blocks or neighborhoods. Concurrency with the District School Board was another important element that was considered. This was achieved by plotting the residency of each School Board member to ensure that no two members resided in the same district. Collier County is a covered jurisdiction under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Asa covered jurisdiction, Collier County must obtain pre-clearance before enforcing any redistricting plan. In order to obtain pre-clearance from the U.S. Deparbnent of Justice, the County must demonstrate that the new plan does not result in the retrogression of minority voting strength. This is ascertained by comparing minority voting strength, as measured by voting age population, under the existing and newly adopted plan (before and after comparison for all five proposed maps). pre-clearance District 5 has the greatest minority population in Collier County (See Table 1, below). Although it does not qualify as a minority--majority district at this time, It is the district that warrants the dosest scrutiny fer possible retrogression of minority voting strength. As District 5 is presentiy configured, it has a total voting age population of 39,440, based on the 2000 Census. Of this total voting age population, 2,875 are identified as Black and 14,242 are identified as Hispanic. This means that in District 5, as it is presentiy configured, Blacks make up 7.3% of the voting age population and Hispanics make up 36.1% of the voting age population (See Table 1). [It is important to note that "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity.] 3 -- - - -- ---_."~-~_._-,--_._.,-~_. DRAFT DRAFT Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population by District Present Configuration District Total Black Hispanic {All} 1 43,038 1,036 (2.4%) 5,141 (11.9%) 2 40,401 2'57 (0.6%) 2,249 (5.5%) 3 44,153 1,811 (4.1%) 8,238 (18.6%) 4 34,404 1,333 (3.8%) 3,685 (10.7%) 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Total 2.01,436 7,312. (3.6%) 33,555 (16.6%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). ANALYSIS OF EACH OF THE PROPOSED MAPS Features MAP #1 District 1 remains the same. Collier Boulevard Is the main feature as it fonns the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area. MAP #2 District 1 remains the same. Collier Boulevard is the main feature as it fonns the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 In the greater Naples area. MAP #3 Most of the population in the coastal area south of US-41 is included in District 1. Portions of the Uvingston Road corridor fonn a north-south line parallel to Collier Boulevard. MAP #4 The main feature of this plan is the elongated shape of District 3 - extending from the Lee County line to below Davis Boulevard, and from 1-75 and the Uvingston Road corridor to Collier Boulevard. Also, Coilier Boulevard fonns the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 In the greater Naples area. 4 -,~_._--~------~ ..._-~ DRAFT DRAFT MAP #5 Districts 1 and 5 are nearly identical in configuration to their existing boundaries. Districts 2, 3 and 4, while maintaining their core Census Tracts and most of their existing boundaries, are now neatly realigned along the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Uvingston Road. This north-south alignment, parallel to Collier Boulevard, is the distinguishing feature of this plan. StrenGths All five plans accomplish the Board's directives regarding population equity and respecting the residency of each commissioner. All five plans accomplish the Board's directive regarding the creation of compact districts with regularly shaped boundaries, though to varying degrees. MAP #1 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd. - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #2 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd. - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #3 Of the five proposed maps, the population is most evenly distributed on this map. This map shifts the communities of Everglades Oty, Plantation Island and Chokoloskee from District 5 into District 1 - these three communities have some characteristics similar to Goodland which also lies in District 1. All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #4 All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #5 By using the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Uvingston Road as a major boundary, this plan creates highly compact and geometrically neat districts with well-defined and well-recognized boundaries that follow major features. The Uvingston Road Plan avoids dividing neighborhoods, utilizing minor features and creating numerous irregular boundaries. At the same time, the boundaries of the current districts were respected where practicable: All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. 5 -- - -_._.._..__.....__._~~.. -_._- _._..,-",--_.- DRAFT DRAFT Critiaue MAP #1 There are several jogs and tums in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Distlicts 4-3. The common boundary between Districts 4-3 runs through Coconut Creek and Coconut Grove neighborhoods dividing each between two different Commission Districts. MAP #2 There are a few jogs and turns in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Districts 4-3. The deviation between highest and lowest District population is the greatest on this map out of all five maps. MAP #3 This map shifts the communities of Everglades City, Plantation Island and QlOkoloskee from District 5 into District 1. Arguably, the character of these communities is dissimilar to many of the developments in District 1, e.g. Marco Island and Lely Resort Also, at least in recent history, those three coastal communities have been located within District 5. MAP #4 The common boundary between Districts 3-1 contains several jogs; some of these do not follow recognizable features, e.g. the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, and the east side of Wing South Airstrip. MAP #5 Arguably, that portion of Census Tract 112.01 east of 1-75 has evolved into developments substantially different in character from the rest of the proposed district. This is a legitimate concern, and communities of interest were considered in devising this plan. However, it should be noted that no district is perfectly homogeneous, nor is it dear that strict class or ethnic/raclai segregation is wise or desirable in a community as diverse as ours. In addition, District 5, as it is presently configured, includes all of Census Tract 112.01. This plan shifts to District 2 that portion of Census Tract 112.01 west of 1-75 Retroaression AnalYsis As noted earlier in this report, only District 5 warrants a retrogression analysis as it has, by far, the largest minolity population. In the present District 5, the Black population complises 7.3% of the voting age population, and the Hispanic population complises 36.1% of the voting age population. As indicated in the attached Exhibit A-3, Retrogression Analysis, all five proposed maps result in an increase in these minority populations in District 5; conversely, none of the five proposed maps resuit in a retrogression of minolity voting strength. Redistricting Report ORAFT1 F. Redistricting TOfdw Oct 2001 6 - -.- --~.. -.---.-.--- - - -~- -~ -~ " 0>'" ", COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ,I , 2000 CENSUS TRACTS 11. , : 114 -, ~ ~ '"~ -- ~- 0' :; -- '. -- I I ! , 10101 101.02 ~- 112.01 - ..- ------- 101.03 112.02 -- I , 1.01.14 ~ I:;; ,.....05 1004.12 I .-- , :<f' ~ 1lM.1J7 i : --....... 102.04 - .. ~..-...- 103 , 3.01 4 2 1Gol.13 3JJ2 .-. Cl71'OP - .. N.U'LBS ......'-.."'-,.. ........_.".'s 7 ,...01 ! ,..... . 107.01 ~ '" \. 0 111.02 ) Cl71'OP r .....,,=<ND ______ 11. 1 ~.~ I ,,"" I 0 ,~. "". I II ll'<:END II E'3 ! "''''''''''' i - PRe'AAED 9'1': ~AAI'HlCS AHO l'ECHtIICAl.. SUPPORT s:e:Cl'lCfO ~ i COMNUHIT"l'CE\<UOP!oIENTAHDEHvRlHIICfT.-tSER'oICESOI\llSIQ" , > [lATE: ~/2001 AlE: CEHlR-A,--2OOll.DWG I - -----_._--~._.....,,- ~._._.._- --~~_.~~,.~_..............'" ._-~----_." ,.".. April 1. 2000 Permanent Population Collier County Flonda 2000 Census Tract 2000 Total Population 1 3~lS49 2 2.199 3.01 3.532 3.02 1.631 4 4,717 5 1,813 ~ 1,483 7 1,292 101.01 1\,802 101.02 3,542 101.03 6,337 101.04 7,194 102.02 8,106 102.03 5,283 102.IM 7,383 102.05 2,3SS 103 "-235 104.01 3,713 IIM.OS 5,802 IIM.O~ 7,007 IIM.07 6,92~ 104.08 3,1-47 104.09 ll.3SO 104.10 1\,469 104.11 1\,102 104.12 6,697 1IM.13 3,33~ . 104.14 6,6S~ 105.02 7,028 105.03 7,230 105.04 6,464 106.01 2,601 106.02 3,359 106.03 5,/i99 10~.04 3,157 107.01 4,807 107.02 4,1~2 108.01 3,8S7 108.02 6,~12 108.03 3,458 109.01 4,048 109.02 3,377 109.03 4,090 110 3.698 111.01 5.s87 111.02 4,213 112.01 3,384 112.02 5.790 112.04 4,623 112.0S 3,464 113 9,430 114 4,551 COUNTYWIDE 251,377 N'atr: nr.nC~ Bun::w: "o.allctadjustcdbuedOll thc:ACCUl'3CYllld COYt:rage Ev.e.hwiorL" So= u.s. Census Bureau, CcnJUi 2000 Redislric:ring Dara (Public: L:l... 94-171) S\IfIUt1lllY File. Mllrie<:s Pt.l. Pl...2. PL3. ..dPU. Tractpopuiarioll G, ~ve.,2000Cmtu! dwl Apr112001 --------~,_.. -"-'.,~ .~. Retrogression Analvsis Maps #1. #2 & #4 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Maps #1, #2 & #4 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111.01 (portlan) 1,594 2 106 111.02 3,137 105 729 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 I 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Maps #1, #2 & #4) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Change +0.9% +4.1% Source: Figures extracted from u.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: '4Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic etbnicity. -_._-_._..__._~_.....__._......_~--- -"----~- Retrogression Analysis Maw Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #3 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 I 39 505 104.14 4,598 I 69 862 , 111.02 (portion) 2,177 102 702 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 I 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #3) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Change + 1.6% +7.3% Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an etbnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. ---------"------- -_.~-~- -,--"-,-~.- Retrogression'Analysis Mac #5 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #5 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 - 111.02 3,437 105 729 112.01 2,327 13 76 (east of 1-75) 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 35,667 , 2,865 (8.0%) 14,028 (39.3%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #5) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 13,349 (39.3%) Change +0.7% + 3.2% I Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not il race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. _.~.._-_.__._._- lIJ W - Z i - Ul i ..l z ! I ~t :0 "'""'-- ... <.) AUlOOJ:ilI'I'Q Z_ ~ =~ 5 ot- a I ullJ Ui - c '" I a:C z ::i w '" . !!!z " 0 w <.) I ... " ...0 '" ! I z ...- >= ~ ollJ '" u! i;'i . ; I :: : ; == LI . 0 , U 8 1i ~ I i I i .u"no~ MICl/OH ~"11.~ . : 1I " ~ ! I ~ Ill: '~'S q .. " . . " - r': ~ . . " . . "'""""'" ....... - ........- - i : -~ = . . 1/1 ~ ~ . ~ : . . " ~ " . ~~ ~~ ~ " ," .m'- I ~ ~~ .~= .. ' . ; ~2 . - << ~ ~ -, ~ . . . . a~ If' ~ :: ~. .- <J't0ll ~lfi'VW t~1Y8 a ~~ U" i ., ~ ;N .~ ,-~ Wi ~!li %~ 1ll!~^1 ,,.'S." ~;~I ~::-";:..~ 0'/'" e'~~ >. 5~~1 Go"'v ~Q'i' , "11 5~~ 0 -,- 0 gCi23 g, pol I I ]~ ,~~ -- -- ~~..:: ~ - -- ~'C:_ - - - Q~~ - ~5~ .3~ .u. - - ~.'-~- I I In I w ! I- z I , U ::J i ~ to """"- - ".UlIlo:):]O'f(I I c: "' ZeI- t;; // I :) In i5 z ow- .... 0 J urn e =It Ui '" I Oz c ~ II: D. 0 D. z ::; w 0 I 1.1I0 - C ~ 0 , ~ :; c: In :E fil . , '" s ....D.! 0 Q. ! I o :E 0 u :E g: , , ; I 0 I ~ U Q I " ~ """"- ,_....:l - - . I 0 ~ &;1:"11'11 ~-1I'.s - ~ ;; . " . J.l,lIl'lQOlno -- OIl'r>\311lll8SJilJ'#lO~ i ; . -~. . . . 1/1 . ~ I . ! - . . . .~~ ~ ~8 I 1P~ J I 'l ,l I ~~ gQ I ::lE i . .5 , 00 ' .N ~~ 1 ~ ~.;( I ~I ,,:;-r1 iilE~1 .~~~~ .~ j~~i ~-' 5.i~ ..."p ~~~: ~".,J 0" ~57i 3 ",yO, ::;:~li 5~~ 0 "'....."'1 0 ",zi:>' ~J ","'..1 ';::~"'l IZ 53~ j~ . ' - - ;.:..... I - - ",0_: c~~] .~ol ..~ <~ ~~~\ ",-uo: ~- - - ~ - ~'" I I I .. . . t-;!; I I ~ U;: ~_. I I' _ 0 -- a: Ii: Za~ l / ~ III! N :z ( o.a ~ UOZ:a: c> !!l a:A.O A. ~ ~ ' 11I0-" w " : -a:..... -' c .. ...... A.. :I ~ ~ - .. > o :I ~! U :I .. . 01: I U - ! I I ~~- -" . . " . ~ , "~ ~ "n I ~ 0" . u · " . . ~ ' J.J.l'I~m ~~ -- ; . , ~ <JIfWA31'DI __ :i ~ ~ III ~ . ~ l ~ . ~ . ~ i i ~ t:- ~ l;; ll3fl'1lX) ~ % ~ c.; 191' 11'= , ., - " .' " ' eo .. o. .. "~ - !: I ." ,.~, "~~ ~. ~~N' , ",.< ~';~ ~~~ I """ 0 .'j' \3 >>1 '" 0 ,~....'" a. 0 .. ~ I . I I ~j ~ U~ I _ _ ~ ~~.e.I' ~~~ o :-5: ,. :i!a~ 'uo , I I I i I AlI<<lD:l'_ A.l.f<I'lClQJlhl'll fn W I z t :J i ~ i I z I::d;; 15 z 0 :)11.I- CO) gj Ofn" . ~ . Uoz Q a. ill 0 a::a.o III 0 t JUo- ee ~ c ~ ; w -a::fn :E ., I . 0 " "'a.fn .. 0 ... - 0: . o :IE .. U :IE ~ 0 I u M__ -~ ! . . :> . U'~ U'~ " " . ~ ! . . 0 . ~ . , . -~ -- . ~ :: . ~ --~ 11\ ~ ~ . ! . I ; i! . .~~ - . .' . * 0" 01"'" .. , u. ~~ , .~ .' .- . o. . t. .. ~. ~~ .i! ~~ .' I 00 ~~ O.~ 0 "" 0 S~ ; ~j ~ "'-- : 5t~ II ~~ I I 1;;05 - f1~~ ~r:: 0 .,. c., .u. --.-... ---- I i I J.LM1OO~OlllI I .wom:I:xrtQ '" ~ t- ;: ~ U ~ - >- Ill: ~ Zat- ~ :::::IW! "'iI' lil o",e =II: Q ~ ' uoz ~ ~ ' g::LO II. lil 0 " I O cC -,0 Ii - W - w C> ... ,... tn'" oj _g::...:!! 0 . ' :III.'" g; ~ - o is if: ~ U :!! . i 8 I ' I ..-,- -~ . . . . u 6/:"11"5 Ill,n. ::J ;e , <JIrj'W1U1I1O.~ lJIft'..rn:I8$~ S =. CI .. fi! <llI'ItUlnofl -- ~ 1ft · . . . , ~ < ~ . Ii ~ ;' I , ~51 :;1< ::i~ ! i ~; liI~ I g ~ 2 ~~ -' 5(-' t~ "';3j "OIl 5~~ z~d. ~ 11I1 Qij ~ 1I.J- 2",;; I . !OM ~~61 U '" '7 1\" %~-:' u ~f ;:...t;; ">IlI~^ r:.'J..:J 0 '.13<=>1 --'. ilj ~~~ I I 5'~ I '- N ~ ~~5 ~ ~i~ i oj ~~81 ! ~ g:u~1 - -- --_._--~,- - - I , w ~-~. I ~- I W z ' I- ::; // I >- g ~ / I- a:: 1ii I zal- ~ ::) UI! In ~ o.a.. Q Sl ^ UOz ~ ~ ' -LO L co 0 " iiio- c ~ ~ ~ ' -a::. == 0 ~ - :IL! ~ ~ o == ~ . U == . 8 I ......,,- -= . . " Q ~~ un ,<' " ~ i OJ: ,,; J! , ~SJCI'f"ClIUjQ G~~ ~ : . . <aft'AnrXllJ -- ~ III . . . g . " " _. 0 ; l:im ~ g i ~ <L Y ~lX il-' :t;;;t ~ .. I "lIlI c'lNml'l J,WdI:IW ~; I =~ . /\I ~ ~. I 00 ", o' ~;" I ",\lli 0 1'J3.i5 g ;i:5:~ " gj a~<, 5'. I Z ~ """I' ~ g ~f~ , ...j.. I 0- ~a~ I ____._.__ ,,-uc.: - -----" ".. .~ ------ EXHIBIT -A- General DescriDtions. MAP #1 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastem shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southem boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Alrport...pulllng Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the MalO) River, easterly and southerly to a point that Is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastem shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the Intersection of the eastem shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 2S East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest comer of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 1S and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County-Road 846, westerly to the eastem boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast comer of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 2S East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine RIdge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Oam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast comer of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 9S1 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of lakewood Boulevard, northerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, westerly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, northerly to the center of Coconut Qrde South; thence along the center of Coconut Orde South, westerly to the center of Coalnut Orde West; thence along the center of Coconut Orcle West, northerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, easterly to the center of Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road B56, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Rorlda Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road _._-~._----,._._.__......-.-.._,,_. ........ -- 862 (Vanderbilt Beach ~ad); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-pulling Road);:.thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly to the south line of Sectlon, 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly to the eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly to the southeast comer of the Regent Park PUD; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Park PUD, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Rorlda; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Dam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Dam Bay in alignment with an Imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine RIdge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, southerly to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green Canal, westerly to the center of the Aorlda Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road), thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, southerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, westerly to the center of Coconut Circle West; thence along the center of Coconut Orde West, southerly to the center of Coconut Orde South; thence along the center of Coconut Orcle South, easterly to the center of Guava Drive, thence along the center of Guava Drive, southerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, easterly to the center of Lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of Lakewood Boulevard, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Aorida; thence along said Lee County-CollIer County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north, thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south, thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east, thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the CollIer County-Mlami-Dade boundary line begins, thence along the Collier County- Mlami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County- Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road), thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 1S, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. DW Imklf:/comp.planning/davidweeks General Descriptions Map 111, A F, Redistricting -- ---_.._~._--_._, ---------"' EXHIBIT -A" General DescriDtions. MAlJ #2 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section. 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasteriy to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southeriy to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence. along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest comer of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast comer of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Oam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast comer of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Rorida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Rorida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Rdad 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road . ---"~--~~.- -_.,-,-.~_. 862, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly to the soUth line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 2S East, also being the north boundary of Pelican MarSh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly to the eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly to the southeast corner of the Regent Park PUD; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Park PUD, northerly to the Point of 8eginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Oam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Oam Pass and Oam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, southerly to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green Can,!l, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of san Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 8S6, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miaml-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. DW/mk\tJcomp.planning/davidweeks General Descliptions Map #2, A F,R_g -- -----~.~_.__. ,~---_..~- EXHIBIT-A" General DescriDtions. MAP #3 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the aty of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the LeIy Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of County Road 864; thence along the center of County Road 864, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of said road, southerly to the north line of Section 11, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 11, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 12, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 7, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along the north line of said Section 7, easterly to the northeast comer of Section 7; thence southerly along the east line of said Section 7 and continuing southerly along the east line of Sections 18, 19, 30, and 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East, to the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, westerly and northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Coilier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and S of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 29 and 32 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26, and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Coilier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 9S1 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of County Road 864 (Rattlesnake Hammock Road); thence along the center of County Road 864, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to east ~- - --,---~,. line of Section 32, TOWDShip 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 32 and 29 of said Township and Range, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and dam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of dam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the westem terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Florida Power & Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road B4 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfail Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 2S East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Rorida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line tums and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line tums and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line tums north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary tums south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary tums east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point south of, and in alignment with, the east line of Section 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along said alignment and along the east line of Sections 31, 3D, 19, 18, and 7, of said Township and Range, northerly to the northeast comer of Section 7, of said Township and Range; thence along the north line of Section 7, of said Township and Range, westerly to the northeast comer of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of Sections 12 and 11, of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of County . Road 29, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of Collier Boulevard, northerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. General Descriptions Map #3, A F,Redlslridlng --- -----_.._--- ..~._-_..,.._"._-"_.- EXHIBIT -A" General Descriotions. MAP #4 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, easterly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, southerly to the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of said Section 16, easterly to the northeast comer of said Section 16; thence along the east line of said Section 16, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Oub; thence along said north boundary, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway u.s. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road B62, westerly to the center of the Rorida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Oam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road) and County Road 951 (Collier BOUlevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club; thence along said north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club, westerly to the east line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Section 16 of said Township and Range, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, northerly to the north line of said Section 16; thence along the north line of said Section 16, westerly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, northerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Rorlda Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the ---.