Loading...
Agenda 11/10/2025 Item #11E (Execute an Economic Development Agreement with ‘Project Bones’)11/10/2025 Item # 11.E ID# 2025-4411 Executive Summary Recommendation to approve and authorize the Chair to execute an Economic Development Agreement with ‘Project Bones’, in the amount of $6 million. OBJECTIVE: To approve and authorize the chairman to execute an Economic Development Agreement (EDA) with ‘Project Bones’, in the amount of $6 million. CONSIDERATIONS: The Bay College of Osteopathic Medicine, LLC, based in Tampa, is looking at sites for a sister school to complement its recently completed Orlando College of Osteopathic Medicine. Their projected cost to construct the school is estimated at a $170 million investment (See concept plan attached). The Naples College of Osteopathic Medicine is a proposed 108,000-square-foot facility that can accommodate a maximum of 400 students on campus, employing 325 construction workers and generating over 100 target industry jobs. It is expected to graduate 180 medical students annually by 2029. The Bay College will offer at least 20 scholarships to Collier County residents on a needs basis. Initial projections of the overall economic impact over 20 years are close to $2 billion. They are focusing on an already zoned site within the Hacienda Lakes PUD and are finalizing their Purchase and Sale Agreement. The applicant has requested confidentiality under FS 288.075 (codename ‘Project Bones’). The proposed Naples College of Osteopathic Medicine has applied for $6 million in economic development assistance from Collier County. The request represents 3.5% of the project cost, and projected ROIs are positive. It is proposed that the EDA provide a $1 million payment to the Naples School of Osteopathic Medicine upon issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy (CO), followed by $500,000 per year of operation in Collier County for up to ten (10) years, totaling $6 million. These payments will be made upon verification of the certificate of occupancy, business tax receipts, and property taxes being current in Collier County. Bay College shall not convert, reorganize, or otherwise become a nonprofit or tax-exempt entity until it has paid at least $6,000,000 in ad valorem property taxes for the property where the Facility is located. If Bay College seeks to convert to a nonprofit or tax-exempt entity before reaching the $6,000,000 property tax threshold, it must first repay the County all funds previously disbursed under this Agreement. This item is consistent with the Collier County strategic plan objective to encourage diverse economic opportunities by fostering a business-friendly environment. FISCAL IMPACT: The proposed incentive is for up to the sum of $6 million, which will be budgeted over an 11-year period. Reimbursement would only be distributed upon the receipt of sufficiency, as identified in the Economic Development Agreement. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: This request is consistent with Objective 3 of the Economic Element of the Collier County Growth Management Plan. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney, is approved as to form and legality and requires a majority vote for Board approval. -JAK RECOMMENDATION(S): To approve and authorize the Chair to execute an Economic Development Agreement with ‘Project Bones’, in the amount of $6 million. PREPARED BY: Cormac Giblin, Director, Housing Policy & Economic Development ATTACHMENTS: 1. Economic Development Agreement Bay College -Vendor Signed 2. Bay College bones IZ application Page 2114 of 6525 11/10/2025 Item # 11.E ID# 2025-4411 Page 2115 of 6525 Page 2116 of 6525 Page 2117 of 6525 Page 2118 of 6525 Page 2119 of 6525 Page 2120 of 6525 Page 2121 of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age 2122 of 6525 Housing Policy & Economic Development • 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Florida 34104 APPLICATION FORMAT INNOVATION ZONE TRUST FUND The Collier County Board of County Commissioners created Innovation Zones in 2010 to promote economic development and diversify the local economy. Under