Loading...
Agenda 03/02/2010 W (FTF) AGENDA BCC WORKSHOP MEETING March 2, 2010 ,- ~~----_.." '.. ,..-...,...._..,--_.".._-_._-,~,..__.~--- ..".,~---,-_. '-.-..," -._-- I ---- For@~losur@ Tasla For~@ Worlashop Tuesday, March 2nd, 2010 9:00 A.M.- Noon ). -, 1'-"''' "'" Workshop Agenda Task Foree Fad Sheet Matrix of Besonrees PalDphlet I~... . ---oiJ :~~t COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS O~'\ II,/,. '\ r ( . I" """ JI ,\ AGENDA March 2, 2010 9:00 AM BGG/Foreclosure Task Force Workshop 3rd Floor Boardroom W. Harmon Turner Building Fred W. Coyle, BCC Chairman Commissioner, District 4 Frank Halas, BCC Vice-Chairman Commissioner, District 2 Jim Coletta, BCC Commissioner, District 5; CRAB Chairman Donna Fiala, BCC Commissioner, District 1; CRAB Vice-Chairman Tom Henning, BCC Commissioner, District 3 NOTICE: ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEMS MUST REGISTER PRIOR TO SPEAKING. SPEAKERS MUST REGISTER WITH THE COUNTY MANAGER PRIOR TO THE PRESENTATION OF THE AGENDA ITEM TO BE ADDRESSED. ALL REGISTERED SPEAKERS WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES UNLESS THE TIME IS ADJUSTED BY THE CHAIRMAN. COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2003-53, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE 2004-05 AND 2007-24, REQUIRES THAT ALL LOBBYISTS SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS), REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT. IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY WHO NEEDS ANY ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS PROCEEDING, YOU ARE ENTITLED, AT NO COST TO YOU, TO THE PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PLEASE CONTACT THE COLLIER COUNTY FACILITIES MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT LOCATED AT 3301 EAST TAMIAMI TRAIL, NAPLES, FLORIDA, 34112, (239) 252-8380; ASSISTED LISTENING DEVICES FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABLE IN THE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' OFFICE. 1. Pledge of Allegiance 2. Introduction- Jeff Ahren- Chairman, Collier County Foreclosure Task Force 3. Overview of Foreclosures in Collier County- Jeff Ahren, Chairman, Collier County Foreclosure Task Force 4. Foreclosure Task Force's Response- Diane B. Flagg- Director, Code Enforcement 5. Recommendations - Kathleen Passidomo, Co-Chair, Collier County Foreclosure Task Force 6. Question and Answer Period 7. Adjourn INQUIRIES CONCERNING CHANGES TO THE BOARD'S AGENDA SHOULD BE MADE TO THE COUNTY MANAGER'S OFFICE AT 252-8383. FACT SHEET COLLIER COUNTY FORECLOSURE TASK FORCE OVERVIEW OF THE INITIATIVE: A. FORECLOSURE TASK FORCE * Grassroots initiative * Foreclosure Task Force (FTF) formed in February of2008 * Began