-.---..-.- "-_._-~----- center of County RoaQ 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos 'Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the intersection of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Oam Pass, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Oam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the westem terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Rorida Power &. Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of'Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 2S East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastem shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Aorida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary tums south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary tums east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the westem end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. General Oe:laiptlons Map #4. A F. Red_g _m_~___ --_._--~, " _.._....~~--------_._~._--,-"._------~ - ~-_..,-_.__.._--------_..- EXHIBITWA" General DescriDtions. MAP #5 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Rorida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the east boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern . boundary of Eboli PUD, southerly to the southern boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along the southern boundary of Eboli PUD, westerly to the southeast comer of April Circle PUD; thence along the southern boundary of April Orde PUD, westerly to the center of the Rorida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Oam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast comer of the Eboli PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Rorida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Rorida Power & Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the . center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the southwest comer of the April Orcle PUD; thence along the south boundary of April Circle PUD, easterly to the southwest corner of the Eboli PUD; thence along the south boundary of the Eboli PUD, easterly to the east boundary of the Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road ._-------,_._.~ __.0. ._- - _.~_.._.- 896 (Pine Ridge Road); easterly to the center of the florida Power & Ught (FPl) transmission line' - , thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of the FPl transmission line' thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davi~ Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the Oty of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 7S (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line tums and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line tums and goes east; thence continue along said lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary tums south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County--Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (1mmokalee Road); thence along the center of said road, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along said 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. Gellllllll~ptIo""MapIlS,A F,-.g 1 "".,~-- ',~ ,~'--""-"--- -- " ~ ~ ..- ~ ~ \n s:. r ~ .... ~ r-S r- l) N ...., I' .,.j rfl. C"\ - - 0 '" ~ 0 ...... ,l'lt ~ ~ s;- .-' ;:. -"' \n r- ~ ~ ~ - r: \,,> ~ ,.J< 9 -r- <) N :r- <:\ - ..... ;: ~ ...: 0\ ""' Ql "'i ~ UO -' sf. .- , .!1 cr- ..' ~ ! Q .:g - ~ ~ CJ ..! ld !!, tll . 1\1 o J!l ..!! ~ c: ~::J5 0 .. .- (.) - 0 c: co .!! cri c cS c: <: ~ L( u ~ ..!! :s III III III ..!! c: Ql Ql lD ('1l c: .. e e e ~ e .,.,'" -:1'8 () C""1ll ~ ~~ ~~ .0 Q <:r"""') .> ""OJ. a rf.. '"'",,;,. ~)n~ I . I ~l ... ~""C'\l ,.)-::: C"') c> .,. ~ \nit) -?"" ~ '" "'- ..::>-- - .. .... .- - - -.r <.l CJ ~CJ .::> ~CJ ~ U ,.,. E .- ~- "- .,..~.- - "t: '- - ,g ... ~ N ~ - >.; ~ . - - .... " ~ . .!! III r" .!! .!! \\ ~ .' .. ;> .- ? ~ .:>';) Q Q Q Q > Cl .. P> V\Q ~ c: c: c: c: c: .. }} .. .. 0 0 0 0 0 'Cl ; .- .- .- .- .- .~ ~ 0> '" <> II) III III III III ~ ::"',, .!! ~ .!! III III .e-l! c .- .- ,9 ~ e e e e e = 0 7i = E-< "5 e e e e e 0 a. \\ 0 U 0- 0 0 0 <3 0 ;,; >- (.) (.) (.) (.) "0 c ..... t'- to) '<!' .... .... ..~ to) I.Cl M ~ '<!' C;; ,l""; '<!" t'l r-:' It'l + + , + I E> E- E- E- E- .; .. =' os: .; " ... ... ... ... ... 1'01 1'01 1'01 1'01 1'01 '" .", .. '" '" ~ ~ ~ >- ~ '" ......, .. :a .:a :a -= -= .'" "'. '" '" '" <11 <11 '<11 <11 <11 0 '0 <> o. 0 ... ... ... ... ... ... .... ... ... ... 5 = = = .. '" .. '" .. a a a a a ... ... ... ... ... .., .. .., .., .. " " " " " .~ .~ .- .~ .~ .., .., .., .., .., <11 <11 <11 <11 <11 ~ = c:i .. = .. .. .... 0 0 <> 0 0 ~ 'l:l .c: .. ... .. ...: .. m ... ... ... ~ .. .. .. .. ""'j .. :; a. :; :; CD :; :; .. -' c. c. c. '- c:.. . C. .Q 0 ..- 0 0 ~ <> ~ 0 :a ll.. CD "'" ll.. -() ll.. ll.. ~ 1: CD !1,. C) ~ - l'I ..!!:! ~ t:: 8 M .- a .!! t:: II) '" c:i t:: :c: .., u: 13 :! .!! :s III III III w 'C t:: CD CD CD ~ t:: e e e e '" '" 0 ~ ~ '" ~ ~ '" Q N W . ~ . I I ~ w ~ C') "" It) ~ ~ .... .... - .... .... () () () () () () E .,.. 1: '- .- .- .g .::: .... .::: .::: .::: .!!l III .!!l .!!l .!!l '0 ~ .- > Q Q Q Q Q 'C ~ '0 t:: t:: t:: t:: t:: ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 ~ .- .- .- .- .- '" III III III III III ~ .!!l .!!l III III III ~ .9 '- '- .- ;; e e e e e " e e E e E a. 0 "- 0 0 0 0 0 ~ (,) (,) 0 0 (,) <; ~ -._----- _. ~.._-_._"..'..- -,",.",---- ......-....-.-..---. ;::: .. ~ '" CD ..., i; . --' ... .2 ..: ~ .s :a ~ - ~ u .!!! eo. tIl ~ !9 IV oS 8 .. u " l:: 0> c:i II) C l:: c: 'ii ~ .!!! :5i = III .. '5 CD CIl &! e e e e " ~ ~ ~ ~ " " N .. . . . . . ~ .. ..... c-. CO) ~ It') C .. - - - - - u U U U U U E ... '- ... ... .- J; .::: .::: .::: .::: ~ .!! III .!,! .!,! .!,! '" " ... > Q Q Q Q Q .C " '" l:: l:: l:: l:: l:: .. 0 0 0 0 0 .. l!' 'CI ~ ... ... ... ... ... .. m III III III III III ~ .=l ~ III III III III III .... .. C ... ... ... . ... .- - - .2 e E E e E = Q 1V = .... 3 E E E e e Q "- 0 U C- O 0 0 0 0 ~ U U U U U 15 C ""~'.'.'-'--"-'-- -.-- ---_..~~_.-....."--, - ______.______.._n____._______ _. r-- f"'l ..., .on. -, ..... - N ~; \Q ..., of ...,. Q\ r-- ..., r--~ iii' + I + I i> i> i> E- E- 'Er .- .; 'S 'S = a' CO' a' CO' a' 1'<1 1'<1 1'<1 1'<1 1'<1 ... .. .. .. .. t ,.. t: t t .. .- :a- :a~ .- := A .lOt "" " " " " -< -< <. -< -< Q; '" '" '" '" ... - - - - ... .- .....'. - .. = r:l r:l r:l = 0:,- .. ... .. .. El e e ! e, - - - .. .. .. .. .. .. ::I .= ::I = = .~ .~ .~ .~ .~ .... ... ... "" ... -< -< -< < -< ;: r:l cS r:l r:l = = :,j: '" '" '" '" '" .- 'I:l .- .- ..: .- '" - f - .. .. ~ .. .. .. .. .., .. - - - III :; - = = = = -' Q, 0. 0. ~ "" - .Q '" ...- '" '" '" J! ~ :0 ,p." III p., p., Po. -p., ~ u e- t l:lI ~ .!! .. ..!!! ~ c:: 8 ;; .- n c:: co III cri c .... cS l: <: l'i u: Gl ..!!! Ii III III :x: III n ;; l: III III III " c:: e e e e '" " Q ~ i:. " ~ ~ " Cl '" n . . . . ab ~ n ..... C'II CW) 'It c . - - - .... - () U U U U U E .- .- 1:: 1:: '- 0 ~ ~ ~ '" .... .... ~ .!!! III .!!! .!!! III ~ .- .- Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl ~ . ~ c:: l: c:: l: l: n Q Q Q Q .Q ~ ~ .- .- .- .- " III III III III III = .!!l .!!l III .!!l III c .Q '- .- ;; e E E E e '3 0. E E E e E 0 a. 8 Q Q Q Q 0; (,) (,) (,) (,) <; c -~~._-~ ---.----,..-.,.-.- --~---,--- ~ is . ! ('IlCOC)tw')r')\D NCOU'JClOc")'O .....OJp).....N\O NNCO.....C')'<Il ...CD.....NC.., OOQ:l....NO~ gOCDGOOC~ U.....I()O'l,...(")~ UO(QC").....O~ U""NP)Nrc~ _1O..""..C":!.c-t<<!.o.'" _1O_~ ....."'CIO.rz.,'" -N.'""'''''''''':tC!,f''oo:.Gi -<,!~_C'\!.(Q_Clt!.o.- _tQ_~iC_O_""o< C......""OUll........ ;:"""""0(1)"...... i.caMo"'........ !ClCIC")OID......... ~.....('I)QCD..,...-... g,.....('II ~ .......N g.....N::: _N ....N . . . . . % ~ % : Z "" "'!: - ~~. .",,1f!:i'l'~ -,o;"o.i_ ,. NmIDNCDCS NOJO.....CC... CDq,.....t\ltO..,. Ocn.....N(I)~ C'JNfD""........ :NOCU......DoG :NOIOI()U)~ :ION.NIO~ :II')OION(Q'O :(o}Ofi)C")CO~ U.........N_~~.,; U.........C'\!."!.O't"'. Q.........C'I!,N"'O!."'" U..........C'!,N"'CD"''''. U.........."!.C"o!.cn...... . ............. II .............. III ............... .. .....-... .. .............. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~I ~ ~ ~ ~ g:!J8Vi:3~ m~a;fD:ri~ {:;M8~~~ ~~::~:Z~ ;;~a;~~:: ........WCl)C")...,...... ........(Q(Q(")......... L..("')CCdJN...,...,.; '-('I')a:tOlN........;- ..N(QCDN..,..... ~N- ....."'."..:ai- ~N ........,...:oi- ~N" ....."'"..:0)- IN .. "0;- ~N- ~"':ai~ o 000 6 ....~~~P.l:a~ ...~~~~:55 ..~~~re:ilS ..~~~~~;:: ..~~~~~5 . G . . . ~ u ~ ~ ~ i :; ; ; :i g iii ii ii 'ii iii e == - - - - - >. o . - . - ~ ClII P)....O(o,)N~ ""_C:O""'N~ mmNMlO"" .....N.....MC'\Il;J\ ..,.0.....010... ::: "'3" U)f'oo,II1N.......... IO,...MM......... Mu)""'(o)CO~ IOCDlO(O),....~ 1I'l(Q""C")OO~ .Q Cl.,;g CN~""(,")""",,: cN('I)..,.C")..-....: cN('I)..,.('")-_- CNM..,.('").....; CC'llM..,.t")~....: >. 0:; ..! .!! !! .!! ..!! e ~&; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .?:'3" III b- .~ Q" ---H Q = ~ ...; :a ~;: C ..... M ..... 10 t") ..... c: - (0) <0 0 M'" .c::: d) co ..... ~ CO:... C to II) co ... C":I'" t:..,. 10 N NO'" .: ~ 1.i IOU 1lI...II)(f)m..,.~ ....L()C'IlO..,.~ .-lOMa)('I)1=! ".....II)C'IlO)..,.~ .....It)Mm...,.~ ~.... I>f:. = t;; ... M ;;..... ........... CO) =ti..... ... (0) :a.... M =ti.... CO) It s: 100 ~= S = ~ B B ~....: o . . . . . .. ..J !lu E E E E E ~~ ; C < c( 00( C 2 ..5 Q . C,) :;~M~~~ ~~:glQ~~ ~!9~~N:; :8~~~~; ~s~m:;Q~ ~ ~"'t..51:."'!.~..: ~~""~N.co)~..: ~~....<<t'"'":~..: ~G:!......(C.......~..; ~1t).""(Q_N.l:")...: .!! ~.... NN-ot- ...... NC'Il"'t- g- NN..,.- ~..... N('<4,..,.- ~.... NN""- ii: iii is ii iii iii r; m ~ NC")l'o-CO........ ('tIC"'JCO....l'o-'" ..,.lO.........N.... 00....""'.... CDM....,...<D'" _ Cl)COa)""N~ COlO_IllN;1; 1ON...,.1OCO;:; ......mfClON;!; ,...cafC.........~ r-. .CJtca.~""..-:,1O .cst<<t"":.fC_-~..Q .qlO_""'.C't......v; ."'":IttN..C'I!.'"'":.o .1O......<<I_CD.'"'":..o -: _....co""..,...;:; _....ca......fC..,.;::: _IOCOC")lt)M;:.::; _lI)........lO....;:; _CC<DN...,.IO;:; ;; :c...,........,...M ~...............M ~........,........,.('O') ~......,....,.....P') 2:.......,..........(0) ~ ~ ~ s s ~ .:l o H o ~ OCftco......r:: CCIIl"'l.......~ 1ft.,...,......,:;: OtN..............r:;: ....COIOClII...,;:: ii:'i :;~;;:!~'"l :~;;;aC")"!. ;!~~~~"'l. S:~=~~." :n::t;2~"'l. ~.. ii 0; 0 0 0; o. 5 iii ca. o~ .; N ~ S ii r:i 0 r:i o. r:i S ii 0 <Ii 0" r:i o. S ii....:.; oj o~ :..: S Ii ':. o...,....,an.....1IIlI "S...r.n..,.1CJ1ft 011:I"'''''''11) 0..,...1011010 Ci.,....ltJlO 8.g I- I- I- ..... .... ; .S :.= .. ;3 1j ~ " =~~~~ ::~~~~ ::~:~~ ::~:~~ ::~.,~~ ~g uuuuu uuuuu uuuuu uuuuu uutSuu ...... :5li:5:S:5 :S:S:S5.:: :S:SE:5E l::'EEEE 'S:S:S:S"E .~~ .!l!.!!.l!!.!l!.!!~ .!!.!!.!!.!!.l!!~ .!!~.!!J!!.!!g .!!.!!!.!!.!!.!!!! .!!.!!.!!.!!.!!~ .;~ cocco.. ooccc.. coaco.. cooco.. cocco.. ~u 000(,)0 U(J(,)UO uuouu uouou (,)oOeJO 0"- eJoooo (Jouuo (Juuou OUO()U uuot,Ju u: .c:ammmm allDmc:Ql:O: aJl:Oa:lmm mlDlXlala:l mc:Qmmm ~!3: . '" o ~ U " '- = "'- 'a " " " '"II ';:u R- ..... .N till") at..,. -., :;...,j a :- ~- :- :- :_ ~::i ~ Go a. .a. G. a. IL a. L Q. L II .. .... ec ~cC ec fcC ~c u~ ~ Q.:E Go :Ii Go"5!: Q. S Q" =: ~ ~ 2 . "._* ----_._.....~-" .~-,---~.._._---_..._._--_.~--- _...~_._-~--- - COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY 3301 Tamiami Trail East Heidi F. Ashton Naples, Florida 34112-4902 Ramiro Manalich Telephone: (941) 774-8400 Thomas C. Palmer Facsimile: (941) 774-0225 Michael W. Pettit E-Mail: attorney@naples.net Marn! M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET TO: Bridgette FAX: 941/793-9195 PHONE: 941/793-9292 FROM: Ramiro Maiialich. Chief Assistant County Attorney (Marilyn) DATE: December 5,2001 PAGES: 71~ RE: HAAB Minutes of October 25,2001 COMMENTS: Attached per your request. Marilyn The information contained in this facsimile message is attorney privileged and confidential information intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above, If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copy of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify us by telephone and return the original message to us at the above address via the U. $, Postal Service. Thank you, If there are any problems or complications, please notify us immediately at (941) 774-8400. Facsimile Operator: Gail Bonham ._-_._--~.._"~-,...._~_._....,."..... --..-----".,. .-.....'''-...-..------ . -~_.~..."_.--._.__._.--.._-- -- NOTES FOR HAAB MEETING: 1) Minutes: Get Signatures on Minutes from the current Chairman. Spare minutes on the front-inside pocket of your binder, behind these notes. 2) Absences: Mr. Pina called Monday and advised that he will be unable to attend the meeting Thursday as he has been called to the North Carolina Military base to assist with operations. He further advised that his is not intending to reenlist and expects to be at the next meeting. 3) Mr. Greener: I have stapled into individual packages to be distributed to the board members Mr. Greener's resignation letter, his letter to you regarding his absences, and my memorandum to you explaining my actions prior his resignation. I have placed a few additional packages into the folder for distribution upon request. 4) Review of Board: The general advisory boards ordinance that was adopted on Tuesday provides for review of boards every four years from the date that they are established. The Executive Manager to the Board of County Commissioners has notified me that the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board is up for review in 2002. The review procedures, taken directly from the general advisory boards ordinance, are as follows: SECTION NINE: Review of Boards. Each Board shall be reviewed in the following manner: A. All Boards shall be reviewed every four (4) years from the year the Board was first established. B. The County Manager or his designee shall provide notice to the Board prior to its date of review. On or before January 15th of the year in which a Board is to be reviewed, its Chairperson shall submit to the County Manager a report setting forth the following information regarding the Board: 1.) Whether the Board is serving the purpose for which it was created. 2.) Whether the Board is adequately serving current community needs. 3.) A list of the Board's major accomplishments for the preceding twelve month period. 4.) Whether there is any other Board or agency, either public or private, which is serving or would better serve the purpose for which the Board was created. ,"'"_._-"----_.... .;._..____, _4__ _~_.___ -- " 5.) Whether the ordinance creating the Board should be amended to allow the board to more adequately serve the purpose for which it was created. 6.) Whether the Board's membership requirements should be modified. 7.) The cost, both direct and indirect, of maintaining the Board. C. On or before February 15th of the year in which a Board is to be reviewed, the County Manager shall deliver to the Commission the report submitted by the Chairperson of each Board, pursuant to Section Nine (B) of this Ordinance, together with any recommendation or comments the County Manager may have. In order to assist the County Manager and the Commission in the evaluation of the Chairperson's report, the County Manager and Commission may review applicable minutes of meetings of the Boards. All Boards shall be required to forward the minutes of all Board meetings to the Commission in a timely manner. D. During March of the year in which a Board is to be reviewed, the Chairperson shall make an oral presentation to the Commission. Said presentation shall be based upon the report submitted to the County Manager pursuant to Section Nine (B) of this Ordinance. At the conclusion of said oral presentation any Commissioner may request the formation of a subcommittee consisting of three (3) members of the Commission. Said subcommittee shall evaluate the Chairperson's report, the County Manager's recommendations and any other information it deems relevant to determine whether the Board shall continue in its present form. The subcommittee shall report to the Commission not later than within ninety (90) days after their initial meeting. E. At the conclusion of this review process, the Commission shall determine whether to abolish, continue, consolidate or modify the Board for the ensuing four years. 5) Return all to Kay when through. .~,.~._--_.__._,~~- ., ----,----~_..._.._-_.._.- DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT Report on the Five (5) Redistricting Proposals: Collier County Board of County Commissioners Collier County, Florida October 2001 --~_. ~_~_".._,.,... ..o,,"c' ~.__'_..M"'_. _____ .__.._.~____.___ DRAFT DRAFT Table of Contents Paae Introduction............................................................................................ . 2 Redistricting Criteria................................................................................ 2 Methodology............................................................................................ . 3 Pre-clearance Data..................................................................................... 3 Features............................................................................................ ........ 4 Strengths................................................................................................. . 5 Critique.................................................................................................... . 6 Retrogression Analysis.............................................................................. 7 . Exhibits 2000 Census Tract Map 2000 Census Tract Population Retrogression Analysis Map of Existing Districts Proposed Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 General Descriptions of Districts for Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 1 ^~m~__~__ '-,-'- ,.,,_.__.._,-_.~...._--_._--- DRAFT DRAFT Methodoloav The first step in creation of all five proposed maps was to plot the residency of each commissioner on the 2000 Census Tract Map for Collier County. The next step was to build each district by incorporating those Census Tracts adjacent to the place of residency, to the extent possible and practical. (See attached Exhibits, 2000 Census Tract Map and Tract Population.) Examole: Commissioner Carter, representing District 2, resides in Pelican Bay which lies within Census Tract 102.04. Given his place of residency, the place of residency of the other four Commissioners, and the existing boundaries of District 2, it was only natural that Census Tracts 101.01, 101.02, 101.03, 101.04 and 102.05 be incorporated into his district. Generally, this same process was repeated for all five districts on all five proposed maps. The next step, which was the most challenging, involved expanding or retracting each district as necessary to achieve relative equity in population, while at the same time creating compact and contiguous districts with well-defined boundaries that did not split voting blocks or neighborhoods. Concurrency with the District School Board was another important element that was considered. This was achieved by plotting the residency of each School Board member to ensure that no two members resided in the same district. Collier County is a covered jurisdiction under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Asa covered jurisdiction, Collier County must obtain pre-clearance before enforcing any redistricting plan. In order to obtain pre-clearance from the u.s. Department of Justice, the County must demonstrate that the new plan does not result in the retrogression of minority voting strength. This is ascertained by comparing minority voting strength, as measured by voting age population, under the existing and newly adopted plan (before and after comparison for all five proposed maps). Pre-clearance District 5 has the greatest minority population in Collier County (See Table 1, below). Although it does not qualify as a minority-majority district at this time, it is the district that warrants the closest scrutiny for possible retrogression of minority voting strength. As District 5 is presently configured, it has a total voting age population of 39,440, based on the 2000 Census. Of this total voting age population, 2,875 are identified as Black and 14,242 are identified as Hispanic. This means that in District 5, as it is presently configured, Blacks make up 7.3% of the voting age population and Hispanics make up 36.1% of the voting age population (See Table 1). [It is important to note that "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity.] 3 ,-,--- - .',"___'_..n ..._ow_....__.__.__"____...~~_________._ DRAFT DRAFT MAP #S Districts 1 and 5 are nearly identical in configuration to their existing boundaries. Districts 2, 3 and 4, while maintaining their core Census Tracts and most of their existing boundaries, are now neatly realigned along the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Livingston Road. This north-south alignment, parallel to Collier Boulevard, is the distinguishing feature of this plan. Strenaths All five plans accomplish the Board's directives regarding population equity and respecting the residency of each commissioner. All five plans accomplish the Board's directive regarding the creation of compact districts with regularly shaped boundaries, though to varying degrees. MAP #1 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd. - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #2 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd. - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #3 Of the five proposed maps, the population is most evenly distributed on this map. This map shifts the communities of Everglades City, Plantation Island and Chokoloskee from District 5 into District 1 - these three communities have some characteristics similar to Goodland which also lies in District 1. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #4 All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #S By using the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Livingston Road as a major boundary, this plan creates highly compact and geometrically neat districts with well-defined and well-recognized boundaries that follow major features. The Livingston Road Plan avoids dividing neighborhoods, utilizing minor features and creating numerous irregular boundaries. At the same time, the boundaries of the current districts were respected where practicable. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. 5 --,'- -.,--.-.-- U___", --- ---~~------._..~ -...-- --.----------- '<,""" " ""'Ll"'0 ~-"-- " COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA :1 2000 CENSUS TRACTS 113 114 IMMOKAI,EE f"" ~:' COLllE"-] """c, .c'",., 112.04 112. ;j - " -~ I , /""",, COlL',"'N" i 101.02 I --+'-'~'-- --_/ i 112.01 -- ------..-- I 112.02 ",.. ~ ~S 10cOU"-" 101.04 104.05 104.12 U", ~ i~ , .- 104.07 --' , - , i 'O,D<Nc.rr""n 102.04 , : ~Nl ",OGf' PI"'ROGE.D.E>! 104.14 103 ~~_.~3 ~ 3.01- ' : '. 4 2- 104.13 3.02 _ lOCO,"'" CITY OF -- \ '''''_ NAPLES ;."" '"'le""',,, ,.,. ,N'""',,_,, 7- I 1 106.01 106.04 . 5 107.01- "".. ". S, -? Y, c 0 111.02 CITY OF MARCO ISLAND i SCALE EVERGlADES ~ -L.--.....J __ C11l' 0 .M' 2MI. i - LEGEND 1 [:= """' ww em",,,] PREPARED8Y-GRAPHICSANDITCHNICAl';UPPORT5ECTlON _____J COM~UNITY OEVELOP~ENT AND ENVlRONt.I(NTAL SERVlCFS /:lJ\I1SI(]N 'JA'[f' 6/2001 Fll.E: C[NTR-~.--2000,OW<:; --,,--------_._-----,~ ----.--- -.--, ------.----..,.--.---------- -.------.- _.......m~_..~,..,_~_____..~._~_,_^~._ . *~--,~_... _..>~--_.._.__..-----_..__..- Tmcts April I, 2000 Permanent Population Collier County, Florida 2CK)Q Census Tract 2CK)Q Total Population I 3,649 2 2,199 3.01 3.532 3.02 1,631 4 4,717 5 1,813 6 1,483 7 1,292 101.01 6.802 101.02 3,542 101.03 6,337 101.04 7,194 102.02 8,106 102.03 5,283 102.04 7,383 102.05 2,355 103 4,235 104.01 3,713 104.05 5,802 104.06 7,007 104.07 6,926 104.08 3,147 104.09 8,380 104.10 6,469 104.11 6,102 104.12 6,697 104.13 3,336 104.14 6,656 105.02 7,028 105.03 7,230 105.04 6.464 106.01 2,601 106.02 3,359 10(,.03 S,699 106.04 3,757 107.01 4,807 107.02 4,162 108.01 3,857 108.02 6,612 108.03 3,458 109.01 4,048 109.02 3,377 109.03 4,090 110 3,698 111.01 5,887 111.02 4,213 112.01 3,384 \12.02 5,790 112.04 4,623 112.05 3,464 113 9,430 114 4,551 COUNTYWIDE 251,377 Note from Census Bureau: "D'Ita not adjusled ba,cd on the A.ccur~cy ~nd Coverage Evaluation" Source: US Census Bureau. Censlls lOOO Redislrirting Dara (Public Law 94.)71) SlImmary File. Matrices I'U. PL2, I'Ll. and PIA rrJclpopulatirm GComprehensive,2000Census dw/ April 2001 ___""~~_'~'~.