CSRM Agenda 10/30/2024
Growth Management Community Development Department
Collier County Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory
Committee
Wednesday, October 30, 2024
1:00 PM
Collier County GMCDD Building – Room 609/610
AGENDA
1. Approval of previous meeting minutes from November 8, 2023
2. Status of CSRM study
3. Tentatively Selected Plan (TSP) – What is a TSP?
4. Chairman update
5. Open discussion regarding the status of the CSRM Feasibility Study
6. Other Items/Committee Correspondence
Motion to Ajourn: _______ Time Ajourned:_______
8.B.b
Packet Pg. 74 Attachment: CSRM Agenda 10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory Committee)
Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory Committee
Wednesday October 30, 2024
Growth Management Department – Conference Room 609/610
Committee Sign-In Sheet
1:00 PM
***Please be advised***
The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e -mail addresses, phone numbers and
certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency. If you do not want y our e-mail address, phone number or home address
released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet. You have the option of checking
with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county website for additional information.
Name Representing Email
8.B.c
Packet Pg. 75 Attachment: CSRM Committee Sign-In 10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility
Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory Committee
Wednesday October 30, 2024
Growth Management Department – Conference Room 609/610
Public Sign-In Sheet
1:00 PM
***Please be advised***
The information on this sheet is to contact you regarding this project and future public meetings. Under Florida law, e -mail addresses, phone numbers and
certain home addresses are public records once received by a government agency. If you do not want your e -mail address, phone number or home address
released if the county receives a public records request, you can refrain from including such information on this sheet . You have the option of checking
with the county staff on your own to obtain updates on the project as well as checking the county website for additional info rmation.
Name Representing Email
8.B.d
Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: CSRM Public Sign-In 10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study
1
Collier County Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study
CSRM Ad Hoc Committee – 10/30/2024
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
2Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study: Planning Areas Update
USACE refined the Planning Areas based on results of
the Planning Charettes conducted in April of 2023 and
Public Information meetings that occurred in April and
June of 2023
Revision of Planning Areas from a total of 6 to 4
Planning Areas will focus on beaches and
Environmental Justice communities
Screening out of structural measures. Analysis to focus
on beach nourishment, Critical Infrastructure,
nonstructural measures, and possible Natural &
Nature-Based Features (NNBF)
No analysis of measures within Coastal Barrier
Resource Systems (CBRS)
N
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
3COLLIER CSRM
Geographic Scope – Planning Areas:
North County Beaches Planning Area
Marco Island Beach Planning Area
Naples Planning Area
Goodland Planning Area Historically disadvantaged back
bay communities that have
elevated risks to livelihood and
life safety during coastal storm
events.
Areas defined by EJ Screen Tool
This study is not a one-time, fix-all solution to coastal storm
risk. There will always be coastal storm risk in Collier County.
Upcoming Analysis Scope:
Beach nourishment, nonstructural measures, Critical Infrastructure,
and Nature-Based Solutions.
Nature-Based Solutions being considered: vegetated dune
(as component of beach nourishment) and mangrove
restoration at Clam Pass
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
4Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study: Array of Alternatives8.B.e
Packet Pg. 80 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
58.B.e
Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
6
What is “Environmental Justice” and the “Justice40 Initiative”?
Environmental Justice is “The fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people
regardless of race, color, national origin, or income regarding the development,
implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies, with no
group bearing a disproportionate burden of environmental harms and risks.” (ASA(CW)
Memorandum 15 March 2022)
Justice40 is “A whole-of-government initiative that 40% of the overall benefits flow to
marginalized, disadvantaged, and overburdened by pollution.” (Section 233 of EO 14008)
We strive to scope our studies so that they are inclusive of all communities at risk.
ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLIANCE:
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
78.B.e
Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
88.B.e
Packet Pg. 84 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
9NEXT STATUS MEETING
& ADDITIONAL INFO
❖Email to contact the USACE team:
Collier-CSRM@usace.army.mil
❖Visit the story map using the QR code or the following link:
❖ https://colliercountyfl.webex.com/colliercountyfl/j.php?MTID=ma30d7a38d56e302ce2111614f7d75e9a
❖Next monthly status meeting is on Wednesday, November 25th
at 3:30 PM
2024 - 2025 Monthly Public Status Meetings
Wednesday, October 23
Wednesday, November 27
Wednesday, December 25
Wednesday, January 22
Wednesday, February 26
Collier County
Nonfederal Sponsor
3 years
Study Schedule
$2.97 Million
Study Budget, 100% Federal
February 2025
Anticipated Draft Report Public Release
May 2026
Anticipated Signed Chief’s Report
Visit the
USACE website
or the Collier
CSRM story
map for more
information
Collier CSRM
Re-initiated Feasibility
Study Quick Facts
X
X
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
10
TENTATIVELY SELECTED PLAN
A TSP is a key milestone in the environmental planning and decision-making process for large-scale projects,
particularly those involving transportation infrastructure or land development. It represents the preferred
alternative among the options considered during the planning and environmental analysis phase. When a
project undergoes environmental assessment, various alternatives are typically evaluated to determine their
potential impacts on the environment, social factors, and economic considerations. These alternatives could
include different routes for a highway, locations for a new facility, or designs for a development project.
