Immokalee MSTU Minutes 09/18/2024Enclosure 1
1
MINUTES
Meeting of the Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency Immokalee Local Redevelopment
Advisory Board on September 18, 2024. The Advisory Board members, staff, and public appeared virtually
and in person.
Hybrid Remote Public Meeting
CareerSource
750 South 5th Street
Immokalee, FL 34142
A. Call to Order.
The meeting was called to order by CRA Chair Mark Lemke at 8:30 A.M.
B. Pledge of Allegiance and Opening Prayer .
Mark Lemke led the Pledge of Allegiance and asked for a moment of silence.
C. Roll Call and Announcement of a Quorum.
Christie Betancourt opened roll call. A quorum was announced for the CRA Board.
CRA Advisory Board Members Present in Person:
Mark Lemke, Patricia Anne Goodnight, Andrea Halman, Estil Null, and Yvar Pierre.
CRA Advisory Board Members Present via Zoom:
None.
CRA Advisory Board Members Absent/Excused:
Mike Facundo, Edward “Ski” Olesky and Lupita Vazquez Reyes.
Others Present in Person:
Said Gomez, James Hanrahan, Silvia Puente, Misty Smith, Dottie Cook, Cristina Perez, Bernardo
Barnhart, Clara Herrera, Commissioner Bill McDaniel, and Sarah Harrington.
Others Present via Zoom:
Iliana Caris, Rosemary LaBarge, Aristeo Alviar, Max Rams, and Kyle Pryce.
Staff Present in Person: John Dunnuck, Christie Betancourt, Yvonne Blair, and Yuridia Zaragoza.
D. Voting Privileges for Board Members via Zoom
Staff announced that a CRA Board Member may join on Zoom.
CRA Action: Mr. Estil Null made a motion to allow board members on Zoom privileges. Ms.
Patricia Anne Goodnight seconded the motion, and it passed by unanimous vote. 5-0.
E. Approval of Agenda.
Staff presented the Agenda to the Board for approval. The Agenda was approved as presented.
CRA Action: Ms. Patricia Anne Goodnight made a motion to approve the Agenda as presented.
Mr. Estil Null seconded the motion, and it passed by unanimous vote. 5-0.
F. Approval of Consent Agenda
1. Minutes
i. CRA Advisory Board Meeting for August 21, 2024 (Enclosure 1)
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 325 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
2
2. Budget Reports (Enclosure 2)
3. Code Enforcement Report (Enclosure 3)
4. Staff Reports
i. Assistant Director Report (Enclosure 4)
ii. Project Manager Report (Enclosure 5)
iii. Community Meetings (Enclosure 6)
Staff presented the Consent Agenda to the board for approval. Staff informed board members on Packet Page
29, the title of the report, Program Manager Report, is supposed to be titled Assistant Director Report, like
stated in the Agenda.
The Consent Agenda was approved as presented.
CRA Action: Ms. Patricia Anne Goodnight made a motion to approve the Consent Agenda as
presented. Ms. Andrea Halman seconded the motion, and it passed by unanimous vote. 5-0.
G. Announcements.
1. Public Comments speaker slips
CRA Staff reiterated the public 3-minute speaker slip policy. The Board will give more time if they
feel it necessary.
2. Communications Folder
Staff reviewed the communication folder with the board and members of the public. The folder
included the public notice for the CRA meeting, letter of support sent to the Zoning Division for
the renaming of Eustis Ave to Howard Way, Neighborhood Information Meeting Notice on the
renaming of Eustis Ave to Howard Way, updated 2024 Public Meeting Calendar, details on the
Community Cleanup held in Immokalee, International Coastal Cleanup Flyer, 11th Annual
Christmas Tree Lighting Event flyer, Cherryle Thomas Christmas Around the World Parade and
Gala Event flyer, and the Immokalee CRA and MSTU Board vacancies.
3. Dr. Frank Nappo Retirement
Ms. Yvar Pierre commented that even before she joined the Advisory Board and being in the
CareerSource center and seeing Dr. Frank Nappo and talking to him, Dr. Frank Nappo definitely
has a passion for Immokalee, which is rare to see because he is not fro m here. To see him not be
from here and the passion that he has for the community is something that she will always cherish,
and she will miss seeing that. If there’s one thing that she and all the members in the CareerSource
center know is that Dr. Frank Nappo does not play about Immokalee. She loves the dedication he
has and said she will miss him.
Mr. Estil Null commented on the many good things Dr. Frank Nappo has done for Immokalee. Dr.
Frank Nappo was needed on this Board, especially with all of his experiences. We will miss him.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 326 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
3
Ms. Andrea Halman commented that she and Dr. Frank Nappo joined the Board around the same
time. Although both were strong willed and often bumped heads, they always got over it and were
able to discuss things out. She commented on one of her experiences with Dr. Nappo and said that
Dr. Frank Nappo showed up to the Christmas Tree Lighting Event and took the cookies off the table
to help serve to the community members. She said that the cookies were being saved for the kids
that were performing and Dr. Frank Nappo had no idea about this, and she realized that he probably
helped serve the cookies since he saw many of them on the table. She found this scenario very
funny. She commented that she has enjoyed Dr. Frank Nappo. He is very smart and loved in
Immokalee.
