The URL can be used to link to this page

Backup Documents 01/19/2010 S (GMP)BCC GMP Meeting BACK -UP DOCUMENTS January 19, 2010 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS SPECIAL AGENDA GMP AMENDMENTS (Transmittal Hearing) January 19, 2010 9:00 a.m. 2007/2008 Cycle of Growth Management Plan Amendments (Including a 2009 Petition) Fred Coyle, BCC Chairman, District 4 Frank Halas, BCC Vice - Chairman Commissioner, District 2 (Arrived at 9:40 a.m.) Tom Henning, Commissioner, District 3 Jim Coletta, Commissioner, District 5 Donna Fiala, Commissioner, District 1 NOTE: THE BOARD INTENDS TO BREAK AT APPROXIMATELY 3:00 P.M., AND THEN WILL RECONVENE AT 5:00 P.M. TO HEAR ITEMS 2.C. AND 2.D. NOTICE: ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEMS MUST REGISTER PRIOR TO SPEAKING. SPEAKERS MUST REGISTER WITH THE COUNTY MANAGER PRIOR TO THE PRESENTATION OF THE AGENDA ITEM TO BE ADDRESSED. ALL REGISTERED SPEAKERS WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES UNLESS THE TIME IS ADJUSTED BY THE CHAIRMAN. COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2003 -53, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE 2004 -05 AND 2007 -249 REQUIRES THAT ALL LOBBYISTS SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS), REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT. Page 1 January 19, 2010 REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON SUBJECTS WHICH ARE NOT ON THIS AGENDA MUST BE SUBMITTED IN WRITING WITH EXPLANATION TO THE COUNTY MANAGER AT LEAST 13 DAYS PRIOR TO THE DATE OF THE MEETING AND WILL BE HEARD UNDER "PUBLIC PETITIONS." PUBLIC PETITIONS ARE LIMITED TO THE PRESENTER, WITH A MAXIMUM TIME OF TEN MINUTES. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY WHO NEEDS ANY ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS PROCEEDING, YOU ARE ENTITLED, AT NO COST TO YOU, TO THE PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PLEASE CONTACT THE COLLIER COUNTY FACILITIES MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT LOCATED AT 3301 EAST TAMIAMI TRAIL, NAPLES, FLORIDA, 34112, (239) 252 -8380; ASSISTED LISTENING DEVICES FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABLE IN THE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' OFFICE. 1. Pledge of Allegiance 2. Proclamation designating January 27, 2010 as International Holocaust Remembrance Day — Adopted 410 (Commissioner Halas absent) 3. 2007/2008 Combined Cycle of Growth Management Plan Amendments, including a 2009 Petition (Transmittal Hearing) A. CP- 2007 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area master Plan Future Land Use Mqp and Map Series, to create the Wilson Boulevard Conditional Uses Subdistrict, to allow a maximum of 40,000 square feet of permitted and conditional uses of the Estates zoning district, for property located on the southeast corner of Immokalee Road (CR 846) and Wilson boulevard, in Section 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±5.17 acres. [Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] Motion to continue until petitioner arrives — Approved 3/0 (Commissioner Coyle and Commissioner Halas absent); Page 2 January 19, 2010 Motion to transmit amended petition — Approved 3/2 (Commissioner Halas and Commissioner Coyle opposed) B. CP- 2007 -3, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map an d Man Series, to create the Mission Subdistrict to allow church and related uses, including schools, adult care and child care, and community outreach, with a maximum of 90,000 square feet of total development, for property located on the south side of Oil Well Road (CR 858), 1/4 miles west of Everglades Boulevard, in Section 19, Township 48 South, Range 28 East, consisting of ±21.72 acres. [Coordinator: Beth Yang, AICP, Principal Planner] Motion to transmit — Approved 4/0 (Commissioner Halas absent) C. CP- 2008 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Estates Shopping Center Subdistrict to allow a maximum of 210,000 square feet of commercial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, and some uses of the C -5 zoning district, with requirement to construct a grocery store, for property located on the north side of Golden Gate Boulevard extending from Wilson Boulevard west to 3rd Street Northwest, in Section 4, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±40.62 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, Principal Planner] [Note: To be heard when BCC reconvenes at 5:00 p.m.] Motion to continue indefinitely and place proposed amendment on the November, 2010 ballot, as a straw measure, to be voted on by the residents of Golden Gate Estates; petitioner will bear all advertising costs and costs associated with putting this amendment on the ballot Approved — 4/0 (Commissioner Coyle absent) D. CP- 2008 -2, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Mgp Series, to expand and modify the Randall Boulevard Commercial Subdistrict to allow an additional 370,950 square feet of commercial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, for property located on the south side of Randall Boulevard, extending from 8h Street Northeast west to the canal on the west side of the Big Corkscrew Island Fire Station, in Sections 26 and 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±56.5 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, Principal Planner] Page 3 January 19, 2010 [Note: To be heard when BCC reconvenes at 5:00 p.m.] Motion to transmit w /CCPC recommendations — Approved 4/0 (Commissioner Coyle absent) E. CP- 2008 -4, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Map and Mgp Series, to re- designate from Rural Fringe Mixed -Use District (RFMUD) Sending Lands to Neutral Lands for property located on the east and south sides of Washburn Avenue, east of the Naples Landfill, in Section 31, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±28.76 acres. [Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] Motion to transmit w /CCPC recommendations — Approved 5/0 F. CPSP- 2008 -7, Staff petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element to add a new Policy 4.11 pertaining to aligning planning time frames in the Growth Management Plan (GMP). [Coordinator: David Weeks, AICP, GMP Manager] Approved — 510 G. CP- 2009 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Map and Map Series (FLUE/FLUM) to create the Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area District within the Conservation Designation, for property located along the Miami - Dade /Collier County border, in Sections 13, 14, 15 &16, Township 53 South, Range 34 East, consisting of 1,608 ± acres. [Coordinator: David Weeks, AICP, GMP Manager] Motion to transmit w /amendments — Approved 4/0 (Commissioner Coyle absent) • Resolution 2010 -12: Transmitting amendments to DCA (Department of Community Affairs) — Adopted w /amendments 4. Adjourn — Consensus INQUIRIES CONCERNING CHANGES TO THE BOARD'S AGENDA SHOULD BE MADE TO THE COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING DEPARTMENT AT (239) 252 -2400. Page 4 January 19, 2010 COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA REQUEST FOR LEGAL ADVERTISING OF PUBLIC HEARINGS To: Clerk to the Board: Please place the following as a: X Normal legal Advertisement (Display Adv., location, etc.) ❑ Other: y ,uvq, r �r. Originating Dept/ Div: Comm.Dev.Serv./Planning Person: Marcia R. Kendall Date 1/04/2010 Petition No. (If none, give brief description): Growth Management Plan Amendment CP- 2007 -1, CP- 2007 -3, CP- 2007 -5, CP- 2008 -1, CP- 2008 -2, CP- 2008 -4, CPSP - 2008 -7 and CP- 2009 -1 Petitioner: (Name & Address): Robert L. Duane, Hole Mertes & Associates, 950 Encore Way, Naples, FL 34110; Robert J. Mulbere & Dwight Nadeau, RWA, Inc., 6610 Willow Park Drive, Ste. 200, Naples, FL 34109; Rich Yovanovich, of Coleman, Yovanovich, & Koester, PA, 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Naples, FL 34105, D. Wayne Arnold, Q. Grady Minor, 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, Ronald F. Nino, Vanesse- Daylor LLC 12730 New Brittany Blvd. Ste, 600, Ft. Myers, FL 33907, Timothy Hancock, Davidson Engineering, 2154 Trade Center Way, Suite 3, Naples, FL 34109, Andy McCall, Miami -Dade County, Parks & Recreation Department, 275 NW 2nd ST, 3rd Floor, Miami, FL 33128. Name & Address of any person(s) to be notified by Clerk's Office: (If more space is needed, attach separate sheet) N/A Hearing before XXX BCC BZA Other Requested Hearing Date: January 19. 2010 Based on advertisement appearing 10 -7 days before hearing. Newspaper(s) to be used: (Complete only if important): XXX Naples Daily News Other Proposed Text: (Include legal description & common location & Size: See Attached Companion petition(s), if any & proposed hearing date: N/A ❑ Legally Required Does Petition Fee include advertising cost? ❑ Yes ❑ No If Yes, what account should be charged for advertising costs: 111- 138317 - 649100 -00000 Reviewed & Approved by: Division Administrator or Designee Date miw B. s;y,.,,r.. eH<vc. N List Attachments: Advertisement Request for BCC Hearing & Associated Map DISTRIBUTION INSTRUCTIONS A. For hearings before BCC or BZA: Initiating person to complete one coy and obtain Division Head approval before submitting to County Manager. Note: If legal document is involved, be sure that any necessary legal review, or request for same, is submitted to County Attorney before submitting to County Manager. The Manager's office will distribute copies: ❑ County Manager agenda rile: to ❑ Requesting Division Clerk's Office ❑ Original B. Other hearings: Initiating Division head to approve and submit original to Clerk's Office, retaining a copy for file. FOR CLERK'S OFFICE USP p)VLYL:� 19 `LeIO 1 I 2'0 1t Date Received: L 'I4II� Date of Public hearing: Date Advertised: 1 n 2010 kendall m From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Advertisement Route Sheet - GM... kendalL m Monday, January 04, 2010 8:58 AM ( minutesandrecords @clerk.collier.fl. us) 'Patricia L. Morgan'; weeks_d; CohenRandall; brocic_m; NeetVirginia Advertisement Request 2007 -2008 Combined Cycle Transmittal GMP Amendments - BCC IT] 07-08 Trans Cycle BCC 10 7 d... l:J 2007 -2008 and 2009 BCC Ad Map.... Please process the attached, acknowledge receipt and provide confirmation of advertisement at your earliest convenience. Thank you. P.S. Hard copy is being forwarded interoffice mail to your Department w /County Manager Copy forwarded to Mary Jo Brock /County Manager office. Marcia Kendall, Senior Planner Comprehensive Planning Department 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Phone: (239)252-2387 Fax: (239)252-2946 Email: mardakendallOcolliergov.net Martha S. Vergara From: kendall_m [MarciaKendall @colliergov.net] Sent: Monday, January 04, 2010 8:58 AM To: Minutes and Records Cc: Patricia L. Morgan; Weeks, David; Cohen, Randall; Brock, Mary; NeetVirginia Subject: Advertisement Request 2007 -2008 Combined Cycle Transmittal GMP Amendments - BCC Attachments: Advertisement Route Sheet - GMP 07 -08 Amend ments0001.pdf; 07 -08 Trans Cycle BCC 10 7 day Ad_Revt.docx; 2007 -2008 and 2009 BCC Ad Map.pdf <<Advertisement Route Sheet - GMP 07 -08 Amend ments0001.pdf>> «07 -08 Trans Cycle BCC 10 7 day Ad Rev1.docx>> «2007 -2008 and 2009 BCC Ad Map.pdf>> Please process the attached, acknowledge receipt and provide confirmation of advertisement at your earliest convenience. Thank you. P.S. Hard copy is being forwarded interoffice mail to your Department w /County Manager Copy forwarded to Mary Jo Brock /County Manager office. Marcia Kendall, Senior Planner Comprehensive Planning Department 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Phone: (239)252-2387 Fax: (239)252-2946 Email: marciakendatIPcolliergov net January 19, 2010 Board of County Commissioners Public Hearing Advertising Requirements Please publish the following Advertisement and Map on Friday, January 8, 2010 and Monday, January 11, 2010, and furnish proof of publication to the attention of Marcia Kendall in the Comprehensive Planning Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Suite 400, Naples, Florida 34104. The advertisement must be a "FULL" page ad, and the headline in the advertisement must be in a type no smaller than 18 point. The advertisement must not be placed in that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear. Please reference the following on ALL Invoices: DEPARTMENT: COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING FUND & COST CENTER: 111 - 138317- 649100 -00000 PURCHASE ORDER NUMBER: 4500112358 ACCOUNT NUMBER: 068778 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER RESOLUTION Notice is hereby given that on Tuesday, January 19, 2010 in the Boardroom, 3`d Floor, Administration Building, Collier County Government Center, 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida the Board of County Commissioners will hold a public hearing to consider the Transmittal of the following County Resolution, 2007/2008 Combined Cycle of Amendments including a 2009 Petition to the Collier County Growth Management Plan. The meeting will commence at 9:00 A.M. The title of the proposed resolution is as follows: The purpose of the hearing is to consider a recommendation on amendments to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Maps and Map Series, the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map series, of the Growth Management Plan. The RESOLUTION title is as follows: RESOLUTION NO. 10- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROPOSING AMENDMENTS TO THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN, ORDINANCE 89 -05, AS AMENDED, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT, INCLUDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES, AND THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN, INCLUDING THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES; AND FURTHERMORE RECOMMENDING TRANSMITTAL OF THESE AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS. ➢ CP- 2007 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Mao and Map Series, to create the Wilson Boulevard Conditional Uses Subdistrict, to allow a maximum of 40,000 square feet of permitted and conditional uses of the Estates zoning district, for property located on the southeast corner of Immokalee Road (CR 846) and Wilson Boulevard, in Section 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of 15.17 acres. [Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] ➢ CP- 2007 -3, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Mission Subdistrict to allow church and related uses, including schools, adult care and child care, and community outreach, with a maximum of 90,000 square feet of total development, for property located on the south side of Oil Well Road (CR 858), 1/4 mile west of Everglades Boulevard, in Section 19, Township 48 South, Range 28 East, consisting of ±21.72 acres. [Coordinator: Beth Yang, AICP, Principal Planner] ➢ CP- 2008 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Estates Shopping Center Subdistrict to allow a maximum of 210,000 square feet of commercial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, and some uses of the C -5 zoning district, with requirement to construct a grocery store, for property located on the north side of Golden Gate Boulevard extending from Wilson Blvd. west to 3'd Street Northwest, in Section 4, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±40.62 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, Principal Planner] - [Note: to be heard when BCC reconvenes after 5:00 p.m.] ➢ CP- 2008 -2, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to expand and modify the Randall Boulevard Commercial Subdistrict to allow an additional 370,950 square feet of commercial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, for property located on the south side of Randall Boulevard, extending from 8'" Street Northeast west to the canal on the west side of the Big Corkscrew Island Fire Station, in Sections 26 and 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±56.5 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, Principal Planner] - [Note: to be heard when BCC reconvenes after 5:00 p.m.] ➢ CP- 2008 -4, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to re- designate from Rural Fringe Mixed -Use District (RFMUD) Sending Lands to Neutral Lands property located on the east and south sides of Washburn Avenue, east of the Naples landfill, in Section 31, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±28.76 acres. [Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] ➢ CPSP- 2008 -7, Staff Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element to add a new Policy 4.11 pertaining to aligning planning time frames in the Growth Management Plan (GMP). [Coordinator: David Weeks, AICP, Planning Manager] ➢ CP- 2009 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Map and Map Series (FLUE /FLUM), to create the Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area District within the Conservation Designation, for property located along the Miami - Dade /Collier County border, in Sections 13, 14, 15 & 16, Township 53 South, Range 34 East, consisting of 1,608± acres. [Coordinator: Thomas Greenwood, AICP, Principal Planner] All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed amendment are available for inspection at the Comprehensive Planning Department, 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M., Monday through Friday. Any questions pertaining to these documents should be directed to the Comprehensive Planning Department. (239 - 252 - 2400). Written comments filed with the Comprehensive Planning Department prior to Tuesday, January 19, 2009, will be read and considered at the public hearing. