The URL can be used to link to this page

CCPC Agenda 01/21/2010 RPLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA JANUARY 21, 2010 AGENDA COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION WILL MEET AT 8:30 A.M., THURSDAY, JANUARY 21, 2010, IN THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING ROOM, ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER, 3301 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, NAPLES, FLORIDA: NOTE: INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO 5 MINUTES ON ANY ITEM. INDIVIDUALS SELECTED TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF AN ORGANIZATION OR GROUP ARE ENCOURAGED AND MAY BE ALLOTTED 10 MINUTES TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM IF SO RECOGNIZED BY THE CHAIRMAN. PERSONS WISHING TO HAVE WRITTEN OR GRAPHIC MATERIALS INCLUDED IN THE CCPC AGENDA PACKETS MUST SUBMIT SAID MATERIAL A MINIMUM OF 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE RESPECTIVE PUBLIC HEARING. IN ANY CASE, WRITTEN MATERIALS INTENDED TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE CCPC SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE APPROPRIATE COUNTY STAFF A MINIMUM OF SEVEN DAYS PRIOR TO THE PUBLIC HEARING. ALL MATERIAL USED IN PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE CCPC WILL BECOME A PERMANENT PART OF THE RECORD AND WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR PRESENTATION TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IF APPLICABLE. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE CCPC WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. 1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 2. ROLL CALL BY SECRETARY 3. ADDENDA TO THE AGENDA 4. PLANNING COMMISSION ABSENCES 5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES — DECEMBER 16, 2009 CRA AND IMMOKALEE MASTER PLAN & VISIONING COMMITTEE WORKSHOP and DECEMBER 17,2009 REGULAR MEETING 6 BCC REPORT- RECAPS —JANUARY 12, 2010 7. CHAIRMAN'S REPORT 8. CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS A. Petition: VA- PL2009 -37, FLO TV Inc., represented by Kimberly J. Madison, Esq., of Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A., is requesting a Variance of 55.7 feet from the 75 -foot front yard setback requirement; and Variances of 22.3 feet and 22.6 feet from the 30 -foot eastern and western side yard setback requirements, respectively, of LDC subsection 4.02.01, Table 2.1, Table of Minimum Yard Requirements for Base Zoning Districts, to permit 19.3 -foot, 7.7 -foot and 7.4 -foot setbacks, respectively, for the guy lines and anchors of a communications tower in excess of 75 feet in the Estates (E) Zoning District. The 4.77 -acre subject property is located at 5860 Crews Road, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, in Collier County, Florida. (Companion item to CU- 2008 -AR- 14085) 1 B. Petition: CU- 2008 -AR- 14085, FLO TV, Inc., represented by Kimberly J. Madison, Esq., of Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A., is requesting a Conditional Use for a communications tower and the installation of related shelter and equipment in the Estates (E) Zoning District, as specified in Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). The approximately 4.77 -acre subject property is located at 5860 Crews Road, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, in Collier County, Florida. (Companion item to VA- PL2009 -037) C. Petition: PUDZ -A- 2006 -AR- 10318, Pawel and Teryl Brzeski, Magnolia Pond Holdings, LLC and Teryl Brzeski, Trustee of the Land Trust # 1 -B, represented by Davidson Engineering and Patrick White of Porter, Wright, Morris & Arthur, LLP, are requesting a rezone from the Magnolia Pond Planned Unit Development (PUD), Ordinance No. 98 -49, and Rural Agriculture (A) Zoning Districts to a Mixed -Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD) to be known as Magnolia Pond MPUD, permitting 231 multi - family dwelling units and/or an assisted living facility (ALF) at a floor area ratio of .60 with the applicant seeking to add an additional 5 acres to the site. The subject property is 47.05± acres and is located on the north side of the I -75 right -of -way and half mile west of Collier Boulevard (CR -951) in Section 34, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. D. Petition: CU- PL2009 -405, Collier County Alternative Transportation Modes Department represented by Abra Horne, AICP, of Wilbur Smith Associates is requesting a Conditional Use in the Gallman Olds PUD zoning District to add a Government Facility, limited to a Bus Transfer Station pursuant to LDC Section 2.01.03.G. Le, Essential Services. The subject 10.04± acre property is located on the south side of Radio Road extending to Davis Boulevard, approximately 1,000 feet from the Radio Road and Davis Boulevard intersection in Section 3, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. (Coordinator: Kay Deselem, AICP) E. Petition: RZ- PL2009 -469, East Naples Fire Control and Rescue District No. 26, represented by Robert L. Duane, AICP of Hole Montes Inc., is requesting to rezone from Rural Agriculture (A) and Commercial Intermediate (C -3) zoning districts to the Public Use (P) zoning district for a Fire Station and accessory uses. The subject property is 3.68± acres and is located in Section 20, Township 51 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. 9. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Petition: CPSP - 2009 -3, A staff initiated petition amending the Capital Improvement Element of the Collier County Growth Management Plan to incorporate updates based on the 2009 Annual Update and Inventory Report on Public Facilities (AUIR), and additional staff analysis, including updates to the 5 -Year Schedule of Capital Improvements (for Fiscal Years 2010 — 2014) and the Schedule of Capital Improvements for Future 5 -Year Period (for Fiscal Years 2015 — 2019). (Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner) 10. OLD BUSINESS 11, NEW BUSINESS 12. PUBLIC COMMENT ITEM 13. DISCUSSION OF ADDENDA 14. ADJOURN 1/8/10 CCPC Agenda/Ray BellowsAd FLO TV, Incorporated 5860 Crews Road, Naples, FL Application No. CU- 2008 -AR- 14085 and VA- PL2009 -37 Collier County Planning Commission January 7, 2010 Administration Building F, 3rd Floor Naples, FL Conditional Use Petition — Application No. CU- 2008 -AR -14085 and Variance Petition — Application No. VA -PL- 2009 -037 Applicant: FLO TV, Incorporated EXHIBIT LIST Item No. Description 1. Application for Conditional Use Petition 2. Application for Variance Petition 3. Site Plan 4. Property Survey 5. Aerial Photographs 6. Staff Report for Conditional Use Petition a. January 7, 2010 b. October 15, 2009 7. Staff Report for Variance Petition a. January 7, 2010 b. October 15, 2009 8. Expert Resume(s) a. Dave Hallowell, P.E. b. David Kuhn, P.E. c. Brian Grant 9. Photographs 10. Allied (Old) Tower Inspection Report 11. Site Distance Map 12. Collapse Zone Analysis 13. Collier Mosquito Control Response 14. Collier County Land Development Code provisions: a. Section 5.05.09 (G)(1) b. Section 5.05.09 (G)(3) c. Section 5.05.09 (G)(7) d. Section 5.05.09 (G)(9) e. Section 5.05.09 (G)(13) oi�Roden McClosl<y March 2. 2009 VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS Jolin -David Moss Zoning & Land Development Review Community- Development & Environmental Services 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples. FL 34104 401 EAST JACKSON STREET SUITE 2700 TAMPA. FLORIDA 33602 (613) 314 -67C9 FAX (813) 314 -6809 KIMBERLY.MADISON@RUDEN COM Re: Application for Conditional Use — CU- 2208 -AR -14085 Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware Corporation (the "Applicant ") 5860 Crews Road (Existing Address) % 5864 Crews Road (Proposed Address) Our File No. 60479 -0001 Dear John - David: Thank you very much for your assistance regarding the Application referenced above. In resolution of Staff comments following initial review of this Application, the Applicant provides the following supplemental information for your review: 1. Twenty (20) cover letters from Roden McClosky and Black & Veatch Engineering respectively, identifying revisions to the Application and Conceptual Site Plan; 2. Twenty (20) copies of the revised Application for Conditional Use; 3. Twenty (20) Conceptual Site Plans (24" x 36 "), plus one (1) 8 %2 x 11 copy; and, 4. One (1) CDROM containing an electronic copy of all documents and plans. The Applicant identifies the following revisions and,'or supplemental information to the Application and Conceptual Site Plan ( "Site Plan ") in accordance with the Staff comments enumerated below: 1. Verifv Propertv's zonin¢ desivation and FLUE designation. a. Staff Comment #1: On application, zoning to north and west is "PUD" only. Applicant's Response: Zoning to the north and west of the Property has been revised to "PUD" on the Application. TP.A o8 i 805 ? RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. _ +. P 0 rw. .I. 1i RD iJ NUNI - ♦APLFS -OR L�\ DO • FCRT S. LLCIE SARASOT • ar PETER£3.PC + .11?5.& n.+ Lac h p dE,EC.a John -David floss .March 2. 2009 Page 2 b. Staff Comment #2: On same page. please list what the land uses are adjacent to property, e.g... residential. vacant, etc. Applicant's Response: The Property is adjacent to vacant. non - agricultural acreage to the north. south, east and west. This information has been added to the Application. 2. Review Site Plan, LDC 10.08.00.B. a. Staff Comment #1: Landscape buffers have not been shown on the plan. Applicant's Response: Landscape buffers have been added to the Site Plan. Please refer to revised Site Plan and Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch, attached. 3. Revieki' plans for additional requirements for specific conditional uses, where applicable. LDC10.08.00.B. a. Staff Comment #1: What is the distance between the existing and proposed (2 "d) tower? Please state on plans. Applicant's Response: The distance between the two towers is stated on the Site Plan. Please refer to revised Site Plan and Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch, attached. b. Staff Comment #2: Please explain how the proximity of the tower to the existing tower will not present an unacceptable risk or case the tower to fail (see LDC 5.05.09.G.9). Applicant's Response: Please refer to Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch, attached. c. Staff Comment #3: Please show all setbacks on the plans for the existing and proposed improvements. Applicant's Response: All setbacks are now shown on the Site Plan. Please refer to revised Site Plan and Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch, attached. d. Staff Comment 94: An existing "dirt access road" is shown on the plan. Access to the site is only permissible via Crews. Please clarify this on plans. Applicant's Response: This information has been added to the Site Plan. Please refer to revised Site Plan and Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch. attached. e. Staff Comment #5: Please depict location of the 2 required parking spaces (which may be pervious). -9PA.69',K 1 RUDEN, McCLOSKI', SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. S)C:. R C:9'.; . •'FT >,.CER �11n'.I . \RGEEC . CRS> \CG • PORT ST LCr • 5>R>SCTS . ST. PETER55LRC • TSILlH >;,EE . '_.,Pa • E'+E . .. BEAC . John -Day id Moss March 2. 2009 Page 3 Applicant's Response: The 2 required parking spaces are now shown on the Site Plan. Please refer to revised Site Plan and Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch, attached. f. Staff Comment #6: Please show location of required fence around the tower bases, guy anchors. equipment and buildings. Applicant's Response: All required fencing is now shown on the Site Plan. Please refer to revised Site Plan and Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch. attached. g. Staff Comment #7: Please state on plans that towers have had red beacon or dual mode lights for the Mosquito Control District airplanes and/or strobe lights, as required by the FAA for airplane traffic. Applicant's Response: This information has been added to the Site Plan. Please refer to revised Site Plan and Cover Letter from David Kuhn of Black & Veatch, attached. 4. Additional Staff Comments: a. Staff Comment #1: The address for the existing tower is 5860 Crews Road. This tower will have a different address. Applicant's Response: Peggy Jarrell of Collier County's Addressing Department has assigned a new address of 5864 Crews Road to the tower that is the subject of Applicant's Conditional Use Request. The proposed address and the existing address have been added to the Application. If you have any questions regarding the information contained herein, please do not hesitate to contact me at (813) 314 -6709. KJM /kcw Enclosures cc: Thomas Voltero (w /o enclosures) TPA 68 T 606 1 Sincerely, Kimberly J. Madison RUDEN, MCCLOSKY SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. 1,DFPDA'., 11I A,%! •'APEfS • 09.,Ad0 • PORT IT l- C.c •'ARA•.O'A - ST PETE 9'9lRC ..l -Hau9c •'4N °A • NEB ,,1 :; =.C1 BLACK & VEATCH building a , , ; of differerce° ENERGY WATER INFORMATION GOVERNMENT February 23, 2009 John -David Moss Zoning & Land Development Review Community Development & Environmental Services 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 RE: Application for Conditional Use — CU- 2208 -AR -14085 5864 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (the 'Property") MedfaFLO USA, Inc. (the "Applicant ") Dear Mr. Moss: Thank you very much for your assistance regarding the Application referenced above. The Applicant provides the following responses in light of comments received from Staff: 1. Verify Property's zoning designation and FLUE designation. 1. Zoning to the north and west of the Property is 'PUD." This has been corrected on the Application. 2. The Property is adjacent to vacant, non - agricultural acreage to the north, south, east and west. 2. Review Site plan, LDC 10.08.00.13 1. See existing Site Vegetation Plan on Sheet A -0.1. 3. Review plans for additional requirements for specific conditional uses, where applicable. LDC10.08.00.B 1. Distance between the two towers is now indicated on the Overall Site Plan on Sheet A -0. 2. In accordance with the statement from the engineer that performed the structural analysis for this site, "The proximity of the towers do not present any cause for the tower not to meet the TIA standard for acceptable structural requirements. The two towers are independent structures not connected at any elevation. Both towers were independently designed and constructed with their own set of guying hardware, tower geometry, and foundations." 3. Setbacks have been added to the plans. 4. The "dirt access road" is on the drawings indicating that access to the guy anchors is available. The only access to the site is from Crews Road. We have clarified this on the Overall Site Plan on Sheet A -0. 5. The two parking spaces have been added to the Overall Site Plan on Sheet A -0. 6. Fencing is indicated and called out on the Overall Site Plan on Sheet A -0, and the Site Plan on Sheet A -1. 7, A Note has been added to the Exterior Elevations on Sheet A -4.1, stating that the towers are presently lit and shall remain lighted in accordance with the requirements for the Mosquito Control District airplanes and FAA airplane traffic for this site. If you have any questions regarding the information contained herein, please do not hesitate to contact me at 913 - 458 -7036. Best regards r, David H. Kuhn, P E. Project Engineer Black & Veatch Corporation 11401 Lamar Avenue Overland Park, KS 66211 USA Telephone: 913.458.2000 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLIERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239)252.2400 FAX (239) 643 -6968 'C k, PETITION NO (AR) PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER To be completed by staff DATE PROCESSED ASSIGNED PLANNER ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF NAME OF APPLICANT(S) MEDIAFLO USA, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION ADDRESS 5775 MOREHOUSE DRIVE CITY SAN DIEGO STATE CA ZIP 92121 TELEPHONE # (858) 651 -3244 CELL # FAX # E-MAIL NAME OF AGENT JAMES J. PORTER, ESQ . FIRM RUDEN MCCLOSKY ADDRESS 401 E. JACKSON ST., SUITE 2700 CITY TAMPA STATE FL ZIP 33602 TELEPHONE # (813) 222 -6620 CELL # FAX # (813) 314 -6920 E -MAIL ADDRESS JIM.PORTER @RUDEN.COM BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESE REGULATIONS. APPLI CATION FOR PUBLIC HEARINC FOR CONDITIONAL USE- 4114103, rev 512012005, rev 2171108, rev 7114.08 Complete the following for all registered Assoclation(s) that could be affected by this petition. Provide additional sheets If necessary. Information can be found on the Board of County Commissioner's webslte at hltD:llwww.collleraov.netJIndex.asDx?Daae=774 Please see Exhibit "A", attached. NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP . NAME OF MASTER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF CIVIC ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP DISCLOSI.I.FtE.OFINTER'E;$':tINFORIIIAtJQ.f\l..... a. If the property Is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety, tenancy In common, or Joint tenancy, list all parties wIth an ownership Interest as well as the percentage of such interest. (Use addItional sheets If necessary). Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. b. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and the percentage of stock owned by each. APPLlCA nON FOR PU8ltC HEARtNG FOR CONDITIONAL U5E - 4//4/03, rev 5120/2005, rev 2//2/08, rev. 7//4.08 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Existing Address) 5864 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (proposed Address) Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Exhibit A List of Surroundinl! Rel!istered Homeowners and Master Associations 1. Falling Waters Beach Resort, Phase II Mr. Thomas Powers, President 6660 Beach Resort Drive, #6 Naples, FL 34114 2. Falling Waters Condominium Owners Association I Mr. Tom Lee, President 2202 Hidden Lake Drive, #7 Naples, FL 34112 3. Falling Waters Homeowners Association II Mr. Tim Boyle, President 2274 Hidden Lake Drive, #9 Naples, FL 34112 4. Magnolia Cove of Falling Waters Mr. Raymond C. McCabe, President 2338 Magnolia Lane, #2 Naples, FL 34112 5. Cascades of Falling Waters Condo Association Mr. George W. Baker, President 1972 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 6. Cascades at Falling Waters Mr. Robert Hinklin, President 2004 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 7. Falling Waters Beach Resort Master Association Mr. Donald K. Bassett, President 6580 Beach Resort Drive, #3 Naples, FL 34112 TP A:642048: I Name and Address Percentage of Ownership See attached listing of officers for Renda Broadcasting Corporation, attached as Exhibit "B". c. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the percentage of interest. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. d. If the property is In the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the general and/or limited partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. APPLlCA nON FOR PU8L1C HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL USE - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08. rev. 7/14.08 WWW.sunblz.org - Department of State Page 1 00 Home Contact Us E-Fillng Services Document Searches Forms H Previous on List Next on List Return To List No Events No Name History iiiiiiiiiiiii. ... .. .... , . .... .... ... Detail by Entity Name Foreign Profit Corporation RENDA BROADCASTING CORPORATION Filing Information Document Number P30305 FEI Number 251259502 Date Flied 07/26/1990 State PA Status ACTIVE Principal Address 10915 K-NINE DR BONITA SPRINGS FL 34135 Changed 07/0212007 Mailing Address 900 PARRISH ST 4TH FLOOR PITTSBURGH PA 15220 Changed 04/2612000 Registered Agent Name & Address RENDA, ANTHONY F RENDA BROADCASTING CORP 10915 K-NINE DRIVE BONITA SPRINGS FL 34135-6802 US Name Changed: 07/02/2007 Address Changed: 07/02/2007 Officer/Director Detail Name & Address Title DPT RENDA, ANTHONY MERRIMAN RD. SEWlCKLEY PA 15143 b :;; j EXHIBIT B http://sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?action=DETFIL&inq_doC _ number=P30305&inq_ earn... 12/2/2008 www.sunbiz.org - Department of State Page 2 of3 Title DVS RENDA, CATHERINE R. MERRIMAN ROAD SEWlCKLEY PA 15143 Title V SERENA, ALAN C 3111 CHESTNUT RIDGE DR PITTSBURGH PA 15205 TitleDV KELLY, MARYANN 114 ALPINE CIR BELLE VERNON PA 15012 Title V REICH, JUDY 506 COVENTY TRAIL LANE MARYLAND HEIGHTS MO 63043 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date 2006 07/1712006 2007 07/0212007 2008 02/2812008 Note: This is not official record. See documents if question or conflict. http://sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?action=DETFIL&inq_ doc _ number=P30305&inq_ cam... 12/2/2008 www.sunbiz.org - Department of State Page 3 of 3 Previous on List Next on List Return To List No Events No Name History ~_lili Home Contact us Document Searches E-Filing Services Forms Help Copyright and Privacy Policies Copyright @ 2007 State of Florida, Department of State. http://sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?action=DETFIL&inq_ doc _ number=P30305&inq_ cam... 12/2/2008 e. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. Date of Contract: 1. If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all individuals or officers, if a corporation, partnership, or trust. Name and Address Not applicable. g. Date subject property acquired IZI Owner acquired property on January 13, 1999. leased D Term of lease yrs./mos. If, Petitioner has option to buy, indicate the following: Date of option: Not applicable. Date option terminates: , or Anticipated closing date: h. Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, it is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form. APPLlCA TION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL U5E - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 PFl6p,~R'lYlQPATIO~; _ <c if Hi '?~""i'" Detailed leaal description of the property covered bv the application: (If space is inadequate, attach on separate page.) If request involves change to more than one zoning district, include separate legal description for property involved in each district. Applicant shall submit four (4) copies of a recent survey (completed within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale) if required to do so at the pre- application meeting. NOTE: The applicant is responsible for supplying the correct legal description. If questions arise concerning the legal description, an engineer's certification or sealed survey may be required. Section/Township/Range 08/50/26 Lot: Block: Subdivision: Also known as Lot 20. Enchanted Acres Plat Book Page #: Property I.D.#: 00405160008 Metes & Bounds Description: SIZE OF PROPERTY: ft. X ft. = Total Sq. Ft. Acres 4.77 ac (207,781.20 s.f. m.o.l.) ADDRESS/GENERAL LOCATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 5860 Crews Rd., Naples, FL (existing address), 5864 Crews Rd., Naples, FL (proposed address) <C. ", ~'~Q~~c;re,t#:t~,iSr~..l~m'i,"~~':,,"iE; Zoning Land use N PUD S E E PUD W PUD Non-agricultural acreage / vacant Non-agricultural acreage / vacant Non-agricultural acreage / vacant Non-agricultural acreage / vacant Does the owner of the subject property own property contiguous to the subject property? If so, give complete legal description of entire contiguous property. (If space is inadequate, attach on separate page). Not applicable. Sectionrrownshlp/Range / / Lot: Block: Subdivision: Not applicable. Plat Book Page #: Property I.D.#: APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDmONAL USE - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08. rev. 7/14.08 LEGAL DESCRlPTION Property located in Collier, FL The West one-half(W Yz) of the Northwest one-quarter (NW Y..) of the Southeast one- quarter (SE Y..) of the Southeast one-quarter (SE Y..) of Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County Florida, also known as Tract No. 20, Enchanted Acres, less the South 30 feet for road right-of-way purposes. AND BEING the same property conveyed to Renda Broadcasting Corporation, a Pennsylvania corporation from Sterling Communication Corporation, a Florida corporation by Warranty Deed dated January 13, 1999 and recorded January 20, 1999 in Deed Book 2503, Page 1624. Tax Parcel No. 00405160008 EXHIBIT I G Metes & Bounds Description: CONDiTIONAL liSE REGUJE$T DI;TAiL TVDe of Conditional Use: This application is requesting a conditional use allowed per LDC Section 2.04.03 of the E zoning district for installation of broadcastina eauioment and antenna to existina tower (type of use). Present Use of the Property: Existing communication tower. EVALU> , ,,~rlf'EBIA;' '>e ATllOI ~,JrH"'", Evaluation Criteria: Provide a narrative statement describing this request for conditional use. See Exhibit "D", attached. NOTE: Pursuant to Section 10.08.00. of the Collier County Land Development Code, staff's recommendation to the Planning Commission and the Planning Commission's recommendation to the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be based upon a finding that the granting of the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and that the specific requirements governing the individual conditional use, If any, have been met, and that further, satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable. Please provide detailed response to each of the criterion listed below. Specify how and why the request Is consistent with each. (Attach additional pages as may be necessary). a. Describe how the project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan (include inlormation on how the request is consistent with the applicable section or portions of the future land use element): b. Describe the existing or planned means of ingress and egress to the property and proposed structure thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: c. Describe the effect the conditional use will have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic impact and odor: d. Describe the site's and the proposed use's compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district: APPliCATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL U5E - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/t2/08. rev. 7//4.08 e. Please provide any additional information which you may feel is relevant to this request. Deed Restrictions: The County is legaily precluded from enforcing deed restrictions, however, many communities have adopted such restrictions. You may wish to contact the civic or property owners association in the area for which this use is being requested in order to ascertain whether or not the request is affected by existing deed restrictions. Previous land use Detitions on the sublect DroDertv: To your knowledge, has a public hearing been held on this property within the last year? If so, what was the nature of that hearing? No. OfflclallnterDretatlons or Zonlna Verifications: To your knowledge, has there been an . official interpretation or zoning verification rendered on this property within the last year? ~ Yes 0 No If so, please provide copies. See Exhibit" E", attached. Additional Submittal reaulrements: In addition to this completed application, the foilowing must be submitted in order for your application to be deemed sufficient, unless otherwise waived during the pre-application meeting. a. A copy of the pre-application meeting notes; See Exhibit" F", attached. b. Twenty (20) copies of a 24" x 36" conceptual site plan [and one reduced 8Y2" x 11" copy of site plan], drawn to a maximum scale of 1 inch equals 400 feet, depicting the foilowing [Additional copies of the plan may be requested upon completion of staff evaluation for distribution to the Board and various advisory boards such as the Environmental Advisory Board (EAB), or CCPC]; · all existing and proposed structures and the dimensions thereof, · provisions for existing and/or proposed ingress and egress (including pedestrian ingress and egress to the site and the structure(s) on site), · all existing and/or proposed parking and loading areas [include matrix indicating required and provided parking and loading, including required parking for the disabled], · locations of solid waste (refuse) containers and service function areas, · required yards, open space and preserve areas, · proposed locations for utilities (as weil as location of existing utility services to the site), · proposed and/or existing landscaping and buffering as may be required by the County, · location of ail signs and lighting including a narrative statement as to the type, character, and dimensions (such as height, area, etc.); APPLlCA nON FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL U5E - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08. rev. 7/14.08 c. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), as required by Section 3.8. of the Land Development Code (LDC). Not required. d. Whether or not an EIS is required, two copies of a recent aerial photograph, (taken within the previous twelve months), minimum scale of one inch equals 400 feet, shall be submitted. Said aerial shall identify plant and/or wildlife habitats and their boundaries. Such identification shall be consistent with Florida Department of Transportation Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System. See Exhibit "G", attached. e. Statement of utility provisions (with all required attachments and sketches); See Exhibit "H", attached. f. A Traffic Impact Statement (TIS), unless waived at the pre-application meeting; Not required. g. A historical and archeological surveyor waiver application if property is located within an area of historical or archaeological probability (as identified at pre-application meeting); Not required. h. Any additional requirements as may be applicable to specific conditional uses and Identified during the pre-application meeting, including but not limited to any required state or federal permits. BE ADVISED THAT SECTION 10.03.05.B.3 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIRES AN APPLICANT TO REMOVE THEIR PUBLIC HEARING SIGN (S) AFTER FINAL ACTION IS TAKEN BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. BASED ON THE BOARD'S FINAL ACTION ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE REMOVE ALL PUBLIC HEARING ADVERTISING SIGN(S) IMMEDIATELY. '"',"'''''mi';;'''>C'''jf'VO, ...~lOJ!~W~"iMl& " ~tb"':";'~~~:!f~~if0ttli-.,;:~~~t;I;~r;:~t,~:tr~~~~'\!_IIW.k,r., ',;, Within 30 days of adoption of the Ordinance, the owner or developer (specify name) at its expense shall record In the Public Records of Collier County a Memorandum of Understanding of Developer Commitments or Notice of Developer Commitments that contains the legal description of the property that Is the subject of the land use petition and contains each and every commitment of the owner or developer specified in the Ordinance. The Memorandum or Notice shall be in form acceptable to the County and shall comply with the recording requirements of Chapter 695, FS. A recorded copy of the Memorandum or Notice shall be provided to the assigned Principal Planner, Collier County Zoning Department, within 15 days of recording of said Memorandum or Notice. APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARtNG FOR CONomONAL USE - 4/14/03, rev S/20/200S, rev 2/12/0B, rev. 7/14.0B Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Existing Address) 5864 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Proposed Address) Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Exhibit D Narrative Statement The Applicant seeks approval of a conditional use request to permit the co-location of broadcast equipment on an existing wireless tower located at 5860 Crews Road (existing address), in Collier County, Florida (the "Project"). The Project will essentially entail the addition of cellular antenna and broadcast equipment to an already existing, functioning tower and as such will require only minor alterations, at best, to the site as it presently exists. There will be no additional employees stationed at or accessing the site due to the installation, and no additional building square footage will be associated with the Project. a. The Project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC) and Growth Management Plan. The Project is consistent with the County's desire to "maximize the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites," as set forth in Section 5.05.09(A) of the LDC. The essential service provider for the Project is the U.S. Department of Justice, FBI, an agency of the Federal Government, in compliance with Section 5.05.09(G)(3) of the LDC. The Project is consistent with the LDC provisions goveming the standards for design, vegetation screening, construction and facilities setting for communications towers. b. Means of ingress and egress to the Property and proposed structure; automotive and pedestrian safety; traffic flow and control; access in case of fire or catastrophe. The Property features an existing private access road from Crews Road as a means of ingress and egress to the Property for maintenance vehicles and in the event of fIre or catastrophe. There are existing parking spaces on the Property for maintenance vehicles. As the facility is an un-manned site, no alterations to the existing parking or to the existing means of ingress and egress on the Property are required. Pedestrians and the general public will not have access to the site. c. The Project will have a minimal effect on neighboring properties with regard to noise, glare, economic impact and odor. The Project involves the installation of an additional antenna to an already existing communication tower and will require the addition of an enclosed generator. Notwithstanding, the Project will have only a minimal effect, if any, with regard to noise and glare to neighboring properties given (i) the tower already exists and (ii) the Project involves only the addition of equipment to the existing tower. The Proj ect will have no known effect on neighboring properties with regard to odor or economic impact. d. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district. The compatibility of the site with adjacent properties will not be affected by the co-location of broadcast equipment on the existing communications tower. Given (i) the tower already exists and (ii) the Project involves only the addition of equipment to the existing tower, the existing compatibility of the site with adjacent properties and other properties in the district will not be disturbed. TPA:639135:! (i) STATEMENT OF UTILITY PROVISIONS FOR CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST APPLICANT INFOFtMATI9N ". NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) MEDIAFLO USA., INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION ADDRESS 5775 MOREHOUSE DRIVE CITY SAN DIEGO STATE CA ZIP 92121 TELEPHONE # (858) 651-3244 CEll # FAX # E-MAil ADDRESS: ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY (IF AVAilABLE): 5860 Crews Rd. (existing address), 5864 Crews Rd. (proposed address) . . t'!!A. oesco dfltf' LE"l. L .." PIF ..N SectionfTownship/Range 08/50/26 Lot: Block: Subdivision: a1k/a Tract 20, Enchanted Acres Plat Book Page #: Property I.D.#: 00405160008 Metes & Bounds Description: I TYpijl OF S.I;WA~E.OfS~qlA.1", :rQ.l[Ji\PllflVIQ:G~ (Check applicable system): a. COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM D b. CITY UTILITY SYSTEM D c. FRANCHISED UTILITY SYSTEM D PROVIDE NAME d. PACKAGE TREATMENT PLANT D (GPD capacity) e. SEPTIC SYSTEM D fYPEciFWATER SERVICeT613ePROVIDED a. COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM D b. CITY UTILITY SYSTEM D c. FRANCHISED UTILITY SYSTEM D PROVIDE NAME d. PRIVATE SYSTEM (WELL) D TOTAL POf:)UlATIONTQ Bl;Sl;RVE:D: APPLlCA TlON FOR PU8L1C HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL U5E - 4/14/03. rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 p!.....R:ANO:i.\IIIN(lI~'9Jm'Y'91,..'iNJljs~ .A. . .~...,....n.......,. .............""'"',,.. .... ... A. WATER-PEAK AVERAGE DAilY B. SEWER-PEAK AVERAGE DAilY IF PROPOSING TO BE CONNECTED TO COLLIER COUNTY REGIONAL WATER SYSTEM, PLEASE PROVIDE THE DATE SERVICE IS EXPECTED TO BE REQUIRED Not applicable. NAFlaATlvESTATEMEN,..: Provide a brief and concise narrative statement and schematic drawing of sewage treatment process to be used as well as a specific statement regarding the method of affluent and sludge disposal. If percolation ponds are to be used, then percolation data and soil involved shall be provided from tests prepared and certified by a professional engineer. C~I...",uaJt$~~IilN~>~"l1"J~'iI~"ll.tllfi!~[.~t_N:f;llf the project is located within the services boundaries of Collier County's utility service system, written notarized statement shall be provided agreeing to dedicate to Collier County Utilities the water distribution and sewage collection facilities within the project area upon completion of the construction of these facilities in accordance with all applicable County ordinances in effect at the at time. This statement shall also include an agreement that the applicable system development charges and connection fees will be paid to the County Utilities Division prior to the issuance of building permits by the County. If applicable, the statement shall contain shall contain an agreement to dedicate the appropriate utility easements for serving the water and sewer systems. $'ltj]ttIMt;t"I""ElJI~.~.~.'ji~'JlI!lJt;k"~~,t;SiA8Nm~~I!!I"lIlSi.~:~!ftl~f>:i'i~~Q'"'"'r;ll;;Unless waived .. ....~~~~.".....I!:Il:lI'W!!!_J!l,..""..",'!iJ_.I!!il~~I4'~li!l'n~."'iWI!!ml1ll!i.~"'"',1~!im.. 'i'. or otherwise provided for at the pre-application meeting, if the project is to receive sewer or potable water services from any provider other than the County, a statement from that provider indicating that there is adequate capacity to serve the project shall be provided. APPLlCA TION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL USE - 4/14/03, rev S/20/200S, rev 2/ 12/08, rev. 7/14.08 COLLffiR COUNTY GOVERNMENT April 3, 2008 Community Development and Environmental Services Division Department of Zoning and Land Development Review 2800 North Horseshoe Drive' Naples, Florida 341 04 Margaret Smith MediaFLO USA c/o Redna Broadcasting 2 Larkspur Ct Greenfield, NY 12833 RE: Zoning Verification Letter ZLTR-2007-AR-12825, zoning verification for property addressed as 5860 Crews Road, legally described as the West Y, of Northwest y. of Southeast Y. of Southeast Y. Less the South 30-foot right-of-way, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. Property ID No: 00405160008 Dear Ms. Smith: In your application dated January 23, 2008 you request a zoning determination regarding the two existing communication towers and your desire to co-locate antennas on the tower that was to be dismantled on the subject property. The zoning for the subject property is Estates with an approved conditional use (Resolution 93-219). As provided below, an expansion of the original approved conditional use cannot be granted; furthermore, the tower designated to be dismantled remains and must be removed in order to comply with the terms of approval of the original conditional use. The conditional use, referenced above, was approved on May 25, 1993 for the subject property to allow the replacement of the existing 438-foot guyed communications tower and accessory structures with a 430-foot guyed communications tower and a new 2,400 square foot building. Site Development Plan (SDP) 93-62 was approved July 23, 1993 showing the new 430-fuot guyed communications tower and accessory building. An amendment to SDP 93-62 was approved July 19, 1999, proposing the replacement of the existing 430-foot guyed communications tower with a stronger 394-foot communications tower. Several insubstantial changes to SDP 93-62 have been approved to add generators or co-locate antennas on onto an existing tower on the site. Your application states you would like to co-locate antennas 011 the tower that was to be dismantled. A current aerial shows two towers existing on the subject property. The approved conditional use provided for the replacement of an existing communications tower; not an expansion of use by adding an additional tower. Section 10.08.00, of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC), provides for conditional use procedures and requires any additional uses or expansion of permitted uses not shown on the conceptual site development plan or otherwise specifically provided for in the c o ~ Phone (239) 403-2400 I EXHIBIT E Ie o U H ,. or (239) 213-2913 www.colliergov.net conditional use application to undergo submittal, review and approval of a new conditional use application. LDC Section 5.05.09.G states no new tower of any height shall be pennitted in the Estates zoning district except for essential services listed in subsection 5.05.09.G.3, thereby prohibiting the expansion of the approved conditional use. Please be advised that the infonnation presented in this verification letter is based on the Land Development Code and/or Growth Management Plan in effect as of this date. It is possible that subsequent amendment(s) to either of these documents could affect the validity of this verification letter. It is also possible that development of the subject property could be affected by other issues not addressed in this letter, such as, but not limited to, concurrency related to the provision of adequate public facilities, enviromnental impact, and other requirements of the Collier County Land Development Code or related ordinances. Should you require further infonnation please do not hesitate to call me at (239) 252- 5748. Researched and prepared by: Reviewed by: =--= ss Goc aur, Planning Manager Department of Zoning and Land Development Review hristine Willoughby, PI er Department of Zoning and Land Development Review Cc: Correspondence File, ZLTR-2008-AR-12825 Mike Sawyer, Senior Planner Peggy Jarrell, Addressing Section &;;'^IIIJ.l11 j F ." . OLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT EPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPME WW.COLLlERGOV.NET o'Jl68 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES. FLORIDA 34104 (239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643. (i) CONDITIONAL USE PETITION PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Date: t;/2(p NS Time: ;:3D Planner: ::J D ~SS I ( ?~;loO#m;::;;r-h~ UL. Project Addr/Localion: _ __~ Applicant Name: Mr .f.n..;,+t..../I4~ Phone:--0F/8) 413 ---(Odj 0 Project Name: Firm: Current Zoning: ~ ~~ @nl~l-h~ Owner Name: Owner Address: Phone: Meeting Attendees: (attach Sign In Sheet) NOTES: CbhAft,)u,..f}"f 'p!R.~n'tJ... - ~"JeJ. /J f\ .{J...{ r'1thl, ~,~ NJ '"1 )$C1eS. ?v b(~~ &1' \,~g-" ~~"ld~~~g ~f.-\ft,~~itJOn W'_.J == ~,i;:f,,,,, ~~,....- ,,,,,,or "'-<'77"'-~"'T"" "'4' ^"" 4PDlTtD",,""'--- ~1 P c;e~v,.'T"l'>,Q..'" A-l1:.€- 'PJ2.~'j::OSG't:> k<;' ?=l~ 01"- T-l/ls ~"''l:>IT/&rv~ us.e.. . - 1-15+1;& SII;w;S .fl/J/,(;i;y Wlltl Fv(()S 0# ;<JiI}'(ocMII.PtJ w"ot1A:ck~~ (J( (w.) /lA/lJ J'1f:, Cl"I',e~T rot Y~vl-<r;{S'. - wlif(M!J .)1/IlIJ!JI(flfW/J( AIHEI?4/ W/WrOA/ - OJ.:"JI (fi'A"ili 1'/1IiJIi/t-W.:: A/lliJ9 of1/ C() ..J'1I5 jJlA,v. (Io/., (} F tilt; F}-IJ'fW(/lAtll/J( II!iC/;rAft'u/V O,N-J"/+J:) J.os..G7 lJC. CONDITIONAL USE (CU) APPLICATION SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST " THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. # OF_ NOT REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED , 20 X 20 ~ 1 )c;- 1 20 20 2 1 2 1 5 1 7 3 4 4 1 2 EDC "Fast Track" must submIt approved copy of offldal application Affordable Housing "Expedited" must submIt copy of signed CertIficate of A re..ment. PLANNER MARK IF NEEDED TO BE ROUTED TO REVIEWERS BELOW: C t h Id b f d d t th PI I t th d d t 2 ommen s S ou e orwar e 0 e anner pr or 0 e ue ae SCHOOL DISTRICT (J) "ARKS & REC - Murda Smith (I) SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS (1) UTILITIES ENGINEERING - Zamira Deltoro (1) COMMUNITY PLANNING BAYSHORE/GATEWAY TRIANGLE COORDINATOR - Linda Bedlelyon (I) REDEVELOPMENT Executive Director (I) Communications Towers Onl : MOSQUITO CONTROL NAPLES AIRPORT AUTHORITY 2 FEES: . ~ ~ Pre-application Fee $500.00 (Applications submiHed 9 manths or more after the date 01 the last pre-opp meeting shall not be credited towards application lees and a new pre- application meeting will be required.) $4,000.00 $150.00 $300.00 $760.00 $363.00 Application Fee / $1500 if flied in conjunction with a rezone petition Fire Code Review Comprehensive Planning Consistency Review Estimated lega I Advertising Fee - eepc Meeting Estimated legal Advertising Fee - Bee Meeting (any over- or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Dally News). $2,500.00 EIS Review, If required JII/A $1000.00 Listed or Protected Species survey review fee (when an EIS Is not required) Transportation Fees, If required, 0 o $500.00 Methodology Review Fee, If required ^ \ I ^ - ;P o $750.00 Minor Study Review Fee, If required I V rr o $1,500.00 Malar Study Review Fee, If required OTHER REQUIREMENTS: o o o n Applicanf / Agenl Slgnalure Dale 3 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS LDC 10.03.05 F. Applicant must conduct at least one Neighborhood Informational Meeting (NIM) after initial stoff review and comment on the application and before the Public Hearing is scheduled with the Planning Commission. Written notice of the meeting sholl be sent to 011 property owners who ore required to receive legal notification from the County pursuant to Sec:tlon 1 0.03.05.8.8. Notification sholl also be sent to property owners, condominium and civic associations whose members ore Impac:ted by the proposed land use change and who hove fonnally requested the County to be notified. A copy of the list of 011 parties noticed, and the dote, time, and location of the meeting, must be furnished to the Zoning Deportment and the Office of the 8aard of County Commissioners no less than ten (10) days prior to the scheduled dote of the NIM. The applicant must make arrangements for the location of the meeting. The location must be reasonably convenient to those property owners who ore required to receive notice and the facilities must be of sufficient size to accommodate expec:ted oftendance. The applicant must place on advertisement of the meeting In that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear stating the purpose, location, time of the meeting and legible site location mop of the property for which the zoning change Is being requested. The display advertisement must be one-fourth page, In type no smaller than 1 2 point and must be placed within 0 newspaper of general circulation in the County at least seven (7) days prior to, but no sooner than five (5) days before, the NIM. The Collier County stoff planner assigned to the projec:t must attend the NIM and sholl serve os the facilitator of the meeting; however, the applicant is expec:ted to make 0 presentation of how It intends to develop the subject property. The applicant Is required to audio or video tope the proceedings of the meeting and provide 0 copy to the Zoning Deportment. As a result of mandated meetings with the public, ony commitments mode by the applicant sholl be reduced to writing and mode 0 port of the record of the proceedings provided to the Zoning Deportment. These written commitments will be mode a part of the stoff report of the County's review and approval bodies and mode 0 port of the consideration for Inclusion In the conditions of approval. -1'./~ ~ ~~ o.rf&'~~ . 