Ms. Patricia Anne Goodnight commented on Dr. Frank Nappo. She said Dr. Frank Nappo b rought
a different aspect to Immokalee and many things. She said that everyone appreciates all the advice
and work that he has done to help us all out. We will miss him.
Mr. Mark Lemke commented that he started to attend these meeting maybe 10 to 12 years ago, and
before he even joined the Board, Dr. Frank Nappo was already on the board. Dr. Frank Nappo had
a passion and cared about Immokalee and making it a better place. Dr. Frank Nappo put a lot of
effort and time into that matter. Mr. Lemke said that many don’t find people very often who really
care but Mr. Lemke has remembered Dr. Frank Nappo’s passion on the Lake Trafford fixing and
getting another road out of town in case of an emergency. Dr. Frank Nappo was always thinking
ahead and thinking about what would be best for the community and what is needed, and even
though he didn’t live in Immokalee, he was always a part of it. Dr. Frank Nappo really strived to
teach new leaders how to step up and do what they can for the community, part of his legacy will
live on in the people that he has touched and inspired to care about the community and invest the
time needed into the community. He will be missed.
Commissioner McDaniel commented that he has been in the community for 43 years, and Dr. Frank
Nappo has been here forever himself. When Commissioner McDaniel started to get involved in
politics with regards to becoming a Collier County Commissioner, Dr. Frank Nappo was not just a
mentor but a friend. At the same time, Dr. Frank Nappo always brought up global thoughts on how
to approach circumstances within our community, that Commissioner McDaniel hadn’t really given
much concept to. Commissioner McDaniel had his way of doing things and so has Dr. Frank Nappo,
and one spot that they both came together on was the necessity of Infrastructure for our community.
The successes that come to a community by putting infrastructure are untold, almost unmeasurable
and Dr. Frank Nappo worked with Commissioner McDaniel to help bring forward all of the benefits
that we are currently experiencing now. Commissioner McDaniel wished Dr. Frank Nappo and his
family well.
Ms. Christie Betancourt commented that Dr. Frank Nappo has been on the CRA Board for over 10
years, and he has changed the way we thought and our way of thinking outside the box on how to
get things accomplished.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 327 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
4
She has recently sent him an email with details on what the CRA Board is looking to accomplish,
and she has spoken with Ms. Cherryle Thomas, who recently retired from the Chamber, and who
has been with the MSTU Board for 36 years, and the impact that she has made with changing a lot
of things dealing with infrastructure in Immokalee. Dr. Frank Nappo has done the same thing but
in a different way. Although not many agreed with Dr. Nappo methods, he was a professor, and he
knew what people thought and how it worked. He knew how to play the game. Dr. Frank Nappo
made staff have public meetings in areas that many would never think to have public meetings at.
Ms. Betancourt recalled the many times she became emotional and her thoughts on whether or not
she wanted to continue doing this. She commented on the difficulties of having a public meeting at
the lake, museum, and aircraft hangar, however, that was the best thing that could have ever been
done because that brought many people to the area that needed to lay eyes on it. Dr. Frank Nappo
did that and also made sure that a new pier was done at Lake Trafford. Behind him was staff and
the community supporting him, but he did that with all his efforts and pushing others to help with
this matter. She commented that it was the coldest day of the year when they had this meeting at
the Lake, and she remembered the County Manager at the time, Mr. Leo Ochs, being present at the
meeting. Ms. Betancourt said that at the time she didn’t want to be seen, she likes to do the work
but not be seen and Dr. Frank Nappo made her stand out and encouraged her to take a stand on the
needs of the community. She commented on the many flaws Dr. Frank Nappo would point out, but
with that Dr. Frank Nappo was her mentor, and she is in the position she is in now because of him.
She thanked Dr. Nappo and his family for allowing him to come to the meetings and for giving a
piece of himself to Immokalee.
Mr. Aristeo Alviar commented on the Zoom chat ” In these last few years I've known Dr. Frank
Nappo, he has always been one of the biggest and most passionate advocates for our beautiful little
town of Immokalee! Wishing him and his family well”.
H. Other Agencies
1. FDOT Updates
Commissioner McDaniel commented that the Moving Florida Forward initiative is making
progress. FDOT is working to finish up the PD&E on the Loop Road. The Loop Road will come
down by the West side of the Airport and the East side of the Park and then key in back into New
Market Road. This project is close to 100 million dollars’ worth of infrastructure into the
community.
