CAC Minutes 11/14/2024 Draft
1
COLLIER COUNTY
COASTAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE (CAC)
Thursday, November 14, 2024 – 1:00 p.m.
Collier County Board Chambers
Collier County Government Center
3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor, Naples, FL
Chairman Joe Burke, City of Naples
Linda Penniman, City of Naples
Erik Brecknitz, City of Marco Island
Jim Burke, Unincorporated Collier County
Bob Raymond, Unincorporated Collier County
Robert Roth
Dr. Judith Hushon
ALSO, PRESENT
Andy Miller, Coastal Zone Management
Colleen Greene, Managing Assistant County Attorney
Any person who decides to appeal a decision of This Board you will need a record of the
proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the
proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is
to be based, Neither Collier County nor This Board shall be responsible for providing this record.
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
3. ROLL CALL
4. CHANGES AND APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion passed 7-0
5. PUBLIC COMMENTS
Patrick Wack, Seagate POA and Joanne Janney, Naples Gate
Patrick Wack presented a packet about the water quality at Clam Bay and asked the Board to allocate
$75,000.00.
The responsibility for Clam Pass and the affected mangrove forest is Pelican Bay Services Division.
This request should go to them. If Pelican Bay Services approves your request, they would recommend
this Board to recommend it to the TDC and they would recommend it to the BCC.
This Board cannot act on Public Comment. It must be a regular agenda item for that.
2
Scott Schultz, Chairman of Coastal Storm Risk Management Ad Hoc Committee
I’ve spoken to 13 of the 18 HOA’s in the City of Naples. All the HOA’s I met with did not want structures
for storm protection.
I’m a resident of Naples Cay and the Naples Cay Master wants structures.
Army Corps will deliver a plan in 2025 for us to make a recommendation to the BCC.
Dr. Judith Hushon – I wrote a letter and asked for the Army Corps send people to Naples to ride the
Beaches here and assess the situation after the last 2 Hurricanes.
Andy Miller – They are here today.
6. APPROVAL OF CAC MINUTES September 19, 2024
Robert Roth asked for corrections. Core be changed to Corps, $50.00 per cubic ton changed to cubic
yard and clarification of $15,000.
Would like pages numerated
Bob Raymond indicated he was listed as a Councilman which is incorrect.
Bob Raymond moved to approve the minutes with amendments
Robert Roth seconded
Motion passed 7-0
7. STAFF REPORTS
Extended Revenue Report
Andy Miller presented table and chart of revenues exceeding budget and last year’s numbers.
8. NEW BUSINESS
1. ES – 2025 Annual Monitoring
Andy Miller
Our annual monitoring, which is our survey of the beaches and inlets performed by Humiston & Moore
Engineers.
This item is a recommendation to approve and authorize the chair, to approve and authorize the chair, to
execute a work order with Humiston and Moore Engineers to provide professional engineering services
for State required annual monitoring of Collier County beaches and inlets for 2025 under contract 18-
7432-CZ for time and materials not to exceed $158,597 and make a finding that this item promotes
tourism.
• Work Order – 2025 Annual Monitoring
Motion pass 7-0
2. ES – Earth Tech Emergency Re-Grade
• Proposal – Barefoot-Vanderbilt Beach
• Proposal – Naples Beaches
3
Andy Miller
The recommendation here is to authorize a budget amendment to approve or to provide funding for
regrading of the beaches damaged by hurricanes Helene and Milton and make a finding that this
expenditure promotes tourism. The amount is $538,000.00.
Our pre-construction meeting for the planting project is on Dec. 10 with the Board of County
Commissioners. We'll be meeting with the contractor and the FDEP and the other agencies, including the
City of Naples to talk about the planting schedule.
Dr. Judith Hushon
The test plot that the Garden planted did not do well in these storms. They did a test plot using the same
plants that they are using for the beach.
Robert Roth motioned to approve the budget amendment
Dr. Judith Hushon seconded
Motion passed 7-0
3. ES – H&M Emergency Beach Survey
• H&M – Post Milton Survey Proposal
• SDI – Post Milton Survey Proposal
Andy Miller
FTEP sent out an email a few weeks after the storm asking for the survey information to be provided to
them by November 27th. We've already released Thomas and Amor on an emergency PO, but this
additional revenue will give them enough money to do the work and complete the work.
It is more than the original PO.
We already approved the annual monitoring effort on our first item, which includes surveying our
beaches and inlets. This PO includes the the cost of resurveying the beaches and inlets. And the good
news is that the surveys would have been so close together that FDEP will, allow us to use one for the
other or one for both. We won't have to duplicate that effort.
Robert Roth motioned to approve
Dr. Judith Hushon seconded
Motion passed 7-0
4. ES – 2024 Park Shore Renourishment
• 24-8292 Contract – Park Shore Renourishment
Dr. Judith Hushon motioned to approve the Park Shore Renourishment amount of $3,563,530.00.
Robert Roth seconded
Motion passed 7-0
9. OLD BUSINESS
4
None
10. ANNOUNCEMENTS
None
11. COMMITTEE MEMBER DISCUSSION
Chairman Burke
Andy and his staff have had a very busy fall, and we should congratulate them on great job.
12. NEXT MEETING DATE/LOCATION
December 12, 2024, at 1:00 p.m.
13 ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business for the good of The County, the Coastal Advisory Committee
Hearing was adjourned at 1.56 p.m.
Collier County Coastal Advisory Committee
_________________________________________
Chairman Joe Burke
The Minutes were approved by
____________________________________ _______________________________________
Name Signature
as presented on__________________
or amended on____________________