Loading...
HAAB Backup 06/24/1999 Backup Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Meeting June 24, 1999 NOTICE OF lYIEETING AND .A.GEND.A. COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD THURSDAY, JUNE 24,1999 7:00 P.M. - 9:00 P.M. Golden Gate Community Center, Rooms A & B, Naples, Florida * * * * * * * * * * *.* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * AGENDA I. 7:00 P.M: Meeting of full Board and determination of quorum. II. Meeting called to order. (A) Welcome new appointee(s) (B) Approval of minutes of the April 29, 1999 Special Meeting and minutes of the May 27, 1999 meeting. (C) Approval of excused absences from the May 27,1999 meeting. III. Election of a new Chairman. IV. Discussions regarding: (A) Review of applicant seeking recommendation for appointment to HAAB. (B) Discussions by Faye Reddick regarding (i) report on Immokalee Town Hall meetings that she attended, and (ii) to consider a plan of action to identify goals to be accomplished within the next twelve months. (C) Discussion by Maria Grimaldo relating to a letter about the School Board. V. Presentations by Board members. VI. Old business. VII. New business and public comments. ** Election of a new liaison for the Collier County School Board's Diversity Steering Committee. VIII. Meeting adjourns. ** PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO 5 MINUTES PER SPEAKER/TOPIC UNLESS ADDITIONAL TIME AUTHORIZED BY HAAB. ,'-'.. .'-" John C. Norris District 1 James D. Carter, Ph.D. District 2 Timothy J. Constantine District 3 Pamela S. Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Berry District 5 gjoayd ol-fboi/wy {f;~mty -fbonwru"mOne?(;J 3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples, Florida 34112-4977 (941) 774-8097. Fax (941) 774-3602 May 4, 1999 Mr. Frank Rodriguez, Chairman Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Post Office Box 990244 Naples, Florida 34101 ~~.~ F t!-q., k Dear Mr. R~uez: Thank you very much for your letter of April 26, 1999, in reference to Resolution No. 99-205 regarding English as the Official language of Collier County Government I appreciate you taking the time to write and share your views with me. While I do not agree with your views, I will certainly take your comments under consideration should this be brought before the Board of County Commissioners in the future. Once again, Mr. Rodriguez, thank you for sharing your views with me and if! may be of assistance to you in the future, please contact my oftice. Very truly yours, Commissioner, District I JCN:tlm :r=L:~;U(:~ D-~-.--' 'i ! I , . ,'." I ..., jCc.c ",..., 0 '-'-'- I L_._ F"'-iC:; ,-,., rl'_.J.,-~ ~ i:~\_; , .1 4. Election of Chairman, July 1999 Over half our members are new to the Board this year. For all practical purposes, three of you are here tonight for the first time. Each of you posses unique and special talents that are much needed by this Board. The Hispanic community and the HAAB are at a cross-roads. Through a series of events this past year that culminated in the English Only Ordinance we have the attention of the community and particularly our commisioners as we have seldom had before. It behooves us to take advantage of the momentum. 1 cannot stress enough how critical the role of Chairman is to the success or failure of the future of this Board. At least half the people on this Board have the necessary skills and character to be Chairman. 1 hope as you consider whether or not this position is right for you, that you will lay aside any reservation you may have regarding the length of time you've been a member, whether or not you're too old or too young, or your lack of involvement with recent issues. I do not believe any of these things are relevant. Committment, common sense, temperament and judgement are what is critical to fill this position; length of service on this Board is not. Under the time constraints of meeting once a month for only two hours, as well as the constraints imposed by the Sunshine Law, for us to accomplish anything requires a structured, goal oriented, and above all a courteous working environment. Our new Chairman has a solemn obligation to invoke his authority to control any behavior that is counter productive to the objectives of the meeting. In the interest of all he must be willing to limit individual discussion, whether from the Board or the audience, and insist on absolute courtesy by all. I hope, too, as we vote we will consider the number of potential issues facing us this year. Our Chairmau needs to possess more than enthusiasm and committment, he needs to have the personality and temperament to bring concensus. In other words, please, do not hesitate to stand up and be counted. The year ahead can be filled with accomplishments, but as they say, "a team of wide receivors with no quarterback is not going to make touchdowns". I do not believe we should elect a chairman until the Board can sit with all new members present. This will allow us to select our Chairman from the full compliment of the Board. Therefore, I make a motion that we post-pone the election of a new Chairman until the August meeting and that an interim Chairman be appointed if the present Chairman is not agreeable to act in this capacity. This will allow all the new members to settle in and become more knowledgeable. New Business HAAB Meeting May 27,1999 Town Hall Meeting The Collier Co. Commissioners have decided to host a series of Town Hall Meetings throughout the county this year. The fact that they scheduled the first one in Immokalee is significant. There were approximately 150 people attending. For three hours I listened as gracious, eloquent people gave their testimony in Spanish aud English regarding the problems in the Hispanic community. The topics of concern covered substandard housing, slum landlords, outrageous rents, infrequent garbage collection, inadequate garbage receptacles, exploitive grocery prices, non-existent public transportation, inadequate banking services, fear of the implications of the English Only Proposal, ineffective government programs, the need for a 24 hour health clinic, and the need for recreational programs for their youth. Although I was extremely disappointed that the only commissioners to attend were Pam Mc'Kie and Barbara Berry, I'm happy to say that all the county officials were responsive, courteous, patient and informative. They addressed the plans for roads, the concerns regarding health care, questions of long term planning, and what home and business loans are available and how to apply. The commissioners were particularly concerned with the problems of high rent and unsanitary and inadequate housing as well as illegal housing and promised to give all of it their immediate attention. They encouraged people to speak as long as they needed to and they gave the impression that they cared. And I believe they do. It was a productive meeting. Before the meeting ended the commissioners described committees that were forming to address specific problems of health and housing. These committees are to report their findings directly to the commissioners. My question is, where was the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board in any of this? The problems certainly aren't new. They are old, they are conspicuous, they are offensive and often evil. Though some of these problems are beyond our scope, most are within our purview. Why haven't the people come to this Board with these problems? Why do I have the impression that many in the Hispanic Community itself are deliberately bi-passing this Board? After the meeting I spoke with some of the individuals who had voiced their opinions and who had received applause from the audience. As we know, Spanish speaking people have an excellent word of mouth communication system, so it didn't come as a surprise to hear that our reputation as a Board has preceded us. Page 2 One person said that we have a reputation of being "hot heads". She believes, from attending some of our meetings in the past, that this Board spends its time fighting each other, debating and arguing issues but actually accomplishing very little. Someone else voiced the opinion that we have an "elitist" attitude. That we sit comfortably in Naples debating issues but are actually out of touch with the needs of the majority of people. Another thought we were just another government agency, a sort of "Think Tank", long on talk, short on action. Most weren't aware that we even exist. Fortunately, this Town Hall Meeting has given us the opportunity to change these perceptions. I hope that part of our discussion tonight will explore how to make our Board more visible and more accessible. A few suggestions to accomplish this was using the Guadalupe Social Services, Immokalee Chamber of Commerce, sending fliers, and contacting the heads of the churches. A half century ago Edward R. Morrow made a famous documentary entitled Harvest of Shame. Perhaps some of you remember it. It was seen by nearly every American school child in the decades of the 40's, SO's and 60's. It exposed the deplorable working and living conditions of migrant farm workers throughout the United States. What many don't know is that it was filmed in Immokalee. Fifty years later most of these problems still exist in Immokalee. I believe that there are now enough people in Collier County who have the desire, the moral conviction and the political sophistication to finally change this. Many do not want their wealth built on the backs of the migrant farm worker or the poor. They want to see an end to the grinding poverty of a significant percentage of our population and they have the political power now to do it. The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board can be in the forefront of this effort, representing the interests of the Hispanic Community, as we were created to do. But we're not going to do it meeting once a month in Naples. The immediate issues have already been presented and are now on the table. The people are getting organized. Their leaders are intelligent and articulate. The impression I had was that loud talk and empty gestures is not how they plan to get things done. Perhaps, even more important to their success is that they're planning to use the system to see their needs accomplished. They're convinced that it's important to make the system work for them in order to bring about significant changes. And we can do the same by understanding how the system works and applying it to our objectives. We, as a Board, hold an important place in this system. We have the opportunity to take a leadershjl~le in this grass roots effort because unlike other organizations who have to wait t 'turn to be heard, we have been directed to bring important issues before our commissioners on a regular basis. Page 3 It's also important to understand that it's not just Immokalee that would benefit from our efforts. By helping to resolve the problems in Immokalee we help resolve problems for Hispanics all over the county. We can, of course, continue to determine our own method of identifying, evaluating, and presenting the problems of the Hispanic Community. But in decidiug whether or not to involve ourselves in Immokalee's concerns we have to keep in mind that familiar American saying, "Lead, follow or get out of the way". They are not going to wait for us. What I would like you to consider is, how to fulfill our duty to the community if the majority of people we represent have little or no knowledge or access to us. As the center of Hispanic culture it's important that the people of Immokalee have the opportunity to participate. In fact, it's more than important, it's essential if we're going to remain credible in the eyes of the community and survive as a Board. An individual I know responded to the idea of holding our meetings iu Immokalee by saying, "What prevents them from coming here to Naples once a month? It's only once a month and after all this meeting is for them." Well, let's see. What might be preventing them from filling those chairs in front of us as they did for the Town Hall Meeting. Here are just a few things to consider. 1. Most of them work extremely long days starting from 4 a.m. when they wake up until they arrive home after dark. 2. Child care responsibilities after work. 3. Transportation. Which we take for granted here in Naples, but is a big problem for the majority living in Immokalee. 