Loading...
HAAB Backup 08/29/1991 Backup- Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Meeting August 29, 1991 HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD Thursday, August 29, 1991 8:30 a.m. Building H Conference Room AGENDA I. APPROVE MINUTES OF 8/14/91 MEETING II. DISCUSSION OF ADOPTION OF ROBERT'S RULES OF ORDER III. STAFF REPORT - RAMIRO MANALICH IV. DISCUSSION REGARDING CREATION OF SUBCOMMITTEES V. VICTOR VALDES RESOLUTION VI. REVIEW OF COLLIER COUNTY ORGANIZATION CHART VII. OLD BUSINESS VIII. NEW BUSINESS nnfkkef4492 '. (f!oJl/er<.. (lJOUIJ Tj 8CXlP-J 0;:, CJ!oUf2T7 0u/l1 J11! 5J'IO,/je,e$ }ftr)71@ UtrO t'l2s 4Ju'so/2j boo~d r/'I L i '1- /) G' ! (/1""9' I /1 'OIIS <'" / IfU/V~ - f I " if /11/1 )rJ {!j CD @ 1~k~, ~~" ~\ '" 6~. L l. C IC" Vi) :; \07j<-' R} '0" 7_ ,;/V,f/q, @ (j'()(h' (C ':170/!~ C ( @ ...-, 'bYe'\-t I'\. 1:.1.. b-" \t.-,.r(. h.. GbR,fi ))Dm/NGJe/G .-. (J) ~ tJ) ';::0.- (2:) "i...-'\ (S; CEi I ;U~) ~. '/"\ ~j .~_..'\ ~ (~'~ 0V , >'-j (-!!./ ) ) A I" i ....., ./1 fl.' - i;/j J-' / /L/V->..."'''/ '1" if [" ..,jr::___ CD l:fntziYJid j il.!L2 ",dtn>?Y7 ('C,7'~\ ' . , .. 1b _,~;<~U,?:t~~ ~;l' ."M..- @) (' ..~\ (..- ',"" <if) \ '-Ve'l)r1cOlfc}O 11 $/~cr.. C@ ~~~b.eY+ c~.u byte (jJ) (3,7 .f~./~ 5i I ( ,. ,e )'i~4 cJ1) (!I1IC(o 5 HI ICJJ31f'fI, ~) Qj~A/~/t//~zf4 Q~) Urc/o/(' /! ' t/r! /Jb'> ~ ~~L tZ;;L 07; 2,f~ J..v-e rio C if3 CA~ O. (fto..! j.. U, \ Lt"",. @ ,~;? )r: 9r~,; /7// "/ /' ~~-Z-::-" @ jf"6t~~ f., L ,~;:tjc( ~. / './ r-. I :;,"')/ ,,?AP I u120 j/ . ;~(0r~' _ '~) ~~ (A7<'c , d .' c??~,5 K P:3 ~/:( /' , . :/;'-, /, V/; ,I /Yt.'-/f1/i..-~ c' ,?,./cf,./<t4(r.;.l.:.'cc"., ,- . - \j"l:'::\ ';-S ~~f -~~:=l. 'l..." ,,.., .., c., /W'ti ,', ?~?"~, ,,) .,. ',' /1 ~~j?~ {j ~' . ,.:>f f<,;-, ~ - c--e " , / \,: '-" ( "X-"\ "'t/{ C ~ '-.... ,"j I,' ~ i J J v f&~ ?( UCM'"~ , 1<. l. ;(..,...<j\ ~ L b~a-"-Jk (!o~d~~ !tt:/t4~4 f\ , / (;.' \' tV;;;;~~:if~ S,)veyi 0 C' --;&2/l,(/O, 1/, LlC"'~ ,/;~ i r)'31 \:-" ~' ,,,........, (25) j.' e@.-yt~()..