PSCC Minutes 06/11/2009 R
June 11,2009
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE
COLLIER COUNTY
PUBLIC SAFETY COORDINATING COUNCIL
Naples, Florida, June 11, 2009
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Public Safety
Coordinating Council, in and for the County of Collier, having conducted business
herein, met on this date at 2:00 PM., in REGULAR SESSION, at the Human
Resources Conference Room, Building "B," 330 I East Tamiami Trail, in Naples,
Florida, with the following members present:
CHAIRMAN: Commissioner Fred Coyle
Judge Eugene C. Turner, County Court
Kathleen A. Smith, Public Defender
Charles Rice, Director, County Probation
David Schimmel, Chief Executive Officer, David
Lawrence Center
Christine Holmes, Administrator, Batterers Intervention
Program
Rich Montecalvo,
Designee for Stephen Russell, State Attorney
Pamela Donelson, Circuit Administrator, State Probation
Mark Lennon, Sr. Supervisor, State Probation Office,
Designee for Pamela Donelson
Sheriff Kevin Rambosk, Chief Correctional Officer
Chief Greg Smith, Collier County Sheriffs Office,
Designee for Sheriff Rambosk
Mark Middlebrook, Collier County Court Administration
(Non-voting)
Chief Scott Salley, Sheriffs Office (Non-voting)
ALSO PRESENT:
Robert Zachary, Assistant County Attorney
Skip Camp, Director, Facilities Management
Mike Sheffield, Assistant to County Manager
Damon Gonzales, Facilities Management
Collier County
Public Safety Coordinating Council
June 11, 2009, 2:00pm
Human Resources Conference Room
3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida
I. Introduction
A. Call to Order- Commissioner Coyle
B. Approval of the PSCC Meeting Minutes from March 19,2009
II. Old Business
A. Brief Presentation Regarding the State's Re-entry Program-
Pamela Donelson, State Probation Circuit Administrator
B. Jail "Snap-Shot" Report-Chief Scott Salley
III. New Business
A. Update on Collier County's Criminal Alien Task Force-
Cmdr. Mike Williams and Lt. Keith Harmon
IV. Member Comments
V. Public Comments
VI. Adjourn-The next meeting will be held on September 3,2009 at 2pm in the
Human Resources Conference Room
June 11,2009
I. Introduction
A. Call to Order
Commissioner Fred Coyle called the meeting to order at 2:00 PM.
B. Approval of PSSC Meeting Minutes from March 19,2009
Rich Montecalvo moved to approve the Minutes of March 19, 2009 Meeting as
submitted. Second by Kathleen Smith. Carried unanimously, 9-0.
II. Old Business
A. Presentation regarding the State's Re-entry Program - Pamela Donelson
The purpose of the presentation was to clarify the State Probation Department's
position regarding its reversal of the "zero tolerance" policy.
. "Zero Tolerance" pushed the State's incarceration rate to an intolerable level
. Secretary McNeil stated the emphasis is on public safety; re-entry is not just
about inmates
. Evidence-based practices are being implemented to deal with the soaring
crime rates
. Department's Mission Statement: "To protect the public and ensure the
safety of Department personnel; to give proper care and supervision of all
offenders under the Department's jurisdiction, and to assist as appropriate"
. Offenders considered for re-entry are those who present the least amount of
risk to the public concerning recidivism
. New Re-entry Mission Statement: "To provide inmates and offenders with
comprehensive programs and services that will assist in their successful re-
entry into the community thereby reducing recidivism while enhancing
public safety and promoting post-release success."
. It is not economically feasible to build the scheduled 20 prisons at a cost of
$40M each and to operate/maintain each prison at a cost of $13M - only six
prisons are scheduled to be built
. It is anticipated that the inmate population will increase by 24% in the next
5 years to 129,328
. Education and drug treatment programs are effective at reducing recidivism
(return to prison within three years after release)
. Probation officers are being trained regarding motivational interviewing and
using positive reinforcement techniques
. Partnerships have been established with the Sheriffs Office, the David
Lawrence Center, the County Re-entry Coalition, and the 20th Judicial
Circuit
. The Career Service of SW Florida is teaching offenders how to interview,
how to dress for an interview, how to prepare a resume
. Collier County's Drug Court Program is very successful
. Community Corrections collected $90M last year: approximately $25M
was allocated to the State's General Revenue Fund, approximately $35M
was returned to victims of crime, and the remainder was distributed to the
various Counties
2
June 11,2009
B. Jail "Snap-Shot" Report - Chief Scott Salley
. Inmate population has declined over 15% in the past two years
. Criminal Alien Task Force has been successful in identifying criminal
illegal aliens for transport to the Immigration & Customs Enforcement
("ICE") detention facilities at Krome Avenue by the U.S. Marshall's Office
. Number of documented gang members has increased from 35 to 59 (average
daily population)
. Sexual offenders registration program was instituted; there are approximately
615 registered offenders in Collier County
. Prison Rape Elimination Act ("PREA"):
o Program was established in 2003 and staff training is in process
o PREA standards are higher; additional cameras will be required
o Collect and disseminate information
. Influenza virus:
o Not yet a serious problem in Collier County
o Isolation/quarantine plan is in place if outbreak occurs
. Re-Integration Program:
o Lack of employment is a problem
o V ocational training is encouraged
. Suggestion: Form a Re-Integration Subcommittee
oRe-integration is a community problem, not just a law enforcement
problem
o Sponsors are needed to meet released inmate and assist in their
development of basic social skills
· i.e., Bus tokens and schedules are provided for Immokalee
inmates
Sheriff Rambosk reiterated the position of the Sheriffs Office: to ensure those
individuals who should be incarcerated are incarcerated, and to obtain treatment
and/or education for inmates to deter recidivism.
