HAAB Backup 01/21/1999
Backup
Hispanic Affairs
Advisory Board
Meeting
January 21, 1999
NOTICE OF 1YIEETING
~ ..A..G END..A..
COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS
ADVISORY BOARD
THURSDAY, JANUARY 2], ]999
7:00 P.M.
Golden Gate Community Center Meeting Room A & B
470] Golden Gate Parkway
Naples, Florida
** ** * ** ** * ** ** * ** * * * ***** * ***** * * * * **** * * * * * * ** * * **
AGENDA
I. 7:00 P.M: Meeting of full Board and determination of quorum.
II. Meeting called to order.
Approval of minutes of the November 19, 1998 meeting.
III. Election of a new Chairman, Vice Chairman, and Secretary.
IV. Discussions regarding:
(A) Excused absences rule, including votes on whether previous absentees should
be excused.
(B) Discussion by Dr. Kate Warner regarding the Collier County Public School
District's organizational meeting on "Commitment to Diversity" that was
held on January 14, 1999.
(C) Invitation from the American Association of University Women for HAAB
to attend the Florida Humanities Council's Dialogue on Diversity scheduled
for Tuesday, March 30, 1999.
V. Presentations by Board members.
VI. New business and public comments. **
VII. Meeting adjourns.
**PUBLIC COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO 5 MINUTES PER SPEAKERffOPIC
UNLESS ADDITIONAL TIME AUTHORIZED BY HAAB.
01/21/99 15:00
'5'18132625203
F'RST NATIONAL
I4J 00 1
FRANK RODRIGUEZ
TEL: (941)435-7635
FAX: (941) 435-7684
DATE:
01/21/99
FAX TRANSMITTAL
(.;2... pA-"i Q..~)
TO: RAMIRO MANALICH, Chief Assistant County Attorney
HAAB Liaison
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
FROM:
FRANK RODRIGUEZ, Chairman of the HAAB
RE:
Notice of absence.
Enclosed is my notice of absence to the meeting of the
HAAB scheduled for tonight. I will appreciate if you
please make a copy available (via Fax) to any HAAB member
that will bring it to the meeting tonight. Thanks for
your help!
FAX #
(i)
!iI'Yo'
'.
<I
. .
.'0""
COLLIER COUNTY
DAVID C. WEIGEl
COlLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY
3301 Tamiami Trail East
Naples, Florido 34112-4902
Telephone: (941) 774-8400
FAX: (941) 774-0225
Email: attorney@naples.net
January 11, 1999
Heidi F. Ashton
Ramiro Manalich
Thomas C. Palmer
Michael W. Pettit
Marjorie M. Student
Melissa A. Vasquez
Rodney C. Wade
Robert N. Zachary
Board Members
Collier County Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
Re: January 21, 1999 Meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
Dear Members:
Attached please find the following
1. Agenda for the January 21, 1999 Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Meeting.
2, Copy of the January 8, 1999 Memorandum from HAAB Liaison, Ramiro Maiialich, to
Sue Filson regarding vacancies on this Board.
3. Copy of Sue Filson's list of Board members and terms of office.
4. Minutes of the November 19, 1998 Board Meeting.
Due to a conflict with County business, Ramiro Maiialich will be unable to attend the
Meeting ofJanuary 21, 1999. If you have any questions, please contact me or Ramiro at
774-8400.
Si"~Y
Kath~Kay" M. Nell, CLA
Office of the Collier County Attorney
Ikn
attachments
cc: Ramiro Maiialich, HAAB Liaison and Chief Assistant County Attorney, w/attachments v
David C. Weigel, County Attorney
NOTICE OF 1YIEETING
~ .A..GEND..A..
COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS
ADVISORY BOARD
THURSDAY, JANUARY 2], ]999
7:00 P.M.
Golden Gate Community Center Meeting Room C
4701 Golden Gate Parkway
Naples, Florida
* *** **** *** ** *** * *** * * * * * * * * *** * * * * ****** * **** * ** * *
AGENDA
I. 7:00 P.M: Meeting of full Board and determination of quorum.
II. Meeting called to order.
Approval of minutes of the November 19, 1998 meeting.
