Agenda 03/25/2025 Item #12A (Remove Christina Aguilera from the East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee for consecutive absences, appoint Bruce Hamels to replace the vacant seat)3/25/2025
Item # 12.A
ID# 2025-1065
Executive Summary
Recommendation to remove Christina Aguilera from the East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee for consecutive
absences, appoint Bruce Hamels to replace the vacant seat, appoint a member to the alternate seat, and consider
extending the sunset date from August 15, 2025, to August 15, 2026.
OBJECTIVE: To add members to the East of 951 Ad Hoc Committee and to consider extending the committee by one
year. The Resolution provides that if the Committee is extended, the terms of all members shall automatically be
extended until the end of the extended term.
CONSIDERATIONS: This ad hoc committee was established on March 28, 2023, by Resolution No. 2023-54, to assist
the Board of County Commissioners in compiling and identifying issues and relevant best practices relating to the
geographic area lying east of CR 951 (Collier Boulevard) and north of I-75 (Alligator Alley), and to provide a forum for
the citizens of this area to identify and discuss issues facing their community. This committee was set to sunset on
August 15, 2024, and was extended by resolution 24-112 to expire 12 months from the sunset date on August 15,
2025.
The committee is composed of five regular members and two alternate members who represent a broad base of residents
and business and property owners within the targeted geographic area.
There is a vacant seat for an alternate member on this Board from the resignation of Rae Ann Burton on February 10,
2025. The committee also seeks to declare a vacancy for a regular member seat, as Christina Aguilera has missed five
consecutive meetings. This committee is perpetually advertised, and a total of 15 applications were received. All
applications are included in the backup. The Committee has narrowed down the applicants to the following:
APPLICANT DISTRICT VOTER ADVISORY COMMITTEES
Bruce Hamels 5 Yes Productivity Committee (2024-Current)
Douglas Rankin 5 Yes East of 951 Horizon Master Plan Committee
(2006-2008), Productivity Committee (1993-
1996), Golden Gate Estates Ad Hoc (2001-
2003)
Angela Birks 5 Yes Golden Gate Estates Land Trust Committee
(2019-2022)
Frank Roberts 5 Yes None
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff has considered the applications received and recommends appointing
Bruce Hamels to the Committee to serve the remainder of Christina Aguilera’s vacant term expiring August
15, 2025. No recommendation was made for the alternate seat.
FISCAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact associated with this action.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated with this action.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item is approved as to form and legality and requires majority vote for Board
approval. - JAK
Page 758 of 5415
3/25/2025
Item # 12.A
ID# 2025-1065
RECOMMENDATIONS: That the Board of County Commissioners declares the seat held by Christina Aguilera to be
vacant, adopts the Staff Recommendation, appoints an additional alternate member, and directs the County Attorney to
prepare a resolution confirming the appointments.
PREPARED BY: Jeffrey A. Klatzkow, County Attorney
ATTACHMENTS:
1. E951 Backup 3.25.25
2. E951 Membership List 3.25.25
3. Resolution 2023-054 E951 Committee
Page 759 of 5415
Page 760 of 5415
Page 761 of 5415
Page 762 of 5415
Page 763 of 5415
Page 764 of 5415
Page 765 of 5415
Page 766 of 5415
Page 767 of 5415
Page 768 of 5415
Page 769 of 5415
Page 770 of 5415
Page 771 of 5415
Page 772 of 5415
Page 773 of 5415
Page 774 of 5415
Page 775 of 5415
Page 776 of 5415
Page 777 of 5415
Page 778 of 5415
Page 779 of 5415
Page 780 of 5415
Page 781 of 5415
Page 782 of 5415
Page 783 of 5415
Page 784 of 5415
Page 785 of 5415
Page 786 of 5415
Page 787 of 5415
Page 788 of 5415
Page 789 of 5415
Page 790 of 5415
Page 791 of 5415
Page 792 of 5415
Page 793 of 5415
Page 794 of 5415
Page 795 of 5415
Page 796 of 5415
Page 797 of 5415
Page 798 of 5415
Page 799 of 5415
Page 800 of 5415
Page 801 of 5415
Page 802 of 5415
Page 803 of 5415
Page 804 of 5415
Page 805 of 5415
Page 806 of 5415
Page 807 of 5415
Name Home Phone
Appt'd Exp. Date Term
DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Work Phone
East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee
05/23/23 08/15/24
6/11/24 8/15/25
1 Year
8671 Addison Place Circle #417
Regular Member
3
1 Year
District:
Category:
Ms. Christina Aguilera
Naples, FL 34119
(239) 784-8058
E-Mail:christinagrayaguilera@gmail.com
05/23/23 08/15/24
6/11/24 8/15/25
1 Year
2631 4th St. NW
Regular Member
3
1 Year
District:
Category:
Mr. Michael Ramsey
Naples, FL 34120
(239) 564-1660
E-Mail:michael.r.ramsey@embarqmail.com
05/23/23 08/15/24
6/11/24 8/15/25
1 Year
530 3rd St. SW
Regular Member
5
1 Year
District:
Category:
Ms. Kimberley Ellis
Naples, FL 34117
(239) 269-7025
E-Mail:kellis@johnrwood.com
05/23/23 08/15/24
6/11/24 8/15/25
1 Year
560 5th St. SW
Regular Member
5
1 Year
District:
Category:
Mr. Robert Raines
Naples, FL 34117
(239) 285-2658
E-Mail:robertbobrains@aol.com
05/23/23 08/15/24
6/11/24 8/15/25
1 Year
140 Wilson Blvd. S.
Regular Member
5
1 Year
District:
Category:
Mr. Mark Teaters, Sr.