as a cooperative effort between Legal Aid Service of Collier County ('Legal Aid') and the Collier County Bar Association ('CCBA') * 100% pro bono initiative * Goal - to promote foreclosure prevention in Collier County through education and intervention * Many other agencics and volunteers subsequently joined the FTF, including Housing Development Corporation of SW Florida, Inc. - a HUD certified credit and foreclosure intervention counseling agency * The FTF has assisted approximately 1,000 homeowners through numerous Workshops, Legal Clinics, and Seminars, and 10,000 visitors to the website it created (Vvww.collierFTF.com) * The FTF has been asked by the Collier County Board of County Commissioners to conduct a formal workshop before the Commissioners in March of201O to present information on the state of foreclosure activity in Collier County, and recommendations for action B. STEERING COMMITTEE FOR A COORDINATED COMMUNITY RESPONSE CONCERNING FORECLOSED/ABANDONED HOMES * Organized, formed and supported through the Greater Naples Area Chamber of Commerce * Steering Committee formed in July-Aug. 2008 * Goal. to enhance communication between public, private, business and non-profit agencies (any applicable stakeholders) to formulate a volunteer driven 'coordinated community response' to the issues and challenges posed to Collier County by the rising number of foreclosed and abandoned homes in the area * To best leverage the limited resources available, promote efficiency, and broaden the scope of future projects, the FTF and Steering Committee 'merged' in January, 2009 C. LEADERSHIP * Legal Aid Service of Collier County's (LASCC) Pro Bono Coordinator and Development Officer, Jeffrey Ahren, Esq., has served as Chairman of the Task Force since its inception * Kathleen Passidomo, Esq., past President of the Collier County Bar Association, serves as Co- Chair of the FTF * A core group of founding attorneys and others serve on the FTF 'working group'. which collectively plans the activities and outreach efforts of the initiative * Executive Committee formed in 20 I 0 to plan and administer special projects D. A WARDS AND ACCOLADES * October 2009 - Proclamation honoring the pro bono service of the FTF by the Collier County Board of County Commissioners * December 2009 - Proclamation by the Mayor and City of Naples honoring the FTF's service to the community * December 2009 - Attorney members of the FTF's 'working group' each given a 'Special Recognition Award' by the Collier County Women's Bar Association * April 2009 - Jeffrey Ahren, Esq., of Legal Aid Service of Collier County and FTF Co- Chairman named 'Attorney of the Year' by the Collier County Bar Association (CCBA) * December 