~'"_'~____W__~_"_______" ...-.-.--....- Retrogression Analysis Maps #1, #2 & #4 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Maps #1, #2 & #4 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111. 0 1 (portion) 1,594 2 106 111.02 3,437 105 729 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Source: Figures extracted from U.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Maps #1, #2 & #4) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) -- " "---- Change + 0.9% + 4.1% - - Source: Figures extracted from U.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171)_ NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a face; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. "-,--,.._----~~.- ",^._~_." --"- --~--_..~------_.._-- Retrogression Analysis Map #3 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #3 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111.02 (portion) 2,177 102 702 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Source: Figures extracted from u.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redlstncting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #3) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) - Change + 1.6% + 7.3% Source: Figures extracted from u.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race: accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. ".._-~.._._.."'-------._~'~._-~~,--,--,--~..--.._....,.. - ......_.'~" -.---------...-- Retrogression Analysis Map #5 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #5 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111.02 3,437 105 729 112.01 2,327 13 76 (east of 1-75) 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 14,028 (39.3%) Source: Figures extracted from U.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #5) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) -- Proposed District 5 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 13,349 (39.3%) Change +0.7% + 3.2% Source: Figures extracted from U.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also he ofHispallic ethnicity. ~~--~--"'--'-'----'_." ___,__~ _.. ......~m'_ " .---...-.. t/) -----.-- -" -.-. w ....-.- --- ).1 ~(\Q~ fJ~~IMl,,8 Z UJ HNrWJJ ,aVU - Z -I :::; ~ >- I- 0 ii' Z CJ Iii - 6 :) D:: z 0 I- 0 (jj CJ t/) (/) ~ c :E - z D:: Q w ::; '" 0 W Z UJ 0 oJ CJ - ... 0 z . ;:: ... - (/) " 0 t/) ~ t/) ~ I CJ - ~ ! ::E I ::E i 1 0 CJ I I AlNI1OJAijON3H 1 I vO.ll -~-J r \ il . -,t'i " " .1 c ~V- 6l-11'S r 6Z-,,'5 , ~ I s --r- ~~ ,I I J7 -'I . . J : " c u 1\";, ;i '\ ! -- (JI!V^Jlooe ------i------- s]a'f~!J3IIJ o ClI'/^:nnog SJQ"'-'::llll'lJ ,uNI)();)]:f' , . '----- " . i " . O.r;'^31006 NQSllii i ~ III " " il ~ " . , : ~ " M~ ~3ITlO::> , 0 ^ c j ~ . ~~ a F" e , u. u n " ~u 5 ~ <;L-I ~ al " M"m " ". / ~~ " ll:;;! Oe (j~Od ~Nr;,rld- "z f ' :'& N E.~-1I" ~L-lt.!:]l ~~~ ,.,J5 ~~:3 ~. ~~9 --",'-- --;---- lJOiiiOl ~ 5J I" j ~. yn -.c,c" ,1-~" ~~11 jil~~Nv^t .. o. .",,':.:...._-- (,S'; "eo \~ 0 u:z6 0 ~~~ 0 Gr~~ ( -E- ~] ~ ",--,0:1 0" 0, u ~i~- J E;5~ :.n::~ ---'-"""""'-"" "'..".~,--_.'...'-'~~""-~,-~'''~-- ._- ,---_.--- - -"---"- --.-.- -~---------- -.--.- ----. tn w t- z U ::J ~ t- ,l~r){)'l 'W'YMO~B - U ~ 1< U~I"Y) :JO'YQ zQt- tn is =>>Wtn z OtnE "I'" 0 Oi UOz ;t '" Q :E a:A-O z ::; A- w " " 0 11.I0- CI: w u _~tn ..J 0 > ..IA-tn :IE w I <Jl , 0 ..I - 0 0 0- > o :IE ~ I i I U :IE 0- I :1 0 I u ~ z I 8 ~ g , I ,UNrlOJ ~l:lON:lH I 'Y01<i1 -~.:;) . . 5 5 r - ) .- ~- - v ~ - --- .. J'! .,. 6~ -II'S ----- '" 0 5 . 5 . ~ " \ - " U~OOJi"- O<IYII3looe SJ(J~""(l~3I\] ~ . --J o~^~m" """'~, ----- . " ," O!IV^]lI1OB ~ NOsliil .. 5 " III g , . rn 5 . ! " gB I ~ "0 " " 'i n I S(-I ,0 -- . 0 - . I~ 00 e" ~ Ow " '0 5 " ,,,~N t --",5;:>--...." ~!jj _J' V~ :1l? ~ "~ 5;';::>----- '3~ "IO ~w' <'0 >l'i..'j..\'~() ~a- \'< ()\ 5~4 C','-' wn "I ~w, 00"'1 E\:;~ ZI< " ~:~I 0 ~J ~.3i5 -- I, "-~- - - "~w - - -- - ! I- j ~ g-,~ .u - , -- --~._~-- ~~- - - - u, ~~~ -- ----- " ~~ I -- - i:!at "- ,-,0 - _____1 I ! I I I Ajt<IY-'~ a!l~"'o~~ ^!-I<()<)_) ',.O\"" I ---'---_.--- -- W t/) z ::J l- I- () U "' ~ i ~ 15 z cd;; z 0 N en " ::lw- Ul Ot/)Q ~ " 5E , :;; UOz z 0 " w () , , L " D::LO w " 2 ~ CC .... w wO- Ul E 0 " -D::t/) a. ~ ....Lt/) 0 ^ I a: .... - a. ~ o E JJ I U E 0 U r )J.N()(]:J.U!(lN3H '0 U) VOtil' '~J':> I 1 I ~, . " ''''0 . u " ~~,~'s ~, 0 , ~ > 0 . . . . " " " 0 0 -- ---- Oll't'~BS](!'o'Y,lll3^3 Oll't'AJlnoe S)(lYlOlf.lA3 0 , , k1NflOJ3)1 ~ ~ g g Q!WAJlOO8 ~~. a III ~ z . " . 0 g " . . , . " ~ ~a I ~~ 5 "> c" :;;E ~. "0 "< , ^' ~gjgl ~ '" -::1'0 I > . ~51J i 'i Si--I ""0:,,-, 05< ~i37 oo';il ~ ~ >1, . v.~P}:.G 0 i;)g6 0> ~~~ " Gill)' 0 0 0 " cO 0 0~ N .~ ,.. 0._ ~ I Z ,0 ~~~, < .'~ - U 00% W ~3__ 0 ~'l~ "-0""' ---- - ----- I - I -, '~-'*'"-,._._--~---------_._--- ^""'-_._~-"'~ ~____ ~___.v____~_,__ ~ r - w I I z ~ CJ ::i - 1-. a:: () ) INr!nJ ']JjYH.O~U 1i' ZQI- 1-- AlNfIO:;30V>wrn Ci i C") z orne 0 CJOz :a: gj c :i! a:: a. 0 z a. w ::; wo- er: lil 8 " -a::rn ... c ..Ia.rn :IE w " <JJ 8 ..I - 0 o :IE "- " 0 CJ :IE 0: r "- 0 I . CJ " " c ~ 8 . ~ AlNrKl::l "'lIlJ~]~ V01>~ .~~ " " u - - c ~ 6Z '~'S ! ~ " " !I u " u " AlNfDOJJl OllV"Jlnoe SW'n:l!llll3 ! QlI'I'/'J1noQ S30Y1~l:llII) ~ . ~ " NOSlilO. - " ~ III . g " ~ . ~ S . " " r U j ; c ~ , ~l ~ I ~ t5~ o. ~tj > ~lM !t:;;! - 8'~~ :3~ :{>co < >0 UZ"'; ,_:j\i o. ~~, 'i01 ~ i5~~ )o:'3~ 8" 000 -- or zz< ~ 0 <<-<.!- -~.- ~ 0 ~e. - OJ 0 _~5 - - / N ~:l~ --- - -I- 0 ~ 5~c ~~~ ----_.~-" -.--. -- ~ ~~~ - . ~i~ <" -- ~ - ~~~ ....-.-_""-~_.- Q. (~a - --" - -- --~~-~._. - .-." "~ ---...-- i ~~ ~---I ^iliF~:;~J 'Uh'MO)j>\ ;..llino:>:'j(J't'O en I- J ' t- U U ~ - Ci' D:: t- U) Z I- 0 a en z :::>> 0 I w - ~ U; 0 tI) a U) =It ::E " , u 0 Q Z Z ::; W 0 a:: a. 0 a. " u " wO CI: W Q ~ - .... w , -D:: en :IE U) > " 0 ..I a. en a. 0 " ..I - 0 " :IE '" ~ 0 a. . U :IE ~ " l 0 > U ),Hlno8 ~lKlN]>1 \ \ 't'O~~ '~'J I r I i I ~ --- e~ '~'S ez~-s C ~ < " " li ~ , I G1I'o'^.31008 S3QV"l:JlllII3 -+ 01l'o'^.3100El S3Q~1~l13^3 0 ~I 0 . " ~ . 011'0'1\.3'1008 ~~. 5 III I 0 I " I I . ~ ~ ! " < ! z 0 0 " , ~~ em'", ~o ~~ o~ u~ ~ ~~ ~~E1 ~ ... ~5 ~~ 0 ~z"" _0, .N z.^ .S1!UI iiL-3.ll.3l -- D~; "w, .tyn pc" <:IO~ ~o 111~N~^ ---J -- ~,;..- ?-.:~~- .' ~~>-'- ,\ (-,\J'-~ D Vlf--~ . "';f'~'--~---- ~~o 0 ~~~ " gj ~ €:;;; 5~G: - ! ~ ~~D fJi'::'2 ~;s ',~ 0 fu~~1 - ---- ----.--- ffS~1 ---- ..e._'_." ~".~.,____,,_.._..,_",__,___ .. ,_,._.,"y,~,~'., "_'>~"'____'_""_'-'~'~'~~_~"' .~~,-_.~"--------_..__._, ~ .... m ~ "''"' ,,~<O"" I ^''''''~''' >-!:! Q I- Ill:: ~ ZQI- c; :;:)w! \I) ~ o U) Q gj UOZ lit !i! ~ " Ill:: IL. 0 IL. ~ 8 wO- CC ~ c _-U) -= w ~~U) ~ ~ . ~IL._ :5 0 o :E g: . u 8 I : AJ.Nf100AtIOH]1i 'o'OHi '~'::.o I'" ~ : ~ 0 fli'yS 6Z'I!"S ________ " ~ ~ . " . <.J ~ :l ) ~ : CJ 0 " IJliVJ\31noe S30V1!llf.ll\3 ;- AJ.N!lOO33l O\j'ffJi"(leS3O'I'l:lIlJIIJ o ~ .) " . a c.; m VI Ii -0 IJliV^:nnoll ~SlWl ~ ~ UI ::I: z ~ . . z ! g 16 " :'; i z o o ~ " . ;;~ a ~ 1=", u z Uw 'i '" ' ~~ ~. " "n;oo ~~ N ~~~ . . e.. ill ~~" " . Z~" v " ,. '0 o~~ I 0 ,;>co ~o , .:.-g~'^./ ~ 0' . ~~~ .N../ . '"~ <<" . \ 0 "';;:~ Ii'< 0 'lwO. :'l 0 :I:::f. p,r-.!ll 0 ~~':l 0:0<; 1\l <r-,G: , "' I 3L ~.o _IL-"': in"".. ?;l 8~~ _ _ _.... _...._ __ au; __ __'..''''_'u_ ......._.______ ..u._ _ou<c~ - .. -"".--_......_~~~----- .-.-.,.---. EXHIBIT "A" General DescriDtions. MAP #1 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast corner of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the Intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of Lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of Lakewood Boulevard, northerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, westerly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, northerly to the center of Coconut Circle South; thence along the center of Coconut Circle South, westerly to the center of Coconut Circle West; thence along the center of Coconut Circle West, northerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, easterly to the center of Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road _._- - "'--""'.---" .__._~-_...,- EXHIBIT "A" General DescriDtions. MAP #2 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast corner of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road ~__"'~_.~_"""'_"'~"'_"''-~'_M'~'~~___''_'',"_ _" ._ ..",'<_.w_.______.___._____~__.~._._"'_.____.u_.__~..__._. EXHIBIT "An General DescriDtions. MAP #3 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of County Road 864; thence along the center of County Road 864, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of said road, southerly to the north line of Section 11, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 11, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 12, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 7, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along the north line of said Section 7, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 7; thence southerly along the east line of said Section 7 and continuing southerly along the east line of Sections 18, 19, 3D, and 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East, to the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, westerly and northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 29 and 32 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26, and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of County Road 864 (Rattlesnake Hammock Road); thence along the center of County Road 864, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to east --._""--_._.._..-~ ._"_~ "_______m EXHIBIT "A" General DescriDtions. MAP #4 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, easterly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, southerly to the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of said Section 16, easterly to the northeast corner of said Section 16; thence along the east line of said Section 16, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club; thence along said north boundary, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway u.s. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road) and County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club; thence along said north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club, westerly to the east line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Section 16 of said Township and Range, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, northerly to the north line of said Section 16; thence along the north line of said Section 16, westerly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, northerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the -- - .--. EXHIBIT "A" General DescriDtions. MAP #5 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34. Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the east boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Eboli PUD, southerly to the southern boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along the southern boundary of Eboli PUD, westerly to the southeast corner of April Circle PUD; thence along the southern boundary of April Circle PUD, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Eboli PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the southwest corner of the April Circle PUD; thence along the south boundary of April Circle PUD, easterly to the southwest corner of the Eboli PUD; thence along the south boundary of the Eboli PUD, easterly to the east boundary of the Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of County Road .... . ---~._---_.--- ./ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 - .. 0 0 0 0 0 \\ "J Q :3 :3 :3 :3 :3 ~\ ~:;'; :3 :3 :3 :3 :3 TV -- .... i ;:. ;:. ;:. .... -. .r g ~ v. v. v. 1Il 1Il ~~ ~ ~ 1Il 1Il 1Il 1Il 1Il e>. '" co..... .... .... .... _. .... .,:"1: ~ =- 0 0 0 0 0 ,,\ ill to ::s ::s <::s ::s --' ::s o~ ~ ~ < _ CI( ~. .( <. S! < S! " S! \"\ S! \ \ S! <'0 ~ " ,\ 1Il ,\ 1Il.-.l 1Il ""' 1Il. 1Il 0, _ """"-1 ~~ "",,,,- """"~. ~ ." a - 1'-' ::!. ,- :::t - ::!.c::--... ::!. _~ :::t 3 v" 0-'.... ~ '" ~(.c- ~,.<:. ~ ~ ()...J:. s- .... - ....~C" ........ ....,,,'f;: .... " - S> "" ~ . _, - , -,-, ;;lor..&- :., "" U1\1\..s> oI:l. yo! ~ w -., I\)cc '" .... c -, ""- ,~ (;' . . ~ . ~ I ~ . . I ;:','" ~ ~ c... <Xl "tl ~ c...:i I:J 8's;.. " III ~ III ~ III ~ 0 00<; :3 :;-t:3 :3 .. ::s il'...) (1) (1) (1)::S 9,,,, 1Il _ 1Il III [ ~ III 1:J:n -. . en . Ill.... => . ~- Qc<; 3:~ vv Q;; iii " 8 - ' III . ... "'000 (1)-J ~j it'"'- gO iit~;lI1;~ .....,..9->' n ... b-- -. o<:! :;;- c... (1) ~ <;;> ~ :" .-.l _ Q> f" _.,S:) J"J ~ < ~ ~ .....~ .0<\ I;'-' ...9 <l -- - - Q ...t: 0 t'--' " //\ ()......c. Y" - '-oJ. .:..J - " <:-' "" o -J VI .. _ <-' -.3 ~ ~ ~ 2;-J' ....... 0 u o ~ (iJ !'""' ;:} '"" IV () -.J . t-.l -<" ...,. t\. '..J ~ V, :,..! W -<' - " :;J o ~ 1lV -~-"^---,~ -~~------_._--~---~._._._-_...._.- " 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 "1J (") :3 :3 :3 :3 :3 0 0 "0 c: .., = :3 :3 :3 :3 :3 " o 1:1 ~ ~i iii' iii' iii' .., iii' 0 (/) " (/) (/) (/) (/) (/) :h <0 .. ... ... .., ... .., c: Q. 0 0 0 0 0 iii '" ::J ::J ::J ::J ::J "' 0. 0 0 0 0 0 Cl> "" <1i iii' iii' iii' ... iii' (/) 0. c;- c;- c;- ~ c;- a .., .., .., i C:;" .., 3 (') (') (') (') () - - - - - Cl> 01 olio. W N ...... " "' I I I I I c: "' ~ 'll t.... 0 '" 0 Q) 0 0 :3 :3 :3 0 ::J ;lJ Cl> 11l 11l 11l ::J 0. (/) iii (/) Q) ,." s: ~ !=' :tt ~ ~ 5" Q)' <0 0 0 iii " ~ III 0 Q) or - ~ "'U 11l (') c: fif )i; 11l 2: .... 0" . ... "tJ r ~ 11l III ~ :E ! !=' :: _."'__..__u_"____ ~ 8 . ~ " C\lCOOC")C"'>~ C\lOOLOCOC")~ .....Q)("').....N~ NNCO.....M~ .....a:),....NCO'D Uom,...C\lON UOO)CX>OON U"ltlOO"""'MN UOOOMr--ON U""'NMNlO~ _LOMMNCOo; _lOM.....'O:I'<O'" ._N"lt.....(O,....'" ._NMNCOCO", ._COMlOO.......'" :;,..:MOl.Ow.....w..,. i,..:MO(!i......... l;a:iM'oari"":"" ;ctJ.riolt"j.....w..,. ;1'--',"ici(J)-~':"" c. ..... N Q. .... N C. .... N Q. .... N a. ..... N W W 000 X ~ X ~ X .""., NlJ)Lt)NCO;t NO) 01'-<0""" OlCO.....C\l<O"<t OO>,....N(,O:2: O')N(oM""~ :NOcn'r"CD\6 :NOIOIO<O@ :I.()N"ltNl()g :IOOlONCO:;O :MOI.OM<O-c U...."lt"!,C\l.Ol."". O,....~N_~O'l_.n u""V"!.C\l.Ol",' U,...."1'C\l.N..~,..i UI'-'Ct"!.N.O)....... " ............. fa .............. ftI ........ <N'o:t"." !N- .....-....:0;- !N" ....:...."'0';.... !N" ....-~.:a)- !C\i ....:.....0';- ,!C'>i .....-~.:ai- o 000 0 ...~~~~~g ...~~~~f55 ...~?i3~re~S ...~~~ref5S ...~~(J)~~5 ~ ~ ~ $ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ C C C C C U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e = - - - - - >. o 0 .~ . - ~ .!! ('I').....OMN$ C"')....Ol'OtN$ OlO'lNM<O$ .....N....MN$ .."O,....OCO$ ~ =- lO.....lON.....'" LO""MMI"--." ('O')<O'CtMO::l", lO(OlOC")/'.V\ lOCOMMCO", .0 c.:E CNM~M.....-: CNM"<tC"':l..--: CNM"<tC"':l,.-. CC\lM"<tC"':l,--: CNM~M..--_ i:i' ca .!! .!! .!! .!! .! E ~ &; .:I .:I .:( ~ .:( .~..; ~ -; ~ .!O! ~ '5 ~ = ~ ,<O..--..--<o.... CCOlO(O..--C"':I.... C"<tlONNO.... .~Q... Ill: =u ftI.....lO("')O>~~ ftI.....lOC\l "<t~ ftI,.-IOMO>M;:::' ftI"--lONcnv~ rG"--lOMO>~~ ;N " Q... .- ,.- ..-- ("') .-..... ..... M .- ..... ..... ("') - ..... M -..... ,.- M 0.. ...l "" QU " " " " "C ",Q.. M= .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 :E_ li!! 0 . . . . . Ui ...l =U E E E E E ....~ :; cf: of( oct oct oct ~ .~ ~ . u ~e("')~;.?; ~e[gl;;;e~ ~~~gN; ~~Nge; ~~~m~~ ~ .lI::lO.V~N.M._" .lI::~~CO.C\l.M.-: .lI::<O""<t~.....~-: ,:,::~v~.""'~_' .lI::~"<tCO"~M"_ .sf ~..... NNv- ~..... NN~- ~..... NN"<t- ~..... NN"<t- ~ NN"<t- ii: - - - - - ~ m m m m m I co ~gS;~~~ ~fZ~ro~~ ~~~~~~ "-~~ro~~ :ef:ci<D~~~ r:: cnCOCO~..-" cnCO,...(()..-" OlO,...C\l,.... .....lONN..-" lO/"'o.COOl..-. S"';co.ri"';"';\O .!..,;c:t:i..-.tO"<t":::: .!U"'ic:t:iC"':l.IO"M~ .!.or--:..j.ov.~ .!<O.<O.N..j.o~ .J "-"<t~~~("')N ._~~"<t"<tMN .-"<t~"<t"<tMN .-"<t"<t"<t"<tMN .-"<t-"<t"<tMN 0\ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ j .a ~ .C " o ~ ~~~C;;C;;::: ~~~:;M::: ~~~:;:~::: ~~;Z;C;;::: ::~~~~::: u:; _GO."":.~"":."t:!- _CC!."':.f"'I..<=t"ltM:!- _......'Il:I;.f"'I..M..<=t:!- _C"t."lt.u).r"t'lf;.:J. _ltI..<DM'".C"!.."lt.:!- :So ",cnoocno~ ",cnOCl)NC~ ftlOOCCO~ ",cmcoo:!:: ra....=O)o....:!:: 91>0 0: ~ II) II) "''It II) 0: ~ II) ''It II) '" 0: II) II) '" '" '" '0 '" ''It Il) Il) II) 0: Il) ...,. ...,. II) Il) 0 .1:: ~ ~ ~ I- ~ c: .f .~ E "0 ;;:; u " ~ '" .....NM...,.ln .....NC"')"lt'" ....NC"')...,.cn ....NM...,.II) .....NM.II) OQ '0'0'0'0'0 'O'01:)u'O uu'O'O'O 'Ouuuu u'Ouuu ~g ';:';:i:';:';: .;::S:S";:';: .........c.c.c .C';:'!:'!:';: 'C'!:';:"i:i: 8:g in in in U; in E iii en en in iii E 1ii 1ii 1ii U; in E 1ii 1ii iii iii U; e 1ii 1ii U; 1ii 1;; E .~ .- .- .- .- .- ::I .- .- .- .- .- ::l .- .- .- .- .- ::l .- "- .- .- .- ::I .- ._ ._ ._ _ ::I ';::l I:: ceccc... cceoc... ceoco... OCCCC... coccc... ~u uuuuu uuuuu uuuuu uuuuu UUUUU 0::1 uuuuu uuuuu uuuuu uuuuu uuooo u~ mmmmm mmmmm mmma:lm mmmmm mmalma1 Z,3 3 OJ o ~ U . ~ 0 " " 'a " " ~u 8: ,,~ "N "M lit. lit." ;tti ~ :- :- :- :- :- ~;:j.g c.a. c.D.. ICI.D.. c.D.. I:I.D" II u ..... o~ 011( 011( OC:C oCC UU .. .. IIIIi: .. IIIIi: r. IIIIi: .. III!! U "3 ij- C. C.C D.c Q.c CLc 1:IlS: ~ '--. _-.<<_._",.~c"._....,._.,~ . .~__'"._~ _____._.___________ COLLIER COUNTY DAVID c. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY 3301 Tamiami Trail East HeidiF.Asnlon Naples, Florida 34112-4902 Ellen T. Chadwell RamiroMaiio\ich Telephone: (941) 774-8400 William E. Mountford FAX: (941) 774-0225 Thomas C. Palmer MicnoelW. Petti I Jacqueline Hubbard Robinson November 15, 2001 Marjorie M. Student Potri(k G, While RoberlN.lochory Board Members Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Re: November 29, 2001 Meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Dear Board Members: Enclosed please find the Agenda notice and backup for the Thursday, November 29, 2001 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board meeting. If you have any questions or are unable to attend this meeting, please contact me or Ramiro at 774-8400. s;"~' Ka~~1Ktt~" C~ Office of the Collier County Attorney Ikn encl. cc: Ramiro Manalich, HAAB Liaison and Chief Assistant County Attorney, wjattachments David C. Weigel, County Attorney -,..,-...-.--.-.- _~,.,_,_..'~d._~_~,,_. -.--.- -"_._-,, GOODMAN, GLAZER, GREENER & KREMER, P. C., OF MEMPHIS, TN., ATTORNEYS HERBERTGL"ZER EUGENE GREENER, JR. 600 FIFTH AVENUE SOUTH EUGENE GREENER. .JR. '''001. H." n., RESIDENT PRINCIPAL SUITE 203 RICHARD H. KREMER NAPLES, FLORIDA 34102 B. PERCY ",AGNE:S5 BRUCE M. K"'HN TELEPHONE (Q411 435-9800 HARRIETTE R. COLEMAN FAX (941) 435-9802 greener@naples.infi.nel EDWARD E. WOLLMAN, ,.....P...:" F", OF COUNSEL AVAILABLE BY APPOINTMENT WILLI...", W. Gooo......N SUNTRUST BUILDING "lKlO-ll1BII MORRIS L. STRAUCH MARco ISLAND, FLORIDA ,11tO!J-20001 lALL CORRE:;;PONOENCE TO NAPLES) October 17, 2001 James D. Carter, Ph.D. , Chairman Board of Collier County Commissioners 3301 East Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112-3602 Dear Dr. Carter: I hereby resign as a member of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board. ~egard"' / /" ",. " ..~. EG/ds E gene Greene~ cc: "Mr. Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney ........ J,.:.) - .r:" ~---- .---... - --~ ",--..".,,".._',.. GOODMAN, GlAZER, GREENER & KREMER, P. C., OF MEMPHIS, TN., ATTORNEYS HERBERT GLAZER EUGENE GREENER, JR. 600 FIFTH AVENUe: SOUTH EUGENE GREENER, JR. '''0'' FL.TN, RESIDENT PRINCIPAL SUITE 203 RICHARD H. KREMER NAPLES FLORIDA 34102 fl. PERCY MAGNESS . BRUCE M KAl-IN TELEPHONE (941) 43S-9800 HARRIETTE R. COLEMAN FAX (941) 43!5-9802 greener@naples.inti_net EDWARD E. WOLL-MAN. '''A~U:6 Fl.) __ ') _'''~ OF COUNSE:l.. . -' (_, WII..LIAM W. GOoDMAN AVAtL.ABLl;;; BY AP,Pelf,J.M..l::NT (1900-19811 SUNTf!UST 8Lntillp,j(t MORRIS L. STRAUCH MARco ISIAND::;F~DA (lllOlt-:WOO) (ALL CORRESPONDENGLT\:I-;:NAPI..ES) ,c'\ I', September 28, 2001 ..- Mr. Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney Collier County Attorney's Office 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FL 34112-4902 Re: Hispanic Affairs Advisorv Board Dear Mr. Mafialich: I am a new member of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board. I missed the meeting in August, about which I advised everyone in advance, because I was on vacation and out of the City on the date of the meeting. I missed the meeting in September for a different reason: I never received notice of the meeting. I would certainly hope that I will receive timely notice of future meetings, including an agenda for the meeting and perhaps telephone contact prior to the meeting if there is going to be something controversial discussed at the meeting or something as to which I need to prepare. I really want to serve in a proper manner, but I will not continue to be a member of the Board unless I receive proper information regarding the meetings in the future. I respectfully request that you send a copy of this letter to the Chairman of the Commission. -df;With kindest r~gards, ... / //-.':X~ . . . . . .....- ," ,.' " . . .. . .<';I./'-h / ~. ---Eu e~ene';1,C~;?f-- EG/ds _ ________________ ____.__~._______.__.._._.._~.__.".____...__.____~^____.__.___.~_.____. __ __.__u.______._~._.______~_..__.... .. _..._____._...__ ..__ .'__'_' MEMORANDUM TO: Ramiro Manalich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and Staff Liaison to the Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board FROM: Kay Nell, CLA, County Attorney's Office cg) DATE: October 24, 2001 RE: Mr. Eugene Greener You have asked me to identify what actions I took to notify Eugene Greener, Jr. of the meetings prior to Mr. Greener's resignation from the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board. On Thursday, September 20, 2001, I mailed the agenda notice to all members. I mailed Mr. Greener's agenda notice to his office, which is one of two addresses that he provided. On Thursday, September 27, 2001, the day of the meeting, I contacted all board members to remind them of the meeting. I received a return call from Denise, Mr. Greener's secretary, advising that Mr. Greener had not received his package, was not aware of the meeting that night and had already made plans; therefore, he would not be able to attend the meeting. I asked Denise to have him call me so that I could confirm the address for delivery of future notices and to have an opportunity to apologize for his not receiving the agenda notice in the mail. To date I have not received a call from Mr. Greener. On Thursday, October 18, 2001, after mailing the agenda packages to all board members, I attempted to e-mail Mr. Greener the agenda notice from the e-mail address he provided. The e-mail receipt came back undeliverable. On the day I began calling all board members to remind them of the meeting, I received notice of Mr. Greener's resignation from the Board. /kn cc: Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board / David C. Weigel, County Attorney - - --"""-~--'- --."....~--- GOODMAN. GLAZER, GREENER & KREMER, P. C., OF MEMPHIS, TN., ATTORNEYS HERIEIERT GLAZER EUGENE GREENER, JR, 600 FIFTH AVENUE SOUTH EUGEr-+E GREENER, JR. ,"'OM n.. TN, RESIDENT PRINCIPAL SUITE 203 :'c,.:~~~ ~~:::::R NAPLES, FLORIDA 34102 BRUCE M. KAHN TELEPHONE (9411 435-9800 HARRIETTE Fl. COLEMAN FAX 1941) 435"9802 greener@naples.inti..net EOWARD E. WOlLIo'IAN. ,N"PLE5 n, OF COUNSEL ( WILLIAM W. GOOOMAN AVAILABLE BY AP~T.III.ENT ,llIOO_.9a'l SUNTRUST a&u..-oING' MORRIS 1... STFlAUCH MARCO ISIANn(;,FL~IDA (1909-20001 (ALL CORRESPONDENCE TP:NAPLES) '\ , , September 28, 2001 Mr. Ramiro Manalich, Chief Assistant County Attorney Collier County Attorney's Office 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FL 34112-4902 Re: Hisoanic Affairs Advisorv Board Dear Mr. Mafialich: I am a new member of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board. I missed the meeting in August, about which I advised everyone in advance, because I was on vacation and out of the City on the date of the meeting. I missed the meeting in September for a different reason: I never received notice of the meeting. I would certainly hope that I will receive timely notice of future meetings, including an agenda for the meeting and perhaps telephone contact prior to the meeting if there is going to be something controversial discussed at the meeting or something as to which I need to prepare. I really want to serve in a proper manner, but I will not continue to be a member of the Board unless I receive proper information regarding the meetings in the future. I respectfully request that you send a copy of this letter to the Chairman of the Commission. dWith kindest r~gards, -~/ ~ '~-----Eu 'e~{n1I/~----/ EG/ds --"..