CCLAAC Agenda 02/08/2010CONSERVATION COLLIER
LAND ACQUISITION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
February 8, 2010 9:00 A.M.
Commission Boardroom
W. Harmon Turner Building (Building "F"), Third Floor
AGENDA
I. Roll Call — Welcome back to Committee Members Bob Dorta and Mike Delate; Goodbye
and Thank you to Mimi Wolok
II. Committee Elections — Chair and Vice Chair
III. Approval of agenda
IV. Approval of January 11, 2010 Minutes
V. Committee Member Applications
VI. Old Business:
A. Cosentino property appraisal — Mr. Paul Cosentino
B. Real Property Management Update
1. Contract — Devisse Trust (Rivers Road)
C. Budget Recommendations
D. Gordon River Greenway
E. Update — City Gate TDR Donation
VII. New Business
A. Review of properties currently accepted within acquisition cycle 8
B. New Property Applications
C. Coordinator Communications.
VIII. Subcommittee Meeting Reports
A. Outreach — Tony Pires, Chair
B. Lands Evaluation and Management— Mike Delate, Vice Chair
C. Ord. Policy and Procedures — Mimi Wolok, Chair
IX. Chair Committee Member Comments
X. Public General Comments
XI. Staff Comments
XII. Adjourn
Committee Members: Please notify Alexandra Sulecki at 252 -2961 no later than 5:00 p.m. on
February 5,20 10 if you cannot attend this meeting.
2
cu
f
/
E
E
/
o\
\j
\ƒLL
ko
aj
&
_m
a
)
§
k
W
E
#
�
_
{
(D
0
\
§
k
w
-
j
\
/
E
7
}
ƒ
_3
}
t
CD
k
3
7\
�
\
CL
°
E
{k
—ca �
\ \
\
\
\
_
�}
)\\
\
2E
-
2
\§
-
/
\
k}
(
-
/7
0
LL
x <E
7
\/
cm
4
fG
k
0
S{
LU
2
r-
m[
�/
\§
-\
�a
)
\
4
\
^
.
:
\
(
: w
\\
\0
j
\
a
®
®
-
-
L
k}
-
-�
2
-
,
\ \
.
\
§
*
\
12
k
}
=
7{g
/f7
±
)
§_2
-
a
c
)E
-Si
c'
c }
'
'
�k
§k
-
j
f§@�
LUm
�\
$a
\m
\]
-\
\]
cl
.
§2
)276
E°
&$co
%)
\)
_
\
\
§\
�,$/
{{rm
®
`
y
)
\�
)2��
°
k
o
SB
{k
CD
)
ƒ
2\
��.
E
(
CL
k3
\Q
p
O
I
j
k
0
$
®'
3°
/
n
i
z
MEMORANDUM
DATE: January 22, 2010
TO: Alex Sulecki, Facilities Managerne
FROM: Sue Filson, Executive Manager
r
Board of County Commissions $..
RE: Land Acquisition Advisory Committee
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit an
application for consideration. I have attached the applications received for your review as follows:
Clarence S. Tears, Jr.
320 Lambton Lane
Naples, FL 34104
Robert A. Schultheis,
6 1, 01 Pelican Bay Blvd., Apt 803
Naples, FL 34108
Lauren Barber
16123"' Street, S.W.
Naples, FL 34117
Anthony M. Ojanovac
2829 Inlet Cove Lane West
Naples, FL 34120
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time - frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration.
Please include, in your return memo the attendance records, for the last 2 years, of the applicants
i I
recommended for reappointment.
Please categorize the applicants in arm of expertise. If you have any questions, please call me
at 252-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Attachments
filson s
rom: ctearsjr@sfwmd.gov
Went: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 4:25 PM
To: filson_s
Subject: New On -line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239 )252 -8606
Application was received on: 1/20/2010 4:25:00 PM.