4 II) 18 , Iii: 0 Q <( ... ~ w ~ Z I. iii ~ i w :e .~ f1i II. 0 ~ ilQ e-, w - J. ~ ~ C Gl Z l\) Q E w a. 1i ~ I , 0 ~ ~ c :; Gl 0 a. Q 2' i "tI Gl C :: l:l '0 ... J u o1S @) l:ll III C III .".. !1 'c 0 a. . 0 E w J N "tI 0 ~ - '> I~ 0 l:l - "tI C C ~ Gl .c .. E .2- I~~ ~ 1: in ~ l:l ~ 0 a. III Gl 2! ~ Q "tI Z ~ . "tI 5 ~ III <( III 0 - U N :: '0 ~ "tI ~ '> w i:i l:l " " Q 'S: I I!! c .c .... 0 0 0 ... M '0 C'l ~ ria ;t IU :I: W Ul Z It) Z C'l w ~ <( t: :e z w Gl (!) :e ... .a <( ~ Q. <( Q E z " z ;) 0 w Z ::; ti z G 0 W (!) Gl ~ .., in c 0 0 ::> 0: \I) .c Sl llo. <( Q. i!i -.. ~~-'--~.'----,-------------,.-,~,-_:,:"._--_.- .....,.")..\. ... It " "......... '. I ct> (/)l ::>\ , 0' ..JI IL' ..' -3 '0' 4>' :;;: . I p Ii! ill <(~ CJ)4. ll. :)2 o OU ...J2 U-2 ca~ .- J -04. (1)6 :E~ I I , 1 ~ I' > I~ mi. Il~ ~ liE ::5 - Gl , 3 l ! I. . ii Ii e Hi - ~ I i !t~~ I. · ~th~ .- ~ ~ia~l~ r ~ i! 8 Ii ~ q 1 ; I B ,I ! lap · nn;lil l! j j III j 1"li 'I g~'i sl!i I!II, · Iii 2 % '~!5;1'!il: ; ~ ! ;'leillllll! ~ ~ ! I;~':l ~ I! 3 I 1~I!il II!I'! ~ 'f 1.1 I a. ~ . N ~ C1~ o e:::~ /-' '<t -<lL.lJ1"l a.. .~-' ::;:lJ1wlL. -<We::: I- -' U . ,a.. lJ1 lJ1-<ow I-ZlO-' lL. tOo.. ::;: U")~ II ... ~~.ft\: d 11111, l~"': ; .~ lC'jt ~Il. I 'I ,.~, ',... II dill. .... - "'J~' -,,1,1, ,....".... ~. ,,' ,"1111 HUH, ...', ,.' I.g. i ~ =;- ~ i ',."...".". . -D. ......._., k. r- ... " :: ~ o , ~~V1~~ ll.. .~ .cs 2::]ct1o ':!~O::~::l ~~~~8 % % , o u ,. ~ t:i~ I ~~.... !- I V1~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ .~ ... I .! ~ Idl. ~ i III :3 I!lll! ~ ~ I ! II: I' .- II i 1<1 ;; liiu'li" . 8 5~ ~i. n i ~ II i!,j - ! ' 0 , , I I:I;! . -Iii ~ "I 1111" ~" ~~, I 0.. > ~. ! II" ~ ! H ~ ~ · i! ~ hn e ~ g h illl" ~ d,ll i ~ ~ ~ i h ~.! " g ~ . I! ~ i i IiI! H I! d Illt'l 50 liil!lln' I '" R Z i I~ I ,,'II I! ~H HI! I! gg i I 1 ~ \ i- pU'S I" I~ " ~ ~ rS "" Cl.. S ! et Blvd . Santa Barbara 81v~ t:r:. <I) f; ~ ........"iI "tJ .s~ '" '. i, CI;J Q..~ W . t' :~ :"'1;1) g. C I, (,J (,):;1 ~ I Founty, Barn Rd <3 '" " Glen Eagle :: AeM sliClI..!;-: Kings Lake Blvd ii ~ ' ~~ood Blvd - .._ _.__ ______n....__._.~.._____.___n..._. ._____ I ~ I i I 8 I i I i ~ ! II ' 5 II 9 ~ III! ;, I II ~I ; ,~ 'I' . It! ,I' ~!!I ~ 11:1 Ill; lik. I', d! ~ '" ~ u o E E ~ J:: ]I ~ ~ ~ 00 ..., ~ :i: ij <I) & ~ Ji "t:l = . . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . .~ . ~ ~ ..JQ a,,~ ~ j h PAIS !!,i!MBH ~ ~ 1-- c(> cnl ::Jl . 0' ..JI u.1 ..g ._, 'C' ..i :::iE, :c ~ I~ ~" I~ ~ ~IE :5 "! III N 5 . i ',I,) i II .~: ~,~..':>". II ; [)ty.,N',-lIf 'I"!i(.~'~:ll I 111"'~'d~ :\~/ dl, mml"'~~~~"/ I~! '" ,.' ~ c ...",,--; ,..,,,,..,., =1' j 'i' ! c( I:; _ . z ;; ~ :s ..I:;:II1;ij: Q. ~vi..~ ~ ~ i:!~~~~ W. ~ 0~)-<o ~- c;: ~%O : > z w , > o 0 o I . . i I I t i!1 !, 1'1 ! ,I', ~I I I I ! ,I, I, II I, , lit: h. l!" ~ \ _\~' ___ "''' :'y' ~II il H _ ~\)L "-.:" '~ '000'",'--- -_-_=-C.~_~-_o -~~- I _~ "-___ ___ o./' I ......... I I -, J : I : 1 : I !i I · , I ' J1-.Co< , ! ': ~ ~ : I Pi I! I a ! i l Ii dflld J'ld ib~ ~II~' "I' , I I i I' " nlllJ I H~HI I ~ I i I I I . I , I S I , I ! , Ir-=J FI , ' , v iii" 51 i ~ ! "v Ii I I ~ , , ~ ~ ~ II 'I ~. I I I I ;~ I .~ iHili , ~ i e!;1 i li~lt, !~ !ig~;~ f ~ !\ / ,'r-~----.--~----.-L'~c~- -~'~~/l2 /,/ ~ ,.~. .G-~ ~ 'rt ! ',,-- . "--,,X::' . ~\~ ~i I "--. ! ,/ ',,-- r---- h_... II ,,--, / ' : \1 /. . "-- - / ' r: I . \-i-. ~ I. 1 ~. . ! 1 . 1\ ~ I~~,~, 'i. I ~ l II ~""~": lfi--i-\.-jjl ~ rrlll~l~ . . -/ '" r ?- =i- - -I ~""T~*''- I Ii Ii! ~) i [ ir LJ: I I L. , I i [ I 'I ' I j I I I ' Iii Iii ~1"'~''''''''''~ j III I' [ ! [i 0 U IJ V I ,I, I , . L'--~'_,_,--.J I '! [~ [__J uJ ~-J \ I L..__.__..___..----'. I i ! -'---'~7 '--'-'--'-' i 1-' i! I ;1 !~ ~"M ~ ~t III ~ . -- z ;; , llt~lt~ ~ ~ I :. ."'.~ 1::: or;- ~~:i~~ I;i < l~>-~o ~~ ti, !:ZQ::zo > ~ o o ;; a l ! ! . . iil .."" -. I 1 ~ I) Ij, )l: ~f ~ . ;;;1:: /:';':Ji . [OIl I 'v Ii --"-... ---._--,.,._--~----_.~------~._--_._- ct: u), ::ll . O' -J' 11..' tag ._, 'tl' ..~ :!:, ......"....,',."",'" , -- --- ------.- -----.------------------..--.-------------..---____n.___. _. _'__ :z:. ! n ~ il~ ~" I~ !~r iii " w . % :: ~ :5 ~~VI~~ ~ 0.. "'I _,' lL .~.~ J: ~ .... ::I~Qtlo i~. ;:!:A:'~A:':f _ ~ <( J, o<>-~8 ~ t:Z~ ~ ::I g : u , ~ , ", ~ Id';' I. l~.b. 0" e "~i;; .' '. 0" e ~ " - i /' ./ ~. ---- y "'- ~ ~ . ~.~ I: -, , . . 1,lll'idll! 11.li!lIiqdl iI':; iii I ! ~! l! !! ~! ~ l! dlll'il ~!il, ""...- .....-.. '.____.."m.....__._.___... ..__.a'__________. /--- ---- --~-- ---.-.----- ,""""""'. _u_ -- ,.-' <I'tJ ce' :z: " ~ , II .'~ ,,' ....~Q/It....'~ d I Ull ~ 0 ~ ~i ~.' 0 '. J ~ ::ll 111111 . '.. l;;> J.. v I - ~ i . 'ji .,: ~~':.lll :: !i % O' ~ ! 'I Ii I ~LtVl ~ > ...., r;~ ': - : 'II . i u.' fA 1111. . ,"......... . . .~ 5 ~ 5% M ..2 ~;;- \ ~ '. "Ql-.'" I !~fi1 ~ . 3~ . '-' ~ !I^ ~ 8' ! <( 'tI. S ' - . mm, ....~~. ill ~~~ 0 Gll iil u 0 ",(jJ,< .... 'j ')'" ' t ~ ~ ::!!. \;.,..., "I' ,.\,.,. . c > % ~ III """" , -,.""...." ,'rI', ..~a 0 ~ u /1 \T .-/ - '[I // I // I 1\\ .-/ I y I ] \ I \ 1 \ I \ \ ) \ I , '- ) \-....., I \ \ I I , I ] I ] I > Ii I I I I I >-'-'-'--i o I I I , 1 I d ~ II Jjl i I I I ~~!!~~~ll 11,':1 ~ 1111111 ; . !ll ~ !il! ~ ~ ~I~i I ~ .1 ~ ~ ~tb~ .' ~'!~I~ f <l:' enl ::II , O' ..J. u.' ca' .-j 'tl< Gl' ~: Ii""-',.;;;"",, ..0-.; -------~--~~-----. is , !ii; i' > !~ ~'" I!~ tl ~!' :s -! III ! . . III .1""""""'" ------- --------__.___..__ __U_"____ " a l ! " illll, 'I 'I! I 11111 IBml --~j-i<,iSiiJ"'-O;~O~.------ ''''NlUft ~~'''''l ~l JJ- ..... ('J ~",,"J1"'" ''''~l'''''' .,..,,,.., III .,ll .Ollr (1) ----<;;;;.;m;,.--;Oi;.;,:;;i;;;,;-":;.;",.,,, o,"j,-:.Ofr (i"i ''''''''''''''9.''''"'01,''_,'<;(11 ..."ll....."']fO'.ll><1~~.oQOL J)-.o.t(]l 1'0"'<),,,, ,"ooo..ftO lid I ;=~~__:=:1:__:~~:~' _o~_:.~~- ......,,~. ~"".'., OL .0".,,, 1 I; . z <; " . .!c~V1~~ 1 z ! 0. ...,. .~ ~g 't ~~~~~ i .~ ~~)-~8 ~~ 8 <I: t;;!:~Z w , > z " 0 U WlKl1Iff.l>ln_JD_ --,~ , , I ! :o~,- i>iOiii"'iWi""",s:...Ii"'l" J ~ ~ n .,', ~ . '~h'! ~, o ~~..s!~ a; ~ .'1'1' · ,! " . i ! i j , ~ ~ , . !! ~. I C:(, Ctll ::>1 . 0" -I, 11..' ..8 -, 'C< c>' :e: . ~ ' z ~ ~ ~ ~ ~:: ~ ~ iH_~ ~ ~ z i I. · r~,J ~ ~-~---- ~._--- :c 0 ~ I' ~ 08 I~! lot '0' C.l ,l- ::s -. III ! I- ~~ . :~ lllg~ H .m, ~ ~ ~[ ~ ,.1. I ~B" o ". ~. o~.o =>. .... Q ~ .,.~ ~ ~ ~~~~! ~ g ~ i !~!_g .~ i < td nlli ~Ihh ~h..1 ~< ~~ . i ~ _l ! I I ~ . nUn ! ~ II I < . I , I I i~ , ~~ ~ I ~ .~,. ~ ~~a~ ~~ .. i ~!;lii ~ ~ h ! ....~.. \.r. I i'~"""" · , l ! ""I ":"~\~~ 1'1 d,' ,'o.:~ i..:ill 1111 ~". ~3.1' ~ . ,1 . if Hi Ii'" '. .:~ ........ I:I! 'f, . " ....."... -.1' '''---1 . . ~ r: ~H~ , ~ ~d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~V1lij:! L .oItl .< 'l:lcVlg ~[ra:~::l J,o()-o(o t:z~%O , Z o o u I . . , i ' ! i o "~ '. ^~. ~ ~ i~~l'h, 10. ~! .' I ~~gi;g f 'v Ii II i II ! ,i ~ II ili ,I I ;1 hI Ii ! !~ p: Iii I 'i ! Ir ji ! i' !" Ii' 'i' !i ill I hi I 'I ~ ~lnd!1 Hi ! '": ! ~ ---/ Ii I l i ! I; ; 'I II if If I <\ Ill' ::ll . 0" -I, u..' ..8 .-. 'C. Oll :!;. :z: 0 ~ II > !~ rnJ.. I!~ l:f'r- :5 ! III · 3 l ! ..... . , . r------_._._._n...____.........___..___ ..... ~\..~J 't'-t '. .,' ';> ...........0 r-=--------- I I I i . i e i . di 0"0-'1 ~ z ~ ~ - z . - , 1~Vl~~ z i ~ ~ ... &:I,. ..-s .jj 9 ~~~g~ i 5 i J,~>-~8 ~ < t ~z > , z ~ , ~ 0 ~ u , i i . j ; . a . . I' I I I III I ! , , , " ! ! ::: ~d i I II '1'1 I' II I /1/ I Ii. t!i I! , J II II ill m m r}1-1-fn I ! ! II ! I I J~.... .r' iil I ,I ! , ! ~ I e~:~ ! . ilzl~! ;~ ~'l'l" ." , 0 ., e ~ ~ " Conditional Use Petition Applicant: Media FLO, USA 5860 Crews Road Collier County, Florida Index of Application and Required Exhibits/Components Item No. Description I. Cover Letter Briefly Explaining the Project 2. Application and Exhibits A-F: Ex. A: List of Surrounding Registered HOAs/Master Associations Ex. B: Corporate Officer List for Renda Broadcasting Corp. Ex. C: Legal Description for Property Ex. D: Narrative Statement Ex. E: Zoning Verification Letter from Collier County dated April 3, 2008 Ex. F: Pre-Application meeting notes 3. Addressing Checklist Signed by Addressing - Ex. I 4. Copies of Warranty Deed(s) - Ex. J j. Completed Owner / Agent Affidavits 6. Aerial Photographs Showing FLUCCS Codes, Legend, and Project Boundary Engineer - Ex. G 7. Statement of Utility Provisions ~ Ex. H 8. Traffic Impact Statement (TIS) (e-mail confirmation of waiver attached and referenced in justification statement) 9. Electronic Copy of All Documents and Plans (CD ROM or Diskette) 10. Boundary Survey II. Listed Species Survey 12. Wetlands Designation 13. Conceptual Site Plan 24"x36' plus (one 8 Y, x II copy) Engineer TP A:656523: I TPA:667IJ8:1 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation COVER LETTER (20 COPIES ATTACHED) IIII Ruden ~I McClosky 401 EAST JACKSON STREET SUITE 2700 TAMPA, FLORIDA 33602 (813) 314-6709 FAX: (8l3) 314-6809 KIMBERL Y.MADISON@RUDEN.COM December 16, 2008 John David Moss, Principal Planner Collier County Zoning & Land Development Review 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Re: Application for Conditional Use - Collier County (the "Application") 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (the "Property") Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Our File No. 60479-0001 Dear John David: The Applicant seeks approval of its Application for Conditional Use to permit the co- location of broadcast equipment on an existing wireless tower located at 5860 Crews Road, in Collier County, Florida (the "Project"). The Project will essentially entail the addition of a cellular antenna and broadcast equipment to an already existing, functioning tower and as such will require only minor alterations, at best, to the site as it presently exists. There will be no additional employees stationed at or accessing the site due to the installation, and no additional building square footage will be associated with the Project. Applicant's request is consistent with the County's desire to "maximize the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites," as set forih in Section 5.05.09(A) of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). The Project is consistent with LDC provisions governing the standards for design, vegetation screening, construction and facilities setting for communications towers. In connection with the above-referenced Application, and on behalf of the Applicant, MediaFLO USA, Inc., enclosed please find the following documentation for your review and consideration: 1. Twenty (20) copies of the signed Application for Conditional Use; 2. One (1) check for the Application Fee, in the amount of$7,073.00; 3. One (I) original, signed and notarized Agent Affidavit; TPA:66399n BOCA RATON. CARACAS' FT. LAUDERDALE . MIA~I . NAPlES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE. SARASOT^ . ST. PETERSBURG' TAllAHASSEE. TAMPA' WEST PALM BEACH RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. John David Moss December 16, 2008 Page 2 4. One (1) original, signed and notarized Owner Affidavit; 5. One (I) copy of the Addressing Checklist signed by Addressing; 6. Twenty (20) copies of the Pre-Application Meeting Notes and Submittal Checklist; 7. Twenty (20) Conceptual Site Plans (24" x 36"), plus one (1) 8 y, x 11 copy; 8. Two (2) copies of the warranty deeds; 9. Five (5) copies of aerial photographs showing FLUCCS Codes, Legend, and project boundary; 10. Five (5) copies of the Listed Species Survey for the Property; II. Five (5) copies of the Wetlands Jurisdictional Determination for the Property; 12. One (1) copy of the Statement of Utility Provision; 13. One (1) CDROM containing an electronic copy of all documents and plans; and, 14. Two (2) signed and sealed Boundary Surveys. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you require additional copies of any of the above-referenced documents, or to address any questions regarding this Application. ;;~~u Kimberly J. Madison KJMlkcw Enclosures cc: Thomas Voltero, Esq. (w/o enclosures) TPA:6639971 BOCA RATON' CARACAS' FT.lAUDERDALE . MIAMI' NAPLES' ORLANDO' PORT 51. LUCIE . SARASOTA' ST. PETERSBURC, . TAIlAHA~~FF . T^\,.\P~ . WFq PAl ~\ RFA.H RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. DUVAL Be KLASNICK LLC OPERATING ACCOUNT 10 CEDAR STREET SUITE 17 WOBURN. MA 01801 2633 STONEHAM SAVINGS BA':fk 'J1,o~a....l!Io.llI5! .....-.... 53-7048-2113 Aug 29, 2008 PAY 10 THE ORDER OF Collier County Board of Commissioner $ 7,073.00 j I ! , J I 5 << ... Seven ThOl.lsand Seventy Three .................................... and 00/100 DOLLARS Zoning Filingf'ee; 070443 ~ E w. n ~_.'GflA1URE . .- (i MIO"'C:> ._-~ 5 2"l Wb"l711' TPk6671381 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation APPLICA TION (20 COPIESATTACHED) COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET (i) 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES. FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 PETITION NO (AR) PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER DATE PROCESSED ASSIGNED PLANNER To be completed by staff ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF t~~''J'1 '.", ",,,,,, . . '. - - '. ..". - ,.. -"'f""r':'i""'- ,.... ~ '~'.'" . .' ....-.. ',- ..- "'-' "." NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) MEDIAFLO USA, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION ADDRESS 5775 MOREHOUSE DRIVE CITY SAN DIEGO STATE CA ZIP 92121 TELEPHONE # (858) 651-3244 CELL # FAX # E-MAIL NAME OF AGENT JAMES J. PORTER, ESQ., AND KIMBERLY J. MADISON, ESQ. FIRM RUDEN, MCCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. ADDRESS 401 E. JACKSON ST., SUITE 2700 CITY TAMPA STATE FL ZIP 33602 TELEPHONE # (813) 222-6620 CELL # FAX # (813) 314.6920 E-MAIL ADDRESSJIM.PORTER@RUDEN.COM.KIMBERLY.MADISON@RUDEN.COM '.-''':~",.,,'-'' ~,.--,.. ,- . '" ,,,., ^ . 'c , ,';--r'.;".....' v- ~._ _ .-. .,-:-",:'"',, '_,,' :~::::_f:;,r>::---: ," >:: :_:-;;/;-~>('.};:::';,':':, __'::,,__- ':'\.;:'0; :'_ ;,',: :.;',V:' .- ,:~.:'4?,:--:':,_ _ ',_ '".,-: BE AW ARETHAT..qOUJEF{Q~UNJtJ1AS 4ge$YI$" F{~G'U4:T;iON$"GlJIJjE YOURSELF ccaRb GLY'4N'ENSU-'~ "'. "'y" ,A"'~lrl'f~r.'i""PLlANCE WITH " . .4, '. ..J~",~.P,.:.~~-m~l;'H't ~'I" '~~""'i . . THESE REGULATlq~$. ,~, ,,' ,., ':C\"'. ~ " ., """'.' "".,. ;jA}:::_,',;'j:_,.- _',' APPL/CA TION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL USE - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 Complete the fOllowing for all registered Assoclation(s) that could be affected by this petition. Provide additional sheets If necessary. Information can be found on the Board of County Commissioner's webslte at httD:/Iwww.collleraoY.net/lndex.asDx?oaoe=774 PLEASE SEE EXHIBIT nAn, ATTACHED NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF MASTER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF CIVIC ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP I: ','~'<'"c:,;')'r,": , ".,L~,,'\; 'fjrrm'OAT!lJlilBf:i" .....-l_!!)t'l"'(_: ~,~,-- ~II.., ,--,.-,,- ,,'~:. ~~,~:~. '; '.;'. "i,111\tl, :-. :"_' ~<. ,.,'_;,..;. :,,>:.~C::;~:f'r::,'.L, a. If the property Is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety, tenancy In common, or Joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership Interest as well as the percentage of such interest. (Use additional sheets if necessary). Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. APPLlCA T/ON FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL U5E - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/'2/08, rev. 7/'4.08 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Exhibit A List of Surroundinl! Rel!istered Homeowners and Master Associations 1. Falling Waters Beach Resort, Phase II Mr. Thomas Powers, President 6660 Beach Resort Drive, #6 Naples, FL 34114 2. Falling Waters Condominium Owners Association I Mr. Tom Lee, President 2202 Hidden Lake Drive, #7 Naples, FL 34112 3. Falling Waters Homeowners Association II Mr. Tim Boyle, President 2274 Hidden Lake Drive, #9 Naples, FL 34112 4. Magnolia Cove of Falling Waters Mr. Raymond C. McCabe, President 2338 Magnolia Lane, #2 Naples, FL 34112 5. Cascades of Falling Waters Condo Association Mr. George W. Baker, President 1972 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 6. Cascades at Falling Waters Mr. Robert Hinklin, President 2004 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 7. Falling Waters Beach Resort Master Association Mr. Donald K. Bassett, President 6580 Beach Resort Drive, #3 Naples, FL 34112 TPA:642048:! b. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and the percentage of stock owned by each. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership See attached listing of officers for Renda Broadcasting Corporation, attached as Exhibit "B". c. If the property Is In the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the percentage of interest. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable d. If the property Is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the general and/or limited partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. APPLICATION FOil PUBLIC HEARING FOil CONDITIONAL U5E - 4/14/03, rev 5/20;2005, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 Www.sunbiz.org - Department of State Page 1 of3 Home Contact Us E-Filing Services Document Searches Forms H Previous on List Next on List Return To List No Events No Name History (_Iin~ ~'~'_~'~___k"^.~~.'"_" ^"W"'"""'~~''''~'''___'''''''_;'''''_'<'''=_'_~___''';''=''._", "'~""'_'__"""""~'_,"'...._"_m'___~'.,'m _"~="."",",,,_,._~_~~_.^~.._.~.__,~..__~_~~~,_.,,~_'__,____,"_"_'.._~''''_ _,,,,,.,..,,,~_";~,,_;,~_~~~_~~~~ Detail by Entity Name Foreign Profit Corporation RENDA BROADCASTING CORPORATION Filing Information Document Number P30305 FEI Number 251259502 Date Filed 07/26/1990 State PA Status ACTIVE Principal Address 10915 K-NINE DR BONITA SPRINGS FL 34135 Changed 07/02/2007 Mailing Address 900 PARRISH ST 4TH FLOOR PITTSBURGH PA 15220 Changed 04/26/2000 Registered Agent Name & Address RENDA, ANTHONY F RENDA BROADCASTING CORP 10915 K-NINE DRIVE BONITA SPRINGS FL 34135-6802 US Name Changed: 07/02/2007 Address Changed: 07/0212007 Officer/Director Detail Name & Address Title DPT RENDA, ANTHONY MERRIMAN RD. SEWlCKLEY PA 15143 B D # EXHIBIT B t......._.II....,.....1..:...... "_...../...,,-:......+~/...,,...--1...+ ......../").........:,,__T"'\T:''T'T:'TT 0.:__ ...1",.., ......_t........._n'1f"\'1f\J:: OP:....,..., "............ 1'1nl'")()()Q wWw.sunbiz.org - Department of State Title DVS RENDA, CATHERINE R. MERRIMAN ROAD SEWlCKLEY PA 15143 Title V SERENA, ALAN C 3111 CHESTNUT RIDGE DR PITTSBURGH PA 15205 TitleDV KELLY, MARYANN 114 ALPINE CIR BELLE VERNON PA 15012 Title V REICH, JUDY 506 COVENTY TRAIL LANE MARYLAND HEIGHTS MO 63043 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date 2006 07/1712006 2007 07/02/2007 2008 02/28/2008 Document Images QZL2Jl!2POIL:l'\NNU_ALJ3f;PORTf.. \~,v.jma~';:';.~';;~': 1 07/02/2007 -- ANNUAL REPORT t \B......mA~......a. ...1 QZL11@QQ_:~l'>!'l_f'il,Ji'>lBJ;f'QRIl'.\li"""i_"'~'''-~' .. I Q;}/14/200!2::ANJ'I1IbJ,R.El'QI'l~r .....MiAwoim..,,~.~~. l 03/01/2004 :: ANNUAL REPORT I '" 'llft... im..ft~;~'".,,~, 1 Q4/22/2PJl1==bNflilLJIJ.,REPQRI 't-v';':,;, ,;..~~~~;:.: 1 03/24/2002 -- ANNUAL REPORTf-""..il'i",W.imS€laJliililirfli>rmot.."":i'l 05/15/2001 ::.ANNUAL REPORTr- .. \(j'ilw.iml3'~o iIi/iIiIflr;ma~1 Q4/2(lJ2QQ.Q:: bJ.JN.VALRf;PQRI (. ;/i~~s~e.J~n>';L ,..-~l 03/16/1999 -- ANNUAL REPORT r... Mill.WJmaa~format"",_l Q4/J4!1IJl1fJ::.ANN.l,J,Al..Rl;PQRT r,-~\liAw.io:DJ;l"e.in,~[ma'-w,~l Q4L2J/1~7:: bNNl,J,Al.Bl;PQBI r=..,\Lj,w,il:Jlaa6,~Orma~ 05/01/1996 ::ANNUAL REPORT r-._.\ljeWdmaQe.~o[ms~l Q!2!Q1/1;l;l;;::.A.NNlJbLREPQRT [-""..vjew.imaoe.i!i&iDi.f';~m..t...~..l Note: This is not official record. See documents if question or conflict. ,,,"-"~,_._.,-~..,,-,,,;,-,;,,',-"'<"~<',,~""'...."="""~,,,--.~.....~-,.,,,,,,,,,.",~.,,,~...~=""""",~--_.~;~-=""----~-~-~_._."-"".- Page 2 of3 1_",--,,-__ 11_.___1.~_ _ _I__..:__",-_I____..l_... _n_C)__"'-~_.__T'\r"'T'rTT 0_=___ .J__ ._..___t...___n'1('\'''}(\':::~~:....~ ...."'...... 1'1/'1/'1f\nQ wWw.sunbiz.org - Department of State Page 3 of3 Previous on List Next on List Return To List No Events No Name History [ll~ama"" Home Contact us Document Searches E-Filing Services Forms Help Copyright and Privacy Policies Copyright @ 2007 State of Florida, Department of State. J..,+t......II~~l....h~'7 ..............I...."...;.....+..../.............rl....+ o:vof).."......;..........=fYCTDTT A'T;......... A............ ......".......'h.o...=P1fl1f1,.R,.;,.,rl f"o:lO,.,..... 1~/'J/~()()~ e. If there Is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an Individual or Individuals, a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purChasers below, Including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. Date of Contract: f. If any contingency clause or contract terms Involve additional parties, list all Individuals or officers, If a corporation, partnership, or trust. Name and Address Not applicable. g. Date subJect property acquired ~ Owner acquired property on January 13, 1999. leased 0 Term of lease yrs./mos. If, Petitioner has option to buy, Indicate the following: Date of option: Not applicable. Date option terminates: , or Anticipated closing date: APPLICATION FOR PU8L1C HEARING FOR CONDt770NAL U5E - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 h. Should any changes of ownership or changes In contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the fln~1 publiC hearing, It Is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on hIS behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of Interest form. Detailed leaal descrl~tlon of the DrODSrtv covered bv the aDDllcatlon: (If space Is Inadequate, attach on separate page.) If request Involves change to more than one zoning district, Include separate legal clescrlptlon for propsrty Involved In each district. Applicant shall submit four (4) copies of a recent survey (completed within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale) If required to do so at the pre- application meeting. See legal description, attached as Exhibit "C". NOTE: The applicant is responsible for supplying the correct legal description. If questions arise concerning the legal description, an engineer's certification or sealed survey may be required. SectlonfTownshipJRange 08/50/26 Lot: Block: Subdivision: Also known as Lot 20, Enchanted Acres Plat Book Page #: Property I.D.#: 00405160008 Metes & Bounds Description: SIZE OF PROPERTY: ft. X ft. = Total Sq. Ft. Acres 4.77 ae (207,781.20 s.f. m.o.!.) ADDRESS/GENERAL LOCATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 5860 Crews Rd., Naples, FL Zoning Land use N E1PUD S E E PUD W PUD/E Does the owner of the subject property own property contiguous to the subject property? If so, give complete legal description of entire contiguous property. (If space Is inadequate, attach on separate page). Not Applicable. APPUCA nON FOR PUBLIC HEARtNG FOR CONDmONAL USE - 4/ t4/0J, rev S/lO/lOOS, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 LEGAL DESCRIPTION Property located in Collier, FL The West one-half (W 'Iz) of the Northwest one-quarter (NW Y..) of the Southeast one- quarter (SE Y..) of the Southeast one-quarter (SE Y..) of Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County Florida, also known as Tract No. 20, Enchanted Acres, less the South 30 feet for road right-of-way purposes. AND BEING the same property conveyed to Renda Broadcasting Corporation, a Pennsylvania corporation from Sterling Communication Corporation, a Florida corporation by Warranty Deed dated January 13, 1999 and recorded January 20,1999 in Deed Book 2503, Page 1624. Tax Parcel No. 00405160008 EXHIBIT I G SectlonITownshlp/Range I I Lot: Block: SubdMsion: Not applicable. Plat Book Page #: Property I.D.': Metes & Bounds Description: 1;"...~.,,::":';'"!~filjj};;;~;i:lL~~:'.~. i.; ."",,',-,' ::'..~.'; - '-~' TVDe of C;:ondltlonal. Use: This application is requesting a conditional use allowed per LOC Section 2.04.03 of the J;, zoning district for installation of broadca$!lna eouiDment and antenna to exlstina tower (type of use). Present Use of the PropertY: Existing communication tower. l>n"ii\V;"';"i"'I',!\'j;_'7";;',;"~~F"...;;;1 . ;..:.,.....-:;.,i~;-'_,'" ..',......"",1:.,. . . .. . . ~. .'l'.J>-',J,,'J':-, -'i;t.~,\S:~ii~"'" ,', ~".;,..-_,~,;..'. . . .' '. - . ',... .:. ..... ' . . h . _ . '_,_'... ~.' ", "..~.., " ," ,',. .' _." ~., __, " ... .,. Evaluallon C?rl\!lrtl!: Provide II narratlve staternent describing this request for condillonal use. See Exhipit "D", attached. NOTE: Pursuant to Section 10.08.00. of the GolliElr County land Development Code, staff's recommendation to. the Planning Coml'lll$$lon and the Planning Commission's recommendation to the Board of Zoning AppealS shall be ba$ed upon a finding that the granting of the conditional use will f1()t allver$&ly ~~ the public Intarest and that the specmc requlrelT1en~ gQVemlng the 1000Mdualcondltlonal use, If any, have been met, and thatfIJrther, satlsfaqJolY proviSloo and arrangemlfilt have been made conceming the fOllOWing matters, whlfre appl~le. P"" pi'ovtcte dete"fild reeponee to each of the criterion listed belOW. Specify how and WIlY the reqUll" Is consistent with each. (Attach addItional pege8 88 may be neclt888ty). a. DeSCribe how the. project Is consIStent with the ColJler County land Development Code and Growth Management Pian (include InfOrl'llatf(m on h<lw the request Is consistent with the applicable section or portions of the future land use element): b. DeSCribe the existing or planned means of ingress and egress to the property and proposed structure thereon With particular reterel1CEl to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access In case of fire or catastrophe: C. Describe the effect the conc1ltfonal use win have on neighboring properties in relation to nolS9, glare, economic Impact and odor: APPUCATlON FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOIICONDtTtONAL //Sf - 4/14/03, rev 5120/200S. rev2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 d. Describe the site's and the proposed use's compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district: e. Please provide any additional information which you may feel is relevant to this request. Deed Restrictions: The County is legally precluded from enforcing deed restrictions. however, many communities have adopted such restrictions. You may wish to contact the civic or property owners association In the area for which this use Is being requested in order to ascertain whether or not the request Is affected by existing deed restrictions. Previous land use _Itlons on the sublect DroDertv: To your kI:Iowledge, has a public hearing been held on this property within the last year? If so, what was the nature of that hearing? No. OfflclallnterDretatlons or Zonlna Verifications: To your knowledge, has there been an official interpretation or zoning verffication rendered on this property within the last year? 181 VesD No If so, please provide copies. See Exhibit "E", attached. Additional Submittal reaulrententa: In addition to this completed application, the following must be submitted in order for your application to be deemed sufficient, unless otherwise waived during the pre-application meeting. a. A copy of the pre-application meeting notes; See Exhibit "F", attached. b. Twenty (20) caples of a 24" x 36" conceptual site plan [and one reduced 8~n x 11" copy of site plan], drawn to a maximum scale of 1 Inch equals 400 feet, depleting the following [Additional copies of the plan may be requested upon completion of staff evaluation for distribution to the Board and various advisory boards such as the Environmental Advisory Board (EAB), or CCPC]; · all existing and proposed structures and the dimensions thereof, · provisions for existing and/or proposed Ingress and egress (including pedestrian ingress and egress to the site and the structure(s) on site), · all existing and/or proposed parking and loading areas [include matrix indicating required and provided parking and loading, including required parking for the disabled], · locations of solid waste (refUse) containers and service function areas, . required yards, open space and preserve areas, · proposed locations for utilities (as well as location of existing utility services to the site), APPLlCA nON FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL IJSE - 4/t4/0il, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 · proposed and/or existing landscaping and buffering as may be required by the County, · location of all signs and lighting including a narrative statement as to the type, character, and dimensions (such as height, area, etc.); c. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), as required by Section 3.8. of the Land Development Code (LDC). Not required. d. Whether or not an EIS is required, two copies of a recent aerial photograph, (taken within the previous twelve months), minimum scale of one Inch equals 400 feet, shall be submitted. Said aerial shall Identify plant and/or wildlife habitats and their boundaries. Such Identification shall be consistent with Florida Department of Transportation Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System. See Exhibit "8", attached. e. Statement of utility provisions (with all required attachments and sketches); See Exhibit "H', attached. f. A Traffic Impact Statement (TIS), unless waived at the pre-application meeting; Not required. g. A hIstorical and archeological surveyor waiver application if property is located within an area of historical or archaeological probability (as Identified at pre-application meeting); Not requl.red. h. Any additional requirements as may be applicable to specific conditional uses and identified during the pre-application meeting, Including but not limited to any required state or federal permits. BE ADVISED THAT SECTION 10.03.05.B.3 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIRES AN APPLICANT Tb REMOVE THEIR PUBLIC HEARING SIGN (S) AFTER FINAL ACTION IS TAKEN BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. BASED ON THE BOARD'S FINAL ACTION ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE REMOVE ALL PUBLIC HEARING ADVERTISING SIGN(S) IMMEDIATELY. -,.'" :i~~~i , . . ,1\',;,;~_,~_~iE~ Within 30 days of adoption of the Ordinance, the owner or developer (specify name) at Its expense shall record In the Public Records of Collier County a Memorandum of Understanding of Developer Commitments or Notice of Developer Commitments that contains the le.gal description of the property that is the subject of the land use petition and contains each and every commitment of the owner or developer specified in the Ordinance. The Memorandum or Notice shall be in form acceptable to the County and shall comply with the recording requirements of Chapter 695, FS. A recorded copy of the Memorandum or Notice shall be provided to the assigned Principal Planner, Collier County Zoning Department, within 15 days of recording of said Memorandum or Notice. APPLlCA nON FOR PI/SLlC HEARING FOR CONOITIONAL I/Sf - 4/ t 4/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/'2/08, rev. 1/'4.08 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Exhibit D Narrative Statement The Applicant seeks approval of a conditional use request to pennit the co-location of broadcast equipment on an existing wireless tower located at 5860 Crews Road, in Collier County, Florida (the "Project"). The Project will essentially entail the addition of cellular antenna and broadcast equipment to an already existing, functioning tower and as such will require only minor alterations, at best, to the site as it presently exists. There will be no additional employees stationed at or accessing the site due to the installation, and no additional building square footage will be associated with the Project. a. The Project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC) and Growth Managemeut Plan. The Project is consistent with the County's desire to "maximize the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites," as set forth in Section 5.05.09(A) of the LDC. The Project is consistent with the LDC provisions governing the standards for design, vegetation screening, construction and facilities setting for commUI)ications towers. b. Means of ingress and egress to the Property and proposed structure; automotive and pedestrian safety; traffic flow and control; access in case of fire or catastrophe. The Property features an existing private access road from Crews Road as a means of ingress and egress to the Property for maintenance vehicles and in the event of fIre or catastrophe. There are existing parking spaces on the Property for maintenance vehicles. As the facility is an un-manned site, no alterations to the existing parking or to the existing means of ingress and egress on the Property are required. Pedestrians and the general public will not have access to the site. c. The Project will have a minimal effect on neighboring properties with regard to noise, glare, economic impact and odor. The Project involves the installation of an additional antenna to an already existing communication tower and will require the addition of an enclosed generator. Notwithstanding, the Project will have only a minimal effect, if any, with regard to noise and glare to neighboring properties given (i) the tower already exists and (ii) the Project involves only the addition of equipment to the existing tower. The Proj ect will have no known effect on neighboring properties with regard to odor or economic impact. d. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district. The compatibility of the site with adjacent properties will not be affected by the co-location of broadcast equipment on the existing communications tower. Given (i) the tower already exists and (ii) the Project involves only the addition of equipment to the existing tower, the existing compatibility of the site with adjacent properties and other properties in the district will not be disturbed. TPA:639135I COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT April 3, 2008 Community Development and Environmental Services Division Department of Zoning and Land Development Review 2800 North Horseshoe Drive' Naples, Florida 34] 04 Margaret Smith MediaFLO USA c/o Redna Broadcasting 2 Larkspur Ct Greenfield, NY 12833 RE: Zoning VerificatioD Letter ZL TR-2007-AR-12825, zoning verification for property addressed as 5860 Crews Road, legally described as the West Y:z of Northwest y. of Southeast Y. of Southeast Y. Less the South 30-foot right-of-way, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. Property 10 No: 00405160008 Dear Ms. Smith: In your application dated January 23, 2008 you request a zoning determination regarding the two existing communication towers and your desire to co-locate antennas on the tower that was to be dismantled on the subject property. The zoning for the subject property is Estates with an approved conditional use (Resolution 93-219). As provided below, an expansion of the original approved conditional use cannot be granted; furthermore, the tower designated to be dismantled remains and must be removed in order to comply with the terms of approval of the original conditional use. The conditional use, referenced above, was approved on May 25, 1993 for the subject property to allow the replacement of the existing 438-foot guyed communications tower and accessory structures with a 430-foot guyed communications tower and a new 2,400 square foot building. Site Development Plan (SDP) 93-62 was approved July 23, 1993 showing the new 430-fuot guyed Communications tower and accessory building. An amendment to SOP 93-62 was approved July 19, 1999, proposing the replacement of the existing 430-foot guyed communications tower with a stronger 394-foot communications tower. Several insubstantial changes to SDP 93-62 have been approved to add generators or co-locate antennas on onto an existing tower on the site. Your application states you would like to co-locate antennas on the tower that was to be dismantled. A current aerial shows two towers existing on the subject property. The approved conditional use provided for the replacement of an existing communications tower; not an expansion of use by adding an additional tower. Section 10.08.00, of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC), provides for conditional use procedures and requires any additional uses or expansion of permitted uses not shown on the conceptual site development plan or otherwise specifically provided for in the c o Phone (239) 403-2400 .; il 3 EXHIBIT E o n ." or (239) 213-2913 www.colliergov.net conditional use application to undergo submittal, review and approval of a new conditional use application. LDC Section 5.05.09.G states no new tower of any height shall be pennitted in the Estates zoning district except for essential services listed in subsection 5.05.09.G.3, thereby prohibiting the. expansion of the approved conditional use. Please be advised that the infonnation presented in this verification letter is based on the Land Development Code and/or Growth Management Plan in effect as of this date. It is possible that subsequent amendment(s) to either of these documents could affect the validity of this verification letter. It is also possible that development of the subject property could be affected by other issues not addressed in this letter, such as, but not limited to, concurrency related to the provision of adequate public facilities, environmental impact, and other requirements of the Collier County Land Development Code or related ordinances. Should you require further infonnation please do not hesitate to call me at (239) 252- 5748. Researched and prepared by; Reviewed by: CrrJ~th~ hristine Willoughby, PI er Department of Zoning and Land Development Review ~ ss Ooc aur, Planning Manager Department of Zoning and Land Development Review Cc; Correspondence File, ZLTR-2008-AR-12825 Mike Sawyer, Senior Planner Peggy Jarrell, Addressing Section EXHIBIT I F . . OLLlER COUNTY GOVERNMENT EPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPME WW.COLLlERGOV.NET ooJ68 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643- (i) CONDITIONAL USE PETITION PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Date: t;,/2 r; / oS Time: J.' 3D Planner: :::J D Jf4As~ f I Project Nome: ?~~ ~~~~~UL Prolect AddrfLocation: It, 0 C-ru,..[ . Applicant Name: ~ J-n.;.-!t.-j 14~ Firm: Phone: ({-It) 413 '~dl 0 Current Zoning: 'f. ~d..Ao.. @nl NLu<1j,~ Owner Name: Owner Address: Phone: Meeting Attendees: (attach Sign In Sheet) NOTES: a,....rl'eM.;Jve 'p{,..~ntJ.. - ~Pt;leJ.,;" ~ rAJU;(~ ~ Cu.4 N1 "1 1$~5. 70 b~8 t}-+\ \,~fS' 'J'~[Jltj.",S\--a2 ~HC~~~i~JOl) WI {fA === ......;~''"' <P1A..v,,.,.- N,."" A ~~6L ~"'T"" '"~, t0e> ,a,PDITt.CtvA,L ~lP 6E~Ur-rc<~'" A-lZE P~O't:'OSG'b ,0\-<;' ~~ 01"'- T-IN. ~f\I'J)IT/e",........ (JS6 . - lIS+f;/.J Sh;U/35 S"LtJ2l1i;y U/t.}/'I ;:VC/;j 0.;11 /(ti)-(oCMII.PtJ WQO#A<k~~ (!< (lv,) /9/f/lJ 6'/6 Ct"',IJ'(J;JT For J'lJv/~!iIS'. - WIi-HA4'/J YI//2IJ/}1 (ktW.4( liHfI?41 W'.4fr"A/ - oJ,JI(~A-f/.;- 1'121iJIi'ItU:- A-1L1i'.4 off/ c(J J'lfl.i jJlA4/. (;Oh d tilt Gt1j'fW(/fIAfft/1( l/F.( Grt1-#P/V ok-ri+l5') 1. QS. 07 lJ(. CONDITIONAL USE (CU) APPLICATION SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMmED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. #OF NOT REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED 20 X 20 .)(" 1 X 1 20 20 2 1 2 1 5 1 7 3 4 4 I 2 o EDC "Fast Track" must submit approved copy of official application o Affordable Housing "Expedited" must submit copy of signed Certificate of A reement. PLANNER MARK IF NEEDED TO BE ROUTED TO REVIEWERS BELOW: C ts h Id b f d d t th PI I t th d d t 2 ommen $ ou e orwar e 0 e anner_p_r or 0 e ue ae SCHOOL DISTRICT (1) PARKS & REC - Murda Smith (I) SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS (1) UTILITIES ENGINEERING - Zamira Deltoro (1) COMMUNITY PLANNING BAYSHORE/GATEWAY TRIANGLE COORDINATOR - Linda Bedlelyon (I) REDEVELOPMENT Executive Director (1) Communications Towers Onl : MOSQUITO CONTROL NAPLES AIRPORT AUTHORITY 0) (I) 2 FEES: . K ~ Pre-application Fee $500.00 (Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre- application meeting will be required.) $4,000.00 $150.00 $300.00 $760.00 $363.00 Application Fee / $1500 jf flied in con(unctlon with a rezone petition Fire Code Review Comprehensive Planning Consistency Review Estimated legal Advertising Fee - CCPC Meeting Estimated Legal Advertising Fee - BCC Meeting (any over- or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Noples Dally News). $2,500.00 EIS Review, if required JII/A $1000.00 LIsted or Protected Species survey review fee (when an EIS Is not required) Transportation Fees, If required: ~ o $500.00 Methodology Review Fee, If required ^ \ 111_ ;P o $750.00 Minor Study Review Fee, If required / V rr o $1,500.00 Malor Study Review Fee, If required OTHER REQUIREMENTS: o o [l n Applicant/Agent Signature Date 3 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS LOC 10.03.05 F. Applicant must conduct at least one Neighborhood Informational Meeting (NIM) after Initial staff review and comment on the application and before the Public Hearing is scheduled with the Planning Commission. Written notice of the meeting shall be sent to all property owners who are required to receive legal notification from the County pursuant to Section 1 0.03.05.B.8. Notification shall also be sent to property owners, condominium and civic associations whose members are Impacted by the proposed land use change and who have fonnally requested the County to be notified. A copy of the list of all parties noticed, and the date, lime, and location of the meeting, must be furnished to the Zoning Department and the Office of the Board of County Commissioners no less than ten (10) days prior to the scheduled date of the NIM. The applicant must make arrangements for the location of the meeting. The location must be reasonably convenient to those property owners who are required to receive notice and the facilities must be of sufficient size to accommodate expected attendance. The applicant must place an advertisement of the meeting In that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear stating the purpose, location, time of the meeting and legible site location map of the property for which the zoning change Is being requested. The display advertisement must be one.fourth page, In type no smaller than 12 point and must be placed within a newspaper of general circulation In the County at least seven (7) days prior to, but no sooner than five (5) days before, the NIM. The Callier County staff planner assigned to the project must attend the NIM and shall serve as the facilitator of the meeting; however, the applicant Is expected to make a presentation of how It intends to develop the subject property. The applicant Is required to audio or video tape the proceedings of the meeting and provide a copy to the Zoning Department. As a result of mandated meetings with the public, any commitments made by the applicant shall be reduced to writing and made a part of the record of the proceedings provided to the Zoning Department. These written commitments will be made a part of the staff report of the County's review and approval bodies and made a part of the consideration for inclusion In the conditions of approval. ~-i~ ~ ~~ o-rf(jd~. 4 ~ t ~ J . t ~ ~ I l p.c I ~ ~ ;3 w :E .( z ~ a <r: Cl. Cl z iii w :E II. o w !:i Q ~ cp '> cp << - c cp E a. o 'ai Q; ~ ~ > Q 0 "tl fl c .! o = ... 0 0/1 @ Ol .. .5 tit c 0 o E N "tl ... .- o > _ 0 C "tl Gl C E ~ 1: .- 8. ~ ~ 2! . :g ::: 00( o _ :E '0 ~ ~ o Q I C .l: o ... " M N m ~ z 10 Z N < C ... Gl ll.. .a Q E w ;) Z Z C> Gl - C II) 0 ~ .l: ll.. II) to a: Q Q 00( ... ~ J. ~ III i ~ z w Z o ::c ll. to- ll. W Q - i:e iiew ~it~ Ci .. >- 0 !Z :,) 8 . 2 ~ N ~ '" -0 " '" 'S: I!! TP A66 71381 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation ADDRESSING CHECKLIST (1 COPY ATTACHED) COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT ADDRESSING DEPARTMENT (i) 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 I ADDRESSING CHECKLIST Please complete the following and fax to the Addressing Department at 239-252-5724 or submit In person to the Addressing Department at the above address. Fonn must be signed by Addressing personnel prior to pre-application meeting. Not all items will apply to eveJ)l project. Items in bold type are required. Forms older than 6 months will require additional review and approval by the Addressing Department. PETITION TYPE (check petition type below, complete a separate Addressing Checklist for each Petition Type) o BL (Blasting Pennlt) o BD (Boat Dock Extension) g..carnlvallClrcus Pennlt ~ CU (Conditional Use) o EXP (Excavation Penni!) o FP (Final Plat o LLA (Lot Line Adjustment) o PNC (Project Name Change) o PPL (Plans & Plat Review) o PSP (PreliminaJ)l Subdivision Plat) o PUD Rezone o RZ (Standard Rezone) o SOP (Site Development Plan) o SDPA (SOP Amendment) o SDPI (Insubstantial Change to SOP) o SIP (Site Improvement Plan) o SIPI (Insubstantial Change to SIP) o SNR (Street Name Change) o SNC (Street Name Change - Unplatted) o TOR (Transfer of Development Rights) o VA (Variance) o VRP (Vegetation Removal Pennlt) o VRSFP (Vegetation Removal & Site FIIi pennlt) o OTHER LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subject property or properties (copy of lengthy description may be attaohed) 60 ~~ "'8 ~~c..EL G:.3 , FOLIO (Property 10) NUMBER(s) of above (attach to, or associate with, legal description if more than one) (')6 ~ \(." e> <:')0'8 STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES (as applicable, if already assigned) !:Se<oc ~~ ~t::::. . LOCATION MAP must be attached showing exact location of projecVslte in relation to nearest public road right-of-way · SURVEY (copy - needed only for unplatted properties) PROPOSED PROJECT NAME (if applicabla) PROPOSED STREET NAMES (if applicable) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (foraxisting projects/sites only) SOP orAR# EXHIBIT I Page 1 of 2 ~ 11 8 c9 ADDRESSING CHECKLIST - PAGE 1WO Project or development names proposed for, or already appearing in, condominium doouments (If application; indicate whether proposed or existing) Please Check One: o Checklist is to be Faxed back IDersonaliy Picked Up APPLICANT NAME: \-fU:.-t,uJ:JeA. ~Q ~ / tq+tv()ilQ..\..( itx A<<?\ l('An-t- PHONE FAX Signature on Addressing Checklist does not constitute Project and/or Street Name approval and is subject to further review by the Addressing Department. FOR STAFF USE ONLY Primary Number -9 '3 LI-R Address Number Address Number Address Number Ap..