the Innovation Zone program, county commissioners create a zone, set a base tax year, and any tax increases collected in that zone are deposited into that zone's Innovation Trust Fund. Revenues are deposited into each zone's Trust Fund annually. Revenue from increased property values in each zone's geographic boundaries helps pay for projects in that zone that result in high wage jobs and helps diversify the economy of Collier County. Thisis an application form to assist applicants to any of the Innovation Zones. Kindly provide an answer to all the questions. Questions can be emailed to Lincoln.price@colliercountyfl.gov. Application Format: BUSINESS NAME: PROJECT NAME: CONTACT NAME: ADDRESS: PHONE: FAX: EMAIL: WEBSITE: SELECT INNOVATION ZONE: AVE MARIA IAC 9 GOLDEN GATE EDZ APPLICATION DATE: Provide relevant information on the applicant's background and development experience and financial ability to successfully complete the project. Include resumes of key individuals assigned to the project. Identify the applicant's consultants involved or proposed Bay College of Osteopathic Medicine Naples College of Osteopathic Medicine Chad Toujague 5600 Mariner St, Ste 227, Tampa, FL 33609 8133171617 ctoujague@medicalimpactgroup.com September 15th, 2025 Current Director at the Dr. Kiran C.Patel Family Office in Tampa, FL. Our team has delivered several medical schools to the state of Florida and our goal is to complete our final Medical School in the Naples corridor to meet our goal of graduating 1,000 new medical students annually. Our next goal would be to create 1,000 new residency positions for physician residents. Page 2123 of 6525 Housing Policy & Economic Development • 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Florida 34104 to be involved in the project noting relevant experience on similar projects (i.e., civil engineer, land use planner, applicant's legal counsel, applicant's financial advisor). Describe the proposed project, including the size and scope and phasing of the proposed project. Specifically outline residential development, if any, to be included in the project. Define the boundaries of the proposed project by address and/or locator/parcel number(s). Include a plat and map of the proposed area and legal description. Identify the property which is currently in the control of the applicant via ownership or option. If under option note the option expiration date. Is the Redevelopment Plan consistent with the Collier County Growth Management Plan? If not, please provide details. Is the property currently zoned for the proposed use? Will the proposed project result in the relocation of residential, commercial, or industrial facilities? If so, discuss the nature of any anticipated relocations. State the need and justification for the application to the Trust We are currently working on a structured PSA to acquire the property from its current landowner. Portions of the closing cost are attributed to enabling infrastructure on the property The project is just around 170MM in capital commitments. We are partnered with a local healthcare system. We would construct the building to house the College of Medicine and it would open for students by 2028. The first students would be in clerkship at local healthcare facilities by 2030 and graduating in 2032. No - Currently the land is raw and needs to be brought to acceptable level with infill and soilwork. A specific ask to be considered would be $2,100,000 to provide for soil/earth work, $1,100,000 upon certificate of occupancy and $250,000 a year for four years to support the FFE for the students Yes, Hacineda is a PUD which already has approved uses for Educaitonal and Research Facilities in its ordinance. Yes as it is in the target industry for the health care sector. Additionally, it supports an underrepresented Osteopathic community. The last 3 presidential physicians were DOs. Community anchors, such as Arthrex, are having to import physicians to train medical staff. This project is structured to be ergonomically complementary of the current health care eco system in the greater Naples area. Civil