4. Meeting in an unfamiliar and formal environment with an organization they haven't learned to trust. Beside our duty to the Hispanic people and the commissioners we should give equal thought to how this Board can be more productive under the limitations of the Sunshine Law and in the two hours a month we meet. To be a productive Board we have to have a thorough understanding of our limitations as well as our powers. When I first applied to be on the Board I was under the impression that this would give me the opportunity to express some deeply felt political views regarding the poverty and exploitation of a people that I have a great concern for. It didn't take long for me to realize that we have no political power. We have been appointed only as advisors. We serve at the pleasure of the commissioners. Our Board can be dissolved as quickly as it was created. We do, however, have great moral power. And we have the envied and sought after power of influence. Page 4 Our most affective but under utilized tool is the imperative we've been given to submit timely and frequent reports on important issues to our political leaders. We have their ear. We have the ability to bring to them awareness of the moral correctness of our community's needs on a regular basis. We have the power to raise consciousness. We have credibility because we are not political. And although there are times when we will not be able to persuade with reason, as we are so painfully aware from our experiences concerning Dr. Cordova and the issue of the School Superintendent, we also have the power to persuade with shame, as is evident by the Commissioners passage of the Hispanic Advisory Boards Diversity Statement this week. The message I have received is that to maintain our credibility with Hispanics and non-Hispanics alike we must improve our knowledge of the system and what it takes to make it work for us. When things don't go our way nothing is accomplished with threats, intimidation or the use of inflammatory words that get individuals focused so much on our anger that they no longer hear our message. To insure our credibility to all we serve, we must present our position in a manner that promotes respect for them as well as ourselves. We can be passionate yet dignified. Without an attitude that reflects our moral sensibility, we only en flame situations, create anger and resistance and most damaging of all, we then give those in power justification to ignore the issues. We cannot afford to be ignorant or unsophisticated or overstep our authority as a Board. Truth, like a bell, has a ring that we all recognize. Individuals may not agree with the message but the purity of its moral tone cannot be denied. We represent a long suffering, patient people whose goals are to be treated with dignity and for a fair playing field to improve their lives. We represent a morally correct cause. Repeated long enough, our message will encourage communication, cooperation and generate awareness that will result in positive action on the important issues we present. Latino's have spoken. Lucas Benitez, the leader of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers ended his presentation to the commissioners in eloquent Spanish by saying, "We are asking for you to dig down and get at the root of the problems and not just the branches". The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board can respond to this urgent plea by being the strong, persistent and dignified voice the people need to represent them. Therefore I move that we adopt the following resolution: ~? /1 yl({,'vL I:'}, e/ ,,/ '~(c'')~ '/((c/j(~l s/;; -f /<7; RESOLUTION COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD Whereas, the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board has been formed to assist and advise the the Collier County Commissioners in matters effecting the interests of the Hispanic community of Collier County; and Whereas, the Collier County Commissioners have embarked upon a community wide town hall meeting schedule to increase their awareness of and response to the interests of individual citizen groups within the County; and Whereas; the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board should provide positive input and guidance to the Commissioners on a continuing basis during and after the completion of this effort; Therefore, be it resolved that the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board of Collier County will accomplish the following goals and establish the following policies during the next twelve months of the Board's operations. 1. The adoption by August 26,1999 of specific Goals and Objectives for the HAAB to be accomplished by specific committees during the next twelve months. This commitment shall be known as the One Year Action Plan. 2. All future monthly meetings shall be held in Immokalee with an additional monthly meeting to be held elsewhere as the need arises. 3. The immediate adoption of rules of conduct which encourage courtesy, professionalism, cooperation and communications between the HAAB , the Commissioners and all other levels of County Government. 4. The receipt of a report by the County Liaison interpreting the Powers, Limitations and Responsibilities of the HAAB related to our relationship with the County Commissioners as defined in the Collier County Code. 5. The preparation and presentation of a monthly report by the HAAB to the County Commissioners addressing the current status of and progress on issues of importance to the Hispanic Community of Collier County. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS DAY OF _,1999 Chair, Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Collier County ,OM JAY AND SANDRA PHONE NU. : 912 443 0239 , JUN. 01 1999 12:28PM Pi r " , ;, \ I j I .,' -- 180 CENTRAL AVENUE NAPLES. FLORIDA 34102 TEL (I) 941/261-0275 FAX (1) 941/263.6914 TO SUE FILSON amall: jaysandra@worldnel.att.nel ~~'VP.tV AT COLLIER COUNTY JUI') 0 1 1999 FROM ANDREW J. FOX JR. ..... It ....., C_i. ~'! SUBJECT COUN1Y ADVISORY BOARD June 1, 1999 This is a follow-up to our phone conversation earlier this morning. I would like to apply for a position on the County Advisory Board dealing with minority groUpS, Latin Americans etc. Address, phone, fax and email in the upper right hand comer. My date of birth is 916130. My Social Security # 081-24-65l5A I purchased my Naples home in April 1999 and became a year round resident Oil Sept. 1,1999. I am retired, married, a registered voter, and would like to become active in local civic activities. I was born in Brooklyn, N. Y., brought up on Long Island, attended the University of Notre Dame and graduated from Harvard University in 1952. Forty of my forty five working years were spent abroad. I retired lan L J 998 A list of my more recent civic activities is as follows: Member Fulbright Commission, Dublin, 1989-96 Eisenhower Fellowship Fund, 1987-95 Director US Chamber of Commerce Ireland, 1980-96, President 1984-86 Member Irish Corrugated Packaging Assoc. 1982-95, President 1986-88, 1993. Director Irish Management Institute, Dublin 1985-95 Director Scholarship Exchange Board 1985-89 Fund Raising Committee, British American Hospital, Madrid Member General Council FEFCO, Paris 1993-96 Listed Marquis Publications Who's Who in the World 1991-98 My worlcing experience includes; Director International Development Europe, Africa, Middle East, India Union Camp Corp. Founder and Managing Director Union Camp's investments abroad in 1 of 3 May 27, 1999 Governor Jeb Bush STATE OF FLORIDA Executive Office of the Governor The Capitol Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0001 Dear Governor Jeb Bush My name is I am a member of a group of concerned parents in Collier County. We are involved in issues that could affect our children's future and our community as well. We want to inform you about the outrageous conduct of the school board members and Superintendent Dr. Dan White. This , letter is a follow up of previous information that we sent to you on August 29, 1998, with Mr. Frank T. Brogan when he came to The Vineyards Farms in Naples. Also of recent information that you received in your hands during a Town Hall Meeting on May 7, 1999 in Orlando. All of this information provided to you is to make you aware of the mess created by Dr. Dan White and his school board member Nelson Faerber, Barbara Church, Don York, and the worst of them Ann Goodnight. There is clear evidence of discrimination, and abuse of power conducted by them. Since former Superintendent Dr. Robert Munz stepped down on June 30, 1998, Dan White initiated a very controversial reorganization that put Dr. Leo Cardona out of his old job because he was not on the list of administrators that played by Dan White's rules. Reorganization those school board members unanimously accepted July 23, 1998, during a school board meeting. On September 17, 1998, during a Hispanic Affair Advisory Board meeting, we questioned Dr. White about the removal of Dr. Cardona from his office in Immokalee. He told us, ~It was a decision I made solely on who would be the best person for the position." One of his reasons being to save money. How, if the next day of the meeting, August 18, 1998, we read in the Naples Daily News that he raised his and his corrupted accomplices' salary. Another reason was ability, talents, and qualifications. Dr. White is wrong for trying to convince us that Dr. Cardona did not qualify for the assistant superintendent position. White lies to us over and over. We believe that Cardona was discriminated just because of his race 2 of 3 and because he was tough on teachers or whoever was not doing a good job. But first of all, because Dr. Cardona did not play the game by White's rules. All this is, is a plan full of conspiracy. Therefore, Ann Goodnight, Dan White, and the Teachers Union furiously attacked him. It is urgent that you, Governor Jeb Bush, appoint an outsider, and open an investigation to review the circumstances for which Dr. Leo Cardona was removed from his office in Immokalee. It is also important to monitor the abuse of authority by the school board members along with Dr. Dan White, and his team. You need to control them in the way they spend the tax payer's money. In addition to the issue of conflict of interest by the school board member Ann Goodnight who is also working for the David Lawrence Center. She approved to give money to the David Lawrence Center from the school budget. She used her influence and authority as a school board member to do this. Even more, she broke the law for practice'nepotism and uses her influence to give school positions to members of her family. On November 5, 1998, the parents of Immokalee were insulted by her stereotypical racial prejudice against most of the Hispanic farm working parents of Immokalee (see attached letter). It is critical that you get involved and open an investigation on the way they misused the taxpayers money, $35,000, to pay the searching firm to find a superintendent. Which was a fraud because they all knew that the plan was and is to appoint White. They could have used the money in school material, field trips, or another tutor. It is obvious that they don't care and that the children are not their first priority. Please it is urgent that you get involved to improve teachers' poor performance. For instance, we have teachers teaching behind the desk, covering up children's misconduct just because they are of the same race. Teachers letting the students work by themselves most of the time without instructional assistance while she/he is eating in the classroom, or talking on the phone, or talking with her/his fellow workers. Even more some parents caught them watching soap operas. All these violations happened during instructional time. It is urgent to control the use of too much dittos and easy worksheets that are not required by the educational curriculum; instead the use of verbal and visual instructions should be enforced. Teachers don't use the chalkboards much. They need to control the use of video entertainment for the students during instructional time. Also, we have teachers insulting Hispanic students just because they cannot learn to read. According to teachers and administrators, 3 of 3 children are not learning because their parents are farm workers and low income families. We do not want more poor excuses. The solution is that we need better teachers and new administrators. The ones that we have now have been working here so long that they think they own the schools. On top of all this mess, they are facing lawsuits for breaking the Sunshine Law. They should be removed from their jobs. The key to solving the problem is that you need to implement a law that reforms the old curriculum in our Collier County schools, and to allow the replacement of bad teachers and administrators. In addition, Mrs. Goodnight should also be removed from her school board seat. Finally, it is so disgraceful to see the list of the Character Traits such as honest, kindness, truthfulness, and responsibility, because we frankly believe none of these traits . apply to Dr. White, his team or the school board members. They have been deliberately manipulating the school system and ignoring our input. We believe that as taxpayers and registered voters, we have the right to select our leaders. Therefore, we want to recognize Dr. Leo Cardona as an outstanding administrator. In addition, he should be placed back in his rightful position in Immokalee. Please, we want to see justice served. It is urgent to send auditor, at least every semester to audit administrators, teachers, and coordinators of federal programs and to audit students' progress as well. If any teacher does not improve students' grades, she/he should be out of the school system. NO MORE EXCUSES. NO MORE LIES. You, Governor Jeb Bush, need to get immediately involved. Please, put children first. We would like to invite you to come to Immokalee and have a Town Hall Meeting with us. We hope to hear from you soon. Sincerely Cc. Porter Goss Naples Daily News Reporter, Denise Zoldan Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Members Dr. Leo Cardona HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES OF MEETING of June 24, 1999 at the Golden Gate Community Center, Naples, Florida PRESENT: ABSENT: Frank Rodriguez, Chairman, HAAB David Correa, HAAB Member Frank Loney, HAAB Member Pete Cade, HAAB Member Faye Reddick, HAAB Member Leo Cardona, HAAB Member Ramiro Maftalich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison Member Dora Vidaurri, HAAB Member Maria Grimaldo, HAAB Member Also Present: Chris Bent, Applicant Jay Fox, Applicant Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones Newspaper The June 24, 1999 regular meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board of Collier County (HAAB) commenced at approximately 7:17 P.M. A quorum of six (6) members was present. The HAAB reviewed and considered the approval of the April 29, 1999 meeting minutes. Mr. Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones News, commented that the attached page for the April 29, 1999 minutes referencing his prior comments was fine. A motion to approve the minutes was made by Faye Reddick and seconded by Pete Cade. There was a unanimous vote to approve. The Board reviewed and considered the approval of the May 27, 1999 meeting minutes. Frank Loney made a motion to approve which was seconded by David Correa. There was a unanimous vote for approval. A discussion next ensued regarding whether Mr. Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones News and Hispanic Rights Advocate, should have a separate place on the agenda regarding a report that Mr. Valdes wished to present to the Board regarding the Collier County Sheriffs office. Chairman Frank Rodriguez commented that he thought that the appropriate place for Mr. Valdes to comment was under the Public Comments section of the Agenda without separate reference to the topic in the Agenda. Staff Liaison Ramiro Maiialich reviewed the minutes of the last meeting with the Board regarding this topic and advised that the Chairman controls the agenda but that there can be a specific vote by the HAAB regarding the subject. Mr. Valdes commented that he wished to be specifically mentioned on the agenda so that the Sheriff s Office would find a need to be present and respond at the meeting. For the record, Mr. Valdes protested that the Chairman was trying to preclude him from speaking due to his allegations that the Chairman is involved in a Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) investigation and is defending a civil rights violator (the Sheriff). Mr. Valdes stated that he specifically wished to be placed on the next agenda with specific reference to his topic. A motion was made by Frank Loney to place the matter on the next agenda with reference to the specific topic. The motion was seconded by Pete Cade. The motion passed by a 5-1 vote (Frank Rodriguez voting against). Frank Rodriguez requested that the record reflect that he was voting against the motion because he did not believe it was appropriate for him to comment on a future agenda when his term on the Board was ending as of this meeting. Chairman Rodriguez welcomed Leo Cardona as a member. He advised Mr. Cardona that there are limits on the conduct of the HAAB members imposed by Ordinance and the Sunshine Law. He stated that the HAAB is a link to the community for Hispanics. He mentioned that the HAAB is constrained to act within the framework of the enabling ordinance. He mentioned, as an example, a recent Resolution on diversity which, perhaps, could have been stronger but that it reflected the efforts of Mr. Rodriguez and the HAAB to effectuate positive change for the Hispanic community. Frank Rodriguez further mentioned that the Minority Task Force is working diligently within the Sheriffs office and the FDLE framework. Frank Rodriguez mentioned that there is a growing Hispanic population and much to be done in Collier County. He stressed the need for the commitment of all of the HAAB members to the Hispanic community. Frank stated that he would stay involved with the Hispanic community and the HAAB after the end of his term. Frank stated that he was confident that Leo Cardona would be an asset to the Board. Frank Rodriguez stated that the Resolution declaring English as the official language of Collier County government continues to be a problem. He stated that it would be up to future HAAB members to follow up on this subject. He reminded the members that the HAAB had sent a letter of opposition to this Resolution to the Board of County Commissioners. He mentioned that Commissioner Norris had responded to Frank regarding the HAAB letter. A copy of Commissioner Norris' letter is attached to these minutes. Frank stated the opinion that Commissioner Norris should have written to the HAAB and not to Frank regarding this subject. Frank Loney inquired whether any letter had ever been sent to the Board of County Commissioners as a result of the joint meeting of the HAAB and Black Affairs Advisory Board (BAAB) of April 29, 1999, regarding the problems affecting minorities and the School Board. Frank Rodriguez commented that the BAAB had never sent the draft letter; however, Frank 2 reminded the members that the Board of County Commissioners had approved a Resolution promoting diversity. At this point, Ramiro Mafialich reminded the members that if they wanted the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) to provide a formal response (as a Board), then they may wish to request to be placed on the agenda for the BCC to obtain a formal vote of the BCC in regard to any HAAB position or request. Frank Rodriguez finished his comments regarding the BCC Resolution on diversity by stating that although it was passed with some word changes, there is now an important policy regarding diversity in place with the Board of County Commissioners. Frank said that this Resolution and its affects should be followed up with Collier County government. Faye Reddick commented that one-half of the members on the HAAB are new but they all have special talents which are needed by the Hispanic community. She said that recent events (such as the English as the official language Resolution) pose unique HAAB opportunities. She encouraged members of the HAAB with commitment and talents to apply for the position of chairman. Faye discussed the role of the chairman and the temperament which is needed for a successful chairman. She suggested that the election of a new chairman occur when all new members are present at the August meeting. She made a motion to this effect. The motion was seconded by Pete Cade. David Correa commented that the elections were supposed to have occurred in January. He discussed the history of postponements of this subject and he stated that the new members are not as familiar with HAAB problems. He explained his reasons for making strong statements regarding School Board Superintendent Dr. White and Board of County Commissioners member James Carter. He stressed that minorities have to stand up for their rights in Collier County. Pete Cade inteIjected that Dora Vidaurri and Maria Grimaldo should be present to participate in the vote. Frank Rodriguez also agreed that the full membership should be present to vote. David Correa commented that he was disappointed with the motion. He stressed this is not a personal issue but that there was talent presently on the Board from which to make the Chairmanship selection. Frank Loney commented that he would vote against the motion. He said that there were too many mind games, postponements and procrastination. He stressed the need for action and not just talk. The motion failed by a 2-4 margin with Pete Cade and Faye Reddick voting in favor of the motion. David Correa nominated himself for the position of Chairman. Leo Cardona provided a second. The vote was 4-2 (Faye Reddick and Frank Rodriguez opposed) and the motion failed since an affirmative vote of 5 is necessary, pursuant to the Ordinance, for official action to be taken. For the record, Frank Rodriguez again stated that it was his philosophical position that since his term was ending with this meeting that he should not vote in favor of matters which would bind future Boards. 3 The HAAB next reviewed the application of member Andrew J. Fox. Mr. Fox described that he had moved to Naples in September of last year and that he speaks Spanish. He explained his international background and that he has lived extensively in Hispanic cultures throughout the world. He said he wanted to give back to the Hispanic culture. He is in the process of familiarizing himself with the City of Immokalee but he has previously farmed in Florida. It is his observation that Hispanics in Florida need representation by persons interested in their plight. He commented how people of his ancestry (Irish) also previously were discriminated against and that the Irish, like Hispanics, also built up the nation. He hopes that there will be more positive action on behalf of Hispanics resulting from HAAB dialogue. The Board discussed with Mr. Fox the history of the HAAB and its interaction with the BCC. Victor Valdes stated that, as a founder of the HAAB, he believed that it was important to feel the heart and problems of the Hispanic population. He stated that Ms. Reddick had shown such qualities. Such qualities do not necessarily require the ability to speak Spanish. He said that many problems remain for Hispanics in Collier County. David Correa made a motion to recommend Mr. Fox for appointment to the HAAB and the motion was seconded by Frank Loney. The vote was unanimous in favor of the motion. Faye Reddick presented a prepared a statement to the HAAB, a copy of which is attached. In her statement, Ms. Reddick commented that the Board of County Commissioners had recently hosted a town hall meeting in Immokalee. Approximately 150 people had attended. A number of social economic and political problems in the Hispanic community were mentioned at the meeting. While only some County officials, including Commissioners, were present, they seemed to be receptive to the concerns and promised action and gave the impression of caring. She challenged the HAAB to get involved in these types of issues on behalf of Hispanics. She said that many people in the Hispanic community were bypassing the HAAB because it had developed a reputation of being an elitist think tank or a bunch of hotheads. In addition, many Hispanics were not even aware of the existence of the HAAB. She stated that it was necessary to make the HAAB more visible to the Hispanic community to be successful. She suggested the use of committee resources to improve Hispanic conditions. She recalled the "Harvest of Shame" film which was made in Immokalee. She thought that the HAAB could be in the forefront of progressive reform efforts but that those results could not be achieved solely through the monthly meetings in Naples. Faye mentioned that there are a number of activists in the Hispanic community who want to use the system to bring about significant positive change. She thought that the HAAB should be a co-leader in this grassroots effort. She thought it was necessary to inform the Board of County Commissioners on a regular basis and that the HAAB should assist Hispanics throughout the County. She thought that HAAB gatherings in Immokalee were critical to the success of these types of efforts. 4 Faye reminded the members that they have the power to influence government leaders and that the best tool to do so would be timely and regular reports to the BCC so as to raise the consciousness of the BCC toward the Hispanic community. The HAAB can persuade with shame when reason does not work. She reminded the HAAB members that they represent dignified and long suffering people of the Hispanic community. At this point, Faye Reddick moved to adopt a Resolution regarding the goals and policies of the HAAB (copy attached). The Resolution would state specific goals and objectives for 1 year; would provide for meetings in Immokalee; rules of conduct; report from the Liaison as to the powers of the HAAB; and monthly reports of the HAAB to the BCC regarding issues of the Hispanic community. Frank Loney seconded the motion of Faye Reddick and stated that there had been a lack of communication by the HAAB with the BCC. He commented that the BCC were a bunch of hypocrites who only approach Hispanics when they need them. He recounted the English as the official language Resolution, the Dr. Cardona incident, and others which are just the start of Hispanics problems. He mentioned that the BCC often ask the HAAB for advice but don't include them in many ofthe decisions. David Correa stated that Faye Reddick's prepared statement should be attached to the minutes as an exhibit. He said he was proud to have Faye on the Board and was impressed with her intellect and grasp of Hispanic issues. A discussion ensued regarding the Resolution proposed by Faye Reddick. Frank Rodriguez suggested that points 2-5 of the Resolution should be subparts of a single point number I. He also suggested stating that there ~ be meetings in Immokalee. Faye Reddick amended her motion to include Frank Rodriguez' comments. David Correa seconded the amended motion. A unanimous vote was had in favor of the motion. The meeting of the Hispanic Board adjourned at approximately 9:15 P.M. Prepared by: Ramiro Mafialich, Board Liaison Approved by the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board on the 22nd day ofJuly, 1999. Frank Loney, Vice Chairlnan Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board 5 John C. Nonis District 1 James D. Carter, Ph.D. District 2 Timothy J. Constantine District 3 Pamela S. Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Berry District 5 gjoard ol-(i;~Mc -floU/n/if {fio~ni:;,JWne%J 3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples, Florida 34112-4977 (941) 774.8097. Fax (941) 774.3602 May 4, 1999 Mr. Frank Rodriguez, Chairman Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Post Office Box 990244 Naples, Florida 34101 ~".~ F t!-q., Ie Dear Mr. R~5uez: Thank you very much for your letter of April 26, 1999, in reference to Resolution No. 99-205 regarding English as the Official language of Collier County Government I appreciate you taking the time to write and share your views with me. While I do not agree with your views, I will certainly take your comments under consideration should this be brought before the Board of County Commissioners in the future. Once again, Mr. Rodriguez, thank you for sharing your views with me and if! may be of assistance to you in the future, please contact my office. Very truly yours, Commissioner, District I JCN:tlm ~!-'i..::~~-,~:,~-.:p-~~ :~.~-...._-_. r~- i ! , I n i'_l.~ i'J ,,-'",,,- i F}C\;:i .,..' " J. i r,t).l_~ ~ ~ .-.....:.; , . . '"'-~'~"_.""--'-"-"""-' 4. Election of Chairman, July 1999 Over half our members are new to the Board this year. For all practical purposes, three of you are here tonight for the first time. Each of you posses unique and special talents that are much needed by this Board. The Hispanic community and the HAAB are at a cross-roads. Through a series of events this past year that culminated in the English Only Ordinance we have the attention of the community and particularly our commisioners as we have seldom had before. It behooves us to take advantage of the momentum. I cannot stress enough how critical the role of Chairman is to the success or failure of the future of this Board. At least half the people on this Board have the necessary skills and character to be Chairman. I hope as you consider whether or not this position is right for you, that you will lay aside any reservation you may have regarding the length of time you've been a member, whether or not you're too old or too young, or your lack of involvement with recent issues. I do not believe any of these things are relevant. Committment, common sense, temperament and judgement are what is critical to fill this position; length of service on this Board is not. Under the time constraints of meeting once a month for only two hours, as well as the constraints imposed by the Sunshine Law, for us to accomplish anything requires a structured, goal oriented, and above all a courteous working environment. Our new Chairman has a solemn obligation to invoke his authority to control any behavior that is counter productive to the objectives of the meeting. In the interest of all he must be willing to limit individual discussion, whether from the Board or the audience, and insist on absolute courtesy by all. I hope, too, as we vote we will consider the number of potential issues facing us this year. Our Chairman needs to posse~s more than enthusiasm and committment, he needs to have the personality and temperament to bring concensus. In other words, please, do not hesitate to stand up and bc counted. The year ahead can be filled with accomplishments, but as they say, "a team of wide receivors with no quarterback is not going to make touchdowns". I do not believe we should elect a chairman until the Board can sit with all new members present. This will allow us to select our Chairman from the full compliment of the Board. Therefore,l make a motion that we post-pone the election of a new Chairman until the August meeting and that an interim Chairman be appointed if the present Chairman is not agreeable to act in this capacity. This will allow all the new members to settle in and become more knowledgeable. New Business HAAB Meeting May 27, ]999 Town Hall Meeting The Collier Co. Commissioners have decided to host a series of Town Hall Meetings throughout the county this year. The fact that they scheduled the first one in Immokalee is significant. There were approximately 150 people attending. For three hours I listened as gracious, eloquent people gave their testimony in Spanish and English regarding the problems in the Hispanic community. The topics of concern covered substandard housing, slum landlords, outrageous rents, infrequent garbage collection, inadequate garbage receptacles, exploitive grocery prices, non-existent public transportation, inadequate banking services, fear of the implications of the English Only Proposal, ineffective government programs, the need for a 24 hour health clinic, and the need for recreational programs for their youth. Although I was extremely disappointed that the only commissioners to attend were Pam Mc'Kie and Barbara Berry, I'm happy to say that all the county officials were responsive, courteous, patient and informative. They addressed the plans for roads, the concerns regarding health care, questions of long term planning, and what home and business loans are availahle and how to apply. The commissioners were particularly concerned with the problems of high rent and unsanitary and inadequate housing as well as illegal housing and promised to give all of it their immediate attention. They encouraged people to speak as long as they needed to and they gave the impression that they cared. And I believe they do. It was a productive meeting. Before the meeting ended the commissioners described committees that were forming to address specific problems of health and housing. These committees are to report their findings directly to the commissioners. My question is, where was the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board in any of this? The problems certainly aren't new. They are old, they are conspicuous, they are offensive and often evil. Though some of these problems are beyond our scope, most are within our purview. Why haven't the people come to this Board with these problems? Why do I have the impression that many in the Hispanic Community itself are deliberately bi-passing this Board? After the meeting I spoke with some of the individuals who had voiced their opinions and who had received applause from the audience. As we know, Spanish speaking people have an excellent word of mouth communication system, so it didn't come as a surprise to hear that our reputation as a Board has preceded us. Page 2 One person said that we have a reputation of being "hot heads". She believes, from attending some of our meetings in the past, that this Board spends its time fighting each other, debating and arguing issues but actually accomplishing very little. Someone else voiced the opinion that we have an "elitist" attitude. That we sit comfortably in Naples debating issues but are actually out of touch with the needs of the majority of people. Another thought we were just another government agency, a sort of "Think Tank", long on talk, short on action. Most weren't aware that we even exist. Fortunately, this Town Hall Meeting has given us the opportunity to change these perceptions. I hope that part of our discussion tonight will explore how to make our Board more visible and more accessible. A few suggestions to accomplish this was using the Guadalupe Social Services, Immokalee Chamber of Commerce, sending fliers, and contacting the heads of the churches. A half century ago Edward R. Morrow made a famous documentary entitled Harvest of Shame. Perhaps some of you remember it. It was seen by nearly every American school child in the decades of the 40's, 50's and 60's. It exposed the deplorable working and living couditions of migrant farm workers throughout the United States. What many don't know is that it was filmed in Immokalee. Fifty years later most of these problems still exist in Immokalee. I believe that there are now enough people in Collier County who have the desire, the moral conviction and the political sophistication to finally change this. Many do not want their wealth built on the backs of the migrant farm worker or the poor. They want to see an end to the grinding poverty of a significant percentage of our population and they have the political power now to do it. The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board can be in the forefront of this effort, representing the interests of the Hispanic Community, as we were created to do. But we're not going to do it meeting once a month in Naples. The immediate issues have already been presented and are now on the table. The people are getting organized. Their leaders are intelligent and articulate. The impression I had was that loud talk and empty gestures is not how they plan to get things done. Perhaps, even more important to their success is that they're planning to use the system to see their needs accomplished. They're convinced that it's important to make the system work for them in order to bring about significant changes. And we can do the same by understanding how the system works and applying it to our objectives. We, as a Board, hold an important place in this system. We have the opportunity to take a leadersh~e in this grass roots effort because unlike other organizations who have to wait t turn to be heard, we have been directed to bring important issues before our commissioners on a regular basis. Page 3 It's also important to understand that it's not just Immokalee that would benefit from our efforts. By helping to resolve the problems in Immokalee we help resolve problems for Hispanics all over the county. We can, of course, continue to determine our own method of identifying, evaluating, and presenting the problems of the Hispanic Community. But in deciding whether or not to involve ourselves in Immokalee's concerns we have to keep in mind that familiar American saying, "Lead, follow or get out ofthe way". They are not going to wait for us. What I would like you to consider is, how to fulfill our duty to the community ifthe majority of people we represent have little or no knowledge or access to us. As the ceuter of Hispanic culture it's important that the people of Immokalee have the opportunity to participate. In fact, it's more than important, it's essential if we're going to remain credible in the eyes of the community and survive as a Board. An individual I know responded to the idea of holding our meetings iu Immokalee by saying, "What prevents them from coming here to Naples once a month? It's only once a month and after all this meeting is for them." Well, let's see. What might be preventing them from filling those chairs in front of us as they did for the Town Hall Meeting. Here are just a few things to consider. 1. Most of them work extremely long days starting from 4 a.m. when they wake up until they arrive home after dark. 2. Child care responsibilities after work. 3. Transportation. Which we take for granted here in Naples, but is a big problem for the majority living in Immokalee. 4. Meeting in an unfamiliar and formal environment with an organization they haven't learned to trust. Beside our duty to the Hispanic people and the commissioners we should give equal thought to how this Board can be more productive under the limitations of the Sunshine Law and in the two hours a month we meet. To be a productive Board we have to have a thorough understanding of our limitations as well as our powers. When I first applied to be on the Board I was under the impression that this would give me the opportunity to express some deeply felt political views regarding the poverty and exploitation of a people that I have a great concern for. It didn't take long for me to realize that we have no political power. We have been appointed only as advisors. We serve at the pleasure of the commissioners. Our Board can be dissolved as quickly as it was created. We do, however, have great moral power. And we have the envied and sought after power of influence. Page 4 Our most affective but under utilized tool is the imperative we've been given to submit timely and frequent reports on important issues to our political leaders. We have their ear. We have the ability to bring to them awareness ofthe moral correctness of our community's needs on a regular basis. We have the power to raise consciousness. We have credibility because we are not political. And although there are times when we will not be able to persuade with reason, as we are so painfully aware from our experiences concerning Dr. Cordova and the issue of the School Superintendent, we also have the power to persuade with shame, as is evident by the Commissioners passage of the Hispanic Advisory Boards Diversity Statement this week. The message I have received is that to maintain our credibility with Hispanics and non-Hispanics alike we must improve our knowledge of the system and what it takes to make it work for us. When things don't go our way nothing is accomplished with threats, intimidation or the use of inflammatory words that get individuals focused so much on our anger that they no longer hear our message. To insure our credibility to all we serve, we must present our position in a manner that promotes respect for them as well as ourselves. We can be passionate yet dignified. Without an attitude that retlects our moral sensibility, we only entlame situations, create anger and resistance and most damaging of all, we then give those in power justification to ignore the issues. We cannot afford to be ignorant or unsophisticated or overstep our authority as a Board. Truth, like a bell, has a ring that we all recognize. Individuals may not agree with the message but the purity of its moral tone cannot be denied. We represent a loug suffering, patient