Name: Ilarence S. Tears Jr.� Home Phone: 39- 348 -1356
Home Address: 1320 Lambton I�an�e
City: ale Zip Code: 410
Phone Numbers
Fax: 39 -263 -8166 Business: 39 -263 -7615
*Mail Address:...: teLnsit!iast s�o
Board / Committee Applied for: lConservation Collier Committe
Category: of indicate
Work Place: ISouth Florida Water Mana ement distric
How long have you lived in Collier County: F -_0
Have you ever been convicted of any offense against the law? N�
of Indicated
Do you or your employer do business with the County? Ye
My agency deals with water resource issues and this requires us to interact with various Division/Denartmentsl
the
NOTE: All advisory board members must update their profile and notify the Board of County
Commissioners in the event that their relationship changes relating to memberships of
organizations that may benefit them in the outcome of advisory board recommendations or they
enter into contracts with the County.
1
Would you and/or any organizations with whom nu are affiliated benefit from decisions or
recommendations made by this advisory board?
P�qot Indicate
Are you a registered voter in Collier County?
Do you currently hold public office?
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee? I' se
ake Trafford Task Force Flood Plain Mann ement Committee Immokalee Master Flan and Visioni.n
{ ommitt
Please list your communi activities:
Past Director of a church youth Group chair of Lely SAC Committee Board of Directors Leadershi
Florida Chaired Leadership Collier PMEM Florida Land and Preservation Trust Bd member Past Conne
Now Advisory Bd member Mentor for Take Stock in Childr
Education:
Experience:
hector for the Bg Cypress Basin the local arm of the South Florida Water Management District. Over 25
'7ears experience in dealing with water resource issues and for the past 14 years focused on mina ing the wate
esources in Collier County
r; .r/}, Ili, �.�'a �LG'.,? �'�'ir�;� ��^ 1�;•'„ 6�' l�w�£: MC�""��tz" � 3,^r,J`L,%` Ct f��,,'�"..- > >�;, °�� �t,;k�.i" ^',; �[,�+C�^4"° ,
v.. 41 ?LA Ole i`
! "��- z�..,y� �? � to _ J� 4r w.. -�.� v " %�tl j..�_G� k'x��� °�„ L%'C.� I`�..! � .ri,�? e+2.°,.:✓ f'd -�f
-, 5° %`t.fC_.r kd .� t °i_\ r.. �` t�C -..t�. -ri QJ t._ t ,�R.•c ..c. , :,`F f / .tx_t 2 €
".all < c} , lr /Gt C4.
t
'� f�- ,�. °�"t..�„i,»df� "r•� �s�d � �..«.«'. ��" Y .�=.,�yr,.,�,..r,,...x,..,,J -�Y L.,., �'�^�+t,.d.�a,...y�i,.,.�,,.s„ �' � k
f �
or
2
filson s
Wmro: rschult(§siue.edu
ent: Friday, January 15, 2010 7:38 AM
To: filson_s
Subject: New On -line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application ,Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)252 -8506
Application was rec zved on: 1/15/2010 7:38:18 AM.
Name: obert A. Schultheis Home Phone: 39 -653 -9512
Home Address: 1.01 Pelican Bay Blvd., Apt. 803
City: Ta le. Zip Code: 4108
Phone Numbers
Fax: Business:
0-mailAddress:1rschizlt�siue.ed
Board l Committee Applied for: onservation Collier Land Acquisition Adviso Co
Category: at indicate
Work Place: etire
How long have you lived in Collier County: P
Have you ever been convicted of any offense against the law?
of Indicate
Do you or your employer do business with the County? ®c
Not Indicate
NOTE: All advisory board members must update their profile and notify the Board of County
Commissioners in the event that their relationship changes relating to memberships of
organizations that may benefit them in the outcome of advisory board recommendations or they
enter into contracts with the County.