Naples, FL 34117
(239) 304-1817
(239) 253-9377
E-Mail:mteaters@aol.com
Tuesday, March 18, 2025 Page 1 of 3
Page 808 of 5415
Name Home Phone
Appt'd Exp. Date Term
DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Work Phone
East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee
05/23/23 08/15/24
6/11/24 8/15/25
1 Year
4741 14th Ave. SE
Alternate Member
5
1 Year
District:
Category:
Mr. Aaron Zwiefel
Naples, FL 34117
(786) 385-1166
E-Mail:azwief@gmail.com
8/15/25 1 Year
Alternate Member
5District:
Category:
VACANT VACANT
Naples, FL
E-Mail:
Tuesday, March 18, 2025 Page 2 of 3
Page 809 of 5415
Name Home Phone
Appt'd Exp. Date Term
DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Work Phone
East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee
This ad hoc committee was established on March 28, 2023, by Resolution No. 2023-54, to assist
the Board of County Commissioners in compiling and identifying issues and relevant best
practices relating to the geographic area lying east of CR 951 (Collier Boulevard) and north of I-
75 (Alligator Alley), and to provide a forum for the citizens of this area to identify and discuss
issues facing their community. The committee shall be composed of five regular members and
two alternate members who represent a broad base of residents and business and property
owners within the targeted geographic area.
The original sunset date of this committee (August 15, 2024) was extended by Resolution No. 24-
112 for 1 year to August 15, 2025.
Parker Klopf: 252-2471Staff:
FL STAT:
Tuesday, March 18, 2025 Page 3 of 3
Page 810 of 5415
RESOLUTION NO. 2023-54
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CREATING THE EAST OF 951 AD HOC
ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
WHEREAS,that portion of Collier County,Florida, located generally east of County Road
951 (Collier Boulevard) and north, is home to a rapidly increasing population; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners (Board) desires to establish an Ad Hoc
Advisory Committee to provide a forum for the citizens of this area to identify and discuss issues
facing their community; and
WHEREAS, the Board desires to create this East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee for
a preliminary term of one initial year, with the potential to make this a permanent advisory board
if warranted.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, THAT:
SECTION ONE: Creation and Purpose of the East of 951 Advisory Committee.
Pursuant to the provisions of Collier County Ordinance No. 2001-55, as amended, the
Board hereby establishes the East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee (Committee), to assist the
Board in identifying issues relating to the residents of Collier County residing in the geographical
area lying East of CR 951 (Collier Boulevard) and north of I-75 (Alligator Alley).
SECTION TWO: Functions, Powers and Duties of the Committee.
The functions, powers, and duties of this Committee shall be to assist the Board in
identifying issues and relevant best practices as they relate to the geographic area of Collier County
identified in Section One above. In addition, at the request of the Board, the committee shall
consider topics of interest for the Board.
SECTION THREE: Appointment of Members,Terms of Office,Attendance Requirements.
A. The Committee shall be composed of five regular members and two alternate
members who are appointed by resolution of the Board of County Commissioners. Alternate
members may only vote in the absence of one or more regular members. Members shall, to the
maximum extent possible, represent a broad base of residents and business and property owners
within the geographical area lying East of CR 951 (Collier Boulevard) and north of 1-75 (Alligator
Alley).
B. Terms of office shall be for one year, commencing with the first meeting of the
Committee; however, if the Board by resolution extends the sunset date of the Committee, the
23-BCC-02175/1779945/1] 1
Page 811 of 5415
terms of the members shall automatically be extended until the end of the extended term. The
members shall serve at the pleasure of the Board.
SECTION FOUR: Officers, Quorum, and Reimbursement of Expenses.
At the Committee's first meeting,the membership shall elect a Chair and Vice-Chair. The
presence of a majority of the membership shall constitute a quorum. The Committee shall follow
Robert's Rules of Order for the transaction of business and shall keep records of the meetings,
findings, and determinations. The members of the Committee shall serve without compensation,
but may be reimbursed for travel, mileage, and/or per diem expenses, if approved in advance by
the Board.
SECTION FIVE: Dissolution of Committee.
Unless extended by Resolution of the Board or converted into a permanent advisory board
by Ordinance, this Committee shall automatically sunset without further action one year from the
first meeting of the Committee.
THIS RESOLUTION ADOPTED upon majority vote this XIllday of 01 2023.
ATTEST:BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Crystal K. Kinzel, Clerk of Courts
i COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
r
By: Gt/,G By; (----126 ; ----
r.
ty Clerk Rick LoCastro, Chairman
Attest as to Chairman's,
Appro l: r and legality:
ILL
Jeffrey A. la !kow, County Attorney
23-BCC-02175/1779945/1] 2
Page 812 of 5415