Engineer - Grady Minor - established civil engineer in the Collier County market. Land Use Planner - Grady Minor Legal Counsel - CYK Law Firm - Richard Yovanovich Architectural Team - Baker Barrios Architects Tract "A" - Cadenza at Hacienda Lakes of Naples - PB 74 - PG 16 Parcel ID - 25116000021 Tract "B" - Cadenza at Hacienda Lakes of Naples - PB 74 - PG 16 Parcel ID - 25116000128 Page 2124 of 6525 Housing Policy & Economic Development • 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Florida 34104 Fund. Substantiate that other alternative methods of financing have also been explored. Discuss the condition(s) that would qualify the proposed project for Tax Increment Financing (TIF). Identify sources, amounts, and status of all debt financing and/or equity funding available to complete the project. Does the applicant anticipate the debt to be privately financed by the construction lender or developer or publicly sold? Provide an outline of the costs associated with the development of the proposed project(s) and related parcel or parcels located within the Innovation Zone area. Identify in the outline those costs applicant would propose to fund with Innovation Zone financing. Discuss and document information used to describe the market feasibility of each element of the proposed project. If a formal feasibility or comparable studies have been prepared, attach such reports as an appendix to this application. Estimate the incremental property taxes and economic activity taxes to be generated by the project. Identify any proposed tenants of the project. Have leases been Qualified target industry generating:140MM capex/opex100+ jobs Page 2125 of 6525 Housing Policy & Economic Development • 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Florida 34104 negotiated or signed? What type of lease is contemplated? Who will own the developed property? How much of the property is intended to be sold after development is complete? Who will manage the property during the life of the Redevelopment Plan and project? Briefly describe the “economic and quality of life" benefits of the proposed project to the County. Attach a letter from a reputable financial institution indicating that the applicant has sufficient financial resources to obtain the private financing for the project. Include a signed cover letter from the applicant’s CEO I understand that I may be contacted by Collier County in response to my application . The project will be self-developed and self perfomed from a development and construction perspective. None of the property will be sold after completion. It will be managed by the medical school for its usable life. Please see attached form for our partner who funded the Orlando College of Osteopathic Medicine, Valley National A letter from the G1 of the Patel Family Office, Dr. Kiran C. Patel is attached! There is minimally projected to be a $1.7 billion impact on the local economy, with other number tracking $2.1 billion. We will have the final feasibility completed in March but it will be at least the $1.7 billion over a 20 year period. In florida, Medical Schools associated with GME (which this one will be) yielded 80% of trainees retained in-state and will support the continuity of healthcare in Naples. This is being done in partnership with the hospital systems to support the workforce pipeline, care for the residents and maintain structural continuity of the health ecosystem. Page 2126 of 6525 Bio on current engineers involved in the project: Grady Minor Founded in 1981, is a full-service civil engineering, land planning, surveying, and īÍIJîŜèÍŕôϙÍŘèēĖťôèťŪŘôϙƱŘıϙæÍŜôîϙĖIJϙ‹ĺŪťēſôŜťϙ>īĺŘĖîÍϟϙ®ĖťēϙĺƯĖèôŜϙĖIJϙĺIJĖťÍϙ‹ŕŘĖIJČŜϙÍIJîϙ >ĺŘťϙaƅôŘŜϠϙťēôϙƱŘıϙŜôŘŽôŜϙÍϙſĖîôϙŘÍIJČôϙĺċϙŕŪæīĖèϙÍIJîϙŕŘĖŽÍťôϙŜôèťĺŘϙèīĖôIJťŜϟϙXIJĺſIJϙċĺŘϙĖťŜϙ ôƄŕôŘťĖŜôϙĖIJϙīÍIJîϙîôŽôīĺŕıôIJťϙÍIJîϙĖIJċŘÍŜťŘŪèťŪŘôϙŕŘĺĤôèťŜϠϙ@ŘÍîƅaĖIJĺŘϙēÍŜϙŕīÍƅôîϙÍϙħôƅϙ ŘĺīôϙĖIJϙŜēÍŕĖIJČϙèĺııŪIJĖťĖôŜϙťēŘĺŪČēĺŪťϙťēôϙbÍŕīôŜϙÍIJîϙĺīīĖôŘϙĺŪIJťƅϙŘôČĖĺIJϟϙIIJϙ͑͏͓͑Ϡϙťēôϙ ƱŘıϙſÍŜϙÍèŗŪĖŘôîϙæƅϙ„Íŕô-"ÍſŜĺIJϙ(IJČĖIJôôŘŜϠϙôIJēÍIJèĖIJČϙĖťŜϙŘôŜĺŪŘèôŜ ſēĖīôϙıÍĖIJťÍĖIJĖIJČϙ ĖťŜϙīĺèÍīϙċĺèŪŜϟ ´Xϙ[Íſϙ>ĖŘı A