Commissioner McDaniel provided information on an 8-lane on I-75 all the way from 951 Collier
Boulevard all the way to Corkscrew Road. He commented on the diverging diamond interchange
and informed everyone to follow the signs while driving. A diverging diamond interchange is being
constructed now at 951 Collier Boulevard in I-75, the next will be done in Pine Ridge Road, which
is slated to be done in two years. The third diverging diamond interchange in Collier County will
be done in Immokalee Road, this project has not been funded yet, but it will certainly come through
with the improvements that are coming up with I-75.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 328 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
5
He commented on the current progress on Collier County acquisition of the Williams Farm
property, with that will come a road from Immokalee Drive clear down to Immokalee Road. This
will be almost right on-line with Little League Road, which will give the community another road
out of town and down through Williams Farm to Immokalee Road.
Mr. Aristeo Alviar commented on the Zoom chat and asked if Commissioner McDaniel could give
an update on the Private Road Emergency Repair Municipal Service Taxing Unit (MSTU)
emergency repairs for private roads.
Commissioner McDaniel followed up and said he reviewed the Executive Summary, and this item
will be on the Agenda for the Board of Collier County Commissioner for the County wide MSTU.
The specs have been redone so that staff can redo the bidding process. The main goal for this is to
bring all the roads, which is about 110 miles of private roads in Collier County, up to a traversable
level by an ambulance, and keep all families and neighborhood safe and allow everybody to drive
on the roads. If this is item is passed, the plans will be to move through the actual fixing of the
roads, and while that is occurring, staff will be going into a maintenance program and documenting
the maintenance and hopefully bring the tax rate down after the initial expenses are paid back. One
of the big prohibition is that Government cannot enter and interrupt the owner’s property without
permission, but with this being declared an Emergency for the County for public safety, it will allow
the government to legally take assets on to private roads.
Ms. Andrea Halman commented on having people understand the importance of doing something
about these roads and asked Commissioner McDaniel if it would help if there was support to show
the other Commissioners on the need for these roads. She commented that this has taken a long time
to come through.
Commissioner McDaniel provided details on what transpired when he pushed to get the County
wide MSTU put in place. He asked Emergency staff, EMS, Fire and Sheriff, to go through all 110
miles and grade them A, B, and C, with A being the worst. Staff were in the process of passing the
graded “A” roads, 13 miles of private roads, and the expense associated with these “A” roads was
almost $600,000 to bring them up to grade to be traversable. This would have been up to 15 to 20
years of tax revenue to repay. Due to Tropical Storm Debby, another Commissioner noticed the
same issue with a couple of roads in their District. He further provided information on other
alternate ways to help with this process. For now, he believes this is the best route to help
accomplish with the Emergency Repair of unpaved private roads. He commented that there will
still be an opt out program, if one opts-out, they will be obligated to keep their road traversable to
the County standards that are established. Once one is opted in, they are in and cannot opt out. He
commented that if anyone wants to call in and voice their support, they are more than welcome to.
Ms. Andrea Halman commented on the importance of people showing support and for others to
realize how important this is for those who live within these private roads.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 329 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
6
Mr. Mark Lemke asked for clarification on whether the 13 miles of roads are already part of this
MSTU Emergency repairs for private roads.
Commissioner McDaniel clarified that the 13 miles is a part of this MSTU, and it is set to be
expanded to the whole County. He commented that this will allow them to use enough funds to be
able to pay back the total exposure quicker. He further provided brief details on what the progress
could be with establishing this MSTU.
2. Other Community Agencies
Immokalee Water and Sewer District, Misty Smith
Ms. Misty Smith provided details on the Charrette that the Immokalee Water and Sewer District
(IWSD) will be hosting on Monday, September 23, 2024 from 9 a.m. to 10:30 a.m. A Charrette is
a collaborative process where individuals come together to share ideas and brainstorm ideas. The
IWSD is looking to do this to explore and see how they can get creative and get funding, whether
its loans or grants but more for grants since loans affect their bottom line. They have a lot of projects
occurring and are really trying their best to update the infrastructure in the community, although
many do not see it since it’s mostly underground. Ms. Smith also informed everyone that the IWSD
have their 3rd rate increase that will take effect on October 1, 2024. This is the third increase of the
rate study that they completed, this started in 2022 and they are set to do another study in the coming
year. The IWSD ultimate goals are to not raise the rates, and coming up with ways to get funding
is the best way to do that.
Ms. Andrea Halman commented that there was infrastructure bill that the Federal Government
passed and asked why the IWSD does not take money from that bill.
Ms. Christie Betancourt commented that the IWSD have great lobbyists. She asked Ms. Misty
Smith if they were awarded this year.
Ms. Misty Smith commented that they were not awarded this year. The only appropriations that
they requested this year where for the utility relocations. Last year, they received funding but for
three project. One project was fully funded, but the other two were not. They were short millions
of dollars. They have a timeline of when certain projects need to be done, so they have to get creative
and gain funding. There are infrastructure dollars there, but the IWSD is competing with utilities
all across the State. Immokalee is a small area and compared to the impact based on customers like
Miami-Dade or Cape Coral, who have a better chance of getting the funding needed. The IWSD
staff is looking to see where they fit as a District and what they could qualify in based on the
population and a list of other things. They have applied heavily on grants.