Would you and/or any organizations with whom you are affiliated benefit from decisions or
1
recommendations made by this advisory board?
of Indicate
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? F-esl
Do you currently hold public office? N�
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee?
of Indicate
Please list your community activities:
Planning and Zoning Commission, City of Glen Carbon, IL 18 years ending in 2006. Various other committee
in Illinois for many years relating to museums and home owners' associations. Professor, Com ut
Management Information Systems, So. Illinois UnivsELA
.z Edwardsville, some 30 years ending in 1998.1
Previously employed by'!:em gle Univ., Philadelphia and State Univ. of NY, Albany. Volunteer, Wildlife RehaN
Eenter, Conservancy of Southwest Florida since Sp 2008. Volunteer, St. Matthews House, since Spring
Education:
B.S. Business Education, NY State Collegefor Teachers, Albany, 1958 M.S. Business Education, State Univ.1
lof NY, Albany Ph.D. Business Education, Indiana University, Bloomington, 19661
17J
nence:
school business teacher at Coxsackie, NY. Assistant Professor of Business Education, State Univ. of N
-fate Professor of Business Education, Temple Univ. Professor of Computer Management Infon-natio
ms, So. Illinois Univ., Edwardsvill
hzr') i-
('4 4"'C ' iii "V
e r
4'- k'L•G( At C a 44 ex A, />-4:�
� 1
1AIA,
Vff
d lei
2
filson s
rom: Lauren (Qturrell- associates.com
ent: Thursday, January 14, 2010 9:18 AM
To: Filson s
Subject: New On -line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3341 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)252 -$606
Application was received on: 1/14/2010 9 :17 :52 AM.
Name: .auren Barb ex Home Phone: 39- 440 -7637
Home Address: 1161 23rd St SW�
City: ale Zip Code: 5411
Phone Numbers
Fax: 39-643 -6632 Business: 39- 643 -016
*Mail Address: 11.:aurenr`u >turrelI- associates. Evil
Board / Committee Applied for: and Acquisition AdvisoryCammitte
Category: of indicate
Work Place: carrell, Hall & Associates, In
How long have you lived in Collier County: ore than 15
Have you ever been convicted of any offense against the law?
Not Indicate
Do you or your employer do business with the County? FeR
he firm that i work for is involved with processing environmental permits with Collier County.
NOTE: All advisory board members must update their profile and notify the Board of County
Commissioners in the event that their relationship changes relating to memberships of
organizations that may benefit them in the outcome of advisory board recommendations or they
enter into contracts with the County.
Would you and /or any organizations with whom you are affiliated benefit from decisions or
I
recommendations made by this advisory board? IN-oj
Wo—t Indicate
-�
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? 0
Do you currently hold public office?
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee? 0
filled in for the LDC Amendment Advisory Board form supervisor Tim Hal�,
Please list your community activities:
C-0
of S j J
Vw�d member WFAE-P] A4, b4
Education:,
:)gy with a minor in Computer Science Partially com leted M.S. Environmental Scienc
Experience •
�have worked for Turrell, Hall & Associates, Inc for over
fA
Z�) "s 6) C." i
dk
-A
czt, 6,*-, 0/,0, C 21', 4'e"
45,7cO e—z J L't"Iz. 4r)
t 1
4
'k—cf—t- er, r, a J r— I ref
Z-44
2
filson—S
From: amoappraisals@gmaii.com
0ent: Tuesday, January 12, 2010 2:57 PM
0: filson s
Subject: New 6n-line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tainiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)252-8606
Application was receive on. 1/12/2010 2:57:23 PM.
Name: Fn—thony M. Ojanov Home Phone: 39-35
Home Address: V829 Inlet Cove Lane We
City: ale Zip Code: F4-1-2-�
Phone Numbers
Fax: E39455-99411 Business: 39-455-997
*Mail Address: kmoavr)rqisals�ie,,gmqil. E01-91
Board / Committee Applied for: and Acquisition Advis2_q Committee�
Category: of indicate
Work Place: aPlatte Appraisal Services, Inc.