full-ŜôŘŽĖèôϙīÍſϙƱŘıϙæÍŜôîϙĖIJϙbÍŕīôŜϠϙ>īĺŘĖîÍϠϙĺƯôŘĖIJČϙīôČÍīϙèĺŪIJŜôīϙĖIJϙÍŘôÍŜϙŜŪèēϙÍŜϙŘôÍīϙ ôŜťÍťôϠϙīĖťĖČÍťĖĺIJϠϙīÍIJîϙŪŜôϙÍIJîϙīĺèÍīϙČĺŽôŘIJıôIJťϠϙèĺŘŕĺŘÍťôϙÍIJîϙæŪŜĖIJôŜŜϙīÍſϠϙÍIJîϙſĖīīŜϠϙ ťŘŪŜťŜϙЭϙôŜťÍťôŜϟϙ“ēôϙƱŘıϙĖŜϙīĺèÍťôîϙÍťϙ͓͏͏͐ϙ“ÍıĖÍıĖϙ“ŘÍĖīϙbĺŘťēϠϙ‹ŪĖťôϙ͒͏͏ϠϙbÍŕīôŜϠϙÍIJîϙēÍŜϙ ÍϙťôÍıϙĺċϙÍæĺŪťϙ͔͐-͑͏ϙÍťťĺŘIJôƅŜϟϙ´XϙôıŕēÍŜĖƏôŜϙēĖČē-ŗŪÍīĖťƅϙèīĖôIJťϙŜôŘŽĖèôϙſĖťēϙÍϙċĺèŪŜϙ ĺIJϙæĺťēϙ>īĺŘĖîÍϙIJÍťĖŽôŜϙÍIJîϙŜôèĺIJî-ēĺıôϙĺſIJôŘŜϟϙIťϙēÍŜϙæŪĖīťϙÍϙŘôŕŪťÍťĖĺIJϙċĺŘϙèĺıæĖIJĖIJČϙ ŜťŘÍťôČĖèϙīôČÍīϙÍîŽĖèôϙſĖťēϙŜĺŕēĖŜťĖèÍťôîϙŘôŕŘôŜôIJťÍťĖĺIJϟ “ŘôæĖīèĺèħϙĺIJŜŪīťĖIJČϙ‹ĺīŪťĖĺIJŜ >ĺŪIJîôîϙĖIJϙ͑͏͏͖ϙæƅϙbĺŘıÍIJϙVϟϙ“ŘôæĖīèĺèħϠϙĖŜϙÍϙťŘÍIJŜŕĺ؝͝ĖĺIJϙôIJČĖIJôôŘĖIJČϙÍIJîϙŘĺÍîſÍƅϙ îôŜĖČIJϙƱŘıϙæÍŜôîϙĖIJϙbÍŕīôŜϠϙ>īĺŘĖîÍϟϙbĺŘıÍIJϠϙſēĺϙēĺīîŜϙèŘôîôIJťĖÍīŜϙÍŜϙÍϙŕŘĺċôŜŜĖĺIJÍīϙ ôIJČĖIJôôŘϠϙŕīÍIJIJôŘϠϙÍIJîϙťŘÍƯĖèϙĺŕôŘÍťĖĺIJŜϙŜŕôèĖÍīĖŜťϠϙīôÍîŜϙťēôϙƱŘıϙĖIJϙēÍIJîīĖIJČϙŕŘĺĤects ŘÍIJČĖIJČϙċŘĺıϙŘĺÍîſÍƅŜϠϙŜĖČIJÍīĖƏÍťĖĺIJϠϙīĖČēťĖIJČϠϙÍIJîϙťŘÍƯĖèϙŜťŪîĖôŜϙťĺϙÍèèôŜŜĖIJČϙŕôŘıĖťťĖIJČϙ ÍIJîϙŘôČŪīÍťĺŘƅϙèĺĺŘîĖIJÍťĖĺIJϟϙ®ĖťēϙÍϙťŘÍèħϙŘôèĺŘîϙĺċϙîôŜĖČIJĖIJČϙēŪIJîŘôîŜϙĺċϙťŘÍIJŜŕĺ؝͝ĖĺIJ- ŘôīÍťôîϙŕŘĺĤôèťŜϙťēŘĺŪČēĺŪťϙ‹ĺŪťēſôŜťϙ>īĺŘĖîÍϠϙ“‹ϙĖŜϙħIJĺſIJϙċĺŘϙĺƯôŘĖng cost-ôƯôèťĖŽôϠϙ ĖIJIJĺŽÍťĖŽôϙŜĺīŪťĖĺIJŜϙċĺèŪŜôîϙĺIJϙċÍèĖīĖťÍťĖIJČϙŜÍċôϙÍIJîϙôƯĖèĖôIJťϙÍèèôŜŜϙĖIJϙæĺťēϙŕŪæīĖèϙÍIJîϙ ŕŘĖŽÍťôϙŜôèťĺŘϙîôŽôīĺŕıôIJťŜϟ Page 2127 of 6525 127)25&216758&7,21&29(56+((7352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66*1&+&201$3/(6)/6'352*5(66Page 2128 of 6525 127)25&216758&7,21&21&(37352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66*Page 2129 of 6525 127)25&216758&7,21&21&(37022'%2$5'352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66*Page 2130 of 6525 127)25&216758&7,21&21&(379,(:6352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66*Page 2131 of 6525  6&$/(  127)25&216758&7,211681678'<6800(5352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66*681678'< 6800(5 $0681678'< 6800(5 $0681678'< 6800(5 30681678'< 6800(5 30Page 2132 of 6525   6&$/(  127)25&216758&7,211681678'<:,17(5352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66*681678'< :,17(5 $0681678'< :,17(5 30681678'< :,17(5 30681678'< :,17(5 30Page 2133 of 6525 3523(57</,1(($6(0(17&&$'(1=$52$'5$77/(61$.(+$002&.52$')$&8/7</2763$&(6'5232))/2233$5.,1*/2763$&(66&+(0(6800$5<&20a*6)3$5.,1*63$&(66(&85,7<&$5'(')$&8/7<$&&(66*$7(')$&8/7<$&&(66  6&$/(  127)25&216758&7,211$5&+,7(&785$/6,7(3/$1352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66$Page 2134 of 6525 =2$$$$$$$$/2%%<6)0(36)&/$6652206 [ 6)0(36)/(&785(+$//6 [ 6)55V),71(66 /2&.(566)678'(17/281*( &$)(6)7(&+6(59,&(66)0(36)67256)'5232))/2236(&85,7<6+2:(56 /2&.(566)83   6&$/(  127)25&216758&7,21129(5$//)/2253/$1/(9(/352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66$Page 2135 of 6525 $$$$$$23(172%(/2:$$678'(17/281*(6)0(36)6725$*(6)6,0/$%6)55V9,578$/$1$720</$%6)26&(6)0(36)678'<522066)/2&.(566)0(36)26&($&725/281*(0$.(83200/$%6)/,%5$5<6)678'<32'66&$/(   127)25&216758&7,21129(5$//)/2253/$1/(9(/352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66$Page 2136 of 6525 $$$$$$$)$&8/7</281*(6)0(36)2)),&(66)55V(;(&2)),&(66)0(36)%2$5'52206))$&8/7<5(6($5&+/$%6)0(36)$'0,66,2166)2)),&(66)2)),&(66)(;(&/2%%<6&$/(   127)25&216758&7,21129(5$//)/2253/$1/(9(/352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66$Page 2137 of 6525 127)25&216758&7,21'9,(:6352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66$1($(5,$/1:$(5,$/6($(5,$/6:$(5,$/Page 2138 of 6525 127)25&216758&7,21/(&785(+$//63/,7352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66$&(17(5352-(&7,216&5((15$7,2  :[ +6,'(352-(&7,216&5((15$7,2  :[a +6,'(352-(&7,216&5((15$7,2  :[a +Page 2139 of 6525 127)25&216758&7,21/(&785(+$//23(1352-$85($7('(9_1&+&206'352*5(66$6,'(352-(&7,216&5((15$7,2  :[a +6,'(352-(&7,216&5((15$7,2  :[a +Page 2140 of 6525 Page 2141 of 6525 Page 2142 of 6525 1 Final Economic Impact Analysis of the Proposed Orlando College of Osteopathic Medicine (OCOM) in Orlando, Florida April 26, 2021 Disclosure Page 2143 of 6525 2 The proposed institution is currently working on an application for provisional licensure for submission to the Florida Commission for Independent Education (“CIE”) with an estimated submission date in July 2021. The