--..,.-.- -.. ",',', '~~.~';~.""'-""" ._-'"."._.'~' R i!5 E R i!& E R i!7 E R i!8 E MAP #1 " - I ,- ,TU-I 1ft .' [, ' ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES \ .~" ._~,~ '""~, .... BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS _, _ = _= 0"' ." --" + ,'-" COlUER COUNTY, FLORIDA " j I, ~ :'\ UNIT 42 lJNlT 41 \ II I - Ul'l1T 40 \ \ ""'''~ !IE'-<:~ ~"." (<:..~, ...) II I I I __n__ ---- '- /7 l !,---- ~t - ,! . ' I 0"' l~',' . ',," " ' .. i "'""" ON"" ~\'/" , ; ~ \1 lEE COUNTY ' -- -- ,e ~ /,1' Ii! ~ II ! 1 1 0"' ,''''f''','''' !.-~, " i" lI' :, o<!'" . I )8 UNIT... UNIT 52 UNlllll ' ~ 'I I I UNI! &~ UNIT '>2 _____ , _ ___ 6J -- -- -- >-1 _ : 1 --- I . I, 1ft o~, ".", ~ I, UNI])7 UNI1 36 : I L: ,,', ." '." I " ~ I U Nt T 6." UN IT 6" , ~k'\v~ " ' cu. ~ .II[ ! -- ~-u I I 1 :( ~ 2, ~, - ONlln UNll22 I UNI161 I I '.' ~ ~,I,c'~.., : I", )1 .-..ll I pQIJI.[V''''' UNIT r,g UNIT 68 ,! \\ i~ ,,""-,. ,""""'...." .p_ (C~, ".' Ii: """,E~-'i"""'"...t\: RO..q IC,~ ...~ .- .--. I \/, I i ~_ ,I, 1,.0: ! I )1 ~ ,', ti ~~!\j~~ ", '! UOlI' ,0 j Utll] '1J UtllT 1~ Utlll 2~ UNIT 10 Utlll 7\ Utlll n ' ~ ;,.", "''II!''~ UNIl 97 a ~ >- I I Y I fIl, 1 . 1 f----- - ---1--------- prc. ~"<H I, 1---------- , ; <.J I ' ""7ar~",,0" ,l':;;; i g UNIT 19 ~ UN, II It! UNIT 11 UNIT 16 UNIT7!; UNII/4 UNlln l ..... " ' IJNlI96 11 II I v.....:.llI-T ...e" "~." ", __' ----..-- -~.- -~. --- . I I ~-~ J. "0, I' ! i :' ;:. U~~' UNI' '1 UNIT J UNll 6 UNI! I UNI1 10 UNIT 11 UNIT 14 UIoII1411 UNI1!'J UNlI 16 Utlll 77 UNI1 16 1 ~ ! I I , . ! II, ,., ~ ;~~ ~.. "" -,"- -. ,.., '00."_ .. UNIT 11 UNIT , UNIl3f> . ",TI I UNIT 4 ut'lIT!'J \JNITA UNIT 9 UNIT 12 UNIT 80 UNIT 79 UNIl IJ UNIT ~8 UNIT ~1 81 I .,,,,,'IOIDGt"""O C,R.... '" 'lMI(IIlMC\IOAll --- ~- -_._~. en I '\~1', i I '" UNIT M UNII 2 IINIT I~ u,.,1 19~ UNIT 19~ UNll llil n . UNITD, ,,',_ 112 UNI185 UNITB4 .., g~nn: 0 ~ . t'''.'j r--- ,~ ..w "'" "-- ""-- I _w n__ ----. .... . - ' . I '" "'. ~ T ~ , -- - Utlll HI<' ! . -- , / J t uNI ~1 I, COLl"t'N , -~' UNll! IJNIT llfi UNIT 8~ " " ... '-I._'f" 117:;, ~ r----:: >: ._- I i ill , C? ~ ~ ~ GATE UNI] 28 1 l:l ---.- " . .,~~' . ' '" ~ " r-- VNIT ~'_ '>IIlDEN <;"'1""""':: . lC,"...l ,CIT, 88 ~ VNI1 89 UNI1 90 .C ~, . . I I--n- i ! I ' __~" '" ' ___no ~--- C '''' " ____ ~ '~ 'i ., -.: r" ., ,........' UtllT UNIl 91 ~ I..."."-....a---~i ! ~ ' ; '" llJ UNIT 91 i= 1'" /' ii' -......", 0,,",000.00 (co..")-- S ' - r---r , ..~,.I."",," ",' 7~ II' ! I 1/'1-1'[ T" I' T ___"''' " I '-' 1'-"""'" II; , - CITY _,_~ , . I" I, ' OF ,,4\' \ O. IU""'" ,1 .0... 1 a~' UNIT 98 UNIT uNIll00 UNll 10 Utlil \\4 I NAPLES ' I 119 v< '1 '0 I. ' ,--- ~--- I J' ..,i" ii ,!' I 1ft (l' 1-- '. i"', ii, u",.ll 10~ ~~~T uNIT 101 UNIT \19 UNI1 \18 , , o ,_,j " i ,!" _ ------- 1----- ----- --- 1ft > ~ UN,l 'O~ ':....~n_ , .f..;:____ ,...,...SSOODII "MTl.rni...t """"'lCll..0,", _ i l, UNIT \JNI1121 UNI! 12..1 UHIl \24 ...._+, T \ J H""" ! ' ,- n__ ". . ,.f) ,j ~ " ,.' ii' ------ ~c;::::, 'i i I UNIT '.,',rr\l " I I ....'" t~ .""0 UNIT 106 \07 uNIT 130 UHI1 121 " '-:-, 'v > I \ ",' . ",,;, )' I -~--', --- , ! j , , ' I '"C I I 'i CO"", ',~'Ji CO,,,"'' co"no CO"'" '1/..:'" " (,,~" I I ----'-.---- ----;;. ____m..._ \\::_'[ , ,\ <,cj '" I ' I' OM' '" ~~\' I 0"' ",' 0.' '" 0"' '" '\ II I' '( ,,- \,'\:i'c" \::_/ )/: I I! - . "_m. ---- $!jillJ',) (t'"='!5',,' ,cA, " r~\ ~ \{,~ r;----,--.}"V'-0=5\{ 1 /1 i; " I 1 1ft '-"'d \'::-;'\;:01-,' ~'~,..Jf "f/ iG i I' UNlfl~6 ~~~ UN\T150 UNI11M UNI1\52 UNlltli'J UNIT 1:\4 , ''1~' , (L -,' '; - 1 ~,~ \\,'1-. i ',1 ',' '.' I ' 1ft _______ "'~! '>',' "I~ j ..;. I ,- / '\ t \\\'\ 1 j'- , 'e I I' UNIT 161 ~~~ uNi"f \~II \INI115ll Utll1 1~7 \JN111!;6 UNIT 1~~ .... \0 '\ V \ ' , OAl)lORC.-o (C.R.ll~b) ~- Jl f']/r!) I' i ~" "'" -1?" I / ~ 1 : \~ \ ~ ~( Jf \! ' .'1 0"'" UNIT lt1!i UNfT lt1t1 UNIT 167" ~ 1 I ~\ l ~b~" Df1 f) UNIT I€>2 16J UNIT 1€>~ '" ~ I ,\ \ ~ \ (,\J.J \l!/ .---, _'-I ~ 0 \;.j ~"I ,'.t-' I, V, -, - -- - ~ ,~'"" ~ II' ,,( , -~ ~----" \\ \t...' i:\:\,'c, I,. I . "'"'"" en "''' '" -, 'COCOtlUI ,,;~/,{'.._ . 1-- . i~'! ~":::::~~/'~'"'OO ~1(~~X\'Jf'C~?\I~-';-;\;"'\1 VI ,,,:~,,:~~,,,,".:::.t'~' ---" -"'" ""'" ~, ",,12-1;\, '.1 'd~C'~ I, I':)! i 1 "'\ ., ~~ ~~f.::~tiV I,' I ~ '-. '^ 7 V/(y /',N , ~"'" ' ' .., ________ ( II .?~ ~ l4", 1\ ~ ) i-.. I ' -_ 't,. " . ' ( '~" ?c:.{1 ,\ " ,I '" I 1ft N----\~ .;\ e'-", , \>I'.~(('-"~ ,,(\ u' I I I ::: + '\ 'd~ \\.." " ~~r\ 11. /1 r~i~ I '", --,- -1-1--- w E ~\'""\'~ ,'(I "- ~~,=/;" 1 ~ ,,: ( , . II' I, !'l, .... '\"\ "i"'~ "'''',,' ' -" 1- ." I I I , '" (~I ,,\ '" '(((\~i I I ! ~ i' CITY // _ ~--,,""- : . ',)I,~ _', "\ -- ".! I . OF '0""" /")): · , /I ' - ",I.e'" i' I,:, ," .'" MARCO 1 II.. n \ ' ',;. . '} >-.-' .... ' S ISLAND 1 )!;~,~~ \',,1, 'i!, , )M~~, r,.,', ) Ii) : Iii I I ) j;.,., . 4), ~., [ : I SCALE ~L,-r;,,"--,,' il, I'i '; ! (\I' !Y-'/~ J' . II ,;' I; f - I I 1 r====+= I I I 'Ii: I, ,,___L ,\: ,," ,. V I '~r\" 1_ o 1 MI 2MI 3MI. 4MI ...J,EGEN.!L PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER I - DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATION 2 - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D ----r-------- 49,840 ~ 3 - TOM HENNING --2---~ --50,759- 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KIE , 3 un.___ --50-;616--- S - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. ... --.. --- ---4973f -. ----- ----,. - --- -_..._~- _ INDICATES COMMISSION DISTRICT LINE 5 __ _ ~- -- 50~(==--- PREPARED 8Y: GRAPHICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECTION 8um 251,377 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DATE: 10/2001 FILE: COM-DIST-MAP-1DWG / PLOT: AUTOCAD.PAL R 25 E R 26 E R 27 E R 28 E MAP #2 I I r \ r --[-T..-' 1/1 ,.,' !'! "I ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES! ' \ ,~".~..'"o ",~,I to BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS II oN"" 0.'" oN""\ II" ,--- -- -- CO\.UER COUNTY. FLORIDA, ll" I ~ UNIT ~2 UNlT~' '. \\ II ~ UNlT 40 \ \ ",.",~ """"" 00.00 1<.". ..~) II \;'~' iii", ~ 9 UNI1 60 ~ ~ I -1':"', I , I. .-- ,- 38 UNIT", UNIT 62 UNIT 61 '2 ' I UNIT 5.'. UNIl'i2 _____ -- _ 6J _n,__ I - ~\\ ' 1" ! ____m ---- ----- I ... - ,- \};;"'-/;':,' " c.~. &/loll ~ UNIl 3] UNll J~ I I 1/1,.;) .. ! I "; ,_ I....'"''''' oN"" I,' III .J~+"Jo 2 i . 'I ' ' -- ! I .., I.~" ( _. " ! < _ I UNIt 21 Ut>!ll 12. 6 UNIT 67 I- :;~, - , .I i .""""'-'- ~u"v...., UNIT &\;1 \JNll e I I \., <ii """-'" I ,""'Ct<~'" Ie... &4.) I I NAf'I.E.--i_",[( ~ lC-". ..I) , i I ",,' -- - I \ \1 ~ ~~ i Ii' \~~} ,.~! ~!i~~ ~ I UIol'110 i UN,T 23 UNIT 14 UIol1125 UNIT 70 UNIT 71 UNIll2 I ~ .j!i!...." ..~ :"'\11 UN,I 97 I g ~'_j~ I i I !.. . - I ---,--.~- I-----~ - --- ~k ~...... ' ,~ 5 ' i r"'ot;:; ~ 1;'1 . ' o"" ; 'lIfACHRO ,,! UNll 96" UNIT 19 "! UN'T11l UNI1 17 UNI1 \6 UNIT 15 UNI! 74 UI-1I1 n 1,\, I.:L - "VANO'."" Ill'AC""""O"L I,' . I \j .'~ .-'---',-- ---- '. IiI') .' , ';:02'1 t ' ,~ Ill; . I! U;~l lIN" '; UNH SUNil 5 UIol,l7 UNIT 10 U/olIT 11 UNIT 14 UNIT 49 UNIT!i UNll 76 UNIT 77 vNI176 I ", ',' [I.. ' ~I~ -"" "" .w",_ -" ,," .wo,_ , 1 ' ~ ~ " ) JUNIT UNlT' ; UNIT ]!i C ,~ ,T 1 UN'T 4 UNIT !i UNIT Il UN!l 9 UNIT 12 UNIT 80 UNIT 79 ' "" UNIT 1] UNI148 UNIT!il 81 I I "",,1.""'00.00 ""0'lm1:t " : '1~." ~i' "UNIT~: UN'.'" UNI' '2 _:tr .:~.:;:. "''' ," "'" '" ---- -ll-~ ---- L_____;__~ U~ll U~-T ~~. --= ~~ 1-- .... \S Hhe...... UNIl 21 n. '.. . -..--" ;... .-.. - 'i' ....... ......., ~-- ------- --_.. --~ to- ~ _ ' "' i ~~". ~..' J :' ," i UNIT)1 I' G.'OlD~N. -.----. , UNlll,.,> I . UNllij> UNIT 116 UIolIT M "-, " . ~., 5 07 r~_ ~ -----;:. ----r -". - ~. - i ' ~ ~ ~ GA TE vNll 21l I ' ? ," ~ .,~ '" ., I UNIT 29 UNIT 30 ~ ," I ,I , , UNlTi ~/' _ I ""'-OE~""'t ~~",""l ":~: CITY I : i. 881 UIolIT 611 UNIT 90 It . - 1- '., ! I I I ' 'I 1 I WIt 1.1r ' ,--- _.~ : ' ' .. ~,,~ ,..."::",'/0 , " _ I I ! ....n__ 'rJr.~' I "'. :" I"'........ I' I. " UNIT UNIT 9'2 uN1l91 1 ! ~A?l"" !OMlOO"""'(C.,."')' ~ _:__~ ! ! i 93 'i' - ! ~=n I ~"IG.'T""I.une'-" 0.)1 I \ < ~ I ,!, 1J1I2A ',~)""~' I " ' I, ' C!TY~ L ~ : I! OF \ " . oa.urv. rjl (S... 0'1 If I, j UNIT 96 UNIT UNI1100 UNIT In UNOl 1\4 NAP! ES \ . i! I : 99 ! I, )\~ ' '1,' "'.; , 1 ~-- --' \ '--, - I: "", I " I III \ I r( i ~ g I i UNIT IU3 \INIT UNIl101 UNIT 110 UNIT 110 ': ' ! ~ ~ ,_ _ 101 o i, ~ I) ,I ~ --- f--- - 1ft i \ > ~ 1 , ' UNIT 104 _"n \ . '._ I.r:': _ .. ,......_00' i O.TlltW.[ ~"'WOCl<:.O.lO UNIT UNIT 111 UNIT 12;\ UNIT 124 to- --~h 11" \ ~ I I (c... ...) I ---- 106 - . ,- ---- --- Itt.-'j .>~ I-' " ! ' \ )c.-;::.., .' I . T ~jJ",-~{\ .'1 '. i i ........, "l'l-w .OAll ! uNit 108 ~~17 UNIT 130 , UNIT 177 ;' (, () '" T I i \ , ~. ' ~n__. _ \ ,'\ i. ' ! " ,I" I "'" '" o,~~ i "''' '" '" "" no "''' no '~::\' ('&3' I -_.~...._-~ - ~. I" '- ' ,". ,,! \"r ~(,. 1\ I (ct I UNIT 112 ~~\l i UNn 140 '. UNIT 137 UNIT HE> \ 'I". \\, J' '.1 '! - \I~j,.l / '\Il-V ")"'. ! ------- -- \1'-"- II' Ij. i ,,;I -'~-- 'I I"~=' \ i \'\' ',:'.'1'\.\ \ I " ' UNIT 141 UNIT UNIT 14J UNIT 144 IftllT 145 UNIT 146 UNIT 147 '\ I Ct\\,~" .' I I 1~'2 \\-"--,\7),....1' ...... '. R'I' """",.. I \(("-l-" I'("!) '"~ -.1 ' I pi 0 " III \\:+-~\ -, 1~~>---:1 J // ;~ UNIT 148 ~~; UNn 150 UNIl 1&1 UNIT 1&'2 UNIT 15J UN1T 154 \ \'Pl"'>--' i -I I c,-/-/ 1__/ ;11 ~ 1 _ '\'--,L (, I C ,j ,_/ - 1ft \'1\1',_~", ,"\1) /,'1 ", !e~ .. to "'i,~,,'i ",'''''...\'.)J _,1~\/.- . I, :\e 1 H UNIT 161 l:~ UNIT 1~9 UNIT1S8 VWIT IS7 UNIT t56 UNIT 1i:\i:\ ,\~"--- ',L ~1rf/' I \ ,_ i ~!n 'Ojo" \ . ; : ~\--~ i '~\{J /1 , ,\" UNIT tftllT 1115 lJI.jll Ifill UNIT 167 . \ \\ 1 ", -t~~ -,ie" IIq !/ UNIT 162 163 UNIT \64 \\ \ ,'--.\ \,' (f\'/:,..:; \y/ --,,'" I \~II ~~"VJ;'I // ..' . \,.':~.. .\.\~\ ,..... "'.'~' G.. ".../.-_~'.- 'r./".j~:; II" 'd UMT 172 UNIT 171 . '\t"- .~) '''(r Iff I\." ,ij,.,,', L _'. ,', - \.. \t~ ''''1 :0U(.\..~'~(" J",.~,~."" '.-",-" ' ,.I,," ,K'~~\u~, "" ; 'v / .''-.r':--'~! ""I1.J;::\,' ~TE _Ill', " : (---'!J'.+r'~I, -,.l,' ""I -i- '. '\7~ ,CI .... rJ~~d-tt f.I" I... A\I/ r~')" ~f: I 't ""'. ,"--' \ // .... r. 0>" "1,'(''---_ '. c~ ..", ' ' '" N -'.\~~~Ol 'I~,.' '\\ '. \ I" 1/1 \' ~. \ \, ',-, 1"~ (('-~\ ' . I, - . N l\ ~ '1." \~ ~ 1/1 ' \.." . . - '," , - I: --- ---- .~ ~..<O\PO"" r" R f-r";;;. ',,-:,/) I.... ~ I r r---1 to W E. II,' ,. ) I ~', """ ',\ i i ( .. '" .! I Of . ,I >' "r ,I :,;~~,:,\ _/-'~, (' ,.,., MARCO i! '-. I ,.,' " ~) , d ' S 'SLAND (,~_.;4---- \, .11'1.',' 0006..", '(/ .ir" I,J - ,. I' I.. I · !,.-'::f\ J, j I'.'. Ii' _ l',l ~(--'i(i"j AV'U'", , __SCALE .-=~>_",_~~c/ '.'r," ,I.,. (';'r.': ': (.. ,'., ',' ,; '. ' I r==,- -,--,--=,' I,;, ' _, --- . ,I: "I, -'., " '1\-' - ' o 1 MI 2MI .31'.11 4MI lEGEND PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER I - DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATION 2 - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D u--1-- . - - ~-49.840--- ::I - TOM HENNING -=~------~--50,759 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KIE 3 ~---48:3~ 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. -4 ----H-li2,034- _ INOICATES COMMISSION DISTRICT LINE -- ------S" ~=-' ~~=_ ~===50,~1~ PREPARED BY: GRAPHICS AND TECHN!CAL SUPPORT SECTION sum 251,3n COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DATE: 10/2001 FILE: COM-DIS1-MAP--2'oWG / PLOT: AUTOCAD.PAL R 25 E R 2& E R 27 E R 28 E MAP #3 ! -1m.- I - \--T --I ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES " !,/ " ! "~, _."w' ,,:~,! I- BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' 0.'" "m" ""' ~ "" I '- __ I 1 COlUER COUNTY. FLORIDA I "I; """ """ i \ II I ~ IJNIT 40 I , \ ~". "'""~"'7' ..., II ' ,. I 1--- .. \~~'! 0 . i , 1 ' lO G _ uNl! ~~li~ .. \ "'"'.'. \\ 44 a UNIT J9 UNIT 4~ , ! ~ II lEE COUNTY I -- I ~ ! Ii'! I, 1 -1 I I I II, I ., UNI1 UNIT 59 UNIT 60 ' ~.~~_ ~ I'; I '1- - ." 't-.. UNIT !: UNll6Z UNI1..61. I , ~ " I UNI1"~ UNII "2___.X-~._- 6;) .-." p--- ~ I I ~---- I &II \;t!'\' "__.' I '"' I UNII!!1 UN\l ~ I ", ". ".:" I '., ' "..~ I UNIT 64 UNIT 65 i, ." ., ,'\ " I . I- ,"'. ' ~ \\' ~\y~ ':), ~ i ,:,:: ""-.,, ""'" 1 I I- ~ ~ I,"'..., I " / U~'U i ""...lv/oIlIl UNIT 69 lJlill 66 ' 2. ~H'U~ ,,; ,...Ol<Al[[ "".1 le._ "') I Nm.. ,....01<.....[ ~""'l (~.. ..f) , I I \ I ,: I, .'m - , 1 I, i lJ!<lll 20 ~ Win ~.j UNll 24 Utltl 2~ UNIT 70 UNII Jl UNIt 12 I ~ I : UNII '<7 i ;, ~ . ~ 5 ---.---.il--------. ..-- ---.----- .--- - --- 1 ^'<Ili ' ;:, >l jij '" lB("'I;~O "I ., " \.INIII\I", UNlf 1(1 UNII17 UNIT \6 UNIT 7'" UNO 74 IJNI17J ' ,H ..." UNII96 ' . 'l .......-n.f Ill""" """~ " _ 1 ---- --' ;:! ._ "~~ .._..' - -----.,,- ---1--.- \!\} , "' I ! " , g :: ~,;~ UNIT 2 UNII J Uf'l." '. UNIT 7 lINIT 10 \lNIT \t lJNll 14 UNIT 49 UNIT i'>l UNIT 76 UNIl n UNI1 78 I ~! I , I - I ~~ ~." ~" -,,,- ~." ~" .-,- ! -' UNn H' UNIT ,,, J " ~ UNII J~ 32 \)N114 lINI1 '" IJNlt 8 UNIT 9 UNIT 1;" UNIT I'IQ \lNIl 79 I!NIT!:'> UNI148 UNITe.l III - , , ......ox.E."'" c......) . - --~_! III ....~ B"'.Hv"~D --'-._- ._~- -. L-.~ T- -..-.. .-------0- ! III "~' I ,,' ".UNlTJ4.UNI12 UNIl" .UNllt9" liN\l1\H i II -~ UNIt I ~ IJNlrn ' I I 82 lJN118~ 1!Nll11~ . UNIT'l1.__,______ 0 I- -.' \: _./""- -_, -'--, I -- , ~ II:-I,I ~. ~ UNIT Jl i ~"OLD, N -0----- UNII III., i f!' U~~I! UNIT 86 UNIT II~ ~ --------:' ~ _~____ ! ,_' I; " J ~ ~ ~ ~ GATE uNn 21\ I '"l r---'- ,1 "" ___'" uNIT 211 UNIT w! , , ~ . ~ " " . liNll' ~_ ~ 00(1)[" c.o.'( P"""'" "-'"R. _1 CITY, 88 ~ UNIl 119 UNll 90 I - t . _ 1 f. I "~ ~! i "---'---- ",lTR"AI<." " ! ----- ~. , i! " ~ !< ---- ----' . I 'l. i I . ---;J - 'i I iil ~ '- 'coli i" J uNIT UNrT'n \ ~ ~2<P"S:J ! I I,~. .==t=.. " 9:'> UN\l91 < ~ ~, "'010"<1.'0 (CO. .!>O) --- -... ....... 'I Sf _ .. ,! - - ~~> ."....!I)Ir'l..,Y(U...j " ' ' ""'~., \ S) ...PCll! i ' 4' ,I -- ~~ -- .~. -- CITY --\--~ I l \ ,,,,~~. I ~ 'j i; I ! OF \ ..~' ~ oj",. ."",,'v 'lll5-"..'} i', I I lJN1t9~ UNIT UN\l100 uNlll1J \lNlT 114 ,I NAPLES\, 1 , ig I I 99 ____ _ ' \" , ') I' "~~ -"--~-"-- .----.-.- ~---- ----- " \-'. I i ~"I! ' III \ ( ) . I j 1 1_ UNII 10:'> V~~T UNIT 101 UNIl 119 UNIl 116 \ I\J'\ ~,! I o ' \ I ' , ..---- e--' .~. ---.- 1ft \ \ "( ~ ,L=no. UNIT 10~ . {--, ;\, all L I UNIT UNITt21 uNIl12J uIoll1124 t- I I \ '-I I : I r i i ~,---..-- \06 "5'..' '\1-' I' 1 -- ".- -- '- ... ., \ ~__! 'j_' i ., I 1 --- I -~ 'f~---':;::i \- I : ' I, uNI! \_'~" R ( i i i I.---------L-- ~_L i~ "0..., I UNit 10~ t07 UNI1 t;\O UNIl \27 ,- C " ' 'I I \ r' '-,"\ : I '__u__'! - 1- '. \,' ill: UNIT 109 lIl~~ j> UNIT 1.11 UNIT 04 \.INn O!i , ' '([,' , '-', i " I \,.-' 1....') " I , I~ ~ \,\ I (--?1 I UNll 112 Ul~IT uNll 140 q UNll1J7 lINIl 13fi \1 ",- " I" j, ,,(j "f - \. :;/)1 ' ' )! -y, ' \~ \)\ i ~ ~ . ulolll 141 'ftJ UNIT I~J UNH 1~~ l/tolll 1411 UNIT 146 UNIT 147 ~,\.." "." I ,1.'J't'. 'C d ".",,"~ , ,,~"'J'-'~ I,ee ' . : 'f~' I III C) 'iK 1:\,,". -~-', ~~....~Jt !r? ," ! uNIl 146 ~~~ UNIT 150 UNIT 15\ UNIT 152 uNIl 153 UNll 1~4 \ \),;'::'j _j' \\/-J); .\l ~ 1- _ \\ __.' ( I. .r' -,' III '''". '\" '" \,,': f " , \1\ ~ 1'/ < I- f~- ~ Gi _.. " .. " ,UNIT 16\ ~~~ uNIl \59 UNIT 1511 UNIl 157 UNIT 15& uNIT ll1l1 ':1 U \. j/ " I ll'-:,' '10-"'" ' ~y~~'Jl "i[1\" t ' : !\\.~\\; ~-,,:'I.tJ~"'" . UNIT UtllT165 UNlTl&6 UNIT 167 . \\-'\ ,I ,\l)'l... II Ie! \ UNit 1&2 16J uNI1164 '\\ \ i"\ ,---&\,I v 1 ~v/ ..____.j-, I .. \\J i ~",.\/ \' > 'Ie "o'-A~: ' __,L_ \\~\\ '. \ ~'. "\ \ f ,,,,", '" " \...._\ . \L.....'....-_'.'.'j"""_h'."'- L,. l' , .""",..0. - UN11172 UNIl171 I '.' \t\-r~f\-'r- j_ 5.... .. \ .' ~\'~~ 1;1'<'>\r:l\\I(' i V ''"::1.,", "."r-' ~' i----"'------'.. , \)'1-.0 / i', I ' ,-\, '\) '(i .\. '-. ,ATE" PARIl'.' " ,. 'i. "," "~~:..l~1 ,I' C, ' , ('" J" ~I,rl("" ! ""- ... '/(_ ' 'J ,,( I r I 1" 1 1\ f' (~'\!I't,.. I ~ ,ce: f, , ri.'..') ,-. '.1 l I( .1" 1\.., ~ '\ I \ \: . I IT-I : N '''\~~\ \.:" ~t~\" / . 1/," ;... ' ... L , 1ft + ":~.:,,\_ ...-;:~~\).I\I/\f}~~ r) -f-..J;~l I-T"I\ Ie" I-.T I- W E" II, ,\~ "~,:-::;:\ .' J I I n'. Iii : i CITY ~i.- \ "~M (y , Jv?;' Q \iL:: " ..r~)(\/;L:\ ...1 ! f""'!--.( " OF ^J,,' \}, . "'"-'Id.,, MARCO ~ L I I "" -' i.. ~ S . 'SLAND ,tbr,,~' I "\,,' (C W4~ i,' l /L\\ I'''''. . ,~\ . i:~ . I SCAle \.... ~j,..Jf~I.c'''c. J..... :1 "'" I, ,i/" ill/\I; "j c1"'! "r--..,I\.! . ___ ,_, .~. . I II,A-\ I. \1 f I I ----+-----------l-------~ (1-, ~- '~"'.('; I \ -"/!',- '8 o 1 MI 2MI 3MI 4MI lEGEND PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER I - DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATION 2 - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D---l'- ------50~145 . 3 - TOM HENNING - -2--- .-----50473--- - n_' _ ' 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KIE- -3-- - -----50~375-- 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA. Jr. 4" ----u50341- - __...._ ____..n --.."" , _ INDICATES COMMISSION DISTRICT LINE - - 5 --- -"~-~-_==_~~~043 =~- PREPARED BY: GRAPHICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECTION sum 251,377 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DATE: 10/2001 FILE: COM-DIST-MAP-J_DWG / PLOT: AUTQCAO.PAL R i!5 E R i!& E R i!7 E R i!8 E MAP #4 I Iii I---r-i III ! "I"" I ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES r" I, \ .m.. -~.~ "',-' I- BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ;, I "'H" ""'" "''',,\- --'-- COlUER COUNTY, FLORIDA, 11 I, ~ ~ UNIT ~2' UNIT 41 \ II II ,,'" UNIT 40 . \ .",,,,~ ~ liE""" .""" l~.", ..~) II 1 ~-- - ... --- IC\N'J~J _ i ~( I, ! & 'Z ~ ~ I uNll \:~:~i' ,\. , ',' " ' ' .. i "''''' "''''' , (" , , ; '" II lEE COUNTY ,,' , , ,- ,,- ~~~~'\;" ~ 'I/~'" i , I' \ ! I _' UNIT UNITfJ9tNI160 f ~ i ,,'- ! I ,'-- 38 UNIT !: UNIT 62 UNIT 61 ~ '= I" I ' " UNIl 5~ ut>lll 52 _~~ _______, ___m___._ 63 n'.______ ~; , ----! III "r;~ c..."'" ~ UNIT 31 UNIT ~6 " "'" I e. llNITf>4 UNI165 i ~,,'. ' I-- .. ,. lD " ' "- i 'III '" ~ ~,.-.l\':.,: 2" ~"~ UNIT ?1 UNIl n UNIT 67 t- ' p\ ,,/", .1; , " ,- I UNIT 1>9 \.INIl 68 I \U" 'I I ',: I ..,.,.." ."<"-,V'OIl I ~ N"""S ,...""....[< "pi (c..." ....IES-I.-.oo..,[[.lI.AI.I IC...ll<lll' -: ---- \ ! '. " ' , .- - 1;:;1'1 1 ! liNt I 10 If Ul<lll 13 IlNl1 2~ UNIT 25 UNIl 70 UNIl 71 UNll 72 \,,:t, ! UNIT'll ,a~ _. i" I' 1 >--_! ,5 ~b- ,~ ii ' . " ....'91:."".0 -;. I" " lINII 19~ UNIT18 UNll17 UNIT 16 UNIT 15 UNI114 lJNI1IJ , ," .... ' IJNi'T 96 1 'j/ '\ 1J~ '- .. ..,T IIl"C" """V'" _1__. ___ _ .._,,_._-. "', ::/ f I =~ ~--= -- --- ,...-..' ..-" I j' " 01 ,., ,.. \\. . ~ G . ; U:~l llN,r 2 "Nl1.~ UN,T 6 lINIl I UNIl 10 UNIl \1 UNIT 14 UNIT 49 tJNIT t)l UNIT 76 UNIl 77 UNIT 78 , .., I 'I".' ~ .&; , ~ l',UIJlM "'It _<1_ _M G01E lOUI.tV_ " " , ,'- -- . _! ~ ~ UNIl. 11 I UNIT ~ UN'l .\5 ,q I IJNl14 UNIT 5 UNI16 UNIT 9 milT \2 " UNn 80 UNll 79 _. UNlll.l ~~B ~~ \ PIMEi"IIlGI'.QlD C.H....' III . -, _.~ J--' --'.-. '- --- L,--- .-- en \'1;". , UNI1.14 UNI12 UNI115 UNll \94 IINIT 19J, \ UNll ~ 'N 9 UNIT.!) . B1 UNI15l UNllB4 .. 3 UNIT V ! I ., ;;,. - .. .--- ..-~. 1!1 ~-. -- ............, -- --.--- ---- ,I '-- I- " . ,,' <;'J. ~ ;; ~ ~ ~, 1--- . UNll 19'> I 1 Ii' cJ., "- 1"::; ~ UNI1 Jl i GOLD!: N ' , u~~ Il'j UNIl 8ti UNIl" 01 " : l/F' '5' I, " -- ~ ---r.----- , ..- ~ i ~ GA TE UNIT 2ll: - -- ) "~ "~ uNIT 10 UNIT ~O ~ I _: !I' UNIT i I ~ 'or _ <lOlDl':N G.ATE ........... ~c,.. 8lllI) (;1 r I' I 118 SUNil 89 UNIT 90 -c'. < ,,,1__ - .' ! Ii" I." " !' II' ~'!i"-"-" . . \ I t I -- ,,--- " ! _" !i1! --1;:'- - .. I ! I 1 I ! "'--- " f~--~ l;g: '! ,,---.. "-... I,: i I i I UNIT UNl1!12 UNI191 I )?Pl<S ~ I ~ ...tliQH<lJ(l (c..""') -~__~ do:: . ,93 '< . --..--' 7" ~ -~....... - --.- 1.."'-~"",1""1"lJ."1'.....); , -,- I' ,,1 "'" , , i' I" ".. a J ...."", ~ ' 4 I - CITY _ I /'''-'-' ~ ! ~ i ! ! Of '~l[\,...I,f"("""') !f I UNIl9~ UNIT UN\1100 UNI11U UNIT 11. NAPLES . Ii. 9\1 . I I~ !_.",.I · I . I I I ___ - -1---- ) "') ,.CH .. I I "c., I' "...., 'N ".--r stC~'" ~" , , -' ,I r 1'. M>-l. f! I ' I "" III 1(.' 1 1,1_ i. I i I '_ UNIl 103 101 UNll101 UNIl 119 UNIl 115 "" , 'i ',~r,/ ' "[ -----. o \, j/ ~ ' ~ ,,,,"5""., / - ',( '" I " N. ><<'1" 1ft \ i. ~ N"",n,..,,,'"" IJNol \04 \ ..I.-?,_ .. l~SSOO" R"f~[_""''''' ~ UNIT UNIT 121 UNIT123 UNIl124 I- i (qJ ,,,.~., i I !' I ,-'- "" ---- I, ~. .JI i, ' ' , , , I ,>C }'" ' ,C ~ \-J...' -?{-O'1 '- I' Ii "'LI' "" "".0 i I Ufm lOB ~~7' UNH 1.10 I UNIT 127 . '~" 'I ' " ' I, I' \ " "'" " - --- J ~ .' ! (,_ ; I U~, 109 U1~~ ';t UNn '.II !)Nil 134 UNIT 13~ \'1", ' . '" i ~I . ~ (\) \" (I r\ \0', \ ~ ( , '" kI ! ':" ,,,,,,,, ~~:' i "M' ,,,' "''' '" "''' H' e It '~Jj 0" I --. - ---, .' l'j - " ) I I . ,(jl ' 1 p<<_) \ I \\ l 1~ \ UNIT '41 UNIT UNIT 1~3 UNll 144 UNl1 145 Ul'4l1 U6 UNIT 147 , ' , 1 ( ('!11."" "J ' I .m.l. ,,, ~~' 1, I~' '.~ .~..~ ,,' 'J (l:-_' y' ; " ___. \ -';:- ,~~./~ I --'Ii 1 III C~ ~ :\ i-,-, ~ ___1(( f Ii _ ' UNIT '48 ~~~ UNIl150 UNIT 151 UNI1152 UNIl '5J UNIT 1!!4 \ )1)~ --:> I I [1... 1" '.. ~ _ -.':J:' ,... L 1 (J 1 '..- III \,'1 \" ,,-- f' f ,,- ,.." " ' ~\~ - ~~1~ h' I~ ~ ! UNIT 16' ~:~ UNIT 1~9 UNlll511 UNiT 157 UNIT 156 UNll 1f1~ I- 'l l 1 " ' I ~~_ it; l: (.;:(, " I ('______ l!') J?" ': 1 . ,Ii 1 I C I ' 1 UWll 1~5 UNIT 1&5 UNIl 1&7 ' ~~~'.. . \ .t. ..11 "'. ~I)...(j ~ "'" '" ~:\ "'''..''' \\ '\ (,\'/~ $J/, I ~ ~. "'" ' ~ \ 1,1 ~ ,://(' /_ -',- 1 _, I "u;-- I \, \ ~ '-- ~" 'I, L, ::<;'1 ICe" I' "''' '" "'" ",' ~ ~"}y"'-'I\.- - 5;' ') _____, i- I \~\'" !r(~~~~ /~:- \o~,-o1 ,-------- \\. .c" ;:!;]3 ,,/' C lEA IE.IN E " '..'Jltn\/t.. IN.'...' , \'I:\J~(-> ., 'I 1\ ':1:"~' ~' " " ,," '" " ,'V /1<;:;-'.", '" "I'L '. >)J' '" "" " (. . C\\./~';J : L, ',; ,e) I ' 'X' -r--'.'fll'i("/i j ,i l'-..... I" I v)/,')$'" ' , ~,', ~ '" '" . ""1 i lA'/" 1, l' ~ . I V ; .1 [.' .\';",~, ~~(\hY \ ) I -'-, III N '\~ ~ \> ~0.~?C--'tl ((, I. ! , - ::: \ 1",~' ~'" ;~'> I, I', rr'" '- WE. '\r.'''\~ II ..q;~ -t;;';;' c,J ) '" '''"' . 'I, I' 'I 1 t- \ ;J I ,0" 01) .. -j I -r -... j- + C,TY // '~~ ~ VIS', ,\{l~;>~ (, ,(/ff, I' ! .-Ji ' :! 1_ I , OF ......It \1\ ,). I('(~ ~ ,,' i .- 'r-' ~ -jliii;,:,r MARCO \ (' " \ I ~':"'::'" I ' ,I, _ S ,SLAND '. lit!).. -X.' '" ".1., l\~~, I. 'i( !V;,ri\f^,. i i'l"".i,"; I ~<' II ,.. SCALE ". li-,.;,--"Ctl.-:.:=, 'I, i . (,,1 .) '1, I. . ! i' 'i' ,. I r::::=:.::~' I I I - - r d' ': jl I 1,-" I'\./ '1";., /t\..~~W -- - o 1 MI 2MI 3MI 4MI lEGEND PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER I - DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATION 2 - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D ._~----_. 50,229 3 - TOM HENNING -~----- 49,492 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KIE ----3-u--50~il84-- 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr.H4 n__ '" ---50;341-- _ INDICATES COMMISSION OISTRICT LINE ~=_ ~ ~~~~~--=-=~-~-~!~--- PREPARED BY: GRAPHICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECTiON sum 251.377 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DATE: to/2001 FILE: COM-DIST-MAP~4.DWG / PLOT: AUTOCAD.PAL R 25 E R 2& E R 27 E R 28 E MAP #5 . l' T 'U. I-'I-u UI ' ", II' ! " I ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES r ! .."'.-.".. "..", ," .~I' II t- ' uNIT ~7 UNIT 46 ' BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 0.'''. I 0" COlUER COUNTY, FLORIDA i i ~- ! , I;!. liNI147 UN\T41 ,.,,', \ II " UtlIT40 . , .OM'. ~ 8[~CI' "0"" 10... aoo) II i f----- \[N"~ .1 # ',! - in ' ' . . ' I ,.. > \'.'i '" I ,,"' ' u I UNIT 39 UNIT4!> \:~~' ,",' " ',J? \\ LEE COUNTY "~--I--.. ["'.-.. ,.- ',-, I"" 1! I, ~ I i UNIT UNlT!:I9 UNIT eo t\;~~ -<!"'., " -- -- 38 UNIl ! UNIT 62 UNI1 61 ! j ., I UNIT &3 UNlr!>2 1--___ __ _' _ _, ____ IU_________ , Iii I i I I UI c...... ~ I ')NIl ,\1 VNIl ~6 I p. " " "~~;j','\,' 'I "''''' "''' '" " i" .' . ' _, ,....,,~ I ~ 1 I'" I, --- "'..! r- "I ! I \",'J'.! -. 2, I~ ,I I' ',""" "''''' I' ,,,,,,,, i I- .' ~ " [_'~ _,. ' i )i"~:~ I. ._." I ."'.uv,.P IINII f>g \)NIT 68 i ' 2- N.....lH _: ,..."''''-', '0. \~. .,.) ".PLE...b.....o...n." It.. e'l!~ ' 1 \.! 1--1 ' !: '-"''', !" i _. " '~I I UI<,l 20 e U!>lIT)j UNI124 lIti112,) UNIT 70 uNIT 71 UNiT n I I .-:11 J "",T"u,,", , ';, 11 I \,J ~ I. ~!k~'~ UNII9l ~~ I--_~": ________..,__~_____ I ,:,c ---;~ I \:.~ 'Ilf.r.,,"" ,I, '" " B 11Jt<'119~ 1.11'111111 UNlll'l UNIl16 UNlT7!'> UNIIH UNI1H i " " "I' c UNII 96 I a . ~ V..-HeC.T <<.-e" omo "1 _,_ I __ ..i,. i! -.