2009 - FTF Co- Chairman and Past CCBA President Kathleen Passidomo, Esq., awarded The Florida Bar President's Pro Bono Service Award for the 20th Judicial Circuit for her work on the FTF * November 2009 - Jefferson Award for public service - awarded to Bob Murray, FTF Executive Committee and Working Group member since 2008, Greater Naples Chamber of Commerce - Alliance * January 2010 - Jeffrey Ahren, Esq., FTF Co-Chairman, nominated by the Board of Directors ofthe Collier County Bar Association for The Florida Bar Foundation's 2010 Medal of Honor A ward E. COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION AND SUPPORT The FTF enjoys widespread support among the key public, private and non-profit agencies in Collier County - particularly agencies who are 'stakeholders' concerning the issues the FTF has been formed to address. These agencies include governmental agencies, business groups, and other non-profit agencies performing mental health and social service work in the community. In addition to LASCC and the CCBA, the longstanding support of the greater Naples Chamber of Commerce has been particularly important. Particivatinl!: al!:encies include: * Greater Naples Chamber of Commerce Collier County Bar Association Legal Aid Service of Collier County Collier County Code Enforcement Collier County Sheriffs Office Collier County Clerk's Office Collier County Courts Housing Development Corporation of SW Florida, Inc. Naples Area Board of REAL TORS@ City of Naples Code Enforcement Collier County School District/Collier County Public Schools EK Consulting, Inc. David Lawrence Center Mental Health Association of Southwest Florida Chamber Alliance - Greater Naples Chamber of Commerce Collier County Housing and Human Services Marco Island Area Chamber of Commerce Marco Island Area Association of REAL TORS@ SCORE - Naples * This list is not comprehensive, as the initiative is supported by many other individuals and agencies I. PAST PROJECTS Mav 2008 - 'Save Your Home' Workshop * Conducted at Max Hasse Community Center in Golden Gate Estates * Free foreclosure workshop open to the public * Panel of experts on foreclosure related topics (including short sales, loan modifications, bankruptcy, and the foreclosure process in general) * Panel included attorneys and a local Magistrate * Free 25 page booklet of resources disseminated to all attendees * Over 100 members of the public attended the event June 2008 - Free clinic featurinl!: certified foreclosure intervention counselors * Conducted at Legal Aid office in Naples * HUD certified credit and foreclosure intervention counselors provided free individualized counseling sessions to over 20 homeowners Julv 2008 - Pro Bono Foreclosure