III. Election of a new Chairman, Vice Chairman, and Secretary.
IV. Discussions regarding:
(A) Excused absences rule, including votes on whether previous absentees should
be excused.
(B) Discussion by Dr. Kate Warner regarding the Collier County Public School
District's organizational meeting on "Commitment to Diversity" that was
held on January 14, 1999.
(C) Invitation from the American Association of University Women for HAAB
to attend the Florida Humanities Council's Dialogue on Diversity scheduled
for Tuesday, March 30, 1999.
V. Presentations by Board members.
VI. New business and public comments. **
VII. Meeting adjourns.
**PUBLlC COMMENTS ARE LIMITED TO 5 MINUTES PER SPEAKER/TOPIC
UNLESS ADDITIONAL TIME AUTHORIZED BY HAAB.
MEMORANDUM
FROM:
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Boar~ Commissioners
Ramiro afialic~, Chief Assistant County Attorney
TO:
DATE:
January 8, 1999
RE:
Vacancies on the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
On August 20, 1998, the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board (HAAS) considered two
applicants for appointment. Maria Henry was not present at the meeting, but advised the HAAB
that she would not be able to attend all HAAB meetings. The Board was also notified that
Marguerite Gregory is not a citizen of the United States and, therefore, not able to register to
vote. I am attaching, for your information, a copy of the minutes of the August 20, 1998 HAAB
meeting.
One member, Jorge Chemas, was absent for several meetings in 1998 without satisfactory
excuses. On May 21, 1998, the HAAB voted unanimously to have his seat declared vacant. I
have attached a copy of these minutes for your information. Please have the Board of County
Commissioners consider declaring a vacancy for this position. If the Board does declare the
position vacant, two seats will need to be filled.
Thank you for your assistance in this regard. If you have any questions, please do not
hesitate to contact me.
RM/kn
attachments
cc: David C. Weigel, County Attorney
HAAB Members ..,.....-
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Jorge Chemas 08/26/97 06/25/0 I 4 Years
354 Osprey's Landing, #2206 649-3282
Naples, FL 34104
District: 3
Category:
Kate 1. Warner 12/16/97 06/25/0 I 4 Years
1717 Camelia Lane 435-4577
Naples, FL 34105
District: I
Category:
Dora S, Vidaurri 658-2082 08/05/97 06/25/0 I 4 Years
611 Nassau Street Apt. #3
Immokalee, FL 34142
District: 5
Category:
Pete Cade, Jr. 657-1763 08/05/97 06/25/0 I 4 Years
1903 Leed A venue
Immokalee. FL 34142
District: 5
Category:
elashmet 11/14/95 ( 06/2~ 3 Years
Avenue, N.W. 353-0070
34102 ---------
David Correa
11257 Longshore Way West
Naples, FL 34119
District: 5
Category:
06/06/95
10/20/98
06/25/98
06/25/02
3 Years
4 Years
Frank G, Loney
131 Tahiti Street
Naples, FL 34113
District: I
Category:
08/01/95
06/25/99
4 Years
MTuesday, October 2o:r9ijr.~-- -
Page J of2
-
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp. Date
2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
Sandra Buxton
7816 Gardner Drive, #203
Naples, FL 34109
District: 3
Category:
04/28/98
06/25/99
I Year
514-2371
Frank florencio Rodriguez
P.O. Box 990244
Naples, FL 34101
District: 3
Category:
08/01195
06/25/99
4 Years
434-1975
This 9 member committee was created by Ord. No. 91-37, amended by Ord. No. 91-78) to
identify and evaluate problems unique to the Hispanic community, review and recommend ways
to ensure open communication between minorities and Collier County government and provide
periodic reports to the Board of County Commissioners Terms are 4 years.
FL STAT:
Staff: Ramiro Manalich. Assistant County Attorney: 774-8400
TueslJay, October 20, 1998
Page 2 aJ 2 -,-
~
MEMORANDUM
TO:
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
Ramiro Mafialich, Chief Assistant County Attorney
DATE:
March 2, 1999
RE:
Approved Minutes of the January 21, 1999 Meeting of the Hispanic Affairs
Advisory Board
Please find attached the approved minutes of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board meeting
which was held on January 21, 1999. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact
me.