people whose goals are to be treated with dignity and for a fair playing field to improve their lives. We represent a morally correct cause. Repeated long enough, our message will encourage communication, cooperation and generate awareness that will result in positive action on the important issues we present. Latino's have spoken. Lucas Benitez, the leader of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers ended his presentation to the commissioners in eloquent Spanish by saying, "We are asking for you to dig down and get at the root of the problems and not just the branches". The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board can respond to this urgent plea by being the strong, persistent and dignified voice the people need to represent them. Therefore I move that we adopt the following resolution: L' .J )1,~' I' / ,1.1, ( -y< -1/:;'/ RESOLUTION COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD Whereas, the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board has been formed to assist and advise the the Collier County Commissioners in matters effecting the interests of the Hispanic community of Collier County; and Whereas, the Collier County Commissioners have embarked upon a community wide town hall meeting schedule to increase their awareness of and response to the interests of individual citizen groups within the County; and Whereas; the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board should provide positive input and guidance to the Commissioners on a continuing basis during and after the completion of this effort; Therefore, be it resolved that the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board of Collier County will accomplish the following goals and establish the following policies during the next twelve months of the Board's operations. I. The adoption by August 26,1999 of specific Goals and Objectives for the HAAB to be accomplished by specific committees during the next twelve months. This commitment shall be known as the One Year Action Plan. 2. All future monthly meetings shall be held in Immokalee with an additional monthly meeting to be held elsewhere as the need arises. 3. The immediate adoption of rules of conduct which encourage courtesy, professionalism, cooperation and communications between the HAAB , the Commissioners and all other levels of County Government. 4. The receipt of a report by the County Liaison interpreting the Powers, Limitations and Responsibilities of the HAAB related to our relationship with the County Commissioners as defmed in the Collier County Code. 5. The preparation and presentation of a monthly report by the HAAB to the County Commissioners addressing the current status of and progress on issues of importance to the Hispanic Community of Collier County. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS DAY OF _,1999 Chair, Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Collier County John C. Noms District 1 James O. Carter. Ph.D. District 2 Timothy J. Constantine District 3 Pamela S. Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Berry District 5 gjoad oj-ff501/imt -6~11 -fb~ 3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples, Florida 34112-4977 (941) 774-8097 . Fax (941) 774.3602 May 4, 1999 Mr. Frank Rodriguez, Chairman Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Post Office Box 990244 Naples, Florida 34101 ~rl.~ Ft!-q",k Dear Mr. R~uez: Thank you very much for your letter of April 26, 1999, in reference to Resolution No. 99-205 regarding English as the Official language of Collier County Government I appreciate you taking the time to write and share your views with me. While I do not agree with your views, I will certainly take your comments under consideration should this be brought before the Board of County Commissioners in the future. Once again, Mr. Rodriguez, thank you for sharing your views with me and if! may be of assistance to you in the future, please contact my office. Very truly yours, John C. Norris Commissioner, District I JCN:tIm r?~~n[l\rr; -- , I\Lt,n",:.D r-~'.""_._',. --'1 r r i i MAY I 8 1999 ' : L_._ Ff\('1c I' l t',1I11_ i I ':'i' _,_""'....,.,..~..c_.."_.,._...._" COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD - ~. 3301 East Tamiami Trail Naples, Florida 34112 June 9, 1999 Collier County Board of County Commissioners Collier County Government Center 3301 East Tamiami Trail Administration Building, Third Floor Naples, Florida 34112 Re: The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board's Support for Diversity Initiative Resolution Dear Commissioners: This is to inform you that at the meeting of May 29,1999, the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) voted unanimously to support the approval of the "Diversity Initiative" concept as presented by one of our members (please refer to copy enclosed). It is the commitment of this Board to collaborate with others and the County Administrator in evaluating, planning and implementing an initiative to stimulate diversity throughout Collier County. The HAAB respectfully requests that the Board of County Commissioners approve said Resolution at the next available Board meeting. Respectfully submitted, Frank Rodriguez, Chairman Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board cc: Ramiro Maiialich, County Staff Liaison Member Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board OS/22/1992 19:01 941-417~1498 LAS NACIIJNES NEWS: PAGE 01 LAS NA(:IONES NEWS VOICE OF THE HISPANIC COMMUNITY LAS NACIONES IS THE HISPANIC NEWSPAPER SERVJN(; OUR HISPANIC COMMUNITY. Serving Soutb Florida Since 1984 Pagina U no.com fo ~ triA) I{-J, rr..&E fA? t_ i;;!j o v.-- TA 'f, I c, , ~l I Urc--1-v A v ,V,. ~ . VA !(Ie-~ . 1/1 ~ Uy..-' t~+c~ ~. /~. /,:>.'\3 "<';r ~~)--' V4'>....J J----./ \~ ik 0J~~e'f~) (~r s ~AA~ {L4f;.A8 4~ ;LE-~J JoI t~ t J;L. ~ () j 6~tt 6 oa~c~ '" ~_.J ~ '-- /-1 ;,;~ J ,..' -' , {'-to r-I'.o. 80lt 10503 - Naples, Florida 34101 - Pbonr (9!!iI) 417-5551 Voler'" Fax ~~ Linr: (941) 2~117. r-mail: PaElnaUno@aoLcom - http://www.Pal:inaUno.cDdl 05/22/1992 19:01 TO: FROM: COVER PAGE --- --- FAX: 7740225 LAS NACIONES NEWS: FAX: 941-417-1498 TEL: 941-417-5551 COMMENT: PLEASE CALL 05/22/1992 19:03 COVER PAGE TO: FAX: 7740225 FROM: LAS NACIONES NEWS: FAX: 941-417-1498 TEL: 941-417-5551 COMMENT: PLEASE CALL OS/22/1gg2 19:03 g41'417-14gS l.AS NAC IDNE:S NE:WS: PAGE: 01 Op~!!.Ldter to James Carter Collier COUl,1ty Commissioner. Dear Mr. Cartn' I <.Jay I want to express: (1)- My hurting pain fi)r the Holocaust where millions of human bean were killed by Nazis horde. (2)- My hurting p,lIn tor the genocide against millions by the Communism in the world including Cuba. (3)- My hurting pain for the genocide made by Milosevich against people in Kosovo, Yugoslavia with his cth11( cleaning. (4)- My hurting pain for the genocide made by Nazis against our students in Colorado. (5)- My concern "bout a racist resolution made by you and supported by commissioners John Norris, Barhara Berry, Tim Contantine and inspirited by the super racist Thomas Brachko from Califonlla. Please Mr Carter stop ethnic cleaning in Collier County. We can wMk together to make Collier County a better place to live. ~{h( 0(/;/1 (). Id~ Victor A. Valdes. Editor. \- 05/22/1992 19:03 941~417~14g8 L.AS NAe lDNES NEWS: PAGE 02 In Collier COUDty April 22, 1999 COMYLlANT ~lc.'.0t Victor A. Valdes. Publisher and Editor of Las Nadones News, came for mean of the present kiter to make a I, .nnal criminal complaint against the Collier County School Board's Members. And as ground i"f such complaint said: On Monday April 19, 1999 Collier County School Board call to an Emergency Meeting, ignoring the Hispanic And the Haitian Community. School Board f."kd to announce the meeting, according FL SI. NO 50.011 and 50.021. School Board's 111"l11bers intentionally hide the meeting from Hispanics and Haitians, with the purpose of appoiJl."J Dr Don White as Collier County School Superintendent, depriving Hispanics and II:ut.ans of the rights to express theirs concern and opinions. Hispanics and H"ilians were not aware of this meeting do to the total lack of announcements directed to ours communities. Note: Las Naci.lnl's Publish public announcement that result of Hispanic community interest, for free. tjj.. (J.J/!P Victor A. Valdt\s Also Grandfsth,'r of!l children attending Collier County SchooL DOS Ht.:J'ITER, SHERiff * Collier County Shrrirr's Offiu C\,"!l1it'f County GO'wccnmcm Co;nlCr' Blog J Di)\ E::l."l1 T.1ml:1ml Tr;ul .. Nllpl~s.. Flonda q 112 1941) 774-4""J.t PLEASE ALLOW' TO , WORKI~G DAYS FOR YOeR REPORT TO BE PROCESSED BRI:>;G THIS CARl> WITH YOe TO OBTAI~ A COPY QF THF. REPORT. CASE' l.I.S9<J()' '1'1 DEPcTY III .1:3PY_._ ,."ll._-.l..... I-~ -- '2~ John C. Norris District 1 James D. Carter. Ph.D. District 2 Timothy J. Constantine District 3 Pamela S. Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Berry District 5 :!l30<l1'd ol(o~ -fi~lUnty -fi~Mt6 3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples, Florida 34112-4977 (941) 774-8097 . Fax (941) 774-3602 0""'1:[.",'1....... . ~'. . ,.. ,"',.' . May 4, 1999 Mr. Frank Rodriguez, Chairman Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Post Office Box 990244 Naples, Florida 34101 ''''r~ F t!-q., Ie: Dcar Mr. R~5uez: Thank you very much for your letter of April 26, 1999, in reference to Resolution No. 99-205 regarding English as the Official language of Collicr County Government I appreciate you taking the time to write and share your vicws with me. While I do not agree with your views, I will certainly take your commcnts under consideration should this bc brought before the Board of County Commissioners in the future. Oncc again, Mr. Rodriguez, thank you for sharing your views with me and if! may be of assistance to you in the future, please contact my office. John C. Norris Commissioner, District I JCN:tlm HEGEIVED r,"",_._.m_._._,,/ L_~~Y I 8 1900 " "- . J FACIUT![;:; iviL;~'1T COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112-4902 Telephane: (941) 774-8400 FAX (941) 774-0225 Email: attorney@naples.net June 18, 1999 Heidi F. Ashton Ramiro Monolich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W. Pettit Marni M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary Mr. Leo R. Cardona 557 106TH Avenue North Naples, Florida 34108 Re June 24, 1999 Meeting to the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Dear Mr. Cardona: On June 22, 1999, the Board of County Commissioners will be considering the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board's recommendation of applicants for appointment to their Board. In anticipation of your appointment, I welcome you to the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB). The next HAAB meeting is scheduled for Thursday, June 24, 1999 HAAB. Enclosed is the agenda. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me or my Assistant, Kay, at 774-8400. Sincerely, o~ 1#k::7J2.k? Ramiro Manalich Chief Assistant County Attorney RM/kn enclosure cc: David C Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY - DAVID C. WEIGEL COlLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112.4902 Telephone: (941) 774-8400 FAX (941) 774-0225 Email: attarney@naples.net June 18, 1999 Heidi F, Ashton Romiro Manalich Thomas C. Palmer Michae! W. Pettil Marni M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary Mr. Andrews 1. Fox, Jr. 180 Central Avenue Naples, Florida 34102 Re: June 24, 1999 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Meeting Dear Mr. Fox Enclosed is the agenda for the June 24, 1999 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) meeting. The HAAB will be reviewing your application for appointment at this meeting for purpose of providing their recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners. You are invited to appear before the HAAB at this time to discuss your interest in becoming a member and to answer questions from the HA.AB in regard to same. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me or my Assistant, Kay Nell, at 774-8400. Sincerelv, ~ /.-2 r-/7 u~fl~~ Ramiro 1\!ai'ialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RM/kn enclosure cc David C Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112.4902 Telephone: (941) 774-8400 FAX (941) 774-0225 Email: attorney@naples.net June 18, 1999 Heidi F. Ashton Ramiro Manalich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W, Pettit Morni M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary Mr. Andrews 1. Fox, Jr. 180 Central Avenue Naples, Florida 34102 Re: June 24, 1999 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Meeting Dear Mr. Fox: Enclosed is the agenda for the June 24, 1999 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) meeting. The HAAB will be reviewing your application for appointment at this meeting for purpose of providing their recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners. You are invited to appear before the HAAB at this time to discuss your interest in becoming a member and to answer questions from the HAAB in regard to same. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me or my Assistant, Kay Nell, at 774-8400. Sincerely, C;Z, f/~Q? Ramiro Mai'ialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RM/kn enclosure cc: David C. Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY June 18, 1999 Heidi E Ashton Romiro Manalich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W. Pettit Marni M. Scuderi Mariorie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Flarida 34112-4902 Telephane: (941) 774-8400 FAX (941) 774.0225 Email: attarney@naples.net Board Members Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Re: June 24, 1999 Meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Dear Members: Please find enclosed the agenda for the June 24, 1999 HAAB meeting, In addition, I am enclosing a copy of a letter from an applicant seeking appointment to the HAAB as well as a letter that is scheduled by Ms. Grimaldo to be discussed If you are unable to attend this meeting, please contact me or my Assistant, Kay Nell, at 774- 8400. Sincerely, ~, /,C'y!~ /? ( ) ~__>rc-~ y /i.-~ Ramiro Maiialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RM/kn enclosures cc: David C Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112-4902 Telephone: (941) 774.8400 FAX (941) 774-0225 Email: attarney@naples.net June 18, 1999 Heidi F. Ashton Ramiro Manalich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W. Pettit Morni M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A Vasquez Robert N. Zachary Mr. Leo R. Cardona 557 106m Avenue North Naples, Florida 34108 Re: June 24, 1999 Meeting to the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board to Dear Mr. Cardona: On June 22, 1999, the Board of County Commissioners will be considering the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board's recommendation of applicants for appointment to their Board. In anticipation of your appointment, I welcome you to the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB). The next HAAB meeting is scheduled for Thursday, June 24, 1999 HAAB. Enclosed is the agenda. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me or my Assistant, Kay, at 774-8400. Sincerely, ~ 0, O~ !:;Y~ . . Ramiro Maiialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RMlkn enclosure cc: David C. Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORN EY June 18, 1999 Heidi F. Ashton Ramiro Manalich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W. Pettit Marni M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112.4902 Telephane: (941) 774.8400 FAX: (941) 774-0225 Email: aftarney@naples.net Board Members Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Re: June 24, 1999 Meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Dear Members: Please find enclosed the agenda for the June 24, 1999 HAAB meeting. In addition, I am enclosing a copy of a letter from an applicant seeking appointment to the HAAB as well as a letter that is scheduled by Ms Grimaldo to be discussed If you are unable to attend this meeting, please contact me or my Assistant, Kay Nell, at 774- 8400. Sincerely, c;:~ ff)Zc:;:J1Y Ramiro Mai'ialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RMlkn enclosures cc David C Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112.4902 Telephone: (941) 774-8400 FAX (941) 774-0225 Email: attorney@noples.net June 18, 1999 Heidi F. Ashton Ramiro Manalich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W, Pettit Marni M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A Vasquez Robert N. Zachary Mr. Andrews J. Fox, Jr. 180 Central Avenue Naples, Florida 34102 Re: June 24, 1999 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Meeting Dear Mr. Fox: Enclosed is the agenda for the June 24, 1999 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAB) meeting. The HAAB will be reviewing your application for appointment at this meeting for purpose of providing their recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners, You are invited to appear before the HAAB at this time to discuss your interest in becoming a member and to answer questions from the HAAB in regard to same. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me or my Assistant, Kay Nell, at 774-8400. SG7~ f/~.-:aQ; Ramiro Maiialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RM/kn enclosure cc David C Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY June 18, 1999 Heidi F. Ashton Ramiro Manolich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W. Pettit Marni M. Scuderi Marjorie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112.4902 Telephone: (941) 774-8400 FAX: (941) 774-0225 Email: attorney@naples.net Board Members Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Re: June 24, 1999 Meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Dear Members: Please find enclosed the agenda for the June 24, 1999 HAAB meeting. In addition, I am enclosing a copy of a letter from an applicant seeking appointment to the HAAB as well as a letter that is scheduled by Ms. Grimaldo to be discussed If you are unable to attend this meeting, please contact me or my Assistant, Kay Nell, at 774- 8400. Sincerely, ~, \J-;c~-~ /-71 :.-e2Y' . ,;-;-;~, " (;//~~ . Ramiro Mafialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RM/kn enclosures cc: David C Weigel, County Attorney COLLIER COUNTY DAVID C. WEIGEL COlLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY June 18, 1999 Heidi F. Ashton Ramiro Manalich Thomas C. Palmer Michael W. Pettit Marni M. Scuderi Mar[orie M. Student Melissa A. Vasquez Robert N. Zachary 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Flarida 34112-4902 Telephane: (941) 774-8400 FAX: (941) 774-0225 Email: attarney@naples.net Board Members Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Re: June 24, 1999 Meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Dear Members: Please find enclosed the agenda for the June 24, 1999 HAAB meeting. In addition, I am enclosing a copy of a letter from an applicant seeking appointment to the HAAB as well as a letter that is scheduled by Ms. Grimaldo to be discussed If you are unable to attend this meeting, please contact me or my Assistant, Kay Nell, at 774- 8400. Sincerely, ~, "-J/c/"'-.--~ c~~ /~ ("J ,/ ~-->~ Ramiro Mafialich Chief Assistant County Attorney RMlkn enclosures cc David C Weigel, County Attorney "cROM JAY AND SANDRA PHONE NO. ,: 912 443 0239 JUN. 01 1999 i2:28PM Pi i,'; i , .\ '\;'1 f"; ,.<...- 180 CENTRAL AVENUE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34102 TI::L (I) 941/2.61 -0275 FAX (1) 941/2.63-6914 TO SUE FILSON emaJl: jaysandra@worldnet.alt.net ~.:~V~;; AT COLLIER COUNTY JUt) 0 1 1998 FROM ANDREW J. FOX JR. ..... " ~ C..\-tl~.~ SUBJECT COUNTY ADVISORY BOARD June 1, 1999 This is a follow-up to our phone conversation earlier this morning. I would like to apply for a position on the County Advisory Board dealing with minority groups, Latin Americans etc. Address, phone, fax and emai1 in the upper right hand corner. My date of birth is 916/30. My Social Security # 081-24--6515A I purchased my Naples home in April 1999 and became a year rOWld resident on Sept. 1, 1999. I am retired. married, a registered voter, and would like to become active in local civic activities I was born in Brooklyn, N. Y., brought up on Long Island, attended the University of Notre Dame and graduated from Harvard University in 1952. Forty afmy forty five working years were spent abroad. I retired Ian L 1998 A list of my more recent civic activities is as follows: Member Fulbright Commission, Dublin, 1989-96 Eisenhower Fellowship Fund, 198 7-95 Director US Chamber of Commerce Ireland, 1980-96, President 1984-86 Member Irish Corrugated Packaging Assoc. 1982-95, President 19&6-88, 1993. Director Irish Management Institute. Dublin 1985-95 Director Scholarship Exchange Board 1985-89 Fund Raising Committee, British American Hospital, Madrid Member General Council FEFCO, Paris 1993-96 Listed Marquis Publications Who's Who in the Warid 1991-98 My working experience includes; Director International Development Europe, Africa, Middle East, India Union Camp Corp. Founder and Managing Director Union Camp's investments abroad in FROM JAY AND SANDRA PHONE NO. 912 443 0239 JUN. 01 1999 12:28PM P2 Puerto Rico, - Barcelona, Valencia, Canary Islands Spain - Dublin Ireland Istanbul, Turkey. Project Manager W.R. Grace & Co. Colombia J. P. Morgan & Co Case Officer CIA As you can see from some of the above, I have been exposed to Spanish and Hispanic culture for a number of years, speak the language and proudly have two grandchildren living in Mexico and one in Madrid, Spain. . If considered for the Council I would appreciate talking to someone about tbe actions, responsibilities, working procedures etc. before signing on. Hope thi8 is enough information. Regards, HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES OF MEETING of June 24,1999 at the Golden Gate Community Center, Naples, Florida PRESENT: ABSENT: Frank Rodriguez, Chairman, HAAB David Correa, HAAB Member Frank Loney, HAAB Member Pete Cade, HAAB Member Faye Reddick, HAAB Member Leo Cardona, HAAB Member Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney and HAAB Staff Liaison Member Dora Vidaurri, HAAB Member Maria Grimaldo, HAAB Member Also Present: Chris Bent, Applicant Jay Fox, Applicant Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones Newspaper The June 24, 1999 regular meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory BO,ard of Collier County (HAAB) commenced at approximately 7: 17 P.M. A quorum of six (6) members was present. The HAAB reviewed and considered the approval of the April 29, 1999 meeting minutes. Mr. Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones News, commented that the attached page for the April 29, 1999 minutes referencing his prior comments was fine. A motion to approve the minutes was made by Faye Reddick and seconded by Pete Cade. There was a unanimous vote to approve. The Board reviewed and considered the approval of the May 27, 1999 meeting minutes. Frank Loney made a motion to approve which was seconded by David Correa. There was a unanimous vote for approval. A discussion next ensued regarding whether Mr. Victor Valdes, Editor, Las Naciones News and Hispanic Rights Advocate, should have a separate place on the agenda regarding a report that Mr. Valdes wished to present to the Board regarding the Collier County Sheriffs office. Chairman Frank Rodriguez commented that he thought that the appropriate place for Mr. Valdes to comment was under the Public Comments section of the Agenda without separate reference to the topic in the Agenda. Staff Liaison Ramiro Mafialich reviewed the minutes ofthe last meeting with the Board regarding this topic and advised that the Chairman controls the agenda but that there can be a specific vote by the HAAB regarding the subject. Mr. Valdes commented that he wished to be specifically mentioned on the agenda so that the Sheriffs Office would find a need to be present and respond at the meeting. For the record, Mr. Valdes protested that the Chairman was trying to preclude him from speaking due to his allegations that the Chairman is involved in a Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) investigation and is defending a civil rights violator (the Sheriff). Mr. Valdes stated that he specifically wished to be placed on the next agenda with specific reference to his topic. A motion was made by Frank Loney to place the matter on the next agenda with reference to the specific topic. The motion was seconded by Pete Cade. The motion passed by a 5-1 vote (Frank Rodriguez voting against). Frank Rodriguez requested that the record reflect that he was voting against the motion because he did not believe it was appropriate for him to comment on a future agenda when his term on the Board was ending as of this meeting. Chairman Rodriguez welcomed Leo Cardona as a member. He advised Mr. Cardona that there are limits on the conduct of the HAAB members imposed by Ordinance and the Sunshine Law. He stated that the HAAB is a link to the community for Hispanics. He mentioned that the HAAB is constrained to act within the framework of the enabling ordinance. He mentioned, as an example, a recent Resolution on diversity which, perhaps, could have been stronger but that it reflected the efforts of Mr. Rodriguez and the HAAB to effectuate positive change for the Hispanic community. Frank Rodriguez further mentioned that the Minority Task Force is working diligently within the Sheriffs office and the FDLEframework. Frank Rodriguez mentioned that there is a growing Hispanic population and much to be done in Collier County. He stressed the need for the commitment of all of the HAAB members to the Hispanic community. Frank stated that he would stay involved with the Hispanic community and the HAAB after the end of his term. Frank stated that he was confident that Leo Cardona would be an asset to the Board. Frank Rodriguez stated that the Resolution declaring English as the official language of Collier County government continues to be a problem. He stated that it would be up to future HAAB members to follow up on this subject. He reminded the members that the HAAB had sent a letter of opposition to this Resolution to the Board of County Commissioners. He mentioned that Commissioner Norris had responded to Frank regarding the HAAB letter. A copy of Commissioner Norris' letter is attached to these minutes. Frank stated the opinion that Commissioner Norris should have written to the HAAB and not to Frank regarding this subject. Frank Loney inquired whether any letter had ever been sent to the Board of County Commissioners as a result of the joint meeting of the HAAS and Black Affairs Advisory Board (BAAB) of April 29, 1999, regarding the problems affecting minorities and the School Board. Frank Rodriguez commented that the BAAB had never sent the draft