Law Clinic * Over 25 pro bono attorneys specializing in real estate, foreclosure law and bankruptcy law participated * More than 80 homeowners received free individualized advice and counsel at the clinic * Approximately 150 individual counseling sessions in total were conducted * Event conducted at Legal Aid's office in Naples * Certified real estate appraiser present * Each attendee screened by a certified credit and foreclosure intervention counselor as to the potential for loan modification based on current financial circumstances Foreclosure Task Force Website * Created in May of2008 - www.collierFTF.com * Contains links to many helpful resources (local, state and national) regarding foreclosure prevention * Multimedia - contains hours of video (including entire May 2008 workshop) * Has been visited by over 10,000 people to date November 2008 Foreclosure Seminar * Sponsored by the Naples Chamber * Conducted by the Steering Committee (in conjunction with the FTF) * Location - Moorings Presbyterian Church * More than 200 attendees received a wide variety of information on foreclosure prevention, how to avoid foreclosure rescue scams, and the innovative programs launched by Collier County Code Enforcement and the Collier County Sheriffs Office to stabilize the community Mav 2009 Free Foreclosure Workshop . Conducted on May 13,2009 at Naples Area Board of Realtors (NAB OR) Offices . Attended by an estimated 250 - 300 members of the public . Pro Bono Attorneys and a host of other professionals and participating agencies furnished free information on foreclosure prevention and related topics to all attendees . 25 pages of free literature on foreclosure prevention and local resources distributed to all attendees . All attendees had the opportunity to obtain general legal information from the pro bono volunteers in small groups organized by topic and specialty Julv 2009 - Foreclosure Task Force participates in Housinl!: Workshop bv Florida Dept. of Financial Services . Conducted at Edison State College . Pro Bono attorney members of the Task Force provided advice and counsel to homeowners at-risk of foreclosure September 2009 - Pro Bono Foreclosure Law Clinic at Lel!:al Aid . Conducted at the offices of Legal Aid in Naples . Attended by approximately 75 homeowners, who each received individual advice and counsel sessions with pro bono attorneys . Over 25 attorneys volunteered on a Saturday morning for this event November 9. 