---... ~ - - ----". "...-~ 'Il ' \ ... OC", ~, ~ ,~ :I.i! ~ ,. U~~T UNII 2 UN,T.\ UNIT 1\ UNIT 1 lJNIl 10 IINiT 11 UNIT 14 UNil '19 UNIT!'>O UNIT 76 W'lIT 77 UNll 78 . . j . ~ ;; ~ 2 '" ~ <;OWl~ ""f IlII>l<VHlO l'.OLIIIE~ ....'[ ICULlV_ " i - . ') &: ~ UNll. IT I UNI1 '. '; UNll :\5 ~2' I UNI14 UNIT!'l UNIT 8 UNI19 UNIT \2 ., uMT 1\0 IINIT 7\1 " , ~ . UNIT 1,$ UNIT ~Il U"lll ~,l p"""I.""""<IAil c......., ---.. '" "" .... _1[ II<lLUY..U . --, - --:- - ---___,L-_ -'-"__ 1---.--.-- __.u__ III l'iii'!" , !hi '" '.' UNIT 34 UN1I2 111'11115 UNill!l4 IJNI11~J i UNIT .. ),[1 ~ UNI.}} uNlf 21 'i' '" III UNll11~ UNll H4 .s I,. ---- -- ...' " i?: - .. I ' , , _. -. --", ""-. I ..____u I- l~, ~.I ", III I. " ~ ~ I-'IJ :.. ~ 'i \JNI13J i ~OLD' N ---;:-- . UNIT 19~' '" :.; i UNn! UNIT 86 uNIl 8!'l ,,! ' ! I . ~ I' "i . - f------;: ---r . GATE I ,~- --- ~ ::i ~ I UNI! 711 ' I i "~ I~ _.., _- UNIT:?!) UNIT30 l , _ ..' I NIl ('''d ;;:,'" -" ., ~." "" ,-_. ..:"" -," e,n : " I .",,! "':""''' " r "~. ~. 1 " ,___'___. ,,,,1,.,,. I I, -, -- -. " I . : t; . ~ ; _____..:: '=--,_~ " 1--- t_>. '::._ _'j? ,,~,,- : UNIT UNIl!lZ ' 'i Nmt':i I -~ 1 , I '. 9,~ lINlT Y1 ':g' ....""~"..n' ~ ,. , -" ..' I t'. ...... . - ! """''''" .."" 15~ .'J , ' , g ,'. I ' _ ___U~~" 'i : '" ..,pr"" E !~' ,. - - _.._- I CITY _1.----.:.. -----::::::::::. i : I OF ..J4! \... .i.l.."... '" '" ..,! UNIT 9K UNll UNIT \00 UNIT II} UNIT1\~ j I NAPLES ~. j t 99 J ~ 11 I,,, .._, __- ,_ue-'___ u---i- < ,,-,.I" ,i P , In ' 1'/ i~ " i ! UNIT 1(]3 ~~2T UNn 101 UNIl 119 UNIT \Ill Illl, :!i ~ 1- o " I;, ' I, , ----- UI i I. ~ tlNll lQ~ l"______... \ __I ( ... ."r,....'SOOIOll ."'''S"''',....uoc..i,w UNIl UNIT 121 lINI112J UNIl\;r4 1-1" " \1 U! "..., I ! , "" . -' 1~',5).) '. . '" , 1--. - I C:....--- '( , , \j . '~'-"'J.'- ~ I' ..... ..i.L~ ~""o UNII 1011 ~~Ii lINIT \.10 UNll \27 -' , "" "\i '" i T I \l ,,<" ' ':,,;" cd---- -- 1-- -- \ (,.... ~ j , liNn 10\1 Ul~~ 'I UNIT IJ\ It' UNIl 13" UNIT n~ ,:" . . ,," I I _uu_u__.... 'L',.'.. "I., ":t- I .. ~ --~ "':"", ~ i __ I "- i I q ~ \' \';");__'-'~ \\: I ('r t I UNIT 117 ~~\li UN\11.0 "UNll1}7 UN111;)6 \;'\' '.\~'r" ',': " " "('. , ~ '..' 'I I ----- \.'. "\7 " ./1 ' I \)1 .....' /---") I J,. '.;\..J'.\ I" I"~ i UNI1141 UNIT Uf'l1T l~J UNIl \.. utlll145 U~l141l UNIT 147 \!i\ (;- ~\..__ _, -:! \~2: ,"', ' ,',,"__ '1 ell ." ' I "I ., '~""'n"""I,' ," i ,~' , ,{( --j: .. 1.-_--C;f:,-0--,--...-_y;' ,Y 't UI '~~ ):' __~r:_:'-~-)f' .{/ p': UNIT 148 ~~~ UNIT l'!lO UNIT l!;l UNIT 152 UNI1 153 UNI1 1!'l.t '~'\ I'!,!"" - [i -, ,.. . < ''''") i II <,r ( !a ~ I Ui \., t \' "---. ," ;0 I !~ :;; , " . \ { ~ 'If f '- j~ ~ i" UNll 161 ~~~ UNIl l!lll UNIT Ifill \mIl 157 UNIT 156 UNIT 1!)!> I- \,[ \ ,\\ 'I 1, ',- I \ ~ '"",,1'1 I ' ' ,---' .-. ~ (' _ I l- l"ll '" f'-l ':'. i II , \ <<\1 ~ l- I, '. I UNIT UtllT 165 IJtllT lliB uNIT 1&7 . i \\ '\ I\-t~~ ~v!iq;'7' -I, I ' UNIT 162 163 UNlTI6.t \\\ \ I ,j ,,\-.J I, II ' '_-~~ /> , "J\' '..'" ,'. , I , '\ i ~ ,.\, ",'v _"i ('" .. ,- I I \, \' \ "',..\" '''''' ...n, ! e -''-, "J " ,~~" ,^ 'V!! ' Q!',~~r~,j~rl (,' .! '" cl~ r~~~F~!;L\' leJ ,,\ Iii" ~.. .. : N'\;.~\~t.,,"~.~~i, kl' ,! "I, I I ........ UI ~ "''',""~ ~."~., ( I" \ 'I I- WE". ",,, J , -~"""". ',. '-'.j_, . I '~.. - I + ClTY"~' \.,:.. ~/ ,I,. :~'''! ,:' . 1",1)~. ,'I ",1:1 , " 11 I. I i ,/ ';;f'" !' 'I' 'r'" ~ 11\'" .'! II I .1. .! or './ ,; , _ J' '; : ij , .' , !' (U.S_ '." ' MARCO'<. " I . '", ..' I..' .....1 ; ; S ISLAND \ u.. "I~\~J'\JI'^V~ 1m:~ \J J~I((!/\h~ ;r.. ;'\J\rJ, b"l' I SCALE . '--.,,=::,/,lce)\cco>Jt.! (\1 '~. ' 'j,', ' I I ;1'. '-+ "-. I I ' ,---_ I 1--------1-----' --.-- -j..1<_ ._....L.. 'l") .. \ '/ / . ' . '..! \.}l i I !------ ._-----1 j (, _ _ f~. I' i"'''"'' )', .:...:.!.. - --, o 1 MI 2MI 3MI 4MI lEGEND PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER I - DONNA FIAlA DISTRICT POPULATION 2 - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D ---"1'-u- u_ '51;S~- 3 - TOM HENNING -'--2: --.- 48.626 4 - PAMElA S. MAC'KIE ---u3-u- ---49.576 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA, Jr. -4u.- ---50;209- _ INDICATES COMMISSION DISTRICT LINE -------=~--~~--~ =~ -------===-!i:}!.~~~ PREPARED BY: GRAPHICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECTION sum 251,377 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DATE: 10/2001 FilE: COM-DIST-MAP-5DWG / PLOT: AUTOCAD.PAL R 25 E R 25 E R iii!7 E R 28 E MAP #1 --r I m.._,___ ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES: :! ,,--: "' :' ",,:., "":',, :~ ._:.. '":~ BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 1---' ----L- ___ __ ~,,~ _.m_ __ COLUER COUNTY. FlORIOA , I " I!. ' I "' -- .. "' " \ I "' "''''' ~," . , ' "",," I ' -. -........,1 -' ,. --.- ~+- .. - I \l"" i '< .- - . ~ I u,"' ! ~---,', . ,001~.ij '"' .\;/" "I 't" i ~"" """" 1. I _ ~ ~I iI. \\ LEE COUNTY -r _ I~_ ,-- -- - ------1------ ,.- -~ - 1 --f----- : , " (; I I , . L",T """," UNI'." ,I I \'t~, I ' ,f .." .,", I' -" "'" ! "", ,,"''' ", L ~-----II- I....' ---- . .m ,,-- l':"'c' ""'''- -- -- J'- "- -- - -. I III 1'('\'."'00-":7"- "'". I "''''' ,.".' , " I l'v~~"" "~I - 1 ....... ,"".. ""'"' I lD (,,'~b,,1 P -~ -;--- - -- . ,I I "\k/J\::Y~ .....".' I . r I""". """" "" """,," ! " ~ \ J;;<- "; r--' I " 'i . i""""""" "'O,"" ~"".. I 'J.. "........ ".. '~L'" ........ .. f<-< _,I , I \,'^! 11"1 I I I " "I~, \.,~ "I . ", i < . i' ct. ,. I ~! UN" 2"1 u"n" """ Z' ~"" 10 uN" '" ""11" "N"" :, ". ...,~. \""B' , t - ,,- 1- f\~- .... r;;r, - - - " --' m --1---' - ---. Ii, ~ ,,'''''' f- "I .,. " , ' ,,' "I" I """... """.. ,,""" ",,"" "",'" """,. ",,"" l \ I \ 0 Uhl .. ~ , 'I, I, -- ,-, ,-., ="', I" 'i--' ' ____I.. -,--I t, i jj, I" I '. LN" u"'" L'N" 3 Ii"'" """ 7 "."", ""IT" ",,"" "."f" lJ"fT~ ".ot ,. u"T77 I)N",. \ \ 'r, ,!,"''' , \ "__ I" ! ,'. __!___ (_____ ~,,".- ~-"'''-- \ . I ' "";"':1"" ' """ -1 ". . " U~" '5 '.. LJ."t. uNI. " "N"" "Nil I "N" " . ,< ""'.0 "NIT 7il I I - .~ ~I~ ~~ ~f~ . III "',-- ..- -" " -.-,,," '- ----'---r-~'- -------'1- " .. ~" , " " ,,""" """'. "''''' ,.",,, 'N"" '. '..'.~' "1 ... ~l :,_"",,,1 UN"" uN"" . ." I." .1 " ..' ......'., "'<la' ". I- I ?j . _ t t' ..J:'" r ~:c, -, 'm__ 1~,,~,,~I: -L.,~ I ~"-i": t, ~} ,:-: ":,:," ,..I ~ jCl --,: . ','/we """'" , I " .";)_m_ -:-t--, 1-1 I-t--~. - I '" ,,'" "0 " " "'" """ '" -< ;,C I ' ". f..-" """. 1 """.. ,,""" ' 1 "j .) ~ ~ .m,,," ,,,,,. "~_'"I "" I " '" " ~~ ~ r" .\' 1 ~: . ." ,1-- __ ,__ I" ---.- .. ,- "",,! Il!" "~',, 'I l.-t--- ~-- I C-- ".~. ,.. ~."' = '"'" , "I"" ' ~'''''''' ""B' ~ ~ ""''' J ~ I" ., OJ --, -., -....,-, I 1 \----,.. ' " , , ! 'J ): r i "': "". "" r-' . I" ," I'" , , OC I '. "..".'~ 1.1 j' \...1' .1" ",,"" "~'. '."'" ",,,,,, """" """",~ t,.. , _ Ii - '_ "j<,-, 1,1."", I, '."',, III. \ 1 I, i! ~ --t ~ L I - --j_ _._ _ +- .-__-1___ _ "~'_'_:' .:~_ u..t__'~' _ . _ U~' ,,. ,,..,, "" _ o C' IX., I"!! l' "I. ~ I I f 1- -- III L', /)'" ".."__ "~__[_~-'.' """",0< ~:: """"j ,,,,,.,,, """"'1 I- -" J 1''''-' , , B' .. ,_om_ - -.1... ^/ "" I ".,,-' . fJJ, ", I ~" ":" ", ,. , ,,' "", o il,' ~~ I -. -1- f--- '",,*,-,- u t__ '."'"'' ,,' ",,"~ '_,_ .1-- ".""1, __I ~" " ,~.. " "I,' ' I '-- ,. \t~ it"f--". ' '--t -I" i ,. !-." ~_: ".."", ",~~l ".~ --.:" - :."~'"::''' ~ " ",,, , " ".' '"'' "" I 1-h ':'1 -,- (\) ~ -n-\;--I'-_~ lil.!---.--__I_ I I _I":,~~:du:.,,d-"--.". ,..""" ,,""" u \~ ,," ,)1, , ' >- "I' il, C';i r!j. " . I ' , , i CJ \~ "'!:~A~I , ",,,.... ~'I' '!' "I, __om",,______ _u_ _______u___ II' () J. ".~.--~~.~~ Ji--------+~- ._ !I-.--..-..-.-___L u"",," ~~; "",T'lo W"~, """'5' OJNI'''J ""."~' .. :,..., I 1 1/', ,I , I' L.,__, -----.m--r---.. in - ~JY'-. "\,-,' ., ~ ~ ,. I" " I I ........, \:\"1 to/' i' I I I ... ," I." ",," ", ~:: """ ," ".."" "''' ," ".". "''' ",I I- ....~!\-V-- .--'t---.~ ..-... \-_ ._._"..., I, \'.. ",\" ~'~ ,... --. ""'-r--'- " ~';'s' , , , " " , ~c" Va j I I. '.' , "'. i" ,"m.' "."" """"., ",,"'" ' ! i \Lty-? ft---o- __-+-_ _ ' __.~__..____ u..'"l '" """,.. . "- :'\~_2 \'l ~ P::"'~' [ ;-- -.--- --- I ....,,, I \\" i"l\\ ~ '\.' ;f" v;;:-J" I ' i " '.." ". ., I. n~.\~.. ". i. '".' j", . " ~ ~\it15'--- '\. \' I 7"'" I I. .......... ... '. lI'I" Tn U"" 111 \ "",.. I. ,,~ ~ ( ~-c'-./1'" ,,'. ,. - f-- -.:----t-. ~ .-\- '.. . . ''',,'/1' :.::.. II' / ".,";"" " i , , '\ VL cJ'. /0/ ," ,,', ',,'" I . " " v (IL 1'...+ .Lj"> LI 1 me ) ,. . '11,,,-1--- "\--- k\" , ", _/~ I I ,1(.. \!"'1~.".. :C.~~l~/~ .~\ ".'" 1 '., L., '. . I "J . "''' " \ '-.. ~ ,11./'"'' ,,-;; ~~' " ' l I ,,' " '" N "'\._'~ ":_~ "--\,'t;\' (/\" ,,,) _,,_. ___ __ _ __...___: _.._~____.. + \ ,'ell(,; i:p , , ill ,;;,w~ '. ~ "';:':', . f,,', , ",,' " I' 1-'1- ,--- -m_~ """"'''' ~. , /;':", I I W . E \ )),.-.. ~'" ':c:..' c/(- ---+,-,.. I ~ ___kJ..+ --- I- en. ,," ~\J;J;\(f....~~dt:."\'\\ '. '.f,,,ra:r''''~I,I.l ,I" ". .1.. ~"'k --- ,,/ - ")) !,,'JI="J'iJlj f,~ ,,, I.IARCO ~ \ - ',/._ r(j ,~_-:.J. ~.. ----- - ~ _ S 'SLANL' "c!:' r I "': . ),-;-,-;' 1/__" r- I 1. J ~ \ -r:. c --- __se:A,'_ ,'=8"tSJJ'\Y!J'_J< / ,,' hi" : \""\i,':. J,rtc;i ..lY~_ -' ,.--- =---1----= __ L 2J'\I.~..-1--, Ii ,V ,L,,_ ""_,,,_ a 1M' 2MI 3MI 4M' LESEN.!'- _ PROPOSED OISTRICT LINE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER I - DONNA FIALA DISTRICT POPULATION i! - JAMES D" CARTER Ph"D .'1"-----.49,840 -- 3 - TOM HENNING -''2---- 50,759 4 - PAMelA S" MAC'KIE .. :i .------50,818 S - JAMES N" COLETTA, Jr. 4 49,731 _ INDICAHS CO~M1!SlllN DISTRICT UHF _____~__ ___ 5O,431'-~_--- PREPARED BY, GRAPKICS IIND TECIINIC"L SUPPORT SECTION sum 251 3n COMM\!NITY D[\I[LOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVl510~1 , DATE 10/7001 FI'_E: COM~DIST-!,lAP-'OWC I PLOT AUTOCAD.PAL R 25 E R 26 E R 27 E R 28 E ~ COMMISSI::A:S~~ICT LINES -:'- 4-- - --. .. -rTT- -- -:~ ..::..1 :-~ ... BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS .... "_""" ~'" ,.,., ~".~ .. " .. COLLIER COUNTY. fClORIDA " , ., -" i!" . " ---- --...- -- '. I . \. ,,' I" ",,," '""" ., I ~,., 40 ~ -... ---,,,-, --- _ I -I--.~ -'---f---.. -- --+ .--- WI.\'; i ,\ :I .1. \ ~.! ---" ~. l'l ,/1 II lEE COUNTY _I" 1___ ,_I- -" i ".,. ",,,,, - ,..- ';:~ 1:'1 !! -. '__U,"' "",""UN''''' - n_____~_ '\"'\'1 l/l"" .. I " _ I . r .,,!, """" ".. " "'\ .1"_ I I C~'"' w,.,,, :1_ ...._ .' UN'", . ,,--- +- - t I --- - - - --- I -- ---'+--- --- ~\ "I . 1/1 I"~"" ", .. " ~"'" ,,,,,,,,, j "., fl .,. - .. I utI'.< U~".. ~ . I ~ ~l ..- ~ . "J!> -- -; - -- --.. -- - I -- D1P\' , ,~,. " I " :.J . I 1"'"'' """" "II " ~"",... ... \r, t" ~ I " i ........, ""'-"'" """., "N" G" \4- -~-""i -=, "." - "._, - ------1- \Ii! l '\ \ I 1 I i1 ., I" '~' I" I h '~i~i ,.., f,. "I" . f'JN"20! """,~ ,,,.,,. "~r'1~ U",,'O "N"" II~"" \. e:w ~1 ill"'" i. ~------i -- 1:':- .'-:;-, !:'l....;I-~, ---- --- i'------ I ----,-+-- I.:" .."'"......... ~ \ "~~ I I ""T"~ LJNll'" "~I1" liN"'. UNn,S U""" L~"'''! i , . ~ - _ v__, ~:~::."''''. d I 1_ I . ," f' -- ---.- \ \ , ,ii, I . \ ~""" "Noll 'J""" ON'" ">0'" ,,,.,'0 "~"" "NIl" "',,,.. u""" ,,~"'" """77 UNn", , I! I ". ", \ ' , · _"u ./ --I; -- - -- I- -- ! "",. i' "" ~."' -- '"'" - """,,- --to - - 't\ ".' "." """,S' >1 . .""'" wo.'''' l,~"e ,,""" """" . ". t . ., ,,",T'" ""'7< ...... .. """, "",,.. """.' ,,-- . -- "'" : '"'~,."'" "".. ,,"" -'~::':'t ',,,.,,. '""" 1'---\' --.:,- - -- - .. W I"~ ,"'"'' """ _.. " . I . .. ,..., .... "" - ~ - -,'- .~ - '--- -, j .... I.,~ 1 _ ---r; ." ! ",,"" r ~'w::... '".. ~ -~:"-' - -t -.:..:1- [1- ~'l :.. "=j"" -: ''''I . ~J ~ Ii j-/"" ."" I :----~--- if - ri t?""~,, 'LJ"" '" ~ /' " ... -- - , ~'-" -,.. ,,,"," Ct' I,""" " '::'! ,".., '"'wi 1 ~ t'l --;;" 1----- --- I -- ____C-- ---I "t ' " " ~ I II ~ . . ------ --. c--.", .' :"~ - "m',,' ~ '. t!." , "'" ~, I 'I ,. t ":'~' I ,,""~, ""1"' '--+.,:, ;R:' I '.-- 'c.., _..~,..,,-I ' ",,. . " , Cl" ,'I'~I ,. I, .' I I. "r 1 ! ::"';f-~ ~ j,",..",. .'~ .'+-. - I I.. I,. .,.1 . ~ '. """."..~' """00. "~..'." """...." . '.J,. ,1'- , i I r . . 1___ ___ __ -- _ _' , \. \" "I I. I ' I " .." j ", t 1--- I I J l ". '" 1/1 .--~ +--1-. {} ~ -~- -!l- -- --- L__ - - i-- __ _.__ ___ -r-- _:~: _=__ ~~'~o: ___' _ t"<LT'" ,","'", ., o 0 '''I \,'c' ,.! I.!, "" I", . I ' f--- --- 1/1 '-- I,_}I .. -. 1.., ,J_ 1.----"' '.' I"""'" ~~ """" . """."""",,.1 "l' ... f, [I II! ! ,,, -, I; 1- - . .-- -- _ _ _ - --1____ -,D- ,t-', . ",- "I ",. .' " I ~,-~,._ . t-- ',,-- j I I i _J.._ ''''f. "'".,,~, """,,' 1""'$"" "I I , i' . I ! I. I 1 .n_ --- +------ ; 1 \ ",' "I I' "'. . I 1-__,' , r '_ __ ~ j _ __ I' I ~ . 1-. _'__ I -, UN" '0' ",~~ I Jf<T 1>' "j tJN1' ", "'"' ,,. ~ " 1 I --- - I - ~ :ii' ,.. '. '''''' ,,- - ':\), t1- J -1--- ~'I 1-+_-1 1- ", _~__""'~""::,I ".."., , _" """'I~"" \.., \\' If)" 'I' 1 1 ' ,- - -~ -- c;, (!) . " , , I n ~~\11J 0' '.." .. ------ ---- -----, -- - '" ~ ,,) ~~ . ~'.- ' . ,---- 1/1 0 \~'c':""-~ , ~.. le- [--- -~ .mt-.I' - "".... ~~ 1...... """'" ..",,, ~.". ,,,..,, - 't l J' 'I ------ ----- III I . '- /'" . , .. '" '. " ... \ ~~/ _,_____ I, _ _ ! __ ____ __n . ",,"'" ':~~:~': ""'... ~"'" ~... """", "~.-' ~~,. ..1 I' r 1 ,,\(. r ' " ~ .. -' )\ l I~ . \ ' "t<' """'.' """ t.. "'''' '&1 ,. I :'< -j. II W-f\-'" _ 1_ _ "~"'.2 '., "MII'._ , ~\\'-\ 1\ J y,f .--- ---' I I --- \' 111" - , (" (7 r" ,\ . ". ". ....', C---C\-~---' _L..". ". -----j \jU\\, .. ~;~~ \ "' ~ ' .. _..... . I ""'.." "",.... .. , 1'M1; ~ I ~ - - ,.. .. . ..--- -. - -- 1--- I ~~!~ _:l~Jr" ~t-- \"_~_']'~.::'-=-~"__~n~\- '~\---\'l .'~1f"T ;/1/ .'~./O(y ..':.,: .\f." i ' I{ r "C...' I"~, . i---'_ ___1_____1, _\_.j (T:' .l;( -,C\ t'A:Ii, ..- - ___n~). 11"'k., \ { ,'- .~" .\... ;c,\, \ \" ,~ ' .'" II ' I' . I 1 1/1 ")\' \l" _ _" . ,,,f;'ft 1,"\ .I -- of; ~_______,_. _____L__---" N '\ .. "'~~, 'c/./"'" "--"-. - !",..f. . ~.. " I.". n_...._ . III \ ." .". . --- -/\ "J \"'. /.'~ 't... .' I . ... .W+. E en',/ ''-.'i.I'''-':..';;;'' (-~ ":;1\ " 1.:,.t~~'~.".'-.IL.J..-..,-,,-I-,:-.--...-- ffl~:.:-.~-N_- '1--.1... " ""1 T\I' lifif.. !"\ ,1"'-1,,\1 't " -i1~-"" MAII':Q ___ --;,f, t- , .' '__ ..... wL-:,-4-.- --,- - I S """ \ ",;Yitt"t\., \})c')Li!d" v~! )17':1'0' 1 T ) ..'I 1:-" .... t-.' ""J 'u " '. \.. \c-.., (. I "y ," " - ,I _ ~CALE ~_~___/ ~__/1 , ",S/ ~ ___ _t-, l., /"_ __ ---.:;- .. ~ I r i==---:::r::::::.. I I 1 ____...._ __J__ . .... I - ,~"_ [) 1~1 2MI .IMI "MI _llE&EN"'-- _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DlnRl~T COMMISSIONER I - DONNA FIAlA DISTRICT POPULATION i! - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D 1 49,840 3 - TOM HENNING --~- 50,759 4 - PAMelA S. MAC'KIE -- :I 48,313 5 - JAMES N. COlETTA. Jr. ----.r----------52;~ --uS- --- 50431 _ INDICATU COUl.llSlIlON DlsnlCT Wlf. __- --____ ' PREPARED BY: GRAPI4ICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECllQN eum 251 3n COMMUNITY OEVElOPfi.lENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION . OAT[:10/2001 FilE, COM-DlST-MAP-2.DWG I PLOT: AUTOCAD.PAI R 25 E R i!& E R 27 E R 28 E MAP #3" COt.lIER COUNTY. FLORIDA . j I." --"" I " \ , .. I 1 ~ """ <" <m"" ~ -". ---",." .- II . """1 .. :/io" <\ ' I ! "- . \ \ ' s ~ ~" ,', "1<1 ~ UN" J'l' ' \ J: ,,{ II lEE COUNTY !. . ..+-- __I _:_' _"'~ _ .__. ~. I' ;Yl I"" I ! 1 I' .: --'--. ..' '"~E" """" I " . . , ' ,." 1" ..", """. ~,. ',,' \ [ I UN"" ~h<~ _'_ -- --- OJ - UN"" -1__.. ".._ ,'>.)-I-,.,~ ~----f-------~ " --0'- ," -- -- I,. -------" " " III ,\II'''. I""'" j , " I' "I I"""~'" I i ,>~-i..~". ~ I I _ _H ,...... I "N"" ".,,", : ~. . - tJ>~~~ ----- - --I -"-i - ----- ---- ------- I I I -... ~'I"!l 'j." ,,2. ~ ,,' .., . .....,! ~"".. ",,"" " ... \ [K ~ ", I "I i "..,.~ ......... UN"" "..." 08 \~L : ........- -......." .~.._) ...L"._....t~. '.......1 ..- ..-.. I - ~----_.- \11 . I . I" .. , ' .. I " !" ,,:'1 """ "! co"" "'"'' ,,,,,,, ..," ".,,, """,, I " I." \, '" L [""" j, + . C' .- - _ - ,--\__1, T--' .'- . "I---il---- .... 1 , .,," _~ ,. . - , - _N " '" ,,_ "" ~ \1 _ _n "~,, "I";" """'.~ '''''''~ u~IT" """'j U'",,, u,",,, UN"" I ! " - _. :;;;::.." ,,, :\' I 1_1---- . '-- --------1-- ---- ---- ---+- --y . , . 'i~I' l <' ":i' I"",,, ,-",'J "".,. u'," , """TO U~I111 \J~"" Ii"".' U""~ ""'",. UN"" "~Il" \ ,) I' · \ .., ... -'''''-'- -'.'--' -- ... - I' --- - - I.". i'" """ t- . "" "~'T" . ".. UNIT' U"'" "",,. ,,"". UI<I1" . ",,'OO ,,,,,7< ""I''' "Nil.. WIT".' I \ ~......- ~..- ' In ~.~ ."'",,,. ----- -~. - -------- " I~' " " uN" 14 """ """" "N"\~' ".."~,, ) I ',"'T - - - - : __ : _ ~ :--- --. ~ uN"" : :- ~N~: _~_ I . - ,_' "_1 -"--t---~-- _~' 0"'.' UN'.' 1__,,___ __I-- ~_ . ~ ~". , I.L - .'.' ",,'" I'" ,"."" I ' I, '~"""I --- ~ - ~ CO\DN I I _" " " "' "",,"" ""'0> - - -[ ----1-----------7-- - -- f - - __ -:i. I - - : '.' i " \ ij ~ GAlE "N"'" I -- --+___ ~ ------- "1".___,, "uN"" U,""O' " ,'--:-1____ c;) ~..., """." ,_., ".." ". wi" l' .. "." I .. ':'1 ",". '."", 1- \ "'" . I . ---- I I! '-! I ."... il , ' -- ,,----- ----- I (:-... ,. l~ -- " "i I I -)-- - ~_ .'-' ) J "Ii '" ,~" "'" "n_ I , ' . !. I UN" uNl'"' ~ 'I, ~"., I ~ "" ," UNi'ot . ~ ;I '_""'" '0'.,,"' . I -. "., \- ,',," , r~' ~.~-, .... ..., ' ~? ...,." 1 . W..'.~"T~!'" . , ! , "4r... - -,.", 'J, I -- I 1 ,)"'""... "",,,00 "''','' "",,,. I NAPLF!" ---- i -- ~ ---,- ----1----- -- i .. _ ___ ~: , ) ~ ., , ., .,.. I!- -- +---_J---- , III ...'~ -,' I :1- i "~--.I...' __ "~".1~,'_:'.. ' "..,,,,,,,,,,.[ o n I I .0 ,I . .'''.. . 1 ~ -. -- I III '-' > . """'0' L, I . ....-. i~ i~1 .:~ ~"" " """" ...."" I- -" ~ \III ' I . - --- - I 'v:r>,I, "I ,. ", \ .. -- - -- --------. ) 1 J i \11"-' 'if I', - T -,4,- -t---- "..:::I;;, ,..',," i" _ ...,,,,,_.! ',J.. I, " I ,I ~"--- j " , ' , , ! '= ;;.. I - \-- 1----; I 1-) -1-- j ...,,~. ~,' I ,,""" :,--1....:-. """,, ",,"" "- ~, ' I 'I ". .. , . -- ~ :;;(~ I I'~ " I, . ~ (\) '8- I (C', - !~~ II _.m ,_ I +_' ..j__ ".".., "'~,'! '''''''",,''_ ., ..."" ""''', H ,~ .. ,,2 . I ~ I --j ,------- '-- --I- e-. "\1, d' I " - - r- .. 0 '0' I . of" . - 1--------- ---'-.-- --- <;. j i?fJr >-d' ---<' , I . I ,'- , o '~. ~~ .fl-- Ie-I.. _ .--' . ,1.. ~ ~ "",.. 1~; ,""'" '"'''' ~"'" ,,,,,. ."'''' III '- 1..., l't/' } jj 1--'--- - \ 1 , I' /' . I I I' . -"" 1-- III ;.\ " ." Iv./''' I ' ~ ~ ,"" :', ", . I- 11'\ t. +--\" -\___L___, . ___ ____ """. 'I;; "''''''j''''''' '''''''' ~"'" "."" ~ ..J~ I I 1----- -.. ---. ..-1---- .-- ..- -- ~}O , .. '.." " ' 1 :~\j-,.. , 'I.... . .. .. I'. "",.1""""""""""''''\ '.' '----\\i-- _ _ __.'___ __1________'__1- ____ """., ,., U'''''"'I ) '\.)IIK \\,\ ")J")~ j~ I " II --- " I . _~. I - ,;: le-:" i[' .., ~'.~" ., I '''1''''''''1'''''' "I. '~;/f\~J~/}&,/_.~r)! ,-----, - ---- ~~--\I--rm , ~20..~ (V'.~. t:.i..i41l'1~ +-. ,,' - --';1 .... ---. - - x." ':i .1 \ , ( -1)., ~(d;-~l' .t),. 'I' , I'I, I" I I III N ,___,\1.-,...t""~\5:\\;""\'"'.",,i\'-."I' i. '-.---j N + ~.. ..'\".'2C', -.:,./~ I ,.r-/ /" ".j' " "I "0 __.m III \1 """ .. 0-~ r ,. I,J" ,\ I // -- t- w 1':\ '\ _ '" ...-' .. '~"--:_ -~/..ll- -.-1-- ..-- - J '!Ooo 111 , on.' ..1fl' _\. Jrr. (."d.''';:; :;:,;;,1.' .tl a~~" (("rt."..I, 1'.'I..,,!" r/"'<.,I.. , " OK'~"l' '.ill '" 1 v~ W' "n .. - T _r ..,.- s ~~~:~g 'I. " "- ~"~ ,'- i\!I,,)r~l~ vi" ).:~,~} /~?~I.;I ~-It ,t--- ~ \ "\,.. ,----,,'." - --- , -- ,0 I]" 'I I", ,..- 'h" \ r " ''''''- ~ , SCALE \.... v~ ---=-~>- -'::' _____J" J/ I }<:, ,~/ '0 ." 1'-1 I ,- \- \ i __ _ - -- - -:0, - -+t'--. 1 ~ '-- ___,,_____--c- - ,--\- - .---L____ ----~,,-r - '~I ~ -._.~. 2MI 3MI-'-~I>" - .L..__ ---~~-. ;"v - __J 5 i----- 'ii-- U&END _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRict COMWSSIONER I - DONNA FIALA DISlRICT POPULATION i! - JAMES 0, CARTER Ph.D .. -50,145-- 3 - TOM HENNING 2 -~._"'-" 50,473 -- 4 - PAMELA S. MAC'KIE ." ~.=-----. 50,375' 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA. Jr. .4.. __ 50,341-' -5-- -." -. 50043 _ INlH~AH$ COMMISSION D1S1RICT LINE ------------.--~ PREPARED !lY: GRAP~ICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPORT SECTION sum 251,3n COI.lM\}NI1Y Df.vnOPMENl AND [NVlflONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DAT[:1 O!2001 FILE: COM-DIST-MAP-3_0WG ./ PLOT, AUTOCAD.PAL R i!!!i IE R Z& IE R 27 E R 28 E ~ COMMISSI=A:S~ICT LINES r--"-.r ,. tl '_ " ,., I" '-._ "::'.' ,.:J .. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS '"-1_ .."._ ~ -'- _" _::. ~~: ~'-\. ''"_' COlliER COUNTY. FLORIDA t i ! - '. " , I~'" "~IT" "'On,, .",., \.! . I ~,. \'.! - -''', 'i-"""~ ----;~ .-;----~---'i-- --- ,- ~ ~ ... . " .. 1 'UNH ' \1$!~', ;.f. '.. " """"t"",,, '. I \( ;._ ~ .: . ./1 \\ lEE COUNTY _,' _ _oo__ _- -- ,"- ~ - __j____... 1__ ~ I; I - , ',___ C,,"I1 UM' "" U"" 00 1--- ---t---- I i \Cl' I l,fl .., . ! . \ ' I,. I.. ...j.-'- "...... """, ~"" ".'." "t-" ,,' i IZ~c"! I 1 """,, .~-~ --_'. .-_...~---_._-'; -..-- -"- I ~)\ 1- --'1-' ",--( -- - ""1--'-' "" ~--- ---, - I III 'ii".~ " ", 1,.1, 'I"""""'"'' , ,.,,, I ,,-\\' I~"~ . "_ _____ ~',_ """~. """.5 : ('\-~ ",>' . .. - --I - --- -- , ---,,-~-- . ..- , i " \ >\::y- . - _ "N" 2. ,. . '\',1 "" '-, ...... " "I "' ,,,,,,7 """", ,,. I .. Ie i .~, -- ... -" ".w, ',"I .._, -,- """" ..". ,-' -1----' I.", "I I ,_ - ",-, " ! ,,1 I"]" " "I I.. ,. ~ ,-1 V'''''''! "N"" "",,,. ~""" "~"'" ~"",., u..'''... ' C ""'T" I ~~: 1-___ m __------l ',-+- ,,' " 1-___ -'''--r~ j'" \.1 ,----1-- ...,""" "~" " ,~'...... ~ I UN"" ' ,. .." I uN" "i UN"'" UN"'/ """ '" ......." ", """ Y' U,.1'n , ,-" '.-.-.., '-,,, ---'-.---I,----.,,-~+---i__-------.-.----- .t\, ,1 i ". ";;: """ 1 "r".' """. ""IT' 'IN" 10 "",T" ~..'" """.. "..,.J ',,"'f" """ n "l<iT" , 4i I' I I ... tL- __ -....-.- '1 _..._,,- \ ,--,-- !'}:j,' ~"".. .\. . L' ,,;' ",,'TY\' _'1_ "Nil' U"T' 'I><'T" "'''''[ """"" "U"""" """,. ..... __I._ ~ \J"" ""It," ""n~t : l' :-:-.. , ,~'" ::. , -. ::'~:'1"""" ,,"" "'ji=t-~" ---- i I "", -- 1--'- -.:..-+--- .. ~ I "'" ",,", -. 'I "1" " ,.."""'''.." "'f" t- : , - ~-:-! . ~ ! ,_ .~ ____ " ".:,: --", -------!----,...-----,--~i----- -- -..-----------! ~~" t " i i UW" I "OLD N ." ,,; ""' ~ """ 8^ uNIT M I 1 ~. ~:....~ "-- f---------! ----- ;---~-;;;;;;;- LJN'T," 1-"--- -- -'1-- ----~~-i-~~ -~~~ - ------ -- " I " I " 'i _I ,'. _" "u.." 2. """ '" ~ /'" I i ~ ~ - +--~ ~ ~'~'.. ~_.. --, ,..w, "", ,,,,,_ " I " ; "I. '~'! ~". "."" ,,~ ,,' ~ It 1 I'" "'" -f 1-- -----..- .... I c-.... ., I ~ "- I " hi" ~ f'-. ~ " : I """ u"'" j "'" ,. n '--.." ';g'.' I' .~- "",' , i. -.-., "" " ". . _ __...__ """''''.''''''''',M - ' ~ ' I ~ - 0" . . j;::~ I" ',," "\ or .U"M l' I I __I I I ,IN" V" ~"" WIT 100 """", '.'""1" NAPLES ---'- ., --- r ~--------- .. ~ I' -,.." ., . I I, n-f- . ___f--- 'n__ - ----. . "-"":'..' j' L',.\,"::"~' '." o 0 I" ,.Ji I ' '. "Jll" '-~jr::' . I' ..... 1- --~-' ~ .. , . IlL \ r .', ,-_! "" , .""'-" I ' . I I' ""'"' ~'"",,,,' "..,,, "",,,, : .. -" \~~.J" I[".r." I".... --I.:.. ,,~ 'I:-~':'; - ~-I' - :~~,I;~ :~: ~~_~' : _-=-:,_-- \~IA" ,,, ~,\" ",,, ,," I . .- \ , <lo I ~"" I ; -- ___1-.________' -------t-----.- I... ..,_. _ 1_ I I "''''0" ~~'rii """~' " I ' '-""'>' ".",,,. !~. I' ,,,'! I -- - - ----~. , . -, , \.' " " ' " ."" " ,. "t~ t ~- -.- ~ \\.if".~Ii~--n- "1" ~- - "I --t , j -i---j-- J. ... """,,"d '" '" '- ,,' ~"" """, . '\ (JI 1'''- I , , I ' "",. '1H "~J, __ --_~ I ~- _1__" I 1 """,., ~~! ."", ",,,,,. ~"'" """". ,,""'" C') "~ 3~1J,,, I: - , \\\....f0),'"'",,~ ' /,fl . " , U'I 0 ~E"\-:=.<~---.! I~'::-----O+- /1;-- _ _ ~ _____ ' _~ "~""~ ~~; "NlT1l0 """,., "!ll1'~2 Uh","' VI'h'''' iii V"'~I-. '~"" ,',;.. N : f--. .. \ '\ e- " . \'-___ "~'-~-+---_I' ""''''' ':~ ",,",,' """.. ~",,, ,"'''. """,,,1 ~(L- !J; rI{ ~ I r- - I I --- .--.J 'r': ,.J fr . '" " ~ ('" I. , I I".' ,,""'" """'" ,,""'" "\ ~''"'Wit:tJ __ __ j __ o""'"l 's, u..,'~. \ ;~ ",,'" "(--__PC' , I L ---- u, \0, 1.., M" ,./(" //.,- ; , ,---- _ ~ I \ ~., N '" " " . \~ ,,~ ':':"1 r'l<r~ _ \__ _ ~, _ 'l _ '''''''' ""''''', I' I I~\O~~~-;:) ::t~.,\ ' II '''" '~.,::~::.~ ... .. , 1\, -"_...J~~II~\' (-!\i;?~~:fI:((,r~2:~~",A: 15! . If. h,' ~'- \ ' T /~, V. ~\ -re _~ I,I' _ _ - ~ j' . - --"k - ---j- I . ..""L. h \.\ , \~+- I ; N l~ ~'~~~",t','j \. ~ . _ ~ .1 '_~j~.. .. w+. \\. \~<O_ :r~rf' \\~ ~\-;;,::!iJI' jli~:\1 ,1':' ... """"'. !l em ,/ II q':le;..;", , 9"". I r ' I"" _ N. , Dr j \ j lU!{ <<s;-~: /, 11'- --....,JO.{~.,. MARCO __ i".,\ - \ s:..:: - - ,1--........._ u I S SLANO ,,' 1\ ,J\.' _ I 7, -""to--- --. ,------,-- CC~LE ,_ , ,1~!t~J ,)f. j~ ~~ tJ~ ,)/"'ilS '\, b, !,-Ltl ~ ~ '1-, _ - o 1MI 2M! _WI 4MI vt:R LA!:' S ITY Q / , lE6END _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRICT C(lMt.lISSI~NER I - DONNA 'FIAlA DISTRICT POPULATION i! - JAMES D. CARTER Ph.D --- 50,229 3 - TOM HENNING 2 --49,492 u 4 - PAMElA S. MAC'KIE ' ''3-'' - 50,884 S - JAMES N. COlETTA, Jr, _. L_ _,50.341":::. _ INDI~Ans C~MMIUI(l~ DISTRICT liNE 5 _ ___ 50,431 _ PR,PAFlED AY; CRAPHICS AND TECHNICAL SUPPOR' SeCTION lIUIT1 251,3n COMMUNITY DEVf.LOPMENT AND EN\IlRONIo.!ENTAL SfRVlCES DI\IlSION DAlE:ID/20Ql FILE: COM-QIST-IIfAP-4DWG I PLOT, AUTOCAD.PAL R i!5 E R it6 E R 27 E R 28 E MAP #5--r I r--]--- ~ COMMISSION DISTRICT LINES ']1 " .,"' ,,,.,, .... BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS __ __.__. :-.______1.__...__ <Jt<1'" "",'" \IN"" \1_ -J- I COlUER COUNTY, FlORIOA "' I'", 1----, I i ~, "",, ., ,,,,.,, _" _ -- --- ~----I . ",,,., --- --. i \'-' 'i , I -- , , j I ,"" 1 g-' I ,\\1 '\." ~ I" a "",T'" u""" I \ (, I~. ~ lEE COUNTY ___ _ -- ' ; -j II , I ----.--- 'Y:.' ;m. ' .. I , ., '__'__ ",,' """. "",," .. ~. .." " \~I' . f----, '" "N" !,"""'1 ,""11"', . 1ft '~'tl/. "., -~ +- ,11--,--,[' i~"" ,~:::: "Moo -- .~- -~,- -~-~ \ ~ ., I' ,'_ '" j '.. I UN".. "''''"' II ,",/U ( '1- I I . ~":\ '::rJ} i --. i ~ ,.-' ,~_ " I " UN"" .... \ 0."1. ,'.'_ UNoT"" UN,,'"" \~~ ~ ~- \1.-, i - -" ",,,-, I' ' ,,-I ~ . 1 ~.;'",.. ~.~ [ I """ to, "'l" l' I"""" "',,'" ,,"" 7" ""'T" UN" 71 I 11),,-' "'""",,- """"-- !~---11-' .1----1--1. \-- .-r--T-- '"'''''''' : \ 1 r. -, ['" ' u"n,,~ U""'" "..,,, "N""luN"'~ uN"" ".",,, ; " ~ ,,..,,,...' ~:;::.. '" - _' j -1.___. ___ ___ _ "_~L- \- I. -,-- I' - \ "~I. . "",N" VNH 1 \:."", ",,". "~'" UN'T '0 ""'TH "",,14 "'".. """ \MI' If ~N" 77 "N" '" \ \ \ ' . " ~ _I:..! ,_1______, -.., -.'''--, I ' .' 1m' , ""IT -- ,I I ""," "c """ ~"'. """. """, .,,,,, ,,""" """ """,,, " ".." "".. \ : .<-- "-' ,,""" """ -. :::';. '""" '.. -" '''I ~. r-' -- 1- "'" --" ---- " -, IIlf ,,"" " """" . I"".' "N"" "'''.- . I' I I- -~ :- t"--. _ _ ------------- --- --T- - _ _ 1 " " ,,"" j , , """., I, ~. ""I t -+ --1--- ~ ~__ l; GOLD fI J--~-"" _:} _ ~:.. "~I,"' , I I . GAlr uMT," ,- --__ ~ """20 "N" 10 !" I! ~ -- - c;') '...... ,,".'''' " CrT " ." " _ I U:TS VN"'" u,.,.., I , W'I'" ~ ~. ~ ,- -::- r ------ --- - ~-~~ ~=-~, UN""'-- . ~". ~ ., ~, ",.,.,,,,,,,.,' .. J "'> I'" \ I J"" ~- - t__ I 1 ,,",,". U"" ","DO ""T'" ,-,""". ' 1 j_ - - I -'_ .. , I r - .~ " I - -- 1ft . r r I ' [I' [" ""'" ... "."" ' """". """,j - -, _ .- '" _ :j'- a () . I' ,,","0' , I I ,,"" '"T'" "","1' 'J",'''' .... '---f, - + i_ -- ,..~. ,- ' ,,' 'I ,-- ]--- .. ,I ! T " I ---+--. .-..., , I "." '"' ~:, ".' ',," ... I """ '" I- . II I . I - >~ _ ~ . j I.' I ., 1- """ '0' ",~I;~ """ '~l 1- ~_.I__~~_. """ '." I """.>> ~ "'~ I . Ii" I --t--- C\) _. ___ 1__ _-1--- """ '" ~~',' ~ """ "b " , .. "",, '>7 'ON" '-I" N ' , T' -- ---- ---.. ~.' . , 'r- -j, --~t' - ' -- - """ ,., ~~~' ,..,..~ UNIT ,.. VN""~ "." U" uN" ,., CJ 'I I I - ~.. :-1 ' '" I ~" I 1 """ U" ~~.. \,,,,T '"0 "",, 1M """ '52 1m" ,~, UNIT '.' ~ I -'-1--1 .-- ---- ... \ UN" '.' ~~~' U""". ""IT ,..., ~~-'.'~ _""" ,';<; ~.''' V"T '"1 ~:; , ~ w+" , SCALE 1---1 ---,- ~T -:.:j [> 1MI 2MI ~I 4MI ~~~~"'-D_ _ PROPOSED DISTRICT LINE DISTRICT ~OM!<AISSIONER I - DONNA FIAlA DISTRICT POPULATION i! - JAMES D. CARTER Ph,D 1 '51;51'1-- 3 - TOM HENNING :2 -48.626~- 4 - PAMElA 5, MAC'KIE --"3-- 49;578 5 - JAMES N. COLETTA. Jr,- -:.r---~~~::~: w,~_--- _ INDICATES CIlMMISSION OISTR'CT UNI _-~._._- ------ 51,455 PREPARED BY, GRAPHICS ANI) TECHNICAL SIJPPORT SECTION sum 251,3n COMMIJNITY DEVEI.OPMENT AND ENVlRONMENTAL Sm\.1CES DIVlSION DATE: 10/2001 FILE' COM-DIST-MAP-5.DWG / PLOT: AUTOCAD.PAc mSPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES OF MEETING of October 25, 2001 PRESENT: ABSENT: David Correa, HAAB Member Robert Pina Pete Cade, HAAB Member Frank Loney, HAAB Member Sofia Pagan, HAAB Member Susan Calkins, HAAB Member Carlos Aviles Ramiro Maiialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison Also Present: Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones News Timothy Durham, Office of the County Attorney David Weeks, Collier County Planning Services Liza McClenaghan Michael Kirk, Collier County Public Schools, Chuck Mohlke Frank Rodriguez, Que Pasa Southwest Florida TV John Norman, Representative Ralph Arza's office The October 25, 2001 meeting of the Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) took place at the Collier County Commission meeting room and began at approximately 7:03 P.M. A quorum of six (6)) members was present. APPROVAL OF SEPTEMBER 29, 2001 MINUTES David Correa noted a correction that was needed on the draft minutes of September, 2001. Specifically, on page 4, he noted that a reference to the "lmmokalee Bank" should be changed to "Bank of America." There is also a correction to the spelling of the last name of Commissioner Coletta. A motion was made to approve the minutes, as corrected, by Frank Loney. Carlos Aviles seconded the motion. The vote was 6 to 0 in favor of the motion. ,.... -~.._._...-._.,. .-_.-...._~-~~--_-.-. _.._-,--,--_._,. -,-...__.. EXCUSED ABSENCE Ramiro Mafialich informed the Board that Mr. Pina had called several days before and advised that he would be unable to attend the HAAB Meeting as he had been called to military service in North Carolina. Carlos Aviles made a motion to excuse the absence and Frank Loney seconded the motion. A unanimous vote (6 to 0) occurred in favor of the motion. REDISTRICTING PRESENTATION David Weeks from the Collier County Planning staff explained the reasons for redistricting of the Commission boundaries. The basic reason was that there had been population changes throughout the County. He explained that five maps had been prepared (the maps are attached to these minutes) as well as a report (attached) and a spreadsheet regarciing population figures (also attached). He said that the basic ,..", redistricting criteria approved by the County Commission were to maintain incumbency, compact and contiguous districts, equal population districts, and seeking to have the same boundaries as the school district. He also said that additional legal criteria included: avoiding retrogression of minority votes (especially in District 5); and avoiding division of neighborhoods. He mentioned that other criteria that were followed are included in the report. He also stated that retrogression analysis indicated that there was actually an increase in minority populations in the districts. Mr. Weeks explained the redistricting methodology based on census tracts and where Commissioners live. He mentioned that Collier County is a "covered jurisdiction" and that it must submit maps' for "pre- clearance" by the U.S. Justice Department. He explained that the report that has been prepared has standout features and critiques of each map. There is also a description of each district in the package. Mr. Weeks commented about the differences between the maps. With regard to Maps #1 and #2, he said that the only significant difference was in the area of Davis Boulevard. District 1 has not changed in those maps. Map #3 has a significant feature in that District 1 goes farther east. Maps #4 and #5 have different boundaries in North Naples. There are very few "jogs" on Map #5. Mr. Weeks also mentioned some significant changes in the maps regarding the so-called Manatee Road Triangle. Mr. Weeks recapped prior public meeting presentations regarding redistricting. He mentioned that there had been meetings with the League of Women Voters, the Black Affairs Advisory Board, and the School Board. He said the School Board wanted to follow the County lead in this matter and also wanted to wait for public comment. The School Board expressed reservations about Map #3 regarding Everglades City not being in District 5. There were also three community meetings. Weeks said that the turnout varied, but generally the numbers were small. He mentioned that notices of these meetings were provided as described. The notices were in English, Spanish and Creole. The BCC meeting is November 13,2001 for consideration and approval of the maps by the County Commission. The staff group would also be back before the School Board and in Immokalee. He said that residents of Immokalee felt that there was a need for another meeting due to lack of sufficient prior notice for the previous meeting. 2 David Correa mentioned that he felt that there was a lack of ample notice for tonight's meeting. He said that it would have been better if there had been earlier notice. He would have preferred a summary of the large amount of information. Liaison Ramiro MafiaJich expressed regrets about not getting information to the HAAB earlier, but he explained that all of the staff had been very busy and that the information had been coming together recently. He suggested that the Hispanic Board could consider having another meeting before the November 13th County Commission Meeting. David Weeks mentioned that more information about the redistricting process was available on the County Website. Frank Loney asked about the Hispanic population figures in the districts and David Weeks explained the numbers of the spreadsheet. Mr. Weeks emphasized that County Staft' was seeking comments, criticisms and suggestions regarding all of the redistricting process. David Correa asked if any comments would be conveyed to the County Commission. Mr. Wceks explained that the comments would be presented to the Board of County Commissioners. However, staff will not change the maps without County Commission direction. Tim Durham from the County Attorney's Office explained that there had been lots of information received. He emphasized that there had been significant concerns expressed regarding Map #3 as well as regarding the North Naples communities on Map #3 and Map #5 not bcing similar to the rest of District 5. David Correa agreed that there should be concern over these North Naples communities being in District 5 because they are not similar in terms of income and in other ways. Frank Loney echoed those same concerns and he thought that including the North Naples gated communities in District 5 would impede minorities running for office in that district. David Correa asked Chuck Mohlke, Democratic Party Chairman, to comment about the redistricting information. Mr. Mohlke stated that he had been monitoring the redistricting process and that he had previously commented regarding congressional redistricting as Chair of the Collier County Democratic Party. He said that the County Staff had made a good presentation. He stated that he has concerns concerning the North Naples' gated communities being included in District 5. He provided demographics information and mentioned that Commissioners Matthews and Berry had been elected from those North Naples' communities. He compared information of other representative areas in the Immokalee region in District 5. He also spoke of "age demographics" in Immokalee. He said that the last Census it was indicated that the median age in Immokalee was far younger (22.5 years of age) than in the North Naples' gated communities. In those communities, the median age is 55. He also mentioned that those under 18 years of age cannot register to vote. He said that the registered voters are 39% of District 5's population whereas in District 2 it is 66% of the population that are registered to vote. He mentioned that obviously age was a major consideration. He stated that the North Naples' communities had a higher number of registered voters and that they do not have much in common with Immokalee or the rest of District 5. David Correa asked Mr. Mohlke about having just Immokalee as a Commission District. Mr. Mohlke responded that the districts all have to have the same approximate population. A variance of up to five percent is allowed. The present maps have one to two percent variations and they are good maps, but there are the concerns that he expressed previously. 3 .. --.--'" '-'-'-"'""'-'~"---"-~----"'-'~'''''.,...,-- David Correa asked Mr. Mohlke if there could be one "minority" district? Mr. Mohlke explained that it was very hard to do that in the large Collier County area and not violate the compact and contiguous redistricting standards. He said there was no legal basis for line drawing with an exclusive focus on race and ethnicity. David Correa clarified that he was not saying that he wanted to have only minority elected officials, but he did want the Commission Districts to be drawn in such a way as to allow for that potential. Mr. Mohlke emphasized that minorities have a smaller percentage of registered voting age population. He believes that they should not be disadvantaged by mixing the minority population with other populations that have an older age and more voters. He said that Frank Rodriguez would also address this topic. David Correa stated that he would like for Mike Carr, Chairman of the Collier County Republican Party, to share his comments with the HAAB on this topic. Mr. Mohlke presented a spreadsheet (attached) regarding the total registered voters per district and a breakdown by ethnicity and race. The figures presented related to population percentages and minority groups and numbers of registered voters and the percentages of total population made up of registered voters in the Commission Districts. He emphasized again that District 5 has a younger than average population and many of them under voting age. There are also a number of voting age adults who are not naturalized U.S. citizens. He felt that there would be a disproportionate impact to include the North Naples' gated communities in District 5. He repeated that this had been exhibited by the results in the 1992 and 1996 commission elections. Tim Durham emphasized that staff is inviting comments and contact by the public before the November 13th County Commission redistricting decision. Michael Kirk, representing the Collier County Public Schools, stated that he had been working with County staff on the redistricting effort and that the School Board Policy is to seek to have the same school district boundaries as the boundaries for the County Commission District. Frank Rodriguez introduced himself as President of Vision Inc. which features Hispanic TV programming. He said that he is familiar with the census information and seeks to have more Hispanic representation in government. He mentioned that there had heen a dramatic increase in the Hispanic population in Collier County. Many are not U.S. citizens and cannot vote even though they contribute to the community. He mentioned that in reviewing the maps he had a "Catch 22" concern over the lack of concentration of Hispanic voters. He thought that overall there had been a dilution of votes of Hispanics even though it was not the fault of anyone in particular. When there is such a dilution there is a loss of ability to influence candidates. He said that he had been involved in voter registration efforts for Hispanics and that the HAAB and the County Commission need to keep an eye on the concentration of Hispanics in the districts. He observed that the Hispanic population tends to be much younger and that he thought there was a need to get representatives of the Republican Party involved in this process. Sofia Pagan then had some discussion with Mr. Rodriguez about the Hispanic media in town and how the community can best be reached. Frank Loney said that he was happy to see the new redistricting information from staff, but that he wished he had more time to interpret the data. A discussion occurred about the logistics of having another meeting versus taking 4 -----_.__._-~-_._--_.- -.- _..n__________ .____.... _ formal action on this matter this evening. There was also a discussion about potential motions that could be made on this subject. Frank Rodriguez observed that there was a concentration of Hisparuc voters in District 3. Chuck Mohlke suggested that three maps (I, 2 and 4) show District 5 to the East of County Road 951. Frank Loney repeated that he was concerned about the lack of early information. A discussion ensued about the different maps. Susan Calkins made a motion expressing a preference for Maps # 1 and #2 on the basis that the HAAB does not want the minority vote diluted. A motion also included a policy statement that District 5 should not go West of Collier Boulevard (County Road 951). The motion was seconded by Carlos A viles. A 6 - 0 vote in favor of the motion occurred. The HAAB members thanked County Staff and Mr. Kirk for the presentation. IMMOKALEE CHECK CASHING Mr. John Norman explained that he had to gct off to another meeting, but that he wanted to have the Hispanic Board consider a potcntial solution to the check caShing fees problems for Hispanics in Immokalee. He suggested that perhaps the HAAB could persuade a business to cash checks for no charge if minimum purchase occurs. RESIGNATION OF MEMBER EUGENE GREENER Liaison Ramiro Maiialich passed out three documents relating to Mr. Greener's resignation. First, Mr. Greener's October 17, 2001 resignation letter. Liaison also distributed Mr. Greener's September 28, 2001 letter complaining about lack of notice and information of the meetings and a copy of Legal Assistant Kay Nell's Memorandum in response to Mr. Greener's complaints about lack of notice and information. Chairman Correa stated that it has been his experience that Kay Nell has always provided fine notice for the meetings. FARMWORKERS' EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Liaison Ramiro Maiialich passed out a draft of the Executive Summary regarding the HAAB's decision to ask the County Commission to request dialogue between growers and farm workers in the lmmokalee community. The Board members indicated that the Executive Summary should be presented to the County Commissioners as submitted by the Liaison. MR. VALDES' REQUEST FOR AN AGENDA ITEM Mr. Victor Valdes, Editor of Las Naciones News, requested time on the Board's next agenda for a variety of information regarding the activities of the Police Review Board which has been recently formed. The Chairman agreed to his request. 2002 ADVISORY BOARD REPORT The 2002 HAAB Report to the County Commission was deferred to a later agenda. S ,"'-"- '<-.-'-.-' _._..~, "-'--'~'.."_~.^,,- LA TIN FESTIVAL. VOTER REGISTRATION David Correa reported that there had been an effort to register Hispanic voters at the Latin Music Festival. He said that approximately 60-70 voters registered and more than 100 applications were passed out. He said he was assisted in this matter by Mr. Pina and the Elections Office. HARVEST FOR HUMANITY Carlos Aviles asked for Mr. Nojay to be placed on the agenda for November to discuss the Harvest for Humanity in the lmmokalee Hispanic CommlUlity. Mr. A viles said he would contact Mr. Nojay to attend. FRANK RODRIGUEZIHISP ANIC BUSINESS Frank Rodriguez asked the HAAB for its support regarding a factory in Collier COlUlty that has a Code Enforcement Board hearing pending. He said that this factory has many Hispanic employees. He said that the factory obtained approvals from the COlUlty for a new building off Airport Road. Neighbors complained and these approvals were withdrawn. He said he wants the Board of County Commissioners to support the original approval. He said that this business may have to move to Lee COlUlty and Hispanics cannot travel there and then will lose their jobs. He is asking the Hispanic Board to address a private business that has a major impact in the Hispanic Community (200 Hispanic families). Frank Loney asked what was the name of the company and when would it be before the Board of COlUlty Commissioners. Mr. Rodriguez stated that he did not know when the agenda items was coming before the County Commission and that the name of the business was called Gulf Coast American Blinds. He said that the business owners name is Carlos Diaz. Liaison Ramiro Maiialich stated that he would make no comments because he was awarc that this item was being reviewed by the County Attorney's office. However, he stated that he thought this item was going before the County Commission at the second meeting of November. A discussion was held regarding options for action, future meetings or individual comments before the COlUlty Commission. David Correa mentioned that he was inclined to try to help in this situation, but he was not sure if the business had broken any rules. However, he recognized that sometimes Code Enforcement can abuse their powers. David Correa suggested having a special meeting with all parties involved. Liaison Ramiro Maiialich reviewed the HAAB's role under its ordinance. Mr. Valdes stated that this situation could be assisted by the HAAB. He said that he has had success before on these types of issues. Frank Rodriguez stated that he was merely asking the HAAB for support of the original approval and not for a judgment on the Code Enforcement Case. The HAAB decision was to set a special meeting prior to the County Commission meeting with regard to this Hispanic business. They would invite representatives of all parties concerned with the matter. 6 -~"~-""-_.'" ,.,--_._~~.. ~._--,-~--_.__..---- The meeting of the HAAB adjourned at approximately 9:25 p.m. Prepared by: Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison Approved by the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board on this _ day of , 200!. David Correa, Chairman 7 ,.-- _.. ~,_."_., , ""._.~..~-~..,"-~~-~-~------ I I I i , i i I ! """",...... ~'"'' I w I en z // to- :::l .... U u I ~ i ~ I en zcti 15 I z I 0 =UI- ... iii OrnC en ~ Q :! , CJCZ z ::l; w 0 a:a.O a. C!l u ~ ca: w a WO- ...I W " -a:: en :& en a . 0 0 ...Ia.CI) a.. 0 ...I - '" o :& a.. . I . CJ :E . I 0 I I U """"""""" --~ . . ~ . U Q .. R:'"Il'S ,<' .. . . . . . . v--"- u . ( ..J " '-J .. -""'''''''' Wl\II\Tf'I]Ii~ J.JJnIOlm . = - ~ ~ , - ."",, . 1ft ~ ~ ~ ~ . , = g , . I ~ . 5 ~ 08 Ow fo '" .. , " H ~, , ~l - I > . ." .. " ., ~?: ~o !i~~~ <~ . ~, -g ,w ,.,...-n ""'. p. ~~ " ~~i:i ~"v 0 0 "'',:,! , ~l ~~~ 0"' 6~~ j ~ "' I I ,;;~ - :~~I _-01 .z_ ~:f.;J oj ~6':;:i 0..<..>0, ."-.-- ----' -"--_.-~.-._. . ---',',-' _."'._._._~-'._..',_--~ ~ I I ___0. I '~~- I I) ~ / I t- t; I ~ U Ii: I - .... , a: ~ z_t- a _ ... I) _ -ILI- N; . Ol)e =I&: Q 2 Uoz ~ 8 . , lIl:a.o a. W Q , ~ 11I0- cc .... gj B -11I:1) :IE Ii: i ....a.! ~ ~ ; .... ~ l1. . o G . U 8 I '""""..... ...~ . . . " 5 U:'lrS Rn . ~ ~ . . . ~ ~ - .....-. lIWAnna. ~ .wfI'lCl:l:lJ1 ~: . . ... ~ . ~ awA71I'llll~~ U1 ~ . . ~ ~ ~ i! - 9 ~ ~ . ~ '= z~ '" i... 00 u ~ 3~ ~~ eO ~ ~~ z: It;t g ~~~ ~ U-I ~~7 ?~~ ~~1' co~ .... z::i", ... ~.o .(t; It' -s-n <Jf <::I ~a~ Q,\)U g ~~~ oj 5"" \ "'. g I -. !:l ~Q_ ~ ~ -< >-~ !i::la _ j' U 8~'" .. (I] ~3; oj l;!~':< i <1.<.lO j ..----.--------------- ~-_._-~----_._-" , _. I I I I I I I , J.1tfll1X1,~ .lJ.HIlll::l:MYG I I) w z I- :::i l- U '-' ~ i a: l- '" zcl- Ci z =w! 0 l") u; OI)C '" =- i 51 . UOZ :; , .. 0 - III:LO L '" '-' . .. 0 auO- = ..I W ~ " -11I:1) '" ~ ..ILl) ~ ~ Ii , . ..I - . ~ o I: l1. " . U I: . 3 0 , , U M__ "'lJIo'~ . . " " " M ... .... . I ~ I " ! " . " 0 " ~ . , -.........., ..........,,,,,..,'" """""", j . ~ . GllWA3lIUI ~ i 1ft g . ~ ~ ~ ~ ! g " ~ ~ . . . " -- : . ...= ~. oS lim~ ee . .0 ~ . ~y .> 2 3" - "., ~" - ,. .Z ~ """'" ,,~ 00 ~~ ~~ ~t -son cC ~~ ,.~ 0 ~g 0 <. . ; ~j ~ ~~ ~~ !t' I Z -- o. ;;;;00 - eC-;;' ."- <;i .. 0 ~,. .0< '00 _._.._._~. ~-_. .._~-_.- --. ..^~,_....,-,.~ I - I , I I - I ", -I ... w I Z I ~ U ::::i I ... I .u.NrlO:lOllY/llOlill - '"' II: ~ I u__ ZC'" :::>> ", c I / Ow- 'lit z I 0 I U",C :wi: in '" oz '" :i .1 I z , a=ILO IL w ::li I " 0 wo- CC w '"' ,I .... '" ~ -, I ::i 11:'" :e w ~ I ..IlL'" '" 5 0 o - ~ > I U I a: I I Q. 0 ;, I " u . " @ . ~ I .uJIflO;IJ.:lKI1GH -y, . :; " ~ " ~ .n, ~ " ... ,~ .... :; " 0 i "(', " " . . --'"' u . ....",'" """"""""'...... ".,.,m" ......-. > ; ON""" ...... . " " " . ~ III il . ~ ~ ~ " . " i > r ~ .- .- ~ ,.(. - I ~~ Ii w Ii~ ."" G~ ::g~ : RI -QlI}1 ~- >< 13liJ &::;;! ;;:> IP'S.n. .0 'ljQ~1I ~~~ <If.,u.~ 30' ~!:i: GO" ~ffi~l . oa~ ,....$ Q ~~,!.. ~l>= ",>-;11 -- / Z ~j ~ ,-,'''is - ~~tJ ""o~ -- - o~ _'L<_._ - ~ ~~- U ~ o~~ 0 ~~~I ~~~: - - - ~s;:;i - -- ~ ----' ! --, I i I I I 1 IoJ.Ill1OO <JWMOll8 """"'~ 1 . w I z / t- ::i U to (/ I ~ i ii: Iii Zct- a I z ::)III! an 0 ;;; O.c OJ :II: Q :E " UOZ z :IE w 0 ..:a.O a. .. 0 < C w c g 11I0- .... ; w " -..:. :E OJ 0 . ; ..Ia.. a. . ..I - ~ . ~ o :::IE a. . , U :::IE " 0 I g U """"'~.... -= ;; . " 0 ".... ..... ,<> '" . . . ;; " 0 0 " 0 . ,...""... ""'"'''''' -........... """""'" ! : " il " ......... ""'" ~ III ~ ~ , . ! ~ ~ 2 , ~ 0 . ~ , ~a -" . o. < ~;;m. Ow \#~ ~ h ~o -, OW 00 gl-I . " " '5~ I ., .w "OIl !.INilTlI'W ,,; 0' ... AI 'Olll !J ~. . 00 \,'S"'I1 ~~ " ~5 c.\i-.:J 0 0 .. 0, ~. 3 01 .g ~.~ ~i ;j o~ "co... ! ~ 1 < ~~o 1:'; "-' ~~;:: ,,-"I>J 0' w;- .0< '00 ---...