-~~~j Updated by: Date: ~ -.;;t~ -()~ Date: IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST BE UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED Page 2 of 2 G:ICu"enl'Appllcalion FormslAddresslng Checklist rev 04290B.dcc TPA:667!.3~:1 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation COPIES OF WARRANTY DEED(S) (2 COPIESATTACHED) N D. .....-mu QUAlLlS I IWI SUITt 3DD 4501 lMIMI llAlL .. III'US, .IOIIDA 34103 Thi~ instrumenl prepdrOO by: 2422539 OR: 2503 PG: 1624 UCOIDII II OIllClll UCOIDS of coLlIn COml, II Ol/ll/ll It II:UIIIIlGllI. 1IOCI, CUD COIl 1Il1ll.tl DC /II 11.51 10(-.11 m.lt John D. Humphre...ill~, ESQulr~ Quarles & Brady 4501 Tamraml Trail North Suite 300 Naples, Flonda 3410j leU: Qumll I IWI tllllUIUllllllOO Il/Ul II lUOl 3alO WARRANTY DEED This Indenture, made this J:3 j_" day of ) il nuc. ~ 1999, between Slerling Communication Corporation, a Florida corporalion, RANTOR, and Renda Broadcasting Corporal ion a Pennsylvania Corporation, whose federal employer identification number is , and whose post office address is 14S9 Crane Avenue, Pittsburgh. Pennsylvania 15220, GRANTEE. n Subject to restricti ~ estate taxes for the Identification Numb and said Grantor does hereby fu againstlhe lawful claims of all per.;ol In Wilness Whereof, the Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: STERLING COMMUNICATIO~ CORPORATION, a Flor ida !liijxJration ~'~-:2r~ .~ ruce B. Ti m, as president 2500 Airport Road, South Naples, Florida 34112 ~ aqA~.',.J W 5#1 :4" B.77.......". Print name - ... .,. "t.."". 'oj : .,-' /1.11I'I. . ~ 'ti} dAu...t m: Witness #2 <Lt4-hi Co. Wilb',,,ol1 Print name .,-, f' ." 1 EXHIBIT 0UAP\1'C1S'.1 ~ j cr *** OR: 2503 PG: 1625 *** STATE OF i Loj!, /I), J COUNTYOF LEo/'( The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this I:Y!' day of . J~n"Q't . 1999, by Bruce B. Timm, as President of Sterling Communications Corporatio, [rl who is personally known to me or ( I who produced as identification. j)! 0,;1 \ Il,~ {,(; Xv'-fl?! NOTARY PUBLIC (SEAl) /n~f I<S/IA lU. (~^(_ Name of Notary, Printed, Typed or Stamped My Commission Expires: Q8MU\11111U.J -1?A:667138:1 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation OWNER/AGENT AFFIDA VITS (1 COpy ATTACHED) 'i' \U AFFIDAVIT Deborah Barrett MediaFLO USA, Inc. is an Applicant tor a wireless installation on the We/I, "_m" ",," being first duly sworn, depose and say that <NecIt~l'.jOl~~me property described herein and which is the subject matter 01 the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application. including the disclosure of interest mformation, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief. Well understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted. the Applicant Kimberly J. Madison, Esq. As p.~ Well further authorize _ to act as ourlmy representative in any matters regarding this Petition. Signature of Property Owner x CuA'tY\,. ~.~~ Signature of fYmptJ~~ Applicant Typed or Printed Name of Owner ullllluy Uu,::/ Deborah Barrett Sr. Director, Operations Cenie}';" Cit_ D<:.~leI3f.E..l.t t~al.a9E:.l:- ~.... R<:~iofl Typed or Printed Name of &wm'/I< Applicant The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me thiS?"'?' .., day 01 /::'l"~j'( <' 2 b I I J ! '-. -'.- O,e;;, y ;..4.i:." ,v 1_)/ '. I, ,', i who is personally known to me or has produced as identification. r-----------~ " JEANNE SOPER MllBRAND ~,"'" Commllslon # 1556612 ~ ~ N<>Iory PublIc .. California ~ ~ - - - ~:;~~~~ / '--"---::::"::.-. (Signature of Notary Public) ,.' _', ;[,t?t1/?[ _ . >(=t.;~~n I U:.;,;'!il U (prinj;'iype, or Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) A,",oL/CA TlON fOR FUgUe fir.IRING fOR CONOlfltJNAl lI5l - 4 !.J OJ, Ie.. 5 ,"'0 ./(;05, rt'~'.:' ...2(:3 0" , , '0"" AFFIDAVIT Well, Bill Mueller on behalf of Renda Broadcastinq Corp being first duly sworn, depose and say that well amlare the owners of the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief Well understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted. As property owner Well further authorize Kimberlv Madison of Ruden McCloskv to represent Renda Broadcastinq in relation to the conditional use petition and. to act as ourlmy representative- in any mattf?fsJregarding this Petition .' /" //c ,/, / . '(' //' 'l, V L-- - I ( /" \. ,. Signature of Property Owner Signature of Property Owner Bill Mueller Typed or Printed Name of Owner Typed or Printed Name of Owner . I The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ,,,z--!4'-day of ~J;/JJf11<?.('ij ..' '7 20 (,~', by /,~i l /~ /Z fL U{ who is personally known to me or has produced as identification. (Notary Stamp) )t~ d~ , /'/ /d_ }[i"" "e~~',c(~ (Signattfr'; of Notary PUF-"". . '1 I ' L___ (Print, Type, or Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) Page 10 of 10 conditional Use Extension Application - Feb. 2008 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING FLUCCS CODES, LEGEND, AND PROJECT BOUNDARY (5 COPIES ATTACHED) TPA:667138:1 AERIAL FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 5. Aerial I FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; Ramsev Inc. Environmental Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!, FL 34120 239.5_.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEPlSFWMD .JURIS. WETLAND USACOE .JURIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.06 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC IffifI 740310 Itt1tI DISTURBED LAND I GRASS PRAIRIE DEPlSFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #30.15 AC B8 D 7408212 DISTURBED LAND I COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEPlSFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #4 0.38 AC J:"01 7408145 ~ DISTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY DEPlSFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #5 0.22 AC ~ ~\-'ltER PINE ~ DEPlSFWMD UPLAND USACOE .JURIS. WETLAND #6 0.15 AC #7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY . TOWER ~ I 1'1 CO \ Ii. ]\ ------- C!'\ - - - - - - - - - - - - -C't 40 , o 40 80 120 Feet , 330 fT , ~ II I I I ;< ,6;:x>gx ~...>< ><X>< x :>< 9 x >6< x><< ><x>6< >6<'/ ~ c: xxx:>< y:><x ~ x ~ x X y x:.- x.,; ><,; >6< >6< x:;:cx >6< >O<x ><<; x x:>< x...>< <X I? :><x 8> >6< >6< i:B XXXx:;X< >0< ~ >6< >6< >0< XX >0< ><$>< IX':>< >6< '/ ~ >< >6< x >C x ?<X x ><,; >6< >0< x ~ ""xx >6< -':'X' >0< ...>< :5< >6< &x< x x~ >6< XX <~ x ~ x x XX x ><x:>< x >6< x .,?<x c><xx "><' :5< x xX >6< xX ~ >6<x: ><,; x x '" >6< >6< ~ >6< x )< <5 x x ~ 0- x> ><x..?'-J x x)< :;x x :>< -./' ><:x,; ~ x :<s >: >6< x:> <><s x ::x)< ><,; >6< ~ x >6< x .;xx XX ~)< <'~ 8:'~ x >6<'/ ~v ><> :;xx x ~ <5>1 "><' x J>>< x >6<'/ ""><5 ~ ~ x. '/ 9< S><:><> x'>< .J< x I :< xx x: yX . .'-. V;X x ~~ x x>6<* . 4..~ xx x>6<Yx x xx ~ ><;?< j ~ >: ..,.- x 6X< ~ ~ ~ ~&~I~ l~ ~~~~t x&< >6< ?> ~ 8:: s -PS.)< ~ x "" ~ Rx~""} ~:;x ~,,~ ~ )< >< >6<:x >yy<.l'-.:: ~ ~ >6< : x v..,;x I"" 'li ;.;;, 0' 0/ ~ >6< ~~V~l>< ~ 0r5x >< x '''''~0: ~0 I I I q+. I CREWS ROAD ROW +E PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 Figure 4. FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; Ramsev Inc. Environmen"tal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW NaplesLFL 34120 239.564.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. TPA:66713R:l Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation STATEMENT OF UTILITY PROVISIONS (1 COPY ATTACHED) (i) STATEMENT OF UTlLlTY PROVISIONS FOR CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST I "" . '.' . '1i\;;;~il~~illtffil~il!l:b~r' EJ(~~~B' d\::_.-,', -, n._._'::!_~.......~_ NAME OF APPLlCANT(S} MEDIAFLO USA., INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION ADDRESS 5775 MOREHOUSE DRIVE CITY SAN DIEGO STATE CA ZIP 92121 TELEPHONE # (858) 651-3244 CELL # FAX # E-MAIL ADDRESS: ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY (IF AVAILABLE): 5860 Crews Rd., Naples, Florida SectlonrrownshlpIRange 08/50/26 Lot: Block: Subdivision: a1k/a Tract 20. Enchanted Acres Plat Book Page #: Property I.D.#: 00405160008 Metes & Bounds Description: I ....L'1m"jj...S;!.~~_,.-.,. .-,~N,lli"'" ~..,L~&J_i:r;~.:" ::~q~i:~..iL~~':Y~:~.:~~ ~ '. -' ~ ".' _ - _ '.. : ",~':iG\i:i3;;oi"\;;'~ ",~:''t(M/'-'-;<'':' " (Check sppllcable system): a. b. c. o o o o o "",. ,.,ii~l:i!;ji:fcY'..IR;W.'fI_'.P~~~A'(j"IQ~Q >. COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM 0 CITY UTILITY SYSTEM 0 FRANCHISED UTILITY SYSTEM 0 PROVIDE NAME PRIVATE SYSTEM (WELL) 0 COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM CITY UTILITY SYSTEM FRANCHISED UTILITY SYSTEM PROVIDE NAME PACKAGE TREATMENT PLANT (GPD capacity) SEPTlC SYSTEM Not Applicable. d. e. _. I a. ,b. c. Not Applicable. d. .i!IIW!lil'1i'i~~~i!II ~wt~~. ~~,~?'\..." ~.3:f~~ ,,=~~'.~:'~ APPLlCA TION FOR PUBLIC HEARtNG FOR CONOmONAL USE - 4114103, rev SIZ01200S, rev 2112108. rev. 7114.08 J p y,,"''''i'i ,.." '>>'1'.' 0 .c> - ';," 'hf~' f:tl\W'~ J ~f~!--''1I::Y~'t.y.t :"1.;[ 'J~j~-/,-; A. WATER-PEAK AVERAGE DAILY B. SEWER-PEAK AVERAGE DAILY IF PROPOSING TO BE CONNECTED TO COLLIER COUNTY REGIONAL WATER SYSTEM, PLEASE PROVIDE THE DATE SERVICE IS EXPECTED TO BE REQUIRED Not applicable. ._lie} Provide a brief and concise narrative statement and schematic drawing of sewage treatment process to be used as well as a specific statement regarding the method of affluent and sludge disposal. If percolation pondS are to be used, then percolation data and soli involved shall be provided from tests prepared and certified by a professional engineer. Not Applicable. . _ . If the project is located within the services boundaries of Collier County's utility service system, written notarized statement shall be provided agreeing to dedicate to Collier County Utilities the water distribution and sewage collection facilities within the project area upon completion of the construction of these facilities In accordance with all appllceble County ordinances in effect at the at time. This statement shall also Include an agreement that the applicable system development charges and connection fees will be paid to the County Utilities Division prior to the Issuance of building permits by the County. If applicable, the statement shall contain shall contain an agreement to dedicate the appropriate utility easements for serving the water and sewer systems. Not Applicable. APPUCATION FOR PUBUC HEARtNG FOR CONDmONAL USE - 4/14/03, f1!V 5/20/2005, f1!V 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation ELECTRONIC COPY OF ALL DOCUMENTS AND PLANS (1 COPY ATTACHED) TPk6G7138I TPA:667138:\ Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation BOUNDARY SURVEY (2 COPIES ATTACHED) ;m.~~~~~~ d~~iSll~~ z '1 "e a~.,~ 0 . ~fsl~~~~r;! qi;!~~ ~!~;~"~" 8~!S~. 1~~~ilSn :bW~~ a~;~'h! ~;Id]~! ~~ ~. I "- I I " ' ~! i : \ =; ! 0 0 0 ;1 ! ! !!! ! i i! ~ ~ ~~~sn~u 0 ~i ~ ~ II ~ ~ u ~ i !j i a ; i P ~ I! ~i ~ . ~ ~ ~ ;~ i ! " t~ ~ " II UJp _ .' c: feg;i~~~t'11 ...~~ntr1E\ >-~ ~~a *<... "8 zr' j;j o- m c:: - ~ at/) -z RE> Z ~ l:I~ ("ltTl ~ ~: i h . ~p!l;'a ~>'~ ul:r ~ I ". .-~l' _..~ p7'~hJI ' ...~.. - i . ~ i ! r'~-'-'-'~il .--;-~ I iIil. 10] lJ ; ~ ii i ~~~1 i' I CJ ~ 'S i .' 4"",1>,;1>.', ; I .W" i ~, I Ii;! 'd --1 ~i ! I a !tt I ~ g L._. ~ ~~I ~~ ~~ ~~ ~. ~. ~~. all all I i~11 sf I sf 'h I ~I~ I ~,... ... ~;; ~~ ' ~ I~; ~ . ~~ I. ~s ~I ~, ~ ~. JI n~ < . ~ ~ ,~ I ~ ~ / ~ I 'I I UI ~' I - I i " "-,",'~ \1 L. -...... '-...... '\ \ ~l I i I I ~I ~ ; " :; m-SO;-flNOlI.:I3$#Jt/I!S'l'3H.LOOSJMl,IJ./IJ.SY3Hl.n05 MJOt/lln..IWlQN)Ml.1HLIOt/~1Utl\MJO:JMf11S:Jli\ 0.' '" Q . ,1.1 umOSVl .urun flN94l<<l)8 10 J.HDd , . $LIQ !s i i ~ -,,,-:;;... l'';:-''.w,,; ~.1 \ ~ jii~ i~ ~."\~~~~ ~IS" ~3~.&;~ "' ~ ~ ~5 ~' . ~ t ... ~'i:1 I -,." i I '.'" .c:S-' II ! ~ Dill i'iI " .~ ~- ! <}~- ; Ii I ~ ~ ~ ~ ; . 'Dol !~ I I - I hJ ~ 'I ~~ ~ , ! ili i ~ II !::o S ..., .~ ~ !ill I I jO fll ..~ . " ~ ! , I ~!j ".. I I. t I 1 ! I OYOlI!~JOMt.o1 s < ." ~.;.:. '" .. '" <.. '. , . o ; ~ :'~ \-'- '\ ~ ;. ~..., .' " iP~ .,.~>'" "'''''':lb. .,.",.~ ~I~ .~< ", ~!1 ~,.. ~ '1'1:"'.1" ~ ~ ~.r 'd'~'>>J" ~ ~ ~ ~ !I il 3K-$OQ-e HOll.:lJlIJ tll !EY3IU/lOS lHllJ tit !S'fMrtOS :JH1 JDt/IU:M\HUIOH:JHI,MJOZ/I!S:M ]H1JO 3II'1!SY3 ~ ~ ~ . '&il ....-....-....-.... ~ I go ,8 I A .~ I :j; . ~ I ~. ~ ,I ~ II . . ~~I ~. I: ~il ~~ g'i: ,~ hi *~ ~ ~ . ~ ~ " ~ e . - :s 3 :a :g !i ~ ~ ;; ~ III! U -- ~ I -. Jr . =i~z -;j-, & . ee~ . ~ i ;.;. . a. ~ ! ~I ~ !I ~ ~~ 6. all ~I -~ !;i I! i !II~; Iii ~I; I!!i Uli Ii ~ ;~~ ~~ i d~:! Id ~e fit ~~ii b ~ - ~ ~j m ,~~~~J .~~ i~ !i~ ~w.1 mz !A ~ !~~~ u~ "Ii~ n: ~~ 0 ~ ;€~:' I ~~I ~~~ Ii ~~i ;!~I ~~ ~ i ;; g a~ ~I ~h .~n~ . ~ pl'~ =~ i" ~~~ 6~~ i" ~ ~il!; ~g ~m ~~8 i~~ ~~ ~ i<~ ji !; Ii" ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ -- III ;;~ ~ qll\ 0 ~~ ~ .... ~~, z:s; ~Q z -t= o~ ~" ~~ , ~ ! ~ e . "" ~, ~- ~i! !~S ~~i ~"~ ;~ ._'_0_0_0 ", ~ ~ ! ~~~~m ~ ~i::~il' ; *~!I!. ~ ~ ~~i\!l ~~ij" ~~~~ ;~i~ W ii , -;; '" 10 ~ \ ~ ~ g:;~ !~I~ ~~ ~ I~~~ ~. -; 'I'.t'[l[ '" 10 ~ 10 '0. -; '" ~ "<1, ~ '0. -~ l~ -; ~ . . x I i I Ui I~~ I~! ~ ~ ;; ~ ~ i i~ >; ~i. ~ !~S : li~ ~ .~fi . ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ I . ~ ~- ~W~~~~ ~ ~ s h.r U! ~:i ~~m~. ~ I !~~ d~H~!I. ~~ f~~ ~~!~. , i~~ "~g ~~~ i~fi " ;~ . z ~~i~i~ i ~g~g~! 3 '" 6~~1 '..~~~ ~ ml~ ~~I~I ~~.~" ~~ . / ~ gl~ag~s ~~~~~~ j~~ ~~ ~~"~~~ ~i ~ I ~~~'6~z ;~~~~~ ~~~. ~~~t~~ ~~ ~ ~ i;I~!~~ ~i!iil~ ~ij i~ i~~::~ i~ ~ I ~~".~~ ~2~~ . ii ~ m;~~~ ~ '" 6 ~~i~~~ !;~~~. ~~g ~ ~;q~~ ~ ~ ~ ~h~~~ ;;~~h ~;~ ~ ~J!t: ~ ~ " A~~~~. i.'~.~ ~~! - ,,'!ij'- ~ ~~~i;. ~~~~~ m"e! 6'1~~ i " ;~.A~6 ~~5~~ o. i ~8 . ..>;.. . ~~ ~"i ill -~ i 6Ia~~s ~~~g ~~I ~~.;~ ~ ".~-~. ~'6~i ~~c ~~~@ ~ i~i~~~ ~i'~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~~ q~ ~~ 2 ~!~j ~)> ~cr ~"m ~ml ~ ~ ~g -lr ~. ~ ~ ij CIJ .~~ ~< ~~ TPA:667138:1 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation LISTED SPECIES SURVEY (5 COPIES ATTACHED) Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Ramsey Inc. - --"";:'-"'""311""""" LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP LEP - Licensed Environmental Professional CWB - Certified Wildlife Biologist CFEA - Certified Florida Environmental Assessor REPA - Registered Environmental Property Assessor CEHP ~ Certified Environmental Health Professional OSHA 5 - Hazardous Materials Incident Commander E-mail: Ramsey.lnc@embarqrnail.com Office: 239.564.1660, Fax: 866.334.1496 26314"51. NW. Naples. FL 34]20 www.ramseyinc.net 08 October 2008 Ms. lody Lima Black & Veatch Corp. 60 I Walnut Street Suile 550 W Philadelphia, PA 19106 PROJECT: Renda Broadcasting Corp., Black & Veatch Tampa 011: PID 00405 J 60008 ; Street Address: 5860 Crews Rd.; City: Naples ; State: FL; County: Collier; Sec 08 Twn 50 Rge 26; Road Frontage: 330 feet; Acres: 5.0 Ms. Lima, Please find attached a Listed Species and Wildlife Survey Report for the Renda Broadcasing Corp., site in Naples, Florida, Collier County, Tampa 011. Please call if you have any questions. Best regards ~ Michael R. Ramsey Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations ENVIRONMENTAL CONSUL TING Ramsey Inc. LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP -~ --~~ LEP - Licensed Environmental Professional CWB - Certified Wildlife Biologist CFEA - Certified Florida Environmental Assessor REPA - Registered Environmental Properly Assessor CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional OSHA 5 - Hazardous Materials Incident Commander E-mail: Ramsey.Inc@cmbarqrnail.com Office: 239.564.1660. Fax: 866.334.1496 26314"51. NW. Naples. FL 34120 www.ramseyinc.net LISTED SPECIES WILDLIFE SURVEY REPORT 2008 PROJECT: Renda Broadcasting Corp., Black & Veatch Tampa 011 DATE: 10.08.08 BY: Michael R. Ramsey Ramsey Inc. Owner: Renda Broadcasting Corp County: Collier City: Naples Size: 4.77 acres Legal Descriptions: PID 00405160008 5860 Crews Road; Section 08; Township 50, Range 26 INTRODUCTION The applicant Renda Broadcasting Corp. has applied to the for the necessary permits to expand its existing operation of communication towers and broadcasting in Collier Co. (Figure I and 2). The following protected species/wildlife survey report was done to meet the submission requirements for each agency involved. This report evaluates if the above described project property is utilized by any wildlife, and any species listed by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). METHODS First, the project properties were surveyed and a map prepared of the habitat types on site. Second, the official lists of protected species were obtained from each of the agencies (FWC & FWS). The FWC list all species classified as protected by the state of Florida government. The FWS list all species that are classified as protected in the state of Florida by the United States government. Third, each species on each list was researched as to county of occurrence and required habitat in the literature. Last, all species that were indicated as being found in Collier Co. and having a habitat type that occurred on the project properties were searched for by surveys on the project properties. RESULTS Survey Dates. For this survey period the property was visited on 09/24, 09/26, 09/27, 09/30, 10/03 and 10/04 in 2008. Surveys were done in the morning (AM) 2-3 hours after sunrise and in the evening (PM) 2-3 hours before sunset. Survey routes are shown in Figure 3. Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008, 5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 2 Habitat. The Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS) was utilized to produce the habitat maps for the project properties. The habitat or FLUCFCS maps are depicted in Figure 4 for the Yahl Mulching project. Table I below indicates the acres for each habitat type. Table I. FLUCFCS acres for the Yahl Mulching and Recycling property. ID# Acres FLUCCS # Habitat Tvoe I 3.73 624 Pine/Cypress/Palm 2 0.06 624 Pine/Cypress/Palm 3 0.15 740/3 lO Disturbed Land/Grass Prairie 4 0.38 740/8212 Disturbed Land/Communication Towers 5 0.22 740/8145 Disturbed Land/Access Driveway 6 0.15 419 Other Pine 7 0.08 419 Other Pine The Renda Broadcasting Corp (Tampa 0 II) property presently has a communication tower broadcasting operation in place on 0.60 acres. This property has been impacted by road construction on the north, south, east and west sides of the property. This construction has effectively cut off sheet flow across the property, except for unusually high rainfall events. Impacted hydrology appears to be the cause of the pine trees and melaleuca being present with present in cypress transition areas in the 624 habitats. It is also the reason for the heavy melaleuca infestation in the general area. This area has been slowly drying out over time. The property appears to have been "enhanced" for melaleuca more than 4-5 years ago. There are no melaleuca in the canopy or sub-canopy. There are also dead melaleuca stumps and piles of cut canopy and sub-canopy trees that have been cut and treated all around the area. The enhancement of the area removing melaleuca has been very effective. It appears that there is 0.5% or less melaleuca in the groundcover and the area is doing well. On the east and west sides of the Renda parcel there is active enhancement activates for melaleuca taking place. The adjacent properties have canopy and sub canopy trees is various stages of post herbicide treatment. Overall. the general area around Renda is undergoing a lot of changes in the vegetation due to the herbicide enhancement treatments, StateIFederal Protected Soecies Listed. The FWC list was published in November 20ll? and lists 118 animals as protected in the State of Aorida and is attached as Appendix A. Based on general habitat requirements, historic distributions and actual sightings, the FWC lists 52 animal species that may occur in Collier County. There are 51 species that are vertebrates and I invertebrate. The 52 species are listed in Figure 4. The FWS list is updated daily on their website. The October 2008 list totals 113 animal and plant species as protected in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix B. Based on general habitat requirements, historic distributions and actual sightings, the FWS lists 19 species (19 animals and no plants) that may occur in Collier County. Species for Collier Co. are listed in Figure 4 also. Site Survev Results. Figure 5 indicates the cumulative total of all species observed over 10 survey events. Daily field sheets are located in Appendix C. Overall, 15 species were noted, 14 bird species, I mammal and 2 reptiles. The most frequent bird species observed was eastern blue bird with 27 observations, No listed species were observed or indicators noted on the property. Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 0]] PID 00405160008, 5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 3 Listed Soecies Results. Gopher Frog/Rana capito: Prefers dry sandy, upland habitats adjacent to wetland areas. This type habitat is not present onsite, or adjacent properties and no individuals were observed on site. Changes in the project property will have no effect on this species. Cape Sable seaside sparrow/Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis: Currently inhabits seasonally inundated freshwater interior marshes within Everglades National Park and Big Cypress National Preserve in Monroe and Dade County. Last documented in Collier Co. in 1979. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were observed on the property. Florida Grasshopper sparrow/Ammodramus savannarumfloridanus: Prefers large areas of frequently burned dry prairie habitat, with patchy open areas sufficient for foraging. This habitat type is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property. In addition. this species has not been observed since 1955 in Collier Co. Changes in the project property will have no effect on this species. Florida scrub jay/ Aphelocoma coerulescens: Prefers low growing scrub oak plants. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in the project property will have no effect on this species. Limpkin/Aramus guarauna: Inhabits mangroves, freshwater marshes. swamps, springs and spring runs. and pond and river margins. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida burrowing owl/Athene cuniculariafloridana: Prefers habitats of high, sparsely vegetated, sandy ground. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Ivory-billed woodpecker/ Campephilus principalis: This species is considered to be extinct but is still listed. Known to prefer swampy forests, especially large bottomland river swamps of coastal plain and Mississippi Delta and cypress swamps of Florida. This habitat is present onsite. but no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Cuban-/snowy plover. Charadrius alexandrinus: Prefers dry, sandy beaches, where they nest in shallow depressions, usually near some vegetation or debris. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Piping plover/Charadrius melodus: Prefers open, sandy beaches and on tidal mudflats and sandflats along the coasts. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Kirtland's warbler /Dendroica kirtlandii: Nests in nearly homogeneous stands of usually 30 ha or more of dense scrubby jack pine. Florida maybe a migration stop between Michigan and the Bahamas. Individuals may flay straight through. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Little blue heron/Egretta caerulea: Feeds in shallow freshwater, brackish, and saltwater habitats. Nesting colonies usually occur in coastal areas, but prefers foraging in freshwater lakes, marshes, swamps, and streams. Nests in a variety of woody vegetation types, including cypress, willow, maple. black mangrove, and cabbage palm. Usually breeds in mixed-species colonies in flooded vegetation or on islands. Nesting habitat is present onsite. but no other nesting of other wading bird species has been observed. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008.5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 4 which removes all prey species. No individuals or nests were observed on the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Reddish egret/Egretta rufescens: Typically prefers coastal mangrove islands. or in Brazilian pepper on manmade dredge spoil islands. near suitable foraging habitat. Generally forages in shallow water of variable salinity. Broad, open, marine tidal flats and shorelines with little vegetation are ideal feeding areas. Also important are salt evaporation pools and lagoons, often located inside mangrove keys or just inside shoreline on mainland. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Snowy egret/Egretta thula: Nests both inland and in coastal wetlands with nests placed in many types of woody shrubs. especially mangroves and willows; usually over shallow waters. Almost all nesting is over shallow waters or on islands that are separated from shoreline by extensive open water. Feeds in many types of permanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, streams, lakes, and swamps, and in manmade impoundments and ditches. Breeding success is tied to water-level fluctuations. Preferred nesting habitat is not present onsite. There are no permanently inundated areas on site. Seasonally flooded areas are very short in duration. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. No individuals or nesting were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Tricolored heron/Egretta tricolor: Most nesting colonies occur on mangrove islands or in willow thickets in fresh water, but nesting sites include other woody thickets on islands or over standing water. Prefers coastal environments. Feeds in a variety of pennanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, mangrove swamps, tidal creeks, ditches, and edges of ponds and lakes. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. Preferred nesting and feeding habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. White ibis/Eudocimus albus: Found in a wide variety of habitats, including freshwater and brackish marshes, salt flats and salt marsh meadows, many types offorested wetlands, wet prairies, swales, seasonally inundated fields, and man-made ditches. The forested wetland habitat is present onsite and targeted to be preserved and enhanced. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. No individuals or nests were observed in the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Peregrine falcon/Falco peregrinus: The Peregrine Falcon frequents open areas like marshes, fields. swamps, and tidal areas. Since its reintroduction into the eastern United States, however, the Peregrine Falcon has colonized many urban areas because of increased nesting sites (and nesting ledges being created on buildings). This species is considered to be recovered and is waiting for delisting. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Southeastern American kestrel/Falco sparverius paulus: Found in open pine habitats. woodland edges, prairies, and pastures throughout much of Florida. Nest sites are tall dead trees or utility poles generally with an unobstructed view of surroundings. Kestrels are not known to nest in Collier County. Most individuals are migrants from the north. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have little to no effect on this species. Florida sandhill crane/Grus canadensis pratensis: Habitat: Prairies, freshwater marshes, and pasture lands. Avoids forests and deep marshes but uses transition zones and edges between these and prairies or pasture lands. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. American oystercatcher/Haematopus palliates: Habitat: Coastal waters. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Renda Broadcasting Corp. Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008, 5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 5 Bald eaglelHaliaeetus leucocephalus: According to the FWC eagle website, the closest eagle nest (CO 023) is 2.30 miles to the north west. A map of this nest location is presented in Figure 6. he proposed project is not in the primary or secondary zone. No individuals or nests were observed on or utilizing the property. Any proposed changes in this property will have little to no effect on this species. On a larger scale the FWS has delisted the Bald Eagle. Wood stork/Mycteria Americana: Nests colonially in a variety of inundated forested wetlands, including cypress strands and domes, mixed hardwood swamps, sloughs, and mangroves. Forages in 6-15 inches of surface water. The preferred nesting habitat is present onsite. but the surface water does not get very deep on the property during the year due to the impacts of road building changing the hydrology. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Brown pelican/Pelecanus occidentalis: Habitat: Mainly coastal, feeding in shallow estuarine waters. and (less often) far offshore. . This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Red-cockaded woodpeckerlPicoides borealis: Habitat: Inhabits open, mature pine woodlands that have a diversity of grass, forb, and shrub species. Prefers mature slash pine trees that are generally larger than 12 inches in diameter. a wide spacing of trees. no subcanopy and relatively dry conditions. The preferred habitat is not present onsite. No individuals were observed on the property. Again for this survey all pine trees were inspected for nest cavities or start holes and none were found. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Roseate spoonbilllPlatalea ajaja (Ajaia ajaja): Habitat: Primarily nests in mixed-species colonies on coastal mangrove islands or in Brazilian pepper on man-made dredge spoil islands near suitable foraging habitat. Does feed in forested wetland habitats with slow moving water. Although forested wetland type habitat present, hydrology has been so impacted it is very low quality. Because of drainage. the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. No individuals or indications of this species were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Crested caracaralPolyborus plancus audubonii (Caracara cheriway): Open country, including dry prairie and pasture lands with cabbage palm, cabbage palm/live oak hammocks, and shallow ponds and sloughs. Preferred nest trees are cabbage palms, followed by live oaks. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Everglades snail kitelRostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus: Habitat: Large open freshwater marshes and lakes with shallow water. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Black skimmerlRynchops niger: Habitat: Coastal waters, including beaches, bays, estuaries, sandbars, tidal creeks (foraging), and also inland waters of large lakes, phosphate pits, and flooded agricultural fields. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Least ternlSterna antil/arum: Habitat: Coastal areas throughout Florida, including beaches, lagoons. bays and estuaries. Increasingly use artificial nesting sites, including gravel rooftops, dredge spoil islands or other dredged material deposits, construction sites. causeways, and mining lands. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Renda Broadcasting Corp, B]ack & Veatch Tampa 0]] PID 00405] 60008, 5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 6 Roseate tern/Sterna dougalli (Sterna dougal/Ii dougallii): Habitat: Nest sites include bare limestone, shell-sand beaches, newly deposited rock and marl fill, dredge material. and heaps of broken coral deposited by storms. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Bachman's warbler/Vermivora bachmanii: Historic records indicate the Bachman's warbler nested in low, wet forested areas containing variable amounts of water. but usually with some water that was permanent. This species is considered extinct in Florida. This preferred habitat is present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Smalltooth sawfish/Pristis pectinata: Habitat: Shallow coastal, estuarine, and fresh waters; often in brackish water near river mouths and large embayments, in deeper holes on bottoms of mud or muddy sand. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Rivulus (mangrove rivulus)/Rivulus marmoratus: Habitat: coastal, appears to prefer red mangrove (Rhizophora mangle). This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Sei whale/Balaenoptera borealis: Habitat: Pelagic. marine. Generally, in deep water; along edge of continental shelf and in open ocean. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Fin whale (finback whale)/Balaenoptera physalus; Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Usually found in largest numbers 25 miles or more from shore. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species North Atlantic right whale/Eubalaena glacialis (Balaena glacialis fine!. australisjJ: Habitat: Inhabits near shore and offshore waters. Mainly coastal in the North Atlantic. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Florida mastiff bat/Eumops glaucinusfloridanus: Habitat: Roosts in palms and hollow trees and in buildings. Forages high in air over natural as well as human-altered landscapes. Minimal preferred roosting habitat is present onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties or surrounding areas during surveys. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Humpback whale/Megaptera novaeangliae: Habitat: Pelagic and coastal waters, sometimes frequenting inshore areas such as bays. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Caribbean monk seal/Monachus tropicalis: Habitat: Marine areas. Shallow lagoons and reefs, sandy beaches, and permanent islets or beaches above high tide. Mainly west coast of Florida and Caribbean. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Everglades minklMustela vison evergladensis: Habitat: A variety of wetland communities, including salt marsh, freshwater marsh, cypress swamp, and hardwood swamp. The preferred habitat is onsite. However, no individuals were observed or, indicators of the presence was noted on the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Renda Broadcasting Corp, B]ack & Veatch Tampa 0]] PID 00405]60008, 5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 7 Sperm whale/Physeter macrocephalus: Habitat: Pelagic, prefers deep water, sometimes around islands or in shallow shelf waters. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida panther/Puma (Felis) concolor coryi: Habitat: Requires extensive blocks of mostly forested communities. The FWC panthertelemetry database form 1981-2007 indicates no utilization of this property (Figure 7). From 1981 to 1995 the closest telemetry activity was 1.5 miles away. From 1996 to 2007 there has been no telemetry activity within 2.5 miles of the site. The forested habitat panthers utilize is present onsite. No individuals or indicators were observed on the property. Planned changes in this property should have no effect on this species. However, this property is not in the Focus Area or Primary or Secondary Panther Habitat Zones articulated by FWS, but it is within the area of Consultation (Figure 7). Big Cypress fox squirrel/Sciurus niger avicennia: Habitat: Sandhi lis (high pine), pine f1atwoods, and pastures and other open, ruderal habitats with scattered pines and oaks. Depends on a variety of oak trees for seasonal food and nest material. Longleaf pine cones and seeds are important foods. This habitat type is not present onsite, due to little to no oak trees being present. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. FloridalWest Indian manatee/Trichechus manatus latirostris (Trichechus manatus): Habitat: Coastal waters, bays. rivers, and (occasionally) lakes. Requires warm-water refugia such as springs or cooling effluent during cold weather. Sheltered coves are important for feeding, resting, and calving. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida black bear/Ursus american us f/oridanus: Habitat: A wide variety of forested communities is needed to support the varied seasonal diet of black bears. Forested wetlands are particularly important for diurnal cover. This habitat is present onsite. Figure 8 indicates black bear telemetry locations form 1983-2000 as collected by the FWC. The closest bear location was approximately I mile to the east ofthe property. Figure 9 indicates the locations of nuisance issues from 1980-2006 according to the FWC. There has not been any nuisance issues on this parcel. This is an unmanned unoccupied site that produces no waste or trash for weekly pickup. This general area has had no nuisance call since 2005 based on data form FWC. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species and planned activities should not generate nuisance issues. American alligator/Alligator mississippiensis: Habitat: Most permanent bodies of fresh water, including marshes, swamps, lakes, and rivers. Occasionally wanders into brackish and salt water but rarely remains there. Protected classification is primarily due to similarity of appearance with the American Crocodile. This Species is considered recovered in Florida. Habitat is not present onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Loggerhead seaturtle/Caretta caretta: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Green seaturtle//Chelonia mydas: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This habitat is not present on site and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. American crocodile//Crocodylus acutus: Habitat: Coastal estuarine marshes, tidal swamps. and creeks along edges of mainland and islands. Usually associated with mangroves. Nests on beaches, stream banks. and levees. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Renda Broadca~ting Corp, B]ack & Veatch Tampa 0]] PID 00405160008, 5860 Crew~ Rd, Li~{ed Specie~ Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 8 Leatherback seaturtlelDermochelys coriacea: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Eastern indigo snakellDrymarchon corais couperi: Habitat: Broad range of habitats. from scrub and sandhill to wet prairies and mangrove swamps. In northern part of range, often winters in gopher tortoise burrows in sandy uplands but forages in more hydric habitats. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property. Also, no gopher tortoise burrows were discovered. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Hawksbill seaturtlellEretmochelys imbricata: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Gopher tortoise/Gopherus polyphemus: Habitat: Typically found in dry upland habitats, including sandhi lis. scrub. xeric oak hammock, and dry pine flatwoods; also commonly uses disturbed habitats such as pastures, old fields. and road shoulders. Typical habitat not present onsite and area is generally to wet. No burrows or individuals observed on site. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Kemp's ridley seaturtlellLepidochelys kempii: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida tree snail/lLiguusfasdatus: Habitat: Tropical hardwood hammock (rockland hammock). This species prefers smooth-barked trees. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species CONCLUSIONS The majority of habitat on site is 624 pine. cypress, palm. This habitat type appears to be the result of a hydrology impacts over a long period of time, which dried the area out and allowed slash pine and melaleuca to invade in cypress transition areas in the dry years. Melaleuca enhancement onsite has improved the vegetative associations on site. The surrounding properties melaleuca enhancement activities that are currently ongoing are causing a lot of changes in the vegetative structure in the general area. The wildlife utilization of the area is primarily passerines. and raccoons. No listed species were observed utilizing the area. The area has generally a low utilization by wildlife and is not expected to increase because of its fragmeotation of habitat caused by the roads and drainage of the surrounding residential area. This area is not expected to have a high increase in wildlife utilization in the future with or without changes to this parcel, and a continuing problem with melaleuca. Overall, changes in this property will have little to no effect on any wildlife in the general area including any listed species that may occasionally use the site. Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008.5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 9 REFERENCES Ashton, R. E., Jr., and P. S. Ashton. 1988a. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 3: The amphibians. Windward Publ., Inc.. Miami, Florida. _' 1988b. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida. part I: The snakes, 2nd ed. Windward Publ.. Inc., Miami, Florida. _' 1991. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 2: Lizards, turtles & crocodilians, 2nd ed. Windward Publ.. Inc., Miami, Florida. Barbour, D. B.. and S. R. Humphrey. 1982. Status and habitat of the Key Largo woodrat and cotton mouse (Neotoma f10ridana smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola). J Mammal. 63:144-148. Barnwell. M. E., P. A. Meylan, and T. Walsh. 1997. The spotted turtle (Clemmys guttata) in central Florida. Chelonian Cons. BioI. 2:405-408. Bartlett, R. D., and P. P. Bartlett. 1999. A field guide to Florida reptiles and amphibians. Gulf Publ. Co., Houston, Texas. Berner, L., and M. L. Pescador. 1988. The mayflies of Florida. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville. Birkenholz, D. E. 1963. A study of the life history and ecology of the round-tailed muskrat (Neofiber alieni). Ecolog. Monogr. 33:225-280. Bortone. S. A. 1989. Notropis melanostomus, a new species of cyprinid fish from the Blackwater-Yellow River drainage of northwest Florida. Copeia 3:737 -741.story, habitat assessment. and systematics of the blackmouth shiner (Notropis sp.), Blackwater River drainage. Final Rep. Nongame Wildl. Prog., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Bouchard. R. W. 1978. Taxonomy, ecology and phylogeny of the subgenus Depressicambarus, with the description of a new species from Rorida and redescriptions of Cambarus graysoni, Cambarus latimanus, and Cambarus striatus (Decapoda: Cambaridae). Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 3:27-60. Bowen. P. 1. 2000. Demographic, distribution, and metapopulation analyses of the burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia) in Florida. M.S. thesis, Univ. Central Florida, Orlando. Brady, J. T., T. H. Kunz, M. D. Tuttle, and D. E. Wilson. 1982. Gray bat recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Denver, Colorado. Brim Box, J.. and J. D. Williams. 2000. Unionid mollusks of the Apalachicola Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 21:1-143. Brody, R. W. 1990. Status of habitat and populations of Procambarus pictus in the North Fork of Black Creek, Clay County, Florida. St. Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida. Brown, L. N. 1997. A guide to the mammals of the southeastern United States. Univ. Tennessee Press, Knoxville. Brown, W. S. 1993. Biology, status, and management of the timber rattlesnake (Crotalus horridus): a guide for conservation. Soc. Stud. Amphib. Rept. Herp. Circ. 22. Carle, F. L., and M. L. May. 1987. Gomphus (Phanogomphus) westfalli spec. novo from the Gulf coast of Florida (Anisoptera: Gomphidae). Odonatologica 16:67-75. Chace. F. A., Jr. 1954. Two subterranean shrimps (Decapoda: Caridea) from Florida and the West Indies, with a revised key to the American species. J. Washington Acad. Sci. 44:318-324. Chafin, L. 2000. Field guide to the rare plants of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee. Chase. C. A., and J. A. Gore. 1989. Snowy plover breeding distribution. Unpubl. final rept., Florida Fish and Wildl.Conserv. Comm.. Tallahassee. Choate, P. M. 1984. A new species of Cicindela Linnaeus (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae) from Florida, and elevation of C. abdominalis scabrosa Schaupp to species level. Entomol. News 95:73-82. Conant, R.. and J. T. Collins. 1991. A field guide to reptiles and amphibians: eastern and central North America, 3rd ed. Houghton Mifflin. Boston. Cox, J., D. Inkley, and R. Kautz. 1987. Ecology and habitat protection needs of gopher tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus) populations found on lands slated for large-scale development in Florida. Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 4, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Crance, J. H. 1986. Habitat suitability index models and instream flow suitability curves: shortnose sturgeon. U. S. Fish Wildl. Servo BioI. Rep. 82(10.129). Deitz. D. c., and T. C. Hines. 1980. Alligator nesting in north-central Florida. Copeia 1980:249-258. Delany, M. F.. and C. L. Abercrombie. 1986. American alligator food habits in north-central Florida. 1. Wildl. Manag. 50:348-353. Renda Broadcasting Corp. Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008.5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page ]0 Delany. M. F., P.B. Walsh, B. Pranty, and D.W. Perkins. 1999. A previously unknown population of Florida grasshopper sparrow on Avon Park Air Force Range. Florida Field Nat. 27(2):52-56. Deyrup, M., and R. Franz (eds.). 1994. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. IV: Invertebrates. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville. Dodd, C. K., Jr. 1988. Synopsis of the biological data on the loggerhead sea turtle Caretta caretta (Linnaeus 1758). U.S. Fish Wildl. Servo BioI. Rep.88(14). Duggins, C. E, Jr., A. A. Karlin, K. Relyea. and R. W. Yerger. 1986. Systematics of the key silverside. Menidia conchorum, with comments on other Menidia species (Pisces: Atherinidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot. 25(2): 133, 150. Dunkle, S. W. 1989. Dragonflies of the Florida Peninsula. Bennuda and the Bahamas. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville, Florida. _.2000. Dragonflies through binoculars: A field guide to the dragonflies of North America. Oxford Univ. Press. New York. Dunn. J. 1999. National Geographic Society field guide to the birds of North America. 3rd ed. National Geographic Soc., Washington, D.C. Emmel, T. c., and M. C. Minno. 1988. Habitat requirements and status of the endemic Schaus swallowtail in the Florida Keys. Final report, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Enge. K. M., M. M. Bentzien, and E Percival. 1986. Florida scrub lizard status survey. Tech. Rept. No. 26 to U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Jacksonville End. Sp. Office, Florida. Ernst, C. H., and R. W. Barbour. 1989. Snakes of eastern North America. George Mason Univ. Press, Fairfax. Virginia. Ernst, C. H.. J. E. Lovich, and R. W. Barbour. 1994. Turtles of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Inst. Press, Washington, D.C. Ewert, M. A., and D. R. Jackson. 1994. Nesting ecology of the alligator snapping turtle (Macroclemys temminckii) along the lower Apalachicola River, Florida. Final Rep. NG89-020, Nongame Wildlife Prog. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Fitzpatrick, J. W., G. E. Woolfenden, and M. T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related habitat requirements of the Florida scrub jay (Aphelocoma coerulescens coerulescens). Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 8, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003. Management Plan Red-Cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis. Tallahassee, FI. 78 pp. Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003, October 8. Florida's Waterbird Colony Locator. http://www.myfwc.com/waders. Florida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2006. Eagle nest locator. http://wld.fwc.state.fl.us/eagle/eaglenests. Florida Natural Areas Inventory. 1990. Guide to the natural communities of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory and Florida Dept. Natural Resources, Tallahassee. Franz, R. 1986. The Florida gopher frog and the Florida pine snake as burrow associates of the gopher tortoise in northern Florida. Pp. 16-20 in D. R. Jackson and R. J. Bryant (eds.). The gopher tortoise and its community. Proc. 5 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council, Gainesville, Florida. Franz. R., and L. M. Franz. 1979. Distribution, habitat preference and status of populations of the Black Creek crayfish, Procambarus (Ortmannicus) pictus (Decapoda: Cambaridae). Florida Sci. 42: 13-17. Franz, R., and L. L. Smith. 1999. Distribution and status of the striped newt and Florida gopher frog in peninsular Florida. Final Rep. Florida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm., Tallahassee. Gaby, R., M. P. McMahon, E J. Mazzotti, W. N. Gillies, and J. R. Wilcox. 1985. Ecology and status of a population of Crocodylus acutus (Reptilia: Crocodilidae) at a power plant site in Florida. J. Herpetol. 19: 189-198. Georgia Department of Natural Resources. 1999. Protected animals of Georgia. Nongame, Endangered Wildlife Program, Wildlife Res. Div., Georgia Dept. Nat. Res., Social Circle. Gilbert, C. R. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. vol, 4: Fishes. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville. _(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. II: Fishes. Univ. Press of Florida. Gainesville. Glassberg, J., M. C. Minno, and J. V. Calhoun. 2000. Butterflies through binoculars: a field, finding, and gardening guide to butterflies in Florida. Oxford Univ. Press, New York. Gordon, M. E., and W. R. Hoeh. 1993. Anodonta heardi,a new species of freshwater mussel (Bivalvia:Unionidae) trom the Apalachicola River system of the southeastern United States. Walkerana 7:265-273. Gore, J. A., and M. J. Kinnison. 1991. Hatching success in roof and ground colonies of least terns. The Condor 93:759- 762. Renda Broadcasting Corp. Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008. 5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page I I Guillory, V. 1979. Lake Eustis pupfish investigations. Rorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission 1977-1979 Final Report: Study I-N. Tallahassee. Guillory, V., and W. E. Johnson. 1986. Habitat, conservation status, and zoogeography of the cyprinodont fish. Cyprinodon variegatus hubbsi (Carr). The Southwestern Nat. 31 (1 ):95-1 00. Hall, E. R. 1981. Mammals of North America. 2 nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Harvey, M. J. 1992. Bats of the eastern United States. Arkansas Game and Fish Comm., Little Rock. Hersh, S.L. 1981. Ecology of the Key Largo woodrat (Neostoma f10ridana smalli). J. Mammal. 62:201-206. Hipes, D., D. R. Jackson, K. NeSmith, D. Printiss and K. Brandt. 2001. Field guide to the rare animals of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee. Hirth, H. F. 1971. Synopsis of the biological data on the green turtle Chelonia mydas (Linnaeus) 1758. FAO Fish. Synopsis 85. Hobbs, H. H., Jr. 1942. The crayfishes of Rorida. Univ. Rorida Publ., BioI. Sci. Ser. 3(2): 1-179. Hoehn, T. S. 1998. Rare and imperiled fish species of Florida: a watershed perspective. Office Envir. Serv., Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Hovis, J. A., and M. S. Robson. 1989. Breeding status and distribution of the least tern in the Florida Keys. Rorida Field Nat. 17(3):61-66. Humphrey, S. R. (ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. I: Mammals. Univ. Press of Rorida, Gainesville Humphrey, S. R. 1988. Density estimates of the endangered Key Largo woodrat and cotton mouse (Neotoma f10ridana smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola) using the nested-grid approach. J. Mammal. 69(3):524-531. Humphrey, S. R.. and H. W. Setzer. 1989. Geographic variation and taxonomic revision of mink (Mustela vison) in Rorida. J. Mammal. 17:382-392. Hurst, H. N., G. Bass, and C. Hubbs. 1975. The biology of the Guadalupe, Suwannee, and redeye basses. Pp. 47-53 in R. H. Stroud and H. Clepper (eds.). Black bass biology and management. Sport Fishing 1nstitute,Washington, D.C. Jackson, D. R.. and R. Franz. 1999. Survey for the fire-back crayfish in the Apalachicola ravine system, northern Florida. Final report to The Nature Conservancy. Rorida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee. Jackson, D. R., and E. G. Milstrey. 1989. The fauna of gopher tortoise burrows. Pp. 86-98 in J. E. Diemer, D. R. Jackson, J. L. Landers, J. N. Layne, and D. A. Wood. eds. Gopher Tortoise Relocation Symposium Proceedings. Nongame Wildl. Program Tech. Rep. no. 5. Rorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Jackson, D. R., and R. N. Walker. 1997. Reproduction in the Suwannee cooter, Pseudemys concinna suwanniensis. Bull. Florida Mus. Nat. Hist. 41:69-167. Jackson, J. F. 1973. Distribution and population phenetics of the Rorida scrub lizard, Sceloporus woodi. Copeia 1973:746-761. Jackson, J. F., and S. R. Telford. 1974. Reproductive ecology of the Rorida scrub lizard, Sceloporus woodi. Copeia 1974:689-694. James, F. C. 1991. Signs of trouble in the largest remaining population of red-cockaded woodpeckers. Auk 108:419- 423. Johnson, S. A. 2001. Autecology of the striped newt (Notophthalmus perstriatus): life-history, upland-habitat use, paedomorphosis, and conservation genetics. Ph.D. diss., Univ. Florida. Gainesville. Kale, H. W., 11. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Rorida. Vol. 2. Birds. Univ. Presses of Rorida, Gainesville. Kale, H. W., 11.. B. Pranty, B. Stith, and W. Biggs. 1992. An atlas of Florida's breeding birds. Final Rep. Nongame Wildlife Prog., Rorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Keppner, E. J., and L. A. Keppner. 2000. A preliminary search for the Panama City crayfish, Procambarus (Leconticambarus) econfinae, Hobbs, 1942, in Bay County, Florida. Report to U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Panama City, Florida. Knisley, C. B., and 1. M. Hill. 1994. Studies of the Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: distribution, abundance, habitat characteristics and biology. Report to U.S. Fish WildL Serv., Jacksonville, Florida. ~. 1996. The Florida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: habitat requirements, remaining range, life history, and management. Final Rep. Rorida Nongame Wildlife Prog. NG91-012. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Kulhavey, D. L., R. G. Hooper. and R. Costa (eds.). t995. Red-cockaded woodpecker: recovery, ecology, and management. Center for Applied Studies in Forests, College of Forestry, Stephen F. Austin State Univ., Nacogdoches, Texas. Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008,5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 12 Kushlan, J. A. 1974. Observations on the role of the American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) in the southern Aorida wetlands. Copeia 1974:993-996. _, and F. J. Mazzotti. 1989. Population biology of the American crocodile. J. Herpetol. 23:7-21. Lazell. J. D., Jr. 1989. Wildlife of the Aorida Keys: a natural history. Island Press, Washington, D.C. Layne, J. N. 1990. The Florida mouse. Pp. 1-21 in C. K. Dodd, Jr., R. E. Ashton, Jr., R. Franz, and E. Wester (eds.). Burrow Associates of the Gopher Tortoise. Proc. 8 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council. Aorida Mus. Nat. Hist., Gainesville. Loftin, R. W. 1992. Use of nest boxes by the Aorida kestrel. Aorida Field Nat. 20(3):57-64. McMillian. M. 200 I. Aorida Important Bird Areas Program. site nomination fonn -Lake Istokpoga, Audubon of Aorida. Tampa Bay Sanctuaries. McNair, D. B., and J. A. Gore. 1999. Recent breeding status of royal and sandwich terns in northwest Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(3):117-120. Maehr, D. S. 1987. Florida panther movements, social organization, and habitat utilization. E-I-II annual perfonnance report. Florida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm., Tallahassee. Martin. W. H., and D. B. Means. 1998. Distribution and habitat relationships of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake (Crotalus adamanteus). Herpetological Nat. Hist. 7:9-34. Means, D. B. 1975. Competitive exclusion along a habitat gradient between two species of salamanders (Desmognathus) in western Florida. J. Biogeog. 2:253- 263. Means, D. B., and A. A. Karlan. 1989. A new species of Desmognathus from the eastern Gulf Coastal Plain. Herpetologica 45:37-46. Means, D. B., and C. 1. Longden. 1970. Observations on the occurrence of Desmognathus monticola in Aorida. Herpetologica 26:396-399. _' 1976. Aspects of the biology and zoogeography of the pine barrens treefrog, Hyla andersonii. in northern Florida. Herpetologica 32: 117-130. Means, D. B., and P. E. Moler. 1979. The pine barrens treefrog: fire, seepage bogs, and management implications. Pp. 77-83 in R. R. Odom and L. Landers (eds.). Proc. rare and endangered wildlife symposium. Georgia Dept. Nat. Res.. Game and Fish Div. Tech. Bull. WL-4. Meylan. A. B. 1999. Status of the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region. Chelonian Cons. BioI. 3:177.184. _, and M. Donnelly. 1999. Status justification for listing the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) as Critically Endangered on the 1996 IUCN Red List of Threatened Animals. Chelonian Cons. BioI. 3:200-224. Mettee. M. F., P. E. O'Neil, and J. M. Pierson. 1996. Fishes of Alabama and the Mobile Basin. Oxmoor House, Inc.. Birmingham, Alabama. Minno, M. c., and D. Pierce. 1999. Florida butterfly gardening: A complete guide to attracting, identifying, and enjoying butterflies of the lower south. Univ. Press of Florida. Gainesville. Mitchell, J. C. 1977. Geographic variation ofElaphe guttata (Reptilia: Serpentes) in the Atlantic coastal plain. Copeia 1977:33-41. Moler, P. E. 1981. Notes on Hyla andersonii in Florida and Alabama. 1. Herpetol. 15:441-444. _' 1985. A new species offrog (Ranidae: Rana) from northwestern Aorida. Copeia 1985:379-383. _(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. III: Amphibians and reptiles. Univ. Press of Aorida, Gainesville, _' 1996. Alligator snapping turtle: distribution and relative abundance. Final report 7544. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Mount, R. H. 1975. The reptiles and amphibians of Alabama. Auburn Univ. Agric. Exp. Station, Auburn, Alabama. Myers, R. L., and J. J. Ewel (eds.) 1990. Ecosystems of Aorida. Univ. Central Florida Press, Orlando. NatureServe. 2006. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 5.0. NatureServe, Arlington, Virginia. http://www,natureserve,org/explorer. Neill, W. T. 1971. The last of the ruling reptiles: alligators, crocodiles, and their kin. Columbia Univ. Press, New York. Page, L. M., and B. M. Burr. 1998. A field guide to freshwater fishes: North America north of Mexico, 2nd ed. Houghton Mifflin, Boston. Paul, R. T. 1991. Status report - Egretta rufescens (Gmelin) reddish egret. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Houston, Texas. _' and A. F. Schnapf. 2000. Aorida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomina-tion fonn - Passage Key National Wildlife Refuge, Audubon of Aorida. Tampa Bay Sanctuaries. Pennak, R. W. 1978. Fresh-water invertebrates of the United States. 2nd ed. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Renda Broadca~ting Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 0]] PID 00405160008, 5860 Crew~ Rd. Li~ted Specie~ Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 13 Peterson, R.T. 1998. Peterson field guide to eastern birds. 4th ed. Houghton Mifflin, Boston. Petranka, J. W. 1998. Salamanders of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Inst. Press, Washington, D.C. Pilsbry, H. A. 1946. Land Mollusca of North America, Vol. 2, part 1. Monograph of the Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia. Pimm, S. (ed.). 2000. The 2000 Cape Sable sparrow annual report. Accessed 2001 May 8. Poole, A., and F. Gill (eds.). 1992-2000. The birds of North America. The Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia, and The American Ornithologists' Union, Washington, D.C. Post, W., and J. S. Greenlaw. 2000. The present and future of the Cape Sable seaside sparrow. Aorida Field Nat. 28(3):93-110. Pranty, B. 1996. A birder's guide to Aorida. American Birding Association, Inc., Colorado Springs, Colorado. Printiss, D. J., and D. L. Hipes. 1999. Rare amphibian and reptile survey of Eglin Air Force Base, Aorida. Final report to U.S. Dept. of Defense. Aorida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee. Pritchard, P. C. H. 1989. The alligator snapping turtle: biology and conservation. Milwaukee Publ. Mus., Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Quay, T. L., 1. B. Funderburg, Jr., D. S. Lee, E. F. Potter, and C. S. Robbins (eds.). 1983. The seaside sparrow, its biology and management. Occ. Papers, North arolina BioI. Surv. North Carolina State Mus. Nat. Hist., Raleigh. Relyea, K., and B. Sutton. 1975. A new troglobitic crayfish of the genus Procambarus from Aorida. (Decapoda: Astacidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot. 19(1-2):8-16. Rice, D. W. 1957. Life history and ecology of Myotis austroriparius in Aorida. J. Mammal. 38: 15-32. Robbins, C. S., B. Bruun, and H. S. Zim. 2001. Birds of North America: a guide to field identification. St. Martin's Press, New York. Rodgers, J. A., and H. T. Smith. 1995. Set-back distances to protect nesting bird colonies from human disturbance in Aorida. Conserv. BioI. 9:89-99. Rodgers, J. A., Jr., H. W. Kale II, and H. T. Smith (eds.). 1996. Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. V: Birds. Univ. Press of Aorida, Gainesville. Robertson, W. B., Jr., and G. E. Woolfenden. 1992. Aorida bird species: an annotated list. Aorida Ornithol. Soc. Spec. Pub. no. 6: ix + 260. Roosenburg, W. M. 2000. Impact of a bycatch reduction device on diamondback terrapin and blue crab capture in crab pots. Ecol. Applic. 10:882-889. Ross, J. P., S. Beavers, D. Mundell, and M. Airth-Kindree. 1989. The status of Kemp's ridley. Center Marine Conserv., Washington, D.C. Runde, D., J. Gore, J. Hovis, M. Robson, and P. Southall. 1991. Florida atlas of breeding sites for herons and their allies: update 1986 - 1989. Nongame Wildlife Program Tech. Rep. no. 10. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Semlitsch, R. D. 1983. Structure and dynamics of two breeding populations of the eastern tiger salamander, Ambystoma tigrinum. Copeia 1983:608-616. Shealy, R. M. 1976. The natural history of the Alabama map turtle, Graptemys pu1chra Baur, in Alabama. Bull. Florida State Mus., BioI. Sci. 21:47-11. Shriver, G. W., P. D. Vickery, and S. A. Hedges. 1996. Effects of summer burns on Aorida grasshopper sparrows. Aorida Field Nat. 24(3):68-73. Sibley, D. A. 2000. The Sibley guide to birds. Alfred A. Knopf, New York. Spotila, J. R., A. E. Dunham, A. J. Leslie, A. C. Steyermark, P. T. Plotkin, and F. V. Paladino. 1996. Worldwide population decline of Derrnochelys coriacea: are leatherback turtles going extinct" Chelonian Cons. BioI. 2:209-222. Sprandel, G. L., J. A. Gore, and D. T. Cobb. 1997. Winter shorebird survey. Aorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm. Final Perf. Rep. Tallahassee. Stevenson, H. M. 1970. Occurrence of the carpenter frog in Florida. Quart. J. Florida Acad. Sci. 32:233-235. _, and B. H. Anderson. 1994. The birdlife of Florida. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville. Stys, B. 1993. Ecology and habitat protection needs of the southeastern American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) on large-scale development sites in Florida. Nongame Wildl. Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 13. Aorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Telt'lfd, S. R. 1959. A study of the sand skink, Neoseps reynoldsi. Copeia 1959: I 00- 119. Tenant, A. 1997. A field guide to snakes of Florida. Gulf Publ. Co., Houston, Texas. Renda Broadca~ting Corp, B]ack & Veatch Tampa 0] 1 PID 00405]60008,5860 Crews Rd. Li~ted Specie~ Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 14 Timmerman, W. W. 1989. Home range, habitat use and behavior of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake. M. S. thesis, Univ. Florida, Gainesville. Thaxton, J. E., and T. M. Hingtgen. 1996. Effects of suburbanization and habitat fragmentation on Aorida scrub-jay dispersal. Florida Field Nat. 24(2):25-37. Toland, B. 1999a. Nesting success and productivity of Florida sandhill cranes on natural and developed sites in southeastern Aorida. Florida Field Nat. 27(1): I 0- 13. _' I 999b. Nest site characteristics, breeding phenology, and nesting success of American oystercatchers in Indian River County, Aorida. Florida Field Nat. 27(3): 112-116. Tuberville, T D., J. R. Bodie, J. B. Jensen, L. LaClaire, and 1. W. Gibbons. 2000. Apparent decline of the southern hog- nosed snake, Heterodon simus. J. Elisha Mitchell Soc. 116: 19-40. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1982. Stock Island tree snail recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. _' 1984. American crocodile recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. _' 1987. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; proposed threatened status for two Florida lizards. Fed. Reg. 52(13):2242-2246. _' 1998a. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants: 90-day finding for a petition to delist the Squirrel Chimney cave shrimp. Fed. Reg. 63:67618-67619. _' 1998b. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; determination of endangered status for five freshwater mussels and threatened status for two freshwater mussels from the eastem Gulf Slope drainages of Alabama, Aorida, and Georgia. Fed. Reg. 63(50):12664-12687. _' 1998c. Okaloosa darter (Etheostoma okaloosae) recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildl. Servo Atlanta, Georgia. _.1999. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; final rule to list the tlatwoods salamander as a threatened species. Fed. Reg. 64: 15691-15704. _. 1999. South Aorida Multi-Species Recovery Plan U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. 2172 pp. _. 2000. Candidate and listing priority assignment form: Cicindela highlandensis. _.2006. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service The Endangered Species Program [web application]. US Fish & Wildlife Service. Washington, D.C. http://www.fws.gov/endangered U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and Gulf States Marine Fisheries Commission. 1995.Gulf Sturgeon Recovery Plan. Atlanta, Georgia. Walls, J. G. 1976. Fishes of the northern Gulf of Mexico. T. F. H. Publications, Inc., Ltd., Hong Kong. Whitaker, J. O. 1996. National Audubon Society field guide to North American mammals. Alfred A. Knopf, New York. Williams,1. D., and G. H. Burgess. 1999. A new species of bass, Micropterus cataractae (Teleostei: Centrarchidae), from the Apalachicola River basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Bull. Aorida Mus. Nat. Hist. 42(2):81- 114. Witzell, W. N. 1983. Synopsis of the biological data on the hawksbill turtle Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus, 1766). FAO Fish. Synopsis 137. Wood, P. B., M. L. Hoffman, M. W. Collopy, and J. M. Schaefer. 1988. Southeastern American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) natural history, life requirements, and habitat protection guidelines. Final report to Office of Envir. Services, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Woods, C. A., W. Post, and C. W. Kilpatrick. 1982. Microtus pennsylvanicus (Rodentia; Muridae) in Aorida: a Pleistocene relict in a coastal saltmarsh. Bull. Florida State Mus. BioI. Sci. 28:25-52. Wooley, C. M., and E. J. Crateau. 1985. Movement, microhabitat, exploitation, and management of Gulf of Mexico sturgeon, Apalachicola River, Florida. North American 1. Fisheries Manag. 5:590-605. Wunderlin, R.P. 1998. Guide to the vascular plants of Florida. University Presses of Florida, Gainesville, Florida Zambrano, R., M. S. Robson, D. Y. Charnetzky, and H. T. Smith. 1997. Distribution and status of least tern nesting colonies in southeast Florida. Florida Field Nat. 25(3):85-91. Zambrano, R., R., H. T. Smith, and M. Robson. 2000. Summary of breeding roseate terns in the Florida Keys: 1974- 1998. Florida Field Nat. 28(2):64-68. PROJECT LOCATION MAP COlliER COUNTY, Fl 5 , o 5 10 15 Miles , N PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 1. Project Location Map; Ramsev Inc. Environmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples. FL 34120 239.564.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. ~ PROJECT LOCATION - DETAIL MAP - ~~IM~ ~ II Il-~ fr1; ~ ~ \\\\\iY ~ ~a ! ;;; IF j!fit ~ ~ ~ T~ c< ~ ~ I jfiJ bAVIS BLvn c-t b I/.:::...-- ~ L JI \ L - ~ r ~~ = o;u II 0 ~ '" \;\ ~::;" ~_ ~c,t) ~~ ) 1 \ L.-j LL ! -I r , I I I I ; :~ ~ l~d o:i z ! ,--t !l eRE IS RD. u ~ ) I IIII1 I '@ ~ ~ III '~~ m ~ ,\\ I ,tr;; IJlfi'b ~ll 1-IEJv~ ~~~ ),..0 ~6 =:J 0:=0 J ~ ~ ~ l= -= - = = - - 'I ..-r- f- - ~ ~ HIIIJ1 ~~ f=lI ~~:I II ~~ I ~/; -OQ~ '"~ ~ ~ III C~ ~ ll/lllDl\1 d~ iW=k- f-- ~ ~ urr-1 I;, 0~ _'~ \ I I l If PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 + Figure 2. Project Location Detail Map; Ramsev Inc. Envlronmenial Consultin9 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!.FL 34120 239.5_.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. FLUCFCS HABITAT MAP & WILDLIFE SURVEY ROUTES 330FT \ ~ *""" << v< :><::x '/"/,;x ;x ;x X x:>< x:>< >> ,,('<;x x "'~ >x,;x,;x. x:><x >& v<>< x <- -/ "'x X"/ x<;:x X ><y Xy ~x:>< V' >6< ~ Xv-- >0< x "Y '" x:; vx >< >Q< x< >& X,;x ,;x ;x >0< x x x< ><-x>'x >< :>< x5<:'X x x :; :>< .,/ .,/ x> "Y ~ ....?< <x x<>< x<>< x ,;x x >& >& x .? '<x -<; ".X>< x:>< >0< "Y <'> >0< x ,;x ~ ><.,?'- :>< x x ~ ~ ~ x x <:><'- x:. x:>< ,;x 'X x'-' :>< x X 'X ,;x,;x :><::x x x; x >0< x ~~ <Xx x ex :>< J<- ><x "X5 '" ~ x :>< x:<><>< x x x:< :>< ><x xxx ,;x,;x. -9 :.;x /X x:>< x<><<<x x:>< x<< :x< :x '" yx ^ :::>< x 'J x 9< 5<~ x <x x:>< "I. ><~ :>0< >eX 8?< x x <>< x ,;x x ex ~~>/ I :><>< :.;x ~:><>< ;x ~ 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEPlSFWMD JURIS. WETLAND USACOE JURIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.06 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC JI"1"I'1'lI 740310 IEI333I DISTURBED LAND I GRASS PRAIRIE DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE UPLAND #30.15 AC D 7408212 DISTURBED LAND I COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE UPLAND #4 0.38 AC r0] 7408145 ~ DISTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE UPLAND #5 0.22 AC t: o C'l CD 419 ~ OTHER PINE ~ DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE JURIS. WETLAND #6 0.15 AC #7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY . TOWER # , , SURVEY TRANSECT , ;;. " ________ 0, -------C'l-- , . "- ~~ :><>< ><,; X 4 ~ '\ t>< >< ~ ~ . "~l"- >< ~X xx ~~ X~ :x >6< >& x XXv<:? \:'><" ,;xx ~~~'"-I ~~~ ~~~0 ~~~ x x ~ x x\~'\ 0-" h ~ x ;X >< ~ :;:;x x :>< ~~,,~~~~ x x >< X "" 0: ~~ 0' ~ I Tll.Z~ I CREWS ROAD ROW PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. + Ramsev Inc. Envlronmenial Consultin9 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!, FL 34120 239.5_.1660 Figure 3. FLUCFCS habitat and wildlife survey routes map. BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Ywn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. LIST OF USFWS AND FWC PROTECTED SPECIES FOR COLLIER CO., FL. AS OF 10/08/08 COMMON NAME SCIENnFIC NAME DESIGNATED STATUS Z008 2008 O'WO O'W, AMPHIBIANS l,~'p~rfrog Rallam";/,, SSC1I,2j BIRDS r:ap~Sable'ea'i:.le'pamlw Ammo,["'m".I' maritima,,- mira/lili,\' " E HHilagl1l"",'pperspamlw A",mOl/romu,' ,1'(I\.till/1IIm", .I]oridllm. E E Fl:lrida ,,'IID j~y Al'he!t,comanu-,ru/e,,,'''/I,\' T T '""{lkin Aramu.'.~""mUi'" sse I]) Albe"e"uni,."lanll (.4thl'lI" FbriJabumm.;ngowl """ieu/arlaflorid"",,) sse I]) i'~)1);-bjl'ed wmdpecker C"m{X'I,hilu.\'l"ill('il'"li.\' E E Cuban-I"IKlw'ypl.wer C1l1lt'(ulriu'\lIk'.wndri"ul' T pipingpklver OUlrluhlu.,'mr'/odu," T T Kinl.mll',wamler IJl'mlmiwkirtkmt/ii E E ittleblue hl'TIln Egrelt(lca,'m/ell SSC(lAI reddi,hegrl"t EKrl'llaruf".ln'I1." SSCllA) ~ro.m')'egrel ExreUatllllu, SSC(I) rri.'okJrerlheron E/:rellalrim/or 55C(I.4) whireibi, Eudocimu,\'ulbu" SSC(21 pere~fal()n FubJl'ere,~rillu" E S()uthea<lemAII~ri:anke<trel Foh'o,,!mn-<'r;U,\'I>lIulu,I' T H)T'da<a....lhiUemne Gru,\'nwaden,\'i.'pmll'll,\i,\' T Alnelil:al1o>~len:ateher HaeJ)III/0I'u.\'11OIJiatU.\' SSC(I.2) baljeag~ Halilll"'/u,\'kUUJceplorllu'I' T "'\lod ~(()rk M\'('ll"rioamninmu E E b!\lWnpelil.'an l'l"leumu.I'o",'h/eHlali" 55('(11 E Itxl-wdadt:dw()odpeeker /'il"Oil!n'lmreali" SSC , m"eare<poonbill Phua!nl (1;(1;11 (Ajaia ajaja) SSC'(I.41 l'olvlwm"l'hmcu.\'lIudlll"mii ~n:'ted ~amtara (C(lrtlcam('h<"n'~'a-"J T T E~rg~ltle" "!\ailk~e Ro"lrhomu,,'wrialJili,"pl""lbeu,' E E bkKk ~ki"nlO;'r f(mdwl',\'lIi!:e, SSC(I) ~a'ltem S/"n1<1(111/;/Iamm T S/enur,[ollga/li(SI"n!al!ouNilllii fI),ealelem ,[(mgolliil T T Badl111lll'"warb~r Ven,,;nml/:>achmanii E FISH 'Illalltoolh,awfuh I'ri.\'li.\'I"'('li,,oIO E nvuJu.; (llllngmve nvuus) Hirulu,,'mannont/u,\' sse III '1AM!\1AIS seiwhale HohWI"'I'lem/!Of<'oli,\' E finwha~(finbal'kwhale) nolt"'lIlJpleml'h\'wllu,I' E E Eu/mltlellllNloriali.\ (Hnhwnll ~()rthAlb.llIielightwhale glacioli,I'[;nd.llu,'/mli,I'11 E E Fl.Hidallll'liffbal Eum(JIJ.\',~hll"'i,,u.I'fl'Jri(lm'I"\' t, humphUl'kwhale M"XlIl'lertlll""(/<'lIl1g!;,w E , Caribbean nlmk ,eal Mo/1<Id"',I'I"'l'indi,I' E F.l'\:rg'Qo:lesmink MII.I'Idll ,'i,IVII <"I'aglmhl,,'II' , spennwha~ 1'I'.I',\'/'lermIlC"'C"I'II"lu,\' E HHilapamher I'umo IFdl,j ('o))/'ok"wr1'i E E BigCiPrcssfox <(Iuirrel .)('iuru,I'lIigaoriCl'1l/1io T Tricl",cIIII,\'mallll/u,\'kllim,I'lri,,' Fhrila/Wesrlndiilnl1l.H1alee (Trl('hcC!lI/,''''<IIJ(I/u,'j E E Fbrilabluekbear Url'U,"(II!It'r;<'<IlIu.\'fhJri,/(IIIU.\' T' REPTII.ES Alneocan ~lIig:m"r Alliga/,)J'mi,si,\'"IP!JI",J.\'j,\' SSC(U) TS/A bggerl1ea<l>eaturtle C"rellll('lIrello T T greensearurtle Ch,.[(lJlilllllydtl.\, E E,&Th Ameocanl'nX\,dile CrowdylJ/.'iI("UIiI,\' E T leal~rba~k'eah.a11e !Jennuch"'y",'oriiln'lI E E Ea<remin.ligo"nake !Jrymllr("/u!II('()mi,,'('{Jup<'ri 1 T hawbbillseanlrtle t:rellllocll<'lniIllIJriw/a E E gophertmtoi.<;e GOJ1/reru,"l'o'-IJ1/lI'mu,\' T Keltl'\rilleysealUltle L<'I,idodwlr,I'kI'JIlf1ii r E INVERTEBRATFS MOLI.lISKS Fbrilalree,nail LiXUII,I'fll,\'(';'llu,I' SSC(II P1AN'~ (NOM'! Project: Figure 4. List of USFWS and FWC protected species for Collier Co., Fl. RENDA BROADCASTING CORP, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 RENDA, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 01 I, 5860 Crews Road, pm 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsey Inc. En~ironmental COIl~u1ting 26JI4'"SLNW NapJe~,FL J4120 239.564.1660 PROTECTED SPECIES/WILDLIFE FIELD SURVEY SHEET CUMLA TIVE TOTALS PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09/24-10/04/2008 ALL SURVEYS AM & PM TOTAL COUNT MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0630 AM 1945 PM 0-15 69-83 F NONE 10-80 % DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE TOTAL COUNT 1 14 7 11 2 27 1 23 3 15 15 2 4 Project: RENDA BROADCASTING CORP, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 Figure 5. Cumulative totals for Protected Species / Wildlife Survey. Daily field sheets in Appendix C. RENDA, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, pm 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsey Inc. Environmental ConsuJting 2631 4111 St. NW Naples, FL 34]20 239.564.1660 EAGLE NEST MAP OCTOBER 2008 . 2008 EAGLE Nest Locetlons Collier _ Renda Parcel /\I Roads < \.. . N PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 6. Location of Eagles Nests In Coller Co. as of October 2008.; source FWC eagle website. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmen'tal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!,FL 34120 239.5_.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. PANTHER TELEMETRY 1981-2007 I . . . . . . , r ... , ... . ,.. ... ,. ~..,. . . \ ....;. , , , , , ,. . .~ . -. N Roads . Panther telemetry data 1981 2002 . Panther telemetry data 2003 2006 . Panther telemetry data 2007 _ RENDA PARCEL N. Panther Habitat Focus Area 2006 Dee ~.~ Original Panther Consultation Area 1\1IIII Panther secondary zone _ Panther primary zone PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. +E Ramsev Inc. Envlronmedl:al Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!,FL 34120 239.5_.1660 Figure 7 Panther telemetry form 1981-2007 In Coller Co. Source FWC. BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. BEAR TELEMETRY 1983-2000 , .t-<' I L11111 . . pm I . . . . . ... . . . .. · -1'.". · ... · .}i... ,. ... · I ..... '" . . . .. . Black bear telem fl1983 2000 _ RENDA PARCEL /\I ROADS . . PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. + Figure 8. Black Bear Telemetry in Colier Co. 1983-2000. Source FWC. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmen'tal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!, FL 34120 239.5_.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Ywn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. BEAR NUSIANCE LOCATIONS 1980-2006 I '~ 1lliJJJ . . . . . . '\. . Bear_nuisance_1980-2006 _ RENDA PARCEL /\I ROADS PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Fi9ure 9. Black Bear Nusiance Locations In Coller Co. 1980-2006. Source FWC. Ramsev Inc. Environmental Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples,FL 34120 239.56...1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. APPENDIX A. FLORIDA'S ENDANGERED SPECIES, THREATENED SPECIES, AND SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN November 2007 FLORIDA FISH AND WILDLIFE CONSERVATION COMMISSION APPENDIX A. CONTENTS PREF ACE.......................................................................................................................... ii NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN.... 1 OFFICIAL LISTS ....................................................................................................... 1 FISH.................. .................... ......................... .................................. .............................. 2 AMPHIBIANS............................................................................................................... 2 REPTILES............ ......... .............. ......... .............. .................................. ........ ................. 2 BIRDS ............... .................... ......... ................ ............................ ...... .............................. 3 MAMMALS...................................................................................................................4 INVERTEBRATES ...................................................................................................... 6 CORALS .................................................................................................................... 6 CRUST ACEANS....................................................................................................... 6 INSECTS........... ........ ............................ ........... ........... ......................... ....... .............. 6 MOLLUSKS .............................................................................................................. 6 KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATIONS........................................................ 7 APPENDIX A. PREFACE This document consolidates thc official state of Florida list of endangered species, threatened specics, and species of special concern. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) maintains the state list of animals designated as endangered, threatened, or species of special concern, in accordance with Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and 68A-27.005, respectively, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.) htto://fac.dos.state.tl.us/. The state lists of plants, which are designated endangered, threatened, and commercially exploited, are administered and maintained by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (DOACS) via Chaptcr 5B-40, F.A.C. This list of plants can be obtained at htto://www.fl- dof.com/forcst management/olant conscrvc list.html. The federal agencies that share the authority to list species as Endangered and Threatened are the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration-National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA-NMFS) and U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). The NOAA-NMFS is responsible for listing most marine species. The federal list of animals and plants is administered by the USFWS, and this list is published in 50 CFR 17 (animals) and 50 CFR 23 (plants). Additional information regarding federal listings can bc located at the following websites; NOAA-NMFS htto://www.nmfs.noaa.govandUSFWS-htto://cndangcrcd.fws.gov/wildlifc.html#Soccics. Please note that while thc FWC has published a consolidated list of state and fedcrally listed species in the past, we now only publish a list of species listed within the state of Florida. This list will be maintained and available at our agency website: htto://www.mvfwc.com. Lists of fcderally listed species can still be viewed at the USFWS and NOAA-NMFS wcbsites mentioncd above. It is our intent by providing the list in this manner that we will be able to maintain a current list that is more readily available to the public. I would like to thank thc following people who assisted in revising this list; Tom Logan, Jeff Gorc, Paul Vincent, Paul Moler, George Wallacc, Jim Rodgers, Karl Miller, Ted Hoehn, Darrell Scovell, Gray Bass, Kelly Donnelly, Elsa Haubold, Kipp Frohlich, Bill Brooks and the USFWS staff. Special appreciation is expresscd to Ms. Angela T. Williams, Ms. Christine Yannctt and Ms. Kat Dicrsen for their assistance with preparation of this document. . Common and scientific names listed first are as they appear in the FWC "Florida Wildlife Code Title 68A" (F .A.C). Common and/or scientific names following this and located within parentheses ( ) contain names as used by USFWS, or other commonly used names. Bradley J. Gruver, Ph. D Endangered Species Coordinator Species Conservation Planning Section Cover Photos by FWC Staff: Key Largo Woodrat, Burrowing Owls, Okaloosa Darter, Schaus' swallowtail butterfly, Short-tailed Snake. t1 APPENDIX A. NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE ST ATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN STATUS DESIGNATION FISH AMPHIBIANS REPTILES BIRDS MAMMALS INVERTEBRATES TOTAL E 3 0 6 8 20 4 41 T 2 0 11 10 4 0 27 sse 10 5 7 18 6 4 50 TOTAL 15 5 24 36 30 8 1I8 APPENDIX A. OFFICIAL LISTS Common Name Scientific Name Statns FISH Atlantic sturgeon Acipenser oxyrinchus SSC(I) (Gulf sturgeon) (Acivenser oxvrinchus desotoi1 shortnose sturgeon Acivenser brevirostrum E shoal bass Microvterus cataractae sse 11 ,2) Suwannee bass Microvterus not ius sse (]) ri vu Ius Rivulus marmoratus sse (I) (mangrove rivulus) Lake Eustis pupfish Cvvrinodon varielZatus hubbsi sse (]) blackmouth shiner Notrovis melanostomus E blucnose shiner Pteronotrovis welaka sse (1,2) saltmarsh topminnow Fundulus ienkinsi sse 11) key silverside Menidia concho rum T crystal darter Crvstallaria asvrella T harlcauin dartcr Etheostoma his trio sse (i) okaloosa darter Etheostoma okalossae E Southern tessellated darter Etheostoma olmstedi sse (I) (tessellated iohnnv darter) maculaticevs key blennv Starksia starcki sse (]) AMPHIBIANS flatwoods salamander Ambvstoma cinwlatum sse Georgia blind salamander Haideotriton wallacei sse 11 ,2) pine barrens treefrog Hyla andersonii sse (]) Florida bog frog Rana okaloosae sse (2) gooher frog Rana capito sse 11 ,2) REPTILES American alligator Alligator mississippiensis sse (1,3) American crocodilc Crocodvlus acutus E key ringneck snake Diadovhis vunetatus acrieus T Eastcrn indigo snakc Drvmarchon corais couveri T red rat snake Elaphe guttata sse](\) Atlantic salt marsh water snake Nerodia clarkii taeniata T (Atlantic salt marsh snake) 2 Common Name Scientific Name APPENDIX A. Status Florida pine snake Pituophis melanoleueus sse (2) mUf!.itus short-tailed snake Stilosoma extenuatum T Florida brown snake Storeria dekayi vieta TI rim rock crowned snake Tantilla oolitiea T Florida ribbon snake Thamnophis sauritus saekeni TI bluctail mole skink Eumeees ef!ref!ius lividus T Florida Kev mole skink Eumeees ezrezius ezrezius sse (]) sand skink Neoseps reynoldsi T I!onher tortoise Govherus volvvhemus T Barbour's man turtle Graptemys barbouri sse (] ,2) allil!ator snanninl! turtle Macroclemvs temminekii sse (]) striped mud turtle Kinosternon baurii EI Suwannee cooter Pseudemys eoneinna sse (1,2) suwanniensis loggerhead seaturtlc Caretta earetta T (lo",wrhead sea turtle) green seaturtle Chelonia mydas E (green sea turtle) leatherback seaturtle Dermoehelys eoriaeea E (leatherback sea turtle) hawksbill seaturtle Eretmoehelys imbricata E (hawksbill sea turtle) Kemp's ridley scaturtle Lepidoehelys kempii E (Kemn's ridlev sea turtle) BIRDS piping plover Charadrius melodus T snowy plover Charadrius alexandrinus T (ettbansnowvnlover) American ovstercatcher Haematovus valliatus sse (1,2) brown nelican Peleeanus oecidentalis sse (]) black skimmer Rvnehovs nizer ssem least tern Sterna antillarum T roseate tern Sterna dougalli T (Sterna douf!.allii dOUfWllii) limpkin Aramus zuarauna ssem reddish el!ret Ef!.retta rufeseens sse (] ,4) snowy el!ret Ezretta thula sse (]) little blue heron Ef!.retta eaerulea sse (],4) tricolored heron Ef!.retta tricolor SSeO,4) 3 Common Name Scientific Name APPENDIX A. Status white ibis Eudocimus albus ssem Florida sandhill cranc Grus canadensis oratensis T whooping crane Grus americana sse (5) wood stork Mycteria americana E roseate spoonbill Platalea aiaia sse 11,4) burrowing owl Athene cunicularia sse (I) (Florida burrowing ow\) (Athene cunicularia floridana) crestcd caracara Caracara cheriway T (Audubon's crcsted caracara) (Polyborus plancus auduboniil oeregrine falcon Falco pererzrinus E Southeastern American kestrel Falco sparverius paulus T bald eagle Haliaeetus leucoceohalus T osprey Pandion haliaetus sse2 (1,2) snail kite Rostrhamus sociabilis E (Everglades snail kite) plumbeus Florida scrub iav Aphelocoma coerulescens T eape Sable seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus E mirabilis Florida grasshopper sparrow Ammodramus savannarum E floridanus Scott's scaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (I) peninsulae Wakulla seasidc sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (I) iuncicolus white-crowned oigeon Columba leucocephala T Kirtland's warbler Dendraica kirtlandii E Bachman's warbler Vermivora bachmanii E ivorY-billed woodnecker Campephilus principalis E red-cockaded woodoecker Picoides borealis sse Marian's marsh wren Cistothorus palustris marianae sse (1) Worthington's marsh wren Cistothorus palustris rzriseus sse (n MAMMALS Florida panther Puma concolor coryi E (Puma r=Felisl concolorcorvi) Florida black bear Ursus americanus floridanus T3 Evcrglades mink Mustela vison everrzladensis T key dccr Odocoileus virginian us E clavium 4 APPENDIX A. Common Name Scientific Name Status Lower Kevs marsh rabbit Sylvilaf!us valustris hefneri E Big Cypress fox squirrel Sciurus nif!er avicennia T Sherman's fox sauirrel Sciurus niger shermani SSC (1,2) Eastern chipmunk Tamias striatus SSC (]) Sanibel Island ricc rat Oryzomys palustris sanibeli SSC(I,2) silvcr rice rat Oryzomys argentatus E (ricc rat, lowcr FL Kevs) (Oryzomvs valustris natator) Kev Largo woodrat Neotoma floridana smalli E Key Largo Cotton Mouse Peromyscus gossypinus E allapaticola Choctawhatchee beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E allophrys Southeastern bcach mouse Peromyscus polionotus T niveiventris Anastasia Island beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E phasma St. Andrews beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E peninsularis Perdido Kcy beach mouse Peromyscus polionotus E trissyllevsis Florida mouse Podomvs floridanus SSC (I) Florida mastiff bat Eumops f!laucinus floridanus E gray bat Mvotis f!risescens E Indiana bat Myotis sodalis E Florida saltmarsh vole Microtus penmylvanicus E (Florida salt marsh vole) dukecampbelli Sherman's short-tailed shrew Blarina carolonensis SSC (2) r =brevicauda 1 shermani Homosassa shrew Sorex lonf!irostris eionis SSC (2) sei whale Balaenovtera borealis E fin whalc Balaenoptera physalus E (finback whale) North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena glacialis E (right whale) (Balaena glacialis line/. australis 1) humpback whale Mer<aptera novaeangliae E sperm whalc Phvseter macrocevhalus E Florida manatec Trichechus manatus latirostris E (West Indian manatee) (Trichechus manatus) . 5 Common Name Scientific Name APPENDIX A. Status INVERTEBRATES CORALS pillar coral DendroJ!Vra eylindrus E CRUSTACEANS Panama City crayfish Proeambarus eeonfinae sse (I) (econfina crayfish) sims sink crayfish Proeambarus erythrops sse (I) (Santa Fe cave crayfish) black creek crayfish Proeambarus vietus sse (1) INSECTS Miami blue butterfly Cyclargus [=Hermiargus] E thomasi bethunebakeri Schaus' swallowtail butterfly Heraclides aristodemus E poneeanus MOLLUSKS Florida tree snail Li~uus fasciatus sse (1) Stock Island trcc snail Orthalieus reses E Orthalicus reses [not incl. nesodryas 1 6 APPENDIX A. KEY TO ABBREVIA nONS AND NOT A nONS List Abbreviations FWC E= T= SSC= Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Endangered Threatened Species of Special Concern Reasons for SSC listings prior to January 1, 2001 are indicated by the number in parenthesis under the following criteria: (I) has a significant vulnerability to habitat modification, environmental alteration, human disturbance, or human exploitation which, in the foreseeablc future, may result in its becoming a threatened spccies unless appropriate protective or management tcchniques are initiated or maintained; (2) may alrcady meet certain critcria for designation as a threatened species but for which conclusive data are limited or lacking; (3) may occupy such an unusually vital or essential ecological niche that should it decline significantly in numbers or distribution other species would be adversely affected to a significant degree; (4) has not sufficiently rccovered from past population depletion, and (5) occurs as a population either intentionally introduced or being experimentally managed to attain specific objectives, and the species of special concern prohibitions in Rule 68A-27.002, F.A.C., shall not apply to species so designated, provided that thc intentional killing, attempting to kill, possession or sale of such species is prohibited. (FWC) I Lower keys population only. 2 Monroe County population only. Other than those found in Baker and Columbia Counties or in Apalachicola National Forest. 