letter; however, Frank 2 reminded the members that the Board of County Commissioners had approved a Resolution promoting diversity. At this point, Ramiro Mafialich reminded the members that if they wanted the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) to provide a formal response (as a Board), then they may wish to request to be placed on the agenda for the BCC to obtain a formal vote of the BCC in regard to any HAAB position or request. Frank Rodriguez finished his comments regarding the BCC Resolution on diversity by stating that although it was passed with some word changes, there is now an important policy regarding diversity in place with the Board of County Commissioners. Frank said that this Resolution and its affects should be followed up with Collier County government. Faye Reddick commented that one-half of the members on the HAAB are new but they all have special talents which are needed by the Hispanic community. She said that recent events (such as the English as the official language Resolution) pose unique HAAB opportunities. She encouraged members of the HAAB with commitment and talents to apply for the position of chairman. Faye discussed the role of the chairman and the temperament which is needed for a successful chairman. She suggested that the election of a new chairman occur when all new members are present at the August meeting. She made a motion to this effect. The motion was seconded by Pete Cade. David Correa commented that the elections were supposed to have occurred in January. He discussed the history of postponements of this subject and he stated that the new members are not as familiar with HAAB problems. He explained his reasons for making strong statements regarding School Board Superintendent Dr. White and Board of County Commissioners member James Carter. He stressed that minorities have to stand up for their rights in Collier County. Pete Cade interjected that Dora Vidaurri and Maria Grimaldo should be present to participate in the vote. Frank Rodriguez also agreed that the full membership should be present to vote. David Correa commented that he was disappointed with the motion. He stressed this is not a personal issue but that there was talent presently on the Board from which to make the Chairmanship selection. Frank Loney cornmented that he would vote against the motion. He said that there were too many mind games, postponements and procrastination. He stressed the need for action and not just talk. The motion failed by a 2-4 margin with Pete Cade and Faye Reddick voting in favor of the motion. David Correa nominated himself for the position of Chairman. Leo Cardona provided a second. The vote was 4-2 (Faye Reddick and Frank Rodriguez opposed) and the motion failed since an affirmative vote of 5 is necessary, pursuant to the Ordinance, for official action to be taken. For the record, Frank Rodriguez again stated that it was his philosophical position that since his term was ending with this meeting that he should not vote in favor of matters which would bind future Boards. 3 The HAAB next reviewed the application of member Andrew J. Fox. Mr. Fox described that he had moved to Naples in September of last year and that he speaks Spanish. He explained his international background and that he has lived extensively in Hispanic cultures throughout the world. He said he wanted to give back to the Hispanic culture. He is in the process of familiarizing himself with the City of Immokalee but he has previously farmed in Florida. It is his observation that Hispanics in Florida need representation by persons interested in their plight. He commented how people of his ancestry (Irish) also previously were discriminated against and that the Irish, like Hispanics, also built up the nation. He hopes that there will be more positive action on behalf of Hispanics resulting from HAAB dialogue. The Board discussed with Mr. Fox the history of the HAAB and its interaction with the BCC. Victor Valdes stated that, as a founder of the HAAB, he believed that it was important to feel the heart and problems of the Hispanic population. He stated that Ms. Reddick had shown such qualities. Such qualities do not necessarily require the ability to speak Spanish. He said that many problems remain for Hispanics in Collier County. David Correa made a motion to recommend Mr. Fox for appointment to the HAAB and the motion was seconded by Frank Loney. The vote was unanimous in favor of the motion. Faye Reddick presented a prepared a statement to the HAAB, a copy of which is attached. In her statement, Ms. Reddick commented that the Board of County Commissioners had recently hosted a town hall meeting in Immokalee. Approximately 150 people had attended. A number of social economic and political problems in the Hispanic community were mentioned at the meeting. While only some County officials, including Commissioners, were present, they seemed to be receptive to the con~ems and promised action and gave the impression of caring. She challenged the HAAB to get involved in these types of issues on behalf of Hispanics. She said that many people in the Hispanic community were bypassing the HAAB because it had developed a reputation of being an elitist think tank or a bunch of hotheads. In addition, many Hispanics were not even aware of the existence of the HAAB. She stated that it was necessary to make the HAAB more visible to the Hispanic community to be successful. She suggested the use of committee resources to improve Hispanic conditions. She recalled the "Harvest of Shame" film which was made in Immokalee. She thought that the HAAB could be in the forefront of progressive reform efforts but that those results could not be achieved solely through the monthly meetings in Naples. Faye mentioned that there are a number of activists in the Hispanic community who want to use the system to bring about significant positive change. She thought that the HAAB should be a co-leader in this grassroots effort. She thought it was necessary to inform the Board of County Commissioners on a regular basis and that the HAAB should assist Hispanics throughout the County. She thought that HAAB gatherings in Immokalee were critical to the success of these types of efforts. 4 Faye reminded the members that they have the power to influence government leaders and that the best tool to do so would be timely and regular reports to the BCC so as to raise the consciousness of the BCC toward the Hispanic community. The HAAB can persuade with shame when reason does not work. She reminded the HAAB members that they represent dignified and long suffering people of the Hispanic community. At this point, Faye Reddick moved to adopt a Resolution regarding the goals and policies of the HAAB (copy attached). The Resolution would state specific goals and objectives for I year; would provide for meetings in Immokalee; rules of conduct; report from the Liaison as to the powers of the HAAB; and monthly reports of the HAAB to the BCC regarding issues of the Hispanic community. Frank Loney seconded the motion of Faye Reddick and stated that there had been a lack of communication by the HAAB with the BCC. He commented that the BCC were a bunch of hypocrites who only approach Hispanics when they need them. He recounted the English as the official language Resolution, the Dr. Cardona incident, and others which are just the start of Hispanics problems. He mentioned that the BCC often ask the HAAB for advice but don't include them in many of the decisions. David Correa stated that Faye Reddick's prepared statement should be attached to the minutes as an exhibit. He said he was proud to have Faye on the Board and was impressed with her intellect and grasp of Hispanic issues. A discussion ensued regarding the Resolution proposed by Faye Reddick. Frank Rodriguez suggested that points 2-5 of the Resolution should be subparts of a single point number 1. He also suggested stating that there II!l!): be meetings in Immokalee. Faye Reddick amended her motion to include Frank Rodriguez' comments. David Correa seconded the amended motion. A unanimous vote was had in favor of the motion. The meeting of the Hispanic Board adjourned at approximately 9:15 P.M. Prepared by: Ramiro Maiialich, Board Liaison Approved by the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board on the 22nd day of July, 1999. ~ , , Frank Loney, Vice Chairlnan Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board 5 John C. Norris District 1 James D. Carter, Ph.D. District 2 Timothy J. Constantine District 3 Pamela S. Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Beny District 5 gjoa}{d o/-fboitte-r -ffiou n ty {;fr>>mmJJl&neYJ 3301 East Tamiamj Trail. Naples, Florida 34112-4977 (941) 774.8097. Fax (941) 774.3602 May 4, 1999 Mr. Frank Rodriguez, Chairman Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Post Office Box 990244 Naples, Florida 34101 ~rl.~ F t!-q., Ie- Dear Mr. R~"uez: Thank you very much for your letter of April 26, 1999, in reference to Resolution No. 99-205 regarding English as the Ofticiallanguage of Collier County Government I appreciate you taking the time to write and share your views with me. While I do not agree with your views, 1 will certainly take your comments under consideration should this be brought before the Board of County Commissioners in the future. Once again, Mr. Rodriguez, thank you for sharing your views with me and if! may be of assistance to you in the future, please contact my oftice. Very truly yours, /John C. Noms Commissioner, District I JCN:tlm ir)-/;'~:: ~~:~q--~~-- I ' I' I , " i {") I'-~- '> 1", .....-..... I i , , L_.__ F r~ \,', i :',' ,', ',. fl+).....~ ~ i,~\~: , J 4. Election of Chairman, July 1999 Over half our members are new to the Board tbis year. For all practical purposes, three of you are here tonight for the first time. Each of you posses unique and special talents that are much needed by this Board. The Hispanic community and the HAAB are at a cross-roads. Through a series of events this past year that culminated in tbe English Only Ordinance we have the attention of the community and particularly our commisioners as we have seldom bad before. It behooves us to take advantage of tbe momentum. I cannot stress enough bow critical the role of Chairman is to the success or failure of the future of this Board. At least half tbe people on this Board have the necessary skills and character to be Chairman. I hope as you consider whether or not this position is right for you, that you will lay aside any reservation you may have regarding the length of time you've been a member, whether or not you're too old or too young, or your lack of involvement with recent issues. I do not believe any ofthese things are relevant. Committment, common sense, temperament and judgement are what is critical to fill this position; length of service on this Board is not. Under the time constraints of meeting once a month for only two hours, as well as the constraints imposed by the Sunshine Law, for us to accomplish anything requires a structured, goal oriented, and above all a courteous working environment. Our new Chairman has a solemn obligation to invoke his authority to control any bebavior that is counter productive to the objectives of the meeting. In the interest of all be must be willing to limit individual discussion, whether from the Board or the audience, and insist on absolute courtesy by all. I hope, too, as we vote we will consider the number of potential issues facing us this year. Our Chairman needs to possess more than enthusiasm and committment, he needs to have the personality and temperament to bring concensus." In other words, please, do not hesitate to stand up and be counted. The year abead can be filled with accomplisbments, but as tbey say, "a team of wide receivors with no quarterback is not going to make toucbdowns". I do not believe we should elect a chairman until the Board can sit with all new members present. This will allow us to select our Chairman from the full compliment of the Board. Therefore, I make a motion that we post-pone the election of a new Chairman until the August meeting and tbat an interim Chairman be appointed if tbe present Cbairman is not agreeable to act in this capacity. Tbis will allow all the new members to settle in and become more knowledgeable. New Business HAAB Meeting May 27, 1999 Town Hall Meeting The Collier Co. Commissioners have decided to host a series of Town Hall Meetings throughout the county this year. The fact that they scheduled the first one in Immokalee is significant. There were approximately 150 people attending. For three hours I listened as gracious, eloquent people gave their testimony in Spanish and English regarding the problems in the Hispanic community. The topics of concern covered substandard housing, slum landlords, outrageous rents, infrequent garbage collection, inadequate garbage receptacles, exploitive grocery prices, non-existent public transportation, inadequate banking services, fear of the implications of the English Only Proposal, ineffective government programs, the need for a 24 hour health clinic, and the need for recreational programs for their youth. Although I was extremely disappointed that the only commissioners to attend were Pam Mc'Kie and Barbara Berry, I'm happy to say that all the county officials were responsive, courteous, patient and informative. They addressed the plans for roads, the concerns regarding health care, questions