HAAB Minutes 09/07/1995
Minutes
Hispanic Affairs
Advisory Board
Meeting
September 7, 1995
HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD
MINUTES OF MEETING
september 7, 1995
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONER'S
MEETING ROOM
3RD FLOOR, ADMINISTRATION BUILDING
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER
NAPLES, FLORIDA
PRESENT:
Ramiro Manalich, Assistant County Attorney
David Correa, HAAB Member
Frank Rodriguez, HAAB Member
Frank Loney, HAAB Member
Neil Morales, HAAB Member
Pedro Vazquez, HAAB Member
victor Rivera, Visitor
The meeting of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board convened at
approximately 7:30 p.m. The agenda for that evening is attached.
Member Vazquez made a motion for Frank Rodriguez to be the new
Chairman of the Hispanic Board and for Neil Morales to be the
Vice Chairman. The motion was seconded by Member Correa. There
was a 5-0 vote in favor of Mr. Rodriguez as Chairman and a 5-0
vote in favor of Mr. Morales as Vice Chairman. It was agreed
that these gentlemen would hold office for a one (1) year term.
The June 14, June 21, and June 27,
approved upon motion of Neil Morales,
a 5-0 vote in favor of approval.
1995, meeting minutes were
seconded by Mr. Correa, and
A discussion was held regarding
made by Mr. correa, seconded by
Manalich continue to prepare the
secretary is chosen by the Board.
the motion.
minutes-taking. A motion was
Mr. Morales, to have Ramiro
minutes until a new minutes
The vote was 5-0 in favor of
At this point, Frank Rodriguez took over as Chairman for the
meeting. Frank Rodriguez provided a brief history of the
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board creation and explained that the
Board was created through the efforts of Hispanics and
Commissioner Burt Saunders to serve as a link between the
Hispanic community and the Board of County Commissioners.
Between 1991 and 1994, the emphasis of the Board's efforts was on
the Human Rights commission, which was eventually rejected by the
Board of county Commissioners. That was followed by some
resignations and the Hispanic Board deciding to have a new focus
beyond the Human Rights Commission and on the present needs of
the Hispanic community. Frank explained that the Hispanic Board
- 1 -
has previously traveled to Immokalee and other sites to be
accessible to the Hispanic community. A Hispanic Hotline was
created to gather data from the community and address problems
with the Board of County Commissioners. Frank candidly stated
that negative comments have been made in the past about the HAAB.
At one time, the Board of county Commissioners considered
consolidation of the Hispanic board with the Black Affairs
Advisory Board and that was firmly opposed by the HAAB.
Member Frank Loney said that the Hispanic Board was set up to
assist the Hispanic community and that he thought that the
Hotline idea was great and should be continued. Member Vazquez
requested a further update on the status of the Hispanic Hotline.
Chairman ROdriguez mentioned that some of the calls being
received by the Hotline did not relate to county problems.
There was a brief discussion of the Cuban Immigration Issues
Forum. Chairman Rodriguez referred the members to the minutes of
June 21, 1995, for a detailed review of the events that occurred
at the Forum. Chairman Rodriguez mentioned that the Forum was
designed to make the community at large aware of the Cuban
rafters/refugees/Collier County issues. The Forum was driven by
public questions more than it was by the set agenda. Chairman
Rodriguez commented that the news coverage could have been
better.
Member Loney asked what the Hispanic board was doing to reach the
entire Hispanic community.
Regarding point #4 on the agenda, the BCC luncheon workshop,
Chairman Rodriguez requested that a copy of the transcript of
that meeting be obtained.
There was an extensive discussion regarding the problem of
citizens who cannot speak English who attend Hispanic Board
meetings that are being held in English. Liaison Ramiro Manalich
explained that Spanish could be spoken at the meetings so long as
there was an English translation for the Spanish which was
spoken. Member Correa stressed that the business of the board
would have to be conducted in English, but that translators could
help if there were members of the audience who did not speak
English. Frank Loney stressed the need for competent translators
so that the audience and membership would have a full and
accurate translation.
Frank Rodriguez commented that the Board of County Commissioners
have encouraged the Hispanic board to work with other community
groups in creating a Hispanic event with Tourist Development
funds, such as a Hispanic heritage day. Mr. Rivera confirmed
that Tampa has that type of event.
Chairman Rodriguez acquainted the members wi th important
provisions of the ordinances governing the Hispanic board. He
- 2 -
mentioned section 2 (B) requires the members to be permanent
residents and electors of the County. He stressed that if
members do not vote for two successive elections that they can
lose their status as electors. Chairman Rodriguez commented
about section 4 (B) of the ordinance and its attendance
requirements. It was agreed that any excuses or absences would
be timely reported to Ramiro Manalich, who would then report them
to the Board. Frank pointed out that section 6 of the ordinance
allows for reimbursement of expenses and the question arose as to
whether this could apply to out-of-town meetings. Neil Morales
stressed that he would like to see the Board have an advance
schedule of the times and places for the meetings.
Frank Rodriguez covered section 7 of the ordinance regarding the
functions, powers and duties of the Board and mentioned that it
was necessary to understand that the Board acts only in an
advisory role. Regardless, it was important to provide responses
to the public, whatever the answer.
Chairman Rodriguez also covered Section 8 of the ordinance and
section 5 (C) and the members agreed to follow the basic Roberts
Rules of Order. It was decided that there would need to be a
public discussion portion during the agenda for public comment
limited to five (5) minutes per person prior to votes on items
being discussed.
It was decided agenda points 6, 7 and 8 would be discussed at the
next meeting. It was also mentioned that there may be a need to
create subcommittees on ~ssues of interest to the Hispanic
community. Mr. Vazquez suggested using the County cable channel
for outreach and for communication with the Hispanic community.
Ramiro Manalich was requested to find out the Hispanic Hotline
number.
The meeting was adjourned at 9:05 p.m. It was agreed that the
next meeting would be on Thursday, October 26, 1995, at 7:00
p.m., at the Collier County Board of County Commissioners Board
Room.
Respectfully submitted by:
Ramiro Manalich
Staff Liaison to the
Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board
APPROVED BY THE HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY
BOARD ON 1995.
Frank Rodriguez
Chairman of the Board
RM/cs/5957
- 3 -