<( ~.. ~ n-. <L/I-1..e, '.' '-u L Lv t-<?, 77 0 r' , '-., c" Cc..r0i D'1[ Mr.Victor Valdes, editor of 'ILas Nacionesl' newspaper asked the chairman to hear a complaint brought forward from the public. The members objected as to whether priority should be given to the complaint or to follow the order of the agenda. A mCltiorl was made to heal'" other" busiY'less fi.....st. It secoY'lded and passed. Other Busir,ess Mr. Manuel Rodriguez, Jr. an exemployee to Coller County complained to the board that at our last meeting of Rugust 14, 1991 He heard four members discussing His termination of employment, which is a clear violation of the Sunshine Law. Mr. Rodriguez named and identified the following board members as responsible of violating The Sunshine Law: 1. - Dr. Fr'ank Belh-ar, 2.- Antonio Perez Benitoa 3.- NelsoYI Munoz 4.- Jaime Gutierrez Rs a result of this allegation Dr. F. Beltran and Jaime Gutierrez resigned their position as members of The Hispanic Rffairs Rdvisory Board. Mr. Bernardo Garcia claimed that He may have been involved in some discussion regarding Mr. Rodriguez,s case. Dr. Beltran in a very apologetic manner recognized the posibility of violating The Sunshine Law and therefore regreted his implication in this matter. M...... Rarniro MaY'lalich, AssistaY'lt COUY'lty AttOl'....Yley advised D........ F. BeltraY'1 aY'ld Jaime Gutierrez to present their resignation in writting to the County Commissioner,s office. In keeping with the goals and objectives of The Hispanic Rffairs Rdvisory Board Mr. Victor Valdes, suggested to board members the need to visit The lmmokalee Community and to meet with the farmworkers, and other members of the Hispanic Community. In doing so we would be reaching out to the majority of the Hispanic population in Collier County. Because of the intense discussion of this meeting the Chairman of The Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board Mr.Zac Lucio requested Mr. Manalich's legal opinion on this ,natter'. Mr. Ramir-c, Manalish Rssistar,t County Attorr,es called for a r'eccess at 9:45 R.M. to start at 10:00 R.M. SecoY'ld Pa.....t Mr. Manalich returned from consulting with the County Attornes and reported to The Hispanic Rffairs Rdvisory Board his findings. II In keeping with ordinance 91-37". It has been recommended that the grievences of the Hispanic Affairs Advisory Board will be presented to Commissioner Burt Saunders who was instrumental in its creation. 