After considering the environmental impacts, public input, and other factors, the agency or entity responsible for
the project selects a preferred alternative, which is then documented in the Tentatively Selected Plan.This plan
outlines the chosen option and provides justification for why it was selected over the other alternatives. The
Tentatively Selected Plan is subject to further review and public comment before it becomes finalized.
Feedback received during this period may result in adjustments to the plan or the inclusion of additional
mitigation measures to address concerns raised by stakeholders. Once all necessary approvals and permits
are obtained and any required environmental impact statements are completed, the TSP may be formally
adopted as the final plan for the project, paving the way for its implementation.
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
7.0 Tentative Selected
Plan
7.1
Optimization of the TSP
7.2
Description of
Tentatively Selected
Plan
7.3
Total Costs and
Economic Results of
the TSP
7.4
Executive Order (EO)
11988 and Public Law
113-2 Considerations
7.5
Implementation of the
Selected Plan
7.6 Resiliency,
Sustainability &
Adaptability
TENTATIVE SELECTED PLAN (TSP)
The TSP is the outcome of the analyses which occurred to evaluate a
variety of competing measures and alternative plans to reduce the risk
associated with future coastal storms in Collier County.
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
* Specific-Measurable-Achievable-Relevant-Time bound
The USACE SMART* planning process emphasizes study teams should use a reasonable level of
details to collect data and model alternatives and to analyze and evaluate effectiveness in order to
identify the TSP. The PDT has completed the evaluation and comparison of the final array of distinctly
different alternatives for achieving the water resources objectives in the study area, and they have
identified a TSP to carry forward.
1.0 OPTIMIZATION OF THE TSP
2.0 DESCRIPTION OF TENTATIVELY SELECTED PLAN
The TSP is the National Economic Development (NED) plan and will include the best alternative
from the final array of alternatives. The TSP is the outcome of the analyses which occurred to
evaluate a variety of competing measures and alternative plans.
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 88 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
3.0 TOTAL COSTS AND ECONOMIC RESULTS OF THE TSP
In this section the plan will include the total cost and the explanation of the basis for this
amount, including the Benefit-Cost Ratio (BCR)
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
3.0 TOTAL COSTS AND ECONOMIC RESULTS OF THE TSP8.B.e
Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
Executive Order 11988 requires federal agencies
avoid, to the extent possible, the long and short-term
adverse impacts associated with the occupancy and
modification of floodplains and to avoid direct and
indirect support of floodplain development wherever
there is a practicable alternative. In accomplishing this
objective, "each agency shall provide leadership and
shall take action to reduce the risk of flood loss, to
minimize the impact of floods on human safety, health,
and welfare, and to restore and preserve the natural
and beneficial values served by floodplains in carrying
out its responsibilities”.
The Water Resources Council Floodplain
Management Guidelines for implementation of EO
11988, as referenced in USACE ER 1165-2-26,
requires an eight-step process that agencies should
carry out as part of their decision making on projects
that have potential impacts to, or are within the
floodplain.
4.0 EXECUTIVE ORDER (EO) 11988 AND PUBLIC LAW 113-2 8.B.e
Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
Implementation will depend on the final array of alternatives.
5.0 IMPLEMENTATION OF THE SELECTED PLAN
6.0 RESILIENCY, SUSTAINABILITY AND ADAPTABILITY
This intent of this section is to address how the TSP contributes to the resiliency, how it
affects sustainability, and how it may be adapted to continue to perform under changed
future conditions in Collier County.
USACE describes resilience as “the ability to anticipate, prepare for, respond to, and
adapt to changing conditions and to withstand and recover rapidly from disruptions with
minimal damage”.
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk
17
Thank You
Christopher Mason
Christopher.Mason@CollierCountyFL.gov
8.B.e
Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: CSRM Ad Hoc Presentation-10.30.2024 (30049 : Coastal Storm Risk