2009 - Free Foreclosure Workshop at Gulf Coast Hil!:h School . Pro Bono attorneys and other professionals and a host of private, public and non-profit agencies furnished free information and answered general questions on a host of foreclosure related topics . Over 200 attendees participated in post-event exit polling by a consulting firm, which revealed a satisfaction rate of over 98% II. OTHER PROJECTS Matrix of Resources on Foreclosure * Concept - to provide a comprehensive and current list of safe and reliable resources targeted for individuals at-risk of foreclosure * This brochure has been produced in English, Spanish and Creole * Utilization of a 'holistic' approach to the possible needs of each individual using the literature * The "Matrix' was completed in the Spring of2009, and has been disseminated throughout the County in pamphlet format, and online Mediation Sub-Committee formed . Since mid-2008, the Task Force's Mediation Sub-committee has met on a weekly basis to develop a protocol for the mediation of foreclosure cases in Collier County . The Sub-Committee has worked closely with the local judiciary on this project . In 2009, this Sub-Committee submitted a formal report containing recommendations to the Florida Supreme Court, which included the report in the record ofthe State-wide Task Force on Foreclosure appointed by the Supreme Court . On December 28,2009, the Florida Supreme Court issued an Administrative Order concerning the Case Management and Mediation of foreclosure cases in Florida state courts - which adopted many ofthe recommendations advanced by the Collier County Foreclosure Task Force Mediation Sub-Committee Free foreclosure support l!:roup formed * Every Tuesday evenings at the Mental Health Association of Southwest Florida offices * Facilitated by a qualified mental health professional * Interested parties can contact (239) 261-5405 ~ Z :J o U eX u.I :::i -I o U u.I J: I- u.I U eX o u. :..= ~ u.I eX :J V'l o -I U u.I eX o u. eX o u. Z o ~ eX o u. !;; ~ " ~ ~ ...~. ..~ e" ,," :Q~ " ",' l:"- -" ~t{ >:- ..:; ~e ~ 1; '<: " '5 Iii "" -~. ~~ ..9~ " " :ol e ~5 ~" " .;:,' ~" ....- " !S " " ~e .. .. ,. " '5 ~ z o ~ u.I z 3: o u.I :E o J: u.I eX :J V'l o -I U u.I eX o u. '~~'~~~'~~]G'~ ~~~ OOQVO:::loE ;:::::E<:.JE uuu;5;~.; s:::; o~ S E~~ vQ :=.::..~ c::.@::CO..:::loviUvi b t:.Q c:::= ro rov~-ouc.::: ro ~ .~ .g 3 3 .~ ~ ~ S .~ '0 g ~ ~ o Vl c '- ~ ~ is ~= 0 ~ < u: ~~~~6~~ ~ O"l:: ~~ ~ 3~~'~~~E601 'l)og-gcctl~5~ u~~3~..Q<~Vl ~~ 0 'l) < 5 -g v'O is UO 1:lJ)::;: V'l <:.J ...:::! ~ ~_~ U U CO~u..::l<_ vi "Vi U a... 0 0 ro U .~g 6 0~u ~-g'gG -5:r:Ecu~-_~~ vi - < u ~t:4~g-(jo-5~ ::0 "r: ....""'i'5 Z "E ~ ~ .~ :::lQ.J';uo~ou.;!u:::;::: C-\/1i:i: u..::.:c......... '" ~~ f2~ g~ o~~ ~f:l~ ~~~ z~z <",0 I-i='" z>~ ~ e'", "'st;; 1-::l0 <Vl::;: ~~~ -"'I- ~ '" ..; ~~ 15 tj .... t;; ~ ~ i;; ~ S Z ::l0 Vl", Z Vl '" 0 '" .... '" u '" ~ ~ ~ IU e:Q ~ ...0 tp cc E .... ~ c ~ :8 ~ ~ -< '8 ~~ CL ~ " z 6li >, 5 " E ~ ~ o u Us ~ .