RMlkn
attachment
cc: David C. Weigel, County Attorney
~
The January 21, 1999 meeting of the HAAB of Collier County ccmmmced at approximately 7: I Opm.
ThcnlWllA a quorim of five (S) in attendance and late< changed to Sill due to Fnutk Loney arriving late.
Open diBcuaslon CMlmenced regarding the changing the meetings to a differ""t day due to a conflict with
the sc:hedule of the School Board m""'ings.
Kate Warner IUgest we wait til Chairman Rodriguez is present lOr his input.
Minutca of November 19, 1998 considered; Kate Warner moves to approve the minutes of November 19.
1998. s.ndra Bwrton seconded and the minutes were unanimously approved without amcndmCll~
Fnutk Rodriguez Noti"" of Absence read.
DUe.oIoa .. ......nto 10 ese_ _!Joe"... mi..
DlBawion l'qllU'ding CXGUSc absence open fur discussion.
Kate Warner reads a mutiOll proparc:d by her at the request of Frank Rodriguez.
"ODe.... notice of absence."
Kate'I motionllated a week notification with regards to excusable absence should suffioo to an excusable
abseooo.
Kate djpo....- the concern of citizens appearing and 00 quorum is furm. F..,h th~ is a IIIC\c of
<XIlIUI1ltnlC:nt to the board and citizens. Therefor.. the issues regarding absences i. of importance.
Frank Looney addnl.... emergcucy meetins are a conflict to the boord.
Kale withdrawls motion and will mcxlify the motion.
Pele <Ii......... the location of the mcclings. Suggest that HAAB should conduct meetings in lmmokalce.
Mn. Grimaldo lIddresses that Pet.'s SUl!8cstiOll i. a good idea due to the Hispanic population in
Immoka1cc.
Acting 0uIirman David Correa .uggcst this is.... would be: discussed with Ramiro Malalith.
~ ........,u.a Elccdau for - ....... Chal....... VJce..CbaIrm.u, &lid Secretary.
Fnutk Looney discusses hi. expiration in June and would like to conside the Yico-Prcsidcnt pollillOll.
ElectlOll ofncw Chainnllll. Yico-Presidmt and Secretary agreed by board members to be: held iii the next
mcetinll.
Amerlcua Aaodalfoa ofVnlverally Women
Mn. Chris Straton bc&lm her pn::smtatian in regards to her organi:<ation. Explained they have a
Divenlty TII3k Fon:e. States thatthcy arc holding a presentation given by Mn. Oli_ K1ty "DIal"lJUC on
Divcnlty: on Marcl1 30, 1999 at the Main Library on Central Avenue from 7:00PM _ 8:30PM. She i.
lookins fir cooperating agencies and orglllllzations such as ours 10 help publicize. Hopes to get a
Ptoc:lamatiOll fur the County Commissioners fur this event.
Mrs. Grimaldo voluntan to _illt with tnmolatioo If noedcd.
Frank Looo.ey c:omplimcnts Mr.. Slaton 00 he.- presentation of her orllonizatJon and the prcsonlalion they
areproparinJl.
Kate molion8 that HAAB become a coopetlIlioo organization fur the American Aasoclatioo ofUnivc:rsity
Women.
Don Vidaurri $eCOOdcd the motion.
Motion earned unanimously.
Kate will gel copies from Mrs. Staton and will mail to Ramiro'. officc.
Mr.. Grimaldo advises she i. vct)' inla'atcd in joining HAAB , but would Iikc a copy of the
respoosibilities of the board. Allo mentions that she would like to ... the day mange because she also
attends the school board mrx:ting3.
C--Inqeat to Diwntcy
Kate Warner gives a b.-iehyopsia in regords to Commitmcntto Diversity a program out ofCalilor County
Public School.
Explain the progi'am is to rcx:ruit in all positioo..
DisaJssJ... was a1so wade OIl the racial alur made beck in Novanber91 by a teacher.