6 - ,:;:;:1 ------ 11) /)-: . I' ,,-, It, 1-1 /1 ,j I v / :..Ir\ ~ -> I / (- ...i-/.- ,- -) / r I 'c'rf ---- ---~~--- ,<> I ,~,~ f)' ", I ' , / I G{i (.' ~, 'r" ( _;it" -/--' _.~:~- /', L\---"--j , <",..,'J _ ~, (.'1 ,:,- '.- ,j'~ -t_.:.,,~,)K"'~:.:.~....,...,.,_ ~-:; < ( > ( " :2,,} t,.....;:::. (. 1_ ......( r-(' ,~ I . O\,)V_J.--Z{1~;'::':;;--: i\~ /1 ? '." (l/:_-..:::;.,::.. < ~.:;;;.:;:~_;." 7'"' /,- h // /..;' v'Yf :/(..~ .?() /14vi ~-- ", 4 ,.r...: ;::-'Lt , ) '.. J) ~;' ,,-:;:. /; , '/ "".', , I " cc/.<.t...- '~L '.......; ( C /lAJ. ;r)-1/";n07 L,:) ^/\ ~J;(: .-,I..;;:;...~ ,/ i/L t: (_ l.... r\~,-,<"':) ~ " ,;; , :;?~f4i ,-,r I -:..; .,-" ..' ,/, ( . ." I '--~ I' /" .:>1. '-be '/ (/ ( , ! . I,}':--,.. ,i.,:)"',.,, " , .:;-- , l.-';-.__1.:.,'~e'-' \', ".- '-- / t'<~,~_u 1 -1\' :.~-~ ~ i 'I. v( /< ,,:; ; ,I , ~;i 1___:;;;:;;;"-::'-~, "'.-, {~ i/l..,J-c, I \ ). ..\--,.....,,- :::;'..-;<')7 1 V -r;U:A,,}.t 'I ::vi! y!"'---,;y\ 'Vi J/ ;~ '(.. (oL{ -~C.-Cr.. ;?--~:'-7-tN /1 C_/ )' .~,~-~'..~-r- <~(_..:: v~'/'. ) / I) ,') I / t<~L.--;.., , . .>ri(.. '~' L,. ) I _/,/1 1:...""1':<1 ",."--...Ai.",,, __J. / cV"..::'j( ~ " i' /Pl", f..'-;f f 'l:~ -',;, c(.. h 'cc--fr" . ~ ':>-) i,A::- j', ~ y ,/ f /'" (,/' _..>~.. (" ','C ~~c-7t-f--I,~.I, ,- _ ,r ,.~~'-C 1 6+ ./ /, .-' ..!-/'/", ,\~-L''<:'" . /", 1 I ',,---i /\__.\_-,d. ':' ~../-. Ii t f "-p,P....- ,I w C -eo. ~-;;..~ "- o-t~;J;' , 1.-1 /' C''C,~ / /\~J c A, / " -f,_.. 01'. I -1/ ~a..<-f'--;"':r'j''-l-'<- :_>' /k~.-r-71_! ;rl.~ ~~/'r1 '-..J.~ .. \-...:.~ )t._-':'.Y'~ c~ -r' r" '(:- -~'" I (~ (, / ('i.,.'t.-: ,~-:t:::) i/' eJ,,-,':'1 .... -f,rt:; /, / '\.._,-_,,,,-, t i/" .--L "~;.J -,.... -'- c' ~_ .(v ~ ;~'''Y'-..-:,:...~ ) "j , / " if::::- j:::::J.tc;" . ..... t.. (-,I~ ':; 1: ( ::c~ ,- .. f / h-~-I , '.c.::~ jk. /; 7 " ') v /">, " ~?-::::;f' " J.;;. <..->"-1.. ,- eLL ?,c:"",-;;;;;-=7 ~J / 1-- :: ::. ~E\_ ~J;?"\....::-,~~t...c' i"'-- y'\.----~;:~/ --~ i.' / / It_k / Ch,-<J 0, \j,}"t<?1'1A;. '7~"" 7 (! ,/ ,: /~.J2.'LF...'<,; ~" ,/ ,/'{..Lul~~c:""Y\....-...::::::;> ..~ " " :---=:':f-l,', / /) IJ/,; ~ / , -'....