~ w..J o~ u3 "0 u v.c).c\~v ~ s:::; c c v V :::l :::l :::l E 03330 u -5 u :2 ~ -5 " o~~ ~ ~ 0 -g~..c::: ~ u ~..c-5 'l) ~ .:: -5 &~, ~ov; s -t= .s ~ ~ 'l) :2~~ o " u ~~~ i:: U 8 B-5v ~ '" ~ -5 " e ~ CL -9 6 2 .-- >,c... 6-6 6..2 .~ ~ ~c SU 0-5 ~s ~ ~ o U ~ '" ~ -5 fo ~ ~ , c U ~ '0.2 ~ o u > o E .9] ~c: ~ ~ ~ "0 ~ !:: ~ o c "u ~ ~ :2..2 :5 is ~" 1..1..2 -"" fii' C E"' .s~.s-g~~ ~ c O..c::: s::: .3 1ti"C'ij 5}-1:lJ)"(ij ""O..c::: 0... ~ 60... v;;:lE6>>-E -5:E8E-58 .s c..o::J 0 u ro]-5:Z~-5 ~'~~6~~ E :::l"'2 ~ t:: 8- ~~2:-5~~ Vl ro ~ 1-..... -5~~v.8 ros-5-o 6 ~ 'ii t: :;...., c: -' c vi ~~.~ ~.:c ""0 v - ~.~ ~;:: ~:::l .....~c:Es E .-:= u ," >, g 3: v G>t:i '" ro -5 ~ -2 ~E.9 ~ ~ 5~'0-5 6 5 0....... <l,.> :.::; >'t:;E.9.~G !~~~]~ ~'~~~cEE o'-'~E~t::~ -<-,:::l 1l.l::l..Q ii, ~, ~ i;; (3 ro I::: U ro.J:: Il.J .5 c i::.s;::. ~.J:: ~~iSE':;~2 .~ Q...~\ 5 ~ ~ S; v "0 ';; ~ ~ ~,.g ~c~i!;E2 1d=l.J-lvo....c:...g Il.l'~ E :::;; .~ a =V>c~c~~ .9 0.. 0 ... ~ 1'5:.s ~ ~:e~~ u ~ Q.) I'll ro 65 .!: ~ .5~~-u ~Bo~..Q~-,g o~]:; t:-5''''l o 'C;; S ~2 ":: 0 ~ ="E ~ '{;i 0"- ~ E .~3 I- ~ o ~ z '8 u o ~ OS ~. " e " "" ~ " ~ & " ... .9 "E t!i! .. " ~ " a -"'. .~ o ~ ~ "- ~ z " ~ ~ E o u ~ ~ d .~ u -0 ~ -g Q.I 5'=6 "'~ ~ ~ - ~ c ~ ~ G ;3 ::;;:; ;:::J Jl__ ~,.6'~ :J ~ Q u.I -I i:C :s ~ <r::: !:!ll Q.. -I u.I J: .;.; '- .~ :.; c:: o .- .... C\I ~ .s! .5 ~ o E: ~ ~ E o u ..: f- w. - .!:! "5 U ~ ~\ ~ o U ~ ii5 '" u '5 ~ S ~ ~ u'" '1: '" ~< Vly " "" ..~ EN " :1:_ ,,~ fi.2 ",a. .E'i: ~ u " ~ " ~ :1:0. EG>~cti~.Q g-=!::E.~.=t:i ~"'iiJ ~ a v'Ri I'll ""'ffi -= t; 0 V1 :..::; d,J vu(;-01:::~5 ~:CV>O~~.Q ~.~] 0 c .~ ~ ~ 0:;-0 g v~-E~ IU .- l::..Q"'O C -5 'JJ ~';;:;:;;::l~~ro-= ~ ro .9-~'5 ~-= 5 c t: .~..c, C >-,::J '0 a-"2: ~"8~~~,. g~~E~-5~'"2 8~;.9c:v::.~ ~.2~~2~5~ ~"o r:.l) fi5 G VI ~ '"6 "'" .: ~'E ~ ,~ ""'0 ;.:t;uO::ll-~ o-g;:go...~o-g Z~5ro5ZE O::l~~vO~ o ~,~ Jd ro 0 ..Q u '" ~ ~ .g g .~ ....... ('Q I'll V>..... E ~ ~.2 ~ 0 .5 t:::.J:: ti :'0 s.J:: :5 ot: .~ 5..2 I'll 0 0 EUu.. .2.~ Qj .~ ~ 6 ""u~ "g .E ~ D- ~~ O'S: 0 .......= <U .-!:. ~ ~ ~g-.2 ~iS..t:...2 " ;2 .9 ~ ~ "0 u .::; E o ~ u ~u..: '2: t ~ .~ -go ~u ~ ~ ~ o ~ .9 o~ "'~ ~ ~ :::; ro ~ ~ =Q.. ~ Vl ~ v;- u "- ~ s o o N '? N ~ N V E~ ,,~ E @ .. E &~ 08 -5;::2 CiN ,,~ :l:N '" ::l o '" '" '" ; '" ~ .~ ~ CL Vl~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ i3 '3 E " ~ ~ is u ~ '" " ~ ~ ~ .2 " " u u ~= - " ~ ~ , ~ u ~ .. ~ o .. '" ~ .. c ... 2:! ... ~ Jl:E o~ U'm ~ f;; -5 ~ ~ ~ ~ - - ~ ~~ 8 8 u ~ ~ o ro - ~ .", V'l 8 .~ ?5~ ~~ ~ ..J:: .~ 0:0 c ~ "- .g c' ~ c 0 o ~ c ~) 0 ,=u(;5 '" '2 ~ :> '" '" ~ ~ ~ u o o '"' 'i' '" N u :s u -5 '" " :I: " o " .c . " .