7 TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System Page 1 of 4 Florida Notes: APPENDIX A. US. Fish & Wildlife Service Threatened & Endangered Species System . This report shows the species listed in this state according to the Federal Register listing description. . This list does not include experimental populations and similarity of appearance listings. . This fist includes species or populations under the sole jurisdiction of the National Marine Fisheries Service. . Click on the highlighted scientific names below to view a Species Profile for each listing. Animals -- 59 Status T E E E T T T T E E E T E E E E E E E E T E E E Listed species (based on published population data) --114 listings Species/Listing Name ***NOTE: The green sea turtle is listed 2 times IInder animals. So the actual numher listed is- 58 Animals and 113 Total. Bankclimber, purple (mussel) (Elliptaideus slaatianus) Bat, gray (Myatis grisescens) Beetle, American burying (Nicrophorus americanus) Butterfly, Schaus swallowtail (HeracHdes aristodemus ponceanus) Caracara, Audubon's crested FL pop, (Polyborus plancus audubonil) Coral, elkhorn (Acropora palmata) Coral, staghorn (Acropora cervicornis) Crocodile, American FL pop. (Crocodylus acutus) Curlew, Eskimo (Numenius borealis) Darter, Okaloosa (Etheostoma oka/oasae) Deer, key (Odocoileus virginianus clavium) Jay, Florida scrub (Aphefocoma coerulescens) Kite, Everglade snail FL pop. (Rostrhamus saciabilis plumbeus) Manatee, West Indian (Trichechus manatus) Moccasinshell, Gulf (Medionidus penicillatus) Moccasinshell, Ochlockonee (Medionidus simpsonianus) Mouse, Anastasia Island beach (Peromyscus poHonotus phasma) Mouse, Choctawhatchee beach (Peromyscus polionotus allophrys) Mouse, Key Largo cotton (Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola) Mouse, Perdido Key beach (Peromyscus polionotus trissyllepsis) Mouse, southeastern beach (Peromyscus polionotus niveiventris) Mouse, S1. Andrew beach (Peromyscus polionotus peninsularis) Panther, Florida (Puma (=Fe/is) concolor caryl) Pelican, brown except U.s. Atlantic coast, FL, AL (Pelecanus accidentalis) http://ecos.fws.gov/tess_pttblic//pub/stateListing.j sp ?state= FL&s tatus=l i sted 10/8/2008 TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System E T E E E T E E T E E E T E T T T T T T T E E E T E T E E E E E E E E DI.....t'"'__1:;.1:;. APPENDIX A. Pigtoe, oval (Pleurobema pyriforme) Plover, piping except Great Lakes watershed (Charadrius melodus) Pocketbook, shinyrayed (Lamps/lis subangulata) Rabbit, Lower Keys marsh (Sylvilagus palustris hefnen) Rice rat lower FL Keys (Oryzomys palustris nalator) Salamander, flatwoods (Ambystoma cingulatum) Sawfish, smalltooth (Pristis pectinata) Sea turtle, green Fl, Mexico nesting pops. (Chelonia mydas) Sea turtle, green except where endangered (Chelonia mydas) Sea turtle, hawksbill (Eretmochelys imbricata) Sea turtle, Kemp's ridtey (Lepidochelys kempil) Sea turtle, leatherback (Dermochelys coriacea) Sea turtle, loggerhead (Carella caretta) Seal, Caribbean monk (Monachus tropicalis) Shrimp, Squirrel Chimney Cave (Palaemonetes cummingl) Skink, bluetail mole (Eumeces egregius lividus) Skink, sand (Neoseps reynoldsl) Slabshell, Chipola (Elliptio chipolaensis) Snail, Stock Island tree {Orthalicus reses (not incl. nesodryas)) Snake, Atlantic salt marsh (Nerodia c/arkii taeniata) Snake, eastern indigo (Drymarchon corais coupen) Sparrow, Cape Sable seaside (Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis) Sparrow, Florida grasshopper (Ammodramus savannarum fforidanus) Stork, wood AL, FL, GA, SC (Mycteria americana) Sturgeon, gulf (Acipenser oxyrinchus desoto/) Sturgeon, shortnose (Acipenser brevirostrum) Tern, roseate Western Hemisphere except NE U.S. (Sterna douga/lii dougal/it) Three-ridge, fat (mussel) (Amblema neis/eri!) Vole, Florida salt marsh (Microtus pennsylvanicus dukecampbe/Ii) Whale, finback (Balaenoptera physalus) Whale, humpback {Megaptera novaeangliae} Whale, right (Ba/aena glacialis (inc/. australis)) Wolf, gray Lower 48 States, except where delisted and where EXPN. Mexico. (Canis lupus) Woodpecker, red-cockaded (Picoides borealis) Woodrat, Key Largo (Neotoma f10ridana sma/b) h up:1 1 ecos. fw s. gov Itess_pub 1 icllpubl stateLi sti ng.j sp ?state= FL&status= 1 i sted Page 2 of 4 10/8/2008 TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System Status E E E E T E T T T E E E E E T E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E T E E E APPENDIX A. Species/Listing Name Aster, Florida golden (Chrysopsis flaridana) Beargrass, Britton's (Nolina britton/ana) Beauty, Harper's (Harperocallis flava) Bellflower, Brooksville (Campanula robinsiae) Birds-in-a-nest, white (Macbridea alba) Blazingstar, scrub (Liatris ohlingerae) Bonamia, Florida (Bonamia grand/flora) Buckwheat, scrub (Eriogonum longifolium var. gnaphalifalium) Butterwort, Godfrey's (Pinguicula ionantha) Cactus, Key tree (Pilosocereus robinil) Campion, fringed (Silene polypetala) Chaffseed. American (Schwa/bea arnericana) Cladonia. Florida perforate (eladonia perforata) Fringe-tree, pygmy (Chionanthus pygmaeus) Gooseberry, Miccosukee (Ribes echinellum) Gourd, Okeechobee (Cucurbita okeechobeensis ssp. okeechobeensis) Harebells, Avon Park (Crota/aria avonensis) Hypericum, highlands scrub (Hypericum cumulicola) Jacquemontia, beach (Jacquemontia ree/inata) Lead~plant, Crenulate (Amorpha crenu/ata) Lupine, scrub (Lupinus aridorum) Meadowrue, Cooley's (Tha/ictrum cooleYI) Milkpea, Small's (Galactia smallil) Mint, Garrett's (Dicerandra christmanil) Mint, Lakela's (Dicerandra immaculata) Mint, longspurred (Dicerandra comutissima) Mint, scrub (Oicerandra frutescens) Mustard, Carter's (Warea carten) Pawpaw, beautiful (Deeringothamnus pulcheflus) Pawpaw, four-petal (Asimina tetramera) Pawpaw, Rugel's (Deeringothamnus ruge/iI) Pigeon wings (Clitoria fragrans) Pinkroot, gentian (Spigelia gentianoides) Plum, scrub (Prunus geniculata) Polygala, Lewton's (Polyga/a lewtonil) http://ecos. fws. gov Itess_pu b 1 icl Ipttbl stateListi ng.j sp ?state= FL&s tatus= 1 i sted Page 3 of 4 10/8/2008 TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System E E E E E E E T T E E T T E E E T E E APPENDIX A. Polygala, tiny (Polygala sroallil) Pondberry (Lindera melissifolia) Prickly-apple, fragrant (Cereus eriophorus va'. fragrans) Rhododendron, Chapman (Rhododendron chapmanil) Rosemary, Apalachicola (Conradina gfabra) Rosemary, Etonia (Conradina etonia) Rosemary, short-leaved (Conradina brevifo/ia) Sandi ace (Polygonella myriophylla) Seagrass, Johnson's (Halophilajohnsonil) Skullcap, Florida (Scutellaria floridana) Snakeroot (Eryngium cuneifolium) Spurge, deltoid (Chamaesyce deltoidea ssp. deltoidea) Spurge, Garber's (Chamaesyce garben) Spurge, telephus (Euphorbia telephioides) Tarreya, Florida (Tarfeya taxifolia) Warea, wide-leaf (Warea amplexifolia) Water-willow, Cooley's (Justicia cooleYI) Whitlow-wort, papery (Paronychia chartacea) Wireweed (Polygonella basiramia) Ziziphus, Florida (Ziziphus cefata) Page 4 of 4 FWS Endangered Species Home I ECOS Home I Contact ECOS I Privacy I Disclaimer http://ecos. fws. gov /tess _pub I ic/ /pub/ stateListi n g.j sp ?state= FL&status= 1 i sted 10/8/2008 APPENDIX C. PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09/24-10/04/2008 ALL SU RVEYS AM & PM TOTAL COUNT MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0630 AM 1945 PM 0-15 69-83 F NONE 10-80 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE TOTAL COUNT 1 14 7 11 2 27 1 23 3 15 15 2 4 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09.24.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0645 AM 0930 AM NONE 76 F NONE 10-20 % COUNT 3 2 2 2 5 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09.24.08 PM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1730 PM 1945 PM 10-15 N 81 F NONE 40-50 % COUNT 2 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09.26.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0630 AM 1000 AM NONE 71 F NONE <5 0/0 COUNT 1 2 1 2 5 2 2 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09.26.08 PM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1715 PM 1930 PM 0-5 N 83 F NONE 10-20 % COUNT 1 2 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER DATE: 09.27.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0700 AM 1000 AM 0-5 N 72 F NONE 70-80 % OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 4 1 2 1 3 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER DATE: 09.27.08 PM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1715 PM 1930 PM 0-5 S 81 F NONE 50-60 % OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COY: WATER: COMMENTS: BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 4 5 1 2 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIlME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09.30.08 PM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1700 PM 1930 PM 0-5 N 80 F NONE 70-80 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE COUNT 1 2 1 1 3 2 2 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER DATE: 10.03.08 AM OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0645 AM 0930 AM 0-5 N 69 F NONE 10-20 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 2 2 4 3 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE YUL TURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 10.03.08 PM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1730 PM 1745 PM NONE 83 F NONE 10-20 % COUNT 1 1 2 2 3 2 2 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 10.04.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0645 AM 0945 AM 00-5 N 83 F NONE 10-20 % COUNT 2 2 1 5 2 2 2 3 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE TPA>-h'"I,:S,l Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation WETLANDS JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION (5 COPIES A TTACHED) Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Ramsey Inc. LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP -~-----~ LEP - Licensed Environmental Professional CWO - Certified Wildlife Biologist CFEA . Certified Florida Environmental Assessor REPA - Registered Environmental Property Assessor CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional OSHA 5 - Hazardous Materials Incident Commander E-mail: Ramsey.lnc@embarqmai1.com Office: 239.564.1660, Fax: 866.334.1496 2631 4'h SI. NW, Naples, FL 34120 www.ramseyinc.net 08 October 2008 Ms. Jody Lima Black & Veatch Corp. 601 Walnut Street Suite 550 W Philadelphia, PA 19106 PROJECT: Renda Broadcasting Corp., Black & Veatch Tampa 011; pm 00405 160008 ; Street Address: 5860 Crews Rd.; City: Naples ; State: FL; County: Collier; Sec 08 Twn 50 Rge 26; Road Frontage: 330 feet; Acres: 5.0 Ms. Lima, This letter is in response to your request for a review of the project property as described above per the rules of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), the South Aorida Water Management District (SFWMD), and/or the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACOE) for the presence of jurisdictional wetlands and/or surface waters and the need for permits (Figures I and 2). To determine if jurisdictional wetlands are present 3 components (soils, vegetation, and hydrology) of a parcel of property are investigated for wetland characteristics. If any 2 of the components have wetland characteristics then DEP/SFWMD claim jurisdictional wetlands. If all 3 components have wetland characteristics then the USACOE claims jurisdictional wetlands also. Depending on the situation permits could be required from DEP/SFWMD and USACOE prior to commencement of any type of construction activity in jurisdictional wetlands. DEP and USACOE claims Old Farm Field Ditches as jurisdictional surface water areas if they are generally 2 feet or wider, have a side slope greater than 3: I, supply water to a wetland, and there is no current permit in effect on the property. SOILS. The soils are mapped by the Natural Resource Conservation Service (NRCS) for Collier Co. The soils present are #14 Pineda (H), and #21 Boca. The #14 soil is considered to be a wetland soil type by NRCS (Figure 3). Soil sampling on site did reveal wetland characteristcs in the 624, and 419 areas. VEGETATION. The vegetation on the property is defined by the Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS, Figure 4,5,6) as: #1 & #2 624 Cypress Pine Palmi DEP,USACOE Jurisdictional Wetland 3.79 acres; #3740/310 Disturbed Land/Grass Prairie DEP/SFWMD, USACOE Upland 0.15 acres; #4740/8212 Distrubed Land/Communication Towerrs DEP/SFWMD,USACOE Upland 0.38 acres; #5740/8145 Distrubed Land/Access Driveway DEP/SFWMD,USACOE Upland 0.22 acres; #6 & #7 419 Other Pine DEP/SFWMD,USACOE Jurisdictional Wetland 0.23 acres; HYDROLOGY. Last, for DEP/SFWMD there were indications of hydrology on the property in the 624 areas. For USACOE, there were indications of hydrology on the property in the 624 areas. However, USACOE can assume there is hydrology when wetland vegetation and NRCS hydric mapped soils are present. Therefore, the 419 areas are assumed to have hydrology present. CONCLUSION. This review of the property indicates that there are jurisdictional wetlands on the property as delineated by the by the 624 and 419 areas. Renda Broadca~ting Corp, B]ack & Veatch Tampa 011 Pid 00405160008, 5860 Crew~ Rd. Initial Evaluation 08 October 2008 Page 2 Construction or land clearing activities on this parcel will require an Environmental Resource Permit (ERP) from DEP/SFWMD for impacts to jurisdictional wetlands and/or surface waters if any part of the 624 areas are impacted. It will also require a US Army Corps of Engineers (USACOE) permit for impacts to wetlands, and a review by US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) for impacts to Aorida panther and/or wood stork habitat if any of the 624 and/or 419 areas are impacted. This property would be considered "connected to a TNW" by USACOE. Please note that this review was done prior to you having a Surveyor mark the corners of your selected lot and the boundaries were estimated. Iodicated wetland lines may change due to the DEP permitting process and closer investigation. If this evaluation is more than I year old, the property needs to be revisited to note any changes. Please call if you have any questions. Best regards ~ Michael R. Ramsey President PROJECT LOCATION MAP COLLIER COUNTY, FL 5 , o 5 10 15 Miles , N PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 1. Project Location Map; Ramsev Inc. Envlronmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples. FL 34120 239.564.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Ywn 50, Rge 26, totalin9 approx. 4.77 acres. ,,~ 1;1 I I PROJECT LOCATION - DETAIL MAP ciV- ~~Il~ ~ ~ Il ~ f~ ? ~\!I ~ fj I ~ IF ~{ -L. --->',- f ~ u- ~ ~ )v- ~~ \ I nAVIS BLvn, L IT I ' r-:::: -------,,0 ilJU11 L r _J ~ -.,J~ 0=0 ~8~ p I ~ 0 I J~~ ~ (S:J ~ ~ I D \ T ~ 1 I ~ ~ I -f- 1i CREWS RD. L )..,~m ~ ~ l r '- ~~ <Ill< , ~A ~~ ~ I I : ~ i~' 0 'c/' ~ ttffiH]I]' ~ .I ~: n J I I E-- 01f~ ~~ K f- [ b-- ~i ~~, ~ II [~ ~ ~ D ~\. ~ l=[)=O J~ I f-l.j ---- ~I~r~ ~ iJ:;J h I ~_I '" ~[D] J I:, ~~ ~ \~~, \ I u \~ f III I f-- 1m I~ = = = - ~ I l I r PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 + Figure 2. Project Location Detail Map; Ramsev Inc. Environmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples. FL 34120 239.56...1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totalin9 approx. 4.77 acres. - ~ SOIL MAP #14 PINEDA FS (H) c PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. +E Figure 3. Soil Map of project location. Source US Dept. of Agriculture, Natural Resource Conservation Service, 1'990, Soil Surveys, Flolrfda; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naplell.FL 34120 239.5_.1660 FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP 330 fT 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEP/SFWMD JURIS. WETLAND USACOE JURIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.06 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC Il'fI"ll 740310 IttW DISTURBED LAND I GRASS PRAIRIE DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #3 0.15 AC I2J D 7408212 DISTURBED LAND I COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #4 0.38 AC ~ 740 8145 DISTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #5 0.22 AC 419 ~ OTHER PINE ~ DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE JURIS. WETLAND #6 0.15 AC #7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY l- II. Cl l'l CQ . TOWER \ ~ [\ Cl, - - - - - - - - - -l't - 40 , o 40 80 120 Feet , , '\ x >6<~ >0< >6<~ x/ X~ ~ >0< 4 >O<><~ x~ -<" >6< >6< x xy >0< >6< >so<< >0< x >6< x x >0< x" :3< ~ x x:x ~ >0< x x:X><~ ~ >o<::x><8> >0< >0< x x y x ~x>o< >O<~~x xx i>?'x >0< SO< x>: x :x x ~ x >o<:X>< x,;x x 9< >0< :xx8> x >0< ::x x >0< >0< Xx :x x" x ::x >0< x;:; >0< ~ .;:x :x>< 2< -<,,; x ::x '-/Y >0< ><.,?<Y ::x x >0< 'X>< <: x 2< >6< >0< >0< >0< x >0< x ~ >6& ~ ~:x>S<x x:;; >6< x> ~x >0< >0< ~ >0< x:XX > >0< ~ >< >0< >0< x5:: >0< X. ~ x x .>1 >0< ~~ >0< ><5 x xx ~ >0<> >0< ?S:?<'>>< >0< x ><- >0< >< x>0<> . ",",' >0< > X ~"?< >< x ts:: >< 4 1"- LX x >0< x . .. P;; '" >x'>< Ix ><:>: x >< ::x x >< .J >< X ><-,;y ~ "x ::Xx x.....<< j~ ~ ,~ ::Xx X;X~;:;~~.~~~~ ~ ::x x ~~~ ~~ ~0~ x ~ x ""x:x~ ~~'V~ x.;x;b x > ><:>:>< :x "-'~" <' > >< ::x ~"li -<.:x x:~~" :x >0< >< x" "x x ~ ~ ~ >S: x;:: ,,,,", ~ :::;: ~ Y' I CREWS ROAD ROW + Figure 4. FLUCFCS/ Vegetation Map; PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 Ramsev Inc. Environmental Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple!,. FL 34120 239.5.....1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Ywn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. AERIAL FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 5. Aerial / FLUCFCSJ Vegetation Map; Ramsev Inc. Environmental Consultin9 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!. FL 34120 239.5_.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totalin9 approx. 4.77 acres. ZOOM OUT AERIAL ,--. I PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 6. Zoom Out Aerial; Ramsev Inc. Environmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples. FL 34120 239.564.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. SITE PHOTOS PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 12. Site Photos; DATE 10.03.08 Ramsev Inc. Environmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naplel5. FL 34120 239.51>4.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Dale 09,22.08 MAP FLLlCCS CODE Processor 740 DISTURBED LAND 8212 COMMUNICATION TOWER OEP/WMD WETLANDS DETERMINATION FIELD WORK SHEET MICHAEL R. RAMSEY RAMSEY NC CLIENT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 RENDA BROADCASTNG EO PROPERTY LEGAL PIDOO405160008 5860 CREWS ROAO 8145 ACCESS DRIVEWAY DITCHES PRESENT: DITCHES: DITCHES ARE A SPECIAL CATEGORY FORTHE DEP THEY ARE NOTWETlAi'LlS. Bur ARE JURlSDlCTlCWIL BECAUSE THeY ARE THEY ARE Dl.GINTOnE GA:JlNlAND KA.VE NOOTHEflPEfll"fffi ACTlVE CCNCE~I"-G ,",Ifl oPERATlONOFlFUOCllON OITCHESAREJUAIISDICllCWILBECAUSETHEYAFFECTSlIAFACEWATERS SIDESLOPESAAE'IIH:VIOFlSTEEPER"AI<I)AREMEASUl'\EDFACMTOPOFBA~TOTOPOFSANK VEGETATION; WETLAND CANOPY NlA %FAC %PINUSELLOHIVDENSAWI ooSABALPALMEHO(FI % MYRICACERIFERAIFI %.SCHINUSTEREBINHIIFOllUSIF) %MELALEUCAQUINQUENERVIAIF) 'oACACIAALlRICUlIFORMES(FI SUBCANOPY N1A %FAC "loPINUSELLOHIVDENSAIFI 'oSA8ALPALMEHO(F) % MYRICACERIFERAiFl ooSCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUS(FI o,MELALEOCAOUINOUENERVIA{FI ooSERENOAREPENS{F) 00 FICAS AUREAIFI %MYRSINEGUIANENSIS:R,',"",'u,e'"':IF) -%DIOSPYROSVIRGINIANA(FI -o.EUGENIACUMINIIF) ..ACACIAAURICULIFORMES\Fl ~M' GROUNDCOVER t<lIA %FAC %PINUSELLOHIVDENSA(F) o.SABALPALMEHO(F) % MYRICA CERIFERA(Fl o.SCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUSIF) '.MELALEOCAQUINOUENERVIA{F) '.SERENOAREPENS{FI ".FICASAUREA(FI %MYRSINEGUIANENSIS'RP,",,""'CT';IFI -%DIOSPYROSVIRGINIANAIF) -%EUGENIACUMINIIFI -%ACACIAAURICULlFORMES(F) 10-~0 % ANDROPOGON VIRGINICUS{FI 5-10 % ARISTIDA STRICTAIFI -'.AXONOPUSSPiF) %8ACCHARISHALMIFOlIAIFl s.1O % BIDENS PILOSA (F) -'oBUMELIAIF) %DIGITARIASEROTINA(F) == % DIOSCOREA BULBIFERA iP) %ERAGROSTIS SP (F) - % ERIGERON QUERCIFOLlUS IF) -%ERYNGIUM8ALDWINII(FI % EUPATORIUM SP IF' %.EUTHAMIASPiFl %FIMBRISTYLlSSPATHACEA(F) ==%FORESTIERASEGREGATAIFI % ILEXOPACAVOPACAIF) - % IMPERATIICYLlNDRICA IF? COGON) -o,lACHNANTHESCAROLlANA(FI ". LYONIA FERRUGINEA (F) -% MELCOHIACORCfiORIFOLlA IF) -%MIKANIASCANDENS(FI s.1O % PHYLA SP (F) -%PSYCHOTRIASP(FI ==%RUBUSSP{F) '.SAMBUCUSCANADENSISIF) ~%SESBIINIASPIFI %SETERIAGENICULATA(FI %SMILAX SP (F) -% TOXICODENDRON RADICANSIF) s.1O % VITIS ROTUNDIFOLlAIF) -%WEDELlATRLOBATA HYDROLOGIC INDICATORS: XXXX ALGAL MATS WATERMARKS AUFWUCHS RAFTING OF DEBRIS SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: Indicators A8MuckP,e""r>oe F5 Thick Dark Su~aco F10Marl A4 Hydrogonsullido odor A5 SI,atilied Layers A60'gar-ocBodie. A75cm Mucky Mi""ral S4 SandyGleyed Malrix S5SandyRodo< S6 Sttipped Matrix S7D3Jk.urlace F2 Loam G"Y"d Ma1,ix F3DepalatadMal'i< F13Umb,ocsurlaces DEPISFWMD A-test: B_lesl: C-lest. D-lesl: A1le,edSlte YES_NO ~ NfAXX YES NO FUNCTIONAL NfAXXYES- "0- JUAImlICTIONAL- SURFACE WATER YES_NO ~SEEFIG4 INDICATOASTRATA: o % CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10% ORMORE OF AERIAl COVERAGE FACW 0 % OSl QUERCUS LAURIFOLIA(FW) % TAXODIUM DISTICHIUM(O) ACERRUBRUM{FWI ,. PERSEA PALUSTRIS ,'v"l3m..; (0) CEi-TlSLAEVIGATA <.:, ILEX CASSINE (01 SALiXCAROLIANAIO) % FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANAIO) -~ % ..:, Other .u INOICATORSTRATA o % CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10%OR MORE OF AERIAL COVERAGE FACW 0 % OBL QUERCUS LAURIFOliAIFW) TAXODIUM DISTICHIUM(OI ACERRUBRUMIFW) PERSEAPALUSTRIS"'''''WJN>A.{OI CELTISLAEVIGATA '0 ILEX CASSINE (0) CORNUSFOEMINAIFWI % SALlXCAROLlANAIOI % FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANA(O) ,. CEPHALANTHUSOCCIDENTALlSIOI .', % Other Oll...r INDICATOR STRATA' 10-2(J% % CHARACTERIZING VEOET AltoN HAS TO BE 10%ORMOAE OF AERIAL COVERAGE FACW OUERCUSLAURIFOLlAIFW) ACERRUBRUM(FW) CQRNUSFOEMINA(FWI AMPHICARPUMMUHLENBERGANIUM{FWI BLECHNUMSERRUI5-10 CENTELLAASIATICAIFWI CHRYSOBALANUSICACO(FWI CIRSIUMNUHALLI(FWI COMMEliNASP(FWI CONOCARPUS ERECTUS (FW) COREOPSIS SP (FW) CYPERUSLIGUlARIS(FWI CYPERUSODORATUS(FWI DICHROMENA COLORATA (FW) DIODIAVIRGINIANAIFW) EUSTACHYSGLAUCAIFW) FIM8RISTYLlSANNUA(FW) GLEDITSIA TRIACANTHOS (FW) HELIANTHUSSP{FW) HYDROCOTYLESPIFW) HYPERICUMSP(FW) HVPTISALATA(FWI JUNCUSMARGINATUS{FW> LACHNOCAULON SP(BOGBUHON)(OiFWI LlNDERNIAGRANDIFLORAIFWI MELANTHERAHASTATAIFW) PANICUM REPENS (FW) PASPALUMLIGULAAIS(FWI PLLlCHEASP{FW) RHEXIASPIFWI RUMEXVERTICILLATUS IFWI SCLERIASPIFW) SOLlDAGQ{FW) SPARTINABAKERI(FW) THELYPTERIS SP (FW) SHELD FERN WooDWARDIA VIRGINICA (FWI V CHN FERN XYRIS CAROLlNANA (FW) % ". % OBL ,. TAXODIUMDISTICHIUM(O) PERSEA PALUSTRIS "n",mH; (0) % ILEX CASSINE (0) 0'. SALlXCAROLlANAIO) % FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANA(O) % CEPHALANTHUSOCCIDENTALlSIO) % ANNONAGLABRAIO) ,. BACOPA(O) % CLADIUMJAMAICENSEIO) DICHROMENALATIFOLlA{O) ELEOCHARISSP(O) % ERIOCAULON SP{PIPEWORTS) (OiFW) % FUIRENASCIRPODEAIO) % JUNCUSSP.(OI 0'0 LUDWiGIA SP (0) ,. LYTHRUMSP{O) ". NYMPHAEASPIO'I ,. MUHLENBERGIACAPILLLARIS(O) '. PANICUM HEMITOMON 10) % POLYGONUMSPIOI % PONTEDERIA CORDATA (0) 0'. PROSERPINACASP(OI RHYNCOSPORA(O) % SAGIHARIA LANCIFOLlA (0) ,. SETARIA MAGNA 10) '" THALIAGENICULATA(O) TYPHASP(OI 5-10 % % % .'. ., % .'. 5-10 % % % % % % % % 0'0 % ", % ". " % ~~, Olller ~M' YES NO~ SURFACE WATER PRESENT AQUATIC MOSSES/LIVERWORTS DRIFT LINES VEGETATED TUSSOCKS/HUMMOCKS ELEVATED L1CfJEN LINES ADVENTITOUSROOTS HYPERTROPHICLENTICILS ACTIVECYl'RESSKNEES FLOW CHANNELS YES NO '" .." '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" "" '" '" '" NO layer of muckwvaluo 30rlossc...oma 1 Or leS5w,~n6-surlaca NO ==Iayo' at le""tS" ttick v.;th a depleted mauixthat has 60% mo'o chroma 2 or Ie.. slaning below 12" of su~ac" NO _Iaya, of marl wwJuo 01 5 or moro sla~ing w,~n 4- 01 .urlace NO v.;lhin30 cm.urlace NO ==slarting w,jn uppo' 6'... 1 or,'more layers has value::3 I'ollh chroma 1 or~; andiO'" 's muck NO 2% or more 5 1 mUCkJmucI<m,neral1el<\ure wthn6 .urlaco NO 2"laye,wilhin6"ofthesurlace NO - gleyed matn, withe occupies 50% 0' moro 01 a layor wl;n 6," of the su~ace NO -layer w,~n 6 inol .urlace tMI os atle3514 in ''''ck & has main, w60o/,or moro on chroma 2 NO-.trippedaroaso""rS.1"indiam:1D%ofarea NO ==Iayer alleaSl4"thick staning won 6- of su~aco w val"" 3 or 10.. & chrom 1 Or less; 70% paniclas cowrd byorganic male,..1 NO_Qloyed malnxwhichoccupieS60%O' more of a layer starling w.'ln 12-01 11>0 surlaco NO _layer at leaSl6"thick wiadopletod malmthal has SO% or mOle chroma2 or lass .tarting w,;n 10" ot su~ace NO_Mcor>oave positions of imarstraam divides & dop'OSSions;laye'6-'hi cksta~ingw.llnuppe'6":WNalua30rless&chrom.1orlo.. NO~AREALEXTENTOBL>UPL:hydricsoils...hydrology NO~AREAL EXTENTOBL & FACW >= 80% UPLAND (exclOJdi!l(l FAC) NOXX MUCKSOILS NOXX-Hydrologyandhyd'icsoils NOXX 11 cl..mi!l(l Wellard. basod on Rea.onabre Sc'an"li< J"~g~menl, pro"d~ e"d~r>o. below;_ ISOLATED YES NO.!!...NiA CONNECTED YES NO~NiA %'-", %ALBIZIAJUlIBRISSIN %BURSERASIMARUBA(U)GLt.lLMlO %OUERCUSVIRGINANA(FUI Olller %'-", %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN o.BURSERASIMARUBA(U)GLt.llWO %QUERCUSVIRGINANAIFUI %RHUSCOPALLINUM(U) ~M' 1D.2D%lI'L %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN .,AMBROSIAARTEMISIIFOLIAIU) o.BURSERASIMARUBA(U)GUMlMlO % CALLlCARPAAMEAICANA (U) ==%CENCHRUSSP{U) %CYNODONDACTYLON(UI",rrn"d",." 'oDACTYLISGLOMERATA(U) % DACTYLOCTENIUM AEGYPTlUM IU) ,rom"","" % DESMODIUMSP(U) -%ILEXGLABRAIUI ==%LANTANA(FU) %OXALlSSTRICTAIUI % PANICUM MAXIMUM (U)g,WtO,'''' -;;S-%PASPALUMNOTATUM(UI -%PILOBLEPHISRIGIDAIU) %PITYOPSIS,...TFROTH,cA',GRAMINIFOLlA(U) -%PTERIDIUMGLEDITSCH (U) BRACK feRN -'.PTEROCAULONPYCNOSTACfiYUMIU) 'oQUERCUSCHAMANIIIU) o.OUERCUSVIRGINANA(UI % RHUS COPALLlNUM (UI %RHYNCHELYTRUM REPENS(U) ,".I<.oe"" s.1O%SPERMACOCE SP, IU) - % STENOT APHRUM SECUNDATUM IU) FlOR"^~ 5-10 % URENA LOBATAIU) ~%BAREGROUND AOUATICPLANTS BUMMELING HYDROLOGIC DATA SEDIMENT DEPOSITION AOUATICFAUNA SOIL DESCRIPTIONS: 10YR DEPTH: IN. SOIL SAMPLE #3 0,0-6.0 613 SAND W/ROCK 6.0- ROCK REFUSAL SOIL SAMPLE #4 0.0-2.0 2,0.4.0 4.0-7.0 7.0.10.0 A 4,'2 FINE SAND A25i3SAND A3 SANDWiROCKS A47i3SAND SOIL TYPE #21 BOCA SOIL DISTURBED NOT NATURAL """.~~~!; ,#,.'X~,~ ~g~.. EXOTIC INFESTATION LEVELS EO- O%AREAL COVERAGE E1 - 10;"'25%AREAL COVERAGE E2 - 26%-50% AREAL COVERAGE E3 - 51%-75%AREAL COVERAGE E4 -76%-100%AREAL COVERAGE WETLAND: JURISDICTIONAL DETERMNATION -",--""'''''..'..~,-~, STATEOFFL: DEP SFWMD WETLAND YES NO.!!... SURFACE WATER: JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION YES NO NIAXX NOrE'..O'TCHES...EP"ESENT.....O...E NON.FUNCTlONAl_."""'TIOAT",NIS"'OU'~~O "c.'""'.,'.<<'C,""_i'\.""''''''''=C';.;;"..".:......,,'~"'~;.~'''''"',,.., .",-_..;<".,~..",,~. ADDITIONAL INFO: - ,." 10.03.08 MAP FLUCCS CODE 419 OTHER PtlE P,ocaswr DEPIWMD WETLANDS DETERPtlNATION FIELD WORK SHEET MICHAEL R. RAMSEY RAMSEY tiC CLIENT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 RENDA BRDADCASTNG E1 PROPERTY LEGAL PID004051600085860CREWsROAD JUR5D~TONAL~LAND DITCHES: DITCHES ARE II SPECIAL CATEGORY FOFlTHE DEP. n-EV ARE NmWETLANDS, eur ARE JUAISDICTICWll8ECAUSE n1EY ARE n-EY ARE DuG INTOlHE GA:':JlNlAI\O HO,VE i\OOTHE'R PERI>IITS AcnVE CCNCEfNN3 nE'R Cf'ERIITICNOFlFUi'eTlCNDITCHESAREJ[.RISDICl1CW\lBECAUSETHEYAFFECTSlR'ACEWATERS.SIDESloPESARE4:1IH:VIOFlSTEEPEp..'ANDAREMEASUAEDF~TQPOF8ANKTOTOl'OFBAi'I\ DITCHES PRESENT: VEGETATION: WETLAND CANOPY NiA %fAC JQ..400f0PINUSELLOTTIVDENSAIF) :s-- % SABAL PALMETTO(FI -o.MYHIGACERIFERAIF\ '0 SCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLIUSIFI o. MELALEUCA QUINOUENERVIA,(FI ",ACACIAAURICULlFORMES(F) SUBCANOPY NiA %FAC 10_20%PINUSE~WTTIVDENSAlF) ~o;,SABALPALMETTOIF) -%MYRICACERIFERA(FI -%SCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUS(F) -%MELA~EUCAOUIOOUENERVIAIF) %SERENOAREPENS(F) %FICASAUREA(F) %MYRSINEGUIANENSIS,RA"LN"eU",""'A,IF) -%DIOSPYROS VIRGINIANA (F) -%EUGENIACUMINI(FI %ACACIAAURICULlFORMES{F) ...x 0'0 YES_NO .!!.SEEFIG4 NiA XX YES NO FUNCTIONAL NIA XXVES - NO - JURISDICTIONAL, ~URFACE WATER VES.!LNO INDICATORSTRATAc , % CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10%OR MORE OF AERIAL COVERAGE FACW 0 % OBL QUERCUS LAURIFOLIAIFW) % TAXOOIUM OISTICHIUM(O) ACERRUBRUM(FW) 0'. PERSEA PALUSTRIS",,"'o:JN[A:. (0) CELTISlAEVIGATA % ILEX CASSINE (0) % SALIXCAROLlANA(O) ,. FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANAIO) %..., %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN % BURSERASIMARUBAiUIG""LMlO % OUERCUSVIRGINANAIFU) m>c % o. Other Other %..., %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN %BURSERASIMARUBA{UIGtUlMlC) % OUERCUSVIRGINANAIFU) 00 RfJUSCOPALLlNUM(U) XXXX Other GROUNDCOVER HlA %FAC 20~.0%PINUSELWTTIVDENSAlF) ~ %SABALPALMETTOIFI ~%MYRICACERIFERA(F) -%SCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUS(F) s:w % MELA~EUCA OUIOOUENERVIAiF) 20_30 % SERENOA REPENSiF) -%FICASAUREAIFI s:w % MYRSINE GUIANENSIS :R",N" PIJ'lOTOlA;IFI - o;,DIOSPYROS VIRGINIANA (F) -o;,EUGENIACUMINI(FI %ACACIAAURICULlFORMES(FI ~%ANOROPOGON VIRGINICUSiFI 2O-J0%ARISTIDASTRICTA(F) -%AXONOPUSSprF) ~%BACCHARISHALMIFOLlAIF) -%BIDHlSPILOSAIFI -o;,BUMELIAIF) -%DIGITARIASEROTINAIF) -%OIOSCOREABUlBIFERAiFO) -%ERAGROSTISSPIFI -%ERIGERONOUERCIFOLlUS{F) -%ERYNGIUMBALDWINIIIF) ".EUPATORIUMSP(F) %EUTHAMIASP(FI %FIMBRISTYLlSSPATHACEAIFI == % FORESTlERA SEGREGAT A(F) %I~EXOPACAVOPACA(F) - % IMPERATACYLlNDRICA (F? COGON) ==%LACHNANTHESCAROLlANA(F) 00 LYONIAFERRUGINEAIFI %MELCOHIACORCCKJRIFOLIAIFI %MIKANIA SCANDENS IF) 20_30 % PHYLA SP (F) "'5-i'O"%PSYCHOTRIASPif) ==%RUSUSSPIF) % SAMBUCUS CANADENSIS IF) ~%SESBANIASPIF) ~%SETERIAGENICULATAIF) ~%SMI~AXSP(FI 20.30%TOXICODENDRONRADICANS(F) ~%VITISROTUNDIFOLlAIF) -%WEDELlATRLOBATA HYDROLOGIC INDICATORS: ALGAL MATS WATERMARKS AUFWUCHS RAFTING OF DEBRIS SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: l<>JlCalO'S A8M""kPreser>:;e F5 Ttwck DarkSurtoce FlOMarI A4 Hydrogensullide odor A5 SlraU1,ed Layers A6 Organic Bodie. A75cmMuckyMlnara( S4 SandyGleyed Ma~i, 55 Sandy Redox S6 Stnpped Malri, S7 Dark surtace F2 Loam GleyodMalflx F3 Depeleted Mal1ix F13Umbtic5urfaces DEPISFWMD A-1est: B_lesl: C-lest: D-1851: Alle,edSlte INDICATOR STRATA: CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10%OR MORE: OF AERIAL COVERAGE o % FACW <5 % OBL % ~UERCUS lAURIFOLlA{FW) % TAXODIUM DISTICHIUMIO) ACERRUBRUMIFW) '0 PERSEAPALUSTRIS,'ORBONEA,IOI ,. CELTISLAEVIGATA -05 % ILEX CASSINE (0) % CORNUS FOEMINA (FWI % SAlIX CAROLlANA{O) % FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANAIO) '0 CEPHALANTHUSOCCIDENTALlS{O) Other Other INDICATOR STRATA: CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10%OR MORE OF AERIAL COVERAGE 10-20% FACW % OBL ,. OUERCUS LAURIFOLIA(FW) ,. TAXODIUMDISTICHIUMIO) % ACERRUBRUM{FWI -.'. PERSEAPALUSTRIS,BOF<lONfA;(OI % CORNUS FOEMINA IFWI ILEX CASSINE 101 d % AMPHICARPUM MUHLENBERGANIUM IFW) % SALlX CAROLlANAIO) <5 % BLECHNUMSERRUI5-10 % FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANAIOI % CENTELLA ASIATICA (FW) ,. CEPHALANTHUS OCCIDENTALIS (0) !!-10 % CHRYSOBALANUS ICACO IFW) % ANNONA GLABRA 10) % CIRSIUM NUHALlIIFW) % BACOPA 10) % COMMELlNA SP IFW) CLADIUM JAMAICENSEIO) % CONOCARPUS ERECTUS (FW) % DICHROMENA LATlfOLlA (O) % COREOPSIS SP IFW) % ELEOCHARIS SP 10) <5 % CYPERUS L1GULARIS(FW) % ERIOCAULON SP(PIPEWORTS) (OiFWI 10-20 % CYPERUSODORATUSIFW) % FUIRENASCIRPODEA\O) % DICHROMENA COLORATA (FW) % JUNCUSSP.IOI % OIODIA VIRGINIANA{FW) % LUDWIGIA SP (0) % EUSTACHYSGLAUCA(FW) .. LYTHRUMSP(O) % FIMBRISTYLlSANNUA{FW) % NYMPKAEASPIO) % G~EDITSIA TRIACANTHOS IFWI ,. MUHLENBERGIA CAPILLLARIS (0) ,. HELlANTHUSSPIFWI % PANICUM HEMITOt,ON 10) '. HYDROCOTYLE SP (FW) '. POL YGONUM SPIO) ,0 HYPERICUM SP IFW) % PONTEDERIACOROATAIO) ,. HYPTISALATAIFW) 0'. PROSERPINACA SP 10) _ % JUNCUS MARGINATUS IFWI __ % RH\'NCOSPORA 10) % LACHNOCAULONSPIBOGBUTTON\lO/FW) % SAGIHARIA LANCIFOLIA 10) % LINDERNIA GRANOIFLORA IFWI % SETARIA MAGNA 10) % MELANTHERAHASTATA (FW) % THALlAGENICUlATII (0) % PANICUMREPENSIFW) % TYPHASPIO) % PASPALUMLlGULARISIFW) ,0 PLUCHEASPIFWI ,. RHEXIASP{FW) % RUMEXVERTICILLATUS IFW) ,. SCLERIASP{FW) % SOllDAGO(FWI '0 SPARTINA BAKERI (FW) % THELYPTERISSP{FW)SHELOfERN % WOODWARDIA VIRGINICA {FW) V CHN FERN ,. XYRIS CAROLlNANA (FW) O~O Other Olher YES NO~ SURFACE WATER PRESENT AOLlATIC MOSSESillVERWORTS DRIFT LINES VEGETATEDTUSSOCKSIHUMMOCKS ELEVATED LICHEN LINES ADVENTITOUSROOTS HYPERTROPHICLENTICILS ACTIVE CYPRESS KNEES FLOW CHANNELS YES.M.NO '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" YES XX '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" NO layer 01 muck W ,""I"" 30r less chroma 1 or less w~n 6 .urtace NO layeratlea.16"thlck.,;thadepleted matrixlha1 has 60%morechroma2 or Ie. s.tarting balow 12-01.urtace NO layerolmartwvalueol50rmoreslartir>;l w~n4 ol.urtace 00 .,;,hin30cmsurtace 00-stanir>;lw.~nuppers";lor/morelaye"ha.vaIUl3>3,.,;lhthtom.lor>:.ndlor~lsmuck 00-2%ormo", .5-1'"muck/ml>Ckmrne,alte>:lurav.ittlln6" surface NO==2" layer I'oilhin 6" 01 the surface NO _glayed mal,i...;t"" occupies 6O%or more ot a layer w,~n 51n of the .u~oce NO_layerwon6 ,no16urlacetheti.etlea.'4 inlhickS has malnxw60%ormoreinchroma2 NO .tripped araaS over S-l" indiam: 10%01 area NO==laye'alleast4"thickStanir>;l w,106''015urface wvalua 3 or 'es5 & chrom 1 0 rless; 70% particles cove<d by organic malerlal NO _gleyed ma~l, which occupies 60%or more 01 a layer stanlr>;l w.'in 12- 01 Ihe surtace NO _layer alleast S-'''ck w.'adeplalad malti, 'ha1 has 60% or more chroma2 or less starting wI;n 10" 01 surtace NO_oncor>:;allEl positions 01 Interstream diVIdes & de~re.sion.:I.yer6"lhlcksIMing w,'inupper6-:w.',""lue 30,leS5& chroma 1 arless NOXX AREAL EXTENT OBL, UPL; hydric soils: hydrology NO XX AREAL EXTENT OBL & FACW ,. BOo;, UPLAND le>telwir>;l FAC:, NOXX MUCKSOllS NO~Hydrologyardhydricsoils NO XX 11 c'aomir>;l Wollands based Dn ReasonableSclenrrlic Judgemertt,pro0de 00 dencebelow ISOLATED YES NO NiA XX CONNECTEO YES NiA~ ~ YES XX EXOTIC INFESTATION LEVELS EO - O%AREAL COVERAGE El - 1%-25%AREAL COVERAGE E2. 26%-50% AREAL COVERAGE E3- 51%-75%AREAL COVERAGE E4-76%-100%AREAL COVERAGE WETLAND: JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION UPLAND "''''' ~-,-,",-"_:",~, STATEOFFL; DEP SFWMD WETLAND YES NO ~ N~~_" SURFACE WATER: JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION YES NO N/AXX ~oTe, rFOITCHeS>llePRESEMTAi'<O.... NOM.FUNCTIO""-_."""rT'O.<rIO""REOU'REO _~.> ~_'_'Ji;"""";~.*",.""""'m"",~")M%~__..:",",...<w,""#";_";,,,,> ":'",'".,,,.,,,,.'~= "'''''4 ..,_" ADDITIONAL INFO: - 2O-30%UPL %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN 'oAMBROSIAARTEMISIIFOLlA{U) %BURSERASIMARUSA(UIGl-"'ltMlO %CALLICARPA AMERICANA (U) %CENCHRUSSP(U) .oCYNODONOACTYLON(U)b04,,",,,,,,,, o.DACTYLlSGLOMERATA{Uj %DACTYLOCTENIUMAEGYPTIUM{U),mwi""'",,-,-, -%DESMODIUMSPIUI -%ILEXGlABRA(U) .olANTANAIFUI ..0XALlSSTRICTAIU) ..PANICUMMAXIMUM{U)," "41'" %PASPALUMNOTATUMIU) %PILOBLEPHISRtGIOA(U) '. PITYOPSIS HETEFIOHCA GRAMINIFOllA (UI ~5 % PTERIDIUM GLEDITSCH IU) BR.'C" FERN %PTEROCAULONPYCNOSTACHYUMIU) "!.QUERCUSCHAMANII(U) -%QUERCUSVIRGINANAIU) -%RHUSCOPALLlNUM(U) %RHYNCHELYTRUMREPENS{U),,,"lIJ..o.,,,,, 2c-311%SPERMACOCESP.{UI -%STEOOTAPHRUM SECUNDATUMIU) FL,,,,'T.V ~%URENALOBATA(U) ~%BAREGROUND AOUATICPLANTS BUMMElING HYDROLOGIC DATA SEDIMENT DEPOSITION AOUATICFAUNA SOIL DESCRIPTIONS: 10YR DEPTH; IN. SOIL SAMPLE #1 0.5-0,0 01 LEAF LITTER 0.0-2,5 A 511 SAND 2,5'5,0 E MATRIX: 6.11 SAND MOTTLES: 812 SAND 5.0.11.0 E2 MATRIX:Bi4SAND MOTTLES: 812 SAND SOI~ SAMPLE #2 0,5.0,0 Oi LEAF LITTER 0,0-3,0 A S/lSAND 3/2 F SAND STREAKS 3.0-5,0 MATRIX: 6'2 SAND MOTTlES:aI2SAND 5,0'9.0 E2 MATRIX: 6..'2 SAND MOTTLES 812 SAND SOIL TYPE 14PNEDAIHI eo. 09.22.08 P'oce.SOt DEPIWMD WETlANDS DETERMINATION FIELD WORK SHEET MICHAEL R. RAMSEY RAMSEY ~C CLIENT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 RENDA BROADCASTING EO PROPERTYLEGA.L PID004051600085860CREWsROAD MAP FLUCCS CODE 740 DISTURBED LAND 310 DRY PRA~E OIT HE$: DITCHES AIfi' A SPECIAL CATEGCl'rf FORTI'E DEP. ll1EY ARE NOTW~ND5. BUT ARE JURISDICTIONAL BECAUSE T1i:Y ARE Tl-EY ARE Doo Il>ITOll-IE GR:Jl.N) AND f1/IVE NaOll-ERPEfMTS AC1WE CCNCEFNN3 Tl-EIR Of'EIlAT1ONORFUOCllGN. DITCHES ARE JURIISDICTlONAL BoCAUSEll1EYAFFECTSURFACEWATERS SIDE SLOPES ARE 4:1 \HVI OR STEEPEPi AND ARE MEASURED f F'lCMlOP Of 6ANKTOTOP OF BANI< DITCHES PRESENT: VEGETATION: WETLAND CANOPY MiA %FAC ".PINUSELLOTTIVOENSA.IFj ".SABAlPALMETTO(F) %MYRICACERIFERA{F) % SCHINUSTEREBINHIIFOLlUSIF) % MELALEUCA.QUINQUENERVIA(FI %ACACIA.AURICULlFORMES/F) SUBCANOPY N1A %FAC %PINUSELLOTTIVDENSAIF\ .0SABALPALMETTO(F) % MYRICACERIFERA(F) ooSCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUS(FI 'oMELALElJCAOUINOUENERVIAIFI %SERENOAREPENS(F) '.FICASAUREA(F) '.MYRSINEGUIANENSIS",p,"<Ap"c^^(FI '.OIOSPYROSVIRGINIANAIFI %EUGENIACUMINIIFI OoACACIAAURICULlFORMESIF) ~~, YES_NO .!!- SEE FIG 4 NIA XX YES NIA XXYES NO NO FUNCHJNAL JURISDICTIONAL- ffilRFACE WATER YES_NO .!!- INDICATOR STRATA, CHARACTERlZlNil VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10% ORMORE OF AERIAL COVERAGE o % FACW 0 % OBL % QUERCUS LAURIFQLIA(FWI TAXODIUMDISTICHIUM(O) 0'0 ACERRUBRUM(FWI ,. PERSEAPALUSTRIS"QH",'"CA,{OI 0'0 CELTISLAEVIGATA 0,. ILEXCASSINE(OI '0 SALIXCAROLlANA(O) % FRAXINUSCAROLINIANA(OI Other -~- "", %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN '0 BURSERASIMARUBA(U)GlML....O %QUERCUSVIRGINANAIFUI ~~r "", %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN % BURSERASIMARUBA(UIGlIJll.l\O ooQUERCUSVIRGINANA(FUI '.RHUSCQPALLlNUMIUI ~" GROUNDCOVER N1A %FAC %PINUSELLQTTIVDENSAIF) %SABALPALMETTQ(FI % MYRICA CERIFERA(F) -%SCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUS(F) -'oMELALElJCAOUINQUENERVIAIFI % SERENOA REPENSIF) '0 FICAS AUREA(F) o.MYRSINEGUIANENSIS "^"" ^'Jf.TAT.(FI '.DIOSPYROS VIRGINIANA (F) .... EUGENIA CUMINI (F) %ACACIAAURICULIFORMES(FI 10-20 %ANDROPOGONVIRGINICUSIFI ~%ARISTIDASTRICTA(FI -%AXONOPUS SP (F) -%BACCHARISHALMIFOLIAIFI 2O-3G%BIDENSPILOSAIF) -%BUMELlAIFI -%DIGITARIASEROTINA(FI -%DIOSCOREABULBIFERAIF?I -..ERAGROSTISSP(F) 0.ERIGERONQUERCIFOLlU51F1 %ERYNGIUMBALDWINII(F) %EUPATORIUMSPIFI -%EUTHAMIASPIFI -%FIMBRISTYLlSSPATHACEA{F) -0. FORESTIERA SEGREGATAIFI '.ILEXOPACAVOPACA(F) %IMPERATACYLINDRICA(F?COGON) -%LACHNANTHESCAROLlANA(F) -.oLYONIAFERRUGINEA(F) 00 MELCOHIA CORCHORIFOLlA IF) %MIKANIASCANOENS{FI 20-30%PHYLASPIFI 5-10% PSYCHOTRIA SP,(FI -%RUBUSSPIFI -% SAMBUCUS CANADENSIS (F) -;S-%5E5BANIASP IFI 5-10% SETERIA GENICULATA IFI -;S--%SMILAX SP (F) 20_30%TOXICODENDRONRADICANS(FI ~%VITISROTUNDIFOLlAIFI -%WEOELIATRLOBATA HYDROLOGIC INDICATORS: ALGAL MATS WATERMARKS AUFWUCHS RAFTING OF DEBRIS SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: Indicators A8 Muck Presence F5 Thick Dark Surlace F10Marl A4 Hy<irogen sullideodor A5 Stratilied Lal"'rs A60rg~nic Bodies A7 5cm Muc"yMi,,",r~1 S4 SandyGlel"'d Matrix S5 Sandy Redo, S6S1rippadMalrox S7 Oar"surl~ce F2 LoamGleyedM~tri, F3 Oepeleled Malri, F13Umbricsurlaces DEP"SFWMO A-18S1 B-t...t; C-ws\: D.lut. Al\fl,8dSI\fI INDICATOR STRATA; CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10%OR MORE OF AERIAL COVERAGE o % FACW 0 % OBL ... QUERCUS LAURIFOLlA(FW) % TAXODIUMDISTICHIUM(O) % ACERRUBRUM(FW) 0'. PERSEAPALUSTRIS'BOFlOO",,,{OI % CELTISLAEVIGATA 0'0 ILEXCASSINEIOI % CORNUS FOEMINA IFW) '0 SALIXCAROLlANA(O) % FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANA(O) '0 CEPHALANTHUS OCCIDENTALlS 101 Other Other INDICATOR STRATA: CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10%OR MORE OF AERIAL COVERAGE 10-20% FACW 20-30% OBl % QUERCUS LAURIFOLlA{FW) ... TAXODIUM DISTICHIUM(O) % ACERRUBRUM(FW) % PERSEA PALUSTRIS ,",,""0"",10) % CORNUSFOEMINAIFWI ,. ILEXCASSINE{O) 5.\0 % AMPHICARPUM MUHLENBERGANIUM (FWI % SALlX CAROLlANA(O) "'. BLECHNUMSERRUI5-10 % FRAXINUSCARQLlNIANA{OI % CENTELLAASIATICAIFWl '0 CEPHALANTHUSOCCIOENTALlS(OI % CHRYSOBALANUS ICACO (FWI % ANNONA GLABRA (0) % CIRSIUM NUTTALLI (FW) % BACOPA (0) '" COMMELINASPIFW) % CLAOIUMJAMAICENSE(OI % CONOCARPUS ERECTUS IFW) '0 DICKROMENA LATIFOLlA (0) % COREOPSIS SP (FW) % ELEOCHARIS SP (0) % CYPERUS L1GULARIS(FW) ERIOCAULON SP(pIPEWORTS) (O.'FWI 1(1-20 % CYPERUS ODORATUSIFW) ,. FUIRENA SCIRPOOEA(OI % DICHROMENA COLORATAIFWI % JUNCU5 SP.IO) % OIOOIA VIRGINIANA {FW) % LUDWIGIA SP {Ol % EUSTACHYSGLAUCA(FW) '0 LYTHRUMSP(O) % FIMBRISTYLISANNUA(FW) % NYMPHAEA SP (0) % GLEDITSIA TRIACANTH05 IFWI % MUHLENBERGIA CAPILLLARIS {OJ ,. HELlANTHUS SP IFWI '" PANICUM HEMITOMON (01 ,. HYDROCOTYLE SP {FW) POL YGONUM SPIO) % HYPERICUMSP IFWI PONTEDERIACOROATA 10) "0 HYPTISALATAIFW) '" PROSERPINACASP(O) '0 JUNCUS MARGINATUS IFWI % RHYNCOSPORA (0) % LACHNOCAULONSP(BOGBUTTONIIO;FWI '0 SAGITTARIALANCIFOLlA{OI % L1NDERNIAGRANDIFLORA(FW) % SETARIA MAGNA (0) % MELANTHERA HASTATA (FWI '0 THALIAGENICULATA(O) % PANICUM REPENS (FW) % TYPHA SP (0) % PASPALUMLIGULARISIFW) % PLUCHEASP(FWI " RHEXIASPIFW) % RUMEXVERTICILLATUS IFWI .~ SCLERIASPIFWI % SOLIDAGO (FW) .'. SPARTINA BAKER I (FW) % THELYPTERI5SP(FWISHELDFERN % WOODWARDIA VIRGINICA IFW) V CHN FERN % XYRISCAROLINANAIFW) ~, ~" Other YES NO~ SURFACE WATER PRESENT AQUATICMOSSESiLlVERWORTS DRIFT LINES VEGETATED TUSSOCKSiHUMMOCKS ELEVATEDLICHENLINE5 ADVENTITOUSRQOTS H\'PERTROPHICLENTICILS ACTIVE CYPRESS KNEES FLOW CHANNELS YES NO '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" NO layerofmuckwvalue3orlessohromalorlessw;;n6"surtace NO=layeratleast6-lhickwlthadepleled matri,lhalha. 60%mor" chroma 2 Or less stMing below 12" 01 surtace NO_lal"'rof man wvalueof5ormorestMing won 4" o15urlace NO wlttin30cmsurlace NO_.tarting w,jn upper 6"; 1 Orimore layer; has oalue.:l} wlthctvoma1 or >: andio riti.muck NO 2%ormore 51 mucl<muckmHleralt.>cture'MthrnS surlac. NO 2"layerwlthinS"olthe.ur1ace NO =g~yed matri, "'the occupies 60% or mom 01 a layer won Sin ollhe .urlace NO_lel"'rw.'ln6inolsurlac.thatl.atl.ast4inthick&hasmatri,w60%ormoreinchroma2 NO strippedar.asOl'ar.5"-1"indiam:1Q%olarea NO=layeratlea.14"thick.lartJngw,ln6"ol;url""ewvalue3orle5S&chtom10rless:70%paniclescoverd by organic malarial NO_gk3l"'d matri,wh"'hoccupies 60%or mora of a layer slMing won 12"oltt>e. urlace NO_layaralleasI6"thickwladepleled matri,thatha. SD%ormorechroma2orlessstarllngwon10"ol surtace NO~onconcaveposj~onsolinle'streamdlvides&d.pression.jayer6"Ihick.larting w/in upper 6";W.'Value 3orle5S &ctvoma 1 or less NO~AREALEXTENTOBL>UPL:hydriC501Is:hydrology NO~AREAL EXTENT OBL& FACW >=60% UPLAND lexcludlng FAC; NOXX MUCKSOILS NO--XX-Hydrologyand hydric soil5 00 " II claiming Wetle<>:l'ba.adonRea.o....ble Sci.",ilioJudgem."',provld eovldanoebelow:_ ISOLATED YES NO~NIA CONNECTED YES NO~NiA 30-40%UPL %ALBIZIAJULIBRISSIN % AMBROSIA ARTEMISIIFOLlA IUI % BURSERASIMARUBA(U)GlML....O %CALLlCARPA AMERICANA iUI %CENCHRUSSP(U) 5-10% CYNODON DACTYLON IUI ",,,,,,,,ja,,.,, -%DACTYLISGLOMERATAIUI 5-10% OACTYLOCTENIUM AEGYPTIUM IUI ,_"""ass -%DESMODIUMSPIU) -%ILEXGLABRA(U) -.oLANTANAIFU) o.OXALlSSTRICTAIU) % PANICUMMAXIMUM(U)",nB8'"'' o.PASPALUMNOTATUMIU) .~ PILOBLEPHIS RIGIDA(U) %PITYOPSIS:HETEFKJT>€CA:GRAMINIFOLiA(UI '.PTERIDIUMGLEDITSCHfUlaAACKFEAN %PTEROCAULONPYCNQSTACKYUMIU) 'oQUERCU5CHAMANII(UI '.OUERCUSVIRGINANA{U) % RHUS COPALLlNUM{Uj %RHYNCHELYTRUMREPENSIUI",T,"-G""", ~0_3D %SPERMACOCESP.IU) -%5TENOTAPHRUMSECUNDATUMIUI'l'j""^~ 5_10 %URENALOBATA(UI ~%BAREGROUND AQUATIC PLANTS BUMMELlNG HYDROLOGIC DATA SEDIMENT DEPOSITION AQUATIC FAUNA SOI~OESCRlPTIONS: 10YR DEPTH; IN SOIL SAMPLE #3 0,0-6.0 6i3 SAND W/ROCK 6.0- ROCK REFUSAL SOILSAMPLE_4 0.0.2.0 2.0-4.0 4.0-7.0 7,0-10.0 A 4!2 FINE SAND A2 5;3SAND A3 SANOW.'ROCKS A47.'3SAND SOIL TYPE 14PNEOAIH) SOILDISTURBEDNQTNATURAL WETLAND: JURISDICTIONAL ~ETERMINATION ..,' STATE OF FL: DEP, SFWMD WETLAND YES NO ~ UPLAND YES XX NO ""'''''''-~''--'=''<'''''''~.''''"""",",,,'''' EXOTIC INFESTATION LEVELS EO - O%AREAL COVERAGE E1 -1%-25%AREAL COVERAGE E2 - 26%-50%AREAL COVERAGE E3- 51%-75%AREAL COVERAGE E4. 76%-100%AREAL COVERAGE SURFACE WATER: JURISDICTIONAL YES NO N/AXX DETERMINATION ","E, "OffCHES....E PR.S.NT....C..... ""N-<'U""TION"'-._NC""IGATIONISR.GUI~.C ,__",,*,'m,__'~~~:,,,'=:':W"""""'"''':->4'o.'I:''''#,,"'I*:,,;'~'II'''::''''''''':',:",,"',,'i#''_~:{'::''''::= ADDITIONAL INFO: - 0'. 10.03.08 DEP/WMD WETLANDS DETERMINATION FIELD WORK SHEET Processor MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY ~C CLIENT BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 RENDA BROADCAST~G 624 CYPRESS PtlE PALM El PROPERTY LEGAL PIP 00405160008 5860 CREWS ROAD JURISDICTIONAL WETLAND MAP FlUCCS CODE DITCHES PRESENT: DITCHES: DITCHES ARE A SP~CIAL CATEGOFW FOATHE DEP. Tl-EY ARE i'QTWETlANDS, BUT ARE JUAISDICTlCWIl B~CAUSE Tl-EY ARE T11EY ARE DU3INTOTI-E Gfl;';:l.ffi Ai'IJ Kl\VE 1\00000ER PERMTS ACllVE c:a-JCERNII'.O Tl-I~IR OI'ER/lTICNORFtu:TION. DITCHESAREJLlilIISDICTlCW>.LBECAlJSEl11EYAFfECTSURFACEWATEFIS SlDESlOPESAAE41 iHYIOASTEEPER..Ai'l)AREl.It:ASUREDFF(;MTOPOF BANKTOTOPOF BANK VEGETATION: ~TLAND CANOPY xxxx KIA %FAC 30-40 %PINUSELLOTTI VDENSA(FI ~%SABALPALMETTOIF) -%MYRICACERIFERAIFI %SCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUS(F) % MELALEUCAQUINQUENERVIAIF\ %ACACIAAURICULlFORMESIFl SUBCANOPY NiA %FAC 10-20 %PINUS ELLOTTI V DENSAIF\ ~%SABALPALMETTOIF) -%MVRICACERIFERA(F) %sCHINUSTEREBINTHIFOLlUSIF\ %MELALElJCAQUli-IOUENERVIAIF) ooSERENOAREPENsIF) % FICAS AUREAIF) %MYRSINEGUIANENsls <At'" APeN ""IF) %DIOsPYROsVIRGINIANAIF\ %EUGENIACUMINI(FI %ACACIAAURICULlFORMESIF) ~oo, XXXX YES_NO ~sEEFIG4 YES~NO INDICATOR STRATA: CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10% ORMORE OF AERIAl COVERAGE NIA XX YES NIA XXYES NO NO FUNCTIONAL JURISDICTIONAL' 5iURFACEWATER % FACW QUERCusLAURIFOLlAIFWI ACERRUBRUMIFW) CELTlsLAEVIGATA 10-20% OBl 10-20% TAXODIUMDISTICHIUMIO) % PERSEAPALUSTRIs"aR'CNeA,IO) ILEXCASSINEIO) SALlXCAROLlANA(OI % FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANAI01 ~ INDICATOR STRATA: CHARACTERIZING VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10%ORMORE OF AERIAl COVERAGE o % FACW 10-20% OBl OUERCUSLAURIFOLlA(FW) ~% TAXODIUMDlsTICHIUMIOI ,. ACERRUBRUM(FW) '0 PERSEAPALUSTRls,"J"'ON",(OI '" CELTlsLAEVIGATA 5-10 % ILEX CAsSINE (0) % CORNUSFOEMINAIFW) "'0 sALlXCAROLlANA{O) "'. FRAXINUSCAROLINIANAiO) % CEPHALANTHUsOCCIDENTALlsIO) % % .Qther moo' %UPL %ALBIZIAJULIBRISSIN %BURSERASIMARUBAIU)Gl....'MlO %QUERCUsVIRGINANA(FU) OtQe:!:__ %CO, %ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN % BURSERASIMARUBAIU)GLO.llMlO o.QUERCUSVIRGINANA(FU) %RHUSCOPALLlNUM(U) Olher GROUNDCOVER NiA %FAC 20-30 % PINUS ELLOTTI V DENsAIF) ~5-%SABALPALMETTOIF) ~%MYRICACERIFERAIF1 ~%SCHINUSTEREBIN"THIFOLlUSIF) 5-10% MELALEUCA OUINOUENERVIA(F1 5-10 % SERENOA REPENS(F) -%FICASAUREAIF) 5-10% MYRSINE GUIANENSIS :I,^,'LN"euNOT.TA',(F) -0. DIOSPYROS VIRGINIANA IF) '0 EUGENIA CUMINI IF) %ACACIAAURICULIFORMES{F) 5-10% ANDROPOGON VIRGINICUs{F1 20.30 %ARISTIDA STRICTA{F) -%AXONOPUSSP(F) 5-10 % BACCHARI S HALMIFOLlA(F1 -%BIDENSPILOSAiFl % BUMELlA IF) ooDIGITARIASEROTINAIF) %DIOSCOREABULBIFERA(FO) -%ERAGROSTlsSPIF) -o.ERIGERONOUERCIFOLlUS(FI '.ERYNGIUMBALDWINII(FI ..EUPATORIUMSPiF) .0 EUTHAMiA SP (F) "IoFIMBRISTVLISSPATHACEAIFI ..FORESTIERAsEGREGATA(FI %ILEXOPACAVOPACAIF) o. IMPERATA CYLINDRICA (f? COGONI % LACHNANTHESCAROLlANAIF) o. LYONIA FERRUGINEA (F) ooMELCOHiACORCHORIFOLlA(FI %MIKANIASCANDENS(F1 20-30 % PHYLA SPIFI -s:1O%PSYCf-lOTRIASPIFI -%RUBUS SP IF) ".SAMBUCUS CANADENSIS (FI <5 %sESBANIAsPIFI 2--'.SETERIAGENICUlATAIF) <5 %SMILAXSP(F) 20_30%TOXICODENDRONRADICANSIFI 5-10 % VITIS ROTUNDIFOLlAIFI -%WEDELIATRLOBATA HYDROLOGIC INDICATORS: XX ALGAL MATS xx- WATER MARKS -AUFWUCHS RAFTING Of DEBRIS SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: Inclicators Aa Muck P,e""r'koB F5ThickDar!<.Sulloca F10Marl A4Hydrogen5ultideodot A5 Stratiti.d Layero A60rganioBodie5 Al 5cm Mucky Mineral 54 SandyGleyedMaUi, S5SandyRedo' S6 St,ippad Matri' 57 Dar".u~.ce F2Lo1ImGleyedMaI,i' F3DepeleledMa1,i, F13 Umbricsu~acas OEPISFWMD Ilr-"'.t. B-\851: c-11l51: 0_\851: AlI.r.dSIt. CHARACTEFlZlNG VEGETATION HAS TO BE 10% ORMORE OF AERIAL COVERAGE FACW QUERCUSLAURIFOLIAIFW) ACERRUBRUMIFW) CORNUS FOEMINA (FW1 AMPHICARPUM MUHLENBERGANIUM (FW) BLECKNUMSERRUI5.1o CENTELLAASIATICA{FW) CHRYSOBALANUS ICACO (fW1 CIRsIUMNUTTALLIIFW) COMMELlNASP(fW) CONOCARPUSERECTUSIFW) COREOPSISsP{FWI CYPERUSLlGULARIS(FWI CYPERUSODORATUSIFW) DICHROMENA COLORATA (FWI DIODIAVIRGINIANAIFW) EUSTACHysGLAUCA(FW1 FIMBRISTYLlSANNUAIFW) GLEDITSIATRIACANTHOs{FW) HELlANTKUssPIFW) HYDROCOTYLE SP (FW) HYPERICUMSP(FW) HYPTISALATAIFWI JUNCUSMARGINATUS(FW) LACHNOCAULON SP(BOGBUTTONHO'FW) LINDERNIAGRANDIFLORAlFW) MELANTHERAKASTATAIFW) PANICUMREPENSIFWI PASPALUMLIGULARISIFW) PlUCHEASP(FW) RHEXIASP(FWI RUMEXVERTICILLATUS (FW1 SCLERIA SP (FW1 SOLlDAGO(FW) SPARTINABAKERIIFW) THELYPTERls SP (FW)SHELD FERN WOODWARDIA VIRGINICA (FW1 V CHN FERN XYRlsCAROLlNANAIFW) INDICATOR STRATA: 10-20% ~% Other . .. ., % d ... .. ~ .. ". % % % .. ... 10-20 % .. % % .. % .... % % . % % .. % ., .. ". .... . % % . % Other OOl TAXODIUMDISTICHIUM(O) PERSEA PALUSTRIS ,'QF>lON": (0) ILEX CAsslNE (01 SALlXCAROLlANAIO) FRAXINUSCAROLlNIANA(O) CEPHALANTHUSOCCIDENTALlSIO) ANNONA GLABRA (01 BACOPA(O) CLADIUMJAMAICENsEiO) DICHROMENA LATIFOLlA (0) ELEOCHARIS SP 10) ERIOCAULON SPIPIPEWORTS) 10/FW) FUIRENASCIRPODEA(O) JUNCUS SP 101 LUDWIGIASPIOI LYTHRUMSPIO) NYMPHAEA SP (0) MUHLENBERGIA CAPILLLARIS (0) PANICUMHEMIT0M8NI01 POLYGONUMsPIO) PONTEDERIACORDATAIO) PROSERPINACASP(O) RKYNCOSPORA(O) '. SAGITTARIALANCIFOLlAIO) % SETARIA MAGNA (01 % THALlAGENICULATA(OI TYPHA SP 101 20-30%UPL 0;, ALBIZIAJULlBRISSIN o.AMBROSIAARTEMlsIIFOLlAIU) %8URSERASIMARUBAIU)GLO.llMlO % CALLlCARPAAMERICANA (UI -%CENCHRUsSP(U) -'.CYNODONDACTYLONIU)"" "dog'SS '.DACTYLlSGLOMERATAIU) % DACTYLOCTENIUM AEGYPTIUM IU) "owr"~g ass % OESMODIUMsPIU) ==%ILEXGLABRAIU) o.LANTANA(FU) _%OXALisSTRICTA{U) % PANICUM MAXIMUM IUIQ,""~"" -%PASPALUMNOTATUM(U) -%PILOBLEPHlsRIGIDA{U1 -%PITYOPSIS,""",,"QH<lCA:,GRAMINIFOLlA(U1 -%PTERIDIUMGLEDITsCHIU)B~ACKFERN -%PTEROCAULON PYCNOSTACHYUM IU) %OUERCUSCHAMANIIIU) == % QUERCUS VIRGINANA{U1 % RHUS COPALLlNUM{Uj -%RHYNCHELYTRUMREPENs(UI;N'","O"'" .20~3.0 % SPERMACOCESP (U) - %sTENOTAPHRUMSECUNDATUM(U1Fc.""'TA~ 5_10 % URENA LOBATAIUI ~%BAREGROUND YES~NO Other YES.!!- NO ADVENTITOUSROOTS xx HYPERTROPHICLENTICILS xx ACTIVE CYPRESS KNEES FLOW CHANNELS 20-30% ~% % -s:1O% <5 % ... 0'0 ., .. 