Code Enforcement, Cristina Perez
Ms. Cristina Perez provided information on the cleanup held on September 7, 2024. It was a great
event; 65 trips were made from the Immokalee residents. County staff had a total of 7 roll offs that
went away full, out of these roll offs, county staff collected 11.09 tons of construction debris,
garbage, and general miscellaneous garbage, but staff also separated the waste.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 330 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
7
They had 3.56 tons of yard waste, 2.69 tons of tires, and they also collected 1100 pounds of paint,
50 gallons of oil and 37 TVs along with other electronics. The Sheriff’s office assisted with the
Weekenders, this allowed for a thriving service to the community.
Ms. Perez thanked everyone who assisted and helped make this cleanup happen. They took
advantage of the location; it was great going in and out. Staff thanked Mr. Ignacio Soto for the
assistance of using the location, the residents loved it and so did staff since there was enough room
as the residents came in.
Ms. Perez also provided information on the Task Force Meeting. It is the last Monday of every
month at 10 a.m. in the CareerSource conference room. She also commented that Code Enforcement
staff will be getting new hour shifts and will be incorporating a night shift throughout the entire
week. There’ll be anywhere from two to four investigators on shift throughout the entire County
during every day of the week working between 12 p.m. and 9 p.m. to address any concerns or
document any violations that come in the evening hours or complaint about parking food trucks
along the roadside.
Commissioner McDaniel asked what’s a good way for someone to report a code violation.
Ms. Cristina Perez said an individual could report a code violation through the 311 process, or they
could go online to the City View portal and report the violation there. An individual may also call
in or stop at the code enforcement office.
Commissioner McDaniel also asked what the process is if someone would like to remain
anonymous. Ms. Perez followed up and said that a violation that is considered health and safety
could fall within the protocol and be accepted anonymously. Commissioner McDaniel commented
that everyone may call his office and could file the complaint on their behalf and not worry about
retaliation. Ms. Perez reiterated that calling would be best.
There is an Immokalee investigator position posted. Ms. Cristine Perez provided information on
this position.
Ms. Christie Betancourt asked Ms. Cristina Perez if she could give an update on the Food/Storage
container. Ms. Perez commented that the El Gran Taco Loco storage container has been removed.
The next step would be for the owner to take this case back to the Code Enforcement board, so that
he could discuss the fines and receive an outcome for this case.
Mr. Estil Null asked if this container has been removed. He was informed by the owner that
everything was taken care of and approved. Ms. Cristina Perez and staff confirmed that the container
has been removed.
Ms. Andrea Halman complimented their promotional items given by County Staff during the
cleanup.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 331 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
8
Collier County - Immokalee Library, Silvia Puente
Ms. Silvia invited everyone to stop by at the Immokalee Library. She has teen areas that are
overflowing. They have a lot going on. The library has a homework center from Tuesday thru
Thursday from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. Children from Kindergarten to 12th grade are able to be a part of
the homework center. They have two certified teachers and an assistant to help during this program.
They have other library activities on Saturdays.
She commented that Dr. Frank Nappo is the reason why the library is open on Saturdays. She
recalled the moment he asked and was given an answer on when the Library will be open on
Saturdays. She thanked him and said the library gets utilized from many such as Pop Warner. She
suggested that Commissioner McDaniel come out one day and do a story time.
Mr. Estil Null asked Ms. Silvia Puente if they are aware of any book clubs in Immokalee. Ms.
Puente said she is not aware of it; they have tried it in the past but have not been successful in
keeping it going. She is open to it.
Economic Development and Housing Policy, Sarah Harrington
Ms. Sarah Harrington provided information on the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
(AHAC) meeting, they made a recommendation for 2 reappointments and one new appointment
that will be presented to the Board of Collier County Commissioners for approval. At the AHAC
meeting a public comment was made and the speaker gave an update on the Housing Alliance and
Navigator Program and this individual provided good information about resources that are coming
to the community. As more housing developments are making progress in Immokalee, County staff
will provide more details as soon as the developments are further along in their application process.
I. Community Presentations
1. Parks and Recreation (Enclosure 7)
Mr. Said Gomez introduced himself. He is the Regional Manager for Region 3. He is in charge of
the Immokalee Community Park, South Park, and Sports Complex. He provided information on all
three parks.
Immokalee South Park, 418 School Dr., Immokalee, FL 34142
• Summer Camp: Staff noticed an increase in participants. They are very active in the
community. Due to the size of the facility, they do have a limited space, however, this year
they had about 18 participants join during the summer. This year theme was Board Games.
• Preschool: Staff have met their numbers for preschool. Mr. Said Gomez commented that
this program is very much needed especially for the kids on the South side of Immokalee,
who don’t have much out there. Ms. Leonor Montelongo and her team do so much with the
kids and try to help them out as much as they can. They help them with holiday activities
and even lunches.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 332 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
9
• Voluntary Pre-Kindergarten (VPK): Staff have also met their numbers for VPK. Staff would
like to continue to support and help this program. There is enough funding for their materials
and supplies needed for the upcoming year.