-. _ \...... "-'''&.;~_, '''''/ '-l.,>~~ ~~. ,/,-r'J\. A.../~".~a'(>~>'-,,,<_? . ---"".4-, L. L r',A4~-[ 2:-1j --;:c'\'-_...., .......,... '; 1/ r (~~/ ,;-t>L.,~' ")..'::.:1' /), ") , 0/1 I,' I..;", , v/ ( . j t:.{r"L.Vlb-\-:.r<"^~'-:~--:t . ,/'" (i /r / L') .~ "':0~JL~....,,,:i( , , , , , ,,] ; 6)' 1&1" K'--:;; '-- -" '- / ,,1/!/$Jz:t'7\ . .. /'--, U" //~/' ""'~---/ _ ',L1-' ":'--!J ,'-.,.) ~~~'...._,;:.7~'\......I"".:\ ,..; ~__ ;;7/1 //v ("') (j' -/ /, ( / /' ~ t..........." / -', >.___ :t-""",-, /Le ""-1/[>-'] , .. /']..1 '-, / I ,/ / .---..., J .......L- /,:r...... iJ \ -" .. / ~~ ,I, \j..)---; - ; ('b-~~~--=-':Q- , '1 -1/, ./ }i( ~ V _-(.' 1... C' /'" ()' ..--. 7 (, 1- ~ (...-L- t....~ .lo..:4' (-.-...E-e _ I A.~-J-. . , .,(~~0 . 07 ? / ' . /:__,,:-"'''''l J. /, ~~q)./ l/t-.,'I'/ ~,v2 -, -, '/~\<';I, 1 1"./( i,/ f 1.", .J ,----fc, :Z_kJ;~ v~~~4..-t:, - . ~.. j I '--v"f C' 0, '--" c.-,;~:-' ~--7: ,/,-'~?) i 1; /IU-<itJC 1) /' r. i/ . L~A;> _ - "'2f7< /, ~:.;;;.cv .....--u v::::::..::~ ____" _-~ _ -..... J.3~rl .,~?l.;"'-~.c-(' , /) / ~i-~ fj/ ~"-"{;?L-'-~7 e., / (/j <!i:.~;"~ ~,~) , * ~U')(\A\7J) /.1// It- )"0--:-1--:. '-0 4.' c:t [<7, <">-"(>~>;;(;.:/?/z"..t.',j"2- /-7 cxi>s.C>t:'~-O-->11 /~ --- /. j/ /" - // vi{.,.<:\ C, i ~ /2: u / ~,~:?1. ' .'~~,. " ) ,/ ./ /;}/' ,~/i /,//:.oJ'L\,'/v-Q-- tiv'! '., , 7 " ~201..1' {;/ 0'1, (~,::'>,,,L-{ c/o-c(/d.., ~ I ,', ,/"; .' A o~ ,/ '/~~4'U' k;j-C\.t:. 07'1/ ( /-("( 7--Y'\ / - /* ~~,. ~X- ,_/~ ):///l ~. f,17' ,,/~., .y've,., 111'(, ~\\.,;.. y <' ) - ., ;/[,,--<./ . y-f' / I (p ). "--j / ,/ / ,/,,/ / '----' " -:~ \. )f-' ~'- " ,:I~~., n', . .\ c:. - ( ) I) , ! /j,j'1ti.1A} /V~,.;: '1 .,--r4 (()fl/). 1~~_'J-\:k -t{.;,~~--..tl ,., ,/! ( / 11/7'2 ''1 II /1-0~L-f/; (j../{_~i;~::',~:...c: ;:;'>>;: ',/' '/: , i / ' ,. I , '( . /. '}/v,A'" .. ~I , /: , 'ti (<.:~t;:~--\..~_I~__/",-v'" i'_ t'<.:.,) ///, j"".,..I;;'/i,,( (;;.?-- t-_ _' ---lV - p,'\. '..J~' -,:!:,':"-:::'1 /; 'of" , /"'-'~ . .7 1/ './ ' .. ,L":;;, / /...);;,...:;,;~-~:.::.-) " Ii , I,/} ;11/, A;{ , ,/ O'C-\_~/ ~....,J.... _5~,>-<~ .~'- .+. ":<,7,',"" " ~~ , i I' ,-i--j ~p")*' ,7:,,' .... / i ' (~- ,-,' {/~f'-C/'-. _I.:" ;:; / /} L.... " j; ( .. A- ,->~<~~~L-.' /,~. / ll/- / -, / "Y --::;;;:_-.