5-10 % % % .. % % ~% ... % . " % % % % ~ ~oo' SURFACE WATER PRESENT AOUATIC MOSSESillVERWORTS DRIFT LINES VEGETATED TUSSOCKS.,'HUMMOCKS ELEVATEDLlCHENLlNEs AQUATIC PLANTS BUMMELlNG HYQROLOGICOATA SEDIMENTOEPOSITION AQUATIC FAUNA SOILOESCRlPTIONS,10VR DEPTH; IN. SOIL SAMPLE #1 05-DO Oi LEAF LITTER 0,0-2,5 A 6i1SAND 2.5-5.0 E MATRIX: 6/1 SAND MOTTLEs;8..2sAND 5.0.11.0 E2 MATRIX: 8./4 SAND MOTTLES:M'sAND '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" YES~ '" .eo '" '" YES XX YES XX '" YES~ '" NO layerot muckwvalU83orle5S chroma 1 orle55W'n6"su~oc" NO=layerallea516"thiC"",tt1adepleted matnxthat has 60% more chroma 2 0 rlessstartingbelow12"otsurtace NO layer 01 ma~ w value 01 5 or more .tarling w,~n 4" 01 su~ace NO ",tt;n30 em $u~ace NO-starlingw,nupper6";10rimorelayersha.vaIue>3",thcr.oma10r>:andioriti5muck NO - 2% or more .5-1" muck/muck mrMral te<tura "'thiri 6" su~ace NO-2"layerl'oi1t"ono"otthe.u~ace NO=gleyed matrl,withcoocupie560%0l more 01 alayerw,n6inollhe su~ace NO layerw,\n6 notsurlocethatsatleast4 nltoek&hasmatr,w60..ormOla nchroma2 NO stripped araas oVllr S-l" indiam: 10%olaraa NO :=Iayer at laast 4" ttock.1er1Jrxl "'~n 0" ot .u~ace wvalue 3 or Ie.. ~ chrom 1 or lass; 70% panicle. coverd by organic mate!ial NO_9leyedmatri'whlCt1oceup,"s 60%ormoreol a layer starti,," w,\n 12" ot the surtace NO_laye' at least 6"thic" w/adeploted matn,thathas 60%ormorechroma2 orle.s .tartingwon 10" olsurlace NO_on concave po.ilo,,"ol interstraamdividas& depreS5ior>s;layer6"thic"5tartir>;l w..in upper6";wNalue 30' less& chroma 1 orleS5 NO_AREAL EXTENT OBL > UPL; hydric soilS; hydrology NO _AREAL EXTENT OeL & FACW ~~ 80% UPLAND fe;<<:luding FACI NOXX MUCKSOILS NO-Hydrology and hydric soils NO XX Itelaiming Watlands baSed on Rea50neble SC.,nliticJudgement, pro"d ee"deo>:oebelow:_ ISOLATED YES NOM...N/A COMIIECTED YES NO~NiA STATE OF FL: DEP SFWMD WETLAND: WETLAND YES.!!... NO JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION UPLAND YES NO XX """"""",_,""",,,"~,,,,-",,,,,,,__..,~:~~:,",,,=,,,=,,~'_M"'""_"'_'"'_'=~"""""<""",_,_",~~=,,,s,,,,,,,,,,,,", SURFACE WATER: JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION YES NO NIAXX SOIL SAMPLE #2 0.5-D.O 0; LEAF LITTER 0.0.3.0 A 6i1SAND 3i2 FSAND STREAKS 3,0~.0 MATRIX:6,2SAND M8TTLES,S"2SAND 5,a-~,o E2 MATRIX:6/2SAND MOTTLES:S,':/SAND SOIL TYPE 14PNEDA(H) #21 BOCA EXOTIC NFESTATION LEVELS EO. 0% AREAL COVERAGE E1 -1o/",25%AREAL COVERAGE E2 - 26o/.:r50%AREAL COVERAGE E3 - S1o/".75%AREAL COVERAGE E4. 76%-100%AREAL COVERAGE "orE, rFDrrC~ESNlEPllESENr.....ONl. """"UNCT'O"AL_."""'T'UTIONI$REQUIREO "''''''"".'''m__'''~'~'''''''''''__M'*'''__'_'''''''~_'"''''~''''~_-'''"""""",=,,<<,,''''''''''=~ -,.,-", AODITIONALINFO: - Sample Point 1 74082128145 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 1 1'PrOlect Name: Slack & Veatch Tampa 011 - I Sample POint Number: 1 Ilnvestl ators: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC. 'Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? 'tNO.- Is th.e sit.e sig.nif.ican. t1y disturbe.d (At. YPi.cal.S. itua.tiOn)? , No _ Is the site a potential Problem Area? . . VEGETATION Time: State: FL Photo No: Datum: NAD83 Dale: 10/07/2008 County: Collier Roll No: 74082121 Lat./Long.: North: 25039' 48" West: 80057' 17" ~ Scientific Name Strata Indicator Percent Dorninant Status Cover Specie~ J 1 . SPERMACOCE FLORIDANA -- - h'ierb ~ 7.00 Yes -21 URENA LOSATA-- - Herb FACU _ 7.00 Yes r3 . ANDROPOGON VIRGINiCOS-- - ..---.---- Herb FAC- 15.00 Yes 4 VITIS ROTUNDIFOLlA . ....===:f~rb .1r=A~1 7.00 Yes --l -~--_. . ---- j ~ 1 ---...- 1 1 __--.1.._ 1 1 I 1 1 1 I , 1 -. -- , .. - - .. 1 , - 1 I , -. j __..1.... ----- L I. .. 1 I 1 -+- =-== I J- ..--.-- . . _n] - -. ---- -- - l~-i ----. ==- ----- ---- I ---- _I l Total Number of Species: 4 Total Dominants: 4 ::I, Percent of Dominants that are Wetland Species: 50/20: 50.00 FAC(minus)- applied: Prevalence Index. 3.58 L~ HYDROLOGY I Re;~rded Data: - - , Slream, Lake, or Tide Gauge 1_ Aerial Photographs I. Other X No Recorded Data Available FAC Neutral. No ~ -------;- Field Observations: I L' Depth of Surtace Water: j Depth to Free Water in Pit: : Depth to Saturated Soil: _ _........... m__ -...----..---- (in.) (in.) (in.) Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary Indicators: Inundated Saturated in Upper 12 inches Water Marks Drift Li nes .._ Sediment Deposits _ Drainage Patterns in Wetlands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): Oxidized Root Channels in Upper 12 inches Water-Stained Leaves _ Local Soil Survey Data F AC-Neutral Test Other (Explain in Remarks) j Sample Point 1 74082128145 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 2 SOILS 'I Map Unit Name: #21 BOCA DISTURBED .--Drainage Class: . I (Series and Phase). Field Observations ~' Taxonomy (Subgro~_ ___ ____. c__onfirm Mapped Type? .~__ ___ IF'rofile Descrlpllon: I Depth' Matrix Color Texture, Concretions, Redox Feature I Redox Color (inches),. Hz I (Munsell Moist) _ Strllcture Abundance/Contrast (Munsell Moist) ~;O~I~T~'~:::' ~ ~~~"". -_ ~t --'.__1 .' -=-~J-.. ~~t-=-- - -- - - -. --..-- .-..- -- -.. ..- .. . Y rlC 01 n Icators: Histosol Histic Epipedon Sulfidic Odor Aquic Moisture Regime Reducing Conditions Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors NRCS Field indicators: Concretions High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Soils Organic Streaking in Sandy Soils Listed on Local Hydric Soils List Listed on National Hydric Soils List u Organic Pan _Other (Explain in Remarks) , I WETLAND DETERMINATION I No - Hydrophytic Vegetation Present?-- I No Wetland Hydrology Present? ---"'.Cl HydriC SOils Present? ~ Is this Sampling Point Within a Wetland? ~_Is this Sampling Point a Waters of the US? J"JQ.... Have the determination results been overridden by the user? REMARKS I L _ I ..u_J Wetland Yes X No WoUS Yes X No 4 3.58 Species Richness Prevalence Index Sample Point 2 419 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS II Project Name: Black & Veatch Tampa 011 Sample Point Number: 2 Ilnvesti ators: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC. Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? I.NO Is the site significantly disturbed (Atypical Situation)? ,No Is the site a potential Problem Area? I.. -- -... ....._ ..--- ---__ ..___ ---.. _._ - -- ...-- Date: 10/07/2008 County: Collier Roll No: 419 Lat./Long. : North: 25' 39' 48" West: 80' 57' 17" Page 3 Time: State: FL Photo No: Datum: NAD83 ~ Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary Indicators: Inundated __ Saturated in Upper 12 inches Water Marks Drift Lines Sediment Deposits Drainage Patterns in Wetlands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): _ Oxidized Root Channels in Upper 12 inches, Water-Stained Leaves X Local Soil Survey Data L FAC-Neutral Test _ Other (Explain in Remarks) VEGETATION [No. Scientific Name -Percent Cover Strata Indicator Status !FACW FAC , FACW 35.00 2.00 1500 ~ Herb Shrub S H H H H H Herb Herb PINUS ELLlOTTII SABALPALMETTO PINUS ELLlOTTII SABAL PALMETTO fLEX CASSINE SPERMACOCE FLORIDANA PHYLA NODIFLORA ARISTIDA STRICTA TOXICODENDRON RADICANS vms -ROTUNDIFOLlA 1 2 3 4 5 -6- 7 8 9 10 ~,o'^'o, hrub - .FAC 2.00 erb FACW 2.00 erb UPL 25.00 erb FACW 25.00 erb FAC- 25.00 erb 'FAC 25.00 i .' F.AC FAC 7.00 2.00 l~- --I Total Number of Species: 11 Total Dominants: Percenl of Dominants that are Wetland Species: 50/20: 83.30 Prevalence Index: 2.84 6 FAC(minus)- applied: FAC Neutral: HYDROLOGY Recorded Data: Stream, Lake, or Tide Gauge Aerial Photographs Other X No Recorded Data Available Field Observations: Depth of Surface Water: Depth to Free Water in PIt: Depth to Saturated Soil: (in.) (in.) (in.) Domina.n. t -] Spec ills _ Yes No Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No No j-~ 66.70 Yes J ==- -I Sample Point 2 419 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 4 SOILS II Map Unit Name: . #21 BOCA (Series and Phase): . Taxon~my (Subgroup): _ I Profile Description: ....~-.-I , Depth Matrix Color ' (inches) Hz, (Munsell Moist) I .-0:0:2:5-' A m 10YRS/1 F-- , 2.5.5.0 A 10YR6/1 - _50. f1~E -_ 10YR814. _ . -~~ ~---~~- - - - --- I , Drainage Class: Field Observations Confirm Mapped Type? No Redox Color (Munsell Moist) Texture, Concretions, Structure Sand Sand Sand Redox Feature i Abundance/Contrast 1===.. ... r=== 10YR8/2 10YRSf2 y nc 01 n Icators: Histosol Histic Epipedon .. Sulfidic Odor . Aquic Moisture Regime . Reducing Conditions Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors NRCS Field Indicators: S6 Stripped Matrix Concretions . High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Soils Organic Streaking in Sandy Soils Listed on Local Hydric Soils List Listed on National Hydric Soils List Organic Pan X Other (Explain in Remarks) WETLAND DETERMINATION Yes Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? Yes Wetland Hydrology Present? Yes Hydric Soils Present? Yes Is this Sampling Point Within a Wetland? ~ Is this Sampling Point a Waters of the US? NQ. Have the determination results been overridden by the user? REMARKS Wetland X Yes No WoUS Yes X No 11 2.84 Species Richness Prevalence Index Sample Point 3 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 5 740 31 0 II. Project Name: Black & Veatch Tampa 011 ..- I Sample Point Number: 3 . Investi ators: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC. I Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? . i'Jo Is the site significantly disturbed (Atypical Situation)? iNo= Is thesiteapotential Problem ~rea? . ~~~_ Date: 10/07/2008 County: Collier Roll No: 740310 Lat./Long. : North: 25039' 48" West: 80057' 17" Time: State: FL Photo No: Datum: NAD83 ~j VEGETATION I No. Scientific Name r f4~~~~~~~~~FV~~~:~~CNUAS ffiHYOlNODIFLORA-- .. 4 SMILAX BONA~- . 5 .fOXICODENDRON RADiCANs -~ VITIS ROTUNDIFOLlA i...L .__--- 1 .t-- - - I Strata Indicator Percent Domi~arii I . ... . Status Cover. Species. Herb UPL 125.00" Yes l =-=-I~~~ ;~~ j-;f i:' . -- . -l~:;=j~~g n~;~~__I- - ~~s~ ._____ . 1_ .___-.J I . 1 _---.L, 1 __--:-J---+-u _In I I --=i=l..J ..==F .==1 f=t_ ... . -- -- rl=- I Total Number of Species: 6 Total Dominants: l. Percent of Dominants that are Wetland spec.ie. s: 50/20: 75.00 Prevalence Index: 3.23 __ ___n _n_ _ _ __. _ -- --- -- ----- 4 FAC(minus)- applied: FAC Neutral: 50.00 TBD ='J HYDROLOGY I Recorded Data: Stream, Lake, or Tide Gauge Aerial Photographs Other X No Recorded Data Available Field Observations: Depth of Surface Water: Depth to Free Water in Pit: Depth to Saturated Soil: (in.) (in.) (in.) Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary indicators: Inundated Saturated in Upper 12 inches Water Marks Drift Li nes Sediment Deposits _n Drainage Patterns in Wetlands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): _ Oxidized Root Channels in Upper 12 inches Water.Stained Leaves . __ Local Soil Survey Data FAC.Neutral Test Other (Explain in Remarks) Sample Point 3 740 31 0 SOilS Map Unit Name: (Series and Phase): Taxonomy (Subgroup): - - -- i Profiie Description: Depth 1- , Matrix Color r (inches) Hz (Munsell Moist) - 0.0-2.0 A10YR4/2 C-- 2.0-4.0 A 10YR5/3. 4.0-7.0 A 10YR5/3 7.0-10.0 A 10YR7/3 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 6 ~II j! Drainage Class: Field Observations Confirm Mapped Type? No I Redox Feature I Redox Color Abundance/Contrast (Munsell Moist) f ~r Texture, Concretions, Structure Sand Sand Sand/Stonei Sand Y rlC 01 n Icators: Histosol Histic Epipedon Sulfidic Odor Aquic Moisture Regime Reducing Conditions Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors NRCS Field Indicators: Concretions High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Soils Organic Slreaking in Sandy Soils Listed on Local Hydric Soils List Listed on National Hydric Soils List Organic Pan Other (Explain in Remarks) l__ WETLAND DETERMINATION No __ Is this Sampling Point Within a wetland?~1 N()_ls this Sampling Point a Waters of the US? _ c~.=..~~~=-Hav:th=,,-determination results been overridden by the user? . No NO , No L __ Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? Wetiand Hydrology Present? Hydric Soils Present? REMARKS Wetland Yes X No WoUS Yes X No 6 3.23 Species Richness Prevalence Index Sample Point 4 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS 624 !Project Name: Black & Veatch Tampa 011 II Sample Point Number: 4 Investi ators: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC. Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? ! No Is the site significantl.Y.. disturbed (Atypical S. ituatio. n)? ~ Is the site a potentifll Problem Area? u VEGETATION Date: 10/07/2008 County: Collier Roll No: 624 Lat./Long.: North: 25' 39' 48" West: 80'57'17" Page 7 -----, Time: State: FL Photo No: Datum: NAD83 , No. Scientific Name Indicator Strata Status . ~:;t-f~:~w Herb FAC Shrub OBL Herb FACW Shrub FACW Herb UPL Herb FACW Herb , FAC- Herb FAC ~ODIUMDISTICHUM 2 PINUS ELLIOTTII ---- 3 SABAL PALMETtO 4 TAXODILJM DISTICHUM 5 ILEXGASSINE 6 PINUS ELLlOTTII 7 SPERMACOCE FLORIDANA 8 PHYLA NODIFLORA 1.- 9 ARISTIDA STRfCTA "1~ I SMILAX BONA-NOX .- J4~~7~c~gT~N~D~~~L~:DICAN~ Total Number 01 Species: 12 Total Dominants: Percent of Dominants that are Wetland Species: 50/20: 85.70 Prevalence Index: 2.60 7 15.00 35.00 2.00 7.00 7.00 15.00 25.00 25.00 25.00.... _ 2.00 25.00 FAC(minus)- applied: FAC Neutral: Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary Indicators: Inundated ___ Saturated in Upper 12 inches Water Marks Drift Lines X Sediment Deposits Drainage Patterns in Wetlands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): __ Oxidized Root Channels in Upper 12 inches Water-Stained Leaves Local Soil Survey Data 2<... FAC-Neutral Test Other (Explain in Remarks) HYDROLOGY Recorded Data: Stream, Lake, or Tide Gauge Aerial Photographs Other X No Recorded Data Available Field Observations: Depth of Surface Water: Depth to Free Water in Pit: Depth to Saturated Soil: (in.) (in.) (in.) 71.40 Yes Sample Point 4 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 8 624 SOilS II Map UnII Name. #14 PINEDA (H) AND #21 BOCA (Senes and Phase). Taxonomy (Subgroup): ~flle Descnption: _ ---=-- ___-- DepthT fMairix C010rI (inches) I Hz . (Munsell Moist) - 00-25! A ,10YR6/1 1_---=-- --i;"'~I!t~: L ----=- -~ -- ~-+-- -=-+-~~-- - ---+=- ----=+=- 1 Drainage Class: Field Observations Confirm Mapped Type? No Redox Color [~";~;~r_ Texture, Concretions, Structure Sand Sand Sand Redox Feature Abundance/Contrast t=1 - -,---~- -t---- ---- ...---- -.. -- -- -- -- --:- --j y nc 01 n Icaters: Histosol Histic Epipedon Sulfidic Odor Aquic Moisture Regime Reducing Conditions I NRCS Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors I[Field Indicators. ~ Stripped Matrix WETLAND DETERMINATION Yes Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? .Yes Wetland Hydrology Present? Yes Hydric Soils Present? Concretions High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Soiis Organic Streaking in Sandy Soils Listed on Local Hydric Soils List X Listed on National Hydric Soils List Organic Pan -><-__ Other (Explain in Remarks) Yes Is this Sampling Point Within a Wetland? -I No__ls this Sampling Point a Waters of the US? ~ Have the determination results been overridden by the user? I REMARKS n I I 'I Wetland X Yes No WoUS Yes X No 12 2.60 Species Richness Prevalence Index TPA::'16il.1S,1 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation CONCEPTUAL SITE PLAN (20 COPIES ATTACHED) <C' Ull ::ll . O' ....1 ILl ..~ -, 'tl. all :E. , ! ".1' , , t I. d! .,.....'.~ ' :c 0 ' l ' I . \ . . '. ..', ~ ! .. ,,:.,,"'~.,.':-:';.\ /I " i~1 w i!lllff i '.lW.., ',p Ill, ~ ;! z , ~ ~" w II' I! LQ" ",,' III ~ " ~ . . ..' ~ Q ~ f; II h~" 's.. !p ~Q ~ ~ ~. ~ 8 ..:. ~ HT" .~~.. m! ~ ~ ~ ~iE i Iii Iii .. 0 . 0 zo u . ~q',,' U " ~d z ~ : : ~: ~ i ~f'"""~~""",, ,.' , III :1' 0 u , ! ! ! -I' 0 , , I i! <,' ' .::110: , ,.r,ll" ~~: ~ ~ ll.~!~ .' , f I 0 1:5 l" 8 , ;; W 0!?g~Q5' ~<5 , 1 iq, !I' , < . ::11 I ., ,~e; ! 11 II! I '! 7 hi I! I'! , , 1':1 o . illlh II , , II' " ~ . 0 , ! !. i! . 8 ~ ,.. .. ... 0 r'" ~ , ~ ~ E ~- '" ~ i ~" .. ~ -~i fj - t; ~ I'll t; ~ ~ s ~~ "',.. % ~ ~ ~ ~ ! 1 ! I ~ .~ " < ,i,1 ~ ~ ~ < ~o I ~ 0< ~ ~ . < < .- ~ . I I u , , . I I ~ 0 . I " II: · . II' II~I " !" "j <, U Z 0; n ~ I'i ~ I; d ~ . , ri z 0 Ii! ~ i l;d ~ Iii u ~ . . /1' en ~ Illl~ ! i wi'! I ~ Ill!! I 1I1i !~ li~! ~ ,HI:illl!li .11 , !' .. ~ "Ill !I gg ! HI! i nHd I ! " :1 !" n. ~ n" I . , ! , ;1 ::) L 0 N 0 U 0 0 0:: I -l ~ <{ u... (/) to ...I L Cl.. . ~ -l :::;: (/)W u... LL L <{ wo:: f- -lo I Cl.. (/) 0 (/) <{ 0 w as f- z to -l U u... ro Cl.. :::;: L[) <{ .- J z 1::J ~ CD J 0 :E ~ ct: VI' ::11 , 0' ....' 11.' ",' .-3 'tl' Ql~ :!!, o !c I;~ ~~ i" ~tll ~f; ~ ~r al ! ?- m ~..."'.. ", "-, -. ,--', '. ""-" -",-', -'-,,".' " " ',', ' - - ~ -, " " ,.', , , '- . I 1 , f. / / ...... ~ i i <;' " < ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ : ~ ~~"'~ ~ .oIij . !g~g J,~~~ t ~ > z o o u , i: , , , , . . '\7 l ! Hi ti ~ , ! . , r! ' i ; i I , , . , " , , . ;; I' I II I Ii I !J I~ d I _pi I I nil I w "' Ii .. w · ! I II' :i i! !i ;! ' ! !l II ;!l1 o .. II Ii ~ i "'.~ I nl , I :; I! Ii eo . ~~~~!! -~ !'~~Ig r "':'.\"'''~'\'''''' II ...' ..'.. ',"'.....<:, 9 4t' " '. ,- ~ .. "oJ':. l . .' '" "",' ; !~I ~ ...........! f , .' ! , ':?:I:,J~\:') !~, ~ollo ~'" - . " ~~ ........,..,. i I:; t I I I I Ii' I~ll I ii ! i ' ii' !i ill:i II II' " I" ~ I! ,-- -.-""" , ~'~' ------~ ~11 ,SOo-'n9E ___'___ .-'- ~~ . - a / .~ 0 ' "~~~~: i\ /~, / : 1'<' // I", 'j' I': I \ ~& ! ';-. I \ I I I \ I : ' 'I', i \ I I \ II', I~-) . ~ '\ I'Jr ':. '1"'---jI I' (, 1 I" i L=",---.. 'I II : - -t--r~--/i i: I .. /' \ rill' II ILl "'L____ _. _ : 'i -- " , ~'-. ,,\W;,,' +- . .' --, J -. /c - '.--' .' - i-ti! I i ! I k ~ ( o . . , I . i c . , t ~ ! . ! I I 11=1 ~I I I.....""'. <~ :z: 0 " ~ , I ~ l/l' ~ ~;! ! ~ ::1\ i' I!' z " . ~~~ I or: o' ~ ~ ~ Il~ 11I1 .~ . -I. r;. ~~~ u..' I; ~ ~ ~ ca~ ~ ~ ~ II" i .. . ..< -, !Wh z~z 'C. ~ . ~ Gl, z ~ : ~ ~ . ~ :E. h 0 III . ".. . I u 1111" I )0.... '<> - . - - , . , .... ........... .'. . , ." .'. . c . ,- .', , . , - , , ~ '.. . , . U'I~' .-<< ni I ! ,I 'Ill " 6 1 s . 1Jllil' . >~. . . ", /, /:..,< " < < < · " "8 ~ ~ ~. ;: ol" ~.. < . Ii II lis J II ;II ,r' ,iI I i ! ! " I . . . i: , , I t) &'l ~ 5. w~ ! ~ ~"l" ,. ~~. 10 .' fiS~;~ r c(' D ' ~ , U)l 0 :;)1 ; ii, ! . O' ...I, rJ" 11.' Il~ Illg :.: '" :o~ :Ro;;; , " . :5 ,l~ ..i -~ ' . @ :5. III H! .' '" _____.---""~____.__-" -..-----i,,--. ,---- '- , '....... " , _____- I ~~~-.-\C~=;d_, _ \ \ II ~t ~t 1 1 ,I 1 ) '~ (L"""",j I jIi ~ ! coo r i'-'-'~ i_[~ eJ uJ -. -, -- '/t--' -~--~. ---. "---, , i /// i i 'i ......----r------i _I I , I , I , I , , I , I , I , I , i ii' " ;1 ii I' I Ci i! ,I \\ 011 1 ~ [-=U_ II C~ ' I , .-- .._-. -'-' ~ I ", " tI," ", I .'..., .....,........ ".... '._* I I ,..,.,' ''',,-#',:.'', II II i ~ . ~,' . II' I Ii (';' ~".~\ '; illl II!.. '. Bt-i'l' !HH '..~~y" 'I!! ~!!~!I',":.~~. ,,' !i: .... I.t" - . ,,' "!' . .. -. I ',.".',' . " "" .~ ( , U::,','. ~-, .,~ " ~~ " d II -~-~ " '-; ( $' ~ . i \ - - - ! h ,: 8~ ~ . z o ~V1~~ .~ ~ ~ t1o:ilS ill:i:l ~ <()-<O{o T' zo::zU ~ z o o u I . , !IV Ii I l ";' i c( o '! !' ,~:~ I . i'~i~' " ~ ~"l!~ ,. i'S~lg f , ~: . C:(~ :z: 0 lH VI' ~ i;~ ::II , O' ..J' ~" P 11.' ~" ..8 :.= ~t i .. ~ -, ~ '0' Iii Gl~ :;;, a:I I ,'.\ -,. h ...,.)\'...........oJ, "'. I .~. '. '''.\ '111lil : ,.."" ~ ..\- iill III. ",". ~ .q nq, ....., ." Ill' ~~~~~i \#....... ...~I.~.,.' !ic~ ~ ~ .. ~ ! ....:. '. ,..' :BlI .....j -'" .,' , '0' "., /" / / . I' I I ~ " II I ! ! I ii' ,i II ! Ii! IIi ' ld! Ii I:~ Iii ~ ! ~!!! !! ~! ~!! dilllil ~!ili /~./' - ~ ~ z 5 ~ "'.....1.01 Q. oll:lo..,< ~.... c:ig "'!::: ll!it::1 8 '" ><(0 ili ':i. tt:zU i= ~ . z < , . o o ! ~ ! <( . - , o ~ ~ H g,:, g . "~l~" I, ~ ~"l!. " .. ",i!l"OQ~ l='~ 5 if :~e <:i is''' -", "- ! ! /' t ~ ~ i ~l;~ I. ith. " i'3~;g f <(' enl :Jl . 0" ...I, u..' 01' -l 'C. Ql~ :Eo :c 0 ~ ~i ~~ I:! ~ 00. :s ~i III . . ! i I d! I! ~; ! ! ~~ I ~ ;~ll~y&ll hl!:: ~ I;IIIU , ~ . ! i .Ii li i I I i : ~ i!' I jil ~m! ~ " w ~ 5 ~ ~~Vl~~ 4..-" .-< ::J:lllc"'g ~~a:~:i J.<(~o(R tZI::z:.... > z " o u " z ~ ~ ~z i w~ c~ w o . ~ z w ! '? 8 <( , . l~ , " ._,- <(' :z: ~ , Cl)l ~ 0 ~ ~: ~, . '&~ O' -', ;" II.. Il.' ..g ~; ._, g ~r i.. Iii 'tI' C!>' t ' ~ :!!: III II. r- -.------.- --~L~-:~----- I I I I I I I I OO'i'~""-i I ,I !I ".,...""1, II :~.\:..~<~~..:~.:....,. ,III I I .1.' '. v, l III ., ,: ... " ';'l' j' 'I : . . ;L: I IIh\~fl ! H! ~ \.~"x., ." 'I! ~~~~~I ...~.:...~.::.,/ !ic2 " ,.' .e. . ~ .. - co ~ '.,.,,,,..,,,, ~~ r--'- - - - ----- I ___ ______,__ ,.-~c;jO"'-;-;-l--- --~ I '"""J<I<' l"'.llN~-~:=:o~t(;;-'---_.'-- - -- I L r- - -- r- -- I ' . I J ~ .000000 -' L -- '''"NJ;~J;'':;;;;~)N--;;;,'--;::; _00"(;, S,","Jl'''''''';;;C;~'~,-,~ I , i . ~ 'N"lj",;o]""~J''',"O"'''''lN.O_.O''OI'-----1 r----c.' "~,,. """.."" ,,, I I r"'''''. ',":,::::'::',:,".:' :::" ~ I i c c . .".>Q.ltfiJ>r1 Ol&o.Olld JO</OJ. ,D-,Stt 0<;. '""'" ldn"""l~IS ~""$".] . ~ - : % o 0 ..\:.::Vl~~ ll..vi. .~ ~~:i!~g J,!;:)-~5 t~~ZU > 5 o u ~==l --~ -~ I ----~ !l ~'.. 'l"'.' / :z;- / t.'i h. ) i / ' V.J .~ // n II i l ---"- - I!. > . ~ I - € ~~ Ei ~~ ili I-~ i '1 ~ or:( o "~ il.I';11 . jl!~i! l~ : "~i;." ~. i! s, . ~ ~ <~ is 0 u). ~;~ ::J~ ~ . O' ..JI !;" i~ 11.1 "': ~ ~t :s~ l.l Gl~ ; :!:. i > h ~ < . ; 8. ~ ~ ,> "'!i' !j. I; 1"- ;::~!:! d~~~1< ~ ~ ~ ~. .. < . "!. . ~ . !~ 0 ~~"'~ 1 2..J~~l,. o ,,~~ ~ ~ ~"\~ ~ ~ ~;~~~ ~ ; ~ ~ h!o' ~ i · !~ . mh ~"~ h ~ ~i ~ h ~! i ~ .a ~ ~; ~h . f > ~ ~ I , i I ! , . I , I ~n i . &i " - ~ ~h = ~ ~.~!;~ '" ~..lf; ,. ~ ~'~1~g 1" ~ ! " i Ii IE 1 II ! -II ;1 g II qd lit I 'i I ;lh i. ! iii I i;i I S i!lll !I! ; Ii Ii! E ..: ..... . , ;--~, II I, .~ 0-<,. >< ..Y_ !91 m, Ill! .i. :r :;; ~ z o .:Ul~~ ~ .~.'< g 0 g~~s p. ~ ~>-~6 ~ ':J 2;~ZO 1.ol o o o ! ~ ~ ~ '117 II I: r " , I I I, , 'I !I II If lllIl Ruden ~I McClosky 40tEASTJACKSONSTREET SUITE 2700 TAMPA, FLORIDA 33602 (813)314-6709 FAX: (813) 314-6809 KIMBERL Y.MADlSON@RUDEN.COM May 27, 2009 VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS Danelle Carrel, Intake Planner Collier County Zoning & Land Development Review 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Re: Variance Petition - Application #V A-PL2009-37 5860 Crews Road ("Existing Address") / 5864 Crews Road ("Proposed Address") Applicant: FLO TV, Incorporated flk/a MediaFLO TV, Inc. Our File No. 60479-000 I Dear Danelle: In connection with the above-referenced Application, and on behalf of the Applicant, enclosed please find the following supplemental documentation for your review and consideration: I. Three (3) Conceptual Site Plans & Surveys of Property Showing Encroachments, 24" x 36" Please do not hesitate to contact me should you require additional copies of any of the above- referenced documents, or to address any questions regarding this Application. . Sincerely, rIJ0G Kimberly J. Madison KJM/kcw Enclosures RM:6454433:t BOCAAATON. CARACAS. fT, LAUDERDALE. MIAMI. NAPLES. ORLANDO. PORT ST. LUCIE . SARASOTA. ST. PETERSBURC . TALLAHASSEE. TAMPA. WEST PALM BEACH RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. ~ " jH II! III ~ I~! I i ill!. "l ~ I ! 1'1 II I III ~ 1 'I- ~" !A !p :1 ; - II I !III i , ~ i I- l~ I'I! . ~ . !r iI! .. ~ mmm! z , ' , J- III iH ...._."-0 I :!' , I I ~ , ~ I,J i 0 0 . , i ''I t" . ! . ~i= I I ; · !~,~ i- H [iJ~i:;> IiI ;l~' " I, ~l h! "1' i~ " l II; ; ~ I , ~ ~'~'o, " l r I;, !II! iq <I,l ~^ t; E <S ffic'r;j I jl .. l I II ll,1 g 'Il "I i! d" 'I! " ~ ~ ~ ~:l , iil! Ii!! '. !I~ i I~ ~ ~ ~ t; ~ -, 1,1 ~ ~~ ..,~ Iii; ~ I! ,!!llll! ~ 8 11,. ~ ::: ~ ~ . i % i I I!". ~ ~ ..l!i SEi~et;g 0 :Ii ~. B ~ ~ ~ Ii. 0 ~ ~ ~ " ~ ~~ '-Ii' · ~ ~ ~ nllUlli o . ~ ~ u 2:g~ ~ .~ ::: lii N!' 'II "~!l' 'd !'i-,' II'l! -I' '.!I! lh!!.II'~;! ',!<.II III ~ !iil!l I~!'I . ili!' ll~!. I IIi..! .!.I! !,II" 'I!I' I HI.i!! I i n s~~ i l;~ > - .! :0 o E ~ I!n "i" ~~ ~a; Xl """ , "Ill .. I! ~~ I ,I 'i ' I 'II i : I; g Iii! ! I !l!!j I li~~ I ~ l!l~ ! i Ii II I . 111 i .1 . i I! ' ., l l " ! l ill i! ! 1.1 !l ~ ':;:.: \ I~ pu.s ~. ~ = ; Q.. S .... et Blvd . Santa B~rbOlra 81~ ':.T> '1l t:; ~ II -" _ ~ Ii (QQ.s, .5'"0: ;:&:: , t ~ ~ '\ ""V) I:> 'E ,~ 'i u U a .c 't 0 ~ l' i rOUflly- 8arn Rd ~ 11 Glen Eagle I i ]i I AeM s6t14r \ Kings Lake Blvd , . ~ . c " :g t5 ~ ..i<: <l> ~ :::;]: " ,1 ~ o . ~&j,~ liJ r; 'li ~ . . ~ ~~Qod Blvd 1!:~ II; Iii ,'; " ,II 5 ;l!! " 11:1 !il; Ii.. '., l!~' ~ 0: ~ ~ E . :r: ":>.,. .I ~ ~ ~ h . . " PAl8IJBMBH ; C= . 1111: ji :j.li li.lil I >& I'!!I ill 1% i;I~li i ~ i, .Iill: r Ifj !il!!, Iml! ! jl. g i :!ili i l~ Ilil; :1:jI' ; I-- 'p . H,' I !:il'ldi /;1.,; I ~ J!! ! ,l il~i!'IBi,' .iill!,,! i;iill! ! m.1 · '!iI 1'111' "i'-I"l I i ~ !Il~ :11 11.11 ,II!!! I:lh!! i U]. / , " <{ "I" li'!l iN: '1,lhi 1.!1iI1 11+ iii!i I! i'!1 I !!M Ii; !III'!11 II lilli, II,' Iii I'l I'l iLl " Iii!" I, I 'I !If " : Ii Iii! 'II 'I' ~i":illl!! Iii III i !l !Ili !ii! 111 !!I !!iii! !I ,Ii !Ii <J " <J , " . . il A-i! ~I II: ~, II I!, I~ If! Ij .:! ~ II: ! II I 01 ~~ 11 I. " 1 I ~ .. ,. ill I. .Ilt: \! -~~ Ii . 1i.9:ie€ z ~ ! .1/ I I !. 'I~ $~ III 1,ldll~f ! Ilmll. " III " ,I, 'b I! j I I , .. , " .. Iii! ,I, , 'b .. I! I , .. rrs.. i I,M'll , I'" , 'IS'.I ~ is.1I I \ 1 . I \ 11 III 1 ell . Iii; !Il \, ", tlli \ i~:5 ! 1 ~ . s \ -/, i , Ii I I t~ I I:;!j I Ii ~; I ~ Ii I ~;, I, "j I I" I i Ii Iii I~II " ~I Ij !..:~ :j " " ,. I. I i:11 IIi ! I II II, II, ,I, 'b I! ................,,..........._..our,,...... -.""'...-...,/...-............ ~.. ....... \ \.., .................... '1 Jl --- Il, Iii ' I'. i I " ~.... ni ~llb ~ ~~ il .r~ : fjl1tl:!I;jj i /1111 ...~ ! /'llld ~I' > I! ,~ I .. , . LUG ~a. ,): z III 3 II I;, ; Z- ;jBa .I. I:::;~ ~~ :!!. 1~~HI~i, ~5 4 We:= l! 10", " '" ill I t.:J", II I I! II I "I ' I I II ! I": ihlll'llji o mlllh! I ~ III III!!! I! 'O.!kiii il1lil!1 ill,'il 'II ~II' 1.,1, 1llm'l ,,!!ll!. .1. 'I,ll ~:111"!11 Mli~li~ r--'--- ......" .~ \~;;:: i ,9 ~ .. t ~ i~ s: !~ ~" I~ ~ ~.~ ~ -~ , l l ! II!! I '~~'- "':',.; '9 I 1'111" o~~ :111 II I lilt .....~~ ~I' HHHml, "':'.;'\'~" I~! ., .:,; '" ~ .. .. . ., M ~ .. & . ~ ci ~a::~w ...VI........ ~ ui~ui('1 IS: ~~~j i ~;:~8 ~ ~ i 'T o <( ~ 9 . . i I I , A,'!' IlglIll i,l II !Ii:'l ~'Ig:'!! glll'iii ij !lUll! Jl-."- Ii Iii , , :' ill!l~h I~ - 11 1111 I HI ~" I, l- .~__ H =/) ..=0 .,,, ~ .,,11/ - ~ "/ - - - ~ I '.r,ll i>! . I 51 'l '~I ' I : . ~. I Iq'l: 'i! I I' .. 'I I' I' "- , I : I"! Iii I.,' I ~,1 ,'. ..lo!:~('1 I ( I, 1j .rb,,-'.~ I Ii !I I' , - -\---h--j--/ IE I' I I j', I" i I L__ -------' I'__---.J ii I ~ I ! .. _ I I I , !l I; , 'i~ 't ~: ~B ~~ ~ g~ ~~ ! , ! I l ! 1\ 1 i , I Ii ! , ~ , , 1 1 1 ir=-! f<<li , , , . . . , ! ! , , .. ~ . ' I I . !!I .. . I , ! ~ I ! , i . , H,Il!.;';1 , , I I I i !l1'lidgl'll I I I " I i II h ;q ;1 , !! I ! II I" II i' i i' I HIIIII H~Hi Ii ~~ II I I, I i l_______ 'IV Ii , ~ -I ~~~~ I, . ~til~ .' ~ ~'3iig f -..---."-..-.- -------.---' ~. I ~Ii ~t :I: . u . ~ !i~ ;oll I~~ ts l~;; :5 -~ lD ci "" " -~, .. . "-" -"- tUi <. < z.z ~ " l , ! !9, m: i~; :1' . ' . o · ~ iL '! 'I 'Ii;~ ; !; -<>10. 11~;~11 '0',,'1 ~, i:1?'J !Il.,ll :h~,~'. !;1M!id: ,"U!.!!ll l~-$:::;;----r , T-- ~I i L. IIi , I!rl ~ , : ~ : ~ I J il I l I!. · ,!II ~. i !,! " i 1111" il I" I L Ij ,I; " ~! i ~ 1 !L!J ; i I j. Ii 01 ;U 'I' d ii~ "II , ! ! I I ;l I . j . ~-----~- z ~ ~ z ~ g :. ~ ~ 8 > ~ ci <i: , - ~ ~ . ~ , ~ " i. ~. , , :;--1 :--1 ~ : !~;:;. J;'~ ,~ ", , ''',', ',' '" I: '~~l~"' I. Eli~",_.nL ;;; ~i ~'j~i~ j i', ci _.....0:...1101 ::z: W 'i':~:5 ~ ~ I ';" ::~~~g ~ w I.=i oCt ::r~uo..5 &:!::: ! ;!~::~o III ~ ! e ./ i '\ . i _ ~ '~ - ["~-,-~._~ \.~ ;! . ~"~__~'!;;\~ ti ~II -~ i ~-:-<"~_ '--,-.7[-"--- \'1 II I " "j / c~ / I \c. __. ........ - \ ~ "I - 1\ 1 I ~-.\ !! I 'I" I ,I I \n-~{\~h u 1 I h i ~ I . 1--', . ~~,"',,'''''''" ., -;7 '-~~IL-l Jjl i III i: I I .?II I . .'1"1 " . i ;' l i ~\ ~ I.! ii~'J: _J]I ~I I I L._. I ~ . :i I I ~ I ~ I d I I I ; ~"""-.:l",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,-~ i / I I ! n~F'5"D LJ [J r .1 ! ;, 1 -.J i I ~-o--t-w .-,-, i I ~-~ I -"] I ~--, " L--.J ~- 1_ . I / 1_, - -.---.- -, -T- -. --, - (T i I . 1 . I I 1j : \ I- - -, !i I \ \ - .....!. ~. i~! :z: . ~ j ~ ill ~.. j~ ~ ~!e :5 -! as , l l ! iii' i II \ I I I / / = ~ "~I~::~ I, ~"l~l '; .ig.!~ ~ g ":f e , , 'Ii :\ ~ :I~ 'I II" , I): II' !)rl ~: g~ !i '" 'i~ ' ~~ . l~~i; i ! I . L _, 'IV Ii I L ,.,............ ...." "...1. ...... ~ ii~ ~n IE! ;" I~ It If i .I;: .I;: u ::s III III ci . -. -"~ Yvi~ ~~~ ... .z. . ~ J..-.......____ '\ ./ '><// // \ /"/" \ - \ /" '- \' '- /" '-r-,\ ' I '\J ' /". I/'" \ . " . ' \ 4------- , /I /". /" Ii . I ~ /" /" c ^', ~ ~ . Ill! ! i I' d : I III ill! I II ! 800000@000 Ill!:! ~ 11I1111 Iii .Iill ~,ii L___~ ----~-~--- z ~ . i ~ l" i i i ~ . . . , ! o! ~~;~ i , ji~li' !~ I 5'2~;~ f /- , r " ~ i % ~ 3 ;t ~ Iii ! ' ~ ~. ci w "~w ~ . i '? \~! ~.. ~ gz ~.. il! ....ui~ fi~~ l w~ l <l: lOi iig .<0 s. ! . . 0%0 U ~ Iii . " ~ ~ % W .' /' T \T . /' I h /' /' I 1 \.\ /' I y I ) \. \ I ] \. \. I \. ! \ I \ \-...., 1 \ I \. ) , I I o I I ] I Ii . , e I 000 LJe I I I I I I I I I , I 1 . , . ! I d l d " . ~ ;I! Iii o i .~;~ I !i I I !! I Ii! 1I!:i' ~ ii!!!~ .~ ~~l!~~~~l ~ mUl Jill . ~'Si;E f ~d L_.~ ____ ___ !,.~ \~J ............. ", .... :z: 0 ~ il~ ~.. !i~ ~ lIe ::5 -i III ~w ~ i - ........ .. z ~ .~ E fig l' : g~ i ~~ 8 <C ~ ~3 C ai r-r-~~' ....,1 _ II ~.o, Q~~~ I ~ I 3 ~ "-", ' ..iltls'tili..I. ~.. . . 1-, ! t2~~~'1 ~ i . ,.. I' ~,.. . , ~___..J Ii , '.l,',~"<.',, "] . ~ l. , ~ ~~ II ~~ '" ./:l ~i I ,/ [ I " g= II 1- .o-,cl> .~---i . 5 ~ ~ ~ . ~ i i I "',"" "'.-' .--.--....______.._u..___. ___'_.._ _.._____.. ______. I' I I ! i I I 1 I i ,.. IJJi '.'" :c 0 ~ n ~ ir~ ~ 01 if; !~;~ iii III '/>"o;.;'."~ \. I~ ,111111.' ; '..~ :;~. 1'11., '"~I Ii/dill, L .,.'__~ ..l,... hi'. '!I ! ! . .,~'. . ..... ," illHHHI V'. .........,p.... II .~... .,"",,">1 G\~.... :h .........-., ..\~.............~,;>.~ "j w ~ => o w '" I;; X i3 ~ z I~ I I " I I~ ~ I~ ~ ~~-~ ~. H~~lL I L'~ " ._--~ ~ II ~ ~ i i~l~iih ~ ~ ~ ~- _'5 I "S?, i I ;1 1!1 ~.I I jiql!ji, I -jl ~I hi Ii ! 'I pi I' !ljl!i 'II Ii' ~. 1'1 i llU i:lI 11 [!IO!l dl! ~I; 1 . I fi ~ 1 I ..F-~~ J '.J].;." rr:-T!-1 ~, ..UI~ i , I....i: <Hi", " 'I~~ I"j . 1 .." 10 . I' . . ..~~-oo,~" 1- n "le , i I '~J SI' r I " . . . ~ ~ ! ~ ~ . 'i . i ~ u . ~ <l: : ~ . . . Ii I I a; / ~/ ! ~ ~! " o k ., " I \ \ \ ..\ . .~~~\. \ \, z 'f=-~~,-" ~. jl g 3 '~~.,~--~"~~ /"ta: ( ,/ I; . ,~ ~! If II " ~I Ruden ~I McClosky 401 EAST JACKSON STREET SUITE 2700 TAMPA, FLORIDA 33602 j81J)JI4-6709 FAX: 181]) 314.6809 KIM BERL YMADlSON(lIiRUDEN.COM May 19,2009 VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS Danelle Carrell, Intake Technician Collier County Zoning & Land Development Review 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Re: Variance Petition - Collier County (the "Application") 5860 Crews Road ("Existing Address") / 5864 Crews Road ("Proposed Address") Applicant: FLO TV, Incorporated f/kla MediaFLO TV, Inc. Our File No. 60479-0001 Dear Danelle: The Applicant seeks variance approval from Section 5.05.09(G)(l7) of the Collier County Land Development Code ("LDC") so as to pennit a reduction of the front and side yard setback requirements as applied to guy line anchors that support an existing wireless tower located at 5860 Crews Road ("Tower"). This Variance Petition is a companion item to Applicant's pendjp.g peti~ion for Col)llitional Use (CU-2008-AR-14085) to penIlit the installation of a shelter and broadcast eQuipment on the same Tower. No reduction is needed from the rear setback requirements of the LDC. In connection with the above-referenced Application, and on behalf of the Applicant, enclosed please find the following documentation for your review and consideration: 1. Fifteen (15) copies of the signed Variance Petition Application; 2. One (I) check for the Application Fee, in the amount of $11 ,025.00; 3. One (I) signed and notarized Agent Affidavit; 4. One (I) signed and notarized Owner Affidavit; 5. One (I) copy of the Addressing Checklist signed by Addressing; 6. Fifteen (15) copies of the Pre-Application Meeting Notes; 7. Three (3) Conceptual Site Plans, 8 Y, x II (three (3) 24" x 36" plans to be forwarded under separate cover); 8. Two (2) copies of the warranty deeds; 9. Five (5) copies of aerial photographs showing FLUCCS Codes, Legend, and project boundary; 10. One (I) copy of the Statement of Utility Provision; II. One (I) CORaM containing an electronic copy of all documents and plans; and, 12. Three (3) copies of the Survey of Property Showing Encroachments. RM:6390635:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. BOCA RATON. C.\RACA5 . H. LAUDERDAU . MIAMI' NAPlfS . ORl.-\"DO . PORT 5T-LUOE . SARASOT,4, . ST. PETERSBURG. TALLAHASSEE' lAMPA . WEST PALM BEACH Oanell e Carrell May 19,2009 Page 2 As agreed upon at the Pre-Application meeting, the Conditional Use Petition and the Variance Petition will be considered concurrently by the Planning Commission on August 20, 2009 and by the Board of Zoning Appeals on September 29, 2009. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you require additional copies of any of the above-referenced documents, or to address any questions regarding this Application. Sincerely, ~~~J)v,L/ KJM/kcw Enclosures cc: Thomas Voltero, Esq. (w/o enclosures) RM,6390^3S,] RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSELL, P.A. BOCA RATON' (AR,\CAS' H. tACOUDAlE . MIAMI. NAPLES' ORlA\DO' PORTSL lUClE. S"RASOfA' S1. PElEllSBlJRC. TAllAHASSEE' lA\1PA . WEST PALM BEACH ,---- ~.._._-_._- 0 "If.l1Kl UO SII81&Q 'S81m&91 h!Jnoe$ eEl CO C'1 (j) C'1 II: :3 -' 0 0 en 0 0 0 U") 0 0 N N 0 0 <Xl ~ ~ Aw 0 ~ ~ 0 >- i <ll iR- '0 :2: c III SO; . . . . . . . . . . J . ~ . ! I '" . C'- - . ~. J - . []" '" . '" . <..ll il~J . .,. . 0 0 . u~~ " . - '" . '" . []" . . ru . . U1 . . . . . . . .. . . 0 . . CO Q) oJ > 0 u:: C'- }?;- r1"I c: - U (I) - ..J 3:: (') ru ..J I- ..,. ..J ..,. .. l>l "0 0 c: '" t;; t:: <ll 0 ~ <~~- rJl CIi 0 ::J <1> Q;.::I.:>>$ }?;- 0 LL CO d:SO{l)... U 0 .r:: c r1"I ~~Ei c: I- ,g r1"I U" . ::J c: ~ _"'~z 0 (I) 0 zt;:..g; () > 'ii 0 t/)<a:::c ~ (I) ~ <15~O .!!1 a. ..JG.II.I3I: UJ <( ~o~ 0 . <1> " .J () . c . ro < 'C > ro ::l > 0 u. 0 WII: 0 ,.j!:~ :; ~~~ W L :; Variance Petition Applicant: FLO TV, Incorporated 5860 Crews Road/Proposed Address Collier County, Florida Index of Application and Required Exhibits/Components Item No. Description and # of copies I. Cover Letter 2. Application and Exhibits A-D (IS copies) Ex. A: Legal Description for Property Ex. B: List of Surrounding Registered HaAs/Master Associations Ex, C: Narrative Statement Ex, D: Pre-Application meeting notes 3. Addressing Checklist Signed by Addressing - Ex, E (I copy) 4. Copies of Warranty Deed(s) - Ex. F (2 copies) 5. Completed Owner / Agent Affidavits (I copy) ,), Aerial Photographs Showing FLUCCS Codes, Legend, and Project Boundary- Ex, G (5 copies) 7, Electronic Copy of All Documents and Plans (I CDROM) 8. Conceptual Site Plan and Survey of Property Showing Encroaclunents (3 copies) RM:6383627: I COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 6968 ~ 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DR1YE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643- ~~~L~i"wf,";'%~,::. _","T :::>___' ,,' "i',~:: ,. .... QNJfI",.orS'iR/(;f) ::::', _J:~~\_:,:. ,'>r- '- -.,;*::,:(~" >ftJF'-~".._; PETITION NO (AR) PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER DATE PROCESSED ASSIGNED PLANNER To be completed by staff Above 10 be completed by sliJff "~-~lll.L . ..:~' .10" ".' .'_n"'~';I!illo.;.._,,1'!f;;;__M,\t!itC".._ ..'5'r.....:l~.~. '~:'., ;"'1 _:_ D~~<-~'\\ib;:J'""--'-:iI,~;;!~!lI!~~!~"!.!:~!B!ll~;~~,~~(-.,~,,~ht',":"';h'*-C;J~:j,r_. -, NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) FLO TV INCORPORATED, A DELAWARE CORPORATION ADDRESS S775 MOREHOUSE DRIVE, SAN DIEGO, CA 92121 TELEPHONE # (858) 651-3244 CELL # FAX # E-MAIL ADDRESS: NAME OF AGENT KIMBERLY J. MADISON, ESQ. ANDJAMESJ. PORTER. ESQ. OF RUDEN MCCLOSKY ADDRESS 40 I E. JACKSON ST., SUITE 2700, TAMPA, FL 33602 TELEPHONE # (813) 314-6709 (KIMBERLY MADISON) CELL '* (813) 263-5309 FAX II (813) 314-6809 (KIMBERLY MADISON) E-MAIL ADDRESS:KIMBERLY.MADISON@RUDEN.COMANDJIM.PORTEMlRUDEN.COM l...,"""..";,,....;,i.~b.!;~ .,,t\~_.~~.t~~:iif"'~~fj~~~.:J Legal Description ofSllbJect Property: See Exhibit "A". attached. Sectlon/Townshlp/Range 08/50/26 Property !.D.#: 00405160008 Sllbdlvlsion: Unit lot: Block: Also known as Lot 20. Enchanted Acres Metes & Bollnds Description: Acreage: 4.77 m,o,1. Address of Sllbject Property (If different from Petitioner's address): 5860 Crews Road, Naples, FL (existing address); 5864 Crews Road, Naples, FL (proposed address) Colher Coumy Application 200S 1 Exhibit A LEGAL DESCRIPTION Property located in Collier, FL TIle West one-half (W y,) of the Northwest one-quarter (NW \4) of the Southeast one-quarter (SE 'A) of the Southeast one-quarter (SE '4) of Section 8, Township SO South, Range 26 East, Collier County Florida, also known as Tract No. 20, Enchanted Acres, less the South 30 feet for road right-of-way purposes. AND BEING the same property conveyed to Renda Broadcasting Corporation, a Pennsylvania corporation from Sterling Communication Corporation, a Florida corporation by Warranty Deed dated January 13, 1999 and recorded January 20,1999 in Deed Book 2503, Page 1624. Tax Parcel No, 00405160008 RM:63425J.6:1 BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESE REGULATIONS. I ',. :COli', '" " };;?~',;i~tr"':~~IlfjQfAS:":5~/ff'1':'~~i'~~'d~~'_~~~f;;'.i';.~".,'rt',ti ,:'t#f,-~-:~.'.,-s.[rf:.~t Complete the following for all registered Assoclatlon(s) that could be affected by this petition. Provide additional sheets if necessary. Information can be found on the Board of County Commlss.ioner's webslte at hue:/ /www.collleroov.net/lndex.asDx?Daae..774 See Exhibit "B", attached. NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION; MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP .~y"';' . . ".;~' ,.~\iIi:" .~~~1MEAi'Il~_~S.~~~~~'~' '._}~,J Zonin'" Land Use N PUD NOIl-aoricultural acreaoe/vacant S E NOIl-aaricultural acreanelvacant E PUD Non-anricultural aCI1tAoe!vacant W PUD Non-aorlcultural acreaoe/vacant Minimum Yard Reaulrements far Sublect Prooertv: Front; 75 feet Side: 30 feet Rear: 75 feet Corner Lot; Yes 0 No UlI Waterfront lot: Yes 0 No rn ~ t o.mer C.ounly Application 2008. 2 VariaDce Petition 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florlds (Existing Address) 5864 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Proposed Address) Applicant: FLO TV Incorporated flkla MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Exhibit B List of Surroundin.2 Rellistered Homcowners and Master Associations I. Falling Waters Beach Resort, Phase 11 Mr. Thomas Powers. President 6660 Beach Resort Drive.. #6 Naples, FL 34114 2. Falling Waters Condominium Owners Association I Mr. Tom Lee, President 2202 Hidden Lake Drive, #7 Naples, FL 34112 3. Falling Waters Homeowners Association II Mr. Tim Boyle, President 2274 Hidden Lake Drive, #9 Naples, FL 34112 4. Magnolia Cove of Falling Waters Mr. Raymond C. McCabe, President 2338 Magnolia Lane, #2 Naples, FL 34112 5. Cascades of Falling Waters Condo Association Mr. George W, Baker, President 1972 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 6. Cascades at Falling Waters Mr. Robert Hinklin, President 2004 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 7. Falling Waters Beach Resort Master Association Mr, Donald K. Basseit, President 6580 Beach Resort Drive, #3 Naples, FL 34112 RM :6342441 : 1 BE ADVISED THAT SECTION 10.03.0S.B,3 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIRES AN APPLICANT TO REMOVE THEIR PU8UC HEARING SIGN (S) AFTER FINAL ACTION IS TAKEN BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. BASED ON THE BOARD'S FINAL ACTION ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE REMOVE ALL PUBLIC HEARING ADVERTISING SIGN(S} IMMEDIATELY. Collier County Application 2008 3 !..,if'" _. ' _ _.-".". .,~ '."'" c.''''''I'''"..l''i:...1j'li:..lh.....__~i.i.,'''', .~,..;;" .i..-:'<'''~'''' .1''{!''!"...iJi1 !l~j!).^' ';j:..,"..t4i':,.'::.t!';.'i;\~L'i~~;i::~''':~'~~~---:~~'~~~'~"!.~ I Provide a detailed explanation of the request Including what structures are existing and what Is proposed; the amount of encroachment proposed using numbers, I.e. reduce front setback from 2 5' to 1 8'; when property owner purchased property; when existing principal structure was built (Include building permit number (s) If possible); why encroachment Is necessary; how existing encroachment came to be; ete. ** See Exhibit "e". attached, For projects authorized under lDC Section 9.04.02, provide detailed description of site alterations, Including any dredging and filling. Please note that staff and the Collier County Planning Commission shall be guided in their recommendation to the Board of zoning Appeals, and that the Board of zoning appeals shall be guided in its determination to approve or deny a variance petition by the below listed criteria (1- 8). (Please address these criteria using additional pages if necessary,) 1. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing which are peculiar to the location, size and characteristics of the land, structure, or building involved. 2. Are there special conditions and circumstances which do not result from the action of the applicant such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property which is the subject of the variance request. 3. Will a literal undue applicant. Interpretation of the provisions of this zoning code work unnecessary and hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties on the 4. Will the variance, if granted, be the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the land, bulldlng or structure and whlth promote standards of health, safety or welfare. 5. Will grallting the variance requested confer On the petitioner any special privilege that Is denied by these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings. or structures In the same zoning district. 6, Will granting the variance be in harmony with the intent and purpose of this zoning code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood. or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. 7. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the gOllls and objectives of the regulation such as natural preserves, lakes, golf course, etc. 8. Will granting the variance be consistent with the growth management plan. Collier Counry ApphGation 2008 4 9. OfflclallnterDretatlons or Zonlna Verlflcatlons: To your knowledge. has there been an official interpretation or zoning verification rendered on this property within the last year? 0 Yes IZI No If so, please provide copies, Collier County Applka1ion 2008 5 Variance Petition 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Existing Address) 5864 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (proposed Address) Applicant: FLO TV, Incorporated f/k/a MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Exhibit C Narrative Statement The Applicant seeks variance approval from Section 5.05.09(G)(]7) of the Collier County Land Development Code ("LDC") so as to permit a reduction of the front and side yard setback requirements as applied to existing guy line anchors that support an existing wireless tower located at 5860 Crews Road ("Tower"). This Variance Petition is a companion item to Applicant's pending petition for Conditional Use (CU-2008-AR- ]4085) to permit the installation of a shelter and broadcast equipment on the same Tower. No reduction is needed from the rear setback requirements of the LDC. 1. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing which are peculiar to the location, size and characteristics of the land, structure, or building involved. The subject Tower has existed for nearly 30 years and the guy line anchors were installed in specific locations to maximize the strength and structural soundness of the Tower. Relocating the guy anchors will jeopardize the Tower's strength and structural integrity. 2. Are there special conditions and circumstances which do not result from the action of the applicant such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property whicb is the subject of the variance request. The Applicant was not responsible for the construction of the Tower or the guy anchors, nor was the Applicant affiliated with the Tower or the property at the time the Tower was constructed. As such, the current location of the guy anchors constitutes a pre-existing condition existing prior to the Applicant's use ofthe Tower. 3. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this zoning code work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties on the applicant. Strict adherence to the set back requirements will cause undue hardship to the Applicant due to the fact that the guy Jines support an existing Tower and as such, they cannot be removed without jeopardizing the structural integrity of the Tower. Additionally, the location of the guy anchors was pre- existing prior to the Applicant's use of the Tower. 4. Will the variance, if granted, be the mlDImum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure and which promote standards of health, safety or welfare. The requested variance is the mInimum variance required to ensure the Tower's continued strength and structural integrity in promotion of the safety and welfare of the general public. 5. Will granting the variance requested confer on the petitioner any special privilege that is denied by these zoning regulation to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district. The Applicant will not receive any special privileges as a result of the variance request. RM63425681 6. Will granting the variance be in harmony with the intent and purpose of this zoning code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. The variance request is sought to accommodate the location of existing guy anchors and, as such, the variance will have no known effect to the neighborhood or public welfare if approved. 7. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives of the regulation such as national preserves, lakes, golf course, etc. The Applicant is not aware of any such condition. 8. Will granting the variance be consistent with the growth management plan. The Variance request is consistent with Collier County's desire to "maximize the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites," as set forth in Section 5.05.09(A) of the LDC. The essential service provider for the Tower is the U.S. Department of Justice, FBI, an agency of the Federal Government, in compliance with Section 5.05.09(G)(3) of the LDC. RM:6342568:1 EXHIBit COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVEL WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE LES, FLORIDA 34104 f';jIt. ,"......... "" "'.",,..... - ~ \U '* ~~~ VARIANCE PETITION f~\jP1' C8JDlmeri~lon~1 .. . '1 PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES * & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Date. II f/ (J 1 Tim.. I () .' Z:> 0 Assigned Planner: .:To MiJ s.s Prol..tName. Fto J1/ Uw.MJ.R>V/I'~r'yd J:rwe-r I . Prolect Addr/Locatlon. n~() fj;J;s. ~ ::.... "';:~o 1Jjj;;~""'-"._-+'if 3) n 7-- 100 2--D Current Zoning. r;;.~ Own., Name. ~t>.... ~O J;;tD '(1/ I I Own., Add..... 1:>{1~ Phone:~~ (".\I-3?-l/1- Meeting Attende.s: (attach Sign In Sheet) No~.N~ ~ 'f w.~ f~l G 2.4" 'f 3IP '" . · +t~.~ {iliA ~ Q\. V It ~ I..-.:}>r -' S'. D r: a'1 . 6 ..} 1 ) !Jt *~7 ~,;r':tt;;;;;; t~ ~~) if b '11-, / ~ (,( ~ ry./~tf.J ~ ' d a ~ I S J..ov..bur{ ~ Mct~~Lf. -~r::f. .~. f .. '1/v.J' wi) . t\. '0f.tfA'1A'JY\ I'~ ~ r.lv)tmJ/-M. r j?,{P71 .. ~ 1Yc:(r, ~ 4fe.dld, rt.