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Collier County Planning Commission with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he will need a record of that proceeding, and for such purpose he may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA DONNA FIALA, CHAIRMAN or FRED W. COYLE, CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK By: /s /Patricia Morgan Deputy Clerk (SEAL) rd T 40 S T 47 S T 40 S T 40 S T 50 S T 51 S T 52 S I T 53 S uNno] aarMOae uNno'J 3wa w a a' g n i OTT U 41 C W 10 " O p OTT u C W LL N O u _ z s °a uNnw AaaN3N w o O sy -as _ M-S W W g W N � ac w 'a s W y W + d U d U c e p ALNfIro 3?t � H d a N O � y U w Z TSB - -No 73 Q i SL-I n � 5 pp y d aWON w c�UH o- a 3� Mex'�CO a of Gulf ` COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA REQUEST FOR LEGAL ADVERTISING OF PUBLIC HEARINGS To: Clerk to the Board: Please place the following as a: X Normal legal Advertisement (Display Adv., location, etc.) ❑ Other: xs* r* am�x�r�r* e+r* x* x*+****: rx: rz��: x**. e►+ s+ s* s**** x**+ as►*****: r: r: r*** ssa+ r► �s* * *s *r *r *s * *t *� * *xx *.a *s » *r *r� *t Originating Dept/ Div: Comm.Dev.Serv./Planning Person: Marcia R. Kendall Date 1/04/2010 Petition No. (If none, give brief description): Growth Management Plan Amendment CP- 2007 -1, CP- 2007 -3, CP- 2007 -5, CP- 2008 -1, CP- 2008 -2, CP- 20084, CPSP - 2008 -7 and CP- 2009 -1 Petitioner: (Name & Address): Robert L. Duane, Hole Montes & Associates, 950 Fncore Way, Naples, FL 34110; Robert J. Mulhere & Dwight Nadeau, RWA, Inc., 6610 Willow Park Drive, Ste. 200, Naples, FL 34109; Rich Yovanovich, of Coleman, Yovanovich, & Koester, PA, 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Naples, FL 34105, D. Wayne Arnold, Q. Grady Minor, 3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, Ronald F. Nino, Vanesse- Daylor LLC 12730 New Brittany Blvd. Ste, 600, Ft. Myers, FL 33907, Timothy Hancock, Davidson. Engineering, 2154 Trade Center Way, Suite 3, Naples, FL 34109, Andy McCall, Miami -Dade County, Parks & Recreation Department, 275 NW 2nd ST, 3rd Floor, Miami, FL 33128. Name & Address of any person(s) to be notified by Clerk's Office: (If more space is needed, attach separate sheet) N/A Hearing before XXX BCC BZA Other Requested Hearing Date: January 19, 2010 Based on advertisement appearing 10 -7 days before hearing. Newspaper(s) to be used: (Complete only if important): XXX Naples Daily News Other Proposed Text: (Include legal description & common location & Size: See Attached Companion petition(s), if any & proposed hearing date: N/A ❑ Legally Required Does Petition Fee include advertising cost? ❑ Yes ❑ No If Yes, what account should be charged for advertising costs: 111- 138317- 649100 -00000 Reviewed & Approved by: i- y -av�o Division Administrator or Designee Date rn w 3" . sig"'t 1;.. Q� 4 C.t List Attachments: Advertisement Request for BCC Hearing & Associated Map DISTRIBUTION INSTRUCTIONS A. For hearings before BCC or BZA: Initiating person to complete one coy and obtain Division Head approval before submitting to County Manager. Note: If legal document is involved, be sure that any necessary legal review, or request for same, is submitted to County Attorney before submitting to County Manager. The Manager's office will distribute copies: ❑ County Manager agenda file: to ❑ Requesting Division Clerk's Office ❑ Original B. Other hearings: Initiating Division head to approve and submit original to Clerk's Office, retaining a copy for file. � »� » *+a�x- x� * * * *a *ass* spa******* x�* s* asssrrs* r* as�xsx�* r�* xxx* aax* ��*•*+* s**** mr » *x� +ts *t *rs� * * * * * * * *r +xts * *♦a� FOR CLERK'S OFFICE USE ONLY: Date Received: Date of Public hearing: Date Advertised: January 19, 2010 Board of County Commissioners Public Hearing Advertising Requirements Please publish the following Advertisement and Map on Friday, January 8, 2010 and Monday, January 11, 2010, and furnish proof of publication to the attention of Marcia Kendall in the Comprehensive Planning Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Suite 400, Naples, Florida 34104; as well as the Minutes and Records Department, 3301 Tamiami Trail E., Building F, 4ch Floor, Naples, Florida 34112. The advertisement must be a "FULL" page ad, and the headline in the advertisement must be in a type no smaller than 18 point. The advertisement must not be placed in that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear. Please reference the following on ALL Invoices: DEPARTMENT: COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING FUND & COST CENTER: 111 - 138317 - 649100 -00000 PURCHASE ORDER NUMBER: 4500112358 ACCOUNT NUMBER: 068778 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER RESOLUTION Notice is hereby given that on Tuesday, January 19, 2010 in the Boardroom, 3rd Floor, Administration Building, Collier County Government Center, 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida the Board of County Commissioners will hold a public hearing to consider the Transmittal of the following County Resolution, 2007/2008 Combined Cycle of Amendments including a 2009 Petition to the Collier County Growth Management Plan. The meeting will commence at 9:00 A.M. The title of the proposed resolution is as follows: The purpose of the hearing is to consider a recommendation on amendments to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Maps and Map Series, the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map series, of the Growth Management Plan. The RESOLUTION title is as follows: 3�Y�Il�j1[i]�1►[i� A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROPOSING AMENDMENTS TO THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN, ORDINANCE 89 -05, AS AMENDED, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT, INCLUDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES, AND THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN, INCLUDING THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES; AND FURTHERMORE RECOMMENDING TRANSMITTAL OF THESE AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS. rCP- 2007 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Wilson Boulevard Conditional Uses Subdistrict, to allow a maximum of 40,000 square feet of permitted and conditional uses of the Estates zoning district, for property located on the southeast corner of Immokalee Road (CR 846) and Wilson Boulevard, in Section 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±5.17 acres. [Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] ➢CP- 2007 -3, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Mission Subdistrict to allow church and related uses, including schools, adult care and child care, and community outreach, with a maximum of 90,000 square feet of total development, for property located on the south side of Oil Well Road (CR 858), 114 mile west of Everglades Boulevard, in Section 19, Township 48 South, Range 28 East, consisting of ±21.72 acres. [Coordinator: Beth Yang, AICP, Principal Planner] ➢CP- 2008 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Estates Shopping Center Subdistrict to allow a maximum of 210,000 square feet of commercial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, and some uses of the C -5 zoning district, with requirement to construct a grocery store, for property located on the north side of Golden Gate Boulevard extending from Wilson Blvd. west to 3rd Street Northwest, in Section 4, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±40.62 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, Principal Planner] - [Note: to be heard when BCC reconvenes after 5:00 p.m.] ➢ CP- 2008 -2, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to expand and modify the Randall Boulevard Commercial Subdistrict to allow an additional 370,950 square feet of commercial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, for property located on the south side of Randall Boulevard, extending from 8th Street Northeast west to the canal on the west side of the Big Corkscrew Island Fire Station, in Sections 26 and 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±56.5 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, Principal Planner] - [Note: to be heard when BCC reconvenes after 5:00 p.m.] ➢CP- 2008 -4, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to re- designate from Rural Fringe Mixed -Use District (RFMUD) Sending Lands to Neutral Lands property located on the east and south sides of Washburn Avenue, east of the Naples landfill, in Section 31, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±28.76 acres. [Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] ➢CPSP- 2008 -7, Staff Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element to add a new Policy 4.11 pertaining to aligning planning time frames in the Growth Management Plan (GMP). [Coordinator: David Weeks, AICP, Planning Manager] ➢CP- 2009 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Map and Map Series (FLUE /FLUM), to create the Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area District within the Conservation Designation, for property located along the Miami - Dade /Collier County border, in Sections 13, 14, 15 & 16, Township 53 South, Range 34 East, consisting of 1,608± acres. [Coordinator: Thomas Greenwood, AICP, Principal Planner] All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed amendment are available for inspection at the Comprehensive Planning Department, 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M., Monday through Friday. Any questions pertaining to these documents should be directed to the Comprehensive Planning Department. (239- 252 - 2400). Written comments filed with the Comprehensive Planning Department prior to Tuesday, January 19, 2009, will be read and considered at the public hearing. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Collier County Planning Commission with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he will need a record of that proceeding, and for such purpose he may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Department, located at 3301 Tamiami Trail East, Building W, Naples, Florida 34112, (239) 252 -8380. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the County Commissioners' Office. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA DONNA FIALA, CHAIRMAN or FRED W. COYLE, VICE - CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK By: /s /Patricia Morgan Deputy Clerk (SEAL) M T 46 S T 47 S T 46 S T 49 S T 50 S T 51 S T 52 S I T 53 S A1NfgJ atltlMOtl9 A NnOO 30va Y O ry s CL U C W m m m Q u L. o 3 W W LL N _= Om s u uNnOO ♦Wo H m 6Z —tl5 6Z a Q 62 —LS .9,. U � N� l N A1NnOJ IT S �(y a� A vF tV \ IS6 —b5 i)L 1" d � 0 d IYr N 11 - y yw �kg O � 3 MextiO� of Gulf oz„ gsk Acct. #068778 January 4, 2010 Legals Naples News Media Group 1100 Immokalee Road Naples, Florida 34110 Re: 2007, 2008 and 2009 Cycle Growth Management Plan Amendments (CP- 2001 -1, CP- 2007 -3, CP- 2007 -5, CP- 2008 -1, CP- 2008 -2, CP- 2008 -4, CPSP- 2008 -7, and CP- 2009 -1) Dear Legals: Please publish the following Advertisement and Map on Friday, January 8, 2010, and again on Monday, January 11, 2010. This advertisement should be a full page advertisement and the headline in the advertisement should be in a type no smaller than 18 point. The advertisement should not be placed in that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear. Kindly send the Affidavit of Publication, in duplicate, with charges involved to the Minutes & Records Department. Thank you. Sincerely, Martha Vergara, Deputy Clerk P.O. #4500112358 Martha S. Vergara From: Pagan, Emely [EPagan @Naplesnews.com] Sent: Tuesday, January 05, 2010 12:07 PM To: Martha S. Vergara Subject: RE: GMP Amendment 2007, 2008 &2009 ok From: Martha S. Vergara [ mailto: Martha.Vergara @collierclerk.com] Posted At: Tuesday, January 05, 2010 11:56 AM Posted To: Legals - NDN Conversation: GMP Amendment 2007, 2008 &2009 Subject: GMP Amendment 2007, 2008 &2009 Lega Is, Please advertise the following attached ad on Friday. January 8. and January 11, 2010. Please send an ok when you receive. Martha Vergara, Deputy Clerk Clerk to the Board of County Commissioners Minutes and Records Department 239- 252 -7240 239-252 -8408 fax (martha.verga ra @col lierclerk.com ) Please visit us on the web at www.colliereferk.com This electronic communication is confidential and may contain privileged information intended solely for the named addressee(s). It may not be used or disclosed except for the purpose for which it has been sent. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not copy, distribute or take any action induced by or in reliance on information contained in this message. Unless expressly stated, opinions in this message are those of the individual sender and not of the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the Clerk's Office by emailing helodesk@collierclerk.com quoting the sender and delete the message and any attached documents. The Collier County Clerk's Office accepts no liability or responsibility for any onward transmission or use of emails and attachments having left the CollierClerk.com domain. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Martha S. Vergara From: Pagan, Emely [EPagan @Naplesnews.com] Sent: Tuesday, January 05, 2010 3:17 PM To: Martha S. Vergara Subject: RE: GMP Amendment 2007, 2008 &2009 COST $9,021.39 From: Martha S. Vergara [ mai Ito: Martha.Vergara @collierclerk.com] Posted At: Tuesday, January 05, 2010 11:56 AM Posted To: Legals - NDN Conversation: GMP Amendment 2007, 2008 &2009 Subject: GMP Amendment 2007, 2008 &2009 Legals, Please advertise the following attached ad on Friday. January 8, and January 11, 2010. Please send an ok when you receive. Martha Vergara, Deputy Clerk Clerk to the Board of County Commissioners Minutes and Records Department 239- 252 -7240 239- 252 -8408 fax (ma rtha.verga ra(�:bcol lierclerk.com ) Please visit us on the web at www.colliercierk.com This electronic communication is confidential and may contain privileged information intended solely for the named addressee(s). It may not be used or disclosed except for the purpose for which it has been sent. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not copy, distribute or take any action induced by or in reliance on information contained in this message. Unless expressly stated, opinions in this message are those of the individual sender and not of the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the Clerk's Office by emailing helodeskCalcollierclerk.com quoting the sender and delete the message and any attached documents. The Collier County Clerk's Office accepts no liability or responsibility for any onward transmission or use of emails and attachments having left the Coll ierClerk. com domain. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e -mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. NAPLESBONITA DAILY NEWS Published Daily Naples, FL 34102 Affidavit of Publication State of Florida County of Collier Before the undersigned they serve as the authority, per! appeared Phil Lewis, who on oath says that he serves as the Editor of the Naples Daily, a daily new! published at Naples, in Collier County, Florida; distl in Collier and Lee counties of Florida; that the attached of the advertising, being a PUBLIC NOTICE in the matter of PUBLIC NOTICE was published in said newspaper on January 8 & 11, 2010 times in the issue Affiant further says that the said Naples Daily News is a newspaper published at Naples, in said Collier County, Florida, and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida, each day and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Naples, in said Collier County, Florida, for a period of I vmr next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and atfant further says that he has neither paid nor promised anv person, firm or corporation any discount. rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for pubh the said newspaper. 77.7'0 ( Signature of affiant) Sworn to and subscribed before me This 13th day of January, 2010 Hawid I° G (Signature of notary ublicy IM—A-3 7"3341+) KAROL E KANGAS Notary Public - State of Florida ',. MY Comm. Expires Jul 29. 2013 ';Fyn nso Commission # DO 912237 IM—A-3 7"3341+) RESOLUTION NO. 10- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PRO- POSING AMENDMENTS TO THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN, ORDINANCE 89 -05, AS AMENDED, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT, INCLUDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES, AND THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN, INCLUDING THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES;.AND FURTHERMORE RECOMMENDING TRANSMITTAL OF THESE AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF COM- MUNITY AFFAIRS. U CP- 2007 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master. Plan and Golden - Gate Master Plan Future_ Land_ Use Mapand Mao Series, to create the Wilson Boulevard Conditional Uses Subdistrict, to allow a maximum of 40,000 square feet of permitted and conditional uses of the Estates zoning district, for property located on the southeast corner of Immokalee Road (CR 846) and Wilson Boulevard, in Section 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±5.17 acres. [Coordinator: Corby Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] U CP- 2007 -3, Petition requesting an amendment to the _Golden Gate Area Master_Plan and __Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Mission Subdistrict to allow church and related uses, including schools, adult care and child care, and community outreach, with a maximum of 90,000 square feet of total development, for property located on the south side of Oil Well Road (CR 858), 1/4 mile west of Everglades Boulevard, in Section 19, Township 48 South, Range 28 East, consisting of ±21.72 acres. [Coordinator: Beth Yang, AICP, Principal Planner] U CP- 2008 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan and Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, to create the Estates Shopping Center Subdistrict to allow a maximum of 210,000 square feet of commer- cial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, and some uses of the C -5 zoning district, with requirement to construct a grocery store, for property located on the north side of Golden Gate Boulevard extending from Wilson Blvd. west to 3rd Street Northwest, in Section 4, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of 140.62 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, Principal Planner] - [Note: to be heard when BCC reconvenes after 5:00 p.m.] U CP- 2008 -2, Petition requesting an amendment to the G41denGate Area Master_Plan and_Qolde_n_Gate Area Master Plan Future Land_ Use Map and Map Series, to expand and modify the Randall Boulevard Commercial Subdistrict to allow an additional 370,950 square feet of commercial uses of the C -4 zoning district, with exceptions, for property located on the south side of Randall Boulevard, ex- tending from 8th Street Northeast west to the canal on the west side of the Big Corkscrew Island Fire Station, in Sections 26 and 27, Township 48 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±56.5 acres. [Coordinator: Michele Mosca, AICP, 'Principal Planner] - [Note: to be heard when BCC reconvenes after 5:00 p.m.] U CP- 2008 -4, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land ._Use _Mar) and Map Series, to re- designate from Rural Fringe Mixed -Use District (RFMUD) Sending Lands to Neutral Lands property located on the east and south sides of Washburn Avenue, east of the Naples landfill, in Section 31, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, consisting of ±28.76 acres. [Coordinator: Corby.Schmidt, AICP, Principal Planner] U CPSP- 2008 -7, Staff Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element to add a new Policy 4.11 pertaining to align- ing planning time frames in the Growth Management Plan (GMP). [Coordinator: David Weeks, AICP, Planning Manager] U CP- 2009 -1, Petition requesting an amendment to the Future Land Use Element and Future Land Use Mapand Map Seres (FLUE/ FLUM), to create the Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area District within the Conservation Designation, for property located along the Miami - Dade /Collier County border, in Sections 13, 14, 15 & 16, Township 53 South, Range 34 East, consisting of 1,608± acres. [Coordinator: Thomas Greenwood, AICP, Principal Planner] All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed amendment are available for inspection at the Comprehensive Planning Department, 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M., Monday through Friday. Any ques- tions pertaining to these documents should be directed to the Comprehensive Planning Department. (239 -2.52- 2400). Written comments filed with the Comprehensive Planning Department prior to Tuesday, January 19, 2010, will be read and considered at the public hearing. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Board of County Commissioners with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he will need a record of that proceeding, and for such purpose he may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Department, located at 3301 Tamiami Trail East, Building W, Naples, Florida 34112, (239) 252 -8380. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the County Commissioners' Office. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA DONNA FIALA, CHAIRMAN or FRED W. COYLE, VICE- CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK, By: /s /Patricia Morgan, Deputy Clerk (SEAL) No 231157235 __.. __. _. __ _.. January 8, 11.E 2010 Z Collier County �� Fl orldn r e o I d ooa. f � � All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed amendment are available for inspection at the Comprehensive Planning Department, 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M., Monday through Friday. Any ques- tions pertaining to these documents should be directed to the Comprehensive Planning Department. (239 -2.52- 2400). Written comments filed with the Comprehensive Planning Department prior to Tuesday, January 19, 2010, will be read and considered at the public hearing. If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Board of County Commissioners with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he will need a record of that proceeding, and for such purpose he may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Department, located at 3301 Tamiami Trail East, Building W, Naples, Florida 34112, (239) 252 -8380. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the County Commissioners' Office. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA DONNA FIALA, CHAIRMAN or FRED W. COYLE, VICE- CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK, By: /s /Patricia Morgan, Deputy Clerk (SEAL) No 231157235 __.. __. _. __ _.. January 8, 11.E 2010 MEMORANDUM Date: January 22, 2010 To: Marcia Kendall, Senior Planner Comprehensive Planning From: Teresa Polaski, Deputy Clerk Minutes & Records Department Re: Resolution 2010 -12 Enclosed please find one (1) copy of the above referenced documents approved by the Board of County Commissioners on Tuesday, January 19, 2010. If you have any questions, please call me at 252 -8411. Thank you. Enclosures RESOLUTION NO. 10- 12 A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROPOSING AMENDMENTS TO THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN, ORDINANCE 89 -05, AS AMENDED, SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT, INCLUDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES, AND THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN, INCLUDING THE GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN FUTURE LAND USE MAP AND MAP SERIES, AND FURTHERMORE TRANSMITTING THESE AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS. WHEREAS, Collier County, pursuant to Section 163.3161, et. seg., Florida Statutes, the Florida Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act, was required to prepare and adopt a comprehensive plan; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners adopted the Collier County Growth Management Plan on January 10, 1989; and WHEREAS, the Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act of 1985 provides authority for local governments to amend their respective comprehensive plans and outlines certain procedures to amend adopted comprehensive plans pursuant to Sections 163.3184 and 163.3187, Florida Statutes; and WHEREAS, Collier County has prepared plan amendments to the following elements of its Growth Management Plan: Future Land Use Element, including the Future Land Use Map and Map Series, Golden Gate Area Master Plan, including the Golden Gate Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map and Map Series, and WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission has considered the proposed amendments to the Growth Management Plan pursuant to the authority granted to it by Section 163.3174, Florida Statutes, and has made recommendations on said amendments to the Board of County Commissioners; and Words underlined are additions; Words stcdsk4hreu0 are deletions WHEREAS, upon receipt of Collier County's proposed Growth Management Plan amendments, various State agencies and the Department of Community Affairs (DCA) have sixty (60) days to review the proposed amendment and DCA must transmit, in writing, to Collier County, its comments along with any objections and any recommendations for modification, within said sixty (60) days pursuant to Section 163.3184, Florida Statutes; and WHEREAS, Collier County, upon receipt of the written comments from DCA must adopt, adopt with changes or not adopt the proposed Growth Management Plan amendments, within sixty (60) days of such receipt pursuant to Section 163.3184, Florida Statutes; and WHEREAS, the DCA, within forty -five (45) days of receipt of Collier County's adopted Growth Management Plan amendments, must review and determine if the Plan amendments are in compliance with the Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Act of 1985; the State Comprehensive Plan; the appropriate Regional Policy Plan and Rule 9J -5, Florida Administrative Code, pursuant to Section 163.3184, Florida Statutes. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, THAT: The Board of County Commissioners hereby approves the proposed Growth Management Plan amendments, attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated by reference herein, for the purpose of transmittal to the Department of Community Affairs thereby initiating the required State evaluation of the Growth Management Plan amendments, prior to final adoption and State determination of compliance with the Local Government Comprehensive Planning and Land Development Regulation Act of 1985 and Rule 9J -5, Florida Administrative Code, Minimum Criteria for Review of Local Government Comprehensive Plans and Determination of Compliance. Words underlined are additions; Words stFUSk thFOug# are deletions 2 THIS RESOLUTION ADOPTED after motion, second and majority vote this 19th day of January, 2010. ATTEST: DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk urY tfiii.� Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA mow' BY: FRED W. COYLE, CHAIRMAN d\L d' u eidi Ashton - Cicko, Assistant County Attorney Land Use Section Chief CP- 2007 -1, CP- 2007 -3, CP- 2008 -2, CP- 2008 -4, CPSP- 2008 -7 and CP- 2009 -1 GMP Transmittal Resolution Words underlined are additions; Words StFUGk thFGugp are deletions N PROCLAMATION WHEREAS, in a resolution co- sponsored by the 104 Member States, the United Nations General Assembly has designated January 9th as International Holocaust Remembrance Day in an effort to keep memory of the Holocaust alive, and to reaffirm unfaltering resolve to prevent the recurrence of such crimes and future acts of genocide; and WHEREAS, January 27 1945, remembrance for l day when an od camp, Ausc - WHEREAS, Collier WHEREAS, NOW DONE AND ORDERED ATTEST: -. 1 .� is currently recognized as the official day of olocaS* ims in many countries and marks the m, of �4oythe[ aching th�htcry M ��ro'Q�PIRS� tied ,ky th"e)9e6ord of 19 ; t , January 27, the largest Nazi death the grievous wr the tolerance and he Holocaust DAY s of as BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA FRED COYLE, CHAIRMAN EXHIBIT A GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN CP- 2007 -1 Policy 1.1.2 [Page 4] The ESTATES Future Land Use designation shall include Future Land Use Districts and Subdistricts for: A. ESTATES — MIXED USE DISTRICT 1. Residential Estates Subdistrict 2. Neighborhood Center Subdistrict 3. Conditional Uses Subdistrict f. Wilson Boulevard Conditional Uses Subdistrict 4. Golden Gate Parkway Institutional Subdistrict 2. ESTATES DESIGNATION A. Estates — Mixed Use District 3. Conditional Uses Subdistrict [Pages 27 -32] f) Wilson Boulevard Conditional Uses Subdistrict This Subdistrict is located at the southeast corner of the Wilson Boulevard/Immokalee Road process will be governed by the following criteria: 1_ The maximum gross floor area of all uses shall be limited to 40,000 square feet 2. Driveways and curb cuts shall be limited to right -in /right -out turning movements only. 3. Projects directly abutting Estates zoned Property shall provide at a minimum a 75- foot buffer of 4. A twenty -five (25) foot wide landscape strip shall be Provided along the entire frontage of both Immokalee Road and Wilson Boulevard 5. Building heights shall be limited to two (2) stories and a maximum zoned height of thirty -five (35) feet. 6. All lighting shall be architecturally designed and limited to a heiqht of _twenty -five (25) feet. Such Words underlined are added; words skask-thmugh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( "' "' . "') denotes break in text. 34 CP- 2007 -1 34 FUTURE LAND USES MAP SERIES [added next in order] Golden Gate Area Master Plan Study Areas Golden Gate Area Future Land Use Map High Density Residential Subdistrict 1989 Boundaries of Activity Center Downtown Center Commercial Subdistrict Commercial Western Estates Infill Subdistrict Golden Gate Parkway Interchange Conditional Uses Area Golden Gate Parkway Institutional Subdistrict Wilson Boulevard Conditional Uses Subdistrict CP- 2007 -1 Exhibit A post CCPC — David 12 -11 -09 GAComprehensive \COMP PLANNING GMP DATA \Comp Plan Amendments\2007 -2008 Combined Cycle Petitions\2007 Cycle Petitions \CP - 2007 -1 Wilson Blvd Commercial Subdistdct 2 Words underlined are added; words etsask *FGugh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. I� F i m .n !F m F LEGEND W.VI OIwOXA.T. E!T.... RYWN1TgM ow El o , ■A� mw ■w�.�� -.. ■x aAA.ww.muz—I _w ouY.w m.ueu __ ■ im.`."amm .nv ❑nm.amamx. �°'Oi AaecunwumwAE oEwaunoR w6An AM VEG.V. ffyATUEB SCALE: Z. PS /GO unPPwG SECPON pOE.£�[eNENi AXO EuxPwu[ xiµ YpNtt2 MmSw OAIE:0N3 /ROW Illl: CP- EOOi -I.OWL 1226E I ? R27E OR NVA GOLDEN GATE AREA FUTURE LAND USE MAP WMOKALEE ROAD R 28 F. 34 el J ) F q Wq _ z w a JF C F U_ A'. F o Q uj coo Q 00 W 6 � a C z w aaan31moe eosI O F Z Z Q W U U a Q � a C o ,> U W 0 GO z 0 C14 W 3 a �a Fin �5 a� Ab ZK� S Eby c m W 1 u� m U o 0 N a s EXHIBIT A GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN CP- 2007 -3 38 Policy 1.1.2.: The ESTATES Future !Land Use Designation shall include Future Land Use Districts and Subdistricts for: [Page 4] A. ESTATES -MIXED USE DISTRICT 1. Residential Estates Subdistrict 2. Neighborhood Center Subdistrict 3. Conditional Use Subdistrict 4. Golden Gate Parkway Institutional Subdistrict 5. Mission Subdistrict * ** * ** Y #Y 4Y4 * ** 44Y # *4 * ** Y44 * ** *Y# Y #4 [Page 27] A. Estates -Mixed Use District * *Y YYY *4* * #* YY* * ** 444 * ** Y44 4 ** # ** #4* [Page 33] 5. Mission Subdistrict The Mission Subdistrict is located on the south side of Oil Well Road approximately one- guarter mile west of Everglades Boulevard and consists of 21.72 acres The purpose of this Subdistrict is to provide for churches and related uses including community outreach. The following uses are allowed: a) Churches b) Child care centers — must be not - for - profit and affiliated with a church within the Subdistrict. c) Private schools — must be not - for - profit and affiliated with a church within the Subdistrict. d) Individual and family social services (activity centers elderly or handicapped only; day rarer rantarc adult and hnnriirnnnnri nnly\ — hn nro_t..r_nr^l# A e) Medical outreach to the community, to include activities such as administering Soup kitchens and homeless shelters are prohibited in this Subdistrict 1 Words underlined are added; words sNask tgredgh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** 4 ** * * *) denotes break in text. CP- 2007 -3 designed to be comoatible with the existing, and allowed future development in the surrounding area. In the alternate to the foregoing uses, measures of development intensity, and development standards this Subdistrict may be developed with single family dwellings in accordance with the Residential Estates Subdistrict. Property adjacent to this Subdistrict shall not qualify for the Transitional Conditional Use FUTURE LAND USE MAP SERIES Golden Gate Area Master Plan Study Areas Golden Gate Area Future Land Use Map Golden Gate Parkway Institutional Subdistrict Mission Subdistrict : :• r: r::r x *� :tt Exhibit A CP- 2007 -3 revised per CCPC recommendation - David 12 -10 -09 G: \Comprehensive \COMP PLANNING GMP DATA \Comp Plan Amendments \2007 -2008 Combined Cycle Petitions12007 Cycle Petitions \CP - 2007 -3 Mission Subdistrict Words underlined are added; words are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. • F F A LEGEND LRAMYONW1NM AYYd41MNAMK fEPV1ATtlM �rd. mlr rnn �mnx. mm �vlai Q'un inm..w sm+ �wCUMpiW� owiun Uo ■ ulnr� M.� mom. °� o S F a a F c m 0 N F OI b F e M •i4 fl LudOC N6xRl ruEMp AYEx[d uaWm �rcaax �•. am O� GOLDEN GATE AREA FUTURE LAND USE MAP QOdQKAL MAn JbNLL 0 � MI. 2 MI. } MI. ♦ Ml 5 MI. M uI CC MI( H M NT "D p m MCp mm9 DA W; RU9 Y E/ N - M -TOW R 26E I. R27E R28E A 0 0 N d U Z O H a m X w rn N m N • U Q WQ w mQ .w7 � -T F s o� Vw �5 NI yp0 ail og <a ?i X04 m °S wik rc°a � � N N abvA3inos SMVIO?OA3 F A a0 rn o C4 W N w w � z U m O o M W o U LLJ W o 3 ~C:) N U CV o =(n d U U ` N 948 !10 OVOH 331VNOWWI r � O N N N 021tlA3if10S NOSIIM • U Q WQ w mQ .w7 � -T F s o� Vw �5 NI yp0 ail og <a ?i X04 m °S wik rc°a C 3 D O O D m m o X m 0 C C O m D FN+ 0 3 Z_ Z_ 7 O 70 O z W�o O D O O Z 0 3 3 o 0 D V p m m �_ 3 3 ... •G �_ n 3 m 3 m O z m 3 m 3 v' m 0: CL rt m r+ H C v m '+ N C v m N S, D D o °o m ^ -00 z 00 0 o co m 3 N (DD rt d N 90 O V O m G. O m O N W N N I..� W N W �O U'I O -< V O 01 V V N W 0) 00 W F- p Ol N O F" Ln W F� N F+ O N � O O Nj f�D Lo W N W 1.0 W L' Ui aOO O F� W N N N LO F+ -4 0 l0 O N V V N 00 W N O -s 00 W w C oj .x f CL s n w .r G -0 D Z N Z O 3 m O O fl? p C Z C Z_ � O o 0 N N C � O 3 N teo -a r 3 N C 3 cD Q. v g Z°. v 3 (D w -I O O O 7 a '+ m CL Z jV � O CD v O O Ln c O O m O rt °+ W r (-) m O F o C O Z CA0�0 Ol (D -0 D Z N Z 0 m m m D O � � N C � O N CL co D 07 G7 -I O O O 3 a '+ m M Z jV � O CD v O O Ln c O O O O rt °+ W N (-) m O F o m O CA0�0 Ol (D ((DD rt 3 3 3 7 C m D z CA p Q- m N m W cu Z 4�N UI (D 3 'i v — O — W 7 W Ln CL Ln (n O N S T Ln r cu C W K 0000 O O ' 3C D N N m U1 N D � � N C � O N CL W D G7 -I S. o O m a '+ m M Z jV � O CD v = `D Ln O O rt °+ W 1 (-) m O F o m O Ol (D ((DD rt 7 m D z CA Q- N m W cu 4�N N N U1 N W !.� O N W 0) jV � O CD O O O W w a1 O O Ol lD N W w 4�N UI 'i O W F'' W Ln Ln (n O N Ln cu W 0000 O O O l0 0) N 3c o K n O O 0 D m m Q n CD D 3 O 2 W O C C — O 00 O^ Z_ Z_ 3 0 0 a 70 CL o 0 o 0 o O O 3• F 0 o 'a cn cn 3 N v v O v, a N t3 a H 3 v 3 � y 0 v 0 z v 3 W00 a Cm mfD �� -a C3 m3 ro ) � �3 33 cn0 v ' v O O .X �• �• cu N 'a 4a 3 M a) CL m r+ 00 < W 3 S Q N X N N V7 N W V O co O Ln 00 N O W l0 01 O O �l C1 l0 N W Vl O (II1 F.a rcy) (WJI r W N O Ln rD cu a)i N 0000 O O 0 to N 3C 3 ?3\ \ \\ \ § \ / 0 \ o G @\ c , $ k )\ m } \7> ) g =/3 . § 0 X-0 \ . C)0 m \ \\ CO 2 \: 2 g - co { 0 m z >w -n 33> g 3) 0 2/\ ) ? \% \ \\ m 5 % o }c ) \ )\\ �// rn m 222 j ��\ \\\ / § > > >m0 § \05 \ }m \0\ ? < \ § ® \@ / > 3 7 \ % / \ 2 ) \ �£ g \ \ r R \ \ 0 \ Q \ 3 $ X r rn 0 / \ � \ \ ) \ / § ) f \ \ ) \ k g ■E \ G�l / # § j \ / � k } } } j # a j a ( ) \ \ / \7 m 03 2 ; o:% , .. ; z\\ z _ $ .§ § moo & 0 \ j -4 \ \ -n =g& 3 \ -0 \R � < c>( % g m31 \\\ j 0 $\ -4 \/\ 00 \ j I \\ / 2\a \z£ ��> o {/m x _ n GO(0 m 3 - % EMz § 2 �$ k Cl) Cl) �� j u > Cl) y ) j R >m( k /o` co \®� ] ®�> \ §8/ m \+ § \ ) j \� § ,«2+ \ § A \ ( m § � im k k � \ q ) � CD >2 / \0 / cz m \ }\ } / \z � =/z \ 0o\ j /A\ m -mom 2 }}/ a m _ 7 ) \/\ \ \ / } \c // : _ \\ 0 \ \\\ z C�> > \ }\ 9 °/0 \ =m± 0 \ \} ƒ /%/ ` 2 / \\ / 3 \ o \/\ { «p/ 2 X /2 /ae n !2j \ �M/ co U) \\ } z e m 0 } m _ \ OR § .q 0 }J z m \ } > 0 m / } g k � } 0 § / 0 x0 \ \{ 3/ Q / \ P \ Co / j \ Q m \ m 7 m § � � 9 0 � � � i� z m \ � a � � � a x m r m v 0 -i S S m m W z c m T O S O c x n m Z 1 v D z v n m O D 0 v x m N v O z r x rn n x D —o m o r ci O c m D g -D Z n O P O C Z CZ c�� < m O O (n -I 3 y r_ O zo n 73 m z m o m ° -° o 0 0 00 J m a N v m A � m m m M O O M m M A CO s' O = D r 7J > O C, > O O r � T r - � r O O < D j C) N Oz O = —{ D C z C r m O m m z m Wmo c (n m � m r - O Z z m G) O G') D C G) W m Z C) O 1 � z C = z Dm0 �nw D m < Tf z 7, G) n n o n Z D W m �u O rn M D co 33 - o T rD M z m D m m m U) m Z _ Z c m O z m x m S m O v\ I� "CJ a r D m m O v r m m m v T O z 1 S rn D r" r m V r m cn D m m .D x Z --I n r m D S r im O m z 0 D mm r m m h O m z v D m m 9 Z c ca m m n U.1 a 0 O c D m m r m m 0 O S m m rn I z c m m N T O m O C n O m m 2 1 N D Z 0 D m m O D 0 0 m m N N O z r m m n x a -i =z0 m n r 0c_ 0 0 m n D z ° � O c c z c � m O O C() � :u n r_ ° o -q n DJ m Z m ° m 0 o z � - O cO 0 O 0 O J u Cl) A D cn 7u m M O c M z 33 M m A CO � M O D r m -j ou 00 D m T r r O m S Z { D { � Cl) 0 C O O = -i n r 3) c r M m o 37 Z m Wmo c m m cn m ° m z z m O - 2 w �A wmz ' � z m = z y m O �nm y m { ]7 Z n r o n _ < Z m -� D W m �o O cn D ° -n r> m v m m N m Z z m m m O z m �o z D m m i O 0 m m N Cf.) 0 S G am-I v r D m m 0 O v r m m m O m O z S m W r m v r m a N m M z 1 n r m D i. N m z 0 a -I m r m W Q im O m z 0 a m 9 z ca c 3 m m e 0 O C D M M _r M m v 0 x M M M I z c 1 M T O O C M n O M M Z N D z v D M M O D v v M M U) O z r x M n 2 D --i '= 0 z z moo W r 0 m D 7J Z n O L� O c c C { m o O CO --A D r_ O O iz D 37 m z m o m 0 0 Z x- O O D rnoo 0 O V m U A i z m E: O p M Z = -5 m m m A O 2 n 0 D O O r ?J T r O W C W D { 2 � � SON O 0 = IUD 33 Cl) Z m m o Z O c :0 33 CO m O m Z z m O p 2 D O co m Z 0 77 O 1 z C/) T Z y m O SOW D r < m T z �TO D O o zm� n W m O rn m D N o D r -{ M Z M D 70 m M N .. M z z M m 1 � O z m M ' n r� c 0 •O M 5 N N O x M M _ I^ v: r 0 M 0 O v r M 1 M v T O O z 2 M D W r M r M 1 O T 2 M v D Z 2 M W O D 0 0 M O O O 0 O -i x M C m M M n w M z O 2 M D v M D N M D Z n r M D 3] r O M z v D 1 M r M FM O M z v D M m 9 Z c M m f � 1 S � '� O M \(\ / Vic\ m \ \\ E / §/ =/J 0 \ 0 =Ao m °/� 2 }// 2 m - m \0 } m 00 \ ° \// $ _\\ \ \§\ iz § / \\ > mom ° _/» \ m /- / - > °°° \ \ \\ } co z j/\ < /pm /`33 e ;3 o >o $ z m> Fn co co 30 /\ m U) \ m / G § m � \ � � � � d / } § § \ \ § 7 I > n \ m ( / -y / r-" \� � � cu m ,\ 2 \ m m j / m P m \ j / � w_-q m \ j »� 5-A, im \ m \ m 2« � D� � //7 >(\ / �\\ m \ \\ \ )k{ m m 0 \5/. / }/ ro 2 }\/ 2 m - k 7 m 50 \ 2 >2 2 00 o \om + _\\ / 0 o, § kk� ® o n mom 2 _/» ) m (� ( o /}> \ > u4- 8 \ 9 3� / = 27> ] ,2} / j/\ < =nm mwa= n fJA \ /// F M> \\ . .. m § j m \ § / m > n q 7 ƒ ~\ j R. m M. ) � 2 m . 