<> .c '" ;:; z '" ::l ~ ... o I- ::l o ~ ::;: ~ . '" ~~ Vl b;: zl- 0< 0", ::l::;: 00 >:1: c o 4!lCL ~~ Vl '" iJ z '" ~ '" u '" ::l o Vl '" '" Vl Vl '" Z .... .... '" ~ o z < :I: !:; :5 :I: .... fS z '" ::;: j- ~ 0: ~ '03: 8-g ~ ~ ~~ ~ -Su 1.~ :I: en ]j;;< ~~ o o o M "' ~ '"' o o o ") 00 ~ '"' ! e:. -" o ~ t; z ~ ~ ~ U :;: " ~ .... C of' ~ 0 '0 M '~* E: " '" u '5 " ::;: ~ ~ u '1: u Vl -5 "iiu- u~ :1:-" .-" ~o =E "OE u'=' . ~ .c t; ...- ~ .u "'- ~ c~ 00 ';:: E ~~ ~ '- C (;5 -:5 ~ ~ CO v 0 ~ c\B C v C t:= ::::l ....: ::::l ~ (3 ~3o ~ t:;~ E.~ ~ (5 ~ = v U ~3 5,- '-a~~~ C -:5 v .:.= 00 '2: -:50M~ '3: ~ 00 V"I UNv tj'2: V'l:.:t:: ~ ~ N .gV"lo...~ y, M~ '~g~-Jcn "'O.J:! C =;;a ~ ~~.Qu1" C '- :~ G>~ 5 ~\ ~ ~ "':- >\ ~ ~ ::: g:; '= -..l "'- '" N o o ~ 00 v, ~ .,. '"' N " '"' + M .,. eo N ~ 1, M .,. ~ " E " U ~lU ~ U ._ C ~ " ~ - > ~ ~ .. "'.... -8" ~ ~ >=0 ;:. C " " U ~ '0 u '0 'B c.. ~ " :I: ;:. E " e E o u ~ ~ c.. '" z :i1 < z 00 .,. .,. '? N ~ N ~ u E: o .~ " i! u ~ "5.9~ ~~~ t:; ~ "- '" ::::l E' ~ ~ 5 8 ~ U ~:E~ ~ ';;;:; (5 '" e U E o..~ ~Et; '. ro ~ 8t:;-"8u:3 ..J:: ,Q V'I ~-ro:::20 c"8E ~ o E v ~ 8 E 5 C'I ~ 8 ON E ?5 g (;5 S ~ 0 '.1'1 .~ 2 ~8 ~ '5 .~ ~ " ~ ~ "'" "15Cl u: E ;;:~ Vl o~ ~ ~ 00 ~ '" ~ " C " U I!~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ... U", '" ~ Q. ~ i';. >- < >- ::0 0 ::0 ...; ...... ::0 ~ V'l 0 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ UJ >- Vl ~ ~ :E ~ :J: Z Z < '"' ~ ~ U 0 >- ..... I- II') ~ ffi S!Z ~ eX ~ LU ~ U ~ " " >- ~ ~ w ::!: 0.:: I- c.::: I;l u.J cX <: Z~OVl Vi ,.. ~ ~ :J ~ Z :E ~ := ~ -< 0 LLl X ::;: u.. U;l :J: >- :; ::0 :s " :J: Z ... Vl ~ ~ U c.::: l.l.l ci 0'"' ... CQ <: ~ Q~S '" :J: '"' ::E f- ~ f- e:g ~ ~ -' ... ... ... -' ::0 ~ ~ 8 c.. ~ E o u ~ ." - .~ ~~ ~ 6' 3"0- -" E ~ u ~ ~ '" '~ g "> ~ " :!!~ 0;:; u:: ';1 ~~ - ~ ~~ "' '" u C u~ c~ =~ ~Z ~- ..c~ ::;~ c9 o;~ ::00:; .=!-v- ::o5~ :;) 'Z ~ Q.. E 0 ~'- E g ~ ~ ,,- U N ~'" ~ -9)~ "0 9-~ u~';2 5 C 8 ~ " o '" 2;:::] ~ .. "E ~ ~ N ~ ~ ;Q ... ... 1= ~ ~ " '"' b;: 00 ~ ::0 -' ~ :s f- ... :J Z 0 ~ ~ c.. '"' o ... ~ 0 _ Z ... ... U -' ~ ~ ... ~ ~ - ... ~ u o 0'" ~ ~ ~ 0 "'0 ~~ E" ~ ...~ .~ ~ ""6 ~ u'" C ~ ~ ~ 5 - 6' ~o... U E ~:::!. '0 ~ -5"'2 ~ v uu t:l ~ ~.2 C ~ t; >-,t::: C 0 ~ .2 .,; -' -' :s ~ u ~ Vl " ""-" ... o Z ... -' '"' :J ~ i':2 :J t;:; '"' aj .~~ ~ "'0 0 en c2 ~ :;; '" ~ ~ " o 0 >0-5; ~ u C ~ C Vi o "Vi ~ ~ ." V V C ~ o ~ ~ " "0- ~ Z E'- o ..Q U " ~ C 8- ~ ] E 0 "0 ~ c Vi o g ." :I: ~ ~ ;2 -5 ~, c.. .9 ~ o >, c.. ~ ~ ~ .9 " ,g ~ C ~ U ~ C ~ ~ oL E " 0 U -" c.. o " > C; ~ "'0 C _ C 'Vi Il.I 0 ~ :g ~ ~ E -5~J? 6' .: E " .~ ~ :J ~ . E ~ ~ Il.I ~ ~~r--:c..i~-5~ -a'~C"\~~.:;;.;:;;; .5 ~ M :;l"S;...o or;"::; c ~ ]u..~~;)5 c :U "t ro ('\l ;;;; .~ :::l 5 C"\ c C ~ -5 ;;2 ..l:: N 0 8 ro ro ~ro~ u ~ cb~ ~ C 0 ~ ~W:{l c:S: s ~ Vl 8'0 .:0 e-~ b 3 ~ o..ol;: '" ~ E > -3 g.. 0 ~ .: v c Il.I t. r-..... .