• Soccer League (Eden & IMSC) : The adults Men’s Soccer League. This league is being ran
out in the Immokalee Sports Complex. Ms. Leoner Montelongo has been running this
program, she does this about 3 times a year. Staff have spoken and made a decision to move
this program fully to the Immokalee Sports Complex. Brief discussion was made on the
number of participants.
• Playground Project: Mr. Said Gomez provided information on the new playground
equipment. He commented that this playground is utilized every day, and it was very much
needed for the community, since there is not much out there for the kids to do.
Immokalee Community Park, 321 N 1st Street., Immokalee, FL 34142
• Summer Camp: Mr. Said Gomez reiterated that the theme for the Summer Camp was
Board Games. Staff took the students to field trips. This year they took their students
to Head Pinz. The students enjoy this program every year, and Staff are successful with
bring these students back, especially since some qualify for scholarships to help with
the registration.
• Yard Sale: There are many people who enjoy coming out to the yard sale that occurs
at the community park. This is a great opportunity for Staff to get advocacy for any
program that they have. Harry Chapman also come out at times and do food drives.
This is really a big coming out to the Community.
• Trunk or Treat: Staff will host a Trunk or Treat event. This event is always a success.
Staff have received many calls from people who are trying to register themselves or
their business.
• Family Camp Out: Mr. Gomez commented that he is excited about this event. This
camp out is done at the Pepper Ranch Preserve. This location is a huge asset for the
community and it’s great thing that is being utilized just about every other weekend.
The site allows for others to learn a lot about Immokalee and even more on the wildlife
surrounding the community. He complimented staff and the Conservation partners for
participating and educating the kids. This is something new to staff.
• Restroom Renovations, Sidewalk Pathway repairs, and LED Lighting improvements
were discussed.
Immokalee Sports Complex, 505 Escambia St., Immokalee, FL 34142
Mr. James Hanrahan introduced himself. He is the Interim Director for the Collier County
Parks and Recreation. His permanent position is Assistant Director.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 333 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
10
He stepped into Interim Director when the Director moved back to North Carolina. He
commented that with the support of the Commissioners, County Manger Office, and his team,
they have been able to move forward.
He complimented Mr. Said Gomez and said that they made the greatest decision to have him
oversee Immokalee. He thanked Ms. Randi Swinderman for all that she has done for
Immokalee.
The fitness center has been upgraded, they have done some painting in the interior and exterior.
Mr. Hanrahan received an update from Mr. Kyle Pryce, who is the supervisor for the
Immokalee Sports Complex, the first set of fitness equipment will be arriving mid-October.
This includes the treadmills, and the second set of fitness equipment is set to arrive in October
as well. There will be 6 new treadmills and other new equipment.
Resurfacing has been done to the sidewalks at the Immokalee Sports Complex as well as the
area around the Kiddie amenity of the pool.
Mr. Mark Lemke asked if the Kiddie amenity is working.
Mr. Said Gomez said that it is currently still down, they are waiting on parts, pumps, and
motors. They are still working on this.
Mr. Hanrahan commented on the approval made by the Board of Collier County
Commissioners to purchase the Williams Farm property. The Parks and Recreation will have
some part for this property, especially with the need of more sports field. Staff are excited on
the decision made by the Board of Collier County Commissioners.
Mr. Hanrahan complimented Commissioner McDaniel along with the County Manager Office
for supporting and approving the 4 million dollars necessary for improvements at the
Immokalee Sports Complex, which includes turfing the fields, two out of three will be artificial
turf and putting a prefabricated bathroom on those fields. This will be convenient for many.
Stormwater improvement will be made. A rendering was presented.
Ms. Hanrahan commented on park staff receiving the proposal design and upgrading the
aquatic facilities.
Discussion was made on the participants that use the fields.
Mr. Hanrahan commented that they are doing interviews for two dedicated position as
Immokalee Park Rangers. He also commented that Mr. Said Gomez is leading alongside their
Project Manager and assessing options for Lake Trafford. He will provide an update to Ms.
Christie Betancourt.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 334 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
11
Ms. Christie Betancourt commented that a barrier was put in place so that boats could avoid
docking on the side of Mr. Edward “Ski” Olesky property. Mr. Said Gomez commented that
this is a temporary thing, due to some concern of individuals getting stuck.
Mr. Said Gomez commented that they are looking to do some senior programming, his team
will look into what could be done.
Commissioner McDaniel asked Parks and Recreation staff to communicate with the Facilities
Department and ask to get some cell phone boosters on the light poles in the parks.
Ms. Andrea Halman commented on the partnership Parks and Recreation staff have with the
CRA. She is excited about this and said that the CRA are on to something with Parks and
Recreation.
Ms. Hanrahan thanked Ms. Andrea Halman and complimented to the many staff who have
helped and showed him around Immokalee. He has love for Immokalee. Brief discussion was
made on the growth of Immokalee. Mr. Hanrahan commented on the resurfacing that is set to
come for the tennis, basketball and all other courts.
Mr. James Hanrahan provided information on where an individual could find information on
open positions with Collier County. The jobs are posted every Friday.