9 2 f m \: > j ; m / § / / � j } m w { \ � o ` J ��® ® m m U) \ } k al M \ � / C3 0 0 c D x m _r 3 mm O 0 O -i x m m m w z c m m N O 0 O C 0 O m m 2 N D z O D x m O D v v m m N N O z x m n x D m n O ci p C m D D Z C7 o G) O c z C < Z m O O C/) -1 m D r_ O ° - D m Z Jml ° m O p Z 17 - O ° D cn0o o O v 7] m m A M Cf) m j Z O iz O c m M A 0 o= D p p m m r r O m 2 Z { 3n Cl) Oz O = { 3 D C r � � r m Z O m Z m W m O C 37 7J cn m 0- ° z z m 0 D U) O w m Z � z � = z T < y O �Om D m < � � Z > 0 D D O p r 1 � Z m �o O ti M D o r D Vol m v x m N m z z O m _I O Z m R le 1 x m 9 z D m m "R I, v 0 m r D m m 0 O v r m m m v m O 9 O z x m D r- r m Z r m mm Z m z C r m D r D O m z v m im O m z v D m m z c co m m x A� ( V C} -b a / \? > )/o / « @\ m \ \\ \ )q> m = \j G eem / /z/ m 0\/ 2 } \m 7 m E ))/ -n }/? m 00 a \// > \ CO \\\ @ C > m0w ° ° _ /» \ m /- o /(/ > 999 m \ \\ z j\\ \ten@ \// e ;e 2 \oj / zm/ m> \\ m m cn \e � � m c \ m § � � n )} m ) k \ m k I Q > j m co .. § . �_ d m CD \ � / 0 y � \ 0 \ m / m / 4 , / m § \ cn \ \ / m \ \ / \ { @ (A. � �o � \\/ ?Ek )\\ 0 3@Q m \ \\ \ 0� \ ) = z \ m (/\ \\m \2j } <5@ c 2 - 4 / \\ / //} g 00 r- ?3 o %// g =37 0 /)§ ) \/\ § C: > )\ \ \ �)\ m ��z { \o f \\ \ m (j\ a ? %rn\ 40= \ \\} ^ m ® / 0 /So ) Zm7:i \o Fn R ) \ § m m m 2 § \ V � a � 7 G i m m � / \ 2 \ \ \ G \ \ % m M *m � \ k m `2- § � � w / 0 m I m q m � A / � M \ 2 @ 2 � m z i m \ / m \ } ) m � k �G � e � �a � / ch \ § \ im ( ; / � k �b MIC ¢� \� � � � \ f § } \ � \ � . � � M0 / 3E\ k f 0 \ § ® @ / ?) ®) z e n » g(g.2 ; \ $\ j \ m m . ) 0o i�9 z m >co / 2 23e k ; - k »�( I \/ 0 \ (\\ \ \ a \/§ § g =5` \ n ®)J ; 9 °°C, gmm . § o § ) c )_© 9 / ) » m0m = ! \a)m \ > 0 C() ° ( > ° \ m :> \ M \ j \\ k » ;rm ] GGz b \00 3 § 0 % \/� § )?) \ / ch \ § \ im ( ; / � k �b MIC ¢� \� � � � \ f § } \ � \ � . � � /7\ UD o \\ / Z / \ \\ i /)/ / 7/3 2 \2/ e woe \ °m \ } }/ (/\ n \// / \ \ } / \/} \ I/\ \ }\\ 2 // z /gym / °/0 ] # `- + 0 \}> > CO - e@ m \ \\ \ > co 0 » »»m X \// /ao 2 »0j / \/\ j/ = y 2 G / z / g . « _ m § 7 / @ § \.J �p 2 / § I § m \ § 2 \ � e \ / \ \ 2 \ § \ \ k K \ P / / j / � > \ \ 2 T ( 2 \ / m : � \ / K) , a zl� ~ (� � aao m / =j/ � \ \ @ \\ / \ {§ § \ � g- 0 = J $ . c c / »j/ j \ > Q a `&# z ) 7»G § C) //z o « \ 0 j\/ 0 \ q m A <oc S / $ \ y0 X \3 0 //S ¥ ¢\f o =«9 2 f/% \ �)- ; 7- f »Z0 0 7 \} m \m rn w gg> a %r` c rn 3 \ \\ \ o %}§ _ \03 » /\} \ / \\ \ \ \/ /3$ 9\ /4 \ � k y Q (� / } \ % \ q V Q \ \ % § G ® n % \ \ � \ c § �<k � \ \ \ � / r \ \ \ n 2 c 2 k G k \ 2! ; 0 .' � k y Q (� / } \ % \ q V Q \ \ % § G ® n % \ \ � \ c § �<k � d g �o I \ \ � 3 > \ n 2 c 2 k § \ .' In- A % $ ) d g �o I / \/ \ / m ® 9\ \ § k 3 %70 rn o k�� \ 0 c 7%% »j\ },s rn \ %r2 '� ) r \\ \ § \ 0 \ 00 \ « \ j§= ; \ I °\\ .... \77 3 E \ § j m \ m= p. m -0 > >. / U) m =w o q rxy- rn m X \ \ En 4 00 M % g \. ( > \ C 0 K/O j Q \ I g/7 \ %\ ® $ \ \. § > \ ( .. ; 2/\ 2� y a ®/0 §//� S / \ } %2 w :{ > 0 7 \/ / m ( \\/ ' } 0 Q a m j k >�\ ° 3 F j2r 2 \\\ ; m § ® \ :D z ) 3» m \ § o /°° a \ \ � / i /09 \) \� -1t:70 : � 0 O c D m m _r m m 0 0 x m m m w z C m m U) O m 0 O c x n O m m 2 U) D z O D x m O D v 0 x m U) O z r 2 m n 2 D �=- C-) m�0 W r � O m D 7J x z n O O O c z p7 z c m O O Cf) � x D r O O D 37 m Z m o m ooz mu - O 0 0 o O V m a N c A > co x z m � O p i m m A Co 10 = 0 0 > 00 D O O r -7 T r O m C m D � ]7 < c� n O O 2 —{ D r � co r Z Cf) co 31 Oz T W m O C -T m - En m p X 2 m Z Z m G) U D O Cl m z cn = z y m O C) co n m < x z � � O D O n F --A _ < z m �o U) M D 71 D F- -i M z m D m m m m z 1 z a m n m 1 O n z m F -i x m 2 r- L' D v v m m U) m N r n n m n O r m v m O O z 2 m 1 D W r m r m 1 O m 1 2 m 0 D N z 1 2 m m O D x v 2 O O m O m 0 O x m N c m m m O m M z G7 x m n m O 'o r m D m m v 31 z 0 r m D D r O m z 0 n m 75 � 1 im O m z v D mm 9 z c m m x J j ro z > M7\ co ° ,9= m m = \ / �\ \ \ m n @ m CO g \ \ r >r§ 2 § G»/ m m =/j 2 G \- 0 . . ) 0 m m MM k © / 2 -1 m 22 Q � / §mm _ 2 m ) \ \} m j } 00 7 ° \// U \ / m m f// \ \22 j m ` g e/D ) m - \ mm ƒ mzm / { ° _/» § > G m 3 _ \ 2 j \} « » Cl) J g ± m \ \\ ) / § cf) / — o j/r 2 { \o/ k z \/} ) ) / /a= 2 , J f m .. zm - k ¢ zi \� \ ƒ) \ \> � 0 O c D m m r 3 m m v 0 O -i 2 m m m z c m m Vl T O m 0 O c n O m m z N D z v D m m 0 D v v m m m cn O z r s m n s D --I �- C-) = z o °CO O Fn Z n o p O co c c � < m o O U) -q X D r_ O O D Z m 0 m O O Z O D O Cl) 0o � O J JJ 0 c A co x m �L)0 A m M M Cf) .r>m� .o = D O O D O O r 71 m r IoW C m D z -< 3 < � C) Cl) z O S D c z LD m O m 37 z m Q7 m o CD m O 0 m Z cmi co D j O w� oD0 1 *z (D = z y m O �nm D m < -q> D O n P � :j Zm - D Co m �oOa) M D TI D r--� M z > D m m z m U) D D m z 1 - m m m z 3 L? o —I v m m r m 1 m 1 o o z m m O 3 O f z m m D m W s m m c v O z m y N v r m O T 1 m m _v D z -1 2 m m O D v m O O v O m 0 O -i s m m c m m m 1 m m z O m m D P r m mm M Z 1 n r m D r k� 0 m z v D m m E z c ca m m m 0 vv //0 >(\ / �/\ n j ®x m E// i C) z m m0 j \2 \ / /30 \ }// ■ m _ m \// \ � \\ � \oG $ _{\ \ \\\ g a \/ { m / �ƒ0 § m / 3 0 / §} f co m / \\\ z \m0 Q ® ©m m \ \/ 2 ©oj / u0co \\ I R U) \ J z § m m \ \ \ m 2 > � m m } / \ Cl) \ m \ \ 0 § > C \ . \ k \ \ \ \ § j / � F� \ \ \ m T z \ 7 k 2 � �a � / }\: 2 g2e \ rn ��U) G \>> c 3 00 0 %/\ ) + \) \ Z \\ m ®/® ) \§\ a zz, § mg\ m ��° o �� \ > °rn \ \ > m \ 0 >m0 \o\ / \, m3 / / \m @ M \ � ± / t m ? m � / 0 m / q k m \ £ 2 m \ I & � $ k 2 rn \ ,9 ?t § \ \ G e k. \ 3 2 m 2 \ -4 f m ( \ \ \ / / \ ; 5 \ f m j 2 / } � � � avo ] 33 z \)\ $ m e ,=g m \\\ \ 0 ?Z m�� r rn \ /(> 0 ) _/0 \ ] \ /j0 `ƒ ° >- w 2 } / m m §j2 6 / }\: 2 g2e \ rn ��U) G \>> c 3 00 0 %/\ ) + \) \ Z \\ m ®/® ) \§\ a zz, § mg\ m ��° o �� \ > °rn \ \ > m \ 0 >m0 \o\ / \, m3 / / \m @ M \ � ± / t m ? m � / 0 m / q k m \ £ 2 m \ I & � $ k 2 rn \ ,9 ?t § \ \ G e k. \ 3 2 m 2 \ -4 f m ( \ \ \ / / \ ; 5 \ f m j 2 / } � � � O c D m m r m m v 0 O 2 m m m w z c m m h T O a O c a n O 3 m m Z cn D z v D m m O D v m m m m cn O z r { x m n x D Z0 m z o m p r 0 r r C O o mm o o m c z m O O C/) � x D _r O O D m m z m o m 0 o Z x' O � O o � � V m A D Cl) x z m L p M z = a) M m A W Cl) O = D � x � p D O p r x m r C. r 0 a) C m D x { � (7 cf) OZ O iz = D C() r c m mCSm DJ z m CO m O c x x CO m p m x z Z m L7 O D � G7 wmz Cal c) m * z CO Z { y m O n CO D m x z D O n _ < Z m � D CO m 7ocn M D cn x 0 T D r� m m m m m z 1 z O m m —I 1 O z m a W x m a z D m m v M, O O W m m n N -l� f� im O m v D D m m n O -� � r r m mm I•• m v T O 11; ,r--_ O Z x -J m D W r m r m O m x m v D N Z x m W O D a v m O O v a O a 0 O x m m c W m m n W M z x m D a P r m D W m a Z 1 n r m D a r O m z v D mm z c 9 W m m W 0 a §0 > ;j0 / «/ m \ @ }/ r / \) d =RJ q g/2 0 \ »ƒ / -)/ {mf m ƒ Z :0 5 \ y ° G /2/ m }\ \. o \0 § > Fo \ \?\ z w(> z /\\ 0 ogo a g=§ m 5 %g o / \> ƒ /mj m m } /§\ 22z 7 /)3 n /j o \ >M- M> co /> _ ] m Co } m j m / .. � 0 �.� \ IV �\ � \ 4 \ : I 2 �2 w m m � 2 m 2 } § \ � / \ 4 m cn m j / m P m % 7 § ) - c \ m 2 / » \ / m In \ ,� (// > 0 �\» C`® / > @ 3(\ - z/ 0 / R,r ¥ 0o Z / �\\ � ��m. 23 / / ƒ / $ c \/\ / 00 o \0 \ / \/ \ \/\ § a// / \ z\ 0 oM0 > E 0 F= ƒ\ /9/ 2 //2 § _»} o \/� { \o/ e \}/ m eaa \\j n z 2 \ ƒ2 j\ « 7 2. 7 / $ 2 @ / � �* � m _ 20m m \ \0 2 0 �@/ � m moo J§} m m/} } 0oZ j j>9 .� m o \j � 2 }\{ 2 m - Z DO m �'0 m 00 0 \?\ § _/) \ \§ \ k C: » }5� o # $ am ° _/0 ) m § 0 {(( \ §mk q m® (\) S ; o /$y £o@ \// \ a7, = 0 /9f ) \\\ } \° \\ / im m : m \ \ @ 2 \ 2 \ m # \ \ 2 \ m m j m \ m m 0 / � Mq \ { @ m \ @ / } e .� � 0 0 c D m m r 3 m m 0 0 x m m m I z mm N T O m 0 0 c a n O 3 m Z U) N z 0 z m O D 0 0 a m Cl) N O z 2 m n 2 D D i z C-) M O Or W c r p ° m D A A Z O 0 o p z c c z c Z -< m o O D r O D m z m ° m ° -p o ° o 0 o° A N uM > w A m I p �mA U) .P pW = o r DDI ° r D 0 m r tom 2 z < 9: { Cf) Oz O S cn —� D � r U r z D co A zz m W m O C US m o v z M �U?D w Cfi z CO 1 :�E z S z D m W k n r D m { �7N G) Di O O r S < Z m q D W R1 O to D O r � m v m m N m z .0 m O z m n z m m Jj D O m z O n m 3 n O , o T o z C m m r m m a z n r m 9 73. O m z 0 a m Z c m m a I O � N N m v_ z � A, 2 m 0 2 m r �u n a � o O o m O l 2 m � ao m m r m . z N x m f m O r m m a z n r m 9 73. O m z 0 a m Z c m m a I EXHIBIT A GOLDEN GATE AREA MASTER PLAN 2. ESTATES DESIGNATION YYY * ** YYY * *Y *Y* YYY * ** B. Estates - Commercial District * ** YY* * ** YY* YYY * *Y Y ** YY* 3) Randall Boulevard Commercial Subdistrict — C P- 2008 -2 [Page 26] *YY *Y* *YY * ** [Page 331 * ** YYY * *Y Y ** [Page 35] (GH -8415), extendinq from 8 "' Street NE west to the Corkscrew Canal The This Subdistrict is comprised of the following properties: Tracts 54, 55, 71, 72, 89, 90, 107, 108, 125. 126 and 127 Golden Gate Estates, Unit 23; And the fit This Aandall Boulevard Cornmereial Subdistrict has been designated on the Golden Gate Area Future Land Use Map and the Randall Boulevard Commercial Subdistrict Map. See ARap 4-4 It is the intent of this Subdistrict to orovide commercial goods and services to the surrounding area. Development intensity in this Subdistrict shall not exceed 411.950 square feet of floor area All development in this Subdistrict shall comply with the following requirements and limitations: • a. All seraraereia} development is encouraged to be in the form of a PUD. • b. Projects directly abutting Estates zoned property shall provide, at a minimum, a 75 -foot wide buffer of retained native vegetation in which no parking or water management uses are permitted; except that, when abutting conditional uses no such buffer is required. • c. Shared parking shall be required with adjoining developments whenever possible. d. Tract 55 shall only be utilized for native oreservation and water management areas. The eastern boundary of Tract 55 shall contain at a minimum. a 50 -foot wide retained native vegetation buffer development, on Tracts 72, 89 90, 107 108 125 126 127 and the west one -half of Tract 54. Development intensity shall be limited to 20,000 Words underlined are added; words struGk through are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * **) denotes break in text. 3p CP- 2008 -2 30 square feet of floor area on the east one -half of Tract 54 and 31,000 square feet of floor area on Tract 71. f. Allowable uses shall be limited to all permitted and conditional uses of the CA General Commercial District, in the Collier County Land Development Code, Ordinance No. 04 -41 as amended except that the following uses shall be prohibited: • Tire Dealers Automotive Retail (Group 5531) • Automotive Parking (Group 7521) • _Communication Services (Group 4899) • Drinkina Places (Group 5813) • Fishing Piers (Group7999) • Glass and Glazing work (Group 17 3) • Health Services (Groups 8059 -8069) • Specialty Outpatient Facilities (Group 8093) • Houseboat Rental Lakes Operations Partv and Pleasure Boat rental (Group 7999) • Large Appliance repair service (Group 7623) • Marinas (group 4493 and 4499) • Miscellaneous Repair Services (Groups 7622 -7641 7699) • Liquor Store, unless operated by Grocery Retailer (Group 5921) • Used Merchandise Store (Group 5932) • Automatic Merchandising Machine Operators (Group 5962) • Direct Selling Establishment (Group 5963) • Escort Services, Massage Parlors Tattoo Parlors Turkish Baths Wedding Chapels (Group 7299) • Betting Information Services Bath Houses Billiard Parlors Words underlined are added; words skulk thrGugh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. Mi. , M ,mmi-Nimm-ii L . . . . . . • Tire Dealers Automotive Retail (Group 5531) • Automotive Parking (Group 7521) • _Communication Services (Group 4899) • Drinkina Places (Group 5813) • Fishing Piers (Group7999) • Glass and Glazing work (Group 17 3) • Health Services (Groups 8059 -8069) • Specialty Outpatient Facilities (Group 8093) • Houseboat Rental Lakes Operations Partv and Pleasure Boat rental (Group 7999) • Large Appliance repair service (Group 7623) • Marinas (group 4493 and 4499) • Miscellaneous Repair Services (Groups 7622 -7641 7699) • Liquor Store, unless operated by Grocery Retailer (Group 5921) • Used Merchandise Store (Group 5932) • Automatic Merchandising Machine Operators (Group 5962) • Direct Selling Establishment (Group 5963) • Escort Services, Massage Parlors Tattoo Parlors Turkish Baths Wedding Chapels (Group 7299) • Betting Information Services Bath Houses Billiard Parlors Words underlined are added; words skulk thrGugh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. .- 0 CP- 2008 -2 Parole offices. Probation offices. Public welfare centers refugee services settlement houses (Group 8322) Tow -in parking lots (Groups 7514. 7515 7521) Animal Specialty Services (Group 0752) to discontinuance and relocation of the Big Corkscrew Island Fire Station and Florida Division of Forestry fire tower uses h [Placeholder for transportation mitigation reguirementsl CP- 2008 -2 Exhibit A per CCPC —David 12 -11 -09 G: \Comprehensive \COMP PLANNING GMP DATA \Comp Plan Amendments \2007 -2008 Combined Cycle Pethions\2008 Cycle Petitions \CP - 2008 -2 Randall Blvd Com Subdistrict Words underlined are added; words ugh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. F I% F I` F IN E I� LEGEND wrap "TAM o.... mm �alwwwanuu a�miumx US /c.0 • 4'COM ut[ 0` [ma�un�i �cen rcE aov.c - t[0.it_[5 pvWd R 28E ORAF GOLDEN GATE AREA FUTURE LAND USE MAP w„m� R 27E I R28E I 3D EXHIBIT A RANDALL BOULEVARD COMMERCIAL SUBDISTRICT Collier County, Florida IMMOKALEE AMENDED — SEPTEMBER 10, 2003 (Ord. No. 2003 -44) AMENDED — JANUARY 25, 2007 (Ord. No. 2007 -19) 0 1/2 MI. 1 MI. PREPARED BY: GIS /CAD MAPPING SECTION COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION FILE: CP- 2006- 2B.DWG DATE: 9/2009 30 LEGEND GOLDEN GATE STTLEMENT E ESTATES AREA !//,rid �%(✓ CY/ri?iYlb�l/ f 3D MM 0- - , z CCPC PRESENTATION NOTES 11VW-1a7V 10 -19 -09 RANDALL BLVD COMMERCIAL SUBDISTRICT EXPANSION (CP- 2008 -2) Thank you Bruce. RECOGNIZE AND THANK STAFF FOR COOPERATION The petitioner would like to recognize and thank County Staff for their cooperation in the processing of this petition. Specifically, Michele Mosca, Mike Bosi, David Weeks Nick Casalanguida, and John Podczewinsky have made themselves available as needed to address questions and issues for which we are grateful. While the question of demand and locational appropriateness is I believe central to this body's review and may be the primary point of discussion when all is said and done, please allow me to briefly discuss the proposed site and its physical characteristics. While most development standards are more appropriately addressed at the rezone stage, some have been included in the GMPA to ensure that they are more specifically addressed at the rezone for the benefit of the adiacent residents. ( Emergent Development Group has assembled parcels for the purpose of this application extending from 8th Street NE �3p which runs along the East side of the project all the way to the Corkscrew Canal on the West, totaling 56.5 acres. This does not mean that Emergent Development Group is proposing a 50+ acre commercial development, so let me walk you through the parcels included in the proposed amendment: Starting at the western end of the amendment boundary are two parcels owned by the Big Corkscrew Island Fire District. The parcel fronting Immokalee Roa is 2.3 res in size and if approved would result in the ability to rezone the current Fire Station site to commercial uses as a stand- alone project. Teti° , pe of sale - lOCatlnn of the rrr�tatiAn to n }�Qttr�_?c�ratinn �* t�P *�P� ljy in aloe e ion? t is hPiiPY enita� ^r +^ -- -w- ^°R The - -- r r� likely end use for a parcel such as this would be a small scale commercial use or possibly a center similar to what is located next door. The remaining land owned by the Fire District totajs 5 res and is located behind the Fire Station and administrative building. This parcel would be limited to water management and open space uses so is not therefore going to accommodate commercial uses of a kind. Moving to the East is the existing center totaling 2.51 acres which includes a small market with a variety of commercial shops. This site is part of the existing Randall Blvd commercial subdistrict and is built out. Immediately to the east are two parcels that are 1.14 and 4.Q,L acres respectively. They too, are currently zoned ommercial and located within the existing Randall Blvd 2 3p Subdistrict. The front parcel is developed with a gas station and convenience store and the rear parcel is currently vacant. Moving further east you will find what can be considered the core of the proposed amendment that will house the bulk of any new commercial development. This is an assemblage of parcels under the applicant, Emergent Development Group, Inc. and includes a handful of in ' idual owners. This assemblage when added to the 5. c parcel at the corner of Randall and 8f' which is owned by Collier County and currently houses the Forestry service building tot 41.52 cres. Again, these are the core properties that when combined with the parcels to the West constitute the totality of the proposed amendment. mom"WOOMWO MA The physical characteristics of the project when viewed in relation to our neighbors is fairly straight forward. This Master Plan Exhibit shows conceptual access locations that are still being developed and worked on with the County Transportation Department but illustrate the manner in which the site will connect the existing Randall Blvd sub- district with the proposed Randall Blvd 6- laning through the use of multiple access points and a system of internal access roads. The project proposes buffering the residents immediately to our south with a 75' native buffer area supplemented with native plantings to create a type -D buffer to achieve a high 3 3D ;t degree of opacity shortly after planting. This buffer combined with the rear access road will serve to push any building a minimum distance in excess of 100 feet from the common property line and provide a substantial visual buffer for adjacent residents. One request that was conveyed to us was that of a wall or fence along the rear of the property. The reason for this request was not what I expected, but apparently the current use of the property as a local dirt track for ATV's and even pick up trucks has resulted in all forms of vehicles including golf carts driving onto and in some cases through the properties along 24th. At the time of rezoning we can address the placement of a wall or fence more specifically, but it is our intent is to locate it to the south of the access road to address this issue raised by our neighbors and we also feel it will serve as a noise buffer for cars travelling along the rear access road. One resident has inquired about installing a gate to allow them to walk to the future shops which we will also address at zoning. Another concern expressed was what the residents would experience with the eventual 6- laning of Randall which is going to ultimately happen with or without this project. When you compare a retail and office building scenario on this property versus a collection of single family homes, the buildings themselves will serve as barriers to noise and impacts from the roadway far better than fifteen or so single homes would, so oddly enough, the presence of retail buildings on this site will provide some sound mitigation for the residents along 24th upon the widening of Randall. 91 30 The site circulation will use 8th Ave NE prominently since a traffic signal is anticipated in this location and will provide enough distance between the signal at 8th and the signal at Immokalee to ensure the smooth flow of traffic for Estates residents. Let me speak briefly about the proposed roadway design for Randall in this location. This design is very preliminary and surely will be revised further, but the intent is to provide two through lanes of movement from Immokalee Road heading East onto Randall. This would replace the current stop condition at the light for cars travelling Eastbound from Immokalee to Randall. Additional turn lanes are to be added for Randall Westbound onto Immokalee to reduce the wait time which is significant in the mornings. Ultimately, this intersection may include grade separated lanes, and the plans before you are intended to allow for that if it is ever required, without the taking of additional right of way. In addition to the ROW donation discussed earlier by Mr. Anderson, Tract 55 behind the existing Fire Station has been added to the GMPA solely for the purpose of providing water management. The majority of this lake will serve the Randall Blvd widening, not just for the configuration you see here, but will include capacity to address future improvements to Randall that aren't even in the design stage at this time. To say your transportation staff was looking to the future for this intersection would be a gross understatement. Wi 3D What is envisioned for this site is a development that consists of two or three distinct areas that contain a mix of retail, office, medical and convenience uses that are much like what you would see at the Shopping Centers along 951 at Pine Ridge, or VBR. In essence, a community appropriate shopping center with national retail anchors. The square footage associated with our application and as approved by the Planning Commission totals 411,950 sq. ft. as a maximum for all parcels contained within the entire subdistrict. This number was arrived at for the purpose of being consistent with both our TIS and GMPA application when talking about the proposed impacts of the project, so we wanted to present a "worst case scenario' for traffic generation purposes consistent with the direction of this body and your transportation staff. Making up the total square footage is 20,000 sq. ft. allocated to the BCI Fire parcel, the 20,000 square foot small retail center within the subdistrict and 31,000 allocated to the Randall Blvd center PUD which is inclusive of the gas station and the commercial land to the rear of the gas station. Subtracting those parcels from what is the "core" commercial center leaves 340,950 sq. ft. of commercial square footage. With 75,000 square feet for general or medical office, the actual retail component of the proposed core center will be approximately 265,950 sq. ft. A retail and office project that is comparable in size and scope would be the Pine Ridge Commons PUD at the Northeast corner of Pine Ridge Road and Goodlette Frank 6 30 14 Northeast corner of Pine Ridge Road and Goodlette Frank Road. Once you account for the existing and future ROW for Randall Blvd, the Randall Blvd project is a� lat similar in it's proposed mix of retail and office uses. Additionally, the Pine Ridge Commons property has more frontage than depth just as the Randall site does so I feel it is the closest example of the mix of uses and layout that would occupy this site at build -out. Brie th�lge Co very r m y cent n the Rand ISSUES RELATED TO STAFF REPORT AND RECCOMENDATION: The County prepared Staff report is thorough and with relatively few exceptions is reflective of what the petition is seeking to do. The primary focus of the staff report is a discussion of supply and demand for commercial development in the Estates. While we certainly differ with the conclusion and recommendation provided by County staff, the basis for our differences in position stems more from the application of the data, not the data itself. While I believe that the developable square footage for the designated neighborhood centers in the Estates is overstated by more than 100,000 square feet, I'm not sure the developable area within these small parcels are germane to this discussion. E Staff's analysis again, focuses on the available commercial supply in the Estates. The supply includes projects that are built, properties that are zoned and un -built as well as properties that are designated for commercial but as yet un- zoned. These properties together make up a significant portion of the potential supply of commercial acreage in the Estates. The analysis is strictly quantative and does not pretend to be more than that. The State Committee on Community Affairs in a publication from October of 2009 in addressing population need as a criteria for changes to the Future Land Use Map states that "case law has indicated that the need for additional commercial or industrial land may also be demonstrated by other factors such as the suitability of the property for change, locational criteria, and community desires" This point is further recognized in the Executive Summary prepared by staff with states that "even if the numerical analysis fails to demonstrate need, other factors may be considered." Staff has provided further guidance to us in this regard indicating that it is really our responsibility as the applicant to raise these points and bring them to the forefront for consideration. In short, the staff analysis treats all commercial square footage evenly. A foot is a foot is a foot. This approach fails to recognize that the size and location of a given property contribute greatly to the retail and office services it is capable of providing. To illustrate, the intersection of Everglades and Golden Gate Boulevard has a 5 acre parcel at each corner designated for commercial development. 