submission should in no way be represented that the proposed institution will be granted a provisional license by the CIE, will release any advertising materials or will enroll any potential student applicants until all required regulatory agencies, including the CIE, have granted licensure approval(s) and the ability to legally advertise the institution. This statement does not represent advertising of the institution or an attempt to recruit potential students and should not be interpreted as such as the statement is a notification to any member of the public of the proposed institution’s intended plans. Page 2144 of 6525 3 Overview Tripp Umbach’s national studies estimate that medical schools and teaching hospitals generate more than $800 billion annually in the US economy. The establishment of a new medical school campus in central Florida will likewise bring significant “fresh dollars” to the region and is likely to inspire additional economic development through the potential expansion of other health science education programs, clinical and research partnerships with nearby community hospitals, and private business expansions that may be developed over time. The proposed medical school campus will bring economic benefits both directly and indirectly to both the regional and statewide economies. The direct benefits will come from the direct spending of the proposed medical school campus on capital improvements and goods and services to businesses in the region and through the hiring of new faculty and staff and through student spending. The indirect impact is derived from these direct, first -round expenditures, which are received as income by other businesses in the region and state and circulated through the economy in successive rounds of spending. In April 2021, Tripp Umbach conducted a study to quantify the projected annual economic, employment, government revenue and social impacts associated with the proposed Orlando College of Osteopathic Medicine (OCOM) in Orlando, Florida is at full maturity in 2027. This study also demonstrates future economic impacts of the school in 2030 and 204 5 when the college has additional programs and has graduated a significant number of physicians and other healthcare professionals. Tripp Umbach is the national leader in developing economic impact statements for medical schools, having completed studies since 1995 for every allopathic medical school and for more than half of all osteopathic medical schools. Over the past 20 years Tripp Umbach as completed economic impact studies for more than 30 new or expanded medical schools, including studies for 15 new medical schools that are now operational. The economic, employment and government revenue numbers presented in this report are based on projected spending d ata provided to Tripp Umbach by OCOM as well as historical achievement of existing medical schools. Fresh Dollars The establishment of a new medical school campus in central Florida will bring significant “fresh dollars” to the region and is likely to inspire additional economic development. Page 2145 of 6525 4 Executive Summary • The direct and indirect economic impact of the campus during the two-year construction and start-up period (2021-23) is expected to total $62.4 million, provide 338 construction and other jobs, and add $2.6 million in taxes to communities in the central Florida region. • In 2027 when the proposed school is fully operational it will have an economic impact (direct and indirect economic benefits) of $46.4 million, more than 345 jobs, and $3.0 million in taxes to communities in the region. • In addition to operational impact outlined above, by 2030 the economic impact of the proposed campus will grow to $80.4 million as central Florida communities will begin realizing healthcare benefits and additional economic impact as graduates of the campus locate in the region and state. Tripp Umbach estimates that by 2030 when the first class of medical students complete their residencies, these new primary care physicians will also yield real savings, as emergency room utilization declines, for