III. New Business
A. Update on Collier County's Criminal Alien Task Force - Cmdr. Mike
Williams and Lt. Keith Harmon
Sheriff Rambosk stated in 2007, the Collier County Sheriff's Office recognized
that approximately one-quarter of the jail population consisted of illegal criminal
aliens.
Statute 287(g), under the Immigration and Nationality Act, permitted local agencies
to enter into agreements with the Department of Homeland Security to obtain
authority for immigration enforcement within their jurisdiction. In June, 2007,
CCSO entered into a Memorandum of Agreement ("MOA") with the U.S. Attorney
General and ICE ("Immigration and Customs Enforcement"). The CCSO developed
two programs: the Criminal Alien Task Force ("CA TF") and the Criminal Alien
Investigation Unit ("CAIU")
Commander Mike Williams and Lieutenant Keith Harmon outlined the strategy
for each program component:
3
June 11,2009
CA TF:
. ICE supervised training of selected CCSO staff who have received
certification and security clearances
. The CA TF Corrections Coordinator and the CAlli Law Enforcement
Coordinator are liaisons to ICE for the CCSO
. CCSO outlined the Agency's policy regarding arrest criteria, data
documentation, and procedural issues
. Community outreach and education is a key component
o Victims and witnesses of crimes will not be targets ofthe
immigration law enforcement
o Goal: to reassure migrant community and citizens in general
concerning "racial profiling"
o Aliens have been interviewed and identified from more than 50
countries
CAIU:
. Identify violent criminal aliens
o Gang members; felony offenders; sexual predators
. Goal: to apprehend individuals who represent greatest threat to Collier
County residents
. Identify other criminal aliens:
o identify theft, narcotics, fraud
. If a criminal alien is in custody for local charges, the imposed sentence is
completed before the individual is transferred to ICE.
. Educate community - especially local employers concerning the hiring of
authorized workers
(The Program Report, "Partnership for a Safer Community, "was distributed.)
Commissioner Coyle commented the program presents a great opportunity for the
State to positively impact the crime rate and the enormous cost for incarceration.
He was concerned that the State appeared not to be interested and did not offer any
support to Collier County and other Florida Counties.
Pamela Donelson stated the State's emphasis is on identifying sex offenders and/or
violent offenders. The State's Probation Department has a classification process in
place to identify and target illegal criminal aliens in jails.
Discussion ensued regarding the political aspects of the program, i.e., "the chilling
effect." It was suggested the CCSO continue to make presentations to the Sheriffs'
Departments in other Counties in order to promote awareness of the program which
is also being used in Manatee, Brevard, Duval and Bay Counties.
IV. Member Comments/Suggestions
Commissioner Coyle asked for discussion of Chief Sally's suggestion to form a Re-
Integration Committee.
4
June 11,2009
It was suggested the Board of County Commissioners address and establish a Coalition
for Re-Integration, as has been done successfully in the Hillsborough/St. Petersburg area,
since there are so many components to re-entry. The involvement of community
agencies and vocational schools is critical.
Commissioner Coyle suggested creating a Subcommittee to first define the scope of the
issue and establish parameters, and then decide whether the Subcommittee should be
retained under the PSSC or deferred to the Board of County Commissioners. Various
members volunteered. He cautioned about observing the Sunshine Law and holding
public meetings.
Mike Sheffield will contact the volunteers via email with options regarding meeting
dates, times, and location.
V. Public Comment
(None)
VI. Next Meeting:
September 3, 2009 at 2:00 PM in the Human Resources Conference Room
*****
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by
order of the Chair at 3:15 PM.
COLLIER COUNTY PUBLIC SAFETY
COORDINATING COUNCIL
Commissioner Fred Coyle, Chairman
The Minutes were approved by the Board/Committee on
as presented or as amended
5