0 3® Assuming 25,000 square feet per parcel, which based on my experience is a generous number, the intersection could have 4 — 25,000 sq.ft. commercial buildings totaling 100,000 square feet. This scenario is not the same however as a single 100,000 square foot shopping center. In both cases, there are 100,000 square feet, but 4 5 -acre parcels do not equal a 20 acre shopping center parcel. Therefore, not all commercial square footage is created equal. Size and location must be considered in determining if the demands of the community are being met. Contained within the CIGM is the recognition that once a given area reaches a certain population, there exists a demand for larger scale commercial opportunities. Using staff's Attachment 6 ( d . ) you see the population within the primary and secondary trade area for the Randall Project will reach 34,434 in 2015 and 41,371 by 2020. Looking at the CIGM guidelines for commercial development in the green box of that same exhibit, you can see that a Neighborhood Center which is referenced as being approximately 110,000 square feet becomes necessary at a population of 13,110 people. Once you get to a population of over 34,000, an additional Regional Center which is approximately 257,000 square feet becomes necessary to support the commercial needs of the community. This means that by 2015, only five years from now, both a community center and a neighborhood center are needed just to serve the Northern half of the Estates and by 2020 we are well on our way to needing another neighborhood center. Again, this is the data staff has compiled from the approved CIGM. X IVA Based on the staff's county -wide average of commercial yield, this means that each neighborhood center will require 18 to 20 contiguous acres of land and a community center will require 40 to 45 acres. And remember, we will need a minimum of one neighborhood center and one community center just to serve the northern part of the Estates by 2015 with another neighborhood center being necessary by 2025. The myriad of small acre designated commercial parcels throughout the Estates will fill a small, localized need for convenience retail. But they cannot either individually or in the aggregate provide for mid and large scale retail needs such as grocery stores, specialty mini - anchors, fast food or high turn over sit down restaurants such as Outback or Applebees, and so forth. In order to meet the full retail needs of the community we will need to identify these larger tracts of land to serve the residents that are there today and in the near future. The issue then becomes the appropriateness of the size, location and compatibility which we feel are the v str n hs of our a lication. ��''u/��7F� ��` /�'"�'�l�' �1/✓�:A?' ,y: The size of the core retail component oI t ills project is jus over 40 acres. This will allow for the development of a�.� -y>R -� neighborhood center initially and allow for expansion to address the needs of a community center in the future. We are located at one of the busiest intersections in the Estates with over 52,000 cars passing through the intersection each day. 10 3p The property is at the intersection of an existing 6 -lane arterial roadway and a planned 6 -lane arterial roadway and is playing a key role in providing the necessary room for the required expansion of Randall Blvd. The site is also located adjacent to the projects containing the highest residential density ip the Estates area, totaling, 3702 units. / 9 P mile & /ld' i1%� k 4' Gid i.4! SQwee otr` JF 4 0-w v+°c V� t c / We have discussed ed the IIIHO!F tense buffering that iss proposed and will address in more detail the project's ability to achieve compatibility through the site specific location of land uses and buffering techniques at the time of zoning. Even more compelling for this site as a planner, has been the manner in which we have been received by the community. Over the course of a 20 -year career in planning, I have not encountered many developer clients Tiny �nre�uv�S who take the time and effort Mr. Sullivan has taken M4*d� Inf tiNt� getting to know his neighbors and the surrounding 4F- -7 community before leaping into a project. This project 1Z) s" 1. i9'i10iT /BN'+f'C enjoys overwhelming support from the surrounding community which has not been the case in years past when.Tew ' expansions of this sub - district has been discussed. We had "40r79vv only 21 people attend the NIM and the prevailing question was "how fast can you get it built?" We have worked closely with our neighbors and will continue to do so through a rural character committee to help guide the style and character of the development on this site. We feel the language as proposed provides adequate protection for the residents in addressing the potential for noxious uses and through the rezone process, an even greater level of compatibility will be achieved. 3D Lastly, contrary to the staff report which cites Goals 3 and 5 in the GGAMP as a basis for denial, it is the applicants position and my professional opinion that this project in this location will serve to meet the commercial needs of Estates residents while preserving and promoting rural character by locating these necessary land uses in proximity to the residents without being overly intrusive and taking advantage of the only arterial to arterial intersection currently planned for the Estates. In other words, this amendment will provide for a project that is the right size, right location and the right time to meet the clearly identified retail needs of the residents in the Northern Estates. Additional supporting information: • Trip data for intersection • Staff report w /attachments • Tables from Jack • Spreadsheets from Jack • Florida Senate Interim Report • "dot" maps • Letters and e -mails of support Trips — less than IOK for OWR, more than 40K for us. 12 W fllo C *P Petition In Favor of the Randall Blvd. Commercial PUD Expansion We the undersigned approve of Emergent Development Groups' plan to expand the Randall Blvd Commercial PUD. Since we are unable to attend this meeting we are appointing our neighbor, Karen Acquard to speak on our behalf Name (print) Address Signature O c D m m r 3 m m 0 0 O -i m m m w z C m m N 0 O D 0 O c n O m m Z N D z O D m m --i O D 0 0 m m N N O Z -i m rn n S D 9 2 Z O M O r W c r O m D 0 S S Z (7 � 0 Co Z c c < m Z O O Cl) --i x D r O z 3 z O q D Mom M 00Z O D O N O J m° N � m A � U� M O O c -i T m A O 2 o 0 r D O O � �o w 2 z < cn N Oz O = c: D c r N m O m m O c m m 37 Z Z m L7 O—D w N c ovz c� y � Z = z y m O C7 co n m < SAG) y O 0 r 2 < Z m =i D W m UoCl) D fn O T r jyl m m m N m z z M d O z m A m m Z 3 m � r n m n O m r m Tm 0 T O m `C 2 m 2 m �--I m r m r -i v m In N �� O m � m 1 m 0 �j o CJ 0 � v Q 9 O o m N C to m ( m m m_ Z N 2 m p r m N m v z z n m D z J M m z O D m 3 r m l G G 01� r MR r N m z 0 a -1 3 Z c 9 U3 m z ^l7 O FIN C v O c D 2 m r mm v 0 O x x m m w z c m m T O 2 0 O m n O m m z D z v D 2 m O D v v x m U) O z r x m n x n m = z o m O r W C r O o m D Z C)p c � < m 0 0 � m D r O z z O 74 D m C) C) m m ooz o n o Cl) 0 O 0o v � A - m �Zo c Zmcn A 0 n O D O O O D 7J T r O w = Z m U) OZ O Cn S -{ E: D c r 77 Lr M O m v z m W m O c m m cn m ro DI m m z C/) G) c') a] 1 5 z � z z -i < y m O C7 m 7J Z 2N c� n o C) r = < Z m �o� D o T r> � Z m n m m N M Z z L7 V M O z m m ,,. O O 2 m N N F 2 m VIS i D O m Z v D n n m m n � r r m m m m v m O a O z �. x m n W r m r m O C m � D 2 N m m (l\ (n D _ z � 0 x r m m 0 m O F- 0 0 )" m O 2 z 0 v 0 a_ r, m m m x m c Z 133 c m n W m m x m z fl x m D 2 v � o \� � CO / / o §g .. / /{0 / [ - 0 �@G § C $ -< \ \ a �\© / § \ \ ] \) d -i _,$ a y \ \ -0 ' ^ ƒ e z ®c g = o G % f \§, / \L) 0 0 k \0= \ `mot > j " } 2 0 j\ 0 r- , ° k » § 2 § \ // \ 9 ` % =y= $ 9 )9\ \ / } \\{ ` m : ; 9 e cn Cl) 3 = \/ m = y ) % » =/3 § § > \ \ 2 / \ \/3 n 99G) \ 0 \ > ) } \ y G U) U) CO ?/ . / / < } ƒ \/} - § / aao n § f/\ ` q > ^ ` ) �*© C \ }� \ \ 2 \ \� � m m -i O D v v m m U) U) O z r -i x m 0 x D T m o 0 n O v z c D c m m o m � r n r z 3 _ o � m m m o m o 0 O0 m O _ D 0 m o m m m m y CD w x m O z - Z, _ m 1 A W m O to m D O 0 O n 0 r m � m r C c) r O X00 c c m ]7 D Z { O � a'+ 0 O co C 5 �n r D mL m om Z x Z T D W m x �_ m o x m z O D WU)o oMm m?z ani=z nm0 3nm n r < M D O D 0 Z m v W m M 0 m I �x 0 mD F � ZC) o c r o m z � C) 0 c z -I O x O z D z 0 m Z O 0 V N A x m 0 CS m Cn _ D S m m m m m m z 1 z m m i _1 O z m S z D M. r —1 D V►l► 0 m 0 O O m z v D mm 1 r m D v v ° v m O z m �l C, 1 A � r m r ° D ch m T -i D v v ° v m m co m y m A rn ° D ch � S Z y }� a m r ry al D m r rt' W S j S O O , S 4 O x 0 m C m C- m 0 4 CD _m z O x m D m v D m m z v D m z C co m m S � O 0 0 c m x m r m m v 0 0 x W m m I z c -I m in O W 0 O C W n O m m Z fA z z O m m m -i O D v v x m W O O z x m x D M n W C r O Q m D � z O 0 0 m C z Z c z < m O O w-i x D r O O i�: D m „Z m o n m 00Z x- O °noo o m m N v M 1 U Z m M O C Z = D I m m A 0 --I n D r 9 � O O D O O r m T r r 00 = Z { 7D < cn OZ O = D r c r cn m O m J) z � �p m O c m x _rnm r - O 7J Z Z M L) 1> Cl) �i o m z G> 1 � z Cl) = z T < y m o Zz O w > m < 33 Z a o 0 r z < Zm� �ocn D m � r> M z m n v � x m m U) m z z c� m J O z m I 2 m 9 IM O v W m U) X v r n m O O v r m m m v m 0 0 z x m D W r m r m O T 1 x m v D N Z x m W O D W v W O O W 0 W O x m U) c W m m O W m z L1 x m n x O r m D W m W Z --I n r m D 7J O m z v D m m r m im ci m z v D m m K z c W m x i o aa" ^.F��, ,qn J�,i - •`fir � , �f Y v v Je o��}'. gyp• .f F" • R ` f F f� t , Xd '* A9*-," 4.4 L1116 Nk 14, Ito 'Illkl Z W r Q N O O O J N W a0 UD Q2 ax c� 3 Of Ow LL 0 U) W _ 7 U) F- }U J Qa Z� Q W J z Q ` 00 W Z W O U N °y � N N N Do p =Q ggy G o V Q a A H .e c -�s IL go b! 7 K F � kit O Z 0 O o-�` : o 0 0 0 0 0 0 C� c ,van Vat F = 8 0 00 0 0 00 0 0 ° �EE EEE EE E !EE 'yj eR� J O CO 0 0 0 N O Ci V i!i ! f dim a NOLL`dlndOd CL c H Z Z 1Y m U m J OAK C.1. O { a s + 9� 6@ $ xw�wew xw,exwv. ewx xoexx 6 { $ o ei llI ` s� 01400 11,11 10 GP� MQ Iff, A ilk 4L rt 1 nil jr fi J,Ili ,I, X "A 4o is MW4� 71 Carbon Monoxide Emissions I Report on the Environment Database I US EPA Page I of 3 J�ptID ar�� a Report on the Environment � W q You are here: EPA Home Research & D?ydgi m n NCEA Home ROE Home A -Z Indicators wf poi Lis Indicators Carbon Monoxide Emissions brgt R`IIC�k Carbon Monoxide Emissions Carbon Monoxide Emissions Q: What are the trends in outdoor air quality and their Links effects on human health and the environment? The above question pertains to all 'Outdoor Air' Indicators, however, the information on these pages (overview, graphics, references and metadata) relates specifically to "Carbon Monoxide Emissions ". Use the right side drop list to view the other related indicators on this question. Introduction What the Data Show Limitations Introduction Carbon monoxide (CO) gas forms primarily when carbon fuels are not burned completely. Mobile sources account for the majority of CO emissions (U.S. EPA, 2003). These sources include both on -road vehicles (e.g., cars, trucks, motorcycles) and nonroad vehicles and engines (e.g., farm equipment, construction equipment, aircraft, marine vessels). Consequently, high concentrations of CO generally occur in areas with heavy traffic congestion. In cities, as much as 95 percent of all CO emissions may come from automobile exhaust (U.S. EPA, 2003). Other sources of CO emissions include industrial processes, non - transportation fuel combustion, and natural sources, such as wildfires. Fuel- burning appliances also are a large source of CO releases in indoor environments. Undetected releases of carbon monoxide in indoor settings can present serious health risks to building occupants. The CC Concentrations indicator describes health hazards associated with inhaling CO. This indicator presents CO emissions from traditionally inventoried anthropogenic source categories: (1) "Fuel combustion," which includes emissions from coal -, gas -, and oil -fired power plants and industrial, commercial, and institutional sources, as well as residential heaters (e.g., wood - burning stoves) and boilers; (2) "Other industrial processes," which includes chemical production, petroleum refining, metals production, and industrial processes other Indicator Charts and Graphs References MetaData Create a PDF Outdoor Air Indicators Indicators Chapters ROE Database Home Air Water Land Human Health Ecological Condition ERhibtt 2 -1. CO efNRS[lllR m the U5 by scurry c tagorv. 19W 19% 2=. ai 2 5 R.>nMMM1^K 6aRMW W Niwm wNpT' f .., !N a� a b+� arc IFSR --lK �: I190 I. R� InnW N W 14Fr ]pf:. sX:AL ,s w1YI4as XCa atlYygrtY m[uxs Ran¢ue »mr✓r WbRglk wnr.lR1! akh w9a iu �R wren .', er. Icl iJ1S vAN WI IYJ4f °in Ow. 0F -AP.0 enlarge c Exhibit 2 -1 http: / /cf pub. epa .gov /eroe /index.cfm ?fuseaction= detail. viewlnd &lv= list.listByAlpha &r--18... 1/18/2010 Carbon Monoxide Emissions I Report on the Environment Database I US EPA than fuel combustion; (3) "On -road vehicles," which includes cars, trucks, buses, and motorcycles; and (4) " Nonroad vehicles and engines," such as farm and construction equipment, lawnmowers, chainsaws, boats, ships, snowmobiles, aircraft, and others. The indicator also includes estimates of biogenic CO emissions in 2005. Biogenic emissions were estimated using the Biogenic Emissions Inventory System Model, Version 3.12, with data from the Biogenic Emissions Landcover Database and 2001 annual meteorological data. Page 2 of�3 lJ►'rn Uhlb t 3 -2. CO emisslms �n Rw U 5. W EPA Rauro , 1m . t9A6 nw, am eM5 CO emissions data are tracked by the National Emissions m'4 o, Inventory (NEI). The NEI is a composite of data from many o_ different sources, including industry and numerous state, wK tribal, and local agencies. Different data sources use luA Mwt.�.y11GNYYm o I)' q7 »1r different data collection methods, and many of the emissions data are based on estimates rather than actual 3 enlarge u measurements. For most fuel combustion sources and industrial sources, emissions are estimated using emission Exhibit 2 2 factors. Emissions from on -road and nonroad sources were estimated using EPA - approved modeling approaches (U.S. EPA, 2008). CO emissions data are tracked by the National Emissions m'4 o, Inventory (NEI). The NEI is a composite of data from many o_ different sources, including industry and numerous state, wK tribal, and local agencies. Different data sources use luA Mwt.�.y11GNYYm o I)' q7 »1r different data collection methods, and many of the emissions data are based on estimates rather than actual enlarge u measurements. For most fuel combustion sources and industrial sources, emissions are estimated using emission Exhibit 2 2 factors. Emissions from on -road and nonroad sources were estimated using EPA - approved modeling approaches (U.S. EPA, 2008). NEI data have been collected since 1990 and cover all 50 states and their counties, D.C., the U.S. territories of Puerto Rico and Virgin Islands, and some of the territories of federally recognized American Indian nations. Data are presented for 1990, from 1996 to 2002, and for 2005. Data are available from 1991 to 1995 and from 2003 to 2004, but these data have not been updated to be comparable to the inventories from 1990, 1996 to 2002, and 2005. What The Data Show This indicator focuses on trends in CO emissions from anthropogenic sources. However, CO emissions from biogenic sources were estimated for 2005 to provide a sense of the relative contributions of natural versus anthropogenic emissions (Exhibit 2 -1, panel B). Nationally, biogenic emissions were estimated to contribute approximately 16 percent to the CO emissions from all sources during 2005. Nationwide estimated anthropogenic CO emissions have decreased 46 percent between 1990 and 2005, the most recent year for which aggregate NEI emissions estimates are available (Exhibit 2 -1, panel A). Almost the entire emissions reduction is attributed to decreased emissions from on -road mobile sources. In 2005, mobile sources (both on -road and nonroad sources combined) accounted for 89 percent of the nation's total anthropogenic CO emissions. The CO emissions reductions are reflected in corresponding reductions in ambient concentrations (the CO Concentrations indicator). Net estimated anthropogenic CO emissions declined in all EPA Regions between 1990 and 2005 (Exhibit 2 -2). The largest decrease (12.22 million tons) occurred in Region 5, and the smallest decrease (2.28 million tons) occurred in Region 10. Limitations Comparable CO emissions estimates through the NEI are available only for 1990, 1996- 2002, and 2005. Data for 1991 -1995 and 2003 -2004 are not provided due to differences in emissions estimation methodologies from other inventory years, which http: / /cf pub. epa .gov /eroe /index.cfm ?fuseaction= detail. viewlnd &lv= list.listByAlpha &r =18... 1/18/2010 Carbon Monoxide Emissions I Report on the Environment Database I US EPA Pa e 3 of 3 t Igl1D & #P could lead to im roper trend assessments. http: / /cfpub.epa.gov/ eroe /rr d ex. cfm? fuseaction= detail . view Ind &Iv= list,listByAlpha &r- 1687.95 &subtop =34J. Last updated on Monday, January 18th, 2010. CO emissions from "miscellaneous sources," including wildfires, are not included in the total emissions. Yearly fluctuations in wildfire emissions have the potential to mask trends in anthropogenic emissions and therefore have been excluded from the trends graphics. Details on emissions from miscellaneous sources can be found on EPA's emission inventory Web site (http://www.ec)a.gov/ttn/chief/eiinformation.html), by downloading NEI inventory data for the "nonpoint sector." The emissions data for CO are largely based on estimates that employ emission factors generated from empirical and engineering studies, rather than on actual measurements of CO emissions. Although these estimates are generated using well - established approaches, the estimates have uncertainties inherent in the emission factors and emissions models used to represent sources for which emissions have not been directly measured. The methodology for estimating emissions is continually reviewed and is subject to revision. Trend data prior to any revisions must be considered in the context of those changes. Not all states and local agencies provide the same data or level of detail for a given year. This information last updated on 06/01/2009 http: / /cfpub.epa.gov /eroe/ index.cfm ?fuseaction = detail. viewlnd &lv= list.listByAlpha &r =18... 