-vl W/) Y\1 ~(kf ~ ~ ft.rHt UVtM!j . · If telephone pre-application meeting is held, dlrec{the petitIoner to coordinate with..... ~ concerning the requirement for the pefifloner to send the notice letter to the surrounding property owners or 10 gIve Ihem thai information . ~/ttJ PC ~. 1/21 132/+ ~ .{t~~ ~.S) t:Jrt'f1'&0J. /J.A)YJ(i~rrYL 6u.0)"Y\.1-t~~ tAllY\.. rY-1-f f wuls I' . r r 1 oJ- rY\A) 1;+ . VARIANCE PETInON - (VA) APPLICATION SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION, NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITT ALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. Bt:{ ~ #OF NOT REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED ................--- y Comoleted AppllcaHon (download from website for current form) 15 Pre-Aoollcatlon meetlna notes 15 \,/ ..~ .. ...--~- -$'~Ieted Addresslna Cheddlst Slaned bv Addresslna Deoartment I X" ConceDlual Site Plan 24" ,,36" andlOnB\8 V." " II" coov 15 V Survey of property showing the encroaChment (measured In feet) 1 -~ Owner/Agent Affidavit signed & notarized .. I ---~- Deeds/legal's 2 j,-- location map I .~ Aerial photographs (taken within the previous 12 months min. scaled 5 X 1"-200'1. showlna FlUCCS Codes leaend and orolect baundarv Electronic copy of all documents and plans (COROM or Dlskelle) 1 'V' Historical Surveyor waiver reauest -- X- I .-- environmental Impact Statement lEIS) and digital/electronic copy of 'i.. EIS or exemotlon lustification 3 Within 30 days after receiot of the first review comment letter. I X provide Properly Owner Advlsorv lelter and Certification ...-..--- Proiect Narrative 15 ...K U Send copy of review package to Robin Singer, Planning Director, City of Naples 295 Riverside Circle, Naples, FL 34102 illS! I8J Pre-application Fee $500.00 (Applications submitted 9 months or more afhtr the date of the lasl pre-app meeting shall nol be credited towards application fees and a now pre-appllcatlon meeting will be required.) Review Fees: 1$2000.00 Residential $5000.00 Non-Residential After- The-Fact Zoning/land Use Petitions 2x the normal petition fee $100,00 Fire Review 181 $925.00 Estimated legal Advertising Fee - CCPC Meeting 181 $500,00 Estimated legol Advertising fee.. BCC Meeting (over- or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Dolly News). o 2500.00 EIS Review o $1,000 LIsted Species Survey (If EIS Is nol required) OTHER REQUIREMENTS, o 0______ o Agent/Owner Signature Date 2 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS LDC 10.03.06 F.3. eD (f) "Any applicant requesting variance approval ol'-paFkiRg-ex-8mptHm epprevM-must provide documentation to {he planning services department indicating that property owners within 150 feet of the subject site have been advised of the extent and nature of the variance 91' pIiiFkiRf}-6lf9mpti6ft. requested within 30 days of receipt of a letter indicating that the application is sufficient. " Applicant must submit a Property Owner Advisory Letter certifying that the property owners within 150 feel of the subject site were notified. Letter musl have property owners list attached. Property owners list must be submitted after initial staff review and comment on the application and before the Public Hearing is scheduled with the Collier County Planning Commission, 3 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT ADDRESSING DEPARTMENT (i) 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 r- ADDRESSING CHECKLIST J Please complete the following and fax to the Addressing Department at 239-252.5724 or submit In person to the Addressing Department at the above address. Form must be signed by Addressing personnel prior to pre.applloatlon meeting. Nol allllems will apply to every project. Items in bold typo ore required. Forms older than 6 monlhs will requira addlllonal review and approval by the Addressing Department. PETITION TYPE (cheok pelll/on Iype below, complete a seperate Addressing Cheokllst for each Petillon Type) o BL (Blasting Pennlt) o BD (Boat Dook Extension) O....Carnlval/Clrcus Parmll Ail' CU (CondRlonal Uae) o EXP (ExcavBtlon Permit) o FP (Final Plat o LLA (Lol LIne Adjustment) o PNC (Project Name Change) o PPL (Plans & Plat Review) o PSP (Preliminary SUbdivision Plat) o PUD Rezone o RZ (StBndard Rezone) DSDP (Slle Oevelopment Plan) o SOPA (SOP Amendmant) o SDPI (Insubstantial Change to SOP) o SIP (SlIe Improvement Plan) o SIPI (Insubstantlsl Change to SIP) o SNR (sttest Name Change) o SNC (Street Name Change - Unpletted) o TOR (Trsnsfer 01 Development Rights) o VA (Verlance) o VRP (Vegetation Removsl Permll) o VRSFP (Vegetation Removal & Site FIl1 Permit) o OTHER LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subjeot property or properties (copy Of langtllY desarlptlon may be nt/eched) OD ~ak -'8 , ~~c..c::L G.3 FOLtO (Property 101 NUMBER(sl of above (attach 10, or assoclale wIth, legal description If more Ihan one) C<:.':l it~~\(,,<!'.l(!)o'8 STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES (as applloable, If already assIgned) ~\?"l..~ ~\S~ ~t:l. . LOCA~~'if musl be attached Showing exacllooatlon of projecVSlla In relation 10 nearesl public road rtgllt-ot-way . SURVEY (copy - needed only for unplattad properties) PROPOSED PROJECT NAME (If appUoebla) PROPOSED STREET NAMES (If applioeble) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (for existing projeols/sltas only) SOP orAR# I Page 1 012 E e ADDRESSING CHECKLIST. PAGE TWO Project or development names proposed lor, or already appea~ng in, condominium dooumants (If application; Indlcato whether proposed or existing) Please Check One: 0 Checklist Is to be Faxed back IDersonally Picked Up APPLICANT NAME: '-fU..u.,d:JV- ~"Y'\J..a.. &1M0--.-J J,q m~,'i -fix A<<?\ l('A0-j- PHONE FAX Signature on Addressing Checklist does not constitute Project and/or Street Nama approval and Is subject to further review by the Addressing Department. FOR STAFF USE ONLY Primary Number..:f:\:n b\I2\ - ~l.\O <S \ ("oa()~ Addreas Number Address Number Addreas Number -~~fj::::f Updated by: . Date: 6, -;;tt, -() 't: Date: I..\-ao ....c Cj IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST BE UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED Page 2 of2 G:\CUl'font\l\ppUcaUon Forms,^ddrtatlng ChecklIst rey 0-42908,doo .".."" JOIII D. IUI'Mf1IW QUAIll.n I IUD' sum JOO ''01 ''''IMI' TtlAIl .. IlAPl.n, ilOilO. 34100 2422539 OR: 2503 PG: 1624 mOIlIl" omCIll UCOIII.f COLLlII coam, II 1l/lC1II .t 111111 IltGll I. 1I0Cl, CLlU COli 1111ll.II Utili 11.11 DOC'.1I llUI 11"1.!> ;nsrrumf'fH P'l!jJ.irt'(J uv John D HUlllpIHf'lilll>, fsqlJl~" Qualles & ~"...j, <4501 Taml,lfltl ['eI: Nor1t' SUite JOO Napll'~, flllf"l,j \41l1j I,ll: QUUUSI IWl HGI UIU.ll U I Il~a WUS ,~ llltl lOIO WARRANTY!JEED This Indenture, made this -1- 3 1;1 ddyof ) [./IU (~ (If , 1999, between Sterling Communication Corporation, it floridJ corporation, CRANTOR, and RendJ Broadcastmg Corporation a Pennsylvania Corporation, whose federal employer identlfilation number is _, dnd whose post office ,lddrpss is 1459 Crane Avenue, Pittsburgh, PennsylyaOla 15220, GRANTEf Witnesseth that said Grantor, for and in (onslderation of the ~um of TEN DOLLARS, and other good and valuable consideration, to 5aid Grantor in hand p.aid by said Grdntee, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bolrgainro and sold to the said Grantee and Grantee's hein; and assigns forever, the fqUowing described land, situate. Iymg dnd being in Collier County, Ftorida. . \ 1< ( - ,. ) , .. \- - ---! \. .., " - -- ~: --. Th. We<t one-half (W t!2l of the Northw..i o~ll-<lu.rt.r tNW 1/4) ollh. Soulh.a.l one-quart.t (Sf 1/4) 01 th.Southe..l oni!.qua"er (SE 1/4) 01 Section 8, Town.hip 50 South, RanJll' 't("Ea'I,'.co11i,;~ County fll1rida, al.o known a, Tract No. 20, Enchanted I'<re.. r.... t~:~il.lO l~t lor road right-of-way purposes, " / Subject to restrictions, reservations and e~SemE'nts.bf. ~prd, if any; ami feal estate laxe':) for the Y~f 1999, and all su'~~qu'ent ~~fs, bearing Property Identification Number Up40S 160008. . and .aid Grantor doe, hereby lully w~rr'l'11 the.tf\lf tQ laid land, and will defend the 'dOle against the lawful claims of all persol1s wnOn1so'eVer, In Witness Whereof, the Grantor has herpunto 5('t Grantor's hand dnd seal th(' day and year firsl above written, ~a:+",,_.i WIess *1 :14.... is. 1: oM ~ Print name Sf ERLING COMMUNICATIO~ CORPORATION, a rlat i.da ~rporation ~'"2"-'" fure B Ti m, as president /500 Airport Road, South Ni:plt's, florida 34112 Signed, .ealed and delivered In our presence: : "'~ . t',rrl, l! V'/itness #2 (U,l. h , Print name l.i ~~____ { . L . V~'I \~~n"'()rl r :JNU,P'-.. ": l ~ , } " 3 EXHIBIT f::.:' tu OR: 2503 PG: 1625 ttt ST^TEOF 11.\;2,,;) J COUNTYOF~CfV ~.iI The foregoing instrulluml was acknowledgpd before me this ~_~_ dJY at )r;..f1V.AfX --,1999, by Bruce B. Timm, as President of Sterling CommunICations Corporatio I 1....1 who j.;, personally known to me or l J who proouced <.15 identificdtlon ~l}Jt,~ ~t /)I..\...fi"; NOTARY PUBLIC (SEAl I /n,f {l.S/IH O.J (aA(....... Name of NOIJry, Printed, Typed or Stamped My Cornmiss.on hplres: G~,i \ I. "i'Y.,'.._''- Mo;a"'IlC-hLo.~ i\ ,:i ':~ :,j''iSlq~ "'OI~I5f O.Plif5 \\,j ,:._~,~~_' .O:lob.,~, 2002 " . -'''''n'.h''':!., .' ~V'L ',~ Ii' \U AFFIDAVIT Deborah Barrett l>1ediaFLO USA, rne. is an Applicant for a wireless installation on the We/I, Hmml' '~J being first duly sworn, depose and say that we#~Ye'>fM~mt1 property described herein and which is the Subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest Information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belier Well understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered, Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted. the Applicant Kimberly J. Madison, Esq. As f!I~ Well further authorize _ to act as ourlmy representative in any matters regarding this Petition. )(\J.Jrl~ ~~-- -~ Signature of ~~~ Applicant ------------ ._"' Signature of Property Owner Typed or Printed Name of Owner U lllllllY U~l'=i Deborah Barrett ST. Director, Operati OilS L2RieI Oite De:.clopl'F'€l9.t. t1an.:L~e1:: ~...u Rcgisfl Typed or Printed Name of ~wm1}c Applicant The foregoing instrument was acknowledged belore me this /,' ?__ day of _;~;/21'(: , " I I" /. I ~ . 20L-i::., by _~'"v .)/' '. i,1 who is personally known to me or has produced .. as identification. ~ -.:., - - J'iAl;NtSO;';R-MI~~D- ~ ~ Com_ # 1556612 i ~ Nolory Public . Call1ornlo ~ ~ - - - ~:;~;~~ '------::/---~---,-- (Signature of Notary Public) lrfY:/,y)(C'[";;::' 1f!IUj,,'l/ri:) ---1-- ..-----------. ...- (Print Type, or Stamp Commissioned Name of NotalY Public) A,UPUCATlON fOR PU8UC HfARINC FOR CONo/niHII_Hi/SE ~ 4 /4 OJ. fa 5 20 2(105, r(!.' 2 ! 2,e8 AFFIDAVIT Wel" Bill Mueller on behalf of Renda Broadcastinq Corp being first duly sworn, depose and say that we/I am/are the owners of the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief We/I understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered, Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted, As property owner Well further authorize Kimberlv Madison of Ruden McCloskv to reoresent Renda Broadcastinq in relation to the conditional use petition and, to act as our/my representativf7ift any matt/7fSJregarding this Petition /:" /:~~.!/ . .' / / k::. -'~/Ii"~ Signature of Property Owner Signature of Property Owner Bill Mueller Typed or Printed Name of Owner Typed or Printed Name of Owner I The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ,;;2-'/ "^-day of ~ J;t:2~/)<t;(,(j i , ,-{/ ? ,1, 20J2:i, by /~Ll 7~ ,L U( who is personally known to me or has produced as identification (Notary Stamp) )a d-<.. //'/ (tl- (Signatlife of Notary pUF!~ . I ' L~_ (Print, Type, or Stamp Commissioned ) / , , 7'2/ L-~~ ~'_~~~ l Name of Notery Public) Page 10 of 10 Conditional Use Extension Application - Feb. 2008 FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP 330l'T 740 8145 DISTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY DEPfSFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #5 0.22 AC 419 ~ OTHER PINE ~ DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE .JURIS. WETLAND #6 0.15 AC #7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY ~ o l'I U) \ :><>< x<>x >6< x ><>< ::x> :x;><,;>< X;> ><:><X-,,/ XX->< -./ "" ~ >0< ~~:><:> ><> >0< x22 >6<x~ ~~ x ~><x:x:>:so: ~><> x x(: xc X ><",. ~ ~ .? >0< :><>,J<- x x::>< ~ ~ ~ >< ><><:xX;::;:: x::><;:X ><:><> XX ~ ><;x><><>x;::;:: >6< Z ><:><>:> x ><><:x y ':x >6< >S: >0< >0<>< x x x >0< y >6<3 ><",. ><:><>::x> ':x ~ /' / <' ~9<x x >0< Q<"'- ><J< >0< x x::>< '-' x >< >O<:>:::x x x ':x:>< >< x x ~ >< >0< :><:::x x x >6< x "" "X'-- >< >< >0< ~ x x> >x>' ><:>>y< :X;x x ex V'< ><: x. "". ~ >< >O<:><:::x >< ::>:> >< ~ >v :x ;x >< >0< >6<~ >< ><:> ,':x x >< >0<2 ><:>::x ~ >< ><:> > ~ >< Y.>< X:< ~ I ",,: x Xx x"-- ",,/'x:X . ,,~ x ~ '-!:><:X x . 4.. x IV",; x x IQO< x x ~t> ~ >0<x xx r:::sx ~ x xx.xx x ..:~~~ ~ ~1~ x xX x >6< ~~~~ ~~~~ x ~.x>< ><5; ~ '\:: ~ ~ ~ J\.~ ~ ~" ~~xYXX:X ><>0<x>x>xl\' "'-j >6 ",X J< ""><- x >0<~x~' "V' /' 0: 'Y :xx?<?' ><::~~ s: ~~ ~ ~ . i I I 1"1 . i i ! :><><> ~ 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEPISFWMD .JURIS. WETLAND USACOE .JURIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.06 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC Il'l'm 740310 IttW DISTURBED LAND I GRASS PRAIRIE DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #30.15 AC @3 D 7408212 DISTURBED LAND I COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #4 0.38 AC ES] . TOWER \ ~ f' 0\ ~ - - - ~ - - -l't - ! : CREWS ROAD ROW 40 , o 40 80 120 Feet , ~*E S PRO.JECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 figure 4. FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; I G BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. AERIAL FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. Figure 5. Aerial I FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsev Inc. Environmen'tal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples.FL 34120 239.56...1660 ~ ::' ~ il II II III, II! Ii j , ~i III ~. 0'1 "" e I ! 1'1 II I III "e ~ 8~ i!l . ~" vig ~ II I 1111 ~p "e . !" ~j Ei Vlt;:: i f- <>~>;' I'I! ~8 ~ ~a :.= ~,e Ii! -- ~ mmm. , ~ e~ "i " , , .i. e~ , I . :1' III I;! . ~ . n ~ ~ ~ _ 0 iii , I I ; 11,1 " ! 0 0 , , ~ ''I , i t" · i ..,~ I ,:j; ! . I ; ~ .f', , I! I'! '1"~U "' ! i, ~! Ii: i:,! ~ I, ~ !i><~"-~ OC'i l r' ; <!'I . . ~.o, ~ !1I1 I ' ~ ~^ t I I l I! ' ,1 jq , I . l, l"l ,nl II , 'II! " ~ , ~:: 1~1 . 'ii i. . ! II ~ 3 . t ~ ii illll,ih '- ," E e w~~a ~ e ~ ~ . ~ I " 0 , 0 ~ . 1, " , .;j ~ ~E~~Slt;g 0 :Ii ~ei Iii 0 ;; ~ 0 " ~~ u @ 5 ~ ",lUll! 0 ~_I ~:r => ~ ~~ " . bI" ~ g tl z .. . , 9 il:i N "- 0 ~ e il~!! I'! i~ll: ~!II.. I".i~ ill' !!l; 'j.!! li~ Iii;! ',1>,11 Iii ~ Sl!!oll~ l 'ili!!! 11!11! ! ,I" " " .II 1.'1" 'I!ig I"'! ill !ll ,i 1.1 ! ~, , . " i il! I I'"j I', 'I' , h![ i iLl .1 Iii!!! idHi I !! I II, i "! I lq, I ,I . Iii' II 1111 :1 , ,j ., l!i!:i ~ ~ !Ill! ! lilgg! N o 0:: ---' '<j' u"'VJr<1 o 3: IVJw---' <(wo::u", D- ---' U _ :::;:D- VJ <(<('<j'w f-Z<o---' 00D- If)<( Z ":> . ~ J ~ j]0:! ~ "0" :1 . ~~., 1~ pU's ~ ,Ct.. S !:et Blvd . Sahli Barb<ira 8~ -:,-, <I) ~ ~ II ~ ~. ~ Ii"' q,j~k S~ Q:.: :' "" ~ 1:' Ql 'i (.') "" E ~ l ! ~o"n;~ B,mYRd 8 ~ Glen Eagle i r i[ " 'I I l.eM saC/lit Ii Kings Lake Blvd PAle 1!8'MiH > - ~ :0 o E ~ .fQ,&,,~ lJ.J ~ :l' ~ I :+.ll'R"IOod Blvd . . "'li 'I,' I:! ,I; 5 !~l . 11:1 Iii: Ii,. !!~: " '" ~ o ~ E ~ + ~ ~ ~ h ~ ~ ~ r--'---'--'- ~ i~ ' II ~ ! ;! I~ .~ :..! "'..:? u it I .. ~ ::5 - iil III M'f!i '1" EI ! 1:'1 I"!I':! ! ,I !hl'ili ! ! I I' ~ IIU,,! ! l ~l> j ~:sg ,I ,~" , .j)-.;, ~ .,...... .' t~ . I . :~", "'.\ rI 0,'-' "'I' . -~ III ., alf' -' .{:" m! =1' g ~~~~~ :~~~~ :::lEa.. a...... ~~i~8 fl % ~ ~ ~ I '" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ , , , . . . I ~ ! , ' g!i H;!ri~ fli~lfi I Ii S.dlid,I"d .. 'IJI II Hd" : "'iii " 1__- i ---,'-,-------~ . i; . , . i ~ I I I i i iHI ;! ,nHI 'v Ii i~~~:~ I. ~~'3!. .' I"S1Ig f I I i I I L. /---- I ~j .l~tt ~m. i!.. il~f:~ D~I 'I . 1ft 1 f Ii ~ ~ i~U . -.----- --'---'-- .-- -- ." I d ,n ;..m ~lf\ 'Ii i]- 11:1 J ~ j 0( , . i , t " Ii U ~ s i , Hi d di HI II ,I I ~.... iL~ I I i I~lh h rftfl . I I -. I I I ! ~~~~" , I I ~,,~'S I f l~- i I r~~!7j;;:,F---.l I' 1 I; I' I I "" . .. I ,I . \ I fiiU' \ i i--'---'- ! i!, :il I I " "~'f1"~''1'l' i) I 11 I f/ I J i ~-~,~,~,-1 I . L,~E~~.JD I 1'-'---' !!" ~_,.., Ji I " i. I !! ~j i". 1"'- I "'- , I , / .! .r:~ ~ ~i~li! !~ !'~!;g r I I I I I L_ :I: , l ~ ~ j ! I! ,~ tf Ir' s ' al -..Ii -"'t!~l:! % ~,,;~.~ J::l i iil5~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~:::8 I!:: !; 0( . ~ I . ~ ~ ~ j I J /' /' ~ '~ '~ '-'---, I I ! i 1--1 i -., ! i I [' ~l - i.. "v Ii rrF ~! ................... .... """. .... ----.------.- -_.~._- ~ · l ~ j:; i~ ! m! I~ !~r iii % j =~ ~~ Q. ; o <c g.... ~ ~~ ~~ "~ "~ ~~ is a; ~ I ~ ~ "\, /' \// // \ /> '- /// \ // '-.:---./ \ / -~"-'-'- \ /' . " '-r-',' "0: i /'/\~ . . . ' \ ,rr------- - /. /' II . I C y ~ ~ ~ ridHlid: II ! " n! ! II I ~ G 00 0 0 0 G 0 00. i L_______ " II'!. II; '",11 ar, dilUl ~!i ! . ! i!~:!~ I. ~"3!' .' ts!;~ r ----------------- ~- ~l ft "H J:; i~ ! o! I~ !~r iii " , . o ~ =~:~~ ~ ; ~~!ui~ ~ Sj ~ '1 ~~~~~ i 6" i <( ...~;%~u !i ~ ~ ~ -- y //< r /' . /' I /' . /' j I I I I I I I I I < r \f\ i\ I \\ i \\ i \\,-., I \ i > o I i " ,: . , " . , I I I I I I I I I I .j, i J I I I ~j I : ~! r lu ;~ll~~~Ul L__ ______ , ~ . Ii!;;: !~ ~'g~;g f . I ill Iji li.c,' a I dilUl ~ !ill I I I I I I I I I , L ~j ".......,... .., . ". ~ Ii U! II ~ ~r" ; " d _-Illi:...", VI _10. 11l'" I- ::t 2: lj'vi~c.it1 Ii' eio ~~~~~ !;i i:~ ~t:~8 ! ~a . . . ~ ~ ! ~ ~ ~ i II :" i ~ i ^-' ~1iE)ie;"~"::iiii';.' , !."___V"'_'--'-_'_'~"~---,__," ".. .---:--~;;.;.;;;;)1S;l,;"~I:;;:':i:..,i"ii---- ~-~"""- -~- ""-=..,;;;,....,~';~"';,,-' -'~'-''''''-''-1 , r" ~""'-, --,,-,~-;~-::;:::':.::"~,~',,:"'-":,:,'~:,,"J III ),,' , I,'. ./1 r--"..'ii#ii;;;~'''''',..."t,:n,r'''''~---''l --- r 'M~..Q~1..~ril~ ~-~t--~ ii,jj~~~-"tt-'I 1; i, ;,1,' t"" "~~'.w:~1S.~.'ii~j;~;r"---'-J, 1")1, j , I "I II : I I ~j i.l ~ ~ EJ . I., n iH (r}i JI ~ ~,' ' ! = f n E '" ~... .---~.'i,,;;;;)ii<";~4~,..;\O.i . - .------ - .- -- ---."-.--..--------- ----.-------------..----.----..- -.._---.. -----. ------ 1'-' ~j tt . , ~ I; Ii i II! j~ ! ~r i ii . l ';.'" it . ~I ~dh. \ . t4a~r ., ill f ~.'.....$ II.. j'..' ~' df.'IJ! .11 'I i.~I., g ~I ~~ i P II< .~ "j 'I' 1 . In - .. ''''if \'~i~r Ji I J; ~ :; I. - " l/; 'L.__-_._"j ''''Ii it 'fj o- r",!' j~~ - -- -.' --..------- --....-..--... ---------.---- - ----"-"-'--- ----._--, --...-..,- ---__..____ -......0 ci ..Jll<..J1ol VI ~~~~ ~ g~ ! ~ ~5~~ ~ ~~ e ~ ~:~8 L,o,IIol ~ . . v 7; / I . ',0 --- . -.. -; ;mUI33~ di~il~.~z 'I .~ !!'l~o . ~iBm~s~a~;;j I-I ~ ~ ~~n 115;131: ~~~~dn al~f!S~ il!~~II! ~[jld] ! U I" II .. .... ~ <0>1 0 a 0 lliillilm i ~i ~ ~ I R II: I ~ 0 ~~ ~ i m ~ p ~ ~ ~ ii i m ~ ~ h si a ! ~ is II ~ ~ .~ il n ~o : ~~ ;;i ;:j~ L "',lE ~i1a -<...., ~~~ zl' Fl 0- G~s~ ~2: .. '" n tTj ;J . ~ s.... i ir ~~. P 2 III ~ f ~ ~.. -~ ;iii~ : ~ ~ H;, filh I'-'-'-'-'~ jcf0 i ~ 'm rnl~ ! ~ ~ g 1 ~ I CJ ~ -a i= j _ G>J I @ ~ -~I i '-_1 i~~ ~~i i g L._. ~q~ ~~ ~~ ~~m. !~ !~ I i~11 did 'h I ~~~ / ~$: : In q:> ~~ a ~ I ~~ Ii q~ ~ , ~q , ~~ ~ I ~: ql w; !/ . ~ ~ , ,~ I: ~ ~ / ~ If l. '. '. '\ \ - / ~/ q ! ~ ~;:<<> ~~ _N l!l Jj iff =1f! 0 I ~~ ~ .... ~~ @ < . ~ e . e ~ 0_0_0_'_0 "'> ~ 3lI!:-so'i-e NOU.:)]5 JO to/I lSY3Hlcm 3Hl. JO th .lS'OKll'lOS ]1(1 jO to/I J.S)1IHUION 3HL:JKl JO tit lS:JI\ iHJ. JO 31<<1 J.SJIII .8'. ,. f ~S/ - -~ !~f I ~ ':lJi III o' ~iP 1,1'1 , i I i I I "'.~iH , I i -, I .!a ~ q~ l I ! ill i ~ II 5'" S 'f ~~ ! ill ~o t f I I g !II I q i ~ !I I ~ 'I ,I_ e", I I_ II I 0Y0w lallO ~ ,01 c .' , ~ ..: i:: ~ "i\ o . in . " ;.. ... . . . _ c :\~~ ""-.... '"., <!!!i,,,' i ~ - q !/ ~/ ]R-so;-t HIJII.:QS JO loll .LSY3H1t'lOS JH1 JO ./1 J.$V3HU10S 3HI. JO .hlSlllHU'O" :JKI.3H1.JO Z/11Sll1Hl. JO JNnlSYl . - ~ otfI _ --------- f .~'I!iil . . ~ . q~1 ! ~~ ~ I~ " 1': .ssa~:gg~j; ~. ~I ~'I q III !I k ~ u .d ~ hi ~ i ~~ . f " . ~ - ~ I . I ~~ I~ ~~ _l " - ~ ~~ ::~ 0 JJ'" ! _11I2 ~ ~ ~~~ s ~ il- .... ~~ ! ~;i Ij i If'!; Iii l!~ ;::1 lili ;I! of; ~i i m~i.s :11 ji il~ ~M~~ xi vi ~ i- Illiql~ 5~ I~ ~'a h~~ d ~ I ~~: jft;il I~~ Ii I~i ~!i! ~;m i a ~3Ii~ ~I ~II '.~ ~~ ~ I~~ ~6 ~. st 5~~'a ~ iiil ~i :8 ji~ i~~ ~~ ~ Pi q ~~ Ii I~ij ~i$ ~~ i ~ 1$ ~~ m~a $ ~ ~ -< .... ~ f!l~i~ i~ij;;l iqq~ , ~i ~;!~ il t ~ , -;; " i \ \ ~ , -. .. " i \ '" ~ ~a z d~ ~=I ~~ j~ el , -. " i % in ~ , -. I~ gi- 6ii i~~ I~fi :~ . z I I . g~~ I .~~ rPi' . d . ~!=' ~ Q .~.c1.1 S ~~~m!~ ~ ihS~'~ q i!i:!il i IS q~l~ - q f'l~ i I~ ~~~~ ~ gi~ ~, q 6gi ~ : I;~ g I~j ~ !~ q ~ f m:~~!! . i iii!i:!I' ~l q~! ~- I ~~~ " ; ~glg"~ ~ >>MI~ ~ .mi~~ ~ ~~~ ~ ~~~~~ U~ql ~~g~a q~ ~ / ~ gi~i~~i i~ii~~ ~ii ~~ !~i~i~ ~i ~ I ~qm'B~' Bi I~I j'" ~~ ~~. rm ~; ~ ~ I~il~~~~ ;i!xl,q ~II I~ ~S~;; i~ ~ I ~~~;8' ~.R~~ igi S m[j~~~. i !:i B ~~~B~ qi~m~ i!~~ ~ lqMs ~ '6 ~ ~S~~~~ J;;~I! ~d ~ !i!i;! ~ j i~~h; ~~il! !,il~ ~ ~;'~I:' ~ da~.; ~~~:g ~~ !~g:M 2 a'~.'" ~S' ~~ ~ @ ~ s~s~l: li"I!~! !~I; q~ q>.~ ~tj . ,tll. S Ii ~I~ 6ii ~~~ ~~~ ~~ . z "')> iCP ~.. (D ~!iii~ ~~~ r ~ ~g -I ~ i~ CJ) ~i 5; 11< ~~ AERIAL FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP .. PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA BROADCASTING CORP. C) Figure 5. Aerial I FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; ~N.' + BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsev Inc. Environmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples" FL 34120 239.564.1660 FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEP/SFWMD .!URIS. WETLAND USACOE .!URIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.06 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC II"l'l'fI 740310 IttttI DISTURBED LAND I GRASS PRAIRIE DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #30.15 AC f23 O 7408212 DISTURBED LAND I COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEPfSFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #4 0.38 AC ~ 7408145 ~ DISTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #5 0.22 AC 419 ~ OTHER PINE ~ DEPfSFWMD UPLAND USACOE .!URIS. WETLAND #6 0.15 AC #7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY . TOWER ------- ---------- 40 0 40 80 120 Feet I I 330 FT t: o I'l Ul "- \ [xX Xx ~~"'^' ~ ::x x x 0x v<x>< x >0< x x XY' x >9<X>< ><XX ><~ ~ ><:xx >< ~~ x X X x (::x x X ;x ><:,x x X '0 x x x v<>< Xx 'x v<>< >x:x x xx x ~X >0< x V< >0< Xx ~ ><X>Q< >Q< ~ 0 x >< Y x:>><><X-:> x~><><><x~ x x:>x: ~ >sQ< x ::x x x:; x ~ XX"'x "V>< x ">< x '>< x x X ;x ~>O<;x 'x '>< >Q<Xx x xxx x ;xx~ ;x ;x >< x :"> "V>< x >< ",x ><> >: ~x x>< >0< >< 0<">< ",;x::X >< XXx x,>< x>Qxx Xx : xX: ~ x x~ ?:> xx>> ~ :><;xx".,;xxx 0Q<>< .;~X~XX X >Q<>< ~ XXx~X x><>o QSg k ><xx ~ :XX::x x ><xx:> x,;x >0< 'x 0 X ;x >< xxx x I >< x >< 'x · 10.\0< x n XJ< IX,' "'>< 4..t ~-"'><> x 0<>- "K 5:: ~~ ;x ~::::- 0 ,:>x ~ 'A""'- "v ::::- ~~ ~l,'\< ~~ ><- ><::: v vx k x x X>>' ~X :x>S<:X" ~~ 'X x >QQ< y<~ XYx x>> ,,~~ ~ 0y ;x X:~~ >< x ~ ~~ X'< x x,><~ 0 >;:;>Q< ~ :x ~ Xx ;x ~10"". ~ . \ - - _~\I\_ I 1Tl'~~ I CREWS ROAD ROW r PRO~ECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 + 'FIgure 4. FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmedtal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!, FL 34120 239.5_.1660 AGENDA ITEM lO-B Co.:r County ~ --- SUPPLEMENTAL STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION HEARING: JANUARY 7, 2010 SUBJECT: PETITION CU-2008-AR-14085, FLO TV INCORPORATED (COMPANION ITEM V A-PL-2009-037) PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: FLO TV, Inc. 5775 Morehouse Drive San Diego, CA 92121 Agent: James J. Porter, Esq.lKimberly J. Madison, Esq. Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A 401 East Jackson Street, Ste. 2700 Tampa, FL 33602 REOUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Conunission (CCPC) consider an application for Conditional Use Number 3 of the Estates (E) Zoning District, as specified in Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC), for a communications tower and related mechanical equipment shelters. PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: This item and its companion Variance petition were heard by the CCPC at their October IS, 2009 public hearing. However, due to issues raised by CCPC members necessitating further research, the applicant requested a continuance of the hearing, which was ultimately rescheduled for January 7, 2010. The specific questions raised by the CCPC are listed below, with staff's responses highlighted in bold font: CU-2008.AR-14085 12/17/09 1. Was a certificate of occupancy ever issued for the new tower and, if so, why wasn't the old tower dismantled as required by the approving Conditional Use Resolution (No. 93- 219)? The new tower was properly inspected and did receive the required certificate of occupancy prior to becoming operational. However, because the Building Department inspectors do not refer to the approved resolution to verify that the conditions of approval attached to them, if any, have been fulfilled, they did not know of the condition of approval attached to Resolution No. 93-219 that required the old tower to be dismantled. Nevertheless, ensuring compliance with such conditions of approval is normally under the purview of Zoning and Land Development Review staff, and occurs at the time of site development plan (SDP) review and approval. However, in this instance, the applicant needed to maintain the old tower on the site until after the new tower was erected so that the existing antennae could be transferred from the old tower to the new one without an interruption in service. Because of this unique circumstance, Zoning and Land Development Review staff should have required a note on the SDP stating that the old tower had to be removed after the transfer took place, so that it might have been clear to the building inspector that it ueeded to be dismantled. However, it should be noted that the approved SDP did not depict the old tower-ouly its concrete pad- and referred to the new tower as the "replacement tower." The application submitted with that SDP was also unambiguous about the applicants' intent to dismantle the old tower, stating "This SDP amendment is only to replace the existing communications tower structure" and "all the antennas on the existing tower [will be] moved to the new tower... and the existing tower removed." 2. LDC Section 5.05.09. G.3 allows standalone communications towers with Conditional Use approval, provided the tower is owned by, or leased to, an essential service that is the primary user. What is the difference between an essential service "tower" versus an essential service "antenna"? The LDC defines a tower as "a structure whose primary purpose is to raise the height of an antenna." No definition is provided for an antenna or for the "primary user." Nevertheless, staff has historically defined a primary user as a governmental entity whose antenna must remain on the tower for as long as the tower exists; so while other commercial users are free to CU-2008-AR-/4085 /2//7/09 2 use a particular tower and then relocate their antennae to other towers as needed, the governmental entity's antenna is obligated to remain. As such, it is staff's opinion that any tower with an essential service's antenna(e) monnted on it is an essential service tower. 3. Can the essential service user be a leasee? If so, what happens to the other antennae on the tower if the essential service user decides not renew their lease? Does the tower have to come down? According to LDC Subsection 5.05.09.G.3, towers may indeed be leased to a governmental entity. The LDC is silent as to what would happen !. to the non-essential! service users' antennae on a tower should the , essential service user decide not renew his lease and move his antennae elsewhere. (For a list of the commercial tenants on the site's towers, see Appendix 1.) However, pursuant to a policy memo by the Zoning Director, an essential service tower in the E zoning district may not be without a replacement essential service user fora period of more than six months, or else a Code Enforcement violation would be initiated to have the tower dismantled. .q~~,11 .",.:/;:f;;<~,~ , "'~\'t".:~I.i.>.,~ ~_.,.~ .,.., ... 4. What is the required "collapse zone" for the tower? Normally, the required collapse zone for towers over 185 feet is 2.5 times the tower's height from any adjoining residential zoning districts. However, essential service towers are exempted from this requirement. Nevertheless, the applicant has provided staff with a certified letter from a Florida-licensed engineer (Appendix 2) testifying that, in his opinion, due to the design of the guy lines on the subject towers, "it is virtually impossible for the tower[s] to fall in a straight line the way a tree might." Rather, if a tower were to collapse, it would "fall in upon itself in an accordion-type fashion, with the debris contained within the anchor radius of the guy cables." 5, Are lights required for the subject towers since they are in excess of 150 feet? CU-2008-AR-14085 12//7/09 3 Yes. The project was reviewed and approved by the Collier Mosquito Control District, who determined that only one of the towers needed to maintain either a solid red beacon or a dual mode light since the towers are a mere 50 feet apart. However, as noted in the letter from the agency provided to the applicant (see Appendix 3), this exemption is strictly limited to the subject site only and wonld not automatically apply to other sites in the County. Mosquito Control also informed staff that, due to the towers' heights, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) might still require both towers to maintain lights. A. .uch, a condition of approval has been incorporated .into the attached resolution requiring that both towers be equipped with lights unless a waiver of this requirement is granted by the FAA. 6. Are communications towers routinely inspected by the County? According to LDC 5.0S.09.G.14, guyed towers exceeding 185 feet are to be inspected every two years by an engineer or other qualified professional, and any recommended repairs are to be made without delay. The report of this inspection is required to be filed with the County Manager no later than December 1 of the applicable inspection year, and if such report recommends repairs, a letter verifying that the repairs have been made is also required to be submitted to the County Manager following to their completion. To ensure that this reqnirement is fulfilled, staff is mailing notification letters to each of the affected tower owners informing them of this biannnal requirement. The reports subsequently submitted by these owners will then be reviewed by County Engineering staff and maintained on file with the repair reports, if any. Staff will be following up with the CCPC on this new protocol after the New Year in order to apprise them of its status. 7. What happened to communications tower on Tower Road? Why did it collapse? This tower collapsed under usual circumstances in that its failure was not caused by a hurricane, tornado or other violent wind, but rather by a propane fire that was ignited while the tower was being welded. The heat from the gas-fuelled fire actually melted the steel lattice, provoking its collapse. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney's Office reviewed this staff report on December 10, 2009. RECOMMENDATION: Zoning and Land Development Review staff recommends that the CCPC forward Petition CU- 2008-AR-14085 to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval, subject to the following stipulations: CU-2008-AR-/4085 /2//7/09 4 1. The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the Conceptual Site Plan, identified as "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28,2007, as revised through April 9, 2009. The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for Conditional Use approval only. The fmal design must be compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations. 2. Development on the site shall be restricted to 3,359 square feet of impervious area. 3. Maximum height of the two towers on the site shall be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances. 4. Both towers on the site shall be equipped with either solid red beacon or dual mode lights unless a waiver of this requirement is granted by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). 5. All guy line anchors shall be fenced pursuant to LDC 5.05.09.0.12. 6. One tower on the site shall be owned by or leased to a governmental entity for government-related, essential service purposes. Should this entity remove its antennae e) from the tower, the property owner shall immediately notify the County and replace the antennae e) with another essential service user within sixty days. CU-2008-AR.14085 12/17/09 5 PREPARED BY: ~ l):J/th-v~ JO . -DAVID MOSS, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW REVIEWED BY: ~ RAYMO V. BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW xdA...J. "A , '-1'h. ~ '/SUSAN M. ISTENES, AICP, DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW APPROVED BY: H K. SCHMITT, DMINISTRA OR MUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL VICES DIVISION Jut:)) 01 1l-/7.I(~? I ATE J~J~~ 9 DA ' /~/.:2lk I f DATE Tentatively scheduled for the February 23, 2009 Board of County Commissioners Meeting COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION: MARK P. STRAIN, CHAIRMAN CU-2008-AR-14085 12/17/09 6 DATE Jones, Ann From: Sent: To: Subject: Madison, Kimberly J. Thursday, December 31, 2009 10:59 AM Jones,Ann FW:FLO TV -----Original Message----- From: MossJohndavid [mailto:JohndavidMoss@colliergov.net] Sent: Wednesday, December 30, 2009 1:30 PM To: Madison, Kimberly J. Subject: RE: FLO TV No. It has unfortunately been published and sent. It will be easy to correct on the record though. The report itself is clear that it is six months based on the Director's determination. JD -----Original Message----- From: Madison, Kimberly J. [mailto:kimberly.madison@ruden.comJ Sent: Wednesday, December 30, 2009 1:24 PM To: MOssJohndavid Cc: Jones, Ann Subject: Re: FLO TV So there is no way to revise the actual report? On Dec 30, 2009, at 1:22 PM, "MossJohndavid" <JohndavidMoss@colliergov.net > wrote: > Kim, > > I'm sorry for the error. I will correct that on the record at the > hearing because the reports have already been sent out to the PC. > > JD > > -----Original Message----- > From: Madison, Kimberly J. [mailto:kimberly.madison@ruden.com] > Sent: Wednesday, December 30, 2009 8:22 AM > To: MossJohndavid > Cc: Jones, Ann > Subject: Re: FLO TV > > Hi JOhn-David > > Could you please revise page 5, paragraph 6 of the report. It says > '60 days' instead of '6 months' for the time required to replace the > essential service provider. It should be 6 months (in accordance with > the recommendation of 6 months made on page 3 ~3 of the report) . 1 > > Thanks and happy new year! ! > > > > On Dec 23, 2009, at 4:39 PM, "MossJohndavid' > <JohndavidMoss@colliergov.net >> wrote: > >> Kim, >> >> >> >> Attached is the CU report. The VA didn't change. >> >> >> >> Have a nice holiday!! Talk to you next week if you have questions, >> >> >> >> JD >> >> >> >> From: Madison, Kimberly J. [mailto:kimberly.madison@ruden.comJ >> Sent: Wednesday, December 23, 2009 lO:3B AM >> To: MossJohndavid >> Cc: Jones, Ann >> Subject: FLO TV >> >> >> >> Good morning John-David: >> >> >> >> Are the revised staff reports available yet? Thanks! >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> Kimberly J. Madison >> Attorney >> >> >> >> 401 East Jackson Street >> Suite 2700 >> Tampa, FL 33602 >> Direct 813-314-6709 I Fax B13-314-6809 kimberly.madison@ruden.com I >> www.ruden.com >> >> >> >> >> >> To subscribe to our advisories, please click here. >> <http://www.ruden.com/publications-subscribe.html> >> >> >> >> >> 2 >> NOTICE: This e-mail message and any attachment to this e-mail message >> contains confidential information that may be legally privileged. If >> you are not the intended recipient, you must not review, retransmit, >> convert to hard copy, copy, use or disseminate this e-mail or any >> attachments to it. If you have received this e-mail in error, please >> notify us immediately by return e-mail or by telephone at >> 954-764-6660 and delete this message. Please note that if this e-mail >> message contains a forwarded message or is a reply to a prior >>message, some or all of the contents of this message or any >> attachments may not have been produced by the sender. >> >> >> >> >> >> <SUPPLEMENTAL STAFF REPORT12_2_09 (666) .docx> <-WRDOOO.jpg> >> <image001.jpg> 3 Colri'~r County STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION HEARING: OCTOBER 15,2009 SUBJECT: PETITION CU-2008-AR-14085, FLO TV INCORPORATED (COMPANION TO VARIANCE PETITION VA-PL-2009-037) PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: FLO TV, Inc. 5775 Morehouse Drive San Diego, CA 92 I 21 Agent: James J. Porter, EsqJKimberly J. Madison, Esq. Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P,A 401 East Jackson Street, Ste. 2700 Tampa, FL 33602 REOUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider an application for Conditional Use Number 3 for communications towers and related mechanical equipment shelter in the Estates (E) Zoning District, as specified in Section 5.05,09 of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The approximately 4,77-acre subject property is located at 5860 Crews Road, which is south of Davis Boulevard and east of County Barn Road, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, of Collier County, Florida (see the location map on the following page), PURPOSE/DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: On May 25,1993, Resolution No, 93-219 (see Appendix I) was approved for a Conditional Use on the subject property to allow the replacement of an existing 438-foot guyed communications tower and its associated mechanical equipment structures with a 430-foot guyed communications tower and a 2,400 square-foot building. Six years later, due to a federally mandated frequency and power change that could not be accommodated on the site's tower and antenna, the owner of CU-2008-AR-14085 September 24. 2009 Page 1 018 . . . the property, Renda Broadcasting, amended the SOP to allow for another replacement communications tower with a much stronger 394-foot tower. However, instead of removing the tower and erecting a new one, as per the approved SOP, the new tower was simply erected approximately 50 feet away from the existing tower, thereby expanding the use on the site. Not only was this additional tower in violation of the approved SOP, it also contravened Resolution No. 93-219, which permitted only one communications tower, and further stipulated that any "expansion of the uses... or major changes to the site plan submitted... require the submittal of a new conditional use application..." It was not until the applicants, who lease tower space from the owners, attempted to permit an antenna on what was supposed to be a dismantled tower that the County became aware of this violation. In order to redress the infraction and comply with the terms of the approved resolution, the applicant has submitted the subject Conditional Use application, which if approved, would legitimize the existence of the additional communications tower and allow for the expansion of the use on the site. As shown on the Conceptual Site Plan on the preceding page, entitled, "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28, 2007, as revised through April 9, 2009, the unmanned facility is somewhat centrally located on the site, allowing the E Zoning District's required 75-foot front and rear yard setbacks and 30-foot side yard setbacks to be well exceeded. The two existing communications towers and their accessory equipment shelters are shown enclosed within a chain-link fence. The towers are spaced 50 feet apart and linked by elevated walkways labeled as "coax bridges." The walkways connect the towers to a newly proposed 224 Aerial View square-foot equipment shelter, which would house a generator and transfonner, and would be mounted by two new dish antennae and a GPS antenna. Two existing parking spaces for the facility are also shown within the facility's gates, accessible via a private drive from Crews Road. A dead-end, dirt spur road provides access for maintenance vehicles to the tower- CU-2008-AR-/4085 September 24. 2009 Page 2 of 8 . . o supporting guy lines and anchors adjacent to the eastern boundary of the site (these guy lines and anchors, as well as others on the western boundary of the property, are the subject of the companion Variance application). Along the northern boundary of the site, a 20,786 square-foot conservation easement is proposed. Because the site is heavily wooded, as shown in the aerial photograph on the preceding page, the existing vegetation would serve to satisfy the project's perimeter buffer requirements. Because of the limited nature of the proposed change, 79.3 percent of the site would remain as open space. SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: East: South: West: Vacant land, zoned Falling Waters PUD Vacant land, zoned Falling Waters PUD Crews Road, then vacant land, zoned E Vacant land, zoned Falling Waters PUD , IIi".~ ,t ,~'" .. I.. . .. AA......_ GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY: The subject property is designated Urban-Mixed Use Oistrict, Urban Residential Subdistrict on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP. Relevant to this petition, the designation permits non-residential uses, including utility and communication facilities. FLUE Policy 5.4 requires new land uses to be compatible with and complementary to the surrounding land uses as set forth in the LOC. It is the responsibility of the Zoning and Land Oevelopment Review staff as part of their review of the petition in its entirety to perform this compatibility analysis. Based upon the above analysis, staff concludes that the proposed Conditional Use may be deemed consistent with the Future Land Use Element. CU-2008-AR-/4085 September 24. 2009 Page 3 of8 ANAL YSIS: A Conditional Use is defined in the LDC as, "A use that due to special circumstances is not permissible in a zoning district, but may be appropriate if controlled as to number, area, location, or relation to the neighborhood," Per LDC Section 10,07,02.0, before any Conditional Use can be recommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA), the Planning Commission must make a finding that: I) approval of the Conditional Use will not adversely affect the public interest; 2) all specific requirements for the individual Conditional Use have been met by the petitioner; and 3) satisfactory provisions have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable: I. Consistency with the Land Development Code and the Growth Management Plan. As noted above, the existing communications towers are consistent with the provisions of the Urban Residential Subdistrict of the GMP. Furthermore, the LDC permits communications towers as a Conditional Use in the E Zoning District provided that the tower is owned by or leased to an essential service, which is also the primary user. Pursuant to LDC subsection 5,05.09,G.3, Essential Services, such governmental uses include, but are not limited to, safety service facilities such as fire stations, sheriffs substations or facilities, emergency medical service facilities, or any other similar use where a communications tower could be considered a logically associated use. (It should be noted that while there is no definition in the LDC, staff has historically defined this "primary user" as any approved governmental entity which must remain on the tower for as long as the tower exists; so while other commercial users' are free to use the tower and then relocate their antennae to other towers as needed, the governmental entity is obligated to remain.) As noted in the applicant's narrative statement (Exhibit D to the application), the new tower would meet this provision as the primary user would be the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), an agency of the US Department of Justice, Since Resolution No. 93-219 was for a Conditional Use to allow the replacement of a tower that was never actually removed, staff determined via a zoning verification letter issued on April 3, 2008 (ZLTR 2007-AR-12825) that the old tower was now an illegal use. As such, the purpose of the subject Conditional Use is to seek approval of an expansion of the use, pursuant to Resolution No. 93-219, and legitimize the old tower's existence alongside the newer tower. Both the GMP and LDC subsection 5,05.09,G.9 encourage the placement of more than one tower on a site, provided that all setbacks, design and landscape requirements are met and the structures are only located as close to each other as technically feasible so that the failure of one tower would not cause the failure of (or present an unacceptable risk to) any other tower on the site. Although staff would normally insist that this tower comply with the aforementioned E zoning district's provision to have an essential service as the primary user, in this instance, staff considers the subject property to be an essential service site since the other tower would already have a governmental entity as its primary user. CU-200S-AR-140S5 September 24. 2009 Page 4 o(S . Essential services may be allowed to any height as required for the particular use at its specific location. According to the applicant, the height of the towers proposed would be approximately 450 feet, which measurement includes the tower and the pole-mounted antennae at the top. (It should be noted that Resolution No. 93-219 did not restrict the height of the replacement tower on the site.) However, because the towers are in excess of 150 feet, the project had to be reviewed by the Collier Mosquito Control Oistrict, who determined that the towers would be required to maintain either solid red beacon or dual mode lights, pursuant to Federal A viation Administration (F AA) standards as req uired by LDC5.05.09.G.13. I' . As an essential service, the towers would also be exempt from the collapse zone requirements for towers over 185 feet (which is 2.5 times the tower's height from any adjoining residential zoning districts). Therefore, with the conditions of approval recommended by staff and the Board of Zoning Appeals' (BZA) approval of companion item V A-PL- 2009-037, the facility would be consistent with the applicable provisions of the LOC. 2. Ingress and egress to the property and proposed structures thereon, with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe. Transportation Planning staff has reviewed the application and has determined that no transportation issues are associated with the project. As previously noted, the facility is unmanned, and the site is only occasionally visited by a service crew member in order to perform routine maintenance. The facility is accessible to their vehicle(s) via Crews Road, and two on-site parking spaces have been provided for them, as required pursuant to LOC subsection 5.05.09.G.ll. 3. The effect the Conditional Use would have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects. o As previously noted, the two communications towers and accessory structures are surrounded by vacant and wooded E-zoned properties. As the subject property is similarly vegetated, existing flora on the site would serve as a buffer between the facility and adjacent properties, as pennitted by LOC subsection 5.05.09.G.21. Although no offending noise or glare is generated by the facility, if the surrounding properties were to develop, these buffers, CU-2008-AR-/4085 September 24, 2009 Page 5 of8 combined with the site's enhanced setback yards, would effectively mitigate potential impacts. 4. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district. As noted in the application, the site has been the location of a communications tower and mechanical shelters for nearly 30 years, for which Resolution No. 93-219 authorized replacement; and the two existing towers have been in operation on the site since 1999. During this time, there have been no recorded complaints from adjacent property owners, Moreover the facility is separated from the closest single-family home by a distance of over 300 feet, and further buffered by 75 feet of vegetation, Due to this plant material, the facility's somewhat isolated location on the site, and the limited nature of the proposal (to legitimize an existing tower and add a mere 224 square-foot equipment shelter) any impacts on the surrounding neighbors would be minimized and compatibility insured. ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION: Pursuant to LDC Section 8.06,03 0, I Powers and Duties, the EAC did not review this petition because the site is less than ten acres and is not in a Special Treatment (ST) area or an Area of Critical State Concern (ACSC). NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM): (Provided by Cheri Rollins, Administrative Assistant) The applicant duly noticed and held the required NIM at the Fairfield Inn by Marriott on April 15, 2008 at 5:30 p,m. No one from the community attended, and the meeting was officially ended at 5:45 p.m. One letter of objection (to the construction of a tower, which the application does not propose) has been received from the community, which has been attached as Appendix 2. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney's Office has reviewed this staff report, revised on July 30, 2009. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the CCPC forward Petition CU-2008-AR-14085 to the BZA with a recommendation of approval, subject to the following conditions: I. The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the Conceptual Site Plan, identified as "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28,2007, as revised through April 9, 2009. The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for Conditional Use approval only. The final design must be compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations. 2, The southernmost tower shall be owned by or leased to a governmental entity as the primary user of the tower and shall be for this entity's government-related purposes. CU-2008-AR-/4085 September 24, 2009 Page 6 0(8 3. Maximum height of the two towers on the site shall be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances, 4. Development on the site shall be restricted to 3,359 square feet of impervious area, 5, Maximum height of the towers on the site shall be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances. 6, All guy line anchors on the site shall be fenced. ATTACHMENTS: Appendix 1: Resolution No. 93-219 Appendix 2: Letter of Objection CU-2008-AR-N085 September 24. 2009 Page 70[8 PREPARED BY: JOHN-DA VID MOSS, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER DATE DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW REVIEWED BY: RAYMOND V, BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER DATE DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW SUSAN M, ISTENES, AICP, DIRECTOR DATE DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW APPROVED BY: JOSEPH K. SCHMITT, ADMINISTRATOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DATE Collier County Planning Commission: MARK p, STRAIN, CHAIRMAN DATE Tentatively scheduled for the December 1,2009 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting. CU-2008-AR-/4085 September 24, 2009 Page 8 0[8 AGENDA ITEM lD-A Co~:r ~u.nty - ~ SUPPLEMENTAL STAFF REPORT TO: FROM: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION HEARING: JANUARY 7, 2010 SUBJECT: PEmION VA-PL2009-037, FLO TV INCORPORATED (COMPANION ITEM ClJ-2008-~-14085) PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: FLO TV, Inc. 5775 Morehouse Drive San Diego, CA 92121 Agent: James J. Porter, Esq./Kimberly J. Madison, Esq. Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A 401 East Jackson Street, Ste. 2700 Tampa, FL 33602 REOlJESTED AcrION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider the following three after-the- fact Variances of Land Development Code (LDC) subsection 4.02.01, Table 2.1, Table of Minimum Yard Requirements fOr Base Zoning Districts, for the guy lines and anchors of communications towers in excess of 75 feet in the Estates (E) Zoning District: I. A Variance of55,7 feet from the 75-foot front yard setback requirement to permit a 19.3- foot setback; 2. A Variance of22.3 feet from the 30-foot eastern side yard setback requirement to pennit a 7.7-foot setback; and 3. A Variance of 22.6 feet from the 30-foot western side yard setback requirement to pennit a 7.4-foot setback. PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: This item's companion ConditionallJse petition was heard by the CCPC at their October 15, 2009 public hearing. However, due to issues raised by CCPC members necessitating further research, the applicant requested a continuance of the hearing, which was ultimately rescheduled VA-PL2009-037 12117/09 for January 7, 2010. As such, the previously submittedVariance staff report is being attached to this supplement. RECOMMENDATION: Zoning and Land Development Review staff recommends that the CCPC forward Petition V A- PL2009-037 to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval, as noted in the attached Staff Report. PREPARED BY: ~ JO~ MOSS, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW REVIEWED BY: ~~.J fu /?oj - RA YM D V. BE OWS, ZONING MANAGER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW ~lh7h-~~ """'SUSAN M. ISTENES, AICP, DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW APPROVED BY: iJ.-)~) 0 i I1A ' I"(U/" , J()ATE 101, /~I /tJl ' D~T /:I::upr DATE Tentatively scheduled for the February 23, 2009 Board of County Commissioners Meeting COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION: MARK P. STRAIN, CHAIRMAN 2 VA-PL2009-037 12/17/09 DATE ec;rn~r County _..i.!-""...,."'.....~'...,.,,..,'" STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION HEARING DATE: OCTOBER 15,2009 SUBJECT: PETITION VA-PL-2009-037, FLO TV INCORPORATED (COMPANION TO CU PRETITION CU-2008-AR-I4085) PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: FLO TV, Inc. 5775 Morehouse Drive San Diego, CA 92121 Agent: James J, Porter, Esq.lKimberly], Madison, Esq, Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A 401 East Jackson Street, Ste. 2700 Tampa, FL 33602 REQUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider the following three after-the- fact Variances of Land Development Code (LDC) subsection 4.02,01, Table 2.1, Table of Minimum Yard Requirements for Base Zoning Districts, for the guy lines and anchors of communications towers in excess of 75 feet in the Estates (E) Zoning District: l. A Variance of 55,7 feet from the 75-foot front yard setback requirement permit a 19.3- foot setback; 2. A Variance of22.3 feet from the 30-foot eastern side yard setback requirement to permit 7.7-foot setback; and 3. A Variance of22.6 feet from the 30-foot western side yard setback requirement to permit a 7.4- foot setback GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The 4.77-acre subject property is located at 5860 Crews Road, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, in Collier County, Florida (see location map on the following page). l'A-2009-PL-09-037 FLa TI September 24.2009 Page 1 f?f6 PURPOSEIDESCRlPTlON OF PROJECT: As noted in the companion application, the applicant is seeking to legitimize the continued existence of two guyed communications towers on the subject property, According to LDC 5.05.09,0,17, however, ground-mounted guyed towers in excess of 75 feet in height are required to provide the minimum yard requirements of the base zoning district between each guy anchor and all property lines, Since the subject towers exceed 75 feet in height and the subject property is in the E Zoning District, the required front and side yard setbacks for the guy anchors are 75 feet and 30 feet, respectively. (All of the towers' rear guy anchors are a sufficient distance from the rear property boundary and, therefore, unaffected by its required 75-foot setback). As shown on the Conceptual Site Plan on the preceding page, entitled, "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28,2007, as revised through April 9, 2009, the two communications towers and accessory equipment shelters are shown in a chain-link fence enclosure somewhat centrally located on the site, The communications towers are spaced 50 feet apart and supported by guy lines and anchors that are depicted adjacent to the southern, eastern and western boundaries of the site, As shown on the Conceptual Site Plan, two of these anchors are located within the 75-footfront setback yard, two are within the western side setback yard, and three are within the eastern side setback yard, Because these guy lines and anchors were specifically installed in these locations to maximize their strength and the structural soundness of the towers, according to the applicant, their subsequent relocation could jeopardize the towers' integrity. Therefore, the following three after-the-fact Variances are being requested: . 55.7 feet from the 75-foot front yard setback requirement, to permit a 19.3-foot setback; . 22.3 feet from the 30-foot eastern side yard setback requirement, to permit a 7,7-foot setback; and . 22.6 feet from the 30-foot western side yard setback requirement, to permit a 7A-foot setback Although there are seven guy line anchor encroachments affecting three different setback yards, staff normally requests Variances for only the ones that encroach the most into each of the setback yards, (For example, if a setback of 7,7 feet is ultimately approved in the eastern setback yard then, as depicted in the Master Plan, the offending 8A-foot and 13.7-foot guy anchors in this yard would automatically be rendered lawful since they encroach even less than 7.7 feeL) While it is true that this would ultimately grant the applicant the right to relocate the other guy lines closer to the property boundary, the applicant's justification for the after-the-fact Variances in the first place was because the anchors could not be moved without jeopardizing the integrity of the towers. Nevertheless, staff is amenable to stipulating the precise setback of each guy line anchor, as noted in the conditions of approval. SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: East: South: West: Undeveloped land, zoned Falling Waters PUD Undeveloped land, zoned Falling Waters PUD Crews Road, then vacant land, zoned E Undeveloped land, zoned Falling Waters PUD I'A.2009.PL.09.031, FW TI' SepTember 24. 2009 Page 2 of6 GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY: The subject property is designated Urban-Mixed Use District, Urban Residential Subdistrict on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP, Relevant to this petition, the designation permits non-residential uses, including utility and communication facilities. The GMP does not address individual Variance requests but focuses on the larger issue of the actual use, As previously noted, the subject Variances are sought to allow a reduction of the 75- foot front yard setback requirement and 30-foot side yard setback requirement for the guy anchors of two existing communications towers, Future Land Use Element (FLUE) Policy 5.4 requires new land uses to be compatible with and complementary to the surrounding land uses as set forth in the LDC It is the responsibility of the Zoning and Land Development Review staff as part of their review of the petition in its entirety to perform this compatibility analysis. Based upon the above analysis, staff concludes that the proposed Conditional Use may be deemed consistent with the Future Land Use Element. ANAL YSIS: Section 9,04,01 of the LDC gives the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) the authority to grant Variances, The CCPC is advisory to the BZA and utilizes the provisions of Subsection 9.04.03 A through H., in bold font below, as general guidelines to assist in making a recommendation of approval or denial. Staff has analyzed this petition relative to these provisions, and offers the following responses: a. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing, which are peculiar to the location, size and characteristics ofthe land, structure or building involved? Yes. As shown in the aerial photograph in the companion Conditional Use, development on the subject property is primarily confined to a centralized location occupying just 21 percent of the site. This area is then surrounded by dense natural vegetation which occupies the remaining 79 percent of the property. The requested Variances from the required front and side yard setbacks are for guy lines and their anchors only, which have a negligible impact compared to other types of development. Furthermore, the site is mostly surrounded by undeveloped land, especially along the boundaries in which the Variances are being requested, b. Are there special conditions and circumstances, which do not result from the action of the applicant such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property, which is the subject of the Variance request? The current property owner, Renda Broadcasting, was the property owner at the time that the new tower was erected and the old one was left standing. However, the conditions on the site are pre-existing for the applicant, who leases space on the towers from the owner. In addition, a single communications tower has been in operation on the subject property for lA-2009-PL-09-037, FLO TJ' September 24.2009 Page 3 uf6 nearly 30 years, and two have been in existence since 1999, Neither of the towers has had any complaints registered with the County. c. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this zoning code work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties for the applicant? Yes. In their application, the applicants contend that adherence to the required setbacks would require the removal and relocation of the guy lines and anchors, which would jeopardize the structural integrity of the towers the support Therefore, the enforcement of the required setbacks would create practical difficulties for the applicant However, according to the LOC, the towers' bases, guy anchors, outdoor equipment and accessory structures need to be fenced. As everything on the site except the guy line anchors is presently fenced, staff has included a condition of approval requiring that they also be enclosed. d. Will the Variances, if granted, be the minimum Variances tbat will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure and which promote standards of health, safety and welfare? Yes, The Variances requested would be the minimum to make possible the reasonable use of the existing communications towers, Since relocation of these towers' guy lines and anchors could jeopardize public safety, and because existing vegetation on the site and the surrounding areas would adequately screen the guy lines and anchors located in the reduced setback yards, it is staff's opinion that the standards of health safety and welfare would be promoted if the Variances were approved. However, if the Variances were not approved, the petitioner would still have reasonable use ofthe land. e. Will granting the Variances confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes. A Variance by definition confers some dimensional relief from the zoning regulations specific to a site. However, as noted in the Conditional Use application, the communications tower would be located on an essential service site utilized by the FBI. Therefore, the general public, and not only the applicant, would benefit f. Will granting the Variances be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this Land Development Code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes. The proposed Variances would merely legitimize the existence of two communications towers that have been operating on the site without complaint for at least a decade. If the requested Variances are granted, the reduced front and side setback yards would not be detrimental to the neighborhood or the public's welfare due to the fact that the site itself and the surrounding properties are heavily wooded. Furthermore, the communications towers would meet all of the other requirements of LOC 5,05.09.G, Development Standards for Communications Towers, Finally, if approved, the project would further LOC 5,05,09, Communications Towers, subsection A which, among other J 'A-2009-PL-09-037, no!J' Septemher 24, 2009 Pal{e4 of6 objectives, encourages "the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites." g. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives of the regulation such as natural preserves, lakes, golf courses, etc.? Yes, as previously noted, only 21 percent of the site is developed, so the preponderance of the 4,77-acre site would remain as natural open space, Furthermore, the site is generally surrounded by undeveloped land, particularly along the boundaries affected by the requested Variances, Therefore, the visual aspect of the guy lines and anchors would be screened by vegetation and their negligible impact well mitigated. h. Will granting the Variances be consistent with the Growth Management Plan (GMP)? Approval of this Variance petition would not affect or change the requirements of the Growth Management Plan. As previously noted, communications towers are an authorized use in the Urban-Mixed Use District, Urban Residential Subdistrict of the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP. ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION: The EAC does not normally hear Variance petitions and did not hear this one. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney's Office has reviewed this staff report, revised on September 28, 2009. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the CCPC forward petition V A-PL-2009-037 to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval, subject to the following condition: 1. The Variances granted shall be strictly limited to the front and side yard encroachments of the guy lines and their support anchors, as depicted in the applicant's submitted survey, dated September 18, 2008, included as Exhibit A 2, All of the guy line anchors on the site shall be enclosed by a fence. 1'A-2009-PL-09-037, fIO 11 September 24. 2()()9 Page 5 of6 PREPARED BY: JOHN-DAVID MOSS, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DATE REVIEWED BY: RAYMOND V, BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DATE SUSAN MURRA Y-ISTENES, AICP, DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW DATE APPROVED BY: JOSEPH K SCHMITT, ADMINISTRATOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION DATE MARK P. STRAIN, CHAIRMAN DATE Tentatively scheduled for the December 1,2009 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting. 1:4-2009-PL-09-037. FLO TJ" September 24. 2009 Page 60f6 DAVE HALLOWELL - P.E. Director, Emerging Carriers Projec/ MI/Ill/gemelll, Bwdllcss DCl'clopnlelll, Engilleering. E\,tinlllt;ng, COllsfruct;ol1 Education Bachelors, Civil, University of Nebraska. 1992 Professional Registration Engineer-in- Training, Nebraska, 1991 Engineer (PE), Florida, 1997 Engineer (PE) Kansas, 1997 Total Years Experience 18 Joined B&V 1992 Professional Associations American Society of Civil Engineers Dave Hallowell is currently serving as Director, Emerging Carriers. He is responsible for the overall direction, business development, strategy and representation of Black & Veatch in the wireless industry. His expertise in engineering and construction covers most major wireless technologies (COMA, TDMA, GSM) and includes expertise in all site types including roof- top, co-locate and raw land sites. Dedicated to telecommunications projects since 1996, he has held responsible positions that require his expertise in engineering and construction for multiple clients in both office and field assignments, He has relevant experience in the development of project cost estimates as well as development of detailed project schedules. Representative Project Experience Bltlck & Vea/ch, O,'erlalld Park, KS Preselll Direc/or, Emergillg Carriers - Provide market leadership for products and services offered by Black & Veatch to support the development of emerging wireless network carriers. Specific responsibilities include; business development, establishing strategic direction, providing industry representation, evaluating and selecting strategic partners, leading sales teams to support new business growth, analyzing industry trends, driving effective project execution and developing solutions to meet the demands of our wireless customers, Qllalcomm-FLO TV - Si/e De,'elopmell/ 2006 - Preselll Project Manager - Responsible for nationwide turnkey deployment of new technology broadcast sites, The majority of the sites are tall tower sites or mountain top sites. All equipment is indoor equipment and either requires deployment of a shelter or a tenant improvement Sprin/-Nex/el - Si/e Devefopmellt 21J(J6 - Preselll Project Mllllager - Responsible for turnkey deployment of 129 wireless sites in Southern California. Sites are located in difficult jurisdictions and require complex zoning submittals as well as stealth construction. Sprill/-Nex/eI ,. Site Developmellt 21111:; - 21J(J6 Projecl Manager - Responsible for the development and deployment of back- up power solutions on 608 existing sites in the Southeast Region. Solutions include design and installation of fuel cells, micro-turbines, dual fuel generators on existing Sprint-Nextel sites, Bfack & Veatcll COlls/ructioll Opemtiolls MI/llger Celllmlallll Wextem Regioll 211114 - 211116 Operatiolls Manager-Telecom COlls/rllction - Responsible for all construction services within regions including construction execution strategies, status reporting for construction activities, cost estimating, procurement, construction Black & Veatch 9/5/2008 DA VE HALLOWELL - P.E. staffing and overhead cost control. Managed 50 construction managers nationwide, Alamo."a pcs - Site Del'elopment 20()4 - 2()OJ Project Manager - Responsible for the development and deployment of new capacity and coverage site in Alamosa's PCS network. Scope of work includes installation activities for sites located in the Midwest and Southeast Project team includes engineers, construction managers, procurement, construction craft employees and construction subcontractors, "'/Jrint PCS Salllh Centml Region - Site Del'elopmelll 2()(13-200J Project Construction Manager - Assisted in deployment of 230 sites across the Sprint South Central Region, These sites were located in Texas, Louisiana, Arkansas, and Oklahoma. "'/Jrint PCS Northea,\(, Santhea"t a",1 North Celllral Region" -- Project Mercllry 2()(J3-20()J Project Constrllction Manager - Managed the site acquisition, engineering and construction services on forward and reverse link upgrades to over 300 sites. These upgrades were completed on existing Sprint sites and included installation of Remec TMA's, Nortel H-MFRM radios, and Powerwave MCPA's, The sites were located in the Northeast, Southeast and North Central Regions of the country. Responsibilities included managing site acquisition, engineering, direct hire craft employees, subcontractors, and the construction management staff located in the field, Sprilll Site,,' USA - Integrated ConItrllction Serl'ice." Program 2(J(J2 Project Constrllction Manager - Managed the construction for over 160 wireless sites. These sites were all collocations on existing Sprint Sites USA towers located in the Great Lakes, Midwest and Southern Regions of the country, Responsibilities included managing direct hire craft employees, subcontractors, and the construction management staff located in the field, Genllit)' Pol' Hlli/dolll, We.,tern United State,,' 2001-2002 Project Constrllction Manager - Managed the construction for 12 fiber Point of Presence (PoP) sites located throughout the western half of the United States, Responsibilities included coordinating and directing subcontractors, obtaining building permits, interfacing with design team, client liaison, staffing field inspectors, monitoring progress, review of work, processing invoices and preparing project closeout documentation. Sirill," Satellite Radio, United SllIte.' 20t/1-2t/02 Assistant Project Manager - Responsible for the management of site acquisition, engineering and construction activities for 97 terrestrial broadcast sites, These sites were located across the nation and were mainly located on Black & Veatch 2 9/5/2008 DA VE HALLOWELL - P.E. the tallest structures in dense urban areas. Special management skills were required to coordinate the multitude of personnel and various entities involved in the development of the technologically advanced network. Miaoceff Mallagemellt, Greellville, Soutll Carofilla /998-2()()() Program Services Mallager - Responsible for the execution of all field services for the development of 64 build-to-suit tower structure facilities, This included site acquisition, zoning, engineering, permitting, procurement, construction, and equipment installation, The average height of the constructed towers exceeded 250', Various Project.\', TelecmnmuniclIl;ol1.\' Department /999-2()()() COllstructioll Logistics Mallager - Responsibilities included construction pricing support, subcontractor prequalification, construction contract negotiations, field staffing support for a number of telecommunications and power delivery projects across the country. Omllipoilll Comllumicatioll>', Amarillo Texa,\ alll/ Miami Horida /997-/998 Project Field Ellgilleer - Responsible for managing surveying and geotechnical subcontractors, reviewing zoning requirements, attending public hearings and coordinating the engineering effort of over 150 sites in Amarillo and Miami. Sprilll PCS, Ka/l.W1s City, Mi,I',\'fl/ui /996-/997 COllstructioll Mallager - Managed the construction for 187 Sprint pes telecommunication sites. His responsibilities included managing construction subcontractors and inspecting construction for compliance to the specifications, City olColtoll, COltoll, California (Power De/iI'ery) /995-/996 Field Ellgilleer - Responsible for on-site inspection 69kV substation and transmission line, Duties also included inspection of 5 miles of 15kV underground distribution line. The substation, transmission line and underground distribution line were all constructed in environmentally sensitive areas which required special consideration, Ullited Illuminating, New Haven, COllnecticut (Power Delivef'.r) /992-/995 Design Ellgilleer-Field Ellgilleer - Responsible for the civil/structural design of a number of varying substations, Designs included structural design of multilevel control houses and masonry buildings, Also designed specialty transmission line structures and associated foundations. Responsible for on- site inspections to ensure construction was being completed in accordance with the specifications and drawings, Black & Veatch 3 9/5/2008 DAVE K. KUHN - P.E. Project Engineer Telecommunication Site Construction, Civil- Structural llngineering Project Management Education Bachelor of Science Civil Engineering, University of Missouri - Rolla, 1976 Professional Registration Registered PE in 19BO Missouri Kansas Illinois Indiana Massachusetts New Hampshire Pennsylvania Arizona Virginia Maryland Utah Kentucky South Dakota Total Years Experience 29 Joined B&V 2003 Professional Associations MSPE, NSPE, ASCE Dave Kuhn has been involved with the design and construction of telecommunications facilities continuously since 1976, He has participated in wireless site design and construction projects since it's inception in 1982. His background includes knowledge of building codes and industry standards as applicable to telecommunications facilities. He is assigned as a Senior Wireless Implementation Engineer in the Black & Veatch Telecommunications Division. He is experienced in the design of communication towers, including knowledge of steel & concrete design, site layout and foundation design. He is also experienced in the design and analysis of structural systems associated with co-locate & raw land sites, Representative Project Experience Bechtel/Cingular UMTS Project, St. Loui,', Missouri July 2005-Present Projectllngineer - Responsible for all engineering services for approximately 65 sites associated with the expansion of existing wireless communications system and the integration of AT&T wireless sites into the Cingular wireless system. llricsson/RCC Holdings, Western Kansas June 2005-Present Project Engineer - Responsible for all engineering services for 8 sites associated with the expansion of existing wireless communications system, WFI/Cingular UMTS Project, Albany, New York June 2005-Present Project Engineer - Responsible for all engineering services for approximately 15 sites associated with the expansion of existing wireless communications system. Alamosa PCS, Kan..as City, Missouri April 2004-Present Project Engineer - Responsible for all engineering services for approximately 125 sites associated with the expansion of existing wireless communications system, Cingular/Bechtel, St. Loui.., Missouri January 2004-Present Project Engineer - Responsible for all engineering services for approximately 35 sites associated with the expansion of existing Cingular wireless communications system, Sprint PCS Northeast Region, Outsourced Channel Project October 2003-March 2004 Senior Wireless Implementation Engineer - Responsible for the Project Administration of all engineering design and installation services for approximately 600 sites by the Sprint General Contractor that was awarded the Northeast Region, Included the review and approval of Lease Exhibits, Surveys, Environmental Assessments, DS-l Orders, and Site Drawings for both Zoning and Construction, BTS orders, E911 Documentation and Tower orders, Black & Veatch 3/29/2007 DA VE K. KUHN - P.E. Bechtel Telecommunications & Industrial November 2002-September2003 Lead Market Engineer - Responsible for the coordination of all engineering services for approximately 350 sites for an existing wireless communications system. This work was to upgrade the existing Cingular Network from TDMA technology to GSM using Siemens Equipment, the TDMA network had to remain functional along with adding the capability of GSM technology. Included tower analyses, equipment layouts, existing site configuration drawings, addition of E9l1 technology to the sites, power upgrades, antenna and coax installations. Cingular Wireless / Southwestern Bell Wirele~'s / Southwestern Bell Mobile Systems February /995-0ctober 2002 Newark Construction Manager - Responsible for the construction, design, permitting, zoning, integration, materials (towers, antennas, coax, power plants and radio equipment) and service (surveys, geotechnical reports, site construction and antenna and line installation) procurement, and equipment installation for 200 wireless communications sites, Involved in all aspects of a wireless site construction starting with the initial search area request and ending with site turn on for call processing, Self Employed February /993-January /994 Engineer - Designed and detailed guyed and self-supporting telecommunication towers, analyzed existing telecommunication structures and supplied technical expertise on an as needed basis to Andrew Corporation's Tower Engineering Department. Grasis Corporation I Andrew Corporation June /976-January /993 Project Engineering Manager - Coordinated the development of computer design programs that led to reduced engineering turnaround on tower projects, Trained and directed engineers in the design and construction of microwave and cellular communications towers resulting in higher confidence levels of the engineers and their clients in the products designed by them. Responsible for the generation of material prices for tower construction projects and for modification of existing structures to comply with new EIA Standards, Project Engineer-Special Projects - Designed new self-supporting microwave communications tower product line resulting in an improvement in company market share. Responsible for improvements to existing product lines to meet changing needs for the end customers. Project Engineer - Supervised, designed and controlled client's projects, varying in size from one to 20 sites, directing them to a successful on time completion, Involved in the design and construction of communication towers and their foundations resulting in a successful completed installation. Black & Veatch 2 3/29/2007 Brian Keith Grant Construction Manager Telecommunication Site Construction Management Keith Grant has been involved with the broadcasting industry for over 30 years, from operations of television facilities to chief engineer overseeing transmission and tower sites, Current assignment is on the FLO TV project, performing duties to insure timely, cost effective, and safe delivery of sites as Construction Manager II. In his duties, Keith oversees crews of civil and tower sub-contractors, arranges for delivery of goods, confirms safety protocol is followed, and insures quality, Relative Project Experience WRXY Television 2001 - 2006 Chief Engineer - Responsible for all engineering and operations on a daily basis for 24 / 7 broadcast facility. WTVK TV 1996 - 2001 Assistant Chief Engineer - Maintained broadcast television station equipment, oversaw daily operations of network operations center. Designed and implemented new operations center WBBH - Waterman Broadcasting 1990-1996 Transmitter I Tower supervisor - Responsible for daily operations and maintenance of high power UHF transmitter and 1500 foot broadcast toweL Education NCCER - 2008 Safety course for construction Management Harris TTU -110 Tram'mitter Clas.' -1994 Advanced course in transmission and upkeep of high powered transmitters with Klystron tubes and VCO exciters Huntsville Technical School-1980 2 year course in electronics pertaining to broadcasting Black & Veatch ~ ",' ... o o o o o .., .---- --.., '''--" o , c r \ .. L..-..__ . 1 1....."lMil. "" Global Broadcast Services, LLC 2614 N Tamiami Trl #507, Naples, FI34103 Office: 239-963-5434 Email: d.Ellioll@gbs-fl.comwe:GBS-FL.COM Tower Inspection Report Prepared For: Renda Broadcasting Location: Naples Florida Contact: Jerry Heckerman, Chief Engineer Date: December 18, 09 GBS was contracted to do a Tower Inspection plus plumb and tension on an existing Allied guy tower located in South Naples off of County Barn Road. Listed below are the results of the plumb and tension plus the visual inspection of the structure. Visual Inspection of the structure Item Good Fair Fail Notes I. Anchors (6) X 2, Anchor Heads (6) X 3. Turn Buckles (15) X No figure 8s 4. Vera Grips (6) X 5. Tower Sections X Tower Members and legs are in good shape Some light surface rust Needs wire brushing and cold galv (20%) 6. Tower Bolts X All bolts are in good shape, light surface rust on 30% or more 7. Tower Paint X Tower Paint is flaking And very faded 8, Tower lighting NA Power 9. Antennas and lines X Some of the coax needs to be secured better 10, Tower Grounding X II. Guy Wire Grounding X Global Broadcast Services, LLC 2614 N Tamiami Trl #507, Naples, FI34103 Office: 239-963i5434 Email: 1.EIliO\l@2bs.llrcomwe:GB1S-FL.COM Estimated Old Tension Vert Vert New Tension Vert Vert Correct A-B CB A-B CoB Tensions Avg Avg Avg Avg And sizes Lel!2" Lel!2" Lel!2" lel!2" 1,3/8" 1.540 860 2toB 1,5 toC 1,550 II2"toB y, toB 2, 7/16" 2,080 1,560 LStoC 1 toC 2,100 1.4"toB 1,4"'08 3, 9/16" 3.500 2.150 2,75 to C 2 toC 3,500 1/3"toB 1/.I"t08 4, V2" 2,690 1,670 3,75 to A 3 toC 2,700 IA"toB 1/3"IOB 5, 5/8" 4,420 2,860 3,5 toC 3,25 to C 4,450 'A" to B 1,4"'08 6, 13/16" 6.830 3,650 4 toC 4,5 toA 6,800 V2"toB W'toS 7,13/16" 6.830 2,975 3,75 to C 2.7510 A 6,800 V2"toB Y2" to A Corrected Plumb Transits were set up 90% apart and shot of leg A. Transit cross lines were set up on Center of leg to compensate for any leg size variance, .... I Tns i h " G;] Notes: I. Existing guy wire on the first level A anchors had been spliced previously using two pretorms that were hand shake tower with no thimble, The tension caused the preforms to fold and break over time, 2, When proper tension was applied to the splice performs broke, GBS repaired the splice using cable clamps. Global Broadcast Services, LLC 2614 N Tamiami Trl #507, Naples, Fl34103 Office: 239-963-5434 Email: d.Elliott@ebs-nxomwe:GBS-FL.COM This particular ( AI) guy wire should be replaced, the splice repair is only a temp measure and GBS does not guarantee the splice. Tower has light surface rust that needs to be wIre brushed and cold galvanizing compound applied to those areas. After the plumb and tension was done to the tower on the Dec 17,09 the tower now passes inspection. Regards, Darryl Elliott,EE GBS i5 " 0 0 ;; ~ !'i III Iii ! ~ ~ "j " \~ III " 1 N .J.J ;.. i~ ~p ,,; q I" ~ ! ,,~;;;- oc( ! ~~e I'I! . , .. z -~ " . .I. n :1' , . ! I i . . ! I I ! ' , ! . . , ! .. . . . . .. .. . 1 Ii !I 'I I, " CIl !Mla~ ji o , ;: is i o . I' 'I !!:@ ~ I .1.1~7 <, [' "'l"]~' <<;;i.>< 0. 0 ...~ 51!E~~c5' " '" o~le , '.. ~ ~: , , J r _? Structural fI.... ~~ml~t~rents Structural Components, LLC 1617 Pearl Street, Unit A Boulder, CO B0302 Voice: B66-3B6-7622 Fax: 303-962-3577 November 16, 2009 Jerry Heckerman Renda Broadcasting of SW Florida 10915 K-Nine Drive Bonita Springs, FL 34135 Re: Structural Review - Fall Radius Assessment Structures: (1) 454' ERI Guyed Tower, (1) 454' Allied Guyed Tower Site Address: 5B60 Crews Road, Naples, FL 33942 Site Name (#): Renda Broadcasting (Naples) SC Number: 090339 Dear Mr. Heckerman: I am writing this letter In reference to your request for Structural Components, LLC to provide our opinion of the expected mode of collapse for the (2) guyed lattice steel communications tower located in Naples, Collier County, Florida. The two towers stand approximately 50 ft. apart from one another with a maximum outer guy radii of 210 ft. The towers are designed in strict accordance with the Electronics Industry Association Standard EIAfTIA- 222-F, 1996 Code as well as local codes. Due to the safety factors incorporated into the design standard, we would not expect the tower to fail the moment that the designed wind speed has been exceeded. Although it is extremely rare for a guyed tower to collapse, most failures occur during catastrophic natural disasters such as hurricanes or tornadoes in which total devastation to the surrounding area would also occur. Because of the various levels of guy cables designed to support the towers, and having inner and outer guy anchors at both tower sites, it is virtually impossible for the tower to fall in a straight line like a tree might. The expected mode of collapse would be to fall in upon itself in an accordion-type fashion with the debris contained within the anchor radius of the guy cables. Since there are many factors that will affect the failure of a communication tower, we would like to point out that the mode of tower failure mentioned above is just an estimate. We trust that this information confirms to you that towers are designed to survive rather than collapse. Please feel free to contact us if you should have any questions or require further information. Best Regards, Structural Components LLC ~~ //"-'y. ,t - 2-- / .' . .... / ,/ . Mlcl1ael T, DeBoer, PE Florida License # 49140 Expiration 03/26/2011 Brad Cook, P,Eng, VP Engineering " .;- .,j.'/-.,i/'" J ~c. "c:,:::::,;".....,..:,....' ,.....:..". .." '.' .;. .,,"" -:., ""'-'" " ',. , c """"-......- o,llier MIiI.s.qultt) Q>"troJ District 6aONortll ROflC/" N/Ip/w, FLJ4J.~ AdriJin~ (nt) 4$8-1,1/(1(1 I It"} 4S64(fOS (fax) Hangar. (239) 436-10081 (Z39) 436-1,001 (fax) fNWW.mIIIl!r_l1U1ttumJ November 13, 2009 Dear Mr. Beckerman, The Collier Mo$qUito Control Disirict endorses your request that an es:emption to the l~ code requirem~ be~ with respect to the ~perty at 5860 Crews Road, 'NlIjl~ cFL~fMtIl&i:~~cl~~~$'; Sincerely, I(elty Huff DtreetorQ'f~ ~ . ')1 ~xr!DfComnt~ ~D. "'-/Il4Otp!r _F.~~ __ff.ae.iIII'.~ -.i:1ilfHbr UIrdoN.H_ -..rJN~ _VtUt,.,...,"".o. ~~.(Z>>J~QPJ ~tnrr ,Q4J1: ......' Vf ~ "c, , MArt'" 1ilImi'~""Jil, <MW mtIJ tII1'11i11J 5.05.00 - SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS FOR SPECIFIC USES Page 1 of 1 r^"" _~^^""~.~,~_,__w,,^,,,~,~,~_,,_'_~'~"'~"_"_'~_~"'_.".H.____.__.__........._.__~____~.____._._.__."'_.,__--,...~ G. " _.,~.,.,_,.,__,~.M_,._"'".,.._~,_n"..'.__~,_,~._..~__"__MW..__.,.~._W.'^._,W__,_"~".,.........,._...,.~'_'_'_"'__",__~M.M.,,~__~.___.,_,_M.M___..."..._"~._.,~~w~j Development standards for communication towers, i ! 1 , Except to the extenfiii'Bi iimiiieurriidio towers; and ground-mouniediintenniis wiih iihslghi not to exceed twenty (20) feet, are exempted by subsection 5,05.09 herein, no new tower of any height shall be permitted in the RSF-1 through RSF-6. RMF-6, VR, MH, TTRVC, and E zoning districts, However, notwithstanding other provisions of this section, including the separation requirements of subsection5,05.09(F)(7) below, towers may be allowed to any height as a conditional use in the E zoning district only on sites approved for a specified essential service listed in subsection 5.05,09((F)(3) below. There shall be no exception to this subsection except for conditional use applications by a government for a governmental use. http://library.municode.comlHTML/13992I1eveI2/CHAP5_5.05.00.html 1/5/2010 5.05.00 - SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS FOR SPECIFIC USES , I 1"'-""---'-"- I Page I ofl "..-3,~'-.E8senifaTiiervices--::sPecjfiEI(rcondltlonal uses Except in the RSF-l through RSF-6, and RMF-6 zoning districts, towers may be allowed to any height as a conditional use on sites approved for a conditional use essential service for any of the following conditional uses; safety service facilities including, but not necessarily limited to, lire stations, sheriff's substation or facility, emergency medical services facility, and all other similar uses where a communications tower could be considered an accessory or logically associated use with the safety service conditional use on the site, In addition, communications to_s can be approved as a conditional use for a stand-alone essential service facility, provided the tower is to be owned by, or to be leased to, a governmental entity, and the primary uses of the tower are for governmental purposes, http://library.municode.comlHTMLlI3992/leveI2/CHAP5_5.05.00.html 1/512010 5.05.00 - SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS FOR SPECIFIC USES Page 1 of 1 ,..._..._.._,,-,,""-'-_......., , ~~_ .. "..~~"m"__~ , "7:" '-'Wlifittie exception of rooftop towers and tO'wers on essiii1t1al serviceS snes, each new-'---'''''''''' communication tower shall meet the following separation requirements: a, Each new toweritiiiiexceeds185feefiritielgiii siiiiii be i6i:aiednoi iessiiiantwo ." and one.half (2,5) times the height of the tower from all RSF.lthrough RSF-6, and RMF-6 zoning districts, including PUDs where the adjacent use(s) is/are, or comparable to, the RSF.l through RSF-6 and RMF.6 zoning districts. If a part of a PUD is not developed, and n is inconclusive whether the part of a PUD area within such minimum separation distance from the proposed tower site may be developed with a density of six (6) units per acre or less, it shall be presumed that the PUD area nearest to the proposed site will be developed at the lowest density possible under the respective PUD, i i i i L http://library.municode.comlHTML/I3992IleveI2/CHAP5_5.05.00.html 1/5/2010 5.05.00 - SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS FOR SPECIFIC USES Page 1 of 1 r" _""'<~M___~~__ ,- .___M____~~__~.._MH___~___._..,_~,..,__,__~___________.-.---------.--.-.---'...-n----.-..~~----~-----~-.-~----l [- I I , i , , , , I I I 9, -" Placemenfof moreThanone (1) tower'oii~aJand~s1ilils preferred and encouraged,anifmay~~~- ~--1 be permitted, provided, however, that all setbacks, design, and landscape requirements are met as to each tower. structures may be located as close to each other as technically feasible, provided tower failure characteristics of the towers on the site will not likely result in muttiple tower failures in the event that one (1) tower fails, or will not otherwise present an unacceptable risk to any other tower on the site. It shall be the policy of the County to make suitable County-owned land available for towers and ancillary facilities at reasonable rents. http://library.municode.comlHTML/13992/leveI2/CHAP5 5.05.00.html 1/512010 5.05.00 - SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS FOR SPECIFIC USES Page I ofl I ~~". I I ....~"13. Tower lighting. Towers and 'antennas witli"a height greater than 150 leet shall be required to have red beacon or dual mode lights, unless exempted, in writing, by the Collier County Mosquito Control District. Such lights shall meet the then existing Federal Aviation Administration ('FAA") technical standards, No other towers or antennas shall be artificially lighted, except as required by the FAA, the Federal Communications Commission, or other applicable laws, ordinances, or regulations, II the FAA rules require lighting, then the applicant shall comply with such rules. New towers exceeding 199 feet. Each new tower that will have a height in excess 01 one hundred and ninety-nine (199) leet above ground, exclusive 01 antennas, and such tower shall be lighted no more than is otherwise required by state and/or lederallaw, rule, or regulation. Unless otherwise then required by law, rule or regulation, only white strobe lights shall be used at night, unless otherwise required by the FAA, in which case red strobe-type lights shall be used, Such lights shall not exceed the minimum number, minimum intensity, and minimum light flashes per interval of time (requiring the longest allowable duration between light flaShes) required by state or federal law, rule, or regulation, Solid red (or pulsating red) warning lights shall not be used at night. http://1ibrary.municode.comlHTML/13992/1eve12/CHAP5_5.05.00.html 1/5/2010