How long have you lived in Collier County: ore than 15
Have you ever been convicted of any offense against the law?
Not Indicated
Do you or your employer do business with the County?
of Indicate
NOTE: All advisory board members must update their profile and notify the Board of County
Commissioners in the event that their relationship changes relating to memberships of
organizations that may benefit them in the outcome of advisory board recommendations or they
enter into contracts with the County.
Would you and/or any organizations with whom you are affiliated benefit from decisions or
I
recommendations made by this advisory board?
of Indicate
*Are you a registered voter in Collier County? Fe-S]
Do you currently hold public office?
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee?
Not Indicate
Please list your community activities:
FOR
Education:
Kiradwie- - Naples High School, 1995 Current Student - Hodges Universi 914
El
,ivifian Deputy - Collier Sheriff's Office (1996-1999) Law Enforcement Officer - Naples Police Dqpartrnen�
1999-2004) Certified Residential Appmiser - LaPlatte Appraisal Services, Inc. (2004 - Present�
4
X11<111 a
C7
w A4,
Zt C. 4-
2
Details Page I of I
, Alp, �
&�
$¢: :iw� 6..,._ h}eE:aFa:3s,...._ TrtreaNaF.ces �:...
_ _I
Current Ownership
Parcel No 00219120302 Property Address 2140 MOULDER DR
30 48 27 SV2 OF S112 OF
OF E1i2 OF EV2 OF NE1.
No.
1 30 II 48 II 27 II 5 II 3C30 II 482730 100.0003030 I
I Sub No. ll 100 I ACREAGE HEADER Total Scho(
-'`: Use Code fiY AGRICULTURAL F 132 6.4101 11.6491 5.238
akul3i :orlS
2009 Final Tax Roll Latest Sales History
(Subject to Change)
t:;, ues shf,&r.. t>elosr+equaf 0 Ptais
parcel x,: 5 c i ale. after tit* Fuw: l Tar H ,ll
Land Value S 250,000.00
Date Bcaok -page
Amount
( +} Improved Value $ 62,587.00
03 i 2009 4431 -3207
f -} Jusi Value $ 312,587.00
03 12009 4431 -3804 11
$ 0.00
1 -I SON Exempt Value A olher ExEtmptiu0 s $ 197,240.00
I =) Assessed Value $ 115.347.00
03 r 2009 4431-
1 0312009 4431 -3793
F $ 0.00
$ 488,000.00
( -} Homestead and ofher Exempt Value
$0.00
12 12003
USE - 1210
S=) Taxable Value
$ 115.347.00
F12 i 1992
1778-912
H School Taxable Value fUSed fo3 ScEtool Taxes}
$ 115,347.00
SOH ='Save Our Homes" exempt value due to cap on assessment
increases.
The Information is Updated Weekly.
/ 7 7Ku .
httpWwww. colIierappraiser. com /RecordDetai1.asp?Map= &FoliolD= 0000000219120302 2/7/2010
Details
Page 1 of I
UG'
r30 P. e
Current Ownership
Parcel No. 00211040008 Property Address 2430 CATAWBA ST
Sub No. 100 ACREAGE HEADER Total School
'':` Use Code RET. HOMES & MISC. RESIDENCES 132 6.4101 71.6491 5.239
'c�8f3 ICEiif:ii;i l:n5 �:' "131 ^,lAaiii3nF
2009 Final Tax Roll Latest Sales History
(Subject to Change)
,. a8 'Ja3urs sh::x r: Below equai O:.hia;
pn: eal mrva area ei<:.rher the Final Tas Roll
Land Value
S 47,950.00
Date
Book •?gat ;e Amount
(�) Improved Value
$ 250.00
0412009
4443 - 1669
F 1=D just Value
S 48.200.00
03 i 1991
1599 - 153 $ 15,000.00
i -I S' H r.Ompl yauie & Oklier F.xen3ptions
$0,00
—
( =) Assessed Value R-48.200 00
s -) Homestead and other Exempt Valeta $ 0.00
( =p Taxable Value $ 48100.00
S chooi Tdx ihte'. V,31ue fused for School lazes ;J
SOH = "Save Our Homes' exempt value due to cap on assessment
increases.