1/18/2010 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE �o�itr I. PURPOSE OF POLICY This regulation contains The City of Charlottesville's Policy relating to the idling of any and all city fleet vehicles. Idling refers to the operating of a motor vehicle or equipment, regardless of fuel type, while that vehicle is stationary. Effective immediately, it is the policy of the City of Charlottesville that City fleet vehicles will not be stationary with the engine operating for more than 5 minutes unless it is essential for performance of work or otherwise specified below. When engines must be left operating, for any reason, the operator will remain with the unit. This Anti - Idling Policy applies to all City owned or leased motor vehicles and equipment. It also extends to City contractors, subcontractors, and vendors doing business with the City. The unnecessary idling of gasoline and diesel vehicles and equipment wastes fuel, contributes to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, and causes premature engine wear. It is every City employee's responsibility to minimize fleet operating costs while reducing harmful effects to the environment. Violators are subject to disciplinary action. The purposes of this Policy are to: • Reduce fuel consumption e of Policy: (i.e. FISCAL) Policy Number: 100 -12 ject: Idling Reduction Policy for Motor Vehicles & Equipment culated for Comment /Approval of Lead "Team? Yes F Date: 7/31/07 uthorization: Gary O'Connell, City Manager Signature of City Manager: 6,( "V -'" ' J� Effective Date: 9/17/2007 I. PURPOSE OF POLICY This regulation contains The City of Charlottesville's Policy relating to the idling of any and all city fleet vehicles. Idling refers to the operating of a motor vehicle or equipment, regardless of fuel type, while that vehicle is stationary. Effective immediately, it is the policy of the City of Charlottesville that City fleet vehicles will not be stationary with the engine operating for more than 5 minutes unless it is essential for performance of work or otherwise specified below. When engines must be left operating, for any reason, the operator will remain with the unit. This Anti - Idling Policy applies to all City owned or leased motor vehicles and equipment. It also extends to City contractors, subcontractors, and vendors doing business with the City. The unnecessary idling of gasoline and diesel vehicles and equipment wastes fuel, contributes to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, and causes premature engine wear. It is every City employee's responsibility to minimize fleet operating costs while reducing harmful effects to the environment. Violators are subject to disciplinary action. The purposes of this Policy are to: • Reduce fuel consumption /Mid CP- caap • Reduce engine wear • Protect the health of employees and citizens through reduction of harmful vehicle emissions Reduce the volume of greenhouse gases attributed to vehicle emission as part of the City's commitment to climate protection (reference US Mayors Climate Protection Agreement, signed in 2006) II. ENABLING ORDINANCES /LEGISLATION N/A III. DEPARTMENTS /DIVISIONS AFFECTED All City Departments and City contractors, subcontractors and vendors doing business with the City. IV. REGULATIONS AND PROCEDURES A. SPECIFIC PROVISIONS 1. Heavy Duty Diesel Powered Motor Vehicles The following provisions shall apply to the operation and start-up of heavy -duty diesel powered motor vehicles. For the purposes of this section, the term "heavy - duty" shall apply to any motor vehicle with a gross vehicle weight of more than 8,500 pounds or with a passenger carrying capacity of more than 12 persons (i.e., passenger transport vehicles) a. No operator shall permit, cause or allow the engine of a heavy -duty diesel powered motor vehicle to idle prior to or at the conclusion of, any trip or route for any period of time beyond that which is reasonably required to attain, or to secure from, normal operating conditions. The maximum allowable period of idling shall not exceed two (2) consecutive minutes or zero (0) for layovers, except under the following initial start-up conditions: (i). The engine may be idled for the purpose of start-up for a period of up to five (5) consecutive minutes when the ambient temperature is more than 32 °F 0( °C), and /or until the air pressure on the vehicle has reached the proper operating PSI, and /or until the destination signs on a Charlottesville Transit Service (CTS) vehicle are in proper working order. (ii). The engine may be idled for the purpose of start -up for a period of up to fifteen (15) consecutive minutes when the ambient temperature is less than 32 °F (0 10, and/or until the air pressure on the vehicle has reached the proper operating PSI, and /or until the destination signs on a CTS vehicle are in proper working order. I /l f fio 6XP (iii). Any CTS vehicle dwelling at a scheduled transfer point, such as the Downtown Transit Station, Barracks Road Shopping Center, or Fashion Square Mall may idle from the time of arrival until scheduled departure and the driver may step away from the vehicle for a short period subject to receiving approval from the CTS dispatcher. b. No operator shall permit, cause or allow the engine of a heavy -duty diesel powered motor vehicle to be accelerated while idling at any time. 2. Pupil Transportation Vehicles (School Buses) In addition to the provisions outlined in Subsection A, the following shall specifically apply to the operation of school buses. a. When school bus drivers arrive at loading or unloading areas to drop off or pick up passengers, they should turn off their buses as soon as possible to eliminate idling time and reduce harmful emissions. The school bus should not be restarted until it is ready to depart and there is a clear path to exit the pick -up area. Exceptions include conditions that would compromise passenger safety, such as extreme weather conditions, idling in traffic, and when there is concern about restarting the vehicle in a timely manner. When a school bus driver believes it is necessary to idle a bus in a pick up area, the driver should contact the Pupil Transportation dispatcher for approval. b. Buses should not idle while waiting for students during field trips, extracurricular activities or other events where students are transported off school grounds. c. In colder weather, if the warmth of the bus is an issue, idling is to be at a very minimum and occur outside the school zone. The "warmed" bus is to enter the school zone as close to pick -up time as possible to maintain warmth and then shut down. 3. Service Delivery Vehicles All service delivery vehicles shall turn off the engines while making deliveries or pickups. 4. Refueling Refueling operations shall be conducted with vehicle engines and external equipment shut off. This includes times when portable fuel cans or on -board equipment, such as a generator, is being fueled. Responsibility for shutting down the vehicle lies with the driver /operator. B. EXCEPTIONS IIIf110 Due to the diverse nature of the City's vehicle fleet, in terms of vehicle type, function and operating characteristics, a series of operational exemptions to this policy are listed below: 1. Emergency vehicles and equipment while engaged in operational activities, responding to emergency situations, or performing an activity directly related to a public safety function. 2. Vehicles that are required to idle in order to operate auxiliary equipment (including but not limited hydraulic equipment, welding equipment, pumps, compressors, or lights). 3. Vehicles equipped with temperature sensitive equipment. 4. Vehicles that must be kept at an appropriate temperature for the health and safety of occupants being transported (persons or animals). 5. Vehicles and equipment that are being serviced; times when actual mechanical work is being performed on a vehicle that necessitates the engine needs to idle for a longer period. V. CONSEQUENCES OF VIOLATION OF POLICY Violators of this policy will be subject to disciplinary action. VI. RELATED FORMS AND SCHEDULES // 0 r n` i eF,q WHAT ARE SOME OF THE PROBLEMS Use auxiliary Dower SAVE MONEY AN[ Y units Instead of the IDLING WASTES FUEL AND MONEY engine to provide • A typical truck burns approximately one gallon of diesel 1 3 i2EDUIC E PC�l��,,i tT l�1 electric power. VAT, 4 ;0L- SHE1,1 D NAPiW, :w- -- - °•��- days a year, it would consume 1,800 gallons of fuel per year, simply idling. I I Aft C �� I At a price of $1.25 per gallon of diesel, this idling comes \/ G with a price tag of $2,250 per truck. New England All r Q I1E I DLFING Visit www.epa.gov /ne/ W„JC eco /diesel /, or call the speeds. According to the American Trucking Association, EPA Air Quality Hotline at such wear can increase maintenance costs by almost $2,000 per year and shorten the life of the engine. WHAT CAN You Do? Turn, Ott yair engine when your vehicle is not in motion. Use electric engine heaters to minimize warm- uptime. Diesel engines play an important role in the transport of goods and services nationwide. They are a durable and economical source of power. However, there is growing concern about the health effects associated with exposure to diesel exhaust. Diesel exhaust affects everyone, but people with existing heart or lung disease, asthma, or other respiratory problems are most sensitive to the small particles in diesel exhaust. Fortunately, new emission standards and new technology are helping to ensure that the cleaner diesel engines of the future will dramatically reduce these health risks. If you drive a truck, there are several things that you can do now to save money and reduce pollution. _ 1 '. WHAT ARE SOME OF THE PROBLEMS Use auxiliary Dower ASSOCIATED WITH IDLING? units Instead of the IDLING WASTES FUEL AND MONEY engine to provide • A typical truck burns approximately one gallon of diesel 1 fuel for each hour it idles. , electric power. • If this truck idles for 6 hours per day and operates 300 :w- -- - °•��- days a year, it would consume 1,800 gallons of fuel per year, simply idling. I I Aft C �� I At a price of $1.25 per gallon of diesel, this idling comes \/ G with a price tag of $2,250 per truck. New England For more Information: IDLING CAUSES EXCESSIVE ENGINE WEAR Running an engine at low speed (idling) causes twice the Visit www.epa.gov /ne/ wear on internal parts compared to driving at regular eco /diesel /, or call the speeds. According to the American Trucking Association, EPA Air Quality Hotline at such wear can increase maintenance costs by almost $2,000 per year and shorten the life of the engine. 1- 800 - 821 -1237 UNNECESSARY IDLING CAUSES POLLUTION • Idling vehicles can emit significant amounts of pollution including: carbon dioxide, which contributes to global - climate change; nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds, both of which contribute to the formation of l ozone smog; poisonous carbon monoxide; and particulate matter. IDLING POSES HEALTH RISKS TO DRIVERS • While sitting in an idling vehicle, drivers are exposed to the vehicle's pollution more so than when the vehicle is in motion since there is no air flow to vent the emissions. cenhnued D 1111110.an CJ SAVE MONEY AND REDUCE UNNECESSARY IDLING —STEPS YOU CAN TAKE: • Turn off your engine when your vehicle is not in motion. (Follow manufacturers recommendations for cool -down — usually 3 -5 minutes after full load operation.) Follow manufacturers recommendations for minimum warm -up time — usually 3 to 5 minutes depending on the vehicle. • Use electric engine heaters (such as block heaters) to minimize idling time during warm -up, especially in cold weather. Install a small generator or auxiliary power unit specifically designed for a truck that provides heat, air conditioning, and /or electrical power while the vehicle is not in motion. These devices are a better, more efficient alternative to idling as they use substantially less fuel and emit less pollution. Depending on the amount of time spent idling each year, the payback on these devices can be one to two years. • When buying new equipment, purchase engines already equipped with devices that minimize idling and warm -up time automatically. • Follow anti- idling laws and guidelines in your state. Currently, three New England states have anti- idling laws: Connecticut, Massachusetts, and New Hampshire. FACTS ABOUT DIESEL ENGINES AND IDLING Although there are some legitimate reasons why trucks and buses idle (e.g., to bring the engine to proper operating temperature), there are also some misconceptions. i Must engine manufacturers P.f,01Yln1P,lld that hewer INITIAL STARTING / WARM-UP TIME engines nut for roughly 3 -5 Most engine manufacturers recommend that newer engines run for roughly 3 -5 minutes before driving. In colder climates, block heaters are a good alternative to excessive idling. ninnutes before and after They plug into electrical outlets and help warm the engine to avoid starting difficulties and driving. reduce idling time during engine warm -up. , RESTARTING Today's winter blends of Although engine manufacturers recommend that you let your engine idle for a few diesel fuel are much less minutes after you stop, most newer diesel engines will stay warm for several hours after likely t0 gel In Cold weather. they have been running, retaining more than enough heat to keep the engine warm and avoid starting difficulties. Older vehicles may have more difficulty restarting, but don't assume new engines should be operated like older ones. Check the manufacturer's Letting an engine iclleactually recommendations. does mere damage to the engine than starting and FUEL GELLING Gelling of diesel fuel used to be a problem years ago, but refiners have worked to resolve stopping. that issue by creating winter blends that better withstand colder temperatures. ENGINE WEAR AND TEAR Letting an engine idle actually does more damage to the engine than starting and stopping. Running an engine at low speed (idling) causes twice the wear on internal parts compared to driving at regular speeds, which can increase maintenance costs and shorten \`�/ E PA the life of the engine. Generally, fuel consumption during engine start -up is equivalent to about 30 seconds of engine idling. New England 1 Congress Street Suite 1100 Boston, MA 02114 -2023 www.epa.gov/ne/eco/diesel/ EPA Air Quality Hotline: 1- 800 - 821 -1237 3 �' m o a m m' 3_ �o � o m d 3 3 F- Q .� m m a m c 0- m N <� s m? m m 0340 m n c LO n m m o n '� n " o T m a s m m omi `° c Cl J y (p c 3aoma O 3�'m� N F m m m O N S (D N O d N N o S D _ 'm 0o m m O-' :E 0 5" o c a o a m c a 3 N S M _d m N m o a j O F 3 N c < c Orono o- n _ O c m J c C Q S J m m O m J 0 m 0' an d N W m 0 S< 0 m N y m N O c n m J m N< 3 m vm, O O S O c -n < y d m N O O O N 3y S a m m m O N N m m a O J O O y F < o O 3 J ^ J O m �. 0 0 N" p y n J J m ' y0 0Qm m S 3 y m 0 O O O 9 E m - J N sm< 3 mm -3 00o Lo'o ° 3 s Q a 1 m a < ' m c (O d N (O m m (O S m O m O = J m O � J S � m S � m S ,< m N 0 O a 9I C J m m o c O a o o c N n f � m J < y S � Q � m N m m N 0 0 0 0 In N O O O n m m C Cl) O^ T y� O 0_ m d m D 3 -o a^ m y i 0 CD CL m a O a 0 7 J a X 0 J a S m 0 10 J m m m l0 C N .m. m O p m m n J O J m S J a mi to < X C 0 CD vni 0 S N G. O_ N? C N m m m. m m m o C J c O. ,< J' N O N n m N m gym, o m 3 Q g a J o$ °w m a n J J J N m N X N 411 m y a N J =< S d S O< aCD m? m d m m < 0 0 o m -00 y m n 0 0 ' 0 J -O J m m (D 611 00 0 0' L. ou a m J m `2 y O C< o . N J a m O J J O m J m< J O a X o m m a X J O m m (D d n X N n 40 a s o m a Ci O D !� m.-. N �. °: m m Z m N p. 0 0 M a S 3' m o 3 F N N p 411 ? S N Nn a o m m m e 0 a .mom. ' E m d a o < o D m n of m O m c - J 3 =m Nan T m n m 3 m a mn ^ l0 O< - N c S J `< m 5'0 N m to 3 m m< N J a m a m m m'o m 3 .a .< O m y N c P a m J 3 m c_ y m j" m m 3 O (O t0 N m 0 CD �mmmmmN °40 N" O^ y S m m m N N N cr c ems! C. L O C O J a J C (n a O O. 7 T O 41 3 N m Z m N D C) O N n C N a r m b b O O W 6 U N O FINE 1/1 n/P w m d y m° xD a N o m m cM o o 3 J m 3 Q cD (Q m p m N N N (Q 0 0 m< W J� M C S m N O N <. .y. S N '' a ow 3'a S f0 J N »' C 6= N A O O. J< (D fD m tin w m m CD C d w m o DN' o f >> m c° 3 m `D m n. s 3 f0 m ? O a N 7 O o D O o a• cc ID w 3W o n a o o 3 J m d a 3 (D (D (D N C w m 0 N D. m N y o C O T. N N O m J O J m o. w w N. o c co 2 3 Z m° °a.. o m m o'° 'o ° 'm m _ �. C v S <D o c N m `N J ' 0 s N w ^ J J O 0 m N N m O C N w N ° O fC0 F N ° S N O O O m S NJ 0 CD $ c 9 o o0 3 m o m F, D m w m m m Q d N o 3 .0. w w (D C .. d < O O 0 Q 3 Er — en m o O < (°J- , :E CD m c o ° o c m ° mm (w o >O > ¢ m X Z:m f0 > ��O T 3m m m w m - w _ X Cc ? J fQ cD a w N (o m o o o m _ 3 o 3 o o 3 o 3 CD _ Dx' o J F H F . O y 3 N Q m N (D �. N a m O �_ O. O ".' A m N "33 ty J O 'O �' m f0 C J J ¢ O N 3 C y m w Fr (D O N J y d G tG y. y° O ¢ m (D N¢ O w S m �' o O CD n ° n y C m m m n m o o ¢ ¢ w D N N O 3 m 0 0 m O d= .. .. J O !O � `J a y O m a 0m �a 3 ° O y O 3< J O w j m 3 m J m m 0 m 3 o a a 3 <° a m w m m m m 3 N m f w C 7 y m w O m fD 3 J y w O f0 si O a� m y °; N� N m m m ¢ ?'. C m w fmii O C O ry y m fmll c' �0 3 G O O m 0 J y J m o m a -I 3 m om c 3 �D o �' 3 m w o m �D m m w m J C y¢ J 3 w m N S w .< 3 m O 0� J S o cc y o Nm _? ° m 0 w m m S '° O m a t3 0 C m v m O' m m J m m m m m Ov m '. 5 m¢ °? c < °m o ° . 3_ 3 0 ^o 3 ° O o �, D J 0 O w< m m 1 J N m < o n o y A y v m 3 O 0 0 0 n n O O C - m s o N m n m 7 yS O ° ° w < m mF o O ^ O O O (D w O 3 3 y) 0 3 N Q O a n 0 w m n O K D (D m y S p < ° G_ 0 m J M N 6 a C" m w b b ffG N N O M w D d O y �L N N s N � N N N =Q 4 N N N n N O � j O C Q N O 6 Q N O � O `NG � O N N � N N j O N � N O N Q Z n 2 0 0 m � o y 3 m m m N d m N m d T � � x N � d N O r. 7 � O N O � N N d n m o N s o Q N 1/i9//n CIO ORP m 3 N_ O N Q W 0 a m w b W � fIQ N U W N � O_ .y O W 1/19(,0 Cv OMP z � c r c Z n tr CD v o cn g C> -< o O rn ate_; cn m Do m cn Cl) o 0 �. O O AD s CD 7 m x o m 3 v 2 O <_ CO J D D o.D0 v�cr D °a m U) N cD N d cn J cD 3 3 v° 00 J m m n O m a °= m �. °° O o 0 3= 0 M m p m (CD O 0 3 O J 7 z- O (p_ N(D S c c' � O 3 z 'O Cn j < M m m O o-`G O J N (O J N-0 p J 3 3 - .O. 7--0 O 0''< 0 0 O O C C7 m m N ym0 3 a <' m J (D O (D (D 0 N 3 m o p o c D v » N D� p (p 0 J m CD V `< N O X Q N n Cn y N Q c a 0� FD J N < J O ti< Q _.O : CD J N < o (D 0 S o O O m N ;' Cl CD 3 y a J O_ d Q p o CD J N M N S N O N m n m O^" 7 N _ a p J Cl) O * .0 m S m N : J= W m J m z CD o ° 3 m CD - C S p a m _. - (D m 0 - J a 0 c Z7 y (a m Q S� o o ��6? N W � m ' W=cn d'O -COD 3 00 (D O -� O O J (D ma ,..'J'N (D (O -' M -I - — o m o o m a- N o m J Ol o 3 3 ° =vm,Ommoa �° ?. 6 o N 1 O a) 0 J s o-�a0 0m o0 00 CD Q rn CD rn CD p d 3 3 m Z C a N N N 3 W N m O O CD o .$z5 < N �2 J 2 •-2 2 J m m J N N d N Om m Z a o o ! o N N • (D (D O O l O �' o' • (DI a (O O 7 J c HI O J iil C Q I I _!m CD _w J ti z x E C7 O G J J CL N W A N O 0 CD D 0 N 1/19(,0 Cv OMP s, `!;' =w 1 t x �� r o° Cl) r c n tr CD � g o O rn ate_; z :a cn m T O n s Z 3 v 2 z CO D v�cr N v cn s, `!;' =w 1 t x �� r N ID 7 S O C 7 v U) Q (D C 0-0 0) (D m 3v m 0;mcom 7 K O N (O c 3 D)3 my < s CD av °-3a fD fD 52-22 N O N O O- (D N COD O O O CD y O N D O W y(2 3- c°m -� E9 7 7 n y O N 0 S](p O FO R-0 3 Soa o� -0�7 d 7 -7S 0 � 3 o m m N m (p O n D1 pp (D O S D) (p .7 -4 (n I , (D 7 y 3 CJT C C p (O O. (D (D 00 N 0 7 CD j O O. 7 0 p- _ O COD_ -� 0 (p - _' y 'COD f (7 m p m m 0 a m 3 cc = y n 3' .7.. O N (D °- "p- ^Zl n O O C C (D (D 7 Q NC0 O O O (O O S ' m 7 CD 7 7 O O O) _O S 3 N i °o n m f J O d C S < 3 p f0 (D (D S 0 N y d N N O~ 7 0.0 (p 0 0.0 z: n ' O O 7 O O y 3 m m mm ° m O N (D O O" Fad CD O ' 3 • C D m c - C ao-a n CO * _. j n (c D n 7 < FD D cn N d, o v N 3 C N a m mca_a a fD �. C 7 cc m � � 7 (O C o 0 y ( 7) O C n y v 7 CL A O D) N Q y O y 3 D) C CD m S D) o, O O 1 Q O C5 (n n m N 0 Z z CD ZE y CS A 'O T 'O 'O A c) O O C C (T 3 0 co (D p 0 S -O N N 3 7 (D S O _ N � N `G 7 S (D (D y "p D) (D M m D7'° m 7 0 3 j d -0N y S R qm �CMD<<a E N O N Hi a N (D (O C 7 .. N D) N N (D C p 7 (D 7? 