Ms. Andrea Halman suggested that jobs be announced so that others are aware. Mr. James
Hanrahan commented that he could ask his team to post Parks and Recreation position in all
the community parks in Immokalee.
Mr. Said Gomez commented on having events and using the opportunity to let others know on
the opportunities with Parks and Recreation.
Commissioner McDaniel commented on the importance on consistency to help others know
on the opportunities with Collier County. He commented that he is pushing for another Job
Fair.
Ms. Andrea Halman commented if it’s possible to have workshops to inform people on what
needs to be done to apply for a job.
Ms. Christie Betancourt commented that CareerSource is doing an amazing job with this.
Mr. James Hanrahan commented that he would like to meet with Ms. Yvar Pierre and
Careersource staff to get more information on what they assist with.
* Presentation is attached to the minutes for the record.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 335 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
12
J. Old Business.
1. Advisory Board
i. CRA Application
a. Paul Thein (Enclosure 8)
Staff provided Mr. Paul Thein application to the CRA Board. The CRA Board vacancy notice
was posted a day after Dr. Frank Nappo sent his resignation via Email.
Ms. Andrea Halman commented on the need for others to step up and advocate for the Board.
Commissioner McDaniel commented that everyone must be an advocate every time they are in
the community, not just in the meeting. If everyone who knows about the Board could assist
and take the initiative to speak to others who might not know as much, then the outcome could
be a great help to the CRA and MSTU Board.
Ms. Christie Betancourt commented that there are currently three vacancies for the Immokalee
MSTU Advisory Committee. Staff are looking for community members to join the Committee.
Commissioner McDaniel complimented Mr. Paul Thein and said he is doing amazing things in
Immokalee. Mr. Paul Thein is a great advocate and is with Core Health Partners. Commissioner
McDaniel commented that education is key to success.
CRA Action: Ms. Patricia Anne Goodnight made a motion to approve Paul Thein application for
the Immokalee Local Redevelopment Advisory (CRA) Board. Mr. Estil Null seconded the motion, and it
passed by unanimous vote. 5-0.
2. FRA Conference 2024 – Tampa, FL update
Staff provided information on the 2024 FRA Conference. They have registered for the Conference.
Unfortunately, the hotel where the Conference will be held at is booked. Staff and board members
will need to find an alternate hotel near the conference.
3. Brief Staff project update
i. First Street Corridor Safety Project update
Ms. Yvonne Blair provided information on the current progress. KCA provided 60% Plans and
after receiving those plans, staff noticed some Right-of-Way issues. If all the proposed
improvements are pulled into the existing ROW, that will create ADA conflicts. In a way to
avoid this, staff is working with Traffic Ops, and they have received permission to change the
Apollo Metro LED luminaire to a brighter LED and see if less poles could be out on First
Street.
After much discussion with Transportation and Traffic Ops, CRA Staff have asked their
consultant to go back and see if they could phase the project. CRA staff also need to work with
CHS for an extension on the grant.
Mr. Mark Lemke asked if the lights could be put in the center.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 336 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
13
Ms. Yvonne Blair commented that from past experiences, this option is not recommended.
Staff will provide an update on this project.
ii. Panther Crossing Bridge Improvements update
Staff informed everyone in attendance that Road Maintenance have completed the pressure
cleaning of the bridge. The next step for CRA Staff is to coordinate with Road Maintenance to
do the painting. CRA Staff will buy the paint and will coordinate with the Art Committee,
students, and principal to do the murals. Staff hope to bring back some mural ideas to the CRA
Board.
iii. Land Development Code (LDC) update
Staff commented that the Land Development Code has gone to the Development Services
Advisory Committee (DSAC), and it was approved. The Land Development Code will be
going to the Planning Commission next. Staff will send board members a link so that they
have a copy of the changes.
Commissioner McDaniel commented on the new Planning Commissioner for District Five.
4. Strategic Planning Program Final (Enclosure 9)
Staff provided the Immokalee CRA Strategic Plan. Staff will update the year to 2025. Staff is
working on a quarterly report to send to the Board of Collier County Commissioners. The next step
for Staff is to send this plan to the Board of Collier County Commissioners to either adopt or
approve the plan.
5. Tentative 25 Budget (Enclosure 10)
Staff provided brief information on the tentative budget for Fiscal Year 2024. A hearing budget was
held by the Board of Collier County Commissioners. The budget included the CRA, CRA Capital
and MSTU fund.
Mr. John Dunnuck commented that the numbers are with the rollback. The taxable values go back
and roll back the millage accordingly to work with it. Overall, there is still an increase to the budget.
Commissioner McDaniel commented on the rollback. He envisions with the new reorganization of
Collier County, the new establishment of the budget priorities and the initiative of County staff with
regard to the effectuated tax, the next step will be the designation of funds to be fenced off to take
care of the needed processes.
Ms. Patricia Anne Goodnight commented on the Budget and asked if a credit card can be used to
pay for the hotel to attend the FRA Conference and then cancel if one decides not to go.