> /'.d" ...,,_~>---, '-C ..' ,:zic .."I / ~\'J11F=e<1 '''l, f ',_ .?::",s. - /" . ~ I..' '-'-f") ..... G,-, c '\'y,:a-.-::::(;,',~::? ~;, / ;' '-' ~/ '/,,',,:;-;t- )('.1...____ -" /'-( C~) -<~~~-~~~44--. i~~_'~-"~ ", I /) I :.>- Cf:J.-i.. '-;r':;" . ',}"--,. .' ,o'.f /' (.,'):'-'-" -r:: ,_ .~y...(~,,-~;~(./ 1'""1/: ---/-. /)) l)l~&c'},~:~;C_:.-z:-,~ /" / " ,~ )' / '~"i - J I.- ''i' l~1'-/'~'~r/ /0C-~.j . ~'-~'\~:C:~--r:..' -,'j 1 _,(' - (.~ ,<,:t.~ t/,..., (},.., '--..j'_. j Il~U:L "if \,' 1: (l /7p""z..'~',J ~..ut.,'~' , ,., . I "I" ".. . t ...\/ \ 'A"'-:~ ',I '....,. ",:;c",' ,Ct.,,,,,~, -, , .. (} - ' ,~J."f' 'J'::."< ~ I ~ .<') >v~1'- ..{0-."~ '<'L-,~>f {!,~~lc.j JIa~ f ' I . i ' >7~:-..<::.kll /~ ;// ' ~'c:i ,'c -'-1 -' - 1..... '''; .-'/, ~-,.,--::-.--- 'J '" ", \'. /" -'r __, "",.$1,,' ;> \. A ""r'_ I.J .---" f-'" ~. . ~ /--},,,-,.- ,"--' . c (/ ,..',. /---<-~ ~ 1"< L, . <~, r\'/) . _~.-"' \.___> l~ ~..--...--0.-#-, ( " '-') " " "j I '~;_JC' -7~, i~-;~r' /,-" yi.,C.;.}'( / i' /f ,,, v ;f)'1 y'!v! I /-"),1 U<L,J/~''''- ,,,:J(_/ \ //' ci ~, . , ~J~( ::::. ';~4" I ",.,,~ l.__,/)" ~ ......... (... ,---"'""_/' -....- , ;. .::/ ." '-- 't-~r")':J1.__.. J'\ (' x / /2: ,Q:;'f "- '-kJ ../; F "lZ/7 " '><~~ 'iC.- ,'--"'-- / ~ ::,'J..,.. ~i3c ~/1./Le.::::::> /cd-- /~, t ',~ ;;:--"''/. ....~__' '," '__'.n""-' ..' r4.-<-<'.,.l:lit:;t..:, ", ;y). _ 18, ~~L">"~__ : (;::./d,) 0< /fi: (AJ-"" <::;;C:o ./u2--c>.f<-C-..>---<:I_c, +, /lA' ,r\~J <::1:, /!~r:~ yr' i .pJ:..!~(~'fW:-i.':=,,_ 07 /G1-o&:t:<:"'-<!r) f€ i~_e/ui.'<>: ~-1,.<(. 'Ad',Q-i /., il'/} , ,/,/(,,1, /'; r? '" j -.,..jdLcfl 'V:!,A...::-- 0---'i;/J'/ //vvf! LA.~,-': ,,/' " C .{.'.'In./,/>,\ . /),",7/1,' (7," /1.- '"/?~i ._- p , ' ' I.~ ~." (/. X~c.-c~~-e..J' A. ' , , //,/7 / Ie I l1 L:~:' c/Cd._~--cLe) -, /t") /,A~:/ ~ 12i=e-:~~", ~- /~, J /' !, v #:--- , ''') , ".., ;>-1 L./~ /"-c (..J ^'::...~--~-) C-;:, --"1, .... r2 _'-'-:~; ,-.;r:;:::~,-",~_ '-~~ ~ ......_':~..;_:';. /), I c:-~:~___.~-~, ~l/l~ '1 {-'"r-, t/--(~,-'y--~~" 'L,' /1 /' cd: c,~ ..~- 1/, /, / ",-- f. -, ):j --( -:y-. l_.".../ C') i'11~~' e;;-~L/l-(}-'1..,:;.L - ':c.~ v--v1 "t-.......... - , ' ---,..~. / :,.<-......./ ,,! -- " / /. 