7 D1 O O o m 0° j O (D 'c 7 N (O I O VtONN-OO CD 0 C 3 O W N 7 (D O- y 7o co o d m -p = 3 c a w n. 0 p (o m o 3 Q p o m o D y N = 2 ' S0 (D O �3 =<;, C (D X 3. iO O) > 7 7 a) (O 3 'O 0 C O ms m W- Ny7_ -p3 id < � O O O O C . M (D O- � N y S C O O O O 7 7 D La: ^ -0 s S 7 C CD N. a 3 0-E -3 N Q� o (D D) y� Q C 7 (D CD (D d `G 6 (D 7 D) (O N y N p p N (O 3 o 3 y 7 0 D) y D) (D 0 3 o S N 0 7 7 -p O W N 7 C 3 N i O N O O70 O O d (D < = 0 O 7 O (O CD 7 O 00 3 0 (D -' O N O monmD)om y _Sy CD _0_0 CD 2 (D 3 -0 (D 7 . 0 D) D y 7 .. (D -O O O N O D) -O 0 `< CD -0 y -0 (D 7 3-0 0 O N- 7 D < d W 0 y y n. N 7. Q (D D) C O y 7 y N. 0 _, CD y T C d N y (Op 0 O Qy SO Dv, o' 7 3 -0oo(D�CD omD 1 -0 7p CD a w_o 0 CD S a- 5' D tD (D 0) 0 CD -c m o' CD M 3 cc 70 _ y 3 CD O (D - D) O. 5 y 7 (D .7.. O CL co ti p) Ina) 1 In Z' CD 0 Q 4D A) "D :A ii �v 3 C Q. 0 l? rn C O n Z ,k v y r i W N r o N n o 3 O J m N cn o M N -0 M. m T m m N 0 cn 3 v m' I N° o N � 71 O = M � v ° m O 2 0 v N' N n v m O cnr-ZKKm>mO5 ��Ocn=Ozzom {w o o 7 m J' m N M (D m y 3. iTl iio d 7 S m 7 m 7 a y D W O r 7 S .T1 m` y 07 w o o m y n O obi G� p N m° oQ mn�_ ma c7TCL °0mT �. j m Q �. 3 7 O" Cn S C N N Z N (D N 5'.0 O - o N N _D O» 70C (n ?' 7 N N -' O 7 M 2 N n cn m 7 O o v D O m ° z' o o n N ° v O o Dc m p m 7 j O J o T N O p 7 G y N' p z D.. (O n J J 7 n CD CD S o �. OG j 3 N m J Q n v n N N O W Q M v cnm0OG)� �o Dvmmc cn�<cn�< 3 w 0 x _ 7 7OT o O C< x N J =f d C 7 N N y m C J :3 (D Q Q O G O �: _ a 0 m 3 Q O_ m Q OJ O CL -u-, W - (D zSm m 0 0 N m N< ?.a O p z m _ -0 v QN. G O O� 3', Z-l: Do 3J v ic?<.c O ^p _ 71 O j CD NO 7 _ O Z N m 7 to 7. x M m y O W 0 0 7 m O N S Q N O- y 7 N N C y 0 6 O 7 J p� N (] N m N - m v N M N 7 7 Q m 7. O J N 7 v N m W m O ° i < S v O m a 3 7 m O :E m (° a v O J = 7 c m f� o P � I O I i N � 0 c C) m ° v O 3 m -p ° 7 3 v m D °);a3 n Da m --� 3 Fr G M J. d X O < 3 o m m <a) SR C = J o J 7 G. W m J (D O 7 J 7 C 7 y �0 v D3-° m m O n 7 N tV 7 cl) N J v m N D v N m 0 7 y D N Dm _ o v N m O S O M n D' p 7 O O p m N 7 Q 7. DE, O O J 10 7 C j j X= m OG.m o'o_ 3 7 E; v w - d 7 j N o v v m m � a B 7 m N N '^ 3 .-. (T O S I M ° 7 7 (O y V q Cn n m ° 3 Om M fl �C m O Q < m 7 ti v 7 N G C) C 7 Q v m 3 m J m 7 Q o x o m F ? F Q m Q G p (O O m G a 7 v m O N C m O 0-0 N 3 G N ° O d O 3 7 J 7 m Q a J m X �(O N v J ° m N O cc O 7 7 p' 0 O O N c c o N 7 m Q 6 o(° m v (n m m o 0 �3.3N N N O O J CA J N N A m "G CD 0 O CQ CD Cn rn Q ro Df ry m CD C7 CD CD Q a CD Al a> s_ CD N y c �f c�- s1 � AV E�. m m m o m o > m m x m g D O m N Q < G N D .0 N O CL a0 D 0 O 0 N - O J T (D 7 cf) �mO O - N � ( N D 0 0 C-) CD S ;z C7 o o o 3 m 3 O N 0 ^mW y w N G D = . < (D O . (p a (D N Oc n O m m CD m a A Do ?tom' o > > m N y C m m m w a (D O m 0 �' C m a m c<^ D a � m m m m (n _ SO r C) n0 o O<o O� O� m O m N m O� - m ofa> S o>oD - mm �o ED 3m _� a 3.(o a��o_v 3'0 CD N N = 0 O o° �° m m m m` CD C)0 O< u a' a' = O 0 V00 (0j O c 0) m v m rnm m m N Q 0 42 6 O' N m < m m p Q) W O W .... Co N OD Cn N A W N N O 0 O O O J O O) O O J J J # 0 o m m m (D m m Im N m N 0 fk o CD 0 � (D 3 o. N CD CD m N m m 3 ` Q c CD r 7 a < O N 0 =3 A O • O 3 N (U a CC G a -, D a N m N om m a a 0 (D S S Q pi O ( D 3 CD a 0 (D a 3 \ <' m to N X ti N O in n m S S — J 3 N 0 o m N (D Q °y o a a a a Q m � 0 c � o a m 3 3 PC mCL m n Z G) n Z n m ;o m z 0 m N z v m C) c O m m Z G) U) x o � �m o m ma 0 3 < N N m � m m Q a 3 m Q 0) n m Co N O A 0) t O O D D S p Z Z cn -O O' O l N D O 0'0 • • .Z 7 ?N .=. O -i " . 7 7 FD- ( W W T � T n (C O N .S D O C: G CD . W N Cr N .Dl (D _ N N D (D O (D OW O -O< W Oca C, Cy T, ID co3 oc m7WO�W3 cD� �o2 ?�DNNco—a 000 oc CM, �a�- (A mN.F`0mmNcrn�� z -G 2-3 3 (D "6 7 p C N O W W N 7 N W C, O 7 O 7 S G W (D W O O (D 7 m (n W? v '< Z W 7m .o_� N W ��< ° Dim m D cn Ill 0 CL ,. a '1'1 m N c ° m o° o n O m o o m m y.�' Q W 7 D x cNi x W is a-6 N_ 7 N N c n �, s � = W 6 0 Z m m v ° o c 6 CD ° O 7 0 5 m< n-0 m 3 D 7 I C z m NNm NN �7c SA.2F.o %0 3maNm�v�. 3= m Q W < W (] "O 7 7 N j' N -' (p N (p 7' O 0 7 SI C Z o '< 'G c 0_ c0 c0 W Q m 0< m �o0 �0 cD �< W 3-0 -pW fi o m =CD m m W ?(D D ® tb Cl) c� W :E 0 W W N W 3 3 Q N C O S @ ? N_ Q O Nom. > y N (D � N 3 W 3 W ° (D C 5-1 W (D W ,�' O C) 7_ ;O -° (D W Q a- � CD 0 W °— W 7 O m ? 7W n 3 °° 5� N m s m m = W m 0 j' 0 7, W 0 m W v (D O � NOS Nom o a�'o -10 n (C2 f 3 g o 0 0 0�� °- CQ O o O 0 0 (O N N C W 6 N r: C O C 7 S (O in Lty W ODD D) I. V7 �'c 0-0 ' � `G ° rN 1 (O m(D y'= W (W (0 m 9' o c 0 3 o- W c a a 7 y a< CD CD < N V? E7 N C N) y CD y. W W W 7 ,+ C N N W 7 _ _ CD CL W O O (D N O 7 O W N m O: N G 7 (D �S W W l'fD O$ G al 6 .� O. 0 O 5 N -0 S (D 0 D 7 0 7 (D n S r W W CD o O O N O O x c0 O S N .+ j? O (D W 3 7 0 7 ,< C) O 7 (D O 'J " O. N (O O WY C 5-0 0 O �. 7 [D n O. Q N L W �. O S G W 7 (p N W j W j 0 C t 7 7 0 �` p �. O_ O cWi 3 � W ° (�° ° -'3 W =3 cD 2 3 O 7 C O O -' N W c, c 0 c 7 7 a °< 0 m W 0 0 3 y (D 0 W ,_3 7 W m ,� 3-C a CDm gOm W N - CD O j jp W v Q • W N 7 Dom) "0 0 4 p C 0 0 O- (D = cD)p 0 O 2 3 C N W 'G W D °—� a� 3'< Ac o W n�0 3 a° T3 I CL (D' 0 (D 7 (D (O co C S 0 .0 N y a N N W O W 3 == 3 N O, C W° y (D -O N (D N 7 W O (Sp C O M. y N W 7 3° < W W �' O (D D O y CD 7 .<t p S (O W �. O. ? N o N (D N_ O a m n (O N) N CD W s0 CD CD m a`D0�='.7 �a0 3 0 S�7- o W o o .� CL W O W 7 W N 7 (D • p W W O O a d N (Q .0 Cl) a tU M < O �. < C (p ? O y 3' o `< ° o m �D v 0 N= 7 D J i' O N W Cr S C N 7 F. �n O i d Dj 0 W H.vQ (D 0 S°" (D C .2 : 0 O (D W p Q p CD °- =1 0- i7 0 J O W O W C N Q _ N'c0 (D N O O -'O b.T (SDI °-d O O y s c g m c 0 CD M N (D W O Ul O a ° 7 7 p 0) 0 O 0 W (D 7 f�l? //0 av;vp GP� 4 Y , �T a m = Q.3;=, = i7 w ° 0 I CO CD (O w w G C (p (� w C O 0 w N (D - N (D N n (D 3. N ID 1,D (D C O OD N fD Gl ^7'" .Ji. (Q Cn d O O O'O N w 7 �..,, N `� -O O. 5' 7 G p- C 0.�.7?t`� =i_D 'C co�o0ton r1� moo 0 0 ti ? N O. N V 0 CD Co O " JC N ~= OS N i "O O 21 0, (O -x0 w �. GR 7 O < d O O3 N K N w � 7 O n 3 (' n o = G 0 ID ID z C 3 K (D O N S o CD N N C �': y w N 0 (Op O ❑... -2.0 0 0 7 7 3 'p C .0.. O O N J L °cam (D C 7 (O (00' (D (D O O 7 n Q < (D O S v CD N (D (D c N (D rr O m O N �, N m 0 N_ (Sp m "�C 3. N _O_ w 500 C N m c C o go w D 3 n (D O O 7 N 3• w (p .N-. (D `G �' N O 7� _ (D 3 m N 3. Q 0 7 J' (D (.Q O OS C C w Z _ O 7 0 0 Q .7.. O (D 3 (O 0 N O C N 'w N ro C N (�; 00 _< in 0 " Cc 0 3w7 .+ w (D _ 0.0 3 .N.. 0,,:-=. y� 7 o = O O c o _a 3 CD Cr c � b cp o-v o 33 —a0 3 cci m � 0_ M� o'a) CD o� N. o N �' c y a °� ��,. -0o m coil c O 7 a lb J m C» JCL f°•m '' cN -gymo0 3 70 w '(D w O O N C D O C i N O O o 7 B Jc O O_ JC d d N W N �. w O--O N ( fD N. `� 0 y T(D (D p. O J O N -O O w O 0 3 w r: O- xi O O- (D N " 7 N N (D �_ (D N _Q (n y O (D � E (D w- C 0 w p 2 K (D O (D (D �D '(O A aN H J O 7� d W �O w N O 7 J j d3 N (D .0.. 03 �D = w CL m a n o E w CD o m-0 —Do CD a) 0 D x Q -0 o ? v N 3: C w o a n m N 0 (u (o 7 N b' CD w N 03(nw O 3(nd('1 d S 3 3w -Tj CL (D N #O NO:O (D O J. 0; co (-F' O'O <�wo =w rn =-03< o o w 7 90 0 O .. O .. w �. (O .. .. A \ .C. CD ? Q) (D j (D .Z $25 w v O (D < r (D 0 O 2 O 2 2 (D OX o.D w D w 3 N v� o m w3.o.0 3 ? N II go o o 3 7 0 3 7 0. w w m <D �n N >'w n w �-r J.0 j w S' O O > N NO II < Q7 J �� a7 7 �(D (D Q(D ON CD O J N 0 °OD w (D 3 rn m J' 3 o 7 'O.S. 0 3 Q (D N COD � N. 90 w = w cr 0 0_ O0 O a) CL 1 O N N (D D . N< N ?n C w M•�3 0 3�N�� 0N)nw0m 00� 0 0 m i 9 0 0 p w- i 3 J CD 51N S �_ w N.N =N N NON N 7 O�i3 _ d 3 N X Zx7 O O N O N N 0(D N@ N 0 3 w O w ?(D Zgoo 7 7 S CD w J Np7� N .. (D �. N S(p a N N -. �3 3 N N (D C CL a) 7 C o? ? ° �_ U) _l< �"CD a N rn� �= N C -' N N m (n A o N O (D O. oO O O 3 S U (D 6 N 0-0 X o- 5'? O (D O .w.O N v w0 (D J' < r W x m 3 .w r, N O O (D O •. O C O K 0 O.. ? 4 O fJA 7w ° o 3 o mom, o rn CD a rn m o- O� O Vo 0 o N m cw 0 a0 LO CD w D N O O N O w O ^ //"00 t 'k St(� 4 Oy � o ?a`�3D(� S O C N � Q C (D n (D C X� ^ 0 n O N 0 C = O O w CD o0 3 m 3 ((DD ; 7 (D '1. N j (� O M. 0 c? CD O N< O O G Z7 (D O Qm 0n' N. WA? d D oN3 co: � s�vo �(D - m 0c _ m Cy ID o 0 0 CL CD 0 NO N N ~ m � S 3 v v (p O 2 N N 7 (D _ Et 0 COD D7 �c 7 N i S 7 Dl (D O N O y' (D (O N d(O 7 (0D 7 /D (O - '3 0 �< d °- �. 3 m -o CD j = �_ o S (D N j 0 0 0 ? CCD y'O c S 03 N 0 aXZ(o 0 0 a 3, _ m _ o 7 ,Oy 7 0 N O c (D (Q Q (p m 00 7 N O ; S (O O O C 00 -0"O N S W QSQ_O N N �. N.y� 0 0 0 N N N (O 7 6 N CD 1. O d 3 0 (D (D 7 N 3 wS a N N � O 3 Q p1 N N O C G (D S 3 L7 (D C N N m m m N 7 c .Ni Q O O N 7' O c (O 0 O (p N O 7 (D C N N O Q O d �'m 3 X = N N N 2. (D n Q 0 CD S 0 O C N CD Q C p CD N N C a) z 3 m 0 s S (D O N N -00 '< N i 1. 7 Q 3• N O S 7 O� (D (D N O �' 0 61 Q X 0 CD CD 'O 0 D 0 7 (D 7 D j C). CL TO C: 0 O. N (D Q Q 0 0 7 C 7c = 7 m m o d 3 -(D < < 7 4 S 7 7 mNCL <� °� (D S N (0/1 C m D) (D DI d N (T m - O ,� 0. (D O 0 O m m (= o 3 °-6 w o m o 0 (D CD 0 CL 7 Z Q N CL CD 0 0 M W 0 a, (D N v (� 3 N fQ N 3 (D n m a m Z 0 Z r fD ro c� CD m K n� co ro At 03 0 b H CD lb 4:f n O H n Z C T7 D 0 C m z m N ID 3 * CD a-0 C CD Ol7 0 C S Q 0 N O C n � CL N (D N O N O PI) (Q 3 m 3 O a > O (D ,N., (D D QNO�. p D n 0 0 0 0 7 N Q D "00 O N -i�C - N ' Q3 Q v0 p 3m sm ° m D w 0 m(D a O Q Q 7 3 3 .e _ 0 0 < O O N 0 0 3. D 3 �. o 7 O N X 0 7? N (O D) N K (D 0 0 o S m C (O D 7 S N r" o DI - 0 3' S (D -+. N O CD f N (D o c 3 0 3< N CD CED n N N 3 T Ul m O O 7 d v C 0 0 3 v o N 7 N o 7 p_ 7' N 0-3 Q Zm n �. °c (D o< '< D m Q' Q O m o- CD Q 0 3 W o. 0 � (D (SD CD " 0 n � O D (D (D S < O 03 00 -� S 3 * (D 3= N S (D CD D 0 D S CL CE O m (Q cr (D ,N., 3 0 9c � Q - O N N (D N lD 3 ' Q3 < a- n 3 p N m < �Da0�O CC n Zl y (D (D 0 N C D w x j o Q 3< m (00 m N N =_ < m j S O C Q,7:l (D S N Q' Q O D N 0 X (D N o m ,OY (D S < m 03 d v (D ammo.CD I f m Q m -o < m c' m x a, �o �3 ma m D C m n °0' '< ^ ( D 7 w <D 0' �, O .Z7 N M ( S N D W N 7 CL 7 O n O 5 � C m 3 N o m c m � n = CC CD 3 a o Vi $1 m c a, 4 Q 70 ro ct Q z CQ CA 0 d rD ro ro n y �h �d y n 90 O m c N CD N N u 7 O i Illf /lD ,-w !` 7 S 7 a O a o CD om ° m m 3m0 <_ ° Cl) (Dm N0 = m� _ �� °�N n �olDom(a b n m(oomc w` o- 3 1=11 c CD Z o r W 'L7 � a `� c o' -� 0. m N N a] 7 {mD � W m M O CD mo m� 3 o-m° O ? N _� m s q C �t °c �� rf �. a m a m ° 0< aca o� m� Q N 0- D m n cD 3;CD CD m ada m i Z O m m �= —a m an -0 q o sm 0 :E 07 0 0m m __ �mN 31pc_5 sRL 3mo 9 �_C0o_ a) aoo-> cn �o33 O�a cp �D�.v�o- m(D moo m O oommmo° n oma�0' m m Cr o o m m m �_ �° c m 3 D C m 3 0 o D >> ° m o m m° o m o ' ° �.9'N N c cn .Z m.m am o e 3a� m 3 o (D N.3 '3 CD m 3 c C C7 m _.m (<D o 0 m 3 a N= Q 0 n_ ». 0 4D m» m 0 C7 CD —0 m o. o.( 0 0 w a -,(n CSC 3 .5, m M N l< ! m° m 0 -0 N (D y. 0 m (D N a n (O 2. n a- 0 N D N O~ C 35o�N�am C/) 9'CQCD 0 �m _ _ N .7. O m_ y C3 S N N �_ m - N �' •O'^ m 3 N m S d j fn O O cp m° m (n. O �. N O N (<D m 0 _ C a 7 d' Eflry S �m 7 O N N 't+' d O 0� M 0< I N O' m m Z fD 0 x Q m m o m< 7C O CD 0 CD bo O_ N N n !11 1 oDa o Z 0 m c ()sv3 0_o C-) CL y Nw G) C/) °-°- oZ3�° < c � X 0m C CD �..�mm m =r _� CD Zn o a° D m x a c o - o d m °< mpN0 °.=. 0 3��5. 3nCoN 2m��°° »° -o "a 3' =r (D m m ° a o -i m o° m 0 0 m v cnCD w3=m �0 -' <CDm =�° m CD d a0 A, o o °'.v3 -' (D a CD m m 3 ° m o m ° d m >_ > ° ° 0 o C O C- 0 d N. m X C" O O m N W C 3 3 » .. C o- a >> 0 0 0 o N N m N m ;< CD 7 O_ .�.. m C cn O N O y N m m a N N m a d N m m O m m° N < ow 7 O m CD O m 0-3 0 N N m (O .< O m j CD O m ° .-. a W `� O. ° m(D p O O O. m N T OIL c 0 (O m O_ N F N m ° O O � C 0 O m (O m, O N 7 0 ,a�'°_. N m sy> ° 3 CD n _r 0< N m N m 0) a s m m 7 ° 0 C. �n'X(D O Q N ?.3 = 0 E5. O m ». N c m 0 '< m o. cD 3 O 3 S j m CD-a o ° m o 3 ° aa- =0 m N 3 s °• mm o0 0' m �o °Q ET 0 ? ° °- 3 m CO a m m o_ m < 0 N y c 0 LR N 03 2.0 d • Z < N S3 U3 CL d N N S� N 7 CL 0 `7<< N S = 7 N O A — N y O (D O CL O rn S o O A (D ' 0 I°- �. o 7 � = c S (D (D 0. 3 c O N � 411 O d 411 Z] (D d N N lS N n D o 0 D) v 0 CD CD Q = 7 f d � c' 3 m a CL v o = 7 CL y 5' 4U m N tv 7 d O II7 co Y Z3 a CQ ;7 CD A� a N �< O CD W N C N (3 tv d 7 —m N c N (D c N Q fD (] CD a- = N 0 �o v< (D d3 O N 0 N CL d 7 N N C O 0 1 ova° 3 3 =5 (D _. CD j 3 d w(D 7 T�(D S D 3 — o O (D 3 m (D U N CL = (D 7 O O _d N y A N N Fr "6 (D 7 (D 7 O N N 70 C I * d O O _T. X S CD v [D j (D o C = N d K o tv N o � > -c 7 N i X (a O — O' m v 3 00 o a m = 7 (D m m o c a ) 3 N_ �. m m N m Co D O N N N N 7_ 3 4D g 7 a 0 .0 S C, 9' 0 3' d o g o (p -O N (D (D O �. 7 Nm3 (o N 0. 3 0 G U (D y 7 N > S 0 0 l 3 c D o N c c 9 o � CD m CD o 5 m= 0 c (D N N S C r a °e LVW n i' U--i c tJ .,w O s $3 Cl, CZ CD C') 0 z 0 z CD C+1 Er O (D "O 3 3 0 y y' w ' O .0. 111 = N Q 0 o Kd(l. O O y O_ 7 y 7 K N - CO ti (D S D (D N m J 7 N om v D 7 CI),< d 3 co T = O O N G 7 3 3o N � O N d = a 7 o CD O 0 N N m n m m (D CD CL �w 3 CD W CD ". . 0 —o o m 0 m y CD .C3 b m CD tU Z3 CD a Q sa n m C n Z3 Z3 N n b n <4 CL zz- 'O m Cn m E /,q /Io o omp xf a (p Cn N D a v 3 -.cm j 3 d w(D D v o D D N o 3 m (D n (D Ddp 7 O O T m N ^". c0 A N N Fr "6 (D 7 D 7 O N N c 0 (D (D < -� (D S O N (Dp_ O O _T. X Q 7 Z ' = 7 S d M d N N = rn cn o C N y N. 0 S -o 4D� 7 (D � > -c O:0 X N CD CD (D C .= a) S ddN c = 7 (D m m o (OD N_ O 0 7 (O N Co D o = �. N (D O .0 0 0 :E 7_ 3 N .0 S = O CD 3' d 7 3 N n d o N (D (D O �. 7 D -n T OO N ? (0 a �' (D p �O fll U (D y 7 N > S m 3 c D o N c c o m ?. x--o CD CD o 5 m= CD 3 (D N N Er O (D "O 3 3 0 y y' w ' O .0. 111 = N Q 0 o Kd(l. O O y O_ 7 y 7 K N - CO ti (D S D (D N m J 7 N om v D 7 CI),< d 3 co T = O O N G 7 3 3o N � O N d = a 7 o CD O 0 N N m n m m (D CD CL �w 3 CD W CD ". . 0 —o o m 0 m y CD .C3 b m CD tU Z3 CD a Q sa n m C n Z3 Z3 N n b n <4 CL zz- 'O m Cn m E /,q /Io o omp xf a 0m 3 0 g-o m 'm 0 i = ON n (O COD � �� OT ID � � o (O T G o =� 0 a� (D CD Co- .: N D v N to 3 0 ,S. �<p ;3<o (D O O 7 7 w 3 3 7< N _� t S. O < 0 O D CT i w _ N S (D CD < =^ u3 .d. 3 N N 0 .7+ 7 fD fD 7 N 0 O� 7 < N (D j 0-0 - 7 N O �, (D 7 (D O 'O (D CD T 10 c3.Z CD '�7 M o c (DD3o O 0 SN N O<D 70, D. EPA 0 , ao 0 m3 3 -O :a7NO y O 0 '12D 7 (O CD 7 O (O 7 �` (D (D y 0 GiD N (p- Z N O0 (D k�!'P ' , p O _ -O Q (D O a `< (D fD <o (D O 7 N Z v y 7 (N D `< n y N K 00 N n G) a O. CD ? N OR .Z] (D d (D (D < m ro 7 0 0. R p (D a (D 7 E 3 0 7 CD 7 r M K CD < o CD O j (D (on p T. 7 (D O S 0 CD S 5 Cn Cn CO, "R O m (O N `< S y N N D) C Z ro p tT d fD 7 'O 7 �% ,C7» (D o 0 CL `< N 7 „d„ N DFj N N N fD O O O m (D (D K M (O p O mm _ O v m m l o 0 N 2.0 3 D) C `G 7 D (D y A C (D m o 7 0 a N 0 CD - 7 900 N (D O X 7 (D N a 0 A OW O n C "00 fD (D (D N O (D N N 00 3c N �m w�oi°- fan M a w (D N c r O N O _S 7 O (D '< O N a c3 N O O a y 7 f%! O T N O 0 7 N O &P Q i i r `jam Awl F —m p m p N � m` ±Ll x.. I m O' c0 C n 7 M O o Z ! i OR Cn "3 (O T G G7 ^;y "' =� 0 a� y CD m m Co- .: N D v O N 7 to »m >' (D p1 a. 331 (22 N 3 [D N (D O O 7 7 w 3 3Z. N _� -0 ID o o CT i a ? -n < u3 Z CD O t1I CT (D C �' 7 < N (D j 3Z - 7 N O �, (D 7 (D O 'O (D CD T 10 c3.Z CD '�7 O 0 SN N VO 70, D. F y N 0 S (D fD (D N N • CD ,: O N '7" j m CA mm3o_n D N� N N ri 7 O (O 7 �` (D N Q -w 3 GiD _ n. N O (n (p- Z N O0 (D k�!'P 7 57 Sn D O .7.. O O O j Q c CD D N a ? m 3 o CD CL `< n (D S p 7 C c N O Taaa y C c O O C T. N N 7 ro -00 (D 0 K n S S 5 Cn Cn S = N (O -{ 'O "R O # M S O ".-C' .N. N @ =r �CD ro M f° O o 0 s m n C 7 m o iD O (on O Doi O 7 (D (D K M N 7 N h (D N d CD m O O S O O C] CD v= v m m l o 0 N Q 7 N O N N w CD a N O N O N N CD (D .p N O (D 0madm CD N _ DD p N a � (D p (D (2 (D N - a (D O < X N 7 N O (D N y C S a 3 fan M a w (D N O N N Vl O O 01 7 _S 7 O (D '< O N a c3 O O a C. y O 7 -p o O T N O N CD N O 7 N 0 3 7 N < o p_ 3 N T, m O 0 _ 3 3 N - N =. (D O � 0 O 1 &P Q i i r `jam Awl //11/10 , /1 Ca Alp HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION OF GOLDEN GATE ESTATES January 19, 2010 With regard to Petition CP2008 -1 and CP2008 -2 " The Homeowners Association of Golden Gate Estates reaffirms the stand by our Board of Directors and the Membership in pursuit of our goal of a World Class Rural Community. We support the current Golden Gate Area Master Plan as written." Per the Board of Directors and the Advisory Council Members. Mark Teaters Advisory Council Member 1/11//0 CP- 6MP Big Corkscrew Island Fire Control and Rescue District 13240 Immokalee Road, Naples, Florida 34120 239 - 455 -1204 January 19, 2010 Board of County Commissioners, Collier County: In reference to the GMPA proposal, I submit the following: The Big Corkscrew Island Fire Control and Rescue District would like to be recognized as supporting this project, as it relates to the impact on the Fire District. We would also like to clarify that the District was not, in any way, "threatened or coerced" into working with the Developer on the proposed project. The Board of Fire Commissioners has been involved with the proposed agreement from the time there was discussion of purchasing District property to present. The Board has taken several steps to ensure the District is "protected ", which were embraced by the Developer, throughout this process. There are several reasons that the Board of Fire Commissioners has agreed to become part of this project the first and foremost is the potential to relocate to a straight/dual access corridor. While the existing facility fills the current needs, it has always been a concern being located on the curve. Another benefit the District will receive is the potential to access water and sewer hook -ups. Again our facility serves the current need however we do not have the drain field /well capacity to expand our staff as our service demand and community continue to grow. The third noted benefit is that of sharing a property site with Division of Forestry. There is the potential that we would not only share the property but could share the facility. We as a Board are committed to keeping DOF within the Estates Residential Community. In summary this project, if approved, will enhance the safe entrance and exit of apparatus and personal vehicles and the working relationship between DOF and BCIFR personnel, while allowing for a more reliable and safe water supply and sewer hook -up. Please accept our apologies for not being in attendance this evening, but prior engagements require our attention. Respectfully, PAd M. P&,+�A Paul M. Plamondon, Chairman )4ta M. jreenbar9 Rita M. Greenberg, Chief 111f/ID Cp� (amp January 14, 2010 Commissioner Donna Fiala Board of County Commissioners 3301 Tamiami Trail East Naples, Florida 34112 Dear Commissioner Fiala: Re: BCC Meeting January 19, 2010, Items Numbers CP- 2008 -1 and CP- 2008 -2 Enclosed please find petitions signed in opposition to the proposed shopping center at the intersection of Wilson and Golden Gate Boulevard in Golden Gate Estates. Since the petition is ongoing, I will be submitting more names at the upcoming meeting. Add to these signatures the 800 negative responses to the March 2009 Collier Citizen poll, and you are looking at close to 1000 names that do not want this shopping center. The developer conducted a market survey by mail that was sent to 5,700 Estates residents. Four thousand (4,000) did not respond - a sure sign of a lack of interest on the part of the recipients. If I had the resources available to me that have been utilized by the developer, 1 feel that I would have far outnumbered their positive responses with negative responses. Permitting a 40 -acre shopping center on the NW corner of Golden Gate Boulevard and Wilson Boulevard is a doomsday prediction of future commercial growth on those boulevards and would certainly generate excessive traffic on these residential roads. It is also a breech of consideration toward the petitioners who developed the other three comers. These individuals abided by the Golden Gate Master Plan and are now faced with a development that far exceeds the requirements that they obeyed. Also, please find enclosed a petition supporting the shopping center on Randall Boulevard and Immokalee Road. This is a more appropriate site for a project this large and has a better chance to attract a quality grocer} store because of the rooftops afforded by three communities adjacent to the location. Sincerely, G Aum s Attachments Copy: Michele Mosca, Principal Planner 1 i 6J We the undersigned are against a 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe the shopping center at the intersection of Randall and Immokalee Road is a more appropriate location and will not destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Address ,Pk -r 5� EMAIL ., /lca�P clL We the undersigned areagainst a 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe the shopping center at the intersection of Randall and Immokalee Road is a more appropriate location and will not destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL meC.0 � z, <zz Y�() `),/J� PA ANA , Jlf /P dl /,i-i) - t, 4 fYVC. �,4UJ I,A Vrart oil 1 et i4 &( C- 0.'9 v 11tR to 004P We the undersigned are against the 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe it will destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL a� P 3 [ a Jj- S� US�oCD- &�tcS+ -. tud We the undersigned are against the 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe it will destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL //11 /lo Cvl�P � We the undersigned are against the 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe it will destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name rtAddress` EMAIL �Pi 9 /io We the undersigned are in favor of the new 40 acre shopping center on Randall Blvd. It will consist of a grocery store, retail stores and professional offices. �wwwn r'('rLj' 11111to �V CT-- We the undersigned are in favor of the new 40 acre shopping center on Randall Blvd. it will consist of a grocery store, retail stores and professional offices. N1 Ime Address EMAIL 7 vie" A-, doMe —1 1 v m II19[t° cP &MP We the undersigned are in favor of the new 40 acre shopping center on Randall Blvd. It will consist of a grocery store, retail stores and professional offices. Name Address EMAIL C "s'! /? �. j 7A P We the undersigned are in favor of the new 40 acre shopping center on Randall Blvd. It will consist of a grocery store, retail stores and professional offices. N�rt Address �� EMAIL , �� 3 f�tA Ft ?)