The Information is Updated Weekly.
e 12�i
http:// www. colIierappraiser .com/RecordDetaii. asp ?Map= &FoliofD-0000000211040008 2/7/2010
'77[jIu`°
PROPERTY OF
=R COUNTY E'J =:';0 OF COMMISSION'
FeR afi ii
"—WARRANTED
Land -Value Analysis
Discussion of Vacant Land Sales
In order to estimate the market value of the Subje t Property, a search was made
in the Subject's neighborhood for land sales with development potential similar to
the Subject. We analyzed the Subject Property and the comparables on a price per
acre basis, as this is the most recognized unit of comparison in this market. All of
the comparables were considered with regard to property rights transferred,
financing, conditions of sale, time or market conditions, location, size, site duality
and access. The data is summarized below.
i
Land Sales
Rivers Road Parcels 0 8 B �g "
Callaway 8 Price, Inc. # 09!,227 ! ` "
Sale Number
Subject Property (A)
Subject Property (B)
Sale 1
Sale 2
Sale 3
Listing 4
Record ID #
Cosentino
Devissee
7147
7149
7150
7151
ORBK/PG
4437/0113
4431/1571
433610710
WA
Sale Price
$125,000
$145,000
$99,900
$200,000
Size - Acres
8.92
4.84
4.77
5,00
4.92
4.77
Price/Acre
$26,205
$29,000
$20,305
$41,929
West side of Rivers Road
Approximately 300 feet
east of Rivers Road
South side of Deer Run
South side of Ken Island
East side of Moulde- Drive
North side of No Name
Location
approximately 0.60 miles
,
a 0 3 miles
Lane approximately 700
Road approximately 400
approximately 0.60 miles
Lane approximately 350
south of Immokalee Road
pproximately
south of Immokalee Road
feet east of Rock Road
fe #t west of Rock Road
south of Immokalee Road
feet east of Rock Road
City
Unincorp. Collier Co.
Unincorp. Collier Co.
Unincorp. Collier Co.
L nincorp. Collier Co.
Unincorp. Collier Co.
Unincorp. Collier Co.
Date of Sale
Mar -09
Feb-09
Mar -08
Current Listing
Zoning
A -MHO
A -MHO
A -MHO
A -MHO
A -MHO
A -MHO
Future Land Use
Rural Fringe Mixed Use
Rural Fringe Mixed Use
Rural Frnge Mixed Use
Rural Fringe Mixed Use
Rural Fringe Mixed Use
Rural Fringe Mixed Use
Receiving Lands
Receiving Lands
Receiving Lands
Receiving Lands
Receiving Lands
Receiving Lands
Conditions of Sale Adj.
0%
0%
0%
-25%
Market Condition Adj-
-5%
-5%
-15%
0%
Adjusted Price Per Acre
$24,895
$27,550
$17,259
$31,447
Physical Adjustments
Location
0%
0%
0%
0%
Size
0%
0%
0%
01%
Site Quality
0%
0%
0%
0%
Access
0%
0%
0%
01A
Overall Adj
0%
0%
0%
0%
Adjusted Price Per Acre
95
$27,550 1
$17,259 1
$31,447
Gl Pnce Per Acre
Average $25,288
Minimum $17,259
Maximum $31,447
M edian $26,223
PREPARED FOR . r- ROPERTY OF
, LLIER COUNTY EC ,;;J OF COMMISSION`
7LIANCE UPON ,`.';`?RAISAL FOR OTH":.