of long term planning, and what home and business loans are available and how to apply. The commissioners were particularly concerned with the problems of high rent and unsanitary and inadequate housing as well as illegal housing and promised to give all of it their immediate attention. They encouraged people to speak as long as they needed to and they gave the impression that they cared. And I believe they do. It was a productive meeting. Before the meeting ended the commissioners described committees that were forming to address specific problems of health and housing. These committees are to report their findings directly to the commissioners. My question is, where was the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board in any of this? The problems certainly aren't new. They are old, they are conspicuous, they are offensive and ofteu evil. Though some of these problems are beyond our scope, most are within our purview. \Vhy haven't the people come to this Board with these problems? Why do I have the impression that many in the Hispanic Community itself are deliberately bi-passing this Board'! After the meeting I spoke with some of the individuals who had voiced their opinions and who had received applause from the audience. As we know, Spanish speaking people have an excellent word of mouth communication system, so it didn't come as a surprise to hear that our reputation as a Board has preceded us. Page 2 One person said that we have a reputation of being "hot heads". She believes, from attending some of our meetings in the past, that this Board spends its time fighting each other, debating and arguing issues but actually accomplishing very little. Someone else voiced the opinion that we have an "elitist" attitude. That we sit comfortably in Naples debating issues but are actually out of touch with the needs of the majority of people. Another thought we were just another government agency, a sort of "Think Tank", long on talk, short on action. Most weren't aware that we even exist. Fortunately, this Town Hall Meeting has given us the opportunity to change these perceptions. I hope that part of our discussion tonight will explore how to make our Board more visible and more accessible. A few suggestions to accomplish this was using the Guadalupe Social Services, Immokalee Chamber of Commerce, sending fliers, and contacting the heads of the churches. A half century ago Edward R. Morrow made a famous documentary entitled Harvest of Shame. Perhaps some of you remember it. It was seen by nearly every American school child in the decades of the 40's, 50's and 60's. It exposed the deplorable working and living conditions of migrant farm workers throughout tbe United States. What many don't know is that it was filmed in Immokalee. Fifty years later most of tbese problems still exist in Immokalee. I believe that there are now enough people in Collier County who bave the desire, the moral conviction and the political sophistication to finally change this. Many do not want tbeir wealth built on the backs of the migrant farm worker or the poor. They want to see an end to the grinding poverty of a significant percentage of our population and they have the political power now to do it. The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board can be in the forefront of this effort, representing the interests of the Hispanic Community, as we were created to do. But we're not going to do it meeting once a month in Naples. The immediate issues have already been presented and are now on the table. The people are getting organized. Their leaders are intelligent and articulate. The impression I had was that loud talk and empty gestures is not how they plan to get things done. Perhaps, even more important to their success is that they're planning to use the system to see their needs accomplished. They're convinced that it's important to make the system work for them in order to bring about significant changes. And we can do the same by understanding how the system works and applying it to our objectives. We, as a Board, hold an important place in this system. We have the opportunity to take a leadershjp,.~~e in this grass roots effort because unlike other organizations who have to wait tJWe'iurn to be heard, we have been directed to bring important issues before our commissioners on a regular basis. Page 3 It's also important to understand that it's not just Immokalee that would benefit from our efforts. By helping to resolve the problems in Immokalee we help resolve problems for Hispanics all over the county. We can, of course, continue to determine our own method of identifying, evaluating, and presenting the problems of the Hispanic Community. But in deciding whether or Dot to involve ourselves in Immokalee's concerns we have to keep in mind that familiar American saying, "Lead, follow or get out of the way". They are not going to wait for us. What I would like you to consider is, how to fulfill our duty to the community if the majority of people we represent have little or no knowledge or access to us. As the center of Hispanic culture it's important that the people of Immokalee have the opportunity to participate. In fact, it's more than important, it's essential if we're going to remain credible in the eyes of the community and survive as a Board. An individual I know responded to the idea of holding our meetings in Immokalee by saying, ""Vhat prevents them from coming here to Naples once a month? It's only once a month and after all this meeting is for them." Well, let's see. What might be preventing them from filling those chairs in front of us as they did for the Town Hall Meeting. Here are just a few things to consider. 1. Most of them work extremely long days starting from 4 a.m. when they wake up until they arrive home after dark. 2. Child care responsibilities after work. 3. Transportation. Which we take for granted here in Naples, but is a big problem for the majority living in Immokalee. 4. Meeting in an unfamiliar and formal environment with an organization they haven't learned to trust. Beside our duty to the Hispanic people and the commissioners we should give equal thought to how this Board can be more productive under the limitations of the Sunshine Law and in the two hours a month we meet. To be a productive Board we have to have a thorough understanding of our limitations as well as our powers. When I first applied to be on the Board I was under the impression that this would give me the opportunity to express some deeply felt political views regarding the poverty and exploitation of a people that I bave a great concern for. It didn't take long for me to realize that we have no political power. We have been appointed only as advisors. "Ve serve at the pleasure of the commissioners. Our Board can be dissolved as quickly as it was created. We do, however, have great moral power. And we have the envied and sought after power of iufluence. Page 4 Our most affective but under utilized tool is the imperative we've been given to submit timely and frequent reports on important issues to our political leaders. We have their ear. We have the ability to bring to them awareness ofthe moral correctness of our community's needs on a regular basis. \Ve have the power to raise consciousness. We have credibility because we are not political. And although there are times when we will not be able to persuade with reason, as we are so painfully aware from our experiences concerning Dr. Cordova and the issue of the School Superintendent, we also have the power to persuade with shame, as is evident by the Commissioners passage of the Hispanic Advisory Boards Diversity Statement this week. The message I have received is that to maintain our credibility with Hispanics and non-Hispanics alike we must improve our knowledge of the system and what it takes to make it work for us. When things don't go our way nothing is accomplished with threats, intimidation or the use of inflammatory words that get individuals focused so much on our anger that they no longer hear our message. To insure our credibility to all we serve, we must present our position in a manner that promotes respect for them as well as ourselves. \Ve can be passionate yet dignified. Without an attitude that reflects our moral sensibility, we only enflame situations, create anger and resistance and most damaging of all, we then give those in power justification to ignore the issues. We cannot afford to be ignorant or unsophisticated or overstep our authority as a Board. Truth, like a bell, has a ring that we all recognize. Individuals may not agree with the message but the purity of its moral tone cannot be denied. We represent a long suffering, patient people whose goals are to be treated with dignity and for a fair playing field to improve their lives. We represent a morally correct cause. Repeated long enough, our message will encourage communication, cooperation and generate awareness that will result in positive action on the important issues we present. Latino's have spoken. Lucas Benitez, the leader of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers ended his presentation to the commissioners in eloquent Spanish by saying, "We are asking for you to dig down and get at the root of the problems and not just the branches". The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board can respond to this urgent plea by being the strong, persistent and dignified voice the people need to represent them. Therefore I move that we adopt the following resolution: '- /Jr1au_ t} I l_j // ~} '/:.r clcie.l 0'/;;; -I /'/; RESOLUTION COLLIER COUNTY HlSPANlC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD Whereas, the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board has been formed to assist and advise the the Collier County Commissioners in matters effecting the interests of the Hispanic community of Collier County; and Whereas, the Collier County Commissioners have embarked upon a community wide town hall meeting schedule to increase their awareness of and response to the interests of individual citizen groups within the County; and Whereas; the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board should provide positive input and guidance to the Commissioners on a continuing basis during and after the completion of this effort; Therefore, be it resolved that the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board of Collier County will accomplish the following goals and establish the following policies during the next twelve months of the Board's operations. I. The adoption by August 26,1999 of specific Goals and Objectives for the HAAB to be accomplished by specific committees during the next twelve months. This commitment shall be known as the One Year Action Plan. 2. All future monthly meetings shall be held in Immokalee with an additional monthly meeting to be held elsewhere as the need arises. 3. The immediate adoption of rules of conduct which encourage courtesy, professionalism, cooperation and communications between the HAAB , the Commissioners and all other levels of County Government. 4. The receipt of a report by the County Liaison interpreting the Powers, Limitations and Responsibilities of the HAAB related to our relationship with the County Commissioners as defmed in the Collier County Code. 5. The preparation and presentation of a monthly report by the HAAB to the County Commissioners addressing the current status of and progress on issues of importance to the Hispanic Community of Collier County. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED THIS DAY OF ,1999 Chair, Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Collier County ~ m<<i:/nJ f~ ~ /1M" 1Y/eM.~ ~(p/I.4/I? , FMII/< /?o)l2(c;dG2-- . Fll/.! /" I':: ! t ,f- cP '/):.0 ((ii-,d f...E() R CIfJ:;)/J;1Ir! , . . , 'I I '1';',,0/ t,((Jel/,l-- cAamiro /lZMf~f'~ rldo-t. ~ - rI~ C'-l.. ~'-S ~E..,...:r<; JAY -;:?X /f44B /{J Il ,(~ iU) I) /!.If,tfl; 4113>>1/J~ '-7 ,-"./ ',i 'i I j/,//f/ Ifllftt Ii 0.-1.5 0,\ ~~~o,~r~ I' )) :;. - >-"--~-~'-""-~~""'''~---''''''''''''---'--' lna.1 \ (),.. G-r \ Y'(\Q \6C) ,2 0 23 r0. ~.~ .s~\ee\ \ rmY\Q hn1ee ,FL --3'-1 \<-1 2- (9<i1) &,51- '7 '75<1 "J U' !J ,2, / q c! (-7 ('" ~.O "j:) .,", I '.J) ~A\ .'~o.lY\'WO \\)(),5'\o,\~C:~ 33D I ~"" ,-,":'~\,-, ~ \ ~(\"'+- I'fc~\e.::') t L 3'-1 \12-- .. L.( 'io2 "",;, :'3~ \"" i::::J ..:J).e.o.<' ~l-f\('" 'f-rV';':\CL \'L\' ) -~. \ \ \ h\';::, \;,. '''j Ie-\- .~, () \- CA.~O c(~ --\-or \\Cl-\- be... y (e. -:"e "- \- CL \- \-\"u... \c\ ~ \- \:\ ,,,,- ""- ~':::"-f\\e e_\-",-:~ iJ n J,u.rVi..- 2'1, '1'i . 'Th.-e. ,e.G.-se.-, wo..,s \-\'-c\...\- \Gne... c-c"IY\j --\",enAs hc\c\ 0. \'eo..\~ y,e;.b\e.."(Y\ .-\~e<E' \.-.:,-e. ,\. \C)Q Y,,- \'\2.( -h \\-,e cLoc+o( CAf\c\. o+\-.e(' fue dOL~('i", u\~'W<... V;:o,.'I+ m,-\--h~el\c\ . neede.c\. --*0 7)c"b ~~e. "'rne.(~ei-'c..j . ro'o (YO --fc r,. 1;;-, yY, ,e. d '--0-J'el 'j - os.';, { ~+o .'1 c...c... w h; chv40 A: (i ~~:J --h-;-ne (-I,4J //lcfcte. /7?C /.1;,,'S..JCCL .-fire Mee.I'~3" J aJoeJ(d Irlre //71 Ie/Iei' -5hiJ,..d,:i b-c- odd/D & tZ"fJ0rl,cic( / .s CO /l ~) / ! I be., (--Jr.,' ul 5 ~ j,L r r;~ J cJ-t.U' /le.1i /yJ" --e..l ~ 1 ,.)r...UJ I-+;;- /" -Ihf. / e C~).f" dJ .. -ih a ~d- ',.Ie L{ . , 7 ;;;;;c:/LJ~ L-' p.5. j 0177 --.Su/e Ma l- I uJ? II al-I-ellel/he pe v-I /Y!EL -!r;'1 ~"____._~,"__. _~_"_'_'~"_~"'~~"_""~_'"" __,..;<..~.~,.~.,."_.."""._...",,,..~_w__ _.._...~.,,_",,_..,_.. ~_'_....'. ' _ "".... ._-.=.,',~~.,-.-,__,~,_'"_"