*20' 3tZO �a ate• LNlao CQr�Yn S 'A rf4 P 11GS 3S P4 to h r v ' e -§A/10'1 Cre5PO 3VY1 E 4L L, 3 j/ 2-- r---S 3 i� t,J✓ td 1 U 2eit",4'11E Nf 3`/ /ZG mcvc a�-k*k fire; 3Li I20 �f D We the undersigned support the construction of a shopping center at the intersection of Randall Blvd. and Immokalee Road. Name Address EMAIL ,A)l Vea Lua �/ z SC, ac--, Ile Z, &.V=C 7 &4 C (4A, ,A)l Vea Lua �/ z SC, ac--, Nosotros el apoyo abajofirmante la construccion del propuso centro comercial de 40 acres en el cruce de Randall Blvd. y el Camino de Immokalee. Consistira en una tienda de comestibles, las tiendas al por menor y un centro profesional. Denomine Direccion CORREO ELECTRONICO I Z C: 01110 C� Nosotros el apoyo abajofirmante la construccion del propuso centro comercial de 40 acres en el cruce de Randall Blvd. y el Camino de Immokalee. Consistira en una tienda de comestibles, las tiendas al por menor y un centro profesional. Denomine Direccion CORREO ELECTRONICO ^Y1C (Ci/1 fJilcft' /t ' G 77/J /✓� ` " t 3 vC fV L-, IlIqllv CA, Ow We the undersigned support the construction of a shopping center at the intersection of Randall Blvd. and Immokalee Road. N one Address EMAIL 0 /-/V-/o 6Kt L-A We the undersigned are against a 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe the shopping center at the intersection of Randall and Immokalee Road is a more appropriate location and will not destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL Ckq2, -1 1(,, 1 S'71h S-T- /VVV Pl�,4 - AL rA Ij LA tJJf Lv 114: ltA�! L /" L-L AL rA 1/1 q1j, C � We the undersigned are against a 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe the shopping center at the intersection of Randall and Immokalee Road is a more appropriate location and will not destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL W 7� W 11100 CAP C� We the undersigned are in favor of the construction of a shopping center on Randall Blvd rather than one on Golden Gate Blvd., because it intersects on Immokalee Road a six lane highway and Randall Blvd. a soon to be six land- highway. It is, therefore, a more appropriate location and will do less environmental and aesthetic damage to the Estates. 10/30/09 Name Address vL ti EMAIL N MggA�MjJ 14950 Cz'�M4 JJQ Q S[ _ q 4Gt1'7('Y��,�: �n _ i 1 „ / .^• . _ � .-.�L � C.�i'' / "� �ivY, . l.n'.iv^.1 ,.iri ��i!1 ltYr..1- ` _ �Jin rvcs rw 2 vet We the undersigned are in favor of the construction of a shopping center on Randall Blvd rather than one on Golden Gate Blvd., because it intersects on Immokalee Road a six lane highway and Randall Blvd. a soon to be six land' highway. It is, therefore, a more appropriate location and will do less environmental and aesthetic damage to the Estates. 10/30/09 Address EMAIL 7 let r(D(i� MT D : J •C J3.°'G:/ .I-1 r LJ �7,'h< / y' VLt h.12 1�1Qde1' z Sl`7C lLo ✓vq vi 0' 'Ca60.' m 2. Ar) :221 D 2 / f ✓1 1 rA c S wj- l 17 1, C1 "ffvy ie)"ih <� _l 7 . C07t\' -i 41zi.' - l G i`c 10`2 `f l e We the undersigned are In favor of the construction of a shopping center on Randall Blvd rather than one on Golden Gate Blvd., because it intersects on Immokalee Road a six lane highway and Randall Blvd. a soon to be six lan4t highway. It is, therefore, a more appropriate location and will do less environmental and aesthetic damage to the Estates. 10/30/09 } We the undersigned are in favor of the construction of a shopping center on Randall Blvd rather than one on Golden Gate Blvd., because it intersects on Immokalee Road a six lane highway and Randall Blvd. a soon to be six land L--A A/ highway. It is, therefore, a more appropriate location and will do less environmental and aesthetic damage to the Estates. 10/30/09 , 1 �9gr cf Address EMAIL v > , 1 �9gr cf We the undersigned are against a 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe the shopping center at the intersection of Randall and Immokalee Road is a more appropriate location and will not destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL I, ` l.IA ,c vCxbl�<�� _' i Fl We the undersigned are against a 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe the shopping center at the intersection of Randall and Immokalee Road is a more appropriate location and will not destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL G+ �onz�i'rz (�5:±5¢s'� �Sw'j�l?Z L�or �v ro ti 7 -I- I llgllod 00 We the undersigned are against the 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe it will destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL i16_ .,1 I111bo C 6mf We the undersigned are against the 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe it will destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL 0 -1-+ -7 16 1C M P G� We the undersigned are against the 40 acre shopping center at the intersection of Golden Gate Blvd. and Wilson Blvd. We believe it will destroy the rural characteristics of the Estates. Name Address EMAIL T. net .j- {c_t��e._. �1SL;c,• -�� \tee �...��- ��r�. ��t��.. ✓Ceti �ari2a.�t2. !gl- 31S-i�54e- �r It Exhibit A FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT V. OVERLAYS AND SPECIAL FEATURES B. North Belle Meade Overlay 44* 44* 4 ** * ** *44 444 4 ** 4. SENDING AREAS CP- Z(1014 [Page 87] * ** *Y4 444 444 4 ** [Page 96] Within the NBM Overlay are t 4,598 44,569 acres of land that are identified as Sending Areas for the transfer of development rights that are located in the western, eastern and southern portion of the study area. The Sending Areas consist of the NRPA lands and t5 and 3/4 sections west of the NRPA. The sending areas are locations where residential development is discouraged. Endangered and threatened species are located within the Sending Areas, including colonies of Red Cockaded Woodpeckers. Therefore, the protection of endangered and threatened species including the protection of habitat are primary planning considerations in this area. * *4 * *4 YY4 YY4 44* * ** *44 Y44 Y4* 4 ** * ** *4Y 5. NEUTRAL LANDS [Page 96] Within the NBM Overlay there are t 4;2W 14,309 acres of land that are identified as Neutral Areas. The Neutral Areas consist of two 1/2 sections located at the northeast corner of this Overlay ate, Section 24 located in the northwest portion of this Overlay. and approximate 29 acres located in Section 31. The preservation standards for Neutral Lands shall be those contained in CCME Policy 6.1.2 for Neutral Lands. The County has performed an RCW study for Section 24 and, if the results of the study warrant, the Plan will be amended. Words underlined are added; words struck thFaugh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( *44 4 ** 4i ;) denotes break in text. f, F m X W T as S T 47 S T 45 S a � y 0��oo5�E•I��o�l ®1 � t G iy i dip a, qq ua 3 mg�1y y yL g #� mom ME] BEIM �11 �e�. c qro INIeai EyQS vg�cs &y g j7 ge Jea4 a : "S & {y g$ gi m'° A�qi�$ €9 3 as `bs S'� 97 ag' sA9 F I c @ hygi m. 1 T 43 S I T 50 S T 52 S 3E un= Sava �� pf Hill MR n llf� t. ti "t N��y''� e fe .• � 3F m o N W�. > Q 1 n 7 F � J Q. � U d V 0 Z _ n o o 0 N < i rN , arcI0 m m W h lO � 00 Z W� Q O 0 WmUw Z Z N O O a + �n o �0 d r � � W 0�R0Z¢ ¢ . ¢ 0 2 0 Q r O V a w i 0 W U W ,U � Z O a (078 e 37!08 4b'79 3 3 Z o Q - n C ° L 8z8 a Q F z LU LN��Q / i W O w U Q N LU Q J LU w N w W L4 a_ J J v Lu W m H O z 0 o W U wN�°=w v 5 Lza w Q2 sza " . d WaWm Wz O ro LU ry O sa= N v o� (56 YO) (IHVA37no8 a370o wmw°"UOa_us¢N °oY �� ao° 00 W� W" Z Z r 2 0 Q 0 O c D m m _r 3 m m 0 -I O 2 m m m CA) O m n OO 0 — On m ° O C c m { Z m O O O � m n r_ ° 3 D M z M ° m O --j m O ° D (n O O O J m v � A c m -i z O � O c m m M A 0 M On n r m - O ° n O O r m m r O Om 2z< n C/) X00 Oz O --j � � 2 n 1) c r O Z O m m Z T W m O m m Ccnm ° m m z m O 2 n Cl) n G7 c) 1 z Cf) = z y m O �Ouj a m < m z �XO m--i n n O O J _ < zm:� m O m Fn r m > co cr) o �l r> X Z > o D m 3 m N D m D Z1 m m z �? o -I v m r m r rn m m m O -n z T m p �� w 1 2 m O 0 m r m U) m n r m D { m 0 m z 0 D m m 9 Z c m m m e GN \� -v�p� EXHIBIT A FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT CPSP- 2008 -7 0:3F` [Page 15 -16] OBJECTIVE 4: In order to improve coordination of land uses with natural and historic resources, public facilities, economic development, housing and urban design, the Future Land Use Element shall be continually refined through detailed planning. Future studies might address specific geographic or issue areas. All future studies must be consistent with the Growth Management Plan and further its intent. Policy 4.11 [Page 18] In the next Evaluation and Appraisal Report (EAR) due January 1 2011 Collier County will identify as an issue to be addressed the need to align dates within the various Area Overlay, and Transportation Element long range maps Necessary amendments to achieve the alignment of dates will be included in the EAR -based amendments to the Plan. Words underlined are added; words stfask threegh are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. EXHIBIT A FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT CP- 2009 -1 3G Policy 1.4: [FLUE page 12] The CONSERVATION Future Land Use Designation shall include a Future Land Use District. A. DADE- COLLIER CYPRESS RECREATION AREA DISTRICT IV. CONSERVATION DESIGNATION [FLUE page 86] [3rd paragraph] Natural resource protection strategies and standards for development in the Conservation Designation are found in the Conservation and Coastal Management Element and the County's Land Development Regulations. The Conservation Designation will accommodate limited residential development and future non - residential uses. The following uses are authorized in this Designation, but may not be permitted in all Districts and may be subiect to specific criteria conditions, and development standards than those listed below. A. Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area District [FLUE page 87] The Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area District encompasses approximately 1,608 acres of land located within Sections 13, 14 15 and 16 of Township 53 South Ranee 34 East adioining the Miami-Dade/Collier County line north of U.S. Highway 41 and south of the runway of the Dade- Collier Training and Transition Airport and within the Big Cypress Area of Critical State Concern (ACSCI. All lands within this District are entirety owned by Miami Dade County and include wetlands, cypress and hardwood forests and five man -made lakes The primary purpose of this District is to enhance the existing natural resources while providing for an appropriate level of recreational uses beneficial to the county and the region The uses allowed within this District with limitations specific to this District are as follows: a. Visitors' center building — for administrative offices orientation area meeting room, oom and restrooms - not to exceed 2,400 square feet• b. Parking lot- not to exceed 80 passenger vehicles and associated trailers• c. Primitive Camping - not to exceed 10 acres d. Recreational vehicle camping - not to exceed 10 acres; e. Fishing piers and docks - not to exceed 300 acres; f. Multi -use trails for Pedestrians and bicycles wildlife viewing platforms and overlooks — not to exceed 45 acres and 10 miles of trails; R. Archery range — not to exceed 10 acres: Words underlined are added; words GtFuek44feuo are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. CP- 2009 -1 3G h. Off highway vehicles (OHV) — not to exceed 15 acres and 15 miles of trail length and limited to use on improved trails: and i. Other uses as allowed in the Conservation Designation. Development within this District except for trails shall be concentrated within already disturbed area within the western portions of the site primarily in Section 16 All development shall comply with the Area of Critical State Concern Overlay standards except for Section 1 Site Alteration, standard d, which prohibits destruction or alteration of mangrove trees salt marsh grasses, and all wetland plants listed by the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation in Chapter 17 -301, Florida Administrative Code as amended The drainage and storm water management systems for this District shall be designed to be compatible with environmental site assessments development and mitigation strategies environmental enhancements and regulatory requirements Site development shall restore /realign existing trails previously created by swamp buggies that traverse the site primarily in an east/west direction. Lake edges may be improved with a shallow littoral zone where determined appropriate. At the time of rezoning an adaptive comprehensive management plan shall be provided that includes: 1. OHV uses as defined in F.S. 261.03 and 261.20 for operation of OHVs on up blic land. These specifications shall address vehicle and tire size noise control prohibition of certain OHV types (e.g. tracked vehicles) prohibition of devices affixed to tires (e.g. tire chains). OHV's for this site shall be limited to ATVs and motocross vehicles Swami) buggies are prohibited 2. An OHV inspection program and vehicle registration program 3. Provisions to demarcate site boundaries. 4. Definitive location of all imposed uses — campsites parking areas archery range OHV trails and trail access points pedestrian and bicycle trails etc 5. Development intensity limitations — maximum number of RV and primitive camping sites, can on number of OHV users daily, etc 6. Monitoring provisions to ensure OHV compliance 7. Enforcement Program for compliance with all site /park restrictions and limitations 8. Specification of periods of operation especially for OHVs — daily hours of operation periods of closure (e.g. high water, fire threat hurricane threat) seasonal restrictions or closure. 9. Monitoring for detrimental impacts upon listed species_ 10. Restoration plan for Presently disturbed portions of the site not to be utilized (e.g. most of the existing OHV trails) and creation of littoral zones for all lakes where deemed appropriate. 11. Demonstration of compliance with the ACSC limitations (e maximum site alteration of 10 %), except for Section 1.d., as provided above. Collier County residents shall have the same rights of usage within this District as Miami Dade County residents. Words underlined are added; words 6tFUGk thFough are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** ** *) denotes break in text. FUTURE LAND USE MAP SERIES Future Land Use Map Mixed Use & Interchange Activity Center Maps CP- 2009 -1 [FLUE page 124] Livingston Road/Eatonwood Lane Commercial Infill Subdistrict Map Livingston Road Commercial Infill Subdistrict Map Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area District May Exhibit A CP- 2009-01 per BCC approval for Transmittal on 1 -19 -10 G: \Comprehensive \COMP. PLANNING GMP DATA \Comp. Plan Amendments\2009 Cycle Petitions \CP -2009-1 Dade - Collier Cypress Recreation Area \Exhibit A CP- 2009-01 Words underlined are added; words sk+ls� are deleted. Row of asterisks ( * ** * ** * * *) denotes break in text. t F- m_ 2 X w 3S T 46 S T 47 S T 48 8 T 48 S T 60 S T 61 S T fit 8 T 63 S x f x 8 x x :ypg _ gg W ❑��o�9 ®il�U�l ®I � �,r 4 y g3 S ZBB €C ■t■ ME] 0070 ❑g0l ®�� q g x gs�gpph § gy . p �ya�a�� k 3ppg pp 44 yB p yy Fqx 99 gill !I, 3 � g Ea �i3�� + 12�566 s i 3 3 A I 1 f I. e O Np$ Gulf of Mex',00a � I S Bt 1 S U 1 S Bt 1 g gt 1 S 09 1 1 S l9 1 S 99 S 89 1 �� s N d U O r r a E- E- co w a U �i W a a 0 U W Q Q A 6 Q a 0 a c� E" F z a 0 x w a a 0 U Y O D h� C4 U � Kt b ti �e 4� V C� 5 M� z 0 0 U K N a z zwo oZo f ZN ,0 \ VI j Uw� Z aoo az EF aw3 _OQ U�U m 0�0 QFN I �za ¢�U 20� BULL 0 O c D m m r m rn 0 0 O S m m m w z C —I m N In O S 0 O c n O 3 m m z U) N D z V D S m O D v v S m U) O z r m S m 0 S D _-� _ n moo W c p ° m D 7J z °G'o m c z c < m o O co � 3) b r_ ° O � D X 7:1 z M ° m 00Z o n o cn°o 0 ° J m M A m m m z O m c m z = M cn ' 0 = b r 7J -Di O ° D O O r � m r O m =zco D O °' Oz O = -j � D 33 c r m O CO 77 z m W m O c (n m r ° m z m z G7 O D co � G) wmz o : :�i z w = z j m O O al n m < Z 9> y O n r 2 < Z m v O a M D m � ° �l r� M z m D v � m m N m z z m m O z lw 1 S m S 1' v C) S m U) un J1 A .l .D r n m n O v r m m m v T O O z S m D W r m r m N m .9 z n r m a 9 im O m Z O a -a m 3 � . ' D m z 0 D m Z c W m %i z qz n � / \J > 33 \\/ 0 �@& 4 Z \ UoJ) E )k> ; _ G 0 0 0Z o / >9 / \�n 23E $ / > \ƒ U \ >> } 00 o \0m 5 iy< 0 ® }® 2 \/\ ) C $/m § :0 DI > z f Gxz o ,\{ \ c) �� \ U) ( \ \� / \ \om \ \ ®/ m /\\ / \/� )3\ n 71 TI 7 g \ e \ a \ \� \ \k `Csk °Q ] � k \ ) 2 .. ( � ) 0. '71 } / k \ 0 \ 2 a ] k \ / 3 m r P ,\ p �,. y \ 9 � ( / f ` f m § c ) / ( _ C § 6 § } ( «a § a / 7 \ 7 / u \ « 3 ) " 7 g \ e \ a \ \� \ \k `Csk °Q ] � k \ ) 2 .. ( � ) 0. '71 } / k \ 0 \ 2 a ] k \ / 3 m r P ,\ p �,. y \ 9 � » C @ / f ` § C % � c ( C z 6 \ � § 7 « k / \ \ § C % � c �) � O c m O m m Z N D z v D m m O D v m m m y N O z r x m n x D i_C) =z m n O We O CO m D - m o � n O m c c c - i< m cn o O m r D r O Z 3 y 1 m m z o m o m C) O m Oo O _ � o O m m m N m 0 C a D m m Gz) m m c Z = c m c m a Cl) O O O D m O p r O m C m n a m < � KC) Oz Ocn D r CO r z co M O m m m o c m m -cnm p m z G) G) � D CO 4 - o�G) m *z coa :z i � < A> = r M n a D r < M � m z D O Dj z m D Co lo (n U) 7X7 0 -n D r-q .: m U m m U) m z -a z O rF m 1 --I O z m m z D m m im O O m m U) v 0 x I m Vv r n m m n O v r 1 m v T O 2' O z 1 x m D as r m r m O m x m v n m z x m m O D m v m O O m m O M 1 O 1 x m y c m m m 1 m m z O x m n m v V r m D m m V m z --q 10 r m D m r e O m z v n m m -i r m 1 i N v 1 V u� im O m z v D mm c z c m m m '-11� \ a ) E j / / { } 0 § 2 j # � m ƒ 8 ) \ \ \ / \7 m > \CZ ) < 7 g. CO(a m } \ \> q _/� z . Gj/ § 0 > \ {)� \ \ \\ >> 33 / \00 =g= \cn 0C a \> ¥£ o / §m \ \\ \\\ ( \\ \// � \o\ \ ® - >0 \<j M> / .§ 2 § �0 ,r ?t ,/ § \ § § § $ § \ m . S / / \ k ��