Also iuucs they addr-.:d were llIIPS llII policies. Need to develop a poliey of growing and changing. lpe
policy would a1so include sexual orientation, gender, religioUS, Gte.
They want minimum laws but cocpand.
The lila:ring ammlttc will outline a policy, provide a I...dership coounittee, address leaal 15SUcs, and
wording.
When c:ompldcd policy will then become a law.
Explained that unlOllll would prot.ny haWlto be advised and get involved
MCI:tinp arc scheduled em the 2nd Thuroday of each month lit the Adminimatlve Bldg.
Dr. Snow is providing a diversity lllnry that is open to the public.
Kate a1so advises thllt she COQtactcd All... Hamblin in rcgorda to Issua as Dr. Cardcna..
Dr. C4rdoaas I&su.. baa to be brought up by hinlsel[ That hte c:omiltoc could not take up OIl iL
Frank Looney uk that a meeting be held with the school board regarding Dr. Cardooa. He _co that be
is currently investigation Mr. Whites beckground.
Smool Board aarCCl that a HAAB mCll1bor be a n:preoc:ntative.
Possible CClftflict due to Sunshine Law.
David explains our bands arc lied. That the board is not willing ot help in hit: finding of the taIloval of
Dr. Cardona. David advises the board that he had a meeting with Mr. White lad would not change his
mind. SlaU:d that Mr. ]White slal<:d he was given the authority to remove Dr. Cardona by the School
Board. David talb abollt the lICbeivCllDcnls and abilities Dr. Co.-dona has. Feel4 that this should be an
issue the board should be concaned with.
Frank Looocy explains a previous incident with 0llII Hunkr and Mr. Doria. Thallhe numbers arc 6-2 m.-
minority ~tatiOq. FeeJa the community mould come together to do something or otherwise the
Hispanic Community will i~.
David fa:ls his lit a battle with the board.
Mt&. Grimaldo exprClSSC6 opini...~. Feels Dr. While and Cardona have a pen...... ..roblcm bocause they
are at equal wlue. Has persoaal cxpaienc:e 81 a moch... in rcgarda 10 Dr. Cardooa. Haw much
iIIlprovanent he hall ~c f..-the achoob. FccIa Dr. Wile hall IODIclhlng pcnonaI. That be is prejudice.
Feels Dr. Card.... made tlme fur the eommlDlity.
David dillCUSSCS that Dr. Cardona wee only gi""" a twc day nerice. Fccls we have been silent in regJlI"cIa 10
thi. iasue.
Kate ccplains that her 1_ wa. not UBCd by the board That this board has not been .ilence. That the
preparatiw ofher letter was In regards to Dr. Cardona.
David stales thaI no action has been taken by thi. board, and that we should have mOIled quicldy on thb
iSSWl. That he asked fur an =craonc:y meeting. A meeting with Mr. White that became nothing.
Kate explained that she WlIntcd the public lD be heard at that meeting. That that meeting was a learning
expc:rima:..
Mrs. Orlmald Slateo that Dr. Cardon. wu a good role model f..-the children.
David aab the boerd ifthCS'C I.. problan with the meeting beina beld on the 4th ThW'llday. Bolird has nO
",oblan. Slatm that he wanlS 10 be at the Rex' School Boerd mcc:ting in regards to I'SUClIlike Dr.
Cardona.
Mcetting llljoumed at 9:08pm
Prepared By: Dora Vidaurri
Approved
1
01/21/99 15: 00
'5'18132625203
FIRST NA T IOJ\AL
I4J 002
January 21, 1999
TO:
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
Ramiro Manalich, Chief Assistant County Attorney
~M:
Frank Rodriguez, Chairman
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
This is to inform you that due to an unavoidable scheduled meeting
of all First National Bank of Naples officers TODAY from 6:00PM to
10:00PM, I will not be able to attend tonight's HAAB meeting.
Please carry on with the agenda sent by Mr.Manalich for the meeting
and keep in mind that my term with the HAAB will expire June of
1999. I may not consider applying to renew my appointment for
another term. I look forward to attend the next February meeting
as scheduled in the past.
I wish you have a good and productive meeting!...