6<%>':. 6..-, /f{/~i- f: j. 'v' /J't'v<c""j, tv 19 ':'~1 /' J I ' / ~'J~:'/ _-:;,--:- ~i)' / k! ("1.. < :/1' ~ :;;? > /vO-=:> {/~ --1>:1':":7':":") (/1>-( 0:-, 7...k.. ' .:;rn j 1::--\ .i"f';~;;' ! ....- -. ~.__. -- W:J1 <;,~ if %d',~ L " L,,/l/u.... ~ / \...-..--'1 _ I z'._ c::-----f".J v. ~~I:!:'-:?'\..~Es;r:70- ',- -"--~ /"-'1' ,,<4 -, ) I "". -~ "."" G (.-<::::"':>0 )- '......\.___ u._,_. ~';";;;--7'7 '- ,/rj ~>{-- " (../''0 ~' / , Cl/ '-t' '/ _, /f j L' 71...(/ (i:.-t:(~-e-c -z; ,I-',r'G IJ-.., , ) , ( '- ----- KGC: r== (;cfrl (':z~, .,;j~/ i- :;5(< I +//LC1F'Zk_-<.J-t.tu,>= , .~~.- :.-. -.. --,,1- (';-2 """:;i' . j //./,,-7 ;. ..-' C'di';rc" ,cCt'~ [/ Y~c.-I?y:s(-.~:Jl~-7:;:~J~;~_~ = T c-l';,;;?c2 c.--"-,cc;::? ~k..e~< "n'l~'? /"1 ." ___ (d~<'" ,1 ~;~' ' t-f'z 'oj)' ,_ ~ ~ qj;o 17/~ ',--' -..- ,_ ~ I __--... c,---"f-" '> . d-?:~ . ,~'-~:^--1.--',/ --4,"~_ (,), , "'-<', :L:.--v ,_'- ;.J..') , ",rj/'>1..,'_\ ",;-" / , \, , . C" / j II~) ----L-, , (~ '- c !:~J /;:':i~l \ ' /,-', /" /:c{:cL.sf; (/ ,.".,--~ (\.>,'> \ " "'((' r I (r' (' , ,i" J ' A.A' _,...1l -" 11 ,"', fj'\..I)-\~"~":~~-=~-~ }/f::--- '<:J':-:~ 'I'" ' ,., / '''-~?i . ./ec>C /( , (. Y\ ,',.: -'-,~.:,;..~,,"'t \;>1""--'-'_' / ' . I , '. "J / /e~A!O;:? I /- /) '-/ ,-,~~ v )-<' ;r<:"l€ ;, ij /;7,(C' /~- " ') I ,_L--,,",_ ~,e xxt-" p-' . J " . 11 (1\ c&/. :j~) ,\ ,~ ...,.--- - ,,~ ',/,/ f.-.-,'\/,::i~ -.. '-t:~ - "., /, ' ~,' i. "j - A,/" A 1/1/, / v _, "C (Y //~) " '1 '.. {I, ~~, 4" " ( 'I ,/ /' _.. "/._ ,.'.1/ , /l4/ A..-LC-,)<:- 'e"'T/ 'i'- I' CQ"t/'--71.. ..J-a // , i- , I , ;';",.L:o, <... ,---1:' co.'] /' """ . ,,=jV'L~< -t;2-'-~-La=>-~c17..:l' L r.... .;, /7 <-=., CJ.. ,,'--~ /:-t-z.eo:' d) (~)7L-,ry,. (:..~> 0-U~ ,I? I- )O~,&u(0JV'l;;6y !;' .4,:' - :.-/ //~ ' / ;A._,~-"----#-"'~ ':-:X:"'~~j /" ;//[1, ,~ ') f"l..,rn '1 ,/ /- ( ; /,C;_ , I ! ",. '1;,') .,<:-~-{f:.'C ./(_v-?-1.----c"~ / r ' , "., . i / ,..' \ _ r /" _ C_1-~j\_a---1 .;~ L_ /1/1 1/[,1, i" , " i -' 1 """" (;/ ~__ 0'-JJ__....~ V ,.Q.,- T ' ~"'-+ ' .-- f -, _ c">""f;')<.\ " ....) ,') ) , v , /,/ c'-/, /.1 , 1,,1-/ .,\ ,'~,"'l, ~' , rl;:-u;J LU~~~t<._1-~1._'l..~...,,1 _k(~c:L.-\ 0' j//..; / i(?/ &~1. ~--7../ ~.- ,-~-6: . ~/i 'I