Mr. John Dunnuck followed up and commented that staff will not have the same process again.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 337 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
14
Commissioner McDaniel commented that the FRA Conference needs to be budgeted in the next
years’ budget so that funds are available for this expense.
Ms. Christie Betancourt commented that it’s unavoidable. Staff use to have a hold on the rooms,
however, this year registration had to be paid. There was a domino effect this year, but staff will
make sure that this is better situated for the upcoming year.
Mr. John Dunnuck commented on the process that was done before and said he will discuss this
item with the Clerk’s Office.
6. Budget Priorities (Enclosure 11)
Staff provided a recap of the budget and budget changes. Staff went over the Immokalee Tax
Increment, CRA Fund, CRA Capital Project Fund, Capital Projects funded by Grants, MSTU
Funds, and the Landscaping for Immokalee Rd & SR29.
Staff commented on the CRA Capital Project Fund and said they plan reallocate some funds from
the CRA reserves into a project and are also adding the $644,100 from the land sale located on 9th
Street. Staff have not allocated for Parks and Recreation; however, they did transfer the
Neighborhood Revitalization to Parks and Recreation. Staff will be moving the mobility fund of
$50,000, so Parks and Recreation will have $50,000.
Commissioner McDaniel commented on the tax valuable in 2025 and said that this is key to success
on how our community is thriving and emphasized on what infrastructure has done. He reminded
everyone that infrastructure is key to success.
Mr. Mark Lemke asked for the overall tax valuable of Collier County.
Commissioner McDaniel noted that it was about 12 billion dollars in assessed valuation. Overall,
all were effective last year in adjusting the county priorities, redoing the business statement,
business plan, and budget priorities.
Staff provided information on the CRA Owned Property and highlighted the objects and programs.
They have reveter clause with the Immokalee Community Campus. Staff hope to have them present
their updated rendering design and give an update on their progress. They are still currently in the
rezone process. Zocalo Park is being maintained currently by A&M Property Maintenance LLC on
a temporary basis. Eustis Pond is being maintained under County Contract. Discussion was made
on the Historic Cemetery and the ownership status.
Staff discussed operational and administrative tasks for the CRA. A director has been hired and
staff will be converting their temporary staff to a full-time position. Staff also discussed the short
and long term for their office space. Staff will keep the board updated. Training for Staff were
highlighted as well as community programs staff attends.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 338 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
15
Staff commented on the Land Use Planning and said this was one of the initiatives from the
Immokalee Area Master Plan. Economic Development was highlighted as well and what staff do
to provide support for the community. Discussion was also made on the incentives with CRA Grants
and the Impact Fee Installment Payment Program.
Staff presented the revenues for the CRA, MSTU, and Grant. Ms. Christie Betancourt provided the
project report. A breakdown of the funds was shown for all the projects that were prioritized by the
CRA Board. Staff discussed projects as listed.
• First Street Pedestrian Safety Improvement Project
• First Street Corridor/ Zocalo Improvements
• First Street Zocalo Plaza Holiday Decorations
Staff will be requesting a $30,000 for decoration at the Zocalo Plaza. There are currently
two PO’s open, one is for the decoration of Zocalo Park itself and the other is for the tree.
• Immokalee Sidewalk Phase III project – Eustis Avenue & West Delaware Avenue
• Main Street Corridor Streetscape Project SR29 from 9th Street to East 2nd Street
This project is on a Stop Work Order. Staff currently have 60% plans. Staff have not
allocated any funding for this project. Staff have a projected cost of 2.7 million, but that
could change if FDOT hands the road over to the County.
• Main Street Improvements (Preventative Maintenance)
Staff may come back to the CRA Board if they are short on funds with the MSTU funds.
However, this project is with the MSTU fund. Staff also discussed the banner arm
improvements and trash cans on Main Street and First Street.
• Landscape Maintenance of Immokalee MSTU Road
• Historic Cemetery on Main Street
Staff are waiting on a PO for the Fiscal Year to do the Property survey and ground to do
interior and exterior improvements.
• Fields of Dream Parks Initiative (Sports Field)
Staff reiterated that they would reallocate $50,000 from mobility to Parks and Recreation.
1.2 million has been transferred for the Immokalee Sports Complex improvements.
• Lake Trafford Corridor Improvements
• Immokalee Complete Streets
Staff have a draft executive summary in place to go to the Board of Collier County
Commissioners for the 388 additional poles being added to the project. Staff have allocated
$100,000 for the utility expense.
• Economic Development
• Grant and Programs
Staff discussed the overall allocated funds for the projects and partnerships with other organizations
like the Naples Botanical Garden.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 339 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Enclosure 1
16
K. New Business.
No new busuiness.
L. Citizen Comments
M. Next Meeting Date
The CRA and MSTU Board will be meeting Jointly on Wednesday, October 16, 2024, at 8:30 A.M. at
CareerSource SWFL.
N. Adjournment
Meeting adjourned at 10:47 A.M.
* Zoom Meeting chat is attached to the minutes for the record.