example. These savings are expected to total $10.8 million annually by 2030. • By 2030 commercial spin-off activity from research completed at the proposed campus will equal $100.0 million annually, sustaining approximately 800 additional jobs central Florida. • By 2045 the total economic impact of the proposed college to the Orlando region will equal more than $1.7 billion, support over 9,000 jobs and contribute more than $86 million to state and local governments. Page 2146 of 6525 5 Table 1 includes a summation of total economic, employment, and government revenue impacts. All numbers are presented on an annual basis for the years listed. For example, h ealthcare cost savings is calculated for the year in which a class of expected graduates enter the practice of medicine. Table 1: Summary of Projected Regional Impacts Note: Investments and impacts from additional construction over the period 2023-2045 are not included in the chart above. Additional Impacts not included in the Study Tripp Umbach’s analysis of the economic impact of the proposed OCOM in central Florida is based on many conservative assumptions. Not included in this analysis are the economic impacts associated with the growth of the regional healthcare industry related to additiona l patients staying in the region for care, patients being attracted to the region for care due to increased quality and expanded medical services, or the economic benefits related to the expansion of graduate medical education at local hospitals. 2021-23 Construction Phase 2023 2027 Fully operational 2030 2045 Construction $62.4m - - Annual Operational impacts - $26.4m $46.4m $66.4m $128m Workforce Impacts - - - $80.4m $1.4b Private Spin-Off Impacts - - $25.0m $102.0m $200m Total Economic Impact $62.4m $26.4m $71.4m $248.8m $1.7b Healthcare Cost Savings - - - $30.8m $608m Total Direct Jobs Supported 238 145 392 1,323 9,191 Regional Government Revenue $3.1m $1.3m $3.6m $12.4m $86.4m Page 2147 of 6525 6 Appendix: Economic Impact Methods and Notes Tripp Umbach completed an economic impact assessment of the proposed OCOM campus in central Florida. Tripp Umbach has performed more than 500 economic impact studies for both academic institutions and large health care systems, including for every US medical school and more than 400 teaching hospitals – both allopathic and osteopathic institutions. The economic models used by Tripp Umbach in this analysis were first developed in 1970 by the American Council on Higher Education. The data in the model were supplied by OCOM (faculty, students, and operational expenses etc.) and from Tripp Umbach’s comprehensive database and models from new medical school and existing medical school expansion studies in other localities throughout the United States. The methodology employed in these studies was originally derived from a set of research tools and techniques developed for the American Council on Educ ation (ACE).1 The ACE-based methodology employs linear cash flow modeling to track the flow of institution-originated funds through a delineated spatial area. Based on previous economic impact studies performed for new and/or regional medical schools throughout the United States and State of Florida. The application of this "fresh dollar" model provides a first-line measure in the state economy caused by the proposed OCOM. The final model concept evolved into a hybrid model including a fresh-dollar approach feeding into a traditional model which tracks in -state and in-region spending. The final model used for this research measures funds brought into the state together with the ultimate flow of these funds through the Florida and central Florida region economies and the effect on economic expansion, job growth, and government revenue and enterprise development. The final methodology closely matches the impact study methodology recommended for individual medical schools by the Association of American Me dical Colleges (AAMC). 1 Caffery, John and Issacs, Herbert, “Estimating the Impact of a College or University on the Local Economy,” American Council on Education, 1971. Page 2148 of 6525