~ u 0 ~ 0 ~ ~r:' ~ ro 'Vi.".._ V :::l,....,""6 ~~~~ '- Il.I 0\ . ~-5~~ ~S2 -;:; " ~ ~~~ -5 "f ~ ~ -" ('Ii" Q.; u ~ s ~N .:.;::: :u ~ ~ -" 5 :>:-,-- -" " ~ 3 .2 .~ ~.~ ~8 -2~ cC\~ 0 0 ";;; 0 -0 ::;, <:.J ~ ~ v .~ c ~ ~ C ro _" E';; :;; ;;;:l v Vl ;i ;2 .t: ~ ~ ~ ~ u tj .~ ZVl is fi ~ g ~~ .... "" ~ .= z ; .... " C(:J: " u i') C " -0 ~ '" 0 c ~ u ro .::: u .:0 o E ... '"' ~ ~ ~ o >. U ro C o U ;j ~ " u '" C ro ro ~, .~ E ~ ",0 -" >, f- ~ ~ 0 ."." o C ..3:! ro 1ii 0 i:i ~ C .~ v 0 U ~ ~ ~ u <: is -5 ~ r; ~ " ~ :I: ~~ ro C ~ ~ ,:; ~ ,:; a c vi .~8 ~ ""ii U"l "( ,"'"' 00 :::0 5 J., N o U"l ,;., U V d.,~ L1:~~ cw '" <: '1 N ~ N N ... N '" ,.:. ~ '" ~ ~ u ~ ~ Vl '1ii '0 o Vl ~ ~ "-~ ~ ~ -~ .. 0 -g E ~ E "'" .~ i] ..." ~~ :J:..; Vl '" o o '" ,~ ~ ~ c.. o "- ~ ,:; ." U C ',. C ',. E c o 0 ~ :.::; ....l::~ ~ C o 0 >-', U '" ~ "0- ~ ~ " ... ... ":' ~'E "" , ~ o E'E <~ Co .~ Q o;N >,.:. '1ii~ Vl'" ~ .~ ~, ~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ to -5 'on ~ ~ " Us ,:;.~ i5...~ ~ ~ C N ~ ~ -" N ",d, .5: ~ co;. ~ ro i5... ""'0 t: 2 .~ '2: ~ o ~ ~ u Vl -" c 1;-. r; E " ~ ~ ;2 ~ ~ ro 'E o , ~ &~ 'E ~;~ ~ ;: ~ (3 ro N u ~ " ~ - ~ -" ~ "'u t::S -- ~ ~ -, ." U ~ 0 ci... ~ "" 6~~ ~ e~ ~ t:: (; 1:l ~ ~~:I: =It: g-t:~-5 "'"' E ~ 0 ro g- ~ z c 0 ~ 'r;; 2at=:r= ~) C .9 1ii ~ '" C 'C ~ .2 ~ G 8 v ~ ... ,:; "':'.ri ;0 ~ N 3: d, ~ N ~ ""'r;j....l::'o U ~ ~ Q. ~ z ~ .3] o ~ "'~ s " I ~ i ~ E E ~ c9:::--9- :: ;; ~ " '" '" '" ~ Q. ~ i';. '" ~ o 9 ~ R:-v ~ ~" ,,~ '" 0 't: E .2E U ~~ o~ 'fir--:.. ~~ u'" ~ " " -;; ~ c.. " o c " u C ;> v; " o ~-v v, ~ ~" ...~ ",_E V"I bE 8, U -; u " ,.,., ro u R: Q .~ C " ~Vl ~]! ~~ ~Vl u " ..!! C\..N c.." ... U Ci N U ~ 'f f!:::lr--.. l"jl"j~ ~ ~ ~ ,r, U u ~~ ~ ." .~ u: ~ ~ ~ toO (3 -5.3: ~ ~ ~ "" ~ ~ ~ ~ ] E ,.g :!: u ,2 [;> C g ~ o ~ (i. C .9 1ii C ~ ~ '" ~ o ~ .9 o '" ~~ .9 E ro .9 .,,-" ~ ~ ~ ':': ~ ,~ ~ o >-.. ~ ~ co C ~ ~ .9 "" C '0 ~:':2 -" ~ - ~ o '> " C E 8 b> .' "0-'" E .~ " ~ c~ ~ E' SN ~ ~ u:: ~ ~ '"' ... :J: f- a C:! ;::: ;0 N . ~ = " " U ~ ~ '0 U '0 ~ ;;: '" .!l '= :J = E " " U ~ " u ~ " Vl C ~ e " :J: '" = ~ "" = " " " :J: "'" C " o u" .!;!~ =a~ UN ~ lJ 'ii E " :J: '" ~ C " :J: ~ C " " U~ b~ -'" =E~ UN c..- ~ ~ 0 V;~ gj ." 0 ... 8~Vl " u...E IU V"I -o(j~ r--..5-..o !!~~ ~~~ E!~ ",is ~ i:::';;, r:::: r--.. ::I: ~ ' u.g. ~~rs~~~~ ~~ ,....:.o:c-Oc::: :Er--..~Ou::I:u ,r,u-~E~o.~;E ~ <.... _ _ :c: .. -CUt; __ ou~-= "-,,,5 U - ... ~_Qc-;..:>o: 'S..o.o~~>~~ o~~~vivi.E ~ 6 E >, ~ v ~ ~ n. o 3 '-! ~ ~ ~ ::0 E a 0 :J: v >- C ::0 0 ~ :;: f-' Vl ~ c S 0 .>-~ ':'::' u -ro,:= ~-g ec E Q E ~ .-- :::...Q I- ~ 0.0 Z ....: c ~ -g ] ~ro E o '-..) E ~ 8 -:r; vi 2-8 u~ ." t; .~ 2= ..:.t!. i::: o 8 s: c E 0 j' ~ i o .~ ~ ~ u ~ E '.2 ..w: ;;; -c ~ 0 ....l ~ :-::