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 340 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
IMMOKALEE PARKS UPDATE
09-18-2024
IMMOKALEE PARKS UPDATE
IMMOKALEE SOUTH
PARK
IMMOKALEE
COMMUNITY PARK
IMMOKALEE SPORTS
COMPLEX
IMMOKALEE SOUTH PARK
418 SCHOOL DR, IMMOKALEE, FL 34142
SUMMER CAMP
2024
The Immokalee Local Redevelopment Advisory (CRA) Board Meeting - September 18, 2024
Agenda Item I.1. Parks and Recreation
1
Enclosure 126.A.c
Packet Pg. 341 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
PRESCHOOL
2024
VOLUNTARY PRE-KINDERGARTEN (VPK)
Register for FREE at:
Immokalee South Park
418 School Dr.
239-252-4677
Bring: Child’s Birth Certificate, Physical and
Immunization records
www.collierparks.com
239-252-4677
Registración GRATIS en:
Immokalee South Park
418 School Dr.
239-252-4677
Traiga: Acta de nacimiento, examen físco y papel azul
de sus vacunas.
Enregistreman GRATIS:
Immokalee South Park
418 School Dr.
239-252-4677
Vini: Avèk bastistè, cat vacinatyon, et papié medical.
2024
SOCCER LEAGUE (EDEN & IMSC)
175-200 PARTICIPANTS
PLAYGROUND PROJECT
BEFORE
2
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 342 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
PLAYGROUND PROJECT
AFTER
IMMOKALEE COMMUNITY PARK
321 N 1ST ST, IMMOKALEE, FL 34142
SUMMER CAMP
2024
YARD SALE
2024
3
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 343 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
TRUNK OR TREAT
2023
FAMILY CAMP OUT
PEPPER RANCH PRESERVE
RESTROOM RENOVATIONS
OUTSIDE & INSIDE (MEN'S & WOMAN'S)
SIDEWALK / PATHWAY REPAIRS
4
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 344 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
LED LIGHTING
PATHWAYS, PARKING LOT, AND BUILDING
IMMOKALEE SPORTS COMPLEX
505 ESCAMBIA ST, IMMOKALEE, FL 34142
PAINTING
FITNESS CENTER AND EXTERIOR
RESURFACING
SIDEWALKS AND ACTIVITY POOL
5
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 345 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
BOCC MEETING 05/28
The agreement for the sale and purchase of
the 2,247 +/- acres of property at Williams
Reserve at Lake Trafford, Immokalee, was
approved with all commissioners in favor.
This acreage will be purchased for
$20,770,000, the average of two appraisals.
Possible uses have been identified, including
conservation, affordable and workforce
housing, parks and recreation, transportation
infrastructure, stormwater management, and
economic development. The Chief of the
Immokalee Fire Rescue District has expressed
interest in co-locating a fire station on the
property. On April 3, 2024, the Conservation
Collier Land Acquisition Advisory Committee
(“CCLAAC”) considered the potential
acquisition of approximately 1410 acres of
this land for use in the Conservation Collier
Program
BOCC MEETING 06/11
6.D.8. RECOMMENDATION THAT THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS (BOARD)
ACTING AS THE COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD (CRA), APPROVE A $4,000,000 CAPITAL PROJECT BUDGET FOR THE
RENOVATION OF THE IMMOKALEE SPORTS COMPLEX SOCCER FIELDS, PROVIDING FOR THE CONVERSION OF TWO (2) EXISTING GRASS
FIELDS TO ARTIFICIAL TURF, CONSTRUCTION OF AN ADDITIONAL RESTROOM FACILITY, ADDRESSING STORMWATER MANAGEMENT
ISSUES, AND AUTHORIZING NECESSARY BUDGET AMENDMENTS. (DISTRICT 5) (29057)
IMMOKALE
SPORTS COMPLEX
ATHLETICS
IMMOKALEE SPORTS COMPLEX AQUATICS
6
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 346 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
IMMOKALEE SPORTS COMPLEX ATHLETICS
THANK YOU
7
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 347 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
Zoom Chat
September 18, 2024 Immokalee CRA Hybrid Public Meeting
00:20:18 Teo Alviar: Can we get an update from Commissioner McDaniel
from last week's meeting with his counterparts regarding the Emergency Repairs to
Private Roads.
00:32:55 Teo Alviar: In these last few years I've known Dr. Frank Nappo,
he has always been one of the biggest and most passionate advocates for our
beautiful little town of Immokalee! Wishing him and his family well.
00:55:15 Iliana Caris: Hello everyone, what CRA incentives are there for
new businesses? Including acquiring land/property to open new businesses?
01:29:41 Iliana Caris: Where do we apply for the park ranger position?
01:35:17 Iliana Caris: I’m willing to help volunteer to help you post the
Immokalee jobs as a way of giving back.
02:19:30 Iliana Caris: How does the impact fee installment program work?
26.A.c
Packet Pg. 348 Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)
26.A.cPacket Pg. 349Attachment: CRA Minutes - 09.18.24 (30038 : Immokalee CRA Advisory Board - October 16, 2024)