SFS IS ' '- ,p!AiiRANTED
d
auv is��
24
Emm
p
",MARED FOP,,' : ?ROPERTY
COUNTY EC'%...) OF COMMISS
tl� '', -RRANTED
Land Sales Mal
T
ZiL - f
Parcel A
7
4 --Al
C)
4,
L
4SIVIO
�� 6V
Land-Value Analysis
v W
Z.
-:w
-7.
_y, 7
_e
whe
:4_7
7 -T
Mr
�NW
1171
-41
U
Parcel B
T
ZiL - f
Parcel A
7
4 --Al
C)
4,
L
4SIVIO
�� 6V
Land-Value Analysis
- - ` � - 7-:. 2- 7Z
=j;j5EjZg. I J WU I �W I V W
_7
_-M
7
4"
7
7-
t
Z
2
4z Z,
PREPARED FOR.-' - 'ROPERTY OF
1LIER COUNTY OF COMMISSIOW
LIANCE UPON A,-7?RAISAL FOR OTHE
111;F1z1fn1' —WARRANTED
26
mi 02 04 0.6 0.8 1 1
i "RV
-AREDFOR,', - PROPERTY CF
Ll_'ER COUNTY EC;; :J OF COMMISSION'
1IIANCE UPON APPRAISAL FOR OTHE
"817S IS 7 WARRANTED
v W
Z.
I -A
Mr
�NW
- - ` � - 7-:. 2- 7Z
=j;j5EjZg. I J WU I �W I V W
_7
_-M
7
4"
7
7-
t
Z
2
4z Z,
PREPARED FOR.-' - 'ROPERTY OF
1LIER COUNTY OF COMMISSIOW
LIANCE UPON A,-7?RAISAL FOR OTHE
111;F1z1fn1' —WARRANTED
26
mi 02 04 0.6 0.8 1 1
i "RV
-AREDFOR,', - PROPERTY CF
Ll_'ER COUNTY EC;; :J OF COMMISSION'
1IIANCE UPON APPRAISAL FOR OTHE
"817S IS 7 WARRANTED
Z
-�.r'.?' 4 2� :mac. + �, � s..+yi s �L�.�. 5' • ''�;r}p
-k t
t ,},�� r 4� ,t r�•ra � 1 f �' � c � t �
.` O �u 'iet. F Y k'� 4..� �iS�_ t • Yom# L Z�y �t
Y ... '�'��� rat k �r • P y -� ``� .
S Ts d
- rt!i
t
j' k�y15 - T � y
15
L -A
O
0 P 57 R-I Y OF
El;,-.*',--,D OF COMSSIOIN.
,,PON J-1-RAISAL FOR OTHL
C4-1-' lzl� VIA-HRANTED
•
;'R, E PAR E D F0 R - ' P,7,. 0 P E PITY C. F
.1 ER COUNTY EC, .3 OF C 0 M M'' S S I G NF
-.ANCE UPON FOR OTHL
Es IS F'.- 'h'ARRANTED
V)
C:)
VI)
M
CD
CD
c"i
C�
C)
C)
C)
z
Cl�
C:�
C:�
r-
N
U
7
v1
rq
00
c:,
01�
co
o
o0 'D —
0,
c)
r—
c,,i ci
�e C-i
06
C14
cz
N
lu
C's
CZ
0
C,
E
bra
U
E
(u N
E
E
tn.
Q)
-cj
m
m
0 z
0
0 CZ
i::
cz 0
M
o
o Cj
94 11;
03
E
J-
u CL
A
O E
C) Z"
0042
m
0 oz
0
M
cz
8.
-g-
0,
z 4)
00
C?
O
CD
Q,
C7,
C=,
C?
co
m
co
41
z
z
•
;'R, E PAR E D F0 R - ' P,7,. 0 P E PITY C. F
.1 ER COUNTY EC, .3 OF C 0 M M'' S S I G NF
-.ANCE UPON FOR OTHL
Es IS F'.- 'h'ARRANTED