-------.------.----- -----.-.----..-.-.-.. ~._._._--~ I . , I . , . . ! A - . . ... . . - . . . A . . . ''\: "~; " ""'t: tI.I) 4!~~.st~~:;.:;;;;,,:..... \.;: .~" '~~>._::;!lF'. .v _,' _..-.. f .. - .. DRAFT DRAFT Table of Contents Paae Introduction. ..... .,. .... ..... ........... .......,.,. .......... ........ ......... ...... ........... .......... 2 Redistricting Criteria............. ... ... ...... ... .... ..... ........... ..... ..... .......... .......' .... 2 Methodology... ...... ..... .., .... ... ... ......... ..................... ...... ......... ....... .... .......... 3 Pre-clearance Data... ................ ....... .... ....,..... ........ ....... ....... ..... ................... 3 Features... ... ........ ....'............ .... ........... ......... .......... ..__. ............ ...... ............. 4 Strengths... ........ ..... ................... ........ ... ...... ........ ........ ...... ... __.. ..... ... .... ..... 5 Critique...... ............ .... .... ........... ........... ...... ......... ... ........ .... .... ........... ........ 6 Retrogression Analysis.. ............. ......... ........ .......... ........................... ......... 7 . Exhibits 2000 Census Tract Map 2000 Census Tract Population Retrogression Analysis Map of Existing Districts Proposed Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 General Descriptions of Districts for Maps #1, #2, #3, #4 #5 1 ~.~~'^---"< ._----~_.... -., _._--~- --------_._._~_._-_._-_._...._---~--- -------------- DRAFT DRAFT Introduction Collier County has experienced extraordinary growth since the establishment of the present Board of County Commissioner (BCe) Districts in 1995, when the permanent population was 182,823. The present population of Collier County is 251,377, according to the 2000 Census. As one might expect, this increase in population was not uniform throughout each district (see Table below). BCC District Population in 2000 Ideal Population Deviation District 1 49,840 50,275 - 0.8% District 2 47,164 50,275 - 6.1% District 3 57,712 50,275 + 14.7% District 4 40,662 50,275 - 19.1% District 5 55,999 50,275 + 11.3% Total 251,3n Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). As a result of the uneven growth in Collier County, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners directed staff on June 26, 2001 to redraw the commission districts in order to comply with the one-person one-vote constitutional mandate. The Board of County Commissioners specifically approved the following redistricting criteria: (1) The population of each district should be as similar as possible; (2) All districts should be as compact and regularly shaped as feasible; and (3) The incumbent Commissioner's residence must remain in his or her current district. Additionally, though not spedfically directed by the BCC, there are additional considerations of a legal nature that must also be taken into account. This report contains a summation of the five (5) proposed plans. Redistrictina Criteria Each of the five plans attempts to balance the following redistricting criteria: . Create districts that do not exceed a 5% deviation from the ideal district population. . Create compact and contiguous districts that observe well-defined and easily recognizable boundaries. . Protect incumbent commissioners by building each district around the residency of its commissioner. . Minimize disruption to former districts. . Avoid retrogression of minority voting strength. . Maintain communities of interest. . Devise plans Whereby uniformity can be achieved between the School Board and the Board of County Commissioners. 2 ...~.~-,_. -'-'-..~"~-'-- -.---..-. DRAFT DRAFT Methodoloqv The first step in creation of all five proposed maps was to plot the residency of each commissioner on the 2000 Census Tract Map for Collier County. The next step was to build each district by incorporating those Census Tracts adjacent to the place of residency, to the extent possible and practical. (See attached Exhibits, 2000 Census Tract Map and Tract Population.) Examole: Commissioner Carter, representing District 2, resides in Pelican Bay which lies within Census Tract 102.04. Given his place of residency, the place of residency of the other four Commissioners, and the existing boundaries of District 2, it was only natural that Census Tracts 101.01, 101.02, 101.03, 101.04 and 102.05 be incorporated into his district. Generally, this same process was repeated for all five districts on all five proposed maps. The next step, which was the most challenging, involved expanding or retracting each district as necessary to achieve relative equity in population, while at the same time creating compact and contiguous districts with well-defined boundaries that did not split voting blocks or neighborhoods. Concurrency with the District School Board was another important element that was considered. This was achieved by plotting the residency of each School Board member to ensure that no two members resided in the same district. Collier County is a covered jurisdiction under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Asa covered jurisdiction, Collier County must obtain pre-clearance before enforcing any redistricting plan. In order to obtain pre-clearance from the U.S. Department of Justice, the County must demonstrate that the new plan does not result in the retrogression of minority voting strength. This is ascertained by comparing minority voting strength, as measured by voting age population, under the existing and newly adopted plan (before and after comparison for all five proposed maps). Pre-clearance District 5 has the greatest minority population in Collier County (See Table 1, below). Although it does not qualify as a minority-majority district at this time, it is the district that warrants the closest scrutiny fur possible retrogression of minority voting strength. As District 5 is presently configured, it has a total voting age population of 39,440, based on the 2000 Census. Of this total voting age population, 2,875 are identified as Black and 14,242 are identified as Hispanic. This means that in District 5, as it is presently configured, Blacks make up 7.3% of the voting age population and Hispanics make up 36.1% of the voting age population (See Table 1). [It is important to note that "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity.] 3 _._--- DRAFT DRAFT Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population by District Present Configuration District Total Black Hispanic (All) 1 43,038 1,036 (2.4%) 5,141 (11.9%) 2 40,401 257 (0.6%) 2,249 (5.5%) 3 44,153 1,811 (4.1%) 8,238 (18.6%) 4 34,404 1,333 (3.8%) 3,685 (10.7%) 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Total 201,436 7,312 (3.6%) 33,555 (16.6%) Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). ANALYSIS OF EACH OF THE PROPOSED MAPS Features MAP #1 District 1 remains the same. Collier Boulevard is the main feature as it forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area. MAP #2 District 1 remains the same. Collier Boulevard is the main feature as it forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples area. MAP #3 Most of the population in the coastal area south of US-41 is induded in District 1. Portions of the Uvingston Road corridor form a north-south line parallel to Collier Boulevard. MAP #4 The main feature of this plan is the elongated shape of District 3 - extending' from the Lee County line to below Davis Boulevard, and from 1-75 and the Uvingston Road corridor to Collier Boulevard. Also, Collier Boulevard forms the divider between the more rural District 5 and the more urbanized Districts 1-4 in the greater Naples ,area. 4 - DRAFT DRAFT MAP #5 Districts 1 and 5 are nearly identical in configuration to their existing boundaries. Districts 2, 3 and 4, while maintaining their core Census Tracts and most of their existing boundaries, are now neatly realigned along the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Livingston Road. This north-south alignment, parallel to Collier Boulevard, is the distinguishing feature of this plan. Strenoths All five plans accomplish the Board's directives regarding population equity and respecting the residency of each commissioner. All five plans accomplish the Board's directive regarding the creation of compact districts with regularly shaped boundaries, though to varying degrees. MAP #1 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd. - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the City of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #2 District 1 remains completely the same. The population lying north of Immokalee Road and west of Collier Blvd. - a significant portion of which is within country club developments - is shifted out of District 5, which is comprised of a mostly rural population. All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #3 Of the five proposed maps, the population is most evenly distributed on this map. This map shifts the communities of Everglades Oty, Plantation Island and Chokoloskee from District 5 into District 1 - these three communities have some characteristics similar to Goodland which also lies in District 1. All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #4 All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. MAP #5 By using the FPL transmission line adjacent to the existing and future Livingston Road as a major boundary, this plan creates highly compact and geometrically neat districts with well-defined and well-recognized boundaries that follow major features. The Livingston Road Plan avoids dividing neighborhoods, utilizing minor features and creating numerous irregular boundaries. At the same time, the boundaries of the current districts were respected where practicable: All of the Oty of Naples, and most of the Naples water and sewer service area, is included in District 4. The School Board and County Commission district boundaries are aligned. 5 - DRAFT DRAFT Critiaue MAP #1 There are several jogs and turns in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Districts 4-3. The common boundary between Districts 4-3 runs through Coconut Creek and Coconut Grove neighborhoods dividing each between two different Commission Districts. MAP #2 There are a few jogs and turns in the boundary between Districts 2-3 and between Districts 4-3. The deviation between highest and lowest District population is the greatest on this map out of all five maps. MAP #3 This map shifts the communities of Everglades City, Plantation Island and Chokoloskee from District 5 into District 1. Arguably, the character of these communities is dissimilar to many of the developments in District 1, e.g. Marco Island and Lely Resort. Also, at least in recent history, those three coastal communities have been located within District 5. MAP #4 The common boundary between Districts 3-1 contains several jogs; some of these do not follow recognizable features, e.g. the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, and the east side of Wing South Airstrip. MAP #5 Arguably, that portion of Census Tract 112.01 east of I-75 has evolved into developments substantially different in character from the rest of the proposed district. This is a legitimate concern, and communities of interest were considered in devising this plan. However, it should be noted that no district is perfectly homogeneous, nor is it clear that strict class or ethnic/racial segregation is wise or desirable in a community as diverse as ours. In addition, District 5, as it is presently configured, includes all of Census Tract 112.01. This plan shifts to District 2 that portion of Census Tract 112.01 west of 1-75 Retroaression Analysis As noted earlier in this report, only District 5 warrants a retrogression analysis as It has, by far, the largest minority population. In the present District 5, the Black population comprises 7.3% of the voting age population, and the Hispanic population comprises 36.1% of the voting age population. As indicated in the attached ExhibitA-3, Retrogression Analysis, all five proposed maps result in an increase in these minority populations in District 5; conversely, none of the five proposed maps result in a retrogression of minority voting strength . Redlsbicting Report DRAFT1 F. Redlsbicting TD/dw Oct. 2001 6 -. '-'-."-'- - -,<~"---,,~~ ----.-- "__.00- CWl'_ca. '" ". .' " COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ~ ; , 2000 CENSUS TRACTS "' , " , 114 l' d """'''''' -~ -- "- 3 ~ ~- j :ill n------ '\ I J.. . I , u,_ <u""""".. 112.01 ._---_.~- / 101.03 112.02 ~., ... , :g 1 ~ 104.05 "'~.. 101.1104 10....12 ~I!O 104.07 g- ......."."...... 102.04 , 1 , -- 103 , 3.01 , 4 2 -,.. 3.02 1-" '0"'''.,.., =OF- ~ lW'L&'l u... ,..........._" u... '.lDIT.J[_l$ 7 101.01 108.04 6 107.01 ~ 0 ~ S- o, \1, 0 . , 111.02 ~ ;/ CllTOF kWlC013LAND ______ ~~ ., ~il ',.." '. I ! ~ ~---_.-- , ---..., I I S=E ! ,..--,-----, r;::::: 0 1A.1l. 2M1. I I Ii LEGEND I I ,11- =, ~A" ~""AA'l T' "l"\;, j..' -- I 1.... /H J, 'I!' ,.J ,..;..,= t'..."", ~r: - - PFlO"ARED BY: c:JUPIiICS ANO 11::Cl-lNICAL SUI'I"OFlT SE:CT10~ _..",0. J(J I _ "- \ . -=;:~ '"'-"-7 I COl,WUNITY O[',ROPUENT AHO OlVtROM.lENTAL srn\Olcrs m\OlSl<:l/< '" ;;,... .;"\ )"\,} \_~-;/_, L.. ,~ > [)ATE: 5/2001 Fllt: COllR-A,-2OCa.OWC I -_.~ ~------- ~._-"~-,^------"'- "'""n.. .~ _.,,'"'~ ---.-...- T_ April 1, 2000 Permanent Population Collier County, Florida 2000 Census Tract 2000 Total Population I 3,649 2 2,199 3.01 3,532 3.02 1,631 4 4,717 S 1,813 6 1,.483 7 1,292 101.01 6,802 101.02 3,542 101.03 6,337 101.04 7.194 102.02 8,106 102.03 5,283 102.04 7,383 102.05 2,355 103 4,235 104,01 3,713 104.05 5,802 104.06 7,007 104.07 6,926 104.08 3,147 104.09 8.380 104.10 6,469 104.11 6,102 104.12 6,697 104,13 3,336 104.14 6,656 105.02 7,028 IOS,03 7,230 105.04 6,464 106.01 2,601 106.02 3,359 106.03 5,699 106.04 3,757 107.01 4,807 107.02 4,162 108.01 3,857 108.02 6,612 108.03 3,458 109.01 4,048 109.02 3,377 109.03 4,090 110 3.698 111.01 5,887 111.02 4,213 112.01 3,384 112.02 5,790 112.04 4,623 1I2.0S 3.464 113 9,430 114 4,551 COUNTYWIDE 251,377 Note from Census Bureau: ~DlI.ta not adjusted based an the ACCUlal;y and Coverage evaluarion." Source: U.S_ Census Bureau, C.:nUil; 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171) Summary File. M1ItIices PLJ. PL2, PU, :DId PU Tract population G, Comprehensive, 2000 Census dwl April 2001 ~"--~~-,- .' ---- Retrogression Analysis Maps #1. #2 & #4 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Maps #1, #2 & #4 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111. 0 1 (portion) 1,594 2 106 . 111.02 3,437 105 7.29 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Maps #1, #2 & #4) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 34,934 2,854 (8.2%) 14,058 (40.2%) Change I +0.9% +4.1% L I Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. ~-~. '" --.,... - -------~- ... Retrogression :Analysis Map #3 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #3 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111.02 (portion) 2,177 102 702 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Source: Rgures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #3) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 32,080 2,849 (8.9%) 13,925 (43.4%) Change + 1.6% + 7.3% Source: Figures extracted from U.S. Census Bureau, Census 2000 RedistTlctrng Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an etlmicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. ---- --_...._.._.~._- ,""---" --~~.~._.._-----~-- RetrogressionAnafysis Map #5 Table 1 2000 Voting Age Population in District 5 Map #5 Census Tract No. Total Population Black Hispanic (All) 104.12 4,704 133 813 104.13 2,381 39 505 104.14 4,598 69 862 111.02 3,437 105 729 112.01 2,327 13 76 (east of 1-75) 112.02 3,877 126 1,012 112.04 3,276 1,170 1,790 112.05 2,047 724 1,128 113 5,997 319 4,731 114 3,023 167 2,382 Total 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 14,028 (39.3%) Source: Rgures extracted from u.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). Table 2 2000 Voting Age Population Comparison District 5 Present Configuration vs. Proposed District (Map #5) Plan Total Black Hispanic (All) Present District 5 39,440 2,875 (7.3%) 14,242 (36.1%) Proposed District 5 35,667 2,865 (8.0%) 13,349 (39.3%) Change +0.7% + 3.2% Source: Figures extracted from U.s. Census Bureau, Census 2000 Redistricting Data (Public Law 94-171). NOTE: "Hispanic" is an ethnicity, not a race; accordingly, a person may be of any race and also be of Hispanic ethnicity. ._~~_.__. - -... ----,.' ~---- tn U ' Z : - . ' ... ' I .." __ I .. .. Q -- Z " '" - ... :== ~ o I- Z tn Q U _ c ~ a::Cl ~ ~ · au CI 0 _ Z ~ (J ~ oJO ~ ~ oJ - ~ ~ otn ~ ~ u!!! ~ r :e · ~ II 'I ,i u L~~ " . I AiNf'lO:l.l,lleNJIi l'Ori"ll":J . . . " C " . ' ; -- I -. " " . . . " . " " . . .uH11:XlJ3l GW.u1OOII ~ '" ClIrffIlJlllllIiIUlTr'l!l I ~ ~ , . . ~ lDttllru'lOB '" ::i. ~ 11 ~ III g > . . ~ . I" I ~ i ~ ~~ . z i.il'" ci 1ft"" , !' . , . ~ ,'" g" ~ . . 5 ~ ~o Ii · ,,~ __ 9 "' ,~,,"g e< . . " , ,N.... ' " ., .. " .. "," / .~o ._ .'1 ,,, " , ..- ,", ,I, . 0"" ' ::; I " << , t" 0 .~" 00' 0 OZO ~__~ '1 ~~~ ___ _~ "71' ,.1 ______ _ 15 ~L II __ ~ o~" _____ ____d . n: I -. ~ "'-'-'~ n __n-- I I I -, , ! In w I i ... z I I CJ ::l AlHflO~ awlllOtlll ~ .... .lUlnc:l3.ay(j i I - <..l a:: ~ // I ZC'" 15 = III! z .,.. 0 OlnC lit ill UOZ Q ~ Z ::; . I aca.O a. w 0 '" 11I0- CI: ~ <..l Q ~ -a::1n :E w 8 ..I a. In '" 0 ... - a.. . 0 :IE 0 ~ . 0:: U :E a.. .1 ~ 0 I < I " to) ~ z 0 , i """"'''''''''' i . VOM!'lf:l I . . . ~ u .. " I j 6Z'lfS i an ,<' .. . . .; . ((~ . " .; ~,--i ~ . -U1ll1l1:l!:l,-; ...."""" """"""" Olr'fI\i:TIOlI'OllYlOla'IJ i . . llW.ulOOS NOSlw, " . 5 UI ~ . . g ~ i " ~E ~ ~i! i'i 'i ~l - I >Ii a~ > . '" ow wo ~~ ~. ~ RI "(Ill ~ :t;t ~'Z'" ~ \.-:;"0 ~~~i -"!ai' o~/ !f!!:i,,-I G\;V ~~~I ; ~~~I 0 (I>....tr.il 0"' 0 ~~~I ;:;QZ 0 ~ , - - I :'l 53;;:i --, - Z . ' - < ,,~ I u . - -- ro o~~, .., ~zol --- ,_ oj <' - -- --.-,-- ~~~ ",0"" - o..uol -' I - - - - - - :! II - , III i z ~ U ::l I I - ti Al.HlOOQlItIIlOIII a: ~ .w<~_ Zal- :::::>> fI) a 01U- N z ( 0 u fI) a =II: (jj IJl Oz c :e a:ILo IL ifi ::lE . 1U0- C " 8 :i a: fI) :E ~I 0 . ..IlL! ~ ~ 0 o :E l1. a ~ u :E l1. 0 . u I ~ > I ~ = i I . ,UIU)OCI},tIllfOH -= . . oJ t K" ~ > Kn ~ . oJ . 0 . . oJ ~ . UHl'lOOlD1 awA71fllO ,.,."...., ~ ""......,.,."...., i . "'''''''''' . .,.,.. . ~ III . . . g . . " oJ i t .~~ -" ~ I; 9 ~l - , j~ ~ z' 00 fi" re ~~ 5' It'S'" ~~ I "zO b~~~ .{~i5 I o' """" ,-,,,,,.,,;1 z~ j " ;; 5"~ ,ov wz::;: \ " .W< 000 b'~ zz< .- 0 ..;-<,!.. -- 00. ",...", 0 ~~~ I ~h ~:5:; I 0"" "-~- . - y .;l'i_ .._,', 8~? .z- .0 ..".~"- l:i3~ .0< "vo -",'-'---'---'~ , I -, ! I I MHrltJ:l'lWMOlllll .uHflll:J~'"I = W Z ::; t- U " ~ i 1i2 I t; zal- 2i z :)w! CO) 0 g; Ofna '" lit Q :; " UOz z ::;; a. w 0 lIl:a.o c:t () " wo- c:c ~ Q ~ ,. w -lIl:fn :IE '" " 0 > " . ....a.fn 0.. ~ ~ " .... - ~ o :IE 0.. . . . U :IE . , il 0 , U M""""""'" -= . . . " " " ~.", nOM'S " .. . ~ . " . 0 " " " . , -- OWIlJlOOBDI'nlllQ\l ..."""'''' ~ . g " " . - ..... . III ~ . ~ . ~ ~ .. , ~ . I ~ u . .' ~E OC c. " U" ~u g . > >~ ~. " ~l - I ;~ .. "lJlI tlNl11l'W .~ u' f :z~ 0' "is \,."5"0 " ." CO ., ., ,....." ." 0 ~Q 0 ., gl ~ .. ;; ~~ 5~: - I Z fi~5 I c~, I ~~2 0 l:J i~ g:8~1 - ......... -.--.--^- I I i I - I - en w , t; ! I z I ~ ::i I I .... A.l.NIlOJ mlVIIOIlll - <.1 a::: ~ ~"""- Zal- ::::I en 0 011I- 'It ~ uena :II: in '" I Oz Cl 5i a::: a. 0 a. z ::; I w " 1&1 0 - ocr: " 0 ~ OJ ::; a::: en == c ~ w ....a.en ~ o - a. ~ U I 0 ~ a: a. 0 . I . u . I " i ~ " I i\ . """"',..... I -," I . . . ~ ~ I " " " ~ . W"Ii"5: . . " . //"-, " " . ",---,j " " " ~""'m -"""" """""" . Oll'IA7VlC8!OllY1lllG\J ~ . GWATlnolJ NllSlM ~ ~ III ~ . - . . u i ~ "" Ii. ~ " , 5 . ~ >. " z' 00 'lIII~rw ti~ ~u iN 'O~ ~ "ill 5~ ~. l..".l"n ~~~ ~"~5 ~~q "",;.' ~o" " 0' u .. 5~~ ,0 ~C'.i:;" ~ 000 zz< 5s~ 0 ...:""'!" c ~3;s1 ~h ,i:::::!..1 <""I IZ lS~": - ~~- \ ! 8~~ 0- ~~- ~~8 ~<.l~1 - I ---'-l I I ! , I I ,Uttf'llXl olWMOW .IJ.tIi"IlXl:;Q..O tn OJ I z t- ::l // .... U '-' ~ i ii: t;; zat- 15 z ;:)w! II) 0 ;;; Otna (IJ :a: " :e , UOz z ~ OJ 0 D:a.o a. " '-' " c:c OJ c g wo- .... w " -a::tn == (IJ . . 0 ..Ia.tn l1. 0; ..I - li1 o 2 l1. . . U 2 . 0 I U J.1flJ'm.l.~NJH YOt1I'II~ . I . "' "' u u K '~"$ 11:111'$ . . i ... " . 0 ... " u . , awA3"1nol1 'ii3ClYelDl\] QW.uTIOfilaOV1!llOoU """"'''' ~ . ~ " ,; "' OW.ul11Oll NOS1iI ~ 1ft ~ ~ ^ i ~ i ~ . " 0 u . ~~ " ." " tOm 0_ _u ~ .. ~ ", " h . ,- >. 0" ; <;l-I ~~ ":3 ~ ~Nmn.o :<~ N "' ~J . . ,,^ " ~~>- u ,,'S"n ~n "v ",.-<1 0 >:>CjO 0 ~~e ~ :1 ~ 13'3G: Ii'~ ' , O' I Z ~~-I s~~1 "_1 "'5..- ~;;!~ .0< ....UO! ___m_____... ----------~--_.._._-_._--------- EXHIBIT "A" General DescriDtions. MAP #1 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastem shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastem shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest comer of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southeriy to the northeast comer of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 2S East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence alon9 the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the Intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of Lakewood Boulevard; thence along the center of Lakewood Boulevard, northerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, westerly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, northerly to the center of Coconut Circle South; thence along the center of Coconut Orele South, westerly to the center of Coconut Circle west; thence along the center of Coconut Circle West, northerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, easterly to the center of Donna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, northerly to the center of County Road 8S6 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 8S6, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 7S (I-75); thence along the center of I-75, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of I-7S; thence along the center of I-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said, FPL transmission line, northeriy to the center of County Road ~--_..__._.._--~---_.._--_._-_._- -,,--,-,.._-_._-~._.,.~._"-~~~---- ~~-----,," 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road);: ,thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly to the south line of Section 2S, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly to the eastem boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly to the southeast comer of the Regent Park PUD; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Park PUD, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersectio:1 of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Aorida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, southerly to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green Canal, westerly to the center of the Aorlda Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center Oonna Street; thence along the center of Donna Street, southerly to the center of North Road; thence along the center of North Road, westerly to the center of Coconut Circle West; thence along the center of Coconut Circle West, southerly to the center of Coconut Circle South; thence along the center of Coconut Circle South, easterly to the center of Guava Drive; thence along the center of Guava Drive, southerly to the center of Estey Avenue; thence along the center of Estey Avenue, easterly to the center of l.akewood Boulevard; thence along the center of l.akewood Boulevard, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township SO South, Range 2S East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County- Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County- Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. DW Imklf:/comp.pianning/davidweeks General Descripllons Map #1, A F, Redistricting -. . ..~" ~..__^,M~ ~-_. EXHIBIT "A" General DescriDtions, MAP #2 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.s. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway u.s. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence, along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point 'of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 19, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Regent Park PUD, southerly to the northeast corner of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along the east boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, southerly to the south line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.5. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast corner of the Regent Park PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the north line of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of Section 24 of said Township and Range, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 19, Township 49 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of Section 19 of said Township and Range, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road ---~-~---~_.- -~-~-~-_._,~~-,- ~,--_..- "_.'._.-._--~,,--, 862, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, northerly to the soUth line of Section 25, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, also being the north boundary of Pelican Marsh PUD; thence along the south line of Section 25 of said Township and Range, easterly to the eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision; thence along said eastern boundary of Four Seasons subdivision, northerly to the southeast corner of the Regent Park PUD; thence along the east boundary of the Regent Park PUD, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Sea gate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, southeriy to the center of the Green Canal; thence along the center of the Green CanC!I, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of Golden Gate Parkway; thence along the center of Golden Gate Parkway, easterly to the center of 1-75; thence along the center of 1-75, southeasterly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Rorida; thence along said Lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line tums north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westeriy to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.s. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. DW/mklt/comp.plannlng/davidweeks Genellli Desaiplions Map #2. A F, Redistricting . -~ ..-. ---.....-.. ,-,-,',---,.--,-,-----""--- ,..__..~_._..,,-", .--.-- ~-'~. EXHIBIT "An General DescriDtions. MAP #3 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of County Road 864; thence along the center of County Road 864, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of said road, southerly to the north line of Section 11, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 11, easterly to the northwest comer of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of said Section 12, easterly to the northwest corner of Section 7, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along the north line of said Section 7, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 7; thence southerly along the east line of said Section 7 and continuing southerly along the east line of Sections 18, 19, 30, and 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East, to the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, westerly and northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 29 and 32 of said Township and Range, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the east line of Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 26, and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Florida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of County Road 864 (Rattlesnake Hammock Road); thence along the center of County Road 864, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Aorida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to east ,----~ _-v-_ I.. line of Section 32, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 32 and 29 of said Township and Range, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Oam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of 5eagate Drive; thence along said imaginary 6<l:ension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Florida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence aiong the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier CountycMiami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point south of, and in alignment with, the east line of Section 31, Township 53 South, Range 30 East; thence along said alignment and along the east line of Sections 31, 30, 19, 18, and 7, of said Township and Range, northerly to the northeast corner of Section 7, of said Township and Range; thence along the north line of Section 7, of said Township and Range, westerly to the northeast comer of Section 12, Township 53 South, Range 29 East; thence along the north line of Sections 12 and 11, of said Township and Range, westerly to the center of County Road 29; thence along the center of County Road 29, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of Collier Boulevard, northerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. General Desaiptions Map #3, A F,Redistricllng -~----,_..~--,-_._~--,-_._-_._--_. -~~~-,-~ .._---~~ EXHIBIT "'Au General DescriDtions. MAP #4 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, southerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, easterly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, southerly to the north line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the north line of said Section 16, easterly to the northeast comer of said Section 16; thence along the east line of said Section 16, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, southerly to the north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Oub; thence along said north boundary, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway u.s. 41; thence along the center of State Road 951, southerly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, westerly to the center of the Florida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westeriy to the center of Highway u.s. 41; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the northeast corner of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Sections 10, 15 and 22 of said Township and Range, southerly to the intersection of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road) and County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the north boundary of the Napies Lakes Country Club; thence along said north boundary of the Naples Lakes Country Club, westerly to the east line of Section 16, Township 50 South, Range 26 East; thence along the east line of Section 16 of said Township and Range, also being the east boundary of the Wing South Airstrip, northerly to the north line of said Section 16; thence along the north line of said Section 16, westerly to the center of Sunset Boulevard; thence along the center of Sunset Boulevard, northerly to the center of Cope Lane; thence along the center of Cope Lane, westerly to the center of County Barn Road; thence along the center of County Barn Road, northerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Aorida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the -- - ----_._--~~.,.._._-,-_.__._.__.._-~~,-" ,--- ,,"-."",. - -. center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of San Marcos -Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, northerly to the center of the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, westerly to the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, northerly to the intersection of County Road 862 (Vanderbilt Beach Road); thence along the center of County Road 862, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Coliier County, Aorida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Sea gate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road), easterly to the center of the Aorida Power & Ught (FPl) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPl transmission line, southerly to the Golden Gate Canal; thence along the center of the Golden Gate Canal, easterly to the center of San Marcos Boulevard; thence along the center of San Marcos Boulevard, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPl transmission line; thence along the center of the FPl transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiaml Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the northeast comer of Section 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, also being a point on the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said lee County-Collier County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Ught; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of Manatee Road; thence along the center of Manatee Road, westerly to the intersection of State Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 951, northerly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the east line of Sections 22, 15, and 10, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, northerly to the Point of Beginning. General OescrIpUons Map #4. A F, Red~l1icIing - ---~.~.._-"~_._~_._---"_.._.--._- . --~--_._.._-----_.- EXHIBIT "'A" General Descriptions. MAP #5 District 1 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the southern boundary of the city of Naples), easterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall Canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, northeasterly to the center of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, northwesterly to the center of Airport-Pulling Road; thence along the center of said road, northerly to the center of Davis Boulevard; thence along the center of Davis Boulevard, easterly to the center of County Road 951; thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of County Road 92; thence along said road, southwesterly to the center of the Marco River; thence along the center of the Marco River, easterly and southerly to a point that is 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence southwesterly to the southern most point of Cape Romano; thence along the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northwesterly to the Point of Beginning. District 2 - Begin at the intersection of the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the north section line of Section 6, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida; thence along the north line of Sections 6 and 5 of said Township and Range (also being the Lee County-Collier County boundary line), easterly to the center of County Road 901 (Vanderbilt Drive); thence along the center of said road, southerly to the northwest corner of Section 9 of said Township and Range; thence along the northern boundary of Collier County, easterly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along the center of said 1-75, southerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); thence along the center of County Road 846, westerly to the east boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary of Eboli PUD, southerly to the southern boundary of Eboli PUD; thence along the southern boundary of Eboli PUD, westerly to the southeast corner of April Circle PUD; thence along the southern boundary of April Circle PUD, westerly to the center of the Aorida Power and Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 896 (Pine Ridge Road); thence along the center of County Road 896, westerly to the center of Highway u.s. 41; thence along the center of 5eagate Drive, westerly to the west shoreline of Clam Bay; thence along said west shoreline, northerly and westerly to the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 3 - Begin at the intersection of the northeast comer of the Eboli PUD and County Road 846 (Immokalee Road), Collier County, Aorida; thence along the center of County Road 846, easterly to the intersection of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, southerly to the intersection of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of the Florida Power & Light (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the , center of County Road 856, westerly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of said FPL transmission line, northerly to the southwest comer of the April Circle PUD; thence along the south boundary of April Circle PUD, easterly to the southwest corner of the Eboli PUD; thence along the south boundary of the Eboli PUD, easterly to the east boundary of the Eboli PUD; thence along said eastern boundary, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 4 - Begin at the intersection of the easterly shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico and the south shoreline of Clam Pass, Collier County, Florida; thence along the southerly and westerly shoreline of Clam Pass and Clam Bay, easterly and southerly to a point on the west shoreline of Clam Bay in alignment with an imaginary westerly extension of Seagate Drive; thence along said imaginary extension, easterly to the center of the western terminus of Seagate Drive; thence along the center of Seagate Drive, easterly to the intersection of Highway U.S. 41; thence along the center of County Road ------- ----_._----~.__._--_...__._._.- 896 (Pine Ridge Road)i easterly to the center of the Florida Power & Ught (FPL) transmission line; thence along the center' of said FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of County Road 856 (Radio Road); thence along the center of County Road 856, easterly to the center of the FPL transmission line; thence along the center of the FPL transmission line, southerly to the center of State Road 84 (Davis Boulevard); thence along the center of State Road 84, westerly to the center of County Road 31 (Airport-Pulling Road); thence along the center of County Road 31, southerly to Highway U.s. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of said highway, southeasterly to the center of the Lely Outfall canal; thence along the center of the Lely Outfall Canal, southwesterly to the center of Dollar Bay; thence along the center of Dollar Bay, northwesterly to the north line of Section 34, Township 50 South, Range 25 East; thence along the north line of said Section 34 (also being the south boundary of the City of Naples), westerly to the eastern shoreline of the Gulf of Mexico; thence along said shoreline, northerly to the Point of Beginning. District 5 - Begin at the center of Interstate 75 (1-75) at the Lee County-Collier County boundary, Collier County, Florida; thence along said County boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns and goes north; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, northerly until said boundary line turns and goes east; thence continue along said Lee County-Collier County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary line turns north; thence along said boundary line, northerly to the point where the Collier County-Lee County boundary line meets the Collier County- Hendry County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Hendry County boundary line, easterly to the point where said boundary turns south; thence along said boundary line, southerly to the point where said boundary turns east; thence along said boundary, easterly to the point where said boundary line meets the Collier County-Broward County boundary line; thence along the Collier County-Broward County boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Miami-Dade boundary line, southerly to the point where the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line begins; thence along the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to the western end of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line; thence along a westerly prolongation of the Collier County-Monroe County boundary line, westerly to a point in the Marco River that is south of a point 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence northerly to said point lying 3,500 feet south of the Coon Key Light; thence along the center of the Marco River, northerly and westerly to the center of County Road 92 (San Marco Road); thence along the center of said road, northerly and easterly to the center of Highway U.s. 41 (Tamiami Trail); thence along the center of U.S. 41, northwesterly to the center of County Road 951 (Collier Boulevard); thence along the center of County Road 951, northerly to the center of County Road 846 (Immokalee Road); tl1ence along the center of said road, westerly to the center of Interstate 75 (1-75); thence along said 1-75, northerly to the Point of Beginning. Genellll Desaip1Ions Map 115. A F. Redlslriclll1g 1 - --_.__.__._--~----- -.....-. -. ^_....., .__."._-,~,- -,.. " ~ ~ .,.. ~ ~ lJ'l rI r ~ ..... .,.. !Ia r-i t- o N ~ I' ..; ~ C"\ - - 0 n ~ 0 ...... ..r-'t ~ ~ r;- ... ..:> )n r- ~ "" ~ --> - ~ 1ft ~ ,.fi- g -r- 0 N :!"' C) - - -- E ~ 0\ "'" CIl ~ i:')O -' /if- '- ~ .2 < .: ~ .e Q :g ~ ~ U .... ~ l!, -- oS! 01 . III o J!! ..!!! ~ .c: ~~ <3 - ~ Cl - .11I c: CI) C> c It cS c: :c: '(j ~ ..!!! 'C III III :g o]i c: CIl CIl {"-al c: .. e e e ~ e ~o:: 0 ~III ~ ~~ il>1II -:r8 Cl (;-, \'- ~ -, .> .~ ~,.,." I ~oQ' F!-. ~l .s"\I\ · .,..)n~ ~ 'v\\nN ,.) -::: CO) c> .~ ..:!> \r, tr) - " .... ..... ~-.... - .... .",.. t.l U ..... .... ';>0 .> U .::J~U ~ .~ U ,..,.. E '- f:> - "".., .,.....::::').~ - "t: - ,g '" ~ N ~ - 100.; .:i A - .... ~ .... " '" . III .!!! fA .!!! .!!! \\ .!!! \ \ " ;> .- :;::- ." """" .)0:> Cl Cl Cl " Cl > Cl :;; > '" }}o s::: c: c: c: c: " .. e 0 0 0 0 0 "" ~ .- .- .- .- .- tj C> 'J> 0 III III III III III '" ::i>':::> .!!! III III III III c 0 pl .- .- .- .- - E e e E e = 0 .. = E-< "3 E e e e e 0 C- O \ \ U "- 0 0 0 0 0 jg "'/ u u u u 0 0 C - ---_._-_.......~---~--------~ - .__._---~--_._._.--...__._---- .... I- ~ ...,. Il'l .... ,~ .... M ..... I,Q ~ ~ ...,. a; 1-' '1 ~ ~ .,} I- + I + I .e. .& ,& ,& ,& .- .; .- .- .- = = = = C' C' C' C' C' .... .... .... .... .... ., ,., ., ., .. i; i; i; i; i; .- .- .- .- .- .:: .:: .:: .:: .:: ... ...' ... ... ... -< -< -< -< -< Q '" '" '" Q ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... = = = = = .. ., ., .. .. 8 8 8 ~ 8- ... ... ... ... '" '" '" '" '" = = = = = ..... ;;' .... ..... ..... "Cl "Cl "Cl "Cl -< -< -< -< -< ;::: = c:i = = =: = ~ Q '" '" '" '" " .- .- .- .- ..: .- m ... if ... ... ... ... j: .. .. .. .. ..., .. - - - Ql :; -, '" = = = = --' J:l;, J:l;, J:l;, .- Co ~ Co _!,1 '" ..: '" '" ~ '" .5 '" :c ~ Ql ~ ~ ~ .... ~ " 1:: (,) Q) e, 0) :e - -l!I .!! ~ s::: 0 '" .- 0 Cl .ca s::: co CI) _5 u: c:i s::: :z: u ~ ca :s ca III III '" - 'C s::: Q) Ql Q) " s::: E E E E a:: <> 0 {:. ca <> ~ ~ <> Cl a. N '" . . I I . " '" ~ ~ CW) ~ It) <= .. .... .... .... .... .... <.} .(,) (,) (,) (,) (,) E ;.:: .- 1:: .- .- ~ .... ~ .... ~ ~ '0 III .~ III III .!!! .. .- .- .- > Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl 'C .. '0 s::: s::: s::: s::: :: on .. 0 0 0 0 0 3 '- .- .- .- .... C> III III III III III '" <= III .~ III III III 0 .... .... .- .... m E E E E E '3 0. E E E E E 0 n. 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 <= __._._~__._._~_.__.,~_.__. m._.___ "-----,.__.,- ;:: ~ a: s..: '" ;: CD ...., :'l ~ . .2 ..: .s :c ~ - " u CIl e,. ~ - g ..!!! ClI 0 '" (,) (,) a co ClI Q CI) :c: E .- ~ u: ..!!! ClI III :g ~ '5 r::: CIl CD m r::: e e e 0: 0 Q ~ 0 ClI ~ 0 Q ...., N ., . r:. . I . " ., ,... C") 'It '0 C m - - - .... - c..l U U U U U E .- .- .- .... .- ,g ,::; ,::; ,::; ~ ~ "0 .!!,! III III III III m ... ... ... .- > Q Q Q Q Q .C m "0 r::: r::: r::: r::: r::: ., Q Q Q Q 0 '" ~ "CI " .- '- ... ... .- .i .!3 '" III III III III III ~ .!!,! III III .!I! III .e;..f! " .- ... .- .2 e e e e e = Q '1ij = Eo< " "- e e e e e Q 0 U a. Q Q 0 Q 0 ;,; (,) (,) (,) (J (,) '0 C _ _ __ _ _ _ __ ___u_. . .^.__..,___._._______~__._ .... t-- l"l .., .... .... III .-.-f l"l I,Q M l"l ~ .., 0\ t-- .., ~ ~ + + III I I i> i> E- E- E- ..' "S. 0;: .. .. = = = 0" 0" 0" 0" 0" f;;;l f;;;l f;;;l f;;;l f;;;l .. .. " " .. t t ;.. t t " .. .. .. .. .. .:: .::: .::: .::: .::: u,: '" '" '" '" -< -< -< -< -< C., 0, Q Q Q .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... = = = = = .. .. .. .. .. a a a a a .... .... .... .... .... ... ... ... ... ... = = = = = .- .- .- .- .- "0 "0 '0,' '0 "0 -< -< -< -< -< ;;: = ci = = = = ... Q Q Q Q Q .. .. .. .. ..: .. m .... ii: .... .... .... .... ~ .. .. .. .. "") .. - - - CI) - - .. = = = = = -' =- "" "" '- "" ~ "" ,g Q ..: Q Q ~ Q .s Q :c ~ CI) ~ ~ ~ .... ~ " (,) "- 1:: CI) - 0) III - s .!!! ~ .c: :!: 8 .. Cl - Cl III c: en " .- ci c: ~ 'B u: ~ .!!! :s III III III " '6 c: CI) CI) CD .. c: E E e e .", 0 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 Q '" " . I . . . " " .... C"Il C") ~ It) c .. .... .... .... .... .... '-' (,) (,) (,) (,) (,) E .,., .- .,., .,., .,., ,g .::: .::: .::: .::: :: "0 .!!! .!!! III III III .. .- .- .... > Q Q Q Q Q "" .. "0 c: c: c: c: c: " .. 0 0 0 0 0 !3 .- .- .- .- .... 0> III III CIl III III ~ c .!!! .!!! .!!! III III 0 .- .- 7;i E E e e e 'S 0. E e e E e 0 "- 0 8 0 0 0 ;; u u u U 15 c _.__________.._.___.,.,._,_,._"'___.___,~_._.""__.._..~._ ~..._~_..m..".' ,--- - ~ g ~ 11 NIlOO~C"')~ Na:JIl')G)tf)~ ......Q)(\')..-N~ NNIlO.....(f)\O ..-CCf'oo.NtO~ UOCr--NO('l UOQCOOON U"ltLC')O'.....M.... UOIlJM.....O~ U..,.NMNCON _LOC"')MNIlO_" _lOC"')""'''''IlO. _N"""-CD"""~~ _NMNCOCO - _CO(")Il')O,..' ;.-:trio-cO";. ;,...-Mc:icD......~~ ..CCO-MOIl'i"":::; ;o::iC"idui....-~ C..r-:MO.CD-....-~ a. ..... N ~ ..... N 9- ....... N a. ..... N Q. ..... N . . 00. ~ % % ~ % r:&. . ::'~1~_i:. "'i;;~ i'i',-~"~"i'., '"",,,.,r . ~1!]fn~ '\:l "....~ if!I'1i,"I' NQ)tnNtD"OI' C\I<>>O,..,.<O"" (J)(Q.....NtO"'f" Om......NCO('!; O)NCOC?..,.'"1' :NOcn.....CO:E :NOLt)lt)CO~ :lON<<tNLO:& :"'OIONIO-o =MOCCMt.O~ U r-- ..,. N_ ~ ~ "". u.......,. "t ""'- ~ ...,- U """ ..,. N. ""t ~ ",. u r-- "It' N. N. en. .,; U..... """ N. C\l" ~ ..... .. .............. la ............... .. ............... CI .............. III ............... ~ ~ ~ ~ << N N N N N AI Al AI Al AI m~:g;n~~ g"'~ro~~ ~Mgg~~~ ~~~~~~ ;n~;x;:e~~ .....-CDmC"')..,....; ........~a:JCf')..,....; ...MtccDN..,..... ....M(QC)N..,...,.; "'N(Q(I)N"".,i ~N "':":ai- l!C...j .....-....:0)..... !"r "':-r-wai-.!<'-i ....:......ai-.!N ...:.....-ai- o 000 0 ...~~~~:5~ ...~~~~:g5 ...~?:3~regS ...~~~gj~B ...~:=~~:gg . . . . . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ C C C c: C u ~ -! -m -! ~ M = - - - - - >. o " - . - ~ ~ (\').....OMNoo C"')_cn..,.('I.lO<l lJ)(J)NC"')<O'" ......('\I......M(\IOI ..,.O,...OCOo. ~ =_ 1t),...,It)N,....~ I.O,....~(O'),...:;;: I"')tOoo:tMCiO~ lC)CDlOM""~ I.OCOMMCO~ .J:) c.::2 CNMoo:tM.......; CNM..,.M......"..; CNM..,.M......_ c:NM..,.M......_ CNM..,.P)..... - ..... o ~ .!! .!! .!! .!! .!! e Pol - to 10 10 . lfI . _ ~ .c( .c( c( c( < .~ :s -~ all to .~ Q. _n '0 = .g ..; 1; E--t := v -l .!! o C ..... P) ..... It) CO') M c:.... (0') CO 0 M"'" C a) CO ..... ..... (0'" C CO 10 CO ..... M"'" C:..,. 10 N NO'" .ua ": 1'1 QU 1IS.....1.OP)a.a..,.~ 1'G.....IONO"<t~ a.....lOMO)M~ ftS.....IONo)..,.~ llf.....IOMIJ)....~ ...... ~ Qt ;:;..... ...... C'? :0..... ....._M :e..... .... M ;;..... ..- (I') :0..... ..... M e-s: 100 ~= .5 .E .5 .E .5 5:...: ~a E E E E E d a 0&( c( c( c( c( ~ _~ ~ . u ;1;~a;:~~ ~~::g!;;~; ~~~f6N~ ~~~~~; :gs~g~:; ~ J(lt)w""O)_"!.M~...: .:.t.1O_..,.co_C"I!.(W)._. ,:.&:co...,.co. M~"..; ~CO_""CIO.""'_'"l_ ~IO_""'CO.N..~...: ~ 0..... NN""- eJ..... NN..,.- U...... NN""- u..... NN..,.- u..... NN....- ii: .!! .!! ..!! .!! 1! i:' m m m m m .. ~ en ~~s;;e~~ ~~~to~i ;i';~~ti~~ ~g:5ti~~ ~~(O~~~ ;:: CJ)Q)CO..,......v; O)CI)f'oooCO.....vi OIOI"""N.....vi .....IONN.......o IO,...COa).......o .!..,.-<<irri..ri .!:.<<i"':tIJ-.N .!IriCO.MV";M';;::; Svi":-.iui.-;:::j 'sca-CD-('Ij..fuiN g: ~....,........,.C") ~""""""""M ~""""""""C"'J ~..,...,...,...,.(") ~""'''''''''''''(I') j u .a :a 'C . " .. ~8:~C;;~;:: ;=~~~::: ;~;e~~;q;; ~~::;:;;;:: ;:~:eg:g~ ~; CD....ca......,.:: CDr--MCI""':!- ......C"')C")O-", N"lI'COM..,.:J WlICDU'JC"I..,.:J. ~Q ii ,z," 0 0 oj co, ~ 1i ai 0 00 N C ~ 1i c. 0 0 do:: Ii 0 Gi 0 C 0 ~ ii"': oi ttr a ;,.: ~ 5 eo 0..,.1010......., "0..,."'.....1010 ''01tJ1010101tJ 01tJ..,.10101O 0"'........1010 0.5 to- to- to- ~ ... ~ _~ :.:: ... 'O:a := .:! :~M~~ ::~M~~ ::~~~~ :~:~~ =~~.....~ ~8 uutiuu uuliuu uoouu uuouu ouut$u ....... :5'S:S:S:S :5E:S"EE .=.=.::::5E :S:S:5:S:S :S:S:S:S-S -~~ ~..!!.!!..!!.!!~ .!!.!!.!!.!!.!!~ .!!.!!!.!!.!!!.!!!g J!!.!!.!!!.!!.!!~ .!!.!!.!!.!!!.!!~ _;a~ cocco... cecoo.. cecoo.. ceccc... cocoa.. ~u U(J"OCJ u,,(,)"u (,)ou"u oouuu uooou o:i (,)00(,)0 (,)O(,)UU (,)uouu uU(JU(J uuuuu u~ alalJDa::IaI ma::lma::la:l mma:lma;l CUQ1C11CDa:I tDlDalmm ~3 " '" g ~ u . "a " ,,- "a " ~3 8: II.,.. eN -l'"t .... GlItt =ui iii :_ :_ :_ :_ :_ ~::i.g ~L ~L ~L ~L ~L " ~ eoe ece eC eC eC ~s g. a.'J: a.::E A.::lC a.:E ca.:!: ~ g :E ------------------ ------~------~ '---, -,--